{"kind":"eigenquestions-relation-details","schemaVersion":"1.0.0","relations":{"navigation:parent-reasserted:5e4ac68508ed8a7f30b859b4":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:5e4ac68508ed8a7f30b859b4","source":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","target":"q025-candidate-question:b90c1d2a753bae902cd48f60","type":"narrower","title":"Continuation and quantum saddle admissibility","rationale":"Continuation, boundary data and contours connect classical constructions to specified amplitude questions.","qualification":"Continuation, boundary data and contours organize the passage from classical constructions to specified quantum amplitudes.","evidenceIds":["unit:0b45baefe06facca719b975db6cd73f0db9327c7931f9ca1421f50069cb0bc8f","unit:129c3a5d43df14c7b9d1420495756470f0c59d2cc217ac0dfaaa5ec826ab5fed","unit:1418230f2e85ee2956182e61095ff37e313248ce8a05294486c82dca38c720fc","unit:1a3643e025ae7e683ec6ccfc5d356fa6b58456d9489ef9775f5627c7654a805e","unit:23dedca299ce8c9197f5c587351099dee23bf7040b0d9aeb033d9214753759a2","unit:28f529ffb59d8b7e8b902728433926e07cdf0966fbe2f6b8b1b8c5cfcccfddf4","unit:2e567bca9a19882f61a1181aa672c6651862c3ba969020fa9672abff35ecc371","unit:424dbc9cee47ab69945a2ba5b656bc8478eb4aa22d07f841a4328929e69bf8a7","unit:528a022b18fe951a7de92d103e7fea429ab7053f93a36094b1d58c7d38d27927","unit:621efa310c3c1d6fd7b8adc8b97d48e5e66ec8bf55ce554bd7caafdeb635a6e3","unit:65035708d4cc84822a4fe3ae9198f79c5918903cc1d3ea2221cc9a0e8905d64d","unit:75e5cbfa138e302b2f839d61a898e9334b563deb3f606789cad50b7204dc8c07","unit:801178f25f4f0b10817c8c2efc4c411bff4728cd3b64ed401062085f7ef01d30","unit:8043929b434d969c6ddeabb5a89e2ec83ffb7d49cf84d592f46f756197e39092","unit:a7425bf08bc51b478f636dfda6ad9c5aeaf1705325509bbd76df72abe6da736e","unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","unit:ade71918e9da2c23020370c7a668029e2db0df2e0752da15f7bcf5eee43cad64","unit:c6ae6426542eed79fce69f742eef2baaac3de74a508042861326dfbc14286e1d","unit:e637915452c5efb2a97deaaed070f8aaaf3e2b690584ed05b07b202e1a6e8b20","unit:f34c63f75edb5ed676e5cb09d868b8344fbea9a9b8ddc8d5ec625889adc4a818"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b90c1d2a753bae902cd48f60"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0206153","sourceId":"ev:0c94afc9fa9a7190e6ecec645803a4da","sourceSha256":"1ae97d818cc8af5f629c839a14b5e8f42906b8f22abf4f963311945c4a622c8d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e3ca38647e2f770481c8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c65e15f31e79f9444cbbf9d8cb0f2864388225f6723bf1adb0da4ee73367739e","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":1669,"textSha256":"c7c93ff8a039d470f41e0a96db12cfe321fad014c77d0688343951905cf08b09","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"1807.00824","sourceId":"ev:126a65874ce927454102530a37e2af95","sourceSha256":"a1c057e60645b107f64cc976957337d5a39dabe4db8050312919517982426ea8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/deb9771b0d647bb999bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7e1896a9443eaede558472608bfcc58a4cb1f35bf89a13694c0b79839f51dc6e","pdfPage":9,"start":925,"end":2916,"textSha256":"32f1cb38b75c821b1d8675ad9e93460abbbfe370fbfd76603ba85cc316e304e6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:5e4ac68508ed8a7f30b859b4","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:5","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a","parent-native:challenge:0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Continuation, boundary data and contours connect classical constructions to specified amplitude questions.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Continuation, boundary data and contours organize the passage from classical constructions to specified quantum amplitudes.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b90c1d2a753bae902cd48f60"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0206153","sourceId":"ev:0c94afc9fa9a7190e6ecec645803a4da","sourceSha256":"1ae97d818cc8af5f629c839a14b5e8f42906b8f22abf4f963311945c4a622c8d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e3ca38647e2f770481c8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c65e15f31e79f9444cbbf9d8cb0f2864388225f6723bf1adb0da4ee73367739e","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":1669,"textSha256":"c7c93ff8a039d470f41e0a96db12cfe321fad014c77d0688343951905cf08b09","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"1807.00824","sourceId":"ev:126a65874ce927454102530a37e2af95","sourceSha256":"a1c057e60645b107f64cc976957337d5a39dabe4db8050312919517982426ea8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/deb9771b0d647bb999bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7e1896a9443eaede558472608bfcc58a4cb1f35bf89a13694c0b79839f51dc6e","pdfPage":9,"start":925,"end":2916,"textSha256":"32f1cb38b75c821b1d8675ad9e93460abbbfe370fbfd76603ba85cc316e304e6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b90c1d2a753bae902cd48f60"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0206153","sourceId":"ev:0c94afc9fa9a7190e6ecec645803a4da","sourceSha256":"1ae97d818cc8af5f629c839a14b5e8f42906b8f22abf4f963311945c4a622c8d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e3ca38647e2f770481c8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c65e15f31e79f9444cbbf9d8cb0f2864388225f6723bf1adb0da4ee73367739e","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":1669,"textSha256":"c7c93ff8a039d470f41e0a96db12cfe321fad014c77d0688343951905cf08b09","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"1807.00824","sourceId":"ev:126a65874ce927454102530a37e2af95","sourceSha256":"a1c057e60645b107f64cc976957337d5a39dabe4db8050312919517982426ea8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/deb9771b0d647bb999bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7e1896a9443eaede558472608bfcc58a4cb1f35bf89a13694c0b79839f51dc6e","pdfPage":9,"start":925,"end":2916,"textSha256":"32f1cb38b75c821b1d8675ad9e93460abbbfe370fbfd76603ba85cc316e304e6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"925b3a06e0d58b1ad55d18ab053b1eb9d69cad6c9cf79f5e8c7018f776a6b930","reply.jsonSha256":"da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a6946727adefee7f3b2b748ff0c0ce5f0a58757e5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"135d367256f1c72fe01022ea832c9dc4f9f738e1d96ce8bf53734f13fe5f68e6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4b6e52d88ba3a909c203c07b3da236d98c0b1b281c2e2c6b7f3607b778bfda8b","normalization.jsonSha256":"6fd88b04991ddf39e7ff5092add083be8e384bafd3f19e71277cd6e2f088e477","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"05576f0db3fb5c595fb6d3897bf21da45667e0eb85b5e9a62f807106dd4fde78"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5765d539bf0f3099f1950f796691829e7f864cd76798b1bb052698baddfe718a","reply.jsonSha256":"0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c480e26d6cfc8a931b11cfe5472f4d19633a4fd55","reply.raw.txtSha256":"de1a8fb3eb5515d58d9c7ca2a9b788a8c9e65e1036945a6bf0722f302d37714a","receipt.jsonSha256":"758edf392c44cf3888db4d027ada99bb3d726b6d5f985600aba5ee4acc328beb","normalization.jsonSha256":"a617cbb678db447bcc5636be99fe70967c460f3c466178602875d90df3617927"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:5e4ac68508ed8a7f30b859b4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:acabcee1dfaaecff64c4b655":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:acabcee1dfaaecff64c4b655","source":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","target":"q025-candidate-question:c08db391b75af4a4d54e2f97","type":"narrower","title":"Topology multiplicity versus action in four-dimensional gravity","rationale":"A directly supported four-dimensional topology-weighting route, without admitting the broader pending continuum scope.","qualification":"Provide a directly supported topology-weighting direction without admitting the broader pending continuum card.","evidenceIds":["unit:129c3a5d43df14c7b9d1420495756470f0c59d2cc217ac0dfaaa5ec826ab5fed","unit:2e567bca9a19882f61a1181aa672c6651862c3ba969020fa9672abff35ecc371","unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","unit:c6ae6426542eed79fce69f742eef2baaac3de74a508042861326dfbc14286e1d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"gr-qc/9710114","sourceId":"ev:205f0837617375b3dbf0df8649952fa5","sourceSha256":"ddf972b8058bb8ed729b2828fc3aa11c64952d2b373e9fc856d156f82d6f60b3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9db1307e6f5d1506d71/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32a0c1c6a6af10f4525e0c050e5d3a8b3b6e2e0a5ff7909e90e216807e0189dc","pdfPage":4,"start":104,"end":2304,"textSha256":"c0391fe955394d47e4920022f9cccf8815c08bee8b846ce10a25025ad8f3c117","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"gr-qc/9710114","sourceId":"ev:c2af83993eef3ba485cf6a3c5016c188","sourceSha256":"ddf972b8058bb8ed729b2828fc3aa11c64952d2b373e9fc856d156f82d6f60b3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9db1307e6f5d1506d71/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32a0c1c6a6af10f4525e0c050e5d3a8b3b6e2e0a5ff7909e90e216807e0189dc","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":993,"textSha256":"42f76bfe8bb8ae27d009a649652fc75368b5a579f666c1c842286ec64cb32173","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:acabcee1dfaaecff64c4b655","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:7","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a","parent-native:challenge:0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"A directly supported four-dimensional topology-weighting route, without admitting the broader pending continuum scope.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Provide a directly supported topology-weighting direction without admitting the broader pending continuum card.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"gr-qc/9710114","sourceId":"ev:205f0837617375b3dbf0df8649952fa5","sourceSha256":"ddf972b8058bb8ed729b2828fc3aa11c64952d2b373e9fc856d156f82d6f60b3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9db1307e6f5d1506d71/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32a0c1c6a6af10f4525e0c050e5d3a8b3b6e2e0a5ff7909e90e216807e0189dc","pdfPage":4,"start":104,"end":2304,"textSha256":"c0391fe955394d47e4920022f9cccf8815c08bee8b846ce10a25025ad8f3c117","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"gr-qc/9710114","sourceId":"ev:c2af83993eef3ba485cf6a3c5016c188","sourceSha256":"ddf972b8058bb8ed729b2828fc3aa11c64952d2b373e9fc856d156f82d6f60b3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9db1307e6f5d1506d71/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32a0c1c6a6af10f4525e0c050e5d3a8b3b6e2e0a5ff7909e90e216807e0189dc","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":993,"textSha256":"42f76bfe8bb8ae27d009a649652fc75368b5a579f666c1c842286ec64cb32173","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"gr-qc/9710114","sourceId":"ev:205f0837617375b3dbf0df8649952fa5","sourceSha256":"ddf972b8058bb8ed729b2828fc3aa11c64952d2b373e9fc856d156f82d6f60b3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9db1307e6f5d1506d71/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32a0c1c6a6af10f4525e0c050e5d3a8b3b6e2e0a5ff7909e90e216807e0189dc","pdfPage":4,"start":104,"end":2304,"textSha256":"c0391fe955394d47e4920022f9cccf8815c08bee8b846ce10a25025ad8f3c117","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"gr-qc/9710114","sourceId":"ev:c2af83993eef3ba485cf6a3c5016c188","sourceSha256":"ddf972b8058bb8ed729b2828fc3aa11c64952d2b373e9fc856d156f82d6f60b3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9db1307e6f5d1506d71/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32a0c1c6a6af10f4525e0c050e5d3a8b3b6e2e0a5ff7909e90e216807e0189dc","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":993,"textSha256":"42f76bfe8bb8ae27d009a649652fc75368b5a579f666c1c842286ec64cb32173","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"925b3a06e0d58b1ad55d18ab053b1eb9d69cad6c9cf79f5e8c7018f776a6b930","reply.jsonSha256":"da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a6946727adefee7f3b2b748ff0c0ce5f0a58757e5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"135d367256f1c72fe01022ea832c9dc4f9f738e1d96ce8bf53734f13fe5f68e6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4b6e52d88ba3a909c203c07b3da236d98c0b1b281c2e2c6b7f3607b778bfda8b","normalization.jsonSha256":"6fd88b04991ddf39e7ff5092add083be8e384bafd3f19e71277cd6e2f088e477","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"05576f0db3fb5c595fb6d3897bf21da45667e0eb85b5e9a62f807106dd4fde78"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5765d539bf0f3099f1950f796691829e7f864cd76798b1bb052698baddfe718a","reply.jsonSha256":"0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c480e26d6cfc8a931b11cfe5472f4d19633a4fd55","reply.raw.txtSha256":"de1a8fb3eb5515d58d9c7ca2a9b788a8c9e65e1036945a6bf0722f302d37714a","receipt.jsonSha256":"758edf392c44cf3888db4d027ada99bb3d726b6d5f985600aba5ee4acc328beb","normalization.jsonSha256":"a617cbb678db447bcc5636be99fe70967c460f3c466178602875d90df3617927"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:acabcee1dfaaecff64c4b655","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:ef2794636331348960a93193":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:ef2794636331348960a93193","source":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","target":"q025-candidate-question:f0c1e61f5a72d63fdb8f70f4","type":"narrower","title":"Geometry and distance on spaces of fields and metrics","rationale":"Configuration-space distance requires its own metric and trajectory specification.","qualification":"Configuration-space geometry defines distance independently of a chosen flow parameter or proposed spectral interpretation.","evidenceIds":["unit:10d72088c388cdee7f9b38d7c5f1d7f41eb153c9dd84c3713bae64caa3679913","unit:129c3a5d43df14c7b9d1420495756470f0c59d2cc217ac0dfaaa5ec826ab5fed","unit:210ae4c036fbb0b30fd2e3e52755d2984a3bd33a7ab7ea54f4699048656de8ec","unit:2b559119120db2676179e4ca82398ef2be9970bbd8252014cc790454a36e3e46","unit:2e567bca9a19882f61a1181aa672c6651862c3ba969020fa9672abff35ecc371","unit:3d9174df9114282a9c8d77673f4fdbb796adca1a11b1b1041d5d2d5483f4b4c5","unit:4c01cd20f371b5ac977e1f0f79097b052191e85aa7ed5e1a67c99c260fdc18ab","unit:5e20891cb12629fffa33df70b37ff011e67f1c659bdfc2adaa611e5d2c076152","unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","unit:bf1c1cb9de3afdee426ea903274ed644a77adb1176aacaa4f9b614c16ab67c84","unit:c6ae6426542eed79fce69f742eef2baaac3de74a508042861326dfbc14286e1d","unit:c87b313d905c95625b0805931388bfb34a175e15a34bc92ee0a9e471cbeffe07","unit:f2d16e1773e3c5b168c1d70e06c2819a1ddcd0ba1b980a8a42919a192ed1db5c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f0c1e61f5a72d63fdb8f70f4"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:ef2794636331348960a93193","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:10","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a","parent-native:challenge:0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Configuration-space distance requires its own metric and trajectory specification.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Configuration-space geometry defines distance independently of a chosen flow parameter or proposed spectral interpretation.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f0c1e61f5a72d63fdb8f70f4"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f0c1e61f5a72d63fdb8f70f4"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"925b3a06e0d58b1ad55d18ab053b1eb9d69cad6c9cf79f5e8c7018f776a6b930","reply.jsonSha256":"da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a6946727adefee7f3b2b748ff0c0ce5f0a58757e5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"135d367256f1c72fe01022ea832c9dc4f9f738e1d96ce8bf53734f13fe5f68e6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4b6e52d88ba3a909c203c07b3da236d98c0b1b281c2e2c6b7f3607b778bfda8b","normalization.jsonSha256":"6fd88b04991ddf39e7ff5092add083be8e384bafd3f19e71277cd6e2f088e477","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"05576f0db3fb5c595fb6d3897bf21da45667e0eb85b5e9a62f807106dd4fde78"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5765d539bf0f3099f1950f796691829e7f864cd76798b1bb052698baddfe718a","reply.jsonSha256":"0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c480e26d6cfc8a931b11cfe5472f4d19633a4fd55","reply.raw.txtSha256":"de1a8fb3eb5515d58d9c7ca2a9b788a8c9e65e1036945a6bf0722f302d37714a","receipt.jsonSha256":"758edf392c44cf3888db4d027ada99bb3d726b6d5f985600aba5ee4acc328beb","normalization.jsonSha256":"a617cbb678db447bcc5636be99fe70967c460f3c466178602875d90df3617927"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:ef2794636331348960a93193","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:31907b684cfefd58572ab117":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:31907b684cfefd58572ab117","source":"q025-candidate-region:e52fcb6489b7f044e70ddb7d","target":"q025-candidate-question:16f5a1e00af6a60aab217f56","type":"narrower","title":"Constructing black objects and determining horizon geometry","rationale":"Reuse the construction and horizon-geometry direction across batches.","qualification":"Reuse the construction and horizon-geometry direction across review batches.","evidenceIds":["unit:145a3df72cea777bbc4b03efb5b9d7501a4fe473fdd070f8d634c258553dd062","unit:4e8aff51cfadc15ced0de3baa6d5794543d998151b82590318c26746e7a80cfb","unit:677b609b049f341afd42fb330c4de6b855d17323c43de47a19079f48a18aa4c3","unit:68b2460dbd5e441bfa56c8a9dfb9ce0ee2a84d74f21591cdc3ecd5e4763aa332","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:16f5a1e00af6a60aab217f56"},{"localRef":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:921c76b9f363f2b0bb5588b9"},{"localRef":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f7dd8ce714c5588352f9ee2c"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:31907b684cfefd58572ab117","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:5","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:7ed90616c9778f81b207849b","parent-native:challenge:9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse the construction and horizon-geometry direction across batches.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the construction and horizon-geometry direction across review batches.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:16f5a1e00af6a60aab217f56"},{"ref":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:921c76b9f363f2b0bb5588b9"},{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f7dd8ce714c5588352f9ee2c"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:16f5a1e00af6a60aab217f56"},{"ref":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:921c76b9f363f2b0bb5588b9"},{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f7dd8ce714c5588352f9ee2c"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:31907b684cfefd58572ab117","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:18a4e038917bf70f11f66dbe":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:18a4e038917bf70f11f66dbe","source":"q025-candidate-region:e52fcb6489b7f044e70ddb7d","target":"q025-candidate-question:4cf0a93fe307ced42155ce9c","type":"narrower","title":"Collapse, instability and exterior predictability","rationale":"Give collapse and exterior predictability a route separate from stationary horizon tests.","qualification":"Keep collapse and exterior predictability distinct from stationary horizon-root tests.","evidenceIds":["unit:0204513a9c81f214ac1861c49b726bf7bc0d1446232d699eec15a43dbf5af7b7","unit:0933727f2b1e78b6c4fce9163c5643143cb5c8c6a846908e1b76659f42729f1f","unit:1009562b2bddbcbc396cad0d94a3ecf03c7e5a984c8a9c22dbe063419cd9bccf","unit:1aa41971357bbc8d9a48dc12e595e8a84344b31f759a8ac29ce90639468aef6f","unit:1fbd9994e8dce907c1a607b983b7fe4b429899904fdcc98b44da5fa11ad4caa6","unit:20f62ddbd8d08d3704830812469fa900113e0d490ab3d12e2889402eff69476c","unit:25144eaef9f114bc4ffc947bf3239a119316200a028a129c567a495d4d1628b9","unit:2575e6fa37dde12ceed2082dc000a1e210189526e2fbec9790245f86bfbebf0b","unit:2581bef062735ef6a3e7b2f838f69be219c12d7a658f5a723ae22189969d38e2","unit:309721ad12a6782ffa1f2db2d295ebb632e4e7db8315d48afba83929b2084285","unit:3700b7f4e3d1b3886c19c5a25fa127077d39e9035b6d54a3e6f2a1316bde6371","unit:41824dd287e055ad6327ea30458a0fcc28a9ced687f100cf2108caf0fddfe63d","unit:44d06de4401805f7182a7bf86bb6932f58600d8625e45a21b67a358f696a94fb","unit:473230cc9b104b0aabee312943fd77b70a6046ed6f5f6020eb1ef5c32d696985","unit:4e8aff51cfadc15ced0de3baa6d5794543d998151b82590318c26746e7a80cfb","unit:51a9abaa575aebff02f777d4f5c1a6b19c17532394aac3f05cba39a4edc0ca3d","unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","unit:53b280edea8265620d50add58732e99c4f7f7d1ac2612b61b5fb9a17bd9fc187","unit:577da843774ab5910089e3d17a70b15ff00027c68599cea456a3d2476ea2d36b","unit:5c57793bfe2b69a7f10cae45744159a7be7ab72d459445d1bd3d622a3abc0c5a","unit:652069de11f02c4055e64bda8114f0e178820d54d8b1ed2e2713bfb647cd71d1","unit:677b609b049f341afd42fb330c4de6b855d17323c43de47a19079f48a18aa4c3","unit:68b2460dbd5e441bfa56c8a9dfb9ce0ee2a84d74f21591cdc3ecd5e4763aa332","unit:6de98888d80f498ce217d03fbc1b95363d1595a722cc595142423a9f6152f655","unit:7d49e5b06fb4ae979c708a1607c555eaf0aa44a972bbb66325f9a7927fab8d84","unit:80ced4e261f7bd849b890b151e846c5db246a73d8884fe7115705f0a3ea49636","unit:980b90636d48fa37ade545448b2f62d0a1e55517abbf01aa52bd1fe066004160","unit:9b1af258da600ca582a26124b5d3fc7221979629be28b93db2e18f1bdb884ef5","unit:a249186d0a70834eb6a294ce61823d1ac2c47b50ce7fc3d9a0260001b83cfcfd","unit:a6018dbf3d8987ad39fcbe7d807a8a0c42337ab859ac9ee097dfa274a51d150c","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:a7598adbe03e2639ecc87aad679b23c115d94591604634847142e7291b64fb58","unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","unit:bb32af9f72f7b08cf02e00487daa62e1fd8d12254ef213656f5b085c7b111d02","unit:be1888340eb6ca76cd61373d1b7b8f55838b0485b2f5f47a77de92af5681b559","unit:c59c5b266b0385f3b85fe0b2da06c1857cccfaea44a9c67e2de3f62461f5fea6","unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","unit:e2668da545e21408bbc9ec9e5f9655abb76d0ce660df82db737814e0fcde6d12","unit:e33478e55b0ab253ccdc50874e98772364abb288b51add1fe9ff41944f6ae1e0","unit:e547701099a8451170bf0a59ba0185f0925e04e9a7d2cbb37322675770f274e8","unit:f6e6520ebd3be8de2d5fbda228c06d12577bef50f7001c085587438f370d4ab9"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4cf0a93fe307ced42155ce9c"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:18a4e038917bf70f11f66dbe","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:12","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:7ed90616c9778f81b207849b","parent-native:challenge:9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Give collapse and exterior predictability a route separate from stationary horizon tests.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Keep collapse and exterior predictability distinct from stationary horizon-root tests.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4cf0a93fe307ced42155ce9c"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4cf0a93fe307ced42155ce9c"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:18a4e038917bf70f11f66dbe","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:207559511df4dd6049d3c663":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:207559511df4dd6049d3c663","source":"q025-candidate-region:e52fcb6489b7f044e70ddb7d","target":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34","type":"narrower","title":"Corrected black-hole thermodynamics and extremality","rationale":"Reuse the specified-family calculation target for corrected thermodynamics and extremality.","qualification":"Reuse the specified-family calculation target for corrected thermodynamics and extremality.","evidenceIds":["unit:151822cebd530bc89ef31bc2293f2213b585ebef17202aaa220318cf5d97b739","unit:1877ac824b12f923a22b9a1410a474675bcab4fcc7fee2a93c55f9d96742d23a","unit:1efd9f9c192ab47eb9d6b64ea349f9a6c0b2cf5d7672b12b7dafd61e379548a7","unit:25e50cf0d0c93ce5a51d4da0f884796d5145450e7798d5c79585492c25c5a652","unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","unit:3a270e0aeff8114e04b2252be47b23163f3375a232f890db0ae0c73850f08fe9","unit:3c106070bf074f6507e76f297d665fec11c195d39b6edf65e83ca0a5905723f8","unit:4e8aff51cfadc15ced0de3baa6d5794543d998151b82590318c26746e7a80cfb","unit:5311dc99f3430f7032763d85160d29683df4356ea8bdf483093010dd804882fd","unit:55793d616bd78fdb5fd72de6dd8be224c096f26641468c99c8869dad9ea3126e","unit:5c65d0cc3602f62da727f036ccdefaed1719e834b500725b75902f372f9d3e66","unit:5e772a318ef7be8c945f9d319d01674f0415ff74d9c34fc08b5bab13c69de57a","unit:5e8532e5d51877e6508933ce812aee19d40f5c30fc314fa643ab478e9470eb0a","unit:5ead4ae79a9f4c448d9f47daddc72047adc7d0385aa0c7a0aef9e117ce97a12c","unit:618c7476e9bd17d716b6730a0c83a5b14174deb00690e4bdd359630f74f131ed","unit:632375f47b6ebe7abe302950673fb2c489271d92fc2110cd14ac0990dcb709a5","unit:677b609b049f341afd42fb330c4de6b855d17323c43de47a19079f48a18aa4c3","unit:68b2460dbd5e441bfa56c8a9dfb9ce0ee2a84d74f21591cdc3ecd5e4763aa332","unit:745f35375ebfb12aece3f15c491f2ecd90af4e669e1107e37754ca972cc5f180","unit:787534e2e35e019673c656715a983d3413316961ea455fd7e07a57627a3fe3dd","unit:7a51a318f853da645a4e7c073f452e8b31664afe3cf0f9fa153d19c330037177","unit:7f74ed53aa9e88488adf9350f6c34e4c409b716f24a0b2def99253e7842a7b56","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:accfe2a19c4fb08ce0eb7fdd83f5012cde08774653f070f81705669e75537fb6","unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","unit:b35ae44c6ba74a9966e60b6bc994be69e207b51b2d01e515329ee1674f058fcd","unit:b5505445a85f89950ba6f38d799d36a1a46dac4f03dffa2e386a69b4c2895fb8","unit:b58a3ad71c793111d5d8d7025b3a3347bcf56652af65c3684c18af99e2480f56","unit:b83d41617038331d16fae81216e62872b17f5b98219d20a94a085a90f61e26cb","unit:bb0076de91c75000347da475dde66347547beff9291ae679c16b5b82ddc329fe","unit:bb6e38375672c2460f470d98ff71dc7fab8eb1ac1065293d909e84faf63c58d7","unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","unit:d4362492b6339b25a09c8fe17e66561967023cb288122938666ca4ff4d8fb342","unit:deb140f8a9d9eebacd7cd647cd5eda20c50b3319aac96e371ee35bee877f32e1","unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","unit:eb1997d2fb75c5bf865bea781a0327dc3e8bca4a01cd4d523428103d4c7c6c83","unit:f9459fa6a0698d7fb5eb5597ac1d3f3adcd0dacbbe7f34945a11fbe510d58ebc","unit:ff6e5c9f362ef2405a4c290978ce050944e9987a99ee38ce1ae9521bb42b2327"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2011.14366","sourceId":"ev:58148d6069e3f8746b9579c4dae3842f","sourceSha256":"b230520ef018aa7e8b690fc94398383bb208388531ad6d79c103a951b5e9c139","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fbf228539ffa8b4660be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a5db89d94ce9f9c390d0c91058dc85d528932a717b285f1c69d13d24b068dd76","pdfPage":2,"start":101,"end":3332,"textSha256":"45e2c71afb1d7919b00aa7ca5143d9860841c9a35c34a85c7524372f7f6c1649","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","paperId":"2011.14366","sourceId":"ev:f703754ab33f188b68a5b736ac0acc8a","sourceSha256":"b230520ef018aa7e8b690fc94398383bb208388531ad6d79c103a951b5e9c139","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fbf228539ffa8b4660be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a5db89d94ce9f9c390d0c91058dc85d528932a717b285f1c69d13d24b068dd76","pdfPage":1,"start":105,"end":2113,"textSha256":"de61296bc40b22580b312ecc8b9ab348102bfcc17bd9b7981121df6b7838760a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:207559511df4dd6049d3c663","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:6","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:7ed90616c9778f81b207849b","parent-native:challenge:9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse the specified-family calculation target for corrected thermodynamics and extremality.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the specified-family calculation target for corrected thermodynamics and extremality.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2011.14366","sourceId":"ev:58148d6069e3f8746b9579c4dae3842f","sourceSha256":"b230520ef018aa7e8b690fc94398383bb208388531ad6d79c103a951b5e9c139","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fbf228539ffa8b4660be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a5db89d94ce9f9c390d0c91058dc85d528932a717b285f1c69d13d24b068dd76","pdfPage":2,"start":101,"end":3332,"textSha256":"45e2c71afb1d7919b00aa7ca5143d9860841c9a35c34a85c7524372f7f6c1649","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e16","kind":"primary","paperId":"2011.14366","sourceId":"ev:f703754ab33f188b68a5b736ac0acc8a","sourceSha256":"b230520ef018aa7e8b690fc94398383bb208388531ad6d79c103a951b5e9c139","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fbf228539ffa8b4660be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a5db89d94ce9f9c390d0c91058dc85d528932a717b285f1c69d13d24b068dd76","pdfPage":1,"start":105,"end":2113,"textSha256":"de61296bc40b22580b312ecc8b9ab348102bfcc17bd9b7981121df6b7838760a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2011.14366","sourceId":"ev:58148d6069e3f8746b9579c4dae3842f","sourceSha256":"b230520ef018aa7e8b690fc94398383bb208388531ad6d79c103a951b5e9c139","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fbf228539ffa8b4660be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a5db89d94ce9f9c390d0c91058dc85d528932a717b285f1c69d13d24b068dd76","pdfPage":2,"start":101,"end":3332,"textSha256":"45e2c71afb1d7919b00aa7ca5143d9860841c9a35c34a85c7524372f7f6c1649","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e16","kind":"primary","paperId":"2011.14366","sourceId":"ev:f703754ab33f188b68a5b736ac0acc8a","sourceSha256":"b230520ef018aa7e8b690fc94398383bb208388531ad6d79c103a951b5e9c139","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fbf228539ffa8b4660be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a5db89d94ce9f9c390d0c91058dc85d528932a717b285f1c69d13d24b068dd76","pdfPage":1,"start":105,"end":2113,"textSha256":"de61296bc40b22580b312ecc8b9ab348102bfcc17bd9b7981121df6b7838760a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:207559511df4dd6049d3c663","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:06c0314de411501f0a67e7c8":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:06c0314de411501f0a67e7c8","source":"q025-candidate-region:e52fcb6489b7f044e70ddb7d","target":"q025-candidate-question:94d01979496f4cc48fd01f07","type":"narrower","title":"Discharge kinematics and charged spectra","rationale":"Keep charged spectra and discharge permission distinct from rates, endpoints and stronger conjectural requirements.","qualification":"Separate charged spectra and discharge permission from rates, endpoints and stronger conjectural requirements.","evidenceIds":["unit:0d6e960e72bca88185dda6b524682a894dd2fbdcef7130c4a65006db9cb6663f","unit:1834f4b5e0ec8ae541bf2af110d283008c3197872ea91eb59958386dca077eb9","unit:1ad7e1448faa2822223e5bfa33c744c6a2076e14289fbd244e85c213fb578476","unit:2072546c33c7beab8e62e690504370dc9e8cb749bd0ea68b412c643706ca940e","unit:265f636e5b8c4af14debd6b2cbec78178e9b65f33cdcae183e62dc36da13766e","unit:2a292d9c1f609e6b7b62503b0606bbb682b3d64055262aad8acfa0e6be8c76b6","unit:3120acdf8712ea2a085f4f7fc5b0aadcb5dec534e94228d84eaf4cd44bd31c61","unit:44a1ca5f443bbf0d189876dfc9dc435b49c7bf3732a0bfc7b5a43ec242884d03","unit:47f20c13555b6a24e036eb69dac9e33374893a5dd73e32257e2e2d23a39ca6c6","unit:48d159e6ec1b6e90f62ea33493ecc393688701e840a04f196b4fe7ed0fe76373","unit:4e8aff51cfadc15ced0de3baa6d5794543d998151b82590318c26746e7a80cfb","unit:52e3584c514ebebe470005d57fd1e9beb298f6e6b66be25969930ceb01d253a1","unit:5eb7269d133bcc124e5f2978561dfaf43be90ea823d6a8ac7c5284bc5b02f9d4","unit:677b609b049f341afd42fb330c4de6b855d17323c43de47a19079f48a18aa4c3","unit:68b2460dbd5e441bfa56c8a9dfb9ce0ee2a84d74f21591cdc3ecd5e4763aa332","unit:6df39bcb6b52192e783e45e332d170619d74452ddfa32f036f52c1457ca2c8e1","unit:721e755cfa00e72412262ca696dee1be27d2f117b5661c9f9e4b68db0e9d322e","unit:72bbb8d97766ebab58410a0c0b1cea282137820056cabaf3c12c763d7b5ac8c3","unit:95609cc4e7bb836fab3f8d5763087c674eec09ef7452e10e98b4254798c27011","unit:a031fc2d256129f061136749fbade74e97986eb3eabacbcc514bfc8b00ed4a46","unit:a5d8b5b4b53946f24f3b04fecbfcdc0a8caf1b001f97da321d8e15a33638657e","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:aa187c3dd3581f687242bc9e00d3c89aba683ff9177b0014ae3df06a6b1eace8","unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","unit:b1e385cc48b784981ee54d5147073e605f6f8b58bced0582512d2ddbdebd158a","unit:b3b0f8f1f4818b59a2950deea42af23fd0ec4532d6d475ba3c37dae542d64c30","unit:b595bc30dfbeb3610478f1f561421de0c24500efb36e372387a9357cedae59e5","unit:b8eeb04259e98f50dddd3f2b07a0adf79cb2d75e0d24509dc3d4649af2eae94e","unit:c1bad2ece74ad8f47e53e931f6a5cfca1ac211dc1c368843e46be3d629665b2f","unit:c7ba1a37fc98ee63474d7ae2e0ce4f894585426dada668e990ef6e1f75c01fdb","unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","unit:d8413d25e3c4b1bb2699f405d7a0f9de45b24b6b5003944fa1bc83b0f59e9538","unit:ebe88f5466f4479a35649d43d9643c65bdcc0e36cab1fd4c7450032da8680838","unit:f310cc62291d0ad9f437d30c8ec3785fc47aca44dde7189d98d5912091cc6017"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:94d01979496f4cc48fd01f07"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:06c0314de411501f0a67e7c8","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:8","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:7ed90616c9778f81b207849b","parent-native:challenge:9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Keep charged spectra and discharge permission distinct from rates, endpoints and stronger conjectural requirements.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Separate charged spectra and discharge permission from rates, endpoints and stronger conjectural requirements.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:94d01979496f4cc48fd01f07"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:94d01979496f4cc48fd01f07"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:06c0314de411501f0a67e7c8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:ee3c2e4612f442121efa8431":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:ee3c2e4612f442121efa8431","source":"q025-candidate-region:e52fcb6489b7f044e70ddb7d","target":"q025-candidate-question:9cdb16a400568ad8d467d359","type":"narrower","title":"Classical orbits, scattering and energy extraction","rationale":"Preserve ordinary orbital dynamics, scattering and energy extraction as distinct observables.","qualification":"Preserve ordinary orbital dynamics, scattering and energy extraction as their own observables.","evidenceIds":["unit:13e2b7935927f018ba049a3bf0464f3e0cbaac9f97924169e07217318918aa2f","unit:1b8e3370fa7859f2ec7f276df2829f99d5e3d778d3e3f3396691a06ea2253548","unit:455807e282f0deb83d24bab745c7579007c06b300820d3b13a54d19b168a9543","unit:4937f4fa356cf3c51cbb209dfaa28b355c1a4416025532245377d7f61c6dbb60","unit:4e8aff51cfadc15ced0de3baa6d5794543d998151b82590318c26746e7a80cfb","unit:677b609b049f341afd42fb330c4de6b855d17323c43de47a19079f48a18aa4c3","unit:68b2460dbd5e441bfa56c8a9dfb9ce0ee2a84d74f21591cdc3ecd5e4763aa332","unit:86f7b3a864a3e0c9e09f00890cabd3db247b8fa0247fdec394f405ab7ad2a123","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","unit:e65f0f92d80d7795671289baaa75914a7f57286a542b6231f2c5245d5322f92e","unit:fad110e33ac2d5f343c53205a222cd4554d93b78d0d090e9aab6a174e51dfc34"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9cdb16a400568ad8d467d359"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:ee3c2e4612f442121efa8431","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:11","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:7ed90616c9778f81b207849b","parent-native:challenge:9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Preserve ordinary orbital dynamics, scattering and energy extraction as distinct observables.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Preserve ordinary orbital dynamics, scattering and energy extraction as their own observables.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9cdb16a400568ad8d467d359"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9cdb16a400568ad8d467d359"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:ee3c2e4612f442121efa8431","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:b641081427b91a99b48f0979":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:b641081427b91a99b48f0979","source":"q025-candidate-region:e52fcb6489b7f044e70ddb7d","target":"q025-candidate-question:a0b81ad3358ecff3e0f1c4ad","type":"narrower","title":"Field spectra, boundary conditions and stability","rationale":"Reuse field spectra with their background, boundary-condition and stability qualifications.","qualification":"Reuse the field-spectrum direction while retaining field sectors, boundary conditions and stability limits.","evidenceIds":["unit:2cffb9faa09377ebdb32ba5c63683b146eb96e11aeb144b60b3ac3fc4bd423ae","unit:4e8aff51cfadc15ced0de3baa6d5794543d998151b82590318c26746e7a80cfb","unit:5783724fc808522c2af61b13b75cf4729a590d52ffb40088d43573abb197d4c6","unit:677b609b049f341afd42fb330c4de6b855d17323c43de47a19079f48a18aa4c3","unit:68b2460dbd5e441bfa56c8a9dfb9ce0ee2a84d74f21591cdc3ecd5e4763aa332","unit:6c9b99404221e9a3f9f6a31fd5345f7e6f40f9cdfe0fc8bc88457e067defde70","unit:7bf4bd3a8935302c15057334958e89cdfed7cf4a5930f6a2ba758513eec88130","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","unit:d39ec96e47b495cb46c0adbd42b4804910fdc2511938c586a37113fbf9da13ef","unit:d3f5b55db4a44f1242a1e7d55aa8537cef7c92ac8fdf3ab106110092aee93643","unit:d7329c96948bb1c45bad844bb1e9569b94ff66c1afd943be70e980acc24a4f2d","unit:d8efc3c113d9682ae66c3f4f2a4291e4ae73e03ca649880fde809a5da49d2d12","unit:df55ebc8a474485011f53ee5b3441b949228d4863fe885a7baea3ea4b38b809a","unit:f2107ba4391515831703f47d5d2f16773f60be9737f4c55764ce5ceeb6fd5603","unit:fbc21f1bbe6b9d93460c81b998bfdeec6d15061b26c6abe7a25b081bb1691970"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a0b81ad3358ecff3e0f1c4ad"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:b641081427b91a99b48f0979","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:10","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:7ed90616c9778f81b207849b","parent-native:challenge:9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse field spectra with their background, boundary-condition and stability qualifications.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the field-spectrum direction while retaining field sectors, boundary conditions and stability limits.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a0b81ad3358ecff3e0f1c4ad"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a0b81ad3358ecff3e0f1c4ad"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:b641081427b91a99b48f0979","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:4b37c438a5cc0f7285352c74":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:4b37c438a5cc0f7285352c74","source":"q025-candidate-region:e52fcb6489b7f044e70ddb7d","target":"q025-candidate-question:bc0e38e8d6299c3104eddde6","type":"comparison","title":"Extremality, decay and consistency diagnostics","rationale":"Reuse the conditional diagnostic overview; entropy, extremality, decay and censorship tests supply no common theorem.","qualification":"Reuse the conditional diagnostic overview for entropy, extremality, decay and censorship comparisons; it supplies no common theorem.","evidenceIds":["unit:0204513a9c81f214ac1861c49b726bf7bc0d1446232d699eec15a43dbf5af7b7","unit:1795cc43c34e4468a9eee4ff690aa981d599e887b59d54aff3f3ceda218fc0ed","unit:25144eaef9f114bc4ffc947bf3239a119316200a028a129c567a495d4d1628b9","unit:2581bef062735ef6a3e7b2f838f69be219c12d7a658f5a723ae22189969d38e2","unit:2bc6461a15f9c1c9b31c409e32777bc9fa894db1ea7c49be62265268d5ed0527","unit:30f70fa4094b23afac639f7a2f78cdccffeb406dafaa56beba6a14f3790e1175","unit:4bea2236adce2a83cf3c451f430db2b31ccbb60826ec94caf64e9a0ca2613854","unit:4e8aff51cfadc15ced0de3baa6d5794543d998151b82590318c26746e7a80cfb","unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","unit:576dc306e4137d4062854a319e419173c19bf889e64525f6b74866c36efcf4fa","unit:677b609b049f341afd42fb330c4de6b855d17323c43de47a19079f48a18aa4c3","unit:689ec46b1256a9f14ae10d8debdd43b57ddf716979afb61cbc1a9b8fcc8e396f","unit:68b2460dbd5e441bfa56c8a9dfb9ce0ee2a84d74f21591cdc3ecd5e4763aa332","unit:73eaf12b0b4b20ca9b32b5fa4b92324a79de7c01cf4c48e27cb92542eb8e154d","unit:95b33eeeb3e1a10dd9bde6bf1cf18c8bc2713283974bb1960b099b3a3c76e0fa","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","unit:bb32af9f72f7b08cf02e00487daa62e1fd8d12254ef213656f5b085c7b111d02","unit:be079f13f6d1770b003bdd4a0ee9a0bb68883c92e090162c91a5db6ec9bdcbef","unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","unit:d2ea5ad1dd2d82ce009ad8bc4c8bf2e1f0349abcb7c75712256478751968e68e","unit:de8041ddd7acec54d3f515d90e848e4e9dcad7b68bfe86be9a04e5ed380d4c0d","unit:e547701099a8451170bf0a59ba0185f0925e04e9a7d2cbb37322675770f274e8","unit:eba41a449c52cda273339321940e923267180c27613d3af5a9895ec0c1195f0b","unit:ed121c25fc3cdc8096d38d3a7d2376acbcbc74e0e3d7f0c6b102f41e38077dfc","unit:f292ebe81993cf3529f2453014d183a3a9d346d7c643bbe49315840f921c2968","unit:fbf40b6d4807285c6bd7514cd39c5c1eada19fc21f9b5473f80f03e7584b8b04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bc0e38e8d6299c3104eddde6"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1706.08257","sourceId":"ev:54accceedf52767c11a77917f762c43d","sourceSha256":"81837e3d00e8661ebab5b00816832f425dd94efc6557e9e4ab95ea7b9bd2b113","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ee2e32fdade8c327655e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1b227ff39643ca72f60807dee182d0cfdfebfbca3241fd2a2c6b54765548c3f9","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"48a3f995b7e1892574e32a794647cac23876abf415062b55fcac78217a734e7a","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"1706.08257","sourceId":"ev:d9cc2df797fe482678daba38b78f88f9","sourceSha256":"81837e3d00e8661ebab5b00816832f425dd94efc6557e9e4ab95ea7b9bd2b113","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ee2e32fdade8c327655e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1b227ff39643ca72f60807dee182d0cfdfebfbca3241fd2a2c6b54765548c3f9","pdfPage":17,"start":0,"end":2198,"textSha256":"3b3ce0e61934ad7238adbd3ba743f66d61b063703661dfb630e1365e9508bb73","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceId":"ev:056f03f61a118320a256cbd4666feeb2","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2437,"textSha256":"f104d9b8804048972bcc6fbc39c5f4533de6425c49dfc7a2d30e494aa0ddf228","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","paperId":"2404.15981","sourceId":"ev:eb7f02c3f93f2e4ea559c91f87f5f9be","sourceSha256":"27a18b083792cf487e9c956a266574549407d78a84704593e01017aefb1ca641","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9a8cd2387d9a5754f832/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c81084bc3e51717afbbe3a58f983be650638f41420491a17b9a9bd0c331ec635","pdfPage":13,"start":151,"end":3540,"textSha256":"4f4cb66d024dd02c1da6b87ba2c0e8998b32d3a8daaab5d07de932c2ba49ab51","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:4b37c438a5cc0f7285352c74","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:14","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:7ed90616c9778f81b207849b","parent-native:challenge:9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b"],"originalNativeType":"comparison","challengeReason":"Reuse the conditional diagnostic overview; entropy, extremality, decay and censorship tests supply no common theorem.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the conditional diagnostic overview for entropy, extremality, decay and censorship comparisons; it supplies no common theorem.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bc0e38e8d6299c3104eddde6"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1706.08257","sourceId":"ev:54accceedf52767c11a77917f762c43d","sourceSha256":"81837e3d00e8661ebab5b00816832f425dd94efc6557e9e4ab95ea7b9bd2b113","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ee2e32fdade8c327655e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1b227ff39643ca72f60807dee182d0cfdfebfbca3241fd2a2c6b54765548c3f9","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"48a3f995b7e1892574e32a794647cac23876abf415062b55fcac78217a734e7a","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"1706.08257","sourceId":"ev:d9cc2df797fe482678daba38b78f88f9","sourceSha256":"81837e3d00e8661ebab5b00816832f425dd94efc6557e9e4ab95ea7b9bd2b113","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ee2e32fdade8c327655e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1b227ff39643ca72f60807dee182d0cfdfebfbca3241fd2a2c6b54765548c3f9","pdfPage":17,"start":0,"end":2198,"textSha256":"3b3ce0e61934ad7238adbd3ba743f66d61b063703661dfb630e1365e9508bb73","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceId":"ev:056f03f61a118320a256cbd4666feeb2","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2437,"textSha256":"f104d9b8804048972bcc6fbc39c5f4533de6425c49dfc7a2d30e494aa0ddf228","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e14","kind":"primary","paperId":"2404.15981","sourceId":"ev:eb7f02c3f93f2e4ea559c91f87f5f9be","sourceSha256":"27a18b083792cf487e9c956a266574549407d78a84704593e01017aefb1ca641","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9a8cd2387d9a5754f832/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c81084bc3e51717afbbe3a58f983be650638f41420491a17b9a9bd0c331ec635","pdfPage":13,"start":151,"end":3540,"textSha256":"4f4cb66d024dd02c1da6b87ba2c0e8998b32d3a8daaab5d07de932c2ba49ab51","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bc0e38e8d6299c3104eddde6"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1706.08257","sourceId":"ev:54accceedf52767c11a77917f762c43d","sourceSha256":"81837e3d00e8661ebab5b00816832f425dd94efc6557e9e4ab95ea7b9bd2b113","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ee2e32fdade8c327655e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1b227ff39643ca72f60807dee182d0cfdfebfbca3241fd2a2c6b54765548c3f9","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"48a3f995b7e1892574e32a794647cac23876abf415062b55fcac78217a734e7a","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"1706.08257","sourceId":"ev:d9cc2df797fe482678daba38b78f88f9","sourceSha256":"81837e3d00e8661ebab5b00816832f425dd94efc6557e9e4ab95ea7b9bd2b113","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ee2e32fdade8c327655e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1b227ff39643ca72f60807dee182d0cfdfebfbca3241fd2a2c6b54765548c3f9","pdfPage":17,"start":0,"end":2198,"textSha256":"3b3ce0e61934ad7238adbd3ba743f66d61b063703661dfb630e1365e9508bb73","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceId":"ev:056f03f61a118320a256cbd4666feeb2","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2437,"textSha256":"f104d9b8804048972bcc6fbc39c5f4533de6425c49dfc7a2d30e494aa0ddf228","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e14","kind":"primary","paperId":"2404.15981","sourceId":"ev:eb7f02c3f93f2e4ea559c91f87f5f9be","sourceSha256":"27a18b083792cf487e9c956a266574549407d78a84704593e01017aefb1ca641","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9a8cd2387d9a5754f832/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c81084bc3e51717afbbe3a58f983be650638f41420491a17b9a9bd0c331ec635","pdfPage":13,"start":151,"end":3540,"textSha256":"4f4cb66d024dd02c1da6b87ba2c0e8998b32d3a8daaab5d07de932c2ba49ab51","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"comparison","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"comparison","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:4b37c438a5cc0f7285352c74","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:dd96ce6c337e810e24bb74e1":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:dd96ce6c337e810e24bb74e1","source":"q025-candidate-region:e52fcb6489b7f044e70ddb7d","target":"q025-candidate-question:d9e9e00415abb7105f05f79c","type":"narrower","title":"Emission mechanisms and long-lived charge","rationale":"Provide access to emission mechanisms, rates, lifetimes and charge retention.","qualification":"Provide the distinct emission-rate, lifetime and charge-retention direction.","evidenceIds":["unit:143d93388147d279b650be4b61634a1631aa2be664cfb3aa810025ca8e3984f7","unit:1834f4b5e0ec8ae541bf2af110d283008c3197872ea91eb59958386dca077eb9","unit:2072546c33c7beab8e62e690504370dc9e8cb749bd0ea68b412c643706ca940e","unit:2a292d9c1f609e6b7b62503b0606bbb682b3d64055262aad8acfa0e6be8c76b6","unit:3c8e3edc0617fdf6f99991a291884bf52d86a543efbc494ebb93486c824d470c","unit:48d159e6ec1b6e90f62ea33493ecc393688701e840a04f196b4fe7ed0fe76373","unit:49f038a6240393ef3562478a459444ca77c77d934ad799f75e4708cb5e957cab","unit:4e8aff51cfadc15ced0de3baa6d5794543d998151b82590318c26746e7a80cfb","unit:530da9a14202edd3f640458385ba13f8bb5818132ec972130e5836d253d4a239","unit:565b7ff08372b2e5678b6addd4274268ae7a4773323149e8b064129b9013008c","unit:60176c056a981821ae51ac8415d8413e091f389281336bf6b558de555075ac93","unit:628ddeb6d1147c1586be4269d21e3008f4cee6841751649478a2383137fba1ae","unit:62b0fc57ba710c6a81d38c5fa4efe1e4bd57e1d8d6d3c04802355eb9d68fca00","unit:677b609b049f341afd42fb330c4de6b855d17323c43de47a19079f48a18aa4c3","unit:68b2460dbd5e441bfa56c8a9dfb9ce0ee2a84d74f21591cdc3ecd5e4763aa332","unit:6df39bcb6b52192e783e45e332d170619d74452ddfa32f036f52c1457ca2c8e1","unit:72adc931d1154a2532da4df175555681ba6f4398e90b9d459a0751c90029c4cf","unit:72bbb8d97766ebab58410a0c0b1cea282137820056cabaf3c12c763d7b5ac8c3","unit:7df1c85da845450c9716b165c05aa684929f21e5fec2536297b438c8c216a6b1","unit:8223ed8ebb386b7371b4da04d99a06fbb6fd076fca118d4bbd5ea3b42f9d4d20","unit:8f15f6385386378b356ad6e3313e4da862585485372f2311c4a2e2ac92ffe4ab","unit:9949abe3cef17ebfb0e5d2cd9710c430cf1b97b59043a1e02c5c2de088da554f","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:aa187c3dd3581f687242bc9e00d3c89aba683ff9177b0014ae3df06a6b1eace8","unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","unit:b60bdb72c08ffc5ad3d28ff091ddc05bcc76edf0c54e64ea1e5dbb4277b5b7e3","unit:c392c2786cf154d281bc04b2155bb1493eef379545d168bc8322bfb97b56c934","unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","unit:e3bab4a9180ade0203f4e0a68a6acdf8868aaa8e6eea84e3b8dd9810bee72e17","unit:ebe88f5466f4479a35649d43d9643c65bdcc0e36cab1fd4c7450032da8680838"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d9e9e00415abb7105f05f79c"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:dd96ce6c337e810e24bb74e1","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:9","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:7ed90616c9778f81b207849b","parent-native:challenge:9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Provide access to emission mechanisms, rates, lifetimes and charge retention.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Provide the distinct emission-rate, lifetime and charge-retention direction.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d9e9e00415abb7105f05f79c"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d9e9e00415abb7105f05f79c"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:dd96ce6c337e810e24bb74e1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:2d19a8cb9f322186c662c3ac":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:2d19a8cb9f322186c662c3ac","source":"q025-candidate-region:e52fcb6489b7f044e70ddb7d","target":"q025-candidate-question:e467a3835ad69a76fa663b52","type":"narrower","title":"Microscopic and near-horizon entropy accounts","rationale":"Preserve microscopic and near-horizon entropy accounts without identifying their counting mechanisms.","qualification":"Keep microscopic and near-horizon entropy accounts accessible without assuming one counting mechanism.","evidenceIds":["unit:0d082a81ec4e262e49c931c5c007ac577ec08c35a86cc3593e72ef81217470f0","unit:1367c8eb0a5ab835e3c592d086f23cde362d7d6909c80e47c9f0d683ec158ccc","unit:1a34ca3f06688a7d692f74d32abe7985815eb025eb117c6273b5d63f40c1538e","unit:291d21d2c5acb4efae5a7c56ff00b71ff03b9aee41070a14fdfee9e71de7aa44","unit:36d9465e586e7cb9e542b7e1575a3a639c59413d95a941316561144452beb744","unit:3a21df082b12193bd62c4225ad4386097f0e996e9249e043c8332aa1babe4d1f","unit:4e8aff51cfadc15ced0de3baa6d5794543d998151b82590318c26746e7a80cfb","unit:677b609b049f341afd42fb330c4de6b855d17323c43de47a19079f48a18aa4c3","unit:68b2460dbd5e441bfa56c8a9dfb9ce0ee2a84d74f21591cdc3ecd5e4763aa332","unit:76f6a3ded7beb243515dee32e8f3f5dae495350da26c777ee863e4a0834e31bd","unit:97e1c647951082bcdeda3f1608e4957de3bc59f682867c857970a6a52cbfb91a","unit:a37a4876c0cc579774c9a152a0ad1bb54c31dac45fd6d1b41eff0a396641d4b3","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","unit:bfa71a4b4a3bc531fe5ddbb7e20a18325571f39f1e2f59fe1995dbc7e40d715b","unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","unit:d0e8d0be5e21442b476bb15bcfac7f1fef16f79de6ee432e6a86adf60f48100f","unit:df7475646db43f4f4853741aacbb5d06f91a3328bd2ec383e6daf98635f9cf76"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e467a3835ad69a76fa663b52"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:2d19a8cb9f322186c662c3ac","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:7","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:7ed90616c9778f81b207849b","parent-native:challenge:9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Preserve microscopic and near-horizon entropy accounts without identifying their counting mechanisms.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Keep microscopic and near-horizon entropy accounts accessible without assuming one counting mechanism.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e467a3835ad69a76fa663b52"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e467a3835ad69a76fa663b52"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:2d19a8cb9f322186c662c3ac","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:46f94129944af09ca6dc4f0a":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:46f94129944af09ca6dc4f0a","source":"q025-candidate-region:e80b9bd29294a1e014919731","target":"q025-candidate-question:3b2ffb19b08e6266baa77ef1","type":"narrower","title":"Spectral, dynamical and scattering consistency tests","rationale":"Provide access to physical consistency diagnostics without equating spectral, causal, dynamical and scattering tests.","qualification":"Provide a common diagnostic direction without identifying spectral, causal, dynamical and scattering tests.","evidenceIds":["unit:0a98fd0db0d72af5fa86ff7aa484a48b124d9022e420f664805498bd2d3bbe06","unit:17178cf81544083eb02fd8c7883aba719aa0de132be35e031bbca4dee550363b","unit:23b0e2f177a1bd4d9aecba2e8ca545e1b58e9255b71ddfbb27377bd2e057e806","unit:2554d2a530e401b54daf2fd304f3eea5bba427fd4cc3f3de53a1d858eca64386","unit:28c1982a855da4660b4fba9cec512860c482cd0db14eb8b89077216cd518c8e3","unit:31e06f8d2d183db422c78ba88787ba19eb99421cc78528c8ae36b6e3762489fc","unit:35f91f34e3afd4585b979a81f8a30d794a5ed8f89c69f1f418489ef2f68d2a82","unit:3b2b1c226aa9d43ce03cc3b45ff2e9725e78cc8bab537dc38bf803065e1fbce0","unit:41d1ca0724c03cb538f50fbac06aa67b347b37c36696a7ffce0556532c4ca7c1","unit:4a336e5f001aafce410a2dbc60873e1eae325468c4105f79234b371ce31e7c97","unit:4ba99f3f4128c7cab47404bfe511688eff07361377493a68c5c36a3758661cd0","unit:4dd07ac7608ed81cec382be8c79adf4fb50075897b86cc6eff0dc3811a96621e","unit:544f8b9540516cddc4eabd8f56fe9daedc70cb3fbbe76ac740baac3339f5d097","unit:584f854e3761f7e0477cb6fbea2b42a73e92b5b3e1c25c4150cc5a83db0f6bdc","unit:61f6ace0f0b72c9797cd1be3b7acef5ec5d1246ed7ff2df6eaeac464f4bf10c2","unit:88760091093be7e93f820fbdca75f8052e4f62250594201265a1d58b9955142f","unit:a962a84b2b5c9738a9358402fd2e46b3a4ef62c6135e882d57e2fe12fb549f0b","unit:b2552ad68a61b8792bcf65c8e89410684d1b5a600a5f0a4656ae5d737e488a00","unit:cbf855f1b6005dcad3a8634ba4e3ab53846a4fcc354c30594b3b3999f3d24ab1","unit:d29d449e77ffc1182aa86093ac6c53848d2649a20d9980f470cd30d27bdb91ce","unit:d3aff5cf4cf96dbe73f9170fef86c79c9da08b5cd1cbff884d1413ba2b8b1e0e","unit:d50bc6d9fefeaaa7e20cd084dedeb2e0d43cc4d77f4582ce4fb186c558f92844","unit:d77d8bc033852630ec83b30273527493829f0af9ffae0f81f19888682cdb00df","unit:e8614ca0239bcdc27860d1d8ba0187b72e45be841248e2c02ec14b4dbde3712c","unit:e9544187a6fc28587c5f7b2882d7f3ec290f277a5c6f3ea5e6950c98704906ea","unit:eb93db065d33b732f71a3fdc49979280cdf9df1e86c76748540d8f4c6e895aa2","unit:f24263baf7890aa1019b1a3817d69b425cc1cf102f9b3fffe6e4dd5ba43b0b65","unit:f6ef5a553715cf402c36e9c967ad8769478206198c6ab52024b64173f8e8a212"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3b2ffb19b08e6266baa77ef1"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1808.09015","sourceId":"ev:73c8613f8ef9c8005df30f0dafb5771c","sourceSha256":"3137920b093435ff10622a9c57a1168300d45f069296f83cd7359fc3b9280a0e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525be94a52a7d517f861/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"26de8ecb19a03dbf722df3cef4a87a1664328bfdbf3bf1cebafa780843ca8e95","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":3500,"textSha256":"bc186a0026bca36e9e61bf3df99637408afb7c56139df715aeda84329c5eca39","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9510140","sourceId":"ev:9d3b2bb9d94db0d40695997f3e26a193","sourceSha256":"766c6b34f7004d7e26a43fd7f47825edd9423e5d4e09187cbe1ecca36f0670be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4dc04279bcd54d996a09/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e9c5818f1b6186d675f7e2c60305098c4af0aea02d60a5301a54316f5ece440","pdfPage":143,"start":101,"end":2303,"textSha256":"cdedb96d739ad8d1fee8048ecbb3d8c2000d11d519d627b18953ed2bfda1a8a3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:46f94129944af09ca6dc4f0a","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge:link:7","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f","parent-native:challenge:8ffabc85492363a1042777c2"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Provide access to physical consistency diagnostics without equating spectral, causal, dynamical and scattering tests.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Provide a common diagnostic direction without identifying spectral, causal, dynamical and scattering tests.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3b2ffb19b08e6266baa77ef1"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1808.09015","sourceId":"ev:73c8613f8ef9c8005df30f0dafb5771c","sourceSha256":"3137920b093435ff10622a9c57a1168300d45f069296f83cd7359fc3b9280a0e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525be94a52a7d517f861/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"26de8ecb19a03dbf722df3cef4a87a1664328bfdbf3bf1cebafa780843ca8e95","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":3500,"textSha256":"bc186a0026bca36e9e61bf3df99637408afb7c56139df715aeda84329c5eca39","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9510140","sourceId":"ev:9d3b2bb9d94db0d40695997f3e26a193","sourceSha256":"766c6b34f7004d7e26a43fd7f47825edd9423e5d4e09187cbe1ecca36f0670be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4dc04279bcd54d996a09/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e9c5818f1b6186d675f7e2c60305098c4af0aea02d60a5301a54316f5ece440","pdfPage":143,"start":101,"end":2303,"textSha256":"cdedb96d739ad8d1fee8048ecbb3d8c2000d11d519d627b18953ed2bfda1a8a3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3b2ffb19b08e6266baa77ef1"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1808.09015","sourceId":"ev:73c8613f8ef9c8005df30f0dafb5771c","sourceSha256":"3137920b093435ff10622a9c57a1168300d45f069296f83cd7359fc3b9280a0e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525be94a52a7d517f861/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"26de8ecb19a03dbf722df3cef4a87a1664328bfdbf3bf1cebafa780843ca8e95","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":3500,"textSha256":"bc186a0026bca36e9e61bf3df99637408afb7c56139df715aeda84329c5eca39","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9510140","sourceId":"ev:9d3b2bb9d94db0d40695997f3e26a193","sourceSha256":"766c6b34f7004d7e26a43fd7f47825edd9423e5d4e09187cbe1ecca36f0670be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4dc04279bcd54d996a09/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e9c5818f1b6186d675f7e2c60305098c4af0aea02d60a5301a54316f5ece440","pdfPage":143,"start":101,"end":2303,"textSha256":"cdedb96d739ad8d1fee8048ecbb3d8c2000d11d519d627b18953ed2bfda1a8a3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a3765c49038bc6b3111caf2e08467002b2fcc2084dcaaac8d14960717d5c400b","reply.jsonSha256":"e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f061aac7d257291628983cde729c905a9651af003","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ebb5757ecf5a957044b601f6ba4376f4008a1e752d3720d27d5d71ae866d41d4","receipt.jsonSha256":"7a27fe1a900d63d74b05a8c0cf1682742699185af92ae8c001e228b87c91b6bb","normalization.jsonSha256":"43596ae0b2eedfd65c33d536027b49a8c56401a5ac877ac312b1a09631b0d56b","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"d76e0f371e96e8d8830817b4b83e68fec13a898aad312b3f471eb0b3f8973e5b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d51409d65247fce6a82e7e9d8dda3d3dd170ef1b9db83a82d79ae792d987158a","reply.jsonSha256":"8ffabc85492363a1042777c2890ebeeff499c7b7e5148106f70715faa37ffccb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f07a76bd9b31f4d9ce7338403d6cece7206abaf40883fb612cc8116f28144bfc","receipt.jsonSha256":"233d8c48e611b73259e2a2e62830ffcae990817ec0da4d00f41b3e5e955ee55f","normalization.jsonSha256":"01aeea66d8e2d6b41f9aa9dc86b5fa5e4374e983ca64e90998801c5d5a22f4f9"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:46f94129944af09ca6dc4f0a","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:dbd777ab185ccedf3bb64c0b":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:dbd777ab185ccedf3bb64c0b","source":"q025-candidate-region:e80b9bd29294a1e014919731","target":"q025-candidate-question:6a750af0cb788364e953a6fa","type":"narrower","title":"Prescriptions and mechanisms for extra modes","rationale":"Reuse the question about controlling extra modes while preserving distinctions among prescriptions, state selection and proposed binding mechanisms.","qualification":"Reuse the question about controlling extra modes through distinct physical-state, quantization or binding mechanisms.","evidenceIds":["unit:1b15dd14aced0014311aff778bcf7f9f51974fcedbc95e9ff1b6828cb37ceeb2","unit:2309f6d3e3f0448dba4735a8520eec68dc4610fc82090a9929e910f9e785ba0b","unit:2554d2a530e401b54daf2fd304f3eea5bba427fd4cc3f3de53a1d858eca64386","unit:31e06f8d2d183db422c78ba88787ba19eb99421cc78528c8ae36b6e3762489fc","unit:3b2b1c226aa9d43ce03cc3b45ff2e9725e78cc8bab537dc38bf803065e1fbce0","unit:4100a808223e86f7fe92db83fdc7d8ed8193473730361fe40d19239655b3470b","unit:4a336e5f001aafce410a2dbc60873e1eae325468c4105f79234b371ce31e7c97","unit:4b3882e1411852598154ba974441a6cd8de48e1f5e297149fd2c14123040de02","unit:4ba99f3f4128c7cab47404bfe511688eff07361377493a68c5c36a3758661cd0","unit:57fa9f28b6c23d6eb934076c17fadf9c04586f8bb840097a395d063f23b4c557","unit:584f854e3761f7e0477cb6fbea2b42a73e92b5b3e1c25c4150cc5a83db0f6bdc","unit:88760091093be7e93f820fbdca75f8052e4f62250594201265a1d58b9955142f","unit:8c37f2d4b038dca2fbe07cf9b911b096a1c06f2ae7608899793355d63a02ff49","unit:a21e336359b2bb041842a3cb950d22729788c8a2671eb6576db2a5543650c571","unit:a423ce9107108f4ae1c7ef629292195bb7639061ed61cfea5c298b62cad8d356","unit:a962a84b2b5c9738a9358402fd2e46b3a4ef62c6135e882d57e2fe12fb549f0b","unit:cbf855f1b6005dcad3a8634ba4e3ab53846a4fcc354c30594b3b3999f3d24ab1","unit:d3aff5cf4cf96dbe73f9170fef86c79c9da08b5cd1cbff884d1413ba2b8b1e0e","unit:e9544187a6fc28587c5f7b2882d7f3ec290f277a5c6f3ea5e6950c98704906ea","unit:f24263baf7890aa1019b1a3817d69b425cc1cf102f9b3fffe6e4dd5ba43b0b65","unit:fa63fce87bbfc9e1e32d4804fdc924ac0fd6926177dbc33cc1f7fbf07a7104ed"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6a750af0cb788364e953a6fa"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"1808.09015","sourceId":"ev:34d0b072d723e0bbc3dc801eb79b5f24","sourceSha256":"3137920b093435ff10622a9c57a1168300d45f069296f83cd7359fc3b9280a0e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525be94a52a7d517f861/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"26de8ecb19a03dbf722df3cef4a87a1664328bfdbf3bf1cebafa780843ca8e95","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2932,"textSha256":"69bc496adf49138b535ab13e00e80e0929c2df8112f4768fa25eef9be3e754f0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"1808.09015","sourceId":"ev:cc24161637b8b329ccbc8db3c9bac10c","sourceSha256":"3137920b093435ff10622a9c57a1168300d45f069296f83cd7359fc3b9280a0e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525be94a52a7d517f861/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"26de8ecb19a03dbf722df3cef4a87a1664328bfdbf3bf1cebafa780843ca8e95","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"67a6e20018c1918a42923293ef3e67269d84beef70c0d2d90c3fe881f9501bb8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:dbd777ab185ccedf3bb64c0b","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge:link:6","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f","parent-native:challenge:8ffabc85492363a1042777c2"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse the question about controlling extra modes while preserving distinctions among prescriptions, state selection and proposed binding mechanisms.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the question about controlling extra modes through distinct physical-state, quantization or binding mechanisms.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6a750af0cb788364e953a6fa"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"1808.09015","sourceId":"ev:34d0b072d723e0bbc3dc801eb79b5f24","sourceSha256":"3137920b093435ff10622a9c57a1168300d45f069296f83cd7359fc3b9280a0e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525be94a52a7d517f861/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"26de8ecb19a03dbf722df3cef4a87a1664328bfdbf3bf1cebafa780843ca8e95","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2932,"textSha256":"69bc496adf49138b535ab13e00e80e0929c2df8112f4768fa25eef9be3e754f0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"1808.09015","sourceId":"ev:cc24161637b8b329ccbc8db3c9bac10c","sourceSha256":"3137920b093435ff10622a9c57a1168300d45f069296f83cd7359fc3b9280a0e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525be94a52a7d517f861/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"26de8ecb19a03dbf722df3cef4a87a1664328bfdbf3bf1cebafa780843ca8e95","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"67a6e20018c1918a42923293ef3e67269d84beef70c0d2d90c3fe881f9501bb8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6a750af0cb788364e953a6fa"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"1808.09015","sourceId":"ev:34d0b072d723e0bbc3dc801eb79b5f24","sourceSha256":"3137920b093435ff10622a9c57a1168300d45f069296f83cd7359fc3b9280a0e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525be94a52a7d517f861/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"26de8ecb19a03dbf722df3cef4a87a1664328bfdbf3bf1cebafa780843ca8e95","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2932,"textSha256":"69bc496adf49138b535ab13e00e80e0929c2df8112f4768fa25eef9be3e754f0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"1808.09015","sourceId":"ev:cc24161637b8b329ccbc8db3c9bac10c","sourceSha256":"3137920b093435ff10622a9c57a1168300d45f069296f83cd7359fc3b9280a0e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525be94a52a7d517f861/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"26de8ecb19a03dbf722df3cef4a87a1664328bfdbf3bf1cebafa780843ca8e95","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"67a6e20018c1918a42923293ef3e67269d84beef70c0d2d90c3fe881f9501bb8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a3765c49038bc6b3111caf2e08467002b2fcc2084dcaaac8d14960717d5c400b","reply.jsonSha256":"e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f061aac7d257291628983cde729c905a9651af003","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ebb5757ecf5a957044b601f6ba4376f4008a1e752d3720d27d5d71ae866d41d4","receipt.jsonSha256":"7a27fe1a900d63d74b05a8c0cf1682742699185af92ae8c001e228b87c91b6bb","normalization.jsonSha256":"43596ae0b2eedfd65c33d536027b49a8c56401a5ac877ac312b1a09631b0d56b","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"d76e0f371e96e8d8830817b4b83e68fec13a898aad312b3f471eb0b3f8973e5b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d51409d65247fce6a82e7e9d8dda3d3dd170ef1b9db83a82d79ae792d987158a","reply.jsonSha256":"8ffabc85492363a1042777c2890ebeeff499c7b7e5148106f70715faa37ffccb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f07a76bd9b31f4d9ce7338403d6cece7206abaf40883fb612cc8116f28144bfc","receipt.jsonSha256":"233d8c48e611b73259e2a2e62830ffcae990817ec0da4d00f41b3e5e955ee55f","normalization.jsonSha256":"01aeea66d8e2d6b41f9aa9dc86b5fa5e4374e983ca64e90998801c5d5a22f4f9"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:dbd777ab185ccedf3bb64c0b","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:d8171e707178afeebc79a148":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:d8171e707178afeebc79a148","source":"q025-candidate-region:e80b9bd29294a1e014919731","target":"q025-candidate-question:77971b65c8e87c3c7e4b0e48","type":"narrower","title":"Controlled fixed points and gravitational observables","rationale":"Use fixed-point control and observable construction as a shared RG direction across batches, retaining source-specific approximations and backgrounds.","qualification":"Use controlled fixed points and observable construction as a shared RG direction across batches, preserving approximation and background distinctions.","evidenceIds":["unit:0a3e82dfb4ebc6c0352a4a2186ddf821505b7bb6af82c0290d3ef62b744c7cc9","unit:0ef4a8e654cd9436af39f7d4c98915d51deab48538fd1526ac59e366d0bdf096","unit:1400335d2ec5d4c9002d95f04ef1b52b69397657aaab3b15e0ad84c723c0c20d","unit:1d22c43b8541648ae03a2a61b46e098f74cefc0922d7a31491b0ff78c11661df","unit:2064fad41c0d63558d71a51bc0ed5ae9fb8d7a4ef021ea113d89e90d18f78a3a","unit:2b5234bdb93c2fb632531e8c5fe6262be6e2b7ec05643b42ac507a90896c4c5a","unit:3ba3b88b76f7661a10a4b8c73da73a165bf686d62385ee2417401d9e644a8064","unit:405b6ea93948b0f7fbe88ebf188149e8d6e8771b581b4377df31ebc8308362e5","unit:4a336e5f001aafce410a2dbc60873e1eae325468c4105f79234b371ce31e7c97","unit:584f854e3761f7e0477cb6fbea2b42a73e92b5b3e1c25c4150cc5a83db0f6bdc","unit:6e5e6d7dc56f511f719d4cb5d1d969a12c9bfb33d19b4a536852c3984ba99494","unit:80672dccb388af936d46d7e4a9f368056d2005e0cd05b8d6bd2cd4ec5c82315d","unit:913d46a601af6a7b1e0dd3d9b233b4e8b1af444f9d11f40b2073713e8285191b","unit:a962a84b2b5c9738a9358402fd2e46b3a4ef62c6135e882d57e2fe12fb549f0b","unit:b011806389e0b794749abf031b9d8f902816c5361165cb4222deee7707995d26","unit:cbf855f1b6005dcad3a8634ba4e3ab53846a4fcc354c30594b3b3999f3d24ab1","unit:d3aff5cf4cf96dbe73f9170fef86c79c9da08b5cd1cbff884d1413ba2b8b1e0e","unit:f3324ac2bf5119569b7517296bb4fd85c3a4d91f0e8651a8444e7f15881868d5","unit:f6ffdaf511ed5c765e6752c83ea51cd536f512ef62d58d04838a9ddde016f71a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:77971b65c8e87c3c7e4b0e48"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1510.07018","sourceId":"ev:49117c10f7d69c2364365c9cbefef907","sourceSha256":"aaa538560d21d9a3e08c73c9ace36bfe25cff4e88fba2187e3daf97a8211d363","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2beec444aa291b6ab4d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e70d00a524e435140225b0d9a165a1989e2e1ed644ee9530f5db7da2f6589df9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"50c6ec52ae119aace3956e53eb96309262227be8cb6e4958ade84acc77bb63ef","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"1510.07018","sourceId":"ev:997ce937488f80a59cd638b006a9bd97","sourceSha256":"aaa538560d21d9a3e08c73c9ace36bfe25cff4e88fba2187e3daf97a8211d363","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2beec444aa291b6ab4d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e70d00a524e435140225b0d9a165a1989e2e1ed644ee9530f5db7da2f6589df9","pdfPage":1,"start":2502,"end":5293,"textSha256":"91148a257e5666284d464208a23e473c3a556e2f7e9a5ea98c29ab2be5bd7b61","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:d8171e707178afeebc79a148","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge:link:8","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f","parent-native:challenge:8ffabc85492363a1042777c2"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Use fixed-point control and observable construction as a shared RG direction across batches, retaining source-specific approximations and backgrounds.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Use controlled fixed points and observable construction as a shared RG direction across batches, preserving approximation and background distinctions.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:77971b65c8e87c3c7e4b0e48"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1510.07018","sourceId":"ev:49117c10f7d69c2364365c9cbefef907","sourceSha256":"aaa538560d21d9a3e08c73c9ace36bfe25cff4e88fba2187e3daf97a8211d363","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2beec444aa291b6ab4d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e70d00a524e435140225b0d9a165a1989e2e1ed644ee9530f5db7da2f6589df9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"50c6ec52ae119aace3956e53eb96309262227be8cb6e4958ade84acc77bb63ef","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"1510.07018","sourceId":"ev:997ce937488f80a59cd638b006a9bd97","sourceSha256":"aaa538560d21d9a3e08c73c9ace36bfe25cff4e88fba2187e3daf97a8211d363","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2beec444aa291b6ab4d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e70d00a524e435140225b0d9a165a1989e2e1ed644ee9530f5db7da2f6589df9","pdfPage":1,"start":2502,"end":5293,"textSha256":"91148a257e5666284d464208a23e473c3a556e2f7e9a5ea98c29ab2be5bd7b61","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:77971b65c8e87c3c7e4b0e48"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1510.07018","sourceId":"ev:49117c10f7d69c2364365c9cbefef907","sourceSha256":"aaa538560d21d9a3e08c73c9ace36bfe25cff4e88fba2187e3daf97a8211d363","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2beec444aa291b6ab4d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e70d00a524e435140225b0d9a165a1989e2e1ed644ee9530f5db7da2f6589df9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"50c6ec52ae119aace3956e53eb96309262227be8cb6e4958ade84acc77bb63ef","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"1510.07018","sourceId":"ev:997ce937488f80a59cd638b006a9bd97","sourceSha256":"aaa538560d21d9a3e08c73c9ace36bfe25cff4e88fba2187e3daf97a8211d363","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2beec444aa291b6ab4d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e70d00a524e435140225b0d9a165a1989e2e1ed644ee9530f5db7da2f6589df9","pdfPage":1,"start":2502,"end":5293,"textSha256":"91148a257e5666284d464208a23e473c3a556e2f7e9a5ea98c29ab2be5bd7b61","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a3765c49038bc6b3111caf2e08467002b2fcc2084dcaaac8d14960717d5c400b","reply.jsonSha256":"e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f061aac7d257291628983cde729c905a9651af003","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ebb5757ecf5a957044b601f6ba4376f4008a1e752d3720d27d5d71ae866d41d4","receipt.jsonSha256":"7a27fe1a900d63d74b05a8c0cf1682742699185af92ae8c001e228b87c91b6bb","normalization.jsonSha256":"43596ae0b2eedfd65c33d536027b49a8c56401a5ac877ac312b1a09631b0d56b","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"d76e0f371e96e8d8830817b4b83e68fec13a898aad312b3f471eb0b3f8973e5b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d51409d65247fce6a82e7e9d8dda3d3dd170ef1b9db83a82d79ae792d987158a","reply.jsonSha256":"8ffabc85492363a1042777c2890ebeeff499c7b7e5148106f70715faa37ffccb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f07a76bd9b31f4d9ce7338403d6cece7206abaf40883fb612cc8116f28144bfc","receipt.jsonSha256":"233d8c48e611b73259e2a2e62830ffcae990817ec0da4d00f41b3e5e955ee55f","normalization.jsonSha256":"01aeea66d8e2d6b41f9aa9dc86b5fa5e4374e983ca64e90998801c5d5a22f4f9"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:d8171e707178afeebc79a148","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:f67aeb5903b00b029ceb684d":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:f67aeb5903b00b029ceb684d","source":"q025-candidate-region:e80b9bd29294a1e014919731","target":"q025-candidate-question:bba36bc033378532477245d8","type":"comparison","title":"Framework-dependent constraints on effective theories","rationale":"Framework-dependent EFT restrictions provide access to the difference between scoped admissibility tests and proposed universal criteria.","qualification":"Reuse the framework-dependent EFT question to distinguish source-specific restrictions from proposed universal criteria.","evidenceIds":["unit:0ef4a8e654cd9436af39f7d4c98915d51deab48538fd1526ac59e366d0bdf096","unit:1400335d2ec5d4c9002d95f04ef1b52b69397657aaab3b15e0ad84c723c0c20d","unit:314b653507601be94b85991853af1ddc66079bfbebdedbc7324b0339b0615085","unit:4a336e5f001aafce410a2dbc60873e1eae325468c4105f79234b371ce31e7c97","unit:584f854e3761f7e0477cb6fbea2b42a73e92b5b3e1c25c4150cc5a83db0f6bdc","unit:7a0df42f87a46aad5f97c7ac4b295697074b23a11518c35e60ffc316e36920aa","unit:97cd2aa09dc11dabeb20a78a9464ac8f74253886ca7fea16a5e00f74bb71f520","unit:a962a84b2b5c9738a9358402fd2e46b3a4ef62c6135e882d57e2fe12fb549f0b","unit:b302e962d78c38c66e4c7b6b748fceb724c9457299310651bfa90dc64ce4190a","unit:b727527c22fb134515ff61f5f0a793913ec36d22379bdd76432303fe145949a7","unit:c47ca7f258250dae23aff5b4f95363c103c637b2d169d4250b7e5b38f757c38b","unit:c48b8d358480f7b6731d6054b57c95c3f840c26ab31555c1d80951e9bee0b52c","unit:cbf855f1b6005dcad3a8634ba4e3ab53846a4fcc354c30594b3b3999f3d24ab1","unit:d0c56ac28a3609c88e7828f20e1ce41644f10c23c517ab645474136a75674a09","unit:d3aff5cf4cf96dbe73f9170fef86c79c9da08b5cd1cbff884d1413ba2b8b1e0e","unit:e070c63df767c836b99861d8dc4ed56fcdd5a6e88849cd5c40741e4c5a388bdf","unit:e23b734e137f1efecdc44e8f0fea7fbce930d941a61c4aab783cb2c15174d6c1"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bba36bc033378532477245d8"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:f67aeb5903b00b029ceb684d","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge:link:13","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f","parent-native:challenge:8ffabc85492363a1042777c2"],"originalNativeType":"comparison","challengeReason":"Framework-dependent EFT restrictions provide access to the difference between scoped admissibility tests and proposed universal criteria.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the framework-dependent EFT question to distinguish source-specific restrictions from proposed universal criteria.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bba36bc033378532477245d8"},{"ref":"c1","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bba36bc033378532477245d8"},{"ref":"c1","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a3765c49038bc6b3111caf2e08467002b2fcc2084dcaaac8d14960717d5c400b","reply.jsonSha256":"e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f061aac7d257291628983cde729c905a9651af003","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ebb5757ecf5a957044b601f6ba4376f4008a1e752d3720d27d5d71ae866d41d4","receipt.jsonSha256":"7a27fe1a900d63d74b05a8c0cf1682742699185af92ae8c001e228b87c91b6bb","normalization.jsonSha256":"43596ae0b2eedfd65c33d536027b49a8c56401a5ac877ac312b1a09631b0d56b","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"d76e0f371e96e8d8830817b4b83e68fec13a898aad312b3f471eb0b3f8973e5b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d51409d65247fce6a82e7e9d8dda3d3dd170ef1b9db83a82d79ae792d987158a","reply.jsonSha256":"8ffabc85492363a1042777c2890ebeeff499c7b7e5148106f70715faa37ffccb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f07a76bd9b31f4d9ce7338403d6cece7206abaf40883fb612cc8116f28144bfc","receipt.jsonSha256":"233d8c48e611b73259e2a2e62830ffcae990817ec0da4d00f41b3e5e955ee55f","normalization.jsonSha256":"01aeea66d8e2d6b41f9aa9dc86b5fa5e4374e983ca64e90998801c5d5a22f4f9"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"comparison","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"comparison","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:f67aeb5903b00b029ceb684d","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:dc85080cbb6a710debb92a3e":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:dc85080cbb6a710debb92a3e","source":"q025-candidate-region:e80b9bd29294a1e014919731","target":"q025-candidate-question:c8f35deffa4a53b237ad4c9a","type":"comparison","title":"Limits on local completion and trans-Planckian access","rationale":"Retain challenges to local completion and alternative trans-Planckian mechanisms without imposing a common ultraviolet endpoint.","qualification":"Retain challenges to local completion and alternative trans-Planckian mechanisms without assuming a common ultraviolet endpoint.","evidenceIds":["unit:1e4ce119c5b5574cabf7868cf5c6f902ae6f5fbc0af95a6621615806f0818a45","unit:4a336e5f001aafce410a2dbc60873e1eae325468c4105f79234b371ce31e7c97","unit:584f854e3761f7e0477cb6fbea2b42a73e92b5b3e1c25c4150cc5a83db0f6bdc","unit:5a41609e35f42a1db6b76d48232d1a402aff85b205c4da7861f9497025f71868","unit:a962a84b2b5c9738a9358402fd2e46b3a4ef62c6135e882d57e2fe12fb549f0b","unit:b9727b497eb2c8ee4f188290a4557928a0e78fff0bc70d827ec654cd153a047f","unit:cbf855f1b6005dcad3a8634ba4e3ab53846a4fcc354c30594b3b3999f3d24ab1","unit:d3aff5cf4cf96dbe73f9170fef86c79c9da08b5cd1cbff884d1413ba2b8b1e0e","unit:f6ef5a553715cf402c36e9c967ad8769478206198c6ab52024b64173f8e8a212"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c8f35deffa4a53b237ad4c9a"},{"localRef":"c0","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:dc85080cbb6a710debb92a3e","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge:link:14","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f","parent-native:challenge:8ffabc85492363a1042777c2"],"originalNativeType":"comparison","challengeReason":"Retain challenges to local completion and alternative trans-Planckian mechanisms without imposing a common ultraviolet endpoint.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Retain challenges to local completion and alternative trans-Planckian mechanisms without assuming a common ultraviolet endpoint.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c8f35deffa4a53b237ad4c9a"},{"ref":"c0","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c8f35deffa4a53b237ad4c9a"},{"ref":"c0","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a3765c49038bc6b3111caf2e08467002b2fcc2084dcaaac8d14960717d5c400b","reply.jsonSha256":"e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f061aac7d257291628983cde729c905a9651af003","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ebb5757ecf5a957044b601f6ba4376f4008a1e752d3720d27d5d71ae866d41d4","receipt.jsonSha256":"7a27fe1a900d63d74b05a8c0cf1682742699185af92ae8c001e228b87c91b6bb","normalization.jsonSha256":"43596ae0b2eedfd65c33d536027b49a8c56401a5ac877ac312b1a09631b0d56b","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"d76e0f371e96e8d8830817b4b83e68fec13a898aad312b3f471eb0b3f8973e5b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d51409d65247fce6a82e7e9d8dda3d3dd170ef1b9db83a82d79ae792d987158a","reply.jsonSha256":"8ffabc85492363a1042777c2890ebeeff499c7b7e5148106f70715faa37ffccb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f07a76bd9b31f4d9ce7338403d6cece7206abaf40883fb612cc8116f28144bfc","receipt.jsonSha256":"233d8c48e611b73259e2a2e62830ffcae990817ec0da4d00f41b3e5e955ee55f","normalization.jsonSha256":"01aeea66d8e2d6b41f9aa9dc86b5fa5e4374e983ca64e90998801c5d5a22f4f9"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"comparison","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"comparison","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:dc85080cbb6a710debb92a3e","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:3e0486a9f1cddc4ccec74839":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:3e0486a9f1cddc4ccec74839","source":"q025-candidate-region:e80b9bd29294a1e014919731","target":"q025-candidate-question:da759331e3d3f6fd1ac62525","type":"narrower","title":"Matter spectra and coupling constraints","rationale":"Reuse the matter-spectrum and coupling question for compatibility, ultraviolet trajectories and conditional infrared restrictions.","qualification":"Reuse the matter-spectrum and coupling question for compatibility, ultraviolet trajectories and conditional infrared restrictions.","evidenceIds":["unit:0ef4a8e654cd9436af39f7d4c98915d51deab48538fd1526ac59e366d0bdf096","unit:22fed2b3c5c298ac35da0c3d057621f0fde6ed3a435810cb14f03fac35837b92","unit:314b653507601be94b85991853af1ddc66079bfbebdedbc7324b0339b0615085","unit:4a336e5f001aafce410a2dbc60873e1eae325468c4105f79234b371ce31e7c97","unit:5445f3d937900ef1fe5e2ea054ead0f28064c7bc9f63343e1d63015dc508f707","unit:584f854e3761f7e0477cb6fbea2b42a73e92b5b3e1c25c4150cc5a83db0f6bdc","unit:632794421d0745f6aed5fec6d2a901d984de8015e34ef7baab547fdeda6eb04f","unit:80672dccb388af936d46d7e4a9f368056d2005e0cd05b8d6bd2cd4ec5c82315d","unit:9e323f468816f3aeb0eb0cdc7a0828e6bffaa1ed69be2389efbb91a36a9ec56e","unit:a962a84b2b5c9738a9358402fd2e46b3a4ef62c6135e882d57e2fe12fb549f0b","unit:b727527c22fb134515ff61f5f0a793913ec36d22379bdd76432303fe145949a7","unit:c9889f3195757c16bbd3cd89e02931649e2d81b94c96c269207b46cb6aeaf891","unit:cbf855f1b6005dcad3a8634ba4e3ab53846a4fcc354c30594b3b3999f3d24ab1","unit:ccd14468ea64ece62729b09e6caa3b5785fadaf15afa6c2a684e227469c3ea71","unit:d0c56ac28a3609c88e7828f20e1ce41644f10c23c517ab645474136a75674a09","unit:d1a2306cf457ace47800c67ccf65b74a90a27698da87e5aaca01f7a9cb00d66d","unit:d3aff5cf4cf96dbe73f9170fef86c79c9da08b5cd1cbff884d1413ba2b8b1e0e","unit:d7b1e9fe57c3b466bf93133c4919f23f4a927b8ad1359e3533f7eb58b560f653","unit:dd0662b311c3a0bc9edbd95b033181851a63c900975f2fd8b2c9618f52c0c584"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da759331e3d3f6fd1ac62525"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1709.07252","sourceId":"ev:418a1057e20ff16fe8e5c0d74ffd68b6","sourceSha256":"de86f36a13f063b46f6a5a8c0bb7276f3a19522f5a2ba45a539ed7e26c7d1ee8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/14312e3db6c44e3df48e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"31a24c0fd414b7cf6a6ac89ddcd9a31aa0b987fc9addf5b6b9a16e67785d083d","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"730b319b6d28847e7e4b0cb219ead2c9fd706e78155fd49125bf3aa1e119e10f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"1709.07252","sourceId":"ev:44f1a5c7b4d4b564e96c5c067759f5ab","sourceSha256":"de86f36a13f063b46f6a5a8c0bb7276f3a19522f5a2ba45a539ed7e26c7d1ee8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/14312e3db6c44e3df48e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"31a24c0fd414b7cf6a6ac89ddcd9a31aa0b987fc9addf5b6b9a16e67785d083d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1257,"textSha256":"c10e0f241da4a5c4db2a8e3651eeffa7ad26cf8760e7036377bdb426e7490494","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1510.07018","sourceId":"ev:49117c10f7d69c2364365c9cbefef907","sourceSha256":"aaa538560d21d9a3e08c73c9ace36bfe25cff4e88fba2187e3daf97a8211d363","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2beec444aa291b6ab4d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e70d00a524e435140225b0d9a165a1989e2e1ed644ee9530f5db7da2f6589df9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"50c6ec52ae119aace3956e53eb96309262227be8cb6e4958ade84acc77bb63ef","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:3e0486a9f1cddc4ccec74839","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge:link:9","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f","parent-native:challenge:8ffabc85492363a1042777c2"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse the matter-spectrum and coupling question for compatibility, ultraviolet trajectories and conditional infrared restrictions.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the matter-spectrum and coupling question for compatibility, ultraviolet trajectories and conditional infrared restrictions.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da759331e3d3f6fd1ac62525"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1709.07252","sourceId":"ev:418a1057e20ff16fe8e5c0d74ffd68b6","sourceSha256":"de86f36a13f063b46f6a5a8c0bb7276f3a19522f5a2ba45a539ed7e26c7d1ee8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/14312e3db6c44e3df48e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"31a24c0fd414b7cf6a6ac89ddcd9a31aa0b987fc9addf5b6b9a16e67785d083d","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"730b319b6d28847e7e4b0cb219ead2c9fd706e78155fd49125bf3aa1e119e10f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"1709.07252","sourceId":"ev:44f1a5c7b4d4b564e96c5c067759f5ab","sourceSha256":"de86f36a13f063b46f6a5a8c0bb7276f3a19522f5a2ba45a539ed7e26c7d1ee8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/14312e3db6c44e3df48e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"31a24c0fd414b7cf6a6ac89ddcd9a31aa0b987fc9addf5b6b9a16e67785d083d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1257,"textSha256":"c10e0f241da4a5c4db2a8e3651eeffa7ad26cf8760e7036377bdb426e7490494","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1510.07018","sourceId":"ev:49117c10f7d69c2364365c9cbefef907","sourceSha256":"aaa538560d21d9a3e08c73c9ace36bfe25cff4e88fba2187e3daf97a8211d363","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2beec444aa291b6ab4d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e70d00a524e435140225b0d9a165a1989e2e1ed644ee9530f5db7da2f6589df9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"50c6ec52ae119aace3956e53eb96309262227be8cb6e4958ade84acc77bb63ef","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da759331e3d3f6fd1ac62525"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1709.07252","sourceId":"ev:418a1057e20ff16fe8e5c0d74ffd68b6","sourceSha256":"de86f36a13f063b46f6a5a8c0bb7276f3a19522f5a2ba45a539ed7e26c7d1ee8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/14312e3db6c44e3df48e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"31a24c0fd414b7cf6a6ac89ddcd9a31aa0b987fc9addf5b6b9a16e67785d083d","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"730b319b6d28847e7e4b0cb219ead2c9fd706e78155fd49125bf3aa1e119e10f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"1709.07252","sourceId":"ev:44f1a5c7b4d4b564e96c5c067759f5ab","sourceSha256":"de86f36a13f063b46f6a5a8c0bb7276f3a19522f5a2ba45a539ed7e26c7d1ee8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/14312e3db6c44e3df48e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"31a24c0fd414b7cf6a6ac89ddcd9a31aa0b987fc9addf5b6b9a16e67785d083d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1257,"textSha256":"c10e0f241da4a5c4db2a8e3651eeffa7ad26cf8760e7036377bdb426e7490494","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1510.07018","sourceId":"ev:49117c10f7d69c2364365c9cbefef907","sourceSha256":"aaa538560d21d9a3e08c73c9ace36bfe25cff4e88fba2187e3daf97a8211d363","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2beec444aa291b6ab4d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e70d00a524e435140225b0d9a165a1989e2e1ed644ee9530f5db7da2f6589df9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"50c6ec52ae119aace3956e53eb96309262227be8cb6e4958ade84acc77bb63ef","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a3765c49038bc6b3111caf2e08467002b2fcc2084dcaaac8d14960717d5c400b","reply.jsonSha256":"e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f061aac7d257291628983cde729c905a9651af003","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ebb5757ecf5a957044b601f6ba4376f4008a1e752d3720d27d5d71ae866d41d4","receipt.jsonSha256":"7a27fe1a900d63d74b05a8c0cf1682742699185af92ae8c001e228b87c91b6bb","normalization.jsonSha256":"43596ae0b2eedfd65c33d536027b49a8c56401a5ac877ac312b1a09631b0d56b","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"d76e0f371e96e8d8830817b4b83e68fec13a898aad312b3f471eb0b3f8973e5b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d51409d65247fce6a82e7e9d8dda3d3dd170ef1b9db83a82d79ae792d987158a","reply.jsonSha256":"8ffabc85492363a1042777c2890ebeeff499c7b7e5148106f70715faa37ffccb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f07a76bd9b31f4d9ce7338403d6cece7206abaf40883fb612cc8116f28144bfc","receipt.jsonSha256":"233d8c48e611b73259e2a2e62830ffcae990817ec0da4d00f41b3e5e955ee55f","normalization.jsonSha256":"01aeea66d8e2d6b41f9aa9dc86b5fa5e4374e983ca64e90998801c5d5a22f4f9"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:3e0486a9f1cddc4ccec74839","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:640c04b95f2c1894dcb4c832":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:640c04b95f2c1894dcb4c832","source":"q025-candidate-region:e80b9bd29294a1e014919731","target":"q025-candidate-question:eb2478896feb325e5b5d4f70","type":"narrower","title":"Covariant gravitational QFT constructions","rationale":"Reuse the covariant action-and-quantization question for perturbative ultraviolet constructions.","qualification":"Reuse the action-and-quantization question for covariant perturbative ultraviolet constructions.","evidenceIds":["unit:0a98fd0db0d72af5fa86ff7aa484a48b124d9022e420f664805498bd2d3bbe06","unit:17178cf81544083eb02fd8c7883aba719aa0de132be35e031bbca4dee550363b","unit:1c4281f5eb5bd71745c34df6c7a41d2c8f113de2990736e8f11e7ee2e276a812","unit:1e4ce119c5b5574cabf7868cf5c6f902ae6f5fbc0af95a6621615806f0818a45","unit:2309f6d3e3f0448dba4735a8520eec68dc4610fc82090a9929e910f9e785ba0b","unit:2554d2a530e401b54daf2fd304f3eea5bba427fd4cc3f3de53a1d858eca64386","unit:28c1982a855da4660b4fba9cec512860c482cd0db14eb8b89077216cd518c8e3","unit:35f91f34e3afd4585b979a81f8a30d794a5ed8f89c69f1f418489ef2f68d2a82","unit:4100a808223e86f7fe92db83fdc7d8ed8193473730361fe40d19239655b3470b","unit:4a336e5f001aafce410a2dbc60873e1eae325468c4105f79234b371ce31e7c97","unit:4b3882e1411852598154ba974441a6cd8de48e1f5e297149fd2c14123040de02","unit:54d3039a43043c5694fce618d3ba36ba440a7b8bf22e77e66cd036abc67e9230","unit:57fa9f28b6c23d6eb934076c17fadf9c04586f8bb840097a395d063f23b4c557","unit:584f854e3761f7e0477cb6fbea2b42a73e92b5b3e1c25c4150cc5a83db0f6bdc","unit:5a41609e35f42a1db6b76d48232d1a402aff85b205c4da7861f9497025f71868","unit:8c37f2d4b038dca2fbe07cf9b911b096a1c06f2ae7608899793355d63a02ff49","unit:a21e336359b2bb041842a3cb950d22729788c8a2671eb6576db2a5543650c571","unit:a423ce9107108f4ae1c7ef629292195bb7639061ed61cfea5c298b62cad8d356","unit:a962a84b2b5c9738a9358402fd2e46b3a4ef62c6135e882d57e2fe12fb549f0b","unit:b2552ad68a61b8792bcf65c8e89410684d1b5a600a5f0a4656ae5d737e488a00","unit:c6d305de0957315f2787d07e2eb94c3072f8c6f3120a41b623c609509c7c9940","unit:cbf855f1b6005dcad3a8634ba4e3ab53846a4fcc354c30594b3b3999f3d24ab1","unit:d29d449e77ffc1182aa86093ac6c53848d2649a20d9980f470cd30d27bdb91ce","unit:d3aff5cf4cf96dbe73f9170fef86c79c9da08b5cd1cbff884d1413ba2b8b1e0e","unit:dae76ae94309bae4bebbc7035e9109d7924bec0ba6c7734b14fb424fee1a9684","unit:e8614ca0239bcdc27860d1d8ba0187b72e45be841248e2c02ec14b4dbde3712c","unit:eb93db065d33b732f71a3fdc49979280cdf9df1e86c76748540d8f4c6e895aa2","unit:ee474e97ab016a3dc29f8067508ce63c0b8d347bbc634d64bcf97b1825539729","unit:fa63fce87bbfc9e1e32d4804fdc924ac0fd6926177dbc33cc1f7fbf07a7104ed"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:eb2478896feb325e5b5d4f70"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"1808.09015","sourceId":"ev:34d0b072d723e0bbc3dc801eb79b5f24","sourceSha256":"3137920b093435ff10622a9c57a1168300d45f069296f83cd7359fc3b9280a0e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525be94a52a7d517f861/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"26de8ecb19a03dbf722df3cef4a87a1664328bfdbf3bf1cebafa780843ca8e95","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2932,"textSha256":"69bc496adf49138b535ab13e00e80e0929c2df8112f4768fa25eef9be3e754f0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9510140","sourceId":"ev:7a621363369d477fb245cec4f3598721","sourceSha256":"766c6b34f7004d7e26a43fd7f47825edd9423e5d4e09187cbe1ecca36f0670be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4dc04279bcd54d996a09/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e9c5818f1b6186d675f7e2c60305098c4af0aea02d60a5301a54316f5ece440","pdfPage":9,"start":102,"end":2652,"textSha256":"8abd8aab64dbe9686f33c3bd03f7460af0515eade60d84de36e81a30c2166f32","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:640c04b95f2c1894dcb4c832","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge:link:5","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f","parent-native:challenge:8ffabc85492363a1042777c2"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse the covariant action-and-quantization question for perturbative ultraviolet constructions.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the action-and-quantization question for covariant perturbative ultraviolet constructions.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:eb2478896feb325e5b5d4f70"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"1808.09015","sourceId":"ev:34d0b072d723e0bbc3dc801eb79b5f24","sourceSha256":"3137920b093435ff10622a9c57a1168300d45f069296f83cd7359fc3b9280a0e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525be94a52a7d517f861/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"26de8ecb19a03dbf722df3cef4a87a1664328bfdbf3bf1cebafa780843ca8e95","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2932,"textSha256":"69bc496adf49138b535ab13e00e80e0929c2df8112f4768fa25eef9be3e754f0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9510140","sourceId":"ev:7a621363369d477fb245cec4f3598721","sourceSha256":"766c6b34f7004d7e26a43fd7f47825edd9423e5d4e09187cbe1ecca36f0670be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4dc04279bcd54d996a09/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e9c5818f1b6186d675f7e2c60305098c4af0aea02d60a5301a54316f5ece440","pdfPage":9,"start":102,"end":2652,"textSha256":"8abd8aab64dbe9686f33c3bd03f7460af0515eade60d84de36e81a30c2166f32","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:eb2478896feb325e5b5d4f70"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"1808.09015","sourceId":"ev:34d0b072d723e0bbc3dc801eb79b5f24","sourceSha256":"3137920b093435ff10622a9c57a1168300d45f069296f83cd7359fc3b9280a0e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525be94a52a7d517f861/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"26de8ecb19a03dbf722df3cef4a87a1664328bfdbf3bf1cebafa780843ca8e95","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2932,"textSha256":"69bc496adf49138b535ab13e00e80e0929c2df8112f4768fa25eef9be3e754f0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9510140","sourceId":"ev:7a621363369d477fb245cec4f3598721","sourceSha256":"766c6b34f7004d7e26a43fd7f47825edd9423e5d4e09187cbe1ecca36f0670be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4dc04279bcd54d996a09/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e9c5818f1b6186d675f7e2c60305098c4af0aea02d60a5301a54316f5ece440","pdfPage":9,"start":102,"end":2652,"textSha256":"8abd8aab64dbe9686f33c3bd03f7460af0515eade60d84de36e81a30c2166f32","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a3765c49038bc6b3111caf2e08467002b2fcc2084dcaaac8d14960717d5c400b","reply.jsonSha256":"e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f061aac7d257291628983cde729c905a9651af003","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ebb5757ecf5a957044b601f6ba4376f4008a1e752d3720d27d5d71ae866d41d4","receipt.jsonSha256":"7a27fe1a900d63d74b05a8c0cf1682742699185af92ae8c001e228b87c91b6bb","normalization.jsonSha256":"43596ae0b2eedfd65c33d536027b49a8c56401a5ac877ac312b1a09631b0d56b","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"d76e0f371e96e8d8830817b4b83e68fec13a898aad312b3f471eb0b3f8973e5b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d51409d65247fce6a82e7e9d8dda3d3dd170ef1b9db83a82d79ae792d987158a","reply.jsonSha256":"8ffabc85492363a1042777c2890ebeeff499c7b7e5148106f70715faa37ffccb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f07a76bd9b31f4d9ce7338403d6cece7206abaf40883fb612cc8116f28144bfc","receipt.jsonSha256":"233d8c48e611b73259e2a2e62830ffcae990817ec0da4d00f41b3e5e955ee55f","normalization.jsonSha256":"01aeea66d8e2d6b41f9aa9dc86b5fa5e4374e983ca64e90998801c5d5a22f4f9"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:640c04b95f2c1894dcb4c832","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:3aac2e11987d9e4ab9238045":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:3aac2e11987d9e4ab9238045","source":"q025-candidate-region:e80b9bd29294a1e014919731","target":"q025-candidate-question:ff6ccd979cd7d5f714011965","type":"narrower","title":"Dynamical chiral breaking and light fermions","rationale":"Dynamical chiral breaking and fermion lightness require a distinct test beyond generic matter fixed-point existence.","qualification":"Give dynamical chiral breaking and fermion lightness their own direct target rather than reducing them to generic matter fixed-point existence.","evidenceIds":["unit:4a336e5f001aafce410a2dbc60873e1eae325468c4105f79234b371ce31e7c97","unit:55b6408fa6c151d1d4c345bfc38f8146ce589e217ed0f72d0b42ef160d70fac8","unit:584f854e3761f7e0477cb6fbea2b42a73e92b5b3e1c25c4150cc5a83db0f6bdc","unit:5d6fe11efb299aa6d475973d02a91a8d972816166e4fec8c09c5d5f49c32026e","unit:a962a84b2b5c9738a9358402fd2e46b3a4ef62c6135e882d57e2fe12fb549f0b","unit:cbf855f1b6005dcad3a8634ba4e3ab53846a4fcc354c30594b3b3999f3d24ab1","unit:d3aff5cf4cf96dbe73f9170fef86c79c9da08b5cd1cbff884d1413ba2b8b1e0e","unit:f098d122ba358c8b3a878dbc7297a825affac135e9193d40a221419a8a3048ca"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ff6ccd979cd7d5f714011965"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"1104.5366","sourceId":"ev:42fc1ef5555e7871f2433e96be169c16","sourceSha256":"6e0fbe8549ccb3962713784c42629900ca5d4e302feb00c2360784acc790111b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9f6f98a151ecdcb06a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e3773ed0f46ddac1f1aa80e15e1f2837a0650ca6b3d6054dbb9d0984259bf9d","pdfPage":1,"start":1292,"end":4691,"textSha256":"5783934d418e6e784ad777fca23ed7c282f2ea2ecef8b923560f2ac0ebcb6de6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"1104.5366","sourceId":"ev:8d6d410b1d50f0b96c3222b058b49b59","sourceSha256":"6e0fbe8549ccb3962713784c42629900ca5d4e302feb00c2360784acc790111b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9f6f98a151ecdcb06a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e3773ed0f46ddac1f1aa80e15e1f2837a0650ca6b3d6054dbb9d0984259bf9d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c3a06bc1b30ec7745d2e0e1e44ab0422e99a3cb080e3fc29aa7fd8ac995ed236","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"1104.5366","sourceId":"ev:b098678a52bf03bb34608bf977a34cc8","sourceSha256":"6e0fbe8549ccb3962713784c42629900ca5d4e302feb00c2360784acc790111b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9f6f98a151ecdcb06a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e3773ed0f46ddac1f1aa80e15e1f2837a0650ca6b3d6054dbb9d0984259bf9d","pdfPage":1,"start":2492,"end":5719,"textSha256":"4ccc054ca5a0c14f294e224aed26df9e283e2c06f306546cb9a635efade663a2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:3aac2e11987d9e4ab9238045","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge:link:10","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f","parent-native:challenge:8ffabc85492363a1042777c2"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Dynamical chiral breaking and fermion lightness require a distinct test beyond generic matter fixed-point existence.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Give dynamical chiral breaking and fermion lightness their own direct target rather than reducing them to generic matter fixed-point existence.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ff6ccd979cd7d5f714011965"},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"1104.5366","sourceId":"ev:42fc1ef5555e7871f2433e96be169c16","sourceSha256":"6e0fbe8549ccb3962713784c42629900ca5d4e302feb00c2360784acc790111b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9f6f98a151ecdcb06a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e3773ed0f46ddac1f1aa80e15e1f2837a0650ca6b3d6054dbb9d0984259bf9d","pdfPage":1,"start":1292,"end":4691,"textSha256":"5783934d418e6e784ad777fca23ed7c282f2ea2ecef8b923560f2ac0ebcb6de6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"1104.5366","sourceId":"ev:8d6d410b1d50f0b96c3222b058b49b59","sourceSha256":"6e0fbe8549ccb3962713784c42629900ca5d4e302feb00c2360784acc790111b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9f6f98a151ecdcb06a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e3773ed0f46ddac1f1aa80e15e1f2837a0650ca6b3d6054dbb9d0984259bf9d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c3a06bc1b30ec7745d2e0e1e44ab0422e99a3cb080e3fc29aa7fd8ac995ed236","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"1104.5366","sourceId":"ev:b098678a52bf03bb34608bf977a34cc8","sourceSha256":"6e0fbe8549ccb3962713784c42629900ca5d4e302feb00c2360784acc790111b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9f6f98a151ecdcb06a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e3773ed0f46ddac1f1aa80e15e1f2837a0650ca6b3d6054dbb9d0984259bf9d","pdfPage":1,"start":2492,"end":5719,"textSha256":"4ccc054ca5a0c14f294e224aed26df9e283e2c06f306546cb9a635efade663a2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ff6ccd979cd7d5f714011965"},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"1104.5366","sourceId":"ev:42fc1ef5555e7871f2433e96be169c16","sourceSha256":"6e0fbe8549ccb3962713784c42629900ca5d4e302feb00c2360784acc790111b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9f6f98a151ecdcb06a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e3773ed0f46ddac1f1aa80e15e1f2837a0650ca6b3d6054dbb9d0984259bf9d","pdfPage":1,"start":1292,"end":4691,"textSha256":"5783934d418e6e784ad777fca23ed7c282f2ea2ecef8b923560f2ac0ebcb6de6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"1104.5366","sourceId":"ev:8d6d410b1d50f0b96c3222b058b49b59","sourceSha256":"6e0fbe8549ccb3962713784c42629900ca5d4e302feb00c2360784acc790111b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9f6f98a151ecdcb06a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e3773ed0f46ddac1f1aa80e15e1f2837a0650ca6b3d6054dbb9d0984259bf9d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c3a06bc1b30ec7745d2e0e1e44ab0422e99a3cb080e3fc29aa7fd8ac995ed236","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"1104.5366","sourceId":"ev:b098678a52bf03bb34608bf977a34cc8","sourceSha256":"6e0fbe8549ccb3962713784c42629900ca5d4e302feb00c2360784acc790111b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c9f6f98a151ecdcb06a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e3773ed0f46ddac1f1aa80e15e1f2837a0650ca6b3d6054dbb9d0984259bf9d","pdfPage":1,"start":2492,"end":5719,"textSha256":"4ccc054ca5a0c14f294e224aed26df9e283e2c06f306546cb9a635efade663a2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a3765c49038bc6b3111caf2e08467002b2fcc2084dcaaac8d14960717d5c400b","reply.jsonSha256":"e0f4d0291de2b094d45c4d7f061aac7d257291628983cde729c905a9651af003","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ebb5757ecf5a957044b601f6ba4376f4008a1e752d3720d27d5d71ae866d41d4","receipt.jsonSha256":"7a27fe1a900d63d74b05a8c0cf1682742699185af92ae8c001e228b87c91b6bb","normalization.jsonSha256":"43596ae0b2eedfd65c33d536027b49a8c56401a5ac877ac312b1a09631b0d56b","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"d76e0f371e96e8d8830817b4b83e68fec13a898aad312b3f471eb0b3f8973e5b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-8faef27ce1cad100b7fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d51409d65247fce6a82e7e9d8dda3d3dd170ef1b9db83a82d79ae792d987158a","reply.jsonSha256":"8ffabc85492363a1042777c2890ebeeff499c7b7e5148106f70715faa37ffccb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f07a76bd9b31f4d9ce7338403d6cece7206abaf40883fb612cc8116f28144bfc","receipt.jsonSha256":"233d8c48e611b73259e2a2e62830ffcae990817ec0da4d00f41b3e5e955ee55f","normalization.jsonSha256":"01aeea66d8e2d6b41f9aa9dc86b5fa5e4374e983ca64e90998801c5d5a22f4f9"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:3aac2e11987d9e4ab9238045","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:b91bfed4c77e74a9594f6f78":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:b91bfed4c77e74a9594f6f78","source":"q025-candidate-region:e8d76d9907161eb0534206f7","target":"q025-candidate-question:674aafcb45db8090fc96bf44","type":"narrower","title":"Horizonless BPS geometries and throat structure","rationale":"Horizonless construction and throat structure provide a geometric target distinct from a completed entropy count.","qualification":"Reuse horizonless construction and throat structure as a geometric target separate from entropy counting.","evidenceIds":["unit:143466b9c2dc1ac90c1dcc5eab875b9ee7bd867f2cd9fd85246726d1071431ce","unit:3f2f69fb8c668fddeaa76a883c972d513a7bc718c04789617a6519df5e91adb0","unit:4157b87f10a4c44adfecec19618b2b92affecec6ea52e24b488b9ff19293048d","unit:4ef40fc75357132f351e7b8958adb569e5803344fef42b39053c139088d8bbed","unit:8753b59c55475c3451c34ea7de444f624d9f1286a14bae7cc076dfea08ee3c6c","unit:9310e7bbf90b447ff4cf5211763289e4371676a39f5717b35643c13de853648d","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:bdb72f9bd07de83cf2e69fab9965b91e776fda276ccb25f06e2fd8430cc99234","unit:cceaa3bfcc201207993f4ea13cdf3e0b51d16dd54831a1207e883fec12ff0214","unit:df7475646db43f4f4853741aacbb5d06f91a3328bd2ec383e6daf98635f9cf76"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:674aafcb45db8090fc96bf44"},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0604110","sourceId":"ev:acfd0e85e368ce17f62a6ccf869eacc0","sourceSha256":"7d29aea68a71dec593c540a2cc2f90e863ba16f206b8615a3dce6ef51bb07570","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9565148736e40c094c11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a6bad354fd02c32f3c0a06386e0895f294cd2e94f15849ee49eb94dbcb171624","pdfPage":2,"start":97,"end":2796,"textSha256":"1fc575275ee5e06e5b5d340af274c1e906ed114506d2179a85f5a485792faee0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0604110","sourceId":"ev:fb60a414fa003bd8467ec4f139b3ad4c","sourceSha256":"7d29aea68a71dec593c540a2cc2f90e863ba16f206b8615a3dce6ef51bb07570","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9565148736e40c094c11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a6bad354fd02c32f3c0a06386e0895f294cd2e94f15849ee49eb94dbcb171624","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2354,"textSha256":"aa6a042d93d8161360ef92b3a61316469d2a3ab089c6e99dc1b9994934711b9b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:b91bfed4c77e74a9594f6f78","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge:link:7","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:ed0ddf2aa48827f39ee29f07","parent-native:challenge:3467d7c089ba60097d869d8a"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Horizonless construction and throat structure provide a geometric target distinct from a completed entropy count.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse horizonless construction and throat structure as a geometric target separate from entropy counting.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:674aafcb45db8090fc96bf44"},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0604110","sourceId":"ev:acfd0e85e368ce17f62a6ccf869eacc0","sourceSha256":"7d29aea68a71dec593c540a2cc2f90e863ba16f206b8615a3dce6ef51bb07570","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9565148736e40c094c11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a6bad354fd02c32f3c0a06386e0895f294cd2e94f15849ee49eb94dbcb171624","pdfPage":2,"start":97,"end":2796,"textSha256":"1fc575275ee5e06e5b5d340af274c1e906ed114506d2179a85f5a485792faee0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e15","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0604110","sourceId":"ev:fb60a414fa003bd8467ec4f139b3ad4c","sourceSha256":"7d29aea68a71dec593c540a2cc2f90e863ba16f206b8615a3dce6ef51bb07570","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9565148736e40c094c11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a6bad354fd02c32f3c0a06386e0895f294cd2e94f15849ee49eb94dbcb171624","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2354,"textSha256":"aa6a042d93d8161360ef92b3a61316469d2a3ab089c6e99dc1b9994934711b9b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:674aafcb45db8090fc96bf44"},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0604110","sourceId":"ev:acfd0e85e368ce17f62a6ccf869eacc0","sourceSha256":"7d29aea68a71dec593c540a2cc2f90e863ba16f206b8615a3dce6ef51bb07570","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9565148736e40c094c11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a6bad354fd02c32f3c0a06386e0895f294cd2e94f15849ee49eb94dbcb171624","pdfPage":2,"start":97,"end":2796,"textSha256":"1fc575275ee5e06e5b5d340af274c1e906ed114506d2179a85f5a485792faee0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e15","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0604110","sourceId":"ev:fb60a414fa003bd8467ec4f139b3ad4c","sourceSha256":"7d29aea68a71dec593c540a2cc2f90e863ba16f206b8615a3dce6ef51bb07570","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9565148736e40c094c11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a6bad354fd02c32f3c0a06386e0895f294cd2e94f15849ee49eb94dbcb171624","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2354,"textSha256":"aa6a042d93d8161360ef92b3a61316469d2a3ab089c6e99dc1b9994934711b9b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5cfa3fbc6230938417f752789e5b19629bea85493a107ce0a9edccfa8debf5ce","reply.jsonSha256":"ed0ddf2aa48827f39ee29f0738396b0de6c107c9a4e4f803262c2f3103860945","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f2184132d59aa6e5d2de7b3bd1b8e5e969f1538f58bfd809c690af54a0bff09e","receipt.jsonSha256":"da83a02e8e5d2e7920d535543a9de9c3a9a22870cd37251e6bcf32850800f7fc","normalization.jsonSha256":"2fd2f708d57b759c35b6f201499146945293785684776a91cceb503f43a72874","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6ce40753b78e58db08e049e9c1a6014b58905f4361e9dc27e04f147328f1a5bb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bc5c8121ee29c96d699bf39e479f9d07f30411182d1f9cc646afb0edfabadaff","reply.jsonSha256":"3467d7c089ba60097d869d8a855916e06138b64628659fd6f47b104ea9819116","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ac8f446c753c13e70c728faa83431989b9d0b5ff7dc04678079bde0c98a2de24","receipt.jsonSha256":"fb13edb637a6330cbcf3d41a89db0d1cb8d4e2d18bb9acb545e688ef7b37d2d8","normalization.jsonSha256":"cc105d678855ba283b2b06939fc7ce8cb8163aaad4ea7de3c0876311b34a3559"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:b91bfed4c77e74a9594f6f78","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:e94fdb4b89d24973d4e423d6":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:e94fdb4b89d24973d4e423d6","source":"q025-candidate-region:e8d76d9907161eb0534206f7","target":"q025-candidate-question:8a35446d8726f87aec13ccc4","type":"narrower","title":"Excitation spectra, relaxation and near-horizon limits","rationale":"Reuse the spectral and dynamical direction without identifying gaps, thermal decay and soft transitions.","qualification":"A shared spectral and dynamical direction connects existing questions without identifying gaps, decay or soft transitions.","evidenceIds":["unit:4ef40fc75357132f351e7b8958adb569e5803344fef42b39053c139088d8bbed","unit:8753b59c55475c3451c34ea7de444f624d9f1286a14bae7cc076dfea08ee3c6c","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:bdb72f9bd07de83cf2e69fab9965b91e776fda276ccb25f06e2fd8430cc99234","unit:cceaa3bfcc201207993f4ea13cdf3e0b51d16dd54831a1207e883fec12ff0214","unit:df7475646db43f4f4853741aacbb5d06f91a3328bd2ec383e6daf98635f9cf76"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9fcda24471df25aabf65a640"},{"localRef":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:749b5584857e7b52eeebdbe2"},{"localRef":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:26de1cebb3c55722cbb2a605"},{"localRef":"p0","kind":"prior_parent_question","sourceId":"q0"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:e94fdb4b89d24973d4e423d6","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge:link:9","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:ed0ddf2aa48827f39ee29f07","parent-native:challenge:3467d7c089ba60097d869d8a"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse the spectral and dynamical direction without identifying gaps, thermal decay and soft transitions.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"A shared spectral and dynamical direction connects existing questions without identifying gaps, decay or soft transitions.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9fcda24471df25aabf65a640"},{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:749b5584857e7b52eeebdbe2"},{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:26de1cebb3c55722cbb2a605"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"p0","kind":"prior_parent_question","sourceId":"q0"},{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9fcda24471df25aabf65a640"},{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:749b5584857e7b52eeebdbe2"},{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:26de1cebb3c55722cbb2a605"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5cfa3fbc6230938417f752789e5b19629bea85493a107ce0a9edccfa8debf5ce","reply.jsonSha256":"ed0ddf2aa48827f39ee29f0738396b0de6c107c9a4e4f803262c2f3103860945","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f2184132d59aa6e5d2de7b3bd1b8e5e969f1538f58bfd809c690af54a0bff09e","receipt.jsonSha256":"da83a02e8e5d2e7920d535543a9de9c3a9a22870cd37251e6bcf32850800f7fc","normalization.jsonSha256":"2fd2f708d57b759c35b6f201499146945293785684776a91cceb503f43a72874","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6ce40753b78e58db08e049e9c1a6014b58905f4361e9dc27e04f147328f1a5bb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bc5c8121ee29c96d699bf39e479f9d07f30411182d1f9cc646afb0edfabadaff","reply.jsonSha256":"3467d7c089ba60097d869d8a855916e06138b64628659fd6f47b104ea9819116","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ac8f446c753c13e70c728faa83431989b9d0b5ff7dc04678079bde0c98a2de24","receipt.jsonSha256":"fb13edb637a6330cbcf3d41a89db0d1cb8d4e2d18bb9acb545e688ef7b37d2d8","normalization.jsonSha256":"cc105d678855ba283b2b06939fc7ce8cb8163aaad4ea7de3c0876311b34a3559"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:e94fdb4b89d24973d4e423d6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:5350276ac518a1f5a1b4cb47":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:5350276ac518a1f5a1b4cb47","source":"q025-candidate-region:e8d76d9907161eb0534206f7","target":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2","type":"narrower","title":"Attractor geometry and extremal solutions","rationale":"Reuse the cross-setting attractor and extremal-solution question while preserving different bulk and boundary variables.","qualification":"Reuse the cross-setting attractor and extremal-solution direction, including its explicitly distinguished boundary realization.","evidenceIds":["unit:061875dcc30d1b8da4858ce9119fec3f0a0332c10d1297bfee281b823fb05617","unit:06f00059ec0527c30284350afc99332ed924cf941fc5c17c9bce0ae018029f52","unit:4ef40fc75357132f351e7b8958adb569e5803344fef42b39053c139088d8bbed","unit:8753b59c55475c3451c34ea7de444f624d9f1286a14bae7cc076dfea08ee3c6c","unit:9c32e248b69dfeda0dea51636dd14c04cc878d0b924c3dcc8b8a17a3c222600e","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:bdb72f9bd07de83cf2e69fab9965b91e776fda276ccb25f06e2fd8430cc99234","unit:c82868f2de6c8d5e337785d9510ab83df6b6a8189a9ea394153d0928002068ed","unit:cceaa3bfcc201207993f4ea13cdf3e0b51d16dd54831a1207e883fec12ff0214","unit:dab83aafc1ba7e84ce962d19c7fe7dbd6fb7b160a96a84d2896ead4067aeda35","unit:df7475646db43f4f4853741aacbb5d06f91a3328bd2ec383e6daf98635f9cf76"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9602136","sourceId":"ev:37bf7d4149a1a8843cd54fdaad51e9bb","sourceSha256":"f3f40420b8e1a5a84fe28502d610c10a206be0902ed1f2ea17690fc4f1427953","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8043b58cc8da05c51d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f473373d5c6d483eedddd072c080a47d2acb9c908cbbc0ceb796f5c201c0595a","pdfPage":2,"start":102,"end":3202,"textSha256":"11cde44e28313a16005b12f9484d1a2fbe3e4ee77e02efbf268cdf5ddd305b42","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"1712.01849","sourceId":"ev:74af606e3ba5a1f7e6d966aff540b0d3","sourceSha256":"241f249719a8375169f228b1172e770036bfb4186e6b5ac8452fe178e5479588","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/db15432027a2b33c427b/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6924498d4fb2583c003e28e73e539fca3c06951a8219d752372452d9144b438f","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3499,"textSha256":"0f2b28e505b520fbc25ee62903037664788dcb18a945eba30b6d0d7bb4f75de9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"1712.01849","sourceId":"ev:8151cab53c096a41a909dca5e25353cd","sourceSha256":"241f249719a8375169f228b1172e770036bfb4186e6b5ac8452fe178e5479588","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/db15432027a2b33c427b/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6924498d4fb2583c003e28e73e539fca3c06951a8219d752372452d9144b438f","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a2713a609f6f3ba55b8a447bc43c8fa770cefc9e9183262885ad935ba85df952","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:5350276ac518a1f5a1b4cb47","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge:link:6","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:ed0ddf2aa48827f39ee29f07","parent-native:challenge:3467d7c089ba60097d869d8a"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse the cross-setting attractor and extremal-solution question while preserving different bulk and boundary variables.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the cross-setting attractor and extremal-solution direction, including its explicitly distinguished boundary realization.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9602136","sourceId":"ev:37bf7d4149a1a8843cd54fdaad51e9bb","sourceSha256":"f3f40420b8e1a5a84fe28502d610c10a206be0902ed1f2ea17690fc4f1427953","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8043b58cc8da05c51d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f473373d5c6d483eedddd072c080a47d2acb9c908cbbc0ceb796f5c201c0595a","pdfPage":2,"start":102,"end":3202,"textSha256":"11cde44e28313a16005b12f9484d1a2fbe3e4ee77e02efbf268cdf5ddd305b42","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"1712.01849","sourceId":"ev:74af606e3ba5a1f7e6d966aff540b0d3","sourceSha256":"241f249719a8375169f228b1172e770036bfb4186e6b5ac8452fe178e5479588","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/db15432027a2b33c427b/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6924498d4fb2583c003e28e73e539fca3c06951a8219d752372452d9144b438f","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3499,"textSha256":"0f2b28e505b520fbc25ee62903037664788dcb18a945eba30b6d0d7bb4f75de9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"1712.01849","sourceId":"ev:8151cab53c096a41a909dca5e25353cd","sourceSha256":"241f249719a8375169f228b1172e770036bfb4186e6b5ac8452fe178e5479588","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/db15432027a2b33c427b/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6924498d4fb2583c003e28e73e539fca3c06951a8219d752372452d9144b438f","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a2713a609f6f3ba55b8a447bc43c8fa770cefc9e9183262885ad935ba85df952","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9602136","sourceId":"ev:37bf7d4149a1a8843cd54fdaad51e9bb","sourceSha256":"f3f40420b8e1a5a84fe28502d610c10a206be0902ed1f2ea17690fc4f1427953","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8043b58cc8da05c51d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f473373d5c6d483eedddd072c080a47d2acb9c908cbbc0ceb796f5c201c0595a","pdfPage":2,"start":102,"end":3202,"textSha256":"11cde44e28313a16005b12f9484d1a2fbe3e4ee77e02efbf268cdf5ddd305b42","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"1712.01849","sourceId":"ev:74af606e3ba5a1f7e6d966aff540b0d3","sourceSha256":"241f249719a8375169f228b1172e770036bfb4186e6b5ac8452fe178e5479588","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/db15432027a2b33c427b/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6924498d4fb2583c003e28e73e539fca3c06951a8219d752372452d9144b438f","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3499,"textSha256":"0f2b28e505b520fbc25ee62903037664788dcb18a945eba30b6d0d7bb4f75de9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5cfa3fbc6230938417f752789e5b19629bea85493a107ce0a9edccfa8debf5ce","reply.jsonSha256":"ed0ddf2aa48827f39ee29f0738396b0de6c107c9a4e4f803262c2f3103860945","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f2184132d59aa6e5d2de7b3bd1b8e5e969f1538f58bfd809c690af54a0bff09e","receipt.jsonSha256":"da83a02e8e5d2e7920d535543a9de9c3a9a22870cd37251e6bcf32850800f7fc","normalization.jsonSha256":"2fd2f708d57b759c35b6f201499146945293785684776a91cceb503f43a72874","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6ce40753b78e58db08e049e9c1a6014b58905f4361e9dc27e04f147328f1a5bb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bc5c8121ee29c96d699bf39e479f9d07f30411182d1f9cc646afb0edfabadaff","reply.jsonSha256":"3467d7c089ba60097d869d8a855916e06138b64628659fd6f47b104ea9819116","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ac8f446c753c13e70c728faa83431989b9d0b5ff7dc04678079bde0c98a2de24","receipt.jsonSha256":"fb13edb637a6330cbcf3d41a89db0d1cb8d4e2d18bb9acb545e688ef7b37d2d8","normalization.jsonSha256":"cc105d678855ba283b2b06939fc7ce8cb8163aaad4ea7de3c0876311b34a3559"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:5350276ac518a1f5a1b4cb47","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:a4979a026f57f44abb888fca":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:a4979a026f57f44abb888fca","source":"q025-candidate-region:e8d76d9907161eb0534206f7","target":"q025-candidate-question:a31754bfdb42eed547f22213","type":"narrower","title":"Quantum entropy corrections and EFT limits","rationale":"Reuse quantum corrections and EFT validity while retaining the source-specific loop and coupling prescriptions.","qualification":"Reuse the existing quantum-correction and EFT-limit direction, preserving different loop and coupling prescriptions.","evidenceIds":["unit:06f00059ec0527c30284350afc99332ed924cf941fc5c17c9bce0ae018029f52","unit:2be669014ca84fc8e35e163bd77c219f5fad9e0126442cf4ef7d60401e91c9b1","unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","unit:4ef40fc75357132f351e7b8958adb569e5803344fef42b39053c139088d8bbed","unit:8753b59c55475c3451c34ea7de444f624d9f1286a14bae7cc076dfea08ee3c6c","unit:8fb8681ed4c1713cb3f5958c5fe59b314fd128c7218c61f47882c58cfce2fade","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:bdb72f9bd07de83cf2e69fab9965b91e776fda276ccb25f06e2fd8430cc99234","unit:cceaa3bfcc201207993f4ea13cdf3e0b51d16dd54831a1207e883fec12ff0214","unit:df7475646db43f4f4853741aacbb5d06f91a3328bd2ec383e6daf98635f9cf76","unit:f009c07cff3302e24297f122f9b02532a01c1e3dbf2564b848ae94e80cbb4ddf"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a31754bfdb42eed547f22213"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:a4979a026f57f44abb888fca","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge:link:12","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:ed0ddf2aa48827f39ee29f07","parent-native:challenge:3467d7c089ba60097d869d8a"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse quantum corrections and EFT validity while retaining the source-specific loop and coupling prescriptions.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the existing quantum-correction and EFT-limit direction, preserving different loop and coupling prescriptions.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a31754bfdb42eed547f22213"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a31754bfdb42eed547f22213"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5cfa3fbc6230938417f752789e5b19629bea85493a107ce0a9edccfa8debf5ce","reply.jsonSha256":"ed0ddf2aa48827f39ee29f0738396b0de6c107c9a4e4f803262c2f3103860945","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f2184132d59aa6e5d2de7b3bd1b8e5e969f1538f58bfd809c690af54a0bff09e","receipt.jsonSha256":"da83a02e8e5d2e7920d535543a9de9c3a9a22870cd37251e6bcf32850800f7fc","normalization.jsonSha256":"2fd2f708d57b759c35b6f201499146945293785684776a91cceb503f43a72874","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6ce40753b78e58db08e049e9c1a6014b58905f4361e9dc27e04f147328f1a5bb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bc5c8121ee29c96d699bf39e479f9d07f30411182d1f9cc646afb0edfabadaff","reply.jsonSha256":"3467d7c089ba60097d869d8a855916e06138b64628659fd6f47b104ea9819116","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ac8f446c753c13e70c728faa83431989b9d0b5ff7dc04678079bde0c98a2de24","receipt.jsonSha256":"fb13edb637a6330cbcf3d41a89db0d1cb8d4e2d18bb9acb545e688ef7b37d2d8","normalization.jsonSha256":"cc105d678855ba283b2b06939fc7ce8cb8163aaad4ea7de3c0876311b34a3559"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:a4979a026f57f44abb888fca","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:1bf80fd0852734711e1da018":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:1bf80fd0852734711e1da018","source":"q025-candidate-region:e8d76d9907161eb0534206f7","target":"q025-candidate-question:e467a3835ad69a76fa663b52","type":"narrower","title":"Microscopic and near-horizon entropy accounts","rationale":"Reuse microscopic and near-horizon entropy accounts with their distinct precision, protection and counting assumptions.","qualification":"Reuse the existing microscopic and near-horizon entropy direction, retaining its precision and protection distinctions.","evidenceIds":["unit:0d082a81ec4e262e49c931c5c007ac577ec08c35a86cc3593e72ef81217470f0","unit:1367c8eb0a5ab835e3c592d086f23cde362d7d6909c80e47c9f0d683ec158ccc","unit:1a34ca3f06688a7d692f74d32abe7985815eb025eb117c6273b5d63f40c1538e","unit:291d21d2c5acb4efae5a7c56ff00b71ff03b9aee41070a14fdfee9e71de7aa44","unit:36d9465e586e7cb9e542b7e1575a3a639c59413d95a941316561144452beb744","unit:3a21df082b12193bd62c4225ad4386097f0e996e9249e043c8332aa1babe4d1f","unit:4ef40fc75357132f351e7b8958adb569e5803344fef42b39053c139088d8bbed","unit:76f6a3ded7beb243515dee32e8f3f5dae495350da26c777ee863e4a0834e31bd","unit:8753b59c55475c3451c34ea7de444f624d9f1286a14bae7cc076dfea08ee3c6c","unit:97e1c647951082bcdeda3f1608e4957de3bc59f682867c857970a6a52cbfb91a","unit:a37a4876c0cc579774c9a152a0ad1bb54c31dac45fd6d1b41eff0a396641d4b3","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:bdb72f9bd07de83cf2e69fab9965b91e776fda276ccb25f06e2fd8430cc99234","unit:bfa71a4b4a3bc531fe5ddbb7e20a18325571f39f1e2f59fe1995dbc7e40d715b","unit:cceaa3bfcc201207993f4ea13cdf3e0b51d16dd54831a1207e883fec12ff0214","unit:d0e8d0be5e21442b476bb15bcfac7f1fef16f79de6ee432e6a86adf60f48100f","unit:df7475646db43f4f4853741aacbb5d06f91a3328bd2ec383e6daf98635f9cf76"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e467a3835ad69a76fa663b52"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9309145","sourceId":"ev:0c82931dde6411fe79ba49569f55c9e8","sourceSha256":"4d95da2c496f90a43de153a0ab243af4d90e7183eb36d88fb25545fa03123927","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/76734be5b1acacba41a6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d1bd8d51de136c3af1a7616bf4ee322fd6c15b4a2528fd848d57e3c3cb446c98","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1685,"textSha256":"c9d5d1844dc7aa19c679654c44162318cce6e7dc756621d8540ed1f20fba1d75","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9309145","sourceId":"ev:4ffa1e002861416847041c95fe5cf290","sourceSha256":"4d95da2c496f90a43de153a0ab243af4d90e7183eb36d88fb25545fa03123927","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/76734be5b1acacba41a6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d1bd8d51de136c3af1a7616bf4ee322fd6c15b4a2528fd848d57e3c3cb446c98","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2731,"textSha256":"3cbe4e2efcc95d30cc8b205f7dd71034c3cbe7a62c581faaef1363d037d8583d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:1bf80fd0852734711e1da018","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge:link:5","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:ed0ddf2aa48827f39ee29f07","parent-native:challenge:3467d7c089ba60097d869d8a"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse microscopic and near-horizon entropy accounts with their distinct precision, protection and counting assumptions.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the existing microscopic and near-horizon entropy direction, retaining its precision and protection distinctions.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e467a3835ad69a76fa663b52"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9309145","sourceId":"ev:0c82931dde6411fe79ba49569f55c9e8","sourceSha256":"4d95da2c496f90a43de153a0ab243af4d90e7183eb36d88fb25545fa03123927","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/76734be5b1acacba41a6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d1bd8d51de136c3af1a7616bf4ee322fd6c15b4a2528fd848d57e3c3cb446c98","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1685,"textSha256":"c9d5d1844dc7aa19c679654c44162318cce6e7dc756621d8540ed1f20fba1d75","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9309145","sourceId":"ev:4ffa1e002861416847041c95fe5cf290","sourceSha256":"4d95da2c496f90a43de153a0ab243af4d90e7183eb36d88fb25545fa03123927","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/76734be5b1acacba41a6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d1bd8d51de136c3af1a7616bf4ee322fd6c15b4a2528fd848d57e3c3cb446c98","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2731,"textSha256":"3cbe4e2efcc95d30cc8b205f7dd71034c3cbe7a62c581faaef1363d037d8583d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e467a3835ad69a76fa663b52"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9309145","sourceId":"ev:0c82931dde6411fe79ba49569f55c9e8","sourceSha256":"4d95da2c496f90a43de153a0ab243af4d90e7183eb36d88fb25545fa03123927","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/76734be5b1acacba41a6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d1bd8d51de136c3af1a7616bf4ee322fd6c15b4a2528fd848d57e3c3cb446c98","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1685,"textSha256":"c9d5d1844dc7aa19c679654c44162318cce6e7dc756621d8540ed1f20fba1d75","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9309145","sourceId":"ev:4ffa1e002861416847041c95fe5cf290","sourceSha256":"4d95da2c496f90a43de153a0ab243af4d90e7183eb36d88fb25545fa03123927","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/76734be5b1acacba41a6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d1bd8d51de136c3af1a7616bf4ee322fd6c15b4a2528fd848d57e3c3cb446c98","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2731,"textSha256":"3cbe4e2efcc95d30cc8b205f7dd71034c3cbe7a62c581faaef1363d037d8583d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5cfa3fbc6230938417f752789e5b19629bea85493a107ce0a9edccfa8debf5ce","reply.jsonSha256":"ed0ddf2aa48827f39ee29f0738396b0de6c107c9a4e4f803262c2f3103860945","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f2184132d59aa6e5d2de7b3bd1b8e5e969f1538f58bfd809c690af54a0bff09e","receipt.jsonSha256":"da83a02e8e5d2e7920d535543a9de9c3a9a22870cd37251e6bcf32850800f7fc","normalization.jsonSha256":"2fd2f708d57b759c35b6f201499146945293785684776a91cceb503f43a72874","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6ce40753b78e58db08e049e9c1a6014b58905f4361e9dc27e04f147328f1a5bb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bc5c8121ee29c96d699bf39e479f9d07f30411182d1f9cc646afb0edfabadaff","reply.jsonSha256":"3467d7c089ba60097d869d8a855916e06138b64628659fd6f47b104ea9819116","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ac8f446c753c13e70c728faa83431989b9d0b5ff7dc04678079bde0c98a2de24","receipt.jsonSha256":"fb13edb637a6330cbcf3d41a89db0d1cb8d4e2d18bb9acb545e688ef7b37d2d8","normalization.jsonSha256":"cc105d678855ba283b2b06939fc7ce8cb8163aaad4ea7de3c0876311b34a3559"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:1bf80fd0852734711e1da018","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:06352b3cc5b12f6ab64e7011":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:06352b3cc5b12f6ab64e7011","source":"q025-candidate-region:ec6e08226449cb148b80a2d2","target":"q025-candidate-question:126bba8c232d065b443d1778","type":"narrower","title":"Local anomaly cancellation and chiral model building","rationale":"Local cancellation is a distinct target. The low-rank contrast checks the validity of a coefficient-based exclusion shortcut.","qualification":"Local anomaly cancellation is a distinct target; the low-rank contrast checks a premise of coefficient-based exclusions.","evidenceIds":["unit:0821874fae6dfdef0ff46e5790b457b629245f56f7d2f79f1d179867b8bd54e1","unit:0ec7a43507d417d909cb7e32bb2f82bc02fa953a89c31a2f642cd4fa3c5b75aa","unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","unit:148f742319d9eb77dccddd56f8481f4667630059f540830d0a1ffbaf24c532ae","unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","unit:24444b902f8dcd1dbb7292e79ff9938141193f02654915def0c2572ac610c185","unit:2a5d1e8df6529c1227a3e2afb812e04870092d78fc2ea424826bacf1d1264777","unit:39a8ac6f93fbe7f476283d4712aad1c1f49823acea1908e6f3c133b2f69086c3","unit:39c258b22adb7806291598ae01fb5d61e13b53113bb1698aa9be689d46145cd2","unit:40d20b6ce4482c8d11f312f3a72fd6ffeee73898ff2ba49c92ce1555bc12a557","unit:4125f53f78e47f1b8047d5c3afd1dc1fce13b663debf8e9f0198f8bfcc0e7a72","unit:4c9d67cd0e7fa8eb9666ce5341cdc2b72a30b2bde12a25988bb8dc207eb835ad","unit:54a26b94a160f751504f8d5e1638d879b2dce4e3ce9b4528254332685080ad8a","unit:61329dc1578276063fe3202a32f1e26f7ac62ffd90affde319e7611d6c901912","unit:6880010aa1d761cf7fb4ac2d0aa6c6c417ab6f27c4f1502c531f660cf7e1347a","unit:6be7921b00a5d1407c959162fc72f53a09a58bc358fb6b732f2a8a595d875f81","unit:796c0c5f568705b72b30fc2d2b8f1b20f38306a351ee3bcd86cabc4afc69673a","unit:9348c648eb6d5adf0f43f0678d2f2e8cac2d220dbd7cc4ef3a91fde2a4bb8650","unit:99a4783eed986051a93f5b7b843f24c4619ebecd5bc6e6e1244dfc51c499fad3","unit:9a8a8d367a6154037e0d2b3157dd6a4a9b2b26e1a10b7fb10fe7647b62ff9f1d","unit:a6741fed0393eaa3920a4b52513eab92bb46300685d11048ad311d45e359a1a2","unit:a791a6e127c555447d1494cc8311c8776aa91aaf5c5053ae98f8a9cecf29d91d","unit:c248fec87e2bfd5708e5bcd1949850bbc5095e79807423b9a482283818514825","unit:cb4847778fdd586f8b258c2df85324de0da516aa7f00693d07b546ca7e9ce866","unit:d1e4e2e4b2bdae6bb027a859c01bd93b7428ed45adc801720ac9375668db7aec","unit:dc60362d5252fe2fb4605b4f060311334c896b20601544c5b487fe0247856adf","unit:e5d0e5cca55086c00dcfdb49818eb208aa277167e84a9ff00f7cbb65219184da","unit:e81230e7237fd664ee1681fbd22765e4d92e737185131c7ba0ec743ae6660b10","unit:e8a9614bccb2eaf35062e5eb925e9b0295ad3e3d99fdcd3ff7af9c8558367e4f","unit:ef2b7c21b94e9482a0cb99efffe193ecaf0cb479618e6723617b1aed07c56564","unit:f37e264206d899f7bb4bbf7156a98c308d233afae86c196251439d7107d04cab","unit:f904853308f7f5d696e3cf8c5bcdc85594e1b2a8fc027167142bf6e9d1321ae5","unit:fc952676da48abe5ff6a146bbc24cc1fd029bd967429d8c84150af4899170a9b","unit:fd398558531d755bf5fa761f3253030eddc584e45a8024a3f23cd5a9a926eee6"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:126bba8c232d065b443d1778"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"1507.08642","sourceId":"ev:03ec03e2ebb5814c68ed197440f9e10b","sourceSha256":"728f39a5196c58473b58bf99571b4b68eb8eab92c44e995f327ed11a062b4cf5","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/21765429fcfc08978462/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"66762144e13df0409a08dafc2ddb413d3458e2af61b3d840101dc144fdaf7d2b","pdfPage":20,"start":208,"end":1988,"textSha256":"8bc77c4142963fc8135325d15112e9dcae2e70ed0064cc0f5aa3987ebfa5694f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:06352b3cc5b12f6ab64e7011","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge:link:3","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3","parent-native:challenge:8165e73a65a0812ac118afc4"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Local cancellation is a distinct target. The low-rank contrast checks the validity of a coefficient-based exclusion shortcut.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Local anomaly cancellation is a distinct target; the low-rank contrast checks a premise of coefficient-based exclusions.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:126bba8c232d065b443d1778"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"1507.08642","sourceId":"ev:03ec03e2ebb5814c68ed197440f9e10b","sourceSha256":"728f39a5196c58473b58bf99571b4b68eb8eab92c44e995f327ed11a062b4cf5","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/21765429fcfc08978462/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"66762144e13df0409a08dafc2ddb413d3458e2af61b3d840101dc144fdaf7d2b","pdfPage":20,"start":208,"end":1988,"textSha256":"8bc77c4142963fc8135325d15112e9dcae2e70ed0064cc0f5aa3987ebfa5694f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:126bba8c232d065b443d1778"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"1507.08642","sourceId":"ev:03ec03e2ebb5814c68ed197440f9e10b","sourceSha256":"728f39a5196c58473b58bf99571b4b68eb8eab92c44e995f327ed11a062b4cf5","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/21765429fcfc08978462/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"66762144e13df0409a08dafc2ddb413d3458e2af61b3d840101dc144fdaf7d2b","pdfPage":20,"start":208,"end":1988,"textSha256":"8bc77c4142963fc8135325d15112e9dcae2e70ed0064cc0f5aa3987ebfa5694f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c758baedbafb89f5b9239e79415bd74ce0de8ed8384f3f0ad1984b96639f41d3","reply.jsonSha256":"21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3ecfc6dda2a3e061e7aac37649c7f0f053bf719f6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f498f0d7ebd9d47d3545140282fd2af05dd824a6aa2294c4b1969be7754de6b0","receipt.jsonSha256":"88737414007b505f0efd94b94fe73010c00c1d298a688bdac0408b020b9bc9ec","normalization.jsonSha256":"ed5d2d478b940b2cd97aa26dc3d777f813fbfe8c553db4bd9bf9a94eb3310b66","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"37e03ff157538fe0a652f94a08187a06d31b472ba1f3d1fb68c6146476776320"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"cda8e63406c657a2d2527808f4cc8c688062dd0c80968d349353cabc6cc0f979","reply.jsonSha256":"8165e73a65a0812ac118afc49e2dddb573c747607c62d7d2d31e62c90d14acfc","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c2c2c6e5948b3468e12a29f3ef7507314ab0e797e5856093d9c66a5d5d9be396","receipt.jsonSha256":"17c4a7604553e0f3de5e628efe0f87972ca2b92ad264f8c1eb77143d29ab8e31","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9a2969c637e8565b30abb7a0bb20676b9ce0754c50f334971a52c3923127fed"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:06352b3cc5b12f6ab64e7011","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:2aa0d0c77fb9923dc09bef4f":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:2aa0d0c77fb9923dc09bef4f","source":"q025-candidate-region:ec6e08226449cb148b80a2d2","target":"q025-candidate-question:12fbf695d2c00ead28a95c19","type":"narrower","title":"Global anomalies and admissible backgrounds","rationale":"Global consistency supplies a shared direction while dimensions, field content, backgrounds and possible cancellation mechanisms remain specified separately.","qualification":"Global anomalies and allowed backgrounds provide a common direction while preserving dimension, field-content and cancellation-mechanism distinctions.","evidenceIds":["unit:003bbcca9ad54e26e6a1a542d53aeb3f141f5891e660332cd06a96eb390836f0","unit:0171686f327c042d23b8bde64fdf74881fa12e1bb2a7986548c8ef00178d5b53","unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","unit:2013744f6ff0fa1ff631e74c0570bf68ab82b324de386da13b3b7696b6b36b11","unit:2daa3a658f96be6378addb8b5c384511cbb24215a71c9eaf38b1b6868a9f3df2","unit:4125f53f78e47f1b8047d5c3afd1dc1fce13b663debf8e9f0198f8bfcc0e7a72","unit:45f28bdd841e03f33ce0e81796fb4fbba803f4253fb618d601abc5a69e7c5353","unit:483f547e3b7e0cfbae12c21bc38b276cc7a5c49d630930f49a8fa0e3a3bf1db9","unit:4db3d585d48063b29bd3d780531f544ecab0cc77f0d1d4eef1d51c72d925c1c0","unit:52c98b3ecfefc5a753b924a798b2c46ce3fd814ac05c174f2dfa5e324e461c18","unit:54a26b94a160f751504f8d5e1638d879b2dce4e3ce9b4528254332685080ad8a","unit:5ae1841793b936f0f34c98aba582901207ea79e44b2258148337bcd6ab5f8c1a","unit:6880010aa1d761cf7fb4ac2d0aa6c6c417ab6f27c4f1502c531f660cf7e1347a","unit:6be7921b00a5d1407c959162fc72f53a09a58bc358fb6b732f2a8a595d875f81","unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","unit:861349d720ff011dd92c295ade59b9adf42ba11310025acb7d4823fbb66bcb0e","unit:8638107849984e32d73956c70e8c7bbdd470a8518836e1015c4633a2f5329691","unit:86e8e51867327bb0f905c91557ee114ba65c02f61d36342758a7de5555b5e96b","unit:89532602eae3619289935e8e286f7892edd6592c8185ed8d90a66f69c92327d5","unit:8de808936b189d3db316917ac56e966a19a983eb913e06fadd304764f6efda3e","unit:9348c648eb6d5adf0f43f0678d2f2e8cac2d220dbd7cc4ef3a91fde2a4bb8650","unit:956d63449be7a77af7aa4c84367966edf27576ceef41c0fd134d77965d1f9e32","unit:99a4783eed986051a93f5b7b843f24c4619ebecd5bc6e6e1244dfc51c499fad3","unit:9d46e02908e30145753fe44d1a1d7c279348ad4616dc92f6ae52b59a14fff346","unit:a057ae58ea84174fdf04f4270d27f37954b191518d0f606b1d8e30a80baea774","unit:b1dff6825d7bfdc0ee431f8ceca88c8621c389506485ca8a65988776ab3b6111","unit:b79bf6bee2d9e939626e355ce794b6c37ba00c2334c91443c8b5efe351c10a93","unit:c0004e1ddfae71878d3d0af962bd12d51efdbcbdb380b6cf7fc3b6b9ef287d1f","unit:c0041e46f057ecfdb39941d3304dd1a87556622731e36009a7df0e038b264999","unit:c2ed7c0b21ec35c68b5c4aef2d222e008d80b72bde163235ef42074f1e38b3b4","unit:cd42afaee8bd21c381c0384d06ba676a28d119c2703a536ec7f9a31519b1118d","unit:e5d0e5cca55086c00dcfdb49818eb208aa277167e84a9ff00f7cbb65219184da","unit:ec953ff3566f91db7c79a0daa669c8d014b49b9e10147a14bbf778201e1b6d77","unit:f041f13ddca46a67c6849f15355843692998218e9db2938c6eff227780d46717","unit:f09dacaa3c692e68db523913e3cbcea2f210ec936150cfe5d6e0e40ab4488b82","unit:f184c2fa38d6ccd8ab2ba4ee48c01f4720e9d7da62451694a512a01b408e790d","unit:fd398558531d755bf5fa761f3253030eddc584e45a8024a3f23cd5a9a926eee6","unit:ffa85dae501867d7a0833db5c97a4bb162083faacb0bf3d57efcaddd0769fdc3"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:12fbf695d2c00ead28a95c19"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1710.04218","sourceId":"ev:0c661fe4e414a03aefd6b2d54d5ca72c","sourceSha256":"033ff27254fd612924f92246096b9f335265ecd454848e5649e004c39613a1e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25e88884b925e401690f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2741d31f08be69b1fa72e2a15199c42272d24cce081287d7e4ffba88a58dc91a","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a2693a24164faff7fb5552b7dedb8818984d7a16ae8716a5b64c61174992fbf2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"2212.04503","sourceId":"ev:bd03e53bb8c91c86f88c4667e78220f3","sourceSha256":"f978fd35a32ff866798f0e3e5d4c8de2f437804dd4d8d72eb620cf2b596be565","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c10c96102e205afa0dc7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0dd97facdb9986cf810cdf587288a865487027fe0eadcbd0dda9e4acbb260389","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1993,"textSha256":"8cc2204308fa6bdd167a6a2405c993e455420f711e8be845fd7a6d170a1cde7f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:2aa0d0c77fb9923dc09bef4f","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge:link:4","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3","parent-native:challenge:8165e73a65a0812ac118afc4"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Global consistency supplies a shared direction while dimensions, field content, backgrounds and possible cancellation mechanisms remain specified separately.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Global anomalies and allowed backgrounds provide a common direction while preserving dimension, field-content and cancellation-mechanism distinctions.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:12fbf695d2c00ead28a95c19"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1710.04218","sourceId":"ev:0c661fe4e414a03aefd6b2d54d5ca72c","sourceSha256":"033ff27254fd612924f92246096b9f335265ecd454848e5649e004c39613a1e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25e88884b925e401690f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2741d31f08be69b1fa72e2a15199c42272d24cce081287d7e4ffba88a58dc91a","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a2693a24164faff7fb5552b7dedb8818984d7a16ae8716a5b64c61174992fbf2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"2212.04503","sourceId":"ev:bd03e53bb8c91c86f88c4667e78220f3","sourceSha256":"f978fd35a32ff866798f0e3e5d4c8de2f437804dd4d8d72eb620cf2b596be565","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c10c96102e205afa0dc7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0dd97facdb9986cf810cdf587288a865487027fe0eadcbd0dda9e4acbb260389","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1993,"textSha256":"8cc2204308fa6bdd167a6a2405c993e455420f711e8be845fd7a6d170a1cde7f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:12fbf695d2c00ead28a95c19"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1710.04218","sourceId":"ev:0c661fe4e414a03aefd6b2d54d5ca72c","sourceSha256":"033ff27254fd612924f92246096b9f335265ecd454848e5649e004c39613a1e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25e88884b925e401690f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2741d31f08be69b1fa72e2a15199c42272d24cce081287d7e4ffba88a58dc91a","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a2693a24164faff7fb5552b7dedb8818984d7a16ae8716a5b64c61174992fbf2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"2212.04503","sourceId":"ev:bd03e53bb8c91c86f88c4667e78220f3","sourceSha256":"f978fd35a32ff866798f0e3e5d4c8de2f437804dd4d8d72eb620cf2b596be565","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c10c96102e205afa0dc7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0dd97facdb9986cf810cdf587288a865487027fe0eadcbd0dda9e4acbb260389","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1993,"textSha256":"8cc2204308fa6bdd167a6a2405c993e455420f711e8be845fd7a6d170a1cde7f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c758baedbafb89f5b9239e79415bd74ce0de8ed8384f3f0ad1984b96639f41d3","reply.jsonSha256":"21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3ecfc6dda2a3e061e7aac37649c7f0f053bf719f6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f498f0d7ebd9d47d3545140282fd2af05dd824a6aa2294c4b1969be7754de6b0","receipt.jsonSha256":"88737414007b505f0efd94b94fe73010c00c1d298a688bdac0408b020b9bc9ec","normalization.jsonSha256":"ed5d2d478b940b2cd97aa26dc3d777f813fbfe8c553db4bd9bf9a94eb3310b66","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"37e03ff157538fe0a652f94a08187a06d31b472ba1f3d1fb68c6146476776320"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"cda8e63406c657a2d2527808f4cc8c688062dd0c80968d349353cabc6cc0f979","reply.jsonSha256":"8165e73a65a0812ac118afc49e2dddb573c747607c62d7d2d31e62c90d14acfc","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c2c2c6e5948b3468e12a29f3ef7507314ab0e797e5856093d9c66a5d5d9be396","receipt.jsonSha256":"17c4a7604553e0f3de5e628efe0f87972ca2b92ad264f8c1eb77143d29ab8e31","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9a2969c637e8565b30abb7a0bb20676b9ce0754c50f334971a52c3923127fed"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:2aa0d0c77fb9923dc09bef4f","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:4938ee8d80540a2234c1879d":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:4938ee8d80540a2234c1879d","source":"q025-candidate-region:ec6e08226449cb148b80a2d2","target":"q025-candidate-question:46dc4842b1f81f7a6b1e89f0","type":"narrower","title":"SCFT construction, classification and dynamics","rationale":"SCFT construction, distinguishing data and dynamics provide a separate direction, including gravity-decoupled settings.","qualification":"SCFT construction, distinguishing data and dynamics form a separate target direction, including gravity-decoupled settings.","evidenceIds":["unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","unit:42c997c37eb6184ea8ae3faf9dd958bf6ff5417191f6623cf6a4e5a28e32a6e3","unit:54a26b94a160f751504f8d5e1638d879b2dce4e3ce9b4528254332685080ad8a","unit:5b5884b2db3e7b991d33967b45e0ee452a4c7eb82b9e8e735d92b622d695d340","unit:7afd5dc97cf2aac540d145869f130d5d9aaebd31ed8bc5d80abd982a1f001309","unit:8f635bec7c68b0dfcd49a6d20e9851961b1ef85276c224734bc9dc9318472851","unit:9348c648eb6d5adf0f43f0678d2f2e8cac2d220dbd7cc4ef3a91fde2a4bb8650","unit:97a3348ec2dab70902123d2ddb7f1422379fe6e3f4b47918e07069194d1ef062","unit:a595dae8211ba91115d72392e4e3a79b48519747857e78b80dc3b4fd16727009","unit:adcda1c497afc18070117fd5f67183ba403eb1bb5e899d14d8a29bec064ee607","unit:b5185662f6f84f1252d4ddea936acc4f382810e45d658b5966a5245fd5869d25","unit:d5a3d05c62fd212b7292193945d70818d6fff33bc76c147d1026dd69e0d4c969","unit:ed07eee43e28b821b29812f3df64dafe4870e6c528b9b5f09b617ad7075a28d6"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:46dc4842b1f81f7a6b1e89f0"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:4938ee8d80540a2234c1879d","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge:link:12","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3","parent-native:challenge:8165e73a65a0812ac118afc4"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"SCFT construction, distinguishing data and dynamics provide a separate direction, including gravity-decoupled settings.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"SCFT construction, distinguishing data and dynamics form a separate target direction, including gravity-decoupled settings.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:46dc4842b1f81f7a6b1e89f0"},{"ref":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:46dc4842b1f81f7a6b1e89f0"},{"ref":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c758baedbafb89f5b9239e79415bd74ce0de8ed8384f3f0ad1984b96639f41d3","reply.jsonSha256":"21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3ecfc6dda2a3e061e7aac37649c7f0f053bf719f6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f498f0d7ebd9d47d3545140282fd2af05dd824a6aa2294c4b1969be7754de6b0","receipt.jsonSha256":"88737414007b505f0efd94b94fe73010c00c1d298a688bdac0408b020b9bc9ec","normalization.jsonSha256":"ed5d2d478b940b2cd97aa26dc3d777f813fbfe8c553db4bd9bf9a94eb3310b66","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"37e03ff157538fe0a652f94a08187a06d31b472ba1f3d1fb68c6146476776320"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"cda8e63406c657a2d2527808f4cc8c688062dd0c80968d349353cabc6cc0f979","reply.jsonSha256":"8165e73a65a0812ac118afc49e2dddb573c747607c62d7d2d31e62c90d14acfc","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c2c2c6e5948b3468e12a29f3ef7507314ab0e797e5856093d9c66a5d5d9be396","receipt.jsonSha256":"17c4a7604553e0f3de5e628efe0f87972ca2b92ad264f8c1eb77143d29ab8e31","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9a2969c637e8565b30abb7a0bb20676b9ce0754c50f334971a52c3923127fed"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:4938ee8d80540a2234c1879d","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:a884af866742f5dccfb9c970":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:a884af866742f5dccfb9c970","source":"q025-candidate-region:ec6e08226449cb148b80a2d2","target":"q025-candidate-question:616f7c6900ad863e561b16fc","type":"narrower","title":"Weak-coupling limits and emergent strings","rationale":"Weak-coupling limits retain the stated gravitational strength, distance and decompactification conditions.","qualification":"Weak-coupling limits and emergent strings retain their gravitational-strength, distance and decompactification qualifications.","evidenceIds":["unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","unit:522b96a8fdbf8fa1f59f9133844a0f228f4ecb99ba43e5cdc945d0230cc30309","unit:54a26b94a160f751504f8d5e1638d879b2dce4e3ce9b4528254332685080ad8a","unit:5cc0fbc343c071e6efca8e63f802682196609fccdf01074e9e2bbd2938c0320f","unit:7a4c782d71574e73e8f9f355fbd01ca2d2b2ce5b232ef7ccc937e82453b97b51","unit:8d07997210297de470622c48e0ba24030b130c26d948e6d1127a7d5bb87ce294","unit:9348c648eb6d5adf0f43f0678d2f2e8cac2d220dbd7cc4ef3a91fde2a4bb8650","unit:adcda1c497afc18070117fd5f67183ba403eb1bb5e899d14d8a29bec064ee607"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:616f7c6900ad863e561b16fc"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:a884af866742f5dccfb9c970","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge:link:13","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3","parent-native:challenge:8165e73a65a0812ac118afc4"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Weak-coupling limits retain the stated gravitational strength, distance and decompactification conditions.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Weak-coupling limits and emergent strings retain their gravitational-strength, distance and decompactification qualifications.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:616f7c6900ad863e561b16fc"},{"ref":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:616f7c6900ad863e561b16fc"},{"ref":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c758baedbafb89f5b9239e79415bd74ce0de8ed8384f3f0ad1984b96639f41d3","reply.jsonSha256":"21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3ecfc6dda2a3e061e7aac37649c7f0f053bf719f6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f498f0d7ebd9d47d3545140282fd2af05dd824a6aa2294c4b1969be7754de6b0","receipt.jsonSha256":"88737414007b505f0efd94b94fe73010c00c1d298a688bdac0408b020b9bc9ec","normalization.jsonSha256":"ed5d2d478b940b2cd97aa26dc3d777f813fbfe8c553db4bd9bf9a94eb3310b66","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"37e03ff157538fe0a652f94a08187a06d31b472ba1f3d1fb68c6146476776320"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"cda8e63406c657a2d2527808f4cc8c688062dd0c80968d349353cabc6cc0f979","reply.jsonSha256":"8165e73a65a0812ac118afc49e2dddb573c747607c62d7d2d31e62c90d14acfc","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c2c2c6e5948b3468e12a29f3ef7507314ab0e797e5856093d9c66a5d5d9be396","receipt.jsonSha256":"17c4a7604553e0f3de5e628efe0f87972ca2b92ad264f8c1eb77143d29ab8e31","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9a2969c637e8565b30abb7a0bb20676b9ce0754c50f334971a52c3923127fed"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:a884af866742f5dccfb9c970","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:12b025304ee2fca61bbac757":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:12b025304ee2fca61bbac757","source":"q025-candidate-region:ec6e08226449cb148b80a2d2","target":"q025-candidate-question:7a166dd5376e1e3190dc0257","type":"narrower","title":"Allowed spectra, enumeration and finiteness","rationale":"Enumeration and finiteness retain their tensor sectors, representation restrictions and tested conditions.","qualification":"Spectrum enumeration and finiteness retain the specified tensor sectors and tested conditions rather than implying complete quantum-gravity classification.","evidenceIds":["unit:033c61b7f5495aadaba46ad97bb95ed6785a0997bf9dd85b475b6a2e4d612d81","unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","unit:126be64c9635a96625961af1030369808590194a10075103d8acbba3e473e864","unit:16c30409023d31d7a87d5a23f882780704139d61b7f5754b2eba97d1fb2cda55","unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","unit:21566519271e2447b13403d6db9c7cfba8d467ae5799e6ce96711b660fdbba79","unit:21a26563cc26952f32d4944411e7684120ec7b1a9d124374f5e7da6a1b9a87ea","unit:23dd831acc6bda8ec30a4bf67dd50da19f105e280476378f2032015df33241f1","unit:25496b9946799f8ed1dd7634937fe30fb9526a2b33c9d25bb2144cd397a7b689","unit:2fb9d6d8e7fba600034f1efa646d0dfc11e76172b4a8803fc5e436a97c072ae6","unit:302297d1e5071db08a0c4d31c3edc68bff84dcefb6c3892baeff2c9bd3bff0f8","unit:318af2006d4a3e955cf87af226dd81cf1889eaafc84fe455c8592ae22d23c820","unit:36bf3f2a06ee16c0eccc7e4e4e1c8376035de1d15de91f4bb3965f59a72b729a","unit:418d69af9a20f23f982fa6e49dc1d9ec7ffff710a6eb410eecce9cb84e9a279f","unit:54a26b94a160f751504f8d5e1638d879b2dce4e3ce9b4528254332685080ad8a","unit:5c7a05a1e1731cf6364e7a0aa96551d97489f2a5e03c2da2e0d10ccdf7678592","unit:65db9361ee40c1ec1b38db63f071d0b6a1e14ff338f5b79d8a9f0c1704254348","unit:6b93b452f81c16c933b01a95de32b84dc2604ebb943d85a0b7b16d2e3f95f53b","unit:73d4c499e67dd53704cd400d14e4f0d2d65c53a45541d91551fec71a48589dd3","unit:7920af5db5ced3f0ac4d0174a9cec0567e8faacc3b48bb8704270e6347d24a47","unit:888f1805fff63b3a9565cd6244d6bc9d41e3c96eef9e455851271762ec479922","unit:9348c648eb6d5adf0f43f0678d2f2e8cac2d220dbd7cc4ef3a91fde2a4bb8650","unit:94370915bb74e3a8685a95b325c0c3e591af522260f4586862fc2bd6fa6356aa","unit:9fe0325dca533741a05ab71e81cd0c49d2dd8ccac1ee04a51d78060cae9cf74d","unit:b4a51aff8ce7705ff22c976093897842857ca08c149bc41e7c4bec97b8f8cb91","unit:c4069ec500497761d5d409cb8682848082bc20f9e404e4c0d8996456a674c7a9","unit:d65051bb76ca12390207b6ca6bd682c5bcab451a5188a929c90bfe48ec0901f6","unit:e6e520759447d8908c23bef127e0f9768e351083beb4304c52a2f2489ee31961","unit:f0d7a61248aa66478b9772b211533f8fce6de4d3a539ddc089a62d6be053ef7a","unit:f16c2fa8a3041f93e36842460d3a833cea4e632ac0d49ceaf75a03433d99950f","unit:f34eeb6f53712298baa0fb06182f084f74f5ca49ffea5bf6793faeace58c98f2","unit:f694d40b499fa78ce3eca6ab231d3d07633c98c46f56d63259df0e5ff6c73b34","unit:fb9f81919c5a44b76c35c0685a0e59065779d18632574b67f061ec87457dab75","unit:fd76a1d8357ccac743adb1683b912e9ad554636a918e12f813f8aecd474d419a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7a166dd5376e1e3190dc0257"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:12b025304ee2fca61bbac757","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge:link:11","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3","parent-native:challenge:8165e73a65a0812ac118afc4"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Enumeration and finiteness retain their tensor sectors, representation restrictions and tested conditions.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Spectrum enumeration and finiteness retain the specified tensor sectors and tested conditions rather than implying complete quantum-gravity classification.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7a166dd5376e1e3190dc0257"},{"ref":"c1","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7a166dd5376e1e3190dc0257"},{"ref":"c1","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c758baedbafb89f5b9239e79415bd74ce0de8ed8384f3f0ad1984b96639f41d3","reply.jsonSha256":"21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3ecfc6dda2a3e061e7aac37649c7f0f053bf719f6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f498f0d7ebd9d47d3545140282fd2af05dd824a6aa2294c4b1969be7754de6b0","receipt.jsonSha256":"88737414007b505f0efd94b94fe73010c00c1d298a688bdac0408b020b9bc9ec","normalization.jsonSha256":"ed5d2d478b940b2cd97aa26dc3d777f813fbfe8c553db4bd9bf9a94eb3310b66","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"37e03ff157538fe0a652f94a08187a06d31b472ba1f3d1fb68c6146476776320"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"cda8e63406c657a2d2527808f4cc8c688062dd0c80968d349353cabc6cc0f979","reply.jsonSha256":"8165e73a65a0812ac118afc49e2dddb573c747607c62d7d2d31e62c90d14acfc","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c2c2c6e5948b3468e12a29f3ef7507314ab0e797e5856093d9c66a5d5d9be396","receipt.jsonSha256":"17c4a7604553e0f3de5e628efe0f87972ca2b92ad264f8c1eb77143d29ab8e31","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9a2969c637e8565b30abb7a0bb20676b9ce0754c50f334971a52c3923127fed"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:12b025304ee2fca61bbac757","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:aa3c409d16115846d7b00ac5":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:aa3c409d16115846d7b00ac5","source":"q025-candidate-region:ec6e08226449cb148b80a2d2","target":"q025-candidate-question:b1c4c37becd0a3ce0ded3d15","type":"narrower","title":"Charged strings and tests beyond bulk anomalies","rationale":"String, quantization and lower-dimensional tests provide additional diagnostics with distinct admissibility assumptions.","qualification":"Charged strings, quantization and effective-theory tests supply distinct diagnostics beyond bulk anomaly cancellation.","evidenceIds":["unit:002c4e5fbdee96b81e899bfae015ede31b5c59dcd22c3310352ade5f8dd25164","unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","unit:16e5760b894765ab1a0598d09bf4e163545d99299a64d242c848ac7fd661ea16","unit:1aa4847fb5f31863fca58b8abe0ec5b495d267282d1a13c8ecbc11787fe20962","unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","unit:46d2f275bb7b71b49beec5631d1ed2d092ac470fd32a2701f3a89ab4539a54e6","unit:4e1818c5cbe9e99a7018d8e987ed82fed05b22b4b08c5855d2a51b959ee71cc5","unit:54a26b94a160f751504f8d5e1638d879b2dce4e3ce9b4528254332685080ad8a","unit:57fb12a8667e086b98aa6b6ab4fdba765c8f96f55269dd46e1d1b83fc333788c","unit:6dcb82a1b54b56fd5bd9ca28819452448b1a02b518b47261389cb31126830164","unit:71dcb4bfc2ee8e354658bf0873f3c9c67b66636cf479330d0fe2720bd4b46c0f","unit:8638107849984e32d73956c70e8c7bbdd470a8518836e1015c4633a2f5329691","unit:873e56ca61e5f0bb8bc0689676817ab75c75cffdcad0f5eb3173788dee4c6b37","unit:9348c648eb6d5adf0f43f0678d2f2e8cac2d220dbd7cc4ef3a91fde2a4bb8650","unit:949c963109800e37fb21bbbeb2396cc93a61f7f8a0a53521b1c7ec5fa32da7df","unit:b74519e223ec4654df4f9832d63ec3a14e8122f2b5dcdbc821f741f7a20aceab","unit:b9c70e2cc4f86cd8e96a3c7716b9aaba85cbcd639c9b7987153a2cc5fa965b74","unit:d1e4e2e4b2bdae6bb027a859c01bd93b7428ed45adc801720ac9375668db7aec","unit:d7425436138b2c46698af19b33f1a9f174d1e22727b784be92c95778e956a481","unit:dc60362d5252fe2fb4605b4f060311334c896b20601544c5b487fe0247856adf"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b1c4c37becd0a3ce0ded3d15"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceId":"ev:2e2911efe2aa99dcf542ce53e4bfd71f","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":3331,"textSha256":"fe044a98fc79e764f1bfa2167d527ed55a9a71e5e488bd702c4f344772525a9d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceId":"ev:e43e2b5a5b2a5d6d8d417cac80b63f76","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b82113e5d0345d1188abd0a95be0e94f6ed91617ba29db732d6d60269f435d49","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:aa3c409d16115846d7b00ac5","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge:link:6","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3","parent-native:challenge:8165e73a65a0812ac118afc4"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"String, quantization and lower-dimensional tests provide additional diagnostics with distinct admissibility assumptions.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Charged strings, quantization and effective-theory tests supply distinct diagnostics beyond bulk anomaly cancellation.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b1c4c37becd0a3ce0ded3d15"},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceId":"ev:2e2911efe2aa99dcf542ce53e4bfd71f","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":3331,"textSha256":"fe044a98fc79e764f1bfa2167d527ed55a9a71e5e488bd702c4f344772525a9d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceId":"ev:e43e2b5a5b2a5d6d8d417cac80b63f76","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b82113e5d0345d1188abd0a95be0e94f6ed91617ba29db732d6d60269f435d49","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b1c4c37becd0a3ce0ded3d15"},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceId":"ev:2e2911efe2aa99dcf542ce53e4bfd71f","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":3331,"textSha256":"fe044a98fc79e764f1bfa2167d527ed55a9a71e5e488bd702c4f344772525a9d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceId":"ev:e43e2b5a5b2a5d6d8d417cac80b63f76","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b82113e5d0345d1188abd0a95be0e94f6ed91617ba29db732d6d60269f435d49","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c758baedbafb89f5b9239e79415bd74ce0de8ed8384f3f0ad1984b96639f41d3","reply.jsonSha256":"21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3ecfc6dda2a3e061e7aac37649c7f0f053bf719f6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f498f0d7ebd9d47d3545140282fd2af05dd824a6aa2294c4b1969be7754de6b0","receipt.jsonSha256":"88737414007b505f0efd94b94fe73010c00c1d298a688bdac0408b020b9bc9ec","normalization.jsonSha256":"ed5d2d478b940b2cd97aa26dc3d777f813fbfe8c553db4bd9bf9a94eb3310b66","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"37e03ff157538fe0a652f94a08187a06d31b472ba1f3d1fb68c6146476776320"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"cda8e63406c657a2d2527808f4cc8c688062dd0c80968d349353cabc6cc0f979","reply.jsonSha256":"8165e73a65a0812ac118afc49e2dddb573c747607c62d7d2d31e62c90d14acfc","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c2c2c6e5948b3468e12a29f3ef7507314ab0e797e5856093d9c66a5d5d9be396","receipt.jsonSha256":"17c4a7604553e0f3de5e628efe0f87972ca2b92ad264f8c1eb77143d29ab8e31","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9a2969c637e8565b30abb7a0bb20676b9ce0754c50f334971a52c3923127fed"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:aa3c409d16115846d7b00ac5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:85e78e9f7a4819b874b548a6":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:85e78e9f7a4819b874b548a6","source":"q025-candidate-region:ec6e08226449cb148b80a2d2","target":"q025-candidate-question:ba6c0c8b7e3685cf8d7246d8","type":"narrower","title":"Realization, enhancement and ultraviolet completion","rationale":"Realization and enhancement questions retain positive, obstructed and unresolved outcomes, including the source-dated g2 construction question.","qualification":"Realization and enhancement questions retain positive, obstructed and unresolved outcomes, including the source-dated g2 realization question.","evidenceIds":["unit:0337682f4686898ff87b6fc468ea7157e574658f326a2c323af535e061dd822c","unit:07c1bfd612be7000d6406c4337e15d4febb4ed965308e3a076d0ba6d30810ddb","unit:0821874fae6dfdef0ff46e5790b457b629245f56f7d2f79f1d179867b8bd54e1","unit:0ec7a43507d417d909cb7e32bb2f82bc02fa953a89c31a2f642cd4fa3c5b75aa","unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","unit:16e5760b894765ab1a0598d09bf4e163545d99299a64d242c848ac7fd661ea16","unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","unit:2013744f6ff0fa1ff631e74c0570bf68ab82b324de386da13b3b7696b6b36b11","unit:24444b902f8dcd1dbb7292e79ff9938141193f02654915def0c2572ac610c185","unit:2a5d1e8df6529c1227a3e2afb812e04870092d78fc2ea424826bacf1d1264777","unit:2b9e23302d7defa3ffd11244dda3818e7b401d0feb33ec6defd67dc9424d088e","unit:2daa3a658f96be6378addb8b5c384511cbb24215a71c9eaf38b1b6868a9f3df2","unit:39a8ac6f93fbe7f476283d4712aad1c1f49823acea1908e6f3c133b2f69086c3","unit:3b031d3101f8740b58434112ba984d9a70f3f0dbbe3a416d9b466669cf4aec51","unit:40d20b6ce4482c8d11f312f3a72fd6ffeee73898ff2ba49c92ce1555bc12a557","unit:46d2f275bb7b71b49beec5631d1ed2d092ac470fd32a2701f3a89ab4539a54e6","unit:483f547e3b7e0cfbae12c21bc38b276cc7a5c49d630930f49a8fa0e3a3bf1db9","unit:54a26b94a160f751504f8d5e1638d879b2dce4e3ce9b4528254332685080ad8a","unit:57fb12a8667e086b98aa6b6ab4fdba765c8f96f55269dd46e1d1b83fc333788c","unit:61329dc1578276063fe3202a32f1e26f7ac62ffd90affde319e7611d6c901912","unit:6be7921b00a5d1407c959162fc72f53a09a58bc358fb6b732f2a8a595d875f81","unit:6dcb82a1b54b56fd5bd9ca28819452448b1a02b518b47261389cb31126830164","unit:71dcb4bfc2ee8e354658bf0873f3c9c67b66636cf479330d0fe2720bd4b46c0f","unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","unit:89532602eae3619289935e8e286f7892edd6592c8185ed8d90a66f69c92327d5","unit:9348c648eb6d5adf0f43f0678d2f2e8cac2d220dbd7cc4ef3a91fde2a4bb8650","unit:a7177e8793327dba3888663e68928ec37954fa1c5e8719830bf5ae8383972ad7","unit:b74519e223ec4654df4f9832d63ec3a14e8122f2b5dcdbc821f741f7a20aceab","unit:b79bf6bee2d9e939626e355ce794b6c37ba00c2334c91443c8b5efe351c10a93","unit:c289184b5c2ecd8ff15e05d437956712e1628d9e70d734d3abb7c464148ae2f4","unit:d7425436138b2c46698af19b33f1a9f174d1e22727b784be92c95778e956a481","unit:e81230e7237fd664ee1681fbd22765e4d92e737185131c7ba0ec743ae6660b10","unit:ec953ff3566f91db7c79a0daa669c8d014b49b9e10147a14bbf778201e1b6d77","unit:ef2b7c21b94e9482a0cb99efffe193ecaf0cb479618e6723617b1aed07c56564","unit:f041f13ddca46a67c6849f15355843692998218e9db2938c6eff227780d46717","unit:f70667996e73ba08ac4ea6e192061e84206373833edeab9edfa99510f03fe957","unit:f904853308f7f5d696e3cf8c5bcdc85594e1b2a8fc027167142bf6e9d1321ae5","unit:fd398558531d755bf5fa761f3253030eddc584e45a8024a3f23cd5a9a926eee6"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ba6c0c8b7e3685cf8d7246d8"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1710.04218","sourceId":"ev:0c661fe4e414a03aefd6b2d54d5ca72c","sourceSha256":"033ff27254fd612924f92246096b9f335265ecd454848e5649e004c39613a1e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25e88884b925e401690f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2741d31f08be69b1fa72e2a15199c42272d24cce081287d7e4ffba88a58dc91a","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a2693a24164faff7fb5552b7dedb8818984d7a16ae8716a5b64c61174992fbf2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1710.04218","sourceId":"ev:abb9bebcd48600f3cf580969488cc137","sourceSha256":"033ff27254fd612924f92246096b9f335265ecd454848e5649e004c39613a1e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25e88884b925e401690f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2741d31f08be69b1fa72e2a15199c42272d24cce081287d7e4ffba88a58dc91a","pdfPage":3,"start":99,"end":3496,"textSha256":"bd17350601308032c650cc9521a0c84b74fdf2aeac412488f467cdfd333beb3c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:85e78e9f7a4819b874b548a6","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge:link:7","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3","parent-native:challenge:8165e73a65a0812ac118afc4"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Realization and enhancement questions retain positive, obstructed and unresolved outcomes, including the source-dated g2 construction question.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Realization and enhancement questions retain positive, obstructed and unresolved outcomes, including the source-dated g2 realization question.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ba6c0c8b7e3685cf8d7246d8"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1710.04218","sourceId":"ev:0c661fe4e414a03aefd6b2d54d5ca72c","sourceSha256":"033ff27254fd612924f92246096b9f335265ecd454848e5649e004c39613a1e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25e88884b925e401690f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2741d31f08be69b1fa72e2a15199c42272d24cce081287d7e4ffba88a58dc91a","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a2693a24164faff7fb5552b7dedb8818984d7a16ae8716a5b64c61174992fbf2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1710.04218","sourceId":"ev:abb9bebcd48600f3cf580969488cc137","sourceSha256":"033ff27254fd612924f92246096b9f335265ecd454848e5649e004c39613a1e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25e88884b925e401690f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2741d31f08be69b1fa72e2a15199c42272d24cce081287d7e4ffba88a58dc91a","pdfPage":3,"start":99,"end":3496,"textSha256":"bd17350601308032c650cc9521a0c84b74fdf2aeac412488f467cdfd333beb3c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ba6c0c8b7e3685cf8d7246d8"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1710.04218","sourceId":"ev:0c661fe4e414a03aefd6b2d54d5ca72c","sourceSha256":"033ff27254fd612924f92246096b9f335265ecd454848e5649e004c39613a1e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25e88884b925e401690f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2741d31f08be69b1fa72e2a15199c42272d24cce081287d7e4ffba88a58dc91a","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a2693a24164faff7fb5552b7dedb8818984d7a16ae8716a5b64c61174992fbf2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1710.04218","sourceId":"ev:abb9bebcd48600f3cf580969488cc137","sourceSha256":"033ff27254fd612924f92246096b9f335265ecd454848e5649e004c39613a1e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/25e88884b925e401690f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2741d31f08be69b1fa72e2a15199c42272d24cce081287d7e4ffba88a58dc91a","pdfPage":3,"start":99,"end":3496,"textSha256":"bd17350601308032c650cc9521a0c84b74fdf2aeac412488f467cdfd333beb3c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c758baedbafb89f5b9239e79415bd74ce0de8ed8384f3f0ad1984b96639f41d3","reply.jsonSha256":"21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3ecfc6dda2a3e061e7aac37649c7f0f053bf719f6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f498f0d7ebd9d47d3545140282fd2af05dd824a6aa2294c4b1969be7754de6b0","receipt.jsonSha256":"88737414007b505f0efd94b94fe73010c00c1d298a688bdac0408b020b9bc9ec","normalization.jsonSha256":"ed5d2d478b940b2cd97aa26dc3d777f813fbfe8c553db4bd9bf9a94eb3310b66","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"37e03ff157538fe0a652f94a08187a06d31b472ba1f3d1fb68c6146476776320"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"cda8e63406c657a2d2527808f4cc8c688062dd0c80968d349353cabc6cc0f979","reply.jsonSha256":"8165e73a65a0812ac118afc49e2dddb573c747607c62d7d2d31e62c90d14acfc","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c2c2c6e5948b3468e12a29f3ef7507314ab0e797e5856093d9c66a5d5d9be396","receipt.jsonSha256":"17c4a7604553e0f3de5e628efe0f87972ca2b92ad264f8c1eb77143d29ab8e31","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9a2969c637e8565b30abb7a0bb20676b9ce0754c50f334971a52c3923127fed"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:85e78e9f7a4819b874b548a6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:f5b8859abaf378c99bc14e05":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:f5b8859abaf378c99bc14e05","source":"q025-candidate-region:ec6e08226449cb148b80a2d2","target":"q025-candidate-question:c2f24f1ff74140c8291007a8","type":"narrower","title":"Vacua, matter spectra and duality organization","rationale":"Vacuum construction and duality organization retain different supersymmetry sectors and source-dated classification claims.","qualification":"Construction-based vacua and duality organization retain different supersymmetry sectors and source-dated completeness claims.","evidenceIds":["unit:0edef83eff1bb17d04c666f44b410feffb10e730bfb523419a773a766a8c857a","unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","unit:25496b9946799f8ed1dd7634937fe30fb9526a2b33c9d25bb2144cd397a7b689","unit:3ec113b1a492d0cac477acb2114f9075f6173cce165367b264b2d07217cb415c","unit:54a26b94a160f751504f8d5e1638d879b2dce4e3ce9b4528254332685080ad8a","unit:6bdd39a3e96e01c7da81594a27b1218d36e90520d96cae1934aaac2f6fa35958","unit:8ba92a023d5d59be05774747146c255f7921cddedaed6005421fd7e024976dad","unit:9348c648eb6d5adf0f43f0678d2f2e8cac2d220dbd7cc4ef3a91fde2a4bb8650","unit:97a3348ec2dab70902123d2ddb7f1422379fe6e3f4b47918e07069194d1ef062","unit:c2cbcf859ba196c41ba47dd002dfac017ca9988f1af068ca26ac57b3cc1183a3","unit:d104d03f21c890c60e82e263d76a5c415f6840f79c40d09591a6cf5f4aec245d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c2f24f1ff74140c8291007a8"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:f5b8859abaf378c99bc14e05","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge:link:14","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3","parent-native:challenge:8165e73a65a0812ac118afc4"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Vacuum construction and duality organization retain different supersymmetry sectors and source-dated classification claims.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Construction-based vacua and duality organization retain different supersymmetry sectors and source-dated completeness claims.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c2f24f1ff74140c8291007a8"},{"ref":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c2f24f1ff74140c8291007a8"},{"ref":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c758baedbafb89f5b9239e79415bd74ce0de8ed8384f3f0ad1984b96639f41d3","reply.jsonSha256":"21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3ecfc6dda2a3e061e7aac37649c7f0f053bf719f6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f498f0d7ebd9d47d3545140282fd2af05dd824a6aa2294c4b1969be7754de6b0","receipt.jsonSha256":"88737414007b505f0efd94b94fe73010c00c1d298a688bdac0408b020b9bc9ec","normalization.jsonSha256":"ed5d2d478b940b2cd97aa26dc3d777f813fbfe8c553db4bd9bf9a94eb3310b66","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"37e03ff157538fe0a652f94a08187a06d31b472ba1f3d1fb68c6146476776320"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"cda8e63406c657a2d2527808f4cc8c688062dd0c80968d349353cabc6cc0f979","reply.jsonSha256":"8165e73a65a0812ac118afc49e2dddb573c747607c62d7d2d31e62c90d14acfc","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c2c2c6e5948b3468e12a29f3ef7507314ab0e797e5856093d9c66a5d5d9be396","receipt.jsonSha256":"17c4a7604553e0f3de5e628efe0f87972ca2b92ad264f8c1eb77143d29ab8e31","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9a2969c637e8565b30abb7a0bb20676b9ce0754c50f334971a52c3923127fed"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:f5b8859abaf378c99bc14e05","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:94d2ea90863ad6b743a79128":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:94d2ea90863ad6b743a79128","source":"q025-candidate-region:ec6e08226449cb148b80a2d2","target":"q025-candidate-question:fd5211b683511ff4d6b93478","type":"narrower","title":"Global gauge forms, charges and observables","rationale":"Global forms and charge observables remain accessible even when anomaly cancellation is not the principal target.","qualification":"Global forms and charge observables remain accessible independently of whether an anomaly obstruction is the main target.","evidenceIds":["unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","unit:45f28bdd841e03f33ce0e81796fb4fbba803f4253fb618d601abc5a69e7c5353","unit:52c98b3ecfefc5a753b924a798b2c46ce3fd814ac05c174f2dfa5e324e461c18","unit:54a26b94a160f751504f8d5e1638d879b2dce4e3ce9b4528254332685080ad8a","unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","unit:861349d720ff011dd92c295ade59b9adf42ba11310025acb7d4823fbb66bcb0e","unit:9348c648eb6d5adf0f43f0678d2f2e8cac2d220dbd7cc4ef3a91fde2a4bb8650","unit:93ae3371773ab64c00a0cbcd22704d343871f4517542547ea3e4ccf72fb85aec","unit:956d63449be7a77af7aa4c84367966edf27576ceef41c0fd134d77965d1f9e32","unit:9d46e02908e30145753fe44d1a1d7c279348ad4616dc92f6ae52b59a14fff346","unit:a5ecf81198febe8a9c0642d006e13cb7e7d5c1b4971e83a91a4bfc157f5da448","unit:a7177e8793327dba3888663e68928ec37954fa1c5e8719830bf5ae8383972ad7","unit:b638d7f3c7687a6235089349414d265455db69014eeacf5958c538af1c8b4a23","unit:b79bf6bee2d9e939626e355ce794b6c37ba00c2334c91443c8b5efe351c10a93","unit:c0004e1ddfae71878d3d0af962bd12d51efdbcbdb380b6cf7fc3b6b9ef287d1f","unit:c248fec87e2bfd5708e5bcd1949850bbc5095e79807423b9a482283818514825","unit:c2ed7c0b21ec35c68b5c4aef2d222e008d80b72bde163235ef42074f1e38b3b4","unit:d1e4e2e4b2bdae6bb027a859c01bd93b7428ed45adc801720ac9375668db7aec","unit:d7425436138b2c46698af19b33f1a9f174d1e22727b784be92c95778e956a481","unit:ec953ff3566f91db7c79a0daa669c8d014b49b9e10147a14bbf778201e1b6d77","unit:f70667996e73ba08ac4ea6e192061e84206373833edeab9edfa99510f03fe957","unit:ffa85dae501867d7a0833db5c97a4bb162083faacb0bf3d57efcaddd0769fdc3"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fd5211b683511ff4d6b93478"},{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","textSha256":"15b1e590735c3a6ff49a6fa300d6d3ee2db98046685164dddc1c35ae68071cb0"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:94d2ea90863ad6b743a79128","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge:link:5","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3","parent-native:challenge:8165e73a65a0812ac118afc4"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Global forms and charge observables remain accessible even when anomaly cancellation is not the principal target.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Global forms and charge observables remain accessible independently of whether an anomaly obstruction is the main target.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fd5211b683511ff4d6b93478"},{"ref":"d1","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","textSha256":"15b1e590735c3a6ff49a6fa300d6d3ee2db98046685164dddc1c35ae68071cb0"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fd5211b683511ff4d6b93478"},{"ref":"d1","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","textSha256":"15b1e590735c3a6ff49a6fa300d6d3ee2db98046685164dddc1c35ae68071cb0"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c758baedbafb89f5b9239e79415bd74ce0de8ed8384f3f0ad1984b96639f41d3","reply.jsonSha256":"21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3ecfc6dda2a3e061e7aac37649c7f0f053bf719f6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f498f0d7ebd9d47d3545140282fd2af05dd824a6aa2294c4b1969be7754de6b0","receipt.jsonSha256":"88737414007b505f0efd94b94fe73010c00c1d298a688bdac0408b020b9bc9ec","normalization.jsonSha256":"ed5d2d478b940b2cd97aa26dc3d777f813fbfe8c553db4bd9bf9a94eb3310b66","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"37e03ff157538fe0a652f94a08187a06d31b472ba1f3d1fb68c6146476776320"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"cda8e63406c657a2d2527808f4cc8c688062dd0c80968d349353cabc6cc0f979","reply.jsonSha256":"8165e73a65a0812ac118afc49e2dddb573c747607c62d7d2d31e62c90d14acfc","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c2c2c6e5948b3468e12a29f3ef7507314ab0e797e5856093d9c66a5d5d9be396","receipt.jsonSha256":"17c4a7604553e0f3de5e628efe0f87972ca2b92ad264f8c1eb77143d29ab8e31","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9a2969c637e8565b30abb7a0bb20676b9ce0754c50f334971a52c3923127fed"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:94d2ea90863ad6b743a79128","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:f9d50ced85c265bc78709995":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:f9d50ced85c265bc78709995","source":"q025-candidate-region:f174f5f3658af4e764385fd2","target":"q025-candidate-question:15eede7db820c188145c48b5","type":"narrower","title":"Measurements of particle sectors and varying constants","rationale":"Reuse measurement and inference questions, including empirical varying-constant tests.","qualification":"A measurement direction accommodates particle tests and independent searches for varying constants.","evidenceIds":["unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","unit:36f38a0bcfe9b654ecb7a0cf1f78b8db9a38da51786d7cba3deb93177ef94253","unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:f8f05f6f77273996698edae5531e1fecfd426c09a2039483c21834c501f2d479"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:64d5f9b67d11b1a4f7f8c113"},{"localRef":"x4_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e2cee5c300352e35b52b6d08"},{"localRef":"x5_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3c0cd88604668889a65cf7be"},{"localRef":"x6_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d252b2e89ab996553c954c1e"},{"localRef":"p2","kind":"prior_parent_question","sourceId":"q2"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"1202.4758","sourceId":"ev:017b5cc271a4085993eb93d2b58fe8de","sourceSha256":"382f97723a1611e0e6d6fc8a1171a0c640f8a4c141fb0d5dc83c7178fc5b3cdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eac348b16725705a084c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4999a2f720e27bf7c25b63d9589f69d7d4bfd3319fc060ed8a0111ba0caa2fce","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"cb0505cc615b58558f4e8baf04e41d57e5caa558f2f9aa373ac833877722d07a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","paperId":"1202.4758","sourceId":"ev:d304cd462b7ce83b12b70497d4217bcc","sourceSha256":"382f97723a1611e0e6d6fc8a1171a0c640f8a4c141fb0d5dc83c7178fc5b3cdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eac348b16725705a084c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4999a2f720e27bf7c25b63d9589f69d7d4bfd3319fc060ed8a0111ba0caa2fce","pdfPage":1,"start":1304,"end":4131,"textSha256":"5da67b79ec0740232099052a4c8c75281f9025d2a712f8e23fdea1bb15392c2a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:f9d50ced85c265bc78709995","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:10","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd","parent-native:challenge:a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse measurement and inference questions, including empirical varying-constant tests.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"A measurement direction accommodates particle tests and independent searches for varying constants.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:64d5f9b67d11b1a4f7f8c113"},{"ref":"x4_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e2cee5c300352e35b52b6d08"},{"ref":"x5_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3c0cd88604668889a65cf7be"},{"ref":"x6_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d252b2e89ab996553c954c1e"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"p2","kind":"prior_parent_question","sourceId":"q2"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"1202.4758","sourceId":"ev:017b5cc271a4085993eb93d2b58fe8de","sourceSha256":"382f97723a1611e0e6d6fc8a1171a0c640f8a4c141fb0d5dc83c7178fc5b3cdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eac348b16725705a084c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4999a2f720e27bf7c25b63d9589f69d7d4bfd3319fc060ed8a0111ba0caa2fce","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"cb0505cc615b58558f4e8baf04e41d57e5caa558f2f9aa373ac833877722d07a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e19","kind":"primary","paperId":"1202.4758","sourceId":"ev:d304cd462b7ce83b12b70497d4217bcc","sourceSha256":"382f97723a1611e0e6d6fc8a1171a0c640f8a4c141fb0d5dc83c7178fc5b3cdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eac348b16725705a084c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4999a2f720e27bf7c25b63d9589f69d7d4bfd3319fc060ed8a0111ba0caa2fce","pdfPage":1,"start":1304,"end":4131,"textSha256":"5da67b79ec0740232099052a4c8c75281f9025d2a712f8e23fdea1bb15392c2a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"0d479554dd0b39ca9daf07157c4f39675210457752a02cafa57ef8e2f52bfa7e","reply.jsonSha256":"b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd4722ba8dda705c880ad49294161d9061295ac5c5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9f3caf81e788c84ac0164350156eee9d2eb362baacf7ad9f05eaf093273877e8","receipt.jsonSha256":"1165f285c2c643f1a2270fabeb515a22bfcd8476412d71364f6c4b7cc0b1b52b","normalization.jsonSha256":"65d79380e46d8c2f1a63efb46f5d49883594612e5b03d1e4c4c4cbcabbee2346","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4a44ea5475d2801e35e1e86aad6ff99d9db2dce8307fdc2c9041f7beb32dd37a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"876fcf82b3760877d5adf0ad3cea3352e0f0e96e9be01cbf7c7325a0609e4a55","reply.jsonSha256":"a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d2e1d06273788a3258264e645c16dcacdaa3f68ac","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d04dfd346aec28f9d51f6dd453759d3040c159c9b9041a0287eecdb7310d96d9","receipt.jsonSha256":"a1fa78d73a75fe703fb1cbeac5b35a16ddc235795219891d7e028e0e8f09c26b","normalization.jsonSha256":"2e493e2c7f4741d29428ad8769d68daf9d37a86a64b17eea548d298edea89613"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:f9d50ced85c265bc78709995","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:a6dda0e2b5e6f8da649efa9a":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:a6dda0e2b5e6f8da649efa9a","source":"q025-candidate-region:f174f5f3658af4e764385fd2","target":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","type":"narrower","title":"Candidates and cosmic origins","rationale":"Reuse candidate construction and cosmic origins across distinct dark relic species and production mechanisms.","qualification":"Reuse the existing candidate-and-origin question for dark relics across particle and axion-related sources.","evidenceIds":["unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","unit:086443a70e473b97b9bf2b7cef696694c8b0c2e3ed9d6cce4c0e47b19fb12e22","unit:0ac5f33eee9e30f13d39d3e40376e84955b2b4250896a9c79dff2932fe52ddfe","unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","unit:1e96331a613901b21e0941d90c6652e41bcf7c74ba6030bed0a42d0a478e2968","unit:2d3d65b41648c0f939fba5152e588f2fb018d4e2274f758e39c6b9da23a72c57","unit:36f38a0bcfe9b654ecb7a0cf1f78b8db9a38da51786d7cba3deb93177ef94253","unit:383d13703c71f3f25373a6ba0e1661f1e7e8cdeb7bd60a8065f24cc2200577f8","unit:3a27d6408cf96805cf6c280eb0c67b7715232bc784b79320000b8679b38de17a","unit:4388ba5c525b417e4a3e81463cabf723b16fda2447df04105d5d37c95b9f7fad","unit:56017bdcddd38ed7cba4066f0d2855ab32f64ec5330fc5104299358b29497dba","unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","unit:699d34cdd7756d1c072c7a517702ec67f86c041e11097f1ed8ca0fb4a3816e82","unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","unit:743a5ec4ec3327442a03957751dfa536fef453cc99c934ad167cc223432045a0","unit:886390bae4de13ca3fa9e42b4829aee4c1b2f9d3fa5107860df6115430055e16","unit:8e20c0326768a1f649bdfd14b44bd23e09092673cf36a5ad36fe7532ac92f1c6","unit:96c6613c2dd137e812dbc4166a6e8ead41b9b0d2a2518722c8fa4f4de6056bbc","unit:9f867e2655c9ee718616d07641d24237d81c9f1ee269a6f9ce1169bb7a5ebaee","unit:a757dfd6e7766fa39431351f4621d054ffbea3c8fc2ad8463b5fe265bc329bf7","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:c78813fed1118a3a9647db73b578c6931e7f80a6e2ea08f4a434be88cb997525","unit:cf0f5d73068de72fc720bc98c5772e2ad522fbd1b1df061575a88c53cc930bb5","unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","unit:dbed9b6879afe9a03c27774aa14c0f3595a9a18d55979fecac48c074509831f2","unit:f8f05f6f77273996698edae5531e1fecfd426c09a2039483c21834c501f2d479"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"0905.3039","sourceId":"ev:3fb3e29b97881cd7c7d563df16bcc96b","sourceSha256":"00688f7c4f719e4076d838a9afd1a4c3d9ae93d9846cbee7f4b12c75da9a2ed9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5239cbaa86b924ee1ca5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"151bfc27361f800cae8aa583e93b41228ce47dcf61c8b97edacbefc47a24e894","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2126,"textSha256":"f51adf68dd4e74b3411026d919653f474bc359713cde29ba2469a37816643ef6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"1810.07188","sourceId":"ev:86c04a91e8313a18f51161ff8eafaf6c","sourceSha256":"fb625cec828bb20a2a569f76b3583271bded3125c7a415dd83a57be677175285","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6605b27afc85b20399a6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4f2aedeadfd1deda4dde3df877d7d5ae6622e2eeb5962f0e8c545069bbd09353","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"08f02d946716f3da421c6599deb01375aa94b2e026a401c259ceec5e0f84045b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:a6dda0e2b5e6f8da649efa9a","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:7","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd","parent-native:challenge:a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse candidate construction and cosmic origins across distinct dark relic species and production mechanisms.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the existing candidate-and-origin question for dark relics across particle and axion-related sources.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"0905.3039","sourceId":"ev:3fb3e29b97881cd7c7d563df16bcc96b","sourceSha256":"00688f7c4f719e4076d838a9afd1a4c3d9ae93d9846cbee7f4b12c75da9a2ed9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5239cbaa86b924ee1ca5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"151bfc27361f800cae8aa583e93b41228ce47dcf61c8b97edacbefc47a24e894","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2126,"textSha256":"f51adf68dd4e74b3411026d919653f474bc359713cde29ba2469a37816643ef6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"1810.07188","sourceId":"ev:86c04a91e8313a18f51161ff8eafaf6c","sourceSha256":"fb625cec828bb20a2a569f76b3583271bded3125c7a415dd83a57be677175285","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6605b27afc85b20399a6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4f2aedeadfd1deda4dde3df877d7d5ae6622e2eeb5962f0e8c545069bbd09353","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"08f02d946716f3da421c6599deb01375aa94b2e026a401c259ceec5e0f84045b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"0905.3039","sourceId":"ev:3fb3e29b97881cd7c7d563df16bcc96b","sourceSha256":"00688f7c4f719e4076d838a9afd1a4c3d9ae93d9846cbee7f4b12c75da9a2ed9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5239cbaa86b924ee1ca5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"151bfc27361f800cae8aa583e93b41228ce47dcf61c8b97edacbefc47a24e894","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2126,"textSha256":"f51adf68dd4e74b3411026d919653f474bc359713cde29ba2469a37816643ef6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"1810.07188","sourceId":"ev:86c04a91e8313a18f51161ff8eafaf6c","sourceSha256":"fb625cec828bb20a2a569f76b3583271bded3125c7a415dd83a57be677175285","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6605b27afc85b20399a6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4f2aedeadfd1deda4dde3df877d7d5ae6622e2eeb5962f0e8c545069bbd09353","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"08f02d946716f3da421c6599deb01375aa94b2e026a401c259ceec5e0f84045b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"0d479554dd0b39ca9daf07157c4f39675210457752a02cafa57ef8e2f52bfa7e","reply.jsonSha256":"b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd4722ba8dda705c880ad49294161d9061295ac5c5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9f3caf81e788c84ac0164350156eee9d2eb362baacf7ad9f05eaf093273877e8","receipt.jsonSha256":"1165f285c2c643f1a2270fabeb515a22bfcd8476412d71364f6c4b7cc0b1b52b","normalization.jsonSha256":"65d79380e46d8c2f1a63efb46f5d49883594612e5b03d1e4c4c4cbcabbee2346","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4a44ea5475d2801e35e1e86aad6ff99d9db2dce8307fdc2c9041f7beb32dd37a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"876fcf82b3760877d5adf0ad3cea3352e0f0e96e9be01cbf7c7325a0609e4a55","reply.jsonSha256":"a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d2e1d06273788a3258264e645c16dcacdaa3f68ac","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d04dfd346aec28f9d51f6dd453759d3040c159c9b9041a0287eecdb7310d96d9","receipt.jsonSha256":"a1fa78d73a75fe703fb1cbeac5b35a16ddc235795219891d7e028e0e8f09c26b","normalization.jsonSha256":"2e493e2c7f4741d29428ad8769d68daf9d37a86a64b17eea548d298edea89613"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:a6dda0e2b5e6f8da649efa9a","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:16b14c23195616e3cdc9f739":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:16b14c23195616e3cdc9f739","source":"q025-candidate-region:f174f5f3658af4e764385fd2","target":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5","type":"narrower","title":"Scalar potentials, physical trajectories and cosmic evolution","rationale":"Reuse the shared scalar-potential, trajectory and cosmic-evolution direction.","qualification":"A shared scalar-dynamics direction organizes range, vacuum and cosmological questions across batches.","evidenceIds":["unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","unit:36f38a0bcfe9b654ecb7a0cf1f78b8db9a38da51786d7cba3deb93177ef94253","unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a","unit:f8f05f6f77273996698edae5531e1fecfd426c09a2039483c21834c501f2d479"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8"},{"localRef":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e8e6b3ce91854a1f951673cb"},{"localRef":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a933bcee7169dcddca789765"},{"localRef":"x5_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a038991cd90f75408deae378"},{"localRef":"x5_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb053304be3775d8c79d2f4"},{"localRef":"p0","kind":"prior_parent_question","sourceId":"q0"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"1409.5793","sourceId":"ev:4332d9c182c65cadc0f4a696367986ec","sourceSha256":"6221e370748694c7330e0d6550cd1396503021964a1d9a81f6d733b1b1dbc338","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3093c328a6fd30539a1e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4f0a1142969720809f1b236b1333d507d20710b37d3281a8eb57d2a43243fe27","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2704,"textSha256":"a21591a17f76fe0add11bd842a6e146e2daa15a792b1c9095ce082e48c3cf258","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:5a2e732afa0228bb0d2ebc3a8af9f62a","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3493,"textSha256":"15a6c25c062e0337468495e8677e600e961960919a557c1279f5f4aa87e6ed7e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1812.07558","sourceId":"ev:3537e818df942d2ff09de23cfe140800","sourceSha256":"654bbb5a4b7ae3f43fd6a9dc93e7f05ea202967be9e560117956c27cfa6679dd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8a22553f66b06003a453/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"57f7ae0cfad83626d602a8d334ce6ea250b4eb5f3520d98b61ea247a26b42be3","pdfPage":11,"start":2122,"end":4610,"textSha256":"c0f21e49619e6d40bb503f8504596f4c52cab3db4a5957b2ba530cfe9bfe0c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:16b14c23195616e3cdc9f739","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:8","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd","parent-native:challenge:a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse the shared scalar-potential, trajectory and cosmic-evolution direction.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"A shared scalar-dynamics direction organizes range, vacuum and cosmological questions across batches.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8"},{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e8e6b3ce91854a1f951673cb"},{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a933bcee7169dcddca789765"},{"ref":"x5_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a038991cd90f75408deae378"},{"ref":"x5_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb053304be3775d8c79d2f4"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"p0","kind":"prior_parent_question","sourceId":"q0"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"1409.5793","sourceId":"ev:4332d9c182c65cadc0f4a696367986ec","sourceSha256":"6221e370748694c7330e0d6550cd1396503021964a1d9a81f6d733b1b1dbc338","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3093c328a6fd30539a1e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4f0a1142969720809f1b236b1333d507d20710b37d3281a8eb57d2a43243fe27","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2704,"textSha256":"a21591a17f76fe0add11bd842a6e146e2daa15a792b1c9095ce082e48c3cf258","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:5a2e732afa0228bb0d2ebc3a8af9f62a","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3493,"textSha256":"15a6c25c062e0337468495e8677e600e961960919a557c1279f5f4aa87e6ed7e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1812.07558","sourceId":"ev:3537e818df942d2ff09de23cfe140800","sourceSha256":"654bbb5a4b7ae3f43fd6a9dc93e7f05ea202967be9e560117956c27cfa6679dd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8a22553f66b06003a453/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"57f7ae0cfad83626d602a8d334ce6ea250b4eb5f3520d98b61ea247a26b42be3","pdfPage":11,"start":2122,"end":4610,"textSha256":"c0f21e49619e6d40bb503f8504596f4c52cab3db4a5957b2ba530cfe9bfe0c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"0d479554dd0b39ca9daf07157c4f39675210457752a02cafa57ef8e2f52bfa7e","reply.jsonSha256":"b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd4722ba8dda705c880ad49294161d9061295ac5c5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9f3caf81e788c84ac0164350156eee9d2eb362baacf7ad9f05eaf093273877e8","receipt.jsonSha256":"1165f285c2c643f1a2270fabeb515a22bfcd8476412d71364f6c4b7cc0b1b52b","normalization.jsonSha256":"65d79380e46d8c2f1a63efb46f5d49883594612e5b03d1e4c4c4cbcabbee2346","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4a44ea5475d2801e35e1e86aad6ff99d9db2dce8307fdc2c9041f7beb32dd37a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"876fcf82b3760877d5adf0ad3cea3352e0f0e96e9be01cbf7c7325a0609e4a55","reply.jsonSha256":"a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d2e1d06273788a3258264e645c16dcacdaa3f68ac","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d04dfd346aec28f9d51f6dd453759d3040c159c9b9041a0287eecdb7310d96d9","receipt.jsonSha256":"a1fa78d73a75fe703fb1cbeac5b35a16ddc235795219891d7e028e0e8f09c26b","normalization.jsonSha256":"2e493e2c7f4741d29428ad8769d68daf9d37a86a64b17eea548d298edea89613"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:16b14c23195616e3cdc9f739","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:379a95fa74d6eebb5b30b3a9":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:379a95fa74d6eebb5b30b3a9","source":"q025-candidate-region:f174f5f3658af4e764385fd2","target":"q025-candidate-question:f8d258f07eb369740028cc21","type":"narrower","title":"Mass generation, symmetry protection and particle stability","rationale":"Reuse the mass-generation, CP and protection direction without a common symmetry premise.","qualification":"A shared mechanism direction connects masses, physical CP and particle protection while retaining different symmetries.","evidenceIds":["unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","unit:36f38a0bcfe9b654ecb7a0cf1f78b8db9a38da51786d7cba3deb93177ef94253","unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:f8f05f6f77273996698edae5531e1fecfd426c09a2039483c21834c501f2d479"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bfe372a2298b01d22d9cf52c"},{"localRef":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d5f8fa5d7ea8d89342670ca5"},{"localRef":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c1f9aa1a4410c9c93d81aad4"},{"localRef":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2957ddb1117e80052e226768"},{"localRef":"x4_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24124b028c946c6bc1e48479"},{"localRef":"p1","kind":"prior_parent_question","sourceId":"q1"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"0905.3039","sourceId":"ev:3fb3e29b97881cd7c7d563df16bcc96b","sourceSha256":"00688f7c4f719e4076d838a9afd1a4c3d9ae93d9846cbee7f4b12c75da9a2ed9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5239cbaa86b924ee1ca5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"151bfc27361f800cae8aa583e93b41228ce47dcf61c8b97edacbefc47a24e894","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2126,"textSha256":"f51adf68dd4e74b3411026d919653f474bc359713cde29ba2469a37816643ef6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2209.14219","sourceId":"ev:11014a27e05f2fe9ecf45074c34f9bbc","sourceSha256":"a13831f3df2f5c0729e748c4b6ffc3121a360bf0e34d04658a0fe1ca4607d3a8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca2c5708f32ba00d2977/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fbf50a01af6aa90632004bc747b5d2df3e20e45ced5e7fc3809251084f6ab1ca","pdfPage":1,"start":2496,"end":5338,"textSha256":"83cb06712a3c3179734d2c9010821dff425500a3c2e8721fe05498256498fb93","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"2110.15755","sourceId":"ev:6f0b46b8040641d430778d6aa5a6e855","sourceSha256":"49b942675ae95ad094f4b7e4e7f9746986a05b4b0eb91c65f01492b7956a7e6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/70a8ab94eab8ffb96dea/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9326dfe963d219e34f551884bc27c4c4471526f6d03a5b8ec7bb19757029eb51","pdfPage":119,"start":102,"end":1968,"textSha256":"af11943a5bf736e0d25a2f03d86d0fbe23e4a63f980bcce67b19382efb8fea4b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:379a95fa74d6eebb5b30b3a9","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:9","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd","parent-native:challenge:a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse the mass-generation, CP and protection direction without a common symmetry premise.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"A shared mechanism direction connects masses, physical CP and particle protection while retaining different symmetries.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bfe372a2298b01d22d9cf52c"},{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d5f8fa5d7ea8d89342670ca5"},{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c1f9aa1a4410c9c93d81aad4"},{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2957ddb1117e80052e226768"},{"ref":"x4_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24124b028c946c6bc1e48479"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"p1","kind":"prior_parent_question","sourceId":"q1"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"0905.3039","sourceId":"ev:3fb3e29b97881cd7c7d563df16bcc96b","sourceSha256":"00688f7c4f719e4076d838a9afd1a4c3d9ae93d9846cbee7f4b12c75da9a2ed9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5239cbaa86b924ee1ca5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"151bfc27361f800cae8aa583e93b41228ce47dcf61c8b97edacbefc47a24e894","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2126,"textSha256":"f51adf68dd4e74b3411026d919653f474bc359713cde29ba2469a37816643ef6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2209.14219","sourceId":"ev:11014a27e05f2fe9ecf45074c34f9bbc","sourceSha256":"a13831f3df2f5c0729e748c4b6ffc3121a360bf0e34d04658a0fe1ca4607d3a8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca2c5708f32ba00d2977/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fbf50a01af6aa90632004bc747b5d2df3e20e45ced5e7fc3809251084f6ab1ca","pdfPage":1,"start":2496,"end":5338,"textSha256":"83cb06712a3c3179734d2c9010821dff425500a3c2e8721fe05498256498fb93","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"2110.15755","sourceId":"ev:6f0b46b8040641d430778d6aa5a6e855","sourceSha256":"49b942675ae95ad094f4b7e4e7f9746986a05b4b0eb91c65f01492b7956a7e6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/70a8ab94eab8ffb96dea/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9326dfe963d219e34f551884bc27c4c4471526f6d03a5b8ec7bb19757029eb51","pdfPage":119,"start":102,"end":1968,"textSha256":"af11943a5bf736e0d25a2f03d86d0fbe23e4a63f980bcce67b19382efb8fea4b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"0d479554dd0b39ca9daf07157c4f39675210457752a02cafa57ef8e2f52bfa7e","reply.jsonSha256":"b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd4722ba8dda705c880ad49294161d9061295ac5c5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9f3caf81e788c84ac0164350156eee9d2eb362baacf7ad9f05eaf093273877e8","receipt.jsonSha256":"1165f285c2c643f1a2270fabeb515a22bfcd8476412d71364f6c4b7cc0b1b52b","normalization.jsonSha256":"65d79380e46d8c2f1a63efb46f5d49883594612e5b03d1e4c4c4cbcabbee2346","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4a44ea5475d2801e35e1e86aad6ff99d9db2dce8307fdc2c9041f7beb32dd37a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"876fcf82b3760877d5adf0ad3cea3352e0f0e96e9be01cbf7c7325a0609e4a55","reply.jsonSha256":"a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d2e1d06273788a3258264e645c16dcacdaa3f68ac","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d04dfd346aec28f9d51f6dd453759d3040c159c9b9041a0287eecdb7310d96d9","receipt.jsonSha256":"a1fa78d73a75fe703fb1cbeac5b35a16ddc235795219891d7e028e0e8f09c26b","normalization.jsonSha256":"2e493e2c7f4741d29428ad8769d68daf9d37a86a64b17eea548d298edea89613"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:379a95fa74d6eebb5b30b3a9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:59726d06c5ce75fd3caeb32b":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:59726d06c5ce75fd3caeb32b","source":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","target":"q025-candidate-question:161ab9fa038592a6586e54e1","type":"narrower","title":"Vacuum energy and the supersymmetry-breaking scale","rationale":"Reuse the vacuum-energy and supersymmetry-scale question while keeping cancellation, uplift and scale-setting proposals distinct.","qualification":"Reuse the vacuum-energy and supersymmetry-scale question while keeping cancellation, uplift and scale-setting proposals distinct.","evidenceIds":["unit:0d525c9f5e14caffc01d4336fe6c35719270c11af023ab0194298a8ee1633d8f","unit:2ddfcadcceb2aea604a04a0a6c73f83a49b1a8e522236751e37c2da6bad3220d","unit:4331be7cb1ef5b8888984ef61f04719c84ee8920565e48ab0fe0ba72c71b43a0","unit:6131a6c0aa4375fe3b59d41504466f7b76de87a8815953a9c3ec2646e852962b","unit:72784e5fa42228a07fbb4371b3ca08be6b570d412a30841e500d2629c5cd8cee","unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","unit:acfa3c138fe7f7b17c784ccfc8c8cea3c9281ba86224d642963559b38f4a1c7c","unit:adf249b07b18434ba58b71fbc9873ff45a6694164faf5f0759e34b3b5fba5174","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:c656e3015e47f1c8f03051c24f2999d157f01024b3bbfe258f7becd3c312a859","unit:d6c532a0767d19c246874778435da569beb823103147b8652f709c74bb673463","unit:e16f67137d2df72baca21302278a1e8186aa7d5cfe7eb4248957ac4d1727291e","unit:ea468168deccbaf5737c0a01b59625146a2687e04e22d35ea765ea482bbbfa82","unit:f12074876d2226dff1c73eb66784473fe6b8027a2e23b350b437f6572f3fb433","unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:161ab9fa038592a6586e54e1"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:59726d06c5ce75fd3caeb32b","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:9","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baa","parent-native:challenge:56f480852079df01466714ab"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse the vacuum-energy and supersymmetry-scale question while keeping cancellation, uplift and scale-setting proposals distinct.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the vacuum-energy and supersymmetry-scale question while keeping cancellation, uplift and scale-setting proposals distinct.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:161ab9fa038592a6586e54e1"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:161ab9fa038592a6586e54e1"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d644ddab626378471e4e0e42e4647c7e7a25fecadbaa1e63a95a554f87191605","reply.jsonSha256":"6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baaa57c3371646728a9a6fdf0dbcf6993ec3823ad12","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d31aef6575a76f59717d4759f4579ffdd1d56fd28b78e02e8db7fc516e6047f7","receipt.jsonSha256":"9e433a0026eb4f85d23db2f00953ee9a3ae4a365086892133927c9d41ea370b0","normalization.jsonSha256":"183ad7569d3dae4c3d0b00de6b21c3f4f4bf7a84481aad349887a3baf49e221a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"cda5fe05a626a0f00541f652aa13f42b5d89bc4664a6f297b0a65b2db3d67f04"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec2db46cf22a587a919921edc537a478392d749e785a8148972bd1e70652a9ea","reply.jsonSha256":"56f480852079df01466714ab316a55727b30a2e0de94c29702889e66cda21363","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3f9873c2026cbfa22c8a3d0437949e4299c0be824d455277cf16d93676a1394e","receipt.jsonSha256":"e14c0967089e928b0b363cde04fa9a71ebc69e8422f7e25bc9ac929991d8120c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d7163380927a596c08f8f55bcb25bd02a8d363abdbb6eeeea8f0a08f9a8bcb4f"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:59726d06c5ce75fd3caeb32b","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:1897b40b3f8b34018b3b525d":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:1897b40b3f8b34018b3b525d","source":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","target":"q025-candidate-question:626250d1cf4fae4cb2f38b96","type":"narrower","title":"Higgs vacuum stability, criticality and inference","rationale":"Keep vacuum stability, lifetime and instability-scale inference accessible as diagnostic targets with their own assumptions.","qualification":"Preserve stability and lifetime as independently useful diagnostic targets, including their role in selection proposals.","evidenceIds":["unit:17d09347dd939560dcc1c42ad2a82bce66a5ba7b20f2e06b93bab1d9f22683d5","unit:199f6b0fce9bae286503fdf2418b2a96c35e0c2dca9e9f4293e8fc22f15fcd8c","unit:27d10739a4173802d43927c8caddb54b4369d4945c7c43f06c7b50aefabcb2ed","unit:87cdd4696e9d733a20e8eb8482a1305d323d9f5f52df715697120c99bf4361d4","unit:aa4774c7a943ccbad2a52983890c11a232dc2915e66e61c1180f68a23b8ab082","unit:aab8de110b756774005a643db1f1a2ff7f10b0b4dce92da670e9d5a153c7e322","unit:b0f6c76cc535164b7cbed504ce3b6e2ac0d8dcb369edf65a3c67a3d67952aa01","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:c10774b049cb18ec9c9f0b2e958fc0ab6cd71b451bd85c494dbd49a4cddd4761","unit:c632a2e01571c45f72132a1a610dad6ce2f62e9c3bac4cdaf899b7712d57deb4","unit:d1a88fa786d7359ef81cda261da55738b7fdfaa0bbd02d6d7b15a915dd25f175","unit:e16f67137d2df72baca21302278a1e8186aa7d5cfe7eb4248957ac4d1727291e","unit:ed2192dc41e60e41e23c386e995dfd77891c81c89b5de451b1354e6a607cbde4","unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:626250d1cf4fae4cb2f38b96"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:a0251bebe68a60253ffa41cbc11bfb0f","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"eb684df53b76cc4bc8746e1233ab1bace2fd8fbbf645352cdacd40bfca85ba0a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:7a7de13567ad7751d33811288481e377","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":3537,"textSha256":"d5e1c22f29a0b9878cc7a0aa8f915b45d95035246c848e5db876cdaf84dfa894","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:1897b40b3f8b34018b3b525d","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:5","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baa","parent-native:challenge:56f480852079df01466714ab"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Keep vacuum stability, lifetime and instability-scale inference accessible as diagnostic targets with their own assumptions.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Preserve stability and lifetime as independently useful diagnostic targets, including their role in selection proposals.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:626250d1cf4fae4cb2f38b96"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:a0251bebe68a60253ffa41cbc11bfb0f","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"eb684df53b76cc4bc8746e1233ab1bace2fd8fbbf645352cdacd40bfca85ba0a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:626250d1cf4fae4cb2f38b96"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:7a7de13567ad7751d33811288481e377","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":3537,"textSha256":"d5e1c22f29a0b9878cc7a0aa8f915b45d95035246c848e5db876cdaf84dfa894","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:a0251bebe68a60253ffa41cbc11bfb0f","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"eb684df53b76cc4bc8746e1233ab1bace2fd8fbbf645352cdacd40bfca85ba0a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d644ddab626378471e4e0e42e4647c7e7a25fecadbaa1e63a95a554f87191605","reply.jsonSha256":"6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baaa57c3371646728a9a6fdf0dbcf6993ec3823ad12","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d31aef6575a76f59717d4759f4579ffdd1d56fd28b78e02e8db7fc516e6047f7","receipt.jsonSha256":"9e433a0026eb4f85d23db2f00953ee9a3ae4a365086892133927c9d41ea370b0","normalization.jsonSha256":"183ad7569d3dae4c3d0b00de6b21c3f4f4bf7a84481aad349887a3baf49e221a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"cda5fe05a626a0f00541f652aa13f42b5d89bc4664a6f297b0a65b2db3d67f04"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec2db46cf22a587a919921edc537a478392d749e785a8148972bd1e70652a9ea","reply.jsonSha256":"56f480852079df01466714ab316a55727b30a2e0de94c29702889e66cda21363","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3f9873c2026cbfa22c8a3d0437949e4299c0be824d455277cf16d93676a1394e","receipt.jsonSha256":"e14c0967089e928b0b363cde04fa9a71ebc69e8422f7e25bc9ac929991d8120c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d7163380927a596c08f8f55bcb25bd02a8d363abdbb6eeeea8f0a08f9a8bcb4f"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:1897b40b3f8b34018b3b525d","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:a0cf7b336a41d072a971c566":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:a0cf7b336a41d072a971c566","source":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","target":"q025-candidate-question:83d666a45156c1d95c78009f","type":"comparison","title":"Standard Model history and motivations for future searches","rationale":"Retain the historical proceedings question as an alternate home for discovery history and future motivations.","qualification":"Provide an alternate historical home for the proceedings contrast without making its broad research motivations a hierarchy mechanism.","evidenceIds":["unit:0cdd3a7c49c125358eeef64a14af2934fde686da2b70a553e7f1e2e3bd3e217a","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:e16f67137d2df72baca21302278a1e8186aa7d5cfe7eb4248957ac4d1727291e","unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"2507.14275","sourceId":"ev:0e60f3fd69164079bda855c55f6a5e49","sourceSha256":"fafe6cd691c4e3599747df84683159ee43f175386c612976e796a917706a4333","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/82453d200d22be41c8b3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"28cc732c63808cdfd8a705160e388a7d42fd45f2827e052b3ff49f798daf78b7","pdfPage":4,"start":1298,"end":4413,"textSha256":"61bb6880a43f26a0649df6f732b3eeb50862813ad23249c4334d5a3d0f487ab4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2507.14275","sourceId":"ev:9adf1a5adcb6c4dfd3a0133e81a1ea21","sourceSha256":"fafe6cd691c4e3599747df84683159ee43f175386c612976e796a917706a4333","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/82453d200d22be41c8b3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"28cc732c63808cdfd8a705160e388a7d42fd45f2827e052b3ff49f798daf78b7","pdfPage":4,"start":101,"end":3497,"textSha256":"ed705b937f339dcee90b1acd2be3b03607fff1ca64b3c0d1a0d01805377dcf12","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"p0","kind":"prior_parent_question","sourceId":"q0"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:a0cf7b336a41d072a971c566","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:14","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baa","parent-native:challenge:56f480852079df01466714ab"],"originalNativeType":"comparison","challengeReason":"Retain the historical proceedings question as an alternate home for discovery history and future motivations.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Provide an alternate historical home for the proceedings contrast without making its broad research motivations a hierarchy mechanism.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"2507.14275","sourceId":"ev:0e60f3fd69164079bda855c55f6a5e49","sourceSha256":"fafe6cd691c4e3599747df84683159ee43f175386c612976e796a917706a4333","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/82453d200d22be41c8b3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"28cc732c63808cdfd8a705160e388a7d42fd45f2827e052b3ff49f798daf78b7","pdfPage":4,"start":1298,"end":4413,"textSha256":"61bb6880a43f26a0649df6f732b3eeb50862813ad23249c4334d5a3d0f487ab4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2507.14275","sourceId":"ev:9adf1a5adcb6c4dfd3a0133e81a1ea21","sourceSha256":"fafe6cd691c4e3599747df84683159ee43f175386c612976e796a917706a4333","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/82453d200d22be41c8b3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"28cc732c63808cdfd8a705160e388a7d42fd45f2827e052b3ff49f798daf78b7","pdfPage":4,"start":101,"end":3497,"textSha256":"ed705b937f339dcee90b1acd2be3b03607fff1ca64b3c0d1a0d01805377dcf12","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"p0","kind":"prior_parent_question","sourceId":"q0"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"2507.14275","sourceId":"ev:0e60f3fd69164079bda855c55f6a5e49","sourceSha256":"fafe6cd691c4e3599747df84683159ee43f175386c612976e796a917706a4333","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/82453d200d22be41c8b3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"28cc732c63808cdfd8a705160e388a7d42fd45f2827e052b3ff49f798daf78b7","pdfPage":4,"start":1298,"end":4413,"textSha256":"61bb6880a43f26a0649df6f732b3eeb50862813ad23249c4334d5a3d0f487ab4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2507.14275","sourceId":"ev:9adf1a5adcb6c4dfd3a0133e81a1ea21","sourceSha256":"fafe6cd691c4e3599747df84683159ee43f175386c612976e796a917706a4333","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/82453d200d22be41c8b3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"28cc732c63808cdfd8a705160e388a7d42fd45f2827e052b3ff49f798daf78b7","pdfPage":4,"start":101,"end":3497,"textSha256":"ed705b937f339dcee90b1acd2be3b03607fff1ca64b3c0d1a0d01805377dcf12","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d644ddab626378471e4e0e42e4647c7e7a25fecadbaa1e63a95a554f87191605","reply.jsonSha256":"6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baaa57c3371646728a9a6fdf0dbcf6993ec3823ad12","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d31aef6575a76f59717d4759f4579ffdd1d56fd28b78e02e8db7fc516e6047f7","receipt.jsonSha256":"9e433a0026eb4f85d23db2f00953ee9a3ae4a365086892133927c9d41ea370b0","normalization.jsonSha256":"183ad7569d3dae4c3d0b00de6b21c3f4f4bf7a84481aad349887a3baf49e221a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"cda5fe05a626a0f00541f652aa13f42b5d89bc4664a6f297b0a65b2db3d67f04"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec2db46cf22a587a919921edc537a478392d749e785a8148972bd1e70652a9ea","reply.jsonSha256":"56f480852079df01466714ab316a55727b30a2e0de94c29702889e66cda21363","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3f9873c2026cbfa22c8a3d0437949e4299c0be824d455277cf16d93676a1394e","receipt.jsonSha256":"e14c0967089e928b0b363cde04fa9a71ebc69e8422f7e25bc9ac929991d8120c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d7163380927a596c08f8f55bcb25bd02a8d363abdbb6eeeea8f0a08f9a8bcb4f"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"comparison","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"comparison","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:a0cf7b336a41d072a971c566","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:c670c7211c36a337027bd773":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:c670c7211c36a337027bd773","source":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","target":"q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a","type":"narrower","title":"Cosmological viability of supersymmetry-breaking sectors","rationale":"Preserve supersymmetry-sector cosmological viability, including vacuum evolution and histories beyond late-modulus decay.","qualification":"Keep broader supersymmetry-sector cosmological viability accessible, including vacuum selection and histories beyond late-modulus decay.","evidenceIds":["unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","unit:06d0fff814a1ccfbc9c6fc6722b6a758f63b71fbbda46dffd5e1745f57d4723b","unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","unit:1d39a7630ee3159f91ad89bdf62c078a4dd1b6675a5f1dcaea10c449cf9d24f6","unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","unit:66f2128fe3c730b2c6401827e2da1852e7022d1fbc910e8bdfa4ea219db44ee9","unit:86bdd8dbc9e3994b23ea8394c40a8c95b2c6cf1488c02715afa36663c68c2495","unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:ba2db2d76dd6ce5790bb60ec53801f7a3dcc9b3b31008a748cc4b2135a5fc45f","unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","unit:c85f81c5a449a568894fda092cbbcd10adb8c797ffb1e7ef9afea547ca5f1d49","unit:def0cc0aaaca0f3f633f056025e839e8d87045631214f1060e58c46d7001255d","unit:e16f67137d2df72baca21302278a1e8186aa7d5cfe7eb4248957ac4d1727291e","unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"0804.0863","sourceId":"ev:721d9c9acde0509dbf3c4cc24657d325","sourceSha256":"ca626475b9b29c674fd471998c558b67c88bfebd4ff0ceeeff839b80039fa487","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1deec9f65b4e990b6597/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"469c036d9822dcfecc48a52c8ad26ad8c5fe3968c70538ac43f1f29ed2683464","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":1464,"textSha256":"a5c3cfbee1c233c94c9cf672718ae696e0565d0e7e848eb643f4bccb9e7d2631","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"0804.0863","sourceId":"ev:a3892f73cb9c8e27bc7b4c95274c8bc3","sourceSha256":"ca626475b9b29c674fd471998c558b67c88bfebd4ff0ceeeff839b80039fa487","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1deec9f65b4e990b6597/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"469c036d9822dcfecc48a52c8ad26ad8c5fe3968c70538ac43f1f29ed2683464","pdfPage":3,"start":98,"end":3495,"textSha256":"74b6089e35d8846ce175103ad780cd36373e1d7ac174672e1f073ca272045d2b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:c670c7211c36a337027bd773","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:8","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baa","parent-native:challenge:56f480852079df01466714ab"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Preserve supersymmetry-sector cosmological viability, including vacuum evolution and histories beyond late-modulus decay.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Keep broader supersymmetry-sector cosmological viability accessible, including vacuum selection and histories beyond late-modulus decay.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"0804.0863","sourceId":"ev:721d9c9acde0509dbf3c4cc24657d325","sourceSha256":"ca626475b9b29c674fd471998c558b67c88bfebd4ff0ceeeff839b80039fa487","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1deec9f65b4e990b6597/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"469c036d9822dcfecc48a52c8ad26ad8c5fe3968c70538ac43f1f29ed2683464","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":1464,"textSha256":"a5c3cfbee1c233c94c9cf672718ae696e0565d0e7e848eb643f4bccb9e7d2631","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"0804.0863","sourceId":"ev:a3892f73cb9c8e27bc7b4c95274c8bc3","sourceSha256":"ca626475b9b29c674fd471998c558b67c88bfebd4ff0ceeeff839b80039fa487","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1deec9f65b4e990b6597/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"469c036d9822dcfecc48a52c8ad26ad8c5fe3968c70538ac43f1f29ed2683464","pdfPage":3,"start":98,"end":3495,"textSha256":"74b6089e35d8846ce175103ad780cd36373e1d7ac174672e1f073ca272045d2b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d644ddab626378471e4e0e42e4647c7e7a25fecadbaa1e63a95a554f87191605","reply.jsonSha256":"6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baaa57c3371646728a9a6fdf0dbcf6993ec3823ad12","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d31aef6575a76f59717d4759f4579ffdd1d56fd28b78e02e8db7fc516e6047f7","receipt.jsonSha256":"9e433a0026eb4f85d23db2f00953ee9a3ae4a365086892133927c9d41ea370b0","normalization.jsonSha256":"183ad7569d3dae4c3d0b00de6b21c3f4f4bf7a84481aad349887a3baf49e221a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"cda5fe05a626a0f00541f652aa13f42b5d89bc4664a6f297b0a65b2db3d67f04"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec2db46cf22a587a919921edc537a478392d749e785a8148972bd1e70652a9ea","reply.jsonSha256":"56f480852079df01466714ab316a55727b30a2e0de94c29702889e66cda21363","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3f9873c2026cbfa22c8a3d0437949e4299c0be824d455277cf16d93676a1394e","receipt.jsonSha256":"e14c0967089e928b0b363cde04fa9a71ebc69e8422f7e25bc9ac929991d8120c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d7163380927a596c08f8f55bcb25bd02a8d363abdbb6eeeea8f0a08f9a8bcb4f"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:c670c7211c36a337027bd773","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:8c11a5205f1903b0e66ada5d":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:8c11a5205f1903b0e66ada5d","source":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","target":"q025-candidate-question:9b8098b806eb3a4f18a108ac","type":"comparison","title":"Higgs connections to inflation and vacuum energy","rationale":"Preserve Higgs-related inflation and vacuum-energy questions without turning them into explanations of weak-scale selection.","qualification":"Preserve inflation and dark-energy targets involving Higgs or electroweak physics without identifying them with weak-scale selection.","evidenceIds":["unit:03bd9a53345f7e8fa4d36e540cb2a798e271a8e3295085231f3569ffdf59e672","unit:17d09347dd939560dcc1c42ad2a82bce66a5ba7b20f2e06b93bab1d9f22683d5","unit:199f6b0fce9bae286503fdf2418b2a96c35e0c2dca9e9f4293e8fc22f15fcd8c","unit:1b8f0e2f4775166f3d147b751b06640675f79830cbb41407c956f91748e3751c","unit:27d10739a4173802d43927c8caddb54b4369d4945c7c43f06c7b50aefabcb2ed","unit:32396e134ac59d6d3da5a22ba13b942018fb675c783e865af68db6648a33f2a2","unit:3319fc6c6a336917d4cb45fe2ac01390db6e0e18fe3047c2547e3ce6472c08be","unit:3952317ebb5d58768e76751aeadb22eab9a264485a4e01360397f2f24f576a35","unit:43c15fee9715d1d9c5d95b5099d6fb9f1aaa26108daf87be34ab7cb6a07e5bdd","unit:4890e62c0b7b1f6bd75d7f826e1e7ff075dbb0f2b75db54da66b11b78da35a81","unit:4fb1495798b951f82386317f602fceb63ae24f91d75fde8fbd12d52c49dc9846","unit:5022b50390cd2498ce6dbcfd8a46142a665042c2403ef29e901897c753f9dedb","unit:6870ae021972f92a80dd346121dc5445c3523a09f94cfbbaa013cc761481ec0d","unit:77304c11e8a9fdeb057a68ad400bab27b2d71e8f6b22f848f8dad8d32f23ef4b","unit:8073617eadf0b0b4f7818b98bc59a645547dbbce57a77ccc5d934ff08fda68eb","unit:817779675cec36cd7d6f23c7573cc5a5004e159289cbdf34148d6d2d6f009c60","unit:994055d5b3fe54377d838aed0d9e48e88dfb7cfa8f4ff4a928523e89cfda9ef1","unit:aab8de110b756774005a643db1f1a2ff7f10b0b4dce92da670e9d5a153c7e322","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:d2a01a99623b020e8b83d5cfd7e77b07be1ec8bce23af0d4c51b1cddb79884d9","unit:dfad598fee3ad0953280e247a445bf8b722fab40c64cd83dde637970457cf834","unit:e16f67137d2df72baca21302278a1e8186aa7d5cfe7eb4248957ac4d1727291e","unit:ed2192dc41e60e41e23c386e995dfd77891c81c89b5de451b1354e6a607cbde4","unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9b8098b806eb3a4f18a108ac"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:8c11a5205f1903b0e66ada5d","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:13","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baa","parent-native:challenge:56f480852079df01466714ab"],"originalNativeType":"comparison","challengeReason":"Preserve Higgs-related inflation and vacuum-energy questions without turning them into explanations of weak-scale selection.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Preserve inflation and dark-energy targets involving Higgs or electroweak physics without identifying them with weak-scale selection.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9b8098b806eb3a4f18a108ac"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9b8098b806eb3a4f18a108ac"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d644ddab626378471e4e0e42e4647c7e7a25fecadbaa1e63a95a554f87191605","reply.jsonSha256":"6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baaa57c3371646728a9a6fdf0dbcf6993ec3823ad12","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d31aef6575a76f59717d4759f4579ffdd1d56fd28b78e02e8db7fc516e6047f7","receipt.jsonSha256":"9e433a0026eb4f85d23db2f00953ee9a3ae4a365086892133927c9d41ea370b0","normalization.jsonSha256":"183ad7569d3dae4c3d0b00de6b21c3f4f4bf7a84481aad349887a3baf49e221a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"cda5fe05a626a0f00541f652aa13f42b5d89bc4664a6f297b0a65b2db3d67f04"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec2db46cf22a587a919921edc537a478392d749e785a8148972bd1e70652a9ea","reply.jsonSha256":"56f480852079df01466714ab316a55727b30a2e0de94c29702889e66cda21363","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3f9873c2026cbfa22c8a3d0437949e4299c0be824d455277cf16d93676a1394e","receipt.jsonSha256":"e14c0967089e928b0b363cde04fa9a71ebc69e8422f7e25bc9ac929991d8120c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d7163380927a596c08f8f55bcb25bd02a8d363abdbb6eeeea8f0a08f9a8bcb4f"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"comparison","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"comparison","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:8c11a5205f1903b0e66ada5d","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:6aeae34f85f9792a547dafb0":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:6aeae34f85f9792a547dafb0","source":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","target":"q025-candidate-question:a933bcee7169dcddca789765","type":"narrower","title":"Cosmological and environmental weak-scale selection","rationale":"Reuse cosmological weak-scale selection across batches. Crunching survival and inflationary relaxation share a target while retaining different dynamics and premises.","qualification":"A common weak-scale-selection target connects different cosmological mechanisms across child batches without equating their dynamics.","evidenceIds":["unit:0dd50f09801bbe36e67f310bbb7a822b9f135fac8fa91c0a0ed8e31047ab38bb","unit:11a76fcf82f7057a9cc816da8e28bce12c7ac8e7ab4edd67804b4b8a534240dc","unit:1b8f0e2f4775166f3d147b751b06640675f79830cbb41407c956f91748e3751c","unit:32396e134ac59d6d3da5a22ba13b942018fb675c783e865af68db6648a33f2a2","unit:3319fc6c6a336917d4cb45fe2ac01390db6e0e18fe3047c2547e3ce6472c08be","unit:35ed96b584f91b47fa7d2eaca535aa6338a93f13b966e66d2451713f50c16466","unit:3952317ebb5d58768e76751aeadb22eab9a264485a4e01360397f2f24f576a35","unit:45061ceb132d557b4131f8bfab9c382a391a82f306f6c67619f32712c2b03e50","unit:4d7f7289c468297a8dd1c9c1fc8723d6294973362c5622119ce2ce5db4e7e9f5","unit:6870ae021972f92a80dd346121dc5445c3523a09f94cfbbaa013cc761481ec0d","unit:69be19facfa996156c61f80ee76f314dd41c639239eb6b59ef63e0476ab6dd7f","unit:8073617eadf0b0b4f7818b98bc59a645547dbbce57a77ccc5d934ff08fda68eb","unit:817779675cec36cd7d6f23c7573cc5a5004e159289cbdf34148d6d2d6f009c60","unit:872294c8bb9ba4a9e6c4233bcdd8a83f8372385487d5999f8e3e683db7b907a4","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:b5dcdda9758c946146d53027cf6c556e0e2b7ea7e060606ffc74c130bac5e028","unit:b87019598e2188eccfb22391b8e2324945f69a5ae6a207b96715e79a1ac9abb9","unit:b9e3db8650ea29a6107205991324e6aa3ec320331e73f9be967b23a1c8c5e527","unit:c0c0ef6359c25b5d75513933cab7c3bba540ec2f3adbc6100661c86470b436c1","unit:e16f67137d2df72baca21302278a1e8186aa7d5cfe7eb4248957ac4d1727291e","unit:e79d0f85a5eb3941177b2774f83a15683d15ecd4ffd8d96fa2c30ed06794e817","unit:ec921b45e6d82d62a365e5a8a5d846dcb325dffaaf641db2f5dd1ebcac20a13a","unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a933bcee7169dcddca789765"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:5a2e732afa0228bb0d2ebc3a8af9f62a","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3493,"textSha256":"15a6c25c062e0337468495e8677e600e961960919a557c1279f5f4aa87e6ed7e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"1509.00834","sourceId":"ev:21d87f86fcd923e1cc3f049c5c422f3d","sourceSha256":"19948b821d019fd984b40f84c8c561d0510b3d5bd1f1ac1e2f987c88fff4aaf8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b9514e93ff7fe22cc992/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c16922ac7ee53e99874fcbd5299aa1caa6c8210cd81c5f5f75579f10d6d0bb30","pdfPage":4,"start":95,"end":3494,"textSha256":"f43527c08e94d7ce093c47c63f33628b4bffc1332ca1f6d5afafe70eccb8d096","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:6aeae34f85f9792a547dafb0","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:4","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baa","parent-native:challenge:56f480852079df01466714ab"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse cosmological weak-scale selection across batches. Crunching survival and inflationary relaxation share a target while retaining different dynamics and premises.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"A common weak-scale-selection target connects different cosmological mechanisms across child batches without equating their dynamics.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a933bcee7169dcddca789765"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:5a2e732afa0228bb0d2ebc3a8af9f62a","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3493,"textSha256":"15a6c25c062e0337468495e8677e600e961960919a557c1279f5f4aa87e6ed7e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"1509.00834","sourceId":"ev:21d87f86fcd923e1cc3f049c5c422f3d","sourceSha256":"19948b821d019fd984b40f84c8c561d0510b3d5bd1f1ac1e2f987c88fff4aaf8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b9514e93ff7fe22cc992/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c16922ac7ee53e99874fcbd5299aa1caa6c8210cd81c5f5f75579f10d6d0bb30","pdfPage":4,"start":95,"end":3494,"textSha256":"f43527c08e94d7ce093c47c63f33628b4bffc1332ca1f6d5afafe70eccb8d096","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a933bcee7169dcddca789765"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:5a2e732afa0228bb0d2ebc3a8af9f62a","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3493,"textSha256":"15a6c25c062e0337468495e8677e600e961960919a557c1279f5f4aa87e6ed7e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"1509.00834","sourceId":"ev:21d87f86fcd923e1cc3f049c5c422f3d","sourceSha256":"19948b821d019fd984b40f84c8c561d0510b3d5bd1f1ac1e2f987c88fff4aaf8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b9514e93ff7fe22cc992/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c16922ac7ee53e99874fcbd5299aa1caa6c8210cd81c5f5f75579f10d6d0bb30","pdfPage":4,"start":95,"end":3494,"textSha256":"f43527c08e94d7ce093c47c63f33628b4bffc1332ca1f6d5afafe70eccb8d096","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d644ddab626378471e4e0e42e4647c7e7a25fecadbaa1e63a95a554f87191605","reply.jsonSha256":"6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baaa57c3371646728a9a6fdf0dbcf6993ec3823ad12","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d31aef6575a76f59717d4759f4579ffdd1d56fd28b78e02e8db7fc516e6047f7","receipt.jsonSha256":"9e433a0026eb4f85d23db2f00953ee9a3ae4a365086892133927c9d41ea370b0","normalization.jsonSha256":"183ad7569d3dae4c3d0b00de6b21c3f4f4bf7a84481aad349887a3baf49e221a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"cda5fe05a626a0f00541f652aa13f42b5d89bc4664a6f297b0a65b2db3d67f04"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec2db46cf22a587a919921edc537a478392d749e785a8148972bd1e70652a9ea","reply.jsonSha256":"56f480852079df01466714ab316a55727b30a2e0de94c29702889e66cda21363","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3f9873c2026cbfa22c8a3d0437949e4299c0be824d455277cf16d93676a1394e","receipt.jsonSha256":"e14c0967089e928b0b363cde04fa9a71ebc69e8422f7e25bc9ac929991d8120c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d7163380927a596c08f8f55bcb25bd02a8d363abdbb6eeeea8f0a08f9a8bcb4f"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:6aeae34f85f9792a547dafb0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:448b8aadeeb638c221872b61":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:448b8aadeeb638c221872b61","source":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","target":"q025-candidate-question:b05855605657ab25a065f8f7","type":"comparison","title":"Thermal electroweak transitions","rationale":"Thermal electroweak behavior is a neighboring target. Its physical cross-over and conditional first-order regimes remain distinct.","qualification":"Thermal electroweak behavior is a useful neighboring target; transition calculations alone do not explain the hierarchy.","evidenceIds":["unit:06552982d252b03f1acc809710a1442978fb0b9bc28907047cae71d4416ab9b9","unit:1d1db5be5b161d32d2a55b681556aaee2fcff4bfd926e7312045c2c480b1bea8","unit:39a71b4db549f5caed523dacf7dfcea96d220941bfc863507c898c590ff3b113","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:d6f00f05e9ae1a226afb2083014449d2cb69283b70e1503c1790e554bdbfa92f","unit:e16f67137d2df72baca21302278a1e8186aa7d5cfe7eb4248957ac4d1727291e","unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b05855605657ab25a065f8f7"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:448b8aadeeb638c221872b61","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:12","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baa","parent-native:challenge:56f480852079df01466714ab"],"originalNativeType":"comparison","challengeReason":"Thermal electroweak behavior is a neighboring target. Its physical cross-over and conditional first-order regimes remain distinct.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Thermal electroweak behavior is a useful neighboring target; transition calculations alone do not explain the hierarchy.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b05855605657ab25a065f8f7"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b05855605657ab25a065f8f7"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d644ddab626378471e4e0e42e4647c7e7a25fecadbaa1e63a95a554f87191605","reply.jsonSha256":"6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baaa57c3371646728a9a6fdf0dbcf6993ec3823ad12","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d31aef6575a76f59717d4759f4579ffdd1d56fd28b78e02e8db7fc516e6047f7","receipt.jsonSha256":"9e433a0026eb4f85d23db2f00953ee9a3ae4a365086892133927c9d41ea370b0","normalization.jsonSha256":"183ad7569d3dae4c3d0b00de6b21c3f4f4bf7a84481aad349887a3baf49e221a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"cda5fe05a626a0f00541f652aa13f42b5d89bc4664a6f297b0a65b2db3d67f04"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec2db46cf22a587a919921edc537a478392d749e785a8148972bd1e70652a9ea","reply.jsonSha256":"56f480852079df01466714ab316a55727b30a2e0de94c29702889e66cda21363","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3f9873c2026cbfa22c8a3d0437949e4299c0be824d455277cf16d93676a1394e","receipt.jsonSha256":"e14c0967089e928b0b363cde04fa9a71ebc69e8422f7e25bc9ac929991d8120c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d7163380927a596c08f8f55bcb25bd02a8d363abdbb6eeeea8f0a08f9a8bcb4f"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"comparison","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"comparison","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:448b8aadeeb638c221872b61","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:148547f2a6236c06fea9f17f":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:148547f2a6236c06fea9f17f","source":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","target":"q025-candidate-question:bfe372a2298b01d22d9cf52c","type":"narrower","title":"Microscopic origins and protection of the weak scale","rationale":"Reuse microscopic weak-scale generation and protection, preserving separate ultraviolet assumptions and naturalness claims.","qualification":"Reuse the existing question about microscopic weak-scale origins and protection, including its separation of naturalness claims.","evidenceIds":["unit:03e2016057e759a07fd15c21c84c0911e3d6d6c5f3e5f486e63901665eb3f93d","unit:11a76fcf82f7057a9cc816da8e28bce12c7ac8e7ab4edd67804b4b8a534240dc","unit:1b8f0e2f4775166f3d147b751b06640675f79830cbb41407c956f91748e3751c","unit:1da1632b404bc4db79a6cf415567de4af9846de61148eadbd81d99d455ce5357","unit:2bf037ce8c9998cf4d046bdf05c6a4e158b1822c551eddc3f145ea30aca3df18","unit:30fff49bf370a30ca7eddcdf6cf037161cc9f2491f09a25bd424ccb1d126f0a9","unit:31408aa86f56a134d6ec73134418d888c990ebe7b57d4a6da8f5dc986b998918","unit:3319fc6c6a336917d4cb45fe2ac01390db6e0e18fe3047c2547e3ce6472c08be","unit:35ed96b584f91b47fa7d2eaca535aa6338a93f13b966e66d2451713f50c16466","unit:36b4545c3f7ac5af22a611333a84c884559b27d3728d7df5d88ed1961e8a0a83","unit:40b1ca284dc6797baf4f1d4601ae025e61e57d7580e4fc718ce6c83a47fe9e0b","unit:43c15fee9715d1d9c5d95b5099d6fb9f1aaa26108daf87be34ab7cb6a07e5bdd","unit:45061ceb132d557b4131f8bfab9c382a391a82f306f6c67619f32712c2b03e50","unit:4d7f7289c468297a8dd1c9c1fc8723d6294973362c5622119ce2ce5db4e7e9f5","unit:54c21caf77796c05e48c93bffa72a3d12aaa36f3de2e8b82f272df80f84532d0","unit:5bf996b185a3a38471189f08ed73ee4e30d8ef515c10a9a56d4ea3f83a5ac8a8","unit:5c85851b79f0438ab83420ea87ab925ae233b4d9bd5a9890e6b4136e45397ded","unit:5e91d8d52e5cc3bbda39ce8b0e0d170a5f366072216964a4d3c2b720071bf67f","unit:666c9a459fcc3584853eed6c3c426fbe7ad6b326c05d9d736e0ee757e01d1c4b","unit:683f43a9c14ea8ac66f509737d9b1e6ad5b3e60cf5382308ec0cde5533c23231","unit:6870ae021972f92a80dd346121dc5445c3523a09f94cfbbaa013cc761481ec0d","unit:716810c7a0c3b08b7255426733a1bebe9e0c8dd55d904b3dae7c38082118e254","unit:77304c11e8a9fdeb057a68ad400bab27b2d71e8f6b22f848f8dad8d32f23ef4b","unit:77ea7d519aa8bda20e245af3fec12a8bed24fd3fa1fac68c932cd4b598a37c1d","unit:7f6ea5e4765806f1752f0dbc0296f5d52b04bbb78c6e9a56bc1ce55b65192a1c","unit:85a36b9ceb688c2b50119ca834c127b06191bbeef26c092872ccab796573a215","unit:872294c8bb9ba4a9e6c4233bcdd8a83f8372385487d5999f8e3e683db7b907a4","unit:9419708ac2f18c5783ea762b38a37b6fe2bfa891052b2504dbb88cf7dae820a9","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:b9e3db8650ea29a6107205991324e6aa3ec320331e73f9be967b23a1c8c5e527","unit:c2623164c142e609ed750491fe3748eb123a17dec9c68f82e76a3914c057a3f4","unit:c862a364d0b8b2f5220a41fc36840005433981a3bc0bf7fc8cfcb98841aaaee0","unit:d2a01a99623b020e8b83d5cfd7e77b07be1ec8bce23af0d4c51b1cddb79884d9","unit:d974c1697e8f9caef19885bdf7019664a20ae5286f35f90df703b1e63947fb82","unit:da809d9df9139a9579f84a9be5963ae19f082b348111239601e728f7a6017b04","unit:db91529936d155eaa0ac4e04dbf0bde8136837d44e88b33e2e6647dc30f99630","unit:dfad598fee3ad0953280e247a445bf8b722fab40c64cd83dde637970457cf834","unit:e16f67137d2df72baca21302278a1e8186aa7d5cfe7eb4248957ac4d1727291e","unit:e2e099886f88562437330f1114bea77be84ea05a15066b7fc4c55b9ef446f047","unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351","unit:f9cd0d09416078182ebdebf95a3c5a2083105da408624694b3103a9ca4d202a2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bfe372a2298b01d22d9cf52c"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"1509.00834","sourceId":"ev:66bd936579ad3c55ca14d1be55566516","sourceSha256":"19948b821d019fd984b40f84c8c561d0510b3d5bd1f1ac1e2f987c88fff4aaf8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b9514e93ff7fe22cc992/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c16922ac7ee53e99874fcbd5299aa1caa6c8210cd81c5f5f75579f10d6d0bb30","pdfPage":3,"start":1299,"end":3612,"textSha256":"d018a9377d2226995691f5ae5a9886d581ec4f9a57b128e352828ee68aa257ea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:148547f2a6236c06fea9f17f","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:3","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baa","parent-native:challenge:56f480852079df01466714ab"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse microscopic weak-scale generation and protection, preserving separate ultraviolet assumptions and naturalness claims.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the existing question about microscopic weak-scale origins and protection, including its separation of naturalness claims.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bfe372a2298b01d22d9cf52c"},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"1509.00834","sourceId":"ev:66bd936579ad3c55ca14d1be55566516","sourceSha256":"19948b821d019fd984b40f84c8c561d0510b3d5bd1f1ac1e2f987c88fff4aaf8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b9514e93ff7fe22cc992/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c16922ac7ee53e99874fcbd5299aa1caa6c8210cd81c5f5f75579f10d6d0bb30","pdfPage":3,"start":1299,"end":3612,"textSha256":"d018a9377d2226995691f5ae5a9886d581ec4f9a57b128e352828ee68aa257ea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bfe372a2298b01d22d9cf52c"},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"1509.00834","sourceId":"ev:66bd936579ad3c55ca14d1be55566516","sourceSha256":"19948b821d019fd984b40f84c8c561d0510b3d5bd1f1ac1e2f987c88fff4aaf8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b9514e93ff7fe22cc992/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c16922ac7ee53e99874fcbd5299aa1caa6c8210cd81c5f5f75579f10d6d0bb30","pdfPage":3,"start":1299,"end":3612,"textSha256":"d018a9377d2226995691f5ae5a9886d581ec4f9a57b128e352828ee68aa257ea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d644ddab626378471e4e0e42e4647c7e7a25fecadbaa1e63a95a554f87191605","reply.jsonSha256":"6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baaa57c3371646728a9a6fdf0dbcf6993ec3823ad12","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d31aef6575a76f59717d4759f4579ffdd1d56fd28b78e02e8db7fc516e6047f7","receipt.jsonSha256":"9e433a0026eb4f85d23db2f00953ee9a3ae4a365086892133927c9d41ea370b0","normalization.jsonSha256":"183ad7569d3dae4c3d0b00de6b21c3f4f4bf7a84481aad349887a3baf49e221a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"cda5fe05a626a0f00541f652aa13f42b5d89bc4664a6f297b0a65b2db3d67f04"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec2db46cf22a587a919921edc537a478392d749e785a8148972bd1e70652a9ea","reply.jsonSha256":"56f480852079df01466714ab316a55727b30a2e0de94c29702889e66cda21363","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3f9873c2026cbfa22c8a3d0437949e4299c0be824d455277cf16d93676a1394e","receipt.jsonSha256":"e14c0967089e928b0b363cde04fa9a71ebc69e8422f7e25bc9ac929991d8120c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d7163380927a596c08f8f55bcb25bd02a8d363abdbb6eeeea8f0a08f9a8bcb4f"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:148547f2a6236c06fea9f17f","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:f1586283fb332c0172d18935":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:f1586283fb332c0172d18935","source":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","target":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","type":"narrower","title":"Generating and mediating supersymmetry breaking","rationale":"Reuse the existing breaking-and-mediation question for soft spectra, flavor and sequestering premises; support here is attributed to its child definition.","qualification":"Reuse the mechanism and mediation question for soft spectra, flavor and sequestering premises.","evidenceIds":["unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","unit:06d0fff814a1ccfbc9c6fc6722b6a758f63b71fbbda46dffd5e1745f57d4723b","unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","unit:11c64a9574c7812ca866ffe455dfa66bb99851524485b81fd996e966bf19d13f","unit:1b3f60d668b6e5e34f7d802825aca8a7da3d450a02c8871cc663009dcd0c4c9b","unit:45d4b4ad8550bdbdc0c2b8b0b231e4802095910fec1c356277c544d8d63b79f0","unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","unit:4e46e8a6e98d00a4b93a3d78291fea1340276a1f49811129d1d7ba403c007d88","unit:66f2128fe3c730b2c6401827e2da1852e7022d1fbc910e8bdfa4ea219db44ee9","unit:6f4bd85cba9e7fa6775a09acf61cb878ef117b3cc5044b200147abb7a136e6b7","unit:86bdd8dbc9e3994b23ea8394c40a8c95b2c6cf1488c02715afa36663c68c2495","unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","unit:a89ad673796c91d6a0bd8f292dde9faae5fb686f291bb1208aa3d4b66da55f97","unit:ab871d7619e7955fe098f2140aba6103cfaf8991943cfa38ba18b6b2dca0f666","unit:acfa3c138fe7f7b17c784ccfc8c8cea3c9281ba86224d642963559b38f4a1c7c","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:ba2db2d76dd6ce5790bb60ec53801f7a3dcc9b3b31008a748cc4b2135a5fc45f","unit:c0939c5f7d452074b0f8f661a7a753e218ece5c8f215491d476a15ebe0124af2","unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","unit:c85f81c5a449a568894fda092cbbcd10adb8c797ffb1e7ef9afea547ca5f1d49","unit:e16f67137d2df72baca21302278a1e8186aa7d5cfe7eb4248957ac4d1727291e","unit:e292d6f025aad66121d75508a8aa35844e2add144cb61d853c67b6b73c559f23","unit:f12074876d2226dff1c73eb66784473fe6b8027a2e23b350b437f6572f3fb433","unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:f1586283fb332c0172d18935","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:6","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baa","parent-native:challenge:56f480852079df01466714ab"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse the existing breaking-and-mediation question for soft spectra, flavor and sequestering premises; support here is attributed to its child definition.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Reuse the mechanism and mediation question for soft spectra, flavor and sequestering premises.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"},{"ref":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d644ddab626378471e4e0e42e4647c7e7a25fecadbaa1e63a95a554f87191605","reply.jsonSha256":"6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baaa57c3371646728a9a6fdf0dbcf6993ec3823ad12","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d31aef6575a76f59717d4759f4579ffdd1d56fd28b78e02e8db7fc516e6047f7","receipt.jsonSha256":"9e433a0026eb4f85d23db2f00953ee9a3ae4a365086892133927c9d41ea370b0","normalization.jsonSha256":"183ad7569d3dae4c3d0b00de6b21c3f4f4bf7a84481aad349887a3baf49e221a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"cda5fe05a626a0f00541f652aa13f42b5d89bc4664a6f297b0a65b2db3d67f04"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec2db46cf22a587a919921edc537a478392d749e785a8148972bd1e70652a9ea","reply.jsonSha256":"56f480852079df01466714ab316a55727b30a2e0de94c29702889e66cda21363","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3f9873c2026cbfa22c8a3d0437949e4299c0be824d455277cf16d93676a1394e","receipt.jsonSha256":"e14c0967089e928b0b363cde04fa9a71ebc69e8422f7e25bc9ac929991d8120c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d7163380927a596c08f8f55bcb25bd02a8d363abdbb6eeeea8f0a08f9a8bcb4f"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:f1586283fb332c0172d18935","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:6f4c670fef760fc829205afd":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:6f4c670fef760fc829205afd","source":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","target":"q025-candidate-question:f39333b08ebf2cd4de3e3f4a","type":"narrower","title":"Modulus and gravitino cosmology","rationale":"Reuse modulus/gravitino histories and relic abundances without identifying all production, dilution or stability alternatives.","qualification":"Retain the focused modulus/gravitino history and relic-abundance direction across compactification and effective-model settings.","evidenceIds":["unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","unit:0987e132a53ff8e612486a3859842e861b76301b93ebb11d8a56e4f8e3022f43","unit:0e272eaeb369777716438692886a914336835f7b1943247e715a695370f36972","unit:0f564b72ccb9dd08acc40928a16c7107cbedce0b4d0f338d42736790503aea1a","unit:0ffa4883d2d1dbb4846bc0dddb5b72eafc6b959820a8da8a78a239830607e70c","unit:1d0d221f850057f7d3770dda05242e9041fdf6414d1d0d486ddc7269a519bbdb","unit:1f8a143c34d15dddf88975dd80bcf893118c16c9b304ffe0e7c94185e5d9a5b6","unit:22567be11e9250ddabe2dba0a23b533b68abf8ea436c5d51f21cef613f5cc319","unit:245c1476e91cb35c093c370c48846f79a7f15c4f1cf5c57a488bb6aa08916b2f","unit:28bdd6f52cc30df281f1f4d836c85a0bf8578e9fd138fd286883b1f5c0a4f7c8","unit:2cfcc2ad59f436a184caf080c4d5f7db2f7b571ff75e8694880e0099242d0a98","unit:2d519cedab67a35e4e6b961e6c53a7b6712a382b0def484b733ad7e83ded608f","unit:328727ae562b449a9c1c36bf482eb6c2e8e0019f40018ad0b98fbba669217b28","unit:3a933b3a4fea0ed8ff28bb524e17b1e78260b146648f34c54a75342a3c3dadf0","unit:4ed2ac936157aab2ac1031a731c7fd778188055e7092082eb69b67b68a11dc32","unit:605de0761b2358e37045e8df8819d2caf5b1d711f2cf269ba2307b74a697e465","unit:62188642114ea75ef7b0d83ae1a11b515b9046a89f476a957ad3dafacdfd5826","unit:67f94de05cb1ac512bcdd1cc70ba500a06f124b5b86dfc0e4bf48b4c139eb88e","unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","unit:7667a79b815f99de0d65c3e6792c3b433b65808c1385cdf7bf516fdcbf430f15","unit:7a836c7d5a9f02b5b0226b19a6d9a926a7507db1647810018d8563ccb41414ba","unit:7ebc51e5198ec3aeeefa5f45c261821b80198a81057463793194b8a1e6d3e133","unit:8283124d4672ec8e1ea6d1db07e36cf9cdfb9d3086b022af48550547e446bb0a","unit:92a8fd8dbb27d5f8753b2e4259043bf1597de9feb26d3debd0c6c9806828f22e","unit:93e9fd67f1a42aeed6cf34020522ef2cda2998b28c161743ee91ef38aa89b137","unit:940f536d87ce2d1808f7b2604dffb29758784c347401d1ee5e8399cd9a2e551d","unit:a2984727dd94401649bcc01005538019d158f676a57d990613ae344d81618cbf","unit:a4c43d802142af3a9b10fcaaeb95f96273f81e146fb39d2fd6f9fadd7402f3f2","unit:ac36205563daf4202f4e9f37ea58874f0aeb0b9c3ee1f9e1a6d13a8779652faf","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:bd18ebf05dedcfe1f8bdc3b2684907dfd28bad4c4f7460ece446bec2bccbe86d","unit:c406ba31ec49cbb23a6d7202a58582d1019db1e20a9e3531272a0bd7152d4e5c","unit:c6cd9586163c2c91d5f0751d8986e5f7f4d9a7b73e6aa797136ce0d141c2d3e0","unit:d27ec210a934297e8291848f916d78ce168c3d6fa1baae330d0b45542e610256","unit:dbd4ad422b115a1fe937440fef5d7995f208c895aa74b6cfebd6d79c22c0c2d6","unit:df4e43a49a8da815ba04100193a71993abd31ca89a823b3a15331e8e74205f14","unit:e16f67137d2df72baca21302278a1e8186aa7d5cfe7eb4248957ac4d1727291e","unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351","unit:f73648819770976e88055679fe32b0e5ec86b15c9aa45cd9fde1cbad23b16e87","unit:f8fd77bc87187ff0d5ff4caa8595f7c1b8df79ad86c5762d73083c83307369a9"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f39333b08ebf2cd4de3e3f4a"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"0804.0863","sourceId":"ev:721d9c9acde0509dbf3c4cc24657d325","sourceSha256":"ca626475b9b29c674fd471998c558b67c88bfebd4ff0ceeeff839b80039fa487","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1deec9f65b4e990b6597/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"469c036d9822dcfecc48a52c8ad26ad8c5fe3968c70538ac43f1f29ed2683464","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":1464,"textSha256":"a5c3cfbee1c233c94c9cf672718ae696e0565d0e7e848eb643f4bccb9e7d2631","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"0804.0863","sourceId":"ev:a3892f73cb9c8e27bc7b4c95274c8bc3","sourceSha256":"ca626475b9b29c674fd471998c558b67c88bfebd4ff0ceeeff839b80039fa487","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1deec9f65b4e990b6597/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"469c036d9822dcfecc48a52c8ad26ad8c5fe3968c70538ac43f1f29ed2683464","pdfPage":3,"start":98,"end":3495,"textSha256":"74b6089e35d8846ce175103ad780cd36373e1d7ac174672e1f073ca272045d2b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:6f4c670fef760fc829205afd","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:7","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baa","parent-native:challenge:56f480852079df01466714ab"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Reuse modulus/gravitino histories and relic abundances without identifying all production, dilution or stability alternatives.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Retain the focused modulus/gravitino history and relic-abundance direction across compactification and effective-model settings.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f39333b08ebf2cd4de3e3f4a"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"0804.0863","sourceId":"ev:721d9c9acde0509dbf3c4cc24657d325","sourceSha256":"ca626475b9b29c674fd471998c558b67c88bfebd4ff0ceeeff839b80039fa487","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1deec9f65b4e990b6597/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"469c036d9822dcfecc48a52c8ad26ad8c5fe3968c70538ac43f1f29ed2683464","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":1464,"textSha256":"a5c3cfbee1c233c94c9cf672718ae696e0565d0e7e848eb643f4bccb9e7d2631","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"0804.0863","sourceId":"ev:a3892f73cb9c8e27bc7b4c95274c8bc3","sourceSha256":"ca626475b9b29c674fd471998c558b67c88bfebd4ff0ceeeff839b80039fa487","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1deec9f65b4e990b6597/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"469c036d9822dcfecc48a52c8ad26ad8c5fe3968c70538ac43f1f29ed2683464","pdfPage":3,"start":98,"end":3495,"textSha256":"74b6089e35d8846ce175103ad780cd36373e1d7ac174672e1f073ca272045d2b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f39333b08ebf2cd4de3e3f4a"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"0804.0863","sourceId":"ev:721d9c9acde0509dbf3c4cc24657d325","sourceSha256":"ca626475b9b29c674fd471998c558b67c88bfebd4ff0ceeeff839b80039fa487","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1deec9f65b4e990b6597/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"469c036d9822dcfecc48a52c8ad26ad8c5fe3968c70538ac43f1f29ed2683464","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":1464,"textSha256":"a5c3cfbee1c233c94c9cf672718ae696e0565d0e7e848eb643f4bccb9e7d2631","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"0804.0863","sourceId":"ev:a3892f73cb9c8e27bc7b4c95274c8bc3","sourceSha256":"ca626475b9b29c674fd471998c558b67c88bfebd4ff0ceeeff839b80039fa487","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1deec9f65b4e990b6597/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"469c036d9822dcfecc48a52c8ad26ad8c5fe3968c70538ac43f1f29ed2683464","pdfPage":3,"start":98,"end":3495,"textSha256":"74b6089e35d8846ce175103ad780cd36373e1d7ac174672e1f073ca272045d2b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d644ddab626378471e4e0e42e4647c7e7a25fecadbaa1e63a95a554f87191605","reply.jsonSha256":"6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baaa57c3371646728a9a6fdf0dbcf6993ec3823ad12","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d31aef6575a76f59717d4759f4579ffdd1d56fd28b78e02e8db7fc516e6047f7","receipt.jsonSha256":"9e433a0026eb4f85d23db2f00953ee9a3ae4a365086892133927c9d41ea370b0","normalization.jsonSha256":"183ad7569d3dae4c3d0b00de6b21c3f4f4bf7a84481aad349887a3baf49e221a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"cda5fe05a626a0f00541f652aa13f42b5d89bc4664a6f297b0a65b2db3d67f04"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec2db46cf22a587a919921edc537a478392d749e785a8148972bd1e70652a9ea","reply.jsonSha256":"56f480852079df01466714ab316a55727b30a2e0de94c29702889e66cda21363","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3f9873c2026cbfa22c8a3d0437949e4299c0be824d455277cf16d93676a1394e","receipt.jsonSha256":"e14c0967089e928b0b363cde04fa9a71ebc69e8422f7e25bc9ac929991d8120c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d7163380927a596c08f8f55bcb25bd02a8d363abdbb6eeeea8f0a08f9a8bcb4f"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:6f4c670fef760fc829205afd","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:bbb7199b531f89cba34eb8ac":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:bbb7199b531f89cba34eb8ac","source":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","target":"q025-candidate-question:3eb3429a740bfe0116b92293","type":"narrower","title":"Axion potential generation, protection and EFT validity","rationale":"Potential generation, symmetry protection and coupling hierarchies remain targets independently of a particular cosmological use.","qualification":"Potential generation, symmetry protection and coupling hierarchies remain useful targets independently of a particular cosmological application.","evidenceIds":["unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","unit:2472aa7f6431071a7ecfd145294b3acc1b55c8f5dd05e532b58afaca295edef5","unit:5580f57a353a06beeb3fa735e95ed8cacbb43ebc2939a83d965b30542073bb5c","unit:69741b713901707aa03020cd63aab91ac081e3f07ff638c1c174e28c104eac06","unit:71995227ec6bbc1a9ae11ea627ea7b5c2c071ebd83a281337a32c5ce4c997f00","unit:87a082cc421b4d0572c13f55e6a23859181f44b49b1d2f6c8c1f95f6d0ee613d","unit:c0b7559fb56cee36b6c99164c1b855f4ce2c050a3f46756ff6e1781ced5c76ab","unit:c6c86df782561dcce60ac528d3d4dc67d6575ad8ad7091b986a1faf68f273f77","unit:d18b2bac4da18f878d8f9a0663ddda680cdee4e108ba2c8083aa7dbbda01cb71","unit:db8dcbb524b03ac8b235266bce4cb17ebe1de2b2cf02d4671307db6b7a2f66a7","unit:de8d62560f7c8b93a4ccbe90e1de1aac7c7d1c8fe917bf8329e45a8381a299c0","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a","unit:f185332de23766b66a802f2bede69479f1849089774b79ca0687079cab79d78c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3eb3429a740bfe0116b92293"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:bbb7199b531f89cba34eb8ac","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:10","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:632fafe96baf728ba9d00850","parent-native:challenge:cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b82"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Potential generation, symmetry protection and coupling hierarchies remain targets independently of a particular cosmological use.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Potential generation, symmetry protection and coupling hierarchies remain useful targets independently of a particular cosmological application.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3eb3429a740bfe0116b92293"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3eb3429a740bfe0116b92293"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:bbb7199b531f89cba34eb8ac","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:38494880ec96a321c95fa7d0":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:38494880ec96a321c95fa7d0","source":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","target":"q025-candidate-question:6ec04df6db7c4c4e14a3466c","type":"narrower","title":"Light axions, companion moduli and observable properties","rationale":"Surviving light fields, masses and couplings connect stabilization questions with observable applications.","qualification":"Light-field survival, masses and observable couplings connect compactification questions with applications.","evidenceIds":["unit:0288f951cf49b32b43717f3f340e3b4dfa5a2ee59063906bb36b60714c8a2805","unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","unit:2472aa7f6431071a7ecfd145294b3acc1b55c8f5dd05e532b58afaca295edef5","unit:4897d77b6feef4c4d016ab7862d57d150ba3b479174eb1815e7d027184150d88","unit:4e7fdce27fa1c114181feb3b0b3293cb8b41c1bf9acc4ad64315ebdcd7bd7b47","unit:64080662ecd1089ef20ab86a8f738c3e7989713afbc8e97812eea7bfb6c670da","unit:96e805dd16c7f6bac0a504d1e7cd49a2a3caeb0a4aacd44a0c5feb4f6f2332eb","unit:b4a5b8d0cee266be5a9e1d8956f5335ae1efe3086f2ea6883fe851a55f4b8365","unit:ba72cf37df0554976b85eddee32024723ad742155094a110a7c7e5b36efbbc74","unit:c6c86df782561dcce60ac528d3d4dc67d6575ad8ad7091b986a1faf68f273f77","unit:c73c4569a4adc899921d9c968cdcaf3713f2eeae21eba0a7fdbd4bbcbbd56cbe","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a","unit:f185332de23766b66a802f2bede69479f1849089774b79ca0687079cab79d78c","unit:ffeb9dbf92ae78580abf09cdcabeff7bf0452b093929ec6832241f9433eb4c22"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6ec04df6db7c4c4e14a3466c"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:38494880ec96a321c95fa7d0","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:11","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:632fafe96baf728ba9d00850","parent-native:challenge:cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b82"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Surviving light fields, masses and couplings connect stabilization questions with observable applications.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Light-field survival, masses and observable couplings connect compactification questions with applications.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6ec04df6db7c4c4e14a3466c"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6ec04df6db7c4c4e14a3466c"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:38494880ec96a321c95fa7d0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:211083c1a1f1a68f0ee1f430":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:211083c1a1f1a68f0ee1f430","source":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","target":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","type":"narrower","title":"Inflationary potentials, trajectories and observables","rationale":"Potential shape, finite inflation, trajectory stability and primordial observables form a common target direction without identifying mechanisms.","qualification":"Potential shape, finite duration, stable evolution and primordial observables provide a common dynamical direction without identifying mechanisms.","evidenceIds":["unit:089741721f36735b166e321ed8443a5b7c5194e0d0ef6b8859996254d24c7f36","unit:0f741c02bbae28e4099f4b85590230d3558377f4e21daf676ab986ba82031002","unit:1250ebeed54952b26e25c8f332139d3b5fe4bc9bfc721c64241683ee0dc8e9d7","unit:13fff5545063255f2448c6dfee410e9df4c329abe8319bf87872deb125a9fcec","unit:1ed7acfa72460537797b28b9b2d74edad7cf2561d853678d6bf9bc422607b904","unit:1fa1d6965b2b4d15843ec9bfa4b8e9ea0e198a2dc8df4f761d029449f24c3260","unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","unit:2472aa7f6431071a7ecfd145294b3acc1b55c8f5dd05e532b58afaca295edef5","unit:2acf2e165d284872cc674da3477d42164092f746d47c1ccc727f20fba6ee4e7d","unit:39d73bca80a56ea22a73711654b127662488b2a7dd56c6189cef65a4b8707b07","unit:4068ceb643876e29d8afca37189b823a880fb47541ebd8cfe6f7de0840d50ebf","unit:43e08751f478cf3ad715cd966544aafa1dce1db79f0cfef60358984c89fe631f","unit:440e9c79ce25f6b4bfee58231d3ee8e17d54c8c3dfc576b57380eda6da4e9785","unit:44c4cb36779d40cd065031fe74d3171faf148f868aeaae6ce7b56c2e9ccf157c","unit:4a1403670591dc9e626826441942ce7596e96825b8d1ca73b16000e6b43abc52","unit:58bdb4c80701d53da220dae66740f1e27a74dc08b74f679c81691ccc424a2a0d","unit:5d7f7e18aa16e6086bf4413b8b97dbc3c83c8b04b571a792a122e746e42ead7c","unit:69b3a487be496c140ef5324a8bd1ffd3ffd1e1b1fe4708203d6e3c6f420f5920","unit:79401bdb6e9b39bdda4a68d35ec78bf65921e348a480ffd55e9ee7da741e7c67","unit:7a16c6358397efbdeb773b01d136b33c4ade2a593369be237424ac16ba04916a","unit:7d5f73f7367b73d9fd1e3030efc6f5a9291fca13480a67e2a8b5fce40a24eb24","unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","unit:8813193476478867455e89227605fa910549b354a8c0ca92097661d8c788e278","unit:8e34bd7382e88e1bdf6e0e00924028f2eaf8f304a1df35bf441856fda3419ffa","unit:90ebf5f92864e10383e36dabb9e0bbecd9ad77ddd42b9ab00fe909a956f89319","unit:96ae24c93aa28d1c62aae68e9d06f1b01dd88f0bffaafd87c953745a7e66e80a","unit:a7951b1a1bf3c3b2a19ae12c1a96332fa73b002b005e1cf099296e057dfa6a10","unit:ae2ea5e7a3f91f3b95e18e544d9cc75cdd3b7cd75f96739d2f8c0c069f980c67","unit:b94bbd51efd5f2d3dbb843d83c0e54b0c28e85d8ba2615bdd7bb09ad8313e201","unit:c6c86df782561dcce60ac528d3d4dc67d6575ad8ad7091b986a1faf68f273f77","unit:ce9e8c6172f7206e22f7b4b25ca052f00790b1618260c45369038e97e84ca9a2","unit:e163f9233750831cb88e35aa05ec7de30973d42424819d9c121f1ac3b85e9e71","unit:e50105d51ef65387e4e82eaf2f653c33b204dc8fd44466599fd4b1a11661f07c","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a","unit:e8c0a0bffd5b08931037fafc4f60b51a9c3f1973750a35405bcdcded2eaab51b","unit:eb19bb063d1bfb70b4d8b52a4787ba551e6ee0ab71764f1df0d7d610495b244e","unit:f185332de23766b66a802f2bede69479f1849089774b79ca0687079cab79d78c","unit:f6a4df371b8b0c027eda1620205eb32aecdd1f83e2c1625a76801ccef8ec8753","unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c"}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:211083c1a1f1a68f0ee1f430","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:8","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:632fafe96baf728ba9d00850","parent-native:challenge:cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b82"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Potential shape, finite inflation, trajectory stability and primordial observables form a common target direction without identifying mechanisms.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Potential shape, finite duration, stable evolution and primordial observables provide a common dynamical direction without identifying mechanisms.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c"}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c"}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:211083c1a1f1a68f0ee1f430","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:da7e1b3465123fbe0038994d":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:da7e1b3465123fbe0038994d","source":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","target":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8","type":"narrower","title":"Axion periods and effective range enhancement","rationale":"Fundamental periods and effective range enhancement share a direction while retaining different measurements and assumptions.","qualification":"Shared access to fundamental periods and effective range enhancement, retaining their different measurements and premises.","evidenceIds":["unit:0aacb2f51d637ca4427e2def670018cb6de3b695d8dbfae5455552c89c072966","unit:104260b9a56d84ab04eb5d7e114008be579d8f8bb3e8a508774e0ae73ad6a649","unit:10ec2b4baf0ee06c640c0b17912b0c889ca8b1dc6374175fdfa3a4f80bba3865","unit:16516a56d3ac8e73bc13cb49617cdde9977dcccd4518ab1af0dafa31402f05d8","unit:1fb3ddfa526bf36841aa82ec0d8ed6e796523054d2e2313b09b8bf37024dfd2e","unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","unit:2472aa7f6431071a7ecfd145294b3acc1b55c8f5dd05e532b58afaca295edef5","unit:2a5415c009e4ebfc381ff601f91eea9ff6f766f8fbbe3a98c50f5e5d68fa16a5","unit:36f38a0bcfe9b654ecb7a0cf1f78b8db9a38da51786d7cba3deb93177ef94253","unit:53eddd61d2fa628502ee2ee0f60ecf3e4794ebb47bb5839119f002ddf6011267","unit:5b8b77361824dcc686ca693c4425197ddf0ff020b24af62897d86784f1cbad9b","unit:c40a86235cd7c595290180eb708f8bc59e1fbe2c543b61756bd61226e53bc745","unit:c6c86df782561dcce60ac528d3d4dc67d6575ad8ad7091b986a1faf68f273f77","unit:d1e0189cb1c9032a1ca8e475132eb6492a2a476bda7c8998a16b126e3c9bb972","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a","unit:efb8179652cb838f3a7c8812145553616d4b9274ce7d13a81cfac102b0b6764b","unit:f185332de23766b66a802f2bede69479f1849089774b79ca0687079cab79d78c","unit:f208201c60b72fdd70b35c7d69c3fedc571c52d157cc73bfad2b7e23b0636649","unit:fd36b395fa2112b50ab90ad9277c4995601fbc01745ad016309e652c75ae826e","unit:fe24f21300fba4f511139d03921cc978ec067dc5643d0a5593fbd5f62c50bd7e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-ph/0409138","sourceId":"ev:8431ccca320b33b8d6cc4356beb462d2","sourceSha256":"f841c4fa0f3e4ba26fdd984d9938db7bf9ddae6ee40a3871fd5cb8702020a415","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1b94666753a5f70c2c97/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6fef795fcb90da390e24fc14fb07b0e1fae3b1e7c002be6c79f061e28c832567","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":2880,"textSha256":"f53279150048677683108bc626724ae7ee0aeb94a8da2a656354a5a1959bb209","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"1601.00647","sourceId":"ev:c0c1b5ba4099d90f79fa887ea66e098b","sourceSha256":"af73d72b99cfe98fd808e7068b325f4ed5de98f9f286fa3145deb86ee6a04e28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/46b944d680584c1d27be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"02c858afb93dddff0c9a69d7b63832fd3126ea2006bd5f6c141412e80a48a013","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2776,"textSha256":"0beb1b9ed093485e222a6a1661ad6fadd8de5269dca74298714c57a6349abb9a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"1601.00647","sourceId":"ev:eed8bfb32e4fd44b980e1cb9a4308d99","sourceSha256":"af73d72b99cfe98fd808e7068b325f4ed5de98f9f286fa3145deb86ee6a04e28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/46b944d680584c1d27be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"02c858afb93dddff0c9a69d7b63832fd3126ea2006bd5f6c141412e80a48a013","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":932,"textSha256":"ef6aafd679b72c326e42173dafeedfa09424ae626429f15d295586acf545522f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:da7e1b3465123fbe0038994d","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:4","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:632fafe96baf728ba9d00850","parent-native:challenge:cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b82"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Fundamental periods and effective range enhancement share a direction while retaining different measurements and assumptions.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Shared access to fundamental periods and effective range enhancement, retaining their different measurements and premises.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-ph/0409138","sourceId":"ev:8431ccca320b33b8d6cc4356beb462d2","sourceSha256":"f841c4fa0f3e4ba26fdd984d9938db7bf9ddae6ee40a3871fd5cb8702020a415","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1b94666753a5f70c2c97/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6fef795fcb90da390e24fc14fb07b0e1fae3b1e7c002be6c79f061e28c832567","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":2880,"textSha256":"f53279150048677683108bc626724ae7ee0aeb94a8da2a656354a5a1959bb209","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"1601.00647","sourceId":"ev:c0c1b5ba4099d90f79fa887ea66e098b","sourceSha256":"af73d72b99cfe98fd808e7068b325f4ed5de98f9f286fa3145deb86ee6a04e28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/46b944d680584c1d27be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"02c858afb93dddff0c9a69d7b63832fd3126ea2006bd5f6c141412e80a48a013","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2776,"textSha256":"0beb1b9ed093485e222a6a1661ad6fadd8de5269dca74298714c57a6349abb9a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"1601.00647","sourceId":"ev:eed8bfb32e4fd44b980e1cb9a4308d99","sourceSha256":"af73d72b99cfe98fd808e7068b325f4ed5de98f9f286fa3145deb86ee6a04e28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/46b944d680584c1d27be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"02c858afb93dddff0c9a69d7b63832fd3126ea2006bd5f6c141412e80a48a013","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":932,"textSha256":"ef6aafd679b72c326e42173dafeedfa09424ae626429f15d295586acf545522f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-ph/0409138","sourceId":"ev:8431ccca320b33b8d6cc4356beb462d2","sourceSha256":"f841c4fa0f3e4ba26fdd984d9938db7bf9ddae6ee40a3871fd5cb8702020a415","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1b94666753a5f70c2c97/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6fef795fcb90da390e24fc14fb07b0e1fae3b1e7c002be6c79f061e28c832567","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":2880,"textSha256":"f53279150048677683108bc626724ae7ee0aeb94a8da2a656354a5a1959bb209","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"1601.00647","sourceId":"ev:c0c1b5ba4099d90f79fa887ea66e098b","sourceSha256":"af73d72b99cfe98fd808e7068b325f4ed5de98f9f286fa3145deb86ee6a04e28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/46b944d680584c1d27be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"02c858afb93dddff0c9a69d7b63832fd3126ea2006bd5f6c141412e80a48a013","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2776,"textSha256":"0beb1b9ed093485e222a6a1661ad6fadd8de5269dca74298714c57a6349abb9a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"1601.00647","sourceId":"ev:eed8bfb32e4fd44b980e1cb9a4308d99","sourceSha256":"af73d72b99cfe98fd808e7068b325f4ed5de98f9f286fa3145deb86ee6a04e28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/46b944d680584c1d27be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"02c858afb93dddff0c9a69d7b63832fd3126ea2006bd5f6c141412e80a48a013","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":932,"textSha256":"ef6aafd679b72c326e42173dafeedfa09424ae626429f15d295586acf545522f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:da7e1b3465123fbe0038994d","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:aae5486f699ef827cb4828ee":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:aae5486f699ef827cb4828ee","source":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","target":"q025-candidate-question:e7f1f7e0dfa9ec3de0d57a1e","type":"narrower","title":"Constructing and protecting monodromy inflation","rationale":"Monodromy construction and protection provide a distinct framework direction; proposed control remains a target.","qualification":"Construction and protection of monodromy potentials form a distinct framework direction.","evidenceIds":["unit:140b3a523f0bcabd9cceddeaf88f1637614ca6a40a70c5fb411131505321ee02","unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","unit:2472aa7f6431071a7ecfd145294b3acc1b55c8f5dd05e532b58afaca295edef5","unit:25d18c6e50abd9338849640ded0d4fa4d8a88cae4c6d75ecf757465d6692d665","unit:360f186d6fb696c05871d35f590905c504ab190c5396b5e1bda349043206cf3a","unit:4280a9997fa9bce959e29c0e0b884b8a7f2cf98990583a72ffa337b9621400ba","unit:53bf2a5e8129d30faba8f8a17ff0fd94fa21b3c96247e3a026580aa96083e23a","unit:5885ca7377c8a47b4792f55bf07368c1830a042674fee672923b92ca8a13e5a5","unit:6ae168479f8b7403955c468a7f7cb5af03a5a3ceeb95836dc598ae2fa1562935","unit:7b194abe4bcf98640e000727b1cea7787f60534195647e780bb5aabff5144731","unit:9b3a25ae335112ce544d932aef8a713a361ac3bb3d4edd2c88402c4bab50752e","unit:a2fe8916034090315b510a4bfa9d61585f4a21f732589d70584aced15acf0f64","unit:a3dafc31c72c964ef5877a204ffb0f9a11f227ea7ac132a29c69f11b12b62819","unit:a534fb598f77ae2d0285862d752530bd98d9f1a9f367ed3584a6ae148119094a","unit:ada147e3d763277ce23584cb79825409ada4200825b2e7df029057248d44ec28","unit:af2e052d9530868d5fcd5aa5824eed5fe147778a90cff8799d14b803ad79fcb7","unit:b1483427933eecccc5ae0ae9b367e49aca455e879cfde8bfebde38a9003a60d6","unit:b6f16126a8df0660481b3e9a274dffa137a4396f76b43e99033ca07ca0a3e36e","unit:bf40421712b0d217a22c6d4bf39582855ec9be408acbdc6f3ce29e123b2b3792","unit:c6c86df782561dcce60ac528d3d4dc67d6575ad8ad7091b986a1faf68f273f77","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a","unit:ed213e8733a265277001f044df867dc39bff8c00e1eff18ea6bd5f9cf4f0b38a","unit:f185332de23766b66a802f2bede69479f1849089774b79ca0687079cab79d78c","unit:fa4daec4d6482245ec3bc5df595f21ec1ec74fcc05686495f2e7b5c5c792d5aa"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e7f1f7e0dfa9ec3de0d57a1e"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceId":"ev:6475a36d27af5f426e6dcafc138e18ee","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":3702,"end":5258,"textSha256":"3b386ffdd7e00343d9b8b9c78a87c535d4ebd1153ce40d5598760376100d573b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceId":"ev:6fbfc7c06218d1d003c92a9d3fd374a3","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"d6edb05265bfd680fcf58e49ee05b7dbfe68c6b77f17ac6c6b0970f6aa23b9ce","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceId":"ev:e9f6cdddd5e5c88c22931151b9dd2d01","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":1307,"end":4704,"textSha256":"75cdbcbda398bc937658606360153f2b5dd29fcf1bb0b21a7eac1355800f1c43","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:aae5486f699ef827cb4828ee","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:5","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:632fafe96baf728ba9d00850","parent-native:challenge:cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b82"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Monodromy construction and protection provide a distinct framework direction; proposed control remains a target.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Construction and protection of monodromy potentials form a distinct framework direction.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e7f1f7e0dfa9ec3de0d57a1e"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceId":"ev:6475a36d27af5f426e6dcafc138e18ee","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":3702,"end":5258,"textSha256":"3b386ffdd7e00343d9b8b9c78a87c535d4ebd1153ce40d5598760376100d573b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceId":"ev:6fbfc7c06218d1d003c92a9d3fd374a3","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"d6edb05265bfd680fcf58e49ee05b7dbfe68c6b77f17ac6c6b0970f6aa23b9ce","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceId":"ev:e9f6cdddd5e5c88c22931151b9dd2d01","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":1307,"end":4704,"textSha256":"75cdbcbda398bc937658606360153f2b5dd29fcf1bb0b21a7eac1355800f1c43","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e7f1f7e0dfa9ec3de0d57a1e"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceId":"ev:6475a36d27af5f426e6dcafc138e18ee","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":3702,"end":5258,"textSha256":"3b386ffdd7e00343d9b8b9c78a87c535d4ebd1153ce40d5598760376100d573b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceId":"ev:6fbfc7c06218d1d003c92a9d3fd374a3","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"d6edb05265bfd680fcf58e49ee05b7dbfe68c6b77f17ac6c6b0970f6aa23b9ce","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceId":"ev:e9f6cdddd5e5c88c22931151b9dd2d01","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":1307,"end":4704,"textSha256":"75cdbcbda398bc937658606360153f2b5dd29fcf1bb0b21a7eac1355800f1c43","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:aae5486f699ef827cb4828ee","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:parent-reasserted:63f27d6a0412a7a7653048bc":{"id":"navigation:parent-reasserted:63f27d6a0412a7a7653048bc","source":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","target":"q025-candidate-question:e8e6b3ce91854a1f951673cb","type":"narrower","title":"Backreaction and validity of axion trajectories","rationale":"Physical trajectory questions require companion-field, kinetic and EFT-validity checks beyond coordinate displacement.","qualification":"Physical trajectories require separate attention to companion fields, kinetic geometry and EFT validity.","evidenceIds":["unit:0aacb2f51d637ca4427e2def670018cb6de3b695d8dbfae5455552c89c072966","unit:104260b9a56d84ab04eb5d7e114008be579d8f8bb3e8a508774e0ae73ad6a649","unit:10ec2b4baf0ee06c640c0b17912b0c889ca8b1dc6374175fdfa3a4f80bba3865","unit:1346637c74e520e5d2cf965d89575d05855a8acc8229050ac525ef915369288f","unit:16516a56d3ac8e73bc13cb49617cdde9977dcccd4518ab1af0dafa31402f05d8","unit:231ce17c6a2db51553f8735cdb5a6c8a885f7b8f2910777f04c1b85701586023","unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","unit:2472aa7f6431071a7ecfd145294b3acc1b55c8f5dd05e532b58afaca295edef5","unit:2a5415c009e4ebfc381ff601f91eea9ff6f766f8fbbe3a98c50f5e5d68fa16a5","unit:482460fce4af89e5cb58ce80a5532d91713c0bbdf0bc0f252ddb903db7ea91f1","unit:564bd310d79479177cd5a3ed626f0d7c841610484bf93ee32102db20419cc120","unit:58aa0e240769cf1b9f23b549f8286495db557d6790c1d9dc6f4e3544f5bf315c","unit:5b8b77361824dcc686ca693c4425197ddf0ff020b24af62897d86784f1cbad9b","unit:79426bd9c2164856e134ca655f1522136eb0a2be32fc1efff6301fd6fd9d321b","unit:c40a86235cd7c595290180eb708f8bc59e1fbe2c543b61756bd61226e53bc745","unit:c6c86df782561dcce60ac528d3d4dc67d6575ad8ad7091b986a1faf68f273f77","unit:d94216671b5adbeed629f636c52033a2e08eee1ce8fd78d85dba72f970cdbb91","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a","unit:efb8179652cb838f3a7c8812145553616d4b9274ce7d13a81cfac102b0b6764b","unit:f185332de23766b66a802f2bede69479f1849089774b79ca0687079cab79d78c","unit:f208201c60b72fdd70b35c7d69c3fedc571c52d157cc73bfad2b7e23b0636649","unit:f663cf4368fe8df3b12dde05a79ffc1034907757ec12d0c37f539c76420634f4","unit:fa3e75bad4146b538a292a38fa2588928adf1605e76185d0faa9da84fe2f0af1","unit:fd36b395fa2112b50ab90ad9277c4995601fbc01745ad016309e652c75ae826e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e8e6b3ce91854a1f951673cb"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"1812.07558","sourceId":"ev:3537e818df942d2ff09de23cfe140800","sourceSha256":"654bbb5a4b7ae3f43fd6a9dc93e7f05ea202967be9e560117956c27cfa6679dd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8a22553f66b06003a453/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"57f7ae0cfad83626d602a8d334ce6ea250b4eb5f3520d98b61ea247a26b42be3","pdfPage":11,"start":2122,"end":4610,"textSha256":"c0f21e49619e6d40bb503f8504596f4c52cab3db4a5957b2ba530cfe9bfe0c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"1812.07558","sourceId":"ev:9895e39526c47a1635783d59739b0a1c","sourceSha256":"654bbb5a4b7ae3f43fd6a9dc93e7f05ea202967be9e560117956c27cfa6679dd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8a22553f66b06003a453/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"57f7ae0cfad83626d602a8d334ce6ea250b4eb5f3520d98b61ea247a26b42be3","pdfPage":12,"start":171,"end":3171,"textSha256":"91b5526498e1192d41d16bb55f852a3c1d7343131705e81f39477ce218de8244","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceId":"ev:e9f6cdddd5e5c88c22931151b9dd2d01","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":1307,"end":4704,"textSha256":"75cdbcbda398bc937658606360153f2b5dd29fcf1bb0b21a7eac1355800f1c43","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:63f27d6a0412a7a7653048bc","provenance":{"sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_reauthored_under_original_parent_contract","observations":[{"candidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:6","sourceReviewIds":["parent-native:proposal:632fafe96baf728ba9d00850","parent-native:challenge:cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b82"],"originalNativeType":"narrows","challengeReason":"Physical trajectory questions require companion-field, kinetic and EFT-validity checks beyond coordinate displacement.","priorStatements":[{"reason":"Physical trajectories require separate attention to companion fields, kinetic geometry and EFT validity.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e8e6b3ce91854a1f951673cb"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"1812.07558","sourceId":"ev:3537e818df942d2ff09de23cfe140800","sourceSha256":"654bbb5a4b7ae3f43fd6a9dc93e7f05ea202967be9e560117956c27cfa6679dd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8a22553f66b06003a453/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"57f7ae0cfad83626d602a8d334ce6ea250b4eb5f3520d98b61ea247a26b42be3","pdfPage":11,"start":2122,"end":4610,"textSha256":"c0f21e49619e6d40bb503f8504596f4c52cab3db4a5957b2ba530cfe9bfe0c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"1812.07558","sourceId":"ev:9895e39526c47a1635783d59739b0a1c","sourceSha256":"654bbb5a4b7ae3f43fd6a9dc93e7f05ea202967be9e560117956c27cfa6679dd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8a22553f66b06003a453/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"57f7ae0cfad83626d602a8d334ce6ea250b4eb5f3520d98b61ea247a26b42be3","pdfPage":12,"start":171,"end":3171,"textSha256":"91b5526498e1192d41d16bb55f852a3c1d7343131705e81f39477ce218de8244","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceId":"ev:e9f6cdddd5e5c88c22931151b9dd2d01","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":1307,"end":4704,"textSha256":"75cdbcbda398bc937658606360153f2b5dd29fcf1bb0b21a7eac1355800f1c43","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"challengeEvidenceRefs":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e8e6b3ce91854a1f951673cb"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"1812.07558","sourceId":"ev:3537e818df942d2ff09de23cfe140800","sourceSha256":"654bbb5a4b7ae3f43fd6a9dc93e7f05ea202967be9e560117956c27cfa6679dd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8a22553f66b06003a453/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"57f7ae0cfad83626d602a8d334ce6ea250b4eb5f3520d98b61ea247a26b42be3","pdfPage":11,"start":2122,"end":4610,"textSha256":"c0f21e49619e6d40bb503f8504596f4c52cab3db4a5957b2ba530cfe9bfe0c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"1812.07558","sourceId":"ev:9895e39526c47a1635783d59739b0a1c","sourceSha256":"654bbb5a4b7ae3f43fd6a9dc93e7f05ea202967be9e560117956c27cfa6679dd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8a22553f66b06003a453/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"57f7ae0cfad83626d602a8d334ce6ea250b4eb5f3520d98b61ea247a26b42be3","pdfPage":12,"start":171,"end":3171,"textSha256":"91b5526498e1192d41d16bb55f852a3c1d7343131705e81f39477ce218de8244","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceId":"ev:e9f6cdddd5e5c88c22931151b9dd2d01","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":1307,"end":4704,"textSha256":"75cdbcbda398bc937658606360153f2b5dd29fcf1bb0b21a7eac1355800f1c43","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"reviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"noExplicitLinkReviewsFieldClaimed":true}],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","nativeType":"narrows","noNewerLinkReviewsClaim":true,"coordinatorTypeMap":"narrower","decisionId":"decision:parent-reasserted:63f27d6a0412a7a7653048bc","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:screen-conflict:n4794":{"id":"navigation:screen-conflict:n4794","source":"q025-candidate-region:4b1b43798f4cff47d094ef0a","target":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","type":"comparison","title":"Weak gravity, black-hole bounds and neighboring diagnostics","rationale":"Compare light-field cloud signals with conditional weak-gravity diagnostics.","qualification":"Cloud signals or spin constraints do not by themselves test the charged spectrum of a specified weak-gravity formulation. Shared methods and conditional applications remain nominations, not admitted scientific claims.","evidenceIds":["unit:0117a9cf3f76cc8d96d54767bed479ad69e7ca2f0a2489c0bba309109c13e946","unit:0420386896116997f9d93c655a9a0fb3b27bbb2a274ad18abef8bc4c3dc3fe0d","unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","unit:17bdc8a426ac6b6b065b7e1cb157370aeed8a77c52758b49a6330e9def3cfb56","unit:1a53d58f3915072098c87122a494b17aa46de6f14fdbd2c0cc9a70184483bdb0","unit:1e0b62fef6d88368f14aa9f84041a33d5f8b936c7b9e126d935c8f502e4d1e44","unit:2294e2535ad9cbcc8a710083374c23fa24e5d7dae4413c76901664d015c9c527","unit:250f00a77454639daab4d868b8fbf4201fb055c349e01ce92146b2043a656345","unit:25b08e923faccd30417be78d70b65751bff47f9afa89ec8cc12f21cdd11b6aba","unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","unit:276adf2e98150b2c186a8579dcc80deb499b90809192a919238990efea0089d6","unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","unit:2b1b860fbdb83c7d8c55b6f81c97a2ced236f791c884a2daa85528579985b2f7","unit:2bdf6897d3ad965723709b3de07b4376f98a144c39d28a99e15696afa0673655","unit:2c57554bd891179447c68ade7c563016eb986b9f3a7fd71ae6e8448d2ca8a71b","unit:33795b828c5d509854c6ec3adce7eeee65ea986fb28dc301a1390891b2de3c71","unit:35a216e6c5501f63c4009a8bdc97b17298648c6a87de5530f62c4873a5aeb9db","unit:3ab86e61e8814610ec2787793b95ec264381823425e0b04d029bb9a3ca53ca59","unit:3ff699bc6587ebbe1237f6282e32360be69c5148170a34d55491650fe330050a","unit:4212b356374ee46c6eaae28709a8a879683f90f4691236e3c6073843250f65cc","unit:442450ed577c0ace11aed790b64aa09b9cb6701356ca17f277f10a0e54c9ca3b","unit:47f20c13555b6a24e036eb69dac9e33374893a5dd73e32257e2e2d23a39ca6c6","unit:4815ffb5b30606a1aa43bd5d25b7609dc8685ddec78bd8b43a2fbd6229321a99","unit:4a8b876bcba99634b4c95779f37fa0547a65d27c6bbf4010a534aafe14bed149","unit:4bea2236adce2a83cf3c451f430db2b31ccbb60826ec94caf64e9a0ca2613854","unit:4e2cab08e7f0df6be0448a25a839294e700e472b95d20785a81b881d554b05f1","unit:4e8aff51cfadc15ced0de3baa6d5794543d998151b82590318c26746e7a80cfb","unit:50ae26e7178dc7c8152a1eb463d1a62ab05d5fe5152cfa680c672feab1c5408a","unit:5107683aa5078cfb208f0295f4a0d5c5399428d73b3e61aa6838241082db58de","unit:5188ce81d62d67277a73c7069ddfd7c21b6038edf540a0a0f0c7eb3bc7f0da31","unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","unit:57efaacada3863df7e123e58e578da23f20a5e64026a365781eb3ad5232b873d","unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","unit:6254a0d609b810a26b3a951611cd0ad87c34c5ed96e5cab7a245ac3e6a38b94c","unit:62b40ad157d793c9cc78f21fa8d1d19ae7adab53275014bd7e8a60c51b0b2171","unit:63eaf4c1dd6b6aa06f6e83ceed9c4254299f6278e0ca399a33dc39fa2898ea1d","unit:69ab822f9ef72c6e77724c7e855a82a64f800d947b2c9bd535fa649d760447bc","unit:6b80cef545935f21b527b5ceeb703dafa0329cb3b10cadfe77a906ff93929c8c","unit:7509711d28ea068af122a682e1a69d0f317098085664dc2a7929fb6c9f62e68f","unit:753eb80972aeb4eef8bed36c3cb2d5095c7adbe4b7dcf803204ab2b1475b8eba","unit:78f8c006ee532a8f2f71ede7991935e6ff0cb89fa0bd684233b37250ad31efaf","unit:7eab9a098f85c6a0b7562d4142c361bcaf441b882f40d53761b48e1cb315dc17","unit:8ae09dace2d4af58ff11886bc22142df89fcfa8ed88ab3af85e43b27273d84cb","unit:8c95002112050360fd76dd930e1e653b08a02969e99c77000bf3c6d1a9032505","unit:9191adcddf262538f4a5c2f8acf3f1530bceb4b4c1276da25cf3d50b8e566fe5","unit:94794b970e2c6ee6f19e94eefdc28cc8ff8f029cb53bf01ebd46e00bb64e8ff4","unit:9f82c7e6ecaccd2d0c5e41eb0688af2055cabd987e8e27800b862e41a8704433","unit:a2166410499a2bef7c018bf486d7539e60be7b0619b4bffd63e6fb544c597dc0","unit:a241ceeb60f8ce44b604d840e35480933137033c69cba89afcb21797c8fce2c7","unit:a3529ebf11deefb232a45e387c3826c342bf9168ed78b2093e2ae96feb51fb79","unit:a3df2663033601cc3412d9f5a1ad0f07255ce84ed88f69bcef1921cf237a2a3d","unit:b29e943f46599a933462f1a4d376e1ef14b2f6708aac265ad11131c6b8790d62","unit:b302e962d78c38c66e4c7b6b748fceb724c9457299310651bfa90dc64ce4190a","unit:b502c3d7a4c574777a3aff1ab878a16ee135a693de189664b41c0189004c3659","unit:be3c6edb12ec861b9845aca564c31c0ac1bfce92770620a25ca7b058cc7906bc","unit:c21c27956bcaf785e9e22220849c3b2ef508a04eee76456f52b4199d0422b106","unit:c53fe0cb63661e4735a97407619f188f8e9d897c8a059f35f5ecead70e743130","unit:c542faa4b1b9322025c6645622489f285cf811fad163096d8a2ce58e2ff47fb6","unit:c6214d47eef85c8576b1d85fbb1ce2a25ab523cd0429710e3a182400ba1c2397","unit:c6563221c2c1dca457447c30242889f9167ce8b510d99c43cf82a1f86f103018","unit:c968f06d50228fe212cb7e45816b7f35e3444357e758e2832990902058a57ac6","unit:cc67b01b92cc0c69e48900ed71b3aa6a7e229bcdd620425ee89d7f7a1ffa12e1","unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","unit:cf77a2f729303877f62ebf6a57f2e63cfa0a7f89da85b8e9a0f155568982b217","unit:d06b2c47e3f97274183d8bda455ea3fa831af1448dca3d2c9f8882b42c598930","unit:d22c24711af895746971fbd84b326f858447ea7119bfe47f18062cd62b0d3901","unit:dc31b1e4e5ac9c0d62ed98a3a4d88240c5c55f56653e92e52d59c32647cfbc65","unit:e5217d6bfd5a06bb7a32126b865514eacd2c783cfccf3c2e79aaa94240038adb","unit:e722ad5b450f745a3b93641c4229c3d871bdac170eb7dc52217d33a0a1c6b264","unit:e7a65f8d645fbdd101fa0033714297e9cb79a940dacd4ffc3e645c1f498dd6ad","unit:ea2129ac6e7dfd542549a7202edfba610e6440b0b5f7335908058d5f5ce19294","unit:ecf9f9b202f60b0c0ca316429727217b4caf4f64191a741564d505447c9ccb97","unit:ef3d845a857d7254b7c1aecfbe4be69bc2c547574efd300ab012ca5b8b78c32d","unit:efb3e8a7ab876f220ebbeb63b3c90d95796d05249052b7f51c30295b4ba0f7f6","unit:fd43742ca58f46da5f51bf854f14e8cbd18802b75920ca2975df42affd04e2b5"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"admitted_scope_definition","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:4b1b43798f4cff47d094ef0a","scopeContentSha256":"c27e7c690d53caa33e3da863b071c125439ece276a7a296d2a3538f6632d34c1","definitionSha256":"d37fd1e504a663720694648db8f1bd1b458e9473bcd26eca3358d54b9d26e7d8"},{"kind":"admitted_scope_definition","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","definitionSha256":"f9841731decea0afacdb241d368004b615fbaddc02f68ea350cfd6cc82a59752"}],"decisionId":"decision:screen-conflict:n4794","provenance":{"screenNominationId":"n4794","variantRef":"attempt1:comparisonReviews:n4794","readingBasis":"coordinator_complete_definition_review","freshPrimaryReading":false,"pairedPerUnitNotesReadForThisDecision":false,"pairedLinkVerdict":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","originalSelectedScreen":{"ref":"n4794","identityScreen":"different_scoped_targets","scientificConnections":["shared_method","conditional_application","comparison"],"basis":"scope_definition","priority":"definition_decision_candidate","definingDifferences":["c1183 centers cloud dynamics and light-field signals; c1577 centers conditional weak-gravity diagnostics.","Spin or gravitational-wave boson constraints do not automatically constrain the charged spectrum required by a WGC formulation."],"reason":"The target change is explicit. Spectral or relaxation methods could connect selected questions after matching field charges, backgrounds and assumptions; superradiance membership alone supplies no WGC implication.","refs":["c1183","c1577"]},"originalAlternateScreen":{"ref":"n4794","identityScreen":"different_scoped_targets","scientificConnections":["shared_method","conditional_application"],"basis":"scope_definition","priority":"definition_decision_candidate","definingDifferences":["c1183 targets light-field clouds and their signals; c1577 targets conditional weak-gravity constraints and neighboring diagnostics.","Boson spin or gravitational-wave constraints need not concern a charged-particle spectrum."],"reason":"The definitions distinguish observational cloud questions from weak-gravity tests. Spectral or relaxation methods could connect them only after checking field charges, background, growth assumptions and the proposed conjectural implication.","refs":["c1183","c1577"]},"originalConflictAssessment":{"variantRef":"attempt1:comparisonReviews:n4794","judgment":"material_conflict","definingDifferences":["The alternate removes comparison from scientificConnections, retaining only shared_method and conditional_application.","The different_scoped_targets identity judgment remains unchanged; the conflict concerns the explicit scientific connection."],"reason":"Removing the comparison route changes a completed connection judgment. The distinct cloud-probe and weak-gravity targets do not make comparison redundant with method reuse or conditional application. Preserve the selected judgment and withhold the alternate for adjudication.","refs":["c1183","c1577"]},"historicalScopeAssessments":[{"ref":"c1183","priorReadingAssessment":{"decision":"supported_as_written","scopeChange":"same","replacement":"","note":"The numerical proposal alone establishes no scientific unity. The exact prior region is supported as a heterogeneous family with explicit neighboring routes. Alternate dispositions concern the narrower superradiance core, not eligibility for the broader family; ordinary and pre-Swampland questions remain eligible."}},{"ref":"c1577","priorReadingAssessment":{"decision":"supported_as_written","scopeChange":"same","replacement":"","note":"The original numerical selection does not establish a common physical predicate. The exact prior region is nevertheless supported as a broad navigation family because it preserves heterogeneous questions, conditional interpretations and alternate homes."}}],"inputPins":{"packet":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0039-screen-completion/packet.actual.json","sha256":"094c92872d86c9181fd92a2ad186f1b3eaf58960f48e9aaae93ac6ff631a4f79"},"reply":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0039-screen-completion/reply.json","sha256":"d73e23dbb3a237b7a97cf3e6481ca4b0a60f17846e3376f4ce70e3690615abd2"},"normalization":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0039-screen-completion/normalization.json","sha256":"fadc3eac22d691cb8dc68691e28deefad7af1d5facb0cb343d190404d931cb3e"},"receipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0039-screen-completion/receipt.json","sha256":"7b47f5fb14eb213908430c24a4ed96e5790793c5a508c2ddd0c67d801ab38e54"}},"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","decisionId":"decision:screen-conflict:n4794","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:screen-conflict:n5103":{"id":"navigation:screen-conflict:n5103","source":"q025-candidate-region:9454e2dc275dec5e822bba03","target":"q025-candidate-region:0373a22d5bfba4144b34728b","type":"comparison","title":"Black-hole corrections, thermodynamics and adjoining structures","rationale":"Compare charge retention and discharge processes with corrected equilibrium and thermodynamic questions.","qualification":"Equilibrium or extremality corrections do not establish dynamical accessibility, a nonzero emission rate or a short lifetime. Matter sector, approximation and dynamics remain source-specific.","evidenceIds":["unit:0d6e960e72bca88185dda6b524682a894dd2fbdcef7130c4a65006db9cb6663f","unit:143d93388147d279b650be4b61634a1631aa2be664cfb3aa810025ca8e3984f7","unit:151822cebd530bc89ef31bc2293f2213b585ebef17202aaa220318cf5d97b739","unit:1834f4b5e0ec8ae541bf2af110d283008c3197872ea91eb59958386dca077eb9","unit:1877ac824b12f923a22b9a1410a474675bcab4fcc7fee2a93c55f9d96742d23a","unit:1a4b6b75844cc50b4421f0f0c2c54e836c240836e86362590c4cc2c89e5f268b","unit:1ad7e1448faa2822223e5bfa33c744c6a2076e14289fbd244e85c213fb578476","unit:1efd9f9c192ab47eb9d6b64ea349f9a6c0b2cf5d7672b12b7dafd61e379548a7","unit:2072546c33c7beab8e62e690504370dc9e8cb749bd0ea68b412c643706ca940e","unit:25e50cf0d0c93ce5a51d4da0f884796d5145450e7798d5c79585492c25c5a652","unit:265f636e5b8c4af14debd6b2cbec78178e9b65f33cdcae183e62dc36da13766e","unit:2a292d9c1f609e6b7b62503b0606bbb682b3d64055262aad8acfa0e6be8c76b6","unit:3120acdf8712ea2a085f4f7fc5b0aadcb5dec534e94228d84eaf4cd44bd31c61","unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","unit:3a270e0aeff8114e04b2252be47b23163f3375a232f890db0ae0c73850f08fe9","unit:3c106070bf074f6507e76f297d665fec11c195d39b6edf65e83ca0a5905723f8","unit:3c8e3edc0617fdf6f99991a291884bf52d86a543efbc494ebb93486c824d470c","unit:3f984b792760fc7c233a7b05279a99cf4c2f2a0d6c5c0a4530e3e38748dae8d3","unit:44a1ca5f443bbf0d189876dfc9dc435b49c7bf3732a0bfc7b5a43ec242884d03","unit:47f20c13555b6a24e036eb69dac9e33374893a5dd73e32257e2e2d23a39ca6c6","unit:48d159e6ec1b6e90f62ea33493ecc393688701e840a04f196b4fe7ed0fe76373","unit:49f038a6240393ef3562478a459444ca77c77d934ad799f75e4708cb5e957cab","unit:4c32bdfa28be69aa88fae99dfa39e46313efca7eb0a52a634655680b45e567b0","unit:4eed395343818bfba203c6fb50a1692618ec3ad5b5c9c362928a4cb25d471ef7","unit:52e3584c514ebebe470005d57fd1e9beb298f6e6b66be25969930ceb01d253a1","unit:530da9a14202edd3f640458385ba13f8bb5818132ec972130e5836d253d4a239","unit:5311dc99f3430f7032763d85160d29683df4356ea8bdf483093010dd804882fd","unit:55793d616bd78fdb5fd72de6dd8be224c096f26641468c99c8869dad9ea3126e","unit:565b7ff08372b2e5678b6addd4274268ae7a4773323149e8b064129b9013008c","unit:5875ad92d475ee3b8193c14295d78bcbb755ff270ad9cde807dc5d0c2a130957","unit:5c65d0cc3602f62da727f036ccdefaed1719e834b500725b75902f372f9d3e66","unit:5e772a318ef7be8c945f9d319d01674f0415ff74d9c34fc08b5bab13c69de57a","unit:5e8532e5d51877e6508933ce812aee19d40f5c30fc314fa643ab478e9470eb0a","unit:5ead4ae79a9f4c448d9f47daddc72047adc7d0385aa0c7a0aef9e117ce97a12c","unit:5eb7269d133bcc124e5f2978561dfaf43be90ea823d6a8ac7c5284bc5b02f9d4","unit:60176c056a981821ae51ac8415d8413e091f389281336bf6b558de555075ac93","unit:618c7476e9bd17d716b6730a0c83a5b14174deb00690e4bdd359630f74f131ed","unit:628ddeb6d1147c1586be4269d21e3008f4cee6841751649478a2383137fba1ae","unit:62b0fc57ba710c6a81d38c5fa4efe1e4bd57e1d8d6d3c04802355eb9d68fca00","unit:632375f47b6ebe7abe302950673fb2c489271d92fc2110cd14ac0990dcb709a5","unit:6686c0f595e92020810dcd791a1fc5ab5ee933267f487569b762fc37a24dbf96","unit:677b609b049f341afd42fb330c4de6b855d17323c43de47a19079f48a18aa4c3","unit:68b2460dbd5e441bfa56c8a9dfb9ce0ee2a84d74f21591cdc3ecd5e4763aa332","unit:6c60987ceda9c57485fc5104c2484ef87a196893d0ae66d1fff69c54e03d98fd","unit:6df39bcb6b52192e783e45e332d170619d74452ddfa32f036f52c1457ca2c8e1","unit:6fe9b12c0029cb6df18bcb3e8b769d27239e24bb1a599c4ff136a4a671b34ea5","unit:721996feece6b9126b562fae0456d931908b41d1caff084c2532a2f90d0c7537","unit:721e755cfa00e72412262ca696dee1be27d2f117b5661c9f9e4b68db0e9d322e","unit:72adc931d1154a2532da4df175555681ba6f4398e90b9d459a0751c90029c4cf","unit:72bbb8d97766ebab58410a0c0b1cea282137820056cabaf3c12c763d7b5ac8c3","unit:745f35375ebfb12aece3f15c491f2ecd90af4e669e1107e37754ca972cc5f180","unit:787534e2e35e019673c656715a983d3413316961ea455fd7e07a57627a3fe3dd","unit:7a51a318f853da645a4e7c073f452e8b31664afe3cf0f9fa153d19c330037177","unit:7df1c85da845450c9716b165c05aa684929f21e5fec2536297b438c8c216a6b1","unit:7f74ed53aa9e88488adf9350f6c34e4c409b716f24a0b2def99253e7842a7b56","unit:8223ed8ebb386b7371b4da04d99a06fbb6fd076fca118d4bbd5ea3b42f9d4d20","unit:82a99483cb65e6f9ef40b859c9cdc8503d00d8230cdc5641a19c3b1bccfd7bb0","unit:8f15f6385386378b356ad6e3313e4da862585485372f2311c4a2e2ac92ffe4ab","unit:95609cc4e7bb836fab3f8d5763087c674eec09ef7452e10e98b4254798c27011","unit:99e6cb62f73ec8c5d20696492e826550b8b8310f6460ee4effff2a9f77e4a3ea","unit:a031fc2d256129f061136749fbade74e97986eb3eabacbcc514bfc8b00ed4a46","unit:a5d8b5b4b53946f24f3b04fecbfcdc0a8caf1b001f97da321d8e15a33638657e","unit:a727b64eab87223cc4d4ac4151fdddb01bfa16692c58e7b096151cda1be54fdf","unit:aa187c3dd3581f687242bc9e00d3c89aba683ff9177b0014ae3df06a6b1eace8","unit:aab79ee6f2a343e96318f32a41936dd346556077c12d2c3927112d255ad8b3de","unit:accfe2a19c4fb08ce0eb7fdd83f5012cde08774653f070f81705669e75537fb6","unit:aec57e70b80e9bdc7e512dbde8ef185526f6c385bca773378758644114e61b3d","unit:afcb4402d62a090a6e6dcaf9aceb57af1da8a5526c38f6e16bbc43044f580997","unit:b1e385cc48b784981ee54d5147073e605f6f8b58bced0582512d2ddbdebd158a","unit:b35ae44c6ba74a9966e60b6bc994be69e207b51b2d01e515329ee1674f058fcd","unit:b3b0f8f1f4818b59a2950deea42af23fd0ec4532d6d475ba3c37dae542d64c30","unit:b5505445a85f89950ba6f38d799d36a1a46dac4f03dffa2e386a69b4c2895fb8","unit:b58a3ad71c793111d5d8d7025b3a3347bcf56652af65c3684c18af99e2480f56","unit:b595bc30dfbeb3610478f1f561421de0c24500efb36e372387a9357cedae59e5","unit:b60bdb72c08ffc5ad3d28ff091ddc05bcc76edf0c54e64ea1e5dbb4277b5b7e3","unit:b83d41617038331d16fae81216e62872b17f5b98219d20a94a085a90f61e26cb","unit:b8eeb04259e98f50dddd3f2b07a0adf79cb2d75e0d24509dc3d4649af2eae94e","unit:bb0076de91c75000347da475dde66347547beff9291ae679c16b5b82ddc329fe","unit:bb6e38375672c2460f470d98ff71dc7fab8eb1ac1065293d909e84faf63c58d7","unit:c1bad2ece74ad8f47e53e931f6a5cfca1ac211dc1c368843e46be3d629665b2f","unit:c392c2786cf154d281bc04b2155bb1493eef379545d168bc8322bfb97b56c934","unit:c7ba1a37fc98ee63474d7ae2e0ce4f894585426dada668e990ef6e1f75c01fdb","unit:d4362492b6339b25a09c8fe17e66561967023cb288122938666ca4ff4d8fb342","unit:d8413d25e3c4b1bb2699f405d7a0f9de45b24b6b5003944fa1bc83b0f59e9538","unit:daf87ad1bc9dfc6cf3bac84c3ba668ee1e75508787f5b6e0d0bada7ecc2f2052","unit:deb140f8a9d9eebacd7cd647cd5eda20c50b3319aac96e371ee35bee877f32e1","unit:e3bab4a9180ade0203f4e0a68a6acdf8868aaa8e6eea84e3b8dd9810bee72e17","unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","unit:e6e5d5c6881f6a1312249f0dd0e6a27b39b6f4c813374b8d7966db881c4e1409","unit:eb1997d2fb75c5bf865bea781a0327dc3e8bca4a01cd4d523428103d4c7c6c83","unit:ebe88f5466f4479a35649d43d9643c65bdcc0e36cab1fd4c7450032da8680838","unit:f27f3ad38a3e91b0411be91b0a858ea14ae312c4dbd914b70018f4fd15e3cfcc","unit:f310cc62291d0ad9f437d30c8ec3785fc47aca44dde7189d98d5912091cc6017","unit:f5bcdc4630739e02c9d07476a826ec968a003aaf31d015e207f051b7b925d757","unit:f9459fa6a0698d7fb5eb5597ac1d3f3adcd0dacbbe7f34945a11fbe510d58ebc","unit:fb1cc9efcd8034ac80f79c9ea04dd515ecea5e6333bb0a019cec796868c71d74","unit:ff6e5c9f362ef2405a4c290978ce050944e9987a99ee38ce1ae9521bb42b2327"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"admitted_scope_definition","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:9454e2dc275dec5e822bba03","scopeContentSha256":"e147fd943566a01846df6e2e28486396bc2dc277cdac113953b8e44d5a8d8365","definitionSha256":"fe5625a7c4232916a4dde2b6bf0a8ec1c023810d7d846b140be0039aabaafa44"},{"kind":"admitted_scope_definition","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:0373a22d5bfba4144b34728b","scopeContentSha256":"a3a2579d115a1464f96eb7bb79e1cb85ffbd506856b1563c8355b3c516c8a5a0","definitionSha256":"61e5c1d2f0d960082115fff4bca5eb1cecae30752bc8d0de65be86b209d8b8c0"}],"decisionId":"decision:screen-conflict:n5103","provenance":{"screenNominationId":"n5103","variantRef":"attempt1:comparisonReviews:n5103","readingBasis":"coordinator_complete_definition_review","freshPrimaryReading":false,"pairedPerUnitNotesReadForThisDecision":false,"pairedLinkVerdict":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","originalSelectedScreen":{"ref":"n5103","identityScreen":"different_scoped_targets","scientificConnections":["conditional_application","comparison"],"basis":"scope_definition","priority":"definition_decision_candidate","definingDifferences":["c1201 asks about charge processes and lifetimes; c1480 asks about corrected equilibria and thermodynamic calculations.","Zero-temperature equilibrium shifts do not establish dynamical accessibility or emission."],"reason":"The definitions distinguish the targets. A corrected solution may supply input to a discharge calculation only with a specified matter sector, approximation and dynamical prescription.","refs":["c1201","c1480"]},"originalAlternateScreen":{"ref":"n5103","identityScreen":"different_scoped_targets","scientificConnections":["conditional_application"],"basis":"scope_definition","priority":"definition_decision_candidate","definingDifferences":["c1201 targets charge evolution and proposed spectrum conditions; c1480 targets corrected geometry and equilibrium thermodynamics.","Static corrected extremality and entropy do not determine a discharge timescale."],"reason":"The definitions permit a changed-target decision. Corrected equilibria can be inputs to charge-evolution models only with compatible charge normalization, approximation and emission physics.","refs":["c1201","c1480"]},"originalConflictAssessment":{"variantRef":"attempt1:comparisonReviews:n5103","judgment":"material_conflict","definingDifferences":["The alternate removes comparison from scientificConnections and retains only conditional_application.","The distinct process-versus-equilibrium identity judgment is unchanged."],"reason":"The alternate withdraws an explicit comparison judgment even though both readings preserve the same conditional equilibrium-to-discharge application. This is a material connection change and remains withheld; the selected comparison is not replaced.","refs":["c1201","c1480"]},"historicalScopeAssessments":[{"ref":"c1201","priorReadingAssessment":{"decision":"supported_with_limits","scopeChange":"same","replacement":"","note":"Retain the exact prior region. Numerical membership alone does not establish a common mechanism, premise or question. Its explicit neighboring scopes and alternate homes make the family usable; it is not a universal discharge principle."}},{"ref":"c1480","priorReadingAssessment":{"decision":"supported_as_written","scopeChange":"same","replacement":"","note":"The original scope already distinguishes a broad neighborhood from a single question and preserves alternate homes. The evidence supports that scope, but cannot validate the numerical partition, an exclusive boundary or shared physical premises."}}],"inputPins":{"packet":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0039-screen-completion/packet.actual.json","sha256":"094c92872d86c9181fd92a2ad186f1b3eaf58960f48e9aaae93ac6ff631a4f79"},"reply":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0039-screen-completion/reply.json","sha256":"d73e23dbb3a237b7a97cf3e6481ca4b0a60f17846e3376f4ce70e3690615abd2"},"normalization":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0039-screen-completion/normalization.json","sha256":"fadc3eac22d691cb8dc68691e28deefad7af1d5facb0cb343d190404d931cb3e"},"receipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0039-screen-completion/receipt.json","sha256":"7b47f5fb14eb213908430c24a4ed96e5790793c5a508c2ddd0c67d801ab38e54"}},"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","decisionId":"decision:screen-conflict:n5103","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:screen-conflict:n5953":{"id":"navigation:screen-conflict:n5953","source":"q025-candidate-region:1b676e04cbd94e2caf104916","target":"q025-candidate-region:9cc6623edc9d8c83bc264832","type":"comparison","title":"Black-hole spectra, classical response and extremality","rationale":"Compare thermodynamic entropy–extremality responses with spectra, damping and classical response.","qualification":"Thermodynamic variables, mode labels and time normalizations remain distinct. No family-wide relaxation prerequisite or universal entropy-to-mode relation is admitted.","evidenceIds":["unit:054a3aaa4e3655b7ef0555bfba63a5cd29ea65e6b526ee56432bc2fcf85fb217","unit:05cd4f24969a052c34c8179054503d486871b3aed4b1e1a358d1eb5d420df862","unit:0702b8a1df85cd2f038bbf2cb02964037dd5c07a76a319b8f3fc3068e4beb9dc","unit:09b1d263ea0af87c59b8c615e1c5b7fba1883f740987a48a0df536be7390498c","unit:0b54fd0f5f3814f2dfffd0c39c24992549b88467d27d245c5a1710aef6be0409","unit:0f3f7ba9a79195a39e0ff616b7a71ead79494c7eec1ade776956b1782aab311a","unit:13e2b7935927f018ba049a3bf0464f3e0cbaac9f97924169e07217318918aa2f","unit:1b8e3370fa7859f2ec7f276df2829f99d5e3d778d3e3f3396691a06ea2253548","unit:1c6d9de4bce931fdd7703796693240c867e543d658214a42846ae5b2f411ce61","unit:2b3919215dc1fca229981ae3e7b23c3934cb596808b4edc4a419fc5185b8abaf","unit:2cffb9faa09377ebdb32ba5c63683b146eb96e11aeb144b60b3ac3fc4bd423ae","unit:316b6aba761439e7ba6e17cf62f24d43ea17ff33e0023bf9773e840882d386ba","unit:33c0d814c0b006cb08912b3f8bebb7b3656b611be8ea7d2b001ea9098c40936d","unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","unit:3c6fe1a3fbb93d537c10542256e163cc61ec0d243746307a6a6053def1ad0966","unit:43527b6acc9949962f85a2cb17ce8564be00d0dc88fcfe207376f9f97b0abc53","unit:455807e282f0deb83d24bab745c7579007c06b300820d3b13a54d19b168a9543","unit:4937f4fa356cf3c51cbb209dfaa28b355c1a4416025532245377d7f61c6dbb60","unit:4bea2236adce2a83cf3c451f430db2b31ccbb60826ec94caf64e9a0ca2613854","unit:4f0d1fc376ea4ae4f6e4db123c48391a5a9dd5cb1e02ee44f763cb5d8973334c","unit:5783724fc808522c2af61b13b75cf4729a590d52ffb40088d43573abb197d4c6","unit:57a7a2acf4ccbf7274c833c50127cdbf73951f3ee6f2fcc4e268829fb231e490","unit:61c8e0b22962446471f9a1fd2596a8c42b4f9d2f8adbb0365a087b2487dc82ea","unit:6c9b99404221e9a3f9f6a31fd5345f7e6f40f9cdfe0fc8bc88457e067defde70","unit:746648263d181074a402dd7e7b541e73c68a2669b150300a24df9fe061f4db9d","unit:753eb80972aeb4eef8bed36c3cb2d5095c7adbe4b7dcf803204ab2b1475b8eba","unit:7bf4bd3a8935302c15057334958e89cdfed7cf4a5930f6a2ba758513eec88130","unit:8645df96e1d5a104c77d9fd0bdb5a08073bfedec34d3951354a6e84eedbcadb4","unit:86f7b3a864a3e0c9e09f00890cabd3db247b8fa0247fdec394f405ab7ad2a123","unit:88df84f42743eece8af1fa6e459123a00c600f2576ea257b282fa55b0c00f028","unit:9a8af3668541b2fe297df0e6b321c5a00f6bf829c6daac0c9c5116444be5642b","unit:b32f2bfc3e7e02031176bc3b4f7bd584734d74365f81b2b3656c004990e5bb02","unit:b5505445a85f89950ba6f38d799d36a1a46dac4f03dffa2e386a69b4c2895fb8","unit:b97e6a826ab6cdc44a171bf65cccd053ec7f897a2bdb522ae8e185dbc5b08693","unit:bafc4b56732941e2a932db04d2397cd6650889120d1309550cb23ff4059e06f8","unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","unit:d39ec96e47b495cb46c0adbd42b4804910fdc2511938c586a37113fbf9da13ef","unit:d3f5b55db4a44f1242a1e7d55aa8537cef7c92ac8fdf3ab106110092aee93643","unit:d7329c96948bb1c45bad844bb1e9569b94ff66c1afd943be70e980acc24a4f2d","unit:d8efc3c113d9682ae66c3f4f2a4291e4ae73e03ca649880fde809a5da49d2d12","unit:da3b42fb5f4247edfd1bd072b8701216486945905a8766c825f60e221ca0ce61","unit:df55ebc8a474485011f53ee5b3441b949228d4863fe885a7baea3ea4b38b809a","unit:e65f0f92d80d7795671289baaa75914a7f57286a542b6231f2c5245d5322f92e","unit:e8031fc404e3674cecf9260727208dd068349f5eaed7ca729a465c859af2255b","unit:f2107ba4391515831703f47d5d2f16773f60be9737f4c55764ce5ceeb6fd5603","unit:f95d9b3737fce20c95c6061f117c58dd0a1291c50c409ba305b980cd11933d97","unit:fad110e33ac2d5f343c53205a222cd4554d93b78d0d090e9aab6a174e51dfc34","unit:fbc21f1bbe6b9d93460c81b998bfdeec6d15061b26c6abe7a25b081bb1691970","unit:fc9c1cda908566f5795739de21dabe0301edc2180530d8e6e8ff42a8212b6836"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"admitted_scope_definition","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:1b676e04cbd94e2caf104916","scopeContentSha256":"01d0bfe6c2911b558a4743ba8c0d38de189dd724a13f75fd9607dc42078f87bd","definitionSha256":"2b7db5cf6f07f00716368ea4db887625888381c8d6c49864beadaa3aa91ae3f1"},{"kind":"admitted_scope_definition","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:9cc6623edc9d8c83bc264832","scopeContentSha256":"db10961658d1435226a720a302a772a7824b36d2e61e2be786e0c17da8ee575f","definitionSha256":"9da9fe5cbe8ba418aaefab2fcd2bc5f201e09e402968a7dae11337ec7c27fd7c"}],"decisionId":"decision:screen-conflict:n5953","provenance":{"screenNominationId":"n5953","variantRef":"attempt1:comparisonReviews:n5953","readingBasis":"coordinator_complete_definition_review","freshPrimaryReading":false,"pairedPerUnitNotesReadForThisDecision":false,"pairedLinkVerdict":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","originalSelectedScreen":{"ref":"n5953","identityScreen":"different_scoped_targets","scientificConnections":["conditional_application","comparison"],"basis":"scope_definition","priority":"definition_decision_candidate","definingDifferences":["c1282 centers thermodynamic entropy–extremality responses; c1345 centers modes, damping and classical dynamics.","Fixed thermodynamic variables and horizon-response endpoints differ from fixed-mode and time-normalization choices."],"reason":"The definitions distinguish these targets. Thermodynamic input could inform a specified spectral calculation, but no universal relaxation or entropy-to-mode relation is established here.","refs":["c1282","c1345"]},"originalAlternateScreen":{"ref":"n5953","identityScreen":"different_scoped_targets","scientificConnections":["conditional_application","comparison"],"basis":"scope_definition","priority":"definition_decision_candidate","definingDifferences":["c1282 centers entropy–extremality responses; c1345 centers perturbation spectra and classical motion.","Thermodynamic derivatives, damping times and orbital Lyapunov exponents use different observables and limits."],"reason":"The definitions support separate targets. Thermodynamic data could constrain a spectral comparison only with the exact relaxation proposal, time convention and mode limit supplied.","refs":["c1282","c1345"]},"originalConflictAssessment":{"variantRef":"attempt1:comparisonReviews:n5953","judgment":"material_conflict","definingDifferences":["The selected row permits thermodynamic input to a specified spectral calculation without requiring a relaxation proposal.","The alternate states that a spectral comparison is possible only with the exact relaxation proposal supplied, adding a prerequisite despite retaining the same connection labels."],"reason":"As written, the alternate narrows the application premise. c1345 includes spectra and classical response beyond conjectural relaxation tests, and c1282 supplies no family-wide relaxation premise. The extra requirement must remain explicit and withheld rather than silently restricting the selected conditional interface.","refs":["c1282","c1345"]},"historicalScopeAssessments":[{"ref":"c1282","priorReadingAssessment":{"decision":"supported_as_written","scopeChange":"same","replacement":"","note":"Retain the exact prior region. Its broad navigation scope accommodates ordinary thermodynamics and alternate targets without claiming equivalence. The nu"}},{"ref":"c1345","priorReadingAssessment":{"decision":"supported_as_written","scopeChange":"same","replacement":"","note":"The numerical cluster alone supplies no physical equivalence. The exact prior region is nevertheless supported as a broad navigational family with explicitly separate adjacent homes. Charge, near-extremality, dimension and conjectural bounds cannot be imposed family-wide."}}],"inputPins":{"packet":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0039-screen-completion/packet.actual.json","sha256":"094c92872d86c9181fd92a2ad186f1b3eaf58960f48e9aaae93ac6ff631a4f79"},"reply":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0039-screen-completion/reply.json","sha256":"d73e23dbb3a237b7a97cf3e6481ca4b0a60f17846e3376f4ce70e3690615abd2"},"normalization":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0039-screen-completion/normalization.json","sha256":"fadc3eac22d691cb8dc68691e28deefad7af1d5facb0cb343d190404d931cb3e"},"receipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0039-screen-completion/receipt.json","sha256":"7b47f5fb14eb213908430c24a4ed96e5790793c5a508c2ddd0c67d801ab38e54"}},"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","decisionId":"decision:screen-conflict:n5953","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:screen-conflict:n467":{"id":"navigation:screen-conflict:n467","source":"q025-candidate-question:cb9d8ed82c9b8b3f697be05f","target":"q025-candidate-question:c2d09be6e44cc5f905ad1da7","type":"comparison","title":"Apparent phantom behavior","rationale":"Compare microscopic rolling construction and control with apparent-phantom inference.","qualification":"Microscopic scalar dynamics and inferred dark-energy behavior have different targets. A compound source may address both; scalar w and inferred w must remain distinct. No shared-method theorem follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:04bbd27e171530f1ca15b8becbfbeffffb614e8898f98cab5e356e060126335f","unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","unit:30e469dad86f2093687b4ce209e575cf9975924d40b859ab9ce3377e8915c306","unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","unit:4998e7350d955aa68185a0db9d187f6dd0cf69f937ce83a92490a71f3980b597","unit:4c0de05c6db76aa4a3fc01a44dbca59527f6c8724ba8f138060e7f9516ebb781","unit:4ea455d25f925a2ba8a956f05b4f002e50bf678ed2b309e51bd58ab2cfecd11e","unit:597932033244fa69c82f19bfb04cd5e6042ef92b2cef58d932dcac367494dceb","unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f","unit:6be0ecc7820d5e13c5e215d806fb3daa52adb13f979b5d088ad899c85097eb82","unit:871ddd3cecae3861f7949fd676086290a5175f4698a407ee72e3c35d0264d575","unit:8b8691d111d78239dfebb4f1295fdb40c5a4c6bcd312819477396cedc278eb47","unit:a2d315adcc6a6218212c056887892e7ff120e5d9cb11e66de3c9b693b65af474","unit:a7fbef7e8a557f6a9cdb88206bb7f578e8db0da283b8b3319707d6caab402123","unit:a86c20191a1dc1779510b965f7169dd574e12b81ebc6b47306051b1d11dbd0f9","unit:b1cf19af5cf136fbb49041ad43db6f95143cad70f3ae72000c29746dd813c79a","unit:bff5f38896802d1c22a015771b36398fd9925228457e3cf6424900f472bc9bc9","unit:ce3f118987da1eca9c5b5c26d112ed8f5c0f184cec476453d0e026bd7be505c8","unit:d6bf0b556994a0d99310a91945144814a89448a5e45f7c830627a63fd1d807c1","unit:df03aadc4b99d143164b10bdcc0851d80e5716b2ed1a9c7b093777528c222206"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"admitted_scope_definition","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cb9d8ed82c9b8b3f697be05f","scopeContentSha256":"0b12990174fac44b92532be67665101d789a75310dcfa732ef46c9285eb95205","definitionSha256":"56347c4c71d0de13411e8a85527f7cf12d3f0c10ce4e25c30d473a340a247b3e"},{"kind":"admitted_scope_definition","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c2d09be6e44cc5f905ad1da7","scopeContentSha256":"c879bdebfa26c7e040d4e54f07a442b33b7dcd585faca7f9c96b73ebe6e0927d","definitionSha256":"a807e905414e3c1fb08fc6556e61f89364fa2573b5b33d051a9ef1ceae694038"}],"decisionId":"decision:screen-conflict:n467","provenance":{"screenNominationId":"n467","variantRef":"attempt0:comparisonReviews:n467","readingBasis":"coordinator_complete_definition_review","freshPrimaryReading":false,"pairedPerUnitNotesReadForThisDecision":false,"pairedLinkVerdict":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","originalSelectedScreen":{"ref":"n467","identityScreen":"different_scoped_targets","scientificConnections":["conditional_application","shared_method"],"basis":"description_checked","priority":"rich_relation_review","definingDifferences":["Microscopic support for slow evolution versus apparent-phantom inference.","Mechanism control versus the definition of effective dark energy."],"reason":"The u3114 description joins steep-potential accommodation to effective phantom behavior and poles. That compound source can contribute to both questions. Recover the paired reasons identifying each facet; a background mechanism does not establish microscopic control, and scalar w must remain distinct from inferred w.","refs":["c57","c306","u3114"]},"originalAlternateScreen":{"ref":"n467","identityScreen":"different_scoped_targets","scientificConnections":["conditional_application","comparison"],"basis":"description_checked","priority":"rich_relation_review","definingDifferences":["Microscopic support for slow evolution versus apparent-phantom inference","Construction control versus definitions of scalar and effective w"],"reason":"The coupled-quintessence description contains both steep-potential accommodation and effective-w behavior. That makes a conditional application plausible, not the scopes identical. Retrieve its paired contribution reasons to distinguish the construction-facing facet from the inference mechanism; the description establishes neither microscopic control nor observational validation.","refs":["c57","c306","u3114"]},"originalConflictAssessment":{"variantRef":"attempt0:comparisonReviews:n467","judgment":"material_conflict","definingDifferences":["The selected connection set contains conditional_application and shared_method; the alternate retains conditional_application but replaces shared_method with comparison."],"reason":"Identity and the conditional construction-to-inference application agree, but the alternate changes the recorded scientific connection judgment. A comparison and a shared method are not interchangeable assertions, even if both could ultimately be supported. Preserve the selected record and withhold this alternative for adjudication.","refs":["c57","c306","u3114"]},"historicalScopeAssessments":[{"ref":"c306","priorReadingAssessment":{"decision":"supported_as_written","scopeChange":"same","replacement":"","note":"The supplied sources support distinct effective-phantom mechanisms and inference conventions. The card properly separates scalar kinetics, inferred dark energy, constant-w distance fitting and effective poles, while withholding universal interaction or stability conclusions."}},{"ref":"c57","priorReadingAssessment":{"decision":"supported_as_written","scopeChange":"same","replacement":"","note":"The question accommodates different mechanisms without equating small slopes with gauge slowing. Descriptions and the conditional axion excerpt support candidate construction questions, not certified ultraviolet realizations; dynamical uplifting remains adjacent context."}}],"inputPins":{"packet":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0047-screen-completion/packet.actual.json","sha256":"8cc72216a23e5d930cca2571ac47ca7229de2c41705abb47a7608d60406518b2"},"reply":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0047-screen-completion/reply.json","sha256":"16ccd592b47cb25778942f71a9a33c0c98267d608e2411c6afd2e86ab5172298"},"normalization":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0047-screen-completion/normalization.json","sha256":"3eff8bb4dcd8a4d1771a90d4c455459ecaafdebb8ccb61b0cd45454e7a79f9a8"},"receipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0047-screen-completion/receipt.json","sha256":"cfaf353eb508da4598c6faaa56310fb1ebca37440af1afbcb1d590f357995eb9"}},"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","decisionId":"decision:screen-conflict:n467","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:screen-conflict:n475":{"id":"navigation:screen-conflict:n475","source":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a","target":"q025-candidate-question:c2d09be6e44cc5f905ad1da7","type":"narrower","title":"Apparent phantom behavior","rationale":"Apparent-phantom histories and poles form a scoped inference question within broader background evolution and observational inference.","qualification":"Retain the noninteracting-CDM inference convention, the distinction between scalar and inferred equations of state, coupling-induced effective w versus constant-w fitting, and source-date conditions. This is organizational narrowing, not a shared-method theorem.","evidenceIds":["unit:1db3427f5e01897af82ffb70341402a5903a4ba2804954ea09a6398a0f6f8816","unit:32c76a3dc827cd85202ac3b6c42f7b7d8f6d6c2ab3ad9142f2ee9eb607b4d4b4","unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","unit:4998e7350d955aa68185a0db9d187f6dd0cf69f937ce83a92490a71f3980b597","unit:4c0de05c6db76aa4a3fc01a44dbca59527f6c8724ba8f138060e7f9516ebb781","unit:4ea455d25f925a2ba8a956f05b4f002e50bf678ed2b309e51bd58ab2cfecd11e","unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f","unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","unit:6a562fcb3f25b9ea7c981d6374a41848f4179fe3dba2f1a86ec0d452a09b0364","unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","unit:871ddd3cecae3861f7949fd676086290a5175f4698a407ee72e3c35d0264d575","unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","unit:8b8691d111d78239dfebb4f1295fdb40c5a4c6bcd312819477396cedc278eb47","unit:a2d315adcc6a6218212c056887892e7ff120e5d9cb11e66de3c9b693b65af474","unit:a7fbef7e8a557f6a9cdb88206bb7f578e8db0da283b8b3319707d6caab402123","unit:acc5e23bc2409d650a891c6737176fe601245c73bee1218e1c7fd918a01c4b20","unit:b0a10a242143873e59ba2d7f08fd905bc49dfacec461eeee485fdb7cf2d748e3","unit:b25a1afc039080d5e2a7b3fbb390ce16604e2cf7b726f019e5aac919ee19377b","unit:bf99c7e3ba1c57e54212667656b9210bfefca360519cd5b1e9c2f1442d0f2f8f","unit:bff5f38896802d1c22a015771b36398fd9925228457e3cf6424900f472bc9bc9","unit:ccc46b79310e36a2cb8ad72afac190e35647e06a48443af8db1593a1f224931d","unit:cf5d992980e77e2c29936f1c1086725207f3d11567c24bcaec83400cc91664bc","unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"admitted_scope_definition","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a","scopeContentSha256":"cf4b878f8c8a9e621142d4757c68c105582cb223b4ed08afbca88ce0cbdf5a8a","definitionSha256":"140ca8e4154ee522cfeb3e8835eb31bfbf4af5579f596bbd087ccb92d6112ef9"},{"kind":"admitted_scope_definition","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c2d09be6e44cc5f905ad1da7","scopeContentSha256":"c879bdebfa26c7e040d4e54f07a442b33b7dcd585faca7f9c96b73ebe6e0927d","definitionSha256":"a807e905414e3c1fb08fc6556e61f89364fa2573b5b33d051a9ef1ceae694038"}],"decisionId":"decision:screen-conflict:n475","provenance":{"screenNominationId":"n475","variantRef":"attempt0:comparisonReviews:n475","readingBasis":"coordinator_complete_definition_review","freshPrimaryReading":false,"pairedPerUnitNotesReadForThisDecision":false,"pairedLinkVerdict":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","originalSelectedScreen":{"ref":"n475","identityScreen":"specialization_candidate","scientificConnections":["shared_method","broader_question"],"basis":"description_checked","priority":"rich_scope_review","definingDifferences":["General background evolution and inference versus apparent-phantom histories and poles.","A broad history question versus specific inference conventions."],"reason":"Descriptions place apparent-phantom mechanisms within a narrower part of background/inference work. Check paired reasons for that specialization while retaining the distinction between coupling-induced effective w and constant-w fitting of climbing quintessence. Shared histories do not make their inferred quantities interchangeable.","refs":["c58","c306","u3114","u3617","u1669"]},"originalAlternateScreen":{"ref":"n475","identityScreen":"specialization_candidate","scientificConnections":["shared_method","conditional_application"],"basis":"description_checked","priority":"rich_scope_review","definingDifferences":["General background histories and inference versus apparent-phantom mechanisms","Canonical scalar evolution versus interaction-dependent or distance-fitted effective quantities"],"reason":"Descriptions make apparent-phantom behavior a candidate narrower question within background inference. Its contributing mechanisms remain different: coupled effective w and constant-w distance fitting cannot inherit one crossing convention. Use the existing contribution reasons to decide the specialization without treating all background models as phantom mechanisms.","refs":["c58","c306","u3114","u3617","u1669"]},"originalConflictAssessment":{"variantRef":"attempt0:comparisonReviews:n475","judgment":"material_conflict","definingDifferences":["The selected connection set contains shared_method and broader_question; the alternate replaces broader_question with conditional_application while retaining the specialization candidate."],"reason":"The identity assessment and equation-of-state qualifications remain compatible, but the alternate substitutes a conditional application for the selected broader organizing relation. Those connections can coexist but are not the same recorded judgment. The change remains withheld for downstream adjudication.","refs":["c58","c306","u3114","u3617","u1669"]},"historicalScopeAssessments":[{"ref":"c306","priorReadingAssessment":{"decision":"supported_as_written","scopeChange":"same","replacement":"","note":"The supplied sources support distinct effective-phantom mechanisms and inference conventions. The card properly separates scalar kinetics, inferred dark energy, constant-w distance fitting and effective poles, while withholding universal interaction or stability conclusions."}},{"ref":"c58","priorReadingAssessment":{"decision":"supported_as_written","scopeChange":"same","replacement":"","note":"Boundary dependence and field-origin degeneracy are directly supported. The scope correctly separates coupled effective phantom behavior from the scalar equation of state and preserves negative or inconclusive observational results."}}],"inputPins":{"packet":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0047-screen-completion/packet.actual.json","sha256":"8cc72216a23e5d930cca2571ac47ca7229de2c41705abb47a7608d60406518b2"},"reply":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0047-screen-completion/reply.json","sha256":"16ccd592b47cb25778942f71a9a33c0c98267d608e2411c6afd2e86ab5172298"},"normalization":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0047-screen-completion/normalization.json","sha256":"3eff8bb4dcd8a4d1771a90d4c455459ecaafdebb8ccb61b0cd45454e7a79f9a8"},"receipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0047-screen-completion/receipt.json","sha256":"cfaf353eb508da4598c6faaa56310fb1ebca37440af1afbcb1d590f357995eb9"}},"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","decisionId":"decision:screen-conflict:n475","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:screen-conflict:n478":{"id":"navigation:screen-conflict:n478","source":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a","target":"q025-candidate-question:f23ce27773b0d5af5ed5ce55","type":"comparison","title":"Reconstruction and CPL interpretation","rationale":"Compare general background inference with reconstruction, identifiability and CPL representation.","qualification":"The shared canonical setting permits comparison and overlap. Proposed beyond-canonical extensions need independent premises, so whole-scope containment is not admitted. CPL expansion matching is not an interaction-induced equation of state.","evidenceIds":["unit:1db3427f5e01897af82ffb70341402a5903a4ba2804954ea09a6398a0f6f8816","unit:202e6ec43555beedfcf41aed9d6ab187a5f0e2abf05a15181619cdad76ed6b65","unit:32c76a3dc827cd85202ac3b6c42f7b7d8f6d6c2ab3ad9142f2ee9eb607b4d4b4","unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","unit:4bbb9e9371dcd0288290b1ef4ee0a0fb559f101cf0ec4e5af23ae6642733f7e1","unit:4ea455d25f925a2ba8a956f05b4f002e50bf678ed2b309e51bd58ab2cfecd11e","unit:5d3abb4e9d1936973db6cc4f2926528e9a9b400670cda263c0da5f924991823a","unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f","unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","unit:6a562fcb3f25b9ea7c981d6374a41848f4179fe3dba2f1a86ec0d452a09b0364","unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","unit:8b8691d111d78239dfebb4f1295fdb40c5a4c6bcd312819477396cedc278eb47","unit:9a46687f77a7d1b805cec6d0a210216920b0a3df4fe3099b9de9d95a1ac5f882","unit:a2d315adcc6a6218212c056887892e7ff120e5d9cb11e66de3c9b693b65af474","unit:acc5e23bc2409d650a891c6737176fe601245c73bee1218e1c7fd918a01c4b20","unit:b0a10a242143873e59ba2d7f08fd905bc49dfacec461eeee485fdb7cf2d748e3","unit:b25a1afc039080d5e2a7b3fbb390ce16604e2cf7b726f019e5aac919ee19377b","unit:bf99c7e3ba1c57e54212667656b9210bfefca360519cd5b1e9c2f1442d0f2f8f","unit:bff5f38896802d1c22a015771b36398fd9925228457e3cf6424900f472bc9bc9","unit:ccc46b79310e36a2cb8ad72afac190e35647e06a48443af8db1593a1f224931d","unit:cf5d992980e77e2c29936f1c1086725207f3d11567c24bcaec83400cc91664bc","unit:d3fbb7bee46ed75d94c928d6133a137b3b98323ef89bf06ff6f720e8fede32ec","unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234","unit:ec7b75f28f2cecdefc1b075782c1b877b39e51a02b063d8be45c5ba384f38ca1"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"admitted_scope_definition","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a","scopeContentSha256":"cf4b878f8c8a9e621142d4757c68c105582cb223b4ed08afbca88ce0cbdf5a8a","definitionSha256":"140ca8e4154ee522cfeb3e8835eb31bfbf4af5579f596bbd087ccb92d6112ef9"},{"kind":"admitted_scope_definition","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f23ce27773b0d5af5ed5ce55","scopeContentSha256":"eac2f79694fc95787a5cf9d64d551fefd5a831efeb40e79d7bc52245dd4da3d3","definitionSha256":"41eae8a7437167a8b56eecfa52d3c5ae9874e09e93406b63f953e1c778ec7936"}],"decisionId":"decision:screen-conflict:n478","provenance":{"screenNominationId":"n478","variantRef":"attempt0:comparisonReviews:n478","readingBasis":"coordinator_complete_definition_review","freshPrimaryReading":false,"pairedPerUnitNotesReadForThisDecision":false,"pairedLinkVerdict":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","originalSelectedScreen":{"ref":"n478","identityScreen":"specialization_candidate","scientificConnections":["shared_method","broader_question"],"basis":"description_checked","priority":"rich_scope_review","definingDifferences":["Broad evolution/inference versus identifiability and CPL representation.","General coupled histories versus canonical mapping and proposed theory-specific extensions."],"reason":"The descriptions support a narrower reconstruction/CPL question within much of c58's inference coverage. Check paired reasons for the shared canonical setting and the proposed extensions. CPL expansion matching is not an interaction-induced equation of state, and extensions cannot inherit canonical restrictions without their own premises.","refs":["c58","c351","u4975","u2103","u742","u4735"]},"originalAlternateScreen":{"ref":"n478","identityScreen":"specialization_candidate","scientificConnections":["shared_method","conditional_application"],"basis":"description_checked","priority":"rich_scope_review","definingDifferences":["General cosmic evolution and inference versus identifiability and CPL representation","Broad interacting backgrounds versus explicitly bounded canonical reconstruction"],"reason":"The reconstruction and CPL descriptions support a narrower inference question within the broader background overview. Proposed beyond-canonical reconstruction and electromagnetic couplings need their own premises. Retrieve the shared reconstruction reasons and repair c351's incomplete-looking assessment before an exact reuse decision.","refs":["c58","c351","u4975","u2103","u742","u4735"]},"originalConflictAssessment":{"variantRef":"attempt0:comparisonReviews:n478","judgment":"material_conflict","definingDifferences":["The selected connection set contains shared_method and broader_question; the alternate substitutes conditional_application for broader_question while retaining the specialization candidate."],"reason":"Both preserve the narrower reconstruction/CPL target and source-specific extension premises. Nevertheless, the changed connection set replaces an organizing-question judgment with an application judgment. The additional assessment-repair caution does not reconcile that difference; retain the selected record and withhold the alternative.","refs":["c58","c351","u4975","u2103","u742","u4735"]},"historicalScopeAssessments":[{"ref":"c351","priorReadingAssessment":{"decision":"supported_as_written","scopeChange":"same","replacement":"","note":"The excerpts support boundary-data dependence, field-origin nonuniqueness and expansion-based CPL mapping. They also justify separating fitted phantom"}},{"ref":"c58","priorReadingAssessment":{"decision":"supported_as_written","scopeChange":"same","replacement":"","note":"Boundary dependence and field-origin degeneracy are directly supported. The scope correctly separates coupled effective phantom behavior from the scalar equation of state and preserves negative or inconclusive observational results."}}],"inputPins":{"packet":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0047-screen-completion/packet.actual.json","sha256":"8cc72216a23e5d930cca2571ac47ca7229de2c41705abb47a7608d60406518b2"},"reply":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0047-screen-completion/reply.json","sha256":"16ccd592b47cb25778942f71a9a33c0c98267d608e2411c6afd2e86ab5172298"},"normalization":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0047-screen-completion/normalization.json","sha256":"3eff8bb4dcd8a4d1771a90d4c455459ecaafdebb8ccb61b0cd45454e7a79f9a8"},"receipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/screen-recovery-v1/jobs/canonical-continuation-v4-0047-screen-completion/receipt.json","sha256":"cfaf353eb508da4598c6faaa56310fb1ebca37440af1afbcb1d590f357995eb9"}},"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","decisionId":"decision:screen-conflict:n478","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l0":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l0","source":"q025-candidate-question:d7eff9c143cead9be06735d4","target":"q025-candidate-question:3193b8d7483071b6c5ef1193","type":"method_for","title":"Check gravitational dispersion relations with loop and running calculations","rationale":"Loop calculations and renormalization supply checks on dispersive control and interpretation, so the methodological arrow runs from s33 to s8.","qualification":"Apply within the overlapping gravitational scattering setups and their controlled loop and EFT expansions. Running coefficients remain distinct from complete dispersive observables. Retain regulators, conditional species and nonminimal-coupling assumptions, and the epsilon-regulated or qualitative finite-log interpretation of the negative-running argument. Finite Regge contributions, ultraviolet growth assumptions and external-state or boundary prescriptions remain necessary; infrared-finite subtraction alone does not control the ultraviolet integral.","evidenceIds":["unit:0b21eedd06fc865eb5789abc903521004a545547e3a32602954c719ac7de7088","unit:20d8a793b545cc5ba0ed741ce878ed9ea729b1bd3521f438ee5b9dae460ae2bc","unit:2ce00c7adf4b8b57ef5ca8cc514599b0b3c57528310c8432b5cf5a020f08e5af","unit:32780bacee92ce6d5c0f031f9c9fa2ed085bd9330061e6d1ef8c2cb3be3530b9","unit:40a437e37249a3cf8244d0ca006155f9b7ac69bc7103c3481cf3a4bda59602a3","unit:559253ec56bd79eefe9544918efedb2f9acd0e4807f3627a309bdaf9c224a8ea","unit:5d5cfee1673d90f89020f3958f1bf80871e3f7eed57cf4de9a63b4fe5e915b8f","unit:768031644c4776c04002ce3ed0efeda5eedcdff55dd4ef252249d74a4c71adde","unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","unit:8ffa2fc0f14d636bad63bd4d6fc11e7ada05de6429b09761426725c5310abefc","unit:c24e8dd2015d4b7a21c87252883843bd70c2562b34f7c05f6c8b55c957b1760d","unit:c6b424d0c89d21d3380c06e232b930b246b79fdc8d82ba33abd2d0e78dc4b1a9","unit:c6c8cf1df058c9f1ae94ef54cbb9b443c3cff7f695dbe66f9b40340180a8c9f5","unit:f84a3eed9de9e4d742118e493274a3e2cd794ea58739e4a21c1fa9661725b184","unit:f88c31b8c79f69691ccb2bb747394a4fc0344246900dbed31791139f3d7adcbe","unit:fdf3b3c97c1d76e00daefbc5119bc71c2c9f514b012deb23b5363eb4f09aebc9"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d7eff9c143cead9be06735d4","scopeContentSha256":"e1f0df6f67e1d89e0b02f2b96082921eece302e1a6bed03352d1d607f24cf55b","localRef":"s33"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3193b8d7483071b6c5ef1193","scopeContentSha256":"89c02b0cc34ff35889c116f2e853ff77cad1aa8d9e7608f5c10a872875b2fb36","localRef":"s8"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l0","originalCandidateId":"parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge:link:16","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l0","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge:link:16","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:3193b8d7483071b6c5ef1193","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:d7eff9c143cead9be06735d4","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l0","source":"s8","target":"s33","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Loop calculations and renormalization test dispersive control and interpretation, with their own regulators and perturbative qualifications."],"challengeStatement":"Loops and renormalization inform dispersive interpretation under their own regulator and perturbative conditions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"283163d18ba710f459e0484e6542df91ca7736b322fdb2cc449617c5c04f597e","reply.jsonSha256":"398e8ffdfea28788c7df83fccb39c6b6b8765da14fa612698b725c281d72189d","reply.raw.txtSha256":"eafa7fae8eeef29098f63fbfb97587e70350b984274fc3b7632ef7094011764b","receipt.jsonSha256":"9ed9bbaa6747d6410c4706f71658336335859ea5d22baa19d8377e8df2ec1337","normalization.jsonSha256":"a42e51e8cdc567cfb764406a9be9d7c989697c2a60b114892b73238763e1a225","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"27a0b7f7853c909116f5ac24b26580040136c9b602012ffb78031fb8b94d8306"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"f5d2dd4194f583becec9b806a0f45bdc0428f3683e5559e7ae0e3d6128f3584d","reply.jsonSha256":"9237166341a88d80a3eb1baa20cdae1d2e4ea87c5d26fd2566974d3a929303ad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ec453393a3eaa3991788df984fedbe3796f68c98efe57d521d07eeeb11a815a4","receipt.jsonSha256":"ced6b81cf3d15466ec17b68129125a0d27760db45a15907132e3e030e1966851","normalization.jsonSha256":"64201833b74276dce09a5f789a77b82978d432b2a066f29a568edd100c870ef0"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3193b8d7483071b6c5ef1193"},{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d7eff9c143cead9be06735d4"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2111.09226","sourceId":"ev:6af5d5326d5e76694627c95253a8daad","sourceSha256":"3c7e47fff6d0980e7c02dbd2788d3c603aea13be8f89ef279dd96c89af1e9f35","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/24c4c3a9e839502abfb9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"24405d87b92c6ed328cdecf12f22dfaa8bf7d04fe8e42d179a335cde991822b4","pdfPage":3,"start":1306,"end":4261,"textSha256":"f999b3f2d5989b8fb1920bfc39ef89198463e916f99439c8b6b325ac1fae62f1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"2111.09226","sourceId":"ev:74ab7563140b6daad9817968e9ed078a","sourceSha256":"3c7e47fff6d0980e7c02dbd2788d3c603aea13be8f89ef279dd96c89af1e9f35","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/24c4c3a9e839502abfb9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"24405d87b92c6ed328cdecf12f22dfaa8bf7d04fe8e42d179a335cde991822b4","pdfPage":4,"start":104,"end":3501,"textSha256":"fe0b19cf08395ed30505de14e90e7531b420e484f5549d44a4bcc8db8887a9bc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3193b8d7483071b6c5ef1193"},{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d7eff9c143cead9be06735d4"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2111.09226","sourceId":"ev:6af5d5326d5e76694627c95253a8daad","sourceSha256":"3c7e47fff6d0980e7c02dbd2788d3c603aea13be8f89ef279dd96c89af1e9f35","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/24c4c3a9e839502abfb9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"24405d87b92c6ed328cdecf12f22dfaa8bf7d04fe8e42d179a335cde991822b4","pdfPage":3,"start":1306,"end":4261,"textSha256":"f999b3f2d5989b8fb1920bfc39ef89198463e916f99439c8b6b325ac1fae62f1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"2111.09226","sourceId":"ev:74ab7563140b6daad9817968e9ed078a","sourceSha256":"3c7e47fff6d0980e7c02dbd2788d3c603aea13be8f89ef279dd96c89af1e9f35","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/24c4c3a9e839502abfb9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"24405d87b92c6ed328cdecf12f22dfaa8bf7d04fe8e42d179a335cde991822b4","pdfPage":4,"start":104,"end":3501,"textSha256":"fe0b19cf08395ed30505de14e90e7531b420e484f5549d44a4bcc8db8887a9bc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d0","originalRef":"l0","status":"route","source":"s33","target":"s8","type":"method_for","title":"Check gravitational dispersion relations with loop and running calculations","rationale":"Loop calculations and renormalization supply checks on dispersive control and interpretation, so the methodological arrow runs from s33 to s8.","qualification":"Apply within the overlapping gravitational scattering setups and their controlled loop and EFT expansions. Running coefficients remain distinct from complete dispersive observables. Retain regulators, conditional species and nonminimal-coupling assumptions, and the epsilon-regulated or qualitative finite-log interpretation of the negative-running argument. Finite Regge contributions, ultraviolet growth assumptions and external-state or boundary prescriptions remain necessary; infrared-finite subtraction alone does not control the ultraviolet integral.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l0","s8","s33"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Loop and running calculations supply methodological checks on gravitational dispersive inference, supporting s33 to s8. The record preserves regulator and perturbative restrictions, distinguishes running coefficients from complete observables, and does not mistake infrared subtraction for ultraviolet control.","refs":["l0","s8","s33"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-00-proposal","parent-orientation-00-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements for each relation. No tools, primary texts, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed or newly read.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts and reported source findings do not constitute fresh proof, calculation, numerical or observational verification.","Methods and applications are restricted to the supported components and stated conditions of their endpoints. They do not imply full-scope containment, common premises or transfer across dimensions, spectra, backgrounds, regulators or boundary conditions.","All source-version limits, historical status, description-only support and explicit exclusions remain operative. The workload grouping supplies no connection between disconnected cases.","This orientation review does not admit pending scopes, resolve canonical identities, create source homes or verify the complete atlas. Independent challenge, receipt checks and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements for every relation, and all 39 proposal records. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly supplied or read. Inherited reading counts, source claims and review descriptions are not fresh verification of calculations, proofs or observations.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Conditional methods and applications do not establish full-scope containment or applicability beyond their stated components and assumptions.","Source-specific versions, dimensions, backgrounds, spectra, regulators, boundary conditions and historical limitations remain operative. The packet grouping establishes no additional scientific relationship.","Agreement concerns these navigation records only. Pending scope identities, source questions and scientific uncertainties remain unresolved; endpoint, receipt, admission and global canonical/DAG checks are separate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l1":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l1","source":"q025-candidate-question:18c08f83d8e385bf27be7e48","target":"q025-candidate-question:3193b8d7483071b6c5ef1193","type":"application_of","title":"Trace charged-spectrum and cutoff inferences to gravitational dispersion","rationale":"The dispersive branches of the charged-spectrum, weak-gravity and matter-cutoff questions apply gravitational scattering inference. Their geometric and phenomenological comparison branches retain a different role.","qualification":"This application concerns only analyses using the stated gravitational dispersive construction. Positivity, infrared treatment, high-energy behavior, sector choices, dimensions and perturbative limits require their source-specific justification. WGC criteria may be tested implications, comparison criteria or assumed inputs; particle and black-hole criteria remain distinct. Preserve charge and mass normalizations, uncertainty in high-energy QCD extrapolation, and the distinction between the QCD-free electroweak and full Standard Model cutoff claims. Neither a universal WGC derivation nor a current cutoff is established.","evidenceIds":["unit:20d8a793b545cc5ba0ed741ce878ed9ea729b1bd3521f438ee5b9dae460ae2bc","unit:2ce00c7adf4b8b57ef5ca8cc514599b0b3c57528310c8432b5cf5a020f08e5af","unit:32780bacee92ce6d5c0f031f9c9fa2ed085bd9330061e6d1ef8c2cb3be3530b9","unit:350cd95c74620fbfab0dbb5c79cc78322487379753fefb4837a4c1e22096025d","unit:40a437e37249a3cf8244d0ca006155f9b7ac69bc7103c3481cf3a4bda59602a3","unit:459a4d4ffdefb89d83c4caf9c84f38ad68d1b687ee40da3043fef0c2b49b25ce","unit:556158a73312227ff6429aa39ae91f36e1dc45682c46957f285da3a2e6766840","unit:64979e95f4e79c9b2aac55c5065066c781a4e9540e14d41d113f4f57236febd7","unit:6cc5509b76c342121edf97987fa6948c2b03a96c2c2fec8995bbcd518a6fc4ca","unit:768031644c4776c04002ce3ed0efeda5eedcdff55dd4ef252249d74a4c71adde","unit:7af54f9c618807e9f65d1e09023ce3623054055ba525c517692bd3a1feff1f7e","unit:7c8d0eaa7927b57e277d70f3c65874a83a25c2591f917f157bc2f6f8d6fa0ff5","unit:867ad99f206cc65d5282b81a2bbde1e489e5d0cdd60ad7e90fd49b770e7b1005","unit:9b3d3dcf687b4ef01aa21d5507c90a282aca641eb26109065f3c837abed2eb66","unit:9e8132e79ed6ccf5a23f8ff3f6ef41ac328c67560b3370f8ba177b46124dbc12","unit:9fd2fd67a4e9f6aca445397f8f0008d7271135993ff6da6d2d911dbcfa8058c5","unit:a46c09d199681e52d44a63ec0ad704437af90313cab5b44a6fba72bce76f1025","unit:a7290827ee003593836b9c30477252c66529a9ca0f71a31678a3d85ee5a8b1d7","unit:aa833892e4ace978097da5c3c8d37eb8beaf99b6c20bc02a777e50395260f618","unit:af03dccff2afc9b568b2e0556e5510a2a5e3a16cf018ca801175a8f404dcfc72","unit:afbc39ab67289457564951c4dfb5f02691ec225766bec15d79b4ef24b82d9b74","unit:b1695f15fa8ad2420983abc244585b93bc8f2efc925640599c011d187027d9d8","unit:c13021f0e2d551d2da50c708277f8f15662b5c393b873a8af55022d1bf5ded3f","unit:c13ea98a42bbae5fc713f40e19ec45ab9e13f96946e4f6cf4db2072c0248c6d9","unit:c6b424d0c89d21d3380c06e232b930b246b79fdc8d82ba33abd2d0e78dc4b1a9","unit:c6c8cf1df058c9f1ae94ef54cbb9b443c3cff7f695dbe66f9b40340180a8c9f5","unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8","unit:d28ec7ed1c8b537101fbf472bb7d2c3a637512561c212ef76a51efbb7eacb5d8","unit:f88c31b8c79f69691ccb2bb747394a4fc0344246900dbed31791139f3d7adcbe","unit:fdf3b3c97c1d76e00daefbc5119bc71c2c9f514b012deb23b5363eb4f09aebc9"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:18c08f83d8e385bf27be7e48","scopeContentSha256":"5cdcffc72bc885e7d4f9e097879b86ac26872a50e12d92f312b2dce86515fa53","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3193b8d7483071b6c5ef1193","scopeContentSha256":"89c02b0cc34ff35889c116f2e853ff77cad1aa8d9e7608f5c10a872875b2fb36","localRef":"s8"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l1","originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-challenge:link:29","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l1","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-challenge:link:29","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:3193b8d7483071b6c5ef1193","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:18c08f83d8e385bf27be7e48","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l1","source":"s8","target":"s5","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Charged spectra, weak-gravity criteria and conditional matter-sector cutoffs are applications or comparisons whose extra premises remain explicit."],"challengeStatement":"Charged-spectrum, weak-gravity and matter-cutoff questions require their own additional premises and sector choices.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"65efef2c5bb5566a5be05169b1a4c3c66be34ea203f58131bcec79993c5d5ae4","reply.jsonSha256":"fb97e5a7496915d72f486f56c5d5069448604219496582d04b406c25be90d0fb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"5ceb31a6a1cfbd31f749bc101ba09f78c51a17135ecd85a6ae3cff45290170a4","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa25c116c35e4a1be6112ff1f5127732df32700a2137ca0a6efef5151851a1ba","normalization.jsonSha256":"b6833520d559221fc1c5fbe58df58c096b3ef572566c342fe0596a3ffe6f74fe","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"782392732b0bdcfe56a8ba0a77a39fa568ad20e243db3bf908e85e5434364435"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1e95e3d1be787a43213f6055a62dc510ab1da705a28bdd5df5343a7e486344f7","reply.jsonSha256":"e65acc810c8ac0d38ab2949a4d45ee8e0da13b4b1da3488460ba3d6ca18bf33e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"6b94b5f7354a32c36b851bc7d27b8c1d0bab93ca3e7a930c8dd0a490407e9649","receipt.jsonSha256":"c485527a69ede7c09a6ae8b7757e66b9f70d808ea88193cf36303dcdcaa2da21","normalization.jsonSha256":"c9c5c28367e615db4acc6f13a4a454ea1e96bad5ace6709f834c4e09f03f17ac"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3193b8d7483071b6c5ef1193"},{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:18c08f83d8e385bf27be7e48"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3193b8d7483071b6c5ef1193"},{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:18c08f83d8e385bf27be7e48"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d1","originalRef":"l1","status":"route","source":"s5","target":"s8","type":"application_of","title":"Trace charged-spectrum and cutoff inferences to gravitational dispersion","rationale":"The dispersive branches of the charged-spectrum, weak-gravity and matter-cutoff questions apply gravitational scattering inference. Their geometric and phenomenological comparison branches retain a different role.","qualification":"This application concerns only analyses using the stated gravitational dispersive construction. Positivity, infrared treatment, high-energy behavior, sector choices, dimensions and perturbative limits require their source-specific justification. WGC criteria may be tested implications, comparison criteria or assumed inputs; particle and black-hole criteria remain distinct. Preserve charge and mass normalizations, uncertainty in high-energy QCD extrapolation, and the distinction between the QCD-free electroweak and full Standard Model cutoff claims. Neither a universal WGC derivation nor a current cutoff is established.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l1","s8","s5"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The application arrow correctly runs from the dispersive charged-spectrum and cutoff analyses to gravitational dispersive inference. Its explicit restriction to those analyses preserves the other comparison branches and the additional positivity, sector, dimensional and high-energy assumptions in both original statements.","refs":["l1","s8","s5"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-00-proposal","parent-orientation-00-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements for each relation. No tools, primary texts, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed or newly read.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts and reported source findings do not constitute fresh proof, calculation, numerical or observational verification.","Methods and applications are restricted to the supported components and stated conditions of their endpoints. They do not imply full-scope containment, common premises or transfer across dimensions, spectra, backgrounds, regulators or boundary conditions.","All source-version limits, historical status, description-only support and explicit exclusions remain operative. The workload grouping supplies no connection between disconnected cases.","This orientation review does not admit pending scopes, resolve canonical identities, create source homes or verify the complete atlas. Independent challenge, receipt checks and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements for every relation, and all 39 proposal records. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly supplied or read. Inherited reading counts, source claims and review descriptions are not fresh verification of calculations, proofs or observations.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Conditional methods and applications do not establish full-scope containment or applicability beyond their stated components and assumptions.","Source-specific versions, dimensions, backgrounds, spectra, regulators, boundary conditions and historical limitations remain operative. The packet grouping establishes no additional scientific relationship.","Agreement concerns these navigation records only. Pending scope identities, source questions and scientific uncertainties remain unresolved; endpoint, receipt, admission and global canonical/DAG checks are separate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l2":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l2","source":"q025-candidate-question:0e226d69a7c3bb82fb9345a2","target":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac","type":"application_of","title":"Identify the dispersive inputs to supersymmetric amplitude isolation","rationale":"Only the separately conditioned numerical-bootstrap stage applies the amplitude constraints organized by s13.","qualification":"The application is restricted to the stated non-gravitational, weakly coupled, four-dimensional planar setting reducing to N=4 SYM. Keep supersymmetry, unbroken SU(4) R-symmetry, massless-pole tree factorization and the scalar-parity restriction attached to the algebraic stage. Unitarity, analyticity, large-energy falloff and the nonzero spectral gap enter the separate bootstrap stage. The reported numerical evidence supplies neither verified uniqueness nor a UV-completion premise for the first stage; the Coulomb-branch parity boundary remains distinct.","evidenceIds":["unit:018d4c4d635c1a327db762bbd83d22d22617c659c3f0f7b051a55b75ea9173b2","unit:0aae56d12e1c88dcce6fe876f4dd88e52d8c285919842fb5435b56b336f829a7","unit:0f83af556cbc223dc2d12838dfc17fe1d406d863412cabfe96fb8d382fd3a2d6","unit:1383b2e2a0baf9ad9fda731b7fb65b6240584d5dd90236462cd11ac1e7182546","unit:1546dfaa33229f71c6a1939a83f16f835db130fb6a514c78b1b9fd15b48d6e11","unit:1655c2bcdd847ca3ad3572d4f0c5ca77a3c42f6ee7185d69fff5910e0a276409","unit:20d8a793b545cc5ba0ed741ce878ed9ea729b1bd3521f438ee5b9dae460ae2bc","unit:2f8ff4b55d7fd79ba1f49b1ce4f7080933cee8bff6af14dc1b94c0babbe98a40","unit:33ba57e407b9680fde51d6052fa4c6516b5e1a755b294a9bd36f4f3d582786a3","unit:43e363fb9814337b83f0e03a93aba748c0f6d3edcefbc7c8dd35b229fbb91478","unit:45088b06df418f90f258efb0c24ec4c20dc8f63e1289ac2111f4b29e0f0c4301","unit:4551cfd9b505ac1c3b6e6611a518c96e59e1cb6b51b6d6a02ee5a736d7b355a4","unit:4a9170893fb095bd1552f765db3e3a89e550bfc9f3a9ec919bb9fad8cdd53d30","unit:504a2df8eb7235f657fb58c10df2f77780c9ec0259e2f68983cf5eb53b43d493","unit:5163ff5ce8a41793cf9b259d58e4d53199b95e57640128c5d638da324a33a97a","unit:5297e29d8d427a9c3be0ba6e3961266cf210e0e6b4fe1364c3d890526a2b0a51","unit:56db8f87d65703ff80f4a3e6811087d0dc9946cfca00e0a456b0f0b0de6a0aee","unit:6427f1e39fe9a03c52d4fc3fcbd067872b2522c1cc3159644358bfbaa0022a49","unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","unit:6b8140fff99ef7ae2e0c19e23d4f6f9e784c75231cda12a3085163278c8af3b4","unit:7cf200d70597770e80bcbf279c4c7f49dbd0b40c8551006ed3ae05530f2e8fdc","unit:8442c6b1d700aeee9e2d712b39774bf60f01d328f481ed7477ba4a521fa3e58a","unit:844c3f250d4dfcdf7339199d1d64f6fd5bb62ee605e9b1973a0b1b7788777c48","unit:887e412bf115201387ac47dcdf20315c69dcd3104ef4f59b3e20bc873d02409c","unit:b7e5c5ffdf2bae9f0e32f3530d06ea4300c0e6005258d71a6b6c24a046e623d4","unit:c65404fc057a90ba747ce597c19b5f1f6479733e17169c31d2f460c7438a3b66","unit:c7aedf787b45ea0f17843ec329e0cc42be93175a25f130ce20175df49415ac9f","unit:cba697f61769b347eec12dbfae95a18f946156cec919565df140dd0c792b80f8","unit:daa7eb7f6a86e612633d818ecf1fcae97da1ac72666ca5350f1e2baf1b4ffcb3","unit:f703a0711336e1294e3dbb90041a9dd50cb94c9c5c41b199d47cc7c381c40f30","unit:f8ea0b88e9e618f1f9c80eb92c33961aa6df43aa8807a8c55bbc8d943b6a30db","unit:fdf3b3c97c1d76e00daefbc5119bc71c2c9f514b012deb23b5363eb4f09aebc9"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:44cfc530ee4b7053d438805d","scopeContentSha256":"40feb0266e67de3da90be9c7e169dc84955bba22e308618a51e5657633261550","localRef":"s10"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac","scopeContentSha256":"6bff48f3bcdae9e362626581fcbf8e5ec7841b40ed00a6b7a16e59f5a5cabd39","localRef":"s13"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l2","originalCandidateId":"parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge:link:27","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l2","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge:link:27","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:44cfc530ee4b7053d438805d","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l2","source":"s13","target":"s10","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["The conditional numerical-bootstrap stage applies scattering constraints to a specified supersymmetric setting; no uniqueness theorem or UV premise is imported into its first stage."],"challengeStatement":"Only the separately conditioned bootstrap stage applies dispersive constraints; it supplies no verified uniqueness theorem or UV premise for the first stage.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"283163d18ba710f459e0484e6542df91ca7736b322fdb2cc449617c5c04f597e","reply.jsonSha256":"398e8ffdfea28788c7df83fccb39c6b6b8765da14fa612698b725c281d72189d","reply.raw.txtSha256":"eafa7fae8eeef29098f63fbfb97587e70350b984274fc3b7632ef7094011764b","receipt.jsonSha256":"9ed9bbaa6747d6410c4706f71658336335859ea5d22baa19d8377e8df2ec1337","normalization.jsonSha256":"a42e51e8cdc567cfb764406a9be9d7c989697c2a60b114892b73238763e1a225","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"27a0b7f7853c909116f5ac24b26580040136c9b602012ffb78031fb8b94d8306"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"f5d2dd4194f583becec9b806a0f45bdc0428f3683e5559e7ae0e3d6128f3584d","reply.jsonSha256":"9237166341a88d80a3eb1baa20cdae1d2e4ea87c5d26fd2566974d3a929303ad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ec453393a3eaa3991788df984fedbe3796f68c98efe57d521d07eeeb11a815a4","receipt.jsonSha256":"ced6b81cf3d15466ec17b68129125a0d27760db45a15907132e3e030e1966851","normalization.jsonSha256":"64201833b74276dce09a5f789a77b82978d432b2a066f29a568edd100c870ef0"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac"},{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:44cfc530ee4b7053d438805d"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac"},{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:44cfc530ee4b7053d438805d"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d2","originalRef":"l2","status":"route","source":"s10","target":"s13","type":"application_of","title":"Identify the dispersive inputs to supersymmetric amplitude isolation","rationale":"Only the separately conditioned numerical-bootstrap stage applies the amplitude constraints organized by s13.","qualification":"The application is restricted to the stated non-gravitational, weakly coupled, four-dimensional planar setting reducing to N=4 SYM. Keep supersymmetry, unbroken SU(4) R-symmetry, massless-pole tree factorization and the scalar-parity restriction attached to the algebraic stage. Unitarity, analyticity, large-energy falloff and the nonzero spectral gap enter the separate bootstrap stage. The reported numerical evidence supplies neither verified uniqueness nor a UV-completion premise for the first stage; the Coulomb-branch parity boundary remains distinct.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l2","s13","s10"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The separately conditioned bootstrap stage applies amplitude constraints, supporting s10 to s13. The qualification preserves the specified supersymmetric setting and prevents the bootstrap assumptions or numerical isolation claim from becoming premises or a uniqueness theorem for the algebraic stage.","refs":["l2","s13","s10"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-00-proposal","parent-orientation-00-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements for each relation. No tools, primary texts, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed or newly read.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts and reported source findings do not constitute fresh proof, calculation, numerical or observational verification.","Methods and applications are restricted to the supported components and stated conditions of their endpoints. They do not imply full-scope containment, common premises or transfer across dimensions, spectra, backgrounds, regulators or boundary conditions.","All source-version limits, historical status, description-only support and explicit exclusions remain operative. The workload grouping supplies no connection between disconnected cases.","This orientation review does not admit pending scopes, resolve canonical identities, create source homes or verify the complete atlas. Independent challenge, receipt checks and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements for every relation, and all 39 proposal records. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly supplied or read. Inherited reading counts, source claims and review descriptions are not fresh verification of calculations, proofs or observations.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Conditional methods and applications do not establish full-scope containment or applicability beyond their stated components and assumptions.","Source-specific versions, dimensions, backgrounds, spectra, regulators, boundary conditions and historical limitations remain operative. The packet grouping establishes no additional scientific relationship.","Agreement concerns these navigation records only. Pending scope identities, source questions and scientific uncertainties remain unresolved; endpoint, receipt, admission and global canonical/DAG checks are separate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true,"canonicalEndpointProjection":{"sourceOriginalId":"q025-candidate-question:44cfc530ee4b7053d438805d","targetOriginalId":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac","originalRelation":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l2","source":"q025-candidate-question:44cfc530ee4b7053d438805d","target":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac","type":"application_of","title":"Identify the dispersive inputs to supersymmetric amplitude isolation","rationale":"Only the separately conditioned numerical-bootstrap stage applies the amplitude constraints organized by s13.","qualification":"The application is restricted to the stated non-gravitational, weakly coupled, four-dimensional planar setting reducing to N=4 SYM. Keep supersymmetry, unbroken SU(4) R-symmetry, massless-pole tree factorization and the scalar-parity restriction attached to the algebraic stage. Unitarity, analyticity, large-energy falloff and the nonzero spectral gap enter the separate bootstrap stage. The reported numerical evidence supplies neither verified uniqueness nor a UV-completion premise for the first stage; the Coulomb-branch parity boundary remains distinct.","evidenceIds":["unit:018d4c4d635c1a327db762bbd83d22d22617c659c3f0f7b051a55b75ea9173b2","unit:0aae56d12e1c88dcce6fe876f4dd88e52d8c285919842fb5435b56b336f829a7","unit:0f83af556cbc223dc2d12838dfc17fe1d406d863412cabfe96fb8d382fd3a2d6","unit:1383b2e2a0baf9ad9fda731b7fb65b6240584d5dd90236462cd11ac1e7182546","unit:1546dfaa33229f71c6a1939a83f16f835db130fb6a514c78b1b9fd15b48d6e11","unit:1655c2bcdd847ca3ad3572d4f0c5ca77a3c42f6ee7185d69fff5910e0a276409","unit:20d8a793b545cc5ba0ed741ce878ed9ea729b1bd3521f438ee5b9dae460ae2bc","unit:2f8ff4b55d7fd79ba1f49b1ce4f7080933cee8bff6af14dc1b94c0babbe98a40","unit:33ba57e407b9680fde51d6052fa4c6516b5e1a755b294a9bd36f4f3d582786a3","unit:43e363fb9814337b83f0e03a93aba748c0f6d3edcefbc7c8dd35b229fbb91478","unit:45088b06df418f90f258efb0c24ec4c20dc8f63e1289ac2111f4b29e0f0c4301","unit:4551cfd9b505ac1c3b6e6611a518c96e59e1cb6b51b6d6a02ee5a736d7b355a4","unit:4a9170893fb095bd1552f765db3e3a89e550bfc9f3a9ec919bb9fad8cdd53d30","unit:504a2df8eb7235f657fb58c10df2f77780c9ec0259e2f68983cf5eb53b43d493","unit:5163ff5ce8a41793cf9b259d58e4d53199b95e57640128c5d638da324a33a97a","unit:5297e29d8d427a9c3be0ba6e3961266cf210e0e6b4fe1364c3d890526a2b0a51","unit:56db8f87d65703ff80f4a3e6811087d0dc9946cfca00e0a456b0f0b0de6a0aee","unit:6427f1e39fe9a03c52d4fc3fcbd067872b2522c1cc3159644358bfbaa0022a49","unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","unit:6b8140fff99ef7ae2e0c19e23d4f6f9e784c75231cda12a3085163278c8af3b4","unit:7cf200d70597770e80bcbf279c4c7f49dbd0b40c8551006ed3ae05530f2e8fdc","unit:8442c6b1d700aeee9e2d712b39774bf60f01d328f481ed7477ba4a521fa3e58a","unit:844c3f250d4dfcdf7339199d1d64f6fd5bb62ee605e9b1973a0b1b7788777c48","unit:887e412bf115201387ac47dcdf20315c69dcd3104ef4f59b3e20bc873d02409c","unit:b7e5c5ffdf2bae9f0e32f3530d06ea4300c0e6005258d71a6b6c24a046e623d4","unit:c65404fc057a90ba747ce597c19b5f1f6479733e17169c31d2f460c7438a3b66","unit:c7aedf787b45ea0f17843ec329e0cc42be93175a25f130ce20175df49415ac9f","unit:cba697f61769b347eec12dbfae95a18f946156cec919565df140dd0c792b80f8","unit:daa7eb7f6a86e612633d818ecf1fcae97da1ac72666ca5350f1e2baf1b4ffcb3","unit:f703a0711336e1294e3dbb90041a9dd50cb94c9c5c41b199d47cc7c381c40f30","unit:f8ea0b88e9e618f1f9c80eb92c33961aa6df43aa8807a8c55bbc8d943b6a30db","unit:fdf3b3c97c1d76e00daefbc5119bc71c2c9f514b012deb23b5363eb4f09aebc9"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:44cfc530ee4b7053d438805d","scopeContentSha256":"40feb0266e67de3da90be9c7e169dc84955bba22e308618a51e5657633261550","localRef":"s10"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac","scopeContentSha256":"6bff48f3bcdae9e362626581fcbf8e5ec7841b40ed00a6b7a16e59f5a5cabd39","localRef":"s13"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l2","originalCandidateId":"parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge:link:27","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l2","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge:link:27","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:44cfc530ee4b7053d438805d","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l2","source":"s13","target":"s10","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["The conditional numerical-bootstrap stage applies scattering constraints to a specified supersymmetric setting; no uniqueness theorem or UV premise is imported into its first stage."],"challengeStatement":"Only the separately conditioned bootstrap stage applies dispersive constraints; it supplies no verified uniqueness theorem or UV premise for the first stage.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"283163d18ba710f459e0484e6542df91ca7736b322fdb2cc449617c5c04f597e","reply.jsonSha256":"398e8ffdfea28788c7df83fccb39c6b6b8765da14fa612698b725c281d72189d","reply.raw.txtSha256":"eafa7fae8eeef29098f63fbfb97587e70350b984274fc3b7632ef7094011764b","receipt.jsonSha256":"9ed9bbaa6747d6410c4706f71658336335859ea5d22baa19d8377e8df2ec1337","normalization.jsonSha256":"a42e51e8cdc567cfb764406a9be9d7c989697c2a60b114892b73238763e1a225","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"27a0b7f7853c909116f5ac24b26580040136c9b602012ffb78031fb8b94d8306"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"f5d2dd4194f583becec9b806a0f45bdc0428f3683e5559e7ae0e3d6128f3584d","reply.jsonSha256":"9237166341a88d80a3eb1baa20cdae1d2e4ea87c5d26fd2566974d3a929303ad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ec453393a3eaa3991788df984fedbe3796f68c98efe57d521d07eeeb11a815a4","receipt.jsonSha256":"ced6b81cf3d15466ec17b68129125a0d27760db45a15907132e3e030e1966851","normalization.jsonSha256":"64201833b74276dce09a5f789a77b82978d432b2a066f29a568edd100c870ef0"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac"},{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:44cfc530ee4b7053d438805d"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac"},{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:44cfc530ee4b7053d438805d"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d2","originalRef":"l2","status":"route","source":"s10","target":"s13","type":"application_of","title":"Identify the dispersive inputs to supersymmetric amplitude isolation","rationale":"Only the separately conditioned numerical-bootstrap stage applies the amplitude constraints organized by s13.","qualification":"The application is restricted to the stated non-gravitational, weakly coupled, four-dimensional planar setting reducing to N=4 SYM. Keep supersymmetry, unbroken SU(4) R-symmetry, massless-pole tree factorization and the scalar-parity restriction attached to the algebraic stage. Unitarity, analyticity, large-energy falloff and the nonzero spectral gap enter the separate bootstrap stage. The reported numerical evidence supplies neither verified uniqueness nor a UV-completion premise for the first stage; the Coulomb-branch parity boundary remains distinct.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l2","s13","s10"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The separately conditioned bootstrap stage applies amplitude constraints, supporting s10 to s13. The qualification preserves the specified supersymmetric setting and prevents the bootstrap assumptions or numerical isolation claim from becoming premises or a uniqueness theorem for the algebraic stage.","refs":["l2","s13","s10"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-00-proposal","parent-orientation-00-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements for each relation. No tools, primary texts, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed or newly read.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts and reported source findings do not constitute fresh proof, calculation, numerical or observational verification.","Methods and applications are restricted to the supported components and stated conditions of their endpoints. They do not imply full-scope containment, common premises or transfer across dimensions, spectra, backgrounds, regulators or boundary conditions.","All source-version limits, historical status, description-only support and explicit exclusions remain operative. The workload grouping supplies no connection between disconnected cases.","This orientation review does not admit pending scopes, resolve canonical identities, create source homes or verify the complete atlas. Independent challenge, receipt checks and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements for every relation, and all 39 proposal records. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly supplied or read. Inherited reading counts, source claims and review descriptions are not fresh verification of calculations, proofs or observations.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Conditional methods and applications do not establish full-scope containment or applicability beyond their stated components and assumptions.","Source-specific versions, dimensions, backgrounds, spectra, regulators, boundary conditions and historical limitations remain operative. The packet grouping establishes no additional scientific relationship.","Agreement concerns these navigation records only. Pending scope identities, source questions and scientific uncertainties remain unresolved; endpoint, receipt, admission and global canonical/DAG checks are separate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"identityDecisionIds":["decision:whole-group:a6196286e366f88a7d64bf6f"],"sourceCanonicalScopeContentSha256":"c464520aa10ec07a448ddfd40b69ea5e29c38eb7fc378f58490ca3079a05c35a","targetCanonicalScopeContentSha256":"6bff48f3bcdae9e362626581fcbf8e5ec7841b40ed00a6b7a16e59f5a5cabd39"}},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l3":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l3","source":"q025-candidate-question:4a2b2d3dfb9188c29d755ab5","target":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac","type":"method_for","title":"Supply spinning amplitudes for scattering-constraint tests","rationale":"Interaction construction supplies amplitude structures for subsequent constraint tests, reversing the original methodological direction.","qualification":"Use the corresponding spinning-field sectors, exchange content, dimensions and amplitude constructions. A specified soft weakly coupled completion does not cover all completions. Massive constructions and the separate massless gauge-theory results are not interchangeable, and the latter are not established limits of the massive cutoff analyses. Symmetry compatibility supplies no UV-consistency conclusion; the subsequent scattering tests retain their own analyticity, unitarity, crossing, growth and infrared assumptions.","evidenceIds":["unit:018d4c4d635c1a327db762bbd83d22d22617c659c3f0f7b051a55b75ea9173b2","unit:0aae56d12e1c88dcce6fe876f4dd88e52d8c285919842fb5435b56b336f829a7","unit:0f83af556cbc223dc2d12838dfc17fe1d406d863412cabfe96fb8d382fd3a2d6","unit:115e793d3e1ca72daf0b9e4e88ccc2a2182362c08d4098e3cd743f96871dfb2d","unit:1383b2e2a0baf9ad9fda731b7fb65b6240584d5dd90236462cd11ac1e7182546","unit:13bfc279b787c7338005730a2adaa154774092d26cf21cdef1a39fa4f6f6e011","unit:1546dfaa33229f71c6a1939a83f16f835db130fb6a514c78b1b9fd15b48d6e11","unit:1655c2bcdd847ca3ad3572d4f0c5ca77a3c42f6ee7185d69fff5910e0a276409","unit:20d8a793b545cc5ba0ed741ce878ed9ea729b1bd3521f438ee5b9dae460ae2bc","unit:2f8ff4b55d7fd79ba1f49b1ce4f7080933cee8bff6af14dc1b94c0babbe98a40","unit:33ba57e407b9680fde51d6052fa4c6516b5e1a755b294a9bd36f4f3d582786a3","unit:43e363fb9814337b83f0e03a93aba748c0f6d3edcefbc7c8dd35b229fbb91478","unit:45088b06df418f90f258efb0c24ec4c20dc8f63e1289ac2111f4b29e0f0c4301","unit:4551cfd9b505ac1c3b6e6611a518c96e59e1cb6b51b6d6a02ee5a736d7b355a4","unit:4a9170893fb095bd1552f765db3e3a89e550bfc9f3a9ec919bb9fad8cdd53d30","unit:504a2df8eb7235f657fb58c10df2f77780c9ec0259e2f68983cf5eb53b43d493","unit:5163ff5ce8a41793cf9b259d58e4d53199b95e57640128c5d638da324a33a97a","unit:5297e29d8d427a9c3be0ba6e3961266cf210e0e6b4fe1364c3d890526a2b0a51","unit:56db8f87d65703ff80f4a3e6811087d0dc9946cfca00e0a456b0f0b0de6a0aee","unit:6427f1e39fe9a03c52d4fc3fcbd067872b2522c1cc3159644358bfbaa0022a49","unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","unit:6b8140fff99ef7ae2e0c19e23d4f6f9e784c75231cda12a3085163278c8af3b4","unit:736d2314d251c89d51c00cd947121909bdb10a18c24464f99922fd28c09a8bd3","unit:7cf200d70597770e80bcbf279c4c7f49dbd0b40c8551006ed3ae05530f2e8fdc","unit:8442c6b1d700aeee9e2d712b39774bf60f01d328f481ed7477ba4a521fa3e58a","unit:844c3f250d4dfcdf7339199d1d64f6fd5bb62ee605e9b1973a0b1b7788777c48","unit:887e412bf115201387ac47dcdf20315c69dcd3104ef4f59b3e20bc873d02409c","unit:a7fbe1328b105156ffabc8927e9916e4b1d7ae1f5626dcd99b5b7ffc4543c063","unit:b7e5c5ffdf2bae9f0e32f3530d06ea4300c0e6005258d71a6b6c24a046e623d4","unit:c65404fc057a90ba747ce597c19b5f1f6479733e17169c31d2f460c7438a3b66","unit:c7aedf787b45ea0f17843ec329e0cc42be93175a25f130ce20175df49415ac9f","unit:cba697f61769b347eec12dbfae95a18f946156cec919565df140dd0c792b80f8","unit:d3578a28100b4532f538b8afd7e765dcbb922bdc674e33c1f6375ed9c4329c1b","unit:da1db3431b044e122489315966a93e49848549ab489de8f705ca1ebdae2c7518","unit:daa7eb7f6a86e612633d818ecf1fcae97da1ac72666ca5350f1e2baf1b4ffcb3","unit:f703a0711336e1294e3dbb90041a9dd50cb94c9c5c41b199d47cc7c381c40f30","unit:f8ea0b88e9e618f1f9c80eb92c33961aa6df43aa8807a8c55bbc8d943b6a30db","unit:fdf3b3c97c1d76e00daefbc5119bc71c2c9f514b012deb23b5363eb4f09aebc9"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4a2b2d3dfb9188c29d755ab5","scopeContentSha256":"5a57c97824f2c7a54132b5c8350ca3b8d0d34181ce91111f1661171253574d5e","localRef":"s12"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac","scopeContentSha256":"6bff48f3bcdae9e362626581fcbf8e5ec7841b40ed00a6b7a16e59f5a5cabd39","localRef":"s13"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l3","originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-challenge:link:33","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l3","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-challenge:link:33","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:4a2b2d3dfb9188c29d755ab5","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l3","source":"s13","target":"s12","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Constructing spinning-field interactions supplies amplitude structures for later tests, without identifying symmetry compatibility with UV consistency."],"challengeStatement":"Interaction construction supplies amplitude structures for subsequent tests; symmetry compatibility alone does not establish UV consistency.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"65efef2c5bb5566a5be05169b1a4c3c66be34ea203f58131bcec79993c5d5ae4","reply.jsonSha256":"fb97e5a7496915d72f486f56c5d5069448604219496582d04b406c25be90d0fb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"5ceb31a6a1cfbd31f749bc101ba09f78c51a17135ecd85a6ae3cff45290170a4","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa25c116c35e4a1be6112ff1f5127732df32700a2137ca0a6efef5151851a1ba","normalization.jsonSha256":"b6833520d559221fc1c5fbe58df58c096b3ef572566c342fe0596a3ffe6f74fe","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"782392732b0bdcfe56a8ba0a77a39fa568ad20e243db3bf908e85e5434364435"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1e95e3d1be787a43213f6055a62dc510ab1da705a28bdd5df5343a7e486344f7","reply.jsonSha256":"e65acc810c8ac0d38ab2949a4d45ee8e0da13b4b1da3488460ba3d6ca18bf33e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"6b94b5f7354a32c36b851bc7d27b8c1d0bab93ca3e7a930c8dd0a490407e9649","receipt.jsonSha256":"c485527a69ede7c09a6ae8b7757e66b9f70d808ea88193cf36303dcdcaa2da21","normalization.jsonSha256":"c9c5c28367e615db4acc6f13a4a454ea1e96bad5ace6709f834c4e09f03f17ac"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac"},{"ref":"x1_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4a2b2d3dfb9188c29d755ab5"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac"},{"ref":"x1_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4a2b2d3dfb9188c29d755ab5"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d3","originalRef":"l3","status":"route","source":"s12","target":"s13","type":"method_for","title":"Supply spinning amplitudes for scattering-constraint tests","rationale":"Interaction construction supplies amplitude structures for subsequent constraint tests, reversing the original methodological direction.","qualification":"Use the corresponding spinning-field sectors, exchange content, dimensions and amplitude constructions. A specified soft weakly coupled completion does not cover all completions. Massive constructions and the separate massless gauge-theory results are not interchangeable, and the latter are not established limits of the massive cutoff analyses. Symmetry compatibility supplies no UV-consistency conclusion; the subsequent scattering tests retain their own analyticity, unitarity, crossing, growth and infrared assumptions.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l3","s13","s12"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify interaction construction as supplying amplitude structures for later tests, so s12 to s13 is the correct methodological direction. The record preserves distinct massive and massless regimes and does not equate symmetry compatibility with ultraviolet consistency.","refs":["l3","s13","s12"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-00-proposal","parent-orientation-00-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements for each relation. No tools, primary texts, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed or newly read.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts and reported source findings do not constitute fresh proof, calculation, numerical or observational verification.","Methods and applications are restricted to the supported components and stated conditions of their endpoints. They do not imply full-scope containment, common premises or transfer across dimensions, spectra, backgrounds, regulators or boundary conditions.","All source-version limits, historical status, description-only support and explicit exclusions remain operative. The workload grouping supplies no connection between disconnected cases.","This orientation review does not admit pending scopes, resolve canonical identities, create source homes or verify the complete atlas. Independent challenge, receipt checks and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements for every relation, and all 39 proposal records. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly supplied or read. Inherited reading counts, source claims and review descriptions are not fresh verification of calculations, proofs or observations.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Conditional methods and applications do not establish full-scope containment or applicability beyond their stated components and assumptions.","Source-specific versions, dimensions, backgrounds, spectra, regulators, boundary conditions and historical limitations remain operative. The packet grouping establishes no additional scientific relationship.","Agreement concerns these navigation records only. Pending scope identities, source questions and scientific uncertainties remain unresolved; endpoint, receipt, admission and global canonical/DAG checks are separate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l4":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l4","source":"q025-candidate-question:042027303efe727f05b67a3d","target":"q025-candidate-question:4a2b2d3dfb9188c29d755ab5","type":"application_of","title":"Trace spinning-sector signatures to interaction constructions","rationale":"The supported primordial, classical-matching and compact-binary questions apply specified spinning-interaction constructions.","qualification":"Keep primordial correlators, classical spinning interactions and low-energy binary observables as separate applications with their own fields, interactions and regimes. The binary higher-spin question does not assume a detailed dark-sector model. An announced correlator calculation is not a detection. The qualitative torsion proposal remains a neighboring question with no supplied waveform, effect size or observational bound; this route does not establish that it applies the same amplitude construction.","evidenceIds":["unit:115e793d3e1ca72daf0b9e4e88ccc2a2182362c08d4098e3cd743f96871dfb2d","unit:13bfc279b787c7338005730a2adaa154774092d26cf21cdef1a39fa4f6f6e011","unit:736d2314d251c89d51c00cd947121909bdb10a18c24464f99922fd28c09a8bd3","unit:a7fbe1328b105156ffabc8927e9916e4b1d7ae1f5626dcd99b5b7ffc4543c063","unit:c56ea8072bcf439774490499c64162437be6f4d6602eaa4b032e544d7df9c687","unit:c7e5ab331e2fdf954956ea0691a43da91418e2fcbfafb00d6030622a482ef732","unit:d3578a28100b4532f538b8afd7e765dcbb922bdc674e33c1f6375ed9c4329c1b","unit:da1db3431b044e122489315966a93e49848549ab489de8f705ca1ebdae2c7518","unit:fed843a1ef07c202efaa61d6ab23ca400223c34026c94a98c453cfe430a2516e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:042027303efe727f05b67a3d","scopeContentSha256":"ce22a3b3f1000ae03b6e741aa40d29e5c3ca6dd5b9841a11c69ca62fb55917cd","localRef":"s1"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4a2b2d3dfb9188c29d755ab5","scopeContentSha256":"5a57c97824f2c7a54132b5c8350ca3b8d0d34181ce91111f1661171253574d5e","localRef":"s12"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l4","originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-challenge:link:34","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l4","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-challenge:link:34","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:4a2b2d3dfb9188c29d755ab5","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:042027303efe727f05b67a3d","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l4","source":"s12","target":"s1","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Spinning interactions have separate primordial, classical-matching and binary-observable applications."],"challengeStatement":"Spinning interactions have separate primordial, classical-matching and compact-binary applications.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"65efef2c5bb5566a5be05169b1a4c3c66be34ea203f58131bcec79993c5d5ae4","reply.jsonSha256":"fb97e5a7496915d72f486f56c5d5069448604219496582d04b406c25be90d0fb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"5ceb31a6a1cfbd31f749bc101ba09f78c51a17135ecd85a6ae3cff45290170a4","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa25c116c35e4a1be6112ff1f5127732df32700a2137ca0a6efef5151851a1ba","normalization.jsonSha256":"b6833520d559221fc1c5fbe58df58c096b3ef572566c342fe0596a3ffe6f74fe","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"782392732b0bdcfe56a8ba0a77a39fa568ad20e243db3bf908e85e5434364435"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-6695e767a08bf35f78fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1e95e3d1be787a43213f6055a62dc510ab1da705a28bdd5df5343a7e486344f7","reply.jsonSha256":"e65acc810c8ac0d38ab2949a4d45ee8e0da13b4b1da3488460ba3d6ca18bf33e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"6b94b5f7354a32c36b851bc7d27b8c1d0bab93ca3e7a930c8dd0a490407e9649","receipt.jsonSha256":"c485527a69ede7c09a6ae8b7757e66b9f70d808ea88193cf36303dcdcaa2da21","normalization.jsonSha256":"c9c5c28367e615db4acc6f13a4a454ea1e96bad5ace6709f834c4e09f03f17ac"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4a2b2d3dfb9188c29d755ab5"},{"ref":"x1_10","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:042027303efe727f05b67a3d"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4a2b2d3dfb9188c29d755ab5"},{"ref":"x1_10","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:042027303efe727f05b67a3d"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d4","originalRef":"l4","status":"route","source":"s1","target":"s12","type":"application_of","title":"Trace spinning-sector signatures to interaction constructions","rationale":"The supported primordial, classical-matching and compact-binary questions apply specified spinning-interaction constructions.","qualification":"Keep primordial correlators, classical spinning interactions and low-energy binary observables as separate applications with their own fields, interactions and regimes. The binary higher-spin question does not assume a detailed dark-sector model. An announced correlator calculation is not a detection. The qualitative torsion proposal remains a neighboring question with no supplied waveform, effect size or observational bound; this route does not establish that it applies the same amplitude construction.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l4","s12","s1"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The specified signature and classical-matching questions apply spinning-interaction constructions, supporting the reversed application arrow. Primordial, classical and compact-binary applications remain separate, and the qualification appropriately leaves the qualitative torsion proposal outside any established common amplitude application.","refs":["l4","s12","s1"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-00-proposal","parent-orientation-00-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements for each relation. No tools, primary texts, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed or newly read.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts and reported source findings do not constitute fresh proof, calculation, numerical or observational verification.","Methods and applications are restricted to the supported components and stated conditions of their endpoints. They do not imply full-scope containment, common premises or transfer across dimensions, spectra, backgrounds, regulators or boundary conditions.","All source-version limits, historical status, description-only support and explicit exclusions remain operative. The workload grouping supplies no connection between disconnected cases.","This orientation review does not admit pending scopes, resolve canonical identities, create source homes or verify the complete atlas. Independent challenge, receipt checks and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements for every relation, and all 39 proposal records. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly supplied or read. Inherited reading counts, source claims and review descriptions are not fresh verification of calculations, proofs or observations.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Conditional methods and applications do not establish full-scope containment or applicability beyond their stated components and assumptions.","Source-specific versions, dimensions, backgrounds, spectra, regulators, boundary conditions and historical limitations remain operative. The packet grouping establishes no additional scientific relationship.","Agreement concerns these navigation records only. Pending scope identities, source questions and scientific uncertainties remain unresolved; endpoint, receipt, admission and global canonical/DAG checks are separate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l5":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l5","source":"q025-candidate-question:6b63db6f0ed1efb2583781d2","target":"q025-candidate-question:042027303efe727f05b67a3d","type":"method_for","title":"Calculate selected spinning-sector gravitational observables","rationale":"Gravitational amplitude calculations provide methods for selected observables and classical matching in s1.","qualification":"The connection is limited to the corresponding gravitational observable and amplitude calculation, with its post-Minkowskian, test-particle or loop assumptions. Inclusive scattering, propagation, reheating and the separate agravity model retain their additional systems and regimes. Inclusive observables are not exclusive forward amplitudes, and successful calculation does not establish ultraviolet consistency. No transfer to every primordial, binary or qualitative torsion question is implied; the supplied support remains description-level.","evidenceIds":["unit:0b21eedd06fc865eb5789abc903521004a545547e3a32602954c719ac7de7088","unit:5d5cfee1673d90f89020f3958f1bf80871e3f7eed57cf4de9a63b4fe5e915b8f","unit:736d2314d251c89d51c00cd947121909bdb10a18c24464f99922fd28c09a8bd3","unit:8d6f54f789fd0a583712d85ec33f4513b652222533fef83752fa39629b31bfe2","unit:97d2fa4b5d2a990f980ebd770106840190d95e7bdd357f135765ed65d45a8445","unit:aa833892e4ace978097da5c3c8d37eb8beaf99b6c20bc02a777e50395260f618","unit:c56ea8072bcf439774490499c64162437be6f4d6602eaa4b032e544d7df9c687","unit:c7e5ab331e2fdf954956ea0691a43da91418e2fcbfafb00d6030622a482ef732","unit:ce4b71cfb13956d8b1c60dad8b5885fbf983cf3c4ea6a86dbb67be631b38b9bd","unit:d28ec7ed1c8b537101fbf472bb7d2c3a637512561c212ef76a51efbb7eacb5d8","unit:fed843a1ef07c202efaa61d6ab23ca400223c34026c94a98c453cfe430a2516e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6b63db6f0ed1efb2583781d2","scopeContentSha256":"7460d21de35975203cb94c0dea02decfd2b588b790f43315a358f9880b384bd9","localRef":"s18"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:042027303efe727f05b67a3d","scopeContentSha256":"ce22a3b3f1000ae03b6e741aa40d29e5c3ca6dd5b9841a11c69ca62fb55917cd","localRef":"s1"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l5","originalCandidateId":"parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge:link:29","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l5","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge:link:29","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:042027303efe727f05b67a3d","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:6b63db6f0ed1efb2583781d2","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l5","source":"s1","target":"s18","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Amplitude calculations provide methods for selected gravitational observables. Inclusive scattering, propagation and reheating retain their additional systems and regimes."],"challengeStatement":"Amplitude calculations support selected observables, while inclusive scattering, propagation and reheating retain their additional regimes.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"283163d18ba710f459e0484e6542df91ca7736b322fdb2cc449617c5c04f597e","reply.jsonSha256":"398e8ffdfea28788c7df83fccb39c6b6b8765da14fa612698b725c281d72189d","reply.raw.txtSha256":"eafa7fae8eeef29098f63fbfb97587e70350b984274fc3b7632ef7094011764b","receipt.jsonSha256":"9ed9bbaa6747d6410c4706f71658336335859ea5d22baa19d8377e8df2ec1337","normalization.jsonSha256":"a42e51e8cdc567cfb764406a9be9d7c989697c2a60b114892b73238763e1a225","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"27a0b7f7853c909116f5ac24b26580040136c9b602012ffb78031fb8b94d8306"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00602c541f9d268ad95f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"f5d2dd4194f583becec9b806a0f45bdc0428f3683e5559e7ae0e3d6128f3584d","reply.jsonSha256":"9237166341a88d80a3eb1baa20cdae1d2e4ea87c5d26fd2566974d3a929303ad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ec453393a3eaa3991788df984fedbe3796f68c98efe57d521d07eeeb11a815a4","receipt.jsonSha256":"ced6b81cf3d15466ec17b68129125a0d27760db45a15907132e3e030e1966851","normalization.jsonSha256":"64201833b74276dce09a5f789a77b82978d432b2a066f29a568edd100c870ef0"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:042027303efe727f05b67a3d"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6b63db6f0ed1efb2583781d2"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:042027303efe727f05b67a3d"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6b63db6f0ed1efb2583781d2"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d5","originalRef":"l5","status":"route","source":"s18","target":"s1","type":"method_for","title":"Calculate selected spinning-sector gravitational observables","rationale":"Gravitational amplitude calculations provide methods for selected observables and classical matching in s1.","qualification":"The connection is limited to the corresponding gravitational observable and amplitude calculation, with its post-Minkowskian, test-particle or loop assumptions. Inclusive scattering, propagation, reheating and the separate agravity model retain their additional systems and regimes. Inclusive observables are not exclusive forward amplitudes, and successful calculation does not establish ultraviolet consistency. No transfer to every primordial, binary or qualitative torsion question is implied; the supplied support remains description-level.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l5","s1","s18"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Amplitude calculations supply methods for selected gravitational observables, supporting s18 to s1. The record retains the additional systems and regimes of inclusive scattering, propagation and reheating without claiming applicability to every signature question or inferring ultraviolet consistency.","refs":["l5","s1","s18"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-00-proposal","parent-orientation-00-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements for each relation. No tools, primary texts, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed or newly read.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts and reported source findings do not constitute fresh proof, calculation, numerical or observational verification.","Methods and applications are restricted to the supported components and stated conditions of their endpoints. They do not imply full-scope containment, common premises or transfer across dimensions, spectra, backgrounds, regulators or boundary conditions.","All source-version limits, historical status, description-only support and explicit exclusions remain operative. The workload grouping supplies no connection between disconnected cases.","This orientation review does not admit pending scopes, resolve canonical identities, create source homes or verify the complete atlas. Independent challenge, receipt checks and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements for every relation, and all 39 proposal records. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly supplied or read. Inherited reading counts, source claims and review descriptions are not fresh verification of calculations, proofs or observations.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Conditional methods and applications do not establish full-scope containment or applicability beyond their stated components and assumptions.","Source-specific versions, dimensions, backgrounds, spectra, regulators, boundary conditions and historical limitations remain operative. The packet grouping establishes no additional scientific relationship.","Agreement concerns these navigation records only. Pending scope identities, source questions and scientific uncertainties remain unresolved; endpoint, receipt, admission and global canonical/DAG checks are separate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"}}}