{"schemaVersion":"1.0.0","kind":"eigenquestions-organizational-access-certificates","records":{"organizational-access:56af0b28f13cac2760144985":{"id":"organizational-access:56af0b28f13cac2760144985","source":"q025-candidate-question:04ea1b1376fe4c1d2d1be282","target":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:04ea1b1376fe4c1d2d1be282","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"4119f58084310653cd4979a630a4cb6aea3e09446188622f55e0b9364aa15695","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:56a119305b000c19d80fa5e7"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1e56d8ed3c0ddff03060b195"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5","home":{"unitId":"unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:04ea1b1376fe4c1d2d1be282","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly includes evaporation and resolution bounds, weakly coupled string species, entropy bounds and continuation into the strong-coupling M-theory limit.","qualification":"q0 explicitly names the evaporation/resolution methods and both string and M-theory systems, making it more specific than q4 for the complete question. The neutral, nonrotating, asymptotically flat evaporation argument retains its own domain. Continuation and entropy equivalence do not establish a subsystem-factorization map.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5","paperId":"1004.3744","textSha256":"6c623ea966e2cf3b78a820438a862d3de469f0d15c9d702f91f79c5425824fe8"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0021:u13:q0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0021:u13:q0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5","q025-candidate-question:04ea1b1376fe4c1d2d1be282"],"scopeContentSha256":"4119f58084310653cd4979a630a4cb6aea3e09446188622f55e0b9364aa15695","placementContentSha256":"6e103bd296eb4b429b4d47d2254fa3e1104af0695f584cb6a65d2ca67e405e04","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0021:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0021:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5","paperId":"1004.3744","textSha256":"6c623ea966e2cf3b78a820438a862d3de469f0d15c9d702f91f79c5425824fe8"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0021","unitRef":"u13"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5","textSha256":"6c623ea966e2cf3b78a820438a862d3de469f0d15c9d702f91f79c5425824fe8"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ce9de083fd8f4257a8fad024","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Effective string-species counting and continuation to strong-coupling M-theory remain distinct parts of the source scope. Independent challenge qualification: Effective string-species counting and strong-coupling continuation require separate reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ce9de083fd8f4257a8fad024","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5","q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","contributionContentSha256":"cb7b074198f14e2ab675af32f423f37f62dd3479cf534c9043bc5db649161dce","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5","textSha256":"6c623ea966e2cf3b78a820438a862d3de469f0d15c9d702f91f79c5425824fe8"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ce9de083fd8f4257a8fad024","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Effective string-species counting and continuation to strong-coupling M-theory remain distinct parts of the source scope.","challengeNote":"Effective string-species counting and strong-coupling continuation require separate reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"c16fb6c336cd52a8c449a912af9f98a59e79620dea7d1061acc13c4178fecdf7"},"organizational-access:622cb692eceabd6b7b30503b":{"id":"organizational-access:622cb692eceabd6b7b30503b","source":"q025-candidate-question:0e226d69a7c3bb82fb9345a2","target":"q025-candidate-question:1255f0086476b4077b7bf5f5","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:0e226d69a7c3bb82fb9345a2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c464520aa10ec07a448ddfd40b69ea5e29c38eb7fc378f58490ca3079a05c35a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:navigation-amplitude:scope:pq0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1255f0086476b4077b7bf5f5","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"80aee43db092929988164204830b10c7d17ab89dff2a2f270eea46602162f19e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:9b2dce72058e85ecbf68dfea"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","home":{"unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0e226d69a7c3bb82fb9345a2","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q1 explicitly combines UV-independent symmetry/factorization/parity constraints with a separate conditional dispersive bootstrap of the four-gluon Veneziano amplitude.","qualification":"q1 is the source-specific complete composite: symmetry, factorization and six-scalar parity constrain the EFT independently of UV existence, while the numerical amplitude-selection stage adds dispersive premises. Its amplitude normalization, kinematic prefactors and spectral-gap convention remain explicit. The broader q2 and q6 do not warrant additional allocations, and the truncated historical parity clause is not reconstructed.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","paperId":"2601.11705","textSha256":"3d464c9fb911fe316295724edc7094ae506fb7b3517c74df194d4471723e49e9"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0012:u19:q1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0012:u19:q1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","q025-candidate-question:0e226d69a7c3bb82fb9345a2"],"scopeContentSha256":"c464520aa10ec07a448ddfd40b69ea5e29c38eb7fc378f58490ca3079a05c35a","placementContentSha256":"5ab23dffafe7e4c1b185eb5f89e7a0960ff6eb8a7398c2dcd073f3b7f5786579","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0012:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0012:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","paperId":"2601.11705","textSha256":"3d464c9fb911fe316295724edc7094ae506fb7b3517c74df194d4471723e49e9"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0012","unitRef":"u19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1255f0086476b4077b7bf5f5","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d52","kind":"description","unitIndex":52,"unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","textSha256":"3d464c9fb911fe316295724edc7094ae506fb7b3517c74df194d4471723e49e9"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:62049fb9f5f145b8435632bd"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:62049fb9f5f145b8435632bd","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","q025-candidate-question:1255f0086476b4077b7bf5f5"],"scopeContentSha256":"80aee43db092929988164204830b10c7d17ab89dff2a2f270eea46602162f19e","contributionContentSha256":"80e98d9c5b3fa7e7bee1439e0827fec5614a3914cfa19a29df4bdb06c90b1ba6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d52","kind":"description","unitIndex":52,"unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","textSha256":"3d464c9fb911fe316295724edc7094ae506fb7b3517c74df194d4471723e49e9"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:62049fb9f5f145b8435632bd","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"EFT restrictions and isolation of Veneziano are distinct targets with different assumption sets.","challengeNote":"EFT restrictions and Veneziano isolation are distinct targets; the latter additionally invokes dispersive positivity.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"9214c93edb6221247cde7946a46e6722dfc0054a24e16b3f547ec4558677447f"},"organizational-access:121feb4f9df964833658599b":{"id":"organizational-access:121feb4f9df964833658599b","source":"q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643","target":"q025-candidate-question:64d242f010006f3d1a0a3120","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"0090ea9d5afb7931a126341f2a1e9970079dcf78145b0e7a0788e1866f3fd496","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:41f48b1d477a13a8051c2461"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:64d242f010006f3d1a0a3120","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6db4338af96093be5bb3a761b43810837e71fd34bbfca731558568f4853ee5ef","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:dafca507ba1939d2aba44091"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4662b44467681f883d21e8b73a7f5898a545b8ee2ef47d050bd9464cd9d288f6","home":{"unitId":"unit:4662b44467681f883d21e8b73a7f5898a545b8ee2ef47d050bd9464cd9d288f6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4662b44467681f883d21e8b73a7f5898a545b8ee2ef47d050bd9464cd9d288f6","paperId":"0806.2667","textSha256":"c549b66541fd94aafb5fdbd15db121d8e1ea6e2d1985ed2e77d7f60245e1755d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e9ca603da5b4b0e789134074"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e9ca603da5b4b0e789134074","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4662b44467681f883d21e8b73a7f5898a545b8ee2ef47d050bd9464cd9d288f6","q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643"],"scopeContentSha256":"0090ea9d5afb7931a126341f2a1e9970079dcf78145b0e7a0788e1866f3fd496","placementContentSha256":"3eb61f33dd7d1397390163965741672845d4d1556486bc755a5956bd2f722640","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge","leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4662b44467681f883d21e8b73a7f5898a545b8ee2ef47d050bd9464cd9d288f6","paperId":"0806.2667","textSha256":"c549b66541fd94aafb5fdbd15db121d8e1ea6e2d1985ed2e77d7f60245e1755d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e9ca603da5b4b0e789134074"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4662b44467681f883d21e8b73a7f5898a545b8ee2ef47d050bd9464cd9d288f6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:64d242f010006f3d1a0a3120","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","qualification":"Confirm the contribution to the reused coupling and scale-hierarchy target. Poly-instanton, racetrack and KKLT/LARGE-volume alternatives retain their own premises. The description poses unification and supersymmetry-scale goals; it establishes neither their realization, a particular breaking pattern nor an inflationary target. Independent confirmation: u15's unification, string-scale and supersymmetry-scale goals fit c8's coupling and hierarchy targets. The explicit alternatives remain intact, and the role does not claim a realized breaking pattern, successful construction or inflation.","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:4662b44467681f883d21e8b73a7f5898a545b8ee2ef47d050bd9464cd9d288f6","textSha256":"c549b66541fd94aafb5fdbd15db121d8e1ea6e2d1985ed2e77d7f60245e1755d","paperId":"0806.2667"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:role:1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:role:1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4662b44467681f883d21e8b73a7f5898a545b8ee2ef47d050bd9464cd9d288f6","q025-candidate-question:64d242f010006f3d1a0a3120"],"challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-proposal","challengeReviewId":"strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-independent-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-independent-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:4662b44467681f883d21e8b73a7f5898a545b8ee2ef47d050bd9464cd9d288f6","textSha256":"c549b66541fd94aafb5fdbd15db121d8e1ea6e2d1985ed2e77d7f60245e1755d","paperId":"0806.2667"}],"originalRole":{"unitRef":"u15","questionRef":"c8","role":"specializes","reason":"Confirm the contribution to the reused coupling and scale-hierarchy target. Poly-instanton, racetrack and KKLT/LARGE-volume alternatives retain their own premises. The description poses unification and supersymmetry-scale goals; it establishes neither their realization, a particular breaking pattern nor an inflationary target.","refs":["u15","c3","c8","n4"]},"independentAssessment":{"index":1,"verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"u15's unification, string-scale and supersymmetry-scale goals fit c8's coupling and hierarchy targets. The explicit alternatives remain intact, and the role does not claim a realized breaking pattern, successful construction or inflation.","refs":["u15","c3","c8","n4"]},"contextRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643"},{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0594a24f01f9b493cef4-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:64d242f010006f3d1a0a3120"},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:4662b44467681f883d21e8b73a7f5898a545b8ee2ef47d050bd9464cd9d288f6","reviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"scopeContentSha256":"6db4338af96093be5bb3a761b43810837e71fd34bbfca731558568f4853ee5ef","contributionContentSha256":"c4e7a3210a09fcadf4edce472f90dd0947695d4b881b03cd81a4d44dffbc66b1","coordinatorAdmissionReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/navigation-admissions-v4/strong-scope-bundle-04-admission.json","sha256":"c886766c5d40b66a96570bff12695ec1bc37b9d08bf368c4c60c1461d0ae2be6"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"c2d53b420b72d96f33c97a0055f348b6ea647d2c82d665162f74d21ea41aaddd"},"organizational-access:e24dc3f7d7d6f75540d93a1e":{"id":"organizational-access:e24dc3f7d7d6f75540d93a1e","source":"q025-candidate-question:12a2e56e9a3e4a85989a684c","target":"q025-candidate-question:528990f28c3ccba6d5d8b47d","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:12a2e56e9a3e4a85989a684c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"da7d218c2f8e077a8e32d2aee988ab77679ea16fa2e7eb999dfecb655306f99a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f172d745f261c9ec6e9cde96"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:528990f28c3ccba6d5d8b47d","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"bae79f7df0fdb4a7de842c161ffdcee66a0f9322f4a87a0745d2c078fcb27cf7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5fb1a25377f06ba5149f24fe"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","home":{"unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:12a2e56e9a3e4a85989a684c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers additive exponential scalar fields, cooperative inflation, exact scaling backgrounds and their perturbation spectra.","qualification":"q0 explicitly joins additive exponential fields, ordinary assistance, scaling attractors and perturbation spectra. Unequal slopes and expansion-only cooperation remain local premises. Exact background scaling does not establish an exact spectral formula, a current observational fit or any quantum-gravity criterion.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","textSha256":"7aa306b37d444bb72c20d45042ed6c79f78d4ba7f75932003723cbbf8f4517f2"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0024:u14:q0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0024:u14:q0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","q025-candidate-question:12a2e56e9a3e4a85989a684c"],"scopeContentSha256":"da7d218c2f8e077a8e32d2aee988ab77679ea16fa2e7eb999dfecb655306f99a","placementContentSha256":"40fab782d5e0c1e1843fb646cb64f3ba77e1f3938d800ec0d2b00dff962d1b94","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0024:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0024:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","textSha256":"7aa306b37d444bb72c20d45042ed6c79f78d4ba7f75932003723cbbf8f4517f2"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0024","unitRef":"u14"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:528990f28c3ccba6d5d8b47d","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d83","kind":"description","unitIndex":83,"unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","textSha256":"7aa306b37d444bb72c20d45042ed6c79f78d4ba7f75932003723cbbf8f4517f2"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:45fe1827b0f2a4faf3e6a9dcab050945","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","sourceSha256":"4bb665e487cd75fe15fd8ea0f2272ab9e37a9200669c3c812bbd20beb393b2ab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1018abf2bf26376a9ff3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"376a42a5a2823341f2ec6361814659bb206ac52b64a4aed93c5961399642e8bb","pdfPage":1,"start":1304,"end":4170,"textSha256":"22f59185f431d90fd30a7c9e307aab51ff0b20069dfc343731e06e392e2fa351","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e27","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fcc37c0fa77317481e78cd5e0f8c2a6e","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","sourceSha256":"4bb665e487cd75fe15fd8ea0f2272ab9e37a9200669c3c812bbd20beb393b2ab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1018abf2bf26376a9ff3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"376a42a5a2823341f2ec6361814659bb206ac52b64a4aed93c5961399642e8bb","pdfPage":3,"start":114,"end":3510,"textSha256":"d9ab2330a1965d788609160167983b17fba678af63e3da71bd03391c218973ae","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:79356626aafd3b2c74ba43de03ab8827","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","sourceSha256":"4bb665e487cd75fe15fd8ea0f2272ab9e37a9200669c3c812bbd20beb393b2ab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1018abf2bf26376a9ff3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"376a42a5a2823341f2ec6361814659bb206ac52b64a4aed93c5961399642e8bb","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"6153dfd2eb7e0a944f70498cfaa8b781d45c8ee43b409dca43f036cc1e6fb034","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3fb6f53d6defe20dfa945833"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3fb6f53d6defe20dfa945833","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","q025-candidate-question:528990f28c3ccba6d5d8b47d"],"scopeContentSha256":"bae79f7df0fdb4a7de842c161ffdcee66a0f9322f4a87a0745d2c078fcb27cf7","contributionContentSha256":"745bff353b8c6027708a78089eb526191609b7fdc94226b714bb760f60b00bb7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d83","kind":"description","unitIndex":83,"unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","textSha256":"7aa306b37d444bb72c20d45042ed6c79f78d4ba7f75932003723cbbf8f4517f2"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:45fe1827b0f2a4faf3e6a9dcab050945","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","sourceSha256":"4bb665e487cd75fe15fd8ea0f2272ab9e37a9200669c3c812bbd20beb393b2ab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1018abf2bf26376a9ff3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"376a42a5a2823341f2ec6361814659bb206ac52b64a4aed93c5961399642e8bb","pdfPage":1,"start":1304,"end":4170,"textSha256":"22f59185f431d90fd30a7c9e307aab51ff0b20069dfc343731e06e392e2fa351","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e27","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fcc37c0fa77317481e78cd5e0f8c2a6e","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","sourceSha256":"4bb665e487cd75fe15fd8ea0f2272ab9e37a9200669c3c812bbd20beb393b2ab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1018abf2bf26376a9ff3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"376a42a5a2823341f2ec6361814659bb206ac52b64a4aed93c5961399642e8bb","pdfPage":3,"start":114,"end":3510,"textSha256":"d9ab2330a1965d788609160167983b17fba678af63e3da71bd03391c218973ae","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:79356626aafd3b2c74ba43de03ab8827","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","sourceSha256":"4bb665e487cd75fe15fd8ea0f2272ab9e37a9200669c3c812bbd20beb393b2ab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1018abf2bf26376a9ff3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"376a42a5a2823341f2ec6361814659bb206ac52b64a4aed93c5961399642e8bb","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"6153dfd2eb7e0a944f70498cfaa8b781d45c8ee43b409dca43f036cc1e6fb034","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3fb6f53d6defe20dfa945833","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Fields interact only through expansion. Background scaling is exact; no quantum-gravity criterion is imposed.","challengeNote":"Fields couple through expansion only. Exact background scaling and the spectral calculation are separate results; no quantum-gravity criterion is imposed.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ef77b79caf0d09d926e6d8fc463cd90655595d83ea686d48e2c63f27f11d8658"},"organizational-access:ba6391027d2896d22b7f884c":{"id":"organizational-access:ba6391027d2896d22b7f884c","source":"q025-candidate-question:1af1f76a68247aa1f31f97b5","target":"q025-candidate-question:1c2f7b605b90533b39bf3f76","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1af1f76a68247aa1f31f97b5","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"d35395d7bda75d8974d750a504aab3d64b45fefb9783177448ee4969cacdbabf","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f2cf6e5804b0f328a1ad301a"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1c2f7b605b90533b39bf3f76","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"fc5c5a7228b5c4d97645af4cb390c46788b3d3f4c829c3ecbe9497f403748bdc","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:statistics:pq9"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:33180cddbf29413b88ea541ad9a79801acd2b253f9cab8dcd6958b6020d70698","home":{"unitId":"unit:33180cddbf29413b88ea541ad9a79801acd2b253f9cab8dcd6958b6020d70698","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1af1f76a68247aa1f31f97b5","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q2 jointly covers parallel-source de Sitter existence conditions and instability tests in the retained volume, dilaton and source-adapted anisotropy fields.","qualification":"q2 explicitly combines the parallel-source existence question with the selected volume, dilaton and anisotropy stability test. Neither passing inequalities nor failing to find a tachyon establishes a complete solution or full metastability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:33180cddbf29413b88ea541ad9a79801acd2b253f9cab8dcd6958b6020d70698","paperId":"1807.09698","textSha256":"5e75b394db2beee31b11384d21aaacdfeae5c82de1ccf09092056c1833590384"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u19:q2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u19:q2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:33180cddbf29413b88ea541ad9a79801acd2b253f9cab8dcd6958b6020d70698","q025-candidate-question:1af1f76a68247aa1f31f97b5"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35395d7bda75d8974d750a504aab3d64b45fefb9783177448ee4969cacdbabf","placementContentSha256":"9e35a897f8fa64936c8a5c4653f2f0805c24ab358d1afa2fdd85bbb52e06d39c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:33180cddbf29413b88ea541ad9a79801acd2b253f9cab8dcd6958b6020d70698","paperId":"1807.09698","textSha256":"5e75b394db2beee31b11384d21aaacdfeae5c82de1ccf09092056c1833590384"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0031","unitRef":"u19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:33180cddbf29413b88ea541ad9a79801acd2b253f9cab8dcd6958b6020d70698","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1c2f7b605b90533b39bf3f76","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u12","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:33180cddbf29413b88ea541ad9a79801acd2b253f9cab8dcd6958b6020d70698","paperId":"1807.09698","textSha256":"5e75b394db2beee31b11384d21aaacdfeae5c82de1ccf09092056c1833590384"},{"localRef":"e51","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:085897bdf1bd59159515d852fd8f45c2","paperId":"1807.09698","sourceSha256":"3bbef00dd791572a2a43a24de7c60608b30520167d055037cf7281eb94612ab6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d8e1fcf087319ef2549c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"404ef8a4dee67d0bc5ba69db9ed284594c495cf1627e452b1d522185256dd9b7","pdfPage":9,"start":863,"end":2618,"textSha256":"c911bd1b9ccb8b8060950f3b7f98797d4be53cac5eba88eca7f126dbc9da2f06","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e55","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:33732340cc7c9ecd222d3c6c6dae57e7","paperId":"1807.09698","sourceSha256":"3bbef00dd791572a2a43a24de7c60608b30520167d055037cf7281eb94612ab6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d8e1fcf087319ef2549c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"404ef8a4dee67d0bc5ba69db9ed284594c495cf1627e452b1d522185256dd9b7","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"6497e7b2d7a0e7326e0495772b0acaf06cc5f2fd66fb9c5b9c7587e94b4ce270","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e57","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:be318762939909ffe11ab2fe1aa8c343","paperId":"1807.09698","sourceSha256":"3bbef00dd791572a2a43a24de7c60608b30520167d055037cf7281eb94612ab6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d8e1fcf087319ef2549c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"404ef8a4dee67d0bc5ba69db9ed284594c495cf1627e452b1d522185256dd9b7","pdfPage":3,"start":423,"end":3423,"textSha256":"9d9ffbc3a6cdc9b39964a12ba5b51435f0053c2359fc6294bf26a2095832c1a4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"qualification":"Primary windows identify the parallel-source volume, dilaton and anisotropy test and the failure to obtain a full systematic-tachyon exclusion. A surviving three-field region is not a constructed stable vacuum.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z63"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z63","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:33180cddbf29413b88ea541ad9a79801acd2b253f9cab8dcd6958b6020d70698","q025-candidate-question:1c2f7b605b90533b39bf3f76"],"scopeContentSha256":"fc5c5a7228b5c4d97645af4cb390c46788b3d3f4c829c3ecbe9497f403748bdc","contributionContentSha256":"3cb8645abceba68919de8c186c60ca5dabf13a15807e25ec1e0b8d56d1c023fa","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation"},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","statistics-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u12","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:33180cddbf29413b88ea541ad9a79801acd2b253f9cab8dcd6958b6020d70698","paperId":"1807.09698","textSha256":"5e75b394db2beee31b11384d21aaacdfeae5c82de1ccf09092056c1833590384"},{"localRef":"e51","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:085897bdf1bd59159515d852fd8f45c2","paperId":"1807.09698","sourceSha256":"3bbef00dd791572a2a43a24de7c60608b30520167d055037cf7281eb94612ab6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d8e1fcf087319ef2549c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"404ef8a4dee67d0bc5ba69db9ed284594c495cf1627e452b1d522185256dd9b7","pdfPage":9,"start":863,"end":2618,"textSha256":"c911bd1b9ccb8b8060950f3b7f98797d4be53cac5eba88eca7f126dbc9da2f06","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e55","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:33732340cc7c9ecd222d3c6c6dae57e7","paperId":"1807.09698","sourceSha256":"3bbef00dd791572a2a43a24de7c60608b30520167d055037cf7281eb94612ab6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d8e1fcf087319ef2549c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"404ef8a4dee67d0bc5ba69db9ed284594c495cf1627e452b1d522185256dd9b7","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"6497e7b2d7a0e7326e0495772b0acaf06cc5f2fd66fb9c5b9c7587e94b4ce270","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e57","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:be318762939909ffe11ab2fe1aa8c343","paperId":"1807.09698","sourceSha256":"3bbef00dd791572a2a43a24de7c60608b30520167d055037cf7281eb94612ab6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d8e1fcf087319ef2549c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"404ef8a4dee67d0bc5ba69db9ed284594c495cf1627e452b1d522185256dd9b7","pdfPage":3,"start":423,"end":3423,"textSha256":"9d9ffbc3a6cdc9b39964a12ba5b51435f0053c2359fc6294bf26a2095832c1a4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"explicitConfirmation":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z63","family":"statistics","originalRowId":"z63","oldRole":{"id":"z63","unitRef":"u12","questionRef":"pq9","role":"specializes","reason":"Primary windows identify the parallel-source volume, dilaton and anisotropy test and the failure to obtain a full systematic-tachyon exclusion. A surviving three-field region is not a constructed stable vacuum.","refs":["u12","e51","e55","e57"]},"confirmation":{"id":"z63","verdict":"supported_as_written","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":[],"reason":"The parallel-source three-field analysis directly supplies the narrower stability test and explicitly fails to establish a general tachyon exclusion or a constructed stable vacuum.","refs":["u12","pq9","e51","e55","e57"]},"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation","qualificationUnchanged":true}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c819731843def5df5d6c475dbd8ef1c2e5fe25b711c6156e5806c1d00c4e479a","home":{"unitId":"unit:c819731843def5df5d6c475dbd8ef1c2e5fe25b711c6156e5806c1d00c4e479a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1af1f76a68247aa1f31f97b5","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q2 expressly includes type-II orientifolds to D>4 and the joint necessary existence and volume/dilaton stability screen.","qualification":"q2 explicitly covers the joint necessary-condition screen in D>4. Its higher-dimensional source restrictions and noncanonical universal-field coordinates remain applicable; surviving cases do not establish full solutions, physical mass values or complete stability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c819731843def5df5d6c475dbd8ef1c2e5fe25b711c6156e5806c1d00c4e479a","paperId":"1111.3154","textSha256":"0377016aefcd46605ae30cf6d055b82b0008d47a5f58c048e454b14abce5cd07"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u14:q2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u14:q2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c819731843def5df5d6c475dbd8ef1c2e5fe25b711c6156e5806c1d00c4e479a","q025-candidate-question:1af1f76a68247aa1f31f97b5"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35395d7bda75d8974d750a504aab3d64b45fefb9783177448ee4969cacdbabf","placementContentSha256":"0d580312bbf6e6875339a82a51c87659a3b9fa33a200f40578898fe456c4b662","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c819731843def5df5d6c475dbd8ef1c2e5fe25b711c6156e5806c1d00c4e479a","paperId":"1111.3154","textSha256":"0377016aefcd46605ae30cf6d055b82b0008d47a5f58c048e454b14abce5cd07"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0031","unitRef":"u14"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c819731843def5df5d6c475dbd8ef1c2e5fe25b711c6156e5806c1d00c4e479a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1c2f7b605b90533b39bf3f76","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c819731843def5df5d6c475dbd8ef1c2e5fe25b711c6156e5806c1d00c4e479a","paperId":"1111.3154","textSha256":"0377016aefcd46605ae30cf6d055b82b0008d47a5f58c048e454b14abce5cd07"},{"localRef":"e52","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:161480b4fff37ffd3663d5d79b0ad970","paperId":"1111.3154","sourceSha256":"47e07ba7152d0428cb3bc65d1f27607f772b70b295dfadbd191b801393230b2d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4f6e45a628f3eca862bb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a98b32b6c29c2e6d5c6e1a1deadb222626ccad4c7d3b905b9b20010c3f675828","pdfPage":7,"start":103,"end":2677,"textSha256":"b35a718f7f99c44a37b87bd3386067b5a3d77db2d46a2716c6a8872004e82b85","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e54","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2293ee5dbb4491c2c842c9af30c610a9","paperId":"1111.3154","sourceSha256":"47e07ba7152d0428cb3bc65d1f27607f772b70b295dfadbd191b801393230b2d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4f6e45a628f3eca862bb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a98b32b6c29c2e6d5c6e1a1deadb222626ccad4c7d3b905b9b20010c3f675828","pdfPage":13,"start":113,"end":2134,"textSha256":"1d277b5f6e2811cfc4e261825891112397f3ba7b56ae6f2a42f5005ce9832c15","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e56","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6b20bc9420cd27ed0ae5d171e3627d12","paperId":"1111.3154","sourceSha256":"47e07ba7152d0428cb3bc65d1f27607f772b70b295dfadbd191b801393230b2d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4f6e45a628f3eca862bb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a98b32b6c29c2e6d5c6e1a1deadb222626ccad4c7d3b905b9b20010c3f675828","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":798,"textSha256":"8cd6c69ab477887d7fc18e4cf2d736da102c4b464e34b9673d5b370a0a122526","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"qualification":"Primary windows supply the higher-dimensional volume-and-dilaton tests with calibrated-source restrictions, excluded ingredients and noncanonical coordinates. Their surviving cases satisfy necessary conditions only.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z62"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z62","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c819731843def5df5d6c475dbd8ef1c2e5fe25b711c6156e5806c1d00c4e479a","q025-candidate-question:1c2f7b605b90533b39bf3f76"],"scopeContentSha256":"fc5c5a7228b5c4d97645af4cb390c46788b3d3f4c829c3ecbe9497f403748bdc","contributionContentSha256":"0a3dc76aa5b5bbfe33534774c309b54b454d34dcee12389ceb697fdade6d1327","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation"},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","statistics-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c819731843def5df5d6c475dbd8ef1c2e5fe25b711c6156e5806c1d00c4e479a","paperId":"1111.3154","textSha256":"0377016aefcd46605ae30cf6d055b82b0008d47a5f58c048e454b14abce5cd07"},{"localRef":"e52","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:161480b4fff37ffd3663d5d79b0ad970","paperId":"1111.3154","sourceSha256":"47e07ba7152d0428cb3bc65d1f27607f772b70b295dfadbd191b801393230b2d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4f6e45a628f3eca862bb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a98b32b6c29c2e6d5c6e1a1deadb222626ccad4c7d3b905b9b20010c3f675828","pdfPage":7,"start":103,"end":2677,"textSha256":"b35a718f7f99c44a37b87bd3386067b5a3d77db2d46a2716c6a8872004e82b85","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e54","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2293ee5dbb4491c2c842c9af30c610a9","paperId":"1111.3154","sourceSha256":"47e07ba7152d0428cb3bc65d1f27607f772b70b295dfadbd191b801393230b2d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4f6e45a628f3eca862bb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a98b32b6c29c2e6d5c6e1a1deadb222626ccad4c7d3b905b9b20010c3f675828","pdfPage":13,"start":113,"end":2134,"textSha256":"1d277b5f6e2811cfc4e261825891112397f3ba7b56ae6f2a42f5005ce9832c15","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e56","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6b20bc9420cd27ed0ae5d171e3627d12","paperId":"1111.3154","sourceSha256":"47e07ba7152d0428cb3bc65d1f27607f772b70b295dfadbd191b801393230b2d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4f6e45a628f3eca862bb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a98b32b6c29c2e6d5c6e1a1deadb222626ccad4c7d3b905b9b20010c3f675828","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":798,"textSha256":"8cd6c69ab477887d7fc18e4cf2d736da102c4b464e34b9673d5b370a0a122526","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"explicitConfirmation":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z62","family":"statistics","originalRowId":"z62","oldRole":{"id":"z62","unitRef":"u7","questionRef":"pq9","role":"specializes","reason":"Primary windows supply the higher-dimensional volume-and-dilaton tests with calibrated-source restrictions, excluded ingredients and noncanonical coordinates. Their surviving cases satisfy necessary conditions only.","refs":["u7","e52","e54","e56"]},"confirmation":{"id":"z62","verdict":"supported_as_written","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":[],"reason":"The higher-dimensional volume/dilaton screen specializes pq9 with calibrated-source restrictions, excluded ingredients, noncanonical coordinates and necessary-only surviving cases.","refs":["u7","pq9","e52","e54","e56"]},"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation","qualificationUnchanged":true}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"c04a4f64a4e7dd5fe51c5212e0880ae101fcdeaa3c7ed68c5795b4d891819227"},"organizational-access:01200ebb10b4893c6e38a2b2":{"id":"organizational-access:01200ebb10b4893c6e38a2b2","source":"q025-candidate-question:20b741d8aefd7b97af399a0e","target":"q025-candidate-question:ddf084727c4029dbb6941505","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:20b741d8aefd7b97af399a0e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"2d4a598788c789f940f9603a925ec36f6c52f9fb9d92738196ae48d188d668d8","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3c9ba049d2e35e9d87fe9d04"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ddf084727c4029dbb6941505","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"18ae7c7271ee30c147edc9f742a914f37b27fefafe287a71f3dc1aa693e40396","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f3bf11ba89d1bd54744a34d1"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","home":{"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:20b741d8aefd7b97af399a0e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers regulated AdS/CFT information density and comparison of boundary entropy with boundary area through bulk-IR/boundary-UV regulation.","qualification":"q5 expressly covers finite information density, regulated entropy/area comparison and bulk-IR/boundary-UV regulation. q0 also supplies a complete foundational counting alternative, while q10 and q17 supply broader dictionary contexts. q5 is a focused choice because it names the compared quantities and regulator regime. Information capacity is not replaced with a particular subregion's entropy or operational reconstruction.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","textSha256":"f778529a916d97c311f42305661e888bca67f8f9e502e409f80cc3cd8f94d177"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0016:u19:q5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0016:u19:q5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","q025-candidate-question:20b741d8aefd7b97af399a0e"],"scopeContentSha256":"2d4a598788c789f940f9603a925ec36f6c52f9fb9d92738196ae48d188d668d8","placementContentSha256":"6bf7f662242c03163b66a0596de4ec5f9d7cf3fe18d9d46ffda363f3db6f16be","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0016:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0016:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","textSha256":"f778529a916d97c311f42305661e888bca67f8f9e502e409f80cc3cd8f94d177"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0016","unitRef":"u19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ddf084727c4029dbb6941505","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d63","kind":"description","unitIndex":63,"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","textSha256":"f778529a916d97c311f42305661e888bca67f8f9e502e409f80cc3cd8f94d177"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8a364bd089ae3f1fdd73dad149e30eaf","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","sourceSha256":"5185a9cd80d1f1d92b3b74832c0d3c3b7a8678dcef19d14912f41c4bc2051b3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6117198e7743034ee921/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e116a91f23e0758514e5c79078a3ff51beb54da84e09dcf8bd850bdeb3a0b7aa","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1083,"textSha256":"a68ee0222566040e6f1d3819e543b44a4ac00abe61bbb32fd8ce4ce4c7e7af5c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cb0d76e453019315ec1dcb33e694f229","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","sourceSha256":"5185a9cd80d1f1d92b3b74832c0d3c3b7a8678dcef19d14912f41c4bc2051b3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6117198e7743034ee921/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e116a91f23e0758514e5c79078a3ff51beb54da84e09dcf8bd850bdeb3a0b7aa","pdfPage":2,"start":96,"end":2566,"textSha256":"c0803c62f1b2eaa132532b62f62dabc6f141cbfcc815895e5248d1f50673137b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f60efdfff3d0d3b6b51b4f67","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: v1, 19 May 1998. The target is a regulated comparison of boundary area and entropy. Independent challenge qualification: v1, 19 May 1998. The target is the regulated area/entropy comparison through the bulk IR–boundary UV relation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f60efdfff3d0d3b6b51b4f67","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","q025-candidate-question:ddf084727c4029dbb6941505"],"scopeContentSha256":"18ae7c7271ee30c147edc9f742a914f37b27fefafe287a71f3dc1aa693e40396","contributionContentSha256":"36e143f088ac4f20f53ff7ff938b6c5a413aee4401baa76ac0dc7fc876ed3098","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d63","kind":"description","unitIndex":63,"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","textSha256":"f778529a916d97c311f42305661e888bca67f8f9e502e409f80cc3cd8f94d177"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8a364bd089ae3f1fdd73dad149e30eaf","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","sourceSha256":"5185a9cd80d1f1d92b3b74832c0d3c3b7a8678dcef19d14912f41c4bc2051b3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6117198e7743034ee921/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e116a91f23e0758514e5c79078a3ff51beb54da84e09dcf8bd850bdeb3a0b7aa","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1083,"textSha256":"a68ee0222566040e6f1d3819e543b44a4ac00abe61bbb32fd8ce4ce4c7e7af5c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cb0d76e453019315ec1dcb33e694f229","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","sourceSha256":"5185a9cd80d1f1d92b3b74832c0d3c3b7a8678dcef19d14912f41c4bc2051b3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6117198e7743034ee921/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e116a91f23e0758514e5c79078a3ff51beb54da84e09dcf8bd850bdeb3a0b7aa","pdfPage":2,"start":96,"end":2566,"textSha256":"c0803c62f1b2eaa132532b62f62dabc6f141cbfcc815895e5248d1f50673137b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f60efdfff3d0d3b6b51b4f67","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"v1, 19 May 1998. The target is a regulated comparison of boundary area and entropy.","challengeNote":"v1, 19 May 1998. The target is the regulated area/entropy comparison through the bulk IR–boundary UV relation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4a7b32476b0224bbcf83451c47fef47616725fd5f95b6693a84e82ac44e3bd5c"},"organizational-access:b8da918aca3898e5f9693c88":{"id":"organizational-access:b8da918aca3898e5f9693c88","source":"q025-candidate-question:32fb14ab6798cddd2cde3f5d","target":"q025-candidate-question:c51edd3f05748be7fdb1dbb5","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:32fb14ab6798cddd2cde3f5d","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"594dc89c7e49b39a3a50358f39b6283e92e2ecdc0389830e98f215129590b8cf","scopeDecisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:scope:pq0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c51edd3f05748be7fdb1dbb5","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9c9181367745d6a9ea303f2be2728453e68e41d27507097b1d8e7e58997ad0e1","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:24a0983c79649c3ce3d8396c"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","home":{"unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:32fb14ab6798cddd2cde3f5d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Its admitted question explicitly combines five-dimensional coupling/BPS diagnostics with tests of the associated Calabi–Yau geometric predictions.","qualification":"q4 explicitly combines the five-dimensional gauge/BPS diagnostic question with the associated geometric tests. Bottom-up cubic-EFT arguments and top-down charged BPS/GV tests remain separate evidence routes. Reported favorable-CICY agreement neither audits the sweep nor proves a universal classification, tower theorem or controlled worldsheet identification.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","paperId":"2309.10024","textSha256":"b839d43c589a477882b7e23cd04af016c466f1249c06d808d70a544baa012739"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0009:u20:q4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0009:u20:q4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","q025-candidate-question:32fb14ab6798cddd2cde3f5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"594dc89c7e49b39a3a50358f39b6283e92e2ecdc0389830e98f215129590b8cf","placementContentSha256":"33279f925a61f80f3f6a468d60c054081af0254023aee0a0276685e1ea329ee0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0009:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0009:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","paperId":"2309.10024","textSha256":"b839d43c589a477882b7e23cd04af016c466f1249c06d808d70a544baa012739"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0009","unitRef":"u20"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c51edd3f05748be7fdb1dbb5","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d73","kind":"description","unitIndex":73,"unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","textSha256":"b839d43c589a477882b7e23cd04af016c466f1249c06d808d70a544baa012739"},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ad7cbb807bbf1fc735c7bf6b9c9f9581","paperId":"2309.10024","sourceSha256":"37763c541b77890e8b7024250ce16b27ce96dcb8c40bdc33c664c3fe8732fe3c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/222f6634fd6f8353feda/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2be8db64cb2c48830804ead23e890c538da6f8142c392e5a5f13860d6b34ea6f","pdfPage":3,"start":99,"end":2941,"textSha256":"297eadda29d7c3bf5118319e08e57e35b51ea4c21a2d6ec77f5a453eb52f6d2a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c58116c501c02fa35cbce7bd6bafd083","paperId":"2309.10024","sourceSha256":"37763c541b77890e8b7024250ce16b27ce96dcb8c40bdc33c664c3fe8732fe3c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/222f6634fd6f8353feda/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2be8db64cb2c48830804ead23e890c538da6f8142c392e5a5f13860d6b34ea6f","pdfPage":2,"start":114,"end":2064,"textSha256":"3652c31610a939058e90ab8a8ee146e08a4bef35d101acde469a1a54468e2bd5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e28","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f0fd5b2d4c23ab8d5367405d41129287","paperId":"2309.10024","sourceSha256":"37763c541b77890e8b7024250ce16b27ce96dcb8c40bdc33c664c3fe8732fe3c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/222f6634fd6f8353feda/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2be8db64cb2c48830804ead23e890c538da6f8142c392e5a5f13860d6b34ea6f","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2941,"textSha256":"148d9ded185b2e694f733a6fafb81f9e41c458f4b8b3c16efe3487cecff5d4dc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b7c0d8c4dd1450353f27fb56"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b7c0d8c4dd1450353f27fb56","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","q025-candidate-question:c51edd3f05748be7fdb1dbb5"],"scopeContentSha256":"9c9181367745d6a9ea303f2be2728453e68e41d27507097b1d8e7e58997ad0e1","contributionContentSha256":"ff096d92e59fb74adce63625a92c48f0bd6f79523aaf18ae79451440a0d7345c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d73","kind":"description","unitIndex":73,"unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","textSha256":"b839d43c589a477882b7e23cd04af016c466f1249c06d808d70a544baa012739"},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ad7cbb807bbf1fc735c7bf6b9c9f9581","paperId":"2309.10024","sourceSha256":"37763c541b77890e8b7024250ce16b27ce96dcb8c40bdc33c664c3fe8732fe3c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/222f6634fd6f8353feda/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2be8db64cb2c48830804ead23e890c538da6f8142c392e5a5f13860d6b34ea6f","pdfPage":3,"start":99,"end":2941,"textSha256":"297eadda29d7c3bf5118319e08e57e35b51ea4c21a2d6ec77f5a453eb52f6d2a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c58116c501c02fa35cbce7bd6bafd083","paperId":"2309.10024","sourceSha256":"37763c541b77890e8b7024250ce16b27ce96dcb8c40bdc33c664c3fe8732fe3c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/222f6634fd6f8353feda/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2be8db64cb2c48830804ead23e890c538da6f8142c392e5a5f13860d6b34ea6f","pdfPage":2,"start":114,"end":2064,"textSha256":"3652c31610a939058e90ab8a8ee146e08a4bef35d101acde469a1a54468e2bd5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e28","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f0fd5b2d4c23ab8d5367405d41129287","paperId":"2309.10024","sourceSha256":"37763c541b77890e8b7024250ce16b27ce96dcb8c40bdc33c664c3fe8732fe3c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/222f6634fd6f8353feda/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2be8db64cb2c48830804ead23e890c538da6f8142c392e5a5f13860d6b34ea6f","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2941,"textSha256":"148d9ded185b2e694f733a6fafb81f9e41c458f4b8b3c16efe3487cecff5d4dc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b7c0d8c4dd1450353f27fb56","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound bottom-up gauge-scaling and top-down BPS-index tests; reported favorable-CICY agreement is evidence, not a universal proof.","challengeNote":"Compound bottom-up gauge-scaling and top-down BPS-index tests. Reported favorable-CICY agreement is evidence, not a verified universal result.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"dcd8dd94aaa2a8a9cc562b52b0569ebd1c0885b6872473df390dc8e78e653c98"},"organizational-access:4a521e1d9ebaea60fb564093":{"id":"organizational-access:4a521e1d9ebaea60fb564093","source":"q025-candidate-question:365a8ae7b07971fd71ed8f88","target":"q025-candidate-question:3270af996c7d02d7d52c9482","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:365a8ae7b07971fd71ed8f88","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f28d51ec98387f0434b7c492025cd5edb3d158bbeab3552ccca73ae321f18c0c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:028da2db37e670ca0ac3a847"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3270af996c7d02d7d52c9482","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"0946dee2a07a1c7cc1dfe7d8f357453ccc58a2889809cda2cd6a7efc43f7735d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e34b7f6f3d05441a431306d8"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:ee9782043f39d70ae808b45e5c94d9ee57e182329153f87c51dbe89451ba2e19","home":{"unitId":"unit:ee9782043f39d70ae808b45e5c94d9ee57e182329153f87c51dbe89451ba2e19","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:365a8ae7b07971fd71ed8f88","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly includes second-order modified-measure constructions, their scalar interpretation, inflation and late vacuum-energy targets.","qualification":"q17 includes the specified second-order modified-measure construction, its scalar interpretation and both cosmological targets. Its conventions explicitly protect the distinction between potential dependence and dynamical field content. q2 covers early-to-late cosmological matching but does not provide equally complete coverage of the independent scalar-generation question. Natural generation remains a target rather than an established naturalness result.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ee9782043f39d70ae808b45e5c94d9ee57e182329153f87c51dbe89451ba2e19","textSha256":"aeb0da721fc602ba8af442dec1eedea3ccaf2caf6e379b89fd3d324410debc1b"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:competing:u6:q17"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:competing:u6:q17","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ee9782043f39d70ae808b45e5c94d9ee57e182329153f87c51dbe89451ba2e19","q025-candidate-question:365a8ae7b07971fd71ed8f88"],"scopeContentSha256":"f28d51ec98387f0434b7c492025cd5edb3d158bbeab3552ccca73ae321f18c0c","placementContentSha256":"cb3b5091e8acb8e782d7e485491d5849b7a42999fb0187281d13e68fc4f70bb8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:competing:proposal","placement-pilot:competing:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ee9782043f39d70ae808b45e5c94d9ee57e182329153f87c51dbe89451ba2e19","textSha256":"aeb0da721fc602ba8af442dec1eedea3ccaf2caf6e379b89fd3d324410debc1b"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:ee9782043f39d70ae808b45e5c94d9ee57e182329153f87c51dbe89451ba2e19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ee9782043f39d70ae808b45e5c94d9ee57e182329153f87c51dbe89451ba2e19","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3270af996c7d02d7d52c9482","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:ee9782043f39d70ae808b45e5c94d9ee57e182329153f87c51dbe89451ba2e19","textSha256":"aeb0da721fc602ba8af442dec1eedea3ccaf2caf6e379b89fd3d324410debc1b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:95fd2023fde4dc64990bef96"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:95fd2023fde4dc64990bef96","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ee9782043f39d70ae808b45e5c94d9ee57e182329153f87c51dbe89451ba2e19","q025-candidate-question:3270af996c7d02d7d52c9482"],"scopeContentSha256":"0946dee2a07a1c7cc1dfe7d8f357453ccc58a2889809cda2cd6a7efc43f7735d","contributionContentSha256":"64f1ae77d8fca7383ce0c8e7128311848253ffb264e9eec9ac9817965c2a52c0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-proposal","leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:ee9782043f39d70ae808b45e5c94d9ee57e182329153f87c51dbe89451ba2e19","textSha256":"aeb0da721fc602ba8af442dec1eedea3ccaf2caf6e379b89fd3d324410debc1b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:95fd2023fde4dc64990bef96","recordId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Two scalar degrees of freedom and a small positive final vacuum energy are construction targets in the second-order formalism.","challengeNote":"Two scalar degrees of freedom, inflation and final positive vacuum energy are construction targets in the specified second-order formalism.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"54cb0dcc71ad2848a2df912a353fd42a61d33916c10e701704cca64091645b8b"},"organizational-access:25db28a6f85ee568b1dea5c0":{"id":"organizational-access:25db28a6f85ee568b1dea5c0","source":"q025-candidate-question:377c1312908bf36a9fc734a9","target":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:377c1312908bf36a9fc734a9","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7fccfebc21cbee0e57ae9aa921f4b3834354eb8e37bdddd3db1d4c38c07c128a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:dbd24bb6d6a7bd8050b82d6a"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0f607371ea101890393fea69"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:ba2db2d76dd6ce5790bb60ec53801f7a3dcc9b3b31008a748cc4b2135a5fc45f","home":{"unitId":"unit:ba2db2d76dd6ce5790bb60ec53801f7a3dcc9b3b31008a748cc4b2135a5fc45f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:377c1312908bf36a9fc734a9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines local LARGE-volume mediation and soft spectra with gauge-mediation compatibility and moduli-cosmology consequences.","qualification":"q9 explicitly joins the bulk/local mediation calculation to gauge-mediation compatibility and moduli cosmology. Both gravity and anomaly contributions remain targets. Suppression and gauge dominance are questions, while damaged historical extraction cannot supply precise formulas.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ba2db2d76dd6ce5790bb60ec53801f7a3dcc9b3b31008a748cc4b2135a5fc45f","paperId":"0906.3297","textSha256":"9e84f3d9eddd52199e064be4c178937bf2487df8c396a06c4f3de6a2308f4a67"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0023:u24:q9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0023:u24:q9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ba2db2d76dd6ce5790bb60ec53801f7a3dcc9b3b31008a748cc4b2135a5fc45f","q025-candidate-question:377c1312908bf36a9fc734a9"],"scopeContentSha256":"7fccfebc21cbee0e57ae9aa921f4b3834354eb8e37bdddd3db1d4c38c07c128a","placementContentSha256":"8f9e1692d5ffab07677ee8113466db1e6d12f1a04af06db59b9d2409f7cfcb94","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0023:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0023:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ba2db2d76dd6ce5790bb60ec53801f7a3dcc9b3b31008a748cc4b2135a5fc45f","paperId":"0906.3297","textSha256":"9e84f3d9eddd52199e064be4c178937bf2487df8c396a06c4f3de6a2308f4a67"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0023","unitRef":"u24"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ba2db2d76dd6ce5790bb60ec53801f7a3dcc9b3b31008a748cc4b2135a5fc45f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:ba2db2d76dd6ce5790bb60ec53801f7a3dcc9b3b31008a748cc4b2135a5fc45f","textSha256":"9e84f3d9eddd52199e064be4c178937bf2487df8c396a06c4f3de6a2308f4a67"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:31c7a7dfe1033cdc51f775126b1bfa97","paperId":"0906.3297","sourceSha256":"73ac981baf751f3b5856b528893414dfc493e7ace7d741097f87c16a960e9e8c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1df636c765545fe77fd7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ad3eceb6578a1ea987bd5de057f0172b89ac3247097f1bf10e3fa8978ab0d09d","pdfPage":4,"start":1332,"end":3442,"textSha256":"00f48028e2b0c1588af7e0fd917f0a6b2ccaed4a756df028515d1344c8c0f38f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:602e8a10d5cbaa609b0d1a70b83de964","paperId":"0906.3297","sourceSha256":"73ac981baf751f3b5856b528893414dfc493e7ace7d741097f87c16a960e9e8c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1df636c765545fe77fd7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ad3eceb6578a1ea987bd5de057f0172b89ac3247097f1bf10e3fa8978ab0d09d","pdfPage":4,"start":112,"end":3442,"textSha256":"1f3cc80f424194fc46b7237813b38101c1866d121aadb3f3c56163e44cb1bcfd","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6f2cde6c678405f4099b2d2e","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound local soft-term calculation and cosmological implications; tests assumed gravity suppression and gauge dominance. OCR prevents precise coefficient/form Independent challenge qualification: Compound local soft-term calculation and cosmological implications. Gravity suppression and gauge dominance are examined, not inherited; damaged extraction "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6f2cde6c678405f4099b2d2e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ba2db2d76dd6ce5790bb60ec53801f7a3dcc9b3b31008a748cc4b2135a5fc45f","q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"],"scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","contributionContentSha256":"42ae772bfc05b3fbb3836520c75aa396e62f7c5d69071d50a86431103d7fcff4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:ba2db2d76dd6ce5790bb60ec53801f7a3dcc9b3b31008a748cc4b2135a5fc45f","textSha256":"9e84f3d9eddd52199e064be4c178937bf2487df8c396a06c4f3de6a2308f4a67"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:31c7a7dfe1033cdc51f775126b1bfa97","paperId":"0906.3297","sourceSha256":"73ac981baf751f3b5856b528893414dfc493e7ace7d741097f87c16a960e9e8c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1df636c765545fe77fd7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ad3eceb6578a1ea987bd5de057f0172b89ac3247097f1bf10e3fa8978ab0d09d","pdfPage":4,"start":1332,"end":3442,"textSha256":"00f48028e2b0c1588af7e0fd917f0a6b2ccaed4a756df028515d1344c8c0f38f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:602e8a10d5cbaa609b0d1a70b83de964","paperId":"0906.3297","sourceSha256":"73ac981baf751f3b5856b528893414dfc493e7ace7d741097f87c16a960e9e8c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1df636c765545fe77fd7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ad3eceb6578a1ea987bd5de057f0172b89ac3247097f1bf10e3fa8978ab0d09d","pdfPage":4,"start":112,"end":3442,"textSha256":"1f3cc80f424194fc46b7237813b38101c1866d121aadb3f3c56163e44cb1bcfd","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6f2cde6c678405f4099b2d2e","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound local soft-term calculation and cosmological implications; tests assumed gravity suppression and gauge dominance. OCR prevents precise coefficient/form","challengeNote":"Compound local soft-term calculation and cosmological implications. Gravity suppression and gauge dominance are examined, not inherited; damaged extraction ","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"3129d4181535c8bba5c65d1f6b2e6c3a5eebe88ffc2f5f64a8da6a903423a391"},"organizational-access:ea4bea331d1247ecf183ba41":{"id":"organizational-access:ea4bea331d1247ecf183ba41","source":"q025-candidate-question:38ea8d7b16f6a8726c81a6f3","target":"q025-candidate-question:6a4acdd5504a55612dbfce6e","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:38ea8d7b16f6a8726c81a6f3","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"aa8de3a58f23b483548c1329344e7ee3e5bb38a689eb369b357aa769c536243e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f6bef67a0a3b95e1c3f4a62d"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6a4acdd5504a55612dbfce6e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"93b5bac1d8fbedcaab700cd59d61d0371df18fd5a553e48e4c9252a44161d00b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:aec62c2073d9e64921c08b57"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:86ee96cee13b942a21941418964f7d0f9782e8ca9ec31a6e174127a332dcef72","home":{"unitId":"unit:86ee96cee13b942a21941418964f7d0f9782e8ca9ec31a6e174127a332dcef72","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:38ea8d7b16f6a8726c81a6f3","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly connects axion quality to cosmological wall viability and distinguishes anomaly coefficients from physical vacuum identifications.","qualification":"q7 explicitly joins quality protection and defect viability in gauge-protected and extra-dimensional systems. It preserves the intermediate-scale anomalous-string setting and requires vacuum identifications before interpreting the apparent multiplicity.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:86ee96cee13b942a21941418964f7d0f9782e8ca9ec31a6e174127a332dcef72","paperId":"1604.00716","textSha256":"f535dd8bf9463550443c726e7cc78ec9b7b53c194cfdfc4117a1c9dfe26b7454"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0038:u6:q7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0038:u6:q7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:86ee96cee13b942a21941418964f7d0f9782e8ca9ec31a6e174127a332dcef72","q025-candidate-question:38ea8d7b16f6a8726c81a6f3"],"scopeContentSha256":"aa8de3a58f23b483548c1329344e7ee3e5bb38a689eb369b357aa769c536243e","placementContentSha256":"4657c121040e2b9f5e510de5d427e0ba9956f2a93a11790781d8aac4e03dc66c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0038:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0038:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:86ee96cee13b942a21941418964f7d0f9782e8ca9ec31a6e174127a332dcef72","paperId":"1604.00716","textSha256":"f535dd8bf9463550443c726e7cc78ec9b7b53c194cfdfc4117a1c9dfe26b7454"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0038","unitRef":"u6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:86ee96cee13b942a21941418964f7d0f9782e8ca9ec31a6e174127a332dcef72","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6a4acdd5504a55612dbfce6e","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d51","kind":"description","unitIndex":51,"unitId":"unit:86ee96cee13b942a21941418964f7d0f9782e8ca9ec31a6e174127a332dcef72","textSha256":"f535dd8bf9463550443c726e7cc78ec9b7b53c194cfdfc4117a1c9dfe26b7454"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7b1453317325ab425482ecab9cc6671a","paperId":"1604.00716","sourceSha256":"0e29a4ce78134edff443609b74ceb74d56b244a1c20ca965c4787336895773b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/58e9c4c4a50aeba2d3e1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"379a49f771baac70988328f965e1c35a12e3dce54b78363ea09890359fb09409","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a6ece5ff083228edb293c3f105a9b77e703de656b1724414cc73ea69d954ccfa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9913bc3aed28500f0ca80d496329d188","paperId":"1604.00716","sourceSha256":"0e29a4ce78134edff443609b74ceb74d56b244a1c20ca965c4787336895773b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/58e9c4c4a50aeba2d3e1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"379a49f771baac70988328f965e1c35a12e3dce54b78363ea09890359fb09409","pdfPage":5,"start":2501,"end":4608,"textSha256":"82d7ca6909b570eedf432e1df3ddc58a306f9ca0a5e9031cf7fa2cda8830b5bb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c83b691200e77e306042caca59552126","paperId":"1604.00716","sourceSha256":"0e29a4ce78134edff443609b74ceb74d56b244a1c20ca965c4787336895773b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/58e9c4c4a50aeba2d3e1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"379a49f771baac70988328f965e1c35a12e3dce54b78363ea09890359fb09409","pdfPage":1,"start":2498,"end":4274,"textSha256":"11db053c191c941691eebdf83eb12dd85e8d4ba5edf66f24a38faa5ddda069a3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5cdec008b95d38bb624c9e79","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The April 2016 source couples gravity spoil and wall identification; its axion window depends on cosmology and VEV/decay-constant conventions. Independent challenge qualification: 4 April 2016 v1 combines gravity spoil and physical wall identification; its window depends on cosmology, VEV normalization and vacuum identifications."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5cdec008b95d38bb624c9e79","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:86ee96cee13b942a21941418964f7d0f9782e8ca9ec31a6e174127a332dcef72","q025-candidate-question:6a4acdd5504a55612dbfce6e"],"scopeContentSha256":"93b5bac1d8fbedcaab700cd59d61d0371df18fd5a553e48e4c9252a44161d00b","contributionContentSha256":"0dd62834244465154fa91846160c0ebed47f71670ef1a3e327b36fcfc22a2699","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d51","kind":"description","unitIndex":51,"unitId":"unit:86ee96cee13b942a21941418964f7d0f9782e8ca9ec31a6e174127a332dcef72","textSha256":"f535dd8bf9463550443c726e7cc78ec9b7b53c194cfdfc4117a1c9dfe26b7454"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7b1453317325ab425482ecab9cc6671a","paperId":"1604.00716","sourceSha256":"0e29a4ce78134edff443609b74ceb74d56b244a1c20ca965c4787336895773b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/58e9c4c4a50aeba2d3e1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"379a49f771baac70988328f965e1c35a12e3dce54b78363ea09890359fb09409","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a6ece5ff083228edb293c3f105a9b77e703de656b1724414cc73ea69d954ccfa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9913bc3aed28500f0ca80d496329d188","paperId":"1604.00716","sourceSha256":"0e29a4ce78134edff443609b74ceb74d56b244a1c20ca965c4787336895773b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/58e9c4c4a50aeba2d3e1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"379a49f771baac70988328f965e1c35a12e3dce54b78363ea09890359fb09409","pdfPage":5,"start":2501,"end":4608,"textSha256":"82d7ca6909b570eedf432e1df3ddc58a306f9ca0a5e9031cf7fa2cda8830b5bb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c83b691200e77e306042caca59552126","paperId":"1604.00716","sourceSha256":"0e29a4ce78134edff443609b74ceb74d56b244a1c20ca965c4787336895773b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/58e9c4c4a50aeba2d3e1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"379a49f771baac70988328f965e1c35a12e3dce54b78363ea09890359fb09409","pdfPage":1,"start":2498,"end":4274,"textSha256":"11db053c191c941691eebdf83eb12dd85e8d4ba5edf66f24a38faa5ddda069a3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5cdec008b95d38bb624c9e79","recordId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The April 2016 source couples gravity spoil and wall identification; its axion window depends on cosmology and VEV/decay-constant conventions.","challengeNote":"4 April 2016 v1 combines gravity spoil and physical wall identification; its window depends on cosmology, VEV normalization and vacuum identifications.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"475d8eb4e75214c5b1d9ad41bed9bc5110fad12295a5d21b8a5e7b178a2510ea"},"organizational-access:15df61a10b6d9bc3eb3f31ed":{"id":"organizational-access:15df61a10b6d9bc3eb3f31ed","source":"q025-candidate-question:3d5c2b4ed57cefc85bb9a422","target":"q025-candidate-question:1be677c9a0a26161fd1e91a0","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3d5c2b4ed57cefc85bb9a422","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1f348cab8fcb7081a6fb142faa239ec4d8ce85e6031349fff85e8ffaa14e81e2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:scope:pq0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1be677c9a0a26161fd1e91a0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"abed67899f7b6e3fc7b5849efde529409621b2e485c7820cf23110151f1fff4c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:statistics:pq2"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","home":{"unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3d5c2b4ed57cefc85bb9a422","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q9 explicitly covers finite IIB flux, source and lattice consistency, classical correction control, and the separate implications of a proposed asymptotic scaling.","qualification":"q9 explicitly combines finite quantized IIB consistency/control with the separate question of parametric improvement and obstruction evasion. The reported tachyons, tower limitation and inconclusive correction estimates restrict conclusions, without removing either target.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","paperId":"2403.07065","textSha256":"d8e5d6cccfe27b0d233e28d23db633473b21413bbc7ea9b5862c3a89d3da04e0"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u13:q9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u13:q9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","q025-candidate-question:3d5c2b4ed57cefc85bb9a422"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f348cab8fcb7081a6fb142faa239ec4d8ce85e6031349fff85e8ffaa14e81e2","placementContentSha256":"ab8f66c6ea5d584f82c635c09e2f990ec8003e341efd8768da627b77130151ab","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","paperId":"2403.07065","textSha256":"d8e5d6cccfe27b0d233e28d23db633473b21413bbc7ea9b5862c3a89d3da04e0"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0031","unitRef":"u13"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1be677c9a0a26161fd1e91a0","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u37","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","paperId":"2403.07065","textSha256":"d8e5d6cccfe27b0d233e28d23db633473b21413bbc7ea9b5862c3a89d3da04e0"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:464f8ecb8622f01c189cd53ecfa72248","paperId":"2403.07065","sourceSha256":"5be1329ee3cf770594e4c2172176556c1e4203ebb7f2e5a0a0d06d4449cceb28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eb309a810c842697eae1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1f25699c74daa7c51ef93aa11e828ef60cfc2b418b306c63fa4481b2d3fbea7c","pdfPage":6,"start":98,"end":3490,"textSha256":"e86f3ddd22652eba0fb8582bea1a910823361cb0766cf190f714e8468fbd41fa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"qualification":"The primary discussion reports a Kaluza-Klein tower co-scaling with curvature under the proposed scaling, preventing a parametrically growing gap by that scaling. It leaves other spectrum contributions unexamined.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z47"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z47","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","q025-candidate-question:1be677c9a0a26161fd1e91a0"],"scopeContentSha256":"abed67899f7b6e3fc7b5849efde529409621b2e485c7820cf23110151f1fff4c","contributionContentSha256":"1bdbeaf4bfe2ad3d10e8c18ada7a47d456b76e571edd3ab10300dfc1f40e7f9a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation"},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","statistics-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u37","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","paperId":"2403.07065","textSha256":"d8e5d6cccfe27b0d233e28d23db633473b21413bbc7ea9b5862c3a89d3da04e0"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:464f8ecb8622f01c189cd53ecfa72248","paperId":"2403.07065","sourceSha256":"5be1329ee3cf770594e4c2172176556c1e4203ebb7f2e5a0a0d06d4449cceb28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eb309a810c842697eae1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1f25699c74daa7c51ef93aa11e828ef60cfc2b418b306c63fa4481b2d3fbea7c","pdfPage":6,"start":98,"end":3490,"textSha256":"e86f3ddd22652eba0fb8582bea1a910823361cb0766cf190f714e8468fbd41fa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"explicitConfirmation":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z47","family":"statistics","originalRowId":"z47","oldRole":{"id":"z47","unitRef":"u37","questionRef":"pq2","role":"addresses","reason":"The primary discussion reports a Kaluza-Klein tower co-scaling with curvature under the proposed scaling, preventing a parametrically growing gap by that scaling. It leaves other spectrum contributions unexamined.","refs":["u37","e10"]},"confirmation":{"id":"z47","verdict":"supported_as_written","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":[],"reason":"e10 directly reports no parametric gap improvement for the identified KK tower under this scaling and leaves other spectrum contributions unexamined.","refs":["u37","pq2","e10"]},"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation","qualificationUnchanged":true}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"24b35bb2381a6df845293efe698d8d517c09c3a3830641820df96a80e404347a"},"organizational-access:6037d46308240a4a549c979e":{"id":"organizational-access:6037d46308240a4a549c979e","source":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","target":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5fe049038e0d09e39d73d407"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"adb5d31dd329431521ed5321fd138dbfb86e5c2aaeebab9116b92f32e0b1e624","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c662c02e180fa7532a16ecc9"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:b63d3da3b6ce278b8f181c21560d3525dd134e594326f9551ddde0ebec0b6385","home":{"unitId":"unit:b63d3da3b6ce278b8f181c21560d3525dd134e594326f9551ddde0ebec0b6385","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Centers canonical quintessence inference and covers equation of state, potential properties, field travel and dynamical histories under source-specific priors.","qualification":"q9 covers all four reconstruction targets within canonical scalar dynamics. Potential-formula independence does not remove smoothness or boundary priors; the admitted source-specific quantitative interval remains 0≤z≤1.5. Reconstructed trajectories are within its evolution-and-inference question.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b63d3da3b6ce278b8f181c21560d3525dd134e594326f9551ddde0ebec0b6385","paperId":"2101.04666","textSha256":"5ded4c813b6cc2d487554d20265bf10c87dd9ecf2708f1039858a3712f985079"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0071:u24:q9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0071:u24:q9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b63d3da3b6ce278b8f181c21560d3525dd134e594326f9551ddde0ebec0b6385","q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b"],"scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","placementContentSha256":"0168d6129367b8287ef0679e1a925fa0a3191afdba8e15bf22093490d9095d49","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0071:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0071:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b63d3da3b6ce278b8f181c21560d3525dd134e594326f9551ddde0ebec0b6385","paperId":"2101.04666","textSha256":"5ded4c813b6cc2d487554d20265bf10c87dd9ecf2708f1039858a3712f985079"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0071","unitRef":"u24"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b63d3da3b6ce278b8f181c21560d3525dd134e594326f9551ddde0ebec0b6385","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d62","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:b63d3da3b6ce278b8f181c21560d3525dd134e594326f9551ddde0ebec0b6385","textSha256":"5ded4c813b6cc2d487554d20265bf10c87dd9ecf2708f1039858a3712f985079"},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b3d8a1e0ee2c8b502545eb1a151aedd4","paperId":"2101.04666","sourceSha256":"604b32bdfe7f5f64c68bded6c39078fbfdf30d85710099e117e579a7339beecd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/176cb98d2fd47e508d27/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3d02f7d7b63b88b90c2ac31240bd4e26a28d70f59228d6d3f97f5079ae52976a","pdfPage":1,"start":1991,"end":4991,"textSha256":"ab6ed4c497301a6c349110767fa0df946718b4f119cd1106f0809dd5e7e38a26","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8f7266af0ba9fbc012140824bb344475","paperId":"2101.04666","sourceSha256":"604b32bdfe7f5f64c68bded6c39078fbfdf30d85710099e117e579a7339beecd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/176cb98d2fd47e508d27/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3d02f7d7b63b88b90c2ac31240bd4e26a28d70f59228d6d3f97f5079ae52976a","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"dccc9e9434c5aad4d878223af2d2fa3bb09a93641f4f5b25aae68297b1e80f61","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:90c828480afcf52ea3c6cb03"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:90c828480afcf52ea3c6cb03","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b63d3da3b6ce278b8f181c21560d3525dd134e594326f9551ddde0ebec0b6385","q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6"],"scopeContentSha256":"adb5d31dd329431521ed5321fd138dbfb86e5c2aaeebab9116b92f32e0b1e624","contributionContentSha256":"b4a4f7c5d5a1d9a4e498d29c2bbfbc8bf390509b09174c8e04a85664f60c32ef","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-proposal","leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d62","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:b63d3da3b6ce278b8f181c21560d3525dd134e594326f9551ddde0ebec0b6385","textSha256":"5ded4c813b6cc2d487554d20265bf10c87dd9ecf2708f1039858a3712f985079"},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b3d8a1e0ee2c8b502545eb1a151aedd4","paperId":"2101.04666","sourceSha256":"604b32bdfe7f5f64c68bded6c39078fbfdf30d85710099e117e579a7339beecd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/176cb98d2fd47e508d27/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3d02f7d7b63b88b90c2ac31240bd4e26a28d70f59228d6d3f97f5079ae52976a","pdfPage":1,"start":1991,"end":4991,"textSha256":"ab6ed4c497301a6c349110767fa0df946718b4f119cd1106f0809dd5e7e38a26","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8f7266af0ba9fbc012140824bb344475","paperId":"2101.04666","sourceSha256":"604b32bdfe7f5f64c68bded6c39078fbfdf30d85710099e117e579a7339beecd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/176cb98d2fd47e508d27/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3d02f7d7b63b88b90c2ac31240bd4e26a28d70f59228d6d3f97f5079ae52976a","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"dccc9e9434c5aad4d878223af2d2fa3bb09a93641f4f5b25aae68297b1e80f61","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:90c828480afcf52ea3c6cb03","recordId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Quantitative scope z∈[0,1.5]; no fixed potential, monotonicity or attractor assumption.","challengeNote":"The exact quantitative interval z∈[0,1.5] comes from supplied graph context. Smoothness and early ΛCDM remain assumptions; no monotonic potential or attractor","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"bf291a695b2f3450edd51ec9005e025467183c4e888eeb579b164da489b61d64"},"organizational-access:430d0cdc8db9e8a44f0c52ce":{"id":"organizational-access:430d0cdc8db9e8a44f0c52ce","source":"q025-candidate-question:50f75a19b55e0395217ba3f2","target":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:50f75a19b55e0395217ba3f2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"31b8a74e417f58373bcdcfab22319157968f3f045610d7ca4c2fedd651988c0a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b67ae9bc78938ff6531a5091"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ab31c979113b80aa3f10cabf458a728321f6f6edcfe214864404101a2ecea357","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:06fffc6496cfad14b8bfe647"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:16a93eb4b1db1b29cba350318f99e180e2a96ef34f3978fad40898793579fcdd","home":{"unitId":"unit:16a93eb4b1db1b29cba350318f99e180e2a96ef34f3978fad40898793579fcdd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:50f75a19b55e0395217ba3f2","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q11 explicitly combines stable extrema and controlled hierarchies in flux/Casimir compactifications, including BF-stability and alternative-branch questions.","qualification":"q11 includes flux/Casimir systems and the joint target of stable extrema and controlled hierarchies. Torus-shape changes, flux changes and smooth Riemann-flat quotients remain alternative routes within that construction problem. Neither uplift nor rolling is required, and geometric separation does not establish BF stability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:16a93eb4b1db1b29cba350318f99e180e2a96ef34f3978fad40898793579fcdd","paperId":"2610.27058","textSha256":"06757f5e40b880665be50b027333fc105806c7ffd030edb5a85e875df0732a9f"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0069:u12:q11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0069:u12:q11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:16a93eb4b1db1b29cba350318f99e180e2a96ef34f3978fad40898793579fcdd","q025-candidate-question:50f75a19b55e0395217ba3f2"],"scopeContentSha256":"31b8a74e417f58373bcdcfab22319157968f3f045610d7ca4c2fedd651988c0a","placementContentSha256":"96ab6aa9319e68fac1d322d1a2bcce9b8e1885da4870a5d98d0e3356dafe1692","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0069:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0069:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-05"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:16a93eb4b1db1b29cba350318f99e180e2a96ef34f3978fad40898793579fcdd","paperId":"2610.27058","textSha256":"06757f5e40b880665be50b027333fc105806c7ffd030edb5a85e875df0732a9f"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-05/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"6079f3dff4de3bce86aff04cfa91b1a0da7ebf86722c5c33e44b4f563ac45e8e"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-05/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"b73dfbc8974cebd1c5c02da428f1652a9b6f36d6a1073a93ae692399858c7d3e","bytes":1594204,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0069","unitRef":"u12"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:16a93eb4b1db1b29cba350318f99e180e2a96ef34f3978fad40898793579fcdd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d58","kind":"description","unitIndex":58,"unitId":"unit:16a93eb4b1db1b29cba350318f99e180e2a96ef34f3978fad40898793579fcdd","textSha256":"06757f5e40b880665be50b027333fc105806c7ffd030edb5a85e875df0732a9f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6060260053373b6de44a00d2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6060260053373b6de44a00d2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:16a93eb4b1db1b29cba350318f99e180e2a96ef34f3978fad40898793579fcdd","q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3"],"scopeContentSha256":"ab31c979113b80aa3f10cabf458a728321f6f6edcfe214864404101a2ecea357","contributionContentSha256":"a57f1212099ad4ad51ceefabbfba59acfd7bb09daff64cafb991a3651e661400","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-proposal","leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d58","kind":"description","unitIndex":58,"unitId":"unit:16a93eb4b1db1b29cba350318f99e180e2a96ef34f3978fad40898793579fcdd","textSha256":"06757f5e40b880665be50b027333fc105806c7ffd030edb5a85e875df0732a9f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6060260053373b6de44a00d2","recordId":"leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Construction and BF stability remain separate targets; torus changes and smooth Riemann-flat quotients are alternative routes.","challengeNote":"Compound construction/BF-stability target retained as source-scoped access; torus changes and smooth flat quotients are alternative routes.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"1bc55e2b2c29750d75fcd337bf8db96576f379104d7cd586d4b73c50e824e91d"},"organizational-access:5ac7e4b1eabd20b8e4cd96d4":{"id":"organizational-access:5ac7e4b1eabd20b8e4cd96d4","source":"q025-candidate-question:524e2f5f36cb09c5956aa59f","target":"q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:524e2f5f36cb09c5956aa59f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f420e09a4cc2e9d40175d7f540c29ed011087a20e085d4a3c2af3359e0b3884a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3dfe1a0e96e0507de03d160f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"415f34d29d669ea4ee617c917a714ffcd0c5ce9064597d47550ab71d206d3dc1","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:a073b2b3658a3c372508e781"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:ade68997314b20e6fa12b920c3f53cca37dadcc9b6d6b8eab510c7dba0aff90d","home":{"unitId":"unit:ade68997314b20e6fa12b920c3f53cca37dadcc9b6d6b8eab510c7dba0aff90d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:524e2f5f36cb09c5956aa59f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":0.34,"reason":"Covers the corrected Swiss-cheese nonsupersymmetric de Sitter construction without anti-D3 uplift.","qualification":"Explicit compound union: de Sitter construction at 524e2f5f weight 0.34, inflation at f138007c weight 0.33, inverse attractor at edbb1ba5 weight 0.33. Preserve exact source-span coverage and independent component targets.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ade68997314b20e6fa12b920c3f53cca37dadcc9b6d6b8eab510c7dba0aff90d","paperId":"0809.5149","textSha256":"26b3c9b4456fb895607f8206502d83a5164e0579c44da276ad44c2fd8bf43aee"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-03:placement-continuation-0031:u10:q12","coverageMode":"explicit_compound_union","targetCoverage":[{"sourceSpan":"Can corrected Swiss-cheese compactifications support a nonsupersymmetric de Sitter minimum without anti-D3 uplift","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:524e2f5f36cb09c5956aa59f"],"explanation":"The correction-dependent compactification mechanism, nonsupersymmetric minimum and exclusion of anti-D3 uplift are retained together."},{"sourceSpan":"and axionic slow-roll inflation?","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273"],"explanation":"Both supplied annotations identify axionic inflation as an additional target in the corrected Swiss-cheese setting; it is not inferred from the existence of a static minimum."},{"sourceSpan":"Separately, how can extremal black-hole charges and fake superpotentials be obtained from prescribed attractor moduli?","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:edbb1ba5fc83a80d04330ea4"],"explanation":"The explicitly separate black-hole inverse problem retains both charge and fake-superpotential reconstruction."}],"coverageReason":"The exact paired annotations identify inflation as an additional target, resolving the sentence's conjunction for placement purposes. q12, q26 and q24 collectively cover construction, axionic inflation and inverse attractors while retaining one immutable source. No supplied composite scope includes all three: q31 expressly excludes absorbing black-hole reconstruction, and q33 does not specify that target. Separate coordinator scrutiny remains required."},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-03:placement-continuation-0031:u10:q12","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ade68997314b20e6fa12b920c3f53cca37dadcc9b6d6b8eab510c7dba0aff90d","q025-candidate-question:524e2f5f36cb09c5956aa59f"],"scopeContentSha256":"f420e09a4cc2e9d40175d7f540c29ed011087a20e085d4a3c2af3359e0b3884a","placementContentSha256":"a840fa896d6027c412c63e9d2586abbe1f9b7ac3a71d6f5ee7ae3a480fc85b1e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-03:placement-continuation-0031:proposal","explicit-cut-03:placement-continuation-0031:challenge","root:explicit-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ade68997314b20e6fa12b920c3f53cca37dadcc9b6d6b8eab510c7dba0aff90d","paperId":"0809.5149","textSha256":"26b3c9b4456fb895607f8206502d83a5164e0579c44da276ad44c2fd8bf43aee"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-03/admission.json","sha256":"5b6b7da34396186993a8ef61e55aeed43d5e0f46a341da8375feb2433acaa490"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/exception-intake.json","sha256":"e2c8feedca7ab901585b3a3f046fa6900d1fb60eec30b2dd8f668d09a2d15a7b","bytes":7068293,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0031","unitRef":"u10"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ade68997314b20e6fa12b920c3f53cca37dadcc9b6d6b8eab510c7dba0aff90d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:ade68997314b20e6fa12b920c3f53cca37dadcc9b6d6b8eab510c7dba0aff90d","textSha256":"26b3c9b4456fb895607f8206502d83a5164e0579c44da276ad44c2fd8bf43aee"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1c8793c782b5dd9bd14463b4"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1c8793c782b5dd9bd14463b4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ade68997314b20e6fa12b920c3f53cca37dadcc9b6d6b8eab510c7dba0aff90d","q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273"],"scopeContentSha256":"415f34d29d669ea4ee617c917a714ffcd0c5ce9064597d47550ab71d206d3dc1","contributionContentSha256":"eab85f19b732d4da2d3315af47ca03ed3af265d4a77a0bdc444a03dc52014729","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-proposal","leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:ade68997314b20e6fa12b920c3f53cca37dadcc9b6d6b8eab510c7dba0aff90d","textSha256":"26b3c9b4456fb895607f8206502d83a5164e0579c44da276ad44c2fd8bf43aee"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1c8793c782b5dd9bd14463b4","recordId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: anti-D3-free de Sitter, axionic inflation and separate black-hole reconstruction targets.","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound identity: anti-D3-free de Sitter, axionic inflation and separate black-hole reconstruction.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"1588526e5e6859f016f3cfb6cb15610e509d3ff0b00d6ed875ee85b9d4e86407"},"organizational-access:f0e200af03fc0ced94d8a022":{"id":"organizational-access:f0e200af03fc0ced94d8a022","source":"q025-candidate-question:5c0e01464732c8f9e3d5f0bf","target":"q025-candidate-question:f844af3c3bf25030139c7e89","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:5c0e01464732c8f9e3d5f0bf","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"efdff36f9f04c60a7eefd327d94c1c9f97c830a8693bfdd4607c5ae018a39fe1","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:bcf7de4569ec8a7026a37a07"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f844af3c3bf25030139c7e89","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"d9f5f04d82420e43dc6f893602512deac724f7e993edef814480778f95fdf135","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:fcc36c19551042091979e911"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:cea4817cad9946f0ab4b02a298e6c23b7fde1842d0ccc2de74d286578a76be75","home":{"unitId":"unit:cea4817cad9946f0ab4b02a298e6c23b7fde1842d0ccc2de74d286578a76be75","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:5c0e01464732c8f9e3d5f0bf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q6 covers rolling dark energy as an alternative to stationary positive vacua, with source-specific endpoint assumptions and conditional duration restrictions.","qualification":"The complete target is compatibility of rolling dark energy with adopted endpoint and lifetime conditions. q6 covers this conditional dynamical application. The source does not separately derive a TCC bound or construct the endpoint states, so q12 and q9 are contextual comparisons rather than necessary additional homes.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cea4817cad9946f0ab4b02a298e6c23b7fde1842d0ccc2de74d286578a76be75","paperId":"2110.07300","textSha256":"4eea0fb6f84e99fb9a166b3a185c698b1df53433db84b16c481575b10280fbf9"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0058:u19:q6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0058:u19:q6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cea4817cad9946f0ab4b02a298e6c23b7fde1842d0ccc2de74d286578a76be75","q025-candidate-question:5c0e01464732c8f9e3d5f0bf"],"scopeContentSha256":"efdff36f9f04c60a7eefd327d94c1c9f97c830a8693bfdd4607c5ae018a39fe1","placementContentSha256":"9a61db846655ee5cdc3233c03dc51dcb6eef5cbc609788c2786fc84ac9b40206","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0058:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0058:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cea4817cad9946f0ab4b02a298e6c23b7fde1842d0ccc2de74d286578a76be75","paperId":"2110.07300","textSha256":"4eea0fb6f84e99fb9a166b3a185c698b1df53433db84b16c481575b10280fbf9"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0058","unitRef":"u19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cea4817cad9946f0ab4b02a298e6c23b7fde1842d0ccc2de74d286578a76be75","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f844af3c3bf25030139c7e89","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:cea4817cad9946f0ab4b02a298e6c23b7fde1842d0ccc2de74d286578a76be75","textSha256":"4eea0fb6f84e99fb9a166b3a185c698b1df53433db84b16c481575b10280fbf9"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6f7aa016739c2305e3e2d4de"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6f7aa016739c2305e3e2d4de","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cea4817cad9946f0ab4b02a298e6c23b7fde1842d0ccc2de74d286578a76be75","q025-candidate-question:f844af3c3bf25030139c7e89"],"scopeContentSha256":"d9f5f04d82420e43dc6f893602512deac724f7e993edef814480778f95fdf135","contributionContentSha256":"37298c44e6378453fa4ee1b1d87a3a9b545dda91c91a7d99479bc7c97edc7bb6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:cea4817cad9946f0ab4b02a298e6c23b7fde1842d0ccc2de74d286578a76be75","textSha256":"4eea0fb6f84e99fb9a166b3a185c698b1df53433db84b16c481575b10280fbf9"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6f7aa016739c2305e3e2d4de","recordId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Tests compatibility in an adopted no-stationary-de Sitter setting without constructing the underlying string states.","challengeNote":"Compatibility is tested in an adopted setting without construction of its underlying string states.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"3a39e6818ed37e6b4769746b48b78a5c3c5f603a8e4633038765688e8efa3bbb"},"organizational-access:f8657649c4f1217ddf9479de":{"id":"organizational-access:f8657649c4f1217ddf9479de","source":"q025-candidate-question:5c3a70858517139579f1e590","target":"q025-candidate-question:2bfbfa0a3ce49c01c495fa65","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:5c3a70858517139579f1e590","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"3fdc053455c56e7690eab3dd23968124951a77744267adb0f85de4b9112f48f7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2fd9e527d0a87f6d0a30a24d"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:2bfbfa0a3ce49c01c495fa65","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"898e7fc87f52003dfee82232c88622f9b279d711250d7eb0260fabd021053827","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7b99ea34bcdf3ca59524b546"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:9862914f0de48ca4eb8441e82be9768a77afba6900dff6c8c80c3758ac3a5f86","home":{"unitId":"unit:9862914f0de48ca4eb8441e82be9768a77afba6900dff6c8c80c3758ac3a5f86","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:5c3a70858517139579f1e590","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers unified-gauge defects, first-order transitions, source-specific inflation and joint gravitational-wave/particle tests of breaking histories.","qualification":"The overarching target is discrimination of symmetry-breaking histories. q9 combines unified-gauge defects, first-order transitions, source-specific inflation and joint wave/particle constraints, allowing proton decay to remain an explicit discriminator in the same question. Supersymmetric and non-supersymmetric routes are not identified.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9862914f0de48ca4eb8441e82be9768a77afba6900dff6c8c80c3758ac3a5f86","paperId":"2112.14483","textSha256":"5ba4dca557102ad9ca8142a05e1c42ce492e69e36237705d124ac6b43318c3b8"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0015:u10:q9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0015:u10:q9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9862914f0de48ca4eb8441e82be9768a77afba6900dff6c8c80c3758ac3a5f86","q025-candidate-question:5c3a70858517139579f1e590"],"scopeContentSha256":"3fdc053455c56e7690eab3dd23968124951a77744267adb0f85de4b9112f48f7","placementContentSha256":"65f14e7519e0a6cf82346a24b6227acba03775bbe1d6150644a946ddef4df966","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0015:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0015:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9862914f0de48ca4eb8441e82be9768a77afba6900dff6c8c80c3758ac3a5f86","paperId":"2112.14483","textSha256":"5ba4dca557102ad9ca8142a05e1c42ce492e69e36237705d124ac6b43318c3b8"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0015","unitRef":"u10"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9862914f0de48ca4eb8441e82be9768a77afba6900dff6c8c80c3758ac3a5f86","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2bfbfa0a3ce49c01c495fa65","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:9862914f0de48ca4eb8441e82be9768a77afba6900dff6c8c80c3758ac3a5f86","textSha256":"5ba4dca557102ad9ca8142a05e1c42ce492e69e36237705d124ac6b43318c3b8"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2a3d1b702a3b124641bfacf1","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Joint GW/proton-decay target; inflation assumptions and SUSY versus non-SUSY comparisons remain explicit. Independent challenge qualification: Joint GW/proton-decay target retains inflation assumptions and SUSY versus non-SUSY comparisons."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2a3d1b702a3b124641bfacf1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9862914f0de48ca4eb8441e82be9768a77afba6900dff6c8c80c3758ac3a5f86","q025-candidate-question:2bfbfa0a3ce49c01c495fa65"],"scopeContentSha256":"898e7fc87f52003dfee82232c88622f9b279d711250d7eb0260fabd021053827","contributionContentSha256":"0131e4874e546c94dccb700afa383d79c62564396feb7e6dd9473243f7b02f8d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-56a64c205c83cf5b2113-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-56a64c205c83cf5b2113-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-56a64c205c83cf5b2113-proposal","leaf-56a64c205c83cf5b2113-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:9862914f0de48ca4eb8441e82be9768a77afba6900dff6c8c80c3758ac3a5f86","textSha256":"5ba4dca557102ad9ca8142a05e1c42ce492e69e36237705d124ac6b43318c3b8"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2a3d1b702a3b124641bfacf1","recordId":"leaf-56a64c205c83cf5b2113-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-56a64c205c83cf5b2113-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-56a64c205c83cf5b2113-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Joint GW/proton-decay target; inflation assumptions and SUSY versus non-SUSY comparisons remain explicit.","challengeNote":"Joint GW/proton-decay target retains inflation assumptions and SUSY versus non-SUSY comparisons.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"55676f3986684a311a1b0cf10b2c17a7747c0a5438fd8562ce86c4ad55f3c93f"},"organizational-access:72e46a1557b4454dad45c2d8":{"id":"organizational-access:72e46a1557b4454dad45c2d8","source":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","target":"q025-candidate-question:08008eacbf96c86438c5c1e9","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"bc4d55c0b31819b24d800407c881468951f19c5ed35195b203feba0c0a2d6f23","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:49f7fe9cbc98de691227886e"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:08008eacbf96c86438c5c1e9","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"d6a5e2949116a798d759847ffe3dcdf75520e9a4128af40211f2631afd72709e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:50a2ca13cf62d0f7ca5ea688"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:c0b479b56d09cc435e7d91beb8841b897ce3ea8df951c6c471bcf6e2efcdeaaf","home":{"unitId":"unit:c0b479b56d09cc435e7d91beb8841b897ce3ea8df951c6c471bcf6e2efcdeaaf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"This source addresses a question within this scoped destination. Its specific system, regime and source-reading limits remain attached; membership does not equate the source statement with the broader question.","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:c0b479b56d09cc435e7d91beb8841b897ce3ea8df951c6c471bcf6e2efcdeaaf","textSha256":"226d84478bffc1e224c861a04e44610c4fba62d3f2c8a643c7c7b764f58e6038"}],"decisionId":"decision:organizational-home:7af56cb163ef90a26fe6a74b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:organizational-home:7af56cb163ef90a26fe6a74b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c0b479b56d09cc435e7d91beb8841b897ce3ea8df951c6c471bcf6e2efcdeaaf","q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7"],"scopeContentSha256":"bc4d55c0b31819b24d800407c881468951f19c5ed35195b203feba0c0a2d6f23","placementContentSha256":"f7496db0eab0787b8a98c8e77fee3d1440504a6950b35efa30b196293e3b564c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../../evaluation/full-pass/home-admissions-v1/home-policy-admission.json","sha256":"275fd7dc27c397141cee2737c967e070cf75df3c6446f8d5c2e2a3e7cc79d740"}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:c0b479b56d09cc435e7d91beb8841b897ce3ea8df951c6c471bcf6e2efcdeaaf","textSha256":"226d84478bffc1e224c861a04e44610c4fba62d3f2c8a643c7c7b764f58e6038"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"decisionId":"decision:organizational-home:7af56cb163ef90a26fe6a74b","sourceContributionDecisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f333eb68ccec40bb639e2717","sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"],"reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"},"sourceDescriptionSha256":"226d84478bffc1e224c861a04e44610c4fba62d3f2c8a643c7c7b764f58e6038","sourceScopeContentSha256":"bc4d55c0b31819b24d800407c881468951f19c5ed35195b203feba0c0a2d6f23","originalNotesSha256":{"proposal":"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855","challenge":"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855"},"evidenceAgreementIsNotOriginalPlacementAgreement":true}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c0b479b56d09cc435e7d91beb8841b897ce3ea8df951c6c471bcf6e2efcdeaaf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:08008eacbf96c86438c5c1e9","role":"instantiates","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d80","kind":"description","unitIndex":80,"unitId":"unit:c0b479b56d09cc435e7d91beb8841b897ce3ea8df951c6c471bcf6e2efcdeaaf","textSha256":"226d84478bffc1e224c861a04e44610c4fba62d3f2c8a643c7c7b764f58e6038"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:02f9eadec439542f8a8a840fb1a78de9","paperId":"2202.02690","sourceSha256":"69f2fe81ad39348e758fe35052b219f1aae62afd61b3eda4a2faf355b334c12e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/96d5d089ab3bac8c5a46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cd7c49472f4a96244a38fc96fbdac972d3910910c6e9902be4a58830258a38ee","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2132,"textSha256":"b9b0e585dc00510e73f70545940bb6a8eea9863c2d5b0611b42f03b834532cc9","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:beaa8c94deee676dd8ebfc78fd735285","paperId":"2202.02690","sourceSha256":"69f2fe81ad39348e758fe35052b219f1aae62afd61b3eda4a2faf355b334c12e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/96d5d089ab3bac8c5a46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cd7c49472f4a96244a38fc96fbdac972d3910910c6e9902be4a58830258a38ee","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":1844,"textSha256":"188503c94878a32453cf18e3723e643af36971e2b50073f25f8df7c834114bfb","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a7f898cb37db4e070d8823a285a42fe8","paperId":"2202.02690","sourceSha256":"69f2fe81ad39348e758fe35052b219f1aae62afd61b3eda4a2faf355b334c12e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/96d5d089ab3bac8c5a46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cd7c49472f4a96244a38fc96fbdac972d3910910c6e9902be4a58830258a38ee","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2343,"textSha256":"ddf2acb9fe7caaa039862af53bee7c380397dc72717ec783b6841a80677a613b","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:47ecac62d55a14436339a9c5"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:47ecac62d55a14436339a9c5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c0b479b56d09cc435e7d91beb8841b897ce3ea8df951c6c471bcf6e2efcdeaaf","q025-candidate-question:08008eacbf96c86438c5c1e9"],"scopeContentSha256":"d6a5e2949116a798d759847ffe3dcdf75520e9a4128af40211f2631afd72709e","contributionContentSha256":"0c2eed42c9476e3784e9796ee1d87a40c62c9c30db63f4a14b64d955f2d10dd5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-proposal","leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d80","kind":"description","unitIndex":80,"unitId":"unit:c0b479b56d09cc435e7d91beb8841b897ce3ea8df951c6c471bcf6e2efcdeaaf","textSha256":"226d84478bffc1e224c861a04e44610c4fba62d3f2c8a643c7c7b764f58e6038"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:02f9eadec439542f8a8a840fb1a78de9","paperId":"2202.02690","sourceSha256":"69f2fe81ad39348e758fe35052b219f1aae62afd61b3eda4a2faf355b334c12e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/96d5d089ab3bac8c5a46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cd7c49472f4a96244a38fc96fbdac972d3910910c6e9902be4a58830258a38ee","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2132,"textSha256":"b9b0e585dc00510e73f70545940bb6a8eea9863c2d5b0611b42f03b834532cc9","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:beaa8c94deee676dd8ebfc78fd735285","paperId":"2202.02690","sourceSha256":"69f2fe81ad39348e758fe35052b219f1aae62afd61b3eda4a2faf355b334c12e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/96d5d089ab3bac8c5a46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cd7c49472f4a96244a38fc96fbdac972d3910910c6e9902be4a58830258a38ee","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":1844,"textSha256":"188503c94878a32453cf18e3723e643af36971e2b50073f25f8df7c834114bfb","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a7f898cb37db4e070d8823a285a42fe8","paperId":"2202.02690","sourceSha256":"69f2fe81ad39348e758fe35052b219f1aae62afd61b3eda4a2faf355b334c12e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/96d5d089ab3bac8c5a46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cd7c49472f4a96244a38fc96fbdac972d3910910c6e9902be4a58830258a38ee","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2343,"textSha256":"ddf2acb9fe7caaa039862af53bee7c380397dc72717ec783b6841a80677a613b","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:47ecac62d55a14436339a9c5","recordId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Four-dimensional scalar–tensor inflationary tests; the disjunctive and combined criteria remain distinct, and extracted derivative notation is defective.","challengeNote":"Four-dimensional scalar–tensor applications use a canonical Einstein-frame scalar. Disjunctive and combined conjectures remain distinct; defective extract","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"45b94f77dcd9213eca19b99691649a9db1796e433aa9e532233073622df0237f"},"organizational-access:348b87abc73b50f186eb11bc":{"id":"organizational-access:348b87abc73b50f186eb11bc","source":"q025-candidate-question:6713a07b5b30dacb0268a4bf","target":"q025-candidate-question:891a8b29f5b4c34d1fea8065","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6713a07b5b30dacb0268a4bf","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a6915af7571edbdff254263025ab5c962d0d3a5a1febee2c303270069e42dbe1","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7504f4aaebb1e8b7963e9477"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:891a8b29f5b4c34d1fea8065","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1338a4e95740a79b34858bbda68c9c1adabe8ef60833f2f95e343ebbe57aa1f6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d8d64ed137b9ea81530d91fd"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:76c75b529785dd190a9fa84dd61cfcd837c540944ab4ac793562a36a69aa5285","home":{"unitId":"unit:76c75b529785dd190a9fa84dd61cfcd837c540944ab4ac793562a36a69aa5285","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6713a07b5b30dacb0268a4bf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers the four string-inflation potentials, weak and strong dissipative dynamics, observational viability, excursion reduction and perturbative compactification control as prerequisites of the inflationary scenarios.","qualification":"Preserve four potentials and both dissipation regimes without inventing a distance-conjecture test. Exact full challenge coverage and source-local qualifications remain binding. Weights are organizational allocation, not confidence or physical importance.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:76c75b529785dd190a9fa84dd61cfcd837c540944ab4ac793562a36a69aa5285","paperId":"2505.04447","textSha256":"979967f8d9b12045ababa312318e8741e2447fb1529a7ddb25be49fedb863e43"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0061:u29:q5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0061:u29:q5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:76c75b529785dd190a9fa84dd61cfcd837c540944ab4ac793562a36a69aa5285","q025-candidate-question:6713a07b5b30dacb0268a4bf"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6915af7571edbdff254263025ab5c962d0d3a5a1febee2c303270069e42dbe1","placementContentSha256":"b7c13dd779d8d803f49d6bcac3fd0a6fae8329099b25af3eb54066da46ca16e2","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0061:proposal","explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0061:challenge","root:explicit-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:76c75b529785dd190a9fa84dd61cfcd837c540944ab4ac793562a36a69aa5285","paperId":"2505.04447","textSha256":"979967f8d9b12045ababa312318e8741e2447fb1529a7ddb25be49fedb863e43"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"45cd7c1d060cb6f2fd1d8a4ace5cca7c3d64df235a869afc4ce7e31b2e6badfb"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0061","unitRef":"u29"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:76c75b529785dd190a9fa84dd61cfcd837c540944ab4ac793562a36a69aa5285","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:891a8b29f5b4c34d1fea8065","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d50","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:76c75b529785dd190a9fa84dd61cfcd837c540944ab4ac793562a36a69aa5285","textSha256":"979967f8d9b12045ababa312318e8741e2447fb1529a7ddb25be49fedb863e43"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6235289c3d72787f8e1238da"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6235289c3d72787f8e1238da","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:76c75b529785dd190a9fa84dd61cfcd837c540944ab4ac793562a36a69aa5285","q025-candidate-question:891a8b29f5b4c34d1fea8065"],"scopeContentSha256":"1338a4e95740a79b34858bbda68c9c1adabe8ef60833f2f95e343ebbe57aa1f6","contributionContentSha256":"e342017ec8925a91ff60e71505315210d58dba6968e43ec8b3d17e5f39c2de70","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-proposal","leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d50","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:76c75b529785dd190a9fa84dd61cfcd837c540944ab4ac793562a36a69aa5285","textSha256":"979967f8d9b12045ababa312318e8741e2447fb1529a7ddb25be49fedb863e43"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6235289c3d72787f8e1238da","recordId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Field-excursion reduction and perturbative type-IIB control are additional targets; no specific Swampland criterion is supplied.","challengeNote":"Adds explicit excursion and compactification-control targets. This compound scope does not supply a distance-conjecture premise.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"81681e8e752eeb1a79f62ec712a04e316433a38c1b0c38f4573dfe55ecfcaa82"},"organizational-access:9d9c63d04f3c9049796980d7":{"id":"organizational-access:9d9c63d04f3c9049796980d7","source":"q025-candidate-question:6893d4df02d24c96883d8b2d","target":"q025-candidate-question:1ba62c251207fe202acb1b7e","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6893d4df02d24c96883d8b2d","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"082c00c0fc6a31c82e4b486b6ed1ebd37becda928d30abb1b384f270ce6569cc","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:38f76d5b65c13dadeb8ad395"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1ba62c251207fe202acb1b7e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"5012deb20f8f6a72b8c7f7abb2c58690dcba380d4156c74f62fd7bc0fd27cdc6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8331ea6109615c41827ae543"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:e0a21e5da0ab376151e95c73030a9044eb857070c64cac284d44b47c97c570e9","home":{"unitId":"unit:e0a21e5da0ab376151e95c73030a9044eb857070c64cac284d44b47c97c570e9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6893d4df02d24c96883d8b2d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers construction of the gravitational effective average action and exact flow, plus Einstein–Hilbert running in both 2+ε and four dimensions.","qualification":"q10 explicitly covers the exact functional construction and both Einstein–Hilbert dimensional regimes. Exactness of the equation does not establish exactness or convergence of its truncation; covariance and Ward-identity qualifications remain local.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e0a21e5da0ab376151e95c73030a9044eb857070c64cac284d44b47c97c570e9","paperId":"hep-th/9605030","textSha256":"53cd0d8b36991ad6f9e68c0248d40b2a3b9b02754cc99a4acbb15abde0d2e95f"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0053:u8:q10"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0053:u8:q10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e0a21e5da0ab376151e95c73030a9044eb857070c64cac284d44b47c97c570e9","q025-candidate-question:6893d4df02d24c96883d8b2d"],"scopeContentSha256":"082c00c0fc6a31c82e4b486b6ed1ebd37becda928d30abb1b384f270ce6569cc","placementContentSha256":"55b809a4db5a4d6c63e6c51b39a5f1214e54384147f56694cffa877bbdcae6b7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0053:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0053:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e0a21e5da0ab376151e95c73030a9044eb857070c64cac284d44b47c97c570e9","paperId":"hep-th/9605030","textSha256":"53cd0d8b36991ad6f9e68c0248d40b2a3b9b02754cc99a4acbb15abde0d2e95f"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0053","unitRef":"u8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e0a21e5da0ab376151e95c73030a9044eb857070c64cac284d44b47c97c570e9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1ba62c251207fe202acb1b7e","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:e0a21e5da0ab376151e95c73030a9044eb857070c64cac284d44b47c97c570e9","textSha256":"53cd0d8b36991ad6f9e68c0248d40b2a3b9b02754cc99a4acbb15abde0d2e95f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:720d07781f8f11412905ff90","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound exact-flow construction and Einstein–Hilbert truncation predictions in 2+ε and four dimensions. Independent challenge qualification: Compound exact-flow construction and Einstein–Hilbert truncation predictions in 2+ε and four dimensions."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:720d07781f8f11412905ff90","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e0a21e5da0ab376151e95c73030a9044eb857070c64cac284d44b47c97c570e9","q025-candidate-question:1ba62c251207fe202acb1b7e"],"scopeContentSha256":"5012deb20f8f6a72b8c7f7abb2c58690dcba380d4156c74f62fd7bc0fd27cdc6","contributionContentSha256":"ae4dfdbb52c76414f3cb40dda3a5acc1d61d0ac8c16d78c48273e6aae84bcae4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-proposal","successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:e0a21e5da0ab376151e95c73030a9044eb857070c64cac284d44b47c97c570e9","textSha256":"53cd0d8b36991ad6f9e68c0248d40b2a3b9b02754cc99a4acbb15abde0d2e95f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:720d07781f8f11412905ff90","recordId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound exact-flow construction and Einstein–Hilbert truncation predictions in 2+ε and four dimensions.","challengeNote":"Compound exact-flow construction and Einstein–Hilbert truncation predictions in 2+ε and four dimensions.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"11eeea72ee81efbcf1894c87426b7f26784054dabcd600892512378a8117180d"},"organizational-access:e78c23935fc952b26a3b3b52":{"id":"organizational-access:e78c23935fc952b26a3b3b52","source":"q025-candidate-question:6893d4df02d24c96883d8b2d","target":"q025-candidate-question:bb4e0b85bd0e1f5e06a2d521","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6893d4df02d24c96883d8b2d","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"082c00c0fc6a31c82e4b486b6ed1ebd37becda928d30abb1b384f270ce6569cc","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:38f76d5b65c13dadeb8ad395"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:bb4e0b85bd0e1f5e06a2d521","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e6c2846708b1c29660e3795f6f2d7dbedd0a3a6e5e370b5e89959c46f0bf9940","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7b767cec0c7d01a0fade0ef6"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:d431cff8fc30f4ee5fed5aa9d262744f4d884c564b315c85fc23bcd905576391","home":{"unitId":"unit:d431cff8fc30f4ee5fed5aa9d262744f4d884c564b315c85fc23bcd905576391","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6893d4df02d24c96883d8b2d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines the complete four-derivative essential approximation, shift-symmetric scalar gravity, UV-to-IR trajectories and scalar-interaction bounds.","qualification":"q7 explicitly covers the stated approximation and both UV-to-IR existence and scalar-bound targets. Completeness through four derivatives does not establish completeness of the theory, and essential and conventional coupling bases remain distinct.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d431cff8fc30f4ee5fed5aa9d262744f4d884c564b315c85fc23bcd905576391","paperId":"2204.08564","textSha256":"83534000b3d31628e759b2408ddd0ea2fa63f7757f6c7f86f20d591d73eb925d"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0052:u8:q7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0052:u8:q7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d431cff8fc30f4ee5fed5aa9d262744f4d884c564b315c85fc23bcd905576391","q025-candidate-question:6893d4df02d24c96883d8b2d"],"scopeContentSha256":"082c00c0fc6a31c82e4b486b6ed1ebd37becda928d30abb1b384f270ce6569cc","placementContentSha256":"06fb6186489c10050eaa5e92558d55a0d482a55adcbf8cc59408ec1ca67e4c9e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0052:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0052:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d431cff8fc30f4ee5fed5aa9d262744f4d884c564b315c85fc23bcd905576391","paperId":"2204.08564","textSha256":"83534000b3d31628e759b2408ddd0ea2fa63f7757f6c7f86f20d591d73eb925d"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0052","unitRef":"u8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d431cff8fc30f4ee5fed5aa9d262744f4d884c564b315c85fc23bcd905576391","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:bb4e0b85bd0e1f5e06a2d521","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:d431cff8fc30f4ee5fed5aa9d262744f4d884c564b315c85fc23bcd905576391","textSha256":"83534000b3d31628e759b2408ddd0ea2fa63f7757f6c7f86f20d591d73eb925d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0a50b52179872f7835b2464a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0a50b52179872f7835b2464a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d431cff8fc30f4ee5fed5aa9d262744f4d884c564b315c85fc23bcd905576391","q025-candidate-question:bb4e0b85bd0e1f5e06a2d521"],"scopeContentSha256":"e6c2846708b1c29660e3795f6f2d7dbedd0a3a6e5e370b5e89959c46f0bf9940","contributionContentSha256":"eb4548699bbc6746eab07d4124c49c59f0240180cc762f4fed30bc5f38d1df7c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-proposal","leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:d431cff8fc30f4ee5fed5aa9d262744f4d884c564b315c85fc23bcd905576391","textSha256":"83534000b3d31628e759b2408ddd0ea2fa63f7757f6c7f86f20d591d73eb925d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0a50b52179872f7835b2464a","recordId":"leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Essential couplings and completeness at four-derivative order distinguish this from other scalar truncations.","challengeNote":"Essential couplings and completeness at four-derivative order define this approximation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"65e0debe94474cace84b85903b49a68dca68eb9a9f512cd4f20ae8a1b2a015af"},"organizational-access:fd8345cb5301451c62543278":{"id":"organizational-access:fd8345cb5301451c62543278","source":"q025-candidate-question:6ac02a667323a234d6246b3f","target":"q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6ac02a667323a234d6246b3f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"78bf7f471c1adaf6c27bee6e9d9d8119f1ee41f17bd8a6b454a6a0b29d7a4d31","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5d247ad98bdc316b1e17b54a"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6222773dbbd2d1d21ae40e96680b69b7a1a683aa0e99245dc7ce3a37bf1dc278","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f664c84546bd5a79082b408f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:44f896289f988ae22f8cbdf9c2786133fe80640387051fbf190a4702037ff272","home":{"unitId":"unit:44f896289f988ae22f8cbdf9c2786133fe80640387051fbf190a4702037ff272","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6ac02a667323a234d6246b3f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers potential-free nonquadratic kinetic inflation, its perturbative viability and graceful radiation exit in the stated Einstein-frame expansion convention.","qualification":"q7 explicitly covers potential-free kinetic inflation, perturbative viability and graceful exit while preserving Einstein-frame expansion. The decreasing-curvature regime remains an expanding history. Deferred detailed spectra and reheating qualify the source's achievement, not coverage of its stated targets.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:44f896289f988ae22f8cbdf9c2786133fe80640387051fbf190a4702037ff272","paperId":"hep-th/9904075","textSha256":"e2b6b37b4dcada60b412317bb4763f5083c338986115287e96468ebaf157225b"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0024:u12:q7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0024:u12:q7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:44f896289f988ae22f8cbdf9c2786133fe80640387051fbf190a4702037ff272","q025-candidate-question:6ac02a667323a234d6246b3f"],"scopeContentSha256":"78bf7f471c1adaf6c27bee6e9d9d8119f1ee41f17bd8a6b454a6a0b29d7a4d31","placementContentSha256":"227e6cb2be2fcd246ce3af2842409cb042a9f08832e897fd19d287ddab5584a7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0024:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0024:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:44f896289f988ae22f8cbdf9c2786133fe80640387051fbf190a4702037ff272","paperId":"hep-th/9904075","textSha256":"e2b6b37b4dcada60b412317bb4763f5083c338986115287e96468ebaf157225b"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0024","unitRef":"u12"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:44f896289f988ae22f8cbdf9c2786133fe80640387051fbf190a4702037ff272","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","qualification":"Confirm the reused overview covers potential-free nonquadratic kinetic inflation in the Einstein frame. Decreasing curvature, acceptable perturbations and transition to radiation are linked source questions, not independently certified outcomes or potential-slope tests. Independent confirmation: Potential-free nonquadratic Einstein-frame kinetics is a concrete instance of c3's kinetic modifications. The contribution correctly preserves decreasing curvature, perturbations and radiation exit as linked questions rather than certified outcomes.","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u22","kind":"description","unitIndex":82,"unitId":"unit:44f896289f988ae22f8cbdf9c2786133fe80640387051fbf190a4702037ff272","textSha256":"e2b6b37b4dcada60b412317bb4763f5083c338986115287e96468ebaf157225b","paperId":"hep-th/9904075"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:role:2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:navigation-inflation:role:2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:44f896289f988ae22f8cbdf9c2786133fe80640387051fbf190a4702037ff272","q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae"],"challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"inflation-scope-navigation-proposal","challengeReviewId":"inflation-retained-whole-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["inflation-scope-navigation-proposal","inflation-retained-whole-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u22","kind":"description","unitIndex":82,"unitId":"unit:44f896289f988ae22f8cbdf9c2786133fe80640387051fbf190a4702037ff272","textSha256":"e2b6b37b4dcada60b412317bb4763f5083c338986115287e96468ebaf157225b","paperId":"hep-th/9904075"}],"originalRole":{"unitRef":"u22","questionRef":"c3","role":"specializes","reason":"Confirm the reused overview covers potential-free nonquadratic kinetic inflation in the Einstein frame. Decreasing curvature, acceptable perturbations and transition to radiation are linked source questions, not independently certified outcomes or potential-slope tests.","refs":["u22","c2","c3","n57"]},"independentAssessment":{"index":2,"verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Potential-free nonquadratic Einstein-frame kinetics is a concrete instance of c3's kinetic modifications. The contribution correctly preserves decreasing curvature, perturbations and radiation exit as linked questions rather than certified outcomes.","refs":["u22","c2","c3","n57"]},"scopeContentSha256":"6222773dbbd2d1d21ae40e96680b69b7a1a683aa0e99245dc7ce3a37bf1dc278","contributionContentSha256":"50c4505454a63e23e69fb5a515cc3abe5973ea6aedb42617bd0e2b1b488b96ae","coordinatorAdmissionReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/navigation-admissions-v1/inflation-admission.json","sha256":"c58c7f7a6a49c669b2adf1ceecbd28492470ce67da115918763442bc7b8465c8"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ea8645028aeb4a4da36eb11c89ef7cb2d6450270661805703c4c679ac39afc71"},"organizational-access:28bdb23f93cb88b7cd73d96a":{"id":"organizational-access:28bdb23f93cb88b7cd73d96a","source":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","target":"q025-candidate-question:a68ea5fe057952294008ca70","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"268939a83d4929df66b954dacdd9bfeebd08b3331a1d4d7a3dd2f54778f8da73","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6d28e66d9dabc88b794c03d7"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a68ea5fe057952294008ca70","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7c1a05f26669fd12dda2e1f78d0c77a0c6d343b789c25cc9305b6772bd4fab7b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d8acfa2c24db29db9f2ce041"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","home":{"unitId":"unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers steep-potential acceleration, near-constant dark-energy equations of state, multifield turning and perturbation signatures.","qualification":"q14 explicitly covers the background behavior, turning mechanism and perturbation discrimination together. Trajectory turning is not identified with field-space curvature, and the flat-field-space illustration retains its angular-potential qualification. Observational prospects remain qualitative.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","paperId":"2008.13660","textSha256":"410cbe69e10e8931e4f852f0f34dd0ac3831bc8f593c5a18121d017595ba25ea"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0071:u22:q14"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0071:u22:q14","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83"],"scopeContentSha256":"268939a83d4929df66b954dacdd9bfeebd08b3331a1d4d7a3dd2f54778f8da73","placementContentSha256":"127db8d113427a6f5e806b69890114b023a2696cd2f9ee93dc96614572f19a0c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0071:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0071:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","paperId":"2008.13660","textSha256":"410cbe69e10e8931e4f852f0f34dd0ac3831bc8f593c5a18121d017595ba25ea"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0071","unitRef":"u22"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a68ea5fe057952294008ca70","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","textSha256":"410cbe69e10e8931e4f852f0f34dd0ac3831bc8f593c5a18121d017595ba25ea"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3f0a5fee84017cc911de4dbdcd193646","paperId":"2008.13660","sourceSha256":"a10662c081e8c32cbe747ca9184173d5c44becd0a3d35ecc858a6e00a89d1b15","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2871bf85926e2dacf51d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"047f2f8e53ae6a1e9e10fe1e40a49ee27edd838b2bb2dfe480a3aad6da3f7d5a","pdfPage":1,"start":2,"end":3002,"textSha256":"9c144126c1d519fdefb3e43c9bbb5958b5fb46b65c155dd5973d5ab045addb5d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:26101c9f53411f2ac3471b1058d33850","paperId":"2008.13660","sourceSha256":"a10662c081e8c32cbe747ca9184173d5c44becd0a3d35ecc858a6e00a89d1b15","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2871bf85926e2dacf51d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"047f2f8e53ae6a1e9e10fe1e40a49ee27edd838b2bb2dfe480a3aad6da3f7d5a","pdfPage":3,"start":2264,"end":4593,"textSha256":"6ed2d31a71442ffa1a97f80682814f1c652045ebe7bad00b3049e9cb6c016517","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5486afdb3ecf0c367bb272981866ba2a","paperId":"2008.13660","sourceSha256":"a10662c081e8c32cbe747ca9184173d5c44becd0a3d35ecc858a6e00a89d1b15","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2871bf85926e2dacf51d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"047f2f8e53ae6a1e9e10fe1e40a49ee27edd838b2bb2dfe480a3aad6da3f7d5a","pdfPage":6,"start":1808,"end":4808,"textSha256":"fcf17b6a12d2759ce1b137210ce743c968cb7ff93cdad4987606123e46135838","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c46e3208a7e735415173baa2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c46e3208a7e735415173baa2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","q025-candidate-question:a68ea5fe057952294008ca70"],"scopeContentSha256":"7c1a05f26669fd12dda2e1f78d0c77a0c6d343b789c25cc9305b6772bd4fab7b","contributionContentSha256":"1047227615aab9cd901ce381ac360402561819ca44eeb87883ecccaaac6d2e67","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-951cd9c26d20519fe596-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-951cd9c26d20519fe596-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-951cd9c26d20519fe596-proposal","leaf-951cd9c26d20519fe596-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","textSha256":"410cbe69e10e8931e4f852f0f34dd0ac3831bc8f593c5a18121d017595ba25ea"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3f0a5fee84017cc911de4dbdcd193646","paperId":"2008.13660","sourceSha256":"a10662c081e8c32cbe747ca9184173d5c44becd0a3d35ecc858a6e00a89d1b15","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2871bf85926e2dacf51d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"047f2f8e53ae6a1e9e10fe1e40a49ee27edd838b2bb2dfe480a3aad6da3f7d5a","pdfPage":1,"start":2,"end":3002,"textSha256":"9c144126c1d519fdefb3e43c9bbb5958b5fb46b65c155dd5973d5ab045addb5d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:26101c9f53411f2ac3471b1058d33850","paperId":"2008.13660","sourceSha256":"a10662c081e8c32cbe747ca9184173d5c44becd0a3d35ecc858a6e00a89d1b15","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2871bf85926e2dacf51d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"047f2f8e53ae6a1e9e10fe1e40a49ee27edd838b2bb2dfe480a3aad6da3f7d5a","pdfPage":3,"start":2264,"end":4593,"textSha256":"6ed2d31a71442ffa1a97f80682814f1c652045ebe7bad00b3049e9cb6c016517","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5486afdb3ecf0c367bb272981866ba2a","paperId":"2008.13660","sourceSha256":"a10662c081e8c32cbe747ca9184173d5c44becd0a3d35ecc858a6e00a89d1b15","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2871bf85926e2dacf51d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"047f2f8e53ae6a1e9e10fe1e40a49ee27edd838b2bb2dfe480a3aad6da3f7d5a","pdfPage":6,"start":1808,"end":4808,"textSha256":"fcf17b6a12d2759ce1b137210ce743c968cb7ff93cdad4987606123e46135838","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c46e3208a7e735415173baa2","recordId":"leaf-951cd9c26d20519fe596-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-951cd9c26d20519fe596-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-951cd9c26d20519fe596-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Background and perturbation targets remain separable within this source-scoped singleton; observability is qualitative.","challengeNote":"Background and perturbation targets remain a compound source-scoped singleton pending reconciliation; detectability is qualitative.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"c89573c67f4ca13592df270003bda5ad83851d9b3eeb261ffb9ca36d5c57bccd"},"organizational-access:a69f12e034ae4a8413af1d6f":{"id":"organizational-access:a69f12e034ae4a8413af1d6f","source":"q025-candidate-question:7cfc3c80ec3e9595600a1c24","target":"q025-candidate-question:3e171750fc85d66e6b4588fb","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:7cfc3c80ec3e9595600a1c24","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"556d351b8d1b321c856b5c4de0f45a1c5d5efe57509ea3880d8a33d48a9b246c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:149d0293a819474f0d343acb"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3e171750fc85d66e6b4588fb","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"8ced300734fede3e14d606b0aabe1d0caad38a6950975b40c6db5669cb54bf8b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:104b31b8d86f90b117197e6c"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:a665ba573c42dc51e4ff821fb93ab0fddc344f8f3e520ab3408b74cf61613d60","home":{"unitId":"unit:a665ba573c42dc51e4ff821fb93ab0fddc344f8f3e520ab3408b74cf61613d60","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7cfc3c80ec3e9595600a1c24","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Combines KKLT/LVS stabilization effects, visible-sector soft terms and D3-brane stability in anti-D3 uplift settings.","qualification":"q10 covers effects on KKLT/LVS vacua, visible-sector soft terms and D3 stability together. The nilpotent description is the stated EFT treatment. q5 covers the phenomenological targets but does not clearly include the independent vacuum-response target; q8's matching contribution does not repair that whole-home gap.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a665ba573c42dc51e4ff821fb93ab0fddc344f8f3e520ab3408b74cf61613d60","paperId":"1511.08105","textSha256":"9483d98729aa16cc1255ddc89429bf5dbad58661572a4d89c2df632494846422"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0029:u24:q10"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0029:u24:q10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a665ba573c42dc51e4ff821fb93ab0fddc344f8f3e520ab3408b74cf61613d60","q025-candidate-question:7cfc3c80ec3e9595600a1c24"],"scopeContentSha256":"556d351b8d1b321c856b5c4de0f45a1c5d5efe57509ea3880d8a33d48a9b246c","placementContentSha256":"a52501f728b2f6affb59cf9446d7677ce5a7b5f8e3e80db6344ddff45775e710","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0029:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0029:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a665ba573c42dc51e4ff821fb93ab0fddc344f8f3e520ab3408b74cf61613d60","paperId":"1511.08105","textSha256":"9483d98729aa16cc1255ddc89429bf5dbad58661572a4d89c2df632494846422"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0029","unitRef":"u24"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a665ba573c42dc51e4ff821fb93ab0fddc344f8f3e520ab3408b74cf61613d60","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3e171750fc85d66e6b4588fb","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:a665ba573c42dc51e4ff821fb93ab0fddc344f8f3e520ab3408b74cf61613d60","textSha256":"9483d98729aa16cc1255ddc89429bf5dbad58661572a4d89c2df632494846422"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:20e746c3fc5a67973ac9e11412546df7","paperId":"1511.08105","sourceSha256":"6b297d01c04e429c349f0e8c78aacecb19549dae92c3d84d1b6bdb523d3ffeb9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b11227f7924cf0c3648c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1822718c869bbbe2cc16fa0e298ed4420a02b37c2ae24b987cbfb5686058e9d0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1730,"textSha256":"08b14f3a13671418102995dc65d454ad5b1fbe458d5174f050a67992d09ce3ee","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fbce1572cf958b87148dd4a50fd22fc3","paperId":"1511.08105","sourceSha256":"6b297d01c04e429c349f0e8c78aacecb19549dae92c3d84d1b6bdb523d3ffeb9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b11227f7924cf0c3648c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1822718c869bbbe2cc16fa0e298ed4420a02b37c2ae24b987cbfb5686058e9d0","pdfPage":1,"start":96,"end":1730,"textSha256":"ad4735b1ceddc49902f0897bf30818f92a93324a76e4c374faa2bc902c767c1c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3e3f1841d63a44ffd5c7a278"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3e3f1841d63a44ffd5c7a278","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a665ba573c42dc51e4ff821fb93ab0fddc344f8f3e520ab3408b74cf61613d60","q025-candidate-question:3e171750fc85d66e6b4588fb"],"scopeContentSha256":"8ced300734fede3e14d606b0aabe1d0caad38a6950975b40c6db5669cb54bf8b","contributionContentSha256":"7296fea91db851f92556009799acbcbae5a357ff3e6f19d428b1ec0243fc8e6b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:a665ba573c42dc51e4ff821fb93ab0fddc344f8f3e520ab3408b74cf61613d60","textSha256":"9483d98729aa16cc1255ddc89429bf5dbad58661572a4d89c2df632494846422"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:20e746c3fc5a67973ac9e11412546df7","paperId":"1511.08105","sourceSha256":"6b297d01c04e429c349f0e8c78aacecb19549dae92c3d84d1b6bdb523d3ffeb9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b11227f7924cf0c3648c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1822718c869bbbe2cc16fa0e298ed4420a02b37c2ae24b987cbfb5686058e9d0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1730,"textSha256":"08b14f3a13671418102995dc65d454ad5b1fbe458d5174f050a67992d09ce3ee","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fbce1572cf958b87148dd4a50fd22fc3","paperId":"1511.08105","sourceSha256":"6b297d01c04e429c349f0e8c78aacecb19549dae92c3d84d1b6bdb523d3ffeb9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b11227f7924cf0c3648c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1822718c869bbbe2cc16fa0e298ed4420a02b37c2ae24b987cbfb5686058e9d0","pdfPage":1,"start":96,"end":1730,"textSha256":"ad4735b1ceddc49902f0897bf30818f92a93324a76e4c374faa2bc902c767c1c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3e3f1841d63a44ffd5c7a278","recordId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound: EFT vacua, soft terms and visible D3 stability; nilpotent uplift matching is a method contribution.","challengeNote":"Compound: EFT vacua, soft terms and visible D3 stability. The p0 contribution is uplift-coupling matching.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"8908ba72d902fe78d45eefe0d6020a0b4ef7ee78b1db60ef2411c343cb69be4e"},"organizational-access:f7eae095eb7f79600092e36e":{"id":"organizational-access:f7eae095eb7f79600092e36e","source":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","target":"q025-candidate-question:921c76b9f363f2b0bb5588b9","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ec2c47e7ee84c6d123adca5b3d961b204b3261307a6c2bc5a4aaf3baae54201d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:cef6ef19d5338c5bfb7fa705"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:921c76b9f363f2b0bb5588b9","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"15656a34080f758e3028cd71eb0f83f0a6e315d7ea8f012921840d6f979bbde9","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c80e43ce8a66f7e2c3bd7980"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","home":{"unitId":"unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","paperId":"2303.02487","textSha256":"08962bc8c1f3b3b197184e03a5342b7328439372057c3d7eabc5ef395004d69b"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0c63c6518043ef6850b030c5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0c63c6518043ef6850b030c5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec2c47e7ee84c6d123adca5b3d961b204b3261307a6c2bc5a4aaf3baae54201d","placementContentSha256":"451cb947db34d8e0b0e31d167384d80ae13b6b396253bdbe54ff70c17b855451","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","paperId":"2303.02487","textSha256":"08962bc8c1f3b3b197184e03a5342b7328439372057c3d7eabc5ef395004d69b"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0c63c6518043ef6850b030c5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:921c76b9f363f2b0bb5588b9","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d90","kind":"description","unitIndex":90,"unitId":"unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","textSha256":"08962bc8c1f3b3b197184e03a5342b7328439372057c3d7eabc5ef395004d69b"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8d9947dcbc84f9cb8e22633d39ed7a35","paperId":"2303.02487","sourceSha256":"e8231034df6804d4deb0f709d8f57dc54394dbcaa4e6e52daf708da564f25b8e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62a7825d84c2e8252388/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"da7b3a24b82b43c9126390609109958223d4bc96f7fd89cb7851833e8d79e83d","pdfPage":3,"start":1298,"end":3088,"textSha256":"c5cf49fa874212f9c7fc31f2491fe69294cbde24a5e122bc2f184119f632c971","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a5d0c3e81400dfe4fc1c6d279be6a01f","paperId":"2303.02487","sourceSha256":"e8231034df6804d4deb0f709d8f57dc54394dbcaa4e6e52daf708da564f25b8e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62a7825d84c2e8252388/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"da7b3a24b82b43c9126390609109958223d4bc96f7fd89cb7851833e8d79e83d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1908,"textSha256":"a076074c2d7cc43453c1c36d6043610adf15a28bac0737b3d72f2d4535617fac","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e537a6c971766d3a4c9c60252bc13e8f","paperId":"2303.02487","sourceSha256":"e8231034df6804d4deb0f709d8f57dc54394dbcaa4e6e52daf708da564f25b8e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62a7825d84c2e8252388/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"da7b3a24b82b43c9126390609109958223d4bc96f7fd89cb7851833e8d79e83d","pdfPage":1,"start":104,"end":1908,"textSha256":"841bf7221c9faa808b9fb5ecb89cb58888f1dd38b230feaec35a744d8bda0eb4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ec8bb009c268b8ce7b89b42f","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: March 2023 v1 critical-point RPS test with variable G and central charge; distinct from rotating extremal KNKL and from a dynamical censorship theorem. Independent challenge qualification: March 2023 v1 RPS critical-point test with variable G and central charge; neither extremality nor dynamical censorship follows from this setup."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ec8bb009c268b8ce7b89b42f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","q025-candidate-question:921c76b9f363f2b0bb5588b9"],"scopeContentSha256":"15656a34080f758e3028cd71eb0f83f0a6e315d7ea8f012921840d6f979bbde9","contributionContentSha256":"03f211ae9eef59230d1994c57da92886c94beaac2666d9bf0bf7f246395e9731","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d90","kind":"description","unitIndex":90,"unitId":"unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","textSha256":"08962bc8c1f3b3b197184e03a5342b7328439372057c3d7eabc5ef395004d69b"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8d9947dcbc84f9cb8e22633d39ed7a35","paperId":"2303.02487","sourceSha256":"e8231034df6804d4deb0f709d8f57dc54394dbcaa4e6e52daf708da564f25b8e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62a7825d84c2e8252388/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"da7b3a24b82b43c9126390609109958223d4bc96f7fd89cb7851833e8d79e83d","pdfPage":3,"start":1298,"end":3088,"textSha256":"c5cf49fa874212f9c7fc31f2491fe69294cbde24a5e122bc2f184119f632c971","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a5d0c3e81400dfe4fc1c6d279be6a01f","paperId":"2303.02487","sourceSha256":"e8231034df6804d4deb0f709d8f57dc54394dbcaa4e6e52daf708da564f25b8e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62a7825d84c2e8252388/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"da7b3a24b82b43c9126390609109958223d4bc96f7fd89cb7851833e8d79e83d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1908,"textSha256":"a076074c2d7cc43453c1c36d6043610adf15a28bac0737b3d72f2d4535617fac","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e537a6c971766d3a4c9c60252bc13e8f","paperId":"2303.02487","sourceSha256":"e8231034df6804d4deb0f709d8f57dc54394dbcaa4e6e52daf708da564f25b8e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62a7825d84c2e8252388/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"da7b3a24b82b43c9126390609109958223d4bc96f7fd89cb7851833e8d79e83d","pdfPage":1,"start":104,"end":1908,"textSha256":"841bf7221c9faa808b9fb5ecb89cb58888f1dd38b230feaec35a744d8bda0eb4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ec8bb009c268b8ce7b89b42f","recordId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"March 2023 v1 critical-point RPS test with variable G and central charge; distinct from rotating extremal KNKL and from a dynamical censorship theorem.","challengeNote":"March 2023 v1 RPS critical-point test with variable G and central charge; neither extremality nor dynamical censorship follows from this setup.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","home":{"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Specifically covers environmentally dressed charged-hole horizons at source-defined charge-to-mass thresholds and the authors' conditional WGC–WCCC interpretations.","qualification":"q4 directly covers environmental deformations, horizon existence at source-defined charge-to-mass thresholds and the attributed WGC–WCCC interpretation. The RN reference ratio, deformed extremality relation and particle criterion remain distinct. Neither a charged spectrum nor a dynamical censorship test is supplied or required to place this qualified question.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","paperId":"2508.01487","textSha256":"0fe7561fb15c4ef32d44fe1d9ab5bab835c29bf3c5247d8c6aa8ad93d3daba86"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0003:u29:q4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0003:u29:q4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec2c47e7ee84c6d123adca5b3d961b204b3261307a6c2bc5a4aaf3baae54201d","placementContentSha256":"643ef9ef38602396f188cc7cae2a52e7c457ff91b5bc404b46b2ba6ae4055aed","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0003:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0003:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","paperId":"2508.01487","textSha256":"0fe7561fb15c4ef32d44fe1d9ab5bab835c29bf3c5247d8c6aa8ad93d3daba86"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0003","unitRef":"u29"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:921c76b9f363f2b0bb5588b9","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d72","kind":"description","unitIndex":72,"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","textSha256":"0fe7561fb15c4ef32d44fe1d9ab5bab835c29bf3c5247d8c6aa8ad93d3daba86"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:056f03f61a118320a256cbd4666feeb2","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2437,"textSha256":"f104d9b8804048972bcc6fbc39c5f4533de6425c49dfc7a2d30e494aa0ddf228","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1d88198c6582501de8c447c84e4cdc56","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":2,"start":2496,"end":5891,"textSha256":"9569f3b4337df96d2ff86a7f3015a39a170777acb8435607459ab1bf57d4cfda","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af029defe36ef00c6fac0019ee4c7429","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2437,"textSha256":"73bf4a56b7dcbc3bd67f37591e166bc1da313f12fc5fa144a84a5d390e746dde","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:55eb5c731cb5a3f271d3f5d3","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Supplied August 2025 v2 gives a stationary parameter/horizon test and an author interpretation; it does not establish collapse censorship or a WGC spectrum. Independent challenge qualification: August 2025 v2 announces stationary parameter/horizon compatibility. This does not establish collapse censorship or the required charged-matter spectrum."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:55eb5c731cb5a3f271d3f5d3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","q025-candidate-question:921c76b9f363f2b0bb5588b9"],"scopeContentSha256":"15656a34080f758e3028cd71eb0f83f0a6e315d7ea8f012921840d6f979bbde9","contributionContentSha256":"f5c5ef386f5d8e5c266b9c8ce7b261828aaa4bc4c667171e270059dd8cbc8173","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d72","kind":"description","unitIndex":72,"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","textSha256":"0fe7561fb15c4ef32d44fe1d9ab5bab835c29bf3c5247d8c6aa8ad93d3daba86"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:056f03f61a118320a256cbd4666feeb2","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2437,"textSha256":"f104d9b8804048972bcc6fbc39c5f4533de6425c49dfc7a2d30e494aa0ddf228","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1d88198c6582501de8c447c84e4cdc56","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":2,"start":2496,"end":5891,"textSha256":"9569f3b4337df96d2ff86a7f3015a39a170777acb8435607459ab1bf57d4cfda","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af029defe36ef00c6fac0019ee4c7429","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2437,"textSha256":"73bf4a56b7dcbc3bd67f37591e166bc1da313f12fc5fa144a84a5d390e746dde","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:55eb5c731cb5a3f271d3f5d3","recordId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Supplied August 2025 v2 gives a stationary parameter/horizon test and an author interpretation; it does not establish collapse censorship or a WGC spectrum.","challengeNote":"August 2025 v2 announces stationary parameter/horizon compatibility. This does not establish collapse censorship or the required charged-matter spectrum.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"90b24cff153bd7ac1a79291e2f278656163238e38a63f81b29126c8c99bb8c59"},"organizational-access:f2bd3cb9afb144e00d78ff7a":{"id":"organizational-access:f2bd3cb9afb144e00d78ff7a","source":"q025-candidate-question:8508f44be914b48522e882b1","target":"q025-candidate-question:c19b646d564f6e3e0f160f53","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8508f44be914b48522e882b1","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"be8872f8c8320bd74651e2ad2881be36654fad422aa8ac1a937cc1b5a8733d16","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:79ad82dde76ba586053af89f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c19b646d564f6e3e0f160f53","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"21c07c83ba088a36e1a1cf7583290e425b0c2b5a00162d828cb61cd5a0e6342c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6c96864172b9a71a377fd635"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:b063fd5023d1181170a7e17949cb39a2a6fa7b99009b065cfbcf8c6a272dc5ab","home":{"unitId":"unit:b063fd5023d1181170a7e17949cb39a2a6fa7b99009b065cfbcf8c6a272dc5ab","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8508f44be914b48522e882b1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers joint potential and kinetic-function reconstruction from a prescribed spectral attractor under source-coordinate conjectural filters.","qualification":"q10 explicitly joins the prescribed spectral attractor, reconstruction of both unknown functions and the source-coordinate conjectural filters. It preserves auxiliary assumptions and the distinction between reconstructing in e-fold and scalar coordinates, without asserting uniqueness, invariant compatibility or a geometric attractor mechanism.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b063fd5023d1181170a7e17949cb39a2a6fa7b99009b065cfbcf8c6a272dc5ab","paperId":"2009.01355","textSha256":"f5381297cda5e694d71eb68dc72e3329aaaff46f2babf65fe35850846a767a49"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0024:u11:q10"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0024:u11:q10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b063fd5023d1181170a7e17949cb39a2a6fa7b99009b065cfbcf8c6a272dc5ab","q025-candidate-question:8508f44be914b48522e882b1"],"scopeContentSha256":"be8872f8c8320bd74651e2ad2881be36654fad422aa8ac1a937cc1b5a8733d16","placementContentSha256":"ea27ceb4fabe91aeeff4723252a07c47c43c6b4dbb0e1ff58382be6572ba1b62","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0024:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0024:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b063fd5023d1181170a7e17949cb39a2a6fa7b99009b065cfbcf8c6a272dc5ab","paperId":"2009.01355","textSha256":"f5381297cda5e694d71eb68dc72e3329aaaff46f2babf65fe35850846a767a49"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0024","unitRef":"u11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b063fd5023d1181170a7e17949cb39a2a6fa7b99009b065cfbcf8c6a272dc5ab","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c19b646d564f6e3e0f160f53","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:b063fd5023d1181170a7e17949cb39a2a6fa7b99009b065cfbcf8c6a272dc5ab","textSha256":"f5381297cda5e694d71eb68dc72e3329aaaff46f2babf65fe35850846a767a49"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d1eb8e1d61905525b399769f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d1eb8e1d61905525b399769f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b063fd5023d1181170a7e17949cb39a2a6fa7b99009b065cfbcf8c6a272dc5ab","q025-candidate-question:c19b646d564f6e3e0f160f53"],"scopeContentSha256":"21c07c83ba088a36e1a1cf7583290e425b0c2b5a00162d828cb61cd5a0e6342c","contributionContentSha256":"97d96f375c2d8aa4bea6f2eb71501c5281ea297429f66f954f9da89394c4f603","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:b063fd5023d1181170a7e17949cb39a2a6fa7b99009b065cfbcf8c6a272dc5ab","textSha256":"f5381297cda5e694d71eb68dc72e3329aaaff46f2babf65fe35850846a767a49"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d1eb8e1d61905525b399769f","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound reconstruction and constraint target. d53 supplies same-paper coordinate-test context, not independent validation of this row.","challengeNote":"Compound reconstruction and constraint target. d53 remains other-unit normalization context, not this unit's primary evidence.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"94101bb2dfa49defc6448cc97ea93f0a0b76c3a6904d5c0078e046458fd2151d"},"organizational-access:87fe393a697e0b5f24641ccf":{"id":"organizational-access:87fe393a697e0b5f24641ccf","source":"q025-candidate-question:850c14ec5e9355cc9d819037","target":"q025-candidate-question:f19bee7b8e7cec3d7887c150","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:850c14ec5e9355cc9d819037","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"0c13efc1c984b416b5a190141e46445132dd16e5a47edf6c2cd112a79c285452","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0d61f0f468c093fa1e3b9dea"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f19bee7b8e7cec3d7887c150","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"93e5781df4075595227c2a177219e8ad8af5d596322205bcfbfa6259113c7a9f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ca1f4bbd99df934d174eb666"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1c28587cc64367af38923ed63d36d42ff909d5f1b6bab6ffc7562989eb12e281","home":{"unitId":"unit:1c28587cc64367af38923ed63d36d42ff909d5f1b6bab6ffc7562989eb12e281","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:850c14ec5e9355cc9d819037","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q5 explicitly combines macroscopic quantum production and finite-temperature nucleation under entropy-dependent analysis.","qualification":"q5 explicitly contains both entropy-assisted macroscopic quantum production and finite-temperature nucleation. The common method connects two retained targets; q9 alone would omit nucleation.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1c28587cc64367af38923ed63d36d42ff909d5f1b6bab6ffc7562989eb12e281","paperId":"2302.08353","textSha256":"1a69aadffff12b7204196bb31e604a69aa830211c7a59b2f05e4063bdebced34"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0035:u6:q5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0035:u6:q5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1c28587cc64367af38923ed63d36d42ff909d5f1b6bab6ffc7562989eb12e281","q025-candidate-question:850c14ec5e9355cc9d819037"],"scopeContentSha256":"0c13efc1c984b416b5a190141e46445132dd16e5a47edf6c2cd112a79c285452","placementContentSha256":"f24d4ac8a6773717f1b31e9c2061fdccaa8f96e54b7918f16a1eec8c6c7c566b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0035:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0035:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1c28587cc64367af38923ed63d36d42ff909d5f1b6bab6ffc7562989eb12e281","paperId":"2302.08353","textSha256":"1a69aadffff12b7204196bb31e604a69aa830211c7a59b2f05e4063bdebced34"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0035","unitRef":"u6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1c28587cc64367af38923ed63d36d42ff909d5f1b6bab6ffc7562989eb12e281","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f19bee7b8e7cec3d7887c150","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:1c28587cc64367af38923ed63d36d42ff909d5f1b6bab6ffc7562989eb12e281","textSha256":"1a69aadffff12b7204196bb31e604a69aa830211c7a59b2f05e4063bdebced34"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7d8c8dc3ed88996bf6d1782e","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Material compound: direct macroscopic dark-matter production and enhanced finite-temperature bubble nucleation require separate reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Material compound: macroscopic dark-matter production and finite-temperature bubble nucleation require separate fine reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7d8c8dc3ed88996bf6d1782e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1c28587cc64367af38923ed63d36d42ff909d5f1b6bab6ffc7562989eb12e281","q025-candidate-question:f19bee7b8e7cec3d7887c150"],"scopeContentSha256":"93e5781df4075595227c2a177219e8ad8af5d596322205bcfbfa6259113c7a9f","contributionContentSha256":"08225b66c11a8dcbcf9dc63cedc79dd41d769f416c299278d31c63b67157b2e8","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-proposal","leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:1c28587cc64367af38923ed63d36d42ff909d5f1b6bab6ffc7562989eb12e281","textSha256":"1a69aadffff12b7204196bb31e604a69aa830211c7a59b2f05e4063bdebced34"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7d8c8dc3ed88996bf6d1782e","recordId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Material compound: direct macroscopic dark-matter production and enhanced finite-temperature bubble nucleation require separate reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Material compound: macroscopic dark-matter production and finite-temperature bubble nucleation require separate fine reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:de10ded146c06a240463a8fdccf047c3e85f01ca6c7821da8692a94661ccb1a7","home":{"unitId":"unit:de10ded146c06a240463a8fdccf047c3e85f01ca6c7821da8692a94661ccb1a7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:850c14ec5e9355cc9d819037","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q5 includes arbitrary-spin physical-component perturbation theory and its theory-to-cosmology applications.","qualification":"q5 covers both the arbitrary-spin perturbative description and its explicit theory-to-cosmology application. Freeze-out and freeze-in remain alternatives, and the bounds retain the paper's scope and date.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:de10ded146c06a240463a8fdccf047c3e85f01ca6c7821da8692a94661ccb1a7","paperId":"2010.02224","textSha256":"fef08371a37cf64ef656c0ccf8754a5dc5466e00a242616b25b501ffdcb4e0d6"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0035:u9:q5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0035:u9:q5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:de10ded146c06a240463a8fdccf047c3e85f01ca6c7821da8692a94661ccb1a7","q025-candidate-question:850c14ec5e9355cc9d819037"],"scopeContentSha256":"0c13efc1c984b416b5a190141e46445132dd16e5a47edf6c2cd112a79c285452","placementContentSha256":"7dbca76dc5365974a8765e91d0b72b3567364f75a9ac921a2d80150e7b3bd11b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0035:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0035:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:de10ded146c06a240463a8fdccf047c3e85f01ca6c7821da8692a94661ccb1a7","paperId":"2010.02224","textSha256":"fef08371a37cf64ef656c0ccf8754a5dc5466e00a242616b25b501ffdcb4e0d6"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0035","unitRef":"u9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:de10ded146c06a240463a8fdccf047c3e85f01ca6c7821da8692a94661ccb1a7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f19bee7b8e7cec3d7887c150","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:de10ded146c06a240463a8fdccf047c3e85f01ca6c7821da8692a94661ccb1a7","textSha256":"fef08371a37cf64ef656c0ccf8754a5dc5466e00a242616b25b501ffdcb4e0d6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cc392e0997013d9fb5c739e3","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Material compound: arbitrary-spin perturbative formalism and a neutral Higgs-portal freeze-out or freeze-in application. Independent challenge qualification: Material compound: arbitrary-spin formalism and a neutral Higgs-portal freeze-out or freeze-in application require separate fine reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:cc392e0997013d9fb5c739e3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:de10ded146c06a240463a8fdccf047c3e85f01ca6c7821da8692a94661ccb1a7","q025-candidate-question:f19bee7b8e7cec3d7887c150"],"scopeContentSha256":"93e5781df4075595227c2a177219e8ad8af5d596322205bcfbfa6259113c7a9f","contributionContentSha256":"07bccdae6696628bd56c710e78010eca14c1ce4cb7ad8c8a325790aede2a3ca5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-proposal","leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:de10ded146c06a240463a8fdccf047c3e85f01ca6c7821da8692a94661ccb1a7","textSha256":"fef08371a37cf64ef656c0ccf8754a5dc5466e00a242616b25b501ffdcb4e0d6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cc392e0997013d9fb5c739e3","recordId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Material compound: arbitrary-spin perturbative formalism and a neutral Higgs-portal freeze-out or freeze-in application.","challengeNote":"Material compound: arbitrary-spin formalism and a neutral Higgs-portal freeze-out or freeze-in application require separate fine reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"9d92baa793161580ec0a3d33221bca2788708a94cc9b373f9324b62e4bedb219"},"organizational-access:b8fa8c35a47ef3978fb8bc87":{"id":"organizational-access:b8fa8c35a47ef3978fb8bc87","source":"q025-candidate-question:8bfa3dd8ec9de6c479eeaef8","target":"q025-candidate-question:8be01c4d39f1dbfac4e9bf69","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8bfa3dd8ec9de6c479eeaef8","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"4a24be59ea305ada723881431f72d706a79aef565e3d1dbef69de4f84f0bef32","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:04c80a280452849e2f8c24ef"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8be01c4d39f1dbfac4e9bf69","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"925b40a9e7e2bf02e1b26801391c62fa97fcb667da087bc64f80ced06fcd5b97","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:94cea0fa6f3bf96138c7f625"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:b38361f64f21663f35f3f15dcab23d73b28382f1c2061578878f2a2dc5d58347","home":{"unitId":"unit:b38361f64f21663f35f3f15dcab23d73b28382f1c2061578878f2a2dc5d58347","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8bfa3dd8ec9de6c479eeaef8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b38361f64f21663f35f3f15dcab23d73b28382f1c2061578878f2a2dc5d58347","paperId":"1707.05811","textSha256":"651686eb50988dccb035207f3b526664a15a3aaa27afd4075360be2f44641195"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:82b8db7bd22f2f0354ef02f1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:82b8db7bd22f2f0354ef02f1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b38361f64f21663f35f3f15dcab23d73b28382f1c2061578878f2a2dc5d58347","q025-candidate-question:8bfa3dd8ec9de6c479eeaef8"],"scopeContentSha256":"4a24be59ea305ada723881431f72d706a79aef565e3d1dbef69de4f84f0bef32","placementContentSha256":"9d24daf581f1f607c69b99a1cdc40a9ab5502a1e7b77bac215d5f170cbd59ec5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b38361f64f21663f35f3f15dcab23d73b28382f1c2061578878f2a2dc5d58347","paperId":"1707.05811","textSha256":"651686eb50988dccb035207f3b526664a15a3aaa27afd4075360be2f44641195"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:82b8db7bd22f2f0354ef02f1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b38361f64f21663f35f3f15dcab23d73b28382f1c2061578878f2a2dc5d58347","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8be01c4d39f1dbfac4e9bf69","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:b38361f64f21663f35f3f15dcab23d73b28382f1c2061578878f2a2dc5d58347","textSha256":"651686eb50988dccb035207f3b526664a15a3aaa27afd4075360be2f44641195"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2239458116520e8423dfbda9173dfbdb","paperId":"1707.05811","sourceSha256":"fa4514fce2cbe52d75ba6ce520d0c3a7d67ed55be8b18bfd5ec36ba926370033","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bca515c9776a7b5ba796/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7232fe51ac4cadf8f0890699723eadb8b504eb1f067b9f5f9d1e83c08d35b8ab","pdfPage":1,"start":995,"end":3995,"textSha256":"f2f8ee7e0688b78213005a63bcc60e193e3c45b3b1a6ac024a8e78e7399d82c6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:97390aea82674249f48dfa680d026dfe","paperId":"1707.05811","sourceSha256":"fa4514fce2cbe52d75ba6ce520d0c3a7d67ed55be8b18bfd5ec36ba926370033","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bca515c9776a7b5ba796/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7232fe51ac4cadf8f0890699723eadb8b504eb1f067b9f5f9d1e83c08d35b8ab","pdfPage":1,"start":1278,"end":4158,"textSha256":"8c60b6db76f20a6569f7b1a76c1bd8b73305ea934bd8db777fcb3b3e5ebade0c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:31f596e48e2dff444c43c04dbfd10839","paperId":"1707.05811","sourceSha256":"fa4514fce2cbe52d75ba6ce520d0c3a7d67ed55be8b18bfd5ec36ba926370033","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bca515c9776a7b5ba796/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7232fe51ac4cadf8f0890699723eadb8b504eb1f067b9f5f9d1e83c08d35b8ab","pdfPage":1,"start":1988,"end":4158,"textSha256":"ee0a1efa5c51ae416951f9eb25639501a6689c05787647110662982b6da8c3b2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:14467f42cf1997d4d68c1fdf","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Conditional neutrino/Higgs bounds; the discussed Majorana realization adds a light Weyl fermion. Imported potential calculations are not supplied. Independent challenge qualification: Joint conditional neutrino/Higgs targets. The discussed Majorana case adds a light Weyl fermion; quantitative potential calculations are imported."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:14467f42cf1997d4d68c1fdf","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b38361f64f21663f35f3f15dcab23d73b28382f1c2061578878f2a2dc5d58347","q025-candidate-question:8be01c4d39f1dbfac4e9bf69"],"scopeContentSha256":"925b40a9e7e2bf02e1b26801391c62fa97fcb667da087bc64f80ced06fcd5b97","contributionContentSha256":"212f5a4eac090173349a9c091541fc9457feddb4eb3fc63fab388ec23d4f3ebe","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-56a64c205c83cf5b2113-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-56a64c205c83cf5b2113-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-56a64c205c83cf5b2113-proposal","leaf-56a64c205c83cf5b2113-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:b38361f64f21663f35f3f15dcab23d73b28382f1c2061578878f2a2dc5d58347","textSha256":"651686eb50988dccb035207f3b526664a15a3aaa27afd4075360be2f44641195"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2239458116520e8423dfbda9173dfbdb","paperId":"1707.05811","sourceSha256":"fa4514fce2cbe52d75ba6ce520d0c3a7d67ed55be8b18bfd5ec36ba926370033","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bca515c9776a7b5ba796/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7232fe51ac4cadf8f0890699723eadb8b504eb1f067b9f5f9d1e83c08d35b8ab","pdfPage":1,"start":995,"end":3995,"textSha256":"f2f8ee7e0688b78213005a63bcc60e193e3c45b3b1a6ac024a8e78e7399d82c6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:97390aea82674249f48dfa680d026dfe","paperId":"1707.05811","sourceSha256":"fa4514fce2cbe52d75ba6ce520d0c3a7d67ed55be8b18bfd5ec36ba926370033","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bca515c9776a7b5ba796/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7232fe51ac4cadf8f0890699723eadb8b504eb1f067b9f5f9d1e83c08d35b8ab","pdfPage":1,"start":1278,"end":4158,"textSha256":"8c60b6db76f20a6569f7b1a76c1bd8b73305ea934bd8db777fcb3b3e5ebade0c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:31f596e48e2dff444c43c04dbfd10839","paperId":"1707.05811","sourceSha256":"fa4514fce2cbe52d75ba6ce520d0c3a7d67ed55be8b18bfd5ec36ba926370033","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bca515c9776a7b5ba796/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7232fe51ac4cadf8f0890699723eadb8b504eb1f067b9f5f9d1e83c08d35b8ab","pdfPage":1,"start":1988,"end":4158,"textSha256":"ee0a1efa5c51ae416951f9eb25639501a6689c05787647110662982b6da8c3b2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:14467f42cf1997d4d68c1fdf","recordId":"leaf-56a64c205c83cf5b2113-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-56a64c205c83cf5b2113-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-56a64c205c83cf5b2113-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Conditional neutrino/Higgs bounds; the discussed Majorana realization adds a light Weyl fermion. Imported potential calculations are not supplied.","challengeNote":"Joint conditional neutrino/Higgs targets. The discussed Majorana case adds a light Weyl fermion; quantitative potential calculations are imported.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"60beaf8eba10cb89f37f00c8f72808c312ada46a3562aa4865b6c24d5b3fcf4c"},"organizational-access:87d241f81ac4bfa5acc2dfe0":{"id":"organizational-access:87d241f81ac4bfa5acc2dfe0","source":"q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd","target":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7d9d96e78da885b873119f7761b68d7d9d83239838c2086498214ba3aa8734a2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7bf564e28fb040852d80558f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9e6c184caeeca1fe514b806a44ec65f74bf314448503e5b9dead2e99a6f758bf","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:498d2ccc89fa873c91e4b585"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","home":{"unitId":"unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":0.5,"reason":"Covers the distinct conditional de Sitter, distance and trans-Planckian tests specified by the source.","qualification":"Thermal dynamics and three conditional criteria remain distinct. Exact full challenge coverage and source-local qualifications remain binding. Weights are organizational allocation, not confidence or physical importance.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","paperId":"1911.00323","textSha256":"950c928b0245d6f31d6daadd318e2a783f897a124df9753c860442b330cd9440"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0056:u16:q10","coverageMode":"explicit_compound_union","targetCoverage":[{"sourceSpan":"Can a concrete axion-induced thermal bath sustain inflation on steep potentials while reproducing the observed scalar spectrum","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a"],"explanation":"Assigns the thermal mechanism, steep-potential background and scalar-spectrum viability to the modified-dynamics scope."},{"sourceSpan":"and respecting the paper's de Sitter, distance, and trans-Planckian criteria?","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd"],"explanation":"Assigns the three source-specific conditional consistency tests to their explicit admitted scope, without treating them as universal premises."}],"coverageReason":"The union covers the thermal mechanism, steep-potential inflation and observed-spectrum requirement through q12, and the explicitly named conjectural criteria through q10. q12's stability/EFT targets do not themselves specify those three quantum-gravity tests; its exclusion of automatic Swampland compatibility is a warning, not positive coverage of every test. q10 does not independently cover the full thermal construction and spectrum calculation. No supplied single scope covers all these targets without enlargement. The source remains one question, with coordinator scrutiny required."},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0056:u16:q10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd"],"scopeContentSha256":"7d9d96e78da885b873119f7761b68d7d9d83239838c2086498214ba3aa8734a2","placementContentSha256":"b04e1d8248681d073997b9c4fa6409dac12281179282c28721c3128a11fa31c6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0056:proposal","explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0056:challenge","root:explicit-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","paperId":"1911.00323","textSha256":"950c928b0245d6f31d6daadd318e2a783f897a124df9753c860442b330cd9440"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"45cd7c1d060cb6f2fd1d8a4ace5cca7c3d64df235a869afc4ce7e31b2e6badfb"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0056","unitRef":"u16"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","textSha256":"950c928b0245d6f31d6daadd318e2a783f897a124df9753c860442b330cd9440"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9a8029d3b8ab6ba360faf856","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Shares a paper with the completion question but has a different target and scope. Independent challenge qualification: Shares a paper with the completion facet, but asks a different scoped question."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9a8029d3b8ab6ba360faf856","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a"],"scopeContentSha256":"9e6c184caeeca1fe514b806a44ec65f74bf314448503e5b9dead2e99a6f758bf","contributionContentSha256":"57036941846c21436a4c695ef0f34af040f6b6e36335f903cc1bffe042094b56","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","textSha256":"950c928b0245d6f31d6daadd318e2a783f897a124df9753c860442b330cd9440"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9a8029d3b8ab6ba360faf856","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Shares a paper with the completion question but has a different target and scope.","challengeNote":"Shares a paper with the completion facet, but asks a different scoped question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"9a1eb51447550032bc614f25a5f4c9a2b8f8606bda85720c42f3a6d2298ed5d9"},"organizational-access:3f8b03533533e9949d868a1f":{"id":"organizational-access:3f8b03533533e9949d868a1f","source":"q025-candidate-question:bd03d48ac70107b65ca01d2f","target":"q025-candidate-question:3f15ffb413ced96ee003177a","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:bd03d48ac70107b65ca01d2f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ac917d79ec6f62e1aa4038b053488c56289c8fb82f799b8c19ba84dea335032e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:02d73bf8f233b7b8118ef320"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3f15ffb413ced96ee003177a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"8df310c696f49b94321af5100df89b2d19c24d4830f235a2cd3faec67cb3251d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:33653a099a2a2c62800edd63"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","home":{"unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:bd03d48ac70107b65ca01d2f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines late dark-force activation, scalar slowing, background constraints and structure formation.","qualification":"q14 explicitly combines early-suppressed/late-active forces, expansion, growth and interaction-induced scalar slowing. It therefore covers the larger-slope target as well as force-history viability. Illustrative comparisons remain distinct from a fitted viable parameter region.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","paperId":"1904.07082","textSha256":"f146c93dbd9e0eaf26fe2d87bc210df0bd18209d305a8816121fce9e84b75986"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0020:u18:q14"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0020:u18:q14","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","q025-candidate-question:bd03d48ac70107b65ca01d2f"],"scopeContentSha256":"ac917d79ec6f62e1aa4038b053488c56289c8fb82f799b8c19ba84dea335032e","placementContentSha256":"c241a2d3f83276795dfc9d4c8318a57d026c94096555661ccfd962a8d7fc5541","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0020:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0020:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","paperId":"1904.07082","textSha256":"f146c93dbd9e0eaf26fe2d87bc210df0bd18209d305a8816121fce9e84b75986"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0020","unitRef":"u18"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3f15ffb413ced96ee003177a","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","textSha256":"f146c93dbd9e0eaf26fe2d87bc210df0bd18209d305a8816121fce9e84b75986"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:655c2a496708f6162b962dc2cbfca3d8","paperId":"1904.07082","sourceSha256":"a2b2946d97aace557f8f4a6525b3dfee6e1bcab2e52175df638996dd4f7ea402","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8b5447e6964f083fc57/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46d120255ad59203f625dcf6ac85588403834451cb957e8386ca21d733248911","pdfPage":7,"start":489,"end":3489,"textSha256":"2b844d0b117298705dd1c0f563d4ad28165eb4e3609f6bff61dc2f4dff48a6cb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:87b83e916bf3893088fbc8b09c4aa0ed","paperId":"1904.07082","sourceSha256":"a2b2946d97aace557f8f4a6525b3dfee6e1bcab2e52175df638996dd4f7ea402","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8b5447e6964f083fc57/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46d120255ad59203f625dcf6ac85588403834451cb957e8386ca21d733248911","pdfPage":3,"start":420,"end":3420,"textSha256":"6e7847da9a1cd409fb1102fbca7906d83e14eeae1bb7583615fa9af3cbb98826","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:03275cf96c50045f8842257beb0980bb","paperId":"1904.07082","sourceSha256":"a2b2946d97aace557f8f4a6525b3dfee6e1bcab2e52175df638996dd4f7ea402","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8b5447e6964f083fc57/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46d120255ad59203f625dcf6ac85588403834451cb957e8386ca21d733248911","pdfPage":4,"start":414,"end":3414,"textSha256":"da33312bcff66a42955a852a9233971220f601eccc882e336032649f1c2f6aa1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7527e5034f9b23dbda13a771","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound force, expansion and structure targets. Illustrated benchmarks are not fitted viability; enhanced clustering remains consequential. Independent challenge qualification: Compound force, expansion and structure targets. Benchmark comparisons are illustrative; a detailed data fit is deferred and enhanced clustering remains co"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7527e5034f9b23dbda13a771","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","q025-candidate-question:3f15ffb413ced96ee003177a"],"scopeContentSha256":"8df310c696f49b94321af5100df89b2d19c24d4830f235a2cd3faec67cb3251d","contributionContentSha256":"954a133b0dda9cf18afb45ce87190a5105ed9c09ac14bc2d45268d9cc96123bf","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","textSha256":"f146c93dbd9e0eaf26fe2d87bc210df0bd18209d305a8816121fce9e84b75986"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:655c2a496708f6162b962dc2cbfca3d8","paperId":"1904.07082","sourceSha256":"a2b2946d97aace557f8f4a6525b3dfee6e1bcab2e52175df638996dd4f7ea402","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8b5447e6964f083fc57/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46d120255ad59203f625dcf6ac85588403834451cb957e8386ca21d733248911","pdfPage":7,"start":489,"end":3489,"textSha256":"2b844d0b117298705dd1c0f563d4ad28165eb4e3609f6bff61dc2f4dff48a6cb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:87b83e916bf3893088fbc8b09c4aa0ed","paperId":"1904.07082","sourceSha256":"a2b2946d97aace557f8f4a6525b3dfee6e1bcab2e52175df638996dd4f7ea402","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8b5447e6964f083fc57/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46d120255ad59203f625dcf6ac85588403834451cb957e8386ca21d733248911","pdfPage":3,"start":420,"end":3420,"textSha256":"6e7847da9a1cd409fb1102fbca7906d83e14eeae1bb7583615fa9af3cbb98826","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:03275cf96c50045f8842257beb0980bb","paperId":"1904.07082","sourceSha256":"a2b2946d97aace557f8f4a6525b3dfee6e1bcab2e52175df638996dd4f7ea402","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8b5447e6964f083fc57/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46d120255ad59203f625dcf6ac85588403834451cb957e8386ca21d733248911","pdfPage":4,"start":414,"end":3414,"textSha256":"da33312bcff66a42955a852a9233971220f601eccc882e336032649f1c2f6aa1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7527e5034f9b23dbda13a771","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound force, expansion and structure targets. Illustrated benchmarks are not fitted viability; enhanced clustering remains consequential.","challengeNote":"Compound force, expansion and structure targets. Benchmark comparisons are illustrative; a detailed data fit is deferred and enhanced clustering remains co","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"21fec03a2481a8a5a48011b4190b48e2d6fc1df95c39d2882462d6698b2d5b0a"},"organizational-access:f3a2fcfe197a089e56f51bba":{"id":"organizational-access:f3a2fcfe197a089e56f51bba","source":"q025-candidate-question:bd03d48ac70107b65ca01d2f","target":"q025-candidate-question:9003410b1ddf627c787f413f","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:bd03d48ac70107b65ca01d2f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ac917d79ec6f62e1aa4038b053488c56289c8fb82f799b8c19ba84dea335032e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:02d73bf8f233b7b8118ef320"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9003410b1ddf627c787f413f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"40b97fa8b684bf812f05396e56c1e9b34fd86b1bfe0699a85def1ce3dd0d2ee6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:a7fa31c27a81839e79f4d6b1"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","home":{"unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:bd03d48ac70107b65ca01d2f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines late dark-force activation, scalar slowing, background constraints and structure formation.","qualification":"q14 explicitly combines early-suppressed/late-active forces, expansion, growth and interaction-induced scalar slowing. It therefore covers the larger-slope target as well as force-history viability. Illustrative comparisons remain distinct from a fitted viable parameter region.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","paperId":"1904.07082","textSha256":"f146c93dbd9e0eaf26fe2d87bc210df0bd18209d305a8816121fce9e84b75986"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0020:u18:q14"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0020:u18:q14","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","q025-candidate-question:bd03d48ac70107b65ca01d2f"],"scopeContentSha256":"ac917d79ec6f62e1aa4038b053488c56289c8fb82f799b8c19ba84dea335032e","placementContentSha256":"c241a2d3f83276795dfc9d4c8318a57d026c94096555661ccfd962a8d7fc5541","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0020:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0020:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","paperId":"1904.07082","textSha256":"f146c93dbd9e0eaf26fe2d87bc210df0bd18209d305a8816121fce9e84b75986"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0020","unitRef":"u18"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9003410b1ddf627c787f413f","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","textSha256":"f146c93dbd9e0eaf26fe2d87bc210df0bd18209d305a8816121fce9e84b75986"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:51e8bed5997dfb047fdab87e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:51e8bed5997dfb047fdab87e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","q025-candidate-question:9003410b1ddf627c787f413f"],"scopeContentSha256":"40b97fa8b684bf812f05396e56c1e9b34fd86b1bfe0699a85def1ce3dd0d2ee6","contributionContentSha256":"77db484599f5fc7329f77eb291579ec9857a33403e6f407458ff20344693e91c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","textSha256":"f146c93dbd9e0eaf26fe2d87bc210df0bd18209d305a8816121fce9e84b75986"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:51e8bed5997dfb047fdab87e","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Force-history viability and accommodation of a steeper potential are linked targets requiring fine reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Force-history viability and accommodation of a steeper potential remain linked, distinguishable targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"19c61fe444badc66cb6a37d7d8b497ca49ce527f695ff1682aff68ab6c7cfac0"},"organizational-access:5174c88fc125aa206d0308b0":{"id":"organizational-access:5174c88fc125aa206d0308b0","source":"q025-candidate-question:c62054cbd3f53ee7d55fb5dc","target":"q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c62054cbd3f53ee7d55fb5dc","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1c302afcd544d554d26372752a2997aee2325b2b5370361a574186f76f898bd8","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:bf52914c7c3b3febc18c00fc"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"5d417a0fbda515287e8c5249a8dae741394e71605d3ba2b32d39982005753813","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:56bc30ad04066bdc9033cabe"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","home":{"unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c62054cbd3f53ee7d55fb5dc","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers supersymmetric stronger-QCD histories reconciling inflation, suppressed isocurvature and axions constituting all dark matter, with distinct inflationary and present axion scales.","qualification":"q11 jointly covers the supersymmetric model, high-scale inflationary compatibility, all-dark-matter abundance and suppressed isocurvature through the specified stronger-QCD history. Inflationary axion normalization and subsequent suppression remain distinct ingredients.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","textSha256":"cfc48717a6a3c3f04dd4b500b0739b1dd611a94ff9e3bce707f319b5afa78b72"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u0:q11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u0:q11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","q025-candidate-question:c62054cbd3f53ee7d55fb5dc"],"scopeContentSha256":"1c302afcd544d554d26372752a2997aee2325b2b5370361a574186f76f898bd8","placementContentSha256":"59703f1018299f5e27ee309c5530f49b1ea3f6c80725dd3113ea3a842d8f6b01","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:coverage:proposal","placement-pilot:coverage:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","textSha256":"cfc48717a6a3c3f04dd4b500b0739b1dd611a94ff9e3bce707f319b5afa78b72"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d85","kind":"description","unitIndex":85,"unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","textSha256":"cfc48717a6a3c3f04dd4b500b0739b1dd611a94ff9e3bce707f319b5afa78b72"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:928a16324b03bde78d21b59f0b31f4d5","paperId":"1505.00306","sourceSha256":"e703b456fa7a4c820e6c26728498c0f75b17489b3ed4e51d6fb99c11663bb33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f86fa9c83484e648a275/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e7ddbe419c17a4419e18d1f58fbc83a450baa3d3cd5a5930b55baefd2e1bb7d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"d0491254ad0e5b0c839109660916ca48cca51d8a9c8e403dfa22e4353751d28a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ba09a28e19c5d96fb916a8af467e73ed","paperId":"1505.00306","sourceSha256":"e703b456fa7a4c820e6c26728498c0f75b17489b3ed4e51d6fb99c11663bb33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f86fa9c83484e648a275/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e7ddbe419c17a4419e18d1f58fbc83a450baa3d3cd5a5930b55baefd2e1bb7d","pdfPage":2,"start":1293,"end":4696,"textSha256":"d428bf503890d3a72bd4ed4521fd93387e5ac20578683b3e3080e5d48b665a34","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f76e8ef85a13773383ddc534","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The May 2015 v2 proposal suppresses fluctuations after primordial inflation using stronger QCD and a larger inflationary axion scale; its observational bounds  Independent challenge qualification: May 2015 v2 combines a larger inflationary scale for the axion with later stronger-QCD fluctuation suppression; observational bounds remain source-dated."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f76e8ef85a13773383ddc534","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2"],"scopeContentSha256":"5d417a0fbda515287e8c5249a8dae741394e71605d3ba2b32d39982005753813","contributionContentSha256":"9486e23dc961e754e07e7ce3c9018dd1faf05b87cc8dba44320082332a1c5c51","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d85","kind":"description","unitIndex":85,"unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","textSha256":"cfc48717a6a3c3f04dd4b500b0739b1dd611a94ff9e3bce707f319b5afa78b72"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:928a16324b03bde78d21b59f0b31f4d5","paperId":"1505.00306","sourceSha256":"e703b456fa7a4c820e6c26728498c0f75b17489b3ed4e51d6fb99c11663bb33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f86fa9c83484e648a275/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e7ddbe419c17a4419e18d1f58fbc83a450baa3d3cd5a5930b55baefd2e1bb7d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"d0491254ad0e5b0c839109660916ca48cca51d8a9c8e403dfa22e4353751d28a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ba09a28e19c5d96fb916a8af467e73ed","paperId":"1505.00306","sourceSha256":"e703b456fa7a4c820e6c26728498c0f75b17489b3ed4e51d6fb99c11663bb33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f86fa9c83484e648a275/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e7ddbe419c17a4419e18d1f58fbc83a450baa3d3cd5a5930b55baefd2e1bb7d","pdfPage":2,"start":1293,"end":4696,"textSha256":"d428bf503890d3a72bd4ed4521fd93387e5ac20578683b3e3080e5d48b665a34","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f76e8ef85a13773383ddc534","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The May 2015 v2 proposal suppresses fluctuations after primordial inflation using stronger QCD and a larger inflationary axion scale; its observational bounds ","challengeNote":"May 2015 v2 combines a larger inflationary scale for the axion with later stronger-QCD fluctuation suppression; observational bounds remain source-dated.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"02c7d1acaa0f81edf5945fa96543b9b3da8992a9d9a2431757eb3f167a0180d1"},"organizational-access:2fca45d11dbb82283d8b59e7":{"id":"organizational-access:2fca45d11dbb82283d8b59e7","source":"q025-candidate-question:d77c0c524f51f526be3502c0","target":"q025-candidate-question:af98307d84cf3d8781924708","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:d77c0c524f51f526be3502c0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9300f932f4d0fa8d87915949f99da14bf0a4138ac05becea9a197dd34743e828","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:693fd5d83e68e5f032033046"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:af98307d84cf3d8781924708","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"51be4ba5d6c1170aae41990375846b538eb3d6595ba47868aaff428dfcf908a7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:dec419511cd94cdd1efba3b6"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:48c51a222538ab1b1813e864a0a2703902cc9f055c08a817078952c09b4a8334","home":{"unitId":"unit:48c51a222538ab1b1813e864a0a2703902cc9f055c08a817078952c09b4a8334","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d77c0c524f51f526be3502c0","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers extremal systems, microstate measurements and event-horizon regimes.","qualification":"q11 supplies the closest complete match to microstate measurement in an extremal system with an event horizon. q9 also addresses accessibility, but q11 states the measurement and horizon regime more specifically. Measurability is not equated with an evaporation-recovery protocol.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:48c51a222538ab1b1813e864a0a2703902cc9f055c08a817078952c09b4a8334","paperId":"hep-th/9606016","textSha256":"ed771b2140c64b7f3dd0cbe46394f3282eed2b3b97f02bcc2aca8cd1c18d7db6"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0070:u2:q11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0070:u2:q11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:48c51a222538ab1b1813e864a0a2703902cc9f055c08a817078952c09b4a8334","q025-candidate-question:d77c0c524f51f526be3502c0"],"scopeContentSha256":"9300f932f4d0fa8d87915949f99da14bf0a4138ac05becea9a197dd34743e828","placementContentSha256":"d3d3a86eb136147b671f18e4b5eb2d3d4d64cc763c84105dcd7ae632ad5307d4","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0070:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0070:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:48c51a222538ab1b1813e864a0a2703902cc9f055c08a817078952c09b4a8334","paperId":"hep-th/9606016","textSha256":"ed771b2140c64b7f3dd0cbe46394f3282eed2b3b97f02bcc2aca8cd1c18d7db6"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0070","unitRef":"u2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:48c51a222538ab1b1813e864a0a2703902cc9f055c08a817078952c09b4a8334","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:af98307d84cf3d8781924708","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:48c51a222538ab1b1813e864a0a2703902cc9f055c08a817078952c09b4a8334","textSha256":"ed771b2140c64b7f3dd0cbe46394f3282eed2b3b97f02bcc2aca8cd1c18d7db6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fda73e439c4cc982f3709e77","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:fda73e439c4cc982f3709e77","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:48c51a222538ab1b1813e864a0a2703902cc9f055c08a817078952c09b4a8334","q025-candidate-question:af98307d84cf3d8781924708"],"scopeContentSha256":"51be4ba5d6c1170aae41990375846b538eb3d6595ba47868aaff428dfcf908a7","contributionContentSha256":"3067f16dd4c187707d4332ccd256db690e7aadad16be94f1ea6e32e2a76c0f01","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:48c51a222538ab1b1813e864a0a2703902cc9f055c08a817078952c09b4a8334","textSha256":"ed771b2140c64b7f3dd0cbe46394f3282eed2b3b97f02bcc2aca8cd1c18d7db6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fda73e439c4cc982f3709e77","recordId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"30a38be32f4927a3e78a0fed448b999720aa08db5b825b00b34741f0c6c16181"},"organizational-access:2eb71226e7f3c81d72178107":{"id":"organizational-access:2eb71226e7f3c81d72178107","source":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30","target":"q025-candidate-question:c5267f5181cc7692f3008718","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"5e2d870128fc2bf088bc5ef1add58d06f7fb940950476c4c9faed0dabe9fca8e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c090b529d103b8fbf762a36e"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c5267f5181cc7692f3008718","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9248e7247eed0410a2a0bfbcfe7eef0f46e6aea8897e02e58dd3b6bc6b6a3f3a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3b5998c94e148172b6302d80"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:43be8448f4682498cc452befddd47cf57622a14b9ca6e1676e7f8a887d285ace","home":{"unitId":"unit:43be8448f4682498cc452befddd47cf57622a14b9ca6e1676e7f8a887d285ace","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q6 covers Lorentzian gravitational transition methods, comparison of exponents and formulation-dependent post-transition cosmology.","qualification":"q6 covers the Lorentzian treatment, comparison with Euclidean exponents and allowed closed post-transition geometry without the specified analytic continuations. Matching exponents would not identify all boundary conditions or formulations.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:43be8448f4682498cc452befddd47cf57622a14b9ca6e1676e7f8a887d285ace","paperId":"2011.13936","textSha256":"f07d22a316aee45cf43088e6345ae92958709c0a7fbc00d037a3807d9bdda999"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0033:u19:q6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0033:u19:q6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:43be8448f4682498cc452befddd47cf57622a14b9ca6e1676e7f8a887d285ace","q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30"],"scopeContentSha256":"5e2d870128fc2bf088bc5ef1add58d06f7fb940950476c4c9faed0dabe9fca8e","placementContentSha256":"c732fb6da56efb7734ec6b20f19e725f407c9dfb909b1ee423f35f5f9bd69608","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0033:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0033:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:43be8448f4682498cc452befddd47cf57622a14b9ca6e1676e7f8a887d285ace","paperId":"2011.13936","textSha256":"f07d22a316aee45cf43088e6345ae92958709c0a7fbc00d037a3807d9bdda999"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0033","unitRef":"u19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:43be8448f4682498cc452befddd47cf57622a14b9ca6e1676e7f8a887d285ace","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c5267f5181cc7692f3008718","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d49","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:43be8448f4682498cc452befddd47cf57622a14b9ca6e1676e7f8a887d285ace","textSha256":"f07d22a316aee45cf43088e6345ae92958709c0a7fbc00d037a3807d9bdda999"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c9a5b3ac75669d0b02660ec3"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c9a5b3ac75669d0b02660ec3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:43be8448f4682498cc452befddd47cf57622a14b9ca6e1676e7f8a887d285ace","q025-candidate-question:c5267f5181cc7692f3008718"],"scopeContentSha256":"9248e7247eed0410a2a0bfbcfe7eef0f46e6aea8897e02e58dd3b6bc6b6a3f3a","contributionContentSha256":"971c317017d514a4b2b2f4f66e5f4565da9bdec5d12f21d78dc593f14c1dea95","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d49","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:43be8448f4682498cc452befddd47cf57622a14b9ca6e1676e7f8a887d285ace","textSha256":"f07d22a316aee45cf43088e6345ae92958709c0a7fbc00d037a3807d9bdda999"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c9a5b3ac75669d0b02660ec3","recordId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:7807efa647b660301429e3cf412053a830647eb53d82b088009ab591892dea7b","home":{"unitId":"unit:7807efa647b660301429e3cf412053a830647eb53d82b088009ab591892dea7b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q6 covers stochastic estimates of gravitational cosmological transitions with source-specific initial settings and formulation limitations.","qualification":"q6 covers stochastic tunneling and baby-universe formation estimates in both empty Minkowski space and a heated laboratory, together with the Euclidean-method ambiguity. Its specified cosmological transition applications are not restricted to existing de Sitter false vacua; the intuitive estimates retain their limited status.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7807efa647b660301429e3cf412053a830647eb53d82b088009ab591892dea7b","paperId":"hep-th/9110037","textSha256":"c38e14f1176bc53da04ab9fae1a25e9243a26378d054f2c9c3231f31933bcc5e"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0033:u23:q6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0033:u23:q6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7807efa647b660301429e3cf412053a830647eb53d82b088009ab591892dea7b","q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30"],"scopeContentSha256":"5e2d870128fc2bf088bc5ef1add58d06f7fb940950476c4c9faed0dabe9fca8e","placementContentSha256":"34c8889bfda9c0fc181f735d424e61bd22db062e80dff081abacaa0108192045","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0033:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0033:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7807efa647b660301429e3cf412053a830647eb53d82b088009ab591892dea7b","paperId":"hep-th/9110037","textSha256":"c38e14f1176bc53da04ab9fae1a25e9243a26378d054f2c9c3231f31933bcc5e"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0033","unitRef":"u23"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7807efa647b660301429e3cf412053a830647eb53d82b088009ab591892dea7b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c5267f5181cc7692f3008718","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d81","kind":"description","unitIndex":81,"unitId":"unit:7807efa647b660301429e3cf412053a830647eb53d82b088009ab591892dea7b","textSha256":"c38e14f1176bc53da04ab9fae1a25e9243a26378d054f2c9c3231f31933bcc5e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:06d51947df160aeb7ea4f178"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:06d51947df160aeb7ea4f178","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7807efa647b660301429e3cf412053a830647eb53d82b088009ab591892dea7b","q025-candidate-question:c5267f5181cc7692f3008718"],"scopeContentSha256":"9248e7247eed0410a2a0bfbcfe7eef0f46e6aea8897e02e58dd3b6bc6b6a3f3a","contributionContentSha256":"4b1dc74352a0f011830f23a4eb4156f34de569c4b2aceda7b354f592458b1a3e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d81","kind":"description","unitIndex":81,"unitId":"unit:7807efa647b660301429e3cf412053a830647eb53d82b088009ab591892dea7b","textSha256":"c38e14f1176bc53da04ab9fae1a25e9243a26378d054f2c9c3231f31933bcc5e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:06d51947df160aeb7ea4f178","recordId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Empty Minkowski and heated-laboratory settings remain distinct from decay of an existing de Sitter vacuum.","challengeNote":"Empty Minkowski and heated-laboratory settings are retained as alternatives.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:cd0b160c82d27b5e657840be48ebfc93df072d932148f6c4415861f3ac877da3","home":{"unitId":"unit:cd0b160c82d27b5e657840be48ebfc93df072d932148f6c4415861f3ac877da3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q6 explicitly includes Wheeler–DeWitt methods and homogeneous anisotropic transition models.","qualification":"q6 covers the Lorentzian Wheeler–DeWitt method, homogeneous anisotropic background and anisotropy dependence of transition probabilities. The observable remains the transition probability rather than general past stability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cd0b160c82d27b5e657840be48ebfc93df072d932148f6c4415861f3ac877da3","paperId":"2107.07035","textSha256":"546c16ead17979912d605b16336c0d6288e5ded1e0559ca06b42c12c790b83a4"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0033:u20:q6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0033:u20:q6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cd0b160c82d27b5e657840be48ebfc93df072d932148f6c4415861f3ac877da3","q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30"],"scopeContentSha256":"5e2d870128fc2bf088bc5ef1add58d06f7fb940950476c4c9faed0dabe9fca8e","placementContentSha256":"68794f1642aab8af92bc648bcfd2cb0b6f042957fa2cb459581b5433ac3f51ac","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0033:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0033:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cd0b160c82d27b5e657840be48ebfc93df072d932148f6c4415861f3ac877da3","paperId":"2107.07035","textSha256":"546c16ead17979912d605b16336c0d6288e5ded1e0559ca06b42c12c790b83a4"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0033","unitRef":"u20"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cd0b160c82d27b5e657840be48ebfc93df072d932148f6c4415861f3ac877da3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c5267f5181cc7692f3008718","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d53","kind":"description","unitIndex":53,"unitId":"unit:cd0b160c82d27b5e657840be48ebfc93df072d932148f6c4415861f3ac877da3","textSha256":"546c16ead17979912d605b16336c0d6288e5ded1e0559ca06b42c12c790b83a4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1b340e76c9bd69175d787538"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1b340e76c9bd69175d787538","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cd0b160c82d27b5e657840be48ebfc93df072d932148f6c4415861f3ac877da3","q025-candidate-question:c5267f5181cc7692f3008718"],"scopeContentSha256":"9248e7247eed0410a2a0bfbcfe7eef0f46e6aea8897e02e58dd3b6bc6b6a3f3a","contributionContentSha256":"0cf3db2a3b18d5851c649f3fa265ae14fe7e2e8f1dd6240cd275810292e7ac7a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d53","kind":"description","unitIndex":53,"unitId":"unit:cd0b160c82d27b5e657840be48ebfc93df072d932148f6c4415861f3ac877da3","textSha256":"546c16ead17979912d605b16336c0d6288e5ded1e0559ca06b42c12c790b83a4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1b340e76c9bd69175d787538","recordId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"19f60befde2803cdbd441ecc65e60b29307aa9060cba1b3963c6eca87941057c"},"organizational-access:d053e90c48cf53f88d59d155":{"id":"organizational-access:d053e90c48cf53f88d59d155","source":"q025-candidate-question:e2c4083adb09d23e9f378897","target":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e2c4083adb09d23e9f378897","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c859c270c7ba173162d6065b48e1b35d23eb3af94c9c9e50d14abdf2a453b49d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0000daf9353309109a32b14a"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"5e2d870128fc2bf088bc5ef1add58d06f7fb940950476c4c9faed0dabe9fca8e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c090b529d103b8fbf762a36e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:f41ed6d0fcbff2006396541321a6e19d874a009b1a6b1177adb966994e220469","home":{"unitId":"unit:f41ed6d0fcbff2006396541321a6e19d874a009b1a6b1177adb966994e220469","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e2c4083adb09d23e9f378897","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q8 covers the combined test of a near-zero transition law and its proposed justification of lowest-positive-vacuum weighting.","qualification":"q8 covers the linked test of near-zero decay behavior and its ability to justify lowest-positive-energy weighting. The inherited annotations identify discontinuous suppression as the criticized proposal and continuity under potential shifts as the source's position; this review proves neither claim.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f41ed6d0fcbff2006396541321a6e19d874a009b1a6b1177adb966994e220469","paperId":"hep-th/0603105","textSha256":"a6f600afb87c7f8bed2e33d6ee347fec1a567b177ff1a9052d3aedee1e6ecd55"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0033:u24:q8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0033:u24:q8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f41ed6d0fcbff2006396541321a6e19d874a009b1a6b1177adb966994e220469","q025-candidate-question:e2c4083adb09d23e9f378897"],"scopeContentSha256":"c859c270c7ba173162d6065b48e1b35d23eb3af94c9c9e50d14abdf2a453b49d","placementContentSha256":"b2b871db87d31039eadd17ee62a2520f650924f69a26555bdfc81bfd309f7634","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0033:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0033:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f41ed6d0fcbff2006396541321a6e19d874a009b1a6b1177adb966994e220469","paperId":"hep-th/0603105","textSha256":"a6f600afb87c7f8bed2e33d6ee347fec1a567b177ff1a9052d3aedee1e6ecd55"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0033","unitRef":"u24"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f41ed6d0fcbff2006396541321a6e19d874a009b1a6b1177adb966994e220469","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d76","kind":"description","unitIndex":76,"unitId":"unit:f41ed6d0fcbff2006396541321a6e19d874a009b1a6b1177adb966994e220469","textSha256":"a6f600afb87c7f8bed2e33d6ee347fec1a567b177ff1a9052d3aedee1e6ecd55"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:06b178d5549612e85658c2398b33eda9","paperId":"hep-th/0603105","sourceSha256":"8285fac302626d6f15634ee6d47a73853694c4eb0856011df18f30b302278823","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/afbf8f21734addaf98d6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"96c21621288942ecde034d0e1d1b4dfc08f29df31830117eafaba4d0b71bdef0","pdfPage":2,"start":1296,"end":4694,"textSha256":"30ef091e50834b977db77a3d951ad27ade416d0587aa381d634cfd2245c2e5c4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b6714b4df57535c2a04c6a6040956f46","paperId":"hep-th/0603105","sourceSha256":"8285fac302626d6f15634ee6d47a73853694c4eb0856011df18f30b302278823","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/afbf8f21734addaf98d6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"96c21621288942ecde034d0e1d1b4dfc08f29df31830117eafaba4d0b71bdef0","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"24dbfdf8d1f2a79077d26f3b407e895b72a35f5073f67d8c18ccf2d7ebb5004b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6aa1539740854244a6913c241b09d168","paperId":"hep-th/0603105","sourceSha256":"8285fac302626d6f15634ee6d47a73853694c4eb0856011df18f30b302278823","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/afbf8f21734addaf98d6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"96c21621288942ecde034d0e1d1b4dfc08f29df31830117eafaba4d0b71bdef0","pdfPage":2,"start":2495,"end":5807,"textSha256":"9dd1d36c32c462077d783b20c2b9605c83693bac6b2bc21db155da486986da7e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ec0b8bc19befba20cdfeabe5"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ec0b8bc19befba20cdfeabe5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f41ed6d0fcbff2006396541321a6e19d874a009b1a6b1177adb966994e220469","q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30"],"scopeContentSha256":"5e2d870128fc2bf088bc5ef1add58d06f7fb940950476c4c9faed0dabe9fca8e","contributionContentSha256":"2afe0116096bb06a3911b894580e150ca6904652c2c4fc930e7376aa1510c17c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d76","kind":"description","unitIndex":76,"unitId":"unit:f41ed6d0fcbff2006396541321a6e19d874a009b1a6b1177adb966994e220469","textSha256":"a6f600afb87c7f8bed2e33d6ee347fec1a567b177ff1a9052d3aedee1e6ecd55"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:06b178d5549612e85658c2398b33eda9","paperId":"hep-th/0603105","sourceSha256":"8285fac302626d6f15634ee6d47a73853694c4eb0856011df18f30b302278823","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/afbf8f21734addaf98d6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"96c21621288942ecde034d0e1d1b4dfc08f29df31830117eafaba4d0b71bdef0","pdfPage":2,"start":1296,"end":4694,"textSha256":"30ef091e50834b977db77a3d951ad27ade416d0587aa381d634cfd2245c2e5c4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b6714b4df57535c2a04c6a6040956f46","paperId":"hep-th/0603105","sourceSha256":"8285fac302626d6f15634ee6d47a73853694c4eb0856011df18f30b302278823","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/afbf8f21734addaf98d6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"96c21621288942ecde034d0e1d1b4dfc08f29df31830117eafaba4d0b71bdef0","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"24dbfdf8d1f2a79077d26f3b407e895b72a35f5073f67d8c18ccf2d7ebb5004b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6aa1539740854244a6913c241b09d168","paperId":"hep-th/0603105","sourceSha256":"8285fac302626d6f15634ee6d47a73853694c4eb0856011df18f30b302278823","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/afbf8f21734addaf98d6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"96c21621288942ecde034d0e1d1b4dfc08f29df31830117eafaba4d0b71bdef0","pdfPage":2,"start":2495,"end":5807,"textSha256":"9dd1d36c32c462077d783b20c2b9605c83693bac6b2bc21db155da486986da7e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ec0b8bc19befba20cdfeabe5","recordId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound rate-continuity and measure questions. The source argues against the historical discontinuous-suppression proposal; it does not adopt that proposal.","challengeNote":"Compound rate-continuity and measure questions. Discontinuous suppression is the criticized proposal; the source argues for continuity under potential shifts.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"dd626d0a0efd8ce2d94f2e088aa29e477681b48893dd613279a5f6c1c821c1d5"},"organizational-access:2a4242b06c5ec4d7f68c07d1":{"id":"organizational-access:2a4242b06c5ec4d7f68c07d1","source":"q025-candidate-question:e375e3a777fbccf230745197","target":"q025-candidate-question:6ac02a667323a234d6246b3f","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e375e3a777fbccf230745197","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b8690d50ae925a10733b1c0ed0093ad211a7ab9a281f6602efd807466a69051e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6b9395b19a6c8832d154028f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6ac02a667323a234d6246b3f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"78bf7f471c1adaf6c27bee6e9d9d8119f1ee41f17bd8a6b454a6a0b29d7a4d31","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5d247ad98bdc316b1e17b54a"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","home":{"unitId":"unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e375e3a777fbccf230745197","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":0.5,"reason":"Covers inverse reconstruction from a(t) for both canonical and other specified homogeneous scalar backgrounds, including the tachyonic alternative.","qualification":"Canonical and tachyonic reconstructions are alternatives and string viability remains open. Exact full challenge coverage and source-local qualifications remain binding. Weights are organizational allocation, not confidence or physical importance.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","paperId":"hep-th/0204150","textSha256":"afd0795a9e2e19594ae4cef73ab21eaf024b41881d89541ded920d362f0a3ac1"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0057:u26:q16","coverageMode":"explicit_compound_union","targetCoverage":[{"sourceSpan":"How can a prescribed expansion history a(t) determine a canonical or tachyonic scalar potential","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:e375e3a777fbccf230745197"],"explanation":"Both alternative inverse reconstructions fit q16; they are not combined into one scalar action."},{"sourceSpan":"and under what unresolved string-theoretic conditions could a tachyon condensate produce late accelerated expansion?","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef"],"explanation":"q9 covers the conditional string-inspired consistency and open-application target without asserting that the required conditions are satisfied."}],"coverageReason":"q16 covers both alternative reconstructions; q9 covers the unresolved string-theoretic conditions on the tachyon application. q16 alone lacks the string-consistency target, q9 lacks the complete inverse problem, and q8 lacks the canonical reconstruction alternative. No supplied single home covers all parts. The union preserves one source question and keeps the string conditions open."},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0057:u26:q16","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","q025-candidate-question:e375e3a777fbccf230745197"],"scopeContentSha256":"b8690d50ae925a10733b1c0ed0093ad211a7ab9a281f6602efd807466a69051e","placementContentSha256":"78aca24da2fa7df11b4d77a942a94cbcb5d5b68fd72635eb8e2f6b31daca7891","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0057:proposal","explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0057:challenge","root:explicit-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","paperId":"hep-th/0204150","textSha256":"afd0795a9e2e19594ae4cef73ab21eaf024b41881d89541ded920d362f0a3ac1"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"45cd7c1d060cb6f2fd1d8a4ace5cca7c3d64df235a869afc4ce7e31b2e6badfb"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0057","unitRef":"u26"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6ac02a667323a234d6246b3f","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d96","kind":"description","unitIndex":96,"unitId":"unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","textSha256":"afd0795a9e2e19594ae4cef73ab21eaf024b41881d89541ded920d362f0a3ac1"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:54eb0e69c61e02ab4bdfdb85"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:54eb0e69c61e02ab4bdfdb85","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","q025-candidate-question:6ac02a667323a234d6246b3f"],"scopeContentSha256":"78bf7f471c1adaf6c27bee6e9d9d8119f1ee41f17bd8a6b454a6a0b29d7a4d31","contributionContentSha256":"91a67b0e2bc07aa663dcdfeeebea3939ef3234a82f75aff56ad2fe05824e7f00","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d96","kind":"description","unitIndex":96,"unitId":"unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","textSha256":"afd0795a9e2e19594ae4cef73ab21eaf024b41881d89541ded920d362f0a3ac1"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:54eb0e69c61e02ab4bdfdb85","recordId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound reconstruction and unresolved string/tachyon viability targets; canonical and tachyonic reconstructions are alternatives.","challengeNote":"Canonical/tachyonic reconstruction alternatives and unresolved string conditions are distinct contributions of a compound source question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"abc31280546927f4c181ed29440821483d1b2169c31818292f9870be7ab4adad"},"organizational-access:716b3955ca9b879cd2b90d35":{"id":"organizational-access:716b3955ca9b879cd2b90d35","source":"q025-candidate-question:f23ce27773b0d5af5ed5ce55","target":"q025-candidate-question:690548efb26af1f935d2d594","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f23ce27773b0d5af5ed5ce55","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"eac2f79694fc95787a5cf9d64d551fefd5a831efeb40e79d7bc52245dd4da3d3","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:785779be1d2f7f4f8981f332"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:690548efb26af1f935d2d594","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"489b80fcc4b3ac5c7d49acd17445b3b681dc50e87397e7ee32290d805f529a21","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:a16b977bd19f1ad08ddc3063"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:ec7b75f28f2cecdefc1b075782c1b877b39e51a02b063d8be45c5ba384f38ca1","home":{"unitId":"unit:ec7b75f28f2cecdefc1b075782c1b877b39e51a02b063d8be45c5ba384f38ca1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f23ce27773b0d5af5ed5ce55","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers DESI-era CPL interpretation and reassessment of hilltop-fit claims.","qualification":"q21 directly covers interpreting DESI contours with physical scalar models and reassessing hilltop-fit claims through an appropriate CPL mapping. The earlier fit remains a proposition under review, not an accepted or rejected result.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ec7b75f28f2cecdefc1b075782c1b877b39e51a02b063d8be45c5ba384f38ca1","paperId":"2505.18937","textSha256":"9550966e3dadf64ca7ab9c8ee321dd531ba225d718ff2d666c9624d37bacc6e3"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0064:u17:q21"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0064:u17:q21","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ec7b75f28f2cecdefc1b075782c1b877b39e51a02b063d8be45c5ba384f38ca1","q025-candidate-question:f23ce27773b0d5af5ed5ce55"],"scopeContentSha256":"eac2f79694fc95787a5cf9d64d551fefd5a831efeb40e79d7bc52245dd4da3d3","placementContentSha256":"8ed5d29d4d5b841e29292966f08e6fc4ed87a54bc5d4c805be8e100b0697173b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0064:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0064:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ec7b75f28f2cecdefc1b075782c1b877b39e51a02b063d8be45c5ba384f38ca1","paperId":"2505.18937","textSha256":"9550966e3dadf64ca7ab9c8ee321dd531ba225d718ff2d666c9624d37bacc6e3"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0064","unitRef":"u17"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ec7b75f28f2cecdefc1b075782c1b877b39e51a02b063d8be45c5ba384f38ca1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:690548efb26af1f935d2d594","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:ec7b75f28f2cecdefc1b075782c1b877b39e51a02b063d8be45c5ba384f38ca1","textSha256":"9550966e3dadf64ca7ab9c8ee321dd531ba225d718ff2d666c9624d37bacc6e3"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a1d0c84032bcb414309ff800"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a1d0c84032bcb414309ff800","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ec7b75f28f2cecdefc1b075782c1b877b39e51a02b063d8be45c5ba384f38ca1","q025-candidate-question:690548efb26af1f935d2d594"],"scopeContentSha256":"489b80fcc4b3ac5c7d49acd17445b3b681dc50e87397e7ee32290d805f529a21","contributionContentSha256":"5898fa4b2569799755296d6de42aafa77417bfc3b5d03718b2d68df2878c5678","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-496f2098d49aa45afa29-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-496f2098d49aa45afa29-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-496f2098d49aa45afa29-proposal","leaf-496f2098d49aa45afa29-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:ec7b75f28f2cecdefc1b075782c1b877b39e51a02b063d8be45c5ba384f38ca1","textSha256":"9550966e3dadf64ca7ab9c8ee321dd531ba225d718ff2d666c9624d37bacc6e3"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a1d0c84032bcb414309ff800","recordId":"leaf-496f2098d49aa45afa29-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-496f2098d49aa45afa29-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-496f2098d49aa45afa29-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The earlier excellent hilltop fit is the claim under reassessment; neither its acceptance nor rejection is supplied.","challengeNote":"The earlier excellent-hilltop-fit claim is under reassessment; its acceptance or rejection is not supplied.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ee9d0252c33058a277a2c3d118448052bfef655bbc8d791766f41a35f85ffe6a"},"organizational-access:a8923000eff8b0bdbb10f180":{"id":"organizational-access:a8923000eff8b0bdbb10f180","source":"q025-candidate-question:f6c6a73697bbafc4c42632f0","target":"q025-candidate-question:3035b20700f5f847ecc68840","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f6c6a73697bbafc4c42632f0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"04a17ed0e1dfe8929843cb8fa6730fc7e5f52e40b29ab74bb26a5f0b7a907f51","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:184bb27b2076496eeae61c09"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3035b20700f5f847ecc68840","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6cde9e361e15464fb882cf97988721d51852efb48038c924e4118bd59c06ba8b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:cd6c06db87be3e6d7873d9b0"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5dffb3078285b9d2cf69d6df42980a10fe8c4c6e54c4d8f8300e7d1751aeb62f","home":{"unitId":"unit:5dffb3078285b9d2cf69d6df42980a10fe8c4c6e54c4d8f8300e7d1751aeb62f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f6c6a73697bbafc4c42632f0","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Directly covers thermal phase transitions and the dominance condition for a candidate branch.","qualification":"q16 includes associated gauge phases, thermal transitions and the explicit requirement that a candidate branch dominate. It covers both the coincidence/order of confinement and chiral restoration and the proposed separating branch. Existence of that branch alone does not settle the transition.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5dffb3078285b9d2cf69d6df42980a10fe8c4c6e54c4d8f8300e7d1751aeb62f","paperId":"1809.06861","textSha256":"3690e8274d7c17d608aaa19f8a63e6887c7233e2a98895525fa4b4fa166a5501"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0007:u16:q16"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0007:u16:q16","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5dffb3078285b9d2cf69d6df42980a10fe8c4c6e54c4d8f8300e7d1751aeb62f","q025-candidate-question:f6c6a73697bbafc4c42632f0"],"scopeContentSha256":"04a17ed0e1dfe8929843cb8fa6730fc7e5f52e40b29ab74bb26a5f0b7a907f51","placementContentSha256":"c507ad212aa3d44f37b664754bbea69acc289432262b5cc63819baec7f481a97","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0007:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0007:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5dffb3078285b9d2cf69d6df42980a10fe8c4c6e54c4d8f8300e7d1751aeb62f","paperId":"1809.06861","textSha256":"3690e8274d7c17d608aaa19f8a63e6887c7233e2a98895525fa4b4fa166a5501"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0007","unitRef":"u16"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5dffb3078285b9d2cf69d6df42980a10fe8c4c6e54c4d8f8300e7d1751aeb62f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3035b20700f5f847ecc68840","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:5dffb3078285b9d2cf69d6df42980a10fe8c4c6e54c4d8f8300e7d1751aeb62f","textSha256":"3690e8274d7c17d608aaa19f8a63e6887c7233e2a98895525fa4b4fa166a5501"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e4f2fc950443ef55de400231"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e4f2fc950443ef55de400231","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5dffb3078285b9d2cf69d6df42980a10fe8c4c6e54c4d8f8300e7d1751aeb62f","q025-candidate-question:3035b20700f5f847ecc68840"],"scopeContentSha256":"6cde9e361e15464fb882cf97988721d51852efb48038c924e4118bd59c06ba8b","contributionContentSha256":"0574fb19ff1143d6125214a78b2314330c616f4f5b89bf700010e22047ee49ed","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-83f6f5397e92d26dec7e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-83f6f5397e92d26dec7e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-83f6f5397e92d26dec7e-proposal","leaf-83f6f5397e92d26dec7e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:5dffb3078285b9d2cf69d6df42980a10fe8c4c6e54c4d8f8300e7d1751aeb62f","textSha256":"3690e8274d7c17d608aaa19f8a63e6887c7233e2a98895525fa4b4fa166a5501"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e4f2fc950443ef55de400231","recordId":"leaf-83f6f5397e92d26dec7e-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-83f6f5397e92d26dec7e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-83f6f5397e92d26dec7e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The target is thermal phase ordering; a chirally broken deconfined branch matters only if dominant.","challengeNote":"Thermal phase ordering is the target; a chirally broken deconfined branch matters only if dominant.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"9c2636cae5cd71e9bc025425ccdce967efd7bb946f3b0be384cf54d2ef5feba6"},"organizational-access:9a4aa6391a9b457fde1636c8":{"id":"organizational-access:9a4aa6391a9b457fde1636c8","source":"q025-candidate-question:f844cc9f0ab6bd558e073eaf","target":"q025-candidate-question:c01050ef5b783440c6387ba7","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f844cc9f0ab6bd558e073eaf","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c307050c3e041ccc68c46c606b28d36c86908eda8f42c3e8a886f74276c7e4af","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b71b673ce15994d270194d52"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c01050ef5b783440c6387ba7","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"11cef13619ecf01d6f8cfb497ba01cec86f5d1d357eba88b7f1806cba145e8bd","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e4be432b1e808607b531c3a0"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe","home":{"unitId":"unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f844cc9f0ab6bd558e073eaf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly includes warm inflation, radiation-separated stages and conditional field-range, potential and censorship tests.","qualification":"q9 specifically includes radiation-separated warm stages, primordial spectra, energy bounds and conditional field-range, potential and censorship criteria. Single-stage bounds, staged histories and relaxing censorship for later stages remain separate conditional cases. Thermal sourcing alone supplies no exemption.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe","paperId":"1910.10516","textSha256":"dcf05b6f58993ba89942fbd0068f54fd3a81161040feb4a753333341b672bd11"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0001:u12:q9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0001:u12:q9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe","q025-candidate-question:f844cc9f0ab6bd558e073eaf"],"scopeContentSha256":"c307050c3e041ccc68c46c606b28d36c86908eda8f42c3e8a886f74276c7e4af","placementContentSha256":"214abd2339628ada0e5f49e1467eed0cc7931904a896b26db465677a31e4b5a5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0001:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0001:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe","paperId":"1910.10516","textSha256":"dcf05b6f58993ba89942fbd0068f54fd3a81161040feb4a753333341b672bd11"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0001","unitRef":"u12"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c01050ef5b783440c6387ba7","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe","textSha256":"dcf05b6f58993ba89942fbd0068f54fd3a81161040feb4a753333341b672bd11"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0b907c2abff758adab3e333414f53440","paperId":"1910.10516","sourceSha256":"d871753c87bd760a3960cd6eca04cd773bdb5b5a47b2c4a6762b8bb6ed36e841","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/021a09704aef4745733c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e0d67fdc581e3922a4dffcc9dcafff78aefeed390de01fe5f0c0e85947bf61a","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":3506,"textSha256":"ff5ffe561103ebfb16bc346e776b3e2c878a6efb0e5fbb3e74d339affbd831dd","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a95aa138f5d6b40d14305cbf73298ac3","paperId":"1910.10516","sourceSha256":"d871753c87bd760a3960cd6eca04cd773bdb5b5a47b2c4a6762b8bb6ed36e841","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/021a09704aef4745733c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e0d67fdc581e3922a4dffcc9dcafff78aefeed390de01fe5f0c0e85947bf61a","pdfPage":1,"start":2495,"end":5500,"textSha256":"16e7bdfd0c825efdc23662cd438687b997d06815c1f8ca2ffb957df6baac22b6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8922b0d119618aa9b2994a3e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8922b0d119618aa9b2994a3e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe","q025-candidate-question:c01050ef5b783440c6387ba7"],"scopeContentSha256":"11cef13619ecf01d6f8cfb497ba01cec86f5d1d357eba88b7f1806cba145e8bd","contributionContentSha256":"d6dc80c93c9ad47ddc43a79e90e13b7119d4dc8d4f6b18adbee2c44d5869389a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe","textSha256":"dcf05b6f58993ba89942fbd0068f54fd3a81161040feb4a753333341b672bd11"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0b907c2abff758adab3e333414f53440","paperId":"1910.10516","sourceSha256":"d871753c87bd760a3960cd6eca04cd773bdb5b5a47b2c4a6762b8bb6ed36e841","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/021a09704aef4745733c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e0d67fdc581e3922a4dffcc9dcafff78aefeed390de01fe5f0c0e85947bf61a","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":3506,"textSha256":"ff5ffe561103ebfb16bc346e776b3e2c878a6efb0e5fbb3e74d339affbd831dd","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a95aa138f5d6b40d14305cbf73298ac3","paperId":"1910.10516","sourceSha256":"d871753c87bd760a3960cd6eca04cd773bdb5b5a47b2c4a6762b8bb6ed36e841","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/021a09704aef4745733c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e0d67fdc581e3922a4dffcc9dcafff78aefeed390de01fe5f0c0e85947bf61a","pdfPage":1,"start":2495,"end":5500,"textSha256":"16e7bdfd0c825efdc23662cd438687b997d06815c1f8ca2ffb957df6baac22b6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8922b0d119618aa9b2994a3e","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Thermal perturbations do not exempt the source's warm scenario from TCC. Relaxing TCC for later stages is a separate option from imposing it throughout.","challengeNote":"Thermal perturbations provide no automatic TCC exemption. Relaxing TCC for later stages is a separate prescription.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"38b4055fb22a5a8fdda3a51ef91bc2c3ddbcb3bc11b41495c0a661a3ff7f9423"},"organizational-access:fed88dd56ad46f000b250307":{"id":"organizational-access:fed88dd56ad46f000b250307","source":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","target":"q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:924fe997fc8f49068b91d181"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e030c5f828eed826766a5a0e2db4b052b6a43e19b5c358607b0f436632bff301","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:107ce5b351e31a0b42385698"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","home":{"unitId":"unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","paperId":"2005.01515","textSha256":"098a40597fce8b1f0ffc67b95294f02ef90a5023d56722c3193b4241aa859fe6"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d3ad84c1c53a552bf0e3f61f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d3ad84c1c53a552bf0e3f61f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"2c950317f830b5b7e410e61a64d02a678fb89cd779dcfc946b07cc8a11733889","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","paperId":"2005.01515","textSha256":"098a40597fce8b1f0ffc67b95294f02ef90a5023d56722c3193b4241aa859fe6"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d3ad84c1c53a552bf0e3f61f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","textSha256":"098a40597fce8b1f0ffc67b95294f02ef90a5023d56722c3193b4241aa859fe6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:34921186e5ed05364641b2ce","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound theoretical and experimental review of massless and massive cases, not one interaction mechanism. Independent challenge qualification: Compound theoretical and experimental review; massless and massive cases remain alternatives."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:34921186e5ed05364641b2ce","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e030c5f828eed826766a5a0e2db4b052b6a43e19b5c358607b0f436632bff301","contributionContentSha256":"accfe657be3b140ef6a9c168a0fce0259a9d7dc5de4a33cd99a97f1943f170a0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","textSha256":"098a40597fce8b1f0ffc67b95294f02ef90a5023d56722c3193b4241aa859fe6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:34921186e5ed05364641b2ce","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound theoretical and experimental review of massless and massive cases, not one interaction mechanism.","challengeNote":"Compound theoretical and experimental review; massless and massive cases remain alternatives.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","home":{"unitId":"unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","paperId":"1103.4556","textSha256":"0f73eecb3f80234af71138127d86c1257886fe7ef0b2596dfd93a2bd4bf0e873"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6208b5c7d974740bd7ec0c27"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6208b5c7d974740bd7ec0c27","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"50c51d17f201ef4bbb92840793f451f183f6adc018dc321d748e05ea4bbfdec0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","paperId":"1103.4556","textSha256":"0f73eecb3f80234af71138127d86c1257886fe7ef0b2596dfd93a2bd4bf0e873"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6208b5c7d974740bd7ec0c27"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","textSha256":"0f73eecb3f80234af71138127d86c1257886fe7ef0b2596dfd93a2bd4bf0e873"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:efe3ba723b4fcfce252a49d8","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Combines MeV-to-TeV phenomenological constraints with ultraviolet motivation. Independent challenge qualification: Compound MeV-to-TeV constraints and ultraviolet model-building targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:efe3ba723b4fcfce252a49d8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e030c5f828eed826766a5a0e2db4b052b6a43e19b5c358607b0f436632bff301","contributionContentSha256":"5dce5a262841d53bf6439a254a7c165c2be215930121c04a6fcd7474a317aa7b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","textSha256":"0f73eecb3f80234af71138127d86c1257886fe7ef0b2596dfd93a2bd4bf0e873"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:efe3ba723b4fcfce252a49d8","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Combines MeV-to-TeV phenomenological constraints with ultraviolet motivation.","challengeNote":"Compound MeV-to-TeV constraints and ultraviolet model-building targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:7b5dde50f1386f1487fd26ba67e585433fd51a8e82d6bb9e15abda97670b5b2d","home":{"unitId":"unit:7b5dde50f1386f1487fd26ba67e585433fd51a8e82d6bb9e15abda97670b5b2d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Combines massless hidden-U(1) construction and parameter questions with the cosmological role and survival of related charged matter.","qualification":"q18 covers unification, hidden-parameter dependence and stable minicharged dark matter together. q16 directly covers the construction branch; q5's bosonic matter restriction is not established for this source.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7b5dde50f1386f1487fd26ba67e585433fd51a8e82d6bb9e15abda97670b5b2d","paperId":"1610.00631","textSha256":"52cfc31e1e4e4e0736cc8167adb2a985a3d49314760076a8b6f916eba212df3f"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0020:u4:q18"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0020:u4:q18","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7b5dde50f1386f1487fd26ba67e585433fd51a8e82d6bb9e15abda97670b5b2d","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"1c3b74b06cb7ec6010bb0127d388bd229b113edd37bcb7bf5cfa7c4227905d32","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0020:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0020:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7b5dde50f1386f1487fd26ba67e585433fd51a8e82d6bb9e15abda97670b5b2d","paperId":"1610.00631","textSha256":"52cfc31e1e4e4e0736cc8167adb2a985a3d49314760076a8b6f916eba212df3f"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0020","unitRef":"u4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7b5dde50f1386f1487fd26ba67e585433fd51a8e82d6bb9e15abda97670b5b2d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:7b5dde50f1386f1487fd26ba67e585433fd51a8e82d6bb9e15abda97670b5b2d","textSha256":"52cfc31e1e4e4e0736cc8167adb2a985a3d49314760076a8b6f916eba212df3f"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a462c2b35d220cecc1fe6f26a8cb71a8","paperId":"1610.00631","sourceSha256":"52bacc3c9c9873b2a413de04c02e213f40ad258854f491779dd2990829375fb8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/712cfda2f0e27e6e3428/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f06531ee18fac07a519c1d25357b76987a85128dfc15437adc65b7267d647ab3","pdfPage":2,"start":1291,"end":3922,"textSha256":"0d01ad00ef250dcc59a346f22a22aa8fef31901442cd60d3452e41a4de97a28b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d751ecae9d4e46ec9e2b3a62b98c0055","paperId":"1610.00631","sourceSha256":"52bacc3c9c9873b2a413de04c02e213f40ad258854f491779dd2990829375fb8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/712cfda2f0e27e6e3428/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f06531ee18fac07a519c1d25357b76987a85128dfc15437adc65b7267d647ab3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1317,"textSha256":"3da6d2b4fe7243a4be196caa69938d1043276cef0f4e86acd4e71eddb661175a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:602e4b1ba7e8dc1323a1e419","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound unification and dark-matter targets; large mixing and tiny hidden coupling play different roles. Independent challenge qualification: Compound unification and dark-matter targets. Changed p2 to boundary: the excerpts do not identify its stable matter as bosonic. Large mixing and tiny hidden-gA"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:602e4b1ba7e8dc1323a1e419","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7b5dde50f1386f1487fd26ba67e585433fd51a8e82d6bb9e15abda97670b5b2d","q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e030c5f828eed826766a5a0e2db4b052b6a43e19b5c358607b0f436632bff301","contributionContentSha256":"bae608effcd41d2ecd550f4fc0c6b9151bac7fb2d4cdcb048a83c9439e6ee3e5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:7b5dde50f1386f1487fd26ba67e585433fd51a8e82d6bb9e15abda97670b5b2d","textSha256":"52cfc31e1e4e4e0736cc8167adb2a985a3d49314760076a8b6f916eba212df3f"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a462c2b35d220cecc1fe6f26a8cb71a8","paperId":"1610.00631","sourceSha256":"52bacc3c9c9873b2a413de04c02e213f40ad258854f491779dd2990829375fb8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/712cfda2f0e27e6e3428/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f06531ee18fac07a519c1d25357b76987a85128dfc15437adc65b7267d647ab3","pdfPage":2,"start":1291,"end":3922,"textSha256":"0d01ad00ef250dcc59a346f22a22aa8fef31901442cd60d3452e41a4de97a28b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d751ecae9d4e46ec9e2b3a62b98c0055","paperId":"1610.00631","sourceSha256":"52bacc3c9c9873b2a413de04c02e213f40ad258854f491779dd2990829375fb8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/712cfda2f0e27e6e3428/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f06531ee18fac07a519c1d25357b76987a85128dfc15437adc65b7267d647ab3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1317,"textSha256":"3da6d2b4fe7243a4be196caa69938d1043276cef0f4e86acd4e71eddb661175a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:602e4b1ba7e8dc1323a1e419","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound unification and dark-matter targets; large mixing and tiny hidden coupling play different roles.","challengeNote":"Compound unification and dark-matter targets. Changed p2 to boundary: the excerpts do not identify its stable matter as bosonic. Large mixing and tiny hidden-gA","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","home":{"unitId":"unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","paperId":"2405.08534","textSha256":"f4ec3bc74ecb02982e21c24f0524414ccc9a3011faa29781aeb11a7e2b2d92e5"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:84b5500fef2e1adc1e6bb3e8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:84b5500fef2e1adc1e6bb3e8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"3b3f13b5f70a73553c3d1d72409f10f82b0a9d82c5e5afe5086e8b6910b9d665","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","paperId":"2405.08534","textSha256":"f4ec3bc74ecb02982e21c24f0524414ccc9a3011faa29781aeb11a7e2b2d92e5"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:84b5500fef2e1adc1e6bb3e8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","textSha256":"f4ec3bc74ecb02982e21c24f0524414ccc9a3011faa29781aeb11a7e2b2d92e5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:54b76e9ea9a4538ce6c23be4","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound overview; the description does not identify a particular quantum-gravity conjecture or mass mechanism. Independent challenge qualification: Compound overview; no particular quantum-gravity conjecture or mass mechanism is specified."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:54b76e9ea9a4538ce6c23be4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e030c5f828eed826766a5a0e2db4b052b6a43e19b5c358607b0f436632bff301","contributionContentSha256":"46af6594dc139821e8a931c96fccec6219205d14e8d917cdf486d87e7fb6c76c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","textSha256":"f4ec3bc74ecb02982e21c24f0524414ccc9a3011faa29781aeb11a7e2b2d92e5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:54b76e9ea9a4538ce6c23be4","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound overview; the description does not identify a particular quantum-gravity conjecture or mass mechanism.","challengeNote":"Compound overview; no particular quantum-gravity conjecture or mass mechanism is specified.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","home":{"unitId":"unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","paperId":"2007.02655","textSha256":"bf5ab907a3991c25c4a670ad12fd4b10bb2ebf59eba57c1e1c484077f519e06d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:251d0d394bf3462a329cf25e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:251d0d394bf3462a329cf25e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"69a8662ace1c02f7fad91d0d683d749a8be96315d0b93b67be78746bea114e13","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","paperId":"2007.02655","textSha256":"bf5ab907a3991c25c4a670ad12fd4b10bb2ebf59eba57c1e1c484077f519e06d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:251d0d394bf3462a329cf25e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","textSha256":"bf5ab907a3991c25c4a670ad12fd4b10bb2ebf59eba57c1e1c484077f519e06d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3a9ba548456334fb2f17005d","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Retains both the conditional magnetic-WGC inference and a proposed compactification realization. Independent challenge qualification: Compound conditional magnetic-WGC inference and proposed compactification realization."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3a9ba548456334fb2f17005d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e030c5f828eed826766a5a0e2db4b052b6a43e19b5c358607b0f436632bff301","contributionContentSha256":"b473d0398297173ab631d75ca491ec36bf1e4b9130a4f49095b3950d66c85072","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","textSha256":"bf5ab907a3991c25c4a670ad12fd4b10bb2ebf59eba57c1e1c484077f519e06d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3a9ba548456334fb2f17005d","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Retains both the conditional magnetic-WGC inference and a proposed compactification realization.","challengeNote":"Compound conditional magnetic-WGC inference and proposed compactification realization.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:fd96745cb83a6a50d8656e0b21ea0d9bc11b8aff49f3a7297c7232e33f02c04f","home":{"unitId":"unit:fd96745cb83a6a50d8656e0b21ea0d9bc11b8aff49f3a7297c7232e33f02c04f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fd96745cb83a6a50d8656e0b21ea0d9bc11b8aff49f3a7297c7232e33f02c04f","paperId":"2302.03056","textSha256":"55cb786a2f31c2ac99b43051e6f1d8e2dcad6b695ffa4f4c090c2470442f69ba"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:64adb35463b760d88585fa6e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:64adb35463b760d88585fa6e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fd96745cb83a6a50d8656e0b21ea0d9bc11b8aff49f3a7297c7232e33f02c04f","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"4d89e39ffd9fd9037e13e7b9ca29c0ba588ff86adc34101462f6e4272042535a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fd96745cb83a6a50d8656e0b21ea0d9bc11b8aff49f3a7297c7232e33f02c04f","paperId":"2302.03056","textSha256":"55cb786a2f31c2ac99b43051e6f1d8e2dcad6b695ffa4f4c090c2470442f69ba"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:64adb35463b760d88585fa6e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fd96745cb83a6a50d8656e0b21ea0d9bc11b8aff49f3a7297c7232e33f02c04f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:fd96745cb83a6a50d8656e0b21ea0d9bc11b8aff49f3a7297c7232e33f02c04f","textSha256":"55cb786a2f31c2ac99b43051e6f1d8e2dcad6b695ffa4f4c090c2470442f69ba"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:91a850ca175574632a580325","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound early production, later scalar signals and naturalness targets; portal activity decreases with time. Independent challenge qualification: Changed p2 to boundary: the produced dark-matter species is unspecified. Compound early production, later scalar signals and naturalness targets remain; the p"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:91a850ca175574632a580325","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fd96745cb83a6a50d8656e0b21ea0d9bc11b8aff49f3a7297c7232e33f02c04f","q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e030c5f828eed826766a5a0e2db4b052b6a43e19b5c358607b0f436632bff301","contributionContentSha256":"71e5f37704b6f62f6629972d149e2b06d00395380ad5d1555c1dc2aa550bc0eb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:fd96745cb83a6a50d8656e0b21ea0d9bc11b8aff49f3a7297c7232e33f02c04f","textSha256":"55cb786a2f31c2ac99b43051e6f1d8e2dcad6b695ffa4f4c090c2470442f69ba"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:91a850ca175574632a580325","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound early production, later scalar signals and naturalness targets; portal activity decreases with time.","challengeNote":"Changed p2 to boundary: the produced dark-matter species is unspecified. Compound early production, later scalar signals and naturalness targets remain; the p","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":6,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"1536768cc03d09c36c651c4eff3648f495f4907979b6607a084917b5e5cea632"},"organizational-access:5dda0cf58a4e62b01383ca4a":{"id":"organizational-access:5dda0cf58a4e62b01383ca4a","source":"q025-candidate-region:0c603fa5159ab39094554a1f","target":"q025-candidate-question:4592028a976cb6e398ae76a2","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:0c603fa5159ab39094554a1f","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"2abb367532aabbbca54d73d3e43bb30332b0c210d1c612fcc1464e8aa1ebff32","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2abedcab33c631b9bac17a3b"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:4592028a976cb6e398ae76a2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"3b074e7dd20c6292ee5e4149039babdf95f7b2e99f119cdb9e4b5317fe9f4598","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d515b170eb2f03ecc3305803"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","home":{"unitId":"unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0c603fa5159ab39094554a1f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","paperId":"2102.05550","textSha256":"b06da6c33f848b4586d90c72d2e2259e5b7ffb5b02e946555a251a57805df938"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5a8b5c065527f98d61b9fbc6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5a8b5c065527f98d61b9fbc6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","q025-candidate-region:0c603fa5159ab39094554a1f"],"scopeContentSha256":"2abb367532aabbbca54d73d3e43bb30332b0c210d1c612fcc1464e8aa1ebff32","placementContentSha256":"eea8829e0fb9e3956c0e5560b4da3a65524754d2ecd42679032d2d2870f65397","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-challenge","leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","paperId":"2102.05550","textSha256":"b06da6c33f848b4586d90c72d2e2259e5b7ffb5b02e946555a251a57805df938"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5a8b5c065527f98d61b9fbc6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4592028a976cb6e398ae76a2","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","textSha256":"b06da6c33f848b4586d90c72d2e2259e5b7ffb5b02e946555a251a57805df938"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:37717882cf212d3c5d505130"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:37717882cf212d3c5d505130","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","q025-candidate-question:4592028a976cb6e398ae76a2"],"scopeContentSha256":"3b074e7dd20c6292ee5e4149039babdf95f7b2e99f119cdb9e4b5317fe9f4598","contributionContentSha256":"566ce6ea2f1e85e08965a24b3084602687e7c93120696f6e3524065e420ff93f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-proposal","leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","textSha256":"b06da6c33f848b4586d90c72d2e2259e5b7ffb5b02e946555a251a57805df938"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:37717882cf212d3c5d505130","recordId":"leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound background and dimensional-release question extracted from a setting.","challengeNote":"Compound background-persistence and dimensional-release question extracted from a setting.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"3216f1be5b88739fcdbb972d3f9d6d6afd186a4af59cb2b42d3716dad5f386e9"},"organizational-access:521536d6c71768dfa764a096":{"id":"organizational-access:521536d6c71768dfa764a096","source":"q025-candidate-region:1be95b360ae1e67db1740fe6","target":"q025-candidate-question:e3f30f854573155119688234","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:1be95b360ae1e67db1740fe6","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"607680562d8b7d901e873cedd67b88d5ad42c04e34fcf609d5a42f9a9efaee2f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:103b6a6f75c3dbb11baef3a4"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e3f30f854573155119688234","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"34fa4656de2febee673ef6f2480ac81e4666168d11e234073f4f64b376ae51d7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8b3388e2d7a18205809b2665"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","home":{"unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:1be95b360ae1e67db1740fe6","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines universal consistent reduction, massive-mode retention, resulting four-dimensional gaugings, AdS vacua and subtruncations within the compactification family.","qualification":"Whole composite supergravity target; retain every stated branch and no universal stability conclusion.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","paperId":"1110.5327","textSha256":"e8ec3115be3c89d2a146767159855bae9b1142fe39ddf3d3f3e513dc23a14b54"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-03:placement-continuation-0019:u16:q19"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-03:placement-continuation-0019:u16:q19","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","q025-candidate-region:1be95b360ae1e67db1740fe6"],"scopeContentSha256":"607680562d8b7d901e873cedd67b88d5ad42c04e34fcf609d5a42f9a9efaee2f","placementContentSha256":"5f47063a4adae5f6b493872c02298112c902cd7e29613a8238b73bbe92985917","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-03:placement-continuation-0019:proposal","explicit-cut-03:placement-continuation-0019:challenge","root:explicit-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","paperId":"1110.5327","textSha256":"e8ec3115be3c89d2a146767159855bae9b1142fe39ddf3d3f3e513dc23a14b54"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-03/admission.json","sha256":"5b6b7da34396186993a8ef61e55aeed43d5e0f46a341da8375feb2433acaa490"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/exception-intake.json","sha256":"e2c8feedca7ab901585b3a3f046fa6900d1fb60eec30b2dd8f668d09a2d15a7b","bytes":7068293,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0019","unitRef":"u16"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e3f30f854573155119688234","role":"instantiates","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","textSha256":"e8ec3115be3c89d2a146767159855bae9b1142fe39ddf3d3f3e513dc23a14b54"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6b882f14aa0fee0255fcd78389923d79","paperId":"1110.5327","sourceSha256":"9184e818255a65d7b1406131f22d6ad3403ac3a5c602bd2f92ef41ee3bd3ffbf","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/608fb7156331e4d391cc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cccd33f78cc8f00023c856030ea86f1c8c7e5f08d529e5334bb3e66098ba4bc1","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0a4b6318d33420e969e6d4e3dbaa8e9d240da4623bed9cbabe0d904b37a67ea4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:713fb9d19de3f8626604bd641933ade0","paperId":"1110.5327","sourceSha256":"9184e818255a65d7b1406131f22d6ad3403ac3a5c602bd2f92ef41ee3bd3ffbf","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/608fb7156331e4d391cc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cccd33f78cc8f00023c856030ea86f1c8c7e5f08d529e5334bb3e66098ba4bc1","pdfPage":4,"start":100,"end":3276,"textSha256":"5da4b22d451e773319b957580e5845978c81f858b957c2862c4ea4d03990a1e9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ede3c5d9cb8dc7cc3eec906f06e82441","paperId":"1110.5327","sourceSha256":"9184e818255a65d7b1406131f22d6ad3403ac3a5c602bd2f92ef41ee3bd3ffbf","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/608fb7156331e4d391cc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cccd33f78cc8f00023c856030ea86f1c8c7e5f08d529e5334bb3e66098ba4bc1","pdfPage":5,"start":1286,"end":3259,"textSha256":"a3193af96851740109191b938a2ec8bf1db545e60161be3a2ec050e034925d1a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7c9a7216c8bca0a7103fb573"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7c9a7216c8bca0a7103fb573","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","q025-candidate-question:e3f30f854573155119688234"],"scopeContentSha256":"34fa4656de2febee673ef6f2480ac81e4666168d11e234073f4f64b376ae51d7","contributionContentSha256":"817bb1db91ad45592c3f2239a1ab1c55d30d315840cfaeca6190d4c04a9943d6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","textSha256":"e8ec3115be3c89d2a146767159855bae9b1142fe39ddf3d3f3e513dc23a14b54"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6b882f14aa0fee0255fcd78389923d79","paperId":"1110.5327","sourceSha256":"9184e818255a65d7b1406131f22d6ad3403ac3a5c602bd2f92ef41ee3bd3ffbf","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/608fb7156331e4d391cc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cccd33f78cc8f00023c856030ea86f1c8c7e5f08d529e5334bb3e66098ba4bc1","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0a4b6318d33420e969e6d4e3dbaa8e9d240da4623bed9cbabe0d904b37a67ea4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:713fb9d19de3f8626604bd641933ade0","paperId":"1110.5327","sourceSha256":"9184e818255a65d7b1406131f22d6ad3403ac3a5c602bd2f92ef41ee3bd3ffbf","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/608fb7156331e4d391cc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cccd33f78cc8f00023c856030ea86f1c8c7e5f08d529e5334bb3e66098ba4bc1","pdfPage":4,"start":100,"end":3276,"textSha256":"5da4b22d451e773319b957580e5845978c81f858b957c2862c4ea4d03990a1e9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ede3c5d9cb8dc7cc3eec906f06e82441","paperId":"1110.5327","sourceSha256":"9184e818255a65d7b1406131f22d6ad3403ac3a5c602bd2f92ef41ee3bd3ffbf","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/608fb7156331e4d391cc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cccd33f78cc8f00023c856030ea86f1c8c7e5f08d529e5334bb3e66098ba4bc1","pdfPage":5,"start":1286,"end":3259,"textSha256":"a3193af96851740109191b938a2ec8bf1db545e60161be3a2ec050e034925d1a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7c9a7216c8bca0a7103fb573","recordId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Universal truncation, vacua and subtruncations are distinct targets; distinguish the retained N=4 theory from its N=3 vacuum.","challengeNote":"Truncation, vacua and subtruncations are distinct targets. The retained N=4 theory differs from its N=3 vacuum; the source reports a specific Pope–Warner ins","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"8b1fc8dacdd010ce4b090f006ada150622ddbddb79e9fc47b07f51b9c0cc550f"},"organizational-access:cb72becd99105911c805094d":{"id":"organizational-access:cb72becd99105911c805094d","source":"q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a","target":"q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"3726e09093e830087c1d743d7925875e25b4f96b620eb3b8357ffec79dba2269","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c4d55bbe6aadd5783251d571"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f182d2957140a3f44bdc7c0c469ec4c0b69768b439470a47b36d261656eee304","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2d91b98abf949cd418ef9d0e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:07721cd2784be6b8d946ab995bc34115fe06c00c8c11756b914148a9a1d29256","home":{"unitId":"unit:07721cd2784be6b8d946ab995bc34115fe06c00c8c11756b914148a9a1d29256","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers compactification-dependent superstring survival and astronomical tests of origin, tension and network properties.","qualification":"q12 covers formation, compactification and stability conditions together with astronomical origin discrimination and parameter inference. Shared scope does not establish equivalence with other broad viability questions.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:07721cd2784be6b8d946ab995bc34115fe06c00c8c11756b914148a9a1d29256","paperId":"1105.0207","textSha256":"3c690fa43ad47cdd3e42d6471f0b4f591df046a20bb0ef2f980f105cb31f9def"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0061:u10:q12"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0061:u10:q12","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:07721cd2784be6b8d946ab995bc34115fe06c00c8c11756b914148a9a1d29256","q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a"],"scopeContentSha256":"3726e09093e830087c1d743d7925875e25b4f96b620eb3b8357ffec79dba2269","placementContentSha256":"d30508cbe152abff34ecd58b2a918e2e82d1cc89f07aa60932dc1e681bc5bfe6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0061:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0061:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:07721cd2784be6b8d946ab995bc34115fe06c00c8c11756b914148a9a1d29256","paperId":"1105.0207","textSha256":"3c690fa43ad47cdd3e42d6471f0b4f591df046a20bb0ef2f980f105cb31f9def"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0061","unitRef":"u10"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:07721cd2784be6b8d946ab995bc34115fe06c00c8c11756b914148a9a1d29256","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:07721cd2784be6b8d946ab995bc34115fe06c00c8c11756b914148a9a1d29256","textSha256":"3c690fa43ad47cdd3e42d6471f0b4f591df046a20bb0ef2f980f105cb31f9def"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:522ed8f3ea76d5a3a0eaf610","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound survival and astronomical-diagnostics scope; equivalence with other broad viability questions is unestablished. Independent challenge qualification: Compound survival and astronomical-diagnostics scope; shared overview mappings do not establish equivalence with other viability questions."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:522ed8f3ea76d5a3a0eaf610","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:07721cd2784be6b8d946ab995bc34115fe06c00c8c11756b914148a9a1d29256","q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef"],"scopeContentSha256":"f182d2957140a3f44bdc7c0c469ec4c0b69768b439470a47b36d261656eee304","contributionContentSha256":"f4f88f4e3b4dd8e1a3b4c6317a493be6900405eafa0882e7cf12c21707c36ea1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:07721cd2784be6b8d946ab995bc34115fe06c00c8c11756b914148a9a1d29256","textSha256":"3c690fa43ad47cdd3e42d6471f0b4f591df046a20bb0ef2f980f105cb31f9def"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:522ed8f3ea76d5a3a0eaf610","recordId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound survival and astronomical-diagnostics scope; equivalence with other broad viability questions is unestablished.","challengeNote":"Compound survival and astronomical-diagnostics scope; shared overview mappings do not establish equivalence with other viability questions.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:1306756664377d046523a80e2ba56403228528443099745e7dd1e6d9cd9d9a11","home":{"unitId":"unit:1306756664377d046523a80e2ba56403228528443099745e7dd1e6d9cd9d9a11","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers the comparative cosmological review of string formation, macroscopic-superstring viability and observational discrimination.","qualification":"The review explicitly connects cosmic superstrings to cosmological formation, viability objections and observations, satisfying q12's connection requirement. It preserves field-theory comparisons and source-dated 2009 expectations without equating origins or updating empirical claims.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1306756664377d046523a80e2ba56403228528443099745e7dd1e6d9cd9d9a11","paperId":"0911.1345","textSha256":"20c3e0aa063596b26bd488594e7f73bf9e77184eede186108a7ca7602901cb07"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0061:u13:q12"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0061:u13:q12","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1306756664377d046523a80e2ba56403228528443099745e7dd1e6d9cd9d9a11","q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a"],"scopeContentSha256":"3726e09093e830087c1d743d7925875e25b4f96b620eb3b8357ffec79dba2269","placementContentSha256":"7898b5f14151ab28a1c9e1e1bf74002657b085fe2cb8a3986065b823eced760d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0061:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0061:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1306756664377d046523a80e2ba56403228528443099745e7dd1e6d9cd9d9a11","paperId":"0911.1345","textSha256":"20c3e0aa063596b26bd488594e7f73bf9e77184eede186108a7ca7602901cb07"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0061","unitRef":"u13"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1306756664377d046523a80e2ba56403228528443099745e7dd1e6d9cd9d9a11","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:1306756664377d046523a80e2ba56403228528443099745e7dd1e6d9cd9d9a11","textSha256":"20c3e0aa063596b26bd488594e7f73bf9e77184eede186108a7ca7602901cb07"},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a233c368f64f88ed00410baacba7d1d0","paperId":"0911.1345","sourceSha256":"55e9837a3293e03c0d1945823afc87b61ba46ed94eb401d71b0a6f008c2c1a38","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca666eca7baccd885aa3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"be99a10ec140be29579eb16d9d18190ca03807bc426bc157b6bdb67251880201","pdfPage":2,"start":92,"end":3490,"textSha256":"180c3e7f6637c343e824b9ebbe4a1abfb3c6b1e28fd77c9570068b64ea625fca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b1f427a8f40624c5be8beb467bc65be5","paperId":"0911.1345","sourceSha256":"55e9837a3293e03c0d1945823afc87b61ba46ed94eb401d71b0a6f008c2c1a38","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca666eca7baccd885aa3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"be99a10ec140be29579eb16d9d18190ca03807bc426bc157b6bdb67251880201","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"964bb99ac97c54e1ed3a84f1fdc0bc30159721b9e8560e6a9b0455aa8c2d3f08","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b793ece4276220963151875ab83e3d98","paperId":"0911.1345","sourceSha256":"55e9837a3293e03c0d1945823afc87b61ba46ed94eb401d71b0a6f008c2c1a38","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca666eca7baccd885aa3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"be99a10ec140be29579eb16d9d18190ca03807bc426bc157b6bdb67251880201","pdfPage":2,"start":1291,"end":3687,"textSha256":"8582939fb2d7f409b7cff8562ae24635707d122497da0ac9bb28b7e65f4c90e4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ec21339042e11c7279d46c81","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound 2009 review: production/survival and observational discrimination. Historical expectations are not current evidence. Independent challenge qualification: Compound 2009 review of formation, viability and detection. Earlier universal objections remain historical context; detection expectations are source-dated."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ec21339042e11c7279d46c81","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1306756664377d046523a80e2ba56403228528443099745e7dd1e6d9cd9d9a11","q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef"],"scopeContentSha256":"f182d2957140a3f44bdc7c0c469ec4c0b69768b439470a47b36d261656eee304","contributionContentSha256":"1cf432463183e0f9b51045770ae83929e90844f5448beb77049ce143430e7a57","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:1306756664377d046523a80e2ba56403228528443099745e7dd1e6d9cd9d9a11","textSha256":"20c3e0aa063596b26bd488594e7f73bf9e77184eede186108a7ca7602901cb07"},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a233c368f64f88ed00410baacba7d1d0","paperId":"0911.1345","sourceSha256":"55e9837a3293e03c0d1945823afc87b61ba46ed94eb401d71b0a6f008c2c1a38","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca666eca7baccd885aa3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"be99a10ec140be29579eb16d9d18190ca03807bc426bc157b6bdb67251880201","pdfPage":2,"start":92,"end":3490,"textSha256":"180c3e7f6637c343e824b9ebbe4a1abfb3c6b1e28fd77c9570068b64ea625fca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b1f427a8f40624c5be8beb467bc65be5","paperId":"0911.1345","sourceSha256":"55e9837a3293e03c0d1945823afc87b61ba46ed94eb401d71b0a6f008c2c1a38","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca666eca7baccd885aa3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"be99a10ec140be29579eb16d9d18190ca03807bc426bc157b6bdb67251880201","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"964bb99ac97c54e1ed3a84f1fdc0bc30159721b9e8560e6a9b0455aa8c2d3f08","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b793ece4276220963151875ab83e3d98","paperId":"0911.1345","sourceSha256":"55e9837a3293e03c0d1945823afc87b61ba46ed94eb401d71b0a6f008c2c1a38","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca666eca7baccd885aa3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"be99a10ec140be29579eb16d9d18190ca03807bc426bc157b6bdb67251880201","pdfPage":2,"start":1291,"end":3687,"textSha256":"8582939fb2d7f409b7cff8562ae24635707d122497da0ac9bb28b7e65f4c90e4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ec21339042e11c7279d46c81","recordId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound 2009 review: production/survival and observational discrimination. Historical expectations are not current evidence.","challengeNote":"Compound 2009 review of formation, viability and detection. Earlier universal objections remain historical context; detection expectations are source-dated.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:20f8de7803ae8986c02ebcfccf663d8be4b940ef5a1028528159e7067ec8bb6d","home":{"unitId":"unit:20f8de7803ae8986c02ebcfccf663d8be4b940ef5a1028528159e7067ec8bb6d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers model-dependent post-inflationary production, survival, allowed observability and discrimination of cosmic strings arising from string constructions.","qualification":"q12 covers all species and the full production, survival, allowed-observability and discrimination sequence. Model dependence applies to every condition, and the gauge-theory comparison remains physically distinct.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:20f8de7803ae8986c02ebcfccf663d8be4b940ef5a1028528159e7067ec8bb6d","paperId":"hep-th/0412244","textSha256":"2de12ece26439f6b015981e72ae271ee3450c7153fccf7669c3528952148fd0e"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0061:u12:q12"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0061:u12:q12","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:20f8de7803ae8986c02ebcfccf663d8be4b940ef5a1028528159e7067ec8bb6d","q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a"],"scopeContentSha256":"3726e09093e830087c1d743d7925875e25b4f96b620eb3b8357ffec79dba2269","placementContentSha256":"04d474141b2eb2a9f1fc1b43ad741d2df5417d078faa45de9c2b1ddc3289c521","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0061:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0061:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:20f8de7803ae8986c02ebcfccf663d8be4b940ef5a1028528159e7067ec8bb6d","paperId":"hep-th/0412244","textSha256":"2de12ece26439f6b015981e72ae271ee3450c7153fccf7669c3528952148fd0e"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0061","unitRef":"u12"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:20f8de7803ae8986c02ebcfccf663d8be4b940ef5a1028528159e7067ec8bb6d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:20f8de7803ae8986c02ebcfccf663d8be4b940ef5a1028528159e7067ec8bb6d","textSha256":"2de12ece26439f6b015981e72ae271ee3450c7153fccf7669c3528952148fd0e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4fa2dedf7a4d1bf7c3f0797d","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound production, survival, allowed observability and discrimination conditions are explicitly model-dependent. Independent challenge qualification: Compound production, survival, allowed observability and discrimination conditions are explicitly model-dependent."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4fa2dedf7a4d1bf7c3f0797d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:20f8de7803ae8986c02ebcfccf663d8be4b940ef5a1028528159e7067ec8bb6d","q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef"],"scopeContentSha256":"f182d2957140a3f44bdc7c0c469ec4c0b69768b439470a47b36d261656eee304","contributionContentSha256":"d4c4a8b55218d32c1ceefef31720e1f8406644d38e3024e00b9b81e81973734d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:20f8de7803ae8986c02ebcfccf663d8be4b940ef5a1028528159e7067ec8bb6d","textSha256":"2de12ece26439f6b015981e72ae271ee3450c7153fccf7669c3528952148fd0e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4fa2dedf7a4d1bf7c3f0797d","recordId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound production, survival, allowed observability and discrimination conditions are explicitly model-dependent.","challengeNote":"Compound production, survival, allowed observability and discrimination conditions are explicitly model-dependent.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b90840fad6cab60ba59b622293438489d3849be966c3c24495234da398192c51","home":{"unitId":"unit:b90840fad6cab60ba59b622293438489d3849be966c3c24495234da398192c51","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers defect production at the end of brane inflation and the resulting string properties and observational consequences.","qualification":"q12 covers actual defect production and the subsequent tension, initial-density and signature questions in the explicit brane-inflation setting. Topological allowance remains distinct from production, and neither establishes an observed signal.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b90840fad6cab60ba59b622293438489d3849be966c3c24495234da398192c51","paperId":"hep-th/0204074","textSha256":"32635cdc49d10a3230004456c5ec64cd5339c71f5af55a302cadb97ef7b1a7d5"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0061:u9:q12"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0061:u9:q12","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b90840fad6cab60ba59b622293438489d3849be966c3c24495234da398192c51","q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a"],"scopeContentSha256":"3726e09093e830087c1d743d7925875e25b4f96b620eb3b8357ffec79dba2269","placementContentSha256":"8fa9b5e1afa5d410d1ec0d4e94e9647ca141e8f40ec765eceed2ef233956f3ab","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0061:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0061:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b90840fad6cab60ba59b622293438489d3849be966c3c24495234da398192c51","paperId":"hep-th/0204074","textSha256":"32635cdc49d10a3230004456c5ec64cd5339c71f5af55a302cadb97ef7b1a7d5"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0061","unitRef":"u9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b90840fad6cab60ba59b622293438489d3849be966c3c24495234da398192c51","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:b90840fad6cab60ba59b622293438489d3849be966c3c24495234da398192c51","textSha256":"32635cdc49d10a3230004456c5ec64cd5339c71f5af55a302cadb97ef7b1a7d5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ccc243aaf65397145b72f9fa","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Actual defect production is distinguished from topological allowance; tension, initial density and signatures remain additional targets. Independent challenge qualification: Actual production is distinguished from topological allowance; tension, initial density and observational signatures are additional targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ccc243aaf65397145b72f9fa","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b90840fad6cab60ba59b622293438489d3849be966c3c24495234da398192c51","q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef"],"scopeContentSha256":"f182d2957140a3f44bdc7c0c469ec4c0b69768b439470a47b36d261656eee304","contributionContentSha256":"cc12062784fd9c1789a69898cb3c039879dc5a254c1e184e12fa6697eb562f37","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:b90840fad6cab60ba59b622293438489d3849be966c3c24495234da398192c51","textSha256":"32635cdc49d10a3230004456c5ec64cd5339c71f5af55a302cadb97ef7b1a7d5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ccc243aaf65397145b72f9fa","recordId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Actual defect production is distinguished from topological allowance; tension, initial density and signatures remain additional targets.","challengeNote":"Actual production is distinguished from topological allowance; tension, initial density and observational signatures are additional targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c1d524fbcd47146eee36e4c4453b7d8258faaa9196062a248a49e9088546e6b3","home":{"unitId":"unit:c1d524fbcd47146eee36e4c4453b7d8258faaa9196062a248a49e9088546e6b3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers post-brane-inflation string production, survival and network formation together with empirical discrimination from a field-theory comparison.","qualification":"q12 covers the explicit brane-inflation setting, production, survival, network formation and empirical discrimination using tension spectra and density. Abelian Higgs strings remain a distinct comparison system.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c1d524fbcd47146eee36e4c4453b7d8258faaa9196062a248a49e9088546e6b3","paperId":"hep-th/0303269","textSha256":"cff2fc131a0f9cbbabecb69b09871c0405c402c32b23ae29a6fd71550ba324fc"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0061:u8:q12"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0061:u8:q12","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c1d524fbcd47146eee36e4c4453b7d8258faaa9196062a248a49e9088546e6b3","q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a"],"scopeContentSha256":"3726e09093e830087c1d743d7925875e25b4f96b620eb3b8357ffec79dba2269","placementContentSha256":"09b72594e6a65c3e91b9ca2d6302769835eb825d4da15ac20cbf0e8d220f3031","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0061:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0061:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c1d524fbcd47146eee36e4c4453b7d8258faaa9196062a248a49e9088546e6b3","paperId":"hep-th/0303269","textSha256":"cff2fc131a0f9cbbabecb69b09871c0405c402c32b23ae29a6fd71550ba324fc"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0061","unitRef":"u8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c1d524fbcd47146eee36e4c4453b7d8258faaa9196062a248a49e9088546e6b3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:c1d524fbcd47146eee36e4c4453b7d8258faaa9196062a248a49e9088546e6b3","textSha256":"cff2fc131a0f9cbbabecb69b09871c0405c402c32b23ae29a6fd71550ba324fc"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:28d611d7bab719d994fff981","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound production/survival/network target; Abelian Higgs strings supply the stated comparison. Independent challenge qualification: Compound production, survival and network-discrimination scope; Abelian Higgs strings are the stated comparison system."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:28d611d7bab719d994fff981","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c1d524fbcd47146eee36e4c4453b7d8258faaa9196062a248a49e9088546e6b3","q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef"],"scopeContentSha256":"f182d2957140a3f44bdc7c0c469ec4c0b69768b439470a47b36d261656eee304","contributionContentSha256":"adcc000632655cc0f3d499c21be7c23e89b3f166892da7946a7edd47b0f213b0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:c1d524fbcd47146eee36e4c4453b7d8258faaa9196062a248a49e9088546e6b3","textSha256":"cff2fc131a0f9cbbabecb69b09871c0405c402c32b23ae29a6fd71550ba324fc"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:28d611d7bab719d994fff981","recordId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound production/survival/network target; Abelian Higgs strings supply the stated comparison.","challengeNote":"Compound production, survival and network-discrimination scope; Abelian Higgs strings are the stated comparison system.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":5,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"36c58c8ba3be9bfc17d4ec4c7325463c89b7241a9319b2e6c6735ffa73169f49"},"organizational-access:c164029dca64f9566a6d4199":{"id":"organizational-access:c164029dca64f9566a6d4199","source":"q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a","target":"q025-candidate-question:699d60993cf42d39a8cd5012","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"3726e09093e830087c1d743d7925875e25b4f96b620eb3b8357ffec79dba2269","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c4d55bbe6aadd5783251d571"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:699d60993cf42d39a8cd5012","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1683a794c00a1300779518d3491172d7ade96f83fa11437da3efd23f7dcc59bd","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:709ad0d3dcfcd72ef99a3814"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1110b738a3785af318342b07accf9f24d84ad3010372ab5c9c8f6d328cadd1fc","home":{"unitId":"unit:1110b738a3785af318342b07accf9f24d84ad3010372ab5c9c8f6d328cadd1fc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1110b738a3785af318342b07accf9f24d84ad3010372ab5c9c8f6d328cadd1fc","paperId":"2508.17333","textSha256":"f5ce5221f5e1c3a0153dcc9d870bd9af9d319e8ef8931bc4cac34218eda1a38b"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0e3d98be52bfffa2085e6eaf"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0e3d98be52bfffa2085e6eaf","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1110b738a3785af318342b07accf9f24d84ad3010372ab5c9c8f6d328cadd1fc","q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a"],"scopeContentSha256":"3726e09093e830087c1d743d7925875e25b4f96b620eb3b8357ffec79dba2269","placementContentSha256":"d5ffa29acbaf5f4d6d4088c903504454d830b2d4e9791f847311870b3f98db84","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge","leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1110b738a3785af318342b07accf9f24d84ad3010372ab5c9c8f6d328cadd1fc","paperId":"2508.17333","textSha256":"f5ce5221f5e1c3a0153dcc9d870bd9af9d319e8ef8931bc4cac34218eda1a38b"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0e3d98be52bfffa2085e6eaf"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1110b738a3785af318342b07accf9f24d84ad3010372ab5c9c8f6d328cadd1fc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:699d60993cf42d39a8cd5012","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:1110b738a3785af318342b07accf9f24d84ad3010372ab5c9c8f6d328cadd1fc","textSha256":"f5ce5221f5e1c3a0153dcc9d870bd9af9d319e8ef8931bc4cac34218eda1a38b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5c649fa3ac825b56d313ceef"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5c649fa3ac825b56d313ceef","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1110b738a3785af318342b07accf9f24d84ad3010372ab5c9c8f6d328cadd1fc","q025-candidate-question:699d60993cf42d39a8cd5012"],"scopeContentSha256":"1683a794c00a1300779518d3491172d7ade96f83fa11437da3efd23f7dcc59bd","contributionContentSha256":"7c28a8aaaac89f0abcf447e2fdf139e6dc3a481b4e0782ec0e2413a70a599a10","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:1110b738a3785af318342b07accf9f24d84ad3010372ab5c9c8f6d328cadd1fc","textSha256":"f5ce5221f5e1c3a0153dcc9d870bd9af9d319e8ef8931bc4cac34218eda1a38b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5c649fa3ac825b56d313ceef","recordId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: scale symmetry, weakened restrictions, dark matter and four-dimensional preference; exact restrictions are not supplied.","challengeNote":"Compound scale-symmetry, restriction-weakening, dark-matter and dimensionality targets; exact restrictions are not supplied.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:13e947fb27e924b731f3c5a26a5c063fdcecbb60e813f3fe09aba6a98b8b4b68","home":{"unitId":"unit:13e947fb27e924b731f3c5a26a5c063fdcecbb60e813f3fe09aba6a98b8b4b68","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:13e947fb27e924b731f3c5a26a5c063fdcecbb60e813f3fe09aba6a98b8b4b68","paperId":"0710.2951","textSha256":"88da9bfd342dbc078f10536625ffe68aad95efbea0c2be52ddedb118a96110a2"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3497ed1bf73aac8fdde87dc2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3497ed1bf73aac8fdde87dc2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:13e947fb27e924b731f3c5a26a5c063fdcecbb60e813f3fe09aba6a98b8b4b68","q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a"],"scopeContentSha256":"3726e09093e830087c1d743d7925875e25b4f96b620eb3b8357ffec79dba2269","placementContentSha256":"554e3d8e7aa283b4c17fa31b47220e88f3cfeb8e993666bc282bc80368566290","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge","leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:13e947fb27e924b731f3c5a26a5c063fdcecbb60e813f3fe09aba6a98b8b4b68","paperId":"0710.2951","textSha256":"88da9bfd342dbc078f10536625ffe68aad95efbea0c2be52ddedb118a96110a2"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3497ed1bf73aac8fdde87dc2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:13e947fb27e924b731f3c5a26a5c063fdcecbb60e813f3fe09aba6a98b8b4b68","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:699d60993cf42d39a8cd5012","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:13e947fb27e924b731f3c5a26a5c063fdcecbb60e813f3fe09aba6a98b8b4b68","textSha256":"88da9bfd342dbc078f10536625ffe68aad95efbea0c2be52ddedb118a96110a2"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:98033ad20553a2d50afeafff"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:98033ad20553a2d50afeafff","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:13e947fb27e924b731f3c5a26a5c063fdcecbb60e813f3fe09aba6a98b8b4b68","q025-candidate-question:699d60993cf42d39a8cd5012"],"scopeContentSha256":"1683a794c00a1300779518d3491172d7ade96f83fa11437da3efd23f7dcc59bd","contributionContentSha256":"ecfd8de799a6b890e8881640395b4b6bcce2c1ae9384e77b9df2938055622042","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:13e947fb27e924b731f3c5a26a5c063fdcecbb60e813f3fe09aba6a98b8b4b68","textSha256":"88da9bfd342dbc078f10536625ffe68aad95efbea0c2be52ddedb118a96110a2"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:98033ad20553a2d50afeafff","recordId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound review spanning singularities, inflation, moduli and dark energy; singleton access does not assert atomicity.","challengeNote":"Compound review across singularities, inflation, moduli, dark energy and observational tests.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:7721ff0f7f728ce3899dd72c62c69c0e3acaf4ee6664b2072022411a7b33a66c","home":{"unitId":"unit:7721ff0f7f728ce3899dd72c62c69c0e3acaf4ee6664b2072022411a7b33a66c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7721ff0f7f728ce3899dd72c62c69c0e3acaf4ee6664b2072022411a7b33a66c","paperId":"0808.0746","textSha256":"9a9696efe28451d0b463620065b7b25ffd27c8c697d35b191287550c8fa76355"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:02f357689902010d52ef8d2c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:02f357689902010d52ef8d2c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7721ff0f7f728ce3899dd72c62c69c0e3acaf4ee6664b2072022411a7b33a66c","q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a"],"scopeContentSha256":"3726e09093e830087c1d743d7925875e25b4f96b620eb3b8357ffec79dba2269","placementContentSha256":"63199c02046ffb3cbec07c3da135ae582804e356090a9f48c5e29ca1dd6a8d3e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge","leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7721ff0f7f728ce3899dd72c62c69c0e3acaf4ee6664b2072022411a7b33a66c","paperId":"0808.0746","textSha256":"9a9696efe28451d0b463620065b7b25ffd27c8c697d35b191287550c8fa76355"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:02f357689902010d52ef8d2c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7721ff0f7f728ce3899dd72c62c69c0e3acaf4ee6664b2072022411a7b33a66c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:699d60993cf42d39a8cd5012","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:7721ff0f7f728ce3899dd72c62c69c0e3acaf4ee6664b2072022411a7b33a66c","textSha256":"9a9696efe28451d0b463620065b7b25ffd27c8c697d35b191287550c8fa76355"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:463d1498e8e50e9aebc6b218"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:463d1498e8e50e9aebc6b218","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7721ff0f7f728ce3899dd72c62c69c0e3acaf4ee6664b2072022411a7b33a66c","q025-candidate-question:699d60993cf42d39a8cd5012"],"scopeContentSha256":"1683a794c00a1300779518d3491172d7ade96f83fa11437da3efd23f7dcc59bd","contributionContentSha256":"7d9d602ee2e6fca4d4c4e817ad149f29700745e9afc9d7ad8a779493978825c3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:7721ff0f7f728ce3899dd72c62c69c0e3acaf4ee6664b2072022411a7b33a66c","textSha256":"9a9696efe28451d0b463620065b7b25ffd27c8c697d35b191287550c8fa76355"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:463d1498e8e50e9aebc6b218","recordId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: pre-EFT cosmology, dimensionality, stabilization and fluctuations without inflation.","challengeNote":"Compound: pre-EFT cosmology, dimensionality, stabilization and fluctuations without inflation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d418d446b3fe531c2fda27ea0c4826b5e90be9649c55a9124a6fddd6731b8120","home":{"unitId":"unit:d418d446b3fe531c2fda27ea0c4826b5e90be9649c55a9124a6fddd6731b8120","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d418d446b3fe531c2fda27ea0c4826b5e90be9649c55a9124a6fddd6731b8120","paperId":"2112.10783","textSha256":"8e1d7645425fc034acbfef42fa26ce5b01380776eb58ee5d7e0e49bcab122060"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6518b52092d5c9aff34cbfae"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6518b52092d5c9aff34cbfae","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d418d446b3fe531c2fda27ea0c4826b5e90be9649c55a9124a6fddd6731b8120","q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a"],"scopeContentSha256":"3726e09093e830087c1d743d7925875e25b4f96b620eb3b8357ffec79dba2269","placementContentSha256":"1f35e0533e0d117603492a04e47403b333558f026bd38a2739567fec83677188","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge","leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d418d446b3fe531c2fda27ea0c4826b5e90be9649c55a9124a6fddd6731b8120","paperId":"2112.10783","textSha256":"8e1d7645425fc034acbfef42fa26ce5b01380776eb58ee5d7e0e49bcab122060"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6518b52092d5c9aff34cbfae"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d418d446b3fe531c2fda27ea0c4826b5e90be9649c55a9124a6fddd6731b8120","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:699d60993cf42d39a8cd5012","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:d418d446b3fe531c2fda27ea0c4826b5e90be9649c55a9124a6fddd6731b8120","textSha256":"8e1d7645425fc034acbfef42fa26ce5b01380776eb58ee5d7e0e49bcab122060"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8d1cf08a0c4045e2aaf1a6a0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8d1cf08a0c4045e2aaf1a6a0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d418d446b3fe531c2fda27ea0c4826b5e90be9649c55a9124a6fddd6731b8120","q025-candidate-question:699d60993cf42d39a8cd5012"],"scopeContentSha256":"1683a794c00a1300779518d3491172d7ade96f83fa11437da3efd23f7dcc59bd","contributionContentSha256":"b2e0a8c64818adc1ec2a7ff536c1674cb0877d352022415f9844ad9298d8d031","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:d418d446b3fe531c2fda27ea0c4826b5e90be9649c55a9124a6fddd6731b8120","textSha256":"8e1d7645425fc034acbfef42fa26ce5b01380776eb58ee5d7e0e49bcab122060"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8d1cf08a0c4045e2aaf1a6a0","recordId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ef888fc100ba94fae93aef5afa64bfe4756726665dbd7ead81d91c55d25b6f97","home":{"unitId":"unit:ef888fc100ba94fae93aef5afa64bfe4756726665dbd7ead81d91c55d25b6f97","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ef888fc100ba94fae93aef5afa64bfe4756726665dbd7ead81d91c55d25b6f97","paperId":"hep-th/0510022","textSha256":"b092a704e5f573b792aaefe0ba8f237cdf6cc031a7edede8589bbdffeb63876e"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9a47aeab70f37a0118c97b0f5f64c8eb","paperId":"hep-th/0510022","sourceSha256":"55598a034cdfdb13c9581d4e3ce86819c745e886125f7aa37e882c9eb3cb4be9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25ee28ccf8dbede6c4ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e24cfbcd803111fc1a02bff775f1fed82b0619a8addb2ec990f63ab57ae6d9b9","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1243,"textSha256":"c9dc3d60ca526a14b4f784eff8f4a30ee615e44a5f1f50717aae6bf04ad76433","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ae9c8bfea67f35ab188240a7725c27a6","paperId":"hep-th/0510022","sourceSha256":"55598a034cdfdb13c9581d4e3ce86819c745e886125f7aa37e882c9eb3cb4be9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25ee28ccf8dbede6c4ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e24cfbcd803111fc1a02bff775f1fed82b0619a8addb2ec990f63ab57ae6d9b9","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2424,"textSha256":"182de9372ef343ffae5a2d1d195016bb793974c64f6440e602e7915120bf2287","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d8d3f443e52dd8ccd52575d83969f792","paperId":"hep-th/0510022","sourceSha256":"55598a034cdfdb13c9581d4e3ce86819c745e886125f7aa37e882c9eb3cb4be9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25ee28ccf8dbede6c4ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e24cfbcd803111fc1a02bff775f1fed82b0619a8addb2ec990f63ab57ae6d9b9","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":1924,"textSha256":"d7abd67190c92f6b2ded330c0cff89ba331adfdd0401d6d999ac402b05addb0d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:25c4d59c54d32330089f80ad"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:25c4d59c54d32330089f80ad","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ef888fc100ba94fae93aef5afa64bfe4756726665dbd7ead81d91c55d25b6f97","q025-candidate-region:1f2df7a882631437e185db0a"],"scopeContentSha256":"3726e09093e830087c1d743d7925875e25b4f96b620eb3b8357ffec79dba2269","placementContentSha256":"331f1462e3af47934b6d6042b9f772b5f2ccd32f76324eec50fc9b7e4ade1f49","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge","leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ef888fc100ba94fae93aef5afa64bfe4756726665dbd7ead81d91c55d25b6f97","paperId":"hep-th/0510022","textSha256":"b092a704e5f573b792aaefe0ba8f237cdf6cc031a7edede8589bbdffeb63876e"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9a47aeab70f37a0118c97b0f5f64c8eb","paperId":"hep-th/0510022","sourceSha256":"55598a034cdfdb13c9581d4e3ce86819c745e886125f7aa37e882c9eb3cb4be9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25ee28ccf8dbede6c4ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e24cfbcd803111fc1a02bff775f1fed82b0619a8addb2ec990f63ab57ae6d9b9","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1243,"textSha256":"c9dc3d60ca526a14b4f784eff8f4a30ee615e44a5f1f50717aae6bf04ad76433","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ae9c8bfea67f35ab188240a7725c27a6","paperId":"hep-th/0510022","sourceSha256":"55598a034cdfdb13c9581d4e3ce86819c745e886125f7aa37e882c9eb3cb4be9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25ee28ccf8dbede6c4ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e24cfbcd803111fc1a02bff775f1fed82b0619a8addb2ec990f63ab57ae6d9b9","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2424,"textSha256":"182de9372ef343ffae5a2d1d195016bb793974c64f6440e602e7915120bf2287","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d8d3f443e52dd8ccd52575d83969f792","paperId":"hep-th/0510022","sourceSha256":"55598a034cdfdb13c9581d4e3ce86819c745e886125f7aa37e882c9eb3cb4be9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25ee28ccf8dbede6c4ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e24cfbcd803111fc1a02bff775f1fed82b0619a8addb2ec990f63ab57ae6d9b9","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":1924,"textSha256":"d7abd67190c92f6b2ded330c0cff89ba331adfdd0401d6d999ac402b05addb0d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:25c4d59c54d32330089f80ad"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ef888fc100ba94fae93aef5afa64bfe4756726665dbd7ead81d91c55d25b6f97","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:699d60993cf42d39a8cd5012","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:ef888fc100ba94fae93aef5afa64bfe4756726665dbd7ead81d91c55d25b6f97","textSha256":"b092a704e5f573b792aaefe0ba8f237cdf6cc031a7edede8589bbdffeb63876e"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9a47aeab70f37a0118c97b0f5f64c8eb","paperId":"hep-th/0510022","sourceSha256":"55598a034cdfdb13c9581d4e3ce86819c745e886125f7aa37e882c9eb3cb4be9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25ee28ccf8dbede6c4ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e24cfbcd803111fc1a02bff775f1fed82b0619a8addb2ec990f63ab57ae6d9b9","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1243,"textSha256":"c9dc3d60ca526a14b4f784eff8f4a30ee615e44a5f1f50717aae6bf04ad76433","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ae9c8bfea67f35ab188240a7725c27a6","paperId":"hep-th/0510022","sourceSha256":"55598a034cdfdb13c9581d4e3ce86819c745e886125f7aa37e882c9eb3cb4be9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25ee28ccf8dbede6c4ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e24cfbcd803111fc1a02bff775f1fed82b0619a8addb2ec990f63ab57ae6d9b9","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2424,"textSha256":"182de9372ef343ffae5a2d1d195016bb793974c64f6440e602e7915120bf2287","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d8d3f443e52dd8ccd52575d83969f792","paperId":"hep-th/0510022","sourceSha256":"55598a034cdfdb13c9581d4e3ce86819c745e886125f7aa37e882c9eb3cb4be9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25ee28ccf8dbede6c4ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e24cfbcd803111fc1a02bff775f1fed82b0619a8addb2ec990f63ab57ae6d9b9","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":1924,"textSha256":"d7abd67190c92f6b2ded330c0cff89ba331adfdd0401d6d999ac402b05addb0d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:53b6934fdfcead799355812f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:53b6934fdfcead799355812f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ef888fc100ba94fae93aef5afa64bfe4756726665dbd7ead81d91c55d25b6f97","q025-candidate-question:699d60993cf42d39a8cd5012"],"scopeContentSha256":"1683a794c00a1300779518d3491172d7ade96f83fa11437da3efd23f7dcc59bd","contributionContentSha256":"9d54609f7dcdb6cae70608206c034c3b3b14e71170451b56463540d1dd646a2e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:ef888fc100ba94fae93aef5afa64bfe4756726665dbd7ead81d91c55d25b6f97","textSha256":"b092a704e5f573b792aaefe0ba8f237cdf6cc031a7edede8589bbdffeb63876e"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9a47aeab70f37a0118c97b0f5f64c8eb","paperId":"hep-th/0510022","sourceSha256":"55598a034cdfdb13c9581d4e3ce86819c745e886125f7aa37e882c9eb3cb4be9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25ee28ccf8dbede6c4ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e24cfbcd803111fc1a02bff775f1fed82b0619a8addb2ec990f63ab57ae6d9b9","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1243,"textSha256":"c9dc3d60ca526a14b4f784eff8f4a30ee615e44a5f1f50717aae6bf04ad76433","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ae9c8bfea67f35ab188240a7725c27a6","paperId":"hep-th/0510022","sourceSha256":"55598a034cdfdb13c9581d4e3ce86819c745e886125f7aa37e882c9eb3cb4be9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25ee28ccf8dbede6c4ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e24cfbcd803111fc1a02bff775f1fed82b0619a8addb2ec990f63ab57ae6d9b9","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2424,"textSha256":"182de9372ef343ffae5a2d1d195016bb793974c64f6440e602e7915120bf2287","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d8d3f443e52dd8ccd52575d83969f792","paperId":"hep-th/0510022","sourceSha256":"55598a034cdfdb13c9581d4e3ce86819c745e886125f7aa37e882c9eb3cb4be9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25ee28ccf8dbede6c4ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e24cfbcd803111fc1a02bff775f1fed82b0619a8addb2ec990f63ab57ae6d9b9","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":1924,"textSha256":"d7abd67190c92f6b2ded330c0cff89ba331adfdd0401d6d999ac402b05addb0d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:53b6934fdfcead799355812f","recordId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound gas review; pure winding stabilization fails in its treatment, while quantum trapping and dark-matter possibilities have separate qualifications.","challengeNote":"Compound gas review. Pure winding stabilization fails within its treatment; enhanced-symmetry quantum trapping and dark-matter possibilities remain distinct.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":5,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"bbfde50f8f6b80a19978df9e950779f4c7c04d98f4b737d23d6ab9344f13e019"},"organizational-access:12cde193e519c053818ff310":{"id":"organizational-access:12cde193e519c053818ff310","source":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","target":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"1123f220fa66dcfaf6d7e353a5cf057117c27fd54c0bd35da01fa61759e8d824","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:4ed4ace2d0148acd0fa0f6ef"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"71871b4049eae42d5a1f8261a512e9159784414b96da3dc46efe68e19792349a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:243b81183878d52e44407693"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","home":{"unitId":"unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","paperId":"1912.07035","textSha256":"e1aea81d9bd585ee762e5b69301278e87c9066181525bb4f5b04a418a26dafc5"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2ec82b2f70aabaa6cfa328ab7c804558","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":97,"end":2881,"textSha256":"0e06c003edd1d789601faebce4ee1de5444df67912a0f317078f9fe7887229d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6ac192739d9b90633d519a4c5d974d8a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":52,"start":103,"end":2928,"textSha256":"88ac6d250126085be76bf1731dd9ed1643a4b2d35eadefb0336d3d722e55e639","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:713fb43ca7fd96fd919ec46895f6027a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":0,"end":2881,"textSha256":"fad42dabc3103931820ed5b6950fd27cc8cd4b2de969bf275e28435904a81c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0149353f35a4b32af877a66b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0149353f35a4b32af877a66b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278"],"scopeContentSha256":"1123f220fa66dcfaf6d7e353a5cf057117c27fd54c0bd35da01fa61759e8d824","placementContentSha256":"d5ecec94cf92589ba1f861ab9bb0d025ae977603d5686fcc1fef473ad0221782","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge","parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","paperId":"1912.07035","textSha256":"e1aea81d9bd585ee762e5b69301278e87c9066181525bb4f5b04a418a26dafc5"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2ec82b2f70aabaa6cfa328ab7c804558","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":97,"end":2881,"textSha256":"0e06c003edd1d789601faebce4ee1de5444df67912a0f317078f9fe7887229d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6ac192739d9b90633d519a4c5d974d8a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":52,"start":103,"end":2928,"textSha256":"88ac6d250126085be76bf1731dd9ed1643a4b2d35eadefb0336d3d722e55e639","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:713fb43ca7fd96fd919ec46895f6027a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":0,"end":2881,"textSha256":"fad42dabc3103931820ed5b6950fd27cc8cd4b2de969bf275e28435904a81c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0149353f35a4b32af877a66b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","textSha256":"e1aea81d9bd585ee762e5b69301278e87c9066181525bb4f5b04a418a26dafc5"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6ac192739d9b90633d519a4c5d974d8a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":52,"start":103,"end":2928,"textSha256":"88ac6d250126085be76bf1731dd9ed1643a4b2d35eadefb0336d3d722e55e639","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:713fb43ca7fd96fd919ec46895f6027a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":0,"end":2881,"textSha256":"fad42dabc3103931820ed5b6950fd27cc8cd4b2de969bf275e28435904a81c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2ec82b2f70aabaa6cfa328ab7c804558","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":97,"end":2881,"textSha256":"0e06c003edd1d789601faebce4ee1de5444df67912a0f317078f9fe7887229d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:449fb27ae9541c10bfd48960","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound thesis: spectrum classification, black-hole thermodynamics and CFT observables need separate fine-facet reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Unresolved compound thesis: spectrum classification, black-hole thermodynamics and CFT observables require separate fine facets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:449fb27ae9541c10bfd48960","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34"],"scopeContentSha256":"71871b4049eae42d5a1f8261a512e9159784414b96da3dc46efe68e19792349a","contributionContentSha256":"668b89e2846120edbebcefe8467f0060b9df5fd2e76c187a134af5626732c5ea","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-proposal","leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","textSha256":"e1aea81d9bd585ee762e5b69301278e87c9066181525bb4f5b04a418a26dafc5"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6ac192739d9b90633d519a4c5d974d8a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":52,"start":103,"end":2928,"textSha256":"88ac6d250126085be76bf1731dd9ed1643a4b2d35eadefb0336d3d722e55e639","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:713fb43ca7fd96fd919ec46895f6027a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":0,"end":2881,"textSha256":"fad42dabc3103931820ed5b6950fd27cc8cd4b2de969bf275e28435904a81c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2ec82b2f70aabaa6cfa328ab7c804558","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":97,"end":2881,"textSha256":"0e06c003edd1d789601faebce4ee1de5444df67912a0f317078f9fe7887229d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:449fb27ae9541c10bfd48960","recordId":"leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound thesis: spectrum classification, black-hole thermodynamics and CFT observables need separate fine-facet reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound thesis: spectrum classification, black-hole thermodynamics and CFT observables require separate fine facets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"e71161d0f58dbbfd22d7ddea357db6b7058ec916f74471bf5aa4c90789234635"},"organizational-access:727772623f69505665d70347":{"id":"organizational-access:727772623f69505665d70347","source":"q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba","target":"q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"0a5f2902a138407a2d1d797db99ca0cacf6a1300be5f62e2b680c9224bc88037","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:69f329ffc7e943d81c657aef"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"5b36fcc6054f22dabed9d8808ec44a1107c01f10a602951db0ef2cda23b889c4","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:878c94f8bafbac542388bfbc"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0419db493de7f13019ba45835bd671ac53fd81faee9a13a405f6325b7e71ca35","home":{"unitId":"unit:0419db493de7f13019ba45835bd671ac53fd81faee9a13a405f6325b7e71ca35","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0419db493de7f13019ba45835bd671ac53fd81faee9a13a405f6325b7e71ca35","paperId":"2111.00989","textSha256":"f5c839c6f7751e4023eda4e6c3b89e354b511ab6b7157e81e7f4c2b4a42f81b2"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f62a534fb08bec13b1f2dbac"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f62a534fb08bec13b1f2dbac","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0419db493de7f13019ba45835bd671ac53fd81faee9a13a405f6325b7e71ca35","q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba"],"scopeContentSha256":"0a5f2902a138407a2d1d797db99ca0cacf6a1300be5f62e2b680c9224bc88037","placementContentSha256":"76d4cd6390fc95ebcb2ebdd85d3c0b22bd7aab3831f85812edfc1c4da856bac7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0419db493de7f13019ba45835bd671ac53fd81faee9a13a405f6325b7e71ca35","paperId":"2111.00989","textSha256":"f5c839c6f7751e4023eda4e6c3b89e354b511ab6b7157e81e7f4c2b4a42f81b2"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f62a534fb08bec13b1f2dbac"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0419db493de7f13019ba45835bd671ac53fd81faee9a13a405f6325b7e71ca35","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:0419db493de7f13019ba45835bd671ac53fd81faee9a13a405f6325b7e71ca35","textSha256":"f5c839c6f7751e4023eda4e6c3b89e354b511ab6b7157e81e7f4c2b4a42f81b2"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b25b641b92ab0d21637df881"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b25b641b92ab0d21637df881","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0419db493de7f13019ba45835bd671ac53fd81faee9a13a405f6325b7e71ca35","q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65"],"scopeContentSha256":"5b36fcc6054f22dabed9d8808ec44a1107c01f10a602951db0ef2cda23b889c4","contributionContentSha256":"c98d2b7f6e04e958502a508aabb9d00808ee2d8907388874e500ff47b0fe2872","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:0419db493de7f13019ba45835bd671ac53fd81faee9a13a405f6325b7e71ca35","textSha256":"f5c839c6f7751e4023eda4e6c3b89e354b511ab6b7157e81e7f4c2b4a42f81b2"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b25b641b92ab0d21637df881","recordId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound mechanism, naturalness and observational-signature targets; Planck-steepness alone does not supply a Swampland premise.","challengeNote":"Compound mechanism, naturalness and signature targets; Planck-steepness alone does not impose a Swampland premise.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:389d471971c29207f752bb16a3881fe895bc5df1fa2c63422ea5a6a84903a588","home":{"unitId":"unit:389d471971c29207f752bb16a3881fe895bc5df1fa2c63422ea5a6a84903a588","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:389d471971c29207f752bb16a3881fe895bc5df1fa2c63422ea5a6a84903a588","paperId":"1901.08603","textSha256":"13e489b976fc6a7f60dea7769f4117d2ed86a847b917ad3eea69dd2561b55241"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d583b6062074e48dd40eb71a"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d583b6062074e48dd40eb71a","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:389d471971c29207f752bb16a3881fe895bc5df1fa2c63422ea5a6a84903a588","q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba"],"scopeContentSha256":"0a5f2902a138407a2d1d797db99ca0cacf6a1300be5f62e2b680c9224bc88037","placementContentSha256":"25faa9f0d6253269e35b04c1082f41870e31a4689c0561a82e22ef81c3e68bcb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:389d471971c29207f752bb16a3881fe895bc5df1fa2c63422ea5a6a84903a588","paperId":"1901.08603","textSha256":"13e489b976fc6a7f60dea7769f4117d2ed86a847b917ad3eea69dd2561b55241"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d583b6062074e48dd40eb71a"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:389d471971c29207f752bb16a3881fe895bc5df1fa2c63422ea5a6a84903a588","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:389d471971c29207f752bb16a3881fe895bc5df1fa2c63422ea5a6a84903a588","textSha256":"13e489b976fc6a7f60dea7769f4117d2ed86a847b917ad3eea69dd2561b55241"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5966cd41871ab44a88e3d5d5"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5966cd41871ab44a88e3d5d5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:389d471971c29207f752bb16a3881fe895bc5df1fa2c63422ea5a6a84903a588","q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65"],"scopeContentSha256":"5b36fcc6054f22dabed9d8808ec44a1107c01f10a602951db0ef2cda23b889c4","contributionContentSha256":"1f8d728674696ccddeea28c5d296ca9e47363b6194f1c1e01e88f2c1d1e64e8f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:389d471971c29207f752bb16a3881fe895bc5df1fa2c63422ea5a6a84903a588","textSha256":"13e489b976fc6a7f60dea7769f4117d2ed86a847b917ad3eea69dd2561b55241"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5966cd41871ab44a88e3d5d5","recordId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Small curvature radius permits rapid turning and can destabilize transverse fluctuations; neither outcome is automatic.","challengeNote":"Replace the spectrum target and sustained-turn regime: the description specifies fluctuation masses and permits rapid turning without stating its duration.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:6b4b8f3242b320516f8714a5876de427859a9b12e0c760d7589f1f71ef5e619b","home":{"unitId":"unit:6b4b8f3242b320516f8714a5876de427859a9b12e0c760d7589f1f71ef5e619b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6b4b8f3242b320516f8714a5876de427859a9b12e0c760d7589f1f71ef5e619b","paperId":"2210.14900","textSha256":"ee222f435c217bee7cf50f8802c7de166e07bc687a2b0c65015d01371b3cd78f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f578b5527767353aae079a47"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f578b5527767353aae079a47","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6b4b8f3242b320516f8714a5876de427859a9b12e0c760d7589f1f71ef5e619b","q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba"],"scopeContentSha256":"0a5f2902a138407a2d1d797db99ca0cacf6a1300be5f62e2b680c9224bc88037","placementContentSha256":"8f0483ba14c389fe81230b67891bf694c6179cfeea57140994f656daba5239cf","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6b4b8f3242b320516f8714a5876de427859a9b12e0c760d7589f1f71ef5e619b","paperId":"2210.14900","textSha256":"ee222f435c217bee7cf50f8802c7de166e07bc687a2b0c65015d01371b3cd78f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f578b5527767353aae079a47"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:6b4b8f3242b320516f8714a5876de427859a9b12e0c760d7589f1f71ef5e619b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:6b4b8f3242b320516f8714a5876de427859a9b12e0c760d7589f1f71ef5e619b","textSha256":"ee222f435c217bee7cf50f8802c7de166e07bc687a2b0c65015d01371b3cd78f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dfb2d27476a4cacb44924ef7"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:dfb2d27476a4cacb44924ef7","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6b4b8f3242b320516f8714a5876de427859a9b12e0c760d7589f1f71ef5e619b","q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65"],"scopeContentSha256":"5b36fcc6054f22dabed9d8808ec44a1107c01f10a602951db0ef2cda23b889c4","contributionContentSha256":"e3d860115672db662a970aa5914901a12ba22cf914f6cc6bd1ba60e56a433364","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:6b4b8f3242b320516f8714a5876de427859a9b12e0c760d7589f1f71ef5e619b","textSha256":"ee222f435c217bee7cf50f8802c7de166e07bc687a2b0c65015d01371b3cd78f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dfb2d27476a4cacb44924ef7","recordId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound background and perturbation questions for three or more fields; late-time here refers to approach to inflationary attractors.","challengeNote":"Compound background and perturbation targets for three or more fields; late-time means approach to an inflationary attractor.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9a2b35c0128cb869f5d845cbf34ce5a05224d5d5b150eb66016b0772d487b0e0","home":{"unitId":"unit:9a2b35c0128cb869f5d845cbf34ce5a05224d5d5b150eb66016b0772d487b0e0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9a2b35c0128cb869f5d845cbf34ce5a05224d5d5b150eb66016b0772d487b0e0","paperId":"1705.03023","textSha256":"fc0d516984c9f8eceea8495f80a53811e19231f5f4c8cb75b431d2603c1a0839"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:424469d0179d2b665b808a20"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:424469d0179d2b665b808a20","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9a2b35c0128cb869f5d845cbf34ce5a05224d5d5b150eb66016b0772d487b0e0","q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba"],"scopeContentSha256":"0a5f2902a138407a2d1d797db99ca0cacf6a1300be5f62e2b680c9224bc88037","placementContentSha256":"af3edff89cfdde2b3132ad4cf64a1f4b9ece36349bcd2d98838fdde393bb3206","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9a2b35c0128cb869f5d845cbf34ce5a05224d5d5b150eb66016b0772d487b0e0","paperId":"1705.03023","textSha256":"fc0d516984c9f8eceea8495f80a53811e19231f5f4c8cb75b431d2603c1a0839"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:424469d0179d2b665b808a20"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9a2b35c0128cb869f5d845cbf34ce5a05224d5d5b150eb66016b0772d487b0e0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:9a2b35c0128cb869f5d845cbf34ce5a05224d5d5b150eb66016b0772d487b0e0","textSha256":"fc0d516984c9f8eceea8495f80a53811e19231f5f4c8cb75b431d2603c1a0839"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9bdee6e87a04fea4362d857f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9bdee6e87a04fea4362d857f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9a2b35c0128cb869f5d845cbf34ce5a05224d5d5b150eb66016b0772d487b0e0","q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65"],"scopeContentSha256":"5b36fcc6054f22dabed9d8808ec44a1107c01f10a602951db0ef2cda23b889c4","contributionContentSha256":"23fbb7b53cd14f85b540fc96d5a58264ab679e4130d1bbff649ac2128bf39586","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:9a2b35c0128cb869f5d845cbf34ce5a05224d5d5b150eb66016b0772d487b0e0","textSha256":"fc0d516984c9f8eceea8495f80a53811e19231f5f4c8cb75b431d2603c1a0839"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9bdee6e87a04fea4362d857f","recordId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound centrifugal-background, primordial-perturbation and radiative-control targets; none is independently verified here.","challengeNote":"Compound centrifugal-background, perturbation and radiative-stability targets remain source-scoped.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a345ef7b0610f1ed022582469240855564d3dc779f51ddde0386e2ed5b92ba08","home":{"unitId":"unit:a345ef7b0610f1ed022582469240855564d3dc779f51ddde0386e2ed5b92ba08","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a345ef7b0610f1ed022582469240855564d3dc779f51ddde0386e2ed5b92ba08","paperId":"astro-ph/9812204","textSha256":"2878d6abe56b3f6b3c19cd79b3c6ab793e03907d4c952ed8debb33aa5bbae0c4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:959af2177f35a04c90598fff"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:959af2177f35a04c90598fff","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a345ef7b0610f1ed022582469240855564d3dc779f51ddde0386e2ed5b92ba08","q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba"],"scopeContentSha256":"0a5f2902a138407a2d1d797db99ca0cacf6a1300be5f62e2b680c9224bc88037","placementContentSha256":"0ecd2e15dd3c414989dadec243da16814ac76091182a66dc217283ce140aeb9c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a345ef7b0610f1ed022582469240855564d3dc779f51ddde0386e2ed5b92ba08","paperId":"astro-ph/9812204","textSha256":"2878d6abe56b3f6b3c19cd79b3c6ab793e03907d4c952ed8debb33aa5bbae0c4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:959af2177f35a04c90598fff"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a345ef7b0610f1ed022582469240855564d3dc779f51ddde0386e2ed5b92ba08","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d60","kind":"description","unitIndex":60,"unitId":"unit:a345ef7b0610f1ed022582469240855564d3dc779f51ddde0386e2ed5b92ba08","textSha256":"2878d6abe56b3f6b3c19cd79b3c6ab793e03907d4c952ed8debb33aa5bbae0c4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:141ded752fdcbd9ea81168e5"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:141ded752fdcbd9ea81168e5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a345ef7b0610f1ed022582469240855564d3dc779f51ddde0386e2ed5b92ba08","q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65"],"scopeContentSha256":"5b36fcc6054f22dabed9d8808ec44a1107c01f10a602951db0ef2cda23b889c4","contributionContentSha256":"ba1a6ea78b683ecfb07422815956bb1d3289a65d81a77242d9bae7b5ec756cf4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d60","kind":"description","unitIndex":60,"unitId":"unit:a345ef7b0610f1ed022582469240855564d3dc779f51ddde0386e2ed5b92ba08","textSha256":"2878d6abe56b3f6b3c19cd79b3c6ab793e03907d4c952ed8debb33aa5bbae0c4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:141ded752fdcbd9ea81168e5","recordId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Homogeneous, adiabatic and isocurvature perturbations are examined without a slow-roll approximation.","challengeNote":"Compound attraction and homogeneous/adiabatic/isocurvature perturbation targets are studied without a slow-roll approximation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f9c8b4dc678450688b0b618c265d662786bb3ffc1d01105fd2076e7df911157c","home":{"unitId":"unit:f9c8b4dc678450688b0b618c265d662786bb3ffc1d01105fd2076e7df911157c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f9c8b4dc678450688b0b618c265d662786bb3ffc1d01105fd2076e7df911157c","paperId":"1902.10529","textSha256":"62ba670a29de15f966100122ab1b4c4a19195963b638854ecacad78833f22db7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2ac15707fbe1310311dbcea2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2ac15707fbe1310311dbcea2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f9c8b4dc678450688b0b618c265d662786bb3ffc1d01105fd2076e7df911157c","q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba"],"scopeContentSha256":"0a5f2902a138407a2d1d797db99ca0cacf6a1300be5f62e2b680c9224bc88037","placementContentSha256":"73f27fb2d184f47deef4130fc68786fb2581bbb46688071016af6c0850679d92","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f9c8b4dc678450688b0b618c265d662786bb3ffc1d01105fd2076e7df911157c","paperId":"1902.10529","textSha256":"62ba670a29de15f966100122ab1b4c4a19195963b638854ecacad78833f22db7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2ac15707fbe1310311dbcea2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f9c8b4dc678450688b0b618c265d662786bb3ffc1d01105fd2076e7df911157c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:f9c8b4dc678450688b0b618c265d662786bb3ffc1d01105fd2076e7df911157c","textSha256":"62ba670a29de15f966100122ab1b4c4a19195963b638854ecacad78833f22db7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cee2e947886cf776e4892782"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:cee2e947886cf776e4892782","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f9c8b4dc678450688b0b618c265d662786bb3ffc1d01105fd2076e7df911157c","q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65"],"scopeContentSha256":"5b36fcc6054f22dabed9d8808ec44a1107c01f10a602951db0ef2cda23b889c4","contributionContentSha256":"cdd769dfa47329c90f1313a31ae51e06e569cc7e5f14bba6a3e45be66c75cc5b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:f9c8b4dc678450688b0b618c265d662786bb3ffc1d01105fd2076e7df911157c","textSha256":"62ba670a29de15f966100122ab1b4c4a19195963b638854ecacad78833f22db7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cee2e947886cf776e4892782","recordId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"More-than-two-field background construction and perturbation reduction are compound open targets in this description.","challengeNote":"Compound background-construction and perturbation-reduction questions for more than two fields remain open targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":6,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"68ee72f73fa8d1b6cf1a083e2d6c3a731ee255c81a1833aac024b6bcb9a6e435"},"organizational-access:2b676d7557ade8da5c988ae7":{"id":"organizational-access:2b676d7557ade8da5c988ae7","source":"q025-candidate-region:4439c1e724e9e3ff7a00ca50","target":"q025-candidate-question:b28a4297e68a4e66f23d8537","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:4439c1e724e9e3ff7a00ca50","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"176bf2d81f8e8913730a689b5cf6d58cf4cec63989b1a6bded70629c7640f83f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b396e0ead96447db12c2c5f8"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:b28a4297e68a4e66f23d8537","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"d9b0b639500ff3024f1b435d612f2937c50a8dcaf6d5badb145a2db90f1a2afd","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2f8b40f43bc32c2014498898"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:45088b06df418f90f258efb0c24ec4c20dc8f63e1289ac2111f4b29e0f0c4301","home":{"unitId":"unit:45088b06df418f90f258efb0c24ec4c20dc8f63e1289ac2111f4b29e0f0c4301","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4439c1e724e9e3ff7a00ca50","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:45088b06df418f90f258efb0c24ec4c20dc8f63e1289ac2111f4b29e0f0c4301","paperId":"hep-th/0602178","textSha256":"9002919d872ca3025945fbec3be42236cd8bba28936cd848bea53bc6dcf80139"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:776a9a5f43dca4b71e4b670b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:776a9a5f43dca4b71e4b670b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:45088b06df418f90f258efb0c24ec4c20dc8f63e1289ac2111f4b29e0f0c4301","q025-candidate-region:4439c1e724e9e3ff7a00ca50"],"scopeContentSha256":"176bf2d81f8e8913730a689b5cf6d58cf4cec63989b1a6bded70629c7640f83f","placementContentSha256":"88f043d3a1ffbd11453238529a64bc2262c6f1f5200e2194fadbc505fcfb0863","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge","leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:45088b06df418f90f258efb0c24ec4c20dc8f63e1289ac2111f4b29e0f0c4301","paperId":"hep-th/0602178","textSha256":"9002919d872ca3025945fbec3be42236cd8bba28936cd848bea53bc6dcf80139"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:776a9a5f43dca4b71e4b670b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:45088b06df418f90f258efb0c24ec4c20dc8f63e1289ac2111f4b29e0f0c4301","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b28a4297e68a4e66f23d8537","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d48","kind":"description","unitIndex":48,"unitId":"unit:45088b06df418f90f258efb0c24ec4c20dc8f63e1289ac2111f4b29e0f0c4301","textSha256":"9002919d872ca3025945fbec3be42236cd8bba28936cd848bea53bc6dcf80139"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:afa453f2ff869e1c62e5f53a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:afa453f2ff869e1c62e5f53a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:45088b06df418f90f258efb0c24ec4c20dc8f63e1289ac2111f4b29e0f0c4301","q025-candidate-question:b28a4297e68a4e66f23d8537"],"scopeContentSha256":"d9b0b639500ff3024f1b435d612f2937c50a8dcaf6d5badb145a2db90f1a2afd","contributionContentSha256":"7d068cb5788e4da9ff394bfd1eaa2a12758f96eb105f3ce307bcc23fe853acfb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-proposal","leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d48","kind":"description","unitIndex":48,"unitId":"unit:45088b06df418f90f258efb0c24ec4c20dc8f63e1289ac2111f4b29e0f0c4301","textSha256":"9002919d872ca3025945fbec3be42236cd8bba28936cd848bea53bc6dcf80139"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:afa453f2ff869e1c62e5f53a","recordId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound sign-based conventional-UV obstruction and its associated infrared pathology.","challengeNote":"Compound: sign-based conventional-UV obstruction and its associated infrared pathology.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5163ff5ce8a41793cf9b259d58e4d53199b95e57640128c5d638da324a33a97a","home":{"unitId":"unit:5163ff5ce8a41793cf9b259d58e4d53199b95e57640128c5d638da324a33a97a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4439c1e724e9e3ff7a00ca50","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5163ff5ce8a41793cf9b259d58e4d53199b95e57640128c5d638da324a33a97a","paperId":"1710.09611","textSha256":"19072533ff5226713b7202d122dee026e993855cce1c6973bd99fe6799d9c443"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eb0152b1e8eeea0e805813c8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eb0152b1e8eeea0e805813c8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5163ff5ce8a41793cf9b259d58e4d53199b95e57640128c5d638da324a33a97a","q025-candidate-region:4439c1e724e9e3ff7a00ca50"],"scopeContentSha256":"176bf2d81f8e8913730a689b5cf6d58cf4cec63989b1a6bded70629c7640f83f","placementContentSha256":"d3e26a4034b9b1c0466688e040c0da71090fdf461938266fbbc2a7d2edbae38d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge","leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5163ff5ce8a41793cf9b259d58e4d53199b95e57640128c5d638da324a33a97a","paperId":"1710.09611","textSha256":"19072533ff5226713b7202d122dee026e993855cce1c6973bd99fe6799d9c443"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eb0152b1e8eeea0e805813c8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5163ff5ce8a41793cf9b259d58e4d53199b95e57640128c5d638da324a33a97a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b28a4297e68a4e66f23d8537","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:5163ff5ce8a41793cf9b259d58e4d53199b95e57640128c5d638da324a33a97a","textSha256":"19072533ff5226713b7202d122dee026e993855cce1c6973bd99fe6799d9c443"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1711b93251dfed9a636cfd6a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1711b93251dfed9a636cfd6a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5163ff5ce8a41793cf9b259d58e4d53199b95e57640128c5d638da324a33a97a","q025-candidate-question:b28a4297e68a4e66f23d8537"],"scopeContentSha256":"d9b0b639500ff3024f1b435d612f2937c50a8dcaf6d5badb145a2db90f1a2afd","contributionContentSha256":"5f0e0f816a8b90ec69b028a5e535a21bce2021bc783fb5d75a879e8576fab85a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-proposal","leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:5163ff5ce8a41793cf9b259d58e4d53199b95e57640128c5d638da324a33a97a","textSha256":"19072533ff5226713b7202d122dee026e993855cce1c6973bd99fe6799d9c443"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1711b93251dfed9a636cfd6a","recordId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound positivity compatibility and controlled Vainshtein/cutoff hierarchy.","challengeNote":"Compound: positivity compatibility and controlled Vainshtein/cutoff hierarchies.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:56db8f87d65703ff80f4a3e6811087d0dc9946cfca00e0a456b0f0b0de6a0aee","home":{"unitId":"unit:56db8f87d65703ff80f4a3e6811087d0dc9946cfca00e0a456b0f0b0de6a0aee","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4439c1e724e9e3ff7a00ca50","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:56db8f87d65703ff80f4a3e6811087d0dc9946cfca00e0a456b0f0b0de6a0aee","paperId":"0912.4258","textSha256":"c331e972a85702f06566a3667947a2eba2bd9aaf2081938734e1b6780800ffe5"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c97f8abaea04bcf183954ea9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c97f8abaea04bcf183954ea9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:56db8f87d65703ff80f4a3e6811087d0dc9946cfca00e0a456b0f0b0de6a0aee","q025-candidate-region:4439c1e724e9e3ff7a00ca50"],"scopeContentSha256":"176bf2d81f8e8913730a689b5cf6d58cf4cec63989b1a6bded70629c7640f83f","placementContentSha256":"f1d4dc7d1da76d4ff33b83400b31a31ed768543377ba026ab411c471655bdd11","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge","leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:56db8f87d65703ff80f4a3e6811087d0dc9946cfca00e0a456b0f0b0de6a0aee","paperId":"0912.4258","textSha256":"c331e972a85702f06566a3667947a2eba2bd9aaf2081938734e1b6780800ffe5"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c97f8abaea04bcf183954ea9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:56db8f87d65703ff80f4a3e6811087d0dc9946cfca00e0a456b0f0b0de6a0aee","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b28a4297e68a4e66f23d8537","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:56db8f87d65703ff80f4a3e6811087d0dc9946cfca00e0a456b0f0b0de6a0aee","textSha256":"c331e972a85702f06566a3667947a2eba2bd9aaf2081938734e1b6780800ffe5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:928e2d647648f961ce2df85f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:928e2d647648f961ce2df85f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:56db8f87d65703ff80f4a3e6811087d0dc9946cfca00e0a456b0f0b0de6a0aee","q025-candidate-question:b28a4297e68a4e66f23d8537"],"scopeContentSha256":"d9b0b639500ff3024f1b435d612f2937c50a8dcaf6d5badb145a2db90f1a2afd","contributionContentSha256":"47c4cc1cb636aab947347b38542e52b5483b93143ea999a61ff545ff095e5d0f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-proposal","leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:56db8f87d65703ff80f4a3e6811087d0dc9946cfca00e0a456b0f0b0de6a0aee","textSha256":"c331e972a85702f06566a3667947a2eba2bd9aaf2081938734e1b6780800ffe5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:928e2d647648f961ce2df85f","recordId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: stable NEC violation and simultaneous amplitude/UV-completion compatibility.","challengeNote":"Compound: stable NEC violation, luminal fluctuations and amplitude/UV compatibility remain simultaneous questions.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"413532b2623269a9979071d93a58405fa186dc8ebeb222b88a0656f574cc1917"},"organizational-access:517a0a0f0217e282f18ecb45":{"id":"organizational-access:517a0a0f0217e282f18ecb45","source":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","target":"q025-candidate-question:14e6b7213b2ab6cf07d06535","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b767efda27a7bd28e206e3c3"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:14e6b7213b2ab6cf07d06535","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c02c5053850a785021030ba7cf38a4b8141c686448d27bdcb1fbcbd3d07d0bf0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:92e211d68ca8de19225d315d"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:240df1a912fd507f8b3aa55a9fba546a83a26fc869223942d72d064961dce54e","home":{"unitId":"unit:240df1a912fd507f8b3aa55a9fba546a83a26fc869223942d72d064961dce54e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:240df1a912fd507f8b3aa55a9fba546a83a26fc869223942d72d064961dce54e","paperId":"2504.21508","textSha256":"11f1f58113d167e48f3f0e0e4ebb5590236b51adc7ff94d5b0a4dab39be50254"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:88bb7b8f73c7239a7dbfa7bc"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:88bb7b8f73c7239a7dbfa7bc","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:240df1a912fd507f8b3aa55a9fba546a83a26fc869223942d72d064961dce54e","q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207"],"scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","placementContentSha256":"7e29811693acddec931d2cc74bdc91a89cc273e82ce34a56c70939d9ba093318","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:240df1a912fd507f8b3aa55a9fba546a83a26fc869223942d72d064961dce54e","paperId":"2504.21508","textSha256":"11f1f58113d167e48f3f0e0e4ebb5590236b51adc7ff94d5b0a4dab39be50254"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:88bb7b8f73c7239a7dbfa7bc"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:240df1a912fd507f8b3aa55a9fba546a83a26fc869223942d72d064961dce54e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:14e6b7213b2ab6cf07d06535","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:240df1a912fd507f8b3aa55a9fba546a83a26fc869223942d72d064961dce54e","textSha256":"11f1f58113d167e48f3f0e0e4ebb5590236b51adc7ff94d5b0a4dab39be50254"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8b2fd282633109f9d1cabe32"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8b2fd282633109f9d1cabe32","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:240df1a912fd507f8b3aa55a9fba546a83a26fc869223942d72d064961dce54e","q025-candidate-question:14e6b7213b2ab6cf07d06535"],"scopeContentSha256":"c02c5053850a785021030ba7cf38a4b8141c686448d27bdcb1fbcbd3d07d0bf0","contributionContentSha256":"61371f1b9cfe6b1ae6e37d788615d04e4f252253dfffe715c6ec8f9dfe5b8d23","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:240df1a912fd507f8b3aa55a9fba546a83a26fc869223942d72d064961dce54e","textSha256":"11f1f58113d167e48f3f0e0e4ebb5590236b51adc7ff94d5b0a4dab39be50254"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8b2fd282633109f9d1cabe32","recordId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Fixed tadpoles and quantized fluxes are explicit; supersymmetry and full stabilization are not supplied by this description.","challengeNote":"Fixed tadpoles and quantized fluxes are explicit; supersymmetry and full stabilization are unassessed by this description.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","home":{"unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q28 jointly includes bulk spectra, strong-coupling dual descriptions, retained-modulus stabilization and conditional uplift mechanisms.","qualification":"q28 covers the independent mass-scaling, strong-coupling dual and correction-dependent stabilization/uplift tasks. Its admitted regimes explicitly include strong-coupling alternatives and related uplift branches. The comparison formula and coefficients are not supplied, but their values are unnecessary to identify these targets; neither a mass-scaling law nor successful uplift is inferred. q0, q3 and q19 are individually incomplete.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","textSha256":"8c2614b19f09ade7c79d9af44a0247aaed3e66876173fad52613bf06464cd890"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:annotation:u13:q28"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:annotation:u13:q28","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207"],"scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","placementContentSha256":"36b7f00a26d77fc8c57cc1c0150748ac2900b0e15f5386e37960c4ace658a6bb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:annotation:proposal","placement-pilot:annotation:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","textSha256":"8c2614b19f09ade7c79d9af44a0247aaed3e66876173fad52613bf06464cd890"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:14e6b7213b2ab6cf07d06535","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","textSha256":"8c2614b19f09ade7c79d9af44a0247aaed3e66876173fad52613bf06464cd890"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3e5107df411dc77a34cd618887d4f077","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":23,"start":0,"end":2757,"textSha256":"07670aae1d9238cfb0d73cc57ad12f3e9609ec2015a99862a944b7fce7dc435c","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0accde7f47c9ea3c6065ce8a60f5ee3b","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2825,"textSha256":"c6a8d96152c120a20410c9676ec3abb35b67435d12b5d337b033d4fa134cec90","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b129517d38dadae2762f50ab00c2f986","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":24,"start":0,"end":2148,"textSha256":"1eecd6c8ebf625c74a9836798030901f206e6623ada4d3b617b8006540214287","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b7329b42c339227bab60c06d"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b7329b42c339227bab60c06d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","q025-candidate-question:14e6b7213b2ab6cf07d06535"],"scopeContentSha256":"c02c5053850a785021030ba7cf38a4b8141c686448d27bdcb1fbcbd3d07d0bf0","contributionContentSha256":"397e3cf5845e04e18e0736083bad33ff76530204104fcb5a66b6c4a12c764eb4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","textSha256":"8c2614b19f09ade7c79d9af44a0247aaed3e66876173fad52613bf06464cd890"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3e5107df411dc77a34cd618887d4f077","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":23,"start":0,"end":2757,"textSha256":"07670aae1d9238cfb0d73cc57ad12f3e9609ec2015a99862a944b7fce7dc435c","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0accde7f47c9ea3c6065ce8a60f5ee3b","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2825,"textSha256":"c6a8d96152c120a20410c9676ec3abb35b67435d12b5d337b033d4fa134cec90","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b129517d38dadae2762f50ab00c2f986","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":24,"start":0,"end":2148,"textSha256":"1eecd6c8ebf625c74a9836798030901f206e6623ada4d3b617b8006540214287","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b7329b42c339227bab60c06d","recordId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound identity: anisotropic mass scaling, a strong-coupling dual and correction coefficients are separate unresolved tasks.","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound identity: anisotropic mass scaling, a strong-coupling dual and theory-determined correction coefficients are separate tasks. Supersymmetry-b","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","home":{"unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q28 covers controlled reductions, vacuum stability, geometric scale separation and bulk/holographic spectra within one admitted composite scope.","qualification":"q28 covers the reduction dictionary together with non-supersymmetric IIB AdS3 stability, scale separation and scalar conformal data. q22 organizes reductions but does not independently encompass the hierarchy and holographic-spectrum targets; q15, q19 and q3 cover other components. N=8 refers to the action, and the reported vacuum stability is confined to half-maximal supergravity.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","textSha256":"dc6e7c87b173780eeeaf385ca890b0b5ff47fee0a6fa13b4444498bc74ec7ff2"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:annotation:u14:q28"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:annotation:u14:q28","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207"],"scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","placementContentSha256":"34e408ad514c737c18010b524847e0e95654554a6f4781b729ebb8226aca61c4","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:annotation:proposal","placement-pilot:annotation:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","textSha256":"dc6e7c87b173780eeeaf385ca890b0b5ff47fee0a6fa13b4444498bc74ec7ff2"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:14e6b7213b2ab6cf07d06535","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","textSha256":"dc6e7c87b173780eeeaf385ca890b0b5ff47fee0a6fa13b4444498bc74ec7ff2"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4238766ec6ba911d9ab0ff5a86f82cb4","paperId":"2408.01403","sourceSha256":"c0b3c5c6ddc0120bb0dfc23e08361fb610a0c67947f897000273fd95fc19235e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae20e281219e5d25f4c4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81ab2c9facc2a28c2b259171103ece5b1781564e4831b1b85494f927222f223c","pdfPage":3,"start":2485,"end":4565,"textSha256":"0f81d80fc9122f10cb9ea6881fd9e9d734641da0a6551810c9b87a8b52776f7b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:74879da01477731ec68ee0e2f6d6c9cb","paperId":"2408.01403","sourceSha256":"c0b3c5c6ddc0120bb0dfc23e08361fb610a0c67947f897000273fd95fc19235e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae20e281219e5d25f4c4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81ab2c9facc2a28c2b259171103ece5b1781564e4831b1b85494f927222f223c","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"807b5613fe9960f32ceb38bb947a72230c7d5b8db35c0ed19ea55b3eeebc7f70","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0843928a82de274f8a024acb"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0843928a82de274f8a024acb","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","q025-candidate-question:14e6b7213b2ab6cf07d06535"],"scopeContentSha256":"c02c5053850a785021030ba7cf38a4b8141c686448d27bdcb1fbcbd3d07d0bf0","contributionContentSha256":"d78f54f1fdd37e96bf4e80d65f3cd435197fb703a528d211f1a8f1b33aa0549f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","textSha256":"dc6e7c87b173780eeeaf385ca890b0b5ff47fee0a6fa13b4444498bc74ec7ff2"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4238766ec6ba911d9ab0ff5a86f82cb4","paperId":"2408.01403","sourceSha256":"c0b3c5c6ddc0120bb0dfc23e08361fb610a0c67947f897000273fd95fc19235e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae20e281219e5d25f4c4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81ab2c9facc2a28c2b259171103ece5b1781564e4831b1b85494f927222f223c","pdfPage":3,"start":2485,"end":4565,"textSha256":"0f81d80fc9122f10cb9ea6881fd9e9d734641da0a6551810c9b87a8b52776f7b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:74879da01477731ec68ee0e2f6d6c9cb","paperId":"2408.01403","sourceSha256":"c0b3c5c6ddc0120bb0dfc23e08361fb610a0c67947f897000273fd95fc19235e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae20e281219e5d25f4c4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81ab2c9facc2a28c2b259171103ece5b1781564e4831b1b85494f927222f223c","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"807b5613fe9960f32ceb38bb947a72230c7d5b8db35c0ed19ea55b3eeebc7f70","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0843928a82de274f8a024acb","recordId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound reduction dictionary and vacuum/spectrum study. N=8 describes the action; reported stability of non-SUSY IIB vacua is within half-maximal supergravity.","challengeNote":"Compound reduction dictionary and vacuum/spectrum study. N=8 labels the action; announced non-SUSY IIB stability is restricted to half-maximal supergravity.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b81888fd70a75583d4154833243ba852daf7cbeb34bae8a357b79d92219a0bec","home":{"unitId":"unit:b81888fd70a75583d4154833243ba852daf7cbeb34bae8a357b79d92219a0bec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b81888fd70a75583d4154833243ba852daf7cbeb34bae8a357b79d92219a0bec","paperId":"2509.12801","textSha256":"7437a00fae63685b9e9665637ee9c2171cdfbc01ddd04cce07ac7a062926c3a4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:abb67cedaa42f17908377d7a"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:abb67cedaa42f17908377d7a","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b81888fd70a75583d4154833243ba852daf7cbeb34bae8a357b79d92219a0bec","q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207"],"scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","placementContentSha256":"0afdcaabafb73510e153090d6cb8e1c05c9690dc9a791a4253a6564847b3928a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b81888fd70a75583d4154833243ba852daf7cbeb34bae8a357b79d92219a0bec","paperId":"2509.12801","textSha256":"7437a00fae63685b9e9665637ee9c2171cdfbc01ddd04cce07ac7a062926c3a4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:abb67cedaa42f17908377d7a"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b81888fd70a75583d4154833243ba852daf7cbeb34bae8a357b79d92219a0bec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:14e6b7213b2ab6cf07d06535","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:b81888fd70a75583d4154833243ba852daf7cbeb34bae8a357b79d92219a0bec","textSha256":"7437a00fae63685b9e9665637ee9c2171cdfbc01ddd04cce07ac7a062926c3a4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6f169f943cfb039b7af2cb41"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6f169f943cfb039b7af2cb41","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b81888fd70a75583d4154833243ba852daf7cbeb34bae8a357b79d92219a0bec","q025-candidate-question:14e6b7213b2ab6cf07d06535"],"scopeContentSha256":"c02c5053850a785021030ba7cf38a4b8141c686448d27bdcb1fbcbd3d07d0bf0","contributionContentSha256":"fefe7475dd8b73fd8ceaccad24c04ef1290ef002931fb877794643fab3c82921","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:b81888fd70a75583d4154833243ba852daf7cbeb34bae8a357b79d92219a0bec","textSha256":"7437a00fae63685b9e9665637ee9c2171cdfbc01ddd04cce07ac7a062926c3a4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6f169f943cfb039b7af2cb41","recordId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Bulk stabilization and integer versus asymptotically integer dimensions retain their stated scopes.","challengeNote":"Bulk stabilization and integer versus asymptotically integer dimensions retain their stated scopes.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:fc93be0f45a10d53774f8b9ce90bebbfda512735ee01be90820224ec6df66722","home":{"unitId":"unit:fc93be0f45a10d53774f8b9ce90bebbfda512735ee01be90820224ec6df66722","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q28 jointly covers G2-orientifold hierarchy constructions, limiting conformal spectra and stabilization of the retained moduli.","qualification":"q28 includes the full compatibility question among massive-IIA G2 flux choices, supersymmetric AdS3 scale separation, limiting scalar dimensions and retained-modulus stabilization. q3 lacks the independent KK hierarchy target, while q5 and q15 lack the full conformal-spectrum target. The modulus-retaining branch and modified-flux stabilization aim remain distinct, as do near-integer, limiting-integer and corrected exact spectra. No full-field stabilization result is inferred.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fc93be0f45a10d53774f8b9ce90bebbfda512735ee01be90820224ec6df66722","textSha256":"656a5d578b4207292e5e03ff3201bd19d4e548d5a4996a5b9afaafecd1f63d79"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:annotation:u16:q28"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:annotation:u16:q28","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fc93be0f45a10d53774f8b9ce90bebbfda512735ee01be90820224ec6df66722","q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207"],"scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","placementContentSha256":"14304e393d3cb4e92f3827cf2aa4a84e21117d2819cf249860ae9254ad94e4e1","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:annotation:proposal","placement-pilot:annotation:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fc93be0f45a10d53774f8b9ce90bebbfda512735ee01be90820224ec6df66722","textSha256":"656a5d578b4207292e5e03ff3201bd19d4e548d5a4996a5b9afaafecd1f63d79"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:fc93be0f45a10d53774f8b9ce90bebbfda512735ee01be90820224ec6df66722"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fc93be0f45a10d53774f8b9ce90bebbfda512735ee01be90820224ec6df66722","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:14e6b7213b2ab6cf07d06535","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:fc93be0f45a10d53774f8b9ce90bebbfda512735ee01be90820224ec6df66722","textSha256":"656a5d578b4207292e5e03ff3201bd19d4e548d5a4996a5b9afaafecd1f63d79"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:582076d7a84888301eddf8789e6ce4c5","paperId":"2502.08215","sourceSha256":"b55f07fda07f36deda256b800b2123d5faebf7b435bfd4165c621a545327efb5","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3e53533069713de369c8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32132f4e8510553212375d2d3de650eea6818d4e7373d8b25f3b5647926e2e4e","pdfPage":3,"start":1293,"end":3399,"textSha256":"c734fabc95b19e83655cd5e234703e6032a881473f864ab481b0078d8553cc22","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:be8cd20699acc9a22946eb25cc4e91c6","paperId":"2502.08215","sourceSha256":"b55f07fda07f36deda256b800b2123d5faebf7b435bfd4165c621a545327efb5","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3e53533069713de369c8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32132f4e8510553212375d2d3de650eea6818d4e7373d8b25f3b5647926e2e4e","pdfPage":12,"start":103,"end":2266,"textSha256":"91d43732037706bf36e8b3dfe822e3423bf59a676c5eece0ed8fa87be4aa4ff8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bd5128579df00ebeb372e61e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:bd5128579df00ebeb372e61e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fc93be0f45a10d53774f8b9ce90bebbfda512735ee01be90820224ec6df66722","q025-candidate-question:14e6b7213b2ab6cf07d06535"],"scopeContentSha256":"c02c5053850a785021030ba7cf38a4b8141c686448d27bdcb1fbcbd3d07d0bf0","contributionContentSha256":"c00a3fe166718e25ec57f00f2b593a6b8cb2689ddacdb637a537856385cd4572","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:fc93be0f45a10d53774f8b9ce90bebbfda512735ee01be90820224ec6df66722","textSha256":"656a5d578b4207292e5e03ff3201bd19d4e548d5a4996a5b9afaafecd1f63d79"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:582076d7a84888301eddf8789e6ce4c5","paperId":"2502.08215","sourceSha256":"b55f07fda07f36deda256b800b2123d5faebf7b435bfd4165c621a545327efb5","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3e53533069713de369c8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32132f4e8510553212375d2d3de650eea6818d4e7373d8b25f3b5647926e2e4e","pdfPage":3,"start":1293,"end":3399,"textSha256":"c734fabc95b19e83655cd5e234703e6032a881473f864ab481b0078d8553cc22","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:be8cd20699acc9a22946eb25cc4e91c6","paperId":"2502.08215","sourceSha256":"b55f07fda07f36deda256b800b2123d5faebf7b435bfd4165c621a545327efb5","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3e53533069713de369c8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32132f4e8510553212375d2d3de650eea6818d4e7373d8b25f3b5647926e2e4e","pdfPage":12,"start":103,"end":2266,"textSha256":"91d43732037706bf36e8b3dfe822e3423bf59a676c5eece0ed8fa87be4aa4ff8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bd5128579df00ebeb372e61e","recordId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"A discussed branch retains a modulus; the excerpt then seeks full stabilization with near-integer dimensions. Corrections threaten exact integrality.","challengeNote":"One branch retains a modulus; the supplied page then seeks stabilization with limiting integrality through changed flux/tadpole choices. Corrected spectra need ","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":5,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"e9a706c3a849ad0f0e7055c65d955c1c3831853becc669d818adb99b636724de"},"organizational-access:80ca080fdf57ce4ec9cad785":{"id":"organizational-access:80ca080fdf57ce4ec9cad785","source":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","target":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b767efda27a7bd28e206e3c3"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ad449becadd3a4e1ef632d22d11437ab8b2060c64f934db103812d0ed558ea64","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e63d372fde3b4b8f1ee681f8"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:dac66f21f9b37768247e585a5639e18b13725b83df6887af681d55d4bd8dd0a0","home":{"unitId":"unit:dac66f21f9b37768247e585a5639e18b13725b83df6887af681d55d4bd8dd0a0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:dac66f21f9b37768247e585a5639e18b13725b83df6887af681d55d4bd8dd0a0","paperId":"2210.08466","textSha256":"64211bd3490ebce9ee341273736ec42611347dd5c33a5c6caf63a384ffec87d1"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9118f21de2ec7c460521176b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9118f21de2ec7c460521176b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:dac66f21f9b37768247e585a5639e18b13725b83df6887af681d55d4bd8dd0a0","q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207"],"scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","placementContentSha256":"c157895215d01c732e91999e74501b5f8794ad3a01a96af8b57de0a4abe8025a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:dac66f21f9b37768247e585a5639e18b13725b83df6887af681d55d4bd8dd0a0","paperId":"2210.08466","textSha256":"64211bd3490ebce9ee341273736ec42611347dd5c33a5c6caf63a384ffec87d1"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9118f21de2ec7c460521176b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:dac66f21f9b37768247e585a5639e18b13725b83df6887af681d55d4bd8dd0a0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d81","kind":"description","unitIndex":81,"unitId":"unit:dac66f21f9b37768247e585a5639e18b13725b83df6887af681d55d4bd8dd0a0","textSha256":"64211bd3490ebce9ee341273736ec42611347dd5c33a5c6caf63a384ffec87d1"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:177fde577f2d52ac71037ad2ac30af34","paperId":"2210.08466","sourceSha256":"cd076166030d44e986e63be845f04be33597a479e9ea8dd59525f81fabc5c298","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/268990978cefc2e4ada8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bbb80c293508991720c49775db73f833ff7970278c31ae12ad6f2ad95bac8e36","pdfPage":142,"start":1291,"end":4083,"textSha256":"ceccb8fa02d9cb2c9143cee4d80729b153b04e59accbb5fe4801e2af0ac88d41","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b5558e445cc3b2d36fadb20cc0dfaff7","paperId":"2210.08466","sourceSha256":"cd076166030d44e986e63be845f04be33597a479e9ea8dd59525f81fabc5c298","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/268990978cefc2e4ada8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bbb80c293508991720c49775db73f833ff7970278c31ae12ad6f2ad95bac8e36","pdfPage":141,"start":0,"end":2957,"textSha256":"326537c56b09d3a1e9d962fed33001f826adf1ae7f7caf671d356b2908dfea67","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:503c98c3c32537a366fd58781f39c1ee","paperId":"2210.08466","sourceSha256":"cd076166030d44e986e63be845f04be33597a479e9ea8dd59525f81fabc5c298","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/268990978cefc2e4ada8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bbb80c293508991720c49775db73f833ff7970278c31ae12ad6f2ad95bac8e36","pdfPage":142,"start":97,"end":3490,"textSha256":"e49b3337fe695161e32dfcf486832db0e3c673f49c8efe7449e083eb166faef2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3e1bac79973c604243ad464f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3e1bac79973c604243ad464f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:dac66f21f9b37768247e585a5639e18b13725b83df6887af681d55d4bd8dd0a0","q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e"],"scopeContentSha256":"ad449becadd3a4e1ef632d22d11437ab8b2060c64f934db103812d0ed558ea64","contributionContentSha256":"2cd8030318b0d66f427adeebd9857912b8c90d9646da72c7ae09c1a275839078","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d81","kind":"description","unitIndex":81,"unitId":"unit:dac66f21f9b37768247e585a5639e18b13725b83df6887af681d55d4bd8dd0a0","textSha256":"64211bd3490ebce9ee341273736ec42611347dd5c33a5c6caf63a384ffec87d1"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:177fde577f2d52ac71037ad2ac30af34","paperId":"2210.08466","sourceSha256":"cd076166030d44e986e63be845f04be33597a479e9ea8dd59525f81fabc5c298","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/268990978cefc2e4ada8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bbb80c293508991720c49775db73f833ff7970278c31ae12ad6f2ad95bac8e36","pdfPage":142,"start":1291,"end":4083,"textSha256":"ceccb8fa02d9cb2c9143cee4d80729b153b04e59accbb5fe4801e2af0ac88d41","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b5558e445cc3b2d36fadb20cc0dfaff7","paperId":"2210.08466","sourceSha256":"cd076166030d44e986e63be845f04be33597a479e9ea8dd59525f81fabc5c298","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/268990978cefc2e4ada8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bbb80c293508991720c49775db73f833ff7970278c31ae12ad6f2ad95bac8e36","pdfPage":141,"start":0,"end":2957,"textSha256":"326537c56b09d3a1e9d962fed33001f826adf1ae7f7caf671d356b2908dfea67","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:503c98c3c32537a366fd58781f39c1ee","paperId":"2210.08466","sourceSha256":"cd076166030d44e986e63be845f04be33597a479e9ea8dd59525f81fabc5c298","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/268990978cefc2e4ada8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bbb80c293508991720c49775db73f833ff7970278c31ae12ad6f2ad95bac8e36","pdfPage":142,"start":97,"end":3490,"textSha256":"e49b3337fe695161e32dfcf486832db0e3c673f49c8efe7449e083eb166faef2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3e1bac79973c604243ad464f","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound thesis scope. RR/NSNS and geometric-flux cases differ; localization is first order in g_s. D8/D6 Q>T is reported for a specified nonsupersymmetric case","challengeNote":"Compound thesis scope. RR/NSNS and geometric-flux results differ; localization is first order in gs, omitting higher-order O6 intersections. Q>T is reported fo","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"c1d51f2fdd6fc1c230fc423cce5036be2b527f3634e8c4ebb5d672681ae4dac3"},"organizational-access:263b0d1afda098688bf8e5a0":{"id":"organizational-access:263b0d1afda098688bf8e5a0","source":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","target":"q025-candidate-question:d802fb52bfa7607aab454d3c","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b767efda27a7bd28e206e3c3"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:d802fb52bfa7607aab454d3c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b3885a19a35790f8caa210b7bcbea2bfd7b07846e4a30de2fc3e31a4aa7119a9","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0df0882410076c4dfdb7868a"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:33d0c2a3705f57fc8845ce127dea15e2f73f1903a0048b696bf78333656fcebd","home":{"unitId":"unit:33d0c2a3705f57fc8845ce127dea15e2f73f1903a0048b696bf78333656fcebd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:33d0c2a3705f57fc8845ce127dea15e2f73f1903a0048b696bf78333656fcebd","paperId":"2005.05246","textSha256":"ed238292602d0d52e233c27c201ae6d73bb8810419998d882a307256aa760107"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0e01d818fb76e8860fe378a5b3075516","paperId":"2005.05246","sourceSha256":"804f0e5ed6ff71e9875c3fae2f9b71d6d021c4fb8f16a9107fede7ee20f77f5b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/85d1a388c79da984b334/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"612157a240f4a962d5ba3b08b1ee9a4b25e955b2d788b55b68435ec1128666de","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1131,"textSha256":"f9c503cd19d58dbb2a6eb8b1821058bc1f8fcfbfce884c38aeabdf47c9c80afc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ae32e9308bfbadf025110336ada225b8","paperId":"2005.05246","sourceSha256":"804f0e5ed6ff71e9875c3fae2f9b71d6d021c4fb8f16a9107fede7ee20f77f5b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/85d1a388c79da984b334/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"612157a240f4a962d5ba3b08b1ee9a4b25e955b2d788b55b68435ec1128666de","pdfPage":3,"start":102,"end":3343,"textSha256":"6ca63991f7135cb4a3fe45bf885fab07acc2870da506ee3f7ce9560478e8a1f9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:017464f5e26a3814362bce04"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:017464f5e26a3814362bce04","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:33d0c2a3705f57fc8845ce127dea15e2f73f1903a0048b696bf78333656fcebd","q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207"],"scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","placementContentSha256":"927be3f6ff62b652f0fc8e4f7557c9337d19c8f39c06048942cd86b344c6e19b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:33d0c2a3705f57fc8845ce127dea15e2f73f1903a0048b696bf78333656fcebd","paperId":"2005.05246","textSha256":"ed238292602d0d52e233c27c201ae6d73bb8810419998d882a307256aa760107"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0e01d818fb76e8860fe378a5b3075516","paperId":"2005.05246","sourceSha256":"804f0e5ed6ff71e9875c3fae2f9b71d6d021c4fb8f16a9107fede7ee20f77f5b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/85d1a388c79da984b334/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"612157a240f4a962d5ba3b08b1ee9a4b25e955b2d788b55b68435ec1128666de","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1131,"textSha256":"f9c503cd19d58dbb2a6eb8b1821058bc1f8fcfbfce884c38aeabdf47c9c80afc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ae32e9308bfbadf025110336ada225b8","paperId":"2005.05246","sourceSha256":"804f0e5ed6ff71e9875c3fae2f9b71d6d021c4fb8f16a9107fede7ee20f77f5b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/85d1a388c79da984b334/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"612157a240f4a962d5ba3b08b1ee9a4b25e955b2d788b55b68435ec1128666de","pdfPage":3,"start":102,"end":3343,"textSha256":"6ca63991f7135cb4a3fe45bf885fab07acc2870da506ee3f7ce9560478e8a1f9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:017464f5e26a3814362bce04"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:33d0c2a3705f57fc8845ce127dea15e2f73f1903a0048b696bf78333656fcebd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d802fb52bfa7607aab454d3c","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:33d0c2a3705f57fc8845ce127dea15e2f73f1903a0048b696bf78333656fcebd","textSha256":"ed238292602d0d52e233c27c201ae6d73bb8810419998d882a307256aa760107"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0e01d818fb76e8860fe378a5b3075516","paperId":"2005.05246","sourceSha256":"804f0e5ed6ff71e9875c3fae2f9b71d6d021c4fb8f16a9107fede7ee20f77f5b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/85d1a388c79da984b334/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"612157a240f4a962d5ba3b08b1ee9a4b25e955b2d788b55b68435ec1128666de","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1131,"textSha256":"f9c503cd19d58dbb2a6eb8b1821058bc1f8fcfbfce884c38aeabdf47c9c80afc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ae32e9308bfbadf025110336ada225b8","paperId":"2005.05246","sourceSha256":"804f0e5ed6ff71e9875c3fae2f9b71d6d021c4fb8f16a9107fede7ee20f77f5b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/85d1a388c79da984b334/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"612157a240f4a962d5ba3b08b1ee9a4b25e955b2d788b55b68435ec1128666de","pdfPage":3,"start":102,"end":3343,"textSha256":"6ca63991f7135cb4a3fe45bf885fab07acc2870da506ee3f7ce9560478e8a1f9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8fce152d318e54bdac06b2b6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8fce152d318e54bdac06b2b6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:33d0c2a3705f57fc8845ce127dea15e2f73f1903a0048b696bf78333656fcebd","q025-candidate-question:d802fb52bfa7607aab454d3c"],"scopeContentSha256":"b3885a19a35790f8caa210b7bcbea2bfd7b07846e4a30de2fc3e31a4aa7119a9","contributionContentSha256":"cc119516e69889fc7523b108eb9daba34dbb3332a69dbb9b8157d0ac69958f99","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:33d0c2a3705f57fc8845ce127dea15e2f73f1903a0048b696bf78333656fcebd","textSha256":"ed238292602d0d52e233c27c201ae6d73bb8810419998d882a307256aa760107"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0e01d818fb76e8860fe378a5b3075516","paperId":"2005.05246","sourceSha256":"804f0e5ed6ff71e9875c3fae2f9b71d6d021c4fb8f16a9107fede7ee20f77f5b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/85d1a388c79da984b334/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"612157a240f4a962d5ba3b08b1ee9a4b25e955b2d788b55b68435ec1128666de","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1131,"textSha256":"f9c503cd19d58dbb2a6eb8b1821058bc1f8fcfbfce884c38aeabdf47c9c80afc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ae32e9308bfbadf025110336ada225b8","paperId":"2005.05246","sourceSha256":"804f0e5ed6ff71e9875c3fae2f9b71d6d021c4fb8f16a9107fede7ee20f77f5b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/85d1a388c79da984b334/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"612157a240f4a962d5ba3b08b1ee9a4b25e955b2d788b55b68435ec1128666de","pdfPage":3,"start":102,"end":3343,"textSha256":"6ca63991f7135cb4a3fe45bf885fab07acc2870da506ee3f7ce9560478e8a1f9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8fce152d318e54bdac06b2b6","recordId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound no-scale Minkowski and Romans-mass AdS3 branches. The AdS account is a smeared 3D description; holography is future motivation.","challengeNote":"Compound no-scale Minkowski and Romans-mass AdS3 branches. The AdS account is a smeared 3D description; the paper explicitly leaves holography for future work.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","home":{"unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q28 covers controlled reductions, vacuum stability, geometric scale separation and bulk/holographic spectra within one admitted composite scope.","qualification":"q28 covers the reduction dictionary together with non-supersymmetric IIB AdS3 stability, scale separation and scalar conformal data. q22 organizes reductions but does not independently encompass the hierarchy and holographic-spectrum targets; q15, q19 and q3 cover other components. N=8 refers to the action, and the reported vacuum stability is confined to half-maximal supergravity.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","textSha256":"dc6e7c87b173780eeeaf385ca890b0b5ff47fee0a6fa13b4444498bc74ec7ff2"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:annotation:u14:q28"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:annotation:u14:q28","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207"],"scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","placementContentSha256":"34e408ad514c737c18010b524847e0e95654554a6f4781b729ebb8226aca61c4","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:annotation:proposal","placement-pilot:annotation:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","textSha256":"dc6e7c87b173780eeeaf385ca890b0b5ff47fee0a6fa13b4444498bc74ec7ff2"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d802fb52bfa7607aab454d3c","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","textSha256":"dc6e7c87b173780eeeaf385ca890b0b5ff47fee0a6fa13b4444498bc74ec7ff2"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4238766ec6ba911d9ab0ff5a86f82cb4","paperId":"2408.01403","sourceSha256":"c0b3c5c6ddc0120bb0dfc23e08361fb610a0c67947f897000273fd95fc19235e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae20e281219e5d25f4c4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81ab2c9facc2a28c2b259171103ece5b1781564e4831b1b85494f927222f223c","pdfPage":3,"start":2485,"end":4565,"textSha256":"0f81d80fc9122f10cb9ea6881fd9e9d734641da0a6551810c9b87a8b52776f7b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:74879da01477731ec68ee0e2f6d6c9cb","paperId":"2408.01403","sourceSha256":"c0b3c5c6ddc0120bb0dfc23e08361fb610a0c67947f897000273fd95fc19235e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae20e281219e5d25f4c4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81ab2c9facc2a28c2b259171103ece5b1781564e4831b1b85494f927222f223c","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"807b5613fe9960f32ceb38bb947a72230c7d5b8db35c0ed19ea55b3eeebc7f70","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:180c8f047894f1294bc49b80"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:180c8f047894f1294bc49b80","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","q025-candidate-question:d802fb52bfa7607aab454d3c"],"scopeContentSha256":"b3885a19a35790f8caa210b7bcbea2bfd7b07846e4a30de2fc3e31a4aa7119a9","contributionContentSha256":"3a649502fab79b9eb3e643148ce5a5a7cdeb5b9131456648e3ad73640226017d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:6375ee9cc082461a6aae533f9c2336ded674db1fa0d7ed313f7fa2384d35f336","textSha256":"dc6e7c87b173780eeeaf385ca890b0b5ff47fee0a6fa13b4444498bc74ec7ff2"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4238766ec6ba911d9ab0ff5a86f82cb4","paperId":"2408.01403","sourceSha256":"c0b3c5c6ddc0120bb0dfc23e08361fb610a0c67947f897000273fd95fc19235e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae20e281219e5d25f4c4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81ab2c9facc2a28c2b259171103ece5b1781564e4831b1b85494f927222f223c","pdfPage":3,"start":2485,"end":4565,"textSha256":"0f81d80fc9122f10cb9ea6881fd9e9d734641da0a6551810c9b87a8b52776f7b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:74879da01477731ec68ee0e2f6d6c9cb","paperId":"2408.01403","sourceSha256":"c0b3c5c6ddc0120bb0dfc23e08361fb610a0c67947f897000273fd95fc19235e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae20e281219e5d25f4c4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81ab2c9facc2a28c2b259171103ece5b1781564e4831b1b85494f927222f223c","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"807b5613fe9960f32ceb38bb947a72230c7d5b8db35c0ed19ea55b3eeebc7f70","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:180c8f047894f1294bc49b80","recordId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound reduction dictionary and vacuum/spectrum study. N=8 describes the action; reported stability of non-SUSY IIB vacua is within half-maximal supergravity.","challengeNote":"Compound reduction dictionary and vacuum/spectrum study. N=8 labels the action; announced non-SUSY IIB stability is restricted to half-maximal supergravity.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:96cf67edcc103041bbbf76e6a35f99ef32579e6e84aff5defc90c83d610710dc","home":{"unitId":"unit:96cf67edcc103041bbbf76e6a35f99ef32579e6e84aff5defc90c83d610710dc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"The admitted AdS compactification region jointly covers controlled reductions, maximal truncation neighbors, retained moduli, vacuum stability and higher-dimensional descriptions.","qualification":"q43 combines effective-description, retained-moduli, vacuum-stability and uplift questions and explicitly includes maximal truncations as qualified neighbors. It therefore covers the complete flux/truncation/deformation program without requiring scale separation. q37 alone does not establish the full global-moduli and stability coverage; q30 alone omits the truncation-construction target.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:96cf67edcc103041bbbf76e6a35f99ef32579e6e84aff5defc90c83d610710dc","paperId":"2306.12487","textSha256":"ce78ae8f5080b6186e18f03b908fec3d0f7a88c020a93b222cb7b4e2986a7c44"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0074:u22:q43"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0074:u22:q43","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:96cf67edcc103041bbbf76e6a35f99ef32579e6e84aff5defc90c83d610710dc","q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207"],"scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","placementContentSha256":"48f2203ab0ff30cfc61ec451a30e6242b601c1a050c120576b0680347f311856","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0074:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0074:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-05"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:96cf67edcc103041bbbf76e6a35f99ef32579e6e84aff5defc90c83d610710dc","paperId":"2306.12487","textSha256":"ce78ae8f5080b6186e18f03b908fec3d0f7a88c020a93b222cb7b4e2986a7c44"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-05/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"6079f3dff4de3bce86aff04cfa91b1a0da7ebf86722c5c33e44b4f563ac45e8e"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-05/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"b73dfbc8974cebd1c5c02da428f1652a9b6f36d6a1073a93ae692399858c7d3e","bytes":1594204,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0074","unitRef":"u22"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:96cf67edcc103041bbbf76e6a35f99ef32579e6e84aff5defc90c83d610710dc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d802fb52bfa7607aab454d3c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:96cf67edcc103041bbbf76e6a35f99ef32579e6e84aff5defc90c83d610710dc","textSha256":"ce78ae8f5080b6186e18f03b908fec3d0f7a88c020a93b222cb7b4e2986a7c44"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:43469994caeeb7ece5b47aeb"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:43469994caeeb7ece5b47aeb","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:96cf67edcc103041bbbf76e6a35f99ef32579e6e84aff5defc90c83d610710dc","q025-candidate-question:d802fb52bfa7607aab454d3c"],"scopeContentSha256":"b3885a19a35790f8caa210b7bcbea2bfd7b07846e4a30de2fc3e31a4aa7119a9","contributionContentSha256":"639ad464a9654028e5b011307a8b804b87ad7ea5b4a1ba73117890ae0f4ba489","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:96cf67edcc103041bbbf76e6a35f99ef32579e6e84aff5defc90c83d610710dc","textSha256":"ce78ae8f5080b6186e18f03b908fec3d0f7a88c020a93b222cb7b4e2986a7c44"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:43469994caeeb7ece5b47aeb","recordId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The linked truncation, deformation, stability and global-moduli targets remain source-scoped. No parametric hierarchy is asserted.","challengeNote":"Truncation, deformations, stability and global moduli remain compound source-scoped targets. No parametric hierarchy is asserted.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ddb8c386e4972539a253c99edae2ddea20ad034449f628f7852f87787619d295"},"organizational-access:b382395bea770a6e3af4fb4e":{"id":"organizational-access:b382395bea770a6e3af4fb4e","source":"q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a","target":"q025-candidate-question:e3f30f854573155119688234","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"30c36f42402d35fe28afd0916c0fd8f432c8e7cf296dc1a1d7ad4d05de84583c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5829fa4ebe39e2aa42ded4f1"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e3f30f854573155119688234","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"34fa4656de2febee673ef6f2480ac81e4666168d11e234073f4f64b376ae51d7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8b3388e2d7a18205809b2665"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:267c9d114dcd4a96e133acc07bade7e518590a9f6126809d5640f6fadba1c0ef","home":{"unitId":"unit:267c9d114dcd4a96e133acc07bade7e518590a9f6126809d5640f6fadba1c0ef","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:267c9d114dcd4a96e133acc07bade7e518590a9f6126809d5640f6fadba1c0ef","paperId":"hep-th/9812035","textSha256":"e4aaac21fef1ff5f0d40b7eb26fb182706137392f68d12380c9d9e9cf4bfd793"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:76b9048502efd6c0d31a2e15"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:76b9048502efd6c0d31a2e15","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:267c9d114dcd4a96e133acc07bade7e518590a9f6126809d5640f6fadba1c0ef","q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a"],"scopeContentSha256":"30c36f42402d35fe28afd0916c0fd8f432c8e7cf296dc1a1d7ad4d05de84583c","placementContentSha256":"f1b48dcaf7218d5be133781e4d6f0685ab3224fcd90313b54a15b7eae9607699","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge","leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:267c9d114dcd4a96e133acc07bade7e518590a9f6126809d5640f6fadba1c0ef","paperId":"hep-th/9812035","textSha256":"e4aaac21fef1ff5f0d40b7eb26fb182706137392f68d12380c9d9e9cf4bfd793"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:76b9048502efd6c0d31a2e15"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:267c9d114dcd4a96e133acc07bade7e518590a9f6126809d5640f6fadba1c0ef","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e3f30f854573155119688234","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:267c9d114dcd4a96e133acc07bade7e518590a9f6126809d5640f6fadba1c0ef","textSha256":"e4aaac21fef1ff5f0d40b7eb26fb182706137392f68d12380c9d9e9cf4bfd793"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a676b792770994caa8699e97"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a676b792770994caa8699e97","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:267c9d114dcd4a96e133acc07bade7e518590a9f6126809d5640f6fadba1c0ef","q025-candidate-question:e3f30f854573155119688234"],"scopeContentSha256":"34fa4656de2febee673ef6f2480ac81e4666168d11e234073f4f64b376ae51d7","contributionContentSha256":"d4fd6bbb40a9f04b879fac89965fe8387d3f0c20aa5edf223c17a714ec1307ef","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:267c9d114dcd4a96e133acc07bade7e518590a9f6126809d5640f6fadba1c0ef","textSha256":"e4aaac21fef1ff5f0d40b7eb26fb182706137392f68d12380c9d9e9cf4bfd793"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a676b792770994caa8699e97","recordId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Critical-point observables and ten-dimensional conformal interpretations remain compound and sector-specific.","challengeNote":"Critical-point properties and proposed ten-dimensional conformal interpretations remain compound and sector-specific.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:deca2d8dff89afffc834ced7053fa34b5fc34e8c05d51c6c1da2a2c06b9f5870","home":{"unitId":"unit:deca2d8dff89afffc834ced7053fa34b5fc34e8c05d51c6c1da2a2c06b9f5870","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:deca2d8dff89afffc834ced7053fa34b5fc34e8c05d51c6c1da2a2c06b9f5870","paperId":"2312.15777","textSha256":"cac9d97a587d8f3d56da7f08c3e71195dbcda3181ca6396becd3c847041dd5ec"},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5e4c84490019cd5816e21455535a1099","paperId":"2312.15777","sourceSha256":"dcf86af4ba63baa8b5c0438bcaef90c7d6e3c856cd846a5e79a62b85f7b4ab36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/367ab2909e8534049df7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5aae1fb87439e7462e93f5e856a7686d63e4b25d73859bad42c50965c469c386","pdfPage":2,"start":1293,"end":3122,"textSha256":"df140d2d6083aa1975f1c87dff61230f337e7382c9bf82cd69b374c63677d10e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:89b705469b1a7d8a5d9e67aa2564e88b","paperId":"2312.15777","sourceSha256":"dcf86af4ba63baa8b5c0438bcaef90c7d6e3c856cd846a5e79a62b85f7b4ab36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/367ab2909e8534049df7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5aae1fb87439e7462e93f5e856a7686d63e4b25d73859bad42c50965c469c386","pdfPage":16,"start":106,"end":2014,"textSha256":"eee2a879d2e235ed5e68718f6cf3530f31e2d5d18204d94fcb6581ac6d3da6a1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d6238eceef87f258c22e24b69455f91b","paperId":"2312.15777","sourceSha256":"dcf86af4ba63baa8b5c0438bcaef90c7d6e3c856cd846a5e79a62b85f7b4ab36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/367ab2909e8534049df7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5aae1fb87439e7462e93f5e856a7686d63e4b25d73859bad42c50965c469c386","pdfPage":2,"start":94,"end":3122,"textSha256":"360d508f2de9a744041498fd7ff8c941de05efe3db12e2eaa338c8bb1ff0f7db","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a5ff0e9f127fb00cbc12071f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a5ff0e9f127fb00cbc12071f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:deca2d8dff89afffc834ced7053fa34b5fc34e8c05d51c6c1da2a2c06b9f5870","q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a"],"scopeContentSha256":"30c36f42402d35fe28afd0916c0fd8f432c8e7cf296dc1a1d7ad4d05de84583c","placementContentSha256":"7cc5564b5a5f533b2eff8fc3b30fb4b5798580305edff70578e019d60840e373","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge","leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:deca2d8dff89afffc834ced7053fa34b5fc34e8c05d51c6c1da2a2c06b9f5870","paperId":"2312.15777","textSha256":"cac9d97a587d8f3d56da7f08c3e71195dbcda3181ca6396becd3c847041dd5ec"},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5e4c84490019cd5816e21455535a1099","paperId":"2312.15777","sourceSha256":"dcf86af4ba63baa8b5c0438bcaef90c7d6e3c856cd846a5e79a62b85f7b4ab36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/367ab2909e8534049df7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5aae1fb87439e7462e93f5e856a7686d63e4b25d73859bad42c50965c469c386","pdfPage":2,"start":1293,"end":3122,"textSha256":"df140d2d6083aa1975f1c87dff61230f337e7382c9bf82cd69b374c63677d10e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:89b705469b1a7d8a5d9e67aa2564e88b","paperId":"2312.15777","sourceSha256":"dcf86af4ba63baa8b5c0438bcaef90c7d6e3c856cd846a5e79a62b85f7b4ab36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/367ab2909e8534049df7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5aae1fb87439e7462e93f5e856a7686d63e4b25d73859bad42c50965c469c386","pdfPage":16,"start":106,"end":2014,"textSha256":"eee2a879d2e235ed5e68718f6cf3530f31e2d5d18204d94fcb6581ac6d3da6a1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d6238eceef87f258c22e24b69455f91b","paperId":"2312.15777","sourceSha256":"dcf86af4ba63baa8b5c0438bcaef90c7d6e3c856cd846a5e79a62b85f7b4ab36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/367ab2909e8534049df7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5aae1fb87439e7462e93f5e856a7686d63e4b25d73859bad42c50965c469c386","pdfPage":2,"start":94,"end":3122,"textSha256":"360d508f2de9a744041498fd7ff8c941de05efe3db12e2eaa338c8bb1ff0f7db","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a5ff0e9f127fb00cbc12071f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:deca2d8dff89afffc834ced7053fa34b5fc34e8c05d51c6c1da2a2c06b9f5870","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e3f30f854573155119688234","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:deca2d8dff89afffc834ced7053fa34b5fc34e8c05d51c6c1da2a2c06b9f5870","textSha256":"cac9d97a587d8f3d56da7f08c3e71195dbcda3181ca6396becd3c847041dd5ec"},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5e4c84490019cd5816e21455535a1099","paperId":"2312.15777","sourceSha256":"dcf86af4ba63baa8b5c0438bcaef90c7d6e3c856cd846a5e79a62b85f7b4ab36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/367ab2909e8534049df7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5aae1fb87439e7462e93f5e856a7686d63e4b25d73859bad42c50965c469c386","pdfPage":2,"start":1293,"end":3122,"textSha256":"df140d2d6083aa1975f1c87dff61230f337e7382c9bf82cd69b374c63677d10e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:89b705469b1a7d8a5d9e67aa2564e88b","paperId":"2312.15777","sourceSha256":"dcf86af4ba63baa8b5c0438bcaef90c7d6e3c856cd846a5e79a62b85f7b4ab36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/367ab2909e8534049df7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5aae1fb87439e7462e93f5e856a7686d63e4b25d73859bad42c50965c469c386","pdfPage":16,"start":106,"end":2014,"textSha256":"eee2a879d2e235ed5e68718f6cf3530f31e2d5d18204d94fcb6581ac6d3da6a1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d6238eceef87f258c22e24b69455f91b","paperId":"2312.15777","sourceSha256":"dcf86af4ba63baa8b5c0438bcaef90c7d6e3c856cd846a5e79a62b85f7b4ab36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/367ab2909e8534049df7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5aae1fb87439e7462e93f5e856a7686d63e4b25d73859bad42c50965c469c386","pdfPage":2,"start":94,"end":3122,"textSha256":"360d508f2de9a744041498fd7ff8c941de05efe3db12e2eaa338c8bb1ff0f7db","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8c92b60e858a137cdea6ff28"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8c92b60e858a137cdea6ff28","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:deca2d8dff89afffc834ced7053fa34b5fc34e8c05d51c6c1da2a2c06b9f5870","q025-candidate-question:e3f30f854573155119688234"],"scopeContentSha256":"34fa4656de2febee673ef6f2480ac81e4666168d11e234073f4f64b376ae51d7","contributionContentSha256":"cb31e40e425bffb7f770f6aa6ccae81e681e820823ed6f87c93c4682d51aa2fd","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:deca2d8dff89afffc834ced7053fa34b5fc34e8c05d51c6c1da2a2c06b9f5870","textSha256":"cac9d97a587d8f3d56da7f08c3e71195dbcda3181ca6396becd3c847041dd5ec"},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5e4c84490019cd5816e21455535a1099","paperId":"2312.15777","sourceSha256":"dcf86af4ba63baa8b5c0438bcaef90c7d6e3c856cd846a5e79a62b85f7b4ab36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/367ab2909e8534049df7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5aae1fb87439e7462e93f5e856a7686d63e4b25d73859bad42c50965c469c386","pdfPage":2,"start":1293,"end":3122,"textSha256":"df140d2d6083aa1975f1c87dff61230f337e7382c9bf82cd69b374c63677d10e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:89b705469b1a7d8a5d9e67aa2564e88b","paperId":"2312.15777","sourceSha256":"dcf86af4ba63baa8b5c0438bcaef90c7d6e3c856cd846a5e79a62b85f7b4ab36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/367ab2909e8534049df7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5aae1fb87439e7462e93f5e856a7686d63e4b25d73859bad42c50965c469c386","pdfPage":16,"start":106,"end":2014,"textSha256":"eee2a879d2e235ed5e68718f6cf3530f31e2d5d18204d94fcb6581ac6d3da6a1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d6238eceef87f258c22e24b69455f91b","paperId":"2312.15777","sourceSha256":"dcf86af4ba63baa8b5c0438bcaef90c7d6e3c856cd846a5e79a62b85f7b4ab36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/367ab2909e8534049df7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5aae1fb87439e7462e93f5e856a7686d63e4b25d73859bad42c50965c469c386","pdfPage":2,"start":94,"end":3122,"textSha256":"360d508f2de9a744041498fd7ff8c941de05efe3db12e2eaa338c8bb1ff0f7db","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8c92b60e858a137cdea6ff28","recordId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Gauging classification and wall construction differ; explicit walls use selected scalar sectors and 56−1/8+3 embedding-tensor components.","challengeNote":"Gauging classification and wall construction differ. Explicit walls use selected scalar sectors and 56−1/8+3 components with one independent projector.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"1a867c838e50285086c2297b35be7ade8c3dba985eda69fcda74a40aa19e4e93"},"organizational-access:6da5d55e388c701cab4fadb1":{"id":"organizational-access:6da5d55e388c701cab4fadb1","source":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","target":"q025-candidate-question:a5af3073fe62bec660f4626a","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5025d915791a4d704d8c95c2"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a5af3073fe62bec660f4626a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c823c064c5193a372a906924aa8a8a8f657fa0828d7dff15c59009a3257367d2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:47b9fa5106f0fbb1c554e426"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","home":{"unitId":"unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","paperId":"2512.07922","textSha256":"6d8e287667544c9e1cf688ddeeddacaf4665af3fece547d8c6e5a3947ad1b399"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1799571771d21b92c6cf0ca6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1799571771d21b92c6cf0ca6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"8471bbaf554b0c4458055bdf26f9dc2d93f88b19d1cb612bdcb8492d53797d1f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","paperId":"2512.07922","textSha256":"6d8e287667544c9e1cf688ddeeddacaf4665af3fece547d8c6e5a3947ad1b399"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1799571771d21b92c6cf0ca6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a5af3073fe62bec660f4626a","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d53","kind":"description","unitIndex":53,"unitId":"unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","textSha256":"6d8e287667544c9e1cf688ddeeddacaf4665af3fece547d8c6e5a3947ad1b399"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3b1729d807f699c9a60783e9","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Extremality/particle bounds and weak lensing remain distinct targets. Independent challenge qualification: Extremality, particle bounds, censorship and weak lensing remain distinguishable targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3b1729d807f699c9a60783e9","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","q025-candidate-question:a5af3073fe62bec660f4626a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c823c064c5193a372a906924aa8a8a8f657fa0828d7dff15c59009a3257367d2","contributionContentSha256":"0a15d917958cb88ce1f99a0d07ab38ae65081f2a9c1a3b8597ee3534a83fd8a6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d53","kind":"description","unitIndex":53,"unitId":"unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","textSha256":"6d8e287667544c9e1cf688ddeeddacaf4665af3fece547d8c6e5a3947ad1b399"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3b1729d807f699c9a60783e9","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Extremality/particle bounds and weak lensing remain distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Extremality, particle bounds, censorship and weak lensing remain distinguishable targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:2294e2535ad9cbcc8a710083374c23fa24e5d7dae4413c76901664d015c9c527","home":{"unitId":"unit:2294e2535ad9cbcc8a710083374c23fa24e5d7dae4413c76901664d015c9c527","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2294e2535ad9cbcc8a710083374c23fa24e5d7dae4413c76901664d015c9c527","paperId":"2305.08907","textSha256":"e5bbff6de17dd3d2a562201d348dcfedda0f600f3b6a54eac3a1ddd8256d17c9"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4b7b73214997af94c4379d13"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4b7b73214997af94c4379d13","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2294e2535ad9cbcc8a710083374c23fa24e5d7dae4413c76901664d015c9c527","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"6cde5462f02d881dc81335bc99f86e55dfe1a68ccc63b179abb56ecb18a13472","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2294e2535ad9cbcc8a710083374c23fa24e5d7dae4413c76901664d015c9c527","paperId":"2305.08907","textSha256":"e5bbff6de17dd3d2a562201d348dcfedda0f600f3b6a54eac3a1ddd8256d17c9"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4b7b73214997af94c4379d13"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2294e2535ad9cbcc8a710083374c23fa24e5d7dae4413c76901664d015c9c527","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a5af3073fe62bec660f4626a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:2294e2535ad9cbcc8a710083374c23fa24e5d7dae4413c76901664d015c9c527","textSha256":"e5bbff6de17dd3d2a562201d348dcfedda0f600f3b6a54eac3a1ddd8256d17c9"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cfa8d66ff7c1f50231ed32a3","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Probe binding, CFT energies and ISCO links remain coupled but distinct targets. Independent challenge qualification: Probe binding, CFT energies and ISCO links remain distinct connected targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:cfa8d66ff7c1f50231ed32a3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2294e2535ad9cbcc8a710083374c23fa24e5d7dae4413c76901664d015c9c527","q025-candidate-question:a5af3073fe62bec660f4626a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c823c064c5193a372a906924aa8a8a8f657fa0828d7dff15c59009a3257367d2","contributionContentSha256":"b345ae2fa5b046ce60d731b6b75daab1e760217856345011befd384b25a362c4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:2294e2535ad9cbcc8a710083374c23fa24e5d7dae4413c76901664d015c9c527","textSha256":"e5bbff6de17dd3d2a562201d348dcfedda0f600f3b6a54eac3a1ddd8256d17c9"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cfa8d66ff7c1f50231ed32a3","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Probe binding, CFT energies and ISCO links remain coupled but distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Probe binding, CFT energies and ISCO links remain distinct connected targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","home":{"unitId":"unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","paperId":"2602.22930","textSha256":"01877014db3f362e43394e04cd7bb38b399cbc60d3f8d66124740d870d9aed79"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:700f2c72796ca56a37e4aaaf"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:700f2c72796ca56a37e4aaaf","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"732864db1d67a24bf18cf086a3de5e7a5c1a3f3ab4351a9f9f98ee24883a16ac","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","paperId":"2602.22930","textSha256":"01877014db3f362e43394e04cd7bb38b399cbc60d3f8d66124740d870d9aed79"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:700f2c72796ca56a37e4aaaf"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a5af3073fe62bec660f4626a","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","textSha256":"01877014db3f362e43394e04cd7bb38b399cbc60d3f8d66124740d870d9aed79"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:672f8558491db45614dff247","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Conjecture compatibility, optical predictions and Barrow thermodynamics need separate facet reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Conjecture compatibility, optics and Barrow thermodynamics require separate facet reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:672f8558491db45614dff247","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","q025-candidate-question:a5af3073fe62bec660f4626a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c823c064c5193a372a906924aa8a8a8f657fa0828d7dff15c59009a3257367d2","contributionContentSha256":"e12001706f531446e8b5f6d75d62faeab86aff1c38fee1b962457d27e1d88c49","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","textSha256":"01877014db3f362e43394e04cd7bb38b399cbc60d3f8d66124740d870d9aed79"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:672f8558491db45614dff247","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Conjecture compatibility, optical predictions and Barrow thermodynamics need separate facet reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Conjecture compatibility, optics and Barrow thermodynamics require separate facet reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","home":{"unitId":"unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","paperId":"2412.00079","textSha256":"d03d1b50b781ff5409984998207acc0198e513509b34c5c757e9e25f3790875f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4accca414640b6a328667b11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4accca414640b6a328667b11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"bdfe47a208e63ac1faf4a723351055cac4e9020af4ce6c54b21f0d5edbd0a845","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","paperId":"2412.00079","textSha256":"d03d1b50b781ff5409984998207acc0198e513509b34c5c757e9e25f3790875f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4accca414640b6a328667b11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a5af3073fe62bec660f4626a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","textSha256":"d03d1b50b781ff5409984998207acc0198e513509b34c5c757e9e25f3790875f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6299e8209d0740ee0011eca8","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Horizon, photon and timelike-orbit targets remain a compound source scope. Independent challenge qualification: Horizon, photon and timelike-orbit targets remain a compound source scope."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6299e8209d0740ee0011eca8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","q025-candidate-question:a5af3073fe62bec660f4626a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c823c064c5193a372a906924aa8a8a8f657fa0828d7dff15c59009a3257367d2","contributionContentSha256":"661e36625df12a0c10a5809f078662c24e26e3a5a9aeedfd5c7e1bcfe3de95c8","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","textSha256":"d03d1b50b781ff5409984998207acc0198e513509b34c5c757e9e25f3790875f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6299e8209d0740ee0011eca8","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Horizon, photon and timelike-orbit targets remain a compound source scope.","challengeNote":"Horizon, photon and timelike-orbit targets remain a compound source scope.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","home":{"unitId":"unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers environmental black-hole relaxation, geometric or optical diagnostics and conditional conjectural compatibility tests within one regional scope.","qualification":"q21 includes ordinary relaxation and geometric diagnostics together with conditional conjecture tests. It covers both environmental modifications and the simultaneous inequality/cutoff question. q16 omits optics and q12 omits relaxation compatibility; scalar charge and a specific optical construction need not be inferred.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","paperId":"2603.09816","textSha256":"335b550de1ce8282fae259a249eb28594cf0558e12d4689bd40a6fe769cc2d17"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0059:u10:q21"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0059:u10:q21","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"8863a87cbace3351bf2aa92aea793c42479273046857937e951d3efe73639534","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0059:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0059:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","paperId":"2603.09816","textSha256":"335b550de1ce8282fae259a249eb28594cf0558e12d4689bd40a6fe769cc2d17"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0059","unitRef":"u10"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a5af3073fe62bec660f4626a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","textSha256":"335b550de1ce8282fae259a249eb28594cf0558e12d4689bd40a6fe769cc2d17"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0bd9a448bcc633f94db3ae15","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Relaxation, optics and an adopted distance-conjecture cutoff require separate facet checks; WGC is not stated. Independent challenge qualification: Replace pf34/pf29: scalar charge and photon-sphere diagnostics are unspecified. Relaxation, optics and an adopted distance cutoff require facet reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0bd9a448bcc633f94db3ae15","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","q025-candidate-question:a5af3073fe62bec660f4626a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c823c064c5193a372a906924aa8a8a8f657fa0828d7dff15c59009a3257367d2","contributionContentSha256":"eae988ebf03a2e9bc5efe9c4fa9074afb17d0ad74ff803aa22a795d0bbef8f97","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","textSha256":"335b550de1ce8282fae259a249eb28594cf0558e12d4689bd40a6fe769cc2d17"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0bd9a448bcc633f94db3ae15","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Relaxation, optics and an adopted distance-conjecture cutoff require separate facet checks; WGC is not stated.","challengeNote":"Replace pf34/pf29: scalar charge and photon-sphere diagnostics are unspecified. Relaxation, optics and an adopted distance cutoff require facet reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:75ab976213103eef1399876a215257d2f6a1fc890189046d24739d4dd1079c53","home":{"unitId":"unit:75ab976213103eef1399876a215257d2f6a1fc890189046d24739d4dd1079c53","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Its geometric, orbital and thermodynamic diagnostics cover the entire specified deformed RN-AdS application.","qualification":"q21 covers the three modifications and all optical, neutral-orbit and thermodynamic targets. q12 lacks thermodynamic stability; q10 lacks the full optical and orbital question. The source supplies neither a winding diagnostic nor a WGC claim or derivation of the quantum-inspired model.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:75ab976213103eef1399876a215257d2f6a1fc890189046d24739d4dd1079c53","paperId":"2508.10069","textSha256":"8840b6dfb7afcfd0b595dc895b8c6a075a03d67cf57bf2ee9025cbd1eeef1869"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0059:u11:q21"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0059:u11:q21","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:75ab976213103eef1399876a215257d2f6a1fc890189046d24739d4dd1079c53","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"a3fed6096e499f1886581a484666f0025285b577b6076955e6d17f51f5dd8770","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0059:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0059:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:75ab976213103eef1399876a215257d2f6a1fc890189046d24739d4dd1079c53","paperId":"2508.10069","textSha256":"8840b6dfb7afcfd0b595dc895b8c6a075a03d67cf57bf2ee9025cbd1eeef1869"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0059","unitRef":"u11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:75ab976213103eef1399876a215257d2f6a1fc890189046d24739d4dd1079c53","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a5af3073fe62bec660f4626a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d51","kind":"description","unitIndex":51,"unitId":"unit:75ab976213103eef1399876a215257d2f6a1fc890189046d24739d4dd1079c53","textSha256":"8840b6dfb7afcfd0b595dc895b8c6a075a03d67cf57bf2ee9025cbd1eeef1869"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9c4509a2fb55f3adef03e261","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Optical/orbital and thermodynamic targets are compound; no WGC claim is supplied. Independent challenge qualification: Replace pf29 with f1: photon motion and shadows do not specify a winding diagnostic. Optical/orbital and thermodynamic targets remain compound; no WGC claim is."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9c4509a2fb55f3adef03e261","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:75ab976213103eef1399876a215257d2f6a1fc890189046d24739d4dd1079c53","q025-candidate-question:a5af3073fe62bec660f4626a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c823c064c5193a372a906924aa8a8a8f657fa0828d7dff15c59009a3257367d2","contributionContentSha256":"a71c7c6c8dfcbe1963369ad9609772e847b348f908b3c85e47434feb3824bc38","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d51","kind":"description","unitIndex":51,"unitId":"unit:75ab976213103eef1399876a215257d2f6a1fc890189046d24739d4dd1079c53","textSha256":"8840b6dfb7afcfd0b595dc895b8c6a075a03d67cf57bf2ee9025cbd1eeef1869"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9c4509a2fb55f3adef03e261","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Optical/orbital and thermodynamic targets are compound; no WGC claim is supplied.","challengeNote":"Replace pf29 with f1: photon motion and shadows do not specify a winding diagnostic. Optical/orbital and thermodynamic targets remain compound; no WGC claim is.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":6,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"3769dc97f17578d96b6b6a47c609e63830814807b0a51d08349f00c8afa7e0f9"},"organizational-access:35d0889b4b36dc91ebc5153b":{"id":"organizational-access:35d0889b4b36dc91ebc5153b","source":"q025-candidate-region:7b614634ab6daa5c973dec85","target":"q025-candidate-question:e82a790cc8ea53712e29982d","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:7b614634ab6daa5c973dec85","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"df2a02064de8c227854dce39edc472544c28acae17135c0e58fc539e75ff190b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:df7c1d438496d3b7585bce8f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e82a790cc8ea53712e29982d","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"25441f147c235a8fa21d93b61e4fec793928c179f3e13e1b24072fae084835fc","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b6631fd84276bf714ca0faf9"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","home":{"unitId":"unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:7b614634ab6daa5c973dec85","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","paperId":"0803.4474","textSha256":"cf119116160ef8bf549a6fcd4ee1bd060a8033e04fefdcfe6ac0c23cc36d87c7"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:369523f7345594e0462c783811b5cf81","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1059,"textSha256":"30934071613d9a710c34ba34f2d5ba709e51ea2110116567bb127eb4ea1dcf3e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3620b2574e4c216a020bd7f5925690e","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":12,"start":99,"end":2764,"textSha256":"57f8d29781439657b7ad09fb9f9854739127909c924c5f2004149c0ed668ac95","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:22ba736db5983f0ec3581ba7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:22ba736db5983f0ec3581ba7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","q025-candidate-region:7b614634ab6daa5c973dec85"],"scopeContentSha256":"df2a02064de8c227854dce39edc472544c28acae17135c0e58fc539e75ff190b","placementContentSha256":"652d702aedfba6e352356c28ebd8b5d130913bda956fc3314047e1812f03c853","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge","leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","paperId":"0803.4474","textSha256":"cf119116160ef8bf549a6fcd4ee1bd060a8033e04fefdcfe6ac0c23cc36d87c7"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:369523f7345594e0462c783811b5cf81","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1059,"textSha256":"30934071613d9a710c34ba34f2d5ba709e51ea2110116567bb127eb4ea1dcf3e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3620b2574e4c216a020bd7f5925690e","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":12,"start":99,"end":2764,"textSha256":"57f8d29781439657b7ad09fb9f9854739127909c924c5f2004149c0ed668ac95","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:22ba736db5983f0ec3581ba7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e82a790cc8ea53712e29982d","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","textSha256":"cf119116160ef8bf549a6fcd4ee1bd060a8033e04fefdcfe6ac0c23cc36d87c7"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:369523f7345594e0462c783811b5cf81","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1059,"textSha256":"30934071613d9a710c34ba34f2d5ba709e51ea2110116567bb127eb4ea1dcf3e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3620b2574e4c216a020bd7f5925690e","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":12,"start":99,"end":2764,"textSha256":"57f8d29781439657b7ad09fb9f9854739127909c924c5f2004149c0ed668ac95","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a1ce2721646a45099b3966e6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a1ce2721646a45099b3966e6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","q025-candidate-question:e82a790cc8ea53712e29982d"],"scopeContentSha256":"25441f147c235a8fa21d93b61e4fec793928c179f3e13e1b24072fae084835fc","contributionContentSha256":"338f0ce2c9099a4b47f0ab3dba743c3cc8241183aec3a378196b3a19ace1b0e5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-proposal","leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","textSha256":"cf119116160ef8bf549a6fcd4ee1bd060a8033e04fefdcfe6ac0c23cc36d87c7"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:369523f7345594e0462c783811b5cf81","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1059,"textSha256":"30934071613d9a710c34ba34f2d5ba709e51ea2110116567bb127eb4ea1dcf3e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3620b2574e4c216a020bd7f5925690e","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":12,"start":99,"end":2764,"textSha256":"57f8d29781439657b7ad09fb9f9854739127909c924c5f2004149c0ed668ac95","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a1ce2721646a45099b3966e6","recordId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound encoding, central-charge/volume matching and homological-mirror-symmetry targets require finer reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Encoding, central-charge/volume matching and homological mirror symmetry are compound targets requiring finer reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"8ffc1bab138d3b1714ce83e9a566e603bcf7c8aa4a380427155a8250d5aaf33f"},"organizational-access:f8172cb7e5578d10f03685d9":{"id":"organizational-access:f8172cb7e5578d10f03685d9","source":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","target":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0725de22166d9fb2ff8caea8"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7dbb9cac613d29daedaa36d1"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:006406ef638c115a3450193e745f53284397781540f310c152871b6f010c5d23","home":{"unitId":"unit:006406ef638c115a3450193e745f53284397781540f310c152871b6f010c5d23","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:006406ef638c115a3450193e745f53284397781540f310c152871b6f010c5d23","paperId":"hep-th/9605150","textSha256":"5fa237e05415e7922da94ecf93f2f4b3e94152f45578a6b68a63551a28326c80"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8855afa344bd7b3cdf7b36ad"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8855afa344bd7b3cdf7b36ad","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:006406ef638c115a3450193e745f53284397781540f310c152871b6f010c5d23","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"22d50e3779d1ed5c133060e7174ac4c73396f6c98c0fecefffdcdb676a7b0ac1","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:006406ef638c115a3450193e745f53284397781540f310c152871b6f010c5d23","paperId":"hep-th/9605150","textSha256":"5fa237e05415e7922da94ecf93f2f4b3e94152f45578a6b68a63551a28326c80"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8855afa344bd7b3cdf7b36ad"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:006406ef638c115a3450193e745f53284397781540f310c152871b6f010c5d23","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d120","kind":"description","unitIndex":120,"unitId":"unit:006406ef638c115a3450193e745f53284397781540f310c152871b6f010c5d23","textSha256":"5fa237e05415e7922da94ecf93f2f4b3e94152f45578a6b68a63551a28326c80"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:54a8c07ec5bc49398de914e8"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:54a8c07ec5bc49398de914e8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:006406ef638c115a3450193e745f53284397781540f310c152871b6f010c5d23","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"fdc11e2d5280777faa74e3f680f27afdb7a35cdfba3331165b03b5afad9e32f4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d120","kind":"description","unitIndex":120,"unitId":"unit:006406ef638c115a3450193e745f53284397781540f310c152871b6f010c5d23","textSha256":"5fa237e05415e7922da94ecf93f2f4b3e94152f45578a6b68a63551a28326c80"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:54a8c07ec5bc49398de914e8","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Constant coupling is a locus to compare with nonperturbative departures, not a universal regime.","challengeNote":"Constant coupling is the comparison locus for nonperturbative departures.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:01f6f5cdf3258742c388557e1648ea448e9ec7025140d7de68cb5c7b79c59977","home":{"unitId":"unit:01f6f5cdf3258742c388557e1648ea448e9ec7025140d7de68cb5c7b79c59977","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:01f6f5cdf3258742c388557e1648ea448e9ec7025140d7de68cb5c7b79c59977","paperId":"2209.10297","textSha256":"a0a4e452666287653879948b92d9e9bac7af1de63fce6a34b4cb27012a058e3d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9c689195c958d498bd94c561"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9c689195c958d498bd94c561","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:01f6f5cdf3258742c388557e1648ea448e9ec7025140d7de68cb5c7b79c59977","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"dbe84025d742968819cc6b811710e4d0815905876048a805b87b3725d1ce3a11","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:01f6f5cdf3258742c388557e1648ea448e9ec7025140d7de68cb5c7b79c59977","paperId":"2209.10297","textSha256":"a0a4e452666287653879948b92d9e9bac7af1de63fce6a34b4cb27012a058e3d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9c689195c958d498bd94c561"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:01f6f5cdf3258742c388557e1648ea448e9ec7025140d7de68cb5c7b79c59977","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d104","kind":"description","unitIndex":104,"unitId":"unit:01f6f5cdf3258742c388557e1648ea448e9ec7025140d7de68cb5c7b79c59977","textSha256":"a0a4e452666287653879948b92d9e9bac7af1de63fce6a34b4cb27012a058e3d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8c61a7efbfbce1bcb9a84d7d"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8c61a7efbfbce1bcb9a84d7d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:01f6f5cdf3258742c388557e1648ea448e9ec7025140d7de68cb5c7b79c59977","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"3190f198b72ce5c7641a1cb42e9fb45619b1f0aaca9385f4ee68f50b661abffe","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d104","kind":"description","unitIndex":104,"unitId":"unit:01f6f5cdf3258742c388557e1648ea448e9ec7025140d7de68cb5c7b79c59977","textSha256":"a0a4e452666287653879948b92d9e9bac7af1de63fce6a34b4cb27012a058e3d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8c61a7efbfbce1bcb9a84d7d","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:2487c18ba8b42adbe2ea4ce0fc1d8e9b98ef929f908173a9024794bff5a6d647","home":{"unitId":"unit:2487c18ba8b42adbe2ea4ce0fc1d8e9b98ef929f908173a9024794bff5a6d647","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2487c18ba8b42adbe2ea4ce0fc1d8e9b98ef929f908173a9024794bff5a6d647","paperId":"hep-th/9605200","textSha256":"f7f3f2bd4ee1767b5cd256582dba7caa3c5653f1ddb7d1a8d749c45f993e5bce"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ff4ffbfcbaa6b933ff810267"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ff4ffbfcbaa6b933ff810267","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2487c18ba8b42adbe2ea4ce0fc1d8e9b98ef929f908173a9024794bff5a6d647","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"ac20eaf75a7b1904cabcfe901428e926bba5f7e5951f505101c4f09fcc7d4e72","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2487c18ba8b42adbe2ea4ce0fc1d8e9b98ef929f908173a9024794bff5a6d647","paperId":"hep-th/9605200","textSha256":"f7f3f2bd4ee1767b5cd256582dba7caa3c5653f1ddb7d1a8d749c45f993e5bce"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ff4ffbfcbaa6b933ff810267"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2487c18ba8b42adbe2ea4ce0fc1d8e9b98ef929f908173a9024794bff5a6d647","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d122","kind":"description","unitIndex":122,"unitId":"unit:2487c18ba8b42adbe2ea4ce0fc1d8e9b98ef929f908173a9024794bff5a6d647","textSha256":"f7f3f2bd4ee1767b5cd256582dba7caa3c5653f1ddb7d1a8d749c45f993e5bce"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:46179a989010da51e89832c2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:46179a989010da51e89832c2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2487c18ba8b42adbe2ea4ce0fc1d8e9b98ef929f908173a9024794bff5a6d647","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"d9ca46005171623d6c5e95bdf0bc6dff2e68dd991d53712d643dc1890c492db7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d122","kind":"description","unitIndex":122,"unitId":"unit:2487c18ba8b42adbe2ea4ce0fc1d8e9b98ef929f908173a9024794bff5a6d647","textSha256":"f7f3f2bd4ee1767b5cd256582dba7caa3c5653f1ddb7d1a8d749c45f993e5bce"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:46179a989010da51e89832c2","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Perturbative, nonperturbative and mixed enhancements remain distinct cases.","challengeNote":"Perturbative, nonperturbative and mixed enhancements remain distinct cases.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:43122f8a1623bc10111335055308ba9510767a4dc01cdb3615280b63afd69ed4","home":{"unitId":"unit:43122f8a1623bc10111335055308ba9510767a4dc01cdb3615280b63afd69ed4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:43122f8a1623bc10111335055308ba9510767a4dc01cdb3615280b63afd69ed4","paperId":"2112.11467","textSha256":"d22948d7d2a7cc79b0bcccd643e87975bbc0bcf58add630eef9d77b0e9c2d753"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1508e6bb1ddc87c7f524c9b0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1508e6bb1ddc87c7f524c9b0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:43122f8a1623bc10111335055308ba9510767a4dc01cdb3615280b63afd69ed4","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"963a9820e80128baaf722ac56184a1b4fdfc9026c7f08220023195547b993dd6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:43122f8a1623bc10111335055308ba9510767a4dc01cdb3615280b63afd69ed4","paperId":"2112.11467","textSha256":"d22948d7d2a7cc79b0bcccd643e87975bbc0bcf58add630eef9d77b0e9c2d753"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1508e6bb1ddc87c7f524c9b0"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:43122f8a1623bc10111335055308ba9510767a4dc01cdb3615280b63afd69ed4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d96","kind":"description","unitIndex":96,"unitId":"unit:43122f8a1623bc10111335055308ba9510767a4dc01cdb3615280b63afd69ed4","textSha256":"d22948d7d2a7cc79b0bcccd643e87975bbc0bcf58add630eef9d77b0e9c2d753"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:47cf1c7142e44e8ad2bb168b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:47cf1c7142e44e8ad2bb168b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:43122f8a1623bc10111335055308ba9510767a4dc01cdb3615280b63afd69ed4","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"72c45a68ed44c605a7617f39e6d5f4df1ca36b72f074a0210731bfb3b87873bf","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d96","kind":"description","unitIndex":96,"unitId":"unit:43122f8a1623bc10111335055308ba9510767a4dc01cdb3615280b63afd69ed4","textSha256":"d22948d7d2a7cc79b0bcccd643e87975bbc0bcf58add630eef9d77b0e9c2d753"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:47cf1c7142e44e8ad2bb168b","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Protected D3 strings are accessible; generic KK, string-excitation and charged-particle masses are not reliably computed.","challengeNote":"Wrapped D3 strings are accessible; generic KK, string-excitation and charged-particle masses are not reliably computed.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:555811959158eb32f4cf08ba52e676d75f4065c4496a72fa7e613ce532864281","home":{"unitId":"unit:555811959158eb32f4cf08ba52e676d75f4065c4496a72fa7e613ce532864281","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:555811959158eb32f4cf08ba52e676d75f4065c4496a72fa7e613ce532864281","paperId":"2210.10797","textSha256":"5cf6b4f634379cb7c3221443d6f60c41472933535ba817d28e1a22a8063a8f20"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:53be89eb504f8caaa7ab83e7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:53be89eb504f8caaa7ab83e7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:555811959158eb32f4cf08ba52e676d75f4065c4496a72fa7e613ce532864281","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"3ad85a07f5504f056be3a3cbc6beddaed4e2fe8a85e09c59a080b58a3a3cd343","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:555811959158eb32f4cf08ba52e676d75f4065c4496a72fa7e613ce532864281","paperId":"2210.10797","textSha256":"5cf6b4f634379cb7c3221443d6f60c41472933535ba817d28e1a22a8063a8f20"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:53be89eb504f8caaa7ab83e7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:555811959158eb32f4cf08ba52e676d75f4065c4496a72fa7e613ce532864281","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d106","kind":"description","unitIndex":106,"unitId":"unit:555811959158eb32f4cf08ba52e676d75f4065c4496a72fa7e613ce532864281","textSha256":"5cf6b4f634379cb7c3221443d6f60c41472933535ba817d28e1a22a8063a8f20"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:088099bda9be3da40c2a9158"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:088099bda9be3da40c2a9158","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:555811959158eb32f4cf08ba52e676d75f4065c4496a72fa7e613ce532864281","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"f4aec6dfaa39181455e71a22df8bed0703f55256d57989bbec8acd910e79036d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d106","kind":"description","unitIndex":106,"unitId":"unit:555811959158eb32f4cf08ba52e676d75f4065c4496a72fa7e613ce532864281","textSha256":"5cf6b4f634379cb7c3221443d6f60c41472933535ba817d28e1a22a8063a8f20"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:088099bda9be3da40c2a9158","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:836803b01a48419a809e05bdb0b2c3fa01428f5e090907797ed7f494ebd89710","home":{"unitId":"unit:836803b01a48419a809e05bdb0b2c3fa01428f5e090907797ed7f494ebd89710","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:836803b01a48419a809e05bdb0b2c3fa01428f5e090907797ed7f494ebd89710","paperId":"1806.01854","textSha256":"9e714a670a1a09a6fbba0b9c80b8a90bc85057ed3548c5985cefb8ad50cca83c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9636efc0acf6e3ed04bb6f10"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9636efc0acf6e3ed04bb6f10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:836803b01a48419a809e05bdb0b2c3fa01428f5e090907797ed7f494ebd89710","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"ac10b83f9c8b9780cb436695f1c3e60d54b21c2acba0dca4f0e504b4cec1ed8b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:836803b01a48419a809e05bdb0b2c3fa01428f5e090907797ed7f494ebd89710","paperId":"1806.01854","textSha256":"9e714a670a1a09a6fbba0b9c80b8a90bc85057ed3548c5985cefb8ad50cca83c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9636efc0acf6e3ed04bb6f10"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:836803b01a48419a809e05bdb0b2c3fa01428f5e090907797ed7f494ebd89710","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:836803b01a48419a809e05bdb0b2c3fa01428f5e090907797ed7f494ebd89710","textSha256":"9e714a670a1a09a6fbba0b9c80b8a90bc85057ed3548c5985cefb8ad50cca83c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dd9807a8e14267febf67ee84"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:dd9807a8e14267febf67ee84","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:836803b01a48419a809e05bdb0b2c3fa01428f5e090907797ed7f494ebd89710","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"d3b9d9954f540b8fb7c52b31cd3a20706628319a9a746208fde530929b26e30f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:836803b01a48419a809e05bdb0b2c3fa01428f5e090907797ed7f494ebd89710","textSha256":"9e714a670a1a09a6fbba0b9c80b8a90bc85057ed3548c5985cefb8ad50cca83c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dd9807a8e14267febf67ee84","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:97660405e9a045513246df784ed56fa94bb24f6622d2def521e2ed76c17eefae","home":{"unitId":"unit:97660405e9a045513246df784ed56fa94bb24f6622d2def521e2ed76c17eefae","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:97660405e9a045513246df784ed56fa94bb24f6622d2def521e2ed76c17eefae","paperId":"hep-th/9702165","textSha256":"62d81862b9a5accfd2f724bce6f77e60914ba182759b5132d53daf1d001f7fbe"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b35b8a3e3aaa800d886822c3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b35b8a3e3aaa800d886822c3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:97660405e9a045513246df784ed56fa94bb24f6622d2def521e2ed76c17eefae","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"5881968cc32e5bc0d52c9fbb72abb8205f51e89a90f0ef2702aaa00bee610ac1","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:97660405e9a045513246df784ed56fa94bb24f6622d2def521e2ed76c17eefae","paperId":"hep-th/9702165","textSha256":"62d81862b9a5accfd2f724bce6f77e60914ba182759b5132d53daf1d001f7fbe"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b35b8a3e3aaa800d886822c3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:97660405e9a045513246df784ed56fa94bb24f6622d2def521e2ed76c17eefae","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d124","kind":"description","unitIndex":124,"unitId":"unit:97660405e9a045513246df784ed56fa94bb24f6622d2def521e2ed76c17eefae","textSha256":"62d81862b9a5accfd2f724bce6f77e60914ba182759b5132d53daf1d001f7fbe"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7b5967acc849340fd436d882"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7b5967acc849340fd436d882","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:97660405e9a045513246df784ed56fa94bb24f6622d2def521e2ed76c17eefae","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"bfc2f31c4d939b0eaa161c0fb5cdd8d5125d2bf9831b6c36b3d5a17678731f17","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d124","kind":"description","unitIndex":124,"unitId":"unit:97660405e9a045513246df784ed56fa94bb24f6622d2def521e2ed76c17eefae","textSha256":"62d81862b9a5accfd2f724bce6f77e60914ba182759b5132d53daf1d001f7fbe"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7b5967acc849340fd436d882","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The auxiliary orientifold space may be singular; weak coupling is an existence question.","challengeNote":"Weak coupling is an existence question; the auxiliary orientifold space may be singular.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a3002b25e84ba0da194a99d302689e4bf9365854708aaab286ef5632a80b2d23","home":{"unitId":"unit:a3002b25e84ba0da194a99d302689e4bf9365854708aaab286ef5632a80b2d23","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a3002b25e84ba0da194a99d302689e4bf9365854708aaab286ef5632a80b2d23","paperId":"1502.06953","textSha256":"129c517e93619e589432beef91d71a34bb937dfbd209f8d76e1cb57b9ef3fe23"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9d9c1aecbabe8b584cbbc51e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9d9c1aecbabe8b584cbbc51e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a3002b25e84ba0da194a99d302689e4bf9365854708aaab286ef5632a80b2d23","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"bd745d2299e0de331a1695acae27d11004e1274c6216694dad7affc4952d713d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a3002b25e84ba0da194a99d302689e4bf9365854708aaab286ef5632a80b2d23","paperId":"1502.06953","textSha256":"129c517e93619e589432beef91d71a34bb937dfbd209f8d76e1cb57b9ef3fe23"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9d9c1aecbabe8b584cbbc51e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a3002b25e84ba0da194a99d302689e4bf9365854708aaab286ef5632a80b2d23","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:a3002b25e84ba0da194a99d302689e4bf9365854708aaab286ef5632a80b2d23","textSha256":"129c517e93619e589432beef91d71a34bb937dfbd209f8d76e1cb57b9ef3fe23"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:216781194377a5d18c80b584"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:216781194377a5d18c80b584","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a3002b25e84ba0da194a99d302689e4bf9365854708aaab286ef5632a80b2d23","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"ec4783cbae0765070910b438e086846546e06cd335090a136782bec7c6d2e183","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:a3002b25e84ba0da194a99d302689e4bf9365854708aaab286ef5632a80b2d23","textSha256":"129c517e93619e589432beef91d71a34bb937dfbd209f8d76e1cb57b9ef3fe23"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:216781194377a5d18c80b584","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a3550f1c20eac2326489a3b9222c89fceb700f0b3cc4e674dcde0234a4212ed1","home":{"unitId":"unit:a3550f1c20eac2326489a3b9222c89fceb700f0b3cc4e674dcde0234a4212ed1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a3550f1c20eac2326489a3b9222c89fceb700f0b3cc4e674dcde0234a4212ed1","paperId":"1904.06344","textSha256":"acdccf12eb33222349cae10088b6ef62ece7c7b6d7755176013c5b1d9b840e56"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:aec8e61d82a1bcadbd1393ec"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:aec8e61d82a1bcadbd1393ec","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a3550f1c20eac2326489a3b9222c89fceb700f0b3cc4e674dcde0234a4212ed1","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"4c04c291023e5e0f58529200f9f5ace363607e28f1eab6c56e066e879a9f4756","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a3550f1c20eac2326489a3b9222c89fceb700f0b3cc4e674dcde0234a4212ed1","paperId":"1904.06344","textSha256":"acdccf12eb33222349cae10088b6ef62ece7c7b6d7755176013c5b1d9b840e56"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:aec8e61d82a1bcadbd1393ec"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a3550f1c20eac2326489a3b9222c89fceb700f0b3cc4e674dcde0234a4212ed1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:a3550f1c20eac2326489a3b9222c89fceb700f0b3cc4e674dcde0234a4212ed1","textSha256":"acdccf12eb33222349cae10088b6ef62ece7c7b6d7755176013c5b1d9b840e56"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6799f619bd480940f47acafe"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6799f619bd480940f47acafe","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a3550f1c20eac2326489a3b9222c89fceb700f0b3cc4e674dcde0234a4212ed1","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"96f65b7cb68cef7049c32a8dce60c7230b36853410b446a511bd4b869fe259e9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:a3550f1c20eac2326489a3b9222c89fceb700f0b3cc4e674dcde0234a4212ed1","textSha256":"acdccf12eb33222349cae10088b6ef62ece7c7b6d7755176013c5b1d9b840e56"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6799f619bd480940f47acafe","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"A setting for relating weak tensor coupling to surface degeneration, not a supplied universal tower result.","challengeNote":"A setting for weak tensor coupling and surface degeneration, not a universal tower result.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a50b138ca6063d90b35a13764bd8c7f079494f2bea036cbfba26deb3517a5bc9","home":{"unitId":"unit:a50b138ca6063d90b35a13764bd8c7f079494f2bea036cbfba26deb3517a5bc9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a50b138ca6063d90b35a13764bd8c7f079494f2bea036cbfba26deb3517a5bc9","paperId":"hep-th/9605199","textSha256":"1cb882a2afd9c4fe8381aeb894c2ba5c9d1b01b46d42ad47f61bced917a3e346"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eff989c5b4c85b353b1253b4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eff989c5b4c85b353b1253b4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a50b138ca6063d90b35a13764bd8c7f079494f2bea036cbfba26deb3517a5bc9","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"97d0db553cff1a7597beccda2ff514a201e386ef22adffd10f3a41af34d65aff","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a50b138ca6063d90b35a13764bd8c7f079494f2bea036cbfba26deb3517a5bc9","paperId":"hep-th/9605199","textSha256":"1cb882a2afd9c4fe8381aeb894c2ba5c9d1b01b46d42ad47f61bced917a3e346"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eff989c5b4c85b353b1253b4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a50b138ca6063d90b35a13764bd8c7f079494f2bea036cbfba26deb3517a5bc9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d121","kind":"description","unitIndex":121,"unitId":"unit:a50b138ca6063d90b35a13764bd8c7f079494f2bea036cbfba26deb3517a5bc9","textSha256":"1cb882a2afd9c4fe8381aeb894c2ba5c9d1b01b46d42ad47f61bced917a3e346"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7e6d4379d66bca621a5dcc4f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7e6d4379d66bca621a5dcc4f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a50b138ca6063d90b35a13764bd8c7f079494f2bea036cbfba26deb3517a5bc9","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"6a07af26d8288075e773e3b003b4eb032408ec5e7800ecd2d88c73d2a1a577ff","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d121","kind":"description","unitIndex":121,"unitId":"unit:a50b138ca6063d90b35a13764bd8c7f079494f2bea036cbfba26deb3517a5bc9","textSha256":"1cb882a2afd9c4fe8381aeb894c2ba5c9d1b01b46d42ad47f61bced917a3e346"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7e6d4379d66bca621a5dcc4f","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b60872edddbe3fb02cbe7c5963d5decb80a66807ee85479edd684486bccb6d19","home":{"unitId":"unit:b60872edddbe3fb02cbe7c5963d5decb80a66807ee85479edd684486bccb6d19","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b60872edddbe3fb02cbe7c5963d5decb80a66807ee85479edd684486bccb6d19","paperId":"2112.07682","textSha256":"36e7a3e21b18fc5c7623a344daa15e71802fff53068e5463cb6c09e2f814d560"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f2558113c29ad5bb37f91f89"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f2558113c29ad5bb37f91f89","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b60872edddbe3fb02cbe7c5963d5decb80a66807ee85479edd684486bccb6d19","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"6b939be14ffaae379e1d049f7513cac2e7983a9a01173626975e7819d5ef384a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b60872edddbe3fb02cbe7c5963d5decb80a66807ee85479edd684486bccb6d19","paperId":"2112.07682","textSha256":"36e7a3e21b18fc5c7623a344daa15e71802fff53068e5463cb6c09e2f814d560"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f2558113c29ad5bb37f91f89"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b60872edddbe3fb02cbe7c5963d5decb80a66807ee85479edd684486bccb6d19","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d95","kind":"description","unitIndex":95,"unitId":"unit:b60872edddbe3fb02cbe7c5963d5decb80a66807ee85479edd684486bccb6d19","textSha256":"36e7a3e21b18fc5c7623a344daa15e71802fff53068e5463cb6c09e2f814d560"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9fda37f9bc01d4340b03d60f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9fda37f9bc01d4340b03d60f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b60872edddbe3fb02cbe7c5963d5decb80a66807ee85479edd684486bccb6d19","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"bd72b2d1d1a8e3b8b63bd5ce8d9b710765271efba71d9a24a3429436dd0c3423","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d95","kind":"description","unitIndex":95,"unitId":"unit:b60872edddbe3fb02cbe7c5963d5decb80a66807ee85479edd684486bccb6d19","textSha256":"36e7a3e21b18fc5c7623a344daa15e71802fff53068e5463cb6c09e2f814d560"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9fda37f9bc01d4340b03d60f","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:bfeda7377f0cd2c1dfcfab590c29787441f907c2c20f55093d4b6f5d9828af5a","home":{"unitId":"unit:bfeda7377f0cd2c1dfcfab590c29787441f907c2c20f55093d4b6f5d9828af5a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bfeda7377f0cd2c1dfcfab590c29787441f907c2c20f55093d4b6f5d9828af5a","paperId":"2109.11534","textSha256":"5c7c46ee528e2a51164df2dd1768e920fca183b59e5d3cbff78313e62a21d088"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:20fae409cf65f45f28b03b02"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:20fae409cf65f45f28b03b02","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bfeda7377f0cd2c1dfcfab590c29787441f907c2c20f55093d4b6f5d9828af5a","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"c5d31d5afb4c54ae5dc9e716d1f6775bce0466226f62984eb7d3883a328d768b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bfeda7377f0cd2c1dfcfab590c29787441f907c2c20f55093d4b6f5d9828af5a","paperId":"2109.11534","textSha256":"5c7c46ee528e2a51164df2dd1768e920fca183b59e5d3cbff78313e62a21d088"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:20fae409cf65f45f28b03b02"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bfeda7377f0cd2c1dfcfab590c29787441f907c2c20f55093d4b6f5d9828af5a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d88","kind":"description","unitIndex":88,"unitId":"unit:bfeda7377f0cd2c1dfcfab590c29787441f907c2c20f55093d4b6f5d9828af5a","textSha256":"5c7c46ee528e2a51164df2dd1768e920fca183b59e5d3cbff78313e62a21d088"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dafc2d55694eed1328c07a41"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:dafc2d55694eed1328c07a41","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bfeda7377f0cd2c1dfcfab590c29787441f907c2c20f55093d4b6f5d9828af5a","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"d42aae3fb051815631d7c37b3384a253741b1b2ad45e5195fc5e9fb5dd542333","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d88","kind":"description","unitIndex":88,"unitId":"unit:bfeda7377f0cd2c1dfcfab590c29787441f907c2c20f55093d4b6f5d9828af5a","textSha256":"5c7c46ee528e2a51164df2dd1768e920fca183b59e5d3cbff78313e62a21d088"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dafc2d55694eed1328c07a41","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Base enlargement and modifications of the duality dictionary are distinct linked targets.","challengeNote":"Enlarging base geometries and modifying the duality dictionary are distinct linked targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ce30664a6c54d767f61ca0d8d1d73df12beab6b6fa0067c5aff930b7a01083cd","home":{"unitId":"unit:ce30664a6c54d767f61ca0d8d1d73df12beab6b6fa0067c5aff930b7a01083cd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ce30664a6c54d767f61ca0d8d1d73df12beab6b6fa0067c5aff930b7a01083cd","paperId":"2104.05726","textSha256":"95c499d5d1aee2bcb5c33aee2aabd78ad6806326c75ad75159e1abc53763673e"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bec000fcb510b60538e55312"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bec000fcb510b60538e55312","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ce30664a6c54d767f61ca0d8d1d73df12beab6b6fa0067c5aff930b7a01083cd","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"6cac98c45e5e987d1e7e7682ab9c5534755bcbbf021c909655854c2c5fce9c85","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ce30664a6c54d767f61ca0d8d1d73df12beab6b6fa0067c5aff930b7a01083cd","paperId":"2104.05726","textSha256":"95c499d5d1aee2bcb5c33aee2aabd78ad6806326c75ad75159e1abc53763673e"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bec000fcb510b60538e55312"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ce30664a6c54d767f61ca0d8d1d73df12beab6b6fa0067c5aff930b7a01083cd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d84","kind":"description","unitIndex":84,"unitId":"unit:ce30664a6c54d767f61ca0d8d1d73df12beab6b6fa0067c5aff930b7a01083cd","textSha256":"95c499d5d1aee2bcb5c33aee2aabd78ad6806326c75ad75159e1abc53763673e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fabf72234a5051a8d6a40221"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:fabf72234a5051a8d6a40221","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ce30664a6c54d767f61ca0d8d1d73df12beab6b6fa0067c5aff930b7a01083cd","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"1647fc7c2b2f7537487f653782957ba9baa39a81a829a3fa8c6a95de05d48447","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d84","kind":"description","unitIndex":84,"unitId":"unit:ce30664a6c54d767f61ca0d8d1d73df12beab6b6fa0067c5aff930b7a01083cd","textSha256":"95c499d5d1aee2bcb5c33aee2aabd78ad6806326c75ad75159e1abc53763673e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fabf72234a5051a8d6a40221","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"General charge-ray volumes depend on the resolution chamber.","challengeNote":"General charge-ray volumes depend on the resolution chamber.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:e0320f13408912567d93bf1ab94e937ff977a3a86ccb80e9a4ffdae7e4e02147","home":{"unitId":"unit:e0320f13408912567d93bf1ab94e937ff977a3a86ccb80e9a4ffdae7e4e02147","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e0320f13408912567d93bf1ab94e937ff977a3a86ccb80e9a4ffdae7e4e02147","paperId":"2310.07761","textSha256":"a1f7e99f7b8994ef7b5eb88055ee5f714091da51f0c5eef93e78b797b8d23e4c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e1bf059488bad08ba1fe4d13"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e1bf059488bad08ba1fe4d13","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e0320f13408912567d93bf1ab94e937ff977a3a86ccb80e9a4ffdae7e4e02147","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"5843c0f87a1abe1d104186fc45ab5ea37fe906c4f4e63b2b0bfc8974350a0ff2","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e0320f13408912567d93bf1ab94e937ff977a3a86ccb80e9a4ffdae7e4e02147","paperId":"2310.07761","textSha256":"a1f7e99f7b8994ef7b5eb88055ee5f714091da51f0c5eef93e78b797b8d23e4c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e1bf059488bad08ba1fe4d13"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e0320f13408912567d93bf1ab94e937ff977a3a86ccb80e9a4ffdae7e4e02147","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d113","kind":"description","unitIndex":113,"unitId":"unit:e0320f13408912567d93bf1ab94e937ff977a3a86ccb80e9a4ffdae7e4e02147","textSha256":"a1f7e99f7b8994ef7b5eb88055ee5f714091da51f0c5eef93e78b797b8d23e4c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:68e12000d0d44a4c902bd465"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:68e12000d0d44a4c902bd465","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e0320f13408912567d93bf1ab94e937ff977a3a86ccb80e9a4ffdae7e4e02147","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"10016a533e9d2c6662c161dda754de71bace6020be6768842f061257e608f6f7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d113","kind":"description","unitIndex":113,"unitId":"unit:e0320f13408912567d93bf1ab94e937ff977a3a86ccb80e9a4ffdae7e4e02147","textSha256":"a1f7e99f7b8994ef7b5eb88055ee5f714091da51f0c5eef93e78b797b8d23e4c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:68e12000d0d44a4c902bd465","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:e955f6b177614c2730da282959b4712cbce740a2d6b534db8c668e069750048e","home":{"unitId":"unit:e955f6b177614c2730da282959b4712cbce740a2d6b534db8c668e069750048e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e955f6b177614c2730da282959b4712cbce740a2d6b534db8c668e069750048e","paperId":"2308.07364","textSha256":"64651eb67f3bef8c4e064fa169e31a6de0e6d2c263c398adc561c761d4b23e7d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1d1f31c75851b2a393aa45ed"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1d1f31c75851b2a393aa45ed","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e955f6b177614c2730da282959b4712cbce740a2d6b534db8c668e069750048e","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"8ab50cf44299e392a91e742a501cadfeaf2b4a3f01fae377f49c27e4480907e2","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e955f6b177614c2730da282959b4712cbce740a2d6b534db8c668e069750048e","paperId":"2308.07364","textSha256":"64651eb67f3bef8c4e064fa169e31a6de0e6d2c263c398adc561c761d4b23e7d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1d1f31c75851b2a393aa45ed"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e955f6b177614c2730da282959b4712cbce740a2d6b534db8c668e069750048e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d111","kind":"description","unitIndex":111,"unitId":"unit:e955f6b177614c2730da282959b4712cbce740a2d6b534db8c668e069750048e","textSha256":"64651eb67f3bef8c4e064fa169e31a6de0e6d2c263c398adc561c761d4b23e7d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:920f6245e3baff0687e6903e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:920f6245e3baff0687e6903e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e955f6b177614c2730da282959b4712cbce740a2d6b534db8c668e069750048e","q025-candidate-question:732ddf54cc5920d49047ced8"],"scopeContentSha256":"beac20f8372ade0c9b4223fef4734b433847dd1ad5494abc1a8d1495a9fc4ebd","contributionContentSha256":"e1f64f0d26dbd1d6f5a15e0f41eb11537e6d1d3725cde2a8af9d96f52751105b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d111","kind":"description","unitIndex":111,"unitId":"unit:e955f6b177614c2730da282959b4712cbce740a2d6b534db8c668e069750048e","textSha256":"64651eb67f3bef8c4e064fa169e31a6de0e6d2c263c398adc561c761d4b23e7d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:920f6245e3baff0687e6903e","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Five-dimensional spectra, six-dimensional Jacobians and rank-changing transitions remain separate outputs.","challengeNote":"Five-dimensional spectra, six-dimensional Jacobians and rank-changing transitions remain distinct outputs.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":15,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"2441ea9ba5882d8d26104c9fb664bed8b10bbdbae788af051a3e9783440a9187"},"organizational-access:e8b7ee3f5b9c91e0923ac94b":{"id":"organizational-access:e8b7ee3f5b9c91e0923ac94b","source":"q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e","target":"q025-candidate-question:4d177680b8a9fc0b4dcfbc97","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"7f0d26455f3d8805a4200b0c150bb440a09b6e854e08978c54f94b1829a3370a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:170d19771c86199111bcd0f9"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:4d177680b8a9fc0b4dcfbc97","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"bf7a034bfff4c09a9da0b2b970725a3851eeb1f912025a4daf1b8c7db6b29bcc","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e01063cbffc23692f3250730"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5b779c3b57735542adea4bffd2fad9e1e05c3d72bbed6503633f4514d3d81aa0","home":{"unitId":"unit:5b779c3b57735542adea4bffd2fad9e1e05c3d72bbed6503633f4514d3d81aa0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5b779c3b57735542adea4bffd2fad9e1e05c3d72bbed6503633f4514d3d81aa0","paperId":"1809.06861","textSha256":"bb3a39b7bbfc630d5ff071bcb9b6d5076a04c41ff9d4c80c89f419c8f9d2a84b"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:79a9a027c9c524d98ec0a1377c15ce2d","paperId":"1809.06861","sourceSha256":"a5c68c71ab7e931b680006bd9d6bb10cc8da410d1697fdfb28423454dfe8d5d3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fcc4520dc1aa8cce3ffc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87ff455275e21e1e41ba65512a367fb6ba38cd193046a309944939ae3076bd3c","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a5c39c26a598257b4560ac512c5157ecdac2f3e505a50be5e40112347799ac33","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f36e61a693614b8c318d4f05cadecf23","paperId":"1809.06861","sourceSha256":"a5c68c71ab7e931b680006bd9d6bb10cc8da410d1697fdfb28423454dfe8d5d3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fcc4520dc1aa8cce3ffc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87ff455275e21e1e41ba65512a367fb6ba38cd193046a309944939ae3076bd3c","pdfPage":13,"start":0,"end":1652,"textSha256":"356ae3bcf2a0ac00ab7bfecc6abd090e6b411d888229c0cc57657c44e352bd27","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3a4cc5bc8b8ce8c0599d6fec7a34d6cf","paperId":"1809.06861","sourceSha256":"a5c68c71ab7e931b680006bd9d6bb10cc8da410d1697fdfb28423454dfe8d5d3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fcc4520dc1aa8cce3ffc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87ff455275e21e1e41ba65512a367fb6ba38cd193046a309944939ae3076bd3c","pdfPage":13,"start":310,"end":1652,"textSha256":"c81ddc2a852bb815f898ef31f1248790d1a1217f4dbbdc76259af166d70383a2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:47db5fba1a4d85454726116a"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:47db5fba1a4d85454726116a","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5b779c3b57735542adea4bffd2fad9e1e05c3d72bbed6503633f4514d3d81aa0","q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e"],"scopeContentSha256":"7f0d26455f3d8805a4200b0c150bb440a09b6e854e08978c54f94b1829a3370a","placementContentSha256":"17eba8d6aa72366384a68ad1e4dadef50192b19ce8ef64ed754ec3b71ef87bf0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5b779c3b57735542adea4bffd2fad9e1e05c3d72bbed6503633f4514d3d81aa0","paperId":"1809.06861","textSha256":"bb3a39b7bbfc630d5ff071bcb9b6d5076a04c41ff9d4c80c89f419c8f9d2a84b"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:79a9a027c9c524d98ec0a1377c15ce2d","paperId":"1809.06861","sourceSha256":"a5c68c71ab7e931b680006bd9d6bb10cc8da410d1697fdfb28423454dfe8d5d3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fcc4520dc1aa8cce3ffc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87ff455275e21e1e41ba65512a367fb6ba38cd193046a309944939ae3076bd3c","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a5c39c26a598257b4560ac512c5157ecdac2f3e505a50be5e40112347799ac33","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f36e61a693614b8c318d4f05cadecf23","paperId":"1809.06861","sourceSha256":"a5c68c71ab7e931b680006bd9d6bb10cc8da410d1697fdfb28423454dfe8d5d3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fcc4520dc1aa8cce3ffc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87ff455275e21e1e41ba65512a367fb6ba38cd193046a309944939ae3076bd3c","pdfPage":13,"start":0,"end":1652,"textSha256":"356ae3bcf2a0ac00ab7bfecc6abd090e6b411d888229c0cc57657c44e352bd27","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3a4cc5bc8b8ce8c0599d6fec7a34d6cf","paperId":"1809.06861","sourceSha256":"a5c68c71ab7e931b680006bd9d6bb10cc8da410d1697fdfb28423454dfe8d5d3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fcc4520dc1aa8cce3ffc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87ff455275e21e1e41ba65512a367fb6ba38cd193046a309944939ae3076bd3c","pdfPage":13,"start":310,"end":1652,"textSha256":"c81ddc2a852bb815f898ef31f1248790d1a1217f4dbbdc76259af166d70383a2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:47db5fba1a4d85454726116a"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5b779c3b57735542adea4bffd2fad9e1e05c3d72bbed6503633f4514d3d81aa0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4d177680b8a9fc0b4dcfbc97","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:5b779c3b57735542adea4bffd2fad9e1e05c3d72bbed6503633f4514d3d81aa0","textSha256":"bb3a39b7bbfc630d5ff071bcb9b6d5076a04c41ff9d4c80c89f419c8f9d2a84b"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:79a9a027c9c524d98ec0a1377c15ce2d","paperId":"1809.06861","sourceSha256":"a5c68c71ab7e931b680006bd9d6bb10cc8da410d1697fdfb28423454dfe8d5d3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fcc4520dc1aa8cce3ffc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87ff455275e21e1e41ba65512a367fb6ba38cd193046a309944939ae3076bd3c","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a5c39c26a598257b4560ac512c5157ecdac2f3e505a50be5e40112347799ac33","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f36e61a693614b8c318d4f05cadecf23","paperId":"1809.06861","sourceSha256":"a5c68c71ab7e931b680006bd9d6bb10cc8da410d1697fdfb28423454dfe8d5d3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fcc4520dc1aa8cce3ffc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87ff455275e21e1e41ba65512a367fb6ba38cd193046a309944939ae3076bd3c","pdfPage":13,"start":0,"end":1652,"textSha256":"356ae3bcf2a0ac00ab7bfecc6abd090e6b411d888229c0cc57657c44e352bd27","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3a4cc5bc8b8ce8c0599d6fec7a34d6cf","paperId":"1809.06861","sourceSha256":"a5c68c71ab7e931b680006bd9d6bb10cc8da410d1697fdfb28423454dfe8d5d3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fcc4520dc1aa8cce3ffc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87ff455275e21e1e41ba65512a367fb6ba38cd193046a309944939ae3076bd3c","pdfPage":13,"start":310,"end":1652,"textSha256":"c81ddc2a852bb815f898ef31f1248790d1a1217f4dbbdc76259af166d70383a2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7c7d8529b9739bb7583ebbdb"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7c7d8529b9739bb7583ebbdb","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5b779c3b57735542adea4bffd2fad9e1e05c3d72bbed6503633f4514d3d81aa0","q025-candidate-question:4d177680b8a9fc0b4dcfbc97"],"scopeContentSha256":"bf7a034bfff4c09a9da0b2b970725a3851eeb1f912025a4daf1b8c7db6b29bcc","contributionContentSha256":"a0a9379f0b0b9186a1efdd2c541ddbf8473dacb5c4a057d07e0a684160d64605","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:5b779c3b57735542adea4bffd2fad9e1e05c3d72bbed6503633f4514d3d81aa0","textSha256":"bb3a39b7bbfc630d5ff071bcb9b6d5076a04c41ff9d4c80c89f419c8f9d2a84b"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:79a9a027c9c524d98ec0a1377c15ce2d","paperId":"1809.06861","sourceSha256":"a5c68c71ab7e931b680006bd9d6bb10cc8da410d1697fdfb28423454dfe8d5d3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fcc4520dc1aa8cce3ffc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87ff455275e21e1e41ba65512a367fb6ba38cd193046a309944939ae3076bd3c","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a5c39c26a598257b4560ac512c5157ecdac2f3e505a50be5e40112347799ac33","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f36e61a693614b8c318d4f05cadecf23","paperId":"1809.06861","sourceSha256":"a5c68c71ab7e931b680006bd9d6bb10cc8da410d1697fdfb28423454dfe8d5d3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fcc4520dc1aa8cce3ffc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87ff455275e21e1e41ba65512a367fb6ba38cd193046a309944939ae3076bd3c","pdfPage":13,"start":0,"end":1652,"textSha256":"356ae3bcf2a0ac00ab7bfecc6abd090e6b411d888229c0cc57657c44e352bd27","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3a4cc5bc8b8ce8c0599d6fec7a34d6cf","paperId":"1809.06861","sourceSha256":"a5c68c71ab7e931b680006bd9d6bb10cc8da410d1697fdfb28423454dfe8d5d3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fcc4520dc1aa8cce3ffc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87ff455275e21e1e41ba65512a367fb6ba38cd193046a309944939ae3076bd3c","pdfPage":13,"start":310,"end":1652,"textSha256":"c81ddc2a852bb815f898ef31f1248790d1a1217f4dbbdc76259af166d70383a2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7c7d8529b9739bb7583ebbdb","recordId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound identity unresolved: antibrane stability and horizon response are separate targets; the horizon extension has only description/object support.","challengeNote":"Compound identity unresolved: horizon response has only description/object support. The reduced-potential runaway is conditional on the flux regime.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","home":{"unitId":"unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","paperId":"2010.15903","textSha256":"d4dd85c73e441f19a809b9e3c6345592d20ba52264841afb4ad5c4399eadd688"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f29ba2f3a825a219be912888"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f29ba2f3a825a219be912888","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e"],"scopeContentSha256":"7f0d26455f3d8805a4200b0c150bb440a09b6e854e08978c54f94b1829a3370a","placementContentSha256":"679457bce5f4d1e5db6a86deac33bb064c1b8c5aa76b14448631aa98b6d728a7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","paperId":"2010.15903","textSha256":"d4dd85c73e441f19a809b9e3c6345592d20ba52264841afb4ad5c4399eadd688"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f29ba2f3a825a219be912888"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4d177680b8a9fc0b4dcfbc97","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","textSha256":"d4dd85c73e441f19a809b9e3c6345592d20ba52264841afb4ad5c4399eadd688"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3be1f00602d02fc049b92c06"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3be1f00602d02fc049b92c06","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","q025-candidate-question:4d177680b8a9fc0b4dcfbc97"],"scopeContentSha256":"bf7a034bfff4c09a9da0b2b970725a3851eeb1f912025a4daf1b8c7db6b29bcc","contributionContentSha256":"68b65d1644703eb2dce84b6adaaf1389175b1bf2d9fb28a880833a993cd4c9cf","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","textSha256":"d4dd85c73e441f19a809b9e3c6345592d20ba52264841afb4ad5c4399eadd688"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3be1f00602d02fc049b92c06","recordId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","home":{"unitId":"unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","paperId":"2201.03572","textSha256":"3743f66644ef863f841b437f55e159dd1ef0772d8062583ac9ecaff7fd9c6d1e"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:836a660e84ec56d272949370"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:836a660e84ec56d272949370","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e"],"scopeContentSha256":"7f0d26455f3d8805a4200b0c150bb440a09b6e854e08978c54f94b1829a3370a","placementContentSha256":"134e2128823d55fe25b263b1d3981c6a6e02b384ddccb20d0a4c61740fd96a95","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","paperId":"2201.03572","textSha256":"3743f66644ef863f841b437f55e159dd1ef0772d8062583ac9ecaff7fd9c6d1e"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:836a660e84ec56d272949370"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4d177680b8a9fc0b4dcfbc97","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","textSha256":"3743f66644ef863f841b437f55e159dd1ef0772d8062583ac9ecaff7fd9c6d1e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dece0e09b714f21ee59e7c56"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:dece0e09b714f21ee59e7c56","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","q025-candidate-question:4d177680b8a9fc0b4dcfbc97"],"scopeContentSha256":"bf7a034bfff4c09a9da0b2b970725a3851eeb1f912025a4daf1b8c7db6b29bcc","contributionContentSha256":"bd27944092ecdf00cb67ec5d8f1509e6b22303baf489b4c45391c5e7a1a60a38","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","textSha256":"3743f66644ef863f841b437f55e159dd1ef0772d8062583ac9ecaff7fd9c6d1e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dece0e09b714f21ee59e7c56","recordId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Setting-derived facet: a single canonical question is unresolved; retaining the conifold field does not establish a vacuum or an LVS identification.","challengeNote":"Setting-derived facet; canonical question identity is unresolved. Its instantiated EFT setting establishes neither an LVS identification nor a vacuum.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"5ed4865347fae408fee67bae165dd2de77da2245ca46162fb22fd610284257ba"},"organizational-access:605cf6907301e83a1ce20792":{"id":"organizational-access:605cf6907301e83a1ce20792","source":"q025-candidate-region:9e268159d6a07c40234a5dcd","target":"q025-candidate-question:2279572397602033dafa6471","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:9e268159d6a07c40234a5dcd","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"b0bafd21c8b50a2ebf77e804e5a113ae02cc3f2cc6ae87b171ff3746f2d6a3ce","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:373b6b59fcbb8b1676798b15"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:2279572397602033dafa6471","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7282e4ebdec55a5103e359a688f45ddcd143a9d24af94ca0f1e95dfe57103176","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0ff39c801b868a8d0954998e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:9a3ab115f5c6672d68512bf7e0c8d2a0384bacca295a406a6b43573fa182dd04","home":{"unitId":"unit:9a3ab115f5c6672d68512bf7e0c8d2a0384bacca295a406a6b43573fa182dd04","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:9e268159d6a07c40234a5dcd","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9a3ab115f5c6672d68512bf7e0c8d2a0384bacca295a406a6b43573fa182dd04","paperId":"2603.29781","textSha256":"eb2053c067828fe3f6f97e11c159930f5d815cc63179d75a4656e6c2a75990a6"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:42b352728ec9424326da597e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:42b352728ec9424326da597e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9a3ab115f5c6672d68512bf7e0c8d2a0384bacca295a406a6b43573fa182dd04","q025-candidate-region:9e268159d6a07c40234a5dcd"],"scopeContentSha256":"b0bafd21c8b50a2ebf77e804e5a113ae02cc3f2cc6ae87b171ff3746f2d6a3ce","placementContentSha256":"12ef89406aa4c46cfd23ff3c30a20d80318232603cd36b9f13f8324cc43253e5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge","leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9a3ab115f5c6672d68512bf7e0c8d2a0384bacca295a406a6b43573fa182dd04","paperId":"2603.29781","textSha256":"eb2053c067828fe3f6f97e11c159930f5d815cc63179d75a4656e6c2a75990a6"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:42b352728ec9424326da597e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9a3ab115f5c6672d68512bf7e0c8d2a0384bacca295a406a6b43573fa182dd04","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2279572397602033dafa6471","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:9a3ab115f5c6672d68512bf7e0c8d2a0384bacca295a406a6b43573fa182dd04","textSha256":"eb2053c067828fe3f6f97e11c159930f5d815cc63179d75a4656e6c2a75990a6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0d6ba1775b36f89e6dcf7638"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0d6ba1775b36f89e6dcf7638","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9a3ab115f5c6672d68512bf7e0c8d2a0384bacca295a406a6b43573fa182dd04","q025-candidate-question:2279572397602033dafa6471"],"scopeContentSha256":"7282e4ebdec55a5103e359a688f45ddcd143a9d24af94ca0f1e95dfe57103176","contributionContentSha256":"c1567a57e72b09862b8a6a94d4282114356dd7488d982cb54d6a83669a5aa88f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal","leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:9a3ab115f5c6672d68512bf7e0c8d2a0384bacca295a406a6b43573fa182dd04","textSha256":"eb2053c067828fe3f6f97e11c159930f5d815cc63179d75a4656e6c2a75990a6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0d6ba1775b36f89e6dcf7638","recordId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Radial and angular models are alternatives; the effective decay-constant condition belongs to the angular case.","challengeNote":"Radial and angular models are alternatives; the effective decay-constant condition applies to the angular case.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ad8d1c41689a7d10a99665fcc8c3f33d1d567da47103c3b1b229ca18a87ea518","home":{"unitId":"unit:ad8d1c41689a7d10a99665fcc8c3f33d1d567da47103c3b1b229ca18a87ea518","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:9e268159d6a07c40234a5dcd","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ad8d1c41689a7d10a99665fcc8c3f33d1d567da47103c3b1b229ca18a87ea518","paperId":"0708.4414","textSha256":"7c23186eec7e46acd956c55c95abb9b04c5b1d8a242a4fa97f473595766d6171"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a23dc3166125f53e55441760"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a23dc3166125f53e55441760","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ad8d1c41689a7d10a99665fcc8c3f33d1d567da47103c3b1b229ca18a87ea518","q025-candidate-region:9e268159d6a07c40234a5dcd"],"scopeContentSha256":"b0bafd21c8b50a2ebf77e804e5a113ae02cc3f2cc6ae87b171ff3746f2d6a3ce","placementContentSha256":"d117f49e24984466405b1c1cc3e2eb16adb2191b659b193d03446e5cbcd7467a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge","leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ad8d1c41689a7d10a99665fcc8c3f33d1d567da47103c3b1b229ca18a87ea518","paperId":"0708.4414","textSha256":"7c23186eec7e46acd956c55c95abb9b04c5b1d8a242a4fa97f473595766d6171"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a23dc3166125f53e55441760"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ad8d1c41689a7d10a99665fcc8c3f33d1d567da47103c3b1b229ca18a87ea518","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2279572397602033dafa6471","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:ad8d1c41689a7d10a99665fcc8c3f33d1d567da47103c3b1b229ca18a87ea518","textSha256":"7c23186eec7e46acd956c55c95abb9b04c5b1d8a242a4fa97f473595766d6171"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0e397ae62ea569b44db67d3b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0e397ae62ea569b44db67d3b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ad8d1c41689a7d10a99665fcc8c3f33d1d567da47103c3b1b229ca18a87ea518","q025-candidate-question:2279572397602033dafa6471"],"scopeContentSha256":"7282e4ebdec55a5103e359a688f45ddcd143a9d24af94ca0f1e95dfe57103176","contributionContentSha256":"c1ca374f78711a2daa95e185446ee391e73f8367e2294d67b89f03b083bbb52f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal","leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:ad8d1c41689a7d10a99665fcc8c3f33d1d567da47103c3b1b229ca18a87ea518","textSha256":"7c23186eec7e46acd956c55c95abb9b04c5b1d8a242a4fa97f473595766d6171"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0e397ae62ea569b44db67d3b","recordId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c9defcd4a836cacd3bc03dfdb756a10eaa6990ac5d6e5e81babe7bbfd1eff232","home":{"unitId":"unit:c9defcd4a836cacd3bc03dfdb756a10eaa6990ac5d6e5e81babe7bbfd1eff232","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:9e268159d6a07c40234a5dcd","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c9defcd4a836cacd3bc03dfdb756a10eaa6990ac5d6e5e81babe7bbfd1eff232","paperId":"hep-th/0501130","textSha256":"d112ae1afa243c3dceed5e47f843e50138251f651d46c1f9a2d31f096997d33c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9197264bf4044065b103f106"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9197264bf4044065b103f106","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c9defcd4a836cacd3bc03dfdb756a10eaa6990ac5d6e5e81babe7bbfd1eff232","q025-candidate-region:9e268159d6a07c40234a5dcd"],"scopeContentSha256":"b0bafd21c8b50a2ebf77e804e5a113ae02cc3f2cc6ae87b171ff3746f2d6a3ce","placementContentSha256":"ad68a1bf64ce1bf9d54b37936f8a73026867b1d62299e316e7eb0af2fb355f9e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge","leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c9defcd4a836cacd3bc03dfdb756a10eaa6990ac5d6e5e81babe7bbfd1eff232","paperId":"hep-th/0501130","textSha256":"d112ae1afa243c3dceed5e47f843e50138251f651d46c1f9a2d31f096997d33c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9197264bf4044065b103f106"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c9defcd4a836cacd3bc03dfdb756a10eaa6990ac5d6e5e81babe7bbfd1eff232","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2279572397602033dafa6471","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d65","kind":"description","unitIndex":65,"unitId":"unit:c9defcd4a836cacd3bc03dfdb756a10eaa6990ac5d6e5e81babe7bbfd1eff232","textSha256":"d112ae1afa243c3dceed5e47f843e50138251f651d46c1f9a2d31f096997d33c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:690a24fef1a99a77c5ccb75b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:690a24fef1a99a77c5ccb75b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c9defcd4a836cacd3bc03dfdb756a10eaa6990ac5d6e5e81babe7bbfd1eff232","q025-candidate-question:2279572397602033dafa6471"],"scopeContentSha256":"7282e4ebdec55a5103e359a688f45ddcd143a9d24af94ca0f1e95dfe57103176","contributionContentSha256":"1d4885570cd7653dd8adbc8dd9331efa20cf1662628fa33874292108882e26ad","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal","leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d65","kind":"description","unitIndex":65,"unitId":"unit:c9defcd4a836cacd3bc03dfdb756a10eaa6990ac5d6e5e81babe7bbfd1eff232","textSha256":"d112ae1afa243c3dceed5e47f843e50138251f651d46c1f9a2d31f096997d33c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:690a24fef1a99a77c5ccb75b","recordId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The source bundles assisted inflation, stabilization requirements and later exit/reheating; the singleton preserves that bundle.","challengeNote":"The singleton preserves the compound assisted-inflation, stabilization and exit/reheating construction.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"1eed35996ac521d3af15f3f220323d9537aa6906b04263cffadf23928d9431d6"},"organizational-access:a1c52778427b704da1146058":{"id":"organizational-access:a1c52778427b704da1146058","source":"q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c","target":"q025-candidate-question:2a2b074dcd15669c99b26e87","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"40d119e6f3e79ff22d58b64fe35d941338fbbccd79639cfbab9bcaf7d1badbd3","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0a0e2b9ba274a7ea779a675f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:2a2b074dcd15669c99b26e87","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ed60d9066e29fdbd5164d0c57ca55865885493f06c12d297c5fc25a5b50a419d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:4252732354ba9fb42733c7a3"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4979ca37722ae46f4cc60674d5b0f7a6d957b5fb1cfb91b70ef2ac2f27fcebb1","home":{"unitId":"unit:4979ca37722ae46f4cc60674d5b0f7a6d957b5fb1cfb91b70ef2ac2f27fcebb1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4979ca37722ae46f4cc60674d5b0f7a6d957b5fb1cfb91b70ef2ac2f27fcebb1","paperId":"hep-th/0402046","textSha256":"d91bbfe3e50b8cc906a62ef968151919981bdb7f3958e7028b3e1f60342fb058"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:42e9d9186a1046236fb0b255"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:42e9d9186a1046236fb0b255","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4979ca37722ae46f4cc60674d5b0f7a6d957b5fb1cfb91b70ef2ac2f27fcebb1","q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c"],"scopeContentSha256":"40d119e6f3e79ff22d58b64fe35d941338fbbccd79639cfbab9bcaf7d1badbd3","placementContentSha256":"83ca502417bf707243cb560c2d30a1dd468eec31a81bca001bf5efc1817eab34","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge","leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4979ca37722ae46f4cc60674d5b0f7a6d957b5fb1cfb91b70ef2ac2f27fcebb1","paperId":"hep-th/0402046","textSha256":"d91bbfe3e50b8cc906a62ef968151919981bdb7f3958e7028b3e1f60342fb058"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:42e9d9186a1046236fb0b255"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4979ca37722ae46f4cc60674d5b0f7a6d957b5fb1cfb91b70ef2ac2f27fcebb1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2a2b074dcd15669c99b26e87","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:4979ca37722ae46f4cc60674d5b0f7a6d957b5fb1cfb91b70ef2ac2f27fcebb1","textSha256":"d91bbfe3e50b8cc906a62ef968151919981bdb7f3958e7028b3e1f60342fb058"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f61af5a5fe276bf2950612d8"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f61af5a5fe276bf2950612d8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4979ca37722ae46f4cc60674d5b0f7a6d957b5fb1cfb91b70ef2ac2f27fcebb1","q025-candidate-question:2a2b074dcd15669c99b26e87"],"scopeContentSha256":"ed60d9066e29fdbd5164d0c57ca55865885493f06c12d297c5fc25a5b50a419d","contributionContentSha256":"afee7856fd2f30c6accafd911659dfd161967703c9a76f372781f51d67ea7445","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:4979ca37722ae46f4cc60674d5b0f7a6d957b5fb1cfb91b70ef2ac2f27fcebb1","textSha256":"d91bbfe3e50b8cc906a62ef968151919981bdb7f3958e7028b3e1f60342fb058"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f61af5a5fe276bf2950612d8","recordId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"FI restrictions and inflation, cosmic-string and D-brane applications remain compound targets.","challengeNote":"FI restrictions and inflation, cosmic-string and D-brane applications remain compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:676f06f5c0f696e019fd591e4defe97af2c41eb8fb0a10062ad9aa066fda4aa6","home":{"unitId":"unit:676f06f5c0f696e019fd591e4defe97af2c41eb8fb0a10062ad9aa066fda4aa6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:676f06f5c0f696e019fd591e4defe97af2c41eb8fb0a10062ad9aa066fda4aa6","paperId":"2108.04469","textSha256":"e06ba3c35e8a8b90ba09e90d579442e0cc9fadb3921a22267db63e866e0d52ef"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:009dc1dd326ece612f21e7d1c3256821","paperId":"2108.04469","sourceSha256":"226ee7a4c8b54c49a5ddce162291685f156c6bb3c80935f177388084f7666de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cff3c31f48647e4b1282/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3857de791440a81cb8c497369562ebd2e1f9ceead9cdeb5adbae4daae42d7bf9","pdfPage":4,"start":1291,"end":3357,"textSha256":"d05f7e0d7dfe65c0b5defe4f378b766908c5652cf12344b157ac388774dfce39","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3483a9d06a9b919890647952ca060e72","paperId":"2108.04469","sourceSha256":"226ee7a4c8b54c49a5ddce162291685f156c6bb3c80935f177388084f7666de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cff3c31f48647e4b1282/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3857de791440a81cb8c497369562ebd2e1f9ceead9cdeb5adbae4daae42d7bf9","pdfPage":4,"start":99,"end":3357,"textSha256":"ff6d28850f03f92b4379cfa42dfbf796ac532717a1af67200131879673e9692e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b9ec2951a7ba7c30397a9b362cd973c3","paperId":"2108.04469","sourceSha256":"226ee7a4c8b54c49a5ddce162291685f156c6bb3c80935f177388084f7666de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cff3c31f48647e4b1282/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3857de791440a81cb8c497369562ebd2e1f9ceead9cdeb5adbae4daae42d7bf9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1116,"textSha256":"6ae5f46ea823eccd5f6059d7f7d38a7b75fe937a5f59a6983b6e6b42d11b1813","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3b46e219be841a31800ab2e9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3b46e219be841a31800ab2e9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:676f06f5c0f696e019fd591e4defe97af2c41eb8fb0a10062ad9aa066fda4aa6","q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c"],"scopeContentSha256":"40d119e6f3e79ff22d58b64fe35d941338fbbccd79639cfbab9bcaf7d1badbd3","placementContentSha256":"72d24bb1e44d30ac7839232731255fcb015e1f37e188d5c7697200630f6708cf","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge","leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:676f06f5c0f696e019fd591e4defe97af2c41eb8fb0a10062ad9aa066fda4aa6","paperId":"2108.04469","textSha256":"e06ba3c35e8a8b90ba09e90d579442e0cc9fadb3921a22267db63e866e0d52ef"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:009dc1dd326ece612f21e7d1c3256821","paperId":"2108.04469","sourceSha256":"226ee7a4c8b54c49a5ddce162291685f156c6bb3c80935f177388084f7666de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cff3c31f48647e4b1282/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3857de791440a81cb8c497369562ebd2e1f9ceead9cdeb5adbae4daae42d7bf9","pdfPage":4,"start":1291,"end":3357,"textSha256":"d05f7e0d7dfe65c0b5defe4f378b766908c5652cf12344b157ac388774dfce39","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3483a9d06a9b919890647952ca060e72","paperId":"2108.04469","sourceSha256":"226ee7a4c8b54c49a5ddce162291685f156c6bb3c80935f177388084f7666de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cff3c31f48647e4b1282/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3857de791440a81cb8c497369562ebd2e1f9ceead9cdeb5adbae4daae42d7bf9","pdfPage":4,"start":99,"end":3357,"textSha256":"ff6d28850f03f92b4379cfa42dfbf796ac532717a1af67200131879673e9692e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b9ec2951a7ba7c30397a9b362cd973c3","paperId":"2108.04469","sourceSha256":"226ee7a4c8b54c49a5ddce162291685f156c6bb3c80935f177388084f7666de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cff3c31f48647e4b1282/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3857de791440a81cb8c497369562ebd2e1f9ceead9cdeb5adbae4daae42d7bf9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1116,"textSha256":"6ae5f46ea823eccd5f6059d7f7d38a7b75fe937a5f59a6983b6e6b42d11b1813","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3b46e219be841a31800ab2e9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:676f06f5c0f696e019fd591e4defe97af2c41eb8fb0a10062ad9aa066fda4aa6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2a2b074dcd15669c99b26e87","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:676f06f5c0f696e019fd591e4defe97af2c41eb8fb0a10062ad9aa066fda4aa6","textSha256":"e06ba3c35e8a8b90ba09e90d579442e0cc9fadb3921a22267db63e866e0d52ef"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:009dc1dd326ece612f21e7d1c3256821","paperId":"2108.04469","sourceSha256":"226ee7a4c8b54c49a5ddce162291685f156c6bb3c80935f177388084f7666de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cff3c31f48647e4b1282/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3857de791440a81cb8c497369562ebd2e1f9ceead9cdeb5adbae4daae42d7bf9","pdfPage":4,"start":1291,"end":3357,"textSha256":"d05f7e0d7dfe65c0b5defe4f378b766908c5652cf12344b157ac388774dfce39","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3483a9d06a9b919890647952ca060e72","paperId":"2108.04469","sourceSha256":"226ee7a4c8b54c49a5ddce162291685f156c6bb3c80935f177388084f7666de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cff3c31f48647e4b1282/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3857de791440a81cb8c497369562ebd2e1f9ceead9cdeb5adbae4daae42d7bf9","pdfPage":4,"start":99,"end":3357,"textSha256":"ff6d28850f03f92b4379cfa42dfbf796ac532717a1af67200131879673e9692e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b9ec2951a7ba7c30397a9b362cd973c3","paperId":"2108.04469","sourceSha256":"226ee7a4c8b54c49a5ddce162291685f156c6bb3c80935f177388084f7666de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cff3c31f48647e4b1282/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3857de791440a81cb8c497369562ebd2e1f9ceead9cdeb5adbae4daae42d7bf9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1116,"textSha256":"6ae5f46ea823eccd5f6059d7f7d38a7b75fe937a5f59a6983b6e6b42d11b1813","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d4b09a52175fff86a222d741"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d4b09a52175fff86a222d741","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:676f06f5c0f696e019fd591e4defe97af2c41eb8fb0a10062ad9aa066fda4aa6","q025-candidate-question:2a2b074dcd15669c99b26e87"],"scopeContentSha256":"ed60d9066e29fdbd5164d0c57ca55865885493f06c12d297c5fc25a5b50a419d","contributionContentSha256":"4b1c2e61e5dc48305ca94e1798d81caf035c41cf999ff61b65fbe4ae21fc7234","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:676f06f5c0f696e019fd591e4defe97af2c41eb8fb0a10062ad9aa066fda4aa6","textSha256":"e06ba3c35e8a8b90ba09e90d579442e0cc9fadb3921a22267db63e866e0d52ef"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:009dc1dd326ece612f21e7d1c3256821","paperId":"2108.04469","sourceSha256":"226ee7a4c8b54c49a5ddce162291685f156c6bb3c80935f177388084f7666de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cff3c31f48647e4b1282/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3857de791440a81cb8c497369562ebd2e1f9ceead9cdeb5adbae4daae42d7bf9","pdfPage":4,"start":1291,"end":3357,"textSha256":"d05f7e0d7dfe65c0b5defe4f378b766908c5652cf12344b157ac388774dfce39","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3483a9d06a9b919890647952ca060e72","paperId":"2108.04469","sourceSha256":"226ee7a4c8b54c49a5ddce162291685f156c6bb3c80935f177388084f7666de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cff3c31f48647e4b1282/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3857de791440a81cb8c497369562ebd2e1f9ceead9cdeb5adbae4daae42d7bf9","pdfPage":4,"start":99,"end":3357,"textSha256":"ff6d28850f03f92b4379cfa42dfbf796ac532717a1af67200131879673e9692e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b9ec2951a7ba7c30397a9b362cd973c3","paperId":"2108.04469","sourceSha256":"226ee7a4c8b54c49a5ddce162291685f156c6bb3c80935f177388084f7666de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cff3c31f48647e4b1282/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3857de791440a81cb8c497369562ebd2e1f9ceead9cdeb5adbae4daae42d7bf9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1116,"textSha256":"6ae5f46ea823eccd5f6059d7f7d38a7b75fe937a5f59a6983b6e6b42d11b1813","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d4b09a52175fff86a222d741","recordId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Two distinct action families and their cutoff analyses require finer reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Two distinct action families and their cutoff analyses require finer reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:69f53ae869869d195570580ff81694809f50748cef66c022872d9b1972448def","home":{"unitId":"unit:69f53ae869869d195570580ff81694809f50748cef66c022872d9b1972448def","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:69f53ae869869d195570580ff81694809f50748cef66c022872d9b1972448def","paperId":"hep-th/0006179","textSha256":"58033544315b6a237eb510e435e400e7eef30bcf172978369d351bbf899cb913"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1c3c7d36fca90b5e3b22d5bc"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1c3c7d36fca90b5e3b22d5bc","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:69f53ae869869d195570580ff81694809f50748cef66c022872d9b1972448def","q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c"],"scopeContentSha256":"40d119e6f3e79ff22d58b64fe35d941338fbbccd79639cfbab9bcaf7d1badbd3","placementContentSha256":"87712d77a26df6b2090daa061e7cb52765d80dc764bfca2aa743ed9692fcdfec","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge","leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:69f53ae869869d195570580ff81694809f50748cef66c022872d9b1972448def","paperId":"hep-th/0006179","textSha256":"58033544315b6a237eb510e435e400e7eef30bcf172978369d351bbf899cb913"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1c3c7d36fca90b5e3b22d5bc"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:69f53ae869869d195570580ff81694809f50748cef66c022872d9b1972448def","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2a2b074dcd15669c99b26e87","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:69f53ae869869d195570580ff81694809f50748cef66c022872d9b1972448def","textSha256":"58033544315b6a237eb510e435e400e7eef30bcf172978369d351bbf899cb913"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3b405290083038d36a20208a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3b405290083038d36a20208a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:69f53ae869869d195570580ff81694809f50748cef66c022872d9b1972448def","q025-candidate-question:2a2b074dcd15669c99b26e87"],"scopeContentSha256":"ed60d9066e29fdbd5164d0c57ca55865885493f06c12d297c5fc25a5b50a419d","contributionContentSha256":"e6d7c614425f23548ed353e70d300b0f9c23fb7fcf9213339fe632af352d59d0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:69f53ae869869d195570580ff81694809f50748cef66c022872d9b1972448def","textSha256":"58033544315b6a237eb510e435e400e7eef30bcf172978369d351bbf899cb913"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3b405290083038d36a20208a","recordId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Matter-action organization, FI couplings and cosmological production remain compound targets.","challengeNote":"Matter-action organization, FI couplings and cosmological production remain compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:83446a077f03cdeb0e92979625d43562414a6ee506b56f56a75a80118a2e43d4","home":{"unitId":"unit:83446a077f03cdeb0e92979625d43562414a6ee506b56f56a75a80118a2e43d4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:83446a077f03cdeb0e92979625d43562414a6ee506b56f56a75a80118a2e43d4","paperId":"0904.1159","textSha256":"a1d2346295cfe28c62bfdea776724f1073499f895830d030bbef7c8610deb6fc"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8e6e2421455d18c726e4e6d3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8e6e2421455d18c726e4e6d3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:83446a077f03cdeb0e92979625d43562414a6ee506b56f56a75a80118a2e43d4","q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c"],"scopeContentSha256":"40d119e6f3e79ff22d58b64fe35d941338fbbccd79639cfbab9bcaf7d1badbd3","placementContentSha256":"671bd31977138512ae46943ee79641cef42f3b69a533312fec72556c6447771b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge","leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:83446a077f03cdeb0e92979625d43562414a6ee506b56f56a75a80118a2e43d4","paperId":"0904.1159","textSha256":"a1d2346295cfe28c62bfdea776724f1073499f895830d030bbef7c8610deb6fc"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8e6e2421455d18c726e4e6d3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:83446a077f03cdeb0e92979625d43562414a6ee506b56f56a75a80118a2e43d4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2a2b074dcd15669c99b26e87","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:83446a077f03cdeb0e92979625d43562414a6ee506b56f56a75a80118a2e43d4","textSha256":"a1d2346295cfe28c62bfdea776724f1073499f895830d030bbef7c8610deb6fc"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:17d6ba35e447a649813829cc"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:17d6ba35e447a649813829cc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:83446a077f03cdeb0e92979625d43562414a6ee506b56f56a75a80118a2e43d4","q025-candidate-question:2a2b074dcd15669c99b26e87"],"scopeContentSha256":"ed60d9066e29fdbd5164d0c57ca55865885493f06c12d297c5fc25a5b50a419d","contributionContentSha256":"8fca72e23e9ee4ca2b8908bb7e369bbf0d7cd8c05d50ab7dc525965d08ae7b6a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:83446a077f03cdeb0e92979625d43562414a6ee506b56f56a75a80118a2e43d4","textSha256":"a1d2346295cfe28c62bfdea776724f1073499f895830d030bbef7c8610deb6fc"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:17d6ba35e447a649813829cc","recordId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"FI renormalization/generation and gravity-coupling tests remain a compound source question.","challengeNote":"Renormalization, dynamical generation and gravitational coupling remain compound targets requiring reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":4,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"5c71cabefa42f0764fa739301948c387128f5ea4f3c2f61d7464f11e60ef2541"},"organizational-access:62a06e5aec81c89cf37cae34":{"id":"organizational-access:62a06e5aec81c89cf37cae34","source":"q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c","target":"q025-candidate-question:7872a16aa0e86e4b70680dea","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"40d119e6f3e79ff22d58b64fe35d941338fbbccd79639cfbab9bcaf7d1badbd3","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0a0e2b9ba274a7ea779a675f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:7872a16aa0e86e4b70680dea","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"fc3bbb545e900867b9f73d21720461bad6fe86216f7be491a417ebf44ea0d50e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:564411cae14416c0a458b1e4"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:00ae3ee9633152e11d57514a254cab75add65fe65f2cff9bfaddff2e734ce2d8","home":{"unitId":"unit:00ae3ee9633152e11d57514a254cab75add65fe65f2cff9bfaddff2e734ce2d8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:00ae3ee9633152e11d57514a254cab75add65fe65f2cff9bfaddff2e734ce2d8","paperId":"1509.02136","textSha256":"40c95ce05facf47ac5d42d50dc8c16c7f0a21396c4acf1a1efb9e4c34b10b644"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:535a057fbde98c81afe984ad9983749f","paperId":"1509.02136","sourceSha256":"6c71939c2a7bacdc4c418ead583d8cd801478ba801e85ad8463094af02f18490","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d95c798d5187d1300db/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1b7a40f9d1943ee1e5fa94d37afb2891b2e1e1a5775a4b71b7fc69cfaf76002","pdfPage":11,"start":0,"end":2979,"textSha256":"c03690988056a57320e09e076e43abde4d92feccb74988272c30711a53b6bd5a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:688b19f21dfcfc4934846f6cfc93c5ab","paperId":"1509.02136","sourceSha256":"6c71939c2a7bacdc4c418ead583d8cd801478ba801e85ad8463094af02f18490","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d95c798d5187d1300db/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1b7a40f9d1943ee1e5fa94d37afb2891b2e1e1a5775a4b71b7fc69cfaf76002","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1368,"textSha256":"e1b868e04a00f8d14aa85ce4d1838f4e9d4a627521b92f9ed5f19ffa18bd0075","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a0c26ba49222d260859e9ef5c0b88a17","paperId":"1509.02136","sourceSha256":"6c71939c2a7bacdc4c418ead583d8cd801478ba801e85ad8463094af02f18490","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d95c798d5187d1300db/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1b7a40f9d1943ee1e5fa94d37afb2891b2e1e1a5775a4b71b7fc69cfaf76002","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2645,"textSha256":"af478c08f3a90eb9dcbb62f92e573002f06750449773e873c1b8ba15d31c3921","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c2f56d66e4619de38173e5ec"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c2f56d66e4619de38173e5ec","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:00ae3ee9633152e11d57514a254cab75add65fe65f2cff9bfaddff2e734ce2d8","q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c"],"scopeContentSha256":"40d119e6f3e79ff22d58b64fe35d941338fbbccd79639cfbab9bcaf7d1badbd3","placementContentSha256":"0206a994914fe820ef5ef8cc20b0e79411aad06784c0e4d9d1298a8ca056f1b0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge","leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:00ae3ee9633152e11d57514a254cab75add65fe65f2cff9bfaddff2e734ce2d8","paperId":"1509.02136","textSha256":"40c95ce05facf47ac5d42d50dc8c16c7f0a21396c4acf1a1efb9e4c34b10b644"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:535a057fbde98c81afe984ad9983749f","paperId":"1509.02136","sourceSha256":"6c71939c2a7bacdc4c418ead583d8cd801478ba801e85ad8463094af02f18490","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d95c798d5187d1300db/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1b7a40f9d1943ee1e5fa94d37afb2891b2e1e1a5775a4b71b7fc69cfaf76002","pdfPage":11,"start":0,"end":2979,"textSha256":"c03690988056a57320e09e076e43abde4d92feccb74988272c30711a53b6bd5a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:688b19f21dfcfc4934846f6cfc93c5ab","paperId":"1509.02136","sourceSha256":"6c71939c2a7bacdc4c418ead583d8cd801478ba801e85ad8463094af02f18490","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d95c798d5187d1300db/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1b7a40f9d1943ee1e5fa94d37afb2891b2e1e1a5775a4b71b7fc69cfaf76002","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1368,"textSha256":"e1b868e04a00f8d14aa85ce4d1838f4e9d4a627521b92f9ed5f19ffa18bd0075","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a0c26ba49222d260859e9ef5c0b88a17","paperId":"1509.02136","sourceSha256":"6c71939c2a7bacdc4c418ead583d8cd801478ba801e85ad8463094af02f18490","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d95c798d5187d1300db/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1b7a40f9d1943ee1e5fa94d37afb2891b2e1e1a5775a4b71b7fc69cfaf76002","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2645,"textSha256":"af478c08f3a90eb9dcbb62f92e573002f06750449773e873c1b8ba15d31c3921","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c2f56d66e4619de38173e5ec"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:00ae3ee9633152e11d57514a254cab75add65fe65f2cff9bfaddff2e734ce2d8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7872a16aa0e86e4b70680dea","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:00ae3ee9633152e11d57514a254cab75add65fe65f2cff9bfaddff2e734ce2d8","textSha256":"40c95ce05facf47ac5d42d50dc8c16c7f0a21396c4acf1a1efb9e4c34b10b644"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:535a057fbde98c81afe984ad9983749f","paperId":"1509.02136","sourceSha256":"6c71939c2a7bacdc4c418ead583d8cd801478ba801e85ad8463094af02f18490","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d95c798d5187d1300db/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1b7a40f9d1943ee1e5fa94d37afb2891b2e1e1a5775a4b71b7fc69cfaf76002","pdfPage":11,"start":0,"end":2979,"textSha256":"c03690988056a57320e09e076e43abde4d92feccb74988272c30711a53b6bd5a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:688b19f21dfcfc4934846f6cfc93c5ab","paperId":"1509.02136","sourceSha256":"6c71939c2a7bacdc4c418ead583d8cd801478ba801e85ad8463094af02f18490","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d95c798d5187d1300db/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1b7a40f9d1943ee1e5fa94d37afb2891b2e1e1a5775a4b71b7fc69cfaf76002","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1368,"textSha256":"e1b868e04a00f8d14aa85ce4d1838f4e9d4a627521b92f9ed5f19ffa18bd0075","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a0c26ba49222d260859e9ef5c0b88a17","paperId":"1509.02136","sourceSha256":"6c71939c2a7bacdc4c418ead583d8cd801478ba801e85ad8463094af02f18490","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d95c798d5187d1300db/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1b7a40f9d1943ee1e5fa94d37afb2891b2e1e1a5775a4b71b7fc69cfaf76002","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2645,"textSha256":"af478c08f3a90eb9dcbb62f92e573002f06750449773e873c1b8ba15d31c3921","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:535240d57635a03a7431b250"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:535240d57635a03a7431b250","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:00ae3ee9633152e11d57514a254cab75add65fe65f2cff9bfaddff2e734ce2d8","q025-candidate-question:7872a16aa0e86e4b70680dea"],"scopeContentSha256":"fc3bbb545e900867b9f73d21720461bad6fe86216f7be491a417ebf44ea0d50e","contributionContentSha256":"3d79970ad46a5f3e721cf9832bc38bbf3fb8b2cc889fdc1cc165595f84091076","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:00ae3ee9633152e11d57514a254cab75add65fe65f2cff9bfaddff2e734ce2d8","textSha256":"40c95ce05facf47ac5d42d50dc8c16c7f0a21396c4acf1a1efb9e4c34b10b644"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:535a057fbde98c81afe984ad9983749f","paperId":"1509.02136","sourceSha256":"6c71939c2a7bacdc4c418ead583d8cd801478ba801e85ad8463094af02f18490","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d95c798d5187d1300db/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1b7a40f9d1943ee1e5fa94d37afb2891b2e1e1a5775a4b71b7fc69cfaf76002","pdfPage":11,"start":0,"end":2979,"textSha256":"c03690988056a57320e09e076e43abde4d92feccb74988272c30711a53b6bd5a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:688b19f21dfcfc4934846f6cfc93c5ab","paperId":"1509.02136","sourceSha256":"6c71939c2a7bacdc4c418ead583d8cd801478ba801e85ad8463094af02f18490","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d95c798d5187d1300db/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1b7a40f9d1943ee1e5fa94d37afb2891b2e1e1a5775a4b71b7fc69cfaf76002","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1368,"textSha256":"e1b868e04a00f8d14aa85ce4d1838f4e9d4a627521b92f9ed5f19ffa18bd0075","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a0c26ba49222d260859e9ef5c0b88a17","paperId":"1509.02136","sourceSha256":"6c71939c2a7bacdc4c418ead583d8cd801478ba801e85ad8463094af02f18490","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d95c798d5187d1300db/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1b7a40f9d1943ee1e5fa94d37afb2891b2e1e1a5775a4b71b7fc69cfaf76002","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2645,"textSha256":"af478c08f3a90eb9dcbb62f92e573002f06750449773e873c1b8ba15d31c3921","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:535240d57635a03a7431b250","recordId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"General strategy and explicit unitary-gauge action are supplied; generic symbolic coefficients are deferred.","challengeNote":"The general strategy has deferred symbolic coefficients; the explicit simple action is gauge-specific.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:22bf9c95174422fd54815bd05edfdd7b6ec685b8e33c350a67d6a76e813e1875","home":{"unitId":"unit:22bf9c95174422fd54815bd05edfdd7b6ec685b8e33c350a67d6a76e813e1875","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:22bf9c95174422fd54815bd05edfdd7b6ec685b8e33c350a67d6a76e813e1875","paperId":"1511.01542","textSha256":"8435e5a135ea645fc1d3b5d4154f164dbc2983f45acbbabcd9ef140028afad66"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8255508adc52628cf534011b162439fe","paperId":"1511.01542","sourceSha256":"447104010a4a738390493f5253b991ce049c139560d624c959b2a67cf45fa7f7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/12a3650e1af74aa7e358/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3025d524b239129c17d24f5b72331ad908330ab11dd0a937d3aec4b11eee9671","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"4c1594cb9713ae38f010152f2d54e65e0d5fda948e9c6bbe35c3270e08ec45b8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:915be86472792d9510b32eb82f850aa6","paperId":"1511.01542","sourceSha256":"447104010a4a738390493f5253b991ce049c139560d624c959b2a67cf45fa7f7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/12a3650e1af74aa7e358/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3025d524b239129c17d24f5b72331ad908330ab11dd0a937d3aec4b11eee9671","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b8c7550ecde938b9f44aa1f57b6342702c827e2fe3808505884c82903ebe6f3d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f4788a16c958810e46ce7da55084963c","paperId":"1511.01542","sourceSha256":"447104010a4a738390493f5253b991ce049c139560d624c959b2a67cf45fa7f7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/12a3650e1af74aa7e358/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3025d524b239129c17d24f5b72331ad908330ab11dd0a937d3aec4b11eee9671","pdfPage":6,"start":2510,"end":4789,"textSha256":"23b2e70280bfd97db23764b7c44475a20c0f5ae6beb5b7d93548d3bae3ae9d1e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b092e70aa90b43ac30bf6f8e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b092e70aa90b43ac30bf6f8e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:22bf9c95174422fd54815bd05edfdd7b6ec685b8e33c350a67d6a76e813e1875","q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c"],"scopeContentSha256":"40d119e6f3e79ff22d58b64fe35d941338fbbccd79639cfbab9bcaf7d1badbd3","placementContentSha256":"a29658d221a4e43e5b6075192cc65939082e9cc7a88520deb9b6f119170fb478","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge","leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:22bf9c95174422fd54815bd05edfdd7b6ec685b8e33c350a67d6a76e813e1875","paperId":"1511.01542","textSha256":"8435e5a135ea645fc1d3b5d4154f164dbc2983f45acbbabcd9ef140028afad66"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8255508adc52628cf534011b162439fe","paperId":"1511.01542","sourceSha256":"447104010a4a738390493f5253b991ce049c139560d624c959b2a67cf45fa7f7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/12a3650e1af74aa7e358/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3025d524b239129c17d24f5b72331ad908330ab11dd0a937d3aec4b11eee9671","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"4c1594cb9713ae38f010152f2d54e65e0d5fda948e9c6bbe35c3270e08ec45b8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:915be86472792d9510b32eb82f850aa6","paperId":"1511.01542","sourceSha256":"447104010a4a738390493f5253b991ce049c139560d624c959b2a67cf45fa7f7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/12a3650e1af74aa7e358/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3025d524b239129c17d24f5b72331ad908330ab11dd0a937d3aec4b11eee9671","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b8c7550ecde938b9f44aa1f57b6342702c827e2fe3808505884c82903ebe6f3d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f4788a16c958810e46ce7da55084963c","paperId":"1511.01542","sourceSha256":"447104010a4a738390493f5253b991ce049c139560d624c959b2a67cf45fa7f7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/12a3650e1af74aa7e358/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3025d524b239129c17d24f5b72331ad908330ab11dd0a937d3aec4b11eee9671","pdfPage":6,"start":2510,"end":4789,"textSha256":"23b2e70280bfd97db23764b7c44475a20c0f5ae6beb5b7d93548d3bae3ae9d1e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b092e70aa90b43ac30bf6f8e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:22bf9c95174422fd54815bd05edfdd7b6ec685b8e33c350a67d6a76e813e1875","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7872a16aa0e86e4b70680dea","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:22bf9c95174422fd54815bd05edfdd7b6ec685b8e33c350a67d6a76e813e1875","textSha256":"8435e5a135ea645fc1d3b5d4154f164dbc2983f45acbbabcd9ef140028afad66"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8255508adc52628cf534011b162439fe","paperId":"1511.01542","sourceSha256":"447104010a4a738390493f5253b991ce049c139560d624c959b2a67cf45fa7f7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/12a3650e1af74aa7e358/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3025d524b239129c17d24f5b72331ad908330ab11dd0a937d3aec4b11eee9671","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"4c1594cb9713ae38f010152f2d54e65e0d5fda948e9c6bbe35c3270e08ec45b8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:915be86472792d9510b32eb82f850aa6","paperId":"1511.01542","sourceSha256":"447104010a4a738390493f5253b991ce049c139560d624c959b2a67cf45fa7f7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/12a3650e1af74aa7e358/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3025d524b239129c17d24f5b72331ad908330ab11dd0a937d3aec4b11eee9671","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b8c7550ecde938b9f44aa1f57b6342702c827e2fe3808505884c82903ebe6f3d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f4788a16c958810e46ce7da55084963c","paperId":"1511.01542","sourceSha256":"447104010a4a738390493f5253b991ce049c139560d624c959b2a67cf45fa7f7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/12a3650e1af74aa7e358/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3025d524b239129c17d24f5b72331ad908330ab11dd0a937d3aec4b11eee9671","pdfPage":6,"start":2510,"end":4789,"textSha256":"23b2e70280bfd97db23764b7c44475a20c0f5ae6beb5b7d93548d3bae3ae9d1e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:583fb32313e540e6da54c52a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:583fb32313e540e6da54c52a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:22bf9c95174422fd54815bd05edfdd7b6ec685b8e33c350a67d6a76e813e1875","q025-candidate-question:7872a16aa0e86e4b70680dea"],"scopeContentSha256":"fc3bbb545e900867b9f73d21720461bad6fe86216f7be491a417ebf44ea0d50e","contributionContentSha256":"959c55b2b3c35bc2e65cee06c2d4c8994ceffc9defcac78e26e7b5137328b0c8","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:22bf9c95174422fd54815bd05edfdd7b6ec685b8e33c350a67d6a76e813e1875","textSha256":"8435e5a135ea645fc1d3b5d4154f164dbc2983f45acbbabcd9ef140028afad66"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8255508adc52628cf534011b162439fe","paperId":"1511.01542","sourceSha256":"447104010a4a738390493f5253b991ce049c139560d624c959b2a67cf45fa7f7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/12a3650e1af74aa7e358/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3025d524b239129c17d24f5b72331ad908330ab11dd0a937d3aec4b11eee9671","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"4c1594cb9713ae38f010152f2d54e65e0d5fda948e9c6bbe35c3270e08ec45b8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:915be86472792d9510b32eb82f850aa6","paperId":"1511.01542","sourceSha256":"447104010a4a738390493f5253b991ce049c139560d624c959b2a67cf45fa7f7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/12a3650e1af74aa7e358/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3025d524b239129c17d24f5b72331ad908330ab11dd0a937d3aec4b11eee9671","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b8c7550ecde938b9f44aa1f57b6342702c827e2fe3808505884c82903ebe6f3d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f4788a16c958810e46ce7da55084963c","paperId":"1511.01542","sourceSha256":"447104010a4a738390493f5253b991ce049c139560d624c959b2a67cf45fa7f7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/12a3650e1af74aa7e358/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3025d524b239129c17d24f5b72331ad908330ab11dd0a937d3aec4b11eee9671","pdfPage":6,"start":2510,"end":4789,"textSha256":"23b2e70280bfd97db23764b7c44475a20c0f5ae6beb5b7d93548d3bae3ae9d1e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:583fb32313e540e6da54c52a","recordId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Linear nilpotent-field Kähler terms are explicitly admitted; no fine merge with the strategy source.","challengeNote":"Linear nilpotent-field Kähler terms are explicitly admitted; the excerpts do not establish their exclusion from every earlier strategy.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:dec10dbec1fe45756ea44d30ea17e8be4d3a3b7435ae6d1a02be62f80802d370","home":{"unitId":"unit:dec10dbec1fe45756ea44d30ea17e8be4d3a3b7435ae6d1a02be62f80802d370","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:dec10dbec1fe45756ea44d30ea17e8be4d3a3b7435ae6d1a02be62f80802d370","paperId":"1512.02158","textSha256":"4d6cb8622da4859441556b9caab668c1ec48a94d66de872c3d65086b99280af4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:757c9743494f872f8eb90e08"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:757c9743494f872f8eb90e08","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:dec10dbec1fe45756ea44d30ea17e8be4d3a3b7435ae6d1a02be62f80802d370","q025-candidate-region:a04fd1021477a1c8c588520c"],"scopeContentSha256":"40d119e6f3e79ff22d58b64fe35d941338fbbccd79639cfbab9bcaf7d1badbd3","placementContentSha256":"534e47e2a453a73babbc59d51616a5827289c6f79b6665d1b2e3c0756aefd2a7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge","leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:dec10dbec1fe45756ea44d30ea17e8be4d3a3b7435ae6d1a02be62f80802d370","paperId":"1512.02158","textSha256":"4d6cb8622da4859441556b9caab668c1ec48a94d66de872c3d65086b99280af4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:757c9743494f872f8eb90e08"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:dec10dbec1fe45756ea44d30ea17e8be4d3a3b7435ae6d1a02be62f80802d370","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7872a16aa0e86e4b70680dea","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:dec10dbec1fe45756ea44d30ea17e8be4d3a3b7435ae6d1a02be62f80802d370","textSha256":"4d6cb8622da4859441556b9caab668c1ec48a94d66de872c3d65086b99280af4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:109b8ef1881ad3a2dc96257b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:109b8ef1881ad3a2dc96257b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:dec10dbec1fe45756ea44d30ea17e8be4d3a3b7435ae6d1a02be62f80802d370","q025-candidate-question:7872a16aa0e86e4b70680dea"],"scopeContentSha256":"fc3bbb545e900867b9f73d21720461bad6fe86216f7be491a417ebf44ea0d50e","contributionContentSha256":"2fb2074d652dae40e5ba1bb49f08b3aaf3d4c63eeab394cde93e7f28a4ee7fce","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:dec10dbec1fe45756ea44d30ea17e8be4d3a3b7435ae6d1a02be62f80802d370","textSha256":"4d6cb8622da4859441556b9caab668c1ec48a94d66de872c3d65086b99280af4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:109b8ef1881ad3a2dc96257b","recordId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4317c30b131ec7fbc5ef-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Existing-constraint supergravity extensions and a new fermion-removing constraint need finer reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Existing-constraint extensions and a new fermion-removing constraint need finer reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"6566316fdb189fb3100281dd9b584bb818c1304ad876558c3bc973da96d831c8"},"organizational-access:f8bbaac29a3b9b4a1a1345f7":{"id":"organizational-access:f8bbaac29a3b9b4a1a1345f7","source":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9","target":"q025-candidate-question:a2482fda5031d59e6148314c","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"2aaa3916150d9c40eb23087fe71c0dabf37597ff3dd1a43473e1e63c8e828df0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:76c8c127702b0d2975d9e4ab"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a2482fda5031d59e6148314c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"d93f64e2ba448428619954ef4ff74d942f152127955b880bc93a4916f80c7eb1","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e4bdb00f6f71b95701741336"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","home":{"unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly accommodates period reconstruction, charge bounds and flux stabilization as distinct contributions of one source, including asymptotic regimes beyond large complex structure.","qualification":"q22 covers periods and couplings near degenerations, selected-state weak-gravity calculations and flux stabilization beyond large complex structure as one compound source. Its explicit treatment of these distinct contributions avoids a source split. Polynomial self-duality or potential approximations do not remove exponential terms required for other observables, including metrics and F-terms.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","paperId":"2207.00303","textSha256":"dca7fd64b03fee3206aca2cb0907fb91afdcc045dcd9fc29e3cb9fe3c26c54ce"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0040:u11:q22"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0040:u11:q22","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9"],"scopeContentSha256":"2aaa3916150d9c40eb23087fe71c0dabf37597ff3dd1a43473e1e63c8e828df0","placementContentSha256":"c96b97ab2ba8d722364519f809fefee0d8462997e6e4aa0dc8d6ca491d3c670d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0040:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0040:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","paperId":"2207.00303","textSha256":"dca7fd64b03fee3206aca2cb0907fb91afdcc045dcd9fc29e3cb9fe3c26c54ce"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0040","unitRef":"u11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a2482fda5031d59e6148314c","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d43","kind":"description","unitIndex":43,"unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","textSha256":"dca7fd64b03fee3206aca2cb0907fb91afdcc045dcd9fc29e3cb9fe3c26c54ce"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:309ac92ca466bb3c7a5527db1e889080","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":261,"start":0,"end":2500,"textSha256":"acf7b20aec273527e541c0841fa6f50e02654cc1292218f91d865396cef23659","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f2dff08833dc8363cf59ee00a5e5c422","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":261,"start":91,"end":2500,"textSha256":"a28ce145f8f83a65e060cbcdb5fdefc086e0a9ded5a24a1ff2ad5a94f0738b65","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:65e7f1b1ca28f02e924bcaa6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:65e7f1b1ca28f02e924bcaa6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","q025-candidate-question:a2482fda5031d59e6148314c"],"scopeContentSha256":"d93f64e2ba448428619954ef4ff74d942f152127955b880bc93a4916f80c7eb1","contributionContentSha256":"53ebc84fd1d2c1ec975d9404151419aad946a0de87e97db8394d903b64276eb3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-proposal","leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d43","kind":"description","unitIndex":43,"unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","textSha256":"dca7fd64b03fee3206aca2cb0907fb91afdcc045dcd9fc29e3cb9fe3c26c54ce"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:309ac92ca466bb3c7a5527db1e889080","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":261,"start":0,"end":2500,"textSha256":"acf7b20aec273527e541c0841fa6f50e02654cc1292218f91d865396cef23659","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f2dff08833dc8363cf59ee00a5e5c422","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":261,"start":91,"end":2500,"textSha256":"a28ce145f8f83a65e060cbcdb5fdefc086e0a9ded5a24a1ff2ad5a94f0738b65","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:65e7f1b1ca28f02e924bcaa6","recordId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound period construction, WGC bounds and flux stabilization. Essential exponentials depend on the observable and approximation.","challengeNote":"Period construction, selected-state BPS bounds and flux stabilization remain compound. Essential exponentials depend on observable and approximation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"7eb6e2f4af8d4d010212439beadd58d76ea603ffbb261d076eb413857ed64c3f"},"organizational-access:95b87e1e331289b609971c7c":{"id":"organizational-access:95b87e1e331289b609971c7c","source":"q025-candidate-region:b9db50aaf90c19b193c32982","target":"q025-candidate-question:48983ed3b27eda877fa09791","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:b9db50aaf90c19b193c32982","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"4a01628243d0ec62f424667e141932e8b0188d8e32a68b76d4857223e7666e21","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:67b97ad2b56a9aec8147dc24"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:48983ed3b27eda877fa09791","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"2523b6296f982ab9ee2d58331dc4b17a7093e16cff40531ac92ff2a81d8aad5d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6b8d8424f9e2c0162f0f759c"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5985e1ca3ee1964f066e5aacde2153af6772236641ec0f4517d958769c26f1ab","home":{"unitId":"unit:5985e1ca3ee1964f066e5aacde2153af6772236641ec0f4517d958769c26f1ab","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b9db50aaf90c19b193c32982","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers infinite-volume induced gravity, matter localization and source-specific gravitational scales in string-based braneworlds.","qualification":"q20 includes string-based braneworlds, infinite-volume induced gravity, matter localization, quantum-corrected descriptions and gravitational-scale conventions. Chiral matter is a requirement of the proposed embedding, rather than a separate spectrum-enumeration question. These provisions cover the construction and possible TeV-string/Planck-scale separation without asserting its success.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5985e1ca3ee1964f066e5aacde2153af6772236641ec0f4517d958769c26f1ab","paperId":"hep-th/0109054","textSha256":"1451a72460117fc01dae90cead511cef5191e0c876a05085e0fb20be711f4ceb"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0007:u3:q20"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0007:u3:q20","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5985e1ca3ee1964f066e5aacde2153af6772236641ec0f4517d958769c26f1ab","q025-candidate-region:b9db50aaf90c19b193c32982"],"scopeContentSha256":"4a01628243d0ec62f424667e141932e8b0188d8e32a68b76d4857223e7666e21","placementContentSha256":"55c09bf471adee704ab2e14a3a26ce6f49898bcf4723fc98d97e9d9cd0930a44","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0007:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0007:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5985e1ca3ee1964f066e5aacde2153af6772236641ec0f4517d958769c26f1ab","paperId":"hep-th/0109054","textSha256":"1451a72460117fc01dae90cead511cef5191e0c876a05085e0fb20be711f4ceb"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0007","unitRef":"u3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5985e1ca3ee1964f066e5aacde2153af6772236641ec0f4517d958769c26f1ab","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:48983ed3b27eda877fa09791","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d68","kind":"description","unitIndex":68,"unitId":"unit:5985e1ca3ee1964f066e5aacde2153af6772236641ec0f4517d958769c26f1ab","textSha256":"1451a72460117fc01dae90cead511cef5191e0c876a05085e0fb20be711f4ceb"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c32ff43d71198409c957d501"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c32ff43d71198409c957d501","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5985e1ca3ee1964f066e5aacde2153af6772236641ec0f4517d958769c26f1ab","q025-candidate-question:48983ed3b27eda877fa09791"],"scopeContentSha256":"2523b6296f982ab9ee2d58331dc4b17a7093e16cff40531ac92ff2a81d8aad5d","contributionContentSha256":"867caf628a1f3be94b7767e65bffeae1dc170d19dafbe03f632356c60ac37f50","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-83f6f5397e92d26dec7e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-83f6f5397e92d26dec7e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-83f6f5397e92d26dec7e-proposal","leaf-83f6f5397e92d26dec7e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d68","kind":"description","unitIndex":68,"unitId":"unit:5985e1ca3ee1964f066e5aacde2153af6772236641ec0f4517d958769c26f1ab","textSha256":"1451a72460117fc01dae90cead511cef5191e0c876a05085e0fb20be711f4ceb"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c32ff43d71198409c957d501","recordId":"leaf-83f6f5397e92d26dec7e-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-83f6f5397e92d26dec7e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-83f6f5397e92d26dec7e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"0b68d6d34469e83fd66296d54741179036b222afaaf80dda18df008268e0b5a8"},"organizational-access:4fb2c130a12c76e21ce2706b":{"id":"organizational-access:4fb2c130a12c76e21ce2706b","source":"q025-candidate-region:bbf5b94408d4b85f34e31f16","target":"q025-candidate-question:40042ea5fd4d29246857e8ba","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:bbf5b94408d4b85f34e31f16","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"026e49f12b81612507fda1698dacdaba6907571147351c36bb8444efba16398d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1ad6bf9b0cfa1360daaa2ee9"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:40042ea5fd4d29246857e8ba","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"13ba027074da2ae11f30264a208a810f20f83e0d345327a910ab901f951a6768","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:fbfd18577fdcafc062cfec4e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:19365b8dd60a229782bb625eb47657f7aed739d58b216031adc79d666f5a5216","home":{"unitId":"unit:19365b8dd60a229782bb625eb47657f7aed739d58b216031adc79d666f5a5216","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:bbf5b94408d4b85f34e31f16","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers small-instanton emergent gauge sectors and their vacuum-dynamics applications across the specified weakly and strongly coupled heterotic descriptions.","qualification":"q0 supplies low-scale gauge sectors and dual descriptions but does not establish coverage of their separate supersymmetry-breaking applications. q2 supplies the latter target without the full sector question. q8 covers both within one existing region, preserving weak and strong coupling and the tentative status of the application.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:19365b8dd60a229782bb625eb47657f7aed739d58b216031adc79d666f5a5216","paperId":"hep-th/9910090","textSha256":"a64356f405349b709ea050c5799507371f92a0b86344e34f919adad7bb2d9421"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0014:u19:q8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0014:u19:q8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:19365b8dd60a229782bb625eb47657f7aed739d58b216031adc79d666f5a5216","q025-candidate-region:bbf5b94408d4b85f34e31f16"],"scopeContentSha256":"026e49f12b81612507fda1698dacdaba6907571147351c36bb8444efba16398d","placementContentSha256":"3838313d98167039a2af97723fcd0d53d219bf3fd41b6d0005f69002d9da2af6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0014:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0014:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:19365b8dd60a229782bb625eb47657f7aed739d58b216031adc79d666f5a5216","paperId":"hep-th/9910090","textSha256":"a64356f405349b709ea050c5799507371f92a0b86344e34f919adad7bb2d9421"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0014","unitRef":"u19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:19365b8dd60a229782bb625eb47657f7aed739d58b216031adc79d666f5a5216","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:40042ea5fd4d29246857e8ba","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d63","kind":"description","unitIndex":63,"unitId":"unit:19365b8dd60a229782bb625eb47657f7aed739d58b216031adc79d666f5a5216","textSha256":"a64356f405349b709ea050c5799507371f92a0b86344e34f919adad7bb2d9421"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2e8347dc5b7eafe38ec617fd"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2e8347dc5b7eafe38ec617fd","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:19365b8dd60a229782bb625eb47657f7aed739d58b216031adc79d666f5a5216","q025-candidate-question:40042ea5fd4d29246857e8ba"],"scopeContentSha256":"13ba027074da2ae11f30264a208a810f20f83e0d345327a910ab901f951a6768","contributionContentSha256":"2cfd1f6d1211d357187c10cf68dba49333977bf1b207e4433dc3d97ed451f1de","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-proposal","leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d63","kind":"description","unitIndex":63,"unitId":"unit:19365b8dd60a229782bb625eb47657f7aed739d58b216031adc79d666f5a5216","textSha256":"a64356f405349b709ea050c5799507371f92a0b86344e34f919adad7bb2d9421"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2e8347dc5b7eafe38ec617fd","recordId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Four-dimensional gauge interactions at arbitrarily low heterotic string scale, with possible supersymmetry-breaking roles.","challengeNote":"Low-scale gauge interactions and possible supersymmetry-breaking roles remain distinct application targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"51dcd2e5d4045afea5c9c3efb3652e7e0effcdb0b5cd11b922e817346368f059"},"organizational-access:7a5fb1c25289ad6ede62ec4b":{"id":"organizational-access:7a5fb1c25289ad6ede62ec4b","source":"q025-candidate-region:d0aad74f894499b6a6598789","target":"q025-candidate-question:d7a9b6ef1f7371f7f621506e","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:d0aad74f894499b6a6598789","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"f9abeb80690b126078156b05f9f65caf120428b5345e0f70c12c527cf3905a28","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f89c9b70a8fdb93264d9359c"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:d7a9b6ef1f7371f7f621506e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"8dd977bf1f1facc951f3111484c3faa0e66ef29880a6eeaf3697e9f5f7b20c24","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:bf05c0c29794e12ab913319b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4d8b06529eb27454ef014103ef06638f3768cf3f067789e50d2eadcd65beedfd","home":{"unitId":"unit:4d8b06529eb27454ef014103ef06638f3768cf3f067789e50d2eadcd65beedfd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:d0aad74f894499b6a6598789","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4d8b06529eb27454ef014103ef06638f3768cf3f067789e50d2eadcd65beedfd","paperId":"2103.04999","textSha256":"0f040bd8e2b7805f417129ab4b87ed585ec09667e8157d74dae77312b3011182"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:554faa43a3f9cadd1f22f9bf"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:554faa43a3f9cadd1f22f9bf","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4d8b06529eb27454ef014103ef06638f3768cf3f067789e50d2eadcd65beedfd","q025-candidate-region:d0aad74f894499b6a6598789"],"scopeContentSha256":"f9abeb80690b126078156b05f9f65caf120428b5345e0f70c12c527cf3905a28","placementContentSha256":"6c1012bca54886ce5c503dd4c19e2651b1d238a1ba7d19fe4263537c5f3221f1","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4d8b06529eb27454ef014103ef06638f3768cf3f067789e50d2eadcd65beedfd","paperId":"2103.04999","textSha256":"0f040bd8e2b7805f417129ab4b87ed585ec09667e8157d74dae77312b3011182"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:554faa43a3f9cadd1f22f9bf"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4d8b06529eb27454ef014103ef06638f3768cf3f067789e50d2eadcd65beedfd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d7a9b6ef1f7371f7f621506e","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:4d8b06529eb27454ef014103ef06638f3768cf3f067789e50d2eadcd65beedfd","textSha256":"0f040bd8e2b7805f417129ab4b87ed585ec09667e8157d74dae77312b3011182"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7bdc5882359daa75506425d7"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7bdc5882359daa75506425d7","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4d8b06529eb27454ef014103ef06638f3768cf3f067789e50d2eadcd65beedfd","q025-candidate-question:d7a9b6ef1f7371f7f621506e"],"scopeContentSha256":"8dd977bf1f1facc951f3111484c3faa0e66ef29880a6eeaf3697e9f5f7b20c24","contributionContentSha256":"cd38eabaf265d08adddba5fd097e79c05c5674a32d378d30b746a32e7eb18a3f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:4d8b06529eb27454ef014103ef06638f3768cf3f067789e50d2eadcd65beedfd","textSha256":"0f040bd8e2b7805f417129ab4b87ed585ec09667e8157d74dae77312b3011182"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7bdc5882359daa75506425d7","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9de0e271e58e3cb68d199bdbb85776fe2ae318c64e69850975bff3d69e94864e","home":{"unitId":"unit:9de0e271e58e3cb68d199bdbb85776fe2ae318c64e69850975bff3d69e94864e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:d0aad74f894499b6a6598789","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9de0e271e58e3cb68d199bdbb85776fe2ae318c64e69850975bff3d69e94864e","paperId":"1910.08837","textSha256":"e778526891c8c10f8c0117456649f433024bb179bb9926998dcf4d28f616f804"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7b0eafe32faa1875680e9517"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7b0eafe32faa1875680e9517","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9de0e271e58e3cb68d199bdbb85776fe2ae318c64e69850975bff3d69e94864e","q025-candidate-region:d0aad74f894499b6a6598789"],"scopeContentSha256":"f9abeb80690b126078156b05f9f65caf120428b5345e0f70c12c527cf3905a28","placementContentSha256":"dbe23578ed136d59b046c776a028723d249e192aec2e3ddb1d7fba4ea9dcb7cd","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9de0e271e58e3cb68d199bdbb85776fe2ae318c64e69850975bff3d69e94864e","paperId":"1910.08837","textSha256":"e778526891c8c10f8c0117456649f433024bb179bb9926998dcf4d28f616f804"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7b0eafe32faa1875680e9517"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9de0e271e58e3cb68d199bdbb85776fe2ae318c64e69850975bff3d69e94864e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d7a9b6ef1f7371f7f621506e","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:9de0e271e58e3cb68d199bdbb85776fe2ae318c64e69850975bff3d69e94864e","textSha256":"e778526891c8c10f8c0117456649f433024bb179bb9926998dcf4d28f616f804"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f2d59af6011da63343548e98"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f2d59af6011da63343548e98","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9de0e271e58e3cb68d199bdbb85776fe2ae318c64e69850975bff3d69e94864e","q025-candidate-question:d7a9b6ef1f7371f7f621506e"],"scopeContentSha256":"8dd977bf1f1facc951f3111484c3faa0e66ef29880a6eeaf3697e9f5f7b20c24","contributionContentSha256":"8fe65dd3093de1fde4e8c27be28516b188f6692620446c66ecdceff746451ab3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:9de0e271e58e3cb68d199bdbb85776fe2ae318c64e69850975bff3d69e94864e","textSha256":"e778526891c8c10f8c0117456649f433024bb179bb9926998dcf4d28f616f804"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f2d59af6011da63343548e98","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Shared gravitino scale links DHI, axion dark energy and dark-matter decay; their fine question decomposition is unresolved.","challengeNote":"The shared gravitino scale connects DHI, axion dark energy and dark-matter decay; their fine decomposition remains unresolved.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"63e4149dd61442a5d7f11a042fbbf3fc4f9f6fc7252d8ec1c2755a477bedb85b"},"organizational-access:ed8e8d65d345b3c3d7f845cd":{"id":"organizational-access:ed8e8d65d345b3c3d7f845cd","source":"q025-candidate-region:d67c1658cfca4508929dcc9d","target":"q025-candidate-question:ee233163e41eed46b2433010","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:d67c1658cfca4508929dcc9d","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"e96e9b4b9c0010fe9e050dfe174e4bd54df9609501429d01f4207ae88db8a774","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:413aecf0759b7a5f7fb32428"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ee233163e41eed46b2433010","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"788310ab6fbe1251ee3beec77ed790f63af16ffe53bb925cb882c785b99c50c2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c71c1e0d22f86c2872aeb886"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:c42e4c3ccbf820a5df4a7428a47b4eee4fba7245bd7e17d0c9aa81014d08bcca","home":{"unitId":"unit:c42e4c3ccbf820a5df4a7428a47b4eee4fba7245bd7e17d0c9aa81014d08bcca","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:d67c1658cfca4508929dcc9d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c42e4c3ccbf820a5df4a7428a47b4eee4fba7245bd7e17d0c9aa81014d08bcca","paperId":"1911.10466","textSha256":"71672107904f7bcf83852749c271fd67650d3ecc55db7d8b399c702bcf9d96c5"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bfd6a7eaeea91b5acf31e55e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bfd6a7eaeea91b5acf31e55e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c42e4c3ccbf820a5df4a7428a47b4eee4fba7245bd7e17d0c9aa81014d08bcca","q025-candidate-region:d67c1658cfca4508929dcc9d"],"scopeContentSha256":"e96e9b4b9c0010fe9e050dfe174e4bd54df9609501429d01f4207ae88db8a774","placementContentSha256":"f9d8dc7ca31d8b175007349603b2afa231b8f7c31992dc40dd3a99157e440b74","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-challenge","leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c42e4c3ccbf820a5df4a7428a47b4eee4fba7245bd7e17d0c9aa81014d08bcca","paperId":"1911.10466","textSha256":"71672107904f7bcf83852749c271fd67650d3ecc55db7d8b399c702bcf9d96c5"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bfd6a7eaeea91b5acf31e55e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c42e4c3ccbf820a5df4a7428a47b4eee4fba7245bd7e17d0c9aa81014d08bcca","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ee233163e41eed46b2433010","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:c42e4c3ccbf820a5df4a7428a47b4eee4fba7245bd7e17d0c9aa81014d08bcca","textSha256":"71672107904f7bcf83852749c271fd67650d3ecc55db7d8b399c702bcf9d96c5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:496e9889a2c956ca0ca35425","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The joint inflation/quintessence target is preserved intact; singleton status does not make the two epochs one atomic target. Independent challenge qualification: The joint inflation/quintessence target requires unchanged parameters. Its source-scoped singleton does not collapse the epochs into an atomic target."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:496e9889a2c956ca0ca35425","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c42e4c3ccbf820a5df4a7428a47b4eee4fba7245bd7e17d0c9aa81014d08bcca","q025-candidate-question:ee233163e41eed46b2433010"],"scopeContentSha256":"788310ab6fbe1251ee3beec77ed790f63af16ffe53bb925cb882c785b99c50c2","contributionContentSha256":"6fcde5100be57e997738658702134a210ccdd6e45d3465df06f350df71b10ddd","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-proposal","leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:c42e4c3ccbf820a5df4a7428a47b4eee4fba7245bd7e17d0c9aa81014d08bcca","textSha256":"71672107904f7bcf83852749c271fd67650d3ecc55db7d8b399c702bcf9d96c5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:496e9889a2c956ca0ca35425","recordId":"leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"The joint inflation/quintessence target is preserved intact; singleton status does not make the two epochs one atomic target.","challengeNote":"The joint inflation/quintessence target requires unchanged parameters. Its source-scoped singleton does not collapse the epochs into an atomic target.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"201bf825ac3f3481d1b25c6b234303e042e8d617f4672376c62196f966ae9ea4"},"organizational-access:925eec9d152983c3a3870511":{"id":"organizational-access:925eec9d152983c3a3870511","source":"q025-candidate-region:dc1c9a3b1df435748bd34d33","target":"q025-candidate-question:51b73f047b59e889b2cc01d0","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:dc1c9a3b1df435748bd34d33","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"fea3cdf70f0946b47cff29e76466613767bb4f4608f0e6f78add7f4709dabdc3","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:32615fc2efe2c7b4d1be21a3"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:51b73f047b59e889b2cc01d0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"cb94cb1a4f545df6704c781af3f052be6db7c1d8cd2cd95520584e227161a532","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3c3ab8e69288e22a50af7545"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:f94aa8fa0f09f71fea3b599c1c53626d58f121c77f18a611408331c871f40098","home":{"unitId":"unit:f94aa8fa0f09f71fea3b599c1c53626d58f121c77f18a611408331c871f40098","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:dc1c9a3b1df435748bd34d33","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Combines inflationary dynamics, scalar and tensor statistics, non-Gaussianity, and explicitly stated model-consistency conditions without imposing a common cold or thermal premise.","qualification":"The source jointly requests a controlled warm-inflation mechanism and acceptable scalar, tensor, and non-Gaussian statistics. q19 covers inflationary dynamics, primordial observables, and explicit source-local consistency conditions without imposing a common thermal or cold premise. q7 and q4 each cover only part of this target set; q19 is therefore the supplied complete composite home despite not being nominated. The condition f<Mp remains a parameter restriction, not an excursion bound.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f94aa8fa0f09f71fea3b599c1c53626d58f121c77f18a611408331c871f40098","paperId":"1901.01897","textSha256":"16bcc144ffdd91ee0a56e847f6e91c351bce4a2c20b529e1eee116a7a8fa4a51"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0068:u14:q19"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0068:u14:q19","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f94aa8fa0f09f71fea3b599c1c53626d58f121c77f18a611408331c871f40098","q025-candidate-region:dc1c9a3b1df435748bd34d33"],"scopeContentSha256":"fea3cdf70f0946b47cff29e76466613767bb4f4608f0e6f78add7f4709dabdc3","placementContentSha256":"b1c0c434bc24bb285b728575bf387b54f0df07fb5a8b3fb80a4a40158516fd85","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0068:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0068:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f94aa8fa0f09f71fea3b599c1c53626d58f121c77f18a611408331c871f40098","paperId":"1901.01897","textSha256":"16bcc144ffdd91ee0a56e847f6e91c351bce4a2c20b529e1eee116a7a8fa4a51"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0068","unitRef":"u14"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f94aa8fa0f09f71fea3b599c1c53626d58f121c77f18a611408331c871f40098","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:51b73f047b59e889b2cc01d0","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:f94aa8fa0f09f71fea3b599c1c53626d58f121c77f18a611408331c871f40098","textSha256":"16bcc144ffdd91ee0a56e847f6e91c351bce4a2c20b529e1eee116a7a8fa4a51"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3e324b795641d97a97a93450"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3e324b795641d97a97a93450","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f94aa8fa0f09f71fea3b599c1c53626d58f121c77f18a611408331c871f40098","q025-candidate-question:51b73f047b59e889b2cc01d0"],"scopeContentSha256":"cb94cb1a4f545df6704c781af3f052be6db7c1d8cd2cd95520584e227161a532","contributionContentSha256":"65d115d55c8f51954d431e087b76d9791b7291828b06f588c35d11936dfd0e5c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-proposal","leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:f94aa8fa0f09f71fea3b599c1c53626d58f121c77f18a611408331c871f40098","textSha256":"16bcc144ffdd91ee0a56e847f6e91c351bce4a2c20b529e1eee116a7a8fa4a51"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3e324b795641d97a97a93450","recordId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Includes small non-Gaussianity and f < Mp; these are not a field-excursion statement.","challengeNote":"Compound microphysics and perturbation target, including small non-Gaussianity. The condition f < Mp is not an excursion bound.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"c8d2e7c5980c073ce4c39ebd4495fbf0269e92462d6cf05a88c6eb15cc727b01"},"organizational-access:0c8519d4f089118bd210a166":{"id":"organizational-access:0c8519d4f089118bd210a166","source":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","target":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e836593b270a54ee0f044826"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"8bba339c9e4207dca6b0f3f316a16a489c020412fb829f92cc20ae3c6ec3b8da","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:df00d2de0e7306de80e3946b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","home":{"unitId":"unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","paperId":"1809.00726","textSha256":"03553f340f6bbe16e68e4330b0502b508aa9aa4e6a4c0d00b857ffe4eddffaf0"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1d2cabd6f9b6b73f5ff13674"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1d2cabd6f9b6b73f5ff13674","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","placementContentSha256":"28b61e1d2cc2f26e332a882788c37b6e65ab7eec5964db30688b409338265906","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","paperId":"1809.00726","textSha256":"03553f340f6bbe16e68e4330b0502b508aa9aa4e6a4c0d00b857ffe4eddffaf0"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1d2cabd6f9b6b73f5ff13674"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","textSha256":"03553f340f6bbe16e68e4330b0502b508aa9aa4e6a4c0d00b857ffe4eddffaf0"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:59a7766898b5a5224dbdf7287874f1f2","paperId":"1809.00726","sourceSha256":"89d2bcf4d9d6153d8c6d33ad1330b8dc2cc7d2675003e90833d8e16b68b13618","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f0b05da962b95c0ce32e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2948bf4c0c92fcfb4b11eb43193386b98195c1d81e3633ecdf848fe885c1b166","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"ab1524cb65a30bb7e9c688f8ff5002ab288a6b171bc3525243d14bafe1c2c3cf","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:07f1cd23498359a90ecdda5f81feb06e","paperId":"1809.00726","sourceSha256":"89d2bcf4d9d6153d8c6d33ad1330b8dc2cc7d2675003e90833d8e16b68b13618","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f0b05da962b95c0ce32e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2948bf4c0c92fcfb4b11eb43193386b98195c1d81e3633ecdf848fe885c1b166","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"99eac2fd0a6975a1eb7240ae4c36fa2eb755748a107ec74808ce43687d335be5","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fbfb91455562f2dc14076083775b459a","paperId":"1809.00726","sourceSha256":"89d2bcf4d9d6153d8c6d33ad1330b8dc2cc7d2675003e90833d8e16b68b13618","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f0b05da962b95c0ce32e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2948bf4c0c92fcfb4b11eb43193386b98195c1d81e3633ecdf848fe885c1b166","pdfPage":1,"start":185,"end":3185,"textSha256":"26f2349610c25cdf1bc452daa8a3a5fb25217a8abbd61b564296c13379e83c5f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:93176de12b27c7c418b4f177"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:93176de12b27c7c418b4f177","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af"],"scopeContentSha256":"8bba339c9e4207dca6b0f3f316a16a489c020412fb829f92cc20ae3c6ec3b8da","contributionContentSha256":"c24bd01134ea6ad295e474708d8370d3d8672e1c79c98a9c95c127287c0138e9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","textSha256":"03553f340f6bbe16e68e4330b0502b508aa9aa4e6a4c0d00b857ffe4eddffaf0"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:59a7766898b5a5224dbdf7287874f1f2","paperId":"1809.00726","sourceSha256":"89d2bcf4d9d6153d8c6d33ad1330b8dc2cc7d2675003e90833d8e16b68b13618","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f0b05da962b95c0ce32e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2948bf4c0c92fcfb4b11eb43193386b98195c1d81e3633ecdf848fe885c1b166","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"ab1524cb65a30bb7e9c688f8ff5002ab288a6b171bc3525243d14bafe1c2c3cf","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:07f1cd23498359a90ecdda5f81feb06e","paperId":"1809.00726","sourceSha256":"89d2bcf4d9d6153d8c6d33ad1330b8dc2cc7d2675003e90833d8e16b68b13618","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f0b05da962b95c0ce32e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2948bf4c0c92fcfb4b11eb43193386b98195c1d81e3633ecdf848fe885c1b166","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"99eac2fd0a6975a1eb7240ae4c36fa2eb755748a107ec74808ce43687d335be5","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fbfb91455562f2dc14076083775b459a","paperId":"1809.00726","sourceSha256":"89d2bcf4d9d6153d8c6d33ad1330b8dc2cc7d2675003e90833d8e16b68b13618","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f0b05da962b95c0ce32e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2948bf4c0c92fcfb4b11eb43193386b98195c1d81e3633ecdf848fe885c1b166","pdfPage":1,"start":185,"end":3185,"textSha256":"26f2349610c25cdf1bc452daa8a3a5fb25217a8abbd61b564296c13379e83c5f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:93176de12b27c7c418b4f177","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"The target is additional field-dependent radiative sensitivity; the unknown cancellation option is not an exhibited completion.","challengeNote":"The target is additional field-dependent radiative sensitivity. The cancellation mechanism is an unknown alternative, not an exhibited completion.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a7758fc884fab2236e2e6ad2bb661480963d0f2b035e0cc076544d8109cee656"},"organizational-access:ad3bb37f83855b1efd9db72d":{"id":"organizational-access:ad3bb37f83855b1efd9db72d","source":"q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416","target":"q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"605d6588e09eaa96a4eab90dfd66b189ae0a890234a707553cef72b35bed8d36","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:4fa8cc768c5e6cabccf10441"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"eb47a3d9439b4ebb73a6304084f394b60e7eef771823541c4c9f92f27f9b5bd0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:510a8692fbbb127918161676"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:3fa174682e1c7083b8a33d846ed0decb71d184f63ae0137683fc680d7dda8505","home":{"unitId":"unit:3fa174682e1c7083b8a33d846ed0decb71d184f63ae0137683fc680d7dda8505","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3fa174682e1c7083b8a33d846ed0decb71d184f63ae0137683fc680d7dda8505","paperId":"1508.03468","textSha256":"f16ebdfbb5353425b012f5a8397825ff93ba491e8b18ca50d34a30098d46fa53"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:21fcaec8781063c31854f9bc"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:21fcaec8781063c31854f9bc","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3fa174682e1c7083b8a33d846ed0decb71d184f63ae0137683fc680d7dda8505","q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416"],"scopeContentSha256":"605d6588e09eaa96a4eab90dfd66b189ae0a890234a707553cef72b35bed8d36","placementContentSha256":"cab58263406f1ff9359574d88d9b02d50c46bcdfef1d2b83bc2d11054aa3aff2","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge","leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3fa174682e1c7083b8a33d846ed0decb71d184f63ae0137683fc680d7dda8505","paperId":"1508.03468","textSha256":"f16ebdfbb5353425b012f5a8397825ff93ba491e8b18ca50d34a30098d46fa53"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:21fcaec8781063c31854f9bc"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3fa174682e1c7083b8a33d846ed0decb71d184f63ae0137683fc680d7dda8505","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:3fa174682e1c7083b8a33d846ed0decb71d184f63ae0137683fc680d7dda8505","textSha256":"f16ebdfbb5353425b012f5a8397825ff93ba491e8b18ca50d34a30098d46fa53"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:337e5353fc5d601490791b18"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:337e5353fc5d601490791b18","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3fa174682e1c7083b8a33d846ed0decb71d184f63ae0137683fc680d7dda8505","q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5"],"scopeContentSha256":"eb47a3d9439b4ebb73a6304084f394b60e7eef771823541c4c9f92f27f9b5bd0","contributionContentSha256":"2545ae2a7c02fb47b0980543e047516fe0381e279108ba871ae7b397d379c078","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:3fa174682e1c7083b8a33d846ed0decb71d184f63ae0137683fc680d7dda8505","textSha256":"f16ebdfbb5353425b012f5a8397825ff93ba491e8b18ca50d34a30098d46fa53"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:337e5353fc5d601490791b18","recordId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound SPT realization, circuit nontriviality and logical-gate targets retained.","challengeNote":"Compound lattice-SPT construction, circuit nontriviality and logical-gate targets retained.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5a96ea9898f33dac97bd4b5e712170a78e94da3c9b58752dd640d1c36fcfbe1c","home":{"unitId":"unit:5a96ea9898f33dac97bd4b5e712170a78e94da3c9b58752dd640d1c36fcfbe1c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5a96ea9898f33dac97bd4b5e712170a78e94da3c9b58752dd640d1c36fcfbe1c","paperId":"quant-ph/9707021","textSha256":"4ca8ba74ed5ca2c870de45397487b7cdde788316af08b5b144203d07c4c7f9b3"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0e688ef078652f2eb4715b3811324ec0","paperId":"quant-ph/9707021","sourceSha256":"601bb98b8b3f6014982ec19332891e4616c7dd8562721a0c801d1cb9109129bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/99913f03ac48032d9048/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"13352f638b9f088b29fb5b3237fe14fc0ed90002ff06d3e2f24db8e2bb588836","pdfPage":2,"start":97,"end":2989,"textSha256":"d53ba075a723bc644d840dc3a242a72f6d461bf906bdb0da7d31af8a30c196ba","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3af1a7625b39a71d0a7af1c13a83e1b","paperId":"quant-ph/9707021","sourceSha256":"601bb98b8b3f6014982ec19332891e4616c7dd8562721a0c801d1cb9109129bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/99913f03ac48032d9048/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"13352f638b9f088b29fb5b3237fe14fc0ed90002ff06d3e2f24db8e2bb588836","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2989,"textSha256":"4eb0e8398f446861cbfb623c40dc3179b2cbe28e4387f403cfc58691c861c1b0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c797415b455c5f8623a6c230"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c797415b455c5f8623a6c230","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5a96ea9898f33dac97bd4b5e712170a78e94da3c9b58752dd640d1c36fcfbe1c","q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416"],"scopeContentSha256":"605d6588e09eaa96a4eab90dfd66b189ae0a890234a707553cef72b35bed8d36","placementContentSha256":"98af9158c0e5963891a6aaa8bf17b45bed2114af7b7f82cf7138cc3401188a4b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge","leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5a96ea9898f33dac97bd4b5e712170a78e94da3c9b58752dd640d1c36fcfbe1c","paperId":"quant-ph/9707021","textSha256":"4ca8ba74ed5ca2c870de45397487b7cdde788316af08b5b144203d07c4c7f9b3"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0e688ef078652f2eb4715b3811324ec0","paperId":"quant-ph/9707021","sourceSha256":"601bb98b8b3f6014982ec19332891e4616c7dd8562721a0c801d1cb9109129bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/99913f03ac48032d9048/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"13352f638b9f088b29fb5b3237fe14fc0ed90002ff06d3e2f24db8e2bb588836","pdfPage":2,"start":97,"end":2989,"textSha256":"d53ba075a723bc644d840dc3a242a72f6d461bf906bdb0da7d31af8a30c196ba","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3af1a7625b39a71d0a7af1c13a83e1b","paperId":"quant-ph/9707021","sourceSha256":"601bb98b8b3f6014982ec19332891e4616c7dd8562721a0c801d1cb9109129bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/99913f03ac48032d9048/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"13352f638b9f088b29fb5b3237fe14fc0ed90002ff06d3e2f24db8e2bb588836","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2989,"textSha256":"4eb0e8398f446861cbfb623c40dc3179b2cbe28e4387f403cfc58691c861c1b0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c797415b455c5f8623a6c230"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5a96ea9898f33dac97bd4b5e712170a78e94da3c9b58752dd640d1c36fcfbe1c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:5a96ea9898f33dac97bd4b5e712170a78e94da3c9b58752dd640d1c36fcfbe1c","textSha256":"4ca8ba74ed5ca2c870de45397487b7cdde788316af08b5b144203d07c4c7f9b3"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0e688ef078652f2eb4715b3811324ec0","paperId":"quant-ph/9707021","sourceSha256":"601bb98b8b3f6014982ec19332891e4616c7dd8562721a0c801d1cb9109129bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/99913f03ac48032d9048/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"13352f638b9f088b29fb5b3237fe14fc0ed90002ff06d3e2f24db8e2bb588836","pdfPage":2,"start":97,"end":2989,"textSha256":"d53ba075a723bc644d840dc3a242a72f6d461bf906bdb0da7d31af8a30c196ba","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3af1a7625b39a71d0a7af1c13a83e1b","paperId":"quant-ph/9707021","sourceSha256":"601bb98b8b3f6014982ec19332891e4616c7dd8562721a0c801d1cb9109129bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/99913f03ac48032d9048/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"13352f638b9f088b29fb5b3237fe14fc0ed90002ff06d3e2f24db8e2bb588836","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2989,"textSha256":"4eb0e8398f446861cbfb623c40dc3179b2cbe28e4387f403cfc58691c861c1b0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:566045c5d740d7d7b8efeb2a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:566045c5d740d7d7b8efeb2a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5a96ea9898f33dac97bd4b5e712170a78e94da3c9b58752dd640d1c36fcfbe1c","q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5"],"scopeContentSha256":"eb47a3d9439b4ebb73a6304084f394b60e7eef771823541c4c9f92f27f9b5bd0","contributionContentSha256":"2caa989214d8bbd599a8f06be067d657df93ddeb0a27ceff42519868cf89822a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:5a96ea9898f33dac97bd4b5e712170a78e94da3c9b58752dd640d1c36fcfbe1c","textSha256":"4ca8ba74ed5ca2c870de45397487b7cdde788316af08b5b144203d07c4c7f9b3"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0e688ef078652f2eb4715b3811324ec0","paperId":"quant-ph/9707021","sourceSha256":"601bb98b8b3f6014982ec19332891e4616c7dd8562721a0c801d1cb9109129bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/99913f03ac48032d9048/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"13352f638b9f088b29fb5b3237fe14fc0ed90002ff06d3e2f24db8e2bb588836","pdfPage":2,"start":97,"end":2989,"textSha256":"d53ba075a723bc644d840dc3a242a72f6d461bf906bdb0da7d31af8a30c196ba","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3af1a7625b39a71d0a7af1c13a83e1b","paperId":"quant-ph/9707021","sourceSha256":"601bb98b8b3f6014982ec19332891e4616c7dd8562721a0c801d1cb9109129bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/99913f03ac48032d9048/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"13352f638b9f088b29fb5b3237fe14fc0ed90002ff06d3e2f24db8e2bb588836","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2989,"textSha256":"4eb0e8398f446861cbfb623c40dc3179b2cbe28e4387f403cfc58691c861c1b0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:566045c5d740d7d7b8efeb2a","recordId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Physical memory and non-Abelian computational constructions remain distinct parts of the source question.","challengeNote":"Physical memory and non-Abelian computation remain distinct targets; the simple model's operations are not a complete computational basis.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"bc9a1553fff657e1c339a1392f8e023e2982f7cea256c3bea4d31849c8866461"},"organizational-access:fa3260cbbc88b1e8bb07a052":{"id":"organizational-access:fa3260cbbc88b1e8bb07a052","source":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","target":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"ef71386060e2fc1d227f043cc98ffc9fb214a5308e8300f4925a535889b37388","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b49337f8db3daf684ab18e8c"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0f607371ea101890393fea69"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351","home":{"unitId":"unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351","paperId":"1509.00834","textSha256":"4f63eea5ed8aaa6480f9d3dc5cd25fb985a229cfe2bdda24a585cf3ed8dea046"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:21d87f86fcd923e1cc3f049c5c422f3d","paperId":"1509.00834","sourceSha256":"19948b821d019fd984b40f84c8c561d0510b3d5bd1f1ac1e2f987c88fff4aaf8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b9514e93ff7fe22cc992/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c16922ac7ee53e99874fcbd5299aa1caa6c8210cd81c5f5f75579f10d6d0bb30","pdfPage":4,"start":95,"end":3494,"textSha256":"f43527c08e94d7ce093c47c63f33628b4bffc1332ca1f6d5afafe70eccb8d096","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:66bd936579ad3c55ca14d1be55566516","paperId":"1509.00834","sourceSha256":"19948b821d019fd984b40f84c8c561d0510b3d5bd1f1ac1e2f987c88fff4aaf8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b9514e93ff7fe22cc992/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c16922ac7ee53e99874fcbd5299aa1caa6c8210cd81c5f5f75579f10d6d0bb30","pdfPage":3,"start":1299,"end":3612,"textSha256":"d018a9377d2226995691f5ae5a9886d581ec4f9a57b128e352828ee68aa257ea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f15c86064cc6087342db3a88"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f15c86064cc6087342db3a88","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351","q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef71386060e2fc1d227f043cc98ffc9fb214a5308e8300f4925a535889b37388","placementContentSha256":"4c4e807122a6520d2cb5eda9121b440e8bad3e8881d5901f4cf4bea97772eb07","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge","parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351","paperId":"1509.00834","textSha256":"4f63eea5ed8aaa6480f9d3dc5cd25fb985a229cfe2bdda24a585cf3ed8dea046"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:21d87f86fcd923e1cc3f049c5c422f3d","paperId":"1509.00834","sourceSha256":"19948b821d019fd984b40f84c8c561d0510b3d5bd1f1ac1e2f987c88fff4aaf8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b9514e93ff7fe22cc992/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c16922ac7ee53e99874fcbd5299aa1caa6c8210cd81c5f5f75579f10d6d0bb30","pdfPage":4,"start":95,"end":3494,"textSha256":"f43527c08e94d7ce093c47c63f33628b4bffc1332ca1f6d5afafe70eccb8d096","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:66bd936579ad3c55ca14d1be55566516","paperId":"1509.00834","sourceSha256":"19948b821d019fd984b40f84c8c561d0510b3d5bd1f1ac1e2f987c88fff4aaf8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b9514e93ff7fe22cc992/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c16922ac7ee53e99874fcbd5299aa1caa6c8210cd81c5f5f75579f10d6d0bb30","pdfPage":3,"start":1299,"end":3612,"textSha256":"d018a9377d2226995691f5ae5a9886d581ec4f9a57b128e352828ee68aa257ea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f15c86064cc6087342db3a88"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351","textSha256":"4f63eea5ed8aaa6480f9d3dc5cd25fb985a229cfe2bdda24a585cf3ed8dea046"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:21d87f86fcd923e1cc3f049c5c422f3d","paperId":"1509.00834","sourceSha256":"19948b821d019fd984b40f84c8c561d0510b3d5bd1f1ac1e2f987c88fff4aaf8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b9514e93ff7fe22cc992/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c16922ac7ee53e99874fcbd5299aa1caa6c8210cd81c5f5f75579f10d6d0bb30","pdfPage":4,"start":95,"end":3494,"textSha256":"f43527c08e94d7ce093c47c63f33628b4bffc1332ca1f6d5afafe70eccb8d096","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:66bd936579ad3c55ca14d1be55566516","paperId":"1509.00834","sourceSha256":"19948b821d019fd984b40f84c8c561d0510b3d5bd1f1ac1e2f987c88fff4aaf8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b9514e93ff7fe22cc992/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c16922ac7ee53e99874fcbd5299aa1caa6c8210cd81c5f5f75579f10d6d0bb30","pdfPage":3,"start":1299,"end":3612,"textSha256":"d018a9377d2226995691f5ae5a9886d581ec4f9a57b128e352828ee68aa257ea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6d12278ff8b56c8c87b1780d","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Scanning occurs during inflation; the unusual field range and non-field-theoretic origin of small shift breaking remain qualifications. Independent challenge qualification: Inflationary scanning and QCD backreaction are proposed within unusual field-range and shift-breaking assumptions; their non-field-theoretic origin is unres"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6d12278ff8b56c8c87b1780d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351","q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"],"scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","contributionContentSha256":"51bbdd4585f6768c0efc863afd5193c5b8f5f4a17e16c2a7603ebb3c1fc2d4b5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351","textSha256":"4f63eea5ed8aaa6480f9d3dc5cd25fb985a229cfe2bdda24a585cf3ed8dea046"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:21d87f86fcd923e1cc3f049c5c422f3d","paperId":"1509.00834","sourceSha256":"19948b821d019fd984b40f84c8c561d0510b3d5bd1f1ac1e2f987c88fff4aaf8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b9514e93ff7fe22cc992/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c16922ac7ee53e99874fcbd5299aa1caa6c8210cd81c5f5f75579f10d6d0bb30","pdfPage":4,"start":95,"end":3494,"textSha256":"f43527c08e94d7ce093c47c63f33628b4bffc1332ca1f6d5afafe70eccb8d096","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:66bd936579ad3c55ca14d1be55566516","paperId":"1509.00834","sourceSha256":"19948b821d019fd984b40f84c8c561d0510b3d5bd1f1ac1e2f987c88fff4aaf8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b9514e93ff7fe22cc992/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c16922ac7ee53e99874fcbd5299aa1caa6c8210cd81c5f5f75579f10d6d0bb30","pdfPage":3,"start":1299,"end":3612,"textSha256":"d018a9377d2226995691f5ae5a9886d581ec4f9a57b128e352828ee68aa257ea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6d12278ff8b56c8c87b1780d","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Scanning occurs during inflation; the unusual field range and non-field-theoretic origin of small shift breaking remain qualifications.","challengeNote":"Inflationary scanning and QCD backreaction are proposed within unusual field-range and shift-breaking assumptions; their non-field-theoretic origin is unres","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"eb17481c308691009a00f0f64bffc4efadf1bff05dcb2f661f381258e9d94c28"},"organizational-access:18f8ff6888996ab44009064a":{"id":"organizational-access:18f8ff6888996ab44009064a","source":"q025-placement-question:ae544b4fcf3dd41d1fabccdc","target":"q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-placement-question:ae544b4fcf3dd41d1fabccdc","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7d73e784ad0d359291371a6b364cf04b485a391deb3257d9e901f3ecebb8e9de","scopeDecisionId":"decision:placement-new-scope:placement-continuation-0004:n0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"180f1b26eea91a8928c13ef8e091163bdb7576381d7b769b3a164f09e93feeb6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ff005957536bac1812fa8219"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:9f99151b3c374e5d38fe46e3abc154150662a8901d0c509926fa6fdd5f0eb713","home":{"unitId":"unit:9f99151b3c374e5d38fe46e3abc154150662a8901d0c509926fa6fdd5f0eb713","destinationId":"q025-placement-question:ae544b4fcf3dd41d1fabccdc","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"The proposed composite scope explicitly includes construction precision, quantum-gravity consistency exclusions and phenomenological typicality/tuning.","qualification":"The unchanged n0 definition covers all three targets. q5 covers construction and background consistency but not the complete typicality question; q7 covers statistics but not construction precision and general quantum-gravity exclusions. q11's approximation-control target does not establish coverage of the distinct low-energy exclusion problem.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9f99151b3c374e5d38fe46e3abc154150662a8901d0c509926fa6fdd5f0eb713","paperId":"2204.01742","textSha256":"a227051f5acdf4e0def17e86791fe0c7b8927e263357efc87edb929975c0ffaa"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0004:u11:n0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0004:u11:n0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9f99151b3c374e5d38fe46e3abc154150662a8901d0c509926fa6fdd5f0eb713","q025-placement-question:ae544b4fcf3dd41d1fabccdc"],"scopeContentSha256":"7d73e784ad0d359291371a6b364cf04b485a391deb3257d9e901f3ecebb8e9de","placementContentSha256":"72be95a2616236dc387f44a2fe6fdfcd5f3f638e1f4ac7d17bbd8f2449bb8ab5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0004:proposal","new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0004:challenge","root:placement-new-scope-homes-cut01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9f99151b3c374e5d38fe46e3abc154150662a8901d0c509926fa6fdd5f0eb713","paperId":"2204.01742","textSha256":"a227051f5acdf4e0def17e86791fe0c7b8927e263357efc87edb929975c0ffaa"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/new-scope-cut-01/admission.json","sha256":"9dded082079d58697b154619b36b4a67fe46234126ce54ba74bc876fa12b26b8"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/exception-intake.json","sha256":"71263a9f0021efdb21ad157d46dc559b5271318bbabb074cf7b3d6ec8a9658a9","bytes":2044150,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0004","unitRef":"u11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9f99151b3c374e5d38fe46e3abc154150662a8901d0c509926fa6fdd5f0eb713","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d35","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:9f99151b3c374e5d38fe46e3abc154150662a8901d0c509926fa6fdd5f0eb713","textSha256":"a227051f5acdf4e0def17e86791fe0c7b8927e263357efc87edb929975c0ffaa"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e47b061b595e36cfc60ecb7a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e47b061b595e36cfc60ecb7a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9f99151b3c374e5d38fe46e3abc154150662a8901d0c509926fa6fdd5f0eb713","q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5"],"scopeContentSha256":"180f1b26eea91a8928c13ef8e091163bdb7576381d7b769b3a164f09e93feeb6","contributionContentSha256":"15be0d98affe4418ad0c43e3a391f8f140f16edf0b2e277e104f5ea5f39d1826","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d35","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:9f99151b3c374e5d38fe46e3abc154150662a8901d0c509926fa6fdd5f0eb713","textSha256":"a227051f5acdf4e0def17e86791fe0c7b8927e263357efc87edb929975c0ffaa"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e47b061b595e36cfc60ecb7a","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: construction precision, consistency exclusions and phenomenological typicality.","challengeNote":"Compound construction-precision, consistency-exclusion and typicality targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ae634e8c48e5292ac8195b93009e5b722b9e4531d3b6e8a4c657515d24b653dd"},"organizational-access:f1af74347fae99de99ab8512":{"id":"organizational-access:f1af74347fae99de99ab8512","source":"q025-placement-question:b910dbf5f9b0d15143f3158e","target":"q025-candidate-question:2ad902d8305bb29bbade4879","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-placement-question:b910dbf5f9b0d15143f3158e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"acebb59c2108ea43870f82cbf2e16abf5bfa9220d26565ed2b4ce45830a7cde4","scopeDecisionId":"decision:placement-new-scope:placement-continuation-0012:n1"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:2ad902d8305bb29bbade4879","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"34ee02e46df75f341a05b8f9ff94fa07ef9337aa4cb3490f572270b5ef329fd2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:198e9a71b4ce0e1ef11416ac"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:054d4f3117e5c5151c8ef7d36e8aa99926b1221a454ac88a7838b3948b63b88d","home":{"unitId":"unit:054d4f3117e5c5151c8ef7d36e8aa99926b1221a454ac88a7838b3948b63b88d","destinationId":"q025-placement-question:b910dbf5f9b0d15143f3158e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"n1 explicitly joins negatively curved background construction with supersymmetry, reduction, gravitational potentials and candidate holographic conformal theories.","qualification":"n1 covers the background-existence question, both geometric alternatives and all four consequences. q4 covers reduction and effective physics but does not establish coverage of the independent holographic-CFT target. q8's holographic interpretations concern its formulation, coupling and defect program; its comparison connection does not supply this whole background question.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:054d4f3117e5c5151c8ef7d36e8aa99926b1221a454ac88a7838b3948b63b88d","paperId":"hep-th/0003281","textSha256":"825b179c5794dc97c1d9bc4c4ce9c7b871ff6949f9d417509f008c0c852a4fc4"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0012:u8:n1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0012:u8:n1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:054d4f3117e5c5151c8ef7d36e8aa99926b1221a454ac88a7838b3948b63b88d","q025-placement-question:b910dbf5f9b0d15143f3158e"],"scopeContentSha256":"acebb59c2108ea43870f82cbf2e16abf5bfa9220d26565ed2b4ce45830a7cde4","placementContentSha256":"1c21d4aa42819fabb0484d3ba57526bc10b24200858fd3426fcc673d27f4d49c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0012:proposal","new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0012:challenge","root:placement-new-scope-homes:new-scope-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:054d4f3117e5c5151c8ef7d36e8aa99926b1221a454ac88a7838b3948b63b88d","paperId":"hep-th/0003281","textSha256":"825b179c5794dc97c1d9bc4c4ce9c7b871ff6949f9d417509f008c0c852a4fc4"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/new-scope-cut-03/admission.json","sha256":"ed9b279fbd2610132af5432861b575b9b5f0bc272d51f65d6debc817b84fab02"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/exception-intake.json","sha256":"e2c8feedca7ab901585b3a3f046fa6900d1fb60eec30b2dd8f668d09a2d15a7b","bytes":7068293,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0012","unitRef":"u8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:054d4f3117e5c5151c8ef7d36e8aa99926b1221a454ac88a7838b3948b63b88d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2ad902d8305bb29bbade4879","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:054d4f3117e5c5151c8ef7d36e8aa99926b1221a454ac88a7838b3948b63b88d","textSha256":"825b179c5794dc97c1d9bc4c4ce9c7b871ff6949f9d417509f008c0c852a4fc4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2962bac4045979a07340f87f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2962bac4045979a07340f87f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:054d4f3117e5c5151c8ef7d36e8aa99926b1221a454ac88a7838b3948b63b88d","q025-candidate-question:2ad902d8305bb29bbade4879"],"scopeContentSha256":"34ee02e46df75f341a05b8f9ff94fa07ef9337aa4cb3490f572270b5ef329fd2","contributionContentSha256":"d12a3d89de56ccf422b9413e5d432dee97eda542bfa2d7ca124d887fd8a10c21","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:054d4f3117e5c5151c8ef7d36e8aa99926b1221a454ac88a7838b3948b63b88d","textSha256":"825b179c5794dc97c1d9bc4c4ce9c7b871ff6949f9d417509f008c0c852a4fc4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2962bac4045979a07340f87f","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound applications include supersymmetry, reduction, gravitational potentials and candidate holographic theories.","challengeNote":"Compound applications include supersymmetry, reduction, gravitational potentials and candidate holographic theories.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"36d1b9d763f4974fd60d1cb5062e1bfcc3726c00cbc37aee75b5dcf23137967f"}}}
