{"kind":"eigenquestions-relation-details","schemaVersion":"1.0.0","relations":{"navigation:kk:0":{"id":"navigation:kk:0","source":"q-kk-graviton-thermal-production","target":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay","type":"comparison","title":"Does the produced population have the assumed subsequent cascade?","rationale":"Adequate initial production does not establish cascade efficiency. Check the background and couplings before applying the reported threshold scaling.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","unit:be7aae21bb2419d0869faff0e2d1c1e653b0e8e75d40ce2e657fb8fb7495284a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:98101f0d696c278269902e9cbb5320e0","paperId":"2311.05318","sourceSha256":"5e86e533b2f8f00ae0864f03f12ce5d448bac05c49793705c07efa39bc149903","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fab9bf3fee6db124cc91/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bba1f3f7366677016355706e27db014e6ad9156af892761f097b3ed5a48c5014","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f0e4c6eec8d6d63ebf4b8ca921034d36a649eb3ac4b7d8e95c99a321fe6d2a37","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:kk-navigation:0","provenance":{"originalProposalId":"route:kk:p0:p1:premise_check","originalProposedType":"premise_check","coordinatorTypeAdjudication":true,"sourceReviewIds":["kk-normalized-original","kk-compact-challenge"],"reviewedNativeLinkAgreement":"exact_independent_type_and_direction","notScientificImplication":true,"decisionId":"decision:kk-navigation:0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:1":{"id":"navigation:kk:1","source":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay","target":"q-flat-darkdimension-freezein-bounds","type":"related_question","title":"What flat-model bounds follow from suppressed cascades?","rationale":"The 2026 source applies its reported suppression to irreducible production and reheating bounds in a flat dimension; the numerical bound remains source-attributed.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346"],"evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:kk-navigation:1","provenance":{"originalProposalId":"route:kk:p1:p3:application_of","originalProposedType":"application_of","coordinatorTypeAdjudication":true,"sourceReviewIds":["kk-normalized-original","kk-compact-challenge"],"reviewedNativeLinkAgreement":"exact_independent_type_and_direction","notScientificImplication":true,"decisionId":"decision:kk-navigation:1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:2":{"id":"navigation:kk:2","source":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay","target":"q-kk-decay-linear-cosmology","type":"comparison","title":"How does the conditional recoil model depend on the decay history?","rationale":"Compare a microscopic rate question with a conditional linear-cosmology calculation. Their targets differ; the latter does not establish that its assumed cascade occurs.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","unit:be7aae21bb2419d0869faff0e2d1c1e653b0e8e75d40ce2e657fb8fb7495284a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2fad585ea0fd6a9e881beb23831ceaa7","paperId":"2311.05318","sourceSha256":"5e86e533b2f8f00ae0864f03f12ce5d448bac05c49793705c07efa39bc149903","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fab9bf3fee6db124cc91/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bba1f3f7366677016355706e27db014e6ad9156af892761f097b3ed5a48c5014","pdfPage":5,"start":92,"end":3490,"textSha256":"61c3e56df1d3e250b6c058bf036fe06e39f281e0111f2c5b8b38423b4af22398","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bbf52e208ce8497a6b71719219ba7d85","paperId":"2311.05318","sourceSha256":"5e86e533b2f8f00ae0864f03f12ce5d448bac05c49793705c07efa39bc149903","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fab9bf3fee6db124cc91/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bba1f3f7366677016355706e27db014e6ad9156af892761f097b3ed5a48c5014","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1673,"textSha256":"7f3a9c3dff1be519144f71674fae6fab4ecf7c7d625152e8fe85d4abbf95c382","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:kk-navigation:2","provenance":{"originalProposalId":"route:kk:p1:p2:comparison","originalProposedType":"comparison","coordinatorTypeAdjudication":false,"sourceReviewIds":["kk-normalized-original","kk-compact-challenge"],"reviewedNativeLinkAgreement":"coordinator_type_and_direction_required","notScientificImplication":true,"decisionId":"decision:kk-navigation:2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:3":{"id":"navigation:kk:3","source":"q-kk-decay-linear-cosmology","target":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay","type":"premise_check","title":"Is the assumed repeated-decay history microscopically supported?","rationale":"The linear model presupposes repeated near-threshold decays. Check the applicable threshold rate without replacing the conditional calculation by a universal exclusion.","evidenceIds":["unit:be7aae21bb2419d0869faff0e2d1c1e653b0e8e75d40ce2e657fb8fb7495284a","unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346"],"evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2fad585ea0fd6a9e881beb23831ceaa7","paperId":"2311.05318","sourceSha256":"5e86e533b2f8f00ae0864f03f12ce5d448bac05c49793705c07efa39bc149903","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fab9bf3fee6db124cc91/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bba1f3f7366677016355706e27db014e6ad9156af892761f097b3ed5a48c5014","pdfPage":5,"start":92,"end":3490,"textSha256":"61c3e56df1d3e250b6c058bf036fe06e39f281e0111f2c5b8b38423b4af22398","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:kk-navigation:3","provenance":{"originalProposalId":"route:kk:p2:p1:premise_check","originalProposedType":"premise_check","coordinatorTypeAdjudication":false,"sourceReviewIds":["kk-normalized-original","kk-compact-challenge"],"reviewedNativeLinkAgreement":"coordinator_type_and_direction_required","notScientificImplication":true,"decisionId":"decision:kk-navigation:3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:4":{"id":"navigation:kk:4","source":"q-kk-decay-linear-cosmology","target":"q-kk-graviton-thermal-production","type":"premise_check","title":"Which initial KK population does the cosmology assume?","rationale":"The linear analysis inherits hot-brane production with an initially empty bulk and a specified initial temperature. This is an initial-condition route, not source equivalence.","evidenceIds":["unit:be7aae21bb2419d0869faff0e2d1c1e653b0e8e75d40ce2e657fb8fb7495284a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:98101f0d696c278269902e9cbb5320e0","paperId":"2311.05318","sourceSha256":"5e86e533b2f8f00ae0864f03f12ce5d448bac05c49793705c07efa39bc149903","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fab9bf3fee6db124cc91/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bba1f3f7366677016355706e27db014e6ad9156af892761f097b3ed5a48c5014","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f0e4c6eec8d6d63ebf4b8ca921034d36a649eb3ac4b7d8e95c99a321fe6d2a37","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bbf52e208ce8497a6b71719219ba7d85","paperId":"2311.05318","sourceSha256":"5e86e533b2f8f00ae0864f03f12ce5d448bac05c49793705c07efa39bc149903","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fab9bf3fee6db124cc91/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bba1f3f7366677016355706e27db014e6ad9156af892761f097b3ed5a48c5014","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1673,"textSha256":"7f3a9c3dff1be519144f71674fae6fab4ecf7c7d625152e8fe85d4abbf95c382","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:kk-navigation:4","provenance":{"originalProposalId":"route:kk:p2:p0:premise_check","originalProposedType":"premise_check","coordinatorTypeAdjudication":false,"sourceReviewIds":["kk-normalized-original","kk-compact-challenge"],"reviewedNativeLinkAgreement":"coordinator_new_route_required","notScientificImplication":true,"decisionId":"decision:kk-navigation:4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:5":{"id":"navigation:kk:5","source":"q-kk-graviton-thermal-production","target":"q-kk-decay-linear-cosmology","type":"related_question","title":"What linear signatures follow for a specified decaying population?","rationale":"Follow initial production to a distinct calculation that additionally assumes a repeated-decay history, symmetric nonrelativistic daughter kinematics and a linear regime. Production alone does not entail those premises.","evidenceIds":["unit:be7aae21bb2419d0869faff0e2d1c1e653b0e8e75d40ce2e657fb8fb7495284a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:98101f0d696c278269902e9cbb5320e0","paperId":"2311.05318","sourceSha256":"5e86e533b2f8f00ae0864f03f12ce5d448bac05c49793705c07efa39bc149903","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fab9bf3fee6db124cc91/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bba1f3f7366677016355706e27db014e6ad9156af892761f097b3ed5a48c5014","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f0e4c6eec8d6d63ebf4b8ca921034d36a649eb3ac4b7d8e95c99a321fe6d2a37","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2fad585ea0fd6a9e881beb23831ceaa7","paperId":"2311.05318","sourceSha256":"5e86e533b2f8f00ae0864f03f12ce5d448bac05c49793705c07efa39bc149903","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fab9bf3fee6db124cc91/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bba1f3f7366677016355706e27db014e6ad9156af892761f097b3ed5a48c5014","pdfPage":5,"start":92,"end":3490,"textSha256":"61c3e56df1d3e250b6c058bf036fe06e39f281e0111f2c5b8b38423b4af22398","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bbf52e208ce8497a6b71719219ba7d85","paperId":"2311.05318","sourceSha256":"5e86e533b2f8f00ae0864f03f12ce5d448bac05c49793705c07efa39bc149903","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fab9bf3fee6db124cc91/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bba1f3f7366677016355706e27db014e6ad9156af892761f097b3ed5a48c5014","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1673,"textSha256":"7f3a9c3dff1be519144f71674fae6fab4ecf7c7d625152e8fe85d4abbf95c382","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:kk-navigation:5","provenance":{"originalProposalId":"route:kk:p0:p2:application_of","originalProposedType":"application_of","coordinatorTypeAdjudication":true,"sourceReviewIds":["kk-normalized-original","kk-compact-challenge"],"reviewedNativeLinkAgreement":"coordinator_new_route_required","notScientificImplication":true,"decisionId":"decision:kk-navigation:5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:6":{"id":"navigation:kk:6","source":"q-flat-darkdimension-freezein-bounds","target":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay","type":"premise_check","title":"Which threshold suppression underlies the flat-model bound?","rationale":"Check the rate premise used by the flat-model freeze-in analysis; this reverse route does not broaden the bound to warped dimensions or other species.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346"],"evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:kk-navigation:6","provenance":{"originalProposalId":"route:kk:p3:p1:premise_check","originalProposedType":"premise_check","coordinatorTypeAdjudication":false,"sourceReviewIds":["kk-normalized-original","kk-compact-challenge"],"reviewedNativeLinkAgreement":"coordinator_new_route_required","notScientificImplication":true,"decisionId":"decision:kk-navigation:6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:inflation:pn0":{"id":"navigation:inflation:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-question:12a2e56e9a3e4a85989a684c","target":"q025-candidate-question:528990f28c3ccba6d5d8b47d","type":"comparison","title":"Compare inflationary mechanisms and trajectory distances","qualification":"Use c0 for the shared dynamics overview; this route emphasizes c1's distinct cooperative, exit, turning and trajectory/geodesic questions. The full c1 definition is unchanged. No common attractor, universal curvature sign or compulsory SDC premise is implied.","rationale":"The exact definitions support a differentiated next direction without presenting another indistinguishable multifield overview or merging their complete scopes.","evidenceIds":["unit:4af27c308433ed96897b4f154906c8eaa06e5c09e636f426886d96754d77c275","unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","unit:f3c1328da956bff58dbfb949f0a7c75260ec904d9556000faed0d3dfe72367f6"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:12a2e56e9a3e4a85989a684c"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:528990f28c3ccba6d5d8b47d"},{"localRef":"u25","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:4af27c308433ed96897b4f154906c8eaa06e5c09e636f426886d96754d77c275","textSha256":"501321b282bfbb14557ac348ee90284630e513951cda0a03528972d9ce9fa847"},{"localRef":"n35","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:4af27c308433ed96897b4f154906c8eaa06e5c09e636f426886d96754d77c275","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u30","kind":"description","unitIndex":83,"unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","textSha256":"7aa306b37d444bb72c20d45042ed6c79f78d4ba7f75932003723cbbf8f4517f2"},{"localRef":"n58","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u71","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:f3c1328da956bff58dbfb949f0a7c75260ec904d9556000faed0d3dfe72367f6","textSha256":"e3fed400061ec47fbab046840b136e58ac869307d6bdd9fc65d3bc01e08969ae"},{"localRef":"n46","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f3c1328da956bff58dbfb949f0a7c75260ec904d9556000faed0d3dfe72367f6","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["inflation-scope-navigation-proposal","inflation-retained-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The comparison direction exposes c1's distinct mechanism and distance targets while retaining c0 for shared dynamics. It asserts neither containment nor a compulsory conjecture premise.","refs":["c0","c1","u25","n35","u71","n46"]},"noImplicationBeyondTypedQualifiedRoute":true,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:inflation:pn1":{"id":"navigation:inflation:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae","target":"q025-candidate-question:c19b646d564f6e3e0f160f53","type":"narrower","title":"Examine kinetic, dissipative and gravitational mechanisms","qualification":"Focus on c2's stated mechanisms and their separate perturbation and exit calculations, including potential-free kinetics. General kinetic actions are not all P(φ,X), and a changed background expansion law does not supply a complete perturbation theory.","rationale":"c3 supplies the shared broad destination; c2 supplies a more specific comparison while preserving its action and control restrictions.","evidenceIds":["unit:2f6f00e39c157ddcabebbe6b29ccd9158eb1406d68cba75ca73640d0212c2f7c","unit:44f896289f988ae22f8cbdf9c2786133fe80640387051fbf190a4702037ff272"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c19b646d564f6e3e0f160f53"},{"localRef":"u22","kind":"description","unitIndex":82,"unitId":"unit:44f896289f988ae22f8cbdf9c2786133fe80640387051fbf190a4702037ff272","textSha256":"e2b6b37b4dcada60b412317bb4763f5083c338986115287e96468ebaf157225b"},{"localRef":"n57","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:44f896289f988ae22f8cbdf9c2786133fe80640387051fbf190a4702037ff272","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":48,"unitId":"unit:2f6f00e39c157ddcabebbe6b29ccd9158eb1406d68cba75ca73640d0212c2f7c","textSha256":"bf9132cc35500dbe3d9c78a19ab37eacb80529d341c2c87fd0fe0588ed84a25c"},{"localRef":"n39","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2f6f00e39c157ddcabebbe6b29ccd9158eb1406d68cba75ca73640d0212c2f7c","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["inflation-scope-navigation-proposal","inflation-retained-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The direction is correctly broader c3 to focused c2. Its qualification preserves potential-free kinetics and prevents a background modification from being mistaken for a complete perturbation prescription.","refs":["c3","c2","u22","n57","u19","n39"]},"noImplicationBeyondTypedQualifiedRoute":true,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:inflation:pn2":{"id":"navigation:inflation:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-question:12a2e56e9a3e4a85989a684c","target":"q025-candidate-question:c19b646d564f6e3e0f160f53","type":"comparison","title":"Compare perturbation methods across kinetic actions","qualification":"Compare source-specific multifield methods with noncanonical and modified-gravity calculations. PyTransport's curved-metric tree-level scope does not establish support for every kinetic action; multiple-DBI horizon-exit and separable-Hubble evolution restrictions remain distinct.","rationale":"The existing scopes explicitly identify an action-support boundary that is useful when moving from general multifield calculations to modified dynamics.","evidenceIds":["unit:28cc3b8fbc59cb74cee255fb796373ce619cff34da0cf31634c5e2d8732b8aa0","unit:e11deefd980d73a0a6df6c68de43a0c805e7db3e5f523b0f12c99aa712c227e5"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:12a2e56e9a3e4a85989a684c"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c19b646d564f6e3e0f160f53"},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:28cc3b8fbc59cb74cee255fb796373ce619cff34da0cf31634c5e2d8732b8aa0","textSha256":"8e92c481fbc3c42a86309060eb52acf655835b2eea7bdd24d3ad9dd9df63afe4"},{"localRef":"n11","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:28cc3b8fbc59cb74cee255fb796373ce619cff34da0cf31634c5e2d8732b8aa0","reviewId":"leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u66","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:e11deefd980d73a0a6df6c68de43a0c805e7db3e5f523b0f12c99aa712c227e5","textSha256":"44e60a0db770e7db3621811f21a9d3aaa0692b9390e00b6ce86b7fdff9e6d927"},{"localRef":"n9","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e11deefd980d73a0a6df6c68de43a0c805e7db3e5f523b0f12c99aa712c227e5","reviewId":"leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["inflation-scope-navigation-proposal","inflation-retained-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Comparison is the licensed type: action applicability is explicitly restricted in c0 and n11, and n9 separates multiple-DBI horizon-exit assumptions from later analytical evolution.","refs":["c0","c2","u14","n11","u66","n9"]},"noImplicationBeyondTypedQualifiedRoute":true,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:inflation:pn3":{"id":"navigation:inflation:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-question:c19b646d564f6e3e0f160f53","target":"q025-candidate-question:9b49c6ccf6462c9e89de1083","type":"narrower","title":"Study Gauss–Bonnet corrections to rapid-turn inflation","qualification":"Select u70's two-field inflationary question. The packet supports the target through a description and inherited introductory assessments, not its detailed formulas. No single-field inverse-potential ansatz or late-time dark-matter condition is imported.","rationale":"This supplies a precise gravitational-coupling question beneath the mechanism comparison while preserving the compound source's epoch split.","evidenceIds":["unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c19b646d564f6e3e0f160f53"},{"localRef":"u70","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","textSha256":"78cb7d616db1242c87b4506921af36e198b09b50c8ca953c7f04499bc7585e82"},{"localRef":"n5","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","reviewId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n8","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","reviewId":"leaf-431e39adaf172dcc211a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n63","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","reviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","sourceReviewIds":["inflation-scope-navigation-proposal","inflation-retained-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c2 to pq0 correctly narrows a gravitational-coupling question to a source-specific two-field inflationary target. The qualification makes the description-level support and absent action derivation explicit.","refs":["c2","u70","n5","n8","n63"]},"noImplicationBeyondTypedQualifiedRoute":true,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:inflation:pn4":{"id":"navigation:inflation:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-question:9b49c6ccf6462c9e89de1083","target":"q025-candidate-question:34990732591a1b91983b1849","type":"related_question","title":"Examine the source's late-time phantom conditions","qualification":"The target changes from two-field rapid-turn inflation to multifield late-time dark energy. The supplied late-time account requires non-negligible dark matter without direct DM–DE interaction. This is a separate announced analysis, not a demonstrated continuation of the inflationary solution.","rationale":"u70 explicitly contains both targets, licensing a source-linked reading route without a new physical equivalence or shared-premise claim.","evidenceIds":["unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u70","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","textSha256":"78cb7d616db1242c87b4506921af36e198b09b50c8ca953c7f04499bc7585e82"},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-431e39adaf172dcc211a-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:34990732591a1b91983b1849"},{"localRef":"n5","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","reviewId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n8","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","reviewId":"leaf-431e39adaf172dcc211a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n63","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","reviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","sourceReviewIds":["inflation-scope-navigation-proposal","inflation-retained-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The compound description supports this explicit related-question arc. Its type and qualifications correctly avoid treating the late-time branch as a narrower inflationary question or an application of already-established inflationary formulas.","refs":["u70","c4","n5","n8","n63"]},"noImplicationBeyondTypedQualifiedRoute":true,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:inflation:pn5":{"id":"navigation:inflation:pn5","source":"q025-candidate-question:8d27c10725a1f68d46910a02","target":"q025-candidate-question:34990732591a1b91983b1849","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on Gauss–Bonnet phantom-like dark energy","qualification":"Select the late-time effective equation-of-state question below -1, retaining its non-negligible-dark-matter condition and no direct DM–DE interaction. Other c5 models need not share these conditions; no wrong-sign kinetic term or observational confirmation is inferred.","rationale":"The existing precise c4 question supplies the phantom branch without duplicating it within the later-evolution overview.","evidenceIds":["unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8d27c10725a1f68d46910a02"},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-431e39adaf172dcc211a-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:34990732591a1b91983b1849"},{"localRef":"u70","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","textSha256":"78cb7d616db1242c87b4506921af36e198b09b50c8ca953c7f04499bc7585e82"},{"localRef":"n5","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","reviewId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n8","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","reviewId":"leaf-431e39adaf172dcc211a-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn5","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn5","sourceReviewIds":["inflation-scope-navigation-proposal","inflation-retained-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c5 expressly contains the phantom target, so broader-to-narrower access to c4 is supported. The matter conditions remain attached only to that model branch.","refs":["c5","c4","u70","n5","n8"]},"noImplicationBeyondTypedQualifiedRoute":true,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:inflation:pn6":{"id":"navigation:inflation:pn6","source":"q025-candidate-question:144691c70786c15357e04bcf","target":"q025-candidate-question:34990732591a1b91983b1849","type":"narrower","title":"Isolate the Gauss–Bonnet phantom branch","qualification":"Select u70's multifield Gauss–Bonnet analysis, with its stated dark-matter conditions. u69's turning-dark-energy model remains a distinct question and receives no automatic phantom, dark-matter or stability conclusion.","rationale":"The same c4 destination is reached from the late-acceleration comparison; a second public phantom definition is unnecessary.","evidenceIds":["unit:ec32c018b6b28fb4ac93c87da80d24b9ccbb1ccf46209fcd375882c5f51c1dfe","unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:144691c70786c15357e04bcf"},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-431e39adaf172dcc211a-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:34990732591a1b91983b1849"},{"localRef":"u69","kind":"description","unitIndex":43,"unitId":"unit:ec32c018b6b28fb4ac93c87da80d24b9ccbb1ccf46209fcd375882c5f51c1dfe","textSha256":"56ab1d5e5d9940b1ba6946506a5ce36fbb6ded84bc67e98d4ca1f725fd46e1cc"},{"localRef":"u70","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","textSha256":"78cb7d616db1242c87b4506921af36e198b09b50c8ca953c7f04499bc7585e82"},{"localRef":"n61","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ec32c018b6b28fb4ac93c87da80d24b9ccbb1ccf46209fcd375882c5f51c1dfe","reviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n63","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","reviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn6","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn6","sourceReviewIds":["inflation-scope-navigation-proposal","inflation-retained-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The second broader-to-narrower route correctly reaches the same c4 definition. It preserves u69 as a distinct turning target without phantom, dark-matter or stability conclusions.","refs":["c6","c4","u69","u70","n61","n63"]},"noImplicationBeyondTypedQualifiedRoute":true,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:inflation:pn7":{"id":"navigation:inflation:pn7","source":"q025-candidate-question:528990f28c3ccba6d5d8b47d","target":"q025-candidate-question:144691c70786c15357e04bcf","type":"comparison","title":"Compare inflationary turning with turning dark energy","qualification":"Compare the early- and late-universe questions while retaining their source-specific metrics and targets. A metric differing from the flat polar example does not fix its curvature sign. Inflationary attractors, fluctuation formulas and observational tests are not transferred.","rationale":"c6 explicitly allows comparison with inflationary turning methods, and the supplied descriptions identify the changed epoch without establishing stronger physical relations.","evidenceIds":["unit:a373f914c70791b9711cbeaeb950a55f37271b4df6a6d4ee136f93b4835c8e0b","unit:ec32c018b6b28fb4ac93c87da80d24b9ccbb1ccf46209fcd375882c5f51c1dfe"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:528990f28c3ccba6d5d8b47d"},{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:144691c70786c15357e04bcf"},{"localRef":"u52","kind":"description","unitIndex":75,"unitId":"unit:a373f914c70791b9711cbeaeb950a55f37271b4df6a6d4ee136f93b4835c8e0b","textSha256":"7c342ba751e8d593f5da5c663b785b2e7c735997d9b4b61ffed701302f868ec4"},{"localRef":"n31","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:a373f914c70791b9711cbeaeb950a55f37271b4df6a6d4ee136f93b4835c8e0b","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u69","kind":"description","unitIndex":43,"unitId":"unit:ec32c018b6b28fb4ac93c87da80d24b9ccbb1ccf46209fcd375882c5f51c1dfe","textSha256":"56ab1d5e5d9940b1ba6946506a5ce36fbb6ded84bc67e98d4ca1f725fd46e1cc"},{"localRef":"n61","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ec32c018b6b28fb4ac93c87da80d24b9ccbb1ccf46209fcd375882c5f51c1dfe","reviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn7","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn7","sourceReviewIds":["inflation-scope-navigation-proposal","inflation-retained-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The comparison is explicitly allowed by c6 and supported by the two descriptions. No stronger application relation is established; metric change alone does not fix curvature sign.","refs":["c1","c6","u52","n31","u69","n61"]},"noImplicationBeyondTypedQualifiedRoute":true,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:inflation:pn8":{"id":"navigation:inflation:pn8","source":"q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae","target":"q025-candidate-question:8d27c10725a1f68d46910a02","type":"related_question","title":"Follow a scalar–gravity model beyond inflation","qualification":"Use this route only for matching scalar–gravity systems. In u31, the Einstein term is retained and adding a potential is a proposed intervention tied to perturbative repair and later Einstein-dominated evolution. An inflationary fit does not establish reheating success or a universal later history.","rationale":"The supplied compound description connects the temporal questions while c5 preserves its distinct reheating, stiff-era, GR-attraction and dark-energy targets.","evidenceIds":["unit:5920fd499acb284d4ee6bc42afe33c003bc6ef4e1eaed3f34ce4e68d8697000b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae"},{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8d27c10725a1f68d46910a02"},{"localRef":"u31","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:5920fd499acb284d4ee6bc42afe33c003bc6ef4e1eaed3f34ce4e68d8697000b","textSha256":"3fc2049e9cda0c05c77f0cf6be86abdeb89ec1495ac53c05d47d1373eb1ba003"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:5920fd499acb284d4ee6bc42afe33c003bc6ef4e1eaed3f34ce4e68d8697000b","reviewId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn8","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn8","sourceReviewIds":["inflation-scope-navigation-proposal","inflation-retained-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"u31 supports a conditional reading path between temporal targets. related_question is appropriate because the packet supplies neither universal containment nor a demonstrated postinflationary solution.","refs":["c3","c5","u31","n0"]},"noImplicationBeyondTypedQualifiedRoute":true,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-inflation:route:pn8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:amplitude:pn0":{"id":"navigation:amplitude:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-question:1255f0086476b4077b7bf5f5","target":"q025-candidate-question:0e226d69a7c3bb82fb9345a2","type":"narrower","title":"Follow higher-point N=4 constraints toward Veneziano selection","qualification":"Restrict to weakly coupled, non-gravitational planar 4d EFTs with leading N=4 SYM, unbroken SU(4), massless-pole factorization and parity-even six-scalar amplitudes. Numerical selection additionally requires unitarity, analyticity, a nonzero gap and A4/s² → 0 at large |s| for fixed u < 0 or t < 0. The candidate includes four-gluon prefactors; uniqueness is unproved.","rationale":"c3 explicitly includes this restricted amplitude question. Both original descriptions now lead to pq0 without duplicating the destination.","evidenceIds":["unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1255f0086476b4077b7bf5f5"},{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-435f493b9a3a1b52277e-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:39594f3f2592c9816c879036"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:44cfc530ee4b7053d438805d"},{"localRef":"u33","kind":"description","unitIndex":52,"unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","textSha256":"3d464c9fb911fe316295724edc7094ae506fb7b3517c74df194d4471723e49e9"},{"localRef":"n34","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","reviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:10a01e71dc991bacbaf37e301a29c8f5","paperId":"2601.11705","sourceSha256":"da326530747833518ef0fc44a14848fdfcf9bcf23bd33aaaf65a89cdeffb8485","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/589fd5fd280d2a8b6ee1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dfcba77d881caf3c32896059699ebb797769c8352e2821b319ff7eefdfadba9f","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":3315,"textSha256":"eccce786b44cc1c7f26e93f6a7a501bfaa17af84af93f2256c5ee4d29b357457","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a36f7023155baf18c1256ccae937f352","paperId":"2601.11705","sourceSha256":"da326530747833518ef0fc44a14848fdfcf9bcf23bd33aaaf65a89cdeffb8485","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/589fd5fd280d2a8b6ee1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dfcba77d881caf3c32896059699ebb797769c8352e2821b319ff7eefdfadba9f","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2882,"textSha256":"e5758dd406a4f2fe57cfc19dc9a1cc90596f247efd25ab2e5f56ac332ec2cd76","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-amplitude:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","originalOutgoingTitle":"Follow higher-point N=4 constraints toward Veneziano selection","sourceReviewIds":["amplitude-navigation-original-proposal","amplitude-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Retain value-identically. The direction is correctly broader c3 to narrower pq0. c3 explicitly includes this question; e0/e2 support the displayed system, two stages, exact falloff, four-gluon candidate and parity boundary. The route does not claim verified uniqueness.","refs":["c3","c0","c1","u33","n34","e0","e2"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-amplitude:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:amplitude:pn1":{"id":"navigation:amplitude:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac","target":"q025-candidate-question:0e226d69a7c3bb82fb9345a2","type":"narrower","title":"Combine dispersive bounds with independent N=4 coefficient relations","qualification":"This is c4's selected supersymmetric EFT branch. Symmetry, higher-point factorization and six-scalar parity first constrain coefficients without any UV-existence assumption. Only the later bootstrap adds unitarity, analyticity, a nonzero gap and the fixed-negative-u-or-t A4/s² falloff. The output remains numerical evidence for the gluon-prefactored Veneziano amplitude.","rationale":"c4 includes conditional combinations with independent symmetry constraints, and n77 supplies the exact specialization attribution. Parent navigation does not impose dispersion premises on the first stage.","evidenceIds":["unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:44cfc530ee4b7053d438805d"},{"localRef":"u33","kind":"description","unitIndex":52,"unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","textSha256":"3d464c9fb911fe316295724edc7094ae506fb7b3517c74df194d4471723e49e9"},{"localRef":"n77","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","reviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:10a01e71dc991bacbaf37e301a29c8f5","paperId":"2601.11705","sourceSha256":"da326530747833518ef0fc44a14848fdfcf9bcf23bd33aaaf65a89cdeffb8485","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/589fd5fd280d2a8b6ee1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dfcba77d881caf3c32896059699ebb797769c8352e2821b319ff7eefdfadba9f","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":3315,"textSha256":"eccce786b44cc1c7f26e93f6a7a501bfaa17af84af93f2256c5ee4d29b357457","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a36f7023155baf18c1256ccae937f352","paperId":"2601.11705","sourceSha256":"da326530747833518ef0fc44a14848fdfcf9bcf23bd33aaaf65a89cdeffb8485","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/589fd5fd280d2a8b6ee1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dfcba77d881caf3c32896059699ebb797769c8352e2821b319ff7eefdfadba9f","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2882,"textSha256":"e5758dd406a4f2fe57cfc19dc9a1cc90596f247efd25ab2e5f56ac332ec2cd76","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-amplitude:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","originalOutgoingTitle":"Combine dispersive bounds with independent N=4 coefficient relations","sourceReviewIds":["amplitude-navigation-original-proposal","amplitude-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Retain value-identically. The direction is broader c4 to narrower pq0, supported by c4's explicit independent-symmetry combinations and n77's exact mapping. Its qualification protects the UV-independent first stage and limits dispersive assumptions to the later numerical bootstrap.","refs":["c4","c1","u33","n77","e0","e2"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-amplitude:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:amplitude:pn2":{"id":"navigation:amplitude:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-question:0e226d69a7c3bb82fb9345a2","target":"q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6","type":"comparison","title":"Compare amplitude selection with gravitational string realizability","qualification":"The starting question is nongravitational and concerns conditional numerical four-point selection. The destination concerns necessary gravitational consistency tests and dated string-construction comparisons in specified classes. Its restricted six-dimensional conjecture and source-specific probe assumptions remain separate; no amplitude result proves gravitational universality.","rationale":"n34 explicitly supports a comparison between u33 and c2. The route compares research questions without asserting containment or equivalent physical statements.","evidenceIds":["unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6"},{"localRef":"u33","kind":"description","unitIndex":52,"unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","textSha256":"3d464c9fb911fe316295724edc7094ae506fb7b3517c74df194d4471723e49e9"},{"localRef":"n34","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","reviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:10a01e71dc991bacbaf37e301a29c8f5","paperId":"2601.11705","sourceSha256":"da326530747833518ef0fc44a14848fdfcf9bcf23bd33aaaf65a89cdeffb8485","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/589fd5fd280d2a8b6ee1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dfcba77d881caf3c32896059699ebb797769c8352e2821b319ff7eefdfadba9f","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":3315,"textSha256":"eccce786b44cc1c7f26e93f6a7a501bfaa17af84af93f2256c5ee4d29b357457","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a36f7023155baf18c1256ccae937f352","paperId":"2601.11705","sourceSha256":"da326530747833518ef0fc44a14848fdfcf9bcf23bd33aaaf65a89cdeffb8485","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/589fd5fd280d2a8b6ee1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dfcba77d881caf3c32896059699ebb797769c8352e2821b319ff7eefdfadba9f","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2882,"textSha256":"e5758dd406a4f2fe57cfc19dc9a1cc90596f247efd25ab2e5f56ac332ec2cd76","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-amplitude:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","originalOutgoingTitle":"Compare amplitude selection with gravitational string realizability","sourceReviewIds":["amplitude-navigation-original-proposal","amplitude-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Retain value-identically. n34 supports this particular comparison arc to c2, not containment or application. The qualification preserves the nongravitational/gravitational distinction, c2's restricted conjectures and the lack of a universality inference.","refs":["c2","u33","n34","e0","e2"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-amplitude:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:amplitude:pn3":{"id":"navigation:amplitude:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6","target":"q025-candidate-question:1255f0086476b4077b7bf5f5","type":"comparison","title":"Compare string coefficient minima with proposed consistency bounds","qualification":"The concrete example is leading four-graviton coefficients in toroidally compactified type II theory in D=6,7,8. Reported minima motivate future sharp-unitarity-bound tests; they are not established universal bounds or a completeness result. This route uses description and inherited attribution evidence.","rationale":"u58 addresses the amplitude question and has a comparison role for gravitational consistency, providing a concrete connection between the retained scopes.","evidenceIds":["unit:c36a13fa2e8f6f1b1a64356c5688076b9b3955e66e39be67305e17db285e8b6a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6"},{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1255f0086476b4077b7bf5f5"},{"localRef":"u58","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:c36a13fa2e8f6f1b1a64356c5688076b9b3955e66e39be67305e17db285e8b6a","textSha256":"af64b280279741b2938197cae037323922de0586cf6b8ff4123670a019cfe8e4"},{"localRef":"n29","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c36a13fa2e8f6f1b1a64356c5688076b9b3955e66e39be67305e17db285e8b6a","reviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-amplitude:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","originalOutgoingTitle":"Compare string coefficient minima with proposed consistency bounds","sourceReviewIds":["amplitude-navigation-original-proposal","amplitude-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Retain value-identically. u58's whole description and n29's mapped roles support the concrete c2-to-c3 comparison. Its qualification correctly confines the minima to toroidal type II theory in D=6,7,8 and treats sharp-bound testing as prospective. No fresh primary verification is implied.","refs":["c2","c3","u58","n29"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-amplitude:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:amplitude:pn4":{"id":"navigation:amplitude:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-question:1255f0086476b4077b7bf5f5","target":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac","type":"comparison","title":"Compare symmetry and factorization constraints with dispersive bounds","qualification":"The overlap is selected amplitude-coefficient questions. KLT constructions, counterterm soft tests and arithmetic inequalities retain their own targets. Dispersive bounds retain source-specific growth, infrared, polarization and symmetry conditions; positivity-only and full nonlinear unitarity are distinct, and neither universal boundedness nor general transfer to gravity follows.","rationale":"The definitions support complementary constraint programs and a shared narrower destination pq0, while preserving their different complete scopes.","evidenceIds":["unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","unit:c65404fc057a90ba747ce597c19b5f1f6479733e17169c31d2f460c7438a3b66"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1255f0086476b4077b7bf5f5"},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5a5e811b1dce2d3684f2a0ac"},{"localRef":"u33","kind":"description","unitIndex":52,"unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","textSha256":"3d464c9fb911fe316295724edc7094ae506fb7b3517c74df194d4471723e49e9"},{"localRef":"n34","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","reviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n77","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:68e6e000f88a2ca2427c173df89b3e3f031bf8dd7227fbc421005f909a3a5e7f","reviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u59","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:c65404fc057a90ba747ce597c19b5f1f6479733e17169c31d2f460c7438a3b66","textSha256":"41dad4abdce2d9b077bfc8a9361583fec0fc1bdc253a200bc5ce78e4ce787c8a"},{"localRef":"n68","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c65404fc057a90ba747ce597c19b5f1f6479733e17169c31d2f460c7438a3b66","reviewId":"leaf-7ffba6ee241f0310c173-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-amplitude:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","originalOutgoingTitle":"Compare symmetry and factorization constraints with dispersive bounds","sourceReviewIds":["amplitude-navigation-original-proposal","amplitude-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Retain value-identically. The definitions and u33's mapped roles support comparison of the two constraint programs through a shared narrower question. c4 and u59/n68 support the cautions about nonlinear unitarity and unbounded directions; the arc supplies neither nesting nor unrestricted gravitational transfer.","refs":["c3","c4","u33","n34","n77","u59","n68"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-amplitude:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn0":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-region:7961ee3cebdb154299e78b58","target":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","type":"narrower","title":"Explore dark-matter candidates and their cosmic origins","qualification":"Reuse the existing candidate scope; inclusion is not certification of current viability or coverage of every compact-object proposal.","rationale":"Candidate construction and model–search connections form a defined direction within the dark-sector family.","evidenceIds":["unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:7961ee3cebdb154299e78b58"},{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"},{"localRef":"n13","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","reviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge"},{"localRef":"n14","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","reviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge"},{"localRef":"u3","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","textSha256":"ae6e861847a51d6e2b3ea57d2182d19c804e9babb1adbe0ae6fc919cc382a708"},{"localRef":"u4","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","textSha256":"ec963c07f2ae2c7386b3649f2be5efbe6ed1c6b84636e639cdcffcbbd508aba9"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","originalOutgoingTitle":"Explore dark-matter candidates and their cosmic origins","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The direction is broader region to the existing narrower candidate question; the viability and compact-object qualifications prevent scope inflation.","refs":["c9","c6","n13","n14"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn1":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-region:7961ee3cebdb154299e78b58","target":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","type":"narrower","title":"Explore extra dimensions and conditional consistency tests","qualification":"Construction, background and conjecture assumptions remain local to each branch.","rationale":"The family explicitly accommodates extra-dimensional dark sectors and conditional gravitational tests.","evidenceIds":["unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:7961ee3cebdb154299e78b58"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"},{"localRef":"n14","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","reviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge"},{"localRef":"u4","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","textSha256":"ec963c07f2ae2c7386b3649f2be5efbe6ed1c6b84636e639cdcffcbbd508aba9"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","originalOutgoingTitle":"Explore extra dimensions and conditional consistency tests","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The exact region accommodates the narrower construction branch while leaving conjectures and backgrounds local.","refs":["c9","c7","n14"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn2":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-region:7961ee3cebdb154299e78b58","target":"q025-candidate-question:62dacb9af0517b2a3ba9ed97","type":"narrower","title":"What lets a relic persist, and what depletes it?","qualification":"Keep collective annihilation, PBH evaporation and discharge, and KK cascades distinct; some constrained relics need not supply dark matter.","rationale":"The existing survival question provides the shared persistence direction without identifying mechanisms.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","unit:82d977a4365b8f5f3f0ee2447b7369235538e893bf9f106c1abd635ed12cecd5"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:7961ee3cebdb154299e78b58"},{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:62dacb9af0517b2a3ba9ed97"},{"localRef":"n15","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:82d977a4365b8f5f3f0ee2447b7369235538e893bf9f106c1abd635ed12cecd5","reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge"},{"localRef":"n16","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge"},{"localRef":"u6","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:82d977a4365b8f5f3f0ee2447b7369235538e893bf9f106c1abd635ed12cecd5","textSha256":"09d8138257810d38687712fa8cf65b601352bc5c8220478d45c128f25da1e5f2"},{"localRef":"u1","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","textSha256":"b15227ab24b6d9e9aa2221056c9eaf81216f3e71f3bd75f708ef906dd9496512"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","originalOutgoingTitle":"What lets a relic persist, and what depletes it?","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The region's persistence target supports this narrower direction; the explicit mechanism distinctions avoid a common-stabilization claim.","refs":["c9","c8","n15","n16"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn3":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","target":"q025-candidate-question:f19bee7b8e7cec3d7887c150","type":"related_question","title":"How is the candidate's abundance and momentum distribution produced?","qualification":"Thermal contact, equilibrium, stability and initial conditions remain source-specific. The production overview also includes systems beyond the candidate overview.","rationale":"Candidate origins lead to the existing production target without requiring scope equivalence or containment.","evidenceIds":["unit:445345e93a3ef6cbc1c9b1829cfd7ac8458ba81e309410ba379da6198af25151","unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"},{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f19bee7b8e7cec3d7887c150"},{"localRef":"n9","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:445345e93a3ef6cbc1c9b1829cfd7ac8458ba81e309410ba379da6198af25151","reviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"},{"localRef":"n11","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac","reviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"},{"localRef":"u2","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:445345e93a3ef6cbc1c9b1829cfd7ac8458ba81e309410ba379da6198af25151","textSha256":"74aedec539dc81858817f658c25445d9e60f41898b5b4a3f5f79bf41ccc8b6f9"},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac","textSha256":"a1ba9f6015de8de7f002b1b06f65007425ff9bf6ecc6517bf3be86de2ad125ff"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","originalOutgoingTitle":"How is the candidate's abundance and momentum distribution produced?","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Origins and production are connected, but differing system breadth justifies related_question rather than containment.","refs":["c6","c5","n9","n11"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn4":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","target":"q025-candidate-question:62dacb9af0517b2a3ba9ed97","type":"related_question","title":"Can the proposed population survive its later evolution?","qualification":"An initial abundance does not establish persistence; the destination also covers populations that are not dark matter.","rationale":"Candidate construction and later survival are connected but separate questions.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","unit:82d977a4365b8f5f3f0ee2447b7369235538e893bf9f106c1abd635ed12cecd5"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"},{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:62dacb9af0517b2a3ba9ed97"},{"localRef":"n14","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","reviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge"},{"localRef":"n15","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:82d977a4365b8f5f3f0ee2447b7369235538e893bf9f106c1abd635ed12cecd5","reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge"},{"localRef":"n16","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge"},{"localRef":"u4","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","textSha256":"ec963c07f2ae2c7386b3649f2be5efbe6ed1c6b84636e639cdcffcbbd508aba9"},{"localRef":"u6","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:82d977a4365b8f5f3f0ee2447b7369235538e893bf9f106c1abd635ed12cecd5","textSha256":"09d8138257810d38687712fa8cf65b601352bc5c8220478d45c128f25da1e5f2"},{"localRef":"u1","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","textSha256":"b15227ab24b6d9e9aa2221056c9eaf81216f3e71f3bd75f708ef906dd9496512"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","originalOutgoingTitle":"Can the proposed population survive its later evolution?","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The route separates construction and initial abundance from later persistence, including populations that are not dark matter.","refs":["c6","c8","n14","n15","n16"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn5":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn5","source":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","target":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","type":"premise_check","title":"Check extra-dimensional assumptions where invoked","qualification":"Follow this check only for candidates invoking the specified constructions or gravitational hypotheses; ordinary candidates acquire no such premise.","rationale":"The existing definitions support a conditional construction check, not a universal quantum-gravity test.","evidenceIds":["unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"},{"localRef":"n14","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","reviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge"},{"localRef":"u4","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","textSha256":"ec963c07f2ae2c7386b3649f2be5efbe6ed1c6b84636e639cdcffcbbd508aba9"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn5","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn5","originalOutgoingTitle":"Which extra-dimensional assumptions does this candidate require?","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"This remains a conditional premise check for the specified candidates. It neither imposes c7 on all candidates nor asserts a new conjectural implication.","refs":["c6","c7","n14","u4"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":true,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn6":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn6","source":"q025-candidate-question:f19bee7b8e7cec3d7887c150","target":"q-kk-graviton-thermal-production","type":"narrower","title":"Can a hot Standard Model brane populate a KK tower?","qualification":"Use the fixed Dark Dimension production assumptions, including specified temperature and bulk population. No production integral or later survival is verified.","rationale":"This is the source-specific gravitational production branch of the existing abundance question.","evidenceIds":["unit:be7aae21bb2419d0869faff0e2d1c1e653b0e8e75d40ce2e657fb8fb7495284a","unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f19bee7b8e7cec3d7887c150"},{"localRef":"c10","kind":"admitted_scope","candidateId":"q-kk-graviton-thermal-production"},{"localRef":"n11","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac","reviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac","textSha256":"a1ba9f6015de8de7f002b1b06f65007425ff9bf6ecc6517bf3be86de2ad125ff"},{"localRef":"u9","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:be7aae21bb2419d0869faff0e2d1c1e653b0e8e75d40ce2e657fb8fb7495284a","textSha256":"d9fc482c4e4edaf9b5e3f5a8913f61a8f87a9b9997d8900b9abbc8907049ef1c"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:98101f0d696c278269902e9cbb5320e0","paperId":"2311.05318","sourceSha256":"5e86e533b2f8f00ae0864f03f12ce5d448bac05c49793705c07efa39bc149903","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fab9bf3fee6db124cc91/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bba1f3f7366677016355706e27db014e6ad9156af892761f097b3ed5a48c5014","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f0e4c6eec8d6d63ebf4b8ca921034d36a649eb3ac4b7d8e95c99a321fe6d2a37","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn6","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn6","originalOutgoingTitle":"Can a hot Standard Model brane populate a KK tower?","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The narrower hot-brane target fits the existing production overview; both initial-state specificity and absence of an independently checked production integral are retained.","refs":["c5","c10","n11","u14","e10"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn7":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn7","source":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","target":"q-kk-graviton-thermal-production","type":"narrower","title":"Study hot-brane production in the Dark Dimension setup","qualification":"The route concerns one specified construction and its initial abundance, not every compactification or a demonstrated dark-energy mechanism.","rationale":"The extra-dimensional and dark-relic production entries converge on the same fixed scientific destination.","evidenceIds":["unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"},{"localRef":"c10","kind":"admitted_scope","candidateId":"q-kk-graviton-thermal-production"},{"localRef":"n11","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac","reviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac","textSha256":"a1ba9f6015de8de7f002b1b06f65007425ff9bf6ecc6517bf3be86de2ad125ff"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:98101f0d696c278269902e9cbb5320e0","paperId":"2311.05318","sourceSha256":"5e86e533b2f8f00ae0864f03f12ce5d448bac05c49793705c07efa39bc149903","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fab9bf3fee6db124cc91/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bba1f3f7366677016355706e27db014e6ad9156af892761f097b3ed5a48c5014","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f0e4c6eec8d6d63ebf4b8ca921034d36a649eb3ac4b7d8e95c99a321fe6d2a37","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn7","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn7","originalOutgoingTitle":"Study hot-brane production in the Dark Dimension setup","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Specified extra-dimensional abundance is within c7. Reusing c10 provides convergence without extending its construction or claiming a dark-energy mechanism.","refs":["c7","c10","n11","u14","e10"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn8":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn8","source":"q025-candidate-question:62dacb9af0517b2a3ba9ed97","target":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","type":"narrower","title":"Can KK cascades preserve a relic population?","qualification":"Retain the threshold, dark-matter-viability and non-dark-matter freeze-in components, with separate flat and warped qualifications.","rationale":"The compound KK question is the existing survival overview's focused tower branch.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:62dacb9af0517b2a3ba9ed97"},{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"},{"localRef":"n16","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge"},{"localRef":"u1","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","textSha256":"b15227ab24b6d9e9aa2221056c9eaf81216f3e71f3bd75f708ef906dd9496512"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fac9569d8f192e54850486112c7fe0d8","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f047caa6711ddcf0dab834ac0976f6f55b1f49660dd4bcadb530252e9ef74864","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn8","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn8","originalOutgoingTitle":"Can KK cascades preserve a relic population?","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c8 explicitly includes the compound KK survival branch. A narrower route captures all of c3 more accurately than making its threshold component a premise for unrelated survival mechanisms.","refs":["c8","c3","n16","e6","e8"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn9":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn9","source":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","target":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay","type":"narrower","title":"Isolate the near-threshold decay law","qualification":"Keep daughter-momentum scaling separate from a summed cascade history. The reported p^5 rate and its stated domain are not a certified universal theorem.","rationale":"The fixed threshold question exposes one component while c3 retains its cosmological targets.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"},{"localRef":"c11","kind":"admitted_scope","candidateId":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay"},{"localRef":"n3","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},{"localRef":"u11","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","textSha256":"9106a842c07c887daa181d76dfb11f0af970dcc414acc0eae0997cf771d0bf97"},{"localRef":"u1","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","textSha256":"b15227ab24b6d9e9aa2221056c9eaf81216f3e71f3bd75f708ef906dd9496512"},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c8544b384a261048a1203da39609d23f","paperId":"2609.36234","sourceSha256":"c00cd25b0bd7453e4396e5019fbd50ef9668863dcbdaf265fd05ec9ba35c9df8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/859136b54d28aa532422/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6717dc406ef79136d2ceb3c1da6f4bb7a0f4790d46edc1eef7d2699d369418e9","pdfPage":1,"start":1294,"end":4696,"textSha256":"0c9461b7861efa5ebfb648899dd483a90d792edf40ae01026eaba2c630a745e5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn9","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn9","originalOutgoingTitle":"Isolate the near-threshold decay law","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn9","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The compound question can lead to its focused threshold component. Momentum versus parent-mass scaling, partial rate versus history and the unverified generality boundary remain explicit.","refs":["c3","c11","n3","n4","e3","e5","e7"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn10":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn10","source":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","target":"q-flat-darkdimension-freezein-bounds","type":"narrower","title":"What bounds remain if KK gravitons are not the dark matter?","qualification":"The fixed destination assumes a flat dimension, specified freeze-in and visible decays, and applicable reheating floors. Its radius exclusion remains attributed.","rationale":"The non-dark-matter irreducible population is a separate component of the compound question.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"},{"localRef":"c13","kind":"admitted_scope","candidateId":"q-flat-darkdimension-freezein-bounds"},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},{"localRef":"n16","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge"},{"localRef":"u1","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","textSha256":"b15227ab24b6d9e9aa2221056c9eaf81216f3e71f3bd75f708ef906dd9496512"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fac9569d8f192e54850486112c7fe0d8","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f047caa6711ddcf0dab834ac0976f6f55b1f49660dd4bcadb530252e9ef74864","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn10","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn10","originalOutgoingTitle":"What bounds remain if KK gravitons are not the dark matter?","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn10","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The flat freeze-in component is explicit in c3 and the source. The route retains the thermal, coupling and reheating conditions and does not require KK dark matter.","refs":["c3","c13","n4","n16","e6","e8"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn10","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn11":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn11","source":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","target":"q025-candidate-question:fc582eff749d1936943465cf","type":"related_question","title":"How do stars test KK production and extra dimensions?","qualification":"Stellar cooling need not assume KK dark matter. Preserve different dimension counts, uncertain pion inputs and the distinction between energy loss and later visible decays.","rationale":"This supplies a concrete observational direction without treating the construction overview as an underlying production method.","evidenceIds":["unit:bd8c5b9a8b57126b3ca4cd9f8f106d4a591051d19ace30fd62d33141efb25f60"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fc582eff749d1936943465cf"},{"localRef":"n2","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:bd8c5b9a8b57126b3ca4cd9f8f106d4a591051d19ace30fd62d33141efb25f60","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},{"localRef":"u8","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:bd8c5b9a8b57126b3ca4cd9f8f106d4a591051d19ace30fd62d33141efb25f60","textSha256":"f591ef39e476db08dadb1faa2c20ee22ad3c9b44b6ddfeded63c0bc33c310518"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2b94db04ccf99bdc785b41c697bfd856","paperId":"2510.18975","sourceSha256":"3e4ce35f2d73da3253f0da40340d2f85f5ffdf31274b7a5f05a9a3d5fb1e9228","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cf8e11b67887a4778108/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"51c770ce0e52c321a63c001c4e033bfac682be4ab8a7fd59c679fe68c9704d64","pdfPage":3,"start":1297,"end":3877,"textSha256":"8c4729b9e2a918fc3846c94db34fa0468fd366384cf9f9b4ced57dfb20439ac5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d661ead3766893948a5981337e6c2698","paperId":"2510.18975","sourceSha256":"3e4ce35f2d73da3253f0da40340d2f85f5ffdf31274b7a5f05a9a3d5fb1e9228","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cf8e11b67887a4778108/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"51c770ce0e52c321a63c001c4e033bfac682be4ab8a7fd59c679fe68c9704d64","pdfPage":3,"start":2496,"end":3877,"textSha256":"36a6524d09677904cd70e8b6900fca5a14891258f008a594d3c2cf8c7891787b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn11","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn11","originalOutgoingTitle":"How do stars test KK production and extra dimensions?","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn11","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Stellar tests are a supported neighboring direction. The route avoids interpreting a broad construction question as an underlying stellar-production method.","refs":["c7","c2","n2","e12","e13"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn11","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn12":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn12","source":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","target":"q025-candidate-question:bdfb6100643885f4cae8dc2f","type":"premise_check","title":"Can the proposed vacuum-energy relation be matched to EFT?","qualification":"Applicable to constructions invoking Λcc ∼ mKK^4. The cutoff prescriptions and UV-sensitive terms remain contested; no family-wide premise is imposed.","rationale":"The native direction correctly points from a conditionally invoked construction relation to its matching question.","evidenceIds":["unit:22463270ddbc42a8a786821c81a569a3926481fb3b7ad73092b1bc863b2db5f0","unit:6ad52e8398308fc98ca01b366cd01e5025d0579ba5a58d45cc7788bd81aeac12"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bdfb6100643885f4cae8dc2f"},{"localRef":"n5","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6ad52e8398308fc98ca01b366cd01e5025d0579ba5a58d45cc7788bd81aeac12","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},{"localRef":"n6","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:22463270ddbc42a8a786821c81a569a3926481fb3b7ad73092b1bc863b2db5f0","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},{"localRef":"u5","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:6ad52e8398308fc98ca01b366cd01e5025d0579ba5a58d45cc7788bd81aeac12","textSha256":"89798d435d40a720a4272589150e743a99ad4492c476e54b4a9fe7aa473c1d04"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:22463270ddbc42a8a786821c81a569a3926481fb3b7ad73092b1bc863b2db5f0","textSha256":"a2568d91d4778dc6c6e46a99deaccdc2031f2e6b7ca55ad2761c347def20e820"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:395329734151d81cb74b1a6b7c14d4ee","paperId":"2309.09330","sourceSha256":"cecae9c41c73d1324ee26e6548208831fbeb9baab92caf08b1dadd70d316b14c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/efd404684ab9ed88278b/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a3783696d35dd8ad1646ff9dbefb9927b52567d242b0fdf7c673178d8832f64d","pdfPage":2,"start":2507,"end":5093,"textSha256":"b17c98bb9ae660c87acf26c8a088e6345d4fd42c103c35852ab4896a1e258e24","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4f3e90f93cda30477cf6c17552807f26","paperId":"2404.10068","sourceSha256":"c6cf10432d750c75a741092b2d218494a7ecc2f827bf6ad47db16fa1f39e5017","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9116e61d02103d4bef1a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de79618274df654126b127e9270189585e21c201bad7a0bfb3c0527c0defbfa1","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"03a27e2c9c2373649b481aba696b9900abcc3d0d819656e618e6d41ca01d90d4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8ed3391da7a08626a741b891425b113b","paperId":"2404.10068","sourceSha256":"c6cf10432d750c75a741092b2d218494a7ecc2f827bf6ad47db16fa1f39e5017","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9116e61d02103d4bef1a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de79618274df654126b127e9270189585e21c201bad7a0bfb3c0527c0defbfa1","pdfPage":3,"start":108,"end":3328,"textSha256":"83998c0e9fc90695d52ca5ad94681df1d89666d5d9fd5723c9beb13c31ceff9c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn12","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn12","originalOutgoingTitle":"Can the proposed vacuum-energy relation be matched to EFT?","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn12","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The direction correctly checks a conditionally invoked matching relation, while the supplied opposing positions remain unresolved.","refs":["c7","c4","n5","n6","e15","e18","e19"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn12","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn13":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn13","source":"q025-candidate-question:6b27590dbc2f3a0722174815","target":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay","type":"premise_check","title":"Does the assumed cascade support these visible-decay bounds?","qualification":"Check the rate in the relevant action and background. The later threshold result does not provide updated energy-deposition, heating, photon or positron constraints.","rationale":"The historical visible-decay calculation assumes tower evolution that depends on intra-tower dynamics.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","unit:e12ca8a5f0ff6c3418a1bad027868db22196d443140dbd0952d62c39ff0d811e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6b27590dbc2f3a0722174815"},{"localRef":"c11","kind":"admitted_scope","candidateId":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e12ca8a5f0ff6c3418a1bad027868db22196d443140dbd0952d62c39ff0d811e","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},{"localRef":"n3","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:e12ca8a5f0ff6c3418a1bad027868db22196d443140dbd0952d62c39ff0d811e","textSha256":"dd80e5b3df75dd00f0563dc81a6afc738b613db12e667b688d3a52d475cef707"},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:64f421dfe96a55d2d045fbd08742a255","paperId":"2307.11048","sourceSha256":"e293aac5117495c4acb5e3a5fdf652c81c9dc4ed2d32624d8430bc61f52abcec","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/87ab740ce7579fffbe8e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"abe6572669f2ca8a3227f2525de829392a44f6544bbe2a3acc2d4db058a1bca9","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"793a7c683ad2ce1bf920c11d8a20917afdb44109a22bc87ceabb1a733a7b8390","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b5844480c05d0d147da2b730a1e57e96","paperId":"2609.36234","sourceSha256":"c00cd25b0bd7453e4396e5019fbd50ef9668863dcbdaf265fd05ec9ba35c9df8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/859136b54d28aa532422/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6717dc406ef79136d2ceb3c1da6f4bb7a0f4790d46edc1eef7d2699d369418e9","pdfPage":2,"start":92,"end":3489,"textSha256":"a1c4bd00a0014d7fbee2b1492d36232d4c08d93e7b2ddcb6db103686ca4031e3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c8544b384a261048a1203da39609d23f","paperId":"2609.36234","sourceSha256":"c00cd25b0bd7453e4396e5019fbd50ef9668863dcbdaf265fd05ec9ba35c9df8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/859136b54d28aa532422/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6717dc406ef79136d2ceb3c1da6f4bb7a0f4790d46edc1eef7d2699d369418e9","pdfPage":1,"start":1294,"end":4696,"textSha256":"0c9461b7861efa5ebfb648899dd483a90d792edf40ae01026eaba2c630a745e5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn13","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn13","originalOutgoingTitle":"Does the assumed cascade support these visible-decay bounds?","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn13","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The historical tower evolution is an explicit input to c0. Its microscopic premise can be checked without transferring a threshold claim into new observational bounds.","refs":["c0","c11","e1","e3","e5","e6"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn13","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn14":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn14","source":"q025-candidate-question:fc582eff749d1936943465cf","target":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay","type":"premise_check","title":"Can intra-tower decays dominate in this stellar setting?","qualification":"This checks only the weakening of later visible-decay limits. Match geometry, field content and threshold regime before transferring a five-dimensional result; no revised cooling bound follows here.","rationale":"The stellar source explicitly conditions weaker visible-decay constraints on dominant intra-tower decays.","evidenceIds":["unit:bd8c5b9a8b57126b3ca4cd9f8f106d4a591051d19ace30fd62d33141efb25f60"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fc582eff749d1936943465cf"},{"localRef":"c11","kind":"admitted_scope","candidateId":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay"},{"localRef":"n2","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:bd8c5b9a8b57126b3ca4cd9f8f106d4a591051d19ace30fd62d33141efb25f60","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},{"localRef":"u8","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:bd8c5b9a8b57126b3ca4cd9f8f106d4a591051d19ace30fd62d33141efb25f60","textSha256":"f591ef39e476db08dadb1faa2c20ee22ad3c9b44b6ddfeded63c0bc33c310518"},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c8544b384a261048a1203da39609d23f","paperId":"2609.36234","sourceSha256":"c00cd25b0bd7453e4396e5019fbd50ef9668863dcbdaf265fd05ec9ba35c9df8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/859136b54d28aa532422/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6717dc406ef79136d2ceb3c1da6f4bb7a0f4790d46edc1eef7d2699d369418e9","pdfPage":1,"start":1294,"end":4696,"textSha256":"0c9461b7861efa5ebfb648899dd483a90d792edf40ae01026eaba2c630a745e5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2b94db04ccf99bdc785b41c697bfd856","paperId":"2510.18975","sourceSha256":"3e4ce35f2d73da3253f0da40340d2f85f5ffdf31274b7a5f05a9a3d5fb1e9228","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cf8e11b67887a4778108/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"51c770ce0e52c321a63c001c4e033bfac682be4ab8a7fd59c679fe68c9704d64","pdfPage":3,"start":1297,"end":3877,"textSha256":"8c4729b9e2a918fc3846c94db34fa0468fd366384cf9f9b4ced57dfb20439ac5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d661ead3766893948a5981337e6c2698","paperId":"2510.18975","sourceSha256":"3e4ce35f2d73da3253f0da40340d2f85f5ffdf31274b7a5f05a9a3d5fb1e9228","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cf8e11b67887a4778108/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"51c770ce0e52c321a63c001c4e033bfac682be4ab8a7fd59c679fe68c9704d64","pdfPage":3,"start":2496,"end":3877,"textSha256":"36a6524d09677904cd70e8b6900fca5a14891258f008a594d3c2cf8c7891787b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn14","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn14","originalOutgoingTitle":"Can intra-tower decays dominate in this stellar setting?","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn14","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The stellar source explicitly conditions weaker visible-decay limits on intra-tower dominance. The applicability qualification is essential because its dimensional scope exceeds the threshold analyses.","refs":["c2","c11","n2","e5","e12","e13"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn14","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn15":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn15","source":"q-kk-decay-linear-cosmology","target":"q025-candidate-question:6b27590dbc2f3a0722174815","type":"comparison","title":"Compare recoil constraints with visible-decay signals","qualification":"Both retain their historical tower assumptions. Linear structure suppression and energy injection constrain different parameter combinations; no combined or updated fit is supplied.","rationale":"The supplied sources distinguish daughter kicks from decay products reaching the Standard Model.","evidenceIds":["unit:be7aae21bb2419d0869faff0e2d1c1e653b0e8e75d40ce2e657fb8fb7495284a","unit:e12ca8a5f0ff6c3418a1bad027868db22196d443140dbd0952d62c39ff0d811e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c12","kind":"admitted_scope","candidateId":"q-kk-decay-linear-cosmology"},{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6b27590dbc2f3a0722174815"},{"localRef":"u9","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:be7aae21bb2419d0869faff0e2d1c1e653b0e8e75d40ce2e657fb8fb7495284a","textSha256":"d9fc482c4e4edaf9b5e3f5a8913f61a8f87a9b9997d8900b9abbc8907049ef1c"},{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:e12ca8a5f0ff6c3418a1bad027868db22196d443140dbd0952d62c39ff0d811e","textSha256":"dd80e5b3df75dd00f0563dc81a6afc738b613db12e667b688d3a52d475cef707"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:07176133fbb03438ee326c621cfff45c","paperId":"2307.11048","sourceSha256":"e293aac5117495c4acb5e3a5fdf652c81c9dc4ed2d32624d8430bc61f52abcec","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/87ab740ce7579fffbe8e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"abe6572669f2ca8a3227f2525de829392a44f6544bbe2a3acc2d4db058a1bca9","pdfPage":5,"start":95,"end":3499,"textSha256":"c691c109ccbe41a4c162d46d678e000cfeba4b68f6d98ff2bf32b080162129ce","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:64f421dfe96a55d2d045fbd08742a255","paperId":"2307.11048","sourceSha256":"e293aac5117495c4acb5e3a5fdf652c81c9dc4ed2d32624d8430bc61f52abcec","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/87ab740ce7579fffbe8e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"abe6572669f2ca8a3227f2525de829392a44f6544bbe2a3acc2d4db058a1bca9","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"793a7c683ad2ce1bf920c11d8a20917afdb44109a22bc87ceabb1a733a7b8390","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b44a6affbfeb029f730888f62100bc93","paperId":"2307.11048","sourceSha256":"e293aac5117495c4acb5e3a5fdf652c81c9dc4ed2d32624d8430bc61f52abcec","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/87ab740ce7579fffbe8e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"abe6572669f2ca8a3227f2525de829392a44f6544bbe2a3acc2d4db058a1bca9","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":1729,"textSha256":"156dc4bb44ac504ade5379a9e877137b6e3a7cd67645f98cc9f885eb0d4a1b5e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2fad585ea0fd6a9e881beb23831ceaa7","paperId":"2311.05318","sourceSha256":"5e86e533b2f8f00ae0864f03f12ce5d448bac05c49793705c07efa39bc149903","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fab9bf3fee6db124cc91/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bba1f3f7366677016355706e27db014e6ad9156af892761f097b3ed5a48c5014","pdfPage":5,"start":92,"end":3490,"textSha256":"61c3e56df1d3e250b6c058bf036fe06e39f281e0111f2c5b8b38423b4af22398","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bbf52e208ce8497a6b71719219ba7d85","paperId":"2311.05318","sourceSha256":"5e86e533b2f8f00ae0864f03f12ce5d448bac05c49793705c07efa39bc149903","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fab9bf3fee6db124cc91/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bba1f3f7366677016355706e27db014e6ad9156af892761f097b3ed5a48c5014","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1673,"textSha256":"7f3a9c3dff1be519144f71674fae6fab4ecf7c7d625152e8fe85d4abbf95c382","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn15","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn15","originalOutgoingTitle":"Compare recoil constraints with visible-decay signals","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn15","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The primary windows distinguish recoil-driven linear suppression from visible energy injection. A comparison supports navigation without a joint fit or common parameter constraint.","refs":["c12","c0","e0","e1","e2","e9","e11"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn15","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn16":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn16","source":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay","target":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","type":"related_question","title":"What does the threshold law mean for KK relic viability?","qualification":"A partial decay rate is not a complete cascade history. Follow the separately qualified dark-matter and freeze-in questions without treating all flat and warped conclusions as identical.","rationale":"This returns from the focused microscopic destination to the preserved compound scientific question.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c11","kind":"admitted_scope","candidateId":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay"},{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"},{"localRef":"n3","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},{"localRef":"u11","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","textSha256":"9106a842c07c887daa181d76dfb11f0af970dcc414acc0eae0997cf771d0bf97"},{"localRef":"u1","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","textSha256":"b15227ab24b6d9e9aa2221056c9eaf81216f3e71f3bd75f708ef906dd9496512"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b5844480c05d0d147da2b730a1e57e96","paperId":"2609.36234","sourceSha256":"c00cd25b0bd7453e4396e5019fbd50ef9668863dcbdaf265fd05ec9ba35c9df8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/859136b54d28aa532422/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6717dc406ef79136d2ceb3c1da6f4bb7a0f4790d46edc1eef7d2699d369418e9","pdfPage":2,"start":92,"end":3489,"textSha256":"a1c4bd00a0014d7fbee2b1492d36232d4c08d93e7b2ddcb6db103686ca4031e3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fac9569d8f192e54850486112c7fe0d8","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f047caa6711ddcf0dab834ac0976f6f55b1f49660dd4bcadb530252e9ef74864","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn16","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn16","originalOutgoingTitle":"What does the threshold law mean for KK relic viability?","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn16","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"This is a useful return from threshold microphysics to the preserved compound question. It asserts no automatic cosmological consequence from a partial decay law.","refs":["c11","c3","n3","n4","e3","e6","e8"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn16","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn17":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn17","source":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","target":"q025-candidate-question:62dacb9af0517b2a3ba9ed97","type":"related_question","title":"Compare other ways relic populations persist or disappear","qualification":"KK cascades, collective charged-field depletion and PBH survival have different mechanisms and assumptions. The route transfers no rate law or exclusion.","rationale":"Return from KK-specific viability to the existing shared survival question.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","unit:82d977a4365b8f5f3f0ee2447b7369235538e893bf9f106c1abd635ed12cecd5"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"},{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:62dacb9af0517b2a3ba9ed97"},{"localRef":"n15","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:82d977a4365b8f5f3f0ee2447b7369235538e893bf9f106c1abd635ed12cecd5","reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge"},{"localRef":"n16","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge"},{"localRef":"u6","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:82d977a4365b8f5f3f0ee2447b7369235538e893bf9f106c1abd635ed12cecd5","textSha256":"09d8138257810d38687712fa8cf65b601352bc5c8220478d45c128f25da1e5f2"},{"localRef":"u1","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","textSha256":"b15227ab24b6d9e9aa2221056c9eaf81216f3e71f3bd75f708ef906dd9496512"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn17","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn17","originalOutgoingTitle":"Compare other ways relic populations persist or disappear","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn17","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The return route compares survival targets while explicitly withholding transfer of mechanisms, rates and exclusions.","refs":["c3","c8","n15","n16","u6","u1"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn17","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn18":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn18","source":"q-kk-graviton-thermal-production","target":"q025-candidate-question:f19bee7b8e7cec3d7887c150","type":"related_question","title":"Compare other ways to produce a dark relic","qualification":"Freeze-out, freeze-in and other nonthermal mechanisms retain distinct interactions, equilibrium conditions and initial histories.","rationale":"Return from the specific hot-brane model to the reused production overview without equating mechanisms that yield an abundance.","evidenceIds":["unit:445345e93a3ef6cbc1c9b1829cfd7ac8458ba81e309410ba379da6198af25151","unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c10","kind":"admitted_scope","candidateId":"q-kk-graviton-thermal-production"},{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f19bee7b8e7cec3d7887c150"},{"localRef":"n9","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:445345e93a3ef6cbc1c9b1829cfd7ac8458ba81e309410ba379da6198af25151","reviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"},{"localRef":"n11","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac","reviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"},{"localRef":"u2","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:445345e93a3ef6cbc1c9b1829cfd7ac8458ba81e309410ba379da6198af25151","textSha256":"74aedec539dc81858817f658c25445d9e60f41898b5b4a3f5f79bf41ccc8b6f9"},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac","textSha256":"a1ba9f6015de8de7f002b1b06f65007425ff9bf6ecc6517bf3be86de2ad125ff"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn18","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn18","originalOutgoingTitle":"Compare other ways to produce a dark relic","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn18","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"A specific production mechanism can return to the existing overview without identifying mechanisms or their thermal assumptions.","refs":["c10","c5","n9","n11","u2","u14"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn18","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn19":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn19","source":"q025-candidate-question:fc582eff749d1936943465cf","target":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","type":"related_question","title":"Which extra-dimensional construction is being tested?","qualification":"Dimension count, geometry and coupling assumptions must be specified; stellar production does not establish a quantum-gravity conjecture or dark-matter interpretation.","rationale":"Return from the stellar observable to the existing construction and consistency questions.","evidenceIds":["unit:bd8c5b9a8b57126b3ca4cd9f8f106d4a591051d19ace30fd62d33141efb25f60"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fc582eff749d1936943465cf"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"},{"localRef":"u8","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:bd8c5b9a8b57126b3ca4cd9f8f106d4a591051d19ace30fd62d33141efb25f60","textSha256":"f591ef39e476db08dadb1faa2c20ee22ad3c9b44b6ddfeded63c0bc33c310518"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2b94db04ccf99bdc785b41c697bfd856","paperId":"2510.18975","sourceSha256":"3e4ce35f2d73da3253f0da40340d2f85f5ffdf31274b7a5f05a9a3d5fb1e9228","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cf8e11b67887a4778108/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"51c770ce0e52c321a63c001c4e033bfac682be4ab8a7fd59c679fe68c9704d64","pdfPage":3,"start":1297,"end":3877,"textSha256":"8c4729b9e2a918fc3846c94db34fa0468fd366384cf9f9b4ced57dfb20439ac5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d661ead3766893948a5981337e6c2698","paperId":"2510.18975","sourceSha256":"3e4ce35f2d73da3253f0da40340d2f85f5ffdf31274b7a5f05a9a3d5fb1e9228","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cf8e11b67887a4778108/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"51c770ce0e52c321a63c001c4e033bfac682be4ab8a7fd59c679fe68c9704d64","pdfPage":3,"start":2496,"end":3877,"textSha256":"36a6524d09677904cd70e8b6900fca5a14891258f008a594d3c2cf8c7891787b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn19","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn19","originalOutgoingTitle":"Which extra-dimensional construction is being tested?","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn19","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The stellar source's dimensional and coupling dependence supports returning to construction questions; this makes no dark-matter or conjectural inference.","refs":["c2","c7","u8","e12","e13"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn19","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn20":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn20","source":"q025-candidate-question:bdfb6100643885f4cae8dc2f","target":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","type":"related_question","title":"Explore the constructions that invoke this matching relation","qualification":"The matching dispute remains unresolved and does not invalidate or validate every extra-dimensional construction.","rationale":"Return from the specific contested relation to the broader source-specific construction questions.","evidenceIds":["unit:22463270ddbc42a8a786821c81a569a3926481fb3b7ad73092b1bc863b2db5f0","unit:6ad52e8398308fc98ca01b366cd01e5025d0579ba5a58d45cc7788bd81aeac12"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bdfb6100643885f4cae8dc2f"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"},{"localRef":"n5","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6ad52e8398308fc98ca01b366cd01e5025d0579ba5a58d45cc7788bd81aeac12","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},{"localRef":"n6","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:22463270ddbc42a8a786821c81a569a3926481fb3b7ad73092b1bc863b2db5f0","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:07f51bb6546d84ffbbf9dfbd7d4c6476","paperId":"2309.09330","sourceSha256":"cecae9c41c73d1324ee26e6548208831fbeb9baab92caf08b1dadd70d316b14c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/efd404684ab9ed88278b/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a3783696d35dd8ad1646ff9dbefb9927b52567d242b0fdf7c673178d8832f64d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"6f242f885061e9e413521979103c5470362a617ea11c635c477482b9b85117e1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:395329734151d81cb74b1a6b7c14d4ee","paperId":"2309.09330","sourceSha256":"cecae9c41c73d1324ee26e6548208831fbeb9baab92caf08b1dadd70d316b14c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/efd404684ab9ed88278b/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a3783696d35dd8ad1646ff9dbefb9927b52567d242b0fdf7c673178d8832f64d","pdfPage":2,"start":2507,"end":5093,"textSha256":"b17c98bb9ae660c87acf26c8a088e6345d4fd42c103c35852ab4896a1e258e24","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1c16a7d968872b0a676ba02947d4e51c","paperId":"2404.10068","sourceSha256":"c6cf10432d750c75a741092b2d218494a7ecc2f827bf6ad47db16fa1f39e5017","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9116e61d02103d4bef1a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de79618274df654126b127e9270189585e21c201bad7a0bfb3c0527c0defbfa1","pdfPage":2,"start":1307,"end":2565,"textSha256":"8f034278bbb9eeaa9ca22438d2ee30b8616073b46b414fc87d5c079713fbbc58","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8ed3391da7a08626a741b891425b113b","paperId":"2404.10068","sourceSha256":"c6cf10432d750c75a741092b2d218494a7ecc2f827bf6ad47db16fa1f39e5017","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9116e61d02103d4bef1a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de79618274df654126b127e9270189585e21c201bad7a0bfb3c0527c0defbfa1","pdfPage":3,"start":108,"end":3328,"textSha256":"83998c0e9fc90695d52ca5ad94681df1d89666d5d9fd5723c9beb13c31ceff9c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn20","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn20","originalOutgoingTitle":"Explore the constructions that invoke this matching relation","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn20","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The specific matching dispute can return to constructions that invoke it, without treating the dispute as an adjudication of all extra dimensions.","refs":["c4","c7","n5","n6","e15","e17","e19"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn20","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:kk:pn21":{"id":"navigation:kk:pn21","source":"q-kk-graviton-thermal-production","target":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","type":"related_question","title":"Revisit the extra-dimensional assumptions behind production","qualification":"This is a return to construction questions, not a claim that all production models require the same conjecture, dimension size or vacuum-energy relation.","rationale":"The shared production destination remains accessible back toward the extra-dimensional entry as well as toward the dark-relic production overview.","evidenceIds":["unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c10","kind":"admitted_scope","candidateId":"q-kk-graviton-thermal-production"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"},{"localRef":"n11","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac","reviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:d5031ab16d8b871bddd917aa4e9de3e7203c9cda1499e4fcfe9a5f463cd4a4ac","textSha256":"a1ba9f6015de8de7f002b1b06f65007425ff9bf6ecc6517bf3be86de2ad125ff"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:98101f0d696c278269902e9cbb5320e0","paperId":"2311.05318","sourceSha256":"5e86e533b2f8f00ae0864f03f12ce5d448bac05c49793705c07efa39bc149903","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fab9bf3fee6db124cc91/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bba1f3f7366677016355706e27db014e6ad9156af892761f097b3ed5a48c5014","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f0e4c6eec8d6d63ebf4b8ca921034d36a649eb3ac4b7d8e95c99a321fe6d2a37","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn21","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn21","originalOutgoingTitle":"Revisit the extra-dimensional assumptions behind production","sourceReviewIds":["kk-navigation-original-proposal","kk-navigation-derived-whole-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn21","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"This supplies the construction-side return from the shared production destination. It is a related-question route, not an asserted universal prerequisite.","refs":["c10","c7","n11","u14","e10"]},"explicitTitleCopyedit":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-kk:route:pn21","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:ads-kk-scale-control:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v2:ads-kk-scale-control:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","target":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","type":"narrower","title":"Can internal KK modes decouple from AdS curvature?","qualification":"Retain dimension, supersymmetry, quantized flux constraints and source treatment. Curvature estimates, selected spectral sectors and large bulk radii do not by themselves certify a complete KK gap or localized control.","rationale":"Selects the region's explicit geometric hierarchy/control target. The current definitions support the route; l0 records the earlier proposal without independently admitting it.","evidenceIds":["unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","unit:566bab49279fecec97511945784f722b340083e352ab4abb2d198fdccce98d3a","unit:e934cddef50d5f6f02086b4afe8ac459732213ee183e490f8ff42289915b405e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3"},{"localRef":"l0","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","candidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:7","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n15","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:566bab49279fecec97511945784f722b340083e352ab4abb2d198fdccce98d3a","reviewId":"leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n19","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e934cddef50d5f6f02086b4afe8ac459732213ee183e490f8ff42289915b405e","reviewId":"leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n20","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","reviewId":"leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:ads-kk-scale-control:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["ads-kk-scale-control-navigation-proposal","ads-kk-scale-control-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The c3-to-c2 direction correctly offers a narrower question about an explicit regional target. Its title is readable, and its qualification preserves flux admissibility, source treatment and the distinction between partial diagnostics and complete spectral/localization control. Support comes from current definitions; l0 supplies historical route context only.","refs":["c3","c2","l0","u5","n15","u15","n19","u4","n20"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:ads-kk-scale-control:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:ads-kk-scale-control:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v2:ads-kk-scale-control:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","target":"q025-candidate-question:746588a70cd01ac07e0ef706","type":"comparison","title":"Which constructions also meet their stabilization requirements?","qualification":"Compare the specified type II, type I, heterotic and modified Freund–Rubin settings in their own dimensions. Preserve each construction's stabilized fields, source charges and coupling regime; geometric KK separation alone does not settle scalar masses or localized control.","rationale":"Offers a construction-focused continuation of the shared hierarchy question while preserving the nonidentical framework coverage and joint requirements.","evidenceIds":["unit:62084b0d512e60bfb6d61b4aef3e8f3ea6cf19f63b1d1d1548f20234b015259e","unit:c9097d30b51c77d81ef95b468fde19333ae785dc0ed19d4ec8eeeba100161de5","unit:f83165e390c51b48339b7b864228eb70d8177255a25415de24ed228e74fa17c0"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:746588a70cd01ac07e0ef706"},{"localRef":"l1","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:746588a70cd01ac07e0ef706","candidateId":"parent-3ad8848c0af01da6b749-challenge:link:13","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:62084b0d512e60bfb6d61b4aef3e8f3ea6cf19f63b1d1d1548f20234b015259e","textSha256":"36408f0410d747de72e35fa9b4098abd470a4559b56b56308061996cb3be5751"},{"localRef":"n7","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:62084b0d512e60bfb6d61b4aef3e8f3ea6cf19f63b1d1d1548f20234b015259e","reviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:c9097d30b51c77d81ef95b468fde19333ae785dc0ed19d4ec8eeeba100161de5","textSha256":"58ed028998cb830021fee4de99776f7fd74273cda21f23e260a049f9ca784412"},{"localRef":"n8","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c9097d30b51c77d81ef95b468fde19333ae785dc0ed19d4ec8eeeba100161de5","reviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u16","kind":"description","unitIndex":60,"unitId":"unit:f83165e390c51b48339b7b864228eb70d8177255a25415de24ed228e74fa17c0","textSha256":"aa2ab0f3636477155a3f147f98be4863ac8a062bbdcfcf90f69ed06d70ca61f9"},{"localRef":"n12","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f83165e390c51b48339b7b864228eb70d8177255a25415de24ed228e74fa17c0","reviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n21","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f83165e390c51b48339b7b864228eb70d8177255a25415de24ed228e74fa17c0","reviewId":"leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:ads-kk-scale-control:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["ads-kk-scale-control-navigation-proposal","ads-kk-scale-control-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The comparison from c2 to c1 offers a useful construction-focused continuation without asserting containment. The destination definition supports its framework range, while the paired notes preserve joint brane-dual requirements, qualified localization and heterotic control limitations. The interrogative title does not claim these requirements have been met.","refs":["c2","c1","l1","u7","n7","u14","n8","u16","n12","n21"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:ads-kk-scale-control:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:ads-kk-scale-control:pn2":{"id":"navigation:v2:ads-kk-scale-control:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","target":"q025-candidate-question:50954f05a9d7ea3b25af096a","type":"comparison","title":"Compare spectral restrictions, M-theory and KKLT candidates","qualification":"Keep c0's AdS3/4 settings and adjacent AdS2 horizon comparison distinct. A light spin-2 mode is a family-specific hierarchy diagnostic; bounds cannot be transferred across changed assumptions, and neither total volume nor a partial spectral test certifies every internal KK scale.","rationale":"Connects the physical-KK question to the overlapping hierarchy/control question with its additional candidate settings and spectral emphasis, without equating their full scopes.","evidenceIds":["unit:2c7ced13a97f845e75bfcb434755ddfb84f873b01a57c46c86773a84846caeef","unit:566bab49279fecec97511945784f722b340083e352ab4abb2d198fdccce98d3a","unit:5c497e6fd82091d7773d87faa5b46919398f100c880cac7f0907b56688d3a775"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3"},{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-04442f0e58623f0db643-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:50954f05a9d7ea3b25af096a"},{"localRef":"l2","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:50954f05a9d7ea3b25af096a","candidateId":"parent-3ad8848c0af01da6b749-challenge:link:14","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:2c7ced13a97f845e75bfcb434755ddfb84f873b01a57c46c86773a84846caeef","textSha256":"70f6c5d61e8f7a81a5a222ef0bc1f7e38a025836b93dc0dd8d731f7370cd2cfc"},{"localRef":"n3","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2c7ced13a97f845e75bfcb434755ddfb84f873b01a57c46c86773a84846caeef","reviewId":"leaf-04442f0e58623f0db643-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u5","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:566bab49279fecec97511945784f722b340083e352ab4abb2d198fdccce98d3a","textSha256":"94d0be0a69d2dc1b2d97ed71569d8471f565e5adc8d0307cd2347db1ea6c9f67"},{"localRef":"n15","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:566bab49279fecec97511945784f722b340083e352ab4abb2d198fdccce98d3a","reviewId":"leaf-ea65aa3aa0acd8b2e111-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u6","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:5c497e6fd82091d7773d87faa5b46919398f100c880cac7f0907b56688d3a775","textSha256":"fd1baa45e4902f159a3448c948839640e8751974b58f3f6b82b50c300d894291"},{"localRef":"n2","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:5c497e6fd82091d7773d87faa5b46919398f100c880cac7f0907b56688d3a775","reviewId":"leaf-04442f0e58623f0db643-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:ads-kk-scale-control:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["ads-kk-scale-control-navigation-proposal","ads-kk-scale-control-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The comparison from c2 to c0 is licensed by their overlapping hierarchy target and c0's explicit M-theory/KKLT and spectral coverage. Its qualification correctly preserves dimensional treatment and family-specific diagnostics without transferring bounds. Reusing those declared settings does not add individual source roles or certify their physical claims.","refs":["c2","c0","l2","u0","n3","u5","n15","u6","n2"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:ads-kk-scale-control:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:axion-vector-production:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v2:axion-vector-production:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-question:891203df753b324531020eb9","target":"q025-candidate-question:42f0331dd20ca2ee24482e63","type":"narrower","title":"Explore very light vector masses","qualification":"Focus on masses poorly populated by the compared inflationary mechanism. The lattice benchmark and reported vector-to-axion mass ratio O(10^-3–1) are scenario-specific; they do not certify every mass or coupling choice.","rationale":"The overview includes this production regime, and the supplied u0 description directly identifies it as a target.","evidenceIds":["unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:891203df753b324531020eb9"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","textSha256":"ca5c3819c6cbef862c59d13f239ce055856b7c7050ee6111942b9c26d9cc48fa"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","reviewId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n2","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","reviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:axion-vector-production:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["axion-vector-production-navigation-proposal","axion-vector-production-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction is correct. u0 identifies the low-mass target already included in c1, while n0 and n2 support the benchmark and mass-ratio qualifications. The title offers a concrete next question without implying quantitative mass reach or validation across all couplings.","refs":["c1","u0","n0","n2"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:axion-vector-production:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:axion-vector-production:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v2:axion-vector-production:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-question:891203df753b324531020eb9","target":"q025-candidate-question:950f397cc22787451c607c3e","type":"narrower","title":"Include required residual-axion depletion","qualification":"Select the construction requiring visible-sector elimination of the residual axion. Domination and subdominance before depletion are alternative histories; depletion is not a universal condition for dominant vector dark matter.","rationale":"This selects an explicitly included construction-dependent thermal-history requirement while keeping production and depletion jointly scoped.","evidenceIds":["unit:28f7540ef75be1abce5689118561e94ac2ec5e9f85c512c6308979a285697197"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:49d3e894f117509cb5f6a9f2"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:891203df753b324531020eb9"},{"localRef":"u1","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:28f7540ef75be1abce5689118561e94ac2ec5e9f85c512c6308979a285697197","textSha256":"7b720543fd97a0b2e3d735ddec0563cf640f0e33ed47eda66e7edfa7247864ec"},{"localRef":"n1","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:28f7540ef75be1abce5689118561e94ac2ec5e9f85c512c6308979a285697197","reviewId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n3","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:28f7540ef75be1abce5689118561e94ac2ec5e9f85c512c6308979a285697197","reviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:axion-vector-production:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["axion-vector-production-navigation-proposal","axion-vector-production-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The route correctly moves from the overview to its depletion-dependent refinement. Its qualification preserves the alternative pre-depletion histories and distinguishes required removal in this construction from the general requirement of dominant vector dark matter.","refs":["c0","c1","u1","n1","n3"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:axion-vector-production:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:axion-vector-production:pn2":{"id":"navigation:v2:axion-vector-production:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-question:42f0331dd20ca2ee24482e63","target":"q025-candidate-question:950f397cc22787451c607c3e","type":"comparison","title":"Compare residual-axion requirements","qualification":"Residual-axion elimination is not imported into the very-light-vector benchmark question; it is explicit in the depletion construction. Shared tachyonic production does not equate their thermal histories or establish quantitative viability across parameter space.","rationale":"The paired attribution notes license a comparison of stated requirements, without a new physical implication or performance claim.","evidenceIds":["unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","unit:28f7540ef75be1abce5689118561e94ac2ec5e9f85c512c6308979a285697197"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","textSha256":"ca5c3819c6cbef862c59d13f239ce055856b7c7050ee6111942b9c26d9cc48fa"},{"localRef":"u1","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:28f7540ef75be1abce5689118561e94ac2ec5e9f85c512c6308979a285697197","textSha256":"7b720543fd97a0b2e3d735ddec0563cf640f0e33ed47eda66e7edfa7247864ec"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","reviewId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n1","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:28f7540ef75be1abce5689118561e94ac2ec5e9f85c512c6308979a285697197","reviewId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n2","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","reviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n3","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:28f7540ef75be1abce5689118561e94ac2ec5e9f85c512c6308979a285697197","reviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:axion-vector-production:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["axion-vector-production-navigation-proposal","axion-vector-production-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The supplied descriptions and paired notes support this directed comparison of stated residual-axion requirements. The route does not claim that depletion is absent from every realization of the low-mass question, nor infer a physical implication or quantitative viability comparison from the shared mechanism.","refs":["u0","u1","n0","n1","n2","n3"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:axion-vector-production:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9","target":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f","type":"narrower","title":"Compute periods, mirror maps and moduli couplings","qualification":"Use the stated hypersurface or complete-intersection families and deformation sectors. Polynomial coverage is not full deformation coverage; moduli-space metrics are distinct from internal Ricci-flat metrics.","rationale":"The existing parent explicitly includes special geometry, and the supplied calculations support this narrower computational direction.","evidenceIds":["unit:05bbd28d938b41d04f3cff01ca15658911eecbbf83ffcc4791b18b3856f6b669","unit:0ab89e9b3e058896b7c2ce5a4532d38d77d794d6b411df04b66072275988539a","unit:394ea8d3adc525d1ea1ed5942e57d7dc169767d9f191f15bf489878004e5cbca","unit:926b345c92affb58b9589a950142ae23a51f3801b52561f92b8ad7ae0109f605"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9"},{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:05bbd28d938b41d04f3cff01ca15658911eecbbf83ffcc4791b18b3856f6b669","textSha256":"412ba6ab5661932d7a1d1ca5603e36f5df8a4f5e9746300a04eab0b19e809065"},{"localRef":"u2","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:0ab89e9b3e058896b7c2ce5a4532d38d77d794d6b411df04b66072275988539a","textSha256":"5f6fbe92bee0cc7d775fd98e46338689a9254e07abf411e5d071dfe0a1cad655"},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:394ea8d3adc525d1ea1ed5942e57d7dc169767d9f191f15bf489878004e5cbca","textSha256":"98ad70d89950b4c84cf2b0ac95048e37fb1e8d5e2765b56846692a460efd4a80"},{"localRef":"u12","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:926b345c92affb58b9589a950142ae23a51f3801b52561f92b8ad7ae0109f605","textSha256":"5d2115398eca83e1eaf90c87de297adc233710300ba1a5196e3e527060542ad2"},{"localRef":"n9","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0ab89e9b3e058896b7c2ce5a4532d38d77d794d6b411df04b66072275988539a","reviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n15","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:05bbd28d938b41d04f3cff01ca15658911eecbbf83ffcc4791b18b3856f6b669","reviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n16","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:926b345c92affb58b9589a950142ae23a51f3801b52561f92b8ad7ae0109f605","reviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n17","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:394ea8d3adc525d1ea1ed5942e57d7dc169767d9f191f15bf489878004e5cbca","reviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l0","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f","candidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:3","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["calabi-yau-periods-and-bps-navigation-proposal","calabi-yau-periods-and-bps-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction follows the explicit definitions. Its title exposes useful computations, while the qualification preserves model and deformation restrictions and the distinction between moduli and internal metrics.","refs":["c4","c3","u0","u2","u7","u12","n9","n15","n16","n17","l0"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9","target":"q025-candidate-question:853de7f0a8e55cb55e507432","type":"narrower","title":"Define and constrain curve invariants","qualification":"Keep local and compact constructions, invariant definitions, genus and refinement separate. Smooth local Fano and suitable singular-surface cases retain different assumptions; subtraction questions do not establish coordinate-independent regularization.","rationale":"Curve invariants and topological amplitudes form an explicit narrower target within c4.","evidenceIds":["unit:3930d3016d5fce2f6edd9af5dfe2beadbfce9dc299691f330b50846041efae6f","unit:cb95eb9c9a2e4dfc478e7da2079600014e592a8c9f790932d740b44550510a13"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:853de7f0a8e55cb55e507432"},{"localRef":"u6","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:3930d3016d5fce2f6edd9af5dfe2beadbfce9dc299691f330b50846041efae6f","textSha256":"12c06bebed06a92fe9fed76ddffaff2287bc050347691b9855d3e5170ca505e1"},{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:cb95eb9c9a2e4dfc478e7da2079600014e592a8c9f790932d740b44550510a13","textSha256":"7f0c73db29bbb19ae442dca7191d75f103e389a18ea7047dab97f3f0b12027e2"},{"localRef":"n12","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:3930d3016d5fce2f6edd9af5dfe2beadbfce9dc299691f330b50846041efae6f","reviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n18","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:cb95eb9c9a2e4dfc478e7da2079600014e592a8c9f790932d740b44550510a13","reviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l1","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:853de7f0a8e55cb55e507432","candidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:4","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["calabi-yau-periods-and-bps-navigation-proposal","calabi-yau-periods-and-bps-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c1 is an explicit narrower direction of c4. The route retains invariant definitions, local-versus-compact scope, genus, refinement and the unresolved coordinate-independence of subtraction.","refs":["c4","c1","u6","u15","n12","n18","l1"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:pn2":{"id":"navigation:v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9","target":"q025-candidate-question:6a9d9c1d809f904f41b8f560","type":"narrower","title":"Compute topological amplitudes and interpret BPS data","qualification":"Preserve each construction's domain: large-Calabi–Yau isolated-sphere assumptions for the cited one-loop interpretation, noncompact toric scope for the vertex, and resolved-conifold scope for the supplied resummation question. Protected amplitudes do not certify general scattering.","rationale":"The existing parent includes topological quantum corrections and protected compactification observables, while c0 supplies their computational and interpretive direction.","evidenceIds":["unit:2ee491ecbe35b797fcf4f5f237cc1e6f3cee0b191b6f6f778ed3ab506fa3d2e9","unit:55609489a8990f86061f49417d67adb04f5a804e4f4a33d9a6aa4031c3123937","unit:d7d23971e1a6ecf64d786f5585d30b1eaaf5a080cbe0a5dc1fd1150396d8bfdc"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9"},{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-02b834cc1fe57554842a-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6a9d9c1d809f904f41b8f560"},{"localRef":"u5","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:2ee491ecbe35b797fcf4f5f237cc1e6f3cee0b191b6f6f778ed3ab506fa3d2e9","textSha256":"e334b7766e6ee7a4f96ed331e84d53f9bf75740c7960ca6ce786b4610d8028a9"},{"localRef":"u10","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:55609489a8990f86061f49417d67adb04f5a804e4f4a33d9a6aa4031c3123937","textSha256":"e838258edbc58a3d658f65cded62609f33acc885c05e8ac61e5d61b7da5eb0a1"},{"localRef":"u16","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:d7d23971e1a6ecf64d786f5585d30b1eaaf5a080cbe0a5dc1fd1150396d8bfdc","textSha256":"b8cfcd85538067b6a628f5dd4a3e80cdab7d72ddf4442f6f6450b556a2ab7cfb"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2ee491ecbe35b797fcf4f5f237cc1e6f3cee0b191b6f6f778ed3ab506fa3d2e9","reviewId":"leaf-02b834cc1fe57554842a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n1","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:d7d23971e1a6ecf64d786f5585d30b1eaaf5a080cbe0a5dc1fd1150396d8bfdc","reviewId":"leaf-02b834cc1fe57554842a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n2","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:55609489a8990f86061f49417d67adb04f5a804e4f4a33d9a6aa4031c3123937","reviewId":"leaf-02b834cc1fe57554842a-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["calabi-yau-periods-and-bps-navigation-proposal","calabi-yau-periods-and-bps-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c4 explicitly includes the amplitude and protected-observable direction. One-loop and vertex restrictions are reused from c0's supported scope; selected descriptions support the counting and conifold branches without extending their domains.","refs":["c4","c0","u5","u10","u16","n0","n1","n2"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:pn3":{"id":"navigation:v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9","target":"q025-candidate-question:af30c367be77504492951c97","type":"narrower","title":"Study periods near degenerations","qualification":"Retain specified deformation families, threefold or fourfold settings and observable-dependent exponential corrections. Formal special geometries remain an alternate realizability comparison, not established compactifications; Hodge-operator components are not a physical small-parameter expansion.","rationale":"Period geometry and degenerations are explicit directions within c4. The formal branch remains a qualified comparison boundary within the destination.","evidenceIds":["unit:0ab89e9b3e058896b7c2ce5a4532d38d77d794d6b411df04b66072275988539a","unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","unit:b4dae808e46351372059513b88c424f8265f556298a35ac21c221330c3405f38"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-9f316e5cd9cfe1d3bd13-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:af30c367be77504492951c97"},{"localRef":"u2","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:0ab89e9b3e058896b7c2ce5a4532d38d77d794d6b411df04b66072275988539a","textSha256":"5f6fbe92bee0cc7d775fd98e46338689a9254e07abf411e5d071dfe0a1cad655"},{"localRef":"u8","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","textSha256":"dca7fd64b03fee3206aca2cb0907fb91afdcc045dcd9fc29e3cb9fe3c26c54ce"},{"localRef":"u13","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:b4dae808e46351372059513b88c424f8265f556298a35ac21c221330c3405f38","textSha256":"84ad63b5e4d6c78188492cdebcfbe01a174479093c93e3e335e5cecd86afa288"},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:b4dae808e46351372059513b88c424f8265f556298a35ac21c221330c3405f38","reviewId":"leaf-9f316e5cd9cfe1d3bd13-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n6","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","reviewId":"leaf-9f316e5cd9cfe1d3bd13-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n7","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0ab89e9b3e058896b7c2ce5a4532d38d77d794d6b411df04b66072275988539a","reviewId":"leaf-9f316e5cd9cfe1d3bd13-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","sourceReviewIds":["calabi-yau-periods-and-bps-navigation-proposal","calabi-yau-periods-and-bps-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Period geometry and degenerations are narrower directions of c4. The route preserves observable-dependent corrections and treats formal realizability as an alternate comparison boundary, with no claim that all formal geometries are compactifications.","refs":["c4","c2","u2","u8","u13","n4","n6","n7"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:pn4":{"id":"navigation:v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f","target":"q025-candidate-question:af30c367be77504492951c97","type":"related_question","title":"Explore asymptotic periods and realizability questions","qualification":"The overlap includes Fermat period pairing and parts of the asymptotic-period program. Additional operator and realizability questions are not consequences of every explicit mirror calculation, and physical and motivic realizability are not asserted equal.","rationale":"The shared witnesses support a useful neighboring question while the complete scopes remain distinct.","evidenceIds":["unit:0ab89e9b3e058896b7c2ce5a4532d38d77d794d6b411df04b66072275988539a","unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","unit:b4dae808e46351372059513b88c424f8265f556298a35ac21c221330c3405f38"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-9f316e5cd9cfe1d3bd13-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:af30c367be77504492951c97"},{"localRef":"u2","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:0ab89e9b3e058896b7c2ce5a4532d38d77d794d6b411df04b66072275988539a","textSha256":"5f6fbe92bee0cc7d775fd98e46338689a9254e07abf411e5d071dfe0a1cad655"},{"localRef":"u8","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","textSha256":"dca7fd64b03fee3206aca2cb0907fb91afdcc045dcd9fc29e3cb9fe3c26c54ce"},{"localRef":"u13","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:b4dae808e46351372059513b88c424f8265f556298a35ac21c221330c3405f38","textSha256":"84ad63b5e4d6c78188492cdebcfbe01a174479093c93e3e335e5cecd86afa288"},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:b4dae808e46351372059513b88c424f8265f556298a35ac21c221330c3405f38","reviewId":"leaf-9f316e5cd9cfe1d3bd13-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n6","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","reviewId":"leaf-9f316e5cd9cfe1d3bd13-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n7","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0ab89e9b3e058896b7c2ce5a4532d38d77d794d6b411df04b66072275988539a","reviewId":"leaf-9f316e5cd9cfe1d3bd13-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n9","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0ab89e9b3e058896b7c2ce5a4532d38d77d794d6b411df04b66072275988539a","reviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n19","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","reviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l2","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:af30c367be77504492951c97","candidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:15","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","sourceReviewIds":["calabi-yau-periods-and-bps-navigation-proposal","calabi-yau-periods-and-bps-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The shared Fermat and asymptotic-period contributions justify this related-question arc. Its qualification avoids implying that explicit computations settle operator or realizability questions.","refs":["c3","c2","u2","u8","u13","n4","n6","n7","n9","n19","l2"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:pn5":{"id":"navigation:v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:pn5","source":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f","target":"q025-candidate-question:853de7f0a8e55cb55e507432","type":"method_for","title":"Use mirror calculations for instanton invariants","qualification":"Apply only in the specified two-parameter, toric-hypersurface or complete-intersection settings. Preserve continuous instanton families in the two-parameter examples and distinguish genus-zero outputs from genus-one predictions. This route supplies no universal refined, higher-genus or regularization method.","rationale":"The supplied sources explicitly connect period and mirror calculations to instanton data. Method-to-target direction is method_for; the historical application wording does not justify reversing application_of semantics.","evidenceIds":["unit:05bbd28d938b41d04f3cff01ca15658911eecbbf83ffcc4791b18b3856f6b669","unit:394ea8d3adc525d1ea1ed5942e57d7dc169767d9f191f15bf489878004e5cbca","unit:926b345c92affb58b9589a950142ae23a51f3801b52561f92b8ad7ae0109f605"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:853de7f0a8e55cb55e507432"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:05bbd28d938b41d04f3cff01ca15658911eecbbf83ffcc4791b18b3856f6b669","textSha256":"412ba6ab5661932d7a1d1ca5603e36f5df8a4f5e9746300a04eab0b19e809065"},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:394ea8d3adc525d1ea1ed5942e57d7dc169767d9f191f15bf489878004e5cbca","textSha256":"98ad70d89950b4c84cf2b0ac95048e37fb1e8d5e2765b56846692a460efd4a80"},{"localRef":"u12","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:926b345c92affb58b9589a950142ae23a51f3801b52561f92b8ad7ae0109f605","textSha256":"5d2115398eca83e1eaf90c87de297adc233710300ba1a5196e3e527060542ad2"},{"localRef":"n15","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:05bbd28d938b41d04f3cff01ca15658911eecbbf83ffcc4791b18b3856f6b669","reviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n16","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:926b345c92affb58b9589a950142ae23a51f3801b52561f92b8ad7ae0109f605","reviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n17","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:394ea8d3adc525d1ea1ed5942e57d7dc169767d9f191f15bf489878004e5cbca","reviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n21","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:05bbd28d938b41d04f3cff01ca15658911eecbbf83ffcc4791b18b3856f6b669","reviewId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l3","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:853de7f0a8e55cb55e507432","candidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:16","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:route:pn5","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn5","sourceReviewIds":["calabi-yau-periods-and-bps-navigation-proposal","calabi-yau-periods-and-bps-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The descriptions explicitly support mirror or period methods for instanton data. method_for correctly runs from c3 to c1, with model, continuous-family and genus restrictions and no universal refined, higher-genus or regularization claim.","refs":["c3","c1","u0","u7","u12","n15","n16","n17","n21","l3"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:route:pn5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:pn6":{"id":"navigation:v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:pn6","source":"q025-candidate-question:6a9d9c1d809f904f41b8f560","target":"q025-candidate-question:853de7f0a8e55cb55e507432","type":"comparison","title":"Compare BPS interpretations with invariant definitions","qualification":"Compare only the overlapping amplitude and enumerative questions. GW-type, GV and refined data require their own definitions; BPS interpretation, anomaly constraints and subtraction prescriptions are not interchangeable. Local, compact and genus restrictions remain explicit.","rationale":"This preserves the useful supplied comparison without equating full scopes or claiming a universal conversion between physical and enumerative statements.","evidenceIds":["unit:2ee491ecbe35b797fcf4f5f237cc1e6f3cee0b191b6f6f778ed3ab506fa3d2e9","unit:3930d3016d5fce2f6edd9af5dfe2beadbfce9dc299691f330b50846041efae6f","unit:55609489a8990f86061f49417d67adb04f5a804e4f4a33d9a6aa4031c3123937","unit:cb95eb9c9a2e4dfc478e7da2079600014e592a8c9f790932d740b44550510a13"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-02b834cc1fe57554842a-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6a9d9c1d809f904f41b8f560"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:853de7f0a8e55cb55e507432"},{"localRef":"u5","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:2ee491ecbe35b797fcf4f5f237cc1e6f3cee0b191b6f6f778ed3ab506fa3d2e9","textSha256":"e334b7766e6ee7a4f96ed331e84d53f9bf75740c7960ca6ce786b4610d8028a9"},{"localRef":"u6","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:3930d3016d5fce2f6edd9af5dfe2beadbfce9dc299691f330b50846041efae6f","textSha256":"12c06bebed06a92fe9fed76ddffaff2287bc050347691b9855d3e5170ca505e1"},{"localRef":"u10","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:55609489a8990f86061f49417d67adb04f5a804e4f4a33d9a6aa4031c3123937","textSha256":"e838258edbc58a3d658f65cded62609f33acc885c05e8ac61e5d61b7da5eb0a1"},{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:cb95eb9c9a2e4dfc478e7da2079600014e592a8c9f790932d740b44550510a13","textSha256":"7f0c73db29bbb19ae442dca7191d75f103e389a18ea7047dab97f3f0b12027e2"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2ee491ecbe35b797fcf4f5f237cc1e6f3cee0b191b6f6f778ed3ab506fa3d2e9","reviewId":"leaf-02b834cc1fe57554842a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n2","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:55609489a8990f86061f49417d67adb04f5a804e4f4a33d9a6aa4031c3123937","reviewId":"leaf-02b834cc1fe57554842a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n12","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:3930d3016d5fce2f6edd9af5dfe2beadbfce9dc299691f330b50846041efae6f","reviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n18","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:cb95eb9c9a2e4dfc478e7da2079600014e592a8c9f790932d740b44550510a13","reviewId":"leaf-a346db48b7ff939db512-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l4","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6a9d9c1d809f904f41b8f560","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:853de7f0a8e55cb55e507432","candidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:47","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:route:pn6","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn6","sourceReviewIds":["calabi-yau-periods-and-bps-navigation-proposal","calabi-yau-periods-and-bps-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The overlapping amplitude and enumerative questions support this directed comparison. Its wording keeps GW-type, GV and refined definitions distinct and asserts no universal conversion from BPS interpretations to invariant or subtraction prescriptions.","refs":["c0","c1","u5","u6","u10","u15","n0","n2","n12","n18","l4"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:calabi-yau-periods-and-bps:route:pn6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-region:6d76d85d1e34d2ab20751fc0","target":"q025-candidate-question:850ca5650c2b1fe3e990cc72","type":"narrower","title":"Encode compactification data in actions and flux dictionaries","qualification":"Follow the effective-dynamics branch across the target's stated dimensions and supersymmetries. Formal encodings and reliable finite light-field reductions remain distinct.","rationale":"The region explicitly includes effective actions and consistency; c3 supplies the existing focused question.","evidenceIds":["unit:4ecd4b5e6fc56c1a4cfa49d4f5aa9c740b22f6419ed43a2951fdcf9fb264d03b","unit:9213e56426a0b7531c5cbbc6b9887280710a9064bda7909af4251918b23b572d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-30cfd228b7769fd058dc-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:6d76d85d1e34d2ab20751fc0"},{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-c3339e1f151b5c739eb5-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:850ca5650c2b1fe3e990cc72"},{"localRef":"l0","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-region:6d76d85d1e34d2ab20751fc0","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:850ca5650c2b1fe3e990cc72","candidateId":"parent-30cfd228b7769fd058dc-challenge:link:6","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:4ecd4b5e6fc56c1a4cfa49d4f5aa9c740b22f6419ed43a2951fdcf9fb264d03b","textSha256":"63c137606ce408a2af45a5986b3d7fd61b6913e533209db10ec4e8982bede523"},{"localRef":"n29","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:4ecd4b5e6fc56c1a4cfa49d4f5aa9c740b22f6419ed43a2951fdcf9fb264d03b","reviewId":"parent-30cfd228b7769fd058dc-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:9213e56426a0b7531c5cbbc6b9887280710a9064bda7909af4251918b23b572d","textSha256":"15610f372c0742aa168a9278b04d4410d5cb43328748d77b76239c5382d4e8d7"},{"localRef":"n25","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:9213e56426a0b7531c5cbbc6b9887280710a9064bda7909af4251918b23b572d","reviewId":"leaf-c3339e1f151b5c739eb5-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["consistent-reductions-and-actions-navigation-proposal","consistent-reductions-and-actions-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction is correct: c5's effective-dynamics branch leads to c3. The title describes the destination, and the qualification preserves dimensions, supersymmetries and the distinction between formal encodings and reliable finite reductions.","refs":["c5","c3","l0","u7","n29","u14","n25"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-question:850ca5650c2b1fe3e990cc72","target":"q025-candidate-question:98ed3765c22addab01ecc561","type":"narrower","title":"Determine retained-field couplings and flux potentials","qualification":"Keep the stated field content, open-string sectors, form-field formulations and dimensional regimes explicit, including the distinct six-dimensional N=(1,1) branch. An action or potential does not establish vacuum stability or string realization.","rationale":"c2 develops the action-and-supergravity-data branch of c3 while retaining the scope distinctions identified by the comparison candidate.","evidenceIds":["unit:56a1f40d01c2f0f9fd6a550b0be7fe9318b52593cb7a27a0de4042b0c02ca94a","unit:acaa5a673376b66c4a70d5477bdc8c298a68465fffaf6b7084434f824b16be39"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-c3339e1f151b5c739eb5-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:850ca5650c2b1fe3e990cc72"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-8cbd232bf6adad063a61-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98ed3765c22addab01ecc561"},{"localRef":"l1","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:850ca5650c2b1fe3e990cc72","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98ed3765c22addab01ecc561","candidateId":"parent-30cfd228b7769fd058dc-challenge:link:16","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u8","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:56a1f40d01c2f0f9fd6a550b0be7fe9318b52593cb7a27a0de4042b0c02ca94a","textSha256":"9b77f2edc1fc291e87c0f2b4078d68a615ad9c68cfd00ae5fb0adf1f2eaa9f3c"},{"localRef":"n20","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:56a1f40d01c2f0f9fd6a550b0be7fe9318b52593cb7a27a0de4042b0c02ca94a","reviewId":"leaf-8cbd232bf6adad063a61-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u16","kind":"description","unitIndex":81,"unitId":"unit:acaa5a673376b66c4a70d5477bdc8c298a68465fffaf6b7084434f824b16be39","textSha256":"07333849b8cfb720e4a87a49bc90b6565f1d400139968b70598104013d38fa67"},{"localRef":"n21","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:acaa5a673376b66c4a70d5477bdc8c298a68465fffaf6b7084434f824b16be39","reviewId":"leaf-8cbd232bf6adad063a61-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["consistent-reductions-and-actions-navigation-proposal","consistent-reductions-and-actions-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c3 can organize c2's detailed action-and-supergravity-data branch. The route explicitly retains open-string sectors, form formulations and the distinct six-dimensional regime, and does not infer stability or realization from a potential. Its narrower type is justified by the definitions rather than inherited from l1.","refs":["c3","c2","l1","u8","n20","u16","n21"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:pn2":{"id":"navigation:v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-question:2ad902d8305bb29bbade4879","target":"q025-candidate-question:11fac3e3216724977778f4e2","type":"narrower","title":"Derive reductions and test higher-dimensional origins","qualification":"Separate effective-action derivation, necessary origin tests, algebraic compatibility and explicit consistent truncations. Massive-mode retention does not by itself establish low-energy completeness or controlled phenomenology.","rationale":"c0 isolates the reduction-and-realization branch already distinguished within c4.","evidenceIds":["unit:21566519271e2447b13403d6db9c7cfba8d467ae5799e6ce96711b660fdbba79","unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2ad902d8305bb29bbade4879"},{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:11fac3e3216724977778f4e2"},{"localRef":"l2","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2ad902d8305bb29bbade4879","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:11fac3e3216724977778f4e2","candidateId":"parent-51a62d0da6201c295801-challenge:link:19","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u1","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:21566519271e2447b13403d6db9c7cfba8d467ae5799e6ce96711b660fdbba79","textSha256":"69e087f5946c2b8427f403882564e2ecf907dfe184c7b68fa579843c33370888"},{"localRef":"n3","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:21566519271e2447b13403d6db9c7cfba8d467ae5799e6ce96711b660fdbba79","reviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","textSha256":"e8ec3115be3c89d2a146767159855bae9b1142fe39ddf3d3f3e513dc23a14b54"},{"localRef":"n6","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","reviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["consistent-reductions-and-actions-navigation-proposal","consistent-reductions-and-actions-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The route correctly runs from broad construction and interpretation to reduction and origin questions. Its qualification preserves necessary versus sufficient tests and prevents massive-mode truncations from acquiring an automatic low-energy or phenomenological interpretation.","refs":["c4","c0","l2","u1","n3","u19","n6"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:pn3":{"id":"navigation:v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-question:11fac3e3216724977778f4e2","target":"q025-candidate-question:e356a66ea835237726bb7474","type":"narrower","title":"Which finite reductions are consistent, and what can they retain?","qualification":"Check nonlinear consistency, retained modes, source content and global identifications under the chosen construction's hypotheses. AdS5 matter bounds remain classification-specific; necessary origin tests are not sufficient uplift criteria.","rationale":"c1 provides the focused consistency-and-realization question within c0's broader treatment of reductions.","evidenceIds":["unit:21566519271e2447b13403d6db9c7cfba8d467ae5799e6ce96711b660fdbba79","unit:5c57d59057069b1b90c14541005c44710d3ff3e04d6481d6499fde71bc400e1b","unit:f01689b48c8df9f02a33b4e18d1a83b973c07aebdd7af5adf05ed8f0216ebcd3"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:11fac3e3216724977778f4e2"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-20c5327b935823b2fe6a-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e356a66ea835237726bb7474"},{"localRef":"u22","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:f01689b48c8df9f02a33b4e18d1a83b973c07aebdd7af5adf05ed8f0216ebcd3","textSha256":"5cb1191011ab6fd36d5ea02f10fc67361fa9431b7da367ed215c4753699f8c20"},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f01689b48c8df9f02a33b4e18d1a83b973c07aebdd7af5adf05ed8f0216ebcd3","reviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n12","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f01689b48c8df9f02a33b4e18d1a83b973c07aebdd7af5adf05ed8f0216ebcd3","reviewId":"leaf-20c5327b935823b2fe6a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u9","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:5c57d59057069b1b90c14541005c44710d3ff3e04d6481d6499fde71bc400e1b","textSha256":"2ac335610e97a904d3abfd53398753a6ffd75ae57ab040ae4444307bb778af93"},{"localRef":"n11","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:5c57d59057069b1b90c14541005c44710d3ff3e04d6481d6499fde71bc400e1b","reviewId":"leaf-20c5327b935823b2fe6a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u1","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:21566519271e2447b13403d6db9c7cfba8d467ae5799e6ce96711b660fdbba79","textSha256":"69e087f5946c2b8427f403882564e2ecf907dfe184c7b68fa579843c33370888"},{"localRef":"n3","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:21566519271e2447b13403d6db9c7cfba8d467ae5799e6ce96711b660fdbba79","reviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","sourceReviewIds":["consistent-reductions-and-actions-navigation-proposal","consistent-reductions-and-actions-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader reduction question leads correctly to finite consistency and retained content. Source/global conditions and the classification-specific nature of AdS5 matter bounds remain explicit; the route does not turn necessary origin conditions into sufficient constructions.","refs":["c0","c1","u22","n4","n12","u9","n11","u1","n3"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:pn4":{"id":"navigation:v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-question:11fac3e3216724977778f4e2","target":"q025-candidate-question:850ca5650c2b1fe3e990cc72","type":"comparison","title":"Compare higher-dimensional origins with effective-theory encodings","qualification":"Compare reduction constructions and origin tests with actions, gauging maps and formal supersymmetry descriptions. A common encoding need not supply a reliable finite spectrum or an uplift.","rationale":"The overlapping questions offer complementary next steps while retaining their different targets and premises.","evidenceIds":["unit:9213e56426a0b7531c5cbbc6b9887280710a9064bda7909af4251918b23b572d","unit:acaa5a673376b66c4a70d5477bdc8c298a68465fffaf6b7084434f824b16be39","unit:c349479bfe7c4fcd2c135b9110efc8ecf1fb3c8439eb5c139414136a8e6907a6"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:11fac3e3216724977778f4e2"},{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-c3339e1f151b5c739eb5-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:850ca5650c2b1fe3e990cc72"},{"localRef":"u16","kind":"description","unitIndex":81,"unitId":"unit:acaa5a673376b66c4a70d5477bdc8c298a68465fffaf6b7084434f824b16be39","textSha256":"07333849b8cfb720e4a87a49bc90b6565f1d400139968b70598104013d38fa67"},{"localRef":"n5","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:acaa5a673376b66c4a70d5477bdc8c298a68465fffaf6b7084434f824b16be39","reviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:9213e56426a0b7531c5cbbc6b9887280710a9064bda7909af4251918b23b572d","textSha256":"15610f372c0742aa168a9278b04d4410d5cb43328748d77b76239c5382d4e8d7"},{"localRef":"n25","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:9213e56426a0b7531c5cbbc6b9887280710a9064bda7909af4251918b23b572d","reviewId":"leaf-c3339e1f151b5c739eb5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u20","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:c349479bfe7c4fcd2c135b9110efc8ecf1fb3c8439eb5c139414136a8e6907a6","textSha256":"e45a4fb7690738377b18c72a6a6dbcdce65384304b6a727eff389be25e52f497"},{"localRef":"n2","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c349479bfe7c4fcd2c135b9110efc8ecf1fb3c8439eb5c139414136a8e6907a6","reviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","sourceReviewIds":["consistent-reductions-and-actions-navigation-proposal","consistent-reductions-and-actions-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The directed comparison offers a useful move from higher-dimensional origins to effective encodings. Its qualification preserves the difference between common descriptions, reliable finite spectra and actual uplifts without asserting a new physical implication.","refs":["c0","c3","u16","n5","u14","n25","u20","n2"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:pn5":{"id":"navigation:v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:pn5","source":"q025-candidate-question:850ca5650c2b1fe3e990cc72","target":"q025-candidate-question:e356a66ea835237726bb7474","type":"premise_check","title":"Does the encoding define a consistent higher-dimensional reduction?","qualification":"Use this check when a formal encoding or dictionary is claimed to define a finite consistent reduction or an uplift of its solutions. Formal supersymmetry data alone need not make that claim; consistency, low-energy completeness and source/global realization require separate assessments.","rationale":"c3 explicitly asks when reductions are justified, and c1 supplies the existing consistency question needed for that conditional interpretation.","evidenceIds":["unit:5c57d59057069b1b90c14541005c44710d3ff3e04d6481d6499fde71bc400e1b","unit:9213e56426a0b7531c5cbbc6b9887280710a9064bda7909af4251918b23b572d","unit:d3e4f4baa2fb42e27b549d2effcf9264a0466217d450f067e5fed1a4ecb1302d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-c3339e1f151b5c739eb5-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:850ca5650c2b1fe3e990cc72"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-20c5327b935823b2fe6a-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e356a66ea835237726bb7474"},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:9213e56426a0b7531c5cbbc6b9887280710a9064bda7909af4251918b23b572d","textSha256":"15610f372c0742aa168a9278b04d4410d5cb43328748d77b76239c5382d4e8d7"},{"localRef":"n25","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:9213e56426a0b7531c5cbbc6b9887280710a9064bda7909af4251918b23b572d","reviewId":"leaf-c3339e1f151b5c739eb5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u9","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:5c57d59057069b1b90c14541005c44710d3ff3e04d6481d6499fde71bc400e1b","textSha256":"2ac335610e97a904d3abfd53398753a6ffd75ae57ab040ae4444307bb778af93"},{"localRef":"n11","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:5c57d59057069b1b90c14541005c44710d3ff3e04d6481d6499fde71bc400e1b","reviewId":"leaf-20c5327b935823b2fe6a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u21","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:d3e4f4baa2fb42e27b549d2effcf9264a0466217d450f067e5fed1a4ecb1302d","textSha256":"f60e84a04f6905f0df48256207006290587c9005f905f721e33e3d6d03ac165c"},{"localRef":"n8","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:d3e4f4baa2fb42e27b549d2effcf9264a0466217d450f067e5fed1a4ecb1302d","reviewId":"leaf-20c5327b935823b2fe6a-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:route:pn5","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn5","sourceReviewIds":["consistent-reductions-and-actions-navigation-proposal","consistent-reductions-and-actions-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The premise-check direction is correct: a c3 interpretation claiming a finite consistent reduction leads to c1's consistency inquiry. The explicit condition keeps formal supersymmetry descriptions eligible without that claim and separates consistency from completeness and global/source realization.","refs":["c3","c1","u14","n25","u9","n11","u21","n8"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:route:pn5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:pn6":{"id":"navigation:v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:pn6","source":"q025-candidate-region:6d76d85d1e34d2ab20751fc0","target":"q025-candidate-question:2ad902d8305bb29bbade4879","type":"related_question","title":"Explore compactification vacua, control and phenomenology","qualification":"Extend the inquiry to construction and physical interpretation, including source-specific supersymmetry breaking. No common flux content, control regime, stabilization mechanism or vacuum measure is implied.","rationale":"The region's application directions connect to c4's existing broad construction and interpretation question without asserting containment.","evidenceIds":["unit:4ecd4b5e6fc56c1a4cfa49d4f5aa9c740b22f6419ed43a2951fdcf9fb264d03b","unit:699d1c26b65d492cfd75f3e58dcb1b57fa7c5493217a577042353b61c637a9e9","unit:82522e3c91ab0fb20db03b11bab8c143cb2d9701bc62b996dcd0eb9a2ac423cc"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-30cfd228b7769fd058dc-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:6d76d85d1e34d2ab20751fc0"},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2ad902d8305bb29bbade4879"},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:4ecd4b5e6fc56c1a4cfa49d4f5aa9c740b22f6419ed43a2951fdcf9fb264d03b","textSha256":"63c137606ce408a2af45a5986b3d7fd61b6913e533209db10ec4e8982bede523"},{"localRef":"n29","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:4ecd4b5e6fc56c1a4cfa49d4f5aa9c740b22f6419ed43a2951fdcf9fb264d03b","reviewId":"parent-30cfd228b7769fd058dc-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u11","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:699d1c26b65d492cfd75f3e58dcb1b57fa7c5493217a577042353b61c637a9e9","textSha256":"397bd92a19f6ffc07d495b938882bf6b2a0a540a8ef9a1d477a9eaa374446662"},{"localRef":"n15","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:699d1c26b65d492cfd75f3e58dcb1b57fa7c5493217a577042353b61c637a9e9","reviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u13","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:82522e3c91ab0fb20db03b11bab8c143cb2d9701bc62b996dcd0eb9a2ac423cc","textSha256":"7c2695941d09d141c01dcf5aa3c05d963aad9bdbad4efd7c678f8553fd5290ad"},{"localRef":"n13","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:82522e3c91ab0fb20db03b11bab8c143cb2d9701bc62b996dcd0eb9a2ac423cc","reviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:route:pn6","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn6","sourceReviewIds":["consistent-reductions-and-actions-navigation-proposal","consistent-reductions-and-actions-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The related-question arc connects the region to concrete construction, control and phenomenological questions. Its title and qualification support this outgoing choice without asserting containment, a universal stabilization mechanism or a common measure.","refs":["c5","c4","u7","n29","u11","n15","u13","n13"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:consistent-reductions-and-actions:route:pn6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-region:5fb081b9efa119868d87802b","target":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6","type":"narrower","title":"What can cosmological observations determine?","qualification":"Inference depends on source-specific windows, matter allocation, reconstruction priors and prescribed histories. Archived fits do not establish current observational validation.","rationale":"c1 gives a concrete inference direction within the supplied broader region; the exact endpoint definitions support the nominated route.","evidenceIds":["unit:120c2cb0b711c90fe2146fad6110c576a6d9f5bb61a2282eb9193a32adbc0781","unit:17ce6a8c558247f5d1babb1f7b675efcc62a404687ac8380c8458f643cfa24b9","unit:1d179d9ec0eeb226883411ac325737a1080d4d6be30e418be0a8b6f5aabd7ebc","unit:1d991528537c30eea8bb179079e2da8f6f0ebc83144e9a906e7dfa6179962f02","unit:1f3a44d5c43400920c65d02390ca364343e4c9b4dd746dd61439f8dd4cdf680b","unit:22c21ca871bd81d8f096b1b1792a59f08ccccb442a914dfade862288e1ccfbb4","unit:31271d7dfca4fe764442d0aa4e4801816261e32a4eae883b87aef7d1e0748704","unit:3ce597e198d727b29270b1010d378cb7e69a79d091bbb00bb22bd87570bcf8fe","unit:3d994014aaf88ac04db134c38b6908054d6a9f340c1bf7e922de4709ee42cd1c","unit:4fb0631119e19948090cfce6f4de34d798b58a6b8de8a44dd26a4b632fbc39bc","unit:6118d7e96a4f864fc3e782183eb3e43d7a4be73f346ab0d364dfb0f008a67775","unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","unit:68f4f4ffd4d4a71a068438e8dc7381a0d17df877d59b41d9ef0d979d4ed7d79b","unit:6b2130ad6e7b0e47e7506c23e438d0b9f422fc271081de5f71663fca7df987e7","unit:7451f5bda7b338ca10496dce52f7d8d27a1f7af6a837a399dfd50ed064e8be9c","unit:845e803c48654d712dc6eaf284c0c6c1c55eb0163af14e3a57f9681214936dce","unit:8622e1b046ad7758b7a2e489de32ec77b84b8f58531ea38343f9a699d14febd6","unit:8dbd5c3383317914b8e2f51b50b5f81b97c5590bba6322976ef4214b4e8c24fd","unit:8dfeb4f2701afdceb4409038dbee8c405856e17e281a0c1faf8cc627ac2b9542","unit:901c5fab7695b54466b6a37c27b993da70a4ca9134d5b9d07d6c9b70300cf760","unit:ad3d22473312b5e18cad347b59aa11b8287ee5ab98f8ed90ee566fb78441a4a5","unit:b53e13f9d30f2970b0a9171f1ab65a507b587ff40b3cc4aa2f7650369f08db1f","unit:b608be96ec00e275288357f876c88b0f1fd8ec3be6a67705025229b6bf767613","unit:b63d3da3b6ce278b8f181c21560d3525dd134e594326f9551ddde0ebec0b6385","unit:b9bac0cd5f769d330250fc015c3d2f7ba13fc06f6d1a53e3ab004d781ba58865","unit:d270782bac26220422ff24d42ded24f1fcc35784c97d2da1569e5025061d8a90","unit:f1cedb4fe828b30a905a1fddaf9f5ca95a51ff00999aadd22f202f5c99ab5542","unit:ffa164e65727d11206e8bc77e800dd904d519f93275ff3ce7eb3214a7e97f7df"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-31256938ec369089ee3f-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:5fb081b9efa119868d87802b"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6"},{"localRef":"l0","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-region:5fb081b9efa119868d87802b","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6","candidateId":"parent-31256938ec369089ee3f-challenge:link:5","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["dark-energy-histories-navigation-proposal","dark-energy-histories-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction matches the complete definitions. The title offers c1's inference question, and the qualification preserves matter allocation, priors, observational windows and the distinction between archived fits and present validation.","refs":["c4","c1","l0"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":true,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-region:5fb081b9efa119868d87802b","target":"q025-candidate-question:b95a5d67b2f154bc9029b3d5","type":"narrower","title":"How do dark-sector interactions change expansion and clustering?","qualification":"Coupling laws, signs and coupled species remain model-specific. Pre-BBN applications enter only as boundary contributions, and review breadth does not establish universal viability.","rationale":"c3 supplies the region's focused interaction question without equating its mechanisms.","evidenceIds":["unit:19e623c2554071ebaa406431820c702bc6c37b730bb9b5ee2af3176e226da49c","unit:c1c77923b9f2dfb80489268b8dec3ff650cb3bf91d0a85423ec126eba532afb5"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-31256938ec369089ee3f-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:5fb081b9efa119868d87802b"},{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b95a5d67b2f154bc9029b3d5"},{"localRef":"l1","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-region:5fb081b9efa119868d87802b","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b95a5d67b2f154bc9029b3d5","candidateId":"parent-31256938ec369089ee3f-challenge:link:7","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u20","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:c1c77923b9f2dfb80489268b8dec3ff650cb3bf91d0a85423ec126eba532afb5","textSha256":"f9b0eb59c34a11e56dbdfa3598398ab22c67333cc325586d63d603ff3f703d55"},{"localRef":"n11","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c1c77923b9f2dfb80489268b8dec3ff650cb3bf91d0a85423ec126eba532afb5","reviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u2","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:19e623c2554071ebaa406431820c702bc6c37b730bb9b5ee2af3176e226da49c","textSha256":"b2828745ddec188edd8760ec673911e3469812996eb10960cf3864fc1ba6d34f"},{"localRef":"n14","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:19e623c2554071ebaa406431820c702bc6c37b730bb9b5ee2af3176e226da49c","reviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["dark-energy-histories-navigation-proposal","dark-energy-histories-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c3 is a focused interaction question within c4. The route preserves model-dependent laws and species, review-level viability limits and the pre-BBN boundary role; it asserts no common mechanism.","refs":["c4","c3","l1","u20","n11","u2","n14"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn2":{"id":"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6","target":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80","type":"related_question","title":"How do potentials and initial conditions generate candidate histories?","qualification":"A potential alone does not fix a scalar history. Boundary conditions and matter-era restrictions remain substantive; the cited 2021 reconstruction retains z ∈ [0,1.5] and field-origin ambiguity.","rationale":"Readers can move from inference to c0's prediction and boundary-data targets without treating the two complete scopes as nested or equivalent.","evidenceIds":["unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6"},{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80"},{"localRef":"u22","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234","textSha256":"43ca33640a5dded2d2aeb4028654c06ad78eb2a8d0b955cecd852a433eaac14c"},{"localRef":"n5","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234","reviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["dark-energy-histories-navigation-proposal","dark-energy-histories-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The move from inference to prediction and boundary conditions is licensed by c0 and u22. related_question correctly avoids nesting the full scopes. The reconstruction interval and field-origin qualification are retained from c0's existing assessment.","refs":["c1","c0","u22","n5"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn3":{"id":"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80","target":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6","type":"related_question","title":"Which inferred features depend on priors and matter allocation?","qualification":"Canonical dynamics applies only where specified. Chaplygin matter-budget alternatives, reconstruction priors and coupled-history assumptions remain distinct; expansion alone does not uniquely identify arbitrary coupling and equation-of-state functions.","rationale":"The shared inference target has an existing destination that explicitly exposes these conditional interpretations.","evidenceIds":["unit:120c2cb0b711c90fe2146fad6110c576a6d9f5bb61a2282eb9193a32adbc0781","unit:7451f5bda7b338ca10496dce52f7d8d27a1f7af6a837a399dfd50ed064e8be9c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:120c2cb0b711c90fe2146fad6110c576a6d9f5bb61a2282eb9193a32adbc0781","textSha256":"ad04617a61200994d11e309d25d3cfd88ed07edac4ec809eda6c289ab2113a07"},{"localRef":"n9","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:120c2cb0b711c90fe2146fad6110c576a6d9f5bb61a2282eb9193a32adbc0781","reviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:7451f5bda7b338ca10496dce52f7d8d27a1f7af6a837a399dfd50ed064e8be9c","textSha256":"569e3d1b7d9927a30ad9076fd655fcbfdd6a4a0addd5ff37157c22008f770b63"},{"localRef":"n19","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:7451f5bda7b338ca10496dce52f7d8d27a1f7af6a837a399dfd50ed064e8be9c","reviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","sourceReviewIds":["dark-energy-histories-navigation-proposal","dark-energy-histories-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c1 explicitly supplies the matter-allocation and conditional-identifiability questions that readers of c0 can pursue. The route keeps Chaplygin budget alternatives and coupled-history assumptions distinct and makes no prior-free reconstruction claim.","refs":["c0","c1","u0","n9","u15","n19"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn4":{"id":"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-question:b95a5d67b2f154bc9029b3d5","target":"q025-candidate-question:1666a2058189eda606293478","type":"related_question","title":"Can selected interactions produce stable accelerated scaling?","qualification":"Scaling, density ratios and force histories depend on the chosen interaction and matter content. No universal coincidence solution follows, and normalized-phase-space singularities are not automatically spacetime singularities.","rationale":"c2 preserves a useful dynamical direction from the interaction overview. A related-question route avoids asserting complete containment of its additional targets.","evidenceIds":["unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","unit:fbd339f4ff7e3dbfa59a7ce6d7bad0b10bdf6ff36a085fee114fc959ff710a5c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b95a5d67b2f154bc9029b3d5"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1666a2058189eda606293478"},{"localRef":"u23","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:fbd339f4ff7e3dbfa59a7ce6d7bad0b10bdf6ff36a085fee114fc959ff710a5c","textSha256":"6bc7d21b0b4e6f97d634f41e8149582c5b75614220b063a86893cd4eb41fd5a4"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:fbd339f4ff7e3dbfa59a7ce6d7bad0b10bdf6ff36a085fee114fc959ff710a5c","reviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u8","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","textSha256":"f146c93dbd9e0eaf26fe2d87bc210df0bd18209d305a8816121fce9e84b75986"},{"localRef":"n3","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:4a2ba00f804c46f0735102b8115241a161829b3f0a621229e8f2808cc13c0484","reviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","sourceReviewIds":["dark-energy-histories-navigation-proposal","dark-energy-histories-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"u23 supplies the concrete accelerated-scaling question and u8 supplies related force-history targets within c2. related_question preserves c2's additional scope; the qualification avoids universal coincidence or spacetime-singularity claims.","refs":["c3","c2","u23","n0","u8","n3"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn5":{"id":"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn5","source":"q025-candidate-question:1666a2058189eda606293478","target":"q025-candidate-question:b95a5d67b2f154bc9029b3d5","type":"related_question","title":"Explore other coupling laws and their observational tests","qualification":"Conformal, disformal, mass-varying and energy-transfer descriptions retain their own dictionaries. Observational discrimination, coupling suppression and stability are separate questions; parameters and conclusions are not transferred between models.","rationale":"c3 offers broader interaction mechanisms and inference targets beyond c2's emphasis on scaling, composition and forces.","evidenceIds":["unit:a9e0c48735f61cc319bc51a28f93a76770ea00687cb03075f730cfe3d43b8ba4","unit:c1c77923b9f2dfb80489268b8dec3ff650cb3bf91d0a85423ec126eba532afb5"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1666a2058189eda606293478"},{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b95a5d67b2f154bc9029b3d5"},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:a9e0c48735f61cc319bc51a28f93a76770ea00687cb03075f730cfe3d43b8ba4","textSha256":"6083a0ce95270d5fde9f3614dce216958367cfdb5a9cdcbd4aa1d298d739657d"},{"localRef":"n13","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:a9e0c48735f61cc319bc51a28f93a76770ea00687cb03075f730cfe3d43b8ba4","reviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u20","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:c1c77923b9f2dfb80489268b8dec3ff650cb3bf91d0a85423ec126eba532afb5","textSha256":"f9b0eb59c34a11e56dbdfa3598398ab22c67333cc325586d63d603ff3f703d55"},{"localRef":"n11","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c1c77923b9f2dfb80489268b8dec3ff650cb3bf91d0a85423ec126eba532afb5","reviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn5","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn5","sourceReviewIds":["dark-energy-histories-navigation-proposal","dark-energy-histories-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c3 offers interaction dictionaries and inference targets beyond c2's emphasis. u19 and u20 support this comparative direction while the qualification prevents transferring parameters, stability or observational conclusions across models.","refs":["c2","c3","u19","n13","u20","n11"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn6":{"id":"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn6","source":"q025-candidate-question:b95a5d67b2f154bc9029b3d5","target":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6","type":"related_question","title":"What can expansion reconstruct when one dark-sector history is supplied?","qualification":"In the supplied conditional inversion, either the equation-of-state history or coupling history is prescribed. General-fluid inversion and canonical realization are alternatives; perturbations are not reconstructed.","rationale":"u15 explicitly connects both destinations and provides a concrete inference question following the study of interactions.","evidenceIds":["unit:1d179d9ec0eeb226883411ac325737a1080d4d6be30e418be0a8b6f5aabd7ebc","unit:7451f5bda7b338ca10496dce52f7d8d27a1f7af6a837a399dfd50ed064e8be9c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b95a5d67b2f154bc9029b3d5"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6"},{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:7451f5bda7b338ca10496dce52f7d8d27a1f7af6a837a399dfd50ed064e8be9c","textSha256":"569e3d1b7d9927a30ad9076fd655fcbfdd6a4a0addd5ff37157c22008f770b63"},{"localRef":"n19","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:7451f5bda7b338ca10496dce52f7d8d27a1f7af6a837a399dfd50ed064e8be9c","reviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u3","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:1d179d9ec0eeb226883411ac325737a1080d4d6be30e418be0a8b6f5aabd7ebc","textSha256":"ef2c435210b782514f295e66660c93d6f073ac501360c9976c1b6210e5c3e560"},{"localRef":"n20","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:1d179d9ec0eeb226883411ac325737a1080d4d6be30e418be0a8b6f5aabd7ebc","reviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn6","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn6","sourceReviewIds":["dark-energy-histories-navigation-proposal","dark-energy-histories-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"u15 and n19 explicitly connect the two endpoints through conditional background inversion. The route accurately requires one prescribed history and preserves the fluid/canonical alternatives and absence of perturbation reconstruction. It makes no inverted application claim.","refs":["c3","c1","u15","n19","u3","n20"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn7":{"id":"navigation:v2:dark-energy-histories:pn7","source":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80","target":"q025-candidate-question:b95a5d67b2f154bc9029b3d5","type":"comparison","title":"Compare fitted H0 with apparent phantom behavior","qualification":"The supplied same-paper targets distinguish low-redshift fit quality from effective phantom behavior of a canonical coupled scalar. Present normalization fixes a nonphantom effective value today; possible behavior away from today is not a demonstrated global crossing. A higher fitted H0 does not establish an acceptable joint fit.","rationale":"The paired source descriptions support this concrete comparison while retaining distinct statistical and mechanism questions.","evidenceIds":["unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","unit:6118d7e96a4f864fc3e782183eb3e43d7a4be73f346ab0d364dfb0f008a67775","unit:68f4f4ffd4d4a71a068438e8dc7381a0d17df877d59b41d9ef0d979d4ed7d79b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80"},{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b95a5d67b2f154bc9029b3d5"},{"localRef":"u5","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","textSha256":"fabb290146b115b17311b3b2c38b0343ebb029cf637ecf49554b7bea58f59a65"},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","reviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u11","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:6118d7e96a4f864fc3e782183eb3e43d7a4be73f346ab0d364dfb0f008a67775","textSha256":"4b092681427d1e376db43d3472190415db40461267a9c6ed95f6a59336df6834"},{"localRef":"n17","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6118d7e96a4f864fc3e782183eb3e43d7a4be73f346ab0d364dfb0f008a67775","reviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u13","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:68f4f4ffd4d4a71a068438e8dc7381a0d17df877d59b41d9ef0d979d4ed7d79b","textSha256":"b1781a03be63eedf3e69e335825778e37d82a9b15e9ad163e955f09aa512421e"},{"localRef":"n18","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:68f4f4ffd4d4a71a068438e8dc7381a0d17df877d59b41d9ef0d979d4ed7d79b","reviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn7","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn7","sourceReviewIds":["dark-energy-histories-navigation-proposal","dark-energy-histories-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The supplied descriptions and paired notes support comparison of distinct same-paper fit and effective-equation-of-state targets. The qualification retains the nonphantom present value, unproved global crossing and independent joint-fit requirement; no causal improvement in H0 inference is asserted.","refs":["c0","c3","u5","n4","u11","n17","u13","n18"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:dark-energy-histories:route:pn7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:de-sitter-organization:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v2:de-sitter-organization:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0","target":"q025-candidate-question:3d5c2b4ed57cefc85bb9a422","type":"narrower","title":"Test finite and parametric classical control","qualification":"For specified classical type II candidates. Keep quantization, small corrections, finite parameter choices, asymptotic scaling and physical hierarchies separate; none establishes metastability by itself.","rationale":"A concrete narrower route within c4's controlled-construction branch, supported by the quantized IIB and restricted classical type II questions.","evidenceIds":["unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0dd2c748860e78df66b5-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0"},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","textSha256":"d8e5d6cccfe27b0d233e28d23db633473b21413bbc7ea9b5862c3a89d3da04e0"},{"localRef":"u24","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","textSha256":"13d2a2a68a7c8d73145c555257b20f27296ae1046d89c4e0071c488fbd4f77c3"},{"localRef":"n7","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","reviewId":"leaf-0dd2c748860e78df66b5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n8","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","reviewId":"leaf-0dd2c748860e78df66b5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n12","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","reviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n16","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","reviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["de-sitter-organization-navigation-proposal","de-sitter-organization-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction c4→pq0 is correct. Its title gives a concrete control test, and its qualification retains classical type II restrictions and separates quantization, corrections, scaling, hierarchies and metastability.","refs":["c4","u19","u24","n7","n8","n12","n16"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:de-sitter-organization:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v2:de-sitter-organization:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0","target":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","type":"premise_check","title":"Check the effective expansion","qualification":"When a compactification claim relies on a controlled effective description. Solving higher-dimensional equations or counting operators does not complete Wilsonian integration. This route does not impose a four-dimensional EFT on every noncompact background or alternative realization.","rationale":"c4's conditional control claim requires the relevant approximation test; c5 distinguishes the unfinished steps without assuming their success.","evidenceIds":["unit:0a7894cd67c1ab57b2737e741969081e9a796494033d35f595b85bd6f18c0dc2","unit:148e545792b1782dc240c5aa9a1996d599b189b76551bd6ae529c44c5de3287d","unit:5d44db45b25d450de0329358dd75fed0db273e0034f8088dee99ea6acba04fd2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0dd2c748860e78df66b5-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0"},{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c"},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:0a7894cd67c1ab57b2737e741969081e9a796494033d35f595b85bd6f18c0dc2","textSha256":"33271933bb80163e63b728cbf8a32254f6634cdf941371a16bfa434873201849"},{"localRef":"u17","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:5d44db45b25d450de0329358dd75fed0db273e0034f8088dee99ea6acba04fd2","textSha256":"9b87bf64b161d970b1a6b48bc3d81f34804f5596e239ae016c6b8fd28384b74c"},{"localRef":"u9","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:148e545792b1782dc240c5aa9a1996d599b189b76551bd6ae529c44c5de3287d","textSha256":"5a3b437de292b32aeaed187be8e4b54754fdd4603c87ff8bf43a16078dc7c9b9"},{"localRef":"n29","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0a7894cd67c1ab57b2737e741969081e9a796494033d35f595b85bd6f18c0dc2","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n27","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:5d44db45b25d450de0329358dd75fed0db273e0034f8088dee99ea6acba04fd2","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n23","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:148e545792b1782dc240c5aa9a1996d599b189b76551bd6ae529c44c5de3287d","reviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["de-sitter-organization-navigation-proposal","de-sitter-organization-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c4→c5 correctly goes from a conditional controlled-construction claim to its effective-description check. The qualification limits applicability and does not impose a four-dimensional EFT on every alternative background.","refs":["c4","c5","u7","u17","u9","n29","n27","n23"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:de-sitter-organization:pn2":{"id":"navigation:v2:de-sitter-organization:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0","target":"q025-candidate-question:7675a53bd22b622819d7b5e6","type":"premise_check","title":"Test metastability and decay","qualification":"For an identified candidate being interpreted as a metastable vacuum. Apply only the relevant scalar, omitted-mode, brane and transition tests; a stable truncation or removal of one tachyon is insufficient for full stability.","rationale":"The metastability branch of c4 requires a stability assessment distinct from existence and control. The supplied restricted-source analysis does not prove a universal tachyon.","evidenceIds":["unit:8ad924b91b8a1bcd9067950fc6156f3db7a9a031b1b0ace350163a1f4cc67fd4","unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","unit:f7dacde5e3ec1cd1a0ec3c942186b9014318356ac97fa62126074ac816fa49c7"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0dd2c748860e78df66b5-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0"},{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7675a53bd22b622819d7b5e6"},{"localRef":"u24","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","textSha256":"13d2a2a68a7c8d73145c555257b20f27296ae1046d89c4e0071c488fbd4f77c3"},{"localRef":"u26","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:f7dacde5e3ec1cd1a0ec3c942186b9014318356ac97fa62126074ac816fa49c7","textSha256":"49b927bbaa73a79df808e79167fb97c754e91b6d6a33a62d3542903ce656954f"},{"localRef":"u21","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:8ad924b91b8a1bcd9067950fc6156f3db7a9a031b1b0ace350163a1f4cc67fd4","textSha256":"b5491f1cd7d5666813ca73f7e0ce55de3e9f6705ebfcbe3de33fd8640a67eeb9"},{"localRef":"n12","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","reviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n3","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f7dacde5e3ec1cd1a0ec3c942186b9014318356ac97fa62126074ac816fa49c7","reviewId":"leaf-0dd2c748860e78df66b5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n10","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:8ad924b91b8a1bcd9067950fc6156f3db7a9a031b1b0ace350163a1f4cc67fd4","reviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["de-sitter-organization-navigation-proposal","de-sitter-organization-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c4→c6 correctly checks the metastability premise for an identified candidate. Relevant scalar, brane and transition tests remain source-specific; a stable truncation or removal of one tachyon is insufficient.","refs":["c4","c6","u24","u26","u21","n12","n3","n10"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:de-sitter-organization:pn3":{"id":"navigation:v2:de-sitter-organization:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0","target":"q025-candidate-question:cbec67884d8051e3e85220e5","type":"comparison","title":"Compare existence with vacuum statistics","qualification":"Compare specified models only. Fixed-flux multiplicity differs from varying-flux statistics; the sphere model assumes a positive parent cosmological constant, and retained-field spectra do not certify complete compactification control.","rationale":"The compound fixed-flux/construction witness and the contrasting distribution models provide a useful route without treating population statistics as an existence or control proof.","evidenceIds":["unit:186da3931017fddf28e82cb04ec8a81de3e2815d1d2a18599fc38542d9f7372a","unit:225686e3711b95bfbd209681b2e29b34f4e29cd5ec94708d24883f8435cca1e4","unit:29347bb9ce38dc5829437015bab31988f5335c632397e281cb2d1cf8a8a1dafb"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0dd2c748860e78df66b5-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cbec67884d8051e3e85220e5"},{"localRef":"u12","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:225686e3711b95bfbd209681b2e29b34f4e29cd5ec94708d24883f8435cca1e4","textSha256":"bb09c15b25b638bb2d110c15b1531ed19b6542392a67e92f93b3c5c85998bef2"},{"localRef":"u10","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:186da3931017fddf28e82cb04ec8a81de3e2815d1d2a18599fc38542d9f7372a","textSha256":"0b50c11b24cc54c085a757950d2ef63bafd4b9e2a341667921f783a22b0ed63e"},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:29347bb9ce38dc5829437015bab31988f5335c632397e281cb2d1cf8a8a1dafb","textSha256":"3d2006402e27a3912bd4601688a29f0d5df24f014cc8b4c0cfe6e644df97978c"},{"localRef":"n20","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:225686e3711b95bfbd209681b2e29b34f4e29cd5ec94708d24883f8435cca1e4","reviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n21","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:186da3931017fddf28e82cb04ec8a81de3e2815d1d2a18599fc38542d9f7372a","reviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n22","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:29347bb9ce38dc5829437015bab31988f5335c632397e281cb2d1cf8a8a1dafb","reviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","sourceReviewIds":["de-sitter-organization-navigation-proposal","de-sitter-organization-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The c4→c7 comparison is useful and supported by the compound construction/multiplicity witness and contrasting distribution models. It does not claim statistical containment or use assumed positive parent energy as a string-existence result.","refs":["c4","c7","u12","u10","u14","n20","n21","n22"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:de-sitter-organization:pn4":{"id":"navigation:v2:de-sitter-organization:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","target":"q025-candidate-question:3d5c2b4ed57cefc85bb9a422","type":"comparison","title":"Compare effective expansion with classical scaling","qualification":"Compare criteria, not transferred results. The classical question includes quantization and finite/parametric hierarchy tests; c5 also covers quantum corrections, evolving fields and unresolved Wilsonian integration.","rationale":"This route exposes distinct meanings of control while preserving the source-specific regimes.","evidenceIds":["unit:0a7894cd67c1ab57b2737e741969081e9a796494033d35f595b85bd6f18c0dc2","unit:5d44db45b25d450de0329358dd75fed0db273e0034f8088dee99ea6acba04fd2","unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c"},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:0a7894cd67c1ab57b2737e741969081e9a796494033d35f595b85bd6f18c0dc2","textSha256":"33271933bb80163e63b728cbf8a32254f6634cdf941371a16bfa434873201849"},{"localRef":"u17","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:5d44db45b25d450de0329358dd75fed0db273e0034f8088dee99ea6acba04fd2","textSha256":"9b87bf64b161d970b1a6b48bc3d81f34804f5596e239ae016c6b8fd28384b74c"},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","textSha256":"d8e5d6cccfe27b0d233e28d23db633473b21413bbc7ea9b5862c3a89d3da04e0"},{"localRef":"u24","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","textSha256":"13d2a2a68a7c8d73145c555257b20f27296ae1046d89c4e0071c488fbd4f77c3"},{"localRef":"n29","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0a7894cd67c1ab57b2737e741969081e9a796494033d35f595b85bd6f18c0dc2","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n27","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:5d44db45b25d450de0329358dd75fed0db273e0034f8088dee99ea6acba04fd2","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n7","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","reviewId":"leaf-0dd2c748860e78df66b5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n12","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","reviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","sourceReviewIds":["de-sitter-organization-navigation-proposal","de-sitter-organization-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The c5→pq0 comparison offers a concrete next question about different control criteria. Its qualification preserves classical versus quantum/Wilsonian regimes and expressly transfers no result.","refs":["c5","u7","u17","u19","u24","n29","n27","n7","n12"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:de-sitter-organization:pn5":{"id":"navigation:v2:de-sitter-organization:pn5","source":"q025-candidate-question:3d5c2b4ed57cefc85bb9a422","target":"q025-candidate-question:7675a53bd22b622819d7b5e6","type":"comparison","title":"Separate control from stability","qualification":"The inherited IIB assessment reports tachyonic examples while leaving control conditional. The restricted type II assessment does not prove a systematic tachyon. Neither statement establishes a general relation between control and stability.","rationale":"Sources addressing both tests make their independence a useful next direction, without turning a control question into a metastability claim.","evidenceIds":["unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7675a53bd22b622819d7b5e6"},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","textSha256":"d8e5d6cccfe27b0d233e28d23db633473b21413bbc7ea9b5862c3a89d3da04e0"},{"localRef":"u24","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","textSha256":"13d2a2a68a7c8d73145c555257b20f27296ae1046d89c4e0071c488fbd4f77c3"},{"localRef":"n7","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","reviewId":"leaf-0dd2c748860e78df66b5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n12","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","reviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n16","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","reviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:route:pn5","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn5","sourceReviewIds":["de-sitter-organization-navigation-proposal","de-sitter-organization-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The pq0→c6 comparison is supported by sources addressing both control and instability. It reports the inherited examples and unsuccessful general tachyon test without asserting a general control–stability relation.","refs":["c6","u19","u24","n7","n12","n16"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:route:pn5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067","target":"q025-candidate-question:d292e0749341c9b371266594","type":"narrower","title":"Test completion through distance, towers and EFT limits","qualification":"This is one proposed consistency direction. Ordinary, refined and sharpened distance statements remain distinct; failure of a fixed EFT does not by itself rule out a completion.","rationale":"c2 is a concrete narrower question within c6's completion-selection program. The supplied parent candidate supports this direction.","evidenceIds":["unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d292e0749341c9b371266594"},{"localRef":"u10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","textSha256":"5d0a687405a4a129aa50a2e87696184884adbcb0ede13dfdfd02895d528d29fb"},{"localRef":"n2","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","reviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l3","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d292e0749341c9b371266594","candidateId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge:link:25","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["distance-and-emergence-navigation-proposal","distance-and-emergence-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The c6→c2 direction correctly runs from broader completion selection to a narrower distance–tower consistency question. The title is concrete, and the qualification prevents fixed-EFT failure from becoming a completion obstruction.","refs":["c6","c2","u10","n2","l3"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true,"canonicalEndpointProjection":{"sourceOriginalId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a","targetOriginalId":"q025-candidate-question:d292e0749341c9b371266594","originalRelation":{"id":"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a","target":"q025-candidate-question:d292e0749341c9b371266594","type":"narrower","title":"Test completion through distance, towers and EFT limits","qualification":"This is one proposed consistency direction. Ordinary, refined and sharpened distance statements remain distinct; failure of a fixed EFT does not by itself rule out a completion.","rationale":"c2 is a concrete narrower question within c6's completion-selection program. The supplied parent candidate supports this direction.","evidenceIds":["unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d292e0749341c9b371266594"},{"localRef":"u10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","textSha256":"5d0a687405a4a129aa50a2e87696184884adbcb0ede13dfdfd02895d528d29fb"},{"localRef":"n2","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","reviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l3","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d292e0749341c9b371266594","candidateId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge:link:25","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["distance-and-emergence-navigation-proposal","distance-and-emergence-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The c6→c2 direction correctly runs from broader completion selection to a narrower distance–tower consistency question. The title is concrete, and the qualification prevents fixed-EFT failure from becoming a completion obstruction.","refs":["c6","c2","u10","n2","l3"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"identityDecisionIds":["decision:whole-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7"],"sourceCanonicalScopeContentSha256":"b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd","targetCanonicalScopeContentSha256":"597d41c02e08201f63c8ea2e357b53bb31030a5fd8a010f7b4b1bc03c2122b9e"}},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-question:d292e0749341c9b371266594","target":"q025-candidate-question:0cfe4a3951d071f1ddc2d078","type":"comparison","title":"Compare onset bounds with envelopes and special triggers","qualification":"Finite-region onset and absolute masses differ from fixed envelopes, trajectory conditions and special zero-mass triggers. A trigger does not automatically establish infinite geodesic distance.","rationale":"The shared distance–tower target supports a comparison while the complete definitions prevent equivalence.","evidenceIds":["unit:571c78dd8db9a7928cc3d5ca711740a7c7650021fbfa9bb4462a941fa35ce16d","unit:a5fc5563f783fbbb8994e9f871ab582c02837e61fe4ec99d33e38ba73f9a0563"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d292e0749341c9b371266594"},{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-bea4433b3d92cecb48c7-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0cfe4a3951d071f1ddc2d078"},{"localRef":"u8","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:571c78dd8db9a7928cc3d5ca711740a7c7650021fbfa9bb4462a941fa35ce16d","textSha256":"7641ffdae9bc84927d4cc1737774b325197eeff220e6ec589416de6ddc523346"},{"localRef":"u16","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:a5fc5563f783fbbb8994e9f871ab582c02837e61fe4ec99d33e38ba73f9a0563","textSha256":"3c54a9f5a4e978aa0af506827bf7465c6b1703b57f275a6504d8726f70a3418b"},{"localRef":"n12","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:571c78dd8db9a7928cc3d5ca711740a7c7650021fbfa9bb4462a941fa35ce16d","reviewId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n28","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:a5fc5563f783fbbb8994e9f871ab582c02837e61fe4ec99d33e38ba73f9a0563","reviewId":"leaf-bea4433b3d92cecb48c7-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l2","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d292e0749341c9b371266594","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0cfe4a3951d071f1ddc2d078","candidateId":"parent-2cf7cf7591d39055bca1-challenge:link:20","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["distance-and-emergence-navigation-proposal","distance-and-emergence-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The comparison gives a useful next question while preserving onset, absolute-mass, envelope and special-trigger distinctions. It neither treats c3 as fully contained in c2 nor supplies missing infinite-distance premises.","refs":["c2","c3","u8","u16","n12","n28","l2"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn2":{"id":"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-question:d292e0749341c9b371266594","target":"q025-candidate-question:fe41d31ca6db8d7e995d4b58","type":"comparison","title":"Ask whether the tower signals a string or extra dimensions","qualification":"Tower existence or exponential lightening alone does not identify a weak string, establish uniqueness or prove equi-dimensionality. Finite internal volume is insufficient for the cited equi-dimensional criterion.","rationale":"u26 has distinct supplied contributions to both destinations, supporting a comparison between tower restrictions and the further identification question.","evidenceIds":["unit:ecaac504888cef30a68ac68c2500e8a18ea93f9f002d8979ab8939da1d5e93bf"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d292e0749341c9b371266594"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fe41d31ca6db8d7e995d4b58"},{"localRef":"u26","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:ecaac504888cef30a68ac68c2500e8a18ea93f9f002d8979ab8939da1d5e93bf","textSha256":"262f5ac29344ed9b72cd24ccda94b09cad3d363b4283237c6e0129707b18e340"},{"localRef":"n13","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ecaac504888cef30a68ac68c2500e8a18ea93f9f002d8979ab8939da1d5e93bf","reviewId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n24","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ecaac504888cef30a68ac68c2500e8a18ea93f9f002d8979ab8939da1d5e93bf","reviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["distance-and-emergence-navigation-proposal","distance-and-emergence-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The route asks the additional identification question after tower restrictions. Its comparison type and explicit equi-dimensional, uniqueness and finite-volume qualifications avoid an unsupported physical implication.","refs":["c2","c1","u26","n13","n24"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn3":{"id":"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-question:8e4149c7991f4ca5156a5299","target":"q025-candidate-question:fe41d31ca6db8d7e995d4b58","type":"narrower","title":"Classify leading strings and decompactification at asymptotic limits","qualification":"Focus on the source-specified infinite-distance and weak-coupling branch. Keep dimension, spectrum, reference scale and quantum accessibility explicit; uniqueness remains a proposal.","rationale":"c1 narrows c4's broader physical-tower and limiting-regime question to asymptotic leading descriptions.","evidenceIds":["unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","unit:ecaac504888cef30a68ac68c2500e8a18ea93f9f002d8979ab8939da1d5e93bf"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8e4149c7991f4ca5156a5299"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fe41d31ca6db8d7e995d4b58"},{"localRef":"u26","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:ecaac504888cef30a68ac68c2500e8a18ea93f9f002d8979ab8939da1d5e93bf","textSha256":"262f5ac29344ed9b72cd24ccda94b09cad3d363b4283237c6e0129707b18e340"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","textSha256":"b839d43c589a477882b7e23cd04af016c466f1249c06d808d70a544baa012739"},{"localRef":"n24","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ecaac504888cef30a68ac68c2500e8a18ea93f9f002d8979ab8939da1d5e93bf","reviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n26","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","reviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","sourceReviewIds":["distance-and-emergence-navigation-proposal","distance-and-emergence-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The c4→c1 direction correctly exposes an asymptotic leading-description branch of the broader limiting-spectrum question. The route retains source-specific dimensions, spectra, scales and quantum accessibility; uniqueness remains a question.","refs":["c4","c1","u26","u0","n24","n26"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn4":{"id":"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-question:fe41d31ca6db8d7e995d4b58","target":"q025-candidate-question:8e4149c7991f4ca5156a5299","type":"comparison","title":"Compare asymptotic strings with other boundary spectra","qualification":"The destination also examines finite-distance alternatives and separate SCFT cusps. Tensionlessness need not establish an infinite massless non-BPS tower, and SCFT distance is not automatically gravitational distance.","rationale":"This retains the useful supplied comparison to boundary questions beyond c1's asymptotic classification branch.","evidenceIds":["unit:3949b3aa6d882b450cf301677a2be789ba9deb1b9841383efaa93cec680efc3c","unit:899dfc82da145a9f887be1bb5dd403c23af1b62b05e4e6e46cf7b235f04eea8e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fe41d31ca6db8d7e995d4b58"},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8e4149c7991f4ca5156a5299"},{"localRef":"u13","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:899dfc82da145a9f887be1bb5dd403c23af1b62b05e4e6e46cf7b235f04eea8e","textSha256":"8213c911e74dd4a835d98d02b39183511226c2c66009867b42cf755118eb95e1"},{"localRef":"u6","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:3949b3aa6d882b450cf301677a2be789ba9deb1b9841383efaa93cec680efc3c","textSha256":"513f8cf75158596480cbfac6a64af34fd8368e7711f88b126ab964ddd22d9542"},{"localRef":"n20","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:899dfc82da145a9f887be1bb5dd403c23af1b62b05e4e6e46cf7b235f04eea8e","reviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n14","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:3949b3aa6d882b450cf301677a2be789ba9deb1b9841383efaa93cec680efc3c","reviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l0","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fe41d31ca6db8d7e995d4b58","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8e4149c7991f4ca5156a5299","candidateId":"parent-2cf7cf7591d39055bca1-challenge:link:16","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","sourceReviewIds":["distance-and-emergence-navigation-proposal","distance-and-emergence-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"This explicitly reviewed comparison offers access to boundary spectra outside c1's focal asymptotic branch. Finite-distance tensionlessness and nongravitational SCFT distance remain qualified alternatives; the arc is not inferred by reversing containment.","refs":["c1","c4","u13","u6","n20","n14","l0"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn5":{"id":"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn5","source":"q025-candidate-question:fe41d31ca6db8d7e995d4b58","target":"q025-candidate-question:f0194c1ae166dcb82da0a36c","type":"comparison","title":"Compare competing towers along quantum and coupling paths","qualification":"Specify the coupling path, frame and reference scale before comparing towers. Quantum-volume growth alone does not prove decompactification; the membrane obstruction is conditional, and finite-geometry or large-D comparisons have separate premises.","rationale":"The supplied comparison connects leading-description questions to concrete competition and accessibility issues without resolving the earlier membrane-exception question.","evidenceIds":["unit:2b01ba5e21cab3e12bf5afa37dccf7e4bee97447b291fd23ada4e331f1abb0d7","unit:a0e1121d1cb8d53bd561b63aba562c525ae2d93a0576d59dbad1842e5f222542","unit:f248474915c717e6122e6f37fe1774ac5d988ec8889d78340311ad0dda1c9cec","unit:ff07ef3ceaea434a36ce7a73250261e4b0f8a0082eba724f2db8a020c7d69a2b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fe41d31ca6db8d7e995d4b58"},{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f0194c1ae166dcb82da0a36c"},{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:a0e1121d1cb8d53bd561b63aba562c525ae2d93a0576d59dbad1842e5f222542","textSha256":"647d6eaf762fc635b8a50cf05caaef5da00b485c69157362131097f68fbc3f82"},{"localRef":"u28","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:f248474915c717e6122e6f37fe1774ac5d988ec8889d78340311ad0dda1c9cec","textSha256":"ff1c71c3db9a6dab3c8c02b76b84f5f9898a3ef83dd3e91864e83eb24c53362a"},{"localRef":"u30","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:ff07ef3ceaea434a36ce7a73250261e4b0f8a0082eba724f2db8a020c7d69a2b","textSha256":"b4f2dcd04d13b9d3781f0b521e8ce3f1d7e35eab9e1715ec56125d44424c06da"},{"localRef":"u4","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:2b01ba5e21cab3e12bf5afa37dccf7e4bee97447b291fd23ada4e331f1abb0d7","textSha256":"33971826a788a038630bcea3078bf908514e9a1e83c3cee5c41f9f72e41f4b5a"},{"localRef":"n34","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:a0e1121d1cb8d53bd561b63aba562c525ae2d93a0576d59dbad1842e5f222542","reviewId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n35","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ff07ef3ceaea434a36ce7a73250261e4b0f8a0082eba724f2db8a020c7d69a2b","reviewId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n36","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2b01ba5e21cab3e12bf5afa37dccf7e4bee97447b291fd23ada4e331f1abb0d7","reviewId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l1","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fe41d31ca6db8d7e995d4b58","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f0194c1ae166dcb82da0a36c","candidateId":"parent-2cf7cf7591d39055bca1-challenge:link:17","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn5","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn5","sourceReviewIds":["distance-and-emergence-navigation-proposal","distance-and-emergence-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The comparison usefully moves from leading descriptions to path-dependent competition and quantum accessibility. It preserves scale and frame conditions, the conditional membrane obstruction and the separate premises of finite-geometry and large-D comparisons.","refs":["c1","c5","u15","u28","u30","u4","n33","n34","n35","n36","l1"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn6":{"id":"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn6","source":"q025-candidate-question:3a00d832e32b48298c0a9b77","target":"q025-candidate-question:fe41d31ca6db8d7e995d4b58","type":"comparison","title":"Compare worldsheet control with the leading asymptotic description","qualification":"A weak sigma model for a wrapped EFT string does not by itself establish a unique critical emergent string or exclude decompactification. Unresolved Type IIA identifications and source-specific trajectories remain explicit.","rationale":"The definitions share a string/decompactification question but ask different questions about control and leading status.","evidenceIds":["unit:60fda2fa93af519b7964403dde9c27133d61f7e61f7b16d950765805ee641b09","unit:caf09c31de4c1f59f1bb9b95a124b65def3af492434891dd9f9b7f2efe0c3bbe","unit:ecaac504888cef30a68ac68c2500e8a18ea93f9f002d8979ab8939da1d5e93bf"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-3de3f7d3229146ca8e58-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3a00d832e32b48298c0a9b77"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fe41d31ca6db8d7e995d4b58"},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:caf09c31de4c1f59f1bb9b95a124b65def3af492434891dd9f9b7f2efe0c3bbe","textSha256":"1b9e2d6f8d8c755447dbc291bc7be233e8a58d98d3af34922c29d95ebe6d2fdc"},{"localRef":"u9","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:60fda2fa93af519b7964403dde9c27133d61f7e61f7b16d950765805ee641b09","textSha256":"fc0535660787969247cbe69449471fcf854e40f87c08f6531f9b593c33bf51a7"},{"localRef":"u26","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:ecaac504888cef30a68ac68c2500e8a18ea93f9f002d8979ab8939da1d5e93bf","textSha256":"262f5ac29344ed9b72cd24ccda94b09cad3d363b4283237c6e0129707b18e340"},{"localRef":"n6","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:caf09c31de4c1f59f1bb9b95a124b65def3af492434891dd9f9b7f2efe0c3bbe","reviewId":"leaf-3de3f7d3229146ca8e58-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:60fda2fa93af519b7964403dde9c27133d61f7e61f7b16d950765805ee641b09","reviewId":"leaf-3de3f7d3229146ca8e58-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n24","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ecaac504888cef30a68ac68c2500e8a18ea93f9f002d8979ab8939da1d5e93bf","reviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn6","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn6","sourceReviewIds":["distance-and-emergence-navigation-proposal","distance-and-emergence-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The route compares worldsheet control with the distinct leading-description question. Its qualification follows the supplied scopes' separation of EFT strings, critical emergent strings and unresolved identifications; it asserts no new worldsheet criterion.","refs":["c0","c1","u19","u9","u26","n6","n4","n24"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn7":{"id":"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn7","source":"q025-candidate-question:fe41d31ca6db8d7e995d4b58","target":"q025-candidate-question:32fb14ab6798cddd2cde3f5d","type":"narrower","title":"Explore five-dimensional coupling and BPS-index diagnostics","qualification":"Restrict to the supplied five-dimensional argument and tested Calabi–Yau geometries. Separate cubic-EFT reasoning from top-down index tests; reported agreement does not establish universal uniqueness.","rationale":"The source's existing specialization of c1 supports a concrete diagnostic destination.","evidenceIds":["unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fe41d31ca6db8d7e995d4b58"},{"localRef":"pq0","kind":"prior_authored_scope","objectValueSha256":"9c079b8a3faa095422a1e8ddc57670f3d006727ab6e6139b1a9412976cb4272c","notPrimary":true,"notIndependentSourceEvidence":true},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","textSha256":"b839d43c589a477882b7e23cd04af016c466f1249c06d808d70a544baa012739"},{"localRef":"n26","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","reviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn7","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn7","sourceReviewIds":["distance-and-emergence-navigation-proposal","distance-and-emergence-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The c1→pq0 direction correctly provides a concrete narrower diagnostic question. The route distinguishes bottom-up coupling reasoning from top-down tests and limits the reported agreement to the supplied setting.","refs":["c1","pq0","u0","n26"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn8":{"id":"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn8","source":"q025-candidate-question:3a00d832e32b48298c0a9b77","target":"q025-candidate-question:32fb14ab6798cddd2cde3f5d","type":"narrower","title":"Distinguish strings from decompactification in five dimensions","qualification":"Use coupling asymptotics and charged BPS/GV tests in their stated setting. These are diagnostic and geometric tests, not a universal worldsheet-control criterion.","rationale":"The five-dimensional diagnostic branch is already explicit in c0 and can share the same narrower destination used by c1.","evidenceIds":["unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-3de3f7d3229146ca8e58-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3a00d832e32b48298c0a9b77"},{"localRef":"pq0","kind":"prior_authored_scope","objectValueSha256":"9c079b8a3faa095422a1e8ddc57670f3d006727ab6e6139b1a9412976cb4272c","notPrimary":true,"notIndependentSourceEvidence":true},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","textSha256":"b839d43c589a477882b7e23cd04af016c466f1249c06d808d70a544baa012739"},{"localRef":"n8","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","reviewId":"leaf-3de3f7d3229146ca8e58-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn8","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn8","sourceReviewIds":["distance-and-emergence-navigation-proposal","distance-and-emergence-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The c0→pq0 direction exposes c0's explicit five-dimensional branch and reuses the same bounded destination as pn7. The qualification correctly prevents these diagnostics from becoming a universal worldsheet-control test.","refs":["c0","pq0","u0","n8"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn9":{"id":"navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn9","source":"q025-candidate-question:0cfe4a3951d071f1ddc2d078","target":"q025-candidate-question:8e4149c7991f4ca5156a5299","type":"comparison","title":"Compare decay-rate questions with physical-sector identification","qualification":"For the higher-form extremality route, sector existence and force matching are independent requirements. The charged tower may be subleading; neither universal existence nor a quantitative decay bound follows from this comparison.","rationale":"The exact paired notes for u7 support comparing the quantitative program with the physical-spectrum questions it leaves open.","evidenceIds":["unit:52aadd573c21334fc996ec94283afef5ba6e7bc0ad18575c6918c1ff0c46276d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-bea4433b3d92cecb48c7-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0cfe4a3951d071f1ddc2d078"},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8e4149c7991f4ca5156a5299"},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":17,"unitId":"unit:52aadd573c21334fc996ec94283afef5ba6e7bc0ad18575c6918c1ff0c46276d","textSha256":"e8627f42bcdb4543b2abc74e405f57c9e14e6be4014182bd8eb35b597391c6c4"},{"localRef":"n18","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:52aadd573c21334fc996ec94283afef5ba6e7bc0ad18575c6918c1ff0c46276d","reviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n31","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:52aadd573c21334fc996ec94283afef5ba6e7bc0ad18575c6918c1ff0c46276d","reviewId":"leaf-bea4433b3d92cecb48c7-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn9","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn9","sourceReviewIds":["distance-and-emergence-navigation-proposal","distance-and-emergence-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn9","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The comparison links decay-rate questions to physical-sector identification without asserting that the higher-form route applies universally. Its qualification preserves independent existence and force-matching requirements and permits a subleading charged tower; no quantitative bound is inferred.","refs":["c3","c4","u7","n18","n31"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:route:pn9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:entropy-and-extremality:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v2:entropy-and-extremality:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-question:4a96ce81d3c4841657c6029d","target":"q025-candidate-question:450e8e5a5838a796c971a3bb","type":"narrower","title":"Examine the entropy and conjugate responses","qualification":"For the selected AdS examples and specified small constant cosmological-term deformation; the announced relations and their universality remain unverified.","rationale":"This selects the explicit response-calculation component of the existing broader question.","evidenceIds":["unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-203fd6a716a0a1f60d6f-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2ed35c0e62570949d976b307"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3352e6028241d142f5d-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4a96ce81d3c4841657c6029d"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","textSha256":"e8856871240afd65c442d813c1c0d7d749cf50c919e677fec9e41683182f50cc"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","reviewId":"leaf-203fd6a716a0a1f60d6f-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n1","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","reviewId":"leaf-a3352e6028241d142f5d-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:entropy-and-extremality:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["entropy-and-extremality-navigation-proposal","entropy-and-extremality-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction is correct. The title selects the explicit entropy and conjugate-response component, and the qualification preserves the selected examples, specified deformation and unverified status of the announced relations.","refs":["c0","c1","u0","n0","n1"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:entropy-and-extremality:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:entropy-and-extremality:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v2:entropy-and-extremality:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-question:4a96ce81d3c4841657c6029d","target":"q025-candidate-question:51d213e52260433a1885e2e3","type":"narrower","title":"Assess the proposed WGC-like interpretation","qualification":"For the same selected examples and deformation; no universal WGC claim, BPS premise or common charge–mass normalization is adopted.","rationale":"This selects the interpretation assessment already included in the broader question.","evidenceIds":["unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-203fd6a716a0a1f60d6f-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2ed35c0e62570949d976b307"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3352e6028241d142f5d-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4a96ce81d3c4841657c6029d"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","textSha256":"e8856871240afd65c442d813c1c0d7d749cf50c919e677fec9e41683182f50cc"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","reviewId":"leaf-203fd6a716a0a1f60d6f-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n1","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","reviewId":"leaf-a3352e6028241d142f5d-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:entropy-and-extremality:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["entropy-and-extremality-navigation-proposal","entropy-and-extremality-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"This correctly leads from c1 to its interpretation-assessment component. Its qualification does not assume universal WGC validity, supersymmetry or a common charge–mass normalization.","refs":["c0","c1","u0","n0","n1"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:entropy-and-extremality:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v2:entropy-and-extremality:pn2":{"id":"navigation:v2:entropy-and-extremality:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-question:450e8e5a5838a796c971a3bb","target":"q025-candidate-question:51d213e52260433a1885e2e3","type":"related_question","title":"What supports the WGC-like reading?","qualification":"The source investigates both targets under the same cosmological deformation. An entropy derivative identity alone is not admitted as a quantum-gravity bound, and no implication between the targets is asserted.","rationale":"The whole description supports moving from the calculation question to its separately stated interpretive question without claiming a demonstrated physical connection.","evidenceIds":["unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","textSha256":"e8856871240afd65c442d813c1c0d7d749cf50c919e677fec9e41683182f50cc"},{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-203fd6a716a0a1f60d6f-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2ed35c0e62570949d976b307"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3352e6028241d142f5d-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4a96ce81d3c4841657c6029d"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","reviewId":"leaf-203fd6a716a0a1f60d6f-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n1","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","reviewId":"leaf-a3352e6028241d142f5d-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:entropy-and-extremality:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["entropy-and-extremality-navigation-proposal","entropy-and-extremality-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"u0 explicitly investigates both targets under the same deformation, supporting this directed related-question choice. The route expressly withholds implication and does not turn the response question into a demonstrated method or premise for the interpretation.","refs":["u0","c0","c1","n0","n1"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:entropy-and-extremality:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44","target":"q025-candidate-region:1a284aee5a8a7637c41d3c4d","type":"related_question","title":"Examine fluxless stabilization and decompactification barriers","qualification":"The fluxless M-theory racetrack and hidden-meson construction retains a separate barrier-width target. Candidate existence, barrier properties and correction control require separate assessment; the route certifies none of their outcomes.","rationale":"c0 explicitly preserves this construction branch within the shared de Sitter stability-and-control area. The route adds access without asserting total containment.","evidenceIds":["unit:148e545792b1782dc240c5aa9a1996d599b189b76551bd6ae529c44c5de3287d","unit:19639e9d1a90593d9080f4b0ab212960dac48dda0834342e34cd41bfe0299c81"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44"},{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:1a284aee5a8a7637c41d3c4d"},{"localRef":"u18","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:19639e9d1a90593d9080f4b0ab212960dac48dda0834342e34cd41bfe0299c81","textSha256":"27e651b37c13f07707202efd848cdd0fc5ed740a8bc06d64834d90155f769cdb"},{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:148e545792b1782dc240c5aa9a1996d599b189b76551bd6ae529c44c5de3287d","textSha256":"5a3b437de292b32aeaed187be8e4b54754fdd4603c87ff8bf43a16078dc7c9b9"},{"localRef":"n11","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:19639e9d1a90593d9080f4b0ab212960dac48dda0834342e34cd41bfe0299c81","reviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n13","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:148e545792b1782dc240c5aa9a1996d599b189b76551bd6ae529c44c5de3287d","reviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The outgoing choice points to an explicit branch of c0: fluxless racetrack/hidden-meson stabilization with a separate barrier-width target. related_question correctly avoids total containment, and the qualification separates existence, barrier properties and correction control without transferring a calculation.","refs":["c0","c5","u15","u18","n11","n13"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44","target":"q025-candidate-region:4358a34a0cf4ae04154d032c","type":"related_question","title":"Explore evolving backgrounds, effective actions and state interpretations","qualification":"Fixed Newton coupling belongs to the specified evolving-IIB question. Wilsonian integration and vacuum-versus-coherent-state interpretation remain separate open targets; higher-dimensional behavior does not establish controlled four-dimensional EFT.","rationale":"c2 provides explicit access to these linked but distinct effective-description questions within the shared construction area.","evidenceIds":["unit:07dbefdad760ee366f46d17ea86b866308b5ddf8cad29cd0e7980d7f2cbb0d61","unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","unit:0a7894cd67c1ab57b2737e741969081e9a796494033d35f595b85bd6f18c0dc2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:4358a34a0cf4ae04154d032c"},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:07dbefdad760ee366f46d17ea86b866308b5ddf8cad29cd0e7980d7f2cbb0d61","textSha256":"58128a9eef2ad0da2fe2db3fe352c0acdc0b46f95c56972bcce83beb403e8c46"},{"localRef":"u8","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","textSha256":"577541ee725dd3912cb102c363b9c596722c2226efa21fceee9907ca9e979d2c"},{"localRef":"u9","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:0a7894cd67c1ab57b2737e741969081e9a796494033d35f595b85bd6f18c0dc2","textSha256":"33271933bb80163e63b728cbf8a32254f6634cdf941371a16bfa434873201849"},{"localRef":"n14","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n15","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:07dbefdad760ee366f46d17ea86b866308b5ddf8cad29cd0e7980d7f2cbb0d61","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n16","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0a7894cd67c1ab57b2737e741969081e9a796494033d35f595b85bd6f18c0dc2","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c2 explicitly exposes the evolving-background, effective-action and state questions named by the route. The qualification keeps fixed Newton coupling local to u7 and integration/state questions separately open; it does not infer controlled four-dimensional EFT from higher-dimensional behavior.","refs":["c2","c5","u7","u8","u9","n14","n15","n16"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn2":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44","target":"q025-candidate-region:9340c76876dcc74d64b994c3","type":"comparison","title":"Compare compact and noncompact construction assumptions","qualification":"Compact F-theory-derived models, noncompact comparisons, duality-patched backgrounds and bubble-wall alternatives retain different source and control assumptions. Bulk pedigree does not resolve localized singular-source interpretation or establish a controlled string vacuum.","rationale":"c6 explicitly exposes alternatives whose comparison is useful for construction and control, without equating their realizations.","evidenceIds":["unit:03394bf20ceebe5d8fa665d97dfd6b5e900d27627f13bc5286f807cfb8cacd4f","unit:0cfada55cef2a9abf0e7d7ebf8ce24d1982d6613b658361ae2df64e16ce35818"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44"},{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0dd2c748860e78df66b5-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:9340c76876dcc74d64b994c3"},{"localRef":"u3","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:03394bf20ceebe5d8fa665d97dfd6b5e900d27627f13bc5286f807cfb8cacd4f","textSha256":"6f6c2d39378d0035ee3663c0aadb53c4042f5808f87871e5860211c4cd78c418"},{"localRef":"u11","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:0cfada55cef2a9abf0e7d7ebf8ce24d1982d6613b658361ae2df64e16ce35818","textSha256":"7c98553d1ac3a5b1a6a463d0d9e0b67e87b7ab07acdfceab7fd39f7e3a83b2cc"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:03394bf20ceebe5d8fa665d97dfd6b5e900d27627f13bc5286f807cfb8cacd4f","reviewId":"leaf-0dd2c748860e78df66b5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n2","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0cfada55cef2a9abf0e7d7ebf8ce24d1982d6613b658361ae2df64e16ce35818","reviewId":"leaf-0dd2c748860e78df66b5-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The c6 definition supplies construction alternatives, and n2 explicitly distinguishes the compact F-theory route from noncompact comparison. The comparison arc asserts an examination of assumptions, not equivalence or a derived compact/noncompact correspondence; localized-source limitations remain visible.","refs":["c5","c6","u3","u11","n0","n2"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn3":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-region:b6066d8938d079cd5060a13f","target":"q025-candidate-region:38d8722ca9d7cf8552714286","type":"related_question","title":"Connect survey tests with potential protection and initial conditions","qualification":"The survey witness retains its 2018 assumptions, conditional conjectures and prospective forecasts. Potential protection, conditional axion realization and cosmological preparation are separate questions, not consequences of an observational fit.","rationale":"The repeated survey witness establishes shared access, while c1 explicitly supplies the broader preparation and protection questions.","evidenceIds":["unit:3f6f5dd44558b038277c91cc115224366734a2feb2ed3db55e6bcf3ddc877423","unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-496f2098d49aa45afa29-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:b6066d8938d079cd5060a13f"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:38d8722ca9d7cf8552714286"},{"localRef":"u26","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:3f6f5dd44558b038277c91cc115224366734a2feb2ed3db55e6bcf3ddc877423","textSha256":"d0429c01adde15bde004eadb730b4994e13afa55f9bee6aa08b8d9aff7b39aa9"},{"localRef":"u28","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f","textSha256":"6f9181871522cbd0d06e518351d25a55bfb8caa17cf99c6ee0af8d47118d4ca7"},{"localRef":"n10","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:3f6f5dd44558b038277c91cc115224366734a2feb2ed3db55e6bcf3ddc877423","reviewId":"leaf-496f2098d49aa45afa29-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n30","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f","reviewId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n31","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:3f6f5dd44558b038277c91cc115224366734a2feb2ed3db55e6bcf3ddc877423","reviewId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The shared survey witness and c1's explicit protection/preparation scope support this related-question journey. Its wording separates dated prospective forecasts from microscopic and initial-condition tests. Reviewing the arc does not resolve c8's pending admission qualification.","refs":["c1","c8","u26","u28","n10","n30","n31"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn4":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-region:38d8722ca9d7cf8552714286","target":"q025-candidate-region:d0aad74f894499b6a6598789","type":"narrower","title":"Explore quintessence histories, interactions and observational tests","qualification":"Thermal and modified-gravity alternatives retain their separate status. Low-redshift H0 fits, proposed light-tower effects and the 2004 clustering forecast use distinct, source-dated assumptions; a higher fitted H0 does not establish an acceptable joint fit.","rationale":"c9 provides a narrower set of specified dynamics and observational questions within c1.","evidenceIds":["unit:128622e23dbd0a7aabb43506baba17e3b38181fb22558a0db701685bfbda855c","unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","unit:2a381bd49c66b3c9d2ca626bbb6a74ef1e930a95de8e042839b64246011c7c13"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:38d8722ca9d7cf8552714286"},{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:d0aad74f894499b6a6598789"},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:128622e23dbd0a7aabb43506baba17e3b38181fb22558a0db701685bfbda855c","textSha256":"a660ffc2b2fbf6656f11b1445e2d7f7f0133c9f14939c6dbf9cc1ec754ea37bb"},{"localRef":"u20","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","textSha256":"fabb290146b115b17311b3b2c38b0343ebb029cf637ecf49554b7bea58f59a65"},{"localRef":"u21","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:2a381bd49c66b3c9d2ca626bbb6a74ef1e930a95de8e042839b64246011c7c13","textSha256":"3e4df71313d0e1da3d4bb1e42c9bf9c9ca95aa9913a0c6041a4d1b211b543a71"},{"localRef":"n7","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2a381bd49c66b3c9d2ca626bbb6a74ef1e930a95de8e042839b64246011c7c13","reviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n8","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","reviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n9","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:128622e23dbd0a7aabb43506baba17e3b38181fb22558a0db701685bfbda855c","reviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction matches pd2. c9 directly supplies histories, interactions and observational investigations; the route retains distinct historical clustering, fitted-H0 and proposed light-tower contexts and does not claim an acceptable joint fit.","refs":["c1","c9","u14","u20","u21","n7","n8","n9"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn5":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn5","source":"q025-candidate-region:38d8722ca9d7cf8552714286","target":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","type":"narrower","title":"Check potential stability and particle-sector couplings","qualification":"Quantum protection, suppression of matter couplings and viable preparation remain separate tests. Radion force and gravitational-evolution bounds are source-specific; the Higgs comparison remains conditional, and dynamical uplifting is not an established quintessence realization.","rationale":"c10 develops the interaction and microscopic-consistency questions explicitly included in c1.","evidenceIds":["unit:04bbd27e171530f1ca15b8becbfbeffffb614e8898f98cab5e356e060126335f","unit:0b53e5e6646ffb16fadf3ea1c0783332fb56433f06fc8ab4cd05b3aedfc53b22","unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:38d8722ca9d7cf8552714286"},{"localRef":"c10","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"},{"localRef":"u5","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:04bbd27e171530f1ca15b8becbfbeffffb614e8898f98cab5e356e060126335f","textSha256":"59aad55be246c2b7103521e6e167551c32116b5218eac2eeb736a7100bea2175"},{"localRef":"u10","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:0b53e5e6646ffb16fadf3ea1c0783332fb56433f06fc8ab4cd05b3aedfc53b22","textSha256":"b998dd1246c342a3829648479721fdbed1695ea2cfd93d77a6e710895c16cf7a"},{"localRef":"u12","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","textSha256":"872abab4bbe5138f2c8b321340aa88c4ff1cc001b80a8d6b193db22b78f358a0"},{"localRef":"u28","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f","textSha256":"6f9181871522cbd0d06e518351d25a55bfb8caa17cf99c6ee0af8d47118d4ca7"},{"localRef":"n3","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:04bbd27e171530f1ca15b8becbfbeffffb614e8898f98cab5e356e060126335f","reviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0b53e5e6646ffb16fadf3ea1c0783332fb56433f06fc8ab4cd05b3aedfc53b22","reviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n5","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","reviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n6","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f","reviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn5","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn5","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction matches pd3 and leads to c10's explicit coupling and microscopic tests. The qualification preserves source-specific radion constraints, conditional Higgs claims and the distinction between dynamical uplifting and an established quintessence realization.","refs":["c1","c10","u5","u10","u12","u28","n3","n4","n5","n6"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn6":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn6","source":"q025-candidate-region:52c981d65bc67d01afc13507","target":"q025-candidate-region:5fb081b9efa119868d87802b","type":"related_question","title":"Distinguish microscopic and apparent phantom behavior","qualification":"A microscopic w below minus one and an apparent phantom inference are alternative targets. Background agreement does not establish kinetic, perturbative or microscopic equivalence, and matter allocation remains source-specific.","rationale":"c4 explicitly organizes the phantom alternatives and effective-representation questions relevant to c3's mechanism and inference concerns.","evidenceIds":["unit:120c2cb0b711c90fe2146fad6110c576a6d9f5bb61a2282eb9193a32adbc0781","unit:3d994014aaf88ac04db134c38b6908054d6a9f340c1bf7e922de4709ee42cd1c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:52c981d65bc67d01afc13507"},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-31256938ec369089ee3f-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:5fb081b9efa119868d87802b"},{"localRef":"u13","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:120c2cb0b711c90fe2146fad6110c576a6d9f5bb61a2282eb9193a32adbc0781","textSha256":"ad04617a61200994d11e309d25d3cfd88ed07edac4ec809eda6c289ab2113a07"},{"localRef":"u25","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:3d994014aaf88ac04db134c38b6908054d6a9f340c1bf7e922de4709ee42cd1c","textSha256":"bb0b66ac6ae5dd66fa13a5ec56f0f0640a3582bd5efc8e6c986a7afc7a02521d"},{"localRef":"n26","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:120c2cb0b711c90fe2146fad6110c576a6d9f5bb61a2282eb9193a32adbc0781","reviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n35","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:3d994014aaf88ac04db134c38b6908054d6a9f340c1bf7e922de4709ee42cd1c","reviewId":"parent-31256938ec369089ee3f-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn6","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn6","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c4 explicitly supports the microscopic/apparent phantom distinction through u25 and n35. u13 supplies a separate matter-allocation caution, not a demonstrated phantom mechanism. The related-question arc and qualification preserve that separation.","refs":["c3","c4","u13","u25","n26","n35"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn7":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn7","source":"q025-candidate-region:5fb081b9efa119868d87802b","target":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","type":"narrower","title":"Explore scalar motion, field travel and conditional tests","qualification":"Kinetic sectors, field-space dynamics and conjecture versions remain source-specific. The screened and flat-potential descriptions do not identify an original-gradient condition; the assisted trajectory's epoch is unspecified, and turning-model clustering prospects remain qualitative.","rationale":"c7 supplies a focused scalar, interacting and geometric direction within c4's broader mechanism-and-inference question.","evidenceIds":["unit:019ab837a07be33eefed31acf4d2f4d82286eac30c505a864fc061a4465e4eda","unit:0284bc6fd0575aed2a997e87f0db3d9563ecb1c3a6f25ec3769d4ae8c2296ebf","unit:03cf30d4c866480f1c3ceb6e63236eb4ab717b2990737dc19dfbf8ef5e726755","unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-31256938ec369089ee3f-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:5fb081b9efa119868d87802b"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:019ab837a07be33eefed31acf4d2f4d82286eac30c505a864fc061a4465e4eda","textSha256":"f8d11a2184aa38c5e080082342cb5f413eddad33705e4d71f748d799cb75e582"},{"localRef":"u1","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:0284bc6fd0575aed2a997e87f0db3d9563ecb1c3a6f25ec3769d4ae8c2296ebf","textSha256":"5b43317b405dc33147e3ed67205e6373cf4e2210122a6fcc1a1d253c6eb2c666"},{"localRef":"u4","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:03cf30d4c866480f1c3ceb6e63236eb4ab717b2990737dc19dfbf8ef5e726755","textSha256":"a159ef83938de55483aee0530fe87e666cd4c9107f9b1538c19d9f01de5d1232"},{"localRef":"u29","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","textSha256":"410cbe69e10e8931e4f852f0f34dd0ac3831bc8f593c5a18121d017595ba25ea"},{"localRef":"n17","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0284bc6fd0575aed2a997e87f0db3d9563ecb1c3a6f25ec3769d4ae8c2296ebf","reviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n18","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:03cf30d4c866480f1c3ceb6e63236eb4ab717b2990737dc19dfbf8ef5e726755","reviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n19","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:019ab837a07be33eefed31acf4d2f4d82286eac30c505a864fc061a4465e4eda","reviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n33","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","reviewId":"parent-31256938ec369089ee3f-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn7","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn7","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction matches pd6. c7 supplies scalar motion, field travel and conditional tests, while its mapped notes support the precise limits on conjecture versions, the assisted trajectory's unspecified epoch and qualitative clustering prospects.","refs":["c4","c7","u0","u1","u4","u29","n17","n18","n19","n20","n33"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn8":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn8","source":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","target":"q025-candidate-region:d0aad74f894499b6a6598789","type":"comparison","title":"Compare dynamical mechanisms with expansion and clustering tests","qualification":"Turning dynamics, coupled low-redshift fits, proposed light-tower effects and historical clustering forecasts retain separate mechanisms and assumptions. This comparison transfers neither a signal prediction nor a likelihood between them.","rationale":"The two scopes make a useful comparison between dynamical questions and specified observational investigations without identifying their models.","evidenceIds":["unit:128622e23dbd0a7aabb43506baba17e3b38181fb22558a0db701685bfbda855c","unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","unit:2a381bd49c66b3c9d2ca626bbb6a74ef1e930a95de8e042839b64246011c7c13","unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"},{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:d0aad74f894499b6a6598789"},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:128622e23dbd0a7aabb43506baba17e3b38181fb22558a0db701685bfbda855c","textSha256":"a660ffc2b2fbf6656f11b1445e2d7f7f0133c9f14939c6dbf9cc1ec754ea37bb"},{"localRef":"u20","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","textSha256":"fabb290146b115b17311b3b2c38b0343ebb029cf637ecf49554b7bea58f59a65"},{"localRef":"u21","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:2a381bd49c66b3c9d2ca626bbb6a74ef1e930a95de8e042839b64246011c7c13","textSha256":"3e4df71313d0e1da3d4bb1e42c9bf9c9ca95aa9913a0c6041a4d1b211b543a71"},{"localRef":"u29","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","textSha256":"410cbe69e10e8931e4f852f0f34dd0ac3831bc8f593c5a18121d017595ba25ea"},{"localRef":"n7","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2a381bd49c66b3c9d2ca626bbb6a74ef1e930a95de8e042839b64246011c7c13","reviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n8","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","reviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n9","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:128622e23dbd0a7aabb43506baba17e3b38181fb22558a0db701685bfbda855c","reviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n33","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","reviewId":"parent-31256938ec369089ee3f-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn8","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn8","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The explicit comparison is useful between c7's dynamical mechanisms and c9's expansion/clustering investigations. The route correctly withholds signal or likelihood transfer between turning models, coupled fits, proposed light-tower effects and historical forecasts.","refs":["c7","c9","u14","u20","u21","u29","n7","n8","n9","n20","n33"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn9":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:pn9","source":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","target":"q025-candidate-region:f98dedd88f1fbf85423f3af8","type":"comparison","title":"Compare microscopic constraints with preparation and cosmic futures","qualification":"DBI extensions, gauge friction, tracker termination and brane-potential origins remain separate targets. Conjectural slope motivation does not transfer to ordinary tracker or DBI work, and potential protection alone establishes no acceleration endpoint.","rationale":"c11 exposes preparation, kinetic and future-evolution questions complementary to c10's coupling and quantum-consistency focus; the shared axion witness does not equate these targets.","evidenceIds":["unit:21e884874da8a5686fb34bf9708e01870420077b57a8f828f69438e9c128db10","unit:2b493f37c145ae35bdda98ba2b10a9d148f23baa91dcafe1e93d8c4d9671e9ed","unit:2b534c5c748c72829faefceb4c662865dc9a80147f6a5952f8fa74a0d648d80b","unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c10","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"},{"localRef":"c11","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-adb0d0a7d3119878efcf-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:f98dedd88f1fbf85423f3af8"},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:21e884874da8a5686fb34bf9708e01870420077b57a8f828f69438e9c128db10","textSha256":"bd7fc93b5ceade5cf78ee751d2c1f722e266190df3f29a9b41d8748cf492ef86"},{"localRef":"u22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:2b493f37c145ae35bdda98ba2b10a9d148f23baa91dcafe1e93d8c4d9671e9ed","textSha256":"0868951dcc98e63193c61ffe51b7b6c2497280d9ec2c746f16598fa5e0e5b920"},{"localRef":"u23","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:2b534c5c748c72829faefceb4c662865dc9a80147f6a5952f8fa74a0d648d80b","textSha256":"ff5f4f6f825e6f3c1c207893833c64ccbf508e3ca476804b2916771fe59db8b8"},{"localRef":"u28","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f","textSha256":"6f9181871522cbd0d06e518351d25a55bfb8caa17cf99c6ee0af8d47118d4ca7"},{"localRef":"n6","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f","reviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n21","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:21e884874da8a5686fb34bf9708e01870420077b57a8f828f69438e9c128db10","reviewId":"leaf-adb0d0a7d3119878efcf-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n22","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2b534c5c748c72829faefceb4c662865dc9a80147f6a5952f8fa74a0d648d80b","reviewId":"leaf-adb0d0a7d3119878efcf-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n24","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2b493f37c145ae35bdda98ba2b10a9d148f23baa91dcafe1e93d8c4d9671e9ed","reviewId":"leaf-adb0d0a7d3119878efcf-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n25","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f","reviewId":"leaf-adb0d0a7d3119878efcf-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn9","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn9","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-00-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn9","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c11 explicitly supplies preparation, kinetic extensions and future-evolution questions complementary to c10. The comparison preserves separate tracker-termination and brane-origin targets, and does not export gauge-friction slope motivation into DBI or ordinary tracker work.","refs":["c10","c11","u19","u22","u23","u28","n6","n21","n22","n24","n25"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-00:route:pn9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-question:bccc113e1f2909a24d10640b","target":"q-historical-uhecr-suppression","type":"related_question","title":"Compare Auger and HiRes suppression definitions","qualification":"Use the frozen historical measurements. Auger's 50%-deficit suppression energy is not automatically HiRes's cutoff; preserve the distinct reported scales, uncertainty conventions and unequal inherited reading depth.","rationale":"Provides access from reported significance and features to the shared measurement-comparison target without asserting identical experiment-level questions.","evidenceIds":["unit:306affd2f71614518f8b02535b471e11e6f87c38e95eb27e2cbb67de5131b4d4","unit:8bb9290e0c6baf0fb1ad7c21c15591676b37660343311852ca5a04b453c20cc8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"admitted:q-historical-uhecr-suppression","candidateId":"q-historical-uhecr-suppression"},{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bccc113e1f2909a24d10640b"},{"localRef":"u11","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:306affd2f71614518f8b02535b471e11e6f87c38e95eb27e2cbb67de5131b4d4","textSha256":"518faf5485a636f8075080dc98f7ef8adfc50bdb5fc8d0a9b43bb75f050db947"},{"localRef":"u22","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:8bb9290e0c6baf0fb1ad7c21c15591676b37660343311852ca5a04b453c20cc8","textSha256":"3beee23af8db5d041d9cf833e99b1aaf29baaf0736d5242725d4c8919c12272c"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:306affd2f71614518f8b02535b471e11e6f87c38e95eb27e2cbb67de5131b4d4","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n2","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:8bb9290e0c6baf0fb1ad7c21c15591676b37660343311852ca5a04b453c20cc8","reviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n53","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:306affd2f71614518f8b02535b471e11e6f87c38e95eb27e2cbb67de5131b4d4","reviewId":"kk-compact-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n55","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:8bb9290e0c6baf0fb1ad7c21c15591676b37660343311852ca5a04b453c20cc8","reviewId":"kk-compact-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The related-question route offers the uncertainty and definition comparison at c0 while preserving c6's empirical scope, distinct reported scales and unequal inherited reading depth.","refs":["c0","c6","u11","u22","n0","n2","n53","n55"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","target":"q025-candidate-question:157d528f72cc02f9ee13ebcc","type":"narrower","title":"Test cold, warm and excited-state compatibility","qualification":"Keep conjecture coefficients conditional and scenario-dependent perturbation relations separate. Assess earlier self-reproduction in its own regime under the original criteria; it does not directly predict the observed small perturbations.","rationale":"The complete definitions and paired attributions support a narrower scenario question. This refines the unadmitted comparison candidate without equating its temporal regimes.","evidenceIds":["unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:157d528f72cc02f9ee13ebcc"},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7"},{"localRef":"u16","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","textSha256":"d9a66617be22f12d5d7e95bccf36e2e7cda114245831c357c0f8d03bb4647c70"},{"localRef":"u35","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","textSha256":"d5a8a587374a18807a0e7f886b8a73c00998c7e8e9eb910ff4eccaddde06b5d9"},{"localRef":"n11","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","reviewId":"leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n12","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","reviewId":"leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n16","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n22","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l2","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:157d528f72cc02f9ee13ebcc","candidateId":"parent-570548e969849fcc2e72-challenge:link:41","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Broader-to-narrower direction is correct. c4's own attributions support c1's scenario selection and separately assessed earlier self-reproduction; the qualification prevents transferring perturbation formulas or predictions between regimes.","refs":["c1","c4","n11","n12","n16","n22","l2"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn2":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","target":"q025-candidate-question:2c61283813c36fc170920977","type":"related_question","title":"Which fields and distances enter the test?","qualification":"Retained spectators, source-specific cutoffs, constituent excursions, path lengths and geodesic separations require separate assessment. Canonical slow-roll translation does not apply unchanged to turning or curvature-coupled models.","rationale":"Field selection and geometry provide useful adjacent checks while retaining targets beyond c4's inference question.","evidenceIds":["unit:5976e0c1e14fa7d1c220bf7fbece19ae41029967df4767020f9bd7a403e42e68","unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","unit:9549828709a1b10d13254a69e7a754ed0034f626c0afb00250929075de867c41"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2c61283813c36fc170920977"},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7"},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:5976e0c1e14fa7d1c220bf7fbece19ae41029967df4767020f9bd7a403e42e68","textSha256":"5e82c901fd9f75fd919aa4c1a1304c3ea42e25c4812d5c53411c6e178f7fa3f5"},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","textSha256":"98bd5a83f4714e1f96215725578c3da50945911b03fb378b583073669c44fc3a"},{"localRef":"u24","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:9549828709a1b10d13254a69e7a754ed0034f626c0afb00250929075de867c41","textSha256":"c5ac8efd320a36cd0684342173a8ffc292e00a7435ddeefd200a3f035ebc7c37"},{"localRef":"n24","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","reviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n25","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:5976e0c1e14fa7d1c220bf7fbece19ae41029967df4767020f9bd7a403e42e68","reviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n29","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:9549828709a1b10d13254a69e7a754ed0034f626c0afb00250929075de867c41","reviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l1","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2c61283813c36fc170920977","candidateId":"parent-570548e969849fcc2e72-challenge:link:40","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"A related-question route fits the additional field-retention, cutoff and distance targets. Neither strict containment nor general applicability of the canonical translation is asserted.","refs":["c2","c4","u14","u19","u24","n24","n25","n29","l1"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn3":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-question:2c61283813c36fc170920977","target":"q025-candidate-question:cad9d896bc3a9b24629980d2","type":"comparison","title":"Compare field-range limits with eternal-inflation tests","qualification":"Compare only explicitly adopted range and cutoff assumptions. Assisted slow-roll self-reproduction, single-inflaton calculations and false-vacuum persistence remain different settings; no common cutoff law or universal prohibition follows.","rationale":"The supplied descriptions connect admissibility and continuation through conditional range or cutoff questions while preserving their distinct targets.","evidenceIds":["unit:18be9d6ece9a4cb2487124568b990f795211771fc7ec2009f69fcdfa06beeea6","unit:45bf432df114925c7cc10ce941e0f0f8f5e16db41b4c75ae535b17c9be1ee723","unit:75204dd5f60e873d8304fa07409d3dcb9ac7013cb31456a3ff7b542ea30ed3a0","unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2c61283813c36fc170920977"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cad9d896bc3a9b24629980d2"},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","textSha256":"98bd5a83f4714e1f96215725578c3da50945911b03fb378b583073669c44fc3a"},{"localRef":"u4","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:18be9d6ece9a4cb2487124568b990f795211771fc7ec2009f69fcdfa06beeea6","textSha256":"afd04c7b91697e7fbc2fac1274d273f4216092f786ab169387355e3ae216ced5"},{"localRef":"u13","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:45bf432df114925c7cc10ce941e0f0f8f5e16db41b4c75ae535b17c9be1ee723","textSha256":"1a5b58340f802792a13708ef1744be1685999360c7d1e36d0c740a49c754e32a"},{"localRef":"u18","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:75204dd5f60e873d8304fa07409d3dcb9ac7013cb31456a3ff7b542ea30ed3a0","textSha256":"44c9a54185aecc4b0359b66daa2a7f13757fed058fcd1f18018dcd6088a44bb2"},{"localRef":"u35","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","textSha256":"d5a8a587374a18807a0e7f886b8a73c00998c7e8e9eb910ff4eccaddde06b5d9"},{"localRef":"n24","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","reviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n35","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:45bf432df114925c7cc10ce941e0f0f8f5e16db41b4c75ae535b17c9be1ee723","reviewId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n36","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:18be9d6ece9a4cb2487124568b990f795211771fc7ec2009f69fcdfa06beeea6","reviewId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n37","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:75204dd5f60e873d8304fa07409d3dcb9ac7013cb31456a3ff7b542ea30ed3a0","reviewId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n39","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","reviewId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The explicit comparison is supported by the cutoff and self-reproduction descriptions. Its qualification preserves assisted, single-field and false-vacuum settings without inventing a common restriction.","refs":["c2","c7","u19","u4","u13","u18","u35","n24","n35","n36","n37","n39"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn4":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-question:5f89175e5c6793ff5e4dcefc","target":"q025-candidate-question:cad9d896bc3a9b24629980d2","type":"method_for","title":"Check the criteria used in continuation arguments","qualification":"Apply normalization, branch and cutoff-applicability checks only where the continuation argument adopts them. Quotient topology, S-matrix premises and quantum-breaking proposals do not become interchangeable tests.","rationale":"Uses the diagnostic question as a method for assessing specified restriction arguments, without supplying a new lifetime relation.","evidenceIds":["unit:2af235ec954a736d318bc8bbdea00d3cd91e17931b5deb5af04564b8c2bc4fe0","unit:c0b479b56d09cc435e7d91beb8841b897ce3ea8df951c6c471bcf6e2efcdeaaf","unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5f89175e5c6793ff5e4dcefc"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cad9d896bc3a9b24629980d2"},{"localRef":"u9","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:2af235ec954a736d318bc8bbdea00d3cd91e17931b5deb5af04564b8c2bc4fe0","textSha256":"90a789e82f6b1a80341d0f89f8027a7adc79893ea86bf99ef3a0e43a0ac99112"},{"localRef":"u32","kind":"description","unitIndex":77,"unitId":"unit:c0b479b56d09cc435e7d91beb8841b897ce3ea8df951c6c471bcf6e2efcdeaaf","textSha256":"226d84478bffc1e224c861a04e44610c4fba62d3f2c8a643c7c7b764f58e6038"},{"localRef":"u35","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","textSha256":"d5a8a587374a18807a0e7f886b8a73c00998c7e8e9eb910ff4eccaddde06b5d9"},{"localRef":"n39","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","reviewId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n41","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c0b479b56d09cc435e7d91beb8841b897ce3ea8df951c6c471bcf6e2efcdeaaf","reviewId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n45","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2af235ec954a736d318bc8bbdea00d3cd91e17931b5deb5af04564b8c2bc4fe0","reviewId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The method_for direction correctly runs from diagnostic checks to the question using them. Applicability is conditional; no quotient-topology, S-matrix or quantum-breaking result is transferred between frameworks.","refs":["c3","c7","u9","u32","u35","n39","n41","n45"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn5":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn5","source":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","target":"q025-candidate-question:8ed595b668e0ce28a313a22f","type":"narrower","title":"Compare conjecture versions across inflation models","qualification":"Retain each Higgs, curvature, brane, multifield or DBI model's action, approximation and historical observational inputs. An announced joint test is not a successful joint result; refined OR and combined criteria remain distinct.","rationale":"Offers a concrete named-model specialization of the broader conditional inference question.","evidenceIds":["unit:9a00edcb71e061eaed78fa38c29b16bfdc50a2ac2aa96fcbc409d60133f754e5","unit:bf67eede250ac54e8a5b23051140b74d5a21127755334dc194740647ff605333","unit:e31617c9b66aa35233790aaab09e54817638253b65cefa610fd5590fa48334dd"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7"},{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-15e4ee95696901bc525a-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8ed595b668e0ce28a313a22f"},{"localRef":"u25","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:9a00edcb71e061eaed78fa38c29b16bfdc50a2ac2aa96fcbc409d60133f754e5","textSha256":"13ce35e3463b0758e223f0b79ae19a61f6481f1b5d82edc63ff77a27a7626bd1"},{"localRef":"u31","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:bf67eede250ac54e8a5b23051140b74d5a21127755334dc194740647ff605333","textSha256":"ac3f2b4a9da0ed32b300d993036df4906771b55eadca2ac3eee4d129ddb73a32"},{"localRef":"u34","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:e31617c9b66aa35233790aaab09e54817638253b65cefa610fd5590fa48334dd","textSha256":"7cc2978eb894d291de6c84b00f61f07fa558a82519c759baac7f232062320eae"},{"localRef":"n3","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e31617c9b66aa35233790aaab09e54817638253b65cefa610fd5590fa48334dd","reviewId":"leaf-15e4ee95696901bc525a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:9a00edcb71e061eaed78fa38c29b16bfdc50a2ac2aa96fcbc409d60133f754e5","reviewId":"leaf-15e4ee95696901bc525a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n7","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:bf67eede250ac54e8a5b23051140b74d5a21127755334dc194740647ff605333","reviewId":"leaf-15e4ee95696901bc525a-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn5","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn5","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The route correctly narrows from general conditional inference to selected model comparisons. Its qualifications preserve conjecture versions, local regimes and the distinction between an announced test and its outcome.","refs":["c4","c5","u25","u31","u34","n3","n4","n7"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn6":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn6","source":"q025-candidate-region:e3c867c46139e156f816e00f","target":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","type":"narrower","title":"What do conjectural tests permit us to infer?","qualification":"This direction concerns models that explicitly adopt particular inequalities. It does not make conjectures premises of every inflationary mechanism, and preserves source-specific perturbation, domain and normalization requirements.","rationale":"The exact broad definition includes conditional consistency tests; the supplied navigation candidate supports this narrower direction.","evidenceIds":["unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c10","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-570548e969849fcc2e72-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:e3c867c46139e156f816e00f"},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7"},{"localRef":"u37","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","textSha256":"80a73b3365e34cd8e871968d68b1ca985059f4145724351bf166a51b899c9ff9"},{"localRef":"n46","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","reviewId":"parent-570548e969849fcc2e72-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l0","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-region:e3c867c46139e156f816e00f","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","candidateId":"parent-570548e969849fcc2e72-challenge:link:11","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn6","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn6","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c10 expressly includes conditional consistency tests, and l0 supplies the matching direction. This question-level narrowing does not change c10's outstanding scope-adjudication or descendant status.","refs":["c10","c4","u37","n46","l0"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn7":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn7","source":"q025-candidate-region:6071e42aaa3af11c82dedb5a","target":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","type":"narrower","title":"Test conditional bounds and their observational implications","qualification":"Separate conjecture choice, scalar normalization, perturbation origin and tested epochs. A printed energy ceiling is not by itself a duration-dependent TCC check; thermal sourcing alone supplies no exemption.","rationale":"Provides the reusable conditional-testing direction within the broader dynamics, signals and control question.","evidenceIds":["unit:92e6390713de5767eb356ab0174309b6d772c8ccb25129c4b275fb10e1b24653","unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe","unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:6071e42aaa3af11c82dedb5a"},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7"},{"localRef":"u23","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:92e6390713de5767eb356ab0174309b6d772c8ccb25129c4b275fb10e1b24653","textSha256":"a3e5da584fb3104ace168b587c46e6b38a8201764918e3bc6270cb7631535f9d"},{"localRef":"u30","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe","textSha256":"dcf05b6f58993ba89942fbd0068f54fd3a81161040feb4a753333341b672bd11"},{"localRef":"u35","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","textSha256":"d5a8a587374a18807a0e7f886b8a73c00998c7e8e9eb910ff4eccaddde06b5d9"},{"localRef":"u37","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","textSha256":"80a73b3365e34cd8e871968d68b1ca985059f4145724351bf166a51b899c9ff9"},{"localRef":"n48","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","reviewId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n49","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","reviewId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n50","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:92e6390713de5767eb356ab0174309b6d772c8ccb25129c4b275fb10e1b24653","reviewId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n51","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe","reviewId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l4","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-region:6071e42aaa3af11c82dedb5a","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","candidateId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge:link:7","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn7","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn7","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c9's exact scope and l4 support the narrower conditional-inference direction. The TCC qualification is inherited context, including distinct stage prescriptions and no thermal-source exemption, rather than a freshly checked bound.","refs":["c9","c4","u23","u30","u35","u37","n48","n49","n50","n51","l4"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn8":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn8","source":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","target":"q025-candidate-question:5f89175e5c6793ff5e4dcefc","type":"premise_check","title":"Check whether the diagnostic is defined and applicable","qualification":"Check the adopted criterion, field coordinates, normalization, derivative prescription and validity domain before drawing an inference. This route does not prove the conjecture or resolve the inherited Gauss–Bonnet formula conflict.","rationale":"c3 explicitly examines applicability and diagnostic limitations that can obstruct c4's conditional inference. Only that shared facet is used as a premise check.","evidenceIds":["unit:1b8db0b9dd9683840185d20d6be5ba61e0e5d7965874efd88c72ca5ff0a0951d","unit:92e6390713de5767eb356ab0174309b6d772c8ccb25129c4b275fb10e1b24653"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7"},{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5f89175e5c6793ff5e4dcefc"},{"localRef":"u6","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:1b8db0b9dd9683840185d20d6be5ba61e0e5d7965874efd88c72ca5ff0a0951d","textSha256":"ff04cbdc7f619a7278e869601f26dad16681a5b33edbebc11be001656b5b8a73"},{"localRef":"u23","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:92e6390713de5767eb356ab0174309b6d772c8ccb25129c4b275fb10e1b24653","textSha256":"a3e5da584fb3104ace168b587c46e6b38a8201764918e3bc6270cb7631535f9d"},{"localRef":"n43","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:1b8db0b9dd9683840185d20d6be5ba61e0e5d7965874efd88c72ca5ff0a0951d","reviewId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n50","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:92e6390713de5767eb356ab0174309b6d772c8ccb25129c4b275fb10e1b24653","reviewId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l5","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5f89175e5c6793ff5e4dcefc","candidateId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge:link:39","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn8","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn8","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The conditional question correctly points to diagnostic definition and applicability as the premise being checked. c3 and c4 support that facet directly; n50 supplies contextual caution, not a new u23 contribution to c3.","refs":["c4","c3","u6","u23","n43","n50","l5"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn9":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn9","source":"q025-candidate-question:5f89175e5c6793ff5e4dcefc","target":"q025-candidate-region:fb43300e7ba5681745d9331b","type":"method_for","title":"Apply qualified checks to cosmological constructions","qualification":"Use source-specific conjectural, geometric or EFT checks only for constructions to which they apply. Passing one check does not establish dynamical viability, observational agreement, coupling necessity or ultraviolet completion.","rationale":"The inherited method connection supports method-to-question access in the required direction. It does not make every construction in the broader region an application of one common diagnostic.","evidenceIds":["unit:1b8db0b9dd9683840185d20d6be5ba61e0e5d7965874efd88c72ca5ff0a0951d","unit:9b87ac98acdf6d46b567366b9880d0b004a415fcb10781c8e3aa7d1cac5e46bd","unit:d79ae3bf398b11069dd2caf12526c2c7766ef7f2594a5ee5da6965af8baa873f"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5f89175e5c6793ff5e4dcefc"},{"localRef":"c11","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"successor-parent-73840db6800ed57ab471-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:fb43300e7ba5681745d9331b"},{"localRef":"u6","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:1b8db0b9dd9683840185d20d6be5ba61e0e5d7965874efd88c72ca5ff0a0951d","textSha256":"ff04cbdc7f619a7278e869601f26dad16681a5b33edbebc11be001656b5b8a73"},{"localRef":"u26","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:9b87ac98acdf6d46b567366b9880d0b004a415fcb10781c8e3aa7d1cac5e46bd","textSha256":"9ea7f1c61e559ce288b6a7cdbf2ac228e3aa3746fbe525f173eba31e2b3e3ba1"},{"localRef":"u33","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:d79ae3bf398b11069dd2caf12526c2c7766ef7f2594a5ee5da6965af8baa873f","textSha256":"c98e2c21a24258b55cbdedc3ec8993cdba997bee339224728efdd8edf2443b4b"},{"localRef":"n42","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:d79ae3bf398b11069dd2caf12526c2c7766ef7f2594a5ee5da6965af8baa873f","reviewId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n43","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:1b8db0b9dd9683840185d20d6be5ba61e0e5d7965874efd88c72ca5ff0a0951d","reviewId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n44","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:9b87ac98acdf6d46b567366b9880d0b004a415fcb10781c8e3aa7d1cac5e46bd","reviewId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l3","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-region:fb43300e7ba5681745d9331b","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5f89175e5c6793ff5e4dcefc","candidateId":"successor-parent-73840db6800ed57ab471-challenge:link:2","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn9","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn9","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn9","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Method-to-question direction is correct. The route explicitly limits diagnostic use to applicable constructions and does not make every c11 branch an application or resolve its pending descendants.","refs":["c3","c11","u6","u26","u33","n42","n43","n44","l3"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn10":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn10","source":"q025-candidate-region:fb43300e7ba5681745d9331b","target":"q025-candidate-region:402b72881561aec06577ac84","type":"related_question","title":"Explore accelerated phases and de Sitter systems","qualification":"Inflation, late acceleration, horizon or particle questions and microscopic constructions retain different systems and regimes. Classical nonsingular and research-resource comparisons are not thereby included in every accelerated-phase test.","rationale":"Exposes the shared accelerated-cosmology target through an admitted destination while preserving c11's additional boundaries.","evidenceIds":["unit:0a3282897fe1e63d0462a061719d9bc3acedad8c54d84ea7ce97ea84f7afe1fb","unit:0c042234b5629fd2b8a12910265e1d839da03bbd32ed7d337abc5ca36b2d96cb"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:402b72881561aec06577ac84"},{"localRef":"c11","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"successor-parent-73840db6800ed57ab471-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:fb43300e7ba5681745d9331b"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:0a3282897fe1e63d0462a061719d9bc3acedad8c54d84ea7ce97ea84f7afe1fb","textSha256":"3614220933cf11ffede511b0754e2c19463eb11dc1aacea888deb101acfdd413"},{"localRef":"u2","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:0c042234b5629fd2b8a12910265e1d839da03bbd32ed7d337abc5ca36b2d96cb","textSha256":"b3b416f43188a47aa1f8c3bdb06f436bbd4799e3811fd72f92e6328581933663"},{"localRef":"n30","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0a3282897fe1e63d0462a061719d9bc3acedad8c54d84ea7ce97ea84f7afe1fb","reviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n33","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0c042234b5629fd2b8a12910265e1d839da03bbd32ed7d337abc5ca36b2d96cb","reviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn10","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn10","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn10","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Related-question access to admitted c8 is supported by the shared accelerated-phase target. The qualification preserves different quantum-state questions and excludes automatic absorption of c11's nonsingular and resource branches.","refs":["c8","c11","u0","u2","n30","n33"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn10","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn11":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:pn11","source":"q025-candidate-region:fb43300e7ba5681745d9331b","target":"q025-candidate-region:6071e42aaa3af11c82dedb5a","type":"related_question","title":"Follow trajectories to primordial signals and EFT limits","qualification":"Background construction, perturbation generation, energy transfer and effective-theory control require separate evidence. Action-accounting and alternative-origin branches are qualified neighbors, not universal requirements on each model.","rationale":"Provides common access to the dynamics and prediction target without equating the regions' complete contextual branches or descendant coverage.","evidenceIds":["unit:190be18e1f2ab5bf0acde59e139bab7baad88958f2a8e0ed967b06d13472c7d3","unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:6071e42aaa3af11c82dedb5a"},{"localRef":"c11","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"successor-parent-73840db6800ed57ab471-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:fb43300e7ba5681745d9331b"},{"localRef":"u5","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:190be18e1f2ab5bf0acde59e139bab7baad88958f2a8e0ed967b06d13472c7d3","textSha256":"a6f038709589e029be8d9c81f18fc2fcd9ffec6f51e1dc3f75c67dae3fb53429"},{"localRef":"u35","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","textSha256":"d5a8a587374a18807a0e7f886b8a73c00998c7e8e9eb910ff4eccaddde06b5d9"},{"localRef":"u37","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","textSha256":"80a73b3365e34cd8e871968d68b1ca985059f4145724351bf166a51b899c9ff9"},{"localRef":"n47","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:190be18e1f2ab5bf0acde59e139bab7baad88958f2a8e0ed967b06d13472c7d3","reviewId":"successor-parent-73840db6800ed57ab471-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n48","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","reviewId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n49","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","reviewId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn11","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn11","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-01-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn11","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The common dynamics and prediction target supports this explicit arc to c9. Separate evidence requirements and qualified neighboring branches prevent a containment or complete-equivalence inference.","refs":["c9","c11","u5","u35","u37","n47","n48","n49"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-01:route:pn11","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067","target":"q025-candidate-question:0e48cffa284b6cecf1592281","type":"related_question","title":"Explore restrictions on inflation and particle physics","qualification":"Follow stated consistency conditions into conditional applications. Potential restrictions retain alternative gradient and Hessian branches and construction-dependent assumptions; conventional positivity bounds remain comparisons. Neither completion nor a solution to the phenomenological problems is guaranteed.","rationale":"The completion program and the application review share an EFT-consistency target, while asking distinct selection and consequence questions.","evidenceIds":["unit:39b4f00b619e7b4815d0341dd061458952c6cbd2968b8a3e8b893b4f24ee4e80","unit:41d1ca0724c03cb538f50fbac06aa67b347b37c36696a7ffce0556532c4ca7c1","unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0e48cffa284b6cecf1592281"},{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a"},{"localRef":"c10","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067"},{"localRef":"u10","kind":"description","unitIndex":48,"unitId":"unit:39b4f00b619e7b4815d0341dd061458952c6cbd2968b8a3e8b893b4f24ee4e80","textSha256":"e9323dc1ab62676b34d8ea4992ce6ce96d10d6efb6eb34416fec8669e52e3bf8"},{"localRef":"u12","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:41d1ca0724c03cb538f50fbac06aa67b347b37c36696a7ffce0556532c4ca7c1","textSha256":"39cd554480c182a7b8d6bccb75342f8fedb012c62abe7a11758552baa5d70b80"},{"localRef":"u37","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8","textSha256":"495bf3f89c139f93197d0408c023a17d4b50a95a608afd0792d5e23719757667"},{"localRef":"n10","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8","reviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n53","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:39b4f00b619e7b4815d0341dd061458952c6cbd2968b8a3e8b893b4f24ee4e80","reviewId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n54","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:41d1ca0724c03cb538f50fbac06aa67b347b37c36696a7ffce0556532c4ca7c1","reviewId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n55","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8","reviewId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The outgoing choice connects completion selection to the distinct conditional-application question using the shared review and its two mapped attributions. related_question is appropriate: the arc asserts neither containment nor successful application of a sufficient completion test. Its qualifications preserve potential branches, construction dependence and positivity comparisons.","refs":["c0","c9","c10","u10","u12","u37","n10","n53","n54","n55"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-question:165edf41405890a5da70439b","target":"q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1","type":"related_question","title":"Check barriers and decay after uplift","qualification":"For the relevant string-vacuum branch, continue from local response to barrier, decay and consistency tests. A surviving displaced extremum does not establish a lifetime or complete de Sitter vacuum. Small-displacement arguments retain curvature, coefficient-scaling, other-modulus and fractional-mass-change conditions.","rationale":"Mechanism-specific response leads naturally to the separate tests of vacuum survival and positive-energy control already represented in c5.","evidenceIds":["unit:10ff325d4a1e4dff8accc4e543d0343755ef0ea083e701b635ad37f3c3b3d05a","unit:1af83f77ec5e151082052a8256540cbcd0c3533ea243d90789a1fc5d1d344240","unit:926a8f17bbd42c4b9018a5d5f315a28475859cdfdd6e4f35e1e2ee4a4bbfd8a2","unit:c319d7046901768d6ecd16c7ac64cbc3f7e70a2459ee9eb8c508820c3b77929b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:165edf41405890a5da70439b"},{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"},{"localRef":"u3","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:1af83f77ec5e151082052a8256540cbcd0c3533ea243d90789a1fc5d1d344240","textSha256":"4b33b59df025b113ea13175b25f72a328b11fd075d5d951a00a8dc1916fe4036"},{"localRef":"u34","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:c319d7046901768d6ecd16c7ac64cbc3f7e70a2459ee9eb8c508820c3b77929b","textSha256":"da9519895e186fa3532236dec00809cae6905bc713dc04340791893d67dba42d"},{"localRef":"u27","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:926a8f17bbd42c4b9018a5d5f315a28475859cdfdd6e4f35e1e2ee4a4bbfd8a2","textSha256":"c2c6c48756b31eec8edd5197a70b0d7d7f271be51c0413aaa5f11a23c74ae3ee"},{"localRef":"u2","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:10ff325d4a1e4dff8accc4e543d0343755ef0ea083e701b635ad37f3c3b3d05a","textSha256":"ce2dba183875ad5dc65589a148aae38b1b0649cba22a46f1edb979ac8f8fb6b5"},{"localRef":"n49","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:1af83f77ec5e151082052a8256540cbcd0c3533ea243d90789a1fc5d1d344240","reviewId":"leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n51","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c319d7046901768d6ecd16c7ac64cbc3f7e70a2459ee9eb8c508820c3b77929b","reviewId":"leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n27","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:926a8f17bbd42c4b9018a5d5f315a28475859cdfdd6e4f35e1e2ee4a4bbfd8a2","reviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n29","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:10ff325d4a1e4dff8accc4e543d0343755ef0ea083e701b635ad37f3c3b3d05a","reviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The route offers a concrete continuation from mechanism-specific response to barrier and decay tests. related_question correctly avoids asserting that the entire c1 question specializes c5. The relevant-string-branch qualification preserves local displacement conditions and separates a surviving extremum from an established lifetime or complete de Sitter vacuum.","refs":["c1","c5","u3","u34","u27","u2","n49","n51","n27","n29"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn2":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1","target":"q025-candidate-question:58385c6977fdde6738d43669","type":"premise_check","title":"Check the de Sitter construction and its control","qualification":"For a branch claimed to yield a controlled de Sitter vacuum, check stabilization, higher-dimensional consistency and neglected corrections separately. Closed-string stability is insufficient by itself. Rejection of one specified flux class is not a verdict on all flux models, and mildly unstable points remain comparisons.","rationale":"The positive-energy question depends, in its de Sitter branch, on the construction and control requirements investigated by c6.","evidenceIds":["unit:502f95c456ced006e72e5d4b8ce566edce120cac6118c03208b88c1c6ff61cda","unit:7883b8811854a8ffe572f9c250a7593f20d3711381690dbefe23622e12975f8f","unit:c37c4bef5fe8722f2b6812fcb88b76596ca10d8c5e1dc0214bf9dbffc866760c","unit:e2163e59a5cd14ffba779370517eeeb4f16b7d75d18d652b4506f51ac5a8f98e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"},{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:58385c6977fdde6738d43669"},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:502f95c456ced006e72e5d4b8ce566edce120cac6118c03208b88c1c6ff61cda","textSha256":"3ade436444eb30428e5c20d6d23cb83b3cc35c58c688d97f65e1eff761488404"},{"localRef":"u35","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:c37c4bef5fe8722f2b6812fcb88b76596ca10d8c5e1dc0214bf9dbffc866760c","textSha256":"268428c611a6836aaafd57cf041b1a785002285a3ff77f3565b411797acbfc2b"},{"localRef":"u44","kind":"description","unitIndex":17,"unitId":"unit:e2163e59a5cd14ffba779370517eeeb4f16b7d75d18d652b4506f51ac5a8f98e","textSha256":"863261873c6821611479db5b26695185dc80e258248c32994967313fc3ed998b"},{"localRef":"u22","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:7883b8811854a8ffe572f9c250a7593f20d3711381690dbefe23622e12975f8f","textSha256":"c1be9dbb48b833f447e07863ee12170bc3a343050649743bf40a3f68034a8960"},{"localRef":"n36","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e2163e59a5cd14ffba779370517eeeb4f16b7d75d18d652b4506f51ac5a8f98e","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n37","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:7883b8811854a8ffe572f9c250a7593f20d3711381690dbefe23622e12975f8f","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n38","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c37c4bef5fe8722f2b6812fcb88b76596ca10d8c5e1dc0214bf9dbffc866760c","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n39","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:502f95c456ced006e72e5d4b8ce566edce120cac6118c03208b88c1c6ff61cda","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The direction is correct for premise_check: the conditional positive-energy question points to construction and control requirements for its de Sitter branch. These requirements are already explicit in the definitions and inherited assessments. The route does not transfer u44's rejection to other flux classes or treat mild instability as metastability.","refs":["c5","c6","u14","u35","u44","u22","n36","n37","n38","n39"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn3":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-question:24124b028c946c6bc1e48479","target":"q025-candidate-question:1741aec31a82052c172c976b","type":"narrower","title":"Test neutrino masses against residual protections","qualification":"Focus on source-specific mass mechanisms and signatures compatible with intended proton or dark-matter protection. Bulk, seesaw and radiative mechanisms remain distinct; Dirac character and gravity-dependent restrictions retain their model-specific status.","rationale":"This selects the protected-mass branch from the broader mass-mechanism and fermion-inventory question.","evidenceIds":["unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","unit:38e35bfd30ea71bbeb47bde9237c6f40f858445494d3887bb3a5d42fd9436d80","unit:8162a37584b22c7f9ea15454a130e44b59ce6c735878c75a9604cde9cd02f210","unit:adc0d95df7942e559e5152a47c04bb1b623e9f7a45bb73e7c854aadfb99836ed"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24124b028c946c6bc1e48479"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1741aec31a82052c172c976b"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","textSha256":"1b1486827b6017d8e3d11794f6eeb0c5bb94904826be395667cba3eea2a1903f"},{"localRef":"u9","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:38e35bfd30ea71bbeb47bde9237c6f40f858445494d3887bb3a5d42fd9436d80","textSha256":"447daef84609acbbf7921ae6961afa73101b6bcb3bf634c4505fa937adc4c08d"},{"localRef":"u25","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:8162a37584b22c7f9ea15454a130e44b59ce6c735878c75a9604cde9cd02f210","textSha256":"977b0cf281509600a6f367a0e2271e311ecc3638c471de8923006f479dbabd21"},{"localRef":"u31","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:adc0d95df7942e559e5152a47c04bb1b623e9f7a45bb73e7c854aadfb99836ed","textSha256":"76d88c540cf2821d0df915ab07e9b46b7d01f94bc71f9700b8601e75c99d3d3c"},{"localRef":"n13","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:38e35bfd30ea71bbeb47bde9237c6f40f858445494d3887bb3a5d42fd9436d80","reviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n14","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:8162a37584b22c7f9ea15454a130e44b59ce6c735878c75a9604cde9cd02f210","reviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n15","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:adc0d95df7942e559e5152a47c04bb1b623e9f7a45bb73e7c854aadfb99836ed","reviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n17","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","reviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l4","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24124b028c946c6bc1e48479","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1741aec31a82052c172c976b","candidateId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge:link:18","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The public direction is broader c4 to narrower c2. The title selects residual-protection compatibility, while the qualification retains c2's distinct bulk, seesaw and radiative mechanisms and conditional mass character. It does not equate u0's compound programme with the individual protection constructions.","refs":["c4","c2","u0","u9","u25","u31","n13","n14","n15","n17","l4"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn4":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-question:24124b028c946c6bc1e48479","target":"q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a","type":"narrower","title":"Inspect allowed neutrino mass operators","qualification":"Focus on symmetry, field and operator requirements, including corrections to existing masses. Explicit and spontaneous breaking remain distinct, and an unspecified breaking implementation stays unspecified. Symmetry-preserving Planck-suppressed operators are not identified with gravitational symmetry breaking.","rationale":"Operator compatibility and mass-structure protection form a narrower direction within the broad mass-and-symmetry question.","evidenceIds":["unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","unit:30e9c711f0e30d3b1ad0d63e416ff09223f0c8813c475a6017f6e4c30ad6646b","unit:6a58422fe8ce102f5915326c7a5de944fd4efc211f02574a4a2a93bc1d825be7","unit:db14babc41641f2bc8d3864acfc4ee8bca5483524f9969dd1d9b0f160b4ecf2f"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24124b028c946c6bc1e48479"},{"localRef":"c11","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a"},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:30e9c711f0e30d3b1ad0d63e416ff09223f0c8813c475a6017f6e4c30ad6646b","textSha256":"eb8d7a17c291a2dd6e1a9051336099ff1ef4220af8c044f12eedf418246fb505"},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:6a58422fe8ce102f5915326c7a5de944fd4efc211f02574a4a2a93bc1d825be7","textSha256":"15145191227f6db22ac3090e03e4311b569287ae1bf9f89ab87dbfbf9283ba2e"},{"localRef":"u40","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:db14babc41641f2bc8d3864acfc4ee8bca5483524f9969dd1d9b0f160b4ecf2f","textSha256":"ed9c6832b6c621314caba2985989d697cf51734d7bba9855993242803f8fd140"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","textSha256":"1b1486827b6017d8e3d11794f6eeb0c5bb94904826be395667cba3eea2a1903f"},{"localRef":"n31","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:30e9c711f0e30d3b1ad0d63e416ff09223f0c8813c475a6017f6e4c30ad6646b","reviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n32","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6a58422fe8ce102f5915326c7a5de944fd4efc211f02574a4a2a93bc1d825be7","reviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n33","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:db14babc41641f2bc8d3864acfc4ee8bca5483524f9969dd1d9b0f160b4ecf2f","reviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n34","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","reviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l3","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24124b028c946c6bc1e48479","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a","candidateId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge:link:17","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction and operator-focused title match c4 and c11. The qualification explicitly retains corrections, unspecified breaking implementation and the distinction between symmetry-preserving Planck-suppressed operators and gravitational breaking. u19's spontaneous-breaking premise is not generalized.","refs":["c4","c11","u7","u19","u40","u0","n31","n32","n33","n34","l3"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn5":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn5","source":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a","target":"q025-candidate-question:640ecf6fc92cc27f6876f2e5","type":"narrower","title":"Confront quintessence with dated observations","qualification":"Restrict attention to parameter inference, reconstruction, model comparison and H0 tests using each source's models and datasets. Retain inconclusive shape constraints and unsuccessful discussed H0 cases. Background agreement does not establish microscopic consistency.","rationale":"The observational destination isolates an existing branch of the broader dynamics-and-inference question.","evidenceIds":["unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-adb0d0a7d3119878efcf-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:640ecf6fc92cc27f6876f2e5"},{"localRef":"u16","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","textSha256":"6e0c5bfacfbc6b3ca37fecc88061ce7970d88d295b9e590dbca371904722c3a1"},{"localRef":"u42","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234","textSha256":"43ca33640a5dded2d2aeb4028654c06ad78eb2a8d0b955cecd852a433eaac14c"},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234","reviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n5","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","reviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n42","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","reviewId":"leaf-adb0d0a7d3119878efcf-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n43","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234","reviewId":"leaf-adb0d0a7d3119878efcf-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l0","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:640ecf6fc92cc27f6876f2e5","candidateId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:link:14","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn5","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn5","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The route correctly narrows c3 to its observational branch at c7. Its title and qualification preserve source dates, model/dataset dependence and negative or inconclusive outcomes. Neither the title nor the route claims that asking to constrain parameters establishes successful constraints.","refs":["c3","c7","u16","u42","n4","n5","n42","n43","l0"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn6":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn6","source":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80","target":"q025-candidate-question:640ecf6fc92cc27f6876f2e5","type":"narrower","title":"Compare potential fits and reconstruction limits","qualification":"Select the observational quintessence branch. Reconstruction remains dependent on assumptions, kernels, H0 choices and source-specific redshift intervals, including z ∈ [0, 1.5] for the supplied 2021 EFT analysis. A reconstructed traversed potential segment does not fix an absolute field origin; a raised fitted H0 alone does not establish an acceptable joint fit.","rationale":"c7 concentrates the inference and discrimination work within c8 while leaving analytic prediction and modified-cosmology comparisons as separate branches.","evidenceIds":["unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-adb0d0a7d3119878efcf-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:640ecf6fc92cc27f6876f2e5"},{"localRef":"u6","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","textSha256":"fabb290146b115b17311b3b2c38b0343ebb029cf637ecf49554b7bea58f59a65"},{"localRef":"u16","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","textSha256":"6e0c5bfacfbc6b3ca37fecc88061ce7970d88d295b9e590dbca371904722c3a1"},{"localRef":"u42","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234","textSha256":"43ca33640a5dded2d2aeb4028654c06ad78eb2a8d0b955cecd852a433eaac14c"},{"localRef":"n20","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","reviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n21","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234","reviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n42","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","reviewId":"leaf-adb0d0a7d3119878efcf-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n43","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234","reviewId":"leaf-adb0d0a7d3119878efcf-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn6","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn6","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The route correctly selects c7's observational branch from c8. The 2021 redshift interval, field-origin ambiguity and raised-H0-versus-joint-fit distinction are supported by the supplied definitions and mapped inherited notes. These are retained qualifications, not newly checked reconstruction or fit results.","refs":["c8","c7","u6","u16","u42","n20","n21","n42","n43"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn7":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn7","source":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a","target":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80","type":"comparison","title":"Compare late-time histories with modified cosmologies","qualification":"Compare overlapping history and inference questions while retaining c3's radiation-era and specified coupled histories and c8's modified-cosmology and f(Q) comparison branches. Quintessence-like effective behavior does not establish a canonical scalar realization; Slotheon's gravitational derivative coupling remains distinct.","rationale":"The common history-and-inference target supports comparison across the explicitly different regimes and systems, without declaring the destinations aliases.","evidenceIds":["unit:797b34e24c41674baa58eed915617080b3183ec42d4f6eb727b9536690831e87","unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a"},{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80"},{"localRef":"u42","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234","textSha256":"43ca33640a5dded2d2aeb4028654c06ad78eb2a8d0b955cecd852a433eaac14c"},{"localRef":"u23","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:797b34e24c41674baa58eed915617080b3183ec42d4f6eb727b9536690831e87","textSha256":"c96259522eb7d5f17d2042f53150c22353195f333f8751ba7970f9df8fd8e0ff"},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234","reviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n19","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:797b34e24c41674baa58eed915617080b3183ec42d4f6eb727b9536690831e87","reviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n21","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234","reviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l1","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80","candidateId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:link:16","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn7","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn7","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The explicit comparison arc is useful despite failed full-scope identity. c8's definition supplies the modified-cosmology and f(Q) comparison branch; u23 and n19 supply the distinct Slotheon qualification. The route does not infer a canonical scalar realization from effective behavior or admit a completed observational fit.","refs":["c3","c8","u42","u23","n4","n19","n21","l1"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:route:pn7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","target":"q025-candidate-question:04ea1b1376fe4c1d2d1be282","type":"related_question","title":"Count mixed towers and assess entropy saturation","qualification":"Mixed-tower counting and saturation are source-specific. The evaporation derivation is neutral, nonrotating and asymptotically flat; charged and near-extremal models remain separate. DGKT-CFI reports an obeyed but unsaturated four-dimensional bound, with unresolved counts/grouping and no fixed-flux or ten-dimensional conclusion.","rationale":"This takes the broad species question toward the explicit tower-spectrum and saturation questions without asserting complete containment or equivalence.","evidenceIds":["unit:269b88addfc1185d719c9c63a0c2f6e1c10bcf7267a6d5f921f8a7c95078326a","unit:5db65eca89d59627547028c6c2fbe6d671dd460dd9cc066de8a612bb439614c7","unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:04ea1b1376fe4c1d2d1be282"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"},{"localRef":"u11","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:269b88addfc1185d719c9c63a0c2f6e1c10bcf7267a6d5f921f8a7c95078326a","textSha256":"7f83a17647f5abf9fae404ca31e1c0e9762411373a40dc68b3bdf29d7ffd8d05"},{"localRef":"n10","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:269b88addfc1185d719c9c63a0c2f6e1c10bcf7267a6d5f921f8a7c95078326a","reviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u20","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:5db65eca89d59627547028c6c2fbe6d671dd460dd9cc066de8a612bb439614c7","textSha256":"1eed423f2e4465666e30d98fa2652125c79ad91a7df5587b97566047a7c3f090"},{"localRef":"n11","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:5db65eca89d59627547028c6c2fbe6d671dd460dd9cc066de8a612bb439614c7","reviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u30","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5","textSha256":"6c623ea966e2cf3b78a820438a862d3de469f0d15c9d702f91f79c5425824fe8"},{"localRef":"n8","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5","reviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n12","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5","reviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-03-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-03-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The outgoing title selects concrete mixed-tower and saturation questions supported by u11 and u20. related_question correctly avoids asserting containment, and the qualification preserves neutral evaporation assumptions, separate charged regimes and DGKT-CFI limitations.","refs":["c0","c1","u11","n10","u20","n11","u30","n8","n12"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae","target":"q025-candidate-question:b1eba9143531ae9fa14f21e1","type":"narrower","title":"Translate modified dynamics into potential constraints","qualification":"Translation depends on the action and regime; potential curvature is not dynamical slow roll. The concrete DBI translation does not establish the unfinished generic P(X,φ) entropy extension. The inherited Gauss–Bonnet tilt warning remains unresolved, and successful examples do not establish a necessary coupling.","rationale":"The narrower question examines how specified interactions alter the connection between background evolution, potential data and observables.","evidenceIds":["unit:28c0e3fd9bfe0e8fc5be1e662f018fb0c3afc0518c0b59e52a379362a4981a9d","unit:a63ac6afd1ba332c9df94c36b756b64c9974a872518bd2173bb659bd3bad8077","unit:b4d7e7c86e1d66cbc706c82e2b4a0ebe1f2153cf381698f82f36016b8bc4b87d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b1eba9143531ae9fa14f21e1"},{"localRef":"u12","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:28c0e3fd9bfe0e8fc5be1e662f018fb0c3afc0518c0b59e52a379362a4981a9d","textSha256":"70852a735fa41f362e25e4ff82e61194a0ffeb413abedde59e8d034c3ab37ad1"},{"localRef":"n25","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:28c0e3fd9bfe0e8fc5be1e662f018fb0c3afc0518c0b59e52a379362a4981a9d","reviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u28","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:b4d7e7c86e1d66cbc706c82e2b4a0ebe1f2153cf381698f82f36016b8bc4b87d","textSha256":"bef154fce6d510e3ec49b5517fb9bc3149487ff18713489465ad926e90af99a7"},{"localRef":"n26","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:b4d7e7c86e1d66cbc706c82e2b4a0ebe1f2153cf381698f82f36016b8bc4b87d","reviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u26","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:a63ac6afd1ba332c9df94c36b756b64c9974a872518bd2173bb659bd3bad8077","textSha256":"a86ed6c6ef172751427905790be463fae26aaae3a6708f65cc003fa902cd3835"},{"localRef":"n27","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:a63ac6afd1ba332c9df94c36b756b64c9974a872518bd2173bb659bd3bad8077","reviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-03-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-03-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction agrees with pd2. The DBI and hilltop descriptions support the action-dependent translation choice; the route does not equate potential curvature with dynamical slow roll or promote the unfinished general entropy extension.","refs":["c4","c2","u12","n25","u28","n26","u26","n27"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:pn2":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae","target":"q025-candidate-question:c19b646d564f6e3e0f160f53","type":"related_question","title":"Compare dissipation and potential-free inflation","qualification":"Dissipation, kinetic support, gravitational couplings and deformed evolution laws retain distinct actions and control conditions. General kinetic actions need not reduce to P(φ,X), and a changed background law alone supplies no complete perturbation theory. No common small-Hubble-parameter regime is imposed. Gauss–Bonnet results retain their restricted coupling and unestablished cutoff/full-stability control.","rationale":"This opens c3's explicit mechanism comparison within the common inflation-support inquiry without asserting that every altered-evolution branch has been shown to be a strict subcase of c4.","evidenceIds":["unit:0c902a5e71124edcc0d4c1c57811c9b866b69e9b6ae61ce4f6de288825feed8d","unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","unit:e2c4f4558f612ec692a19b078afecd0b4d2303a5032eec31f21d8950c711acbb","unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae"},{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c19b646d564f6e3e0f160f53"},{"localRef":"u32","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:e2c4f4558f612ec692a19b078afecd0b4d2303a5032eec31f21d8950c711acbb","textSha256":"edc78985d8c6a3472429d77403f0b6efe4002ca2afe4a686042c43a32164c2ae"},{"localRef":"n13","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e2c4f4558f612ec692a19b078afecd0b4d2303a5032eec31f21d8950c711acbb","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u22","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","textSha256":"d9a66617be22f12d5d7e95bccf36e2e7cda114245831c357c0f8d03bb4647c70"},{"localRef":"n14","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u6","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:0c902a5e71124edcc0d4c1c57811c9b866b69e9b6ae61ce4f6de288825feed8d","textSha256":"33e341a6ad8551c341504cfdf3ad32cd3a05feca76b22753f8a78f3432004e37"},{"localRef":"n15","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0c902a5e71124edcc0d4c1c57811c9b866b69e9b6ae61ce4f6de288825feed8d","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u34","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","textSha256":"80a73b3365e34cd8e871968d68b1ca985059f4145724351bf166a51b899c9ff9"},{"localRef":"n16","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-03-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-03-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c3 explicitly supports the dissipation and potential-free choice. A related-question arc is appropriately weaker than full containment, and its qualifications retain action differences, incomplete perturbation information and the corrected absence of a shared small-Hubble-parameter regime.","refs":["c4","c3","u32","n13","u22","n14","u6","n15","u34","n16"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:pn3":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","target":"q025-candidate-region:30898744388e6013c0be7322","type":"related_question","title":"Examine flux hierarchies and conditional consistency tests","qualification":"Construction, charge cancellation, hierarchy and effective-description tests remain distinct. Cutoff, distance and proposed dual-realizability tests are conditional. Bubble topology and dynamical decay suppression are separate questions; truncated or smeared descriptions do not establish full string consistency.","rationale":"The route selects c5's flux-centered diagnostic questions from the shared compactification inquiry while preserving c6's independently scoped decay and protection directions.","evidenceIds":["unit:2df68cc360d9803367e006001b21a7bff4856ea790d4dd173a8196c7644cfe59","unit:45ef74aceef210d62a6384e200f077d1cdabaf7e7f313293da00366634d068e2","unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94"},{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-3ad8848c0af01da6b749-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:30898744388e6013c0be7322"},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","textSha256":"8579808dd6cce4883f7cbcb6afe2aa072aed6dcbeb55ffecfe0084bfe2548cc6"},{"localRef":"n32","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","reviewId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u13","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:2df68cc360d9803367e006001b21a7bff4856ea790d4dd173a8196c7644cfe59","textSha256":"3b6364063001b2b7fb2292609be1032016003e582e8e654660c55953992b46de"},{"localRef":"n34","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2df68cc360d9803367e006001b21a7bff4856ea790d4dd173a8196c7644cfe59","reviewId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u17","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:45ef74aceef210d62a6384e200f077d1cdabaf7e7f313293da00366634d068e2","textSha256":"49bbbe6b90232be1a16fd4f899d67644df6654e2c0a0788f8a55886eaa61ef10"},{"localRef":"n33","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:45ef74aceef210d62a6384e200f077d1cdabaf7e7f313293da00366634d068e2","reviewId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-03-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-03-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The title selects c5's explicit hierarchy and conditional-test targets. related_question matches the shared-target decision while separating construction, diagnostic consistency and bubble suppression. The route supplies no new physical relation among those tests.","refs":["c6","c5","u19","n32","u17","n33","u13","n34"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:pn4":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-region:30898744388e6013c0be7322","target":"q025-candidate-region:c44298520b2dfeda9cfc89de","type":"narrower","title":"Study localized sources, KK spectra and light gravitons","qualification":"Keep dimensions, supersymmetry, frames and approximation orders source-specific. Compactification radii, curvature radii, KK gaps and isolated light-graviton masses are distinct. O6 core resolution and essential string corrections remain alternatives; announced AdS3 construction claims do not verify full spectra or localized control.","rationale":"c9 provides the more focused flux-vacuum direction represented by global modulus identifications, localized cores, light-graviton constructions and AdS3 hierarchy questions.","evidenceIds":["unit:09d7bcf312eb9157bbb778dd644f4d090d94a1e16a0b5a79d0c944d72e8c9c8b","unit:0de0ad84cc807325ec2f6cc317736a86dd4606d0d3fc825a741c23cd20332c97","unit:101f4cf4c5efce466ccb68cc327ef8acbbd575d1af38b488638293000fddbe49","unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-3ad8848c0af01da6b749-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:30898744388e6013c0be7322"},{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-04442f0e58623f0db643-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:c44298520b2dfeda9cfc89de"},{"localRef":"u3","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:09d7bcf312eb9157bbb778dd644f4d090d94a1e16a0b5a79d0c944d72e8c9c8b","textSha256":"035f1ab05fac7f3cacd8cc2f171554bdd38e919be089524f9be2c44e7193f2f1"},{"localRef":"n2","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:09d7bcf312eb9157bbb778dd644f4d090d94a1e16a0b5a79d0c944d72e8c9c8b","reviewId":"leaf-04442f0e58623f0db643-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:0de0ad84cc807325ec2f6cc317736a86dd4606d0d3fc825a741c23cd20332c97","textSha256":"98fd83a72b183043006ed61927929adcf0117d98ae7558cdb3a33474ca2291e9"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0de0ad84cc807325ec2f6cc317736a86dd4606d0d3fc825a741c23cd20332c97","reviewId":"leaf-04442f0e58623f0db643-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u9","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:101f4cf4c5efce466ccb68cc327ef8acbbd575d1af38b488638293000fddbe49","textSha256":"3b84c7ee0dade84b3dfab87a20747dbab737f77d622296f6d6cb977b0451b4dd"},{"localRef":"n1","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:101f4cf4c5efce466ccb68cc327ef8acbbd575d1af38b488638293000fddbe49","reviewId":"leaf-04442f0e58623f0db643-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","textSha256":"8579808dd6cce4883f7cbcb6afe2aa072aed6dcbeb55ffecfe0084bfe2548cc6"},{"localRef":"n3","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","reviewId":"leaf-04442f0e58623f0db643-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-03-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-03-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction matches pd4, and the source/core, modulus and graviton witnesses make the choice concrete. Its qualifications preserve distinct spectral scales and leave O6 alternatives and announced AdS3 control claims unresolved.","refs":["c5","c9","u3","n2","u7","n0","u9","n1","u19","n3","n32"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:pn5":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:pn5","source":"q025-candidate-region:b35c5857878f0111cd402204","target":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","type":"narrower","title":"Explore holographic dictionaries and controlled observables","qualification":"Descriptions and calculations retain their own dimensions, states, boundary conditions and control assumptions. Large N, strong coupling and weak curvature are conditions of particular classical calculations, not requirements for every proposal. Holography-inspired hierarchy mechanisms need not supply an established dictionary; action and volume complexity remain distinct.","rationale":"This selects the description-and-observable direction from c8's broader region, which also includes speculative vacuum mechanisms and proposed signatures.","evidenceIds":["unit:030faef097ceb5e740ded69e20ae8166e9f1b3cbc3243386e56f3db29770ca21","unit:20a61027fa4f361cbdbd89d2b93a7bfe07861a335dd8df8772f4b0fb17a269ca","unit:31d1dc204679dbf8182252fa7e3ae100b58c040c65c75fd42e2f7d3b64bab06b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"parent-398c9d4f5960a5d24944-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:b35c5857878f0111cd402204"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"},{"localRef":"u1","kind":"description","unitIndex":64,"unitId":"unit:030faef097ceb5e740ded69e20ae8166e9f1b3cbc3243386e56f3db29770ca21","textSha256":"ab9acd7312b6f37f6696a56513cea5d5a0a80988307ef607785601dda0cbad62"},{"localRef":"n20","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:030faef097ceb5e740ded69e20ae8166e9f1b3cbc3243386e56f3db29770ca21","reviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u10","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:20a61027fa4f361cbdbd89d2b93a7bfe07861a335dd8df8772f4b0fb17a269ca","textSha256":"01dbbfc7edc0e0f21d009cfb79abf8cc048f44ca8586682a8759b86c0409173e"},{"localRef":"n17","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:20a61027fa4f361cbdbd89d2b93a7bfe07861a335dd8df8772f4b0fb17a269ca","reviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n35","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:20a61027fa4f361cbdbd89d2b93a7bfe07861a335dd8df8772f4b0fb17a269ca","reviewId":"parent-398c9d4f5960a5d24944-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:31d1dc204679dbf8182252fa7e3ae100b58c040c65c75fd42e2f7d3b64bab06b","textSha256":"edcab0f6a0e2db0b2399674106965451ad7c853918d545536087925164854ad0"},{"localRef":"n36","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:31d1dc204679dbf8182252fa7e3ae100b58c040c65c75fd42e2f7d3b64bab06b","reviewId":"parent-398c9d4f5960a5d24944-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:route:pn5","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn5","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-03-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-03-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The narrower route correctly runs from c8 to c7. The title selects a supported dictionary/observable direction without restricting all c7 contributions to classical control; the qualification expressly localizes large N, coupling and curvature assumptions and distinguishes speculative mechanisms.","refs":["c8","c7","u1","n20","u10","n17","n35","u14","n36"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:route:pn5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:pn6":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:pn6","source":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","target":"q025-candidate-region:db2b0d8182ae1c0e65ae7688","type":"related_question","title":"Reconstruct bulk fields and compare scattering methods","qualification":"Keep AdS and de Sitter prescriptions distinct. Rotating-BTZ outer and inner horizons remain separate, and single-boundary mirror operators are a state-dependent reconstruction alternative. For discrete-series de Sitter fields with integer boundary dimensions, GEC, conformal anomalies and holographic renormalisability are compared conditions. Standalone curved-space and analogue models supply comparisons, not a universal duality or physical equivalence.","rationale":"The descriptions support a concrete route from holographic observables to reconstruction and scattering questions without identifying their methods or settling the ambiguous de Sitter destination.","evidenceIds":["unit:015f7021a7fb6f3683a66223332156dafc49edb891c9d9bc5c9346c5477fb5ea","unit:06a24b2a3847aa6dbb693617229112fd691acf1858a5db5d45bcd606f14132e8","unit:0b697ddcf3c1f6b5977c4b90709926f2b384d7cddd08dc044228c71eb1ba5df9"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"},{"localRef":"c10","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge:r","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:db2b0d8182ae1c0e65ae7688"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:015f7021a7fb6f3683a66223332156dafc49edb891c9d9bc5c9346c5477fb5ea","textSha256":"5fd4805bb1c9dc4f1ac0dfb8809099a4ce42ed3779767c4d08fcd8bd43e10480"},{"localRef":"n21","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:015f7021a7fb6f3683a66223332156dafc49edb891c9d9bc5c9346c5477fb5ea","reviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u5","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:0b697ddcf3c1f6b5977c4b90709926f2b384d7cddd08dc044228c71eb1ba5df9","textSha256":"58d5c517967f26dde53713e35c3456637624aaa38f1ad7439d58ef3a9af31c72"},{"localRef":"n22","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:0b697ddcf3c1f6b5977c4b90709926f2b384d7cddd08dc044228c71eb1ba5df9","reviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"u2","kind":"description","unitIndex":52,"unitId":"unit:06a24b2a3847aa6dbb693617229112fd691acf1858a5db5d45bcd606f14132e8","textSha256":"a2d58e3a45c4234cff053a9176c385f7b190f501cd8827fa509062e62024be02"},{"localRef":"n23","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:06a24b2a3847aa6dbb693617229112fd691acf1858a5db5d45bcd606f14132e8","reviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:route:pn6","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn6","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-03-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-03-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The descriptions provide concrete reconstruction and scattering directions. related_question asserts only this outgoing choice; it does not establish a shared scattering method, universal duality or resolved de Sitter destination. BTZ state dependence and the distinct de Sitter conditions are retained.","refs":["c7","c10","u0","n21","u5","n22","u2","n23"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-03:route:pn6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35","target":"q025-candidate-question:0777daf5a5d5108c1a33bb07","type":"related_question","title":"Explore ultralight transitions and axion decay bounds","qualification":"Ultralight background evolution and techni-anomalous X-ray constraints retain distinct populations and abundance assumptions. Historical Hubble and EDGES motivations are not current-fit claims, and techni-anomalous axions are not identified with QCD axions.","rationale":"The existing related-route candidate is supported by the shared abundance/evolution target and c0's additional explicit coverage.","evidenceIds":["unit:2757290f362c1e62c87bf55f52fab8fbacb228e7332078beedf0d8c31b41e8a3","unit:2bfeafa50c6ee30b26f75ce03c9b2351625bc25c9c29b8247cb6c12be2bd03d9","unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35"},{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-d43a8973642e5bf710ff-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0777daf5a5d5108c1a33bb07"},{"localRef":"u9","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:2757290f362c1e62c87bf55f52fab8fbacb228e7332078beedf0d8c31b41e8a3","textSha256":"cac98423e25f9eacc2d2c7e17a39c341879c04b295b5bb13526f365ce56ed794"},{"localRef":"u10","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:2bfeafa50c6ee30b26f75ce03c9b2351625bc25c9c29b8247cb6c12be2bd03d9","textSha256":"15d2376a7263597a611ee38d3018761751b9574a7ca9055c3a0f5d95a468241e"},{"localRef":"u31","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","textSha256":"a43716256e5420305ab4cb364f4c990e81bcab046ecc6f7a0d6c16f116602642"},{"localRef":"n37","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2757290f362c1e62c87bf55f52fab8fbacb228e7332078beedf0d8c31b41e8a3","reviewId":"leaf-d43a8973642e5bf710ff-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n38","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2bfeafa50c6ee30b26f75ce03c9b2351625bc25c9c29b8247cb6c12be2bd03d9","reviewId":"leaf-d43a8973642e5bf710ff-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n40","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","reviewId":"leaf-d43a8973642e5bf710ff-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l0","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0777daf5a5d5108c1a33bb07","candidateId":"parent-4b8be5938efde44fe7a7-challenge:link:17","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The related-question direction opens c0's explicit transition and decay branches. Its population distinctions and historical-status qualification are supported; neither containment nor a new physical connection is asserted.","refs":["c9","c0","u9","u10","u31","n37","n38","n40","l0"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-question:0777daf5a5d5108c1a33bb07","target":"q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35","type":"related_question","title":"Study axion stars, minihalos and metric signals","qualification":"This opens c9's nonlinear dark-matter questions; a linear-field or abundance calculation does not provide their answers. Full versus fractional abundance, preliminary pure-glue inputs and conditional axinova assumptions remain source-specific.","rationale":"The exact definitions support a next question from abundance and linear structure to the separately scoped nonlinear signatures, without asserting a new physical result.","evidenceIds":["unit:051540688eb85aaac402d313994139d962ba92e41615a42261afabe13889b3c2","unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-d43a8973642e5bf710ff-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0777daf5a5d5108c1a33bb07"},{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:051540688eb85aaac402d313994139d962ba92e41615a42261afabe13889b3c2","textSha256":"bb5e10603460dbfd3d61d70fea99d99a2f514c918f87f041098b86802f697d12"},{"localRef":"u31","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","textSha256":"a43716256e5420305ab4cb364f4c990e81bcab046ecc6f7a0d6c16f116602642"},{"localRef":"n26","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","reviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n39","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:051540688eb85aaac402d313994139d962ba92e41615a42261afabe13889b3c2","reviewId":"leaf-d43a8973642e5bf710ff-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n40","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","reviewId":"leaf-d43a8973642e5bf710ff-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c9 explicitly supplies the nonlinear destinations named in the title. The route correctly presents a further question rather than an inference from linear perturbations, preserving its pure-glue and conditional-collapse limits.","refs":["c0","c9","u0","u31","n26","n39","n40"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:cn0":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:cn0","source":"q025-candidate-question:f844cc9f0ab6bd558e073eaf","target":"q025-candidate-question:09f5a18193d84f33cc744dad","type":"premise_check","title":"Check the model's thermal and dissipative assumptions","qualification":"For a warm or dissipative scenario, check the consistency conditions its mechanism actually invokes. Test thermal dominance or a specified dissipation strength only where assumed; additional damping alone establishes neither requirement. Thermal trapping remains a distinct mechanism. Thermal perturbations provide no automatic TCC exemption, and relaxing TCC for later stages differs from imposing it throughout.","rationale":"c1 provides model-specific consistency questions relevant to c11's conditional viability tests. The tachyon and RS-II witnesses illustrate such checks without exporting their thermal or strong-dissipation premises to every c11 model.","evidenceIds":["unit:34aec69e636ccc1a84326a9428e2ba80708d085eb3544f25cb35183bf8d9375d","unit:6767526b014d7c9f20daa9be08d60964fea073ce7fddc913a6f704f48a71449a","unit:80b2f9a7aa9ef5ef75bd86462d31f9b3df65f8764ec95403e69d6911abb28617","unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c11","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f844cc9f0ab6bd558e073eaf"},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:09f5a18193d84f33cc744dad"},{"localRef":"u11","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:34aec69e636ccc1a84326a9428e2ba80708d085eb3544f25cb35183bf8d9375d","textSha256":"5bb38a9055bddb22ccb43cd1a3eb54ec9d784ec4a02031074145df770e44233c"},{"localRef":"u21","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:6767526b014d7c9f20daa9be08d60964fea073ce7fddc913a6f704f48a71449a","textSha256":"91a8ded39fd6e22536a1e444540a2796720d8f3e40827d4b103097756a94c2be"},{"localRef":"u25","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:80b2f9a7aa9ef5ef75bd86462d31f9b3df65f8764ec95403e69d6911abb28617","textSha256":"16eadc0abe794b9fbfb39edbd706327c6b78a67a2cd0a6a93613aec579c1e9cc"},{"localRef":"u34","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe","textSha256":"dcf05b6f58993ba89942fbd0068f54fd3a81161040feb4a753333341b672bd11"},{"localRef":"n13","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ba45822b31667bacac33f819d86d9181d0ad5e9114407e4a1e8f872a4f678fbe","reviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n15","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:34aec69e636ccc1a84326a9428e2ba80708d085eb3544f25cb35183bf8d9375d","reviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n33","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6767526b014d7c9f20daa9be08d60964fea073ce7fddc913a6f704f48a71449a","reviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n34","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:80b2f9a7aa9ef5ef75bd86462d31f9b3df65f8764ec95403e69d6911abb28617","reviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:cn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"cn0","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"coordinatorAssessment":{"verdict":"coordinator_approved","reason":"Root explicitly approved this exact challenger replacement after reading the complete implicated scopes, whole descriptions and both attribution notes. c1 provides model-specific consistency questions relevant to c11's conditional viability tests. The tachyon and RS-II witnesses illustrate such checks without exporting their thermal or strong-dissipation premises to every c11 model.","refs":["c11","c1","u11","u21","u25","u34","n13","n15","n33","n34"],"originalIndependentJudgment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"revise","reason":"The premise-check direction is useful, but applying thermal-dominance checks to 'warm or damped branches' can transfer a thermal premise to unspecified additional damping. c11 and u11 do not license that universal requirement. Replace with cn0, which checks thermal dominance and dissipation strength only when invoked by the model.","refs":["c1","c11","u11","u21","u25","u34","n13","n15","n33","n34"]},"replacedOriginal":{"id":"pn2","source":"c11","target":"c1","type":"premise_check","title":"Check thermal and dissipative consistency","qualification":"For the warm or damped branches, test the stated dissipation law, thermal dominance and required strength independently of observational agreement. Thermal trapping remains a separate mechanism; thermal perturbations provide no automatic TCC exemption, and later-stage relaxation differs from imposing TCC throughout.","reason":"c11's conditional viability question requires model-specific thermal consistency, which c1 explicitly investigates and u25 makes an independent test.","refs":["c11","c1","u25","u21","u11","u34","n13","n15","n33","n34"]},"nativeChallengerObject":{"id":"cn0","source":"c11","target":"c1","type":"premise_check","title":"Check the model's thermal and dissipative assumptions","qualification":"For a warm or dissipative scenario, check the consistency conditions its mechanism actually invokes. Test thermal dominance or a specified dissipation strength only where assumed; additional damping alone establishes neither requirement. Thermal trapping remains a distinct mechanism. Thermal perturbations provide no automatic TCC exemption, and relaxing TCC for later stages differs from imposing it throughout.","reason":"c1 provides model-specific consistency questions relevant to c11's conditional viability tests. The tachyon and RS-II witnesses illustrate such checks without exporting their thermal or strong-dissipation premises to every c11 model.","refs":["c11","c1","u11","u21","u25","u34","n13","n15","n33","n34"]}},"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:cn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:pn3":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","target":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","type":"narrower","title":"Test compactification hierarchies and Wilsonian control","qualification":"Distinguish equation solving, correction ordering and integrating out degrees of freedom. Static or evolving internal fields and fixed or varying gravitational coefficients are separate branches. Reported hierarchies do not certify convergence; corrected duality and the Wilsonian construction retain their stated unresolved limits.","rationale":"c6 provides the specific compactification reliability tests within c2's broader effective-description question.","evidenceIds":["unit:5d44db45b25d450de0329358dd75fed0db273e0034f8088dee99ea6acba04fd2","unit:607daedfc9bbd0023f28c127b2edf0128da4d654fbaa907d69a02d06a9158526","unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","unit:f0304fcd14da8894c06149b79ac42ca8b8761d69b9ed26cdcaeed02d20da576d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-3a77497cf907c29b63ed-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d"},{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c"},{"localRef":"u45","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:f0304fcd14da8894c06149b79ac42ca8b8761d69b9ed26cdcaeed02d20da576d","textSha256":"2da062755504d02226b77b08d287e3a9de5589a4d04edebad1519ee8b496e096"},{"localRef":"u18","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:5d44db45b25d450de0329358dd75fed0db273e0034f8088dee99ea6acba04fd2","textSha256":"9b87bf64b161d970b1a6b48bc3d81f34804f5596e239ae016c6b8fd28384b74c"},{"localRef":"u20","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:607daedfc9bbd0023f28c127b2edf0128da4d654fbaa907d69a02d06a9158526","textSha256":"8dcfea361f3010c596c57ecb00b160f9ce4281d5100c9bc7675399c4c3de06f8"},{"localRef":"n8","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f0304fcd14da8894c06149b79ac42ca8b8761d69b9ed26cdcaeed02d20da576d","reviewId":"leaf-3a77497cf907c29b63ed-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n22","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:607daedfc9bbd0023f28c127b2edf0128da4d654fbaa907d69a02d06a9158526","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n23","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:5d44db45b25d450de0329358dd75fed0db273e0034f8088dee99ea6acba04fd2","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n24","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction matches the supported specialization. Its qualification preserves equation solving, correction ordering and Wilsonian integration as distinct tests and retains unresolved convergence and duality concerns.","refs":["c2","c6","u18","u20","u45","n8","n22","n23","n24"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:pn4":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643","target":"q025-candidate-question:64d242f010006f3d1a0a3120","type":"comparison","title":"Compare stabilization and supersymmetry breaking","qualification":"Compare shared coupling and hierarchy goals while retaining each compactification's assumptions. Negligible-warping and corrected warped conifold analyses remain distinct, as do non-geometric ISS constants and gravitino hierarchies. Suitable scales alone establish neither a breaking pattern, inflation nor a complete compactification.","rationale":"The destinations share concrete stabilization targets while exposing different geometric conditions, sectors and supersymmetry-breaking tests.","evidenceIds":["unit:14a2146d250ce913608b4defd62d04dfe2658cca550fd5594fcfdf58b473bcec","unit:4662b44467681f883d21e8b73a7f5898a545b8ee2ef47d050bd9464cd9d288f6","unit:9b071fd37c312de6622529db7d0134e7ac54728ef6906cf44f97914c112bb934","unit:b2e63c6fb71ac27aa7c23301ae32df91861d94d39a9099906c923875d1048d53","unit:ebbd0f85c26fe09842b7ded9d51d31eae52891bcec1e45d00aadc356c0afe517"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643"},{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0594a24f01f9b493cef4-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:64d242f010006f3d1a0a3120"},{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:4662b44467681f883d21e8b73a7f5898a545b8ee2ef47d050bd9464cd9d288f6","textSha256":"c549b66541fd94aafb5fdbd15db121d8e1ea6e2d1985ed2e77d7f60245e1755d"},{"localRef":"u32","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:b2e63c6fb71ac27aa7c23301ae32df91861d94d39a9099906c923875d1048d53","textSha256":"064f865548bafacc88c365b7c467dff55ab1ff51a3112f025778fa64abf07466"},{"localRef":"u4","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:14a2146d250ce913608b4defd62d04dfe2658cca550fd5594fcfdf58b473bcec","textSha256":"95a189a65d55853e127ea0bbdac51a50e1f9ec6cb88e86f06373cee315504632"},{"localRef":"u29","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:9b071fd37c312de6622529db7d0134e7ac54728ef6906cf44f97914c112bb934","textSha256":"48d7929259b9ea9cdc5be7fe688aa7701d59bac60019b4cbc55b3b3750a09918"},{"localRef":"u43","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:ebbd0f85c26fe09842b7ded9d51d31eae52891bcec1e45d00aadc356c0afe517","textSha256":"b1b3730e095a9fabc2a545577a2ef020a8546d61bc2b65d0767dfb814349e3fa"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:9b071fd37c312de6622529db7d0134e7ac54728ef6906cf44f97914c112bb934","reviewId":"leaf-0594a24f01f9b493cef4-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n1","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ebbd0f85c26fe09842b7ded9d51d31eae52891bcec1e45d00aadc356c0afe517","reviewId":"leaf-0594a24f01f9b493cef4-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:4662b44467681f883d21e8b73a7f5898a545b8ee2ef47d050bd9464cd9d288f6","reviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n5","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:b2e63c6fb71ac27aa7c23301ae32df91861d94d39a9099906c923875d1048d53","reviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n6","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:14a2146d250ce913608b4defd62d04dfe2658cca550fd5594fcfdf58b473bcec","reviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The comparison is useful for shared coupling and hierarchy goals while distinguishing geometric and breaking-pattern questions. The route preserves warped versus negligible-warping premises and ISS versus gravitino targets.","refs":["c3","c8","u4","u15","u29","u32","u43","n0","n1","n4","n5","n6"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:pn5":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:pn5","source":"q025-candidate-question:17c2095dd57e53c275a35728","target":"q025-candidate-question:5c0e01464732c8f9e3d5f0bf","type":"comparison","title":"Compare mechanisms for sustaining or ending acceleration","qualification":"Near-two-dimensional dressing is not identified with four-dimensional dynamics. Fixed-background particle production only motivates curvature reduction when gravitational backreaction is deferred; stochastic treatments retain their semiclassical assumptions. The early-to-late vacuum-fluctuation proposal remains an incomplete consistency program and only compares with RVM.","rationale":"The definitions and shared u22 contribution support the nominated comparison between epoch-spanning evolution and mechanism-specific persistence or exit.","evidenceIds":["unit:1cc9f2ae9c5794115790ea0a0f99ec2c3cecb49ca817b42c8194425e59004bf7","unit:6ff4f058e147a3060972c1203a944562c4ba409856b381d67d44b9cb9d545c62","unit:cc1e4913880ae3054588aee1465945f966ce8de797240169d904cf6255912aee","unit:f2a4cd6c6db7f6636d11cdb603d3b623ade964b12e888c7a9ad169e7e2edd3bd"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:17c2095dd57e53c275a35728"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5c0e01464732c8f9e3d5f0bf"},{"localRef":"u22","kind":"description","unitIndex":83,"unitId":"unit:6ff4f058e147a3060972c1203a944562c4ba409856b381d67d44b9cb9d545c62","textSha256":"fb3be3d3e9df3350c21c4f353f8a8e71951fc507c4fd9b8c0403592960e8f001"},{"localRef":"u46","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:f2a4cd6c6db7f6636d11cdb603d3b623ade964b12e888c7a9ad169e7e2edd3bd","textSha256":"bf9ab3263930fd22da7cb223d58a21b3fd014185aa9987b08a0706d2fc89d700"},{"localRef":"u37","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:cc1e4913880ae3054588aee1465945f966ce8de797240169d904cf6255912aee","textSha256":"1ec012542b85ec1d26ae631f61d026300a269565f43692a03df2c0951e332ebe"},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:1cc9f2ae9c5794115790ea0a0f99ec2c3cecb49ca817b42c8194425e59004bf7","textSha256":"9733b8e4904650b5b815328d8f4a9b74087130ba17b12f307ef55431b71c7e01"},{"localRef":"n18","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f2a4cd6c6db7f6636d11cdb603d3b623ade964b12e888c7a9ad169e7e2edd3bd","reviewId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n20","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6ff4f058e147a3060972c1203a944562c4ba409856b381d67d44b9cb9d545c62","reviewId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n41","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:cc1e4913880ae3054588aee1465945f966ce8de797240169d904cf6255912aee","reviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n45","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6ff4f058e147a3060972c1203a944562c4ba409856b381d67d44b9cb9d545c62","reviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n46","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:1cc9f2ae9c5794115790ea0a0f99ec2c3cecb49ca817b42c8194425e59004bf7","reviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l1","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:17c2095dd57e53c275a35728","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5c0e01464732c8f9e3d5f0bf","candidateId":"successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-challenge:link:20","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:pn5","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn5","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The nominated comparison connects epoch-spanning evolution with persistence and exit mechanisms. Near-two-dimensional dynamics, deferred gravitational backreaction, semiclassical assumptions and unfinished RVM comparison are accurately qualified.","refs":["c4","c7","u7","u22","u37","u46","n18","n20","n41","n45","n46","l1"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:pn5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:pn6":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:pn6","source":"q025-candidate-question:196ad6a1578dbedb9be738a4","target":"q025-candidate-question:ef74c380b30b8ba4df509c90","type":"premise_check","title":"Test whether fluctuations sustain inflating volume","qualification":"Separate local quantum dominance, escape from a finite region and growth of inflating volume. Fluctuation estimates require their stated control regime; no universal beyond-slow-roll threshold is supplied. The original-gradient single-inflaton calculation does not universally exclude hilltop, assisted or other mechanisms.","rationale":"The survival and control tests in c10 check premises needed before c5's self-reproduction and subsequent-history questions can be answered.","evidenceIds":["unit:161ba479ed6f097ed38c5bae5bbde20f96dbb59cfe2e015acea0852cc608f1e9","unit:1cc9f2ae9c5794115790ea0a0f99ec2c3cecb49ca817b42c8194425e59004bf7","unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","unit:ea4f1ec7e98b46550ea9072be1e94a4f8a111c51671ec16c1ae8de7e7d30a588"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:196ad6a1578dbedb9be738a4"},{"localRef":"c10","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ef74c380b30b8ba4df509c90"},{"localRef":"u5","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:161ba479ed6f097ed38c5bae5bbde20f96dbb59cfe2e015acea0852cc608f1e9","textSha256":"129b1ad21143fd7e04df18c6953d2281fd3828dcc22cf0a3f8c9838a1d5b8bf0"},{"localRef":"u40","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","textSha256":"d5a8a587374a18807a0e7f886b8a73c00998c7e8e9eb910ff4eccaddde06b5d9"},{"localRef":"u41","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:ea4f1ec7e98b46550ea9072be1e94a4f8a111c51671ec16c1ae8de7e7d30a588","textSha256":"13f8b52372a6576293fb66fdcec31e367569711a529c7bd7389741bd595add4a"},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:1cc9f2ae9c5794115790ea0a0f99ec2c3cecb49ca817b42c8194425e59004bf7","textSha256":"9733b8e4904650b5b815328d8f4a9b74087130ba17b12f307ef55431b71c7e01"},{"localRef":"n29","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:161ba479ed6f097ed38c5bae5bbde20f96dbb59cfe2e015acea0852cc608f1e9","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n31","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n50","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ea4f1ec7e98b46550ea9072be1e94a4f8a111c51671ec16c1ae8de7e7d30a588","reviewId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n51","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","reviewId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n52","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:1cc9f2ae9c5794115790ea0a0f99ec2c3cecb49ca817b42c8194425e59004bf7","reviewId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:pn6","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn6","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"A conditional self-reproduction question can use c10 to check survival and fluctuation-control premises. The route correctly separates local dominance, finite-region escape and volume growth without universalizing the restricted gradient calculation.","refs":["c5","c10","u5","u7","u40","u41","n29","n31","n50","n51","n52"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:pn6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:pn7":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:pn7","source":"q025-candidate-question:ef74c380b30b8ba4df509c90","target":"q025-candidate-question:196ad6a1578dbedb9be738a4","type":"related_question","title":"Check the later observable phase","qualification":"A self-reproducing phase does not by itself supply sufficient later expansion or the observed small primordial perturbations. These are additional targets; stochastic or entropy compatibility does not demonstrate the transition.","rationale":"Once the survival question is posed, c5 provides the separately defined next question about subsequent observable cosmology.","evidenceIds":["unit:a9255b4aa3b990808bbf3f9e02f6083c2e383842996d2115f901593fe26e6bff","unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c10","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ef74c380b30b8ba4df509c90"},{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p6","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:196ad6a1578dbedb9be738a4"},{"localRef":"u30","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:a9255b4aa3b990808bbf3f9e02f6083c2e383842996d2115f901593fe26e6bff","textSha256":"310a464a03960fb3833d65fe36d26f3aa37053dc33fa6d9570fb20a03e1c6050"},{"localRef":"u40","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","textSha256":"d5a8a587374a18807a0e7f886b8a73c00998c7e8e9eb910ff4eccaddde06b5d9"},{"localRef":"n30","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:a9255b4aa3b990808bbf3f9e02f6083c2e383842996d2115f901593fe26e6bff","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n31","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","reviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n51","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e8a506532850319212502f3f2f75b8bc3a1965f04745f06ac4b2fb348cfc331b","reviewId":"leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:pn7","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn7","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-04-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c5 explicitly asks about later sufficient expansion and acceptable perturbations. A related-question route from survival to that additional temporal target is supported without claiming a demonstrated transition or an application relation.","refs":["c10","c5","u30","u40","n30","n31","n51"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-04:route:pn7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-question:1bb053304be3775d8c79d2f4","target":"q025-candidate-question:ee233163e41eed46b2433010","type":"comparison","title":"Test axion quintessence assumptions","qualification":"Compare flatness, potential amplitude and initial conditions. The single-cosine tension requires its stated prefactor and relevant-instanton bound; electroweak and many-axion alternatives need separate checks. The joint inflation/quintessence branch additionally requires unchanged parameters and retains historical data benchmarks.","rationale":"Provides a concrete next question within the shared dark-energy target while preserving c10's additional assumptions and joint-epoch task.","evidenceIds":["unit:c42e4c3ccbf820a5df4a7428a47b4eee4fba7245bd7e17d0c9aa81014d08bcca","unit:cd3d86dc325f086555b0647b37a8bd44b5b393d10540674f23b21bab18b12996","unit:f292ab0dcc1705ec766ea8e97e3f4cb614ca8f3332f6da09002666ca9e7dc5da"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb053304be3775d8c79d2f4"},{"localRef":"c10","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ee233163e41eed46b2433010"},{"localRef":"u25","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:c42e4c3ccbf820a5df4a7428a47b4eee4fba7245bd7e17d0c9aa81014d08bcca","textSha256":"71672107904f7bcf83852749c271fd67650d3ecc55db7d8b399c702bcf9d96c5"},{"localRef":"u30","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:cd3d86dc325f086555b0647b37a8bd44b5b393d10540674f23b21bab18b12996","textSha256":"473ad03fd1f6ede3acef30b0adbb2f2bbf9963c0482066100eebd9509cf8c32a"},{"localRef":"u35","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:f292ab0dcc1705ec766ea8e97e3f4cb614ca8f3332f6da09002666ca9e7dc5da","textSha256":"fedcb3506104609465d67b412348c611581dc211a2c68bb261b48c3a09d790cf"},{"localRef":"n22","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:cd3d86dc325f086555b0647b37a8bd44b5b393d10540674f23b21bab18b12996","reviewId":"leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n23","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:f292ab0dcc1705ec766ea8e97e3f4cb614ca8f3332f6da09002666ca9e7dc5da","reviewId":"leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n24","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c42e4c3ccbf820a5df4a7428a47b4eee4fba7245bd7e17d0c9aa81014d08bcca","reviewId":"leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"A comparison from the broad axionic dark-energy question to potential and initial-condition tests is supported. The route explicitly preserves the relevant-instanton/prefactor premises, separate alternative constructions and unchanged-parameter joint epochs; it does not claim containment.","refs":["c0","c10","u25","u30","u35","n22","n23","n24"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-question:1c0707643dd3d6c558ee5b6a","target":"q025-candidate-question:e686cfbdc5894823cdcd1c30","type":"comparison","title":"Compare long-range forces and scattering criteria","qualification":"Massless scalar exchange and neutral massive-scalar threshold scattering use different observables. The threshold prescription assumes flat spacetime, frozen spectators and small external kinetic energies. Horizon mediator selection and repulsive-force criteria are not automatically equivalent to either prescription.","rationale":"Moves from formulation distinctions to concrete alternative comparison regimes without asserting a common inequality.","evidenceIds":["unit:3a812b007310f39981c1db0955bea8cb50867ddf95deb82d6d7d9e353eb5bbd6","unit:69d038447a9890865532db22a99c4e9b1a4155160480492601f5d8b1cf9b0568","unit:87afe2c571ef4ae309e28297d03888307da6a1b2143375130b477f0df80040c3","unit:c0653333dae3a67fa83fe536e0c76d7a480a4f571cf24baf021b8e6cdeb8f1f8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-777289df84203d433c78-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1c0707643dd3d6c558ee5b6a"},{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-bada8f0b6f9749c30c67-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e686cfbdc5894823cdcd1c30"},{"localRef":"u5","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:3a812b007310f39981c1db0955bea8cb50867ddf95deb82d6d7d9e353eb5bbd6","textSha256":"a562e359f6a4f1059fc045159b6e55f7562ed7bf1ded7c9d263f721691333e5e"},{"localRef":"u11","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:69d038447a9890865532db22a99c4e9b1a4155160480492601f5d8b1cf9b0568","textSha256":"40405b1c67ed072bc409a397eed78cdcf015c1b2b894266fdceda173e349a1c4"},{"localRef":"u16","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:87afe2c571ef4ae309e28297d03888307da6a1b2143375130b477f0df80040c3","textSha256":"137a7be37e80558657a83116380fdc224ea6dad0953e8f549e3fb16a98918755"},{"localRef":"u24","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:c0653333dae3a67fa83fe536e0c76d7a480a4f571cf24baf021b8e6cdeb8f1f8","textSha256":"7d2f5d758247ec5f2e894e3ad8bafaa8840dc758c4b70e1d6c1f854a1ae9d6b0"},{"localRef":"n19","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:69d038447a9890865532db22a99c4e9b1a4155160480492601f5d8b1cf9b0568","reviewId":"leaf-777289df84203d433c78-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n20","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c0653333dae3a67fa83fe536e0c76d7a480a4f571cf24baf021b8e6cdeb8f1f8","reviewId":"leaf-777289df84203d433c78-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n30","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:87afe2c571ef4ae309e28297d03888307da6a1b2143375130b477f0df80040c3","reviewId":"leaf-bada8f0b6f9749c30c67-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n32","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:3a812b007310f39981c1db0955bea8cb50867ddf95deb82d6d7d9e353eb5bbd6","reviewId":"leaf-bada8f0b6f9749c30c67-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"u16 and u5 supply concrete long-range and threshold-scattering alternatives. The route retains flat spacetime, frozen spectators and small kinetic energies and distinguishes horizon selection and repulsive-force criteria without claiming equivalent inequalities.","refs":["c1","c9","u5","u11","u16","u24","n19","n20","n30","n32"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn2":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-question:f2d9f1c4d20ccb21b752aa1e","target":"q025-candidate-question:1e336be02213b690c67114dd","type":"comparison","title":"Compare interaction tests with geometric control","qualification":"Partial scalar-interaction exclusions and perturbative-locality criteria differ from graviton-localization and compactification-hierarchy tests. A cutoff above curvature is not a compactification mass gap; brane-decoupling and species-scale arguments retain their stated conditions.","rationale":"Admits the concrete comparison suggested by l2 while preserving the full scope differences.","evidenceIds":["unit:18a5e8212ad5a926d0d74e3d177808c9d0355569608ac3ebfa2c3dbc03554fd1","unit:36e32b09834c5e312c413871c5c43843dbe877ec013019b77569900dc796bf19","unit:c934cb230b244fe18976a0b8c42d1e2c438b17f2c9b3c1f0140075e137a2861d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c11","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-07c5faf6babeb0673e5b-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f2d9f1c4d20ccb21b752aa1e"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1e336be02213b690c67114dd"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:18a5e8212ad5a926d0d74e3d177808c9d0355569608ac3ebfa2c3dbc03554fd1","textSha256":"a00ac4253856fc70f7b579427b4d89b79f5fc9fce55e369b765bcddbbadc03fa"},{"localRef":"u3","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:36e32b09834c5e312c413871c5c43843dbe877ec013019b77569900dc796bf19","textSha256":"34a1ec050a9df223133039c7d6de35ed9ce88e7c9b8827870fbfe5911c0a2898"},{"localRef":"u28","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:c934cb230b244fe18976a0b8c42d1e2c438b17f2c9b3c1f0140075e137a2861d","textSha256":"adf0763c2d58c1b482b1f08959fd9c94b4355c514d8145aa1e07f5717afca83c"},{"localRef":"n3","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:36e32b09834c5e312c413871c5c43843dbe877ec013019b77569900dc796bf19","reviewId":"leaf-07c5faf6babeb0673e5b-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n40","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c934cb230b244fe18976a0b8c42d1e2c438b17f2c9b3c1f0140075e137a2861d","reviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l2","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f2d9f1c4d20ccb21b752aa1e","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1e336be02213b690c67114dd","candidateId":"successor2-parent-0b9505226b0fcc606395-challenge:link:18","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The direction matches the comparison nominated in l2. The title gives a concrete next question, and the qualification preserves interaction/geometric differences and conditional hierarchy premises. This compares tasks; it asserts no physical implication between their bounds.","refs":["c11","c2","u0","u3","u28","n3","n40","l2"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn3":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-question:23afe5edb99a839a6bd60ad8","target":"q025-candidate-question:cc6407d4ae9b11e139f5bd22","type":"comparison","title":"Distinguish counts, indices and finiteness","qualification":"Keep the counted object, quotient, geometry and charge regime explicit. Signed indices, isolated points and connected components are different outputs; fixed-family bounds do not establish global finiteness. Description-supported claims retain their missing-hypothesis and completeness limits.","rationale":"Makes the finiteness and count-convention questions accessible from enumeration and search without equating their answers or evidential strength.","evidenceIds":["unit:b55c030cb3a24e2a9d3159266ce477dd62742558d985eaefb28608ea25d83deb","unit:c518029af2b4b2b0263ede0dd2917955a86faae2983fda7551c53811bdeffb7d","unit:e5137b7007ef0315283ea5017b1117043f0cf4f5c85775630cf68558f6f92223"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:23afe5edb99a839a6bd60ad8"},{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cc6407d4ae9b11e139f5bd22"},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:b55c030cb3a24e2a9d3159266ce477dd62742558d985eaefb28608ea25d83deb","textSha256":"fb46477b47c09be9e40ce363837b1a15a02c145c77f6a3116a1accd600ebc776"},{"localRef":"u26","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:c518029af2b4b2b0263ede0dd2917955a86faae2983fda7551c53811bdeffb7d","textSha256":"edf884344a5286d5d951d663be22cbcafb292530fbca6d6e6494af8004121855"},{"localRef":"u33","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:e5137b7007ef0315283ea5017b1117043f0cf4f5c85775630cf68558f6f92223","textSha256":"5ba1fcd671fec0dbab737e190fe942eaab44ddd44053af4493d3853492ceed51"},{"localRef":"n10","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:b55c030cb3a24e2a9d3159266ce477dd62742558d985eaefb28608ea25d83deb","reviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n35","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c518029af2b4b2b0263ede0dd2917955a86faae2983fda7551c53811bdeffb7d","reviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n36","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:e5137b7007ef0315283ea5017b1117043f0cf4f5c85775630cf68558f6f92223","reviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l0","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:23afe5edb99a839a6bd60ad8","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cc6407d4ae9b11e139f5bd22","candidateId":"parent-30cfd228b7769fd058dc-challenge:link:28","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The comparison realizes l0 using c8's explicit count, index, component and finiteness distinctions. Its qualification preserves geometry, quotient, charge regime and missing-hypothesis limits rather than treating search results as certified counts.","refs":["c3","c8","u19","u26","u33","n10","n35","n36","l0"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn4":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-question:24e1b09b901c1be54e4d61ee","target":"q025-candidate-question:83e35ef679868008269066eb","type":"narrower","title":"Examine the conditional thermal mass bound","qualification":"Restrict to near-ultracold Nariai throats, vacuum-energy dominance, equilibrium Boltzmann-suppressed charges and the stated coupling domain. Rapid discharge means order-one charge loss within a Hubble time; conduction is independent of the photon-fusion estimate. Collapse uses homogeneous models. The c=1, g*=2 benchmarks and logarithmic normalization are not universal; B−L applications additionally require an unbroken sufficiently light gauge sector. Announced phenomenology is not independently validated here.","rationale":"Provides the narrower constraint question from the broader mechanism question while retaining every consequential applicability restriction.","evidenceIds":["unit:6260e0e141321b5108335e18494f7cc739fd304c1862ccd9ac79a67a094ff5d1"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-87d7993188bba7a3ec4c-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24e1b09b901c1be54e4d61ee"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:83e35ef679868008269066eb"},{"localRef":"u10","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:6260e0e141321b5108335e18494f7cc739fd304c1862ccd9ac79a67a094ff5d1","textSha256":"f9f2091cb7048e22e6d4a2af58123cdc1c67b6f2b7f801530cb0387604838ab5"},{"localRef":"n21","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6260e0e141321b5108335e18494f7cc739fd304c1862ccd9ac79a67a094ff5d1","reviewId":"leaf-87d7993188bba7a3ec4c-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n28","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:6260e0e141321b5108335e18494f7cc739fd304c1862ccd9ac79a67a094ff5d1","reviewId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction follows the written scopes. The route retains Boltzmann suppression, coupling applicability, charge-loss criterion, independent conduction, homogeneous evolution, benchmark sensitivity and the extra B−L premises. It does not require a new physical relation beyond those inherited qualifications.","refs":["c4","c7","u10","n21","n28"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn5":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn5","source":"q025-candidate-question:265bd371fe1997a8c8287c76","target":"q025-candidate-question:530e8cb46259544847e705a1","type":"related_question","title":"Explore ultraviolet prescriptions for primordial fluctuations","qualification":"Compare initial-state observables with modified propagation, finite-time prescriptions and conditional censorship implementations. Their consistency conditions remain source-specific. Damping is not decoherence or censorship, and historical observational comparisons are not current fits.","rationale":"Admits the bounded overlap in l1 without claiming containment or equivalence of the complete scopes.","evidenceIds":["unit:811f0cd0e6a8dc24a2f2e2b763c0837b65b9e0227ee249adacc415663181a248","unit:b0f7bc9b4d6d1431b11d387a4c24d385542d33b98192cb805e7696bec1fa6ec3","unit:bf7a3f7051d78debe2078ca945a826df58e3421a064511b9ce8db859c8cda024"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:265bd371fe1997a8c8287c76"},{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:530e8cb46259544847e705a1"},{"localRef":"u14","kind":"description","unitIndex":100,"unitId":"unit:811f0cd0e6a8dc24a2f2e2b763c0837b65b9e0227ee249adacc415663181a248","textSha256":"867c91767b2689e22ea807500dfc7e95a8e5a9857a33e21cc2736ec733d748e5"},{"localRef":"u18","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:b0f7bc9b4d6d1431b11d387a4c24d385542d33b98192cb805e7696bec1fa6ec3","textSha256":"1a76fee6691def76114a30f95e40f160bae1d722c14c2ccb27d1e77d430bffa4"},{"localRef":"u23","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:bf7a3f7051d78debe2078ca945a826df58e3421a064511b9ce8db859c8cda024","textSha256":"d070a11b591bca008deb70c75fd202fe208b4d628946cffbf640a253d7755d80"},{"localRef":"n12","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:bf7a3f7051d78debe2078ca945a826df58e3421a064511b9ce8db859c8cda024","reviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n14","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:b0f7bc9b4d6d1431b11d387a4c24d385542d33b98192cb805e7696bec1fa6ec3","reviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n16","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:811f0cd0e6a8dc24a2f2e2b763c0837b65b9e0227ee249adacc415663181a248","reviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l1","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:265bd371fe1997a8c8287c76","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:530e8cb46259544847e705a1","candidateId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge:link:28","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn5","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn5","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The related-question arc is supported by shared robustness and observable-state targets and the bounded overlap in l1. It neither asserts containment nor identifies damping, decoherence and censorship.","refs":["c5","c6","u14","u18","u23","n12","n14","n16","l1"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn6":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn6","source":"q025-candidate-question:1e336be02213b690c67114dd","target":"q025-candidate-question:c073ce5ebda7456546a71118","type":"narrower","title":"Inspect the CFT criteria for local bulk EFT","qualification":"Focus on perturbativity, finitely generated low-dimension Fock-space structure and polynomial Mellin boundedness. The target is an EFT cutoff above curvature, not a universal compactification hierarchy; the announced criterion is not proved by this packet.","rationale":"Offers a precise locality question within the broader classification and geometric-control scope.","evidenceIds":["unit:18a5e8212ad5a926d0d74e3d177808c9d0355569608ac3ebfa2c3dbc03554fd1"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1e336be02213b690c67114dd"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:18a5e8212ad5a926d0d74e3d177808c9d0355569608ac3ebfa2c3dbc03554fd1","textSha256":"a00ac4253856fc70f7b579427b4d89b79f5fc9fce55e369b765bcddbbadc03fa"},{"localRef":"n42","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:18a5e8212ad5a926d0d74e3d177808c9d0355569608ac3ebfa2c3dbc03554fd1","reviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn6","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn6","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c2 explicitly contains the locality criterion, so the broader-to-narrower arc is licensed. The route distinguishes cutoff control from compactification hierarchy and retains the absence of an independently checked proof.","refs":["c2","u0","n42"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn7":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn7","source":"q025-candidate-question:f2d9f1c4d20ccb21b752aa1e","target":"q025-candidate-question:c073ce5ebda7456546a71118","type":"narrower","title":"Isolate the perturbative locality criterion","qualification":"The three-part criterion concerns a controlled local AdS EFT. Separate scalar and higher-spin interaction restrictions, including their loopholes, remain outside this narrower question. Necessity and sufficiency are source-announced.","rationale":"Separates the shared locality target from c11's additional interaction and dual-type tests.","evidenceIds":["unit:18a5e8212ad5a926d0d74e3d177808c9d0355569608ac3ebfa2c3dbc03554fd1"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c11","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-07c5faf6babeb0673e5b-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f2d9f1c4d20ccb21b752aa1e"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:18a5e8212ad5a926d0d74e3d177808c9d0355569608ac3ebfa2c3dbc03554fd1","textSha256":"a00ac4253856fc70f7b579427b4d89b79f5fc9fce55e369b765bcddbbadc03fa"},{"localRef":"n0","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:18a5e8212ad5a926d0d74e3d177808c9d0355569608ac3ebfa2c3dbc03554fd1","reviewId":"leaf-07c5faf6babeb0673e5b-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn7","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn7","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The route correctly isolates c11's locality target while leaving scalar and higher-spin restrictions outside pq0. The announced status of necessity and sufficiency remains explicit.","refs":["c11","u0","n0"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn8":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn8","source":"q025-candidate-question:23afe5edb99a839a6bd60ad8","target":"q025-candidate-question:5712feb81e448688e3572680","type":"narrower","title":"Check BP counts beyond the volume approximation","qualification":"Restrict to the specified BP lattice and counting region. Very thin shells belong to the stated formulation, and minimum nonnegative Λ remains distinct from minimum strictly positive Λ. No exact-count or search-completeness guarantee is supplied.","rationale":"Gives a concrete approximation question within the broader enumeration and search program.","evidenceIds":["unit:41135c4acb7efa885e8f4b23a8988918f52b1f2f2da458ab4ae587ed7916410d","unit:45162bef371508fe437d35d4586b9d4d87532392305e69369455264970a28c7f"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge:p2","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:23afe5edb99a839a6bd60ad8"},{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cc6407d4ae9b11e139f5bd22"},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:41135c4acb7efa885e8f4b23a8988918f52b1f2f2da458ab4ae587ed7916410d","textSha256":"1d544a082eef0afa2fb2ef40d176b7905b6d8d43d93bce46dfbdc7cb74453454"},{"localRef":"u8","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:45162bef371508fe437d35d4586b9d4d87532392305e69369455264970a28c7f","textSha256":"1a4d7ac08908042c30e5991c460a53d3222ab828683824c4895ca0eabe8c147b"},{"localRef":"n33","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:41135c4acb7efa885e8f4b23a8988918f52b1f2f2da458ab4ae587ed7916410d","reviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n34","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:45162bef371508fe437d35d4586b9d4d87532392305e69369455264970a28c7f","reviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn8","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn8","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"A specified BP lattice-counting question fits within c3's enumeration and approximation scope. The qualification preserves source-specific shells and minimum conventions, and the arc does not transfer u7/u8 contributions to c3.","refs":["c3","c8","u7","u8","n33","n34"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn9":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn9","source":"q025-candidate-question:cc6407d4ae9b11e139f5bd22","target":"q025-candidate-question:5712feb81e448688e3572680","type":"narrower","title":"Separate the two minimum-Λ counting targets","qualification":"Compare BP counts and occupation estimates while retaining u7's nonnegative and u8's strictly positive minimum conventions. The shared destination establishes neither identical minima nor a quantitative relation between them.","rationale":"Turns an explicit convention distinction in c8 into an accessible narrower question.","evidenceIds":["unit:41135c4acb7efa885e8f4b23a8988918f52b1f2f2da458ab4ae587ed7916410d","unit:45162bef371508fe437d35d4586b9d4d87532392305e69369455264970a28c7f"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cc6407d4ae9b11e139f5bd22"},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:41135c4acb7efa885e8f4b23a8988918f52b1f2f2da458ab4ae587ed7916410d","textSha256":"1d544a082eef0afa2fb2ef40d176b7905b6d8d43d93bce46dfbdc7cb74453454"},{"localRef":"u8","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:45162bef371508fe437d35d4586b9d4d87532392305e69369455264970a28c7f","textSha256":"1a4d7ac08908042c30e5991c460a53d3222ab828683824c4895ca0eabe8c147b"},{"localRef":"n33","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:41135c4acb7efa885e8f4b23a8988918f52b1f2f2da458ab4ae587ed7916410d","reviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n34","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:45162bef371508fe437d35d4586b9d4d87532392305e69369455264970a28c7f","reviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn9","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn9","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn9","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The route makes c8's explicit minimum-Λ distinction accessible through pq1. Its qualification correctly permits a shared public destination while withholding equality or a quantitative relation between the minima.","refs":["c8","u7","u8","n33","n34"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn10":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn10","source":"q025-candidate-question:265bd371fe1997a8c8287c76","target":"q025-candidate-question:c539cd6d9e549c4c5b0ee3e3","type":"narrower","title":"Ask how fast admissible excitations fade","qualification":"The damping question assumes EFT-compatible states that already support inflation. It does not determine generic-state survival, inflationary onset probabilities or environmental decoherence; the contracting comparison remains separate.","rationale":"Exposes the controlled memory-loss question while preserving its essential initial-state restriction.","evidenceIds":["unit:c5eb98d28de194ba19467078f0e9a621005b86392759056d9d7bb21a56b3e2c6"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:265bd371fe1997a8c8287c76"},{"localRef":"u27","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:c5eb98d28de194ba19467078f0e9a621005b86392759056d9d7bb21a56b3e2c6","textSha256":"1481fa58aaf938779141508297e2f664f2f9ba3320c598d82f72eae38f5a1cbe"},{"localRef":"n6","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c5eb98d28de194ba19467078f0e9a621005b86392759056d9d7bb21a56b3e2c6","reviewId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn10","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn10","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn10","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The route selects the admissible-state memory-loss question already in c5 and preserves the surviving-background premise. Onset probability, decoherence and contraction are explicitly kept separate.","refs":["c5","u27","n6"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn10","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn11":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:pn11","source":"q025-candidate-question:530e8cb46259544847e705a1","target":"q025-candidate-question:c539cd6d9e549c4c5b0ee3e3","type":"narrower","title":"Examine controlled initial-state relaxation","qualification":"Specialize state relaxation to admissible inflationary EFT excitations. This restriction is not imposed on every propagation or quantum-cosmology prescription, and the damping result does not establish a censorship bound or universal ultraviolet insensitivity.","rationale":"Supplies a concrete relaxation destination within c6 without transferring its premises to unrelated branches.","evidenceIds":["unit:c5eb98d28de194ba19467078f0e9a621005b86392759056d9d7bb21a56b3e2c6"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:530e8cb46259544847e705a1"},{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:265bd371fe1997a8c8287c76"},{"localRef":"u27","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:c5eb98d28de194ba19467078f0e9a621005b86392759056d9d7bb21a56b3e2c6","textSha256":"1481fa58aaf938779141508297e2f664f2f9ba3320c598d82f72eae38f5a1cbe"},{"localRef":"n6","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c5eb98d28de194ba19467078f0e9a621005b86392759056d9d7bb21a56b3e2c6","reviewId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn11","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn11","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-05-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn11","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"c6's state-relaxation target supports the narrower destination. The qualification confines the EFT-admissibility premise to this branch and avoids deriving censorship or universal ultraviolet insensitivity from damping.","refs":["c6","c5","u27","n6"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-05:route:pn11","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn0":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn0","source":"q025-candidate-question:2787cd18a2486e736fd5921b","target":"q025-candidate-question:f85a966454b318a2706bf0cb","type":"related_question","title":"Follow flatness into field range and initial conditions","qualification":"Move from shared potential construction to the additional trajectory, gauge-component and axionic branches under their own assumptions. Canonical-Kähler obstructions are conditional; fixed-modulus baselines do not establish stabilization, and observational comparisons remain dated.","rationale":"The shared obstruction and relative-coupling descriptions support a useful continuation into c11's explicit dynamics targets without asserting whole-scope containment.","evidenceIds":["unit:01ed613346ef96646a7de1d8cc6c673dd1d5caaeca4bee5c8d2d9b47c19f7b8d","unit:1b78587762045c393aa696677de10213a9369530ad072a1f940e9f7e0476d21c","unit:637f529a670807364f144d33aedc23b0b8e7e2f4830bf3a9044de13e2bc92c0d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2787cd18a2486e736fd5921b"},{"localRef":"c11","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f85a966454b318a2706bf0cb"},{"localRef":"u0","kind":"description","unitIndex":71,"unitId":"unit:01ed613346ef96646a7de1d8cc6c673dd1d5caaeca4bee5c8d2d9b47c19f7b8d","textSha256":"7cd16e63958802f4746fbedc90d53549b0fd5354952deb4db48e10ee3263fff3"},{"localRef":"u18","kind":"description","unitIndex":70,"unitId":"unit:637f529a670807364f144d33aedc23b0b8e7e2f4830bf3a9044de13e2bc92c0d","textSha256":"a252a6d5b5b447aee3e12989e374e12a1ba394fb0ea85995062f394f5211313a"},{"localRef":"u7","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:1b78587762045c393aa696677de10213a9369530ad072a1f940e9f7e0476d21c","textSha256":"a6442081fd1c27dd3fbc8f57984142e999731d0d03662a53b15c5d5f9c083d8f"},{"localRef":"n40","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:1b78587762045c393aa696677de10213a9369530ad072a1f940e9f7e0476d21c","reviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n44","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:637f529a670807364f144d33aedc23b0b8e7e2f4830bf3a9044de13e2bc92c0d","reviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n45","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:01ed613346ef96646a7de1d8cc6c673dd1d5caaeca4bee5c8d2d9b47c19f7b8d","reviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n59","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:01ed613346ef96646a7de1d8cc6c673dd1d5caaeca4bee5c8d2d9b47c19f7b8d","reviewId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn0","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn0","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The outgoing related-question route reaches c11's explicit additional dynamics targets. It retains the conditional Kähler obstruction, fixed-modulus limit and dated observational context without implying containment.","refs":["c0","c11","u0","u18","u7","n40","n44","n59"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn1":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn1","source":"q025-candidate-question:2c78e415731e9932afb29e16","target":"q025-candidate-question:3f132bb92b987d107da81d00","type":"related_question","title":"Compare fixed couplings and baby-universe states","qualification":"Physical contribution remains open. The physical one-state hypothesis is unproved and restricted to d > 3; nontrivial state sectors remain alternatives. Recursive factorization has simple-model support, and interacting boundaries do not test the decoupled-boundary factorization premise.","rationale":"The shared review and proposed resolutions support the interpretive continuation nominated by l0 while preserving their different premises and evidential reach.","evidenceIds":["unit:185ac8d73d64d28130a2008434e05b4be603a2c03aeea7a61f298708e915bba1","unit:225bb5564b3448903eabe2bade8a2950f3377db1c685e2fafc024453837ae79d","unit:8ec9fba12d7a1436f20406007570500dd621a25f504f804a56300c089ca57760","unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","unit:c942b222e9151c78f137a29bf4560d99c9b0faf6e6b846f0c4d5fab6ad2b421a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1e7cdcae6a7c724f1c69-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2c78e415731e9932afb29e16"},{"localRef":"c7","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3f132bb92b987d107da81d00"},{"localRef":"u29","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","textSha256":"c780a3a6f1fa4141c5da87f8ae2c7318592b83de76b79cb1b3e901c3b913b2a8"},{"localRef":"u6","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:185ac8d73d64d28130a2008434e05b4be603a2c03aeea7a61f298708e915bba1","textSha256":"470264a00e36431f703f7904c4a91ba443549b880f32f8e9f105b4c300419f1e"},{"localRef":"u25","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:8ec9fba12d7a1436f20406007570500dd621a25f504f804a56300c089ca57760","textSha256":"5c8f8083a2eec6074058633bf1c1c39de6a088abc8ccf0fd716ebc88aa91d1c0"},{"localRef":"u39","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:c942b222e9151c78f137a29bf4560d99c9b0faf6e6b846f0c4d5fab6ad2b421a","textSha256":"ef9a39fa60160f1c96dd52d7817336e023deaed8609b8dc36bf757ab021d5a18"},{"localRef":"u10","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:225bb5564b3448903eabe2bade8a2950f3377db1c685e2fafc024453837ae79d","textSha256":"73c3c9c57d4582a597b73f825995acaa1f93ae821e1684fa3fc9190f527da04a"},{"localRef":"n4","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c942b222e9151c78f137a29bf4560d99c9b0faf6e6b846f0c4d5fab6ad2b421a","reviewId":"leaf-1e7cdcae6a7c724f1c69-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n48","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:225bb5564b3448903eabe2bade8a2950f3377db1c685e2fafc024453837ae79d","reviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n49","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:8ec9fba12d7a1436f20406007570500dd621a25f504f804a56300c089ca57760","reviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n51","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:185ac8d73d64d28130a2008434e05b4be603a2c03aeea7a61f298708e915bba1","reviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l0","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2c78e415731e9932afb29e16","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3f132bb92b987d107da81d00","candidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:20","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn1","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn1","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The interpretive continuation is supported by the shared descriptions. Its qualification preserves the conjectural higher-dimensional one-state proposal, simple-model recursion and interacting-boundary comparison.","refs":["c1","c7","u6","u25","u39","u10","n4","n48","n51","l0"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn2":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn2","source":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c","target":"q025-candidate-question:338eb8fe45755c7577288902","type":"related_question","title":"Explore spectra, selection rules and particle models","qualification":"Shared RG and phase constraints lead to further model-dependent applications. Ordinary anomaly matching, non-invertible obstructions and phenomenological constructions retain different conditions; the parity-wall energetic expectation is not promoted to a general symmetry theorem.","rationale":"The common dynamics review and higher-form framework support l1's outgoing direction toward c2's additional spectral, coupling and particle-physics questions.","evidenceIds":["unit:1499d3f87d9960e9e22d055c78ce96cfcd13406443950a53efa719588f155109","unit:27f42d44ec1f38f25b84edb210587300fe2bd6e5f170b12459bada7ee9355c2a","unit:b3243010621ba839c60d57fc9a6563615a68974ba45c407927be707fc3fada88","unit:bcb930350cfb30cb461ddebd3d55950894281611fce99b74467d22f1b7048f22"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c"},{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-c0f344101cf345acf854-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:338eb8fe45755c7577288902"},{"localRef":"u34","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:b3243010621ba839c60d57fc9a6563615a68974ba45c407927be707fc3fada88","textSha256":"d67581076339e8a21f784c62fe02d46421ee2c23d2c1581e3e804b1e31a811b9"},{"localRef":"u37","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:bcb930350cfb30cb461ddebd3d55950894281611fce99b74467d22f1b7048f22","textSha256":"8650d504c2c8fdac4be5bebf13e4461ab4a480fd545dd7f29242c4d98ece7617"},{"localRef":"u3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:1499d3f87d9960e9e22d055c78ce96cfcd13406443950a53efa719588f155109","textSha256":"836291404cc4fbf6c06abd81abd39329f0c2bdf7badaec39b4ef806f91965e87"},{"localRef":"u11","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:27f42d44ec1f38f25b84edb210587300fe2bd6e5f170b12459bada7ee9355c2a","textSha256":"7624a45fdf0dde8339598d1206158324695ab127b09d5dbd627efebd2085f6f5"},{"localRef":"n31","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:27f42d44ec1f38f25b84edb210587300fe2bd6e5f170b12459bada7ee9355c2a","reviewId":"leaf-c0f344101cf345acf854-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n38","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:bcb930350cfb30cb461ddebd3d55950894281611fce99b74467d22f1b7048f22","reviewId":"leaf-c0f344101cf345acf854-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n39","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:b3243010621ba839c60d57fc9a6563615a68974ba45c407927be707fc3fada88","reviewId":"leaf-c0f344101cf345acf854-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l1","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:338eb8fe45755c7577288902","candidateId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge:link:26","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn2","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn2","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The direction from c6 to c2's additional spectra, selection-rule and particle-model questions is readable and supported. The route does not turn parity-wall energetics or model-specific obstructions into universal consequences.","refs":["c6","c2","u34","u37","u11","n31","n39","l1"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn3":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn3","source":"q025-candidate-question:374623f65e03eab654c343ac","target":"q025-candidate-question:aed6eac98dd91f2b2da7e827","type":"related_question","title":"Explore SymTFT defects and geometric realizations","qualification":"Use the shared symmetry-encoding branch. Relative/absolute data, fluxes and branes have their own assumptions; auxiliary, physical holographic and tensor-network bulks retain distinct meanings. Non-topological constructions are not thereby reclassified as SymTFTs.","rationale":"Shared lecture methods and explicit duality-defect examples support l2's continuation without equating the complete encoding programs.","evidenceIds":["unit:479fd01bba5530d46bc8cf136a9b39a497a60d35fe8833f525a9e7eae7600cc6","unit:63c2129a8cf5d9679d3fedd47f040014eba4b02d2f99709d8f0e9b1bba7a2013","unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","unit:d76d82b38ddf95149c49469a8248a91c527858596d3d6dec3bba4ca97205f87c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c3","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:374623f65e03eab654c343ac"},{"localRef":"c10","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-c0f344101cf345acf854-challenge:p5","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:aed6eac98dd91f2b2da7e827"},{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitIndex":43,"unitId":"unit:479fd01bba5530d46bc8cf136a9b39a497a60d35fe8833f525a9e7eae7600cc6","textSha256":"c46ec9f0ba269f9ce18e6984b6ed476d458ccc71395b4ca7b90571dd3bb2449b"},{"localRef":"u38","kind":"description","unitIndex":61,"unitId":"unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","textSha256":"91596907933a9297d0c1f42cbcc68c2b3ac6e394197b76ed7201f9b7305d32ae"},{"localRef":"u19","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:63c2129a8cf5d9679d3fedd47f040014eba4b02d2f99709d8f0e9b1bba7a2013","textSha256":"a64da0d4a76873b3a6930091714601403b34a5513847e93acf77ffc15348100b"},{"localRef":"u42","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:d76d82b38ddf95149c49469a8248a91c527858596d3d6dec3bba4ca97205f87c","textSha256":"bc88d70d03617f09becf65a94f0adba980639e17c9bd4da0d131c8f74e9e4b0c"},{"localRef":"n12","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:63c2129a8cf5d9679d3fedd47f040014eba4b02d2f99709d8f0e9b1bba7a2013","reviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n34","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:d76d82b38ddf95149c49469a8248a91c527858596d3d6dec3bba4ca97205f87c","reviewId":"leaf-c0f344101cf345acf854-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n35","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:479fd01bba5530d46bc8cf136a9b39a497a60d35fe8833f525a9e7eae7600cc6","reviewId":"leaf-c0f344101cf345acf854-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n37","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","reviewId":"leaf-c0f344101cf345acf854-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"l2","kind":"inherited_navigation_candidate","sourceCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:374623f65e03eab654c343ac","targetCandidateId":"q025-candidate-question:aed6eac98dd91f2b2da7e827","candidateId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge:link:30","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn3","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn3","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The shared encoding methods support this related-question arc. The qualification preserves auxiliary, physical holographic and tensor-network meanings and does not reclassify non-topological theories.","refs":["c3","c10","u15","u19","u42","n12","n34","n35","l2"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn4":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn4","source":"q025-candidate-question:50f2c2fea436ef961efa8450","target":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","type":"related_question","title":"Trace dark-matter candidates to their cosmic abundance","qualification":"Production and viable parameter regions depend on the specified thermal or nonthermal history. A framework or interaction-suppression hypothesis need not supply an abundance calculation. Subjective review inclusion does not certify viability.","rationale":"The shared review and the explicit production witness support moving from selected dark-matter frameworks to c4's candidate-and-origin questions.","evidenceIds":["unit:1e96331a613901b21e0941d90c6652e41bcf7c74ba6030bed0a42d0a478e2968","unit:2d3d65b41648c0f939fba5152e588f2fb018d4e2274f758e39c6b9da23a72c57","unit:7fea12237e216dc158a8d55448647920910fbd77eac285ee5f5e520cf9c71de3","unit:958c3e2a5c675715f5662baa67a7a971aacdb27cc104c0f898395e0060fba3f3"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c8","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge:p7","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:50f2c2fea436ef961efa8450"},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"},{"localRef":"u8","kind":"description","unitIndex":63,"unitId":"unit:1e96331a613901b21e0941d90c6652e41bcf7c74ba6030bed0a42d0a478e2968","textSha256":"53f0d7cd3b0fec44108713501f8fcbe78f1c27e70e5f19df84bc54fdda2f3dda"},{"localRef":"u12","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:2d3d65b41648c0f939fba5152e588f2fb018d4e2274f758e39c6b9da23a72c57","textSha256":"f36bb2da974fc8f1a04a8cf640f9e2579dbd67a190292fc3e538eda98372f155"},{"localRef":"u22","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:7fea12237e216dc158a8d55448647920910fbd77eac285ee5f5e520cf9c71de3","textSha256":"071971f35360c23d70f29d9e268e37e5fc97af39187fb9e42f9d7958d26f7a34"},{"localRef":"u26","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:958c3e2a5c675715f5662baa67a7a971aacdb27cc104c0f898395e0060fba3f3","textSha256":"42f0ef44de93fed9e3af0cb98955d051c26fae9d4db019ec5ec94ce5665a558f"},{"localRef":"n24","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:2d3d65b41648c0f939fba5152e588f2fb018d4e2274f758e39c6b9da23a72c57","reviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n27","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:1e96331a613901b21e0941d90c6652e41bcf7c74ba6030bed0a42d0a478e2968","reviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n53","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:7fea12237e216dc158a8d55448647920910fbd77eac285ee5f5e520cf9c71de3","reviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n54","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:958c3e2a5c675715f5662baa67a7a971aacdb27cc104c0f898395e0060fba3f3","reviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n55","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:1e96331a613901b21e0941d90c6652e41bcf7c74ba6030bed0a42d0a478e2968","reviewId":"leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn4","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn4","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The shared review and explicit production descriptions support moving toward cosmic abundance. The route correctly denies an automatic abundance calculation or viability conclusion for an interaction-suppression hypothesis.","refs":["c8","c4","u8","u12","u22","u26","n53","n54","n55"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn5":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn5","source":"q025-candidate-question:959672acb11e6953138545cf","target":"q025-candidate-question:3c0cd88604668889a65cf7be","type":"narrower","title":"Explore axion detection channels","qualification":"Select the axion-channel branch of the broader measurement question. Non-PQ CP-odd source discrimination remains separate in c9. Historical birefringence reports and projected sensitivities are not detections, and no universal mass–coupling relation is imposed.","rationale":"c5 provides concrete observational channels within c9's broader property-and-source measurement remit.","evidenceIds":["unit:594822f52e4c2b61ea8c1fafa1bb93dbbea0a0482d6c25222ad5e04c239d0124","unit:9eea79081da6b2b335c83a27e308ec06b1948c711f98859cea9c91f898d99f56","unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","unit:acbcbb2a06ddda0a17aae4781b7ce43da9115305484a8da92c95f65d8698352d","unit:ebd0a34924be07207d236aae6a251efa2d7438b4ddfc5cb5a00abbceeaab08e4"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:959672acb11e6953138545cf"},{"localRef":"c5","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3c0cd88604668889a65cf7be"},{"localRef":"u28","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:9eea79081da6b2b335c83a27e308ec06b1948c711f98859cea9c91f898d99f56","textSha256":"f045c09dfe48b4337be72da6a8a20d3892bf208238a91eaf34576d61579e7a80"},{"localRef":"u30","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","textSha256":"a43716256e5420305ab4cb364f4c990e81bcab046ecc6f7a0d6c16f116602642"},{"localRef":"u31","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:acbcbb2a06ddda0a17aae4781b7ce43da9115305484a8da92c95f65d8698352d","textSha256":"2a99b538f0f9a20824bfb1e5ea876351fb5a24fe8c65ad2e86b262195cd63e9e"},{"localRef":"u46","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:ebd0a34924be07207d236aae6a251efa2d7438b4ddfc5cb5a00abbceeaab08e4","textSha256":"f60dd3da17a815757449a69c93c33c51441bfd53374e1dd0032c09a692bd74e9"},{"localRef":"n19","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:594822f52e4c2b61ea8c1fafa1bb93dbbea0a0482d6c25222ad5e04c239d0124","reviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n21","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:9eea79081da6b2b335c83a27e308ec06b1948c711f98859cea9c91f898d99f56","reviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"n22","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:ebd0a34924be07207d236aae6a251efa2d7438b4ddfc5cb5a00abbceeaab08e4","reviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn5","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn5","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broader-to-narrower direction follows the admitted measurement scopes. Non-PQ source discrimination remains in c9, and the route retains historical and mass–coupling qualifications.","refs":["c9","c5","u28","u46","n19","n22"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn6":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn6","source":"q025-candidate-question:2787cd18a2486e736fd5921b","target":"q025-candidate-question:2a61b2bee7a3303b9060245f","type":"narrower","title":"Build a Starobinsky potential and stabilize its spectators","qualification":"Restrict to the stated no-scale supergravity models. Potential realization and spectator stabilization require separate checks; the description supplies the targets, not their detailed derivation.","rationale":"u40 gives a concrete construction-and-stability branch of c0.","evidenceIds":["unit:d5318fffd70c1d2373fa53c8a68191731bcb343b1c064a23493531dfbb47a8d7"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c0","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge:p1","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2787cd18a2486e736fd5921b"},{"localRef":"u40","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:d5318fffd70c1d2373fa53c8a68191731bcb343b1c064a23493531dfbb47a8d7","textSha256":"4301ebb33cbd40d1011b90914d366811e7cf4c0656d817c0e0204032953dfb51"},{"localRef":"n57","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:d5318fffd70c1d2373fa53c8a68191731bcb343b1c064a23493531dfbb47a8d7","reviewId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn6","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn6","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"u40 directly supplies the no-scale construction and spectator-stability branch. The qualification makes clear that these are separate tasks without a supplied derivation.","refs":["c0","u40","n57"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn7":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn7","source":"q025-candidate-question:f85a966454b318a2706bf0cb","target":"q025-candidate-question:2a61b2bee7a3303b9060245f","type":"narrower","title":"Examine no-scale stability and potential deformations","qualification":"Study the source-specific spectator sector and changes in predictions. No completed stabilization calculation or present observational acceptance is established by the supplied description.","rationale":"The same explicit construction question fits c11's potential-control, partner-stability and prediction targets.","evidenceIds":["unit:d5318fffd70c1d2373fa53c8a68191731bcb343b1c064a23493531dfbb47a8d7"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c11","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge:p3","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f85a966454b318a2706bf0cb"},{"localRef":"u40","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:d5318fffd70c1d2373fa53c8a68191731bcb343b1c064a23493531dfbb47a8d7","textSha256":"4301ebb33cbd40d1011b90914d366811e7cf4c0656d817c0e0204032953dfb51"},{"localRef":"n57","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:d5318fffd70c1d2373fa53c8a68191731bcb343b1c064a23493531dfbb47a8d7","reviewId":"leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn7","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn7","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The restricted construction fits c11's potential, stability and prediction targets. Its qualification avoids asserting completed stabilization or present observational acceptance.","refs":["c11","u40","n57"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn8":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn8","source":"q025-candidate-question:338eb8fe45755c7577288902","target":"q025-candidate-question:fd5b6861f11e0a433730e52a","type":"narrower","title":"Test whether a trivial gapped endpoint is allowed","qualification":"The theory must admit the stated half-space-gauging construction, and the obstruction is conditional. No claim excludes every gapped phase or follows from arbitrary non-invertible symmetry alone.","rationale":"u36 supplies a specific infrared constraint within the broader dynamics overview.","evidenceIds":["unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c2","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-c0f344101cf345acf854-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:338eb8fe45755c7577288902"},{"localRef":"u36","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839","textSha256":"a485540ff078f0966491859055000b20c5781c5f15f44c14ff1c51eb6dfc8a64"},{"localRef":"n30","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839","reviewId":"leaf-c0f344101cf345acf854-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn8","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn8","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broad-to-narrow direction and conditional trivial-gap wording are supported by u36; the route does not assert generic gaplessness.","refs":["c2","u36","n30"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn9":{"id":"navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:pn9","source":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c","target":"q025-candidate-question:fd5b6861f11e0a433730e52a","type":"narrower","title":"Check a duality-defect obstruction to a trivial gap","qualification":"Keep the defect construction separate from the conditions for its infrared obstruction. The supplied description does not provide the detailed criterion or a complete phase classification.","rationale":"The explicit phase-obstruction facet offers a concrete next question from c6 without identifying it with every anomaly constraint.","evidenceIds":["unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c"},{"localRef":"u36","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839","textSha256":"a485540ff078f0966491859055000b20c5781c5f15f44c14ff1c51eb6dfc8a64"},{"localRef":"n30","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839","reviewId":"leaf-c0f344101cf345acf854-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn9","provenance":{"nativeRouteId":"pn9","sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-independent-challenge"],"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","independentAssessment":{"ref":"pn9","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The description supports this particular phase-constraint route from c6. The missing obstruction criterion and distinction between construction and consequence are explicit.","refs":["c6","u36","n30"]},"freshPrimaryReading":false,"evidenceIdBasis":"direct_supplied_description_refs","inheritedEvidenceIsNotFreshReading":false,"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:route:pn9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"}}}