{"kind":"eigenquestions-relation-details","schemaVersion":"1.0.0","relations":{"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l2":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l2","source":"q025-candidate-question:6d77b611eb7f62b294df42c8","target":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259","type":"application_of","title":"Trace duality-defect requirements to background completion","rationale":"Specified duality backgrounds apply the conditional completion program to concrete defect requirements. The applied question is s19, so the original application direction is reversed.","qualification":"Defect requirements depend on the chosen background structure and conjectural completion principle. Abelianized bordism charges do not reconstruct full non-Abelian monodromy, and reflections, fermionic lifts, exchange data and higher-degree sectors remain distinct. The supplied U-duality ranges remain k=1 with 3≤D≤11 and 1≤k≤7 at D=8. Neither completion arguments nor these requirements determine a unique stable microscopic core or settle anomaly-compatible worldvolume choices.","evidenceIds":["unit:064b7795efc4138b39aad15c1bf22b7af51cdffb4c9791597112dcf3dc6a5185","unit:16792d86625c31739156ba8e32df771e8e658f6ceeb7505d500fc9b52a4284f8","unit:1871e0b76f84078a00be7f328c49e040fab6590092cf12f960c1947de43ddcbe","unit:1b0f416b6bbd866123474c0872863b3947a775c926dadc5f7abf428776c87553","unit:336a7539b0a7e7525b52210b15fdd37c022defaa2422a3ee7e13cc06696078d8","unit:454704c3f34c893b8b19a12a9f81687f962d4e5aaf6cccf6cd2424e5c9544b64","unit:4d032b44a2c2229c38c902dad4f7278781769872ff7d7ad4c906407292f185f5","unit:59c2bd3860d5013d1fe5ef350cdaddf7f1d53e9b7e2eda80c223496b03871aee","unit:7015ca76b63c91fc93495b3956eb0f269680540f0f91c1ba2d6a6f015ca19d89","unit:76eb30453bf0c8cfcd407e0bb41a8c2a15377fc1445fe4b022e402c1a0a5930b","unit:773638d284370f4ac5ada564d5f1410c02e2fddfb6550b1636db64636030f5be","unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","unit:87106b30338595709fd06d561e01f7fecd8bd121ff392e779ba8512bc18c632a","unit:8910f715e4ea72097e152c589ce2936a25c2e753ae13b506bc48d73d58644c8e","unit:8eb105f66790c381743963e5e98d2fffb2edf71684a2c57d014003272fbf423c","unit:aea7225648815b38046d03d104235c7188002026ed4cba764a175e814e1682f1","unit:c96b2a1e716750bd9f96efc5cd21642abb91bdc75744e27e6d4da61cf83db09c","unit:cc3ffc09d129de590e8523844fef16ab9cb34e8dd461777666c5ea7c1c14d80b","unit:e2fae9982289912e7be9c1c346f6a71c68c7087103a959798b132e41f7061423"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6d77b611eb7f62b294df42c8","scopeContentSha256":"018abedc0a4d19928773ed7c3dc689875d4303f94505a494485008f1bfc9fbd9","localRef":"s19"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259","scopeContentSha256":"d5e38e3210f4c6470c46f05705502e3eac55d65af02bef909f8451000a16a2ca","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l2","originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:41","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l2","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:41","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:6d77b611eb7f62b294df42c8","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l2","source":"s22","target":"s19","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Specified duality backgrounds make conditional defect requirements more concrete without fixing unique microscopic cores."],"challengeStatement":"Specified duality backgrounds give conditional defect requirements without determining unique stable microscopic cores.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"21496eadb83bfd89726e6068cb313c4459eb02b5c7319e3a443ecef8270fff51","reply.jsonSha256":"2b13522cde089dccca6ad5a606e861ba63c324f568607e4c375a0cc4bb41db20","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c36a6e5deffe73ebc0b1e16be7efeacce3b5a91518427e213f2adceb5abec192","receipt.jsonSha256":"1ac3619b922316ab9daed0b834a08152271b89bff3673ca6a536ac321cd7466f","normalization.jsonSha256":"34b6a384ae3212b9f12a1af0a4c8b1577afc8d9d2f9c6739f7b3e4d4e90d2e8a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f23d8110109e2321e451a757253617422655ce2cba84255be89203e01dad788"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"44719832235d537d40d8c3f9fde7ff9934aad947d84f431af08131529e35cace","reply.jsonSha256":"ba3566417aebc92a1caeed4499b097fe44f303e7c53fb9665b12679327751a5b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ad4fdae6bffbb728f2978451b9900b4b2db3bee70853770a6186005751e27323","receipt.jsonSha256":"97a00e5fe99821077fd249a980950dbc16461262f4d8c9f2bca8b01c4a37abd0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7a8af76f3c278360ec57798a76e3899c73d387ea4d4b3a0d9d7a02a5e66f129a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259"},{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6d77b611eb7f62b294df42c8"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259"},{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6d77b611eb7f62b294df42c8"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d2","originalRef":"l2","status":"route","source":"s19","target":"s22","type":"application_of","title":"Trace duality-defect requirements to background completion","rationale":"Specified duality backgrounds apply the conditional completion program to concrete defect requirements. The applied question is s19, so the original application direction is reversed.","qualification":"Defect requirements depend on the chosen background structure and conjectural completion principle. Abelianized bordism charges do not reconstruct full non-Abelian monodromy, and reflections, fermionic lifts, exchange data and higher-degree sectors remain distinct. The supplied U-duality ranges remain k=1 with 3≤D≤11 and 1≤k≤7 at D=8. Neither completion arguments nor these requirements determine a unique stable microscopic core or settle anomaly-compatible worldvolume choices.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l2","s19","s22"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Specified duality backgrounds apply the conditional completion program to defect requirements, supporting application_of from s19 to s22. The record preserves the stated calculation ranges and distinctions among bordism charges, full monodromies and microscopic stability.","refs":["l2","s19","s22"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l3":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l3","source":"q025-candidate-question:c735fce66dd185eb495f29c6","target":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259","type":"application_of","title":"Examine the completion program behind dynamical endings","rationale":"Both statements present particular dynamical endings and compactification configurations as candidate realizations of admissible completion processes. This places the applied question at s27 and the underlying completion program at s22.","qualification":"The application concerns the specified configurations and their proposed completion interpretation. Spatial and timelike backgrounds, scalar contents, causal types and theory-dependent admissibility criteria remain separate. A singular solution does not identify an endpoint defect or microscopic completion. Possible tachyon-condensation descriptions and additional defects beyond cohomological tadpole cancellation remain conditional proposals. Neither a universal local description nor termination or uniqueness of background refinement is established.","evidenceIds":["unit:064b7795efc4138b39aad15c1bf22b7af51cdffb4c9791597112dcf3dc6a5185","unit:1b0f416b6bbd866123474c0872863b3947a775c926dadc5f7abf428776c87553","unit:1bf8762fef1b96afedf1db30388bf36d255a141530b462de6ecc24d400b8ec8d","unit:1d5ad275cca2de22abd18bcf876837ae1621775e3c001204603d7f7749151c64","unit:336a7539b0a7e7525b52210b15fdd37c022defaa2422a3ee7e13cc06696078d8","unit:454704c3f34c893b8b19a12a9f81687f962d4e5aaf6cccf6cd2424e5c9544b64","unit:4e41975077696b9111b99bb7665daebca9ae75ae68ac5e1d5fa1885f210a97eb","unit:67fd329a2a19edaa08603f477fcf702e1d15359c9f3e5ae938dd9cad948372f0","unit:7b750ced48ac0f62b42026fc710fb68446574c8aeab1d9bf9fb29d3c7584355a","unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","unit:7f67c5063c95dec1ded64e9ca45cb48d4f8acdd2f60508ddd371ac2dc93dbf3f","unit:8910f715e4ea72097e152c589ce2936a25c2e753ae13b506bc48d73d58644c8e","unit:8eb105f66790c381743963e5e98d2fffb2edf71684a2c57d014003272fbf423c","unit:9c8fbd219dc602cb2f68836d4aa204ce7650f4c184a0c4e0c4226f3152b5d9fe","unit:adf0169aa27472e7e4e28781d7dcb939e70e09f51700007bd08ab3ab22f30b5d","unit:cc514f73deef8694495ba2f009ce6311644ad4ae33b151cb448f35ec9f757551","unit:d7e3f6e663b166346685812b0680fd4bc0f6f06e001431efd5f05eddc62e3a39","unit:e30ab6117d8c33fa671a4def995a59f15dc1eb97df95e432a51383fbc6d38013","unit:edbe1a01e4355c116165627860249bb4010b0aa379f3f6b20a94eb794e9ac705"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c735fce66dd185eb495f29c6","scopeContentSha256":"32efa9bf2d92a8dbe645ad00001b553ae6030876ba5f47104107dd121d0b8cb7","localRef":"s27"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259","scopeContentSha256":"d5e38e3210f4c6470c46f05705502e3eac55d65af02bef909f8451000a16a2ca","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l3","originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:42","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l3","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:42","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:c735fce66dd185eb495f29c6","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l3","source":"s22","target":"s27","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Dynamical endings and compactification ask whether particular field configurations realize admissible completion processes."],"challengeStatement":"Dynamical endings and compactification ask whether specified field configurations realize admissible completion processes.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"21496eadb83bfd89726e6068cb313c4459eb02b5c7319e3a443ecef8270fff51","reply.jsonSha256":"2b13522cde089dccca6ad5a606e861ba63c324f568607e4c375a0cc4bb41db20","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c36a6e5deffe73ebc0b1e16be7efeacce3b5a91518427e213f2adceb5abec192","receipt.jsonSha256":"1ac3619b922316ab9daed0b834a08152271b89bff3673ca6a536ac321cd7466f","normalization.jsonSha256":"34b6a384ae3212b9f12a1af0a4c8b1577afc8d9d2f9c6739f7b3e4d4e90d2e8a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f23d8110109e2321e451a757253617422655ce2cba84255be89203e01dad788"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"44719832235d537d40d8c3f9fde7ff9934aad947d84f431af08131529e35cace","reply.jsonSha256":"ba3566417aebc92a1caeed4499b097fe44f303e7c53fb9665b12679327751a5b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ad4fdae6bffbb728f2978451b9900b4b2db3bee70853770a6186005751e27323","receipt.jsonSha256":"97a00e5fe99821077fd249a980950dbc16461262f4d8c9f2bca8b01c4a37abd0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7a8af76f3c278360ec57798a76e3899c73d387ea4d4b3a0d9d7a02a5e66f129a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259"},{"ref":"x4_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c735fce66dd185eb495f29c6"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259"},{"ref":"x4_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c735fce66dd185eb495f29c6"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d3","originalRef":"l3","status":"route","source":"s27","target":"s22","type":"application_of","title":"Examine the completion program behind dynamical endings","rationale":"Both statements present particular dynamical endings and compactification configurations as candidate realizations of admissible completion processes. This places the applied question at s27 and the underlying completion program at s22.","qualification":"The application concerns the specified configurations and their proposed completion interpretation. Spatial and timelike backgrounds, scalar contents, causal types and theory-dependent admissibility criteria remain separate. A singular solution does not identify an endpoint defect or microscopic completion. Possible tachyon-condensation descriptions and additional defects beyond cohomological tadpole cancellation remain conditional proposals. Neither a universal local description nor termination or uniqueness of background refinement is established.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l3","s27","s22"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements identify specified dynamical configurations as candidate realizations of completion processes. The reversed application direction is justified, while the qualification keeps their interpretation conditional and preserves differences in backgrounds, causal types and microscopic completion.","refs":["l3","s27","s22"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l4":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l4","source":"q025-candidate-question:228c5e54dcf9c025bf961506","target":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259","type":"application_of","title":"Trace microscopic defect realization to completion requirements","rationale":"Microscopic realization of completion-required defects applies the conditional completion program while testing dynamical content that its topological arguments leave open. This supports reversing the application direction without deriving stability or tension results from completion.","qualification":"The application is limited to realizing defects motivated by the specified completion requirements. Their cores, worldvolume physics, charges, stability and tensions require separate analysis. The elementary-constituent tension bound remains conjectural and concerns suitable elementary generators in object-dependent regions of EFT field space, not arbitrary charged stacks or every field-space point. Horizon-bearing black-brane evidence does not determine intrinsic tensions of proposed horizon-free generators; torsion-charge cases retain their stated lack of a classical extremal-black-hole comparison. No fixed numerical coefficient or universal stability follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:064b7795efc4138b39aad15c1bf22b7af51cdffb4c9791597112dcf3dc6a5185","unit:0db021ee058874e71b8c600cb8cb357a2ac99715cfe785e0032f77bb335091c9","unit:1b0f416b6bbd866123474c0872863b3947a775c926dadc5f7abf428776c87553","unit:26449dacc67921d19ab9228ed20ef9c037ad02b6bdedb1653fa0bfc5d2d1e627","unit:336a7539b0a7e7525b52210b15fdd37c022defaa2422a3ee7e13cc06696078d8","unit:454704c3f34c893b8b19a12a9f81687f962d4e5aaf6cccf6cd2424e5c9544b64","unit:4d032b44a2c2229c38c902dad4f7278781769872ff7d7ad4c906407292f185f5","unit:59c2bd3860d5013d1fe5ef350cdaddf7f1d53e9b7e2eda80c223496b03871aee","unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","unit:87106b30338595709fd06d561e01f7fecd8bd121ff392e779ba8512bc18c632a","unit:8910f715e4ea72097e152c589ce2936a25c2e753ae13b506bc48d73d58644c8e","unit:8eb105f66790c381743963e5e98d2fffb2edf71684a2c57d014003272fbf423c","unit:9c8fbd219dc602cb2f68836d4aa204ce7650f4c184a0c4e0c4226f3152b5d9fe","unit:aea7225648815b38046d03d104235c7188002026ed4cba764a175e814e1682f1","unit:c1a72fa08c9dd564ade09c520b7d608f3ef8696fece4cfa0a7aa5ced5a718cb2","unit:cc514f73deef8694495ba2f009ce6311644ad4ae33b151cb448f35ec9f757551"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:228c5e54dcf9c025bf961506","scopeContentSha256":"6d6684f4e93559841143be037967fae8ee8d0cbd19a681f45d74937cd3c677b3","localRef":"s4"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259","scopeContentSha256":"d5e38e3210f4c6470c46f05705502e3eac55d65af02bef909f8451000a16a2ca","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l4","originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:44","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l4","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:44","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:228c5e54dcf9c025bf961506","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l4","source":"s22","target":"s4","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Microscopic realization, stability and tensions test dynamical content left open by topological completion arguments."],"challengeStatement":"Microscopic realization, stability and tensions test dynamical content left open by conditional completion arguments.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"21496eadb83bfd89726e6068cb313c4459eb02b5c7319e3a443ecef8270fff51","reply.jsonSha256":"2b13522cde089dccca6ad5a606e861ba63c324f568607e4c375a0cc4bb41db20","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c36a6e5deffe73ebc0b1e16be7efeacce3b5a91518427e213f2adceb5abec192","receipt.jsonSha256":"1ac3619b922316ab9daed0b834a08152271b89bff3673ca6a536ac321cd7466f","normalization.jsonSha256":"34b6a384ae3212b9f12a1af0a4c8b1577afc8d9d2f9c6739f7b3e4d4e90d2e8a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f23d8110109e2321e451a757253617422655ce2cba84255be89203e01dad788"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"44719832235d537d40d8c3f9fde7ff9934aad947d84f431af08131529e35cace","reply.jsonSha256":"ba3566417aebc92a1caeed4499b097fe44f303e7c53fb9665b12679327751a5b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ad4fdae6bffbb728f2978451b9900b4b2db3bee70853770a6186005751e27323","receipt.jsonSha256":"97a00e5fe99821077fd249a980950dbc16461262f4d8c9f2bca8b01c4a37abd0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7a8af76f3c278360ec57798a76e3899c73d387ea4d4b3a0d9d7a02a5e66f129a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259"},{"ref":"x4_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:228c5e54dcf9c025bf961506"},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.31749","sourceId":"ev:d03868a099e81f5d04b5cf1b0941e94a","sourceSha256":"3246465bb6e7e415d921799ac5b05de3cd1003929fc3bbbe64f65f96f4557f95","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a9f792dd9844870637fc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7e80df9f7ddfcfe18336c3346f5c5b7d3184b8e823fee83eb8ab14eb056a2b22","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2594,"textSha256":"eddf4d0fcf76c49814d1b0ffda755eebf4273c5a86ab4914158a645fde69b951","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259"},{"ref":"x4_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:228c5e54dcf9c025bf961506"},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.31749","sourceId":"ev:d03868a099e81f5d04b5cf1b0941e94a","sourceSha256":"3246465bb6e7e415d921799ac5b05de3cd1003929fc3bbbe64f65f96f4557f95","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a9f792dd9844870637fc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7e80df9f7ddfcfe18336c3346f5c5b7d3184b8e823fee83eb8ab14eb056a2b22","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2594,"textSha256":"eddf4d0fcf76c49814d1b0ffda755eebf4273c5a86ab4914158a645fde69b951","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d4","originalRef":"l4","status":"route","source":"s4","target":"s22","type":"application_of","title":"Trace microscopic defect realization to completion requirements","rationale":"Microscopic realization of completion-required defects applies the conditional completion program while testing dynamical content that its topological arguments leave open. This supports reversing the application direction without deriving stability or tension results from completion.","qualification":"The application is limited to realizing defects motivated by the specified completion requirements. Their cores, worldvolume physics, charges, stability and tensions require separate analysis. The elementary-constituent tension bound remains conjectural and concerns suitable elementary generators in object-dependent regions of EFT field space, not arbitrary charged stacks or every field-space point. Horizon-bearing black-brane evidence does not determine intrinsic tensions of proposed horizon-free generators; torsion-charge cases retain their stated lack of a classical extremal-black-hole comparison. No fixed numerical coefficient or universal stability follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l4","s4","s22"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The endpoint definitions and paired statements support applying completion requirements to microscopic defect realization. The reversed application is expressly confined to that branch; stability, worldvolume properties and the conjectural elementary-tension bound remain separate dynamical questions rather than consequences of topology.","refs":["l4","s4","s22"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l6":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l6","source":"q025-candidate-question:febea5a4e25e1504e98bf0b1","target":"q025-candidate-question:faf460540ff37253842e9b08","type":"narrower","title":"Test minimal warm inflation against Planck and TCC","rationale":"The broad question asks which inflationary dynamics satisfy their stated observational and theoretical conditions. The target genuinely refines it to one specified warm-inflation model and its joint observational and conjectural test, rather than applying a method supplied by the broader question.","qualification":"The refinement concerns the direct inflaton–non-Abelian gauge interaction, supplied hybrid-form potential, high-dissipation regime and evolving-Hubble treatment. It retains the source's fixed cosmological assumptions, uniform parameter priors and Planck 2018 TT, TE, EE and lowE data, with the 20 November 2021 version. TCC remains conjectural. Conclusions do not extend to scalar WLI, all warm-inflation models or every Swampland condition. The packet reports corrupted spectrum-equation extraction and uninspected chains and final joint region, so compatibility is not independently reproduced.","evidenceIds":["unit:01ed613346ef96646a7de1d8cc6c673dd1d5caaeca4bee5c8d2d9b47c19f7b8d","unit:1c4a22f08f644a662ca5b2ba25c8e8b90167818d1fe5077cd6057cb2cc1a028f","unit:27e9718bbd297638075db70c88418decaa70fa69b7c20a698f58e994ece15025","unit:2ab023fb30a63119a84492b5e7c49045cebe6bd46e9cb48cc6286d55fd9e2e9b","unit:2f2938d98209cb969338ce98103c58ab91c049da31819e4948dd4a8822ef8e83","unit:2faff309a04dadd4a8154bcb4ad4f304d0a3513b92753fa431c622e5fea2a6d8","unit:427fb282a3db53c2391e399da64d3bd8b98a667b685da6d60025a8cb2e510703","unit:58116a0e941a0eddbc42d2bcfc7bfb2f13d15a5732813e1defad660ec94a65a2","unit:582ada2156217e41a7faf8a9d8f40631a11e676d52b7306a550915f68671aeb2","unit:5f6a65f0235d45974516680a6289963a0f1b7975e7cd48a472e2f7aa1f867690","unit:76909204017cb72bb2ada2e37b16097a25844fd26c5d418bfab2513da69e90ec","unit:7a002f5cbbf1fc8abb9b7c86eb2057a743105e8f130cd433956f07faed42ae2e","unit:8790be309011888c107c62bc41c18ebc86d601b966b7054a9df144f16f16b635","unit:d6c3bca8b9ea72f7d8e58527c7878134dc4b69142009321c9909abc883f36baa","unit:e863cf7cc174e5b8d9a0cd033cc8b221610f7ca8fa88e44239e422ff08fa1aa9","unit:e9855f47ea25af8971436c56841b89b0678c8bad0e7f4d331b7cd56ea225112f"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:febea5a4e25e1504e98bf0b1","scopeContentSha256":"17b29d8632b2ff95560c1019e554f8647c63941c74a8a42e60a7a1d6a3c208cb","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:faf460540ff37253842e9b08","scopeContentSha256":"716f7151b162cf4c9ffa119e87ee66da931326a6d04801293bc7889a5f9e0f93","localRef":"s37"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l6","originalCandidateId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge:link:25","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l6","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge:link:25","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:febea5a4e25e1504e98bf0b1","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:faf460540ff37253842e9b08","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l6","source":"s38","target":"s37","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Minimal warm inflation supplies a model-specific joint fit and conjectural TCC-compatibility application, not a result for all warm models."],"challengeStatement":"Minimal warm inflation supplies a specific joint observational-fit and conjectural-TCC application, without extending its conclusions to scalar WLI or all warm models.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"66f9156f8fe28e406657ad6c5cee86f7f6e9baf40988c3988a1628ba84d86c80","reply.jsonSha256":"d7dc1e6648d0579a0bf191d54ae6b09f175f4e209aaebd61541648189647abba","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ed73ef48972c8139e692767ba38cf8e7bf1058d4505b02db11c5e74ba4915202","receipt.jsonSha256":"14dc3120560ac8b6a48f3d3e02678c18955ec5859b0a8eadae1314d123b6bf86","normalization.jsonSha256":"b7137677b9c674b685d4d953913b7a7bda9163b9b85eed729855e3dcefda4649","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"86e973c78319a900cfdf8e4058da9886504d0528cfbd35be39b5efe8c6d05144"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a52c651c6f2d8c32be3d1e2c0156d67eec4732883c023cc9cfd80f9b5b7edb07","reply.jsonSha256":"6879db0861ea8166ef2ceb7498f0b7bce2eb6b0272b7c64bffc8b9a7d89baa51","reply.raw.txtSha256":"20b2158022b8fbba1848acb3698c830137dc1ad865595346c298c059ea614b36","receipt.jsonSha256":"748fe80f9a903d64997ac89886574070104cea40da96afae5477009139b1410e","normalization.jsonSha256":"c09973688f86ea9785baeeb1b84cf565d72a4e25605d264c2683579b1196c9eb"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:febea5a4e25e1504e98bf0b1"},{"ref":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:faf460540ff37253842e9b08"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:febea5a4e25e1504e98bf0b1"},{"ref":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:faf460540ff37253842e9b08"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"2105.08045","sourceId":"ev:63553f3cec0501b4387f21f44c5a93fd","sourceSha256":"0fa7f3acb98befca7e61e4fa9f98989dc1da38087f41836e3af89cbc934c6c69","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/daaaae9de3f44f71b6df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"165859b3229ca80eb6329055d95d18287dcdfc7158f84bf37179a68e6dd9924f","pdfPage":2,"start":2497,"end":5885,"textSha256":"b9fa227854308e3f7a46e83c5cd9a6481bf8c511edd080731771be4e216578d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d6","originalRef":"l6","status":"route","source":"s38","target":"s37","type":"narrower","title":"Test minimal warm inflation against Planck and TCC","rationale":"The broad question asks which inflationary dynamics satisfy their stated observational and theoretical conditions. The target genuinely refines it to one specified warm-inflation model and its joint observational and conjectural test, rather than applying a method supplied by the broader question.","qualification":"The refinement concerns the direct inflaton–non-Abelian gauge interaction, supplied hybrid-form potential, high-dissipation regime and evolving-Hubble treatment. It retains the source's fixed cosmological assumptions, uniform parameter priors and Planck 2018 TT, TE, EE and lowE data, with the 20 November 2021 version. TCC remains conjectural. Conclusions do not extend to scalar WLI, all warm-inflation models or every Swampland condition. The packet reports corrupted spectrum-equation extraction and uninspected chains and final joint region, so compatibility is not independently reproduced.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l6","s38","s37"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The complete minimal-warm-inflation question refines s38's model-viability question to a specified model, regime, dataset and theoretical condition. The narrower direction is correct, and the qualification retains conjectural TCC status, the scalar-WLI non-transfer limit and the incomplete verification of the spectrum and joint region.","refs":["l6","s38","s37"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l7":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l7","source":"q025-candidate-question:febea5a4e25e1504e98bf0b1","target":"q025-candidate-question:1beaca7f5ef4d4621f6ce248","type":"related_question","title":"Explore relic and baryogenesis tests of inflation","rationale":"The paired statements connect inflationary viability to particle relics and baryon asymmetry through additional production assumptions. They do not identify a particular method or construction supplied by the broad viability and tensor-inference question.","qualification":"The connection requires the specified inflationary or reheating history and its production mechanism. Anomaly-driven baryogenesis, gravitational particle production and inflaton-decay relics remain separate; the two polynomial decay models remain alternatives. Quantum-gravity exclusions are conjecture-dependent where invoked, and ordinary phenomenological models need no string embedding. Particle relics remain distinct from PBH dark matter, and baryogenesis is not recast as a gravitational-wave detection proposal. Abundances and combined consistency constraints were not reproduced.","evidenceIds":["unit:01ed613346ef96646a7de1d8cc6c673dd1d5caaeca4bee5c8d2d9b47c19f7b8d","unit:1b68a8bc9bf785ba1a6f9b9d072fc176b0676b437d969c6d649ef43f24621c2d","unit:1c4a22f08f644a662ca5b2ba25c8e8b90167818d1fe5077cd6057cb2cc1a028f","unit:248497b5b7d1b851d3b6e29dabb0407038068b3748d918422ca48352be9551f9","unit:27e9718bbd297638075db70c88418decaa70fa69b7c20a698f58e994ece15025","unit:2ab023fb30a63119a84492b5e7c49045cebe6bd46e9cb48cc6286d55fd9e2e9b","unit:2faff309a04dadd4a8154bcb4ad4f304d0a3513b92753fa431c622e5fea2a6d8","unit:427fb282a3db53c2391e399da64d3bd8b98a667b685da6d60025a8cb2e510703","unit:58116a0e941a0eddbc42d2bcfc7bfb2f13d15a5732813e1defad660ec94a65a2","unit:582ada2156217e41a7faf8a9d8f40631a11e676d52b7306a550915f68671aeb2","unit:5f6a65f0235d45974516680a6289963a0f1b7975e7cd48a472e2f7aa1f867690","unit:76909204017cb72bb2ada2e37b16097a25844fd26c5d418bfab2513da69e90ec","unit:7a002f5cbbf1fc8abb9b7c86eb2057a743105e8f130cd433956f07faed42ae2e","unit:8790be309011888c107c62bc41c18ebc86d601b966b7054a9df144f16f16b635","unit:a4dbd30ff94d53fa8d599b1e3945f8c0e9a876c2693b6a95a89892a411629fc4","unit:d6c3bca8b9ea72f7d8e58527c7878134dc4b69142009321c9909abc883f36baa","unit:e863cf7cc174e5b8d9a0cd033cc8b221610f7ca8fa88e44239e422ff08fa1aa9","unit:e9855f47ea25af8971436c56841b89b0678c8bad0e7f4d331b7cd56ea225112f","unit:ff4c28fc60a677c6ea7cf3c0bc847c599c97a770081d90f8ef8bd34fade86534"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:febea5a4e25e1504e98bf0b1","scopeContentSha256":"17b29d8632b2ff95560c1019e554f8647c63941c74a8a42e60a7a1d6a3c208cb","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1beaca7f5ef4d4621f6ce248","scopeContentSha256":"5538c3a73b8dc3c1eee12fdefbfa90609d299794a1155a60c6f3d45e2a0ecdb6","localRef":"s1"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l7","originalCandidateId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge:link:26","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l7","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge:link:26","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:febea5a4e25e1504e98bf0b1","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:1beaca7f5ef4d4621f6ce248","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l7","source":"s38","target":"s1","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Inflationary or reheating dynamics can be tested through particle relics and baryon asymmetry, with additional production assumptions."],"challengeStatement":"Inflation and reheating can be investigated through particle relics and baryon asymmetry under additional production assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"66f9156f8fe28e406657ad6c5cee86f7f6e9baf40988c3988a1628ba84d86c80","reply.jsonSha256":"d7dc1e6648d0579a0bf191d54ae6b09f175f4e209aaebd61541648189647abba","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ed73ef48972c8139e692767ba38cf8e7bf1058d4505b02db11c5e74ba4915202","receipt.jsonSha256":"14dc3120560ac8b6a48f3d3e02678c18955ec5859b0a8eadae1314d123b6bf86","normalization.jsonSha256":"b7137677b9c674b685d4d953913b7a7bda9163b9b85eed729855e3dcefda4649","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"86e973c78319a900cfdf8e4058da9886504d0528cfbd35be39b5efe8c6d05144"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a52c651c6f2d8c32be3d1e2c0156d67eec4732883c023cc9cfd80f9b5b7edb07","reply.jsonSha256":"6879db0861ea8166ef2ceb7498f0b7bce2eb6b0272b7c64bffc8b9a7d89baa51","reply.raw.txtSha256":"20b2158022b8fbba1848acb3698c830137dc1ad865595346c298c059ea614b36","receipt.jsonSha256":"748fe80f9a903d64997ac89886574070104cea40da96afae5477009139b1410e","normalization.jsonSha256":"c09973688f86ea9785baeeb1b84cf565d72a4e25605d264c2683579b1196c9eb"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:febea5a4e25e1504e98bf0b1"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1beaca7f5ef4d4621f6ce248"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:febea5a4e25e1504e98bf0b1"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1beaca7f5ef4d4621f6ce248"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d7","originalRef":"l7","status":"route","source":"s38","target":"s1","type":"related_question","title":"Explore relic and baryogenesis tests of inflation","rationale":"The paired statements connect inflationary viability to particle relics and baryon asymmetry through additional production assumptions. They do not identify a particular method or construction supplied by the broad viability and tensor-inference question.","qualification":"The connection requires the specified inflationary or reheating history and its production mechanism. Anomaly-driven baryogenesis, gravitational particle production and inflaton-decay relics remain separate; the two polynomial decay models remain alternatives. Quantum-gravity exclusions are conjecture-dependent where invoked, and ordinary phenomenological models need no string embedding. Particle relics remain distinct from PBH dark matter, and baryogenesis is not recast as a gravitational-wave detection proposal. Abundances and combined consistency constraints were not reproduced.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l7","s38","s1"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The paired reasoning establishes a connection between inflationary viability and relic or baryogenesis tests under additional production assumptions. It does not identify a method or construction supplied by s38 that establishes a stronger application relation. The related-question record preserves the separate mechanisms and their stated limits.","refs":["l7","s38","s1"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l8":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l8","source":"q025-candidate-question:1cf65a5fde8682a5e4e0f95b","target":"q025-candidate-question:675c4c4dca4814ca6ef3efee","type":"related_question","title":"Follow an amplifying scalar into proposed dark-energy roles","rationale":"Both statements connect the scalar-amplification branch to a proposed later dark-energy role. This is a connection between temporal roles of a specified scalar, without establishing that the entire late-time cosmology question applies a gravitational-wave production or transfer method.","qualification":"The shared branch concerns post-inflationary amplification and subsequent proposed early- and late-dark-energy evolution. Wave generation, amplification, propagation and dark-energy roles remain separate. Late axion–gauge wave production retains its own epoch and mechanism; use of a CMB observable does not make those waves primordial inflationary tensors. The description-level evidence does not verify a complete unified scalar history or observational reach.","evidenceIds":["unit:183c9f1446b31355bc42c1e12a69860a0e79235c4d7f464f30ff5405fbe48123","unit:2130ac01b4921c76144fdd4d50fc3dbccb735288bd61971c09d2032ff8b04144","unit:27e9718bbd297638075db70c88418decaa70fa69b7c20a698f58e994ece15025","unit:4998ca23f15c984e10ae383f3d29a792aa324bb61c35ca90cd5b5d5415fbbb23","unit:8e74739d5f7d1a6c54a091d34e70818ce532c2073b4e42c97ed0fabfc6ffe542","unit:91ed937b042373efa71eb52c1a7a28fe00b6a7ca81db2d5281d6917b798c970f","unit:e31acda379069ee2288c4b1e39ec48b61f75cb193a07505bd397598016f500e9","unit:e9855f47ea25af8971436c56841b89b0678c8bad0e7f4d331b7cd56ea225112f","unit:ea3c94e276220ff00117853e0ad4332bbbbd6571a556eb8f78f9d8e995086585"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1cf65a5fde8682a5e4e0f95b","scopeContentSha256":"9d19883875426d9b002cecb66372a0faec350b3d18db589c8f31cf6b371a1046","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:675c4c4dca4814ca6ef3efee","scopeContentSha256":"623212534443388db974187f1ad8dfe8c4cd633a850049c3a94e67c271fb270f","localRef":"s18"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l8","originalCandidateId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge:link:30","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l8","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge:link:30","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:1cf65a5fde8682a5e4e0f95b","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:675c4c4dca4814ca6ef3efee","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l8","source":"s2","target":"s18","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["The scalar-amplification branch connects to a proposed later dark-energy role. The late axion-production branch remains a separate temporal mechanism."],"challengeStatement":"The scalar-amplification branch connects to a proposed later dark-energy role; late axion-wave production retains its separate epoch and mechanism.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"66f9156f8fe28e406657ad6c5cee86f7f6e9baf40988c3988a1628ba84d86c80","reply.jsonSha256":"d7dc1e6648d0579a0bf191d54ae6b09f175f4e209aaebd61541648189647abba","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ed73ef48972c8139e692767ba38cf8e7bf1058d4505b02db11c5e74ba4915202","receipt.jsonSha256":"14dc3120560ac8b6a48f3d3e02678c18955ec5859b0a8eadae1314d123b6bf86","normalization.jsonSha256":"b7137677b9c674b685d4d953913b7a7bda9163b9b85eed729855e3dcefda4649","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"86e973c78319a900cfdf8e4058da9886504d0528cfbd35be39b5efe8c6d05144"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a52c651c6f2d8c32be3d1e2c0156d67eec4732883c023cc9cfd80f9b5b7edb07","reply.jsonSha256":"6879db0861ea8166ef2ceb7498f0b7bce2eb6b0272b7c64bffc8b9a7d89baa51","reply.raw.txtSha256":"20b2158022b8fbba1848acb3698c830137dc1ad865595346c298c059ea614b36","receipt.jsonSha256":"748fe80f9a903d64997ac89886574070104cea40da96afae5477009139b1410e","normalization.jsonSha256":"c09973688f86ea9785baeeb1b84cf565d72a4e25605d264c2683579b1196c9eb"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1cf65a5fde8682a5e4e0f95b"},{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:675c4c4dca4814ca6ef3efee"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1cf65a5fde8682a5e4e0f95b"},{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:675c4c4dca4814ca6ef3efee"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d8","originalRef":"l8","status":"route","source":"s2","target":"s18","type":"related_question","title":"Follow an amplifying scalar into proposed dark-energy roles","rationale":"Both statements connect the scalar-amplification branch to a proposed later dark-energy role. This is a connection between temporal roles of a specified scalar, without establishing that the entire late-time cosmology question applies a gravitational-wave production or transfer method.","qualification":"The shared branch concerns post-inflationary amplification and subsequent proposed early- and late-dark-energy evolution. Wave generation, amplification, propagation and dark-energy roles remain separate. Late axion–gauge wave production retains its own epoch and mechanism; use of a CMB observable does not make those waves primordial inflationary tensors. The description-level evidence does not verify a complete unified scalar history or observational reach.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l8","s2","s18"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The supported connection concerns successive roles of the scalar-amplification branch. Related_question correctly avoids treating all late-time cosmology as an application of wave transfer, while preserving the separate late axion-production mechanism and the unverified unified scalar history.","refs":["l8","s2","s18"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l9":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l9","source":"q025-candidate-question:4542518149ede7f8bf5ecc71","target":"q025-candidate-question:24b94aefd795da3b08c511f4","type":"related_question","title":"Explore late-time sources and their detection limits","rationale":"The statements connect observational programmes to source-specific late-time field dynamics and cloud transitions, including unfavourable prospects. They do not identify a shared observatory method or construction applied across those systems.","qualification":"Observatory agendas and capabilities retain their source-era assumptions and prospective status. Quintessence production and tidally driven boson-cloud transitions have different systems, epochs and mechanisms. Quintessence conclusions remain within the stated backreaction treatment, including the limited U(1) and low-backreaction SU(2) results described by the packet. Proposed probe frequencies and produced frequencies are distinct. Imported spectral-distortion projections were not independently verified, and cloud transitions have description-only support.","evidenceIds":["unit:1a76d2923e061c0dd0b499017d12f5b513f29ca6d6e9e068ee2153f444cb2d89","unit:6fe9c0979b28e94ea7202d1f31def45a4c742b82a2754d19512a4f1a7faa0cbd","unit:7c15328f2083e90b35419cfc342aa4d61639234484c411b680d9d9f5d7d1adce","unit:995fac8ef781ed9412f3735025d9b052fd1866dd83491beb5a24d496bc2be993","unit:dac25c35a47fdf989c735cba4561387c01d49c880c7334bcf1040897ace31885","unit:e31acda379069ee2288c4b1e39ec48b61f75cb193a07505bd397598016f500e9","unit:ff94d1acd48ad3f2ea9ae25e67a77b9ef2af77a094be18bb94c8d0d5832ba6cb"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4542518149ede7f8bf5ecc71","scopeContentSha256":"9598ad189915bd4ce7f51e6ae52138eaa0891fe83f8a4eae4ead7379166a0adc","localRef":"s14"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24b94aefd795da3b08c511f4","scopeContentSha256":"05e9dc31365639b2ce1003f5709f95da4fc94d43b4d5f3b189d4cd0131c4abb8","localRef":"s6"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l9","originalCandidateId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge:link:32","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l9","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge:link:32","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:4542518149ede7f8bf5ecc71","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:24b94aefd795da3b08c511f4","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l9","source":"s14","target":"s6","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Late-time field dynamics and cloud transitions provide source-specific observational applications, including unfavourable prospects."],"challengeStatement":"Late-time field dynamics and cloud transitions supply source-specific observational applications, including unfavourable prospects.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"66f9156f8fe28e406657ad6c5cee86f7f6e9baf40988c3988a1628ba84d86c80","reply.jsonSha256":"d7dc1e6648d0579a0bf191d54ae6b09f175f4e209aaebd61541648189647abba","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ed73ef48972c8139e692767ba38cf8e7bf1058d4505b02db11c5e74ba4915202","receipt.jsonSha256":"14dc3120560ac8b6a48f3d3e02678c18955ec5859b0a8eadae1314d123b6bf86","normalization.jsonSha256":"b7137677b9c674b685d4d953913b7a7bda9163b9b85eed729855e3dcefda4649","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"86e973c78319a900cfdf8e4058da9886504d0528cfbd35be39b5efe8c6d05144"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a52c651c6f2d8c32be3d1e2c0156d67eec4732883c023cc9cfd80f9b5b7edb07","reply.jsonSha256":"6879db0861ea8166ef2ceb7498f0b7bce2eb6b0272b7c64bffc8b9a7d89baa51","reply.raw.txtSha256":"20b2158022b8fbba1848acb3698c830137dc1ad865595346c298c059ea614b36","receipt.jsonSha256":"748fe80f9a903d64997ac89886574070104cea40da96afae5477009139b1410e","normalization.jsonSha256":"c09973688f86ea9785baeeb1b84cf565d72a4e25605d264c2683579b1196c9eb"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4542518149ede7f8bf5ecc71"},{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24b94aefd795da3b08c511f4"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4542518149ede7f8bf5ecc71"},{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:24b94aefd795da3b08c511f4"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d9","originalRef":"l9","status":"route","source":"s14","target":"s6","type":"related_question","title":"Explore late-time sources and their detection limits","rationale":"The statements connect observational programmes to source-specific late-time field dynamics and cloud transitions, including unfavourable prospects. They do not identify a shared observatory method or construction applied across those systems.","qualification":"Observatory agendas and capabilities retain their source-era assumptions and prospective status. Quintessence production and tidally driven boson-cloud transitions have different systems, epochs and mechanisms. Quintessence conclusions remain within the stated backreaction treatment, including the limited U(1) and low-backreaction SU(2) results described by the packet. Proposed probe frequencies and produced frequencies are distinct. Imported spectral-distortion projections were not independently verified, and cloud transitions have description-only support.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l9","s14","s6"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d9","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Observatory programmes and these source-specific signals have the stated observational connection, but the packet identifies no particular programme method being applied. The related-question route retains unfavourable prospects, distinct cloud and quintessence mechanisms, backreaction limits and unverified detector projections.","refs":["l9","s14","s6"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l10":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l10","source":"q025-candidate-question:ce30a8183fac0b3cc73bc3fb","target":"q025-candidate-question:da14ff104d685afe397c2425","type":"method_for","title":"Use bispectra in release-specific CMB inference","rationale":"Bispectrum diagnostics supply model-specific inference beyond power spectra. The methodological direction therefore runs from s29 to the CMB-inference question in s32.","qualification":"Application to CMB inference requires separate observational projection and detectability checks, using the specified release, likelihood, dataset combinations and cosmological priors. Initial-state excitation, additional particles, resonant dynamics and D3/anti-D3 signatures remain distinct. Backreaction and EFT restrictions remain model-specific; the supplied tree-level D3/anti-D3 analysis assumes no problematic particle-production backreaction. Primordial signatures do not establish angular detectability, a universal detection pipeline or a QSFI explanation of the rare D3/anti-D3 cases.","evidenceIds":["unit:1b37134cfa7a20619ae8745dd91daf5904952a3ef9c31712b33206d96a6cc922","unit:1c4a22f08f644a662ca5b2ba25c8e8b90167818d1fe5077cd6057cb2cc1a028f","unit:28e59ef534c650e70ad0ab2837265a32b95a09f5ee44da7a6a4b75b330bb65bd","unit:2f2938d98209cb969338ce98103c58ab91c049da31819e4948dd4a8822ef8e83","unit:3041ad507424a48a10fc5b13121653acb3db738d2539921c30d111e33cf35e19","unit:30c729c8c54bf1c79e2c816aefbaa30aa0b80848af087483f67fb05ca675e896","unit:3bcbab0f3aea941647c7f6cfd98a1b107f1648732e3ec49e8af8c076d3e427f9","unit:427fb282a3db53c2391e399da64d3bd8b98a667b685da6d60025a8cb2e510703","unit:45f73e03d6e87b139fecca7c8022fbf31852be90f3b462bf3e7566a7bb677371","unit:63602b3457a359aa6fd2b75f4ebfa4092be87e6b767d54b2bf45455ab498979d","unit:701861e1030a4ccb650c2e5717783dd8b015a265355d7e45af0d70386a64e156","unit:81272e56817c0860ae28fc2ef8fe731d2bc8f3aea84ba984a14e991793f780d6","unit:8f4aeafc2674e5be22db0c99d6e2e3d62a04dd1ed4dc86eac8f156b1a2a164f2","unit:98481837dfea4f44c8c4693631e3055d5c0693c33f1afd6e5c316c9552f56c25","unit:98e4d1fb94df8e7bcca7f8cfa5c2e9fa0aa6b45e3a9792446eb20c1b9e088deb"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ce30a8183fac0b3cc73bc3fb","scopeContentSha256":"3f9a6ddec4b84e965510789480b3af8e956ad1453473a8538baec02b16074218","localRef":"s29"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da14ff104d685afe397c2425","scopeContentSha256":"91007145ebf8cbb571a4e09cb1b18c7c5e5a7b57470c18e69792c7dcdbe57065","localRef":"s32"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l10","originalCandidateId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge:link:39","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l10","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge:link:39","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:da14ff104d685afe397c2425","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:ce30a8183fac0b3cc73bc3fb","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l10","source":"s32","target":"s29","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Bispectrum diagnostics offer model-specific inference beyond power spectra; projection and detectability require separate checks."],"challengeStatement":"Bispectrum diagnostics offer model-specific inference beyond power spectra, subject to separate projection and detectability checks.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"66f9156f8fe28e406657ad6c5cee86f7f6e9baf40988c3988a1628ba84d86c80","reply.jsonSha256":"d7dc1e6648d0579a0bf191d54ae6b09f175f4e209aaebd61541648189647abba","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ed73ef48972c8139e692767ba38cf8e7bf1058d4505b02db11c5e74ba4915202","receipt.jsonSha256":"14dc3120560ac8b6a48f3d3e02678c18955ec5859b0a8eadae1314d123b6bf86","normalization.jsonSha256":"b7137677b9c674b685d4d953913b7a7bda9163b9b85eed729855e3dcefda4649","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"86e973c78319a900cfdf8e4058da9886504d0528cfbd35be39b5efe8c6d05144"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d14f2d7211435a2b2c3c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a52c651c6f2d8c32be3d1e2c0156d67eec4732883c023cc9cfd80f9b5b7edb07","reply.jsonSha256":"6879db0861ea8166ef2ceb7498f0b7bce2eb6b0272b7c64bffc8b9a7d89baa51","reply.raw.txtSha256":"20b2158022b8fbba1848acb3698c830137dc1ad865595346c298c059ea614b36","receipt.jsonSha256":"748fe80f9a903d64997ac89886574070104cea40da96afae5477009139b1410e","normalization.jsonSha256":"c09973688f86ea9785baeeb1b84cf565d72a4e25605d264c2683579b1196c9eb"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da14ff104d685afe397c2425"},{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ce30a8183fac0b3cc73bc3fb"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da14ff104d685afe397c2425"},{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ce30a8183fac0b3cc73bc3fb"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d10","originalRef":"l10","status":"route","source":"s29","target":"s32","type":"method_for","title":"Use bispectra in release-specific CMB inference","rationale":"Bispectrum diagnostics supply model-specific inference beyond power spectra. The methodological direction therefore runs from s29 to the CMB-inference question in s32.","qualification":"Application to CMB inference requires separate observational projection and detectability checks, using the specified release, likelihood, dataset combinations and cosmological priors. Initial-state excitation, additional particles, resonant dynamics and D3/anti-D3 signatures remain distinct. Backreaction and EFT restrictions remain model-specific; the supplied tree-level D3/anti-D3 analysis assumes no problematic particle-production backreaction. Primordial signatures do not establish angular detectability, a universal detection pipeline or a QSFI explanation of the rare D3/anti-D3 cases.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l10","s29","s32"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d10","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Bispectrum diagnostics supply the method for the relevant CMB-inference branch, so reversal to s29 → s32 is correct. The record retains model-specific backreaction restrictions and separate projection, detectability and release-dependent inference requirements.","refs":["l10","s29","s32"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l10","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l11":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l11","source":"q025-candidate-question:da14ff104d685afe397c2425","target":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","type":"method_for","title":"Use dated CMB inference for inflationary reconstruction","rationale":"Release-specific CMB inference supplies observational constraints for the spectral-reconstruction and background-viability questions in s26. The stated methodological conditions belong to s32, supporting reversal of the original direction.","qualification":"The method applies where reconstruction uses the specified CMB analysis. WMAP, Planck nominal 2013, full-mission and 2018 analyses and source-dated forecasts remain separate, including the supplied full-mission and 2018 excerpt versions. Dataset combinations, priors, pivots, confidence levels and reheating treatments must be retained. Translation to background parameters, field ranges or energy scales remains model-dependent and preserves the crossing prescription and e-fold evaluation epoch. No single current combined constraint, universal excursion bound or independently checked likelihood is supplied.","evidenceIds":["unit:191b042c99b96a6bbf9054bb55f0a26fd22f39ecb72902e415b194c805d36959","unit:1acdbfde4891df21db56ffa8b5f06998c7c2cf160530a25da77bbacd7c1016ce","unit:1b37134cfa7a20619ae8745dd91daf5904952a3ef9c31712b33206d96a6cc922","unit:1c4a22f08f644a662ca5b2ba25c8e8b90167818d1fe5077cd6057cb2cc1a028f","unit:1fcb591c2eef1d7f1736d14cfd5f0657c10cf46ddb378fc5fd9e59d1109495f2","unit:28cc3b8fbc59cb74cee255fb796373ce619cff34da0cf31634c5e2d8732b8aa0","unit:2f2938d98209cb969338ce98103c58ab91c049da31819e4948dd4a8822ef8e83","unit:3041ad507424a48a10fc5b13121653acb3db738d2539921c30d111e33cf35e19","unit:30c729c8c54bf1c79e2c816aefbaa30aa0b80848af087483f67fb05ca675e896","unit:3bcbab0f3aea941647c7f6cfd98a1b107f1648732e3ec49e8af8c076d3e427f9","unit:427fb282a3db53c2391e399da64d3bd8b98a667b685da6d60025a8cb2e510703","unit:45f73e03d6e87b139fecca7c8022fbf31852be90f3b462bf3e7566a7bb677371","unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","unit:63602b3457a359aa6fd2b75f4ebfa4092be87e6b767d54b2bf45455ab498979d","unit:701861e1030a4ccb650c2e5717783dd8b015a265355d7e45af0d70386a64e156","unit:7405da195cb830f27b2cd597163f8f4435a5030c41d088896b6f666b1bb2db6a","unit:8f4aeafc2674e5be22db0c99d6e2e3d62a04dd1ed4dc86eac8f156b1a2a164f2","unit:98481837dfea4f44c8c4693631e3055d5c0693c33f1afd6e5c316c9552f56c25","unit:98e4d1fb94df8e7bcca7f8cfa5c2e9fa0aa6b45e3a9792446eb20c1b9e088deb","unit:bed792616c1d639d395b11b23c540ebfb15789613a361cb814a5ae83711f55e5","unit:c2b5e41e943b0473e5089ba598ef130ffb2472b981725ca11a500e88860850ee","unit:d7be6dedc1f0ebe9db505a6d2a0e52bfc67bda19fb0d810974550e35b53ed7bb","unit:fe379acef869280e8dd5e98899501ac6ec3e3dd42cdeaeba4cf123c6630e5147"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da14ff104d685afe397c2425","scopeContentSha256":"91007145ebf8cbb571a4e09cb1b18c7c5e5a7b57470c18e69792c7dcdbe57065","localRef":"s32"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","scopeContentSha256":"29f9bef9407be52a4a73021a58c1ea2b135a172ca9f15f97d64890e6b981f802","localRef":"s26"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l11","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge:link:30","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l11","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge:link:30","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:da14ff104d685afe397c2425","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l11","source":"s26","target":"s32","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["CMB inference is conditioned on a specified release, likelihood and model assumptions rather than a single current combined constraint."],"challengeStatement":"CMB inference depends on a specified release, likelihood and model assumptions rather than an undated combined constraint.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"95b1c7ba751c3f0831666906655a0772176b892862235639ba1b9f54177c0fe0","reply.jsonSha256":"2e948e54b460d4b78bd71e446414fb0734f34ec4e97be5eb0e4df090e615020e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"05a9a6b1249fce2e08510b7210c348274ab6822ab09918c64eda2a48a3cc30ae","receipt.jsonSha256":"50b7a181fc889d648a958ce20d90f3bf63e9351bac28605053ee83284da96d71","normalization.jsonSha256":"4538227034e50489c356d26e199de14d19afbe9d7c067bd7af5966066d994d3c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8bb74bad7dd366b41cb748c2d9278ae4184272afe37dc42ea085bed7dcb576d9"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"e259dbe129fef2f9d0be22648b8d6689b863f0acbb87ac00124a1011e9a73600","reply.jsonSha256":"08d00dca4e0be0dc1f1d71e1671f981ef07dd6078404652a39279d6ea35d1b25","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b0cb06db5235be5edcd5239e9867cbb3cf4eaa54bc95dcfd1b6d46130f595856","receipt.jsonSha256":"92c8bdf185ba9b933381dece64798713f76f0bfe64151241faee9b7b222a9e7a","normalization.jsonSha256":"0ef5d823adf0a25e589964d662378d8e7b623e16dece9d8146aed46a759851e4"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf"},{"ref":"x4_10","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da14ff104d685afe397c2425"},{"ref":"c4","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf"},{"ref":"x4_10","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da14ff104d685afe397c2425"},{"ref":"c4","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d11","originalRef":"l11","status":"route","source":"s32","target":"s26","type":"method_for","title":"Use dated CMB inference for inflationary reconstruction","rationale":"Release-specific CMB inference supplies observational constraints for the spectral-reconstruction and background-viability questions in s26. The stated methodological conditions belong to s32, supporting reversal of the original direction.","qualification":"The method applies where reconstruction uses the specified CMB analysis. WMAP, Planck nominal 2013, full-mission and 2018 analyses and source-dated forecasts remain separate, including the supplied full-mission and 2018 excerpt versions. Dataset combinations, priors, pivots, confidence levels and reheating treatments must be retained. Translation to background parameters, field ranges or energy scales remains model-dependent and preserves the crossing prescription and e-fold evaluation epoch. No single current combined constraint, universal excursion bound or independently checked likelihood is supplied.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l11","s32","s26"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d11","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The endpoint definitions support using release-specific CMB inference for observational reconstruction and viability questions in s26. The reversed methodological direction is appropriately limited to that use, preserving dated datasets, likelihood assumptions and model-dependent translation to background parameters.","refs":["l11","s32","s26"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l11","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l12":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l12","source":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","target":"q025-candidate-question:418bbc31ee2bd8903cfa3c24","type":"related_question","title":"Explore feature generation, transfer and recovery across probes","rationale":"Both statements connect primordial spectral predictions to scale- and probe-dependent feature questions. Transfer through CMB, matter and scalar-induced waves adds targets beyond the background and scale-inference question, so full-scope containment is not established. The statements also do not identify a common construction applied across these probes.","qualification":"Feature mechanisms and accessible scales remain distinct across probes. The supplied two-field examples require tuning of feature location and amplitude, and direct reconstruction requires sufficient signal-to-noise. Transfer can render primordial oscillations observationally insignificant. Potential periodicity, primordial spectral structure and observed frequency dependence are different quantities. The 2021 feature study and 2005 corrected-natural-inflation context do not establish a common cross-band feature, equivalent mechanisms or a joint forecast. The proposed cross-probe scope retains its stated review limits.","evidenceIds":["unit:176053607ecb1d13949784e5bfef7286f19f84c8376721330c1421746d6570cd","unit:191b042c99b96a6bbf9054bb55f0a26fd22f39ecb72902e415b194c805d36959","unit:1acdbfde4891df21db56ffa8b5f06998c7c2cf160530a25da77bbacd7c1016ce","unit:1fcb591c2eef1d7f1736d14cfd5f0657c10cf46ddb378fc5fd9e59d1109495f2","unit:28cc3b8fbc59cb74cee255fb796373ce619cff34da0cf31634c5e2d8732b8aa0","unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","unit:7405da195cb830f27b2cd597163f8f4435a5030c41d088896b6f666b1bb2db6a","unit:782d8dc2d0389de10f9b4de3a6dfbc348ccb61721843a1e951078fa7abc280f9","unit:bed792616c1d639d395b11b23c540ebfb15789613a361cb814a5ae83711f55e5","unit:c2b5e41e943b0473e5089ba598ef130ffb2472b981725ca11a500e88860850ee","unit:d7be6dedc1f0ebe9db505a6d2a0e52bfc67bda19fb0d810974550e35b53ed7bb","unit:fe379acef869280e8dd5e98899501ac6ec3e3dd42cdeaeba4cf123c6630e5147"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","scopeContentSha256":"29f9bef9407be52a4a73021a58c1ea2b135a172ca9f15f97d64890e6b981f802","localRef":"s26"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:418bbc31ee2bd8903cfa3c24","scopeContentSha256":"e97e416bd9d39d8a7e36e3e691c3241cdc7d7ac1457f3273bb387dc60ef0ff88","localRef":"s11"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l12","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge:link:27","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l12","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge:link:27","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:418bbc31ee2bd8903cfa3c24","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l12","source":"s26","target":"s11","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Feature generation and observational transfer specialize spectral questions without identifying mechanisms or scales across probes."],"challengeStatement":"Feature generation and transfer add scale- and probe-dependent questions to primordial spectral predictions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"95b1c7ba751c3f0831666906655a0772176b892862235639ba1b9f54177c0fe0","reply.jsonSha256":"2e948e54b460d4b78bd71e446414fb0734f34ec4e97be5eb0e4df090e615020e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"05a9a6b1249fce2e08510b7210c348274ab6822ab09918c64eda2a48a3cc30ae","receipt.jsonSha256":"50b7a181fc889d648a958ce20d90f3bf63e9351bac28605053ee83284da96d71","normalization.jsonSha256":"4538227034e50489c356d26e199de14d19afbe9d7c067bd7af5966066d994d3c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8bb74bad7dd366b41cb748c2d9278ae4184272afe37dc42ea085bed7dcb576d9"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"e259dbe129fef2f9d0be22648b8d6689b863f0acbb87ac00124a1011e9a73600","reply.jsonSha256":"08d00dca4e0be0dc1f1d71e1671f981ef07dd6078404652a39279d6ea35d1b25","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b0cb06db5235be5edcd5239e9867cbb3cf4eaa54bc95dcfd1b6d46130f595856","receipt.jsonSha256":"92c8bdf185ba9b933381dece64798713f76f0bfe64151241faee9b7b222a9e7a","normalization.jsonSha256":"0ef5d823adf0a25e589964d662378d8e7b623e16dece9d8146aed46a759851e4"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf"},{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:418bbc31ee2bd8903cfa3c24"},{"ref":"c4","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf"},{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:418bbc31ee2bd8903cfa3c24"},{"ref":"c4","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d12","originalRef":"l12","status":"route","source":"s26","target":"s11","type":"related_question","title":"Explore feature generation, transfer and recovery across probes","rationale":"Both statements connect primordial spectral predictions to scale- and probe-dependent feature questions. Transfer through CMB, matter and scalar-induced waves adds targets beyond the background and scale-inference question, so full-scope containment is not established. The statements also do not identify a common construction applied across these probes.","qualification":"Feature mechanisms and accessible scales remain distinct across probes. The supplied two-field examples require tuning of feature location and amplitude, and direct reconstruction requires sufficient signal-to-noise. Transfer can render primordial oscillations observationally insignificant. Potential periodicity, primordial spectral structure and observed frequency dependence are different quantities. The 2021 feature study and 2005 corrected-natural-inflation context do not establish a common cross-band feature, equivalent mechanisms or a joint forecast. The proposed cross-probe scope retains its stated review limits.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l12","s26","s11"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d12","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original statements connect spectral predictions with feature generation and transfer, but the complete s11 scope adds matter and induced-wave recovery targets beyond established containment in s26. Related_question preserves that useful connection without asserting a shared construction, common scale or joint forecast.","refs":["l12","s26","s11"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l12","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l13":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l13","source":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","target":"q025-candidate-question:9e97dc74ffbfc148dfee6333","type":"premise_check","title":"Check B-mode reliability before interpreting tensor amplitudes","rationale":"For reconstruction or scale inference that uses B-mode-derived tensor information, reliable amplitude and physical-origin inference are prerequisites. Both statements explicitly identify foreground, lensing, instrumental and tensor-origin conditions beyond a primordial prediction.","qualification":"This prerequisite applies to the B-mode-dependent inference branch, not to every theoretical spectrum calculation in s26. Foreground, lensing and instrumental treatments remain source-specific, with each tensor pivot, confidence level and data combination preserved. Vacuum-generated and matter-sourced tensors cannot be identified without the relevant origin assumptions. Delensing efficiency is a separate target from r, and excess B-mode power is not an established primordial tensor detection. Neither a universal inflationary scale or excursion relation nor complete tensor-origin diagnostics are supplied.","evidenceIds":["unit:191b042c99b96a6bbf9054bb55f0a26fd22f39ecb72902e415b194c805d36959","unit:1acdbfde4891df21db56ffa8b5f06998c7c2cf160530a25da77bbacd7c1016ce","unit:1fcb591c2eef1d7f1736d14cfd5f0657c10cf46ddb378fc5fd9e59d1109495f2","unit:28cc3b8fbc59cb74cee255fb796373ce619cff34da0cf31634c5e2d8732b8aa0","unit:3bcbab0f3aea941647c7f6cfd98a1b107f1648732e3ec49e8af8c076d3e427f9","unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","unit:7405da195cb830f27b2cd597163f8f4435a5030c41d088896b6f666b1bb2db6a","unit:914cad79d50e2ef0bbeda00f4b647df746b698495f695fa358405b30b5543aba","unit:98e4d1fb94df8e7bcca7f8cfa5c2e9fa0aa6b45e3a9792446eb20c1b9e088deb","unit:acd0c088d54f8d9ac7b03e41d4e15f4943e81e3e32913fc1e4a8554d0e0e78d4","unit:af9c6b37afaedbf0cfb810eda45d3bf4d8a9861ef90545c48e28b0da2c440bca","unit:b7b3a3b23bf754f4d9ee465e3c328c168c3dfec49ceb286226eeb5e41ad1fdb3","unit:bed792616c1d639d395b11b23c540ebfb15789613a361cb814a5ae83711f55e5","unit:c2b5e41e943b0473e5089ba598ef130ffb2472b981725ca11a500e88860850ee","unit:c6ce87574cccde82f3e907cfa29e9dacbce0e59bcd2d0e0fe1afa2ea9baf5435","unit:d7be6dedc1f0ebe9db505a6d2a0e52bfc67bda19fb0d810974550e35b53ed7bb","unit:d7f156d0e4ff6f63801d1ddce836c4a69ac35a59c92b559935299e531949f88a","unit:dd7a0dbe0ae746df17b28202c0da86df0f85d12ce209b2a4c2f5569d47bb24a8","unit:fe379acef869280e8dd5e98899501ac6ec3e3dd42cdeaeba4cf123c6630e5147","unit:ff5d02c897ddcbe883420b27acb2d7815e6b69df461b37e335e91f6a12017fc1"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","scopeContentSha256":"29f9bef9407be52a4a73021a58c1ea2b135a172ca9f15f97d64890e6b981f802","localRef":"s26"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9e97dc74ffbfc148dfee6333","scopeContentSha256":"ed6b4e00c4035bebc48ba2faa2a211803a4b8a95b2faf0ea6140e8e0d0cd3904","localRef":"s23"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l13","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge:link:29","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l13","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge:link:29","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:9e97dc74ffbfc148dfee6333","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l13","source":"s26","target":"s23","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["B-mode interpretation requires foreground, lensing, instrumental and tensor-origin assumptions in addition to a primordial prediction."],"challengeStatement":"B-mode interpretation requires foreground, lensing, instrument and tensor-origin assumptions beyond a primordial spectrum.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"95b1c7ba751c3f0831666906655a0772176b892862235639ba1b9f54177c0fe0","reply.jsonSha256":"2e948e54b460d4b78bd71e446414fb0734f34ec4e97be5eb0e4df090e615020e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"05a9a6b1249fce2e08510b7210c348274ab6822ab09918c64eda2a48a3cc30ae","receipt.jsonSha256":"50b7a181fc889d648a958ce20d90f3bf63e9351bac28605053ee83284da96d71","normalization.jsonSha256":"4538227034e50489c356d26e199de14d19afbe9d7c067bd7af5966066d994d3c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8bb74bad7dd366b41cb748c2d9278ae4184272afe37dc42ea085bed7dcb576d9"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"e259dbe129fef2f9d0be22648b8d6689b863f0acbb87ac00124a1011e9a73600","reply.jsonSha256":"08d00dca4e0be0dc1f1d71e1671f981ef07dd6078404652a39279d6ea35d1b25","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b0cb06db5235be5edcd5239e9867cbb3cf4eaa54bc95dcfd1b6d46130f595856","receipt.jsonSha256":"92c8bdf185ba9b933381dece64798713f76f0bfe64151241faee9b7b222a9e7a","normalization.jsonSha256":"0ef5d823adf0a25e589964d662378d8e7b623e16dece9d8146aed46a759851e4"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf"},{"ref":"x4_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9e97dc74ffbfc148dfee6333"},{"ref":"c4","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf"},{"ref":"x4_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9e97dc74ffbfc148dfee6333"},{"ref":"c4","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d13","originalRef":"l13","status":"route","source":"s26","target":"s23","type":"premise_check","title":"Check B-mode reliability before interpreting tensor amplitudes","rationale":"For reconstruction or scale inference that uses B-mode-derived tensor information, reliable amplitude and physical-origin inference are prerequisites. Both statements explicitly identify foreground, lensing, instrumental and tensor-origin conditions beyond a primordial prediction.","qualification":"This prerequisite applies to the B-mode-dependent inference branch, not to every theoretical spectrum calculation in s26. Foreground, lensing and instrumental treatments remain source-specific, with each tensor pivot, confidence level and data combination preserved. Vacuum-generated and matter-sourced tensors cannot be identified without the relevant origin assumptions. Delensing efficiency is a separate target from r, and excess B-mode power is not an established primordial tensor detection. Neither a universal inflationary scale or excursion relation nor complete tensor-origin diagnostics are supplied.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l13","s26","s23"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d13","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Reliable B-mode amplitude and origin inference is a prerequisite for the branch of s26 that uses those observations. The premise-check direction is correct and explicitly branch-limited, preserving foreground, lensing, instrumental and production-mechanism conditions without imposing them on every spectrum calculation.","refs":["l13","s26","s23"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l13","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l14":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l14","source":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","target":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","type":"application_of","title":"Trace model comparisons to their spectral predictions","rationale":"The paired statements explicitly describe model-specific observational comparisons as applying primordial predictions. The applied question is s17, and s26 supplies the underlying background-to-spectrum and reconstruction questions.","qualification":"The application concerns the relevant scalar and tensor spectral predictions, without making the full phenomenology of every model a power-spectrum application. Perturbation, reheating, pivot-to-end matching, crossing and e-fold prescriptions remain source-specific. Historical Planck, pre-Planck and BICEP2/Keck comparisons are not present-day refits. Model mechanisms remain distinct, and TCC is not a generic premise. Most supplied model calculations and fits remain description-supported.","evidenceIds":["unit:08d8901b7c533a10bfa9665788f6e4a89256182ce89514bff331f0423a1867c5","unit:0e18d5137fbb2c08501ba41ee4102f31ae759e5c8c81ff981ce2ff10f23dd3a1","unit:124ed1126f661a0223c5c61828b628c35307a39dc84f5563bc0491826e09beec","unit:176bc4f314e3d92a9165735dd704b55023531584fc89f620988e321ce28a59a5","unit:191b042c99b96a6bbf9054bb55f0a26fd22f39ecb72902e415b194c805d36959","unit:1acdbfde4891df21db56ffa8b5f06998c7c2cf160530a25da77bbacd7c1016ce","unit:1fcb591c2eef1d7f1736d14cfd5f0657c10cf46ddb378fc5fd9e59d1109495f2","unit:2674f97bb6735f1edb7f47b93d7fb1623efc998bbf2b6adba0f1f689fde9f1be","unit:27d263abd5f680ed64cfee2e4eb77251e3ce2b64cd8b73ad126f3915c8935ef0","unit:28cc3b8fbc59cb74cee255fb796373ce619cff34da0cf31634c5e2d8732b8aa0","unit:2f2938d98209cb969338ce98103c58ab91c049da31819e4948dd4a8822ef8e83","unit:31af791641d9d411fdcb39b65495daaa6e06ee362ade9b0cc4db58aa46392c30","unit:3d4f835fdc59859ee7b9157c2f4863e7109395619a126626d0e84d5e1446892c","unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","unit:4de21260a3f38d06ffab4dc22b77bc57d4ba402d91c7f824fd96b00ce06fadcd","unit:5445fafd9d26017758dbaa7433f3cbe949a3af250e6497e3805b2ca4fb0e8519","unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","unit:5eaebb7eb4a017d508dc306caa74107586604a60c58cb7975b986bf28c6a0edd","unit:6053bac8bf161b150fa458c69d59b73952c3968ce40e7e8d731f4cc54e9beb0d","unit:7405da195cb830f27b2cd597163f8f4435a5030c41d088896b6f666b1bb2db6a","unit:76a49116cbc95c35996540123dd8464c12375749fda6cb53b8eb0d40b4ac16ef","unit:776d2714eaa2908e98f60f1d7c25d49e5c3e6f1aae2174f39c5fb01013336f7f","unit:79976139a53921e2aa0f20cb46896dac1cecfc4e1d6e8097baecd2bb418fac06","unit:7b800fbd26a77b6f6922249f135456b7a385e564b6df99cfcab9ca40580b489b","unit:86af21b54647c64fd7c2b3569f2d026e5b45e3c8f1a37cc3f404acb867159cff","unit:86efc60d253adc4966dc41332d33c405445c3606812bc70e5ab4878cfdb1f254","unit:a000dcfeca9d2f236c7cdce6a4ca97192d10927cce49ee813f025249a246dc89","unit:aad39b2845e5af2bb362d37b3633ecfcb49ae168e6a897feecd4e3e1a83fbb2d","unit:b2e31b61079143fe03df0dd00ea5c401055d35bc1f5110a86266ea04e02e38fe","unit:b9edf5b2713f37a383fe3f32b780a20766f2e4f52f80444436a0343378f977d8","unit:be7f5ea1577349df1dfd2ec9eee1cb8ecdfee95d0c2e0bf5f3edabaf4e57eb2c","unit:bed792616c1d639d395b11b23c540ebfb15789613a361cb814a5ae83711f55e5","unit:bf7a3f7051d78debe2078ca945a826df58e3421a064511b9ce8db859c8cda024","unit:c284418d7af17bb525d9f7fb3efd2e260b2e41f58da03b18d0e534f5f0d2f067","unit:c2a49b73c2bedc55a18a13e1ca8c35a4218580bacb0da68b6c27f48fc72adb20","unit:c2b5e41e943b0473e5089ba598ef130ffb2472b981725ca11a500e88860850ee","unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","unit:d7be6dedc1f0ebe9db505a6d2a0e52bfc67bda19fb0d810974550e35b53ed7bb","unit:de324d1d16e0101503bea97360f20c0dfa8154f867190e310618e85bf19c8aeb","unit:e3b88af4e4e863af2d3399a4dad82e2ee43fae4307f0c7f37df20705928cff09","unit:ed0b94aa900b52dad4a70eb6d88da5c142d5210011dcb08c8d37a94c85b3c5eb","unit:f875b511a94b7fc9ec26a9f1b438271de93ba37ae0b3366b6f6c529681b71b82","unit:fbf8762cba530fed0884cb5771a786d3dfc6d5f7566db36f14bc92572be22b47","unit:fc9cb019f0353e5bf435ede88e1a49a7632b5d7d7ac9604a5393a3bb4f6d2d3a","unit:fe379acef869280e8dd5e98899501ac6ec3e3dd42cdeaeba4cf123c6630e5147","unit:fe8b057e0beaffaf96c3fcfa7f9c50cdb1c3f604eb9a187e10389094656a24bd"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","localRef":"s17"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","scopeContentSha256":"29f9bef9407be52a4a73021a58c1ea2b135a172ca9f15f97d64890e6b981f802","localRef":"s26"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l14","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge:link:22","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l14","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge:link:22","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l14","source":"s26","target":"s17","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Model-specific comparisons with dated observations apply primordial predictions without supplying a present-day refit."],"challengeStatement":"Model predictions enter source-dated observational comparisons without supplying a present-day fit.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"26a022dd4b863e0ced6b4826e51618e9d0b7380f8d2cad67f7c1f9130ce880ea","reply.jsonSha256":"b987ae93f8ffd76a516b4425eaa7d0d3849bd14888687cc3b116532a55388ae8","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ec4de6fea7a07a3033023321737adfca0e25899c2073f049812d6a063fa8421f","receipt.jsonSha256":"4e8fa714b927913b58cdd6387ee0d34bdbf24174f027664f7d4f0b5cebd477bd","normalization.jsonSha256":"dc53e8e8b717a6efea99a195ad19640af6b36dc85c27874db186e4c83683f86d","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"88800c9593a3b6977f7725f8e6d3bbc90ca17af3f685de2da11a65a33a5140eb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-e216581a59d87c4cff7a-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"cd12d5c8240730b408812cebb5e116777c80982d54964bca1d09587c6563ddd1","reply.jsonSha256":"75e9f54aeeee97495137739e9a6381a17deecba7f2cb866fb525786bffaa15b1","reply.raw.txtSha256":"6fe6b0497ccceec7c9ccd4d1481ddec505bb34ed09f4b563ff3f473409d97868","receipt.jsonSha256":"af67c1c01289866af5b6b1f05a10c997c353e6ea0801c936075ceff6af2d6617","normalization.jsonSha256":"cb226b20f4025a6f30cdb06945fa9b7fccf9374f9f31e8a63ef565997fd56f5a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d14","originalRef":"l14","status":"route","source":"s17","target":"s26","type":"application_of","title":"Trace model comparisons to their spectral predictions","rationale":"The paired statements explicitly describe model-specific observational comparisons as applying primordial predictions. The applied question is s17, and s26 supplies the underlying background-to-spectrum and reconstruction questions.","qualification":"The application concerns the relevant scalar and tensor spectral predictions, without making the full phenomenology of every model a power-spectrum application. Perturbation, reheating, pivot-to-end matching, crossing and e-fold prescriptions remain source-specific. Historical Planck, pre-Planck and BICEP2/Keck comparisons are not present-day refits. Model mechanisms remain distinct, and TCC is not a generic premise. Most supplied model calculations and fits remain description-supported.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l14","s17","s26"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d14","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify model comparisons as applications of primordial predictions. The reversed application direction is justified for the relevant spectral branch, and the qualification preserves source-specific perturbation and reheating prescriptions, historical datasets and the absence of a present-day refit.","refs":["l14","s17","s26"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l14","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l15":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l15","source":"q025-candidate-question:abb0ee1770a30f9a904d10bf","target":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","type":"premise_check","title":"Check FCNC control in flavour constructions","rationale":"Both statements say flavour constructions face unwanted flavour effects, and both explicitly identify FCNC control as required by the historical contrast. This supports a prerequisite check for the relevant constructions, rather than a general application of hierarchy generation to all phenomenological signatures.","qualification":"The prerequisite is limited to constructions and unwanted effects for which the requirement is supplied. It does not impose every EDM, magnetic-moment, mediator or collider target on every mass-and-mixing model. Representations, symmetry breaking, mediator parameters, suppression mechanisms and unknown coefficients remain model-specific; family gauging is not universal. The historical horizontal-gauge context has no readable scientific excerpt supplying an independently checked numerical constraint. Qualitative flavour safety is not a quantitative bound, and dated anomaly motivations remain dated.","evidenceIds":["unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","unit:123861fe64d4d7d9d08ec3123134ddb64a44d0d11cd7b576a4cab0ffdb6dca3f","unit:1a1b2cba9f689e035407cce5cbb6f8a1b2b37622a83873dd11b8a0483a96a858","unit:1bd246f4e25cb80b6922d9621cf9ac07ba3c06d2db5efcefd7eaa2b801858d07","unit:21a744432ea5c2a44b59461b33f566e28da299f1a95a899f29d4a6968855505b","unit:2f40897ce40985f0aed53d57525957da134aa1fab861226daa0e1fd329150f77","unit:399ccbcc371eaf4fcbe1b6f9d7a0ea891d1532fcca4ba6f61522f897a339de72","unit:4985c89fa8231b69b28c956e89653144a04b68f69420d5fe8edbd8c9af260cac","unit:4d30b938a4e74693c9c031450a15d142d396e693a15b3e4be560d256cc447722","unit:58f0248166912206ea1fd983aa0a1b4c564260a6586236766dc708392d9011d6","unit:59ad169bc432b1a2fce4e7e109256e7e48705a4d656e2ca3f3e33741889a4c0b","unit:64f0e51828d074a760e41412f8e80f24f22405feee97bbda8fcbad21545cd306","unit:69eb5a362799e584b33c1493d282a31733d29f8a495c6be5023ccebbfc6c83fd","unit:74c20818f2e83853c08634d70e09c533ea716a8164e60fd7c089fcbc35d80970","unit:7ee28f87899cceb297cbe7435d0e7fda91ab7e8853f3d7b83b4b56a8f31031b4","unit:92ddde398de33b59a195fa2a0fd7d3822950e3499a971b7ae2bee7735b39d70c","unit:a73f05de86b9bbd556c6838740af716b6069e20ee9380818ef33127c30345760","unit:b3fe97ce3b8f2cefa969015225420b6e1cd4ef763dafd872c525a99d20ef2d55","unit:b604821725804734b597284dab5fdbcfd4f268cd6eff23e3403e25c8f6624094","unit:c4e930ea2979f60b435134b88a1a398778d7172bcc08d7c06939fc02e20b7b6b","unit:cb9253be78362fb64ea474e1945b662db8219f8d10b44e6811a8c3a045a85b10","unit:cd84608a4681c6c6d3becc7daa0706eb390efcce7942ec0431574bf9c1d54101","unit:e146fe09bb6828d60898c0a4625fc5434c1b2daf47346a76385b62b62ff59e06","unit:e93860a130334815b30349340a5b1b0db004a5150a6e7364f6cfe7785a15be36","unit:fa83000a9e94b7442161dc086bebfff5c9132cda8e7b66599faef3f7b0775550","unit:fc1de7722afc529751e003268d80d727e569c3e288058775ccf55ea6f96a60d2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:abb0ee1770a30f9a904d10bf","scopeContentSha256":"93654a1968a9f53b35c515b7b669c80f2ee62892d26e072c251a7b77c08b236c","localRef":"s25"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","scopeContentSha256":"76c5d082026fd9a0d47bd5d09cd42348561556f627fab562e3c50e192dff0d48","localRef":"s9"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l15","originalCandidateId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge:link:16","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l15","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge:link:16","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:abb0ee1770a30f9a904d10bf","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l15","source":"s25","target":"s9","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Flavour construction can be tested through unwanted flavour effects and other signatures; the historical contrast explicitly requires FCNC control."],"challengeStatement":"Flavour constructions face unwanted flavour effects and observational tests; the historical contrast explicitly requires FCNC control.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4072febe985cef9457c25d65a66e5b2bbc71fd0a8016c6a1514e2a65f43f9009","reply.jsonSha256":"127b75b4054909d98ef3b0f749d7cd61f52677ec83e81088a9abd22ccfb48ee3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3224234ea5835881478a43caef9c09116995699c1aacef20b53206ab0b5a46fd","receipt.jsonSha256":"b28cd17dc8de75255112994b654547193fb9ae7c191278c5cf735931346dcfab","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7efcdab6567128d4e7c67450017dc07610665f3f48998af2ced594c6f865ffa","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"5d67631bd66b66bd5a948541529d1b35385a83ddfc241101b4464ec5d61d2350"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"593076f4b160ea4a7a928519728804eecce10020298e6c295d88bf79ad433eea","reply.jsonSha256":"bf7ef29bac3cb1cd5f2e2e00e91ae3758327a40acd5dd0e216cb85d02dd7ed6b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9d8011f7840c285b6477d716c6f02e4455b4419453e0b38053a5917896081c81","receipt.jsonSha256":"3c4b12ba86334bc2ef9c7b4e7e689446864a14a78974994c7ac17643691aa59d","normalization.jsonSha256":"f9c19cc85d80e02408edb2c9f95fab01a9f9e7fa52a0bbb5af702f378f07ca11"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-ph/0010144","sourceId":"ev:5f2c3a83d110af7a3f98025fdbbfc8c1","sourceSha256":"ee38bf7bb1c54f79a3984b59245baee1934184df8e1889ae55578f75274db652","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a627cdd9e69a96606469/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4e56e07e5171ff1c85ec26ab715efed31ffd1ec430d4657f1b29b7083f4380f0","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a1a326436025f4e2302942b0267f2144e9800e35346b302ebc511ee33b7bb486","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-ph/0010144","sourceId":"ev:5f2c3a83d110af7a3f98025fdbbfc8c1","sourceSha256":"ee38bf7bb1c54f79a3984b59245baee1934184df8e1889ae55578f75274db652","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a627cdd9e69a96606469/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4e56e07e5171ff1c85ec26ab715efed31ffd1ec430d4657f1b29b7083f4380f0","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a1a326436025f4e2302942b0267f2144e9800e35346b302ebc511ee33b7bb486","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d15","originalRef":"l15","status":"route","source":"s25","target":"s9","type":"premise_check","title":"Check FCNC control in flavour constructions","rationale":"Both statements say flavour constructions face unwanted flavour effects, and both explicitly identify FCNC control as required by the historical contrast. This supports a prerequisite check for the relevant constructions, rather than a general application of hierarchy generation to all phenomenological signatures.","qualification":"The prerequisite is limited to constructions and unwanted effects for which the requirement is supplied. It does not impose every EDM, magnetic-moment, mediator or collider target on every mass-and-mixing model. Representations, symmetry breaking, mediator parameters, suppression mechanisms and unknown coefficients remain model-specific; family gauging is not universal. The historical horizontal-gauge context has no readable scientific excerpt supplying an independently checked numerical constraint. Qualitative flavour safety is not a quantitative bound, and dated anomaly motivations remain dated.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l15","s25","s9"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d15","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements explicitly identify required FCNC control for the historical flavour construction. This supports a premise check from construction to the relevant phenomenological reliability question. The qualification avoids making every signature a prerequisite and retains the absence of an independently checked historical numerical constraint.","refs":["l15","s25","s9"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l15","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l16":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l16","source":"q025-candidate-question:50a72199b010ce93bbc70376","target":"q025-candidate-question:2957ddb1117e80052e226768","type":"method_for","title":"Apply consistency checks to protecting symmetries","rationale":"Anomaly and effective-description checks constrain proposed protecting symmetries. The source of those methods is s15, requiring reversal of the original methodological direction.","qualification":"Checks apply to the symmetry realization and effective description actually used by each protection model. Vanishing fermion anomalies and cancellation by another mechanism remain distinct; no universal cancellation mechanism or family-universality assumption is imposed. Full-theory consistency and low-energy matching are separate, and an anomaly-free global twist does not establish gauging. Permitted lepton-number violation need not permit proton decay, and forbidding a bare μ term can coexist with another μ-generation mechanism. No complete independent anomaly or operator analysis is claimed.","evidenceIds":["unit:0ec7a43507d417d909cb7e32bb2f82bc02fa953a89c31a2f642cd4fa3c5b75aa","unit:0fbe5f2b829f1d9dcb6dd8f5fdca2ea664765a1092c56cd5fc74271b78802a36","unit:1ba0c4834dc54837ff447f538552c7b360c02b4371d3fafc4f633ba4d6e5bccf","unit:1bd246f4e25cb80b6922d9621cf9ac07ba3c06d2db5efcefd7eaa2b801858d07","unit:1ce080ff73463a02b7abdb6c6750006a774b9c56b07b224fa9fe40dc01b25d41","unit:1d3373d617b699e5ad7fffbefca71afad78db2d1384190f848452bba7e555747","unit:214158575db7895e61b291be2fd6c448e66237af9eb52b93aae18829a39e2336","unit:2f40897ce40985f0aed53d57525957da134aa1fab861226daa0e1fd329150f77","unit:300579edcf4af9e13ae0bdf3069087e7c0e7a53fe52c8183db76da835a2d8660","unit:38e35bfd30ea71bbeb47bde9237c6f40f858445494d3887bb3a5d42fd9436d80","unit:399ccbcc371eaf4fcbe1b6f9d7a0ea891d1532fcca4ba6f61522f897a339de72","unit:4985c89fa8231b69b28c956e89653144a04b68f69420d5fe8edbd8c9af260cac","unit:59ad169bc432b1a2fce4e7e109256e7e48705a4d656e2ca3f3e33741889a4c0b","unit:62a31b86ebf537505fcc37d86e63113dd46c26f4034c35d993914335af66c33b","unit:64ed602c11d4649d5812da0812fd2618e3bbf8d8f1b26b3134b087569a67f5b4","unit:73401536cf9b22d15342dba710a94ce7b588d65f5b71416ab942994fd38282c7","unit:750f5a287fe874c364d04f9511eba80c74e0697abe98817a5abc12e97d0c24d6","unit:7ee28f87899cceb297cbe7435d0e7fda91ab7e8853f3d7b83b4b56a8f31031b4","unit:80428aec4757959a2a6f7118bc783a4aa0e2632b4b581af93b1b6f0727869e83","unit:8162a37584b22c7f9ea15454a130e44b59ce6c735878c75a9604cde9cd02f210","unit:a73f05de86b9bbd556c6838740af716b6069e20ee9380818ef33127c30345760","unit:adc0d95df7942e559e5152a47c04bb1b623e9f7a45bb73e7c854aadfb99836ed","unit:b3fe97ce3b8f2cefa969015225420b6e1cd4ef763dafd872c525a99d20ef2d55","unit:b604821725804734b597284dab5fdbcfd4f268cd6eff23e3403e25c8f6624094","unit:b6e7761181e5551efae43340632873bca426bbebaab492d3d54b47822df9a990","unit:cd84608a4681c6c6d3becc7daa0706eb390efcce7942ec0431574bf9c1d54101","unit:d17aca3e623b4e7ab0ceb4be3bfc4ad08abaf57b675caa288c841cd4f8b63963","unit:de5abbd4b0291f6aad6ab1f51ab7413aea3abbc0a4e66c6b12e02321fe9feb54","unit:e146fe09bb6828d60898c0a4625fc5434c1b2daf47346a76385b62b62ff59e06","unit:e3c21788eb512a42daf5308c52e6685c76cdc1a8ccf2f4d5ab1ed640acf95fb8","unit:e93860a130334815b30349340a5b1b0db004a5150a6e7364f6cfe7785a15be36","unit:fa83000a9e94b7442161dc086bebfff5c9132cda8e7b66599faef3f7b0775550","unit:fc1de7722afc529751e003268d80d727e569c3e288058775ccf55ea6f96a60d2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:50a72199b010ce93bbc70376","scopeContentSha256":"f16cda300158f6d3ed0eb9e60b0f3a0d6f4284b530777e947d83b7d2c2603385","localRef":"s15"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2957ddb1117e80052e226768","scopeContentSha256":"195f546106bb618b98eb2ce88d9716164a8d815cbca150bcfbc8cffee6fb00e3","localRef":"s7"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l16","originalCandidateId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge:link:23","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l16","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge:link:23","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:2957ddb1117e80052e226768","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:50a72199b010ce93bbc70376","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l16","source":"s7","target":"s15","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Anomaly and effective-description checks can constrain proposed protecting symmetries; no universal cancellation mechanism is assumed."],"challengeStatement":"Consistency checks constrain proposed protecting symmetries without requiring one universal anomaly-cancellation mechanism.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4072febe985cef9457c25d65a66e5b2bbc71fd0a8016c6a1514e2a65f43f9009","reply.jsonSha256":"127b75b4054909d98ef3b0f749d7cd61f52677ec83e81088a9abd22ccfb48ee3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3224234ea5835881478a43caef9c09116995699c1aacef20b53206ab0b5a46fd","receipt.jsonSha256":"b28cd17dc8de75255112994b654547193fb9ae7c191278c5cf735931346dcfab","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7efcdab6567128d4e7c67450017dc07610665f3f48998af2ced594c6f865ffa","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"5d67631bd66b66bd5a948541529d1b35385a83ddfc241101b4464ec5d61d2350"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"593076f4b160ea4a7a928519728804eecce10020298e6c295d88bf79ad433eea","reply.jsonSha256":"bf7ef29bac3cb1cd5f2e2e00e91ae3758327a40acd5dd0e216cb85d02dd7ed6b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9d8011f7840c285b6477d716c6f02e4455b4419453e0b38053a5917896081c81","receipt.jsonSha256":"3c4b12ba86334bc2ef9c7b4e7e689446864a14a78974994c7ac17643691aa59d","normalization.jsonSha256":"f9c19cc85d80e02408edb2c9f95fab01a9f9e7fa52a0bbb5af702f378f07ca11"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2957ddb1117e80052e226768"},{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:50a72199b010ce93bbc70376"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2957ddb1117e80052e226768"},{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:50a72199b010ce93bbc70376"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d16","originalRef":"l16","status":"route","source":"s15","target":"s7","type":"method_for","title":"Apply consistency checks to protecting symmetries","rationale":"Anomaly and effective-description checks constrain proposed protecting symmetries. The source of those methods is s15, requiring reversal of the original methodological direction.","qualification":"Checks apply to the symmetry realization and effective description actually used by each protection model. Vanishing fermion anomalies and cancellation by another mechanism remain distinct; no universal cancellation mechanism or family-universality assumption is imposed. Full-theory consistency and low-energy matching are separate, and an anomaly-free global twist does not establish gauging. Permitted lepton-number violation need not permit proton decay, and forbidding a bare μ term can coexist with another μ-generation mechanism. No complete independent anomaly or operator analysis is claimed.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l16","s15","s7"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d16","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Anomaly and effective-description checks in s15 supply methods for testing protecting symmetries in s7, requiring the proposed reversal. The record preserves distinct cancellation mechanisms, full-theory versus effective-theory checks and model-specific operator requirements.","refs":["l16","s15","s7"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l16","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l17":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l17","source":"q025-candidate-question:2bfbfa0a3ce49c01c495fa65","target":"q025-candidate-question:d5467bbc0dde52c78fb24608","type":"application_of","title":"Trace particle and rare-process tests to specified constructions","rationale":"The statements connect gauge-particle and rare-process tests to the constructions and scale choices they test. For those specified constructions, s8 is the applied phenomenological question and s30 is the underlying construction question.","qualification":"The original reviews identify a dark-dimension contribution and a GUT contrast respectively; this route does not infer their identity from those descriptions. Application is limited to the constructions actually supporting both targets, without assigning an ultraviolet embedding to every portal or collider model. Matter content, dimensions, thresholds, perturbative cutoffs and any conjecture-motivated cutoff remain source-specific. In the identified standard-like unification example, the proton-decaying X-boson premise and its mass definition of the GUT scale remain explicit. Gauge-coupling compatibility is not automatically conventional grand unification, and a TeV particle mass does not establish a low gravity cutoff.","evidenceIds":["unit:0e1bff7d169dd719d9c6c02411553da2c8feb75740648acf1a7feb5803411d7e","unit:1569b0bcf0a571e434364fadc401745e0e8de5af17b17b2bf7ffd71565911894","unit:1ba0c4834dc54837ff447f538552c7b360c02b4371d3fafc4f633ba4d6e5bccf","unit:2f40897ce40985f0aed53d57525957da134aa1fab861226daa0e1fd329150f77","unit:300579edcf4af9e13ae0bdf3069087e7c0e7a53fe52c8183db76da835a2d8660","unit:3154a18d87041eaf21d788edd3c3f0d414ccde556df38eddb067e03ece839551","unit:4985c89fa8231b69b28c956e89653144a04b68f69420d5fe8edbd8c9af260cac","unit:59ad169bc432b1a2fce4e7e109256e7e48705a4d656e2ca3f3e33741889a4c0b","unit:608a9c2a5b76f93c34c12e5a973b27748127a05296eca59d74211b1a72701cb1","unit:64ed602c11d4649d5812da0812fd2618e3bbf8d8f1b26b3134b087569a67f5b4","unit:6d910e883d0396fc23f453361a38bc771197604778241e0c8e9ce108befa65ea","unit:6dfb9f953438e8c32a9c38a8fed79ef19791d558e31d1e1e61e8eefc059d7abc","unit:74404a248d33fa3959b6d15e89b3e7ab78332fef17fb4ce97e6909ae9067bd31","unit:80428aec4757959a2a6f7118bc783a4aa0e2632b4b581af93b1b6f0727869e83","unit:9862914f0de48ca4eb8441e82be9768a77afba6900dff6c8c80c3758ac3a5f86","unit:98c1fb3f82848970d0a4015c84218894ba12555c0a4df9acd21b67be06a2df61","unit:a6ec4a26265d85592133514a868599d4ae8567acef6cc0f1ba850eb99c392ba2","unit:adc0d95df7942e559e5152a47c04bb1b623e9f7a45bb73e7c854aadfb99836ed","unit:b3fe97ce3b8f2cefa969015225420b6e1cd4ef763dafd872c525a99d20ef2d55","unit:b6e7761181e5551efae43340632873bca426bbebaab492d3d54b47822df9a990","unit:bfdc18c0fbb4877bf1ac6b1ecf0922dd0ec1c35e8466b63200f17e92b135f792","unit:c02f603d7473f05dc9ed26e78a0265cb49db543239f2a2c9a6bfa206de652b9f","unit:cd84608a4681c6c6d3becc7daa0706eb390efcce7942ec0431574bf9c1d54101","unit:de5abbd4b0291f6aad6ab1f51ab7413aea3abbc0a4e66c6b12e02321fe9feb54","unit:e146fe09bb6828d60898c0a4625fc5434c1b2daf47346a76385b62b62ff59e06"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2bfbfa0a3ce49c01c495fa65","scopeContentSha256":"898e7fc87f52003dfee82232c88622f9b279d711250d7eb0260fabd021053827","localRef":"s8"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d5467bbc0dde52c78fb24608","scopeContentSha256":"cc8146b1b70ebfa77b93ae33b3e5cda6fc04b31e8dd90ba8e7a0ab20d68254ac","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l17","originalCandidateId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge:link:25","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l17","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge:link:25","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:d5467bbc0dde52c78fb24608","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:2bfbfa0a3ce49c01c495fa65","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l17","source":"s30","target":"s8","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Connects construction and scale compatibility to rare-process and gauge-particle tests; the dark-dimension source contributes to both targets."],"challengeStatement":"Connects construction and scale compatibility to rare-process and gauge-particle tests; the GUT contrast contributes to both.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4072febe985cef9457c25d65a66e5b2bbc71fd0a8016c6a1514e2a65f43f9009","reply.jsonSha256":"127b75b4054909d98ef3b0f749d7cd61f52677ec83e81088a9abd22ccfb48ee3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3224234ea5835881478a43caef9c09116995699c1aacef20b53206ab0b5a46fd","receipt.jsonSha256":"b28cd17dc8de75255112994b654547193fb9ae7c191278c5cf735931346dcfab","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7efcdab6567128d4e7c67450017dc07610665f3f48998af2ced594c6f865ffa","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"5d67631bd66b66bd5a948541529d1b35385a83ddfc241101b4464ec5d61d2350"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"593076f4b160ea4a7a928519728804eecce10020298e6c295d88bf79ad433eea","reply.jsonSha256":"bf7ef29bac3cb1cd5f2e2e00e91ae3758327a40acd5dd0e216cb85d02dd7ed6b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9d8011f7840c285b6477d716c6f02e4455b4419453e0b38053a5917896081c81","receipt.jsonSha256":"3c4b12ba86334bc2ef9c7b4e7e689446864a14a78974994c7ac17643691aa59d","normalization.jsonSha256":"f9c19cc85d80e02408edb2c9f95fab01a9f9e7fa52a0bbb5af702f378f07ca11"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d5467bbc0dde52c78fb24608"},{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2bfbfa0a3ce49c01c495fa65"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"2409.01405","sourceId":"ev:51b7856e43932d8718fc2a941678609b","sourceSha256":"6a13c0b11904da9b2e58af2467623ce6790d36019d44497bfbf04bd153dc9d10","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca907c9443d88b080764/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9b1079ae2ebc7a080253b209e9c4b7a321d2b4d84db19b49721464b03787ce18","pdfPage":4,"start":96,"end":2948,"textSha256":"dbb0834e02047a6883eb0fdffd5d2755b18aa483c6cfd5be0c5013d13f8e5744","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"2409.01405","sourceId":"ev:f5def06f08a55a0de38b922f3721367f","sourceSha256":"6a13c0b11904da9b2e58af2467623ce6790d36019d44497bfbf04bd153dc9d10","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca907c9443d88b080764/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9b1079ae2ebc7a080253b209e9c4b7a321d2b4d84db19b49721464b03787ce18","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"426a566b3ce579f92e338f222955859fac2f1bbf0140265b4f22882251f4ec78","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d5467bbc0dde52c78fb24608"},{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2bfbfa0a3ce49c01c495fa65"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"2409.01405","sourceId":"ev:51b7856e43932d8718fc2a941678609b","sourceSha256":"6a13c0b11904da9b2e58af2467623ce6790d36019d44497bfbf04bd153dc9d10","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca907c9443d88b080764/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9b1079ae2ebc7a080253b209e9c4b7a321d2b4d84db19b49721464b03787ce18","pdfPage":4,"start":96,"end":2948,"textSha256":"dbb0834e02047a6883eb0fdffd5d2755b18aa483c6cfd5be0c5013d13f8e5744","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"2409.01405","sourceId":"ev:f5def06f08a55a0de38b922f3721367f","sourceSha256":"6a13c0b11904da9b2e58af2467623ce6790d36019d44497bfbf04bd153dc9d10","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca907c9443d88b080764/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9b1079ae2ebc7a080253b209e9c4b7a321d2b4d84db19b49721464b03787ce18","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"426a566b3ce579f92e338f222955859fac2f1bbf0140265b4f22882251f4ec78","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d17","originalRef":"l17","status":"route","source":"s8","target":"s30","type":"application_of","title":"Trace particle and rare-process tests to specified constructions","rationale":"The statements connect gauge-particle and rare-process tests to the constructions and scale choices they test. For those specified constructions, s8 is the applied phenomenological question and s30 is the underlying construction question.","qualification":"The original reviews identify a dark-dimension contribution and a GUT contrast respectively; this route does not infer their identity from those descriptions. Application is limited to the constructions actually supporting both targets, without assigning an ultraviolet embedding to every portal or collider model. Matter content, dimensions, thresholds, perturbative cutoffs and any conjecture-motivated cutoff remain source-specific. In the identified standard-like unification example, the proton-decaying X-boson premise and its mass definition of the GUT scale remain explicit. Gauge-coupling compatibility is not automatically conventional grand unification, and a TeV particle mass does not establish a low gravity cutoff.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l17","s8","s30"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d17","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements support the construction-to-test connection. The reversed application is confined to phenomenological branches backed by the specified constructions. Its qualification preserves the differently described dark-dimension and GUT contributions without asserting their identity, and does not assign ultraviolet embeddings to unrelated portals.","refs":["l17","s8","s30"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l17","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l18":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l18","source":"q025-candidate-question:853184ca0ee505c2c2ed2b9f","target":"q025-candidate-question:18dc4f4eb6b419ff578229eb","type":"method_for","title":"Use gravity–matter fixed points for conditional neutrino questions","rationale":"The specified fixed-point and gravity–matter framework supplies a methodology for the asymptotic-safety branch of the broader conditional neutrino question. The method direction therefore runs from s21 to s0.","qualification":"Applicability is restricted to the modeled gravity–matter system and calculation. The Higgs–Yukawa toy model and extended Standard Model neutrino sectors remain distinct, including independently treated left- and right-handed Majorana masses where supplied. Additional matter, a type-I seesaw scale and pseudo-Dirac accommodation are announced research questions, not supplied final answers; the seesaw assumption remains conditional. The stated negative beta-function Jacobian convention for critical exponents is retained. This framework is not transferred to flux statistics, Casimir arguments or conjectural neutrino-charge bounds.","evidenceIds":["unit:56db74ccf51c16edaacf4a055fb27ea2e502dc8f5439ea9696af73931a683e37","unit:a4bbc70b8ff90545022c6fa62957effdbb1088c81878ce4432b41ef9bcd2fbd7","unit:b8aa51ab780cbeb99abc5f746d9535da6fa5e61f4f3c50998e356f99c3d77221","unit:d957ce179aae781e89f1096222425c5c5be55113a531c7ef0b0a9d098496b3f5","unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:853184ca0ee505c2c2ed2b9f","scopeContentSha256":"d7f4179f42c2423c777965aed9c0d022a821f2f15b795396f1726908c66ca642","localRef":"s21"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:18dc4f4eb6b419ff578229eb","scopeContentSha256":"9ca20718cf1f1d3af91343e9b539d67581cf470622898403a6eacf2fcea84d64","localRef":"s0"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l18","originalCandidateId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge:link:36","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l18","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge:link:36","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:18dc4f4eb6b419ff578229eb","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:853184ca0ee505c2c2ed2b9f","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l18","source":"s0","target":"s21","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Provides a specific fixed-point and gravity–matter framework route; its stated research questions are not supplied final answers."],"challengeStatement":"Provides a specific fixed-point and gravity–matter framework route; announced research questions do not establish their answers.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4072febe985cef9457c25d65a66e5b2bbc71fd0a8016c6a1514e2a65f43f9009","reply.jsonSha256":"127b75b4054909d98ef3b0f749d7cd61f52677ec83e81088a9abd22ccfb48ee3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3224234ea5835881478a43caef9c09116995699c1aacef20b53206ab0b5a46fd","receipt.jsonSha256":"b28cd17dc8de75255112994b654547193fb9ae7c191278c5cf735931346dcfab","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7efcdab6567128d4e7c67450017dc07610665f3f48998af2ced594c6f865ffa","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"5d67631bd66b66bd5a948541529d1b35385a83ddfc241101b4464ec5d61d2350"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"593076f4b160ea4a7a928519728804eecce10020298e6c295d88bf79ad433eea","reply.jsonSha256":"bf7ef29bac3cb1cd5f2e2e00e91ae3758327a40acd5dd0e216cb85d02dd7ed6b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9d8011f7840c285b6477d716c6f02e4455b4419453e0b38053a5917896081c81","receipt.jsonSha256":"3c4b12ba86334bc2ef9c7b4e7e689446864a14a78974994c7ac17643691aa59d","normalization.jsonSha256":"f9c19cc85d80e02408edb2c9f95fab01a9f9e7fa52a0bbb5af702f378f07ca11"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:18dc4f4eb6b419ff578229eb"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:853184ca0ee505c2c2ed2b9f"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:18dc4f4eb6b419ff578229eb"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:853184ca0ee505c2c2ed2b9f"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d18","originalRef":"l18","status":"route","source":"s21","target":"s0","type":"method_for","title":"Use gravity–matter fixed points for conditional neutrino questions","rationale":"The specified fixed-point and gravity–matter framework supplies a methodology for the asymptotic-safety branch of the broader conditional neutrino question. The method direction therefore runs from s21 to s0.","qualification":"Applicability is restricted to the modeled gravity–matter system and calculation. The Higgs–Yukawa toy model and extended Standard Model neutrino sectors remain distinct, including independently treated left- and right-handed Majorana masses where supplied. Additional matter, a type-I seesaw scale and pseudo-Dirac accommodation are announced research questions, not supplied final answers; the seesaw assumption remains conditional. The stated negative beta-function Jacobian convention for critical exponents is retained. This framework is not transferred to flux statistics, Casimir arguments or conjectural neutrino-charge bounds.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l18","s21","s0"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d18","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The paired statements identify a fixed-point gravity–matter framework, which supplies a method for the asymptotic-safety branch of s0. The reversed direction and branch restriction are correct; announced questions, toy-model conclusions and the conditional seesaw assumption are not promoted to general results.","refs":["l18","s21","s0"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l18","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l19":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l19","source":"q025-candidate-question:82487b8cbf0848b5967846bd","target":"q025-candidate-question:f269ccb237ccbb2f2c408d09","type":"application_of","title":"Trace axion and dark-sector protection to symmetry mechanisms","rationale":"Both statements connect axion and dark-sector applications to symmetry-protection mechanisms. The applied question is s20, while s35 addresses the underlying protection and breaking mechanisms.","qualification":"The application concerns the shared protection branches, not every inflationary or leptogenesis target in s20. Continuous global, discrete global and discrete gauge symmetries remain distinct. Absence of exact global symmetries is conjectural where imported, and an explicit breaking operator does not establish a quantum-gravity origin. Exact stability, long lifetime and cosmological viability are separate; PQ quality depends on the stated operators and symmetry realization. An invisible axion description does not establish abundance, and shared fields do not establish a common candidate or production history. The supplied connections do not certify relic abundance, inflationary fits or successful leptogenesis.","evidenceIds":["unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","unit:214158575db7895e61b291be2fd6c448e66237af9eb52b93aae18829a39e2336","unit:399ccbcc371eaf4fcbe1b6f9d7a0ea891d1532fcca4ba6f61522f897a339de72","unit:4d3677317631c14b4fcad88b577bcac591899284c801175a3463b273c01d9e77","unit:4f049859f707f7834d3cc98739ff54b200e3450e1e270e55a8c560dee00fce96","unit:62a31b86ebf537505fcc37d86e63113dd46c26f4034c35d993914335af66c33b","unit:64ed602c11d4649d5812da0812fd2618e3bbf8d8f1b26b3134b087569a67f5b4","unit:75b46ea666ae309741f9dfec54b4099f3afb4a7787dae7f2d3b5e43448867e2a","unit:b836d9b17db4cd34ebf17ebf064223393f040c51326b6b8c6f11c9fc98cde03f","unit:bdbf9454dd950c72ac9186ab32df0774042f836892da1235f5b4b2fd7b8bffad","unit:bfdc18c0fbb4877bf1ac6b1ecf0922dd0ec1c35e8466b63200f17e92b135f792","unit:c4e930ea2979f60b435134b88a1a398778d7172bcc08d7c06939fc02e20b7b6b","unit:ce62879f25c258487bd7608b5c42ab12ae87f6a512980b86cd141b9ccd29f9a4","unit:d05b5922f4235a137bbf127916b9f17a55123c0e07a7892b6289d0dd27f93a6f","unit:d6862937b4740fdd97d81c653a82586042b2524ad12347d8486ff790ed2b6433","unit:e93860a130334815b30349340a5b1b0db004a5150a6e7364f6cfe7785a15be36","unit:eeac2ed43d8538749ddd9470df255cd855e57f0aa2ce9fe5b9fa02ab5007816b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:82487b8cbf0848b5967846bd","scopeContentSha256":"7fa8cd8d9bbf2124faa0e7040d2c681f3ae38bf88f5bff724a999b7c7dbea9f3","localRef":"s20"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f269ccb237ccbb2f2c408d09","scopeContentSha256":"4f61ad9894040f677257995430cd9de4926d805c3d462d22cdc568ffe1690685","localRef":"s35"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l19","originalCandidateId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge:link:37","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l19","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge:link:37","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:f269ccb237ccbb2f2c408d09","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:82487b8cbf0848b5967846bd","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l19","source":"s35","target":"s20","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Connects symmetry protection to axion and dark-sector applications while distinguishing exact stability, longevity and cosmological viability."],"challengeStatement":"Connects symmetry protection to axion and dark-sector applications while preserving distinctions between stability, longevity and cosmological viability.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4072febe985cef9457c25d65a66e5b2bbc71fd0a8016c6a1514e2a65f43f9009","reply.jsonSha256":"127b75b4054909d98ef3b0f749d7cd61f52677ec83e81088a9abd22ccfb48ee3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3224234ea5835881478a43caef9c09116995699c1aacef20b53206ab0b5a46fd","receipt.jsonSha256":"b28cd17dc8de75255112994b654547193fb9ae7c191278c5cf735931346dcfab","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7efcdab6567128d4e7c67450017dc07610665f3f48998af2ced594c6f865ffa","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"5d67631bd66b66bd5a948541529d1b35385a83ddfc241101b4464ec5d61d2350"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d52c5745cd04bfaaf51d-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"593076f4b160ea4a7a928519728804eecce10020298e6c295d88bf79ad433eea","reply.jsonSha256":"bf7ef29bac3cb1cd5f2e2e00e91ae3758327a40acd5dd0e216cb85d02dd7ed6b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9d8011f7840c285b6477d716c6f02e4455b4419453e0b38053a5917896081c81","receipt.jsonSha256":"3c4b12ba86334bc2ef9c7b4e7e689446864a14a78974994c7ac17643691aa59d","normalization.jsonSha256":"f9c19cc85d80e02408edb2c9f95fab01a9f9e7fa52a0bbb5af702f378f07ca11"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f269ccb237ccbb2f2c408d09"},{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:82487b8cbf0848b5967846bd"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f269ccb237ccbb2f2c408d09"},{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:82487b8cbf0848b5967846bd"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d19","originalRef":"l19","status":"route","source":"s20","target":"s35","type":"application_of","title":"Trace axion and dark-sector protection to symmetry mechanisms","rationale":"Both statements connect axion and dark-sector applications to symmetry-protection mechanisms. The applied question is s20, while s35 addresses the underlying protection and breaking mechanisms.","qualification":"The application concerns the shared protection branches, not every inflationary or leptogenesis target in s20. Continuous global, discrete global and discrete gauge symmetries remain distinct. Absence of exact global symmetries is conjectural where imported, and an explicit breaking operator does not establish a quantum-gravity origin. Exact stability, long lifetime and cosmological viability are separate; PQ quality depends on the stated operators and symmetry realization. An invisible axion description does not establish abundance, and shared fields do not establish a common candidate or production history. The supplied connections do not certify relic abundance, inflationary fits or successful leptogenesis.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l19","s20","s35"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d19","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original reasoning explicitly connects dark-sector and axion applications to symmetry-protection mechanisms. The reversed application is limited to those shared branches and preserves distinctions among symmetry realizations, exact stability, longevity, PQ quality and cosmological viability.","refs":["l19","s20","s35"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l19","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l20":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l20","source":"q025-candidate-region:a57a8295d18da404582887ac","target":"q025-candidate-question:247a94092548b630ad781040","type":"related_question","title":"Explore magnetic-relic and warped-dimension probes","rationale":"The statements support observational connections to distinct black-hole-related sectors. The broad exploratory region supplies no single method or construction that all magnetic-relic and warped-dimension observations apply.","qualification":"Magnetic-relic abundance, enclosed net magnetic charge and spin-based constraints on ultralight spin-2 KK towers are different observables and mechanisms. Monopoles and magnetic black holes remain alternative interpretations, and the warped-dimension spin question supplies no charged or extremal-black-hole premise. No common population, numerical bound or current exclusion is asserted. Observational support is description-only. This connection does not independently admit the newly authored parent region or its pending child scopes.","evidenceIds":["unit:0f3f7ba9a79195a39e0ff616b7a71ead79494c7eec1ade776956b1782aab311a","unit:145a3df72cea777bbc4b03efb5b9d7501a4fe473fdd070f8d634c258553dd062","unit:1c6d9de4bce931fdd7703796693240c867e543d658214a42846ae5b2f411ce61","unit:6260e0e141321b5108335e18494f7cc739fd304c1862ccd9ac79a67a094ff5d1","unit:95609cc4e7bb836fab3f8d5763087c674eec09ef7452e10e98b4254798c27011","unit:97cb894352e33156d277920f062a66695201b9e1fd7f5521d700fa6d61177819","unit:dc0d2b2fc6e6b5fbc269e66c98f119dd4b095f5933c5f4bb09115759eead5374","unit:e21e422c35f84f9dce782a6a400e570453c146b1bce9d01624f68f3b7e5f3748"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:a57a8295d18da404582887ac","scopeContentSha256":"9259927d41c3eaddd065f3235a1b975c947bae46e5d6cd1f530b74b8d0e09c2c","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:247a94092548b630ad781040","scopeContentSha256":"78c08922ca30c64978e9f10b555ccdb7b62c8552766e97f9b04872108c9563c2","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l20","originalCandidateId":"parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge:link:13","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l20","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge:link:13","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:a57a8295d18da404582887ac","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:247a94092548b630ad781040","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l20","source":"s39","target":"s5","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Magnetic-relic and warped-dimension observations test different sectors; no common population or current bound is asserted."],"challengeStatement":"Magnetic-relic and warped-dimension observations probe separate sectors; no common population or current exclusion is asserted.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c00ff9f669c2d036fa1bcb30ef4b99ce5a6dde85f700160cfce19e80c799a1c9","reply.jsonSha256":"5fb4089c285d0ed61fb2dc5bf7ab98cab2877bfa9b30ab497dc1722558a0372e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"48d49aa0869fdc876c1e1679087458a07a957d7c15e5c10eabf57160d5f5a030","receipt.jsonSha256":"e895d58d05cfa054be96879032625a011287887b792388f9ce176ca4bd05148c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f2556ca8cbd16ebc1bed21c03f34f8a9a7e5b57540d4f729539938e966e55c07","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a51fd97e15010788cf5754354e902bc7cdc740b8ad519421b52440beb94c484b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8b4d7646af50b84e8e8109e4e0585ad63db32f1ae4c044e2f5579b735b19d30f","reply.jsonSha256":"c6936586ea6c476dfae41382a5e1247668eda8d16484a4b20999bd634e26bc8a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"e24c060a50886ef7301be9c85977ef227cf90aa73575d5757dd8f4958830b580","receipt.jsonSha256":"a703f9f09755d10b216f54d72227a3744bb47e8ee4331606da91dd9da1adc436","normalization.jsonSha256":"e1424163c0eb09e08a60284f41bedd44f639b04aef69f88438f5a7829181afab"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:247a94092548b630ad781040"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:247a94092548b630ad781040"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d20","originalRef":"l20","status":"route","source":"s39","target":"s5","type":"related_question","title":"Explore magnetic-relic and warped-dimension probes","rationale":"The statements support observational connections to distinct black-hole-related sectors. The broad exploratory region supplies no single method or construction that all magnetic-relic and warped-dimension observations apply.","qualification":"Magnetic-relic abundance, enclosed net magnetic charge and spin-based constraints on ultralight spin-2 KK towers are different observables and mechanisms. Monopoles and magnetic black holes remain alternative interpretations, and the warped-dimension spin question supplies no charged or extremal-black-hole premise. No common population, numerical bound or current exclusion is asserted. Observational support is description-only. This connection does not independently admit the newly authored parent region or its pending child scopes.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l20","s39","s5"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d20","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The broad black-hole region supplies observational context without identifying a common construction applied by all of s5. Related_question is justified, and its qualification preserves the separate observables, alternative magnetic interpretations, absence of a charged-hole premise for the KK probe and pending scope admission.","refs":["l20","s39","s5"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l20","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l21":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l21","source":"q025-candidate-question:dfd957f1176fb30606c06f33","target":"q025-candidate-question:d9e9e00415abb7105f05f79c","type":"application_of","title":"Examine the discharge physics behind dark-charge PBH survival","rationale":"Dark-charge primordial-black-hole survival applies emission, discharge and lifetime analysis to a conditional cosmological scenario. The applied question is s34, requiring reversal of the original application direction.","qualification":"The dark charged spectrum and coupling control the stated suppression of Hawking emission and Schwinger discharge. Mass-and-charge-dependent thresholds retain their modeled geometry, backreaction and boundary conditions, including near-extremality in the 11 June 2019 v1 context. Cosmological longevity is finite-time survival, not exact stability. A WGC inequality alone supplies no discharge rate. Possible dark matter and merger-induced radiation remain conditional, without a verified present-day abundance fit, current observational bound or complete signal forecast.","evidenceIds":["unit:143d93388147d279b650be4b61634a1631aa2be664cfb3aa810025ca8e3984f7","unit:1834f4b5e0ec8ae541bf2af110d283008c3197872ea91eb59958386dca077eb9","unit:2072546c33c7beab8e62e690504370dc9e8cb749bd0ea68b412c643706ca940e","unit:2a292d9c1f609e6b7b62503b0606bbb682b3d64055262aad8acfa0e6be8c76b6","unit:3c8e3edc0617fdf6f99991a291884bf52d86a543efbc494ebb93486c824d470c","unit:48d159e6ec1b6e90f62ea33493ecc393688701e840a04f196b4fe7ed0fe76373","unit:49f038a6240393ef3562478a459444ca77c77d934ad799f75e4708cb5e957cab","unit:530da9a14202edd3f640458385ba13f8bb5818132ec972130e5836d253d4a239","unit:565b7ff08372b2e5678b6addd4274268ae7a4773323149e8b064129b9013008c","unit:60176c056a981821ae51ac8415d8413e091f389281336bf6b558de555075ac93","unit:628ddeb6d1147c1586be4269d21e3008f4cee6841751649478a2383137fba1ae","unit:62b0fc57ba710c6a81d38c5fa4efe1e4bd57e1d8d6d3c04802355eb9d68fca00","unit:6df39bcb6b52192e783e45e332d170619d74452ddfa32f036f52c1457ca2c8e1","unit:72adc931d1154a2532da4df175555681ba6f4398e90b9d459a0751c90029c4cf","unit:72bbb8d97766ebab58410a0c0b1cea282137820056cabaf3c12c763d7b5ac8c3","unit:7df1c85da845450c9716b165c05aa684929f21e5fec2536297b438c8c216a6b1","unit:8223ed8ebb386b7371b4da04d99a06fbb6fd076fca118d4bbd5ea3b42f9d4d20","unit:8f15f6385386378b356ad6e3313e4da862585485372f2311c4a2e2ac92ffe4ab","unit:9949abe3cef17ebfb0e5d2cd9710c430cf1b97b59043a1e02c5c2de088da554f","unit:aa187c3dd3581f687242bc9e00d3c89aba683ff9177b0014ae3df06a6b1eace8","unit:b60bdb72c08ffc5ad3d28ff091ddc05bcc76edf0c54e64ea1e5dbb4277b5b7e3","unit:c392c2786cf154d281bc04b2155bb1493eef379545d168bc8322bfb97b56c934","unit:e3bab4a9180ade0203f4e0a68a6acdf8868aaa8e6eea84e3b8dd9810bee72e17","unit:ebe88f5466f4479a35649d43d9643c65bdcc0e36cab1fd4c7450032da8680838"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:dfd957f1176fb30606c06f33","scopeContentSha256":"76b342105292cf6e6cc51271695760a062580b4ad8a90c2eaa45cfe22baf54b7","localRef":"s34"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d9e9e00415abb7105f05f79c","scopeContentSha256":"b72120f90e80c8290f6ea0c025b4d2afeae38105e0fcf11341081b2208a64df9","localRef":"s31"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l21","originalCandidateId":"parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge:link:32","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l21","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge:link:32","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:d9e9e00415abb7105f05f79c","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:dfd957f1176fb30606c06f33","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l21","source":"s31","target":"s34","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Dark-charge primordial-black-hole survival applies discharge and lifetime questions to a conditional cosmological setting."],"challengeStatement":"Dark-charge primordial-black-hole survival applies discharge and lifetime questions to a conditional cosmological scenario with its original dated evidence.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c00ff9f669c2d036fa1bcb30ef4b99ce5a6dde85f700160cfce19e80c799a1c9","reply.jsonSha256":"5fb4089c285d0ed61fb2dc5bf7ab98cab2877bfa9b30ab497dc1722558a0372e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"48d49aa0869fdc876c1e1679087458a07a957d7c15e5c10eabf57160d5f5a030","receipt.jsonSha256":"e895d58d05cfa054be96879032625a011287887b792388f9ce176ca4bd05148c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f2556ca8cbd16ebc1bed21c03f34f8a9a7e5b57540d4f729539938e966e55c07","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a51fd97e15010788cf5754354e902bc7cdc740b8ad519421b52440beb94c484b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8b4d7646af50b84e8e8109e4e0585ad63db32f1ae4c044e2f5579b735b19d30f","reply.jsonSha256":"c6936586ea6c476dfae41382a5e1247668eda8d16484a4b20999bd634e26bc8a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"e24c060a50886ef7301be9c85977ef227cf90aa73575d5757dd8f4958830b580","receipt.jsonSha256":"a703f9f09755d10b216f54d72227a3744bb47e8ee4331606da91dd9da1adc436","normalization.jsonSha256":"e1424163c0eb09e08a60284f41bedd44f639b04aef69f88438f5a7829181afab"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:dfd957f1176fb30606c06f33"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:dfd957f1176fb30606c06f33"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d21","originalRef":"l21","status":"route","source":"s34","target":"s31","type":"application_of","title":"Examine the discharge physics behind dark-charge PBH survival","rationale":"Dark-charge primordial-black-hole survival applies emission, discharge and lifetime analysis to a conditional cosmological scenario. The applied question is s34, requiring reversal of the original application direction.","qualification":"The dark charged spectrum and coupling control the stated suppression of Hawking emission and Schwinger discharge. Mass-and-charge-dependent thresholds retain their modeled geometry, backreaction and boundary conditions, including near-extremality in the 11 June 2019 v1 context. Cosmological longevity is finite-time survival, not exact stability. A WGC inequality alone supplies no discharge rate. Possible dark matter and merger-induced radiation remain conditional, without a verified present-day abundance fit, current observational bound or complete signal forecast.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l21","s34","s31"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d21","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Dark-charge PBH survival is explicitly an application of emission, discharge and lifetime questions, so s34 → s31 is correct. The record preserves the dark-spectrum dependence, near-extremal and dated source context, finite-time meaning of longevity and limits on abundance and signal claims.","refs":["l21","s34","s31"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l21","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l22":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l22","source":"q025-candidate-question:1f3d727ece026a0670a4cdb1","target":"q025-candidate-question:54eddf77515ba26f22851839","type":"comparison","title":"Compare Kerr damping with relaxation-to-WGC arguments","rationale":"Both statements explicitly contrast Kerr damping comparisons with proposed relaxation-to-WGC inference, emphasizing additional thermalization assumptions and normalization checks. This supports comparison with non-transfer limits, rather than either direction of premise implication.","qualification":"The CFT thermalization premise remains conjectural and independently unestablished here. Its relaxation-time normalization must not be identified with the Kerr damping threshold. The Kerr, Kerr–Newman and Reissner–Nordström sectors in s3 are not identified with the charged-scalar RNdS or holographic HSV and Kerr–Newman–AdS settings in s16. Field sectors, couplings, mode labels, damping signs, mass normalization and orders of limits remain explicit. Dudley–Finley sectors remain distinct from coupled gravito-electromagnetic perturbations, and fixed-mode comparisons do not establish globally least-damped behavior. WGC and Festina-Lente inputs or proposed outputs retain their stated direction and conjectural status; no universal SCC target or WGC proof follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:09b1d263ea0af87c59b8c615e1c5b7fba1883f740987a48a0df536be7390498c","unit:0f3f7ba9a79195a39e0ff616b7a71ead79494c7eec1ade776956b1782aab311a","unit:1c6d9de4bce931fdd7703796693240c867e543d658214a42846ae5b2f411ce61","unit:4bea2236adce2a83cf3c451f430db2b31ccbb60826ec94caf64e9a0ca2613854","unit:7bf4bd3a8935302c15057334958e89cdfed7cf4a5930f6a2ba758513eec88130","unit:d3f5b55db4a44f1242a1e7d55aa8537cef7c92ac8fdf3ab106110092aee93643","unit:d8efc3c113d9682ae66c3f4f2a4291e4ae73e03ca649880fde809a5da49d2d12","unit:df55ebc8a474485011f53ee5b3441b949228d4863fe885a7baea3ea4b38b809a","unit:f2107ba4391515831703f47d5d2f16773f60be9737f4c55764ce5ceeb6fd5603","unit:fbc21f1bbe6b9d93460c81b998bfdeec6d15061b26c6abe7a25b081bb1691970"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f3d727ece026a0670a4cdb1","scopeContentSha256":"7696ef6f85706ddcd370d496164a9387bf3e17cf342dbdff2f23cc43e4cf6341","localRef":"s3"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:54eddf77515ba26f22851839","scopeContentSha256":"02dd21510070662929153dd0e5044d56b92bd30032a4a27b52ff91ec85e64408","localRef":"s16"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l22","originalCandidateId":"parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge:link:40","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l22","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge:link:40","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:1f3d727ece026a0670a4cdb1","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:54eddf77515ba26f22851839","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l22","source":"s3","target":"s16","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["Proposed relaxation-to-WGC arguments require additional thermalization premises and conventions; Kerr damping comparisons do not establish that implication."],"challengeStatement":"Proposed relaxation-to-WGC arguments require additional thermalization assumptions and normalization checks; the Kerr damping comparison supplies no such implication.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c00ff9f669c2d036fa1bcb30ef4b99ce5a6dde85f700160cfce19e80c799a1c9","reply.jsonSha256":"5fb4089c285d0ed61fb2dc5bf7ab98cab2877bfa9b30ab497dc1722558a0372e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"48d49aa0869fdc876c1e1679087458a07a957d7c15e5c10eabf57160d5f5a030","receipt.jsonSha256":"e895d58d05cfa054be96879032625a011287887b792388f9ce176ca4bd05148c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f2556ca8cbd16ebc1bed21c03f34f8a9a7e5b57540d4f729539938e966e55c07","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a51fd97e15010788cf5754354e902bc7cdc740b8ad519421b52440beb94c484b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8b4d7646af50b84e8e8109e4e0585ad63db32f1ae4c044e2f5579b735b19d30f","reply.jsonSha256":"c6936586ea6c476dfae41382a5e1247668eda8d16484a4b20999bd634e26bc8a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"e24c060a50886ef7301be9c85977ef227cf90aa73575d5757dd8f4958830b580","receipt.jsonSha256":"a703f9f09755d10b216f54d72227a3744bb47e8ee4331606da91dd9da1adc436","normalization.jsonSha256":"e1424163c0eb09e08a60284f41bedd44f639b04aef69f88438f5a7829181afab"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:54eddf77515ba26f22851839"},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"0705.1725","sourceId":"ev:b1a1ff25f9519d77e90a14d8c0011b54","sourceSha256":"2bba4875483f57551e1e629610df6f083fdae240bf8bf974c7d60239a9637dad","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ef5dbc584628a9345ec9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"93bfc490313e55cbb1df773fc2d51d8efae34310a7ce633ace78966839e84ed9","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":1354,"textSha256":"731c4b74d85f9c70b0d5319f5e2bbfc5d39ea609da0a6747576d2073f579b789","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:54eddf77515ba26f22851839"},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"0705.1725","sourceId":"ev:b1a1ff25f9519d77e90a14d8c0011b54","sourceSha256":"2bba4875483f57551e1e629610df6f083fdae240bf8bf974c7d60239a9637dad","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ef5dbc584628a9345ec9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"93bfc490313e55cbb1df773fc2d51d8efae34310a7ce633ace78966839e84ed9","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":1354,"textSha256":"731c4b74d85f9c70b0d5319f5e2bbfc5d39ea609da0a6747576d2073f579b789","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d22","originalRef":"l22","status":"route","source":"s3","target":"s16","type":"comparison","title":"Compare Kerr damping with relaxation-to-WGC arguments","rationale":"Both statements explicitly contrast Kerr damping comparisons with proposed relaxation-to-WGC inference, emphasizing additional thermalization assumptions and normalization checks. This supports comparison with non-transfer limits, rather than either direction of premise implication.","qualification":"The CFT thermalization premise remains conjectural and independently unestablished here. Its relaxation-time normalization must not be identified with the Kerr damping threshold. The Kerr, Kerr–Newman and Reissner–Nordström sectors in s3 are not identified with the charged-scalar RNdS or holographic HSV and Kerr–Newman–AdS settings in s16. Field sectors, couplings, mode labels, damping signs, mass normalization and orders of limits remain explicit. Dudley–Finley sectors remain distinct from coupled gravito-electromagnetic perturbations, and fixed-mode comparisons do not establish globally least-damped behavior. WGC and Festina-Lente inputs or proposed outputs retain their stated direction and conjectural status; no universal SCC target or WGC proof follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l22","s3","s16"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d22","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The paired statements explicitly contrast Kerr damping comparisons with relaxation-to-WGC inference and identify non-transfer limits. Comparison preserves that content without inventing a premise-check link to an endpoint that does not establish the CFT thermalization premise. Normalizations, sectors, mode selection and conjectural status remain distinct.","refs":["l22","s3","s16"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l22","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l23":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l23","source":"q025-candidate-question:44d11612f54d20c253297e73","target":"q025-candidate-question:da2b38749f8c655a444b47b0","type":"application_of","title":"Examine Nariai constructions underlying creation instantons","rationale":"Where an appropriate instanton interpretation is supported, inflationary black-hole creation applies a Nariai realization. The applied creation question is s12, so the application direction is reversed.","qualification":"The route retains the appropriate-background requirement, particularly for the supplied dilatonic charged-Nariai branch. It does not extend an instanton interpretation to every product geometry, dark-bubble realization or proposed interpolation. Fixed cosmological terms and effective inflaton-dependent parameters remain distinct. The creation scope retains its separate neutral models and the standard calculation's no-boundary assumption. Black-hole creation remains distinct from charged-particle production; rejection of a tunneling wavefunction prescription does not reject Hamilton–Jacobi radiation calculations. Slow-roll growth, quantum evaporation and model-dependent magnetic relic claims remain separate. Announced existence and possible applications do not certify every instanton or a universal relic prediction.","evidenceIds":["unit:1f04221b8f0b2d81f170aaaa669c194aba40099c16092f787b11fd4a78735fe5","unit:5d39725bd1233ad1d5af878b3a60dacd64e100695f503114d44c0d8be045315d","unit:603a6719ec5c51f36086dd9ad73df58c383b883f2aa57479a4711b73909e5932","unit:97fc10a12c96a702bc2f36320a50edc883752e92b21a7cce3d9c634b3539b131","unit:b0dafa8c0895a78a1c20deaf712468718ba4f70ad8fcb67548b7af5da01a0eb4","unit:c3665fcf8ce78e2ce8fec24291d707e7a8f4fde65dc89ce5356e6b710bdb7bdf","unit:d9a517344302b3efe50f1deaf7aa92af5dd62f3292a626b95935d74921093c3c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:44d11612f54d20c253297e73","scopeContentSha256":"939dd8082219841314e5aee31ac3ea2876293315395dfc0f1c1b2c48cc4d94dd","localRef":"s12"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da2b38749f8c655a444b47b0","scopeContentSha256":"7d72daf57307003b9b8bd1f6ac2580016fed4cb4e76663fc7d0fc3f393289744","localRef":"s33"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l23","originalCandidateId":"parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge:link:44","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l23","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge:link:44","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:da2b38749f8c655a444b47b0","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:44d11612f54d20c253297e73","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l23","source":"s33","target":"s12","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Where an instanton interpretation is supported, Nariai realizations enter inflationary black-hole creation. The destination also retains separate neutral models and does not identify black-hole creation with particle production."],"challengeStatement":"An appropriate instanton interpretation connects Nariai realizations to inflationary black-hole creation. Neutral models remain accessible, and black-hole creation is distinct from charged-particle production.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c00ff9f669c2d036fa1bcb30ef4b99ce5a6dde85f700160cfce19e80c799a1c9","reply.jsonSha256":"5fb4089c285d0ed61fb2dc5bf7ab98cab2877bfa9b30ab497dc1722558a0372e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"48d49aa0869fdc876c1e1679087458a07a957d7c15e5c10eabf57160d5f5a030","receipt.jsonSha256":"e895d58d05cfa054be96879032625a011287887b792388f9ce176ca4bd05148c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f2556ca8cbd16ebc1bed21c03f34f8a9a7e5b57540d4f729539938e966e55c07","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a51fd97e15010788cf5754354e902bc7cdc740b8ad519421b52440beb94c484b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-dda30fa692c9a71fb398-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8b4d7646af50b84e8e8109e4e0585ad63db32f1ae4c044e2f5579b735b19d30f","reply.jsonSha256":"c6936586ea6c476dfae41382a5e1247668eda8d16484a4b20999bd634e26bc8a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"e24c060a50886ef7301be9c85977ef227cf90aa73575d5757dd8f4958830b580","receipt.jsonSha256":"a703f9f09755d10b216f54d72227a3744bb47e8ee4331606da91dd9da1adc436","normalization.jsonSha256":"e1424163c0eb09e08a60284f41bedd44f639b04aef69f88438f5a7829181afab"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da2b38749f8c655a444b47b0"},{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:44d11612f54d20c253297e73"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da2b38749f8c655a444b47b0"},{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:44d11612f54d20c253297e73"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d23","originalRef":"l23","status":"route","source":"s12","target":"s33","type":"application_of","title":"Examine Nariai constructions underlying creation instantons","rationale":"Where an appropriate instanton interpretation is supported, inflationary black-hole creation applies a Nariai realization. The applied creation question is s12, so the application direction is reversed.","qualification":"The route retains the appropriate-background requirement, particularly for the supplied dilatonic charged-Nariai branch. It does not extend an instanton interpretation to every product geometry, dark-bubble realization or proposed interpolation. Fixed cosmological terms and effective inflaton-dependent parameters remain distinct. The creation scope retains its separate neutral models and the standard calculation's no-boundary assumption. Black-hole creation remains distinct from charged-particle production; rejection of a tunneling wavefunction prescription does not reject Hamilton–Jacobi radiation calculations. Slow-roll growth, quantum evaporation and model-dependent magnetic relic claims remain separate. Announced existence and possible applications do not certify every instanton or a universal relic prediction.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l23","s12","s33"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d23","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements support applying suitable Nariai realizations to inflationary black-hole creation under an appropriate instanton interpretation. The reversed application retains that applicability condition, separate neutral models and the distinction from charged-particle production, without extending the interpretation to every construction.","refs":["l23","s12","s33"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l23","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l0":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l0","source":"q025-candidate-question:6372c6a9f7962ae6567a4af7","target":"q025-candidate-question:45b35d1b40119653cf502d18","type":"method_for","title":"Use reusable numerical software for Calabi–Yau metric computation","rationale":"The software question supplies computational infrastructure for metric approximation, so the method arrow runs from s17 to s12. The concrete connection is the metric-computation package component.","qualification":"The generic numerical-language question establishes no Julia dependency for the metric calculations. CYJAX support concerns its first release, with quantitative package comparisons left to future work. Geometry, sampled moduli, approximation resolution and downstream accuracy remain separately assessed; software availability establishes neither universal accuracy nor a performance ranking.","evidenceIds":["unit:0a7ff058e6bf3f5324228adfae4ca6d086ba813b0d29aa8e34d2d0cb3134aca8","unit:0dec50a7b1db36e65420e1e492cdc8d5b57b476ca4451d70c4446ae92da516d1","unit:24fb5caa5a9353e67e59336b845543d16000de8e2428085198590cb5eece9147","unit:454092d9d1919e534ec5cc9d5cffb9334db0b609f085b5f7ae30fde26b02d231","unit:5341cfac9219632b5838d7e8ceb04e015f238bf76c3e1d490fba20375c525fcb","unit:634b4ff95a550bd61effc0cf8e62f8256ea3b1b52be78c457ffbe318bbc97f2a","unit:66deadaab3f05d064af6e0027be417d703874e84769eb704e15befc1eff85a2f","unit:9667a439bcc458764a28ac8fb964e2c7635730302e348fe2dab3183d9748987c","unit:9f64fe2101d45c57bbf74f5ca9e9ceada4cb79e8545968e9f958b2faa5a5797f","unit:aed460729778a8883c9eacdc46a7467fb071f6bd5ac61aa6a011f5c090bfff21","unit:b7a51c348451844081c096888323b6f7a4d5d165865add9e5134757f0699bb12","unit:c447f312993707df7e9cee8d7aac22270b558651a6da4ffbcb607b10cb47eed2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6372c6a9f7962ae6567a4af7","scopeContentSha256":"7c8c17657051dfe7bfba59ef582242f8a1bd7264146732fd292606cfcb199bfe","localRef":"s17"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:45b35d1b40119653cf502d18","scopeContentSha256":"15fb1d116db4a9c8b356d21dc1cf12e9b2b73ad59e41c739dde0ce9ed7e297bb","localRef":"s12"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l0","originalCandidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:27","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l0","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge:link:27","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:45b35d1b40119653cf502d18","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:6372c6a9f7962ae6567a4af7","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l0","source":"s12","target":"s17","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Reusable numerical software is a useful infrastructure route. The supplied Julia paper does not establish an implementation dependency of the metric sources."],"challengeStatement":"Numerical software provides an infrastructure route; this establishes no Julia dependency for the Calabi–Yau calculations.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3965339798d71b33ab5ee48539d5a115edc6b34a7faab02eddde739ad75f3688","reply.jsonSha256":"7644da5fce58517e3221a765f17a1aa001ce05e45d1104d6a56c038eda498fd3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c75590e1700e60606f892a4bff0180cdd637c210e56999144734d092c912aa15","receipt.jsonSha256":"677688246447085846b344a6f17c725446cc72ef74ae734c48d4b83cd95575de","normalization.jsonSha256":"b7ee6b02b7b74616a7a0e5fc9978834ed599cff4c6988a470863edabac99df96","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4b4d97dc13bcc60a381f267b5de5e3d90ddafd18f817d63874b0970f4f3a1032"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-fc8db97ee042e05990a1-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1fd91c573564255cac4f2a90ce27bc09560fcbe642c76ea21ed514364b5f4cfd","reply.jsonSha256":"d1ee2097387a6094e506534262542448b8cfdfd5f1a876f40d2142b8c3eae0d3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7fff57d73701936f8a6700c378cce374efce17f30bc917dd65ca68b535b7437f","receipt.jsonSha256":"6044fc47ccaaa90fb4447257c33abb6eb8f70157d4d523ab0449fafa1cb6cb04","normalization.jsonSha256":"a70efad348d4e671a33683f9125fbeb539d35206f453dda5889880f091496aec"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:45b35d1b40119653cf502d18"},{"ref":"x2_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6372c6a9f7962ae6567a4af7"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"1411.1607","sourceId":"ev:b31e58f8ac39d566a1514bd82511cb96","sourceSha256":"b7edde5e41ccf207f76fa94ce44802e34ef0464ead56bc93bc7b582975e3fb74","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e0ba923427f70c183654/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a981a046cdb8fcf5a40ccdbfe57ce49da4213280b1e0d0387eba0de48e8b4e15","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1428,"textSha256":"47c70a445585fee91593de9cdc89d5fcb468cf7ee210c40a68bb0339335d3bc6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"1411.1607","sourceId":"ev:874f4f87f7ea52dd5c441801a39561ea","sourceSha256":"b7edde5e41ccf207f76fa94ce44802e34ef0464ead56bc93bc7b582975e3fb74","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e0ba923427f70c183654/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a981a046cdb8fcf5a40ccdbfe57ce49da4213280b1e0d0387eba0de48e8b4e15","pdfPage":4,"start":97,"end":3495,"textSha256":"bd31d2fb40402a7d07440f4720acf05cc2b33e26c303363497693c1d11eb48dc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:45b35d1b40119653cf502d18"},{"ref":"x2_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6372c6a9f7962ae6567a4af7"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"1411.1607","sourceId":"ev:b31e58f8ac39d566a1514bd82511cb96","sourceSha256":"b7edde5e41ccf207f76fa94ce44802e34ef0464ead56bc93bc7b582975e3fb74","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e0ba923427f70c183654/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a981a046cdb8fcf5a40ccdbfe57ce49da4213280b1e0d0387eba0de48e8b4e15","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1428,"textSha256":"47c70a445585fee91593de9cdc89d5fcb468cf7ee210c40a68bb0339335d3bc6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"1411.1607","sourceId":"ev:874f4f87f7ea52dd5c441801a39561ea","sourceSha256":"b7edde5e41ccf207f76fa94ce44802e34ef0464ead56bc93bc7b582975e3fb74","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e0ba923427f70c183654/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a981a046cdb8fcf5a40ccdbfe57ce49da4213280b1e0d0387eba0de48e8b4e15","pdfPage":4,"start":97,"end":3495,"textSha256":"bd31d2fb40402a7d07440f4720acf05cc2b33e26c303363497693c1d11eb48dc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d0","originalRef":"l0","status":"route","source":"s17","target":"s12","type":"method_for","title":"Use reusable numerical software for Calabi–Yau metric computation","rationale":"The software question supplies computational infrastructure for metric approximation, so the method arrow runs from s17 to s12. The concrete connection is the metric-computation package component.","qualification":"The generic numerical-language question establishes no Julia dependency for the metric calculations. CYJAX support concerns its first release, with quantitative package comparisons left to future work. Geometry, sampled moduli, approximation resolution and downstream accuracy remain separately assessed; software availability establishes neither universal accuracy nor a performance ranking.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l0","s17","s12"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The concrete metric-computation package component makes s17 the infrastructure supplier and s12 the target, supporting the reversal to method_for. The qualification preserves both statements' exclusion of an inferred Julia dependency and retains the first-release, comparison and accuracy limitations.","refs":["l0","s17","s12"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l1":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l1","source":"q025-candidate-question:8e7c29283a6e005cf9ad63fd","target":"q025-candidate-question:e1f184a931a13986dbbacefa","type":"related_question","title":"Explore Wilson-line enhancement and compactification spectra","rationale":"Wilson-line enhancement and massless spectra are concrete gauge-realization targets. The statements establish this connection, but do not identify a method or construction supplied by the broad admissibility question that s34 applies. The separate vacuum-energy target also prevents full-scope narrower containment.","qualification":"Circle, fixed-line two-torus and heterotic interpolation settings remain distinct. The displayed two-torus construction retains its fixed Wilson lines, initial roots and finite search limits. Vacuum-energy suppression belongs only to the specified constant-background, supersymmetry-restoring interpolation region and one-loop analysis; it is neither an all-loop result nor a universal gauge-realizability criterion. D counts compactified directions.","evidenceIds":["unit:03a019ea2214c6351dd4d158df5bc5c4d751dfd5cabc7edb2b0368d3c9a2cdd5","unit:07773a160ebbf445d8342aa4f665542dca7e17366d5f462f793f5dad99484926","unit:0e4f5c989b93ff5ce31429fee4b1324d85f992aeae09c98edd94c560420cc6d9","unit:16c8e3644686cebfa4433563a3335483a256f88859e90f42fadebd7b836b33d2","unit:39a8ac6f93fbe7f476283d4712aad1c1f49823acea1908e6f3c133b2f69086c3","unit:51f79b2a5079fc35907f9ed2cc016ccf0dc98ddb9d9ed38368a9d9aac092bd07","unit:5d6f3344edafa56fe12a6b47d7b4e2336ef2c7b1a966691dc8aeedec7aa3d952","unit:6fd3a9288ed3420105d1a3f0077501c4d5d21122ea74df5791590321b43fc392","unit:9340f49a4a21a27e0ddb5ee8a61488fedf92279592282ea7cf26114bc5d1a7f7","unit:a407a7c0792376cc28807bcf47a6c10d3c433c2660baf819d9fbb544a54120af","unit:a5071ae7a132b9466a1a55fa21928926ca07a4230a811e6d8d7eca35b7855634","unit:b0ddeda5fefc0d2a084f66fdcf6c0eed5ea1e23f1403e662b23b7a2b756f3e4f","unit:b92d0592cee4534a2420c8e68db9a4fcb201e12a25c45c67f2e425e9d26fda43","unit:bc7ce334a83277db2aa05625b35d73bfe5f6f1611d4e5658a858a43ecaaf7589","unit:bdb71e32c6b1082c82d09440de88340c492059283eea8e4344786cb83d1269e7","unit:c9463a57b7847eb9cd3130eaede76b01862ff2d72aea850c712817f4538cc15b","unit:cb54cb61db15a47f6e9590e277a050115d4760e0e2e68b12781704e2750cec81","unit:f036905702374c98c83088e478e5616b2f58bae69a4dfc723bd4f893eb25d649"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8e7c29283a6e005cf9ad63fd","scopeContentSha256":"67c9bdeb9e7b4a6b8099f57e08114854d171c144824387e0c6d30e56f99e5f76","localRef":"s25"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e1f184a931a13986dbbacefa","scopeContentSha256":"ed5b5d266ea1ee584a20a854baebfb64e50c98b315ab69391934810a6fa130cb","localRef":"s34"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l1","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge:link:22","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l1","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge:link:22","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:8e7c29283a6e005cf9ad63fd","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:e1f184a931a13986dbbacefa","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l1","source":"s25","target":"s34","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Wilson-line enhancement and massless spectra are concrete gauge-realization targets; their vacuum-energy question remains separately qualified."],"challengeStatement":"Wilson-line enhancement and massless spectra instantiate gauge-realization targets; the linked vacuum-energy target keeps its separate regime and perturbative limit.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8f32c9816c88693b1073966b7a701a9b37bb56e07d9ba2cad4a63d5f1402c9e9","reply.jsonSha256":"8c68a543650d3f514e6786d7086053d0a248a085a91a8aa06d8510672569eddf","reply.raw.txtSha256":"4078ce93f48399d496ba26c1fdc6466c79b74546b897d1697834754400e4f1e2","receipt.jsonSha256":"f87d07d2ccdf90d57355244e3f8765638cd205b4d77a5d068fec762c97f8b858","normalization.jsonSha256":"bb5dfa2f90198d6fbce2eaa772e11d0e0e24e3921bd040bbffd0ee22ec34c92e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"bdf5fc214ef75952ec3360a1c4eb99436f3eec3d99bc16eb07356419349e9005"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1462bc51e14463b7105728663b25abb906aa4c53414bec11f93960ea3b120f7e","reply.jsonSha256":"8fdb429497f25696e1c08e0bd4adabb75019d80c9fae159a31c4d1603dcfecc0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"014064f5a2f1974cfcde5bfe9ba6ffe8bfc2b120c439f5dfc1c4bfff66309b72","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa830d9bbdf5879bf096e608f8ce9d5f44658a12b2762c511859d49f2c19febe","normalization.jsonSha256":"5b5f52e1e68270a1c48112f924ad6ac5bde0c0e93e59a83ca0cd9f11ef9fc495"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8e7c29283a6e005cf9ad63fd"},{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e1f184a931a13986dbbacefa"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2101.10619","sourceId":"ev:e1bf0189c15e6e0ac2ded8a38b751800","sourceSha256":"2896b3d8a5dae223f84aaa73ab1f25967398ed54f5d3586c33f65e8e11b74b19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c691b99fcca42b287f00/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ef83d84d25a4947dc2da2ca2aae1674993ef1495772b0640c08c206a501514bb","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2209,"textSha256":"f7ec8d684c6b20363f18586a4fc061d0c54d8d4c6a384217b49bca1bc8584bc1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"2101.10619","sourceId":"ev:e35cfd28c6217d0cd47ba8b3dceb7f47","sourceSha256":"2896b3d8a5dae223f84aaa73ab1f25967398ed54f5d3586c33f65e8e11b74b19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c691b99fcca42b287f00/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ef83d84d25a4947dc2da2ca2aae1674993ef1495772b0640c08c206a501514bb","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1358,"textSha256":"db7ecc3761608b9f49f349096a9395a487dc5a6d99218ad35692b8c512afbcd5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8e7c29283a6e005cf9ad63fd"},{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e1f184a931a13986dbbacefa"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2101.10619","sourceId":"ev:e1bf0189c15e6e0ac2ded8a38b751800","sourceSha256":"2896b3d8a5dae223f84aaa73ab1f25967398ed54f5d3586c33f65e8e11b74b19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c691b99fcca42b287f00/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ef83d84d25a4947dc2da2ca2aae1674993ef1495772b0640c08c206a501514bb","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2209,"textSha256":"f7ec8d684c6b20363f18586a4fc061d0c54d8d4c6a384217b49bca1bc8584bc1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"2101.10619","sourceId":"ev:e35cfd28c6217d0cd47ba8b3dceb7f47","sourceSha256":"2896b3d8a5dae223f84aaa73ab1f25967398ed54f5d3586c33f65e8e11b74b19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c691b99fcca42b287f00/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ef83d84d25a4947dc2da2ca2aae1674993ef1495772b0640c08c206a501514bb","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1358,"textSha256":"db7ecc3761608b9f49f349096a9395a487dc5a6d99218ad35692b8c512afbcd5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d1","originalRef":"l1","status":"route","source":"s25","target":"s34","type":"related_question","title":"Explore Wilson-line enhancement and compactification spectra","rationale":"Wilson-line enhancement and massless spectra are concrete gauge-realization targets. The statements establish this connection, but do not identify a method or construction supplied by the broad admissibility question that s34 applies. The separate vacuum-energy target also prevents full-scope narrower containment.","qualification":"Circle, fixed-line two-torus and heterotic interpolation settings remain distinct. The displayed two-torus construction retains its fixed Wilson lines, initial roots and finite search limits. Vacuum-energy suppression belongs only to the specified constant-background, supersymmetry-restoring interpolation region and one-loop analysis; it is neither an all-loop result nor a universal gauge-realizability criterion. D counts compactified directions.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l1","s25","s34"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements connect Wilson-line enhancement and massless spectra to gauge realization without identifying a construction supplied by s25 that s34 applies. The separate vacuum-energy target prevents full-scope containment. related_question preserves the supported connection while retaining the distinct compactification settings and one-loop interpolation limit.","refs":["l1","s25","s34"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l2":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l2","source":"q025-candidate-question:8e7c29283a6e005cf9ad63fd","target":"q025-candidate-question:2737542226cd07080b80a12e","type":"related_question","title":"Examine anomaly tests and discrete remnants in Wilson-line models","rationale":"The specified string models connect gauge realization to anomaly tests, surviving remnants and interaction selection rules. These are distinct tests rather than an application of a single construction supplied by s25; the J-solvability and interaction targets also exceed a simple gauge-realization refinement.","qualification":"Single-axion cancellation is a necessary test and does not prove that every discrete symmetry is gauged or that a model is fully consistent. An anomalous U(1) can have fermionic anomalies cancelled by a Green–Schwarz mechanism. Discrete protection and all-orders selection rules retain the exhibited model, charges, hidden-sector representations and breaking choices. Negative J-solvability results remain negative results for the tested BSB configurations, with no universal Wilson-line cure inferred.","evidenceIds":["unit:03a019ea2214c6351dd4d158df5bc5c4d751dfd5cabc7edb2b0368d3c9a2cdd5","unit:07773a160ebbf445d8342aa4f665542dca7e17366d5f462f793f5dad99484926","unit:0e4f5c989b93ff5ce31429fee4b1324d85f992aeae09c98edd94c560420cc6d9","unit:16c8e3644686cebfa4433563a3335483a256f88859e90f42fadebd7b836b33d2","unit:1a1327da38161bfafda493b11283211f02f3afd357c0c0c2d5fbba52877eae08","unit:39a8ac6f93fbe7f476283d4712aad1c1f49823acea1908e6f3c133b2f69086c3","unit:51f79b2a5079fc35907f9ed2cc016ccf0dc98ddb9d9ed38368a9d9aac092bd07","unit:5d6f3344edafa56fe12a6b47d7b4e2336ef2c7b1a966691dc8aeedec7aa3d952","unit:6fd3a9288ed3420105d1a3f0077501c4d5d21122ea74df5791590321b43fc392","unit:9340f49a4a21a27e0ddb5ee8a61488fedf92279592282ea7cf26114bc5d1a7f7","unit:a5071ae7a132b9466a1a55fa21928926ca07a4230a811e6d8d7eca35b7855634","unit:acd13694c234566e4f62e7c9524acd44ac7930e84eb4abac2cd2e543688b2bc5","unit:b0ddeda5fefc0d2a084f66fdcf6c0eed5ea1e23f1403e662b23b7a2b756f3e4f","unit:b74519e223ec4654df4f9832d63ec3a14e8122f2b5dcdbc821f741f7a20aceab","unit:b92d0592cee4534a2420c8e68db9a4fcb201e12a25c45c67f2e425e9d26fda43","unit:bc7ce334a83277db2aa05625b35d73bfe5f6f1611d4e5658a858a43ecaaf7589","unit:bdb71e32c6b1082c82d09440de88340c492059283eea8e4344786cb83d1269e7","unit:cb54cb61db15a47f6e9590e277a050115d4760e0e2e68b12781704e2750cec81","unit:e038c51b4b875fd8f22eb20fe88366a37576da2ded9c7c84ccfbd6da0e405737","unit:ea4fd32c120e87ef0afc6fe6dfa27d8321b0947f948a78ec6715f96f107912bd"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8e7c29283a6e005cf9ad63fd","scopeContentSha256":"67c9bdeb9e7b4a6b8099f57e08114854d171c144824387e0c6d30e56f99e5f76","localRef":"s25"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2737542226cd07080b80a12e","scopeContentSha256":"a4b9de4d22881cb9f4a6de4c08ca035fcf2d35860b1e236467e5320a110ba700","localRef":"s7"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l2","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge:link:23","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l2","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge:link:23","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:8e7c29283a6e005cf9ad63fd","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:2737542226cd07080b80a12e","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l2","source":"s25","target":"s7","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Specified string models provide separate anomaly, remnant and interaction tests. Negative J-solvability results and the insufficiency of necessary anomaly tests are retained."],"challengeStatement":"Specified string models supply distinct anomaly, remnant and interaction tests. Necessary anomaly tests are not sufficient consistency proofs, and reported negative J-solvability results remain visible.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8f32c9816c88693b1073966b7a701a9b37bb56e07d9ba2cad4a63d5f1402c9e9","reply.jsonSha256":"8c68a543650d3f514e6786d7086053d0a248a085a91a8aa06d8510672569eddf","reply.raw.txtSha256":"4078ce93f48399d496ba26c1fdc6466c79b74546b897d1697834754400e4f1e2","receipt.jsonSha256":"f87d07d2ccdf90d57355244e3f8765638cd205b4d77a5d068fec762c97f8b858","normalization.jsonSha256":"bb5dfa2f90198d6fbce2eaa772e11d0e0e24e3921bd040bbffd0ee22ec34c92e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"bdf5fc214ef75952ec3360a1c4eb99436f3eec3d99bc16eb07356419349e9005"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1462bc51e14463b7105728663b25abb906aa4c53414bec11f93960ea3b120f7e","reply.jsonSha256":"8fdb429497f25696e1c08e0bd4adabb75019d80c9fae159a31c4d1603dcfecc0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"014064f5a2f1974cfcde5bfe9ba6ffe8bfc2b120c439f5dfc1c4bfff66309b72","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa830d9bbdf5879bf096e608f8ce9d5f44658a12b2762c511859d49f2c19febe","normalization.jsonSha256":"5b5f52e1e68270a1c48112f924ad6ac5bde0c0e93e59a83ca0cd9f11ef9fc495"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8e7c29283a6e005cf9ad63fd"},{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2737542226cd07080b80a12e"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8e7c29283a6e005cf9ad63fd"},{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2737542226cd07080b80a12e"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d2","originalRef":"l2","status":"route","source":"s25","target":"s7","type":"related_question","title":"Examine anomaly tests and discrete remnants in Wilson-line models","rationale":"The specified string models connect gauge realization to anomaly tests, surviving remnants and interaction selection rules. These are distinct tests rather than an application of a single construction supplied by s25; the J-solvability and interaction targets also exceed a simple gauge-realization refinement.","qualification":"Single-axion cancellation is a necessary test and does not prove that every discrete symmetry is gauged or that a model is fully consistent. An anomalous U(1) can have fermionic anomalies cancelled by a Green–Schwarz mechanism. Discrete protection and all-orders selection rules retain the exhibited model, charges, hidden-sector representations and breaking choices. Negative J-solvability results remain negative results for the tested BSB configurations, with no universal Wilson-line cure inferred.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l2","s25","s7"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The model-specific anomaly, remnant and interaction tests connect the endpoints without establishing application of a single s25 construction or containment of the complete J-solvability and interaction scope. The qualification preserves necessary-versus-sufficient anomaly testing, model-dependent discrete protection and the reported negative BSB results.","refs":["l2","s25","s7"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l3":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l3","source":"q025-candidate-question:dab664a433b751dc8540d09c","target":"q025-candidate-question:c124179f43a09ee9ccfafac7","type":"application_of","title":"Apply TFT constructions to ensembles, condensation and factorization","rationale":"The ensemble and factorization questions are proposed uses of topological constructions. The applied question is s33, and the underlying construction question is s28.","qualification":"Ensemble construction, weights, contributing topologies and factorization remain separate targets. Gauging, condensation and topology summation are not interchangeable without an argument. Fixed-topology descriptions remain distinct from topology sums, and continuous Wilson-line spectra from finite topological data. Each construction retains its dimension, spin, boundary and matter-coupling restrictions. These applications remain description-supported proposals; shared TFT terminology supplies neither weights nor a factorization result.","evidenceIds":["unit:11b0f357f25d6db9410d5a1a25b9d291c99bc4d2c1e280cea93cb4d931dc6354","unit:21bbe11d8d6d3ce8fb896a6b9b94421f1d751b2c33125f58a65967fa1430ab8f","unit:222de3560b82b47bdcc26193a272e680e21a2ac2dd87d510e896983cdae50aed","unit:2985006688830d290aa7727e0ab711dc84bbe6cc560734e13225a7e0a713edc1","unit:4f35a4d7d5ef46d0aff609ce4d20ace6f4a96220225153a5a5a7a4dd457cbde7","unit:7d25bda767a9a40a0de6e8eea111808187cbddf276c01e7a83e7f9e67959089b","unit:8165bf98ca76654d2cba08d190162ed0d487841e55329d536bebc8b219ce73b6","unit:9bfaa25f35aeca0431fc8f0826c426fcde501eed0375b4e7405b3cf3834d5fcf","unit:a1facc26ff7887d871d648f464fa39dee8327a9f946e1906b40893d939f4dd14","unit:a384bd82ec15e21b1d8465e33057dce0d8df090f7ad7ad021f5b2cfc8dde5708","unit:a546eb52ac7fbadcf5dfbf4148f3c06db71a403d4b1028d9e6075bc838b23ec2","unit:c91922a035d9ed07298c05bd9e149c40fe9bbf7158de6e6ddc7cb1eed3a9a1fd","unit:d2e385ab4b8a093d58a471e166f26575596f180dedcd00cd8e121552c2f8fb64","unit:de27f975c23dd47857e54f1517bc9d05b5c2a5369413677c949b383de3e7f433"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:dab664a433b751dc8540d09c","scopeContentSha256":"344f9babd6981cece324dcbd4cc132faed89f59f0eb0392844bc72d4a624d740","localRef":"s33"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c124179f43a09ee9ccfafac7","scopeContentSha256":"7f3193e4432965c92ecc1af234ae6bd14fe38a26a907c55de13cdca83a2a8c89","localRef":"s28"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l3","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge:link:34","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l3","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge:link:34","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c124179f43a09ee9ccfafac7","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:dab664a433b751dc8540d09c","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l3","source":"s28","target":"s33","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["TQFT ensembles, condensation and factorization are distinct proposed uses of topological constructions; weights and topology sums are not fixed by shared terminology."],"challengeStatement":"Ensembles, condensation and factorization are qualified applications of TQFT constructions; shared terminology determines neither ensemble weights nor topology sums.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8f32c9816c88693b1073966b7a701a9b37bb56e07d9ba2cad4a63d5f1402c9e9","reply.jsonSha256":"8c68a543650d3f514e6786d7086053d0a248a085a91a8aa06d8510672569eddf","reply.raw.txtSha256":"4078ce93f48399d496ba26c1fdc6466c79b74546b897d1697834754400e4f1e2","receipt.jsonSha256":"f87d07d2ccdf90d57355244e3f8765638cd205b4d77a5d068fec762c97f8b858","normalization.jsonSha256":"bb5dfa2f90198d6fbce2eaa772e11d0e0e24e3921bd040bbffd0ee22ec34c92e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"bdf5fc214ef75952ec3360a1c4eb99436f3eec3d99bc16eb07356419349e9005"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1462bc51e14463b7105728663b25abb906aa4c53414bec11f93960ea3b120f7e","reply.jsonSha256":"8fdb429497f25696e1c08e0bd4adabb75019d80c9fae159a31c4d1603dcfecc0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"014064f5a2f1974cfcde5bfe9ba6ffe8bfc2b120c439f5dfc1c4bfff66309b72","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa830d9bbdf5879bf096e608f8ce9d5f44658a12b2762c511859d49f2c19febe","normalization.jsonSha256":"5b5f52e1e68270a1c48112f924ad6ac5bde0c0e93e59a83ca0cd9f11ef9fc495"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c124179f43a09ee9ccfafac7"},{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:dab664a433b751dc8540d09c"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c124179f43a09ee9ccfafac7"},{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:dab664a433b751dc8540d09c"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d3","originalRef":"l3","status":"route","source":"s33","target":"s28","type":"application_of","title":"Apply TFT constructions to ensembles, condensation and factorization","rationale":"The ensemble and factorization questions are proposed uses of topological constructions. The applied question is s33, and the underlying construction question is s28.","qualification":"Ensemble construction, weights, contributing topologies and factorization remain separate targets. Gauging, condensation and topology summation are not interchangeable without an argument. Fixed-topology descriptions remain distinct from topology sums, and continuous Wilson-line spectra from finite topological data. Each construction retains its dimension, spin, boundary and matter-coupling restrictions. These applications remain description-supported proposals; shared TFT terminology supplies neither weights nor a factorization result.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l3","s33","s28"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements explicitly describe qualified uses of topological constructions, placing the applied ensemble and factorization question at s33 and the construction question at s28. The reversal is supported. The qualification preserves separate weights, topology sums, condensation operations, spectrum settings and construction restrictions without asserting a factorization result.","refs":["l3","s33","s28"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l4":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l4","source":"q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5","target":"q025-candidate-question:71a9bb6c10ab84c1ec55de85","type":"application_of","title":"Use higher-form SPT constructions for protected logical operations","rationale":"The protected-operation component of s31 uses specified higher-form SPT constructions from s20. This supports an application arrow toward those constructions.","qualification":"The route applies to the identified logical-operation component, not to every lattice-order criterion, stabilizer code or memory-stability question. Abstract error correction and passive Hamiltonian protection retain separate assumptions. Weak-perturbation ground-state stability establishes no thermal lifetime or threshold. Source-specific symmetry and dimension restrictions remain in force, and proposed higher-symmetry classifications are not promoted to universal results.","evidenceIds":["unit:337905933cfe597fb189d7ef2317dd5c1831107b14862e5ed0d41061f66d5c98","unit:3fa174682e1c7083b8a33d846ed0decb71d184f63ae0137683fc680d7dda8505","unit:4a64af2a540374062de75852e280f274ccf70b6899c427cb99676e6743219ed7","unit:4adb0d9290d31a3c7c782a98186178d0519ee1da0799e4eced1e467836be52e4","unit:5a96ea9898f33dac97bd4b5e712170a78e94da3c9b58752dd640d1c36fcfbe1c","unit:69c76d156cb620563e0bcda4c4219b65b68b63f4c351d8ec77d3ccdab52bfac6","unit:6ed06566f28267471c96ac3e4708aecb987170407445d64f3f8dfbabb2e728da","unit:a1facc26ff7887d871d648f464fa39dee8327a9f946e1906b40893d939f4dd14","unit:a546eb52ac7fbadcf5dfbf4148f3c06db71a403d4b1028d9e6075bc838b23ec2","unit:e238b235df45a0919a8cab1882d6e7c02f5f798a993bfe0690041346e487554d","unit:e614dfb455838b88b528e6ee1c02ed6517ed9052877fcd5432ebede49fc296c7","unit:e99451d066029c60f98c05c38c4ab865f094857a16daa7777be75384f96151a0","unit:ecf8733557b69fe15d53969b5a15f7fb1977c890c47ce3d57dea79696a174ebc","unit:fd0310e4424911cd9d341a167fa6318b790b09327d30383c3ed88512787883fe"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5","scopeContentSha256":"eb47a3d9439b4ebb73a6304084f394b60e7eef771823541c4c9f92f27f9b5bd0","localRef":"s31"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:71a9bb6c10ab84c1ec55de85","scopeContentSha256":"cee3a605d58cfcf4c86e6418599327cc14269c615abd8eadb60334dd72056b32","localRef":"s20"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l4","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge:link:35","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l4","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge:link:35","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:71a9bb6c10ab84c1ec55de85","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l4","source":"s20","target":"s31","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Specified higher-form SPT constructions can motivate protected-operation questions, while abstract coding and physical memory stability retain separate assumptions."],"challengeStatement":"Specified higher-form SPT constructions connect to protected logical operations. This relation does not turn arbitrary stabilizer codes or physical memory-stability questions into SPT classifications.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8f32c9816c88693b1073966b7a701a9b37bb56e07d9ba2cad4a63d5f1402c9e9","reply.jsonSha256":"8c68a543650d3f514e6786d7086053d0a248a085a91a8aa06d8510672569eddf","reply.raw.txtSha256":"4078ce93f48399d496ba26c1fdc6466c79b74546b897d1697834754400e4f1e2","receipt.jsonSha256":"f87d07d2ccdf90d57355244e3f8765638cd205b4d77a5d068fec762c97f8b858","normalization.jsonSha256":"bb5dfa2f90198d6fbce2eaa772e11d0e0e24e3921bd040bbffd0ee22ec34c92e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"bdf5fc214ef75952ec3360a1c4eb99436f3eec3d99bc16eb07356419349e9005"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1462bc51e14463b7105728663b25abb906aa4c53414bec11f93960ea3b120f7e","reply.jsonSha256":"8fdb429497f25696e1c08e0bd4adabb75019d80c9fae159a31c4d1603dcfecc0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"014064f5a2f1974cfcde5bfe9ba6ffe8bfc2b120c439f5dfc1c4bfff66309b72","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa830d9bbdf5879bf096e608f8ce9d5f44658a12b2762c511859d49f2c19febe","normalization.jsonSha256":"5b5f52e1e68270a1c48112f924ad6ac5bde0c0e93e59a83ca0cd9f11ef9fc495"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:71a9bb6c10ab84c1ec55de85"},{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:71a9bb6c10ab84c1ec55de85"},{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d4","originalRef":"l4","status":"route","source":"s31","target":"s20","type":"application_of","title":"Use higher-form SPT constructions for protected logical operations","rationale":"The protected-operation component of s31 uses specified higher-form SPT constructions from s20. This supports an application arrow toward those constructions.","qualification":"The route applies to the identified logical-operation component, not to every lattice-order criterion, stabilizer code or memory-stability question. Abstract error correction and passive Hamiltonian protection retain separate assumptions. Weak-perturbation ground-state stability establishes no thermal lifetime or threshold. Source-specific symmetry and dimension restrictions remain in force, and proposed higher-symmetry classifications are not promoted to universal results.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l4","s31","s20"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The endpoint definition explicitly includes logical gates from higher-form SPT constructions, supporting application_of from that component of s31 to s20. The restriction to protected logical operations preserves both original statements and avoids extending the application to arbitrary codes, order criteria or physical memory stability.","refs":["l4","s31","s20"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l5":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l5","source":"q025-candidate-question:79e2f21b7d2d5acf1c8e6cf9","target":"q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5","type":"method_for","title":"Use stabilizer methods in the coding component of topological-order studies","rationale":"General stabilizer formalism supplies the coding-method component explicitly distinguished within s31. The original direction already follows the method supplier toward its application question.","qualification":"The connection concerns group-theoretic coding, encoding, fault-tolerant operations and code analysis where applicable. A physical lattice Hamiltonian, geometric locality and topological order are not universal premises of stabilizer theory. No thermal lifetime, threshold or passive Hamiltonian protection follows. The supplied definitions report an announced program, without encoding constructions, capacity calculations or bound proofs.","evidenceIds":["unit:337905933cfe597fb189d7ef2317dd5c1831107b14862e5ed0d41061f66d5c98","unit:3fa174682e1c7083b8a33d846ed0decb71d184f63ae0137683fc680d7dda8505","unit:5a96ea9898f33dac97bd4b5e712170a78e94da3c9b58752dd640d1c36fcfbe1c","unit:e614dfb455838b88b528e6ee1c02ed6517ed9052877fcd5432ebede49fc296c7","unit:ecf8733557b69fe15d53969b5a15f7fb1977c890c47ce3d57dea79696a174ebc","unit:fd0310e4424911cd9d341a167fa6318b790b09327d30383c3ed88512787883fe"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:79e2f21b7d2d5acf1c8e6cf9","scopeContentSha256":"9be81f2a3b7e72c3d6230082ea9ac0f0a61860f0559b238c966ea7180f3528ab","localRef":"s21"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5","scopeContentSha256":"eb47a3d9439b4ebb73a6304084f394b60e7eef771823541c4c9f92f27f9b5bd0","localRef":"s31"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l5","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge:link:37","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l5","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge:link:37","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:79e2f21b7d2d5acf1c8e6cf9","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l5","source":"s21","target":"s31","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["General stabilizer formalism supplies the coding-method component already distinguished by the topological-order card; it does not establish thermal lifetimes or Hamiltonian protection."],"challengeStatement":"Stabilizer formalism supplies the coding-method component already distinguished in x2_3; it establishes no thermal lifetime, threshold or passive Hamiltonian protection here.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8f32c9816c88693b1073966b7a701a9b37bb56e07d9ba2cad4a63d5f1402c9e9","reply.jsonSha256":"8c68a543650d3f514e6786d7086053d0a248a085a91a8aa06d8510672569eddf","reply.raw.txtSha256":"4078ce93f48399d496ba26c1fdc6466c79b74546b897d1697834754400e4f1e2","receipt.jsonSha256":"f87d07d2ccdf90d57355244e3f8765638cd205b4d77a5d068fec762c97f8b858","normalization.jsonSha256":"bb5dfa2f90198d6fbce2eaa772e11d0e0e24e3921bd040bbffd0ee22ec34c92e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"bdf5fc214ef75952ec3360a1c4eb99436f3eec3d99bc16eb07356419349e9005"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1462bc51e14463b7105728663b25abb906aa4c53414bec11f93960ea3b120f7e","reply.jsonSha256":"8fdb429497f25696e1c08e0bd4adabb75019d80c9fae159a31c4d1603dcfecc0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"014064f5a2f1974cfcde5bfe9ba6ffe8bfc2b120c439f5dfc1c4bfff66309b72","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa830d9bbdf5879bf096e608f8ce9d5f44658a12b2762c511859d49f2c19febe","normalization.jsonSha256":"5b5f52e1e68270a1c48112f924ad6ac5bde0c0e93e59a83ca0cd9f11ef9fc495"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"quant-ph/9705052","sourceId":"ev:ccc30da8f6355d5eed883046f6db4246","sourceSha256":"8f20c4bd0807f289fbc185ae7fd3982ad6c957c6597e47ceb4d35b91f8693659","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8bb4e9c044c2f38855ad/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3bef8326d140425a4eef4c44f95b242dd8390c107604fe42a5ee8bd9f1b47446","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":795,"textSha256":"5633f4c1f479e96d22c57d3c841e2db9d569fe039fd47a302fc45afc2f5312c1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"quant-ph/9705052","sourceId":"ev:ccc30da8f6355d5eed883046f6db4246","sourceSha256":"8f20c4bd0807f289fbc185ae7fd3982ad6c957c6597e47ceb4d35b91f8693659","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8bb4e9c044c2f38855ad/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3bef8326d140425a4eef4c44f95b242dd8390c107604fe42a5ee8bd9f1b47446","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":795,"textSha256":"5633f4c1f479e96d22c57d3c841e2db9d569fe039fd47a302fc45afc2f5312c1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ca3e4f59dbdbccfa1298deb5"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d5","originalRef":"l5","status":"route","source":"s21","target":"s31","type":"method_for","title":"Use stabilizer methods in the coding component of topological-order studies","rationale":"General stabilizer formalism supplies the coding-method component explicitly distinguished within s31. The original direction already follows the method supplier toward its application question.","qualification":"The connection concerns group-theoretic coding, encoding, fault-tolerant operations and code analysis where applicable. A physical lattice Hamiltonian, geometric locality and topological order are not universal premises of stabilizer theory. No thermal lifetime, threshold or passive Hamiltonian protection follows. The supplied definitions report an announced program, without encoding constructions, capacity calculations or bound proofs.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l5","s21","s31"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements identify stabilizer formalism as the coding-method contribution within s31, so the retained method_for direction is correct. The qualification preserves the distinction between abstract coding and physical Hamiltonian protection and excludes unsupported thermal lifetimes, thresholds and detailed calculation claims.","refs":["l5","s21","s31"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l6":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l6","source":"q025-candidate-question:f743d3c71a5a38de72647392","target":"q025-candidate-question:253b31161d563d79524ced21","type":"method_for","title":"Use local Wess–Zumino cohomology for applicable anomaly-consistency questions","rationale":"Local Wess–Zumino consistency cohomology supplies the method; anomaly compatibility and gauging consistency supply the target. The original method direction therefore requires reversal.","qualification":"Applicability is limited to the stated Yang–Mills-type local BRS cohomology with compact Lie group, trivial principal bundle, globally defined forms and polynomials in fields and finitely many derivatives. External fields and nontrivial spacetime cohomology are allowed within that setting. The announced result covers arbitrary ghost number and form degree, modulo BRS-exact and spacetime-exact terms. It establishes no extension to nontrivial principal bundles, automatic application to discrete string anomaly tests, complete global-anomaly classification or representation-specific anomaly coefficients.","evidenceIds":["unit:12fbdb05d6bad2faa16a98900dc9a4bcb6389b51191ba16380053b4db4c8055f","unit:26353d6150208e09edb2933b34f7b59aa63d3b07f8161ac0d40cad9134478058","unit:2818bbba697eb395138cbe7c48b7d5e3c9af01304a6057423263a9b95b171429","unit:2c6316ddfa9b0ea13e8d7019630da15c6bf94d8711a361699a44c44b76ef84a5","unit:50adbcf536d3bd3d05f4db5bc1aaab55796657be92ccdad0e9d517aa0600685c","unit:665c74b0a6b757181888c759e206505735bd25ff4222965502561361e89c639d","unit:6f1a37c5a7e80eb71e1f7a9499e9529fb73f52764b7dae31672da7244a412d0d","unit:883b2849e5b1f1d82def5f644998b1e2d6a5cb21c7dc185b5fe25b99df1f00d9","unit:8ba9b2ff426c85dc9db561b9a5c615156ff61957a3889acbcc25cfbd1fd45bc0","unit:8f5029ee08f096e7ec2d171696279b956c7d96c53703226f3bf73926590df6f1","unit:97694418fadf13355bce8fca9f0290f52e161b6f507e33e377d692c24507cefb","unit:bcb930350cfb30cb461ddebd3d55950894281611fce99b74467d22f1b7048f22","unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","unit:cc5d049e79065c6230f4c68ca5739be48bf20340bec9055041f098658f97c49f"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f743d3c71a5a38de72647392","scopeContentSha256":"fe7742fbb4b43fccd5c7a9df0f9387bff92e189dc96bfe0c753360885a797925","localRef":"s36"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:253b31161d563d79524ced21","scopeContentSha256":"2d0a11d42a1b13d420d5895086e2c85ac6202f6d60926fc848029242c5f64174","localRef":"s6"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l6","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge:link:38","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l6","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge:link:38","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:253b31161d563d79524ced21","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:f743d3c71a5a38de72647392","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l6","source":"s6","target":"s36","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Local Wess–Zumino consistency cohomology is a separate consistency method with a trivial-principal-bundle assumption; automatic applicability to discrete string anomaly tests is not asserted."],"challengeStatement":"Local Wess–Zumino consistency cohomology is a separate anomaly-consistency method with a trivial-principal-bundle assumption; applicability to discrete string anomaly tests is not automatic.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8f32c9816c88693b1073966b7a701a9b37bb56e07d9ba2cad4a63d5f1402c9e9","reply.jsonSha256":"8c68a543650d3f514e6786d7086053d0a248a085a91a8aa06d8510672569eddf","reply.raw.txtSha256":"4078ce93f48399d496ba26c1fdc6466c79b74546b897d1697834754400e4f1e2","receipt.jsonSha256":"f87d07d2ccdf90d57355244e3f8765638cd205b4d77a5d068fec762c97f8b858","normalization.jsonSha256":"bb5dfa2f90198d6fbce2eaa772e11d0e0e24e3921bd040bbffd0ee22ec34c92e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"bdf5fc214ef75952ec3360a1c4eb99436f3eec3d99bc16eb07356419349e9005"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-076a8e988b123c215a92-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"1462bc51e14463b7105728663b25abb906aa4c53414bec11f93960ea3b120f7e","reply.jsonSha256":"8fdb429497f25696e1c08e0bd4adabb75019d80c9fae159a31c4d1603dcfecc0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"014064f5a2f1974cfcde5bfe9ba6ffe8bfc2b120c439f5dfc1c4bfff66309b72","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa830d9bbdf5879bf096e608f8ce9d5f44658a12b2762c511859d49f2c19febe","normalization.jsonSha256":"5b5f52e1e68270a1c48112f924ad6ac5bde0c0e93e59a83ca0cd9f11ef9fc495"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:253b31161d563d79524ced21"},{"ref":"x3_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f743d3c71a5a38de72647392"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:253b31161d563d79524ced21"},{"ref":"x3_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f743d3c71a5a38de72647392"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d6","originalRef":"l6","status":"route","source":"s36","target":"s6","type":"method_for","title":"Use local Wess–Zumino cohomology for applicable anomaly-consistency questions","rationale":"Local Wess–Zumino consistency cohomology supplies the method; anomaly compatibility and gauging consistency supply the target. The original method direction therefore requires reversal.","qualification":"Applicability is limited to the stated Yang–Mills-type local BRS cohomology with compact Lie group, trivial principal bundle, globally defined forms and polynomials in fields and finitely many derivatives. External fields and nontrivial spacetime cohomology are allowed within that setting. The announced result covers arbitrary ghost number and form degree, modulo BRS-exact and spacetime-exact terms. It establishes no extension to nontrivial principal bundles, automatic application to discrete string anomaly tests, complete global-anomaly classification or representation-specific anomaly coefficients.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l6","s36","s6"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The local Wess–Zumino cohomology question supplies the anomaly-consistency method, requiring reversal toward s6. The qualification retains the trivial principal bundle, locality, polynomial and globally defined form assumptions while excluding automatic transfer to discrete string tests, nontrivial bundles or complete global-anomaly classifications.","refs":["l6","s36","s6"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l7":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l7","source":"q025-candidate-question:8167beb97c0f26ca30868a12","target":"q025-candidate-question:5bfbf57a25426c653b9178d4","type":"premise_check","title":"Check existence and no-go assumptions for a vacuum-energy construction","rationale":"A particular vacuum-energy construction can depend on existence and consistency conditions examined by s16. The arrow correctly runs from the conditional construction question to the relevant audit.","qualification":"Only constructions meeting the stated dynamical, perturbative and quantum hypotheses are covered. A tree-level or ansatz-specific no-go does not automatically extend to quantum corrections, another duality frame or full string theory. A positive contribution is not a minimum of the complete dynamical system. Metastable de Sitter space, evolving dark energy and an observable formulation remain distinct, as do radiative stability, realistic matter and observational viability.","evidenceIds":["unit:020694a6559437feca3f0b1c23d2dd4ff57b293fa51a330edbefeb19c03337ef","unit:044c89558474fca51d0009429d9c11f666287f530eaefa958aaf399f00296a1b","unit:061237fed4ff2e3b945ed826221c78fe0cad2d68d1648af23358a193000574e3","unit:13e947fb27e924b731f3c5a26a5c063fdcecbb60e813f3fe09aba6a98b8b4b68","unit:16678cfa667e88f9b68447aab15ea0a65f14227932fc28e9d0c8b49e5694830f","unit:179616289a37dd58fb9ed09878903b0770a41afe7e44baadf7bc37991d955e56","unit:1ec1869c236c714a75217808faf94f1d0890c44436c554933c942e62a4a02cf2","unit:252cf7494baee99032934337115a72a64e8dbdd83756ef3901f10f538546df06","unit:2ffae8b17f3ee5b76c8f3c6a8cd389368715f9d1775e486f6c27246d4b2ceef2","unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","unit:5c474dddabd28af3a6559a75af32bff50241b635118305fd32955733b719c62c","unit:5f07deb20d7cbc7e22f2da1b72f37318f368866d9da86e90381db6f1fe2ba6e5","unit:68533562018d518e0a6193108741b857d915b11910a7d0d65d00fe6e0d355dee","unit:802cf1f1983df3141e930fb2ccdeeefdef8a1167e1b4fc91de464b83da700dd2","unit:8438fa00085f56094076a8c2b001b2f1fd8a5f40d16f91d03e053882b9b18dcc","unit:88d07cd5d082b9712f26b9dd0dfa287c7f27d501a0833ad995e43aa52523bc32","unit:bc7d047ea7fa315802d2fdfb581f0f3d9b2678c1fd06a8868323d012c01298da","unit:bcfdeed1bd17700ea33d71dbf7194b20d87c75eba1eac127e8557c76d862d22b","unit:d2034b292e268141ec5162ca7880c7997df055abcafd3d0d4c491893b4092729","unit:d24f7d346a3f287079d21166bf233ec06a1f6b0f5d13eb226e33d44b8ed45500","unit:d418d446b3fe531c2fda27ea0c4826b5e90be9649c55a9124a6fddd6731b8120","unit:dacc4c28ffd8de9eb99ffae3f7617364d1fc4a56b939ef39838895dfb66aefee","unit:e3581a187356f856d52a152891645bfc03faf2c890a0a83a2ff910d8bbe867b0","unit:e75d07a9a9814714235abe81093190d2acb38363d6a39195c6091a603c99c100","unit:f52b3603def5bfba237bce862122fc53e0dc118f3729dd7c54c0185ba0594352","unit:f5aafbebbdadceb09757d1d63d685d0d3bc1e76cff58e5185c2612c675f6f420","unit:f7977419ee3cbdecd2553d0cd09ae49e94a91e17e08d3cc8c29eae28d618005e","unit:f7e7fdca6548f0c503ec5c2620b740e5ebdc38bdd74eed0a17e0a2d26a5e4968"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8167beb97c0f26ca30868a12","scopeContentSha256":"9492cd17d3b5d1a31512c98091ae6994a5910f5fa73c74d703455de9fbf81e6e","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5bfbf57a25426c653b9178d4","scopeContentSha256":"6a368d3790b7d4a582b6b02c15f244023c3a8dcfbb2ebe6e727bacefa102508d","localRef":"s16"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l7","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge:link:16","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l7","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge:link:16","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:8167beb97c0f26ca30868a12","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:5bfbf57a25426c653b9178d4","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l7","source":"s22","target":"s16","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["Existence and no-go audits can constrain particular vacuum-energy constructions only within their stated assumptions."],"challengeStatement":"Existence and no-go arguments bear on vacuum-energy constructions only under their own stated dynamical and quantum assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a065dc77831f1426b136a434261e7ff3a728d452fe131e6a223ea37b66766bf5","reply.jsonSha256":"dbd73f35444e16f3a0632cf5e2f81847da586bbb4d58abd15fed1e63163c4188","reply.raw.txtSha256":"4c5ecf27fa7d17999b3680fc82c75db2a66a995218652304a00f4b6ebbfdd15f","receipt.jsonSha256":"94ee3e29f72ce7c8f6ee3f307c13eb652c73f464df05be06c299951b81287b08","normalization.jsonSha256":"97fad01ede5d903016c7b2d65d83cec491da46044e90f0276b4d46ecce297351","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"bec31b5d869b9e42b8e3ff1ffaacdbf51b11cd7aa9d810c54458480a80891c42"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5d78b9598438b810a5fdd990d9991fa4744a4c945459209bbe6827842a795aeb","reply.jsonSha256":"c0827234923137611faf0a59b9fbaa04d8ba4e9995c996b3cf3a52745340f987","reply.raw.txtSha256":"816842d55f475679594e1878ff7044b75a88cf1822139a6517292d73e8b18e42","receipt.jsonSha256":"d57df400c3ad234e76cd841786e88d91de916de979e710185dbb9d180f52eaf3","normalization.jsonSha256":"5a6f7539afc5d6ea482c219bee305df1a196125741c43dd061024d99df902c3a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8167beb97c0f26ca30868a12"},{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5bfbf57a25426c653b9178d4"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8167beb97c0f26ca30868a12"},{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5bfbf57a25426c653b9178d4"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d7","originalRef":"l7","status":"route","source":"s22","target":"s16","type":"premise_check","title":"Check existence and no-go assumptions for a vacuum-energy construction","rationale":"A particular vacuum-energy construction can depend on existence and consistency conditions examined by s16. The arrow correctly runs from the conditional construction question to the relevant audit.","qualification":"Only constructions meeting the stated dynamical, perturbative and quantum hypotheses are covered. A tree-level or ansatz-specific no-go does not automatically extend to quantum corrections, another duality frame or full string theory. A positive contribution is not a minimum of the complete dynamical system. Metastable de Sitter space, evolving dark energy and an observable formulation remain distinct, as do radiative stability, realistic matter and observational viability.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l7","s22","s16"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The conditional vacuum-energy construction points to the relevant existence and no-go audit, matching premise_check. Both statements limit applicability to the argument's own assumptions. The qualification maintains this restriction and distinguishes positive contributions, dynamical minima, metastability, quantum extrapolations and observational viability.","refs":["l7","s22","s16"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l8":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l8","source":"q025-candidate-question:22ff633e30349f549be61820","target":"q025-candidate-question:6aa6745e1b0914098d589de2","type":"method_for","title":"Use thermal-correlation methods in the specified matrix cosmologies","rationale":"Both original statements attribute thermal-correlation methods to the matrix proposals. This supports a method contribution from s5 to that component of s18.","qualification":"The connection is to the specified thermal matrix proposals, not to an established thermal state of the topological-gravity proposal. Closed-string gases and matrix systems are not identified, and their background, equilibrium and spectrum-transfer assumptions remain distinct. The high-temperature import of IKKT numerical results and the distinction between BFSS time and proposed emergent time retain their stated status. Shared methods establish neither a common microscopic system nor a certified nonsingular or ultraviolet-complete cosmology.","evidenceIds":["unit:2dd65a000a38f3068985bb14d21b19611d1444d3dcbeb021c86d410c5f417b8f","unit:31d5d2ccf8164911139f8708436d2a45b3bed425d06001af7131733bb73b9171","unit:3a25e73160277dea8f48bb999f78f06cff869a73a1e3ea6f0f55b18320e5e138","unit:425dc97b8e07baff2e3fc2922ceed7bd61b749cc10deca4c24a97bd25ad7124d","unit:53948920f6b1d30aa4b03d528cd0e69cb688b4d724784f538b2589e23f0c77da","unit:78fb234d77b80818569c70f64da55c8b164d7521238ece58aff6e79d43677ad4","unit:9424deb300b97a6b378abe0f752ddc3bedb16dd490e916cc5f17f885bcc6aad7","unit:9ca073cf0785d04a4223f9a8af82fb12e180f0023f05b34a7850167501228a70","unit:c4afe5b88b1da70060a3abd3cd8298246a98a4d653322f9093de570aece6a8f5","unit:c5981c7e4e6d2578331b8285c11707d509140831db4a0e6187c1046ef880352a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22ff633e30349f549be61820","scopeContentSha256":"8811090c0da4342458552bf87864ca1b284f9acda0f6ad34a6fe20fff3e67414","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6aa6745e1b0914098d589de2","scopeContentSha256":"bbb6856b27de53ef53d91d6a113c253f280c7c281e38e1dd305052cc9d44e150","localRef":"s18"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l8","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge:link:29","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l8","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge:link:29","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:22ff633e30349f549be61820","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:6aa6745e1b0914098d589de2","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l8","source":"s5","target":"s18","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["The child attributes thermal-correlation methods to matrix proposals. This does not establish a thermal state for the topological proposal or equate microscopic systems."],"challengeStatement":"The child attributes thermal-correlation methods to matrix proposals. This does not establish a thermal state for the topological proposal or identify the microscopic systems.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a065dc77831f1426b136a434261e7ff3a728d452fe131e6a223ea37b66766bf5","reply.jsonSha256":"dbd73f35444e16f3a0632cf5e2f81847da586bbb4d58abd15fed1e63163c4188","reply.raw.txtSha256":"4c5ecf27fa7d17999b3680fc82c75db2a66a995218652304a00f4b6ebbfdd15f","receipt.jsonSha256":"94ee3e29f72ce7c8f6ee3f307c13eb652c73f464df05be06c299951b81287b08","normalization.jsonSha256":"97fad01ede5d903016c7b2d65d83cec491da46044e90f0276b4d46ecce297351","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"bec31b5d869b9e42b8e3ff1ffaacdbf51b11cd7aa9d810c54458480a80891c42"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5d78b9598438b810a5fdd990d9991fa4744a4c945459209bbe6827842a795aeb","reply.jsonSha256":"c0827234923137611faf0a59b9fbaa04d8ba4e9995c996b3cf3a52745340f987","reply.raw.txtSha256":"816842d55f475679594e1878ff7044b75a88cf1822139a6517292d73e8b18e42","receipt.jsonSha256":"d57df400c3ad234e76cd841786e88d91de916de979e710185dbb9d180f52eaf3","normalization.jsonSha256":"5a6f7539afc5d6ea482c219bee305df1a196125741c43dd061024d99df902c3a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22ff633e30349f549be61820"},{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6aa6745e1b0914098d589de2"},{"ref":"c3","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22ff633e30349f549be61820"},{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6aa6745e1b0914098d589de2"},{"ref":"c3","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d8","originalRef":"l8","status":"route","source":"s5","target":"s18","type":"method_for","title":"Use thermal-correlation methods in the specified matrix cosmologies","rationale":"Both original statements attribute thermal-correlation methods to the matrix proposals. This supports a method contribution from s5 to that component of s18.","qualification":"The connection is to the specified thermal matrix proposals, not to an established thermal state of the topological-gravity proposal. Closed-string gases and matrix systems are not identified, and their background, equilibrium and spectrum-transfer assumptions remain distinct. The high-temperature import of IKKT numerical results and the distinction between BFSS time and proposed emergent time retain their stated status. Shared methods establish neither a common microscopic system nor a certified nonsingular or ultraviolet-complete cosmology.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l8","s5","s18"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements attribute thermal-correlation methods to the matrix proposals, supporting method_for from s5 to the specified component of s18. The qualification preserves the lack of an established thermal state for the topological proposal, the distinct microscopic systems, the numerical import and the separate time definitions.","refs":["l8","s5","s18"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l9":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l9","source":"q025-candidate-question:22ff633e30349f549be61820","target":"q025-candidate-question:1c82dddd78c19c2008d9a50f","type":"method_for","title":"Supply thermal perturbations to the specified hybrid inflationary history","rationale":"Thermal fluctuation production supplies the perturbation-generation component of the hybrid history. Later flattening by inflation and the compatibility of the successive phases remain separate questions.","qualification":"This route is restricted to the closed-string hybrid construction, with initial thermal equilibrium, survival of the generated spectrum, sufficiently persistent super-Hubble observable modes and the specified radiation history. It retains TCC and the stated constant-w warm-inflation or cold exponential-potential settings. The near-exponential slow-roll limit fails the paired hybrid bounds under those assumptions. No graceful exit for the cold exponential potential, solved curved-radiation recollapse problem or microscopic nonsingular history follows. The method is not transferred to every open-string or lingering scenario, and string-frame quasi-static behavior establishes no Einstein-frame equivalence.","evidenceIds":["unit:2dd65a000a38f3068985bb14d21b19611d1444d3dcbeb021c86d410c5f417b8f","unit:31d5d2ccf8164911139f8708436d2a45b3bed425d06001af7131733bb73b9171","unit:3a25e73160277dea8f48bb999f78f06cff869a73a1e3ea6f0f55b18320e5e138","unit:425dc97b8e07baff2e3fc2922ceed7bd61b749cc10deca4c24a97bd25ad7124d","unit:484e68d48c5712f5b7bfb9989a5316ca5c9f48be6b0eb5aa8436966fd09f7f22","unit:53948920f6b1d30aa4b03d528cd0e69cb688b4d724784f538b2589e23f0c77da","unit:6ba38f0834229a7f59aa742da17798d668ccf115e2cecae73c7a61e28d3f5813","unit:760128930c9993167f1283f7b6ce8d20265bbb5b22f87f33fae24ff2d2f59b0e","unit:78fb234d77b80818569c70f64da55c8b164d7521238ece58aff6e79d43677ad4","unit:9424deb300b97a6b378abe0f752ddc3bedb16dd490e916cc5f17f885bcc6aad7","unit:9adbb3fff5814088247783b7a8c7da8a59b90c9865ebd2f3b49b382d0440578f","unit:9ca073cf0785d04a4223f9a8af82fb12e180f0023f05b34a7850167501228a70","unit:c5981c7e4e6d2578331b8285c11707d509140831db4a0e6187c1046ef880352a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22ff633e30349f549be61820","scopeContentSha256":"8811090c0da4342458552bf87864ca1b284f9acda0f6ad34a6fe20fff3e67414","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1c82dddd78c19c2008d9a50f","scopeContentSha256":"6666b456bb420b27f9c36e2ccadc41296841c35317a68fb818f1385bd6562399","localRef":"s3"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l9","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge:link:30","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l9","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge:link:30","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:22ff633e30349f549be61820","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:1c82dddd78c19c2008d9a50f","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l9","source":"s5","target":"s3","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Thermal fluctuation production can supply a component of the specified hybrid history; later inflation and its additional conditions remain separate."],"challengeStatement":"Thermal fluctuation production contributes to the specified hybrid history; later inflation, mode survival and its additional bounds require separate checks.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a065dc77831f1426b136a434261e7ff3a728d452fe131e6a223ea37b66766bf5","reply.jsonSha256":"dbd73f35444e16f3a0632cf5e2f81847da586bbb4d58abd15fed1e63163c4188","reply.raw.txtSha256":"4c5ecf27fa7d17999b3680fc82c75db2a66a995218652304a00f4b6ebbfdd15f","receipt.jsonSha256":"94ee3e29f72ce7c8f6ee3f307c13eb652c73f464df05be06c299951b81287b08","normalization.jsonSha256":"97fad01ede5d903016c7b2d65d83cec491da46044e90f0276b4d46ecce297351","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"bec31b5d869b9e42b8e3ff1ffaacdbf51b11cd7aa9d810c54458480a80891c42"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5d78b9598438b810a5fdd990d9991fa4744a4c945459209bbe6827842a795aeb","reply.jsonSha256":"c0827234923137611faf0a59b9fbaa04d8ba4e9995c996b3cf3a52745340f987","reply.raw.txtSha256":"816842d55f475679594e1878ff7044b75a88cf1822139a6517292d73e8b18e42","receipt.jsonSha256":"d57df400c3ad234e76cd841786e88d91de916de979e710185dbb9d180f52eaf3","normalization.jsonSha256":"5a6f7539afc5d6ea482c219bee305df1a196125741c43dd061024d99df902c3a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22ff633e30349f549be61820"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1c82dddd78c19c2008d9a50f"},{"ref":"c3","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22ff633e30349f549be61820"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1c82dddd78c19c2008d9a50f"},{"ref":"c3","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d9","originalRef":"l9","status":"route","source":"s5","target":"s3","type":"method_for","title":"Supply thermal perturbations to the specified hybrid inflationary history","rationale":"Thermal fluctuation production supplies the perturbation-generation component of the hybrid history. Later flattening by inflation and the compatibility of the successive phases remain separate questions.","qualification":"This route is restricted to the closed-string hybrid construction, with initial thermal equilibrium, survival of the generated spectrum, sufficiently persistent super-Hubble observable modes and the specified radiation history. It retains TCC and the stated constant-w warm-inflation or cold exponential-potential settings. The near-exponential slow-roll limit fails the paired hybrid bounds under those assumptions. No graceful exit for the cold exponential potential, solved curved-radiation recollapse problem or microscopic nonsingular history follows. The method is not transferred to every open-string or lingering scenario, and string-frame quasi-static behavior establishes no Einstein-frame equivalence.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l9","s5","s3"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d9","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Thermal fluctuation production supplies the stated hybrid history's perturbation component, supporting the original method direction. The qualification retains equilibrium, spectrum and mode survival, the radiation history, TCC and the warm/cold settings, including the failed near-exponential limit and unresolved exit and recollapse questions.","refs":["l9","s5","s3"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l10":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l10","source":"q025-candidate-question:4592028a976cb6e398ae76a2","target":"q025-candidate-question:f8ffa37fa518a5158bee6ae1","type":"related_question","title":"Explore dark-radiation abundance in a visible Hagedorn plasma","rationale":"The statements connect primordial thermal histories to a distinct Hagedorn application with a radiation-abundance target. They do not identify a persistence or exit construction from s11 that s37 applies, so a direct application_of claim between these complete questions is unsupported.","qualification":"The abundance question concerns an open-string Hagedorn plasma confined to the visible sector, a dark sector outside that plasma and potentially appreciable inflaton branching into dark radiation. It is not an application of a closed-string scalar-spectrum formula or a common-bath assumption. No quantitative suppression, abundance calculation or observational limit is supplied. The background and exit questions retain their source-specific dilaton, frame and control requirements; finite temperature alone establishes no past completeness.","evidenceIds":["unit:077506d0635aa68b6023717968f0121b9c9da185186db035c8ebe1c69868ed54","unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","unit:484e68d48c5712f5b7bfb9989a5316ca5c9f48be6b0eb5aa8436966fd09f7f22","unit:5deaad457b4e2dad628871e78c919d2e170bd40ce9aa757f915678f5a73aa7e2","unit:760128930c9993167f1283f7b6ce8d20265bbb5b22f87f33fae24ff2d2f59b0e","unit:d0966e2152666dd0da4dd7de24b826a2ab54e2e00c115b4ebb5aab15fe92d5a4"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4592028a976cb6e398ae76a2","scopeContentSha256":"3b074e7dd20c6292ee5e4149039babdf95f7b2e99f119cdb9e4b5317fe9f4598","localRef":"s11"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f8ffa37fa518a5158bee6ae1","scopeContentSha256":"895a7881e329d01b31024ba861464c50d2f1f304b33170acf795ff0424e3d122","localRef":"s37"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l10","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge:link:32","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l10","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge:link:32","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:4592028a976cb6e398ae76a2","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:f8ffa37fa518a5158bee6ae1","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l10","source":"s11","target":"s37","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["The visible-sector Hagedorn plasma is a distinct thermal-history application to dark-radiation abundance, not an application of a closed-string scalar-spectrum formula."],"challengeStatement":"Visible-sector open-string plasma provides a distinct thermal-history application to dark-radiation abundance, with sector participation assumptions separate from closed-string perturbation calculations.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a065dc77831f1426b136a434261e7ff3a728d452fe131e6a223ea37b66766bf5","reply.jsonSha256":"dbd73f35444e16f3a0632cf5e2f81847da586bbb4d58abd15fed1e63163c4188","reply.raw.txtSha256":"4c5ecf27fa7d17999b3680fc82c75db2a66a995218652304a00f4b6ebbfdd15f","receipt.jsonSha256":"94ee3e29f72ce7c8f6ee3f307c13eb652c73f464df05be06c299951b81287b08","normalization.jsonSha256":"97fad01ede5d903016c7b2d65d83cec491da46044e90f0276b4d46ecce297351","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"bec31b5d869b9e42b8e3ff1ffaacdbf51b11cd7aa9d810c54458480a80891c42"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5d78b9598438b810a5fdd990d9991fa4744a4c945459209bbe6827842a795aeb","reply.jsonSha256":"c0827234923137611faf0a59b9fbaa04d8ba4e9995c996b3cf3a52745340f987","reply.raw.txtSha256":"816842d55f475679594e1878ff7044b75a88cf1822139a6517292d73e8b18e42","receipt.jsonSha256":"d57df400c3ad234e76cd841786e88d91de916de979e710185dbb9d180f52eaf3","normalization.jsonSha256":"5a6f7539afc5d6ea482c219bee305df1a196125741c43dd061024d99df902c3a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4592028a976cb6e398ae76a2"},{"ref":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f8ffa37fa518a5158bee6ae1"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4592028a976cb6e398ae76a2"},{"ref":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f8ffa37fa518a5158bee6ae1"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d10","originalRef":"l10","status":"route","source":"s11","target":"s37","type":"related_question","title":"Explore dark-radiation abundance in a visible Hagedorn plasma","rationale":"The statements connect primordial thermal histories to a distinct Hagedorn application with a radiation-abundance target. They do not identify a persistence or exit construction from s11 that s37 applies, so a direct application_of claim between these complete questions is unsupported.","qualification":"The abundance question concerns an open-string Hagedorn plasma confined to the visible sector, a dark sector outside that plasma and potentially appreciable inflaton branching into dark radiation. It is not an application of a closed-string scalar-spectrum formula or a common-bath assumption. No quantitative suppression, abundance calculation or observational limit is supplied. The background and exit questions retain their source-specific dilaton, frame and control requirements; finite temperature alone establishes no past completeness.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l10","s11","s37"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d10","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The statements establish a connection between primordial thermal histories and visible-sector Hagedorn abundance physics but identify no persistence or exit construction transferred from s11. related_question is therefore supported. The qualification preserves the separate dark sector, potentially appreciable inflaton branching and absence of a supplied quantitative suppression calculation.","refs":["l10","s11","s37"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l10","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l11":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l11","source":"q025-candidate-question:85856543c0cd2198f16d4ad3","target":"q025-candidate-question:abcd6d61cfd7986df83a9212","type":"related_question","title":"Examine internal motion and supported loops relevant to network evolution","rationale":"Internal motion, localization and supported loops can inform specified network models and their observational interpretation. The statements identify this physical connection, but do not specify a transferable method or a particular network premise sufficient to select a stronger directional type.","qualification":"Supported-loop existence and restricted stability remain distinct from dynamical throat localization and collective network consequences. The M4×S1 model, deformed-conifold embedding and source-specific treatments of expansion or gravitational energy loss are not interchangeable. Stable loops in a parameter range establish neither generic localization nor universal damping of internal motion. Implications for intercommutation, loop populations and gravitational radiation require their own network tests.","evidenceIds":["unit:07721cd2784be6b8d946ab995bc34115fe06c00c8c11756b914148a9a1d29256","unit:1306756664377d046523a80e2ba56403228528443099745e7dd1e6d9cd9d9a11","unit:20f8de7803ae8986c02ebcfccf663d8be4b940ef5a1028528159e7067ec8bb6d","unit:21f9a79fe647cc90493d58b314d2ea770770b104d32610154738b4f0ec1dfa10","unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","unit:5389f4317809a21bb141105f1118c137d4537dced7520271d29ade247b07be67","unit:54cda38b1d3dd8fc25523524cb7c349214c9e8c2cf7db96808d6ef3923373080","unit:56d54e303273b2385d3449783a21f349d2db0a7f89e1a2a309c14fcb58b59291","unit:5bc48c695884b67a92e29371c5f6218bace76e3f1703a26cf9266a16cc85826e","unit:5ff99caf481dc7dd22db1d29fd665b920667f4ad66a9fd48e8d7db30eb5ce36d","unit:7b170403a5737e6af2f3a916800b62fce5693b16a808044e1344110b2dd9c52e","unit:8608fdf8333e331d6569d3e56a21a5f321cbd4138d198ec2811b9e488fa817cc","unit:9cb390ac6388635d3e7ff5311abf3eb19d650ce2c41d2c0657eb715cbf2a518b","unit:ad7ca505da4b78e1e8cd9ec535b3fe24ddc438e91886b08e02eb5f5b792b42bf","unit:b90840fad6cab60ba59b622293438489d3849be966c3c24495234da398192c51","unit:c002cde99345c03f0ce94163150352de3a38280b28c24413fb92d5abcbec50bf","unit:c1d524fbcd47146eee36e4c4453b7d8258faaa9196062a248a49e9088546e6b3","unit:db642f6ba1ed046bfa2d96ceb8ac02f169f56068e832de717167edaf1fcb216a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:85856543c0cd2198f16d4ad3","scopeContentSha256":"44bdb67249358064eae26abb998d5a29185a33b51ca8bee930c4b20c5997d44b","localRef":"s23"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:abcd6d61cfd7986df83a9212","scopeContentSha256":"2201b08fbba69e0a42518bfe57bf715d6a686812c09e557b7af28c85ed7e18d6","localRef":"s27"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l11","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge:link:36","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l11","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge:link:36","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:85856543c0cd2198f16d4ad3","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:abcd6d61cfd7986df83a9212","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l11","source":"s23","target":"s27","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Internal motion, localization and supported loops may inform specified network models; loop support and localization require their own dynamical tests."],"challengeStatement":"Internal motion and localization may inform specified network models. Supported-loop existence and dynamical localization require their own tests.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a065dc77831f1426b136a434261e7ff3a728d452fe131e6a223ea37b66766bf5","reply.jsonSha256":"dbd73f35444e16f3a0632cf5e2f81847da586bbb4d58abd15fed1e63163c4188","reply.raw.txtSha256":"4c5ecf27fa7d17999b3680fc82c75db2a66a995218652304a00f4b6ebbfdd15f","receipt.jsonSha256":"94ee3e29f72ce7c8f6ee3f307c13eb652c73f464df05be06c299951b81287b08","normalization.jsonSha256":"97fad01ede5d903016c7b2d65d83cec491da46044e90f0276b4d46ecce297351","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"bec31b5d869b9e42b8e3ff1ffaacdbf51b11cd7aa9d810c54458480a80891c42"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5d78b9598438b810a5fdd990d9991fa4744a4c945459209bbe6827842a795aeb","reply.jsonSha256":"c0827234923137611faf0a59b9fbaa04d8ba4e9995c996b3cf3a52745340f987","reply.raw.txtSha256":"816842d55f475679594e1878ff7044b75a88cf1822139a6517292d73e8b18e42","receipt.jsonSha256":"d57df400c3ad234e76cd841786e88d91de916de979e710185dbb9d180f52eaf3","normalization.jsonSha256":"5a6f7539afc5d6ea482c219bee305df1a196125741c43dd061024d99df902c3a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:85856543c0cd2198f16d4ad3"},{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:abcd6d61cfd7986df83a9212"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:85856543c0cd2198f16d4ad3"},{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:abcd6d61cfd7986df83a9212"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d11","originalRef":"l11","status":"route","source":"s23","target":"s27","type":"related_question","title":"Examine internal motion and supported loops relevant to network evolution","rationale":"Internal motion, localization and supported loops can inform specified network models and their observational interpretation. The statements identify this physical connection, but do not specify a transferable method or a particular network premise sufficient to select a stronger directional type.","qualification":"Supported-loop existence and restricted stability remain distinct from dynamical throat localization and collective network consequences. The M4×S1 model, deformed-conifold embedding and source-specific treatments of expansion or gravitational energy loss are not interchangeable. Stable loops in a parameter range establish neither generic localization nor universal damping of internal motion. Implications for intercommutation, loop populations and gravitational radiation require their own network tests.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l11","s23","s27"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d11","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The statements say internal motion and localization may inform network models without identifying a transferable method or a definite prerequisite for a particular network inference. related_question preserves that connection. The qualification correctly separates supported-loop existence, restricted stability, dynamical localization and collective network consequences.","refs":["l11","s23","s27"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l11","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l12":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l12","source":"q025-candidate-question:ee1bdb8d7c5bf6f08e35baf6","target":"q025-candidate-question:46228dfa113d796ed0b87b17","type":"method_for","title":"Use duality-constrained actions in specified cosmological models","rationale":"Action construction and gravitational-correction methods in s35 can inform particular dynamics questions in s13. The original direction already runs from the methodological contribution to the target.","qualification":"Applicability retains the selected homogeneous reduction, derivative or α′ treatment, dimensions, matter content, dilaton conditions and frame. All-order claims apply only where explicitly stated; restricted FRG results remain restricted. No common coefficient choice, controlled string embedding or correction hierarchy is established. An accelerating solution is not by itself an inflationary model, and solution existence does not establish perturbative stability. The α of α-attractors is not identified with α′.","evidenceIds":["unit:0c27e14149f724ec96bec1d403473b584158d9b52c11bdc1d83e6236bea3c33e","unit:1f6d36df85d4b913e9eafd3507a8083faed3974d6c5253c917c6d12bc3a9cd04","unit:252cf7494baee99032934337115a72a64e8dbdd83756ef3901f10f538546df06","unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","unit:458febaf68f6666a36b672776d100949c4a309505a7f46309662d93b2e2f2045","unit:4918ab1b72dcf371f377e59de8fa375c92a499a4bebfd232b5864db81e35c0f8","unit:57dd0fff751821c7460894e2fcc9cee0b458903c9607e400bc27eebc9fdf7ecb","unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","unit:5f07deb20d7cbc7e22f2da1b72f37318f368866d9da86e90381db6f1fe2ba6e5","unit:6d41548b84f2e324c98e151a7a311d2729cc1a2a122396cc46564353d94f5130","unit:73a8aeef9c76bf4a47fff920393c9237621e849a0ca023df9ebf18a509d96efc","unit:760128930c9993167f1283f7b6ce8d20265bbb5b22f87f33fae24ff2d2f59b0e","unit:8ef244c61cf0f14bfaaa09f3883b99ecf9e8836f0d77616c9cd602fb1565cf34","unit:a06b1b2fd26cf92900904897235a68fe032a37b1b7236e43160cf763a1373da3","unit:a782de620d0297fda5f2fde2d7797272d9dd6ccde4b952a1441c1bd9f25d52c2","unit:a97a5fc4f24a62db3c8984dfb6cb91c3d8f7ba40024456f68cf419cf1af4e818","unit:ac3a3a17bc71b5f9af496d419306c8deb25ced2e9298b16c92be97d2230562bc","unit:baef926a0b6cfdc1d5bb2ce06ce3093e2cd9da90deb3676db7dd2a0a605c1d7b","unit:bcfdeed1bd17700ea33d71dbf7194b20d87c75eba1eac127e8557c76d862d22b","unit:ca9c72ab1403388ca64da24455aa91c96abbd4ec3820973cbc46038d4403d823","unit:d24f7d346a3f287079d21166bf233ec06a1f6b0f5d13eb226e33d44b8ed45500","unit:d825ef0619fdf5d55dba0e647357e1c6339c3d942a25656a238f16ab8dd138d2","unit:e3581a187356f856d52a152891645bfc03faf2c890a0a83a2ff910d8bbe867b0","unit:f6aca0fa856ac0255597236e9f62549b1c39c84a07173c492d8c9a1883975c87","unit:f8fe0bbe8ea2539d7113f239f3978c9f288f399b457960cbc0aa8254a5152335"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ee1bdb8d7c5bf6f08e35baf6","scopeContentSha256":"a49d86d835485ee5683a1da2aaacccd5f9b0550f1fca4080b6edfc2d49615f6d","localRef":"s35"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:46228dfa113d796ed0b87b17","scopeContentSha256":"5a2d158ead6d9de97f148a0f17bd624480c290193a0539966990e2f557bbf500","localRef":"s13"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l12","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge:link:44","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l12","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge:link:44","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:ee1bdb8d7c5bf6f08e35baf6","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:46228dfa113d796ed0b87b17","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l12","source":"s35","target":"s13","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Action construction and gravitational corrections can inform particular cosmological models; method overlap does not establish an inflationary solution or common control."],"challengeStatement":"Action construction and gravitational corrections can inform particular cosmological models without establishing an inflationary solution or common control.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a065dc77831f1426b136a434261e7ff3a728d452fe131e6a223ea37b66766bf5","reply.jsonSha256":"dbd73f35444e16f3a0632cf5e2f81847da586bbb4d58abd15fed1e63163c4188","reply.raw.txtSha256":"4c5ecf27fa7d17999b3680fc82c75db2a66a995218652304a00f4b6ebbfdd15f","receipt.jsonSha256":"94ee3e29f72ce7c8f6ee3f307c13eb652c73f464df05be06c299951b81287b08","normalization.jsonSha256":"97fad01ede5d903016c7b2d65d83cec491da46044e90f0276b4d46ecce297351","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"bec31b5d869b9e42b8e3ff1ffaacdbf51b11cd7aa9d810c54458480a80891c42"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-0f746a8c818c4fa5bc2d-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5d78b9598438b810a5fdd990d9991fa4744a4c945459209bbe6827842a795aeb","reply.jsonSha256":"c0827234923137611faf0a59b9fbaa04d8ba4e9995c996b3cf3a52745340f987","reply.raw.txtSha256":"816842d55f475679594e1878ff7044b75a88cf1822139a6517292d73e8b18e42","receipt.jsonSha256":"d57df400c3ad234e76cd841786e88d91de916de979e710185dbb9d180f52eaf3","normalization.jsonSha256":"5a6f7539afc5d6ea482c219bee305df1a196125741c43dd061024d99df902c3a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ee1bdb8d7c5bf6f08e35baf6"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:46228dfa113d796ed0b87b17"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ee1bdb8d7c5bf6f08e35baf6"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:46228dfa113d796ed0b87b17"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d12","originalRef":"l12","status":"route","source":"s35","target":"s13","type":"method_for","title":"Use duality-constrained actions in specified cosmological models","rationale":"Action construction and gravitational-correction methods in s35 can inform particular dynamics questions in s13. The original direction already runs from the methodological contribution to the target.","qualification":"Applicability retains the selected homogeneous reduction, derivative or α′ treatment, dimensions, matter content, dilaton conditions and frame. All-order claims apply only where explicitly stated; restricted FRG results remain restricted. No common coefficient choice, controlled string embedding or correction hierarchy is established. An accelerating solution is not by itself an inflationary model, and solution existence does not establish perturbative stability. The α of α-attractors is not identified with α′.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l12","s35","s13"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d12","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Action construction and gravitational corrections supply the stated methodological contribution from s35 to particular models in s13. The qualification retains reduction, frame, dilaton, dimensional and correction assumptions while preserving both statements' exclusions of an established inflationary solution or common calculational control.","refs":["l12","s35","s13"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l12","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l13":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l13","source":"q025-candidate-question:ee1bdb8d7c5bf6f08e35baf6","target":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","type":"method_for","title":"Use duality-constrained reductions in effective-description studies","rationale":"The supplied method is the action-construction and α′-reduction component of s35. It contributes to the effective-description question in s2, requiring reversal of the original arrow.","qualification":"The contribution is limited to the specified cosmological reductions and action ansätze. Solution existence and temporal or anisotropic stability remain separate tests, and no general compactification theorem follows. Physical and generalized dilatons, string and Einstein frames, and vacuum and matter sectors remain distinguished. The isotropic B2=0 FRG calculation retains its ansatz and dimensional expansion. Unspecified α′ orders, loops, broader ansätze and perturbative matching remain unassessed; action construction alone establishes no complete controlled quantum expansion.","evidenceIds":["unit:06d619a3f9cd6c118e95ce21a68c5afb281abdc88140d30b9b75e417ae77b328","unit:0c27e14149f724ec96bec1d403473b584158d9b52c11bdc1d83e6236bea3c33e","unit:1421bc40e0296de522e491369956d13142b21c3130129bfd0b8a6eace1de0026","unit:16ba46eabea64a755d1df737c8fe9326212f881fa1f17af6660d42527e9e350f","unit:1f6d36df85d4b913e9eafd3507a8083faed3974d6c5253c917c6d12bc3a9cd04","unit:1f86b8f56cc05dc17d3b634d5e2a23030579e86853782bb35ca45669d02e0b46","unit:25014344603a0d374ba7b097c9f633f6b7bbd27aa57af705b27720f160822faa","unit:42153de84eb3201c9bd1b31073bcf78905d3eac2d2dbf222bf1ce8f781d5bc32","unit:458febaf68f6666a36b672776d100949c4a309505a7f46309662d93b2e2f2045","unit:6d41548b84f2e324c98e151a7a311d2729cc1a2a122396cc46564353d94f5130","unit:73a8aeef9c76bf4a47fff920393c9237621e849a0ca023df9ebf18a509d96efc","unit:8ff938e6fb3430f74f3a2a1c2533da4895247f5e7bc2b3004b60e59304d63535","unit:9d5a1b9a7ae2a06bddfbb112b2bf99197f32095b151d1a1e55abcf2507683475","unit:a06b1b2fd26cf92900904897235a68fe032a37b1b7236e43160cf763a1373da3","unit:a782de620d0297fda5f2fde2d7797272d9dd6ccde4b952a1441c1bd9f25d52c2","unit:ac3a3a17bc71b5f9af496d419306c8deb25ced2e9298b16c92be97d2230562bc","unit:baef926a0b6cfdc1d5bb2ce06ce3093e2cd9da90deb3676db7dd2a0a605c1d7b","unit:bcfdeed1bd17700ea33d71dbf7194b20d87c75eba1eac127e8557c76d862d22b","unit:ca9c72ab1403388ca64da24455aa91c96abbd4ec3820973cbc46038d4403d823","unit:d24f7d346a3f287079d21166bf233ec06a1f6b0f5d13eb226e33d44b8ed45500","unit:d825ef0619fdf5d55dba0e647357e1c6339c3d942a25656a238f16ab8dd138d2","unit:de3f3441e41f78390511e22dd1a68bafb5856a8a9b292000b6d0d2310f89ac94","unit:e3581a187356f856d52a152891645bfc03faf2c890a0a83a2ff910d8bbe867b0","unit:e482cec954a76d0f10eeb897e9e6aa0d270b6820988dead420fe07e1bf974134","unit:f0304fcd14da8894c06149b79ac42ca8b8761d69b9ed26cdcaeed02d20da576d","unit:f470eb824c4b1d16b3f6da475b1b6ce95854de58171ce5393ccb7281c05a2a35"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ee1bdb8d7c5bf6f08e35baf6","scopeContentSha256":"a49d86d835485ee5683a1da2aaacccd5f9b0550f1fca4080b6edfc2d49615f6d","localRef":"s35"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","scopeContentSha256":"cd7a16d039368d5b5b3ef6a3740e2852ca2d5e3de60e11d423e7984cd53b935b","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l13","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge:link:41","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l13","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge:link:41","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:ee1bdb8d7c5bf6f08e35baf6","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l13","source":"s2","target":"s35","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Duality-constrained cosmological actions and alpha-prime reductions provide a particular action-construction and solution-testing direction, not a general compactification theorem."],"challengeStatement":"The action-construction component supplies duality-constrained cosmological methods. Its solution and stability questions remain separate, and no general compactification theorem follows.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d74ef9e8de7ccb6c76fada42c5e27d42c62aec361ae9b20ac18e2f8242bc2462","reply.jsonSha256":"7543ed240baf12671130249e9ac447f641347028f8ad40cbbe1236ebabc039c7","reply.raw.txtSha256":"360eef90c54b8e706ba9d55e7688667e03aff2e4518891c245f9cd79e9e366b1","receipt.jsonSha256":"b894284b89419cb2243f6083f0a10d854a1c04ac200e2504c9c6c361993abff0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7186445d890d5bce4b53e7b5c839d86bfeebe545827571f3165888f65cec8442","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f48e593f505e082901f043e292bc7f7ac36c911464b469bf761d05e984dc814"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"b0b76a86e2c011a6ba54fff12ae9898300fbbebf8d2049353cf95cc6aea35848","reply.jsonSha256":"32ad3764ac69abca6b479b0af99324de4f268ec634bd263dc987273997535ae1","reply.raw.txtSha256":"a3a5da31e96c47bd9b153eef5cbceda3e25ac45ee2fcb284e02915812c83d8b5","receipt.jsonSha256":"30438f5a50df56e8b4b59c12aa2d3282f3b894f92af32d2a8d0044f403bb5278","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9b7f54fe98d3361e373a66ff4ce3b4c65c968ef112a10d9ce0d9e11b407566f"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ee1bdb8d7c5bf6f08e35baf6"},{"ref":"c0","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ee1bdb8d7c5bf6f08e35baf6"},{"ref":"c0","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d13","originalRef":"l13","status":"route","source":"s35","target":"s2","type":"method_for","title":"Use duality-constrained reductions in effective-description studies","rationale":"The supplied method is the action-construction and α′-reduction component of s35. It contributes to the effective-description question in s2, requiring reversal of the original arrow.","qualification":"The contribution is limited to the specified cosmological reductions and action ansätze. Solution existence and temporal or anisotropic stability remain separate tests, and no general compactification theorem follows. Physical and generalized dilatons, string and Einstein frames, and vacuum and matter sectors remain distinguished. The isotropic B2=0 FRG calculation retains its ansatz and dimensional expansion. Unspecified α′ orders, loops, broader ansätze and perturbative matching remain unassessed; action construction alone establishes no complete controlled quantum expansion.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l13","s35","s2"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d13","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements identify the duality-constrained action-construction component as the method, making s35 the supplier to s2. The qualification separates construction from solution and stability tests, preserves the restricted FRG setting and leaves unspecified orders and broader control questions unresolved without inferring a compactification theorem.","refs":["l13","s35","s2"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l13","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l15":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l15","source":"q025-candidate-question:a159f0d586a5ce50fb70fd88","target":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","type":"method_for","title":"Use multiplet constraints and truncations to specify effective degrees of freedom","rationale":"Multiplet constraints and truncation procedures determine which scalar and fermionic degrees of freedom an effective description retains. The method supplier is s26, so the original arrow is reversed.","qualification":"The route concerns the specified supersymmetric inflationary effective theories and their scalar and fermionic consistency tests, including later evolution only where studied. Removing a field and retaining a heavy field define different theories. Nilpotency alone does not remove the inflatino, and Kähler restrictions are not identical to explicit superfield constraints. Equal bosonic content establishes no equality of fermion dynamics. The claims are description-supported; full constraints and component actions are not supplied.","evidenceIds":["unit:017de48f3564e05fa47dba1b125f6bc42b0b9582627ac2ab6db00bda5edf808b","unit:06d619a3f9cd6c118e95ce21a68c5afb281abdc88140d30b9b75e417ae77b328","unit:1421bc40e0296de522e491369956d13142b21c3130129bfd0b8a6eace1de0026","unit:16ba46eabea64a755d1df737c8fe9326212f881fa1f17af6660d42527e9e350f","unit:1f86b8f56cc05dc17d3b634d5e2a23030579e86853782bb35ca45669d02e0b46","unit:25014344603a0d374ba7b097c9f633f6b7bbd27aa57af705b27720f160822faa","unit:3372b98092cc30e1f7f816341d9ae8f3c27f7e6070998d7901ce1fed758b036d","unit:42153de84eb3201c9bd1b31073bcf78905d3eac2d2dbf222bf1ce8f781d5bc32","unit:4bb5b829c202cc0a4b1045af45eb81d85af9ce700134b9fde8edd5222ffc798f","unit:589d9bba737ec1db999f931b7297321d3d9c43e9ad21c6339b1df6caa7f94f6f","unit:5926cc767072e12a3d70879b8a9f4380f508984f08f4f67c78b865d050ce6941","unit:5aaf22ff12bfc99733a0d0dfa7676447af086258e2fa0a925c23a8167c8c12f6","unit:65fed2a98cbc7fc544e490165d77d0db71d0947e97b761d93121f122a119698e","unit:84ed94cc09f6a635a48a1fc95ebe96e4860c3408179d488838c1336897f47caa","unit:8ff938e6fb3430f74f3a2a1c2533da4895247f5e7bc2b3004b60e59304d63535","unit:9d5a1b9a7ae2a06bddfbb112b2bf99197f32095b151d1a1e55abcf2507683475","unit:a78f72ee47933d926710be6d0e61e986a92beefaef580a06be266f63461a3d04","unit:b564686b9466ac0a5100ff6600af40299759f8be6d7c5db1d9c77f092452e807","unit:bdc8f87478fb481f878f096b21dac75da7fad34196a347f816aec80f0eee559c","unit:bf88fab97e53eaef787f0a3f897ebb1fa114a49b6fccac8b4330cbafcf5ecb76","unit:c6bc3cc451c6a5097f6f176b72632f2fc43d6d92432a57020888a21d01f1de78","unit:d52dd2be0bd05db766ebf1b7c9d9e5d8ea73d9e56836a26960b82886add2d4a0","unit:de3f3441e41f78390511e22dd1a68bafb5856a8a9b292000b6d0d2310f89ac94","unit:e482cec954a76d0f10eeb897e9e6aa0d270b6820988dead420fe07e1bf974134","unit:e7610d69f92141238c5da091db0e22d1a82c4a42a2b621163af9e463c0a8da0e","unit:f0304fcd14da8894c06149b79ac42ca8b8761d69b9ed26cdcaeed02d20da576d","unit:f470eb824c4b1d16b3f6da475b1b6ce95854de58171ce5393ccb7281c05a2a35"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a159f0d586a5ce50fb70fd88","scopeContentSha256":"f79e670a82b5d69959830c3ad3893e87dd531ed48cb093a5260fbc9e086da310","localRef":"s26"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","scopeContentSha256":"cd7a16d039368d5b5b3ef6a3740e2852ca2d5e3de60e11d423e7984cd53b935b","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l15","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge:link:45","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l15","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge:link:45","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:a159f0d586a5ce50fb70fd88","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l15","source":"s2","target":"s26","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Multiplet constraints and truncations determine which scalar and fermion degrees of freedom the effective theory actually retains."],"challengeStatement":"Multiplet constraints and truncations determine which scalar and fermionic degrees of freedom remain in an effective description.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d74ef9e8de7ccb6c76fada42c5e27d42c62aec361ae9b20ac18e2f8242bc2462","reply.jsonSha256":"7543ed240baf12671130249e9ac447f641347028f8ad40cbbe1236ebabc039c7","reply.raw.txtSha256":"360eef90c54b8e706ba9d55e7688667e03aff2e4518891c245f9cd79e9e366b1","receipt.jsonSha256":"b894284b89419cb2243f6083f0a10d854a1c04ac200e2504c9c6c361993abff0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7186445d890d5bce4b53e7b5c839d86bfeebe545827571f3165888f65cec8442","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f48e593f505e082901f043e292bc7f7ac36c911464b469bf761d05e984dc814"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"b0b76a86e2c011a6ba54fff12ae9898300fbbebf8d2049353cf95cc6aea35848","reply.jsonSha256":"32ad3764ac69abca6b479b0af99324de4f268ec634bd263dc987273997535ae1","reply.raw.txtSha256":"a3a5da31e96c47bd9b153eef5cbceda3e25ac45ee2fcb284e02915812c83d8b5","receipt.jsonSha256":"30438f5a50df56e8b4b59c12aa2d3282f3b894f92af32d2a8d0044f403bb5278","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9b7f54fe98d3361e373a66ff4ce3b4c65c968ef112a10d9ce0d9e11b407566f"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a159f0d586a5ce50fb70fd88"},{"ref":"c3","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a159f0d586a5ce50fb70fd88"},{"ref":"c3","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d15","originalRef":"l15","status":"route","source":"s26","target":"s2","type":"method_for","title":"Use multiplet constraints and truncations to specify effective degrees of freedom","rationale":"Multiplet constraints and truncation procedures determine which scalar and fermionic degrees of freedom an effective description retains. The method supplier is s26, so the original arrow is reversed.","qualification":"The route concerns the specified supersymmetric inflationary effective theories and their scalar and fermionic consistency tests, including later evolution only where studied. Removing a field and retaining a heavy field define different theories. Nilpotency alone does not remove the inflatino, and Kähler restrictions are not identical to explicit superfield constraints. Equal bosonic content establishes no equality of fermion dynamics. The claims are description-supported; full constraints and component actions are not supplied.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l15","s26","s2"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d15","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Multiplet constraints and truncations supply the method for specifying retained effective degrees of freedom, requiring reversal from s26 toward s2. The qualification preserves removal versus stabilization, nilpotency versus inflatino removal, distinct constraint procedures and the description-only status of the component claims.","refs":["l15","s26","s2"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l15","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l16":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l16","source":"q025-candidate-question:6aaa9013e706aa371167686a","target":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","type":"method_for","title":"Use computational workflows for specified noncanonical effective models","rationale":"The symbolic-potential and numerical-evolution component of s19 supplies the computational contribution to effective-description studies. Its methodological direction is toward s2.","qualification":"This contribution concerns tractable noncanonical multifield evolution with the potentials and kinetic structures of the stated demonstrations. Inflationary and dark-energy applications remain separate. Computational tractability does not establish a controlled correction hierarchy, reliable truncation or convergence of a quantum expansion. The broader lecture topics in s19 do not themselves demonstrate this computational method, and the computational source is description-only. No later consistency criterion or updated historical observational bound is inferred.","evidenceIds":["unit:06d619a3f9cd6c118e95ce21a68c5afb281abdc88140d30b9b75e417ae77b328","unit:1421bc40e0296de522e491369956d13142b21c3130129bfd0b8a6eace1de0026","unit:16ba46eabea64a755d1df737c8fe9326212f881fa1f17af6660d42527e9e350f","unit:1f86b8f56cc05dc17d3b634d5e2a23030579e86853782bb35ca45669d02e0b46","unit:25014344603a0d374ba7b097c9f633f6b7bbd27aa57af705b27720f160822faa","unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","unit:42153de84eb3201c9bd1b31073bcf78905d3eac2d2dbf222bf1ce8f781d5bc32","unit:77c17ec43ea961b855e80e8a8ec17f2d47ceccfd5ab01ca23e7c447a53e0607d","unit:8ff938e6fb3430f74f3a2a1c2533da4895247f5e7bc2b3004b60e59304d63535","unit:9d5a1b9a7ae2a06bddfbb112b2bf99197f32095b151d1a1e55abcf2507683475","unit:de3f3441e41f78390511e22dd1a68bafb5856a8a9b292000b6d0d2310f89ac94","unit:e482cec954a76d0f10eeb897e9e6aa0d270b6820988dead420fe07e1bf974134","unit:f0304fcd14da8894c06149b79ac42ca8b8761d69b9ed26cdcaeed02d20da576d","unit:f470eb824c4b1d16b3f6da475b1b6ce95854de58171ce5393ccb7281c05a2a35"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6aaa9013e706aa371167686a","scopeContentSha256":"b37bdd38e7429b64ac5ab1ee36bfe80c6cf00ecbc2315f9a31855f4333fd8138","localRef":"s19"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","scopeContentSha256":"cd7a16d039368d5b5b3ef6a3740e2852ca2d5e3de60e11d423e7984cd53b935b","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l16","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge:link:46","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l16","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge:link:46","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:6aaa9013e706aa371167686a","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l16","source":"s2","target":"s19","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["The computational component concerns tractable noncanonical multifield evolution. The same existing question also preserves lecture targets, which do not themselves demonstrate a computational method."],"challengeStatement":"The computational component concerns tractable noncanonical multifield evolution. The same existing question retains lecture targets, which do not themselves demonstrate that computational method.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d74ef9e8de7ccb6c76fada42c5e27d42c62aec361ae9b20ac18e2f8242bc2462","reply.jsonSha256":"7543ed240baf12671130249e9ac447f641347028f8ad40cbbe1236ebabc039c7","reply.raw.txtSha256":"360eef90c54b8e706ba9d55e7688667e03aff2e4518891c245f9cd79e9e366b1","receipt.jsonSha256":"b894284b89419cb2243f6083f0a10d854a1c04ac200e2504c9c6c361993abff0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7186445d890d5bce4b53e7b5c839d86bfeebe545827571f3165888f65cec8442","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f48e593f505e082901f043e292bc7f7ac36c911464b469bf761d05e984dc814"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"b0b76a86e2c011a6ba54fff12ae9898300fbbebf8d2049353cf95cc6aea35848","reply.jsonSha256":"32ad3764ac69abca6b479b0af99324de4f268ec634bd263dc987273997535ae1","reply.raw.txtSha256":"a3a5da31e96c47bd9b153eef5cbceda3e25ac45ee2fcb284e02915812c83d8b5","receipt.jsonSha256":"30438f5a50df56e8b4b59c12aa2d3282f3b894f92af32d2a8d0044f403bb5278","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9b7f54fe98d3361e373a66ff4ce3b4c65c968ef112a10d9ce0d9e11b407566f"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x5_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6aaa9013e706aa371167686a"},{"ref":"c5","kind":"attributed_child_review"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceId":"ev:479709da7b0565762ae80098e8872263","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":15,"start":0,"end":2393,"textSha256":"d418ffc8c05e0bbae1cf077f9e2d94112db012340a54a83a5779743616202eca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceId":"ev:62f49ee8e8a82ce94588f3b1f2ab2f95","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":796,"textSha256":"54e81229f435c7cea300f012cc56902556fc702f6f63cd4d1da53452403899f7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceId":"ev:97564ff6e8f39bb975ed1d2ce35c5879","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1721,"textSha256":"6851be5b22ec413c1d1bc9adc047e842297468a22d3ec9cd9dd7c30403d7638a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x5_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6aaa9013e706aa371167686a"},{"ref":"c5","kind":"attributed_child_review"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceId":"ev:479709da7b0565762ae80098e8872263","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":15,"start":0,"end":2393,"textSha256":"d418ffc8c05e0bbae1cf077f9e2d94112db012340a54a83a5779743616202eca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceId":"ev:62f49ee8e8a82ce94588f3b1f2ab2f95","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":796,"textSha256":"54e81229f435c7cea300f012cc56902556fc702f6f63cd4d1da53452403899f7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceId":"ev:97564ff6e8f39bb975ed1d2ce35c5879","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1721,"textSha256":"6851be5b22ec413c1d1bc9adc047e842297468a22d3ec9cd9dd7c30403d7638a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d16","originalRef":"l16","status":"route","source":"s19","target":"s2","type":"method_for","title":"Use computational workflows for specified noncanonical effective models","rationale":"The symbolic-potential and numerical-evolution component of s19 supplies the computational contribution to effective-description studies. Its methodological direction is toward s2.","qualification":"This contribution concerns tractable noncanonical multifield evolution with the potentials and kinetic structures of the stated demonstrations. Inflationary and dark-energy applications remain separate. Computational tractability does not establish a controlled correction hierarchy, reliable truncation or convergence of a quantum expansion. The broader lecture topics in s19 do not themselves demonstrate this computational method, and the computational source is description-only. No later consistency criterion or updated historical observational bound is inferred.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l16","s19","s2"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d16","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The identified symbolic and numerical component supplies the computational method, supporting reversal from s19 toward the relevant effective-description studies. The qualification keeps tractability separate from established correction control, truncation reliability and quantum convergence, and does not treat the broader lecture topics as demonstrations of that method.","refs":["l16","s19","s2"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l16","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l17":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l17","source":"q025-candidate-question:fbe2f0658c055d54f586125f","target":"q025-candidate-question:a159f0d586a5ce50fb70fd88","type":"application_of","title":"Use multiplet and truncation choices in gravitino calculations","rationale":"The supergravity branch of the gravitino question applies choices about retained and removed fermions made by the multiplet and constraint constructions. The applied question is s38 and the underlying construction question is s26.","qualification":"This connection is limited to the specified constrained or ordinary supergravity settings; it does not identify every spectator spin-3/2 model with an inflationary multiplet construction. All dynamically retained fermions matter, and equal bosonic sectors do not establish equal fermion dynamics. Constant mass belongs only to the stated examples or limits. A nominal sound-speed parameter is not a production rate, and neither universal catastrophic production nor an order-one lower bound is established. No primary excerpts are supplied for adjudicating the debate.","evidenceIds":["unit:017de48f3564e05fa47dba1b125f6bc42b0b9582627ac2ab6db00bda5edf808b","unit:281fda38c3628c7b8b057dc64063688a476c809c59862b31213b832a24a07205","unit:2910afadf42ab22cf3e2fc12b53496219320fb5184c6a5dca9573ab96de3dc85","unit:3372b98092cc30e1f7f816341d9ae8f3c27f7e6070998d7901ce1fed758b036d","unit:4bb5b829c202cc0a4b1045af45eb81d85af9ce700134b9fde8edd5222ffc798f","unit:4ed65262ab8eef86382c7d02b813a2365001cf9c73093d15cf83039eea931d64","unit:5521b361971bc524c0b4977f4372d96a60dad07e18fc5f8ffbe94515453b928a","unit:5812384fcf2af37bf9fbf14473233d764d3be30e8c187d5e467c02002fe891fd","unit:589d9bba737ec1db999f931b7297321d3d9c43e9ad21c6339b1df6caa7f94f6f","unit:5926cc767072e12a3d70879b8a9f4380f508984f08f4f67c78b865d050ce6941","unit:5aaf22ff12bfc99733a0d0dfa7676447af086258e2fa0a925c23a8167c8c12f6","unit:63bffb8037fdb394bda14c571f1fc055205789bd8c7410a7f36fdcb6ed407df5","unit:65fed2a98cbc7fc544e490165d77d0db71d0947e97b761d93121f122a119698e","unit:7b027293c26b6335533ca66852cff9935ec823b3d4b7e662e4ec3cc5327d7dec","unit:84ed94cc09f6a635a48a1fc95ebe96e4860c3408179d488838c1336897f47caa","unit:a78f72ee47933d926710be6d0e61e986a92beefaef580a06be266f63461a3d04","unit:b564686b9466ac0a5100ff6600af40299759f8be6d7c5db1d9c77f092452e807","unit:b8e7cb6af01bc0427ba23318da1776f59bce84c8fe748c9215abaf6dfcfd9bde","unit:bdc8f87478fb481f878f096b21dac75da7fad34196a347f816aec80f0eee559c","unit:bf88fab97e53eaef787f0a3f897ebb1fa114a49b6fccac8b4330cbafcf5ecb76","unit:c6bc3cc451c6a5097f6f176b72632f2fc43d6d92432a57020888a21d01f1de78","unit:d52dd2be0bd05db766ebf1b7c9d9e5d8ea73d9e56836a26960b82886add2d4a0","unit:e7610d69f92141238c5da091db0e22d1a82c4a42a2b621163af9e463c0a8da0e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fbe2f0658c055d54f586125f","scopeContentSha256":"a30d8d3b030cf4b4f27d4c4be40f7c8f819b274b5406058352d9aa1b3efd4a9f","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a159f0d586a5ce50fb70fd88","scopeContentSha256":"f79e670a82b5d69959830c3ad3893e87dd531ed48cb093a5260fbc9e086da310","localRef":"s26"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l17","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge:link:56","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l17","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge:link:56","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:a159f0d586a5ce50fb70fd88","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:fbe2f0658c055d54f586125f","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l17","source":"s26","target":"s38","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Retained or removed fermions materially affect longitudinal gravitino propagation and production questions; similar bosonic sectors do not establish equivalent fermion dynamics."],"challengeStatement":"Retained versus removed fermions materially affect longitudinal gravitino propagation and production questions; equal bosonic content does not establish equal fermion dynamics.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d74ef9e8de7ccb6c76fada42c5e27d42c62aec361ae9b20ac18e2f8242bc2462","reply.jsonSha256":"7543ed240baf12671130249e9ac447f641347028f8ad40cbbe1236ebabc039c7","reply.raw.txtSha256":"360eef90c54b8e706ba9d55e7688667e03aff2e4518891c245f9cd79e9e366b1","receipt.jsonSha256":"b894284b89419cb2243f6083f0a10d854a1c04ac200e2504c9c6c361993abff0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7186445d890d5bce4b53e7b5c839d86bfeebe545827571f3165888f65cec8442","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f48e593f505e082901f043e292bc7f7ac36c911464b469bf761d05e984dc814"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"b0b76a86e2c011a6ba54fff12ae9898300fbbebf8d2049353cf95cc6aea35848","reply.jsonSha256":"32ad3764ac69abca6b479b0af99324de4f268ec634bd263dc987273997535ae1","reply.raw.txtSha256":"a3a5da31e96c47bd9b153eef5cbceda3e25ac45ee2fcb284e02915812c83d8b5","receipt.jsonSha256":"30438f5a50df56e8b4b59c12aa2d3282f3b894f92af32d2a8d0044f403bb5278","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9b7f54fe98d3361e373a66ff4ce3b4c65c968ef112a10d9ce0d9e11b407566f"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a159f0d586a5ce50fb70fd88"},{"ref":"x3_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fbe2f0658c055d54f586125f"},{"ref":"c3","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a159f0d586a5ce50fb70fd88"},{"ref":"x3_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fbe2f0658c055d54f586125f"},{"ref":"c3","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d17","originalRef":"l17","status":"route","source":"s38","target":"s26","type":"application_of","title":"Use multiplet and truncation choices in gravitino calculations","rationale":"The supergravity branch of the gravitino question applies choices about retained and removed fermions made by the multiplet and constraint constructions. The applied question is s38 and the underlying construction question is s26.","qualification":"This connection is limited to the specified constrained or ordinary supergravity settings; it does not identify every spectator spin-3/2 model with an inflationary multiplet construction. All dynamically retained fermions matter, and equal bosonic sectors do not establish equal fermion dynamics. Constant mass belongs only to the stated examples or limits. A nominal sound-speed parameter is not a production rate, and neither universal catastrophic production nor an order-one lower bound is established. No primary excerpts are supplied for adjudicating the debate.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l17","s38","s26"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d17","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The constrained and ordinary supergravity branch of s38 applies field-content and truncation constructions addressed by s26. The reversed application_of route is supported for that branch. Its qualification preserves retained-versus-removed fermions, limited constant-mass assumptions and the distinction between a sound-speed parameter and physical production.","refs":["l17","s38","s26"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l17","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l18":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l18","source":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","target":"q025-candidate-region:d9a3fb6ff54e53ca6812cea2","type":"method_for","title":"Test effective-description control in the applicable cosmological constructions","rationale":"Effective-description control supplies checks on truncations, correction hierarchies and claimed cosmological regimes. The method question is s2 and the broader target region is s39.","qualification":"The route applies only to cosmological constructions for which the stated higher-dimensional or effective-description tests are relevant. Static and evolving internal fields, finite and asymptotic limits, dimensions, frames and classical or quantum approximations remain source-specific. An obstruction for one ansatz does not exclude another duality frame or resummation. Reported hierarchies and conjectural criteria are not verified constructions or universal laws, and no common control test is imposed on every cosmic-string, matter-sector or neighboring comparison question in s39.","evidenceIds":["unit:06d619a3f9cd6c118e95ce21a68c5afb281abdc88140d30b9b75e417ae77b328","unit:0ec9ffd3bd604b650ecef4eff79361ddf607fb043eae11c3be88d77be436e4af","unit:1421bc40e0296de522e491369956d13142b21c3130129bfd0b8a6eace1de0026","unit:16ba46eabea64a755d1df737c8fe9326212f881fa1f17af6660d42527e9e350f","unit:1f86b8f56cc05dc17d3b634d5e2a23030579e86853782bb35ca45669d02e0b46","unit:25014344603a0d374ba7b097c9f633f6b7bbd27aa57af705b27720f160822faa","unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","unit:42153de84eb3201c9bd1b31073bcf78905d3eac2d2dbf222bf1ce8f781d5bc32","unit:53948920f6b1d30aa4b03d528cd0e69cb688b4d724784f538b2589e23f0c77da","unit:72f4c3a669487af409a2d41a9787b334b9f62c23465107014eead55b87c7b498","unit:8ff938e6fb3430f74f3a2a1c2533da4895247f5e7bc2b3004b60e59304d63535","unit:9d5a1b9a7ae2a06bddfbb112b2bf99197f32095b151d1a1e55abcf2507683475","unit:bebef5361994e7697246476e0eed50d33552c9a52e09c8880d0cf6ed19857d3f","unit:de3f3441e41f78390511e22dd1a68bafb5856a8a9b292000b6d0d2310f89ac94","unit:e482cec954a76d0f10eeb897e9e6aa0d270b6820988dead420fe07e1bf974134","unit:e64cfef1df0ac5832d482634198227c3371e030c6cfb511a68bd06a259d1b005","unit:f0304fcd14da8894c06149b79ac42ca8b8761d69b9ed26cdcaeed02d20da576d","unit:f470eb824c4b1d16b3f6da475b1b6ce95854de58171ce5393ccb7281c05a2a35","unit:fe7edae1df43a00dedb70ffdd7e451b630131eb05d5a3a5063c011e64236fd98"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","scopeContentSha256":"cd7a16d039368d5b5b3ef6a3740e2852ca2d5e3de60e11d423e7984cd53b935b","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:d9a3fb6ff54e53ca6812cea2","scopeContentSha256":"c87de3dc852251bf4ae31d9125c4ccd28974c12d513a99527fb5b427a4253cd9","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l18","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge:link:9","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l18","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge:link:9","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:d9a3fb6ff54e53ca6812cea2","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l18","source":"s39","target":"s2","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Effective-description control supplies cross-batch checks on truncations, correction hierarchies and claimed cosmological regimes."],"challengeStatement":"Effective-description control supplies cross-batch tests of truncations, correction hierarchies and claimed cosmological regimes.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d74ef9e8de7ccb6c76fada42c5e27d42c62aec361ae9b20ac18e2f8242bc2462","reply.jsonSha256":"7543ed240baf12671130249e9ac447f641347028f8ad40cbbe1236ebabc039c7","reply.raw.txtSha256":"360eef90c54b8e706ba9d55e7688667e03aff2e4518891c245f9cd79e9e366b1","receipt.jsonSha256":"b894284b89419cb2243f6083f0a10d854a1c04ac200e2504c9c6c361993abff0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7186445d890d5bce4b53e7b5c839d86bfeebe545827571f3165888f65cec8442","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f48e593f505e082901f043e292bc7f7ac36c911464b469bf761d05e984dc814"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-ede3e74822319a5ec5a5-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"b0b76a86e2c011a6ba54fff12ae9898300fbbebf8d2049353cf95cc6aea35848","reply.jsonSha256":"32ad3764ac69abca6b479b0af99324de4f268ec634bd263dc987273997535ae1","reply.raw.txtSha256":"a3a5da31e96c47bd9b153eef5cbceda3e25ac45ee2fcb284e02915812c83d8b5","receipt.jsonSha256":"30438f5a50df56e8b4b59c12aa2d3282f3b894f92af32d2a8d0044f403bb5278","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9b7f54fe98d3361e373a66ff4ce3b4c65c968ef112a10d9ce0d9e11b407566f"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d"},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:7bcf187a512e6048026ab1540a9372e8","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":14,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c0370c0b7b360c684b3fa733888fe9d3a7f72c571e96027e8d018ba9ef17fe03","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"c1","kind":"attributed_child_review"},{"ref":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"},{"ref":"c4","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d"},{"ref":"c1","kind":"attributed_child_review"},{"ref":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"},{"ref":"c4","kind":"attributed_child_review"},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:7bcf187a512e6048026ab1540a9372e8","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":14,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c0370c0b7b360c684b3fa733888fe9d3a7f72c571e96027e8d018ba9ef17fe03","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d18","originalRef":"l18","status":"route","source":"s2","target":"s39","type":"method_for","title":"Test effective-description control in the applicable cosmological constructions","rationale":"Effective-description control supplies checks on truncations, correction hierarchies and claimed cosmological regimes. The method question is s2 and the broader target region is s39.","qualification":"The route applies only to cosmological constructions for which the stated higher-dimensional or effective-description tests are relevant. Static and evolving internal fields, finite and asymptotic limits, dimensions, frames and classical or quantum approximations remain source-specific. An obstruction for one ansatz does not exclude another duality frame or resummation. Reported hierarchies and conjectural criteria are not verified constructions or universal laws, and no common control test is imposed on every cosmic-string, matter-sector or neighboring comparison question in s39.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l18","s2","s39"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d18","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements identify effective-description control as supplying tests of truncations, correction hierarchies and cosmological regimes, so s2 supplies the method to s39. The qualification restricts applicability to relevant constructions and preserves source-specific limits without imposing a common test on every member of the region.","refs":["l18","s2","s39"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l18","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l19":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l19","source":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","target":"q025-candidate-question:09d21797eba0045cf9179b12","type":"method_for","title":"Use cosmological control tests within quantum-description construction","rationale":"Higher-dimensional cosmological control supplies a specified methodological direction within the wider description-construction program. The arrow runs from that contribution in s2 to s0.","qualification":"This is a contribution to the relevant higher-dimensional, bulk-to-brane and effective-description branches, not a universal method for intrinsic QFT, constrained quantization or every proposed de Sitter description. Expansion hierarchies, truncations and convergence retain their source-specific regimes. A controlled calculation does not establish a complete quantum theory, and renormalizability, finiteness, positivity, unitarity and background independence remain separate assessments. No common duality or quantization prescription follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:06d619a3f9cd6c118e95ce21a68c5afb281abdc88140d30b9b75e417ae77b328","unit:1421bc40e0296de522e491369956d13142b21c3130129bfd0b8a6eace1de0026","unit:16ba46eabea64a755d1df737c8fe9326212f881fa1f17af6660d42527e9e350f","unit:1f86b8f56cc05dc17d3b634d5e2a23030579e86853782bb35ca45669d02e0b46","unit:25014344603a0d374ba7b097c9f633f6b7bbd27aa57af705b27720f160822faa","unit:42153de84eb3201c9bd1b31073bcf78905d3eac2d2dbf222bf1ce8f781d5bc32","unit:7b4dc81132bb3052c56b0c5a7251f1ffae6a361b10b9fbc7c70f7820583286ef","unit:80e68f047ac20e38ce26b446eb2e8af9e7b973bc4892aa28080464d19a5409ce","unit:8ff938e6fb3430f74f3a2a1c2533da4895247f5e7bc2b3004b60e59304d63535","unit:9d5a1b9a7ae2a06bddfbb112b2bf99197f32095b151d1a1e55abcf2507683475","unit:de3f3441e41f78390511e22dd1a68bafb5856a8a9b292000b6d0d2310f89ac94","unit:e482cec954a76d0f10eeb897e9e6aa0d270b6820988dead420fe07e1bf974134","unit:f0304fcd14da8894c06149b79ac42ca8b8761d69b9ed26cdcaeed02d20da576d","unit:f470eb824c4b1d16b3f6da475b1b6ce95854de58171ce5393ccb7281c05a2a35"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","scopeContentSha256":"cd7a16d039368d5b5b3ef6a3740e2852ca2d5e3de60e11d423e7984cd53b935b","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:09d21797eba0045cf9179b12","scopeContentSha256":"57b74ae56893021391834868d0598cc3ddc4542b618d45fd815b4765161b974f","localRef":"s0"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l19","originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge:link:18","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l19","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge:link:18","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:09d21797eba0045cf9179b12","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l19","source":"s0","target":"s2","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Higher-dimensional cosmological control provides a specified method direction within the wider description-construction program."],"challengeStatement":"Higher-dimensional cosmological control supplies a specified methodological direction within the broader description-construction programme.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"e5504a2c4da076c85104a2266ee2d7736e709a7e52a5d800af1700943c465cac","reply.jsonSha256":"c7670a2a3f34e361015dbf9482392020b1a573e8a83b6a60c6d900a13e7586eb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7128fb9710583d064a2fdcc6d110ef96841760bd1a2dbd1edd5c8ddfa1e91415","receipt.jsonSha256":"1dfa74ad6830cffb2282b232a13cc93ffd43f1fb20e262f22448b79744e21f56","normalization.jsonSha256":"dc92ec109885b2b11e32b021171ca6cb99228c52647c0739d967d53f52076084","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4fe88709dd8c30df946cd8ecebff01e16afac4d554ebd9a82df8762a9494b5cd"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"783fca8ad0c206144b663c532d96a903a50df8724949f88395f9d5e460bfcc59","reply.jsonSha256":"a5b87b3059ea83dd4136caff9089a981a93d2932676041a5fb90dc12adfba988","reply.raw.txtSha256":"0150d21a762614339b2ad10b13e27b5e332664b355b59600c635fd0574428e03","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a03ea25b1d3f029bf1b8a76cff9e15f8ffafc2b2052cabf5059938d238e7b36","normalization.jsonSha256":"f9d3c8d0a480348d5e8e97bd7f55dad45c7dd4baec013e9547a323081f64a5be"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:09d21797eba0045cf9179b12"},{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:09d21797eba0045cf9179b12"},{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0c787e40a4b9f4d880e1ee7d"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d19","originalRef":"l19","status":"route","source":"s2","target":"s0","type":"method_for","title":"Use cosmological control tests within quantum-description construction","rationale":"Higher-dimensional cosmological control supplies a specified methodological direction within the wider description-construction program. The arrow runs from that contribution in s2 to s0.","qualification":"This is a contribution to the relevant higher-dimensional, bulk-to-brane and effective-description branches, not a universal method for intrinsic QFT, constrained quantization or every proposed de Sitter description. Expansion hierarchies, truncations and convergence retain their source-specific regimes. A controlled calculation does not establish a complete quantum theory, and renormalizability, finiteness, positivity, unitarity and background independence remain separate assessments. No common duality or quantization prescription follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l19","s2","s0"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d19","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements identify higher-dimensional cosmological control as a methodological contribution within the broader construction program, supporting reversal from s2 to s0. The qualification limits that contribution to relevant branches and preserves the separation between controlled calculations, complete quantum theories and the distinct consistency criteria.","refs":["l19","s2","s0"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l19","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l20":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l20","source":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c","target":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","type":"application_of","title":"Use symmetry definitions and gauging structures to analyze breaking and phases","rationale":"The breaking, flow and phase questions apply the symmetry structures and operator or gauging constructions organized by s24. This reverses the original application arrow.","qualification":"The cited lecture treatment supports the stated higher-form properties without extending its detailed treatment to higher-group properties. Other structures retain their separately described support. Explicit breaking, spontaneous breaking and gauging remain distinct, and gauging retains anomaly and background-field conditions. Anomaly constraints are necessary conditions where stated, not complete infrared classifications. No universal local-current definition, common symmetry mechanism or quantitative parity-wall decay conclusion follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:048b24e6fb1702d451e7a2fa9cbf99ceb5dc79756748c46c51dc7fdb5341634f","unit:06fc2e875179b953fd421e410fe6c2bd2645320182c64be3e44125cc7f1d823d","unit:07773a160ebbf445d8342aa4f665542dca7e17366d5f462f793f5dad99484926","unit:077ad8c62c2c8ff1e8f5d7993ded4fd76a7e124e12d2e289d12d34c98a1e2bec","unit:08ed0a4adf8ed31c8bbdd3a38c4b386e315a0d9c800849c73e1d828eb1d73ab5","unit:0cdde3e82466a95627c6bf4d48c086b754e80976d7fad6b1965faea60f60d049","unit:10cc78b1357b454aa6215b512f6a731305176ebdc685f1d284782b01d8d073ba","unit:2add721a2c187da46197d34fc1c6cc58c185b6259dbc13fc878c099bd450eb7f","unit:387a60b627d33cef1247a88a91062c09270f8bba701df2b3c35d9fe17916ce50","unit:479fd01bba5530d46bc8cf136a9b39a497a60d35fe8833f525a9e7eae7600cc6","unit:52bd26ac9bc1fa7da3f0ef55035af631425d0ec0717bb41c996b09f5dacb33d5","unit:5b72ca6c1dce9f6abb744b7b7b5c7efe167d80c04a9158516d933e0201293e56","unit:5ec1ee2dd9812900af3be14dcece90714ac3fe7d2828fa2a6b4f7e021d2ae6a3","unit:63c2129a8cf5d9679d3fedd47f040014eba4b02d2f99709d8f0e9b1bba7a2013","unit:68e2ad317ad34bbf58f59ec555abef57472526a57d9a4a705c40a54ae0066775","unit:760a1cb3290ddf8c3446bdd55f3ae43b763ef10c6a945004f3cde4024cf02c41","unit:760a51193899fb044a5118a91ee6a618502b6c201f0ae95174dcd14ebe2d111b","unit:8c084637064525624a7bcc1f8fbeb124801e77cd1eda3b01fab9a762b7cf10f0","unit:8d012cdc0ce6c73709992943d14bdc6c2fbfc96510b607ce7e92fa49bb427a13","unit:a5071ae7a132b9466a1a55fa21928926ca07a4230a811e6d8d7eca35b7855634","unit:b014332825ca4cdc7d1ef0e3234b0d8276a4f3ad18a1021d32ee5214d3c32a99","unit:b0ddeda5fefc0d2a084f66fdcf6c0eed5ea1e23f1403e662b23b7a2b756f3e4f","unit:b3243010621ba839c60d57fc9a6563615a68974ba45c407927be707fc3fada88","unit:bc7ce334a83277db2aa05625b35d73bfe5f6f1611d4e5658a858a43ecaaf7589","unit:bc8b421870b960cab9d77620e76d73b4f3a6483c2f6d4f1bd40ef2e9ea4afe77","unit:bcb930350cfb30cb461ddebd3d55950894281611fce99b74467d22f1b7048f22","unit:c382e8e37d72e628162b1f8f7e454d7a3d146112a9aa9fd457e0614563b70b61","unit:c428ec107a056565b6700a108e70ec37138fa58eb42ce207ad623e9527bf78fd","unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","unit:cb54cb61db15a47f6e9590e277a050115d4760e0e2e68b12781704e2750cec81","unit:d18705566d9a39b40973aa3e4759e603efe165bc76e69e54aa19c1a5f64974de","unit:e1942fe152e7797bf0bfd4accf8ec67a941c0baf6d9ad1f3cff2b52469d6e02f","unit:ef300e71c2946be15c47b67a1cab1561fc82af70cc8966a6c53c804f36d18fc7","unit:fc2fde2dfdce8d350b0a72bf96b9fac449e8316a4c5f24e4ff90319ba9fc4d87","unit:fef8d2101e3ebd25bc1cab514f17e7ee29f8495d30b9346b98f6d6833787d8b5"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c","scopeContentSha256":"0c62cb248ae157b466d10e16f6fe43104cbd02070f364a7cafb72faef0cffa3c","localRef":"s10"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","scopeContentSha256":"9df5eeb57c828ca805a8889c867a256e76e38e13192ef8ce26ce44c6bf51d190","localRef":"s24"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l20","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-challenge:link:33","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l20","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-challenge:link:33","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l20","source":"s24","target":"s10","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Symmetry structures and their anomalies are used to constrain breaking and phases; the lecture develops these properties for higher-form symmetries."],"challengeStatement":"Symmetry structures and anomalies constrain breaking and phases. The current lecture develops these properties for higher-form symmetries without extending its detailed treatment to higher-group properties.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"588262299b674d4befbe7fe032922d589e6d5f16e771509b80c79af5a0599439","reply.jsonSha256":"6f4e644d6491aa85115bddcb0f2e17d01d323d64932fa442c7d1b9922a87c5b3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c73ea5b600ca3dd2c5ab8a38ebc235648e9ef174a4bd61af58b06305ad2a31a8","receipt.jsonSha256":"c3fa3366fcd60e7d3697b8b50488e7aa293a1780da661adfebe53a38924e7bb6","normalization.jsonSha256":"a3eac27355f76ec91c57dec40f5bc83844e10dcb3ef9ea9667d8c49ca4aea927","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"753c9efbc446f364b24354eaf89ad398df8d7622ec2d9beb94e8fac5cc74747c"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4ee95e846296ea195394a8790631bbeb87440c55f318427d79e7a0c95afb5a46","reply.jsonSha256":"99147723f2a26f26da1f1d8fb3a095d75987433e96a4b4ff59a39bbfe1752576","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b0e7e36ba30c1528108f6af82c9173f0bdc6cdcce9a399a95eba27570425604d","receipt.jsonSha256":"8542dba9fdf71bd0b7f20e3f1879e5efd683a0d0e58c15a55a29e979cd417018","normalization.jsonSha256":"a0873ca4fb92cc0f560c241bfd27ea6339f3ec5f04148a703800fe89f614a59d"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405"},{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"2307.07547","sourceId":"ev:3f22cac1cce9db34134b96a4a6ae09c7","sourceSha256":"3e97a62f7f9dcfcaa1e6374dee2d0152526ea368f4b3c836a799eddbe306ec31","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e206f2afa29c4e11f785/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0f5e665f33ddf04598d2b684031d436510aa19aa0ed96a99c7a6822accf8bb20","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2351,"textSha256":"e9b9b8dc46fc3702c21e3e48b2fa174aba9035143129ca9c60790ce32bbba607","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2307.07547","sourceId":"ev:9e3da4433c5efd8dad1bd916d562d875","sourceSha256":"3e97a62f7f9dcfcaa1e6374dee2d0152526ea368f4b3c836a799eddbe306ec31","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e206f2afa29c4e11f785/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0f5e665f33ddf04598d2b684031d436510aa19aa0ed96a99c7a6822accf8bb20","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1379,"textSha256":"d21cb57b1b04448edd42ff3eee839dd00c220513d70ae088918d8d5ffda79750","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405"},{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"2307.07547","sourceId":"ev:3f22cac1cce9db34134b96a4a6ae09c7","sourceSha256":"3e97a62f7f9dcfcaa1e6374dee2d0152526ea368f4b3c836a799eddbe306ec31","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e206f2afa29c4e11f785/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0f5e665f33ddf04598d2b684031d436510aa19aa0ed96a99c7a6822accf8bb20","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2351,"textSha256":"e9b9b8dc46fc3702c21e3e48b2fa174aba9035143129ca9c60790ce32bbba607","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2307.07547","sourceId":"ev:9e3da4433c5efd8dad1bd916d562d875","sourceSha256":"3e97a62f7f9dcfcaa1e6374dee2d0152526ea368f4b3c836a799eddbe306ec31","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e206f2afa29c4e11f785/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0f5e665f33ddf04598d2b684031d436510aa19aa0ed96a99c7a6822accf8bb20","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1379,"textSha256":"d21cb57b1b04448edd42ff3eee839dd00c220513d70ae088918d8d5ffda79750","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d20","originalRef":"l20","status":"route","source":"s10","target":"s24","type":"application_of","title":"Use symmetry definitions and gauging structures to analyze breaking and phases","rationale":"The breaking, flow and phase questions apply the symmetry structures and operator or gauging constructions organized by s24. This reverses the original application arrow.","qualification":"The cited lecture treatment supports the stated higher-form properties without extending its detailed treatment to higher-group properties. Other structures retain their separately described support. Explicit breaking, spontaneous breaking and gauging remain distinct, and gauging retains anomaly and background-field conditions. Anomaly constraints are necessary conditions where stated, not complete infrared classifications. No universal local-current definition, common symmetry mechanism or quantitative parity-wall decay conclusion follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l20","s10","s24"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d20","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The breaking and phase questions apply symmetry structures organized by s24, supporting application_of from s10 to s24. The qualification preserves the challenge statement's higher-form lecture limit, retains separate support for other structures and avoids treating anomaly constraints as complete infrared classifications.","refs":["l20","s10","s24"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l20","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l21":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l21","source":"q025-candidate-question:374623f65e03eab654c343ac","target":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","type":"method_for","title":"Organize symmetry operators and gauging with bulk encodings","rationale":"SymTFT and the other specified encodings supply methods for organizing symmetry data. The original reasoning therefore identifies s9 as the method supplier to the intrinsic symmetry question in s24.","qualification":"The method contribution is limited to the symmetry data and constructions actually encoded. Auxiliary symmetry-theory bulk, tensor-network bulk and physical holographic bulk remain distinct. Topological and non-topological theories, finite and continuous symmetry data, and flat-connection and non-flat-background constructions retain their separate conditions. A bulk encoding establishes neither a full gravity dual nor equivalence among all realizations. Detailed newer constructions remain description-supported.","evidenceIds":["unit:06fc2e875179b953fd421e410fe6c2bd2645320182c64be3e44125cc7f1d823d","unit:07773a160ebbf445d8342aa4f665542dca7e17366d5f462f793f5dad99484926","unit:077ad8c62c2c8ff1e8f5d7993ded4fd76a7e124e12d2e289d12d34c98a1e2bec","unit:08ed0a4adf8ed31c8bbdd3a38c4b386e315a0d9c800849c73e1d828eb1d73ab5","unit:0cdde3e82466a95627c6bf4d48c086b754e80976d7fad6b1965faea60f60d049","unit:10cc78b1357b454aa6215b512f6a731305176ebdc685f1d284782b01d8d073ba","unit:174cc2dad1bd275e729c81c7024a32d9ffe9447a7b8e56417a64584b547f4aef","unit:2add721a2c187da46197d34fc1c6cc58c185b6259dbc13fc878c099bd450eb7f","unit:387a60b627d33cef1247a88a91062c09270f8bba701df2b3c35d9fe17916ce50","unit:479fd01bba5530d46bc8cf136a9b39a497a60d35fe8833f525a9e7eae7600cc6","unit:52bd26ac9bc1fa7da3f0ef55035af631425d0ec0717bb41c996b09f5dacb33d5","unit:5b72ca6c1dce9f6abb744b7b7b5c7efe167d80c04a9158516d933e0201293e56","unit:5ec1ee2dd9812900af3be14dcece90714ac3fe7d2828fa2a6b4f7e021d2ae6a3","unit:63c2129a8cf5d9679d3fedd47f040014eba4b02d2f99709d8f0e9b1bba7a2013","unit:68e2ad317ad34bbf58f59ec555abef57472526a57d9a4a705c40a54ae0066775","unit:760a1cb3290ddf8c3446bdd55f3ae43b763ef10c6a945004f3cde4024cf02c41","unit:760a51193899fb044a5118a91ee6a618502b6c201f0ae95174dcd14ebe2d111b","unit:8c084637064525624a7bcc1f8fbeb124801e77cd1eda3b01fab9a762b7cf10f0","unit:8d012cdc0ce6c73709992943d14bdc6c2fbfc96510b607ce7e92fa49bb427a13","unit:a5071ae7a132b9466a1a55fa21928926ca07a4230a811e6d8d7eca35b7855634","unit:b014332825ca4cdc7d1ef0e3234b0d8276a4f3ad18a1021d32ee5214d3c32a99","unit:b3243010621ba839c60d57fc9a6563615a68974ba45c407927be707fc3fada88","unit:bc8b421870b960cab9d77620e76d73b4f3a6483c2f6d4f1bd40ef2e9ea4afe77","unit:bcb930350cfb30cb461ddebd3d55950894281611fce99b74467d22f1b7048f22","unit:bdb71e32c6b1082c82d09440de88340c492059283eea8e4344786cb83d1269e7","unit:c382e8e37d72e628162b1f8f7e454d7a3d146112a9aa9fd457e0614563b70b61","unit:c428ec107a056565b6700a108e70ec37138fa58eb42ce207ad623e9527bf78fd","unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","unit:cb54cb61db15a47f6e9590e277a050115d4760e0e2e68b12781704e2750cec81","unit:d18705566d9a39b40973aa3e4759e603efe165bc76e69e54aa19c1a5f64974de","unit:e1942fe152e7797bf0bfd4accf8ec67a941c0baf6d9ad1f3cff2b52469d6e02f","unit:e5daf8a51912bae59df4bffba2dbfb120086d0a9bb64dcfc31694b62fd2d88ac","unit:e87910165273d83274c8aa1f7aedf4fb22a67c2fcfe061c13a3928f0c72c7d59","unit:ef300e71c2946be15c47b67a1cab1561fc82af70cc8966a6c53c804f36d18fc7","unit:fef8d2101e3ebd25bc1cab514f17e7ee29f8495d30b9346b98f6d6833787d8b5"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:374623f65e03eab654c343ac","scopeContentSha256":"3d600e621ec9ee52b1ac3e7eb8dd432cae0414e9437f63620beaef5e60efd044","localRef":"s9"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","scopeContentSha256":"9df5eeb57c828ca805a8889c867a256e76e38e13192ef8ce26ce44c6bf51d190","localRef":"s24"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l21","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-challenge:link:34","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l21","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-challenge:link:34","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:374623f65e03eab654c343ac","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l21","source":"s24","target":"s9","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["SymTFT and other bulk encodings organize symmetry data while retaining distinctions between auxiliary and physical bulk theories."],"challengeStatement":"SymTFT and other encodings organize symmetry data while preserving distinctions between auxiliary, tensor-network and physical holographic bulk descriptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"588262299b674d4befbe7fe032922d589e6d5f16e771509b80c79af5a0599439","reply.jsonSha256":"6f4e644d6491aa85115bddcb0f2e17d01d323d64932fa442c7d1b9922a87c5b3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c73ea5b600ca3dd2c5ab8a38ebc235648e9ef174a4bd61af58b06305ad2a31a8","receipt.jsonSha256":"c3fa3366fcd60e7d3697b8b50488e7aa293a1780da661adfebe53a38924e7bb6","normalization.jsonSha256":"a3eac27355f76ec91c57dec40f5bc83844e10dcb3ef9ea9667d8c49ca4aea927","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"753c9efbc446f364b24354eaf89ad398df8d7622ec2d9beb94e8fac5cc74747c"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4ee95e846296ea195394a8790631bbeb87440c55f318427d79e7a0c95afb5a46","reply.jsonSha256":"99147723f2a26f26da1f1d8fb3a095d75987433e96a4b4ff59a39bbfe1752576","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b0e7e36ba30c1528108f6af82c9173f0bdc6cdcce9a399a95eba27570425604d","receipt.jsonSha256":"8542dba9fdf71bd0b7f20e3f1879e5efd683a0d0e58c15a55a29e979cd417018","normalization.jsonSha256":"a0873ca4fb92cc0f560c241bfd27ea6339f3ec5f04148a703800fe89f614a59d"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405"},{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:374623f65e03eab654c343ac"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"2307.07547","sourceId":"ev:3f22cac1cce9db34134b96a4a6ae09c7","sourceSha256":"3e97a62f7f9dcfcaa1e6374dee2d0152526ea368f4b3c836a799eddbe306ec31","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e206f2afa29c4e11f785/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0f5e665f33ddf04598d2b684031d436510aa19aa0ed96a99c7a6822accf8bb20","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2351,"textSha256":"e9b9b8dc46fc3702c21e3e48b2fa174aba9035143129ca9c60790ce32bbba607","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2307.07547","sourceId":"ev:9e3da4433c5efd8dad1bd916d562d875","sourceSha256":"3e97a62f7f9dcfcaa1e6374dee2d0152526ea368f4b3c836a799eddbe306ec31","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e206f2afa29c4e11f785/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0f5e665f33ddf04598d2b684031d436510aa19aa0ed96a99c7a6822accf8bb20","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1379,"textSha256":"d21cb57b1b04448edd42ff3eee839dd00c220513d70ae088918d8d5ffda79750","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:866210e6afd3379279bf6405"},{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:374623f65e03eab654c343ac"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"2307.07547","sourceId":"ev:3f22cac1cce9db34134b96a4a6ae09c7","sourceSha256":"3e97a62f7f9dcfcaa1e6374dee2d0152526ea368f4b3c836a799eddbe306ec31","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e206f2afa29c4e11f785/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0f5e665f33ddf04598d2b684031d436510aa19aa0ed96a99c7a6822accf8bb20","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2351,"textSha256":"e9b9b8dc46fc3702c21e3e48b2fa174aba9035143129ca9c60790ce32bbba607","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2307.07547","sourceId":"ev:9e3da4433c5efd8dad1bd916d562d875","sourceSha256":"3e97a62f7f9dcfcaa1e6374dee2d0152526ea368f4b3c836a799eddbe306ec31","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e206f2afa29c4e11f785/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0f5e665f33ddf04598d2b684031d436510aa19aa0ed96a99c7a6822accf8bb20","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1379,"textSha256":"d21cb57b1b04448edd42ff3eee839dd00c220513d70ae088918d8d5ffda79750","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d21","originalRef":"l21","status":"route","source":"s9","target":"s24","type":"method_for","title":"Organize symmetry operators and gauging with bulk encodings","rationale":"SymTFT and the other specified encodings supply methods for organizing symmetry data. The original reasoning therefore identifies s9 as the method supplier to the intrinsic symmetry question in s24.","qualification":"The method contribution is limited to the symmetry data and constructions actually encoded. Auxiliary symmetry-theory bulk, tensor-network bulk and physical holographic bulk remain distinct. Topological and non-topological theories, finite and continuous symmetry data, and flat-connection and non-flat-background constructions retain their separate conditions. A bulk encoding establishes neither a full gravity dual nor equivalence among all realizations. Detailed newer constructions remain description-supported.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l21","s9","s24"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d21","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original reasoning identifies SymTFT and other bulk encodings as methods for organizing symmetry data, making s9 the supplier to s24. The qualification preserves auxiliary, tensor-network and physical holographic meanings, along with topological, background and spectrum distinctions, without claiming equivalence or a complete gravity dual.","refs":["l21","s9","s24"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l21","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l22":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l22","source":"q025-candidate-question:521ef5887d6d5f84360cb4d3","target":"q025-candidate-question:c9c79f300c7021b77f33a2fb","type":"method_for","title":"Use global moduli and duality data in gauge-theory analysis","rationale":"Global moduli and duality data can organize specified gauge dynamics and global structure. The supplying question is s14, so the original method arrow is reversed.","qualification":"The connection is restricted to matching theory, dimension, supersymmetry and global-data settings. Discrete-completion and global-geometry questions retain independent scope. Bosonic and fermionic duality actions can require different group data, and identical massless supergravity does not determine the full quantum theory. The Bagger–Witten ultraviolet criterion remains conjectural. No common spectrum, exactness claim or equivalence among bundles, lattices, theta angles, monodromies and other discrete mechanisms is inferred.","evidenceIds":["unit:05c9a06cb25534392c8283774216622f369be158ddb950fd1df697a3ad318e04","unit:085308ebebb87433ff3fd19aa08c92b31c51959be8711880b288e65f04b5ed9c","unit:08c1f67409201f1345869f4980be953dae9e1e7031f6c6e36c9300f55e53b47c","unit:0d955c352aa842bdbc61fe1271e2cefac4341a489fe409a8b25b6ea189e67e0b","unit:1205fd86ce3193f1937d91e3d557e575a09a3a7ab659bc07c079b0adaabbaaaa","unit:1c28313fb67db906529a8421a3e1037352f579006451a46008f1e4a92c5bca76","unit:2f4069f7ad751d5ad5ff20ffe45a5fa3f7232ef1ca13dae2e077c2f12a5d852f","unit:2f508379ee8c32d16f38585c635e74df15f57e6581697ac6c40046d678ac484c","unit:47ad085d52785da87279f006ada4645906960d46c308c590478b557800895c4c","unit:5490ff781afda182b01f12eb528807a50a175cc7464a8f812bc125bf7df05fa5","unit:7cb406a4c18b28afbd5e5f0b764ecba4a5491c1a431ecc4e380f90f67cde247e","unit:7f7a0fc11945af5249764dfde170fe18ecc8e55665168648e4c7d30477b0166c","unit:8a0afbaf196b1d8891658aa3bb48c83dea7acad3eaeac4fff61565f4babf631c","unit:9573eb717f9ba082735ffefdbacb08031813f955d3a52e90f6461caa1d2ae975","unit:9b493c8359a01d48211fe64fc6e305a69c0e836676cae425498e42c26acef8ae","unit:9ce87f05ad1ce9a6a7239471d83934c66afc2c00514bbbee91ef21a43c2cc878","unit:a520c8eab878c4594dee990c4dc0124d1b011bb9fc118b1f6fdb33c964a264a4","unit:b0284f62bd7a1c4fc137edc30d1b9c26cbca16e8c405787a5c130dd55ffc1e7f","unit:b41fa3a9a27292a24a7b0e542c779b0f5fcf0d6dc86ef3b23485cdb494bcca1e","unit:b79eaa8baa500246ae6cde07b7c458aa7af8cbf9445e822b51567311eb28709f","unit:e26f4458c643532712e6b9cdd192edd6658dfbcbff62fa91fbd84ef36d0a6519","unit:ee2d735429e7c59f128ac7cdb114c552bc0757866a006485135fef6998104480","unit:f27d5df1a437ed312f4c867dfc1b3079ba63b7aa4d37fe9b690f30d95591086e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:521ef5887d6d5f84360cb4d3","scopeContentSha256":"41cd83a33566263676936dc9304dc7e11ac1f92e9d30ea47a99695ac3287215b","localRef":"s14"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c9c79f300c7021b77f33a2fb","scopeContentSha256":"bd0f4da45dc31447b5a1dfc50aeab9a1898c263694d2e607d1e1bcd8cb84abc8","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l22","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-challenge:link:47","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l22","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-challenge:link:47","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c9c79f300c7021b77f33a2fb","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:521ef5887d6d5f84360cb4d3","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l22","source":"s30","target":"s14","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Global moduli and duality data can organize specified gauge dynamics, while the broader discrete-completion questions retain their own scope."],"challengeStatement":"Global moduli and duality data can organize specified gauge dynamics, while discrete-completion and global-geometry targets retain independent scope.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"588262299b674d4befbe7fe032922d589e6d5f16e771509b80c79af5a0599439","reply.jsonSha256":"6f4e644d6491aa85115bddcb0f2e17d01d323d64932fa442c7d1b9922a87c5b3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c73ea5b600ca3dd2c5ab8a38ebc235648e9ef174a4bd61af58b06305ad2a31a8","receipt.jsonSha256":"c3fa3366fcd60e7d3697b8b50488e7aa293a1780da661adfebe53a38924e7bb6","normalization.jsonSha256":"a3eac27355f76ec91c57dec40f5bc83844e10dcb3ef9ea9667d8c49ca4aea927","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"753c9efbc446f364b24354eaf89ad398df8d7622ec2d9beb94e8fac5cc74747c"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-17324a9d1c6d231abdd8-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4ee95e846296ea195394a8790631bbeb87440c55f318427d79e7a0c95afb5a46","reply.jsonSha256":"99147723f2a26f26da1f1d8fb3a095d75987433e96a4b4ff59a39bbfe1752576","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b0e7e36ba30c1528108f6af82c9173f0bdc6cdcce9a399a95eba27570425604d","receipt.jsonSha256":"8542dba9fdf71bd0b7f20e3f1879e5efd683a0d0e58c15a55a29e979cd417018","normalization.jsonSha256":"a0873ca4fb92cc0f560c241bfd27ea6339f3ec5f04148a703800fe89f614a59d"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c9c79f300c7021b77f33a2fb"},{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:521ef5887d6d5f84360cb4d3"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c9c79f300c7021b77f33a2fb"},{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:521ef5887d6d5f84360cb4d3"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d22","originalRef":"l22","status":"route","source":"s14","target":"s30","type":"method_for","title":"Use global moduli and duality data in gauge-theory analysis","rationale":"Global moduli and duality data can organize specified gauge dynamics and global structure. The supplying question is s14, so the original method arrow is reversed.","qualification":"The connection is restricted to matching theory, dimension, supersymmetry and global-data settings. Discrete-completion and global-geometry questions retain independent scope. Bosonic and fermionic duality actions can require different group data, and identical massless supergravity does not determine the full quantum theory. The Bagger–Witten ultraviolet criterion remains conjectural. No common spectrum, exactness claim or equivalence among bundles, lattices, theta angles, monodromies and other discrete mechanisms is inferred.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l22","s14","s30"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d22","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Global moduli and duality data supply the organizing method for specified gauge dynamics, supporting reversal from s14 to s30. The qualification preserves matching theory settings, independent discrete-completion and global-geometry targets, distinct duality group data and the conjectural Bagger–Witten criterion.","refs":["l22","s14","s30"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l22","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l23":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l23","source":"q025-candidate-question:c9c79f300c7021b77f33a2fb","target":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a","type":"application_of","title":"Use brane and geometric constructions for gauge-theory questions","rationale":"In the explicitly engineered sector, the spectrum, vacuum, observable and global-structure questions concern field theories realized through the constructions in s4. The applied gauge-theory question points toward those constructions.","qualification":"Only the brane- or geometrically engineered component of s30 is covered. Compactification, near-horizon and decoupling limits remain construction-specific, while spectra, vacua, observables and global structure remain separate targets. Engineering a theory does not compute every observable or establish a common ultraviolet completion. Protection, exactness and BPS completeness retain their individual assumptions; an enhancement classification is not a brane-existence proof, and gauge-theory, BPS and magnetic quivers are not identified.","evidenceIds":["unit:8a0afbaf196b1d8891658aa3bb48c83dea7acad3eaeac4fff61565f4babf631c","unit:9573eb717f9ba082735ffefdbacb08031813f955d3a52e90f6461caa1d2ae975","unit:9b493c8359a01d48211fe64fc6e305a69c0e836676cae425498e42c26acef8ae","unit:af8681ba8a03f6eaf7b13526aeab94bb1abce3826a4f311c56125a1a1513b4b8","unit:e26f4458c643532712e6b9cdd192edd6658dfbcbff62fa91fbd84ef36d0a6519"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c9c79f300c7021b77f33a2fb","scopeContentSha256":"bd0f4da45dc31447b5a1dfc50aeab9a1898c263694d2e607d1e1bcd8cb84abc8","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a","scopeContentSha256":"911fdbdaf40c9c4bcf2d47efc2bf3275c74bfb4435995a64564bbef11c469e2f","localRef":"s4"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l23","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge:link:59","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l23","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge:link:59","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:c9c79f300c7021b77f33a2fb","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l23","source":"s4","target":"s30","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Engineered field theories raise separate spectrum, vacuum, observable and global-structure questions."],"challengeStatement":"Engineered theories raise separate questions about spectra, vacua, observables and global structure.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"243e04cb28fb6b33bfa96e5eda4d54ca7f1af343e60a821fc67fc105dacfc45b","reply.jsonSha256":"30542dfa624ec89da090e90cf75243da344b32667b277b842ff6cfc654e3aae9","reply.raw.txtSha256":"90b5218bf434a1bfd0c3c1a4d90b8a95a14083ffa4069b7dfe20a16415ab1c11","receipt.jsonSha256":"0fccda43a0971b62d8848ab0ad4ebeae6037b46c45d16ff74a926a773d5f9130","normalization.jsonSha256":"0fc716054d79dd485b69df4e844a187e894e107e53f8694fade7d1b275ed2f6b","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"36b507a45e5ca7df9a0b02fd3fecda404fd0015d22c1a0481b6543582d9ce085"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d02c7ad219c09349e8dcd8124489895af1160579f70282385fc4ab9d9d91ceb0","reply.jsonSha256":"58b5a1301ca2cc8c0e3afef0cbb3dbe2895f9ea425f190878005d66c38458866","reply.raw.txtSha256":"615df2ea57a4fa7bd3c370739d3932d381c2a4e45e87b6acc0096f19c8c21e93","receipt.jsonSha256":"d564d588a101901971c349d0e9e8529d8606a15b8a4a1cf0c61ef4d5b70e8351","normalization.jsonSha256":"af448248cdc4776f7d865f22db7dd34f9c5f22d82789725f0b6c4d6b2bb95deb"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_10","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a"},{"ref":"x1_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c9c79f300c7021b77f33a2fb"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_10","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a"},{"ref":"x1_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c9c79f300c7021b77f33a2fb"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d23","originalRef":"l23","status":"route","source":"s30","target":"s4","type":"application_of","title":"Use brane and geometric constructions for gauge-theory questions","rationale":"In the explicitly engineered sector, the spectrum, vacuum, observable and global-structure questions concern field theories realized through the constructions in s4. The applied gauge-theory question points toward those constructions.","qualification":"Only the brane- or geometrically engineered component of s30 is covered. Compactification, near-horizon and decoupling limits remain construction-specific, while spectra, vacua, observables and global structure remain separate targets. Engineering a theory does not compute every observable or establish a common ultraviolet completion. Protection, exactness and BPS completeness retain their individual assumptions; an enhancement classification is not a brane-existence proof, and gauge-theory, BPS and magnetic quivers are not identified.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l23","s30","s4"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d23","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"For the explicitly engineered sector, s30 asks applied gauge-theory questions about systems realized through the constructions in s4, supporting the reversed application_of direction. The qualification preserves separate spectra, vacua, observables and global structure and does not infer their computation, universal exactness or brane existence from engineering alone.","refs":["l23","s30","s4"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l23","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l24":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l24","source":"q025-candidate-question:3035b20700f5f847ecc68840","target":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a","type":"application_of","title":"Use brane constructions to investigate holographic dynamics and states","rationale":"The holographic-dynamics and microscopic-state questions use brane constructions and geometries as their underlying descriptions. The application arrow therefore runs from s8 to s4.","qualification":"Decoupling, observable tests and state-counting evidence remain additional requirements. A candidate geometry, protected calculation, linearized hair mode or explicit black-brane solution supplies bounded evidence rather than a complete microscopic account. A decoupled field-theory limit differs from a full stringy ultraviolet theory, and a consistent truncation supports its retained sector rather than every observable. Candidate dualities and microstate interpretations retain their proposed status, with no universal entropy count or proof of nonperturbative existence inferred.","evidenceIds":["unit:0b824b458052a65cbdea70261000fbe6aabb8a1cfd76d1521ce462875b97b614","unit:0c79d2f6a9a912178ebaf5402929bc1b5568a2b840ac1f6de96966d015330305","unit:0d6cbd07d24a2058da3672b3af0d12b2d7fab483b48379c7372dfef416b2e311","unit:0db021ee058874e71b8c600cb8cb357a2ac99715cfe785e0032f77bb335091c9","unit:241b16bf2a0221538145a2bc98023aff4fe294f1591cd4574724998fd0c6e4ae","unit:44536154355430880b746cdc50c5a868583ec78d944c611d4679626a6c808235","unit:5ad20bdbfca22f328f80dac96ebc3d114753c0cddaa30c14b6c980d722964554","unit:5dffb3078285b9d2cf69d6df42980a10fe8c4c6e54c4d8f8300e7d1751aeb62f","unit:61ce0ba2f2db04d28e2a5f4fd1b5ef8afa0aeaa2637b71d194727489a3b08c97","unit:7a957888a627dddbb3edf1a8ad606da3cfdb836e85d28ebe0f40fa4c8cc5199d","unit:7c88f770b3b43acc85bbad60c2b8a2fe38505e9948ab18370cb4254738f9e837","unit:af8681ba8a03f6eaf7b13526aeab94bb1abce3826a4f311c56125a1a1513b4b8","unit:e26f4458c643532712e6b9cdd192edd6658dfbcbff62fa91fbd84ef36d0a6519","unit:e6873b11d392f23fefb740879000b16a2e27f3c8a7e51e56ba8111835570587d","unit:f8ecd0d418ba86e6bfb52038f518d9bd44ac6f0a6ef12035fccb9b054c994e36"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3035b20700f5f847ecc68840","scopeContentSha256":"6cde9e361e15464fb882cf97988721d51852efb48038c924e4118bd59c06ba8b","localRef":"s8"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a","scopeContentSha256":"911fdbdaf40c9c4bcf2d47efc2bf3275c74bfb4435995a64564bbef11c469e2f","localRef":"s4"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l24","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge:link:58","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l24","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge:link:58","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:3035b20700f5f847ecc68840","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l24","source":"s4","target":"s8","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Holographic dynamics and microscopic-state proposals require additional decoupling, observable and state-counting evidence."],"challengeStatement":"Holographic dynamics and microscopic-state interpretations require their own decoupling and observable evidence.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"243e04cb28fb6b33bfa96e5eda4d54ca7f1af343e60a821fc67fc105dacfc45b","reply.jsonSha256":"30542dfa624ec89da090e90cf75243da344b32667b277b842ff6cfc654e3aae9","reply.raw.txtSha256":"90b5218bf434a1bfd0c3c1a4d90b8a95a14083ffa4069b7dfe20a16415ab1c11","receipt.jsonSha256":"0fccda43a0971b62d8848ab0ad4ebeae6037b46c45d16ff74a926a773d5f9130","normalization.jsonSha256":"0fc716054d79dd485b69df4e844a187e894e107e53f8694fade7d1b275ed2f6b","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"36b507a45e5ca7df9a0b02fd3fecda404fd0015d22c1a0481b6543582d9ce085"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d02c7ad219c09349e8dcd8124489895af1160579f70282385fc4ab9d9d91ceb0","reply.jsonSha256":"58b5a1301ca2cc8c0e3afef0cbb3dbe2895f9ea425f190878005d66c38458866","reply.raw.txtSha256":"615df2ea57a4fa7bd3c370739d3932d381c2a4e45e87b6acc0096f19c8c21e93","receipt.jsonSha256":"d564d588a101901971c349d0e9e8529d8606a15b8a4a1cf0c61ef4d5b70e8351","normalization.jsonSha256":"af448248cdc4776f7d865f22db7dd34f9c5f22d82789725f0b6c4d6b2bb95deb"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_10","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a"},{"ref":"x3_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3035b20700f5f847ecc68840"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_10","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a"},{"ref":"x3_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3035b20700f5f847ecc68840"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d24","originalRef":"l24","status":"route","source":"s8","target":"s4","type":"application_of","title":"Use brane constructions to investigate holographic dynamics and states","rationale":"The holographic-dynamics and microscopic-state questions use brane constructions and geometries as their underlying descriptions. The application arrow therefore runs from s8 to s4.","qualification":"Decoupling, observable tests and state-counting evidence remain additional requirements. A candidate geometry, protected calculation, linearized hair mode or explicit black-brane solution supplies bounded evidence rather than a complete microscopic account. A decoupled field-theory limit differs from a full stringy ultraviolet theory, and a consistent truncation supports its retained sector rather than every observable. Candidate dualities and microstate interpretations retain their proposed status, with no universal entropy count or proof of nonperturbative existence inferred.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l24","s8","s4"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d24","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The brane-based holographic and microscopic-state questions in s8 apply constructions organized by s4. The reversal is supported, and the qualification preserves the additional decoupling, observable and state-counting evidence required by the two statements without converting candidate geometries or protected calculations into complete microphysics.","refs":["l24","s8","s4"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l24","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l25":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l25","source":"q025-candidate-question:0b3a22fb2ef00f6791bd7a00","target":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a","type":"method_for","title":"Build brane descriptions using worldsheet and worldvolume formulations","rationale":"Worldsheet and worldvolume formulations supply action, geometric and quantization methods to the relevant brane-construction questions. The method arrow requires reversal.","qualification":"Degrees of freedom, dimensions, symmetries and quantization conditions remain specific to each formulation. Classical constructions and quantum procedures are distinguished, as are fixed-oscillator, light-cone and Hamiltonian BRST approaches and explicitly exactly tensionless settings. Requested symmetry preservation remains a test. The reported D=2 result belongs to the specified conformal-string formulation, and positive reflection to the specified topological functorial theory. Topological terms alone establish no full string dynamics or complete microscopic formulation.","evidenceIds":["unit:095845baefd9d38740382e9b1573f154ece8609057a4356ee7d9474daf39776b","unit:0f1cd0d9efd0849161ed0d32a12270514e23687815f257d2996ece8ee78a11fa","unit:150fa07ce09cfda2dc584921da7d261fbd2142ffa7891c35a0a3e4bd7771f829","unit:1fb343410ddd80424a3a4434e5ae6de0db16771ec926666d54088611a8fa2688","unit:20eb9261a824ab6de42a0fdd2d3dd5bc4e9be0b46eacb6992d0e94c98958fdca","unit:26e2ddf71932a99ac1622946389b66ec4f87059840d3be2fd7ef8dddef41c05e","unit:2fb7a3e1297ea4a814c986e277cb445f9c77b1752953c3b16ac680c8e8cc5a49","unit:34f18a3da86ec6644633bde615fb39798f494acf87f472e4cb7a7674b0e8d370","unit:42f47e1974630bdf19b2e21cf8e7d21675a7c71d9b52241dbf1ac435d76fa9ba","unit:45573ef22b01f02367eb75fddd335d970e0c4231dcc923b14bd86f4d4a99649b","unit:45aca9c0affa76f80a70de383f16df0dc9d074c16b018855364fb17488761d73","unit:4732c5df31471be11e2bafe278968796ea1cc138f7f0a29219ef4a908355f63d","unit:4b6112a2310c8f83887f71c8281107100281c217a440f52c6f146171ae98a415","unit:5ffd5a032d00d3ccb189780038b1a4a5e91d85500c74d1845a2722e658995afe","unit:6954917944305438f6219480665af41e506e78fb87635b6c6a695cdf6e49638a","unit:6d23f05e51c3d3d2e0463a26e9bc214ef9c48892a7af2bf94b10f3f970563245","unit:6e754984e9634630be1dc709c6b9727726a05f89290f44e58433fb07d4fe10c9","unit:a721fa4f6c9ecb5fd56259d8c57f59ef2cf8eb160550d5467215814bb10e0ce7","unit:abf6e35d706cf16304affc8fd04087b58de5f779bd31372ac582ff30a52e10c9","unit:af68bccf1cf760ffd3dfed3a52a381c09e693de535e1f9b047772ed1cf9bc698","unit:af8681ba8a03f6eaf7b13526aeab94bb1abce3826a4f311c56125a1a1513b4b8","unit:c8a05726d16ef134628ab4016cc55cbc668d78c8088cc61c854a93d57a87848f","unit:c91f55462d2c0021110e71a1d5c32ad5b933fe7a671eac7e51edc6af8805ac9f","unit:caf09c31de4c1f59f1bb9b95a124b65def3af492434891dd9f9b7f2efe0c3bbe","unit:d543638eccb35bf53b9cea8515f26c13936dc8c54edbccfa8e3bc11bb7616d43","unit:d6309cc975aa9b9ffd8752c0926420d990506c276fccb161644e446c61fec0c1","unit:e26f4458c643532712e6b9cdd192edd6658dfbcbff62fa91fbd84ef36d0a6519","unit:ed1b555c5f866e8b8ba18fd59131e81a218b34a6d41b3d7b9f7ac3299b6c1563","unit:ee2f49cd0be8d32bf755e1c8d65ab5ce4096dfb3bfac06bb0d6421bcaad0631a","unit:f8897ff82f64c7d93216b2275271fd8c1ff8f0f9efb3af8c24383339259039a8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b3a22fb2ef00f6791bd7a00","scopeContentSha256":"32fcd30a1dd252dcd988aefebaddc3469d28b2eae069f74e4b846561a692c1db","localRef":"s1"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a","scopeContentSha256":"911fdbdaf40c9c4bcf2d47efc2bf3275c74bfb4435995a64564bbef11c469e2f","localRef":"s4"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l25","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge:link:60","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l25","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge:link:60","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:0b3a22fb2ef00f6791bd7a00","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l25","source":"s4","target":"s1","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Worldsheet and worldvolume formulations provide methods whose degrees of freedom and quantization conditions remain source-specific."],"challengeStatement":"Worldsheet and worldvolume formulations supply methods with source-specific degrees of freedom and quantization procedures.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"243e04cb28fb6b33bfa96e5eda4d54ca7f1af343e60a821fc67fc105dacfc45b","reply.jsonSha256":"30542dfa624ec89da090e90cf75243da344b32667b277b842ff6cfc654e3aae9","reply.raw.txtSha256":"90b5218bf434a1bfd0c3c1a4d90b8a95a14083ffa4069b7dfe20a16415ab1c11","receipt.jsonSha256":"0fccda43a0971b62d8848ab0ad4ebeae6037b46c45d16ff74a926a773d5f9130","normalization.jsonSha256":"0fc716054d79dd485b69df4e844a187e894e107e53f8694fade7d1b275ed2f6b","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"36b507a45e5ca7df9a0b02fd3fecda404fd0015d22c1a0481b6543582d9ce085"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d02c7ad219c09349e8dcd8124489895af1160579f70282385fc4ab9d9d91ceb0","reply.jsonSha256":"58b5a1301ca2cc8c0e3afef0cbb3dbe2895f9ea425f190878005d66c38458866","reply.raw.txtSha256":"615df2ea57a4fa7bd3c370739d3932d381c2a4e45e87b6acc0096f19c8c21e93","receipt.jsonSha256":"d564d588a101901971c349d0e9e8529d8606a15b8a4a1cf0c61ef4d5b70e8351","normalization.jsonSha256":"af448248cdc4776f7d865f22db7dd34f9c5f22d82789725f0b6c4d6b2bb95deb"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_10","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a"},{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b3a22fb2ef00f6791bd7a00"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_10","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1ca579a906621f6bd2f2643a"},{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0b3a22fb2ef00f6791bd7a00"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d25","originalRef":"l25","status":"route","source":"s1","target":"s4","type":"method_for","title":"Build brane descriptions using worldsheet and worldvolume formulations","rationale":"Worldsheet and worldvolume formulations supply action, geometric and quantization methods to the relevant brane-construction questions. The method arrow requires reversal.","qualification":"Degrees of freedom, dimensions, symmetries and quantization conditions remain specific to each formulation. Classical constructions and quantum procedures are distinguished, as are fixed-oscillator, light-cone and Hamiltonian BRST approaches and explicitly exactly tensionless settings. Requested symmetry preservation remains a test. The reported D=2 result belongs to the specified conformal-string formulation, and positive reflection to the specified topological functorial theory. Topological terms alone establish no full string dynamics or complete microscopic formulation.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l25","s1","s4"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d25","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Worldsheet and worldvolume formulations supply the stated action, geometric and quantization methods, making s1 the supplier to s4. The qualification preserves formulation-specific degrees of freedom, symmetry tests, quantization procedures and tension limits and does not infer full string dynamics from topological terms.","refs":["l25","s1","s4"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l25","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l26":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l26","source":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30","target":"q025-candidate-question:c5267f5181cc7692f3008718","type":"related_question","title":"Follow vacuum endpoints into subsequent cosmological geometry","rationale":"Transition endpoints connect rate calculations to separate questions about geometry, collapse and patch evolution. The supplied reasoning does not show that subsequent geometry applies a transition-rate method or follows from a computed rate, so related_question preserves the established connection.","qualification":"Endpoint potentials, initial data, walls, boundary conditions and dynamical approximations remain source-specific. Transition exponents, prefactors, spacetime rates and observer encounter rates are distinct from post-transition evolution. The broader contracting, anisotropic and runaway branches of s29 are not all transition applications; a negative rolling potential is not automatically an AdS vacuum. Conditional singularity modifications remain conditional. The inherited Hawking–Moss sign conflict and incomplete continuity argument remain unresolved.","evidenceIds":["unit:027935fda9c644cbf55d275f86943590263d955ac3280a9bf3b52193ca1828d6","unit:0cfddf9c1309e3108788fa7d48f292bd12d774456fd6aabf98a2ce1df6600cb1","unit:0f0cda04b7d3de40560bc0f31f28cf74c0e98b7e0dfda2b31d697710b9630b81","unit:10f926b10337cdd8b0f696a1d00965f054c95dfda71559fa142b9c22051913ae","unit:1823e6ba86f6d096b6fb369bfee23355af47c2a348da41a402a3c1362c2d511d","unit:2241ed6711a09d9e2e8569b85233772fa6fc0e1cd98b8c75bcf1198f23fbdd01","unit:290a649792d0547c885ecc044173a6fc748325a5d815555ce59f53004c1a91b3","unit:2dc1ee1d3b024cec43be47e6c5814e0906002823c25bd6a0a80bf762c0cad287","unit:2e619600389d017d4ba52ab8b73e912eff66255f6d1f24d8240c2cf96e8fb17a","unit:3fcb31095588e42a7aa350a2883b924fe775ede8f668018f54401d81cc7613bb","unit:42bf824520aa8f4a86858e743f4ba061b5487c6292cbf960af85a231bba68085","unit:43be8448f4682498cc452befddd47cf57622a14b9ca6e1676e7f8a887d285ace","unit:4a1da8e91d3ec5e2143d2edb317e3941e6ca48ab2da678c40d010b9987d72511","unit:54647f88d7459dfbc3ddc68f741fcfcb20dc5fa75bccd030e8563ba187fe710d","unit:5968134c6179bdbcc95652ac9e2635d0d059ce8c1121402d052ab7b13504d465","unit:745fb88269aa07945d803e69f2d42a4b312c20b0c0ab2fdc992cef501e6ec829","unit:754c1685eddbf7d3c5410b2030bf8f0dc24fe43bdff63060a647d5098683f671","unit:772a1e31efbf63da19a46361a8ab023336c47381a85fe734b6bf38ec33cd1410","unit:7807efa647b660301429e3cf412053a830647eb53d82b088009ab591892dea7b","unit:7be6ccfcf5cba0573b44e97dbdc75d12960f9213fd6ba4e043da606e63e5ee4b","unit:7ced2fccc0e0d118a3b374d1878a1780208c0d8215f2509c0f2e12afe70ea629","unit:801b0126fb29dc22eb572e909e0236df7e4387e943e4705dbbff9ea01b0a5e5a","unit:893bd4aae1914560c56cc941227fe08fe5be319d0afe351f0106d544f6bd3022","unit:8ed2cfb705b463e4d9286c046d1223d8033aa2618d67bf630c04ebb8d76d293f","unit:8eeb0f1278cdc8e158f78a36b81e50ed8332c7d7b31b957ad392f8af1c24a9f5","unit:a1a0ba41db95bdf41fe700730952d83babf194412c1a443db8441a029bdaee1f","unit:b00b5a25eb77b8f1ee3b232b640e3e592287b321a7ec0e2ae61b27c261741722","unit:b1c1ca76b1114639b8d86b9753df0d93a282aa071324847aa670d9b5d794d0c0","unit:ba486b46da7b3b301ba070055d9f0c84c7b38190deee9d3d963da8ec66c2b94c","unit:c34875cb1cb51da733a01e8742b8baa0dddec8d4b70f60b549c6f8269f21b503","unit:c408ce30de5a791e6411405df6097de474524f43f70b33106b0133a69717c002","unit:cd0b160c82d27b5e657840be48ebfc93df072d932148f6c4415861f3ac877da3","unit:cea4817cad9946f0ab4b02a298e6c23b7fde1842d0ccc2de74d286578a76be75","unit:df487ecf6e5fd4c6999c5655e9ff5578931a99ec17347d04190578992928d92b","unit:e34ce0f747e56575ca4c58d387d250c24efbfca01930c5a7c3da82010be5fbd4","unit:e54b4ea467d0a0adffecd42a39ec1229e90e80a25d9a809ba7d5d984296b647e","unit:e94ebd111f3cede7e282b155c9ac1f71895293454fe21995d48a9e496c0cd71a","unit:f41ed6d0fcbff2006396541321a6e19d874a009b1a6b1177adb966994e220469","unit:fcf0431e685c9797217a81b23fad41075543d42a3eb50d7901e4e8bf1113ce3e","unit:fea4d463ffd61b7a7cf8d690e1ce202df08bb8004fc22f3e065b26979aa36fe9"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30","scopeContentSha256":"5e2d870128fc2bf088bc5ef1add58d06f7fb940950476c4c9faed0dabe9fca8e","localRef":"s32"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c5267f5181cc7692f3008718","scopeContentSha256":"9248e7247eed0410a2a0bfbcfe7eef0f46e6aea8897e02e58dd3b6bc6b6a3f3a","localRef":"s29"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l26","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-challenge:link:16","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l26","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-challenge:link:16","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:c5267f5181cc7692f3008718","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l26","source":"s32","target":"s29","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Transition endpoints connect rate questions to subsequent geometry, collapse and patch evolution."],"challengeStatement":"Transition endpoints lead to separate questions about subsequent geometry, collapse and patch evolution.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"27329c1b6d9f08b0e40dcc886e3b16e7b48495f7b3e116d23b255418e3c30094","reply.jsonSha256":"8c59d98d35df44f35a62cf50ff89cfab5b0a51d0cb56815705f609dc42d543c6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1e537d736559b5c3cc8e2ca9fc4aaa951005040c5af998907684cf62d3a9aba7","receipt.jsonSha256":"3d8f17e326fc5d32b27eed5dd5f3c221c19710cfd84ae4eac4ed1048a9a6e1cd","normalization.jsonSha256":"622e78a8ba525092b0a1bdf7a8a0aa0ae592c8eb66468238847b4b83dc58ec22","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"391ed89effe4bf734a9cb96be9a28bf5200873b4518f184a03013ba0f3437fc0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"dcaeb4aaf16cd6998a95fcb0aee7105b728076c982932d27b1738b01362b49ba","reply.jsonSha256":"a64ece51728c2f26cefdf831ce037a577ff967a98b6494cab04da25c93c341b3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"a12381e04e1626159906e74eeec1d0ea30d3a8027a8cd0974c1feda49e3ef5b1","receipt.jsonSha256":"b9324580bf11b35eeeeb69d3cb88261be965e41a09ad040032563e3b69daddd9","normalization.jsonSha256":"0f21552d3de34444ff0d844e6a7cccb2787e301aa04d19a3a0034644d79628ff"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c5267f5181cc7692f3008718"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c5267f5181cc7692f3008718"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d26","originalRef":"l26","status":"route","source":"s32","target":"s29","type":"related_question","title":"Follow vacuum endpoints into subsequent cosmological geometry","rationale":"Transition endpoints connect rate calculations to separate questions about geometry, collapse and patch evolution. The supplied reasoning does not show that subsequent geometry applies a transition-rate method or follows from a computed rate, so related_question preserves the established connection.","qualification":"Endpoint potentials, initial data, walls, boundary conditions and dynamical approximations remain source-specific. Transition exponents, prefactors, spacetime rates and observer encounter rates are distinct from post-transition evolution. The broader contracting, anisotropic and runaway branches of s29 are not all transition applications; a negative rolling potential is not automatically an AdS vacuum. Conditional singularity modifications remain conditional. The inherited Hawking–Moss sign conflict and incomplete continuity argument remain unresolved.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l26","s32","s29"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d26","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements connect transition endpoints to separate subsequent-geometry questions without establishing application of a transition-rate method to determine that geometry. related_question accurately preserves the connection. The qualification retains distinct rates and evolution problems, source-specific endpoint data and the unresolved Hawking–Moss and continuity limitations.","refs":["l26","s32","s29"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-13-proposal","parent-orientation-13-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text was supplied or newly read, and no tools, sidecars or external sources were accessed.","Scope references and route references provide context, not new empirical evidence. Reported reading coverage and source-level results remain inherited claims with their stated limits.","Qualified method and application routes cover only the identified components of broad questions. They establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability.","No calculation, proof, simulation, observational constraint or disputed physical conclusion was independently verified. Description-only support and announced results retain that status.","The packet's grouping establishes no shared scientific question among disconnected cases. This proposal does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve coordinator exceptions or perform the global canonical/DAG checks."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and the complete proposal. No tools, external operations or sidecars were accessed.","No primary text was supplied or newly read. Reading-coverage statements and source-level results remain inherited descriptions with their stated limits.","Scope and relation references provide review context rather than new empirical evidence. No proof, calculation, simulation, disputed physical conclusion or observational claim was independently verified.","Qualified method and application routes concern their identified components; they establish neither full-scope containment nor universal applicability across broad endpoints.","Agreement here does not admit endpoint scopes, resolve other coordinator exceptions or perform the endpoint, receipt, canonical or global DAG checks. Packet membership establishes no common scientific question."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-13:l26","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-14:l0":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-14:l0","source":"q025-candidate-question:c2be25df3a08c71d8387d8e0","target":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30","type":"application_of","title":"Trace catalytic scale selection to vacuum-transition calculations","rationale":"The catalytic cosmological-parameter questions apply transition calculations. Reversing the original order places the application before the underlying calculation question.","qualification":"This concerns the catalytic bounce-action and parameter-selection component of s28 under its specified catalyst, dimensional, vacuum-energy and model assumptions. The reported small-cosmological-constant preference requires appropriate catalyst mass scales. It does not make every flux, thermal or TCC constraint an application of one decay calculation. Boundary conditions, approximations, exponents, prefactors and observer-rate conversions remain distinct; neither an observed cosmological-constant explanation nor an observational fit is established.","evidenceIds":["unit:027935fda9c644cbf55d275f86943590263d955ac3280a9bf3b52193ca1828d6","unit:07a6de6b347c1be714617c9d8be0d584a32d17cdc40d78eb9eb2fa60c6c722ba","unit:0aebbe1e9e64b778d69f9fcf407fb02f4610daf7fdea931d67bf2d2c58d465bf","unit:0f0cda04b7d3de40560bc0f31f28cf74c0e98b7e0dfda2b31d697710b9630b81","unit:10f926b10337cdd8b0f696a1d00965f054c95dfda71559fa142b9c22051913ae","unit:2241ed6711a09d9e2e8569b85233772fa6fc0e1cd98b8c75bcf1198f23fbdd01","unit:2e619600389d017d4ba52ab8b73e912eff66255f6d1f24d8240c2cf96e8fb17a","unit:3fcb31095588e42a7aa350a2883b924fe775ede8f668018f54401d81cc7613bb","unit:42bf824520aa8f4a86858e743f4ba061b5487c6292cbf960af85a231bba68085","unit:43be8448f4682498cc452befddd47cf57622a14b9ca6e1676e7f8a887d285ace","unit:46c41950d53989562dbf9dda9108cd22d5ab3a757acc354a8a672e78b7372d54","unit:47ea9178dc0a565fd9b507a93e85c38fa394c0a8937312f1070c54cd0e84c0dd","unit:4a1da8e91d3ec5e2143d2edb317e3941e6ca48ab2da678c40d010b9987d72511","unit:54647f88d7459dfbc3ddc68f741fcfcb20dc5fa75bccd030e8563ba187fe710d","unit:5968134c6179bdbcc95652ac9e2635d0d059ce8c1121402d052ab7b13504d465","unit:745fb88269aa07945d803e69f2d42a4b312c20b0c0ab2fdc992cef501e6ec829","unit:772a1e31efbf63da19a46361a8ab023336c47381a85fe734b6bf38ec33cd1410","unit:7807efa647b660301429e3cf412053a830647eb53d82b088009ab591892dea7b","unit:7be6ccfcf5cba0573b44e97dbdc75d12960f9213fd6ba4e043da606e63e5ee4b","unit:7ced2fccc0e0d118a3b374d1878a1780208c0d8215f2509c0f2e12afe70ea629","unit:8ed2cfb705b463e4d9286c046d1223d8033aa2618d67bf630c04ebb8d76d293f","unit:8eeb0f1278cdc8e158f78a36b81e50ed8332c7d7b31b957ad392f8af1c24a9f5","unit:ad1c8f21341d44fa7c18b400b4ab3164100559853137e1c9bc4d3fe1bd214365","unit:b00b5a25eb77b8f1ee3b232b640e3e592287b321a7ec0e2ae61b27c261741722","unit:b1c1ca76b1114639b8d86b9753df0d93a282aa071324847aa670d9b5d794d0c0","unit:b486a90012ea2ed663d277544e2f86a16c39eba01a8e1f5baf3431bed4d32ea3","unit:ba486b46da7b3b301ba070055d9f0c84c7b38190deee9d3d963da8ec66c2b94c","unit:c34875cb1cb51da733a01e8742b8baa0dddec8d4b70f60b549c6f8269f21b503","unit:c408ce30de5a791e6411405df6097de474524f43f70b33106b0133a69717c002","unit:cd0b160c82d27b5e657840be48ebfc93df072d932148f6c4415861f3ac877da3","unit:df487ecf6e5fd4c6999c5655e9ff5578931a99ec17347d04190578992928d92b","unit:e34ce0f747e56575ca4c58d387d250c24efbfca01930c5a7c3da82010be5fbd4","unit:e54b4ea467d0a0adffecd42a39ec1229e90e80a25d9a809ba7d5d984296b647e","unit:e94ebd111f3cede7e282b155c9ac1f71895293454fe21995d48a9e496c0cd71a","unit:f41ed6d0fcbff2006396541321a6e19d874a009b1a6b1177adb966994e220469","unit:fcf0431e685c9797217a81b23fad41075543d42a3eb50d7901e4e8bf1113ce3e","unit:fea4d463ffd61b7a7cf8d690e1ce202df08bb8004fc22f3e065b26979aa36fe9"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c2be25df3a08c71d8387d8e0","scopeContentSha256":"818b12a29417ed147f315e7173d43d9b8b16665b571badc2a3c4bc03792dc441","localRef":"s28"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30","scopeContentSha256":"5e2d870128fc2bf088bc5ef1add58d06f7fb940950476c4c9faed0dabe9fca8e","localRef":"s34"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l0","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-challenge:link:18","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-14:l0","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-challenge:link:18","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:c2be25df3a08c71d8387d8e0","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l0","source":"s34","target":"s28","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Catalytic calculations can be applied to cosmological parameter questions under specified catalyst and model assumptions."],"challengeStatement":"Catalytic transition calculations have cosmological parameter applications under the stated catalyst and model assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"27329c1b6d9f08b0e40dcc886e3b16e7b48495f7b3e116d23b255418e3c30094","reply.jsonSha256":"8c59d98d35df44f35a62cf50ff89cfab5b0a51d0cb56815705f609dc42d543c6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1e537d736559b5c3cc8e2ca9fc4aaa951005040c5af998907684cf62d3a9aba7","receipt.jsonSha256":"3d8f17e326fc5d32b27eed5dd5f3c221c19710cfd84ae4eac4ed1048a9a6e1cd","normalization.jsonSha256":"622e78a8ba525092b0a1bdf7a8a0aa0ae592c8eb66468238847b4b83dc58ec22","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"391ed89effe4bf734a9cb96be9a28bf5200873b4518f184a03013ba0f3437fc0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"dcaeb4aaf16cd6998a95fcb0aee7105b728076c982932d27b1738b01362b49ba","reply.jsonSha256":"a64ece51728c2f26cefdf831ce037a577ff967a98b6494cab04da25c93c341b3","reply.raw.txtSha256":"a12381e04e1626159906e74eeec1d0ea30d3a8027a8cd0974c1feda49e3ef5b1","receipt.jsonSha256":"b9324580bf11b35eeeeb69d3cb88261be965e41a09ad040032563e3b69daddd9","normalization.jsonSha256":"0f21552d3de34444ff0d844e6a7cccb2787e301aa04d19a3a0034644d79628ff"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30"},{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c2be25df3a08c71d8387d8e0"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d919e042fef1490757ec5b30"},{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c2be25df3a08c71d8387d8e0"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d0","originalRef":"l0","status":"route","source":"s28","target":"s34","type":"application_of","title":"Trace catalytic scale selection to vacuum-transition calculations","rationale":"The catalytic cosmological-parameter questions apply transition calculations. Reversing the original order places the application before the underlying calculation question.","qualification":"This concerns the catalytic bounce-action and parameter-selection component of s28 under its specified catalyst, dimensional, vacuum-energy and model assumptions. The reported small-cosmological-constant preference requires appropriate catalyst mass scales. It does not make every flux, thermal or TCC constraint an application of one decay calculation. Boundary conditions, approximations, exponents, prefactors and observer-rate conversions remain distinct; neither an observed cosmological-constant explanation nor an observational fit is established.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l0","s28","s34"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The paired statements identify catalytic transition calculations as underlying the cosmological parameter application, supporting the reversal to application_of. The qualification confines this to the relevant component, retains catalyst-mass, dimensional and model assumptions, and avoids extending the calculation to every constraint collected at s28.","refs":["l0","s28","s34"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-14-proposal","parent-orientation-14-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This adjudication uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. Primary-reading claims and coverage counts are inherited metadata, not reading performed in this review.","No primary text, machine-sidecar locator contents, original review files, images or full per-unit attribution notes were supplied or newly examined. The l* and s* references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Routes describe scoped scientific navigation. They do not reproduce calculations, verify proofs or observations, establish ultraviolet completion, or resolve source-local formula and applicability problems.","Disconnected rows imply no shared question. This proposal establishes no transitive identity, new source assignment, admission of pending child material or passage through the global canonical/DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge reviewed all 40 supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for each of the 28 relations, and every proposed decision. These are supplied scope and reasoning context, not newly examined primary evidence.","No tools or external operations were used. No primary text, sidecar locator contents, original review files, images or full per-unit attribution notes were supplied or newly read. Historical reading counts and coverage claims remain attributed metadata.","Support applies to each exact qualified navigation record. It does not verify calculations, proofs, observational results, successful embeddings or ultraviolet completion, and it does not resolve inherited formula conflicts or unfinished constructions.","Disconnected relations establish no common scientific question or transitive identity. This review makes no source assignments and does not admit pending child material or perform the separate endpoint, receipt, canonical or DAG admission checks."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-14:l0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"}}}