How are θ dependence, vacuum structure and axion relaxation represented, and what do specified gravitational arguments require?
Retain ordinary QCD calculability alongside distinct proposals linking gravity, superselection and exact axion mechanisms.
Chiral EFT; Instanton EFT and decoupling; Topological and gauge-form descriptions; Conditional gravitational arguments
9 extracted descriptions checked; 3 source excerpts checked.
The gravity excerpts present proposed arguments. Descriptions of topology, endpoint and EFT questions do not establish their complete derivations.
Separately admitted review observations are retained for each source-and-role relationship. These reviewed roles are separate from source membership. A shared source does not establish question equivalence; a method contribution does not certify applicability.
- addresses — description_checked
Axion RG flows and the holographic dynamics of instanton densities
Original proposal qualification: Endpoint validity, running-θ constraints and self-tuning applications are distinct targets. String constructions are comparison scope. Independent challenge qualification: Endpoint validity, running-θ constraints and self-tuning applications require separate reconciliation. String constructions are comparison scope.
Can the axion endpoint prescription be derived beyond specific string constructions, and does it survive explicit nonperturbative shift breaking? Can running theta be constrained in QCD-like theories or supply useful vacuum branches in self-tuning models?
Exact source: unit:ac37a74b422c65cc41e8ddd0032c4ad51eb638d6dec3095110d7c615268fa418. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:d3678eff7cd22b08f27d3e83.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1905.03663","sourceSha256":"8bd8af395cdc4f17018fe23bbb1da24947de1e07959cec98de776a9890c0bf67","pages":[9,10],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:1ea98b1435e40e78d009fc7636a48208","source-graph:ev:d10a2ab7f25e89410ea1644534b2976b"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d16",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 16,
"unitId": "unit:ac37a74b422c65cc41e8ddd0032c4ad51eb638d6dec3095110d7c615268fa418",
"textSha256": "bb5b3a92b689cb120ee24a79247a6fa9054b2cecd9b8f6117a83df403fb98e67"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "de8436039b543b23fa27163a783f372ebdd4c3221e9491efc58205e3e844ea3b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:d3678eff7cd22b08f27d3e83",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - method — description_checked
Gauge and gravitational instantons: From 3-forms and fermions to Weak Gravity and flat axion potentials
Original proposal qualification: General instanton EFT: heavy matter decouples with v/m corrections; light Dirac matter changes running and retained interactions. Independent challenge qualification: General instanton EFT: heavy matter has v/m corrections; light Dirac matter changes running and retained interactions.
When can fundamental Dirac matter be omitted from an instanton EFT below the Higgs scale v? Heavy fermions decouple with corrections in v/m; light fermions alter both instanton running and the effective interactions that must remain in the theory.
Exact source: unit:65fbef6e6d197bce501609c74219b2787d2c217cacc64b73b09a785f11a95152. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:0f800fbb0433788499269f33.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1906.07728","sourceSha256":"24358a82bddcae1782151d368c9607066d0feff0c2908dc39a62d1bd28948861","pages":[36],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:40befd753c96c02be099e7b82ddd5558","source-graph:ev:45ac14fd5832f7849c20bb9b2dacb187"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d17",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 17,
"unitId": "unit:65fbef6e6d197bce501609c74219b2787d2c217cacc64b73b09a785f11a95152",
"textSha256": "52d5b07b7cf60bcfca3a9354ab4eb4e35770c8e027d7430dd491f98cc38761ec"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "de8436039b543b23fa27163a783f372ebdd4c3221e9491efc58205e3e844ea3b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:0f800fbb0433788499269f33",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - specializes — source_excerpt_checked
Gravity, Superselection Rules and Axions
Original proposal qualification: A proposed emergence argument using reference frames and coherent geometry, not a proved universal rule for free parameters. Independent challenge qualification: Reference frames and coherent geometry enter a proposed emergence argument; the excerpt does not prove a universal rule for parameters.
Can coupling to quantum gravity turn a superselection parameter into a local field's vacuum expectation value? The proposed example is the QCD θ parameter and its promotion to an axion.
Exact source: unit:336b8beff535c077d7ab5e80a1adaa7cad6afd01054c276acc9fbd33a670ce3d. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:066836766fbef936d6961189.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1907.03619","sourceSha256":"285f86a29d206f7c70fc655d3ed5d6799bdef7e0e798a7c54126091ba2d1f151","pages":[1],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:6b6aed31c7e34fdbe2586cdf39c494cd","source-graph:ev:d2544e0c7d2244626a4f2c75e7cdbe55"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d18",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 18,
"unitId": "unit:336b8beff535c077d7ab5e80a1adaa7cad6afd01054c276acc9fbd33a670ce3d",
"textSha256": "50f53504cc5ad9b4264d880089e6cf2afd9fcbba7ba70e2434c91de8e5ef61ef"
},
{
"localRef": "e10",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:6b6aed31c7e34fdbe2586cdf39c494cd",
"paperId": "1907.03619",
"sourceSha256": "285f86a29d206f7c70fc655d3ed5d6799bdef7e0e798a7c54126091ba2d1f151",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/5417e7f6e2b3e5e0cd6a/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "e5af2a288e40e6e6baa090e7f3ac2961edef579f5b131f31a330dfc1f7541704",
"pdfPage": 1,
"start": 93,
"end": 3491,
"textSha256": "2d169f3f3f0b1dd202d6036022764b727a648ed0a7e9e8b7e31121c7262e9664",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e21",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:d2544e0c7d2244626a4f2c75e7cdbe55",
"paperId": "1907.03619",
"sourceSha256": "285f86a29d206f7c70fc655d3ed5d6799bdef7e0e798a7c54126091ba2d1f151",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/5417e7f6e2b3e5e0cd6a/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "e5af2a288e40e6e6baa090e7f3ac2961edef579f5b131f31a330dfc1f7541704",
"pdfPage": 1,
"start": 0,
"end": 3000,
"textSha256": "a8cdf176e7b64f2b82af56c06cb1d8036e5e3981ac1ef79de30da619b4d34558",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "de8436039b543b23fa27163a783f372ebdd4c3221e9491efc58205e3e844ea3b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:066836766fbef936d6961189",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - boundary — source_excerpt_checked
QCD, Flavor, and the de Sitter Swampland
Original proposal qualification: Conditional false-branch test, not an axion-construction question. Coupled-case estimates continue beyond the window; cubic and quartic routes are alternatives. Independent challenge qualification: Conditional false-branch test. Sequestered and coupled cases differ; cubic and quartic estimates are alternatives. The coupled analysis extends beyond the e,
Can an evolving scalar satisfy the conjecture on a would-be QCD false branch while preserving an acceptable present ground-branch universe? Additive sequestering and direct QCD coupling are treated separately.
Exact source: unit:f30a09f54c06fdb8108af52bfa0152b3e5f4867ffe83b89f3e39ff9352ee836b. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:fe7924f6ae5c79facd5eb012.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2006.01144","sourceSha256":"f9b7ee368a087d29ccece175deef9f2ec0001f27101817ce8b089b96462e811b","pages":[16,17],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:13cef47630690e4dc4324d21b74548cb","source-graph:ev:8168d0befb6a73a6de731cb1fb6334f7","source-graph:ev:cfec92ed789610149a4ea2f8bc3a73ca"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d22",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 22,
"unitId": "unit:f30a09f54c06fdb8108af52bfa0152b3e5f4867ffe83b89f3e39ff9352ee836b",
"textSha256": "097fea3da03f9af5121326df1ba4ff2c2ee30947cf6ef99c92a75c2f000ba1da"
},
{
"localRef": "e2",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:13cef47630690e4dc4324d21b74548cb",
"paperId": "2006.01144",
"sourceSha256": "f9b7ee368a087d29ccece175deef9f2ec0001f27101817ce8b089b96462e811b",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/2c904838c65d30694152/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "d035a2db3c104a1404cfb94ffa475d65fe9423f3224808d2dacfde2623f8ffed",
"pdfPage": 16,
"start": 0,
"end": 2704,
"textSha256": "1f354523a91d023f73e9422d33d90bd98b3da2e6c25a63c01d3f9aec88dcd06d",
"quoteExactInPage": false,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e12",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:8168d0befb6a73a6de731cb1fb6334f7",
"paperId": "2006.01144",
"sourceSha256": "f9b7ee368a087d29ccece175deef9f2ec0001f27101817ce8b089b96462e811b",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/2c904838c65d30694152/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "d035a2db3c104a1404cfb94ffa475d65fe9423f3224808d2dacfde2623f8ffed",
"pdfPage": 17,
"start": 0,
"end": 2757,
"textSha256": "e092f50363b2c4b322dc708dc0fd5d371bef212e1bf0d995753ab903427a62c6",
"quoteExactInPage": false,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e18",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:aec7fe244276e5763f70ce73e577669e",
"paperId": "2006.01144",
"sourceSha256": "f9b7ee368a087d29ccece175deef9f2ec0001f27101817ce8b089b96462e811b",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/2c904838c65d30694152/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "d035a2db3c104a1404cfb94ffa475d65fe9423f3224808d2dacfde2623f8ffed",
"pdfPage": 18,
"start": 2274,
"end": 4952,
"textSha256": "e27f6dcb563745569c1d229828cedf4f49a88974888187aefd4656c8e6eb3890",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "de8436039b543b23fa27163a783f372ebdd4c3221e9491efc58205e3e844ea3b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:fe7924f6ae5c79facd5eb012",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - addresses — description_checked
QCD, Flavor, and the de Sitter Swampland
Original proposal qualification: Leading-order light-flavor calculability under confinement and the stated chiral-breaking pattern; no primary reading borrowed from the other facet. Independent challenge qualification: Leading-order light-flavor calculability requires the stated confinement and symmetry-breaking pattern. No primary reading is borrowed from the other facet.
What QCD vacuum structure is calculable with light composite fields? Leading-order chiral dynamics describes N light flavors while masses and θ vary, subject to confinement and the stated spontaneous chiral-symmetry-breaking pattern.
Exact source: unit:ea21e552d29a9967e2ce15db21824d7ca60772672971bbc9b9de185b7cccc682. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:5162a061b00f44e7e87d2344.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2006.01144","sourceSha256":"f9b7ee368a087d29ccece175deef9f2ec0001f27101817ce8b089b96462e811b","pages":[8,9],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:60b1096f04476d87eeeaeac50c60ad47","source-graph:ev:f5633aa09091e2720459fd4d20b283f6","source-graph:ev:f7c0d844881947399471fafd6f0cb4c3"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d23",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 23,
"unitId": "unit:ea21e552d29a9967e2ce15db21824d7ca60772672971bbc9b9de185b7cccc682",
"textSha256": "68a5bb62bf843f27e858902698f55dffb856b73a59d9b716dd7c16da93925b4e"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "de8436039b543b23fa27163a783f372ebdd4c3221e9491efc58205e3e844ea3b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:5162a061b00f44e7e87d2344",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - addresses — description_checked
Strong <math display="inline"><mi>C</mi><mi>P</mi></math> problem and its gauge axion solution as evidence for fundamental strings
Original proposal qualification: Physical θ, exact gauge-axion quality and a fundamental-string implication are distinct targets; no atomic fine identity assigned. Independent challenge qualification: Physical θ, exact gauge-axion quality and a claimed fundamental-string implication are distinct targets; atomic identity remains unresolved.
How does QCD topological susceptibility establish the physicality of θ, how can a gauge two-form eliminate θ-vacua with exact axion quality, and does its string–wall structure imply fundamental strings?
Exact source: unit:cb4ac5608c9cb467097ef87150febf2cc551ccc903f3fde3165905f0656d2aa7. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:51c35d003a3f8077c9d23e1c.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2512.08834","sourceSha256":"5733df2cbf673efdbb2a0d62fba05f6a2347261721a2d5c116899508c959ea35","pages":[1],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:0dc1d820bae817f8cfd8b20431304373","source-graph:ev:496824f8a1b663df4a504410b0b016a6","source-graph:ev:4ff974a15ef7a8d94eaf54a6fcd7802b"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d47",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 47,
"unitId": "unit:cb4ac5608c9cb467097ef87150febf2cc551ccc903f3fde3165905f0656d2aa7",
"textSha256": "ae3ec760533d6d6b146c4ddfc960c389ab1ea646af6eb0f239754f5b95041133"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "de8436039b543b23fa27163a783f372ebdd4c3221e9491efc58205e3e844ea3b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:51c35d003a3f8077c9d23e1c",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - addresses — description_checked
Strong CP and the QCD axion lecture notes via effective field theory
Original proposal qualification: Compound EFT survey with axion, orientifold and phase-alignment comparisons; the description does not establish their equivalence or rejection. Independent challenge qualification: Compound EFT scope with axion, orientifold and phase-alignment comparisons; their equivalence or rejection is not established.
How does chiral EFT encode QCD topology, vacuum alignment and strong CP observables, and how do axions, orientifold theories and proposed phase-alignment prescriptions modify this description?
Exact source: unit:845542f00280705c18af63dc207c59ce54a84edb0a31e06689a155d8c3a43796. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:1bdbca7daa22104361632899.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2601.19735","sourceSha256":"d1b510fff9b55abdeff4344a42a91fcc5c8f3195660d48791a5f940b6637a011","pages":[1],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:0bd8606a763c2e9588fbdda31cdcf177","source-graph:ev:d8db80c13e323b4f2f8e20a515492f87"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d48",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 48,
"unitId": "unit:845542f00280705c18af63dc207c59ce54a84edb0a31e06689a155d8c3a43796",
"textSha256": "ecf9b89c6fe6ce9915da0e404ff4e6657fd0185944985694a1c4bdd749cbc541"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "de8436039b543b23fa27163a783f372ebdd4c3221e9491efc58205e3e844ea3b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:1bdbca7daa22104361632899",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - specializes — description_checked
Irrational axions as a solution of the strong CP problem in an eternal universe
Original proposal qualification: Heavy irrational coupling and absence of a massless particle are explicit; finite cooling time is part of the vacuum-selection test. Independent challenge qualification: Heavy irrational coupling, absence of a massless particle and finite cooling time are defining conditions.
Can an irrationally coupled heavy axion screen the QCD θ angle without a massless particle, and can the resulting vacuum selection operate in a universe that has been cool for only a finite time?
Exact source: unit:0f96a5852aff55abbd95eb199e168884ca2d8073f78fb8708a2e3ded100d86ab. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:82cd94bbc81df87b3a417802.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"hep-th/9109040","sourceSha256":"6ae2f55295fcbb50a1088579c74905dc6efe2ac7704a72a4aad14aeb35872ab3","pages":[1,2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:4895f3986edfb6deada078e8ce8bc9fd","source-graph:ev:a41f92995761d07f7d5c1872bf45fc86"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d59",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 59,
"unitId": "unit:0f96a5852aff55abbd95eb199e168884ca2d8073f78fb8708a2e3ded100d86ab",
"textSha256": "d24e287f22928104da577516be9d8ce3c691c6d2a1cae617919b077fa36845ee"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "de8436039b543b23fa27163a783f372ebdd4c3221e9491efc58205e3e844ea3b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:82cd94bbc81df87b3a417802",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - specializes — source_excerpt_checked
Strong-$CP$ with and without gravity
Original proposal qualification: Joint consistency-and-protection question. S-matrix premises and claimed all-orders gauge protection are not independently proved by this window. Independent challenge qualification: Joint consistency and protection targets. S-matrix reasoning and all-orders gauge protection are source claims, not established by these introductory wind,
Does coupling QCD to gravity turn strong CP from a naturalness puzzle into a consistency condition requiring an exact axion mechanism, and can a gauge formulation protect that mechanism without a global Peccei–Quinn symmetry?
Exact source: unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:dd8881a71fadd93791657e06.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2209.14219","sourceSha256":"a13831f3df2f5c0729e748c4b6ffc3121a360bf0e34d04658a0fe1ca4607d3a8","pages":[1],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:11014a27e05f2fe9ecf45074c34f9bbc","source-graph:ev:34362d7778fa135d0c9e07d388d2e9dc"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d63",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 63,
"unitId": "unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b",
"textSha256": "634ba2516486d170a4b9c0e220c4042b2ed033cfc8db687b33acf8cb8b290475"
},
{
"localRef": "e1",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:11014a27e05f2fe9ecf45074c34f9bbc",
"paperId": "2209.14219",
"sourceSha256": "a13831f3df2f5c0729e748c4b6ffc3121a360bf0e34d04658a0fe1ca4607d3a8",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/ca2c5708f32ba00d2977/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "fbf50a01af6aa90632004bc747b5d2df3e20e45ced5e7fc3809251084f6ab1ca",
"pdfPage": 1,
"start": 2496,
"end": 5338,
"textSha256": "83cb06712a3c3179734d2c9010821dff425500a3c2e8721fe05498256498fb93",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e4",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:34362d7778fa135d0c9e07d388d2e9dc",
"paperId": "2209.14219",
"sourceSha256": "a13831f3df2f5c0729e748c4b6ffc3121a360bf0e34d04658a0fe1ca4607d3a8",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/ca2c5708f32ba00d2977/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "fbf50a01af6aa90632004bc747b5d2df3e20e45ced5e7fc3809251084f6ab1ca",
"pdfPage": 1,
"start": 3694,
"end": 5338,
"textSha256": "32531b2bf0946b47778fff5dfd653e017ced0d126f03ac6266dbbff6e57d03e3",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "de8436039b543b23fa27163a783f372ebdd4c3221e9491efc58205e3e844ea3b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:dd8881a71fadd93791657e06",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
}
- Gauge formulations and gravity consistency tests — comparison (outgoing recorded relation)
QCD vacuum descriptions overlap with gauge-form arguments without equating ordinary vacuum EFT, species arguments and S-matrix premises.
QCD vacuum descriptions and proposed gauge-form protection share some questions without making species or S-matrix arguments equivalent to ordinary vacuum EFT.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:e596826654715739e8cc11e4; 16 source references; SHA-256 8bb255f80dc3afa513246f32f658cb268a3dfd04c3d63614dfee416449ea010f)
- Physical CP violation and θ dependence — method for (incoming recorded relation)
Both statements assign the methodological role to physical-phase and θ diagnostics. These diagnostics help interpret the vacuum descriptions, requiring reversal of the original order.
Retain each framework's symmetry definitions, finite-UV-θ setting and specified infrared boundary conditions. Apparent phases, vacuum phases and physical CP observables are distinct; a bulk axion boundary value is not automatically an observable. Confinement and chiral-symmetry-breaking assumptions remain local to their EFTs. The route does not turn generic flavor diagnostics into a strong-CP solution or gravitational proposals into a theorem requiring an axion.
Complete source and review record (navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l7; 15 source references; SHA-256 e4ce5ae654c8d530c765fd59eceacbba08369c08b8b6655b7dcb4b8a96d87ab8)
- Axions and strong CP: construction, consistency and tests — broader (incoming recorded relation)
QCD theta dependence and vacuum descriptions retain a substantive route, including ordinary QCD calculations.
QCD theta dependence and vacuum descriptions remain a substantive direction, including ordinary QCD work.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:b80cca7487681d58846a53a9; 13 source references; SHA-256 a8ecc17573a708fe077725a47a1173538b00e1fee85c75d589e7fd45ffd27a36)
- Mass generation, symmetry protection and particle stability — broader (incoming recorded relation)
QCD vacuum structure and conditional gravitational arguments retain their existing scope.
QCD vacuum structure and conditional gravitational arguments retain their existing question.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:a65690ce5b01365d856c556e; 11 source references; SHA-256 69ae65574ce5ce388ed57548e325db318e9b8bf138217764d9182217f1499f47)
- Axion origins, strong CP, cosmology and observable consequences — shared source access (incoming recorded relation)
The same source question has a direct reviewed home in this scope and an admitted positive contribution to this scientific scope. The complete qualifications remain in the support certificate.
Complete source and review record (organizational-access:b5067435eebf872dc5929139; 1 source references; SHA-256 ae61ab4f95fb699f50f4381009fd27674d775a28cc1a18d8c35f1261ebfb1f59)
1 shared source questions across the whole scope, independent of source filters. Shared-source organizational access; witnesses are counted across the whole scope. This is not containment, equivalence, physical implication or established method applicability. Incoming browsing does not reverse a scientific claim.
Witnesses, qualifications and review decisions · Access policy
- Gauge formulations and gravity consistency tests — shared source access (incoming recorded relation)
The same source question has a direct reviewed home in this scope and an admitted positive contribution to this scientific scope. The complete qualifications remain in the support certificate.
Complete source and review record (organizational-access:39a32a2049d9b971ec4e722b; 1 source references; SHA-256 150c41adc7f5c0f613a22ce6c4de570d0a8540d2338919544457aca4c1cb958b)
1 shared source questions across the whole scope, independent of source filters. Shared-source organizational access; witnesses are counted across the whole scope. This is not containment, equivalence, physical implication or established method applicability. Incoming browsing does not reverse a scientific claim.
Witnesses, qualifications and review decisions · Access policy
- Can an irrationally coupled heavy axion screen the QCD θ angle without a massless particle, and can the resulting vacuum selection operate in a universe that has been cool for only a finite time? — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:9288e9dd4fc00b7f53e6b586; 1 source references; SHA-256 505df97d6f1abb11f8f92d78a272f38ab380338d677d5a471abe8cd85feeee80)
- Can coupling to quantum gravity turn a superselection parameter into a local field's vacuum expectation value? The proposed example is the QCD θ parameter and its promotion to an axion. — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:b67ba01f32376b4a314de2b8; 1 source references; SHA-256 2709d731b8e9db29cd6d9be7c1061db2b627368ed3816f67604396451eb40e3e)
- Can the axion endpoint prescription be derived beyond specific string constructions, and does it survive explicit nonperturbative shift breaking? Can running theta be constrained in QCD-like theories or supply useful vacuum branches in self-tuning models? — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:3cd2ff62b702ba94128fc1f8; 1 source references; SHA-256 9e33a5748f458883a9c0c84cd867f027c8152cab7b307767f8b9de9f82e442d8)
- How does chiral EFT encode QCD topology, vacuum alignment and strong CP observables, and how do axions, orientifold theories and proposed phase-alignment prescriptions modify this description? — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:cc4614530324d7d37df2df35; 1 source references; SHA-256 449d8210c2a78e2bac7f7df59f28893d54ee9dabad31e3dcf48a409f34fe86b6)
- What QCD vacuum structure is calculable with light composite fields? Leading-order chiral dynamics describes N light flavors while masses and θ vary, subject to confinement and the stated spontaneous chiral-symmetry-breaking pattern. — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:36eb209cbdc37106418be083; 1 source references; SHA-256 9dfceee5fe764216849cf0d2d9cc27094acd45f822ac2ebe62c8989c5289c8df)
- When can fundamental Dirac matter be omitted from an instanton EFT below the Higgs scale v? Heavy fermions decouple with corrections in v/m; light fermions alter both instanton running and the effective interactions that must remain in the theory. — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:1740d717f741cabc3691b8e6; 1 source references; SHA-256 15f0674896acd8307c91c75dba9af95a6da0405ff7626e6fde7a7df5697c9c31)
- Strong-$CP$ with and without gravity
Does coupling QCD to gravity turn strong CP from a naturalness puzzle into a consistency condition requiring an exact axion mechanism, and can a gauge formulation protect that mechanism without a global Peccei–Quinn symmetry?
Source ID: unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2209.14219","sourceSha256":"a13831f3df2f5c0729e748c4b6ffc3121a360bf0e34d04658a0fe1ca4607d3a8","pages":[1],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:11014a27e05f2fe9ecf45074c34f9bbc","source-graph:ev:34362d7778fa135d0c9e07d388d2e9dc"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- Irrational axions as a solution of the strong CP problem in an eternal universe
Can an irrationally coupled heavy axion screen the QCD θ angle without a massless particle, and can the resulting vacuum selection operate in a universe that has been cool for only a finite time?
Source ID: unit:0f96a5852aff55abbd95eb199e168884ca2d8073f78fb8708a2e3ded100d86ab
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"hep-th/9109040","sourceSha256":"6ae2f55295fcbb50a1088579c74905dc6efe2ac7704a72a4aad14aeb35872ab3","pages":[1,2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:4895f3986edfb6deada078e8ce8bc9fd","source-graph:ev:a41f92995761d07f7d5c1872bf45fc86"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- Gravity, Superselection Rules and Axions
Can coupling to quantum gravity turn a superselection parameter into a local field's vacuum expectation value? The proposed example is the QCD θ parameter and its promotion to an axion.
Source ID: unit:336b8beff535c077d7ab5e80a1adaa7cad6afd01054c276acc9fbd33a670ce3d
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1907.03619","sourceSha256":"285f86a29d206f7c70fc655d3ed5d6799bdef7e0e798a7c54126091ba2d1f151","pages":[1],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:6b6aed31c7e34fdbe2586cdf39c494cd","source-graph:ev:d2544e0c7d2244626a4f2c75e7cdbe55"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- Gauge and gravitational instantons: From 3-forms and fermions to Weak Gravity and flat axion potentials
When can fundamental Dirac matter be omitted from an instanton EFT below the Higgs scale v? Heavy fermions decouple with corrections in v/m; light fermions alter both instanton running and the effective interactions that must remain in the theory.
Source ID: unit:65fbef6e6d197bce501609c74219b2787d2c217cacc64b73b09a785f11a95152
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1906.07728","sourceSha256":"24358a82bddcae1782151d368c9607066d0feff0c2908dc39a62d1bd28948861","pages":[36],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:40befd753c96c02be099e7b82ddd5558","source-graph:ev:45ac14fd5832f7849c20bb9b2dacb187"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- Strong CP and the QCD axion lecture notes via effective field theory
How does chiral EFT encode QCD topology, vacuum alignment and strong CP observables, and how do axions, orientifold theories and proposed phase-alignment prescriptions modify this description?
Source ID: unit:845542f00280705c18af63dc207c59ce54a84edb0a31e06689a155d8c3a43796
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2601.19735","sourceSha256":"d1b510fff9b55abdeff4344a42a91fcc5c8f3195660d48791a5f940b6637a011","pages":[1],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:0bd8606a763c2e9588fbdda31cdcf177","source-graph:ev:d8db80c13e323b4f2f8e20a515492f87"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- Axion RG flows and the holographic dynamics of instanton densities
Can the axion endpoint prescription be derived beyond specific string constructions, and does it survive explicit nonperturbative shift breaking? Can running theta be constrained in QCD-like theories or supply useful vacuum branches in self-tuning models?
Source ID: unit:ac37a74b422c65cc41e8ddd0032c4ad51eb638d6dec3095110d7c615268fa418
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1905.03663","sourceSha256":"8bd8af395cdc4f17018fe23bbb1da24947de1e07959cec98de776a9890c0bf67","pages":[9,10],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:1ea98b1435e40e78d009fc7636a48208","source-graph:ev:d10a2ab7f25e89410ea1644534b2976b"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- Strong <math display="inline"><mi>C</mi><mi>P</mi></math> problem and its gauge axion solution as evidence for fundamental strings
How does QCD topological susceptibility establish the physicality of θ, how can a gauge two-form eliminate θ-vacua with exact axion quality, and does its string–wall structure imply fundamental strings?
Source ID: unit:cb4ac5608c9cb467097ef87150febf2cc551ccc903f3fde3165905f0656d2aa7
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2512.08834","sourceSha256":"5733df2cbf673efdbb2a0d62fba05f6a2347261721a2d5c116899508c959ea35","pages":[1],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:0dc1d820bae817f8cfd8b20431304373","source-graph:ev:496824f8a1b663df4a504410b0b016a6","source-graph:ev:4ff974a15ef7a8d94eaf54a6fcd7802b"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- QCD, Flavor, and the de Sitter Swampland
What QCD vacuum structure is calculable with light composite fields? Leading-order chiral dynamics describes N light flavors while masses and θ vary, subject to confinement and the stated spontaneous chiral-symmetry-breaking pattern.
Source ID: unit:ea21e552d29a9967e2ce15db21824d7ca60772672971bbc9b9de185b7cccc682
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2006.01144","sourceSha256":"f9b7ee368a087d29ccece175deef9f2ec0001f27101817ce8b089b96462e811b","pages":[8,9],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:60b1096f04476d87eeeaeac50c60ad47","source-graph:ev:f5633aa09091e2720459fd4d20b283f6","source-graph:ev:f7c0d844881947399471fafd6f0cb4c3"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- QCD, Flavor, and the de Sitter Swampland
Can an evolving scalar satisfy the conjecture on a would-be QCD false branch while preserving an acceptable present ground-branch universe? Additive sequestering and direct QCD coupling are treated separately.
Source ID: unit:f30a09f54c06fdb8108af52bfa0152b3e5f4867ffe83b89f3e39ff9352ee836b
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2006.01144","sourceSha256":"f9b7ee368a087d29ccece175deef9f2ec0001f27101817ce8b089b96462e811b","pages":[16,17],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:13cef47630690e4dc4324d21b74548cb","source-graph:ev:8168d0befb6a73a6de731cb1fb6334f7","source-graph:ev:cfec92ed789610149a4ea2f8bc3a73ca"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Scientific status: source_reviewed_scope_with_explicit_limits. Placement: reviewed_scope_and_placements.
Listed sources support this record; they do not claim exhaustive literature coverage. Versioned data manifest