Swampland collection

N=4 EFT constraints and conditional Veneziano selection

Which nonlinear four-point Wilson-coefficient relations follow from N=4 supersymmetry, unbroken SU(4) R-symmetry, higher-point tree factorization and six-scalar parity, and what numerical selection of the four-gluon open-superstring amplitude follows after separately imposing dispersive assumptions?

New explicit replacement for c0 and c1. UV-independent EFT relations precede a separate numerical bootstrap that suggests selection of the Veneziano amplitude with appropriate four-gluon kinematic prefactors. Neither convergence nor uniqueness is proved here.

Open this destination in SwampWiki

Scope

systems

targets

regimes

assumptions

conventions

includes

excludes

Methods and reading coverage

Supersymmetry Ward identities; Higher-point factorization; Numerical dispersive bootstrap

1 extracted descriptions checked; 1 source excerpts checked.

Retained c0 limit: Bounded introductory pages of the supplied 2601.11705 source. Numerical convergence and the announced coefficient derivation were not independently verified. Retained c1 limit: The excerpts report nonlinear relations and numerical evidence; convergence and uniqueness are not independently established. Current reading is limited to e0–e2; e0 and e1 overlap.

Full reading coverage record
{
  "descriptionCheckedCount": 1,
  "excerptCheckedCount": 1,
  "readingLimit": "Retained c0 limit: Bounded introductory pages of the supplied 2601.11705 source. Numerical convergence and the announced coefficient derivation were not independently verified. Retained c1 limit: The excerpts report nonlinear relations and numerical evidence; convergence and uniqueness are not independently established. Current reading is limited to e0–e2; e0 and e1 overlap.",
  "readingBasis": "Exact source description and own-paper windows cited by both original proposal and explicit whole challenge; root separately read the complete scopes and bounded primary windows.",
  "scopeSupportNotPhysicalResultVerification": true,
  "globalCanonicalUniquenessEstablished": false
}
Earlier reviewed definitions and reading limits

These formulations share an accepted scoped-question destination; underlying source statements are not equated.

EFT amplitude constraints and conditional Veneziano selection

What four-point Wilson-coefficient constraints follow from higher-point supersymmetry, factorization and six-scalar parity, and what additional UV selection is suggested after imposing dispersive assumptions?

The EFT analysis and numerical UV bootstrap are separate stages. The supplied text reports nonlinear coefficient relations and numerical evidence approaching the open-superstring amplitude, not a uniqueness proof.

{
  "id": "q025-candidate-question:39594f3f2592c9816c879036",
  "scope": {
    "systems": [
      "Non-gravitational, weakly coupled, planar four-dimensional EFTs with leading N=4 super Yang–Mills behavior"
    ],
    "targets": [
      "Nonlinear relations among four-point Wilson coefficients",
      "Conditional numerical selection of the open-superstring four-point tree amplitude"
    ],
    "regimes": [
      "Single-trace tree amplitudes",
      "Order-by-order low-energy expansion",
      "Numerical four-point bootstrap with a nonzero spectral gap"
    ],
    "assumptions": [
      "N=4 supersymmetry and unbroken SU(4) R-symmetry",
      "Standard massless-pole factorization of four-, five- and six-point amplitudes",
      "Parity-even six-scalar amplitudes without Levi–Civita-bearing local contact terms",
      "For the bootstrap stage only: unitarity, analyticity and A4/s² tending to zero at large |s| for fixed negative u or t"
    ],
    "conventions": [
      "The EFT stage assumes neither properties nor existence of a UV completion.",
      "The candidate amplitude curve is parameterized by string tension relative to the assumed gap."
    ],
    "includes": [
      "The Coulomb-branch example as a boundary that violates the parity condition"
    ],
    "excludes": [
      "Universal uniqueness of string UV completion",
      "Applying the nonlinear constraints after admitting parity-odd local six-scalar terms",
      "Identification of Wilson coefficients with Wilson lines"
    ]
  },
  "scientificStatus": "source_reviewed_scope_with_explicit_limits",
  "readingCoverage": {
    "descriptionCheckedCount": 1,
    "excerptCheckedCount": 1,
    "readingLimit": "Bounded introductory pages of the supplied 2601.11705 source. Numerical convergence and the announced coefficient derivation were not independently verified.",
    "sourceReadingScope": "Pinned paired source reviews; counted excerpts are only same-source primary windows explicitly shared by both reviewers. No full-paper/proof verification is inferred.",
    "inheritedParentCoverage": null
  },
  "scopeContentSha256": "db10dbaf3cc347621ae5e24a4b3373a867711c28403add172d505fef4326edf8"
}
Supersymmetric factorization and conditional amplitude isolation

Which four-point coefficient relations follow from maximal supersymmetry, R-symmetry, higher-point factorization and scalar parity, and what further isolation follows after adding dispersive assumptions?

The low-energy algebraic stage assumes no UV completion. A separate bootstrap stage provides conditional numerical evidence favoring the open-superstring amplitude.

{
  "id": "q025-candidate-question:44cfc530ee4b7053d438805d",
  "scope": {
    "systems": [
      "Non-gravitational, weakly coupled, four-dimensional planar EFTs reducing to N=4 SYM"
    ],
    "targets": [
      "Nonlinear four-point Wilson-coefficient relations",
      "Conditional isolation of the Veneziano amplitude with appropriate gluon prefactors"
    ],
    "regimes": [
      "Single-trace four-, five- and six-point tree amplitudes",
      "Numerical four-point bootstrap with a nonzero spectral gap"
    ],
    "assumptions": [
      "N=4 supersymmetry and unbroken SU(4) R-symmetry",
      "Standard massless-pole tree factorization",
      "Absence of parity-odd local six-scalar terms",
      "Only in the second stage: unitarity, analyticity and the stated large-energy falloff"
    ],
    "conventions": [
      "The proposed curve is parameterized by string tension relative to the assumed gap"
    ],
    "includes": [
      "The Coulomb-branch comparison as a boundary of the parity assumption"
    ],
    "excludes": [
      "A proved uniqueness theorem",
      "Restrictions on all supersymmetric EFTs",
      "UV-completion assumptions imported into the first stage"
    ]
  },
  "scientificStatus": "source_reviewed_scope_with_explicit_limits",
  "readingCoverage": {
    "descriptionCheckedCount": 1,
    "excerptCheckedCount": 1,
    "readingLimit": "The excerpts report nonlinear relations and numerical evidence; convergence and uniqueness are not independently established.",
    "sourceReadingScope": "Pinned paired source reviews; counted excerpts are only same-source primary windows explicitly shared by both reviewers. No full-paper/proof verification is inferred.",
    "inheritedParentCoverage": null
  },
  "scopeContentSha256": "40feb0266e67de3da90be9c7e169dc84955bba22e308618a51e5657633261550"
}
N=4 EFT constraints and conditional Veneziano selection

Which nonlinear four-point Wilson-coefficient relations follow from N=4 supersymmetry, unbroken SU(4) R-symmetry, higher-point tree factorization and six-scalar parity, and what numerical selection of the four-gluon open-superstring amplitude follows after separately imposing dispersive assumptions?

New explicit replacement for c0 and c1. UV-independent EFT relations precede a separate numerical bootstrap that suggests selection of the Veneziano amplitude with appropriate four-gluon kinematic prefactors. Neither convergence nor uniqueness is proved here.

{
  "id": "q025-candidate-question:0e226d69a7c3bb82fb9345a2",
  "scope": {
    "systems": [
      "Non-gravitational, weakly coupled, planar four-dimensional EFTs reducing to N=4 super Yang–Mills at leading low-energy order"
    ],
    "targets": [
      "Nonlinear relations among four-point Wilson coefficients of Tr D^(2k) F^4 operators and their supersymmetric partners",
      "Conditional numerical selection of the open-superstring four-point tree amplitude: the Veneziano amplitude with kinematic prefactors appropriate to four-gluon scattering"
    ],
    "regimes": [
      "Single-trace four-, five- and six-point tree amplitudes",
      "Order-by-order low-energy expansion",
      "Separate numerical four-point bootstrap with an arbitrary but nonzero spectral gap"
    ],
    "assumptions": [
      "N=4 supersymmetry and unbroken SU(4) R-symmetry",
      "Standard tree-level factorization on massless poles for four-, five- and six-point amplitudes",
      "Parity-even six-scalar amplitudes, excluding local contact terms containing Levi–Civita contractions",
      "For the bootstrap stage only: unitarity, analyticity and A4/s² → 0 as |s| → ∞ at fixed u < 0 or fixed t < 0"
    ],
    "conventions": [
      "The EFT stage assumes neither properties nor existence of a UV completion.",
      "The large-energy condition is stated for the source's four-point amplitude A4; the candidate retains the four-gluon kinematic prefactors.",
      "The candidate curve is parameterized by string tension relative to the assumed spectral gap, following the source's convention."
    ],
    "includes": [
      "The Coulomb-branch example as a boundary of the parity assumption: its reported massive-W one-loop correction gives incompatible coefficients, and its six-scalar amplitudes require Levi–Civita-bearing local terms."
    ],
    "excludes": [
      "A proved uniqueness theorem or universal uniqueness of string UV completion",
      "Applying the nonlinear coefficient constraints after admitting parity-odd local six-scalar terms",
      "Importing dispersive or UV-existence premises into the EFT stage",
      "Inferring inconsistency of Coulomb-branch N=4 SYM from failure of the parity-restricted constraints",
      "Identification of Wilson coefficients with Wilson lines"
    ]
  },
  "scientificStatus": "source_reviewed_scope_with_explicit_limits",
  "readingCoverage": {
    "descriptionCheckedCount": 1,
    "excerptCheckedCount": 1,
    "readingLimit": "Retained c0 limit: Bounded introductory pages of the supplied 2601.11705 source. Numerical convergence and the announced coefficient derivation were not independently verified. Retained c1 limit: The excerpts report nonlinear relations and numerical evidence; convergence and uniqueness are not independently established. Current reading is limited to e0–e2; e0 and e1 overlap.",
    "readingBasis": "Exact source description and own-paper windows cited by both original proposal and explicit whole challenge; root separately read the complete scopes and bounded primary windows.",
    "scopeSupportNotPhysicalResultVerification": true,
    "globalCanonicalUniquenessEstablished": false
  },
  "scopeContentSha256": "c464520aa10ec07a448ddfd40b69ea5e29c38eb7fc378f58490ca3079a05c35a"
}

Source contributions (1; 3 review observations)

Separately admitted review observations are retained for each source-and-role relationship. These reviewed roles are separate from source membership. A shared source does not establish question equivalence; a method contribution does not certify applicability.

Connections

Listed sources

Scientific status: source_reviewed_scope_with_explicit_limits. Placement: reviewed_scope_and_placements.

Listed sources support this record; they do not claim exhaustive literature coverage. Versioned data manifest