{"kind":"eigenquestions-relation-details","schemaVersion":"1.0.0","relations":{"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l15":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l15","source":"q025-candidate-question:f2b5e56bc544ddda7852aae3","target":"q025-candidate-question:8d87c71a16b18808212e9c20","type":"application_of","title":"Examine phantom dynamics and consistency underlying Quintom bounces","rationale":"The Quintom bounce in s35 is a contraction-to-expansion application of the physical phantom and crossing questions in s15.","qualification":"Retain homogeneous four-dimensional Einstein–FRW dynamics, NEC violation near the bounce, subsequent evolution toward w greater than -1, and r less than 1 with s positive for the displayed fluid example. Its equation of state diverges at the bounce, and the stated a(0)=1 retains the normalization caveat. A background bounce does not establish perturbative health, energy boundedness, microscopic viability or a complete hot Big Bang history. It is distinct from reconstructed effective phantom behavior in coupled canonical quintessence.","evidenceIds":["unit:0af328c4ef33b7be22a90b9b2906159493aa38ceefbccb8688bfc2e6a82d5f68","unit:0bc008e70338e94e11bf122d8d2b761f90c800bb5d88ea3b7979886ad15592b0","unit:3d994014aaf88ac04db134c38b6908054d6a9f340c1bf7e922de4709ee42cd1c","unit:599434c8f08d944d7be28bcb00958d940eeeb224128481a22ad9b9f8c1f14ade","unit:5b8733d8ece064a25ea8107458f163814ef4ced03d8e6fd5ad5243e107520844","unit:5d75cbb2552ddfdd4e519f052fef463d4eb2d2d04b3933a522be57b3d11886ad","unit:aa8c6cfce7b732afe2a373357cfc10dccc2efd1be564c6f1563df1f262eb88ed","unit:acc5e23bc2409d650a891c6737176fe601245c73bee1218e1c7fd918a01c4b20","unit:d6e688091a0dcef8bf3112eef3054960687e0d73c0d8dcb747f332452d0f0837","unit:dcc8829b779c1fe11fd406854834c13677436c9e749a86cdfea6749a78a1c348"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f2b5e56bc544ddda7852aae3","scopeContentSha256":"8772b10b394a2893b5d36c2b119b7461e03bbded54c9360946f2e87cdeab8be5","localRef":"s35"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8d87c71a16b18808212e9c20","scopeContentSha256":"22de289ce701f2db1ed26b4574d1329b22c851b72eca8e9de1d50e9600729333","localRef":"s15"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l15","originalCandidateId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge:link:49","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l15","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge:link:49","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:8d87c71a16b18808212e9c20","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:f2b5e56bc544ddda7852aae3","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l15","source":"s15","target":"s35","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["A Quintom bounce is a distinct contraction-to-expansion application, not an alias for late-time effective phantom behavior."],"challengeStatement":"Quintom bouncing is a contraction-to-expansion application, distinct from late-time effective phantom reconstruction.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"7b33b16c985585a06b369b1d0d8f2223ea66f4bf751e8180c02bac1d73685cad","reply.jsonSha256":"1f6db74d58e33725f67aec60f85cbb15f0bcf7f2b88678a3327e4ea342d661c7","reply.raw.txtSha256":"68f65e9cdbde08c1baabde287b0807d7de16a13f2f05da01eca5c7d7f804ab37","receipt.jsonSha256":"9351a4e44cb862bf94bd5d62d4ba23cc06434fe4035352177c15f4ecd41f1c33","normalization.jsonSha256":"5bb01ca69a3683f3cac170091b720de22bb04698b69c9b7d5a53283e96a10200","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"681b060972d2664e2c8461d9d9ba1c6a105480ab939d527c82406b3eba67fb77"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"894314622f9c38a49311c9aba776c5764c823d15384a6e582538f5b4d1b4a3fd","reply.jsonSha256":"b670b1f143a82ba9448c0b01000b16afb6d831937be636f0287ee70b1a133499","reply.raw.txtSha256":"8d3183c6cfd51f88c29ccc9c473017a0d31b94c74bb9512f0201658c79b8594e","receipt.jsonSha256":"14618f9fbef0ad8ab6c2b1b6f497a337f04bcc06f46b8263213fcf5440148635","normalization.jsonSha256":"894fb0b86097950af3369e4ef1eb9944571800d944830fa18ca9ef6594c63998"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8d87c71a16b18808212e9c20"},{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f2b5e56bc544ddda7852aae3"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8d87c71a16b18808212e9c20"},{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f2b5e56bc544ddda7852aae3"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d15","originalRef":"l15","status":"route","source":"s35","target":"s15","type":"application_of","title":"Examine phantom dynamics and consistency underlying Quintom bounces","rationale":"The Quintom bounce in s35 is a contraction-to-expansion application of the physical phantom and crossing questions in s15.","qualification":"Retain homogeneous four-dimensional Einstein–FRW dynamics, NEC violation near the bounce, subsequent evolution toward w greater than -1, and r less than 1 with s positive for the displayed fluid example. Its equation of state diverges at the bounce, and the stated a(0)=1 retains the normalization caveat. A background bounce does not establish perturbative health, energy boundedness, microscopic viability or a complete hot Big Bang history. It is distinct from reconstructed effective phantom behavior in coupled canonical quintessence.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l15","s15","s35"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d15","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The Quintom bounce in s35 applies physical phantom and crossing dynamics organized in s15. Its Einstein–FRW setting, NEC condition, fluid restrictions, divergent equation of state and normalization caveat remain explicit, with no claim of complete cosmological or microscopic viability.","refs":["l15","s15","s35"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l15","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l16":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l16","source":"q025-candidate-question:d836b647e03512ebe99c6abb","target":"q025-candidate-region:90f059c6f5c7ad3d5f062158","type":"method_for","title":"Compare acceleration models using likelihood and evidence methods","rationale":"The likelihood definitions and Bayesian-computation questions in s32 supply methods for the model-comparison branch of s39.","qualification":"Observation spaces, likelihoods and priors must be specified for the candidate models. Conceptual observer-dependent likelihood definitions and numerical evidence or posterior algorithms remain distinct targets. The route does not assert that a general-purpose interface already implements a particular dark-energy analysis. Computational efficiency establishes neither physical model validity nor an acceleration mechanism, and archived assessments retain their dates.","evidenceIds":["unit:0684802524cfc2204abeabaebe46aa023dd15afef9d2f0dad195e84c63b42674","unit:10d7ebcdef3128c5e3657f18db15a83b71ad407eb9e21a8bb1f9c344ba0ffd08","unit:23573d6d437fd50d277b521fc910b8b3e483401c674960be688530a47fe80308","unit:3cd590dd47591ec30441652a5a76986fe49922853b644828174ff4e1bd02cbc6","unit:3d0446f6af2d0021ded666c5a05dda2c6c30dc9ad94951864d630252ee9ab31c","unit:665eecd6756068b3556af19cf7ec19e605e6b2f88eb5a28cf85b9a1e2440a62d","unit:7395a19bf1a42071da6e8e4c2296a9c585caf7cb9ad93eb18e62efe00724541a","unit:85b0b3042ec39763f07e3e10507fdd0bd48855961e4a3b9d5ee13fa286bbc6fa","unit:8cff6c42e83f8f63593c69df52db27458f0aafc1d92a0ca2990c5d6a0f5862d9","unit:aeeb8cd2831785520a524cb3399112212b7de78e437ac8f96b7c4c088fca3477","unit:cb19f7146b803c04638692cf162135e3f4f805fa770926c156c6d227054a79cb","unit:dcaab408a925625b71ce987842ac990ea402334a75b69edbd3237f336c547f89","unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d836b647e03512ebe99c6abb","scopeContentSha256":"0bf6d085a4c1e3be52a614be913d52fcb12a4053f9241b46254a0cf820f5ad52","localRef":"s32"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:90f059c6f5c7ad3d5f062158","scopeContentSha256":"1ec91a87ed4e95c2d5987d7da36b6d20dedfa214c14ac17a38f03b7a9282aa76","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l16","originalCandidateId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge:link:8","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l16","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge:link:8","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:90f059c6f5c7ad3d5f062158","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:d836b647e03512ebe99c6abb","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l16","source":"s39","target":"s32","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["General likelihood and Bayesian-computation questions support model comparison without becoming dark-energy mechanisms."],"challengeStatement":"Likelihood definitions and Bayesian computation support comparisons without constituting acceleration mechanisms.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"7b33b16c985585a06b369b1d0d8f2223ea66f4bf751e8180c02bac1d73685cad","reply.jsonSha256":"1f6db74d58e33725f67aec60f85cbb15f0bcf7f2b88678a3327e4ea342d661c7","reply.raw.txtSha256":"68f65e9cdbde08c1baabde287b0807d7de16a13f2f05da01eca5c7d7f804ab37","receipt.jsonSha256":"9351a4e44cb862bf94bd5d62d4ba23cc06434fe4035352177c15f4ecd41f1c33","normalization.jsonSha256":"5bb01ca69a3683f3cac170091b720de22bb04698b69c9b7d5a53283e96a10200","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"681b060972d2664e2c8461d9d9ba1c6a105480ab939d527c82406b3eba67fb77"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"894314622f9c38a49311c9aba776c5764c823d15384a6e582538f5b4d1b4a3fd","reply.jsonSha256":"b670b1f143a82ba9448c0b01000b16afb6d831937be636f0287ee70b1a133499","reply.raw.txtSha256":"8d3183c6cfd51f88c29ccc9c473017a0d31b94c74bb9512f0201658c79b8594e","receipt.jsonSha256":"14618f9fbef0ad8ab6c2b1b6f497a337f04bcc06f46b8263213fcf5440148635","normalization.jsonSha256":"894fb0b86097950af3369e4ef1eb9944571800d944830fa18ca9ef6594c63998"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d836b647e03512ebe99c6abb"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2005.05290","sourceId":"ev:4e6eea0188601bb6934c60e400a2f84e","sourceSha256":"de3b615ab6695b481558b7be46ed5483deb412edefd49c6fffab17812eaa487b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bdc9dad2e59176e0adc3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"15b09c9627040e2062e5673c5d88a4f5edf76ed684616fc85da295eb8d030df4","pdfPage":1,"start":1298,"end":4697,"textSha256":"1ea7c95911f204e7536c58caeed7f0251c4e6b12bd7823719cd991e56dae5dea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2005.05290","sourceId":"ev:c4a42a008b4a6cd410fa72753db9d677","sourceSha256":"de3b615ab6695b481558b7be46ed5483deb412edefd49c6fffab17812eaa487b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bdc9dad2e59176e0adc3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"15b09c9627040e2062e5673c5d88a4f5edf76ed684616fc85da295eb8d030df4","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f754e9a4488da82a4dc79126feb9e1c0f19e88d64697c5ee55b94ae1daf7074f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d836b647e03512ebe99c6abb"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2005.05290","sourceId":"ev:4e6eea0188601bb6934c60e400a2f84e","sourceSha256":"de3b615ab6695b481558b7be46ed5483deb412edefd49c6fffab17812eaa487b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bdc9dad2e59176e0adc3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"15b09c9627040e2062e5673c5d88a4f5edf76ed684616fc85da295eb8d030df4","pdfPage":1,"start":1298,"end":4697,"textSha256":"1ea7c95911f204e7536c58caeed7f0251c4e6b12bd7823719cd991e56dae5dea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2005.05290","sourceId":"ev:c4a42a008b4a6cd410fa72753db9d677","sourceSha256":"de3b615ab6695b481558b7be46ed5483deb412edefd49c6fffab17812eaa487b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bdc9dad2e59176e0adc3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"15b09c9627040e2062e5673c5d88a4f5edf76ed684616fc85da295eb8d030df4","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f754e9a4488da82a4dc79126feb9e1c0f19e88d64697c5ee55b94ae1daf7074f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d16","originalRef":"l16","status":"route","source":"s32","target":"s39","type":"method_for","title":"Compare acceleration models using likelihood and evidence methods","rationale":"The likelihood definitions and Bayesian-computation questions in s32 supply methods for the model-comparison branch of s39.","qualification":"Observation spaces, likelihoods and priors must be specified for the candidate models. Conceptual observer-dependent likelihood definitions and numerical evidence or posterior algorithms remain distinct targets. The route does not assert that a general-purpose interface already implements a particular dark-energy analysis. Computational efficiency establishes neither physical model validity nor an acceleration mechanism, and archived assessments retain their dates.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l16","s39","s32"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d16","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"s32 supplies likelihood and Bayesian-computation methods for the comparison branch of s39. The record keeps foundational likelihood questions distinct from numerical algorithms and does not infer a dark-energy implementation or acceleration mechanism from a general-purpose method.","refs":["l16","s39","s32"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l16","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l17":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l17","source":"q025-candidate-question:d836b647e03512ebe99c6abb","target":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b","type":"method_for","title":"Define observational likelihoods for selection-conditioned predictions","rationale":"The observer-dependent likelihood definitions organized in s32 provide a methodological input to the predictive-probability and theory-comparison questions in s1.","qualification":"This connection uses the likelihood-definition branch, not an identification of typicality with evidence-computation algorithms. Preserve the observation event, reference and comparison classes, prior weights and physical sampling assumptions. Conditioning differs from a sampling protocol or prior preference, and typicality is assessed rather than imposed. No complete likelihood, unique cosmological measure or automatic penalty for unobserved populations is supplied.","evidenceIds":["unit:0684802524cfc2204abeabaebe46aa023dd15afef9d2f0dad195e84c63b42674","unit:08c6d79631cb5f4e8c1b0b2c8605362b1df6222ce944da6053869d2d0b7b9383","unit:0bec7d24f4b853509974960a9b256ec86ddbf97c6e12ffbe54c5c416fe839bbf","unit:10d7ebcdef3128c5e3657f18db15a83b71ad407eb9e21a8bb1f9c344ba0ffd08","unit:26cac0bab264bed2840cc106cf8fe9a8288356d8f7cc7b397df850f091db8e8d","unit:3065f6db25636dd0d1c20810c8e6bbd2f974c326ee6ed7893a09ec5491a9180f","unit:3cd590dd47591ec30441652a5a76986fe49922853b644828174ff4e1bd02cbc6","unit:3d0446f6af2d0021ded666c5a05dda2c6c30dc9ad94951864d630252ee9ab31c","unit:64952e682d2ca9438649740a8f79cd57a51eeecb9fab57ce864fa3ca3aaa78fa","unit:71bfa0f8554d9df9677c127d9a32886e8e418b156676dd638a8bd7f12b107059","unit:7395a19bf1a42071da6e8e4c2296a9c585caf7cb9ad93eb18e62efe00724541a","unit:85b0b3042ec39763f07e3e10507fdd0bd48855961e4a3b9d5ee13fa286bbc6fa","unit:9c5dbbcd526fb9b55d5bb0729895c291f87fee81376dc3b335df5dd78c99cb1b","unit:9cbd555eb3f47a8a16cc108fd88be595f414a9a9cfec38316cd94350fd3b176c","unit:a4b07c98bcfaf018331c3f567d796aa7730a010b1165f1c0ba75d7fdb7c39b35","unit:aeeb8cd2831785520a524cb3399112212b7de78e437ac8f96b7c4c088fca3477","unit:c713ac71b5243d4dfac0bf1b1015fff9d707c5a09e112e031055d1649de36713","unit:cb19f7146b803c04638692cf162135e3f4f805fa770926c156c6d227054a79cb"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d836b647e03512ebe99c6abb","scopeContentSha256":"0bf6d085a4c1e3be52a614be913d52fcb12a4053f9241b46254a0cf820f5ad52","localRef":"s32"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b","scopeContentSha256":"cc4e84d1aee655aadad777498bf32c05fe61b423305212271117c4154a98aef3","localRef":"s1"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l17","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge:link:48","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l17","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge:link:48","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:d836b647e03512ebe99c6abb","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l17","source":"s1","target":"s32","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Observer-dependent likelihood definitions connect to cosmological inference, while general Bayesian computation remains a separate methodological target."],"challengeStatement":"Observer-dependent likelihood definitions connect to inference; general evidence-computation algorithms remain a different target.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"95b1c7ba751c3f0831666906655a0772176b892862235639ba1b9f54177c0fe0","reply.jsonSha256":"2e948e54b460d4b78bd71e446414fb0734f34ec4e97be5eb0e4df090e615020e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"05a9a6b1249fce2e08510b7210c348274ab6822ab09918c64eda2a48a3cc30ae","receipt.jsonSha256":"50b7a181fc889d648a958ce20d90f3bf63e9351bac28605053ee83284da96d71","normalization.jsonSha256":"4538227034e50489c356d26e199de14d19afbe9d7c067bd7af5966066d994d3c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8bb74bad7dd366b41cb748c2d9278ae4184272afe37dc42ea085bed7dcb576d9"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"e259dbe129fef2f9d0be22648b8d6689b863f0acbb87ac00124a1011e9a73600","reply.jsonSha256":"08d00dca4e0be0dc1f1d71e1671f981ef07dd6078404652a39279d6ea35d1b25","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b0cb06db5235be5edcd5239e9867cbb3cf4eaa54bc95dcfd1b6d46130f595856","receipt.jsonSha256":"92c8bdf185ba9b933381dece64798713f76f0bfe64151241faee9b7b222a9e7a","normalization.jsonSha256":"0ef5d823adf0a25e589964d662378d8e7b623e16dece9d8146aed46a759851e4"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b"},{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d836b647e03512ebe99c6abb"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:144b74531e6a5fefb174a360b27860fe","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":1,"start":1559,"end":4559,"textSha256":"a4122ad2fab0ab09bebb7218e7803460d565c602c378b1caecddcf6e09b8f482","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:45938f30193efbdd44ffcf926589b4a6","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"ef49ebd08ffa019f26abd3d30b32744501edb00f76fc9de72931777fab6a2ecc","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:8b29f7b67c3475ab782291c9eb46d4fc","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":6,"start":797,"end":3797,"textSha256":"3922149b84add3bbec7189b1f6f308ac60fa31e7689d2257d183252b1d485a2f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b"},{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d836b647e03512ebe99c6abb"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:144b74531e6a5fefb174a360b27860fe","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":1,"start":1559,"end":4559,"textSha256":"a4122ad2fab0ab09bebb7218e7803460d565c602c378b1caecddcf6e09b8f482","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:45938f30193efbdd44ffcf926589b4a6","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"ef49ebd08ffa019f26abd3d30b32744501edb00f76fc9de72931777fab6a2ecc","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:8b29f7b67c3475ab782291c9eb46d4fc","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":6,"start":797,"end":3797,"textSha256":"3922149b84add3bbec7189b1f6f308ac60fa31e7689d2257d183252b1d485a2f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d17","originalRef":"l17","status":"route","source":"s32","target":"s1","type":"method_for","title":"Define observational likelihoods for selection-conditioned predictions","rationale":"The observer-dependent likelihood definitions organized in s32 provide a methodological input to the predictive-probability and theory-comparison questions in s1.","qualification":"This connection uses the likelihood-definition branch, not an identification of typicality with evidence-computation algorithms. Preserve the observation event, reference and comparison classes, prior weights and physical sampling assumptions. Conditioning differs from a sampling protocol or prior preference, and typicality is assessed rather than imposed. No complete likelihood, unique cosmological measure or automatic penalty for unobserved populations is supplied.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l17","s1","s32"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d17","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The likelihood-definition branch explicitly present in s32 supplies a methodological input to selection-conditioned prediction and theory comparison in s1. The record preserves observation events, reference classes, priors and sampling distinctions while excluding an identification with general evidence-computation algorithms.","refs":["l17","s1","s32"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l17","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l18":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l18","source":"q025-candidate-question:59964ad08f35611719bd0536","target":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b","type":"premise_check","title":"Check selection premises behind inflationary probabilities","rationale":"The probabilistic weighting and selection branches of s7 depend on the justification of selection, conditioning and typicality examined in s1. The premise-check arrow therefore runs from s7 to s1.","qualification":"This prerequisite concerns probability claims, not every dynamical initial-condition or transition question. Preserve the adopted measure, sampling prescription, observation event and comparison class. Selection assumptions require justification separately from dynamical accessibility, initial conditions and transitions. Neither a universal likelihood of inflation nor a dynamical exit follows from a weighting prescription or prescribed endpoint.","evidenceIds":["unit:0299884a32d71d3c1eb4a5644e84dcb9f39bc9af5679ba6b29d2393c20d58d41","unit:08c6d79631cb5f4e8c1b0b2c8605362b1df6222ce944da6053869d2d0b7b9383","unit:0bec7d24f4b853509974960a9b256ec86ddbf97c6e12ffbe54c5c416fe839bbf","unit:0db1e3cac3d980a10bbc5cb774d24fe8a268bbf6c673061893d985fd196ac9d3","unit:1dc3e3c6c60eaa97fba580512ea00f3b2160013c3d7ce638237d4a780351f1c3","unit:264a8c24464bf40a7811cc6110c134b3670a98fefbe716f818e3a29549406dc8","unit:26cac0bab264bed2840cc106cf8fe9a8288356d8f7cc7b397df850f091db8e8d","unit:279991d2a81c69dcbe6aa0853419ccbeaf894fb46f12c867098ae6f112947e66","unit:3065f6db25636dd0d1c20810c8e6bbd2f974c326ee6ed7893a09ec5491a9180f","unit:3b530d5693494dc001d8dc1f49200a89ac3166c6b2daa66e0e6e01747765b462","unit:4213477040c3aa6d3bdb5628ab7fcee5d62d92e83f7745ca3f5d0526315cf9e2","unit:44f896289f988ae22f8cbdf9c2786133fe80640387051fbf190a4702037ff272","unit:51e48c4f3b655ed350d258489203995d02bda9a55aa1362f34b746a5f9308a4d","unit:52e930d54925ef4d4144d18647fa8339cc209ba5ae20e310bee926a9e678ccbc","unit:64952e682d2ca9438649740a8f79cd57a51eeecb9fab57ce864fa3ca3aaa78fa","unit:71bfa0f8554d9df9677c127d9a32886e8e418b156676dd638a8bd7f12b107059","unit:7c08006507395902aa81211ad85ee30daa715aeb5752366fc16fa698a5d827ca","unit:846b5eaed40fb85686e83739948802175d551df3d0b9a507973ceda91b9482b8","unit:860510a89c1fde29b9af1b76295754f18e2ed495862620caf50d4d679374ed19","unit:8a064ba8e9c50c193528adc1c09e65cbb2e8c99127758ee3654110a193ede210","unit:9c5dbbcd526fb9b55d5bb0729895c291f87fee81376dc3b335df5dd78c99cb1b","unit:9cbd555eb3f47a8a16cc108fd88be595f414a9a9cfec38316cd94350fd3b176c","unit:a373f914c70791b9711cbeaeb950a55f37271b4df6a6d4ee136f93b4835c8e0b","unit:a4b07c98bcfaf018331c3f567d796aa7730a010b1165f1c0ba75d7fdb7c39b35","unit:a9255b4aa3b990808bbf3f9e02f6083c2e383842996d2115f901593fe26e6bff","unit:ab77ac5503f4a1a9a27d5e460186675ed5f83c749798a8c66eeab0c820970f78","unit:ae81e68aac2f2ddb923fa7a3cbbfc0db483f4ff1252403b6776c68554698bac1","unit:bfdb8ee6dd12b2749657c0604a55b20e67a9e2f5ed6d5c2414ab22da0cb7bdc5","unit:c08a0822f844f311f9b581be88d94e14fda9b19287c466498dc2341d240aaf67","unit:c713ac71b5243d4dfac0bf1b1015fff9d707c5a09e112e031055d1649de36713","unit:d8bd40f29de65b2c2d158e7cc8fa271789c43824a8ac9b594c648bb68e365e11"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:59964ad08f35611719bd0536","scopeContentSha256":"388f8d1e229ff5ebd7b1d604f442c73861a0ec93a236bdd7c3ab81d363095437","localRef":"s7"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b","scopeContentSha256":"cc4e84d1aee655aadad777498bf32c05fe61b423305212271117c4154a98aef3","localRef":"s1"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l18","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge:link:49","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l18","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge:link:49","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:59964ad08f35611719bd0536","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l18","source":"s1","target":"s7","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["Selection assumptions require justification separately from dynamical accessibility, initial conditions and cosmological transitions."],"challengeStatement":"Selection assumptions require justification separately from dynamical accessibility, initial conditions and transitions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"95b1c7ba751c3f0831666906655a0772176b892862235639ba1b9f54177c0fe0","reply.jsonSha256":"2e948e54b460d4b78bd71e446414fb0734f34ec4e97be5eb0e4df090e615020e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"05a9a6b1249fce2e08510b7210c348274ab6822ab09918c64eda2a48a3cc30ae","receipt.jsonSha256":"50b7a181fc889d648a958ce20d90f3bf63e9351bac28605053ee83284da96d71","normalization.jsonSha256":"4538227034e50489c356d26e199de14d19afbe9d7c067bd7af5966066d994d3c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8bb74bad7dd366b41cb748c2d9278ae4184272afe37dc42ea085bed7dcb576d9"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"e259dbe129fef2f9d0be22648b8d6689b863f0acbb87ac00124a1011e9a73600","reply.jsonSha256":"08d00dca4e0be0dc1f1d71e1671f981ef07dd6078404652a39279d6ea35d1b25","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b0cb06db5235be5edcd5239e9867cbb3cf4eaa54bc95dcfd1b6d46130f595856","receipt.jsonSha256":"92c8bdf185ba9b933381dece64798713f76f0bfe64151241faee9b7b222a9e7a","normalization.jsonSha256":"0ef5d823adf0a25e589964d662378d8e7b623e16dece9d8146aed46a759851e4"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b"},{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:59964ad08f35611719bd0536"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:144b74531e6a5fefb174a360b27860fe","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":1,"start":1559,"end":4559,"textSha256":"a4122ad2fab0ab09bebb7218e7803460d565c602c378b1caecddcf6e09b8f482","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:45938f30193efbdd44ffcf926589b4a6","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"ef49ebd08ffa019f26abd3d30b32744501edb00f76fc9de72931777fab6a2ecc","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e19","kind":"primary","paperId":"1807.11938","sourceId":"ev:f6b6bbf7a6e84f619586f3c0950a177c","sourceSha256":"808bbf8eb9277e68aa0b31ed7daa16100ace43b084ea4d253d9169c2d588f548","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/da8476043f2c8a1a7363/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e5613f681b78f07373b3aa64d99dc398415941fda7184f83632a0bb58ff193f1","pdfPage":1,"start":1683,"end":4683,"textSha256":"abc7169443ac60a663026eb56c28d1726fd79315b89207671e192b8d2968b8e2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b"},{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:59964ad08f35611719bd0536"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:144b74531e6a5fefb174a360b27860fe","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":1,"start":1559,"end":4559,"textSha256":"a4122ad2fab0ab09bebb7218e7803460d565c602c378b1caecddcf6e09b8f482","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:45938f30193efbdd44ffcf926589b4a6","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"ef49ebd08ffa019f26abd3d30b32744501edb00f76fc9de72931777fab6a2ecc","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e19","kind":"primary","paperId":"1807.11938","sourceId":"ev:f6b6bbf7a6e84f619586f3c0950a177c","sourceSha256":"808bbf8eb9277e68aa0b31ed7daa16100ace43b084ea4d253d9169c2d588f548","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/da8476043f2c8a1a7363/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e5613f681b78f07373b3aa64d99dc398415941fda7184f83632a0bb58ff193f1","pdfPage":1,"start":1683,"end":4683,"textSha256":"abc7169443ac60a663026eb56c28d1726fd79315b89207671e192b8d2968b8e2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d18","originalRef":"l18","status":"route","source":"s7","target":"s1","type":"premise_check","title":"Check selection premises behind inflationary probabilities","rationale":"The probabilistic weighting and selection branches of s7 depend on the justification of selection, conditioning and typicality examined in s1. The premise-check arrow therefore runs from s7 to s1.","qualification":"This prerequisite concerns probability claims, not every dynamical initial-condition or transition question. Preserve the adopted measure, sampling prescription, observation event and comparison class. Selection assumptions require justification separately from dynamical accessibility, initial conditions and transitions. Neither a universal likelihood of inflation nor a dynamical exit follows from a weighting prescription or prescribed endpoint.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l18","s1","s7"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d18","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The probability and weighting branches of s7 require the selection-premise assessment in s1, so the reversed premise-check arrow is appropriate. The qualification avoids imposing those premises on every dynamical initial-condition or transition question.","refs":["l18","s1","s7"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l18","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l20":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l20","source":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b","target":"q025-candidate-region:88aac1f2c237b6c3e063f6e0","type":"method_for","title":"Use selection and typicality analysis in cosmological comparisons","rationale":"The selection and predictive-probability questions in s1 supply the explicit inference route within s38, retaining the original alternate access for the parent boundary contrast.","qualification":"Applicability is limited to observer-conditioned predictions and theory comparisons, not all field, gravitational or cosmological questions in s38. Typicality is assessed rather than imposed. Preserve reference classes, observation events, prior weights and physical sampling assumptions; conditioning is not itself a sampling protocol. This route establishes neither a unique measure nor new evidence about the unsupplied boundary contrasts or descendants.","evidenceIds":["unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","unit:08c6d79631cb5f4e8c1b0b2c8605362b1df6222ce944da6053869d2d0b7b9383","unit:0bec7d24f4b853509974960a9b256ec86ddbf97c6e12ffbe54c5c416fe839bbf","unit:1ec134bf9e80cf29bfe0d57c40fa095ba7d11c974e816c4d4e0bfdd194b507b8","unit:26cac0bab264bed2840cc106cf8fe9a8288356d8f7cc7b397df850f091db8e8d","unit:3065f6db25636dd0d1c20810c8e6bbd2f974c326ee6ed7893a09ec5491a9180f","unit:4bea2236adce2a83cf3c451f430db2b31ccbb60826ec94caf64e9a0ca2613854","unit:64952e682d2ca9438649740a8f79cd57a51eeecb9fab57ce864fa3ca3aaa78fa","unit:71bfa0f8554d9df9677c127d9a32886e8e418b156676dd638a8bd7f12b107059","unit:9c5dbbcd526fb9b55d5bb0729895c291f87fee81376dc3b335df5dd78c99cb1b","unit:9cbd555eb3f47a8a16cc108fd88be595f414a9a9cfec38316cd94350fd3b176c","unit:a4b07c98bcfaf018331c3f567d796aa7730a010b1165f1c0ba75d7fdb7c39b35","unit:c713ac71b5243d4dfac0bf1b1015fff9d707c5a09e112e031055d1649de36713","unit:de7162a45af038398c39670733d289c5664edfd248aee31ff58d29b4e2042f1f"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b","scopeContentSha256":"cc4e84d1aee655aadad777498bf32c05fe61b423305212271117c4154a98aef3","localRef":"s1"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:88aac1f2c237b6c3e063f6e0","scopeContentSha256":"d0d9fba5488b94afa7635c327243dbc3bb4b630288a1a59ec60f2d231661fc5f","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l20","originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge:link:14","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l20","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge:link:14","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:88aac1f2c237b6c3e063f6e0","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l20","source":"s38","target":"s1","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Selection, typicality and predictive probabilities provide an inference route, including a home for the parent boundary contrast."],"challengeStatement":"Selection and typicality provide an inference route and an alternate home for the boundary contrast. Typicality is assessed rather than imposed.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"e5504a2c4da076c85104a2266ee2d7736e709a7e52a5d800af1700943c465cac","reply.jsonSha256":"c7670a2a3f34e361015dbf9482392020b1a573e8a83b6a60c6d900a13e7586eb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7128fb9710583d064a2fdcc6d110ef96841760bd1a2dbd1edd5c8ddfa1e91415","receipt.jsonSha256":"1dfa74ad6830cffb2282b232a13cc93ffd43f1fb20e262f22448b79744e21f56","normalization.jsonSha256":"dc92ec109885b2b11e32b021171ca6cb99228c52647c0739d967d53f52076084","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4fe88709dd8c30df946cd8ecebff01e16afac4d554ebd9a82df8762a9494b5cd"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"783fca8ad0c206144b663c532d96a903a50df8724949f88395f9d5e460bfcc59","reply.jsonSha256":"a5b87b3059ea83dd4136caff9089a981a93d2932676041a5fb90dc12adfba988","reply.raw.txtSha256":"0150d21a762614339b2ad10b13e27b5e332664b355b59600c635fd0574428e03","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a03ea25b1d3f029bf1b8a76cff9e15f8ffafc2b2052cabf5059938d238e7b36","normalization.jsonSha256":"f9d3c8d0a480348d5e8e97bd7f55dad45c7dd4baec013e9547a323081f64a5be"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:144b74531e6a5fefb174a360b27860fe","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":1,"start":1559,"end":4559,"textSha256":"a4122ad2fab0ab09bebb7218e7803460d565c602c378b1caecddcf6e09b8f482","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:45938f30193efbdd44ffcf926589b4a6","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"ef49ebd08ffa019f26abd3d30b32744501edb00f76fc9de72931777fab6a2ecc","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:8b29f7b67c3475ab782291c9eb46d4fc","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":6,"start":797,"end":3797,"textSha256":"3922149b84add3bbec7189b1f6f308ac60fa31e7689d2257d183252b1d485a2f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:245893226e8c43bea58d223b"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:144b74531e6a5fefb174a360b27860fe","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":1,"start":1559,"end":4559,"textSha256":"a4122ad2fab0ab09bebb7218e7803460d565c602c378b1caecddcf6e09b8f482","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:45938f30193efbdd44ffcf926589b4a6","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"ef49ebd08ffa019f26abd3d30b32744501edb00f76fc9de72931777fab6a2ecc","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"0704.2630","sourceId":"ev:8b29f7b67c3475ab782291c9eb46d4fc","sourceSha256":"5de0ef5ec09e3c64f2c8c4e8d0f48617f83c86fe749d2bf58e539040c494c754","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c061b6f3534bb93ecef9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1973fc9d6a65b291514a56981a3f09e662b5036cc5656dfbb809e54f1f60d520","pdfPage":6,"start":797,"end":3797,"textSha256":"3922149b84add3bbec7189b1f6f308ac60fa31e7689d2257d183252b1d485a2f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d20","originalRef":"l20","status":"route","source":"s1","target":"s38","type":"method_for","title":"Use selection and typicality analysis in cosmological comparisons","rationale":"The selection and predictive-probability questions in s1 supply the explicit inference route within s38, retaining the original alternate access for the parent boundary contrast.","qualification":"Applicability is limited to observer-conditioned predictions and theory comparisons, not all field, gravitational or cosmological questions in s38. Typicality is assessed rather than imposed. Preserve reference classes, observation events, prior weights and physical sampling assumptions; conditioning is not itself a sampling protocol. This route establishes neither a unique measure nor new evidence about the unsupplied boundary contrasts or descendants.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l20","s38","s1"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d20","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"s1 supplies the explicit observer-conditioned inference route within s38. The record appropriately treats typicality as assessed rather than imposed, confines applicability to prediction and comparison, and does not claim new evidence about unsupplied contrasts or descendants.","refs":["l20","s38","s1"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l20","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l21":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l21","source":"q025-candidate-question:b1c4c37becd0a3ce0ded3d15","target":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f","type":"method_for","title":"Use charged-string states in physical Coulomb-cone tests","rationale":"The paired statements identify BPS-string states as contributions to reconstructing the physical Coulomb cone. This supports the existing direction from the charged-string diagnostics in s25 to the reduction and Coulomb-branch questions in s17.","qualification":"Use the relevant particle states from both massless fields and BPS strings; the string contribution alone is not asserted to determine the cone. Required strings, admissible charges, sector and normalization must be justified. Positivity and boundary tests apply only within the correctly identified physical cone. Preserve the restricted parent theories and T=0 emphasis, and do not infer arbitrary uplift sufficiency or a quantum-gravity completion from passing these diagnostics.","evidenceIds":["unit:002c4e5fbdee96b81e899bfae015ede31b5c59dcd22c3310352ade5f8dd25164","unit:16e5760b894765ab1a0598d09bf4e163545d99299a64d242c848ac7fd661ea16","unit:1aa4847fb5f31863fca58b8abe0ec5b495d267282d1a13c8ecbc11787fe20962","unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","unit:21566519271e2447b13403d6db9c7cfba8d467ae5799e6ce96711b660fdbba79","unit:46d2f275bb7b71b49beec5631d1ed2d092ac470fd32a2701f3a89ab4539a54e6","unit:4e1818c5cbe9e99a7018d8e987ed82fed05b22b4b08c5855d2a51b959ee71cc5","unit:57fb12a8667e086b98aa6b6ab4fdba765c8f96f55269dd46e1d1b83fc333788c","unit:6dcb82a1b54b56fd5bd9ca28819452448b1a02b518b47261389cb31126830164","unit:71dcb4bfc2ee8e354658bf0873f3c9c67b66636cf479330d0fe2720bd4b46c0f","unit:8638107849984e32d73956c70e8c7bbdd470a8518836e1015c4633a2f5329691","unit:873e56ca61e5f0bb8bc0689676817ab75c75cffdcad0f5eb3173788dee4c6b37","unit:949c963109800e37fb21bbbeb2396cc93a61f7f8a0a53521b1c7ec5fa32da7df","unit:b74519e223ec4654df4f9832d63ec3a14e8122f2b5dcdbc821f741f7a20aceab","unit:b9c70e2cc4f86cd8e96a3c7716b9aaba85cbcd639c9b7987153a2cc5fa965b74","unit:d1e4e2e4b2bdae6bb027a859c01bd93b7428ed45adc801720ac9375668db7aec","unit:d7425436138b2c46698af19b33f1a9f174d1e22727b784be92c95778e956a481","unit:dc60362d5252fe2fb4605b4f060311334c896b20601544c5b487fe0247856adf","unit:eb727c95530ecaca0e0b66a0c91234041eb5e55b262bb50ccc8bb8bd53434ecd"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b1c4c37becd0a3ce0ded3d15","scopeContentSha256":"1c202d368227801eb77bc6e51b81c3bf9bf49fd14459e58bf33c2c1fca27e765","localRef":"s25"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f","scopeContentSha256":"0c8927e5fc77028278e864261d5b309e1bf96114a7ea8c96e0c7a28e10675dba","localRef":"s17"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l21","originalCandidateId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge:link:19","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l21","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge:link:19","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:b1c4c37becd0a3ce0ded3d15","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l21","source":"s25","target":"s17","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["The physical Coulomb-cone test uses particle states from massless fields and BPS strings, with positivity applied only inside the identified cone."],"challengeStatement":"BPS-string states contribute to reconstructing the physical Coulomb cone, where positivity and boundary tests can be applied.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c758baedbafb89f5b9239e79415bd74ce0de8ed8384f3f0ad1984b96639f41d3","reply.jsonSha256":"21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3ecfc6dda2a3e061e7aac37649c7f0f053bf719f6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f498f0d7ebd9d47d3545140282fd2af05dd824a6aa2294c4b1969be7754de6b0","receipt.jsonSha256":"88737414007b505f0efd94b94fe73010c00c1d298a688bdac0408b020b9bc9ec","normalization.jsonSha256":"ed5d2d478b940b2cd97aa26dc3d777f813fbfe8c553db4bd9bf9a94eb3310b66","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"37e03ff157538fe0a652f94a08187a06d31b472ba1f3d1fb68c6146476776320"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"cda8e63406c657a2d2527808f4cc8c688062dd0c80968d349353cabc6cc0f979","reply.jsonSha256":"8165e73a65a0812ac118afc49e2dddb573c747607c62d7d2d31e62c90d14acfc","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c2c2c6e5948b3468e12a29f3ef7507314ab0e797e5856093d9c66a5d5d9be396","receipt.jsonSha256":"17c4a7604553e0f3de5e628efe0f87972ca2b92ad264f8c1eb77143d29ab8e31","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9a2969c637e8565b30abb7a0bb20676b9ce0754c50f334971a52c3923127fed"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b1c4c37becd0a3ce0ded3d15"},{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f"},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceId":"ev:2e2911efe2aa99dcf542ce53e4bfd71f","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":3331,"textSha256":"fe044a98fc79e764f1bfa2167d527ed55a9a71e5e488bd702c4f344772525a9d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceId":"ev:e43e2b5a5b2a5d6d8d417cac80b63f76","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b82113e5d0345d1188abd0a95be0e94f6ed91617ba29db732d6d60269f435d49","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b1c4c37becd0a3ce0ded3d15"},{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f"},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceId":"ev:2e2911efe2aa99dcf542ce53e4bfd71f","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":3331,"textSha256":"fe044a98fc79e764f1bfa2167d527ed55a9a71e5e488bd702c4f344772525a9d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceId":"ev:e43e2b5a5b2a5d6d8d417cac80b63f76","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b82113e5d0345d1188abd0a95be0e94f6ed91617ba29db732d6d60269f435d49","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d21","originalRef":"l21","status":"route","source":"s25","target":"s17","type":"method_for","title":"Use charged-string states in physical Coulomb-cone tests","rationale":"The paired statements identify BPS-string states as contributions to reconstructing the physical Coulomb cone. This supports the existing direction from the charged-string diagnostics in s25 to the reduction and Coulomb-branch questions in s17.","qualification":"Use the relevant particle states from both massless fields and BPS strings; the string contribution alone is not asserted to determine the cone. Required strings, admissible charges, sector and normalization must be justified. Positivity and boundary tests apply only within the correctly identified physical cone. Preserve the restricted parent theories and T=0 emphasis, and do not infer arbitrary uplift sufficiency or a quantum-gravity completion from passing these diagnostics.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l21","s25","s17"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d21","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify BPS-string states as inputs to the physical Coulomb-cone analysis, supporting s25 as the method provider for that branch of s17. The record also retains massless-field particle states, charge and normalization requirements, and positivity only within the identified physical cone.","refs":["l21","s25","s17"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l21","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l22":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l22","source":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f","target":"q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1","type":"method_for","title":"Apply Coulomb-branch tests beyond anomaly cancellation","rationale":"The Coulomb-branch question in s17 supplies the cross-batch consistency diagnostic for the beyond-anomaly questions in s13.","qualification":"The route uses the stated Coulomb-branch and reduced-state tests, with positivity inside the physical Kähler cone and source-specific spectra, normalization, supersymmetry and parent subsets. Restricted exclusions, including the T=0 emphasis, do not become a universal criterion. Anomaly cancellation is not sufficient for completion, while failed geometric realization can reflect either missing constructions or additional consistency conditions.","evidenceIds":["unit:02dd298620e4d0edea3b1967b2805c4362f55a80a94cd7e4f6e28d5ad27a8ce2","unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","unit:21566519271e2447b13403d6db9c7cfba8d467ae5799e6ce96711b660fdbba79","unit:21adb8beb4946e2b9502b04652a5b53a18232d153501b17a3a45925114705ce3","unit:25496b9946799f8ed1dd7634937fe30fb9526a2b33c9d25bb2144cd397a7b689","unit:35a92bb8d63ec5a432cfc6ee076332948aeed5aa1ae87d7b505ed0056c6ab7d3","unit:464b08b6201ce086f0769d74260c6a8e315cf80261d793fbb7e9140fc48b1e8d","unit:5b5884b2db3e7b991d33967b45e0ee452a4c7eb82b9e8e735d92b622d695d340","unit:657e6fe70b5a726a9aca722e51e57fe75353ae8d619857ddcbb1f968f40b60a1","unit:6bed30e9dc83a29dcdeb6c9cf113a3f78529f70f23863e21680624392e54b6c7","unit:845a751a4e78731b7954a097bc7931c282e51d8def186ab9f57c9aecf9563d68","unit:b5185662f6f84f1252d4ddea936acc4f382810e45d658b5966a5245fd5869d25","unit:b8eab7ef7bca66cd3e1c76b9bcbe1df719b94776d69b505ae2bb043f2131e6df","unit:c2cbcf859ba196c41ba47dd002dfac017ca9988f1af068ca26ac57b3cc1183a3","unit:cd3b50eb7e40564674476e06fca78fa21a6033bc95fa8b8be156a446130626bc","unit:d104d03f21c890c60e82e263d76a5c415f6840f79c40d09591a6cf5f4aec245d","unit:eb727c95530ecaca0e0b66a0c91234041eb5e55b262bb50ccc8bb8bd53434ecd","unit:fd76a1d8357ccac743adb1683b912e9ad554636a918e12f813f8aecd474d419a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f","scopeContentSha256":"0c8927e5fc77028278e864261d5b309e1bf96114a7ea8c96e0c7a28e10675dba","localRef":"s17"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1","scopeContentSha256":"93876315d69f2174aefd5e0fbc52f5a74fc389ca489ba711a61a8b7cb1452985","localRef":"s13"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l22","originalCandidateId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge:link:27","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l22","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge:link:27","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l22","source":"s13","target":"s17","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["The Coulomb-branch question supplies a cross-batch route for consistency beyond anomalies; restricted exclusions do not become a universal criterion."],"challengeStatement":"Reuse the Coulomb-branch question across batches for tests beyond anomalies; its limited exclusions do not become a universal consistency criterion.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c758baedbafb89f5b9239e79415bd74ce0de8ed8384f3f0ad1984b96639f41d3","reply.jsonSha256":"21fe1cb99331d56e7a5296a3ecfc6dda2a3e061e7aac37649c7f0f053bf719f6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f498f0d7ebd9d47d3545140282fd2af05dd824a6aa2294c4b1969be7754de6b0","receipt.jsonSha256":"88737414007b505f0efd94b94fe73010c00c1d298a688bdac0408b020b9bc9ec","normalization.jsonSha256":"ed5d2d478b940b2cd97aa26dc3d777f813fbfe8c553db4bd9bf9a94eb3310b66","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"37e03ff157538fe0a652f94a08187a06d31b472ba1f3d1fb68c6146476776320"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae4cdd4e0e8516e33bac-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"cda8e63406c657a2d2527808f4cc8c688062dd0c80968d349353cabc6cc0f979","reply.jsonSha256":"8165e73a65a0812ac118afc49e2dddb573c747607c62d7d2d31e62c90d14acfc","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c2c2c6e5948b3468e12a29f3ef7507314ab0e797e5856093d9c66a5d5d9be396","receipt.jsonSha256":"17c4a7604553e0f3de5e628efe0f87972ca2b92ad264f8c1eb77143d29ab8e31","normalization.jsonSha256":"a9a2969c637e8565b30abb7a0bb20676b9ce0754c50f334971a52c3923127fed"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1"},{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f"},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceId":"ev:2e2911efe2aa99dcf542ce53e4bfd71f","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":3331,"textSha256":"fe044a98fc79e764f1bfa2167d527ed55a9a71e5e488bd702c4f344772525a9d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceId":"ev:e43e2b5a5b2a5d6d8d417cac80b63f76","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b82113e5d0345d1188abd0a95be0e94f6ed91617ba29db732d6d60269f435d49","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1"},{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f"},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceId":"ev:2e2911efe2aa99dcf542ce53e4bfd71f","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":3331,"textSha256":"fe044a98fc79e764f1bfa2167d527ed55a9a71e5e488bd702c4f344772525a9d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceId":"ev:e43e2b5a5b2a5d6d8d417cac80b63f76","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b82113e5d0345d1188abd0a95be0e94f6ed91617ba29db732d6d60269f435d49","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d22","originalRef":"l22","status":"route","source":"s17","target":"s13","type":"method_for","title":"Apply Coulomb-branch tests beyond anomaly cancellation","rationale":"The Coulomb-branch question in s17 supplies the cross-batch consistency diagnostic for the beyond-anomaly questions in s13.","qualification":"The route uses the stated Coulomb-branch and reduced-state tests, with positivity inside the physical Kähler cone and source-specific spectra, normalization, supersymmetry and parent subsets. Restricted exclusions, including the T=0 emphasis, do not become a universal criterion. Anomaly cancellation is not sufficient for completion, while failed geometric realization can reflect either missing constructions or additional consistency conditions.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l22","s13","s17"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d22","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"s17 supplies the Coulomb-branch diagnostic for the beyond-anomaly consistency questions in s13. The reversed method direction preserves the physical-cone requirement and restricted examples without promoting limited exclusions into a universal criterion.","refs":["l22","s13","s17"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l22","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l23":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l23","source":"q025-candidate-question:75700f88267ddfb782519604","target":"q025-candidate-question:9be0cd89f1a22827c73327de","type":"method_for","title":"Test vacuum uplift through higher- and lower-dimensional matching","rationale":"The matching questions in s11 provide methods for testing uplift terms and stabilized-volume response in the relevant vacuum constructions of s20.","qualification":"Restrict the route to the specified uplift setups, reductions, boundary conditions and condensate assumptions. Leading-order and local semiclassical treatments retain their limits. Ten-dimensional condensate existence is conditional, the perfect-square prescription is proposed, and single-condensate and racetrack alternatives remain distinct. Nilpotent EFT matching is not a complete ten-dimensional construction; integrated constraints and global charge availability are separate checks. Opposing conclusions do not establish a universal uplift obstruction.","evidenceIds":["unit:001fce438a04d5c03cada3212aa2f7f8fe2b7c098f7a05f7d59c401228d1b63e","unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","unit:0ccaa5581bc35d9574f62e5affc59c9e63251fc8ad691318aa8342357a930a81","unit:0d86ee83335cba2f44d57a6fd585405baf97660f9ccba1d20f42ef24e94afedc","unit:0d984ab259ff05da671c13b38119b694e910527e64198b0501347b5108d9f9da","unit:1207056f985a2f152dfe58b2fc4b8148b8d3ef843a2793972033fc78cb928552","unit:12db93fcd7db364da2e8233a53f7284428d51bf5123cea9ed11088568c2244bc","unit:14ded0b84d66359cb409a4ee1625b526a8ec3046bd7df577130bdb2b00e5b435","unit:2446dc41e27cc37d5f3d2ec912b7c17306fa3b36a28f1dd34d54f287d3d4353e","unit:2872c594a4168172335d7da136360f09075bbe8261c7c70ff0c98f91d0767cb4","unit:2949679f28bf5644d49f865e0eafb2b3360da2217571b3b99016198d8af69d78","unit:39ad476c27f9e32412d92843adb8a349360603007a8d67febd2ccf5dc72327ca","unit:39d98c271235587fce3faf17e95bd928f21c43be84ba05dc932b44a0f562a8af","unit:3be427ac2bc79f0d27b1ae938a13f37b0d159056ac7f3763f415e75d968e243f","unit:3dd6efd72de390370d6f1c679a7839b714ed89120c208d0cef6827787454c8a0","unit:41a3eb3b375ce9513ff65f1268a22de0acc55096043e38855cb7c1f4835af30a","unit:4523080919414f4cb7d29d9299283e61fda7f0c912de551b3b95450666e1820a","unit:463b5bea7386e01cced835e8d4cb82ed0f2a579401a891332c2a5348c79a8329","unit:478c397d11929dfaa143d4c812563ae364ed3839c075ee00f7a7e583e236ff1d","unit:4d4f590c322198538803d365d432edd7b7a9bb2e0b342d9fa7dc4b4b7a71f67d","unit:5628827e2d7c1990f9ca06489c8419f3b2f511b1b283c85f66b223412d6d99b1","unit:5b64ece6c89f533778ce8dea24a37e364d83e3c24e20607c2659f3d0e0519b39","unit:5fea2e78e138ffff90571570213b6b33fabcbf9a1b0392746537c516d4f75d6b","unit:7019f8009e0277ea255f569129e483e6b9201cf9c86b5a62e3eb72d77edfffcf","unit:7b2c7e079a55ed6da716e3343bd1d23d12fae9505ffccb481fd396aff762f7d2","unit:8066430d3bd8cdd2ff9aa72ef4a5ffcbc880f424fb070f4275d9173b92ff9a8f","unit:9983778aa8e6e0dd30b3aa9b6dbb566f8f10ccc8dae1aa72abc7d5c9f918d9bd","unit:9a9b4d4170531fbe46a9dd2328792231733936f489d1c5f32e2a85a535497d00","unit:a665ba573c42dc51e4ff821fb93ab0fddc344f8f3e520ab3408b74cf61613d60","unit:afe178a64b9d929be3e09e3d0c6059cdd9d0bc6e1835d23f5aed8e50d6ecdf08","unit:b1814d4cb3b872ce646660af20d2cbca3d69ddd7c23c0eb44d436969727b6317","unit:bc2287fed1d687e940eedcbbb1e830ecbdc9e7204ffa5255d3935091b367877d","unit:bec08a96d0c117b3ff31fe45dd12727c69cf788ca7e32131284ebe7be697aad9","unit:c788e8ca15447d431eb3f9e9ab81c4926bbea86544c4d1267696ace2b0e55df6","unit:caee405bd07632e92ae4641e3eb224ed4652c02e4c94c0e647c1be198031d0e5","unit:ce1f8dd63a55d2456df51d883efb20f293c26d32c588565ec9a619e72ce391e4","unit:ceaf95b231cc3176e28ff6a123bb795d9499f7c00d316a8acfdab9bc3e14ea89","unit:d1826f0f6e7fcd37860602709dc7d22790986aa5aab102d21edf3285990cefdb","unit:d2f52cfe1228d5317e33640425a47f89d246c5310eb7debe4beb660f01427a20","unit:d79efaa50b0d69a670da5d8e7c1792dccc1ea2a6cf29997052165a097f26cfea","unit:d7ee61a75a4eb83a65fc75acde7eceaca1e8963e7225437522dd966de815618c","unit:f24bd6e562f61f44e0a0e6a5428ee32ca7d9e93543d470a0f28ee3b0e5085042"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75700f88267ddfb782519604","scopeContentSha256":"3da338caaf853fd6e5a4129afd2370266a26dc4b6df29487463024bb81aa5da9","localRef":"s11"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9be0cd89f1a22827c73327de","scopeContentSha256":"ade19dcd010cb62857fa010534e85d2cb381a424aac2e9b9e82e1d059d031824","localRef":"s20"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l23","originalCandidateId":"parent-b3f2229cf734fe8c68ce-challenge:link:20","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l23","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b3f2229cf734fe8c68ce-challenge:link:20","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:9be0cd89f1a22827c73327de","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:75700f88267ddfb782519604","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l23","source":"s20","target":"s11","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Higher-dimensional and four-dimensional matching tests uplift terms and volume response within specified approximations."],"challengeStatement":"Higher-dimensional matching tests uplift terms and volume response within the stated reduction and condensate assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b3f2229cf734fe8c68ce-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-b3f2229cf734fe8c68ce-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"52b309da4dff83ed1656877daea9b7c8f61d56456a2951003132817a9b1d4371","reply.jsonSha256":"34dcc22b55939753017cf3f090356f50bd98ebe9694efedcdd4e4dcdb9ba389f","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ef78678862cc787cabd2b92cacd3cb1828d18bece7abb85d6c0441a76c311f0a","receipt.jsonSha256":"2a4e293fac78e1550041786195b2c015e653af40da1572937d20bb60ff9f1030","normalization.jsonSha256":"1475194e354817442c4a23905613705e750f627181db92cb908d9d581b177ed6","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-b3f2229cf734fe8c68ce-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"5db3605891a88bf7d289e0ed18ffa18f43f62f245e2d15b46fb346c3f9e2daba"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-b3f2229cf734fe8c68ce-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"0e900c0321d33786a7245d445eee47c0a45e547ab8bc3f657b0c0e0a22d99983","reply.jsonSha256":"d1ba00dc60a409abdef6495dc8336063423c0af9d2b4023d6d11ef401fee1bfb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"65bc6ee8c52b2454902491564771950cf8a785c097c03c9144bd2bfd27f475ef","receipt.jsonSha256":"4f579ef74bf38002c4b8557782dcbebc6b55309d3080fb76e9df583de5885796","normalization.jsonSha256":"6f4a86adb868a4f00bf92a4dd72c2ec206a213e601e1a8914a8e2771622baea7"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75700f88267ddfb782519604"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75700f88267ddfb782519604"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d23","originalRef":"l23","status":"route","source":"s11","target":"s20","type":"method_for","title":"Test vacuum uplift through higher- and lower-dimensional matching","rationale":"The matching questions in s11 provide methods for testing uplift terms and stabilized-volume response in the relevant vacuum constructions of s20.","qualification":"Restrict the route to the specified uplift setups, reductions, boundary conditions and condensate assumptions. Leading-order and local semiclassical treatments retain their limits. Ten-dimensional condensate existence is conditional, the perfect-square prescription is proposed, and single-condensate and racetrack alternatives remain distinct. Nilpotent EFT matching is not a complete ten-dimensional construction; integrated constraints and global charge availability are separate checks. Opposing conclusions do not establish a universal uplift obstruction.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l23","s20","s11"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d23","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The higher- and lower-dimensional matching questions in s11 supply tests for the relevant uplift constructions in s20. The record retains reduction, boundary and condensate assumptions, distinct stabilization alternatives and opposing conditional conclusions.","refs":["l23","s20","s11"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l23","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l24":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l24","source":"q025-candidate-question:653728198dc0e8a5f2d0110b","target":"q025-candidate-question:9be0cd89f1a22827c73327de","type":"method_for","title":"Use corrected potentials and background tests in stabilization","rationale":"The correction-driven potentials and background-validity questions in s9 contribute methods and checks to the stabilization constructions in s20.","qualification":"Do not impose an antibrane or other separate uplift stage. Correction sectors and static-versus-rolling background questions remain distinct, and both the correction expansion and the background require justification. Corrected extrema are not automatically metastable nonnegative-energy minima. The small loop-corrected cosmological constant remains a proposed mechanism, and the description-level rolling-background question establishes no universal obstruction to static flux backgrounds.","evidenceIds":["unit:001fce438a04d5c03cada3212aa2f7f8fe2b7c098f7a05f7d59c401228d1b63e","unit:0ccaa5581bc35d9574f62e5affc59c9e63251fc8ad691318aa8342357a930a81","unit:0d86ee83335cba2f44d57a6fd585405baf97660f9ccba1d20f42ef24e94afedc","unit:1207056f985a2f152dfe58b2fc4b8148b8d3ef843a2793972033fc78cb928552","unit:12db93fcd7db364da2e8233a53f7284428d51bf5123cea9ed11088568c2244bc","unit:14ded0b84d66359cb409a4ee1625b526a8ec3046bd7df577130bdb2b00e5b435","unit:2446dc41e27cc37d5f3d2ec912b7c17306fa3b36a28f1dd34d54f287d3d4353e","unit:2949679f28bf5644d49f865e0eafb2b3360da2217571b3b99016198d8af69d78","unit:2c2f9bbf1d6521a0e9eaa4058ce65013ebec33f04c693ba881240f2800595e22","unit:39ad476c27f9e32412d92843adb8a349360603007a8d67febd2ccf5dc72327ca","unit:3dd6efd72de390370d6f1c679a7839b714ed89120c208d0cef6827787454c8a0","unit:41a3eb3b375ce9513ff65f1268a22de0acc55096043e38855cb7c1f4835af30a","unit:4523080919414f4cb7d29d9299283e61fda7f0c912de551b3b95450666e1820a","unit:478c397d11929dfaa143d4c812563ae364ed3839c075ee00f7a7e583e236ff1d","unit:4d4f590c322198538803d365d432edd7b7a9bb2e0b342d9fa7dc4b4b7a71f67d","unit:5628827e2d7c1990f9ca06489c8419f3b2f511b1b283c85f66b223412d6d99b1","unit:5b64ece6c89f533778ce8dea24a37e364d83e3c24e20607c2659f3d0e0519b39","unit:5fea2e78e138ffff90571570213b6b33fabcbf9a1b0392746537c516d4f75d6b","unit:7019f8009e0277ea255f569129e483e6b9201cf9c86b5a62e3eb72d77edfffcf","unit:7b2c7e079a55ed6da716e3343bd1d23d12fae9505ffccb481fd396aff762f7d2","unit:8066430d3bd8cdd2ff9aa72ef4a5ffcbc880f424fb070f4275d9173b92ff9a8f","unit:9983778aa8e6e0dd30b3aa9b6dbb566f8f10ccc8dae1aa72abc7d5c9f918d9bd","unit:9a9b4d4170531fbe46a9dd2328792231733936f489d1c5f32e2a85a535497d00","unit:afe178a64b9d929be3e09e3d0c6059cdd9d0bc6e1835d23f5aed8e50d6ecdf08","unit:b1814d4cb3b872ce646660af20d2cbca3d69ddd7c23c0eb44d436969727b6317","unit:ba9523aca69d1a05f2dd3cf148882e1ad5e9bac5a3353059db103a055f4eec61","unit:bc2287fed1d687e940eedcbbb1e830ecbdc9e7204ffa5255d3935091b367877d","unit:bec08a96d0c117b3ff31fe45dd12727c69cf788ca7e32131284ebe7be697aad9","unit:c788e8ca15447d431eb3f9e9ab81c4926bbea86544c4d1267696ace2b0e55df6","unit:ce1f8dd63a55d2456df51d883efb20f293c26d32c588565ec9a619e72ce391e4","unit:ceaf95b231cc3176e28ff6a123bb795d9499f7c00d316a8acfdab9bc3e14ea89","unit:d1826f0f6e7fcd37860602709dc7d22790986aa5aab102d21edf3285990cefdb","unit:d79efaa50b0d69a670da5d8e7c1792dccc1ea2a6cf29997052165a097f26cfea","unit:d7ee61a75a4eb83a65fc75acde7eceaca1e8963e7225437522dd966de815618c","unit:f24bd6e562f61f44e0a0e6a5428ee32ca7d9e93543d470a0f28ee3b0e5085042"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:653728198dc0e8a5f2d0110b","scopeContentSha256":"a931f93418dc2aca22fd2bab5d63e275570d393a50ee3bffe2e6bca8ba15acd3","localRef":"s9"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9be0cd89f1a22827c73327de","scopeContentSha256":"ade19dcd010cb62857fa010534e85d2cb381a424aac2e9b9e82e1d059d031824","localRef":"s20"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l24","originalCandidateId":"parent-b3f2229cf734fe8c68ce-challenge:link:21","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l24","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b3f2229cf734fe8c68ce-challenge:link:21","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:9be0cd89f1a22827c73327de","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:653728198dc0e8a5f2d0110b","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l24","source":"s20","target":"s9","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Correction-driven potentials and background-validity checks connect to construction without requiring an antibrane uplift stage."],"challengeStatement":"Correction-driven potentials and background-validity questions contribute without imposing a separate uplift sector.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b3f2229cf734fe8c68ce-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-b3f2229cf734fe8c68ce-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"52b309da4dff83ed1656877daea9b7c8f61d56456a2951003132817a9b1d4371","reply.jsonSha256":"34dcc22b55939753017cf3f090356f50bd98ebe9694efedcdd4e4dcdb9ba389f","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ef78678862cc787cabd2b92cacd3cb1828d18bece7abb85d6c0441a76c311f0a","receipt.jsonSha256":"2a4e293fac78e1550041786195b2c015e653af40da1572937d20bb60ff9f1030","normalization.jsonSha256":"1475194e354817442c4a23905613705e750f627181db92cb908d9d581b177ed6","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-b3f2229cf734fe8c68ce-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"5db3605891a88bf7d289e0ed18ffa18f43f62f245e2d15b46fb346c3f9e2daba"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-b3f2229cf734fe8c68ce-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"0e900c0321d33786a7245d445eee47c0a45e547ab8bc3f657b0c0e0a22d99983","reply.jsonSha256":"d1ba00dc60a409abdef6495dc8336063423c0af9d2b4023d6d11ef401fee1bfb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"65bc6ee8c52b2454902491564771950cf8a785c097c03c9144bd2bfd27f475ef","receipt.jsonSha256":"4f579ef74bf38002c4b8557782dcbebc6b55309d3080fb76e9df583de5885796","normalization.jsonSha256":"6f4a86adb868a4f00bf92a4dd72c2ec206a213e601e1a8914a8e2771622baea7"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:653728198dc0e8a5f2d0110b"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0611332","sourceId":"ev:8cabf05002b88c7773e7e839f9790bd7","sourceSha256":"6725cdbad9d0b97c4101652d924851cd2b82ec5ba6f2a3332dd1e001bffd27c5","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3d2027ff1a3d74c4bdcc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"64442323426dfe6aed18737127c562a0f0272a25d2bfcade02036d4270b85b5e","pdfPage":4,"start":99,"end":3069,"textSha256":"401716ac6e9773ff0328d80dbd5284f3939f99dd54d81f608bb2b5472809ebd8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0611332","sourceId":"ev:97ecf366ca449b7a20934f827567b04c","sourceSha256":"6725cdbad9d0b97c4101652d924851cd2b82ec5ba6f2a3332dd1e001bffd27c5","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3d2027ff1a3d74c4bdcc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"64442323426dfe6aed18737127c562a0f0272a25d2bfcade02036d4270b85b5e","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":2676,"textSha256":"36457717a7a2c59f1508f169ac2d583e47e46ae90e8e344783dc131995ffa598","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:653728198dc0e8a5f2d0110b"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0611332","sourceId":"ev:8cabf05002b88c7773e7e839f9790bd7","sourceSha256":"6725cdbad9d0b97c4101652d924851cd2b82ec5ba6f2a3332dd1e001bffd27c5","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3d2027ff1a3d74c4bdcc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"64442323426dfe6aed18737127c562a0f0272a25d2bfcade02036d4270b85b5e","pdfPage":4,"start":99,"end":3069,"textSha256":"401716ac6e9773ff0328d80dbd5284f3939f99dd54d81f608bb2b5472809ebd8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/0611332","sourceId":"ev:97ecf366ca449b7a20934f827567b04c","sourceSha256":"6725cdbad9d0b97c4101652d924851cd2b82ec5ba6f2a3332dd1e001bffd27c5","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3d2027ff1a3d74c4bdcc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"64442323426dfe6aed18737127c562a0f0272a25d2bfcade02036d4270b85b5e","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":2676,"textSha256":"36457717a7a2c59f1508f169ac2d583e47e46ae90e8e344783dc131995ffa598","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d24","originalRef":"l24","status":"route","source":"s9","target":"s20","type":"method_for","title":"Use corrected potentials and background tests in stabilization","rationale":"The correction-driven potentials and background-validity questions in s9 contribute methods and checks to the stabilization constructions in s20.","qualification":"Do not impose an antibrane or other separate uplift stage. Correction sectors and static-versus-rolling background questions remain distinct, and both the correction expansion and the background require justification. Corrected extrema are not automatically metastable nonnegative-energy minima. The small loop-corrected cosmological constant remains a proposed mechanism, and the description-level rolling-background question establishes no universal obstruction to static flux backgrounds.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l24","s20","s9"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d24","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Correction-driven potentials and background-validity checks in s9 provide methods for relevant stabilization questions in s20. The record does not impose an extra uplift sector and preserves the separate requirements of correction control, background validity and metastability.","refs":["l24","s20","s9"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l24","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l25":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l25","source":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb","target":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0","type":"method_for","title":"Assess de Sitter geometry through excited-state constructions","rationale":"The excited-state questions in s14 supply a proposed construction route to the de Sitter existence and interpretation questions in s36.","qualification":"Identify the reference configuration source by source and retain finite temporal domains and supporting-field requirements. Displacement of an interacting vacuum is distinct from a free-vacuum coherent state; AdS and supersymmetric Minkowski references and heterotic versus IIB realizations are not identified. Metric matching alone does not construct the full state. The reported exclusion of a weakly coupled dual-IIA static-patch regime remains local. Geometry does not by itself establish a controlled metastable positive-energy vacuum.","evidenceIds":["unit:0331d936c08069563803cebe5d3527498080bf62848a27ba3f499deb4eb96d33","unit:03394bf20ceebe5d8fa665d97dfd6b5e900d27627f13bc5286f807cfb8cacd4f","unit:0a7894cd67c1ab57b2737e741969081e9a796494033d35f595b85bd6f18c0dc2","unit:0b6150c3d467453650138e24f2a15302c5bf52501f03c27f57a09038c8c09495","unit:0c18ad4cd9b05b142b219de867695c608554ca0a995e5ea3b967d3467f853cf0","unit:0cfada55cef2a9abf0e7d7ebf8ce24d1982d6613b658361ae2df64e16ce35818","unit:155b7c31c78bdbac3d824f41ff0ee214b17f742d5fc9ee73c67b08ba6ad985db","unit:188d6db23ffc93e21c63c1d2f3923e71b499f86faf2fe53e61c78ab3bffcc31a","unit:1bf98945ce7be113290fc3726eadf2fef51b4cb3ea546ab8ca43b985e6fbb3d1","unit:283b848c49491032e3df7a7c770ec1d4deabd984d7ce676757f46b2b44afa394","unit:379bb291fe90b19793958a3aeceb3f7f014c42ccc719a204c2b4e039bc559688","unit:40b1df30be01109972682771da6e72d51bc6a03e758da501d850504719a8eb5e","unit:49aa5609978dbf0d3e81cfdd55e33e8e4b4866793a24db7ebbdcd8f68c24ddfc","unit:5b2aae28d28e84fb4856d2743e199cb798f7ae995fef3dbc5c6c538b23732215","unit:6608803896cc22be3bb13ddb07582dce3034062c6c3672d137a4feedb7bbc85f","unit:6ee5ff699d48c244284bb3ea68a9a8a9a177946effb68ba75af12334af67efa0","unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","unit:82e073b9ece91b103df2c2ff406fd4cddb090b8745cc48a49b5dbe05189c8764","unit:8c36ce59b59e2e547af818a3e8183807d26108092e3ba75bf4dfb532f37c8eee","unit:9214beb73af7c6709ac195bbefa77d6146aee7d6cf25d8b6b243d417d0024383","unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","unit:a265ef02a67606ac501a5c6c33eafdbaade2c49f426a0aa2c5adbdcf7e9906e8","unit:a891711fce939807aeca71cbc920440485c69abb757068f6624b8f2e49049524","unit:abed7f7a15f00df2901178a63e7b88b901f9e85bcff3092d8375fce922152c08","unit:abff1bab4b954b7f7816aa9134a757eab66e24f4bb44f57bd1e20b3a14646ad2","unit:b687dc671d8c89ac72beffa877c5c1bf53f6cbb35e846e008018f6f799912627","unit:b917d5f832bb2bb4eae66cf23862dfa977547883c15f7da206d402fe7462e339","unit:bf9cbeeef58cb882cda011b856aa3521221620fd0c14a53f8bc382edac0e4a4b","unit:c435074c5c68619bf5c1b8e015028945c4ad637037d768379168188cc7fdce91","unit:c4e61744b580c42fed0988346d2807ac2cc7c161ee79d8a98847ba1b6e32cca5","unit:c95deaf1d68ce408fb48775f104ab6251ddb23d737b188db070d505f7a0fa2d9","unit:cfb072d78bcd8a8e97ee32a59eae1f9721e43fc04ff40df2f423adb804cb1e44","unit:d341373dafe1731f3a6faf7a45eca16fcbd8eeb5d6eda23121000f54e300cd8c","unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","unit:f7dacde5e3ec1cd1a0ec3c942186b9014318356ac97fa62126074ac816fa49c7","unit:fbab42a792c075a76d2902dcefc778a04fb8424b03e6ec4757aa6c7b2b57a51e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb","scopeContentSha256":"6d0c9fd51c5f6983ed3baffb4047622300a4073f1af6fbadfe5f4d17524a003a","localRef":"s14"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0","scopeContentSha256":"98599099741cf51a8964f861a3213d784da1a73c893632c783d5bcab7f34e301","localRef":"s36"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l25","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:17","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l25","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:17","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l25","source":"s36","target":"s14","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["An excited-state realization is a proposed route to geometry and supporting fields, with additional state-construction requirements."],"challengeStatement":"Excited-state realization is a proposed route to geometry with additional supporting-field and state requirements.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0"},{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb"},{"ref":"e19","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:f37c0f2edf0adb46762cc9557eb3f5a4","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2242,"textSha256":"8c059144d3bc7b45fd5f63cedadbc5cbddadad9ffac4ac58e3dfa00750e4bc59","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e17","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:cb33d0c41a6c7d92cda8764d8939682e","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b1c796e53c76313afbd71bb1026e5cc47caeb53d085fc65f731ef124cdb617d9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0"},{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb"},{"ref":"e19","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:f37c0f2edf0adb46762cc9557eb3f5a4","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2242,"textSha256":"8c059144d3bc7b45fd5f63cedadbc5cbddadad9ffac4ac58e3dfa00750e4bc59","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e17","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:cb33d0c41a6c7d92cda8764d8939682e","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b1c796e53c76313afbd71bb1026e5cc47caeb53d085fc65f731ef124cdb617d9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d25","originalRef":"l25","status":"route","source":"s14","target":"s36","type":"method_for","title":"Assess de Sitter geometry through excited-state constructions","rationale":"The excited-state questions in s14 supply a proposed construction route to the de Sitter existence and interpretation questions in s36.","qualification":"Identify the reference configuration source by source and retain finite temporal domains and supporting-field requirements. Displacement of an interacting vacuum is distinct from a free-vacuum coherent state; AdS and supersymmetric Minkowski references and heterotic versus IIB realizations are not identified. Metric matching alone does not construct the full state. The reported exclusion of a weakly coupled dual-IIA static-patch regime remains local. Geometry does not by itself establish a controlled metastable positive-energy vacuum.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l25","s36","s14"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d25","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"s14 supplies a proposed excited-state construction route to the de Sitter questions in s36. The record preserves reference-state, supporting-field, temporal and coupling qualifications and does not equate metric matching with a complete state or controlled metastable vacuum.","refs":["l25","s36","s14"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l25","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l26":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l26","source":"q025-candidate-question:4f3e9266372d423e4c62a10b","target":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0","type":"method_for","title":"Test de Sitter existence with the extrapolated bosonic-string action","rationale":"The massless-amplitude action derivation and separately qualified extrapolated existence test in s5 supply a proposed methodological route to the de Sitter questions in s36.","qualification":"Restrict the route to bosonic string, the one-loop two-derivative action and the stated beyond-critical-dimension extrapolation. Weak coupling and small curvature are proposed control requirements; they do not independently validate the extrapolation. Action-derived terms and extrapolated solutions have different evidential roles. Neither coefficients nor the extrapolation argument are supplied here, and no heterotic or type II construction, metastability or verified string vacuum is inferred.","evidenceIds":["unit:0331d936c08069563803cebe5d3527498080bf62848a27ba3f499deb4eb96d33","unit:03394bf20ceebe5d8fa665d97dfd6b5e900d27627f13bc5286f807cfb8cacd4f","unit:0cfada55cef2a9abf0e7d7ebf8ce24d1982d6613b658361ae2df64e16ce35818","unit:0e737425a32644086b18219525253fe1adf9a178cea35c1e0686e07fbdd51a52","unit:155b7c31c78bdbac3d824f41ff0ee214b17f742d5fc9ee73c67b08ba6ad985db","unit:188d6db23ffc93e21c63c1d2f3923e71b499f86faf2fe53e61c78ab3bffcc31a","unit:1bf98945ce7be113290fc3726eadf2fef51b4cb3ea546ab8ca43b985e6fbb3d1","unit:283b848c49491032e3df7a7c770ec1d4deabd984d7ce676757f46b2b44afa394","unit:379bb291fe90b19793958a3aeceb3f7f014c42ccc719a204c2b4e039bc559688","unit:40b1df30be01109972682771da6e72d51bc6a03e758da501d850504719a8eb5e","unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","unit:8c36ce59b59e2e547af818a3e8183807d26108092e3ba75bf4dfb532f37c8eee","unit:9214beb73af7c6709ac195bbefa77d6146aee7d6cf25d8b6b243d417d0024383","unit:a265ef02a67606ac501a5c6c33eafdbaade2c49f426a0aa2c5adbdcf7e9906e8","unit:abed7f7a15f00df2901178a63e7b88b901f9e85bcff3092d8375fce922152c08","unit:abff1bab4b954b7f7816aa9134a757eab66e24f4bb44f57bd1e20b3a14646ad2","unit:b687dc671d8c89ac72beffa877c5c1bf53f6cbb35e846e008018f6f799912627","unit:bf9cbeeef58cb882cda011b856aa3521221620fd0c14a53f8bc382edac0e4a4b","unit:c95deaf1d68ce408fb48775f104ab6251ddb23d737b188db070d505f7a0fa2d9","unit:cfb072d78bcd8a8e97ee32a59eae1f9721e43fc04ff40df2f423adb804cb1e44","unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","unit:f7dacde5e3ec1cd1a0ec3c942186b9014318356ac97fa62126074ac816fa49c7","unit:fbab42a792c075a76d2902dcefc778a04fb8424b03e6ec4757aa6c7b2b57a51e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4f3e9266372d423e4c62a10b","scopeContentSha256":"7bea38da03bd9dfbbfd581691db2d358ed2c7323296d18d5255731ac788d9097","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0","scopeContentSha256":"98599099741cf51a8964f861a3213d784da1a73c893632c783d5bcab7f34e301","localRef":"s36"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l26","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:19","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l26","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:19","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:4f3e9266372d423e4c62a10b","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l26","source":"s36","target":"s5","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["The bosonic-string question combines action derivation with a separately qualified extrapolated existence test."],"challengeStatement":"The bosonic-string source combines action derivation with a separately qualified extrapolated existence test.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0"},{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4f3e9266372d423e4c62a10b"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0"},{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4f3e9266372d423e4c62a10b"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d26","originalRef":"l26","status":"route","source":"s5","target":"s36","type":"method_for","title":"Test de Sitter existence with the extrapolated bosonic-string action","rationale":"The massless-amplitude action derivation and separately qualified extrapolated existence test in s5 supply a proposed methodological route to the de Sitter questions in s36.","qualification":"Restrict the route to bosonic string, the one-loop two-derivative action and the stated beyond-critical-dimension extrapolation. Weak coupling and small curvature are proposed control requirements; they do not independently validate the extrapolation. Action-derived terms and extrapolated solutions have different evidential roles. Neither coefficients nor the extrapolation argument are supplied here, and no heterotic or type II construction, metastability or verified string vacuum is inferred.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l26","s36","s5"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d26","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The action derivation and qualified existence test in s5 provide a proposed method for the de Sitter question in s36. The record correctly separates amplitude-derived terms from the beyond-critical-dimension extrapolation and leaves that extrapolation's validity unresolved.","refs":["l26","s36","s5"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l26","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l27":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l27","source":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","target":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb","type":"related_question","title":"Examine the separate excited-state construction question","rationale":"Both statements connect effective-control analysis with a separate state-interpretation component of the proposed quantum description. They do not establish that either question supplies a method for solving the other.","qualification":"Keep this connection within the relevant shared proposals, without making state construction a universal condition for every compactification in s4. Correction counting alone constructs neither a state nor a Wilsonian integration. Internal time dependence does not guarantee effective control, and metric expectation-value matching does not supply a complete state or supporting-field solution. Reference backgrounds, temporal limits and Type IIB versus dual-IIA coupling regimes remain source-specific.","evidenceIds":["unit:07dbefdad760ee366f46d17ea86b866308b5ddf8cad29cd0e7980d7f2cbb0d61","unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","unit:0a7894cd67c1ab57b2737e741969081e9a796494033d35f595b85bd6f18c0dc2","unit:0b6150c3d467453650138e24f2a15302c5bf52501f03c27f57a09038c8c09495","unit:0c18ad4cd9b05b142b219de867695c608554ca0a995e5ea3b967d3467f853cf0","unit:49aa5609978dbf0d3e81cfdd55e33e8e4b4866793a24db7ebbdcd8f68c24ddfc","unit:510edff028a5f664da0cb7c6be171d88f882faf4377576f9dd4af798db136ad8","unit:5b2aae28d28e84fb4856d2743e199cb798f7ae995fef3dbc5c6c538b23732215","unit:5b4ab28915bcdf209205327b53d8e0b664c1aa0661388501e07eb7012e9d1bb2","unit:5d44db45b25d450de0329358dd75fed0db273e0034f8088dee99ea6acba04fd2","unit:607daedfc9bbd0023f28c127b2edf0128da4d654fbaa907d69a02d06a9158526","unit:6608803896cc22be3bb13ddb07582dce3034062c6c3672d137a4feedb7bbc85f","unit:6ee5ff699d48c244284bb3ea68a9a8a9a177946effb68ba75af12334af67efa0","unit:825db4a7e38497cb127b363e0473f9658979fae1aca1d36f8dbc52e781672f7f","unit:82e073b9ece91b103df2c2ff406fd4cddb090b8745cc48a49b5dbe05189c8764","unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","unit:a736e013133d28f5fd654ef36aa354b9e8188a932e10e6ae274157b7fa46cd44","unit:a891711fce939807aeca71cbc920440485c69abb757068f6624b8f2e49049524","unit:b727802ba56e21331fa342c9d04ac8e2913970f3e5f349c34285dfd38a813d90","unit:b917d5f832bb2bb4eae66cf23862dfa977547883c15f7da206d402fe7462e339","unit:c435074c5c68619bf5c1b8e015028945c4ad637037d768379168188cc7fdce91","unit:c4e61744b580c42fed0988346d2807ac2cc7c161ee79d8a98847ba1b6e32cca5","unit:d341373dafe1731f3a6faf7a45eca16fcbd8eeb5d6eda23121000f54e300cd8c","unit:fc300ffd0a3125ffe40301e238bc0e77d713c2b597a9543cb1aa772f69dd4d79"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","scopeContentSha256":"109144fa8a095198b384a24792b3bc35aae4f403a9291361948e15c8eb93da90","localRef":"s4"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb","scopeContentSha256":"6d0c9fd51c5f6983ed3baffb4047622300a4073f1af6fbadfe5f4d17524a003a","localRef":"s14"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l27","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:45","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l27","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:45","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l27","source":"s4","target":"s14","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["State interpretation is a separate component of the proposed quantum description, not a consequence of correction counting."],"challengeStatement":"A state-based description supplies separate quantum questions; correction counting alone does not construct the state.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c"},{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb"},{"ref":"e17","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:cb33d0c41a6c7d92cda8764d8939682e","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b1c796e53c76313afbd71bb1026e5cc47caeb53d085fc65f731ef124cdb617d9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e19","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:f37c0f2edf0adb46762cc9557eb3f5a4","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2242,"textSha256":"8c059144d3bc7b45fd5f63cedadbc5cbddadad9ffac4ac58e3dfa00750e4bc59","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c"},{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb"},{"ref":"e17","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:cb33d0c41a6c7d92cda8764d8939682e","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b1c796e53c76313afbd71bb1026e5cc47caeb53d085fc65f731ef124cdb617d9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e19","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:f37c0f2edf0adb46762cc9557eb3f5a4","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2242,"textSha256":"8c059144d3bc7b45fd5f63cedadbc5cbddadad9ffac4ac58e3dfa00750e4bc59","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d27","originalRef":"l27","status":"route","source":"s4","target":"s14","type":"related_question","title":"Examine the separate excited-state construction question","rationale":"Both statements connect effective-control analysis with a separate state-interpretation component of the proposed quantum description. They do not establish that either question supplies a method for solving the other.","qualification":"Keep this connection within the relevant shared proposals, without making state construction a universal condition for every compactification in s4. Correction counting alone constructs neither a state nor a Wilsonian integration. Internal time dependence does not guarantee effective control, and metric expectation-value matching does not supply a complete state or supporting-field solution. Reference backgrounds, temporal limits and Type IIB versus dual-IIA coupling regimes remain source-specific.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l27","s4","s14"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d27","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original statements connect effective control with a separate state-interpretation component, without establishing a method supplied by either endpoint for the other. The related-question route preserves this connection and the explicit insufficiency of correction counting for state construction or Wilsonian integration.","refs":["l27","s4","s14"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-10-proposal","parent-orientation-10-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration. Original reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed.","A conditional method or application route establishes a navigation role, not the success, reliability or universal applicability of the underlying proposal.","Unsupplied per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed. In particular, no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used to justify the Quintom-bounce route.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. This review performs no admission, canonical-identity, global DAG, proof, observational-validation or later-status check."],"challenge":["This challenge uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original route statements and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locator, original review file or omitted attribution note was newly read.","The s* and l* references identify supplied context. Historical reading counts and descendant coverage remain attributed; they are not new empirical evidence or independent corroboration.","Supported records retain their exact proposed wording and qualifications by reference. Conditional navigation does not certify a method's success, a construction's existence or universal applicability.","Source dates, description-only support, negative tests and unresolved constructions remain in force. Missing per-unit qualifications cannot be reconstructed, and no boosted-energy Hamiltonian conclusion is used here.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity or global DAG checks, independently verify results, or establish current observational or later scientific status."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-10:l27","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l0":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l0","source":"q025-candidate-question:9e44e8dff4c26ab1b806c4f8","target":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e","type":"method_for","title":"Screen de Sitter existence with positive-stationarity restrictions","rationale":"Both original statements identify positive-stationarity restrictions as candidate screens for the existence question. The diagnostic question therefore supplies methods to the existence question.","qualification":"Apply only the source-specific classical approximations, ingredients, dimensions and background restrictions. Restricted scalar sectors and integrated equations do not establish all required stationarity conditions or solve the complete higher-dimensional equations. Passing a screen establishes neither a solution nor stability or string-theory control.","evidenceIds":["unit:0823baa35b5b7bdf26b2bfba1f69f431bbd96f2e14713f032b8c581c14ff473e","unit:0a6c9fea36792130242c6f5b058ee8b4e907cd8d263b361b6f4543680ea22d83","unit:140b97d4103e6d2fd0b45ae1c21ba7d063ebae641c53aa1f0b981adc1da54cd9","unit:19cc265cd1902342f30d0330691e3c60bb41358247234a1f9cc831f2698d6ffd","unit:2027e83a940e5b33aa420f66078d8870674e086b128681836d17a22558a0c35c","unit:316858fee8f2d65ce7b8638be56ee59b0dd15914a349a047ece929ec3e6c5057","unit:33180cddbf29413b88ea541ad9a79801acd2b253f9cab8dcd6958b6020d70698","unit:3e9e3133e3aff72e01bee1e76e0c897fdd0ed7609e7a1852e6ef18d02f729824","unit:3ea0e41d9e950fc38e9e98d567fd61e2c09a51575375855e8fc38dab76a74a02","unit:41214a545a81a191b636493fe52812bac54313a4910374ffce82899bd05f591f","unit:42599fbdc11d4a522bc83012b5ad4e07c6381b22d8f0c5a59133227c2c5e8016","unit:44a8ac8e3bc10269af503494db9ad67d09d57ea789ce9a6434e98fa1cd596f29","unit:5b72e5574bbd34020b553e7927c2e7ebdb7408ea580f696556e0607593e143c5","unit:5fdf6b6c0a0cc7419f01f2ce6d10c49fcaee31d1081ed57fca3dd8c1a7fc7df9","unit:647d7a9749503efcfb48e4f4aa48f537b3fdf81f69373eaf1d51ab7f2f536e30","unit:658bb32db81303a97f6e5733008059b8c97e42fc9237ac462b4a463e4fdc12c3","unit:6a189d5879711e985cb123ba5ac95b90e6aaba4335a3b77b80be35f6ad26330e","unit:7deba9638e5fe66aa1a1b58fad8c1b4cc1f97419df310ed813fab20273ee773b","unit:81d6ae180f0fc0d1d901a11693eed9bb75ffff826320fdba51a47c15351aef64","unit:824e4a71e18ebd9d2e0162be9fd83fa782938db4baddc6087e257d68b41030b2","unit:87ffd46d059021e1825e28d84314d1b978890347b6ab12c1009bf3bc8ac9dd69","unit:8ad924b91b8a1bcd9067950fc6156f3db7a9a031b1b0ace350163a1f4cc67fd4","unit:8ba5f51b779c5833f4716366c2330952a8ed8c681408dbcc73ba55f2d70a0d42","unit:92dfbdc3775c4d6d029d8c9ee9f14ff9938b9fa875220fc9f9513495fad11ab4","unit:9486eba84a9df8a386f3b6cc1b62b45dfaaac6d08dd6b6d9cd59a0c30af5d98f","unit:9705ad3d292e33395fde36eb3ebdf125da55c529e7231576925cea450628a092","unit:97b4ed0dec13b3296be26c37294def890c0242d94d9680097cefe9ca2963e065","unit:996055b3141c7e105f0f09cc2ec40b1e0227605c49908822a58fb08c1cbdd1ef","unit:9d3585299192b172ec02132c8d17b96d59f3f60f82e30ff8d76b56a5462ebf1f","unit:a90ab1d025d45b3f9af4cd537ecd0bca7a2aff733ff4f5b6da342a4e174cb5dc","unit:aaca7f61b701c1dc9d30ed7fa60119f29e82426bf99ea6896e77883faceeae67","unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","unit:c819731843def5df5d6c475dbd8ef1c2e5fe25b711c6156e5806c1d00c4e479a","unit:cb1fdf169d94d0179508f3e7a1c385fa5c835d55e56a53a7ddc7286fbf82970a","unit:d39dba941b173d72107d1aefb761508d6dd147847af3925ca135fb7e930d2135","unit:d66812dc042118aecf6f38bc5842c40f3d2d7db0fa75260effccaf27044c4798","unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","unit:e0cdb353ad023d473f95c8c7c4a898a27281dbbc710e181fe8bdb4e77214908a","unit:e721ef79ffe50fef650089a8b215682886ea4cbd50302ff6984ee0758aa9c310","unit:ebcce2e9c0fc487c4491cb251b57648fae3869c2b4c4bd5b9e93ff8f6cc3351a","unit:ecec83bd62de4b786661045f9ea61d3f60c54f643435bed0f7866528ed39d06f","unit:ee7417d0aed5b039c55df66abd077a4832e8e269c881c403520585d190b07285","unit:f55a29e44d18ca3f00585f195b874af79519bea5a7c48463675f46bf3e29ea5c","unit:f913dd0b93896b4614fc8a99aabbf17a67c5676ae76e02d93912760fa68de41e","unit:f999157fb39a8d970f67a5e4a2e1cf1bc55edb3b41a4b1d371e69c2ebab48c10","unit:fc300ffd0a3125ffe40301e238bc0e77d713c2b597a9543cb1aa772f69dd4d79"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9e44e8dff4c26ab1b806c4f8","scopeContentSha256":"c60141132495379295a225dfd91f69ac1c55e5ab3c5a4234f41830d3b9b2858b","localRef":"s21"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e","scopeContentSha256":"28ab16bb1cb4ddf52aa40e94cc60abc953abccb93eee1a8741f6a0e7c9e65f32","localRef":"s19"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l0","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:20","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l0","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:20","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:9e44e8dff4c26ab1b806c4f8","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l0","source":"s19","target":"s21","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Positive-stationarity restrictions test the existence problem without solving all higher-dimensional equations."],"challengeStatement":"Positive-stationarity restrictions screen candidates without solving all higher-dimensional equations.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e"},{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9e44e8dff4c26ab1b806c4f8"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2004.00030","sourceId":"ev:8e4f2f39cf51b6876528f7517d9a7c5c","sourceSha256":"72285ce41685876cd61583783ff41e660693fbfab89a59fcf7cb6a9c9510baff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d3d92aaecc5f322a70e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fdd4204cf9de2ce9e77d1735820f719a6596f82c7156ddda7d46f7199ef7c34","pdfPage":10,"start":0,"end":2783,"textSha256":"5e1e873a3f8705d9babb03e3a3228df1b22890d6f21bcf113a3434ba54e152d1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e15","kind":"primary","paperId":"2004.00030","sourceId":"ev:c5a6654eec2bbd4f8ec6f3b91ac6e312","sourceSha256":"72285ce41685876cd61583783ff41e660693fbfab89a59fcf7cb6a9c9510baff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d3d92aaecc5f322a70e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fdd4204cf9de2ce9e77d1735820f719a6596f82c7156ddda7d46f7199ef7c34","pdfPage":6,"start":1064,"end":3355,"textSha256":"313cd21e222c34f99ce070b0c250224d2adc399593a811d730139d022481930e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e"},{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9e44e8dff4c26ab1b806c4f8"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2004.00030","sourceId":"ev:8e4f2f39cf51b6876528f7517d9a7c5c","sourceSha256":"72285ce41685876cd61583783ff41e660693fbfab89a59fcf7cb6a9c9510baff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d3d92aaecc5f322a70e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fdd4204cf9de2ce9e77d1735820f719a6596f82c7156ddda7d46f7199ef7c34","pdfPage":10,"start":0,"end":2783,"textSha256":"5e1e873a3f8705d9babb03e3a3228df1b22890d6f21bcf113a3434ba54e152d1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e15","kind":"primary","paperId":"2004.00030","sourceId":"ev:c5a6654eec2bbd4f8ec6f3b91ac6e312","sourceSha256":"72285ce41685876cd61583783ff41e660693fbfab89a59fcf7cb6a9c9510baff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d3d92aaecc5f322a70e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fdd4204cf9de2ce9e77d1735820f719a6596f82c7156ddda7d46f7199ef7c34","pdfPage":6,"start":1064,"end":3355,"textSha256":"313cd21e222c34f99ce070b0c250224d2adc399593a811d730139d022481930e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d0","originalRef":"l0","status":"route","source":"s21","target":"s19","type":"method_for","title":"Screen de Sitter existence with positive-stationarity restrictions","rationale":"Both original statements identify positive-stationarity restrictions as candidate screens for the existence question. The diagnostic question therefore supplies methods to the existence question.","qualification":"Apply only the source-specific classical approximations, ingredients, dimensions and background restrictions. Restricted scalar sectors and integrated equations do not establish all required stationarity conditions or solve the complete higher-dimensional equations. Passing a screen establishes neither a solution nor stability or string-theory control.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l0","s21","s19"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify positive-stationarity restrictions as screening methods for existence, supporting s21 → s19. The qualification preserves the distinction between screening candidates and establishing complete solutions, stability or control.","refs":["l0","s21","s19"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l1":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l1","source":"q025-candidate-question:1af1f76a68247aa1f31f97b5","target":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e","type":"method_for","title":"Apply dimension-specific existence and selected-sector stability screens","rationale":"The necessary existence and selected-sector stability tests supply restricted methods for assessing candidate compactifications, rather than receiving a method from the broader existence question.","qualification":"Keep the four-dimensional parallel Dp/Op sources of one size distinct from the higher-dimensional orientifold analysis, and distinguish general internal manifolds from group-manifold, constant-flux restrictions. The higher-dimensional analysis assumes calibrated sources and excludes KK monopoles and fractional Wilson lines; its surviving D=5,6 cases and D>6 exclusion retain those restrictions. Its volume and dilaton variables are not canonically normalized. Passing necessary inequalities or a two- or three-field stability test establishes neither complete equations nor full metastability; the endpoint retains its dated 21 November 2011 version.","evidenceIds":["unit:0a6c9fea36792130242c6f5b058ee8b4e907cd8d263b361b6f4543680ea22d83","unit:18e6b118e8e5b947204bd0483aede08ea42e9b93fbe8e8fc68b8ef1a7818389d","unit:19cc265cd1902342f30d0330691e3c60bb41358247234a1f9cc831f2698d6ffd","unit:2027e83a940e5b33aa420f66078d8870674e086b128681836d17a22558a0c35c","unit:33180cddbf29413b88ea541ad9a79801acd2b253f9cab8dcd6958b6020d70698","unit:3e9e3133e3aff72e01bee1e76e0c897fdd0ed7609e7a1852e6ef18d02f729824","unit:3ea0e41d9e950fc38e9e98d567fd61e2c09a51575375855e8fc38dab76a74a02","unit:42599fbdc11d4a522bc83012b5ad4e07c6381b22d8f0c5a59133227c2c5e8016","unit:5e345ae19ffde267e9877634c9c24f0651d42b9ba5d0f28070824123449ec388","unit:647d7a9749503efcfb48e4f4aa48f537b3fdf81f69373eaf1d51ab7f2f536e30","unit:658bb32db81303a97f6e5733008059b8c97e42fc9237ac462b4a463e4fdc12c3","unit:6a189d5879711e985cb123ba5ac95b90e6aaba4335a3b77b80be35f6ad26330e","unit:7deba9638e5fe66aa1a1b58fad8c1b4cc1f97419df310ed813fab20273ee773b","unit:87ffd46d059021e1825e28d84314d1b978890347b6ab12c1009bf3bc8ac9dd69","unit:8ad924b91b8a1bcd9067950fc6156f3db7a9a031b1b0ace350163a1f4cc67fd4","unit:92dfbdc3775c4d6d029d8c9ee9f14ff9938b9fa875220fc9f9513495fad11ab4","unit:9486eba84a9df8a386f3b6cc1b62b45dfaaac6d08dd6b6d9cd59a0c30af5d98f","unit:9d3585299192b172ec02132c8d17b96d59f3f60f82e30ff8d76b56a5462ebf1f","unit:a90ab1d025d45b3f9af4cd537ecd0bca7a2aff733ff4f5b6da342a4e174cb5dc","unit:aaca7f61b701c1dc9d30ed7fa60119f29e82426bf99ea6896e77883faceeae67","unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","unit:c819731843def5df5d6c475dbd8ef1c2e5fe25b711c6156e5806c1d00c4e479a","unit:cb1fdf169d94d0179508f3e7a1c385fa5c835d55e56a53a7ddc7286fbf82970a","unit:d39dba941b173d72107d1aefb761508d6dd147847af3925ca135fb7e930d2135","unit:d66812dc042118aecf6f38bc5842c40f3d2d7db0fa75260effccaf27044c4798","unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","unit:e0cdb353ad023d473f95c8c7c4a898a27281dbbc710e181fe8bdb4e77214908a","unit:ebcce2e9c0fc487c4491cb251b57648fae3869c2b4c4bd5b9e93ff8f6cc3351a","unit:ecec83bd62de4b786661045f9ea61d3f60c54f643435bed0f7866528ed39d06f","unit:ee7417d0aed5b039c55df66abd077a4832e8e269c881c403520585d190b07285","unit:f55a29e44d18ca3f00585f195b874af79519bea5a7c48463675f46bf3e29ea5c","unit:f913dd0b93896b4614fc8a99aabbf17a67c5676ae76e02d93912760fa68de41e","unit:fc300ffd0a3125ffe40301e238bc0e77d713c2b597a9543cb1aa772f69dd4d79"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1af1f76a68247aa1f31f97b5","scopeContentSha256":"d35395d7bda75d8974d750a504aab3d64b45fefb9783177448ee4969cacdbabf","localRef":"s1"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e","scopeContentSha256":"28ab16bb1cb4ddf52aa40e94cc60abc953abccb93eee1a8741f6a0e7c9e65f32","localRef":"s19"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l1","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:22","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l1","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:22","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:1af1f76a68247aa1f31f97b5","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l1","source":"s19","target":"s1","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Necessary existence and retained-sector stability screens remain dimension- and source-specific."],"challengeStatement":"Necessary existence and selected-sector stability tests retain their dimension and source restrictions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e"},{"ref":"x5_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1af1f76a68247aa1f31f97b5"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceId":"ev:312e7c9b9407e9b31b89cae868fd37c0","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":18,"start":0,"end":2616,"textSha256":"e57bbf55f9044d1a02c08998a7d159b167ed543d71d827f3196d2e0754a4921d","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceId":"ev:6ea480f48f5ab09b145be824be8ccf6a","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":24,"start":0,"end":2393,"textSha256":"7acd082ee3e9e900956c821a92d42e1c577a29fb1e96e11d3ae0a0da13917856","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e"},{"ref":"x5_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1af1f76a68247aa1f31f97b5"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceId":"ev:312e7c9b9407e9b31b89cae868fd37c0","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":18,"start":0,"end":2616,"textSha256":"e57bbf55f9044d1a02c08998a7d159b167ed543d71d827f3196d2e0754a4921d","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceId":"ev:6ea480f48f5ab09b145be824be8ccf6a","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":24,"start":0,"end":2393,"textSha256":"7acd082ee3e9e900956c821a92d42e1c577a29fb1e96e11d3ae0a0da13917856","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d1","originalRef":"l1","status":"route","source":"s1","target":"s19","type":"method_for","title":"Apply dimension-specific existence and selected-sector stability screens","rationale":"The necessary existence and selected-sector stability tests supply restricted methods for assessing candidate compactifications, rather than receiving a method from the broader existence question.","qualification":"Keep the four-dimensional parallel Dp/Op sources of one size distinct from the higher-dimensional orientifold analysis, and distinguish general internal manifolds from group-manifold, constant-flux restrictions. The higher-dimensional analysis assumes calibrated sources and excludes KK monopoles and fractional Wilson lines; its surviving D=5,6 cases and D>6 exclusion retain those restrictions. Its volume and dilaton variables are not canonically normalized. Passing necessary inequalities or a two- or three-field stability test establishes neither complete equations nor full metastability; the endpoint retains its dated 21 November 2011 version.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l1","s1","s19"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The dimension- and source-specific tests in s1 supply methods for s19. The record retains the separate four-dimensional and higher-dimensional setups, source exclusions, normalization convention and necessary-only character of the tests.","refs":["l1","s1","s19"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l2":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l2","source":"q025-candidate-question:b50626a3b93bc714e127c1c9","target":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e","type":"method_for","title":"Use flux equations and scalar-sector classifications to test existence","rationale":"Both original statements assign the testing role to flux equations and scalar-sector restrictions. These provide source-specific existence and stability diagnostics for the broader ingredient question.","qualification":"Retain each theory's allowed sources, flux equations, geometric ansatz, dimension and retained fields. Isotropic, fourteen-real-scalar, universal volume–dilaton and higher-dimensional analyses are different tests. A positive retained Hessian does not establish full-spectrum stability, and necessary conditions do not establish complete solutions. Minkowski comparisons remain separate, and classical restrictions do not transfer automatically to quantum-corrected settings.","evidenceIds":["unit:0a6c9fea36792130242c6f5b058ee8b4e907cd8d263b361b6f4543680ea22d83","unit:19cc265cd1902342f30d0330691e3c60bb41358247234a1f9cc831f2698d6ffd","unit:2027e83a940e5b33aa420f66078d8870674e086b128681836d17a22558a0c35c","unit:21bb5d5e644002c9edbd92f4e91f050765fc4057f7cad9dabe75a134d29b1cf3","unit:2418bd0a670dbfdc597edb1bcec1af12e7c24e76bd981c11c4e26e5aa635720f","unit:24b211ccf3ae6623c69cc174b3981a2604640c93853a6a5981df23ba36eaae3b","unit:33180cddbf29413b88ea541ad9a79801acd2b253f9cab8dcd6958b6020d70698","unit:3e9e3133e3aff72e01bee1e76e0c897fdd0ed7609e7a1852e6ef18d02f729824","unit:3ea0e41d9e950fc38e9e98d567fd61e2c09a51575375855e8fc38dab76a74a02","unit:42599fbdc11d4a522bc83012b5ad4e07c6381b22d8f0c5a59133227c2c5e8016","unit:438e7232514957a45dc7e5ad3d91029f89179417a4a032963532df5ba220fe01","unit:48b614e4e8d10d91b394757a3fea41b09398342cdb09bcc5272e50625f87bd97","unit:57f01a091ccf32ee4692408da23908215330cbd0b65c90017e10a71a0d0879d8","unit:5d5e4243a11bf45e1b62d0056e7a15f8f05ff040b01a2653bb5cd5548ac13a2c","unit:605d6727b634ed6fa6ea2a68164e80f8add95e6052ebd26872317f94b4eda209","unit:60a0907b6441966f69bce2c177d4e6b87e86ec1415fc4893a29e1eb14e0587a6","unit:647d7a9749503efcfb48e4f4aa48f537b3fdf81f69373eaf1d51ab7f2f536e30","unit:658bb32db81303a97f6e5733008059b8c97e42fc9237ac462b4a463e4fdc12c3","unit:6a189d5879711e985cb123ba5ac95b90e6aaba4335a3b77b80be35f6ad26330e","unit:6d77433ecbf100dccf3bd726b241a39e2674e8d893226d6a081200efc085e62e","unit:6de353eadfcc48b1364461c825c71fc1a7db4f81f3e8f04769b3da96c888bd99","unit:7deba9638e5fe66aa1a1b58fad8c1b4cc1f97419df310ed813fab20273ee773b","unit:87ffd46d059021e1825e28d84314d1b978890347b6ab12c1009bf3bc8ac9dd69","unit:8ad924b91b8a1bcd9067950fc6156f3db7a9a031b1b0ace350163a1f4cc67fd4","unit:92dfbdc3775c4d6d029d8c9ee9f14ff9938b9fa875220fc9f9513495fad11ab4","unit:9486eba84a9df8a386f3b6cc1b62b45dfaaac6d08dd6b6d9cd59a0c30af5d98f","unit:9d3585299192b172ec02132c8d17b96d59f3f60f82e30ff8d76b56a5462ebf1f","unit:9dbe06002dbe22ee96631efbe90da07057b0d530348d252a1203d601249b8533","unit:9e7a86a5dc1f81177274f4219e00d4fc9a0837f2bdd80922a6387b97cd9fedc8","unit:a90ab1d025d45b3f9af4cd537ecd0bca7a2aff733ff4f5b6da342a4e174cb5dc","unit:aaca7f61b701c1dc9d30ed7fa60119f29e82426bf99ea6896e77883faceeae67","unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","unit:af0c4052f92bcf492f354a3df9f184068daad11b80465d8131664adeaa5e9cfa","unit:b3f367f65edbb9071507677f74fce3f7be1e6318cea71b608e7098bcc956f4d3","unit:b7a2d007f0ba3749c9cf3ec205e7c29179408e0a8ecfb303d6b60c0f7a831d6d","unit:c1a851cb34e3ac819cabdbb3d4f72e7f68f9e58280b4733438a80263da71d772","unit:c819731843def5df5d6c475dbd8ef1c2e5fe25b711c6156e5806c1d00c4e479a","unit:c97c5e6bec2800f88eb2fc8356a1946c9432289c61aaade8d555a4e4df4dabf4","unit:cb1fdf169d94d0179508f3e7a1c385fa5c835d55e56a53a7ddc7286fbf82970a","unit:d1997e9ba80ee25bc96872e1c5d3a7a3936f3888e03733a3da4445fabcd938f7","unit:d39dba941b173d72107d1aefb761508d6dd147847af3925ca135fb7e930d2135","unit:d66812dc042118aecf6f38bc5842c40f3d2d7db0fa75260effccaf27044c4798","unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","unit:e0cdb353ad023d473f95c8c7c4a898a27281dbbc710e181fe8bdb4e77214908a","unit:e44aa7ccdb20bfeb6d2025f3f3828a5f515f82b225b681005c475d4b9585bea7","unit:ebcce2e9c0fc487c4491cb251b57648fae3869c2b4c4bd5b9e93ff8f6cc3351a","unit:ecec83bd62de4b786661045f9ea61d3f60c54f643435bed0f7866528ed39d06f","unit:ee7417d0aed5b039c55df66abd077a4832e8e269c881c403520585d190b07285","unit:f55a29e44d18ca3f00585f195b874af79519bea5a7c48463675f46bf3e29ea5c","unit:f913dd0b93896b4614fc8a99aabbf17a67c5676ae76e02d93912760fa68de41e","unit:f931b9abe1a238cfcdf6b049f1f652f8d23248e68cc5bdeb4318ee990a395ea6","unit:fc300ffd0a3125ffe40301e238bc0e77d713c2b597a9543cb1aa772f69dd4d79"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b50626a3b93bc714e127c1c9","scopeContentSha256":"8710eba696ebe424f94660c653ade9aa602e8435549cb1c4f7b4871315977012","localRef":"s28"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e","scopeContentSha256":"28ab16bb1cb4ddf52aa40e94cc60abc953abccb93eee1a8741f6a0e7c9e65f32","localRef":"s19"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l2","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:23","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l2","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:23","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:b50626a3b93bc714e127c1c9","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l2","source":"s19","target":"s28","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Flux equations and scalar-sector restrictions supply additional existence and stability tests with different retained fields."],"challengeStatement":"Flux equations and scalar-sector classifications supply source-specific restrictions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e"},{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b50626a3b93bc714e127c1c9"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f9f42d3b7057ade29815e0e"},{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b50626a3b93bc714e127c1c9"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d2","originalRef":"l2","status":"route","source":"s28","target":"s19","type":"method_for","title":"Use flux equations and scalar-sector classifications to test existence","rationale":"Both original statements assign the testing role to flux equations and scalar-sector restrictions. These provide source-specific existence and stability diagnostics for the broader ingredient question.","qualification":"Retain each theory's allowed sources, flux equations, geometric ansatz, dimension and retained fields. Isotropic, fourteen-real-scalar, universal volume–dilaton and higher-dimensional analyses are different tests. A positive retained Hessian does not establish full-spectrum stability, and necessary conditions do not establish complete solutions. Minkowski comparisons remain separate, and classical restrictions do not transfer automatically to quantum-corrected settings.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l2","s28","s19"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Flux equations and retained-sector classifications provide the stated existence diagnostics, supporting s28 → s19. Different field sectors, dimensions and source assumptions remain distinct, without promoting retained-sector stability or classical restrictions to broader conclusions.","refs":["l2","s28","s19"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l3":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l3","source":"q025-candidate-question:9e44e8dff4c26ab1b806c4f8","target":"q025-candidate-question:f2d0592b334c1261e690dd61","type":"method_for","title":"Recast specified classical no-go arguments as slope inequalities","rationale":"The original statements explicitly describe classical no-go arguments being recast into slope inequalities. In that stated use, the no-go question supplies a method to the slope-bound question, so the endpoint order is retained.","qualification":"This applies only to the specified classical arguments that admit the recasting, with their potential restrictions, retained fields, scalar metric, normalization and external dimension. It does not convert every stationarity test into a gradient bound or extend asymptotic results through uncontrolled corrections. The target's TCC comparisons, unresolved general EFT derivation and conditional WGC-saturated membrane proposal are separate questions, not consequences of this route.","evidenceIds":["unit:0823baa35b5b7bdf26b2bfba1f69f431bbd96f2e14713f032b8c581c14ff473e","unit:140b97d4103e6d2fd0b45ae1c21ba7d063ebae641c53aa1f0b981adc1da54cd9","unit:316858fee8f2d65ce7b8638be56ee59b0dd15914a349a047ece929ec3e6c5057","unit:41214a545a81a191b636493fe52812bac54313a4910374ffce82899bd05f591f","unit:44a8ac8e3bc10269af503494db9ad67d09d57ea789ce9a6434e98fa1cd596f29","unit:4f2a971b36d05224e3f5f9ef1dd6894761c5737430882b124a415201687623aa","unit:5b72e5574bbd34020b553e7927c2e7ebdb7408ea580f696556e0607593e143c5","unit:5fdf6b6c0a0cc7419f01f2ce6d10c49fcaee31d1081ed57fca3dd8c1a7fc7df9","unit:7deba9638e5fe66aa1a1b58fad8c1b4cc1f97419df310ed813fab20273ee773b","unit:81d6ae180f0fc0d1d901a11693eed9bb75ffff826320fdba51a47c15351aef64","unit:824e4a71e18ebd9d2e0162be9fd83fa782938db4baddc6087e257d68b41030b2","unit:8ba5f51b779c5833f4716366c2330952a8ed8c681408dbcc73ba55f2d70a0d42","unit:9486eba84a9df8a386f3b6cc1b62b45dfaaac6d08dd6b6d9cd59a0c30af5d98f","unit:9705ad3d292e33395fde36eb3ebdf125da55c529e7231576925cea450628a092","unit:97b4ed0dec13b3296be26c37294def890c0242d94d9680097cefe9ca2963e065","unit:996055b3141c7e105f0f09cc2ec40b1e0227605c49908822a58fb08c1cbdd1ef","unit:d39dba941b173d72107d1aefb761508d6dd147847af3925ca135fb7e930d2135","unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","unit:e721ef79ffe50fef650089a8b215682886ea4cbd50302ff6984ee0758aa9c310","unit:f999157fb39a8d970f67a5e4a2e1cf1bc55edb3b41a4b1d371e69c2ebab48c10"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9e44e8dff4c26ab1b806c4f8","scopeContentSha256":"c60141132495379295a225dfd91f69ac1c55e5ab3c5a4234f41830d3b9b2858b","localRef":"s21"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f2d0592b334c1261e690dd61","scopeContentSha256":"16b75970c2ea0f031740d4b3af9df830930d3033dda4e5345471fd25fbc32020","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l3","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:46","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l3","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:46","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:9e44e8dff4c26ab1b806c4f8","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:f2d0592b334c1261e690dd61","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l3","source":"s21","target":"s38","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Some classical no-go arguments are recast as slope inequalities using the appropriate scalar metric and normalization."],"challengeStatement":"Specified classical no-go arguments are recast as slope inequalities with the appropriate scalar metric and normalization.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9e44e8dff4c26ab1b806c4f8"},{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f2d0592b334c1261e690dd61"},{"ref":"e15","kind":"primary","paperId":"2004.00030","sourceId":"ev:c5a6654eec2bbd4f8ec6f3b91ac6e312","sourceSha256":"72285ce41685876cd61583783ff41e660693fbfab89a59fcf7cb6a9c9510baff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d3d92aaecc5f322a70e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fdd4204cf9de2ce9e77d1735820f719a6596f82c7156ddda7d46f7199ef7c34","pdfPage":6,"start":1064,"end":3355,"textSha256":"313cd21e222c34f99ce070b0c250224d2adc399593a811d730139d022481930e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2004.00030","sourceId":"ev:8e4f2f39cf51b6876528f7517d9a7c5c","sourceSha256":"72285ce41685876cd61583783ff41e660693fbfab89a59fcf7cb6a9c9510baff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d3d92aaecc5f322a70e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fdd4204cf9de2ce9e77d1735820f719a6596f82c7156ddda7d46f7199ef7c34","pdfPage":10,"start":0,"end":2783,"textSha256":"5e1e873a3f8705d9babb03e3a3228df1b22890d6f21bcf113a3434ba54e152d1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9e44e8dff4c26ab1b806c4f8"},{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f2d0592b334c1261e690dd61"},{"ref":"e15","kind":"primary","paperId":"2004.00030","sourceId":"ev:c5a6654eec2bbd4f8ec6f3b91ac6e312","sourceSha256":"72285ce41685876cd61583783ff41e660693fbfab89a59fcf7cb6a9c9510baff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d3d92aaecc5f322a70e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fdd4204cf9de2ce9e77d1735820f719a6596f82c7156ddda7d46f7199ef7c34","pdfPage":6,"start":1064,"end":3355,"textSha256":"313cd21e222c34f99ce070b0c250224d2adc399593a811d730139d022481930e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2004.00030","sourceId":"ev:8e4f2f39cf51b6876528f7517d9a7c5c","sourceSha256":"72285ce41685876cd61583783ff41e660693fbfab89a59fcf7cb6a9c9510baff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d3d92aaecc5f322a70e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fdd4204cf9de2ce9e77d1735820f719a6596f82c7156ddda7d46f7199ef7c34","pdfPage":10,"start":0,"end":2783,"textSha256":"5e1e873a3f8705d9babb03e3a3228df1b22890d6f21bcf113a3434ba54e152d1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d3","originalRef":"l3","status":"route","source":"s21","target":"s38","type":"method_for","title":"Recast specified classical no-go arguments as slope inequalities","rationale":"The original statements explicitly describe classical no-go arguments being recast into slope inequalities. In that stated use, the no-go question supplies a method to the slope-bound question, so the endpoint order is retained.","qualification":"This applies only to the specified classical arguments that admit the recasting, with their potential restrictions, retained fields, scalar metric, normalization and external dimension. It does not convert every stationarity test into a gradient bound or extend asymptotic results through uncontrolled corrections. The target's TCC comparisons, unresolved general EFT derivation and conditional WGC-saturated membrane proposal are separate questions, not consequences of this route.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l3","s21","s38"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Here the original reasoning specifically runs from classical no-go arguments to their slope-inequality reformulation, supporting the retained s21 → s38 method direction. The qualification correctly limits this use and leaves TCC comparisons, the general EFT derivation and the membrane proposal separate.","refs":["l3","s21","s38"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l4":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l4","source":"q025-candidate-question:6ab6e19333e148a30affb029","target":"q025-candidate-question:f2d0592b334c1261e690dd61","type":"method_for","title":"Determine conditional slope coefficients from scaling and field geometry","rationale":"Scaling and scalar geometry supply the methodological inputs for conditional slope coefficients. Both original statements support this direction without asserting a universal gradient law.","qualification":"The required scaling inequality must hold for the particular potential and selected field directions. Retain the scalar metric, Planck normalization, external dimension and classical or asymptotic regime; corrections outside that regime may invalidate the inequality. The endpoint reports missing potential, kinetic-normalization and dimension context in the lecture material, so this route supplies no reconstructed numerical coefficient. It neither completes the general EFT derivation nor removes the separate WGC-saturation premise of the membrane proposal.","evidenceIds":["unit:316858fee8f2d65ce7b8638be56ee59b0dd15914a349a047ece929ec3e6c5057","unit:4f2a971b36d05224e3f5f9ef1dd6894761c5737430882b124a415201687623aa","unit:5b72e5574bbd34020b553e7927c2e7ebdb7408ea580f696556e0607593e143c5","unit:5fdf6b6c0a0cc7419f01f2ce6d10c49fcaee31d1081ed57fca3dd8c1a7fc7df9","unit:7deba9638e5fe66aa1a1b58fad8c1b4cc1f97419df310ed813fab20273ee773b","unit:81d6ae180f0fc0d1d901a11693eed9bb75ffff826320fdba51a47c15351aef64","unit:8b0cf6f7810410e63f7ac36968cbd9a00a0a8ff1b04135ac542fa56acb7d30a4","unit:91a166320176900f4dfab7e1e0d5fcc0b4ff7da01c2cd3552d2b9b186e3b4740","unit:9486eba84a9df8a386f3b6cc1b62b45dfaaac6d08dd6b6d9cd59a0c30af5d98f","unit:9705ad3d292e33395fde36eb3ebdf125da55c529e7231576925cea450628a092","unit:c9ada184a2c5ad7991e680530dba6e49dec382293554f1f700c568aae69f12ea","unit:d39dba941b173d72107d1aefb761508d6dd147847af3925ca135fb7e930d2135","unit:d6e3caa70830ddf91eba65026020e2b77e6963ec2e947d7a7be161d2b464468c","unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6ab6e19333e148a30affb029","scopeContentSha256":"ec93c95809bd34031670c5e29fedf6611ea2b7632909ec0aef504be4a738e5b1","localRef":"s13"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f2d0592b334c1261e690dd61","scopeContentSha256":"16b75970c2ea0f031740d4b3af9df830930d3033dda4e5345471fd25fbc32020","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l4","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:47","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l4","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:47","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:f2d0592b334c1261e690dd61","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:6ab6e19333e148a30affb029","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l4","source":"s38","target":"s13","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Scaling and field geometry explain conditional slope coefficients without establishing a universal gradient law."],"challengeStatement":"Scaling and field geometry determine conditional slope coefficients without establishing a universal gradient law.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f2d0592b334c1261e690dd61"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6ab6e19333e148a30affb029"},{"ref":"e15","kind":"primary","paperId":"2004.00030","sourceId":"ev:c5a6654eec2bbd4f8ec6f3b91ac6e312","sourceSha256":"72285ce41685876cd61583783ff41e660693fbfab89a59fcf7cb6a9c9510baff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d3d92aaecc5f322a70e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fdd4204cf9de2ce9e77d1735820f719a6596f82c7156ddda7d46f7199ef7c34","pdfPage":6,"start":1064,"end":3355,"textSha256":"313cd21e222c34f99ce070b0c250224d2adc399593a811d730139d022481930e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f2d0592b334c1261e690dd61"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6ab6e19333e148a30affb029"},{"ref":"e15","kind":"primary","paperId":"2004.00030","sourceId":"ev:c5a6654eec2bbd4f8ec6f3b91ac6e312","sourceSha256":"72285ce41685876cd61583783ff41e660693fbfab89a59fcf7cb6a9c9510baff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d3d92aaecc5f322a70e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fdd4204cf9de2ce9e77d1735820f719a6596f82c7156ddda7d46f7199ef7c34","pdfPage":6,"start":1064,"end":3355,"textSha256":"313cd21e222c34f99ce070b0c250224d2adc399593a811d730139d022481930e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d4","originalRef":"l4","status":"route","source":"s13","target":"s38","type":"method_for","title":"Determine conditional slope coefficients from scaling and field geometry","rationale":"Scaling and scalar geometry supply the methodological inputs for conditional slope coefficients. Both original statements support this direction without asserting a universal gradient law.","qualification":"The required scaling inequality must hold for the particular potential and selected field directions. Retain the scalar metric, Planck normalization, external dimension and classical or asymptotic regime; corrections outside that regime may invalidate the inequality. The endpoint reports missing potential, kinetic-normalization and dimension context in the lecture material, so this route supplies no reconstructed numerical coefficient. It neither completes the general EFT derivation nor removes the separate WGC-saturation premise of the membrane proposal.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l4","s13","s38"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Scaling and field geometry supply the methodological inputs to the slope-coefficient question, supporting s13 → s38. The record preserves the required potential inequality, metric and normalization dependence, asymptotic limits and unavailable numerical context.","refs":["l4","s13","s38"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l5":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l5","source":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","target":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44","type":"method_for","title":"Use effective potentials and correction estimates to assess de Sitter constructions","rationale":"Effective potentials, symmetry constraints and correction estimates supply methods for the parent question's construction and reliability tests. Their usefulness across batches does not establish common assumptions across constructions.","qualification":"Keep perturbative, nonperturbative, warped and antibrane effective descriptions distinct, with their field content, supersymmetry-breaking scales and reliability conditions. Breaking a scaling symmetry need not remove every no-scale property. Nilpotent-multiplet descriptions, reported correction estimates and numerical examples do not certify universal truncation validity, source realization or control. Removing one universal tachyon does not establish full stability, and the parent inherits rather than independently verifies descendant coverage.","evidenceIds":["unit:0331d936c08069563803cebe5d3527498080bf62848a27ba3f499deb4eb96d33","unit:03394bf20ceebe5d8fa665d97dfd6b5e900d27627f13bc5286f807cfb8cacd4f","unit:0c18ad4cd9b05b142b219de867695c608554ca0a995e5ea3b967d3467f853cf0","unit:81d6ae180f0fc0d1d901a11693eed9bb75ffff826320fdba51a47c15351aef64","unit:8c36ce59b59e2e547af818a3e8183807d26108092e3ba75bf4dfb532f37c8eee","unit:9214beb73af7c6709ac195bbefa77d6146aee7d6cf25d8b6b243d417d0024383","unit:a83c7372568e19dc70aae371bcbbf7df811fef4d7a2530a020b971ba3928d48e","unit:abed7f7a15f00df2901178a63e7b88b901f9e85bcff3092d8375fce922152c08","unit:b7a2d007f0ba3749c9cf3ec205e7c29179408e0a8ecfb303d6b60c0f7a831d6d","unit:bf9cbeeef58cb882cda011b856aa3521221620fd0c14a53f8bc382edac0e4a4b","unit:cfb072d78bcd8a8e97ee32a59eae1f9721e43fc04ff40df2f423adb804cb1e44","unit:ebcce2e9c0fc487c4491cb251b57648fae3869c2b4c4bd5b9e93ff8f6cc3351a","unit:ecec83bd62de4b786661045f9ea61d3f60c54f643435bed0f7866528ed39d06f","unit:f7dacde5e3ec1cd1a0ec3c942186b9014318356ac97fa62126074ac816fa49c7"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","scopeContentSha256":"dc667e1c6331e506dae8bfb90994b6e1469c8c2828b9eb96c93630d236fa3791","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44","scopeContentSha256":"f7451bdf519a5e3b3a89e6e6722e0ae0f8660a0ad25db5e32ecba81abae841eb","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l5","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:3","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l5","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:3","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l5","source":"s39","target":"s30","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Effective potentials, symmetry constraints and correction estimates support construction and reliability tests across batches."],"challengeStatement":"Effective potentials, symmetries and correction estimates support construction and reliability tests across batches.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2006.06694","sourceId":"ev:615509c571019b29b2d54e9a7bdc5305","sourceSha256":"e27707ef3e215c6674cfbef932dbe0043683a628f6ea6d2a8f8f3325a58b02e1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/89479c7ca668eaa45d02/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07d58cc9dea6a89a7cca2486ad0db7affc033b8aa930c1f217b71a2f1413d624","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1944,"textSha256":"050f54d3255a416d86f8f93252354ce998113764368ca42713a558c81b0ee88f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"2006.06694","sourceId":"ev:949459711915fd92a88361f011bf2dd9","sourceSha256":"e27707ef3e215c6674cfbef932dbe0043683a628f6ea6d2a8f8f3325a58b02e1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/89479c7ca668eaa45d02/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07d58cc9dea6a89a7cca2486ad0db7affc033b8aa930c1f217b71a2f1413d624","pdfPage":72,"start":100,"end":2266,"textSha256":"f89a1cbf0f4493e304ad6aa12e0ff114d4e885830f92c1de61bb643d5308baab","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"c0","kind":"attributed_child_review"},{"ref":"c3","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2006.06694","sourceId":"ev:615509c571019b29b2d54e9a7bdc5305","sourceSha256":"e27707ef3e215c6674cfbef932dbe0043683a628f6ea6d2a8f8f3325a58b02e1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/89479c7ca668eaa45d02/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07d58cc9dea6a89a7cca2486ad0db7affc033b8aa930c1f217b71a2f1413d624","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1944,"textSha256":"050f54d3255a416d86f8f93252354ce998113764368ca42713a558c81b0ee88f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"2006.06694","sourceId":"ev:949459711915fd92a88361f011bf2dd9","sourceSha256":"e27707ef3e215c6674cfbef932dbe0043683a628f6ea6d2a8f8f3325a58b02e1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/89479c7ca668eaa45d02/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07d58cc9dea6a89a7cca2486ad0db7affc033b8aa930c1f217b71a2f1413d624","pdfPage":72,"start":100,"end":2266,"textSha256":"f89a1cbf0f4493e304ad6aa12e0ff114d4e885830f92c1de61bb643d5308baab","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"c0","kind":"attributed_child_review"},{"ref":"c3","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d5","originalRef":"l5","status":"route","source":"s30","target":"s39","type":"method_for","title":"Use effective potentials and correction estimates to assess de Sitter constructions","rationale":"Effective potentials, symmetry constraints and correction estimates supply methods for the parent question's construction and reliability tests. Their usefulness across batches does not establish common assumptions across constructions.","qualification":"Keep perturbative, nonperturbative, warped and antibrane effective descriptions distinct, with their field content, supersymmetry-breaking scales and reliability conditions. Breaking a scaling symmetry need not remove every no-scale property. Nilpotent-multiplet descriptions, reported correction estimates and numerical examples do not certify universal truncation validity, source realization or control. Removing one universal tachyon does not establish full stability, and the parent inherits rather than independently verifies descendant coverage.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l5","s30","s39"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The effective-potential methods in s30 serve the construction and reliability targets in s39. The record preserves distinct mechanisms and reliability conditions, without treating cross-batch usefulness or inherited coverage as universal applicability or independent verification.","refs":["l5","s30","s39"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l6":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l6","source":"q025-candidate-question:3f86a58f13196b89db0f4537","target":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","type":"method_for","title":"Organize effective-potential calculations with flux representations and scalar geometry","rationale":"Potential representations and scalar geometry provide calculational inputs to effective-potential reliability and stabilization questions. Both original statements place the method at s5.","qualification":"Retain the generalized-flux, universal-hypermultiplet and classical IIA settings separately, including two-derivative and source-specific asymptotic restrictions. Bare fluxes are distinct from axion-dependent orbits, and generic index ranges must not be replaced by specialized ones. The endpoint's imported Appendix B potential does not supply its unavailable derivation, equation images, quantitative error bounds or a completed exclusion inequality. Writing or organizing a potential does not certify omitted corrections, stability or a controlled vacuum.","evidenceIds":["unit:0331d936c08069563803cebe5d3527498080bf62848a27ba3f499deb4eb96d33","unit:03394bf20ceebe5d8fa665d97dfd6b5e900d27627f13bc5286f807cfb8cacd4f","unit:20a0bca2c1a0822b37872eb53521ef0cf4b2bcd44404e2ef9cf7bdebd5273011","unit:24b211ccf3ae6623c69cc174b3981a2604640c93853a6a5981df23ba36eaae3b","unit:48b614e4e8d10d91b394757a3fea41b09398342cdb09bcc5272e50625f87bd97","unit:57f01a091ccf32ee4692408da23908215330cbd0b65c90017e10a71a0d0879d8","unit:5d5e4243a11bf45e1b62d0056e7a15f8f05ff040b01a2653bb5cd5548ac13a2c","unit:605d6727b634ed6fa6ea2a68164e80f8add95e6052ebd26872317f94b4eda209","unit:656e2f21948f2ab3678894ee6a02fa2f6baea87a2ee7b9a7201b1a74cce79724","unit:6d77433ecbf100dccf3bd726b241a39e2674e8d893226d6a081200efc085e62e","unit:8c36ce59b59e2e547af818a3e8183807d26108092e3ba75bf4dfb532f37c8eee","unit:9214beb73af7c6709ac195bbefa77d6146aee7d6cf25d8b6b243d417d0024383","unit:99685fab52e8b7d57ba151c9242cc04532ca941de14458e5fd1da862146c2a05","unit:9e7a86a5dc1f81177274f4219e00d4fc9a0837f2bdd80922a6387b97cd9fedc8","unit:aaeea2e7b3e0dbb44a4b72426688bf32370ee848f1048de7b76a9ff3a64931a6","unit:abed7f7a15f00df2901178a63e7b88b901f9e85bcff3092d8375fce922152c08","unit:bf9cbeeef58cb882cda011b856aa3521221620fd0c14a53f8bc382edac0e4a4b","unit:c97c5e6bec2800f88eb2fc8356a1946c9432289c61aaade8d555a4e4df4dabf4","unit:cfb072d78bcd8a8e97ee32a59eae1f9721e43fc04ff40df2f423adb804cb1e44","unit:e44aa7ccdb20bfeb6d2025f3f3828a5f515f82b225b681005c475d4b9585bea7","unit:f7dacde5e3ec1cd1a0ec3c942186b9014318356ac97fa62126074ac816fa49c7"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3f86a58f13196b89db0f4537","scopeContentSha256":"bd51d437b61b0ab4463cb6ca96ab159ea921c4be06f7a72bd29b4e5041387fe3","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","scopeContentSha256":"dc667e1c6331e506dae8bfb90994b6e1469c8c2828b9eb96c93630d236fa3791","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l6","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:37","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l6","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:37","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:3f86a58f13196b89db0f4537","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l6","source":"s30","target":"s5","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Potential representations and scalar geometry supply calculational inputs without certifying a controlled vacuum."],"challengeStatement":"Potential representations and scalar geometry supply calculational inputs without certifying a controlled vacuum.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578"},{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3f86a58f13196b89db0f4537"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"2004.00030","sourceId":"ev:01542975d4127ca8070cf84ca3cbb327","sourceSha256":"72285ce41685876cd61583783ff41e660693fbfab89a59fcf7cb6a9c9510baff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d3d92aaecc5f322a70e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fdd4204cf9de2ce9e77d1735820f719a6596f82c7156ddda7d46f7199ef7c34","pdfPage":11,"start":0,"end":2100,"textSha256":"68de0d545fdbc93ef9c18a6074734d0eeaa60097c917307b877e8afa4cb4c4a4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2006.06694","sourceId":"ev:615509c571019b29b2d54e9a7bdc5305","sourceSha256":"e27707ef3e215c6674cfbef932dbe0043683a628f6ea6d2a8f8f3325a58b02e1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/89479c7ca668eaa45d02/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07d58cc9dea6a89a7cca2486ad0db7affc033b8aa930c1f217b71a2f1413d624","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1944,"textSha256":"050f54d3255a416d86f8f93252354ce998113764368ca42713a558c81b0ee88f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578"},{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3f86a58f13196b89db0f4537"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"2004.00030","sourceId":"ev:01542975d4127ca8070cf84ca3cbb327","sourceSha256":"72285ce41685876cd61583783ff41e660693fbfab89a59fcf7cb6a9c9510baff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d3d92aaecc5f322a70e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fdd4204cf9de2ce9e77d1735820f719a6596f82c7156ddda7d46f7199ef7c34","pdfPage":11,"start":0,"end":2100,"textSha256":"68de0d545fdbc93ef9c18a6074734d0eeaa60097c917307b877e8afa4cb4c4a4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2006.06694","sourceId":"ev:615509c571019b29b2d54e9a7bdc5305","sourceSha256":"e27707ef3e215c6674cfbef932dbe0043683a628f6ea6d2a8f8f3325a58b02e1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/89479c7ca668eaa45d02/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07d58cc9dea6a89a7cca2486ad0db7affc033b8aa930c1f217b71a2f1413d624","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1944,"textSha256":"050f54d3255a416d86f8f93252354ce998113764368ca42713a558c81b0ee88f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d6","originalRef":"l6","status":"route","source":"s5","target":"s30","type":"method_for","title":"Organize effective-potential calculations with flux representations and scalar geometry","rationale":"Potential representations and scalar geometry provide calculational inputs to effective-potential reliability and stabilization questions. Both original statements place the method at s5.","qualification":"Retain the generalized-flux, universal-hypermultiplet and classical IIA settings separately, including two-derivative and source-specific asymptotic restrictions. Bare fluxes are distinct from axion-dependent orbits, and generic index ranges must not be replaced by specialized ones. The endpoint's imported Appendix B potential does not supply its unavailable derivation, equation images, quantitative error bounds or a completed exclusion inequality. Writing or organizing a potential does not certify omitted corrections, stability or a controlled vacuum.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l6","s5","s30"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements place the calculational inputs at s5, supporting its methodological direction toward s30. The qualification retains flux and index conventions, regime restrictions and the unavailable Appendix B derivation and bounds, without certifying a controlled vacuum.","refs":["l6","s5","s30"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l7":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l7","source":"q025-candidate-question:524e2f5f36cb09c5956aa59f","target":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","type":"application_of","title":"Connect stabilization and de Sitter constructions to their effective-potential methods","rationale":"The original statements say that effective-potential methods enter distinct stabilization and de Sitter construction mechanisms. The construction question is the application and the effective-potential question is the methodological destination.","qualification":"The connection applies where a construction uses the specified effective-potential methods; it does not identify all uplift, instanton, higher-curvature, Casimir or racetrack mechanisms. Retain each model's sources, fields, corrections and scales. The orientifold hypermultiplet example concerns a subsector, and the perturbative D-term example is illustrative and incomplete. Critical points, stability of retained fields, full metastability, string consistency and parametric control remain separate claims.","evidenceIds":["unit:0331d936c08069563803cebe5d3527498080bf62848a27ba3f499deb4eb96d33","unit:03394bf20ceebe5d8fa665d97dfd6b5e900d27627f13bc5286f807cfb8cacd4f","unit:148e545792b1782dc240c5aa9a1996d599b189b76551bd6ae529c44c5de3287d","unit:186da3931017fddf28e82cb04ec8a81de3e2815d1d2a18599fc38542d9f7372a","unit:19639e9d1a90593d9080f4b0ab212960dac48dda0834342e34cd41bfe0299c81","unit:20a0bca2c1a0822b37872eb53521ef0cf4b2bcd44404e2ef9cf7bdebd5273011","unit:225686e3711b95bfbd209681b2e29b34f4e29cd5ec94708d24883f8435cca1e4","unit:236ce2dea48a6e22b6625810d3dfa2632b27d3d3fae698df1db7c222b3122f56","unit:2949679f28bf5644d49f865e0eafb2b3360da2217571b3b99016198d8af69d78","unit:38997e5df360084877a82441d2efda3f1dfe0775be6c5afee3145f7d7ad2ff6d","unit:478c397d11929dfaa143d4c812563ae364ed3839c075ee00f7a7e583e236ff1d","unit:47f773fcfe90206eafa826d73747a827d229e104d4ba7564e03d86d7088adf66","unit:656e2f21948f2ab3678894ee6a02fa2f6baea87a2ee7b9a7201b1a74cce79724","unit:682769a11087d220ac9c92a615d1dd5c31c74cb2d93bd5d551e9dd4b88f7943f","unit:8c36ce59b59e2e547af818a3e8183807d26108092e3ba75bf4dfb532f37c8eee","unit:9214beb73af7c6709ac195bbefa77d6146aee7d6cf25d8b6b243d417d0024383","unit:99685fab52e8b7d57ba151c9242cc04532ca941de14458e5fd1da862146c2a05","unit:9b3a25ae335112ce544d932aef8a713a361ac3bb3d4edd2c88402c4bab50752e","unit:9b6fdbcf01ba7a005355c082ea13f8654a43b320d1b004eafa30ab864f211235","unit:9dbe06002dbe22ee96631efbe90da07057b0d530348d252a1203d601249b8533","unit:abed7f7a15f00df2901178a63e7b88b901f9e85bcff3092d8375fce922152c08","unit:ade68997314b20e6fa12b920c3f53cca37dadcc9b6d6b8eab510c7dba0aff90d","unit:b0f54b3023614bced88e047d69903a371546cfdc2bc84e3a648ce3e91b3210b5","unit:bf9cbeeef58cb882cda011b856aa3521221620fd0c14a53f8bc382edac0e4a4b","unit:c603cdddc0e5d6bf1a0a8c8337758b51066bd515ecf8d1319100408fd5ff2b91","unit:cfb072d78bcd8a8e97ee32a59eae1f9721e43fc04ff40df2f423adb804cb1e44","unit:d79efaa50b0d69a670da5d8e7c1792dccc1ea2a6cf29997052165a097f26cfea","unit:dcc3df35d4fe5731f4e1cd3bb161eac88eae88ce82e99d010c60ca4d2839e795","unit:df0f2c8a5e81cf312f9c704e8c20d3c1666ee4c47554947f9f7ef93a87adac0f","unit:f7dacde5e3ec1cd1a0ec3c942186b9014318356ac97fa62126074ac816fa49c7","unit:f931b9abe1a238cfcdf6b049f1f652f8d23248e68cc5bdeb4318ee990a395ea6"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:524e2f5f36cb09c5956aa59f","scopeContentSha256":"f420e09a4cc2e9d40175d7f540c29ed011087a20e085d4a3c2af3359e0b3884a","localRef":"s10"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","scopeContentSha256":"dc667e1c6331e506dae8bfb90994b6e1469c8c2828b9eb96c93630d236fa3791","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l7","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:38","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l7","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:38","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:524e2f5f36cb09c5956aa59f","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l7","source":"s30","target":"s10","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Effective-potential methods are used in distinct stabilization and de Sitter construction mechanisms."],"challengeStatement":"Effective-potential methods enter distinct stabilization and de Sitter construction mechanisms.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578"},{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:524e2f5f36cb09c5956aa59f"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578"},{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:524e2f5f36cb09c5956aa59f"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d7","originalRef":"l7","status":"route","source":"s10","target":"s30","type":"application_of","title":"Connect stabilization and de Sitter constructions to their effective-potential methods","rationale":"The original statements say that effective-potential methods enter distinct stabilization and de Sitter construction mechanisms. The construction question is the application and the effective-potential question is the methodological destination.","qualification":"The connection applies where a construction uses the specified effective-potential methods; it does not identify all uplift, instanton, higher-curvature, Casimir or racetrack mechanisms. Retain each model's sources, fields, corrections and scales. The orientifold hypermultiplet example concerns a subsector, and the perturbative D-term example is illustrative and incomplete. Critical points, stability of retained fields, full metastability, string consistency and parametric control remain separate claims.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l7","s10","s30"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The construction question applies effective-potential methods, so s10 → s30 is the correct application direction. Its limited applicability and distinctions among critical points, retained-sector stability, metastability and control preserve both the paired reasoning and endpoint limits.","refs":["l7","s10","s30"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l8":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l8","source":"q025-candidate-question:bf04ac96919ec94426f0da31","target":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","type":"application_of","title":"Relate stabilization and physical scales to potential extensions","rationale":"Stabilization and scale questions apply effective-potential ingredients and extensions even when their vacuum is AdS. The original application direction therefore requires reversal.","qualification":"Classical IIA/IIB stabilization, IIB large-volume models with α′ and nonperturbative terms, and descriptions with a nilpotent sector retain different premises. Partial stabilization may leave a sloped direction, and large total volume need not make every internal modulus large. The endpoint's 2005 IIB account supports the announced AdS mechanism and scale discussion more directly than uplifted de Sitter stability. No classical de Sitter conclusion or general uplift reliability follows from an AdS stabilization example.","evidenceIds":["unit:0331d936c08069563803cebe5d3527498080bf62848a27ba3f499deb4eb96d33","unit:03394bf20ceebe5d8fa665d97dfd6b5e900d27627f13bc5286f807cfb8cacd4f","unit:0823baa35b5b7bdf26b2bfba1f69f431bbd96f2e14713f032b8c581c14ff473e","unit:41214a545a81a191b636493fe52812bac54313a4910374ffce82899bd05f591f","unit:8c36ce59b59e2e547af818a3e8183807d26108092e3ba75bf4dfb532f37c8eee","unit:91a166320176900f4dfab7e1e0d5fcc0b4ff7da01c2cd3552d2b9b186e3b4740","unit:9214beb73af7c6709ac195bbefa77d6146aee7d6cf25d8b6b243d417d0024383","unit:abed7f7a15f00df2901178a63e7b88b901f9e85bcff3092d8375fce922152c08","unit:bf9cbeeef58cb882cda011b856aa3521221620fd0c14a53f8bc382edac0e4a4b","unit:ca01af2138e69abe18d84225e620bdf481d60abbd18695693fc57e58de21b027","unit:cfb072d78bcd8a8e97ee32a59eae1f9721e43fc04ff40df2f423adb804cb1e44","unit:f7dacde5e3ec1cd1a0ec3c942186b9014318356ac97fa62126074ac816fa49c7","unit:fff6a7782b613baac41e699dabffd995958cf249265239c921f2d9ad3646f9dc"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bf04ac96919ec94426f0da31","scopeContentSha256":"cef703cdeb14f9ac67ad4d0de03a8d8415b6d3d6fe7a7594e8c3272127cfb385","localRef":"s29"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","scopeContentSha256":"dc667e1c6331e506dae8bfb90994b6e1469c8c2828b9eb96c93630d236fa3791","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l8","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:39","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l8","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:39","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:bf04ac96919ec94426f0da31","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l8","source":"s30","target":"s29","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Potential extensions can address stabilization and physical scales even when the resulting vacuum is AdS."],"challengeStatement":"Potential extensions address stabilization and physical scales even when the resulting vacuum is AdS.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578"},{"ref":"x3_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bf04ac96919ec94426f0da31"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578"},{"ref":"x3_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bf04ac96919ec94426f0da31"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d8","originalRef":"l8","status":"route","source":"s29","target":"s30","type":"application_of","title":"Relate stabilization and physical scales to potential extensions","rationale":"Stabilization and scale questions apply effective-potential ingredients and extensions even when their vacuum is AdS. The original application direction therefore requires reversal.","qualification":"Classical IIA/IIB stabilization, IIB large-volume models with α′ and nonperturbative terms, and descriptions with a nilpotent sector retain different premises. Partial stabilization may leave a sloped direction, and large total volume need not make every internal modulus large. The endpoint's 2005 IIB account supports the announced AdS mechanism and scale discussion more directly than uplifted de Sitter stability. No classical de Sitter conclusion or general uplift reliability follows from an AdS stabilization example.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l8","s29","s30"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Stabilization and scale questions use potential ingredients and extensions, supporting s29 → s30. The qualification correctly allows AdS outcomes and preserves the different classical, corrected and nilpotent-sector premises without inferring de Sitter stability from the AdS mechanism.","refs":["l8","s29","s30"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l9":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l9","source":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","target":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44","type":"method_for","title":"Assess de Sitter effective control through organized quantum expansions","rationale":"Organizing quantum corrections and examining Wilsonian interpretation provide a methodological direction for the parent question's effective-control target.","qualification":"Restrict the route to the stated compactification descriptions and ansätze, distinguishing static from evolving internal fields and fixed from varying gravitational coefficients. Type IIB and dual type IIA couplings remain distinct, and local or nonlocal corrections enter only where supplied. Solving equations or counting operators does not complete Wilsonian integration. The endpoint leaves convergence, anomaly terms, corrected duality rules and aspects of state interpretation unresolved; internal evolution does not universally guarantee control.","evidenceIds":["unit:0331d936c08069563803cebe5d3527498080bf62848a27ba3f499deb4eb96d33","unit:07dbefdad760ee366f46d17ea86b866308b5ddf8cad29cd0e7980d7f2cbb0d61","unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","unit:0a7894cd67c1ab57b2737e741969081e9a796494033d35f595b85bd6f18c0dc2","unit:0b6150c3d467453650138e24f2a15302c5bf52501f03c27f57a09038c8c09495","unit:0c18ad4cd9b05b142b219de867695c608554ca0a995e5ea3b967d3467f853cf0","unit:49aa5609978dbf0d3e81cfdd55e33e8e4b4866793a24db7ebbdcd8f68c24ddfc","unit:510edff028a5f664da0cb7c6be171d88f882faf4377576f9dd4af798db136ad8","unit:5b2aae28d28e84fb4856d2743e199cb798f7ae995fef3dbc5c6c538b23732215","unit:5b4ab28915bcdf209205327b53d8e0b664c1aa0661388501e07eb7012e9d1bb2","unit:5d44db45b25d450de0329358dd75fed0db273e0034f8088dee99ea6acba04fd2","unit:607daedfc9bbd0023f28c127b2edf0128da4d654fbaa907d69a02d06a9158526","unit:6ee5ff699d48c244284bb3ea68a9a8a9a177946effb68ba75af12334af67efa0","unit:81d6ae180f0fc0d1d901a11693eed9bb75ffff826320fdba51a47c15351aef64","unit:825db4a7e38497cb127b363e0473f9658979fae1aca1d36f8dbc52e781672f7f","unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","unit:a736e013133d28f5fd654ef36aa354b9e8188a932e10e6ae274157b7fa46cd44","unit:a83c7372568e19dc70aae371bcbbf7df811fef4d7a2530a020b971ba3928d48e","unit:a891711fce939807aeca71cbc920440485c69abb757068f6624b8f2e49049524","unit:b727802ba56e21331fa342c9d04ac8e2913970f3e5f349c34285dfd38a813d90","unit:b7a2d007f0ba3749c9cf3ec205e7c29179408e0a8ecfb303d6b60c0f7a831d6d","unit:b917d5f832bb2bb4eae66cf23862dfa977547883c15f7da206d402fe7462e339","unit:c435074c5c68619bf5c1b8e015028945c4ad637037d768379168188cc7fdce91","unit:c4e61744b580c42fed0988346d2807ac2cc7c161ee79d8a98847ba1b6e32cca5","unit:ebcce2e9c0fc487c4491cb251b57648fae3869c2b4c4bd5b9e93ff8f6cc3351a","unit:ecec83bd62de4b786661045f9ea61d3f60c54f643435bed0f7866528ed39d06f","unit:fc300ffd0a3125ffe40301e238bc0e77d713c2b597a9543cb1aa772f69dd4d79"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","scopeContentSha256":"109144fa8a095198b384a24792b3bc35aae4f403a9291361948e15c8eb93da90","localRef":"s8"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44","scopeContentSha256":"f7451bdf519a5e3b3a89e6e6722e0ae0f8660a0ad25db5e32ecba81abae841eb","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l9","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:4","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l9","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:4","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l9","source":"s39","target":"s8","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Effective expansions and Wilsonian interpretation provide a distinct quantum-control direction."],"challengeStatement":"Organized quantum expansions and Wilsonian interpretation provide a distinct effective-control direction.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:24f15c2b8cbf3ff01679d73aaeb3bc72","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":4,"start":1285,"end":3704,"textSha256":"69324a2763479caed0950d09377c7abc5177808af008ac878606dde1e08e5bd2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e17","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:cb33d0c41a6c7d92cda8764d8939682e","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b1c796e53c76313afbd71bb1026e5cc47caeb53d085fc65f731ef124cdb617d9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"c1","kind":"attributed_child_review"},{"ref":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:24f15c2b8cbf3ff01679d73aaeb3bc72","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":4,"start":1285,"end":3704,"textSha256":"69324a2763479caed0950d09377c7abc5177808af008ac878606dde1e08e5bd2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e17","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:cb33d0c41a6c7d92cda8764d8939682e","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b1c796e53c76313afbd71bb1026e5cc47caeb53d085fc65f731ef124cdb617d9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"c1","kind":"attributed_child_review"},{"ref":"c2","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d9","originalRef":"l9","status":"route","source":"s8","target":"s39","type":"method_for","title":"Assess de Sitter effective control through organized quantum expansions","rationale":"Organizing quantum corrections and examining Wilsonian interpretation provide a methodological direction for the parent question's effective-control target.","qualification":"Restrict the route to the stated compactification descriptions and ansätze, distinguishing static from evolving internal fields and fixed from varying gravitational coefficients. Type IIB and dual type IIA couplings remain distinct, and local or nonlocal corrections enter only where supplied. Solving equations or counting operators does not complete Wilsonian integration. The endpoint leaves convergence, anomaly terms, corrected duality rules and aspects of state interpretation unresolved; internal evolution does not universally guarantee control.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l9","s8","s39"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d9","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Organized expansions and Wilsonian interpretation provide a methodological route from s8 to the effective-control targets of s39. The record retains background and coupling distinctions and explicitly leaves convergence, corrected dualities, Wilsonian integration and state interpretation unresolved.","refs":["l9","s8","s39"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l10":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l10","source":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","target":"q025-candidate-question:88437dc28af65e7d1a03e4c5","type":"method_for","title":"Use correction hierarchies to examine compactification control","rationale":"Both original statements identify ordering quantum corrections as a contribution to control, while denying that it completes Wilsonian integration. The expansion question therefore supplies a limited method to the broader control question.","qualification":"Apply only within the specified backgrounds, coupling conventions and static or evolving ansätze. Reported hierarchies do not independently establish convergence or bounds on every omitted term. They do not settle source realization, quantization, missing modes, tower decoupling or the distinction between consistent and low-energy truncations. Wilsonian integration and the endpoint's unresolved correction and state questions remain open; finite-parameter and asymptotic control are not interchangeable.","evidenceIds":["unit:07dbefdad760ee366f46d17ea86b866308b5ddf8cad29cd0e7980d7f2cbb0d61","unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","unit:0a7894cd67c1ab57b2737e741969081e9a796494033d35f595b85bd6f18c0dc2","unit:0b6150c3d467453650138e24f2a15302c5bf52501f03c27f57a09038c8c09495","unit:0c18ad4cd9b05b142b219de867695c608554ca0a995e5ea3b967d3467f853cf0","unit:148e545792b1782dc240c5aa9a1996d599b189b76551bd6ae529c44c5de3287d","unit:1eab3b69f4159ab3840871737d90601288732b8d446fbf413187a86b2c82144a","unit:21bb5d5e644002c9edbd92f4e91f050765fc4057f7cad9dabe75a134d29b1cf3","unit:24b211ccf3ae6623c69cc174b3981a2604640c93853a6a5981df23ba36eaae3b","unit:438e7232514957a45dc7e5ad3d91029f89179417a4a032963532df5ba220fe01","unit:43d7106c49083533ebe72d18138a468f1cc29804d51760bc43d4b582309806fa","unit:47f773fcfe90206eafa826d73747a827d229e104d4ba7564e03d86d7088adf66","unit:49aa5609978dbf0d3e81cfdd55e33e8e4b4866793a24db7ebbdcd8f68c24ddfc","unit:510edff028a5f664da0cb7c6be171d88f882faf4377576f9dd4af798db136ad8","unit:5b2aae28d28e84fb4856d2743e199cb798f7ae995fef3dbc5c6c538b23732215","unit:5b4ab28915bcdf209205327b53d8e0b664c1aa0661388501e07eb7012e9d1bb2","unit:5d44db45b25d450de0329358dd75fed0db273e0034f8088dee99ea6acba04fd2","unit:607daedfc9bbd0023f28c127b2edf0128da4d654fbaa907d69a02d06a9158526","unit:6ee5ff699d48c244284bb3ea68a9a8a9a177946effb68ba75af12334af67efa0","unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","unit:825db4a7e38497cb127b363e0473f9658979fae1aca1d36f8dbc52e781672f7f","unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","unit:9b3a25ae335112ce544d932aef8a713a361ac3bb3d4edd2c88402c4bab50752e","unit:9b6fdbcf01ba7a005355c082ea13f8654a43b320d1b004eafa30ab864f211235","unit:9e7a86a5dc1f81177274f4219e00d4fc9a0837f2bdd80922a6387b97cd9fedc8","unit:a736e013133d28f5fd654ef36aa354b9e8188a932e10e6ae274157b7fa46cd44","unit:a891711fce939807aeca71cbc920440485c69abb757068f6624b8f2e49049524","unit:aaeea2e7b3e0dbb44a4b72426688bf32370ee848f1048de7b76a9ff3a64931a6","unit:b0f54b3023614bced88e047d69903a371546cfdc2bc84e3a648ce3e91b3210b5","unit:b727802ba56e21331fa342c9d04ac8e2913970f3e5f349c34285dfd38a813d90","unit:b7a2d007f0ba3749c9cf3ec205e7c29179408e0a8ecfb303d6b60c0f7a831d6d","unit:b917d5f832bb2bb4eae66cf23862dfa977547883c15f7da206d402fe7462e339","unit:c1a851cb34e3ac819cabdbb3d4f72e7f68f9e58280b4733438a80263da71d772","unit:c435074c5c68619bf5c1b8e015028945c4ad637037d768379168188cc7fdce91","unit:c4e61744b580c42fed0988346d2807ac2cc7c161ee79d8a98847ba1b6e32cca5","unit:d6327dcd749b2469d206fae71b0619490531308f98ddcf905c96c3e7b91cf679","unit:dcc3df35d4fe5731f4e1cd3bb161eac88eae88ce82e99d010c60ca4d2839e795","unit:df0f2c8a5e81cf312f9c704e8c20d3c1666ee4c47554947f9f7ef93a87adac0f","unit:efd49ae96bd324170a1fabfe5eb599279d09c02440a1f3c7b5c020664bd8be4f","unit:fc300ffd0a3125ffe40301e238bc0e77d713c2b597a9543cb1aa772f69dd4d79"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","scopeContentSha256":"109144fa8a095198b384a24792b3bc35aae4f403a9291361948e15c8eb93da90","localRef":"s8"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:88437dc28af65e7d1a03e4c5","scopeContentSha256":"bbda7c487afaea151eacff86cff6b09ce4a7991c8489842ec911bade9b8099fa","localRef":"s16"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l10","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:30","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l10","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:30","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:88437dc28af65e7d1a03e4c5","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l10","source":"s16","target":"s8","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Ordering quantum corrections contributes to control but does not complete Wilsonian integration."],"challengeStatement":"Ordering quantum corrections contributes to control without completing Wilsonian integration.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:88437dc28af65e7d1a03e4c5"},{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:24f15c2b8cbf3ff01679d73aaeb3bc72","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":4,"start":1285,"end":3704,"textSha256":"69324a2763479caed0950d09377c7abc5177808af008ac878606dde1e08e5bd2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:88437dc28af65e7d1a03e4c5"},{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1908.05288","sourceId":"ev:24f15c2b8cbf3ff01679d73aaeb3bc72","sourceSha256":"e15950180bebf307566890d8faf81a6482c067fa2a82b4443006a339fa8691c7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b5d9c81f7dd59925c159/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfb565412ad1584f3281d30de3f460d5c0ffad4cf07c1a1e5b404e2569049ca8","pdfPage":4,"start":1285,"end":3704,"textSha256":"69324a2763479caed0950d09377c7abc5177808af008ac878606dde1e08e5bd2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d10","originalRef":"l10","status":"route","source":"s8","target":"s16","type":"method_for","title":"Use correction hierarchies to examine compactification control","rationale":"Both original statements identify ordering quantum corrections as a contribution to control, while denying that it completes Wilsonian integration. The expansion question therefore supplies a limited method to the broader control question.","qualification":"Apply only within the specified backgrounds, coupling conventions and static or evolving ansätze. Reported hierarchies do not independently establish convergence or bounds on every omitted term. They do not settle source realization, quantization, missing modes, tower decoupling or the distinction between consistent and low-energy truncations. Wilsonian integration and the endpoint's unresolved correction and state questions remain open; finite-parameter and asymptotic control are not interchangeable.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l10","s8","s16"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d10","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Ordering corrections contributes a limited method to the broader control question, supporting s8 → s16. The record does not mistake that contribution for Wilsonian integration, convergence, source consistency, mode completeness or tower decoupling.","refs":["l10","s8","s16"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l10","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l11":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l11","source":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","target":"q025-candidate-question:e89bd0893351e98f13a6149f","type":"related_question","title":"Explore conditional instability near no-scale Minkowski points","rationale":"Both original statements support a shared no-scale framework while distinguishing the origin of no-scale structure from instability under small deformations. They do not establish an application relation between the complete endpoint scopes.","qualification":"The instability question is restricted to small deformations of a no-scale Minkowski point in four-dimensional N=1 F-term supergravity. Its baseline excludes non-negligible relevant Kähler corrections and the specified exceptional superpotential couplings, and assumes perpendicular moduli are stabilized at the Minkowski point. Relaxing these hypotheses opens possibilities without proving a stable solution. The tachyon direction can vary and rotate away from the sgoldstino. Neither arbitrary finite deformations nor all effective-potential constructions are covered, and the full derivation and numerical curvature bound are not reconstructed here.","evidenceIds":["unit:0331d936c08069563803cebe5d3527498080bf62848a27ba3f499deb4eb96d33","unit:03394bf20ceebe5d8fa665d97dfd6b5e900d27627f13bc5286f807cfb8cacd4f","unit:0bd21ce0e59679ea9c186eb3ed0e83d0ba178e1ed91b83e58c1411db687fff8c","unit:8c36ce59b59e2e547af818a3e8183807d26108092e3ba75bf4dfb532f37c8eee","unit:9214beb73af7c6709ac195bbefa77d6146aee7d6cf25d8b6b243d417d0024383","unit:abed7f7a15f00df2901178a63e7b88b901f9e85bcff3092d8375fce922152c08","unit:bf9cbeeef58cb882cda011b856aa3521221620fd0c14a53f8bc382edac0e4a4b","unit:cfb072d78bcd8a8e97ee32a59eae1f9721e43fc04ff40df2f423adb804cb1e44","unit:f7dacde5e3ec1cd1a0ec3c942186b9014318356ac97fa62126074ac816fa49c7"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","scopeContentSha256":"dc667e1c6331e506dae8bfb90994b6e1469c8c2828b9eb96c93630d236fa3791","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e89bd0893351e98f13a6149f","scopeContentSha256":"0820b02749c5462f16fe4bde4457f36d6a35fcf74697f659dc11ba9bc4dd092d","localRef":"s35"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l11","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:40","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l11","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:40","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:e89bd0893351e98f13a6149f","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l11","source":"s30","target":"s35","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["The origin of no-scale structure and conditional instability under small deformations are different questions with a useful framework connection."],"challengeStatement":"No-scale origin and instability under small deformations share a framework but have different targets and hypotheses.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578"},{"ref":"x5_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e89bd0893351e98f13a6149f"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2006.06694","sourceId":"ev:615509c571019b29b2d54e9a7bdc5305","sourceSha256":"e27707ef3e215c6674cfbef932dbe0043683a628f6ea6d2a8f8f3325a58b02e1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/89479c7ca668eaa45d02/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07d58cc9dea6a89a7cca2486ad0db7affc033b8aa930c1f217b71a2f1413d624","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1944,"textSha256":"050f54d3255a416d86f8f93252354ce998113764368ca42713a558c81b0ee88f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"2006.06694","sourceId":"ev:949459711915fd92a88361f011bf2dd9","sourceSha256":"e27707ef3e215c6674cfbef932dbe0043683a628f6ea6d2a8f8f3325a58b02e1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/89479c7ca668eaa45d02/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07d58cc9dea6a89a7cca2486ad0db7affc033b8aa930c1f217b71a2f1413d624","pdfPage":72,"start":100,"end":2266,"textSha256":"f89a1cbf0f4493e304ad6aa12e0ff114d4e885830f92c1de61bb643d5308baab","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578"},{"ref":"x5_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e89bd0893351e98f13a6149f"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2006.06694","sourceId":"ev:615509c571019b29b2d54e9a7bdc5305","sourceSha256":"e27707ef3e215c6674cfbef932dbe0043683a628f6ea6d2a8f8f3325a58b02e1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/89479c7ca668eaa45d02/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07d58cc9dea6a89a7cca2486ad0db7affc033b8aa930c1f217b71a2f1413d624","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1944,"textSha256":"050f54d3255a416d86f8f93252354ce998113764368ca42713a558c81b0ee88f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"2006.06694","sourceId":"ev:949459711915fd92a88361f011bf2dd9","sourceSha256":"e27707ef3e215c6674cfbef932dbe0043683a628f6ea6d2a8f8f3325a58b02e1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/89479c7ca668eaa45d02/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07d58cc9dea6a89a7cca2486ad0db7affc033b8aa930c1f217b71a2f1413d624","pdfPage":72,"start":100,"end":2266,"textSha256":"f89a1cbf0f4493e304ad6aa12e0ff114d4e885830f92c1de61bb643d5308baab","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d11","originalRef":"l11","status":"route","source":"s30","target":"s35","type":"related_question","title":"Explore conditional instability near no-scale Minkowski points","rationale":"Both original statements support a shared no-scale framework while distinguishing the origin of no-scale structure from instability under small deformations. They do not establish an application relation between the complete endpoint scopes.","qualification":"The instability question is restricted to small deformations of a no-scale Minkowski point in four-dimensional N=1 F-term supergravity. Its baseline excludes non-negligible relevant Kähler corrections and the specified exceptional superpotential couplings, and assumes perpendicular moduli are stabilized at the Minkowski point. Relaxing these hypotheses opens possibilities without proving a stable solution. The tachyon direction can vary and rotate away from the sgoldstino. Neither arbitrary finite deformations nor all effective-potential constructions are covered, and the full derivation and numerical curvature bound are not reconstructed here.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l11","s30","s35"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d11","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements establish a shared no-scale framework with different targets and hypotheses, which supports related_question. The record retains the small-deformation F-term setting, baseline assumptions and conditional escape routes without asserting a broader instability theorem.","refs":["l11","s30","s35"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l11","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l12":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l12","source":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44","target":"q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273","type":"related_question","title":"Examine thermal survival, vacuum decay and cosmological use","rationale":"The original statements connect candidate backgrounds to additional thermal, persistence and rolling-cosmology targets. They establish a useful dynamical connection without identifying the broad parent question as an underlying method being applied.","qualification":"A static de Sitter extremum does not answer thermal destabilization, decompactification, tunneling, slow-roll or quintessence questions. Retain the relevant uplifted, racetrack, one-exponential and rolling-scalar models and their application-specific scale hierarchies. Inflationary and late-time scales remain distinct, and slow roll or quintessence is not a metastable de Sitter vacuum. The endpoint's lifetime discussion is model- and approximation-specific; most thermal and inflationary targets have description-level support.","evidenceIds":["unit:0331d936c08069563803cebe5d3527498080bf62848a27ba3f499deb4eb96d33","unit:0c18ad4cd9b05b142b219de867695c608554ca0a995e5ea3b967d3467f853cf0","unit:19639e9d1a90593d9080f4b0ab212960dac48dda0834342e34cd41bfe0299c81","unit:43d7106c49083533ebe72d18138a468f1cc29804d51760bc43d4b582309806fa","unit:478c397d11929dfaa143d4c812563ae364ed3839c075ee00f7a7e583e236ff1d","unit:5d5e4243a11bf45e1b62d0056e7a15f8f05ff040b01a2653bb5cd5548ac13a2c","unit:60a0907b6441966f69bce2c177d4e6b87e86ec1415fc4893a29e1eb14e0587a6","unit:81d6ae180f0fc0d1d901a11693eed9bb75ffff826320fdba51a47c15351aef64","unit:9b3a25ae335112ce544d932aef8a713a361ac3bb3d4edd2c88402c4bab50752e","unit:a83c7372568e19dc70aae371bcbbf7df811fef4d7a2530a020b971ba3928d48e","unit:ade68997314b20e6fa12b920c3f53cca37dadcc9b6d6b8eab510c7dba0aff90d","unit:b3f367f65edbb9071507677f74fce3f7be1e6318cea71b608e7098bcc956f4d3","unit:b7a2d007f0ba3749c9cf3ec205e7c29179408e0a8ecfb303d6b60c0f7a831d6d","unit:d1997e9ba80ee25bc96872e1c5d3a7a3936f3888e03733a3da4445fabcd938f7","unit:ebcce2e9c0fc487c4491cb251b57648fae3869c2b4c4bd5b9e93ff8f6cc3351a","unit:ecec83bd62de4b786661045f9ea61d3f60c54f643435bed0f7866528ed39d06f","unit:f435c816d918c1c5641ddbd17adf7eb329e120e8b688ede2a00a57df3120fae8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44","scopeContentSha256":"f7451bdf519a5e3b3a89e6e6722e0ae0f8660a0ad25db5e32ecba81abae841eb","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273","scopeContentSha256":"415f34d29d669ea4ee617c917a714ffcd0c5ce9064597d47550ab71d206d3dc1","localRef":"s37"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l12","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:6","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l12","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:6","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:62d736e5f22beae93d504a44","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l12","source":"s39","target":"s37","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Thermal evolution, decay and rolling cosmology introduce dynamical targets beyond a static extremum."],"challengeStatement":"Thermal evolution, vacuum persistence and rolling cosmology add dynamical targets.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273"},{"ref":"x2_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da1a8eaa21ee72ef1dbadcdb"},{"ref":"x4_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:73c5ae3a6503f1c74eaf15e8"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273"},{"ref":"x2_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da1a8eaa21ee72ef1dbadcdb"},{"ref":"x4_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:73c5ae3a6503f1c74eaf15e8"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d12","originalRef":"l12","status":"route","source":"s39","target":"s37","type":"related_question","title":"Examine thermal survival, vacuum decay and cosmological use","rationale":"The original statements connect candidate backgrounds to additional thermal, persistence and rolling-cosmology targets. They establish a useful dynamical connection without identifying the broad parent question as an underlying method being applied.","qualification":"A static de Sitter extremum does not answer thermal destabilization, decompactification, tunneling, slow-roll or quintessence questions. Retain the relevant uplifted, racetrack, one-exponential and rolling-scalar models and their application-specific scale hierarchies. Inflationary and late-time scales remain distinct, and slow roll or quintessence is not a metastable de Sitter vacuum. The endpoint's lifetime discussion is model- and approximation-specific; most thermal and inflationary targets have description-level support.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l12","s39","s37"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d12","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The paired reasoning connects candidate backgrounds with additional thermal, decay and rolling-cosmology questions, without identifying the parent as an underlying method. The related-question route preserves those dynamical targets and their model, scale and reading limitations.","refs":["l12","s39","s37"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l12","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l13":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l13","source":"q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273","target":"q025-candidate-question:da1a8eaa21ee72ef1dbadcdb","type":"related_question","title":"Explore transient cosmology, NEC compatibility and axionic couplings","rationale":"The original statements add source-specific transient and phenomenological questions to the dynamical discussion. They do not identify thermal or vacuum-decay analysis as the method underlying the target's temporal state constructions.","qualification":"Retain the specified time-dependent string/M-theory, heterotic and dynamical Hořava–Witten settings and their finite temporal evolution. Weak coupling and time-dependent axion decay constants apply only where asserted. Exact de Sitter, quasi-de Sitter and generic FLRW histories remain distinct. NEC and axionic-coupling requirements are source-specific, and a temporal state construction does not establish phenomenological bounds. The endpoint's 12 December 2024 v1 account announces a transient NEC-respecting phase and axionic model without supplying a numerical bound calculation.","evidenceIds":["unit:19639e9d1a90593d9080f4b0ab212960dac48dda0834342e34cd41bfe0299c81","unit:43d7106c49083533ebe72d18138a468f1cc29804d51760bc43d4b582309806fa","unit:478c397d11929dfaa143d4c812563ae364ed3839c075ee00f7a7e583e236ff1d","unit:49aa5609978dbf0d3e81cfdd55e33e8e4b4866793a24db7ebbdcd8f68c24ddfc","unit:5b2aae28d28e84fb4856d2743e199cb798f7ae995fef3dbc5c6c538b23732215","unit:5d5e4243a11bf45e1b62d0056e7a15f8f05ff040b01a2653bb5cd5548ac13a2c","unit:60a0907b6441966f69bce2c177d4e6b87e86ec1415fc4893a29e1eb14e0587a6","unit:6608803896cc22be3bb13ddb07582dce3034062c6c3672d137a4feedb7bbc85f","unit:6ee5ff699d48c244284bb3ea68a9a8a9a177946effb68ba75af12334af67efa0","unit:9b3a25ae335112ce544d932aef8a713a361ac3bb3d4edd2c88402c4bab50752e","unit:a736e013133d28f5fd654ef36aa354b9e8188a932e10e6ae274157b7fa46cd44","unit:ade68997314b20e6fa12b920c3f53cca37dadcc9b6d6b8eab510c7dba0aff90d","unit:b3f367f65edbb9071507677f74fce3f7be1e6318cea71b608e7098bcc956f4d3","unit:d1997e9ba80ee25bc96872e1c5d3a7a3936f3888e03733a3da4445fabcd938f7","unit:d341373dafe1731f3a6faf7a45eca16fcbd8eeb5d6eda23121000f54e300cd8c","unit:f435c816d918c1c5641ddbd17adf7eb329e120e8b688ede2a00a57df3120fae8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273","scopeContentSha256":"415f34d29d669ea4ee617c917a714ffcd0c5ce9064597d47550ab71d206d3dc1","localRef":"s37"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da1a8eaa21ee72ef1dbadcdb","scopeContentSha256":"b08045d7412fb34bafa4d2dddfd3e5ecb3e370702d85c58a8523641ffa855e79","localRef":"s32"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l13","originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:48","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l13","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge:link:48","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:da1a8eaa21ee72ef1dbadcdb","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l13","source":"s37","target":"s32","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Transient cosmology, NEC compatibility and axionic couplings add source-specific dynamical and phenomenological targets."],"challengeStatement":"Transient cosmology, NEC compatibility and axionic couplings add source-specific dynamical targets.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-proposal","packetFile":"packet.json","packet.jsonSha256":"46299e13367833af17f0abc0e5301b982b034615e6b7e142497e2330005ab41f","reply.jsonSha256":"5fe65cb11a8cece114c8251b3211fde1dc929900bbd739d3f641dc2b00617505","reply.raw.txtSha256":"047bc4c0018c01c36ebf36bf12cc62d2a7c93d262a17fb9a5b11219f36290bb3","receipt.jsonSha256":"385494ee693a01edb637a7b0fa718d5e66fb4372a6bd18a8f14640012be8f031","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8844f64e508d9a01238ca39e65eaffe4345d0f333a96a8ac366c26a01f7530c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8b7128e93c6d21cee03539752520e034298a9488aff8c845e91338d8f47c91cb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parent-pilot-v1/jobs/parent-b518fa2038910d956e04-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bd21ecf62b1b8ff6a753a6f5bcd470472066aaa1c5c48132155e26dc45df1d3c","reply.jsonSha256":"7a85148d0923a4c87f1b28f8a516e5b993c902aa4d9270c311efefc92ffe5a45","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b5a53e5bdd13e8e65f44c0026b826aadf4a323c658f7202917f82dcd7a4eb3ac","receipt.jsonSha256":"14981d007d270118a261eb230c86861b4cf5e861d009b597015d40d98f0ffa2c","normalization.jsonSha256":"f8d56ac9575731e36100a2222aa356925ecbc5a2151ae2dbe40bc5c4dc321337"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273"},{"ref":"x2_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da1a8eaa21ee72ef1dbadcdb"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f138007c6b9cb93954811273"},{"ref":"x2_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da1a8eaa21ee72ef1dbadcdb"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d13","originalRef":"l13","status":"route","source":"s37","target":"s32","type":"related_question","title":"Explore transient cosmology, NEC compatibility and axionic couplings","rationale":"The original statements add source-specific transient and phenomenological questions to the dynamical discussion. They do not identify thermal or vacuum-decay analysis as the method underlying the target's temporal state constructions.","qualification":"Retain the specified time-dependent string/M-theory, heterotic and dynamical Hořava–Witten settings and their finite temporal evolution. Weak coupling and time-dependent axion decay constants apply only where asserted. Exact de Sitter, quasi-de Sitter and generic FLRW histories remain distinct. NEC and axionic-coupling requirements are source-specific, and a temporal state construction does not establish phenomenological bounds. The endpoint's 12 December 2024 v1 account announces a transient NEC-respecting phase and axionic model without supplying a numerical bound calculation.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l13","s37","s32"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d13","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original statements support a connection between dynamical cosmology questions but do not establish that s32 applies a method supplied by s37. The record preserves source-specific transient histories, NEC and axionic requirements, including the absence of a supplied numerical phenomenological calculation.","refs":["l13","s37","s32"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l13","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l15":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l15","source":"q025-candidate-question:54c957af583e29b15de18961","target":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8","type":"application_of","title":"Connect inflationary range control to period and enhancement constructions","rationale":"Both original statements distinguish calculating a range from asking whether that range supports inflation. The inflationary-control question applies range constructions while adding potential, instanton-spectrum and conditional consistency requirements.","qualification":"The route concerns the use of period and range constructions, not containment of either complete scope. Period, decay constant, domain volume or diameter, trajectory length and monotonic potential interval remain distinct. Retain construction-specific stabilization, decoupling and instanton assumptions; dense towers and nonlarge minimum charges are additional hypotheses where used, and subleading WGC instantons need not dominate the potential. Flux variation across models is not fixed-flux motion. Neither a large range, simulated geometry nor an EFT evasion certifies an inflationary trajectory, explicit compactification or quantum-gravity embedding.","evidenceIds":["unit:0aacb2f51d637ca4427e2def670018cb6de3b695d8dbfae5455552c89c072966","unit:0dd7afc4b7841f50fadfb82cd3a194cc7b24833683d82a477c7622e4371f09da","unit:104260b9a56d84ab04eb5d7e114008be579d8f8bb3e8a508774e0ae73ad6a649","unit:10ec2b4baf0ee06c640c0b17912b0c889ca8b1dc6374175fdfa3a4f80bba3865","unit:1112af1de694f4d8247f81d8789b989a821f62ce78d02d86340d6c8610c2de61","unit:16516a56d3ac8e73bc13cb49617cdde9977dcccd4518ab1af0dafa31402f05d8","unit:1fb3ddfa526bf36841aa82ec0d8ed6e796523054d2e2313b09b8bf37024dfd2e","unit:2472aa7f6431071a7ecfd145294b3acc1b55c8f5dd05e532b58afaca295edef5","unit:2a5415c009e4ebfc381ff601f91eea9ff6f766f8fbbe3a98c50f5e5d68fa16a5","unit:2af8f302067053b8e9134cd25232d8dc814ad0b8bcb1ba6f6d2bf4b3aef3696e","unit:36f38a0bcfe9b654ecb7a0cf1f78b8db9a38da51786d7cba3deb93177ef94253","unit:4c7d804a069f3383ed78096e63d030ba20e76eb3a7b287afb4f660f0c981a7b2","unit:53eddd61d2fa628502ee2ee0f60ecf3e4794ebb47bb5839119f002ddf6011267","unit:585e1daac2d01523fa418bd7f0102f175d15dd031150da1b733d5399ebe684e0","unit:5b8b77361824dcc686ca693c4425197ddf0ff020b24af62897d86784f1cbad9b","unit:5f5acebe2dc1df1ad97272a28776c9bcc2f118e8fffa0fc2ae81cccdc7831a69","unit:61a3094b403d49cef56b084faadc5ba7c3e2bf5a691e50e86084348d2377f7d0","unit:69b3a487be496c140ef5324a8bd1ffd3ffd1e1b1fe4708203d6e3c6f420f5920","unit:73cbff6e91a5b915cae72adbfa11a71e5fee228ec0bb99a41bdc972f52aa7504","unit:87a082cc421b4d0572c13f55e6a23859181f44b49b1d2f6c8c1f95f6d0ee613d","unit:a6938565cf1dfb4ac5629544cc2db4f93d4abb760f4a0d694dec335a59318fff","unit:bc93195bbce401af7ef41812ffd2c1b0a8a2348078e6007e8cb375ff37d40145","unit:c40a86235cd7c595290180eb708f8bc59e1fbe2c543b61756bd61226e53bc745","unit:d18b2bac4da18f878d8f9a0663ddda680cdee4e108ba2c8083aa7dbbda01cb71","unit:d1e0189cb1c9032a1ca8e475132eb6492a2a476bda7c8998a16b126e3c9bb972","unit:e5c4ae8d8d48db2abfdc5c70db1906ebb678e7fb6d35b741831d0f9d7378e870","unit:efb8179652cb838f3a7c8812145553616d4b9274ce7d13a81cfac102b0b6764b","unit:f208201c60b72fdd70b35c7d69c3fedc571c52d157cc73bfad2b7e23b0636649","unit:fd36b395fa2112b50ab90ad9277c4995601fbc01745ad016309e652c75ae826e","unit:fe24f21300fba4f511139d03921cc978ec067dc5643d0a5593fbd5f62c50bd7e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:54c957af583e29b15de18961","scopeContentSha256":"dbd7fbce12fb30b4bcc4d338b956c5b3e36779fdd3cf07b1a01537e7701dbd71","localRef":"s11"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8","scopeContentSha256":"6772c8784bb9ededfa73ae2dc0229bdfc4fd39f98408c3cfa6337a6830ea11be","localRef":"s27"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l15","originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:16","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l15","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:16","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:54c957af583e29b15de18961","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l15","source":"s27","target":"s11","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Asking whether a range supports inflation adds potential, instanton-spectrum and conditional consistency requirements to a range calculation."],"challengeStatement":"Inflationary use adds potential, instanton-spectrum and consistency requirements to the existence of a large range.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8"},{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:54c957af583e29b15de18961"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1601.00647","sourceId":"ev:7e19bb86af50dc794fa8d5366a00240e","sourceSha256":"af73d72b99cfe98fd808e7068b325f4ed5de98f9f286fa3145deb86ee6a04e28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/46b944d680584c1d27be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"02c858afb93dddff0c9a69d7b63832fd3126ea2006bd5f6c141412e80a48a013","pdfPage":3,"start":1299,"end":3222,"textSha256":"046448ce8c5f4a4a778061f1cd53684813e1ebb6728afa1494eba16b2fad8143","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"1601.00647","sourceId":"ev:c0c1b5ba4099d90f79fa887ea66e098b","sourceSha256":"af73d72b99cfe98fd808e7068b325f4ed5de98f9f286fa3145deb86ee6a04e28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/46b944d680584c1d27be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"02c858afb93dddff0c9a69d7b63832fd3126ea2006bd5f6c141412e80a48a013","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2776,"textSha256":"0beb1b9ed093485e222a6a1661ad6fadd8de5269dca74298714c57a6349abb9a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8"},{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:54c957af583e29b15de18961"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1601.00647","sourceId":"ev:7e19bb86af50dc794fa8d5366a00240e","sourceSha256":"af73d72b99cfe98fd808e7068b325f4ed5de98f9f286fa3145deb86ee6a04e28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/46b944d680584c1d27be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"02c858afb93dddff0c9a69d7b63832fd3126ea2006bd5f6c141412e80a48a013","pdfPage":3,"start":1299,"end":3222,"textSha256":"046448ce8c5f4a4a778061f1cd53684813e1ebb6728afa1494eba16b2fad8143","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"1601.00647","sourceId":"ev:c0c1b5ba4099d90f79fa887ea66e098b","sourceSha256":"af73d72b99cfe98fd808e7068b325f4ed5de98f9f286fa3145deb86ee6a04e28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/46b944d680584c1d27be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"02c858afb93dddff0c9a69d7b63832fd3126ea2006bd5f6c141412e80a48a013","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2776,"textSha256":"0beb1b9ed093485e222a6a1661ad6fadd8de5269dca74298714c57a6349abb9a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d15","originalRef":"l15","status":"route","source":"s11","target":"s27","type":"application_of","title":"Connect inflationary range control to period and enhancement constructions","rationale":"Both original statements distinguish calculating a range from asking whether that range supports inflation. The inflationary-control question applies range constructions while adding potential, instanton-spectrum and conditional consistency requirements.","qualification":"The route concerns the use of period and range constructions, not containment of either complete scope. Period, decay constant, domain volume or diameter, trajectory length and monotonic potential interval remain distinct. Retain construction-specific stabilization, decoupling and instanton assumptions; dense towers and nonlarge minimum charges are additional hypotheses where used, and subleading WGC instantons need not dominate the potential. Flux variation across models is not fixed-flux motion. Neither a large range, simulated geometry nor an EFT evasion certifies an inflationary trajectory, explicit compactification or quantum-gravity embedding.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l15","s11","s27"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d15","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original statements distinguish obtaining a range from using it for inflation, supporting s11 → s27 as application_of. The record preserves the additional potential, instanton-spectrum and conditional-consistency requirements and keeps the different range measures and construction limits separate.","refs":["l15","s11","s27"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l15","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l16":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l16","source":"q025-candidate-question:5045cac4e1fdd38b62916765","target":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8","type":"application_of","title":"Relate natural-like and alignment inflation to axion period and range mechanisms","rationale":"The original statements explicitly identify natural-like and alignment applications of range questions, with additional potential and control requirements. The applied inflation question therefore points to the period and enhancement question.","qualification":"Apply this connection only to the relevant period or range mechanisms, without assigning every natural-like or chiral-gauge construction an enhancement mechanism. Preserve explicit absence of monodromy in the alignment branch; monodromy is not established for the chiral-gauge description. Axion period, effective decay constant and proper trajectory length differ. Potential generation, condensate backreaction, gravitational effects and EFT control require their own checks. Strong-coupling control in the universal-axion natural branch is unresolved, and alignment and chiral-dynamics support is description-only.","evidenceIds":["unit:0aacb2f51d637ca4427e2def670018cb6de3b695d8dbfae5455552c89c072966","unit:104260b9a56d84ab04eb5d7e114008be579d8f8bb3e8a508774e0ae73ad6a649","unit:10ec2b4baf0ee06c640c0b17912b0c889ca8b1dc6374175fdfa3a4f80bba3865","unit:16516a56d3ac8e73bc13cb49617cdde9977dcccd4518ab1af0dafa31402f05d8","unit:1fb3ddfa526bf36841aa82ec0d8ed6e796523054d2e2313b09b8bf37024dfd2e","unit:2472aa7f6431071a7ecfd145294b3acc1b55c8f5dd05e532b58afaca295edef5","unit:26ea6818f7ce05e2e20dd0077fc343589292de168548b050ac2802f7fc2efe89","unit:2a5415c009e4ebfc381ff601f91eea9ff6f766f8fbbe3a98c50f5e5d68fa16a5","unit:36f38a0bcfe9b654ecb7a0cf1f78b8db9a38da51786d7cba3deb93177ef94253","unit:53eddd61d2fa628502ee2ee0f60ecf3e4794ebb47bb5839119f002ddf6011267","unit:5b8b77361824dcc686ca693c4425197ddf0ff020b24af62897d86784f1cbad9b","unit:bf40421712b0d217a22c6d4bf39582855ec9be408acbdc6f3ce29e123b2b3792","unit:c40a86235cd7c595290180eb708f8bc59e1fbe2c543b61756bd61226e53bc745","unit:d1e0189cb1c9032a1ca8e475132eb6492a2a476bda7c8998a16b126e3c9bb972","unit:efb8179652cb838f3a7c8812145553616d4b9274ce7d13a81cfac102b0b6764b","unit:f208201c60b72fdd70b35c7d69c3fedc571c52d157cc73bfad2b7e23b0636649","unit:fd36b395fa2112b50ab90ad9277c4995601fbc01745ad016309e652c75ae826e","unit:fe24f21300fba4f511139d03921cc978ec067dc5643d0a5593fbd5f62c50bd7e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5045cac4e1fdd38b62916765","scopeContentSha256":"45e0c41efd5e3fdf9a3865f9130f67c7885137ebfc8c8d8b2d01fe243aec47a7","localRef":"s9"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8","scopeContentSha256":"6772c8784bb9ededfa73ae2dc0229bdfc4fd39f98408c3cfa6337a6830ea11be","localRef":"s27"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l16","originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:17","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l16","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:17","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:5045cac4e1fdd38b62916765","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l16","source":"s27","target":"s9","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Natural-like and alignment applications retain their own potential and control requirements, including explicit absence of monodromy where stated."],"challengeStatement":"Natural-like inflation and alignment require their own potential and control checks, including explicit absence of monodromy where stated.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8"},{"ref":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5045cac4e1fdd38b62916765"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-ph/0409138","sourceId":"ev:42561062ee6ed21f464c7ead389879e9","sourceSha256":"f841c4fa0f3e4ba26fdd984d9938db7bf9ddae6ee40a3871fd5cb8702020a415","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1b94666753a5f70c2c97/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6fef795fcb90da390e24fc14fb07b0e1fae3b1e7c002be6c79f061e28c832567","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2026,"textSha256":"109a7c1a4bb6f6b1c175df395087517f468fe9f3f083fffe5b1a6d3e60990d39","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-ph/0409138","sourceId":"ev:8431ccca320b33b8d6cc4356beb462d2","sourceSha256":"f841c4fa0f3e4ba26fdd984d9938db7bf9ddae6ee40a3871fd5cb8702020a415","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1b94666753a5f70c2c97/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6fef795fcb90da390e24fc14fb07b0e1fae3b1e7c002be6c79f061e28c832567","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":2880,"textSha256":"f53279150048677683108bc626724ae7ee0aeb94a8da2a656354a5a1959bb209","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8"},{"ref":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5045cac4e1fdd38b62916765"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-ph/0409138","sourceId":"ev:42561062ee6ed21f464c7ead389879e9","sourceSha256":"f841c4fa0f3e4ba26fdd984d9938db7bf9ddae6ee40a3871fd5cb8702020a415","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1b94666753a5f70c2c97/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6fef795fcb90da390e24fc14fb07b0e1fae3b1e7c002be6c79f061e28c832567","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2026,"textSha256":"109a7c1a4bb6f6b1c175df395087517f468fe9f3f083fffe5b1a6d3e60990d39","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-ph/0409138","sourceId":"ev:8431ccca320b33b8d6cc4356beb462d2","sourceSha256":"f841c4fa0f3e4ba26fdd984d9938db7bf9ddae6ee40a3871fd5cb8702020a415","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1b94666753a5f70c2c97/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6fef795fcb90da390e24fc14fb07b0e1fae3b1e7c002be6c79f061e28c832567","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":2880,"textSha256":"f53279150048677683108bc626724ae7ee0aeb94a8da2a656354a5a1959bb209","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d16","originalRef":"l16","status":"route","source":"s9","target":"s27","type":"application_of","title":"Relate natural-like and alignment inflation to axion period and range mechanisms","rationale":"The original statements explicitly identify natural-like and alignment applications of range questions, with additional potential and control requirements. The applied inflation question therefore points to the period and enhancement question.","qualification":"Apply this connection only to the relevant period or range mechanisms, without assigning every natural-like or chiral-gauge construction an enhancement mechanism. Preserve explicit absence of monodromy in the alignment branch; monodromy is not established for the chiral-gauge description. Axion period, effective decay constant and proper trajectory length differ. Potential generation, condensate backreaction, gravitational effects and EFT control require their own checks. Strong-coupling control in the universal-axion natural branch is unresolved, and alignment and chiral-dynamics support is description-only.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l16","s9","s27"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d16","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Natural-like and alignment inflation are explicitly presented as applications requiring their own potential and control checks, supporting s9 → s27. The qualification preserves non-monodromic alignment, uncertain chiral-gauge classification and unresolved strong-coupling control without assigning every branch a common enhancement mechanism.","refs":["l16","s9","s27"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l16","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l17":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l17","source":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8","target":"q025-candidate-question:897ff5bc3babcd74cbc0c530","type":"premise_check","title":"Check the criteria and assumptions behind proposed period restrictions","rationale":"When period or enhancement arguments import a decay-constant/action restriction, the criterion's formulation and applicability are prerequisites. The conditional range inference must therefore point to the criteria question, reversing the original premise-check arrow.","qualification":"This route applies only when such a restriction is invoked; ordinary period calculations do not universally assume it. Match the required scalar content, instanton and action assumptions, long-distance regime and normalization. Scalar-potential inequalities are not scalar-mediated instanton interaction conditions. Exact period examples neither establish the proposed criterion nor settle its numerical coefficient. The selected asymptotic Type IIA tests do not check a sharp WGC coefficient or extend to arbitrary moduli paths, and the proposed criteria are not universal established laws.","evidenceIds":["unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","unit:0aacb2f51d637ca4427e2def670018cb6de3b695d8dbfae5455552c89c072966","unit:0c3f3015e522cb5f88f02bf32ff273ae9843658d0fdaad4eb067d8c5304faf36","unit:104260b9a56d84ab04eb5d7e114008be579d8f8bb3e8a508774e0ae73ad6a649","unit:10ec2b4baf0ee06c640c0b17912b0c889ca8b1dc6374175fdfa3a4f80bba3865","unit:15881326939cd7a493b0f3dcbfd35885a47bcc1985e669f0ca6919f9849953bf","unit:16516a56d3ac8e73bc13cb49617cdde9977dcccd4518ab1af0dafa31402f05d8","unit:185882e036f4b54e603fa4541e6d0d126a6a25ebe9b19dcd93193fdaeee81b93","unit:1fb3ddfa526bf36841aa82ec0d8ed6e796523054d2e2313b09b8bf37024dfd2e","unit:2472aa7f6431071a7ecfd145294b3acc1b55c8f5dd05e532b58afaca295edef5","unit:2a5415c009e4ebfc381ff601f91eea9ff6f766f8fbbe3a98c50f5e5d68fa16a5","unit:36f38a0bcfe9b654ecb7a0cf1f78b8db9a38da51786d7cba3deb93177ef94253","unit:53eddd61d2fa628502ee2ee0f60ecf3e4794ebb47bb5839119f002ddf6011267","unit:5580f57a353a06beeb3fa735e95ed8cacbb43ebc2939a83d965b30542073bb5c","unit:5b8b77361824dcc686ca693c4425197ddf0ff020b24af62897d86784f1cbad9b","unit:71995227ec6bbc1a9ae11ea627ea7b5c2c071ebd83a281337a32c5ce4c997f00","unit:73cbff6e91a5b915cae72adbfa11a71e5fee228ec0bb99a41bdc972f52aa7504","unit:94b8fdab3c4a221ee3acc81ba24b997229d8e49df6640539ed508ea927d37a01","unit:ae3dcc4c47d85c1abd39f45f0abaa5d697b5293829d6e5c7860e383a9fd287c8","unit:c40a86235cd7c595290180eb708f8bc59e1fbe2c543b61756bd61226e53bc745","unit:c42e4c3ccbf820a5df4a7428a47b4eee4fba7245bd7e17d0c9aa81014d08bcca","unit:c6c86df782561dcce60ac528d3d4dc67d6575ad8ad7091b986a1faf68f273f77","unit:cd9abab268e90728671e680b9aa49084a5c0d8a657b7eddd9f17d726a9e6aa79","unit:d18b2bac4da18f878d8f9a0663ddda680cdee4e108ba2c8083aa7dbbda01cb71","unit:d1e0189cb1c9032a1ca8e475132eb6492a2a476bda7c8998a16b126e3c9bb972","unit:d2da26a218c4979098de4495b2613dbc1325978e454aa6fff68acd8b2eb67616","unit:e450c25cc320cec8ed849b63fba16ced512405b2a63b1320f5ff2466fa539063","unit:efb8179652cb838f3a7c8812145553616d4b9274ce7d13a81cfac102b0b6764b","unit:f208201c60b72fdd70b35c7d69c3fedc571c52d157cc73bfad2b7e23b0636649","unit:fd36b395fa2112b50ab90ad9277c4995601fbc01745ad016309e652c75ae826e","unit:fe24f21300fba4f511139d03921cc978ec067dc5643d0a5593fbd5f62c50bd7e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8","scopeContentSha256":"6772c8784bb9ededfa73ae2dc0229bdfc4fd39f98408c3cfa6337a6830ea11be","localRef":"s27"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:897ff5bc3babcd74cbc0c530","scopeContentSha256":"4662a0d9b8e1a265e91017441f977c008df0b762fdfa205b54ae0acf8831e78a","localRef":"s18"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l17","originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:42","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l17","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:42","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:897ff5bc3babcd74cbc0c530","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l17","source":"s18","target":"s27","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["A proposed decay-constant/action restriction requires its scalar and instanton assumptions before application to period questions. Exact period examples alone neither establish that criterion nor settle its numerical coefficient."],"challengeStatement":"Importing a decay-constant/action restriction requires matching scalar, instanton and normalization assumptions. Exact-period examples alone do not establish the proposed criterion.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:897ff5bc3babcd74cbc0c530"},{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8"},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"2609.16165","sourceId":"ev:5bc83767ef53efa14e2bd565c3f357b7","sourceSha256":"3daa83ba57e861c619c6afba3c86a9308f5d6a4a3f64f49aa8a7cd52ddf5f45b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6b37d54dc4c3a918a910/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3edcd370702c2f1baf4019b80c68d5b49849efe3ab70e073ed5458154e0b7618","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2035,"textSha256":"86ed2813e952b29119cec4584b63b49bd411edec5f70344ee6e89fc9917271e9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2609.16165","sourceId":"ev:8925f412cffa65285e8cca4eaaed3ae2","sourceSha256":"3daa83ba57e861c619c6afba3c86a9308f5d6a4a3f64f49aa8a7cd52ddf5f45b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6b37d54dc4c3a918a910/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3edcd370702c2f1baf4019b80c68d5b49849efe3ab70e073ed5458154e0b7618","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2085,"textSha256":"1b4679cb48ff470ea5206476f7a2f11040f902e6274341d8ef4767a5cbebcb4c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1601.00647","sourceId":"ev:7e19bb86af50dc794fa8d5366a00240e","sourceSha256":"af73d72b99cfe98fd808e7068b325f4ed5de98f9f286fa3145deb86ee6a04e28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/46b944d680584c1d27be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"02c858afb93dddff0c9a69d7b63832fd3126ea2006bd5f6c141412e80a48a013","pdfPage":3,"start":1299,"end":3222,"textSha256":"046448ce8c5f4a4a778061f1cd53684813e1ebb6728afa1494eba16b2fad8143","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"1601.00647","sourceId":"ev:c0c1b5ba4099d90f79fa887ea66e098b","sourceSha256":"af73d72b99cfe98fd808e7068b325f4ed5de98f9f286fa3145deb86ee6a04e28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/46b944d680584c1d27be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"02c858afb93dddff0c9a69d7b63832fd3126ea2006bd5f6c141412e80a48a013","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2776,"textSha256":"0beb1b9ed093485e222a6a1661ad6fadd8de5269dca74298714c57a6349abb9a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:897ff5bc3babcd74cbc0c530"},{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b4e72d1e5154d5d9e59989d8"},{"ref":"e3","kind":"primary","paperId":"2609.16165","sourceId":"ev:5bc83767ef53efa14e2bd565c3f357b7","sourceSha256":"3daa83ba57e861c619c6afba3c86a9308f5d6a4a3f64f49aa8a7cd52ddf5f45b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6b37d54dc4c3a918a910/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3edcd370702c2f1baf4019b80c68d5b49849efe3ab70e073ed5458154e0b7618","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2035,"textSha256":"86ed2813e952b29119cec4584b63b49bd411edec5f70344ee6e89fc9917271e9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2609.16165","sourceId":"ev:8925f412cffa65285e8cca4eaaed3ae2","sourceSha256":"3daa83ba57e861c619c6afba3c86a9308f5d6a4a3f64f49aa8a7cd52ddf5f45b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6b37d54dc4c3a918a910/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3edcd370702c2f1baf4019b80c68d5b49849efe3ab70e073ed5458154e0b7618","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2085,"textSha256":"1b4679cb48ff470ea5206476f7a2f11040f902e6274341d8ef4767a5cbebcb4c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1601.00647","sourceId":"ev:7e19bb86af50dc794fa8d5366a00240e","sourceSha256":"af73d72b99cfe98fd808e7068b325f4ed5de98f9f286fa3145deb86ee6a04e28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/46b944d680584c1d27be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"02c858afb93dddff0c9a69d7b63832fd3126ea2006bd5f6c141412e80a48a013","pdfPage":3,"start":1299,"end":3222,"textSha256":"046448ce8c5f4a4a778061f1cd53684813e1ebb6728afa1494eba16b2fad8143","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"1601.00647","sourceId":"ev:c0c1b5ba4099d90f79fa887ea66e098b","sourceSha256":"af73d72b99cfe98fd808e7068b325f4ed5de98f9f286fa3145deb86ee6a04e28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/46b944d680584c1d27be/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"02c858afb93dddff0c9a69d7b63832fd3126ea2006bd5f6c141412e80a48a013","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2776,"textSha256":"0beb1b9ed093485e222a6a1661ad6fadd8de5269dca74298714c57a6349abb9a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d17","originalRef":"l17","status":"route","source":"s27","target":"s18","type":"premise_check","title":"Check the criteria and assumptions behind proposed period restrictions","rationale":"When period or enhancement arguments import a decay-constant/action restriction, the criterion's formulation and applicability are prerequisites. The conditional range inference must therefore point to the criteria question, reversing the original premise-check arrow.","qualification":"This route applies only when such a restriction is invoked; ordinary period calculations do not universally assume it. Match the required scalar content, instanton and action assumptions, long-distance regime and normalization. Scalar-potential inequalities are not scalar-mediated instanton interaction conditions. Exact period examples neither establish the proposed criterion nor settle its numerical coefficient. The selected asymptotic Type IIA tests do not check a sharp WGC coefficient or extend to arbitrary moduli paths, and the proposed criteria are not universal established laws.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l17","s27","s18"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d17","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"A range inference importing a proposed restriction must check the criterion's assumptions, so s27 → s18 is the correct premise-check direction. The record preserves scalar, instanton, action and normalization matching and does not make the criterion a premise of ordinary period calculations.","refs":["l17","s27","s18"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l17","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l18":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l18","source":"q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd","target":"q025-candidate-question:897ff5bc3babcd74cbc0c530","type":"application_of","title":"Trace conditional inflation and coupling tests to their axion criteria","rationale":"Applying criteria to inflation and couplings is distinct from defining or testing their content and strength. For the criteria shared by these endpoints, s26 is the application and s18 supplies the underlying proposals.","qualification":"The connection covers only applicable axion-criterion branches of s26; its additional EFT, entropy, de Sitter, distance, TCC and other tests are not all derived from s18. Preserve electric, magnetic, scalar, massive-force and different WGC variants, including their spectrum, scalar, normalization and regime assumptions. Parametric consistency is not a sharp-coefficient test, and scalar-potential proposals are not interaction-based conditions. Geometric cases and exceptions remain local to each test; neither small f nor a conditional obstruction establishes a universal trajectory bound or exclusion of axion inflation.","evidenceIds":["unit:05152456b2163e9b78f9d67050bd02702f3e77364c5caed9f13a65375affead6","unit:089741721f36735b166e321ed8443a5b7c5194e0d0ef6b8859996254d24c7f36","unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","unit:0c3f3015e522cb5f88f02bf32ff273ae9843658d0fdaad4eb067d8c5304faf36","unit:15881326939cd7a493b0f3dcbfd35885a47bcc1985e669f0ca6919f9849953bf","unit:185882e036f4b54e603fa4541e6d0d126a6a25ebe9b19dcd93193fdaeee81b93","unit:2d820845c3ca6b0948ada47de2971cc30f566a31dbed8a3b748a86d787f61dd2","unit:3300254a04e2d27a5f3e6f762f081f70596c1a38b695d373adb6e558415534cb","unit:4a1403670591dc9e626826441942ce7596e96825b8d1ca73b16000e6b43abc52","unit:4e7765f4f9f4e397b94cafc5f3ba8f0e0a0d1ecb9a64e51f8e51428ba2abde7f","unit:516ba22ae98d4ab839734f663957f42c8d1c148d43962151dda57a5891be05da","unit:5580f57a353a06beeb3fa735e95ed8cacbb43ebc2939a83d965b30542073bb5c","unit:56bf260292382ba6b171f22d6ecaf87bc0bedbf827e9924624927b89464aec8d","unit:5f5acebe2dc1df1ad97272a28776c9bcc2f118e8fffa0fc2ae81cccdc7831a69","unit:69b3a487be496c140ef5324a8bd1ffd3ffd1e1b1fe4708203d6e3c6f420f5920","unit:710d31bef16e17618c60a36d3a6820339e61f190aa594ee888402661bab308df","unit:71995227ec6bbc1a9ae11ea627ea7b5c2c071ebd83a281337a32c5ce4c997f00","unit:73cbff6e91a5b915cae72adbfa11a71e5fee228ec0bb99a41bdc972f52aa7504","unit:806fb9dbceedc7746e4bf49d2bf83bfa907d6c07ec02ffdd57a3a69df5f48904","unit:8b621155d712bd5ccf62dcb7b209d8d6561dfd9e04c271f206fbdf32aa6a2a5e","unit:8e34bd7382e88e1bdf6e0e00924028f2eaf8f304a1df35bf441856fda3419ffa","unit:90ebf5f92864e10383e36dabb9e0bbecd9ad77ddd42b9ab00fe909a956f89319","unit:94b8fdab3c4a221ee3acc81ba24b997229d8e49df6640539ed508ea927d37a01","unit:9722f05525b43a2e281cf0d8c0dfd28b0afc58f8d63d39dfd0c8d0978471e812","unit:993088d7dfeb08a10b30a288f12211ab962e91635a66bd902a5ce75943b7624b","unit:a3c67f696ef9eaafcab3b09bec99b9d5d4a6b6b2f1d887e30ef4a62b4622252d","unit:ae3dcc4c47d85c1abd39f45f0abaa5d697b5293829d6e5c7860e383a9fd287c8","unit:b94bbd51efd5f2d3dbb843d83c0e54b0c28e85d8ba2615bdd7bb09ad8313e201","unit:c42e4c3ccbf820a5df4a7428a47b4eee4fba7245bd7e17d0c9aa81014d08bcca","unit:c6c86df782561dcce60ac528d3d4dc67d6575ad8ad7091b986a1faf68f273f77","unit:cae501c9faa183c5c6ab2faed7aac5e0920d09c6d18b3695bedbc9e1b50ac4ba","unit:cd9abab268e90728671e680b9aa49084a5c0d8a657b7eddd9f17d726a9e6aa79","unit:d18b2bac4da18f878d8f9a0663ddda680cdee4e108ba2c8083aa7dbbda01cb71","unit:d292d20ab3b91a5fb79c2feb94992264f9abc03f28c249d475b71386fc684a06","unit:d2da26a218c4979098de4495b2613dbc1325978e454aa6fff68acd8b2eb67616","unit:e450c25cc320cec8ed849b63fba16ced512405b2a63b1320f5ff2466fa539063","unit:e95c5104ebe75500827ba7d5b7559c993b431335aca56550b91916df0d720bc0","unit:eb19bb063d1bfb70b4d8b52a4787ba551e6ee0ab71764f1df0d7d610495b244e","unit:fe24f21300fba4f511139d03921cc978ec067dc5643d0a5593fbd5f62c50bd7e","unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd","scopeContentSha256":"7d9d96e78da885b873119f7761b68d7d9d83239838c2086498214ba3aa8734a2","localRef":"s26"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:897ff5bc3babcd74cbc0c530","scopeContentSha256":"4662a0d9b8e1a265e91017441f977c008df0b762fdfa205b54ae0acf8831e78a","localRef":"s18"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l18","originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:26","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l18","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:26","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:897ff5bc3babcd74cbc0c530","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l18","source":"s18","target":"s26","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Applying conditional criteria to inflation and couplings is distinct from defining or testing the criteria themselves; the application card also includes non-WGC tests."],"challengeStatement":"Applying criteria to inflation and couplings differs from defining their content or strength. The application scope also includes other conditional EFT and quantum-gravity tests.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:897ff5bc3babcd74cbc0c530"},{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:897ff5bc3babcd74cbc0c530"},{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d18","originalRef":"l18","status":"route","source":"s26","target":"s18","type":"application_of","title":"Trace conditional inflation and coupling tests to their axion criteria","rationale":"Applying criteria to inflation and couplings is distinct from defining or testing their content and strength. For the criteria shared by these endpoints, s26 is the application and s18 supplies the underlying proposals.","qualification":"The connection covers only applicable axion-criterion branches of s26; its additional EFT, entropy, de Sitter, distance, TCC and other tests are not all derived from s18. Preserve electric, magnetic, scalar, massive-force and different WGC variants, including their spectrum, scalar, normalization and regime assumptions. Parametric consistency is not a sharp-coefficient test, and scalar-potential proposals are not interaction-based conditions. Geometric cases and exceptions remain local to each test; neither small f nor a conditional obstruction establishes a universal trajectory bound or exclusion of axion inflation.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l18","s26","s18"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d18","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Applying axion criteria to inflation and couplings points from s26 to their formulation in s18. The record correctly restricts this application to shared criteria, preserving their distinct assumptions while leaving the additional non-WGC and EFT tests in s26 outside the asserted derivation.","refs":["l18","s26","s18"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l18","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l19":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l19","source":"q025-candidate-question:eb40b8307a12406a757cc9fa","target":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","type":"method_for","title":"Use brane, modulus and flux dynamics to determine inflationary potentials","rationale":"Both original statements identify brane dynamics, modulus response and flux choices as approaches to determining potential shape and multifield evolution. These methods serve the trajectory and observable questions.","qualification":"Keep fractional-power, flattening, plateau, scaling and multiple-axion mechanisms distinct, including their potential coefficients and initial conditions. Single-field and multifield evolution, and small- and large-field descriptions, are not interchangeable. A favorable shape supplies neither cutoff or spectator control nor a complete stable trajectory, sufficient duration or exit. The route does not merge hybrid, chain and other inflationary scenarios; observational comparisons remain source-dated rather than a current global fit.","evidenceIds":["unit:089741721f36735b166e321ed8443a5b7c5194e0d0ef6b8859996254d24c7f36","unit:0f741c02bbae28e4099f4b85590230d3558377f4e21daf676ab986ba82031002","unit:1250ebeed54952b26e25c8f332139d3b5fe4bc9bfc721c64241683ee0dc8e9d7","unit:13fff5545063255f2448c6dfee410e9df4c329abe8319bf87872deb125a9fcec","unit:15797ea2f72a5446d5a60e230e6d20503ce549c77a4de146a47a2c2d4d28676d","unit:1ed7acfa72460537797b28b9b2d74edad7cf2561d853678d6bf9bc422607b904","unit:1fa1d6965b2b4d15843ec9bfa4b8e9ea0e198a2dc8df4f761d029449f24c3260","unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","unit:26ea6818f7ce05e2e20dd0077fc343589292de168548b050ac2802f7fc2efe89","unit:2acf2e165d284872cc674da3477d42164092f746d47c1ccc727f20fba6ee4e7d","unit:360f186d6fb696c05871d35f590905c504ab190c5396b5e1bda349043206cf3a","unit:39d73bca80a56ea22a73711654b127662488b2a7dd56c6189cef65a4b8707b07","unit:4068ceb643876e29d8afca37189b823a880fb47541ebd8cfe6f7de0840d50ebf","unit:43e08751f478cf3ad715cd966544aafa1dce1db79f0cfef60358984c89fe631f","unit:440e9c79ce25f6b4bfee58231d3ee8e17d54c8c3dfc576b57380eda6da4e9785","unit:44c4cb36779d40cd065031fe74d3171faf148f868aeaae6ce7b56c2e9ccf157c","unit:4a1403670591dc9e626826441942ce7596e96825b8d1ca73b16000e6b43abc52","unit:53bf2a5e8129d30faba8f8a17ff0fd94fa21b3c96247e3a026580aa96083e23a","unit:58bdb4c80701d53da220dae66740f1e27a74dc08b74f679c81691ccc424a2a0d","unit:5d7f7e18aa16e6086bf4413b8b97dbc3c83c8b04b571a792a122e746e42ead7c","unit:69b3a487be496c140ef5324a8bd1ffd3ffd1e1b1fe4708203d6e3c6f420f5920","unit:79401bdb6e9b39bdda4a68d35ec78bf65921e348a480ffd55e9ee7da741e7c67","unit:7a16c6358397efbdeb773b01d136b33c4ade2a593369be237424ac16ba04916a","unit:7b194abe4bcf98640e000727b1cea7787f60534195647e780bb5aabff5144731","unit:7d5f73f7367b73d9fd1e3030efc6f5a9291fca13480a67e2a8b5fce40a24eb24","unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","unit:8813193476478867455e89227605fa910549b354a8c0ca92097661d8c788e278","unit:8e34bd7382e88e1bdf6e0e00924028f2eaf8f304a1df35bf441856fda3419ffa","unit:90ebf5f92864e10383e36dabb9e0bbecd9ad77ddd42b9ab00fe909a956f89319","unit:96ae24c93aa28d1c62aae68e9d06f1b01dd88f0bffaafd87c953745a7e66e80a","unit:a7951b1a1bf3c3b2a19ae12c1a96332fa73b002b005e1cf099296e057dfa6a10","unit:ae2ea5e7a3f91f3b95e18e544d9cc75cdd3b7cd75f96739d2f8c0c069f980c67","unit:b94bbd51efd5f2d3dbb843d83c0e54b0c28e85d8ba2615bdd7bb09ad8313e201","unit:c8a0cbdaa81406781d2e38deed4608ac08851cea5ee2c57d4ea35b7fa4594133","unit:c97c2fdf4b625d6b05aed7db080ed871d5b4b4b54120c5c33ccd916ad2418103","unit:ce9e8c6172f7206e22f7b4b25ca052f00790b1618260c45369038e97e84ca9a2","unit:e163f9233750831cb88e35aa05ec7de30973d42424819d9c121f1ac3b85e9e71","unit:e50105d51ef65387e4e82eaf2f653c33b204dc8fd44466599fd4b1a11661f07c","unit:e8c0a0bffd5b08931037fafc4f60b51a9c3f1973750a35405bcdcded2eaab51b","unit:e939b85fd8032f3623d09b5325d5eea82a6aa2a737944a77df56db3679dcbe67","unit:eb19bb063d1bfb70b4d8b52a4787ba551e6ee0ab71764f1df0d7d610495b244e","unit:f185332de23766b66a802f2bede69479f1849089774b79ca0687079cab79d78c","unit:f6a4df371b8b0c027eda1620205eb32aecdd1f83e2c1625a76801ccef8ec8753","unit:f8962ddc433bf1350ed10f04ddbf21bad607d46051aeb454498945d741eff768","unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:eb40b8307a12406a757cc9fa","scopeContentSha256":"39ff735137f8048d85d666d2e1f1ba6769fa3aeb3e8208c11e35567ad32a9198","localRef":"s36"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","scopeContentSha256":"5e6c90cc5733aced848abc6aeafcd6daa829b97d761364bc71ea7803d1df1dd6","localRef":"s23"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l19","originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:20","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l19","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:20","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:eb40b8307a12406a757cc9fa","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l19","source":"s23","target":"s36","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Brane dynamics, modulus response and flux choices are approaches to determining potential shape and multifield trajectories; a favorable shape does not establish control."],"challengeStatement":"Brane dynamics, modulus response and flux choices help determine potential shape and multifield evolution; favorable shape alone does not establish control.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c"},{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:eb40b8307a12406a757cc9fa"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceId":"ev:6fbfc7c06218d1d003c92a9d3fd374a3","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"d6edb05265bfd680fcf58e49ee05b7dbfe68c6b77f17ac6c6b0970f6aa23b9ce","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c"},{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:eb40b8307a12406a757cc9fa"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceId":"ev:6fbfc7c06218d1d003c92a9d3fd374a3","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"d6edb05265bfd680fcf58e49ee05b7dbfe68c6b77f17ac6c6b0970f6aa23b9ce","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d19","originalRef":"l19","status":"route","source":"s36","target":"s23","type":"method_for","title":"Use brane, modulus and flux dynamics to determine inflationary potentials","rationale":"Both original statements identify brane dynamics, modulus response and flux choices as approaches to determining potential shape and multifield evolution. These methods serve the trajectory and observable questions.","qualification":"Keep fractional-power, flattening, plateau, scaling and multiple-axion mechanisms distinct, including their potential coefficients and initial conditions. Single-field and multifield evolution, and small- and large-field descriptions, are not interchangeable. A favorable shape supplies neither cutoff or spectator control nor a complete stable trajectory, sufficient duration or exit. The route does not merge hybrid, chain and other inflationary scenarios; observational comparisons remain source-dated rather than a current global fit.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l19","s36","s23"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d19","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Brane dynamics, modulus response and flux choices supply the stated methods for potential and trajectory questions, supporting s36 → s23. The qualification preserves distinct mechanisms and denies that favorable shape alone establishes control, complete evolution or observational viability.","refs":["l19","s36","s23"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l19","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l20":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l20","source":"q025-candidate-question:8fbd10f22ab4653f85c3d8a9","target":"q025-candidate-question:e7f1f7e0dfa9ec3de0d57a1e","type":"method_for","title":"Check monodromy starting points with flux-vacuum and numerical methods","rationale":"Vacuum construction and numerical reliability can supply starting-point checks for inflationary constructions. The supporting vacuum-computation question therefore points to the monodromy construction question.","qualification":"Apply only to monodromy constructions that use the relevant flux-vacuum ingredients and hierarchies; s20 also contains targets beyond inflation and monodromy. Retain tree-level and model-specific stabilization assumptions, integer-flux restrictions, and the qualified status of effective rational-flux scans. The described positive minima occupy different landscape branches rather than a continuous uplift of the original AdS minimum. A stable vacuum, setting-level stabilization claim or scan establishes neither global compactification nor an inflationary trajectory, and cannot automatically be transferred to every question from the same source.","evidenceIds":["unit:140b3a523f0bcabd9cceddeaf88f1637614ca6a40a70c5fb411131505321ee02","unit:22e5ec66e00db5367153d28f76ced7f94296cd566296cb58696efb43d0c85a43","unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","unit:25d18c6e50abd9338849640ded0d4fa4d8a88cae4c6d75ecf757465d6692d665","unit:360f186d6fb696c05871d35f590905c504ab190c5396b5e1bda349043206cf3a","unit:4280a9997fa9bce959e29c0e0b884b8a7f2cf98990583a72ffa337b9621400ba","unit:53bf2a5e8129d30faba8f8a17ff0fd94fa21b3c96247e3a026580aa96083e23a","unit:5885ca7377c8a47b4792f55bf07368c1830a042674fee672923b92ca8a13e5a5","unit:6ae168479f8b7403955c468a7f7cb5af03a5a3ceeb95836dc598ae2fa1562935","unit:7b194abe4bcf98640e000727b1cea7787f60534195647e780bb5aabff5144731","unit:9b3a25ae335112ce544d932aef8a713a361ac3bb3d4edd2c88402c4bab50752e","unit:a2fe8916034090315b510a4bfa9d61585f4a21f732589d70584aced15acf0f64","unit:a3dafc31c72c964ef5877a204ffb0f9a11f227ea7ac132a29c69f11b12b62819","unit:a534fb598f77ae2d0285862d752530bd98d9f1a9f367ed3584a6ae148119094a","unit:ada147e3d763277ce23584cb79825409ada4200825b2e7df029057248d44ec28","unit:af2e052d9530868d5fcd5aa5824eed5fe147778a90cff8799d14b803ad79fcb7","unit:b1483427933eecccc5ae0ae9b367e49aca455e879cfde8bfebde38a9003a60d6","unit:b6f16126a8df0660481b3e9a274dffa137a4396f76b43e99033ca07ca0a3e36e","unit:bf40421712b0d217a22c6d4bf39582855ec9be408acbdc6f3ce29e123b2b3792","unit:e1e86df574b94fe9886673b36619ad32d038b310c240a3c25c92f197d83e452b","unit:ed213e8733a265277001f044df867dc39bff8c00e1eff18ea6bd5f9cf4f0b38a","unit:fa4daec4d6482245ec3bc5df595f21ec1ec74fcc05686495f2e7b5c5c792d5aa"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8fbd10f22ab4653f85c3d8a9","scopeContentSha256":"8fe661c3d6fe163cbb7fe3ef168f8b6d2acce34cfc69ceb79b203b967f751f8a","localRef":"s20"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e7f1f7e0dfa9ec3de0d57a1e","scopeContentSha256":"50aa6ffa517e52a913f94e4dd0b1066b80e546177137edb108db91ada43f38f9","localRef":"s34"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l20","originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:38","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l20","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:38","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:e7f1f7e0dfa9ec3de0d57a1e","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:8fbd10f22ab4653f85c3d8a9","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l20","source":"s34","target":"s20","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Vacuum construction and numerical reliability can support inflationary starting points; a stable vacuum or a setting-level stabilization statement does not establish an inflationary trajectory."],"challengeStatement":"Vacuum construction and numerical reliability can supply starting-point checks. A stable vacuum or setting-level stabilization claim does not establish inflationary evolution.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e7f1f7e0dfa9ec3de0d57a1e"},{"ref":"x3_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8fbd10f22ab4653f85c3d8a9"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e7f1f7e0dfa9ec3de0d57a1e"},{"ref":"x3_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8fbd10f22ab4653f85c3d8a9"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d20","originalRef":"l20","status":"route","source":"s20","target":"s34","type":"method_for","title":"Check monodromy starting points with flux-vacuum and numerical methods","rationale":"Vacuum construction and numerical reliability can supply starting-point checks for inflationary constructions. The supporting vacuum-computation question therefore points to the monodromy construction question.","qualification":"Apply only to monodromy constructions that use the relevant flux-vacuum ingredients and hierarchies; s20 also contains targets beyond inflation and monodromy. Retain tree-level and model-specific stabilization assumptions, integer-flux restrictions, and the qualified status of effective rational-flux scans. The described positive minima occupy different landscape branches rather than a continuous uplift of the original AdS minimum. A stable vacuum, setting-level stabilization claim or scan establishes neither global compactification nor an inflationary trajectory, and cannot automatically be transferred to every question from the same source.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l20","s20","s34"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d20","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Vacuum construction and numerical reliability provide starting-point methods for relevant monodromy constructions, supporting s20 → s34. The record retains model and flux restrictions, separate landscape branches and the distinction between stabilization, global compactification and an inflationary trajectory.","refs":["l20","s20","s34"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l20","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l21":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l21","source":"q025-candidate-question:8797b30fb1ba4a3e6d919907","target":"q025-candidate-question:78f3617807c684358cebb301","type":"application_of","title":"Relate exotic-brane observability to its duality-monodromy construction","rationale":"The original statements identify exotic-brane observability and gravitational visibility as physical-consequence questions for specified duality monodromies. The applied question therefore points to the duality framework.","qualification":"This connection concerns the monodromy-related branch, not every far-field reconstruction or Casimir-supported core question. Retain source-specific codimension, tension, supersymmetry, held-fixed data and asymptotics. Flat, AdS and asymptotically locally flat settings are alternatives rather than simultaneous premises, and the visibility argument needs suitable configurations outside an event horizon. Core replacement and antibrane flux-cloaking tests remain distinct. Conjectural dualities retain their source-date status, and a duality map does not establish a dynamical transition. The R7 and Casimir questions have description-only support.","evidenceIds":["unit:0f3e5941991d75065de8c16b226277994eb9925b3976db57a5291597209e1204","unit:19e3d97dc2b3913cffbeb6612f3ee920dd16d25ad5380abb3c29881c0bcaff50","unit:1fb343410ddd80424a3a4434e5ae6de0db16771ec926666d54088611a8fa2688","unit:20617f551f77912588e17034973fea315ae0eb2293fa76dfb79c9b1636dd0dab","unit:325501eba8d44c9d596b4e61c0face4958339bcc5f8b8365e20d7567e19511ec","unit:3ab6b6fc857c7396b9083c8622adfd0294af03e6425dc939b5cdc2f8624c086f","unit:48b495a48d7084c6c23b5bcf20a2f4252c0e38b0c81814179b2aca31e19b20e6","unit:4bdddffefe9171c4d3aa4941e88ae59a42d5dfb85590821a356892afb2e11712","unit:4dbfb55614117620c14c9b01996a828a7be9d0a41398dbedbfdb3d1ab32d26ff","unit:51c9ec61b6161eeb7419d43429e31eba86910c5e34016f89f7298d5c70165ad3","unit:5c38dec44f67763f219e1d7c6746dfff153c7dab198f79d87f22e332ef331d77","unit:6011982cffbb5eea6bd56af46092cc7d81075f67bd1982fd4e17ad72d599072c","unit:60fda2fa93af519b7964403dde9c27133d61f7e61f7b16d950765805ee641b09","unit:65364f9d11897809ef4de8ad69ef1c870bec31b712dc8398480748a92d54aef8","unit:7d7dcca4506465882dbabc63c46bf111d9718e462d09341f167d2ab5e1697146","unit:7e3a11bcffc26d2fda99db1f177f9aabc362fb83c39e655be9e907acb432c809","unit:7f40bdb6420b161d1fb735ef0c2bf2c65d0628cae0970de05b629d52e654c383","unit:8140ad3d64c7c8fe7c55e7c7d7610d982ebaf4c3b20e6d878c90265c9cc19189","unit:867cd206499b2cb0dcf9c1fb906cd6572dcb360ea64497a35e34df957fd7b2ba","unit:962ee10c85476a3069beafe02c9a7c3374b8893d1b72c3e734ab453bbd4116d7","unit:a314b65939b01ed9ee7dbbe9ac601495e8c48c612e7fdc907bf18cf5f4f7d8d4","unit:a836cffb6e63079077d48d21d2cd9bf8afc41b7d298b9c0b37efbd4f1ff5c27e","unit:afc5a2b29192f7c45a4b6f1b725cde3fd0520e20541a496a936ffcb148569053","unit:b0182d226efdc80d21094e08a73c578e93bc475c04b8e781edfff6ff22d66f67","unit:b06903dfe4fbf34707a693555cff092a42c4f3fd6c3c5e0c23b7eb430cd4cbd8","unit:b91afb0d85006207139fa5af0899a7833201dd3bbbc5fab06876a8a394e94e77","unit:c2cbcf859ba196c41ba47dd002dfac017ca9988f1af068ca26ac57b3cc1183a3","unit:c8422d8813253812071671aa39c49fcb80e01b5f305088130ac984861181e9d3","unit:c8a05726d16ef134628ab4016cc55cbc668d78c8088cc61c854a93d57a87848f","unit:cf308bdc35f48194e5211b547b07496ce5638f6dd5127fe78c0ac62c4f858b6c","unit:e5992db82477dec2a666971974fd2fb3481a89d30bef10fe27d4986a8c668aa8","unit:e62ea71147dfd462fdb230def1451e97010d19b81b3f0ba17b2d49bbb1025a58","unit:ed1b555c5f866e8b8ba18fd59131e81a218b34a6d41b3d7b9f7ac3299b6c1563"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8797b30fb1ba4a3e6d919907","scopeContentSha256":"92ed54cd4875efbd1df3b5a97dc86823a6ca6bc92fcd3c6f2736127b1e65383b","localRef":"s15"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:78f3617807c684358cebb301","scopeContentSha256":"2f186155862c06c75cbbbf8f1420113a65095a58d46847450789684a87d9e0a5","localRef":"s14"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l21","originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:17","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l21","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:17","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:78f3617807c684358cebb301","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:8797b30fb1ba4a3e6d919907","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l21","source":"s14","target":"s15","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Observable monodromy and gravitational visibility test physical consequences in separately specified exotic-brane settings."],"challengeStatement":"Exotic-brane observability and gravitational visibility ask about consequences of duality monodromies in specified asymptotic settings.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"21496eadb83bfd89726e6068cb313c4459eb02b5c7319e3a443ecef8270fff51","reply.jsonSha256":"2b13522cde089dccca6ad5a606e861ba63c324f568607e4c375a0cc4bb41db20","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c36a6e5deffe73ebc0b1e16be7efeacce3b5a91518427e213f2adceb5abec192","receipt.jsonSha256":"1ac3619b922316ab9daed0b834a08152271b89bff3673ca6a536ac321cd7466f","normalization.jsonSha256":"34b6a384ae3212b9f12a1af0a4c8b1577afc8d9d2f9c6739f7b3e4d4e90d2e8a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f23d8110109e2321e451a757253617422655ce2cba84255be89203e01dad788"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"44719832235d537d40d8c3f9fde7ff9934aad947d84f431af08131529e35cace","reply.jsonSha256":"ba3566417aebc92a1caeed4499b097fe44f303e7c53fb9665b12679327751a5b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ad4fdae6bffbb728f2978451b9900b4b2db3bee70853770a6186005751e27323","receipt.jsonSha256":"97a00e5fe99821077fd249a980950dbc16461262f4d8c9f2bca8b01c4a37abd0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7a8af76f3c278360ec57798a76e3899c73d387ea4d4b3a0d9d7a02a5e66f129a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:78f3617807c684358cebb301"},{"ref":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8797b30fb1ba4a3e6d919907"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:78f3617807c684358cebb301"},{"ref":"x3_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8797b30fb1ba4a3e6d919907"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d21","originalRef":"l21","status":"route","source":"s15","target":"s14","type":"application_of","title":"Relate exotic-brane observability to its duality-monodromy construction","rationale":"The original statements identify exotic-brane observability and gravitational visibility as physical-consequence questions for specified duality monodromies. The applied question therefore points to the duality framework.","qualification":"This connection concerns the monodromy-related branch, not every far-field reconstruction or Casimir-supported core question. Retain source-specific codimension, tension, supersymmetry, held-fixed data and asymptotics. Flat, AdS and asymptotically locally flat settings are alternatives rather than simultaneous premises, and the visibility argument needs suitable configurations outside an event horizon. Core replacement and antibrane flux-cloaking tests remain distinct. Conjectural dualities retain their source-date status, and a duality map does not establish a dynamical transition. The R7 and Casimir questions have description-only support.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l21","s15","s14"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d21","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original statements identify exotic-brane observability as a physical-consequence question for specified duality monodromies, supporting s15 → s14. The qualification limits the application to that branch and retains asymptotic, codimension, horizon and source-status restrictions.","refs":["l21","s15","s14"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l21","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l22":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l22","source":"q025-candidate-question:ad7564d73f8a5e16ff2aaa0f","target":"q025-candidate-question:1936949ab56cdeeaba762212","type":"method_for","title":"Apply spectral, modular and annulus diagnostics to string consistency","rationale":"Both original statements assign a bounded diagnostic role to spectral and modular analysis. The diagnostic question supplies methods to the broader spectra, amplitudes and consistency question.","qualification":"Retain the specified closed-string, open-string, orientifold and conformal-boundary settings, high-mass limits, one-loop order and direct/transverse channels. Tachyon absence and modular invariance are premises only where stated, and orientifold channel transformations need not preserve each amplitude separately. Averaged spectral cancellation, the physical vacuum integral and annulus bounds on boundary spectra or tension are distinct. These diagnostics establish neither complete vacuum stability nor a universal isolated-field cutoff. Their endpoint support is description-level.","evidenceIds":["unit:095845baefd9d38740382e9b1573f154ece8609057a4356ee7d9474daf39776b","unit:0f3e5941991d75065de8c16b226277994eb9925b3976db57a5291597209e1204","unit:12c92d943c39ef452fb559ce154b377bec9d17b75db1e6177307ce585a1c7fcf","unit:26668710500a3a1fe74021596311b9c6293f7c656d17be0a9d9eaec22f870f70","unit:2ada564fa4201c489e6e0b30a665404fd6979827ae1db07cb4cba44fed4cf651","unit:2fb7a3e1297ea4a814c986e277cb445f9c77b1752953c3b16ac680c8e8cc5a49","unit:3ab6b6fc857c7396b9083c8622adfd0294af03e6425dc939b5cdc2f8624c086f","unit:3b77f62fd61217040d6332ea170a6a1a14f13b8ac9b958f045ff6ba422693d99","unit:3d595a025aa80547c215b5251b211582aa9b8304485c088f52959727b0094487","unit:45573ef22b01f02367eb75fddd335d970e0c4231dcc923b14bd86f4d4a99649b","unit:4732c5df31471be11e2bafe278968796ea1cc138f7f0a29219ef4a908355f63d","unit:4feb7db665ac9da6665a1732b78d1bf3693721272228da077fd5c38449b7c976","unit:53f5a5c4ba25feda83d73457fe9773276b566a05bb920e862c494f6c0a15dedd","unit:5ffd5a032d00d3ccb189780038b1a4a5e91d85500c74d1845a2722e658995afe","unit:620bceefc313557a44d164007063d348a6eafb80c3477cfec2f5579c9fe788b4","unit:6d23f05e51c3d3d2e0463a26e9bc214ef9c48892a7af2bf94b10f3f970563245","unit:79c943f9fc291370bdf8c2a8b02f34b7cc47d088b09555c0179beffa03a8c0bb","unit:86e431f876a2058f1832701a12d2ac31c0b3b7809d75938462565f36345497b9","unit:8910cd688c793cba953d7b2d908791b4a94ff808e67d553ec39bc3d47126279a","unit:97b64eee4bd381741df8eea4ad6ea1b17f5295122a98cf96282c5bb776344ae7","unit:a8bfbea0d12e53aaf71fd38a2a9a806afd6845ed37d105ddd12110aaab30452b","unit:b5329ed656d4759683ec10b527811139321cf9d4f5b2fd679542bbd967b155dc","unit:bfb71bce8ecea39e4f761600d24a7c1203cc8b6f1ac9cf50b1efd8f975e90e83","unit:c2cbcf859ba196c41ba47dd002dfac017ca9988f1af068ca26ac57b3cc1183a3","unit:d0bcdb6e6c98c7206016141120efb32600dd5db99dfde6bfa406bfeed77073e0","unit:ea14f42ca1dd550c7559fd2f2edf16bb86123aa539ee761d7d6e19e52296bced","unit:ed821e5a265d1cc18112aba2d02d37e2e3a2a7dabfb8c387724734cfa693aa63","unit:f4529ce27b1d461091e29abe4a77e98625808351ea83ad998b5a5eef6bb33ac2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ad7564d73f8a5e16ff2aaa0f","scopeContentSha256":"9c1dec72082cabc2612bf4ad9b608fd4a1a775127416bad2f5f6a515a764c1bd","localRef":"s25"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1936949ab56cdeeaba762212","scopeContentSha256":"395fcef115c5b4b5d8bb6a108030cf14dcf0dd62936b166c4253ad29f5ada85b","localRef":"s0"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l22","originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:20","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l22","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:20","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:1936949ab56cdeeaba762212","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:ad7564d73f8a5e16ff2aaa0f","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l22","source":"s0","target":"s25","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Spectral and modular diagnostics address specific consistency tests without proving complete vacuum stability."],"challengeStatement":"Spectral and modular diagnostics supply bounded consistency tests, not a complete vacuum-stability criterion.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"21496eadb83bfd89726e6068cb313c4459eb02b5c7319e3a443ecef8270fff51","reply.jsonSha256":"2b13522cde089dccca6ad5a606e861ba63c324f568607e4c375a0cc4bb41db20","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c36a6e5deffe73ebc0b1e16be7efeacce3b5a91518427e213f2adceb5abec192","receipt.jsonSha256":"1ac3619b922316ab9daed0b834a08152271b89bff3673ca6a536ac321cd7466f","normalization.jsonSha256":"34b6a384ae3212b9f12a1af0a4c8b1577afc8d9d2f9c6739f7b3e4d4e90d2e8a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f23d8110109e2321e451a757253617422655ce2cba84255be89203e01dad788"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"44719832235d537d40d8c3f9fde7ff9934aad947d84f431af08131529e35cace","reply.jsonSha256":"ba3566417aebc92a1caeed4499b097fe44f303e7c53fb9665b12679327751a5b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ad4fdae6bffbb728f2978451b9900b4b2db3bee70853770a6186005751e27323","receipt.jsonSha256":"97a00e5fe99821077fd249a980950dbc16461262f4d8c9f2bca8b01c4a37abd0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7a8af76f3c278360ec57798a76e3899c73d387ea4d4b3a0d9d7a02a5e66f129a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1936949ab56cdeeaba762212"},{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ad7564d73f8a5e16ff2aaa0f"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1936949ab56cdeeaba762212"},{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ad7564d73f8a5e16ff2aaa0f"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d22","originalRef":"l22","status":"route","source":"s25","target":"s0","type":"method_for","title":"Apply spectral, modular and annulus diagnostics to string consistency","rationale":"Both original statements assign a bounded diagnostic role to spectral and modular analysis. The diagnostic question supplies methods to the broader spectra, amplitudes and consistency question.","qualification":"Retain the specified closed-string, open-string, orientifold and conformal-boundary settings, high-mass limits, one-loop order and direct/transverse channels. Tachyon absence and modular invariance are premises only where stated, and orientifold channel transformations need not preserve each amplitude separately. Averaged spectral cancellation, the physical vacuum integral and annulus bounds on boundary spectra or tension are distinct. These diagnostics establish neither complete vacuum stability nor a universal isolated-field cutoff. Their endpoint support is description-level.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l22","s25","s0"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d22","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Spectral, modular and annulus diagnostics supply bounded consistency methods, supporting s25 → s0. The record preserves channel, perturbative-order and background assumptions and distinguishes spectral cancellations from vacuum integrals, boundary bounds and complete stability.","refs":["l22","s25","s0"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l22","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l23":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l23","source":"q025-candidate-question:d4fa75073ce6216c2cafa3bc","target":"q025-candidate-question:1936949ab56cdeeaba762212","type":"method_for","title":"Use worldsheet, tadpole, anomaly and defect consistency tests","rationale":"The original statements identify these as distinct consistency methods. Their methodological direction runs from the specialized consistency question to the broader string-consistency question.","qualification":"Keep the specified open or unoriented, ten-dimensional nonsupersymmetric and six-dimensional defect settings separate, including compact/noncompact and BPS/non-BPS restrictions. Direct/transverse consistency is a prerequisite for the stated R-R anomaly analysis; R-R constraints do not replace NS-NS tadpole analysis. Local cancellation does not establish global anomaly freedom, and geometric and integral defect-charge bases may differ. Completeness motivates the cited defect probes without making their generality or conjectured null-defect existence a theorem. No unrestricted consistency proof follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:095845baefd9d38740382e9b1573f154ece8609057a4356ee7d9474daf39776b","unit:0f3e5941991d75065de8c16b226277994eb9925b3976db57a5291597209e1204","unit:0f616320b3bef472f21be8655c47b7a9633632f79edf920a56ed7c0958ae7d47","unit:26668710500a3a1fe74021596311b9c6293f7c656d17be0a9d9eaec22f870f70","unit:2ada564fa4201c489e6e0b30a665404fd6979827ae1db07cb4cba44fed4cf651","unit:2dd2398dc1d6b27f6f2ec972e531cdd4bd7afe60b6a18f74cbd1881038fd0ecc","unit:2fb7a3e1297ea4a814c986e277cb445f9c77b1752953c3b16ac680c8e8cc5a49","unit:3ab6b6fc857c7396b9083c8622adfd0294af03e6425dc939b5cdc2f8624c086f","unit:3b77f62fd61217040d6332ea170a6a1a14f13b8ac9b958f045ff6ba422693d99","unit:45573ef22b01f02367eb75fddd335d970e0c4231dcc923b14bd86f4d4a99649b","unit:45d705732a45d913797d79e6fdfe08a0707b0775fb1498fd282c22a8095eeb39","unit:4732c5df31471be11e2bafe278968796ea1cc138f7f0a29219ef4a908355f63d","unit:5ffd5a032d00d3ccb189780038b1a4a5e91d85500c74d1845a2722e658995afe","unit:620bceefc313557a44d164007063d348a6eafb80c3477cfec2f5579c9fe788b4","unit:657e6fe70b5a726a9aca722e51e57fe75353ae8d619857ddcbb1f968f40b60a1","unit:6d23f05e51c3d3d2e0463a26e9bc214ef9c48892a7af2bf94b10f3f970563245","unit:6e00d74766eff4c94793fdca342f800d44258b6224b309f4b387c11d046549ba","unit:79c943f9fc291370bdf8c2a8b02f34b7cc47d088b09555c0179beffa03a8c0bb","unit:86e431f876a2058f1832701a12d2ac31c0b3b7809d75938462565f36345497b9","unit:8910cd688c793cba953d7b2d908791b4a94ff808e67d553ec39bc3d47126279a","unit:89409c410ba6f06089a6ca9b2497fc8c3b5fc13d3bbf5cb4f704055f6d782a61","unit:97b64eee4bd381741df8eea4ad6ea1b17f5295122a98cf96282c5bb776344ae7","unit:a408e39a8b832cf91a2af6ab3b55a5a94008174137d91122d36668d63fbc15fb","unit:a8bfbea0d12e53aaf71fd38a2a9a806afd6845ed37d105ddd12110aaab30452b","unit:b0c43070087f8a4c15591064aea7fe0f253d97cc286d9de8f25f53ffff505ead","unit:b5329ed656d4759683ec10b527811139321cf9d4f5b2fd679542bbd967b155dc","unit:c2cbcf859ba196c41ba47dd002dfac017ca9988f1af068ca26ac57b3cc1183a3","unit:c7a19446adf5d15a443ad4201a849233b246175d7cde6f962e7cefb36e7bf573","unit:ce3ef26b894335ad92974e6aadae91434fd460a03adcc8cbbea4021a561b030b","unit:dc8dc3ff2b6664fcf81176aa4aec897e9a236ef1692de2cbce283c1323e01343","unit:e62008b589a98f36f58752dc7a1062c1f3b987fd133738b823a383df6a85f04c","unit:ea14f42ca1dd550c7559fd2f2edf16bb86123aa539ee761d7d6e19e52296bced","unit:ed821e5a265d1cc18112aba2d02d37e2e3a2a7dabfb8c387724734cfa693aa63","unit:f4529ce27b1d461091e29abe4a77e98625808351ea83ad998b5a5eef6bb33ac2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d4fa75073ce6216c2cafa3bc","scopeContentSha256":"4c783e9a78bb24cb269ae2836df4e61363825d2e184890762a40a53eb51e6c1e","localRef":"s31"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1936949ab56cdeeaba762212","scopeContentSha256":"395fcef115c5b4b5d8bb6a108030cf14dcf0dd62936b166c4253ad29f5ada85b","localRef":"s0"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l23","originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:21","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l23","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:21","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:1936949ab56cdeeaba762212","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:d4fa75073ce6216c2cafa3bc","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l23","source":"s0","target":"s31","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Worldsheet, tadpole, anomaly and defect conditions provide distinct consistency methods."],"challengeStatement":"Worldsheet, tadpole, local-anomaly, global-anomaly and defect conditions remain distinct consistency methods.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"21496eadb83bfd89726e6068cb313c4459eb02b5c7319e3a443ecef8270fff51","reply.jsonSha256":"2b13522cde089dccca6ad5a606e861ba63c324f568607e4c375a0cc4bb41db20","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c36a6e5deffe73ebc0b1e16be7efeacce3b5a91518427e213f2adceb5abec192","receipt.jsonSha256":"1ac3619b922316ab9daed0b834a08152271b89bff3673ca6a536ac321cd7466f","normalization.jsonSha256":"34b6a384ae3212b9f12a1af0a4c8b1577afc8d9d2f9c6739f7b3e4d4e90d2e8a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f23d8110109e2321e451a757253617422655ce2cba84255be89203e01dad788"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"44719832235d537d40d8c3f9fde7ff9934aad947d84f431af08131529e35cace","reply.jsonSha256":"ba3566417aebc92a1caeed4499b097fe44f303e7c53fb9665b12679327751a5b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ad4fdae6bffbb728f2978451b9900b4b2db3bee70853770a6186005751e27323","receipt.jsonSha256":"97a00e5fe99821077fd249a980950dbc16461262f4d8c9f2bca8b01c4a37abd0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7a8af76f3c278360ec57798a76e3899c73d387ea4d4b3a0d9d7a02a5e66f129a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1936949ab56cdeeaba762212"},{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d4fa75073ce6216c2cafa3bc"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1936949ab56cdeeaba762212"},{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d4fa75073ce6216c2cafa3bc"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d23","originalRef":"l23","status":"route","source":"s31","target":"s0","type":"method_for","title":"Use worldsheet, tadpole, anomaly and defect consistency tests","rationale":"The original statements identify these as distinct consistency methods. Their methodological direction runs from the specialized consistency question to the broader string-consistency question.","qualification":"Keep the specified open or unoriented, ten-dimensional nonsupersymmetric and six-dimensional defect settings separate, including compact/noncompact and BPS/non-BPS restrictions. Direct/transverse consistency is a prerequisite for the stated R-R anomaly analysis; R-R constraints do not replace NS-NS tadpole analysis. Local cancellation does not establish global anomaly freedom, and geometric and integral defect-charge bases may differ. Completeness motivates the cited defect probes without making their generality or conjectured null-defect existence a theorem. No unrestricted consistency proof follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l23","s31","s0"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d23","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The specialized worldsheet, tadpole, anomaly and defect conditions supply methods to the broader consistency question, supporting s31 → s0. Their prerequisites and non-transfer limits remain explicit, particularly local versus global anomalies and R-R versus NS-NS constraints.","refs":["l23","s31","s0"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l23","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l24":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l24","source":"q025-candidate-question:48983ed3b27eda877fa09791","target":"q025-candidate-question:65516cba34720a38a1a98088","type":"application_of","title":"Connect brane cosmological mechanisms to background dynamics","rationale":"Both original statements explicitly describe brane cosmology as applying dynamics to expansion and dimensionality. The cosmological question is therefore the application.","qualification":"Apply only to the specified brane gases, wrapped-brane, inflationary and brane-world models with their own initial distributions and interaction rules. Bulk spatial dimension, surviving brane spatial dimension and worldvolume spacetime dimension remain distinct. Intersection counting alone does not establish dimension selection, and a possible outcome does not determine its probability. Historical proposals do not certify singularity avoidance or observational fits, and DBI bubble analogues do not establish destruction of bulk spacetime. Spacetime evolution, spatial interpolation and worldsheet RG retain their different meanings.","evidenceIds":["unit:0d3432d9d4e89d28ba038c6c7b9ae6a44ca2555a198aa679b4616504d54e17aa","unit:20617f551f77912588e17034973fea315ae0eb2293fa76dfb79c9b1636dd0dab","unit:325501eba8d44c9d596b4e61c0face4958339bcc5f8b8365e20d7567e19511ec","unit:4dbfb55614117620c14c9b01996a828a7be9d0a41398dbedbfdb3d1ab32d26ff","unit:5985e1ca3ee1964f066e5aacde2153af6772236641ec0f4517d958769c26f1ab","unit:5f2aff831c03e56065f940660271be86504fc6624f1f4ca02401ed0e9d8da005","unit:6011982cffbb5eea6bd56af46092cc7d81075f67bd1982fd4e17ad72d599072c","unit:6b6fa69673bb08b3124458c002cc23db74dd9d8bc64a379bf418794153b36166","unit:703a2cd000d8b7b325f26c33dd9866a9c9940997168253e6ab70a0c601156395","unit:7a957888a627dddbb3edf1a8ad606da3cfdb836e85d28ebe0f40fa4c8cc5199d","unit:7b316085098fe72bc465d4edaf6d5477f536d14bfe190f17bf06afca19e71be3","unit:7bfdc5ba30927f34684b612bbba1a5abf6f8f9896d74c0313b21323ae4b80a94","unit:82eb9d68b6fc6b18fb7b2c353af7f07291e6b2a2b5a748a4311b4768c49f8f9e","unit:867cd206499b2cb0dcf9c1fb906cd6572dcb360ea64497a35e34df957fd7b2ba","unit:97b64eee4bd381741df8eea4ad6ea1b17f5295122a98cf96282c5bb776344ae7","unit:ae405bbf8758d249c65bc73a413fced02c5a44deb44a915511d25b42ada66933","unit:bf63122ae42d43954cb58657e9dc100c3571307150e64fab55aa9162d258750a","unit:c249484448d2c01444fd78938fff6e9c5e25d6f6dfe6f3ad204f7d2d2af6b9b1","unit:dd4f0c1b3eaa9557ec17f6c16dbb8424a858b57604188fa5e21440293725cae9","unit:e5bdcfcca6b2b3d76471dd555bfe9e180b98edd2f15a902cc53024b206f0ae1b","unit:f8897ff82f64c7d93216b2275271fd8c1ff8f0f9efb3af8c24383339259039a8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:48983ed3b27eda877fa09791","scopeContentSha256":"2523b6296f982ab9ee2d58331dc4b17a7093e16cff40531ac92ff2a81d8aad5d","localRef":"s7"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:65516cba34720a38a1a98088","scopeContentSha256":"a2ee84365ce8bd930e6de419d4befc70b6f972f5048feb41a23c1bd39d7984cd","localRef":"s12"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l24","originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:30","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l24","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:30","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:65516cba34720a38a1a98088","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:48983ed3b27eda877fa09791","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l24","source":"s12","target":"s7","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Brane cosmology applies dynamics to expansion and dimensionality under model-specific initial conditions."],"challengeStatement":"Brane cosmology applies dynamics to expansion and dimensionality under model-specific initial conditions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"21496eadb83bfd89726e6068cb313c4459eb02b5c7319e3a443ecef8270fff51","reply.jsonSha256":"2b13522cde089dccca6ad5a606e861ba63c324f568607e4c375a0cc4bb41db20","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c36a6e5deffe73ebc0b1e16be7efeacce3b5a91518427e213f2adceb5abec192","receipt.jsonSha256":"1ac3619b922316ab9daed0b834a08152271b89bff3673ca6a536ac321cd7466f","normalization.jsonSha256":"34b6a384ae3212b9f12a1af0a4c8b1577afc8d9d2f9c6739f7b3e4d4e90d2e8a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f23d8110109e2321e451a757253617422655ce2cba84255be89203e01dad788"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"44719832235d537d40d8c3f9fde7ff9934aad947d84f431af08131529e35cace","reply.jsonSha256":"ba3566417aebc92a1caeed4499b097fe44f303e7c53fb9665b12679327751a5b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ad4fdae6bffbb728f2978451b9900b4b2db3bee70853770a6186005751e27323","receipt.jsonSha256":"97a00e5fe99821077fd249a980950dbc16461262f4d8c9f2bca8b01c4a37abd0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7a8af76f3c278360ec57798a76e3899c73d387ea4d4b3a0d9d7a02a5e66f129a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:65516cba34720a38a1a98088"},{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:48983ed3b27eda877fa09791"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:65516cba34720a38a1a98088"},{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:48983ed3b27eda877fa09791"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d24","originalRef":"l24","status":"route","source":"s7","target":"s12","type":"application_of","title":"Connect brane cosmological mechanisms to background dynamics","rationale":"Both original statements explicitly describe brane cosmology as applying dynamics to expansion and dimensionality. The cosmological question is therefore the application.","qualification":"Apply only to the specified brane gases, wrapped-brane, inflationary and brane-world models with their own initial distributions and interaction rules. Bulk spatial dimension, surviving brane spatial dimension and worldvolume spacetime dimension remain distinct. Intersection counting alone does not establish dimension selection, and a possible outcome does not determine its probability. Historical proposals do not certify singularity avoidance or observational fits, and DBI bubble analogues do not establish destruction of bulk spacetime. Spacetime evolution, spatial interpolation and worldsheet RG retain their different meanings.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l24","s7","s12"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d24","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements explicitly describe brane cosmology as applying dynamics to expansion and dimensionality, supporting s7 → s12. The qualification retains model-specific initial conditions and interaction rules without inferring dimension-selection probabilities, observational success or equivalence among distinct dynamical mechanisms.","refs":["l24","s7","s12"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l24","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l25":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l25","source":"q025-candidate-question:dd550854aa0c765cd7f97023","target":"q025-candidate-question:65516cba34720a38a1a98088","type":"application_of","title":"Relate inflationary throats and coupled-throat evolution to background dynamics","rationale":"Both original statements identify inflationary potentials and coupled-throat evolution as separately qualified applications of background dynamics. The applied throat questions therefore point to that underlying dynamics question.","qualification":"Keep D3-probe potentials, five-brane monodromy and post-annihilation evolution of related throats distinct. Retain local-throat approximations, moduli and scale hierarchies, the 2003 treatment's moduli-fixing assumption, and the stated double expansion for the general D3 potential. A D5/anti-D5 calculation is a proxy for the specified NS5/anti-NS5 model. Homologous-throat equivalence remains an endpoint condition to test, and coupled-throat evolution need not have an inflationary application. Neither parametrically small eta, antibrane metastability from a probe force nor a complete inflationary compactification is established.","evidenceIds":["unit:197e51fabf0c4182c0f5b288555d6dd13df0830e13da3cd3b23f6eeffb7b4612","unit:20617f551f77912588e17034973fea315ae0eb2293fa76dfb79c9b1636dd0dab","unit:2910c2ebcc382b400b983706009c48fd28e825a3a1cb255b7993b363fd21366a","unit:325501eba8d44c9d596b4e61c0face4958339bcc5f8b8365e20d7567e19511ec","unit:4dbfb55614117620c14c9b01996a828a7be9d0a41398dbedbfdb3d1ab32d26ff","unit:5ec9ad7eb636e5f6f1ebf6f7dad87efac334dc1cd3142c5e0cb8888c84c7349a","unit:6011982cffbb5eea6bd56af46092cc7d81075f67bd1982fd4e17ad72d599072c","unit:703a2cd000d8b7b325f26c33dd9866a9c9940997168253e6ab70a0c601156395","unit:867cd206499b2cb0dcf9c1fb906cd6572dcb360ea64497a35e34df957fd7b2ba","unit:97b64eee4bd381741df8eea4ad6ea1b17f5295122a98cf96282c5bb776344ae7","unit:98d0d457d4ff8cab1eb5833e8c6e9fd0488b266f50b430b9f6ccda042ebae577","unit:bf63122ae42d43954cb58657e9dc100c3571307150e64fab55aa9162d258750a","unit:dd4f0c1b3eaa9557ec17f6c16dbb8424a858b57604188fa5e21440293725cae9","unit:f8897ff82f64c7d93216b2275271fd8c1ff8f0f9efb3af8c24383339259039a8","unit:fca759558221b773c458d6b8fc8a13c4d004222f8cf0b39ca5b97ba7b733ba55"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:dd550854aa0c765cd7f97023","scopeContentSha256":"37b916d7c47a11a899a7f80d3df97b51849af78cfc4e26dbc64276ece8e24229","localRef":"s33"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:65516cba34720a38a1a98088","scopeContentSha256":"a2ee84365ce8bd930e6de419d4befc70b6f972f5048feb41a23c1bd39d7984cd","localRef":"s12"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l25","originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:31","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l25","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:31","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:65516cba34720a38a1a98088","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:dd550854aa0c765cd7f97023","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l25","source":"s12","target":"s33","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Inflationary potentials and coupled-throat evolution provide distinct applications of controlled background dynamics."],"challengeStatement":"Inflationary potentials and coupled-throat evolution supply separately qualified applications of background dynamics.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"21496eadb83bfd89726e6068cb313c4459eb02b5c7319e3a443ecef8270fff51","reply.jsonSha256":"2b13522cde089dccca6ad5a606e861ba63c324f568607e4c375a0cc4bb41db20","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c36a6e5deffe73ebc0b1e16be7efeacce3b5a91518427e213f2adceb5abec192","receipt.jsonSha256":"1ac3619b922316ab9daed0b834a08152271b89bff3673ca6a536ac321cd7466f","normalization.jsonSha256":"34b6a384ae3212b9f12a1af0a4c8b1577afc8d9d2f9c6739f7b3e4d4e90d2e8a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f23d8110109e2321e451a757253617422655ce2cba84255be89203e01dad788"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"44719832235d537d40d8c3f9fde7ff9934aad947d84f431af08131529e35cace","reply.jsonSha256":"ba3566417aebc92a1caeed4499b097fe44f303e7c53fb9665b12679327751a5b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ad4fdae6bffbb728f2978451b9900b4b2db3bee70853770a6186005751e27323","receipt.jsonSha256":"97a00e5fe99821077fd249a980950dbc16461262f4d8c9f2bca8b01c4a37abd0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7a8af76f3c278360ec57798a76e3899c73d387ea4d4b3a0d9d7a02a5e66f129a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:65516cba34720a38a1a98088"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:dd550854aa0c765cd7f97023"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:65516cba34720a38a1a98088"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:dd550854aa0c765cd7f97023"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d25","originalRef":"l25","status":"route","source":"s33","target":"s12","type":"application_of","title":"Relate inflationary throats and coupled-throat evolution to background dynamics","rationale":"Both original statements identify inflationary potentials and coupled-throat evolution as separately qualified applications of background dynamics. The applied throat questions therefore point to that underlying dynamics question.","qualification":"Keep D3-probe potentials, five-brane monodromy and post-annihilation evolution of related throats distinct. Retain local-throat approximations, moduli and scale hierarchies, the 2003 treatment's moduli-fixing assumption, and the stated double expansion for the general D3 potential. A D5/anti-D5 calculation is a proxy for the specified NS5/anti-NS5 model. Homologous-throat equivalence remains an endpoint condition to test, and coupled-throat evolution need not have an inflationary application. Neither parametrically small eta, antibrane metastability from a probe force nor a complete inflationary compactification is established.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l25","s33","s12"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d25","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements identify inflationary potentials and coupled-throat evolution as qualified applications of background dynamics, supporting s33 → s12. The record preserves the separate throat questions, proxy calculation, expansions and hierarchy assumptions without asserting complete inflationary control or antibrane metastability.","refs":["l25","s33","s12"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l25","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l26":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l26","source":"q025-candidate-question:a06ea405539d12c2b3906f2a","target":"q025-candidate-question:8882c74d1fc0e2c90d57373f","type":"method_for","title":"Use the proposed K-theory–bordism framework to examine brane charges and gauging","rationale":"Both original statements identify the proposed correspondence as a particular charge and gauging framework. It supplies a method for the broader charge-consistency question, with its interpretation limits retained.","qualification":"Keep the proposed open–closed physical interpretation separate from reduction tests on a fixed compactification manifold X, with the specified type I/type II backgrounds and RR gauge fields. Apparent global charges can reflect omitted gauge fields or charged contributions, and continuous and discrete gauging remain distinct. Tadpole cancellation is not cancellation of every refined bordism obstruction. A mathematical charge class does not establish an occupied physical state or universal classification, and the invoked mathematical proofs are not supplied.","evidenceIds":["unit:011868a3dc87c403fdd81c7bd8925c0a2d26e84a3d957b466fb5788e45d2a4f9","unit:0b824b458052a65cbdea70261000fbe6aabb8a1cfd76d1521ce462875b97b614","unit:25141049eaa3ac516ae205e210b804dfabbb00fc5689776ef99653da3b799bd7","unit:289251e4ff7e9c6b138ad30dea0cc9204020f6cece252f46b7b3ecf4c6202278","unit:29331011f30dc8105eed7ae251a7b174acae297b8cd277cef53f2d2ab8d24984","unit:32b818b9450a382663a963a592408ee18230abfea66e2632dde92d783ed96698","unit:336a7539b0a7e7525b52210b15fdd37c022defaa2422a3ee7e13cc06696078d8","unit:3a725a80a4ddacdcd3c49dbeb7e7ce04e0ac8501c8bc90d18d77a4176904555d","unit:46007d9bc07ceae19c94e08020693e2b2165dd3c8fecbec201ea849f0542bbdd","unit:4eebe154936413b733bc12534815c3befec10c830c404e3e6945db1ccb610b2b","unit:5c10d5f1d2a09d04db45a30e88f1bb8b875769743ea19767b4696b92ae6ce2ae","unit:7e3e2b833243bd3ee73678c8222201109bc3f703f6a97f395471d784bbd0450d","unit:81a725dc2be21474b057f4ad56e118a34e91585b5c0673d4e4eb59c5b5c3d88d","unit:8e22652f25e16847b7264ca5c1c477da104124698d10708d3d477f65450ccdf8","unit:b736a52a82738c80c72da003b77eddc1ad6567b8751539182f1049f303d02c74","unit:ba09869cec30de2bc4a2a730a92d67ffe89dfb7eb9918c4ad99d9d33cdade80b","unit:c2ade61deaafeac3a91f703c525c9c4449557f30b54d71ff3aa418b5e0c8cc2b","unit:cb91c2c515fce57875407c5f5f23e95dba75e1e5556ed5974cc1280e0ca49b20","unit:d1df601700c2affc58e50372b87382906d2b07525e4d85b550dd18ef606b65d7","unit:ddebdd04b5e1240819b878840d05af07300b4ea79dc987d31e08205734a349ad","unit:eb4a839dfa8f3318aebaebbe63334d680adfb0ce18ce05929bcaf50796269c08","unit:ed07eee43e28b821b29812f3df64dafe4870e6c528b9b5f09b617ad7075a28d6","unit:f24fb40e644c6d2bde69dee95c679025eb62867910b614aa8a82517b4b82a848","unit:f2f1cde85c8c1f41b6c34b96e20fb7b0c6515923d84a59449338b5a327e11797","unit:f59eb94a31683894b1724dc6fbe1695fbdadff1ed5f80fde4f1fbf111c107643","unit:f802524e6808981e3ae3fb09f913b96d1c3650c1b99534e317e0b8975e3fa858","unit:f808fbe05e7fd3573a72295d051f73daf28ccc5aafd4f0f5d5eef18a884ec692"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a06ea405539d12c2b3906f2a","scopeContentSha256":"117026aabf6d8b749c6bbfef8fb225aeb7a5d4a9e86c12b655318eb45f3016da","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8882c74d1fc0e2c90d57373f","scopeContentSha256":"01c11959c716d3979c792d22df2968c60f018c400071093a6471036bfeaa09b7","localRef":"s17"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l26","originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:33","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l26","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:33","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:8882c74d1fc0e2c90d57373f","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:a06ea405539d12c2b3906f2a","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l26","source":"s17","target":"s22","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["The proposed K-theory/bordism correspondence supplies a particular charge and gauging framework, not a universal classification."],"challengeStatement":"The proposed K-theory/bordism correspondence supplies a particular charge and gauging framework with its own interpretation limits.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"21496eadb83bfd89726e6068cb313c4459eb02b5c7319e3a443ecef8270fff51","reply.jsonSha256":"2b13522cde089dccca6ad5a606e861ba63c324f568607e4c375a0cc4bb41db20","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c36a6e5deffe73ebc0b1e16be7efeacce3b5a91518427e213f2adceb5abec192","receipt.jsonSha256":"1ac3619b922316ab9daed0b834a08152271b89bff3673ca6a536ac321cd7466f","normalization.jsonSha256":"34b6a384ae3212b9f12a1af0a4c8b1577afc8d9d2f9c6739f7b3e4d4e90d2e8a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f23d8110109e2321e451a757253617422655ce2cba84255be89203e01dad788"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"44719832235d537d40d8c3f9fde7ff9934aad947d84f431af08131529e35cace","reply.jsonSha256":"ba3566417aebc92a1caeed4499b097fe44f303e7c53fb9665b12679327751a5b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ad4fdae6bffbb728f2978451b9900b4b2db3bee70853770a6186005751e27323","receipt.jsonSha256":"97a00e5fe99821077fd249a980950dbc16461262f4d8c9f2bca8b01c4a37abd0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7a8af76f3c278360ec57798a76e3899c73d387ea4d4b3a0d9d7a02a5e66f129a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8882c74d1fc0e2c90d57373f"},{"ref":"x4_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a06ea405539d12c2b3906f2a"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8882c74d1fc0e2c90d57373f"},{"ref":"x4_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a06ea405539d12c2b3906f2a"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d26","originalRef":"l26","status":"route","source":"s22","target":"s17","type":"method_for","title":"Use the proposed K-theory–bordism framework to examine brane charges and gauging","rationale":"Both original statements identify the proposed correspondence as a particular charge and gauging framework. It supplies a method for the broader charge-consistency question, with its interpretation limits retained.","qualification":"Keep the proposed open–closed physical interpretation separate from reduction tests on a fixed compactification manifold X, with the specified type I/type II backgrounds and RR gauge fields. Apparent global charges can reflect omitted gauge fields or charged contributions, and continuous and discrete gauging remain distinct. Tadpole cancellation is not cancellation of every refined bordism obstruction. A mathematical charge class does not establish an occupied physical state or universal classification, and the invoked mathematical proofs are not supplied.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l26","s22","s17"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d26","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The proposed correspondence supplies a particular charge and gauging framework, supporting s22 → s17 as method_for. The qualification preserves the proposed physical interpretation, fixed-manifold reduction test and distinctions among charge classes, physical occupancy, tadpoles and refined bordism obstructions.","refs":["l26","s22","s17"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l26","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l27":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l27","source":"q025-candidate-question:ab2f14edf5609f189823ad52","target":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd","type":"premise_check","title":"Check source geometry and boundary admissibility for antibrane configurations","rationale":"The original statements place source-geometry admissibility alongside additional metastability and ultraviolet-theory matching tests. For a proposed antibrane configuration, admissible geometry and localization are prerequisites, so the conditional configuration question points to the geometry question.","qualification":"Match the actual antibrane background, source content, metric/flux ansatz and boundary conditions; the route does not impose every geometry condition on every antibrane model. Keep KS, the respective CGLP settings and anti-D6 backgrounds distinct, along with probe/backreacted, smeared/localized and perturbative/nonlinear analyses. Ordinary source singularities differ from additional flux divergences, and D5, NS5, oblique and M5 channels are not interchangeable. Integrated equations or necessary gluing conditions do not establish a complete localized solution, preserved ultraviolet theory or metastability. A smeared obstruction does not universally exclude localized polarized states or compact uplift.","evidenceIds":["unit:09aa35421f39ea58b4b0598ec7c088b63253ca5046fae69a909e379ae31fe8a9","unit:0a827b4c4c8463e5a64ef13db234883c4b82820e3336ce092bd78133ce96eeb7","unit:0c79d2f6a9a912178ebaf5402929bc1b5568a2b840ac1f6de96966d015330305","unit:0db021ee058874e71b8c600cb8cb357a2ac99715cfe785e0032f77bb335091c9","unit:241b16bf2a0221538145a2bc98023aff4fe294f1591cd4574724998fd0c6e4ae","unit:26b28327dd0e24d47c01e4853aa0cac164ac323c0e38bcccddbaf06e78cccc91","unit:29f9084ff18400c98f4e84a337f085a65d8d99667d6e9a31e12a7d3eaeae6cf1","unit:3c65ef997101da2f205fbc7c8e204ae8e808a5a537897e324e047a69809aaa8f","unit:3ea52866428d2f5f417ff0eedfbf153d06e5d712215380bdf31c1b4638034b7c","unit:44536154355430880b746cdc50c5a868583ec78d944c611d4679626a6c808235","unit:45e8d4bad1843a6dea5af58bb310db151ce2480614ba98139f032602516e1cf6","unit:46524eafc8c1728ccf0f4f79ea85488bb11e4c4669cff7c91104863631e7c362","unit:4700809fa5805605e809483d80521ffd0b432b872d737bb0afa9845c1ea9e7c9","unit:48f013c57ddd19b7dfffe1ee55edbafe813f506c2a83d33d5039412f15f0dc5c","unit:5ad20bdbfca22f328f80dac96ebc3d114753c0cddaa30c14b6c980d722964554","unit:5e48c0ab12d51e7afe57daa0230696aa8d6f916588d9664ca6046ffadf93e93b","unit:5f1f7e3fd4df8aa7c97e4f80fd323014a7cdd2e18dd00f77271c1314324d563a","unit:61ce0ba2f2db04d28e2a5f4fd1b5ef8afa0aeaa2637b71d194727489a3b08c97","unit:662e93a390fb622bf248a7c174371ae7cfbde57ca8afc089c84c5768b6366593","unit:66a390827bd73406b90ded5bebd1b4870ae615aa67f5de0cf1892c2ad6f211c5","unit:677f1d7184e174179f38a18a17ebaeca8c5a83f9d339f6cfea0e54f3eb8769e1","unit:751621fc0acbeeed9e7d5d8e3a994e046066869dde6c6f03a41f212a34219870","unit:7532438ecd0ea0eed5fd68cde220a129e8a3a1a97ad2b55de9725aa858c0ae52","unit:7a957888a627dddbb3edf1a8ad606da3cfdb836e85d28ebe0f40fa4c8cc5199d","unit:7b316085098fe72bc465d4edaf6d5477f536d14bfe190f17bf06afca19e71be3","unit:7d95564f108c82cad347425a8a9e72b7381f5c333d1bcc76a4ae13eb6f013e1f","unit:804a1a90d6e4e300e65afd97b291ccec80ac06712644224f9f05e638e83c0803","unit:82eb42c1316dfaa7864efdec4e8ec3da99560cbe8fed2c7d3896fd5717a44270","unit:9451965a63f603892ecd25134b2e14742ce1a5e6e3c56d45e6c31b8f0d500514","unit:9e8bb0e66181b98677f682bf2ca01ef96e4da29eac4847e337d00e46410d61e2","unit:a0c998c02bc7f2e0ca32c963f736b9d4cef538846c0885a7544519a8d4cec53c","unit:a11eb753f48e358eb73e67569f0ab3c69d7ee05e8ae839f1d2be2f40f402f426","unit:a315f07fa4f4b2d15cb24f2b545d81143f6cf8eb3b49b6a7edf076fb79812606","unit:ba2c4128f0492ba8c813024557bd15b2141884a861c386b8696eff83eabe315c","unit:bb89916419595a5740ce8828a1e642b273ffcb42e96baa18aa578f981ed54e21","unit:c1041c9771c468448d6ac205178c0cfe8dd8aaab27bf9c770224c788d0c52a74","unit:c159b5650159be4e75fec61d33d60ac4d60a8f53e32a2c484ab38398e9b7eee7","unit:c5b64386d0be4d2c72a75bddb503c1bfffff9d43e7e68c1c58b7f14654842680","unit:cb91c2c515fce57875407c5f5f23e95dba75e1e5556ed5974cc1280e0ca49b20","unit:d09646372f66b80337d41d910128ca7311971f2a2e456a4ec529582bba3be959","unit:d40d91ad673bf2e5d399bec3aa4ceee1999136bd2cfdb63120a59b33edbe1890","unit:d63c900787b2a37aca855f2939def9a18097d625ecd30ee23e3781e583a585a1","unit:d6c5fae16fde9d4690f1166c0c306c47e1f3f8922f7d3baa14e55d47226bd6ed","unit:e54ae8831c77ee327c67f00bd322c3faad1bd4d2bfac3931a27cc7f6f871ed21","unit:e6d5e92cd8208714083588f3db13dabadc103f42d8a5834ea0fd89b30519eba1","unit:eb4a839dfa8f3318aebaebbe63334d680adfb0ce18ce05929bcaf50796269c08","unit:eff39ca8d45497163494c8e1e88ff887d5db6de193333cd8b09ebd430610cb4b","unit:eff4396746c31e6aa96420bba4872206bdd6cd3d8e6cedfff0d839a83a574ece","unit:f5f4940151c8b2ad9589a39031cd87f1279f939a8488fded6b67a9bb1f3145de","unit:f8ecd0d418ba86e6bfb52038f518d9bd44ac6f0a6ef12035fccb9b054c994e36","unit:fca759558221b773c458d6b8fc8a13c4d004222f8cf0b39ca5b97ba7b733ba55"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ab2f14edf5609f189823ad52","scopeContentSha256":"21fe4cd191f2ec0fcefff30f217c111288186fcd2152b874ca19b44cfca62ea7","localRef":"s24"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd","scopeContentSha256":"dcbccd889b1a6ea439c2465a402ba8f5b31871265d56923dcb0b8703dce58de4","localRef":"s6"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l27","originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:35","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l27","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:35","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:ab2f14edf5609f189823ad52","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l27","source":"s6","target":"s24","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Antibrane backreaction adds metastability and ultraviolet-theory matching tests to source-geometry admissibility."],"challengeStatement":"Antibrane backreaction adds metastability and ultraviolet-theory matching to source-geometry admissibility.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"21496eadb83bfd89726e6068cb313c4459eb02b5c7319e3a443ecef8270fff51","reply.jsonSha256":"2b13522cde089dccca6ad5a606e861ba63c324f568607e4c375a0cc4bb41db20","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c36a6e5deffe73ebc0b1e16be7efeacce3b5a91518427e213f2adceb5abec192","receipt.jsonSha256":"1ac3619b922316ab9daed0b834a08152271b89bff3673ca6a536ac321cd7466f","normalization.jsonSha256":"34b6a384ae3212b9f12a1af0a4c8b1577afc8d9d2f9c6739f7b3e4d4e90d2e8a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f23d8110109e2321e451a757253617422655ce2cba84255be89203e01dad788"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"44719832235d537d40d8c3f9fde7ff9934aad947d84f431af08131529e35cace","reply.jsonSha256":"ba3566417aebc92a1caeed4499b097fe44f303e7c53fb9665b12679327751a5b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ad4fdae6bffbb728f2978451b9900b4b2db3bee70853770a6186005751e27323","receipt.jsonSha256":"97a00e5fe99821077fd249a980950dbc16461262f4d8c9f2bca8b01c4a37abd0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7a8af76f3c278360ec57798a76e3899c73d387ea4d4b3a0d9d7a02a5e66f129a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd"},{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ab2f14edf5609f189823ad52"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"0912.3519","sourceId":"ev:0d8e4804d5108958db6e93e287017bbd","sourceSha256":"43ce04217510d63bbca05c149a11c85d843207e705f7db362aef4f7fc61cf1ee","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e4d76191f9846ae7b6f8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d1b2783d7f26b8be06cc405d880bd7067d9b16c014ab33ad874554bd4fdd11a4","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"24a4365122867cdcc4dbfd1700b9861d878b593392fe1b42650ad0f83211930e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"0912.3519","sourceId":"ev:35e0a0ca2a661047c92924e600dfeb38","sourceSha256":"43ce04217510d63bbca05c149a11c85d843207e705f7db362aef4f7fc61cf1ee","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e4d76191f9846ae7b6f8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d1b2783d7f26b8be06cc405d880bd7067d9b16c014ab33ad874554bd4fdd11a4","pdfPage":4,"start":99,"end":3497,"textSha256":"cae97a834c2435cabf9d835fd1a3b41a57958d4febdfe855efff3dcb6892d774","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd"},{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ab2f14edf5609f189823ad52"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"0912.3519","sourceId":"ev:0d8e4804d5108958db6e93e287017bbd","sourceSha256":"43ce04217510d63bbca05c149a11c85d843207e705f7db362aef4f7fc61cf1ee","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e4d76191f9846ae7b6f8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d1b2783d7f26b8be06cc405d880bd7067d9b16c014ab33ad874554bd4fdd11a4","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"24a4365122867cdcc4dbfd1700b9861d878b593392fe1b42650ad0f83211930e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"0912.3519","sourceId":"ev:35e0a0ca2a661047c92924e600dfeb38","sourceSha256":"43ce04217510d63bbca05c149a11c85d843207e705f7db362aef4f7fc61cf1ee","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e4d76191f9846ae7b6f8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d1b2783d7f26b8be06cc405d880bd7067d9b16c014ab33ad874554bd4fdd11a4","pdfPage":4,"start":99,"end":3497,"textSha256":"cae97a834c2435cabf9d835fd1a3b41a57958d4febdfe855efff3dcb6892d774","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d27","originalRef":"l27","status":"route","source":"s24","target":"s6","type":"premise_check","title":"Check source geometry and boundary admissibility for antibrane configurations","rationale":"The original statements place source-geometry admissibility alongside additional metastability and ultraviolet-theory matching tests. For a proposed antibrane configuration, admissible geometry and localization are prerequisites, so the conditional configuration question points to the geometry question.","qualification":"Match the actual antibrane background, source content, metric/flux ansatz and boundary conditions; the route does not impose every geometry condition on every antibrane model. Keep KS, the respective CGLP settings and anti-D6 backgrounds distinct, along with probe/backreacted, smeared/localized and perturbative/nonlinear analyses. Ordinary source singularities differ from additional flux divergences, and D5, NS5, oblique and M5 channels are not interchangeable. Integrated equations or necessary gluing conditions do not establish a complete localized solution, preserved ultraviolet theory or metastability. A smeared obstruction does not universally exclude localized polarized states or compact uplift.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l27","s24","s6"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d27","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Source-geometry admissibility is a prerequisite for the proposed antibrane configurations, while metastability and ultraviolet matching add separate tests. The s24 → s6 premise-check direction captures that dependency with the required background, localization, polarization-channel and sufficiency limits.","refs":["l27","s24","s6"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l27","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l28":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l28","source":"q025-candidate-question:2383b8ab760bbc6cd6555340","target":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd","type":"method_for","title":"Assess brane geometries with localization, matching and source prescriptions","rationale":"The source-treatment question supplies localization, matching and self-field methods connecting geometry to effective observables. The paired reasoning supports this limited methodological direction without a universal existence criterion.","qualification":"Apply only to overlapping brane or orientifold problems with the relevant source-specific prescription, bulk ansatz, boundary data and perturbative or effective regime. Scalar toy-model prescriptions and particular higher-dimensional embeddings do not automatically transfer to other sources; BPS and non-BPS comparisons retain their stated conditions. Integrated constraints and local matching have different sufficiency limits, and neither alone establishes full localization or global completion. Full localization, partial localization and smearing remain different claims. The geometry anchors are description-supported, and the localized-source endpoint reports incompletely specified abstract-level assumptions.","evidenceIds":["unit:0344813e7dc1dc7fb9961a611d45de5c083bb716d6af06f53d68ca7c452b1752","unit:0a827b4c4c8463e5a64ef13db234883c4b82820e3336ce092bd78133ce96eeb7","unit:0c79d2f6a9a912178ebaf5402929bc1b5568a2b840ac1f6de96966d015330305","unit:0db021ee058874e71b8c600cb8cb357a2ac99715cfe785e0032f77bb335091c9","unit:197e51fabf0c4182c0f5b288555d6dd13df0830e13da3cd3b23f6eeffb7b4612","unit:241b16bf2a0221538145a2bc98023aff4fe294f1591cd4574724998fd0c6e4ae","unit:44536154355430880b746cdc50c5a868583ec78d944c611d4679626a6c808235","unit:45e8d4bad1843a6dea5af58bb310db151ce2480614ba98139f032602516e1cf6","unit:4700809fa5805605e809483d80521ffd0b432b872d737bb0afa9845c1ea9e7c9","unit:48f013c57ddd19b7dfffe1ee55edbafe813f506c2a83d33d5039412f15f0dc5c","unit:5ad20bdbfca22f328f80dac96ebc3d114753c0cddaa30c14b6c980d722964554","unit:5ec9ad7eb636e5f6f1ebf6f7dad87efac334dc1cd3142c5e0cb8888c84c7349a","unit:5f1f7e3fd4df8aa7c97e4f80fd323014a7cdd2e18dd00f77271c1314324d563a","unit:61ce0ba2f2db04d28e2a5f4fd1b5ef8afa0aeaa2637b71d194727489a3b08c97","unit:662e93a390fb622bf248a7c174371ae7cfbde57ca8afc089c84c5768b6366593","unit:66dc448e0d11564e34bf560be0d99c6e21b0663b4d220d90a9d3436f4a29f14d","unit:751621fc0acbeeed9e7d5d8e3a994e046066869dde6c6f03a41f212a34219870","unit:7a957888a627dddbb3edf1a8ad606da3cfdb836e85d28ebe0f40fa4c8cc5199d","unit:7b316085098fe72bc465d4edaf6d5477f536d14bfe190f17bf06afca19e71be3","unit:9451965a63f603892ecd25134b2e14742ce1a5e6e3c56d45e6c31b8f0d500514","unit:9e8bb0e66181b98677f682bf2ca01ef96e4da29eac4847e337d00e46410d61e2","unit:a0c998c02bc7f2e0ca32c963f736b9d4cef538846c0885a7544519a8d4cec53c","unit:ba2c4128f0492ba8c813024557bd15b2141884a861c386b8696eff83eabe315c","unit:c1041c9771c468448d6ac205178c0cfe8dd8aaab27bf9c770224c788d0c52a74","unit:cb91c2c515fce57875407c5f5f23e95dba75e1e5556ed5974cc1280e0ca49b20","unit:d40d91ad673bf2e5d399bec3aa4ceee1999136bd2cfdb63120a59b33edbe1890","unit:d63c900787b2a37aca855f2939def9a18097d625ecd30ee23e3781e583a585a1","unit:dd907a0d48ff5d9d12bd2fdc04fdbb1ed468ce2e102a961706498c6c72aa0b3d","unit:e54ae8831c77ee327c67f00bd322c3faad1bd4d2bfac3931a27cc7f6f871ed21","unit:e6d5e92cd8208714083588f3db13dabadc103f42d8a5834ea0fd89b30519eba1","unit:eb4a839dfa8f3318aebaebbe63334d680adfb0ce18ce05929bcaf50796269c08","unit:eff4396746c31e6aa96420bba4872206bdd6cd3d8e6cedfff0d839a83a574ece","unit:f5f4940151c8b2ad9589a39031cd87f1279f939a8488fded6b67a9bb1f3145de","unit:f8ecd0d418ba86e6bfb52038f518d9bd44ac6f0a6ef12035fccb9b054c994e36"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2383b8ab760bbc6cd6555340","scopeContentSha256":"b1d2a812c9a217a6002c4152563865e7b26a5bc3f29b384bc1c4b3292961bf12","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd","scopeContentSha256":"dcbccd889b1a6ea439c2465a402ba8f5b31871265d56923dcb0b8703dce58de4","localRef":"s6"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l28","originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:36","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l28","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:36","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:2383b8ab760bbc6cd6555340","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l28","source":"s6","target":"s2","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Localization, matching and self-field treatments connect geometry to effective observables without supplying a universal existence criterion."],"challengeStatement":"Localization, matching and source prescriptions connect geometry to effective observables without supplying a universal existence criterion.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"21496eadb83bfd89726e6068cb313c4459eb02b5c7319e3a443ecef8270fff51","reply.jsonSha256":"2b13522cde089dccca6ad5a606e861ba63c324f568607e4c375a0cc4bb41db20","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c36a6e5deffe73ebc0b1e16be7efeacce3b5a91518427e213f2adceb5abec192","receipt.jsonSha256":"1ac3619b922316ab9daed0b834a08152271b89bff3673ca6a536ac321cd7466f","normalization.jsonSha256":"34b6a384ae3212b9f12a1af0a4c8b1577afc8d9d2f9c6739f7b3e4d4e90d2e8a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f23d8110109e2321e451a757253617422655ce2cba84255be89203e01dad788"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"44719832235d537d40d8c3f9fde7ff9934aad947d84f431af08131529e35cace","reply.jsonSha256":"ba3566417aebc92a1caeed4499b097fe44f303e7c53fb9665b12679327751a5b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ad4fdae6bffbb728f2978451b9900b4b2db3bee70853770a6186005751e27323","receipt.jsonSha256":"97a00e5fe99821077fd249a980950dbc16461262f4d8c9f2bca8b01c4a37abd0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7a8af76f3c278360ec57798a76e3899c73d387ea4d4b3a0d9d7a02a5e66f129a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd"},{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2383b8ab760bbc6cd6555340"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd"},{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2383b8ab760bbc6cd6555340"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d28","originalRef":"l28","status":"route","source":"s2","target":"s6","type":"method_for","title":"Assess brane geometries with localization, matching and source prescriptions","rationale":"The source-treatment question supplies localization, matching and self-field methods connecting geometry to effective observables. The paired reasoning supports this limited methodological direction without a universal existence criterion.","qualification":"Apply only to overlapping brane or orientifold problems with the relevant source-specific prescription, bulk ansatz, boundary data and perturbative or effective regime. Scalar toy-model prescriptions and particular higher-dimensional embeddings do not automatically transfer to other sources; BPS and non-BPS comparisons retain their stated conditions. Integrated constraints and local matching have different sufficiency limits, and neither alone establishes full localization or global completion. Full localization, partial localization and smearing remain different claims. The geometry anchors are description-supported, and the localized-source endpoint reports incompletely specified abstract-level assumptions.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l28","s2","s6"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d28","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The treatments and matching questions in s2 supply methodological input to overlapping localization and boundary problems in s6. The record limits that use to relevant source prescriptions and regimes, preserving the distinction between integrated constraints, local matching and complete localized geometries.","refs":["l28","s2","s6"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-11-proposal","parent-orientation-11-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This proposal uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, paired original route statements and explicit reading limitations. No tools, external operations or primary rereading were performed.","Original primary locators, review hashes and attribution notes are not supplied as text. Scope and relation refs identify review context, not newly examined empirical or primary evidence.","Inherited description/excerpt coverage and source dates remain inherited metadata. These decisions do not verify derivations, constructions, numerical bounds, stability claims, current observational status or later developments.","Method and application routes concern the explicitly qualified uses, not full-scope containment, equivalence or universal applicability. Unresolved quantitative and control questions remain unresolved within their endpoint definitions.","This review does not perform admission, canonical-identity checks, global DAG checks or a complete-atlas assessment."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed only the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both independent original route statements, explicit reading limits and proposal. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and full attribution notes remain outside the supplied text. Scope and relation references identify review context, not newly examined primary evidence; coverage counts and source dates remain inherited metadata.","Agreement concerns navigation direction, type and qualification. It does not verify original results, derivations, numerical bounds, constructions, stability, convergence, observational fits or later developments.","All qualifications in the retained records remain operative. Limited methods and applications do not imply full-scope containment or universal applicability, and acknowledged scientific uncertainties remain unresolved.","Admission, endpoint and receipt validation, canonical-identity checks and the global DAG gate are separate steps not performed here."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-11:l28","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l0":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l0","source":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd","target":"q025-candidate-question:fa67fe69aee2cc8bd46a24f2","type":"related_question","title":"Explore AdS boundary completion and localized gravity","rationale":"Both statements connect brane and boundary geometry questions to AdS interfaces with additional microscopic-completion, anomaly and spin-2-spectrum targets. They establish a useful connection without identifying a particular construction supplied by s13 that s36 applies.","qualification":"Localization and boundary behavior retain their source, ansatz, flux and junction-condition restrictions. Full localization, partial localization and smearing remain distinct. An obstruction to a conformal interface does not settle the broader domain-wall question, and neither topology nor boundary closure alone establishes localized gravity. Thin-brane models and microscopic geometries remain distinct comparison settings. The supplied coverage does not certify global solutions or complete spectra.","evidenceIds":["unit:0a827b4c4c8463e5a64ef13db234883c4b82820e3336ce092bd78133ce96eeb7","unit:0c79d2f6a9a912178ebaf5402929bc1b5568a2b840ac1f6de96966d015330305","unit:0db021ee058874e71b8c600cb8cb357a2ac99715cfe785e0032f77bb335091c9","unit:241b16bf2a0221538145a2bc98023aff4fe294f1591cd4574724998fd0c6e4ae","unit:44536154355430880b746cdc50c5a868583ec78d944c611d4679626a6c808235","unit:454704c3f34c893b8b19a12a9f81687f962d4e5aaf6cccf6cd2424e5c9544b64","unit:4700809fa5805605e809483d80521ffd0b432b872d737bb0afa9845c1ea9e7c9","unit:4e41975077696b9111b99bb7665daebca9ae75ae68ac5e1d5fa1885f210a97eb","unit:5ad20bdbfca22f328f80dac96ebc3d114753c0cddaa30c14b6c980d722964554","unit:61ce0ba2f2db04d28e2a5f4fd1b5ef8afa0aeaa2637b71d194727489a3b08c97","unit:751621fc0acbeeed9e7d5d8e3a994e046066869dde6c6f03a41f212a34219870","unit:7a957888a627dddbb3edf1a8ad606da3cfdb836e85d28ebe0f40fa4c8cc5199d","unit:7b316085098fe72bc465d4edaf6d5477f536d14bfe190f17bf06afca19e71be3","unit:832965e0367641ef42626328522e1f25916f098c99db25e2306c4cff30a51125","unit:9451965a63f603892ecd25134b2e14742ce1a5e6e3c56d45e6c31b8f0d500514","unit:9e8bb0e66181b98677f682bf2ca01ef96e4da29eac4847e337d00e46410d61e2","unit:a0c998c02bc7f2e0ca32c963f736b9d4cef538846c0885a7544519a8d4cec53c","unit:ba2c4128f0492ba8c813024557bd15b2141884a861c386b8696eff83eabe315c","unit:c1041c9771c468448d6ac205178c0cfe8dd8aaab27bf9c770224c788d0c52a74","unit:cb91c2c515fce57875407c5f5f23e95dba75e1e5556ed5974cc1280e0ca49b20","unit:d63c900787b2a37aca855f2939def9a18097d625ecd30ee23e3781e583a585a1","unit:e54ae8831c77ee327c67f00bd322c3faad1bd4d2bfac3931a27cc7f6f871ed21","unit:eb4a839dfa8f3318aebaebbe63334d680adfb0ce18ce05929bcaf50796269c08","unit:f8ecd0d418ba86e6bfb52038f518d9bd44ac6f0a6ef12035fccb9b054c994e36"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd","scopeContentSha256":"dcbccd889b1a6ea439c2465a402ba8f5b31871265d56923dcb0b8703dce58de4","localRef":"s13"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fa67fe69aee2cc8bd46a24f2","scopeContentSha256":"5a335e4c7773c7997e5f269391ea4e36465a95c805889da2761c7e917f4145cb","localRef":"s36"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l0","originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:37","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l0","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:37","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:fa67fe69aee2cc8bd46a24f2","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l0","source":"s13","target":"s36","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["AdS boundary and interface constructions additionally test microscopic completion and localized-gravity spectra."],"challengeStatement":"AdS interfaces and boundaries add microscopic completion, anomaly and localized-gravity spectrum targets.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"21496eadb83bfd89726e6068cb313c4459eb02b5c7319e3a443ecef8270fff51","reply.jsonSha256":"2b13522cde089dccca6ad5a606e861ba63c324f568607e4c375a0cc4bb41db20","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c36a6e5deffe73ebc0b1e16be7efeacce3b5a91518427e213f2adceb5abec192","receipt.jsonSha256":"1ac3619b922316ab9daed0b834a08152271b89bff3673ca6a536ac321cd7466f","normalization.jsonSha256":"34b6a384ae3212b9f12a1af0a4c8b1577afc8d9d2f9c6739f7b3e4d4e90d2e8a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f23d8110109e2321e451a757253617422655ce2cba84255be89203e01dad788"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"44719832235d537d40d8c3f9fde7ff9934aad947d84f431af08131529e35cace","reply.jsonSha256":"ba3566417aebc92a1caeed4499b097fe44f303e7c53fb9665b12679327751a5b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ad4fdae6bffbb728f2978451b9900b4b2db3bee70853770a6186005751e27323","receipt.jsonSha256":"97a00e5fe99821077fd249a980950dbc16461262f4d8c9f2bca8b01c4a37abd0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7a8af76f3c278360ec57798a76e3899c73d387ea4d4b3a0d9d7a02a5e66f129a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd"},{"ref":"x4_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fa67fe69aee2cc8bd46a24f2"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:450803795de261470a2f76dd"},{"ref":"x4_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fa67fe69aee2cc8bd46a24f2"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d0","originalRef":"l0","status":"route","source":"s13","target":"s36","type":"related_question","title":"Explore AdS boundary completion and localized gravity","rationale":"Both statements connect brane and boundary geometry questions to AdS interfaces with additional microscopic-completion, anomaly and spin-2-spectrum targets. They establish a useful connection without identifying a particular construction supplied by s13 that s36 applies.","qualification":"Localization and boundary behavior retain their source, ansatz, flux and junction-condition restrictions. Full localization, partial localization and smearing remain distinct. An obstruction to a conformal interface does not settle the broader domain-wall question, and neither topology nor boundary closure alone establishes localized gravity. Thin-brane models and microscopic geometries remain distinct comparison settings. The supplied coverage does not certify global solutions or complete spectra.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l0","s13","s36"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements support the connection to additional AdS completion, anomaly and localized-gravity targets without identifying an underlying construction supplied by s13. The related-question type preserves that connection and the distinct localization, interface and spectrum conditions.","refs":["l0","s13","s36"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l1":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l1","source":"q025-candidate-question:cb74228797122ebbfc57da6e","target":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259","type":"method_for","title":"Use structured-background classification in completion questions","rationale":"Both statements identify structured-background classification as supplying data for completion questions. The methodological direction therefore runs from s28 to s22.","qualification":"Only classifications relevant to the specified background structure supply completion data. Tangential, gauge, fermionic and higher-group structures, actual global gauge groups, degree ranges and dimensions remain source-specific. Nongravitational phase classification retains its alternate home and does not establish quantum-gravity defect existence. Cobordism triviality and absence of exact global symmetries apply only where invoked. Defect-induced kernels and gauge-field forgetful-map cokernels remain distinct, and classification does not establish termination, uniqueness or convergence of completion.","evidenceIds":["unit:064b7795efc4138b39aad15c1bf22b7af51cdffb4c9791597112dcf3dc6a5185","unit:1b0f416b6bbd866123474c0872863b3947a775c926dadc5f7abf428776c87553","unit:336a7539b0a7e7525b52210b15fdd37c022defaa2422a3ee7e13cc06696078d8","unit:454704c3f34c893b8b19a12a9f81687f962d4e5aaf6cccf6cd2424e5c9544b64","unit:475891d66c5ff9a2cbb815660a1160d9d1712c5d5e9e79762e0ec6bd14e7b43d","unit:5274b7aaec2f7a547ab40cfd9c0dbd8649535d00103964b2915c154d3f275496","unit:76eb30453bf0c8cfcd407e0bb41a8c2a15377fc1445fe4b022e402c1a0a5930b","unit:773638d284370f4ac5ada564d5f1410c02e2fddfb6550b1636db64636030f5be","unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","unit:7f67c5063c95dec1ded64e9ca45cb48d4f8acdd2f60508ddd371ac2dc93dbf3f","unit:8910f715e4ea72097e152c589ce2936a25c2e753ae13b506bc48d73d58644c8e","unit:8eb105f66790c381743963e5e98d2fffb2edf71684a2c57d014003272fbf423c","unit:93e269d0441aef179be02ec1bfe4a11f45de52decc930e099a21337bff8afb67","unit:b8bbbfb48af08198420d739ee0d5441655903a7b3c7a1f34448adfb9e5238101","unit:c96b2a1e716750bd9f96efc5cd21642abb91bdc75744e27e6d4da61cf83db09c","unit:cc3ffc09d129de590e8523844fef16ab9cb34e8dd461777666c5ea7c1c14d80b","unit:e24ae1584be79c7270dc07dc8544bf271ba10168725b220ae9d33ee3f7619961","unit:f204135166a4c701563f0b31b9dea7b1d5b39b6a5e2075a2105a863259513413"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cb74228797122ebbfc57da6e","scopeContentSha256":"15e3e1304eaa15e78c4ed6abe2bf62be7751159ddafae790866a4151831e97b8","localRef":"s28"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259","scopeContentSha256":"d5e38e3210f4c6470c46f05705502e3eac55d65af02bef909f8451000a16a2ca","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l1","originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:40","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l1","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge:link:40","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:cb74228797122ebbfc57da6e","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l1","source":"s22","target":"s28","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Structured-background classification supplies data for completion questions; its nongravitational phase questions retain an alternate home."],"challengeStatement":"Structured-background classification can supply completion data; nongravitational phase classification retains an alternate home.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"21496eadb83bfd89726e6068cb313c4459eb02b5c7319e3a443ecef8270fff51","reply.jsonSha256":"2b13522cde089dccca6ad5a606e861ba63c324f568607e4c375a0cc4bb41db20","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c36a6e5deffe73ebc0b1e16be7efeacce3b5a91518427e213f2adceb5abec192","receipt.jsonSha256":"1ac3619b922316ab9daed0b834a08152271b89bff3673ca6a536ac321cd7466f","normalization.jsonSha256":"34b6a384ae3212b9f12a1af0a4c8b1577afc8d9d2f9c6739f7b3e4d4e90d2e8a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8f23d8110109e2321e451a757253617422655ce2cba84255be89203e01dad788"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-d1051e06be08ba1ea288-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"44719832235d537d40d8c3f9fde7ff9934aad947d84f431af08131529e35cace","reply.jsonSha256":"ba3566417aebc92a1caeed4499b097fe44f303e7c53fb9665b12679327751a5b","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ad4fdae6bffbb728f2978451b9900b4b2db3bee70853770a6186005751e27323","receipt.jsonSha256":"97a00e5fe99821077fd249a980950dbc16461262f4d8c9f2bca8b01c4a37abd0","normalization.jsonSha256":"7a8af76f3c278360ec57798a76e3899c73d387ea4d4b3a0d9d7a02a5e66f129a"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259"},{"ref":"x4_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cb74228797122ebbfc57da6e"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8f1340d8c5464bf4845d2259"},{"ref":"x4_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cb74228797122ebbfc57da6e"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d1","originalRef":"l1","status":"route","source":"s28","target":"s22","type":"method_for","title":"Use structured-background classification in completion questions","rationale":"Both statements identify structured-background classification as supplying data for completion questions. The methodological direction therefore runs from s28 to s22.","qualification":"Only classifications relevant to the specified background structure supply completion data. Tangential, gauge, fermionic and higher-group structures, actual global gauge groups, degree ranges and dimensions remain source-specific. Nongravitational phase classification retains its alternate home and does not establish quantum-gravity defect existence. Cobordism triviality and absence of exact global symmetries apply only where invoked. Defect-induced kernels and gauge-field forgetful-map cokernels remain distinct, and classification does not establish termination, uniqueness or convergence of completion.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l1","s28","s22"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The methodological direction is correctly reversed: s28 supplies structured-background classification data relevant to completion questions in s22. The qualification preserves structure and dimension restrictions, separates nongravitational classification from defect existence, and does not claim completion or convergence.","refs":["l1","s28","s22"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-12-proposal","parent-orientation-12-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or full attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and relation refs provide review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts describe inherited reviews, not work performed here.","Description-only support, dated observations, conjectural inputs, incomplete calculations and unverified forecasts retain their supplied limits. Branch-qualified methods and applications do not assert full-scope containment or universal applicability.","This proposal does not verify scientific results, admit newly proposed scopes such as s11 or s39, or perform endpoint receipts, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."],"challenge":["This challenge used all supplied endpoint definitions, both original statements for each relation and the proposal. No primary text, sidecar locators, review hashes or external attribution files were newly read or inspected.","Scope and route references identify review context, not new empirical evidence. Reading-coverage counts and reported primary-reading limits belong to the inherited reviews.","Accepted methods, applications and premise checks retain their stated branch restrictions. Description-only support, conjectural premises, dated observations and incomplete calculations remain unchanged.","This review does not verify scientific results, admit s11 or s39 or pending descendant scopes, or perform endpoint receipt checks, canonical identity checks or the global DAG gate."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-12:l1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"}}}