{"schemaVersion":"1.0.0","kind":"eigenquestions-organizational-access-certificates","records":{"organizational-access:c18f8d6bd5ddfc4610e924cf":{"id":"organizational-access:c18f8d6bd5ddfc4610e924cf","source":"q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b","target":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e5f0b23e05b128ff01faf30c56b499ddf93e45dcfd83b25fe7c3d1a35cf9eb55","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:98807f68849d9c5d578063b5"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ccd5e77a867e82ef7825199cd2d2c893840dc9ae3a8e87e1462a81ac1aa99d41","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:statistics:pq0"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0c841dc4b0d3731e9687fd46d5af8ebfdd1d6f3dc57d88201a91355d0f9cbc4b","home":{"unitId":"unit:0c841dc4b0d3731e9687fd46d5af8ebfdd1d6f3dc57d88201a91355d0f9cbc4b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0c841dc4b0d3731e9687fd46d5af8ebfdd1d6f3dc57d88201a91355d0f9cbc4b","paperId":"1902.10093","textSha256":"af7ef270de0a6e2d62fb11f4ae16750a38ea20b3026c11c2396f35f80131564a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:91d23cf3d4ce7e38f1cb4124"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:91d23cf3d4ce7e38f1cb4124","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0c841dc4b0d3731e9687fd46d5af8ebfdd1d6f3dc57d88201a91355d0f9cbc4b","q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e5f0b23e05b128ff01faf30c56b499ddf93e45dcfd83b25fe7c3d1a35cf9eb55","placementContentSha256":"3ae60abc2b226bda1859fd0b17c89c71bf4cb4a79550129102729eab7f6ac341","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge","leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0c841dc4b0d3731e9687fd46d5af8ebfdd1d6f3dc57d88201a91355d0f9cbc4b","paperId":"1902.10093","textSha256":"af7ef270de0a6e2d62fb11f4ae16750a38ea20b3026c11c2396f35f80131564a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:91d23cf3d4ce7e38f1cb4124"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0c841dc4b0d3731e9687fd46d5af8ebfdd1d6f3dc57d88201a91355d0f9cbc4b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u33","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0c841dc4b0d3731e9687fd46d5af8ebfdd1d6f3dc57d88201a91355d0f9cbc4b","paperId":"1902.10093","textSha256":"af7ef270de0a6e2d62fb11f4ae16750a38ea20b3026c11c2396f35f80131564a"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:02ab63bee4b07e0b303a5a503a068b2a","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":30,"start":1917,"end":3517,"textSha256":"5e20c9555081e7a7078068b3749dd7e9542703fde5380a4e6a3c6b2694ad1aa3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:550eb8fc26b3055601fead3df0331240","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":30,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"99b1beb1f45d1ea918b16dee11187c74a028336c5f719b32bb7b2d4feb53df91","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"qualification":"The description directly combines weak coupling, physical lengths, flux quantization and bounded orientifold availability. The associated primary discussion leaves an internal hierarchy unresolved.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z10"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z10","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0c841dc4b0d3731e9687fd46d5af8ebfdd1d6f3dc57d88201a91355d0f9cbc4b","q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02"],"scopeContentSha256":"ccd5e77a867e82ef7825199cd2d2c893840dc9ae3a8e87e1462a81ac1aa99d41","contributionContentSha256":"162daeebd9e978619d1bbd7e65b68d84e6e6e1d12f552bc95829bf77a611fd95","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation"},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","statistics-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u33","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0c841dc4b0d3731e9687fd46d5af8ebfdd1d6f3dc57d88201a91355d0f9cbc4b","paperId":"1902.10093","textSha256":"af7ef270de0a6e2d62fb11f4ae16750a38ea20b3026c11c2396f35f80131564a"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:02ab63bee4b07e0b303a5a503a068b2a","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":30,"start":1917,"end":3517,"textSha256":"5e20c9555081e7a7078068b3749dd7e9542703fde5380a4e6a3c6b2694ad1aa3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:550eb8fc26b3055601fead3df0331240","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":30,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"99b1beb1f45d1ea918b16dee11187c74a028336c5f719b32bb7b2d4feb53df91","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"explicitConfirmation":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z10","family":"statistics","originalRowId":"z10","oldRole":{"id":"z10","unitRef":"u33","questionRef":"pq0","role":"addresses","reason":"The description directly combines weak coupling, physical lengths, flux quantization and bounded orientifold availability. The associated primary discussion leaves an internal hierarchy unresolved.","refs":["u33","e0","e1"]},"confirmation":{"id":"z10","verdict":"supported_as_written","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":[],"reason":"The description directly combines finite consistency requirements, and the same paper's supplied summary leaves the relevant internal hierarchy unresolved.","refs":["u33","pq0","e0","e1"]},"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation","qualificationUnchanged":true}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:1548338cbb2b9c5d4edf4b719dbc4af69468cfb1fec04bd4ce88c27090e8ece7","home":{"unitId":"unit:1548338cbb2b9c5d4edf4b719dbc4af69468cfb1fec04bd4ce88c27090e8ece7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1548338cbb2b9c5d4edf4b719dbc4af69468cfb1fec04bd4ce88c27090e8ece7","paperId":"2006.01848","textSha256":"97696b3a0c37c2ed9973ac23863f8a785b356194fa9b5f506bf6da555020a207"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8be6d2882b5f18cd16a83ac8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8be6d2882b5f18cd16a83ac8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1548338cbb2b9c5d4edf4b719dbc4af69468cfb1fec04bd4ce88c27090e8ece7","q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e5f0b23e05b128ff01faf30c56b499ddf93e45dcfd83b25fe7c3d1a35cf9eb55","placementContentSha256":"7e3cb63d18100dd7a1da32ccea43e071a3a3d92ed3d46d5527a8398409a6fd25","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge","leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1548338cbb2b9c5d4edf4b719dbc4af69468cfb1fec04bd4ce88c27090e8ece7","paperId":"2006.01848","textSha256":"97696b3a0c37c2ed9973ac23863f8a785b356194fa9b5f506bf6da555020a207"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8be6d2882b5f18cd16a83ac8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1548338cbb2b9c5d4edf4b719dbc4af69468cfb1fec04bd4ce88c27090e8ece7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u36","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1548338cbb2b9c5d4edf4b719dbc4af69468cfb1fec04bd4ce88c27090e8ece7","paperId":"2006.01848","textSha256":"97696b3a0c37c2ed9973ac23863f8a785b356194fa9b5f506bf6da555020a207"}],"qualification":"The description explicitly asks whether two supergravity candidates meet coupling, size, flux, source-count and lattice requirements. No primary window from this paper is supplied here.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z13"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z13","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1548338cbb2b9c5d4edf4b719dbc4af69468cfb1fec04bd4ce88c27090e8ece7","q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02"],"scopeContentSha256":"ccd5e77a867e82ef7825199cd2d2c893840dc9ae3a8e87e1462a81ac1aa99d41","contributionContentSha256":"bdfeba764753fd66d2d6908817b51bd8c164cfa0b08625a9710593e7d5e69a84","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation"},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","statistics-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u36","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1548338cbb2b9c5d4edf4b719dbc4af69468cfb1fec04bd4ce88c27090e8ece7","paperId":"2006.01848","textSha256":"97696b3a0c37c2ed9973ac23863f8a785b356194fa9b5f506bf6da555020a207"}],"explicitConfirmation":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z13","family":"statistics","originalRowId":"z13","oldRole":{"id":"z13","unitRef":"u36","questionRef":"pq0","role":"addresses","reason":"The description explicitly asks whether two supergravity candidates meet coupling, size, flux, source-count and lattice requirements. No primary window from this paper is supplied here.","refs":["u36"]},"confirmation":{"id":"z13","verdict":"supported_as_written","basis":"description_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":[],"reason":"The description directly asks whether the two candidates satisfy coupling, size, flux, source-count and compactness requirements; no own-paper primary window is supplied.","refs":["u36","pq0"]},"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation","qualificationUnchanged":true}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f8428c1416c52408a6499c90aa7f762e0d06c094670a6ea92a41a2a7418ee117","home":{"unitId":"unit:f8428c1416c52408a6499c90aa7f762e0d06c094670a6ea92a41a2a7418ee117","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Combines correction control, physical volume requirements and curvature–compactification scale hierarchy in source-specific effective descriptions.","qualification":"q0 covers both correction control and the claimed scale hierarchy in a specified Type II effective description. The M-theory organization is part of the same test; q3 alone would omit the broader control requirements and q14 alone is less explicit about tower hierarchy.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f8428c1416c52408a6499c90aa7f762e0d06c094670a6ea92a41a2a7418ee117","paperId":"2005.11421","textSha256":"3b7d037ebb007470c78d923c52b4abad46f3084a98d28f765a397683985ab482"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0049:u22:q0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0049:u22:q0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f8428c1416c52408a6499c90aa7f762e0d06c094670a6ea92a41a2a7418ee117","q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e5f0b23e05b128ff01faf30c56b499ddf93e45dcfd83b25fe7c3d1a35cf9eb55","placementContentSha256":"161ccea75f0afc149c970c1d40d7bac433ba18413f92fac0d445cb9f121877a5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0049:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0049:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f8428c1416c52408a6499c90aa7f762e0d06c094670a6ea92a41a2a7418ee117","paperId":"2005.11421","textSha256":"3b7d037ebb007470c78d923c52b4abad46f3084a98d28f765a397683985ab482"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0049","unitRef":"u22"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f8428c1416c52408a6499c90aa7f762e0d06c094670a6ea92a41a2a7418ee117","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u53","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f8428c1416c52408a6499c90aa7f762e0d06c094670a6ea92a41a2a7418ee117","paperId":"2005.11421","textSha256":"3b7d037ebb007470c78d923c52b4abad46f3084a98d28f765a397683985ab482"},{"localRef":"e33","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3bbfea0cbe8bc8f85d922bbc8eb5729f","paperId":"2005.11421","sourceSha256":"6ac21f5a212ec63ab34b58a320508c0e88034d8677a091fa859ca510b34c291c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc836cfa2b595d1baef6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d453eee52a8efc3d498a0c78849152ac503e556bc3a8f1eb5fea068495c4bfd7","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":1553,"textSha256":"c1eabb9b0f726f31608d12ea78f5be77a365b3ebaa453294c8aef5779706be65","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e35","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:946032f139fa9b7c3ac9233a9fd2c207","paperId":"2005.11421","sourceSha256":"6ac21f5a212ec63ab34b58a320508c0e88034d8677a091fa859ca510b34c291c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc836cfa2b595d1baef6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d453eee52a8efc3d498a0c78849152ac503e556bc3a8f1eb5fea068495c4bfd7","pdfPage":13,"start":0,"end":2292,"textSha256":"787f919af0d59a891f34a7a62d665dd794015c8039443c11f5e74e91cb296d17","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e36","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bbb4ead84fbceae7f3ba201c4c55fcec","paperId":"2005.11421","sourceSha256":"6ac21f5a212ec63ab34b58a320508c0e88034d8677a091fa859ca510b34c291c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc836cfa2b595d1baef6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d453eee52a8efc3d498a0c78849152ac503e556bc3a8f1eb5fea068495c4bfd7","pdfPage":7,"start":0,"end":2780,"textSha256":"8861eb122db4bc592c2addcab99ac2a9d7d9ad216d9cbe06b574f76eb4f9dd90","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"qualification":"The primary M-theory-variable analysis identifies non-scaling operator families and additional weak-field requirements within its specified warped IIB ansatz.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z21"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z21","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f8428c1416c52408a6499c90aa7f762e0d06c094670a6ea92a41a2a7418ee117","q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02"],"scopeContentSha256":"ccd5e77a867e82ef7825199cd2d2c893840dc9ae3a8e87e1462a81ac1aa99d41","contributionContentSha256":"44557f8315499e94a21af0cfa30aaf714e690072765c3693e8c3941a412bd158","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation"},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","statistics-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u53","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f8428c1416c52408a6499c90aa7f762e0d06c094670a6ea92a41a2a7418ee117","paperId":"2005.11421","textSha256":"3b7d037ebb007470c78d923c52b4abad46f3084a98d28f765a397683985ab482"},{"localRef":"e33","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3bbfea0cbe8bc8f85d922bbc8eb5729f","paperId":"2005.11421","sourceSha256":"6ac21f5a212ec63ab34b58a320508c0e88034d8677a091fa859ca510b34c291c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc836cfa2b595d1baef6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d453eee52a8efc3d498a0c78849152ac503e556bc3a8f1eb5fea068495c4bfd7","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":1553,"textSha256":"c1eabb9b0f726f31608d12ea78f5be77a365b3ebaa453294c8aef5779706be65","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e35","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:946032f139fa9b7c3ac9233a9fd2c207","paperId":"2005.11421","sourceSha256":"6ac21f5a212ec63ab34b58a320508c0e88034d8677a091fa859ca510b34c291c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc836cfa2b595d1baef6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d453eee52a8efc3d498a0c78849152ac503e556bc3a8f1eb5fea068495c4bfd7","pdfPage":13,"start":0,"end":2292,"textSha256":"787f919af0d59a891f34a7a62d665dd794015c8039443c11f5e74e91cb296d17","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e36","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bbb4ead84fbceae7f3ba201c4c55fcec","paperId":"2005.11421","sourceSha256":"6ac21f5a212ec63ab34b58a320508c0e88034d8677a091fa859ca510b34c291c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc836cfa2b595d1baef6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d453eee52a8efc3d498a0c78849152ac503e556bc3a8f1eb5fea068495c4bfd7","pdfPage":7,"start":0,"end":2780,"textSha256":"8861eb122db4bc592c2addcab99ac2a9d7d9ad216d9cbe06b574f76eb4f9dd90","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"explicitConfirmation":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z21","family":"statistics","originalRowId":"z21","oldRole":{"id":"z21","unitRef":"u53","questionRef":"pq0","role":"specializes","reason":"The primary M-theory-variable analysis identifies non-scaling operator families and additional weak-field requirements within its specified warped IIB ansatz.","refs":["u53","e33","e35","e36"]},"confirmation":{"id":"z21","verdict":"supported_as_written","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":[],"reason":"The non-scaling operator families and additional weak-field conditions directly specialize finite validity within the specified warped IIB ansatz.","refs":["u53","pq0","e33","e35","e36"]},"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation","qualificationUnchanged":true}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"f7e794ec9ec3e66c82c9f29e05532825b1d5bde1ab3e1a78fd0ae43ef41b258d"},"organizational-access:6d8c9ba3990209b225be4cdc":{"id":"organizational-access:6d8c9ba3990209b225be4cdc","source":"q025-candidate-question:20b741d8aefd7b97af399a0e","target":"q025-candidate-question:04c1e8f4567a4d5eb134a77e","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:20b741d8aefd7b97af399a0e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"2d4a598788c789f940f9603a925ec36f6c52f9fb9d92738196ae48d188d668d8","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3c9ba049d2e35e9d87fe9d04"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:04c1e8f4567a4d5eb134a77e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"d71ad1d41d36c3180f3d4bbaa6062c78a0e2843b7b1fbf623f9c9b6891081a36","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2ec63cb2c08a1af47f12def6"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","home":{"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:20b741d8aefd7b97af399a0e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers regulated AdS/CFT information density and comparison of boundary entropy with boundary area through bulk-IR/boundary-UV regulation.","qualification":"q5 expressly covers finite information density, regulated entropy/area comparison and bulk-IR/boundary-UV regulation. q0 also supplies a complete foundational counting alternative, while q10 and q17 supply broader dictionary contexts. q5 is a focused choice because it names the compared quantities and regulator regime. Information capacity is not replaced with a particular subregion's entropy or operational reconstruction.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","textSha256":"f778529a916d97c311f42305661e888bca67f8f9e502e409f80cc3cd8f94d177"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0016:u19:q5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0016:u19:q5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","q025-candidate-question:20b741d8aefd7b97af399a0e"],"scopeContentSha256":"2d4a598788c789f940f9603a925ec36f6c52f9fb9d92738196ae48d188d668d8","placementContentSha256":"6bf7f662242c03163b66a0596de4ec5f9d7cf3fe18d9d46ffda363f3db6f16be","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0016:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0016:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","textSha256":"f778529a916d97c311f42305661e888bca67f8f9e502e409f80cc3cd8f94d177"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0016","unitRef":"u19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:04c1e8f4567a4d5eb134a77e","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","textSha256":"f778529a916d97c311f42305661e888bca67f8f9e502e409f80cc3cd8f94d177"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8a364bd089ae3f1fdd73dad149e30eaf","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","sourceSha256":"5185a9cd80d1f1d92b3b74832c0d3c3b7a8678dcef19d14912f41c4bc2051b3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6117198e7743034ee921/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e116a91f23e0758514e5c79078a3ff51beb54da84e09dcf8bd850bdeb3a0b7aa","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1083,"textSha256":"a68ee0222566040e6f1d3819e543b44a4ac00abe61bbb32fd8ce4ce4c7e7af5c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cb0d76e453019315ec1dcb33e694f229","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","sourceSha256":"5185a9cd80d1f1d92b3b74832c0d3c3b7a8678dcef19d14912f41c4bc2051b3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6117198e7743034ee921/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e116a91f23e0758514e5c79078a3ff51beb54da84e09dcf8bd850bdeb3a0b7aa","pdfPage":2,"start":96,"end":2566,"textSha256":"c0803c62f1b2eaa132532b62f62dabc6f141cbfcc815895e5248d1f50673137b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:422d8d7bf2c69a58405e7e62","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The target is regulated information counting, beyond the existence of a bulk–boundary correspondence. Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:422d8d7bf2c69a58405e7e62","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","q025-candidate-question:04c1e8f4567a4d5eb134a77e"],"scopeContentSha256":"d71ad1d41d36c3180f3d4bbaa6062c78a0e2843b7b1fbf623f9c9b6891081a36","contributionContentSha256":"045177437d1fcf3dd908cadc6dd3f3066010744493f708b9fff8150b9ac6edc0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal","leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","textSha256":"f778529a916d97c311f42305661e888bca67f8f9e502e409f80cc3cd8f94d177"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8a364bd089ae3f1fdd73dad149e30eaf","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","sourceSha256":"5185a9cd80d1f1d92b3b74832c0d3c3b7a8678dcef19d14912f41c4bc2051b3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6117198e7743034ee921/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e116a91f23e0758514e5c79078a3ff51beb54da84e09dcf8bd850bdeb3a0b7aa","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1083,"textSha256":"a68ee0222566040e6f1d3819e543b44a4ac00abe61bbb32fd8ce4ce4c7e7af5c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cb0d76e453019315ec1dcb33e694f229","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","sourceSha256":"5185a9cd80d1f1d92b3b74832c0d3c3b7a8678dcef19d14912f41c4bc2051b3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6117198e7743034ee921/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e116a91f23e0758514e5c79078a3ff51beb54da84e09dcf8bd850bdeb3a0b7aa","pdfPage":2,"start":96,"end":2566,"textSha256":"c0803c62f1b2eaa132532b62f62dabc6f141cbfcc815895e5248d1f50673137b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:422d8d7bf2c69a58405e7e62","recordId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The target is regulated information counting, beyond the existence of a bulk–boundary correspondence.","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"40efd5f65aa2a9c72a833ac061279bc1264e143e18e77c47fd500770dfab6cb2"},"organizational-access:7330b004fbec72878c06f8e8":{"id":"organizational-access:7330b004fbec72878c06f8e8","source":"q025-candidate-question:265bd371fe1997a8c8287c76","target":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:265bd371fe1997a8c8287c76","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"523159e08cba403accc3f0d480776f86e407ee15237df0429b4f505115fa0dce","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1af070a7cfb619e22a697e27"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:49ec66a8c6b5e4747536c1d3"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:bf7a3f7051d78debe2078ca945a826df58e3421a064511b9ce8db859c8cda024","home":{"unitId":"unit:bf7a3f7051d78debe2078ca945a826df58e3421a064511b9ce8db859c8cda024","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:265bd371fe1997a8c8287c76","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers observable applications of excited inflationary states, spectra, non-Gaussianity and backreaction.","qualification":"q1 explicitly covers observable applications of excited states, state-dependent spectra and non-Gaussianity, and backreaction. It covers the complete high-scale tensor-suppression test with its quadratic-potential emphasis and historical observational conditions. q3 is also complete, but a second allocation adds no needed coverage.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bf7a3f7051d78debe2078ca945a826df58e3421a064511b9ce8db859c8cda024","paperId":"1306.4914","textSha256":"d070a11b591bca008deb70c75fd202fe208b4d628946cffbf640a253d7755d80"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0001:u29:q1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0001:u29:q1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bf7a3f7051d78debe2078ca945a826df58e3421a064511b9ce8db859c8cda024","q025-candidate-question:265bd371fe1997a8c8287c76"],"scopeContentSha256":"523159e08cba403accc3f0d480776f86e407ee15237df0429b4f505115fa0dce","placementContentSha256":"b0aec7878174086327d71bac12e34bd3db0ef7c25f4322cf99e70a8ce4691431","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0001:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0001:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bf7a3f7051d78debe2078ca945a826df58e3421a064511b9ce8db859c8cda024","paperId":"1306.4914","textSha256":"d070a11b591bca008deb70c75fd202fe208b4d628946cffbf640a253d7755d80"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0001","unitRef":"u29"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bf7a3f7051d78debe2078ca945a826df58e3421a064511b9ce8db859c8cda024","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:bf7a3f7051d78debe2078ca945a826df58e3421a064511b9ce8db859c8cda024","textSha256":"d070a11b591bca008deb70c75fd202fe208b4d628946cffbf640a253d7755d80"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e6f1fc1b539e34b0f98b743c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e6f1fc1b539e34b0f98b743c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bf7a3f7051d78debe2078ca945a826df58e3421a064511b9ce8db859c8cda024","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"cfba9435c6e6757e21cce7e1a1471d8bd1f0643020fb0a35b71b11f9c4b8e630","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:bf7a3f7051d78debe2078ca945a826df58e3421a064511b9ce8db859c8cda024","textSha256":"d070a11b591bca008deb70c75fd202fe208b4d628946cffbf640a253d7755d80"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e6f1fc1b539e34b0f98b743c","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Excitations are investigated for tensor suppression in high-scale inflation.","challengeNote":"Tensor suppression is the target, subject to backreaction, tilt and non-Gaussianity constraints.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"219bb5d9a8108006ac33e1140cd2a2d96b0386da8f392c95275e472fe62b0f12"},"organizational-access:86cea636aa9ac51c9f247fe0":{"id":"organizational-access:86cea636aa9ac51c9f247fe0","source":"q025-candidate-question:26ddfdb6006ae7d5377e404a","target":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:26ddfdb6006ae7d5377e404a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"70d426c54e83d32d29834101b6fb3c317a2d537d6814568216e93b0f197e4212","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:49b7e740225b3278cdfedcf8"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"392640e6a9b8a01652bc7d6dafda7769a164fa44c0efde3644a103be5f08f62a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f5ac60178a0af46ce2ffecde"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","home":{"unitId":"unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:26ddfdb6006ae7d5377e404a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers non-Abelian self-interaction models, velocity dependence, halo constraints and relic consistency.","qualification":"q2 covers the specified non-Abelian interaction mechanism, its velocity dependence, galaxy-to-cluster constraints and relic consistency. Natural generation of the splitting is part of constructing that mechanism; no successful naturalness argument, fit or abundance calculation is presumed.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","paperId":"2208.07882","textSha256":"fbdf763cc8ebbd715482930e72b5d26ba8ec782812c5032414b8fd0e0f8a23b2"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0054:u11:q2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0054:u11:q2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","q025-candidate-question:26ddfdb6006ae7d5377e404a"],"scopeContentSha256":"70d426c54e83d32d29834101b6fb3c317a2d537d6814568216e93b0f197e4212","placementContentSha256":"a3e036732fa1b7769a1adad67c6644ffe373f250d09831e62346f7b92c52fd79","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0054:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0054:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","paperId":"2208.07882","textSha256":"fbdf763cc8ebbd715482930e72b5d26ba8ec782812c5032414b8fd0e0f8a23b2"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0054","unitRef":"u11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","textSha256":"fbdf763cc8ebbd715482930e72b5d26ba8ec782812c5032414b8fd0e0f8a23b2"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fe757aa628cef1272248d234","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Natural resonance splitting, halo fit and abundance are linked model requirements. Independent challenge qualification: Natural resonance splitting, source-adopted halo constraints and relic abundance are linked model requirements."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:fe757aa628cef1272248d234","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"],"scopeContentSha256":"392640e6a9b8a01652bc7d6dafda7769a164fa44c0efde3644a103be5f08f62a","contributionContentSha256":"9590ad98caca76b49e0daa6a05079d4b76bb461e263feeec274fbf896bebd067","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-proposal","leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","textSha256":"fbdf763cc8ebbd715482930e72b5d26ba8ec782812c5032414b8fd0e0f8a23b2"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fe757aa628cef1272248d234","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Natural resonance splitting, halo fit and abundance are linked model requirements.","challengeNote":"Natural resonance splitting, source-adopted halo constraints and relic abundance are linked model requirements.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"0c595b01bc1ac782ee41e2ec975abdde169371ede20ca821542d2f0a9161e531"},"organizational-access:892f995641da9cb199caac70":{"id":"organizational-access:892f995641da9cb199caac70","source":"q025-candidate-question:2c78e415731e9932afb29e16","target":"q025-candidate-question:0ce75b71f62a993a0919398b","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:2c78e415731e9932afb29e16","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ee74a12225f6de5b9168f30dccaa16e70ce86fe6bf4008764e2f344828adf1cb","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e9beea9df2fadd202ad9d3f7"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:0ce75b71f62a993a0919398b","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"90606e895059cfb6cf702a94847d6be7af9c98988b5a6ebd3753d88a8abe8d0e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:606466f79ba820267a30c8e2"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","home":{"unitId":"unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2c78e415731e9932afb29e16","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines physical wormhole contribution, local EFT, censorship, baby-universe states and coupling interpretation in the large low-energy review setting.","qualification":"q2 explicitly covers physical inclusion and local-EFT interpretation together with censorship, baby states and couplings in the large, low-curvature setting. Classical construction does not resolve any of those quantum questions. Damaged historical tails are unnecessary for establishing this coverage.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","paperId":"1807.00824","textSha256":"c780a3a6f1fa4141c5da87f8ae2c7318592b83de76b79cb1b3e901c3b913b2a8"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0028:u15:q2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0028:u15:q2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","q025-candidate-question:2c78e415731e9932afb29e16"],"scopeContentSha256":"ee74a12225f6de5b9168f30dccaa16e70ce86fe6bf4008764e2f344828adf1cb","placementContentSha256":"07fa8e4cfbec7629235f04f88005905cc8f16962c8ca75875f954d72c150d70f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0028:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0028:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","paperId":"1807.00824","textSha256":"c780a3a6f1fa4141c5da87f8ae2c7318592b83de76b79cb1b3e901c3b913b2a8"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0028","unitRef":"u15"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0ce75b71f62a993a0919398b","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","textSha256":"c780a3a6f1fa4141c5da87f8ae2c7318592b83de76b79cb1b3e901c3b913b2a8"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:29508b3d982f7672f176717bd88c3b26","paperId":"1807.00824","sourceSha256":"a1c057e60645b107f64cc976957337d5a39dabe4db8050312919517982426ea8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/deb9771b0d647bb999bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7e1896a9443eaede558472608bfcc58a4cb1f35bf89a13694c0b79839f51dc6e","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"6052fe77a2a0e2cf197253d03af12a99db5af34f1e5dc3ab2f8fdcf5b4ecb66e","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:126a65874ce927454102530a37e2af95","paperId":"1807.00824","sourceSha256":"a1c057e60645b107f64cc976957337d5a39dabe4db8050312919517982426ea8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/deb9771b0d647bb999bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7e1896a9443eaede558472608bfcc58a4cb1f35bf89a13694c0b79839f51dc6e","pdfPage":9,"start":925,"end":2916,"textSha256":"32f1cb38b75c821b1d8675ad9e93460abbbfe370fbfd76603ba85cc316e304e6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:62c0229fd7c8318f5a0666b8109ae576","paperId":"1807.00824","sourceSha256":"a1c057e60645b107f64cc976957337d5a39dabe4db8050312919517982426ea8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/deb9771b0d647bb999bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7e1896a9443eaede558472608bfcc58a4cb1f35bf89a13694c0b79839f51dc6e","pdfPage":3,"start":1040,"end":3133,"textSha256":"49dc40871e3dc72bbc3a921f7b7c096f3914ac8137a8fb5cd877c45f90f27f18","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8358a2d229d1f59fa4a793d2","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Physical contribution and effective-theory interpretation are compound open targets. The classical throat is supporting construction evidence, not a resolution of quantum admissibility. Independent challenge qualification: Physical contribution and EFT interpretation remain compound open targets. The classical throat construction supplies no decision on quantum inclusion."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8358a2d229d1f59fa4a793d2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","q025-candidate-question:0ce75b71f62a993a0919398b"],"scopeContentSha256":"90606e895059cfb6cf702a94847d6be7af9c98988b5a6ebd3753d88a8abe8d0e","contributionContentSha256":"dab158efbe38fa2244251c761a27478ae1913ce8b9c596f790eba3266868e032","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"successor2-parent-c8776465ed44d9e65c4c-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor2-parent-c8776465ed44d9e65c4c-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["successor2-parent-c8776465ed44d9e65c4c-proposal","successor2-parent-c8776465ed44d9e65c4c-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","textSha256":"c780a3a6f1fa4141c5da87f8ae2c7318592b83de76b79cb1b3e901c3b913b2a8"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:29508b3d982f7672f176717bd88c3b26","paperId":"1807.00824","sourceSha256":"a1c057e60645b107f64cc976957337d5a39dabe4db8050312919517982426ea8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/deb9771b0d647bb999bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7e1896a9443eaede558472608bfcc58a4cb1f35bf89a13694c0b79839f51dc6e","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"6052fe77a2a0e2cf197253d03af12a99db5af34f1e5dc3ab2f8fdcf5b4ecb66e","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:126a65874ce927454102530a37e2af95","paperId":"1807.00824","sourceSha256":"a1c057e60645b107f64cc976957337d5a39dabe4db8050312919517982426ea8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/deb9771b0d647bb999bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7e1896a9443eaede558472608bfcc58a4cb1f35bf89a13694c0b79839f51dc6e","pdfPage":9,"start":925,"end":2916,"textSha256":"32f1cb38b75c821b1d8675ad9e93460abbbfe370fbfd76603ba85cc316e304e6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:62c0229fd7c8318f5a0666b8109ae576","paperId":"1807.00824","sourceSha256":"a1c057e60645b107f64cc976957337d5a39dabe4db8050312919517982426ea8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/deb9771b0d647bb999bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7e1896a9443eaede558472608bfcc58a4cb1f35bf89a13694c0b79839f51dc6e","pdfPage":3,"start":1040,"end":3133,"textSha256":"49dc40871e3dc72bbc3a921f7b7c096f3914ac8137a8fb5cd877c45f90f27f18","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8358a2d229d1f59fa4a793d2","recordId":"successor2-parent-c8776465ed44d9e65c4c-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"successor2-parent-c8776465ed44d9e65c4c-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor2-parent-c8776465ed44d9e65c4c-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Physical contribution and effective-theory interpretation are compound open targets. The classical throat is supporting construction evidence, not a resolution of quantum admissibility.","challengeNote":"Physical contribution and EFT interpretation remain compound open targets. The classical throat construction supplies no decision on quantum inclusion.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v5/scope-role-admission-v5.json","sha256":"b6da4e2ef0727fa782fbbc4c0acb4ee546e2c0ed072e0e7a295b9f04a618f0e3"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"69545a3493c1e5b97b8e9626b7507312504f430516cdfc9b67aae003289d67b2"},"organizational-access:825558feb78c92ddccd7984f":{"id":"organizational-access:825558feb78c92ddccd7984f","source":"q025-candidate-question:3193b8d7483071b6c5ef1193","target":"q025-candidate-question:e6eb59815789213bde444e45","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3193b8d7483071b6c5ef1193","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"89c02b0cc34ff35889c116f2e853ff77cad1aa8d9e7608f5c10a872875b2fb36","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c1d676f77f366f4076bbb9bc"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e6eb59815789213bde444e45","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"4ab6dabbc60efca3941249f28fec30298404104195fb43e947439187333e8746","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c90ec54a94899d72aa306f15"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:20d8a793b545cc5ba0ed741ce878ed9ea729b1bd3521f438ee5b9dae460ae2bc","home":{"unitId":"unit:20d8a793b545cc5ba0ed741ce878ed9ea729b1bd3521f438ee5b9dae460ae2bc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3193b8d7483071b6c5ef1193","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q7 expressly includes geometrically controlled half-space four-scalar scattering, local coefficients and consistent treatment of the complete ultraviolet spectral integral.","qualification":"q7 covers the local four-scalar bounds and simultaneous geometric control of low-energy exchange and the full UV absorptive spectrum. Channel positivity remains conditional; finite subtractions and reported kernel tests do not establish universal positivity.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:20d8a793b545cc5ba0ed741ce878ed9ea729b1bd3521f438ee5b9dae460ae2bc","paperId":"2610.19149","textSha256":"31e2948b5d26b779e5da4bc02bbd9ea5bcf4f4e951fef2697af22a735e4e6d91"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0026:u13:q7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0026:u13:q7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:20d8a793b545cc5ba0ed741ce878ed9ea729b1bd3521f438ee5b9dae460ae2bc","q025-candidate-question:3193b8d7483071b6c5ef1193"],"scopeContentSha256":"89c02b0cc34ff35889c116f2e853ff77cad1aa8d9e7608f5c10a872875b2fb36","placementContentSha256":"73cc74e5fbdcec4e02f34a8de82908261893493b4ba149cb09b7ea1e431df5df","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0026:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0026:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:20d8a793b545cc5ba0ed741ce878ed9ea729b1bd3521f438ee5b9dae460ae2bc","paperId":"2610.19149","textSha256":"31e2948b5d26b779e5da4bc02bbd9ea5bcf4f4e951fef2697af22a735e4e6d91"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0026","unitRef":"u13"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:20d8a793b545cc5ba0ed741ce878ed9ea729b1bd3521f438ee5b9dae460ae2bc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e6eb59815789213bde444e45","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d62","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:20d8a793b545cc5ba0ed741ce878ed9ea729b1bd3521f438ee5b9dae460ae2bc","textSha256":"31e2948b5d26b779e5da4bc02bbd9ea5bcf4f4e951fef2697af22a735e4e6d91"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:49c2c1fa971e09215b75b31e7f550bb8","paperId":"2610.19149","sourceSha256":"77e205359370b1fc484fbc1b34bad9b65d70c68574fa254388e23e6eab997e21","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a30884bffc46b11b019d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7186446846afb4eb7eb90f6248878e6cff5bf20cabd1a0de72de400e2dfc53d7","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1930,"textSha256":"472cc28173734b9ebd7c060f5733776546784f0cf24ad23e11bcd761d50ea296","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:614dbc52ef120918e702a5441ce3ace4","paperId":"2610.19149","sourceSha256":"77e205359370b1fc484fbc1b34bad9b65d70c68574fa254388e23e6eab997e21","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a30884bffc46b11b019d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7186446846afb4eb7eb90f6248878e6cff5bf20cabd1a0de72de400e2dfc53d7","pdfPage":90,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b7500df03a1ee658114d4bfc7b0121aa1bcb8af47c0b2ab74135ed9c8680f1e9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f4b2f639458ecfad29004437b3f69ca5","paperId":"2610.19149","sourceSha256":"77e205359370b1fc484fbc1b34bad9b65d70c68574fa254388e23e6eab997e21","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a30884bffc46b11b019d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7186446846afb4eb7eb90f6248878e6cff5bf20cabd1a0de72de400e2dfc53d7","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"d0a7c831e8dae84ba03dd9b20e711773bef6791f73f4d49ad2ac468f14664f9e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:07c128eeedc65214f8f06a2b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:07c128eeedc65214f8f06a2b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:20d8a793b545cc5ba0ed741ce878ed9ea729b1bd3521f438ee5b9dae460ae2bc","q025-candidate-question:e6eb59815789213bde444e45"],"scopeContentSha256":"4ab6dabbc60efca3941249f28fec30298404104195fb43e947439187333e8746","contributionContentSha256":"d3885c3fc3cf396a15c73b53f79b8c09c89a294b35d6bfe05885a1835d128f3e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d62","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:20d8a793b545cc5ba0ed741ce878ed9ea729b1bd3521f438ee5b9dae460ae2bc","textSha256":"31e2948b5d26b779e5da4bc02bbd9ea5bcf4f4e951fef2697af22a735e4e6d91"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:49c2c1fa971e09215b75b31e7f550bb8","paperId":"2610.19149","sourceSha256":"77e205359370b1fc484fbc1b34bad9b65d70c68574fa254388e23e6eab997e21","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a30884bffc46b11b019d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7186446846afb4eb7eb90f6248878e6cff5bf20cabd1a0de72de400e2dfc53d7","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1930,"textSha256":"472cc28173734b9ebd7c060f5733776546784f0cf24ad23e11bcd761d50ea296","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:614dbc52ef120918e702a5441ce3ace4","paperId":"2610.19149","sourceSha256":"77e205359370b1fc484fbc1b34bad9b65d70c68574fa254388e23e6eab997e21","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a30884bffc46b11b019d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7186446846afb4eb7eb90f6248878e6cff5bf20cabd1a0de72de400e2dfc53d7","pdfPage":90,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b7500df03a1ee658114d4bfc7b0121aa1bcb8af47c0b2ab74135ed9c8680f1e9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f4b2f639458ecfad29004437b3f69ca5","paperId":"2610.19149","sourceSha256":"77e205359370b1fc484fbc1b34bad9b65d70c68574fa254388e23e6eab997e21","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a30884bffc46b11b019d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7186446846afb4eb7eb90f6248878e6cff5bf20cabd1a0de72de400e2dfc53d7","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"d0a7c831e8dae84ba03dd9b20e711773bef6791f73f4d49ad2ac468f14664f9e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:07c128eeedc65214f8f06a2b","recordId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"The announced bound uses the full absorptive spectrum without weak coupling or a spectral ansatz, conditional on channel positivity in the chosen geometry.","challengeNote":"The October 2026 target includes the full UV absorptive spectrum in the same geometry, without weak coupling or a spectral ansatz, conditional on channel—not un","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"031ba2b82257496c27a03b7597b612bd7c535bec12a900b0d6ad7b34232c817f"},"organizational-access:58bf91643fa5673c2738bd29":{"id":"organizational-access:58bf91643fa5673c2738bd29","source":"q025-candidate-question:330ca25df7e503348d9ecfde","target":"q025-candidate-question:928893436954f1b83e2c5d87","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:330ca25df7e503348d9ecfde","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e95dddd5d75c2d09c350bb4bedd127890cbb782d7b8135fb6cad337e0ba6b6f2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5cc05e2eaafe08ede7e39334"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:928893436954f1b83e2c5d87","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"efe9bee4fd5e3f5fcf74a0e5e28e4050e25220374d9f8b44af124ff3363767b5","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:4c1174f5f92e05d98d9d62e7"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:60370fcb3d49ac4ba6192026d9cd5aed47efb304b183af2ecd360903d88d7f57","home":{"unitId":"unit:60370fcb3d49ac4ba6192026d9cd5aed47efb304b183af2ecd360903d88d7f57","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:330ca25df7e503348d9ecfde","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Directly asks about matching holographic observables with consistent branches, dictionaries and counterterm schemes.","qualification":"q6 directly contains matched deformed theories and requires compatible branches, dictionaries and counterterms. This covers the entire comparison without presuming that differently defined sphere theories should agree. q28 is a less direct application connection.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:60370fcb3d49ac4ba6192026d9cd5aed47efb304b183af2ecd360903d88d7f57","paperId":"2012.10109","textSha256":"34c78bd2ef89f7de1773ef7d8a05bd0f2879b7e7c4165b2c3c706b10a88fd866"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0074:u12:q6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0074:u12:q6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:60370fcb3d49ac4ba6192026d9cd5aed47efb304b183af2ecd360903d88d7f57","q025-candidate-question:330ca25df7e503348d9ecfde"],"scopeContentSha256":"e95dddd5d75c2d09c350bb4bedd127890cbb782d7b8135fb6cad337e0ba6b6f2","placementContentSha256":"94524746773cc9b891d0584e98c4f8d97f74c395a04b4f49734a1bf07a4604dd","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0074:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0074:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-05"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:60370fcb3d49ac4ba6192026d9cd5aed47efb304b183af2ecd360903d88d7f57","paperId":"2012.10109","textSha256":"34c78bd2ef89f7de1773ef7d8a05bd0f2879b7e7c4165b2c3c706b10a88fd866"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-05/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"6079f3dff4de3bce86aff04cfa91b1a0da7ebf86722c5c33e44b4f563ac45e8e"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-05/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"b73dfbc8974cebd1c5c02da428f1652a9b6f36d6a1073a93ae692399858c7d3e","bytes":1594204,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0074","unitRef":"u12"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:60370fcb3d49ac4ba6192026d9cd5aed47efb304b183af2ecd360903d88d7f57","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:928893436954f1b83e2c5d87","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:60370fcb3d49ac4ba6192026d9cd5aed47efb304b183af2ecd360903d88d7f57","textSha256":"34c78bd2ef89f7de1773ef7d8a05bd0f2879b7e7c4165b2c3c706b10a88fd866"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:02fb8dc14770e1ee907065f8","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: Overlap → member: matching holographic observables is explicitly within r; narrower consistency-test membership is unnecessary."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:02fb8dc14770e1ee907065f8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:60370fcb3d49ac4ba6192026d9cd5aed47efb304b183af2ecd360903d88d7f57","q025-candidate-question:928893436954f1b83e2c5d87"],"scopeContentSha256":"efe9bee4fd5e3f5fcf74a0e5e28e4050e25220374d9f8b44af124ff3363767b5","contributionContentSha256":"2d6de5928faf7e3c1371c1f26bcd1b604c1d4bf5edbf13ce6cd5fc71d127a444","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:60370fcb3d49ac4ba6192026d9cd5aed47efb304b183af2ecd360903d88d7f57","textSha256":"34c78bd2ef89f7de1773ef7d8a05bd0f2879b7e7c4165b2c3c706b10a88fd866"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:02fb8dc14770e1ee907065f8","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"Overlap → member: matching holographic observables is explicitly within r; narrower consistency-test membership is unnecessary.","dispositionAgreement":false,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"905f104dfff69d8e97193fc5a0b08c55d5ff23a9b1fe662af363054365eac5e4"},"organizational-access:90734912aa48affeb2337b2f":{"id":"organizational-access:90734912aa48affeb2337b2f","source":"q025-candidate-question:3539cc694caf45fad3b64923","target":"q025-candidate-question:fc373e647b030a128d5c0a8b","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3539cc694caf45fad3b64923","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a28b3bf11d870dfa2bd0b8aeac7a36831c9af02a1e60dd001a55aaf85f9db0a9","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f81e6f15f7c75b57116fdf2f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:fc373e647b030a128d5c0a8b","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9756ca43fd276e6e24d3b8c83d0f8e0939c2f93917c3fc2975694c119d3a2034","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:884c3471c9629aecd1583151"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:53ef23d678d4af44753c17fe5076b83e5f2820b2159b34463c058755ec556dbc","home":{"unitId":"unit:53ef23d678d4af44753c17fe5076b83e5f2820b2159b34463c058755ec556dbc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3539cc694caf45fad3b64923","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly includes gravitationally sourced ALP masses, relic-population viability and alternative metric/Palatini formulations.","qualification":"q5 jointly covers the specified gravitational mass source and relic viability under model-dependent cosmology. Nonminimal gravity, inflation, reheating and symmetry-breaking history remain parameter-determining conditions, with the inherited alternative cases kept distinct.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:53ef23d678d4af44753c17fe5076b83e5f2820b2159b34463c058755ec556dbc","paperId":"2411.07713","textSha256":"b6cbbcf31979e3c18cc029e7c8139525ea28c278d5ba404ea763ea0e6fc9bfac"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0038:u29:q5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0038:u29:q5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:53ef23d678d4af44753c17fe5076b83e5f2820b2159b34463c058755ec556dbc","q025-candidate-question:3539cc694caf45fad3b64923"],"scopeContentSha256":"a28b3bf11d870dfa2bd0b8aeac7a36831c9af02a1e60dd001a55aaf85f9db0a9","placementContentSha256":"4ddf522396214809e6dcc06d86d684a3f855ceda81877d1240dc182105413cbb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0038:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0038:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:53ef23d678d4af44753c17fe5076b83e5f2820b2159b34463c058755ec556dbc","paperId":"2411.07713","textSha256":"b6cbbcf31979e3c18cc029e7c8139525ea28c278d5ba404ea763ea0e6fc9bfac"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0038","unitRef":"u29"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:53ef23d678d4af44753c17fe5076b83e5f2820b2159b34463c058755ec556dbc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:fc373e647b030a128d5c0a8b","role":"instantiates","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:53ef23d678d4af44753c17fe5076b83e5f2820b2159b34463c058755ec556dbc","textSha256":"b6cbbcf31979e3c18cc029e7c8139525ea28c278d5ba404ea763ea0e6fc9bfac"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9b7cfc2d28174ea18821d94c2be0cc73","paperId":"2411.07713","sourceSha256":"db76f294564160d81bfa7ac744186c0fc04393931657e200f338fb9fc1ba6417","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/09e155aa3a677107ce69/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2536bdc7453eeef90d094a7dcfb60d15cb1bc0a05f79d4e84e0f29dfa0e00bec","pdfPage":3,"start":101,"end":2878,"textSha256":"6afdb1d4505e4fe1cd90c17c13898fcf0193b850ffdb60af511bd3e84024ec88","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dd8a7bae0d0d63f3623115ec53e5808d","paperId":"2411.07713","sourceSha256":"db76f294564160d81bfa7ac744186c0fc04393931657e200f338fb9fc1ba6417","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/09e155aa3a677107ce69/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2536bdc7453eeef90d094a7dcfb60d15cb1bc0a05f79d4e84e0f29dfa0e00bec","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2088,"textSha256":"fec99205d8c3ec3f821c0be2729fa482b19e1f918065b1740b382e51796dab04","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eae582ecbe52c62b74b3c620541026a8","paperId":"2411.07713","sourceSha256":"db76f294564160d81bfa7ac744186c0fc04393931657e200f338fb9fc1ba6417","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/09e155aa3a677107ce69/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2536bdc7453eeef90d094a7dcfb60d15cb1bc0a05f79d4e84e0f29dfa0e00bec","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":2088,"textSha256":"1294e610168b9967bf0a321928e7ff79a7995951c14d323b7ad29b8ba9f72568","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:761c4b250c90ac4a3011723f","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Metric/Palatini and general/radial-inflaton cases are alternatives. Post-inflationary production includes string decay as well as misalignment. Independent challenge qualification: The November 2024 proposal distinguishes metric/Palatini and general/radial-inflaton cases. Post-inflationary production includes strings; minimal-coupling non-"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:761c4b250c90ac4a3011723f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:53ef23d678d4af44753c17fe5076b83e5f2820b2159b34463c058755ec556dbc","q025-candidate-question:fc373e647b030a128d5c0a8b"],"scopeContentSha256":"9756ca43fd276e6e24d3b8c83d0f8e0939c2f93917c3fc2975694c119d3a2034","contributionContentSha256":"730076e097b6af22b342473805448283480cd60c0f96efb2db35b9cfa5171d12","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-proposal","leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:53ef23d678d4af44753c17fe5076b83e5f2820b2159b34463c058755ec556dbc","textSha256":"b6cbbcf31979e3c18cc029e7c8139525ea28c278d5ba404ea763ea0e6fc9bfac"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9b7cfc2d28174ea18821d94c2be0cc73","paperId":"2411.07713","sourceSha256":"db76f294564160d81bfa7ac744186c0fc04393931657e200f338fb9fc1ba6417","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/09e155aa3a677107ce69/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2536bdc7453eeef90d094a7dcfb60d15cb1bc0a05f79d4e84e0f29dfa0e00bec","pdfPage":3,"start":101,"end":2878,"textSha256":"6afdb1d4505e4fe1cd90c17c13898fcf0193b850ffdb60af511bd3e84024ec88","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dd8a7bae0d0d63f3623115ec53e5808d","paperId":"2411.07713","sourceSha256":"db76f294564160d81bfa7ac744186c0fc04393931657e200f338fb9fc1ba6417","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/09e155aa3a677107ce69/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2536bdc7453eeef90d094a7dcfb60d15cb1bc0a05f79d4e84e0f29dfa0e00bec","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2088,"textSha256":"fec99205d8c3ec3f821c0be2729fa482b19e1f918065b1740b382e51796dab04","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eae582ecbe52c62b74b3c620541026a8","paperId":"2411.07713","sourceSha256":"db76f294564160d81bfa7ac744186c0fc04393931657e200f338fb9fc1ba6417","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/09e155aa3a677107ce69/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2536bdc7453eeef90d094a7dcfb60d15cb1bc0a05f79d4e84e0f29dfa0e00bec","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":2088,"textSha256":"1294e610168b9967bf0a321928e7ff79a7995951c14d323b7ad29b8ba9f72568","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:761c4b250c90ac4a3011723f","recordId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Metric/Palatini and general/radial-inflaton cases are alternatives. Post-inflationary production includes string decay as well as misalignment.","challengeNote":"The November 2024 proposal distinguishes metric/Palatini and general/radial-inflaton cases. Post-inflationary production includes strings; minimal-coupling non-","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"bfa738e5e98aec00fb18ffaf8cfb946c3d19c39900ba34fa437f3e14f75004f7"},"organizational-access:f04d98a5eec4f3377c6d7458":{"id":"organizational-access:f04d98a5eec4f3377c6d7458","source":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","target":"q025-candidate-question:64d5f9b67d11b1a4f7f8c113","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"392640e6a9b8a01652bc7d6dafda7769a164fa44c0efde3644a103be5f08f62a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f5ac60178a0af46ce2ffecde"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:64d5f9b67d11b1a4f7f8c113","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"67c57ecb7a274eab768c4da5fd628de0e65578a032754d731f44325a38d0ad89","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:808ac93dfcebbb5ee0fa6e3c"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","home":{"unitId":"unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers higher-spin candidates, nonthermal abundance and model-to-search connections.","qualification":"q4 covers higher-spin candidate construction, nonthermal abundance and linked search requirements. It therefore contains both inflationary gravitational production and directional recoil inference, with the massive bosonic spin-greater-than-two restriction intact.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","paperId":"2010.15125","textSha256":"188e5cf3bea17807b5f2b17cf53a9c95e418a3a6e54d5244ec403c714d56d242"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0054:u31:q4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0054:u31:q4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"],"scopeContentSha256":"392640e6a9b8a01652bc7d6dafda7769a164fa44c0efde3644a103be5f08f62a","placementContentSha256":"2eee5d3a1c57072aff0532f4ae1504422db9c06b2359aa2432a8c5cd88a63a16","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0054:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0054:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","paperId":"2010.15125","textSha256":"188e5cf3bea17807b5f2b17cf53a9c95e418a3a6e54d5244ec403c714d56d242"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0054","unitRef":"u31"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:64d5f9b67d11b1a4f7f8c113","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","textSha256":"188e5cf3bea17807b5f2b17cf53a9c95e418a3a6e54d5244ec403c714d56d242"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1f70505d7377e096d85c567f","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound source scope retains inflationary abundance and directional spin readout for bosons with spin greater than two. Independent challenge qualification: Compound source scope retains inflationary production and recoil-based spin inference for bosons with spin greater than two."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1f70505d7377e096d85c567f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","q025-candidate-question:64d5f9b67d11b1a4f7f8c113"],"scopeContentSha256":"67c57ecb7a274eab768c4da5fd628de0e65578a032754d731f44325a38d0ad89","contributionContentSha256":"e91e6aa73d08f53a0c04eada83f9ed6695f8730d0d3d41c93ebc6e21d465a658","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-proposal","leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","textSha256":"188e5cf3bea17807b5f2b17cf53a9c95e418a3a6e54d5244ec403c714d56d242"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1f70505d7377e096d85c567f","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound source scope retains inflationary abundance and directional spin readout for bosons with spin greater than two.","challengeNote":"Compound source scope retains inflationary production and recoil-based spin inference for bosons with spin greater than two.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"83eb762ce52d9f56d8f277e1e847c3ef019d418b932da59b847d2fcc0d8dab6f"},"organizational-access:c30dd3a7c6a6bbe9a4f84dea":{"id":"organizational-access:c30dd3a7c6a6bbe9a4f84dea","source":"q025-candidate-question:39eb0593cfea7c0982886b56","target":"q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:39eb0593cfea7c0982886b56","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"5b55ae9f665f43bead147892b94fe1109120c7a661d8e1eb9a6131948f54bc9d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:eda17098af68ac55578d7095"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"0090ea9d5afb7931a126341f2a1e9970079dcf78145b0e7a0788e1866f3fd496","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:41f48b1d477a13a8051c2461"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:14a2146d250ce913608b4defd62d04dfe2658cca550fd5594fcfdf58b473bcec","home":{"unitId":"unit:14a2146d250ce913608b4defd62d04dfe2658cca550fd5594fcfdf58b473bcec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:39eb0593cfea7c0982886b56","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q9 explicitly includes conifold alignment, supporting Kähler stabilization, effective-theory control and separately specified warping regimes.","qualification":"q9 covers conifold alignment and inflation together with supporting Kähler stabilization, field-range/EFT control, corrections and backreaction. Its definition explicitly separates included-warping and negligible-warping regimes. Higher periods and mass hierarchies remain conditions of this construction; q2 alone would omit the inflationary target.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:14a2146d250ce913608b4defd62d04dfe2658cca550fd5594fcfdf58b473bcec","textSha256":"95a189a65d55853e127ea0bbdac51a50e1f9ec6cb88e86f06373cee315504632"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:annotation:u9:q9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:annotation:u9:q9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:14a2146d250ce913608b4defd62d04dfe2658cca550fd5594fcfdf58b473bcec","q025-candidate-question:39eb0593cfea7c0982886b56"],"scopeContentSha256":"5b55ae9f665f43bead147892b94fe1109120c7a661d8e1eb9a6131948f54bc9d","placementContentSha256":"91c41862a69bdbb4373b7153254ae70008cb6b8804f082afedc5fe2728cd514d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:annotation:proposal","placement-pilot:annotation:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:14a2146d250ce913608b4defd62d04dfe2658cca550fd5594fcfdf58b473bcec","textSha256":"95a189a65d55853e127ea0bbdac51a50e1f9ec6cb88e86f06373cee315504632"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:14a2146d250ce913608b4defd62d04dfe2658cca550fd5594fcfdf58b473bcec"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:14a2146d250ce913608b4defd62d04dfe2658cca550fd5594fcfdf58b473bcec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:14a2146d250ce913608b4defd62d04dfe2658cca550fd5594fcfdf58b473bcec","textSha256":"95a189a65d55853e127ea0bbdac51a50e1f9ec6cb88e86f06373cee315504632"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ea7b54f96600fa257fbda2a9"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ea7b54f96600fa257fbda2a9","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:14a2146d250ce913608b4defd62d04dfe2658cca550fd5594fcfdf58b473bcec","q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643"],"scopeContentSha256":"0090ea9d5afb7931a126341f2a1e9970079dcf78145b0e7a0788e1866f3fd496","contributionContentSha256":"35908c00d0c17efe1d3eec794090b9f8b2b7f09d47d91f5ab6de3e63428e2ede","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-proposal","leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:14a2146d250ce913608b4defd62d04dfe2658cca550fd5594fcfdf58b473bcec","textSha256":"95a189a65d55853e127ea0bbdac51a50e1f9ec6cb88e86f06373cee315504632"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ea7b54f96600fa257fbda2a9","recordId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Includes warping, higher period corrections and mass hierarchies; those premises prevent automatic merging with the negligible-warping question.","challengeNote":"Compound control and alignment question includes warping, higher period corrections and mass hierarchies; equivalence with the negligible-warping question is un","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b2e63c6fb71ac27aa7c23301ae32df91861d94d39a9099906c923875d1048d53","home":{"unitId":"unit:b2e63c6fb71ac27aa7c23301ae32df91861d94d39a9099906c923875d1048d53","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:39eb0593cfea7c0982886b56","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q6 explicitly includes conifold alignment models, parametric compatibility, effective-theory control and negligible-warping regimes.","qualification":"q6 expressly includes conifold alignment models, parametric compatibility and negligible warping. The hierarchy-generation mechanism is part of the coupled construction whose control and compatibility with large-volume Kähler stabilization and inflation are tested. It is retained as a target, not silently treated as established background.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b2e63c6fb71ac27aa7c23301ae32df91861d94d39a9099906c923875d1048d53","paperId":"1605.06299","textSha256":"064f865548bafacc88c365b7c467dff55ab1ff51a3112f025778fa64abf07466"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0069:u19:q6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0069:u19:q6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b2e63c6fb71ac27aa7c23301ae32df91861d94d39a9099906c923875d1048d53","q025-candidate-question:39eb0593cfea7c0982886b56"],"scopeContentSha256":"5b55ae9f665f43bead147892b94fe1109120c7a661d8e1eb9a6131948f54bc9d","placementContentSha256":"5b01ead0b66151c79885f55efd1b266eaabd8b1c4d67094fd8085d6f9a4cd400","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0069:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0069:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-05"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b2e63c6fb71ac27aa7c23301ae32df91861d94d39a9099906c923875d1048d53","paperId":"1605.06299","textSha256":"064f865548bafacc88c365b7c467dff55ab1ff51a3112f025778fa64abf07466"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-05/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"6079f3dff4de3bce86aff04cfa91b1a0da7ebf86722c5c33e44b4f563ac45e8e"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-05/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"b73dfbc8974cebd1c5c02da428f1652a9b6f36d6a1073a93ae692399858c7d3e","bytes":1594204,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0069","unitRef":"u19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b2e63c6fb71ac27aa7c23301ae32df91861d94d39a9099906c923875d1048d53","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:b2e63c6fb71ac27aa7c23301ae32df91861d94d39a9099906c923875d1048d53","textSha256":"064f865548bafacc88c365b7c467dff55ab1ff51a3112f025778fa64abf07466"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:18aa7c0dacea804a3201dbe7"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:18aa7c0dacea804a3201dbe7","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b2e63c6fb71ac27aa7c23301ae32df91861d94d39a9099906c923875d1048d53","q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643"],"scopeContentSha256":"0090ea9d5afb7931a126341f2a1e9970079dcf78145b0e7a0788e1866f3fd496","contributionContentSha256":"0f64c848b25d886ba87cc3d6d810b5b6320765dae46f11f6a6cf85148949c41e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-proposal","leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:b2e63c6fb71ac27aa7c23301ae32df91861d94d39a9099906c923875d1048d53","textSha256":"064f865548bafacc88c365b7c467dff55ab1ff51a3112f025778fa64abf07466"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:18aa7c0dacea804a3201dbe7","recordId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound hierarchy-generation and inflation target; negligible warping is the requested regime.","challengeNote":"Compound hierarchy-generation and inflation question; negligible warping is the requested regime.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:be23423b6f469d5bc6b7ea377c3e0ef994f80dfa42ddc4e58dee126e13f4431c","home":{"unitId":"unit:be23423b6f469d5bc6b7ea377c3e0ef994f80dfa42ddc4e58dee126e13f4431c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:39eb0593cfea7c0982886b56","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q6 includes five-brane inflation with supporting Kähler stabilization and source-specific vacuum stability.","qualification":"q6 covers five-brane inflation, supporting Kähler stabilization and vacuum stability. The absence of membrane-instanton superpotentials, FI contributions and the stabilized endpoint remain source-specific parts of the question. Its explicit convention permits this placement without adding an unstated compactification framework.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:be23423b6f469d5bc6b7ea377c3e0ef994f80dfa42ddc4e58dee126e13f4431c","paperId":"hep-th/0411062","textSha256":"8920b20c2d9b1938cd0a5a1beb17939c2ed55191fa8265eec82f9a98988cdb3d"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0069:u20:q6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0069:u20:q6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:be23423b6f469d5bc6b7ea377c3e0ef994f80dfa42ddc4e58dee126e13f4431c","q025-candidate-question:39eb0593cfea7c0982886b56"],"scopeContentSha256":"5b55ae9f665f43bead147892b94fe1109120c7a661d8e1eb9a6131948f54bc9d","placementContentSha256":"8e5bfd358831be1d5f8e16c15698559b2aeebaa656c0216fc5da51690a3b4bb6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0069:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0069:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-05"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:be23423b6f469d5bc6b7ea377c3e0ef994f80dfa42ddc4e58dee126e13f4431c","paperId":"hep-th/0411062","textSha256":"8920b20c2d9b1938cd0a5a1beb17939c2ed55191fa8265eec82f9a98988cdb3d"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-05/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"6079f3dff4de3bce86aff04cfa91b1a0da7ebf86722c5c33e44b4f563ac45e8e"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-05/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"b73dfbc8974cebd1c5c02da428f1652a9b6f36d6a1073a93ae692399858c7d3e","bytes":1594204,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0069","unitRef":"u20"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:be23423b6f469d5bc6b7ea377c3e0ef994f80dfa42ddc4e58dee126e13f4431c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:be23423b6f469d5bc6b7ea377c3e0ef994f80dfa42ddc4e58dee126e13f4431c","textSha256":"8920b20c2d9b1938cd0a5a1beb17939c2ed55191fa8265eec82f9a98988cdb3d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:74f095eef482b45d2232bdce"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:74f095eef482b45d2232bdce","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:be23423b6f469d5bc6b7ea377c3e0ef994f80dfa42ddc4e58dee126e13f4431c","q025-candidate-question:106b002fd1b6ac18c7db4643"],"scopeContentSha256":"0090ea9d5afb7931a126341f2a1e9970079dcf78145b0e7a0788e1866f3fd496","contributionContentSha256":"49a9111493e6e25426d7615efe43fc44aa3d27d6b7b83cd5a1729ef74a47c690","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-proposal","leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:be23423b6f469d5bc6b7ea377c3e0ef994f80dfa42ddc4e58dee126e13f4431c","textSha256":"8920b20c2d9b1938cd0a5a1beb17939c2ed55191fa8265eec82f9a98988cdb3d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:74f095eef482b45d2232bdce","recordId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-134e6a0b7019801adad3-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound stabilization and five-brane inflation target. Absence of membrane-instanton superpotentials is explicit; no additional framework is inferred.","challengeNote":"Compound stabilization and five-brane inflation target. Membrane-instanton superpotentials are absent; no additional framework is inferred.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"379361c3374281907de526b6c111fb4a82ef77bf6fa2cb7d1caf41622fb2e09e"},"organizational-access:5fab9a75f1ae23d39e9c09b6":{"id":"organizational-access:5fab9a75f1ae23d39e9c09b6","source":"q025-candidate-question:407a45488c47e1a4cafa2b59","target":"q025-candidate-question:e375e3a777fbccf230745197","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:407a45488c47e1a4cafa2b59","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"876efcf6c9c970476211523eafd06f239c121ea710f954d41c9095410963b96d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f2e9c32faeb712a7a1196dab"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e375e3a777fbccf230745197","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b8690d50ae925a10733b1c0ed0093ad211a7ab9a281f6602efd807466a69051e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6b9395b19a6c8832d154028f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:f9b0820f0acf36ec270cfbaca5df0a8aa31611b61be1a51fb64ce2d8958bb761","home":{"unitId":"unit:f9b0820f0acf36ec270cfbaca5df0a8aa31611b61be1a51fb64ce2d8958bb761","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:407a45488c47e1a4cafa2b59","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Summed exponential potentials and the transition from early scaling to late acceleration are explicit parts of q4.","qualification":"q4 explicitly covers summed exponentials and the early-scaling-to-late-acceleration sequence. The fixed component slopes and changing effective slope remain distinct, and the existence of an attractor does not certify a complete intervening cosmological history.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f9b0820f0acf36ec270cfbaca5df0a8aa31611b61be1a51fb64ce2d8958bb761","paperId":"2101.02942","textSha256":"80664b4c10a5e6022d29ad1f502b440af1ce4edc620637c2e571879c0d9fbc58"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0055:u18:q4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0055:u18:q4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f9b0820f0acf36ec270cfbaca5df0a8aa31611b61be1a51fb64ce2d8958bb761","q025-candidate-question:407a45488c47e1a4cafa2b59"],"scopeContentSha256":"876efcf6c9c970476211523eafd06f239c121ea710f954d41c9095410963b96d","placementContentSha256":"21f32661a87d82635058db79cdaf12d4dd901e823ef4142708c3f7b9d92d63ca","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0055:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0055:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f9b0820f0acf36ec270cfbaca5df0a8aa31611b61be1a51fb64ce2d8958bb761","paperId":"2101.02942","textSha256":"80664b4c10a5e6022d29ad1f502b440af1ce4edc620637c2e571879c0d9fbc58"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0055","unitRef":"u18"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f9b0820f0acf36ec270cfbaca5df0a8aa31611b61be1a51fb64ce2d8958bb761","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e375e3a777fbccf230745197","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:f9b0820f0acf36ec270cfbaca5df0a8aa31611b61be1a51fb64ce2d8958bb761","textSha256":"80664b4c10a5e6022d29ad1f502b440af1ce4edc620637c2e571879c0d9fbc58"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f506e546d5cad691c75a7d0d"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f506e546d5cad691c75a7d0d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f9b0820f0acf36ec270cfbaca5df0a8aa31611b61be1a51fb64ce2d8958bb761","q025-candidate-question:e375e3a777fbccf230745197"],"scopeContentSha256":"b8690d50ae925a10733b1c0ed0093ad211a7ab9a281f6602efd807466a69051e","contributionContentSha256":"31c422c0bdb6ffd2aa657ca473464960fdee5bf56ef88e090ad94d486ede49f5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:f9b0820f0acf36ec270cfbaca5df0a8aa31611b61be1a51fb64ce2d8958bb761","textSha256":"80664b4c10a5e6022d29ad1f502b440af1ce4edc620637c2e571879c0d9fbc58"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f506e546d5cad691c75a7d0d","recordId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Two fixed component slopes yield a changing effective slope from early scaling to late acceleration.","challengeNote":"Fixed component slopes produce a changing effective slope across early scaling and late acceleration.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ecef07ec2361e9ac35e39613a75954cc973b6d58326cc7c5d327a2daaa02d26f"},"organizational-access:b795b322e18f95de214c3f97":{"id":"organizational-access:b795b322e18f95de214c3f97","source":"q025-candidate-question:530e8cb46259544847e705a1","target":"q025-candidate-question:265bd371fe1997a8c8287c76","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:530e8cb46259544847e705a1","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"8dceafc78407881af364026aeafdc7324ccd5c45d492ddc35cb89671371f2ca1","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c046bb7a63b736d69a500595"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:265bd371fe1997a8c8287c76","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"523159e08cba403accc3f0d480776f86e407ee15237df0429b4f505115fa0dce","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1af070a7cfb619e22a697e27"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:811f0cd0e6a8dc24a2f2e2b763c0837b65b9e0227ee249adacc415663181a248","home":{"unitId":"unit:811f0cd0e6a8dc24a2f2e2b763c0837b65b9e0227ee249adacc415663181a248","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:530e8cb46259544847e705a1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines robustness of primordial predictions and observable ultraviolet imprints, including pre-TCC questions.","qualification":"q3 explicitly combines prediction robustness and observable ultraviolet imprints, including pre-TCC studies. These distinct targets form one complete admitted question. q1 remains another complete alternative; no multiple allocation, source decomposition or retrospective TCC premise is needed.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:811f0cd0e6a8dc24a2f2e2b763c0837b65b9e0227ee249adacc415663181a248","paperId":"1211.6753","textSha256":"867c91767b2689e22ea807500dfc7e95a8e5a9857a33e21cc2736ec733d748e5"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0001:u30:q3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0001:u30:q3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:811f0cd0e6a8dc24a2f2e2b763c0837b65b9e0227ee249adacc415663181a248","q025-candidate-question:530e8cb46259544847e705a1"],"scopeContentSha256":"8dceafc78407881af364026aeafdc7324ccd5c45d492ddc35cb89671371f2ca1","placementContentSha256":"c3a71af104817ac1ded8b6f014ec93b0459da4c7347ba2e8e939149d04db61af","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0001:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0001:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:811f0cd0e6a8dc24a2f2e2b763c0837b65b9e0227ee249adacc415663181a248","paperId":"1211.6753","textSha256":"867c91767b2689e22ea807500dfc7e95a8e5a9857a33e21cc2736ec733d748e5"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0001","unitRef":"u30"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:811f0cd0e6a8dc24a2f2e2b763c0837b65b9e0227ee249adacc415663181a248","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:265bd371fe1997a8c8287c76","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:811f0cd0e6a8dc24a2f2e2b763c0837b65b9e0227ee249adacc415663181a248","textSha256":"867c91767b2689e22ea807500dfc7e95a8e5a9857a33e21cc2736ec733d748e5"},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dcfa6273df2013e61f774cdee9324950","paperId":"1211.6753","sourceSha256":"ec1867e91bd90a916177fa6cdc61c5a475c10084237975287932386b76e04ed0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6499f9aeed1374adb8ad/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fada0af2750d0b146067b4ae362ff9583fa09c24e61e94a84aaad664bba6955e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"3a41ad26329c7e4fa7de0c6cc05e3d70f28952fa0ebbea62d1f9a0d166d32fbe","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6a8a2fde2292800f10812bda"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6a8a2fde2292800f10812bda","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:811f0cd0e6a8dc24a2f2e2b763c0837b65b9e0227ee249adacc415663181a248","q025-candidate-question:265bd371fe1997a8c8287c76"],"scopeContentSha256":"523159e08cba403accc3f0d480776f86e407ee15237df0429b4f505115fa0dce","contributionContentSha256":"1091201b66de2c331d5e6722b2928fba606f85dc7798d59d5b91ebc52f590401","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-proposal","leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:811f0cd0e6a8dc24a2f2e2b763c0837b65b9e0227ee249adacc415663181a248","textSha256":"867c91767b2689e22ea807500dfc7e95a8e5a9857a33e21cc2736ec733d748e5"},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dcfa6273df2013e61f774cdee9324950","paperId":"1211.6753","sourceSha256":"ec1867e91bd90a916177fa6cdc61c5a475c10084237975287932386b76e04ed0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6499f9aeed1374adb8ad/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fada0af2750d0b146067b4ae362ff9583fa09c24e61e94a84aaad664bba6955e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"3a41ad26329c7e4fa7de0c6cc05e3d70f28952fa0ebbea62d1f9a0d166d32fbe","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6a8a2fde2292800f10812bda","recordId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":1,"proposalNote":"The abstract establishes review targets: robustness and possible Planck-scale imprints, not a universal answer.","challengeNote":"The abstract announces paired robustness and microscopic-imprint review targets, without establishing a universal answer.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a169402713e60a2268ac2e60d7f51b2aa1e2ce200f7e9d1ce6d78bbaa80423a3"},"organizational-access:8faa742aca20d5cf8a6c16f3":{"id":"organizational-access:8faa742aca20d5cf8a6c16f3","source":"q025-candidate-question:59a1073896d8181c0e961e88","target":"q025-candidate-question:b9d8df4f750ac8295aba03ed","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:59a1073896d8181c0e961e88","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"0556f5361342e7c7dadf06e3616af68ae3a5722517fd269ec819471c78640996","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1565e7e8c4b744e184599d06"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:b9d8df4f750ac8295aba03ed","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"751c67059c37642b86d304d553d00f7d0da65d6cecbabd9d011687faa08eca42","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7de725e1eca345f983854a25"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","home":{"unitId":"unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:59a1073896d8181c0e961e88","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":0.5,"reason":"Covers strongly coupled transport with chiral anomalies and translation-breaking comparisons.","qualification":"Keep transport, de Sitter matter tests and TTbar entanglement distinct; infer no holographic construction or TTbar prescription. Exact full challenge coverage and source-local qualifications remain binding. Weights are organizational allocation, not confidence or physical importance.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","paperId":"2012.10109","textSha256":"818a4ad1a0fd66d40c3efb2ca23366e6bfdcc7845321f6465aee87b856e4a826"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0059:u22:q8","coverageMode":"explicit_compound_union","targetCoverage":[{"sourceSpan":"broken translations and chiral anomalies affect strongly coupled transport","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:59a1073896d8181c0e961e88"],"explanation":"q8 includes anomalous strongly coupled QFT transport and translation-breaking comparisons; both stated mechanisms remain in this transport assignment."},{"sourceSpan":"holographic entanglement constrain de Sitter matter","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:b9d8df4f750ac8295aba03ed"],"explanation":"This is q13's entropy-based matter-test direction in a de Sitter setting."},{"sourceSpan":"clarify TT̄-deformed theories","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:3dadd0a3f57bbc0a09ad9c38"],"explanation":"The shared holographic-entanglement method applies here to deformed-theory state structure, within q4's information-measure scope; no particular TT̄ prescription is inferred."}],"coverageReason":"The union covers both transport mechanisms and the two separate entanglement applications. q8 supplies anomalous transport and translation-breaking comparisons, q13 the de Sitter matter test, and q4 entanglement in deformed theories. No supplied whole scope includes all three branches: q17 lacks the entanglement applications and q4 lacks the transport question. The source remains whole; the union requires separate coordinator scrutiny."},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0059:u22:q8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","q025-candidate-question:59a1073896d8181c0e961e88"],"scopeContentSha256":"0556f5361342e7c7dadf06e3616af68ae3a5722517fd269ec819471c78640996","placementContentSha256":"7209af3ceb29da5667467389a9cca0705d3d2220d58ebc566451107066b34fe9","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0059:proposal","explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0059:challenge","root:explicit-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","paperId":"2012.10109","textSha256":"818a4ad1a0fd66d40c3efb2ca23366e6bfdcc7845321f6465aee87b856e4a826"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"45cd7c1d060cb6f2fd1d8a4ace5cca7c3d64df235a869afc4ce7e31b2e6badfb"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0059","unitRef":"u22"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b9d8df4f750ac8295aba03ed","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","textSha256":"818a4ad1a0fd66d40c3efb2ca23366e6bfdcc7845321f6465aee87b856e4a826"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:644d71001249e505ea058773","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound transport, de Sitter-matter and TT̄-entanglement targets require finer reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Transport, de Sitter matter and TT̄-entanglement targets require finer reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:644d71001249e505ea058773","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","q025-candidate-question:b9d8df4f750ac8295aba03ed"],"scopeContentSha256":"751c67059c37642b86d304d553d00f7d0da65d6cecbabd9d011687faa08eca42","contributionContentSha256":"edd50b62486882eeb0eabec4ffe144e647a135ae09c33f9f6bb4e21b0a52e87c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b25d09c378f754eff252-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b25d09c378f754eff252-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b25d09c378f754eff252-proposal","leaf-b25d09c378f754eff252-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","textSha256":"818a4ad1a0fd66d40c3efb2ca23366e6bfdcc7845321f6465aee87b856e4a826"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:644d71001249e505ea058773","recordId":"leaf-b25d09c378f754eff252-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b25d09c378f754eff252-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b25d09c378f754eff252-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound transport, de Sitter-matter and TT̄-entanglement targets require finer reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Transport, de Sitter matter and TT̄-entanglement targets require finer reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"b1cbaf1dabd9447490044fde79af79b1f21ae18897245fa45dcb9b2943d407c2"},"organizational-access:c6e963e37195233ef63379de":{"id":"organizational-access:c6e963e37195233ef63379de","source":"q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77","target":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"10c91e842592747fabd695adde41b1746857f0f5fd32bb1b327ca5c72bdd857c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b95736960161f794ae0ece76"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:49ec66a8c6b5e4747536c1d3"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:3d4f835fdc59859ee7b9157c2f4863e7109395619a126626d0e84d5e1446892c","home":{"unitId":"unit:3d4f835fdc59859ee7b9157c2f4863e7109395619a126626d0e84d5e1446892c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers natural-inflation field budgets, axion-range restrictions and their scalar and tensor consequences.","qualification":"q5 explicitly includes natural models, excursions, decay constants and observable consequences. It covers the joint tensor-versus-field-budget feasibility question with the spectral-index, running and source-specific axion-range conditions retained.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3d4f835fdc59859ee7b9157c2f4863e7109395619a126626d0e84d5e1446892c","paperId":"1305.1947","textSha256":"e1ef03368c36fcb9f162c6239434299b3b3cf85a6d3107c738a3966fb97de091"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0001:u6:q5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0001:u6:q5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3d4f835fdc59859ee7b9157c2f4863e7109395619a126626d0e84d5e1446892c","q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77"],"scopeContentSha256":"10c91e842592747fabd695adde41b1746857f0f5fd32bb1b327ca5c72bdd857c","placementContentSha256":"c6eeabe9f2bb502d7cf5e8e75414886ce4685aa3b94a974ddb3abaf5b287db57","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0001:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0001:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3d4f835fdc59859ee7b9157c2f4863e7109395619a126626d0e84d5e1446892c","paperId":"1305.1947","textSha256":"e1ef03368c36fcb9f162c6239434299b3b3cf85a6d3107c738a3966fb97de091"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0001","unitRef":"u6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3d4f835fdc59859ee7b9157c2f4863e7109395619a126626d0e84d5e1446892c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:3d4f835fdc59859ee7b9157c2f4863e7109395619a126626d0e84d5e1446892c","textSha256":"e1ef03368c36fcb9f162c6239434299b3b3cf85a6d3107c738a3966fb97de091"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:643e748dc352416525083bbc"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:643e748dc352416525083bbc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3d4f835fdc59859ee7b9157c2f4863e7109395619a126626d0e84d5e1446892c","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"30889a2f115d9dd3d0b34bc0df37cc2660d66244f0a58df54d958d44efc4711d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:3d4f835fdc59859ee7b9157c2f4863e7109395619a126626d0e84d5e1446892c","textSha256":"e1ef03368c36fcb9f162c6239434299b3b3cf85a6d3107c738a3966fb97de091"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:643e748dc352416525083bbc","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"e99f7a30a8d8804e57c013c7267f0731a34467c46d0bed4cb438cb567d8eea04"},"organizational-access:1d3504962ab94893e3271404":{"id":"organizational-access:1d3504962ab94893e3271404","source":"q025-candidate-question:6b099a72fa61aa622880dfa2","target":"q025-candidate-question:f245e1f38096549c488c89ac","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6b099a72fa61aa622880dfa2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"24db97dc82d9b7e926b5b22c624c1591c5d8fd94caf62cc41348d2bbb50e6ab2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ab088afeec803d9cd272cf27"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f245e1f38096549c488c89ac","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"bd1537ef49a3e1c058e06ea3543e09f798dc3b88d23af5048bd2867e0fb48cf9","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:statistics:pq1"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","home":{"unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6b099a72fa61aa622880dfa2","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","paperId":"1812.04147","textSha256":"79093b923c07e9d3c57bd1d4f83b5ccdaa90f10630a9f3abd967575c6f30a64c"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9acaec5c0e653c89b0a3ef7432d4b783","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"15ed8868bb10683405878235928c821c92c1d85fd1708e9a2ee6e705ff6bf161","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f54ba78c46dede1a602bc9ae77ffce85","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":1293,"end":4693,"textSha256":"404f190296444d7c2a164706fd626c80a36fcaaf36d767eaea468f46a1eda1d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e27","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ffe5b5d3589c87c44231377111d83fa6","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":2494,"end":5251,"textSha256":"7db530de1ec75dd0da2ed39ae1e90d410ec5bc0be738f16d124db9484263a30d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6028a363351de2049d83ef75"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6028a363351de2049d83ef75","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","q025-candidate-question:6b099a72fa61aa622880dfa2"],"scopeContentSha256":"24db97dc82d9b7e926b5b22c624c1591c5d8fd94caf62cc41348d2bbb50e6ab2","placementContentSha256":"f9e65aa912ce395c04082cf9bbfc9debf8653fc356f034b3d23d46f607548bd5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","paperId":"1812.04147","textSha256":"79093b923c07e9d3c57bd1d4f83b5ccdaa90f10630a9f3abd967575c6f30a64c"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9acaec5c0e653c89b0a3ef7432d4b783","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"15ed8868bb10683405878235928c821c92c1d85fd1708e9a2ee6e705ff6bf161","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f54ba78c46dede1a602bc9ae77ffce85","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":1293,"end":4693,"textSha256":"404f190296444d7c2a164706fd626c80a36fcaaf36d767eaea468f46a1eda1d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e27","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ffe5b5d3589c87c44231377111d83fa6","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":2494,"end":5251,"textSha256":"7db530de1ec75dd0da2ed39ae1e90d410ec5bc0be738f16d124db9484263a30d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6028a363351de2049d83ef75"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f245e1f38096549c488c89ac","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","paperId":"1812.04147","textSha256":"79093b923c07e9d3c57bd1d4f83b5ccdaa90f10630a9f3abd967575c6f30a64c"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9acaec5c0e653c89b0a3ef7432d4b783","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"15ed8868bb10683405878235928c821c92c1d85fd1708e9a2ee6e705ff6bf161","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f54ba78c46dede1a602bc9ae77ffce85","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":1293,"end":4693,"textSha256":"404f190296444d7c2a164706fd626c80a36fcaaf36d767eaea468f46a1eda1d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ffe5b5d3589c87c44231377111d83fa6","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":2494,"end":5251,"textSha256":"7db530de1ec75dd0da2ed39ae1e90d410ec5bc0be738f16d124db9484263a30d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"qualification":"Original source-specific qualification: The primary abstract explicitly claims parametric weak coupling and weak curvature. Its dependence on quantum corrections and the separate boundary-condition challenge remain unresolved; the claim is not certified by this role. Current explicit adjudication: The parametric claim directly addresses pq1, while admissibility of a quantized family is not demonstrated in these windows; u16 supplies the separate boundary-condition objection. Additional qualifications: The abstract's parametric weak-coupling and weak-curvature claim does not supply the discrete-family checks required by pq1 or a uniform correction estimate at singular sources. The reported tree-level moduli remain.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-adjudicated-role:statistics:z35"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-adjudicated-role:statistics:z35","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","q025-candidate-question:f245e1f38096549c488c89ac"],"scopeContentSha256":"bd1537ef49a3e1c058e06ea3543e09f798dc3b88d23af5048bd2867e0fb48cf9","contributionContentSha256":"687dc4ffea61595ff6e31ddcbfcc68228f7742abd0b45db6b2cab9d3b628a0e7","challengerAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_source_contribution","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_source_contribution","receipt":{"path":"../../../evaluation/full-pass/canonical-role-adjudications-v2/admission.json","sha256":"ebb259802ad5fb3293e5a30ab9b6f2efd72ed948191d12ceb30445e26b4dfe97"}},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","statistics-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","paperId":"1812.04147","textSha256":"79093b923c07e9d3c57bd1d4f83b5ccdaa90f10630a9f3abd967575c6f30a64c"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9acaec5c0e653c89b0a3ef7432d4b783","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"15ed8868bb10683405878235928c821c92c1d85fd1708e9a2ee6e705ff6bf161","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f54ba78c46dede1a602bc9ae77ffce85","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":1293,"end":4693,"textSha256":"404f190296444d7c2a164706fd626c80a36fcaaf36d767eaea468f46a1eda1d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ffe5b5d3589c87c44231377111d83fa6","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":2494,"end":5251,"textSha256":"7db530de1ec75dd0da2ed39ae1e90d410ec5bc0be738f16d124db9484263a30d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"explicitAdjudicationBasis":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-adjudicated-role:statistics:z35","sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","statistics-source-role-confirmation"],"originalContribution":{"id":"z35","unitRef":"u15","questionRef":"pq1","role":"addresses","reason":"The primary abstract explicitly claims parametric weak coupling and weak curvature. Its dependence on quantum corrections and the separate boundary-condition challenge remain unresolved; the claim is not certified by this role.","refs":["u15","e4","e7","e8"]},"confirmationJudgment":{"id":"z35","verdict":"supported_with_limits","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":["The abstract's parametric weak-coupling and weak-curvature claim does not supply the discrete-family checks required by pq1 or a uniform correction estimate at singular sources. The reported tree-level moduli remain."],"reason":"The parametric claim directly addresses pq1, while admissibility of a quantized family is not demonstrated in these windows; u16 supplies the separate boundary-condition objection.","refs":["u15","pq1","e4","e7","e8","u16","e2"]},"exactPrivatePacket":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/canonical-role-adjudication-v1/statistics-z35.json","sha256":"9654f6554894e141f1f3678b04b75e29d9bd2e202f164ba4e48456e547833d5a"},"scopeContentSha256":"bd1537ef49a3e1c058e06ea3543e09f798dc3b88d23af5048bd2867e0fb48cf9"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"8dd65a80bbf615accb36b8db9621ebf37bf13ef4b4d07a51e8f4286a25650d9e"},"organizational-access:39a32a2049d9b971ec4e722b":{"id":"organizational-access:39a32a2049d9b971ec4e722b","source":"q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a","target":"q025-candidate-question:c1f9aa1a4410c9c93d81aad4","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1f0300ebb75ae20a042a7a13d20c0a0f3543b50bf6a7f0985811c6bc71256bdd","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:034e173e6c01f70a1cc70b4c"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c1f9aa1a4410c9c93d81aad4","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"de8436039b543b23fa27163a783f372ebdd4c3221e9491efc58205e3e844ea3b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2a5372797e0277d9fc06f9e6"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","home":{"unitId":"unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines claimed axion necessity, exact gauge-form protection and source-specific S-matrix premises.","qualification":"q10 explicitly covers claimed necessity and exactness, gauge-form mechanisms and source-specific S-matrix assumptions. Both the consistency argument and protection construction remain questions; absence of global PQ does not remove the axion.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","paperId":"2209.14219","textSha256":"634ba2516486d170a4b9c0e220c4042b2ed033cfc8db687b33acf8cb8b290475"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0038:u12:q10"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0038:u12:q10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f0300ebb75ae20a042a7a13d20c0a0f3543b50bf6a7f0985811c6bc71256bdd","placementContentSha256":"54ef8998f495d446b2fc12c41a0f1c68ba0ef7e87abb2cc7f0178cd26a944677","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0038:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0038:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","paperId":"2209.14219","textSha256":"634ba2516486d170a4b9c0e220c4042b2ed033cfc8db687b33acf8cb8b290475"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0038","unitRef":"u12"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c1f9aa1a4410c9c93d81aad4","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d63","kind":"description","unitIndex":63,"unitId":"unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","textSha256":"634ba2516486d170a4b9c0e220c4042b2ed033cfc8db687b33acf8cb8b290475"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:11014a27e05f2fe9ecf45074c34f9bbc","paperId":"2209.14219","sourceSha256":"a13831f3df2f5c0729e748c4b6ffc3121a360bf0e34d04658a0fe1ca4607d3a8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca2c5708f32ba00d2977/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fbf50a01af6aa90632004bc747b5d2df3e20e45ced5e7fc3809251084f6ab1ca","pdfPage":1,"start":2496,"end":5338,"textSha256":"83cb06712a3c3179734d2c9010821dff425500a3c2e8721fe05498256498fb93","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:34362d7778fa135d0c9e07d388d2e9dc","paperId":"2209.14219","sourceSha256":"a13831f3df2f5c0729e748c4b6ffc3121a360bf0e34d04658a0fe1ca4607d3a8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca2c5708f32ba00d2977/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fbf50a01af6aa90632004bc747b5d2df3e20e45ced5e7fc3809251084f6ab1ca","pdfPage":1,"start":3694,"end":5338,"textSha256":"32531b2bf0946b47778fff5dfd653e017ced0d126f03ac6266dbbff6e57d03e3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dd8881a71fadd93791657e06","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Joint consistency-and-protection question. S-matrix premises and claimed all-orders gauge protection are not independently proved by this window. Independent challenge qualification: Joint consistency and protection targets. S-matrix reasoning and all-orders gauge protection are source claims, not established by these introductory wind,"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:dd8881a71fadd93791657e06","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","q025-candidate-question:c1f9aa1a4410c9c93d81aad4"],"scopeContentSha256":"de8436039b543b23fa27163a783f372ebdd4c3221e9491efc58205e3e844ea3b","contributionContentSha256":"a8f367e6239c2c61daa7b77cad1f16242b4b7b63e412a0f2d04513b338ecaf4e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d63","kind":"description","unitIndex":63,"unitId":"unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","textSha256":"634ba2516486d170a4b9c0e220c4042b2ed033cfc8db687b33acf8cb8b290475"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:11014a27e05f2fe9ecf45074c34f9bbc","paperId":"2209.14219","sourceSha256":"a13831f3df2f5c0729e748c4b6ffc3121a360bf0e34d04658a0fe1ca4607d3a8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca2c5708f32ba00d2977/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fbf50a01af6aa90632004bc747b5d2df3e20e45ced5e7fc3809251084f6ab1ca","pdfPage":1,"start":2496,"end":5338,"textSha256":"83cb06712a3c3179734d2c9010821dff425500a3c2e8721fe05498256498fb93","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:34362d7778fa135d0c9e07d388d2e9dc","paperId":"2209.14219","sourceSha256":"a13831f3df2f5c0729e748c4b6ffc3121a360bf0e34d04658a0fe1ca4607d3a8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca2c5708f32ba00d2977/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fbf50a01af6aa90632004bc747b5d2df3e20e45ced5e7fc3809251084f6ab1ca","pdfPage":1,"start":3694,"end":5338,"textSha256":"32531b2bf0946b47778fff5dfd653e017ced0d126f03ac6266dbbff6e57d03e3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dd8881a71fadd93791657e06","recordId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Joint consistency-and-protection question. S-matrix premises and claimed all-orders gauge protection are not independently proved by this window.","challengeNote":"Joint consistency and protection targets. S-matrix reasoning and all-orders gauge protection are source claims, not established by these introductory wind,","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"969b696cf5aac01140dbb39daa39241a892d883de0d2ed4eb77cfaf1c874e01d"},"organizational-access:19ee5eb241ac8c289a1f363e":{"id":"organizational-access:19ee5eb241ac8c289a1f363e","source":"q025-candidate-question:79cdd7041ac53955427403ad","target":"q025-candidate-question:81aa3e6e98bedb1c9b443b59","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:79cdd7041ac53955427403ad","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1a7ed0e144996f707264f2f42d45f5b8bc05dace46935450b641973363af96b9","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ab17265576c11d36fd1d1e98"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:81aa3e6e98bedb1c9b443b59","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c90bd52c73575e5109ffe5c79d4b3b5c7595a48d02c2e2c72fb82c8d580188ff","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:4f9b62c4fdd6c79de6470bd2"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:b302e962d78c38c66e4c7b6b748fceb724c9457299310651bfa90dc64ce4190a","home":{"unitId":"unit:b302e962d78c38c66e4c7b6b748fceb724c9457299310651bfa90dc64ce4190a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:79cdd7041ac53955427403ad","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Directly joins running gravitational/electromagnetic couplings, charged-black-hole extremality and proposed WGC emergence under the supplied RG prescription.","qualification":"q9 covers both the extremality correction and its proposed ultraviolet WGC interpretation. The inherited radial identification k(r)=ξ/r and leading small-running approximation remain conditional model inputs.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b302e962d78c38c66e4c7b6b748fceb724c9457299310651bfa90dc64ce4190a","paperId":"2504.20107","textSha256":"1f9c39239d1a588d146076f4ed27ba4b46953a82af45317c7645fef7d0d5c5c0"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0052:u7:q9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0052:u7:q9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b302e962d78c38c66e4c7b6b748fceb724c9457299310651bfa90dc64ce4190a","q025-candidate-question:79cdd7041ac53955427403ad"],"scopeContentSha256":"1a7ed0e144996f707264f2f42d45f5b8bc05dace46935450b641973363af96b9","placementContentSha256":"3b8d7f94e91e81225560baf0575d7e005e88ab7fd7a0c8b1306eae53582b9023","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0052:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0052:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b302e962d78c38c66e4c7b6b748fceb724c9457299310651bfa90dc64ce4190a","paperId":"2504.20107","textSha256":"1f9c39239d1a588d146076f4ed27ba4b46953a82af45317c7645fef7d0d5c5c0"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0052","unitRef":"u7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b302e962d78c38c66e4c7b6b748fceb724c9457299310651bfa90dc64ce4190a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:81aa3e6e98bedb1c9b443b59","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d40","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:b302e962d78c38c66e4c7b6b748fceb724c9457299310651bfa90dc64ce4190a","textSha256":"1f9c39239d1a588d146076f4ed27ba4b46953a82af45317c7645fef7d0d5c5c0"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7057d3823095b346024413f335d4e71b","paperId":"2504.20107","sourceSha256":"7ce0cb79ae6b4999674ce70e3c45119f590528ea6dc19fbc420c84dad3ca6bed","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/83fcfdaa609457ccafe0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7751f8fc3048941f65669423d69e04456a8426699a46cee8a4af8508ce72e501","pdfPage":2,"start":103,"end":2848,"textSha256":"3f212ebf2ec430826056940dd21b6ab03c572c615fc1329480e0534e51bbbf6d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b9efa75b41825f957cc39900981bb00a","paperId":"2504.20107","sourceSha256":"7ce0cb79ae6b4999674ce70e3c45119f590528ea6dc19fbc420c84dad3ca6bed","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/83fcfdaa609457ccafe0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7751f8fc3048941f65669423d69e04456a8426699a46cee8a4af8508ce72e501","pdfPage":2,"start":1304,"end":2848,"textSha256":"49ebfc7827abb2d1fe34df3cfe67af9fb395592d7653f5bb748664757ab25dc0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cfc1d0b7778d26deabfedee1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:cfc1d0b7778d26deabfedee1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b302e962d78c38c66e4c7b6b748fceb724c9457299310651bfa90dc64ce4190a","q025-candidate-question:81aa3e6e98bedb1c9b443b59"],"scopeContentSha256":"c90bd52c73575e5109ffe5c79d4b3b5c7595a48d02c2e2c72fb82c8d580188ff","contributionContentSha256":"f113ba5d201d2735ac38d54a978c2ff6f84c335833cae4dba21f28d9f7936c82","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-proposal","leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d40","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:b302e962d78c38c66e4c7b6b748fceb724c9457299310651bfa90dc64ce4190a","textSha256":"1f9c39239d1a588d146076f4ed27ba4b46953a82af45317c7645fef7d0d5c5c0"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7057d3823095b346024413f335d4e71b","paperId":"2504.20107","sourceSha256":"7ce0cb79ae6b4999674ce70e3c45119f590528ea6dc19fbc420c84dad3ca6bed","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/83fcfdaa609457ccafe0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7751f8fc3048941f65669423d69e04456a8426699a46cee8a4af8508ce72e501","pdfPage":2,"start":103,"end":2848,"textSha256":"3f212ebf2ec430826056940dd21b6ab03c572c615fc1329480e0534e51bbbf6d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b9efa75b41825f957cc39900981bb00a","paperId":"2504.20107","sourceSha256":"7ce0cb79ae6b4999674ce70e3c45119f590528ea6dc19fbc420c84dad3ca6bed","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/83fcfdaa609457ccafe0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7751f8fc3048941f65669423d69e04456a8426699a46cee8a4af8508ce72e501","pdfPage":2,"start":1304,"end":2848,"textSha256":"49ebfc7827abb2d1fe34df3cfe67af9fb395592d7653f5bb748664757ab25dc0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cfc1d0b7778d26deabfedee1","recordId":"leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"The proposed WGC emergence depends on radial scale setting and leading running corrections; the excerpt does not establish universality.","challengeNote":"Extremality corrections and proposed WGC emergence are conditional on radial scale setting and the leading small-running approximation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"f4efc42d8349cd6ec0e7b9d8ed476f76d88a582940d82959cdac3e64d21245b5"},"organizational-access:a175268b0a902ac3abaae044":{"id":"organizational-access:a175268b0a902ac3abaae044","source":"q025-candidate-question:842474decf24d26352d666e3","target":"q025-candidate-question:da2b38749f8c655a444b47b0","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:842474decf24d26352d666e3","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"598cbe774543acaaab789ec2a421583c9ab07bc50810dac7ab2ee756110fd550","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c9ae042c5262fd82db4ec730"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:da2b38749f8c655a444b47b0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7d72daf57307003b9b8bd1f6ac2580016fed4cb4e76663fc7d0fc3f393289744","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:edb0c84ba4a41f12c1f94f48"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:603a6719ec5c51f36086dd9ad73df58c383b883f2aa57479a4711b73909e5932","home":{"unitId":"unit:603a6719ec5c51f36086dd9ad73df58c383b883f2aa57479a4711b73909e5932","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:842474decf24d26352d666e3","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines beyond-truncation extremality monotonicity with light-particle modifications of Nariai curves.","qualification":"q8 explicitly covers both nonlinear monotonicity beyond truncation and light-particle changes to Nariai spectra. The supplied Euler–Heisenberg/DBI examples and cosmological-constant comparisons remain source-specific. Spectral changes and monotonicity are distinct targets; neither establishes a universal nonlinear result or a discharge endpoint.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:603a6719ec5c51f36086dd9ad73df58c383b883f2aa57479a4711b73909e5932","paperId":"2305.17062","textSha256":"0cfb66356719d01d6d6bec7d26fa01796ac28730dae23fa5cde03834e414ebd8"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0037:u11:q8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0037:u11:q8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:603a6719ec5c51f36086dd9ad73df58c383b883f2aa57479a4711b73909e5932","q025-candidate-question:842474decf24d26352d666e3"],"scopeContentSha256":"598cbe774543acaaab789ec2a421583c9ab07bc50810dac7ab2ee756110fd550","placementContentSha256":"bf265fdf5ac4b40db93a581a469a439674c52c2f2c28b6e05574e140c2f658f3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0037:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0037:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:603a6719ec5c51f36086dd9ad73df58c383b883f2aa57479a4711b73909e5932","paperId":"2305.17062","textSha256":"0cfb66356719d01d6d6bec7d26fa01796ac28730dae23fa5cde03834e414ebd8"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0037","unitRef":"u11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:603a6719ec5c51f36086dd9ad73df58c383b883f2aa57479a4711b73909e5932","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:da2b38749f8c655a444b47b0","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:603a6719ec5c51f36086dd9ad73df58c383b883f2aa57479a4711b73909e5932","textSha256":"0cfb66356719d01d6d6bec7d26fa01796ac28730dae23fa5cde03834e414ebd8"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1aeca5756f8f1d1e49a89b52d9f84373","paperId":"2305.17062","sourceSha256":"892070083f39652a05ef217b8f0ced513fa528a505d1ea5262f02852918e0d8a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/78373423b4bfee944e9a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e75e88b1add3494b4b904383ba1edc254cd73b51514a45327d5681f0001fffb4","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2629,"textSha256":"8e9c890bf6d53b5d0d23692f83ad985129a0017dfaa2eedf87c7b7a04b5e0576","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4a23768967e6ad467613075b5c362167","paperId":"2305.17062","sourceSha256":"892070083f39652a05ef217b8f0ced513fa528a505d1ea5262f02852918e0d8a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/78373423b4bfee944e9a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e75e88b1add3494b4b904383ba1edc254cd73b51514a45327d5681f0001fffb4","pdfPage":4,"start":98,"end":2629,"textSha256":"92eb76aef8ba4b7a5524a2cf85dcf8cc0d19a505a54d7c8259fc07f889734cc6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:84c82587af5bafef3a69998fbd59aced","paperId":"2305.17062","sourceSha256":"892070083f39652a05ef217b8f0ced513fa528a505d1ea5262f02852918e0d8a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/78373423b4bfee944e9a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e75e88b1add3494b4b904383ba1edc254cd73b51514a45327d5681f0001fffb4","pdfPage":4,"start":1284,"end":2629,"textSha256":"aa8bee8f9981de6de64ae76832c25db7c778fdb3fb9439977adb139331eaf823","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:99360c01d2098f2bc1b5616f","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound identity unresolved: all-sign extremality monotonicity and light-particle Nariai-curve changes require separate reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Compound identity unresolved: extremality monotonicity across cosmological-constant signs and Euler–Heisenberg Nariai-curve changes require separate scopes."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:99360c01d2098f2bc1b5616f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:603a6719ec5c51f36086dd9ad73df58c383b883f2aa57479a4711b73909e5932","q025-candidate-question:da2b38749f8c655a444b47b0"],"scopeContentSha256":"7d72daf57307003b9b8bd1f6ac2580016fed4cb4e76663fc7d0fc3f393289744","contributionContentSha256":"f4d2a6cddf2fd542ad51b99de8b9b626de56560103ea46754876b2033f9d8514","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-87d7993188bba7a3ec4c-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-87d7993188bba7a3ec4c-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-87d7993188bba7a3ec4c-proposal","leaf-87d7993188bba7a3ec4c-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:603a6719ec5c51f36086dd9ad73df58c383b883f2aa57479a4711b73909e5932","textSha256":"0cfb66356719d01d6d6bec7d26fa01796ac28730dae23fa5cde03834e414ebd8"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1aeca5756f8f1d1e49a89b52d9f84373","paperId":"2305.17062","sourceSha256":"892070083f39652a05ef217b8f0ced513fa528a505d1ea5262f02852918e0d8a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/78373423b4bfee944e9a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e75e88b1add3494b4b904383ba1edc254cd73b51514a45327d5681f0001fffb4","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2629,"textSha256":"8e9c890bf6d53b5d0d23692f83ad985129a0017dfaa2eedf87c7b7a04b5e0576","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4a23768967e6ad467613075b5c362167","paperId":"2305.17062","sourceSha256":"892070083f39652a05ef217b8f0ced513fa528a505d1ea5262f02852918e0d8a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/78373423b4bfee944e9a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e75e88b1add3494b4b904383ba1edc254cd73b51514a45327d5681f0001fffb4","pdfPage":4,"start":98,"end":2629,"textSha256":"92eb76aef8ba4b7a5524a2cf85dcf8cc0d19a505a54d7c8259fc07f889734cc6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:84c82587af5bafef3a69998fbd59aced","paperId":"2305.17062","sourceSha256":"892070083f39652a05ef217b8f0ced513fa528a505d1ea5262f02852918e0d8a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/78373423b4bfee944e9a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e75e88b1add3494b4b904383ba1edc254cd73b51514a45327d5681f0001fffb4","pdfPage":4,"start":1284,"end":2629,"textSha256":"aa8bee8f9981de6de64ae76832c25db7c778fdb3fb9439977adb139331eaf823","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:99360c01d2098f2bc1b5616f","recordId":"leaf-87d7993188bba7a3ec4c-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-87d7993188bba7a3ec4c-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-87d7993188bba7a3ec4c-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound identity unresolved: all-sign extremality monotonicity and light-particle Nariai-curve changes require separate reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Compound identity unresolved: extremality monotonicity across cosmological-constant signs and Euler–Heisenberg Nariai-curve changes require separate scopes.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ee3f969bb1de4a3626b9e5184e642e4eb59a1728b1cfce3d0f30c316eeecc3af"},"organizational-access:9eedb61dd4ead8ab4d9e4c30":{"id":"organizational-access:9eedb61dd4ead8ab4d9e4c30","source":"q025-candidate-question:85856543c0cd2198f16d4ad3","target":"q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:85856543c0cd2198f16d4ad3","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"44bdb67249358064eae26abb998d5a29185a33b51ca8bee930c4b20c5997d44b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:240ccbc3e3fb29b2a0baaf0b"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f182d2957140a3f44bdc7c0c469ec4c0b69768b439470a47b36d261656eee304","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2d91b98abf949cd418ef9d0e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:54cda38b1d3dd8fc25523524cb7c349214c9e8c2cf7db96808d6ef3923373080","home":{"unitId":"unit:54cda38b1d3dd8fc25523524cb7c349214c9e8c2cf7db96808d6ef3923373080","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:85856543c0cd2198f16d4ad3","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Its loop-population, percolation and formation-dependent network scope covers growth and encounters of initially isolated decreasing-tension loops.","qualification":"The complete question concerns growth and percolation from supplied initial loops under modulus-driven tension decrease. q8 covers loop populations, encounters and network percolation without adding an independent origin question for those initial loops.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:54cda38b1d3dd8fc25523524cb7c349214c9e8c2cf7db96808d6ef3923373080","paperId":"2406.12637","textSha256":"aab2bef6e016412a06639c748e2631c1292b8d176dea5fe993227f6a6c3966eb"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0061:u11:q8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0061:u11:q8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:54cda38b1d3dd8fc25523524cb7c349214c9e8c2cf7db96808d6ef3923373080","q025-candidate-question:85856543c0cd2198f16d4ad3"],"scopeContentSha256":"44bdb67249358064eae26abb998d5a29185a33b51ca8bee930c4b20c5997d44b","placementContentSha256":"6b4307e203fcb362dfb96eabbdab20b0b25e6ac35d147ac0bbff372287440112","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0061:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0061:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:54cda38b1d3dd8fc25523524cb7c349214c9e8c2cf7db96808d6ef3923373080","paperId":"2406.12637","textSha256":"aab2bef6e016412a06639c748e2631c1292b8d176dea5fe993227f6a6c3966eb"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0061","unitRef":"u11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:54cda38b1d3dd8fc25523524cb7c349214c9e8c2cf7db96808d6ef3923373080","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:54cda38b1d3dd8fc25523524cb7c349214c9e8c2cf7db96808d6ef3923373080","textSha256":"aab2bef6e016412a06639c748e2631c1292b8d176dea5fe993227f6a6c3966eb"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6e209919365c2dc9d986bcbb","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Links a distinct formation route to network percolation; no symmetry-breaking transition is required by this proposed route. Independent challenge qualification: Formation and percolation are linked targets. The proposed route starts with isolated loops and does not require a symmetry-breaking transition."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6e209919365c2dc9d986bcbb","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:54cda38b1d3dd8fc25523524cb7c349214c9e8c2cf7db96808d6ef3923373080","q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef"],"scopeContentSha256":"f182d2957140a3f44bdc7c0c469ec4c0b69768b439470a47b36d261656eee304","contributionContentSha256":"bd977049bf0a11e91f79d4e7622ed81ade043dbde987edb1daa0ac64ba143e04","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:54cda38b1d3dd8fc25523524cb7c349214c9e8c2cf7db96808d6ef3923373080","textSha256":"aab2bef6e016412a06639c748e2631c1292b8d176dea5fe993227f6a6c3966eb"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6e209919365c2dc9d986bcbb","recordId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Links a distinct formation route to network percolation; no symmetry-breaking transition is required by this proposed route.","challengeNote":"Formation and percolation are linked targets. The proposed route starts with isolated loops and does not require a symmetry-breaking transition.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"efa5c1a920e64399c8f11cbdb4fbc491bee1178781e74601c37798c3e2717bf4"},"organizational-access:2f123ca141bd97db9bee403f":{"id":"organizational-access:2f123ca141bd97db9bee403f","source":"q025-candidate-question:8b5f26f30de0d7cefebdb35c","target":"q025-candidate-question:6ae71c68694413dbe5762262","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8b5f26f30de0d7cefebdb35c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"39cfc1128a73323caad8e7144f46d182027f7666b001dfe9dc615f561cfe77f0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b3e70ec151f204be3d6a3a32"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6ae71c68694413dbe5762262","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"519d2882b8c5dd3f7d69ed01242a7023ccf630a42ddc9c30f5f77636a3e987dc","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:4212937434b73a0310a05e39"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:8e5c5554af6775f98a05e3a2939e55c5b69c696c4b65a4959508d21281b6f986","home":{"unitId":"unit:8e5c5554af6775f98a05e3a2939e55c5b69c696c4b65a4959508d21281b6f986","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8b5f26f30de0d7cefebdb35c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers pre-Swampland geometric restrictions, scalar and axion EFTs, inflationary comparisons and consequences for EFT validity.","qualification":"q15 covers both the pre-Swampland geometric comparison and the resulting EFT, inflation and axion constraints. Nongravitational theories remain comparison systems; their inclusion does not impose gravitational completion on them. The whole conjunction is more fully specified here than in q9's geometric agenda.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8e5c5554af6775f98a05e3a2939e55c5b69c696c4b65a4959508d21281b6f986","paperId":"hep-th/0605264","textSha256":"dfd53ee60ef297c0cc775549138483544407525936ec9ceff3467d53f6a6a387"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0034:u14:q15"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0034:u14:q15","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8e5c5554af6775f98a05e3a2939e55c5b69c696c4b65a4959508d21281b6f986","q025-candidate-question:8b5f26f30de0d7cefebdb35c"],"scopeContentSha256":"39cfc1128a73323caad8e7144f46d182027f7666b001dfe9dc615f561cfe77f0","placementContentSha256":"5971dba3101f8620ca50bac9be8ffa72c3e9544956941e21a0504043d6a3f0d4","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0034:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0034:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8e5c5554af6775f98a05e3a2939e55c5b69c696c4b65a4959508d21281b6f986","paperId":"hep-th/0605264","textSha256":"dfd53ee60ef297c0cc775549138483544407525936ec9ceff3467d53f6a6a387"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0034","unitRef":"u14"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8e5c5554af6775f98a05e3a2939e55c5b69c696c4b65a4959508d21281b6f986","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6ae71c68694413dbe5762262","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:8e5c5554af6775f98a05e3a2939e55c5b69c696c4b65a4959508d21281b6f986","textSha256":"dfd53ee60ef297c0cc775549138483544407525936ec9ceff3467d53f6a6a387"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:89266d39de39afbd5b9f2881","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Nongravitational theories are comparison systems; moduli geometry and EFT/inflation/axion consequences remain compound. Independent challenge qualification: Nongravitational theories are comparison systems; geometric restrictions and EFT, inflation and axion consequences remain compound."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:89266d39de39afbd5b9f2881","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8e5c5554af6775f98a05e3a2939e55c5b69c696c4b65a4959508d21281b6f986","q025-candidate-question:6ae71c68694413dbe5762262"],"scopeContentSha256":"519d2882b8c5dd3f7d69ed01242a7023ccf630a42ddc9c30f5f77636a3e987dc","contributionContentSha256":"efdb6587e1d14d1139d7070bfe4d99b19821a370ff390a70bada5dbb4cc83815","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b93dba7f3b569b6b854f-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b93dba7f3b569b6b854f-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b93dba7f3b569b6b854f-proposal","leaf-b93dba7f3b569b6b854f-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:8e5c5554af6775f98a05e3a2939e55c5b69c696c4b65a4959508d21281b6f986","textSha256":"dfd53ee60ef297c0cc775549138483544407525936ec9ceff3467d53f6a6a387"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:89266d39de39afbd5b9f2881","recordId":"leaf-b93dba7f3b569b6b854f-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b93dba7f3b569b6b854f-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b93dba7f3b569b6b854f-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Nongravitational theories are comparison systems; moduli geometry and EFT/inflation/axion consequences remain compound.","challengeNote":"Nongravitational theories are comparison systems; geometric restrictions and EFT, inflation and axion consequences remain compound.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"28b66f99879f8d970e0d9a8af7cb938f9f16da7527e90bfe173ca27422781836"},"organizational-access:2800e33e983f53d7ff507872":{"id":"organizational-access:2800e33e983f53d7ff507872","source":"q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef","target":"q025-candidate-question:6ac02a667323a234d6246b3f","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"aa5be41770333084b6014c6ea4ebee7f07d662ac4b16a425057f660d33e7713e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d4c1f7c6dcceb1c95c37b70e"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6ac02a667323a234d6246b3f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"78bf7f471c1adaf6c27bee6e9d9d8119f1ee41f17bd8a6b454a6a0b29d7a4d31","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5d247ad98bdc316b1e17b54a"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:00c8aea7b3d85c617d98ea6c84f77baed556a4e8af571802ec1d539537d76135","home":{"unitId":"unit:00c8aea7b3d85c617d98ea6c84f77baed556a4e8af571802ec1d539537d76135","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":0.5,"reason":"Covers the same model's conditional field-excursion and future-acceleration restrictions.","qualification":"Remove redundant q8; empirical expansion/growth and conditional excursion/duration tests cover the source. Exact full challenge coverage and source-local qualifications remain binding. Weights are organizational allocation, not confidence or physical importance.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:00c8aea7b3d85c617d98ea6c84f77baed556a4e8af571802ec1d539537d76135","paperId":"2007.06425","textSha256":"99667721208798ac6b4b69c73d10f46c307e57fbdcc3f56bb5f14485db0be809"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0057:u28:q9","coverageMode":"explicit_compound_union","targetCoverage":[{"sourceSpan":"Can derivative interactions reconcile an order-one potential slope with observed late-time expansion","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:fcb286e899efd10f36b8794c"],"explanation":"q17 covers scalar-model predictions of expansion histories and their empirical tests. The derivative interaction and order-one slope specify the model being tested; no canonical slope criterion is imported."},{"sourceSpan":"and does that same model survive a linear-growth comparison?","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:fcb286e899efd10f36b8794c"],"explanation":"q17 explicitly covers linear growth and preserves its independence from background agreement for the same model."},{"sourceSpan":"The paper tests these questions together with conjectural restrictions on field excursions and future accelerated expansion.","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:fcb286e899efd10f36b8794c","q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef"],"explanation":"q17 retains the preceding expansion and growth tests, while q9 supplies the additional conditional excursion and future-duration filters. All tests remain linked to one unchanged source question and model."}],"coverageReason":"q17 covers the complete empirical question about the specified derivative model, including how its dynamics predicts the expansion being compared; q9 covers the additional conjectural restrictions. q8 is a valid mechanism neighbor but adds no otherwise uncovered source target to this union. q17 alone lacks the conjectural filters, q9 lacks the growth comparison, and q8 alone lacks the full test program. No supplied whole composite home covers all tests. The two-home union requires separate coordinator scrutiny."},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0057:u28:q9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:00c8aea7b3d85c617d98ea6c84f77baed556a4e8af571802ec1d539537d76135","q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef"],"scopeContentSha256":"aa5be41770333084b6014c6ea4ebee7f07d662ac4b16a425057f660d33e7713e","placementContentSha256":"c2995f4cb6a7b8192a65703e32a5f55406486895133d09189c0c4293566ba979","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0057:proposal","explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0057:challenge","root:explicit-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:00c8aea7b3d85c617d98ea6c84f77baed556a4e8af571802ec1d539537d76135","paperId":"2007.06425","textSha256":"99667721208798ac6b4b69c73d10f46c307e57fbdcc3f56bb5f14485db0be809"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"45cd7c1d060cb6f2fd1d8a4ace5cca7c3d64df235a869afc4ce7e31b2e6badfb"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0057","unitRef":"u28"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:00c8aea7b3d85c617d98ea6c84f77baed556a4e8af571802ec1d539537d76135","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6ac02a667323a234d6246b3f","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:00c8aea7b3d85c617d98ea6c84f77baed556a4e8af571802ec1d539537d76135","textSha256":"99667721208798ac6b4b69c73d10f46c307e57fbdcc3f56bb5f14485db0be809"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:64f26f1a57a3039296210893"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:64f26f1a57a3039296210893","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:00c8aea7b3d85c617d98ea6c84f77baed556a4e8af571802ec1d539537d76135","q025-candidate-question:6ac02a667323a234d6246b3f"],"scopeContentSha256":"78bf7f471c1adaf6c27bee6e9d9d8119f1ee41f17bd8a6b454a6a0b29d7a4d31","contributionContentSha256":"b9f21f2242e59056d2371077f2cb4cffdf27edce6af01ea0ad9aeef9d6e987e0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:00c8aea7b3d85c617d98ea6c84f77baed556a4e8af571802ec1d539537d76135","textSha256":"99667721208798ac6b4b69c73d10f46c307e57fbdcc3f56bb5f14485db0be809"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:64f26f1a57a3039296210893","recordId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound background, linear-growth, excursion and future-duration tests remain distinct contributions.","challengeNote":"Background, linear growth, excursions and future acceleration restrictions are compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","home":{"unitId":"unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":0.5,"reason":"Covers unresolved string-theoretic and EFT conditions on the tachyon condensate's late-acceleration application.","qualification":"Canonical and tachyonic reconstructions are alternatives and string viability remains open. Exact full challenge coverage and source-local qualifications remain binding. Weights are organizational allocation, not confidence or physical importance.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","paperId":"hep-th/0204150","textSha256":"afd0795a9e2e19594ae4cef73ab21eaf024b41881d89541ded920d362f0a3ac1"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0057:u26:q9","coverageMode":"explicit_compound_union","targetCoverage":[{"sourceSpan":"How can a prescribed expansion history a(t) determine a canonical or tachyonic scalar potential","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:e375e3a777fbccf230745197"],"explanation":"Both alternative inverse reconstructions fit q16; they are not combined into one scalar action."},{"sourceSpan":"and under what unresolved string-theoretic conditions could a tachyon condensate produce late accelerated expansion?","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef"],"explanation":"q9 covers the conditional string-inspired consistency and open-application target without asserting that the required conditions are satisfied."}],"coverageReason":"q16 covers both alternative reconstructions; q9 covers the unresolved string-theoretic conditions on the tachyon application. q16 alone lacks the string-consistency target, q9 lacks the complete inverse problem, and q8 lacks the canonical reconstruction alternative. No supplied single home covers all parts. The union preserves one source question and keeps the string conditions open."},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0057:u26:q9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef"],"scopeContentSha256":"aa5be41770333084b6014c6ea4ebee7f07d662ac4b16a425057f660d33e7713e","placementContentSha256":"f551f5bfa978c87ba96610732674e497a761ff9133f7cbfe611317c2c4abbf0d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0057:proposal","explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0057:challenge","root:explicit-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","paperId":"hep-th/0204150","textSha256":"afd0795a9e2e19594ae4cef73ab21eaf024b41881d89541ded920d362f0a3ac1"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"45cd7c1d060cb6f2fd1d8a4ace5cca7c3d64df235a869afc4ce7e31b2e6badfb"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0057","unitRef":"u26"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6ac02a667323a234d6246b3f","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d96","kind":"description","unitIndex":96,"unitId":"unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","textSha256":"afd0795a9e2e19594ae4cef73ab21eaf024b41881d89541ded920d362f0a3ac1"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:54eb0e69c61e02ab4bdfdb85"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:54eb0e69c61e02ab4bdfdb85","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","q025-candidate-question:6ac02a667323a234d6246b3f"],"scopeContentSha256":"78bf7f471c1adaf6c27bee6e9d9d8119f1ee41f17bd8a6b454a6a0b29d7a4d31","contributionContentSha256":"91a67b0e2bc07aa663dcdfeeebea3939ef3234a82f75aff56ad2fe05824e7f00","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d96","kind":"description","unitIndex":96,"unitId":"unit:8ea1f156b44db08e6bbabbdb96a5bcbffd0519ceba6a59b685252fdc8cd89fe6","textSha256":"afd0795a9e2e19594ae4cef73ab21eaf024b41881d89541ded920d362f0a3ac1"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:54eb0e69c61e02ab4bdfdb85","recordId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound reconstruction and unresolved string/tachyon viability targets; canonical and tachyonic reconstructions are alternatives.","challengeNote":"Canonical/tachyonic reconstruction alternatives and unresolved string conditions are distinct contributions of a compound source question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"8b9d6389e66fc0a05436dbff9266d338cc7558df0a6ead0e9ce7caff05ae62c9"},"organizational-access:544b9d0cb015a3d3ffc2f193":{"id":"organizational-access:544b9d0cb015a3d3ffc2f193","source":"q025-candidate-question:a3368d6f982c0769f831d924","target":"q025-candidate-question:690efd65319fe5597ecdd907","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a3368d6f982c0769f831d924","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"752ffeafc6ecfb7233431a943f67cf0fe82c1f9881be5b8bb76ef08e7ec50607","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:a95bb2d8bafa49daf11f63f9"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:690efd65319fe5597ecdd907","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"bdd6a7d473169a9e34f827f8b90f463bf0500e59fdfc5cbafdb21020c6bdc9e3","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:01591ad62e3bcceae03dea48"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1ec134bf9e80cf29bfe0d57c40fa095ba7d11c974e816c4d4e0bfdd194b507b8","home":{"unitId":"unit:1ec134bf9e80cf29bfe0d57c40fa095ba7d11c974e816c4d4e0bfdd194b507b8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a3368d6f982c0769f831d924","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Directly combines scalar-tensor slow-roll and spectral compatibility, source-imposed conjectural cuts and subsequent reheating histories.","qualification":"q25 explicitly joins slow-roll and spectral compatibility, source-imposed conjectural cuts and reheating expansion for the specified scalar-tensor ansätze. Three-ansatz and restricted-overlap qualifications remain inherited. The unspecified operator, absent replacement support item, unresolved inequality transcription and truncated reheating conclusion do not prevent target coverage; no action, repaired inequality or preferred equation of state is inferred. Nonminimal coupling and passing cuts establish neither an attractor mechanism nor a UV completion.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1ec134bf9e80cf29bfe0d57c40fa095ba7d11c974e816c4d4e0bfdd194b507b8","paperId":"2011.13957","textSha256":"b7d290885063046464434232c92c26b293a3027075e7db8d07622ff7a5dfbc46"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0060:u23:q25"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0060:u23:q25","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1ec134bf9e80cf29bfe0d57c40fa095ba7d11c974e816c4d4e0bfdd194b507b8","q025-candidate-question:a3368d6f982c0769f831d924"],"scopeContentSha256":"752ffeafc6ecfb7233431a943f67cf0fe82c1f9881be5b8bb76ef08e7ec50607","placementContentSha256":"ebcf86adf33fed3e0d046521e67d4e4451e1c75a49d8bf084048f0e4cb65bab0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0060:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0060:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1ec134bf9e80cf29bfe0d57c40fa095ba7d11c974e816c4d4e0bfdd194b507b8","paperId":"2011.13957","textSha256":"b7d290885063046464434232c92c26b293a3027075e7db8d07622ff7a5dfbc46"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0060","unitRef":"u23"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1ec134bf9e80cf29bfe0d57c40fa095ba7d11c974e816c4d4e0bfdd194b507b8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:690efd65319fe5597ecdd907","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:1ec134bf9e80cf29bfe0d57c40fa095ba7d11c974e816c4d4e0bfdd194b507b8","textSha256":"b7d290885063046464434232c92c26b293a3027075e7db8d07622ff7a5dfbc46"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ffbfd8ffbe49e3b62a24298c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ffbfd8ffbe49e3b62a24298c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1ec134bf9e80cf29bfe0d57c40fa095ba7d11c974e816c4d4e0bfdd194b507b8","q025-candidate-question:690efd65319fe5597ecdd907"],"scopeContentSha256":"bdd6a7d473169a9e34f827f8b90f463bf0500e59fdfc5cbafdb21020c6bdc9e3","contributionContentSha256":"fa7f9bbaf048254aafd7d4731f751fb587166b8c6da1fbbba10aaba116a73586","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-proposal","leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:1ec134bf9e80cf29bfe0d57c40fa095ba7d11c974e816c4d4e0bfdd194b507b8","textSha256":"b7d290885063046464434232c92c26b293a3027075e7db8d07622ff7a5dfbc46"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ffbfd8ffbe49e3b62a24298c","recordId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The gravitational operator is unspecified, and inflationary tests and effective reheating histories are separate targets.","challengeNote":"The curvature operator is unspecified; inflationary tests and effective reheating histories require separate fine reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"5a4b892c0419f1b84f6b4ee44f5e256eb8a771e467f80abaf25e133f0ee9f9bb"},"organizational-access:bd991fb0c43815fa4b7e84b4":{"id":"organizational-access:bd991fb0c43815fa4b7e84b4","source":"q025-candidate-question:c8d3fbad94a53baf0bffa5fe","target":"q025-candidate-question:ec49be4276e71be9401e1ebf","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c8d3fbad94a53baf0bffa5fe","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f7430a79135a075918a8b8c5a36e49171220d4afdbc32fc8013808dfdedb6c71","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:115ae331388d0d35c031e408"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ec49be4276e71be9401e1ebf","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f94eb81dc5bbdc92b45e85dba14326a4776fe8a10f9beec23d9d2fca13bd0062","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:72c623b578b912e7731d770b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:7b4dc81132bb3052c56b0c5a7251f1ffae6a361b10b9fbc7c70f7820583286ef","home":{"unitId":"unit:7b4dc81132bb3052c56b0c5a7251f1ffae6a361b10b9fbc7c70f7820583286ef","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c8d3fbad94a53baf0bffa5fe","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers the proposed Euclidean dS/CFT dictionary, dS3 central charge, scalar correlators and time/past-future boundary encoding in global and observer-region descriptions.","qualification":"q18 directly names every target and the global/observer-region distinction. It preserves the proposal's single Euclidean CFT, antipodal boundary relation and sphere/plane descriptions, with possible nonunitarity and complex conformal weights. The two asymptotic boundaries are not made into independent Hilbert spaces, and the supporting calculations do not certify a complete nonperturbative dual.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7b4dc81132bb3052c56b0c5a7251f1ffae6a361b10b9fbc7c70f7820583286ef","paperId":"hep-th/0106113","textSha256":"b9bd881d8caefd628155e2060fa86b6ae03437ca2dbbe0eb56bb531876122c90"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0016:u18:q18"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0016:u18:q18","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7b4dc81132bb3052c56b0c5a7251f1ffae6a361b10b9fbc7c70f7820583286ef","q025-candidate-question:c8d3fbad94a53baf0bffa5fe"],"scopeContentSha256":"f7430a79135a075918a8b8c5a36e49171220d4afdbc32fc8013808dfdedb6c71","placementContentSha256":"a859a3e7090499fe15b3e7c20a6cd9efde1a32c4a2d81d4caa56782a9e6fe514","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0016:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0016:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7b4dc81132bb3052c56b0c5a7251f1ffae6a361b10b9fbc7c70f7820583286ef","paperId":"hep-th/0106113","textSha256":"b9bd881d8caefd628155e2060fa86b6ae03437ca2dbbe0eb56bb531876122c90"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0016","unitRef":"u18"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7b4dc81132bb3052c56b0c5a7251f1ffae6a361b10b9fbc7c70f7820583286ef","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ec49be4276e71be9401e1ebf","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:7b4dc81132bb3052c56b0c5a7251f1ffae6a361b10b9fbc7c70f7820583286ef","textSha256":"b9bd881d8caefd628155e2060fa86b6ae03437ca2dbbe0eb56bb531876122c90"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1d8376ae13f5e26b1cd0454429119f94","paperId":"hep-th/0106113","sourceSha256":"5b49d823a5f827d02b749d86ed0d3bd30cc0d76de00f5892f805cb9be42f4a3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/825074dbbb7353e27425/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a98aa8ed01f0b986c1722fb8b6ee4adb22dc799678e20e1fbcf767998e4c8a91","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1307,"textSha256":"1548cf43a06e6d993f8a8ac89d3daaff12b32b178ab106b67eb61256a535a2ea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:56715cf08145715e2100ceac9680c669","paperId":"hep-th/0106113","sourceSha256":"5b49d823a5f827d02b749d86ed0d3bd30cc0d76de00f5892f805cb9be42f4a3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/825074dbbb7353e27425/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a98aa8ed01f0b986c1722fb8b6ee4adb22dc799678e20e1fbcf767998e4c8a91","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2822,"textSha256":"0f171ed7879c1540c88048700aaf9ebc7e4e8080dba79ddec0bf882089526314","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:aa3db1edbcd90cbfa3c7974932a61a41","paperId":"hep-th/0106113","sourceSha256":"5b49d823a5f827d02b749d86ed0d3bd30cc0d76de00f5892f805cb9be42f4a3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/825074dbbb7353e27425/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a98aa8ed01f0b986c1722fb8b6ee4adb22dc799678e20e1fbcf767998e4c8a91","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":1307,"textSha256":"5e4383264567da331f914c1fbbce0fa84983c5398ba431293e5c86e1b79b8c28","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:53b437996f142f717bb6b949","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: v2, 2001-07-12. Compound central-charge, scalar-correlator and time-encoding targets; a single Euclidean CFT is proposed, allowing nonunitarity and complex weak Independent challenge qualification: v2, 2001-07-12. Compound symmetry, correlator and time-encoding targets. One Euclidean CFT is proposed, allowing nonunitarity and complex weights."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:53b437996f142f717bb6b949","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7b4dc81132bb3052c56b0c5a7251f1ffae6a361b10b9fbc7c70f7820583286ef","q025-candidate-question:ec49be4276e71be9401e1ebf"],"scopeContentSha256":"f94eb81dc5bbdc92b45e85dba14326a4776fe8a10f9beec23d9d2fca13bd0062","contributionContentSha256":"33a2a7b9926fd4c84ebb4caabc1470e7c88dd68119a65f1a43feb137684d6b3f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-proposal","leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:7b4dc81132bb3052c56b0c5a7251f1ffae6a361b10b9fbc7c70f7820583286ef","textSha256":"b9bd881d8caefd628155e2060fa86b6ae03437ca2dbbe0eb56bb531876122c90"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1d8376ae13f5e26b1cd0454429119f94","paperId":"hep-th/0106113","sourceSha256":"5b49d823a5f827d02b749d86ed0d3bd30cc0d76de00f5892f805cb9be42f4a3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/825074dbbb7353e27425/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a98aa8ed01f0b986c1722fb8b6ee4adb22dc799678e20e1fbcf767998e4c8a91","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1307,"textSha256":"1548cf43a06e6d993f8a8ac89d3daaff12b32b178ab106b67eb61256a535a2ea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:56715cf08145715e2100ceac9680c669","paperId":"hep-th/0106113","sourceSha256":"5b49d823a5f827d02b749d86ed0d3bd30cc0d76de00f5892f805cb9be42f4a3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/825074dbbb7353e27425/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a98aa8ed01f0b986c1722fb8b6ee4adb22dc799678e20e1fbcf767998e4c8a91","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2822,"textSha256":"0f171ed7879c1540c88048700aaf9ebc7e4e8080dba79ddec0bf882089526314","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:aa3db1edbcd90cbfa3c7974932a61a41","paperId":"hep-th/0106113","sourceSha256":"5b49d823a5f827d02b749d86ed0d3bd30cc0d76de00f5892f805cb9be42f4a3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/825074dbbb7353e27425/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a98aa8ed01f0b986c1722fb8b6ee4adb22dc799678e20e1fbcf767998e4c8a91","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":1307,"textSha256":"5e4383264567da331f914c1fbbce0fa84983c5398ba431293e5c86e1b79b8c28","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:53b437996f142f717bb6b949","recordId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"v2, 2001-07-12. Compound central-charge, scalar-correlator and time-encoding targets; a single Euclidean CFT is proposed, allowing nonunitarity and complex weak","challengeNote":"v2, 2001-07-12. Compound symmetry, correlator and time-encoding targets. One Euclidean CFT is proposed, allowing nonunitarity and complex weights.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"beff9b872946b87df41051855beb96f6f402a6b0cbb09b8e19b5360550372179"},"organizational-access:fd52c7261ae8df42d9405cc1":{"id":"organizational-access:fd52c7261ae8df42d9405cc1","source":"q025-candidate-question:d278dee3cabc44b2a5a5b903","target":"q025-candidate-question:3b2ffb19b08e6266baa77ef1","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:d278dee3cabc44b2a5a5b903","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"86abbe39269e3ae85bd3c84ec47cb43ff2df53355056fece705dff66b1b0c7bb","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:02ea01fc5df465cb1c3f6dd6"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3b2ffb19b08e6266baa77ef1","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"3c52142d4ee0fdbf39117cb77f0231a2ac15bb685f50bac24435ab75182f46ea","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:835389d513594c713e84a405"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:41d1ca0724c03cb538f50fbac06aa67b347b37c36696a7ffce0556532c4ca7c1","home":{"unitId":"unit:41d1ca0724c03cb538f50fbac06aa67b347b37c36696a7ffce0556532c4ca7c1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d278dee3cabc44b2a5a5b903","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"This source addresses a question within this scoped destination. Its specific system, regime and source-reading limits remain attached; membership does not equate the source statement with the broader question.","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:41d1ca0724c03cb538f50fbac06aa67b347b37c36696a7ffce0556532c4ca7c1","textSha256":"39cd554480c182a7b8d6bccb75342f8fedb012c62abe7a11758552baa5d70b80"}],"decisionId":"decision:organizational-home:82b5538eb074194c6a321f46"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:organizational-home:82b5538eb074194c6a321f46","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:41d1ca0724c03cb538f50fbac06aa67b347b37c36696a7ffce0556532c4ca7c1","q025-candidate-question:d278dee3cabc44b2a5a5b903"],"scopeContentSha256":"86abbe39269e3ae85bd3c84ec47cb43ff2df53355056fece705dff66b1b0c7bb","placementContentSha256":"c841e0fdcd392f52d48678e19a51aa742d1c53b384c498dd1f1038ce5b6358ec","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../../evaluation/full-pass/home-admissions-v1/home-policy-admission.json","sha256":"275fd7dc27c397141cee2737c967e070cf75df3c6446f8d5c2e2a3e7cc79d740"}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3968a809d18ddb47d873-proposal","leaf-3968a809d18ddb47d873-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:41d1ca0724c03cb538f50fbac06aa67b347b37c36696a7ffce0556532c4ca7c1","textSha256":"39cd554480c182a7b8d6bccb75342f8fedb012c62abe7a11758552baa5d70b80"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"decisionId":"decision:organizational-home:82b5538eb074194c6a321f46","sourceContributionDecisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5f72656cccb58b182ced36e7","sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3968a809d18ddb47d873-proposal","leaf-3968a809d18ddb47d873-challenge"],"reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3968a809d18ddb47d873-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3968a809d18ddb47d873-challenge"},"sourceDescriptionSha256":"39cd554480c182a7b8d6bccb75342f8fedb012c62abe7a11758552baa5d70b80","sourceScopeContentSha256":"86abbe39269e3ae85bd3c84ec47cb43ff2df53355056fece705dff66b1b0c7bb","originalNotesSha256":{"proposal":"618061477a398e07992c1c41610ad55eb24315cc951ebc2785ffa9660667cdf1","challenge":"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855"},"evidenceAgreementIsNotOriginalPlacementAgreement":true}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:41d1ca0724c03cb538f50fbac06aa67b347b37c36696a7ffce0556532c4ca7c1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3b2ffb19b08e6266baa77ef1","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d49","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:41d1ca0724c03cb538f50fbac06aa67b347b37c36696a7ffce0556532c4ca7c1","textSha256":"39cd554480c182a7b8d6bccb75342f8fedb012c62abe7a11758552baa5d70b80"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:59bd71388b0fc65f664da49316c2e8e4","paperId":"1601.04068","sourceSha256":"99babfe1ee6af7dfb6c8ab10051caec5142f5847ca6c85e8d422a12d5a29f18f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8b4406b23ec487035dd1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d58788bc5a71eb1d8ba4ad7037f9d00be2fff734242ffff43d92db7015f1a54","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3032,"textSha256":"bf0cc42957d324ac8b2f1feff3c6932ca717218a3ebf13c9ac8a1116c2fa64ee","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6d6497cb9721f3858438cd4034c6a653","paperId":"1601.04068","sourceSha256":"99babfe1ee6af7dfb6c8ab10051caec5142f5847ca6c85e8d422a12d5a29f18f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8b4406b23ec487035dd1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d58788bc5a71eb1d8ba4ad7037f9d00be2fff734242ffff43d92db7015f1a54","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1265,"textSha256":"f8751097b56c205827612a3e9801edcaec18a43b47e053be1d2016c961c0c6b1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d094db18f2949793a53ec784faf591ac","paperId":"1601.04068","sourceSha256":"99babfe1ee6af7dfb6c8ab10051caec5142f5847ca6c85e8d422a12d5a29f18f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8b4406b23ec487035dd1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d58788bc5a71eb1d8ba4ad7037f9d00be2fff734242ffff43d92db7015f1a54","pdfPage":3,"start":1293,"end":3032,"textSha256":"1748935bf1c00c244debfe97b30b2002b0cd41abb41deb12c3e160c8491c7779","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a3a4e5170791107175266277","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The isolated Galileon and full tensor/vector/scalar multiplet differ; an allowed forward-positivity region is not a constructed ultraviolet completion. Independent challenge qualification: The full tensor/vector/scalar multiplet differs from its isolated Galileon limit; a permitted forward-positivity region is not a constructed UV completion."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a3a4e5170791107175266277","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:41d1ca0724c03cb538f50fbac06aa67b347b37c36696a7ffce0556532c4ca7c1","q025-candidate-question:3b2ffb19b08e6266baa77ef1"],"scopeContentSha256":"3c52142d4ee0fdbf39117cb77f0231a2ac15bb685f50bac24435ab75182f46ea","contributionContentSha256":"d707b3630c57dbe4f5a48b2caae26661314d2e535c29e91bc1232e36bf7a4d44","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-proposal","successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d49","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:41d1ca0724c03cb538f50fbac06aa67b347b37c36696a7ffce0556532c4ca7c1","textSha256":"39cd554480c182a7b8d6bccb75342f8fedb012c62abe7a11758552baa5d70b80"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:59bd71388b0fc65f664da49316c2e8e4","paperId":"1601.04068","sourceSha256":"99babfe1ee6af7dfb6c8ab10051caec5142f5847ca6c85e8d422a12d5a29f18f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8b4406b23ec487035dd1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d58788bc5a71eb1d8ba4ad7037f9d00be2fff734242ffff43d92db7015f1a54","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3032,"textSha256":"bf0cc42957d324ac8b2f1feff3c6932ca717218a3ebf13c9ac8a1116c2fa64ee","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6d6497cb9721f3858438cd4034c6a653","paperId":"1601.04068","sourceSha256":"99babfe1ee6af7dfb6c8ab10051caec5142f5847ca6c85e8d422a12d5a29f18f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8b4406b23ec487035dd1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d58788bc5a71eb1d8ba4ad7037f9d00be2fff734242ffff43d92db7015f1a54","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1265,"textSha256":"f8751097b56c205827612a3e9801edcaec18a43b47e053be1d2016c961c0c6b1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d094db18f2949793a53ec784faf591ac","paperId":"1601.04068","sourceSha256":"99babfe1ee6af7dfb6c8ab10051caec5142f5847ca6c85e8d422a12d5a29f18f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8b4406b23ec487035dd1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d58788bc5a71eb1d8ba4ad7037f9d00be2fff734242ffff43d92db7015f1a54","pdfPage":3,"start":1293,"end":3032,"textSha256":"1748935bf1c00c244debfe97b30b2002b0cd41abb41deb12c3e160c8491c7779","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a3a4e5170791107175266277","recordId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The isolated Galileon and full tensor/vector/scalar multiplet differ; an allowed forward-positivity region is not a constructed ultraviolet completion.","challengeNote":"The full tensor/vector/scalar multiplet differs from its isolated Galileon limit; a permitted forward-positivity region is not a constructed UV completion.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"56ffaba239db0ef99a97f324681a6d8a513d46589ae694f38e268dc2ba120ef6"},"organizational-access:f5dfccbebcc4aeae7ee7992d":{"id":"organizational-access:f5dfccbebcc4aeae7ee7992d","source":"q025-candidate-question:f0194c1ae166dcb82da0a36c","target":"q025-candidate-question:1e054f13da2f935229dadc46","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f0194c1ae166dcb82da0a36c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"897066c5a268c07da1de571c5e2a0a9de192f9e8ec524f3533cf9f87446c1cac","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d09afb7475a800f4c6f049af"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1e054f13da2f935229dadc46","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a23917bb50d43772259e1a85fe72f277f26e9af298a2e19eebbe66176c2cf839","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d91d8f7fef98ca105ba86405"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:2b01ba5e21cab3e12bf5afa37dccf7e4bee97447b291fd23ada4e331f1abb0d7","home":{"unitId":"unit:2b01ba5e21cab3e12bf5afa37dccf7e4bee97447b291fd23ada4e331f1abb0d7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f0194c1ae166dcb82da0a36c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"This source addresses a question within this scoped destination. Its specific system, regime and source-reading limits remain attached; membership does not equate the source statement with the broader question.","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:2b01ba5e21cab3e12bf5afa37dccf7e4bee97447b291fd23ada4e331f1abb0d7","textSha256":"33971826a788a038630bcea3078bf908514e9a1e83c3cee5c41f9f72e41f4b5a"},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d437f0229a4619aa270319d8cb4bcea3","paperId":"2112.09136","sourceSha256":"dc8878cdc8ca9a771ff8329dc453e7df09d55909adcc978afcadc1afbd1421da","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62fd134d418a652d1c92/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b08bfe36e6db6292c73b932f66e847025251fd2004a460c83bcd8c23008c4ea7","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"8c987a815488cb1b0d4d20fa5396de63b654a04ab906009b022ea86086a91b4d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e17c6d3844427507003d6efd6720ddcf","paperId":"2112.09136","sourceSha256":"dc8878cdc8ca9a771ff8329dc453e7df09d55909adcc978afcadc1afbd1421da","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62fd134d418a652d1c92/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b08bfe36e6db6292c73b932f66e847025251fd2004a460c83bcd8c23008c4ea7","pdfPage":2,"start":94,"end":3492,"textSha256":"f1e1c1a43de10766f1c432c1aac6f1394d7833ce805fa6cada9af57041aa1ddc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:organizational-home:4a5ce88db3eafed532e219d4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:organizational-home:4a5ce88db3eafed532e219d4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2b01ba5e21cab3e12bf5afa37dccf7e4bee97447b291fd23ada4e331f1abb0d7","q025-candidate-question:f0194c1ae166dcb82da0a36c"],"scopeContentSha256":"897066c5a268c07da1de571c5e2a0a9de192f9e8ec524f3533cf9f87446c1cac","placementContentSha256":"6ab43040594181c53444d2c1e0dc57f8c98452ed39d081238feaeeee4154070d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../../evaluation/full-pass/home-admissions-v1/home-policy-admission.json","sha256":"275fd7dc27c397141cee2737c967e070cf75df3c6446f8d5c2e2a3e7cc79d740"}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-proposal","leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:2b01ba5e21cab3e12bf5afa37dccf7e4bee97447b291fd23ada4e331f1abb0d7","textSha256":"33971826a788a038630bcea3078bf908514e9a1e83c3cee5c41f9f72e41f4b5a"},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d437f0229a4619aa270319d8cb4bcea3","paperId":"2112.09136","sourceSha256":"dc8878cdc8ca9a771ff8329dc453e7df09d55909adcc978afcadc1afbd1421da","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62fd134d418a652d1c92/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b08bfe36e6db6292c73b932f66e847025251fd2004a460c83bcd8c23008c4ea7","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"8c987a815488cb1b0d4d20fa5396de63b654a04ab906009b022ea86086a91b4d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e17c6d3844427507003d6efd6720ddcf","paperId":"2112.09136","sourceSha256":"dc8878cdc8ca9a771ff8329dc453e7df09d55909adcc978afcadc1afbd1421da","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62fd134d418a652d1c92/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b08bfe36e6db6292c73b932f66e847025251fd2004a460c83bcd8c23008c4ea7","pdfPage":2,"start":94,"end":3492,"textSha256":"f1e1c1a43de10766f1c432c1aac6f1394d7833ce805fa6cada9af57041aa1ddc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"decisionId":"decision:organizational-home:4a5ce88db3eafed532e219d4","sourceContributionDecisionId":"decision:source-contribution:87bf23df1afa863680819f9f","sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-proposal","leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge"],"reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge"},"sourceDescriptionSha256":"33971826a788a038630bcea3078bf908514e9a1e83c3cee5c41f9f72e41f4b5a","sourceScopeContentSha256":"897066c5a268c07da1de571c5e2a0a9de192f9e8ec524f3533cf9f87446c1cac","originalNotesSha256":{"proposal":"c11a6169099bc4fdbe76bc8aa561b0e3980b74933292f443b772047f29449f5a","challenge":"b1aead753bb516ee81902467b23c1600454ae5de87e79a22e2999421e1434d39"},"evidenceAgreementIsNotOriginalPlacementAgreement":true}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2b01ba5e21cab3e12bf5afa37dccf7e4bee97447b291fd23ada4e331f1abb0d7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1e054f13da2f935229dadc46","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d51","kind":"description","unitIndex":51,"unitId":"unit:2b01ba5e21cab3e12bf5afa37dccf7e4bee97447b291fd23ada4e331f1abb0d7","textSha256":"33971826a788a038630bcea3078bf908514e9a1e83c3cee5c41f9f72e41f4b5a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:155187e097c06a9d8f97de08"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:155187e097c06a9d8f97de08","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2b01ba5e21cab3e12bf5afa37dccf7e4bee97447b291fd23ada4e331f1abb0d7","q025-candidate-question:1e054f13da2f935229dadc46"],"scopeContentSha256":"a23917bb50d43772259e1a85fe72f277f26e9af298a2e19eebbe66176c2cf839","contributionContentSha256":"c9553bd658b47c2eef67709201266cb1f7f715d675bd0ad26af6a87bee0d9942","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d51","kind":"description","unitIndex":51,"unitId":"unit:2b01ba5e21cab3e12bf5afa37dccf7e4bee97447b291fd23ada4e331f1abb0d7","textSha256":"33971826a788a038630bcea3078bf908514e9a1e83c3cee5c41f9f72e41f4b5a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:155187e097c06a9d8f97de08","recordId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The membrane-at-KK-scale limit is tested for exclusion, not assumed to exist.","challengeNote":"The membrane-at-KK-scale limit is tested for exclusion, not assumed to be realized.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"3c92bc47b5a45299dd3e3ddf2f61e5574993221e600639918677df73f45904cf"},"organizational-access:4220cc3850ee7582900d5ec2":{"id":"organizational-access:4220cc3850ee7582900d5ec2","source":"q025-candidate-region:06c60531ff0fab4aba38db33","target":"q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:06c60531ff0fab4aba38db33","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"4f1271ffaaf2ec89b80cfd50cb919538cee9ed78a2085024b0c45ac85a383fae","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:53911f887aac9d75132febe4"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"178cf1202434c4b1d5b58290da6d05bcf17995eb49ac448f688f7a3335610bda","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3e14a2fa7e4cffb149733aad"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:7d7db3b220f6f0730f5c0f579a88d6d58024ee834b7e8378d10e9dfc3ef20643","home":{"unitId":"unit:7d7db3b220f6f0730f5c0f579a88d6d58024ee834b7e8378d10e9dfc3ef20643","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:06c60531ff0fab4aba38db33","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7d7db3b220f6f0730f5c0f579a88d6d58024ee834b7e8378d10e9dfc3ef20643","paperId":"2511.20458","textSha256":"659d24947d920ffe74c19a6dd4d3eb1bd678d10c4b46d50316b3609700c48100"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3a93a3547e04f097a2e90ef0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3a93a3547e04f097a2e90ef0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7d7db3b220f6f0730f5c0f579a88d6d58024ee834b7e8378d10e9dfc3ef20643","q025-candidate-region:06c60531ff0fab4aba38db33"],"scopeContentSha256":"4f1271ffaaf2ec89b80cfd50cb919538cee9ed78a2085024b0c45ac85a383fae","placementContentSha256":"fd831de300a5978df6cbba7ebdd1d827ac55b71a6808606882eff8ffeebd4ed5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-challenge","leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7d7db3b220f6f0730f5c0f579a88d6d58024ee834b7e8378d10e9dfc3ef20643","paperId":"2511.20458","textSha256":"659d24947d920ffe74c19a6dd4d3eb1bd678d10c4b46d50316b3609700c48100"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3a93a3547e04f097a2e90ef0"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7d7db3b220f6f0730f5c0f579a88d6d58024ee834b7e8378d10e9dfc3ef20643","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:7d7db3b220f6f0730f5c0f579a88d6d58024ee834b7e8378d10e9dfc3ef20643","textSha256":"659d24947d920ffe74c19a6dd4d3eb1bd678d10c4b46d50316b3609700c48100"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:048ba595750131407ae82c3b","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: Spectra, couplings and experimental constraints are compound targets; no current exclusion is established."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:048ba595750131407ae82c3b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7d7db3b220f6f0730f5c0f579a88d6d58024ee834b7e8378d10e9dfc3ef20643","q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090"],"scopeContentSha256":"178cf1202434c4b1d5b58290da6d05bcf17995eb49ac448f688f7a3335610bda","contributionContentSha256":"c7ececed1fce63c9b28a9212b0863be08068793bab2b4be67d5faf58c38a8cca","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-proposal","leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:7d7db3b220f6f0730f5c0f579a88d6d58024ee834b7e8378d10e9dfc3ef20643","textSha256":"659d24947d920ffe74c19a6dd4d3eb1bd678d10c4b46d50316b3609700c48100"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:048ba595750131407ae82c3b","recordId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"Spectra, couplings and experimental constraints are compound targets; no current exclusion is established.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:bd4d3d077ee56820ace10d371071f7ee96abdf05efd8e352b8c2ec02bd76e4dc","home":{"unitId":"unit:bd4d3d077ee56820ace10d371071f7ee96abdf05efd8e352b8c2ec02bd76e4dc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:06c60531ff0fab4aba38db33","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bd4d3d077ee56820ace10d371071f7ee96abdf05efd8e352b8c2ec02bd76e4dc","paperId":"1603.02145","textSha256":"7a72a1c641d8a94d03d2166ce603ab2208369f4e436a7470ba5bc99b86b4249b"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bdc8c6b8935d12c5f804ee095504c5a2","paperId":"1603.02145","sourceSha256":"7ca8b64f1a2e6d5e5f88298d6c4f642a74af2838b4c1ee3c1a146a9ecd687469","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b58ac1c00f4ffeeeb3e5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c2ac8dc13c92c80c92f06cc160d4cc7c693dbf7fd8f0b93cd121de403ea6e52f","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"85e23d3947c6f5b411ba7d0dfc38c09efa7f04166b30d9e022702a730b1e22a9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c504a6ae37b41e97a32fd7faa01950bd","paperId":"1603.02145","sourceSha256":"7ca8b64f1a2e6d5e5f88298d6c4f642a74af2838b4c1ee3c1a146a9ecd687469","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b58ac1c00f4ffeeeb3e5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c2ac8dc13c92c80c92f06cc160d4cc7c693dbf7fd8f0b93cd121de403ea6e52f","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2431,"textSha256":"bb9fa3e46a20036d3fa3ea0182b2639f589c2d95cd62e16802ca7399ae67d4b9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e20a11ddf36b5b71aa476726e5bdd885","paperId":"1603.02145","sourceSha256":"7ca8b64f1a2e6d5e5f88298d6c4f642a74af2838b4c1ee3c1a146a9ecd687469","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b58ac1c00f4ffeeeb3e5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c2ac8dc13c92c80c92f06cc160d4cc7c693dbf7fd8f0b93cd121de403ea6e52f","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2970,"textSha256":"38f905d64e7fcf3af55fa61cbb424e58c471f7e902dd5ad56d8aa107ec27ab6c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:21ab15d15032970f861924aa"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:21ab15d15032970f861924aa","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bd4d3d077ee56820ace10d371071f7ee96abdf05efd8e352b8c2ec02bd76e4dc","q025-candidate-region:06c60531ff0fab4aba38db33"],"scopeContentSha256":"4f1271ffaaf2ec89b80cfd50cb919538cee9ed78a2085024b0c45ac85a383fae","placementContentSha256":"152fd5904dfa0cfd36135adbb5e39ea0ad43cdce58b86a8414d09b982bed6a10","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-challenge","leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bd4d3d077ee56820ace10d371071f7ee96abdf05efd8e352b8c2ec02bd76e4dc","paperId":"1603.02145","textSha256":"7a72a1c641d8a94d03d2166ce603ab2208369f4e436a7470ba5bc99b86b4249b"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bdc8c6b8935d12c5f804ee095504c5a2","paperId":"1603.02145","sourceSha256":"7ca8b64f1a2e6d5e5f88298d6c4f642a74af2838b4c1ee3c1a146a9ecd687469","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b58ac1c00f4ffeeeb3e5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c2ac8dc13c92c80c92f06cc160d4cc7c693dbf7fd8f0b93cd121de403ea6e52f","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"85e23d3947c6f5b411ba7d0dfc38c09efa7f04166b30d9e022702a730b1e22a9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c504a6ae37b41e97a32fd7faa01950bd","paperId":"1603.02145","sourceSha256":"7ca8b64f1a2e6d5e5f88298d6c4f642a74af2838b4c1ee3c1a146a9ecd687469","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b58ac1c00f4ffeeeb3e5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c2ac8dc13c92c80c92f06cc160d4cc7c693dbf7fd8f0b93cd121de403ea6e52f","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2431,"textSha256":"bb9fa3e46a20036d3fa3ea0182b2639f589c2d95cd62e16802ca7399ae67d4b9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e20a11ddf36b5b71aa476726e5bdd885","paperId":"1603.02145","sourceSha256":"7ca8b64f1a2e6d5e5f88298d6c4f642a74af2838b4c1ee3c1a146a9ecd687469","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b58ac1c00f4ffeeeb3e5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c2ac8dc13c92c80c92f06cc160d4cc7c693dbf7fd8f0b93cd121de403ea6e52f","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2970,"textSha256":"38f905d64e7fcf3af55fa61cbb424e58c471f7e902dd5ad56d8aa107ec27ab6c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:21ab15d15032970f861924aa"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bd4d3d077ee56820ace10d371071f7ee96abdf05efd8e352b8c2ec02bd76e4dc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:bd4d3d077ee56820ace10d371071f7ee96abdf05efd8e352b8c2ec02bd76e4dc","textSha256":"7a72a1c641d8a94d03d2166ce603ab2208369f4e436a7470ba5bc99b86b4249b"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bdc8c6b8935d12c5f804ee095504c5a2","paperId":"1603.02145","sourceSha256":"7ca8b64f1a2e6d5e5f88298d6c4f642a74af2838b4c1ee3c1a146a9ecd687469","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b58ac1c00f4ffeeeb3e5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c2ac8dc13c92c80c92f06cc160d4cc7c693dbf7fd8f0b93cd121de403ea6e52f","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"85e23d3947c6f5b411ba7d0dfc38c09efa7f04166b30d9e022702a730b1e22a9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c504a6ae37b41e97a32fd7faa01950bd","paperId":"1603.02145","sourceSha256":"7ca8b64f1a2e6d5e5f88298d6c4f642a74af2838b4c1ee3c1a146a9ecd687469","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b58ac1c00f4ffeeeb3e5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c2ac8dc13c92c80c92f06cc160d4cc7c693dbf7fd8f0b93cd121de403ea6e52f","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2431,"textSha256":"bb9fa3e46a20036d3fa3ea0182b2639f589c2d95cd62e16802ca7399ae67d4b9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e20a11ddf36b5b71aa476726e5bdd885","paperId":"1603.02145","sourceSha256":"7ca8b64f1a2e6d5e5f88298d6c4f642a74af2838b4c1ee3c1a146a9ecd687469","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b58ac1c00f4ffeeeb3e5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c2ac8dc13c92c80c92f06cc160d4cc7c693dbf7fd8f0b93cd121de403ea6e52f","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2970,"textSha256":"38f905d64e7fcf3af55fa61cbb424e58c471f7e902dd5ad56d8aa107ec27ab6c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0f36da79649d536c63547f3a","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0f36da79649d536c63547f3a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bd4d3d077ee56820ace10d371071f7ee96abdf05efd8e352b8c2ec02bd76e4dc","q025-candidate-question:075d3209836689311abde090"],"scopeContentSha256":"178cf1202434c4b1d5b58290da6d05bcf17995eb49ac448f688f7a3335610bda","contributionContentSha256":"5f1af43b8ab596f3419cd2126389bf6d4c4664bf6532a8956bcdd877f92f7466","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-proposal","leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:bd4d3d077ee56820ace10d371071f7ee96abdf05efd8e352b8c2ec02bd76e4dc","textSha256":"7a72a1c641d8a94d03d2166ce603ab2208369f4e436a7470ba5bc99b86b4249b"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bdc8c6b8935d12c5f804ee095504c5a2","paperId":"1603.02145","sourceSha256":"7ca8b64f1a2e6d5e5f88298d6c4f642a74af2838b4c1ee3c1a146a9ecd687469","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b58ac1c00f4ffeeeb3e5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c2ac8dc13c92c80c92f06cc160d4cc7c693dbf7fd8f0b93cd121de403ea6e52f","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"85e23d3947c6f5b411ba7d0dfc38c09efa7f04166b30d9e022702a730b1e22a9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c504a6ae37b41e97a32fd7faa01950bd","paperId":"1603.02145","sourceSha256":"7ca8b64f1a2e6d5e5f88298d6c4f642a74af2838b4c1ee3c1a146a9ecd687469","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b58ac1c00f4ffeeeb3e5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c2ac8dc13c92c80c92f06cc160d4cc7c693dbf7fd8f0b93cd121de403ea6e52f","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2431,"textSha256":"bb9fa3e46a20036d3fa3ea0182b2639f589c2d95cd62e16802ca7399ae67d4b9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e20a11ddf36b5b71aa476726e5bdd885","paperId":"1603.02145","sourceSha256":"7ca8b64f1a2e6d5e5f88298d6c4f642a74af2838b4c1ee3c1a146a9ecd687469","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b58ac1c00f4ffeeeb3e5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c2ac8dc13c92c80c92f06cc160d4cc7c693dbf7fd8f0b93cd121de403ea6e52f","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2970,"textSha256":"38f905d64e7fcf3af55fa61cbb424e58c471f7e902dd5ad56d8aa107ec27ab6c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0f36da79649d536c63547f3a","recordId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"97f8c2a2aca1e545e526992b11037eab69c144a8ac3aa0f49ea8a1bc4d8cb402"},"organizational-access:28b612c04e08aad8f0c9f21c":{"id":"organizational-access:28b612c04e08aad8f0c9f21c","source":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","target":"q025-candidate-question:5bfbf57a25426c653b9178d4","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:feb098a3c2dcad34f29a5e6f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:5bfbf57a25426c653b9178d4","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6a368d3790b7d4a582b6b02c15f244023c3a8dcfbb2ebe6e727bacefa102508d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:20729000a8b82875c9f32ae9"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:d24f7d346a3f287079d21166bf233ec06a1f6b0f5d13eb226e33d44b8ed45500","home":{"unitId":"unit:d24f7d346a3f287079d21166bf233ec06a1f6b0f5d13eb226e33d44b8ed45500","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d24f7d346a3f287079d21166bf233ec06a1f6b0f5d13eb226e33d44b8ed45500","paperId":"2103.06276","textSha256":"33a9aaacbd502dccc7c6d5bd2cd69cb9f1f53bdcff7551df1882dbd10c42c71e"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3b2f1bbf5eda7535a4e8bf9f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3b2f1bbf5eda7535a4e8bf9f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d24f7d346a3f287079d21166bf233ec06a1f6b0f5d13eb226e33d44b8ed45500","q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9"],"scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","placementContentSha256":"4ab07649f8d5af67a7a4285c03521239967460e4607b10aad6e0aef1e8383b01","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d24f7d346a3f287079d21166bf233ec06a1f6b0f5d13eb226e33d44b8ed45500","paperId":"2103.06276","textSha256":"33a9aaacbd502dccc7c6d5bd2cd69cb9f1f53bdcff7551df1882dbd10c42c71e"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3b2f1bbf5eda7535a4e8bf9f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d24f7d346a3f287079d21166bf233ec06a1f6b0f5d13eb226e33d44b8ed45500","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:5bfbf57a25426c653b9178d4","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:d24f7d346a3f287079d21166bf233ec06a1f6b0f5d13eb226e33d44b8ed45500","textSha256":"33a9aaacbd502dccc7c6d5bd2cd69cb9f1f53bdcff7551df1882dbd10c42c71e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fbd2d806d83e4b2b0ed38250"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:fbd2d806d83e4b2b0ed38250","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d24f7d346a3f287079d21166bf233ec06a1f6b0f5d13eb226e33d44b8ed45500","q025-candidate-question:5bfbf57a25426c653b9178d4"],"scopeContentSha256":"6a368d3790b7d4a582b6b02c15f244023c3a8dcfbb2ebe6e727bacefa102508d","contributionContentSha256":"b1bce8b150bc4dd6794e1ec779c02e8bdb9a7bc3c516b24bbb06e85dfc32b906","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:d24f7d346a3f287079d21166bf233ec06a1f6b0f5d13eb226e33d44b8ed45500","textSha256":"33a9aaacbd502dccc7c6d5bd2cd69cb9f1f53bdcff7551df1882dbd10c42c71e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fbd2d806d83e4b2b0ed38250","recordId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Related primary text is supplied for another facet; this row retains a description-only reading basis.","challengeNote":"Primary excerpts attached to the neighboring setting do not change this row's description-only basis.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f7977419ee3cbdecd2553d0cd09ae49e94a91e17e08d3cc8c29eae28d618005e","home":{"unitId":"unit:f7977419ee3cbdecd2553d0cd09ae49e94a91e17e08d3cc8c29eae28d618005e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f7977419ee3cbdecd2553d0cd09ae49e94a91e17e08d3cc8c29eae28d618005e","paperId":"hep-th/0106276","textSha256":"ffbb1771dca3530fb2c32b208f5f257e010d2288dfe514ad7a8349f23a74c8a3"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:00c825f969077bf345a9ba81"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:00c825f969077bf345a9ba81","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f7977419ee3cbdecd2553d0cd09ae49e94a91e17e08d3cc8c29eae28d618005e","q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9"],"scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","placementContentSha256":"4ea3a0c9097c8b50c078bce83e23141dacd45c9c88813a3940d0206b0016e33d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f7977419ee3cbdecd2553d0cd09ae49e94a91e17e08d3cc8c29eae28d618005e","paperId":"hep-th/0106276","textSha256":"ffbb1771dca3530fb2c32b208f5f257e010d2288dfe514ad7a8349f23a74c8a3"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:00c825f969077bf345a9ba81"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f7977419ee3cbdecd2553d0cd09ae49e94a91e17e08d3cc8c29eae28d618005e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:5bfbf57a25426c653b9178d4","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d43","kind":"description","unitIndex":43,"unitId":"unit:f7977419ee3cbdecd2553d0cd09ae49e94a91e17e08d3cc8c29eae28d618005e","textSha256":"ffbb1771dca3530fb2c32b208f5f257e010d2288dfe514ad7a8349f23a74c8a3"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dbe5aca9c32ee83be72420d1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:dbe5aca9c32ee83be72420d1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f7977419ee3cbdecd2553d0cd09ae49e94a91e17e08d3cc8c29eae28d618005e","q025-candidate-question:5bfbf57a25426c653b9178d4"],"scopeContentSha256":"6a368d3790b7d4a582b6b02c15f244023c3a8dcfbb2ebe6e727bacefa102508d","contributionContentSha256":"0d3f117f3c0b604f10ec36a81868cbcb9b0c48bbe01484606d8d94cb3e9e7810","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d43","kind":"description","unitIndex":43,"unitId":"unit:f7977419ee3cbdecd2553d0cd09ae49e94a91e17e08d3cc8c29eae28d618005e","textSha256":"ffbb1771dca3530fb2c32b208f5f257e010d2288dfe514ad7a8349f23a74c8a3"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dbe5aca9c32ee83be72420d1","recordId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound eternal-acceleration/scattering and stabilized-vacuum-probe questions; no common observable construction is presumed.","challengeNote":"Eternal acceleration, gauge-invariant scattering and access to stabilized vacua form a compound question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"849a805ad416f58428c6e2ece9b100f738c30bd282e9741b61c7ee52ef4ef633"},"organizational-access:c3af80dbdcec4be75c79125a":{"id":"organizational-access:c3af80dbdcec4be75c79125a","source":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","target":"q025-candidate-question:c507c726c5fc2dc93257af9b","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:feb098a3c2dcad34f29a5e6f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c507c726c5fc2dc93257af9b","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ff082eba89e991cfca8f13420d2b7e028100cae1f22f17389bbbc6b729b1d238","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d6090789e7f9fee194f10a87"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:57cb08354df122bb918a3945bd7dbb4bb6c04b34487c566ab47159de19b7d8a8","home":{"unitId":"unit:57cb08354df122bb918a3945bd7dbb4bb6c04b34487c566ab47159de19b7d8a8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:57cb08354df122bb918a3945bd7dbb4bb6c04b34487c566ab47159de19b7d8a8","paperId":"2406.07614","textSha256":"b11be62ac098434bb5773787b6ac920fc20ed62d926b67e41e1747274e12bfa4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fac4a5041b23612ac02996d7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fac4a5041b23612ac02996d7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:57cb08354df122bb918a3945bd7dbb4bb6c04b34487c566ab47159de19b7d8a8","q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9"],"scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","placementContentSha256":"04877856aeb9103f85414f26ad47ce34b8ece9c4c5bebd2d0b1002f47bac53a6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:57cb08354df122bb918a3945bd7dbb4bb6c04b34487c566ab47159de19b7d8a8","paperId":"2406.07614","textSha256":"b11be62ac098434bb5773787b6ac920fc20ed62d926b67e41e1747274e12bfa4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fac4a5041b23612ac02996d7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:57cb08354df122bb918a3945bd7dbb4bb6c04b34487c566ab47159de19b7d8a8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c507c726c5fc2dc93257af9b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:57cb08354df122bb918a3945bd7dbb4bb6c04b34487c566ab47159de19b7d8a8","textSha256":"b11be62ac098434bb5773787b6ac920fc20ed62d926b67e41e1747274e12bfa4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ae53510144d3b5e3576f4065"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ae53510144d3b5e3576f4065","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:57cb08354df122bb918a3945bd7dbb4bb6c04b34487c566ab47159de19b7d8a8","q025-candidate-question:c507c726c5fc2dc93257af9b"],"scopeContentSha256":"ff082eba89e991cfca8f13420d2b7e028100cae1f22f17389bbbc6b729b1d238","contributionContentSha256":"6977fd9f50139a9eda27b34582074ae26cc6b2ef8f8e7d32b2fb551fabe5da58","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:57cb08354df122bb918a3945bd7dbb4bb6c04b34487c566ab47159de19b7d8a8","textSha256":"b11be62ac098434bb5773787b6ac920fc20ed62d926b67e41e1747274e12bfa4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ae53510144d3b5e3576f4065","recordId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Temporary trapping, acceleration and controlled embedding are separate requirements.","challengeNote":"Temporary stabilization, acceleration and controlled embedding remain separate requirements.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b021ddf8f06bba44c0f1521fc2c1da12f0dc4a2f6f2678339c3649b522bdb810","home":{"unitId":"unit:b021ddf8f06bba44c0f1521fc2c1da12f0dc4a2f6f2678339c3649b522bdb810","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b021ddf8f06bba44c0f1521fc2c1da12f0dc4a2f6f2678339c3649b522bdb810","paperId":"1005.3735","textSha256":"2e356e8aa44c94d7e7eab13f84fed492bff434f9703aea148d21793190acdb89"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:612be38c0ede911b3194d689"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:612be38c0ede911b3194d689","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b021ddf8f06bba44c0f1521fc2c1da12f0dc4a2f6f2678339c3649b522bdb810","q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9"],"scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","placementContentSha256":"d303e9cce0ddcc5464be61b53d4e45830254b38a102750ecbced2c8d6c45c1db","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b021ddf8f06bba44c0f1521fc2c1da12f0dc4a2f6f2678339c3649b522bdb810","paperId":"1005.3735","textSha256":"2e356e8aa44c94d7e7eab13f84fed492bff434f9703aea148d21793190acdb89"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:612be38c0ede911b3194d689"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b021ddf8f06bba44c0f1521fc2c1da12f0dc4a2f6f2678339c3649b522bdb810","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c507c726c5fc2dc93257af9b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:b021ddf8f06bba44c0f1521fc2c1da12f0dc4a2f6f2678339c3649b522bdb810","textSha256":"2e356e8aa44c94d7e7eab13f84fed492bff434f9703aea148d21793190acdb89"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f864ca8e427f96ed25fd705c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f864ca8e427f96ed25fd705c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b021ddf8f06bba44c0f1521fc2c1da12f0dc4a2f6f2678339c3649b522bdb810","q025-candidate-question:c507c726c5fc2dc93257af9b"],"scopeContentSha256":"ff082eba89e991cfca8f13420d2b7e028100cae1f22f17389bbbc6b729b1d238","contributionContentSha256":"694e22efecce28cf86dd0e11b6acceeb2da256a450fe51ac26f6e82f7048b143","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:b021ddf8f06bba44c0f1521fc2c1da12f0dc4a2f6f2678339c3649b522bdb810","textSha256":"2e356e8aa44c94d7e7eab13f84fed492bff434f9703aea148d21793190acdb89"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f864ca8e427f96ed25fd705c","recordId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound dark-energy, local-test and structure-formation targets retained in one source-scoped access point.","challengeNote":"Compound dark-energy, local-test and structure-formation targets; the finite coupling minimum is distinct from a potential minimum.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","home":{"unitId":"unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","paperId":"2412.02630","textSha256":"61e8d336c9b31b0112a8ca83d698d6c58e8df5ebe450204911b8e598ad210cc1"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ae1cbf516f8ebf07c0559772"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ae1cbf516f8ebf07c0559772","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9"],"scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","placementContentSha256":"3148d1d630a55ba44f3b33dd72db2df27226c51546bc1550160c990fa7fd10c1","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","paperId":"2412.02630","textSha256":"61e8d336c9b31b0112a8ca83d698d6c58e8df5ebe450204911b8e598ad210cc1"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ae1cbf516f8ebf07c0559772"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c507c726c5fc2dc93257af9b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","textSha256":"61e8d336c9b31b0112a8ca83d698d6c58e8df5ebe450204911b8e598ad210cc1"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9a369f32208b44e76c9f0927"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9a369f32208b44e76c9f0927","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","q025-candidate-question:c507c726c5fc2dc93257af9b"],"scopeContentSha256":"ff082eba89e991cfca8f13420d2b7e028100cae1f22f17389bbbc6b729b1d238","contributionContentSha256":"0dfb14f753df658001bb7de7c3ca4a186a5b0051e5a864570b312ee8dacef85f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","textSha256":"61e8d336c9b31b0112a8ca83d698d6c58e8df5ebe450204911b8e598ad210cc1"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9a369f32208b44e76c9f0927","recordId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Material compound targets: acceleration, effective stabilization, matter gravity and bounces. Source-scoped access does not establish atomicity.","challengeNote":"Compound acceleration, effective stabilization, modified matter gravity and bounce targets; singleton access does not assert atomicity.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"61884834c3fe6d5ae74bc1c42bd995ef17f4b43b605bc8cd94d6a5c0258be7f3"},"organizational-access:a889477b5c5de7f9e4eb2ee0":{"id":"organizational-access:a889477b5c5de7f9e4eb2ee0","source":"q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f","target":"q025-candidate-question:78f3617807c684358cebb301","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"07f03ce1ff096f6decad953599d2576bf2a2c64f0201272a3a194992b5aa3bf5","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:704e11df59f0bb80f98be66e"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:78f3617807c684358cebb301","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"2f186155862c06c75cbbbf8f1420113a65095a58d46847450789684a87d9e0a5","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:453c8da473aa68881390af69"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:c2cbcf859ba196c41ba47dd002dfac017ca9988f1af068ca26ac57b3cc1183a3","home":{"unitId":"unit:c2cbcf859ba196c41ba47dd002dfac017ca9988f1af068ca26ac57b3cc1183a3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q25 covers the six-dimensional geometry/anomaly/vacuum organization together with limiting regimes and associated lower-dimensional theories.","qualification":"q25 provides a complete composite home for the lecture-scale organization of six-dimensional vacua through anomalies, geometry, dualities and transitions, together with the explicitly included lower-dimensional descendants. Conjectured dualities remain conjectural, and a duality map is not identified with a physical transition.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c2cbcf859ba196c41ba47dd002dfac017ca9988f1af068ca26ac57b3cc1183a3","paperId":"hep-th/9707075","textSha256":"27ae244c55ca85e60d53e0d4bb4e95d8f32d904a28b01387183d7111fb149d99"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0027:u19:q25"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0027:u19:q25","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c2cbcf859ba196c41ba47dd002dfac017ca9988f1af068ca26ac57b3cc1183a3","q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f"],"scopeContentSha256":"07f03ce1ff096f6decad953599d2576bf2a2c64f0201272a3a194992b5aa3bf5","placementContentSha256":"d18f778268f8bbabd5586071fc206d59628fc39c954a6dc2c236f60fa6b674c6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0027:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0027:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c2cbcf859ba196c41ba47dd002dfac017ca9988f1af068ca26ac57b3cc1183a3","paperId":"hep-th/9707075","textSha256":"27ae244c55ca85e60d53e0d4bb4e95d8f32d904a28b01387183d7111fb149d99"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0027","unitRef":"u19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c2cbcf859ba196c41ba47dd002dfac017ca9988f1af068ca26ac57b3cc1183a3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:78f3617807c684358cebb301","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d92","kind":"description","unitIndex":92,"unitId":"unit:c2cbcf859ba196c41ba47dd002dfac017ca9988f1af068ca26ac57b3cc1183a3","textSha256":"27ae244c55ca85e60d53e0d4bb4e95d8f32d904a28b01387183d7111fb149d99"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5edd4df0d62dd40b34962398f5e84d5a","paperId":"hep-th/9707075","sourceSha256":"6b12ddeb80c86d06decbad1e038ec31087ab313a7b6692bf28f2d1ba304d5710","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4a3e96f07d68cfbd2638/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7701963f0705b4d2573d93343834ea61dfa38a58e29bc3e1ca4083517fff2d98","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":898,"textSha256":"755a4c19e3f77e9897d322e88f9dbb5edeb7c8af83401db3330e33d80790fee3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a7a41eae4b4b8388c1c758bf0558132e","paperId":"hep-th/9707075","sourceSha256":"6b12ddeb80c86d06decbad1e038ec31087ab313a7b6692bf28f2d1ba304d5710","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4a3e96f07d68cfbd2638/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7701963f0705b4d2573d93343834ea61dfa38a58e29bc3e1ca4083517fff2d98","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2009,"textSha256":"3fef8229932b93af8a264174fb03296611e4ddda1ae8c7c9a4595472f8eb5668","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c1a63ec8a098a97d3fcd60b3741022c2","paperId":"hep-th/9707075","sourceSha256":"6b12ddeb80c86d06decbad1e038ec31087ab313a7b6692bf28f2d1ba304d5710","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4a3e96f07d68cfbd2638/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7701963f0705b4d2573d93343834ea61dfa38a58e29bc3e1ca4083517fff2d98","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2455,"textSha256":"144916ca66d6237d3cf62c24d4d70b2b655cef9cb70710fceea974fb9e509178","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cfb77373716c7ff60872b2c1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:cfb77373716c7ff60872b2c1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c2cbcf859ba196c41ba47dd002dfac017ca9988f1af068ca26ac57b3cc1183a3","q025-candidate-question:78f3617807c684358cebb301"],"scopeContentSha256":"2f186155862c06c75cbbbf8f1420113a65095a58d46847450789684a87d9e0a5","contributionContentSha256":"7148a12c031a5d8168adc07919d5915445e7d19288f453ed1a16bb289733d62a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3de3f7d3229146ca8e58-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3de3f7d3229146ca8e58-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3de3f7d3229146ca8e58-proposal","leaf-3de3f7d3229146ca8e58-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d92","kind":"description","unitIndex":92,"unitId":"unit:c2cbcf859ba196c41ba47dd002dfac017ca9988f1af068ca26ac57b3cc1183a3","textSha256":"27ae244c55ca85e60d53e0d4bb4e95d8f32d904a28b01387183d7111fb149d99"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5edd4df0d62dd40b34962398f5e84d5a","paperId":"hep-th/9707075","sourceSha256":"6b12ddeb80c86d06decbad1e038ec31087ab313a7b6692bf28f2d1ba304d5710","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4a3e96f07d68cfbd2638/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7701963f0705b4d2573d93343834ea61dfa38a58e29bc3e1ca4083517fff2d98","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":898,"textSha256":"755a4c19e3f77e9897d322e88f9dbb5edeb7c8af83401db3330e33d80790fee3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a7a41eae4b4b8388c1c758bf0558132e","paperId":"hep-th/9707075","sourceSha256":"6b12ddeb80c86d06decbad1e038ec31087ab313a7b6692bf28f2d1ba304d5710","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4a3e96f07d68cfbd2638/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7701963f0705b4d2573d93343834ea61dfa38a58e29bc3e1ca4083517fff2d98","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2009,"textSha256":"3fef8229932b93af8a264174fb03296611e4ddda1ae8c7c9a4595472f8eb5668","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c1a63ec8a098a97d3fcd60b3741022c2","paperId":"hep-th/9707075","sourceSha256":"6b12ddeb80c86d06decbad1e038ec31087ab313a7b6692bf28f2d1ba304d5710","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4a3e96f07d68cfbd2638/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7701963f0705b4d2573d93343834ea61dfa38a58e29bc3e1ca4083517fff2d98","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2455,"textSha256":"144916ca66d6237d3cf62c24d4d70b2b655cef9cb70710fceea974fb9e509178","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cfb77373716c7ff60872b2c1","recordId":"leaf-3de3f7d3229146ca8e58-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3de3f7d3229146ca8e58-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3de3f7d3229146ca8e58-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"The 8 July 1997 v1 lectures retain six-dimensional N=1 and derived four-dimensional N=2 scopes; their pre-Swampland date is no exclusion.","challengeNote":"The 8 July 1997 v1 lectures retain six-dimensional N=1 and derived four-dimensional N=2 scopes. Their broader motivations do not establish four-dimensional N=","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"1a68ed527c8b43d487a2a648d8f5d586fcbe095577b5679bb22b69d43c4fac76"},"organizational-access:e9decadd34d71c981a90865c":{"id":"organizational-access:e9decadd34d71c981a90865c","source":"q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba","target":"q025-candidate-question:2c61283813c36fc170920977","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"0a5f2902a138407a2d1d797db99ca0cacf6a1300be5f62e2b680c9224bc88037","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:69f329ffc7e943d81c657aef"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:2c61283813c36fc170920977","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"04b66200bf26d68ca9ca765d48145a9208113172c4f64f881fe8e5817d4c5a7a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1bacd09d7b9766b5ae81648c"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","home":{"unitId":"unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","paperId":"0712.2859","textSha256":"98bd5a83f4714e1f96215725578c3da50945911b03fb378b583073669c44fc3a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0203491080da4677b950c638"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0203491080da4677b950c638","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba"],"scopeContentSha256":"0a5f2902a138407a2d1d797db99ca0cacf6a1300be5f62e2b680c9224bc88037","placementContentSha256":"50a18c59fd358c8bda8113a46c496585b26ca8ef5d58defbc8ffe72fcfbd2056","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","paperId":"0712.2859","textSha256":"98bd5a83f4714e1f96215725578c3da50945911b03fb378b583073669c44fc3a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0203491080da4677b950c638"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2c61283813c36fc170920977","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","textSha256":"98bd5a83f4714e1f96215725578c3da50945911b03fb378b583073669c44fc3a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ce1bd9b03c02bfd78eec7c8a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ce1bd9b03c02bfd78eec7c8a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","q025-candidate-question:2c61283813c36fc170920977"],"scopeContentSha256":"04b66200bf26d68ca9ca765d48145a9208113172c4f64f881fe8e5817d4c5a7a","contributionContentSha256":"e6b2b4cd85a9b149fe30097868c7809f35fd44483d273edc29018da3665a7926","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:7a0e29c862497e9bd87dd2b933767b18e956cb00068c106d7d62582dcec169ec","textSha256":"98bd5a83f4714e1f96215725578c3da50945911b03fb378b583073669c44fc3a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ce1bd9b03c02bfd78eec7c8a","recordId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound cutoff and assisted-dynamics targets; no cutoff formula or compatibility result is supplied.","challengeNote":"Compound cutoff and assisted-inflation targets; their canonical decomposition remains open.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:fbe9ffbb6c4f33ed8c87fe92a0149f90e60cd7c6bf3759eddc83fc9d2d0a2bb1","home":{"unitId":"unit:fbe9ffbb6c4f33ed8c87fe92a0149f90e60cd7c6bf3759eddc83fc9d2d0a2bb1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fbe9ffbb6c4f33ed8c87fe92a0149f90e60cd7c6bf3759eddc83fc9d2d0a2bb1","paperId":"1811.01987","textSha256":"5d045aa1d53ef8eec76c005a44c89af7ddbf342e5ec93511b6fcfc2b0b3a09bf"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e5007f5dd986c0572c041d07"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e5007f5dd986c0572c041d07","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fbe9ffbb6c4f33ed8c87fe92a0149f90e60cd7c6bf3759eddc83fc9d2d0a2bb1","q025-candidate-region:2dcea686e639bc720cccb3ba"],"scopeContentSha256":"0a5f2902a138407a2d1d797db99ca0cacf6a1300be5f62e2b680c9224bc88037","placementContentSha256":"7eee254d1b0ec960e508ec14ae766215b11a08bdac1596645dea3977475adfaa","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fbe9ffbb6c4f33ed8c87fe92a0149f90e60cd7c6bf3759eddc83fc9d2d0a2bb1","paperId":"1811.01987","textSha256":"5d045aa1d53ef8eec76c005a44c89af7ddbf342e5ec93511b6fcfc2b0b3a09bf"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e5007f5dd986c0572c041d07"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fbe9ffbb6c4f33ed8c87fe92a0149f90e60cd7c6bf3759eddc83fc9d2d0a2bb1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2c61283813c36fc170920977","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:fbe9ffbb6c4f33ed8c87fe92a0149f90e60cd7c6bf3759eddc83fc9d2d0a2bb1","textSha256":"5d045aa1d53ef8eec76c005a44c89af7ddbf342e5ec93511b6fcfc2b0b3a09bf"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:65e0b6504bd242a80f4211d0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:65e0b6504bd242a80f4211d0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fbe9ffbb6c4f33ed8c87fe92a0149f90e60cd7c6bf3759eddc83fc9d2d0a2bb1","q025-candidate-question:2c61283813c36fc170920977"],"scopeContentSha256":"04b66200bf26d68ca9ca765d48145a9208113172c4f64f881fe8e5817d4c5a7a","contributionContentSha256":"ecad628bd5d497222aa0bd71f1aa6b0180b20a7aaba8e81cb2a4314334859b06","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:fbe9ffbb6c4f33ed8c87fe92a0149f90e60cd7c6bf3759eddc83fc9d2d0a2bb1","textSha256":"5d045aa1d53ef8eec76c005a44c89af7ddbf342e5ec93511b6fcfc2b0b3a09bf"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:65e0b6504bd242a80f4211d0","recordId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"7290219878075bda49d56e3b2c55dee63d7052aaa752471eef7c8e2b145ac448"},"organizational-access:2066670b119c5a8f5bed6414":{"id":"organizational-access:2066670b119c5a8f5bed6414","source":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","target":"q025-candidate-question:ba83a10fc3f76f6befff7e35","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"23ff9118dfec8a655b571ba9ace4d2116a06675da50b80f04409cfbcecc4a308","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d2d02e5e315cbf7b186130d1"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ba83a10fc3f76f6befff7e35","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c92f5f60c698d01431f10880b8599997e7cfd95b55443d8c80ce072ca3506834","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d2574f0a501e8772aa5c7317"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1b6fb30e1df872f7b97ac8ae392b8b9c0132bc9b200c2fae7abb7198d65fe204","home":{"unitId":"unit:1b6fb30e1df872f7b97ac8ae392b8b9c0132bc9b200c2fae7abb7198d65fe204","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1b6fb30e1df872f7b97ac8ae392b8b9c0132bc9b200c2fae7abb7198d65fe204","paperId":"2102.08951","textSha256":"e6da6e056b065f18efdd424c192ad01bbbdb0c7027b1db10c71f8a3922b81cab"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9ce0a8daacabaa37ba715433"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9ce0a8daacabaa37ba715433","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1b6fb30e1df872f7b97ac8ae392b8b9c0132bc9b200c2fae7abb7198d65fe204","q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8"],"scopeContentSha256":"23ff9118dfec8a655b571ba9ace4d2116a06675da50b80f04409cfbcecc4a308","placementContentSha256":"17188ac1afeef50f4a52642bdfddfd9428fc41a46f2a6fbc03da0ee45b9968be","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1b6fb30e1df872f7b97ac8ae392b8b9c0132bc9b200c2fae7abb7198d65fe204","paperId":"2102.08951","textSha256":"e6da6e056b065f18efdd424c192ad01bbbdb0c7027b1db10c71f8a3922b81cab"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9ce0a8daacabaa37ba715433"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1b6fb30e1df872f7b97ac8ae392b8b9c0132bc9b200c2fae7abb7198d65fe204","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ba83a10fc3f76f6befff7e35","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:1b6fb30e1df872f7b97ac8ae392b8b9c0132bc9b200c2fae7abb7198d65fe204","textSha256":"e6da6e056b065f18efdd424c192ad01bbbdb0c7027b1db10c71f8a3922b81cab"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9961d31e05031182bfe289ab"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9961d31e05031182bfe289ab","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1b6fb30e1df872f7b97ac8ae392b8b9c0132bc9b200c2fae7abb7198d65fe204","q025-candidate-question:ba83a10fc3f76f6befff7e35"],"scopeContentSha256":"c92f5f60c698d01431f10880b8599997e7cfd95b55443d8c80ce072ca3506834","contributionContentSha256":"b8630867437fe962394787441c75d2a947eca04cc22b64f437eeb3695ce10876","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:1b6fb30e1df872f7b97ac8ae392b8b9c0132bc9b200c2fae7abb7198d65fe204","textSha256":"e6da6e056b065f18efdd424c192ad01bbbdb0c7027b1db10c71f8a3922b81cab"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9961d31e05031182bfe289ab","recordId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Newton suppression is questioned; maximal supersymmetry is a special simplifying setting.","challengeNote":"Newton suppression is questioned; maximal supersymmetry supplies a special simplifying setting.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:37c4aaccf13c61864a10b036e86c7c7b8d7ce11963f56a9155f2d1329f627100","home":{"unitId":"unit:37c4aaccf13c61864a10b036e86c7c7b8d7ce11963f56a9155f2d1329f627100","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:37c4aaccf13c61864a10b036e86c7c7b8d7ce11963f56a9155f2d1329f627100","paperId":"2411.04857","textSha256":"7a08839cf596b825d7a22b2dfd532684bc1368ceea21cd3cdb0844abec3e109b"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:099dc3389088713fabe2f6404519babe","paperId":"2411.04857","sourceSha256":"784404db02faabbb0cf0a2729ad2ca850d2e8b6202d11c4a656d9e61ecba1420","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae15d331d7077e4798ab/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"25278c787781c2ded86f45d6a7fd61c5259cd9d0e1b730c10e08dbadaac9ae2b","pdfPage":1,"start":99,"end":3494,"textSha256":"d3ec212a344942565070d24180b79318ec155367d3b41709f59d6d4cd7a33ada","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8fe9f019d990588afa36cf6829551181","paperId":"2411.04857","sourceSha256":"784404db02faabbb0cf0a2729ad2ca850d2e8b6202d11c4a656d9e61ecba1420","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae15d331d7077e4798ab/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"25278c787781c2ded86f45d6a7fd61c5259cd9d0e1b730c10e08dbadaac9ae2b","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"80a402b9e80a2655dcd84bdba0e79ff087fb6c5c60c34d1de83e57dece19d50e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b2cf0402ff088b688be7119dd2958d63","paperId":"2411.04857","sourceSha256":"784404db02faabbb0cf0a2729ad2ca850d2e8b6202d11c4a656d9e61ecba1420","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae15d331d7077e4798ab/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"25278c787781c2ded86f45d6a7fd61c5259cd9d0e1b730c10e08dbadaac9ae2b","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"7a3a6c948cd7b0e89d5d87eb6061140505fc07d419c6c2f076e3bdc958e48f40","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b37f49e3b3fbfa079a7a5836"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b37f49e3b3fbfa079a7a5836","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:37c4aaccf13c61864a10b036e86c7c7b8d7ce11963f56a9155f2d1329f627100","q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8"],"scopeContentSha256":"23ff9118dfec8a655b571ba9ace4d2116a06675da50b80f04409cfbcecc4a308","placementContentSha256":"c54e7fe0aae30e19cf333ab9f146cbb7812f61525fd2bedb5a76ba41f8d58852","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:37c4aaccf13c61864a10b036e86c7c7b8d7ce11963f56a9155f2d1329f627100","paperId":"2411.04857","textSha256":"7a08839cf596b825d7a22b2dfd532684bc1368ceea21cd3cdb0844abec3e109b"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:099dc3389088713fabe2f6404519babe","paperId":"2411.04857","sourceSha256":"784404db02faabbb0cf0a2729ad2ca850d2e8b6202d11c4a656d9e61ecba1420","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae15d331d7077e4798ab/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"25278c787781c2ded86f45d6a7fd61c5259cd9d0e1b730c10e08dbadaac9ae2b","pdfPage":1,"start":99,"end":3494,"textSha256":"d3ec212a344942565070d24180b79318ec155367d3b41709f59d6d4cd7a33ada","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8fe9f019d990588afa36cf6829551181","paperId":"2411.04857","sourceSha256":"784404db02faabbb0cf0a2729ad2ca850d2e8b6202d11c4a656d9e61ecba1420","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae15d331d7077e4798ab/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"25278c787781c2ded86f45d6a7fd61c5259cd9d0e1b730c10e08dbadaac9ae2b","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"80a402b9e80a2655dcd84bdba0e79ff087fb6c5c60c34d1de83e57dece19d50e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b2cf0402ff088b688be7119dd2958d63","paperId":"2411.04857","sourceSha256":"784404db02faabbb0cf0a2729ad2ca850d2e8b6202d11c4a656d9e61ecba1420","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae15d331d7077e4798ab/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"25278c787781c2ded86f45d6a7fd61c5259cd9d0e1b730c10e08dbadaac9ae2b","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"7a3a6c948cd7b0e89d5d87eb6061140505fc07d419c6c2f076e3bdc958e48f40","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b37f49e3b3fbfa079a7a5836"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:37c4aaccf13c61864a10b036e86c7c7b8d7ce11963f56a9155f2d1329f627100","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ba83a10fc3f76f6befff7e35","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:37c4aaccf13c61864a10b036e86c7c7b8d7ce11963f56a9155f2d1329f627100","textSha256":"7a08839cf596b825d7a22b2dfd532684bc1368ceea21cd3cdb0844abec3e109b"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:099dc3389088713fabe2f6404519babe","paperId":"2411.04857","sourceSha256":"784404db02faabbb0cf0a2729ad2ca850d2e8b6202d11c4a656d9e61ecba1420","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae15d331d7077e4798ab/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"25278c787781c2ded86f45d6a7fd61c5259cd9d0e1b730c10e08dbadaac9ae2b","pdfPage":1,"start":99,"end":3494,"textSha256":"d3ec212a344942565070d24180b79318ec155367d3b41709f59d6d4cd7a33ada","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8fe9f019d990588afa36cf6829551181","paperId":"2411.04857","sourceSha256":"784404db02faabbb0cf0a2729ad2ca850d2e8b6202d11c4a656d9e61ecba1420","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae15d331d7077e4798ab/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"25278c787781c2ded86f45d6a7fd61c5259cd9d0e1b730c10e08dbadaac9ae2b","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"80a402b9e80a2655dcd84bdba0e79ff087fb6c5c60c34d1de83e57dece19d50e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b2cf0402ff088b688be7119dd2958d63","paperId":"2411.04857","sourceSha256":"784404db02faabbb0cf0a2729ad2ca850d2e8b6202d11c4a656d9e61ecba1420","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae15d331d7077e4798ab/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"25278c787781c2ded86f45d6a7fd61c5259cd9d0e1b730c10e08dbadaac9ae2b","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"7a3a6c948cd7b0e89d5d87eb6061140505fc07d419c6c2f076e3bdc958e48f40","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:36f9ba12b7e008f4ce2ad6df"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:36f9ba12b7e008f4ce2ad6df","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:37c4aaccf13c61864a10b036e86c7c7b8d7ce11963f56a9155f2d1329f627100","q025-candidate-question:ba83a10fc3f76f6befff7e35"],"scopeContentSha256":"c92f5f60c698d01431f10880b8599997e7cfd95b55443d8c80ce072ca3506834","contributionContentSha256":"590836df8a0e2ce26e6cbfb36e4d422cd7fdd215c7dad34dd40a2eb4fc10240b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:37c4aaccf13c61864a10b036e86c7c7b8d7ce11963f56a9155f2d1329f627100","textSha256":"7a08839cf596b825d7a22b2dfd532684bc1368ceea21cd3cdb0844abec3e109b"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:099dc3389088713fabe2f6404519babe","paperId":"2411.04857","sourceSha256":"784404db02faabbb0cf0a2729ad2ca850d2e8b6202d11c4a656d9e61ecba1420","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae15d331d7077e4798ab/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"25278c787781c2ded86f45d6a7fd61c5259cd9d0e1b730c10e08dbadaac9ae2b","pdfPage":1,"start":99,"end":3494,"textSha256":"d3ec212a344942565070d24180b79318ec155367d3b41709f59d6d4cd7a33ada","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8fe9f019d990588afa36cf6829551181","paperId":"2411.04857","sourceSha256":"784404db02faabbb0cf0a2729ad2ca850d2e8b6202d11c4a656d9e61ecba1420","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae15d331d7077e4798ab/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"25278c787781c2ded86f45d6a7fd61c5259cd9d0e1b730c10e08dbadaac9ae2b","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"80a402b9e80a2655dcd84bdba0e79ff087fb6c5c60c34d1de83e57dece19d50e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b2cf0402ff088b688be7119dd2958d63","paperId":"2411.04857","sourceSha256":"784404db02faabbb0cf0a2729ad2ca850d2e8b6202d11c4a656d9e61ecba1420","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ae15d331d7077e4798ab/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"25278c787781c2ded86f45d6a7fd61c5259cd9d0e1b730c10e08dbadaac9ae2b","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"7a3a6c948cd7b0e89d5d87eb6061140505fc07d419c6c2f076e3bdc958e48f40","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:36f9ba12b7e008f4ce2ad6df","recordId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Representation equations do not require spectral positivity; new-state interpretation is perturbative and spin-2 singletness is tested numerically.","challengeNote":"Exchange-support equations do not require spectral-density positivity. New-state interpretation is perturbative; the separate spin-2 singlet test is numerical.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","home":{"unitId":"unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","paperId":"2406.07606","textSha256":"527c56ec6c0d01c1a4ae70488489fa4c5d616b1b5febc53fa3bdfc56fb9e4655"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b67710f2e8e0776a8aba48e4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b67710f2e8e0776a8aba48e4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8"],"scopeContentSha256":"23ff9118dfec8a655b571ba9ace4d2116a06675da50b80f04409cfbcecc4a308","placementContentSha256":"31ec60a9db26d4a30092970a53918df51bed70575f05c8bada8e8b8eb273b269","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","paperId":"2406.07606","textSha256":"527c56ec6c0d01c1a4ae70488489fa4c5d616b1b5febc53fa3bdfc56fb9e4655"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b67710f2e8e0776a8aba48e4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ba83a10fc3f76f6befff7e35","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","textSha256":"527c56ec6c0d01c1a4ae70488489fa4c5d616b1b5febc53fa3bdfc56fb9e4655"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5fb19dfa0c7177ab184f95de"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5fb19dfa0c7177ab184f95de","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","q025-candidate-question:ba83a10fc3f76f6befff7e35"],"scopeContentSha256":"c92f5f60c698d01431f10880b8599997e7cfd95b55443d8c80ce072ca3506834","contributionContentSha256":"8e7a482d6d04b7c55e273628b4a50c0a58f9c977a3bfa999878604673f4a02fb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","textSha256":"527c56ec6c0d01c1a4ae70488489fa4c5d616b1b5febc53fa3bdfc56fb9e4655"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5fb19dfa0c7177ab184f95de","recordId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","home":{"unitId":"unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","paperId":"2212.08001","textSha256":"251cec4b812fcdefb47c6f2c06fed5421b3e2ec4d81454914e964d33b13d57e7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f8bcb2ab68b1a74b5d69776c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f8bcb2ab68b1a74b5d69776c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8"],"scopeContentSha256":"23ff9118dfec8a655b571ba9ace4d2116a06675da50b80f04409cfbcecc4a308","placementContentSha256":"a5ae346defecfaeb71841a4e568ec59b807477acb0a8ee33ddcc5f95c59bbb90","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","paperId":"2212.08001","textSha256":"251cec4b812fcdefb47c6f2c06fed5421b3e2ec4d81454914e964d33b13d57e7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f8bcb2ab68b1a74b5d69776c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ba83a10fc3f76f6befff7e35","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","textSha256":"251cec4b812fcdefb47c6f2c06fed5421b3e2ec4d81454914e964d33b13d57e7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1b0244518e80da6a31440925"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1b0244518e80da6a31440925","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","q025-candidate-question:ba83a10fc3f76f6befff7e35"],"scopeContentSha256":"c92f5f60c698d01431f10880b8599997e7cfd95b55443d8c80ce072ca3506834","contributionContentSha256":"33a20018598d1cd8dcc55f1cdce390651a8c0fd805ba026fe30e1afab876826b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","textSha256":"251cec4b812fcdefb47c6f2c06fed5421b3e2ec4d81454914e964d33b13d57e7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1b0244518e80da6a31440925","recordId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Avoiding a need for super-Planckian control is a target, not an established premise.","challengeNote":"Avoiding a need for super-Planckian control is an announced target, not an independently established result.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:99c55cd77d2313d829a0796107a64aa69f177deab2b115677f05a379d5c59433","home":{"unitId":"unit:99c55cd77d2313d829a0796107a64aa69f177deab2b115677f05a379d5c59433","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:99c55cd77d2313d829a0796107a64aa69f177deab2b115677f05a379d5c59433","paperId":"2512.17828","textSha256":"fd10bc8c7b33cf3a0a83b8a0d4c6d89b86a8289c341aa8fd50a3cb67b9a2d2e8"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5f593103fad63a4fa4404dba"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5f593103fad63a4fa4404dba","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:99c55cd77d2313d829a0796107a64aa69f177deab2b115677f05a379d5c59433","q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8"],"scopeContentSha256":"23ff9118dfec8a655b571ba9ace4d2116a06675da50b80f04409cfbcecc4a308","placementContentSha256":"e7b90feec80a6d25614ad223ba3ab0fb79a0e6cd7a8042e406b298406a9f2762","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:99c55cd77d2313d829a0796107a64aa69f177deab2b115677f05a379d5c59433","paperId":"2512.17828","textSha256":"fd10bc8c7b33cf3a0a83b8a0d4c6d89b86a8289c341aa8fd50a3cb67b9a2d2e8"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5f593103fad63a4fa4404dba"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:99c55cd77d2313d829a0796107a64aa69f177deab2b115677f05a379d5c59433","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ba83a10fc3f76f6befff7e35","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:99c55cd77d2313d829a0796107a64aa69f177deab2b115677f05a379d5c59433","textSha256":"fd10bc8c7b33cf3a0a83b8a0d4c6d89b86a8289c341aa8fd50a3cb67b9a2d2e8"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e565831b87e966bbf461a270"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e565831b87e966bbf461a270","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:99c55cd77d2313d829a0796107a64aa69f177deab2b115677f05a379d5c59433","q025-candidate-question:ba83a10fc3f76f6befff7e35"],"scopeContentSha256":"c92f5f60c698d01431f10880b8599997e7cfd95b55443d8c80ce072ca3506834","contributionContentSha256":"74fbb932fa1dd91ca707249bad63fff6866521aace003cc579750c6aac0e9b85","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:99c55cd77d2313d829a0796107a64aa69f177deab2b115677f05a379d5c59433","textSha256":"fd10bc8c7b33cf3a0a83b8a0d4c6d89b86a8289c341aa8fd50a3cb67b9a2d2e8"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e565831b87e966bbf461a270","recordId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Trajectory multiplicity and apparently single-trajectory numerical extrema are distinct linked targets.","challengeNote":"Trajectory multiplicity and the appearance of numerical extrema are distinct linked targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":5,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"28b0bf22117a77710735a6ac773a2aa4a77c9d5f42561f2963e8e59f0cbb1556"},"organizational-access:d9ba41ae2b93526a1b62c2b1":{"id":"organizational-access:d9ba41ae2b93526a1b62c2b1","source":"q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f","target":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"4c5e1e825a92921019614144b954d71607b76d7ac245831967edfe78f27905a0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ecf7181b07e48d45387428bd"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9df5eeb57c828ca805a8889c867a256e76e38e13192ef8ce26ce44c6bf51d190","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0390eec8bc968df490b85a17"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:10cc78b1357b454aa6215b512f6a731305176ebdc685f1d284782b01d8d073ba","home":{"unitId":"unit:10cc78b1357b454aa6215b512f6a731305176ebdc685f1d284782b01d8d073ba","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:10cc78b1357b454aa6215b512f6a731305176ebdc685f1d284782b01d8d073ba","paperId":"hep-th/9311162","textSha256":"4c931a4d10d81b6039ba3c5e85b88bce4277ff3f2bfdd4b5b66944dd1c1646f0"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6fe85afa107b76a6c31ca592"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6fe85afa107b76a6c31ca592","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:10cc78b1357b454aa6215b512f6a731305176ebdc685f1d284782b01d8d073ba","q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f"],"scopeContentSha256":"4c5e1e825a92921019614144b954d71607b76d7ac245831967edfe78f27905a0","placementContentSha256":"0022fe27aa4fa5e3690504e3660deaac3bbfc187e49f2ed6f9ebae424093f2fc","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:10cc78b1357b454aa6215b512f6a731305176ebdc685f1d284782b01d8d073ba","paperId":"hep-th/9311162","textSha256":"4c931a4d10d81b6039ba3c5e85b88bce4277ff3f2bfdd4b5b66944dd1c1646f0"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6fe85afa107b76a6c31ca592"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:10cc78b1357b454aa6215b512f6a731305176ebdc685f1d284782b01d8d073ba","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d71","kind":"description","unitIndex":71,"unitId":"unit:10cc78b1357b454aa6215b512f6a731305176ebdc685f1d284782b01d8d073ba","textSha256":"4c931a4d10d81b6039ba3c5e85b88bce4277ff3f2bfdd4b5b66944dd1c1646f0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b74a92dfba2c3712dc27ff72"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b74a92dfba2c3712dc27ff72","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:10cc78b1357b454aa6215b512f6a731305176ebdc685f1d284782b01d8d073ba","q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405"],"scopeContentSha256":"9df5eeb57c828ca805a8889c867a256e76e38e13192ef8ce26ce44c6bf51d190","contributionContentSha256":"047b7857336b7ba5521f1058f2f08d0322648c76c4ba5204c8ecdd84b52d8127","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d71","kind":"description","unitIndex":71,"unitId":"unit:10cc78b1357b454aa6215b512f6a731305176ebdc685f1d284782b01d8d073ba","textSha256":"4c931a4d10d81b6039ba3c5e85b88bce4277ff3f2bfdd4b5b66944dd1c1646f0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b74a92dfba2c3712dc27ff72","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Coulomb screening and surviving Aharonov–Bohm interactions are explicitly distinguished.","challengeNote":"Coulomb screening and surviving Aharonov–Bohm interactions are distinguished.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:387a60b627d33cef1247a88a91062c09270f8bba701df2b3c35d9fe17916ce50","home":{"unitId":"unit:387a60b627d33cef1247a88a91062c09270f8bba701df2b3c35d9fe17916ce50","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:387a60b627d33cef1247a88a91062c09270f8bba701df2b3c35d9fe17916ce50","paperId":"2104.07036","textSha256":"5390315c0c61c9f8dd7e6423bea0991cae384193b2a392feee86670595bdbbd9"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5a81f2448cf226c2a9121dc7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5a81f2448cf226c2a9121dc7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:387a60b627d33cef1247a88a91062c09270f8bba701df2b3c35d9fe17916ce50","q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f"],"scopeContentSha256":"4c5e1e825a92921019614144b954d71607b76d7ac245831967edfe78f27905a0","placementContentSha256":"cefb1223444e63865dc730e804bec7bb17514f8543f873da53e9ac4a10788c3b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:387a60b627d33cef1247a88a91062c09270f8bba701df2b3c35d9fe17916ce50","paperId":"2104.07036","textSha256":"5390315c0c61c9f8dd7e6423bea0991cae384193b2a392feee86670595bdbbd9"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5a81f2448cf226c2a9121dc7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:387a60b627d33cef1247a88a91062c09270f8bba701df2b3c35d9fe17916ce50","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:387a60b627d33cef1247a88a91062c09270f8bba701df2b3c35d9fe17916ce50","textSha256":"5390315c0c61c9f8dd7e6423bea0991cae384193b2a392feee86670595bdbbd9"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:98912a3b1dd063effcc91e8f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:98912a3b1dd063effcc91e8f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:387a60b627d33cef1247a88a91062c09270f8bba701df2b3c35d9fe17916ce50","q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405"],"scopeContentSha256":"9df5eeb57c828ca805a8889c867a256e76e38e13192ef8ce26ce44c6bf51d190","contributionContentSha256":"96baba0f5dbcbe557b6164cbb0e69b5603e6968de096c489b137dc949b37a304","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:387a60b627d33cef1247a88a91062c09270f8bba701df2b3c35d9fe17916ce50","textSha256":"5390315c0c61c9f8dd7e6423bea0991cae384193b2a392feee86670595bdbbd9"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:98912a3b1dd063effcc91e8f","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5ec1ee2dd9812900af3be14dcece90714ac3fe7d2828fa2a6b4f7e021d2ae6a3","home":{"unitId":"unit:5ec1ee2dd9812900af3be14dcece90714ac3fe7d2828fa2a6b4f7e021d2ae6a3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5ec1ee2dd9812900af3be14dcece90714ac3fe7d2828fa2a6b4f7e021d2ae6a3","paperId":"2402.19458","textSha256":"e69f3645923c0d669e6a7f0b01f248f7daac036fed87903fa065bcabd971fda7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c9c7ad4d37d286820c8143f9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c9c7ad4d37d286820c8143f9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5ec1ee2dd9812900af3be14dcece90714ac3fe7d2828fa2a6b4f7e021d2ae6a3","q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f"],"scopeContentSha256":"4c5e1e825a92921019614144b954d71607b76d7ac245831967edfe78f27905a0","placementContentSha256":"594eb06a3188c581dbf73826e49c3b5f4c60dfc3baa2bcd58646f180d29304a3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5ec1ee2dd9812900af3be14dcece90714ac3fe7d2828fa2a6b4f7e021d2ae6a3","paperId":"2402.19458","textSha256":"e69f3645923c0d669e6a7f0b01f248f7daac036fed87903fa065bcabd971fda7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c9c7ad4d37d286820c8143f9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5ec1ee2dd9812900af3be14dcece90714ac3fe7d2828fa2a6b4f7e021d2ae6a3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:5ec1ee2dd9812900af3be14dcece90714ac3fe7d2828fa2a6b4f7e021d2ae6a3","textSha256":"e69f3645923c0d669e6a7f0b01f248f7daac036fed87903fa065bcabd971fda7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cc260aab3ad1cf6a58fe6a1e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:cc260aab3ad1cf6a58fe6a1e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5ec1ee2dd9812900af3be14dcece90714ac3fe7d2828fa2a6b4f7e021d2ae6a3","q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405"],"scopeContentSha256":"9df5eeb57c828ca805a8889c867a256e76e38e13192ef8ce26ce44c6bf51d190","contributionContentSha256":"d576486743bc3f8579971c474f084c4d9d63dcde52b1703af5860f0c8f40286b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:5ec1ee2dd9812900af3be14dcece90714ac3fe7d2828fa2a6b4f7e021d2ae6a3","textSha256":"e69f3645923c0d669e6a7f0b01f248f7daac036fed87903fa065bcabd971fda7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cc260aab3ad1cf6a58fe6a1e","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Material compound: Goldstone thermal phases, D/M-brane fields and M5 nonlinear self-duality.","challengeNote":"Material compound: Goldstone thermal phases, D/M-brane fields and M5 nonlinear self-duality.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:68e2ad317ad34bbf58f59ec555abef57472526a57d9a4a705c40a54ae0066775","home":{"unitId":"unit:68e2ad317ad34bbf58f59ec555abef57472526a57d9a4a705c40a54ae0066775","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:68e2ad317ad34bbf58f59ec555abef57472526a57d9a4a705c40a54ae0066775","paperId":"2411.19683","textSha256":"420ab52d7acb63ca54b7f94cf847541021e611773bc4fb9c9be47aa710296cba"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:117d844d3ca1a330bcfeaf65"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:117d844d3ca1a330bcfeaf65","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:68e2ad317ad34bbf58f59ec555abef57472526a57d9a4a705c40a54ae0066775","q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f"],"scopeContentSha256":"4c5e1e825a92921019614144b954d71607b76d7ac245831967edfe78f27905a0","placementContentSha256":"64b38a5d0b3cea8329d8b9054085fdbf95fda6e8014a6d61b1d41b9dbc572fef","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:68e2ad317ad34bbf58f59ec555abef57472526a57d9a4a705c40a54ae0066775","paperId":"2411.19683","textSha256":"420ab52d7acb63ca54b7f94cf847541021e611773bc4fb9c9be47aa710296cba"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:117d844d3ca1a330bcfeaf65"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:68e2ad317ad34bbf58f59ec555abef57472526a57d9a4a705c40a54ae0066775","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:68e2ad317ad34bbf58f59ec555abef57472526a57d9a4a705c40a54ae0066775","textSha256":"420ab52d7acb63ca54b7f94cf847541021e611773bc4fb9c9be47aa710296cba"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:093eecc5020eac4afed910e5"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:093eecc5020eac4afed910e5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:68e2ad317ad34bbf58f59ec555abef57472526a57d9a4a705c40a54ae0066775","q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405"],"scopeContentSha256":"9df5eeb57c828ca805a8889c867a256e76e38e13192ef8ce26ce44c6bf51d190","contributionContentSha256":"29162b74b8862d47a3c719444186d2d4af4b07b8a0a0c4e97bd4ea635e98ad7e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:68e2ad317ad34bbf58f59ec555abef57472526a57d9a4a705c40a54ae0066775","textSha256":"420ab52d7acb63ca54b7f94cf847541021e611773bc4fb9c9be47aa710296cba"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:093eecc5020eac4afed910e5","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The finite and continuous −1-form targets are not identified with the older brane-degree gauge terminology.","challengeNote":"Remove the p3 instantiation: engineering and polarization choices alone do not establish a gauge-group or matter-structure target.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:760a1cb3290ddf8c3446bdd55f3ae43b763ef10c6a945004f3cde4024cf02c41","home":{"unitId":"unit:760a1cb3290ddf8c3446bdd55f3ae43b763ef10c6a945004f3cde4024cf02c41","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:760a1cb3290ddf8c3446bdd55f3ae43b763ef10c6a945004f3cde4024cf02c41","paperId":"1802.07747","textSha256":"2fb1fb3fb4571f1f638f94d03b540eab14937d55dffec59cd8d7390d37fc8c6d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0cb6abfc1da021363ed6705c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0cb6abfc1da021363ed6705c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:760a1cb3290ddf8c3446bdd55f3ae43b763ef10c6a945004f3cde4024cf02c41","q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f"],"scopeContentSha256":"4c5e1e825a92921019614144b954d71607b76d7ac245831967edfe78f27905a0","placementContentSha256":"79d8e69ce1e37009e9b9f90d58b62d552b35dbbcac8f21b8556a091c1354588b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:760a1cb3290ddf8c3446bdd55f3ae43b763ef10c6a945004f3cde4024cf02c41","paperId":"1802.07747","textSha256":"2fb1fb3fb4571f1f638f94d03b540eab14937d55dffec59cd8d7390d37fc8c6d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0cb6abfc1da021363ed6705c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:760a1cb3290ddf8c3446bdd55f3ae43b763ef10c6a945004f3cde4024cf02c41","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:760a1cb3290ddf8c3446bdd55f3ae43b763ef10c6a945004f3cde4024cf02c41","textSha256":"2fb1fb3fb4571f1f638f94d03b540eab14937d55dffec59cd8d7390d37fc8c6d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dd9ac433749a814420d1ea4e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:dd9ac433749a814420d1ea4e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:760a1cb3290ddf8c3446bdd55f3ae43b763ef10c6a945004f3cde4024cf02c41","q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405"],"scopeContentSha256":"9df5eeb57c828ca805a8889c867a256e76e38e13192ef8ce26ce44c6bf51d190","contributionContentSha256":"e0d5bb163608afa6cde05d88331ce22f8e1d64b83e3fbfda9bb833cbe8a0d20b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:760a1cb3290ddf8c3446bdd55f3ae43b763ef10c6a945004f3cde4024cf02c41","textSha256":"2fb1fb3fb4571f1f638f94d03b540eab14937d55dffec59cd8d7390d37fc8c6d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dd9ac433749a814420d1ea4e","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:8c084637064525624a7bcc1f8fbeb124801e77cd1eda3b01fab9a762b7cf10f0","home":{"unitId":"unit:8c084637064525624a7bcc1f8fbeb124801e77cd1eda3b01fab9a762b7cf10f0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8c084637064525624a7bcc1f8fbeb124801e77cd1eda3b01fab9a762b7cf10f0","paperId":"2204.07523","textSha256":"125b11a8530b4e862a8398e11db7f6314b79bb41a92bc035fc9c8680c48849a0"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:52f14733a2c1741da6d8ac17"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:52f14733a2c1741da6d8ac17","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8c084637064525624a7bcc1f8fbeb124801e77cd1eda3b01fab9a762b7cf10f0","q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f"],"scopeContentSha256":"4c5e1e825a92921019614144b954d71607b76d7ac245831967edfe78f27905a0","placementContentSha256":"6c0e5bb7d36ca634734972cbd4b1ff0acffcf14605fd7c6b6b33ab5a83d0462f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8c084637064525624a7bcc1f8fbeb124801e77cd1eda3b01fab9a762b7cf10f0","paperId":"2204.07523","textSha256":"125b11a8530b4e862a8398e11db7f6314b79bb41a92bc035fc9c8680c48849a0"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:52f14733a2c1741da6d8ac17"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8c084637064525624a7bcc1f8fbeb124801e77cd1eda3b01fab9a762b7cf10f0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:8c084637064525624a7bcc1f8fbeb124801e77cd1eda3b01fab9a762b7cf10f0","textSha256":"125b11a8530b4e862a8398e11db7f6314b79bb41a92bc035fc9c8680c48849a0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8d412fcc93b5ae9f4cdf7fbd"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8d412fcc93b5ae9f4cdf7fbd","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8c084637064525624a7bcc1f8fbeb124801e77cd1eda3b01fab9a762b7cf10f0","q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405"],"scopeContentSha256":"9df5eeb57c828ca805a8889c867a256e76e38e13192ef8ce26ce44c6bf51d190","contributionContentSha256":"f69211c9d0cc323b3c98e298f85d4923aa86a3d2cffd1fd0638821a3cdb01e34","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:8c084637064525624a7bcc1f8fbeb124801e77cd1eda3b01fab9a762b7cf10f0","textSha256":"125b11a8530b4e862a8398e11db7f6314b79bb41a92bc035fc9c8680c48849a0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8d412fcc93b5ae9f4cdf7fbd","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Separates gauging-induced dual symmetry from proposed string defects that break it.","challengeNote":"Gauging-induced dual symmetry and its proposed breaking in string embeddings are separate targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a5071ae7a132b9466a1a55fa21928926ca07a4230a811e6d8d7eca35b7855634","home":{"unitId":"unit:a5071ae7a132b9466a1a55fa21928926ca07a4230a811e6d8d7eca35b7855634","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a5071ae7a132b9466a1a55fa21928926ca07a4230a811e6d8d7eca35b7855634","paperId":"2306.07311","textSha256":"736c40020b0f8b41299d2a4ece60a7776ee808ec454995bc9583a3a9c07cd921"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:47e7bfd6b4ee64d79c9feac7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:47e7bfd6b4ee64d79c9feac7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a5071ae7a132b9466a1a55fa21928926ca07a4230a811e6d8d7eca35b7855634","q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f"],"scopeContentSha256":"4c5e1e825a92921019614144b954d71607b76d7ac245831967edfe78f27905a0","placementContentSha256":"7792a3db1fc1d653550a4b08e1db7e3953e90c6ccbc27af83c25cf0464344bb9","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a5071ae7a132b9466a1a55fa21928926ca07a4230a811e6d8d7eca35b7855634","paperId":"2306.07311","textSha256":"736c40020b0f8b41299d2a4ece60a7776ee808ec454995bc9583a3a9c07cd921"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:47e7bfd6b4ee64d79c9feac7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a5071ae7a132b9466a1a55fa21928926ca07a4230a811e6d8d7eca35b7855634","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d48","kind":"description","unitIndex":48,"unitId":"unit:a5071ae7a132b9466a1a55fa21928926ca07a4230a811e6d8d7eca35b7855634","textSha256":"736c40020b0f8b41299d2a4ece60a7776ee808ec454995bc9583a3a9c07cd921"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d1f6685b5935926981dadd61"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d1f6685b5935926981dadd61","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a5071ae7a132b9466a1a55fa21928926ca07a4230a811e6d8d7eca35b7855634","q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405"],"scopeContentSha256":"9df5eeb57c828ca805a8889c867a256e76e38e13192ef8ce26ce44c6bf51d190","contributionContentSha256":"e663f9c0695a89d35ff84b22f51433c61f6d24b9e55a734bd06d8fe2bf68ce90","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d48","kind":"description","unitIndex":48,"unitId":"unit:a5071ae7a132b9466a1a55fa21928926ca07a4230a811e6d8d7eca35b7855634","textSha256":"736c40020b0f8b41299d2a4ece60a7776ee808ec454995bc9583a3a9c07cd921"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d1f6685b5935926981dadd61","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Material compound: supergravity gauge topology, SCFT symmetries, twisted compactifications and duality defects require later facet reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Material compound: supergravity gauge topology, SCFT symmetry structures, twisted compactifications and duality defects need facet reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c382e8e37d72e628162b1f8f7e454d7a3d146112a9aa9fd457e0614563b70b61","home":{"unitId":"unit:c382e8e37d72e628162b1f8f7e454d7a3d146112a9aa9fd457e0614563b70b61","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c382e8e37d72e628162b1f8f7e454d7a3d146112a9aa9fd457e0614563b70b61","paperId":"1802.04790","textSha256":"2b654477f73796e568bbc05e7526c3b3d13a4570799ff06744ae3e02a6470303"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b2a57d9af3807fe52d0f0938"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b2a57d9af3807fe52d0f0938","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c382e8e37d72e628162b1f8f7e454d7a3d146112a9aa9fd457e0614563b70b61","q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f"],"scopeContentSha256":"4c5e1e825a92921019614144b954d71607b76d7ac245831967edfe78f27905a0","placementContentSha256":"7097cae676dd99b9f2a60cb8a077ecabdaf7f46d0598d2526ed769ac0d3e94c0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c382e8e37d72e628162b1f8f7e454d7a3d146112a9aa9fd457e0614563b70b61","paperId":"1802.04790","textSha256":"2b654477f73796e568bbc05e7526c3b3d13a4570799ff06744ae3e02a6470303"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b2a57d9af3807fe52d0f0938"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c382e8e37d72e628162b1f8f7e454d7a3d146112a9aa9fd457e0614563b70b61","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:c382e8e37d72e628162b1f8f7e454d7a3d146112a9aa9fd457e0614563b70b61","textSha256":"2b654477f73796e568bbc05e7526c3b3d13a4570799ff06744ae3e02a6470303"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9d31173c6a3108f141e2a738"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9d31173c6a3108f141e2a738","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c382e8e37d72e628162b1f8f7e454d7a3d146112a9aa9fd457e0614563b70b61","q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405"],"scopeContentSha256":"9df5eeb57c828ca805a8889c867a256e76e38e13192ef8ce26ce44c6bf51d190","contributionContentSha256":"4e6aa46dbb4266eeaa5f1ba7fbf95af2b469da3cbb7286e10063a81e4b8df829","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:c382e8e37d72e628162b1f8f7e454d7a3d146112a9aa9fd457e0614563b70b61","textSha256":"2b654477f73796e568bbc05e7526c3b3d13a4570799ff06744ae3e02a6470303"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9d31173c6a3108f141e2a738","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:cb54cb61db15a47f6e9590e277a050115d4760e0e2e68b12781704e2750cec81","home":{"unitId":"unit:cb54cb61db15a47f6e9590e277a050115d4760e0e2e68b12781704e2750cec81","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cb54cb61db15a47f6e9590e277a050115d4760e0e2e68b12781704e2750cec81","paperId":"2410.07318","textSha256":"06992f4924d020fe659e8afe9f5e31f6566a5ab366b4ccded5122f4418a29ce9"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dc24567cda3d257d6dbafdcc"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dc24567cda3d257d6dbafdcc","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cb54cb61db15a47f6e9590e277a050115d4760e0e2e68b12781704e2750cec81","q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f"],"scopeContentSha256":"4c5e1e825a92921019614144b954d71607b76d7ac245831967edfe78f27905a0","placementContentSha256":"ff1082c224be0f3fc892ee2fcb00dff79db0d73ce2bac9ffe3bbef64114adffd","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cb54cb61db15a47f6e9590e277a050115d4760e0e2e68b12781704e2750cec81","paperId":"2410.07318","textSha256":"06992f4924d020fe659e8afe9f5e31f6566a5ab366b4ccded5122f4418a29ce9"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dc24567cda3d257d6dbafdcc"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cb54cb61db15a47f6e9590e277a050115d4760e0e2e68b12781704e2750cec81","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d58","kind":"description","unitIndex":58,"unitId":"unit:cb54cb61db15a47f6e9590e277a050115d4760e0e2e68b12781704e2750cec81","textSha256":"06992f4924d020fe659e8afe9f5e31f6566a5ab366b4ccded5122f4418a29ce9"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3104864df98d138e2d4bfa83"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3104864df98d138e2d4bfa83","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cb54cb61db15a47f6e9590e277a050115d4760e0e2e68b12781704e2750cec81","q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405"],"scopeContentSha256":"9df5eeb57c828ca805a8889c867a256e76e38e13192ef8ce26ce44c6bf51d190","contributionContentSha256":"8f9d9113ee7b8513c78f7ed3cb85b94e83c023c4cdafc02a0c1ebb4137ea1d92","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d58","kind":"description","unitIndex":58,"unitId":"unit:cb54cb61db15a47f6e9590e277a050115d4760e0e2e68b12781704e2750cec81","textSha256":"06992f4924d020fe659e8afe9f5e31f6566a5ab366b4ccded5122f4418a29ce9"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3104864df98d138e2d4bfa83","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Identical asymptotic geometry does not identify the fractional C3 holonomy data.","challengeNote":"Identical asymptotic geometry need not identify the fractional C3 holonomy data.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ef300e71c2946be15c47b67a1cab1561fc82af70cc8966a6c53c804f36d18fc7","home":{"unitId":"unit:ef300e71c2946be15c47b67a1cab1561fc82af70cc8966a6c53c804f36d18fc7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ef300e71c2946be15c47b67a1cab1561fc82af70cc8966a6c53c804f36d18fc7","paperId":"2104.07036","textSha256":"78370e31c9c0b6a2d749a237d45c710dc30af626c538240f3dc7605c6c35454d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c76dfb837a1c1b1639dada68"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c76dfb837a1c1b1639dada68","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ef300e71c2946be15c47b67a1cab1561fc82af70cc8966a6c53c804f36d18fc7","q025-candidate-region:39632ea50ec10697c519422f"],"scopeContentSha256":"4c5e1e825a92921019614144b954d71607b76d7ac245831967edfe78f27905a0","placementContentSha256":"f69541032fc86de0b813aad89d7188b8721c413ce067e17c85fbe4a2296e5a0f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ef300e71c2946be15c47b67a1cab1561fc82af70cc8966a6c53c804f36d18fc7","paperId":"2104.07036","textSha256":"78370e31c9c0b6a2d749a237d45c710dc30af626c538240f3dc7605c6c35454d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c76dfb837a1c1b1639dada68"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ef300e71c2946be15c47b67a1cab1561fc82af70cc8966a6c53c804f36d18fc7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:ef300e71c2946be15c47b67a1cab1561fc82af70cc8966a6c53c804f36d18fc7","textSha256":"78370e31c9c0b6a2d749a237d45c710dc30af626c538240f3dc7605c6c35454d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3a3314889ba93e12c998a519"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3a3314889ba93e12c998a519","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ef300e71c2946be15c47b67a1cab1561fc82af70cc8966a6c53c804f36d18fc7","q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405"],"scopeContentSha256":"9df5eeb57c828ca805a8889c867a256e76e38e13192ef8ce26ce44c6bf51d190","contributionContentSha256":"a2822827c72e96f539bd5aaeaf1bf7501d55fc112f4c15d7c31b236f5d537c10","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:ef300e71c2946be15c47b67a1cab1561fc82af70cc8966a6c53c804f36d18fc7","textSha256":"78370e31c9c0b6a2d749a237d45c710dc30af626c538240f3dc7605c6c35454d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3a3314889ba93e12c998a519","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"A vortex specification is sought without introducing a dynamical vortex field.","challengeNote":"No dynamical vortex field is assumed.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":10,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"aeea8e26fcc5c6ea223eed1452fac08df6759a8a6caf54f32698fc9448cc9e21"},"organizational-access:36727d9ec79e760975815c89":{"id":"organizational-access:36727d9ec79e760975815c89","source":"q025-candidate-region:3b3a2de87ca718c7b324bbe8","target":"q025-candidate-question:1cc75225f101a5d135722b28","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:3b3a2de87ca718c7b324bbe8","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"371f10667ec8c90ef1ab6f83601b508a0909cc7ca0e610b65502f8a59eb287d6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:bd676d68d46fb60ad1a42585"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1cc75225f101a5d135722b28","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c464ea555df50ce45772f867ac04ba31c0bd28c99b96b310e31767142fcab4c4","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1d779a8f78f6066b4f92a82a"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:fbed6a97870680386506f6cae1f8bffab5538bf987f348d156fcf81d5a496ff0","home":{"unitId":"unit:fbed6a97870680386506f6cae1f8bffab5538bf987f348d156fcf81d5a496ff0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:3b3a2de87ca718c7b324bbe8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fbed6a97870680386506f6cae1f8bffab5538bf987f348d156fcf81d5a496ff0","paperId":"1511.07414","textSha256":"f7722a5c0c2476776ac53135e6c7dcbc455f1039b7415c39204a99f5bd63efd2"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0b96c68e8d0fe7c47ec2f343d8d4fc31","paperId":"1511.07414","sourceSha256":"05f386680d37debc6759fffae101d910b35bd89c98a7813f35fc96e2bc12300e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e7ce69cdc77147af2b4d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"884ed58680719d38b72213659844befa17af3db9d5c5f92d57112d5bfd4c7c49","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c1f03fb99e8fe0ef14b5e7ec0f22208d1f751d248bdb4d553d8201cd27b3592d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c5d8dcfa0c4708c6acd1455c8c85e9f1","paperId":"1511.07414","sourceSha256":"05f386680d37debc6759fffae101d910b35bd89c98a7813f35fc96e2bc12300e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e7ce69cdc77147af2b4d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"884ed58680719d38b72213659844befa17af3db9d5c5f92d57112d5bfd4c7c49","pdfPage":2,"start":2496,"end":4455,"textSha256":"3f3e824c5d7e40698abda95cd7a5d69af84cafbd1770ee60af9bf633a44ccdf3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cb0b5cb01c36849aabbae3be"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cb0b5cb01c36849aabbae3be","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fbed6a97870680386506f6cae1f8bffab5538bf987f348d156fcf81d5a496ff0","q025-candidate-region:3b3a2de87ca718c7b324bbe8"],"scopeContentSha256":"371f10667ec8c90ef1ab6f83601b508a0909cc7ca0e610b65502f8a59eb287d6","placementContentSha256":"5934be0dfac2f0dd0a21297b2c0426eacd4c06004421c2bf0126e203855f3196","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-challenge","leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fbed6a97870680386506f6cae1f8bffab5538bf987f348d156fcf81d5a496ff0","paperId":"1511.07414","textSha256":"f7722a5c0c2476776ac53135e6c7dcbc455f1039b7415c39204a99f5bd63efd2"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0b96c68e8d0fe7c47ec2f343d8d4fc31","paperId":"1511.07414","sourceSha256":"05f386680d37debc6759fffae101d910b35bd89c98a7813f35fc96e2bc12300e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e7ce69cdc77147af2b4d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"884ed58680719d38b72213659844befa17af3db9d5c5f92d57112d5bfd4c7c49","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c1f03fb99e8fe0ef14b5e7ec0f22208d1f751d248bdb4d553d8201cd27b3592d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c5d8dcfa0c4708c6acd1455c8c85e9f1","paperId":"1511.07414","sourceSha256":"05f386680d37debc6759fffae101d910b35bd89c98a7813f35fc96e2bc12300e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e7ce69cdc77147af2b4d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"884ed58680719d38b72213659844befa17af3db9d5c5f92d57112d5bfd4c7c49","pdfPage":2,"start":2496,"end":4455,"textSha256":"3f3e824c5d7e40698abda95cd7a5d69af84cafbd1770ee60af9bf633a44ccdf3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cb0b5cb01c36849aabbae3be"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fbed6a97870680386506f6cae1f8bffab5538bf987f348d156fcf81d5a496ff0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1cc75225f101a5d135722b28","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:fbed6a97870680386506f6cae1f8bffab5538bf987f348d156fcf81d5a496ff0","textSha256":"f7722a5c0c2476776ac53135e6c7dcbc455f1039b7415c39204a99f5bd63efd2"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0b96c68e8d0fe7c47ec2f343d8d4fc31","paperId":"1511.07414","sourceSha256":"05f386680d37debc6759fffae101d910b35bd89c98a7813f35fc96e2bc12300e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e7ce69cdc77147af2b4d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"884ed58680719d38b72213659844befa17af3db9d5c5f92d57112d5bfd4c7c49","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c1f03fb99e8fe0ef14b5e7ec0f22208d1f751d248bdb4d553d8201cd27b3592d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c5d8dcfa0c4708c6acd1455c8c85e9f1","paperId":"1511.07414","sourceSha256":"05f386680d37debc6759fffae101d910b35bd89c98a7813f35fc96e2bc12300e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e7ce69cdc77147af2b4d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"884ed58680719d38b72213659844befa17af3db9d5c5f92d57112d5bfd4c7c49","pdfPage":2,"start":2496,"end":4455,"textSha256":"3f3e824c5d7e40698abda95cd7a5d69af84cafbd1770ee60af9bf633a44ccdf3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:80a8bdb4ce061365a6939b91"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:80a8bdb4ce061365a6939b91","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fbed6a97870680386506f6cae1f8bffab5538bf987f348d156fcf81d5a496ff0","q025-candidate-question:1cc75225f101a5d135722b28"],"scopeContentSha256":"c464ea555df50ce45772f867ac04ba31c0bd28c99b96b310e31767142fcab4c4","contributionContentSha256":"c49f491782d313db96376462c298a5e2c16d3353864b3ce561fe24828ae3f8b4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-proposal","leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:fbed6a97870680386506f6cae1f8bffab5538bf987f348d156fcf81d5a496ff0","textSha256":"f7722a5c0c2476776ac53135e6c7dcbc455f1039b7415c39204a99f5bd63efd2"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0b96c68e8d0fe7c47ec2f343d8d4fc31","paperId":"1511.07414","sourceSha256":"05f386680d37debc6759fffae101d910b35bd89c98a7813f35fc96e2bc12300e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e7ce69cdc77147af2b4d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"884ed58680719d38b72213659844befa17af3db9d5c5f92d57112d5bfd4c7c49","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c1f03fb99e8fe0ef14b5e7ec0f22208d1f751d248bdb4d553d8201cd27b3592d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c5d8dcfa0c4708c6acd1455c8c85e9f1","paperId":"1511.07414","sourceSha256":"05f386680d37debc6759fffae101d910b35bd89c98a7813f35fc96e2bc12300e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e7ce69cdc77147af2b4d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"884ed58680719d38b72213659844befa17af3db9d5c5f92d57112d5bfd4c7c49","pdfPage":2,"start":2496,"end":4455,"textSha256":"3f3e824c5d7e40698abda95cd7a5d69af84cafbd1770ee60af9bf633a44ccdf3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:80a8bdb4ce061365a6939b91","recordId":"leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound scalar-Goldstone and tensor-coupling targets share a symmetry-breaking setup but are not one observable.","challengeNote":"Scalar-Goldstone interactions and new tensor couplings are distinct targets within the shared symmetry-breaking setup.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"fdb580571ddebaa9b83245cf781903cc485326ff9b13c61ba22925e20fbeb498"},"organizational-access:6fe1abe56fe500b9c58b92d8":{"id":"organizational-access:6fe1abe56fe500b9c58b92d8","source":"q025-candidate-region:3b9378ae3cc20f2bf15f1c6c","target":"q025-candidate-question:9a7df7e0465c928c1b07e4dd","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:3b9378ae3cc20f2bf15f1c6c","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"fadca1fa5ee01411e15fca2cda144e9859f33fd3aecf6d08c8861692db28661d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b37c0009cbdf5b74a396c155"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9a7df7e0465c928c1b07e4dd","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1dee8c49fe01bb634a2e1e0ca367a4c852777286ad43d0a4e86fdee3849c73d4","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c5d77972371088ce882a4cc9"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:a395552e28f6be3caf817a7732fd343a31367c476c7370fafcb2891db0b26e41","home":{"unitId":"unit:a395552e28f6be3caf817a7732fd343a31367c476c7370fafcb2891db0b26e41","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:3b9378ae3cc20f2bf15f1c6c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a395552e28f6be3caf817a7732fd343a31367c476c7370fafcb2891db0b26e41","paperId":"2605.31331","textSha256":"b589509bd2b97117ca4b10d8440604ec59413bcf095206c7be15852e7cf4664d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:727bb2faffe71efe9617e820"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:727bb2faffe71efe9617e820","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a395552e28f6be3caf817a7732fd343a31367c476c7370fafcb2891db0b26e41","q025-candidate-region:3b9378ae3cc20f2bf15f1c6c"],"scopeContentSha256":"fadca1fa5ee01411e15fca2cda144e9859f33fd3aecf6d08c8861692db28661d","placementContentSha256":"bec493ab3b734703ef22648a1f8842e5e599b43f0b206634f5042730a0780a9f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5f459b239777fdeeab87-challenge","leaf-5f459b239777fdeeab87-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a395552e28f6be3caf817a7732fd343a31367c476c7370fafcb2891db0b26e41","paperId":"2605.31331","textSha256":"b589509bd2b97117ca4b10d8440604ec59413bcf095206c7be15852e7cf4664d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:727bb2faffe71efe9617e820"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a395552e28f6be3caf817a7732fd343a31367c476c7370fafcb2891db0b26e41","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9a7df7e0465c928c1b07e4dd","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:a395552e28f6be3caf817a7732fd343a31367c476c7370fafcb2891db0b26e41","textSha256":"b589509bd2b97117ca4b10d8440604ec59413bcf095206c7be15852e7cf4664d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:08d5970e7b3a6d38a8546a26","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound geometry/thermodynamics, worldline recovery and shadow targets require canonical reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Compound geometry/thermodynamics, worldline recovery and shadow targets require canonical reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:08d5970e7b3a6d38a8546a26","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a395552e28f6be3caf817a7732fd343a31367c476c7370fafcb2891db0b26e41","q025-candidate-question:9a7df7e0465c928c1b07e4dd"],"scopeContentSha256":"1dee8c49fe01bb634a2e1e0ca367a4c852777286ad43d0a4e86fdee3849c73d4","contributionContentSha256":"b45223bce1e9326caa0a3e176ebe2abcc5e00b8eb66b836d3aa2d09fc4e17bee","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5f459b239777fdeeab87-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5f459b239777fdeeab87-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5f459b239777fdeeab87-proposal","leaf-5f459b239777fdeeab87-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:a395552e28f6be3caf817a7732fd343a31367c476c7370fafcb2891db0b26e41","textSha256":"b589509bd2b97117ca4b10d8440604ec59413bcf095206c7be15852e7cf4664d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:08d5970e7b3a6d38a8546a26","recordId":"leaf-5f459b239777fdeeab87-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5f459b239777fdeeab87-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5f459b239777fdeeab87-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound geometry/thermodynamics, worldline recovery and shadow targets require canonical reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Compound geometry/thermodynamics, worldline recovery and shadow targets require canonical reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"13f8f56e6ec9eb6cd6771577d7c67e513a53748976e5ca4a79e034b37a249efa"},"organizational-access:99464927b2900f550d2877d6":{"id":"organizational-access:99464927b2900f550d2877d6","source":"q025-candidate-region:46fc37476acf84e240866e4b","target":"q025-candidate-question:247a94092548b630ad781040","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:46fc37476acf84e240866e4b","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"b57275e8f49c4ae0f8d2f94ba9d351f8b437ff9b5e0f97213cbe1a5dcf3df462","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:454ebb371547bf10e8d45e01"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:247a94092548b630ad781040","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"78c08922ca30c64978e9f10b555ccdb7b62c8552766e97f9b04872108c9563c2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f9af48e82c2f1ae8becf5f7d"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:dc0d2b2fc6e6b5fbc269e66c98f119dd4b095f5933c5f4bb09115759eead5374","home":{"unitId":"unit:dc0d2b2fc6e6b5fbc269e66c98f119dd4b095f5933c5f4bb09115759eead5374","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:46fc37476acf84e240866e4b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:dc0d2b2fc6e6b5fbc269e66c98f119dd4b095f5933c5f4bb09115759eead5374","paperId":"2007.03703","textSha256":"1961dbffd9453f60de25e04630462ad2fd077ad3b770d0e40972db8068bc7077"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:88754195bd70fc0a202a04cb"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:88754195bd70fc0a202a04cb","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:dc0d2b2fc6e6b5fbc269e66c98f119dd4b095f5933c5f4bb09115759eead5374","q025-candidate-region:46fc37476acf84e240866e4b"],"scopeContentSha256":"b57275e8f49c4ae0f8d2f94ba9d351f8b437ff9b5e0f97213cbe1a5dcf3df462","placementContentSha256":"9a24e151176836e8c9c70bd10b0e353798ccf40418e50c9a45980c3f54ea408e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge","leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:dc0d2b2fc6e6b5fbc269e66c98f119dd4b095f5933c5f4bb09115759eead5374","paperId":"2007.03703","textSha256":"1961dbffd9453f60de25e04630462ad2fd077ad3b770d0e40972db8068bc7077"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:88754195bd70fc0a202a04cb"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:dc0d2b2fc6e6b5fbc269e66c98f119dd4b095f5933c5f4bb09115759eead5374","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:247a94092548b630ad781040","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:dc0d2b2fc6e6b5fbc269e66c98f119dd4b095f5933c5f4bb09115759eead5374","textSha256":"1961dbffd9453f60de25e04630462ad2fd077ad3b770d0e40972db8068bc7077"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cf40985813b76a5424004303","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:cf40985813b76a5424004303","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:dc0d2b2fc6e6b5fbc269e66c98f119dd4b095f5933c5f4bb09115759eead5374","q025-candidate-question:247a94092548b630ad781040"],"scopeContentSha256":"78c08922ca30c64978e9f10b555ccdb7b62c8552766e97f9b04872108c9563c2","contributionContentSha256":"4aa085fb486ce89e10588f85563eece89b8854d7afe91e8bbae2ff50123543a0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:dc0d2b2fc6e6b5fbc269e66c98f119dd4b095f5933c5f4bb09115759eead5374","textSha256":"1961dbffd9453f60de25e04630462ad2fd077ad3b770d0e40972db8068bc7077"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cf40985813b76a5424004303","recordId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"c43fb125aa05f1128566eb2c08d0287a17d86d62c18590d26109d2c07d73873b"},"organizational-access:592ec917e0d6452dc7545e99":{"id":"organizational-access:592ec917e0d6452dc7545e99","source":"q025-candidate-region:46fc37476acf84e240866e4b","target":"q025-candidate-question:daef9e3af4a064e1f0fcc30a","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:46fc37476acf84e240866e4b","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"b57275e8f49c4ae0f8d2f94ba9d351f8b437ff9b5e0f97213cbe1a5dcf3df462","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:454ebb371547bf10e8d45e01"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:daef9e3af4a064e1f0fcc30a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"475a4b303fa84fd23af70524c38d4203b9b74d14ea586f5eda96550878a0adbf","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f7b5bd1585af20ba93325e9c"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:004197e3ae3e8cf57116b14f15c2d5c2da80157629b89f10c1d8dfff78ff39ff","home":{"unitId":"unit:004197e3ae3e8cf57116b14f15c2d5c2da80157629b89f10c1d8dfff78ff39ff","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:46fc37476acf84e240866e4b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:004197e3ae3e8cf57116b14f15c2d5c2da80157629b89f10c1d8dfff78ff39ff","paperId":"1106.4428","textSha256":"afeb13e787efe0ab03d093e2e64833083d97322877aed0c318699901b708c9df"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4a44eac25cb4700929edb702"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4a44eac25cb4700929edb702","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:004197e3ae3e8cf57116b14f15c2d5c2da80157629b89f10c1d8dfff78ff39ff","q025-candidate-region:46fc37476acf84e240866e4b"],"scopeContentSha256":"b57275e8f49c4ae0f8d2f94ba9d351f8b437ff9b5e0f97213cbe1a5dcf3df462","placementContentSha256":"9105dede3bd94179306f813ad63fd469965a2fa1faf9cf9ca1100df188fbca56","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge","leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:004197e3ae3e8cf57116b14f15c2d5c2da80157629b89f10c1d8dfff78ff39ff","paperId":"1106.4428","textSha256":"afeb13e787efe0ab03d093e2e64833083d97322877aed0c318699901b708c9df"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4a44eac25cb4700929edb702"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:004197e3ae3e8cf57116b14f15c2d5c2da80157629b89f10c1d8dfff78ff39ff","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:daef9e3af4a064e1f0fcc30a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:004197e3ae3e8cf57116b14f15c2d5c2da80157629b89f10c1d8dfff78ff39ff","textSha256":"afeb13e787efe0ab03d093e2e64833083d97322877aed0c318699901b708c9df"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2e86e7067fa4b2fb3f0cab1f","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound dynamics, solution-construction and stability target retained intact. Independent challenge qualification: Compound collective dynamics, rotating-solution construction, extremal limits and stability remain source-scoped."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2e86e7067fa4b2fb3f0cab1f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:004197e3ae3e8cf57116b14f15c2d5c2da80157629b89f10c1d8dfff78ff39ff","q025-candidate-question:daef9e3af4a064e1f0fcc30a"],"scopeContentSha256":"475a4b303fa84fd23af70524c38d4203b9b74d14ea586f5eda96550878a0adbf","contributionContentSha256":"010806b236bcb936d121a406416158b0ed22f33f0cf661c792ac9c80467156ce","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:004197e3ae3e8cf57116b14f15c2d5c2da80157629b89f10c1d8dfff78ff39ff","textSha256":"afeb13e787efe0ab03d093e2e64833083d97322877aed0c318699901b708c9df"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2e86e7067fa4b2fb3f0cab1f","recordId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound dynamics, solution-construction and stability target retained intact.","challengeNote":"Compound collective dynamics, rotating-solution construction, extremal limits and stability remain source-scoped.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:1e11cedce85c3a528428f56472d88c56c3ad092e29797eb0f26fd1827cd36b38","home":{"unitId":"unit:1e11cedce85c3a528428f56472d88c56c3ad092e29797eb0f26fd1827cd36b38","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:46fc37476acf84e240866e4b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e11cedce85c3a528428f56472d88c56c3ad092e29797eb0f26fd1827cd36b38","paperId":"2405.06566","textSha256":"cd146f7923d28288d5281e3c03fdfc7846948ccc871df6826c7097472b09e54f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a1fa6930ae1303f45fb8416c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a1fa6930ae1303f45fb8416c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e11cedce85c3a528428f56472d88c56c3ad092e29797eb0f26fd1827cd36b38","q025-candidate-region:46fc37476acf84e240866e4b"],"scopeContentSha256":"b57275e8f49c4ae0f8d2f94ba9d351f8b437ff9b5e0f97213cbe1a5dcf3df462","placementContentSha256":"ffbe09a1cbf5ea10f9b9e166695cce7f19a3dacade7efb9899884f35c2c5f332","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge","leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e11cedce85c3a528428f56472d88c56c3ad092e29797eb0f26fd1827cd36b38","paperId":"2405.06566","textSha256":"cd146f7923d28288d5281e3c03fdfc7846948ccc871df6826c7097472b09e54f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a1fa6930ae1303f45fb8416c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1e11cedce85c3a528428f56472d88c56c3ad092e29797eb0f26fd1827cd36b38","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:daef9e3af4a064e1f0fcc30a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d17","kind":"description","unitIndex":17,"unitId":"unit:1e11cedce85c3a528428f56472d88c56c3ad092e29797eb0f26fd1827cd36b38","textSha256":"cd146f7923d28288d5281e3c03fdfc7846948ccc871df6826c7097472b09e54f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e0883b4d76ba76f86c433358","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: Instability and charge-superradiant amplification are separate targets of the background comparison."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e0883b4d76ba76f86c433358","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e11cedce85c3a528428f56472d88c56c3ad092e29797eb0f26fd1827cd36b38","q025-candidate-question:daef9e3af4a064e1f0fcc30a"],"scopeContentSha256":"475a4b303fa84fd23af70524c38d4203b9b74d14ea586f5eda96550878a0adbf","contributionContentSha256":"8a5b433729d9fd38c88f64b2bd6acbc38280959b5a8fe118cc8901b615856b25","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d17","kind":"description","unitIndex":17,"unitId":"unit:1e11cedce85c3a528428f56472d88c56c3ad092e29797eb0f26fd1827cd36b38","textSha256":"cd146f7923d28288d5281e3c03fdfc7846948ccc871df6826c7097472b09e54f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e0883b4d76ba76f86c433358","recordId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"Instability and charge-superradiant amplification are separate targets of the background comparison.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a8462355b8345f4de4ca2f160ed6111c4da144694744eda5979bec47656c029f","home":{"unitId":"unit:a8462355b8345f4de4ca2f160ed6111c4da144694744eda5979bec47656c029f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:46fc37476acf84e240866e4b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a8462355b8345f4de4ca2f160ed6111c4da144694744eda5979bec47656c029f","paperId":"2505.02340","textSha256":"f99c3b621b0ba136c9c24fb51b462e2685250e0621ee709b140e400c1b5f938a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:72c8e10f477e03d1ffdac882"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:72c8e10f477e03d1ffdac882","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a8462355b8345f4de4ca2f160ed6111c4da144694744eda5979bec47656c029f","q025-candidate-region:46fc37476acf84e240866e4b"],"scopeContentSha256":"b57275e8f49c4ae0f8d2f94ba9d351f8b437ff9b5e0f97213cbe1a5dcf3df462","placementContentSha256":"87ca6da8cb052b9d1014f795eab71f7500361dc5fd9a7362a8ca202cc36e3f58","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge","leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a8462355b8345f4de4ca2f160ed6111c4da144694744eda5979bec47656c029f","paperId":"2505.02340","textSha256":"f99c3b621b0ba136c9c24fb51b462e2685250e0621ee709b140e400c1b5f938a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:72c8e10f477e03d1ffdac882"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a8462355b8345f4de4ca2f160ed6111c4da144694744eda5979bec47656c029f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:daef9e3af4a064e1f0fcc30a","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:a8462355b8345f4de4ca2f160ed6111c4da144694744eda5979bec47656c029f","textSha256":"f99c3b621b0ba136c9c24fb51b462e2685250e0621ee709b140e400c1b5f938a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c443947686e0e33300bdd50b","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound branch, thermal and scalar-perturbation targets. Theory unspecified here; RN is explicitly not an exact solution. Independent challenge qualification: Compound branch, thermodynamic and scalar-perturbation targets. The theory is unspecified here; RN is explicitly not an exact solution."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c443947686e0e33300bdd50b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a8462355b8345f4de4ca2f160ed6111c4da144694744eda5979bec47656c029f","q025-candidate-question:daef9e3af4a064e1f0fcc30a"],"scopeContentSha256":"475a4b303fa84fd23af70524c38d4203b9b74d14ea586f5eda96550878a0adbf","contributionContentSha256":"bf4c8d82d092fe744d229bc90fc556c7041041ba16d8267859bdbcef2be60f7e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:a8462355b8345f4de4ca2f160ed6111c4da144694744eda5979bec47656c029f","textSha256":"f99c3b621b0ba136c9c24fb51b462e2685250e0621ee709b140e400c1b5f938a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c443947686e0e33300bdd50b","recordId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound branch, thermal and scalar-perturbation targets. Theory unspecified here; RN is explicitly not an exact solution.","challengeNote":"Compound branch, thermodynamic and scalar-perturbation targets. The theory is unspecified here; RN is explicitly not an exact solution.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d46a49b3db66d0c0bbc94177cbaa0c544a7ba213e69c9cf57eb56be2c5e4602b","home":{"unitId":"unit:d46a49b3db66d0c0bbc94177cbaa0c544a7ba213e69c9cf57eb56be2c5e4602b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:46fc37476acf84e240866e4b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d46a49b3db66d0c0bbc94177cbaa0c544a7ba213e69c9cf57eb56be2c5e4602b","paperId":"2508.12378","textSha256":"8b253843c2818c58fdd2fdfc89dab380f3bedd1d495ec683fa578f10b75d1326"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:41485b8994713e4d62cc75fd"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:41485b8994713e4d62cc75fd","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d46a49b3db66d0c0bbc94177cbaa0c544a7ba213e69c9cf57eb56be2c5e4602b","q025-candidate-region:46fc37476acf84e240866e4b"],"scopeContentSha256":"b57275e8f49c4ae0f8d2f94ba9d351f8b437ff9b5e0f97213cbe1a5dcf3df462","placementContentSha256":"38518ea1d460853b9c5877d54d564017c5bf0e3bfd2e885a8c5ae45772368d0b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge","leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d46a49b3db66d0c0bbc94177cbaa0c544a7ba213e69c9cf57eb56be2c5e4602b","paperId":"2508.12378","textSha256":"8b253843c2818c58fdd2fdfc89dab380f3bedd1d495ec683fa578f10b75d1326"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:41485b8994713e4d62cc75fd"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d46a49b3db66d0c0bbc94177cbaa0c544a7ba213e69c9cf57eb56be2c5e4602b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:daef9e3af4a064e1f0fcc30a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:d46a49b3db66d0c0bbc94177cbaa0c544a7ba213e69c9cf57eb56be2c5e4602b","textSha256":"8b253843c2818c58fdd2fdfc89dab380f3bedd1d495ec683fa578f10b75d1326"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3cbab652708470442b7b0c67","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound WGC/stabilization proposal; no validated bound or stability criterion is supplied. Independent challenge qualification: Compound WGC/stabilization proposal; CUDA use establishes neither numerical accuracy nor a stability criterion."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3cbab652708470442b7b0c67","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d46a49b3db66d0c0bbc94177cbaa0c544a7ba213e69c9cf57eb56be2c5e4602b","q025-candidate-question:daef9e3af4a064e1f0fcc30a"],"scopeContentSha256":"475a4b303fa84fd23af70524c38d4203b9b74d14ea586f5eda96550878a0adbf","contributionContentSha256":"6b7f0a739488e2713c2022309ed06b62e6cfb2c1df500d87923b92a2fcc84960","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:d46a49b3db66d0c0bbc94177cbaa0c544a7ba213e69c9cf57eb56be2c5e4602b","textSha256":"8b253843c2818c58fdd2fdfc89dab380f3bedd1d495ec683fa578f10b75d1326"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3cbab652708470442b7b0c67","recordId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6a8eee7ad5a3c4a75a48-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound WGC/stabilization proposal; no validated bound or stability criterion is supplied.","challengeNote":"Compound WGC/stabilization proposal; CUDA use establishes neither numerical accuracy nor a stability criterion.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":4,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"b3a22820c311c835cbf1cda784575b0a6793a214365749da84e508f2dd038e57"},"organizational-access:8283bcf3c33a87a9be4731a6":{"id":"organizational-access:8283bcf3c33a87a9be4731a6","source":"q025-candidate-region:472111c9e43c5f2f1a378254","target":"q025-candidate-question:7ebf30528dd9aea4b5abce70","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:472111c9e43c5f2f1a378254","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"33b4f10f299ff08cbe65edd939a0757534c09afdc4d168ea1b75b60ad029c32d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:08f065df6e8fcf5efcb3809a"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:7ebf30528dd9aea4b5abce70","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"5cb48c98bdfe9d122f9dcc819b135cf48f6079841a12f3f6bbaf6a9bc8587dd1","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3e5c7d8517313d9a1d269133"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4f4249160a532694dee91f0597c588bd8b455c97fa6f9392b8f520c2a3d5091b","home":{"unitId":"unit:4f4249160a532694dee91f0597c588bd8b455c97fa6f9392b8f520c2a3d5091b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:472111c9e43c5f2f1a378254","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4f4249160a532694dee91f0597c588bd8b455c97fa6f9392b8f520c2a3d5091b","paperId":"2101.08882","textSha256":"2546c03926ddf23b65af1f9631c252877962c850509d05fdb23ece542fa264be"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e2e3d5a27e0d917ac7b6f4c7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e2e3d5a27e0d917ac7b6f4c7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4f4249160a532694dee91f0597c588bd8b455c97fa6f9392b8f520c2a3d5091b","q025-candidate-region:472111c9e43c5f2f1a378254"],"scopeContentSha256":"33b4f10f299ff08cbe65edd939a0757534c09afdc4d168ea1b75b60ad029c32d","placementContentSha256":"38ad91fd7f66893c092a71a187a4ba566c47e6f826b344190911d0a31b280f2d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge","leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4f4249160a532694dee91f0597c588bd8b455c97fa6f9392b8f520c2a3d5091b","paperId":"2101.08882","textSha256":"2546c03926ddf23b65af1f9631c252877962c850509d05fdb23ece542fa264be"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e2e3d5a27e0d917ac7b6f4c7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4f4249160a532694dee91f0597c588bd8b455c97fa6f9392b8f520c2a3d5091b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7ebf30528dd9aea4b5abce70","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:4f4249160a532694dee91f0597c588bd8b455c97fa6f9392b8f520c2a3d5091b","textSha256":"2546c03926ddf23b65af1f9631c252877962c850509d05fdb23ece542fa264be"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a686deb5eef6ee5debbaf28e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a686deb5eef6ee5debbaf28e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4f4249160a532694dee91f0597c588bd8b455c97fa6f9392b8f520c2a3d5091b","q025-candidate-question:7ebf30528dd9aea4b5abce70"],"scopeContentSha256":"5cb48c98bdfe9d122f9dcc819b135cf48f6079841a12f3f6bbaf6a9bc8587dd1","contributionContentSha256":"9d8a645341a6a60a1e1ebea517a856a98395f6c120a24736b2e025b653208aa4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:4f4249160a532694dee91f0597c588bd8b455c97fa6f9392b8f520c2a3d5091b","textSha256":"2546c03926ddf23b65af1f9631c252877962c850509d05fdb23ece542fa264be"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a686deb5eef6ee5debbaf28e","recordId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound inflation, reheating and leptogenesis targets; no fine merge with the neighboring setting facet.","challengeNote":"Compound inflation, reheating and leptogenesis targets; equivalence to the neighboring setting facet remains unestablished.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:669f5afce6c68784089f23b484b0177084c337d0dc094328a1a353d6fc651ef2","home":{"unitId":"unit:669f5afce6c68784089f23b484b0177084c337d0dc094328a1a353d6fc651ef2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:472111c9e43c5f2f1a378254","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:669f5afce6c68784089f23b484b0177084c337d0dc094328a1a353d6fc651ef2","paperId":"2301.02631","textSha256":"d0030cd8142b0d975dbfd154c0bc737786d01bcaec9310eecbb656c659cb3aee"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8198e85120fc6a94c4c06626"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8198e85120fc6a94c4c06626","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:669f5afce6c68784089f23b484b0177084c337d0dc094328a1a353d6fc651ef2","q025-candidate-region:472111c9e43c5f2f1a378254"],"scopeContentSha256":"33b4f10f299ff08cbe65edd939a0757534c09afdc4d168ea1b75b60ad029c32d","placementContentSha256":"a6f34eb2bc185e370a2593d7b5a23d87473520544b469e850ba09b5003bb9e7c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge","leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:669f5afce6c68784089f23b484b0177084c337d0dc094328a1a353d6fc651ef2","paperId":"2301.02631","textSha256":"d0030cd8142b0d975dbfd154c0bc737786d01bcaec9310eecbb656c659cb3aee"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8198e85120fc6a94c4c06626"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:669f5afce6c68784089f23b484b0177084c337d0dc094328a1a353d6fc651ef2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7ebf30528dd9aea4b5abce70","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:669f5afce6c68784089f23b484b0177084c337d0dc094328a1a353d6fc651ef2","textSha256":"d0030cd8142b0d975dbfd154c0bc737786d01bcaec9310eecbb656c659cb3aee"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f0566094622504caeb531985"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f0566094622504caeb531985","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:669f5afce6c68784089f23b484b0177084c337d0dc094328a1a353d6fc651ef2","q025-candidate-question:7ebf30528dd9aea4b5abce70"],"scopeContentSha256":"5cb48c98bdfe9d122f9dcc819b135cf48f6079841a12f3f6bbaf6a9bc8587dd1","contributionContentSha256":"e95e24eacac7e2e20bfcb2305e58c075963cb1e13ebf19b6e0a6e957171f201e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:669f5afce6c68784089f23b484b0177084c337d0dc094328a1a353d6fc651ef2","textSha256":"d0030cd8142b0d975dbfd154c0bc737786d01bcaec9310eecbb656c659cb3aee"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f0566094622504caeb531985","recordId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound effective-potential, CMB, reheating and wave-bound targets.","challengeNote":"Compound effective-potential, CMB, reheating and gravitational-wave-bound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:78526b4e8286fc67e54948a1a73174d53a0a7471908fb591c76b06c7721a0010","home":{"unitId":"unit:78526b4e8286fc67e54948a1a73174d53a0a7471908fb591c76b06c7721a0010","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:472111c9e43c5f2f1a378254","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:78526b4e8286fc67e54948a1a73174d53a0a7471908fb591c76b06c7721a0010","paperId":"2605.01992","textSha256":"64591996dede37381bf895816d06fc8af2804a50153ea2d7e96188738f31e0ea"},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9087af191cfcc80eb62ebb8d689f141a","paperId":"2605.01992","sourceSha256":"2d0c99432696547faaf79cf96809db830cf2c6e95d021f433aa1ed4f74951ae9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/099b3089b1d1995236ae/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ec2d1dd9665f0b4f9271339b8cb507e5ae59cef101d0ee96f26bc4a532dc1fa4","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2917,"textSha256":"898c7cfc3cdda174b81f5f232e7cd4ece26d9a14b46e910c1038f7e49bd3f7d9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1d6d401f8539a94c1008cacb5dd847bd","paperId":"2605.01992","sourceSha256":"2d0c99432696547faaf79cf96809db830cf2c6e95d021f433aa1ed4f74951ae9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/099b3089b1d1995236ae/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ec2d1dd9665f0b4f9271339b8cb507e5ae59cef101d0ee96f26bc4a532dc1fa4","pdfPage":4,"start":95,"end":2527,"textSha256":"9de19a222f1c09f4111aff3bd6854b7a92b53c95c3b21754f1f79ee37dd49fa3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e57dcd22037cdb18b4d4302d"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e57dcd22037cdb18b4d4302d","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:78526b4e8286fc67e54948a1a73174d53a0a7471908fb591c76b06c7721a0010","q025-candidate-region:472111c9e43c5f2f1a378254"],"scopeContentSha256":"33b4f10f299ff08cbe65edd939a0757534c09afdc4d168ea1b75b60ad029c32d","placementContentSha256":"de53f46d84a2d93cfcf3c06209a447ccc81fda41b8b7d3b01a92278c9954020a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge","leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:78526b4e8286fc67e54948a1a73174d53a0a7471908fb591c76b06c7721a0010","paperId":"2605.01992","textSha256":"64591996dede37381bf895816d06fc8af2804a50153ea2d7e96188738f31e0ea"},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9087af191cfcc80eb62ebb8d689f141a","paperId":"2605.01992","sourceSha256":"2d0c99432696547faaf79cf96809db830cf2c6e95d021f433aa1ed4f74951ae9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/099b3089b1d1995236ae/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ec2d1dd9665f0b4f9271339b8cb507e5ae59cef101d0ee96f26bc4a532dc1fa4","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2917,"textSha256":"898c7cfc3cdda174b81f5f232e7cd4ece26d9a14b46e910c1038f7e49bd3f7d9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1d6d401f8539a94c1008cacb5dd847bd","paperId":"2605.01992","sourceSha256":"2d0c99432696547faaf79cf96809db830cf2c6e95d021f433aa1ed4f74951ae9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/099b3089b1d1995236ae/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ec2d1dd9665f0b4f9271339b8cb507e5ae59cef101d0ee96f26bc4a532dc1fa4","pdfPage":4,"start":95,"end":2527,"textSha256":"9de19a222f1c09f4111aff3bd6854b7a92b53c95c3b21754f1f79ee37dd49fa3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e57dcd22037cdb18b4d4302d"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:78526b4e8286fc67e54948a1a73174d53a0a7471908fb591c76b06c7721a0010","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7ebf30528dd9aea4b5abce70","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:78526b4e8286fc67e54948a1a73174d53a0a7471908fb591c76b06c7721a0010","textSha256":"64591996dede37381bf895816d06fc8af2804a50153ea2d7e96188738f31e0ea"},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9087af191cfcc80eb62ebb8d689f141a","paperId":"2605.01992","sourceSha256":"2d0c99432696547faaf79cf96809db830cf2c6e95d021f433aa1ed4f74951ae9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/099b3089b1d1995236ae/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ec2d1dd9665f0b4f9271339b8cb507e5ae59cef101d0ee96f26bc4a532dc1fa4","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2917,"textSha256":"898c7cfc3cdda174b81f5f232e7cd4ece26d9a14b46e910c1038f7e49bd3f7d9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1d6d401f8539a94c1008cacb5dd847bd","paperId":"2605.01992","sourceSha256":"2d0c99432696547faaf79cf96809db830cf2c6e95d021f433aa1ed4f74951ae9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/099b3089b1d1995236ae/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ec2d1dd9665f0b4f9271339b8cb507e5ae59cef101d0ee96f26bc4a532dc1fa4","pdfPage":4,"start":95,"end":2527,"textSha256":"9de19a222f1c09f4111aff3bd6854b7a92b53c95c3b21754f1f79ee37dd49fa3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b681a34f914aade1c5ceac74"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b681a34f914aade1c5ceac74","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:78526b4e8286fc67e54948a1a73174d53a0a7471908fb591c76b06c7721a0010","q025-candidate-question:7ebf30528dd9aea4b5abce70"],"scopeContentSha256":"5cb48c98bdfe9d122f9dcc819b135cf48f6079841a12f3f6bbaf6a9bc8587dd1","contributionContentSha256":"1afed6197527b2c89c7019d629cd9f99d1411f0aef8d1c3329cce389645cf659","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:78526b4e8286fc67e54948a1a73174d53a0a7471908fb591c76b06c7721a0010","textSha256":"64591996dede37381bf895816d06fc8af2804a50153ea2d7e96188738f31e0ea"},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9087af191cfcc80eb62ebb8d689f141a","paperId":"2605.01992","sourceSha256":"2d0c99432696547faaf79cf96809db830cf2c6e95d021f433aa1ed4f74951ae9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/099b3089b1d1995236ae/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ec2d1dd9665f0b4f9271339b8cb507e5ae59cef101d0ee96f26bc4a532dc1fa4","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2917,"textSha256":"898c7cfc3cdda174b81f5f232e7cd4ece26d9a14b46e910c1038f7e49bd3f7d9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1d6d401f8539a94c1008cacb5dd847bd","paperId":"2605.01992","sourceSha256":"2d0c99432696547faaf79cf96809db830cf2c6e95d021f433aa1ed4f74951ae9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/099b3089b1d1995236ae/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ec2d1dd9665f0b4f9271339b8cb507e5ae59cef101d0ee96f26bc4a532dc1fa4","pdfPage":4,"start":95,"end":2527,"textSha256":"9de19a222f1c09f4111aff3bd6854b7a92b53c95c3b21754f1f79ee37dd49fa3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b681a34f914aade1c5ceac74","recordId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound CMB/reheating/GW target across two potential families. The quoted tilt is archived motivation; swampland tests are additional diagnostics.","challengeNote":"Compound CMB/reheating/GW program across two potential families. The quoted tilt is historical motivation; conjecture tests are additional diagnostics.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:961c2088e77763734c186a81861c570193563e8ae9dfc9e9d4f9bebdf689d4fc","home":{"unitId":"unit:961c2088e77763734c186a81861c570193563e8ae9dfc9e9d4f9bebdf689d4fc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:472111c9e43c5f2f1a378254","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:961c2088e77763734c186a81861c570193563e8ae9dfc9e9d4f9bebdf689d4fc","paperId":"2301.08319","textSha256":"673cb03ce77ae88454dddfbf31954fbafaaf098d8fb26a62ebfcc14637183ef8"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3125f3ce8fe134b67dff58db"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3125f3ce8fe134b67dff58db","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:961c2088e77763734c186a81861c570193563e8ae9dfc9e9d4f9bebdf689d4fc","q025-candidate-region:472111c9e43c5f2f1a378254"],"scopeContentSha256":"33b4f10f299ff08cbe65edd939a0757534c09afdc4d168ea1b75b60ad029c32d","placementContentSha256":"f787c36cdefa7b7db040cc4d06dbb12fc1d09084a8248676d951754d0107cd01","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge","leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:961c2088e77763734c186a81861c570193563e8ae9dfc9e9d4f9bebdf689d4fc","paperId":"2301.08319","textSha256":"673cb03ce77ae88454dddfbf31954fbafaaf098d8fb26a62ebfcc14637183ef8"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3125f3ce8fe134b67dff58db"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:961c2088e77763734c186a81861c570193563e8ae9dfc9e9d4f9bebdf689d4fc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7ebf30528dd9aea4b5abce70","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:961c2088e77763734c186a81861c570193563e8ae9dfc9e9d4f9bebdf689d4fc","textSha256":"673cb03ce77ae88454dddfbf31954fbafaaf098d8fb26a62ebfcc14637183ef8"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1297dd39d19205d54533bb5f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1297dd39d19205d54533bb5f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:961c2088e77763734c186a81861c570193563e8ae9dfc9e9d4f9bebdf689d4fc","q025-candidate-question:7ebf30528dd9aea4b5abce70"],"scopeContentSha256":"5cb48c98bdfe9d122f9dcc819b135cf48f6079841a12f3f6bbaf6a9bc8587dd1","contributionContentSha256":"24422218af1187d653f031d7c297d29fd6bf62be8cfa8560ce4257c6934196c7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:961c2088e77763734c186a81861c570193563e8ae9dfc9e9d4f9bebdf689d4fc","textSha256":"673cb03ce77ae88454dddfbf31954fbafaaf098d8fb26a62ebfcc14637183ef8"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1297dd39d19205d54533bb5f","recordId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound CMB, reheating-wave and conjecture/TCC targets; no atomic identity is asserted.","challengeNote":"Retains the compound CMB, reheating-wave, swampland and TCC targets without claiming atomic identity.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:986cc3438593bf737b2f5ded77dac166746b4910078d235a25202191baefe6ca","home":{"unitId":"unit:986cc3438593bf737b2f5ded77dac166746b4910078d235a25202191baefe6ca","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:472111c9e43c5f2f1a378254","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:986cc3438593bf737b2f5ded77dac166746b4910078d235a25202191baefe6ca","paperId":"2006.09489","textSha256":"e0742033cc4d605455bad050e5c47690931cd9fcbb866e703d389190e5a1e65f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0cae7fd70fab535182aca5e6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0cae7fd70fab535182aca5e6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:986cc3438593bf737b2f5ded77dac166746b4910078d235a25202191baefe6ca","q025-candidate-region:472111c9e43c5f2f1a378254"],"scopeContentSha256":"33b4f10f299ff08cbe65edd939a0757534c09afdc4d168ea1b75b60ad029c32d","placementContentSha256":"f6b4ea35264adf90de96a0151315309132a219ac0b6b29be95f7fd7be4068585","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge","leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:986cc3438593bf737b2f5ded77dac166746b4910078d235a25202191baefe6ca","paperId":"2006.09489","textSha256":"e0742033cc4d605455bad050e5c47690931cd9fcbb866e703d389190e5a1e65f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0cae7fd70fab535182aca5e6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:986cc3438593bf737b2f5ded77dac166746b4910078d235a25202191baefe6ca","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7ebf30528dd9aea4b5abce70","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:986cc3438593bf737b2f5ded77dac166746b4910078d235a25202191baefe6ca","textSha256":"e0742033cc4d605455bad050e5c47690931cd9fcbb866e703d389190e5a1e65f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:22b8733ff832d86f237e6776"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:22b8733ff832d86f237e6776","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:986cc3438593bf737b2f5ded77dac166746b4910078d235a25202191baefe6ca","q025-candidate-question:7ebf30528dd9aea4b5abce70"],"scopeContentSha256":"5cb48c98bdfe9d122f9dcc819b135cf48f6079841a12f3f6bbaf6a9bc8587dd1","contributionContentSha256":"d47fdfeb53276ca5fb9fb272244787bcced101c76564b2c02c30c93a5dd5c4c4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:986cc3438593bf737b2f5ded77dac166746b4910078d235a25202191baefe6ca","textSha256":"e0742033cc4d605455bad050e5c47690931cd9fcbb866e703d389190e5a1e65f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:22b8733ff832d86f237e6776","recordId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound inflation, reheating and TCC restrictions.","challengeNote":"Compound inflation, reheating and TCC restrictions.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:eb2a504f6e64f91d627415b18724859a29a7c5c136906288d5e5af36840c9223","home":{"unitId":"unit:eb2a504f6e64f91d627415b18724859a29a7c5c136906288d5e5af36840c9223","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:472111c9e43c5f2f1a378254","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:eb2a504f6e64f91d627415b18724859a29a7c5c136906288d5e5af36840c9223","paperId":"2101.08882","textSha256":"b1d60d2182b87232853b9fbbd613d3ea5c051c5671db531855e815c5ce406670"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7edd41823dc519a8231a77b3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7edd41823dc519a8231a77b3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:eb2a504f6e64f91d627415b18724859a29a7c5c136906288d5e5af36840c9223","q025-candidate-region:472111c9e43c5f2f1a378254"],"scopeContentSha256":"33b4f10f299ff08cbe65edd939a0757534c09afdc4d168ea1b75b60ad029c32d","placementContentSha256":"3eb0c1979b082c7a841134e7c042d8234e226e024f6d3817a87213cf257c642a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge","leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:eb2a504f6e64f91d627415b18724859a29a7c5c136906288d5e5af36840c9223","paperId":"2101.08882","textSha256":"b1d60d2182b87232853b9fbbd613d3ea5c051c5671db531855e815c5ce406670"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7edd41823dc519a8231a77b3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:eb2a504f6e64f91d627415b18724859a29a7c5c136906288d5e5af36840c9223","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7ebf30528dd9aea4b5abce70","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:eb2a504f6e64f91d627415b18724859a29a7c5c136906288d5e5af36840c9223","textSha256":"b1d60d2182b87232853b9fbbd613d3ea5c051c5671db531855e815c5ce406670"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:368b2e2053aace16ca1251b3"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:368b2e2053aace16ca1251b3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:eb2a504f6e64f91d627415b18724859a29a7c5c136906288d5e5af36840c9223","q025-candidate-question:7ebf30528dd9aea4b5abce70"],"scopeContentSha256":"5cb48c98bdfe9d122f9dcc819b135cf48f6079841a12f3f6bbaf6a9bc8587dd1","contributionContentSha256":"2cfad90c8e819b6d96d11d2013a7bf9e651d1cc8ffcd9bfbc85cf66fbae0c991","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:eb2a504f6e64f91d627415b18724859a29a7c5c136906288d5e5af36840c9223","textSha256":"b1d60d2182b87232853b9fbbd613d3ea5c051c5671db531855e815c5ce406670"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:368b2e2053aace16ca1251b3","recordId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c64e797c2bfd30a0715b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Additional consistency requirements are unspecified; swampland and leptogenesis targets are not imported from the neighboring facet.","challengeNote":"Additional consistency requirements remain unspecified; neighboring swampland and leptogenesis targets are not imported.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":6,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"49120cba79e71e9925a703709204ee75805a649e5588b82b1165adf1a96cfc49"},"organizational-access:324d12c75881d03c188a884f":{"id":"organizational-access:324d12c75881d03c188a884f","source":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","target":"q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b917a551e8b5c2d24f59328c"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2ff344db1d66f83707f66f37"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4944b8b9cf53d1d4456a84d4768fc256efd3daa81c878fcfc199c572e00bbb76","home":{"unitId":"unit:4944b8b9cf53d1d4456a84d4768fc256efd3daa81c878fcfc199c572e00bbb76","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4944b8b9cf53d1d4456a84d4768fc256efd3daa81c878fcfc199c572e00bbb76","paperId":"1811.07908","textSha256":"93ba3e5fdb12d06864bfc2c9cff1e775136441f79f16a3007487be3a05cd64a4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5ed62eacdfaf3c348d93c3b1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5ed62eacdfaf3c348d93c3b1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4944b8b9cf53d1d4456a84d4768fc256efd3daa81c878fcfc199c572e00bbb76","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"b2b1a8992bdae782f7d85da18db0dc66826415c3be014e2d8cc39a9b587dd4fb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4944b8b9cf53d1d4456a84d4768fc256efd3daa81c878fcfc199c572e00bbb76","paperId":"1811.07908","textSha256":"93ba3e5fdb12d06864bfc2c9cff1e775136441f79f16a3007487be3a05cd64a4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5ed62eacdfaf3c348d93c3b1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4944b8b9cf53d1d4456a84d4768fc256efd3daa81c878fcfc199c572e00bbb76","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:4944b8b9cf53d1d4456a84d4768fc256efd3daa81c878fcfc199c572e00bbb76","textSha256":"93ba3e5fdb12d06864bfc2c9cff1e775136441f79f16a3007487be3a05cd64a4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a496e3b943179f91cb4a7acc","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a496e3b943179f91cb4a7acc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4944b8b9cf53d1d4456a84d4768fc256efd3daa81c878fcfc199c572e00bbb76","q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a"],"scopeContentSha256":"b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50","contributionContentSha256":"1189062bf7f1cc4efb3838d1c859c768233029f14ed0a75eca33692e1178d376","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:4944b8b9cf53d1d4456a84d4768fc256efd3daa81c878fcfc199c572e00bbb76","textSha256":"93ba3e5fdb12d06864bfc2c9cff1e775136441f79f16a3007487be3a05cd64a4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a496e3b943179f91cb4a7acc","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}},"canonicalTarget":{"originalDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a","currentDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067","originalScopeContentSha256":"b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50","currentScopeContentSha256":"b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd","identityGroupId":"identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7"}}]},{"unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","home":{"unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","paperId":"1802.08698","textSha256":"5d0a687405a4a129aa50a2e87696184884adbcb0ede13dfdfd02895d528d29fb"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:57977f3ca04d1b9b2f8ce26c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:57977f3ca04d1b9b2f8ce26c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"6d170711850f7cdafb15cb46df03a4944dcfaf59b58ec2c4f3bb5b277a8e0e2b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","paperId":"1802.08698","textSha256":"5d0a687405a4a129aa50a2e87696184884adbcb0ede13dfdfd02895d528d29fb"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:57977f3ca04d1b9b2f8ce26c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","textSha256":"5d0a687405a4a129aa50a2e87696184884adbcb0ede13dfdfd02895d528d29fb"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:df7b4f9b0984eccaa33fdb39","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound identity unresolved: infrared diagnostics and the foundational necessity of moduli or massless towers are separate questions. Independent challenge qualification: Compound identity remains unresolved: infrared diagnostics and the foundational necessity of moduli or massless towers are separate targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:df7b4f9b0984eccaa33fdb39","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a"],"scopeContentSha256":"b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50","contributionContentSha256":"3b51ce26b1f888eebce99949ae5b5bde4463803ab0a0dd36e93461ba81c318a7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","textSha256":"5d0a687405a4a129aa50a2e87696184884adbcb0ede13dfdfd02895d528d29fb"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:df7b4f9b0984eccaa33fdb39","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound identity unresolved: infrared diagnostics and the foundational necessity of moduli or massless towers are separate questions.","challengeNote":"Compound identity remains unresolved: infrared diagnostics and the foundational necessity of moduli or massless towers are separate targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}},"canonicalTarget":{"originalDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a","currentDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067","originalScopeContentSha256":"b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50","currentScopeContentSha256":"b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd","identityGroupId":"identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7"}},{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","qualification":"Confirm the infrared-diagnostic contribution at the reused completion destination. Whether quantum gravity guarantees moduli and massless towers remains a separate unresolved target, not an assumed premise. Independent confirmation: The infrared-diagnostic target in u17 addresses completion compatibility at c10 after reuse. The row correctly keeps the separate necessity of moduli and massless towers unresolved rather than importing it as a premise.","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u17","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","textSha256":"5d0a687405a4a129aa50a2e87696184884adbcb0ede13dfdfd02895d528d29fb","paperId":"1802.08698"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:role:2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:role:2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067"],"challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal","challengeReviewId":"strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u17","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","textSha256":"5d0a687405a4a129aa50a2e87696184884adbcb0ede13dfdfd02895d528d29fb","paperId":"1802.08698"}],"originalRole":{"unitRef":"u17","questionRef":"c10","role":"addresses","reason":"Confirm the infrared-diagnostic contribution at the reused completion destination. Whether quantum gravity guarantees moduli and massless towers remains a separate unresolved target, not an assumed premise.","refs":["u17","c9","c10","n8"]},"independentAssessment":{"index":2,"verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The infrared-diagnostic target in u17 addresses completion compatibility at c10 after reuse. The row correctly keeps the separate necessity of moduli and massless towers unresolved rather than importing it as a premise.","refs":["u17","c9","c10","n8"]},"contextRefs":[{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a"},{"localRef":"c10","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067"},{"localRef":"n8","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893","reviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"scopeContentSha256":"b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd","contributionContentSha256":"c6099a12ad48d27d3222abbee399d954df9cccf31a33a51758f198bd3cdc8963","coordinatorAdmissionReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/navigation-admissions-v4/strong-scope-bundle-02-admission.json","sha256":"212f07546ff95e3c403f24490cb07deb907c8354f8d2033c9358bbb2e1412070"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","home":{"unitId":"unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","paperId":"2107.00087","textSha256":"b01635e1b0a56b493eae67738dbcc3947293f80ddbadc9c1bc1e475a7bf3c567"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c038e8ad25249552dd2ad2c3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c038e8ad25249552dd2ad2c3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"68a3085bab3c8f1615fc25e15d2e53c110dd94280f37bd3fe5a282e6a0c0db84","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","paperId":"2107.00087","textSha256":"b01635e1b0a56b493eae67738dbcc3947293f80ddbadc9c1bc1e475a7bf3c567"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c038e8ad25249552dd2ad2c3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","textSha256":"b01635e1b0a56b493eae67738dbcc3947293f80ddbadc9c1bc1e475a7bf3c567"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8e71cc120ff53b490ee93b1f","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8e71cc120ff53b490ee93b1f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a"],"scopeContentSha256":"b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50","contributionContentSha256":"6062e8d512f9b2f0a60f8b4ef2794f948b3eedbe60a58a9142dc92aa380c0c4c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","textSha256":"b01635e1b0a56b493eae67738dbcc3947293f80ddbadc9c1bc1e475a7bf3c567"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8e71cc120ff53b490ee93b1f","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}},"canonicalTarget":{"originalDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a","currentDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067","originalScopeContentSha256":"b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50","currentScopeContentSha256":"b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd","identityGroupId":"identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7"}}]},{"unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","home":{"unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","paperId":"1801.03503","textSha256":"70666671b810a7cbb77a17ef0ab9ad3ee1e8f88209200d70d37a4cdaf70aa1d6"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:77052e39d59537333930fa21"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:77052e39d59537333930fa21","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"0ac0a363672d8fb5a9ebd23ca5f4379c2c63361994887bce3c83344ca94e4bcb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","paperId":"1801.03503","textSha256":"70666671b810a7cbb77a17ef0ab9ad3ee1e8f88209200d70d37a4cdaf70aa1d6"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:77052e39d59537333930fa21"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","textSha256":"70666671b810a7cbb77a17ef0ab9ad3ee1e8f88209200d70d37a4cdaf70aa1d6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c22945452abae3a1ff1cd39a","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The description's reference to established restrictions does not identify or independently verify particular restrictions. Independent challenge qualification: The description does not identify or independently verify the restrictions it calls established."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c22945452abae3a1ff1cd39a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a"],"scopeContentSha256":"b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50","contributionContentSha256":"dd9a796626ffafa720166f2c98454555eecf01677ff2d014d1c8f21fc0d5478c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","textSha256":"70666671b810a7cbb77a17ef0ab9ad3ee1e8f88209200d70d37a4cdaf70aa1d6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c22945452abae3a1ff1cd39a","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"The description's reference to established restrictions does not identify or independently verify particular restrictions.","challengeNote":"The description does not identify or independently verify the restrictions it calls established.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}},"canonicalTarget":{"originalDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a","currentDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067","originalScopeContentSha256":"b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50","currentScopeContentSha256":"b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd","identityGroupId":"identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7"}},{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","qualification":"Confirm access through the completion question for low-energy remnants and tests of proposed restrictions. The description does not identify or independently verify the restrictions it calls established. Independent confirmation: u28 addresses low-energy tests of quantum-gravity restrictions, matching the inherited c9 contribution and c10's consistency-testing programme. The row preserves n7's limitation that the restrictions called established are neither identified nor independently verified.","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u28","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","textSha256":"70666671b810a7cbb77a17ef0ab9ad3ee1e8f88209200d70d37a4cdaf70aa1d6","paperId":"1801.03503"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:role:1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:role:1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067"],"challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal","challengeReviewId":"strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u28","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","textSha256":"70666671b810a7cbb77a17ef0ab9ad3ee1e8f88209200d70d37a4cdaf70aa1d6","paperId":"1801.03503"}],"originalRole":{"unitRef":"u28","questionRef":"c10","role":"addresses","reason":"Confirm access through the completion question for low-energy remnants and tests of proposed restrictions. The description does not identify or independently verify the restrictions it calls established.","refs":["u28","c9","c10","n7"]},"independentAssessment":{"index":1,"verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"u28 addresses low-energy tests of quantum-gravity restrictions, matching the inherited c9 contribution and c10's consistency-testing programme. The row preserves n7's limitation that the restrictions called established are neither identified nor independently verified.","refs":["u28","c9","c10","n7"]},"contextRefs":[{"localRef":"c9","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a"},{"localRef":"c10","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067"},{"localRef":"n7","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","reviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"scopeContentSha256":"b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd","contributionContentSha256":"d61b7a0013e8f2d700a3c0d6ebfbb6f36c0a5e6a0c7011f2963c1232edab7945","coordinatorAdmissionReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/navigation-admissions-v4/strong-scope-bundle-02-admission.json","sha256":"212f07546ff95e3c403f24490cb07deb907c8354f8d2033c9358bbb2e1412070"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d7447cc696117c9d733331fe499e8f584ad5d1a375fb0894895a7f5038de38b7","home":{"unitId":"unit:d7447cc696117c9d733331fe499e8f584ad5d1a375fb0894895a7f5038de38b7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d7447cc696117c9d733331fe499e8f584ad5d1a375fb0894895a7f5038de38b7","paperId":"2007.04266","textSha256":"2f87a9df354bac76ca49a7781302dd0a1f00c5146e2db320d872b202e39261b5"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eb9b87e7d4932738813aa888"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eb9b87e7d4932738813aa888","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d7447cc696117c9d733331fe499e8f584ad5d1a375fb0894895a7f5038de38b7","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"8e1dd9a379f66250892250c6f884cfa1462f6baaf6d6695b8da5bc2039809883","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d7447cc696117c9d733331fe499e8f584ad5d1a375fb0894895a7f5038de38b7","paperId":"2007.04266","textSha256":"2f87a9df354bac76ca49a7781302dd0a1f00c5146e2db320d872b202e39261b5"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eb9b87e7d4932738813aa888"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d7447cc696117c9d733331fe499e8f584ad5d1a375fb0894895a7f5038de38b7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:d7447cc696117c9d733331fe499e8f584ad5d1a375fb0894895a7f5038de38b7","textSha256":"2f87a9df354bac76ca49a7781302dd0a1f00c5146e2db320d872b202e39261b5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8a6e4543aaa29fac78ea861d","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Testing three proposed obstructions does not construct a complete UV theory. Independent challenge qualification: Testing proposed obstructions does not construct a complete ultraviolet theory."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8a6e4543aaa29fac78ea861d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d7447cc696117c9d733331fe499e8f584ad5d1a375fb0894895a7f5038de38b7","q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a"],"scopeContentSha256":"b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50","contributionContentSha256":"68c7839108d1a8cdfffcb8f6eba61828425fed6d21bc98b36c5ea63c44b8dd7a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:d7447cc696117c9d733331fe499e8f584ad5d1a375fb0894895a7f5038de38b7","textSha256":"2f87a9df354bac76ca49a7781302dd0a1f00c5146e2db320d872b202e39261b5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8a6e4543aaa29fac78ea861d","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Testing three proposed obstructions does not construct a complete UV theory.","challengeNote":"Testing proposed obstructions does not construct a complete ultraviolet theory.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}},"canonicalTarget":{"originalDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a","currentDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067","originalScopeContentSha256":"b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50","currentScopeContentSha256":"b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd","identityGroupId":"identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7"}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":5,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"7999c8351e66d9b3dd0d25402ab693583c660d2e481b5914bb94798088f0c381"},"organizational-access:3adff815c31ea1cbee3b0cfd":{"id":"organizational-access:3adff815c31ea1cbee3b0cfd","source":"q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a","target":"q025-candidate-question:34737990977f99c8376e1b23","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"30c36f42402d35fe28afd0916c0fd8f432c8e7cf296dc1a1d7ad4d05de84583c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5829fa4ebe39e2aa42ded4f1"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:34737990977f99c8376e1b23","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"d8b64ee58fecba1cd60d388093bd90c2d20eb333452cf7b991c7ca8009c94070","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:86b75d4fbb7b0e3275d51ff0"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:059d0165ad6a618c57c392fd5de56ae455082404a9422ac7fab213252390dfca","home":{"unitId":"unit:059d0165ad6a618c57c392fd5de56ae455082404a9422ac7fab213252390dfca","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:059d0165ad6a618c57c392fd5de56ae455082404a9422ac7fab213252390dfca","paperId":"hep-th/0101074","textSha256":"a48e125205f37bfd2893a66479d2e473b17aebdcf1d3cd0864ef04b88c7e8f03"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d50790805a2e6bd45034dca0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d50790805a2e6bd45034dca0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:059d0165ad6a618c57c392fd5de56ae455082404a9422ac7fab213252390dfca","q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a"],"scopeContentSha256":"30c36f42402d35fe28afd0916c0fd8f432c8e7cf296dc1a1d7ad4d05de84583c","placementContentSha256":"efe0236cd1a41515ed42359436295ef404cfd2f08a258bf3694335fc94d4cc7f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge","leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:059d0165ad6a618c57c392fd5de56ae455082404a9422ac7fab213252390dfca","paperId":"hep-th/0101074","textSha256":"a48e125205f37bfd2893a66479d2e473b17aebdcf1d3cd0864ef04b88c7e8f03"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d50790805a2e6bd45034dca0"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:059d0165ad6a618c57c392fd5de56ae455082404a9422ac7fab213252390dfca","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:34737990977f99c8376e1b23","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:059d0165ad6a618c57c392fd5de56ae455082404a9422ac7fab213252390dfca","textSha256":"a48e125205f37bfd2893a66479d2e473b17aebdcf1d3cd0864ef04b88c7e8f03"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a37e8b5fb57c6aef7fcaebfc"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a37e8b5fb57c6aef7fcaebfc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:059d0165ad6a618c57c392fd5de56ae455082404a9422ac7fab213252390dfca","q025-candidate-question:34737990977f99c8376e1b23"],"scopeContentSha256":"d8b64ee58fecba1cd60d388093bd90c2d20eb333452cf7b991c7ca8009c94070","contributionContentSha256":"085f48079e0854b2fe1475d7848d8d0cceb1b703d2a3191a88b24513ba6fd1b9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:059d0165ad6a618c57c392fd5de56ae455082404a9422ac7fab213252390dfca","textSha256":"a48e125205f37bfd2893a66479d2e473b17aebdcf1d3cd0864ef04b88c7e8f03"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a37e8b5fb57c6aef7fcaebfc","recordId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"344c52eea118d9a61c975714b633bb26c97f505a62989ec48f55d640b2158903"},"organizational-access:8413f63051d7810c61e6651c":{"id":"organizational-access:8413f63051d7810c61e6651c","source":"q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a","target":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"30c36f42402d35fe28afd0916c0fd8f432c8e7cf296dc1a1d7ad4d05de84583c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5829fa4ebe39e2aa42ded4f1"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ad449becadd3a4e1ef632d22d11437ab8b2060c64f934db103812d0ed558ea64","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e63d372fde3b4b8f1ee681f8"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:b89c54e884dd48b5eceb0027fc67d7d1637351c6a6b5c41ad4cf06e4d6eea6f7","home":{"unitId":"unit:b89c54e884dd48b5eceb0027fc67d7d1637351c6a6b5c41ad4cf06e4d6eea6f7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers matter-coupled type IIB solution construction, stability and restrictions on the resulting dimensional realization, including the proposed scale hierarchy.","qualification":"q20 combines matter-coupled construction, solution stability and conditions restricting dimensional realizations. It therefore accommodates all three open-sector tests. q5 alone lacks the new-vacuum and hierarchy targets; q18 covers construction and hierarchy but explicitly separates subsequent stability testing.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b89c54e884dd48b5eceb0027fc67d7d1637351c6a6b5c41ad4cf06e4d6eea6f7","paperId":"2507.18529","textSha256":"7760f05c428c924d7962ea366d04ba00447e3315595989d5d5cd145d773a6ff8"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0046:u28:q20"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0046:u28:q20","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b89c54e884dd48b5eceb0027fc67d7d1637351c6a6b5c41ad4cf06e4d6eea6f7","q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a"],"scopeContentSha256":"30c36f42402d35fe28afd0916c0fd8f432c8e7cf296dc1a1d7ad4d05de84583c","placementContentSha256":"66d435811657d07c7069b141ca437b5b3ccb59387bf1c066afcd62ad43b304fb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0046:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0046:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b89c54e884dd48b5eceb0027fc67d7d1637351c6a6b5c41ad4cf06e4d6eea6f7","paperId":"2507.18529","textSha256":"7760f05c428c924d7962ea366d04ba00447e3315595989d5d5cd145d773a6ff8"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0046","unitRef":"u28"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b89c54e884dd48b5eceb0027fc67d7d1637351c6a6b5c41ad4cf06e4d6eea6f7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d62","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:b89c54e884dd48b5eceb0027fc67d7d1637351c6a6b5c41ad4cf06e4d6eea6f7","textSha256":"7760f05c428c924d7962ea366d04ba00447e3315595989d5d5cd145d773a6ff8"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5b149413034a43774bbe4769"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5b149413034a43774bbe4769","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b89c54e884dd48b5eceb0027fc67d7d1637351c6a6b5c41ad4cf06e4d6eea6f7","q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e"],"scopeContentSha256":"ad449becadd3a4e1ef632d22d11437ab8b2060c64f934db103812d0ed558ea64","contributionContentSha256":"a1220b4d769c0392ed6d4380ebcd3a7bff9b1750daa9587475dd1a96feb727f0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d62","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:b89c54e884dd48b5eceb0027fc67d7d1637351c6a6b5c41ad4cf06e4d6eea6f7","textSha256":"7760f05c428c924d7962ea366d04ba00447e3315595989d5d5cd145d773a6ff8"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5b149413034a43774bbe4769","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Open-string destabilization, additional extrema and scale separation require distinct checks.","challengeNote":"Compound open-sector destabilization, additional-vacuum and scale-separation targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ce4e9445a27181075dc00d4b25bab0a1c941820a8319f28a57623576d4646039","home":{"unitId":"unit:ce4e9445a27181075dc00d4b25bab0a1c941820a8319f28a57623576d4646039","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers type IIA solution construction through flux changes and the explicitly restricted stability tests on those solutions.","qualification":"q20 explicitly combines classical solution construction and stability. It covers the flux-deformed sourceless IIA backgrounds and their left-invariant scalar tests together. Reusing supersymmetric geometry does not establish supersymmetry of the new flux choice, and passing the stated test would not establish stability of omitted sectors.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ce4e9445a27181075dc00d4b25bab0a1c941820a8319f28a57623576d4646039","paperId":"1001.0003","textSha256":"21a19b18b85cc21b46a09b99bd737f133fdd7b3aa71d5cb709276efaa520a021"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0046:u29:q20"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0046:u29:q20","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ce4e9445a27181075dc00d4b25bab0a1c941820a8319f28a57623576d4646039","q025-candidate-region:55cc6d03edaaddd66fe2de7a"],"scopeContentSha256":"30c36f42402d35fe28afd0916c0fd8f432c8e7cf296dc1a1d7ad4d05de84583c","placementContentSha256":"0d978d71753fc4954b054e234090159ac6c513aab6e340869f696f05a269421a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0046:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0046:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ce4e9445a27181075dc00d4b25bab0a1c941820a8319f28a57623576d4646039","paperId":"1001.0003","textSha256":"21a19b18b85cc21b46a09b99bd737f133fdd7b3aa71d5cb709276efaa520a021"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0046","unitRef":"u29"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ce4e9445a27181075dc00d4b25bab0a1c941820a8319f28a57623576d4646039","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:ce4e9445a27181075dc00d4b25bab0a1c941820a8319f28a57623576d4646039","textSha256":"21a19b18b85cc21b46a09b99bd737f133fdd7b3aa71d5cb709276efaa520a021"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e85521c9f0c3ce4f206d4542"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e85521c9f0c3ce4f206d4542","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ce4e9445a27181075dc00d4b25bab0a1c941820a8319f28a57623576d4646039","q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e"],"scopeContentSha256":"ad449becadd3a4e1ef632d22d11437ab8b2060c64f934db103812d0ed558ea64","contributionContentSha256":"1ece54aa810fd876c666460c539b0e011fc770abc7472108c8096f71e9b5de50","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:ce4e9445a27181075dc00d4b25bab0a1c941820a8319f28a57623576d4646039","textSha256":"21a19b18b85cc21b46a09b99bd737f133fdd7b3aa71d5cb709276efaa520a021"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e85521c9f0c3ce4f206d4542","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Supersymmetric geometry is the construction comparator; stability testing is left-invariant.","challengeNote":"Supersymmetric geometry is the construction comparator; the specified fluctuation test is left-invariant.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"de72eb7747edd852b6d925b72783ae8fc32b6aca2a42eff81257e81da423a0f8"},"organizational-access:60c6d696636f51dc27e97fb2":{"id":"organizational-access:60c6d696636f51dc27e97fb2","source":"q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a","target":"q-relic-abundance-early-matter-domination","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"2cedf2781e2953afce1e2340444d42ab59eae346b7d35bce9676fa98db3f3973","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:739782e7c50cd229ce148b16"},"target":{"id":"q-relic-abundance-early-matter-domination","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"63f9c93561235dd2757636d30607450451320364a7360de54bb98010fb8cf022","scopeDecisionId":"decision:kk-scope:p4"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4ed2ac936157aab2ac1031a731c7fd778188055e7092082eb69b67b68a11dc32","home":{"unitId":"unit:4ed2ac936157aab2ac1031a731c7fd778188055e7092082eb69b67b68a11dc32","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4ed2ac936157aab2ac1031a731c7fd778188055e7092082eb69b67b68a11dc32","paperId":"2010.03573","textSha256":"6950a4ff6fe9d2f551f6f687b358d351843a56c4a51577c050d3a38e032b6d58"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:838fea98513824e2293a8b26a8b8326f","paperId":"2010.03573","sourceSha256":"69f2ddcf93542a278aa0328987be18969e813dbaf117bb83e6a654ff24a56871","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ff64b60bb5ec38dfb4a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1fd053c1815bd5fc7cffb2580ec6bd9b76dae518c5281ddf946a4d9eeed82fbc","pdfPage":4,"start":1321,"end":3680,"textSha256":"8cd609c0305f8484508bdf8944ec071e717b57b2aed42367bd163ff5fec86758","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:97c24a2fd94894abf8da2e33e622a088","paperId":"2010.03573","sourceSha256":"69f2ddcf93542a278aa0328987be18969e813dbaf117bb83e6a654ff24a56871","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ff64b60bb5ec38dfb4a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1fd053c1815bd5fc7cffb2580ec6bd9b76dae518c5281ddf946a4d9eeed82fbc","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"1e46d1603cc969322d2ca85d05c7a01cb3561b98e4dddedf953097317f823e71","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c7ff0eff6081d519c7b388be9582dd54","paperId":"2010.03573","sourceSha256":"69f2ddcf93542a278aa0328987be18969e813dbaf117bb83e6a654ff24a56871","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ff64b60bb5ec38dfb4a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1fd053c1815bd5fc7cffb2580ec6bd9b76dae518c5281ddf946a4d9eeed82fbc","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"5ddf197e27a51e4f8587492941d377371fc4d04915cd0aaf9daae52faf7b826f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:751a4cc7a725f9f2a28e990b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:751a4cc7a725f9f2a28e990b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4ed2ac936157aab2ac1031a731c7fd778188055e7092082eb69b67b68a11dc32","q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a"],"scopeContentSha256":"2cedf2781e2953afce1e2340444d42ab59eae346b7d35bce9676fa98db3f3973","placementContentSha256":"5d5c337fd0ac52e1abdd6adb9ce8fa2486a42cbfca8112e69f0748aa19f0dd10","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge","leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4ed2ac936157aab2ac1031a731c7fd778188055e7092082eb69b67b68a11dc32","paperId":"2010.03573","textSha256":"6950a4ff6fe9d2f551f6f687b358d351843a56c4a51577c050d3a38e032b6d58"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:838fea98513824e2293a8b26a8b8326f","paperId":"2010.03573","sourceSha256":"69f2ddcf93542a278aa0328987be18969e813dbaf117bb83e6a654ff24a56871","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ff64b60bb5ec38dfb4a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1fd053c1815bd5fc7cffb2580ec6bd9b76dae518c5281ddf946a4d9eeed82fbc","pdfPage":4,"start":1321,"end":3680,"textSha256":"8cd609c0305f8484508bdf8944ec071e717b57b2aed42367bd163ff5fec86758","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:97c24a2fd94894abf8da2e33e622a088","paperId":"2010.03573","sourceSha256":"69f2ddcf93542a278aa0328987be18969e813dbaf117bb83e6a654ff24a56871","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ff64b60bb5ec38dfb4a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1fd053c1815bd5fc7cffb2580ec6bd9b76dae518c5281ddf946a4d9eeed82fbc","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"1e46d1603cc969322d2ca85d05c7a01cb3561b98e4dddedf953097317f823e71","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c7ff0eff6081d519c7b388be9582dd54","paperId":"2010.03573","sourceSha256":"69f2ddcf93542a278aa0328987be18969e813dbaf117bb83e6a654ff24a56871","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ff64b60bb5ec38dfb4a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1fd053c1815bd5fc7cffb2580ec6bd9b76dae518c5281ddf946a4d9eeed82fbc","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"5ddf197e27a51e4f8587492941d377371fc4d04915cd0aaf9daae52faf7b826f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:751a4cc7a725f9f2a28e990b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4ed2ac936157aab2ac1031a731c7fd778188055e7092082eb69b67b68a11dc32","destinationId":"q-relic-abundance-early-matter-domination","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"d88","kind":"description","unitIndex":88,"unitId":"unit:4ed2ac936157aab2ac1031a731c7fd778188055e7092082eb69b67b68a11dc32","textSha256":"6950a4ff6fe9d2f551f6f687b358d351843a56c4a51577c050d3a38e032b6d58"},{"ref":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:838fea98513824e2293a8b26a8b8326f","paperId":"2010.03573","sourceSha256":"69f2ddcf93542a278aa0328987be18969e813dbaf117bb83e6a654ff24a56871","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ff64b60bb5ec38dfb4a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1fd053c1815bd5fc7cffb2580ec6bd9b76dae518c5281ddf946a4d9eeed82fbc","pdfPage":4,"start":1321,"end":3680,"textSha256":"8cd609c0305f8484508bdf8944ec071e717b57b2aed42367bd163ff5fec86758","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:97c24a2fd94894abf8da2e33e622a088","paperId":"2010.03573","sourceSha256":"69f2ddcf93542a278aa0328987be18969e813dbaf117bb83e6a654ff24a56871","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ff64b60bb5ec38dfb4a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1fd053c1815bd5fc7cffb2580ec6bd9b76dae518c5281ddf946a4d9eeed82fbc","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"1e46d1603cc969322d2ca85d05c7a01cb3561b98e4dddedf953097317f823e71","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c7ff0eff6081d519c7b388be9582dd54","paperId":"2010.03573","sourceSha256":"69f2ddcf93542a278aa0328987be18969e813dbaf117bb83e6a654ff24a56871","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ff64b60bb5ec38dfb4a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1fd053c1815bd5fc7cffb2580ec6bd9b76dae518c5281ddf946a4d9eeed82fbc","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"5ddf197e27a51e4f8587492941d377371fc4d04915cd0aaf9daae52faf7b826f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:kk-contribution:0a9fbd9ccaef7129327b8613"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:kk-contribution:0a9fbd9ccaef7129327b8613","type":"source_contribution","subjectIds":["unit:4ed2ac936157aab2ac1031a731c7fd778188055e7092082eb69b67b68a11dc32","q-relic-abundance-early-matter-domination"],"status":"accepted","scopeContentSha256":"63f9c93561235dd2757636d30607450451320364a7360de54bb98010fb8cf022","contributionContentSha256":"5b3430603e648b98582db0087c7f3a76fc23fb4e203c5576fa7c11c4571c6bc9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"kk-normalized-original","challengeReviewId":"kk-compact-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["kk-normalized-original","kk-compact-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"d88","kind":"description","unitIndex":88,"unitId":"unit:4ed2ac936157aab2ac1031a731c7fd778188055e7092082eb69b67b68a11dc32","textSha256":"6950a4ff6fe9d2f551f6f687b358d351843a56c4a51577c050d3a38e032b6d58"},{"ref":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:838fea98513824e2293a8b26a8b8326f","paperId":"2010.03573","sourceSha256":"69f2ddcf93542a278aa0328987be18969e813dbaf117bb83e6a654ff24a56871","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ff64b60bb5ec38dfb4a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1fd053c1815bd5fc7cffb2580ec6bd9b76dae518c5281ddf946a4d9eeed82fbc","pdfPage":4,"start":1321,"end":3680,"textSha256":"8cd609c0305f8484508bdf8944ec071e717b57b2aed42367bd163ff5fec86758","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:97c24a2fd94894abf8da2e33e622a088","paperId":"2010.03573","sourceSha256":"69f2ddcf93542a278aa0328987be18969e813dbaf117bb83e6a654ff24a56871","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ff64b60bb5ec38dfb4a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1fd053c1815bd5fc7cffb2580ec6bd9b76dae518c5281ddf946a4d9eeed82fbc","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"1e46d1603cc969322d2ca85d05c7a01cb3561b98e4dddedf953097317f823e71","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c7ff0eff6081d519c7b388be9582dd54","paperId":"2010.03573","sourceSha256":"69f2ddcf93542a278aa0328987be18969e813dbaf117bb83e6a654ff24a56871","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ff64b60bb5ec38dfb4a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1fd053c1815bd5fc7cffb2580ec6bd9b76dae518c5281ddf946a4d9eeed82fbc","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"5ddf197e27a51e4f8587492941d377371fc4d04915cd0aaf9daae52faf7b826f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}}],"admissionBasis":"Root explicitly approved these31 exact typed-role intersections; no direct-home, equivalence or method-applicability inference."}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ff6a1e089d74ba8e0638adbeaac30ddedf06158eae201d83abf3519f6222e6e2"},"organizational-access:80858c77594583b5a8edf279":{"id":"organizational-access:80858c77594583b5a8edf279","source":"q025-candidate-region:79dd11c4632243fb25aa5bad","target":"q025-candidate-question:af0fda4fb4fdec799df95524","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:79dd11c4632243fb25aa5bad","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"d3c011dcc64dfd2ee852002e99e8b72bf036b8ef6d7c34b5cf6c9d76a4ba590d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:93af19203cb7f216bc2efec5"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:af0fda4fb4fdec799df95524","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"52ee5874b797f882c60aec085816ebf334fa97ba75ab80622e3ad0fe650bd375","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:274220e89e389be7d7407f58"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:3267740f211252bd12f44b0c848cf418e59f929650f231d45f4371bc63b44ec4","home":{"unitId":"unit:3267740f211252bd12f44b0c848cf418e59f929650f231d45f4371bc63b44ec4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:79dd11c4632243fb25aa5bad","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3267740f211252bd12f44b0c848cf418e59f929650f231d45f4371bc63b44ec4","paperId":"2308.00302","textSha256":"ff294bc7e957dba046e684b2820835934479ff897edd68479fd907ea1a754397"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0286f42ac8bbe1af9f974924107f76df","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":2,"start":2495,"end":5173,"textSha256":"e7c0a5ba884b22057878f87c15d17f9d3c459216f93f6f7bd0834cde3b325aca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ad87fad48150a4ec1d9f8aaebefcffc8","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":1,"start":2495,"end":4175,"textSha256":"968bc4c2c1a3ac84e841a628a50fbbd53e8826323064c7c3e6b2e6e50d3104d6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e513cacef466e56e017b7107fd5b3f67","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":1,"start":1296,"end":4175,"textSha256":"b2d5df577f21cbe0a6499040f33af450149b2859760a63d448eb557f15d46ff5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:aeb9a5964fc25bd12424278a"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:aeb9a5964fc25bd12424278a","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3267740f211252bd12f44b0c848cf418e59f929650f231d45f4371bc63b44ec4","q025-candidate-region:79dd11c4632243fb25aa5bad"],"scopeContentSha256":"d3c011dcc64dfd2ee852002e99e8b72bf036b8ef6d7c34b5cf6c9d76a4ba590d","placementContentSha256":"9de7a95f30a57bd97395458a7082cc116c208d926cad2da1bb9bf98d3e431ecc","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge","parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3267740f211252bd12f44b0c848cf418e59f929650f231d45f4371bc63b44ec4","paperId":"2308.00302","textSha256":"ff294bc7e957dba046e684b2820835934479ff897edd68479fd907ea1a754397"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0286f42ac8bbe1af9f974924107f76df","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":2,"start":2495,"end":5173,"textSha256":"e7c0a5ba884b22057878f87c15d17f9d3c459216f93f6f7bd0834cde3b325aca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ad87fad48150a4ec1d9f8aaebefcffc8","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":1,"start":2495,"end":4175,"textSha256":"968bc4c2c1a3ac84e841a628a50fbbd53e8826323064c7c3e6b2e6e50d3104d6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e513cacef466e56e017b7107fd5b3f67","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":1,"start":1296,"end":4175,"textSha256":"b2d5df577f21cbe0a6499040f33af450149b2859760a63d448eb557f15d46ff5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:aeb9a5964fc25bd12424278a"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3267740f211252bd12f44b0c848cf418e59f929650f231d45f4371bc63b44ec4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:af0fda4fb4fdec799df95524","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d62","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:3267740f211252bd12f44b0c848cf418e59f929650f231d45f4371bc63b44ec4","textSha256":"ff294bc7e957dba046e684b2820835934479ff897edd68479fd907ea1a754397"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0286f42ac8bbe1af9f974924107f76df","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":2,"start":2495,"end":5173,"textSha256":"e7c0a5ba884b22057878f87c15d17f9d3c459216f93f6f7bd0834cde3b325aca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ad87fad48150a4ec1d9f8aaebefcffc8","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":1,"start":2495,"end":4175,"textSha256":"968bc4c2c1a3ac84e841a628a50fbbd53e8826323064c7c3e6b2e6e50d3104d6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e513cacef466e56e017b7107fd5b3f67","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":1,"start":1296,"end":4175,"textSha256":"b2d5df577f21cbe0a6499040f33af450149b2859760a63d448eb557f15d46ff5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b65eb2bb62663abf4c846246"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b65eb2bb62663abf4c846246","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3267740f211252bd12f44b0c848cf418e59f929650f231d45f4371bc63b44ec4","q025-candidate-question:af0fda4fb4fdec799df95524"],"scopeContentSha256":"52ee5874b797f882c60aec085816ebf334fa97ba75ab80622e3ad0fe650bd375","contributionContentSha256":"e28018cca7919d87d121e70214f6f7609788efd2178f2b2286b55fb36596ba39","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d62","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:3267740f211252bd12f44b0c848cf418e59f929650f231d45f4371bc63b44ec4","textSha256":"ff294bc7e957dba046e684b2820835934479ff897edd68479fd907ea1a754397"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0286f42ac8bbe1af9f974924107f76df","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":2,"start":2495,"end":5173,"textSha256":"e7c0a5ba884b22057878f87c15d17f9d3c459216f93f6f7bd0834cde3b325aca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ad87fad48150a4ec1d9f8aaebefcffc8","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":1,"start":2495,"end":4175,"textSha256":"968bc4c2c1a3ac84e841a628a50fbbd53e8826323064c7c3e6b2e6e50d3104d6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e513cacef466e56e017b7107fd5b3f67","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":1,"start":1296,"end":4175,"textSha256":"b2d5df577f21cbe0a6499040f33af450149b2859760a63d448eb557f15d46ff5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b65eb2bb62663abf4c846246","recordId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Two different moduli supply exponentials; this is not the one-modulus racetrack. Inflationary fit claims require later evidence beyond the cited previous model.","challengeNote":"Separate moduli supply the two exponentials. Potential construction and inflationary viability remain distinct; the cited earlier fit does not verify this ext","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"30c5eb22b14f8278e51febe5104b7614dd5bd2fa1790fb820c07e99fcc60eb1b"},"organizational-access:63b2658dc340e18995a00992":{"id":"organizational-access:63b2658dc340e18995a00992","source":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","target":"q025-candidate-question:51c3921960e35c37cbdd75e4","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b6323dd1e35e5cbd54d31c70"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:51c3921960e35c37cbdd75e4","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7ea7d0fc7fcf70ae7ce1c4ef61b575f58ac30411f1568fdbff8c12e509f91bd7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d7ad297e82c24317b4a98761"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1524250918bded16062737dc0a4dace8af08214b7b6122d0cba6816ae88067c6","home":{"unitId":"unit:1524250918bded16062737dc0a4dace8af08214b7b6122d0cba6816ae88067c6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1524250918bded16062737dc0a4dace8af08214b7b6122d0cba6816ae88067c6","paperId":"1806.07242","textSha256":"b6afce7e7de3ce2432a07b3e4e8a566b238cc417f1c0f29ff354239d2002020f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7126f5d68dc9181e29965acb"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7126f5d68dc9181e29965acb","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1524250918bded16062737dc0a4dace8af08214b7b6122d0cba6816ae88067c6","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"d92816a4ebabb0ff72ed04194a8c7ea6663a9afca35a979845bff4d27473960a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1524250918bded16062737dc0a4dace8af08214b7b6122d0cba6816ae88067c6","paperId":"1806.07242","textSha256":"b6afce7e7de3ce2432a07b3e4e8a566b238cc417f1c0f29ff354239d2002020f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7126f5d68dc9181e29965acb"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1524250918bded16062737dc0a4dace8af08214b7b6122d0cba6816ae88067c6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:51c3921960e35c37cbdd75e4","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:1524250918bded16062737dc0a4dace8af08214b7b6122d0cba6816ae88067c6","textSha256":"b6afce7e7de3ce2432a07b3e4e8a566b238cc417f1c0f29ff354239d2002020f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:83acb7b3593ec40b7324817b","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Complexity/rate tests and shock-wave spreading require separate fine reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Unresolved compound identity: complexity/rate tests and shock-wave spreading are distinct targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:83acb7b3593ec40b7324817b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1524250918bded16062737dc0a4dace8af08214b7b6122d0cba6816ae88067c6","q025-candidate-question:51c3921960e35c37cbdd75e4"],"scopeContentSha256":"7ea7d0fc7fcf70ae7ce1c4ef61b575f58ac30411f1568fdbff8c12e509f91bd7","contributionContentSha256":"4797e8f11d2ea88572e6bf5bf0e1b38c6ac3f2cd787953a3091d83ba3d8585da","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:1524250918bded16062737dc0a4dace8af08214b7b6122d0cba6816ae88067c6","textSha256":"b6afce7e7de3ce2432a07b3e4e8a566b238cc417f1c0f29ff354239d2002020f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:83acb7b3593ec40b7324817b","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Complexity/rate tests and shock-wave spreading require separate fine reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound identity: complexity/rate tests and shock-wave spreading are distinct targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:48fe959b2283e3a78ead505f9ae183d67a3f707638269f39ac8ee49d3d9239ef","home":{"unitId":"unit:48fe959b2283e3a78ead505f9ae183d67a3f707638269f39ac8ee49d3d9239ef","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:48fe959b2283e3a78ead505f9ae183d67a3f707638269f39ac8ee49d3d9239ef","paperId":"1509.09291","textSha256":"33780350f674ee435c9eb12157c3c841a29a872f5757cf1957245a3b43d72246"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2d13c0913ab4c5bbe79370d0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2d13c0913ab4c5bbe79370d0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:48fe959b2283e3a78ead505f9ae183d67a3f707638269f39ac8ee49d3d9239ef","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"e7ea45aa1179e7823bbe8fd856d2289c09d1bdf5fe2de8e53d19dd0f8a47810f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:48fe959b2283e3a78ead505f9ae183d67a3f707638269f39ac8ee49d3d9239ef","paperId":"1509.09291","textSha256":"33780350f674ee435c9eb12157c3c841a29a872f5757cf1957245a3b43d72246"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2d13c0913ab4c5bbe79370d0"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:48fe959b2283e3a78ead505f9ae183d67a3f707638269f39ac8ee49d3d9239ef","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:51c3921960e35c37cbdd75e4","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:48fe959b2283e3a78ead505f9ae183d67a3f707638269f39ac8ee49d3d9239ef","textSha256":"33780350f674ee435c9eb12157c3c841a29a872f5757cf1957245a3b43d72246"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f2dcd564539caf2b26719ea4","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f2dcd564539caf2b26719ea4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:48fe959b2283e3a78ead505f9ae183d67a3f707638269f39ac8ee49d3d9239ef","q025-candidate-question:51c3921960e35c37cbdd75e4"],"scopeContentSha256":"7ea7d0fc7fcf70ae7ce1c4ef61b575f58ac30411f1568fdbff8c12e509f91bd7","contributionContentSha256":"3715bbace5770e773ca3b620def8e10a0caf852f78b7ac3383035bec673b4c3b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:48fe959b2283e3a78ead505f9ae183d67a3f707638269f39ac8ee49d3d9239ef","textSha256":"33780350f674ee435c9eb12157c3c841a29a872f5757cf1957245a3b43d72246"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f2dcd564539caf2b26719ea4","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","home":{"unitId":"unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","paperId":"2312.12349","textSha256":"ab1e94bccc0a640f77156ec85ecbe49c8c4fe6bb26ffe45c7e6e9b44ed2bcc59"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e31b93a334d9134e894e56ea"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e31b93a334d9134e894e56ea","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"9a08e1cd11af4985b3939105ddbecaf0660e702b3dc2c470cfe1522dadf1ded9","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","paperId":"2312.12349","textSha256":"ab1e94bccc0a640f77156ec85ecbe49c8c4fe6bb26ffe45c7e6e9b44ed2bcc59"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e31b93a334d9134e894e56ea"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:51c3921960e35c37cbdd75e4","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","textSha256":"ab1e94bccc0a640f77156ec85ecbe49c8c4fe6bb26ffe45c7e6e9b44ed2bcc59"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8c22150a7bd260db387fbd0a","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8c22150a7bd260db387fbd0a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","q025-candidate-question:51c3921960e35c37cbdd75e4"],"scopeContentSha256":"7ea7d0fc7fcf70ae7ce1c4ef61b575f58ac30411f1568fdbff8c12e509f91bd7","contributionContentSha256":"cdd3f83d076724305719d26f5ae829316cde7bb5af96e75593a2b23e47ed3c3f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","textSha256":"ab1e94bccc0a640f77156ec85ecbe49c8c4fe6bb26ffe45c7e6e9b44ed2bcc59"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8c22150a7bd260db387fbd0a","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","home":{"unitId":"unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","paperId":"2307.01263","textSha256":"3388139a03fbdf7eddf84002c6ad9e84323f6b2ba15ffc20f3d324102622f245"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0d7b4813e8c364801c275b363204ac97","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":91,"end":2890,"textSha256":"c244a13a221e023193dafab11b3da512c23d99f0a989929158ec553fe7ac3589","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1df13e1dbd1cadc7e3b87c38cbad3a1b","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2008,"textSha256":"31775e93fcc92f0d2318448abe9b0adaa30b63ab8a6abdf9bdba44c7ae0f7397","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c9caecdb2024463707cede6379b65943","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":1287,"end":2890,"textSha256":"4a4f9474ae695e78143f3aee31c65e39bfac437b3918bb210e1319302c3da466","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c5572b48e4bc17b504395891"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c5572b48e4bc17b504395891","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"6beee1bf0bee9150813f2ae61a438bc8716bfbe3f657fd851e15266217c75d1d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","paperId":"2307.01263","textSha256":"3388139a03fbdf7eddf84002c6ad9e84323f6b2ba15ffc20f3d324102622f245"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0d7b4813e8c364801c275b363204ac97","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":91,"end":2890,"textSha256":"c244a13a221e023193dafab11b3da512c23d99f0a989929158ec553fe7ac3589","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1df13e1dbd1cadc7e3b87c38cbad3a1b","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2008,"textSha256":"31775e93fcc92f0d2318448abe9b0adaa30b63ab8a6abdf9bdba44c7ae0f7397","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c9caecdb2024463707cede6379b65943","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":1287,"end":2890,"textSha256":"4a4f9474ae695e78143f3aee31c65e39bfac437b3918bb210e1319302c3da466","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c5572b48e4bc17b504395891"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:51c3921960e35c37cbdd75e4","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","textSha256":"3388139a03fbdf7eddf84002c6ad9e84323f6b2ba15ffc20f3d324102622f245"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0d7b4813e8c364801c275b363204ac97","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":91,"end":2890,"textSha256":"c244a13a221e023193dafab11b3da512c23d99f0a989929158ec553fe7ac3589","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1df13e1dbd1cadc7e3b87c38cbad3a1b","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2008,"textSha256":"31775e93fcc92f0d2318448abe9b0adaa30b63ab8a6abdf9bdba44c7ae0f7397","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c9caecdb2024463707cede6379b65943","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":1287,"end":2890,"textSha256":"4a4f9474ae695e78143f3aee31c65e39bfac437b3918bb210e1319302c3da466","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1662b9ff414d3d5d466b816e","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: v3, 18 Mar 2024. Tension, island/Page and complexity targets require reconciliation; abstract claims do not settle separate consistency tests. Independent challenge qualification: v3, 18 Mar 2024. Compound identity unresolved. DGP-dependent nonzero tension and Page curves without DGP are separate announced claims; complexity is another"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1662b9ff414d3d5d466b816e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","q025-candidate-question:51c3921960e35c37cbdd75e4"],"scopeContentSha256":"7ea7d0fc7fcf70ae7ce1c4ef61b575f58ac30411f1568fdbff8c12e509f91bd7","contributionContentSha256":"40e82953a8e7b5e1543a559bbadfbd6d3d3675e7cbc7f5cf5b80a7496d2a2cde","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","textSha256":"3388139a03fbdf7eddf84002c6ad9e84323f6b2ba15ffc20f3d324102622f245"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0d7b4813e8c364801c275b363204ac97","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":91,"end":2890,"textSha256":"c244a13a221e023193dafab11b3da512c23d99f0a989929158ec553fe7ac3589","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1df13e1dbd1cadc7e3b87c38cbad3a1b","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2008,"textSha256":"31775e93fcc92f0d2318448abe9b0adaa30b63ab8a6abdf9bdba44c7ae0f7397","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c9caecdb2024463707cede6379b65943","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":1287,"end":2890,"textSha256":"4a4f9474ae695e78143f3aee31c65e39bfac437b3918bb210e1319302c3da466","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1662b9ff414d3d5d466b816e","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"v3, 18 Mar 2024. Tension, island/Page and complexity targets require reconciliation; abstract claims do not settle separate consistency tests.","challengeNote":"v3, 18 Mar 2024. Compound identity unresolved. DGP-dependent nonzero tension and Page curves without DGP are separate announced claims; complexity is another","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":4,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"08326e3a6d2ee23b7bc4cf83daef71d0508a82dd0739eb4ba6fd1a25095e9ffd"},"organizational-access:efc52bd163921068eceeceab":{"id":"organizational-access:efc52bd163921068eceeceab","source":"q025-candidate-region:96ffdaa1cf92c95b23b2ce17","target":"q025-candidate-question:5e959fbaa0703e54b375d7ac","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:96ffdaa1cf92c95b23b2ce17","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"b92bfafa3859ef3a0fdc7ad176c63b424f04dad11f82d8a7302ed1da81a9067c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e2f20243880bf360e57b5668"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:5e959fbaa0703e54b375d7ac","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1da37a0fda6cae23521a9f89f3e277833149dc30cc5dc1d3b4a561ed35210ec6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:59b6cd76dfb993b7cc87ad9d"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:180df4033cd3769bba367aa1af71630b25f80329f70d8f18fe4e1c029e1609a9","home":{"unitId":"unit:180df4033cd3769bba367aa1af71630b25f80329f70d8f18fe4e1c029e1609a9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:96ffdaa1cf92c95b23b2ce17","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:180df4033cd3769bba367aa1af71630b25f80329f70d8f18fe4e1c029e1609a9","paperId":"2007.00786","textSha256":"dd416871e58cd3359bda399900a49b1fe3b3ddfbe3670a98c9c08060556d5dd0"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:31d43a91cac33904cba8b9a1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:31d43a91cac33904cba8b9a1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:180df4033cd3769bba367aa1af71630b25f80329f70d8f18fe4e1c029e1609a9","q025-candidate-region:96ffdaa1cf92c95b23b2ce17"],"scopeContentSha256":"b92bfafa3859ef3a0fdc7ad176c63b424f04dad11f82d8a7302ed1da81a9067c","placementContentSha256":"203e492ee1b5706fbd6adebf46db74da349db72b0c88f009bf93d8c28fadf457","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge","leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:180df4033cd3769bba367aa1af71630b25f80329f70d8f18fe4e1c029e1609a9","paperId":"2007.00786","textSha256":"dd416871e58cd3359bda399900a49b1fe3b3ddfbe3670a98c9c08060556d5dd0"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:31d43a91cac33904cba8b9a1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:180df4033cd3769bba367aa1af71630b25f80329f70d8f18fe4e1c029e1609a9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:5e959fbaa0703e54b375d7ac","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:180df4033cd3769bba367aa1af71630b25f80329f70d8f18fe4e1c029e1609a9","textSha256":"dd416871e58cd3359bda399900a49b1fe3b3ddfbe3670a98c9c08060556d5dd0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bf7e0dfa8caf9e62172c3872","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound construction agenda; finite entropy is a target, not a finite-state premise. Independent challenge qualification: Compound construction agenda; finite entropy is a target. Finer reconciliation remains open."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:bf7e0dfa8caf9e62172c3872","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:180df4033cd3769bba367aa1af71630b25f80329f70d8f18fe4e1c029e1609a9","q025-candidate-question:5e959fbaa0703e54b375d7ac"],"scopeContentSha256":"1da37a0fda6cae23521a9f89f3e277833149dc30cc5dc1d3b4a561ed35210ec6","contributionContentSha256":"2472a7701a66a09942f9ca1f0689302cd262cee39cb9c71bfc6e51bf42e08cef","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:180df4033cd3769bba367aa1af71630b25f80329f70d8f18fe4e1c029e1609a9","textSha256":"dd416871e58cd3359bda399900a49b1fe3b3ddfbe3670a98c9c08060556d5dd0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bf7e0dfa8caf9e62172c3872","recordId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound construction agenda; finite entropy is a target, not a finite-state premise.","challengeNote":"Compound construction agenda; finite entropy is a target. Finer reconciliation remains open.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:e7230c333e14edea174717e1fa5410d32770bc4648eb9e8636df88844545a134","home":{"unitId":"unit:e7230c333e14edea174717e1fa5410d32770bc4648eb9e8636df88844545a134","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:96ffdaa1cf92c95b23b2ce17","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e7230c333e14edea174717e1fa5410d32770bc4648eb9e8636df88844545a134","paperId":"2007.11611","textSha256":"d7ead60f64cfc57c0c14b97b4fa26b0894153af1e5d4398d46feadb86727516c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8f51a2be4139ac140477c443"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8f51a2be4139ac140477c443","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e7230c333e14edea174717e1fa5410d32770bc4648eb9e8636df88844545a134","q025-candidate-region:96ffdaa1cf92c95b23b2ce17"],"scopeContentSha256":"b92bfafa3859ef3a0fdc7ad176c63b424f04dad11f82d8a7302ed1da81a9067c","placementContentSha256":"a3eaa5001c5e2d19f29805f293ba06baa83a868d0cbc3c88e2b7b6f0927f008c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge","leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e7230c333e14edea174717e1fa5410d32770bc4648eb9e8636df88844545a134","paperId":"2007.11611","textSha256":"d7ead60f64cfc57c0c14b97b4fa26b0894153af1e5d4398d46feadb86727516c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8f51a2be4139ac140477c443"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e7230c333e14edea174717e1fa5410d32770bc4648eb9e8636df88844545a134","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:5e959fbaa0703e54b375d7ac","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:e7230c333e14edea174717e1fa5410d32770bc4648eb9e8636df88844545a134","textSha256":"d7ead60f64cfc57c0c14b97b4fa26b0894153af1e5d4398d46feadb86727516c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:503294ea8dc5ffa2e6f03d38","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound construction agenda; equivalence with other string-state questions is unestablished. Independent challenge qualification: Compound construction agenda; equivalence with neighboring string-state questions remains unestablished."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:503294ea8dc5ffa2e6f03d38","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e7230c333e14edea174717e1fa5410d32770bc4648eb9e8636df88844545a134","q025-candidate-question:5e959fbaa0703e54b375d7ac"],"scopeContentSha256":"1da37a0fda6cae23521a9f89f3e277833149dc30cc5dc1d3b4a561ed35210ec6","contributionContentSha256":"5f861b941f61c8817a846b67765123820194a3d0056bd2fe7ee571bfe45ca542","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:e7230c333e14edea174717e1fa5410d32770bc4648eb9e8636df88844545a134","textSha256":"d7ead60f64cfc57c0c14b97b4fa26b0894153af1e5d4398d46feadb86727516c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:503294ea8dc5ffa2e6f03d38","recordId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound construction agenda; equivalence with other string-state questions is unestablished.","challengeNote":"Compound construction agenda; equivalence with neighboring string-state questions remains unestablished.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"67c5a510b0c88229c31a30cb7c7e25ac9172f599ff953fb9d6db35e65ebc1685"},"organizational-access:fefc66bfc7e83196972f4ef9":{"id":"organizational-access:fefc66bfc7e83196972f4ef9","source":"q025-candidate-region:9cc6623edc9d8c83bc264832","target":"q025-candidate-question:65159039db765591bb2d527c","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:9cc6623edc9d8c83bc264832","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"db10961658d1435226a720a302a772a7824b36d2e61e2be786e0c17da8ee575f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:9ee5ca9792b940f26166409f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:65159039db765591bb2d527c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"5f69119347607a838cf804157ba98e486c3cfbb1cbf929a760212c48097cf9ba","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:47b113649d67c881c865aa70"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:fc9c1cda908566f5795739de21dabe0301edc2180530d8e6e8ff42a8212b6836","home":{"unitId":"unit:fc9c1cda908566f5795739de21dabe0301edc2180530d8e6e8ff42a8212b6836","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:9cc6623edc9d8c83bc264832","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fc9c1cda908566f5795739de21dabe0301edc2180530d8e6e8ff42a8212b6836","paperId":"1801.01420","textSha256":"3a5a68b93cbe99123ecd497169c1bd1f332ab38f2e421f71d105e049666a3c2a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ec13c7edc606d2e87a8fb93d"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ec13c7edc606d2e87a8fb93d","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fc9c1cda908566f5795739de21dabe0301edc2180530d8e6e8ff42a8212b6836","q025-candidate-region:9cc6623edc9d8c83bc264832"],"scopeContentSha256":"db10961658d1435226a720a302a772a7824b36d2e61e2be786e0c17da8ee575f","placementContentSha256":"58963d046d3a2d54868381a1475fb73d6d4de4427cdd693f705114998ea91875","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-challenge","leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fc9c1cda908566f5795739de21dabe0301edc2180530d8e6e8ff42a8212b6836","paperId":"1801.01420","textSha256":"3a5a68b93cbe99123ecd497169c1bd1f332ab38f2e421f71d105e049666a3c2a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ec13c7edc606d2e87a8fb93d"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fc9c1cda908566f5795739de21dabe0301edc2180530d8e6e8ff42a8212b6836","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:65159039db765591bb2d527c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:fc9c1cda908566f5795739de21dabe0301edc2180530d8e6e8ff42a8212b6836","textSha256":"3a5a68b93cbe99123ecd497169c1bd1f332ab38f2e421f71d105e049666a3c2a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1794042a39ff51a13e7b75d2","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Growth-rate calculation and conditional spin/disk-based particle bounds are distinct contributions. Independent challenge qualification: Vector growth calculations and conditional spin/disk-based particle bounds are separate targets within this source."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1794042a39ff51a13e7b75d2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fc9c1cda908566f5795739de21dabe0301edc2180530d8e6e8ff42a8212b6836","q025-candidate-question:65159039db765591bb2d527c"],"scopeContentSha256":"5f69119347607a838cf804157ba98e486c3cfbb1cbf929a760212c48097cf9ba","contributionContentSha256":"f4ef726db04bec1b9ee14357a00a0e079de3141658f4588fd521ee0ef63615a6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-proposal","leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:fc9c1cda908566f5795739de21dabe0301edc2180530d8e6e8ff42a8212b6836","textSha256":"3a5a68b93cbe99123ecd497169c1bd1f332ab38f2e421f71d105e049666a3c2a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1794042a39ff51a13e7b75d2","recordId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Growth-rate calculation and conditional spin/disk-based particle bounds are distinct contributions.","challengeNote":"Vector growth calculations and conditional spin/disk-based particle bounds are separate targets within this source.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"faa42e3f53944982df7a25e08d63084d27a668df88f732a978e240ffa81aa526"},"organizational-access:74575cd841b1deeee8fef8e1":{"id":"organizational-access:74575cd841b1deeee8fef8e1","source":"q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323","target":"q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"f17a971eeb6c10205db277c56706e8c84ea6168e3c8144ee6d9dbdd67245625f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e2fb72c2deed2534c05b98ee"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"88083517e7188e9650d4693a035ba9dc3cfdbd97fd3bc8ea208e4a5618a821ac","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:38fc42bf9aa56fff4606d0ac"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:556f2d74f08a4c051743903dd4413c0a6bc453d30c0a8ec50d2fcdb3458d928f","home":{"unitId":"unit:556f2d74f08a4c051743903dd4413c0a6bc453d30c0a8ec50d2fcdb3458d928f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:556f2d74f08a4c051743903dd4413c0a6bc453d30c0a8ec50d2fcdb3458d928f","paperId":"hep-th/0511160","textSha256":"a81a080f9cb391c0a9dc0376c9b30df9ec1c446a47fc27c52ffd5ed3ded17364"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05688251247e4fa6664f5698"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05688251247e4fa6664f5698","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:556f2d74f08a4c051743903dd4413c0a6bc453d30c0a8ec50d2fcdb3458d928f","q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323"],"scopeContentSha256":"f17a971eeb6c10205db277c56706e8c84ea6168e3c8144ee6d9dbdd67245625f","placementContentSha256":"21f639a5babf798adfbc7a92a2a5e27d619d24333269ecd53566ce3ab6071f1e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:556f2d74f08a4c051743903dd4413c0a6bc453d30c0a8ec50d2fcdb3458d928f","paperId":"hep-th/0511160","textSha256":"a81a080f9cb391c0a9dc0376c9b30df9ec1c446a47fc27c52ffd5ed3ded17364"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05688251247e4fa6664f5698"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:556f2d74f08a4c051743903dd4413c0a6bc453d30c0a8ec50d2fcdb3458d928f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d53","kind":"description","unitIndex":53,"unitId":"unit:556f2d74f08a4c051743903dd4413c0a6bc453d30c0a8ec50d2fcdb3458d928f","textSha256":"a81a080f9cb391c0a9dc0376c9b30df9ec1c446a47fc27c52ffd5ed3ded17364"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5e897b4345fb9ba04dfd1692"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5e897b4345fb9ba04dfd1692","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:556f2d74f08a4c051743903dd4413c0a6bc453d30c0a8ec50d2fcdb3458d928f","q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1"],"scopeContentSha256":"88083517e7188e9650d4693a035ba9dc3cfdbd97fd3bc8ea208e4a5618a821ac","contributionContentSha256":"4c0b864fac06d8c69349214acae046d00f12f4972f3c183852872029bb80da87","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d53","kind":"description","unitIndex":53,"unitId":"unit:556f2d74f08a4c051743903dd4413c0a6bc453d30c0a8ec50d2fcdb3458d928f","textSha256":"a81a080f9cb391c0a9dc0376c9b30df9ec1c446a47fc27c52ffd5ed3ded17364"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5e897b4345fb9ba04dfd1692","recordId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound stabilization/tuning, mediation and cosmological-stability targets with one already-heavy modulus.","challengeNote":"Compound stabilization/tuning, mediation and cosmological-stability targets assume one already-heavy modulus.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:82c2356213daa2cc05ebfeec1340610d0f56380865440191070602637534dcb8","home":{"unitId":"unit:82c2356213daa2cc05ebfeec1340610d0f56380865440191070602637534dcb8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers correction-lifted mobile Kähler directions, cosmological dynamics and supersymmetry-breaking mass consequences together.","qualification":"q27 covers correction-lifted quintessence directions and the same sector's gravitino and ordinary soft-mass consequences. The mass estimate remains conditional on the supplied derivative and cancellation assumptions. No omitted hidden-sector claim or complete quintessence construction is inferred.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:82c2356213daa2cc05ebfeec1340610d0f56380865440191070602637534dcb8","paperId":"1909.08625","textSha256":"fb9b221adf70eb5fc3dd9ae5a79f22fe9cf2b0a84fe8f30ccb910a9c994e662f"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0025:u12:q27"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0025:u12:q27","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:82c2356213daa2cc05ebfeec1340610d0f56380865440191070602637534dcb8","q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323"],"scopeContentSha256":"f17a971eeb6c10205db277c56706e8c84ea6168e3c8144ee6d9dbdd67245625f","placementContentSha256":"553af371d0b844c9a4158381ccf426850dacc083e45d0347bef193fc0b61ea1c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0025:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0025:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:82c2356213daa2cc05ebfeec1340610d0f56380865440191070602637534dcb8","paperId":"1909.08625","textSha256":"fb9b221adf70eb5fc3dd9ae5a79f22fe9cf2b0a84fe8f30ccb910a9c994e662f"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0025","unitRef":"u12"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:82c2356213daa2cc05ebfeec1340610d0f56380865440191070602637534dcb8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:82c2356213daa2cc05ebfeec1340610d0f56380865440191070602637534dcb8","textSha256":"fb9b221adf70eb5fc3dd9ae5a79f22fe9cf2b0a84fe8f30ccb910a9c994e662f"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1083edee8e47cfb474a6b4c8b67fd970","paperId":"1909.08625","sourceSha256":"dad019ecf9fd6ea0aae0630d4d8a3a5db39d8545364f666e6a0efd47a8d93f72","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e1296dd71e57899ed0e4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"22b6e86adb911e9639faeb9b346763e3ba5aef45a6f48cfae3f9139766153ea4","pdfPage":3,"start":686,"end":2576,"textSha256":"c6f5c2a4eaa1a7dd5f55cb5a5c72047f668fff619e81c357ce1eee11150e0456","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:088f076d50461316bc1b89abea714e1c","paperId":"1909.08625","sourceSha256":"dad019ecf9fd6ea0aae0630d4d8a3a5db39d8545364f666e6a0efd47a8d93f72","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e1296dd71e57899ed0e4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"22b6e86adb911e9639faeb9b346763e3ba5aef45a6f48cfae3f9139766153ea4","pdfPage":16,"start":0,"end":1985,"textSha256":"8b78461a299c02d65f1cfc9fb8edbf1c23b746bc093c5fee90fa7fb9cd206cff","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9038e3c9a3152d680a26c4ea6605982e","paperId":"1909.08625","sourceSha256":"dad019ecf9fd6ea0aae0630d4d8a3a5db39d8545364f666e6a0efd47a8d93f72","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e1296dd71e57899ed0e4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"22b6e86adb911e9639faeb9b346763e3ba5aef45a6f48cfae3f9139766153ea4","pdfPage":17,"start":0,"end":2247,"textSha256":"84e4635a0a81573dc0b5fa046f6f483d72434217fdfce51035910e804af2d6a9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9becedac86685b139d5994c2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9becedac86685b139d5994c2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:82c2356213daa2cc05ebfeec1340610d0f56380865440191070602637534dcb8","q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1"],"scopeContentSha256":"88083517e7188e9650d4693a035ba9dc3cfdbd97fd3bc8ea208e4a5618a821ac","contributionContentSha256":"3a0b47b62525aa74000f43f7739222f45f6acb05280a33a8a0ffef042d275934","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:82c2356213daa2cc05ebfeec1340610d0f56380865440191070602637534dcb8","textSha256":"fb9b221adf70eb5fc3dd9ae5a79f22fe9cf2b0a84fe8f30ccb910a9c994e662f"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1083edee8e47cfb474a6b4c8b67fd970","paperId":"1909.08625","sourceSha256":"dad019ecf9fd6ea0aae0630d4d8a3a5db39d8545364f666e6a0efd47a8d93f72","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e1296dd71e57899ed0e4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"22b6e86adb911e9639faeb9b346763e3ba5aef45a6f48cfae3f9139766153ea4","pdfPage":3,"start":686,"end":2576,"textSha256":"c6f5c2a4eaa1a7dd5f55cb5a5c72047f668fff619e81c357ce1eee11150e0456","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:088f076d50461316bc1b89abea714e1c","paperId":"1909.08625","sourceSha256":"dad019ecf9fd6ea0aae0630d4d8a3a5db39d8545364f666e6a0efd47a8d93f72","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e1296dd71e57899ed0e4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"22b6e86adb911e9639faeb9b346763e3ba5aef45a6f48cfae3f9139766153ea4","pdfPage":16,"start":0,"end":1985,"textSha256":"8b78461a299c02d65f1cfc9fb8edbf1c23b746bc093c5fee90fa7fb9cd206cff","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9038e3c9a3152d680a26c4ea6605982e","paperId":"1909.08625","sourceSha256":"dad019ecf9fd6ea0aae0630d4d8a3a5db39d8545364f666e6a0efd47a8d93f72","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e1296dd71e57899ed0e4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"22b6e86adb911e9639faeb9b346763e3ba5aef45a6f48cfae3f9139766153ea4","pdfPage":17,"start":0,"end":2247,"textSha256":"84e4635a0a81573dc0b5fa046f6f483d72434217fdfce51035910e804af2d6a9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9becedac86685b139d5994c2","recordId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound quintessence and soft-mass setting. The mass estimate is heuristic; graph-only hidden-sector claims are not primary-verified here.","challengeNote":"Compound quintessence and soft-mass setting. The projected mass estimate assumes regular derivatives and limited cancellations; omitted claim anchors remain un","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9db10074d4a39d150ec763b7859d97ca234330d7e3cdfd81f6ae16d649a0a569","home":{"unitId":"unit:9db10074d4a39d150ec763b7859d97ca234330d7e3cdfd81f6ae16d649a0a569","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9db10074d4a39d150ec763b7859d97ca234330d7e3cdfd81f6ae16d649a0a569","paperId":"hep-th/0605141","textSha256":"3012fec7d451a5d8b24ccc02c850eed2b57b0d1cd514a01c9b6823b0a305933d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:67c162b7687adaf682eb9be5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:67c162b7687adaf682eb9be5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9db10074d4a39d150ec763b7859d97ca234330d7e3cdfd81f6ae16d649a0a569","q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323"],"scopeContentSha256":"f17a971eeb6c10205db277c56706e8c84ea6168e3c8144ee6d9dbdd67245625f","placementContentSha256":"4d14b254952a9761dee41002d9947e508a27a2b54b2fe7fe97b5cc2e74ea83ef","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9db10074d4a39d150ec763b7859d97ca234330d7e3cdfd81f6ae16d649a0a569","paperId":"hep-th/0605141","textSha256":"3012fec7d451a5d8b24ccc02c850eed2b57b0d1cd514a01c9b6823b0a305933d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:67c162b7687adaf682eb9be5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9db10074d4a39d150ec763b7859d97ca234330d7e3cdfd81f6ae16d649a0a569","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:9db10074d4a39d150ec763b7859d97ca234330d7e3cdfd81f6ae16d649a0a569","textSha256":"3012fec7d451a5d8b24ccc02c850eed2b57b0d1cd514a01c9b6823b0a305933d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:42410787c42d4e8bd36e47fb"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:42410787c42d4e8bd36e47fb","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9db10074d4a39d150ec763b7859d97ca234330d7e3cdfd81f6ae16d649a0a569","q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1"],"scopeContentSha256":"88083517e7188e9650d4693a035ba9dc3cfdbd97fd3bc8ea208e4a5618a821ac","contributionContentSha256":"589e1dde2b116eeb8327e850a15df1d0625db6d90e5934148deb56d57375f1e2","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:9db10074d4a39d150ec763b7859d97ca234330d7e3cdfd81f6ae16d649a0a569","textSha256":"3012fec7d451a5d8b24ccc02c850eed2b57b0d1cd514a01c9b6823b0a305933d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:42410787c42d4e8bd36e47fb","recordId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Gravitino–gaugino hierarchy and approximate scalar flavor universality remain separate observables.","challengeNote":"Replace pf2 with pf37: the flavor question specifies large-volume models without naming LVS. Hierarchy and flavor universality remain distinct targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a063f5df3ce70cf64059388e5e404535444330782b9351e7c0af3f62ef924dab","home":{"unitId":"unit:a063f5df3ce70cf64059388e5e404535444330782b9351e7c0af3f62ef924dab","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a063f5df3ce70cf64059388e5e404535444330782b9351e7c0af3f62ef924dab","paperId":"0704.0737","textSha256":"3cd26f7f7e4f82b991bf4de35ef588d8883261286deb1e8c18004a338b9d52a9"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b8b1509b0e9bedf51da9d044"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b8b1509b0e9bedf51da9d044","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a063f5df3ce70cf64059388e5e404535444330782b9351e7c0af3f62ef924dab","q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323"],"scopeContentSha256":"f17a971eeb6c10205db277c56706e8c84ea6168e3c8144ee6d9dbdd67245625f","placementContentSha256":"d5a430724d4e687a97ab9379a38c9cf4722c4aea98798b81104deb32849f19a6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a063f5df3ce70cf64059388e5e404535444330782b9351e7c0af3f62ef924dab","paperId":"0704.0737","textSha256":"3cd26f7f7e4f82b991bf4de35ef588d8883261286deb1e8c18004a338b9d52a9"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b8b1509b0e9bedf51da9d044"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a063f5df3ce70cf64059388e5e404535444330782b9351e7c0af3f62ef924dab","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:a063f5df3ce70cf64059388e5e404535444330782b9351e7c0af3f62ef924dab","textSha256":"3cd26f7f7e4f82b991bf4de35ef588d8883261286deb1e8c18004a338b9d52a9"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fff3083f5c19baf516862b28"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:fff3083f5c19baf516862b28","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a063f5df3ce70cf64059388e5e404535444330782b9351e7c0af3f62ef924dab","q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1"],"scopeContentSha256":"88083517e7188e9650d4693a035ba9dc3cfdbd97fd3bc8ea208e4a5618a821ac","contributionContentSha256":"9503232698db891b6ef5b67531239b4df0482912912df3e874900bfe1939aadb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:a063f5df3ce70cf64059388e5e404535444330782b9351e7c0af3f62ef924dab","textSha256":"3cd26f7f7e4f82b991bf4de35ef588d8883261286deb1e8c18004a338b9d52a9"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fff3083f5c19baf516862b28","recordId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The KK correction is conjectured; stabilization and the gaugino hierarchy are separate tests.","challengeNote":"Replace pf2 with pf37: large volume is stated, but LVS is not identified. The conjectured correction poses both stabilization and gaugino-hierarchy tests.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:be5fdddc1e35223a3725ed46a22f0a451afd64d92d2ee58cb4dca17bdd558da0","home":{"unitId":"unit:be5fdddc1e35223a3725ed46a22f0a451afd64d92d2ee58cb4dca17bdd558da0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:be5fdddc1e35223a3725ed46a22f0a451afd64d92d2ee58cb4dca17bdd558da0","paperId":"1012.1858","textSha256":"285e7773f9c1fa307ab24a1cf5a38ffc3e06b3c51eb8dd7b334e6828f2e3770b"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:64ba505fdf1688e9e5929946"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:64ba505fdf1688e9e5929946","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:be5fdddc1e35223a3725ed46a22f0a451afd64d92d2ee58cb4dca17bdd558da0","q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323"],"scopeContentSha256":"f17a971eeb6c10205db277c56706e8c84ea6168e3c8144ee6d9dbdd67245625f","placementContentSha256":"3136f08fb3cb20770d76ea275cd7f6025bcb1f895e8763d8410fd839d120a830","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:be5fdddc1e35223a3725ed46a22f0a451afd64d92d2ee58cb4dca17bdd558da0","paperId":"1012.1858","textSha256":"285e7773f9c1fa307ab24a1cf5a38ffc3e06b3c51eb8dd7b334e6828f2e3770b"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:64ba505fdf1688e9e5929946"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:be5fdddc1e35223a3725ed46a22f0a451afd64d92d2ee58cb4dca17bdd558da0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:be5fdddc1e35223a3725ed46a22f0a451afd64d92d2ee58cb4dca17bdd558da0","textSha256":"285e7773f9c1fa307ab24a1cf5a38ffc3e06b3c51eb8dd7b334e6828f2e3770b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5a38de4c3f028a2f10dbbf66"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5a38de4c3f028a2f10dbbf66","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:be5fdddc1e35223a3725ed46a22f0a451afd64d92d2ee58cb4dca17bdd558da0","q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1"],"scopeContentSha256":"88083517e7188e9650d4693a035ba9dc3cfdbd97fd3bc8ea208e4a5618a821ac","contributionContentSha256":"ae081b2d49ae0d64df70e314aa2b221696c58e26493090d7f14bea5da383254f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:be5fdddc1e35223a3725ed46a22f0a451afd64d92d2ee58cb4dca17bdd558da0","textSha256":"285e7773f9c1fa307ab24a1cf5a38ffc3e06b3c51eb8dd7b334e6828f2e3770b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5a38de4c3f028a2f10dbbf66","recordId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c496b0f57a26cf707360727607563458edc3af780062af2b4660dc963c7257ec","home":{"unitId":"unit:c496b0f57a26cf707360727607563458edc3af780062af2b4660dc963c7257ec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c496b0f57a26cf707360727607563458edc3af780062af2b4660dc963c7257ec","paperId":"1510.00376","textSha256":"ed560f810feeecc9f202015bc5aa3a3f72c3c5d039e44c72a247553b28363fa2"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b9835c1c93f3c49874bf7a1a"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b9835c1c93f3c49874bf7a1a","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c496b0f57a26cf707360727607563458edc3af780062af2b4660dc963c7257ec","q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323"],"scopeContentSha256":"f17a971eeb6c10205db277c56706e8c84ea6168e3c8144ee6d9dbdd67245625f","placementContentSha256":"deb770645e9214f60ef557bd5aa94686694f6e852d613e6b23a6851704b22d96","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c496b0f57a26cf707360727607563458edc3af780062af2b4660dc963c7257ec","paperId":"1510.00376","textSha256":"ed560f810feeecc9f202015bc5aa3a3f72c3c5d039e44c72a247553b28363fa2"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b9835c1c93f3c49874bf7a1a"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c496b0f57a26cf707360727607563458edc3af780062af2b4660dc963c7257ec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:c496b0f57a26cf707360727607563458edc3af780062af2b4660dc963c7257ec","textSha256":"ed560f810feeecc9f202015bc5aa3a3f72c3c5d039e44c72a247553b28363fa2"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:634e579cb2f8ba8834f8286d"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:634e579cb2f8ba8834f8286d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c496b0f57a26cf707360727607563458edc3af780062af2b4660dc963c7257ec","q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1"],"scopeContentSha256":"88083517e7188e9650d4693a035ba9dc3cfdbd97fd3bc8ea208e4a5618a821ac","contributionContentSha256":"5c4f771c839769bb1e71370d72fabcb7c926661ae166f6a8c8d3d38d59a4804d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:c496b0f57a26cf707360727607563458edc3af780062af2b4660dc963c7257ec","textSha256":"ed560f810feeecc9f202015bc5aa3a3f72c3c5d039e44c72a247553b28363fa2"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:634e579cb2f8ba8834f8286d","recordId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Survey bundles mechanisms, phenomenology, inflation and destabilization; a single fine physical question is unresolved.","challengeNote":"Fine identity remains unresolved: the survey bundles mechanisms, particle phenomenology, inflation, destabilization and backreaction.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d4a84c57329c72aa20451c6f1add41c3f2180e2a497a5ea2aeffd4aad468fc86","home":{"unitId":"unit:d4a84c57329c72aa20451c6f1add41c3f2180e2a497a5ea2aeffd4aad468fc86","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d4a84c57329c72aa20451c6f1add41c3f2180e2a497a5ea2aeffd4aad468fc86","paperId":"2007.04327","textSha256":"5c2001e56f9de5f7f944a8465c10ee355ca22d529731482efe765af08b609ef4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a0a545d89a6fa2bffdbb102e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a0a545d89a6fa2bffdbb102e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d4a84c57329c72aa20451c6f1add41c3f2180e2a497a5ea2aeffd4aad468fc86","q025-candidate-region:a5a0f3155c64f399dc60d323"],"scopeContentSha256":"f17a971eeb6c10205db277c56706e8c84ea6168e3c8144ee6d9dbdd67245625f","placementContentSha256":"8e43f3db7c4f4ad08f7333aadef9db30a6de13b837211e6511ffe9c22b4ab04c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d4a84c57329c72aa20451c6f1add41c3f2180e2a497a5ea2aeffd4aad468fc86","paperId":"2007.04327","textSha256":"5c2001e56f9de5f7f944a8465c10ee355ca22d529731482efe765af08b609ef4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a0a545d89a6fa2bffdbb102e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d4a84c57329c72aa20451c6f1add41c3f2180e2a497a5ea2aeffd4aad468fc86","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:d4a84c57329c72aa20451c6f1add41c3f2180e2a497a5ea2aeffd4aad468fc86","textSha256":"5c2001e56f9de5f7f944a8465c10ee355ca22d529731482efe765af08b609ef4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d5401dfd5be57352412ca7a5"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d5401dfd5be57352412ca7a5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d4a84c57329c72aa20451c6f1add41c3f2180e2a497a5ea2aeffd4aad468fc86","q025-candidate-question:f078031b22564e5456e059a1"],"scopeContentSha256":"88083517e7188e9650d4693a035ba9dc3cfdbd97fd3bc8ea208e4a5618a821ac","contributionContentSha256":"6e69a30699e8d68a55588cdaede10a18db41c55c2c988fb28396c7bc40924b55","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:d4a84c57329c72aa20451c6f1add41c3f2180e2a497a5ea2aeffd4aad468fc86","textSha256":"5c2001e56f9de5f7f944a8465c10ee355ca22d529731482efe765af08b609ef4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d5401dfd5be57352412ca7a5","recordId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Coupled distribution targets: gravitino mass and visible-sector soft terms.","challengeNote":"Gravitino-mass and visible soft-term distributions are related but distinct observables.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":7,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"6431c7f38e6d370d8f91340d5de9e30785ee3393d0a6e928dd628921ca93a5c3"},"organizational-access:881614d29edb9f1dff99e4c2":{"id":"organizational-access:881614d29edb9f1dff99e4c2","source":"q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f","target":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"e2945db24f65f674ea8605b609c51dd9fe5073bd21e154a24a61eea305a587d0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:69a6cdf6a19cdd69ea9874a3"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"10a4e7e7734e47a61979bf33e945f28e1d47ba92237712102852414c91b49856","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:eb45b3bf5c6a528112d9c18a"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5b3e5844a36b8dd1b031cb12cf4e1850134794649b37f1bff5f9c4e3f627766a","home":{"unitId":"unit:5b3e5844a36b8dd1b031cb12cf4e1850134794649b37f1bff5f9c4e3f627766a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5b3e5844a36b8dd1b031cb12cf4e1850134794649b37f1bff5f9c4e3f627766a","paperId":"0705.1557","textSha256":"7935b7d5883a1a7703547007b83d44f985126938d6d0c6e0afe8078ba255034b"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a494e970645c94feaedc569f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a494e970645c94feaedc569f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5b3e5844a36b8dd1b031cb12cf4e1850134794649b37f1bff5f9c4e3f627766a","q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e2945db24f65f674ea8605b609c51dd9fe5073bd21e154a24a61eea305a587d0","placementContentSha256":"89cefe291554d02ab3889cfae6e31c962e46de77b8f4a91d36ea76fc25700efc","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge","leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5b3e5844a36b8dd1b031cb12cf4e1850134794649b37f1bff5f9c4e3f627766a","paperId":"0705.1557","textSha256":"7935b7d5883a1a7703547007b83d44f985126938d6d0c6e0afe8078ba255034b"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a494e970645c94feaedc569f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5b3e5844a36b8dd1b031cb12cf4e1850134794649b37f1bff5f9c4e3f627766a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:5b3e5844a36b8dd1b031cb12cf4e1850134794649b37f1bff5f9c4e3f627766a","textSha256":"7935b7d5883a1a7703547007b83d44f985126938d6d0c6e0afe8078ba255034b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:67b33d9396c6cad689de133b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:67b33d9396c6cad689de133b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5b3e5844a36b8dd1b031cb12cf4e1850134794649b37f1bff5f9c4e3f627766a","q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1"],"scopeContentSha256":"10a4e7e7734e47a61979bf33e945f28e1d47ba92237712102852414c91b49856","contributionContentSha256":"23d846464ca9db42b239a618d68a7ae519c97a66b36850ba5ab73c7ff31c0c7f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:5b3e5844a36b8dd1b031cb12cf4e1850134794649b37f1bff5f9c4e3f627766a","textSha256":"7935b7d5883a1a7703547007b83d44f985126938d6d0c6e0afe8078ba255034b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:67b33d9396c6cad689de133b","recordId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"Stabilization, uplift consistency and the surviving barrier are separate tests within this source-scoped question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:6f9c3ff25194aff40f9858d71f86b80971fa25874c53a6e7faac52d1c0674c18","home":{"unitId":"unit:6f9c3ff25194aff40f9858d71f86b80971fa25874c53a6e7faac52d1c0674c18","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6f9c3ff25194aff40f9858d71f86b80971fa25874c53a6e7faac52d1c0674c18","paperId":"1301.7280","textSha256":"93c34cbb0bbab753ec92dcca898ed9e879c423f6b2e84e9b7821c497419d09be"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:81b735712b6438b8377153a8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:81b735712b6438b8377153a8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6f9c3ff25194aff40f9858d71f86b80971fa25874c53a6e7faac52d1c0674c18","q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e2945db24f65f674ea8605b609c51dd9fe5073bd21e154a24a61eea305a587d0","placementContentSha256":"ed608d25ae7c2c9597db3e5ceffb6e85f64d4f3272f0729dc75cf4873ade437e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge","leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6f9c3ff25194aff40f9858d71f86b80971fa25874c53a6e7faac52d1c0674c18","paperId":"1301.7280","textSha256":"93c34cbb0bbab753ec92dcca898ed9e879c423f6b2e84e9b7821c497419d09be"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:81b735712b6438b8377153a8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:6f9c3ff25194aff40f9858d71f86b80971fa25874c53a6e7faac52d1c0674c18","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:6f9c3ff25194aff40f9858d71f86b80971fa25874c53a6e7faac52d1c0674c18","textSha256":"93c34cbb0bbab753ec92dcca898ed9e879c423f6b2e84e9b7821c497419d09be"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4504582d9a8f5c3591435dcf"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4504582d9a8f5c3591435dcf","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6f9c3ff25194aff40f9858d71f86b80971fa25874c53a6e7faac52d1c0674c18","q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1"],"scopeContentSha256":"10a4e7e7734e47a61979bf33e945f28e1d47ba92237712102852414c91b49856","contributionContentSha256":"4277de55c42d3e1bf5fcac03cbe1884ebcf96b31706ac95d72dbb7d6ad4400e8","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:6f9c3ff25194aff40f9858d71f86b80971fa25874c53a6e7faac52d1c0674c18","textSha256":"93c34cbb0bbab753ec92dcca898ed9e879c423f6b2e84e9b7821c497419d09be"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4504582d9a8f5c3591435dcf","recordId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Four Kähler volume moduli; loop compatibility remains a control test.","challengeNote":"Compound tests concern nonperturbative-term feasibility, four-size stabilization and compatibility with loop corrections.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:defaa5c4ce92ca99501947b2ca3e30fed424ca586d6bf4386548b382b0c3054c","home":{"unitId":"unit:defaa5c4ce92ca99501947b2ca3e30fed424ca586d6bf4386548b382b0c3054c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers higher-derivative modifications of scalar potentials, EFT control and their perturbative moduli-stabilization applications together.","qualification":"q28 covers higher-derivative branch admissibility, induced scalar-potential corrections and their stabilization applications, including the IIB Kähler-volume case. Ghost freedom, EFT compatibility and successful stabilization remain separate tests within the same source question.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:defaa5c4ce92ca99501947b2ca3e30fed424ca586d6bf4386548b382b0c3054c","paperId":"1505.03092","textSha256":"b0ce3c3b49a2da6ec9d7a080991516bfe86774235a95c0e3b82832ca2655b6f9"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0025:u21:q28"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0025:u21:q28","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:defaa5c4ce92ca99501947b2ca3e30fed424ca586d6bf4386548b382b0c3054c","q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e2945db24f65f674ea8605b609c51dd9fe5073bd21e154a24a61eea305a587d0","placementContentSha256":"4426e248d93ba6540e61b40a89126f656d9c61d939bd050d2b705c62e841a5ba","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0025:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0025:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:defaa5c4ce92ca99501947b2ca3e30fed424ca586d6bf4386548b382b0c3054c","paperId":"1505.03092","textSha256":"b0ce3c3b49a2da6ec9d7a080991516bfe86774235a95c0e3b82832ca2655b6f9"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0025","unitRef":"u21"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:defaa5c4ce92ca99501947b2ca3e30fed424ca586d6bf4386548b382b0c3054c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:defaa5c4ce92ca99501947b2ca3e30fed424ca586d6bf4386548b382b0c3054c","textSha256":"b0ce3c3b49a2da6ec9d7a080991516bfe86774235a95c0e3b82832ca2655b6f9"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7559fe8e7cb35adae54b4123"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7559fe8e7cb35adae54b4123","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:defaa5c4ce92ca99501947b2ca3e30fed424ca586d6bf4386548b382b0c3054c","q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1"],"scopeContentSha256":"10a4e7e7734e47a61979bf33e945f28e1d47ba92237712102852414c91b49856","contributionContentSha256":"2755b3cbde7febbea600f15fea6bbd87d7e127f3fbf76576cabb397070d0593b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:defaa5c4ce92ca99501947b2ca3e30fed424ca586d6bf4386548b382b0c3054c","textSha256":"b0ce3c3b49a2da6ec9d7a080991516bfe86774235a95c0e3b82832ca2655b6f9"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7559fe8e7cb35adae54b4123","recordId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound identity: selecting an admissible auxiliary branch and applying its potential to stabilization are distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound identity: admissible auxiliary-branch selection and applications of its potential to stabilization.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","home":{"unitId":"unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","paperId":"0704.0737","textSha256":"e16a39b8987bb3989d40985b56d0180f777dfab354985e26efef19722db78dbc"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8a0961060492a635994b3b61"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8a0961060492a635994b3b61","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e2945db24f65f674ea8605b609c51dd9fe5073bd21e154a24a61eea305a587d0","placementContentSha256":"6237cd427037cf1d9c8deb65a7c86fef8300cd049f63f040477a6036db708109","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge","leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","paperId":"0704.0737","textSha256":"e16a39b8987bb3989d40985b56d0180f777dfab354985e26efef19722db78dbc"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8a0961060492a635994b3b61"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","textSha256":"e16a39b8987bb3989d40985b56d0180f777dfab354985e26efef19722db78dbc"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4591e9cb5de59deaacc30c38"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4591e9cb5de59deaacc30c38","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","q025-candidate-question:63d511152c0994b5a564b0d1"],"scopeContentSha256":"10a4e7e7734e47a61979bf33e945f28e1d47ba92237712102852414c91b49856","contributionContentSha256":"e524f5e13387298db38e53f1877c78f4157e3441ac49685f74996c671d7e4cdb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","textSha256":"e16a39b8987bb3989d40985b56d0180f777dfab354985e26efef19722db78dbc"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4591e9cb5de59deaacc30c38","recordId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The large-volume vacuum is assumed; stabilization compatibility and soft breaking are linked subtargets.","challengeNote":"The vacuum is assumed. Stabilization compatibility and soft supersymmetry breaking are compound subtargets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":4,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"61ce1d7dd8196e5dca36dec4ba9f802aa8d31108ab2b465be3936701a40f08b8"},"organizational-access:733a4c93ff7dc3a0f3b6a984":{"id":"organizational-access:733a4c93ff7dc3a0f3b6a984","source":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9","target":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"2aaa3916150d9c40eb23087fe71c0dabf37597ff3dd1a43473e1e63c8e828df0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:76c8c127702b0d2975d9e4ab"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6cc528912c1f18c1162cdb7868151e38b3047f52ec734fa2f59d4c82a1d10a3d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:283ec5c42d3cd3e507d8c8d1"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","home":{"unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly accommodates period reconstruction, charge bounds and flux stabilization as distinct contributions of one source, including asymptotic regimes beyond large complex structure.","qualification":"q22 covers periods and couplings near degenerations, selected-state weak-gravity calculations and flux stabilization beyond large complex structure as one compound source. Its explicit treatment of these distinct contributions avoids a source split. Polynomial self-duality or potential approximations do not remove exponential terms required for other observables, including metrics and F-terms.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","paperId":"2207.00303","textSha256":"dca7fd64b03fee3206aca2cb0907fb91afdcc045dcd9fc29e3cb9fe3c26c54ce"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0040:u11:q22"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0040:u11:q22","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9"],"scopeContentSha256":"2aaa3916150d9c40eb23087fe71c0dabf37597ff3dd1a43473e1e63c8e828df0","placementContentSha256":"c96b97ab2ba8d722364519f809fefee0d8462997e6e4aa0dc8d6ca491d3c670d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0040:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0040:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","paperId":"2207.00303","textSha256":"dca7fd64b03fee3206aca2cb0907fb91afdcc045dcd9fc29e3cb9fe3c26c54ce"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0040","unitRef":"u11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","textSha256":"dca7fd64b03fee3206aca2cb0907fb91afdcc045dcd9fc29e3cb9fe3c26c54ce"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:309ac92ca466bb3c7a5527db1e889080","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":261,"start":0,"end":2500,"textSha256":"acf7b20aec273527e541c0841fa6f50e02654cc1292218f91d865396cef23659","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f2dff08833dc8363cf59ee00a5e5c422","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":261,"start":91,"end":2500,"textSha256":"a28ce145f8f83a65e060cbcdb5fdefc086e0a9ded5a24a1ff2ad5a94f0738b65","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:431ee698a0faec164a1c842c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:431ee698a0faec164a1c842c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f"],"scopeContentSha256":"6cc528912c1f18c1162cdb7868151e38b3047f52ec734fa2f59d4c82a1d10a3d","contributionContentSha256":"5d7c5e9723802eec2497903c4ce9be298cf7f2782aa52f70cb18e0838f26e717","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-proposal","leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:4fea73399af306abbbb987fd962c91e5e3a816fd2eb6185f24ed0b4d82214a75","textSha256":"dca7fd64b03fee3206aca2cb0907fb91afdcc045dcd9fc29e3cb9fe3c26c54ce"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:309ac92ca466bb3c7a5527db1e889080","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":261,"start":0,"end":2500,"textSha256":"acf7b20aec273527e541c0841fa6f50e02654cc1292218f91d865396cef23659","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9b813e7530f7709f10f1034551fbb80a","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":262,"start":0,"end":2724,"textSha256":"57a38e7ab7fa3fde4c225a8d2174e0b327defb6c80b6a65509b7a2e7a288f9f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f2dff08833dc8363cf59ee00a5e5c422","paperId":"2207.00303","sourceSha256":"5f3ba3e55cdd3f5fd560fcfa4f41b0d56034fd53abe191da8db22b954f106388","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3b90b694a36763f05e80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ac44dd878bf4d0994206a52af028bce0e677512afa879d95db55b09008d02125","pdfPage":261,"start":91,"end":2500,"textSha256":"a28ce145f8f83a65e060cbcdb5fdefc086e0a9ded5a24a1ff2ad5a94f0738b65","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:431ee698a0faec164a1c842c","recordId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound period-construction, selected BPS-extremality and stabilization targets. Polynomial self-duality and exponential-sensitive F-terms are distinguished.","challengeNote":"Distinct period, selected BPS-extremality and stabilization targets. Polynomial self-duality approximations and exponential-sensitive F-terms remain separate.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d89f6f804ad2d7e18b142d8b7fedba3f60c25008eb5c779bbf319170c8af5f0f","home":{"unitId":"unit:d89f6f804ad2d7e18b142d8b7fedba3f60c25008eb5c779bbf319170c8af5f0f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers Calabi–Yau period organization and flux-vacuum applications together with the explicitly connected application to Feynman differential systems.","qualification":"q22 covers the period and restricted-moduli flux-vacuum targets and expressly allows the supplied adjacent amplitude application. The explicit application sentence supplies the connection; common Frobenius or period methods alone would not establish complete coverage. The three outputs remain distinct within one source.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d89f6f804ad2d7e18b142d8b7fedba3f60c25008eb5c779bbf319170c8af5f0f","paperId":"2503.00272","textSha256":"176ac2ab3c67cf9f76f7dbb5222e581fd7d406e913e8aede7bc54d4d99267c5f"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0040:u3:q22"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0040:u3:q22","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d89f6f804ad2d7e18b142d8b7fedba3f60c25008eb5c779bbf319170c8af5f0f","q025-candidate-region:ab32fe5068d3093c0140abe9"],"scopeContentSha256":"2aaa3916150d9c40eb23087fe71c0dabf37597ff3dd1a43473e1e63c8e828df0","placementContentSha256":"f1d9a0e11008ae13b265d258b3f069b4882fb8b53a16b66de73ddf5c00a7d0f3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0040:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0040:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d89f6f804ad2d7e18b142d8b7fedba3f60c25008eb5c779bbf319170c8af5f0f","paperId":"2503.00272","textSha256":"176ac2ab3c67cf9f76f7dbb5222e581fd7d406e913e8aede7bc54d4d99267c5f"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0040","unitRef":"u3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d89f6f804ad2d7e18b142d8b7fedba3f60c25008eb5c779bbf319170c8af5f0f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d50","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:d89f6f804ad2d7e18b142d8b7fedba3f60c25008eb5c779bbf319170c8af5f0f","textSha256":"176ac2ab3c67cf9f76f7dbb5222e581fd7d406e913e8aede7bc54d4d99267c5f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:60f34443b71ea9a6608844c8"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:60f34443b71ea9a6608844c8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d89f6f804ad2d7e18b142d8b7fedba3f60c25008eb5c779bbf319170c8af5f0f","q025-candidate-question:9ce5d981c52bff95759d2a1f"],"scopeContentSha256":"6cc528912c1f18c1162cdb7868151e38b3047f52ec734fa2f59d4c82a1d10a3d","contributionContentSha256":"bf1305cbf8e374888dd38438c725ac986ff79b009b2006ac68b7f66be4b1b275","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-proposal","leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d50","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:d89f6f804ad2d7e18b142d8b7fedba3f60c25008eb5c779bbf319170c8af5f0f","textSha256":"176ac2ab3c67cf9f76f7dbb5222e581fd7d406e913e8aede7bc54d4d99267c5f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:60f34443b71ea9a6608844c8","recordId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Period organization, restricted-space flux vacua and Feynman-integral systems are distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Period organization, restricted-moduli flux vacua and amplitude differential systems remain distinct targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ce4bb0f36f254fd3809eb330bce14b5868b00058eb731bb45056f5ea1d3109cf"},"organizational-access:3a10f0e3588f5ddab417f420":{"id":"organizational-access:3a10f0e3588f5ddab417f420","source":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","target":"q025-candidate-question:ec05022616ac1f5790ff6553","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7b5a236a470736f0c0bd8d64"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ec05022616ac1f5790ff6553","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9fdc54a4f5147edc007cf1903d1315e62c1f1e0d53906683cd1957e585f2b15d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-07:scope:pq0"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:9ed274efe4de46b0e3429e7ab2044f0386212a5acb47cfe61d28bb8a4d21e760","home":{"unitId":"unit:9ed274efe4de46b0e3429e7ab2044f0386212a5acb47cfe61d28bb8a4d21e760","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9ed274efe4de46b0e3429e7ab2044f0386212a5acb47cfe61d28bb8a4d21e760","paperId":"0806.2415","textSha256":"2fc6132451332525369d8db54e702f9c14adba5e8a3185ddb94335c2c8bf5e10"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2805a2665c496a6f7d7865cd"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2805a2665c496a6f7d7865cd","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9ed274efe4de46b0e3429e7ab2044f0386212a5acb47cfe61d28bb8a4d21e760","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"7a8a2f575d60666bca0cc2cc35941e102efe10ae9e9f035c5545fdcc14960173","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9ed274efe4de46b0e3429e7ab2044f0386212a5acb47cfe61d28bb8a4d21e760","paperId":"0806.2415","textSha256":"2fc6132451332525369d8db54e702f9c14adba5e8a3185ddb94335c2c8bf5e10"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2805a2665c496a6f7d7865cd"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9ed274efe4de46b0e3429e7ab2044f0386212a5acb47cfe61d28bb8a4d21e760","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ec05022616ac1f5790ff6553","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","qualification":"The supplied description directly states the scalar-representation question and its necessary positive-density kinetic bound. This new target role does not assert sufficient reconstruction conditions. Independent confirmation: u41 directly addresses pq0's necessary kinetic-sign admissibility question. The role preserves the positive-density condition and does not claim sufficient reconstruction or observational validation.","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u41","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:9ed274efe4de46b0e3429e7ab2044f0386212a5acb47cfe61d28bb8a4d21e760","textSha256":"2fc6132451332525369d8db54e702f9c14adba5e8a3185ddb94335c2c8bf5e10","paperId":"0806.2415"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-07:role:0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-07:role:0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9ed274efe4de46b0e3429e7ab2044f0386212a5acb47cfe61d28bb8a4d21e760","q025-candidate-question:ec05022616ac1f5790ff6553"],"challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"strong-scope-bundle-07-navigation-proposal","challengeReviewId":"strong-scope-bundle-07-navigation-independent-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-07-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-07-navigation-independent-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u41","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:9ed274efe4de46b0e3429e7ab2044f0386212a5acb47cfe61d28bb8a4d21e760","textSha256":"2fc6132451332525369d8db54e702f9c14adba5e8a3185ddb94335c2c8bf5e10","paperId":"0806.2415"}],"originalRole":{"unitRef":"u41","questionRef":"pq0","role":"addresses","reason":"The supplied description directly states the scalar-representation question and its necessary positive-density kinetic bound. This new target role does not assert sufficient reconstruction conditions.","refs":["u41","n25","c1"]},"independentAssessment":{"index":0,"verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"u41 directly addresses pq0's necessary kinetic-sign admissibility question. The role preserves the positive-density condition and does not claim sufficient reconstruction or observational validation.","refs":["u41","n25","c1"]},"contextRefs":[{"localRef":"n25","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:9ed274efe4de46b0e3429e7ab2044f0386212a5acb47cfe61d28bb8a4d21e760","reviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"c1","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b"}],"scopeContentSha256":"9fdc54a4f5147edc007cf1903d1315e62c1f1e0d53906683cd1957e585f2b15d","contributionContentSha256":"fdb78b60e4daf690459e3344227bfe35a4e13cbf1a4ada141dc1b40d234d7964","coordinatorAdmissionReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/navigation-admissions-v4/strong-scope-bundle-07-admission.json","sha256":"674f09c71c6800761f60b9377a5324a97f72347c2d1bb819a016efd54f750137"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"c3f43ea7e7badf4ae4efeacf14ea0713e81e8fe365acd6d56d7df1043dc3c143"},"organizational-access:fb2fa9485d1e0b01ca081109":{"id":"organizational-access:fb2fa9485d1e0b01ca081109","source":"q025-candidate-region:b21723836524518d4ef91f4c","target":"q025-candidate-question:0786330b8b87f5e75752af5a","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:b21723836524518d4ef91f4c","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"2c05b569209711ef792ef3d3bf63ce17f619ca3068980d5e54d03e87524b0257","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:79eabfcbe89a6e88145048a6"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:0786330b8b87f5e75752af5a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"3467d7f5121154ea99d4f6011e08331157129356e1dbd057767973996a253f8e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d11fbdd920d960b2aab47b20"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:9f20f6420fa9897c5a4271d35e10a5713301843997a5ebf6f1e564da930b7359","home":{"unitId":"unit:9f20f6420fa9897c5a4271d35e10a5713301843997a5ebf6f1e564da930b7359","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b21723836524518d4ef91f4c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Combines concrete holographic information/state counting with possible cosmological propagation observables.","qualification":"q16 explicitly combines holographic state counting with possible observables and accommodates the foundational construction. q0 lacks the propagation target; q1's effective locality and signature focus does not expressly include the foundational degree-counting compatibility problem. q16 covers both without a union.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9f20f6420fa9897c5a4271d35e10a5713301843997a5ebf6f1e564da930b7359","paperId":"2402.11016","textSha256":"5c3463c3c4d9c4d98710c2ca25fafb2a3f703da83bf4e9cc467b745da3aa2a81"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0044:u20:q16"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0044:u20:q16","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9f20f6420fa9897c5a4271d35e10a5713301843997a5ebf6f1e564da930b7359","q025-candidate-region:b21723836524518d4ef91f4c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c05b569209711ef792ef3d3bf63ce17f619ca3068980d5e54d03e87524b0257","placementContentSha256":"f850b4f036e27bf81edf2f99b6707a39e9e32d2548d305ab7f75f80583a8aeb7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0044:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0044:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9f20f6420fa9897c5a4271d35e10a5713301843997a5ebf6f1e564da930b7359","paperId":"2402.11016","textSha256":"5c3463c3c4d9c4d98710c2ca25fafb2a3f703da83bf4e9cc467b745da3aa2a81"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0044","unitRef":"u20"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9f20f6420fa9897c5a4271d35e10a5713301843997a5ebf6f1e564da930b7359","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0786330b8b87f5e75752af5a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:9f20f6420fa9897c5a4271d35e10a5713301843997a5ebf6f1e564da930b7359","textSha256":"5c3463c3c4d9c4d98710c2ca25fafb2a3f703da83bf4e9cc467b745da3aa2a81"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:46548585a877c2693ef4b82c","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Algebraic locality/counting and cosmic-neutrino consequences are separate contributions of the compound source question. Independent challenge qualification: The algebraic locality/counting construction and cosmic-neutrino application are distinct contributions."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:46548585a877c2693ef4b82c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9f20f6420fa9897c5a4271d35e10a5713301843997a5ebf6f1e564da930b7359","q025-candidate-question:0786330b8b87f5e75752af5a"],"scopeContentSha256":"3467d7f5121154ea99d4f6011e08331157129356e1dbd057767973996a253f8e","contributionContentSha256":"e2504c8fb00cb16993a0adccef4a3ff56cb673a3ac93af57e3c225f0f940b0b6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal","leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:9f20f6420fa9897c5a4271d35e10a5713301843997a5ebf6f1e564da930b7359","textSha256":"5c3463c3c4d9c4d98710c2ca25fafb2a3f703da83bf4e9cc467b745da3aa2a81"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:46548585a877c2693ef4b82c","recordId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Algebraic locality/counting and cosmic-neutrino consequences are separate contributions of the compound source question.","challengeNote":"The algebraic locality/counting construction and cosmic-neutrino application are distinct contributions.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"44fcf199dcf8fcaa3dd0c42c39809d70f4f3df01c7ffabc1d635c78cb2c4bf5d"},"organizational-access:dbb63e5222d87cf51dc49e16":{"id":"organizational-access:dbb63e5222d87cf51dc49e16","source":"q025-candidate-region:b2904f348b68402830d2f340","target":"q025-candidate-question:4a14c3720eae352ef7660fb7","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:b2904f348b68402830d2f340","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"224e4729a08d957a8b58b842f2cb667b7769339a649752b584fd667aebf188e4","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:15fe9baf0510b51f717d2b9d"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:4a14c3720eae352ef7660fb7","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"d8b5264b598d6062221fef4ad40084d0cef60cf118d3467c435fb7a1128710af","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6c8080949e8f61be3d6d5765"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1367c8eb0a5ab835e3c592d086f23cde362d7d6909c80e47c9f0d683ec158ccc","home":{"unitId":"unit:1367c8eb0a5ab835e3c592d086f23cde362d7d6909c80e47c9f0d683ec158ccc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b2904f348b68402830d2f340","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1367c8eb0a5ab835e3c592d086f23cde362d7d6909c80e47c9f0d683ec158ccc","paperId":"hep-th/9710046","textSha256":"3274ea331bee034752686a8f4b6323b3cdb2fd7f553ecbc85adc8bba8933d568"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e597c3a39d31e259de4817fd"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e597c3a39d31e259de4817fd","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1367c8eb0a5ab835e3c592d086f23cde362d7d6909c80e47c9f0d683ec158ccc","q025-candidate-region:b2904f348b68402830d2f340"],"scopeContentSha256":"224e4729a08d957a8b58b842f2cb667b7769339a649752b584fd667aebf188e4","placementContentSha256":"606bd6bc18dff3eac93cb96acd42bdbd694fde095386c1e3c72e0fea3b6376b4","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge","leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1367c8eb0a5ab835e3c592d086f23cde362d7d6909c80e47c9f0d683ec158ccc","paperId":"hep-th/9710046","textSha256":"3274ea331bee034752686a8f4b6323b3cdb2fd7f553ecbc85adc8bba8933d568"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e597c3a39d31e259de4817fd"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1367c8eb0a5ab835e3c592d086f23cde362d7d6909c80e47c9f0d683ec158ccc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4a14c3720eae352ef7660fb7","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:1367c8eb0a5ab835e3c592d086f23cde362d7d6909c80e47c9f0d683ec158ccc","textSha256":"3274ea331bee034752686a8f4b6323b3cdb2fd7f553ecbc85adc8bba8933d568"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:65230794ce6cede77980f68b","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Supersymmetry and duality encoding differ from restrictions on microscopic entropy interpretation; fine decomposition remains open. Independent challenge qualification: Supersymmetry and duality encoding differ from restrictions on microscopic entropy interpretation; fine decomposition remains open."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:65230794ce6cede77980f68b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1367c8eb0a5ab835e3c592d086f23cde362d7d6909c80e47c9f0d683ec158ccc","q025-candidate-question:4a14c3720eae352ef7660fb7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d8b5264b598d6062221fef4ad40084d0cef60cf118d3467c435fb7a1128710af","contributionContentSha256":"02d2cd723acb5519bb1a61c26f2c2df361ca1af9b4ab2d99c47f562658e7faf9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal","leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:1367c8eb0a5ab835e3c592d086f23cde362d7d6909c80e47c9f0d683ec158ccc","textSha256":"3274ea331bee034752686a8f4b6323b3cdb2fd7f553ecbc85adc8bba8933d568"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:65230794ce6cede77980f68b","recordId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Supersymmetry and duality encoding differ from restrictions on microscopic entropy interpretation; fine decomposition remains open.","challengeNote":"Supersymmetry and duality encoding differ from restrictions on microscopic entropy interpretation; fine decomposition remains open.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:97e1c647951082bcdeda3f1608e4957de3bc59f682867c857970a6a52cbfb91a","home":{"unitId":"unit:97e1c647951082bcdeda3f1608e4957de3bc59f682867c857970a6a52cbfb91a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b2904f348b68402830d2f340","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:97e1c647951082bcdeda3f1608e4957de3bc59f682867c857970a6a52cbfb91a","paperId":"hep-th/9909088","textSha256":"ec3258dcda1308cf3f05cabf6395c3de642be7f596952c4c6eaed086497801fe"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c399c6b49a5faf8b24128f82"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c399c6b49a5faf8b24128f82","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:97e1c647951082bcdeda3f1608e4957de3bc59f682867c857970a6a52cbfb91a","q025-candidate-region:b2904f348b68402830d2f340"],"scopeContentSha256":"224e4729a08d957a8b58b842f2cb667b7769339a649752b584fd667aebf188e4","placementContentSha256":"f9f59029b6fb532242876645084a120ea22c8e57502448b937eb60d193e7436b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge","leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:97e1c647951082bcdeda3f1608e4957de3bc59f682867c857970a6a52cbfb91a","paperId":"hep-th/9909088","textSha256":"ec3258dcda1308cf3f05cabf6395c3de642be7f596952c4c6eaed086497801fe"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c399c6b49a5faf8b24128f82"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:97e1c647951082bcdeda3f1608e4957de3bc59f682867c857970a6a52cbfb91a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4a14c3720eae352ef7660fb7","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:97e1c647951082bcdeda3f1608e4957de3bc59f682867c857970a6a52cbfb91a","textSha256":"ec3258dcda1308cf3f05cabf6395c3de642be7f596952c4c6eaed086497801fe"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3008c9c064d7b680945562b9","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: CFT moduli, charged spectra, solvability and four-dimensional near-extremal entropy are compound targets. Independent challenge qualification: CFT moduli, charged spectra, solvability and four-dimensional near-extremal entropy are compound targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3008c9c064d7b680945562b9","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:97e1c647951082bcdeda3f1608e4957de3bc59f682867c857970a6a52cbfb91a","q025-candidate-question:4a14c3720eae352ef7660fb7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d8b5264b598d6062221fef4ad40084d0cef60cf118d3467c435fb7a1128710af","contributionContentSha256":"d8cb0c4c491f5054c10fde66b7f58f86452d897ddcf8979a36fac888e9b4ab4d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal","leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:97e1c647951082bcdeda3f1608e4957de3bc59f682867c857970a6a52cbfb91a","textSha256":"ec3258dcda1308cf3f05cabf6395c3de642be7f596952c4c6eaed086497801fe"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3008c9c064d7b680945562b9","recordId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"CFT moduli, charged spectra, solvability and four-dimensional near-extremal entropy are compound targets.","challengeNote":"CFT moduli, charged spectra, solvability and four-dimensional near-extremal entropy are compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d0e8d0be5e21442b476bb15bcfac7f1fef16f79de6ee432e6a86adf60f48100f","home":{"unitId":"unit:d0e8d0be5e21442b476bb15bcfac7f1fef16f79de6ee432e6a86adf60f48100f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b2904f348b68402830d2f340","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers solitonic-string realizations of charged black-hole geometry together with microscopic and near-horizon entropy accounts.","qualification":"q40 covers the independent generating-solution and throat-entropy targets. The inherited family is static and spherically symmetric; the six-dimensional conformal model and heterotic compactification remain distinct dimensional descriptions. The entropy interpretation is an argument, not an independently certified count.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d0e8d0be5e21442b476bb15bcfac7f1fef16f79de6ee432e6a86adf60f48100f","paperId":"hep-th/9512031","textSha256":"7f19278ef4538f71c70bd2f21ec597ef60ce7d605e0dc3575156851ec008cd3e"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0066:u20:q40"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0066:u20:q40","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d0e8d0be5e21442b476bb15bcfac7f1fef16f79de6ee432e6a86adf60f48100f","q025-candidate-region:b2904f348b68402830d2f340"],"scopeContentSha256":"224e4729a08d957a8b58b842f2cb667b7769339a649752b584fd667aebf188e4","placementContentSha256":"336253e772f9ca7901a197714cd770d445ddfcc1c150e21c74ca15d9bd10b093","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0066:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0066:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d0e8d0be5e21442b476bb15bcfac7f1fef16f79de6ee432e6a86adf60f48100f","paperId":"hep-th/9512031","textSha256":"7f19278ef4538f71c70bd2f21ec597ef60ce7d605e0dc3575156851ec008cd3e"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0066","unitRef":"u20"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d0e8d0be5e21442b476bb15bcfac7f1fef16f79de6ee432e6a86adf60f48100f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4a14c3720eae352ef7660fb7","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:d0e8d0be5e21442b476bb15bcfac7f1fef16f79de6ee432e6a86adf60f48100f","textSha256":"7f19278ef4538f71c70bd2f21ec597ef60ce7d605e0dc3575156851ec008cd3e"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:55bd2360db08a90592bc0559959d36fc","paperId":"hep-th/9512031","sourceSha256":"3df4fedf88b6a0e309991c3a07f3ce65f2659425365d6f286da243567b8f2f12","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f75d75f11b27fd7d488e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b7ddbf714446a1188420265ded5c8f187ff6f678b65c51b25793b1474c97fec7","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":2341,"textSha256":"6350bc90c4625b8a2c2d32f1285f83695cc336ce62d1330329d1b0ae90e352bc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:edece732b0df9ef540a0f8c562e4d283","paperId":"hep-th/9512031","sourceSha256":"3df4fedf88b6a0e309991c3a07f3ce65f2659425365d6f286da243567b8f2f12","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f75d75f11b27fd7d488e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b7ddbf714446a1188420265ded5c8f187ff6f678b65c51b25793b1474c97fec7","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2341,"textSha256":"5b83f942eec56dd937ab2ecda98eaa5907cc752f94ed8eda2450b96128f772bc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f6fcb3a417b89e6cbfe09db29483207c","paperId":"hep-th/9512031","sourceSha256":"3df4fedf88b6a0e309991c3a07f3ce65f2659425365d6f286da243567b8f2f12","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f75d75f11b27fd7d488e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b7ddbf714446a1188420265ded5c8f187ff6f678b65c51b25793b1474c97fec7","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"bd4ec31a9ed35d4a042623a5c7153f3fc684123bed70c5a4a6ca02fa7286b163","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d5473063f6ebaef6744447c2","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound generating-solution and counting target; the supplied text presents arguments for the entropy interpretation. Independent challenge qualification: The generating family is static and spherically symmetric. Construction and counting remain compound targets; the entropy interpretation is supported by an int﻿"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d5473063f6ebaef6744447c2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d0e8d0be5e21442b476bb15bcfac7f1fef16f79de6ee432e6a86adf60f48100f","q025-candidate-question:4a14c3720eae352ef7660fb7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d8b5264b598d6062221fef4ad40084d0cef60cf118d3467c435fb7a1128710af","contributionContentSha256":"57325ca25198ca82e3efa7f44a2863ee9467b86af833b6531dc203df1cdb092a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal","leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:d0e8d0be5e21442b476bb15bcfac7f1fef16f79de6ee432e6a86adf60f48100f","textSha256":"7f19278ef4538f71c70bd2f21ec597ef60ce7d605e0dc3575156851ec008cd3e"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:55bd2360db08a90592bc0559959d36fc","paperId":"hep-th/9512031","sourceSha256":"3df4fedf88b6a0e309991c3a07f3ce65f2659425365d6f286da243567b8f2f12","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f75d75f11b27fd7d488e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b7ddbf714446a1188420265ded5c8f187ff6f678b65c51b25793b1474c97fec7","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":2341,"textSha256":"6350bc90c4625b8a2c2d32f1285f83695cc336ce62d1330329d1b0ae90e352bc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:edece732b0df9ef540a0f8c562e4d283","paperId":"hep-th/9512031","sourceSha256":"3df4fedf88b6a0e309991c3a07f3ce65f2659425365d6f286da243567b8f2f12","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f75d75f11b27fd7d488e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b7ddbf714446a1188420265ded5c8f187ff6f678b65c51b25793b1474c97fec7","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2341,"textSha256":"5b83f942eec56dd937ab2ecda98eaa5907cc752f94ed8eda2450b96128f772bc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f6fcb3a417b89e6cbfe09db29483207c","paperId":"hep-th/9512031","sourceSha256":"3df4fedf88b6a0e309991c3a07f3ce65f2659425365d6f286da243567b8f2f12","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f75d75f11b27fd7d488e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b7ddbf714446a1188420265ded5c8f187ff6f678b65c51b25793b1474c97fec7","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"bd4ec31a9ed35d4a042623a5c7153f3fc684123bed70c5a4a6ca02fa7286b163","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d5473063f6ebaef6744447c2","recordId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound generating-solution and counting target; the supplied text presents arguments for the entropy interpretation.","challengeNote":"The generating family is static and spherically symmetric. Construction and counting remain compound targets; the entropy interpretation is supported by an int﻿","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"5cc36823c7f8434e6aa0653607db76955ed1332828eed4627130b4b8ba191ade"},"organizational-access:c9405044a86dc85986e86770":{"id":"organizational-access:c9405044a86dc85986e86770","source":"q025-candidate-region:dcf0e518cc7236cee97e18e3","target":"q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:dcf0e518cc7236cee97e18e3","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"5a97781a49b8a5ade517876d6c4a13cc40cf523e97cd5d003fb4b9c9edad6399","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:688b36a36295772ec0a3008f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c336e5d810d94169b24782d03a967568cfa97589d949c2eea680fc9c3a3a619a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8892cfd297028a6f834dc0b5"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:46b81e6ea95dcac1e1238c073dfde8fc62be7164b722029fd9c3231e1cad047a","home":{"unitId":"unit:46b81e6ea95dcac1e1238c073dfde8fc62be7164b722029fd9c3231e1cad047a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:dcf0e518cc7236cee97e18e3","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:46b81e6ea95dcac1e1238c073dfde8fc62be7164b722029fd9c3231e1cad047a","paperId":"2601.14376","textSha256":"3c1babaa35b2391a0c4bfe95c349a06ba784df64b20bd849fa124bb6e2a5d4eb"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e5c0614e7e944c7f3f41fea3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e5c0614e7e944c7f3f41fea3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:46b81e6ea95dcac1e1238c073dfde8fc62be7164b722029fd9c3231e1cad047a","q025-candidate-region:dcf0e518cc7236cee97e18e3"],"scopeContentSha256":"5a97781a49b8a5ade517876d6c4a13cc40cf523e97cd5d003fb4b9c9edad6399","placementContentSha256":"0092c8730c1337252dc80d11a6249a454f361818c50be3b1cf8570d9827e09a7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:46b81e6ea95dcac1e1238c073dfde8fc62be7164b722029fd9c3231e1cad047a","paperId":"2601.14376","textSha256":"3c1babaa35b2391a0c4bfe95c349a06ba784df64b20bd849fa124bb6e2a5d4eb"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e5c0614e7e944c7f3f41fea3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:46b81e6ea95dcac1e1238c073dfde8fc62be7164b722029fd9c3231e1cad047a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:46b81e6ea95dcac1e1238c073dfde8fc62be7164b722029fd9c3231e1cad047a","textSha256":"3c1babaa35b2391a0c4bfe95c349a06ba784df64b20bd849fa124bb6e2a5d4eb"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cc282c456ec7cfc5811a7227","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Charge quantization is relaxed; strong neutrino interactions, tiny masses and searches beyond baryonic fifth forces are joint requirements. Independent challenge qualification: Joint charge, anomaly, interaction, mass-compatibility and search requirements; no unbroken symmetry phase is inferred."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:cc282c456ec7cfc5811a7227","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:46b81e6ea95dcac1e1238c073dfde8fc62be7164b722029fd9c3231e1cad047a","q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c336e5d810d94169b24782d03a967568cfa97589d949c2eea680fc9c3a3a619a","contributionContentSha256":"ce6c812407c162aa17b3617873052c91cbdbc9ac5b2837f5bf823ef6a7cc2b81","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:46b81e6ea95dcac1e1238c073dfde8fc62be7164b722029fd9c3231e1cad047a","textSha256":"3c1babaa35b2391a0c4bfe95c349a06ba784df64b20bd849fa124bb6e2a5d4eb"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cc282c456ec7cfc5811a7227","recordId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Charge quantization is relaxed; strong neutrino interactions, tiny masses and searches beyond baryonic fifth forces are joint requirements.","challengeNote":"Joint charge, anomaly, interaction, mass-compatibility and search requirements; no unbroken symmetry phase is inferred.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:4c1a2ff7a9c3fc65acff4493282d151b768a08973a53d60ff870876868fbc89a","home":{"unitId":"unit:4c1a2ff7a9c3fc65acff4493282d151b768a08973a53d60ff870876868fbc89a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:dcf0e518cc7236cee97e18e3","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4c1a2ff7a9c3fc65acff4493282d151b768a08973a53d60ff870876868fbc89a","paperId":"2609.30136","textSha256":"138a86869db273167964598daa1d6433425cb3fbd3d5b012f3d64c678636c4f0"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c5478348f1e925299691835d"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c5478348f1e925299691835d","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4c1a2ff7a9c3fc65acff4493282d151b768a08973a53d60ff870876868fbc89a","q025-candidate-region:dcf0e518cc7236cee97e18e3"],"scopeContentSha256":"5a97781a49b8a5ade517876d6c4a13cc40cf523e97cd5d003fb4b9c9edad6399","placementContentSha256":"3491955ce5fdb23d8743e1319f4cdb0fe067b0debafbd996246d9459b6645053","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4c1a2ff7a9c3fc65acff4493282d151b768a08973a53d60ff870876868fbc89a","paperId":"2609.30136","textSha256":"138a86869db273167964598daa1d6433425cb3fbd3d5b012f3d64c678636c4f0"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c5478348f1e925299691835d"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4c1a2ff7a9c3fc65acff4493282d151b768a08973a53d60ff870876868fbc89a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:4c1a2ff7a9c3fc65acff4493282d151b768a08973a53d60ff870876868fbc89a","textSha256":"138a86869db273167964598daa1d6433425cb3fbd3d5b012f3d64c678636c4f0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2877a26c7140e17e6689e8f2","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound universal-seesaw mass generation for charged fermions and neutrinos, plus protection of accidental PQ symmetry. Independent challenge qualification: Compound charged-fermion/neutrino universal seesaws and protection of accidental PQ symmetry."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2877a26c7140e17e6689e8f2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4c1a2ff7a9c3fc65acff4493282d151b768a08973a53d60ff870876868fbc89a","q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c336e5d810d94169b24782d03a967568cfa97589d949c2eea680fc9c3a3a619a","contributionContentSha256":"c01a75334a17324515136a4b7b7b1cb7d5de67fb3c7982950b9f51288f201b74","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:4c1a2ff7a9c3fc65acff4493282d151b768a08973a53d60ff870876868fbc89a","textSha256":"138a86869db273167964598daa1d6433425cb3fbd3d5b012f3d64c678636c4f0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2877a26c7140e17e6689e8f2","recordId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound universal-seesaw mass generation for charged fermions and neutrinos, plus protection of accidental PQ symmetry.","challengeNote":"Compound charged-fermion/neutrino universal seesaws and protection of accidental PQ symmetry.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:96af8ca08caa23ab5e52b8721f46cc6562fd5ae1ea573f8f50d9eba9cc8f76f8","home":{"unitId":"unit:96af8ca08caa23ab5e52b8721f46cc6562fd5ae1ea573f8f50d9eba9cc8f76f8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:dcf0e518cc7236cee97e18e3","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:96af8ca08caa23ab5e52b8721f46cc6562fd5ae1ea573f8f50d9eba9cc8f76f8","paperId":"2509.10456","textSha256":"f7c5c260fb21fa3a5f38a9b5c53cfe3f653619334315e4a049b63420b7c6b21c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4d0308168bf0f46014df5a64"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4d0308168bf0f46014df5a64","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:96af8ca08caa23ab5e52b8721f46cc6562fd5ae1ea573f8f50d9eba9cc8f76f8","q025-candidate-region:dcf0e518cc7236cee97e18e3"],"scopeContentSha256":"5a97781a49b8a5ade517876d6c4a13cc40cf523e97cd5d003fb4b9c9edad6399","placementContentSha256":"18e8ac1c52edaa968d69aee610014080216fc32aa79447b03e13363f4223e1e8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:96af8ca08caa23ab5e52b8721f46cc6562fd5ae1ea573f8f50d9eba9cc8f76f8","paperId":"2509.10456","textSha256":"f7c5c260fb21fa3a5f38a9b5c53cfe3f653619334315e4a049b63420b7c6b21c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4d0308168bf0f46014df5a64"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:96af8ca08caa23ab5e52b8721f46cc6562fd5ae1ea573f8f50d9eba9cc8f76f8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:96af8ca08caa23ab5e52b8721f46cc6562fd5ae1ea573f8f50d9eba9cc8f76f8","textSha256":"f7c5c260fb21fa3a5f38a9b5c53cfe3f653619334315e4a049b63420b7c6b21c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:54c227006079583b63b20256","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Joint mass-generation and indirect gravitational-wave discrimination targets; the three neutrino characters are compared. Independent challenge qualification: Joint mass-generation and indirect discrimination targets; the three neutrino characters are compared within specified models."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:54c227006079583b63b20256","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:96af8ca08caa23ab5e52b8721f46cc6562fd5ae1ea573f8f50d9eba9cc8f76f8","q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c336e5d810d94169b24782d03a967568cfa97589d949c2eea680fc9c3a3a619a","contributionContentSha256":"05198ab030db621972423130c8af860e49df9d76a9d26ddc333a27240b59d7dc","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:96af8ca08caa23ab5e52b8721f46cc6562fd5ae1ea573f8f50d9eba9cc8f76f8","textSha256":"f7c5c260fb21fa3a5f38a9b5c53cfe3f653619334315e4a049b63420b7c6b21c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:54c227006079583b63b20256","recordId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Joint mass-generation and indirect gravitational-wave discrimination targets; the three neutrino characters are compared.","challengeNote":"Joint mass-generation and indirect discrimination targets; the three neutrino characters are compared within specified models.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ceae6b4bc14de657efa639bd4293f61998f5bf333c8ca746d4503cfb026de2ac","home":{"unitId":"unit:ceae6b4bc14de657efa639bd4293f61998f5bf333c8ca746d4503cfb026de2ac","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:dcf0e518cc7236cee97e18e3","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ceae6b4bc14de657efa639bd4293f61998f5bf333c8ca746d4503cfb026de2ac","paperId":"hep-ph/0502176","textSha256":"4529eada7f88ba3cee39daf7810a05cd353d1750ee19174847b8df6a098f1640"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f49cd40c73127ee6dad75852"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f49cd40c73127ee6dad75852","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ceae6b4bc14de657efa639bd4293f61998f5bf333c8ca746d4503cfb026de2ac","q025-candidate-region:dcf0e518cc7236cee97e18e3"],"scopeContentSha256":"5a97781a49b8a5ade517876d6c4a13cc40cf523e97cd5d003fb4b9c9edad6399","placementContentSha256":"012741b800b916d45c6b7e9dfbe8d51dad68a07e2271d940e94ff12608d0a4e5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ceae6b4bc14de657efa639bd4293f61998f5bf333c8ca746d4503cfb026de2ac","paperId":"hep-ph/0502176","textSha256":"4529eada7f88ba3cee39daf7810a05cd353d1750ee19174847b8df6a098f1640"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f49cd40c73127ee6dad75852"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ceae6b4bc14de657efa639bd4293f61998f5bf333c8ca746d4503cfb026de2ac","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d29","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:ceae6b4bc14de657efa639bd4293f61998f5bf333c8ca746d4503cfb026de2ac","textSha256":"4529eada7f88ba3cee39daf7810a05cd353d1750ee19174847b8df6a098f1640"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4f09edc9cc0725cf8c676f2c","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Joint suppression of excessive baryon/lepton violation and infrared mass generation; Dirac and Majorana are alternatives. Independent challenge qualification: Joint operator protection and infrared mass generation; Dirac and Majorana are alternatives."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4f09edc9cc0725cf8c676f2c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ceae6b4bc14de657efa639bd4293f61998f5bf333c8ca746d4503cfb026de2ac","q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c336e5d810d94169b24782d03a967568cfa97589d949c2eea680fc9c3a3a619a","contributionContentSha256":"a119921a291feb0a27ed4227a2ea7a52c82640e966bb447f341c490c177b040b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d29","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:ceae6b4bc14de657efa639bd4293f61998f5bf333c8ca746d4503cfb026de2ac","textSha256":"4529eada7f88ba3cee39daf7810a05cd353d1750ee19174847b8df6a098f1640"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4f09edc9cc0725cf8c676f2c","recordId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Joint suppression of excessive baryon/lepton violation and infrared mass generation; Dirac and Majorana are alternatives.","challengeNote":"Joint operator protection and infrared mass generation; Dirac and Majorana are alternatives.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:db14babc41641f2bc8d3864acfc4ee8bca5483524f9969dd1d9b0f160b4ecf2f","home":{"unitId":"unit:db14babc41641f2bc8d3864acfc4ee8bca5483524f9969dd1d9b0f160b4ecf2f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:dcf0e518cc7236cee97e18e3","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:db14babc41641f2bc8d3864acfc4ee8bca5483524f9969dd1d9b0f160b4ecf2f","paperId":"2003.04908","textSha256":"ed9c6832b6c621314caba2985989d697cf51734d7bba9855993242803f8fd140"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eb40d3ace19d379bb6e89172"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eb40d3ace19d379bb6e89172","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:db14babc41641f2bc8d3864acfc4ee8bca5483524f9969dd1d9b0f160b4ecf2f","q025-candidate-region:dcf0e518cc7236cee97e18e3"],"scopeContentSha256":"5a97781a49b8a5ade517876d6c4a13cc40cf523e97cd5d003fb4b9c9edad6399","placementContentSha256":"7fabd00493874f7ceb07f6e7ae9386e5e633dca9ca8ef5a66027978ba52de616","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:db14babc41641f2bc8d3864acfc4ee8bca5483524f9969dd1d9b0f160b4ecf2f","paperId":"2003.04908","textSha256":"ed9c6832b6c621314caba2985989d697cf51734d7bba9855993242803f8fd140"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eb40d3ace19d379bb6e89172"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:db14babc41641f2bc8d3864acfc4ee8bca5483524f9969dd1d9b0f160b4ecf2f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:db14babc41641f2bc8d3864acfc4ee8bca5483524f9969dd1d9b0f160b4ecf2f","textSha256":"ed9c6832b6c621314caba2985989d697cf51734d7bba9855993242803f8fd140"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:77b9236f9f9fa8794b6ac7a0","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Joint mass, axion-dark-matter and neutrino-decay targets. Mass operators preserve the symmetry; only nonperturbative gravity breaks it. Independent challenge qualification: Compound mass, axion-dark-matter and decay targets. The mass operators preserve the symmetry; only the specified nonperturbative gravity effects break it."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:77b9236f9f9fa8794b6ac7a0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:db14babc41641f2bc8d3864acfc4ee8bca5483524f9969dd1d9b0f160b4ecf2f","q025-candidate-question:c719902b27c22a476426167a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c336e5d810d94169b24782d03a967568cfa97589d949c2eea680fc9c3a3a619a","contributionContentSha256":"67f7f6c6e3744fe6a450aab5a1a7fee57a1f385488b0b4ea965fc7ba484d4e47","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:db14babc41641f2bc8d3864acfc4ee8bca5483524f9969dd1d9b0f160b4ecf2f","textSha256":"ed9c6832b6c621314caba2985989d697cf51734d7bba9855993242803f8fd140"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:77b9236f9f9fa8794b6ac7a0","recordId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-76e3d3dd115e5b73a21b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Joint mass, axion-dark-matter and neutrino-decay targets. Mass operators preserve the symmetry; only nonperturbative gravity breaks it.","challengeNote":"Compound mass, axion-dark-matter and decay targets. The mass operators preserve the symmetry; only the specified nonperturbative gravity effects break it.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":5,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"94ca22d958eb10db9011d3c0520565d492c04fffc61fd61bc4224b5caab229ce"},"organizational-access:a87caaaf6d16507e07b23b42":{"id":"organizational-access:a87caaaf6d16507e07b23b42","source":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","target":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e836593b270a54ee0f044826"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:fe77a3f2c280a52da4b8ba47"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","home":{"unitId":"unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","paperId":"astro-ph/0107573","textSha256":"872abab4bbe5138f2c8b321340aa88c4ff1cc001b80a8d6b193db22b78f358a0"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6dfff9a453b564b939123f7b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6dfff9a453b564b939123f7b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","placementContentSha256":"ef7b30b738ff0a25e03ec4838e89b7b11b2ef1534856b0aa881d47b9b1e57adb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","paperId":"astro-ph/0107573","textSha256":"872abab4bbe5138f2c8b321340aa88c4ff1cc001b80a8d6b193db22b78f358a0"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6dfff9a453b564b939123f7b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","textSha256":"872abab4bbe5138f2c8b321340aa88c4ff1cc001b80a8d6b193db22b78f358a0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c71be0d88c73b563674a67d0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c71be0d88c73b563674a67d0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"],"scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","contributionContentSha256":"b544b5555f14291299c777b3d6cd43ede267f0810ca4d44cea5c32870390a864","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","textSha256":"872abab4bbe5138f2c8b321340aa88c4ff1cc001b80a8d6b193db22b78f358a0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c71be0d88c73b563674a67d0","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:1db3427f5e01897af82ffb70341402a5903a4ba2804954ea09a6398a0f6f8816","home":{"unitId":"unit:1db3427f5e01897af82ffb70341402a5903a4ba2804954ea09a6398a0f6f8816","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1db3427f5e01897af82ffb70341402a5903a4ba2804954ea09a6398a0f6f8816","paperId":"0809.4628","textSha256":"f614fb6e283f73ca34b006e5fc231673016bab2769d787352c59df56d78139b7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cfc5e4c47cad5b7576fe749a"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cfc5e4c47cad5b7576fe749a","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1db3427f5e01897af82ffb70341402a5903a4ba2804954ea09a6398a0f6f8816","q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","placementContentSha256":"5c2360f3246653f9087420069418a44f914ab6a4d89196eb452e3178568b6b47","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1db3427f5e01897af82ffb70341402a5903a4ba2804954ea09a6398a0f6f8816","paperId":"0809.4628","textSha256":"f614fb6e283f73ca34b006e5fc231673016bab2769d787352c59df56d78139b7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cfc5e4c47cad5b7576fe749a"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1db3427f5e01897af82ffb70341402a5903a4ba2804954ea09a6398a0f6f8816","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:1db3427f5e01897af82ffb70341402a5903a4ba2804954ea09a6398a0f6f8816","textSha256":"f614fb6e283f73ca34b006e5fc231673016bab2769d787352c59df56d78139b7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:de7123b07de49909bebfe4c0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:de7123b07de49909bebfe4c0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1db3427f5e01897af82ffb70341402a5903a4ba2804954ea09a6398a0f6f8816","q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"],"scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","contributionContentSha256":"c04fee1cbc01d027afafae1c060aa3d144fff712a6295e2e3cf958425822188c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:1db3427f5e01897af82ffb70341402a5903a4ba2804954ea09a6398a0f6f8816","textSha256":"f614fb6e283f73ca34b006e5fc231673016bab2769d787352c59df56d78139b7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:de7123b07de49909bebfe4c0","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:30e469dad86f2093687b4ce209e575cf9975924d40b859ab9ce3377e8915c306","home":{"unitId":"unit:30e469dad86f2093687b4ce209e575cf9975924d40b859ab9ce3377e8915c306","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:30e469dad86f2093687b4ce209e575cf9975924d40b859ab9ce3377e8915c306","paperId":"1807.06581","textSha256":"7d8885e8454d324921b38efdbb6acc6d8fe744e5e5cb3604c585ec273958d3e6"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:032d0d53c71dae090e60d5c6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:032d0d53c71dae090e60d5c6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:30e469dad86f2093687b4ce209e575cf9975924d40b859ab9ce3377e8915c306","q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","placementContentSha256":"c8c38d308ce6dc2399c08242d09885fee6d3f18b8ce48890a75e27da1b2079ef","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:30e469dad86f2093687b4ce209e575cf9975924d40b859ab9ce3377e8915c306","paperId":"1807.06581","textSha256":"7d8885e8454d324921b38efdbb6acc6d8fe744e5e5cb3604c585ec273958d3e6"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:032d0d53c71dae090e60d5c6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:30e469dad86f2093687b4ce209e575cf9975924d40b859ab9ce3377e8915c306","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:30e469dad86f2093687b4ce209e575cf9975924d40b859ab9ce3377e8915c306","textSha256":"7d8885e8454d324921b38efdbb6acc6d8fe744e5e5cb3604c585ec273958d3e6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5cd0d402bc6824bf7494bded"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5cd0d402bc6824bf7494bded","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:30e469dad86f2093687b4ce209e575cf9975924d40b859ab9ce3377e8915c306","q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"],"scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","contributionContentSha256":"5950004fd665d52bcd4f92b918b40c493ad3f5f3ca9e7cdb0030d8ffda4bf153","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:30e469dad86f2093687b4ce209e575cf9975924d40b859ab9ce3377e8915c306","textSha256":"7d8885e8454d324921b38efdbb6acc6d8fe744e5e5cb3604c585ec273958d3e6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5cd0d402bc6824bf7494bded","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Low-energy compatibility and a controlled string realization are separate targets; canonical identity is unresolved.","challengeNote":"Low-energy compatibility and controlled string construction are distinct targets requiring identity reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","home":{"unitId":"unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","paperId":"1203.6655","textSha256":"0066714c83d315a01d94ff9d8cd7a5a21516ff3806bbdb99a351df0248b41cef"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:81bf43f63a9d2f636bbcaed2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:81bf43f63a9d2f636bbcaed2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","placementContentSha256":"4d946425244345e0c3eab0aab35ccf944c39f2c8fb2dd6601659c4e77a4273be","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","paperId":"1203.6655","textSha256":"0066714c83d315a01d94ff9d8cd7a5a21516ff3806bbdb99a351df0248b41cef"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:81bf43f63a9d2f636bbcaed2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","textSha256":"0066714c83d315a01d94ff9d8cd7a5a21516ff3806bbdb99a351df0248b41cef"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:90f846e4de9f4a40e87d3704"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:90f846e4de9f4a40e87d3704","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"],"scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","contributionContentSha256":"60725b234ba74e15cda709824c8cd3d10da47856e95aa639409e2640fc5c9b46","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","textSha256":"0066714c83d315a01d94ff9d8cd7a5a21516ff3806bbdb99a351df0248b41cef"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:90f846e4de9f4a40e87d3704","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound viability target: tiny mass, weak visible coupling and cosmology with or without dark-matter interactions.","challengeNote":"Compound mass, coupling and cosmological viability targets; the source-scoped singleton does not establish atomicity.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5451c93830dd037986fa048786df25d0738ea8e8f0e59085141c1733f9a1b37c","home":{"unitId":"unit:5451c93830dd037986fa048786df25d0738ea8e8f0e59085141c1733f9a1b37c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5451c93830dd037986fa048786df25d0738ea8e8f0e59085141c1733f9a1b37c","paperId":"1812.03184","textSha256":"a1867bb3e6374956b2bc186cf2c95da346da080db4d4307b37366e807dc792d8"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:36e2d0977af14ba3344bb4fe"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:36e2d0977af14ba3344bb4fe","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5451c93830dd037986fa048786df25d0738ea8e8f0e59085141c1733f9a1b37c","q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","placementContentSha256":"8ce1e8b51681db0ff5bde53838fc6225f5bf64aeb3eca1e44615f4dc53393d7e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5451c93830dd037986fa048786df25d0738ea8e8f0e59085141c1733f9a1b37c","paperId":"1812.03184","textSha256":"a1867bb3e6374956b2bc186cf2c95da346da080db4d4307b37366e807dc792d8"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:36e2d0977af14ba3344bb4fe"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5451c93830dd037986fa048786df25d0738ea8e8f0e59085141c1733f9a1b37c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:5451c93830dd037986fa048786df25d0738ea8e8f0e59085141c1733f9a1b37c","textSha256":"a1867bb3e6374956b2bc186cf2c95da346da080db4d4307b37366e807dc792d8"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c916f1e77d31d516553eba80"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c916f1e77d31d516553eba80","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5451c93830dd037986fa048786df25d0738ea8e8f0e59085141c1733f9a1b37c","q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"],"scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","contributionContentSha256":"7a5022e89dadc17b31e2a5872792864875e63d5a78f5f6d761fc0390307abb95","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:5451c93830dd037986fa048786df25d0738ea8e8f0e59085141c1733f9a1b37c","textSha256":"a1867bb3e6374956b2bc186cf2c95da346da080db4d4307b37366e807dc792d8"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c916f1e77d31d516553eba80","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Alternative open routes, not demonstrated solutions.","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:603e025f78e9f821a61c97becfb35dc0f4d9a282942860b6bc69dc8dfd5d4acd","home":{"unitId":"unit:603e025f78e9f821a61c97becfb35dc0f4d9a282942860b6bc69dc8dfd5d4acd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:603e025f78e9f821a61c97becfb35dc0f4d9a282942860b6bc69dc8dfd5d4acd","paperId":"1812.03184","textSha256":"ff99a6f1ca2350230232b856f8947cbd318423f74b4598d1c1f232c58f8c709c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ec88da240ac765fabafcaba7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ec88da240ac765fabafcaba7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:603e025f78e9f821a61c97becfb35dc0f4d9a282942860b6bc69dc8dfd5d4acd","q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","placementContentSha256":"3de3330592a540d8dbeea89ae478ffca1202a86734360fada2d29b1af91e1180","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:603e025f78e9f821a61c97becfb35dc0f4d9a282942860b6bc69dc8dfd5d4acd","paperId":"1812.03184","textSha256":"ff99a6f1ca2350230232b856f8947cbd318423f74b4598d1c1f232c58f8c709c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ec88da240ac765fabafcaba7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:603e025f78e9f821a61c97becfb35dc0f4d9a282942860b6bc69dc8dfd5d4acd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:603e025f78e9f821a61c97becfb35dc0f4d9a282942860b6bc69dc8dfd5d4acd","textSha256":"ff99a6f1ca2350230232b856f8947cbd318423f74b4598d1c1f232c58f8c709c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:33bd95249e026ff1690a339a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:33bd95249e026ff1690a339a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:603e025f78e9f821a61c97becfb35dc0f4d9a282942860b6bc69dc8dfd5d4acd","q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"],"scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","contributionContentSha256":"a4c7f332cad6395a31c14d34a1ab62ec8066266f3518ac35040eb3d550bf9d8b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:603e025f78e9f821a61c97becfb35dc0f4d9a282942860b6bc69dc8dfd5d4acd","textSha256":"ff99a6f1ca2350230232b856f8947cbd318423f74b4598d1c1f232c58f8c709c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:33bd95249e026ff1690a339a","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:78e7e070d1312576cdde11b8505f5bba680eeda98599afdf99319f931f170778","home":{"unitId":"unit:78e7e070d1312576cdde11b8505f5bba680eeda98599afdf99319f931f170778","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:78e7e070d1312576cdde11b8505f5bba680eeda98599afdf99319f931f170778","paperId":"1810.02095","textSha256":"92b2b3d356f0a0a0625b4707061cb64f97e7851a4a82177647c77a88fa657dc5"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:760b648ca46de3385b79d62e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:760b648ca46de3385b79d62e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:78e7e070d1312576cdde11b8505f5bba680eeda98599afdf99319f931f170778","q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","placementContentSha256":"791d43d9b63a484f30760133f0199866c54ca34e60a9a94dbd915ee26c2740c8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:78e7e070d1312576cdde11b8505f5bba680eeda98599afdf99319f931f170778","paperId":"1810.02095","textSha256":"92b2b3d356f0a0a0625b4707061cb64f97e7851a4a82177647c77a88fa657dc5"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:760b648ca46de3385b79d62e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:78e7e070d1312576cdde11b8505f5bba680eeda98599afdf99319f931f170778","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:78e7e070d1312576cdde11b8505f5bba680eeda98599afdf99319f931f170778","textSha256":"92b2b3d356f0a0a0625b4707061cb64f97e7851a4a82177647c77a88fa657dc5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:51a4f92d9302922e9a09c568"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:51a4f92d9302922e9a09c568","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:78e7e070d1312576cdde11b8505f5bba680eeda98599afdf99319f931f170778","q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"],"scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","contributionContentSha256":"36e14441e92104a4aed4b93075234d13a3084bc0ad393c2aa5339ad446ba9d6a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:78e7e070d1312576cdde11b8505f5bba680eeda98599afdf99319f931f170778","textSha256":"92b2b3d356f0a0a0625b4707061cb64f97e7851a4a82177647c77a88fa657dc5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:51a4f92d9302922e9a09c568","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","home":{"unitId":"unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","paperId":"astro-ph/0107386","textSha256":"13dd421e839588916f067005d62b5b1e8fd7f723781a27bfe07d70cf5d651486"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:445671e6d96a22f48ec2fa0f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:445671e6d96a22f48ec2fa0f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","placementContentSha256":"08709ed175f50623027984da50be983f13afa5afcd3f21372c328ccbf6134a10","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","paperId":"astro-ph/0107386","textSha256":"13dd421e839588916f067005d62b5b1e8fd7f723781a27bfe07d70cf5d651486"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:445671e6d96a22f48ec2fa0f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","textSha256":"13dd421e839588916f067005d62b5b1e8fd7f723781a27bfe07d70cf5d651486"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:be5e88097dd5f012831b5237"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:be5e88097dd5f012831b5237","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"],"scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","contributionContentSha256":"76f51e28726c2b79e2dc239b5b3bc86b983f55511805c11470f1f5c816161336","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","textSha256":"13dd421e839588916f067005d62b5b1e8fd7f723781a27bfe07d70cf5d651486"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:be5e88097dd5f012831b5237","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","home":{"unitId":"unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","paperId":"astro-ph/9906066","textSha256":"97dcd36e38169ad8bf5019334f78a16b51e5c360c16c4d2f9b650df7fb7419e2"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:283c0cbac60dbf1ae1f61769c44a3ef7","paperId":"astro-ph/9906066","sourceSha256":"4b77a845583f98eef10b8533315151c563298fd6b9b8a6177e959b9a13576538","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/452208292d42d2c80cfc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f5b728633e8f79f46c010f967637d6ff1c2336702345e89a8d9313728b6eb4a8","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":3497,"textSha256":"22ebc43298b1f49fd375556c9d41bbdbafaac940ccd80cee3ab75f317b3e4257","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3b8acac1cfe4baf461ff5c247a6b3627","paperId":"astro-ph/9906066","sourceSha256":"4b77a845583f98eef10b8533315151c563298fd6b9b8a6177e959b9a13576538","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/452208292d42d2c80cfc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f5b728633e8f79f46c010f967637d6ff1c2336702345e89a8d9313728b6eb4a8","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":3496,"textSha256":"63be0670117255cb5eeb4c049110962db39d68965d3b0ed5993097dcba00cb2d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a89ecd69df4b97b25fadf089a2789eb9","paperId":"astro-ph/9906066","sourceSha256":"4b77a845583f98eef10b8533315151c563298fd6b9b8a6177e959b9a13576538","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/452208292d42d2c80cfc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f5b728633e8f79f46c010f967637d6ff1c2336702345e89a8d9313728b6eb4a8","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c8961a5778467ec400d5b843b7d3cbef621efd08e74c466e75c0b1e5f01b088e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:884128f817fe7ffd55fbc2e0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:884128f817fe7ffd55fbc2e0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","placementContentSha256":"dd7443506f21b8c75ef7c01b39b74cebc79228ff277c8387570ee4481016e0f9","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","paperId":"astro-ph/9906066","textSha256":"97dcd36e38169ad8bf5019334f78a16b51e5c360c16c4d2f9b650df7fb7419e2"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:283c0cbac60dbf1ae1f61769c44a3ef7","paperId":"astro-ph/9906066","sourceSha256":"4b77a845583f98eef10b8533315151c563298fd6b9b8a6177e959b9a13576538","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/452208292d42d2c80cfc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f5b728633e8f79f46c010f967637d6ff1c2336702345e89a8d9313728b6eb4a8","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":3497,"textSha256":"22ebc43298b1f49fd375556c9d41bbdbafaac940ccd80cee3ab75f317b3e4257","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3b8acac1cfe4baf461ff5c247a6b3627","paperId":"astro-ph/9906066","sourceSha256":"4b77a845583f98eef10b8533315151c563298fd6b9b8a6177e959b9a13576538","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/452208292d42d2c80cfc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f5b728633e8f79f46c010f967637d6ff1c2336702345e89a8d9313728b6eb4a8","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":3496,"textSha256":"63be0670117255cb5eeb4c049110962db39d68965d3b0ed5993097dcba00cb2d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a89ecd69df4b97b25fadf089a2789eb9","paperId":"astro-ph/9906066","sourceSha256":"4b77a845583f98eef10b8533315151c563298fd6b9b8a6177e959b9a13576538","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/452208292d42d2c80cfc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f5b728633e8f79f46c010f967637d6ff1c2336702345e89a8d9313728b6eb4a8","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c8961a5778467ec400d5b843b7d3cbef621efd08e74c466e75c0b1e5f01b088e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:884128f817fe7ffd55fbc2e0"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","textSha256":"97dcd36e38169ad8bf5019334f78a16b51e5c360c16c4d2f9b650df7fb7419e2"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:283c0cbac60dbf1ae1f61769c44a3ef7","paperId":"astro-ph/9906066","sourceSha256":"4b77a845583f98eef10b8533315151c563298fd6b9b8a6177e959b9a13576538","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/452208292d42d2c80cfc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f5b728633e8f79f46c010f967637d6ff1c2336702345e89a8d9313728b6eb4a8","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":3497,"textSha256":"22ebc43298b1f49fd375556c9d41bbdbafaac940ccd80cee3ab75f317b3e4257","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3b8acac1cfe4baf461ff5c247a6b3627","paperId":"astro-ph/9906066","sourceSha256":"4b77a845583f98eef10b8533315151c563298fd6b9b8a6177e959b9a13576538","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/452208292d42d2c80cfc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f5b728633e8f79f46c010f967637d6ff1c2336702345e89a8d9313728b6eb4a8","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":3496,"textSha256":"63be0670117255cb5eeb4c049110962db39d68965d3b0ed5993097dcba00cb2d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a89ecd69df4b97b25fadf089a2789eb9","paperId":"astro-ph/9906066","sourceSha256":"4b77a845583f98eef10b8533315151c563298fd6b9b8a6177e959b9a13576538","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/452208292d42d2c80cfc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f5b728633e8f79f46c010f967637d6ff1c2336702345e89a8d9313728b6eb4a8","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c8961a5778467ec400d5b843b7d3cbef621efd08e74c466e75c0b1e5f01b088e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:357401f0f490604dee648bf5"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:357401f0f490604dee648bf5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"],"scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","contributionContentSha256":"58c069554634bfab0e0a63059d24cc72acce6fb3fac0ea0b7357539b93f22485","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","textSha256":"97dcd36e38169ad8bf5019334f78a16b51e5c360c16c4d2f9b650df7fb7419e2"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:283c0cbac60dbf1ae1f61769c44a3ef7","paperId":"astro-ph/9906066","sourceSha256":"4b77a845583f98eef10b8533315151c563298fd6b9b8a6177e959b9a13576538","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/452208292d42d2c80cfc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f5b728633e8f79f46c010f967637d6ff1c2336702345e89a8d9313728b6eb4a8","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":3497,"textSha256":"22ebc43298b1f49fd375556c9d41bbdbafaac940ccd80cee3ab75f317b3e4257","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3b8acac1cfe4baf461ff5c247a6b3627","paperId":"astro-ph/9906066","sourceSha256":"4b77a845583f98eef10b8533315151c563298fd6b9b8a6177e959b9a13576538","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/452208292d42d2c80cfc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f5b728633e8f79f46c010f967637d6ff1c2336702345e89a8d9313728b6eb4a8","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":3496,"textSha256":"63be0670117255cb5eeb4c049110962db39d68965d3b0ed5993097dcba00cb2d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a89ecd69df4b97b25fadf089a2789eb9","paperId":"astro-ph/9906066","sourceSha256":"4b77a845583f98eef10b8533315151c563298fd6b9b8a6177e959b9a13576538","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/452208292d42d2c80cfc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f5b728633e8f79f46c010f967637d6ff1c2336702345e89a8d9313728b6eb4a8","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c8961a5778467ec400d5b843b7d3cbef621efd08e74c466e75c0b1e5f01b088e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:357401f0f490604dee648bf5","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Source-specific induced-gravity and nonminimal examples with 1999 limits; no current fit or general scalar-tensor viability is established.","challengeNote":"The induced-gravity and nonminimal examples use source-dated 1999 constraints and linear perturbations.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:994055d5b3fe54377d838aed0d9e48e88dfb7cfa8f4ff4a928523e89cfda9ef1","home":{"unitId":"unit:994055d5b3fe54377d838aed0d9e48e88dfb7cfa8f4ff4a928523e89cfda9ef1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:994055d5b3fe54377d838aed0d9e48e88dfb7cfa8f4ff4a928523e89cfda9ef1","paperId":"1807.06581","textSha256":"769ee2b2b10092bae60beac3954245b42dfcb7792c821f751e5e78b768d46d9c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:89091afceaccf7eb67562f72"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:89091afceaccf7eb67562f72","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:994055d5b3fe54377d838aed0d9e48e88dfb7cfa8f4ff4a928523e89cfda9ef1","q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","placementContentSha256":"0a32456203c5fb7ee24e2bb5ed549c27bf2e4ac84e6f14fddb8b0edf791f6546","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:994055d5b3fe54377d838aed0d9e48e88dfb7cfa8f4ff4a928523e89cfda9ef1","paperId":"1807.06581","textSha256":"769ee2b2b10092bae60beac3954245b42dfcb7792c821f751e5e78b768d46d9c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:89091afceaccf7eb67562f72"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:994055d5b3fe54377d838aed0d9e48e88dfb7cfa8f4ff4a928523e89cfda9ef1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:994055d5b3fe54377d838aed0d9e48e88dfb7cfa8f4ff4a928523e89cfda9ef1","textSha256":"769ee2b2b10092bae60beac3954245b42dfcb7792c821f751e5e78b768d46d9c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f56999cea1aa01cfe7c62dd5"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f56999cea1aa01cfe7c62dd5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:994055d5b3fe54377d838aed0d9e48e88dfb7cfa8f4ff4a928523e89cfda9ef1","q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"],"scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","contributionContentSha256":"79b13c4cf28ae9492f06bbaba2675abe214c6fc2bbf23356c48486f176b927b6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:994055d5b3fe54377d838aed0d9e48e88dfb7cfa8f4ff4a928523e89cfda9ef1","textSha256":"769ee2b2b10092bae60beac3954245b42dfcb7792c821f751e5e78b768d46d9c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f56999cea1aa01cfe7c62dd5","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","home":{"unitId":"unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","paperId":"1809.00726","textSha256":"03553f340f6bbe16e68e4330b0502b508aa9aa4e6a4c0d00b857ffe4eddffaf0"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1d2cabd6f9b6b73f5ff13674"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1d2cabd6f9b6b73f5ff13674","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","placementContentSha256":"28b61e1d2cc2f26e332a882788c37b6e65ab7eec5964db30688b409338265906","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","paperId":"1809.00726","textSha256":"03553f340f6bbe16e68e4330b0502b508aa9aa4e6a4c0d00b857ffe4eddffaf0"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1d2cabd6f9b6b73f5ff13674"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","textSha256":"03553f340f6bbe16e68e4330b0502b508aa9aa4e6a4c0d00b857ffe4eddffaf0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c927f24c020fc434f0046897"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c927f24c020fc434f0046897","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"],"scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","contributionContentSha256":"f6aa89bbf2a1fcf28d34f8446d439d7f660e6d083f416e258168ca9e9150f7f7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","textSha256":"03553f340f6bbe16e68e4330b0502b508aa9aa4e6a4c0d00b857ffe4eddffaf0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c927f24c020fc434f0046897","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c50ed484b164685b6d82306e5dcdf328f656ab520b17344849d5625e053d5412","home":{"unitId":"unit:c50ed484b164685b6d82306e5dcdf328f656ab520b17344849d5625e053d5412","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c50ed484b164685b6d82306e5dcdf328f656ab520b17344849d5625e053d5412","paperId":"astro-ph/9806099","textSha256":"6c11d6ec875448b9c57dd55e7aeab787b3d0db354e63c068026b2a82bfaf58f2"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:df802388984a6a328e1b80f1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:df802388984a6a328e1b80f1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c50ed484b164685b6d82306e5dcdf328f656ab520b17344849d5625e053d5412","q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","placementContentSha256":"03b371e7fc6de5fb81610ba16268e450945855be57407b762b076ff712eaa882","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c50ed484b164685b6d82306e5dcdf328f656ab520b17344849d5625e053d5412","paperId":"astro-ph/9806099","textSha256":"6c11d6ec875448b9c57dd55e7aeab787b3d0db354e63c068026b2a82bfaf58f2"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:df802388984a6a328e1b80f1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c50ed484b164685b6d82306e5dcdf328f656ab520b17344849d5625e053d5412","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:c50ed484b164685b6d82306e5dcdf328f656ab520b17344849d5625e053d5412","textSha256":"6c11d6ec875448b9c57dd55e7aeab787b3d0db354e63c068026b2a82bfaf58f2"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8ce268d68a36c1b8013be285"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8ce268d68a36c1b8013be285","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c50ed484b164685b6d82306e5dcdf328f656ab520b17344849d5625e053d5412","q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"],"scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","contributionContentSha256":"261da26a471787e7e2f49ee7e88988c1b9a162a65022624369642ac3cb853f47","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:c50ed484b164685b6d82306e5dcdf328f656ab520b17344849d5625e053d5412","textSha256":"6c11d6ec875448b9c57dd55e7aeab787b3d0db354e63c068026b2a82bfaf58f2"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8ce268d68a36c1b8013be285","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d3772e2e30e8f7ce2786ced303ae794af50b581f3d5e01d6cc8d5d61ea5357ec","home":{"unitId":"unit:d3772e2e30e8f7ce2786ced303ae794af50b581f3d5e01d6cc8d5d61ea5357ec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d3772e2e30e8f7ce2786ced303ae794af50b581f3d5e01d6cc8d5d61ea5357ec","paperId":"1812.03184","textSha256":"feba5d64c14b18197ecf0d89bd542628a6d38d1e3209db284cf72b9b7e85c375"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9ca530758dfd1c8504d5f5a8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9ca530758dfd1c8504d5f5a8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d3772e2e30e8f7ce2786ced303ae794af50b581f3d5e01d6cc8d5d61ea5357ec","q025-candidate-region:e85280a1735a9be1ab3520cf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4743fd61ecbe3765eebca56c32915fd2373e025ddd0570ee7b6174fbd57006dd","placementContentSha256":"10da6b242614281ff138d89ba22b56cdd60480be749c18a320386c15ccc66524","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d3772e2e30e8f7ce2786ced303ae794af50b581f3d5e01d6cc8d5d61ea5357ec","paperId":"1812.03184","textSha256":"feba5d64c14b18197ecf0d89bd542628a6d38d1e3209db284cf72b9b7e85c375"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9ca530758dfd1c8504d5f5a8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d3772e2e30e8f7ce2786ced303ae794af50b581f3d5e01d6cc8d5d61ea5357ec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:d3772e2e30e8f7ce2786ced303ae794af50b581f3d5e01d6cc8d5d61ea5357ec","textSha256":"feba5d64c14b18197ecf0d89bd542628a6d38d1e3209db284cf72b9b7e85c375"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2b6612abeaaf7253e280c980"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2b6612abeaaf7253e280c980","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d3772e2e30e8f7ce2786ced303ae794af50b581f3d5e01d6cc8d5d61ea5357ec","q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"],"scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","contributionContentSha256":"f1ddb4910d7a33333b937fa3fdd7de121865aabe4049e0d1567f530fadf89aa1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:d3772e2e30e8f7ce2786ced303ae794af50b581f3d5e01d6cc8d5d61ea5357ec","textSha256":"feba5d64c14b18197ecf0d89bd542628a6d38d1e3209db284cf72b9b7e85c375"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2b6612abeaaf7253e280c980","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":13,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a235471a732b19d8514cd57b8021c7985c5c06eef8dc598a46675f6aecf06d73"},"organizational-access:4011f5bf4d951234afadfd96":{"id":"organizational-access:4011f5bf4d951234afadfd96","source":"q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51","target":"q025-candidate-question:9e41a3868dcdcfebf87974e3","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"d3f7138201941f5392c7965425260297e0654776f08734a7cde28d7a1fd2932f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c40213cb2b4fefffa2b110aa"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9e41a3868dcdcfebf87974e3","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"076583202ef684ad98efa9949aca93770015dec3004e82ade5a5997ddfe6c6a9","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:fc1a6f8d7f5c0ae1b6605ee0"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","home":{"unitId":"unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","paperId":"1503.01777","textSha256":"9e021bdd648713fb2fa0a4b55e77046339db8b3628bfb28329197c56497790cc"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:87c3cf66a375bb88d76f4343fdce5465","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":3496,"textSha256":"727915ee0c75964e3c2018d3269cfc570990d960b7d5ab5085632adb7ca60fb4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8f0ab88755d530002a4d3f89345faae4","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":808,"textSha256":"37baa3889a0a78889b15128b8dc6188062647e465ac779619a8e5ff4b3c8a28d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f8f9460420d4f6c78cde718d3889f09d","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":2,"start":1297,"end":3552,"textSha256":"62e96d09930abfebde28085df00b9afac6a6518fa271b81f16832cb20cbdfec0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1ca5c37f0066d612426ef43b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1ca5c37f0066d612426ef43b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51"],"scopeContentSha256":"d3f7138201941f5392c7965425260297e0654776f08734a7cde28d7a1fd2932f","placementContentSha256":"3cd4b51837c371ec0efa7719d916f1fe26aad9baa0a44722711b904365772456","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","paperId":"1503.01777","textSha256":"9e021bdd648713fb2fa0a4b55e77046339db8b3628bfb28329197c56497790cc"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:87c3cf66a375bb88d76f4343fdce5465","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":3496,"textSha256":"727915ee0c75964e3c2018d3269cfc570990d960b7d5ab5085632adb7ca60fb4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8f0ab88755d530002a4d3f89345faae4","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":808,"textSha256":"37baa3889a0a78889b15128b8dc6188062647e465ac779619a8e5ff4b3c8a28d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f8f9460420d4f6c78cde718d3889f09d","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":2,"start":1297,"end":3552,"textSha256":"62e96d09930abfebde28085df00b9afac6a6518fa271b81f16832cb20cbdfec0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1ca5c37f0066d612426ef43b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9e41a3868dcdcfebf87974e3","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","textSha256":"9e021bdd648713fb2fa0a4b55e77046339db8b3628bfb28329197c56497790cc"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:44d542a960567a34aa867916","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Low-scale and unbroken supersymmetry are alternatives, not simultaneous assumptions. Independent challenge qualification: Low-scale and unbroken supersymmetry are alternatives."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:44d542a960567a34aa867916","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","q025-candidate-question:9e41a3868dcdcfebf87974e3"],"scopeContentSha256":"076583202ef684ad98efa9949aca93770015dec3004e82ade5a5997ddfe6c6a9","contributionContentSha256":"42dba7fbfada3fd18251743f38447dd046d3d33d2f718756aba45b9d3defc77b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","textSha256":"9e021bdd648713fb2fa0a4b55e77046339db8b3628bfb28329197c56497790cc"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:44d542a960567a34aa867916","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Low-scale and unbroken supersymmetry are alternatives, not simultaneous assumptions.","challengeNote":"Low-scale and unbroken supersymmetry are alternatives.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"05699d6c7b6de38fde26861f521241a1013af276862346869a04cfb9aba858fa"},"organizational-access:3377864a97f0bd0aad0013e1":{"id":"organizational-access:3377864a97f0bd0aad0013e1","source":"q025-candidate-region:efd12be51c621b776d6028c4","target":"q025-candidate-question:a06b2f19781bb5c750f7874e","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:efd12be51c621b776d6028c4","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"630467a965fff208acd347fa8316a86d5653e7563ec5d4d3976d73b541adac0a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e57abebbcf1b36c8880ff1e2"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a06b2f19781bb5c750f7874e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c29d1a099f56e6cbdf754053770c4ca678a5876edbf1d4ac45ef9506fa8fee7e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:9f986dec2ce8dd39171ee941"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4c519dd015048e761815c264132bbdad0ed2560ce21e7031dd8e708f2e12cf87","home":{"unitId":"unit:4c519dd015048e761815c264132bbdad0ed2560ce21e7031dd8e708f2e12cf87","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:efd12be51c621b776d6028c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4c519dd015048e761815c264132bbdad0ed2560ce21e7031dd8e708f2e12cf87","paperId":"1011.0714","textSha256":"f6237b92db1923ad2fd90053a755cf3cb04de013cfacbb5aeb76d9aa58ac2279"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2d31e8a097bf01ef61b4e67c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2d31e8a097bf01ef61b4e67c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4c519dd015048e761815c264132bbdad0ed2560ce21e7031dd8e708f2e12cf87","q025-candidate-region:efd12be51c621b776d6028c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"630467a965fff208acd347fa8316a86d5653e7563ec5d4d3976d73b541adac0a","placementContentSha256":"851120514682708ff4bdc5f8788044f09c62c1c829d6a877e0378b6017bd584d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge","leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4c519dd015048e761815c264132bbdad0ed2560ce21e7031dd8e708f2e12cf87","paperId":"1011.0714","textSha256":"f6237b92db1923ad2fd90053a755cf3cb04de013cfacbb5aeb76d9aa58ac2279"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2d31e8a097bf01ef61b4e67c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4c519dd015048e761815c264132bbdad0ed2560ce21e7031dd8e708f2e12cf87","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a06b2f19781bb5c750f7874e","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:4c519dd015048e761815c264132bbdad0ed2560ce21e7031dd8e708f2e12cf87","textSha256":"f6237b92db1923ad2fd90053a755cf3cb04de013cfacbb5aeb76d9aa58ac2279"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9416f617778fa1bcd4bea75a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9416f617778fa1bcd4bea75a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4c519dd015048e761815c264132bbdad0ed2560ce21e7031dd8e708f2e12cf87","q025-candidate-question:a06b2f19781bb5c750f7874e"],"scopeContentSha256":"c29d1a099f56e6cbdf754053770c4ca678a5876edbf1d4ac45ef9506fa8fee7e","contributionContentSha256":"074e1f81bfede913ef3264d7721449578fdfd75b3e963e85eded8d0b805b5c20","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-proposal","leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:4c519dd015048e761815c264132bbdad0ed2560ce21e7031dd8e708f2e12cf87","textSha256":"f6237b92db1923ad2fd90053a755cf3cb04de013cfacbb5aeb76d9aa58ac2279"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9416f617778fa1bcd4bea75a","recordId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Links coincidence and landscape abundance without requiring galaxies or entropy production.","challengeNote":"Compound coincidence and abundance question; galaxies and entropy production are not required inputs.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:6f79e477740be9dd5032e8fb1c81ffacc7a4818b04a34ff78ecfff377b29aaf2","home":{"unitId":"unit:6f79e477740be9dd5032e8fb1c81ffacc7a4818b04a34ff78ecfff377b29aaf2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:efd12be51c621b776d6028c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6f79e477740be9dd5032e8fb1c81ffacc7a4818b04a34ff78ecfff377b29aaf2","paperId":"1611.05786","textSha256":"01ea5eac89c1cffcb7987164f75b89dd13e26b3da5c884b6ba455b7789dfde91"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b595b63c77435ded0fc84b11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b595b63c77435ded0fc84b11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6f79e477740be9dd5032e8fb1c81ffacc7a4818b04a34ff78ecfff377b29aaf2","q025-candidate-region:efd12be51c621b776d6028c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"630467a965fff208acd347fa8316a86d5653e7563ec5d4d3976d73b541adac0a","placementContentSha256":"a84a203a9b595f6ecc3322aeffe34193d496f93bcd93e01172114c4902b64f4e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge","leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6f79e477740be9dd5032e8fb1c81ffacc7a4818b04a34ff78ecfff377b29aaf2","paperId":"1611.05786","textSha256":"01ea5eac89c1cffcb7987164f75b89dd13e26b3da5c884b6ba455b7789dfde91"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b595b63c77435ded0fc84b11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:6f79e477740be9dd5032e8fb1c81ffacc7a4818b04a34ff78ecfff377b29aaf2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a06b2f19781bb5c750f7874e","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:6f79e477740be9dd5032e8fb1c81ffacc7a4818b04a34ff78ecfff377b29aaf2","textSha256":"01ea5eac89c1cffcb7987164f75b89dd13e26b3da5c884b6ba455b7789dfde91"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f7f3868db84fb6cc50e2acde"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f7f3868db84fb6cc50e2acde","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6f79e477740be9dd5032e8fb1c81ffacc7a4818b04a34ff78ecfff377b29aaf2","q025-candidate-question:a06b2f19781bb5c750f7874e"],"scopeContentSha256":"c29d1a099f56e6cbdf754053770c4ca678a5876edbf1d4ac45ef9506fa8fee7e","contributionContentSha256":"6f66ab304f53ba66b948116d91d172d7fd10c542ece2277117a146e44c32ae14","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-proposal","leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:6f79e477740be9dd5032e8fb1c81ffacc7a4818b04a34ff78ecfff377b29aaf2","textSha256":"01ea5eac89c1cffcb7987164f75b89dd13e26b3da5c884b6ba455b7789dfde91"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f7f3868db84fb6cc50e2acde","recordId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: vacuum statistics, light scalars and axions, and correction robustness. Equivalence with the more specified flux question is not established.","challengeNote":"Compound statistical, spectrum and quantum-correction targets. The precise ensemble assumptions needed for equivalence with the flux example are not supplied.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:e9565294d7467881d9601593b14b1342242a5da0824fbe1e9efea704494911f5","home":{"unitId":"unit:e9565294d7467881d9601593b14b1342242a5da0824fbe1e9efea704494911f5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:efd12be51c621b776d6028c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e9565294d7467881d9601593b14b1342242a5da0824fbe1e9efea704494911f5","paperId":"1801.09173","textSha256":"2da36a0e45c068f43eb467e62492701a84aeef2cacff90ef1612e22cc52d40d0"},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b2391ca75361d0ffc375919f959197c1","paperId":"1801.09173","sourceSha256":"485461ef312c0bf4aeb32bbe9c28e3c110acb45a17ae2316c7a47bcf864103b1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525c95d8badf3c9d630a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a99b4671bb71ad4fcdbf6e0162431af9e1dbfb3d9420e1ce02e71ddcaff6532c","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1477,"textSha256":"a937aec53a16a6582e325bf1ba485d4b87f465885d275393f3a786d25028a5c5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:35676efd2d54c727e48d2a987186f6c4","paperId":"1801.09173","sourceSha256":"485461ef312c0bf4aeb32bbe9c28e3c110acb45a17ae2316c7a47bcf864103b1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525c95d8badf3c9d630a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a99b4671bb71ad4fcdbf6e0162431af9e1dbfb3d9420e1ce02e71ddcaff6532c","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2941,"textSha256":"f3df2cbc66217177c71f01e0a57d66775be92f1968a0bd0de3e17dd9f946668d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1316d6941c2ec22e6b44f51be62e3aec","paperId":"1801.09173","sourceSha256":"485461ef312c0bf4aeb32bbe9c28e3c110acb45a17ae2316c7a47bcf864103b1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525c95d8badf3c9d630a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a99b4671bb71ad4fcdbf6e0162431af9e1dbfb3d9420e1ce02e71ddcaff6532c","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":2689,"textSha256":"6e4cf726fbca18b92e38546b807116860808c4e5816ec320368c840ebd6b1c5b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b37c2ca62083f3f3438391f4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b37c2ca62083f3f3438391f4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e9565294d7467881d9601593b14b1342242a5da0824fbe1e9efea704494911f5","q025-candidate-region:efd12be51c621b776d6028c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"630467a965fff208acd347fa8316a86d5653e7563ec5d4d3976d73b541adac0a","placementContentSha256":"7f884a2586897d1b0806a4c36bebe88e90750d9692373c39a118b8bdff80ad86","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge","leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e9565294d7467881d9601593b14b1342242a5da0824fbe1e9efea704494911f5","paperId":"1801.09173","textSha256":"2da36a0e45c068f43eb467e62492701a84aeef2cacff90ef1612e22cc52d40d0"},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b2391ca75361d0ffc375919f959197c1","paperId":"1801.09173","sourceSha256":"485461ef312c0bf4aeb32bbe9c28e3c110acb45a17ae2316c7a47bcf864103b1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525c95d8badf3c9d630a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a99b4671bb71ad4fcdbf6e0162431af9e1dbfb3d9420e1ce02e71ddcaff6532c","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1477,"textSha256":"a937aec53a16a6582e325bf1ba485d4b87f465885d275393f3a786d25028a5c5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:35676efd2d54c727e48d2a987186f6c4","paperId":"1801.09173","sourceSha256":"485461ef312c0bf4aeb32bbe9c28e3c110acb45a17ae2316c7a47bcf864103b1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525c95d8badf3c9d630a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a99b4671bb71ad4fcdbf6e0162431af9e1dbfb3d9420e1ce02e71ddcaff6532c","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2941,"textSha256":"f3df2cbc66217177c71f01e0a57d66775be92f1968a0bd0de3e17dd9f946668d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1316d6941c2ec22e6b44f51be62e3aec","paperId":"1801.09173","sourceSha256":"485461ef312c0bf4aeb32bbe9c28e3c110acb45a17ae2316c7a47bcf864103b1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525c95d8badf3c9d630a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a99b4671bb71ad4fcdbf6e0162431af9e1dbfb3d9420e1ce02e71ddcaff6532c","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":2689,"textSha256":"6e4cf726fbca18b92e38546b807116860808c4e5816ec320368c840ebd6b1c5b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b37c2ca62083f3f3438391f4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e9565294d7467881d9601593b14b1342242a5da0824fbe1e9efea704494911f5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a06b2f19781bb5c750f7874e","role":"instantiates","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:e9565294d7467881d9601593b14b1342242a5da0824fbe1e9efea704494911f5","textSha256":"2da36a0e45c068f43eb467e62492701a84aeef2cacff90ef1612e22cc52d40d0"},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b2391ca75361d0ffc375919f959197c1","paperId":"1801.09173","sourceSha256":"485461ef312c0bf4aeb32bbe9c28e3c110acb45a17ae2316c7a47bcf864103b1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525c95d8badf3c9d630a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a99b4671bb71ad4fcdbf6e0162431af9e1dbfb3d9420e1ce02e71ddcaff6532c","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1477,"textSha256":"a937aec53a16a6582e325bf1ba485d4b87f465885d275393f3a786d25028a5c5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:35676efd2d54c727e48d2a987186f6c4","paperId":"1801.09173","sourceSha256":"485461ef312c0bf4aeb32bbe9c28e3c110acb45a17ae2316c7a47bcf864103b1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525c95d8badf3c9d630a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a99b4671bb71ad4fcdbf6e0162431af9e1dbfb3d9420e1ce02e71ddcaff6532c","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2941,"textSha256":"f3df2cbc66217177c71f01e0a57d66775be92f1968a0bd0de3e17dd9f946668d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1316d6941c2ec22e6b44f51be62e3aec","paperId":"1801.09173","sourceSha256":"485461ef312c0bf4aeb32bbe9c28e3c110acb45a17ae2316c7a47bcf864103b1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525c95d8badf3c9d630a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a99b4671bb71ad4fcdbf6e0162431af9e1dbfb3d9420e1ce02e71ddcaff6532c","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":2689,"textSha256":"6e4cf726fbca18b92e38546b807116860808c4e5816ec320368c840ebd6b1c5b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0a8676c8555ae737470e8604"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0a8676c8555ae737470e8604","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e9565294d7467881d9601593b14b1342242a5da0824fbe1e9efea704494911f5","q025-candidate-question:a06b2f19781bb5c750f7874e"],"scopeContentSha256":"c29d1a099f56e6cbdf754053770c4ca678a5876edbf1d4ac45ef9506fa8fee7e","contributionContentSha256":"387c3d8c3c2866f187e211170acb92a1108a23730afea7c343a8cdc2be12540b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-proposal","leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:e9565294d7467881d9601593b14b1342242a5da0824fbe1e9efea704494911f5","textSha256":"2da36a0e45c068f43eb467e62492701a84aeef2cacff90ef1612e22cc52d40d0"},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b2391ca75361d0ffc375919f959197c1","paperId":"1801.09173","sourceSha256":"485461ef312c0bf4aeb32bbe9c28e3c110acb45a17ae2316c7a47bcf864103b1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525c95d8badf3c9d630a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a99b4671bb71ad4fcdbf6e0162431af9e1dbfb3d9420e1ce02e71ddcaff6532c","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1477,"textSha256":"a937aec53a16a6582e325bf1ba485d4b87f465885d275393f3a786d25028a5c5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:35676efd2d54c727e48d2a987186f6c4","paperId":"1801.09173","sourceSha256":"485461ef312c0bf4aeb32bbe9c28e3c110acb45a17ae2316c7a47bcf864103b1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525c95d8badf3c9d630a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a99b4671bb71ad4fcdbf6e0162431af9e1dbfb3d9420e1ce02e71ddcaff6532c","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2941,"textSha256":"f3df2cbc66217177c71f01e0a57d66775be92f1968a0bd0de3e17dd9f946668d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1316d6941c2ec22e6b44f51be62e3aec","paperId":"1801.09173","sourceSha256":"485461ef312c0bf4aeb32bbe9c28e3c110acb45a17ae2316c7a47bcf864103b1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/525c95d8badf3c9d630a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a99b4671bb71ad4fcdbf6e0162431af9e1dbfb3d9420e1ce02e71ddcaff6532c","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":2689,"textSha256":"6e4cf726fbca18b92e38546b807116860808c4e5816ec320368c840ebd6b1c5b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0a8676c8555ae737470e8604","recordId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-70849169a294e1fa570e-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound: small-energy statistics, loop robustness and light scalars. Toy-model distributional stability does not imply radiative stability at fixed flux.","challengeNote":"Compound statistics, spectrum and loop-robustness targets. The 2018 update reports toy-ensemble robustness through two loops while explicitly allowinginstabili","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"482cb907dfce498d37804892f188c5c09e5d3c116287cb2814f31757328afa78"},"organizational-access:210c6e4cf54e0bdd61b871f9":{"id":"organizational-access:210c6e4cf54e0bdd61b871f9","source":"q025-candidate-region:f0fdba4b7128fdb0c274514c","target":"q025-candidate-question:bf04ac96919ec94426f0da31","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:f0fdba4b7128fdb0c274514c","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"725ad5d997515d79325722dd63d090a516dbad1820e1b7223ea67a44778aa29e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ed541fae51b168d2a5e96d4a"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:bf04ac96919ec94426f0da31","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"cef703cdeb14f9ac67ad4d0de03a8d8415b6d3d6fe7a7594e8c3272127cfb385","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3d8db92e091c6ce35f6066a0"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:41214a545a81a191b636493fe52812bac54313a4910374ffce82899bd05f591f","home":{"unitId":"unit:41214a545a81a191b636493fe52812bac54313a4910374ffce82899bd05f591f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f0fdba4b7128fdb0c274514c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:41214a545a81a191b636493fe52812bac54313a4910374ffce82899bd05f591f","paperId":"hep-th/0505160","textSha256":"2bd838c06ad1a3c80278852b3bdcb09c4cebb0a13ece4d045ef3086288de7e8a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:479b71b2b0bbd730978db348"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:479b71b2b0bbd730978db348","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:41214a545a81a191b636493fe52812bac54313a4910374ffce82899bd05f591f","q025-candidate-region:f0fdba4b7128fdb0c274514c"],"scopeContentSha256":"725ad5d997515d79325722dd63d090a516dbad1820e1b7223ea67a44778aa29e","placementContentSha256":"f890bfe35b93edbeb02ab1a1022fc3096dea3a7f83592fe3eff2aa65fa77ee61","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c3339e1f151b5c739eb5-challenge","leaf-c3339e1f151b5c739eb5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:41214a545a81a191b636493fe52812bac54313a4910374ffce82899bd05f591f","paperId":"hep-th/0505160","textSha256":"2bd838c06ad1a3c80278852b3bdcb09c4cebb0a13ece4d045ef3086288de7e8a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:479b71b2b0bbd730978db348"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:41214a545a81a191b636493fe52812bac54313a4910374ffce82899bd05f591f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:bf04ac96919ec94426f0da31","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:41214a545a81a191b636493fe52812bac54313a4910374ffce82899bd05f591f","textSha256":"2bd838c06ad1a3c80278852b3bdcb09c4cebb0a13ece4d045ef3086288de7e8a"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3c5ef6e64762512e50405b22cbc08d10","paperId":"hep-th/0505160","sourceSha256":"bc52518315fa0cc1cb62469b564bed95a6c365fac00cd9db48974a93ee6f286f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/07e9f01f15afdbb3c8bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"11801d879c43566ac21991e3a6d1051db7bd5e45752b735343754cfcb6f61415","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2822,"textSha256":"2bbcc74a5aaad1f8d408fa8a10c53c88c202c4fc30a49d31a60d2aa951cae5a3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9fa689b26cc30f94442295f854934c8b","paperId":"hep-th/0505160","sourceSha256":"bc52518315fa0cc1cb62469b564bed95a6c365fac00cd9db48974a93ee6f286f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/07e9f01f15afdbb3c8bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"11801d879c43566ac21991e3a6d1051db7bd5e45752b735343754cfcb6f61415","pdfPage":3,"start":1286,"end":3016,"textSha256":"8dc397be443d3b1117e6b104e2a9b60f1691b02bcceb63326fe2cc0b95c672a5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fb46cd51b9c0e4af6601dec6a994d532","paperId":"hep-th/0505160","sourceSha256":"bc52518315fa0cc1cb62469b564bed95a6c365fac00cd9db48974a93ee6f286f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/07e9f01f15afdbb3c8bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"11801d879c43566ac21991e3a6d1051db7bd5e45752b735343754cfcb6f61415","pdfPage":3,"start":95,"end":3016,"textSha256":"320b9665d2ef0120941255f5e55802e8629d004ee96cdaf40c507cfdc75c4378","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:63348db150197245405ccd8e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:63348db150197245405ccd8e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:41214a545a81a191b636493fe52812bac54313a4910374ffce82899bd05f591f","q025-candidate-question:bf04ac96919ec94426f0da31"],"scopeContentSha256":"cef703cdeb14f9ac67ad4d0de03a8d8415b6d3d6fe7a7594e8c3272127cfb385","contributionContentSha256":"07b8da79bd92137b0f6024625db5e94fc0836c1993f724728c4262adc96a076c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:41214a545a81a191b636493fe52812bac54313a4910374ffce82899bd05f591f","textSha256":"2bd838c06ad1a3c80278852b3bdcb09c4cebb0a13ece4d045ef3086288de7e8a"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3c5ef6e64762512e50405b22cbc08d10","paperId":"hep-th/0505160","sourceSha256":"bc52518315fa0cc1cb62469b564bed95a6c365fac00cd9db48974a93ee6f286f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/07e9f01f15afdbb3c8bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"11801d879c43566ac21991e3a6d1051db7bd5e45752b735343754cfcb6f61415","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2822,"textSha256":"2bbcc74a5aaad1f8d408fa8a10c53c88c202c4fc30a49d31a60d2aa951cae5a3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9fa689b26cc30f94442295f854934c8b","paperId":"hep-th/0505160","sourceSha256":"bc52518315fa0cc1cb62469b564bed95a6c365fac00cd9db48974a93ee6f286f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/07e9f01f15afdbb3c8bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"11801d879c43566ac21991e3a6d1051db7bd5e45752b735343754cfcb6f61415","pdfPage":3,"start":1286,"end":3016,"textSha256":"8dc397be443d3b1117e6b104e2a9b60f1691b02bcceb63326fe2cc0b95c672a5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fb46cd51b9c0e4af6601dec6a994d532","paperId":"hep-th/0505160","sourceSha256":"bc52518315fa0cc1cb62469b564bed95a6c365fac00cd9db48974a93ee6f286f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/07e9f01f15afdbb3c8bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"11801d879c43566ac21991e3a6d1051db7bd5e45752b735343754cfcb6f61415","pdfPage":3,"start":95,"end":3016,"textSha256":"320b9665d2ef0120941255f5e55802e8629d004ee96cdaf40c507cfdc75c4378","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:63348db150197245405ccd8e","recordId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Directly useful classical stabilization/control comparison; supplied excerpts do not establish positive vacuum energy.","challengeNote":"Source-reported parametric stabilization does not establish positive vacuum energy. The compound stabilization/control target remains a source-scoped singleton","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"17a0b634613d1e7f3a66c99f0322985de68422edba4d0f16549f6d628730f4b8"},"organizational-access:a21e675057ef19b27601f801":{"id":"organizational-access:a21e675057ef19b27601f801","source":"q025-candidate-region:f3e29a3e470894cf13cebe86","target":"q025-candidate-question:f0194c1ae166dcb82da0a36c","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:f3e29a3e470894cf13cebe86","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"c8a171d61bef3f5fbbf16432a9d490164a7c3ab94102bfc204b327860d75b25d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3456db236f2841b30a7176ce"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f0194c1ae166dcb82da0a36c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"897066c5a268c07da1de571c5e2a0a9de192f9e8ec524f3533cf9f87446c1cac","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d09afb7475a800f4c6f049af"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:a0e1121d1cb8d53bd561b63aba562c525ae2d93a0576d59dbad1842e5f222542","home":{"unitId":"unit:a0e1121d1cb8d53bd561b63aba562c525ae2d93a0576d59dbad1842e5f222542","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f3e29a3e470894cf13cebe86","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a0e1121d1cb8d53bd561b63aba562c525ae2d93a0576d59dbad1842e5f222542","paperId":"1910.01135","textSha256":"647d6eaf762fc635b8a50cf05caaef5da00b485c69157362131097f68fbc3f82"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:292ae2f8f1886d9467099602"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:292ae2f8f1886d9467099602","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a0e1121d1cb8d53bd561b63aba562c525ae2d93a0576d59dbad1842e5f222542","q025-candidate-region:f3e29a3e470894cf13cebe86"],"scopeContentSha256":"c8a171d61bef3f5fbbf16432a9d490164a7c3ab94102bfc204b327860d75b25d","placementContentSha256":"3efb82a8a9177c12e36f15452bb2178034d4a24ecc770b935712ac4cabc11948","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge","leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a0e1121d1cb8d53bd561b63aba562c525ae2d93a0576d59dbad1842e5f222542","paperId":"1910.01135","textSha256":"647d6eaf762fc635b8a50cf05caaef5da00b485c69157362131097f68fbc3f82"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:292ae2f8f1886d9467099602"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a0e1121d1cb8d53bd561b63aba562c525ae2d93a0576d59dbad1842e5f222542","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f0194c1ae166dcb82da0a36c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:a0e1121d1cb8d53bd561b63aba562c525ae2d93a0576d59dbad1842e5f222542","textSha256":"647d6eaf762fc635b8a50cf05caaef5da00b485c69157362131097f68fbc3f82"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e92b315bab732cf8b3df7945"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e92b315bab732cf8b3df7945","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a0e1121d1cb8d53bd561b63aba562c525ae2d93a0576d59dbad1842e5f222542","q025-candidate-question:f0194c1ae166dcb82da0a36c"],"scopeContentSha256":"897066c5a268c07da1de571c5e2a0a9de192f9e8ec524f3533cf9f87446c1cac","contributionContentSha256":"3a2a576886a3581f30f1a5e28eeeb7ddddf5c38362c26585533d26b1052d3274","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-proposal","leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:a0e1121d1cb8d53bd561b63aba562c525ae2d93a0576d59dbad1842e5f222542","textSha256":"647d6eaf762fc635b8a50cf05caaef5da00b485c69157362131097f68fbc3f82"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e92b315bab732cf8b3df7945","recordId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Volume growth, decompactification and Planck-scale finiteness remain path-dependent questions, not equivalent criteria.","challengeNote":"Volume growth, decompactification and finite Planck scale remain distinct, coupling-path-dependent targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b6268f0ad9fa3eab90c96e2ce773402a2256c76c9cc820cb6327a66b96f37ed9","home":{"unitId":"unit:b6268f0ad9fa3eab90c96e2ce773402a2256c76c9cc820cb6327a66b96f37ed9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f3e29a3e470894cf13cebe86","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b6268f0ad9fa3eab90c96e2ce773402a2256c76c9cc820cb6327a66b96f37ed9","paperId":"2603.11163","textSha256":"9fda6c0334b642ef6b821c242c873b22d57242953497d008ce1c122e27f8bda8"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:299855712f3c2dde7b0533b0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:299855712f3c2dde7b0533b0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b6268f0ad9fa3eab90c96e2ce773402a2256c76c9cc820cb6327a66b96f37ed9","q025-candidate-region:f3e29a3e470894cf13cebe86"],"scopeContentSha256":"c8a171d61bef3f5fbbf16432a9d490164a7c3ab94102bfc204b327860d75b25d","placementContentSha256":"971be221a0ff8741355057f89031286addd684a515d6347847c3b0898e9efa09","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge","leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b6268f0ad9fa3eab90c96e2ce773402a2256c76c9cc820cb6327a66b96f37ed9","paperId":"2603.11163","textSha256":"9fda6c0334b642ef6b821c242c873b22d57242953497d008ce1c122e27f8bda8"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:299855712f3c2dde7b0533b0"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b6268f0ad9fa3eab90c96e2ce773402a2256c76c9cc820cb6327a66b96f37ed9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f0194c1ae166dcb82da0a36c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:b6268f0ad9fa3eab90c96e2ce773402a2256c76c9cc820cb6327a66b96f37ed9","textSha256":"9fda6c0334b642ef6b821c242c873b22d57242953497d008ce1c122e27f8bda8"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5d0bef114350283b25468d83"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5d0bef114350283b25468d83","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b6268f0ad9fa3eab90c96e2ce773402a2256c76c9cc820cb6327a66b96f37ed9","q025-candidate-question:f0194c1ae166dcb82da0a36c"],"scopeContentSha256":"897066c5a268c07da1de571c5e2a0a9de192f9e8ec524f3533cf9f87446c1cac","contributionContentSha256":"b4fe3c97985d4a500623caaa8e09d45e2197199e4b8aa8b28f2f171a74f757fb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-proposal","leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:b6268f0ad9fa3eab90c96e2ce773402a2256c76c9cc820cb6327a66b96f37ed9","textSha256":"9fda6c0334b642ef6b821c242c873b22d57242953497d008ce1c122e27f8bda8"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5d0bef114350283b25468d83","recordId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fbb34bbe2dcb2a8c4f2a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"2e1935f1a8791d471837108811773088599f11f25b9702eeb56dfaa40522b8d9"},"organizational-access:70246ac47f0ea7e57d2469d2":{"id":"organizational-access:70246ac47f0ea7e57d2469d2","source":"q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416","target":"q025-candidate-question:5d6c3ed04509afa5f769c4f0","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"605d6588e09eaa96a4eab90dfd66b189ae0a890234a707553cef72b35bed8d36","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:4fa8cc768c5e6cabccf10441"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:5d6c3ed04509afa5f769c4f0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"17d8e9e4a522f34c8d0420c38ff4465085fe551ed3ea525d582a37ee2cc7dced","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:451149d648246daa9c7b567d"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:2e4719bdc75eb93ec51c1b2ebfe719192095a9a3d7737af68f34ccf8d19a495b","home":{"unitId":"unit:2e4719bdc75eb93ec51c1b2ebfe719192095a9a3d7737af68f34ccf8d19a495b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2e4719bdc75eb93ec51c1b2ebfe719192095a9a3d7737af68f34ccf8d19a495b","paperId":"2108.12564","textSha256":"73edeaaace534b6e8425dc513937427a73100ed2f79c6c6607413922f0776594"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:16dbfc477a025269e02934e3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:16dbfc477a025269e02934e3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2e4719bdc75eb93ec51c1b2ebfe719192095a9a3d7737af68f34ccf8d19a495b","q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416"],"scopeContentSha256":"605d6588e09eaa96a4eab90dfd66b189ae0a890234a707553cef72b35bed8d36","placementContentSha256":"e7075c2f4b5cc2f59a911d8fbdf552ef358ed3fb4f6d41c29b6e4e90b470b50d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge","leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2e4719bdc75eb93ec51c1b2ebfe719192095a9a3d7737af68f34ccf8d19a495b","paperId":"2108.12564","textSha256":"73edeaaace534b6e8425dc513937427a73100ed2f79c6c6607413922f0776594"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:16dbfc477a025269e02934e3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2e4719bdc75eb93ec51c1b2ebfe719192095a9a3d7737af68f34ccf8d19a495b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:5d6c3ed04509afa5f769c4f0","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:2e4719bdc75eb93ec51c1b2ebfe719192095a9a3d7737af68f34ccf8d19a495b","textSha256":"73edeaaace534b6e8425dc513937427a73100ed2f79c6c6607413922f0776594"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:16c5c8a966d174fa21938311"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:16c5c8a966d174fa21938311","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2e4719bdc75eb93ec51c1b2ebfe719192095a9a3d7737af68f34ccf8d19a495b","q025-candidate-question:5d6c3ed04509afa5f769c4f0"],"scopeContentSha256":"17d8e9e4a522f34c8d0420c38ff4465085fe551ed3ea525d582a37ee2cc7dced","contributionContentSha256":"24180198c489c62deadeb95a0a460226e12a12f631033c853da3c1608a7c9e87","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:2e4719bdc75eb93ec51c1b2ebfe719192095a9a3d7737af68f34ccf8d19a495b","textSha256":"73edeaaace534b6e8425dc513937427a73100ed2f79c6c6607413922f0776594"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:16c5c8a966d174fa21938311","recordId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:69c76d156cb620563e0bcda4c4219b65b68b63f4c351d8ec77d3ccdab52bfac6","home":{"unitId":"unit:69c76d156cb620563e0bcda4c4219b65b68b63f4c351d8ec77d3ccdab52bfac6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:69c76d156cb620563e0bcda4c4219b65b68b63f4c351d8ec77d3ccdab52bfac6","paperId":"1306.3695","textSha256":"6d6139e3e9c43451a50514095151991d6034be16906d02cb31f2dc70f0f8f873"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:265851cbe3c6a49c3b375f61"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:265851cbe3c6a49c3b375f61","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:69c76d156cb620563e0bcda4c4219b65b68b63f4c351d8ec77d3ccdab52bfac6","q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416"],"scopeContentSha256":"605d6588e09eaa96a4eab90dfd66b189ae0a890234a707553cef72b35bed8d36","placementContentSha256":"829f6df30177d415d8135bb2b647704980dd4021dec942aa3d0b51f9236bcd7f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge","leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:69c76d156cb620563e0bcda4c4219b65b68b63f4c351d8ec77d3ccdab52bfac6","paperId":"1306.3695","textSha256":"6d6139e3e9c43451a50514095151991d6034be16906d02cb31f2dc70f0f8f873"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:265851cbe3c6a49c3b375f61"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:69c76d156cb620563e0bcda4c4219b65b68b63f4c351d8ec77d3ccdab52bfac6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:5d6c3ed04509afa5f769c4f0","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:69c76d156cb620563e0bcda4c4219b65b68b63f4c351d8ec77d3ccdab52bfac6","textSha256":"6d6139e3e9c43451a50514095151991d6034be16906d02cb31f2dc70f0f8f873"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:475310336cfc72f92ed367a8"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:475310336cfc72f92ed367a8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:69c76d156cb620563e0bcda4c4219b65b68b63f4c351d8ec77d3ccdab52bfac6","q025-candidate-question:5d6c3ed04509afa5f769c4f0"],"scopeContentSha256":"17d8e9e4a522f34c8d0420c38ff4465085fe551ed3ea525d582a37ee2cc7dced","contributionContentSha256":"18724a3295901e9411775599ad2328b72a7c09b9cfeaf65e820e5f13eaeea140","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:69c76d156cb620563e0bcda4c4219b65b68b63f4c351d8ec77d3ccdab52bfac6","textSha256":"6d6139e3e9c43451a50514095151991d6034be16906d02cb31f2dc70f0f8f873"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:475310336cfc72f92ed367a8","recordId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Retains the anomalous surface versus strictly 2D SPT comparison.","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c91922a035d9ed07298c05bd9e149c40fe9bbf7158de6e6ddc7cb1eed3a9a1fd","home":{"unitId":"unit:c91922a035d9ed07298c05bd9e149c40fe9bbf7158de6e6ddc7cb1eed3a9a1fd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c91922a035d9ed07298c05bd9e149c40fe9bbf7158de6e6ddc7cb1eed3a9a1fd","paperId":"hep-th/0505235","textSha256":"90334b72c769e89a087d29190b87261c814687f885f69e98fb827e647aa220b5"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6e4d1ae4617237d24d640a27"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6e4d1ae4617237d24d640a27","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c91922a035d9ed07298c05bd9e149c40fe9bbf7158de6e6ddc7cb1eed3a9a1fd","q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416"],"scopeContentSha256":"605d6588e09eaa96a4eab90dfd66b189ae0a890234a707553cef72b35bed8d36","placementContentSha256":"6f22005739676139f8573e9931e618d372d923f3dd726f07b4b0a0b405f6f6ca","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge","leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c91922a035d9ed07298c05bd9e149c40fe9bbf7158de6e6ddc7cb1eed3a9a1fd","paperId":"hep-th/0505235","textSha256":"90334b72c769e89a087d29190b87261c814687f885f69e98fb827e647aa220b5"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6e4d1ae4617237d24d640a27"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c91922a035d9ed07298c05bd9e149c40fe9bbf7158de6e6ddc7cb1eed3a9a1fd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:5d6c3ed04509afa5f769c4f0","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d35","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:c91922a035d9ed07298c05bd9e149c40fe9bbf7158de6e6ddc7cb1eed3a9a1fd","textSha256":"90334b72c769e89a087d29190b87261c814687f885f69e98fb827e647aa220b5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2935c2034f080b87b8d8bef1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2935c2034f080b87b8d8bef1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c91922a035d9ed07298c05bd9e149c40fe9bbf7158de6e6ddc7cb1eed3a9a1fd","q025-candidate-question:5d6c3ed04509afa5f769c4f0"],"scopeContentSha256":"17d8e9e4a522f34c8d0420c38ff4465085fe551ed3ea525d582a37ee2cc7dced","contributionContentSha256":"5d7058447f3dd5b117a8e5a9b62bf9a7733a24f7561ff44f00696d6f55bc7509","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d35","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:c91922a035d9ed07298c05bd9e149c40fe9bbf7158de6e6ddc7cb1eed3a9a1fd","textSha256":"90334b72c769e89a087d29190b87261c814687f885f69e98fb827e647aa220b5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2935c2034f080b87b8d8bef1","recordId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:e99451d066029c60f98c05c38c4ab865f094857a16daa7777be75384f96151a0","home":{"unitId":"unit:e99451d066029c60f98c05c38c4ab865f094857a16daa7777be75384f96151a0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e99451d066029c60f98c05c38c4ab865f094857a16daa7777be75384f96151a0","paperId":"1602.04251","textSha256":"410dfa3d2b2fa7a4b382e1be94164aedea3ce2a4f3f13d063e4dcea128cb4d97"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:00928281a9090739f48ee269"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:00928281a9090739f48ee269","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e99451d066029c60f98c05c38c4ab865f094857a16daa7777be75384f96151a0","q025-candidate-region:f790522f8a2c0893300bc416"],"scopeContentSha256":"605d6588e09eaa96a4eab90dfd66b189ae0a890234a707553cef72b35bed8d36","placementContentSha256":"59366a2234e560d414eed2f03a8b6442bac5023160982600c20a0ffdf56653de","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge","leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e99451d066029c60f98c05c38c4ab865f094857a16daa7777be75384f96151a0","paperId":"1602.04251","textSha256":"410dfa3d2b2fa7a4b382e1be94164aedea3ce2a4f3f13d063e4dcea128cb4d97"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:00928281a9090739f48ee269"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e99451d066029c60f98c05c38c4ab865f094857a16daa7777be75384f96151a0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:5d6c3ed04509afa5f769c4f0","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:e99451d066029c60f98c05c38c4ab865f094857a16daa7777be75384f96151a0","textSha256":"410dfa3d2b2fa7a4b382e1be94164aedea3ce2a4f3f13d063e4dcea128cb4d97"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aa6a92ca67ff4cbc54d600d8"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:aa6a92ca67ff4cbc54d600d8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e99451d066029c60f98c05c38c4ab865f094857a16daa7777be75384f96151a0","q025-candidate-question:5d6c3ed04509afa5f769c4f0"],"scopeContentSha256":"17d8e9e4a522f34c8d0420c38ff4465085fe551ed3ea525d582a37ee2cc7dced","contributionContentSha256":"ade718e24dc859c09fe24cc422c402ec436e8acfdd7734b6ba111bf34b94fd26","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:e99451d066029c60f98c05c38c4ab865f094857a16daa7777be75384f96151a0","textSha256":"410dfa3d2b2fa7a4b382e1be94164aedea3ce2a4f3f13d063e4dcea128cb4d97"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aa6a92ca67ff4cbc54d600d8","recordId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-74dbe506ca55c51eb56a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":4,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"e4743c00f08d795a7e51e4d10918b407f0193888cda23f8abe25850063043440"}}}
