Which apparently consistent low-energy effective theories admit a UV completion with dynamical gravity, and which proposed necessary conditions help distinguish them?
A shared compatibility question connects foundational discussions and reviews. Definitions, conjectural exclusions and constructive completion are different contributions.
Semiclassical black-hole reasoning; String examples and compactifications; Testing further examples, mutual consistency and phenomenological compatibility
14 extracted descriptions checked; 6 source excerpts checked.
Primary support includes the review dated 19 June 2019 and proceedings version dated 30 July 2019. Other formulations remain description-level. These excerpts establish the program and its limitations, not a complete classification.
Separately admitted review observations are retained for each source-and-role relationship. These reviewed roles are separate from source membership. A shared source does not establish question equivalence; a method contribution does not certify applicability.
- addresses — description_checked
The String Landscape, the Swampland, and the Missing Corner
Which apparently consistent effective theories can admit a UV completion with dynamical gravity? The lectures formulate this as distinguishing the string landscape from the Swampland.
Exact source: unit:0ef0bdcb0b0fad8ba06989de6999e721580b9184b89b5cc06b35c8591bebffee. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:eafd3290b7f0f37af11c5681.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1711.00864","sourceSha256":"9c2d1ad12cb4fc40eb91db217fb97dc546ef187bffe8951bedccfba66527361c","pages":[21],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:986256c90a9716d80f6a834e40439369","source-graph:ev:9ce0a516fee87cc2a4aae3c628aac80e"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d1",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 1,
"unitId": "unit:0ef0bdcb0b0fad8ba06989de6999e721580b9184b89b5cc06b35c8591bebffee",
"textSha256": "cd0e60b163dcdfd673387366015ac32a48c5da93224434ad5828eb1aa3216c4e"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:eafd3290b7f0f37af11c5681",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - specializes — source_excerpt_checked
The zoo plot meets the swampland: mutual (in)consistency of single-field inflation, string conjectures, and cosmological data
Which proposed restrictions distinguish scalar effective theories admitting quantum-gravity completion from theories in the swampland?
Exact source: unit:b47f537459c6e8454d9e9830c71fb1324200fcc065c9d5285969306e185d38dd. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:a52f2af56d4d0a8419df3403.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1808.06424","sourceSha256":"1baa02a3eaf6cb17eb607bfb2291efdd85f22233d4f82dde94ca7b93e27a9d32","pages":[1,2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:9379bdc5cdb6339ec9e5e063611ea5d5","source-graph:ev:e95e266e596e5712d9f787955da08c8f"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d3",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 3,
"unitId": "unit:b47f537459c6e8454d9e9830c71fb1324200fcc065c9d5285969306e185d38dd",
"textSha256": "355f260eeaec5502b01bdc030283c9ab6b8e3054f18a2726a23544513d8a880a"
},
{
"localRef": "e16",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:9379bdc5cdb6339ec9e5e063611ea5d5",
"paperId": "1808.06424",
"sourceSha256": "1baa02a3eaf6cb17eb607bfb2291efdd85f22233d4f82dde94ca7b93e27a9d32",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/78cc9876bc429fadf4e4/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "2ea70d6c0bf8d36dce3bcc723adc0a6b39e19533449db155860e43b6827c9903",
"pdfPage": 1,
"start": 3179,
"end": 4725,
"textSha256": "68c2d0a7f6da52d9adc76cfa8a08a66d4c0aff0f55bca181f490a5d5b91cdf70",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e18",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:abaaaa81778640a8a70b28686a4e4be0",
"paperId": "1808.06424",
"sourceSha256": "1baa02a3eaf6cb17eb607bfb2291efdd85f22233d4f82dde94ca7b93e27a9d32",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/78cc9876bc429fadf4e4/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "2ea70d6c0bf8d36dce3bcc723adc0a6b39e19533449db155860e43b6827c9903",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 0,
"end": 3000,
"textSha256": "f2475638223189e7763f46b7658b68f32e681e70039af577b6c9c1ff62149ef9",
"quoteExactInPage": false,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e12",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:6f1bcbbb26be1991aac8773c0160304e",
"paperId": "1808.06424",
"sourceSha256": "1baa02a3eaf6cb17eb607bfb2291efdd85f22233d4f82dde94ca7b93e27a9d32",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/78cc9876bc429fadf4e4/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "2ea70d6c0bf8d36dce3bcc723adc0a6b39e19533449db155860e43b6827c9903",
"pdfPage": 4,
"start": 0,
"end": 3000,
"textSha256": "36423300a58907cca10924c953feb3e92dc59a7b380e4a9c99d7b5aa5eb76d1b",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:a52f2af56d4d0a8419df3403",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - addresses — description_checked
The Swampland: Introduction and Review
Which apparently consistent effective field theories admit an ultraviolet completion including quantum gravity? The Swampland denotes those that fail this requirement; the Landscape denotes the string-realizable subset discussed in the review.
Exact source: unit:7d7148663011ec95f0a8732700970db8330bbfba4a2973d9daa9890faa32efbe. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:97758ec37729a9e958047236.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1903.06239","sourceSha256":"537c19268752f24ceb13db5e2f9169fe757db435e51447d3700a81f289702617","pages":[5,6],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:28df4ef41d35c0960f38c7889dce589e","source-graph:ev:fce9a32c3a94d74e0441be90ce95a615"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d4",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 4,
"unitId": "unit:7d7148663011ec95f0a8732700970db8330bbfba4a2973d9daa9890faa32efbe",
"textSha256": "619c4e29a573fa2c0b3f09b1dc4d8e14670965c01fd8c67802589a79f84e3a76"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:97758ec37729a9e958047236",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - addresses — source_excerpt_checked
The Swampland: Introduction and Review
Which apparently consistent low-energy effective field theories admit ultraviolet completion into quantum gravity, and what constraints distinguish the Landscape from the Swampland?
Exact source: unit:c8ff7d877113e695a54a7c79f6f80f42455669614b76098919f65d31bfac7b63. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:de20083a25d777a7f4f6a079.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1903.06239","sourceSha256":"537c19268752f24ceb13db5e2f9169fe757db435e51447d3700a81f289702617","pages":[1,5],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:64e4742443f14d89d3206d62b9820d04","source-graph:ev:ea4ec1179a2ff7ad72ec549209326fb3"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d5",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 5,
"unitId": "unit:c8ff7d877113e695a54a7c79f6f80f42455669614b76098919f65d31bfac7b63",
"textSha256": "a7e6de83b75851df559d4ac5620fe9623dc3577bf9eecdaa34db3dabb5ec0acb"
},
{
"localRef": "e9",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:64e4742443f14d89d3206d62b9820d04",
"paperId": "1903.06239",
"sourceSha256": "537c19268752f24ceb13db5e2f9169fe757db435e51447d3700a81f289702617",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/5355278e70712927024d/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "42b9738f8525454b9cf46998082190181e8c64338419fc55bb78c8db39029d6b",
"pdfPage": 1,
"start": 0,
"end": 693,
"textSha256": "446f1d4903a18a726bb72b4e7c52660cd6b53bb64122128f8e25fde900b735dd",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e22",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:ea4ec1179a2ff7ad72ec549209326fb3",
"paperId": "1903.06239",
"sourceSha256": "537c19268752f24ceb13db5e2f9169fe757db435e51447d3700a81f289702617",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/5355278e70712927024d/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "42b9738f8525454b9cf46998082190181e8c64338419fc55bb78c8db39029d6b",
"pdfPage": 5,
"start": 101,
"end": 2336,
"textSha256": "dec87de4536ddc90e460ae5f13a214b88b52122dc50771fd299f1d76a5070d2b",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:de20083a25d777a7f4f6a079",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - boundary — description_checked
The Marshland Conjecture
Can the interface between quantum-gravity-compatible theories and incompatible effective theories be identified as a distinct region? The Marshland conjecture names such an interface inside the landscape.
Exact source: unit:1b9fd945cd921ca5d8765f7148014fe3f0f140e12b5770ed8b75b6cae7e812af. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:ebcde72e8bd51fc658c08a38.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1903.12643","sourceSha256":"fec41340c2bc82d80a20f0fe3d94a616ec588eca17acbed01c23f6e2927be9d3","pages":[1],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:23babcc87befe12f9fe47a6e39ff1dbf","source-graph:ev:949c519adacaa3ef6b8a4266c7d65588"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d7",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 7,
"unitId": "unit:1b9fd945cd921ca5d8765f7148014fe3f0f140e12b5770ed8b75b6cae7e812af",
"textSha256": "169d82f2b426a4e2a45e103556eef34d439b2d019921ba319a06a0f426aa5447"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:ebcde72e8bd51fc658c08a38",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - boundary — description_checked
The Marshland Conjecture
Which apparently consistent low-energy theories admit a quantum-gravity embedding? The landscape/swampland distinction organizes this embedding question; this paper adopts it as background for a proposed boundary region.
Exact source: unit:f3643c56fa60f6e2142f51f5703a88d8debb8b2e7affa92a2de22e28581af2c2. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:ba78cc0d005c38eaba981c56.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1903.12643","sourceSha256":"fec41340c2bc82d80a20f0fe3d94a616ec588eca17acbed01c23f6e2927be9d3","pages":[1],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:411d781dd93c059164d639fecd5e647f","source-graph:ev:6a55af85f5923c3c494f0cc92a31dcc8"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d8",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 8,
"unitId": "unit:f3643c56fa60f6e2142f51f5703a88d8debb8b2e7affa92a2de22e28581af2c2",
"textSha256": "d2c08c38cd5af8d6626aaa9d7d902a7d88ee6bc08924a75afdcfae17437776af"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:ba78cc0d005c38eaba981c56",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - addresses — source_excerpt_checked
From Swampland to Phenomenology and Back
Which low-energy effective field theories can arise from quantum gravity? The landscape contains theories admitting a gravitational UV completion; the swampland contains those that do not. Proposed necessary conditions can exclude candidates without constructing their UV completions.
Exact source: unit:b99b4445867c30d891b660afbf320832b9a94828b1307d61745976dc13f9643d. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:d20a028e3da500989d258ed4.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1904.05357","sourceSha256":"1df96a4948cf416824a9d118d6a06f2e08b85debea64db23d9aa4aa4b17f7632","pages":[1,2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:06975b4650b39584f09b0ff1a4b938e6","source-graph:ev:f9223d5925131e0a20435104abf88e4f"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d9",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 9,
"unitId": "unit:b99b4445867c30d891b660afbf320832b9a94828b1307d61745976dc13f9643d",
"textSha256": "130e74b87668615982f4f1b6afac8074eca6a8e76b49dbf8153a33f7886daec2"
},
{
"localRef": "e0",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:06975b4650b39584f09b0ff1a4b938e6",
"paperId": "1904.05357",
"sourceSha256": "1df96a4948cf416824a9d118d6a06f2e08b85debea64db23d9aa4aa4b17f7632",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/3daabf1f5333635158a7/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "4b374bda54e0b76066d94e8319d6be1f0bd4e517adf371821446c3f9e5df7121",
"pdfPage": 1,
"start": 0,
"end": 2816,
"textSha256": "4109c8c95aeb42e3fb901a3b608a79d2f4e669785c06586fd8c41487493274d8",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e2",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:1b1068733c851e52b79eecbd3edcbdba",
"paperId": "1904.05357",
"sourceSha256": "1df96a4948cf416824a9d118d6a06f2e08b85debea64db23d9aa4aa4b17f7632",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/3daabf1f5333635158a7/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "4b374bda54e0b76066d94e8319d6be1f0bd4e517adf371821446c3f9e5df7121",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 911,
"end": 3416,
"textSha256": "7aab118224fed320063d33809691fbb937f5af12b0273fa36c88b30e3a03c57d",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e13",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:70779c6bfbfaef96c4deb0d3780c747d",
"paperId": "1904.05357",
"sourceSha256": "1df96a4948cf416824a9d118d6a06f2e08b85debea64db23d9aa4aa4b17f7632",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/3daabf1f5333635158a7/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "4b374bda54e0b76066d94e8319d6be1f0bd4e517adf371821446c3f9e5df7121",
"pdfPage": 5,
"start": 0,
"end": 3000,
"textSha256": "f22521abcaf7b66e0487fd8f77cd4400931cb42b421c15e49abf690ad763716f",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:d20a028e3da500989d258ed4",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - boundary — source_excerpt_checked
The Swampland Conjecture Bound Conjecture
Which low-energy effective field theories can admit a consistent ultraviolet completion in quantum gravity? The paper adopts the landscape/swampland terminology as the setting for a different question about the information required to formulate conjectures.
Exact source: unit:9811f92308a6610dceaeff2848764915aa8b7a8a7c3d09ab53f5d0860d03b917. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:5973a9ae70c546cb78a6057b.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2103.16583","sourceSha256":"c59424d210ce64da47497d979cdda9bcd7b2720b52fc56099af4fb4ad2907047","pages":[2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:f883c17aabba67ea08ffc274226059f7"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d11",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 11,
"unitId": "unit:9811f92308a6610dceaeff2848764915aa8b7a8a7c3d09ab53f5d0860d03b917",
"textSha256": "0d54b41c324f1cda2b09a340c00365770c7131e9dd82f4cbe89158ce5e1c1a83"
},
{
"localRef": "e24",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:f883c17aabba67ea08ffc274226059f7",
"paperId": "2103.16583",
"sourceSha256": "c59424d210ce64da47497d979cdda9bcd7b2720b52fc56099af4fb4ad2907047",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/5163d951adfb4b0f199e/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "53f3f04dc13ed39cf67d047c9e01607f45ed9c559ffe07db661e7761fd5e0247",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 0,
"end": 2489,
"textSha256": "53f58abc7a2b83b5b25033724b6d13ef8abdd32940b45c6615042ca20ebbb36a",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e6",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:5aea09543cde25dca6574c6d29b82ad0",
"paperId": "2103.16583",
"sourceSha256": "c59424d210ce64da47497d979cdda9bcd7b2720b52fc56099af4fb4ad2907047",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/5163d951adfb4b0f199e/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "53f3f04dc13ed39cf67d047c9e01607f45ed9c559ffe07db661e7761fd5e0247",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 0,
"end": 2489,
"textSha256": "53f58abc7a2b83b5b25033724b6d13ef8abdd32940b45c6615042ca20ebbb36a",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e25",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:fc3fc1f6d46c1c573f41300167fed73e",
"paperId": "2103.16583",
"sourceSha256": "c59424d210ce64da47497d979cdda9bcd7b2720b52fc56099af4fb4ad2907047",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/5163d951adfb4b0f199e/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "53f3f04dc13ed39cf67d047c9e01607f45ed9c559ffe07db661e7761fd5e0247",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 97,
"end": 2489,
"textSha256": "984b776c70e7805ebee6e38cabd5d9ba3a74ecffe6579fd8ff4e8a00ad96aaf8",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:5973a9ae70c546cb78a6057b",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - addresses — description_checked
Lectures on the string landscape and the Swampland
Which effective field theories can consistently couple to quantum gravity, and how do worldsheet consistency, compactifications, dualities and black holes motivate criteria separating the landscape from the Swampland? These are pedagogical review lectures.
Exact source: unit:368ca444bac27952d057063f41e5e110f0aa1e0e5acbb9369fe02764118931fe. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:5db5e8a26ffb03db052b3f3d.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2212.06187","sourceSha256":"18172df5807d5489763ae2dd86c9e367c30d5bd9bef7d60e4bc98fcb917b60af","pages":[1,5],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:cc5848d7e5ffb8fb067006df7c0998b6","source-graph:ev:d1ac9f56c79182e8bbd6620c0ad46f0a","source-graph:ev:e871acf8a97a922ac655a3494266b385"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d18",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 18,
"unitId": "unit:368ca444bac27952d057063f41e5e110f0aa1e0e5acbb9369fe02764118931fe",
"textSha256": "9592dca3f4061e8c7316b5807388498b882e013bff3827046c6423439a5f5ce4"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:5db5e8a26ffb03db052b3f3d",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - method — description_checked
Lectures in quantum gravity
What low-energy framework and consistency tests should quantum-gravity UV completions recover, and what can semiclassical black holes teach before a full completion is known?
Exact source: unit:d35022b6a8dfe8bbd4ec64a54e2cc5a8ff10dbe3353ec702f8c02fc71a2cb774. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:a61ddc683c66afa1869b91de.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2412.08690","sourceSha256":"e835003f384a35433fa947c83beef78951cedaf20d20c6c2d4465c10aef3bcdb","pages":[263],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:758db436266b95d0b705a8093ae836f2","source-graph:ev:8cfa6f1d61f4c60ac502fbe92ce68191","source-graph:ev:f2ae2f742d4052c29a89833a7269f55c"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d21",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 21,
"unitId": "unit:d35022b6a8dfe8bbd4ec64a54e2cc5a8ff10dbe3353ec702f8c02fc71a2cb774",
"textSha256": "b967ac684e1e97eda0666fd02c35aa56b17d5c732e419c8642f57e7689f67d06"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:a61ddc683c66afa1869b91de",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - addresses — description_checked
The String landscape and the swampland
Which apparently consistent low-energy theories can occur in a consistent quantum theory of gravity? The paper asks whether universal restrictions on string constructions constrain infrared physics despite the large diversity of known vacua.
Exact source: unit:d9120eb3634a9c529d1ddf1970b20cc0ff36c9f4432c47da43a8436ba09730c0. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:0df203acf12de0daa01fcf88.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"hep-th/0509212","sourceSha256":"a90c61c46cfa8b9f409f9e7b2d23d8dec7beb737e033e9d16269110cd9540370","pages":[2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:b3807b01bfffd1e0356fa9aa26d7ca84","source-graph:ev:c52baa225cc6fc274c41f2e1f7d2d9ec"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d27",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 27,
"unitId": "unit:d9120eb3634a9c529d1ddf1970b20cc0ff36c9f4432c47da43a8436ba09730c0",
"textSha256": "9f6fe25beb3670477dba587144c5aa4defb81cc8f231ecebded5b9d9b6055d3b"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:0df203acf12de0daa01fcf88",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - instantiates — source_excerpt_checked
The anomaly that was not meant IIB
Do the alternative anomaly-free realizations admit quantum-gravity completions, or do further consistency conditions place them in the Swampland?
Exact source: unit:f041f13ddca46a67c6849f15355843692998218e9db2938c6eff227780d46717. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:1a8ad98bab67da31b92c9e03.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2107.14227","sourceSha256":"f8f8f5ea64380ea11a5301322ea01eb92c771a9ef026d0d7a453afe895cdeba5","pages":[6],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:2cff2c1588adfa3ed343ab990beb806e","source-graph:ev:33c07025b7c36e4e826ae027cda55b27"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d28",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 28,
"unitId": "unit:f041f13ddca46a67c6849f15355843692998218e9db2938c6eff227780d46717",
"textSha256": "7bc73b30def4655aeecf069ab7fe7c963ddab32ba2b40760e5efd4919d1c801e"
},
{
"localRef": "e3",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:2cff2c1588adfa3ed343ab990beb806e",
"paperId": "2107.14227",
"sourceSha256": "f8f8f5ea64380ea11a5301322ea01eb92c771a9ef026d0d7a453afe895cdeba5",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/426b1d1760fd8314da88/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "48488a35424b8fa2c139ca84885ddd34d1e34e49a213144f33c4e8f3326090c7",
"pdfPage": 6,
"start": 6658,
"end": 8637,
"textSha256": "f30d284ce5785b524073044a09acbc5725dc48d413ad397b33133d78dc90abe9",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e21",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:de1279622850b4f2d0ccc84ba4ede45f",
"paperId": "2107.14227",
"sourceSha256": "f8f8f5ea64380ea11a5301322ea01eb92c771a9ef026d0d7a453afe895cdeba5",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/426b1d1760fd8314da88/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "48488a35424b8fa2c139ca84885ddd34d1e34e49a213144f33c4e8f3326090c7",
"pdfPage": 5,
"start": 2143,
"end": 3500,
"textSha256": "38cb154074658a96da697442b2e7532d7c8dfbf7c55d120952effed24fbcace5",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e8",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:637592371fd46ff74497cbbdedc199a2",
"paperId": "2107.14227",
"sourceSha256": "f8f8f5ea64380ea11a5301322ea01eb92c771a9ef026d0d7a453afe895cdeba5",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/426b1d1760fd8314da88/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "48488a35424b8fa2c139ca84885ddd34d1e34e49a213144f33c4e8f3326090c7",
"pdfPage": 6,
"start": 5907,
"end": 8637,
"textSha256": "3b95cdb8d7382a416e5f054514f27b1f5bda34cca591d667faa9c21e680dc32a",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:1a8ad98bab67da31b92c9e03",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - comparison — source_excerpt_checked
Swampland Revisited
How should swampland conjectures distinguish effective theories admitting ultraviolet quantum-gravity completion, and how justified is excluding de Sitter vacua given cosmological observations and disputed string constructions?
Exact source: unit:62a77fabcb27ea6a325981c5177bc34725989588a3c3dd425a181d19c0355bfe. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:2833486b7e28dfadecd230f8.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2301.03464","sourceSha256":"fe36ce896dde2dea08f2e0bf26040167eecec0c358a95827c1393e4610dc2e4b","pages":[2,6,10],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:75ecd69d41298aeb8e08ff1fadcf2bbd","source-graph:ev:b84b5e43dff05a10dabdc32c7054a241","source-graph:ev:c22a7a5391de06ddb449c8a9593540ec"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d29",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 29,
"unitId": "unit:62a77fabcb27ea6a325981c5177bc34725989588a3c3dd425a181d19c0355bfe",
"textSha256": "8d4fe3ca0179732c395ef1f8d4d5119972532ceae723a5835ffd907793b71b6c"
},
{
"localRef": "e14",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:75ecd69d41298aeb8e08ff1fadcf2bbd",
"paperId": "2301.03464",
"sourceSha256": "fe36ce896dde2dea08f2e0bf26040167eecec0c358a95827c1393e4610dc2e4b",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/901d9ac838f30519cb70/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "ff65a17b4ed3063d4ca1a0fb25f88051c90d9fe7d7fb15e2d04c1f8157cb5323",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 0,
"end": 3000,
"textSha256": "cc5f4a1348f992dd2c9374337c75c04a6b3be20488f02a1f921d5cbfe85960ff",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e19",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:b84b5e43dff05a10dabdc32c7054a241",
"paperId": "2301.03464",
"sourceSha256": "fe36ce896dde2dea08f2e0bf26040167eecec0c358a95827c1393e4610dc2e4b",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/901d9ac838f30519cb70/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "ff65a17b4ed3063d4ca1a0fb25f88051c90d9fe7d7fb15e2d04c1f8157cb5323",
"pdfPage": 10,
"start": 0,
"end": 2558,
"textSha256": "ad61caf110dffb4681696dd35baf42b4571ba123ebab5f1956a4af50dd66ad61",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e20",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:c22a7a5391de06ddb449c8a9593540ec",
"paperId": "2301.03464",
"sourceSha256": "fe36ce896dde2dea08f2e0bf26040167eecec0c358a95827c1393e4610dc2e4b",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/901d9ac838f30519cb70/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "ff65a17b4ed3063d4ca1a0fb25f88051c90d9fe7d7fb15e2d04c1f8157cb5323",
"pdfPage": 6,
"start": 0,
"end": 2936,
"textSha256": "e58ad2153b52324d5c1b1df85fc608f8b5552ad21eb685159a7f3536dafae5be",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:2833486b7e28dfadecd230f8",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-de8488f866fa0c26459b-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - specializes — description_checked
An Analysis of Anomaly Cancellation for Theories in D=10
Original proposal qualification: Completion is the clear target; the candidates and their defining premises are underspecified. Independent challenge qualification: Completion is the target, but the candidates, dimension and defining premises are unspecified.
Can the two abelian-containing polynomial candidates be completed into quantum gravity?
Exact source: unit:e8cc19c9a89ff281a022113db638ec13721d815971949b468b1de3aad633ab30. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:4d3eaa12058b2023b0056751.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1507.08642","sourceSha256":"728f39a5196c58473b58bf99571b4b68eb8eab92c44e995f327ed11a062b4cf5","pages":[3,7],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:e48a50955667b8eb254ad97aa73f65a9","source-graph:ev:fc34e8eaf553e571ca25b8c2e3a17eb2"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d2",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 2,
"unitId": "unit:e8cc19c9a89ff281a022113db638ec13721d815971949b468b1de3aad633ab30",
"textSha256": "cf0705e61dc1ef4dbb61166a054a64e93ba0626680631062ff7ab4e310d93070"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:4d3eaa12058b2023b0056751",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true,
"canonicalProjection": {
"identityGroupId": "identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"identityDecisionId": "decision:whole-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"originalDestinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"originalScopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"originalDecisionId": "decision:source-contribution:4d3eaa12058b2023b0056751",
"originalObservation": {
"unitId": "unit:e8cc19c9a89ff281a022113db638ec13721d815971949b468b1de3aad633ab30",
"destinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"role": "specializes",
"basis": "description_checked",
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d2",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 2,
"unitId": "unit:e8cc19c9a89ff281a022113db638ec13721d815971949b468b1de3aad633ab30",
"textSha256": "cf0705e61dc1ef4dbb61166a054a64e93ba0626680631062ff7ab4e310d93070"
}
],
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:4d3eaa12058b2023b0056751",
"qualification": "Original proposal qualification: Completion is the clear target; the candidates and their defining premises are underspecified. Independent challenge qualification: Completion is the target, but the candidates, dimension and defining premises are unspecified.",
"scopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"browserVectorRow": 1373,
"sourceRow": 1373,
"paperId": "1507.08642",
"lens": "physical_question",
"contributionStatus": "accepted_typed_contribution",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:4d3eaa12058b2023b0056751",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
},
"meaning": "Same scoped-question identity projection; original qualification, evidence, target version and receipt remain unchanged."
}
}
} - addresses — description_checked
TASI Lectures on Remnants from the String Landscape
Original proposal qualification: The description's reference to established restrictions does not identify or independently verify particular restrictions. Independent challenge qualification: The description does not identify or independently verify the restrictions it calls established.
Can characteristic low-energy remnants or violations of established quantum-gravity restrictions test a theory with an inaccessible fundamental scale and many possible vacua?
Exact source: unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:c22945452abae3a1ff1cd39a.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1801.03503","sourceSha256":"95e515a9ed06dd810226c2928d8558b3d52981ea0dbdd8f0d7338613cda52476","pages":[28],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:70dcce0d352658fb6570ce3d1591b7be"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d9",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 9,
"unitId": "unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853",
"textSha256": "70666671b810a7cbb77a17ef0ab9ad3ee1e8f88209200d70d37a4cdaf70aa1d6"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:c22945452abae3a1ff1cd39a",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true,
"canonicalProjection": {
"identityGroupId": "identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"identityDecisionId": "decision:whole-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"originalDestinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"originalScopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"originalDecisionId": "decision:source-contribution:c22945452abae3a1ff1cd39a",
"originalObservation": {
"unitId": "unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853",
"destinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"role": "addresses",
"basis": "description_checked",
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d9",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 9,
"unitId": "unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853",
"textSha256": "70666671b810a7cbb77a17ef0ab9ad3ee1e8f88209200d70d37a4cdaf70aa1d6"
}
],
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:c22945452abae3a1ff1cd39a",
"qualification": "Original proposal qualification: The description's reference to established restrictions does not identify or independently verify particular restrictions. Independent challenge qualification: The description does not identify or independently verify the restrictions it calls established.",
"scopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"browserVectorRow": 1910,
"sourceRow": 1910,
"paperId": "1801.03503",
"lens": "physical_question",
"contributionStatus": "accepted_typed_contribution",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:c22945452abae3a1ff1cd39a",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
},
"meaning": "Same scoped-question identity projection; original qualification, evidence, target version and receipt remain unchanged."
}
}
} - addresses — description_checked
Emergence of Weak Coupling at Large Distance in Quantum Gravity
Original proposal qualification: Compound identity unresolved: infrared diagnostics and the foundational necessity of moduli or massless towers are separate questions. Independent challenge qualification: Compound identity remains unresolved: infrared diagnostics and the foundational necessity of moduli or massless towers are separate targets.
Can infrared properties of scalar fields and particle towers identify gravitational EFTs compatible with quantum gravity? A separate unresolved issue is whether quantum gravity itself guarantees moduli and towers becoming massless in large-moduli limits.
Exact source: unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:df7b4f9b0984eccaa33fdb39.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1802.08698","sourceSha256":"cfa54c1c9eb0267263c0f7e70c18de6c5295128b2c350e1d18c829a0333133e4","pages":[1,5],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:3f44ac55e01bc57aa950fd7368366285","source-graph:ev:bd27a5e2a15bdf12a7267688d5578665"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d10",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 10,
"unitId": "unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893",
"textSha256": "5d0a687405a4a129aa50a2e87696184884adbcb0ede13dfdfd02895d528d29fb"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:df7b4f9b0984eccaa33fdb39",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true,
"canonicalProjection": {
"identityGroupId": "identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"identityDecisionId": "decision:whole-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"originalDestinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"originalScopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"originalDecisionId": "decision:source-contribution:df7b4f9b0984eccaa33fdb39",
"originalObservation": {
"unitId": "unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893",
"destinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"role": "addresses",
"basis": "description_checked",
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d10",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 10,
"unitId": "unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893",
"textSha256": "5d0a687405a4a129aa50a2e87696184884adbcb0ede13dfdfd02895d528d29fb"
}
],
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:df7b4f9b0984eccaa33fdb39",
"qualification": "Original proposal qualification: Compound identity unresolved: infrared diagnostics and the foundational necessity of moduli or massless towers are separate questions. Independent challenge qualification: Compound identity remains unresolved: infrared diagnostics and the foundational necessity of moduli or massless towers are separate targets.",
"scopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"browserVectorRow": 1941,
"sourceRow": 1941,
"paperId": "1802.08698",
"lens": "physical_question",
"contributionStatus": "accepted_typed_contribution",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:df7b4f9b0984eccaa33fdb39",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
},
"meaning": "Same scoped-question identity projection; original qualification, evidence, target version and receipt remain unchanged."
}
}
} - method — source_excerpt_checked
Tensionless Strings and the Weak Gravity Conjecture
Original proposal qualification: Several conjecture tests share this controlled limit. Full-charge population differs from superextremality; persistence away from the limit remains speculative. Independent challenge qualification: Several conjecture tests share the limit. Charge completeness differs from superextremality; full-lattice superextremality is example-specific and away-limit ed
Which conjectured quantum-gravity constraints can be tested by a controlled compactification limit with a weak gauge interaction and finite gravitational coupling?
Exact source: unit:6631f3e6512f608e27c8ea1f68a6f3605533630b7bc969278502e4ae0f34a92b. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:919eb0ed0f841bdc02c844ca.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1808.05958","sourceSha256":"202fa4329181dabaf1178b61c87867ed58ba0ffcff3d01b3d07a6fa4d77d7738","pages":[3,23,24],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:03de30691ff29b910f991ee1f59ca6cc","source-graph:ev:22918a0c95e68273ffe4885665afa67a","source-graph:ev:cafd660fce9cc1e8638d12fae8d0a660"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d13",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 13,
"unitId": "unit:6631f3e6512f608e27c8ea1f68a6f3605533630b7bc969278502e4ae0f34a92b",
"textSha256": "2506e738ca718c7d6c26b884ba255b99bf411ed6930b45b75fa8a4816920a309"
},
{
"localRef": "e1",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:03de30691ff29b910f991ee1f59ca6cc",
"paperId": "1808.05958",
"sourceSha256": "202fa4329181dabaf1178b61c87867ed58ba0ffcff3d01b3d07a6fa4d77d7738",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/0f6d78f33b6280a5f5e9/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "4b1bf468ef8828931f51a5c92a3793a4cf4f57d938d8de8a4efc9dd9513f1049",
"pdfPage": 3,
"start": 0,
"end": 3000,
"textSha256": "0b690b2e1b94a68927fdae1cb5eb959778c02596d0c30141e8998faceb6e2e9d",
"quoteExactInPage": false,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e20",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:b34e2c3b8052a2e0341bc63249a08abe",
"paperId": "1808.05958",
"sourceSha256": "202fa4329181dabaf1178b61c87867ed58ba0ffcff3d01b3d07a6fa4d77d7738",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/0f6d78f33b6280a5f5e9/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "4b1bf468ef8828931f51a5c92a3793a4cf4f57d938d8de8a4efc9dd9513f1049",
"pdfPage": 19,
"start": 0,
"end": 1893,
"textSha256": "d93af387ec827cc193fa4e4c34e8bf5c81f5222eea2d5ab43eb1a21bf81385a6",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e14",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:56045fdb431395ef29b9215aa18361d4",
"paperId": "1808.05958",
"sourceSha256": "202fa4329181dabaf1178b61c87867ed58ba0ffcff3d01b3d07a6fa4d77d7738",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/0f6d78f33b6280a5f5e9/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "4b1bf468ef8828931f51a5c92a3793a4cf4f57d938d8de8a4efc9dd9513f1049",
"pdfPage": 23,
"start": 1084,
"end": 3856,
"textSha256": "06af19193ca3169f0ff1076d763e442510db71426156f0b724ca2311e2241760",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:919eb0ed0f841bdc02c844ca",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true,
"canonicalProjection": {
"identityGroupId": "identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"identityDecisionId": "decision:whole-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"originalDestinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"originalScopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"originalDecisionId": "decision:source-contribution:919eb0ed0f841bdc02c844ca",
"originalObservation": {
"unitId": "unit:6631f3e6512f608e27c8ea1f68a6f3605533630b7bc969278502e4ae0f34a92b",
"destinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"role": "method",
"basis": "source_excerpt_checked",
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d13",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 13,
"unitId": "unit:6631f3e6512f608e27c8ea1f68a6f3605533630b7bc969278502e4ae0f34a92b",
"textSha256": "2506e738ca718c7d6c26b884ba255b99bf411ed6930b45b75fa8a4816920a309"
},
{
"localRef": "e1",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:03de30691ff29b910f991ee1f59ca6cc",
"paperId": "1808.05958",
"sourceSha256": "202fa4329181dabaf1178b61c87867ed58ba0ffcff3d01b3d07a6fa4d77d7738",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/0f6d78f33b6280a5f5e9/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "4b1bf468ef8828931f51a5c92a3793a4cf4f57d938d8de8a4efc9dd9513f1049",
"pdfPage": 3,
"start": 0,
"end": 3000,
"textSha256": "0b690b2e1b94a68927fdae1cb5eb959778c02596d0c30141e8998faceb6e2e9d",
"quoteExactInPage": false,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e20",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:b34e2c3b8052a2e0341bc63249a08abe",
"paperId": "1808.05958",
"sourceSha256": "202fa4329181dabaf1178b61c87867ed58ba0ffcff3d01b3d07a6fa4d77d7738",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/0f6d78f33b6280a5f5e9/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "4b1bf468ef8828931f51a5c92a3793a4cf4f57d938d8de8a4efc9dd9513f1049",
"pdfPage": 19,
"start": 0,
"end": 1893,
"textSha256": "d93af387ec827cc193fa4e4c34e8bf5c81f5222eea2d5ab43eb1a21bf81385a6",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e14",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:56045fdb431395ef29b9215aa18361d4",
"paperId": "1808.05958",
"sourceSha256": "202fa4329181dabaf1178b61c87867ed58ba0ffcff3d01b3d07a6fa4d77d7738",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/0f6d78f33b6280a5f5e9/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "4b1bf468ef8828931f51a5c92a3793a4cf4f57d938d8de8a4efc9dd9513f1049",
"pdfPage": 23,
"start": 1084,
"end": 3856,
"textSha256": "06af19193ca3169f0ff1076d763e442510db71426156f0b724ca2311e2241760",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:919eb0ed0f841bdc02c844ca",
"qualification": "Original proposal qualification: Several conjecture tests share this controlled limit. Full-charge population differs from superextremality; persistence away from the limit remains speculative. Independent challenge qualification: Several conjecture tests share the limit. Charge completeness differs from superextremality; full-lattice superextremality is example-specific and away-limit ed",
"scopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"browserVectorRow": 2190,
"sourceRow": 2190,
"paperId": "1808.05958",
"lens": "physical_question",
"contributionStatus": "accepted_typed_contribution",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:919eb0ed0f841bdc02c844ca",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
},
"meaning": "Same scoped-question identity projection; original qualification, evidence, target version and receipt remain unchanged."
}
}
} - instantiates — description_checked
A Spin‐2 Conjecture on the Swampland
Original proposal qualification: Independent challenge qualification:
The paper asks whether quantum gravity imposes a tower threshold on a fundamental massive spin-2 field, beyond the requirements of infrared consistency. The associated massless limit would otherwise produce an additional massless spin-2 field.
Exact source: unit:4944b8b9cf53d1d4456a84d4768fc256efd3daa81c878fcfc199c572e00bbb76. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:a496e3b943179f91cb4a7acc.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1811.07908","sourceSha256":"f07207b1dfcb3aa706b317a9889bc214a0e455400a231c67c51a2226de00fd2c","pages":[1],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:174688443eea06a1512073dda0422b52"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d14",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 14,
"unitId": "unit:4944b8b9cf53d1d4456a84d4768fc256efd3daa81c878fcfc199c572e00bbb76",
"textSha256": "93ba3e5fdb12d06864bfc2c9cff1e775136441f79f16a3007487be3a05cd64a4"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:a496e3b943179f91cb4a7acc",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true,
"canonicalProjection": {
"identityGroupId": "identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"identityDecisionId": "decision:whole-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"originalDestinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"originalScopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"originalDecisionId": "decision:source-contribution:a496e3b943179f91cb4a7acc",
"originalObservation": {
"unitId": "unit:4944b8b9cf53d1d4456a84d4768fc256efd3daa81c878fcfc199c572e00bbb76",
"destinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"role": "instantiates",
"basis": "description_checked",
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d14",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 14,
"unitId": "unit:4944b8b9cf53d1d4456a84d4768fc256efd3daa81c878fcfc199c572e00bbb76",
"textSha256": "93ba3e5fdb12d06864bfc2c9cff1e775136441f79f16a3007487be3a05cd64a4"
}
],
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:a496e3b943179f91cb4a7acc",
"qualification": "Original proposal qualification: Independent challenge qualification: ",
"scopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"browserVectorRow": 2503,
"sourceRow": 2503,
"paperId": "1811.07908",
"lens": "physical_question",
"contributionStatus": "accepted_typed_contribution",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:a496e3b943179f91cb4a7acc",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
},
"meaning": "Same scoped-question identity projection; original qualification, evidence, target version and receipt remain unchanged."
}
}
} - specializes — description_checked
Comment on "Braneworld Effective Field Theories -- Holography, Consistency and Conformal Effects"
Original proposal qualification: Testing three proposed obstructions does not construct a complete UV theory. Independent challenge qualification: Testing proposed obstructions does not construct a complete ultraviolet theory.
Can quantum gravity admit a low-energy braneworld EFT containing pure 4D fields on δ-like branes, or must every such field arise from a bulk zero-mode? The paper tests three proposed obstructions rather than constructing a complete UV theory.
Exact source: unit:d7447cc696117c9d733331fe499e8f584ad5d1a375fb0894895a7f5038de38b7. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:8a6e4543aaa29fac78ea861d.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2007.04266","sourceSha256":"ddc5c248f2037873506fcb9509b1a374b04eda109c126bf3947261eed7cde04c","pages":[1,3],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:7f7a7c8762d325391b16518d70ebdeef","source-graph:ev:8a6f5b249c1b2fe87d9b3db72d3cbbfa"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d23",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 23,
"unitId": "unit:d7447cc696117c9d733331fe499e8f584ad5d1a375fb0894895a7f5038de38b7",
"textSha256": "2f87a9df354bac76ca49a7781302dd0a1f00c5146e2db320d872b202e39261b5"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:8a6e4543aaa29fac78ea861d",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true,
"canonicalProjection": {
"identityGroupId": "identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"identityDecisionId": "decision:whole-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"originalDestinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"originalScopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"originalDecisionId": "decision:source-contribution:8a6e4543aaa29fac78ea861d",
"originalObservation": {
"unitId": "unit:d7447cc696117c9d733331fe499e8f584ad5d1a375fb0894895a7f5038de38b7",
"destinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"role": "specializes",
"basis": "description_checked",
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d23",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 23,
"unitId": "unit:d7447cc696117c9d733331fe499e8f584ad5d1a375fb0894895a7f5038de38b7",
"textSha256": "2f87a9df354bac76ca49a7781302dd0a1f00c5146e2db320d872b202e39261b5"
}
],
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:8a6e4543aaa29fac78ea861d",
"qualification": "Original proposal qualification: Testing three proposed obstructions does not construct a complete UV theory. Independent challenge qualification: Testing proposed obstructions does not construct a complete ultraviolet theory.",
"scopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"browserVectorRow": 3847,
"sourceRow": 3847,
"paperId": "2007.04266",
"lens": "physical_question",
"contributionStatus": "accepted_typed_contribution",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:8a6e4543aaa29fac78ea861d",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
},
"meaning": "Same scoped-question identity projection; original qualification, evidence, target version and receipt remain unchanged."
}
}
} - specializes — description_checked
de Sitter in non-supersymmetric string theories: no-go theorems and brane-worlds
Original proposal qualification: Neither the charged sources nor the compactification obstruction is specified well enough for a fine identity. Independent challenge qualification: The charged sources and compactification obstruction lack enough defining detail for a fine identity.
Could quantum-gravity consistency require charged sources that also modify the compactification obstruction?
Exact source: unit:97dbf3eb781aeb02de7c96c3d29ff90095f2844cc5d2cbd58829c18c3dfc5474. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:7875a7fbb1a388c5f74a3faa.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2007.13757","sourceSha256":"22247e8feeb410a6263e93d1af8860e2498ef02aa5d3257d4b316a13e43deb3c","pages":[13],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:cbefd97f4e98aefccdede601d4551745"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d24",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 24,
"unitId": "unit:97dbf3eb781aeb02de7c96c3d29ff90095f2844cc5d2cbd58829c18c3dfc5474",
"textSha256": "d33d8bb49a1fa487e92c3a0e32a9a3fc56abfbc9389350cf7b3916f709d849f0"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:7875a7fbb1a388c5f74a3faa",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true,
"canonicalProjection": {
"identityGroupId": "identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"identityDecisionId": "decision:whole-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"originalDestinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"originalScopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"originalDecisionId": "decision:source-contribution:7875a7fbb1a388c5f74a3faa",
"originalObservation": {
"unitId": "unit:97dbf3eb781aeb02de7c96c3d29ff90095f2844cc5d2cbd58829c18c3dfc5474",
"destinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"role": "specializes",
"basis": "description_checked",
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d24",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 24,
"unitId": "unit:97dbf3eb781aeb02de7c96c3d29ff90095f2844cc5d2cbd58829c18c3dfc5474",
"textSha256": "d33d8bb49a1fa487e92c3a0e32a9a3fc56abfbc9389350cf7b3916f709d849f0"
}
],
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:7875a7fbb1a388c5f74a3faa",
"qualification": "Original proposal qualification: Neither the charged sources nor the compactification obstruction is specified well enough for a fine identity. Independent challenge qualification: The charged sources and compactification obstruction lack enough defining detail for a fine identity.",
"scopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"browserVectorRow": 3924,
"sourceRow": 3924,
"paperId": "2007.13757",
"lens": "physical_question",
"contributionStatus": "accepted_typed_contribution",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:7875a7fbb1a388c5f74a3faa",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
},
"meaning": "Same scoped-question identity projection; original qualification, evidence, target version and receipt remain unchanged."
}
}
} - boundary — description_checked
Sharp boundaries for the swampland
Original proposal qualification: Extending the consistency method and realizing its suggested spectra are separate unresolved targets. Independent challenge qualification: Method extensions and physical realization of extremal-functional spectra remain separate unresolved targets.
Can the same quantitative consistency program handle general external states, loop discontinuities, infrared-safe four-dimensional scattering, and curved backgrounds? A separate issue is whether the spectra suggested by extremal functionals are realized by physical gravitational theories.
Exact source: unit:de73f67ec4106bc32b5b123c03ff84d9dd8809ade51739e0a267eb8032754c77. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:59d0b3dbb41d284f51256590.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2102.08951","sourceSha256":"67f497d0971d293eba97075818907d45d43fa1af3de1e3afd8ee3fbb14431b28","pages":[26],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:6f11522e1fa60bd6658a75436a24399c","source-graph:ev:f991a34bba0b11b4a8a0b52cf5c97480"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d29",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 29,
"unitId": "unit:de73f67ec4106bc32b5b123c03ff84d9dd8809ade51739e0a267eb8032754c77",
"textSha256": "9b010bbedc64e770e4cb9ad3976ef42ab59d1ba72fb8e2cecbf4e2e31e98a34f"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:59d0b3dbb41d284f51256590",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true,
"canonicalProjection": {
"identityGroupId": "identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"identityDecisionId": "decision:whole-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"originalDestinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"originalScopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"originalDecisionId": "decision:source-contribution:59d0b3dbb41d284f51256590",
"originalObservation": {
"unitId": "unit:de73f67ec4106bc32b5b123c03ff84d9dd8809ade51739e0a267eb8032754c77",
"destinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"role": "boundary",
"basis": "description_checked",
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d29",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 29,
"unitId": "unit:de73f67ec4106bc32b5b123c03ff84d9dd8809ade51739e0a267eb8032754c77",
"textSha256": "9b010bbedc64e770e4cb9ad3976ef42ab59d1ba72fb8e2cecbf4e2e31e98a34f"
}
],
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:59d0b3dbb41d284f51256590",
"qualification": "Original proposal qualification: Extending the consistency method and realizing its suggested spectra are separate unresolved targets. Independent challenge qualification: Method extensions and physical realization of extremal-functional spectra remain separate unresolved targets.",
"scopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"browserVectorRow": 4351,
"sourceRow": 4351,
"paperId": "2102.08951",
"lens": "physical_question",
"contributionStatus": "accepted_typed_contribution",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:59d0b3dbb41d284f51256590",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
},
"meaning": "Same scoped-question identity projection; original qualification, evidence, target version and receipt remain unchanged."
}
}
} - addresses — description_checked
The Swampland Conjectures: A Bridge from Quantum Gravity to Particle Physics
Original proposal qualification: Independent challenge qualification:
Which apparently consistent particle-physics EFTs can admit quantum gravity, and can consistency relate parameters that appear independent in an EFT?
Exact source: unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:8e71cc120ff53b490ee93b1f.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2107.00087","sourceSha256":"11c3ef9e9b5646a962939c04240275d2f56429fc77199651c2b0926d14eaf4a3","pages":[1,3,11],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:722b32b49d11f35dca9265a23e3facf5","source-graph:ev:ae5d7b4e2dd8d09c1a4b4099f31580d5","source-graph:ev:caf20f7a231ba5d163964d2332030019"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d30",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 30,
"unitId": "unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f",
"textSha256": "b01635e1b0a56b493eae67738dbcc3947293f80ddbadc9c1bc1e475a7bf3c567"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:8e71cc120ff53b490ee93b1f",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true,
"canonicalProjection": {
"identityGroupId": "identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"identityDecisionId": "decision:whole-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"originalDestinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"originalScopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"originalDecisionId": "decision:source-contribution:8e71cc120ff53b490ee93b1f",
"originalObservation": {
"unitId": "unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f",
"destinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"role": "addresses",
"basis": "description_checked",
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d30",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 30,
"unitId": "unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f",
"textSha256": "b01635e1b0a56b493eae67738dbcc3947293f80ddbadc9c1bc1e475a7bf3c567"
}
],
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:8e71cc120ff53b490ee93b1f",
"qualification": "Original proposal qualification: Independent challenge qualification: ",
"scopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"browserVectorRow": 4645,
"sourceRow": 4645,
"paperId": "2107.00087",
"lens": "physical_question",
"contributionStatus": "accepted_typed_contribution",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:8e71cc120ff53b490ee93b1f",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
},
"meaning": "Same scoped-question identity projection; original qualification, evidence, target version and receipt remain unchanged."
}
}
} - addresses — source_excerpt_checked
Snowmass White Paper: Implications of Quantum Gravity for Particle Physics
Original proposal qualification: A multi-target review, not one atomic question. It explicitly denies a guarantee that gravitational considerations solve the listed problems. Independent challenge qualification: Multi-target review with unresolved atomic identities. It explicitly denies a guarantee that gravitational considerations solve the listed problems.
Review how quantum-gravity consistency conditions constrain low-energy EFT and might inform strong CP, the weak scale, new gauge interactions and dark energy. The white paper explicitly does not guarantee that gravitational considerations solve these problems.
Exact source: unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:d3e3428668c7a8404eb654d1.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2203.07624","sourceSha256":"c895f9a40099e729ee94446083f8c4f98949a3c894118a104f5cb8ff37823bc7","pages":[1,2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:ad556fc63a18fb1e9885e041b4dd94c6","source-graph:ev:af78084cf347eef98bbe97217bc94e5d"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d32",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 32,
"unitId": "unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8",
"textSha256": "495bf3f89c139f93197d0408c023a17d4b50a95a608afd0792d5e23719757667"
},
{
"localRef": "e18",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:ad556fc63a18fb1e9885e041b4dd94c6",
"paperId": "2203.07624",
"sourceSha256": "c895f9a40099e729ee94446083f8c4f98949a3c894118a104f5cb8ff37823bc7",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/91b86eb8982d9549f2b2/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "acb82ded71c09dd2953075ceed50c39e4596735012ed84fe70752130abae5077",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 0,
"end": 3000,
"textSha256": "5d13a492f0b48823ae05fd433bd8759d20fad827ff545eab98ff692709f823e7",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e19",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:af78084cf347eef98bbe97217bc94e5d",
"paperId": "2203.07624",
"sourceSha256": "c895f9a40099e729ee94446083f8c4f98949a3c894118a104f5cb8ff37823bc7",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/91b86eb8982d9549f2b2/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "acb82ded71c09dd2953075ceed50c39e4596735012ed84fe70752130abae5077",
"pdfPage": 1,
"start": 0,
"end": 1161,
"textSha256": "90600347cf36744684fa2251d16253e0168cc364c2bdee76cc7a05c7ecf92c1e",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:d3e3428668c7a8404eb654d1",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true,
"canonicalProjection": {
"identityGroupId": "identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"identityDecisionId": "decision:whole-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"originalDestinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"originalScopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"originalDecisionId": "decision:source-contribution:d3e3428668c7a8404eb654d1",
"originalObservation": {
"unitId": "unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8",
"destinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"role": "addresses",
"basis": "source_excerpt_checked",
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d32",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 32,
"unitId": "unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8",
"textSha256": "495bf3f89c139f93197d0408c023a17d4b50a95a608afd0792d5e23719757667"
},
{
"localRef": "e18",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:ad556fc63a18fb1e9885e041b4dd94c6",
"paperId": "2203.07624",
"sourceSha256": "c895f9a40099e729ee94446083f8c4f98949a3c894118a104f5cb8ff37823bc7",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/91b86eb8982d9549f2b2/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "acb82ded71c09dd2953075ceed50c39e4596735012ed84fe70752130abae5077",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 0,
"end": 3000,
"textSha256": "5d13a492f0b48823ae05fd433bd8759d20fad827ff545eab98ff692709f823e7",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e19",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:af78084cf347eef98bbe97217bc94e5d",
"paperId": "2203.07624",
"sourceSha256": "c895f9a40099e729ee94446083f8c4f98949a3c894118a104f5cb8ff37823bc7",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/91b86eb8982d9549f2b2/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "acb82ded71c09dd2953075ceed50c39e4596735012ed84fe70752130abae5077",
"pdfPage": 1,
"start": 0,
"end": 1161,
"textSha256": "90600347cf36744684fa2251d16253e0168cc364c2bdee76cc7a05c7ecf92c1e",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:d3e3428668c7a8404eb654d1",
"qualification": "Original proposal qualification: A multi-target review, not one atomic question. It explicitly denies a guarantee that gravitational considerations solve the listed problems. Independent challenge qualification: Multi-target review with unresolved atomic identities. It explicitly denies a guarantee that gravitational considerations solve the listed problems.",
"scopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"browserVectorRow": 5056,
"sourceRow": 5056,
"paperId": "2203.07624",
"lens": "physical_question",
"contributionStatus": "accepted_typed_contribution",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:d3e3428668c7a8404eb654d1",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
},
"meaning": "Same scoped-question identity projection; original qualification, evidence, target version and receipt remain unchanged."
}
}
} - comparison — description_checked
Hitchhiker's Guide to the Swampland: The Cosmologist's Handbook to the String‐Theoretical Swampland Programme
Original proposal qualification: A multi-target survey of constraints and evidence; the description does not resolve its individual question identities. Independent challenge qualification: A survey spanning several cosmological targets; the description does not resolve individual question identities or certify the constraints.
Which proposed quantum-gravity consistency constraints restrict cosmological EFTs, especially models of inflation, dark energy, dark matter and black holes, and how strong is their supporting evidence?
Exact source: unit:442875576a3ec8d6d155e0eb005344e593b4a26ca063c2306fbf1a46e1c47618. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:65964fac7bb05a50ab237fed.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2509.02632","sourceSha256":"58b047c9e79b7b89db5ecba7b6a8419a7d97c18dcfa6351b79f7d8ace4afb9b7","pages":[1,2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:1b8099ddd30abc833b087e981c18ab65","source-graph:ev:3cfb385e1d86ee606a806dfada69c47d","source-graph:ev:d919e47e478f7d695619e287e23a33c4"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d37",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 37,
"unitId": "unit:442875576a3ec8d6d155e0eb005344e593b4a26ca063c2306fbf1a46e1c47618",
"textSha256": "b8a7a9ee2b6e93c5e68c6ae11a213b8cd2c15704d8171b96a9d71444aae3cb41"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:65964fac7bb05a50ab237fed",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true,
"canonicalProjection": {
"identityGroupId": "identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"identityDecisionId": "decision:whole-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"originalDestinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"originalScopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"originalDecisionId": "decision:source-contribution:65964fac7bb05a50ab237fed",
"originalObservation": {
"unitId": "unit:442875576a3ec8d6d155e0eb005344e593b4a26ca063c2306fbf1a46e1c47618",
"destinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"role": "comparison",
"basis": "description_checked",
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d37",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 37,
"unitId": "unit:442875576a3ec8d6d155e0eb005344e593b4a26ca063c2306fbf1a46e1c47618",
"textSha256": "b8a7a9ee2b6e93c5e68c6ae11a213b8cd2c15704d8171b96a9d71444aae3cb41"
}
],
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:65964fac7bb05a50ab237fed",
"qualification": "Original proposal qualification: A multi-target survey of constraints and evidence; the description does not resolve its individual question identities. Independent challenge qualification: A survey spanning several cosmological targets; the description does not resolve individual question identities or certify the constraints.",
"scopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"browserVectorRow": 6669,
"sourceRow": 6669,
"paperId": "2509.02632",
"lens": "physical_question",
"contributionStatus": "accepted_typed_contribution",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:65964fac7bb05a50ab237fed",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
},
"meaning": "Same scoped-question identity projection; original qualification, evidence, target version and receipt remain unchanged."
}
}
} - addresses — source_excerpt_checked
The String landscape and the swampland
Original proposal qualification: The outside-source label does not exclude this foundational question. Missing string constructions motivate restrictions without proving completeness. Independent challenge qualification: The outside-source label has no scientific exclusion force. Shared constructions and construction gaps provide heuristic evidence, without completeness.
Which apparently consistent low-energy theories can occur in a consistent quantum theory of gravity? The paper asks whether universal restrictions on string constructions constrain infrared physics despite the large diversity of known vacua.
Exact source: unit:d9120eb3634a9c529d1ddf1970b20cc0ff36c9f4432c47da43a8436ba09730c0. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:8565d26db99a55c471f27402.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"hep-th/0509212","sourceSha256":"a90c61c46cfa8b9f409f9e7b2d23d8dec7beb737e033e9d16269110cd9540370","pages":[2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:b3807b01bfffd1e0356fa9aa26d7ca84","source-graph:ev:c52baa225cc6fc274c41f2e1f7d2d9ec"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d41",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 41,
"unitId": "unit:d9120eb3634a9c529d1ddf1970b20cc0ff36c9f4432c47da43a8436ba09730c0",
"textSha256": "9f6fe25beb3670477dba587144c5aa4defb81cc8f231ecebded5b9d9b6055d3b"
},
{
"localRef": "e21",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:b3807b01bfffd1e0356fa9aa26d7ca84",
"paperId": "hep-th/0509212",
"sourceSha256": "a90c61c46cfa8b9f409f9e7b2d23d8dec7beb737e033e9d16269110cd9540370",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/b5fad4afdeda5519960a/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "52519084b0947930043f47e389281946a177bcfbef60dfbd223769ad85027a1d",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 0,
"end": 2710,
"textSha256": "781b6c34280bec16a4186b88657ec9a6f651ed45b0299f2027ea1725e17d22c2",
"quoteExactInPage": false,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e25",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:d8a8968d043d82d9a0269804319a9ca4",
"paperId": "hep-th/0509212",
"sourceSha256": "a90c61c46cfa8b9f409f9e7b2d23d8dec7beb737e033e9d16269110cd9540370",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/b5fad4afdeda5519960a/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "52519084b0947930043f47e389281946a177bcfbef60dfbd223769ad85027a1d",
"pdfPage": 8,
"start": 0,
"end": 2305,
"textSha256": "a3cd20e445bd7e758a62124498e4ce1593358d0b2a8d16f993b33137ef4ded7f",
"quoteExactInPage": false,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e13",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:5422d976cbcc8824b6c9a797b92f87b0",
"paperId": "hep-th/0509212",
"sourceSha256": "a90c61c46cfa8b9f409f9e7b2d23d8dec7beb737e033e9d16269110cd9540370",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/b5fad4afdeda5519960a/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "52519084b0947930043f47e389281946a177bcfbef60dfbd223769ad85027a1d",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 0,
"end": 2710,
"textSha256": "781b6c34280bec16a4186b88657ec9a6f651ed45b0299f2027ea1725e17d22c2",
"quoteExactInPage": false,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:8565d26db99a55c471f27402",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true,
"canonicalProjection": {
"identityGroupId": "identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"identityDecisionId": "decision:whole-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"originalDestinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"originalScopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"originalDecisionId": "decision:source-contribution:8565d26db99a55c471f27402",
"originalObservation": {
"unitId": "unit:d9120eb3634a9c529d1ddf1970b20cc0ff36c9f4432c47da43a8436ba09730c0",
"destinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"role": "addresses",
"basis": "source_excerpt_checked",
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d41",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 41,
"unitId": "unit:d9120eb3634a9c529d1ddf1970b20cc0ff36c9f4432c47da43a8436ba09730c0",
"textSha256": "9f6fe25beb3670477dba587144c5aa4defb81cc8f231ecebded5b9d9b6055d3b"
},
{
"localRef": "e21",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:b3807b01bfffd1e0356fa9aa26d7ca84",
"paperId": "hep-th/0509212",
"sourceSha256": "a90c61c46cfa8b9f409f9e7b2d23d8dec7beb737e033e9d16269110cd9540370",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/b5fad4afdeda5519960a/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "52519084b0947930043f47e389281946a177bcfbef60dfbd223769ad85027a1d",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 0,
"end": 2710,
"textSha256": "781b6c34280bec16a4186b88657ec9a6f651ed45b0299f2027ea1725e17d22c2",
"quoteExactInPage": false,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e25",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:d8a8968d043d82d9a0269804319a9ca4",
"paperId": "hep-th/0509212",
"sourceSha256": "a90c61c46cfa8b9f409f9e7b2d23d8dec7beb737e033e9d16269110cd9540370",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/b5fad4afdeda5519960a/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "52519084b0947930043f47e389281946a177bcfbef60dfbd223769ad85027a1d",
"pdfPage": 8,
"start": 0,
"end": 2305,
"textSha256": "a3cd20e445bd7e758a62124498e4ce1593358d0b2a8d16f993b33137ef4ded7f",
"quoteExactInPage": false,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e13",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:5422d976cbcc8824b6c9a797b92f87b0",
"paperId": "hep-th/0509212",
"sourceSha256": "a90c61c46cfa8b9f409f9e7b2d23d8dec7beb737e033e9d16269110cd9540370",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/b5fad4afdeda5519960a/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "52519084b0947930043f47e389281946a177bcfbef60dfbd223769ad85027a1d",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 0,
"end": 2710,
"textSha256": "781b6c34280bec16a4186b88657ec9a6f651ed45b0299f2027ea1725e17d22c2",
"quoteExactInPage": false,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:8565d26db99a55c471f27402",
"qualification": "Original proposal qualification: The outside-source label does not exclude this foundational question. Missing string constructions motivate restrictions without proving completeness. Independent challenge qualification: The outside-source label has no scientific exclusion force. Shared constructions and construction gaps provide heuristic evidence, without completeness.",
"scopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"browserVectorRow": 7921,
"sourceRow": 7921,
"paperId": "hep-th/0509212",
"lens": "physical_question",
"contributionStatus": "accepted_typed_contribution",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:8565d26db99a55c471f27402",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
},
"meaning": "Same scoped-question identity projection; original qualification, evidence, target version and receipt remain unchanged."
}
}
} - comparison — source_excerpt_checked
Asymptotically safe quantum gravity and its phenomenology -- a review
Original proposal qualification: Predictivity and acceptable physical-scale observables are separate targets. A contents entry does not establish a relation to Swampland criteria. Independent challenge qualification: Finite-parameter predictivity and physical-observable behavior are separate targets. The contents listing does not establish a relation to Swampland criteria.
Can quantum scale symmetry make metric quantum gravity predictive and keep physical observables well behaved at high energies? This review surveys fixed-point evidence, extensions toward realistic matter and Lorentzian signature, and possible phenomenological consequences.
Exact source: unit:53013b8e282b21e9fb96ee3d7fc714c0315064b910fa5e98233649b293116960. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:a27a6816f2e9ed96413a1e7b.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2606.21522","sourceSha256":"f479f00deaa8d5b72638195fad0605c7eacd7d4cb30b290d377d52f9858ed8d3","pages":[2,5],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:02a91358ac10765bef84898ac93328c9","source-graph:ev:a8acc2b8a7039bd6d5fda957ef04234a"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d42",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 42,
"unitId": "unit:53013b8e282b21e9fb96ee3d7fc714c0315064b910fa5e98233649b293116960",
"textSha256": "7e8000295b78cb306f998b0c2110cde2083ee5ce25ba1cc43817456a24ffdbfe"
},
{
"localRef": "e0",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:02a91358ac10765bef84898ac93328c9",
"paperId": "2606.21522",
"sourceSha256": "f479f00deaa8d5b72638195fad0605c7eacd7d4cb30b290d377d52f9858ed8d3",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/9365876c9a1fb0bd1311/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "1d6c9d010766dfcb8a36a70eb3356094fe0b4ac6f8144604ff456333adb7a9ef",
"pdfPage": 5,
"start": 1291,
"end": 4689,
"textSha256": "f2df9ecf77bc1dc8db480224a65aa1457a7e4eada384a146a370b5686a67700c",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e17",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:a8acc2b8a7039bd6d5fda957ef04234a",
"paperId": "2606.21522",
"sourceSha256": "f479f00deaa8d5b72638195fad0605c7eacd7d4cb30b290d377d52f9858ed8d3",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/9365876c9a1fb0bd1311/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "1d6c9d010766dfcb8a36a70eb3356094fe0b4ac6f8144604ff456333adb7a9ef",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 101,
"end": 3494,
"textSha256": "b1b3c2f2783d9209c8b798ab7283602658fb871f00c8d859f6a5577db368dbcb",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:a27a6816f2e9ed96413a1e7b",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true,
"canonicalProjection": {
"identityGroupId": "identity-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"identityDecisionId": "decision:whole-group:72bea1cf8ce539d05e3759b7",
"originalDestinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"originalScopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"originalDecisionId": "decision:source-contribution:a27a6816f2e9ed96413a1e7b",
"originalObservation": {
"unitId": "unit:53013b8e282b21e9fb96ee3d7fc714c0315064b910fa5e98233649b293116960",
"destinationId": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
"role": "comparison",
"basis": "source_excerpt_checked",
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d42",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 42,
"unitId": "unit:53013b8e282b21e9fb96ee3d7fc714c0315064b910fa5e98233649b293116960",
"textSha256": "7e8000295b78cb306f998b0c2110cde2083ee5ce25ba1cc43817456a24ffdbfe"
},
{
"localRef": "e0",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:02a91358ac10765bef84898ac93328c9",
"paperId": "2606.21522",
"sourceSha256": "f479f00deaa8d5b72638195fad0605c7eacd7d4cb30b290d377d52f9858ed8d3",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/9365876c9a1fb0bd1311/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "1d6c9d010766dfcb8a36a70eb3356094fe0b4ac6f8144604ff456333adb7a9ef",
"pdfPage": 5,
"start": 1291,
"end": 4689,
"textSha256": "f2df9ecf77bc1dc8db480224a65aa1457a7e4eada384a146a370b5686a67700c",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e17",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:a8acc2b8a7039bd6d5fda957ef04234a",
"paperId": "2606.21522",
"sourceSha256": "f479f00deaa8d5b72638195fad0605c7eacd7d4cb30b290d377d52f9858ed8d3",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/9365876c9a1fb0bd1311/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "1d6c9d010766dfcb8a36a70eb3356094fe0b4ac6f8144604ff456333adb7a9ef",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 101,
"end": 3494,
"textSha256": "b1b3c2f2783d9209c8b798ab7283602658fb871f00c8d859f6a5577db368dbcb",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:a27a6816f2e9ed96413a1e7b",
"qualification": "Original proposal qualification: Predictivity and acceptable physical-scale observables are separate targets. A contents entry does not establish a relation to Swampland criteria. Independent challenge qualification: Finite-parameter predictivity and physical-observable behavior are separate targets. The contents listing does not establish a relation to Swampland criteria.",
"scopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50",
"browserVectorRow": 7034,
"sourceRow": 7034,
"paperId": "2606.21522",
"lens": "physical_question",
"contributionStatus": "accepted_typed_contribution",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:a27a6816f2e9ed96413a1e7b",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
},
"meaning": "Same scoped-question identity projection; original qualification, evidence, target version and receipt remain unchanged."
}
}
} - specializes — description_checked
An Analysis of Anomaly Cancellation for Theories in D=10
Confirm the c9-to-c10 target change only for the stated completion question. The two candidates, dimension and defining premises remain unspecified; no finer identity or completion result is established. Independent confirmation: u46 explicitly asks about quantum-gravity completion, so its existing c9 specialization can be confirmed at equivalent c10. The row correctly leaves candidate definitions, dimension and premises unspecified; it asserts no completion result or finer identity.
Can the two abelian-containing polynomial candidates be completed into quantum gravity?
Exact source: unit:e8cc19c9a89ff281a022113db638ec13721d815971949b468b1de3aad633ab30. Review decision: decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:role:0.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1507.08642","sourceSha256":"728f39a5196c58473b58bf99571b4b68eb8eab92c44e995f327ed11a062b4cf5","pages":[3,7],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:e48a50955667b8eb254ad97aa73f65a9","source-graph:ev:fc34e8eaf553e571ca25b8c2e3a17eb2"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "u46",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 2,
"unitId": "unit:e8cc19c9a89ff281a022113db638ec13721d815971949b468b1de3aad633ab30",
"textSha256": "cf0705e61dc1ef4dbb61166a054a64e93ba0626680631062ff7ab4e310d93070",
"paperId": "1507.08642"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:role:0",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal",
"strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - addresses — description_checked
TASI Lectures on Remnants from the String Landscape
Confirm access through the completion question for low-energy remnants and tests of proposed restrictions. The description does not identify or independently verify the restrictions it calls established. Independent confirmation: u28 addresses low-energy tests of quantum-gravity restrictions, matching the inherited c9 contribution and c10's consistency-testing programme. The row preserves n7's limitation that the restrictions called established are neither identified nor independently verified.
Can characteristic low-energy remnants or violations of established quantum-gravity restrictions test a theory with an inaccessible fundamental scale and many possible vacua?
Exact source: unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853. Review decision: decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:role:1.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1801.03503","sourceSha256":"95e515a9ed06dd810226c2928d8558b3d52981ea0dbdd8f0d7338613cda52476","pages":[28],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:70dcce0d352658fb6570ce3d1591b7be"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "u28",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 9,
"unitId": "unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853",
"textSha256": "70666671b810a7cbb77a17ef0ab9ad3ee1e8f88209200d70d37a4cdaf70aa1d6",
"paperId": "1801.03503"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:role:1",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal",
"strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - addresses — description_checked
Emergence of Weak Coupling at Large Distance in Quantum Gravity
Confirm the infrared-diagnostic contribution at the reused completion destination. Whether quantum gravity guarantees moduli and massless towers remains a separate unresolved target, not an assumed premise. Independent confirmation: The infrared-diagnostic target in u17 addresses completion compatibility at c10 after reuse. The row correctly keeps the separate necessity of moduli and massless towers unresolved rather than importing it as a premise.
Can infrared properties of scalar fields and particle towers identify gravitational EFTs compatible with quantum gravity? A separate unresolved issue is whether quantum gravity itself guarantees moduli and towers becoming massless in large-moduli limits.
Exact source: unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893. Review decision: decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:role:2.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1802.08698","sourceSha256":"cfa54c1c9eb0267263c0f7e70c18de6c5295128b2c350e1d18c829a0333133e4","pages":[1,5],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:3f44ac55e01bc57aa950fd7368366285","source-graph:ev:bd27a5e2a15bdf12a7267688d5578665"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "u17",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 10,
"unitId": "unit:65017cb41a9b8621dda3f38dbcbe0a14c3bbb9b4a9167f24d007e0a0c0f46893",
"textSha256": "5d0a687405a4a129aa50a2e87696184884adbcb0ede13dfdfd02895d528d29fb",
"paperId": "1802.08698"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:role:2",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal",
"strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - boundary — description_checked
Sharp boundaries for the swampland
Confirm only the completion-boundary role: extending quantitative consistency methods and realizing extremal-functional spectra are distinct unresolved tasks. No physical gravitational completion follows from the suggested spectra. Independent confirmation: Only a boundary role is confirmed. u41 and n9 distinguish extending consistency methods from realizing their suggested spectra in physical gravitational theories, so neither a constructive-completion role nor a new method role at c10 is warranted.
Can the same quantitative consistency program handle general external states, loop discontinuities, infrared-safe four-dimensional scattering, and curved backgrounds? A separate issue is whether the spectra suggested by extremal functionals are realized by physical gravitational theories.
Exact source: unit:de73f67ec4106bc32b5b123c03ff84d9dd8809ade51739e0a267eb8032754c77. Review decision: decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:role:3.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2102.08951","sourceSha256":"67f497d0971d293eba97075818907d45d43fa1af3de1e3afd8ee3fbb14431b28","pages":[26],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:6f11522e1fa60bd6658a75436a24399c","source-graph:ev:f991a34bba0b11b4a8a0b52cf5c97480"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "u41",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 29,
"unitId": "unit:de73f67ec4106bc32b5b123c03ff84d9dd8809ade51739e0a267eb8032754c77",
"textSha256": "9b010bbedc64e770e4cb9ad3976ef42ab59d1ba72fb8e2cecbf4e2e31e98a34f",
"paperId": "2102.08951"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:role:3",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal",
"strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - addresses — description_checked
Snowmass White Paper: Implications of Quantum Gravity for Particle Physics
Confirm the broad consistency-review contribution at c10 while retaining the existing c0 application contribution. The review remains multi-target and explicitly offers no guarantee that gravity solves the listed particle-physics problems. Independent confirmation: u37's consistency-review contribution transfers from equivalent c9 to c10 while its separate c0 application contribution remains intact. Both mapped notes preserve the compound programme and explicitly deny guaranteed solutions to the named particle-physics problems.
Review how quantum-gravity consistency conditions constrain low-energy EFT and might inform strong CP, the weak scale, new gauge interactions and dark energy. The white paper explicitly does not guarantee that gravitational considerations solve these problems.
Exact source: unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8. Review decision: decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:role:4.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2203.07624","sourceSha256":"c895f9a40099e729ee94446083f8c4f98949a3c894118a104f5cb8ff37823bc7","pages":[1,2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:ad556fc63a18fb1e9885e041b4dd94c6","source-graph:ev:af78084cf347eef98bbe97217bc94e5d"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "u37",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 32,
"unitId": "unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8",
"textSha256": "495bf3f89c139f93197d0408c023a17d4b50a95a608afd0792d5e23719757667",
"paperId": "2203.07624"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:role:4",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal",
"strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "strong-scope-bundle-02-navigation-independent-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
}
- Consistency constraints and string realizability — narrower (outgoing recorded relation)
Necessary consistency constraints and comparison with string realizations form a restricted completion direction; apparent consistency is not completion.
Necessary consistency constraints and comparison with string realizations form a restricted completion direction; apparent consistency is not completion.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:db1f1f8a2bfa0e4543aed532; 47 source references; SHA-256 1c7df134ae28746a02676f19aae321483e9ccd1adb2ddf3b7c6acf2b76a21a62)
- Distance, towers and EFT validity — narrower (outgoing recorded relation)
Distance, light towers and EFT limitations provide a particular consistency direction without identifying different distance proposals or refinements.
Distance, light towers and EFT limitations provide a particular consistency direction whose proposals and finite-region refinements remain distinguishable.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:8af095772928e7ca8c7c04f3; 45 source references; SHA-256 6c8837df590eab563323366b1fd9376c4e9a3f9e65f26735346ad276fb7973e8)
- Test completion through distance, towers and EFT limits — narrower (outgoing recorded relation)
c2 is a concrete narrower question within c6's completion-selection program. The supplied parent candidate supports this direction.
This is one proposed consistency direction. Ordinary, refined and sharpened distance statements remain distinct; failure of a fixed EFT does not by itself rule out a completion.
Complete source and review record (navigation:v2:distance-and-emergence:pn0; 1 source references; SHA-256 b11e78d0f2892d12df08581ee111eb5384c1ef537334db75ed106de8ac6d2744)
- Framework-dependent constraints on effective theories — narrower (outgoing recorded relation)
Framework-dependent coupling, potential and symmetry restrictions focus the selection problem while leaving universality open.
Framework-dependent coupling, potential and symmetry restrictions sharpen the completion-selection problem while keeping universality open.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:8f37f4093f22da6d1eeb76f4; 26 source references; SHA-256 d819913b91225a11b12a0e73378a87a21c82cc16c31286d5c59d0daf997b9847)
- Gauge WGC formulations and their evidential limits — narrower (outgoing recorded relation)
Gauge weak-gravity proposals form a particular family of completion restrictions with distinct variants and evidential limits.
Gauge WGC formulations are a particular family of proposed completion restrictions with distinct variants and evidential limits.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:0e822d0e9c4763f8d84d6da3; 24 source references; SHA-256 799fb9b4360db6823427200fb2a34a1d65d6488352848bb1b17e8180f532c746)
- Positive-potential consistency criteria — narrower (outgoing recorded relation)
Positive-potential criteria form a specific conjectural restriction programme whose formulations and validity domains require separate assessment.
Positive-potential criteria form a particular conjectural restriction program, with alternative formulations kept distinct.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:51ab1afaf722b7bcfcaa59d0; 64 source references; SHA-256 591c6da0ab1a00c2b0def7d37ce4787a6b5dd01428d6bd59da5694c14933ca69)
- Amplitude constraints on effective interactions — method for (incoming recorded relation)
Amplitude constraints supply necessary tests relevant to completion selection under their stated assumptions; they do not establish completion sufficiency.
Retain the tested theory's spin, mass, polarization, symmetry, derivative order, normalization and pole prescription, together with analyticity, crossing, growth and infrared requirements. Positivity-only bounds and full nonlinear unitarity remain different inputs. Nongravitational bounds cannot be transferred to dynamical gravity without the required gravitational treatment. Passing an applicable inequality neither constructs a completion nor exhaustively classifies quantum gravity.
Complete source and review record (navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l6; 46 source references; SHA-256 3e1d6a34dcaabc2d2186684a8cfb930db8cf8ae850be432a4bc31f54178fbca4)
- Discharge kinematics and charged spectra — method for (incoming recorded relation)
Discharge kinematics and charged-spectrum criteria supply tests of particular proposed completion restrictions.
Universal discharge and remnant avoidance remain proposed premises where invoked, not common established requirements. Distinguish existential, lightest-state, directional, finite-charge and brane formulations. Preserve dimensions, normalizations, scalar contributions and all conserved charges of daughter states. Marginal saturation and strict emission thresholds require separate treatment. An allowed channel does not determine its rate, and no suitable state at every charge or universal WGC follows without explicit support.
Complete source and review record (navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l34; 43 source references; SHA-256 b30306dee5cb19611d12c5f5ed25584748384ca46c008cf461dfde056f4dcd2c)
- Check dynamical EFT consistency before drawing completion inferences — premise check (outgoing recorded relation)
When a completion inference relies on a dynamical EFT diagnostic, s2 asks about its consistency, validity or realizability prerequisites.
The premise check is conditional on use of the corresponding bound-state, localization, continuum, scattering or backreaction calculation. It does not make every diagnostic a universal prerequisite for every completion question. Preserve each EFT validity range, dimension and background. Free-continuum obstructions and holographic alternatives concern different regimes, and an extremal-functional spectrum need not have a demonstrated physical realization. Ordinary consistency is distinct from evidence that a UV completion exists; an instability or coupling obstruction is not automatically a universal quantum-gravity exclusion.
Complete source and review record (navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l16; 19 source references; SHA-256 ef60e41360541ed023fe4515b68191cfb692cd09f887451296bb3df0e036c528)
- Gravitational cutoffs and separated scales — related question (outgoing recorded relation)
Effective-description limits and scale separation retain different meanings of particle thresholds, species scales and gravitational cutoffs.
Effective-description limits and separated scales are relevant to completion while retaining different meanings of thresholds, species scales and cutoffs.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:bd69edfd782434faf09ba048; 25 source references; SHA-256 f2100cb27095130021fdc16d69577127b615d656f2d96731c5da32565e42d208)
- Historical development of gravitational EFT and string constraints — related question (outgoing recorded relation)
Access the historical development of the gravitational EFT viewpoint and later string constraints alongside the foundational UV-admissibility question, without treating historical interpretation as a proof of any conjecture.
Complete source and review record (navigation:placement-entry-cut03:77; 15 source references; SHA-256 43038f9501eece7194e59255a6d9163894bb957d85127dd071cc7d5278d08ca7)
- Particle-physics and cosmological implications — application of (incoming recorded relation)
The phenomenological questions apply particular completion proposals or proposed restrictions considered within s27.
The application attaches to the specified proposal or conjectural criterion, not to completion selection as a universal mechanism. Preserve each source's model, date, observational comparison and evidential status. Proposed parameter correlations do not select observed values, and review-level possibilities do not establish exclusions. No solution of strong CP, weak-scale naturalness or vacuum-energy naturalness is guaranteed, and surveyed constructions do not exhaust all possible quantum gravities.
Complete source and review record (navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l7; 27 source references; SHA-256 58866fe09e19af238fb8bd75b306af75e6040b003c48e70c296bf8fe39981953)
- Potentials, vacuum conditions and cosmological dynamics — application of (incoming recorded relation)
The completion-restriction branch of s20 applies specified proposed quantum-gravity criteria to potentials and vacua.
Only that conditional branch is an application of completion proposals. Ordinary loop calculations and cosmological dynamics remain independent contributions. Retain valid-EFT domains, background choices, potential definitions and kinetic assumptions. The gradient-or-Hessian proposal and its weaker c-prime-zero alternative are not established theorems. Neither a potential restriction nor radiative instability of a classical relation supplies a universal vacuum exclusion, a complete phenomenological fit or a classification of completions.
Complete source and review record (navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l14; 20 source references; SHA-256 28e1fd5850b63f48090016c638788859f3da078fd060dcbfa379e97d7acb6fb4)
- Predictivity in asymptotically safe gravity — comparison (outgoing recorded relation)
Asymptotic-safety predictivity is a constructive target with separate requirements for physical high-energy behavior.
Asymptotic-safety predictivity is an alternative constructive target with separate high-energy viability requirements.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:9644b325afb8b17ebc721837; 14 source references; SHA-256 754c3dd7dc2b93c3255568560a32420dc5b9d81e0e81ce30b5ec0f6dc1ab6a04)
- Propagation tests of causal consistency — method for (incoming recorded relation)
Propagation and scattering-delay tests supply conditional consistency diagnostics relevant to proposed completion restrictions.
Retain the reference cone, frequency range, background, dimensional setting, expansion validity and completion assumptions of each test. Phase velocity and the high-frequency causal diagnostic remain distinct, as do total delay, EFT correction and reference-cone subtraction. Resolvability and accessibility of the tested regime require their stated checks. A source's nonnegative-delay criterion does not prohibit every negative correction universally. Four- and five-dimensional shockwave analyses remain separate, and a single scattering test establishes neither all global causal properties nor completion sufficiency.
Complete source and review record (navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l27; 27 source references; SHA-256 1ddd7023d370a9ce0e00276bedfedb44ee3e8728e5f06545efab278294eb1a91)
- Quantum-gravity restrictions on effective theories — related question (outgoing recorded relation)
Specific symmetry, parameter, vacuum and distance restrictions retain their own applicability and dimensional checks.
Specific symmetry, parameter, vacuum and distance restrictions require their own applicability and dimensional checks.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:bd5d0dcb44a3c66c2719f43e; 21 source references; SHA-256 b7a7fe0d1dfbcb8623ed2db5ad85491707f4524d4969b78bbaad71f6a64d603f)
- Explore restrictions on inflation and particle physics — related question (outgoing recorded relation)
The completion program and the application review share an EFT-consistency target, while asking distinct selection and consequence questions.
Follow stated consistency conditions into conditional applications. Potential restrictions retain alternative gradient and Hessian branches and construction-dependent assumptions; conventional positivity bounds remain comparisons. Neither completion nor a solution to the phenomenological problems is guaranteed.
Complete source and review record (navigation:v3:strong-scope-bundle-02:pn0; 3 source references; SHA-256 e56957f57250da6ac76b624e854bc844e3f612fc018fa741af91fa140a9f0be7)
- Strength and limits of sign-based de Sitter exclusions — method for (incoming recorded relation)
Sign-based exclusion supplies one limited obstruction method relevant to completion-selection questions, so the method points toward s27.
Apply only to the supplied equation span, allowed coefficients and candidate backgrounds. Regrouping within that span does not establish optimality over additional equations, inequalities, sectors or physical correlations. The broader conclusion remains conditional on unestablished residual independence and completeness and is presented as the authors' belief. An unresolved search branch is not a no-go theorem, and this method does not classify gravitational completions generally. The bounded source context does not certify the omitted equations, normalization or derivation.
Complete source and review record (navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-00:l18; 15 source references; SHA-256 e5cc77d130a0d8ff91966766e882322755f4812b07c15d40a96c7bab39995933)
- Fields, gravity and cosmology: construction and tests — broader (incoming recorded relation)
Quantum-gravity compatibility is a conditional selection question; proposed criteria and established obstructions remain distinguishable.
Quantum-gravity compatibility is a conditional selection question, with conjectures distinguished from established obstructions.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:e82945ae3df58d69edb90d08; 18 source references; SHA-256 cdec46c8022ade61da843d5cc24f0988aa5867c2854659f13544cb52dfe87378)
- Gravitational EFTs: consistency, structure and limits — broader (incoming recorded relation)
Use completion compatibility and evidential strength as a shared entry across batches; exact equivalence with x2_0 remains a candidate.
Use the existing completion-compatibility and evidence question as a common entry across batches.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:e433dd60ac9afc2c1bdf1e6e; 17 source references; SHA-256 512fb054e37dfdf7933a5e511e54cb18d09650b6325df3a8971901fa1ca5cc05)
- Quantum fields and gravity: descriptions, dynamics and consistency — broader (incoming recorded relation)
Reuse the completion-compatibility question without identifying necessary diagnostics with sufficient completion criteria.
Reuse the existing completion-compatibility question; necessary diagnostics and established obstructions remain distinguishable.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:76ffac0286b89d9bb2150fec; 19 source references; SHA-256 6bcd3867e21e6d0b74360d1f1a6620d73a6c65d5cdb534540ba5b039d58db910)
- Charges, symmetries and force bounds — shared source access (outgoing recorded relation)
The same source question has a direct reviewed home in this scope and an admitted positive contribution to this scientific scope. The complete qualifications remain in the support certificate.
Complete source and review record (organizational-access:13e0ca0a4f17e2be726b848d; 1 source references; SHA-256 014ab1e18a3f2ae8a696f64764c1f6c508be284d860284e18136aa9416d1a4a8)
1 shared source questions across the whole scope, independent of source filters. Shared-source organizational access; witnesses are counted across the whole scope. This is not containment, equivalence, physical implication or established method applicability. Incoming browsing does not reverse a scientific claim.
Witnesses, qualifications and review decisions · Access policy
- Distances, light towers and geometric limits — shared source access (outgoing recorded relation)
The same source question has a direct reviewed home in this scope and an admitted positive contribution to this scientific scope. The complete qualifications remain in the support certificate.
Complete source and review record (organizational-access:44ba87ea512aec7d1cbb4352; 1 source references; SHA-256 02fca95238ab550c73f0b0911cbbc9861c44b4c7f991d18832cddc0b5bc2775b)
1 shared source questions across the whole scope, independent of source filters. Shared-source organizational access; witnesses are counted across the whole scope. This is not containment, equivalence, physical implication or established method applicability. Incoming browsing does not reverse a scientific claim.
Witnesses, qualifications and review decisions · Access policy
- Gravitational EFTs: completion, validity and low-energy consequences — shared source access (incoming recorded relation)
The same source question has a direct reviewed home in this scope and an admitted positive contribution to this scientific scope. The complete qualifications remain in the support certificate.
Complete source and review record (organizational-access:324d12c75881d03c188a884f; 5 source references; SHA-256 8e2ca6518da13f5e791fcad6f14210d72fdb81c11ed3bbd777b6edd297c837a8)
5 shared source questions across the whole scope, independent of source filters. Shared-source organizational access; witnesses are counted across the whole scope. This is not containment, equivalence, physical implication or established method applicability. Incoming browsing does not reverse a scientific claim.
Witnesses, qualifications and review decisions · Access policy
- Quantum-gravity restrictions on low-energy EFT — shared source access (incoming recorded relation)
The same source question has a direct reviewed home in this scope and an admitted positive contribution to this scientific scope. The complete qualifications remain in the support certificate.
Complete source and review record (organizational-access:da827a514c49b788e17b5c55; 1 source references; SHA-256 ad192e23365dcf356fc72e1447d5c04b3193e7b68c33b7a4a33113ea5b437d52)
1 shared source questions across the whole scope, independent of source filters. Shared-source organizational access; witnesses are counted across the whole scope. This is not containment, equivalence, physical implication or established method applicability. Incoming browsing does not reverse a scientific claim.
Witnesses, qualifications and review decisions · Access policy
- Realization, enhancement and ultraviolet completion — shared source access (incoming recorded relation)
The same source question has a direct reviewed home in this scope and an admitted positive contribution to this scientific scope. The complete qualifications remain in the support certificate.
Complete source and review record (organizational-access:083eb20ead4bed659b0906ad; 1 source references; SHA-256 aa67d3a841df93ef7b4645273158fbf739b5457ebab7f0879bce1baed6058fc6)
1 shared source questions across the whole scope, independent of source filters. Shared-source organizational access; witnesses are counted across the whole scope. This is not containment, equivalence, physical implication or established method applicability. Incoming browsing does not reverse a scientific claim.
Witnesses, qualifications and review decisions · Access policy
- Scalar constraints and EFT validity in quantum gravity — shared source access (incoming recorded relation)
The same source question has a direct reviewed home in this scope and an admitted positive contribution to this scientific scope. The complete qualifications remain in the support certificate.
Complete source and review record (organizational-access:e1f9620502fb92ce5f43a5b2; 1 source references; SHA-256 ff76c53e99c29238a642a13c2f9114fdac368514c711be2505d46c2d93b7f00c)
1 shared source questions across the whole scope, independent of source filters. Shared-source organizational access; witnesses are counted across the whole scope. This is not containment, equivalence, physical implication or established method applicability. Incoming browsing does not reverse a scientific claim.
Witnesses, qualifications and review decisions · Access policy
- Can a quantum-gravity bound expose artificial removal of a source that should drive spacetime evolution? The proposed test follows charged objects away from a supersymmetric vacuum while examining the modified background equations. — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:d556214b79c44e14ba7633d0; 1 source references; SHA-256 5d4d6d46ad3e591acfddc5456c800da1333a982b30e7c8e1bc6439b8516eca2f)
- Can the interface between quantum-gravity-compatible theories and incompatible effective theories be identified as a distinct region? The Marshland conjecture names such an interface inside the landscape. — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:2512fc6dde34ec7afad86d20; 1 source references; SHA-256 a61d434a27047d34cebb781b34bb01205a2383de60d192de302608b71adce706)
- Can the large-D limit of an apparently consistent gravity effective theory belong to quantum gravity? The paper asks whether known conjectures remain restrictive and whether dimension-dependent tower masses suggest additional restrictions. — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:5750c92723a54ff1d303d4e3; 1 source references; SHA-256 04beb429b2e791dffa98024f5284dd2d3eab0c29bcb8a9511d5b505b4c5385ce)
- Can the two abelian-containing polynomial candidates be completed into quantum gravity? — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:b595d1b45a6e45e83a3c613b; 1 source references; SHA-256 10f27f68becc554c8716b43fe14fa46bf97f68efd716104fae3f272d09e83212)
- Could quantum-gravity consistency require charged sources that also modify the compactification obstruction? — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:59335cd80cbfd9065c9898ef; 1 source references; SHA-256 3fa7a38df7b33791eb96db8d085842c15521efb0ed5a469a34e4a9b0c738eb42)
- Which apparently consistent effective field theories admit an ultraviolet completion including quantum gravity? The Swampland denotes those that fail this requirement; the Landscape denotes the string-realizable subset discussed in the review. — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:d4e6a7f996e6c55a793b0a18; 1 source references; SHA-256 f24c6069919f35fb6fa0c7d8e694207eb95916f1554a7de87e56dd16d84f511f)
- Which apparently consistent effective theories can admit a UV completion with dynamical gravity? The lectures formulate this as distinguishing the string landscape from the Swampland. — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:0c3df7e2b36ef0d440620307; 1 source references; SHA-256 bbb0f797130cfe3d737b9cafb5916209b48db1d17a6871baad99343cca0f45bf)
- Which apparently consistent low-energy effective field theories admit ultraviolet completion into quantum gravity, and what constraints distinguish the Landscape from the Swampland? — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:9d3e6345e0a0f28d95d089ba; 1 source references; SHA-256 30142c4e782636eb0174a68e2c1012c0dec8a01abe52ceb15055773eed66a8b7)
- Which apparently consistent low-energy theories admit a quantum-gravity embedding? The landscape/swampland distinction organizes this embedding question; this paper adopts it as background for a proposed boundary region. — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:fa439b29fbd5a664af865271; 1 source references; SHA-256 21ff27f6280643a958919aea5d11764aebfc0137d6f0909fe5281f131306f90c)
- Which apparently consistent low-energy theories can occur in a consistent quantum theory of gravity? The paper asks whether universal restrictions on string constructions constrain infrared physics despite the large diversity of known vacua. — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:f2207d9187cf80081c537d61; 1 source references; SHA-256 f9dbbf3dbfb36bbf10fa7110ea361546cf5c25025b843fc6ea9071ee4a006df3)
- Which conjectured quantum-gravity constraints can be tested by a controlled compactification limit with a weak gauge interaction and finite gravitational coupling? — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:ad79f06994a5b1f6e7cccd67; 1 source references; SHA-256 71a82ba484e935f396b43ab5d6535455186cb8996107c571446c65df5b88fa87)
- Which effective field theories can consistently couple to quantum gravity, and how do worldsheet consistency, compactifications, dualities and black holes motivate criteria separating the landscape from the Swampland? These are pedagogical review lectures. — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:ac1389929104eb787cb98636; 1 source references; SHA-256 2ec60717b3f6342ab368d3923242f6714fea37acc9fec243bc7811037e00d840)
- Which low-energy effective field theories can admit a consistent ultraviolet completion in quantum gravity? The paper adopts the landscape/swampland terminology as the setting for a different question about the information required to formulate conjectures. — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:0690790c9de43150fc040ac5; 1 source references; SHA-256 71c334bcf8a81647de06d5298a05ec05e90901352786d309a470e5ba1d3d36d4)
- Which low-energy effective field theories can arise from quantum gravity? The landscape contains theories admitting a gravitational UV completion; the swampland contains those that do not. Proposed necessary conditions can exclude candidates without constructing their UV completions. — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:2565f317286a02003bf642ed; 1 source references; SHA-256 e8d1b606a8aa9e7a964f78d6952e8b1be93146d34b59350be1073be027e19afc)
- The String Landscape, the Swampland, and the Missing Corner
Which apparently consistent effective theories can admit a UV completion with dynamical gravity? The lectures formulate this as distinguishing the string landscape from the Swampland.
Source ID: unit:0ef0bdcb0b0fad8ba06989de6999e721580b9184b89b5cc06b35c8591bebffee
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1711.00864","sourceSha256":"9c2d1ad12cb4fc40eb91db217fb97dc546ef187bffe8951bedccfba66527361c","pages":[21],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:986256c90a9716d80f6a834e40439369","source-graph:ev:9ce0a516fee87cc2a4aae3c628aac80e"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- The Marshland Conjecture
Can the interface between quantum-gravity-compatible theories and incompatible effective theories be identified as a distinct region? The Marshland conjecture names such an interface inside the landscape.
Source ID: unit:1b9fd945cd921ca5d8765f7148014fe3f0f140e12b5770ed8b75b6cae7e812af
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1903.12643","sourceSha256":"fec41340c2bc82d80a20f0fe3d94a616ec588eca17acbed01c23f6e2927be9d3","pages":[1],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:23babcc87befe12f9fe47a6e39ff1dbf","source-graph:ev:949c519adacaa3ef6b8a4266c7d65588"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- Lectures on the string landscape and the Swampland
Which effective field theories can consistently couple to quantum gravity, and how do worldsheet consistency, compactifications, dualities and black holes motivate criteria separating the landscape from the Swampland? These are pedagogical review lectures.
Source ID: unit:368ca444bac27952d057063f41e5e110f0aa1e0e5acbb9369fe02764118931fe
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2212.06187","sourceSha256":"18172df5807d5489763ae2dd86c9e367c30d5bd9bef7d60e4bc98fcb917b60af","pages":[1,5],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:cc5848d7e5ffb8fb067006df7c0998b6","source-graph:ev:d1ac9f56c79182e8bbd6620c0ad46f0a","source-graph:ev:e871acf8a97a922ac655a3494266b385"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- Swampland Revisited
How should swampland conjectures distinguish effective theories admitting ultraviolet quantum-gravity completion, and how justified is excluding de Sitter vacua given cosmological observations and disputed string constructions?
Source ID: unit:62a77fabcb27ea6a325981c5177bc34725989588a3c3dd425a181d19c0355bfe
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2301.03464","sourceSha256":"fe36ce896dde2dea08f2e0bf26040167eecec0c358a95827c1393e4610dc2e4b","pages":[2,6,10],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:75ecd69d41298aeb8e08ff1fadcf2bbd","source-graph:ev:b84b5e43dff05a10dabdc32c7054a241","source-graph:ev:c22a7a5391de06ddb449c8a9593540ec"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- The Swampland: Introduction and Review
Which apparently consistent effective field theories admit an ultraviolet completion including quantum gravity? The Swampland denotes those that fail this requirement; the Landscape denotes the string-realizable subset discussed in the review.
Source ID: unit:7d7148663011ec95f0a8732700970db8330bbfba4a2973d9daa9890faa32efbe
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1903.06239","sourceSha256":"537c19268752f24ceb13db5e2f9169fe757db435e51447d3700a81f289702617","pages":[5,6],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:28df4ef41d35c0960f38c7889dce589e","source-graph:ev:fce9a32c3a94d74e0441be90ce95a615"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- The Swampland Conjecture Bound Conjecture
Which low-energy effective field theories can admit a consistent ultraviolet completion in quantum gravity? The paper adopts the landscape/swampland terminology as the setting for a different question about the information required to formulate conjectures.
Source ID: unit:9811f92308a6610dceaeff2848764915aa8b7a8a7c3d09ab53f5d0860d03b917
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2103.16583","sourceSha256":"c59424d210ce64da47497d979cdda9bcd7b2720b52fc56099af4fb4ad2907047","pages":[2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:f883c17aabba67ea08ffc274226059f7"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- The zoo plot meets the swampland: mutual (in)consistency of single-field inflation, string conjectures, and cosmological data
Which proposed restrictions distinguish scalar effective theories admitting quantum-gravity completion from theories in the swampland?
Source ID: unit:b47f537459c6e8454d9e9830c71fb1324200fcc065c9d5285969306e185d38dd
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1808.06424","sourceSha256":"1baa02a3eaf6cb17eb607bfb2291efdd85f22233d4f82dde94ca7b93e27a9d32","pages":[1,2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:9379bdc5cdb6339ec9e5e063611ea5d5","source-graph:ev:e95e266e596e5712d9f787955da08c8f"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- From Swampland to Phenomenology and Back
Which low-energy effective field theories can arise from quantum gravity? The landscape contains theories admitting a gravitational UV completion; the swampland contains those that do not. Proposed necessary conditions can exclude candidates without constructing their UV completions.
Source ID: unit:b99b4445867c30d891b660afbf320832b9a94828b1307d61745976dc13f9643d
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1904.05357","sourceSha256":"1df96a4948cf416824a9d118d6a06f2e08b85debea64db23d9aa4aa4b17f7632","pages":[1,2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:06975b4650b39584f09b0ff1a4b938e6","source-graph:ev:f9223d5925131e0a20435104abf88e4f"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- The Swampland: Introduction and Review
Which apparently consistent low-energy effective field theories admit ultraviolet completion into quantum gravity, and what constraints distinguish the Landscape from the Swampland?
Source ID: unit:c8ff7d877113e695a54a7c79f6f80f42455669614b76098919f65d31bfac7b63
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1903.06239","sourceSha256":"537c19268752f24ceb13db5e2f9169fe757db435e51447d3700a81f289702617","pages":[1,5],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:64e4742443f14d89d3206d62b9820d04","source-graph:ev:ea4ec1179a2ff7ad72ec549209326fb3"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- The Swampland: Introduction and Review
How can quantum gravity constrain an effective theory below its apparent cutoff? A Swampland scale indicates when modification becomes necessary for eventual completion, even when no immediate inconsistency occurs at that energy.
Source ID: unit:cbb701371bfff8799687b11c7e2ae173eb77790e8695364fc0d41555c86df4ac
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1903.06239","sourceSha256":"537c19268752f24ceb13db5e2f9169fe757db435e51447d3700a81f289702617","pages":[7,9],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:57159ca0b178d6da0e44a8390ce37d66","source-graph:ev:a4da2c1198d21b35204a92757cbada38"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- Lectures in quantum gravity
What low-energy framework and consistency tests should quantum-gravity UV completions recover, and what can semiclassical black holes teach before a full completion is known?
Source ID: unit:d35022b6a8dfe8bbd4ec64a54e2cc5a8ff10dbe3353ec702f8c02fc71a2cb774
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2412.08690","sourceSha256":"e835003f384a35433fa947c83beef78951cedaf20d20c6c2d4465c10aef3bcdb","pages":[263],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:758db436266b95d0b705a8093ae836f2","source-graph:ev:8cfa6f1d61f4c60ac502fbe92ce68191","source-graph:ev:f2ae2f742d4052c29a89833a7269f55c"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- The String landscape and the swampland
Which apparently consistent low-energy theories can occur in a consistent quantum theory of gravity? The paper asks whether universal restrictions on string constructions constrain infrared physics despite the large diversity of known vacua.
Source ID: unit:d9120eb3634a9c529d1ddf1970b20cc0ff36c9f4432c47da43a8436ba09730c0
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"hep-th/0509212","sourceSha256":"a90c61c46cfa8b9f409f9e7b2d23d8dec7beb737e033e9d16269110cd9540370","pages":[2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:b3807b01bfffd1e0356fa9aa26d7ca84","source-graph:ev:c52baa225cc6fc274c41f2e1f7d2d9ec"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- The anomaly that was not meant IIB
Do the alternative anomaly-free realizations admit quantum-gravity completions, or do further consistency conditions place them in the Swampland?
Source ID: unit:f041f13ddca46a67c6849f15355843692998218e9db2938c6eff227780d46717
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2107.14227","sourceSha256":"f8f8f5ea64380ea11a5301322ea01eb92c771a9ef026d0d7a453afe895cdeba5","pages":[6],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:2cff2c1588adfa3ed343ab990beb806e","source-graph:ev:33c07025b7c36e4e826ae027cda55b27"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- The Marshland Conjecture
Which apparently consistent low-energy theories admit a quantum-gravity embedding? The landscape/swampland distinction organizes this embedding question; this paper adopts it as background for a proposed boundary region.
Source ID: unit:f3643c56fa60f6e2142f51f5703a88d8debb8b2e7affa92a2de22e28581af2c2
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1903.12643","sourceSha256":"fec41340c2bc82d80a20f0fe3d94a616ec588eca17acbed01c23f6e2927be9d3","pages":[1],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:411d781dd93c059164d639fecd5e647f","source-graph:ev:6a55af85f5923c3c494f0cc92a31dcc8"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Scientific status: source_reviewed_scope_with_explicit_limits. Placement: reviewed_scope_and_placements.
Listed sources support this record; they do not claim exhaustive literature coverage. Versioned data manifest