{"kind":"eigenquestions-relation-details","schemaVersion":"1.0.0","relations":{"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-08:l30":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-08:l30","source":"q025-candidate-question:d2d1b5aa3349f0f9d12d3966","target":"q025-candidate-question:e4152f3d61427952901dca29","type":"comparison","title":"Compare black-hole UV constraints with semiwormhole action bounds","rationale":"The original statements explicitly motivate a comparison of UV and positivity methods. They do not establish a transferable method yielding the same criterion for both systems.","qualification":"The semiwormhole target is the source's macroscopic axionic action-to-charge criterion, not a black-hole mass, extremality or force bound. Whether positivity suffices or additional duality information is needed remains open in the supplied material. Black-hole fixed-variable choices, coefficient origin, stability, moduli and asymptotic assumptions retain their separate roles. Entropy positivity, WGC implications and relations among mass, entropy and force corrections are not universal or automatically transferable.","evidenceIds":["unit:151822cebd530bc89ef31bc2293f2213b585ebef17202aaa220318cf5d97b739","unit:1877ac824b12f923a22b9a1410a474675bcab4fcc7fee2a93c55f9d96742d23a","unit:1efd9f9c192ab47eb9d6b64ea349f9a6c0b2cf5d7672b12b7dafd61e379548a7","unit:25e50cf0d0c93ce5a51d4da0f884796d5145450e7798d5c79585492c25c5a652","unit:3a270e0aeff8114e04b2252be47b23163f3375a232f890db0ae0c73850f08fe9","unit:5ead4ae79a9f4c448d9f47daddc72047adc7d0385aa0c7a0aef9e117ce97a12c","unit:606b9c80ea45489c19ac782232a6edc80bc371d63f78bd4a4d82ecfcf6ad8942","unit:618c7476e9bd17d716b6730a0c83a5b14174deb00690e4bdd359630f74f131ed","unit:7f74ed53aa9e88488adf9350f6c34e4c409b716f24a0b2def99253e7842a7b56","unit:b5505445a85f89950ba6f38d799d36a1a46dac4f03dffa2e386a69b4c2895fb8","unit:b83d41617038331d16fae81216e62872b17f5b98219d20a94a085a90f61e26cb","unit:bb6e38375672c2460f470d98ff71dc7fab8eb1ac1065293d909e84faf63c58d7","unit:deb140f8a9d9eebacd7cd647cd5eda20c50b3319aac96e371ee35bee877f32e1","unit:f9459fa6a0698d7fb5eb5597ac1d3f3adcd0dacbbe7f34945a11fbe510d58ebc"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d2d1b5aa3349f0f9d12d3966","scopeContentSha256":"b6d6a91f57b5895c271322fbc9bbcd4c9bd32c02b174a41730dd0c5381c993cd","localRef":"s31"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e4152f3d61427952901dca29","scopeContentSha256":"64729718006794bea5c94eefe77f2fb48c608f5293a68c9d96db08852a51690f","localRef":"s35"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l30","originalCandidateId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge:link:17","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-08:l30","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge:link:17","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:d2d1b5aa3349f0f9d12d3966","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:e4152f3d61427952901dca29","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l30","source":"s31","target":"s35","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["UV and positivity methods motivate comparison with axionic semiwormholes; an action-to-charge criterion is not a black-hole mass or force criterion."],"challengeStatement":"UV and positivity arguments motivate a method comparison; semiwormhole action-to-charge is not a black-hole mass or force observable.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"84c78c62088892b814b68e32c00b71cb44c811e155e03704c869635c02ad60df","reply.jsonSha256":"556603e974a55e8c5927e97fb726622a468d8f112662207e6a08bc0646e43789","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7b38215c12856c8ed885f6428d00f8188a7f89226128f05da080faf2d6792223","receipt.jsonSha256":"e560951e4131a6965c2ba42042f6313b94d08d1f6694451859d5e1f5c63c2050","normalization.jsonSha256":"f3d0459f84b1374a8cadff1057734609b239a1a8c72d3aed44940ebdd51e1ce5","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"d3c8e8b718e7a870eb88a75140444059ccd9d19dca9ec0cb0dfff5c1cfebf466"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"97edd783afd94e77249a9c8387f811508d82091ef1bcf206c36283c8face47a0","reply.jsonSha256":"cdb6a30f0ff898fa6ea97136abb7ea0089e9389e35852e43f10fe2f3db761849","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7495a97ce30109a98279c8ccf8f3d1dab60248a70f6e0c64d9e999d9e3b6f072","receipt.jsonSha256":"2c33f5695d3da5b90ebbb19c4d6d8cc1049f0f09c72f9fd45d205ed8ff0552fe","normalization.jsonSha256":"fcc3c1dfd4aaca584c2d99d78344a028a34a99c7080baf41b099b8f773b50f91"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d2d1b5aa3349f0f9d12d3966"},{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e4152f3d61427952901dca29"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d2d1b5aa3349f0f9d12d3966"},{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e4152f3d61427952901dca29"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d30","originalRef":"l30","status":"route","source":"s31","target":"s35","type":"comparison","title":"Compare black-hole UV constraints with semiwormhole action bounds","rationale":"The original statements explicitly motivate a comparison of UV and positivity methods. They do not establish a transferable method yielding the same criterion for both systems.","qualification":"The semiwormhole target is the source's macroscopic axionic action-to-charge criterion, not a black-hole mass, extremality or force bound. Whether positivity suffices or additional duality information is needed remains open in the supplied material. Black-hole fixed-variable choices, coefficient origin, stability, moduli and asymptotic assumptions retain their separate roles. Entropy positivity, WGC implications and relations among mass, entropy and force corrections are not universal or automatically transferable.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l30","s31","s35"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d30","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The paired reasoning explicitly supports a comparison of UV and positivity arguments. The record preserves the semiwormhole action-to-charge criterion and its unresolved positivity-versus-duality question, without substituting black-hole mass, force or extremality observables or transferring their conditional conclusions.","refs":["l30","s31","s35"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-08-proposal","parent-orientation-08-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and their explicit reading limits. References identify review context, not new empirical evidence.","No primary text, original review files, locators or sidecar hashes were newly accessed. No primary rereading or verification of original scientific results is claimed.","Reading-coverage counts describe earlier bounded reviews. They do not certify full derivations, component formulas, classifications, software behavior or universal applicability.","The s39 parent remains a proposal with attributed child coverage; this review does not independently verify its descendants or infer new homes, identities or placements.","No deterministic admission checks, receipt checks or global canonical/DAG gate were performed. These decisions do not establish consistency of the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original statements for every relation, and every proposed record. References identify supplied review context, not new empirical evidence.","No tools or external operations were used. No primary text, original review files, citation locators or sidecar hashes were newly accessed or reread.","Support is for the scientific navigation records under their qualifications, not independent verification of the underlying results. Earlier reading-coverage counts do not certify full derivations, classifications, component formulas or software behavior.","The s39 parent remains a proposal with attributed descendant coverage. This challenge supplies no independent descendant verification, new placement or question identity.","No endpoint receipt checks, deterministic admission checks or global canonical/DAG gate were performed. These judgments do not decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-08:l30","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l0":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l0","source":"q025-candidate-question:b86bf1e8cdd7302fe82532cb","target":"q025-candidate-question:d5f8fa5d7ea8d89342670ca5","type":"application_of","title":"Trace joint flavor and unification models to their axion-sector constructions","rationale":"Both statements describe flavor, neutrino and unification targets as additional requirements applied to axion-sector construction. The applied model-building question therefore points to the underlying construction question.","qualification":"Restrict the application to the specified PQ or axion sectors and their supersymmetric or nonsupersymmetric settings. Flavor fits, neutrino mechanisms, doublet–triplet splitting, axion couplings and axion quality remain separate checks. Apparent PQ-charge differences require observable comparisons; the heterotic Yukawa structure is not identified with FN power suppression. An additional light pseudoscalar does not automatically provide strong-CP relaxation or protection against gravity.","evidenceIds":["unit:032417b11a93e7e54228b390e3a1ed7e943d3e1503dc0de6fc8348c5d468c170","unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","unit:0e25238380d382fb38f74462a50a57218b3e450549382cd37b4bc96743959313","unit:0f96a5852aff55abbd95eb199e168884ca2d8073f78fb8708a2e3ded100d86ab","unit:130668dc64dab6782a12f1402fc095100efef077df8a76137f0974073bff9f6d","unit:1afe22209df797df7117501faf477b8d658a1d23c80b78be9bca3d0781f633b0","unit:2a162f6afbb5f0d773f713b5991c923c6f410a5b07637dcfc53bfadcf7d48b86","unit:2cfd8ba59736c8d8bc635f3faa2666aa822407b5133b2366d4557ea7363c92f2","unit:306fb6d53296455e0c4540a99b7ab1c8a26ddad81b57274d7f608e2a04d736e6","unit:336b8beff535c077d7ab5e80a1adaa7cad6afd01054c276acc9fbd33a670ce3d","unit:3de1264c8dd5d64de1f6ffbd5335ae056e742f58fd1bdac97b012501ef45faa8","unit:3e47f269b12cc12ce9394273690bdfb747e9bc028340c67b5a2cdadbc2de6cca","unit:3e9bbbedaf88d3f866509b04e8f528fcd5cd62c46756bc0a0496b3d254b991da","unit:4a3e48e5dfe652a96cf016889ff7b881850111276094483e37770e5474c400ba","unit:4d555e0570b023073430673c80926b7743f39bea4e9eb6fc786a850fae454210","unit:55a4241a7514f369fa265e66fe920269176dc8808334401df3ea574b7f1ac111","unit:58a2cb631daf0363f4e6bb7b02670b7e76fb0958fcda2eada8414721f2e9bba5","unit:5ba3116272b44f6282cd1881b5f8876f224e5d963617efc82a969cc9a7378f3b","unit:69ab822f9ef72c6e77724c7e855a82a64f800d947b2c9bd535fa649d760447bc","unit:6bff20f447a4ef623c02e7de8251634e18fa63f1e98311c38770308d80343fc4","unit:6ea3ef888dcae049e1d7adb5e12aa048a8346c2a4c0a5ac774ba73d2780c18ad","unit:70cf432ac012851a55c351667a1e81bf2028527b7837fe83e9414de16afa1268","unit:7643588204101e132c73b40dbbc3cad56bf80e56966d5e71f6d34b45e0fa72ec","unit:7a81eb485ea7aa5de921ecedf860452666796a511ea14e4c836a05418b44485a","unit:8157b3e136b460585752c19063dac2a821c3111d0a501ace198f7125d843ac62","unit:83064feb8b5e1ace7c4730b6c5d958556eef4b2c7be2c47bdac9000567a8d468","unit:843ecc9bcfecff73064a27bcc5b3bcc172ab66e8c7d98d5f705532d0e85608bd","unit:86ee96cee13b942a21941418964f7d0f9782e8ca9ec31a6e174127a332dcef72","unit:8a030d33a0080a354227ca71b9d3ead4395240202bce6a763da8277205a742f1","unit:8c62bdd7cefa5e5b69efbb26ab01a0ad8e0eafdb48f786761fc272f814d4c237","unit:8d5393cead97f84de6668b79688a445ca66e5613dffc003c5e089b60a6162a95","unit:8fa43f887352f169ee25a776050f9ee5b98a6f5445cc8fa6c1628cd41810d8b4","unit:944221aa2e1f8114212e2effc081466279c5cea06b426cb7890b90341b48fd03","unit:97c5b76d12951bc2b8730eb805d5ef856bfa89a341cf7d9680a1505194061807","unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","unit:a6e4b449e5a2092248858dd9a7d20307313cb079a4a2c4b26b332247721a2aea","unit:ac37a74b422c65cc41e8ddd0032c4ad51eb638d6dec3095110d7c615268fa418","unit:acbcbb2a06ddda0a17aae4781b7ce43da9115305484a8da92c95f65d8698352d","unit:b68fcae4f9e147c75e0ad6e85fd76b3eb8bb60edd3b95c6cf4642b44fca4635a","unit:b771884dd2ab0bc8b96738c89402756d88a1be1f711e7fa60a0b37f41be2c0cc","unit:b8bbdb841ea68996c4ab2656807dfdfb7086caf18903e1c94b43652ee9422499","unit:c99ce4001fa57717aa53a26c753978dd0af28a20ea82b46f4ac366aef1ad6adc","unit:cb4ac5608c9cb467097ef87150febf2cc551ccc903f3fde3165905f0656d2aa7","unit:cec1176f88da7ceabc0b9a0be73131e4c42e86f8443bc3d6dc655bc4728945b1","unit:d066e0f487cbc291db7ccf3a49750805b64c0e7a49174b71635b01e3eaf90b78","unit:d20c356cd850934f1f2e86b72acaafa5f043748999fd4e7cf4ec4a2edd36df80","unit:d2a6e2957ac9d2940976c98eda91bdfb2fa94ef830a059cd5ba97bda647a3123","unit:df1567b10930b301d2d2a1e92b4f4a522583b66f30c88f531ef578ff9a5afdd7","unit:e4d180feaa5b44ebd3027c90e3e55423893fd1c23b6108a067c500773973ef88","unit:e60943db97a2a6f9680b9dd8a6fc206b0a83caad2036b7909646eac94f772cfb","unit:ec1e80fd26e44446417a7ab237c43df104f9263069db118a8527270517be3c1c","unit:f02dc950a2af20a8c5807205c788d7b8109d0e8150bd86f46d55bebf7beac6e4","unit:f2ac0a31eb76f8bb6b69692c3f9b679c1f50b2a62efe097409f7030c9e06dd0a","unit:f3a465374d22aaf2d1e3386d43dc37f9a56b33abf3d360c38be1fb895de2fafb","unit:f75a4d61162d8c84d3941b209ebe9934c63390ea3c4e622db73b91733c8a11c0"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b86bf1e8cdd7302fe82532cb","scopeContentSha256":"c0310822b2f3689516ed61d014d4cd1b9accd397f03009cd65ee0b36b795b9b2","localRef":"s34"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d5f8fa5d7ea8d89342670ca5","scopeContentSha256":"c1369c1d0c19a4f197e48cf77b4fae0ad55ec71cbf646a42ed8601c1205092b7","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l0","originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:17","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l0","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:17","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:d5f8fa5d7ea8d89342670ca5","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:b86bf1e8cdd7302fe82532cb","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l0","source":"s38","target":"s34","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Joint flavor, neutrino and unification targets apply axion-sector model building under additional requirements."],"challengeStatement":"Flavor, neutrino and unification requirements add model-building targets to axion-sector construction.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8837533292ba2dc050c09c0f4b04af5d04bacdf1ab973652f26afeac5ab375e1","reply.jsonSha256":"c4da9c37362a39ccb4319f60c4983a440a50a7fded2dbcd384cf07779ef43ba4","reply.raw.txtSha256":"579facbd28ff0cfc08d1f878e55b88a06ebb4422a57589f5577d498e574a43d7","receipt.jsonSha256":"3aa4184cf3ab982b9de218ea326aa5015b854135a6d0a36f719e7fc5d64ffe1a","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7fcdf1f23896f5ae47612e73b6d7804e5ec8667ff11aa2c9d1390d566971293","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"16ccc8f6866b12f72f1cc5bdec200a43d888fd66bdaca563ec623b1b61f881f6"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"172478274c8c6cefae0e46d485d373db74d6ed2e6d67121d0fe60c3553fe8561","reply.jsonSha256":"e4a601e983ad12fb24ac06650339f91a7cb408d1ad0059709c0a71399daf1643","reply.raw.txtSha256":"633b874344705a2d8539b45abb792739f8caf36c5fe116ee81cf82c41bb84161","receipt.jsonSha256":"66ce2c23b3c076188e34e5a95afec015e72e192e7a489859d2d316c4fa3f930c","normalization.jsonSha256":"89c6ce8e7cd2a821fb72347a5e003a2ab62093e88672faf6fa2d440db3279915"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d5f8fa5d7ea8d89342670ca5"},{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b86bf1e8cdd7302fe82532cb"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d5f8fa5d7ea8d89342670ca5"},{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b86bf1e8cdd7302fe82532cb"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d0","originalRef":"l0","status":"route","source":"s34","target":"s38","type":"application_of","title":"Trace joint flavor and unification models to their axion-sector constructions","rationale":"Both statements describe flavor, neutrino and unification targets as additional requirements applied to axion-sector construction. The applied model-building question therefore points to the underlying construction question.","qualification":"Restrict the application to the specified PQ or axion sectors and their supersymmetric or nonsupersymmetric settings. Flavor fits, neutrino mechanisms, doublet–triplet splitting, axion couplings and axion quality remain separate checks. Apparent PQ-charge differences require observable comparisons; the heterotic Yukawa structure is not identified with FN power suppression. An additional light pseudoscalar does not automatically provide strong-CP relaxation or protection against gravity.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l0","s34","s38"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements describe additional flavor, neutrino and unification requirements applied to axion-sector construction. The reversed application_of direction correctly identifies the applied question. The qualification preserves separate phenomenological and quality checks without assuming that every light pseudoscalar solves strong CP.","refs":["l0","s34","s38"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l1":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l1","source":"q025-candidate-question:0a8ba98b6557f2e4185aab0c","target":"q025-candidate-question:d5f8fa5d7ea8d89342670ca5","type":"application_of","title":"Identify the pseudoscalar constructions used in selected dark-energy tests","rationale":"Both statements identify dark-energy and potential-bound questions as applications of selected pseudoscalar constructions under additional premises. This places the cosmological application at the source.","qualification":"The connection covers only the selected constructions, with their own potentials and cosmological assumptions. Slope and negative-curvature conjectures are conditional alternatives, and directly coupled and sequestered QCD cases remain distinct. Hypothetical QCD false-branch premises do not transfer to every axion model, and a branch-energy splitting is not an additional independent parameter. Historical model targets retain their date. Neither dark-energy use nor conjectural compatibility establishes a completed ultraviolet construction or a QCD strong-CP solution.","evidenceIds":["unit:032417b11a93e7e54228b390e3a1ed7e943d3e1503dc0de6fc8348c5d468c170","unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","unit:0f96a5852aff55abbd95eb199e168884ca2d8073f78fb8708a2e3ded100d86ab","unit:130668dc64dab6782a12f1402fc095100efef077df8a76137f0974073bff9f6d","unit:1afe22209df797df7117501faf477b8d658a1d23c80b78be9bca3d0781f633b0","unit:2a162f6afbb5f0d773f713b5991c923c6f410a5b07637dcfc53bfadcf7d48b86","unit:2cfd8ba59736c8d8bc635f3faa2666aa822407b5133b2366d4557ea7363c92f2","unit:306fb6d53296455e0c4540a99b7ab1c8a26ddad81b57274d7f608e2a04d736e6","unit:336b8beff535c077d7ab5e80a1adaa7cad6afd01054c276acc9fbd33a670ce3d","unit:3a90597a10fbb267ab88951d1afcf471bd1257aac6542ca36c67b709af614941","unit:3de1264c8dd5d64de1f6ffbd5335ae056e742f58fd1bdac97b012501ef45faa8","unit:3e47f269b12cc12ce9394273690bdfb747e9bc028340c67b5a2cdadbc2de6cca","unit:3e9bbbedaf88d3f866509b04e8f528fcd5cd62c46756bc0a0496b3d254b991da","unit:4a3e48e5dfe652a96cf016889ff7b881850111276094483e37770e5474c400ba","unit:5ba3116272b44f6282cd1881b5f8876f224e5d963617efc82a969cc9a7378f3b","unit:69ab822f9ef72c6e77724c7e855a82a64f800d947b2c9bd535fa649d760447bc","unit:6bff20f447a4ef623c02e7de8251634e18fa63f1e98311c38770308d80343fc4","unit:70cf432ac012851a55c351667a1e81bf2028527b7837fe83e9414de16afa1268","unit:7643588204101e132c73b40dbbc3cad56bf80e56966d5e71f6d34b45e0fa72ec","unit:7a81eb485ea7aa5de921ecedf860452666796a511ea14e4c836a05418b44485a","unit:8157b3e136b460585752c19063dac2a821c3111d0a501ace198f7125d843ac62","unit:843ecc9bcfecff73064a27bcc5b3bcc172ab66e8c7d98d5f705532d0e85608bd","unit:86ee96cee13b942a21941418964f7d0f9782e8ca9ec31a6e174127a332dcef72","unit:8a030d33a0080a354227ca71b9d3ead4395240202bce6a763da8277205a742f1","unit:8c62bdd7cefa5e5b69efbb26ab01a0ad8e0eafdb48f786761fc272f814d4c237","unit:8d5393cead97f84de6668b79688a445ca66e5613dffc003c5e089b60a6162a95","unit:8fa43f887352f169ee25a776050f9ee5b98a6f5445cc8fa6c1628cd41810d8b4","unit:97c5b76d12951bc2b8730eb805d5ef856bfa89a341cf7d9680a1505194061807","unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","unit:991d57ad8ae0df69374eff0ba7b9499e67a0e48bfb1f0dcd03296274cc92171c","unit:a6e4b449e5a2092248858dd9a7d20307313cb079a4a2c4b26b332247721a2aea","unit:ac37a74b422c65cc41e8ddd0032c4ad51eb638d6dec3095110d7c615268fa418","unit:acbcbb2a06ddda0a17aae4781b7ce43da9115305484a8da92c95f65d8698352d","unit:b68fcae4f9e147c75e0ad6e85fd76b3eb8bb60edd3b95c6cf4642b44fca4635a","unit:b771884dd2ab0bc8b96738c89402756d88a1be1f711e7fa60a0b37f41be2c0cc","unit:b8bbdb841ea68996c4ab2656807dfdfb7086caf18903e1c94b43652ee9422499","unit:bb6d397d7467b8c7862ec28c1f35728ba1d407145720a2066cc649aeb64dcfaa","unit:c99ce4001fa57717aa53a26c753978dd0af28a20ea82b46f4ac366aef1ad6adc","unit:cb4ac5608c9cb467097ef87150febf2cc551ccc903f3fde3165905f0656d2aa7","unit:cec1176f88da7ceabc0b9a0be73131e4c42e86f8443bc3d6dc655bc4728945b1","unit:d066e0f487cbc291db7ccf3a49750805b64c0e7a49174b71635b01e3eaf90b78","unit:d20c356cd850934f1f2e86b72acaafa5f043748999fd4e7cf4ec4a2edd36df80","unit:df1567b10930b301d2d2a1e92b4f4a522583b66f30c88f531ef578ff9a5afdd7","unit:ea21e552d29a9967e2ce15db21824d7ca60772672971bbc9b9de185b7cccc682","unit:ec1e80fd26e44446417a7ab237c43df104f9263069db118a8527270517be3c1c","unit:f02dc950a2af20a8c5807205c788d7b8109d0e8150bd86f46d55bebf7beac6e4","unit:f2ac0a31eb76f8bb6b69692c3f9b679c1f50b2a62efe097409f7030c9e06dd0a","unit:f30a09f54c06fdb8108af52bfa0152b3e5f4867ffe83b89f3e39ff9352ee836b","unit:f3a465374d22aaf2d1e3386d43dc37f9a56b33abf3d360c38be1fb895de2fafb","unit:f75a4d61162d8c84d3941b209ebe9934c63390ea3c4e622db73b91733c8a11c0"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0a8ba98b6557f2e4185aab0c","scopeContentSha256":"0b214bf242905a88b114928d13df7ee90fb676b12678a59071b6198e979e304a","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d5f8fa5d7ea8d89342670ca5","scopeContentSha256":"c1369c1d0c19a4f197e48cf77b4fae0ad55ec71cbf646a42ed8601c1205092b7","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l1","originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:20","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l1","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:20","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:d5f8fa5d7ea8d89342670ca5","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:0a8ba98b6557f2e4185aab0c","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l1","source":"s38","target":"s2","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Dark-energy and potential-bound questions apply selected pseudoscalar constructions under additional cosmological or conjectural premises."],"challengeStatement":"Dark-energy and potential-bound questions apply selected pseudoscalar constructions under additional premises.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8837533292ba2dc050c09c0f4b04af5d04bacdf1ab973652f26afeac5ab375e1","reply.jsonSha256":"c4da9c37362a39ccb4319f60c4983a440a50a7fded2dbcd384cf07779ef43ba4","reply.raw.txtSha256":"579facbd28ff0cfc08d1f878e55b88a06ebb4422a57589f5577d498e574a43d7","receipt.jsonSha256":"3aa4184cf3ab982b9de218ea326aa5015b854135a6d0a36f719e7fc5d64ffe1a","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7fcdf1f23896f5ae47612e73b6d7804e5ec8667ff11aa2c9d1390d566971293","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"16ccc8f6866b12f72f1cc5bdec200a43d888fd66bdaca563ec623b1b61f881f6"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"172478274c8c6cefae0e46d485d373db74d6ed2e6d67121d0fe60c3553fe8561","reply.jsonSha256":"e4a601e983ad12fb24ac06650339f91a7cb408d1ad0059709c0a71399daf1643","reply.raw.txtSha256":"633b874344705a2d8539b45abb792739f8caf36c5fe116ee81cf82c41bb84161","receipt.jsonSha256":"66ce2c23b3c076188e34e5a95afec015e72e192e7a489859d2d316c4fa3f930c","normalization.jsonSha256":"89c6ce8e7cd2a821fb72347a5e003a2ab62093e88672faf6fa2d440db3279915"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d5f8fa5d7ea8d89342670ca5"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0a8ba98b6557f2e4185aab0c"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d5f8fa5d7ea8d89342670ca5"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0a8ba98b6557f2e4185aab0c"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d1","originalRef":"l1","status":"route","source":"s2","target":"s38","type":"application_of","title":"Identify the pseudoscalar constructions used in selected dark-energy tests","rationale":"Both statements identify dark-energy and potential-bound questions as applications of selected pseudoscalar constructions under additional premises. This places the cosmological application at the source.","qualification":"The connection covers only the selected constructions, with their own potentials and cosmological assumptions. Slope and negative-curvature conjectures are conditional alternatives, and directly coupled and sequestered QCD cases remain distinct. Hypothetical QCD false-branch premises do not transfer to every axion model, and a branch-energy splitting is not an additional independent parameter. Historical model targets retain their date. Neither dark-energy use nor conjectural compatibility establishes a completed ultraviolet construction or a QCD strong-CP solution.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l1","s2","s38"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements explicitly identify selected pseudoscalar constructions as the basis of dark-energy and potential-bound applications. The reversed direction is correct. The qualification retains conditional conjectures, alternative QCD couplings and source-specific false-branch assumptions without extending them to the entire axion-construction scope.","refs":["l1","s2","s38"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l2":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l2","source":"q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090","target":"q025-candidate-question:1bef8615353c5b7a99ff1752","type":"application_of","title":"Trace compactification-specific axion regions to their ultraviolet constructions","rationale":"The paired statements explicitly treat spectra and coupling regions from specified compactifications as applications of ultraviolet construction. The parameter-region question therefore points to its construction basis.","qualification":"Retain each construction's gauge embedding, exact gauge-derived versus approximate PQ symmetry, perturbative domain and recovery of observed gauge couplings. The σMSSM restriction does not automatically extend to approximate PQ models. Keep anomaly coefficients, coupling-to-mass ratios and the source-specific QCD chiral contribution distinct. The link neither equates string-inspired models with globally consistent compactifications nor supplies a universal string-axion bound, a verified F-theory spectrum or a current experimental exclusion.","evidenceIds":["unit:069169ac93c6836dd2f1ec6cfdc508f0031750054796b9ed40327dd82f808224","unit:228cd9098aab6509c19bc8ebd040e5b7d395774361c210ae2ccc0c67d68ef919","unit:343c6c959cfd658798ca3cdb49cea1f1b04b8751c185def0a453164bb37cd173","unit:3db6425229a8a7a299b5612e7e53e86cf5af42b821e35683ce3541f291ef5b03","unit:53ad69ad11dc1bd0df3f6ccb580303cd6b932caf4271bedce431c432b4ddf7f4","unit:55a4241a7514f369fa265e66fe920269176dc8808334401df3ea574b7f1ac111","unit:78dc743d702d302782e36332583b89a635856238868ccd81f9eaaee24c7707b8","unit:7d7db3b220f6f0730f5c0f579a88d6d58024ee834b7e8378d10e9dfc3ef20643","unit:86ee96cee13b942a21941418964f7d0f9782e8ca9ec31a6e174127a332dcef72","unit:944221aa2e1f8114212e2effc081466279c5cea06b426cb7890b90341b48fd03","unit:9cef45609fa533433990f88d4ec91fc008fc2859b2934e64cb771db2df1c0406","unit:abb075965401449fd7fa81e66456e47a2f70e2b5d51b30807b7fc3797b6baed3","unit:b4bf32d27573114b377f5833141fcaba14c955b58bf99ee9e4f381ccef21a1d9","unit:bb06bf32b17553f51af8a6c601b0b5d198509d67714c0ec97f2cf3a606d94d3d","unit:bc999b14e38bc703f9fb5402252a2775dcff4114ca35591008f0737c3f0c3336","unit:bd4d3d077ee56820ace10d371071f7ee96abdf05efd8e352b8c2ec02bd76e4dc","unit:bfdc18c0fbb4877bf1ac6b1ecf0922dd0ec1c35e8466b63200f17e92b135f792","unit:c4bad30eb06037bf6215a03602e4c884a7de5c953fc3b9d488d410361b4b90b5","unit:ce2ab38f64939831d8824122d5856ce30668591f42b69a7464fc519151bb4e03","unit:ce7d3da1f63860e69c26286869bf2adf6e52181a7a7158bed428e5b75b532d1d","unit:d2a6e2957ac9d2940976c98eda91bdfb2fa94ef830a059cd5ba97bda647a3123","unit:d554202e8324222e675c830c5dab030707a5179767cfc7fe879c8ad1997e462f","unit:ff5e35da5142d1259b2427910e159252fe25dff3029fd88e4f5a0b0f25d7a0c7"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090","scopeContentSha256":"178cf1202434c4b1d5b58290da6d05bcf17995eb49ac448f688f7a3335610bda","localRef":"s1"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1bef8615353c5b7a99ff1752","scopeContentSha256":"985c7caae1bc00522a34cec75c0d346d2e3a5033af7b46aa3cd2dfb4042c7928","localRef":"s4"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l2","originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:24","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l2","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:24","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:1bef8615353c5b7a99ff1752","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l2","source":"s4","target":"s1","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Specified compactifications provide model-dependent spectra and coupling regions as applications of ultraviolet construction."],"challengeStatement":"Specified compactifications supply model-dependent spectra and coupling regions as construction applications.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8837533292ba2dc050c09c0f4b04af5d04bacdf1ab973652f26afeac5ab375e1","reply.jsonSha256":"c4da9c37362a39ccb4319f60c4983a440a50a7fded2dbcd384cf07779ef43ba4","reply.raw.txtSha256":"579facbd28ff0cfc08d1f878e55b88a06ebb4422a57589f5577d498e574a43d7","receipt.jsonSha256":"3aa4184cf3ab982b9de218ea326aa5015b854135a6d0a36f719e7fc5d64ffe1a","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7fcdf1f23896f5ae47612e73b6d7804e5ec8667ff11aa2c9d1390d566971293","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"16ccc8f6866b12f72f1cc5bdec200a43d888fd66bdaca563ec623b1b61f881f6"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"172478274c8c6cefae0e46d485d373db74d6ed2e6d67121d0fe60c3553fe8561","reply.jsonSha256":"e4a601e983ad12fb24ac06650339f91a7cb408d1ad0059709c0a71399daf1643","reply.raw.txtSha256":"633b874344705a2d8539b45abb792739f8caf36c5fe116ee81cf82c41bb84161","receipt.jsonSha256":"66ce2c23b3c076188e34e5a95afec015e72e192e7a489859d2d316c4fa3f930c","normalization.jsonSha256":"89c6ce8e7cd2a821fb72347a5e003a2ab62093e88672faf6fa2d440db3279915"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1bef8615353c5b7a99ff1752"},{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1bef8615353c5b7a99ff1752"},{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d2","originalRef":"l2","status":"route","source":"s1","target":"s4","type":"application_of","title":"Trace compactification-specific axion regions to their ultraviolet constructions","rationale":"The paired statements explicitly treat spectra and coupling regions from specified compactifications as applications of ultraviolet construction. The parameter-region question therefore points to its construction basis.","qualification":"Retain each construction's gauge embedding, exact gauge-derived versus approximate PQ symmetry, perturbative domain and recovery of observed gauge couplings. The σMSSM restriction does not automatically extend to approximate PQ models. Keep anomaly coefficients, coupling-to-mass ratios and the source-specific QCD chiral contribution distinct. The link neither equates string-inspired models with globally consistent compactifications nor supplies a universal string-axion bound, a verified F-theory spectrum or a current experimental exclusion.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l2","s1","s4"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original reasoning explicitly treats compactification-specific spectra and coupling regions as applications of ultraviolet constructions. The reversal preserves that role assignment. Gauge embeddings, exact versus approximate PQ symmetry, perturbative control and the distinction between anomaly coefficients and observable coupling ratios remain explicit.","refs":["l2","s1","s4"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l3":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l3","source":"q025-candidate-question:9c5c18c51211990f1bbd53d7","target":"q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090","type":"related_question","title":"Connect axion–gauge assumptions to compactification-specific photon regions","rationale":"The statements support a connection through photon couplings and their dependence on gauge embeddings and control. They do not identify a particular quantization, anomaly or duality calculation being applied in a specified compactification, so an application direction is not established.","qualification":"The useful connection concerns model-dependent coupling assumptions. Preserve gauge groups, charge spectra, periodicity, normalization, perturbative control and the QCD meson or chiral contribution. Minimal-group experimental targets retain their minimal-gluon-coupling premise. Neither global-form quantization nor an anomaly coefficient is identified with a universal coupling-to-mass bound, and the σMSSM restriction is not transferred to approximate PQ models.","evidenceIds":["unit:149e90493e80fa8000cf5af82dde1b4b6b539f73f2f390d10733aa2cdb0d0b89","unit:25f2f07bb792d809abfcb5213a3ac549eaa74745c084245cb0133139868291a7","unit:2e1cfab444b67d09ff3fa97dc1053f35c7b21d49c70b72f67f3a085daaaaaf27","unit:34a587fd5d4a5a298f4969ce47c917af5fa80886be39543d7b11e156044fea93","unit:6c5df27e748e85186cf41164fb2614e08a638ee47ec60d345234c3902471b70e","unit:7d7db3b220f6f0730f5c0f579a88d6d58024ee834b7e8378d10e9dfc3ef20643","unit:94aaf87a8313240a048b133e93ab722899aaf5175d5f8fe0f7b7b8342933cdb8","unit:a7e2174c5ac2507d291310e781a5d4e8225891095b1bc2b8b06bf2b16fe63caa","unit:bc999b14e38bc703f9fb5402252a2775dcff4114ca35591008f0737c3f0c3336","unit:bd4d3d077ee56820ace10d371071f7ee96abdf05efd8e352b8c2ec02bd76e4dc"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9c5c18c51211990f1bbd53d7","scopeContentSha256":"edac70b7bc936e6562ef33a709eb8e245cc6d5937d51f4cf818e44b29002e092","localRef":"s29"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090","scopeContentSha256":"178cf1202434c4b1d5b58290da6d05bcf17995eb49ac448f688f7a3335610bda","localRef":"s1"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l3","originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:25","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l3","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:25","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:9c5c18c51211990f1bbd53d7","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l3","source":"s29","target":"s1","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Compactification-specific photon-coupling regions require their own gauge embeddings and control assumptions."],"challengeStatement":"Compactification-specific coupling regions require their own gauge embeddings and control assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8837533292ba2dc050c09c0f4b04af5d04bacdf1ab973652f26afeac5ab375e1","reply.jsonSha256":"c4da9c37362a39ccb4319f60c4983a440a50a7fded2dbcd384cf07779ef43ba4","reply.raw.txtSha256":"579facbd28ff0cfc08d1f878e55b88a06ebb4422a57589f5577d498e574a43d7","receipt.jsonSha256":"3aa4184cf3ab982b9de218ea326aa5015b854135a6d0a36f719e7fc5d64ffe1a","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7fcdf1f23896f5ae47612e73b6d7804e5ec8667ff11aa2c9d1390d566971293","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"16ccc8f6866b12f72f1cc5bdec200a43d888fd66bdaca563ec623b1b61f881f6"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"172478274c8c6cefae0e46d485d373db74d6ed2e6d67121d0fe60c3553fe8561","reply.jsonSha256":"e4a601e983ad12fb24ac06650339f91a7cb408d1ad0059709c0a71399daf1643","reply.raw.txtSha256":"633b874344705a2d8539b45abb792739f8caf36c5fe116ee81cf82c41bb84161","receipt.jsonSha256":"66ce2c23b3c076188e34e5a95afec015e72e192e7a489859d2d316c4fa3f930c","normalization.jsonSha256":"89c6ce8e7cd2a821fb72347a5e003a2ab62093e88672faf6fa2d440db3279915"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9c5c18c51211990f1bbd53d7"},{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9c5c18c51211990f1bbd53d7"},{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d3","originalRef":"l3","status":"route","source":"s29","target":"s1","type":"related_question","title":"Connect axion–gauge assumptions to compactification-specific photon regions","rationale":"The statements support a connection through photon couplings and their dependence on gauge embeddings and control. They do not identify a particular quantization, anomaly or duality calculation being applied in a specified compactification, so an application direction is not established.","qualification":"The useful connection concerns model-dependent coupling assumptions. Preserve gauge groups, charge spectra, periodicity, normalization, perturbative control and the QCD meson or chiral contribution. Minimal-group experimental targets retain their minimal-gluon-coupling premise. Neither global-form quantization nor an anomaly coefficient is identified with a universal coupling-to-mass bound, and the σMSSM restriction is not transferred to approximate PQ models.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l3","s29","s1"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The statements support a useful connection through gauge-dependent axion couplings, but do not identify which interaction constraint is applied to which compactification. related_question preserves that connection without inventing a quantization or anomaly calculation. The qualification retains the model-specific embedding, normalization and control requirements.","refs":["l3","s29","s1"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l4":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l4","source":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293","target":"q025-candidate-question:bc1cfd0af433fc3864669226","type":"application_of","title":"Trace parity and mirror cosmologies to their symmetry constructions","rationale":"Both statements connect source-specific symmetry-breaking histories and cosmological consequences to parity and mirror constructions. Studying those consequences is an application of the corresponding construction.","qualification":"Limit the route to the parity and mirror mechanisms actually shared by these questions. Retain gauged versus global symmetry, spontaneous versus soft breaking and the specified cosmological epoch. Colour-preserving generalized parity and exchange of two colour groups remain different constructions. Cosmological viability and ultraviolet strong-CP protection are separate assessments; the link supplies neither detailed domain-wall calculations nor automatic protection from supersymmetry.","evidenceIds":["unit:312a9a4d4e3e24cb6657e6c75633b52bcb2189c08482bd0106ce36b33c2216aa","unit:35fbf856f839b8177c07528c835bfaaf87faa94d62c348c7148ca2ec895dfd90","unit:372f54cace2ff4ce8198d8b55c0d7dc2441629cd1714bb4dcaec5028624122eb","unit:5e11e18e579ebd55defa4065a5c8ff0da860f13a690bb742f00e8d8a560e4c1d","unit:5f388a1c26cf66963f2191a67579bf7f7536ed1f3e775d341a1f3751225733c3","unit:7170ba545bc5f690fe31b7df10a8b0227ed0ccda30421f1a3b9299be97a0566d","unit:71d64413f10c18cf972d71f6ce6fe855c61223bbe038ef70d63b20518cea4d97","unit:a1dfa3ec012ffdeb423936da17a39fcb830071feb103bc400d21d80e8af9e12a","unit:a63a27f10d1c0057c1f5fd3b1f62a372aab840c4c1c33921b7d2b7a0999bc991","unit:ca8a72a872dfb6f074d6f74ac654a5b5ac81e91d94a38bb0fc26b6b701a351e9","unit:d170103ccdde9de915914a7e86e924885b46a1640bb448be4619ec6a780eacbc","unit:e1f5be01031433d23aca8d21f6550fba3481a55d672afb59257e2584d0630fd6","unit:e580623e54876298225afd9606c98bbe29e807ba983dc3a4cae75fdaa6b080f4","unit:e921d7aeaac23e7fa0d42ca275418513603a298ecbea027f146afefa8054d426"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293","scopeContentSha256":"c4903abecff98423063ad9334a6b25fefdbf71aec3b2202355433d52556d17a2","localRef":"s9"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bc1cfd0af433fc3864669226","scopeContentSha256":"3253d198121fc048972ada1404962c8de05dc7e88361a84f72cf285a7c6612a3","localRef":"s35"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l4","originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:30","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l4","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:30","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:bc1cfd0af433fc3864669226","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l4","source":"s35","target":"s9","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Parity and mirror constructions have source-specific symmetry-breaking histories and cosmological consequences."],"challengeStatement":"Parity and mirror constructions have source-specific symmetry-breaking histories and cosmological consequences.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8837533292ba2dc050c09c0f4b04af5d04bacdf1ab973652f26afeac5ab375e1","reply.jsonSha256":"c4da9c37362a39ccb4319f60c4983a440a50a7fded2dbcd384cf07779ef43ba4","reply.raw.txtSha256":"579facbd28ff0cfc08d1f878e55b88a06ebb4422a57589f5577d498e574a43d7","receipt.jsonSha256":"3aa4184cf3ab982b9de218ea326aa5015b854135a6d0a36f719e7fc5d64ffe1a","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7fcdf1f23896f5ae47612e73b6d7804e5ec8667ff11aa2c9d1390d566971293","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"16ccc8f6866b12f72f1cc5bdec200a43d888fd66bdaca563ec623b1b61f881f6"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"172478274c8c6cefae0e46d485d373db74d6ed2e6d67121d0fe60c3553fe8561","reply.jsonSha256":"e4a601e983ad12fb24ac06650339f91a7cb408d1ad0059709c0a71399daf1643","reply.raw.txtSha256":"633b874344705a2d8539b45abb792739f8caf36c5fe116ee81cf82c41bb84161","receipt.jsonSha256":"66ce2c23b3c076188e34e5a95afec015e72e192e7a489859d2d316c4fa3f930c","normalization.jsonSha256":"89c6ce8e7cd2a821fb72347a5e003a2ab62093e88672faf6fa2d440db3279915"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bc1cfd0af433fc3864669226"},{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bc1cfd0af433fc3864669226"},{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d4","originalRef":"l4","status":"route","source":"s9","target":"s35","type":"application_of","title":"Trace parity and mirror cosmologies to their symmetry constructions","rationale":"Both statements connect source-specific symmetry-breaking histories and cosmological consequences to parity and mirror constructions. Studying those consequences is an application of the corresponding construction.","qualification":"Limit the route to the parity and mirror mechanisms actually shared by these questions. Retain gauged versus global symmetry, spontaneous versus soft breaking and the specified cosmological epoch. Colour-preserving generalized parity and exchange of two colour groups remain different constructions. Cosmological viability and ultraviolet strong-CP protection are separate assessments; the link supplies neither detailed domain-wall calculations nor automatic protection from supersymmetry.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l4","s9","s35"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Studying the stated cosmological consequences is an application of the specified parity or mirror construction, supporting the reversed application_of arrow. The qualification confines this to shared mechanisms and preserves symmetry status, breaking history and the distinction between cosmological viability and ultraviolet strong-CP protection.","refs":["l4","s9","s35"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l5":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l5","source":"q025-candidate-question:89b2fa4fd3b8d60982641584","target":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293","type":"premise_check","title":"Check cosmological viability of a specified CP-breaking history","rationale":"The shared reasoning presents cosmology as an additional viability check for CP-breaking mechanisms and explicitly says that proposing a microscopic embedding does not answer it. This supports a conditional construction-to-viability-check direction.","qualification":"Apply this check when a CP-breaking construction is assessed with a specified cosmological history. Preserve the symmetry's gauged or global status, breaking epoch and relevant relic or defect questions. Cosmological viability is not asserted to be a universal prerequisite for the algebraic separation of weak and strong phases. An embedding proposal establishes neither acceptable cosmology nor control of all threshold and supersymmetry-breaking contributions to the physical QCD angle.","evidenceIds":["unit:228e355fc8caf28912d7590211c19a0fcf9b1479995b8525ff25c07caae50639","unit:2b9bd653ee80a4ba6755d1cacdb8bd32e625582b901b749d2a8ee7c115e77509","unit:312a9a4d4e3e24cb6657e6c75633b52bcb2189c08482bd0106ce36b33c2216aa","unit:372f54cace2ff4ce8198d8b55c0d7dc2441629cd1714bb4dcaec5028624122eb","unit:3fa3ffacdda011675f2a9c4498432fd109da3b2fd8fc2241787b8fb48ab4ad8a","unit:441e97c40ad368f961949ce658d637125f13c50ace730de10ce2a5b20b20a838","unit:636d56a46a9214cf59b74cfc18dbe11f2ee6cc510f2a5d79dc93fb7875bd74c3","unit:7170ba545bc5f690fe31b7df10a8b0227ed0ccda30421f1a3b9299be97a0566d","unit:71d64413f10c18cf972d71f6ce6fe855c61223bbe038ef70d63b20518cea4d97","unit:76fbc5b1a35c809447199df440c40190ff72a283cee5373ef1e54d91ce35f752","unit:a1dfa3ec012ffdeb423936da17a39fcb830071feb103bc400d21d80e8af9e12a","unit:a63a27f10d1c0057c1f5fd3b1f62a372aab840c4c1c33921b7d2b7a0999bc991","unit:ca8a72a872dfb6f074d6f74ac654a5b5ac81e91d94a38bb0fc26b6b701a351e9","unit:d170103ccdde9de915914a7e86e924885b46a1640bb448be4619ec6a780eacbc","unit:d4eb3c7955567c0c91cca346aca93564ee415b3c868509a7d8e00b18dd9b9174","unit:d6ddffb8dbf3b312b310b5aadec096cc6c16afadeaf1a67d9225e52aa6a43ff9","unit:e580623e54876298225afd9606c98bbe29e807ba983dc3a4cae75fdaa6b080f4","unit:e921d7aeaac23e7fa0d42ca275418513603a298ecbea027f146afefa8054d426","unit:f00a69f9ef815fc6e32f3f9a2cf5d1634881d29c86f21ff199d7b5d8d7fa515b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:89b2fa4fd3b8d60982641584","scopeContentSha256":"980837b5cdbfec2417279cf6b46d9de532828619fcaea220d88932396d51f2ae","localRef":"s26"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293","scopeContentSha256":"c4903abecff98423063ad9334a6b25fefdbf71aec3b2202355433d52556d17a2","localRef":"s9"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l5","originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:31","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l5","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:31","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:89b2fa4fd3b8d60982641584","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l5","source":"s26","target":"s9","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Cosmology of CP breaking is an additional viability target, not established by suggesting a microscopic embedding."],"challengeStatement":"Cosmology supplies additional viability questions for CP-breaking mechanisms; an embedding proposal does not answer them.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8837533292ba2dc050c09c0f4b04af5d04bacdf1ab973652f26afeac5ab375e1","reply.jsonSha256":"c4da9c37362a39ccb4319f60c4983a440a50a7fded2dbcd384cf07779ef43ba4","reply.raw.txtSha256":"579facbd28ff0cfc08d1f878e55b88a06ebb4422a57589f5577d498e574a43d7","receipt.jsonSha256":"3aa4184cf3ab982b9de218ea326aa5015b854135a6d0a36f719e7fc5d64ffe1a","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7fcdf1f23896f5ae47612e73b6d7804e5ec8667ff11aa2c9d1390d566971293","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"16ccc8f6866b12f72f1cc5bdec200a43d888fd66bdaca563ec623b1b61f881f6"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"172478274c8c6cefae0e46d485d373db74d6ed2e6d67121d0fe60c3553fe8561","reply.jsonSha256":"e4a601e983ad12fb24ac06650339f91a7cb408d1ad0059709c0a71399daf1643","reply.raw.txtSha256":"633b874344705a2d8539b45abb792739f8caf36c5fe116ee81cf82c41bb84161","receipt.jsonSha256":"66ce2c23b3c076188e34e5a95afec015e72e192e7a489859d2d316c4fa3f930c","normalization.jsonSha256":"89c6ce8e7cd2a821fb72347a5e003a2ab62093e88672faf6fa2d440db3279915"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:89b2fa4fd3b8d60982641584"},{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:89b2fa4fd3b8d60982641584"},{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d5","originalRef":"l5","status":"route","source":"s26","target":"s9","type":"premise_check","title":"Check cosmological viability of a specified CP-breaking history","rationale":"The shared reasoning presents cosmology as an additional viability check for CP-breaking mechanisms and explicitly says that proposing a microscopic embedding does not answer it. This supports a conditional construction-to-viability-check direction.","qualification":"Apply this check when a CP-breaking construction is assessed with a specified cosmological history. Preserve the symmetry's gauged or global status, breaking epoch and relevant relic or defect questions. Cosmological viability is not asserted to be a universal prerequisite for the algebraic separation of weak and strong phases. An embedding proposal establishes neither acceptable cosmology nor control of all threshold and supersymmetry-breaking contributions to the physical QCD angle.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l5","s26","s9"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements identify cosmology as an additional viability assessment for CP-breaking mechanisms. The conditional premise_check direction is justified for constructions assessed with a specified history. Its explicit restriction avoids making cosmological viability a universal prerequisite for weak–strong phase separation or treating an embedding proposal as a completed viability analysis.","refs":["l5","s26","s9"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l6":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l6","source":"q025-candidate-question:610431eba8395e885b1678e7","target":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293","type":"premise_check","title":"Check the epoch and survival conditions of cosmological selection proposals","rationale":"Both statements emphasize the particular cosmological epochs and survival conditions of selection and alternative vacuum mechanisms. For mechanisms that depend on those conditions, the construction question points to their cosmological assessment.","qualification":"Restrict the check to mechanisms with the stated cosmological dependence, including post-QCD survival selection where specified. Twin-sector symmetries, finite θ-shift gauging and membrane-connected vacuum proposals do not inherit one common history or survival rule. Absence of ordinary PQ relaxation does not mean absence of pseudoscalars. Cosmological survival and ultraviolet consistency remain distinct, and descriptive targets do not establish quantitative viability.","evidenceIds":["unit:0c32a33c54d31bc5530aee8eb956fc37f460d8bfe2d5570552faa29d151155c8","unit:312a9a4d4e3e24cb6657e6c75633b52bcb2189c08482bd0106ce36b33c2216aa","unit:4cde5b843bb004bffff5630b1e931a9f8fe805102d8d34f0d5232b69ac9083b4","unit:5ff9b964b571d3f5ea8d90e65d7524222a279df3f04826cd24bd8e8e3b05be82","unit:7170ba545bc5f690fe31b7df10a8b0227ed0ccda30421f1a3b9299be97a0566d","unit:71d64413f10c18cf972d71f6ce6fe855c61223bbe038ef70d63b20518cea4d97","unit:a1dfa3ec012ffdeb423936da17a39fcb830071feb103bc400d21d80e8af9e12a","unit:afd038b4aa13f81ffdf5104d91395c034d4127c9863ada767150874e1d32ebad","unit:ca8a72a872dfb6f074d6f74ac654a5b5ac81e91d94a38bb0fc26b6b701a351e9","unit:d170103ccdde9de915914a7e86e924885b46a1640bb448be4619ec6a780eacbc","unit:e580623e54876298225afd9606c98bbe29e807ba983dc3a4cae75fdaa6b080f4","unit:e921d7aeaac23e7fa0d42ca275418513603a298ecbea027f146afefa8054d426"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:610431eba8395e885b1678e7","scopeContentSha256":"d07a3f8f0ad6f0c4290d4dc6a794f96df9754eda471157c295eea33096c242de","localRef":"s19"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293","scopeContentSha256":"c4903abecff98423063ad9334a6b25fefdbf71aec3b2202355433d52556d17a2","localRef":"s9"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l6","originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:32","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l6","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:32","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:610431eba8395e885b1678e7","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l6","source":"s19","target":"s9","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Selection and alternative vacuum mechanisms retain their particular cosmological epochs and survival conditions."],"challengeStatement":"Selection and alternative vacuum mechanisms retain their particular epochs and survival conditions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8837533292ba2dc050c09c0f4b04af5d04bacdf1ab973652f26afeac5ab375e1","reply.jsonSha256":"c4da9c37362a39ccb4319f60c4983a440a50a7fded2dbcd384cf07779ef43ba4","reply.raw.txtSha256":"579facbd28ff0cfc08d1f878e55b88a06ebb4422a57589f5577d498e574a43d7","receipt.jsonSha256":"3aa4184cf3ab982b9de218ea326aa5015b854135a6d0a36f719e7fc5d64ffe1a","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7fcdf1f23896f5ae47612e73b6d7804e5ec8667ff11aa2c9d1390d566971293","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"16ccc8f6866b12f72f1cc5bdec200a43d888fd66bdaca563ec623b1b61f881f6"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"172478274c8c6cefae0e46d485d373db74d6ed2e6d67121d0fe60c3553fe8561","reply.jsonSha256":"e4a601e983ad12fb24ac06650339f91a7cb408d1ad0059709c0a71399daf1643","reply.raw.txtSha256":"633b874344705a2d8539b45abb792739f8caf36c5fe116ee81cf82c41bb84161","receipt.jsonSha256":"66ce2c23b3c076188e34e5a95afec015e72e192e7a489859d2d316c4fa3f930c","normalization.jsonSha256":"89c6ce8e7cd2a821fb72347a5e003a2ab62093e88672faf6fa2d440db3279915"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:610431eba8395e885b1678e7"},{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:610431eba8395e885b1678e7"},{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:38d03abef262e57a7923f293"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d6","originalRef":"l6","status":"route","source":"s19","target":"s9","type":"premise_check","title":"Check the epoch and survival conditions of cosmological selection proposals","rationale":"Both statements emphasize the particular cosmological epochs and survival conditions of selection and alternative vacuum mechanisms. For mechanisms that depend on those conditions, the construction question points to their cosmological assessment.","qualification":"Restrict the check to mechanisms with the stated cosmological dependence, including post-QCD survival selection where specified. Twin-sector symmetries, finite θ-shift gauging and membrane-connected vacuum proposals do not inherit one common history or survival rule. Absence of ordinary PQ relaxation does not mean absence of pseudoscalars. Cosmological survival and ultraviolet consistency remain distinct, and descriptive targets do not establish quantitative viability.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l6","s19","s9"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The paired reasoning makes epochs and survival conditions relevant to the specified selection mechanisms. A construction-to-premise-check route therefore fits the cosmologically dependent subset. The qualification correctly prevents post-QCD survival assumptions from becoming common requirements of twin-sector, finite-shift or membrane-connected alternatives.","refs":["l6","s19","s9"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l7":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l7","source":"q025-candidate-question:422a6eebdb12ac8c42882dde","target":"q025-candidate-question:c1f9aa1a4410c9c93d81aad4","type":"method_for","title":"Diagnose physical CP and θ in QCD vacuum descriptions","rationale":"Both statements assign the methodological role to physical-phase and θ diagnostics. These diagnostics help interpret the vacuum descriptions, requiring reversal of the original order.","qualification":"Retain each framework's symmetry definitions, finite-UV-θ setting and specified infrared boundary conditions. Apparent phases, vacuum phases and physical CP observables are distinct; a bulk axion boundary value is not automatically an observable. Confinement and chiral-symmetry-breaking assumptions remain local to their EFTs. The route does not turn generic flavor diagnostics into a strong-CP solution or gravitational proposals into a theorem requiring an axion.","evidenceIds":["unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","unit:0f96a5852aff55abbd95eb199e168884ca2d8073f78fb8708a2e3ded100d86ab","unit:336b8beff535c077d7ab5e80a1adaa7cad6afd01054c276acc9fbd33a670ce3d","unit:3fa3ffacdda011675f2a9c4498432fd109da3b2fd8fc2241787b8fb48ab4ad8a","unit:4cde5b843bb004bffff5630b1e931a9f8fe805102d8d34f0d5232b69ac9083b4","unit:65fbef6e6d197bce501609c74219b2787d2c217cacc64b73b09a785f11a95152","unit:718f2fe192efa2c71951225fc84eef4bab93c3a10fe7c360db9069f20431da2e","unit:845542f00280705c18af63dc207c59ce54a84edb0a31e06689a155d8c3a43796","unit:a63a27f10d1c0057c1f5fd3b1f62a372aab840c4c1c33921b7d2b7a0999bc991","unit:ac37a74b422c65cc41e8ddd0032c4ad51eb638d6dec3095110d7c615268fa418","unit:afd038b4aa13f81ffdf5104d91395c034d4127c9863ada767150874e1d32ebad","unit:cb4ac5608c9cb467097ef87150febf2cc551ccc903f3fde3165905f0656d2aa7","unit:d6ddffb8dbf3b312b310b5aadec096cc6c16afadeaf1a67d9225e52aa6a43ff9","unit:ea21e552d29a9967e2ce15db21824d7ca60772672971bbc9b9de185b7cccc682","unit:f30a09f54c06fdb8108af52bfa0152b3e5f4867ffe83b89f3e39ff9352ee836b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:422a6eebdb12ac8c42882dde","scopeContentSha256":"7c275d20aae3ae571b785216c2c782c5dea21cdd0b4af18553e812e66f7aad97","localRef":"s11"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c1f9aa1a4410c9c93d81aad4","scopeContentSha256":"de8436039b543b23fa27163a783f372ebdd4c3221e9491efc58205e3e844ea3b","localRef":"s37"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l7","originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:41","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l7","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:41","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c1f9aa1a4410c9c93d81aad4","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:422a6eebdb12ac8c42882dde","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l7","source":"s37","target":"s11","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Physical-phase and theta diagnostics help interpret vacuum descriptions while retaining framework-specific boundary conditions."],"challengeStatement":"Physical-phase and theta diagnostics provide interpretation methods with framework-specific boundary conditions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8837533292ba2dc050c09c0f4b04af5d04bacdf1ab973652f26afeac5ab375e1","reply.jsonSha256":"c4da9c37362a39ccb4319f60c4983a440a50a7fded2dbcd384cf07779ef43ba4","reply.raw.txtSha256":"579facbd28ff0cfc08d1f878e55b88a06ebb4422a57589f5577d498e574a43d7","receipt.jsonSha256":"3aa4184cf3ab982b9de218ea326aa5015b854135a6d0a36f719e7fc5d64ffe1a","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7fcdf1f23896f5ae47612e73b6d7804e5ec8667ff11aa2c9d1390d566971293","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"16ccc8f6866b12f72f1cc5bdec200a43d888fd66bdaca563ec623b1b61f881f6"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"172478274c8c6cefae0e46d485d373db74d6ed2e6d67121d0fe60c3553fe8561","reply.jsonSha256":"e4a601e983ad12fb24ac06650339f91a7cb408d1ad0059709c0a71399daf1643","reply.raw.txtSha256":"633b874344705a2d8539b45abb792739f8caf36c5fe116ee81cf82c41bb84161","receipt.jsonSha256":"66ce2c23b3c076188e34e5a95afec015e72e192e7a489859d2d316c4fa3f930c","normalization.jsonSha256":"89c6ce8e7cd2a821fb72347a5e003a2ab62093e88672faf6fa2d440db3279915"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c1f9aa1a4410c9c93d81aad4"},{"ref":"x2_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:422a6eebdb12ac8c42882dde"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c1f9aa1a4410c9c93d81aad4"},{"ref":"x2_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:422a6eebdb12ac8c42882dde"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d7","originalRef":"l7","status":"route","source":"s11","target":"s37","type":"method_for","title":"Diagnose physical CP and θ in QCD vacuum descriptions","rationale":"Both statements assign the methodological role to physical-phase and θ diagnostics. These diagnostics help interpret the vacuum descriptions, requiring reversal of the original order.","qualification":"Retain each framework's symmetry definitions, finite-UV-θ setting and specified infrared boundary conditions. Apparent phases, vacuum phases and physical CP observables are distinct; a bulk axion boundary value is not automatically an observable. Confinement and chiral-symmetry-breaking assumptions remain local to their EFTs. The route does not turn generic flavor diagnostics into a strong-CP solution or gravitational proposals into a theorem requiring an axion.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l7","s11","s37"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements assign the methodological role to physical-phase and θ diagnostics, requiring the reversal to s11 → s37. The qualification preserves framework-specific boundary conditions, symmetry definitions and EFT assumptions without promoting adjacent CP diagnostics or gravitational proposals into strong-CP solutions or general theorems.","refs":["l7","s11","s37"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l8":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l8","source":"q025-candidate-question:4ca8af281c0fb323be7579ab","target":"q025-candidate-question:a769109135269dac501c8430","type":"method_for","title":"Test PBH population viability with Hawking-radiation searches and bounds","rationale":"The paired statements describe Hawking-radiation bounds and searches as tests of specified PBH populations. This is a method for assessing population viability, without identifying a formation mechanism.","qualification":"Keep masses, spins, mass functions, evaporation histories, emission, propagation, deposition, backgrounds, sky selection and observational dates specific to each analysis. Initial abundance and present dark-matter fraction are different quantities, and monochromatic limits do not automatically constrain an extended distribution in the same way. Bounds and proposed signal explanations require separate assessments. No universal production mechanism, common likelihood, current allowed mass window or observational ranking follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:034693c97fff26cada7d869d256ca9df45b52d95b34b2b6c45d686b77bafcee9","unit:0b1e52ed812ac1c6407c35252bf4fc4a19c1a8e1c3622d1e87cf6b67fc9773f7","unit:1a6d48cc0e9e67a40005cf1b398e5392b8bc0e073b5e424bf2b4d197a0676394","unit:262e7e604d44510e9353c51437e51ac6f15776d4f9ebe8ba60ddb6814effdf0a","unit:2b1592c8aed650149bea9d6095a344d63570e40a6cb2b11fea1f1cb19230e837","unit:2e823459353e61e2b0bda4815aa646b0477960f26f9ca96ec50f36fa788b1a99","unit:32d480093c8420b79b6b2acc9e86aa981afc12b47a4bd68af86fff9fadc4a270","unit:3384a059406ed760dd77ca728dfcfcc8226327266ab2fba6d9068069280784e4","unit:3ec858943221ec2ed1306e5570dd6996b575708450fd9abb06c3233022c0efde","unit:4c8fc2531cf27ddcee3ed14f4fb5dfe443b6ea61e1434bcc1eca0d6b82aa58a0","unit:5934d82041e931be9e900c6051678de3d0a38fd6548a0a5a75502a7fe2f59c6b","unit:5aa24b970df1e09eb2f838d7ec6421aef76e5ed0f0b7d6e1d208ccfeb5682634","unit:6c1ccb8a4554cd004a13f5ea3fd9df5ecc2d8dbb2097fc23e0cc79925f2d2d62","unit:6df39bcb6b52192e783e45e332d170619d74452ddfa32f036f52c1457ca2c8e1","unit:7291bf9c51ee3ff5ac13accc9f9d6a2aa037f9b774b1f12b2034fde11b02f2bd","unit:7c6297a04edc0fea048168f43d81f5d7f3433b4552886c2189186f699fc7ea5f","unit:7f5d2e2972725556842d972fb2a0683fe27d174c4378f7c81eaf1c8d28e4a72a","unit:af81e296b41f72f2c8685e58dc48fe9efbd11afe0a67af60c61643252c8c8fe1","unit:bcc6bfb083cb6ee371871bffebf1a269b65a0d96b7be7a1f77a4685c7f18e911","unit:c860ece91f178ef3fa54dfd58e1a108defc5877191ab40b901f0efddbdcd2dd6","unit:ce8b0ef70dc9740652201c03aef96b61e49078405f84caa61eaff6f4ab28d2b6","unit:e2a73c5a63d5ec55fd905cb39514430c68df1bd7aa3a2d3394d2fe7e419d4905","unit:e938130dc5f7e49e501bbf1b305e66b4b84b4b65660c7551c20724d533c64d5a","unit:ef90cd39fe7bc8516efdee7afb55725852f1503cf8c64c289d9372ce731ef253","unit:f21bcf6117aeb09d9860eccd259ce184cb36adbb1d0bcaa6798c0c9a0fe23b46"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4ca8af281c0fb323be7579ab","scopeContentSha256":"4ac07dcef49fbb6148785b8f1f754f04c635f2f79c78572f163d38301188c319","localRef":"s15"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a769109135269dac501c8430","scopeContentSha256":"c9cb949c6c1159be655c6ceb607101735b7f9ab2b1e03a7057d6a018437b8ac0","localRef":"s32"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l8","originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:36","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l8","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:36","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:a769109135269dac501c8430","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:4ca8af281c0fb323be7579ab","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l8","source":"s32","target":"s15","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Hawking-radiation searches and bounds test specified PBH populations without fixing a universal formation mechanism."],"challengeStatement":"Hawking-radiation bounds and searches test specified PBH populations without fixing their formation mechanism.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4f88767e140ec911d98ed96cf88d5c80635315d2851f3cd9852ded3be8a0a32d","reply.jsonSha256":"5cae2d296c2312029b6035542eff38fa4f55426587c75161c4fc2c3daf3bbda0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c6c90479f85a502c579e840a4b793e77ec8cb627f84afcf18093558075f3ef53","receipt.jsonSha256":"6ebcdc203daebaca976bd1b819b42105b45f28dbd69c90e3c542386ec01b51ba","normalization.jsonSha256":"ad796afb2ffc10d1f869f0722aff8b560f1e6d4e9437973b922c4a52844fb6e4","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a50a2e796b56f03366769c25357d3bc10a23c6541736b8db4df955ac10e4c3b3"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"96dd7cead2cd66e8dd66af6c8b3e11240e64deb848d05deb23d3178ac1955128","reply.jsonSha256":"a577a7095f0e8b3b0adb6a918afc65ecfde89d0ca82623d9f65ee7caefac275e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f56614a666546960c8d32938e3d0d5e73f0227385870adf8071a35d79b0f57b6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4f7641c188a2eb2a2273ac4156762fc7ee454d1cfee615c39072949beddc3ef4","normalization.jsonSha256":"daa65bd672d3ee84971d3c6c9a70438709e8b57ad333470542b2f6494348fab2"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a769109135269dac501c8430"},{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4ca8af281c0fb323be7579ab"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"1906.04858","sourceId":"ev:1f1434d9d2cbd15930fc26fea60dc807","sourceSha256":"c38d318ee524d5e3610875e9005b8c5a441faae234f502a96149e4b3c043a72b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fef2c18101fd8d0ea76e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9e29b91ea99be6f579c692a3df0677979749ef7e7d35bae8b879cdb6dc6d3a7d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"ca482e523fb3c934b13e36c4d2d7a3c4c376a55aafbcb508c7e244d1de68fda5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a769109135269dac501c8430"},{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4ca8af281c0fb323be7579ab"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"1906.04858","sourceId":"ev:1f1434d9d2cbd15930fc26fea60dc807","sourceSha256":"c38d318ee524d5e3610875e9005b8c5a441faae234f502a96149e4b3c043a72b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fef2c18101fd8d0ea76e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9e29b91ea99be6f579c692a3df0677979749ef7e7d35bae8b879cdb6dc6d3a7d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"ca482e523fb3c934b13e36c4d2d7a3c4c376a55aafbcb508c7e244d1de68fda5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d8","originalRef":"l8","status":"route","source":"s15","target":"s32","type":"method_for","title":"Test PBH population viability with Hawking-radiation searches and bounds","rationale":"The paired statements describe Hawking-radiation bounds and searches as tests of specified PBH populations. This is a method for assessing population viability, without identifying a formation mechanism.","qualification":"Keep masses, spins, mass functions, evaporation histories, emission, propagation, deposition, backgrounds, sky selection and observational dates specific to each analysis. Initial abundance and present dark-matter fraction are different quantities, and monochromatic limits do not automatically constrain an extended distribution in the same way. Bounds and proposed signal explanations require separate assessments. No universal production mechanism, common likelihood, current allowed mass window or observational ranking follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l8","s15","s32"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original statements describe Hawking-radiation searches and bounds as tests of specified PBH populations. method_for from s15 to s32 captures that role more precisely than a formation-based application claim. The qualification retains population, emission, observational and statistical assumptions, including the distinction between initial abundance and present dark-matter fraction.","refs":["l8","s15","s32"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l9":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l9","source":"q025-candidate-question:79cdd7041ac53955427403ad","target":"q025-candidate-question:8ef08a9130a21c0a99c7e8f0","type":"method_for","title":"Assess weak-gravity proposals through specified RG and extremality methods","rationale":"Both statements place correction comparisons, fixed-point studies and running-coupling extremality on the method side of the connection. They are distinct possible approaches to weak-gravity questions, requiring reversal.","qualification":"These are proposed, source-specific tests or support, not a universal derivation. An RG consistency bound is not identified with electric or magnetic WGC without an argument. Retain operator basis, vector multiplicity, gravitational gauge, truncation and scale-setting choices. The 2007 black-hole proposal uses k(r)=ξ/r, a small-running-coefficient expansion and dimensions above three. Genuine charged gauge sectors, WGC variants and source normalizations remain distinct; the supplied record does not verify beta functions, fixed points or corrected solutions.","evidenceIds":["unit:097a902af1281472e8d9698d4cc73193bb1b6229b5aea37d468d4467aef97064","unit:0990a200d33a33fa99eb45c65901c34a1a6703e14ede6723e0eb39c062d425f6","unit:1ff7f6392b4a2da426bc8d08ad8751e1de63966590da3fcd4a666000440db4b6","unit:3e0dfd42eaa7412dc16d6da6608260849f41a8892613e5fc0fd3e98093359488","unit:5b1c5da5c9403c058990af40768c78dca1b01879d49bbfb8474dcab243bf785d","unit:6011ceb2ed90dc6db454978b6083de8fb7eb75dd87410e9bb721f44bea2c38d6","unit:730b77c2a0c59f134fc8a6ac479bab48646bb495b70ec181e731841033a417e9","unit:87a5f861f2149dfbd0e9982e6e9d3353cd53e982e3a9287c52ce21069456fa5e","unit:b302e962d78c38c66e4c7b6b748fceb724c9457299310651bfa90dc64ce4190a","unit:bcf394e3d32ea46c6ce42314dbd0cb6b5e8dbc081432d275c5b728f0fcea0231","unit:c79cce299637fc5cef4c311345edcf9db7c13ae8a77e9ef6a73d7fec974faf13","unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8","unit:e5dae392e32af1980633105a4ba8d88013b2ef3c57f4dd1f8e2029c79d0f7358","unit:ee7be266043df8890f674ddbcf4d9a80b54269b464c8135e6ad1598637a19dd0"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:79cdd7041ac53955427403ad","scopeContentSha256":"1a7ed0e144996f707264f2f42d45f5b8bc05dace46935450b641973363af96b9","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8ef08a9130a21c0a99c7e8f0","scopeContentSha256":"85f6564767509914832220ebba6295bbc776cfc5a38db0d645a91e2cceae7ee3","localRef":"s27"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l9","originalCandidateId":"parent-7463f8aa522ec140c676-challenge:link:23","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l9","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-7463f8aa522ec140c676-challenge:link:23","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:8ef08a9130a21c0a99c7e8f0","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:79cdd7041ac53955427403ad","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l9","source":"s27","target":"s22","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["RG correction comparisons, fixed-point studies and running-coupling extremality are distinct possible methods whose assumptions remain explicit."],"challengeStatement":"Correction comparisons, fixed-point studies and running-coupling extremality are distinct methods with separate assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-7463f8aa522ec140c676-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7463f8aa522ec140c676-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4dbfb2e82dd11db7de0ec4a1ee24f39e9aacbeece749bc274c7994990f137bd3","reply.jsonSha256":"dc8fc59d6e05de8feed93fc70b1abb196a6b3cc7fc08824e23e9f30cb959cb22","reply.raw.txtSha256":"e5bdc20de16ccde6e3907afcccce94cc8bb0f1782c0d12e41d8c72423aceec96","receipt.jsonSha256":"4ac60e90d5bb5c4279287fa81766735a2b384a1850cf9d7fee0215eb305fac79","normalization.jsonSha256":"5f98230ac260913f25958886bc823f8b8a25bc7b507d59c25bf29a36df600f93","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7463f8aa522ec140c676-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"0397df6f8ac00add2aa4fe963436a27913f09a4f8ab68eb1e3738cfb8d957ef5"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7463f8aa522ec140c676-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"19b2e1f2f619ab05be27f032a446a376b9375ee7e6974644c748e2aa99af8876","reply.jsonSha256":"a403e427769f31baed1a08dba46230bac727e2d1bc958527b2a88b20f1d0559e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"95184cfc034ffcd64521da02439f63093a7e99cce99a5ddf19e051fbb4b5bb94","receipt.jsonSha256":"959f63693f78b79f3060e9d759bf92f23d7f1a2a765cfea043dab2e281ad3abf","normalization.jsonSha256":"379ab41c189ac62b8a06d645313dbdffb032635bf370e53e66e2dbd5fc60fe11"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:79cdd7041ac53955427403ad"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0703039","sourceId":"ev:4db2b9134220b4774d5f85f7a0ab57dc","sourceSha256":"554bea99470e0143cae3eb7866786dc44953f70d1045c1d276a67e3b5c3dd270","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4b8180188f85b71aefc3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce22010bf5201e07516cfdf3512fff01e0ac06c3fa7469c9774c1054577a127a","pdfPage":2,"start":101,"end":2723,"textSha256":"2e3f3ad283e25e2e6b0043986ff9852e2b40080552eeea9044416a04cd7ed331","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0703039","sourceId":"ev:a53a496ec0a8b5f911e675114bfa17a7","sourceSha256":"554bea99470e0143cae3eb7866786dc44953f70d1045c1d276a67e3b5c3dd270","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4b8180188f85b71aefc3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce22010bf5201e07516cfdf3512fff01e0ac06c3fa7469c9774c1054577a127a","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":621,"textSha256":"d56a52ec14bbe1032324a3adea6a744c7fb8b6e53aa732f2854e31ce27965733","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:79cdd7041ac53955427403ad"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0703039","sourceId":"ev:4db2b9134220b4774d5f85f7a0ab57dc","sourceSha256":"554bea99470e0143cae3eb7866786dc44953f70d1045c1d276a67e3b5c3dd270","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4b8180188f85b71aefc3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce22010bf5201e07516cfdf3512fff01e0ac06c3fa7469c9774c1054577a127a","pdfPage":2,"start":101,"end":2723,"textSha256":"2e3f3ad283e25e2e6b0043986ff9852e2b40080552eeea9044416a04cd7ed331","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0703039","sourceId":"ev:a53a496ec0a8b5f911e675114bfa17a7","sourceSha256":"554bea99470e0143cae3eb7866786dc44953f70d1045c1d276a67e3b5c3dd270","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4b8180188f85b71aefc3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce22010bf5201e07516cfdf3512fff01e0ac06c3fa7469c9774c1054577a127a","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":621,"textSha256":"d56a52ec14bbe1032324a3adea6a744c7fb8b6e53aa732f2854e31ce27965733","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d9","originalRef":"l9","status":"route","source":"s22","target":"s27","type":"method_for","title":"Assess weak-gravity proposals through specified RG and extremality methods","rationale":"Both statements place correction comparisons, fixed-point studies and running-coupling extremality on the method side of the connection. They are distinct possible approaches to weak-gravity questions, requiring reversal.","qualification":"These are proposed, source-specific tests or support, not a universal derivation. An RG consistency bound is not identified with electric or magnetic WGC without an argument. Retain operator basis, vector multiplicity, gravitational gauge, truncation and scale-setting choices. The 2007 black-hole proposal uses k(r)=ξ/r, a small-running-coefficient expansion and dimensions above three. Genuine charged gauge sectors, WGC variants and source normalizations remain distinct; the supplied record does not verify beta functions, fixed points or corrected solutions.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l9","s22","s27"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d9","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Correction comparisons, fixed-point studies and running-coupling extremality supply the proposed methods, so s22 → s27 is correctly oriented. The qualification preserves their separate assumptions, the stated scale setting and dimensional restriction, and the need for an argument before identifying an RG consistency bound with a gauge-WGC variant.","refs":["l9","s22","s27"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l10":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l10","source":"q025-candidate-question:309d19630875eb09f9d9148c","target":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1","type":"method_for","title":"Use correction estimates and robustness tests to assess effective-theory control","rationale":"Both statements identify correction estimates and robustness tests as inputs to control assessments. The correction-analysis question supplies the method.","qualification":"Retain the calculation's geometry, finite-volume expansion, perturbative order and correction scheme. Genuine loops, local α′ operators and classical warping are distinct; small coefficients and cancellations are not assumed. BHP remains conjectural rather than a universal formula. Historical 2013 GSW-dependent bounds retain their dated premises, with no later validation or invalidation supplied. Results do not transfer automatically between correction schemes or establish that an assumed heavy spectator is dynamically stabilized.","evidenceIds":["unit:035e6383b6602a31cda9d39b845fd6ad6e713d9cf5b894a5da154decc1eae8fd","unit:037a24e1c2d1f0436bc5ca0765a902ef9fe98be0050092ec7779bd218aecb3d3","unit:12e88a8cc2e681c53234ab6a048049585088143cab8f7f5b2a631956778ed071","unit:2157941f5fec83ab75131c70492654cfa86ff8d4483b2b0f6dcca1556b1c8e6c","unit:3d134c341958ad24e671679aceeecb2b229bed67cd0b6cfdb5da3a45d1585884","unit:46fdbb1003d0cb8c25a4c56b529ea26ee11ff0982d6012790950705feff0b8ea","unit:54e45270b6b801b6fc1f4b8d66c0b1199ba7829900b35ee010ff2341fa8c2e18","unit:554e94d245c3f0a043125d575adfd9fbf669b91f5739612587a20fb594981940","unit:5b3e5844a36b8dd1b031cb12cf4e1850134794649b37f1bff5f9c4e3f627766a","unit:5d7c2a067e17ef7fe266482f87065fb4baeb3d602913fce0b4a733e8da194019","unit:6ee488fc13d12e7ac4299cd225d1d2b579c68b57264085164ff070bd115293c2","unit:6f9c3ff25194aff40f9858d71f86b80971fa25874c53a6e7faac52d1c0674c18","unit:8421bc4e41d05a094540e2333bd07758baa2ea1999971d7ab4ebe12e917c39c9","unit:8d97447c2b609f272cd9def253a662b73ffe66c32eb0fce9f9e0193cee6aa5be","unit:9937bc7616f1f64232954890f96ca53fd375dc253b5905a643f003a977cd8256","unit:9cad95c7327a144b2faf96639e08b032a1fe809528e17112c134e495e1f50b7b","unit:9f9f096f1e34a20b3c061ee327cba575c7ecc417b32526ee26b7beaf5b52e0ed","unit:a6fdc088777825f2faab7cf11a6a552885e76f5728a6c8f85eab8e7be73f9836","unit:ac833f8a2f16c94da090aea819f0f62d4bb59337f7e6789791dbf86698634146","unit:be95f5e9be6caeb6ac1adcb05e027537abcc104c71fce3cacc23ab259b747f06","unit:cad8603be5dc26b86428a24c17a30b0a35a404e30be6e35d7be29c58f009e164","unit:d20d204b3df78bf7deab1821cb1fe942c83b9107d82c3bcefd068e3f3ccf7911","unit:daa28791b6c6c157d2d2bf9abfdadc55c0b7e8c8698ea642c53aa4f354dcc564","unit:defaa5c4ce92ca99501947b2ca3e30fed424ca586d6bf4386548b382b0c3054c","unit:e9362c7181aba7a4e90c7028995e6dd5eacd74775c411aa08dbc042e69db69ac","unit:ec77f9da6d36e8fa2334538aca0f9cfdb0e9ecdd2a5828d4dcc254f6dd29d3ba","unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","unit:ee776397e6f080e4c136326b72d80f8f0fc4b840008d919efa189f74bac3482b","unit:f15c1b302895bc0228e7e9a2c86a387140cc22abfce4085a8941cc9b9a80368a","unit:fbe9599596133d1205330dc4f7a583dd1476dbc3997221476c8830eab4f9dc33"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:309d19630875eb09f9d9148c","scopeContentSha256":"8db7b79237c8325206308c3ae7fce540db2639c777cedf060e187e1560b90dd9","localRef":"s8"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1","scopeContentSha256":"10a4e7e7734e47a61979bf33e945f28e1d47ba92237712102852414c91b49856","localRef":"s20"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l10","originalCandidateId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge:link:25","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l10","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge:link:25","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:309d19630875eb09f9d9148c","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l10","source":"s20","target":"s8","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Correction estimates and robustness tests inform control while retaining calculation-specific assumptions."],"challengeStatement":"Correction estimates and robustness tests inform control while retaining calculation-specific assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"131630606abe5e685d4f482c31dbf108eb3c089557aa1767a14f5558e26c7d1a","reply.jsonSha256":"f289006fa1d21bc2e56706aaee31fca5b72c9200d2f69bb1ce803c6586811163","reply.raw.txtSha256":"06bc13b86ad5f081206300276fe54e7905838cbcd5e07e258f250d0653d58d46","receipt.jsonSha256":"efc647c4343d9ff237ba8345051a6dad746e904fed3f31c1a0f07e44a6bf7dd5","normalization.jsonSha256":"15bc44bd9635d55c267b4830aad253c598c0dc2dbc5d3c7f18f49c1fbe9a0f8f","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"843fb31a8154645c7f7487b754b3458f0033f1690cfbca733df381da6d512f3a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec52cc7db9d07efb8eff2523f41369d40988dfc1834866b49ee8da16c206193a","reply.jsonSha256":"3bc5fed164bc8d5b9fb2945acdb0e0b08b80d76dc1977dbd1adb2b65b405f353","reply.raw.txtSha256":"05d6084ab5a49d6844ce34298ad04fdceae55085699880fe94cf18ad2ba3a45d","receipt.jsonSha256":"e26f19694cf9ab164c4afc92ec86916e52e92a5211d21ab59348e16d401a6050","normalization.jsonSha256":"b742016defc4750e562f3bca62011dae9d3813ea2499d18f573140e04a337699"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1"},{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:309d19630875eb09f9d9148c"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"0708.1873","sourceId":"ev:6083998f9d4988ce1123618836170915","sourceSha256":"7ef322362242d74ced01a6ce25e508c4d6fefd54c916027d7c5199ecd1628324","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/43d6174a51ebc3b95a66/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"83dc9d555027c67e3ce4faccd1de3bd8cff2cb8d29083045d81a21388bfd1d7b","pdfPage":31,"start":0,"end":2736,"textSha256":"fa40d8a21272015862879b26ceda9be86073627915f09041cbeeb06209a1e137","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1"},{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:309d19630875eb09f9d9148c"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"0708.1873","sourceId":"ev:6083998f9d4988ce1123618836170915","sourceSha256":"7ef322362242d74ced01a6ce25e508c4d6fefd54c916027d7c5199ecd1628324","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/43d6174a51ebc3b95a66/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"83dc9d555027c67e3ce4faccd1de3bd8cff2cb8d29083045d81a21388bfd1d7b","pdfPage":31,"start":0,"end":2736,"textSha256":"fa40d8a21272015862879b26ceda9be86073627915f09041cbeeb06209a1e137","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d10","originalRef":"l10","status":"route","source":"s8","target":"s20","type":"method_for","title":"Use correction estimates and robustness tests to assess effective-theory control","rationale":"Both statements identify correction estimates and robustness tests as inputs to control assessments. The correction-analysis question supplies the method.","qualification":"Retain the calculation's geometry, finite-volume expansion, perturbative order and correction scheme. Genuine loops, local α′ operators and classical warping are distinct; small coefficients and cancellations are not assumed. BHP remains conjectural rather than a universal formula. Historical 2013 GSW-dependent bounds retain their dated premises, with no later validation or invalidation supplied. Results do not transfer automatically between correction schemes or establish that an assumed heavy spectator is dynamically stabilized.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l10","s8","s20"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d10","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements explicitly make correction estimates and robustness tests inputs to control assessments. The reversed method_for direction is supported. The qualification preserves geometry, expansion order and correction taxonomy, while retaining the conjectural BHP status and dated premises of the historical GSW-dependent bounds.","refs":["l10","s8","s20"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l10","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l11":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l11","source":"q025-candidate-question:39030fbb61dffeb1173be7c9","target":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1","type":"method_for","title":"Translate frames, units and normalizations for scale-based control tests","rationale":"The paired statements require explicit convention translation when comparing physical scales. The scale-and-convention question therefore provides methodological support for control assessments.","qualification":"Limit the route to the stated large-volume IIB scale comparisons and source-specific flux choices. Translate string and Einstein frames, length units, 2π factors and canonical volume normalization explicitly. Logarithmic canonical volume dependence does not establish an allowed stabilized trajectory. The 2005 gravitino-flux-independence statement remains a dated source claim, not a universal scaling law, and these conventions do not supply the dynamics of generic additional-field or uplift settings.","evidenceIds":["unit:035e6383b6602a31cda9d39b845fd6ad6e713d9cf5b894a5da154decc1eae8fd","unit:037a24e1c2d1f0436bc5ca0765a902ef9fe98be0050092ec7779bd218aecb3d3","unit:12e88a8cc2e681c53234ab6a048049585088143cab8f7f5b2a631956778ed071","unit:2157941f5fec83ab75131c70492654cfa86ff8d4483b2b0f6dcca1556b1c8e6c","unit:3d134c341958ad24e671679aceeecb2b229bed67cd0b6cfdb5da3a45d1585884","unit:46fdbb1003d0cb8c25a4c56b529ea26ee11ff0982d6012790950705feff0b8ea","unit:54b4aa3a55c1d040f3dd81d4f74aa30fc931cb68d612329214d9122b55cb35c4","unit:54e45270b6b801b6fc1f4b8d66c0b1199ba7829900b35ee010ff2341fa8c2e18","unit:554e94d245c3f0a043125d575adfd9fbf669b91f5739612587a20fb594981940","unit:5b3e5844a36b8dd1b031cb12cf4e1850134794649b37f1bff5f9c4e3f627766a","unit:5d7c2a067e17ef7fe266482f87065fb4baeb3d602913fce0b4a733e8da194019","unit:6f9c3ff25194aff40f9858d71f86b80971fa25874c53a6e7faac52d1c0674c18","unit:8421bc4e41d05a094540e2333bd07758baa2ea1999971d7ab4ebe12e917c39c9","unit:8443dd496835a26133210ab9fdd8fd6b622bb73bbfae465d903f31b9e88063e7","unit:8d97447c2b609f272cd9def253a662b73ffe66c32eb0fce9f9e0193cee6aa5be","unit:9937bc7616f1f64232954890f96ca53fd375dc253b5905a643f003a977cd8256","unit:9f9f096f1e34a20b3c061ee327cba575c7ecc417b32526ee26b7beaf5b52e0ed","unit:be95f5e9be6caeb6ac1adcb05e027537abcc104c71fce3cacc23ab259b747f06","unit:ca01af2138e69abe18d84225e620bdf481d60abbd18695693fc57e58de21b027","unit:cad8603be5dc26b86428a24c17a30b0a35a404e30be6e35d7be29c58f009e164","unit:cffec71c27634c92762dc36df8812cd045d13c5e90620bef2500e717ffbcb24b","unit:daa28791b6c6c157d2d2bf9abfdadc55c0b7e8c8698ea642c53aa4f354dcc564","unit:defaa5c4ce92ca99501947b2ca3e30fed424ca586d6bf4386548b382b0c3054c","unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","unit:f15c1b302895bc0228e7e9a2c86a387140cc22abfce4085a8941cc9b9a80368a","unit:fbe9599596133d1205330dc4f7a583dd1476dbc3997221476c8830eab4f9dc33"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:39030fbb61dffeb1173be7c9","scopeContentSha256":"17b4c044fb4a7b922918ea9885ee263f5f9a5658d4c86799389ac385cb3afff5","localRef":"s10"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1","scopeContentSha256":"10a4e7e7734e47a61979bf33e945f28e1d47ba92237712102852414c91b49856","localRef":"s20"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l11","originalCandidateId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge:link:27","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l11","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge:link:27","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:39030fbb61dffeb1173be7c9","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l11","source":"s20","target":"s10","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Frame, normalization and scale comparisons require explicit convention translation."],"challengeStatement":"Comparisons of physical scales require explicit frame, units and normalization choices.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","source_object"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"131630606abe5e685d4f482c31dbf108eb3c089557aa1767a14f5558e26c7d1a","reply.jsonSha256":"f289006fa1d21bc2e56706aaee31fca5b72c9200d2f69bb1ce803c6586811163","reply.raw.txtSha256":"06bc13b86ad5f081206300276fe54e7905838cbcd5e07e258f250d0653d58d46","receipt.jsonSha256":"efc647c4343d9ff237ba8345051a6dad746e904fed3f31c1a0f07e44a6bf7dd5","normalization.jsonSha256":"15bc44bd9635d55c267b4830aad253c598c0dc2dbc5d3c7f18f49c1fbe9a0f8f","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"843fb31a8154645c7f7487b754b3458f0033f1690cfbca733df381da6d512f3a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec52cc7db9d07efb8eff2523f41369d40988dfc1834866b49ee8da16c206193a","reply.jsonSha256":"3bc5fed164bc8d5b9fb2945acdb0e0b08b80d76dc1977dbd1adb2b65b405f353","reply.raw.txtSha256":"05d6084ab5a49d6844ce34298ad04fdceae55085699880fe94cf18ad2ba3a45d","receipt.jsonSha256":"e26f19694cf9ab164c4afc92ec86916e52e92a5211d21ab59348e16d401a6050","normalization.jsonSha256":"b742016defc4750e562f3bca62011dae9d3813ea2499d18f573140e04a337699"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1"},{"ref":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:39030fbb61dffeb1173be7c9"},{"ref":"o4","kind":"source_object","paperId":"0708.1873","sourceId":"obj:43d6174a51ebc3b95a66:convention:6ab6f3f53320f66060204a27"},{"ref":"o5","kind":"source_object","paperId":"0708.1873","sourceId":"obj:43d6174a51ebc3b95a66:convention:945ab686baf3395ecee01c36"},{"ref":"o6","kind":"source_object","paperId":"0708.1873","sourceId":"obj:43d6174a51ebc3b95a66:convention:d752e4f96e9e896efbd0af78"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1"},{"ref":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:39030fbb61dffeb1173be7c9"},{"ref":"o4","kind":"source_object","paperId":"0708.1873","sourceId":"obj:43d6174a51ebc3b95a66:convention:6ab6f3f53320f66060204a27"},{"ref":"o5","kind":"source_object","paperId":"0708.1873","sourceId":"obj:43d6174a51ebc3b95a66:convention:945ab686baf3395ecee01c36"},{"ref":"o6","kind":"source_object","paperId":"0708.1873","sourceId":"obj:43d6174a51ebc3b95a66:convention:d752e4f96e9e896efbd0af78"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d11","originalRef":"l11","status":"route","source":"s10","target":"s20","type":"method_for","title":"Translate frames, units and normalizations for scale-based control tests","rationale":"The paired statements require explicit convention translation when comparing physical scales. The scale-and-convention question therefore provides methodological support for control assessments.","qualification":"Limit the route to the stated large-volume IIB scale comparisons and source-specific flux choices. Translate string and Einstein frames, length units, 2π factors and canonical volume normalization explicitly. Logarithmic canonical volume dependence does not establish an allowed stabilized trajectory. The 2005 gravitino-flux-independence statement remains a dated source claim, not a universal scaling law, and these conventions do not supply the dynamics of generic additional-field or uplift settings.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l11","s10","s20"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d11","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Frame, unit and normalization translation supplies methodological support for scale-based control comparisons, supporting s10 → s20. The qualification confines the route to the stated large-volume IIB setting and correctly separates convention work from stabilization dynamics and universal flux-scaling claims.","refs":["l11","s10","s20"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l11","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l12":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l12","source":"q025-candidate-question:aec46cc75f48ea2203d606d7","target":"q025-candidate-question:220ee460807b8b403ee4cb11","type":"method_for","title":"Apply geometric obstructions and potential-construction methods to Kähler inflation","rationale":"Both statements identify geometric obstructions and potential-construction techniques as methods that constrain inflationary proposals. The geometric-method question therefore points to the Kähler-inflation question.","qualification":"Use the stated retained fields, Kähler geometry, superpotential and Hubble-to-gravitino hierarchy, keeping finite-field and asymptotic regimes separate. A Kähler-potential-only transformation is not a transformation of the full theory, and positive-energy rolling is not automatically slow-roll inflation. Seven-disk and open-string α constructions retain different derivations; an independently open-string-driven model is outside s6. These methods establish neither a global string embedding nor an inflationary trajectory from a stabilized vacuum alone.","evidenceIds":["unit:158a2ad6413453f511c3046fa31072b77369b69853e65a39380b51596a1facee","unit:1b3edcbe2b74ec5600fe2beeb7717436848fabc2d494a1fb402fcccbb27c633b","unit:2157941f5fec83ab75131c70492654cfa86ff8d4483b2b0f6dcca1556b1c8e6c","unit:24205a6ee9fb216dc671176ebdac19f8a9d00f4d6bb83a0478557073568d1fc4","unit:3267740f211252bd12f44b0c848cf418e59f929650f231d45f4371bc63b44ec4","unit:475f52efc2ffee32cb981c64439367d7079a76139d36487bf227dd80e1bcad35","unit:51c4c10eebfdbaf133ba0d3dba59bf60456327499f2d1c1f12d164f130da10f0","unit:5641146e0ca962589f35716c3f9a7ca25e4f65434801e4c504fc7277bc69f4ad","unit:6309d9a26b7115e14d73ee3a812c2e3eade54f07f0959c975fffda121aed6216","unit:6ee488fc13d12e7ac4299cd225d1d2b579c68b57264085164ff070bd115293c2","unit:ac833f8a2f16c94da090aea819f0f62d4bb59337f7e6789791dbf86698634146","unit:ae22a03c7cd13ae6f6506e8259a094ec2d3cb9041a62d88d1fe81d54ac8ac3a0","unit:aef6f68110d36c7cbbf7f1c2d09d0f9035c889487545833fbcd444d9a46ecbc7","unit:bd2f3d196e8aedee38ba9cb54f237b9aa855f4f97b71bcafe7982a00c4bcd45c","unit:c04efcb1f3b54d66911bebcde04b4d380033884baf6f5a7886397b068d364ffc","unit:d20d204b3df78bf7deab1821cb1fe942c83b9107d82c3bcefd068e3f3ccf7911","unit:d4b666d8d91606547b750fb8804ced4c4bd3ed8e3eeb467cf300541738369a4c","unit:e0ffd08609d236ca81207a108fe0989a50535d41d8a3cefa1573b5eab8be8817","unit:e9362c7181aba7a4e90c7028995e6dd5eacd74775c411aa08dbc042e69db69ac","unit:ec665714f947860ea4b9504d8b46d77f569af96193a59ffa0eabc4e802ee489e","unit:ec77f9da6d36e8fa2334538aca0f9cfdb0e9ecdd2a5828d4dcc254f6dd29d3ba","unit:f7a272359b6ffc0f0eac0447c129b90c6bc9ed93ea91280eb70e4e2ee399cfd4","unit:f99f7bf5f8c60b89408bc8c1b0adfdb96c577a2d8e02f6a67d19b1dfab159b71"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:aec46cc75f48ea2203d606d7","scopeContentSha256":"eb8eb70eb618258d25f17e982042623816ce8e60405f437ab5686e21ca23be0c","localRef":"s33"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:220ee460807b8b403ee4cb11","scopeContentSha256":"b81a4258adadb2e10d11c753ed1fef6a49a986a31ff3eaf1a06b61f94c224044","localRef":"s6"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l12","originalCandidateId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge:link:35","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l12","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge:link:35","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:220ee460807b8b403ee4cb11","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:aec46cc75f48ea2203d606d7","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l12","source":"s6","target":"s33","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Geometric obstructions and potential-construction methods constrain inflationary proposals without certifying a global embedding."],"challengeStatement":"Geometric obstructions and potential-construction methods constrain inflationary proposals without establishing global embeddings.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"131630606abe5e685d4f482c31dbf108eb3c089557aa1767a14f5558e26c7d1a","reply.jsonSha256":"f289006fa1d21bc2e56706aaee31fca5b72c9200d2f69bb1ce803c6586811163","reply.raw.txtSha256":"06bc13b86ad5f081206300276fe54e7905838cbcd5e07e258f250d0653d58d46","receipt.jsonSha256":"efc647c4343d9ff237ba8345051a6dad746e904fed3f31c1a0f07e44a6bf7dd5","normalization.jsonSha256":"15bc44bd9635d55c267b4830aad253c598c0dc2dbc5d3c7f18f49c1fbe9a0f8f","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"843fb31a8154645c7f7487b754b3458f0033f1690cfbca733df381da6d512f3a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec52cc7db9d07efb8eff2523f41369d40988dfc1834866b49ee8da16c206193a","reply.jsonSha256":"3bc5fed164bc8d5b9fb2945acdb0e0b08b80d76dc1977dbd1adb2b65b405f353","reply.raw.txtSha256":"05d6084ab5a49d6844ce34298ad04fdceae55085699880fe94cf18ad2ba3a45d","receipt.jsonSha256":"e26f19694cf9ab164c4afc92ec86916e52e92a5211d21ab59348e16d401a6050","normalization.jsonSha256":"b742016defc4750e562f3bca62011dae9d3813ea2499d18f573140e04a337699"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:220ee460807b8b403ee4cb11"},{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:aec46cc75f48ea2203d606d7"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:220ee460807b8b403ee4cb11"},{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:aec46cc75f48ea2203d606d7"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d12","originalRef":"l12","status":"route","source":"s33","target":"s6","type":"method_for","title":"Apply geometric obstructions and potential-construction methods to Kähler inflation","rationale":"Both statements identify geometric obstructions and potential-construction techniques as methods that constrain inflationary proposals. The geometric-method question therefore points to the Kähler-inflation question.","qualification":"Use the stated retained fields, Kähler geometry, superpotential and Hubble-to-gravitino hierarchy, keeping finite-field and asymptotic regimes separate. A Kähler-potential-only transformation is not a transformation of the full theory, and positive-energy rolling is not automatically slow-roll inflation. Seven-disk and open-string α constructions retain different derivations; an independently open-string-driven model is outside s6. These methods establish neither a global string embedding nor an inflationary trajectory from a stabilized vacuum alone.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l12","s33","s6"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d12","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The paired statements identify geometric obstructions and potential-construction methods as tools for assessing inflationary proposals. The reversed method_for direction is supported. The qualification preserves retained-field, superpotential and regime assumptions and excludes independently open-string-driven inflation from the Kähler-moduli target.","refs":["l12","s33","s6"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l12","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l13":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l13","source":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce","target":"q025-candidate-question:e920a374a251ab3ab789fcfa","type":"method_for","title":"Use conditional entropy diagnostics to assess horizon-entropy accounting","rationale":"The challenge statement assigns entropy principles an interpretive role in entropy accounting, consistent with the proposal's connection to diagnostics. This supports a methodological direction from principles to accounting while preserving the distinction between entropy reproduction and bound justification.","qualification":"The method is an assessment of assumptions, not a universal microscopic counting prescription. Quantum matter can invalidate classical energy-condition reasoning, and positive cosmological constant alone does not ensure bounded observable entropy. JT, restricted focusing and small-acceleration results retain their domains; the 2002 survey's D=4 and Planck-unit conventions remain explicit when used. Each microscopic dictionary retains its regulators, replica limits and normalization choices. Entropy agreement establishes neither a bound, a unique microscopic theory nor a common finite-dimensional Hilbert space.","evidenceIds":["unit:07411d1d8b7d3150b7f5e65e0b71fcf683e5bc2e2322a2f8527e809a328f6b56","unit:22836f172f28aefee5e7f76432fcc12b31629ad251180161b300541816f158b2","unit:325ce30869140fd438008fafac7faf5a42c8c39c34cbb4e69bb9e9dfac24c00f","unit:399e2e5312c250f6e648e65787b9d827d513ce9f8228598d2fa87c2b8a35d8bb","unit:3ea528ed71e29e74eda69dab93e867e3fc37d47bdebde7099df55811ef11678f","unit:4037a21cf32b6f45a35a1fb2c0920812b765210257396bee1fb95a6330b4a011","unit:4aeb46d224c58b335607841b5e2be8e1fe869b3b0917e252431ae0eb9c83167a","unit:5cdd658eecd9f0a76a8e34b8b5b7e478cd447ec4647635e162fc70e239549a57","unit:6f93356538fb5a79dc4bc2f1f6f1b62ee114528fa6e436094d5a8c02411b074b","unit:77bc5b0f428ad3a920b527d2def478d90630b0276f71f3e0bf585b0a511a54de","unit:79c51941b74d15cd7f6d1d05131bb6a519fb90587faf105872b301f9a8c687a9","unit:7b35c86c287bf15705e87662e6da8454549207f286527a83f2a7355c4e50fc93","unit:890b0a74a7b2f50c78b1f59f2f1d069400cdec0e90410476149491624ccd55ed","unit:8ae0040e64ff1d810ee4ded700b1d8529b67b174be34f237a10cda125bb221cd","unit:8d98235b292673d98c70d22b20aae70455abdf0b3f8629e30d23ad80f15bf55d","unit:91e9947b71468e060d08e1f70c3f8f352b01b66606c0030a549b9b479bcbd25e","unit:9f538d7e1e4df6edbef9c443046523c0f854fc8a3447004298bfe5849cce9359","unit:bb784c393f60e4e979d16674bf1573cd46cead0cdd1e6d677cda2d84837e9dc1","unit:d2fd482955c83a381b3df3202c8d2a5370d6f6c331d30b9a061db5982d134c91","unit:d32d98bda3a08c6baf2e864c5d7a98312ac02d890917461f7512822734cdca07","unit:d351a2ec304ea6cd45f80c34e401aea4ad80f0869d32b1d12e099dd8bbf72dd6","unit:d65062149a7fa3b1eeb1717d64c6b5e0adf3eb184bfafaf7680592c282b22a0d","unit:e5c7adca9df183355afc71a93ae2d64184c52b7a2ad4832d94a3aac770427c98","unit:e873e8f81d6fd56fbcb6feee6ca982d3bb6f08edf5904fbb63e65e37bf0b8b69","unit:e97a4223e2894b3b98a3b1c05c53582c67a07d40000ad3d119193a6530884cb1","unit:fcd7357c7048ac121b6461ca35dfe20dbc6edef78c2030499dca144ef4dd4ac6"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce","scopeContentSha256":"74e274f4edaafb3d85e7b4d03063b3637b8e98fd5d499c4e6ddd41bc82f522ef","localRef":"s17"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e920a374a251ab3ab789fcfa","scopeContentSha256":"c5c5ce3a72349fb85c019f07f564489aa011c0ef678fe54aff8dad88ad0885a9","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l13","originalCandidateId":"parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-challenge:link:13","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l13","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-challenge:link:13","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:e920a374a251ab3ab789fcfa","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l13","source":"s39","target":"s17","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Connect entropy accounting to entropy principles and diagnostics while retaining the distinction between reproducing entropy and justifying a bound."],"challengeStatement":"Entropy principles inform entropy accounting, while reproducing an entropy and justifying a bound remain different tasks.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"b267b947879367d2c6bb7441fd4aca0f1bae15dd358682d42b037e5e470aadff","reply.jsonSha256":"de5763c56c59d8c99939592ebb8fb4121616ac7da0b374947e8fff8b83363eb2","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7f13c184625177f50a9f91126707cb78125eb565c3c40e400847b8e3cc3e33ab","receipt.jsonSha256":"61cc211f4a494f69b859e9a496074f332bdc4a824d390ff6025c9fa24962c775","normalization.jsonSha256":"4b47ee96c9ad8141186f8556089489fbbd00cf6f6fc45fadeffc709687de54aa","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"c09cf9d7168e2eb99039f0c70d0ec0b65b2440b83bc535ba31036d4e4e43b8d5"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"6b9f55cb8c5800efab3cd81fe2176e30d744a6e79c58263d7c13d8e4c7c9cd12","reply.jsonSha256":"438fbf2601077afe23a9f0bfe27cb426fc25474ebb5c8239ff0150d84cc17957","reply.raw.txtSha256":"99d6eeb5f3ed1e0d3c0bfc322dbd852459baf7518ccd2c0e420f316360e0fc61","receipt.jsonSha256":"f93e3a5fd83e372c4776be7c428ce1168f3facbcbb7d7fa736d0a3d673337be5","normalization.jsonSha256":"f1ba299cb3f99a5a9b75a000526c1e21ad8f2322f0f59650593e63b89b959210"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e920a374a251ab3ab789fcfa"},{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e920a374a251ab3ab789fcfa"},{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d13","originalRef":"l13","status":"route","source":"s17","target":"s39","type":"method_for","title":"Use conditional entropy diagnostics to assess horizon-entropy accounting","rationale":"The challenge statement assigns entropy principles an interpretive role in entropy accounting, consistent with the proposal's connection to diagnostics. This supports a methodological direction from principles to accounting while preserving the distinction between entropy reproduction and bound justification.","qualification":"The method is an assessment of assumptions, not a universal microscopic counting prescription. Quantum matter can invalidate classical energy-condition reasoning, and positive cosmological constant alone does not ensure bounded observable entropy. JT, restricted focusing and small-acceleration results retain their domains; the 2002 survey's D=4 and Planck-unit conventions remain explicit when used. Each microscopic dictionary retains its regulators, replica limits and normalization choices. Entropy agreement establishes neither a bound, a unique microscopic theory nor a common finite-dimensional Hilbert space.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l13","s17","s39"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d13","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original challenge explicitly assigns entropy principles an interpretive role in entropy accounting. method_for is supported as the limited diagnostic assessment stated in the proposal. Its qualification preserves quantum-matter and framework restrictions and does not identify entropy reproduction with a justified bound or microscopic counting prescription.","refs":["l13","s17","s39"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l13","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l14":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l14","source":"q025-candidate-question:9f2cd5823705dacaa300c317","target":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce","type":"application_of","title":"Identify the entropy-diagnostic premises of DS/dS comparisons","rationale":"Both statements explicitly describe DS/dS comparisons as framework-specific applications of entropy diagnostics. The DS/dS question is therefore the applied source.","qualification":"Retain the proposed correspondence, horizon-entropy ceiling, tracing domain and distinction between global and static-patch comparisons. The calculations use specified classical extremal areas and warped geometries retaining radial horizons. The explicit D=4 free-massless-scalar example includes A(0); a bounded projection onto that modulus does not bound every trajectory length. The absent thesis inequality cannot be equated with other DS/dS criteria. No general matter exclusion, exponentially light tower or universal entropy ceiling is established.","evidenceIds":["unit:22836f172f28aefee5e7f76432fcc12b31629ad251180161b300541816f158b2","unit:325ce30869140fd438008fafac7faf5a42c8c39c34cbb4e69bb9e9dfac24c00f","unit:4037a21cf32b6f45a35a1fb2c0920812b765210257396bee1fb95a6330b4a011","unit:40b73ab468114f31ba80b22e9336f9727fb9e2409b52c14b5505cc4378e4e441","unit:4aeb46d224c58b335607841b5e2be8e1fe869b3b0917e252431ae0eb9c83167a","unit:77bc5b0f428ad3a920b527d2def478d90630b0276f71f3e0bf585b0a511a54de","unit:7b35c86c287bf15705e87662e6da8454549207f286527a83f2a7355c4e50fc93","unit:80e68f047ac20e38ce26b446eb2e8af9e7b973bc4892aa28080464d19a5409ce","unit:91e9947b71468e060d08e1f70c3f8f352b01b66606c0030a549b9b479bcbd25e","unit:987a7206dac9cb7664d4da2a2b75f913ebca35fbccd47da85f1b9ca202742874","unit:9f538d7e1e4df6edbef9c443046523c0f854fc8a3447004298bfe5849cce9359","unit:b9de22cb1be2a3a816750c5a1df1f60b67e502016f82a4792762940a3ba68c48","unit:c8b78d25c1b8f916d014c4d83bf203e27ac2aab6477495028639fe5ccff382a9","unit:e873e8f81d6fd56fbcb6feee6ca982d3bb6f08edf5904fbb63e65e37bf0b8b69","unit:e97a4223e2894b3b98a3b1c05c53582c67a07d40000ad3d119193a6530884cb1","unit:fcd7357c7048ac121b6461ca35dfe20dbc6edef78c2030499dca144ef4dd4ac6"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9f2cd5823705dacaa300c317","scopeContentSha256":"4cdf4423522012a35926cc245bb174874a37a8416e243f7ca2345640f0ef742a","localRef":"s31"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce","scopeContentSha256":"74e274f4edaafb3d85e7b4d03063b3637b8e98fd5d499c4e6ddd41bc82f522ef","localRef":"s17"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l14","originalCandidateId":"parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-challenge:link:14","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l14","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-challenge:link:14","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:9f2cd5823705dacaa300c317","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l14","source":"s17","target":"s31","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["DS/dS comparisons form a framework-specific application of entropy diagnostics, conditional on their proposed ceiling and tracing domain."],"challengeStatement":"DS/dS entropy comparisons are conditional applications with a proposed ceiling and specified tracing domain.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"b267b947879367d2c6bb7441fd4aca0f1bae15dd358682d42b037e5e470aadff","reply.jsonSha256":"de5763c56c59d8c99939592ebb8fb4121616ac7da0b374947e8fff8b83363eb2","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7f13c184625177f50a9f91126707cb78125eb565c3c40e400847b8e3cc3e33ab","receipt.jsonSha256":"61cc211f4a494f69b859e9a496074f332bdc4a824d390ff6025c9fa24962c775","normalization.jsonSha256":"4b47ee96c9ad8141186f8556089489fbbd00cf6f6fc45fadeffc709687de54aa","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"c09cf9d7168e2eb99039f0c70d0ec0b65b2440b83bc535ba31036d4e4e43b8d5"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"6b9f55cb8c5800efab3cd81fe2176e30d744a6e79c58263d7c13d8e4c7c9cd12","reply.jsonSha256":"438fbf2601077afe23a9f0bfe27cb426fc25474ebb5c8239ff0150d84cc17957","reply.raw.txtSha256":"99d6eeb5f3ed1e0d3c0bfc322dbd852459baf7518ccd2c0e420f316360e0fc61","receipt.jsonSha256":"f93e3a5fd83e372c4776be7c428ce1168f3facbcbb7d7fa736d0a3d673337be5","normalization.jsonSha256":"f1ba299cb3f99a5a9b75a000526c1e21ad8f2322f0f59650593e63b89b959210"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce"},{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9f2cd5823705dacaa300c317"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce"},{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9f2cd5823705dacaa300c317"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d14","originalRef":"l14","status":"route","source":"s31","target":"s17","type":"application_of","title":"Identify the entropy-diagnostic premises of DS/dS comparisons","rationale":"Both statements explicitly describe DS/dS comparisons as framework-specific applications of entropy diagnostics. The DS/dS question is therefore the applied source.","qualification":"Retain the proposed correspondence, horizon-entropy ceiling, tracing domain and distinction between global and static-patch comparisons. The calculations use specified classical extremal areas and warped geometries retaining radial horizons. The explicit D=4 free-massless-scalar example includes A(0); a bounded projection onto that modulus does not bound every trajectory length. The absent thesis inequality cannot be equated with other DS/dS criteria. No general matter exclusion, exponentially light tower or universal entropy ceiling is established.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l14","s31","s17"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d14","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements explicitly describe DS/dS comparisons as conditional applications of entropy diagnostics, supporting s31 → s17. The qualification retains the proposed ceiling, tracing domain, radial-horizon setting and restricted scalar example. The unavailable thesis inequality remains unresolved rather than being supplied or equated with another criterion.","refs":["l14","s31","s17"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l14","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l15":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l15","source":"q025-candidate-question:4b6ceca6715a9d7ad68eed8a","target":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce","type":"application_of","title":"Trace cosmological and scalar bounds to their entropy principles","rationale":"The paired statements identify cosmological and scalar-theory questions as applications whose validity depends on causal access, evolution and entropy-evaluation choices. They point to the underlying entropy principles.","qualification":"Preserve the chosen causal region and evaluation time. The finite-inflation duration argument uses end-of-inflation entropy and subsequent deceleration and mode re-entry; rolling, growing-horizon and subluminal-propagation settings retain their own conditions. Scalar-distance, species and cutoff definitions are not interchangeable. Flat-space operational measurability is a comparison, not a de Sitter existence criterion. Neither a demonstrated rolling-inflation bound nor positive cosmological constant supplies a universal restriction for every bubble observer.","evidenceIds":["unit:325ce30869140fd438008fafac7faf5a42c8c39c34cbb4e69bb9e9dfac24c00f","unit:4037a21cf32b6f45a35a1fb2c0920812b765210257396bee1fb95a6330b4a011","unit:596a8439993c5347955aa99b21eb6c0dd07430a710d4643e1e2881f2c84d30e7","unit:77bc5b0f428ad3a920b527d2def478d90630b0276f71f3e0bf585b0a511a54de","unit:7b35c86c287bf15705e87662e6da8454549207f286527a83f2a7355c4e50fc93","unit:7c53502e63cc4d6a27358810169419cd4cc1d1d6f32d92490cddd7a96c14f884","unit:91e9947b71468e060d08e1f70c3f8f352b01b66606c0030a549b9b479bcbd25e","unit:987a7206dac9cb7664d4da2a2b75f913ebca35fbccd47da85f1b9ca202742874","unit:ac156dda800ef7e8d136a8a3bf177bcd82a37f263e46200bf7436661cb4b8c52","unit:adffc4fc442f8f7b9e32af0f6c69a693e4ef1b9dec4708b61fb0738e64357681","unit:c8b78d25c1b8f916d014c4d83bf203e27ac2aab6477495028639fe5ccff382a9","unit:e873e8f81d6fd56fbcb6feee6ca982d3bb6f08edf5904fbb63e65e37bf0b8b69","unit:e97a4223e2894b3b98a3b1c05c53582c67a07d40000ad3d119193a6530884cb1","unit:eb9266c7bb10390edf7dabaa7110eac28e6db2dbb7fb690e603b75be8746ec32","unit:fcd7357c7048ac121b6461ca35dfe20dbc6edef78c2030499dca144ef4dd4ac6"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4b6ceca6715a9d7ad68eed8a","scopeContentSha256":"6bc95b90945d8e1a33e17ee6dfff83caa197a6d885689b035644e83de434605f","localRef":"s14"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce","scopeContentSha256":"74e274f4edaafb3d85e7b4d03063b3637b8e98fd5d499c4e6ddd41bc82f522ef","localRef":"s17"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l15","originalCandidateId":"parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-challenge:link:15","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l15","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-challenge:link:15","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:4b6ceca6715a9d7ad68eed8a","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l15","source":"s17","target":"s14","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Cosmological and scalar-theory applications depend on causal access, evolution and entropy-evaluation choices."],"challengeStatement":"Cosmological and scalar-theory applications depend on causal access, evolution and entropy-evaluation choices.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"b267b947879367d2c6bb7441fd4aca0f1bae15dd358682d42b037e5e470aadff","reply.jsonSha256":"de5763c56c59d8c99939592ebb8fb4121616ac7da0b374947e8fff8b83363eb2","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7f13c184625177f50a9f91126707cb78125eb565c3c40e400847b8e3cc3e33ab","receipt.jsonSha256":"61cc211f4a494f69b859e9a496074f332bdc4a824d390ff6025c9fa24962c775","normalization.jsonSha256":"4b47ee96c9ad8141186f8556089489fbbd00cf6f6fc45fadeffc709687de54aa","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"c09cf9d7168e2eb99039f0c70d0ec0b65b2440b83bc535ba31036d4e4e43b8d5"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-813ba2ac33c503125e80-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"6b9f55cb8c5800efab3cd81fe2176e30d744a6e79c58263d7c13d8e4c7c9cd12","reply.jsonSha256":"438fbf2601077afe23a9f0bfe27cb426fc25474ebb5c8239ff0150d84cc17957","reply.raw.txtSha256":"99d6eeb5f3ed1e0d3c0bfc322dbd852459baf7518ccd2c0e420f316360e0fc61","receipt.jsonSha256":"f93e3a5fd83e372c4776be7c428ce1168f3facbcbb7d7fa736d0a3d673337be5","normalization.jsonSha256":"f1ba299cb3f99a5a9b75a000526c1e21ad8f2322f0f59650593e63b89b959210"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce"},{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4b6ceca6715a9d7ad68eed8a"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:507a6b0d385ff62b8570d8ce"},{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4b6ceca6715a9d7ad68eed8a"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d15","originalRef":"l15","status":"route","source":"s14","target":"s17","type":"application_of","title":"Trace cosmological and scalar bounds to their entropy principles","rationale":"The paired statements identify cosmological and scalar-theory questions as applications whose validity depends on causal access, evolution and entropy-evaluation choices. They point to the underlying entropy principles.","qualification":"Preserve the chosen causal region and evaluation time. The finite-inflation duration argument uses end-of-inflation entropy and subsequent deceleration and mode re-entry; rolling, growing-horizon and subluminal-propagation settings retain their own conditions. Scalar-distance, species and cutoff definitions are not interchangeable. Flat-space operational measurability is a comparison, not a de Sitter existence criterion. Neither a demonstrated rolling-inflation bound nor positive cosmological constant supplies a universal restriction for every bubble observer.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l15","s14","s17"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d15","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The paired statements identify cosmological and scalar-theory bounds as applications of entropy principles under causal-access and evolution assumptions. The reversed application_of direction is correct. The qualification preserves evaluation time, re-entry conditions and distinct range or cutoff definitions without asserting a universal bubble-observer restriction.","refs":["l15","s14","s17"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l15","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l16":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l16","source":"q025-candidate-question:7da9819450a5129a1e3c8f28","target":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","type":"application_of","title":"Trace selected electric-BPS extremality calculations to asymptotic Hodge geometry","rationale":"Both statements describe the thesis's selected electric-BPS charge-to-mass and extremality calculations as applications of asymptotic geometry. The charged-object application points to the Hodge-geometric framework.","qualification":"Restrict the connection to the selected sl(2)-elementary BPS states and electric extremality regions described in the supplied context. Retain the specified degeneration and approximation regime, distinguishing nilpotent-orbit and hierarchical sl(2)-orbit treatments and keeping essential exponential corrections where required. The route does not cover all charged states, establish non-BPS stability or transfer these results to black strings, other symmetry questions or proposed axion bounds.","evidenceIds":["unit:006e079e2f190781673c599304b1e035a490520ab1452b153963d8c00a0facad","unit:05bbd28d938b41d04f3cff01ca15658911eecbbf83ffcc4791b18b3856f6b669","unit:05f7e0ef70d00cb9c80d57e56a5c0e416feed675f2011c053fd82a88744de3a2","unit:09d06335e9b64a473fd1a0c3dc59991b20c22cc0d18d183d660ab2feaa6eda99","unit:0c0e5bc0d09c001963465763a3e9658f3a596ca8cb8303f361b69b7867258d3a","unit:0edccf4b857f5780a8658e34ffb5b7c45a16532680c6eb884c9e29ad1f87074d","unit:33b36eacf43db41ff24702c6acc6ba57a537026a8fc55603faf2e29639127705","unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","unit:534f7499f9b76f4b96665e52cecfaaf7ac5c6a4e41d27d41c8f63f0001f85a38","unit:6a7d952d77f949f77bc9bdf3f68ec058b77eae90f2f6fdeb8e9e8546bce74f3c","unit:6ec6ffd84ded2c0e9b74ef79eb197622ad7b1e7b109cc2b25f33a5afb0769411","unit:750fb093bba0e53aec34191d0549a0765b4efc9747690b0182696dc4a1299cfa","unit:7ef040afb8643c699191e0f5fcb788413d8b6d52eec8676289a07d9ec012b979","unit:813cf2c8954e5625db37bed7a025af91ee01f2c8be3c01de426b7109631e00e4","unit:8216889a44a4d58661e8bad792263c5ec8e28230c8d3427a9555cb8b7eb95ef6","unit:850c29f54e32d2a856365f4591f54b68ada0145a45e1fcd94ee70a84d627998a","unit:8a4df5a710fd4358a89488eb3e6629994549c0812edd632b0374488c2dfa6b0b","unit:900197a6338402a2648d408ebd1102cc85b8a9fdee39044eb0ddfe7e3fe3159f","unit:a2f65ff116b230fc1a113b92d1153fbdef0cecd02361124015e25561b349977a","unit:b1815e733e5816d59225b9844f227c4539d9efe9e4c8bb9061fa5652500ff444","unit:b352a709b7d7794d9a032b6a59cd9d029d9c609deba3f7d14ed47c1d924ce5af","unit:cc4341720b0e1b089abb0621ada9ab548f22a8c1ae82706ed31ec76151a5f027","unit:ce116363ae5dbc5affb70c1a90cb569dc922c376b4c648b0e5b595f01b5eda1d","unit:ceacc1288d61f5788a47aab20a4b595bf8311daef46a5f7898867d1a0c534b39","unit:cf91b725b07424a6679bce3c68fa3efbf027372a64e5d242af1b3c59fbcd5fa9","unit:e50f653a8c89a44d5d9db6acab3b1402787410e30bafce1c710143540e8017a1","unit:eab949d69b116940af5c4b05cc74e2ed1b98aa97fc9a042cd106c9d2868d5591","unit:eb93831a574a4443eebb99ed809a2b21834d853534607a4e594cd9ac01cbcfcb","unit:f182013d41945ecf2c359580c83478ca280a6da821b08eb86b227c2aeb3c0a03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7da9819450a5129a1e3c8f28","scopeContentSha256":"f64c8dc22c7f463c2c9a8c18d4ab2e62285f52ad822ec7cd4d9df1427ca0154f","localRef":"s23"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","scopeContentSha256":"f3ed7d3385858adaef42ec0fbe9014d241cdd01bedb9d40d653cbd19e4aaeb4c","localRef":"s3"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l16","originalCandidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:16","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l16","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:16","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:7da9819450a5129a1e3c8f28","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l16","source":"s3","target":"s23","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["The thesis applies asymptotic geometry to selected electric BPS charge-to-mass and extremality calculations."],"challengeStatement":"The thesis applies asymptotic Hodge methods to selected electric-BPS charge-to-mass ratios and extremality regions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"6d3a7df0596efe9916b43efec2dfe4f548e3067a1281a088ecd1cfd2d6f97080","reply.jsonSha256":"fea64bac072e650bfc4d15b6f9f837dafd36eb73f989803b2ecdd6bda9ffde93","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21d4d92a6189dc4c195fb915d00b0ab59bc7b327c63ea80639001fdc27a4f69a","receipt.jsonSha256":"3292ca6f2a135959cdead2514dbd2eb6ad6415eb79e6f114495a3c9ea513688a","normalization.jsonSha256":"41a1a38aa368407355f9e15d8fe25fa2415746cab070760d6244aec134c82ab8","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/adopted/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge/request.json","sha256":"c6fa93101222c87fbd5426fe416f787eecaada68658cd016ca6f243d3b449edb"},"originalChallengeDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge"},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/adopted/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"32a47a4de46ffd745f2cd68ad7068da6b6af07db892edfa5c539349f2be0d312","reply.jsonSha256":"bc61492ed7debc615fbeac069e663b8af12918cd689559d1ffb4dcec6c365380","reply.raw.txtSha256":"910c60854c32b0c8a94716a559d8a3b2427b66932a32aceed217c0a76fe3b22d","receipt.jsonSha256":"f92cf97b93df1ff22b2a13c93de2fcf421ce39315f82f35e49ecbc2b904c93df","normalization.jsonSha256":"07362ddb36fec6b6eaa01e8c8f9aa7088e3894e69e628c4c5d736aba6f40b147"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d16","originalRef":"l16","status":"route","source":"s23","target":"s3","type":"application_of","title":"Trace selected electric-BPS extremality calculations to asymptotic Hodge geometry","rationale":"Both statements describe the thesis's selected electric-BPS charge-to-mass and extremality calculations as applications of asymptotic geometry. The charged-object application points to the Hodge-geometric framework.","qualification":"Restrict the connection to the selected sl(2)-elementary BPS states and electric extremality regions described in the supplied context. Retain the specified degeneration and approximation regime, distinguishing nilpotent-orbit and hierarchical sl(2)-orbit treatments and keeping essential exponential corrections where required. The route does not cover all charged states, establish non-BPS stability or transfer these results to black strings, other symmetry questions or proposed axion bounds.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l16","s23","s3"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d16","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements explicitly identify selected electric-BPS charge-to-mass and extremality calculations as applications of asymptotic Hodge geometry. The reversal is justified. The qualification retains the selected-state and approximation restrictions and does not extend the application to all charged objects, non-BPS stability or unrelated symmetry targets.","refs":["l16","s23","s3"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l16","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l17":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l17","source":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f","target":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","type":"method_for","title":"Use explicit period calculations for moduli-boundary questions","rationale":"Both statements assign a methodological role to period and special-geometry calculations while distinguishing explicit model calculations from global boundary organization. The computational question supplies methods for the relevant part of the broader moduli question.","qualification":"Retain the specified hypersurface or complete-intersection family, deformation sector and boundary regime, including polynomial-deformation restrictions where stated. Real structures and period pairings remain part of the calculation. The two-parameter examples retain their continuous-instanton-family qualifications. A model-class period calculation does not cover all Calabi–Yau moduli, every birational phase or every finite- and infinite-volume limit, and appendix identities do not establish quantum exactness.","evidenceIds":["unit:05bbd28d938b41d04f3cff01ca15658911eecbbf83ffcc4791b18b3856f6b669","unit:0ab89e9b3e058896b7c2ce5a4532d38d77d794d6b411df04b66072275988539a","unit:0edccf4b857f5780a8658e34ffb5b7c45a16532680c6eb884c9e29ad1f87074d","unit:33b36eacf43db41ff24702c6acc6ba57a537026a8fc55603faf2e29639127705","unit:36ddd47530f27d6f8387f25249bf58fcbb3caf8ff0ebf806a253f35bc09f6db1","unit:394ea8d3adc525d1ea1ed5942e57d7dc169767d9f191f15bf489878004e5cbca","unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","unit:514e9fbcafd6f182ff959a6f4ccd8339fef63f96bd87be6784404499d2d7b740","unit:66deadaab3f05d064af6e0027be417d703874e84769eb704e15befc1eff85a2f","unit:7ef040afb8643c699191e0f5fcb788413d8b6d52eec8676289a07d9ec012b979","unit:813cf2c8954e5625db37bed7a025af91ee01f2c8be3c01de426b7109631e00e4","unit:850c29f54e32d2a856365f4591f54b68ada0145a45e1fcd94ee70a84d627998a","unit:900197a6338402a2648d408ebd1102cc85b8a9fdee39044eb0ddfe7e3fe3159f","unit:926b345c92affb58b9589a950142ae23a51f3801b52561f92b8ad7ae0109f605","unit:b1815e733e5816d59225b9844f227c4539d9efe9e4c8bb9061fa5652500ff444","unit:c4afbfb40dcef8a1e2dcfdb45a2759c2934d07703b11563935b8fd4dfaa60ca8","unit:cb95eb9c9a2e4dfc478e7da2079600014e592a8c9f790932d740b44550510a13","unit:ce116363ae5dbc5affb70c1a90cb569dc922c376b4c648b0e5b595f01b5eda1d","unit:ceacc1288d61f5788a47aab20a4b595bf8311daef46a5f7898867d1a0c534b39","unit:d3cf19ebc8ba07e11a83b9cf7262613fde4bd2b5dc6a2e506bf2d564f7103259","unit:eab949d69b116940af5c4b05cc74e2ed1b98aa97fc9a042cd106c9d2868d5591","unit:eb93831a574a4443eebb99ed809a2b21834d853534607a4e594cd9ac01cbcfcb","unit:f182013d41945ecf2c359580c83478ca280a6da821b08eb86b227c2aeb3c0a03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f","scopeContentSha256":"ffdcdfd43bf16c41d677b405ceb912250a1923a77812c9d1330dc83c149354e4","localRef":"s0"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","scopeContentSha256":"f3ed7d3385858adaef42ec0fbe9014d241cdd01bedb9d40d653cbd19e4aaeb4c","localRef":"s3"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l17","originalCandidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:18","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l17","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:18","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l17","source":"s3","target":"s0","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Period and special-geometry computations offer related methods; model-class calculations and general boundary organization have different scopes."],"challengeStatement":"Period and special-geometry calculations provide related methods; explicit model-class calculations and global boundary organization have different scopes.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"6d3a7df0596efe9916b43efec2dfe4f548e3067a1281a088ecd1cfd2d6f97080","reply.jsonSha256":"fea64bac072e650bfc4d15b6f9f837dafd36eb73f989803b2ecdd6bda9ffde93","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21d4d92a6189dc4c195fb915d00b0ab59bc7b327c63ea80639001fdc27a4f69a","receipt.jsonSha256":"3292ca6f2a135959cdead2514dbd2eb6ad6415eb79e6f114495a3c9ea513688a","normalization.jsonSha256":"41a1a38aa368407355f9e15d8fe25fa2415746cab070760d6244aec134c82ab8","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/adopted/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge/request.json","sha256":"c6fa93101222c87fbd5426fe416f787eecaada68658cd016ca6f243d3b449edb"},"originalChallengeDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge"},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/adopted/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"32a47a4de46ffd745f2cd68ad7068da6b6af07db892edfa5c539349f2be0d312","reply.jsonSha256":"bc61492ed7debc615fbeac069e663b8af12918cd689559d1ffb4dcec6c365380","reply.raw.txtSha256":"910c60854c32b0c8a94716a559d8a3b2427b66932a32aceed217c0a76fe3b22d","receipt.jsonSha256":"f92cf97b93df1ff22b2a13c93de2fcf421ce39315f82f35e49ecbc2b904c93df","normalization.jsonSha256":"07362ddb36fec6b6eaa01e8c8f9aa7088e3894e69e628c4c5d736aba6f40b147"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:309ac92ca466bb3c7a5527db1e889080","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":261,"start":0,"end":2500,"textSha256":"acf7b20aec273527e541c0841fa6f50e02654cc1292218f91d865396cef23659","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:309ac92ca466bb3c7a5527db1e889080","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":261,"start":0,"end":2500,"textSha256":"acf7b20aec273527e541c0841fa6f50e02654cc1292218f91d865396cef23659","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d17","originalRef":"l17","status":"route","source":"s0","target":"s3","type":"method_for","title":"Use explicit period calculations for moduli-boundary questions","rationale":"Both statements assign a methodological role to period and special-geometry calculations while distinguishing explicit model calculations from global boundary organization. The computational question supplies methods for the relevant part of the broader moduli question.","qualification":"Retain the specified hypersurface or complete-intersection family, deformation sector and boundary regime, including polynomial-deformation restrictions where stated. Real structures and period pairings remain part of the calculation. The two-parameter examples retain their continuous-instanton-family qualifications. A model-class period calculation does not cover all Calabi–Yau moduli, every birational phase or every finite- and infinite-volume limit, and appendix identities do not establish quantum exactness.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l17","s0","s3"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d17","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements give period and special-geometry calculations a methodological role while distinguishing their explicit model classes from broader boundary organization. s0 → s3 therefore fits method_for. The qualification preserves deformation, pairing and continuous-family restrictions without asserting containment of all global-moduli questions.","refs":["l17","s0","s3"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l17","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l18":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l18","source":"q025-candidate-question:4fc6e181bbaa8ab3e1261a9f","target":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","type":"application_of","title":"Trace asymptotic flux-stabilization schemes to Hodge-geometric approximations","rationale":"The paired statements report flux-stabilization approximation schemes built from the thesis's asymptotic geometry. This makes the specified stabilization question an application of the Hodge framework.","qualification":"Limit the application to the stated asymptotic flux settings and their flux, tadpole and boundary assumptions. Polynomial self-duality treatments and F-term treatments have different requirements for exponential corrections; the former does not justify discarding essential terms in the latter. Distinct degeneration regimes and hierarchical approximations remain separate. The route does not extend to every IIB or restricted-flux IIA stabilization mechanism, establish unrestricted all-boundary finiteness or certify general control or de Sitter existence.","evidenceIds":["unit:05bbd28d938b41d04f3cff01ca15658911eecbbf83ffcc4791b18b3856f6b669","unit:09d06335e9b64a473fd1a0c3dc59991b20c22cc0d18d183d660ab2feaa6eda99","unit:0edccf4b857f5780a8658e34ffb5b7c45a16532680c6eb884c9e29ad1f87074d","unit:189d328113ae8ef0d556e178ac8ff1d68b6be130a6ced75391b9b8a8c07d37f4","unit:241b393da38ca346513787f2c63893881df0e2a7c99b84ecc9daa3c1888387df","unit:2a257f8d2e1e110d5144a69538f05774415390166c6663ed8b76faf2cd246753","unit:33b36eacf43db41ff24702c6acc6ba57a537026a8fc55603faf2e29639127705","unit:483ff39dacd71a9860789143ef29bee0d63809e46622adf9ee48b19c0ea87b08","unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","unit:607449b0becda7913f5460edcd6273d76e0abd251caac4e3807821921b05077f","unit:7ef040afb8643c699191e0f5fcb788413d8b6d52eec8676289a07d9ec012b979","unit:813cf2c8954e5625db37bed7a025af91ee01f2c8be3c01de426b7109631e00e4","unit:850c29f54e32d2a856365f4591f54b68ada0145a45e1fcd94ee70a84d627998a","unit:86c85340901a5cc3cac841c8d2b84dbdcce506bb89bcc6bcb1c1eac8eccebee9","unit:900197a6338402a2648d408ebd1102cc85b8a9fdee39044eb0ddfe7e3fe3159f","unit:b0f54b3023614bced88e047d69903a371546cfdc2bc84e3a648ce3e91b3210b5","unit:b1815e733e5816d59225b9844f227c4539d9efe9e4c8bb9061fa5652500ff444","unit:b7a51c348451844081c096888323b6f7a4d5d165865add9e5134757f0699bb12","unit:b8cc0b9a3fca1b02e245b519445a233b70c20885671c271887358903c030962f","unit:bb12831bd39455956111c34e6a84baaaeb3b931c98c7241448f72e8fbc144289","unit:ce116363ae5dbc5affb70c1a90cb569dc922c376b4c648b0e5b595f01b5eda1d","unit:ceacc1288d61f5788a47aab20a4b595bf8311daef46a5f7898867d1a0c534b39","unit:cf91b725b07424a6679bce3c68fa3efbf027372a64e5d242af1b3c59fbcd5fa9","unit:d89f6f804ad2d7e18b142d8b7fedba3f60c25008eb5c779bbf319170c8af5f0f","unit:eab949d69b116940af5c4b05cc74e2ed1b98aa97fc9a042cd106c9d2868d5591","unit:eb93831a574a4443eebb99ed809a2b21834d853534607a4e594cd9ac01cbcfcb","unit:f182013d41945ecf2c359580c83478ca280a6da821b08eb86b227c2aeb3c0a03","unit:f828b293f70a49ede426d42d91be9892f2b38efbe33f95daafeb50cede79138a","unit:fe5099f6d8e04fc0668f5532430b0e12de178341568234800d6c5d3c95c87ffd"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4fc6e181bbaa8ab3e1261a9f","scopeContentSha256":"930c88f86d7c6ea8a5627173d6dc206a1dbc8467b751d2f57ebc7f15dd8eef0f","localRef":"s16"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","scopeContentSha256":"f3ed7d3385858adaef42ec0fbe9014d241cdd01bedb9d40d653cbd19e4aaeb4c","localRef":"s3"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l18","originalCandidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:19","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l18","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:19","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:4fc6e181bbaa8ab3e1261a9f","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l18","source":"s3","target":"s16","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["The thesis constructs approximation schemes for flux stabilization, with different correction requirements for self-duality conditions and F-terms."],"challengeStatement":"The thesis reports flux-stabilization approximation schemes. Polynomial self-duality conditions and F-terms have different requirements for exponential corrections.","originalEvidenceKinds":["primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"6d3a7df0596efe9916b43efec2dfe4f548e3067a1281a088ecd1cfd2d6f97080","reply.jsonSha256":"fea64bac072e650bfc4d15b6f9f837dafd36eb73f989803b2ecdd6bda9ffde93","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21d4d92a6189dc4c195fb915d00b0ab59bc7b327c63ea80639001fdc27a4f69a","receipt.jsonSha256":"3292ca6f2a135959cdead2514dbd2eb6ad6415eb79e6f114495a3c9ea513688a","normalization.jsonSha256":"41a1a38aa368407355f9e15d8fe25fa2415746cab070760d6244aec134c82ab8","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/adopted/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge/request.json","sha256":"c6fa93101222c87fbd5426fe416f787eecaada68658cd016ca6f243d3b449edb"},"originalChallengeDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge"},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/adopted/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"32a47a4de46ffd745f2cd68ad7068da6b6af07db892edfa5c539349f2be0d312","reply.jsonSha256":"bc61492ed7debc615fbeac069e663b8af12918cd689559d1ffb4dcec6c365380","reply.raw.txtSha256":"910c60854c32b0c8a94716a559d8a3b2427b66932a32aceed217c0a76fe3b22d","receipt.jsonSha256":"f92cf97b93df1ff22b2a13c93de2fcf421ce39315f82f35e49ecbc2b904c93df","normalization.jsonSha256":"07362ddb36fec6b6eaa01e8c8f9aa7088e3894e69e628c4c5d736aba6f40b147"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d18","originalRef":"l18","status":"route","source":"s16","target":"s3","type":"application_of","title":"Trace asymptotic flux-stabilization schemes to Hodge-geometric approximations","rationale":"The paired statements report flux-stabilization approximation schemes built from the thesis's asymptotic geometry. This makes the specified stabilization question an application of the Hodge framework.","qualification":"Limit the application to the stated asymptotic flux settings and their flux, tadpole and boundary assumptions. Polynomial self-duality treatments and F-term treatments have different requirements for exponential corrections; the former does not justify discarding essential terms in the latter. Distinct degeneration regimes and hierarchical approximations remain separate. The route does not extend to every IIB or restricted-flux IIA stabilization mechanism, establish unrestricted all-boundary finiteness or certify general control or de Sitter existence.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l18","s16","s3"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d18","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original reasoning identifies flux-stabilization approximation schemes as applications of the thesis's asymptotic geometry. The reversed application_of direction is supported. The qualification preserves the consequential distinction between polynomial self-duality treatments and F-terms requiring exponential corrections, together with source-specific flux and boundary restrictions.","refs":["l18","s16","s3"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l18","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l19":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l19","source":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f","target":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","type":"method_for","title":"Reconstruct asymptotic periods for degeneration and boundary questions","rationale":"Both statements identify period reconstruction and asymptotic Hodge techniques as methods within broader degeneration and global-moduli questions. The reconstruction question therefore supplies the method.","qualification":"Preserve each source's boundary data, growth sectors and one- or multi-modulus setting. Nilpotent-orbit and hierarchical sl(2)-orbit approximations remain distinct, and essential exponential corrections cannot be dropped merely because they are small. Real and integral period bases supply different information. Auxiliary operator or moduli-space field-theory examples need not have a geometric realization; no general reconstruction uniqueness, completeness or global classification is established.","evidenceIds":["unit:05bbd28d938b41d04f3cff01ca15658911eecbbf83ffcc4791b18b3856f6b669","unit:0672ed980abb656d9fa32f7f64ee5b070c83459ee9b47f623ad5f2e87089e980","unit:0edccf4b857f5780a8658e34ffb5b7c45a16532680c6eb884c9e29ad1f87074d","unit:2775bff72b91e5b8ba461752a85a09c39ad48ad2008dc0a6debe7b2ebd6da8f1","unit:2a257f8d2e1e110d5144a69538f05774415390166c6663ed8b76faf2cd246753","unit:2b2377eec299b343f763f9176f91d1c428d5fec31e6b093af60ba485afe9de70","unit:2c03490e931954dbe5c6881854e52269ee9e014bc9bf8e466a5fa561aa224134","unit:33b36eacf43db41ff24702c6acc6ba57a537026a8fc55603faf2e29639127705","unit:3d06f2119857e726823e0a53932d77dc0cc9b1f6dd01d13bc3852911153d0c3f","unit:429f929347fec313a3b131efe5148cc6adae84d05311e43e017a1b5b6f6cb161","unit:45ed32d1262897f0557e6ecd2bc20d615d9119a8d5f6325cee5dbd5ca756a24f","unit:49761bf3be7a637061ee469e889ceaa30c79cc03da954fe12a8be5a7742e4f4b","unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","unit:60bcaf83bc3904d2e930f72a3fe74705850fbb10fccd2013e9a620cc01d2396b","unit:6fcc99eafc86c3e631bc7587d5c9cbd0975cb29c16cca544a89d0ff74f14571d","unit:7ef040afb8643c699191e0f5fcb788413d8b6d52eec8676289a07d9ec012b979","unit:813cf2c8954e5625db37bed7a025af91ee01f2c8be3c01de426b7109631e00e4","unit:850c29f54e32d2a856365f4591f54b68ada0145a45e1fcd94ee70a84d627998a","unit:8bf418d4fc0408b1dfdecb9229d54e2d116cc10ec35a7f79868bfa68a6b6f331","unit:900197a6338402a2648d408ebd1102cc85b8a9fdee39044eb0ddfe7e3fe3159f","unit:9b69e83be5a7cc585b650d02b91a46d370c0975f1d8e36e23c01d5cda842a6c0","unit:a78ad2627bc4ae06c980ea555e128fa963c9cb1fdf556c43b1d74e561bd47bc5","unit:b1815e733e5816d59225b9844f227c4539d9efe9e4c8bb9061fa5652500ff444","unit:be37eb20c6c98412a6bbf24834b043fd2f3bfd30ebbe0cbf122d0e23cab669bd","unit:ce116363ae5dbc5affb70c1a90cb569dc922c376b4c648b0e5b595f01b5eda1d","unit:ceacc1288d61f5788a47aab20a4b595bf8311daef46a5f7898867d1a0c534b39","unit:d6c2417475f95f0c572a910cd8a1e81ae9b75ae9aeac2ef7cb4d9e0edd9ea485","unit:d89f6f804ad2d7e18b142d8b7fedba3f60c25008eb5c779bbf319170c8af5f0f","unit:dc2ec632faed509abca4fd41b52e07a2cb6cbe07382ed18e662f491e5265b099","unit:e155604ccf4d992d26848f8b5bbc6ddcc815348f514d8fe8ca2e9df0f69152f6","unit:eab949d69b116940af5c4b05cc74e2ed1b98aa97fc9a042cd106c9d2868d5591","unit:eb93831a574a4443eebb99ed809a2b21834d853534607a4e594cd9ac01cbcfcb","unit:f182013d41945ecf2c359580c83478ca280a6da821b08eb86b227c2aeb3c0a03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f","scopeContentSha256":"6cc528912c1f18c1162cdb7868151e38b3047f52ec734fa2f59d4c82a1d10a3d","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","scopeContentSha256":"f3ed7d3385858adaef42ec0fbe9014d241cdd01bedb9d40d653cbd19e4aaeb4c","localRef":"s3"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l19","originalCandidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:14","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l19","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:14","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l19","source":"s3","target":"s30","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Period reconstruction and asymptotic Hodge techniques provide a method route within broader degeneration and global-moduli questions."],"challengeStatement":"Asymptotic period reconstruction supplies methods for degeneration questions, preserving hierarchical approximations and essential corrections.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3965339798d71b33ab5ee48539d5a115edc6b34a7faab02eddde739ad75f3688","reply.jsonSha256":"7644da5fce58517e3221a765f17a1aa001ce05e45d1104d6a56c038eda498fd3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c75590e1700e60606f892a4bff0180cdd637c210e56999144734d092c912aa15","receipt.jsonSha256":"677688246447085846b344a6f17c725446cc72ef74ae734c48d4b83cd95575de","normalization.jsonSha256":"b7ee6b02b7b74616a7a0e5fc9978834ed599cff4c6988a470863edabac99df96","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4b4d97dc13bcc60a381f267b5de5e3d90ddafd18f817d63874b0970f4f3a1032"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1fd91c573564255cac4f2a90ce27bc09560fcbe642c76ea21ed514364b5f4cfd","reply.jsonSha256":"d1ee2097387a6094e506534262542448b8cfdfd5f1a876f40d2142b8c3eae0d3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7fff57d73701936f8a6700c378cce374efce17f30bc917dd65ca68b535b7437f","receipt.jsonSha256":"6044fc47ccaaa90fb4447257c33abb6eb8f70157d4d523ab0449fafa1cb6cb04","normalization.jsonSha256":"a70efad348d4e671a33683f9125fbeb539d35206f453dda5889880f091496aec"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c"},{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:309ac92ca466bb3c7a5527db1e889080","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":261,"start":0,"end":2500,"textSha256":"acf7b20aec273527e541c0841fa6f50e02654cc1292218f91d865396cef23659","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c"},{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:309ac92ca466bb3c7a5527db1e889080","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":261,"start":0,"end":2500,"textSha256":"acf7b20aec273527e541c0841fa6f50e02654cc1292218f91d865396cef23659","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d19","originalRef":"l19","status":"route","source":"s30","target":"s3","type":"method_for","title":"Reconstruct asymptotic periods for degeneration and boundary questions","rationale":"Both statements identify period reconstruction and asymptotic Hodge techniques as methods within broader degeneration and global-moduli questions. The reconstruction question therefore supplies the method.","qualification":"Preserve each source's boundary data, growth sectors and one- or multi-modulus setting. Nilpotent-orbit and hierarchical sl(2)-orbit approximations remain distinct, and essential exponential corrections cannot be dropped merely because they are small. Real and integral period bases supply different information. Auxiliary operator or moduli-space field-theory examples need not have a geometric realization; no general reconstruction uniqueness, completeness or global classification is established.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l19","s30","s3"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d19","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements identify asymptotic period reconstruction as a method for degeneration questions, supporting s30 → s3. The qualification retains growth sectors, hierarchical approximations, essential corrections and the distinction between real and integral bases. It does not infer geometric realization or general reconstruction completeness.","refs":["l19","s30","s3"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l19","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l20":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l20","source":"q025-candidate-question:7da9819450a5129a1e3c8f28","target":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f","type":"application_of","title":"Identify period and Hodge methods behind selected BPS extremality regions","rationale":"Both statements explicitly identify selected BPS charge-to-mass ratios and electric extremality regions as applications of asymptotic Hodge methods. The charged-object calculation points to those methods.","qualification":"Restrict the route to the selected BPS states and electric extremality calculations in the supplied thesis context. Boundary constraints, growth sectors, approximation order and essential corrections remain source-specific; real-basis reconstruction is not automatically integral charge-basis information. The application establishes neither a complete charged spectrum nor non-BPS stability and does not encompass all black-object, symmetry or axion questions in s23.","evidenceIds":["unit:006e079e2f190781673c599304b1e035a490520ab1452b153963d8c00a0facad","unit:05f7e0ef70d00cb9c80d57e56a5c0e416feed675f2011c053fd82a88744de3a2","unit:0672ed980abb656d9fa32f7f64ee5b070c83459ee9b47f623ad5f2e87089e980","unit:09d06335e9b64a473fd1a0c3dc59991b20c22cc0d18d183d660ab2feaa6eda99","unit:0c0e5bc0d09c001963465763a3e9658f3a596ca8cb8303f361b69b7867258d3a","unit:2775bff72b91e5b8ba461752a85a09c39ad48ad2008dc0a6debe7b2ebd6da8f1","unit:2a257f8d2e1e110d5144a69538f05774415390166c6663ed8b76faf2cd246753","unit:2b2377eec299b343f763f9176f91d1c428d5fec31e6b093af60ba485afe9de70","unit:2c03490e931954dbe5c6881854e52269ee9e014bc9bf8e466a5fa561aa224134","unit:3d06f2119857e726823e0a53932d77dc0cc9b1f6dd01d13bc3852911153d0c3f","unit:429f929347fec313a3b131efe5148cc6adae84d05311e43e017a1b5b6f6cb161","unit:45ed32d1262897f0557e6ecd2bc20d615d9119a8d5f6325cee5dbd5ca756a24f","unit:49761bf3be7a637061ee469e889ceaa30c79cc03da954fe12a8be5a7742e4f4b","unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","unit:534f7499f9b76f4b96665e52cecfaaf7ac5c6a4e41d27d41c8f63f0001f85a38","unit:60bcaf83bc3904d2e930f72a3fe74705850fbb10fccd2013e9a620cc01d2396b","unit:6a7d952d77f949f77bc9bdf3f68ec058b77eae90f2f6fdeb8e9e8546bce74f3c","unit:6ec6ffd84ded2c0e9b74ef79eb197622ad7b1e7b109cc2b25f33a5afb0769411","unit:6fcc99eafc86c3e631bc7587d5c9cbd0975cb29c16cca544a89d0ff74f14571d","unit:750fb093bba0e53aec34191d0549a0765b4efc9747690b0182696dc4a1299cfa","unit:8216889a44a4d58661e8bad792263c5ec8e28230c8d3427a9555cb8b7eb95ef6","unit:8a4df5a710fd4358a89488eb3e6629994549c0812edd632b0374488c2dfa6b0b","unit:8bf418d4fc0408b1dfdecb9229d54e2d116cc10ec35a7f79868bfa68a6b6f331","unit:9b69e83be5a7cc585b650d02b91a46d370c0975f1d8e36e23c01d5cda842a6c0","unit:a2f65ff116b230fc1a113b92d1153fbdef0cecd02361124015e25561b349977a","unit:a78ad2627bc4ae06c980ea555e128fa963c9cb1fdf556c43b1d74e561bd47bc5","unit:b352a709b7d7794d9a032b6a59cd9d029d9c609deba3f7d14ed47c1d924ce5af","unit:be37eb20c6c98412a6bbf24834b043fd2f3bfd30ebbe0cbf122d0e23cab669bd","unit:cc4341720b0e1b089abb0621ada9ab548f22a8c1ae82706ed31ec76151a5f027","unit:cf91b725b07424a6679bce3c68fa3efbf027372a64e5d242af1b3c59fbcd5fa9","unit:d6c2417475f95f0c572a910cd8a1e81ae9b75ae9aeac2ef7cb4d9e0edd9ea485","unit:d89f6f804ad2d7e18b142d8b7fedba3f60c25008eb5c779bbf319170c8af5f0f","unit:dc2ec632faed509abca4fd41b52e07a2cb6cbe07382ed18e662f491e5265b099","unit:e155604ccf4d992d26848f8b5bbc6ddcc815348f514d8fe8ca2e9df0f69152f6","unit:e50f653a8c89a44d5d9db6acab3b1402787410e30bafce1c710143540e8017a1"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7da9819450a5129a1e3c8f28","scopeContentSha256":"f64c8dc22c7f463c2c9a8c18d4ab2e62285f52ad822ec7cd4d9df1427ca0154f","localRef":"s23"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f","scopeContentSha256":"6cc528912c1f18c1162cdb7868151e38b3047f52ec734fa2f59d4c82a1d10a3d","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l20","originalCandidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:17","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l20","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:17","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:7da9819450a5129a1e3c8f28","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l20","source":"s30","target":"s23","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["The thesis applies asymptotic Hodge methods to selected BPS charge-to-mass ratios and electric extremality regions."],"challengeStatement":"The thesis applies asymptotic Hodge methods to selected BPS charge-to-mass ratios and electric extremality regions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3965339798d71b33ab5ee48539d5a115edc6b34a7faab02eddde739ad75f3688","reply.jsonSha256":"7644da5fce58517e3221a765f17a1aa001ce05e45d1104d6a56c038eda498fd3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c75590e1700e60606f892a4bff0180cdd637c210e56999144734d092c912aa15","receipt.jsonSha256":"677688246447085846b344a6f17c725446cc72ef74ae734c48d4b83cd95575de","normalization.jsonSha256":"b7ee6b02b7b74616a7a0e5fc9978834ed599cff4c6988a470863edabac99df96","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4b4d97dc13bcc60a381f267b5de5e3d90ddafd18f817d63874b0970f4f3a1032"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1fd91c573564255cac4f2a90ce27bc09560fcbe642c76ea21ed514364b5f4cfd","reply.jsonSha256":"d1ee2097387a6094e506534262542448b8cfdfd5f1a876f40d2142b8c3eae0d3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7fff57d73701936f8a6700c378cce374efce17f30bc917dd65ca68b535b7437f","receipt.jsonSha256":"6044fc47ccaaa90fb4447257c33abb6eb8f70157d4d523ab0449fafa1cb6cb04","normalization.jsonSha256":"a70efad348d4e671a33683f9125fbeb539d35206f453dda5889880f091496aec"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f"},{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7da9819450a5129a1e3c8f28"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f"},{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7da9819450a5129a1e3c8f28"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d20","originalRef":"l20","status":"route","source":"s23","target":"s30","type":"application_of","title":"Identify period and Hodge methods behind selected BPS extremality regions","rationale":"Both statements explicitly identify selected BPS charge-to-mass ratios and electric extremality regions as applications of asymptotic Hodge methods. The charged-object calculation points to those methods.","qualification":"Restrict the route to the selected BPS states and electric extremality calculations in the supplied thesis context. Boundary constraints, growth sectors, approximation order and essential corrections remain source-specific; real-basis reconstruction is not automatically integral charge-basis information. The application establishes neither a complete charged spectrum nor non-BPS stability and does not encompass all black-object, symmetry or axion questions in s23.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l20","s23","s30"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d20","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements explicitly describe selected BPS charge-to-mass and electric-extremality calculations as applications of asymptotic Hodge methods. s23 → s30 is correctly oriented. The qualification retains boundary and basis restrictions and avoids extending these selected calculations to a complete charged spectrum or non-BPS stability.","refs":["l20","s23","s30"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l20","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l21":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l21","source":"q025-candidate-question:4fc6e181bbaa8ab3e1261a9f","target":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f","type":"application_of","title":"Trace flux-stabilization approximations to period and Hodge-star reconstruction","rationale":"Both statements describe flux stabilization as an application of period and Hodge-star approximations. They also explicitly distinguish polynomial self-duality from exponentially corrected F-term treatments.","qualification":"Retain the specified asymptotic boundary data, growth sectors, flux and tadpole restrictions. Polynomial self-duality approximations do not replace the essential exponential corrections required by the stated F-term treatment. Auxiliary constructions without an assumed geometric realization do not automatically furnish compactification vacua. This application supplies no general all-boundary flux-finiteness result, completed controlled vacuum or universal uplift prescription.","evidenceIds":["unit:0672ed980abb656d9fa32f7f64ee5b070c83459ee9b47f623ad5f2e87089e980","unit:09d06335e9b64a473fd1a0c3dc59991b20c22cc0d18d183d660ab2feaa6eda99","unit:189d328113ae8ef0d556e178ac8ff1d68b6be130a6ced75391b9b8a8c07d37f4","unit:241b393da38ca346513787f2c63893881df0e2a7c99b84ecc9daa3c1888387df","unit:2775bff72b91e5b8ba461752a85a09c39ad48ad2008dc0a6debe7b2ebd6da8f1","unit:2a257f8d2e1e110d5144a69538f05774415390166c6663ed8b76faf2cd246753","unit:2b2377eec299b343f763f9176f91d1c428d5fec31e6b093af60ba485afe9de70","unit:2c03490e931954dbe5c6881854e52269ee9e014bc9bf8e466a5fa561aa224134","unit:3d06f2119857e726823e0a53932d77dc0cc9b1f6dd01d13bc3852911153d0c3f","unit:429f929347fec313a3b131efe5148cc6adae84d05311e43e017a1b5b6f6cb161","unit:45ed32d1262897f0557e6ecd2bc20d615d9119a8d5f6325cee5dbd5ca756a24f","unit:483ff39dacd71a9860789143ef29bee0d63809e46622adf9ee48b19c0ea87b08","unit:49761bf3be7a637061ee469e889ceaa30c79cc03da954fe12a8be5a7742e4f4b","unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","unit:607449b0becda7913f5460edcd6273d76e0abd251caac4e3807821921b05077f","unit:60bcaf83bc3904d2e930f72a3fe74705850fbb10fccd2013e9a620cc01d2396b","unit:6fcc99eafc86c3e631bc7587d5c9cbd0975cb29c16cca544a89d0ff74f14571d","unit:86c85340901a5cc3cac841c8d2b84dbdcce506bb89bcc6bcb1c1eac8eccebee9","unit:8bf418d4fc0408b1dfdecb9229d54e2d116cc10ec35a7f79868bfa68a6b6f331","unit:9b69e83be5a7cc585b650d02b91a46d370c0975f1d8e36e23c01d5cda842a6c0","unit:a78ad2627bc4ae06c980ea555e128fa963c9cb1fdf556c43b1d74e561bd47bc5","unit:b0f54b3023614bced88e047d69903a371546cfdc2bc84e3a648ce3e91b3210b5","unit:b7a51c348451844081c096888323b6f7a4d5d165865add9e5134757f0699bb12","unit:b8cc0b9a3fca1b02e245b519445a233b70c20885671c271887358903c030962f","unit:bb12831bd39455956111c34e6a84baaaeb3b931c98c7241448f72e8fbc144289","unit:be37eb20c6c98412a6bbf24834b043fd2f3bfd30ebbe0cbf122d0e23cab669bd","unit:cf91b725b07424a6679bce3c68fa3efbf027372a64e5d242af1b3c59fbcd5fa9","unit:d6c2417475f95f0c572a910cd8a1e81ae9b75ae9aeac2ef7cb4d9e0edd9ea485","unit:d89f6f804ad2d7e18b142d8b7fedba3f60c25008eb5c779bbf319170c8af5f0f","unit:dc2ec632faed509abca4fd41b52e07a2cb6cbe07382ed18e662f491e5265b099","unit:e155604ccf4d992d26848f8b5bbc6ddcc815348f514d8fe8ca2e9df0f69152f6","unit:f828b293f70a49ede426d42d91be9892f2b38efbe33f95daafeb50cede79138a","unit:fe5099f6d8e04fc0668f5532430b0e12de178341568234800d6c5d3c95c87ffd"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4fc6e181bbaa8ab3e1261a9f","scopeContentSha256":"930c88f86d7c6ea8a5627173d6dc206a1dbc8467b751d2f57ebc7f15dd8eef0f","localRef":"s16"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f","scopeContentSha256":"6cc528912c1f18c1162cdb7868151e38b3047f52ec734fa2f59d4c82a1d10a3d","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l21","originalCandidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:18","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l21","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:18","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:4fc6e181bbaa8ab3e1261a9f","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l21","source":"s30","target":"s16","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["The thesis applies its period and Hodge-star approximations to flux stabilization, keeping polynomial self-duality and exponentially corrected F-term treatments distinct."],"challengeStatement":"The thesis applies Hodge and period approximations to flux stabilization, distinguishing polynomial self-duality from exponentially corrected F-terms.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3965339798d71b33ab5ee48539d5a115edc6b34a7faab02eddde739ad75f3688","reply.jsonSha256":"7644da5fce58517e3221a765f17a1aa001ce05e45d1104d6a56c038eda498fd3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c75590e1700e60606f892a4bff0180cdd637c210e56999144734d092c912aa15","receipt.jsonSha256":"677688246447085846b344a6f17c725446cc72ef74ae734c48d4b83cd95575de","normalization.jsonSha256":"b7ee6b02b7b74616a7a0e5fc9978834ed599cff4c6988a470863edabac99df96","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4b4d97dc13bcc60a381f267b5de5e3d90ddafd18f817d63874b0970f4f3a1032"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1fd91c573564255cac4f2a90ce27bc09560fcbe642c76ea21ed514364b5f4cfd","reply.jsonSha256":"d1ee2097387a6094e506534262542448b8cfdfd5f1a876f40d2142b8c3eae0d3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7fff57d73701936f8a6700c378cce374efce17f30bc917dd65ca68b535b7437f","receipt.jsonSha256":"6044fc47ccaaa90fb4447257c33abb6eb8f70157d4d523ab0449fafa1cb6cb04","normalization.jsonSha256":"a70efad348d4e671a33683f9125fbeb539d35206f453dda5889880f091496aec"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f"},{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4fc6e181bbaa8ab3e1261a9f"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f"},{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4fc6e181bbaa8ab3e1261a9f"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d21","originalRef":"l21","status":"route","source":"s16","target":"s30","type":"application_of","title":"Trace flux-stabilization approximations to period and Hodge-star reconstruction","rationale":"Both statements describe flux stabilization as an application of period and Hodge-star approximations. They also explicitly distinguish polynomial self-duality from exponentially corrected F-term treatments.","qualification":"Retain the specified asymptotic boundary data, growth sectors, flux and tadpole restrictions. Polynomial self-duality approximations do not replace the essential exponential corrections required by the stated F-term treatment. Auxiliary constructions without an assumed geometric realization do not automatically furnish compactification vacua. This application supplies no general all-boundary flux-finiteness result, completed controlled vacuum or universal uplift prescription.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l21","s16","s30"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d21","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The paired statements directly identify flux stabilization as an application of period and Hodge-star approximations. The reversed direction and application_of type are supported. The qualification preserves polynomial self-duality versus exponentially corrected F-term treatments and does not turn auxiliary constructions into completed compactification vacua.","refs":["l21","s16","s30"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l21","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l22":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l22","source":"q025-candidate-question:853de7f0a8e55cb55e507432","target":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f","type":"application_of","title":"Trace the two-parameter enumerative outputs to their mirror calculation","rationale":"Both statements connect the two-parameter mirror calculation to reported genus-zero Yukawa expansions and genus-one instanton data. These enumerative outputs form a specified application of special-geometry computation.","qualification":"Keep the two-parameter model and its continuous-instanton-family qualifications. Genus-zero Yukawa expansions and genus-one instanton data remain different outputs. The connection does not supply a general higher-genus or refined algorithm, identify GW-type and GV invariants without their definitions, or transfer local-Fano assumptions to compact models. It also does not establish coordinate-independent genus-one subtraction or turn curve-moduli intersection theory into a Calabi–Yau moduli calculation.","evidenceIds":["unit:05bbd28d938b41d04f3cff01ca15658911eecbbf83ffcc4791b18b3856f6b669","unit:0ab89e9b3e058896b7c2ce5a4532d38d77d794d6b411df04b66072275988539a","unit:0edccf4b857f5780a8658e34ffb5b7c45a16532680c6eb884c9e29ad1f87074d","unit:36ddd47530f27d6f8387f25249bf58fcbb3caf8ff0ebf806a253f35bc09f6db1","unit:3930d3016d5fce2f6edd9af5dfe2beadbfce9dc299691f330b50846041efae6f","unit:394ea8d3adc525d1ea1ed5942e57d7dc169767d9f191f15bf489878004e5cbca","unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","unit:514e9fbcafd6f182ff959a6f4ccd8339fef63f96bd87be6784404499d2d7b740","unit:66deadaab3f05d064af6e0027be417d703874e84769eb704e15befc1eff85a2f","unit:7ef040afb8643c699191e0f5fcb788413d8b6d52eec8676289a07d9ec012b979","unit:813cf2c8954e5625db37bed7a025af91ee01f2c8be3c01de426b7109631e00e4","unit:8b9c004a724a8483584fffa388160dded2a29d89f23ade79930d5ac7bd3b8285","unit:8c02721c4a1e664ed61e985624acf69533c7fdc696b37e9dce3e001f11d4f784","unit:926b345c92affb58b9589a950142ae23a51f3801b52561f92b8ad7ae0109f605","unit:b1815e733e5816d59225b9844f227c4539d9efe9e4c8bb9061fa5652500ff444","unit:c4afbfb40dcef8a1e2dcfdb45a2759c2934d07703b11563935b8fd4dfaa60ca8","unit:cb95eb9c9a2e4dfc478e7da2079600014e592a8c9f790932d740b44550510a13","unit:d3cf19ebc8ba07e11a83b9cf7262613fde4bd2b5dc6a2e506bf2d564f7103259","unit:dfc783fe2ea4f4878ebd5e35492933f697a98391cdf293134833a85f2cc3a929","unit:eb93831a574a4443eebb99ed809a2b21834d853534607a4e594cd9ac01cbcfcb","unit:f828b293f70a49ede426d42d91be9892f2b38efbe33f95daafeb50cede79138a","unit:fb906e38bba20f653f3b017293cf856fea4f6251b35bc934d801411d50d0a22e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:853de7f0a8e55cb55e507432","scopeContentSha256":"1191edf288d92ccd85517cd18375cb8a461efbb866a004d1bb799b1c84f3f849","localRef":"s24"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f","scopeContentSha256":"ffdcdfd43bf16c41d677b405ceb912250a1923a77812c9d1330dc83c149354e4","localRef":"s0"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l22","originalCandidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:16","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l22","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:16","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:853de7f0a8e55cb55e507432","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l22","source":"s0","target":"s24","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["The supplied two-parameter mirror calculation produces genus-zero Yukawa expansions and genus-one instanton data, connecting special geometry to distinct enumerative outputs."],"challengeStatement":"The two-parameter mirror study reports genus-zero Yukawa expansions and genus-one instanton data, with continuous-family qualifications retained.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3965339798d71b33ab5ee48539d5a115edc6b34a7faab02eddde739ad75f3688","reply.jsonSha256":"7644da5fce58517e3221a765f17a1aa001ce05e45d1104d6a56c038eda498fd3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c75590e1700e60606f892a4bff0180cdd637c210e56999144734d092c912aa15","receipt.jsonSha256":"677688246447085846b344a6f17c725446cc72ef74ae734c48d4b83cd95575de","normalization.jsonSha256":"b7ee6b02b7b74616a7a0e5fc9978834ed599cff4c6988a470863edabac99df96","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4b4d97dc13bcc60a381f267b5de5e3d90ddafd18f817d63874b0970f4f3a1032"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1fd91c573564255cac4f2a90ce27bc09560fcbe642c76ea21ed514364b5f4cfd","reply.jsonSha256":"d1ee2097387a6094e506534262542448b8cfdfd5f1a876f40d2142b8c3eae0d3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7fff57d73701936f8a6700c378cce374efce17f30bc917dd65ca68b535b7437f","receipt.jsonSha256":"6044fc47ccaaa90fb4447257c33abb6eb8f70157d4d523ab0449fafa1cb6cb04","normalization.jsonSha256":"a70efad348d4e671a33683f9125fbeb539d35206f453dda5889880f091496aec"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9308083","sourceId":"ev:9aff1274fe681364d5122471cf146f51","sourceSha256":"b2873b3bc60dfa79bfb5b78033ebb3163a60978e18170d2633c706a5a6dba6da","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5c984a2fb53acdc9d0ad/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d6d7f8dba0ece3c0b734819d654339007e1d53cb37a16c6a38b526decef5da95","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"fec7d3899c3e9510a43176aae4ead0b96668b903830dee57ecbff394cbf008ac","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9308083","sourceId":"ev:b1887dcf106e0d72e8b90ad351cdf3ac","sourceSha256":"b2873b3bc60dfa79bfb5b78033ebb3163a60978e18170d2633c706a5a6dba6da","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5c984a2fb53acdc9d0ad/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d6d7f8dba0ece3c0b734819d654339007e1d53cb37a16c6a38b526decef5da95","pdfPage":1,"start":111,"end":2352,"textSha256":"da616b672c7bf09e7a11c08591a71a332bbdd0c0ce3ebf9e2c32e0d3218cbc88","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f"},{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:853de7f0a8e55cb55e507432"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9308083","sourceId":"ev:9aff1274fe681364d5122471cf146f51","sourceSha256":"b2873b3bc60dfa79bfb5b78033ebb3163a60978e18170d2633c706a5a6dba6da","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5c984a2fb53acdc9d0ad/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d6d7f8dba0ece3c0b734819d654339007e1d53cb37a16c6a38b526decef5da95","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"fec7d3899c3e9510a43176aae4ead0b96668b903830dee57ecbff394cbf008ac","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9308083","sourceId":"ev:b1887dcf106e0d72e8b90ad351cdf3ac","sourceSha256":"b2873b3bc60dfa79bfb5b78033ebb3163a60978e18170d2633c706a5a6dba6da","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5c984a2fb53acdc9d0ad/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d6d7f8dba0ece3c0b734819d654339007e1d53cb37a16c6a38b526decef5da95","pdfPage":1,"start":111,"end":2352,"textSha256":"da616b672c7bf09e7a11c08591a71a332bbdd0c0ce3ebf9e2c32e0d3218cbc88","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0601142aff7dcb4e3f7fe71f"},{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:853de7f0a8e55cb55e507432"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d22","originalRef":"l22","status":"route","source":"s24","target":"s0","type":"application_of","title":"Trace the two-parameter enumerative outputs to their mirror calculation","rationale":"Both statements connect the two-parameter mirror calculation to reported genus-zero Yukawa expansions and genus-one instanton data. These enumerative outputs form a specified application of special-geometry computation.","qualification":"Keep the two-parameter model and its continuous-instanton-family qualifications. Genus-zero Yukawa expansions and genus-one instanton data remain different outputs. The connection does not supply a general higher-genus or refined algorithm, identify GW-type and GV invariants without their definitions, or transfer local-Fano assumptions to compact models. It also does not establish coordinate-independent genus-one subtraction or turn curve-moduli intersection theory into a Calabi–Yau moduli calculation.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l22","s24","s0"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d22","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements connect the specified two-parameter mirror calculation to its reported genus-zero and genus-one outputs. The enumerative application therefore points to the computational construction. The qualification preserves continuous-instanton-family restrictions and separate output types without claiming a general higher-genus, refined or regularization method.","refs":["l22","s24","s0"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l22","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l23":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l23","source":"q025-candidate-question:5f32da21add50f21c423db3b","target":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","type":"method_for","title":"Use the specific integrable-model realization of Hodge horizontality","rationale":"Both statements identify a specific Hodge-horizontality bridge rather than a general identification of integrable models with compactification dynamics. The integrable-model construction supplies a method for that Hodge-theoretic component.","qualification":"Restrict the connection to the stated classical realization for a one-complex-parameter polarized Hodge variation, with its specified field identification. The separate η- and λ-deformed constructions retain their distinct roles. A one-parameter Hodge variation need not be a degeneration limit. Generic integrable sigma models are not thereby assigned Calabi–Yau targets or compactification interpretations, and no general equivalence with Calabi–Yau moduli dynamics is asserted.","evidenceIds":["unit:05bbd28d938b41d04f3cff01ca15658911eecbbf83ffcc4791b18b3856f6b669","unit:0edccf4b857f5780a8658e34ffb5b7c45a16532680c6eb884c9e29ad1f87074d","unit:33b36eacf43db41ff24702c6acc6ba57a537026a8fc55603faf2e29639127705","unit:3c655520a19086df6f3842790db8abfd8c34f23a48099ba365ae397c773abbef","unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","unit:7ef040afb8643c699191e0f5fcb788413d8b6d52eec8676289a07d9ec012b979","unit:813cf2c8954e5625db37bed7a025af91ee01f2c8be3c01de426b7109631e00e4","unit:850c29f54e32d2a856365f4591f54b68ada0145a45e1fcd94ee70a84d627998a","unit:900197a6338402a2648d408ebd1102cc85b8a9fdee39044eb0ddfe7e3fe3159f","unit:b1815e733e5816d59225b9844f227c4539d9efe9e4c8bb9061fa5652500ff444","unit:ce116363ae5dbc5affb70c1a90cb569dc922c376b4c648b0e5b595f01b5eda1d","unit:ceacc1288d61f5788a47aab20a4b595bf8311daef46a5f7898867d1a0c534b39","unit:eab949d69b116940af5c4b05cc74e2ed1b98aa97fc9a042cd106c9d2868d5591","unit:eb93831a574a4443eebb99ed809a2b21834d853534607a4e594cd9ac01cbcfcb","unit:f182013d41945ecf2c359580c83478ca280a6da821b08eb86b227c2aeb3c0a03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5f32da21add50f21c423db3b","scopeContentSha256":"25d029fc5adf0605b47651a955ba0e8c0827ccc85fda9860c7fb4ebc508bff8d","localRef":"s18"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","scopeContentSha256":"f3ed7d3385858adaef42ec0fbe9014d241cdd01bedb9d40d653cbd19e4aaeb4c","localRef":"s3"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l23","originalCandidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:20","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l23","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:20","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:5f32da21add50f21c423db3b","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l23","source":"s3","target":"s18","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["The child record supplies a specific Hodge-horizontality bridge to integrable models. Generic integrable sigma models retain their alternate home."],"challengeStatement":"The child record supplies a specific Hodge-horizontality connection, without identifying generic integrable models with compactification dynamics.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3965339798d71b33ab5ee48539d5a115edc6b34a7faab02eddde739ad75f3688","reply.jsonSha256":"7644da5fce58517e3221a765f17a1aa001ce05e45d1104d6a56c038eda498fd3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c75590e1700e60606f892a4bff0180cdd637c210e56999144734d092c912aa15","receipt.jsonSha256":"677688246447085846b344a6f17c725446cc72ef74ae734c48d4b83cd95575de","normalization.jsonSha256":"b7ee6b02b7b74616a7a0e5fc9978834ed599cff4c6988a470863edabac99df96","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4b4d97dc13bcc60a381f267b5de5e3d90ddafd18f817d63874b0970f4f3a1032"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1fd91c573564255cac4f2a90ce27bc09560fcbe642c76ea21ed514364b5f4cfd","reply.jsonSha256":"d1ee2097387a6094e506534262542448b8cfdfd5f1a876f40d2142b8c3eae0d3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7fff57d73701936f8a6700c378cce374efce17f30bc917dd65ca68b535b7437f","receipt.jsonSha256":"6044fc47ccaaa90fb4447257c33abb6eb8f70157d4d523ab0449fafa1cb6cb04","normalization.jsonSha256":"a70efad348d4e671a33683f9125fbeb539d35206f453dda5889880f091496aec"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c"},{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5f32da21add50f21c423db3b"},{"ref":"c1","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c"},{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5f32da21add50f21c423db3b"},{"ref":"c1","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d23","originalRef":"l23","status":"route","source":"s18","target":"s3","type":"method_for","title":"Use the specific integrable-model realization of Hodge horizontality","rationale":"Both statements identify a specific Hodge-horizontality bridge rather than a general identification of integrable models with compactification dynamics. The integrable-model construction supplies a method for that Hodge-theoretic component.","qualification":"Restrict the connection to the stated classical realization for a one-complex-parameter polarized Hodge variation, with its specified field identification. The separate η- and λ-deformed constructions retain their distinct roles. A one-parameter Hodge variation need not be a degeneration limit. Generic integrable sigma models are not thereby assigned Calabi–Yau targets or compactification interpretations, and no general equivalence with Calabi–Yau moduli dynamics is asserted.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l23","s18","s3"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d23","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The supplied scopes identify a specific classical integrable-model realization of one-parameter Hodge horizontality, supporting the reversed method_for direction. The qualification preserves this limited bridge, distinguishes the deformation mechanisms and avoids identifying generic integrable models with Calabi–Yau compactification dynamics or degeneration limits.","refs":["l23","s18","s3"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l23","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l24":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l24","source":"q025-candidate-question:457e7c669d5a2f170c3f5eeb","target":"q025-candidate-question:4fc6e181bbaa8ab3e1261a9f","type":"method_for","title":"Compute geometric ingredients for compactification and stabilization studies","rationale":"Both statements place divisor, orientifold and fourfold data on the ingredient-supplying side of model building. Their computation provides methodological support without establishing a complete controlled vacuum.","qualification":"Retain square-free-divisor restrictions where stated, h^{1,1}≤4 for the earlier orientifold search and restricted tadpole tests for later candidates. Threefold orientifold and fourfold compactification sectors have separate premises; asymptotic flux approximations retain their specified regimes. Divisor or zero-mode suitability does not establish a universal nonperturbative superpotential. Passing a restricted consistency test does not certify a completed vacuum, inflationary trajectory or unrestricted phenomenological viability.","evidenceIds":["unit:09d06335e9b64a473fd1a0c3dc59991b20c22cc0d18d183d660ab2feaa6eda99","unit:189d328113ae8ef0d556e178ac8ff1d68b6be130a6ced75391b9b8a8c07d37f4","unit:1c1ad30792d620719abb4c6029c16fe984a2c64ebd3db4b9baf8275f67463db3","unit:241b393da38ca346513787f2c63893881df0e2a7c99b84ecc9daa3c1888387df","unit:2a257f8d2e1e110d5144a69538f05774415390166c6663ed8b76faf2cd246753","unit:2a318d6c0fc4e76b1e37c89ec6a8a9ef51a3024035014ffbfe3c2de85e42d31b","unit:483ff39dacd71a9860789143ef29bee0d63809e46622adf9ee48b19c0ea87b08","unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","unit:607449b0becda7913f5460edcd6273d76e0abd251caac4e3807821921b05077f","unit:7ac289a3947291f77391fdcd5f25b0cac69463df0caf1f6d5e14bd512ea3a2fa","unit:86c85340901a5cc3cac841c8d2b84dbdcce506bb89bcc6bcb1c1eac8eccebee9","unit:b0f54b3023614bced88e047d69903a371546cfdc2bc84e3a648ce3e91b3210b5","unit:b7a51c348451844081c096888323b6f7a4d5d165865add9e5134757f0699bb12","unit:b8cc0b9a3fca1b02e245b519445a233b70c20885671c271887358903c030962f","unit:bb12831bd39455956111c34e6a84baaaeb3b931c98c7241448f72e8fbc144289","unit:ca38faac68878d449e72a3b4c2d2e2136ed6ae628e89891cc28f489cf397152c","unit:cf91b725b07424a6679bce3c68fa3efbf027372a64e5d242af1b3c59fbcd5fa9","unit:d89f6f804ad2d7e18b142d8b7fedba3f60c25008eb5c779bbf319170c8af5f0f","unit:f828b293f70a49ede426d42d91be9892f2b38efbe33f95daafeb50cede79138a","unit:fe5099f6d8e04fc0668f5532430b0e12de178341568234800d6c5d3c95c87ffd"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:457e7c669d5a2f170c3f5eeb","scopeContentSha256":"56d49e6e95bc9dbfd5cd80ed4234a31c4c2c8dec9523c87ebd7186a79827b03a","localRef":"s12"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4fc6e181bbaa8ab3e1261a9f","scopeContentSha256":"930c88f86d7c6ea8a5627173d6dc206a1dbc8467b751d2f57ebc7f15dd8eef0f","localRef":"s16"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l24","originalCandidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:22","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l24","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:22","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:4fc6e181bbaa8ab3e1261a9f","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:457e7c669d5a2f170c3f5eeb","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l24","source":"s16","target":"s12","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Divisor, orientifold and fourfold data supply geometric ingredients for model building. Suitability of those ingredients is weaker than constructing a controlled vacuum."],"challengeStatement":"Divisor, orientifold and fourfold data supply model-building ingredients whose suitability does not establish a complete controlled vacuum.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3965339798d71b33ab5ee48539d5a115edc6b34a7faab02eddde739ad75f3688","reply.jsonSha256":"7644da5fce58517e3221a765f17a1aa001ce05e45d1104d6a56c038eda498fd3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c75590e1700e60606f892a4bff0180cdd637c210e56999144734d092c912aa15","receipt.jsonSha256":"677688246447085846b344a6f17c725446cc72ef74ae734c48d4b83cd95575de","normalization.jsonSha256":"b7ee6b02b7b74616a7a0e5fc9978834ed599cff4c6988a470863edabac99df96","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4b4d97dc13bcc60a381f267b5de5e3d90ddafd18f817d63874b0970f4f3a1032"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1fd91c573564255cac4f2a90ce27bc09560fcbe642c76ea21ed514364b5f4cfd","reply.jsonSha256":"d1ee2097387a6094e506534262542448b8cfdfd5f1a876f40d2142b8c3eae0d3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7fff57d73701936f8a6700c378cce374efce17f30bc917dd65ca68b535b7437f","receipt.jsonSha256":"6044fc47ccaaa90fb4447257c33abb6eb8f70157d4d523ab0449fafa1cb6cb04","normalization.jsonSha256":"a70efad348d4e671a33683f9125fbeb539d35206f453dda5889880f091496aec"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4fc6e181bbaa8ab3e1261a9f"},{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:457e7c669d5a2f170c3f5eeb"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4fc6e181bbaa8ab3e1261a9f"},{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:457e7c669d5a2f170c3f5eeb"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d24","originalRef":"l24","status":"route","source":"s12","target":"s16","type":"method_for","title":"Compute geometric ingredients for compactification and stabilization studies","rationale":"Both statements place divisor, orientifold and fourfold data on the ingredient-supplying side of model building. Their computation provides methodological support without establishing a complete controlled vacuum.","qualification":"Retain square-free-divisor restrictions where stated, h^{1,1}≤4 for the earlier orientifold search and restricted tadpole tests for later candidates. Threefold orientifold and fourfold compactification sectors have separate premises; asymptotic flux approximations retain their specified regimes. Divisor or zero-mode suitability does not establish a universal nonperturbative superpotential. Passing a restricted consistency test does not certify a completed vacuum, inflationary trajectory or unrestricted phenomenological viability.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l24","s12","s16"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d24","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements assign divisor, orientifold and fourfold computations the role of supplying model-building ingredients. s12 → s16 is therefore a supported method_for route. The qualification preserves the search and tadpole restrictions and correctly separates geometric suitability from a controlled vacuum or inflationary construction.","refs":["l24","s12","s16"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l24","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l25":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l25","source":"q025-candidate-question:875e439e55eb5ed9df26b4f0","target":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","type":"application_of","title":"Ground distance and degeneration-path questions in moduli geometry","rationale":"The paired statements identify moduli geometry as support for distance and degeneration questions while separating that geometric application from evidence for a physical tower population. The distance question therefore points to the underlying geometric framework.","qualification":"Retain the particular path, boundary intersection, fixed-volume or infinite-volume regime and geometric identifications. A long trajectory need not be a large physical distance, and a candidate charge tower need not be an infinite stable particle spectrum. Hyperbolic comparisons retain their approximation conditions and unresolved transcription or normalization issues; no metric-error bound or cited Hodge-theory proof is supplied. The route supports the geometric questions without claiming those missing spectral or approximation results.","evidenceIds":["unit:05bbd28d938b41d04f3cff01ca15658911eecbbf83ffcc4791b18b3856f6b669","unit:0edccf4b857f5780a8658e34ffb5b7c45a16532680c6eb884c9e29ad1f87074d","unit:2408069d42b416683d2be24ab8f2deb3d7320127cc4955e4a347e3b24b95b57e","unit:241b393da38ca346513787f2c63893881df0e2a7c99b84ecc9daa3c1888387df","unit:33b36eacf43db41ff24702c6acc6ba57a537026a8fc55603faf2e29639127705","unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","unit:534f7499f9b76f4b96665e52cecfaaf7ac5c6a4e41d27d41c8f63f0001f85a38","unit:5a35faef10809421e97973027775fce29956f536b44edd8eb90e2a1eef4db98a","unit:61d9180c493feca279e8041eb4cdb977737e2a27d68a8e8fd866e8952b96dc66","unit:6a3677aa7cf281ab3f468e287ceab2987a7fc741dc4ef5652ecd3dfd94af089e","unit:6ec6ffd84ded2c0e9b74ef79eb197622ad7b1e7b109cc2b25f33a5afb0769411","unit:75f9c2f19169fb59f5b50626b9ee06001460db1d1ab96b4f0adce5e2f732b637","unit:761d3bf5bbd9609b14253b3c88ca97fce49a5a28e697f560a21d856682e03c21","unit:7ef040afb8643c699191e0f5fcb788413d8b6d52eec8676289a07d9ec012b979","unit:813cf2c8954e5625db37bed7a025af91ee01f2c8be3c01de426b7109631e00e4","unit:850c29f54e32d2a856365f4591f54b68ada0145a45e1fcd94ee70a84d627998a","unit:8ec3c4b73571077c06ed4177a0b7d62212c1ad43b7dc77993b3f28128362435a","unit:900197a6338402a2648d408ebd1102cc85b8a9fdee39044eb0ddfe7e3fe3159f","unit:a70f42a4852ae248ff74c397527455dc4f859ae788a997ae3c25070ec92e7915","unit:a919be738b6ef2cfc56f54b37fbdd2edfca89d095085ac197ebecf1bea03d0dc","unit:b1815e733e5816d59225b9844f227c4539d9efe9e4c8bb9061fa5652500ff444","unit:be37eb20c6c98412a6bbf24834b043fd2f3bfd30ebbe0cbf122d0e23cab669bd","unit:c1cd13180060890188c0a77d6dd5c8dedf9f636c2f3ae41d0c054e5c39cef7fe","unit:cc4341720b0e1b089abb0621ada9ab548f22a8c1ae82706ed31ec76151a5f027","unit:ce116363ae5dbc5affb70c1a90cb569dc922c376b4c648b0e5b595f01b5eda1d","unit:ceacc1288d61f5788a47aab20a4b595bf8311daef46a5f7898867d1a0c534b39","unit:d6c2417475f95f0c572a910cd8a1e81ae9b75ae9aeac2ef7cb4d9e0edd9ea485","unit:e155604ccf4d992d26848f8b5bbc6ddcc815348f514d8fe8ca2e9df0f69152f6","unit:eab949d69b116940af5c4b05cc74e2ed1b98aa97fc9a042cd106c9d2868d5591","unit:eb93831a574a4443eebb99ed809a2b21834d853534607a4e594cd9ac01cbcfcb","unit:f182013d41945ecf2c359580c83478ca280a6da821b08eb86b227c2aeb3c0a03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:875e439e55eb5ed9df26b4f0","scopeContentSha256":"df7c78e17724c72b3c847428ab78061b329238f2af76ae27ad01af6d47f6b448","localRef":"s25"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","scopeContentSha256":"f3ed7d3385858adaef42ec0fbe9014d241cdd01bedb9d40d653cbd19e4aaeb4c","localRef":"s3"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l25","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge:link:55","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l25","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge:link:55","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:875e439e55eb5ed9df26b4f0","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l25","source":"s3","target":"s25","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Distances and degeneration paths supply questions about light spectra, but geometry alone does not establish an infinite stable particle tower."],"challengeStatement":"Moduli geometry supports distance and degeneration questions, while physical tower population requires additional evidence.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"243e04cb28fb6b33bfa96e5eda4d54ca7f1af343e60a821fc67fc105dacfc45b","reply.jsonSha256":"30542dfa624ec89da090e90cf75243da344b32667b277b842ff6cfc654e3aae9","reply.raw.txtSha256":"90b5218bf434a1bfd0c3c1a4d90b8a95a14083ffa4069b7dfe20a16415ab1c11","receipt.jsonSha256":"0fccda43a0971b62d8848ab0ad4ebeae6037b46c45d16ff74a926a773d5f9130","normalization.jsonSha256":"0fc716054d79dd485b69df4e844a187e894e107e53f8694fade7d1b275ed2f6b","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"36b507a45e5ca7df9a0b02fd3fecda404fd0015d22c1a0481b6543582d9ce085"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d02c7ad219c09349e8dcd8124489895af1160579f70282385fc4ab9d9d91ceb0","reply.jsonSha256":"58b5a1301ca2cc8c0e3afef0cbb3dbe2895f9ea425f190878005d66c38458866","reply.raw.txtSha256":"615df2ea57a4fa7bd3c370739d3932d381c2a4e45e87b6acc0096f19c8c21e93","receipt.jsonSha256":"d564d588a101901971c349d0e9e8529d8606a15b8a4a1cf0c61ef4d5b70e8351","normalization.jsonSha256":"af448248cdc4776f7d865f22db7dd34f9c5f22d82789725f0b6c4d6b2bb95deb"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c"},{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:875e439e55eb5ed9df26b4f0"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b14c13b6517e3740290499c"},{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:875e439e55eb5ed9df26b4f0"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d25","originalRef":"l25","status":"route","source":"s25","target":"s3","type":"application_of","title":"Ground distance and degeneration-path questions in moduli geometry","rationale":"The paired statements identify moduli geometry as support for distance and degeneration questions while separating that geometric application from evidence for a physical tower population. The distance question therefore points to the underlying geometric framework.","qualification":"Retain the particular path, boundary intersection, fixed-volume or infinite-volume regime and geometric identifications. A long trajectory need not be a large physical distance, and a candidate charge tower need not be an infinite stable particle spectrum. Hyperbolic comparisons retain their approximation conditions and unresolved transcription or normalization issues; no metric-error bound or cited Hodge-theory proof is supplied. The route supports the geometric questions without claiming those missing spectral or approximation results.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l25","s25","s3"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d25","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The paired statements support applying moduli geometry to distance and degeneration-path questions while separating physical tower population from geometric data. The reversed application_of route retains that limited connection. Its qualification explicitly preserves identification effects, stability requirements and the unresolved hyperbolic approximation and normalization issues.","refs":["l25","s25","s3"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l25","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l26":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l26","source":"q025-candidate-question:2064d452abd633e46ee9dab6","target":"q025-candidate-question:2b36ffea88e1a286094c95b4","type":"method_for","title":"Use boundary, cycle and defect data for gauge-symmetry diagnostics","rationale":"Both statements identify boundary, cycle and defect data as symmetry diagnostics. This assigns the methodological role to the topology-and-defect question for the relevant gauge-symmetry questions.","qualification":"Restrict the method to the specified F-theory geometry and boundary, relative-cycle, defect and tangential-structure data relevant to the gauge question. Bare topological labels need not fix exceptional configurations; the cobordism material does not supply an established ADE reconstruction or gauge classification, and resolution is not assumed to erase all ADE information. Primitive normalization, spectator sectors, massless versus full spectra and four- versus six-dimensional questions remain distinct. No massless-spectrum theorem or automatic identification of Mordell–Weil torsion with a discrete gauge factor follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:009a97c9bd0438d8007d5f324214cedbc0394751e84aa8726bb0051898f7a735","unit:01f6f5cdf3258742c388557e1648ea448e9ec7025140d7de68cb5c7b79c59977","unit:024c45aa65921f523c9c9e6538ec1de6c3b6d86241330fa88258951d08553cd3","unit:0334476ae9bdc3c6912b9e27fe1325f676c81673457496e7f0744882b5ebec3e","unit:064e45cac359c65b5666e5cdabea82f8e2ce81376982c45a5c8c063117e250ce","unit:090675c75fa59dbfb73061ef516269c6fd825f69c99730c21d551c0ec555f67c","unit:11d8ecc9fb6def1d7a502d5d55709b8a49e21fd0dfe691d9b4e726f26057d4e4","unit:1788eb01b7b4a05fdf886568bc54bedb6bf649f65a82274519663ba15ef93081","unit:17bbd9b324ff8bf50bb47b9fda91e6a905bd747807cbd9a9f7ebcb2a2846e8ca","unit:20da9e3e4dbfc4aaebef4140f030b7bbce8b79f2cb11680d3f04b20e3d3cc683","unit:2793ed6ed7d56b5a2c63d570a06251c46bea77223d76c372b00814e06298b979","unit:27bf0ae30f01baefed5448a8c22d5292161f146fd0b3ead30647b83dd8492cd8","unit:29f58c0df74a99486c0296eb8ebeeb809fcf76c1aaca8b0f60bee299e74f59ad","unit:361df604ba5328c7d1771a430d86cdf1e44e83b6992919265579446149d26390","unit:3932aaff54f8a52b0e5b64206215ea8fe809267cabe666ea9171a5dd2ebf9679","unit:488753670c6b95f1284d22fdf3dedbd30108cc350291e80578236cfb0a7504d1","unit:50ebe5f7384b22730362ffd66d8b7a84862d258f1cd9482a6e096bfc5d52c03f","unit:542b89b2e04a1050224cf742809dc9d4268f7e1469c917acb511bbe7a0ca4cb1","unit:624a5892d56b5465fac25c5f934786fa7390feba5469f26614780f0b1d906a1b","unit:64073d460e9947b4d617783f550fa09bfefcf56173af4c6775bc9a126c9223d8","unit:64b165e250ad5aea142212effd21b71676306d7f2fd112483710edd4303a7f65","unit:66b424b0879cdfa17d04127979f131e6a4b562e7a8424b7b7b0fce270741496f","unit:788d93ae80f68d06cb4f6a3d2684ee37e27e21f25503ffc2bf4dbedf004564dd","unit:7ea7f38f3938ca2c54a9cf97b3a14334f0bb1a575cd25ab04749b960b347f9d1","unit:82c46e2e74a787e9f09927af50573aa8463f1de4a2dd8e45c88c32d3918cad66","unit:834e6ce9fdaf1f6476f4ab2c41eab69d9756a2b2da870c8c981face6c50a8e7d","unit:879295a827bbe7f626a2146b5493ea607a7241153b5c25481369d14d884241cb","unit:8eec0c77f59652fd6f5185f1449cc02af06772f63b121e85b9d9f098a218a72c","unit:9ac405cbc23d7b1cd08a5ebc9c267d3d8c6dd5c75836986aca234212e2e73d47","unit:aaa39aa867c2a2c06f371744a24780020d9152ae24d7d508cd335be2dec98a18","unit:aae4b0f56cce7273a57b5e334a19b0509b6c71dfd5b68e7d68623ca2244503e2","unit:ad0fdac4e5e03791d68a361cc73b6be224d9441f033f091f95fa7760cd600809","unit:badec2337c13522ea3f6764cf9f089669d3a5c15d599ca6f1657b05151a5902e","unit:bb149664d0ef7c6d2ea1020c0d2e69dedec5bc692a77f52cbaec5aeda633406d","unit:bdc8ddf7099a72b2173d5f4641bc755cf098b17ba56f1146d4f9b2bea80d7a9e","unit:bea1e5fd90673aecc87bff3f9e92c1137e0eb80e6cbec8e81588944e9a809e6d","unit:bf4f96dbac6614961d5ed89ae5b3feb7664a221f78bb1ec716063aaeff1b79b5","unit:c80434e168d8a9dbe5c3ff3778968b12bb61b1b93c1095f4e9119a0e982ad072","unit:c824a5d9e0917f51aeec984ae58bbbecf1819f7751f46807d3572a388e1ee9b0","unit:cb8d828a1208bc56dd18cb564739142668844dff064eb4d77faef326c7cd856b","unit:d691b4612957c7121d247034a0fce7c63385f0b0bff071288706c23724af5523","unit:d87aa3e4a392eabccb94c44680454d6e26dcaf7b7548829b605e372b1d1a1997","unit:e0d7d83390d7f64bae6c28402f430690c426e77f694a7a7ea0a3e05f6a0c2672","unit:e6ddd0335bcba1625e7b2ab499631cb04de96022189eb7775367295a73518d3c","unit:e84e0869206d6e5a86edec9a3e7a37419ef104c58a64210c528603b8023443d9","unit:f94d6fa30216ecd51c07a80a5c9a496bb716953438241ab01a4db6dae7c6e73c","unit:fc62ba68b23f858213b6bfb75b0f422f9cda1104584f92305f2b2d750ec17469"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2064d452abd633e46ee9dab6","scopeContentSha256":"c6a7f4aafa31b6a90b7596464ad77464aff3a0575caac0b1e59f623577984235","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2b36ffea88e1a286094c95b4","scopeContentSha256":"e950dccd194758c89edc1dbbac7002103c6357c9307d206484f1f7b740038981","localRef":"s7"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l26","originalCandidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:31","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l26","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:31","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:2b36ffea88e1a286094c95b4","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:2064d452abd633e46ee9dab6","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l26","source":"s7","target":"s5","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Boundary, cycle and defect data supply symmetry diagnostics; the proposed reconstruction claims retain their stated limitations."],"challengeStatement":"Boundary, cycle and defect data provide symmetry diagnostics; the reconstruction proposals retain their stated evidential limits.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"6d3a7df0596efe9916b43efec2dfe4f548e3067a1281a088ecd1cfd2d6f97080","reply.jsonSha256":"fea64bac072e650bfc4d15b6f9f837dafd36eb73f989803b2ecdd6bda9ffde93","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21d4d92a6189dc4c195fb915d00b0ab59bc7b327c63ea80639001fdc27a4f69a","receipt.jsonSha256":"3292ca6f2a135959cdead2514dbd2eb6ad6415eb79e6f114495a3c9ea513688a","normalization.jsonSha256":"41a1a38aa368407355f9e15d8fe25fa2415746cab070760d6244aec134c82ab8","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/adopted/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge/request.json","sha256":"c6fa93101222c87fbd5426fe416f787eecaada68658cd016ca6f243d3b449edb"},"originalChallengeDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge"},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/adopted/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"32a47a4de46ffd745f2cd68ad7068da6b6af07db892edfa5c539349f2be0d312","reply.jsonSha256":"bc61492ed7debc615fbeac069e663b8af12918cd689559d1ffb4dcec6c365380","reply.raw.txtSha256":"910c60854c32b0c8a94716a559d8a3b2427b66932a32aceed217c0a76fe3b22d","receipt.jsonSha256":"f92cf97b93df1ff22b2a13c93de2fcf421ce39315f82f35e49ecbc2b904c93df","normalization.jsonSha256":"07362ddb36fec6b6eaa01e8c8f9aa7088e3894e69e628c4c5d736aba6f40b147"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2b36ffea88e1a286094c95b4"},{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2064d452abd633e46ee9dab6"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2b36ffea88e1a286094c95b4"},{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2064d452abd633e46ee9dab6"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d26","originalRef":"l26","status":"route","source":"s5","target":"s7","type":"method_for","title":"Use boundary, cycle and defect data for gauge-symmetry diagnostics","rationale":"Both statements identify boundary, cycle and defect data as symmetry diagnostics. This assigns the methodological role to the topology-and-defect question for the relevant gauge-symmetry questions.","qualification":"Restrict the method to the specified F-theory geometry and boundary, relative-cycle, defect and tangential-structure data relevant to the gauge question. Bare topological labels need not fix exceptional configurations; the cobordism material does not supply an established ADE reconstruction or gauge classification, and resolution is not assumed to erase all ADE information. Primitive normalization, spectator sectors, massless versus full spectra and four- versus six-dimensional questions remain distinct. No massless-spectrum theorem or automatic identification of Mordell–Weil torsion with a discrete gauge factor follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l26","s5","s7"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d26","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements identify boundary, cycle and defect data as symmetry diagnostics, supporting a methodological route to the relevant gauge questions. The qualification confines that use to specified geometric data and preserves the provisional reconstruction status. It does not infer an established ADE classification, massless-spectrum theorem or discrete gauge factor.","refs":["l26","s5","s7"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l26","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l27":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l27","source":"q025-candidate-question:c0acabd5a23eb0c33269a155","target":"q025-candidate-question:691003b8ebd007f1f8b9daa3","type":"related_question","title":"Follow the 2013 heterotic connection to unification and supersymmetry-breaking scales","rationale":"Both statements establish a connection between heterotic stabilization choices and scale targets, with the challenge retaining the 2013 model assumptions. They do not specify a scale or threshold computation that fixes a method–application direction, so the construction-specific connection is retained.","qualification":"Limit the connection to the heterotic setting attributed to the October 2013 abstract and its stated model assumptions; the detailed scale argument is not reproduced here. Bundle, flux, perturbative and nonperturbative choices remain source-specific, and the reported difficulty of cosmological-constant tuning remains visible. Do not extend the link to M-theory on G2 spaces or identify unification with an infinite-distance limit. Exotic thresholds and supersymmetric decoupling require their own checks, and source-dated scale or phenomenological claims do not establish present viability.","evidenceIds":["unit:0d89e6397a2ab1feb8eef826a3ef2e8cb008a19b4aa6a707a6f4ae2ad2f499f8","unit:0de926982a3e0f6935b165bf94f93a2c1f1f70a001184481db4b38c51c737388","unit:0e46dac9a8bbfad89b46ceda568486f5a4a73a17ed6c4c172c517bf867cef35b","unit:0ea5bb44cc2e1ce92257b354e4b88b326d2d6c82f1292b5b502b2c38485d6de2","unit:22ffc3972aa8c769b35b8c929872578ca898a4845fce97110de2cae5f6c491bf","unit:2fe0572425293425e0f4976797e5515c14b3a49c23b1d0c5bfc78a19856c3fe8","unit:341b31a1bca54c469aaaf9e832febac6293e3ffd22d4d6dc44c4b1af7d9b0553","unit:3b09e54a274927f2c34a1d611038338fba1b702b94a1c37245f4a1504da9bc5a","unit:4bebd8a18c0c7e0dc291320f631e74c7d0657a1eae814a5eec1a9227db10504b","unit:4de67551c67b638657b557465ee5d01d95659ed0b14b2af60137fa583d8cd918","unit:624b3ad67e82b2e1d64e5f9f09876f067303350560b9459a4268ec933d12cd85","unit:7ac65b368d2c38c07107174d51bebe9d718187fe8468789ff9c21b09bec2208f","unit:7b8d9af78b1b22ed2a1850e14fbe76ec06254b9fd6edb2b22d2bc550b4ed624c","unit:7bd46e4bb20f874a55c43c49155420ab0802bc4e873966e51dd5aec5fa1264cc","unit:860181a797d826158a1112e7333c5e3136ec4996b2005d0e8dae0039509c48a6","unit:8c9bf28814def9152b7c4ba22df81eafc0b1724e08091f253f515b2f142a2837","unit:a1ea638d2f995cee9e86a190a5e6a5c2d87592e6069f413844c349dd036ddb14","unit:ad5dc3b6424e5d800f8c6e587c2f9e8883a1a854fdc7ff97d02c789cea9f1b8b","unit:c6a1073f257771182ee6c752df9d758d285869f30b3eb586d19027a23e071add","unit:c6d389ddb4a9a568449263e6ad277956629af429d18916349b16e7428ce6770e","unit:c7789ae0fa5ba7c74c2067db0890be3063985ee3c1729f874f4de161ebe7f166","unit:cd7e7b2c28dc62b3cc651c9a7bd1f4c8e52a18bb9e60f26d79b9db411ef71394","unit:cd9239889ce1b6416c6fe593781ead73a1c3ad2b9760dc6364f6ac6bd3101fe5","unit:cf4f7014da1c9c96f941a1a12b1af4ef466f7ff3708193667e9f4be1bc4d762b","unit:cf8c63435105d1d879f9ea09d3f7e26286d048d5543763d73bafdfd56b2e460e","unit:e733f38230818a89684af939488276f69e6ce460041061a12330db6adade9b94","unit:ec0ac1ef42c724831ea3b97562358f3de572f8951f4afd75435dae9d1b529d1a","unit:ecfa3e68c2261ffd244d48a2546bf4c3d98c7ca43fba72469cefedbe06177f5e","unit:f4d94f162ac7225b47583da8b87e4e2646b0f3c14c6d9a06c02f570051cac9a4"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c0acabd5a23eb0c33269a155","scopeContentSha256":"bae42dba5e04296f209c53e2dd30bfa706afbfc2020f7119a1411388245ef82d","localRef":"s36"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:691003b8ebd007f1f8b9daa3","scopeContentSha256":"c0dc42175188271a818cc5064b59a1018e586855efe265baf47503e0a84837f4","localRef":"s21"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l27","originalCandidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:39","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l27","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:39","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c0acabd5a23eb0c33269a155","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:691003b8ebd007f1f8b9daa3","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l27","source":"s36","target":"s21","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["The heterotic contrast connects stabilization choices to gauge unification and supersymmetry-breaking scales."],"challengeStatement":"The heterotic abstract connects stabilization choices to gauge unification and supersymmetry-breaking scales under its 2013 model assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"6d3a7df0596efe9916b43efec2dfe4f548e3067a1281a088ecd1cfd2d6f97080","reply.jsonSha256":"fea64bac072e650bfc4d15b6f9f837dafd36eb73f989803b2ecdd6bda9ffde93","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21d4d92a6189dc4c195fb915d00b0ab59bc7b327c63ea80639001fdc27a4f69a","receipt.jsonSha256":"3292ca6f2a135959cdead2514dbd2eb6ad6415eb79e6f114495a3c9ea513688a","normalization.jsonSha256":"41a1a38aa368407355f9e15d8fe25fa2415746cab070760d6244aec134c82ab8","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/adopted/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge/request.json","sha256":"c6fa93101222c87fbd5426fe416f787eecaada68658cd016ca6f243d3b449edb"},"originalChallengeDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge"},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/adopted/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"32a47a4de46ffd745f2cd68ad7068da6b6af07db892edfa5c539349f2be0d312","reply.jsonSha256":"bc61492ed7debc615fbeac069e663b8af12918cd689559d1ffb4dcec6c365380","reply.raw.txtSha256":"910c60854c32b0c8a94716a559d8a3b2427b66932a32aceed217c0a76fe3b22d","receipt.jsonSha256":"f92cf97b93df1ff22b2a13c93de2fcf421ce39315f82f35e49ecbc2b904c93df","normalization.jsonSha256":"07362ddb36fec6b6eaa01e8c8f9aa7088e3894e69e628c4c5d736aba6f40b147"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1304.1809","sourceId":"ev:4105300abb2cd9664b2414764290a7b6","sourceSha256":"24aeb09138111aa8bcf3f0f7523d38de7eab8587119846224085f263fd63876b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fe4745080c4243fd9771/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"65d350c593a2bdbe1741fad378b3eeb90b5f61564152dacc2af4b07eedeedfb3","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2945,"textSha256":"46db1e78b9dad580cc892a7b567c9401fc14d4368eaac3c6daaf3ea1999cac00","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"1304.1809","sourceId":"ev:4d5e41ab477230c5940a0e283b728faf","sourceSha256":"24aeb09138111aa8bcf3f0f7523d38de7eab8587119846224085f263fd63876b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fe4745080c4243fd9771/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"65d350c593a2bdbe1741fad378b3eeb90b5f61564152dacc2af4b07eedeedfb3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2945,"textSha256":"64a328e067e3c6940378df9f2dbc7117e9da22641ce4d4e86b57326a041986f1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1304.1809","sourceId":"ev:4105300abb2cd9664b2414764290a7b6","sourceSha256":"24aeb09138111aa8bcf3f0f7523d38de7eab8587119846224085f263fd63876b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fe4745080c4243fd9771/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"65d350c593a2bdbe1741fad378b3eeb90b5f61564152dacc2af4b07eedeedfb3","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2945,"textSha256":"46db1e78b9dad580cc892a7b567c9401fc14d4368eaac3c6daaf3ea1999cac00","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"1304.1809","sourceId":"ev:4d5e41ab477230c5940a0e283b728faf","sourceSha256":"24aeb09138111aa8bcf3f0f7523d38de7eab8587119846224085f263fd63876b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fe4745080c4243fd9771/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"65d350c593a2bdbe1741fad378b3eeb90b5f61564152dacc2af4b07eedeedfb3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2945,"textSha256":"64a328e067e3c6940378df9f2dbc7117e9da22641ce4d4e86b57326a041986f1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d27","originalRef":"l27","status":"route","source":"s36","target":"s21","type":"related_question","title":"Follow the 2013 heterotic connection to unification and supersymmetry-breaking scales","rationale":"Both statements establish a connection between heterotic stabilization choices and scale targets, with the challenge retaining the 2013 model assumptions. They do not specify a scale or threshold computation that fixes a method–application direction, so the construction-specific connection is retained.","qualification":"Limit the connection to the heterotic setting attributed to the October 2013 abstract and its stated model assumptions; the detailed scale argument is not reproduced here. Bundle, flux, perturbative and nonperturbative choices remain source-specific, and the reported difficulty of cosmological-constant tuning remains visible. Do not extend the link to M-theory on G2 spaces or identify unification with an infinite-distance limit. Exotic thresholds and supersymmetric decoupling require their own checks, and source-dated scale or phenomenological claims do not establish present viability.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l27","s36","s21"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d27","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The paired statements establish a 2013 heterotic connection between stabilization choices and unification or supersymmetry-breaking scales, but do not specify a calculation fixing a method–application direction. related_question accurately preserves this connection. The qualification retains the dated model assumptions, tuning difficulty and separate threshold checks.","refs":["l27","s36","s21"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l27","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l28":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l28","source":"q025-candidate-question:97d211f19b5c2f8e1e80c05b","target":"q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a","type":"application_of","title":"Trace vacuum and axion-potential applications to sector-specific instanton calculus","rationale":"Both statements retain existing potential and vacuum applications under their own premises while refusing to extend a fluxless normalization result to different sectors. The applied vacuum question therefore points to the underlying instanton calculus.","qualification":"Keep each application's supersymmetry, field content, flux, wrapping, zero modes and interaction type explicit. A fluxless normalization result does not verify fluxed or otherwise different sectors. Moduli-only superpotentials remain distinct from charged-matter interactions and other instanton observables; instantons and gaugino condensation retain different origins. An N=2 metric correction alone does not establish a scalar potential, and an announced application or toy construction does not certify a generally controlled vacuum.","evidenceIds":["unit:07a3f0f53986a8a49a6a3ae465ab91b315a74c84d03cad87958560de36657c00","unit:07ac81b6880e6fec5eb0495d8ff50334aef8e0a09ae3d00a7cc6993d5ce755be","unit:18d7a4223d589b1b98361b1446c08aabfeb46c82fb7b20ade6af02042434168e","unit:19365b8dd60a229782bb625eb47657f7aed739d58b216031adc79d666f5a5216","unit:19a19676eae33f7e8003af265f7488737d8399ab9172de98f68f5744a9726026","unit:1c6e0f5f4a379bc5c868d1d3fcf259d7e6a7e121eb9b56df6872d9e0702281fa","unit:2d2e04ae6ea8e15aca50fce4d2786f847d55c819afa8e4790c53347dccad846b","unit:45f8366820ca588283d0048e71b16cc71ea2df6a126126bfc00bf3924d46486e","unit:48fbaa251fed86bf6f0bbb247b170250bd30178e292c00d97b936faf013c9fce","unit:4bed048611e1589cc8f3715c89db56c68c66912cc700ae5d58d396ead7da7600","unit:56b6532a05622dbc365757681b28f69725ef196b4e805067ec68b6d7951b1403","unit:657c82bcd028afec42f2954c79345caa0ed9a2d89836c0acbff57c5649b50b07","unit:66799fa7e18e909d0c40587886539bf99c2e3a23245191131f1472272d62ee6b","unit:7a172fe766524788dc238526f2051e6d3610dc34dee2695b25ef7b355b70455d","unit:867d6306bb4ef249127e34e49e42de51ce9499dca33bcece718da62847d8f05d","unit:8b0d163659b61b7fcc59d77be4b0facd5eb69c7be3425178fbcba524a0d3dbce","unit:8e1048b4a267963447720009ef43deaadf6c2d0b8c9d6f5947a6e064d068ca6e","unit:913968fe5c253c77050f656b4faace17da8557e3532164c2c3c1fcb79dc36d2e","unit:95484221a85c59636a7556b9784b0dfac3aa87e9f13b44f3f0e19b7fbdbb3929","unit:99a95ccaedda0975901c5eb3394abc80c053a8c98fbd0ffa90b74ace0d5b26a8","unit:a15161de2dbf09b20b49e55a9b7c3f728dc6ef954e66622e73bbe21c96332abc","unit:a6aa0efa44195e64fbb043f04c23e22eef782890d2341539b736fd7b034621ba","unit:a9649f81f5c507b231efa96c51408d61f682bf71e34a3fbe6686cdcea62d1723","unit:ac38e43e81f3e3e268f8b96391eb8269c2da2f2f0f04179da496af612090e886","unit:b1436282578a1e534304b621ab444ddce67a862fa1ce18817702b89f2f4f2940","unit:b44e020bd43a2eda029c93416b5b389572c0bf71bc6e0101eb52b24c9d740f55","unit:b55319065fb89028f8a3d942b823a18f9d4b9d1869cbbcb3320f75dd74168b62","unit:b597128cb83816e11432f9bf21d9d7ba63932ad8f311e55b532df9f6c990006d","unit:b6570d2417723c4597f4c0719060da75d81e8c8371b9a934707314dd9901ea8e","unit:bbb731a96cc66418b92f435d5122fee958bbd8619df52f148f740a8c1ac3f969","unit:bd193a7bdb86206078218b642da5d8d5ddbc8d4acadba3bf319e1eb9cf5ceaea","unit:c2b68af4235d65d1e446f1622d7f03122b1f92f640496eef5402bbcaee5317dd","unit:c5428988a7744ec264323aaf2501996b9b49ddd6184b4db6a61ca0898da0784f","unit:cdec8d8c7284c367905c93f88445349605ecfa7343805c293b7123e9e8175ddf","unit:ce1488c9534a41fefcf3ab1109d5d7555ec42bed34026cc57ccceb3ba7a63e74","unit:d17b2c69265dd507a3cc646cd2023e8f756d01c58b71c740c9fea237f50b6736","unit:d821e701fc53c683e4e3c5951308e62298d543d6544b772a251a25f970c73c70","unit:ebb82a438176bf73083a67752d15a9e5052893a51b5cddf181a09370e16259b6","unit:ef10bc90cfcfef3357244516e8bc50ec95b3404fd2b9d4fe0704c27dd62c25e9","unit:f152a37c762cba94370092d54d5ca2c5df18a0250f88e3b2147171e5b7cf4bf5","unit:f23048956fc214c56adcc7c030fe5017da31709e115133dcc658cb3d4fde0af8","unit:fcc49c5f92b374e9dd1c64a00d63b41475c7c800ef282dbc0239e798c4fb1fca"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:97d211f19b5c2f8e1e80c05b","scopeContentSha256":"6384b18380f7d7bbaceaf4a6e8337f581037f9a8e09fa4a7a172a1ca15d57669","localRef":"s28"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a","scopeContentSha256":"8a73b16635ef766c7dd1d26a5437b8e7551b52c20d6577dca0c0c891452a91f8","localRef":"s13"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l28","originalCandidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:41","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l28","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:41","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:97d211f19b5c2f8e1e80c05b","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l28","source":"s13","target":"s28","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Retain existing potential and vacuum applications without extending the supplied fluxless normalization result to their fluxed or otherwise different sectors."],"challengeStatement":"Retain potential and vacuum applications under their own premises. The fluxless normalization contrast does not verify those different sectors.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"6d3a7df0596efe9916b43efec2dfe4f548e3067a1281a088ecd1cfd2d6f97080","reply.jsonSha256":"fea64bac072e650bfc4d15b6f9f837dafd36eb73f989803b2ecdd6bda9ffde93","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21d4d92a6189dc4c195fb915d00b0ab59bc7b327c63ea80639001fdc27a4f69a","receipt.jsonSha256":"3292ca6f2a135959cdead2514dbd2eb6ad6415eb79e6f114495a3c9ea513688a","normalization.jsonSha256":"41a1a38aa368407355f9e15d8fe25fa2415746cab070760d6244aec134c82ab8","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/adopted/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge/request.json","sha256":"c6fa93101222c87fbd5426fe416f787eecaada68658cd016ca6f243d3b449edb"},"originalChallengeDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge"},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/adopted/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"32a47a4de46ffd745f2cd68ad7068da6b6af07db892edfa5c539349f2be0d312","reply.jsonSha256":"bc61492ed7debc615fbeac069e663b8af12918cd689559d1ffb4dcec6c365380","reply.raw.txtSha256":"910c60854c32b0c8a94716a559d8a3b2427b66932a32aceed217c0a76fe3b22d","receipt.jsonSha256":"f92cf97b93df1ff22b2a13c93de2fcf421ce39315f82f35e49ecbc2b904c93df","normalization.jsonSha256":"07362ddb36fec6b6eaa01e8c8f9aa7088e3894e69e628c4c5d736aba6f40b147"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a"},{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:97d211f19b5c2f8e1e80c05b"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2204.02981","sourceId":"ev:796f9cea9833a6b6fa02307fccc3aebc","sourceSha256":"8c5c3b4edb64c2d845d98f549799b4afd76a4bfa08b30b5cce736506757dccdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/16dbd9e0a3b1aafc9598/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9567ce8b33364563154ae06642f600f4fbcd1387102fe2a50c5db765660dd79f","pdfPage":3,"start":1296,"end":3318,"textSha256":"d577c8e0070cfaa2d34927195949ec77e11c1480f9006f10362134103e39c3a6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"2204.02981","sourceId":"ev:d7b38ea933a08fee1f7dbe2a24d6d689","sourceSha256":"8c5c3b4edb64c2d845d98f549799b4afd76a4bfa08b30b5cce736506757dccdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/16dbd9e0a3b1aafc9598/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9567ce8b33364563154ae06642f600f4fbcd1387102fe2a50c5db765660dd79f","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":1506,"textSha256":"e488b84fca2edd1bb89394b9352c64211a5bf93354e95f6103bf24295167895c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a"},{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:97d211f19b5c2f8e1e80c05b"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2204.02981","sourceId":"ev:796f9cea9833a6b6fa02307fccc3aebc","sourceSha256":"8c5c3b4edb64c2d845d98f549799b4afd76a4bfa08b30b5cce736506757dccdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/16dbd9e0a3b1aafc9598/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9567ce8b33364563154ae06642f600f4fbcd1387102fe2a50c5db765660dd79f","pdfPage":3,"start":1296,"end":3318,"textSha256":"d577c8e0070cfaa2d34927195949ec77e11c1480f9006f10362134103e39c3a6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"2204.02981","sourceId":"ev:d7b38ea933a08fee1f7dbe2a24d6d689","sourceSha256":"8c5c3b4edb64c2d845d98f549799b4afd76a4bfa08b30b5cce736506757dccdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/16dbd9e0a3b1aafc9598/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9567ce8b33364563154ae06642f600f4fbcd1387102fe2a50c5db765660dd79f","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":1506,"textSha256":"e488b84fca2edd1bb89394b9352c64211a5bf93354e95f6103bf24295167895c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d28","originalRef":"l28","status":"route","source":"s28","target":"s13","type":"application_of","title":"Trace vacuum and axion-potential applications to sector-specific instanton calculus","rationale":"Both statements retain existing potential and vacuum applications under their own premises while refusing to extend a fluxless normalization result to different sectors. The applied vacuum question therefore points to the underlying instanton calculus.","qualification":"Keep each application's supersymmetry, field content, flux, wrapping, zero modes and interaction type explicit. A fluxless normalization result does not verify fluxed or otherwise different sectors. Moduli-only superpotentials remain distinct from charged-matter interactions and other instanton observables; instantons and gaugino condensation retain different origins. An N=2 metric correction alone does not establish a scalar potential, and an announced application or toy construction does not certify a generally controlled vacuum.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l28","s28","s13"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d28","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements retain potential and vacuum applications of instanton methods under their own premises, supporting s28 → s13. The qualification explicitly prevents transferring the fluxless normalization result to different sectors and preserves interaction, supersymmetry, flux and zero-mode distinctions without certifying general vacuum control.","refs":["l28","s28","s13"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-09-proposal","parent-orientation-09-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or review hash was newly accessed or reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not represent verification performed in this review.","Routes apply only to their stated scientific components and conditions. They do not establish full-scope containment, universal applicability, verified derivations or current phenomenological validity.","The packet's grouping establishes no relationship between disconnected cases. Separate relations are preserved without inferred transitive identity.","This proposal does not perform independent challenge review, deterministic admission, endpoint receipt checks or the global canonical/DAG gate, and does not decide the complete atlas."],"challenge":["This challenge used only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements, the proposal and explicit reading limits. No primary text, sidecar, locator, review file or hash was accessed or newly reread.","The l* and s* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading-coverage counts do not describe verification performed in this challenge.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and stated applicability. It does not independently verify calculations, proofs, spectra, model viability or present phenomenological status.","The retained routes concern their specified scientific components and do not establish full-scope containment or universal applicability. Packet grouping and separate shared endpoints do not establish transitive identity.","No deterministic admission, endpoint/content/receipt verification or global canonical/DAG gate was performed. Exact agreement does not itself admit these records or decide the complete atlas."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-09:l28","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l0":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l0","source":"q025-candidate-question:cfc31bf32a01b834ef984f5e","target":"q025-candidate-question:6a9d9c1d809f904f41b8f560","type":"method_for","title":"Use modular and anomaly constraints to compute protected amplitudes","rationale":"The modular and anomaly questions in s30 supply computational methods for compatible protected-amplitude and BPS-generating-function targets in s10. The method therefore points from s30 to s10.","qualification":"Keep genus, spacetime dimension, geometry, twist and flux sector source-specific. Genus-zero fourfold functions are distinct from all-genus threefold targets, and gravity-decoupled refined limits do not establish generic compact results. Do not transfer anomaly equations across dimensions or infer modular uniqueness, verified coefficients, general critical-string scattering or a universal completion.","evidenceIds":["unit:0c0e5bc0d09c001963465763a3e9658f3a596ca8cb8303f361b69b7867258d3a","unit:19080817beafb608e0bd61a2367737fee8f87e7b5857be5bd66014d350bfb8e4","unit:1bb0ee4ef89f395e9d60f164d6e34a60417ca750f31d66ff7bd626f3ee936f23","unit:2b26b922d6d6cbcf3a9307c8f76fa5667afa12ba6c962234be865638a68df584","unit:2ee491ecbe35b797fcf4f5f237cc1e6f3cee0b191b6f6f778ed3ab506fa3d2e9","unit:313fe3f0b7b637a83d3c5e3c69dd4ab782c5fa47f66b80fe7a5e3f2dd439dee5","unit:4d15e34a3afb16ebec2b8c1d54f24a0521285d4db14d228cde674027fbcac8d4","unit:50c99daef8f9e52e96048710b8337d19c3aa2dec8ab721265dbeda4463ec7117","unit:55609489a8990f86061f49417d67adb04f5a804e4f4a33d9a6aa4031c3123937","unit:62bbe09790b7105c5af19112f889051b9df1f1e0fde24b9a8d202427b156840d","unit:7360420a7778bf2accd9faa80ca7c1ac866fd140092ddc6186f4ef68877d6866","unit:8518e44b60c515a57e29ca9fc16e1113775b23573fe83b29dc870b110bdd13de","unit:8b5ca8d2aee7e64d6c265d34372ec64073c166cd71037721365aaf4ce8ac90fc","unit:9a7160d332c8afef6eaf55ddd28850ca2d419edc4fe857ed65e865d86359fcb5","unit:bd283062aadf4477e5437b7f712bc37ccbde50089dd300dde247e842855eab07","unit:cac6ded92e886adc1e6ed4c05d9aaccbe0af69a6da8543e089a6d37e76ace01a","unit:d7d23971e1a6ecf64d786f5585d30b1eaaf5a080cbe0a5dc1fd1150396d8bfdc","unit:e4432f2633094599af5d8d07c826506bf714e0e81183a953edafb879e467ed03","unit:e764451e25aba315ae729bf7f96f0d767c1d56597c7ef2c32c04ffae3d4dacb4","unit:ec87e0498733a5c3f1767e97511bc48115200d3246157f3776a2008691c53676","unit:fd542a072d6cfa37434f5631d9b3dae3e42cd98eac5ef75c1d001eb9e86d8f46"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cfc31bf32a01b834ef984f5e","scopeContentSha256":"f8021679771121534b80354dd6850ea3ff34770e2d57c79830c2603b51f5d0d5","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6a9d9c1d809f904f41b8f560","scopeContentSha256":"88ab7ec54de259c7ab27f917a6e3f8db89b9e545682f21aa89a76a355c2cb02b","localRef":"s10"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l0","originalCandidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:49","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l0","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge:link:49","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:6a9d9c1d809f904f41b8f560","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:cfc31bf32a01b834ef984f5e","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l0","source":"s10","target":"s30","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Modular and anomaly constraints provide computation routes whose genus, dimension, twist and flux qualifications remain local."],"challengeStatement":"Modular and anomaly constraints supply computation routes whose genus, dimension, twist and flux qualifications remain source-specific.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"6d3a7df0596efe9916b43efec2dfe4f548e3067a1281a088ecd1cfd2d6f97080","reply.jsonSha256":"fea64bac072e650bfc4d15b6f9f837dafd36eb73f989803b2ecdd6bda9ffde93","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21d4d92a6189dc4c195fb915d00b0ab59bc7b327c63ea80639001fdc27a4f69a","receipt.jsonSha256":"3292ca6f2a135959cdead2514dbd2eb6ad6415eb79e6f114495a3c9ea513688a","normalization.jsonSha256":"41a1a38aa368407355f9e15d8fe25fa2415746cab070760d6244aec134c82ab8","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/adopted/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge/request.json","sha256":"c6fa93101222c87fbd5426fe416f787eecaada68658cd016ca6f243d3b449edb"},"originalChallengeDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge"},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/adopted/parent-8d2b5fd7cc13cefc77fe-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"32a47a4de46ffd745f2cd68ad7068da6b6af07db892edfa5c539349f2be0d312","reply.jsonSha256":"bc61492ed7debc615fbeac069e663b8af12918cd689559d1ffb4dcec6c365380","reply.raw.txtSha256":"910c60854c32b0c8a94716a559d8a3b2427b66932a32aceed217c0a76fe3b22d","receipt.jsonSha256":"f92cf97b93df1ff22b2a13c93de2fcf421ce39315f82f35e49ecbc2b904c93df","normalization.jsonSha256":"07362ddb36fec6b6eaa01e8c8f9aa7088e3894e69e628c4c5d736aba6f40b147"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6a9d9c1d809f904f41b8f560"},{"ref":"x4_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cfc31bf32a01b834ef984f5e"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6a9d9c1d809f904f41b8f560"},{"ref":"x4_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cfc31bf32a01b834ef984f5e"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d0","originalRef":"l0","status":"route","source":"s30","target":"s10","type":"method_for","title":"Use modular and anomaly constraints to compute protected amplitudes","rationale":"The modular and anomaly questions in s30 supply computational methods for compatible protected-amplitude and BPS-generating-function targets in s10. The method therefore points from s30 to s10.","qualification":"Keep genus, spacetime dimension, geometry, twist and flux sector source-specific. Genus-zero fourfold functions are distinct from all-genus threefold targets, and gravity-decoupled refined limits do not establish generic compact results. Do not transfer anomaly equations across dimensions or infer modular uniqueness, verified coefficients, general critical-string scattering or a universal completion.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l0","s10","s30"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"s30 supplies the modular and anomaly methods for compatible protected targets in s10. The reversal correctly identifies the method provider, and the qualification preserves genus, dimension, geometry, twist, flux and non-transfer limits.","refs":["l0","s10","s30"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l2":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l2","source":"q025-candidate-question:91f5bc86c8671e154c6c93a3","target":"q025-candidate-region:600315ef8d9edeaf4a128bb0","type":"method_for","title":"Apply scoped entropy estimates to horizon and cosmological questions","rationale":"The entropy estimates and quantum-information constraints in s16 provide model-specific methods for relevant questions in s37. Independent quantum-system calculations also retain their stated comparison roles.","qualification":"Applicability depends on the specified ensemble, Hamiltonian, regulator, observable and gravitational setting. Ground-state, Haar-random and thermal questions remain distinct; finite-chain limits and high-temperature convergence assumptions remain explicit. JT results and proposed screen-causality conventions remain restricted. Independent quantum-system questions are not thereby gravitational applications, and the mismatch comparison with unspecified compared systems supplies no transferable conclusion.","evidenceIds":["unit:310c8d7b46187bb19b5627035f87e8785cba0df84c0db82b510a6c37d2d8e9ba","unit:3b095c49ead35f9a6d88421cd62f766b187c42a7898d874682b177d64e10609d","unit:41065e34afacaf57236b18baaa579547d12c61a3655be4bdfdcb0fa6da5d4732","unit:5e6bf9fd00714f851cda47305607511bbc1a985c3cf67dfd98f3510dfa158d0f","unit:67de69532e959bf52a62719198e171de4db432d2b6d0ff6eba75ba4103e675fa","unit:8ae0040e64ff1d810ee4ded700b1d8529b67b174be34f237a10cda125bb221cd","unit:91e9947b71468e060d08e1f70c3f8f352b01b66606c0030a549b9b479bcbd25e","unit:bf281f4d17bcb73d0750080a278777fc2fa98d9d88be58955da3b53ce9de309f","unit:c748e640eadbbe1d858e1aeb0bcc44b9d96d7b28aff8a818041f6839fb1439b2","unit:d299dd74d81fc98c9dc67ff0ac22d4082d58bb39a180e3423d3717b7b721f83a","unit:df9620672162bc964e536a0c08e9073be87b7cd5d3d0b304a3d4df7bc078df3a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:91f5bc86c8671e154c6c93a3","scopeContentSha256":"0c055188194bc10c11025922e14fa713ebc75cb99c7b4346aa2ff88f4ddeee80","localRef":"s16"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:600315ef8d9edeaf4a128bb0","scopeContentSha256":"bc9de156cb4ad7a7ebf6ea66eca3534ec69ac93d4d36958a390255557e38e621","localRef":"s37"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l2","originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:10","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l2","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:10","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:600315ef8d9edeaf4a128bb0","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:91f5bc86c8671e154c6c93a3","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l2","source":"s37","target":"s16","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Entropy estimates and quantum-information constraints supply model-specific methods; independent quantum-system questions remain distinguishable from gravitational applications."],"challengeStatement":"Entropy estimates provide methods and comparisons; independent quantum-system questions retain their own ensembles and observables.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"71faa1f4477df1851ad27a60beee36157ad4238846a6423b2e594321abc760a2","reply.jsonSha256":"128765ca0c199e7519337d56f8751787d6d79439a0e14a7a5e4131968c3718da","reply.raw.txtSha256":"79f13a16fc0bc4a225dd073f65045cc82f74c13dc1660732ac8de34db00df704","receipt.jsonSha256":"cc169a91337c6e468da8be22ec52e0ba5de6a2b447154d5411e97d650e3d9b05","normalization.jsonSha256":"22e8932e0657d884bed1c74a21e127d7637d8f39b8bf158a45213512d1d7136e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6540e874330d5957264700cbc1ff58422364444c6aab4b9706f01a07dc9ca055"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"05a3a8aad07314b0fd5899c543db46f6af4e39d0360c7d9e24bff4041902b396","reply.jsonSha256":"fd580105f367bae7f008249bfbd47cbaadd58321a5958bd66c95f3d89cdad343","reply.raw.txtSha256":"050b32cf6091ddcb6cafa2d07d87b34823b463761d03c00d9fcfa7212d429b6c","receipt.jsonSha256":"e090e480dab107992b791ab3731a55b88ae91e65d253c02edee81a82fcda818c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d08d94b6760d12b693c2d593a64bdbe68e1c09c3b04b5e29d180d9a0b62493ac"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:91f5bc86c8671e154c6c93a3"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9306083","sourceId":"ev:1a444d978e2907008e24b78c703a7772","sourceSha256":"40893ca595dc6af94d3f48f896d79d6a10c625b1d68b875fe8198fed7928d328","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e071a8ef1d5acc0788ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f8d86fd5377e7e6fa8da5199d14d949f9e2282a94a5153a395f38354ef8d6af4","pdfPage":3,"start":93,"end":3175,"textSha256":"9580595390dbf549fb4512fd9615716f39fc70f65561f34f50b13ad87dddbdda","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:91f5bc86c8671e154c6c93a3"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9306083","sourceId":"ev:1a444d978e2907008e24b78c703a7772","sourceSha256":"40893ca595dc6af94d3f48f896d79d6a10c625b1d68b875fe8198fed7928d328","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e071a8ef1d5acc0788ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f8d86fd5377e7e6fa8da5199d14d949f9e2282a94a5153a395f38354ef8d6af4","pdfPage":3,"start":93,"end":3175,"textSha256":"9580595390dbf549fb4512fd9615716f39fc70f65561f34f50b13ad87dddbdda","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d2","originalRef":"l2","status":"route","source":"s16","target":"s37","type":"method_for","title":"Apply scoped entropy estimates to horizon and cosmological questions","rationale":"The entropy estimates and quantum-information constraints in s16 provide model-specific methods for relevant questions in s37. Independent quantum-system calculations also retain their stated comparison roles.","qualification":"Applicability depends on the specified ensemble, Hamiltonian, regulator, observable and gravitational setting. Ground-state, Haar-random and thermal questions remain distinct; finite-chain limits and high-temperature convergence assumptions remain explicit. JT results and proposed screen-causality conventions remain restricted. Independent quantum-system questions are not thereby gravitational applications, and the mismatch comparison with unspecified compared systems supplies no transferable conclusion.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l2","s37","s16"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The model-specific entropy estimates in s16 supply methods for relevant questions in s37. The record preserves independent comparison roles, ensembles, observables and model limits without converting every quantum-system calculation into a gravitational application.","refs":["l2","s37","s16"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l3":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l3","source":"q025-candidate-question:91f5bc86c8671e154c6c93a3","target":"q025-candidate-question:ca2f1f84d37158a9764d90e4","type":"method_for","title":"Use random-state entropy estimates for radiation-information questions","rationale":"The random-state entropy estimates in s16 are the methodological input to the radiation-information questions in s29. The original direction is therefore reversed.","qualification":"Restrict this connection to the specified random bipartite pure-state ensemble and subsystem assumptions, with information defined as the entropy deficit from ln m. Purity, ensemble interpretation and accessible state information require separate specification. The estimate supplies neither an evaporation mechanism nor a microscopic release protocol, and entropy agreement does not establish all state-level correlations.","evidenceIds":["unit:0cae689be581e7d71dd2506f746e33a9fc83ce6823f7bf0cb8a3685d8a2ef016","unit:156fea61d40725e6b1eacd15b7c9842ef1c66cbdc6b2352dabb0f935017264ac","unit:1c1e3fe0a91fc56a0e007caa5793349c1d5b15d73ae18d8d9b169c7076bf1f5c","unit:1fb303e65651ccb65041efc93318e523bdda0160de95ea2e872d77fb7fde910e","unit:23967e314a0ff22e27a2d33ee7e6189373a7f0be5f2ed32676b1ae0752f0234e","unit:2b1f451f54a549691bdc034786df5a5183c3c8a13d3c95c687bb99c98377b49f","unit:310c8d7b46187bb19b5627035f87e8785cba0df84c0db82b510a6c37d2d8e9ba","unit:3b095c49ead35f9a6d88421cd62f766b187c42a7898d874682b177d64e10609d","unit:41065e34afacaf57236b18baaa579547d12c61a3655be4bdfdcb0fa6da5d4732","unit:44cc0df15e3be0f899527d5fe300a75ea06f23950fd36c52cd04b72b00b1fcdb","unit:4b99f1136f864e2624968c9710ecd8041fa71f4d66de5ce134f7b445a02d10c6","unit:51759a1d3a5b38428351b58c3b8451c7078a25d27c3cc5702e77d89fbfff5d14","unit:5e6bf9fd00714f851cda47305607511bbc1a985c3cf67dfd98f3510dfa158d0f","unit:5e9fcdf93bded88fa4d95c2511682d411a55827f0d9eef7ca7e700cfea0cb4ed","unit:78836b55f19a64fa4ff165d2d82151818e88718419f3cb905644012a3201d3c8","unit:7aaa07adc6b7bfef840a5ef37e91dd1fedce6de0e2f7bded10f6b4faddb65ffc","unit:91e9947b71468e060d08e1f70c3f8f352b01b66606c0030a549b9b479bcbd25e","unit:9517a6d2679662303feb052953e190c36345c5e0be6d932ea8275bc4110cd76c","unit:a6e60d1065a43f3347df9f40a6ebfba3ed30184ec73c1550c2ba218752b87440","unit:b37fa8a2b6216058909c9a148d0cd11bf03645911ca5fdc3e8f259a6fe4890e5","unit:bf281f4d17bcb73d0750080a278777fc2fa98d9d88be58955da3b53ce9de309f","unit:c2de062c2460d417101aa8d125e5329195f50037a80b079b2ddbcc86436ed5eb","unit:c334ca4fb362c7936dae5eedcd6b940b736626222a9f5e197eab9dfbedfac58e","unit:d21a38613893023982193b938362f547e1ecfd098d22ab9620b296fac9cc6e3d","unit:d299dd74d81fc98c9dc67ff0ac22d4082d58bb39a180e3423d3717b7b721f83a","unit:d918612dc42f7740e8dc1c82b03fd6443cffaee457051049d67bc1096bd22d8f","unit:df9620672162bc964e536a0c08e9073be87b7cd5d3d0b304a3d4df7bc078df3a","unit:ffc295e02ea2bc590df9ee37dbbe4706bec8ab5d89587f1d6e2f90a8748b3c87"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:91f5bc86c8671e154c6c93a3","scopeContentSha256":"0c055188194bc10c11025922e14fa713ebc75cb99c7b4346aa2ff88f4ddeee80","localRef":"s16"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ca2f1f84d37158a9764d90e4","scopeContentSha256":"86c4c9bd53703f89a5ef57fe7db9226301a0c73b667d1c870a3f67e9ccaf5e05","localRef":"s29"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l3","originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:34","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l3","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:34","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:ca2f1f84d37158a9764d90e4","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:91f5bc86c8671e154c6c93a3","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l3","source":"s29","target":"s16","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Random-state entropy estimates are a method bridge to radiation-information questions; the ensemble does not supply an evaporation mechanism."],"challengeStatement":"Random-state entropy estimates inform radiation-information questions without supplying an evaporation mechanism.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"71faa1f4477df1851ad27a60beee36157ad4238846a6423b2e594321abc760a2","reply.jsonSha256":"128765ca0c199e7519337d56f8751787d6d79439a0e14a7a5e4131968c3718da","reply.raw.txtSha256":"79f13a16fc0bc4a225dd073f65045cc82f74c13dc1660732ac8de34db00df704","receipt.jsonSha256":"cc169a91337c6e468da8be22ec52e0ba5de6a2b447154d5411e97d650e3d9b05","normalization.jsonSha256":"22e8932e0657d884bed1c74a21e127d7637d8f39b8bf158a45213512d1d7136e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6540e874330d5957264700cbc1ff58422364444c6aab4b9706f01a07dc9ca055"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"05a3a8aad07314b0fd5899c543db46f6af4e39d0360c7d9e24bff4041902b396","reply.jsonSha256":"fd580105f367bae7f008249bfbd47cbaadd58321a5958bd66c95f3d89cdad343","reply.raw.txtSha256":"050b32cf6091ddcb6cafa2d07d87b34823b463761d03c00d9fcfa7212d429b6c","receipt.jsonSha256":"e090e480dab107992b791ab3731a55b88ae91e65d253c02edee81a82fcda818c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d08d94b6760d12b693c2d593a64bdbe68e1c09c3b04b5e29d180d9a0b62493ac"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ca2f1f84d37158a9764d90e4"},{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:91f5bc86c8671e154c6c93a3"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9306083","sourceId":"ev:1a444d978e2907008e24b78c703a7772","sourceSha256":"40893ca595dc6af94d3f48f896d79d6a10c625b1d68b875fe8198fed7928d328","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e071a8ef1d5acc0788ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f8d86fd5377e7e6fa8da5199d14d949f9e2282a94a5153a395f38354ef8d6af4","pdfPage":3,"start":93,"end":3175,"textSha256":"9580595390dbf549fb4512fd9615716f39fc70f65561f34f50b13ad87dddbdda","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9306083","sourceId":"ev:fe37418fa24cb283c064c57f3352914c","sourceSha256":"40893ca595dc6af94d3f48f896d79d6a10c625b1d68b875fe8198fed7928d328","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e071a8ef1d5acc0788ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f8d86fd5377e7e6fa8da5199d14d949f9e2282a94a5153a395f38354ef8d6af4","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":731,"textSha256":"1f2ee0a72d98492fd6a933be4fa5222d5c1a8945136aa064fae2aa76c8f747bd","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ca2f1f84d37158a9764d90e4"},{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:91f5bc86c8671e154c6c93a3"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9306083","sourceId":"ev:1a444d978e2907008e24b78c703a7772","sourceSha256":"40893ca595dc6af94d3f48f896d79d6a10c625b1d68b875fe8198fed7928d328","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e071a8ef1d5acc0788ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f8d86fd5377e7e6fa8da5199d14d949f9e2282a94a5153a395f38354ef8d6af4","pdfPage":3,"start":93,"end":3175,"textSha256":"9580595390dbf549fb4512fd9615716f39fc70f65561f34f50b13ad87dddbdda","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9306083","sourceId":"ev:fe37418fa24cb283c064c57f3352914c","sourceSha256":"40893ca595dc6af94d3f48f896d79d6a10c625b1d68b875fe8198fed7928d328","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e071a8ef1d5acc0788ca/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f8d86fd5377e7e6fa8da5199d14d949f9e2282a94a5153a395f38354ef8d6af4","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":731,"textSha256":"1f2ee0a72d98492fd6a933be4fa5222d5c1a8945136aa064fae2aa76c8f747bd","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d3","originalRef":"l3","status":"route","source":"s16","target":"s29","type":"method_for","title":"Use random-state entropy estimates for radiation-information questions","rationale":"The random-state entropy estimates in s16 are the methodological input to the radiation-information questions in s29. The original direction is therefore reversed.","qualification":"Restrict this connection to the specified random bipartite pure-state ensemble and subsystem assumptions, with information defined as the entropy deficit from ln m. Purity, ensemble interpretation and accessible state information require separate specification. The estimate supplies neither an evaporation mechanism nor a microscopic release protocol, and entropy agreement does not establish all state-level correlations.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l3","s29","s16"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The random-state estimate is supplied by s16 and used in the radiation-information questions of s29. The reversed method direction preserves the specified ensemble and information convention while explicitly withholding an evaporation or microscopic release mechanism.","refs":["l3","s29","s16"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l4":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l4","source":"q025-candidate-question:9fbf5d3e823e70be2c52c594","target":"q025-candidate-question:ca2f1f84d37158a9764d90e4","type":"application_of","title":"Trace cosmological islands to entropy and reconstruction prescriptions","rationale":"The cosmological island and reconstruction questions in s21 apply the island, entropy and reconstruction prescriptions organized in s29.","qualification":"The connection covers the overlapping prescriptions, not every screen or observer proposal. Preserve the cosmological background, state, purifier, gravitational degrees of freedom and weak-backreaction requirements. Massless-graviton questions remain distinct from state-induced graviton-mass proposals. Screen causality uses its proposed definition, screen entanglement is not automatically boundary-CFT tracing, and a black-hole Page-like curve is not by itself a radiation-entropy calculation.","evidenceIds":["unit:020d4df339195e60dbb43673730dcf53ab2d6fc46e7dcb7b71c606a0b79a5494","unit:0cae689be581e7d71dd2506f746e33a9fc83ce6823f7bf0cb8a3685d8a2ef016","unit:114892a800422b1d889e6723f1ecf2cf8b19eab5ba1f223170d8fcf1a9e5822d","unit:156fea61d40725e6b1eacd15b7c9842ef1c66cbdc6b2352dabb0f935017264ac","unit:1c1e3fe0a91fc56a0e007caa5793349c1d5b15d73ae18d8d9b169c7076bf1f5c","unit:1fb303e65651ccb65041efc93318e523bdda0160de95ea2e872d77fb7fde910e","unit:23967e314a0ff22e27a2d33ee7e6189373a7f0be5f2ed32676b1ae0752f0234e","unit:2b1f451f54a549691bdc034786df5a5183c3c8a13d3c95c687bb99c98377b49f","unit:44cc0df15e3be0f899527d5fe300a75ea06f23950fd36c52cd04b72b00b1fcdb","unit:4b99f1136f864e2624968c9710ecd8041fa71f4d66de5ce134f7b445a02d10c6","unit:51759a1d3a5b38428351b58c3b8451c7078a25d27c3cc5702e77d89fbfff5d14","unit:55e633442de8a46176dafab2e73e1db24529741ca7b25a2bd1fbc84064bc26e5","unit:5e9fcdf93bded88fa4d95c2511682d411a55827f0d9eef7ca7e700cfea0cb4ed","unit:78836b55f19a64fa4ff165d2d82151818e88718419f3cb905644012a3201d3c8","unit:7aaa07adc6b7bfef840a5ef37e91dd1fedce6de0e2f7bded10f6b4faddb65ffc","unit:7c4940c271bea0e907d0902a07a0e34f7616fb79368bd1e00bdeca2c6e83b778","unit:7c53502e63cc4d6a27358810169419cd4cc1d1d6f32d92490cddd7a96c14f884","unit:91e9947b71468e060d08e1f70c3f8f352b01b66606c0030a549b9b479bcbd25e","unit:9517a6d2679662303feb052953e190c36345c5e0be6d932ea8275bc4110cd76c","unit:a6e60d1065a43f3347df9f40a6ebfba3ed30184ec73c1550c2ba218752b87440","unit:b37fa8a2b6216058909c9a148d0cd11bf03645911ca5fdc3e8f259a6fe4890e5","unit:bf281f4d17bcb73d0750080a278777fc2fa98d9d88be58955da3b53ce9de309f","unit:c2de062c2460d417101aa8d125e5329195f50037a80b079b2ddbcc86436ed5eb","unit:c334ca4fb362c7936dae5eedcd6b940b736626222a9f5e197eab9dfbedfac58e","unit:d21a38613893023982193b938362f547e1ecfd098d22ab9620b296fac9cc6e3d","unit:d918612dc42f7740e8dc1c82b03fd6443cffaee457051049d67bc1096bd22d8f","unit:ffc295e02ea2bc590df9ee37dbbe4706bec8ab5d89587f1d6e2f90a8748b3c87"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9fbf5d3e823e70be2c52c594","scopeContentSha256":"1e820d433b32d1a2509beb165eda4fb5e630375b04ac14322be9998d3a374f2d","localRef":"s21"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ca2f1f84d37158a9764d90e4","scopeContentSha256":"86c4c9bd53703f89a5ef57fe7db9226301a0c73b667d1c870a3f67e9ccaf5e05","localRef":"s29"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l4","originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:33","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l4","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:33","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:ca2f1f84d37158a9764d90e4","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:9fbf5d3e823e70be2c52c594","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l4","source":"s29","target":"s21","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Cosmological islands and reconstruction provide a related application direction with different backgrounds, purifiers and gravitational assumptions."],"challengeStatement":"Cosmological islands and reconstruction form an application route with different backgrounds, purifiers and gravitational assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"71faa1f4477df1851ad27a60beee36157ad4238846a6423b2e594321abc760a2","reply.jsonSha256":"128765ca0c199e7519337d56f8751787d6d79439a0e14a7a5e4131968c3718da","reply.raw.txtSha256":"79f13a16fc0bc4a225dd073f65045cc82f74c13dc1660732ac8de34db00df704","receipt.jsonSha256":"cc169a91337c6e468da8be22ec52e0ba5de6a2b447154d5411e97d650e3d9b05","normalization.jsonSha256":"22e8932e0657d884bed1c74a21e127d7637d8f39b8bf158a45213512d1d7136e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6540e874330d5957264700cbc1ff58422364444c6aab4b9706f01a07dc9ca055"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"05a3a8aad07314b0fd5899c543db46f6af4e39d0360c7d9e24bff4041902b396","reply.jsonSha256":"fd580105f367bae7f008249bfbd47cbaadd58321a5958bd66c95f3d89cdad343","reply.raw.txtSha256":"050b32cf6091ddcb6cafa2d07d87b34823b463761d03c00d9fcfa7212d429b6c","receipt.jsonSha256":"e090e480dab107992b791ab3731a55b88ae91e65d253c02edee81a82fcda818c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d08d94b6760d12b693c2d593a64bdbe68e1c09c3b04b5e29d180d9a0b62493ac"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ca2f1f84d37158a9764d90e4"},{"ref":"x0_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9fbf5d3e823e70be2c52c594"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ca2f1f84d37158a9764d90e4"},{"ref":"x0_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9fbf5d3e823e70be2c52c594"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d4","originalRef":"l4","status":"route","source":"s21","target":"s29","type":"application_of","title":"Trace cosmological islands to entropy and reconstruction prescriptions","rationale":"The cosmological island and reconstruction questions in s21 apply the island, entropy and reconstruction prescriptions organized in s29.","qualification":"The connection covers the overlapping prescriptions, not every screen or observer proposal. Preserve the cosmological background, state, purifier, gravitational degrees of freedom and weak-backreaction requirements. Massless-graviton questions remain distinct from state-induced graviton-mass proposals. Screen causality uses its proposed definition, screen entanglement is not automatically boundary-CFT tracing, and a black-hole Page-like curve is not by itself a radiation-entropy calculation.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l4","s29","s21"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The cosmological island questions in s21 are the applied side of the overlapping entropy and reconstruction prescriptions in s29. The qualification appropriately limits this application to those prescriptions and retains different backgrounds, purifiers, gravitational assumptions and screen constructions.","refs":["l4","s29","s21"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l5":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l5","source":"q025-candidate-question:280b40e52891c6b095d3e9ec","target":"q025-candidate-question:9995aa7eccdc7b058b671a36","type":"application_of","title":"Identify entropy constructions used in dynamical gravity","rationale":"The evolution and geometry questions in s3 apply entropy constructions organized in s19. Their dynamical observables remain distinct from identifying microscopic degrees of freedom.","qualification":"Preserve the definitions of thermodynamic, Wald, entanglement and generalized entropy and the source-specific holographic or semiclassical setting. Boundary, black-hole and radiation subsystems are distinct, and maximization and extremization prescriptions are not interchangeable. Classical monotonicity does not automatically survive Hawking corrections. Agreement in entropy scaling or evolution establishes neither identical microscopic degrees of freedom nor a radiation-entropy calculation.","evidenceIds":["unit:0132e7888f377a3e6a7c0cfd8400df8c6495c992998605e43cf846c6d0d709a9","unit:0df3969aa06b524142ea55a0fac85752f8496cc9ca569eee218bd0c6acce8e5c","unit:1160b53ea2be340053aaac5fbf1df383c804d9e24182e52e3b9854347c6b97dd","unit:1c1e3fe0a91fc56a0e007caa5793349c1d5b15d73ae18d8d9b169c7076bf1f5c","unit:23967e314a0ff22e27a2d33ee7e6189373a7f0be5f2ed32676b1ae0752f0234e","unit:27de729e86985af5949fe7e927216effe80691a1e30892a3157395fff62390a4","unit:3eb64d8196d69c872455aedf6f5ecc7681dce9bda2a7bf0dbf028b7adb9ae2b5","unit:45b70c8b85bc08df142065d96c6a0c26e712e137f7efbdebc64a37436afa07ae","unit:51cb5b47379f94d7dfecff41e08c26f11e0820fb6cc8b93f5e46c0979a7f54d2","unit:5f29f9a247b12ad4d624aa8b3430f5c1aa19309493f0de96d089a40c11d49745","unit:6394ca22138ad8f6e2adf6b4cc28480e96d2c1dbdf689a097848ec93a675af7c","unit:6c563a64f9439c20215c488d2a0376dfa937952b5755d8d552108d171cfc5bf9","unit:771bcf58c71ff10c102351c4aca2a4a91e91d1e04f28f0fd44a1183332c0440c","unit:785da44bf96090e2f854d6936c6828304efee0dfa4e90079776754b49732a679","unit:826c59af6b997c852a2f7751a11f1f00106ff8915c8bd935393cc7455d1970c3","unit:873f6af54e48bb57a60814221c1bdd04c06bd4ecdda57e88f30b09de55c7e178","unit:87672a715f9223b7dc84f73ae35504ca0b79843c4d7fef355bd66e3c8774dbeb","unit:958f055b5227b42397b1ce0316f3a6474cdab3b37ccb782a4cf287697a86c5d8","unit:95ddbae26dbcf7e5ce1487ecdf6c3853ba41953e501f35b331911eacb33508f5","unit:9af6e56f4edb9112a174113a32f8b31e29bd76533b6b3a83418f8a8d5de5dbdf","unit:9c561324fc34e6e66b1716cb6fca166dbbf23a2f8b8e28bb1728a8026a8bfe32","unit:a1ab952615e70d93bf703bacbc352d93ef4ef70ebffa4f022783403d1a1284b7","unit:a903518d700445a5fcabddf557bf553dbfe3f3c12ec7b36b582bce0687edb17d","unit:b50dafb6e88285e194ae4d307cef7e28e5be4650085dafb97c563e8066a591bf","unit:bcba3bcd39a42630e71c0606b8096790441e2f1582bc735f8e379f65f10bbaa3","unit:be84db276052807740116351027e22e1b16f571478735b04e58ab589edd9c8e6","unit:bfa71a4b4a3bc531fe5ddbb7e20a18325571f39f1e2f59fe1995dbc7e40d715b","unit:c01b4bf8b06fe73fb45cd7949e93f3cd370b2c56df4b213e3e136b47f4b4f9cd","unit:c4909788d126d68aca9717c4686bf51a73466d49ac42de73f4d78a32ffc9b7cc","unit:c5f0446349d619446abd25d175461a44e0a5b4aed326cb28bf5c4f0acc264260","unit:c7a9fcfdf3857f9d7e270216dba79eda379c2c0fc44d3ef6923e90f64dc183de","unit:c8f1ac050b8b2f9c6eb7ecbaa81442647ed73868ba66aa8459e2f28cd1fd9947","unit:cb6f58b3ce7324b48c8a2cd53b8b3fafd8450c4e9b3e44bd6cc0ade7a4cc83d2","unit:cbaaed2e0221400c6bf393ef0d578dba3e1cdd79d6d21522139a860979c1614c","unit:cec7ac9f8773d807cbf642e6eec5231cda4d2b48741abae0904d9e491ed34918","unit:d0c5ccd2e2f7964699180ed50bca149f78c959b208bd5f1ced881d9fab005133","unit:d3811546e37a3ea7ff6aa8fa5fe287ff8369f534c66dcf00e2fe49c749a52fb4","unit:dbdf46851a4b8e153d89239c5ed065066ceece92835042a21422f3ea72454cbc","unit:dcfcc6af077b5c90c6acc765e99c9fc4f2dd38804e7fd24311c570a3a6cb501e","unit:e2ecec014f0839340d83895c317037d4af23c6294c251775161f30e8f61140ab","unit:eb028a96f9c40e799bf40be2601980d4f3437ae53605896d73e574d9234ec3a5","unit:edd785a95635133e669e7ecdde92a79f034d503f6e634cca9da9bb130c191ce9","unit:eed164211b5113774eb2c99a164ea293d6df6a729f5bf05a8cf7b9aebbb8a879"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:280b40e52891c6b095d3e9ec","scopeContentSha256":"bedf2bbb304bd8a6ab6b1241ac39ac7137ed10fdeca5814b237e1328e11278a1","localRef":"s3"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9995aa7eccdc7b058b671a36","scopeContentSha256":"f662ac1ec11148ea5d2725b7c54597f35b6efaab8366209403afbba5b2790640","localRef":"s19"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l5","originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:20","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l5","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:20","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:9995aa7eccdc7b058b671a36","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:280b40e52891c6b095d3e9ec","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l5","source":"s19","target":"s3","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Entropy constructions are used to study evolution and geometry; their dynamical observables remain distinct from identifying microscopic degrees of freedom."],"challengeStatement":"Entropy constructions are applied to evolution and geometry; these observables remain distinct from identifying microscopic degrees of freedom.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"71faa1f4477df1851ad27a60beee36157ad4238846a6423b2e594321abc760a2","reply.jsonSha256":"128765ca0c199e7519337d56f8751787d6d79439a0e14a7a5e4131968c3718da","reply.raw.txtSha256":"79f13a16fc0bc4a225dd073f65045cc82f74c13dc1660732ac8de34db00df704","receipt.jsonSha256":"cc169a91337c6e468da8be22ec52e0ba5de6a2b447154d5411e97d650e3d9b05","normalization.jsonSha256":"22e8932e0657d884bed1c74a21e127d7637d8f39b8bf158a45213512d1d7136e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6540e874330d5957264700cbc1ff58422364444c6aab4b9706f01a07dc9ca055"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"05a3a8aad07314b0fd5899c543db46f6af4e39d0360c7d9e24bff4041902b396","reply.jsonSha256":"fd580105f367bae7f008249bfbd47cbaadd58321a5958bd66c95f3d89cdad343","reply.raw.txtSha256":"050b32cf6091ddcb6cafa2d07d87b34823b463761d03c00d9fcfa7212d429b6c","receipt.jsonSha256":"e090e480dab107992b791ab3731a55b88ae91e65d253c02edee81a82fcda818c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d08d94b6760d12b693c2d593a64bdbe68e1c09c3b04b5e29d180d9a0b62493ac"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9995aa7eccdc7b058b671a36"},{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:280b40e52891c6b095d3e9ec"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9995aa7eccdc7b058b671a36"},{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:280b40e52891c6b095d3e9ec"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d5","originalRef":"l5","status":"route","source":"s3","target":"s19","type":"application_of","title":"Identify entropy constructions used in dynamical gravity","rationale":"The evolution and geometry questions in s3 apply entropy constructions organized in s19. Their dynamical observables remain distinct from identifying microscopic degrees of freedom.","qualification":"Preserve the definitions of thermodynamic, Wald, entanglement and generalized entropy and the source-specific holographic or semiclassical setting. Boundary, black-hole and radiation subsystems are distinct, and maximization and extremization prescriptions are not interchangeable. Classical monotonicity does not automatically survive Hawking corrections. Agreement in entropy scaling or evolution establishes neither identical microscopic degrees of freedom nor a radiation-entropy calculation.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l5","s19","s3"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"s3 applies entropy constructions organized in s19 to evolution and geometry. The record preserves distinct entropy definitions, subsystems and prescriptions, and does not turn dynamical entropy observables into an identification of microscopic degrees of freedom.","refs":["l5","s19","s3"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l6":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l6","source":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb","target":"q025-candidate-question:9995aa7eccdc7b058b671a36","type":"application_of","title":"Trace extremality tests to their entropy constructions","rationale":"The conditional extremality and consistency questions in s6 apply specified entropy definitions and corrections within the construction questions organized in s19.","qualification":"Retain fixed-mass-and-charge conditions, thermodynamic stability, tree-level dominance and small-additive-correction assumptions where stated. Changing an entropy prescription is distinct from correcting a Lagrangian. Additional sign criteria and exact-area postulates remain independent premises. The route asserts neither universal positivity nor direct species measurements from an area-theorem test; merger applications retain their description-only status.","evidenceIds":["unit:0132e7888f377a3e6a7c0cfd8400df8c6495c992998605e43cf846c6d0d709a9","unit:0df3969aa06b524142ea55a0fac85752f8496cc9ca569eee218bd0c6acce8e5c","unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","unit:1160b53ea2be340053aaac5fbf1df383c804d9e24182e52e3b9854347c6b97dd","unit:1c1e3fe0a91fc56a0e007caa5793349c1d5b15d73ae18d8d9b169c7076bf1f5c","unit:1d3b64bc4ff22f0ed98915bdc55ca1021dbc9596c4d52746dd2719ea94b3ed1f","unit:23967e314a0ff22e27a2d33ee7e6189373a7f0be5f2ed32676b1ae0752f0234e","unit:27de729e86985af5949fe7e927216effe80691a1e30892a3157395fff62390a4","unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","unit:3eb64d8196d69c872455aedf6f5ecc7681dce9bda2a7bf0dbf028b7adb9ae2b5","unit:45b70c8b85bc08df142065d96c6a0c26e712e137f7efbdebc64a37436afa07ae","unit:5f29f9a247b12ad4d624aa8b3430f5c1aa19309493f0de96d089a40c11d49745","unit:6c563a64f9439c20215c488d2a0376dfa937952b5755d8d552108d171cfc5bf9","unit:826c59af6b997c852a2f7751a11f1f00106ff8915c8bd935393cc7455d1970c3","unit:873f6af54e48bb57a60814221c1bdd04c06bd4ecdda57e88f30b09de55c7e178","unit:958f055b5227b42397b1ce0316f3a6474cdab3b37ccb782a4cf287697a86c5d8","unit:95ddbae26dbcf7e5ce1487ecdf6c3853ba41953e501f35b331911eacb33508f5","unit:9af6e56f4edb9112a174113a32f8b31e29bd76533b6b3a83418f8a8d5de5dbdf","unit:a1ab952615e70d93bf703bacbc352d93ef4ef70ebffa4f022783403d1a1284b7","unit:a903518d700445a5fcabddf557bf553dbfe3f3c12ec7b36b582bce0687edb17d","unit:bcba3bcd39a42630e71c0606b8096790441e2f1582bc735f8e379f65f10bbaa3","unit:be84db276052807740116351027e22e1b16f571478735b04e58ab589edd9c8e6","unit:bfa71a4b4a3bc531fe5ddbb7e20a18325571f39f1e2f59fe1995dbc7e40d715b","unit:c01b4bf8b06fe73fb45cd7949e93f3cd370b2c56df4b213e3e136b47f4b4f9cd","unit:c4909788d126d68aca9717c4686bf51a73466d49ac42de73f4d78a32ffc9b7cc","unit:c5f0446349d619446abd25d175461a44e0a5b4aed326cb28bf5c4f0acc264260","unit:c7a9fcfdf3857f9d7e270216dba79eda379c2c0fc44d3ef6923e90f64dc183de","unit:c8f1ac050b8b2f9c6eb7ecbaa81442647ed73868ba66aa8459e2f28cd1fd9947","unit:cb6f58b3ce7324b48c8a2cd53b8b3fafd8450c4e9b3e44bd6cc0ade7a4cc83d2","unit:cbaaed2e0221400c6bf393ef0d578dba3e1cdd79d6d21522139a860979c1614c","unit:cec7ac9f8773d807cbf642e6eec5231cda4d2b48741abae0904d9e491ed34918","unit:d0c5ccd2e2f7964699180ed50bca149f78c959b208bd5f1ced881d9fab005133","unit:d3811546e37a3ea7ff6aa8fa5fe287ff8369f534c66dcf00e2fe49c749a52fb4","unit:da3b42fb5f4247edfd1bd072b8701216486945905a8766c825f60e221ca0ce61","unit:e2ecec014f0839340d83895c317037d4af23c6294c251775161f30e8f61140ab","unit:eb028a96f9c40e799bf40be2601980d4f3437ae53605896d73e574d9234ec3a5","unit:edd785a95635133e669e7ecdde92a79f034d503f6e634cca9da9bb130c191ce9"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb","scopeContentSha256":"17b23896f033122b211a50ba05a1ebc085f18313a14253c55e252acf4c19192d","localRef":"s6"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9995aa7eccdc7b058b671a36","scopeContentSha256":"f662ac1ec11148ea5d2725b7c54597f35b6efaab8366209403afbba5b2790640","localRef":"s19"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l6","originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:21","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l6","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:21","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:9995aa7eccdc7b058b671a36","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l6","source":"s19","target":"s6","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Entropy corrections motivate conditional extremality and consistency tests, with stability, tree-level and prescription assumptions retained."],"challengeStatement":"Entropy corrections enter conditional extremality and consistency tests with their stability, dominance and prescription assumptions retained.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"71faa1f4477df1851ad27a60beee36157ad4238846a6423b2e594321abc760a2","reply.jsonSha256":"128765ca0c199e7519337d56f8751787d6d79439a0e14a7a5e4131968c3718da","reply.raw.txtSha256":"79f13a16fc0bc4a225dd073f65045cc82f74c13dc1660732ac8de34db00df704","receipt.jsonSha256":"cc169a91337c6e468da8be22ec52e0ba5de6a2b447154d5411e97d650e3d9b05","normalization.jsonSha256":"22e8932e0657d884bed1c74a21e127d7637d8f39b8bf158a45213512d1d7136e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6540e874330d5957264700cbc1ff58422364444c6aab4b9706f01a07dc9ca055"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"05a3a8aad07314b0fd5899c543db46f6af4e39d0360c7d9e24bff4041902b396","reply.jsonSha256":"fd580105f367bae7f008249bfbd47cbaadd58321a5958bd66c95f3d89cdad343","reply.raw.txtSha256":"050b32cf6091ddcb6cafa2d07d87b34823b463761d03c00d9fcfa7212d429b6c","receipt.jsonSha256":"e090e480dab107992b791ab3731a55b88ae91e65d253c02edee81a82fcda818c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d08d94b6760d12b693c2d593a64bdbe68e1c09c3b04b5e29d180d9a0b62493ac"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9995aa7eccdc7b058b671a36"},{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9995aa7eccdc7b058b671a36"},{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d6","originalRef":"l6","status":"route","source":"s6","target":"s19","type":"application_of","title":"Trace extremality tests to their entropy constructions","rationale":"The conditional extremality and consistency questions in s6 apply specified entropy definitions and corrections within the construction questions organized in s19.","qualification":"Retain fixed-mass-and-charge conditions, thermodynamic stability, tree-level dominance and small-additive-correction assumptions where stated. Changing an entropy prescription is distinct from correcting a Lagrangian. Additional sign criteria and exact-area postulates remain independent premises. The route asserts neither universal positivity nor direct species measurements from an area-theorem test; merger applications retain their description-only status.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l6","s19","s6"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The extremality and consistency questions in s6 are applications of specified entropy constructions and corrections. The record retains stability, tree-level dominance, fixed-charge conditions and prescription assumptions, including the independent premises needed for phenomenological restrictions.","refs":["l6","s19","s6"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l7":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l7","source":"q025-candidate-question:c5b185b7cb8a2d31fb994b94","target":"q025-candidate-question:1bbcd69d5a64c2a520457b52","type":"application_of","title":"Examine entropy bounds underlying conditional constraints","rationale":"The tower, gauge, vacuum and cosmological questions in s28 conditionally apply entropic arguments and bounds organized in s0.","qualification":"Only the applications invoking those arguments are covered. Preserve the selected bound, gravitational regime, energy accounting, buoyancy, backreaction, observer and subsystem conventions. Measure choices and cosmological thermodynamic hypotheses remain additional source-specific assumptions, and global spatial entropy need not equal one observer's entropy. No general Swampland implication or GSL proof follows; removing a motivation for a bound does not disprove it.","evidenceIds":["unit:0132e7888f377a3e6a7c0cfd8400df8c6495c992998605e43cf846c6d0d709a9","unit:029dcdeba6d3e70ea908d209182c4ed9b5fb168bfd668ebbc3c970679b0fe970","unit:043116c8b1b43b482b46d8df2dc4e7e94b028d014460d0778be26704fae600b4","unit:0d88753b5f19ae4e81ad094b46ae181445c5c32fd6bcdc9f0b839e5fbe5b513f","unit:181b7d72d1bae7952e88eee6df7edecaa835680729f61040731ceedfdea9a4b9","unit:19a0153721dd12fe288051be4a2f30645fc898ada32e824545edfac3f67aa011","unit:1f37b5e03fe9f83979b12b3cfd4b07580011ffbdd93431b0666fcbdac17f9e7c","unit:21c8a7cb765c57727e4a2da3a01793ff45cdbf442a82a164a4e865b99d135c29","unit:27de729e86985af5949fe7e927216effe80691a1e30892a3157395fff62390a4","unit:3606158835cac2aac86329500d527c48b20b1a03d7921bef148929573c8dd4ce","unit:3821a8ab9a8d9304d9dd03e1de7230db749a4bbe37fd10d62188b368126e7b83","unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","unit:42694d521c0eb9d57820f1447f07e596140eb6b990a55d3ede0e77aa9f9f7c72","unit:4ebf031a9cff6d598723f1e32307c4e64774a524655021ee1a2431ded10c6d0e","unit:51cb5b47379f94d7dfecff41e08c26f11e0820fb6cc8b93f5e46c0979a7f54d2","unit:528a7e7bb5e837068abcabe4f04afbfd020257f7e26c81e9c1b1947aa678cb99","unit:54793e8aee4dc8187d08cea62e7f7aa796f778a299239927972af7bff92f78ec","unit:57e063530e56d4fe9e0d6a00adb9a4a8340eaaa2e68849de844007ac5be9841e","unit:629b4b7da0fbd67353227b5327df97e8c4598ecfa1c0c7033b13ca6ebda19af5","unit:6394ca22138ad8f6e2adf6b4cc28480e96d2c1dbdf689a097848ec93a675af7c","unit:65c73a70deab67494d1f6f42d3d4ee5c290559dc65f60b4381e38c77229e38db","unit:669b822b310ef0cff9ca1ae4707189ea71c720dcd8525340ada1ba0c1c0d69b9","unit:67de69532e959bf52a62719198e171de4db432d2b6d0ff6eba75ba4103e675fa","unit:68a13a003e2ccb85bb4c7a84a3e9236734884bca4524be164d47476b0fd92058","unit:6c563a64f9439c20215c488d2a0376dfa937952b5755d8d552108d171cfc5bf9","unit:6fb51e03ce0eaa210879fc540ecc884d3cfacea203ed61d6c8bdf377829bc077","unit:785da44bf96090e2f854d6936c6828304efee0dfa4e90079776754b49732a679","unit:7965aae0df37347e091123ef2c740b8004df38deedc1ade887a528660cc07cea","unit:87672a715f9223b7dc84f73ae35504ca0b79843c4d7fef355bd66e3c8774dbeb","unit:8c2e52b6d80c6b2837a82aba8f9458d4d7777ae2253ff4b5f877a8619791a973","unit:8f855e797331d1c9d924f4a37b93d41fd80f70860f184de96c874931eee43b4e","unit:94be007e1bb29bfa31350fbc937ed0b9effc332e1e507756ce275c2a9f31ba9a","unit:9af6e56f4edb9112a174113a32f8b31e29bd76533b6b3a83418f8a8d5de5dbdf","unit:9c561324fc34e6e66b1716cb6fca166dbbf23a2f8b8e28bb1728a8026a8bfe32","unit:a58ffffac6f83192fcb784932069fc5587798976c160424a8a3d23a696d3767e","unit:a66f304ac79f6847e486545293cda65b15454d96a6d62917e6227a5c8f2697f0","unit:a7858f30e4f198420da499efd0a6f464ec24624dce00dcf545f92c42c790319f","unit:a903518d700445a5fcabddf557bf553dbfe3f3c12ec7b36b582bce0687edb17d","unit:a90ffd232878f54151e92add034526fa80af78e1cd2e2cc9cb451a34d16b8c5e","unit:ac5e7548b50164b5d0209514ea66e0db6d23a9a7e5b52819a5e7fff72ec625c2","unit:b58f9f408c1e22ad6ece03d0528feb3f9d9fa211edfa2ad762ef449727198ef2","unit:b655e6e53aea7fa9771e9113247ce896ea19588ee8fa058e4e4bbc42666dab3a","unit:bbc25e1e0ce2ccb9b1ae5ea8e7f36ec08ba3c14f9ae86fce3288f9808fab70b3","unit:be84db276052807740116351027e22e1b16f571478735b04e58ab589edd9c8e6","unit:c7a9fcfdf3857f9d7e270216dba79eda379c2c0fc44d3ef6923e90f64dc183de","unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5","unit:cb6f58b3ce7324b48c8a2cd53b8b3fafd8450c4e9b3e44bd6cc0ade7a4cc83d2","unit:cec7ac9f8773d807cbf642e6eec5231cda4d2b48741abae0904d9e491ed34918","unit:d3811546e37a3ea7ff6aa8fa5fe287ff8369f534c66dcf00e2fe49c749a52fb4","unit:daeac2cf1dc4fdf8513e522ce5bd50557cd88c3445bc4f20d26eec5008bcd055","unit:dbdf46851a4b8e153d89239c5ed065066ceece92835042a21422f3ea72454cbc","unit:dc5617a0f30d20faf0f35af114c4e5307bbe2eadfcc0833a7472e1323d656496","unit:e0ad916614466e85ee5e7a64740db9764631adb2c705d80945849c819ed8e91a","unit:ea9bf27b4a6a21519b2a4e4939eaec45d8afed56939a9d42dd774a4be8a50286","unit:ee49b954f547030191ab1c13fbbf1ed7b3fb034c64d8e0580d9371d9b62678dd","unit:ef985a9b0a3dca45d937521afe9c75808c6a08457249321591b480e3098b0c5a","unit:fe77754bb481f3869aff42f1204b55066937680437c440e53e287ae93a9ee7e8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c5b185b7cb8a2d31fb994b94","scopeContentSha256":"b7522843eeb27ba83619faa620660f5b85f3017520b4ca341645a0027f1e646e","localRef":"s28"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1bbcd69d5a64c2a520457b52","scopeContentSha256":"cd2d44ea236d1b19218e0c58d21f68e199a0dcf9d122a6c6f34a68feb3006e0b","localRef":"s0"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l7","originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:25","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l7","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:25","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:1bbcd69d5a64c2a520457b52","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:c5b185b7cb8a2d31fb994b94","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l7","source":"s0","target":"s28","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Entropic arguments are applied conditionally to tower, gauge, vacuum and cosmological questions; a general implication is not asserted."],"challengeStatement":"Entropic arguments have conditional tower, gauge, vacuum and cosmological applications; no general implication is asserted.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"71faa1f4477df1851ad27a60beee36157ad4238846a6423b2e594321abc760a2","reply.jsonSha256":"128765ca0c199e7519337d56f8751787d6d79439a0e14a7a5e4131968c3718da","reply.raw.txtSha256":"79f13a16fc0bc4a225dd073f65045cc82f74c13dc1660732ac8de34db00df704","receipt.jsonSha256":"cc169a91337c6e468da8be22ec52e0ba5de6a2b447154d5411e97d650e3d9b05","normalization.jsonSha256":"22e8932e0657d884bed1c74a21e127d7637d8f39b8bf158a45213512d1d7136e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6540e874330d5957264700cbc1ff58422364444c6aab4b9706f01a07dc9ca055"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"05a3a8aad07314b0fd5899c543db46f6af4e39d0360c7d9e24bff4041902b396","reply.jsonSha256":"fd580105f367bae7f008249bfbd47cbaadd58321a5958bd66c95f3d89cdad343","reply.raw.txtSha256":"050b32cf6091ddcb6cafa2d07d87b34823b463761d03c00d9fcfa7212d429b6c","receipt.jsonSha256":"e090e480dab107992b791ab3731a55b88ae91e65d253c02edee81a82fcda818c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d08d94b6760d12b693c2d593a64bdbe68e1c09c3b04b5e29d180d9a0b62493ac"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1bbcd69d5a64c2a520457b52"},{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c5b185b7cb8a2d31fb994b94"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1bbcd69d5a64c2a520457b52"},{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c5b185b7cb8a2d31fb994b94"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d7","originalRef":"l7","status":"route","source":"s28","target":"s0","type":"application_of","title":"Examine entropy bounds underlying conditional constraints","rationale":"The tower, gauge, vacuum and cosmological questions in s28 conditionally apply entropic arguments and bounds organized in s0.","qualification":"Only the applications invoking those arguments are covered. Preserve the selected bound, gravitational regime, energy accounting, buoyancy, backreaction, observer and subsystem conventions. Measure choices and cosmological thermodynamic hypotheses remain additional source-specific assumptions, and global spatial entropy need not equal one observer's entropy. No general Swampland implication or GSL proof follows; removing a motivation for a bound does not disprove it.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l7","s0","s28"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"s28 contains the conditional applications of entropic arguments organized in s0. The reversed application direction is restricted to branches invoking those arguments and preserves observer, gravitational, thermodynamic and measure qualifications without asserting general implications.","refs":["l7","s0","s28"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l8":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l8","source":"q025-candidate-question:c5b185b7cb8a2d31fb994b94","target":"q025-candidate-question:24b37f697d9d643392a06244","type":"related_question","title":"Examine entropy restrictions on vacuum energy and field theory","rationale":"Both statements explicitly connect the entropic-constraints overview to the existing vacuum-energy question. They support this useful reuse without identifying s28 as a particular underlying method or establishing full-scope containment of s2.","qualification":"This remains the same destination question, not a duplicate. Entropy restrictions and GUP modifications are proposed inputs. Preserve vacuum fixed points, radiative consistency, vacuum-energy magnitude and equation of state as distinct targets, including the historical negative dark-energy tests. Smaller-system effects require the additional extrapolation, and diffuse dark matter remains an alternative question. No cosmological-constant solution or current observational fit is established.","evidenceIds":["unit:181b7d72d1bae7952e88eee6df7edecaa835680729f61040731ceedfdea9a4b9","unit:186f00227b632738ef2273c7a53239f0a3007abd22f83763e719ef3128d24ba2","unit:19a0153721dd12fe288051be4a2f30645fc898ada32e824545edfac3f67aa011","unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","unit:528a7e7bb5e837068abcabe4f04afbfd020257f7e26c81e9c1b1947aa678cb99","unit:54793e8aee4dc8187d08cea62e7f7aa796f778a299239927972af7bff92f78ec","unit:57e063530e56d4fe9e0d6a00adb9a4a8340eaaa2e68849de844007ac5be9841e","unit:629b4b7da0fbd67353227b5327df97e8c4598ecfa1c0c7033b13ca6ebda19af5","unit:68a13a003e2ccb85bb4c7a84a3e9236734884bca4524be164d47476b0fd92058","unit:6c563a64f9439c20215c488d2a0376dfa937952b5755d8d552108d171cfc5bf9","unit:6fb51e03ce0eaa210879fc540ecc884d3cfacea203ed61d6c8bdf377829bc077","unit:782f5821cbc7a80af501f568655c47355ac09b76a523fab50110c2e61283b7bb","unit:a66f304ac79f6847e486545293cda65b15454d96a6d62917e6227a5c8f2697f0","unit:a7858f30e4f198420da499efd0a6f464ec24624dce00dcf545f92c42c790319f","unit:a903518d700445a5fcabddf557bf553dbfe3f3c12ec7b36b582bce0687edb17d","unit:b225be4b8f729569cec589805b1bb41545af50953f87075c0830896706b6725b","unit:bbc25e1e0ce2ccb9b1ae5ea8e7f36ec08ba3c14f9ae86fce3288f9808fab70b3","unit:be84db276052807740116351027e22e1b16f571478735b04e58ab589edd9c8e6","unit:c748e640eadbbe1d858e1aeb0bcc44b9d96d7b28aff8a818041f6839fb1439b2","unit:cad431dcb8b42f37192e7d0d5feae25ff554da3c8763afd359a20a74a3b51fc5","unit:dc5617a0f30d20faf0f35af114c4e5307bbe2eadfcc0833a7472e1323d656496","unit:ea9bf27b4a6a21519b2a4e4939eaec45d8afed56939a9d42dd774a4be8a50286","unit:ee49b954f547030191ab1c13fbbf1ed7b3fb034c64d8e0580d9371d9b62678dd","unit:fe77754bb481f3869aff42f1204b55066937680437c440e53e287ae93a9ee7e8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c5b185b7cb8a2d31fb994b94","scopeContentSha256":"b7522843eeb27ba83619faa620660f5b85f3017520b4ca341645a0027f1e646e","localRef":"s28"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24b37f697d9d643392a06244","scopeContentSha256":"28adaaa3703fd4c883fa814a3c01cd0183623aee6e0e7a61c026235dc6731302","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l8","originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:39","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l8","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:39","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c5b185b7cb8a2d31fb994b94","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:24b37f697d9d643392a06244","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l8","source":"s28","target":"s2","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Reuses the same vacuum-energy question from an entropic-constraints route; it creates no second question and preserves the reported negative cosmological test."],"challengeStatement":"Reuses the same vacuum-energy destination from an entropic-constraints route, preserving its historical negative test.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"71faa1f4477df1851ad27a60beee36157ad4238846a6423b2e594321abc760a2","reply.jsonSha256":"128765ca0c199e7519337d56f8751787d6d79439a0e14a7a5e4131968c3718da","reply.raw.txtSha256":"79f13a16fc0bc4a225dd073f65045cc82f74c13dc1660732ac8de34db00df704","receipt.jsonSha256":"cc169a91337c6e468da8be22ec52e0ba5de6a2b447154d5411e97d650e3d9b05","normalization.jsonSha256":"22e8932e0657d884bed1c74a21e127d7637d8f39b8bf158a45213512d1d7136e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6540e874330d5957264700cbc1ff58422364444c6aab4b9706f01a07dc9ca055"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"05a3a8aad07314b0fd5899c543db46f6af4e39d0360c7d9e24bff4041902b396","reply.jsonSha256":"fd580105f367bae7f008249bfbd47cbaadd58321a5958bd66c95f3d89cdad343","reply.raw.txtSha256":"050b32cf6091ddcb6cafa2d07d87b34823b463761d03c00d9fcfa7212d429b6c","receipt.jsonSha256":"e090e480dab107992b791ab3731a55b88ae91e65d253c02edee81a82fcda818c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d08d94b6760d12b693c2d593a64bdbe68e1c09c3b04b5e29d180d9a0b62493ac"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c5b185b7cb8a2d31fb994b94"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24b37f697d9d643392a06244"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0403052","sourceId":"ev:715d5e6d147b1d5389e1dbe4d2b69a12","sourceSha256":"dead10ba6dfe42e54b580e7bca6415f855dadc5606ebfa64800e13953d79c594","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/08b4c1b9ed5feaf9f77d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"193e12f3004f80c08694ff91992c1342137996f020156056f70ebf3569a20813","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":871,"textSha256":"2192447a198a86b5364440b07b28dafb905979518460cb3ca359d23df66bbcfc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0403052","sourceId":"ev:fdb9352e7eb246644c339f217cacbdfe","sourceSha256":"dead10ba6dfe42e54b580e7bca6415f855dadc5606ebfa64800e13953d79c594","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/08b4c1b9ed5feaf9f77d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"193e12f3004f80c08694ff91992c1342137996f020156056f70ebf3569a20813","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2753,"textSha256":"fcb95b82658545809bbb0f8358934092d145f01e85f4c1947b44e6ac0691251e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c5b185b7cb8a2d31fb994b94"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24b37f697d9d643392a06244"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0403052","sourceId":"ev:715d5e6d147b1d5389e1dbe4d2b69a12","sourceSha256":"dead10ba6dfe42e54b580e7bca6415f855dadc5606ebfa64800e13953d79c594","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/08b4c1b9ed5feaf9f77d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"193e12f3004f80c08694ff91992c1342137996f020156056f70ebf3569a20813","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":871,"textSha256":"2192447a198a86b5364440b07b28dafb905979518460cb3ca359d23df66bbcfc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0403052","sourceId":"ev:fdb9352e7eb246644c339f217cacbdfe","sourceSha256":"dead10ba6dfe42e54b580e7bca6415f855dadc5606ebfa64800e13953d79c594","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/08b4c1b9ed5feaf9f77d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"193e12f3004f80c08694ff91992c1342137996f020156056f70ebf3569a20813","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2753,"textSha256":"fcb95b82658545809bbb0f8358934092d145f01e85f4c1947b44e6ac0691251e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d8","originalRef":"l8","status":"route","source":"s28","target":"s2","type":"related_question","title":"Examine entropy restrictions on vacuum energy and field theory","rationale":"Both statements explicitly connect the entropic-constraints overview to the existing vacuum-energy question. They support this useful reuse without identifying s28 as a particular underlying method or establishing full-scope containment of s2.","qualification":"This remains the same destination question, not a duplicate. Entropy restrictions and GUP modifications are proposed inputs. Preserve vacuum fixed points, radiative consistency, vacuum-energy magnitude and equation of state as distinct targets, including the historical negative dark-energy tests. Smaller-system effects require the additional extrapolation, and diffuse dark matter remains an alternative question. No cosmological-constant solution or current observational fit is established.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l8","s28","s2"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The paired statements support access from the entropic-constraints overview to the existing vacuum-energy question, without identifying a particular method or full-scope refinement. The related-question type preserves this connection and the historical negative tests and optional smaller-system extrapolation.","refs":["l8","s28","s2"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l9":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l9","source":"q025-candidate-question:24b37f697d9d643392a06244","target":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf","type":"application_of","title":"Identify cosmological entropy restrictions used by vacuum proposals","rationale":"The original statements describe vacuum and field-theory applications of the cosmological entropy restrictions organized in s18. The applied question is s2.","qualification":"Restrict the route to proposals invoking those cosmological entropy restrictions; it does not assign one bound to every branch of s2. Preserve the relevant geometry, dimension, cosmological-constant sign and entropy-counting convention. Magnitude, equation-of-state and radiative-consistency tests remain separate, and smaller-system effects require an additional extrapolation. Proposed entropy or GUP inputs and the source-reported historical dark-energy problems remain explicit.","evidenceIds":["unit:164d149ab754d2aa9a6b2bdffdc02cb75e88ead4271499f4e334de597f07ae3f","unit:186f00227b632738ef2273c7a53239f0a3007abd22f83763e719ef3128d24ba2","unit:50e704ebcfca339415323818b2b26977f0b2bd892b64b28911a40de512de4fe3","unit:782f5821cbc7a80af501f568655c47355ac09b76a523fab50110c2e61283b7bb","unit:8fad24e9b6bb057128944d399c201c79a82fd6e7ce15278e97bd24312c5ea163","unit:91e9947b71468e060d08e1f70c3f8f352b01b66606c0030a549b9b479bcbd25e","unit:96359c29d82e714c3d1f815e267c1cc74b1500715cdfe5273621b98079c36721","unit:b225be4b8f729569cec589805b1bb41545af50953f87075c0830896706b6725b","unit:c18e8fa494418aad11176d0ee3c5e73343469558a437db25bf36a758261fdb20","unit:c494c5cfd2390c4babb6d2cc08ebe7a8141189182ad3b4a9e05c6d9255c50328","unit:c748e640eadbbe1d858e1aeb0bcc44b9d96d7b28aff8a818041f6839fb1439b2","unit:cb66dbc130fd54137b3abd2a44ba490ec912d20fa9fe6187b939f612c7504a43"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24b37f697d9d643392a06244","scopeContentSha256":"28adaaa3703fd4c883fa814a3c01cd0183623aee6e0e7a61c026235dc6731302","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf","scopeContentSha256":"4c0909a26dff37b92eb93bf6a0a9404871cf159742d072f1b0a16e064f759e97","localRef":"s18"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l9","originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:38","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l9","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:38","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:24b37f697d9d643392a06244","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l9","source":"s18","target":"s2","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Vacuum and field-theory applications retain separate magnitude, equation-of-state and optional smaller-system tests."],"challengeStatement":"Vacuum and field-theory applications preserve separate magnitude, equation-of-state and optional smaller-system tests.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"71faa1f4477df1851ad27a60beee36157ad4238846a6423b2e594321abc760a2","reply.jsonSha256":"128765ca0c199e7519337d56f8751787d6d79439a0e14a7a5e4131968c3718da","reply.raw.txtSha256":"79f13a16fc0bc4a225dd073f65045cc82f74c13dc1660732ac8de34db00df704","receipt.jsonSha256":"cc169a91337c6e468da8be22ec52e0ba5de6a2b447154d5411e97d650e3d9b05","normalization.jsonSha256":"22e8932e0657d884bed1c74a21e127d7637d8f39b8bf158a45213512d1d7136e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6540e874330d5957264700cbc1ff58422364444c6aab4b9706f01a07dc9ca055"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"05a3a8aad07314b0fd5899c543db46f6af4e39d0360c7d9e24bff4041902b396","reply.jsonSha256":"fd580105f367bae7f008249bfbd47cbaadd58321a5958bd66c95f3d89cdad343","reply.raw.txtSha256":"050b32cf6091ddcb6cafa2d07d87b34823b463761d03c00d9fcfa7212d429b6c","receipt.jsonSha256":"e090e480dab107992b791ab3731a55b88ae91e65d253c02edee81a82fcda818c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d08d94b6760d12b693c2d593a64bdbe68e1c09c3b04b5e29d180d9a0b62493ac"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24b37f697d9d643392a06244"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0403052","sourceId":"ev:2ce5f96294f684e8d0ee74fc0edfd6fe","sourceSha256":"dead10ba6dfe42e54b580e7bca6415f855dadc5606ebfa64800e13953d79c594","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/08b4c1b9ed5feaf9f77d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"193e12f3004f80c08694ff91992c1342137996f020156056f70ebf3569a20813","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2337,"textSha256":"a6df2f9972622cefafd02a2861da7b4a888249f8f1916182bc95d61812a760e6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0403052","sourceId":"ev:715d5e6d147b1d5389e1dbe4d2b69a12","sourceSha256":"dead10ba6dfe42e54b580e7bca6415f855dadc5606ebfa64800e13953d79c594","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/08b4c1b9ed5feaf9f77d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"193e12f3004f80c08694ff91992c1342137996f020156056f70ebf3569a20813","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":871,"textSha256":"2192447a198a86b5364440b07b28dafb905979518460cb3ca359d23df66bbcfc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0403052","sourceId":"ev:fdb9352e7eb246644c339f217cacbdfe","sourceSha256":"dead10ba6dfe42e54b580e7bca6415f855dadc5606ebfa64800e13953d79c594","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/08b4c1b9ed5feaf9f77d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"193e12f3004f80c08694ff91992c1342137996f020156056f70ebf3569a20813","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2753,"textSha256":"fcb95b82658545809bbb0f8358934092d145f01e85f4c1947b44e6ac0691251e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24b37f697d9d643392a06244"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0403052","sourceId":"ev:2ce5f96294f684e8d0ee74fc0edfd6fe","sourceSha256":"dead10ba6dfe42e54b580e7bca6415f855dadc5606ebfa64800e13953d79c594","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/08b4c1b9ed5feaf9f77d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"193e12f3004f80c08694ff91992c1342137996f020156056f70ebf3569a20813","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2337,"textSha256":"a6df2f9972622cefafd02a2861da7b4a888249f8f1916182bc95d61812a760e6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0403052","sourceId":"ev:715d5e6d147b1d5389e1dbe4d2b69a12","sourceSha256":"dead10ba6dfe42e54b580e7bca6415f855dadc5606ebfa64800e13953d79c594","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/08b4c1b9ed5feaf9f77d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"193e12f3004f80c08694ff91992c1342137996f020156056f70ebf3569a20813","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":871,"textSha256":"2192447a198a86b5364440b07b28dafb905979518460cb3ca359d23df66bbcfc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0403052","sourceId":"ev:fdb9352e7eb246644c339f217cacbdfe","sourceSha256":"dead10ba6dfe42e54b580e7bca6415f855dadc5606ebfa64800e13953d79c594","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/08b4c1b9ed5feaf9f77d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"193e12f3004f80c08694ff91992c1342137996f020156056f70ebf3569a20813","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2753,"textSha256":"fcb95b82658545809bbb0f8358934092d145f01e85f4c1947b44e6ac0691251e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d9","originalRef":"l9","status":"route","source":"s2","target":"s18","type":"application_of","title":"Identify cosmological entropy restrictions used by vacuum proposals","rationale":"The original statements describe vacuum and field-theory applications of the cosmological entropy restrictions organized in s18. The applied question is s2.","qualification":"Restrict the route to proposals invoking those cosmological entropy restrictions; it does not assign one bound to every branch of s2. Preserve the relevant geometry, dimension, cosmological-constant sign and entropy-counting convention. Magnitude, equation-of-state and radiative-consistency tests remain separate, and smaller-system effects require an additional extrapolation. Proposed entropy or GUP inputs and the source-reported historical dark-energy problems remain explicit.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l9","s18","s2"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d9","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original statements identify vacuum and field-theory applications, making s2 the applied endpoint relative to s18's cosmological entropy formulations. The record restricts applicability to proposals invoking those restrictions and preserves separate magnitude, equation-of-state and smaller-system tests.","refs":["l9","s18","s2"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l10":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l10","source":"q025-candidate-question:e20364c219905ed673296d48","target":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf","type":"application_of","title":"Examine bound assumptions behind cosmological restrictions","rationale":"The history and evolution questions in s34 apply specified entropy assumptions and bound formulations organized in s18.","qualification":"Expansion, contraction, bounce and postbounce thermal comparisons remain distinct, with source-specific dimensions, matter and cosmological constants. Extra-dimensional entropy inflow, unitary horizon descriptions and thermodynamic area entropy are conditional inputs. Ordinary scalar GR is not identified with the high-energy tachyonic braneworld setting or its field coordinate. Formal inequality compatibility does not establish full eternal-inflation consistency, and the GUP illustration does not supply a completed stochastic model.","evidenceIds":["unit:164d149ab754d2aa9a6b2bdffdc02cb75e88ead4271499f4e334de597f07ae3f","unit:186f00227b632738ef2273c7a53239f0a3007abd22f83763e719ef3128d24ba2","unit:50e704ebcfca339415323818b2b26977f0b2bd892b64b28911a40de512de4fe3","unit:8fad24e9b6bb057128944d399c201c79a82fd6e7ce15278e97bd24312c5ea163","unit:91e9947b71468e060d08e1f70c3f8f352b01b66606c0030a549b9b479bcbd25e","unit:96359c29d82e714c3d1f815e267c1cc74b1500715cdfe5273621b98079c36721","unit:a344665dfa46b005f100c58076bc46ca6936b3b3359963577e1ccf54a97236bd","unit:a69255ceecad574cf3749cff0c1b8fb1a4a002e17eb1757b6bd7566225d405f1","unit:b3ce1702364c07ccac005bc89663e80eda79ebaab97c14e3c745780747498d88","unit:c18e8fa494418aad11176d0ee3c5e73343469558a437db25bf36a758261fdb20","unit:c494c5cfd2390c4babb6d2cc08ebe7a8141189182ad3b4a9e05c6d9255c50328","unit:c71a65e2c6cd4c65734ac90a1d78b3b6b4798542ee9720dd3b205b4e3ef0a041","unit:c847b756e39e82e1f6d3d1cdacf588f7ce16c4ddd664d82ec72eff6594ea71dc","unit:cb66dbc130fd54137b3abd2a44ba490ec912d20fa9fe6187b939f612c7504a43","unit:ef272a365d05bc42dd480239c9d77678c3ff9cf46cdc57ccd8c6c897f3d50a7f","unit:f1f735ed25cafab525eef5162c0dd95e70398d5e13d70e5925e47d711882669d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e20364c219905ed673296d48","scopeContentSha256":"4042e4ab2fa5665cdda4c6c225cc815aa81db37379ffc133de93925f1f3ea025","localRef":"s34"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf","scopeContentSha256":"4c0909a26dff37b92eb93bf6a0a9404871cf159742d072f1b0a16e064f759e97","localRef":"s18"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l10","originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:37","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l10","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:37","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:e20364c219905ed673296d48","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l10","source":"s18","target":"s34","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Specified entropy assumptions are tested for restrictions on expansion, contraction and cosmological histories; these regimes are not identified."],"challengeStatement":"Specified entropy assumptions are applied to expansion, contraction and histories while keeping those regimes distinct.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"71faa1f4477df1851ad27a60beee36157ad4238846a6423b2e594321abc760a2","reply.jsonSha256":"128765ca0c199e7519337d56f8751787d6d79439a0e14a7a5e4131968c3718da","reply.raw.txtSha256":"79f13a16fc0bc4a225dd073f65045cc82f74c13dc1660732ac8de34db00df704","receipt.jsonSha256":"cc169a91337c6e468da8be22ec52e0ba5de6a2b447154d5411e97d650e3d9b05","normalization.jsonSha256":"22e8932e0657d884bed1c74a21e127d7637d8f39b8bf158a45213512d1d7136e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6540e874330d5957264700cbc1ff58422364444c6aab4b9706f01a07dc9ca055"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"05a3a8aad07314b0fd5899c543db46f6af4e39d0360c7d9e24bff4041902b396","reply.jsonSha256":"fd580105f367bae7f008249bfbd47cbaadd58321a5958bd66c95f3d89cdad343","reply.raw.txtSha256":"050b32cf6091ddcb6cafa2d07d87b34823b463761d03c00d9fcfa7212d429b6c","receipt.jsonSha256":"e090e480dab107992b791ab3731a55b88ae91e65d253c02edee81a82fcda818c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d08d94b6760d12b693c2d593a64bdbe68e1c09c3b04b5e29d180d9a0b62493ac"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf"},{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e20364c219905ed673296d48"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf"},{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e20364c219905ed673296d48"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d10","originalRef":"l10","status":"route","source":"s34","target":"s18","type":"application_of","title":"Examine bound assumptions behind cosmological restrictions","rationale":"The history and evolution questions in s34 apply specified entropy assumptions and bound formulations organized in s18.","qualification":"Expansion, contraction, bounce and postbounce thermal comparisons remain distinct, with source-specific dimensions, matter and cosmological constants. Extra-dimensional entropy inflow, unitary horizon descriptions and thermodynamic area entropy are conditional inputs. Ordinary scalar GR is not identified with the high-energy tachyonic braneworld setting or its field coordinate. Formal inequality compatibility does not establish full eternal-inflation consistency, and the GUP illustration does not supply a completed stochastic model.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l10","s18","s34"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d10","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"s34 applies specified entropy assumptions to cosmological restrictions and histories, with s18 supplying the formulation questions. The record keeps expansion, contraction and bounce regimes separate and retains the conditional thermodynamic and construction-specific premises.","refs":["l10","s18","s34"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l10","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l11":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l11","source":"q025-candidate-question:ad6c5034c955207e7dbead3b","target":"q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1","type":"application_of","title":"Trace cosmological extensions to black-hole information constructions","rationale":"The explicitly proposed cosmological extensions in s23 apply black-hole information and interior constructions organized in s26.","qualification":"The route covers those proposed extensions, not every cosmological horizon comparison or EFT question. Preserve each cosmological background and the separate assumptions concerning fuzzball resolution, finite amplitudes and fixed-energy comparisons. Black-hole premises about unitarity, causality or interiors do not transfer automatically. A duration bound is distinct from stabilization, and proposed black-hole stabilization does not establish stabilized de Sitter space.","evidenceIds":["unit:060ca229597c675883b8795f21efbaeb7beb61bb72c17d107bd6390b31893f9b","unit:1e8ac24f6b97a40351d25374daed8a5f8650e0fef06abbb205d93de240efa3d2","unit:44cc0df15e3be0f899527d5fe300a75ea06f23950fd36c52cd04b72b00b1fcdb","unit:4aca4f0af754c403fe24bfb91bbb8b2121529a4670028f44ee02561c22db1ded","unit:544afce91f3f26f428955683ef8b2e0198029f59bf5c4cc89ab6825118ed9d28","unit:564f85e2d891497edd3155019661968036fc56e67ac3265e31b3397d10a71a3a","unit:6a09d71d3b564de4aecff192b56fcba54d7efe508c632b7b07a962f0c624b5b6","unit:78836b55f19a64fa4ff165d2d82151818e88718419f3cb905644012a3201d3c8","unit:8dbd997bca967f93dcbb7ce2bae1c7560efaf7f651e9a1bf23b09c5b9a070f46","unit:8e88af0072178a91d959825128990ed827b96940f85b2a702c6d51377f7eab20","unit:a6e60d1065a43f3347df9f40a6ebfba3ed30184ec73c1550c2ba218752b87440","unit:b5be332b824e0a71ea775dd55084860d22b2dd0d8d606acfe601320048bde0f2","unit:bf281f4d17bcb73d0750080a278777fc2fa98d9d88be58955da3b53ce9de309f","unit:bfe365f00f5bf8c6e5a68ce4c2d68810b20898088460d0ebd34bd64a19f18d82","unit:c14dcedd993b5ae69893ecd16b4852e8538b395023bd8ec59be24683c4abd6e8","unit:c4909788d126d68aca9717c4686bf51a73466d49ac42de73f4d78a32ffc9b7cc","unit:c52197fa10beaa6c1d1080c3e34d75ce6b78c8a60e0b12a140c9d7c588f98ffc","unit:d57774f6c14442241866d1feda7b5d634aa65d83789ebff25d7ccd52ebcc3909","unit:d918612dc42f7740e8dc1c82b03fd6443cffaee457051049d67bc1096bd22d8f","unit:ffc295e02ea2bc590df9ee37dbbe4706bec8ab5d89587f1d6e2f90a8748b3c87"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ad6c5034c955207e7dbead3b","scopeContentSha256":"641f2543b9115a38905cef7068a1a6c199dcb474b005b803ed2ee5f5d6ac2aaf","localRef":"s23"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1","scopeContentSha256":"ec72d997efbf3777e636b33eeb54df9badb1160e950b011f7117c74be70e4037","localRef":"s26"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l11","originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:32","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l11","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:32","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:ad6c5034c955207e7dbead3b","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l11","source":"s26","target":"s23","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Retains explicitly proposed cosmological extensions of black-hole information constructions without transferring their assumptions or conclusions automatically."],"challengeStatement":"Preserves proposed cosmological extensions without automatically transferring black-hole premises or conclusions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"71faa1f4477df1851ad27a60beee36157ad4238846a6423b2e594321abc760a2","reply.jsonSha256":"128765ca0c199e7519337d56f8751787d6d79439a0e14a7a5e4131968c3718da","reply.raw.txtSha256":"79f13a16fc0bc4a225dd073f65045cc82f74c13dc1660732ac8de34db00df704","receipt.jsonSha256":"cc169a91337c6e468da8be22ec52e0ba5de6a2b447154d5411e97d650e3d9b05","normalization.jsonSha256":"22e8932e0657d884bed1c74a21e127d7637d8f39b8bf158a45213512d1d7136e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6540e874330d5957264700cbc1ff58422364444c6aab4b9706f01a07dc9ca055"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"05a3a8aad07314b0fd5899c543db46f6af4e39d0360c7d9e24bff4041902b396","reply.jsonSha256":"fd580105f367bae7f008249bfbd47cbaadd58321a5958bd66c95f3d89cdad343","reply.raw.txtSha256":"050b32cf6091ddcb6cafa2d07d87b34823b463761d03c00d9fcfa7212d429b6c","receipt.jsonSha256":"e090e480dab107992b791ab3731a55b88ae91e65d253c02edee81a82fcda818c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d08d94b6760d12b693c2d593a64bdbe68e1c09c3b04b5e29d180d9a0b62493ac"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1"},{"ref":"x2_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ad6c5034c955207e7dbead3b"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1"},{"ref":"x2_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ad6c5034c955207e7dbead3b"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d11","originalRef":"l11","status":"route","source":"s23","target":"s26","type":"application_of","title":"Trace cosmological extensions to black-hole information constructions","rationale":"The explicitly proposed cosmological extensions in s23 apply black-hole information and interior constructions organized in s26.","qualification":"The route covers those proposed extensions, not every cosmological horizon comparison or EFT question. Preserve each cosmological background and the separate assumptions concerning fuzzball resolution, finite amplitudes and fixed-energy comparisons. Black-hole premises about unitarity, causality or interiors do not transfer automatically. A duration bound is distinct from stabilization, and proposed black-hole stabilization does not establish stabilized de Sitter space.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l11","s26","s23"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d11","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The explicitly proposed cosmological extensions in s23 are applications of the relevant black-hole information constructions in s26. The qualification excludes automatic transfer to every cosmological target and preserves the separation between duration bounds and stabilization.","refs":["l11","s26","s23"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l11","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l12":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l12","source":"q025-candidate-question:d77c0c524f51f526be3502c0","target":"q025-candidate-question:af98307d84cf3d8781924708","type":"application_of","title":"Examine microstate and hair diagnostics behind response proposals","rationale":"The relevant collapse, response and phenomenology questions in s31 apply microstate and hair diagnostics organized in s24.","qualification":"Only proposals using those diagnostics are covered; microscopic mechanisms and collapse corrections remain source-specific. Preserve the distinctions among classical hair, quantum hair, memory stabilization and the different symmetry notions. Proposed observables are not detections or validated current constraints. Microstate measurability does not demonstrate an evaporation-recovery protocol, and collapse extremality is distinct from evaporation past extremality.","evidenceIds":["unit:0647b23fdbab1b882f600a99ae63de7ff213a9a09472be29b7be95668740c6d3","unit:0cae689be581e7d71dd2506f746e33a9fc83ce6823f7bf0cb8a3685d8a2ef016","unit:156fea61d40725e6b1eacd15b7c9842ef1c66cbdc6b2352dabb0f935017264ac","unit:17c438be3fe0660fe04c53d2e40453ce7c5a82a0958bd77849f3066ae3653241","unit:17ca36ddb7d4c044a25c46920fadc3b5f9860264b838e423895c3810b953d7f8","unit:17cda36e842d4c7bfbe64f2b1c413cb7b1028b5f792389037c40539a4e494b49","unit:1e8ac24f6b97a40351d25374daed8a5f8650e0fef06abbb205d93de240efa3d2","unit:1fb303e65651ccb65041efc93318e523bdda0160de95ea2e872d77fb7fde910e","unit:231c3d4e09a957ed1933492f83c0cbc9d5b5a7058a0f96058cf4b896ffa19cdf","unit:29c96cc491110a4f82ad7946b66989af5fa67b0b9638611af029682259dcf02e","unit:2bf4d1b3c3bd6a02f5e8a04c31d2db66c28f9161e9d2452ac6ea01c192151a4b","unit:3215f809fd5c58ac548dca1f3579c6fcbf3c019a1adc22e87184739b5be0f747","unit:336f5a3b053e2cb260459111b1fd1e8f50b750ef9f5be4bb2726319c8ca3f5f5","unit:3e2d2e1a12485a264aa42410305082695b454ed8d460bc9a16a06d5fdda91dc7","unit:48c51a222538ab1b1813e864a0a2703902cc9f055c08a817078952c09b4a8334","unit:4b99f1136f864e2624968c9710ecd8041fa71f4d66de5ce134f7b445a02d10c6","unit:51759a1d3a5b38428351b58c3b8451c7078a25d27c3cc5702e77d89fbfff5d14","unit:564f85e2d891497edd3155019661968036fc56e67ac3265e31b3397d10a71a3a","unit:5e8086016891e91ed450f822ed042f9961f523c3d4c7f1eaafac7ef0eb1d4a93","unit:5e9fcdf93bded88fa4d95c2511682d411a55827f0d9eef7ca7e700cfea0cb4ed","unit:6d821266f428e5b18edb56762d276938526008a7eb57ef93d0092277bf08d9a3","unit:7deaeeded8502f83dfe9aa06824f2e247dd9dae6ad1c73340f4096586914da5f","unit:a3f93d37e29ef9f91403bccf02f308346c7ee6859aba9041d4838c57df8aadc7","unit:c2de062c2460d417101aa8d125e5329195f50037a80b079b2ddbcc86436ed5eb","unit:ea2857e167730729c1f979dcb1a75af316628a2b620240b24cf9af3008ca999f","unit:fc87c0925ce66d052cefdb25850a547620e60cdb0aa5c17ddded66de00a2233f","unit:fe13f782dceacf451f5592a53ab4cc3524d85cd7d3ed458a1a540ed96fd2ab9e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d77c0c524f51f526be3502c0","scopeContentSha256":"9300f932f4d0fa8d87915949f99da14bf0a4138ac05becea9a197dd34743e828","localRef":"s31"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:af98307d84cf3d8781924708","scopeContentSha256":"51be4ba5d6c1170aae41990375846b538eb3d6595ba47868aaff428dfcf908a7","localRef":"s24"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l12","originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:35","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l12","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge:link:35","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:af98307d84cf3d8781924708","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:d77c0c524f51f526be3502c0","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l12","source":"s24","target":"s31","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Microstate and hair diagnostics connect to conditional collapse, response and phenomenology questions, without claiming observational validation."],"challengeStatement":"Microstate and hair diagnostics connect to proposed response and phenomenology without observational validation being inferred.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"71faa1f4477df1851ad27a60beee36157ad4238846a6423b2e594321abc760a2","reply.jsonSha256":"128765ca0c199e7519337d56f8751787d6d79439a0e14a7a5e4131968c3718da","reply.raw.txtSha256":"79f13a16fc0bc4a225dd073f65045cc82f74c13dc1660732ac8de34db00df704","receipt.jsonSha256":"cc169a91337c6e468da8be22ec52e0ba5de6a2b447154d5411e97d650e3d9b05","normalization.jsonSha256":"22e8932e0657d884bed1c74a21e127d7637d8f39b8bf158a45213512d1d7136e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6540e874330d5957264700cbc1ff58422364444c6aab4b9706f01a07dc9ca055"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-93e54ec3771cd79938de-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"05a3a8aad07314b0fd5899c543db46f6af4e39d0360c7d9e24bff4041902b396","reply.jsonSha256":"fd580105f367bae7f008249bfbd47cbaadd58321a5958bd66c95f3d89cdad343","reply.raw.txtSha256":"050b32cf6091ddcb6cafa2d07d87b34823b463761d03c00d9fcfa7212d429b6c","receipt.jsonSha256":"e090e480dab107992b791ab3731a55b88ae91e65d253c02edee81a82fcda818c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d08d94b6760d12b693c2d593a64bdbe68e1c09c3b04b5e29d180d9a0b62493ac"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:af98307d84cf3d8781924708"},{"ref":"x2_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d77c0c524f51f526be3502c0"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:af98307d84cf3d8781924708"},{"ref":"x2_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d77c0c524f51f526be3502c0"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d12","originalRef":"l12","status":"route","source":"s31","target":"s24","type":"application_of","title":"Examine microstate and hair diagnostics behind response proposals","rationale":"The relevant collapse, response and phenomenology questions in s31 apply microstate and hair diagnostics organized in s24.","qualification":"Only proposals using those diagnostics are covered; microscopic mechanisms and collapse corrections remain source-specific. Preserve the distinctions among classical hair, quantum hair, memory stabilization and the different symmetry notions. Proposed observables are not detections or validated current constraints. Microstate measurability does not demonstrate an evaporation-recovery protocol, and collapse extremality is distinct from evaporation past extremality.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l12","s24","s31"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d12","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The relevant response and phenomenology proposals in s31 apply microstate and hair diagnostics organized in s24. The record retains their source-specific mechanisms and does not infer observational validation, information recovery or equivalence among different kinds of hair.","refs":["l12","s24","s31"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l12","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l13":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l13","source":"q025-candidate-question:5b92b8a6f9019e398cfb5784","target":"q025-candidate-question:aa9e8f77039c027d166b948b","type":"application_of","title":"Assess late-time models through cosmological inference","rationale":"The observational tests of late-time scalar, interaction and gravity models in s8 are applications of the cosmological inference questions in s22.","qualification":"This covers their empirical assessment, not every theoretical branch of s8. Preserve model parametrization, coupling law, coupled fraction, activation epoch and source-era datasets. Local and CMB-inferred quantities have different dependencies, and low-redshift fits need not supply a CMB-compatible completion. Effective phantom behavior remains distinct from intrinsic scalar dynamics. No current observational endorsement, universal finite-scan exclusion or ultraviolet completion follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:02032097506faedddb62304121141d37daed97aa51550d412877361dc5817ab7","unit:068ae3ce97a07b731988ed7a76794e559826f3b7d3afb7c5649d52ee51709311","unit:0b4b8abf0d8e063179eeecc46516c9576d8158ffbddb9c8e243355cd312fa26b","unit:0c749889a53f8494c6ca41890db42a4debbcad9668327318abb7dfcb3414854b","unit:0cd4e5ce259251c416dc4166c24613a05bea040eccb42b023dc3ec4ce6f9809e","unit:1943686355ffcbd0ed2489683c28cc64496cbab9fc30c769a17c99191613edc4","unit:1bc4a19f0ec42ec94225380934f72731a9c60065c4ead1a69c67c69211e377ec","unit:1f7c4843eb29fa0dce4578c3b09bf709c29ad71239de64bf60f47a277580ea84","unit:2141d5a90208c4e7c451d3ae9c1781b42bfb510edba4712908245bfa75dd38b8","unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","unit:25480af9ca73f0a0d198c5b0ce868fcf8149208866ae7dd7f77300e0d93f9e17","unit:279fdf317c72f5b4824d46606885c809ea644ac172f7ca910684193d422eecf9","unit:2abb832ff7edfe528660455b2cc47b5276e2db395694705f0f5316abc4ec5d60","unit:2bca860e1bed7e71bad21f6776c628f6d1a7d930a16ffbca1e32dc98305b183d","unit:2fb23e35f3fddccfdbfd75c725d6691ab7133cd101087735fa51a004aa401880","unit:397f26b2b8a42cb0076d5f2761bf0376685743790d9129b9e0e142c97c6646a1","unit:3cd590dd47591ec30441652a5a76986fe49922853b644828174ff4e1bd02cbc6","unit:41bf48aec68dbcb8e9c8619115dd922804036c22c4f75a2ed9e277e5dfd568c9","unit:469ee4501419e395c32c25d65527c8c8b0b2626fbdce9ffe36f32f9429fcb07f","unit:49146291657b56c2afbab12783c41586bc6c23683b0d171d2a71ba03e2e12909","unit:4b00bb366f0b93b8f8acbbbaff3375a07842218474925590d04666643f6a50dc","unit:4f54e7cdc7f42fd93ef20fa67fa8b3b26f46f43d79730d4b5e561fa1bdb0cf06","unit:4fb0631119e19948090cfce6f4de34d798b58a6b8de8a44dd26a4b632fbc39bc","unit:52674c49cd24872c0235d506bf5e857ed3dc9818ac42aed22bd3beabd1e03bf4","unit:5536825aa47f3028f26c1a434cd2e3f7cdef94760b459383eb6c1f2d4c0911f8","unit:55e6ca617215ff9154355a526b2a4add2d429ec928eeaac8871c63fafa0446f3","unit:572560320934137fe355205341432f20b9d136b7e4c7361db3f73630d5cac569","unit:60dfaba99ee7b32f108b89fc63d65c5ce7122fe1e29b740d923fc45ea7b6816d","unit:6a956503c160bc9c2d848c2d0198820f44819f8cf93f14871c7a3a1b8b961a63","unit:6f4fd127eaf6e8719466b368c2cf8bfd7264280dea0d27ec05033e5bac1d9864","unit:80645b8e26a88ca75b80f33e04649180b3251870ca72e3462ee498825c5ea17e","unit:811fc507adbd56147a407a3c27834c71143f9f31532209f285b7ace37d95154c","unit:83fa531df0055fb02fa7adb441fa52cf42512236f4e952f4a5e650c09e11ee43","unit:90d8b37007101e41fa484d6988d28bd149638505e624b107295dcc6cac963f35","unit:93c48a6b14d3e486de8f91d777f5458d6746ce075de14ef5c0a6f0630cd65330","unit:98951634b5d15dc095c202922191d619e4bc4e8d52196a898c1c74983babec41","unit:9f20b6b4ef99bc023e543aa0931b623f01cda5a53951fc0f0ff711b889fb8a4c","unit:a1a99d849cf14b253817dfa57e2c322bd44577cf622d1f1ab5c33b118f19bca5","unit:a24ee933f9c08f58fccfeaac95856a8775c591a9772bcba9d04d7676b26b76fd","unit:a2a19d1f7a904b42706919a86bf8b2493b98d3b9ed5575fc89583c8eba64ae8f","unit:a66fc9d2a86077a684da5d9e1a4a8a491919fefaedc531bc93211900f6f2dca4","unit:aabefc98b676930b9d77140acc87d719fcb1c10c30d4d27d94d3801638a3539f","unit:abb14a5bb36ce89c104f873ad0bf1e63e33f64f8089035f40e74c2a14246f805","unit:ae0ddac995b2e79363de6348f097a07e4b0bbb8c8ec86902c65014839e199c68","unit:b18796fd6431a2e70b145190a9f2eaeedecac7c459456895518421d6b932858f","unit:b54155b3e31ce92586da0d9f2f0a2471b165dde362f29329f9e5336f38b0d32c","unit:c0323fc367091f22046fc3d2b367e45c455449092bfb41af253e933ab831cc24","unit:c35d076d4f3b4fd721a37141ffd6591794aabe2f6ba4e57eaedeac4bcb8ebd97","unit:d20a615b87317bb8ed1693e0eecc0ee25d0247c4102a454b632fcb18b77df59b","unit:d889111f077812ed6772d926aeaed05c188987c83643fa9e4dd59c905d3dbe6a","unit:d8c52b05c4560ab28fa9152563288e159d1ff5fab9ffdb00782eac7467d93a1e","unit:db3f55d3d74607027ca00996c598c6b1961c339daebb9d8d6d3790c3fe99c00b","unit:ea4568d8a2dc5712c0a8729925ad0a1400c4b938fbcf9e02fa33802fee01f665","unit:ef8bb900834c00bd63d88fbdc9cff4943d17694f64e42c20566cbb9547d068c1","unit:f39f5dcd2e7a7de4e08828e661f5d8ee0c50fcf7c57027cfb294cc10b32e80b5","unit:f5a3d56f92ce1dffa91804b9dc594353296ce9de7fea28ef075d6f1b2ea5519a","unit:f6da200f69d272774a8e14429d9ade47a7a38981f99b72f40042ae0a4cced16a","unit:f6e2e15f9e23bf3523f282b342f89730d61abbd87196ad32f2d6532909f887f3","unit:f97b8426b1a2eb17b9d4566e6de6675008935b5c4529b33e7a6290732cc672ec","unit:fd2bb8b289796dfefbc3d362f0fa0784dcd9a3d9699535d0dd68fbb7dec1b983"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5b92b8a6f9019e398cfb5784","scopeContentSha256":"0ad3b3f71674ff362425b140142e59f55e207f26a8d04d218b1638d883d4a234","localRef":"s8"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:aa9e8f77039c027d166b948b","scopeContentSha256":"a1eb97621620dd97a88b83616539ae06f8400292f68df99855c7ded5bbdf8b51","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l13","originalCandidateId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge:link:34","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l13","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge:link:34","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:aa9e8f77039c027d166b948b","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:5b92b8a6f9019e398cfb5784","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l13","source":"s22","target":"s8","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Late-time scalar, interaction and gravity models provide a specific application of cosmological inference."],"challengeStatement":"Late-time scalar, interaction and gravity models provide applications of cosmological inference.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"7b33b16c985585a06b369b1d0d8f2223ea66f4bf751e8180c02bac1d73685cad","reply.jsonSha256":"1f6db74d58e33725f67aec60f85cbb15f0bcf7f2b88678a3327e4ea342d661c7","reply.raw.txtSha256":"68f65e9cdbde08c1baabde287b0807d7de16a13f2f05da01eca5c7d7f804ab37","receipt.jsonSha256":"9351a4e44cb862bf94bd5d62d4ba23cc06434fe4035352177c15f4ecd41f1c33","normalization.jsonSha256":"5bb01ca69a3683f3cac170091b720de22bb04698b69c9b7d5a53283e96a10200","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"681b060972d2664e2c8461d9d9ba1c6a105480ab939d527c82406b3eba67fb77"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"894314622f9c38a49311c9aba776c5764c823d15384a6e582538f5b4d1b4a3fd","reply.jsonSha256":"b670b1f143a82ba9448c0b01000b16afb6d831937be636f0287ee70b1a133499","reply.raw.txtSha256":"8d3183c6cfd51f88c29ccc9c473017a0d31b94c74bb9512f0201658c79b8594e","receipt.jsonSha256":"14618f9fbef0ad8ab6c2b1b6f497a337f04bcc06f46b8263213fcf5440148635","normalization.jsonSha256":"894fb0b86097950af3369e4ef1eb9944571800d944830fa18ca9ef6594c63998"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:aa9e8f77039c027d166b948b"},{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5b92b8a6f9019e398cfb5784"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:aa9e8f77039c027d166b948b"},{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5b92b8a6f9019e398cfb5784"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d13","originalRef":"l13","status":"route","source":"s8","target":"s22","type":"application_of","title":"Assess late-time models through cosmological inference","rationale":"The observational tests of late-time scalar, interaction and gravity models in s8 are applications of the cosmological inference questions in s22.","qualification":"This covers their empirical assessment, not every theoretical branch of s8. Preserve model parametrization, coupling law, coupled fraction, activation epoch and source-era datasets. Local and CMB-inferred quantities have different dependencies, and low-redshift fits need not supply a CMB-compatible completion. Effective phantom behavior remains distinct from intrinsic scalar dynamics. No current observational endorsement, universal finite-scan exclusion or ultraviolet completion follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l13","s22","s8"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d13","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Empirical assessment of the late-time models in s8 applies the cosmological inference questions in s22. The record limits the route to that assessment and preserves coupling, dataset, calibration and cross-epoch completion conditions.","refs":["l13","s22","s8"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l13","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l14":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l14","source":"q025-candidate-question:dc90e03f54c0e3c60ed47cb5","target":"q025-candidate-question:aa9e8f77039c027d166b948b","type":"application_of","title":"Assess early energy injection with cosmological observations","rationale":"The early-energy-injection and coupled-sector questions in s33 provide epoch-specific applications of the discrepancy and inference questions in s22.","qualification":"Retain the specified equality or pre-recombination timing and separate acoustic, recombination, perturbation and structure requirements. Fits depend on the selected model and source-era datasets. All-matter and fractional couplings are different premises; the supplied SDC discussion does not determine the coupled fraction. Proposed extensions remain distinct from performed fits, and no universal EDE solution, new coupling limit or model-independent SDC exclusion is inferred.","evidenceIds":["unit:00d5751423da07ea4f6eb13b7ef6de7fcdedc730b926e15d3e51bb9b1ca9c720","unit:02032097506faedddb62304121141d37daed97aa51550d412877361dc5817ab7","unit:0b4b8abf0d8e063179eeecc46516c9576d8158ffbddb9c8e243355cd312fa26b","unit:0c749889a53f8494c6ca41890db42a4debbcad9668327318abb7dfcb3414854b","unit:0cd4e5ce259251c416dc4166c24613a05bea040eccb42b023dc3ec4ce6f9809e","unit:0ceb2b9ca4cbc33d7bc5530d1c5b6c60ca32d9cc4ae9b44a6e530e8ef78435bb","unit:17bf0f1a467406d255b5e19a7ac15f339aa732fb1c0a4f89874daa05ad34a4ac","unit:1943686355ffcbd0ed2489683c28cc64496cbab9fc30c769a17c99191613edc4","unit:2141d5a90208c4e7c451d3ae9c1781b42bfb510edba4712908245bfa75dd38b8","unit:23331dba6f0afe60a3eba320984b63b48d25dc2ff083295d3f5b48c0dff6e04a","unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","unit:25480af9ca73f0a0d198c5b0ce868fcf8149208866ae7dd7f77300e0d93f9e17","unit:2abb832ff7edfe528660455b2cc47b5276e2db395694705f0f5316abc4ec5d60","unit:2bca860e1bed7e71bad21f6776c628f6d1a7d930a16ffbca1e32dc98305b183d","unit:2fb23e35f3fddccfdbfd75c725d6691ab7133cd101087735fa51a004aa401880","unit:323e9b5e0a6a7dda5ca48238344d82dc4e5b613b2e67ebb1067873453cc811dd","unit:3cd590dd47591ec30441652a5a76986fe49922853b644828174ff4e1bd02cbc6","unit:41bf48aec68dbcb8e9c8619115dd922804036c22c4f75a2ed9e277e5dfd568c9","unit:469ee4501419e395c32c25d65527c8c8b0b2626fbdce9ffe36f32f9429fcb07f","unit:49146291657b56c2afbab12783c41586bc6c23683b0d171d2a71ba03e2e12909","unit:4b00bb366f0b93b8f8acbbbaff3375a07842218474925590d04666643f6a50dc","unit:4d0e750899a2c52abc9884da3304caa54be49c5b95056a41fc82de7ce3b0eee4","unit:4f54e7cdc7f42fd93ef20fa67fa8b3b26f46f43d79730d4b5e561fa1bdb0cf06","unit:4fb0631119e19948090cfce6f4de34d798b58a6b8de8a44dd26a4b632fbc39bc","unit:52674c49cd24872c0235d506bf5e857ed3dc9818ac42aed22bd3beabd1e03bf4","unit:5536825aa47f3028f26c1a434cd2e3f7cdef94760b459383eb6c1f2d4c0911f8","unit:572560320934137fe355205341432f20b9d136b7e4c7361db3f73630d5cac569","unit:5fc4d96969fb3009992757a37a3b13de55ace9d448c8215f4b59ef29296a5f14","unit:6a956503c160bc9c2d848c2d0198820f44819f8cf93f14871c7a3a1b8b961a63","unit:6c5fcea36cd89f1b174781e634fcc3734d2d1fb9bc9ea721b8ce0d18622865f2","unit:6fd101c96b61e88a2d7dccc83700d3974739bfdbeb899963a38031aa7756e6b5","unit:73b0d813937bde1d6ea51e4b699d7c137a48862c4a3b1e3775e8643de2b98ff9","unit:80645b8e26a88ca75b80f33e04649180b3251870ca72e3462ee498825c5ea17e","unit:811fc507adbd56147a407a3c27834c71143f9f31532209f285b7ace37d95154c","unit:83fa531df0055fb02fa7adb441fa52cf42512236f4e952f4a5e650c09e11ee43","unit:859285a6f0599dfadae16769ced367f89fac5223023cd2cd8e997fb90f295095","unit:90d8b37007101e41fa484d6988d28bd149638505e624b107295dcc6cac963f35","unit:93c48a6b14d3e486de8f91d777f5458d6746ce075de14ef5c0a6f0630cd65330","unit:98951634b5d15dc095c202922191d619e4bc4e8d52196a898c1c74983babec41","unit:9d6cfaa49438e20e5f5e365f2b183118e55d93ac6a9eb524bfcb988e206477ff","unit:9f20b6b4ef99bc023e543aa0931b623f01cda5a53951fc0f0ff711b889fb8a4c","unit:a1a99d849cf14b253817dfa57e2c322bd44577cf622d1f1ab5c33b118f19bca5","unit:a66fc9d2a86077a684da5d9e1a4a8a491919fefaedc531bc93211900f6f2dca4","unit:abb14a5bb36ce89c104f873ad0bf1e63e33f64f8089035f40e74c2a14246f805","unit:b54155b3e31ce92586da0d9f2f0a2471b165dde362f29329f9e5336f38b0d32c","unit:b815dd160e57fb55e9ea389a7553227ab4c02b2e181a7da62dd08571b2dab756","unit:bc7bff207a8fc2a36917d1a6ae207475e1385d03234ecf8234f4d507af650454","unit:c35d076d4f3b4fd721a37141ffd6591794aabe2f6ba4e57eaedeac4bcb8ebd97","unit:c772b1ee93e23887b9d58d4e623e8a6efa052139f9caf6d5e43cb479ecf4ae8b","unit:c956bad6f72d933b2ac88d4c454a41357007ef6f7a50ff37963a5c1248ea5d35","unit:d20a615b87317bb8ed1693e0eecc0ee25d0247c4102a454b632fcb18b77df59b","unit:d8c52b05c4560ab28fa9152563288e159d1ff5fab9ffdb00782eac7467d93a1e","unit:ea4568d8a2dc5712c0a8729925ad0a1400c4b938fbcf9e02fa33802fee01f665","unit:ed014b9e278ca66da579e43b683a94e513510ba64c99c77de4b03df3b3c234ee","unit:ef8bb900834c00bd63d88fbdc9cff4943d17694f64e42c20566cbb9547d068c1","unit:f456972ffe58ee33c6c2e2cb5cb0ea95dc37897c74f167980abd19fa48963d94","unit:f6da200f69d272774a8e14429d9ade47a7a38981f99b72f40042ae0a4cced16a","unit:f6e2e15f9e23bf3523f282b342f89730d61abbd87196ad32f2d6532909f887f3","unit:f97b8426b1a2eb17b9d4566e6de6675008935b5c4529b33e7a6290732cc672ec","unit:fd2bb8b289796dfefbc3d362f0fa0784dcd9a3d9699535d0dd68fbb7dec1b983"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:dc90e03f54c0e3c60ed47cb5","scopeContentSha256":"61b4ad373ce48765b62d446f02e523b6947a92ae48ea5f13757f0cd6d3ae81f6","localRef":"s33"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:aa9e8f77039c027d166b948b","scopeContentSha256":"a1eb97621620dd97a88b83616539ae06f8400292f68df99855c7ded5bbdf8b51","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l14","originalCandidateId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge:link:35","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l14","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge:link:35","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:aa9e8f77039c027d166b948b","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:dc90e03f54c0e3c60ed47cb5","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l14","source":"s22","target":"s33","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Early energy injection supplies an epoch-specific discrepancy application with its own acoustic, recombination and perturbation requirements."],"challengeStatement":"Early energy injection supplies an epoch-specific discrepancy application with separate acoustic, recombination and perturbation requirements.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"7b33b16c985585a06b369b1d0d8f2223ea66f4bf751e8180c02bac1d73685cad","reply.jsonSha256":"1f6db74d58e33725f67aec60f85cbb15f0bcf7f2b88678a3327e4ea342d661c7","reply.raw.txtSha256":"68f65e9cdbde08c1baabde287b0807d7de16a13f2f05da01eca5c7d7f804ab37","receipt.jsonSha256":"9351a4e44cb862bf94bd5d62d4ba23cc06434fe4035352177c15f4ecd41f1c33","normalization.jsonSha256":"5bb01ca69a3683f3cac170091b720de22bb04698b69c9b7d5a53283e96a10200","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"681b060972d2664e2c8461d9d9ba1c6a105480ab939d527c82406b3eba67fb77"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"894314622f9c38a49311c9aba776c5764c823d15384a6e582538f5b4d1b4a3fd","reply.jsonSha256":"b670b1f143a82ba9448c0b01000b16afb6d831937be636f0287ee70b1a133499","reply.raw.txtSha256":"8d3183c6cfd51f88c29ccc9c473017a0d31b94c74bb9512f0201658c79b8594e","receipt.jsonSha256":"14618f9fbef0ad8ab6c2b1b6f497a337f04bcc06f46b8263213fcf5440148635","normalization.jsonSha256":"894fb0b86097950af3369e4ef1eb9944571800d944830fa18ca9ef6594c63998"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:aa9e8f77039c027d166b948b"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:dc90e03f54c0e3c60ed47cb5"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:aa9e8f77039c027d166b948b"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:dc90e03f54c0e3c60ed47cb5"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d14","originalRef":"l14","status":"route","source":"s33","target":"s22","type":"application_of","title":"Assess early energy injection with cosmological observations","rationale":"The early-energy-injection and coupled-sector questions in s33 provide epoch-specific applications of the discrepancy and inference questions in s22.","qualification":"Retain the specified equality or pre-recombination timing and separate acoustic, recombination, perturbation and structure requirements. Fits depend on the selected model and source-era datasets. All-matter and fractional couplings are different premises; the supplied SDC discussion does not determine the coupled fraction. Proposed extensions remain distinct from performed fits, and no universal EDE solution, new coupling limit or model-independent SDC exclusion is inferred.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l14","s22","s33"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d14","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"s33 supplies the epoch-specific application of cosmological discrepancy inference in s22. The record retains acoustic, recombination, perturbation and structure requirements, source-era datasets and the distinction between proposed extensions and performed fits.","refs":["l14","s22","s33"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l14","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"}}}