Swampland collection

Which EFTs admit gravitational UV completion?

Which apparently consistent low-energy effective theories admit a UV completion with dynamical gravity, and which proposed necessary conditions help distinguish them?

A shared compatibility question connects foundational discussions and reviews. Definitions, conjectural exclusions and constructive completion are different contributions.

Open this destination in SwampWiki

Scope

systems

targets

regimes

assumptions

conventions

includes

excludes

Methods and reading coverage

Semiclassical black-hole reasoning; String examples and compactifications; Testing further examples, mutual consistency and phenomenological compatibility

14 extracted descriptions checked; 6 source excerpts checked.

Primary support includes the review dated 19 June 2019 and proceedings version dated 30 July 2019. Other formulations remain description-level. These excerpts establish the program and its limitations, not a complete classification.

Full reading coverage record
{
  "descriptionCheckedCount": 14,
  "excerptCheckedCount": 6,
  "readingLimit": "Primary support includes the review dated 19 June 2019 and proceedings version dated 30 July 2019. Other formulations remain description-level. These excerpts establish the program and its limitations, not a complete classification.",
  "sourceReadingScope": "Pinned paired source reviews; counted excerpts are only same-source primary windows explicitly shared by both reviewers. No full-paper/proof verification is inferred.",
  "inheritedParentCoverage": null
}
Earlier reviewed definitions and reading limits

These formulations share an accepted scoped-question destination; underlying source statements are not equated.

Selecting EFTs compatible with quantum gravity

Which apparently consistent gravitational EFTs admit quantum-gravity completion, and what evidence can distinguish candidate restrictions from established obstructions?

A common selection problem accommodates conjectural restrictions, controlled examples and unresolved completion questions. Evidence from known constructions does not classify every possible quantum gravity.

{
  "id": "q025-candidate-question:a4f67137d6a4a477cc097c6a",
  "scope": {
    "systems": [
      "Low-energy theories coupled to gravity",
      "Known string, M-theory and F-theory constructions"
    ],
    "targets": [
      "Completion compatibility",
      "Relations among apparently independent EFT parameters",
      "Strength and limitations of proposed consistency evidence"
    ],
    "regimes": [
      "Source-specific dimensions and matter content"
    ],
    "assumptions": [
      "Semiclassical consistency and quantum-gravitational completion are separate requirements"
    ],
    "conventions": [
      "A conjectural criterion, a failure to construct a model and a proved obstruction remain distinct"
    ],
    "includes": [
      "Foundational, review and model-specific questions"
    ],
    "excludes": [
      "Identification of every consistent quantum gravity with the constructions surveyed"
    ]
  },
  "scientificStatus": "source_reviewed_scope_with_explicit_limits",
  "readingCoverage": {
    "descriptionCheckedCount": 14,
    "excerptCheckedCount": 4,
    "readingLimit": "The foundational excerpts present heuristic restrictions, not an exhaustive classification. Several model-specific entries have descriptions only.",
    "sourceReadingScope": "Exact paired descriptions and same own-paper primary windows. Representative broad membership supports scope only; no source home or proof verification is inferred.",
    "inheritedParentCoverage": null
  },
  "scopeContentSha256": "b3bb9a1ebbd3bde977ca4596d60d79c76ed658ac7f508b38dcc836602f200d50"
}
Which EFTs admit gravitational UV completion?

Which apparently consistent low-energy effective theories admit a UV completion with dynamical gravity, and which proposed necessary conditions help distinguish them?

A shared compatibility question connects foundational discussions and reviews. Definitions, conjectural exclusions and constructive completion are different contributions.

{
  "id": "q025-candidate-question:b6a72d6d11c8f9c783284067",
  "scope": {
    "systems": [
      "Apparently consistent low-energy EFTs with gravity"
    ],
    "targets": [
      "Gravitational UV admissibility",
      "Candidate necessary conditions",
      "Landscape and Swampland terminology"
    ],
    "regimes": [
      "No fixed dimension, compactification or cosmological background"
    ],
    "assumptions": [
      "A proposed necessary condition is not a sufficient completion criterion",
      "Universality is an intended target, not an established consequence of examples"
    ],
    "conventions": [
      "String-realizable and generally gravitationally completable classes are not silently identified",
      "Background definitions and humorous summaries are not new classification results"
    ],
    "includes": [
      "Foundational and pedagogical formulations",
      "A proposed boundary region as contextual exploration"
    ],
    "excludes": [
      "An established geometric boundary or complete decision procedure"
    ]
  },
  "scientificStatus": "source_reviewed_scope_with_explicit_limits",
  "readingCoverage": {
    "descriptionCheckedCount": 14,
    "excerptCheckedCount": 6,
    "readingLimit": "Primary support includes the review dated 19 June 2019 and proceedings version dated 30 July 2019. Other formulations remain description-level. These excerpts establish the program and its limitations, not a complete classification.",
    "sourceReadingScope": "Pinned paired source reviews; counted excerpts are only same-source primary windows explicitly shared by both reviewers. No full-paper/proof verification is inferred.",
    "inheritedParentCoverage": null
  },
  "scopeContentSha256": "b1c128ffba092c3b3cc2b6a59cbb1bafc316bbf6e2b365c5f8e16110418020fd"
}

Source contributions (25; 31 review observations)

Separately admitted review observations are retained for each source-and-role relationship. These reviewed roles are separate from source membership. A shared source does not establish question equivalence; a method contribution does not certify applicability.

Connections

Listed sources

Scientific status: source_reviewed_scope_with_explicit_limits. Placement: reviewed_scope_and_placements.

Listed sources support this record; they do not claim exhaustive literature coverage. Versioned data manifest