{"kind":"eigenquestions-relation-details","schemaVersion":"1.0.0","relations":{"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l19":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l19","source":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","target":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on axion roles beyond the inflaton","rationale":"The non-inflaton question refines the spectator, dark-matter, dark-energy and cosmological-evolution settings explicitly included in s39. The original statements support that scoped direction without identifying a common underlying method.","qualification":"Initial-condition, perturbation, abundance and late-time targets remain distinct. An axion present during inflation need not drive it; radial PQ inflation and angular-axion evolution retain different roles. Heuristic angular sampling is not a success probability, and conventional cosmological bounds on f are distinct from Planck-scale field-range criteria. Parent compatibility does not independently validate descendant assignments.","evidenceIds":["unit:04d0657e87fbe8361caa7c6ea285cd8d58a1af94f9c2f6eea29ae16ab42367d7","unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","unit:0f35aad79e513365b8edb7ec5f980ccfe09a912caa9a868b6dee97336580d917","unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","unit:2472aa7f6431071a7ecfd145294b3acc1b55c8f5dd05e532b58afaca295edef5","unit:2acf2e165d284872cc674da3477d42164092f746d47c1ccc727f20fba6ee4e7d","unit:42475120c24644ab18baac5efe62d3f73331d367763c6bfdb714a64e0daa1cec","unit:4b9dcedf1682440a5020f2f9228dce80d564a7f45e509b27938495e6a33738b4","unit:69ac4e9fd736238f4f572feb553d0abdfdb9603b83439c486119d7177e098f68","unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","unit:b9161ceb2f21406c1bcaa52576595709c1c6f8cb0c53d03155a970b28c48da36","unit:c6c86df782561dcce60ac528d3d4dc67d6575ad8ad7091b986a1faf68f273f77","unit:dd96fa9eae2a7cbda855f49ee5ab0843e5f810bf7c448106a401b7142b797ccd","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a","unit:eb1cae1758a8701851d75fdd607a1d25ac6cf994daad8e3dae4556a3a6ae541c","unit:f185332de23766b66a802f2bede69479f1849089774b79ca0687079cab79d78c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","scopeContentSha256":"24d924b5a5bc7ad2a4781a4ea77c66d1d13b0049360b252c512645dbbd8609aa","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","scopeContentSha256":"8b152b0159ec18b695139265318c907f9566cf0589732d73e690bbbbf26732cb","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l19","originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:13","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l19","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:13","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l19","source":"s39","target":"s22","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Non-inflaton roles retain distinct initial-condition, abundance, perturbation and late-time targets."],"challengeStatement":"Non-inflaton axions retain distinct perturbation, initial-condition, abundance and late-time targets.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d19","originalRef":"l19","status":"route","source":"s39","target":"s22","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on axion roles beyond the inflaton","rationale":"The non-inflaton question refines the spectator, dark-matter, dark-energy and cosmological-evolution settings explicitly included in s39. The original statements support that scoped direction without identifying a common underlying method.","qualification":"Initial-condition, perturbation, abundance and late-time targets remain distinct. An axion present during inflation need not drive it; radial PQ inflation and angular-axion evolution retain different roles. Heuristic angular sampling is not a success probability, and conventional cosmological bounds on f are distinct from Planck-scale field-range criteria. Parent compatibility does not independently validate descendant assignments.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l19","s39","s22"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d19","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The full non-inflaton question refines settings and cosmological targets explicitly included in s39. The narrower relation is supported without recasting the broad parent as a method. Both original statements' distinct initial-condition, perturbation, abundance and late-time targets remain separate, as do radial-inflaton and angular-axion roles.","refs":["l19","s39","s22"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l19","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l20":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l20","source":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","target":"q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on exit, reheating and subsequent cosmological completion","rationale":"Exit and cosmological completion are explicit targets of s39, and s34 refines them into physical exit, reheating, thermal backreaction and later matter-history questions.","qualification":"Completion must be assessed beyond the fitted inflationary interval. Efficient energy transfer does not establish immediate completion of reheating. Thermal histories, delayed domination, baryogenesis and relic production remain separate targets with explicit epochs. The reported delayed-reheating result retains its source-specific scope; its full phase diagram and calculations are not supplied.","evidenceIds":["unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","unit:0f35aad79e513365b8edb7ec5f980ccfe09a912caa9a868b6dee97336580d917","unit:1a0905d6b277cc7df5b87e9e8658fed89f9f7c6ed1ae45125613aeb27a592067","unit:1fa1d6965b2b4d15843ec9bfa4b8e9ea0e198a2dc8df4f761d029449f24c3260","unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","unit:2472aa7f6431071a7ecfd145294b3acc1b55c8f5dd05e532b58afaca295edef5","unit:42475120c24644ab18baac5efe62d3f73331d367763c6bfdb714a64e0daa1cec","unit:5d7f7e18aa16e6086bf4413b8b97dbc3c83c8b04b571a792a122e746e42ead7c","unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","unit:a5b498b7ca04d4cdffc7868e4b0210c771b8ab08b92045c786d38b8c797cabd0","unit:c6c86df782561dcce60ac528d3d4dc67d6575ad8ad7091b986a1faf68f273f77","unit:cf108925dee89c4fedb041812f572cd882b0c6233ea7e000ec15c35e206f3740","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a","unit:f185332de23766b66a802f2bede69479f1849089774b79ca0687079cab79d78c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","scopeContentSha256":"24d924b5a5bc7ad2a4781a4ea77c66d1d13b0049360b252c512645dbbd8609aa","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2","scopeContentSha256":"5d417a0fbda515287e8c5249a8dae741394e71605d3ba2b32d39982005753813","localRef":"s34"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l20","originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:12","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l20","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:12","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l20","source":"s39","target":"s34","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Exit, reheating and subsequent histories test cosmological completion beyond an inflationary interval."],"challengeStatement":"Exit and subsequent thermal or matter histories test completion beyond an inflationary interval.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d20","originalRef":"l20","status":"route","source":"s39","target":"s34","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on exit, reheating and subsequent cosmological completion","rationale":"Exit and cosmological completion are explicit targets of s39, and s34 refines them into physical exit, reheating, thermal backreaction and later matter-history questions.","qualification":"Completion must be assessed beyond the fitted inflationary interval. Efficient energy transfer does not establish immediate completion of reheating. Thermal histories, delayed domination, baryogenesis and relic production remain separate targets with explicit epochs. The reported delayed-reheating result retains its source-specific scope; its full phase diagram and calculations are not supplied.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l20","s39","s34"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d20","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Cosmological completion is an explicit target of s39, and s34 refines it into exit, reheating and subsequent thermal or matter histories. Both original statements support this refinement beyond a fitted inflationary interval. The record retains delayed completion, separate epochs and the limitation of the supplied phase-diagram evidence.","refs":["l20","s39","s34"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l20","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l21":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l21","source":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","target":"q025-candidate-question:4df3863ee38e63838d8791de","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on monodromy, membranes and parameter scanning","rationale":"The axion/three-form, monodromy and scanning question is a refinement of the constructions and scanning applications explicitly included in s39.","qualification":"Scanning and parameter landscapes retain branch-transition and membrane questions distinct from compact-period enhancement. A large branch excursion need not require a super-Planckian compact period. Membrane tensions require ultraviolet information or an explicitly adopted conjectural constraint; membrane and axion-instanton WGC formulations are not identified. Different three-form uses, Higgs scanning and soft-term landscapes remain distinct.","evidenceIds":["unit:185882e036f4b54e603fa4541e6d0d126a6a25ebe9b19dcd93193fdaeee81b93","unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","unit:2472aa7f6431071a7ecfd145294b3acc1b55c8f5dd05e532b58afaca295edef5","unit:c6c86df782561dcce60ac528d3d4dc67d6575ad8ad7091b986a1faf68f273f77","unit:cec80842f97e408526585ad25618818dea06d05be80fd1710d254d4ee0f53526","unit:d18b2bac4da18f878d8f9a0663ddda680cdee4e108ba2c8083aa7dbbda01cb71","unit:dd8aa10edade59761ac7b6e12fd109ee593c51f24b1069c57d02c82a0694e9e8","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a","unit:f185332de23766b66a802f2bede69479f1849089774b79ca0687079cab79d78c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","scopeContentSha256":"24d924b5a5bc7ad2a4781a4ea77c66d1d13b0049360b252c512645dbbd8609aa","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4df3863ee38e63838d8791de","scopeContentSha256":"8aa81458a9caa761b4942d491a573f16d90d5aa129d2e1fdfbf2f159a7f7c706","localRef":"s7"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l21","originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:14","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l21","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:14","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:4df3863ee38e63838d8791de","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l21","source":"s39","target":"s7","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Scanning and parameter-landscape uses of monodromy require branch and membrane questions distinct from compact-period enhancement."],"challengeStatement":"Scanning and parameter landscapes require branch and membrane questions distinct from compact-period enhancement.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4df3863ee38e63838d8791de"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4df3863ee38e63838d8791de"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d21","originalRef":"l21","status":"route","source":"s39","target":"s7","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on monodromy, membranes and parameter scanning","rationale":"The axion/three-form, monodromy and scanning question is a refinement of the constructions and scanning applications explicitly included in s39.","qualification":"Scanning and parameter landscapes retain branch-transition and membrane questions distinct from compact-period enhancement. A large branch excursion need not require a super-Planckian compact period. Membrane tensions require ultraviolet information or an explicitly adopted conjectural constraint; membrane and axion-instanton WGC formulations are not identified. Different three-form uses, Higgs scanning and soft-term landscapes remain distinct.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l21","s39","s7"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d21","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Monodromy, axion/three-form constructions and scanning applications are explicitly within s39, supporting the narrower direction to s7. The record preserves both original statements' distinction between branch and membrane questions and compact-period enhancement, together with unresolved tension inputs and distinct WGC formulations.","refs":["l21","s39","s7"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l21","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l22":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l22","source":"q025-candidate-question:061c295ae555271cce2489e2","target":"q025-candidate-question:4df3863ee38e63838d8791de","type":"method_for","title":"Use conditional branch-transition estimates in scanning constructions","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: transition estimates and conditional domain-wall criteria can inform the scanning and membrane questions in s7.","qualification":"Dynamical tunnelling estimates remain separate from conjectural electric and magnetic bounds. Wall species, backgrounds, tensions and the adopted WGC extension must be specified; the applicable extension remains unresolved. Oscillation-induced walls are distinct from membranes of a gauged three-form construction. Flat-space thin-wall or Coleman vacuum-decay assumptions cannot automatically be transferred to rolling evolution. The inherited transition analysis remains incomplete.","evidenceIds":["unit:06b18bd62c90d284396e54cf14b38028bfea9e4fc4c582b3edd8fe423de7e6d6","unit:185882e036f4b54e603fa4541e6d0d126a6a25ebe9b19dcd93193fdaeee81b93","unit:6ae168479f8b7403955c468a7f7cb5af03a5a3ceeb95836dc598ae2fa1562935","unit:970ce62f42c38e63bdeffb3cbb515410f14898d29ab52fc44acffd386a9e107a","unit:a834a7b45645f4626987197ebc2392dbc8db0202161a90291fe790b06bdfda3e","unit:b6f16126a8df0660481b3e9a274dffa137a4396f76b43e99033ca07ca0a3e36e","unit:cec80842f97e408526585ad25618818dea06d05be80fd1710d254d4ee0f53526","unit:d18b2bac4da18f878d8f9a0663ddda680cdee4e108ba2c8083aa7dbbda01cb71","unit:dd8aa10edade59761ac7b6e12fd109ee593c51f24b1069c57d02c82a0694e9e8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:061c295ae555271cce2489e2","scopeContentSha256":"5ef5f81f39fe298f2bcea2ae68e979ad1dceb76ae9401b6468a41d5a6eb333ce","localRef":"s0"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4df3863ee38e63838d8791de","scopeContentSha256":"8aa81458a9caa761b4942d491a573f16d90d5aa129d2e1fdfbf2f159a7f7c706","localRef":"s7"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l22","originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:27","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l22","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:27","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:4df3863ee38e63838d8791de","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:061c295ae555271cce2489e2","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l22","source":"s7","target":"s0","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Branch-transition estimates and conditional domain-wall bounds can inform scanning only under their stated wall species, background and conjecture assumptions."],"challengeStatement":"Transition estimates and domain-wall criteria can inform scanning only with the stated wall species, background and conjectural assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4df3863ee38e63838d8791de"},{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:061c295ae555271cce2489e2"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4df3863ee38e63838d8791de"},{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:061c295ae555271cce2489e2"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d22","originalRef":"l22","status":"route","source":"s0","target":"s7","type":"method_for","title":"Use conditional branch-transition estimates in scanning constructions","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: transition estimates and conditional domain-wall criteria can inform the scanning and membrane questions in s7.","qualification":"Dynamical tunnelling estimates remain separate from conjectural electric and magnetic bounds. Wall species, backgrounds, tensions and the adopted WGC extension must be specified; the applicable extension remains unresolved. Oscillation-induced walls are distinct from membranes of a gauged three-form construction. Flat-space thin-wall or Coleman vacuum-decay assumptions cannot automatically be transferred to rolling evolution. The inherited transition analysis remains incomplete.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l22","s0","s7"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d22","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify transition estimates and conditional wall criteria as tools for scanning questions, requiring the reversed method direction. The record retains wall-species, background and conjectural restrictions, separates tunnelling dynamics from conjectural bounds, and explicitly preserves unresolved WGC applicability and incomplete rolling-background analysis.","refs":["l22","s0","s7"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l22","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l23":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l23","source":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","target":"q025-candidate-question:5fa819a79b9104ad695d8ab2","type":"related_question","title":"Connect non-inflaton initial conditions with axion dark-energy scenarios","rationale":"Both statements support a connection through non-inflaton dark-energy evolution and initial conditions. They do not identify s22 as an underlying method or establish containment of s9's full potential-scale and early-dark-energy construction scope.","qualification":"Early dark energy and late quintessence remain separate scenarios. Random misalignment, assisted evolution and prepared hilltop conditions retain their assumptions; heuristic sampling is not a success probability or measured landscape frequency. A local hilltop equation does not establish a global history, unresolved angular/canonical normalizations remain unresolved, and historical benchmarks are not current observational fits.","evidenceIds":["unit:04d0657e87fbe8361caa7c6ea285cd8d58a1af94f9c2f6eea29ae16ab42367d7","unit:07c1ad479fafcc9d2536acb8c78fc03965ec02c7d2afd2ce601728c00fdb357f","unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","unit:0f35aad79e513365b8edb7ec5f980ccfe09a912caa9a868b6dee97336580d917","unit:1ef725634995275335c08146ae42fb3fb64188dbca0137fe4cba6c5e7905a545","unit:2a2124576413b39c5abc0029b9d9bc63456515a23c31c3db8328427fedd37df9","unit:2acf2e165d284872cc674da3477d42164092f746d47c1ccc727f20fba6ee4e7d","unit:42475120c24644ab18baac5efe62d3f73331d367763c6bfdb714a64e0daa1cec","unit:43741af58773ec574dcb34ceb968d74b5d821a05049e27dd34d7688ab652164d","unit:46026119579822b83de495a8cc8315e57cc2ef40e9793490c80b5388de58f768","unit:4b9dcedf1682440a5020f2f9228dce80d564a7f45e509b27938495e6a33738b4","unit:69ac4e9fd736238f4f572feb553d0abdfdb9603b83439c486119d7177e098f68","unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","unit:b4a5b8d0cee266be5a9e1d8956f5335ae1efe3086f2ea6883fe851a55f4b8365","unit:b9161ceb2f21406c1bcaa52576595709c1c6f8cb0c53d03155a970b28c48da36","unit:dd96fa9eae2a7cbda855f49ee5ab0843e5f810bf7c448106a401b7142b797ccd","unit:eb1cae1758a8701851d75fdd607a1d25ac6cf994daad8e3dae4556a3a6ae541c","unit:edcc3fed80ecf6577dee148bf85dd2acfc93df8d8869eb2c80b4c8d53d456414"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","scopeContentSha256":"8b152b0159ec18b695139265318c907f9566cf0589732d73e690bbbbf26732cb","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5fa819a79b9104ad695d8ab2","scopeContentSha256":"9cdafef65f66a76af984f47230107802cfe59907a8f93aac48d7915dda056349","localRef":"s9"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l23","originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:30","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l23","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:30","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:5fa819a79b9104ad695d8ab2","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l23","source":"s22","target":"s9","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Dark-energy evolution and its initial conditions provide a distinct non-inflaton route, separating early dark energy from late quintessence."],"challengeStatement":"Dark-energy evolution and its initial conditions provide a non-inflaton route while separating early dark energy from late quintessence.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4"},{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5fa819a79b9104ad695d8ab2"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4"},{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5fa819a79b9104ad695d8ab2"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d23","originalRef":"l23","status":"route","source":"s22","target":"s9","type":"related_question","title":"Connect non-inflaton initial conditions with axion dark-energy scenarios","rationale":"Both statements support a connection through non-inflaton dark-energy evolution and initial conditions. They do not identify s22 as an underlying method or establish containment of s9's full potential-scale and early-dark-energy construction scope.","qualification":"Early dark energy and late quintessence remain separate scenarios. Random misalignment, assisted evolution and prepared hilltop conditions retain their assumptions; heuristic sampling is not a success probability or measured landscape frequency. A local hilltop equation does not establish a global history, unresolved angular/canonical normalizations remain unresolved, and historical benchmarks are not current observational fits.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l23","s22","s9"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d23","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The paired statements establish a connection through non-inflaton dark-energy evolution and initial conditions, without identifying a method being applied or establishing containment of the full potential-scale and early-dark-energy construction scope. The related-question type is justified. Early dark energy, late quintessence and their distinct preparation assumptions remain separate.","refs":["l23","s22","s9"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l23","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l24":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l24","source":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","target":"q025-candidate-question:c62054cbd3f53ee7d55fb5dc","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on symmetry-breaking and mass histories for non-inflaton axions","rationale":"Both original statements identify symmetry and mass histories as a specialization of non-inflaton axion cosmology. The refinement retains both the dark-matter isocurvature mechanism and the separate post-inflationary construction.","qualification":"The stronger-QCD model has PQ breaking during inflation without later restoration and an early stronger-QCD interval before the Higgs mu transition. Its history is not combined with the separate open-string post-inflationary construction, whose description supplies no dark-matter abundance target. The dark-matter axion is not the inflaton; inflationary and present axion scales remain distinct, and quoted inflationary bounds are historical context.","evidenceIds":["unit:04d0657e87fbe8361caa7c6ea285cd8d58a1af94f9c2f6eea29ae16ab42367d7","unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","unit:0f35aad79e513365b8edb7ec5f980ccfe09a912caa9a868b6dee97336580d917","unit:2acf2e165d284872cc674da3477d42164092f746d47c1ccc727f20fba6ee4e7d","unit:42475120c24644ab18baac5efe62d3f73331d367763c6bfdb714a64e0daa1cec","unit:4b9dcedf1682440a5020f2f9228dce80d564a7f45e509b27938495e6a33738b4","unit:69ac4e9fd736238f4f572feb553d0abdfdb9603b83439c486119d7177e098f68","unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","unit:b9161ceb2f21406c1bcaa52576595709c1c6f8cb0c53d03155a970b28c48da36","unit:c0b7559fb56cee36b6c99164c1b855f4ce2c050a3f46756ff6e1781ced5c76ab","unit:dd96fa9eae2a7cbda855f49ee5ab0843e5f810bf7c448106a401b7142b797ccd","unit:eb1cae1758a8701851d75fdd607a1d25ac6cf994daad8e3dae4556a3a6ae541c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","scopeContentSha256":"8b152b0159ec18b695139265318c907f9566cf0589732d73e690bbbbf26732cb","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c62054cbd3f53ee7d55fb5dc","scopeContentSha256":"1c302afcd544d554d26372752a2997aee2325b2b5370361a574186f76f898bd8","localRef":"s27"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l24","originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:32","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l24","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:32","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:c62054cbd3f53ee7d55fb5dc","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l24","source":"s22","target":"s27","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Symmetry-breaking and mass histories specialize non-inflaton cosmology without identifying alternative histories or assuming that the dark-matter axion drives inflation."],"challengeStatement":"Symmetry and mass histories specialize non-inflaton cosmology. Alternative histories are not combined, and the dark-matter axion is not identified with the inflaton.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4"},{"ref":"x2_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c62054cbd3f53ee7d55fb5dc"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4"},{"ref":"x2_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c62054cbd3f53ee7d55fb5dc"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d24","originalRef":"l24","status":"route","source":"s22","target":"s27","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on symmetry-breaking and mass histories for non-inflaton axions","rationale":"Both original statements identify symmetry and mass histories as a specialization of non-inflaton axion cosmology. The refinement retains both the dark-matter isocurvature mechanism and the separate post-inflationary construction.","qualification":"The stronger-QCD model has PQ breaking during inflation without later restoration and an early stronger-QCD interval before the Higgs mu transition. Its history is not combined with the separate open-string post-inflationary construction, whose description supplies no dark-matter abundance target. The dark-matter axion is not the inflaton; inflationary and present axion scales remain distinct, and quoted inflationary bounds are historical context.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l24","s22","s27"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d24","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements expressly identify symmetry and mass histories as a specialization of non-inflaton cosmology, and s22 includes later-history alternatives that need not use inflationary preparation. The record preserves both components of s27 without combining their histories or assigning the open-string construction an unstated dark-matter abundance target.","refs":["l24","s22","s27"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l24","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l25":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l25","source":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","target":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","type":"method_for","title":"Use damping and modified dynamics in inflationary-control questions","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the mechanisms in s26 supply distinct approaches to the inflationary-evolution component of s39.","qualification":"Background damping, perturbative viability, stability and controlled coupling generation remain separate tests. Abelian particle production, classical non-Abelian backgrounds, thermal dissipation, derivative interactions and spinodal effects are not one mechanism. Inflationary dissipation does not establish reheating completion. The simplest supplied 2010 construction's reported excessive scalar amplitude remains a failure, and missing chromo-natural action or coupling conventions are not reconstructed.","evidenceIds":["unit:00cceec7964fb90d5a18d62d6d5d9bc8d27678c17a785ceebbe51dd89626bc68","unit:1250ebeed54952b26e25c8f332139d3b5fe4bc9bfc721c64241683ee0dc8e9d7","unit:1a0905d6b277cc7df5b87e9e8658fed89f9f7c6ed1ae45125613aeb27a592067","unit:1fb2ad8bf8e7ccacf6512f3c50c3872aff8cf4a39c286daddd810227cb894cbc","unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","unit:2472aa7f6431071a7ecfd145294b3acc1b55c8f5dd05e532b58afaca295edef5","unit:44c4cb36779d40cd065031fe74d3171faf148f868aeaae6ce7b56c2e9ccf157c","unit:7a16c6358397efbdeb773b01d136b33c4ade2a593369be237424ac16ba04916a","unit:806fb9dbceedc7746e4bf49d2bf83bfa907d6c07ec02ffdd57a3a69df5f48904","unit:85dd8ae5fb468c471425c3e88ad7070959f5d402b98750e345c563ee021087ba","unit:86f88fe792f3cf72f3d88ef114384bd77f6a78c8c235913ee5e373298fc329b2","unit:8791d20b6b8165a5b6a3b2a8dd144d662c216b40f2c5ffc20888bdf5c13c6ebf","unit:a112fb8b21cabcb4f5ddd0246e4d216faabf739c8b32f5528540d918c7f8a19e","unit:c6c86df782561dcce60ac528d3d4dc67d6575ad8ad7091b986a1faf68f273f77","unit:cf108925dee89c4fedb041812f572cd882b0c6233ea7e000ec15c35e206f3740","unit:d292d20ab3b91a5fb79c2feb94992264f9abc03f28c249d475b71386fc684a06","unit:e50105d51ef65387e4e82eaf2f653c33b204dc8fd44466599fd4b1a11661f07c","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a","unit:e8c0a0bffd5b08931037fafc4f60b51a9c3f1973750a35405bcdcded2eaab51b","unit:e95c5104ebe75500827ba7d5b7559c993b431335aca56550b91916df0d720bc0","unit:f185332de23766b66a802f2bede69479f1849089774b79ca0687079cab79d78c","unit:f6a4df371b8b0c027eda1620205eb32aecdd1f83e2c1625a76801ccef8ec8753","unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","scopeContentSha256":"9e6c184caeeca1fe514b806a44ec65f74bf314448503e5b9dead2e99a6f758bf","localRef":"s26"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","scopeContentSha256":"24d924b5a5bc7ad2a4781a4ea77c66d1d13b0049360b252c512645dbbd8609aa","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l25","originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:7","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l25","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge:link:7","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l25","source":"s39","target":"s26","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Damping and modified dynamics provide distinct approaches to inflationary evolution; background damping and viable perturbations remain separate tests."],"challengeStatement":"Damping and modified dynamics offer distinct inflationary mechanisms. Background evolution, perturbative viability and coupling control remain separate tests.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"c161eba2381372983d0f8e9ea12c64d7a3a1205caf79f3c7f8b2ea60ab3d41c0","reply.jsonSha256":"632fafe96baf728ba9d00850d623a19157239ef566a70594ff626494d3f3197c","reply.raw.txtSha256":"15306244106294660445f03eb77d08cb76fa78002f95c7863f1147bd8f8a5b35","receipt.jsonSha256":"c11af3c33647b9495cd7e48e8a686f4743169fd93054e830aeadb03cb0a4d05d","normalization.jsonSha256":"6a4227bfd832d6189ee96f4de5d7f894cf0746fc5b084fa7af3eee2278765226","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"abb555b94b152f00eb3e2e68903961d6c2c79578bef021eebc276159f0cd00b0"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ba12b42c90a79a673e56-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"87406847671a4b83ede2c017a85bc474b612bd8a12625c9a98115b2e26b9f723","reply.jsonSha256":"cf97ad48a4dd5480d7561b8299db3ea0c867e1662a089719638c6d8deb316a90","reply.raw.txtSha256":"21deb0513b4a33261280a4e2fdb062233191f43b40bff5fc00f44f157f2265da","receipt.jsonSha256":"aa693037ffa1cc174b8dac921f1f624ba920f429a096de26cb93103f7e77738d","normalization.jsonSha256":"cbcc8e426a85c134bb4b97a0a7f4c44e4480adc1e4b48b845b4d029e07428724"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d25","originalRef":"l25","status":"route","source":"s26","target":"s39","type":"method_for","title":"Use damping and modified dynamics in inflationary-control questions","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the mechanisms in s26 supply distinct approaches to the inflationary-evolution component of s39.","qualification":"Background damping, perturbative viability, stability and controlled coupling generation remain separate tests. Abelian particle production, classical non-Abelian backgrounds, thermal dissipation, derivative interactions and spinodal effects are not one mechanism. Inflationary dissipation does not establish reheating completion. The simplest supplied 2010 construction's reported excessive scalar amplitude remains a failure, and missing chromo-natural action or coupling conventions are not reconstructed.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l25","s26","s39"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d25","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The damping and modified-dynamics mechanisms supply approaches to the inflationary component of s39, supporting the reversed method direction. The qualification preserves both statements' separation of background evolution, perturbative viability and coupling control. Distinct mechanisms, the reported scalar-amplitude failure and missing action conventions remain explicit.","refs":["l25","s26","s39"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l25","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l26":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l26","source":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","target":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5","type":"application_of","title":"Trace the ALP relic scenario to scalar evolution and incomplete reheating","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the specified ALP abundance scenario applies scalar evolution and energy-transfer dynamics organized in s32. Both statements explicitly identify that application.","qualification":"This route is limited to the ALP contrast; the complete candidate scope in s4 retains independently motivated non-scalar candidates. Incomplete reheating remains part of the stated scenario. Energy transfer does not establish a completed thermal history or a viable abundance, and the connection supplies no common production mechanism for all dark matter.","evidenceIds":["unit:086443a70e473b97b9bf2b7cef696694c8b0c2e3ed9d6cce4c0e47b19fb12e22","unit:0ac5f33eee9e30f13d39d3e40376e84955b2b4250896a9c79dff2932fe52ddfe","unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","unit:1e96331a613901b21e0941d90c6652e41bcf7c74ba6030bed0a42d0a478e2968","unit:2d3d65b41648c0f939fba5152e588f2fb018d4e2274f758e39c6b9da23a72c57","unit:36f38a0bcfe9b654ecb7a0cf1f78b8db9a38da51786d7cba3deb93177ef94253","unit:383d13703c71f3f25373a6ba0e1661f1e7e8cdeb7bd60a8065f24cc2200577f8","unit:3a27d6408cf96805cf6c280eb0c67b7715232bc784b79320000b8679b38de17a","unit:4388ba5c525b417e4a3e81463cabf723b16fda2447df04105d5d37c95b9f7fad","unit:56017bdcddd38ed7cba4066f0d2855ab32f64ec5330fc5104299358b29497dba","unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","unit:699d34cdd7756d1c072c7a517702ec67f86c041e11097f1ed8ca0fb4a3816e82","unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","unit:743a5ec4ec3327442a03957751dfa536fef453cc99c934ad167cc223432045a0","unit:886390bae4de13ca3fa9e42b4829aee4c1b2f9d3fa5107860df6115430055e16","unit:8e20c0326768a1f649bdfd14b44bd23e09092673cf36a5ad36fe7532ac92f1c6","unit:96c6613c2dd137e812dbc4166a6e8ead41b9b0d2a2518722c8fa4f4de6056bbc","unit:9f867e2655c9ee718616d07641d24237d81c9f1ee269a6f9ce1169bb7a5ebaee","unit:a757dfd6e7766fa39431351f4621d054ffbea3c8fc2ad8463b5fe265bc329bf7","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:c78813fed1118a3a9647db73b578c6931e7f80a6e2ea08f4a434be88cb997525","unit:cf0f5d73068de72fc720bc98c5772e2ad522fbd1b1df061575a88c53cc930bb5","unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","unit:dbed9b6879afe9a03c27774aa14c0f3595a9a18d55979fecac48c074509831f2","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","scopeContentSha256":"392640e6a9b8a01652bc7d6dafda7769a164fa44c0efde3644a103be5f08f62a","localRef":"s4"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5","scopeContentSha256":"5e6b6063a3483707453be2900203de57a3f5f636a73095514d99bb64730dd13f","localRef":"s32"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l26","originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge:link:34","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l26","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge:link:34","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l26","source":"s32","target":"s4","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["The ALP contrast links scalar evolution and incomplete reheating to relic abundance. The dark-matter destination also retains independently motivated non-scalar candidates."],"challengeStatement":"The ALP scenario links scalar evolution and incomplete reheating to relic abundance. The destination also retains independently motivated non-scalar candidates.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"e5504a2c4da076c85104a2266ee2d7736e709a7e52a5d800af1700943c465cac","reply.jsonSha256":"c7670a2a3f34e361015dbf9482392020b1a573e8a83b6a60c6d900a13e7586eb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7128fb9710583d064a2fdcc6d110ef96841760bd1a2dbd1edd5c8ddfa1e91415","receipt.jsonSha256":"1dfa74ad6830cffb2282b232a13cc93ffd43f1fb20e262f22448b79744e21f56","normalization.jsonSha256":"dc92ec109885b2b11e32b021171ca6cb99228c52647c0739d967d53f52076084","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4fe88709dd8c30df946cd8ecebff01e16afac4d554ebd9a82df8762a9494b5cd"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"783fca8ad0c206144b663c532d96a903a50df8724949f88395f9d5e460bfcc59","reply.jsonSha256":"a5b87b3059ea83dd4136caff9089a981a93d2932676041a5fb90dc12adfba988","reply.raw.txtSha256":"0150d21a762614339b2ad10b13e27b5e332664b355b59600c635fd0574428e03","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a03ea25b1d3f029bf1b8a76cff9e15f8ffafc2b2052cabf5059938d238e7b36","normalization.jsonSha256":"f9d3c8d0a480348d5e8e97bd7f55dad45c7dd4baec013e9547a323081f64a5be"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1702.03284","sourceId":"ev:1afc171f22bb44f77a9bb5482c3485f5","sourceSha256":"b3358a16cf70f83a310645e3b48ee5f181f65cd7cd3acc99693edd6ebce4583a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1fef8e014ca510b817ee/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5fc4b2ff8dc0870ab100e71e5548e6f1764d865194794231166cf5a6d151f953","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1948,"textSha256":"fc8592bb3537316843086b72635a895d151679190698734c4375468aa61c4231","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"1702.03284","sourceId":"ev:bbd7299494898f376891b1d909068c66","sourceSha256":"b3358a16cf70f83a310645e3b48ee5f181f65cd7cd3acc99693edd6ebce4583a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1fef8e014ca510b817ee/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5fc4b2ff8dc0870ab100e71e5548e6f1764d865194794231166cf5a6d151f953","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3499,"textSha256":"10d737979e1c7a38119d8a41f3ccf106c7ea7a7529dd53d0d5d098c4a831693a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1702.03284","sourceId":"ev:1afc171f22bb44f77a9bb5482c3485f5","sourceSha256":"b3358a16cf70f83a310645e3b48ee5f181f65cd7cd3acc99693edd6ebce4583a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1fef8e014ca510b817ee/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5fc4b2ff8dc0870ab100e71e5548e6f1764d865194794231166cf5a6d151f953","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1948,"textSha256":"fc8592bb3537316843086b72635a895d151679190698734c4375468aa61c4231","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"1702.03284","sourceId":"ev:bbd7299494898f376891b1d909068c66","sourceSha256":"b3358a16cf70f83a310645e3b48ee5f181f65cd7cd3acc99693edd6ebce4583a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1fef8e014ca510b817ee/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5fc4b2ff8dc0870ab100e71e5548e6f1764d865194794231166cf5a6d151f953","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3499,"textSha256":"10d737979e1c7a38119d8a41f3ccf106c7ea7a7529dd53d0d5d098c4a831693a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d26","originalRef":"l26","status":"route","source":"s4","target":"s32","type":"application_of","title":"Trace the ALP relic scenario to scalar evolution and incomplete reheating","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the specified ALP abundance scenario applies scalar evolution and energy-transfer dynamics organized in s32. Both statements explicitly identify that application.","qualification":"This route is limited to the ALP contrast; the complete candidate scope in s4 retains independently motivated non-scalar candidates. Incomplete reheating remains part of the stated scenario. Energy transfer does not establish a completed thermal history or a viable abundance, and the connection supplies no common production mechanism for all dark matter.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l26","s4","s32"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d26","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify a specific ALP relic scenario linking scalar evolution and incomplete reheating to abundance. That supports the reversed application direction for this component. The qualification expressly preserves independently motivated non-scalar candidates and avoids extending the application or its production mechanism to all of s4.","refs":["l26","s4","s32"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l26","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l27":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l27","source":"q025-candidate-question:8fb651398d0b3088fc0b3df4","target":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5","type":"application_of","title":"Trace early axion histories to scalar dynamics and energy transfer","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: early and intermediate axion histories apply scalar dynamics and interactions to expansion, matter properties and radiation.","qualification":"These applications need not share a potential, equation of state or production process. Post-reheating kination, BBN, recombination, equality and later transients retain distinct epochs. Late relativistic axion emission is not automatically a recombination-era ΔNeff constraint. Historical tension relief remains a source-era target, and neither the conditional WGC estimate nor the stated single-axion trade-off becomes a universal result.","evidenceIds":["unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","unit:36f38a0bcfe9b654ecb7a0cf1f78b8db9a38da51786d7cba3deb93177ef94253","unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","unit:678f966692576be2ec931aa2c4536661f2cbe091382aeed5e55a22031bc8cd15","unit:7e20c59adca55cf6639957178a7dd3dbffae7c89a6a6d00555102da06a1478b0","unit:8589a795b3c3304ad9163d0c9905e9c28360bed7df494e8d58942b569ae543ca","unit:a63af1f399a818071def931852f274e26e4b6ba1a36b770c5f7fbf6187291439","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:c213b80be80ab833bb6401eb8c018d1569fc6f04d9186fcede15d7c1a88b0513","unit:dc06133ac8f843d3ef6f2e87b2f3c2b61f8e5e19acde58012185b7d99257ea1d","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a","unit:ebd0a34924be07207d236aae6a251efa2d7438b4ddfc5cb5a00abbceeaab08e4","unit:fa7372bf16bc3ae6b7c5e396f5c6ff0ada6292982fbf075aa43aba334571f6b8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8fb651398d0b3088fc0b3df4","scopeContentSha256":"1c4e8c70a5565e704c44ae01d79a17020a4557193c004c86edfc4525f7cb6e9b","localRef":"s19"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5","scopeContentSha256":"5e6b6063a3483707453be2900203de57a3f5f636a73095514d99bb64730dd13f","localRef":"s32"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l27","originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:32","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l27","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:32","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:8fb651398d0b3088fc0b3df4","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l27","source":"s32","target":"s19","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Early and intermediate axion histories include different expansion, matter-property and radiation targets."],"challengeStatement":"Early and intermediate axion histories apply scalar dynamics to expansion, matter properties and radiation.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"0d479554dd0b39ca9daf07157c4f39675210457752a02cafa57ef8e2f52bfa7e","reply.jsonSha256":"b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd4722ba8dda705c880ad49294161d9061295ac5c5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9f3caf81e788c84ac0164350156eee9d2eb362baacf7ad9f05eaf093273877e8","receipt.jsonSha256":"1165f285c2c643f1a2270fabeb515a22bfcd8476412d71364f6c4b7cc0b1b52b","normalization.jsonSha256":"65d79380e46d8c2f1a63efb46f5d49883594612e5b03d1e4c4c4cbcabbee2346","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4a44ea5475d2801e35e1e86aad6ff99d9db2dce8307fdc2c9041f7beb32dd37a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"876fcf82b3760877d5adf0ad3cea3352e0f0e96e9be01cbf7c7325a0609e4a55","reply.jsonSha256":"a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d2e1d06273788a3258264e645c16dcacdaa3f68ac","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d04dfd346aec28f9d51f6dd453759d3040c159c9b9041a0287eecdb7310d96d9","receipt.jsonSha256":"a1fa78d73a75fe703fb1cbeac5b35a16ddc235795219891d7e028e0e8f09c26b","normalization.jsonSha256":"2e493e2c7f4741d29428ad8769d68daf9d37a86a64b17eea548d298edea89613"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x5_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8fb651398d0b3088fc0b3df4"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x5_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8fb651398d0b3088fc0b3df4"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d27","originalRef":"l27","status":"route","source":"s19","target":"s32","type":"application_of","title":"Trace early axion histories to scalar dynamics and energy transfer","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: early and intermediate axion histories apply scalar dynamics and interactions to expansion, matter properties and radiation.","qualification":"These applications need not share a potential, equation of state or production process. Post-reheating kination, BBN, recombination, equality and later transients retain distinct epochs. Late relativistic axion emission is not automatically a recombination-era ΔNeff constraint. Historical tension relief remains a source-era target, and neither the conditional WGC estimate nor the stated single-axion trade-off becomes a universal result.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l27","s19","s32"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d27","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original challenge explicitly identifies early and intermediate axion histories as applications of scalar dynamics to expansion, matter properties and radiation. Reversing the application direction is supported. The record retains different potentials, processes and epochs, including the distinction between late emission and recombination-era radiation constraints.","refs":["l27","s19","s32"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l27","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l28":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l28","source":"q025-candidate-question:51b3bbe3f82492c7c856a7b8","target":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5","type":"application_of","title":"Trace axiodilaton screening to scalar interactions and effective-theory control","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the screening question applies scalar dynamics and interactions to local forces, source profiles and effective-theory control.","qualification":"Screening efficacy is not assumed. Microscopic coupling, matter dependence and kinetic geometry remain source-specific, and neutron-star calculations are not interchangeable with weak-field solar-system calculations. A nonzero axion gradient does not establish efficient screening. The neutron-star efficacy assessment remains work in progress, and generic Brans–Dicke methods do not supply an axion interaction.","evidenceIds":["unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","unit:2d35ce15b2d11cdc41384ab07f103be1f7e322ec9ec17aa00ddaac2dae187a52","unit:2d9ffeab556377b9602c00a0b59c9937fe9228e9822a3366c1886772a0eda39d","unit:36f38a0bcfe9b654ecb7a0cf1f78b8db9a38da51786d7cba3deb93177ef94253","unit:66a6ec58497f924fae8d5142fa827cf4747439be4c89ea4fe02dc1a37cdd7a9d","unit:678f966692576be2ec931aa2c4536661f2cbe091382aeed5e55a22031bc8cd15","unit:84f7837aaa838b43f86ca0b1f9d246a71640b984dfd2992b32e26429618e4fcc","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:b3683c545f406bfcfcaec31f5fcceb8464093c611eb250d4a619568007f17573","unit:bf01a470d92840fc08ba2d2940d62b6cef8edc3d131a40ea92dd54605007ddf0","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:51b3bbe3f82492c7c856a7b8","scopeContentSha256":"d72e5a9889f7932c4f825521bc31c760707782ed75b20eabe3c6039e5880703f","localRef":"s8"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5","scopeContentSha256":"5e6b6063a3483707453be2900203de57a3f5f636a73095514d99bb64730dd13f","localRef":"s32"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l28","originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:33","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l28","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:33","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:51b3bbe3f82492c7c856a7b8","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l28","source":"s32","target":"s8","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Axiodilaton screening applies scalar dynamics to local-force and control questions; efficacy is not assumed."],"challengeStatement":"Axiodilaton screening applies scalar interactions to local-force and effective-theory questions without assuming screening efficacy.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"0d479554dd0b39ca9daf07157c4f39675210457752a02cafa57ef8e2f52bfa7e","reply.jsonSha256":"b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd4722ba8dda705c880ad49294161d9061295ac5c5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9f3caf81e788c84ac0164350156eee9d2eb362baacf7ad9f05eaf093273877e8","receipt.jsonSha256":"1165f285c2c643f1a2270fabeb515a22bfcd8476412d71364f6c4b7cc0b1b52b","normalization.jsonSha256":"65d79380e46d8c2f1a63efb46f5d49883594612e5b03d1e4c4c4cbcabbee2346","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4a44ea5475d2801e35e1e86aad6ff99d9db2dce8307fdc2c9041f7beb32dd37a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"876fcf82b3760877d5adf0ad3cea3352e0f0e96e9be01cbf7c7325a0609e4a55","reply.jsonSha256":"a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d2e1d06273788a3258264e645c16dcacdaa3f68ac","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d04dfd346aec28f9d51f6dd453759d3040c159c9b9041a0287eecdb7310d96d9","receipt.jsonSha256":"a1fa78d73a75fe703fb1cbeac5b35a16ddc235795219891d7e028e0e8f09c26b","normalization.jsonSha256":"2e493e2c7f4741d29428ad8769d68daf9d37a86a64b17eea548d298edea89613"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x5_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:51b3bbe3f82492c7c856a7b8"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x5_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:51b3bbe3f82492c7c856a7b8"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d28","originalRef":"l28","status":"route","source":"s8","target":"s32","type":"application_of","title":"Trace axiodilaton screening to scalar interactions and effective-theory control","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the screening question applies scalar dynamics and interactions to local forces, source profiles and effective-theory control.","qualification":"Screening efficacy is not assumed. Microscopic coupling, matter dependence and kinetic geometry remain source-specific, and neutron-star calculations are not interchangeable with weak-field solar-system calculations. A nonzero axion gradient does not establish efficient screening. The neutron-star efficacy assessment remains work in progress, and generic Brans–Dicke methods do not supply an axion interaction.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l28","s8","s32"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d28","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify axiodilaton screening as an application of scalar dynamics or interactions to local forces and effective-theory control. The reversed application direction is correct. The record preserves source-specific couplings and environments, distinguishes strong-gravity profiles from weak-field tests, and leaves screening efficacy unfinished.","refs":["l28","s8","s32"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l28","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l29":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l29","source":"q025-candidate-question:6035a222637f761054da8621","target":"q025-candidate-question:51b3bbe3f82492c7c856a7b8","type":"method_for","title":"Use generic particle-screening analysis as axiodilaton methodological context","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the generic Brans–Dicke particle calculation supplies methodological context for the scalar-tensor screening component of s8. It does not establish axion-induced force reduction.","qualification":"The method retains arbitrary A(vχ), potential couplings with kinetic mixing treated as subdominant, and a constant or slowly evolving late-time gravitational scalar. It uses the Einstein frame, canonically normalized fields and local fermion density. Its retained broken-symmetry branch excludes the vanishing-Higgs-VEV, massless-fermion limit. No axion is added, and the broader mass-generation and galactic applications are not independently verified.","evidenceIds":["unit:2d35ce15b2d11cdc41384ab07f103be1f7e322ec9ec17aa00ddaac2dae187a52","unit:2d9ffeab556377b9602c00a0b59c9937fe9228e9822a3366c1886772a0eda39d","unit:66a6ec58497f924fae8d5142fa827cf4747439be4c89ea4fe02dc1a37cdd7a9d","unit:678f966692576be2ec931aa2c4536661f2cbe091382aeed5e55a22031bc8cd15","unit:84f7837aaa838b43f86ca0b1f9d246a71640b984dfd2992b32e26429618e4fcc","unit:b3683c545f406bfcfcaec31f5fcceb8464093c611eb250d4a619568007f17573","unit:bf01a470d92840fc08ba2d2940d62b6cef8edc3d131a40ea92dd54605007ddf0"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6035a222637f761054da8621","scopeContentSha256":"dc9bd8f950e6fd72729e31037dd2b75eb255f566d20573a2ed5ff3ff98b1c139","localRef":"s10"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:51b3bbe3f82492c7c856a7b8","scopeContentSha256":"d72e5a9889f7932c4f825521bc31c760707782ed75b20eabe3c6039e5880703f","localRef":"s8"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l29","originalCandidateId":"parent-4b8be5938efde44fe7a7-challenge:link:36","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l29","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-4b8be5938efde44fe7a7-challenge:link:36","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:51b3bbe3f82492c7c856a7b8","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:6035a222637f761054da8621","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l29","source":"s8","target":"s10","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["The generic scalar-tensor particle calculation is relevant methodological context, but it does not answer whether an axion interaction reduces a dilaton force."],"challengeStatement":"Generic particle screening supplies methodological context but does not establish that an axion interaction reduces a dilaton force.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-4b8be5938efde44fe7a7-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-4b8be5938efde44fe7a7-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"b0d932aa1644fec81b5ac56c9250a79043893527db06974592404afbece8bf74","reply.jsonSha256":"63b4960c3aa1e33fcf2b3f4a9485ca9a730e95cc99967b1354e8b66e034251d6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"2170e6d415cd0e438c38cf40a52c3da1a0d56953ab172236df50f2525a3d6d2b","receipt.jsonSha256":"c00eb8a4527c9b7729add7f7c4551bdcd6e88b226c52dc1e639f3a7e3867e2a1","normalization.jsonSha256":"d2e2f250121cc0e301e9a9a6dda35ab9e7455ad8d194827992caeb778bb34b35","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-4b8be5938efde44fe7a7-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"1b30a5472f1a0d53473c48a3658ac3c5c8b36e56047698fea77c8b0ea0a2e834"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-4b8be5938efde44fe7a7-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"9317840f22c1c690fbabc13c6a6527e0f928edf15db44347fa8c40cddf5a262a","reply.jsonSha256":"a9756412da5dc35380812306475e71cb259601d1baa6c20dbc9230bbb3b01330","reply.raw.txtSha256":"4933c7602a84e3a5a731dc9c6ea80a525b8ee3d575ecf5278e2be6efa5d8d7c7","receipt.jsonSha256":"577f1c1683e6dc82a5405cd99627c29268b8b65b0cf4aa4671f2dfdf5d9112a2","normalization.jsonSha256":"7853f941e2516179e399371a61f67487213f4a3d01766c46ff5275b0fc54a40f"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:51b3bbe3f82492c7c856a7b8"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2407.08779","sourceId":"ev:3b0d94e5e779d59f408deaeebce04be9","sourceSha256":"e45ef9a1f9ba27599337c54608d41a2e7f961c9775f85dc59f1be4f33f67d68d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bbd6c794209d5e7beb2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e233ba83e136ead8440c7daa3ccd9e88a1af37fe5fbe2a8388dd1ca1933f184","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"21ae74bd63407121e67242fec71526844c8aa118d8d4cb4e5de4b53fed82217e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"2407.08779","sourceId":"ev:dbb3d57b24a90b500f23c1cb656619df","sourceSha256":"e45ef9a1f9ba27599337c54608d41a2e7f961c9775f85dc59f1be4f33f67d68d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bbd6c794209d5e7beb2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e233ba83e136ead8440c7daa3ccd9e88a1af37fe5fbe2a8388dd1ca1933f184","pdfPage":7,"start":0,"end":2729,"textSha256":"b157dc3aafaaae33c38d1244d3876958cf1d52a1e7d8d51ed260764db1289f22","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:51b3bbe3f82492c7c856a7b8"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2407.08779","sourceId":"ev:3b0d94e5e779d59f408deaeebce04be9","sourceSha256":"e45ef9a1f9ba27599337c54608d41a2e7f961c9775f85dc59f1be4f33f67d68d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bbd6c794209d5e7beb2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e233ba83e136ead8440c7daa3ccd9e88a1af37fe5fbe2a8388dd1ca1933f184","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"21ae74bd63407121e67242fec71526844c8aa118d8d4cb4e5de4b53fed82217e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"2407.08779","sourceId":"ev:dbb3d57b24a90b500f23c1cb656619df","sourceSha256":"e45ef9a1f9ba27599337c54608d41a2e7f961c9775f85dc59f1be4f33f67d68d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bbd6c794209d5e7beb2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e233ba83e136ead8440c7daa3ccd9e88a1af37fe5fbe2a8388dd1ca1933f184","pdfPage":7,"start":0,"end":2729,"textSha256":"b157dc3aafaaae33c38d1244d3876958cf1d52a1e7d8d51ed260764db1289f22","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d29","originalRef":"l29","status":"route","source":"s10","target":"s8","type":"method_for","title":"Use generic particle-screening analysis as axiodilaton methodological context","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the generic Brans–Dicke particle calculation supplies methodological context for the scalar-tensor screening component of s8. It does not establish axion-induced force reduction.","qualification":"The method retains arbitrary A(vχ), potential couplings with kinetic mixing treated as subdominant, and a constant or slowly evolving late-time gravitational scalar. It uses the Einstein frame, canonically normalized fields and local fermion density. Its retained broken-symmetry branch excludes the vanishing-Higgs-VEV, massless-fermion limit. No axion is added, and the broader mass-generation and galactic applications are not independently verified.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l29","s10","s8"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d29","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The generic particle calculation supplies the methodological context, so s10 → s8 is the correct method direction. Both original statements deny that it establishes axion-induced force reduction. The record retains the background, kinetic-mixing, frame, normalization and broken-symmetry restrictions without adding an axion interaction or verifying announced extensions.","refs":["l29","s10","s8"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l29","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l30":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l30","source":"q025-candidate-question:6035a222637f761054da8621","target":"q025-candidate-region:837ea0a4b78eeda261827a21","type":"method_for","title":"Use particle-screening methods in the adjacent scalar-tensor questions","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: s10 supplies the adjacent generic scalar-tensor screening method explicitly retained within s37. Parent inclusion does not supply an axion premise.","qualification":"Applicability is limited to that scalar-tensor component. Retain arbitrary background coupling, the potential-coupling treatment with subdominant kinetic mixing, the constant or slowly evolving late-time scalar, Einstein-frame canonical normalization and the retained broken-symmetry matter branch. The symmetry-restored massless-fermion limit is excluded. Neither the method nor the parent establishes axion screening efficacy, and the new overview remains provisional.","evidenceIds":["unit:66a6ec58497f924fae8d5142fa827cf4747439be4c89ea4fe02dc1a37cdd7a9d","unit:a01ae066a91edecba0afecb0a17beacca458f816263bcc1a2c115673c0551a34","unit:b103a72317a3c5ecb8c828815acd3dd69bc83e0a13264ece829351c5f896fac4","unit:d22c24711af895746971fbd84b326f858447ea7119bfe47f18062cd62b0d3901","unit:fffe9d4451f96329fa33ba038d7b5572a01e35bc98cfb828ac9b00c74d2f413c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6035a222637f761054da8621","scopeContentSha256":"dc9bd8f950e6fd72729e31037dd2b75eb255f566d20573a2ed5ff3ff98b1c139","localRef":"s10"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:837ea0a4b78eeda261827a21","scopeContentSha256":"c42ec8a7a23039bf4c93967c75d9f0111a5c824a033efe14860e9eb8d89a046e","localRef":"s37"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l30","originalCandidateId":"parent-4b8be5938efde44fe7a7-challenge:link:14","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l30","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-4b8be5938efde44fe7a7-challenge:link:14","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:837ea0a4b78eeda261827a21","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:6035a222637f761054da8621","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l30","source":"s37","target":"s10","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Generic Brans–Dicke particle screening supplies an adjacent method home; parent inclusion does not add an axion to the source."],"challengeStatement":"Provides an adjacent generic scalar-tensor screening home without assigning an axion to that source.","originalEvidenceKinds":["primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-4b8be5938efde44fe7a7-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-4b8be5938efde44fe7a7-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"b0d932aa1644fec81b5ac56c9250a79043893527db06974592404afbece8bf74","reply.jsonSha256":"63b4960c3aa1e33fcf2b3f4a9485ca9a730e95cc99967b1354e8b66e034251d6","reply.raw.txtSha256":"2170e6d415cd0e438c38cf40a52c3da1a0d56953ab172236df50f2525a3d6d2b","receipt.jsonSha256":"c00eb8a4527c9b7729add7f7c4551bdcd6e88b226c52dc1e639f3a7e3867e2a1","normalization.jsonSha256":"d2e2f250121cc0e301e9a9a6dda35ab9e7455ad8d194827992caeb778bb34b35","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-4b8be5938efde44fe7a7-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"1b30a5472f1a0d53473c48a3658ac3c5c8b36e56047698fea77c8b0ea0a2e834"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-4b8be5938efde44fe7a7-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"9317840f22c1c690fbabc13c6a6527e0f928edf15db44347fa8c40cddf5a262a","reply.jsonSha256":"a9756412da5dc35380812306475e71cb259601d1baa6c20dbc9230bbb3b01330","reply.raw.txtSha256":"4933c7602a84e3a5a731dc9c6ea80a525b8ee3d575ecf5278e2be6efa5d8d7c7","receipt.jsonSha256":"577f1c1683e6dc82a5405cd99627c29268b8b65b0cf4aa4671f2dfdf5d9112a2","normalization.jsonSha256":"7853f941e2516179e399371a61f67487213f4a3d01766c46ff5275b0fc54a40f"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"2407.08779","sourceId":"ev:3063c41a8a13c0f0144f1286708e552a","sourceSha256":"e45ef9a1f9ba27599337c54608d41a2e7f961c9775f85dc59f1be4f33f67d68d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bbd6c794209d5e7beb2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e233ba83e136ead8440c7daa3ccd9e88a1af37fe5fbe2a8388dd1ca1933f184","pdfPage":3,"start":2494,"end":4047,"textSha256":"d61e0d79dad4444b5dc8d2a9c264309f414e75de1c4f5db39ed7377aec0e1f6f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2407.08779","sourceId":"ev:3b0d94e5e779d59f408deaeebce04be9","sourceSha256":"e45ef9a1f9ba27599337c54608d41a2e7f961c9775f85dc59f1be4f33f67d68d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bbd6c794209d5e7beb2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e233ba83e136ead8440c7daa3ccd9e88a1af37fe5fbe2a8388dd1ca1933f184","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"21ae74bd63407121e67242fec71526844c8aa118d8d4cb4e5de4b53fed82217e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"2407.08779","sourceId":"ev:dbb3d57b24a90b500f23c1cb656619df","sourceSha256":"e45ef9a1f9ba27599337c54608d41a2e7f961c9775f85dc59f1be4f33f67d68d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bbd6c794209d5e7beb2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e233ba83e136ead8440c7daa3ccd9e88a1af37fe5fbe2a8388dd1ca1933f184","pdfPage":7,"start":0,"end":2729,"textSha256":"b157dc3aafaaae33c38d1244d3876958cf1d52a1e7d8d51ed260764db1289f22","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"2407.08779","sourceId":"ev:3063c41a8a13c0f0144f1286708e552a","sourceSha256":"e45ef9a1f9ba27599337c54608d41a2e7f961c9775f85dc59f1be4f33f67d68d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bbd6c794209d5e7beb2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e233ba83e136ead8440c7daa3ccd9e88a1af37fe5fbe2a8388dd1ca1933f184","pdfPage":3,"start":2494,"end":4047,"textSha256":"d61e0d79dad4444b5dc8d2a9c264309f414e75de1c4f5db39ed7377aec0e1f6f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2407.08779","sourceId":"ev:3b0d94e5e779d59f408deaeebce04be9","sourceSha256":"e45ef9a1f9ba27599337c54608d41a2e7f961c9775f85dc59f1be4f33f67d68d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bbd6c794209d5e7beb2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e233ba83e136ead8440c7daa3ccd9e88a1af37fe5fbe2a8388dd1ca1933f184","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"21ae74bd63407121e67242fec71526844c8aa118d8d4cb4e5de4b53fed82217e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"2407.08779","sourceId":"ev:dbb3d57b24a90b500f23c1cb656619df","sourceSha256":"e45ef9a1f9ba27599337c54608d41a2e7f961c9775f85dc59f1be4f33f67d68d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bbd6c794209d5e7beb2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6e233ba83e136ead8440c7daa3ccd9e88a1af37fe5fbe2a8388dd1ca1933f184","pdfPage":7,"start":0,"end":2729,"textSha256":"b157dc3aafaaae33c38d1244d3876958cf1d52a1e7d8d51ed260764db1289f22","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d30","originalRef":"l30","status":"route","source":"s10","target":"s37","type":"method_for","title":"Use particle-screening methods in the adjacent scalar-tensor questions","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: s10 supplies the adjacent generic scalar-tensor screening method explicitly retained within s37. Parent inclusion does not supply an axion premise.","qualification":"Applicability is limited to that scalar-tensor component. Retain arbitrary background coupling, the potential-coupling treatment with subdominant kinetic mixing, the constant or slowly evolving late-time scalar, Einstein-frame canonical normalization and the retained broken-symmetry matter branch. The symmetry-restored massless-fermion limit is excluded. Neither the method nor the parent establishes axion screening efficacy, and the new overview remains provisional.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l30","s10","s37"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d30","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The complete parent scope explicitly includes adjacent scalar-tensor screening questions, supporting a method connection from s10 to that component of s37. The record preserves both original statements' refusal to infer an axion premise from parent inclusion, retains the calculation's applicability restrictions and leaves the overview provisional.","refs":["l30","s10","s37"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l30","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l31":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l31","source":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","target":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5","type":"application_of","title":"Trace inflationary spectra and reconstruction to specified scalar histories","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: spectral prediction and reconstruction apply the scalar-background evolution considered in s32 and test the corresponding histories.","qualification":"Relations among spectra, field excursions, energy scales and model parameters remain background-dependent. Preserve the specified crossing prescription, e-fold evaluation epoch, observable interval and preceding history. Small-field or nonmonotonic examples do not establish a universal excursion bound. Reconstruction from historical observational summaries is not a current fit, and a fitted interval does not establish sufficient inflation or its termination.","evidenceIds":["unit:0b97a5b0cd1dfc92c04586c623bab9db9f0be77e3afaa142a4e65aee941be33d","unit:191b042c99b96a6bbf9054bb55f0a26fd22f39ecb72902e415b194c805d36959","unit:1acdbfde4891df21db56ffa8b5f06998c7c2cf160530a25da77bbacd7c1016ce","unit:1fcb591c2eef1d7f1736d14cfd5f0657c10cf46ddb378fc5fd9e59d1109495f2","unit:28cc3b8fbc59cb74cee255fb796373ce619cff34da0cf31634c5e2d8732b8aa0","unit:36f38a0bcfe9b654ecb7a0cf1f78b8db9a38da51786d7cba3deb93177ef94253","unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","unit:7405da195cb830f27b2cd597163f8f4435a5030c41d088896b6f666b1bb2db6a","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:bed792616c1d639d395b11b23c540ebfb15789613a361cb814a5ae83711f55e5","unit:c2b5e41e943b0473e5089ba598ef130ffb2472b981725ca11a500e88860850ee","unit:d7be6dedc1f0ebe9db505a6d2a0e52bfc67bda19fb0d810974550e35b53ed7bb","unit:e57e1d89fc7648522699b0c38404e493146e0b5a1ae4c40e6ca23de1f603b81a","unit:fe379acef869280e8dd5e98899501ac6ec3e3dd42cdeaeba4cf123c6630e5147"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","scopeContentSha256":"29f9bef9407be52a4a73021a58c1ea2b135a172ca9f15f97d64890e6b981f802","localRef":"s25"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5","scopeContentSha256":"5e6b6063a3483707453be2900203de57a3f5f636a73095514d99bb64730dd13f","localRef":"s32"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l31","originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge:link:32","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l31","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge:link:32","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l31","source":"s32","target":"s25","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Inflationary spectra and reconstruction test specified scalar histories; their relations to scales and excursions remain model dependent."],"challengeStatement":"Inflationary spectra test specified scalar histories. Relations to field ranges, scales and model parameters retain their background and crossing conventions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"e5504a2c4da076c85104a2266ee2d7736e709a7e52a5d800af1700943c465cac","reply.jsonSha256":"c7670a2a3f34e361015dbf9482392020b1a573e8a83b6a60c6d900a13e7586eb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7128fb9710583d064a2fdcc6d110ef96841760bd1a2dbd1edd5c8ddfa1e91415","receipt.jsonSha256":"1dfa74ad6830cffb2282b232a13cc93ffd43f1fb20e262f22448b79744e21f56","normalization.jsonSha256":"dc92ec109885b2b11e32b021171ca6cb99228c52647c0739d967d53f52076084","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4fe88709dd8c30df946cd8ecebff01e16afac4d554ebd9a82df8762a9494b5cd"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"783fca8ad0c206144b663c532d96a903a50df8724949f88395f9d5e460bfcc59","reply.jsonSha256":"a5b87b3059ea83dd4136caff9089a981a93d2932676041a5fb90dc12adfba988","reply.raw.txtSha256":"0150d21a762614339b2ad10b13e27b5e332664b355b59600c635fd0574428e03","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a03ea25b1d3f029bf1b8a76cff9e15f8ffafc2b2052cabf5059938d238e7b36","normalization.jsonSha256":"f9d3c8d0a480348d5e8e97bd7f55dad45c7dd4baec013e9547a323081f64a5be"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5"},{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2011.13957","sourceId":"ev:a0a225d78b62bb3102eb5a024c3e019f","sourceSha256":"9330c43787a3dfbc6b159dd5a0615c8c778804069913a1f74daa4f7f17ea72a8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/09a4ae2e864ef6cae4bd/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ab2b6474a0c57000f81c471355552881518f24d64871612c4a289725974b530d","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2761,"textSha256":"4815eb2961528a49383f8373c3657165d0840a20e1b579f48028cbcd5c7a16f9","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1702.03284","sourceId":"ev:1afc171f22bb44f77a9bb5482c3485f5","sourceSha256":"b3358a16cf70f83a310645e3b48ee5f181f65cd7cd3acc99693edd6ebce4583a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1fef8e014ca510b817ee/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5fc4b2ff8dc0870ab100e71e5548e6f1764d865194794231166cf5a6d151f953","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1948,"textSha256":"fc8592bb3537316843086b72635a895d151679190698734c4375468aa61c4231","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"1702.03284","sourceId":"ev:bbd7299494898f376891b1d909068c66","sourceSha256":"b3358a16cf70f83a310645e3b48ee5f181f65cd7cd3acc99693edd6ebce4583a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1fef8e014ca510b817ee/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5fc4b2ff8dc0870ab100e71e5548e6f1764d865194794231166cf5a6d151f953","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3499,"textSha256":"10d737979e1c7a38119d8a41f3ccf106c7ea7a7529dd53d0d5d098c4a831693a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e495f6c39fe6bd5641a228b5"},{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2011.13957","sourceId":"ev:a0a225d78b62bb3102eb5a024c3e019f","sourceSha256":"9330c43787a3dfbc6b159dd5a0615c8c778804069913a1f74daa4f7f17ea72a8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/09a4ae2e864ef6cae4bd/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ab2b6474a0c57000f81c471355552881518f24d64871612c4a289725974b530d","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2761,"textSha256":"4815eb2961528a49383f8373c3657165d0840a20e1b579f48028cbcd5c7a16f9","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"2011.13957","sourceId":"ev:a95af48b535562c95750fecf06acf10a","sourceSha256":"9330c43787a3dfbc6b159dd5a0615c8c778804069913a1f74daa4f7f17ea72a8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/09a4ae2e864ef6cae4bd/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ab2b6474a0c57000f81c471355552881518f24d64871612c4a289725974b530d","pdfPage":25,"start":0,"end":2671,"textSha256":"e54775b789803405abc8d1fd4240c133659697b6f55ea4f03ae5a8d48eb21797","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1702.03284","sourceId":"ev:1afc171f22bb44f77a9bb5482c3485f5","sourceSha256":"b3358a16cf70f83a310645e3b48ee5f181f65cd7cd3acc99693edd6ebce4583a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1fef8e014ca510b817ee/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5fc4b2ff8dc0870ab100e71e5548e6f1764d865194794231166cf5a6d151f953","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1948,"textSha256":"fc8592bb3537316843086b72635a895d151679190698734c4375468aa61c4231","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"1702.03284","sourceId":"ev:bbd7299494898f376891b1d909068c66","sourceSha256":"b3358a16cf70f83a310645e3b48ee5f181f65cd7cd3acc99693edd6ebce4583a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1fef8e014ca510b817ee/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5fc4b2ff8dc0870ab100e71e5548e6f1764d865194794231166cf5a6d151f953","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3499,"textSha256":"10d737979e1c7a38119d8a41f3ccf106c7ea7a7529dd53d0d5d098c4a831693a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d31","originalRef":"l31","status":"route","source":"s25","target":"s32","type":"application_of","title":"Trace inflationary spectra and reconstruction to specified scalar histories","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: spectral prediction and reconstruction apply the scalar-background evolution considered in s32 and test the corresponding histories.","qualification":"Relations among spectra, field excursions, energy scales and model parameters remain background-dependent. Preserve the specified crossing prescription, e-fold evaluation epoch, observable interval and preceding history. Small-field or nonmonotonic examples do not establish a universal excursion bound. Reconstruction from historical observational summaries is not a current fit, and a fitted interval does not establish sufficient inflation or its termination.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l31","s25","s32"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d31","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Spectral prediction and reconstruction apply specified scalar-background evolution, supporting the reversed application direction. Both original statements' model dependence is retained, including field-range and scale interpretations, crossing conventions and evaluation epochs. The record does not infer a universal excursion bound, current fit or completed cosmological history.","refs":["l31","s25","s32"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l31","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l32":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l32","source":"q025-candidate-question:75746c8b2d2dcf6ced543642","target":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","type":"method_for","title":"Use the noncanonical p(X,ϕ) perturbation method for spectra","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the p(X,ϕ) component of s16 supplies the noncanonical linear-perturbation method relevant to spectral questions in s25.","qualification":"This method claim does not cover every mechanism grouped in s16. D-cceleration, NEC-violating evolution and stochastic vacuum transitions retain their separate dynamics. Definitions of X, gravitational normalization and slow-roll or power-law assumptions remain local; the high-energy RS-II regime and five-dimensional timing condition apply only where stated. Formal spectral results do not establish viable models throughout the action class, whose detailed viability analysis was deferred.","evidenceIds":["unit:191b042c99b96a6bbf9054bb55f0a26fd22f39ecb72902e415b194c805d36959","unit:1acdbfde4891df21db56ffa8b5f06998c7c2cf160530a25da77bbacd7c1016ce","unit:1fcb591c2eef1d7f1736d14cfd5f0657c10cf46ddb378fc5fd9e59d1109495f2","unit:28cc3b8fbc59cb74cee255fb796373ce619cff34da0cf31634c5e2d8732b8aa0","unit:2939a8644a63e3c44f12aca0efabf5babb598c81c4d90ee2c48918ca4a71ac59","unit:2e46f342191428362890475544c3bfb014a440990ae55327200e11b98631dad1","unit:30cc0165a22fdd9483f6c9b4b8fe3d019e234f8d373789e3b4de2a4dfc6911ca","unit:54e335d22569ea97eba39637ae2eb02f5805c059729ee05cbec99b44d17b744c","unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","unit:7405da195cb830f27b2cd597163f8f4435a5030c41d088896b6f666b1bb2db6a","unit:7fc63d593a1ddf8f4d36b4d95728b6cb8e74ba5c6ec0008e83d3ab0bf04491ac","unit:a047023f1e4ae2871f8cc9fdc638119ba95397b6f00adecf3784def521bd9b37","unit:bcfcaf244290b4b08138848e28a1d9de7d4f1d97b97f8697e05e01ec37defda6","unit:bed792616c1d639d395b11b23c540ebfb15789613a361cb814a5ae83711f55e5","unit:c2b5e41e943b0473e5089ba598ef130ffb2472b981725ca11a500e88860850ee","unit:d7be6dedc1f0ebe9db505a6d2a0e52bfc67bda19fb0d810974550e35b53ed7bb","unit:fe379acef869280e8dd5e98899501ac6ec3e3dd42cdeaeba4cf123c6630e5147"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75746c8b2d2dcf6ced543642","scopeContentSha256":"b80dcf480f0360dde81312655892bc28856fcf3df5375fa207d163d103bf1431","localRef":"s16"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","scopeContentSha256":"29f9bef9407be52a4a73021a58c1ea2b135a172ca9f15f97d64890e6b981f802","localRef":"s25"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l32","originalCandidateId":"parent-570548e969849fcc2e72-challenge:link:30","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l32","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-570548e969849fcc2e72-challenge:link:30","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:75746c8b2d2dcf6ced543642","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l32","source":"s25","target":"s16","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["The p(X,ϕ) formalism supplies a noncanonical linear-perturbation route to spectra, without establishing viable models throughout the action class."],"challengeStatement":"The p(X,ϕ) component supplies a noncanonical linear-perturbation method; it does not establish viable models throughout that action class.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-570548e969849fcc2e72-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-570548e969849fcc2e72-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ded5cd6de65e75c3b2463fe13b4b2436760b09d704ceff51e51dda121417d642","reply.jsonSha256":"1c8e9448d8c95301047b288b1a3d53302fa3e5dc16b75863711134af351e7f17","reply.raw.txtSha256":"928e2d10d1388fa0eb94e912e576823860e093e90fc7f5580293ed5e8a5eede5","receipt.jsonSha256":"cc7d683d00c136d06bb933f481e0b7158b8a734d63f37d245883b225e79a2518","normalization.jsonSha256":"2ed8974e75a637e4fbca951eeef89b841d38da425d2f386dce1b2ccd978577aa","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-570548e969849fcc2e72-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"27b55370113a49d8f04856791f8135883628d88120ad5d01dcda0026e8fa7a41"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-570548e969849fcc2e72-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"eef32772a9fa9b5a9ba74ea67900b06507200e2df8d4fdcc9ad37bf4d5444dab","reply.jsonSha256":"9947800e439a13c0b88102f008997317aa69329a2ad59fecf7a50a5f3c001153","reply.raw.txtSha256":"5830d92947201c61dd1b40c4b439ed74eada2b25ade1fdf32dbaa1bee9b04474","receipt.jsonSha256":"8fb694660f8c5dbccdebe6275ec3a73f9577a6fe03dc2e31ab8079040878154b","normalization.jsonSha256":"6ef769d5a1687300dc703ec45f58d9313dcc60453adba4bdbe9aa5d34bd6a473"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75746c8b2d2dcf6ced543642"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9904176","sourceId":"ev:b0a20784413103e79361a0120185b753","sourceSha256":"1d384cf08164304e0fff63398e1df55962bd71eff5863a7bb93a850abe87972f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/77d6ddf40c6cd8d61497/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"97c8ad4dd213d73a8fce25763ac815a5feaf5e5a8f42e7823ee7c0b224ffc653","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1627,"textSha256":"01aa82ff27490224e2e8a6b2e1b10447e833da82386c5524e42d605a505413d2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9904176","sourceId":"ev:eec27401bf94e07b5e7fde1ef30471a8","sourceSha256":"1d384cf08164304e0fff63398e1df55962bd71eff5863a7bb93a850abe87972f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/77d6ddf40c6cd8d61497/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"97c8ad4dd213d73a8fce25763ac815a5feaf5e5a8f42e7823ee7c0b224ffc653","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1979,"textSha256":"1b998600efa022a2c881e1a1d325392c78f87eb59d4400a7670527883e1d29c3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75746c8b2d2dcf6ced543642"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9904176","sourceId":"ev:b0a20784413103e79361a0120185b753","sourceSha256":"1d384cf08164304e0fff63398e1df55962bd71eff5863a7bb93a850abe87972f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/77d6ddf40c6cd8d61497/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"97c8ad4dd213d73a8fce25763ac815a5feaf5e5a8f42e7823ee7c0b224ffc653","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1627,"textSha256":"01aa82ff27490224e2e8a6b2e1b10447e833da82386c5524e42d605a505413d2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9904176","sourceId":"ev:eec27401bf94e07b5e7fde1ef30471a8","sourceSha256":"1d384cf08164304e0fff63398e1df55962bd71eff5863a7bb93a850abe87972f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/77d6ddf40c6cd8d61497/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"97c8ad4dd213d73a8fce25763ac815a5feaf5e5a8f42e7823ee7c0b224ffc653","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1979,"textSha256":"1b998600efa022a2c881e1a1d325392c78f87eb59d4400a7670527883e1d29c3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d32","originalRef":"l32","status":"route","source":"s16","target":"s25","type":"method_for","title":"Use the noncanonical p(X,ϕ) perturbation method for spectra","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the p(X,ϕ) component of s16 supplies the noncanonical linear-perturbation method relevant to spectral questions in s25.","qualification":"This method claim does not cover every mechanism grouped in s16. D-cceleration, NEC-violating evolution and stochastic vacuum transitions retain their separate dynamics. Definitions of X, gravitational normalization and slow-roll or power-law assumptions remain local; the high-energy RS-II regime and five-dimensional timing condition apply only where stated. Formal spectral results do not establish viable models throughout the action class, whose detailed viability analysis was deferred.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l32","s16","s25"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d32","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify the p(X,ϕ) component as the provider of a noncanonical linear-perturbation method. Reversing to s16 → s25 is correct. The record limits the claim to that component, retains dimensional, timing and normalization restrictions where applicable, and preserves the deferred viability analysis.","refs":["l32","s16","s25"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l32","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l33":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l33","source":"q025-candidate-question:e7dd9e64e880a68126257008","target":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","type":"application_of","title":"Trace PBH and induced-wave calculations to enhanced scalar spectra","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the PBH and scalar-induced-wave questions apply small-scale scalar spectral enhancement, with additional evolution and conversion assumptions.","qualification":"Collapse prescriptions, transfer, reheating, CMB compatibility and perturbative control remain source-specific. Curvature-spectrum amplitudes and comoving-density thresholds are not interchangeable. PBHs may evaporate or contribute negligibly to dark matter, and induced waves need not imply significant PBH abundance. Unspecified accompanying gravitational waves are not automatically scalar induced; no universal detector band, enhancement mechanism or verified full calculation follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:191b042c99b96a6bbf9054bb55f0a26fd22f39ecb72902e415b194c805d36959","unit:1acdbfde4891df21db56ffa8b5f06998c7c2cf160530a25da77bbacd7c1016ce","unit:1aed58314726b84e63fa0058407422998d5a73bc17d90031f582569a13f36411","unit:1fcb591c2eef1d7f1736d14cfd5f0657c10cf46ddb378fc5fd9e59d1109495f2","unit:23964566bb258c436c0345486363dc129f18d8ac382857ae13fd8dee994c5df9","unit:261a92e1df02c7cc99e264738b2c7fd2c6b1704405550c42045a50609b0f0156","unit:28cc3b8fbc59cb74cee255fb796373ce619cff34da0cf31634c5e2d8732b8aa0","unit:2ab023fb30a63119a84492b5e7c49045cebe6bd46e9cb48cc6286d55fd9e2e9b","unit:2fb3b12439a334e616e991b9c2be223a2ee7e671b70169eeb4f69a236b75b718","unit:3384a059406ed760dd77ca728dfcfcc8226327266ab2fba6d9068069280784e4","unit:3b4ec584beef941e92065c2edaa04e591362d324af2be8f75ff3775fc039ebd4","unit:3bd8af20e9fe87f2b5a445c89c3b5aa103d352ff6ec4365d72a6b9b7dca4dad3","unit:3eb779f96fa07d4cd90b9631fe7ee3f457c32883f5d8117278e7169e2d57a2bc","unit:47c9564364ff366c2dfa6e62f90ea0a21d411bfe3cc46b9fad1df2d74b2d1ff2","unit:4ea3981c7bacabc42813050df040b7a5dcd8c3f239caba4343b39cd2452bde9e","unit:502fc45082f82c3d563f0d728e1ada2c08813deac7431e3d0bc69584b91ae16c","unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","unit:64c98773d717f2e88cddd26b5743c529364070443efccfd1f56d070c56467325","unit:7405da195cb830f27b2cd597163f8f4435a5030c41d088896b6f666b1bb2db6a","unit:7bd97f8552fd7c5dd4a6c7e04b75afa4b1207bb1d136ebfc197956445d0b8d6e","unit:870b499a9aad654a12b3ebaca34503bb3a1391408150aa7c4fab85b77aeaa0f9","unit:91ed937b042373efa71eb52c1a7a28fe00b6a7ca81db2d5281d6917b798c970f","unit:bed792616c1d639d395b11b23c540ebfb15789613a361cb814a5ae83711f55e5","unit:c2b5e41e943b0473e5089ba598ef130ffb2472b981725ca11a500e88860850ee","unit:c2fdecc4b4a25b1c986f023c778faae1e1204c07f90890c472a01c3e60800871","unit:cc618aba580eee4ae1874a1ae92baec21bc7d171a5d58f034e41eb71e4735779","unit:cf723505f653c86b3b6a942976202d35855372bf3163e8191f826159f4292e15","unit:d32dd008203d5b5364e019acad308d80d3c98ebde94864569dc8ca9871b99813","unit:d7be6dedc1f0ebe9db505a6d2a0e52bfc67bda19fb0d810974550e35b53ed7bb","unit:fe379acef869280e8dd5e98899501ac6ec3e3dd42cdeaeba4cf123c6630e5147","unit:ff94d1acd48ad3f2ea9ae25e67a77b9ef2af77a094be18bb94c8d0d5832ba6cb"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e7dd9e64e880a68126257008","scopeContentSha256":"4d9c19d0b285c63220bfd0bc6acd5feddb5aaa5403f32db7fa0d7907f952a477","localRef":"s33"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","scopeContentSha256":"29f9bef9407be52a4a73021a58c1ea2b135a172ca9f15f97d64890e6b981f802","localRef":"s25"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l33","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge:link:26","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l33","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge:link:26","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:e7dd9e64e880a68126257008","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l33","source":"s25","target":"s33","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Small-scale scalar enhancement connects spectra to PBH and induced-wave calculations, with additional collapse, transfer and control assumptions."],"challengeStatement":"Small-scale scalar enhancement connects spectra to PBH and induced-wave calculations under additional collapse, transfer and control assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"95b1c7ba751c3f0831666906655a0772176b892862235639ba1b9f54177c0fe0","reply.jsonSha256":"2e948e54b460d4b78bd71e446414fb0734f34ec4e97be5eb0e4df090e615020e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"05a9a6b1249fce2e08510b7210c348274ab6822ab09918c64eda2a48a3cc30ae","receipt.jsonSha256":"50b7a181fc889d648a958ce20d90f3bf63e9351bac28605053ee83284da96d71","normalization.jsonSha256":"4538227034e50489c356d26e199de14d19afbe9d7c067bd7af5966066d994d3c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8bb74bad7dd366b41cb748c2d9278ae4184272afe37dc42ea085bed7dcb576d9"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"e259dbe129fef2f9d0be22648b8d6689b863f0acbb87ac00124a1011e9a73600","reply.jsonSha256":"08d00dca4e0be0dc1f1d71e1671f981ef07dd6078404652a39279d6ea35d1b25","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b0cb06db5235be5edcd5239e9867cbb3cf4eaa54bc95dcfd1b6d46130f595856","receipt.jsonSha256":"92c8bdf185ba9b933381dece64798713f76f0bfe64151241faee9b7b222a9e7a","normalization.jsonSha256":"0ef5d823adf0a25e589964d662378d8e7b623e16dece9d8146aed46a759851e4"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf"},{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e7dd9e64e880a68126257008"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2105.08045","sourceId":"ev:63553f3cec0501b4387f21f44c5a93fd","sourceSha256":"0fa7f3acb98befca7e61e4fa9f98989dc1da38087f41836e3af89cbc934c6c69","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/daaaae9de3f44f71b6df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"165859b3229ca80eb6329055d95d18287dcdfc7158f84bf37179a68e6dd9924f","pdfPage":2,"start":2497,"end":5885,"textSha256":"b9fa227854308e3f7a46e83c5cd9a6481bf8c511edd080731771be4e216578d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2105.08045","sourceId":"ev:690f0a5ac70fc02101cc36589367770b","sourceSha256":"0fa7f3acb98befca7e61e4fa9f98989dc1da38087f41836e3af89cbc934c6c69","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/daaaae9de3f44f71b6df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"165859b3229ca80eb6329055d95d18287dcdfc7158f84bf37179a68e6dd9924f","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b87fa0fdc7bd7e966a22c642ad4b125756932f94628d72f38ee62f81e9355be3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e14","kind":"primary","paperId":"2105.08045","sourceId":"ev:988923559651f6baba865f6926c2fee2","sourceSha256":"0fa7f3acb98befca7e61e4fa9f98989dc1da38087f41836e3af89cbc934c6c69","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/daaaae9de3f44f71b6df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"165859b3229ca80eb6329055d95d18287dcdfc7158f84bf37179a68e6dd9924f","pdfPage":2,"start":1297,"end":4696,"textSha256":"560abaedd227165b2f217daa888ab54db20087e1b1c888d34deea5417f80706a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c27fcd24bcfc71276b396ddf"},{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e7dd9e64e880a68126257008"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2105.08045","sourceId":"ev:63553f3cec0501b4387f21f44c5a93fd","sourceSha256":"0fa7f3acb98befca7e61e4fa9f98989dc1da38087f41836e3af89cbc934c6c69","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/daaaae9de3f44f71b6df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"165859b3229ca80eb6329055d95d18287dcdfc7158f84bf37179a68e6dd9924f","pdfPage":2,"start":2497,"end":5885,"textSha256":"b9fa227854308e3f7a46e83c5cd9a6481bf8c511edd080731771be4e216578d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2105.08045","sourceId":"ev:690f0a5ac70fc02101cc36589367770b","sourceSha256":"0fa7f3acb98befca7e61e4fa9f98989dc1da38087f41836e3af89cbc934c6c69","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/daaaae9de3f44f71b6df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"165859b3229ca80eb6329055d95d18287dcdfc7158f84bf37179a68e6dd9924f","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b87fa0fdc7bd7e966a22c642ad4b125756932f94628d72f38ee62f81e9355be3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e14","kind":"primary","paperId":"2105.08045","sourceId":"ev:988923559651f6baba865f6926c2fee2","sourceSha256":"0fa7f3acb98befca7e61e4fa9f98989dc1da38087f41836e3af89cbc934c6c69","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/daaaae9de3f44f71b6df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"165859b3229ca80eb6329055d95d18287dcdfc7158f84bf37179a68e6dd9924f","pdfPage":2,"start":1297,"end":4696,"textSha256":"560abaedd227165b2f217daa888ab54db20087e1b1c888d34deea5417f80706a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d33","originalRef":"l33","status":"route","source":"s33","target":"s25","type":"application_of","title":"Trace PBH and induced-wave calculations to enhanced scalar spectra","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the PBH and scalar-induced-wave questions apply small-scale scalar spectral enhancement, with additional evolution and conversion assumptions.","qualification":"Collapse prescriptions, transfer, reheating, CMB compatibility and perturbative control remain source-specific. Curvature-spectrum amplitudes and comoving-density thresholds are not interchangeable. PBHs may evaporate or contribute negligibly to dark matter, and induced waves need not imply significant PBH abundance. Unspecified accompanying gravitational waves are not automatically scalar induced; no universal detector band, enhancement mechanism or verified full calculation follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l33","s33","s25"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d33","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"PBH and scalar-induced-wave calculations apply enhanced scalar spectra with additional conversion and evolution assumptions, supporting the reversed application direction. Both original statements' collapse, transfer and control conditions remain explicit. The record also preserves distinctions among spectral amplitudes, collapse thresholds, PBH abundance and induced-wave signals.","refs":["l33","s33","s25"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l33","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l0":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l0","source":"q025-candidate-question:f8d258f07eb369740028cc21","target":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6","type":"premise_check","title":"Check gravity and symmetry premises for strong-CP mechanisms","rationale":"Assessing the strong-CP branches of the mechanism question requires separating the proposed mechanism from the gravitational and symmetry assumptions examined by s2.","qualification":"This check concerns the relevant strong-CP branches, not every mass-generation or particle-protection mechanism in s32. Swampland conjectures, quantum-breaking criteria and S-matrix arguments remain distinct conditional inputs. Classical, quantum-global and gauged symmetries are not interchangeable; the arguments establish neither universal axion necessity nor universal exclusion.","evidenceIds":["unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","unit:0c32a33c54d31bc5530aee8eb956fc37f460d8bfe2d5570552faa29d151155c8","unit:2b9bd653ee80a4ba6755d1cacdb8bd32e625582b901b749d2a8ee7c115e77509","unit:372f54cace2ff4ce8198d8b55c0d7dc2441629cd1714bb4dcaec5028624122eb","unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","unit:636d56a46a9214cf59b74cfc18dbe11f2ee6cc510f2a5d79dc93fb7875bd74c3","unit:71d64413f10c18cf972d71f6ce6fe855c61223bbe038ef70d63b20518cea4d97","unit:76fbc5b1a35c809447199df440c40190ff72a283cee5373ef1e54d91ce35f752","unit:7a9067987f591b758333e29f3578f5edb9474721df7bbd5aff8d5c9629ed42f6","unit:a63a27f10d1c0057c1f5fd3b1f62a372aab840c4c1c33921b7d2b7a0999bc991","unit:d6d2e3fd884cff4e3e7eb2ed4ff4184cd4eda8eca0f818108f3b8eaefdc4f4ee","unit:e580623e54876298225afd9606c98bbe29e807ba983dc3a4cae75fdaa6b080f4","unit:f00a69f9ef815fc6e32f3f9a2cf5d1634881d29c86f21ff199d7b5d8d7fa515b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f8d258f07eb369740028cc21","scopeContentSha256":"04e2ded301de21ca5e72c183774e8b785fd2ca8c7e4df396a0fbbb6d06499b4a","localRef":"s32"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6","scopeContentSha256":"8140eeba742a126675ea43950f86bf36c7bb7fbcedb76ed2b13e72bd710b5e85","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l0","originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:48","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l0","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:48","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:f8d258f07eb369740028cc21","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l0","source":"s32","target":"s2","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["Keep gravity and symmetry premises explicit when assessing strong-CP mechanisms."],"challengeStatement":"Gravity and symmetry premises must be assessed separately from a proposed strong-CP mechanism.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"0d479554dd0b39ca9daf07157c4f39675210457752a02cafa57ef8e2f52bfa7e","reply.jsonSha256":"b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd4722ba8dda705c880ad49294161d9061295ac5c5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9f3caf81e788c84ac0164350156eee9d2eb362baacf7ad9f05eaf093273877e8","receipt.jsonSha256":"1165f285c2c643f1a2270fabeb515a22bfcd8476412d71364f6c4b7cc0b1b52b","normalization.jsonSha256":"65d79380e46d8c2f1a63efb46f5d49883594612e5b03d1e4c4c4cbcabbee2346","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4a44ea5475d2801e35e1e86aad6ff99d9db2dce8307fdc2c9041f7beb32dd37a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"876fcf82b3760877d5adf0ad3cea3352e0f0e96e9be01cbf7c7325a0609e4a55","reply.jsonSha256":"a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d2e1d06273788a3258264e645c16dcacdaa3f68ac","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d04dfd346aec28f9d51f6dd453759d3040c159c9b9041a0287eecdb7310d96d9","receipt.jsonSha256":"a1fa78d73a75fe703fb1cbeac5b35a16ddc235795219891d7e028e0e8f09c26b","normalization.jsonSha256":"2e493e2c7f4741d29428ad8769d68daf9d37a86a64b17eea548d298edea89613"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2209.14219","sourceId":"ev:11014a27e05f2fe9ecf45074c34f9bbc","sourceSha256":"a13831f3df2f5c0729e748c4b6ffc3121a360bf0e34d04658a0fe1ca4607d3a8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca2c5708f32ba00d2977/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fbf50a01af6aa90632004bc747b5d2df3e20e45ced5e7fc3809251084f6ab1ca","pdfPage":1,"start":2496,"end":5338,"textSha256":"83cb06712a3c3179734d2c9010821dff425500a3c2e8721fe05498256498fb93","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2209.14219","sourceId":"ev:11014a27e05f2fe9ecf45074c34f9bbc","sourceSha256":"a13831f3df2f5c0729e748c4b6ffc3121a360bf0e34d04658a0fe1ca4607d3a8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca2c5708f32ba00d2977/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fbf50a01af6aa90632004bc747b5d2df3e20e45ced5e7fc3809251084f6ab1ca","pdfPage":1,"start":2496,"end":5338,"textSha256":"83cb06712a3c3179734d2c9010821dff425500a3c2e8721fe05498256498fb93","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2209.14219","sourceId":"ev:34362d7778fa135d0c9e07d388d2e9dc","sourceSha256":"a13831f3df2f5c0729e748c4b6ffc3121a360bf0e34d04658a0fe1ca4607d3a8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ca2c5708f32ba00d2977/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fbf50a01af6aa90632004bc747b5d2df3e20e45ced5e7fc3809251084f6ab1ca","pdfPage":1,"start":3694,"end":5338,"textSha256":"32531b2bf0946b47778fff5dfd653e017ced0d126f03ac6266dbbff6e57d03e3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d0","originalRef":"l0","status":"route","source":"s32","target":"s2","type":"premise_check","title":"Check gravity and symmetry premises for strong-CP mechanisms","rationale":"Assessing the strong-CP branches of the mechanism question requires separating the proposed mechanism from the gravitational and symmetry assumptions examined by s2.","qualification":"This check concerns the relevant strong-CP branches, not every mass-generation or particle-protection mechanism in s32. Swampland conjectures, quantum-breaking criteria and S-matrix arguments remain distinct conditional inputs. Classical, quantum-global and gauged symmetries are not interchangeable; the arguments establish neither universal axion necessity nor universal exclusion.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l0","s32","s2"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The direction correctly leads from assessing strong-CP mechanisms to their gravitational and symmetry premises. The qualification confines the check to relevant branches of s32 and preserves the distinct conjectural inputs and symmetry categories without imposing them on every mass-generation mechanism.","refs":["l0","s32","s2"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l1":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l1","source":"q025-candidate-question:f8d258f07eb369740028cc21","target":"q025-candidate-question:8bfa3dd8ec9de6c479eeaef8","type":"premise_check","title":"Check conditional gravity restrictions on neutrino models","rationale":"The neutrino-model branches of s32 can be assessed against the explicitly conditional compactification and species-scale restrictions examined by s17.","qualification":"These restrictions are not universal requirements for generating neutrino masses or choosing Dirac neutrinos. Retain the particular conjecture, spectrum, compactification twists, scanning prescription, stability requirement and scale ordering. Stable-AdS arguments, local radion criteria and species-scale arguments cannot be substituted for one another. The precise AdS conjecture variant remains unidentified in the supplied 2017 scope.","evidenceIds":["unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","unit:15e4215875451157da5dfff97ef968a2f251ca5394be5e5b4c0113d430b9c181","unit:54bbb7c5cb752fb920c2824f5b130113204fd0c540b727db94bf138fd8a5f473","unit:5675ab6ef2717e591448cbec2c36f441fc19c1a5e614e80d6110bc2c991f3312","unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","unit:6b0a0be1aa395456af7d43600e607c6e1b1746a7e313a80fe2d4bcd6f0d378b2","unit:98b54f188aa29805646604d76e58c1c847bfc71e69163ea71f7f56f733ce483a","unit:b38361f64f21663f35f3f15dcab23d73b28382f1c2061578878f2a2dc5d58347","unit:bc6829cda98048ed97e975b91826c04bb993229ab98a7732711d3e0afcffab1f","unit:d17aca3e623b4e7ab0ceb4be3bfc4ad08abaf57b675caa288c841cd4f8b63963"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f8d258f07eb369740028cc21","scopeContentSha256":"04e2ded301de21ca5e72c183774e8b785fd2ca8c7e4df396a0fbbb6d06499b4a","localRef":"s32"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8bfa3dd8ec9de6c479eeaef8","scopeContentSha256":"4a24be59ea305ada723881431f72d706a79aef565e3d1dbef69de4f84f0bef32","localRef":"s17"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l1","originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:49","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l1","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:49","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:f8d258f07eb369740028cc21","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:8bfa3dd8ec9de6c479eeaef8","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l1","source":"s32","target":"s17","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["Neutrino restrictions from compactification or species criteria are conditional branches, not mass-generation requirements."],"challengeStatement":"Conditional neutrino restrictions are not universal requirements for mass generation.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"0d479554dd0b39ca9daf07157c4f39675210457752a02cafa57ef8e2f52bfa7e","reply.jsonSha256":"b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd4722ba8dda705c880ad49294161d9061295ac5c5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9f3caf81e788c84ac0164350156eee9d2eb362baacf7ad9f05eaf093273877e8","receipt.jsonSha256":"1165f285c2c643f1a2270fabeb515a22bfcd8476412d71364f6c4b7cc0b1b52b","normalization.jsonSha256":"65d79380e46d8c2f1a63efb46f5d49883594612e5b03d1e4c4c4cbcabbee2346","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4a44ea5475d2801e35e1e86aad6ff99d9db2dce8307fdc2c9041f7beb32dd37a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"876fcf82b3760877d5adf0ad3cea3352e0f0e96e9be01cbf7c7325a0609e4a55","reply.jsonSha256":"a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d2e1d06273788a3258264e645c16dcacdaa3f68ac","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d04dfd346aec28f9d51f6dd453759d3040c159c9b9041a0287eecdb7310d96d9","receipt.jsonSha256":"a1fa78d73a75fe703fb1cbeac5b35a16ddc235795219891d7e028e0e8f09c26b","normalization.jsonSha256":"2e493e2c7f4741d29428ad8769d68daf9d37a86a64b17eea548d298edea89613"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_10","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8bfa3dd8ec9de6c479eeaef8"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_10","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8bfa3dd8ec9de6c479eeaef8"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d1","originalRef":"l1","status":"route","source":"s32","target":"s17","type":"premise_check","title":"Check conditional gravity restrictions on neutrino models","rationale":"The neutrino-model branches of s32 can be assessed against the explicitly conditional compactification and species-scale restrictions examined by s17.","qualification":"These restrictions are not universal requirements for generating neutrino masses or choosing Dirac neutrinos. Retain the particular conjecture, spectrum, compactification twists, scanning prescription, stability requirement and scale ordering. Stable-AdS arguments, local radion criteria and species-scale arguments cannot be substituted for one another. The precise AdS conjecture variant remains unidentified in the supplied 2017 scope.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l1","s32","s17"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The conditional neutrino-consistency branch supports this premise check. The record expressly avoids making these restrictions requirements for mass generation or Dirac neutrinos, preserves the different compactification and species criteria, and leaves the unidentified 2017 AdS conjecture variant unresolved.","refs":["l1","s32","s17"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l2":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l2","source":"q025-candidate-region:277d9b2e77af3c3b06134952","target":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6","type":"premise_check","title":"Examine gravitational premises for axion and non-axion protection","rationale":"The construction and consistency region contains conditional assessments of strong-CP mechanisms whose gravitational and symmetry premises are the subject of s2.","qualification":"Apply this check only where a mechanism invokes the relevant gravity or symmetry argument. Distinct premises can challenge, protect or motivate different mechanisms without implying a common conclusion. Preserve the distinction between global and gauged symmetries and between conjectural exclusions, S-matrix arguments and possible Planck-scale violation. No universal axion necessity, exclusion or certified ultraviolet completion follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","unit:0c32a33c54d31bc5530aee8eb956fc37f460d8bfe2d5570552faa29d151155c8","unit:149e90493e80fa8000cf5af82dde1b4b6b539f73f2f390d10733aa2cdb0d0b89","unit:2b9bd653ee80a4ba6755d1cacdb8bd32e625582b901b749d2a8ee7c115e77509","unit:372f54cace2ff4ce8198d8b55c0d7dc2441629cd1714bb4dcaec5028624122eb","unit:636d56a46a9214cf59b74cfc18dbe11f2ee6cc510f2a5d79dc93fb7875bd74c3","unit:69ab822f9ef72c6e77724c7e855a82a64f800d947b2c9bd535fa649d760447bc","unit:71d64413f10c18cf972d71f6ce6fe855c61223bbe038ef70d63b20518cea4d97","unit:76fbc5b1a35c809447199df440c40190ff72a283cee5373ef1e54d91ce35f752","unit:7a9067987f591b758333e29f3578f5edb9474721df7bbd5aff8d5c9629ed42f6","unit:a63a27f10d1c0057c1f5fd3b1f62a372aab840c4c1c33921b7d2b7a0999bc991","unit:d6d2e3fd884cff4e3e7eb2ed4ff4184cd4eda8eca0f818108f3b8eaefdc4f4ee","unit:d919c5dd993905449cecd1112381c4c78ab564d7f8b6a25c0ed3ed082e2e537e","unit:e580623e54876298225afd9606c98bbe29e807ba983dc3a4cae75fdaa6b080f4","unit:f00a69f9ef815fc6e32f3f9a2cf5d1634881d29c86f21ff199d7b5d8d7fa515b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:277d9b2e77af3c3b06134952","scopeContentSha256":"7734d59030556adba6007612e4ad7e852c30cf220ff043dd355dc4753138f07a","localRef":"s36"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6","scopeContentSha256":"8140eeba742a126675ea43950f86bf36c7bb7fbcedb76ed2b13e72bd710b5e85","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l2","originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:13","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l2","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:13","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:277d9b2e77af3c3b06134952","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l2","source":"s36","target":"s2","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["Compare the distinct gravitational and symmetry premises used to challenge, protect or motivate mechanisms."],"challengeStatement":"Compare distinct gravitational and symmetry premises without endorsing a universal axion necessity or exclusion.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8837533292ba2dc050c09c0f4b04af5d04bacdf1ab973652f26afeac5ab375e1","reply.jsonSha256":"c4da9c37362a39ccb4319f60c4983a440a50a7fded2dbcd384cf07779ef43ba4","reply.raw.txtSha256":"579facbd28ff0cfc08d1f878e55b88a06ebb4422a57589f5577d498e574a43d7","receipt.jsonSha256":"3aa4184cf3ab982b9de218ea326aa5015b854135a6d0a36f719e7fc5d64ffe1a","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7fcdf1f23896f5ae47612e73b6d7804e5ec8667ff11aa2c9d1390d566971293","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"16ccc8f6866b12f72f1cc5bdec200a43d888fd66bdaca563ec623b1b61f881f6"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"172478274c8c6cefae0e46d485d373db74d6ed2e6d67121d0fe60c3553fe8561","reply.jsonSha256":"e4a601e983ad12fb24ac06650339f91a7cb408d1ad0059709c0a71399daf1643","reply.raw.txtSha256":"633b874344705a2d8539b45abb792739f8caf36c5fe116ee81cf82c41bb84161","receipt.jsonSha256":"66ce2c23b3c076188e34e5a95afec015e72e192e7a489859d2d316c4fa3f930c","normalization.jsonSha256":"89c6ce8e7cd2a821fb72347a5e003a2ab62093e88672faf6fa2d440db3279915"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1809.00478","sourceId":"ev:32bc2ac3ab52b6f04f9484447b642c64","sourceSha256":"152485636b3962de198d8a45eac5e3ae536251b7fb1b038719a7c381ea14d930","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/761f1e9be3f30749ca64/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cb3e5c536ff8ad2399c4e1e4461ccc2700480205715388b6a7c11bf81cfcd90b","pdfPage":16,"start":0,"end":2380,"textSha256":"eb39d4a9db8712394ebb10d3e137230cc1f1b0b644f5020cc0a40cc5acb049d7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"1809.00478","sourceId":"ev:8f0803cac871821a02b71b3e6148b7d1","sourceSha256":"152485636b3962de198d8a45eac5e3ae536251b7fb1b038719a7c381ea14d930","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/761f1e9be3f30749ca64/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cb3e5c536ff8ad2399c4e1e4461ccc2700480205715388b6a7c11bf81cfcd90b","pdfPage":15,"start":0,"end":2057,"textSha256":"481bb7a2be7db632941822854c9dd9a1beab578ddfa315c3546c584e3cc9bdeb","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6"},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1809.00478","sourceId":"ev:32bc2ac3ab52b6f04f9484447b642c64","sourceSha256":"152485636b3962de198d8a45eac5e3ae536251b7fb1b038719a7c381ea14d930","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/761f1e9be3f30749ca64/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cb3e5c536ff8ad2399c4e1e4461ccc2700480205715388b6a7c11bf81cfcd90b","pdfPage":16,"start":0,"end":2380,"textSha256":"eb39d4a9db8712394ebb10d3e137230cc1f1b0b644f5020cc0a40cc5acb049d7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"1809.00478","sourceId":"ev:8f0803cac871821a02b71b3e6148b7d1","sourceSha256":"152485636b3962de198d8a45eac5e3ae536251b7fb1b038719a7c381ea14d930","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/761f1e9be3f30749ca64/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cb3e5c536ff8ad2399c4e1e4461ccc2700480205715388b6a7c11bf81cfcd90b","pdfPage":15,"start":0,"end":2057,"textSha256":"481bb7a2be7db632941822854c9dd9a1beab578ddfa315c3546c584e3cc9bdeb","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d2","originalRef":"l2","status":"route","source":"s36","target":"s2","type":"premise_check","title":"Examine gravitational premises for axion and non-axion protection","rationale":"The construction and consistency region contains conditional assessments of strong-CP mechanisms whose gravitational and symmetry premises are the subject of s2.","qualification":"Apply this check only where a mechanism invokes the relevant gravity or symmetry argument. Distinct premises can challenge, protect or motivate different mechanisms without implying a common conclusion. Preserve the distinction between global and gauged symmetries and between conjectural exclusions, S-matrix arguments and possible Planck-scale violation. No universal axion necessity, exclusion or certified ultraviolet completion follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l2","s36","s2"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The source region includes mechanisms assessed under gravitational and symmetry assumptions, making s2 a relevant premise destination. The qualification preserves both original statements' distinction among arguments that challenge, protect or motivate mechanisms without asserting universal axion necessity or exclusion.","refs":["l2","s36","s2"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l3":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l3","source":"q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a","target":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6","type":"method_for","title":"Use gauge formulations to assess strong-CP protection premises","rationale":"The gauge-form formulations and source-specific consistency arguments in s13 supply the methods identified by both statements for examining protection and surviving degrees of freedom. The original arrow therefore reverses.","qualification":"Applicability is limited to the shared protection and consistency questions under the stated S-matrix, spectrum, species-scale or perturbative assumptions. Different form degrees do not establish equivalent mechanisms. A consumed axion with residual particle-number symmetry remains a boundary case. Gauge redundancy alone does not verify all-orders protection, and these methods do not establish that gravity universally requires a QCD axion.","evidenceIds":["unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","unit:0c32a33c54d31bc5530aee8eb956fc37f460d8bfe2d5570552faa29d151155c8","unit:16ec78f3c53eff2e8dd86bcdb932c832baa1ab164c91cc80955eb34726a13944","unit:175bba135d91ae044124d00bca478428a124e354d3b61b189acf75b7aef67d9d","unit:1af723a445ba5267b932adc258ee7e0c648947a7a3733a7113388cf7a48832f3","unit:2b9bd653ee80a4ba6755d1cacdb8bd32e625582b901b749d2a8ee7c115e77509","unit:372f54cace2ff4ce8198d8b55c0d7dc2441629cd1714bb4dcaec5028624122eb","unit:636d56a46a9214cf59b74cfc18dbe11f2ee6cc510f2a5d79dc93fb7875bd74c3","unit:71d64413f10c18cf972d71f6ce6fe855c61223bbe038ef70d63b20518cea4d97","unit:76fbc5b1a35c809447199df440c40190ff72a283cee5373ef1e54d91ce35f752","unit:7a9067987f591b758333e29f3578f5edb9474721df7bbd5aff8d5c9629ed42f6","unit:a63a27f10d1c0057c1f5fd3b1f62a372aab840c4c1c33921b7d2b7a0999bc991","unit:bb06bf32b17553f51af8a6c601b0b5d198509d67714c0ec97f2cf3a606d94d3d","unit:d6d2e3fd884cff4e3e7eb2ed4ff4184cd4eda8eca0f818108f3b8eaefdc4f4ee","unit:e0f28c9bb934d104f33d502364a4c73832c2bafc9ef0e09003d619fed1cafc41","unit:e580623e54876298225afd9606c98bbe29e807ba983dc3a4cae75fdaa6b080f4","unit:f00a69f9ef815fc6e32f3f9a2cf5d1634881d29c86f21ff199d7b5d8d7fa515b","unit:f56cfcf6c354d9050c6493c335df7a80e68c884598cac5ba3171516d7ee1df69","unit:ff5e35da5142d1259b2427910e159252fe25dff3029fd88e4f5a0b0f25d7a0c7"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a","scopeContentSha256":"1f0300ebb75ae20a042a7a13d20c0a0f3543b50bf6a7f0985811c6bc71256bdd","localRef":"s13"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6","scopeContentSha256":"8140eeba742a126675ea43950f86bf36c7bb7fbcedb76ed2b13e72bd710b5e85","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l3","originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:38","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l3","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge:link:38","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l3","source":"s2","target":"s13","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Gauge-form formulations and source-specific consistency arguments offer distinct methods for assessing protection and surviving degrees of freedom."],"challengeStatement":"Gauge-form formulations and specific consistency arguments offer methods for examining protection and surviving degrees of freedom.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"8837533292ba2dc050c09c0f4b04af5d04bacdf1ab973652f26afeac5ab375e1","reply.jsonSha256":"c4da9c37362a39ccb4319f60c4983a440a50a7fded2dbcd384cf07779ef43ba4","reply.raw.txtSha256":"579facbd28ff0cfc08d1f878e55b88a06ebb4422a57589f5577d498e574a43d7","receipt.jsonSha256":"3aa4184cf3ab982b9de218ea326aa5015b854135a6d0a36f719e7fc5d64ffe1a","normalization.jsonSha256":"f7fcdf1f23896f5ae47612e73b6d7804e5ec8667ff11aa2c9d1390d566971293","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"16ccc8f6866b12f72f1cc5bdec200a43d888fd66bdaca563ec623b1b61f881f6"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6b469f457790957ff7ee-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"172478274c8c6cefae0e46d485d373db74d6ed2e6d67121d0fe60c3553fe8561","reply.jsonSha256":"e4a601e983ad12fb24ac06650339f91a7cb408d1ad0059709c0a71399daf1643","reply.raw.txtSha256":"633b874344705a2d8539b45abb792739f8caf36c5fe116ee81cf82c41bb84161","receipt.jsonSha256":"66ce2c23b3c076188e34e5a95afec015e72e192e7a489859d2d316c4fa3f930c","normalization.jsonSha256":"89c6ce8e7cd2a821fb72347a5e003a2ab62093e88672faf6fa2d440db3279915"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6"},{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:22f83c7c4971c36f20f347f6"},{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d3","originalRef":"l3","status":"route","source":"s13","target":"s2","type":"method_for","title":"Use gauge formulations to assess strong-CP protection premises","rationale":"The gauge-form formulations and source-specific consistency arguments in s13 supply the methods identified by both statements for examining protection and surviving degrees of freedom. The original arrow therefore reverses.","qualification":"Applicability is limited to the shared protection and consistency questions under the stated S-matrix, spectrum, species-scale or perturbative assumptions. Different form degrees do not establish equivalent mechanisms. A consumed axion with residual particle-number symmetry remains a boundary case. Gauge redundancy alone does not verify all-orders protection, and these methods do not establish that gravity universally requires a QCD axion.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l3","s13","s2"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify gauge formulations and specific consistency arguments as methodological inputs, so s13 correctly becomes the source. The bounded applicability, differing form degrees, consumed-axion boundary case and unverified all-orders protection prevent the reversal from asserting a universal gravity result.","refs":["l3","s13","s2"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l4":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l4","source":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","target":"q025-candidate-question:f8d258f07eb369740028cc21","type":"application_of","title":"Identify mass and protection mechanisms used by dark-matter candidates","rationale":"Dark-matter candidate construction can apply the mass-generation and protection mechanisms organized by s32. The applied candidate question therefore points to the underlying mechanism question.","qualification":"This applies only to candidate models using the specified mechanisms. Spectrum, charge ordering, symmetry status, ultraviolet assumptions and acceptable lifetimes remain model dependent. Decay protection does not eliminate annihilation or collective depletion. Thermal or nonthermal production, relic abundance, searches and full cosmological viability require additional evidence; candidate inclusion does not certify viability.","evidenceIds":["unit:054cf4e9b765cd2ac5f35b02940165cd655c092b0338423680a24b1d651f621b","unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","unit:086443a70e473b97b9bf2b7cef696694c8b0c2e3ed9d6cce4c0e47b19fb12e22","unit:0ac5f33eee9e30f13d39d3e40376e84955b2b4250896a9c79dff2932fe52ddfe","unit:1e96331a613901b21e0941d90c6652e41bcf7c74ba6030bed0a42d0a478e2968","unit:2d3d65b41648c0f939fba5152e588f2fb018d4e2274f758e39c6b9da23a72c57","unit:383d13703c71f3f25373a6ba0e1661f1e7e8cdeb7bd60a8065f24cc2200577f8","unit:3a27d6408cf96805cf6c280eb0c67b7715232bc784b79320000b8679b38de17a","unit:4388ba5c525b417e4a3e81463cabf723b16fda2447df04105d5d37c95b9f7fad","unit:56017bdcddd38ed7cba4066f0d2855ab32f64ec5330fc5104299358b29497dba","unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","unit:699d34cdd7756d1c072c7a517702ec67f86c041e11097f1ed8ca0fb4a3816e82","unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","unit:743a5ec4ec3327442a03957751dfa536fef453cc99c934ad167cc223432045a0","unit:886390bae4de13ca3fa9e42b4829aee4c1b2f9d3fa5107860df6115430055e16","unit:8e20c0326768a1f649bdfd14b44bd23e09092673cf36a5ad36fe7532ac92f1c6","unit:96c6613c2dd137e812dbc4166a6e8ead41b9b0d2a2518722c8fa4f4de6056bbc","unit:9f867e2655c9ee718616d07641d24237d81c9f1ee269a6f9ce1169bb7a5ebaee","unit:a757dfd6e7766fa39431351f4621d054ffbea3c8fc2ad8463b5fe265bc329bf7","unit:c78813fed1118a3a9647db73b578c6931e7f80a6e2ea08f4a434be88cb997525","unit:cf0f5d73068de72fc720bc98c5772e2ad522fbd1b1df061575a88c53cc930bb5","unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","unit:dbed9b6879afe9a03c27774aa14c0f3595a9a18d55979fecac48c074509831f2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","scopeContentSha256":"392640e6a9b8a01652bc7d6dafda7769a164fa44c0efde3644a103be5f08f62a","localRef":"s6"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f8d258f07eb369740028cc21","scopeContentSha256":"04e2ded301de21ca5e72c183774e8b785fd2ca8c7e4df396a0fbbb6d06499b4a","localRef":"s32"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l4","originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge:link:35","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l4","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge:link:35","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:f8d258f07eb369740028cc21","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l4","source":"s32","target":"s6","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Mass generation and protection can enter candidate construction, while relic production and full cosmological viability require additional evidence."],"challengeStatement":"Mass generation and protection can enter dark-matter construction; abundance and full cosmological viability require additional evidence.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"e5504a2c4da076c85104a2266ee2d7736e709a7e52a5d800af1700943c465cac","reply.jsonSha256":"c7670a2a3f34e361015dbf9482392020b1a573e8a83b6a60c6d900a13e7586eb","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7128fb9710583d064a2fdcc6d110ef96841760bd1a2dbd1edd5c8ddfa1e91415","receipt.jsonSha256":"1dfa74ad6830cffb2282b232a13cc93ffd43f1fb20e262f22448b79744e21f56","normalization.jsonSha256":"dc92ec109885b2b11e32b021171ca6cb99228c52647c0739d967d53f52076084","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4fe88709dd8c30df946cd8ecebff01e16afac4d554ebd9a82df8762a9494b5cd"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-5eef7911f1a80cb73c18-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"783fca8ad0c206144b663c532d96a903a50df8724949f88395f9d5e460bfcc59","reply.jsonSha256":"a5b87b3059ea83dd4136caff9089a981a93d2932676041a5fb90dc12adfba988","reply.raw.txtSha256":"0150d21a762614339b2ad10b13e27b5e332664b355b59600c635fd0574428e03","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a03ea25b1d3f029bf1b8a76cff9e15f8ffafc2b2052cabf5059938d238e7b36","normalization.jsonSha256":"f9d3c8d0a480348d5e8e97bd7f55dad45c7dd4baec013e9547a323081f64a5be"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f8d258f07eb369740028cc21"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f8d258f07eb369740028cc21"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d4","originalRef":"l4","status":"route","source":"s6","target":"s32","type":"application_of","title":"Identify mass and protection mechanisms used by dark-matter candidates","rationale":"Dark-matter candidate construction can apply the mass-generation and protection mechanisms organized by s32. The applied candidate question therefore points to the underlying mechanism question.","qualification":"This applies only to candidate models using the specified mechanisms. Spectrum, charge ordering, symmetry status, ultraviolet assumptions and acceptable lifetimes remain model dependent. Decay protection does not eliminate annihilation or collective depletion. Thermal or nonthermal production, relic abundance, searches and full cosmological viability require additional evidence; candidate inclusion does not certify viability.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l4","s6","s32"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Candidate construction is the applied question, while s32 supplies the relevant mass and protection mechanisms. The reversed application direction preserves the originals' conditional connection and explicitly separates particle protection from abundance, depletion, searches and full cosmological viability.","refs":["l4","s6","s32"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l5":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l5","source":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","target":"q025-candidate-question:697e3045c7aa1c03f400e828","type":"premise_check","title":"Check the hypotheses of energy, barrier and singularity criteria","rationale":"The criteria in s11 test hypotheses relevant to particular geometric and causal constructions in s39 without imposing a common restriction on the region.","qualification":"Keep each criterion's hypotheses local to its application. The stress-tensor classification has its stated n ≥ 3 scope; geometric barriers do not require an energy-condition premise; the singularity/trapped-surface implication has additional slice assumptions. Geodesic incompleteness, soft divergences and geometric-flow singularities remain distinct. No universal censorship result, quantum resolution or identification of the unnamed source-free obstruction follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:082aab8b608d032fa71e74e65c8cdd229111bcb6408e67cee5fd945737e751d2","unit:129c3a5d43df14c7b9d1420495756470f0c59d2cc217ac0dfaaa5ec826ab5fed","unit:24a802e1495877b2de5d9379a55e6c653ebaafad79066895b807ea3023a6b822","unit:2e567bca9a19882f61a1181aa672c6651862c3ba969020fa9672abff35ecc371","unit:489ce850d54b041496e37e2f212cb76d1fe99d09da65381b21dca08e0664bd69","unit:48bcc84c477742ecc2d440b713f5839289895a8cec0dac11e63763e199a4c924","unit:50ea9ab21a49c4d87f5460972c01d37c74d643ae76cfa5035d38813d90edd321","unit:62e19aec34fed015c5633b574829e4bc5fbbfcae46e00331f97ae72e5a2df146","unit:67d86fa100ab30e8251e7004be6deb424b8e614af4ff61dfeb54078dc78224d4","unit:72bda98a5b2812d02fe3f9ff5e8633993bb212e67bb497f06b47d58063cec347","unit:773bd725c3b7f1f81319b667afc4dfa89979ee9ec5da2730f455eb11e1f56732","unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","unit:c6ae6426542eed79fce69f742eef2baaac3de74a508042861326dfbc14286e1d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","scopeContentSha256":"97486901939e48c1469358e67d3f205ba59b52bdff16005addd845c0a8cf9280","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:697e3045c7aa1c03f400e828","scopeContentSha256":"175f186c340c0fdcf295acdcd41a42dd3aaeffe2916ef202e0c87e153eb279a6","localRef":"s11"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l5","originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:11","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l5","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:11","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:697e3045c7aa1c03f400e828","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l5","source":"s39","target":"s11","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["Energy, barrier and singularity questions test source-specific hypotheses; they do not supply a universal restriction for the family."],"challengeStatement":"Energy, barrier and singularity criteria test source-specific hypotheses without imposing a universal family restriction.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"925b3a06e0d58b1ad55d18ab053b1eb9d69cad6c9cf79f5e8c7018f776a6b930","reply.jsonSha256":"da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a6946727adefee7f3b2b748ff0c0ce5f0a58757e5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"135d367256f1c72fe01022ea832c9dc4f9f738e1d96ce8bf53734f13fe5f68e6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4b6e52d88ba3a909c203c07b3da236d98c0b1b281c2e2c6b7f3607b778bfda8b","normalization.jsonSha256":"6fd88b04991ddf39e7ff5092add083be8e384bafd3f19e71277cd6e2f088e477","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"05576f0db3fb5c595fb6d3897bf21da45667e0eb85b5e9a62f807106dd4fde78"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5765d539bf0f3099f1950f796691829e7f864cd76798b1bb052698baddfe718a","reply.jsonSha256":"0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c480e26d6cfc8a931b11cfe5472f4d19633a4fd55","reply.raw.txtSha256":"de1a8fb3eb5515d58d9c7ca2a9b788a8c9e65e1036945a6bf0722f302d37714a","receipt.jsonSha256":"758edf392c44cf3888db4d027ada99bb3d726b6d5f985600aba5ee4acc328beb","normalization.jsonSha256":"a617cbb678db447bcc5636be99fe70967c460f3c466178602875d90df3617927"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:697e3045c7aa1c03f400e828"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:697e3045c7aa1c03f400e828"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d5","originalRef":"l5","status":"route","source":"s39","target":"s11","type":"premise_check","title":"Check the hypotheses of energy, barrier and singularity criteria","rationale":"The criteria in s11 test hypotheses relevant to particular geometric and causal constructions in s39 without imposing a common restriction on the region.","qualification":"Keep each criterion's hypotheses local to its application. The stress-tensor classification has its stated n ≥ 3 scope; geometric barriers do not require an energy-condition premise; the singularity/trapped-surface implication has additional slice assumptions. Geodesic incompleteness, soft divergences and geometric-flow singularities remain distinct. No universal censorship result, quantum resolution or identification of the unnamed source-free obstruction follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l5","s39","s11"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The criteria in s11 examine hypotheses relevant to particular constructions in s39, supporting the proposed premise-check direction. The qualification keeps dimensional, geometric and slice assumptions separate and does not convert the criteria into a universal family restriction.","refs":["l5","s39","s11"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l6":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l6","source":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","target":"q025-candidate-question:d5659f6f5bc20f32e5725182","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on controlled traversability and communication limits","rationale":"The specified Lorentzian traversability, support and communication questions refine the region's explicit causal-access and control targets. The region is an overview, not a single construction being applied.","qualification":"Keep interacting-boundary and coupled-SYK setups separate from four-dimensional charged-field constructions. Opening times, black-hole sizes, species numbers, transverse localization, metastability and semiclassical control remain source-specific. Short openings and static throats differ. Preserve independent-boundary restrictions and the charged-field proposal's no-ambient-shortcut condition. Quantum support is not identified with a classical NEC-violating matter EFT, and communication capacity is not unrestricted.","evidenceIds":["unit:129c3a5d43df14c7b9d1420495756470f0c59d2cc217ac0dfaaa5ec826ab5fed","unit:2e567bca9a19882f61a1181aa672c6651862c3ba969020fa9672abff35ecc371","unit:3f04156e4a369b1a170d4e26b69082029c9e8c4bab0025263a66a9b075021288","unit:937a839e6c9217f54a37897970aa11b2aba3c4a4cd2ab87e063e02c31ba89bf4","unit:966f4231daca587f0bf589836fee07942bee69ccd39ab7b0ad577289b1a10cd8","unit:a5643a3fc266858daabda841a366452e7b3510359b8c25d7b65890287ad943f0","unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","unit:c6ae6426542eed79fce69f742eef2baaac3de74a508042861326dfbc14286e1d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","scopeContentSha256":"97486901939e48c1469358e67d3f205ba59b52bdff16005addd845c0a8cf9280","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d5659f6f5bc20f32e5725182","scopeContentSha256":"9abbc66b3ca76358fd470e083f168b641ee752950675da8c51cbec061f00b34b","localRef":"s26"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l6","originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:13","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l6","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:13","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:d5659f6f5bc20f32e5725182","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l6","source":"s39","target":"s26","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Controlled traversability and communication are Lorentzian applications with specified interactions and quantum support."],"challengeStatement":"Traversability and communication concern specified Lorentzian interactions and quantum support.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"925b3a06e0d58b1ad55d18ab053b1eb9d69cad6c9cf79f5e8c7018f776a6b930","reply.jsonSha256":"da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a6946727adefee7f3b2b748ff0c0ce5f0a58757e5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"135d367256f1c72fe01022ea832c9dc4f9f738e1d96ce8bf53734f13fe5f68e6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4b6e52d88ba3a909c203c07b3da236d98c0b1b281c2e2c6b7f3607b778bfda8b","normalization.jsonSha256":"6fd88b04991ddf39e7ff5092add083be8e384bafd3f19e71277cd6e2f088e477","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"05576f0db3fb5c595fb6d3897bf21da45667e0eb85b5e9a62f807106dd4fde78"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5765d539bf0f3099f1950f796691829e7f864cd76798b1bb052698baddfe718a","reply.jsonSha256":"0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c480e26d6cfc8a931b11cfe5472f4d19633a4fd55","reply.raw.txtSha256":"de1a8fb3eb5515d58d9c7ca2a9b788a8c9e65e1036945a6bf0722f302d37714a","receipt.jsonSha256":"758edf392c44cf3888db4d027ada99bb3d726b6d5f985600aba5ee4acc328beb","normalization.jsonSha256":"a617cbb678db447bcc5636be99fe70967c460f3c466178602875d90df3617927"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d5659f6f5bc20f32e5725182"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d5659f6f5bc20f32e5725182"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d6","originalRef":"l6","status":"route","source":"s39","target":"s26","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on controlled traversability and communication limits","rationale":"The specified Lorentzian traversability, support and communication questions refine the region's explicit causal-access and control targets. The region is an overview, not a single construction being applied.","qualification":"Keep interacting-boundary and coupled-SYK setups separate from four-dimensional charged-field constructions. Opening times, black-hole sizes, species numbers, transverse localization, metastability and semiclassical control remain source-specific. Short openings and static throats differ. Preserve independent-boundary restrictions and the charged-field proposal's no-ambient-shortcut condition. Quantum support is not identified with a classical NEC-violating matter EFT, and communication capacity is not unrestricted.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l6","s39","s26"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The complete traversability and communication scope refines s39's explicit Lorentzian causal-access and support targets. Narrower is more accurate than treating this broad region as an underlying construction. The record retains interaction, quantum-support, opening-time, control and no-shortcut distinctions.","refs":["l6","s39","s26"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l7":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l7","source":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","target":"q025-candidate-question:d7951f38ae2139652f8c4e29","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on conditional wormhole-induced axion phenomenology","rationale":"The induced-interaction and axion-phenomenology question refines s39's explicit targets concerning gravitational histories, effective interactions and phenomenology.","qualification":"Phenomenological estimates remain conditional on the relevant wormhole contribution and operator prescription. Matter dynamics, radial modes, gravity formulation and action estimates are model dependent; metric and Palatini formulations remain alternatives. Neither classical regularity nor membership in the region establishes a quantum contribution, a universal symmetry-breaking strength, success or failure of PQ protection, or an observed signal.","evidenceIds":["unit:0cfddafcd6417097c3c3c3756823bf4d80fd8ceaee54edc785f413aabdefd6fe","unit:129c3a5d43df14c7b9d1420495756470f0c59d2cc217ac0dfaaa5ec826ab5fed","unit:2e567bca9a19882f61a1181aa672c6651862c3ba969020fa9672abff35ecc371","unit:44a528961b2ce61e846737609e53e614ec4f2942041301cee9878ac0d24482f6","unit:7c8fbc7aaa13d9123e33551bc76f79be9a83a06b1efbc691e148bb57318171f4","unit:7e9e95b146062e6d0a496a51dc7767b2bf7054e472d8e99b95096cb1693741de","unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","unit:ae7c62eceddadf1cd5dddf97d7ab88fb72cf7582553b726a2464e400369ccd96","unit:c6ae6426542eed79fce69f742eef2baaac3de74a508042861326dfbc14286e1d","unit:c9a60f36ae7b41562d33623b86202e9b09e83fe60663bd5beab438f67a735fb6"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","scopeContentSha256":"97486901939e48c1469358e67d3f205ba59b52bdff16005addd845c0a8cf9280","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d7951f38ae2139652f8c4e29","scopeContentSha256":"52d080126b550087ded6d51425e3a966f94f014e6b957790ab7f992f211a40bc","localRef":"s27"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l7","originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:14","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l7","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:14","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:d7951f38ae2139652f8c4e29","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l7","source":"s39","target":"s27","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Symmetry breaking and axion phenomenology depend on the model and the assumed physical wormhole contribution."],"challengeStatement":"Axion phenomenology depends on the model and the assumed physical wormhole contribution.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"925b3a06e0d58b1ad55d18ab053b1eb9d69cad6c9cf79f5e8c7018f776a6b930","reply.jsonSha256":"da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a6946727adefee7f3b2b748ff0c0ce5f0a58757e5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"135d367256f1c72fe01022ea832c9dc4f9f738e1d96ce8bf53734f13fe5f68e6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4b6e52d88ba3a909c203c07b3da236d98c0b1b281c2e2c6b7f3607b778bfda8b","normalization.jsonSha256":"6fd88b04991ddf39e7ff5092add083be8e384bafd3f19e71277cd6e2f088e477","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"05576f0db3fb5c595fb6d3897bf21da45667e0eb85b5e9a62f807106dd4fde78"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5765d539bf0f3099f1950f796691829e7f864cd76798b1bb052698baddfe718a","reply.jsonSha256":"0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c480e26d6cfc8a931b11cfe5472f4d19633a4fd55","reply.raw.txtSha256":"de1a8fb3eb5515d58d9c7ca2a9b788a8c9e65e1036945a6bf0722f302d37714a","receipt.jsonSha256":"758edf392c44cf3888db4d027ada99bb3d726b6d5f985600aba5ee4acc328beb","normalization.jsonSha256":"a617cbb678db447bcc5636be99fe70967c460f3c466178602875d90df3617927"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d7951f38ae2139652f8c4e29"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d7951f38ae2139652f8c4e29"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d7","originalRef":"l7","status":"route","source":"s39","target":"s27","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on conditional wormhole-induced axion phenomenology","rationale":"The induced-interaction and axion-phenomenology question refines s39's explicit targets concerning gravitational histories, effective interactions and phenomenology.","qualification":"Phenomenological estimates remain conditional on the relevant wormhole contribution and operator prescription. Matter dynamics, radial modes, gravity formulation and action estimates are model dependent; metric and Palatini formulations remain alternatives. Neither classical regularity nor membership in the region establishes a quantum contribution, a universal symmetry-breaking strength, success or failure of PQ protection, or an observed signal.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l7","s39","s27"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Conditional wormhole-induced interactions and phenomenology are expressly within s39, supporting full-scope refinement to s27. The qualification preserves the assumed physical contribution, operator prescription and model-dependent dynamics without deriving phenomenology from classical regularity.","refs":["l7","s39","s27"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l8":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l8","source":"q025-candidate-question:294fd0bae69760e5ca1f11a0","target":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","type":"method_for","title":"Use geometric flows for selected deformation and endpoint questions","rationale":"Geometric-flow construction supplies the stated methodological direction for selected metric-deformation and endpoint questions in s39, so the arrow reverses.","qualification":"Each flow retains its functional, constraints, initial data, equations and source-limited numerical or perturbative regime. Equation preservation and endpoint criteria require their own checks. An auxiliary metric flow is not automatically physical time evolution or radial Einstein–scalar evolution. Finite flow parameter does not establish finite configuration-space distance or EFT validity, and no universal surgery or quantum-gravity construction is supplied.","evidenceIds":["unit:10d72088c388cdee7f9b38d7c5f1d7f41eb153c9dd84c3713bae64caa3679913","unit:129c3a5d43df14c7b9d1420495756470f0c59d2cc217ac0dfaaa5ec826ab5fed","unit:1390664225d75414aaaf8579263b455d9ec2098e0268de3a8d2614519b4ff28f","unit:2b559119120db2676179e4ca82398ef2be9970bbd8252014cc790454a36e3e46","unit:2e567bca9a19882f61a1181aa672c6651862c3ba969020fa9672abff35ecc371","unit:3d9174df9114282a9c8d77673f4fdbb796adca1a11b1b1041d5d2d5483f4b4c5","unit:4c01cd20f371b5ac977e1f0f79097b052191e85aa7ed5e1a67c99c260fdc18ab","unit:4d388d36e6956a18d864fc2e32f9f5a6e7c65d17a6ae252bcbb192bd245bce65","unit:608619b017b6c673fc4244017dc3661e08376bdfd0ab586c609b615d56cfea8d","unit:62e19aec34fed015c5633b574829e4bc5fbbfcae46e00331f97ae72e5a2df146","unit:64c055b1c7573b0abfdf755e804dcd8d5d01be224faa17c617218782eb37cb51","unit:7ae02a50582e25531383c1233c046cd102fe7f4693e3214107f7f58e05bdbd91","unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","unit:bb182875354f3d6250b755dc736e6e201ff685a9e64682bc842dd535c061cb3f","unit:c6ae6426542eed79fce69f742eef2baaac3de74a508042861326dfbc14286e1d","unit:c87b313d905c95625b0805931388bfb34a175e15a34bc92ee0a9e471cbeffe07","unit:e689f3da70d9186f83102555882b389c6f9abfed1af39282a23e0131570d5ca1","unit:f2d16e1773e3c5b168c1d70e06c2819a1ddcd0ba1b980a8a42919a192ed1db5c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:294fd0bae69760e5ca1f11a0","scopeContentSha256":"d3a4aa86956e85827352aa46b8afcdd142ade7ff45cc24a4df258451a05c2c8d","localRef":"s3"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","scopeContentSha256":"97486901939e48c1469358e67d3f205ba59b52bdff16005addd845c0a8cf9280","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l8","originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:9","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l8","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:9","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:e1e0a6d8ac554b8a8c392ea2","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:294fd0bae69760e5ca1f11a0","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l8","source":"s39","target":"s3","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Geometric-flow construction supplies a method direction with its own endpoint and equation-preservation questions."],"challengeStatement":"Geometric-flow construction supplies a method direction with independent endpoint and equation-preservation questions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"925b3a06e0d58b1ad55d18ab053b1eb9d69cad6c9cf79f5e8c7018f776a6b930","reply.jsonSha256":"da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a6946727adefee7f3b2b748ff0c0ce5f0a58757e5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"135d367256f1c72fe01022ea832c9dc4f9f738e1d96ce8bf53734f13fe5f68e6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4b6e52d88ba3a909c203c07b3da236d98c0b1b281c2e2c6b7f3607b778bfda8b","normalization.jsonSha256":"6fd88b04991ddf39e7ff5092add083be8e384bafd3f19e71277cd6e2f088e477","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"05576f0db3fb5c595fb6d3897bf21da45667e0eb85b5e9a62f807106dd4fde78"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5765d539bf0f3099f1950f796691829e7f864cd76798b1bb052698baddfe718a","reply.jsonSha256":"0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c480e26d6cfc8a931b11cfe5472f4d19633a4fd55","reply.raw.txtSha256":"de1a8fb3eb5515d58d9c7ca2a9b788a8c9e65e1036945a6bf0722f302d37714a","receipt.jsonSha256":"758edf392c44cf3888db4d027ada99bb3d726b6d5f985600aba5ee4acc328beb","normalization.jsonSha256":"a617cbb678db447bcc5636be99fe70967c460f3c466178602875d90df3617927"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:294fd0bae69760e5ca1f11a0"},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"2006.03076","sourceId":"ev:c65c1b97b8f4f826a57655fb3ced929f","sourceSha256":"6d503e5f4a7214e7d4a3fc3bf8055d9994dca8491371cb3b9207b454a9129f85","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6b98e963940a318598b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"829ee0738c1bae8ea2b4010cf8b958b2f010556be97c6acbda7a1951f96f18a8","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1623,"textSha256":"a838b39784c43e769d0d1b68de34cd4bbb84606154a0360683d343b33f66623e","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:294fd0bae69760e5ca1f11a0"},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"2006.03076","sourceId":"ev:c65c1b97b8f4f826a57655fb3ced929f","sourceSha256":"6d503e5f4a7214e7d4a3fc3bf8055d9994dca8491371cb3b9207b454a9129f85","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6b98e963940a318598b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"829ee0738c1bae8ea2b4010cf8b958b2f010556be97c6acbda7a1951f96f18a8","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1623,"textSha256":"a838b39784c43e769d0d1b68de34cd4bbb84606154a0360683d343b33f66623e","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d8","originalRef":"l8","status":"route","source":"s3","target":"s39","type":"method_for","title":"Use geometric flows for selected deformation and endpoint questions","rationale":"Geometric-flow construction supplies the stated methodological direction for selected metric-deformation and endpoint questions in s39, so the arrow reverses.","qualification":"Each flow retains its functional, constraints, initial data, equations and source-limited numerical or perturbative regime. Equation preservation and endpoint criteria require their own checks. An auxiliary metric flow is not automatically physical time evolution or radial Einstein–scalar evolution. Finite flow parameter does not establish finite configuration-space distance or EFT validity, and no universal surgery or quantum-gravity construction is supplied.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l8","s3","s39"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Geometric-flow construction supplies the methodological direction identified by both statements, fixing the source as s3. Independent endpoint and equation-preservation checks remain explicit, as do the distinctions among auxiliary flow, physical evolution, configuration-space distance and effective-theory validity.","refs":["l8","s3","s39"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l9":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l9","source":"q025-candidate-question:294fd0bae69760e5ca1f11a0","target":"q025-candidate-question:b1d00d468b9e623001906be3","type":"method_for","title":"Construct and check flows for selected phase-boundary studies","rationale":"The construction and consistency questions in s3 provide a method for examining the selected phase-boundary problems in s20. This reverses the original arrow without certifying any particular trajectory.","qualification":"The connection is limited to the selected flow applications, including the stated four-dimensional Schwarzschild–AdS examples. A proposed trajectory requires checking the complete tensor equation along a consistent coordinate identification; this packet does not establish that check as completed. Numerical crossings remain limited to examined cases and do not establish a thermal process, a general entropy theorem or a global weak-flow extension.","evidenceIds":["unit:10d72088c388cdee7f9b38d7c5f1d7f41eb153c9dd84c3713bae64caa3679913","unit:1390664225d75414aaaf8579263b455d9ec2098e0268de3a8d2614519b4ff28f","unit:13ddc5d26ffd8aa10c1d23d6e497722704f65b22ed89fbf658bf5f554e87d231","unit:2b559119120db2676179e4ca82398ef2be9970bbd8252014cc790454a36e3e46","unit:2e567bca9a19882f61a1181aa672c6651862c3ba969020fa9672abff35ecc371","unit:3d9174df9114282a9c8d77673f4fdbb796adca1a11b1b1041d5d2d5483f4b4c5","unit:489ce850d54b041496e37e2f212cb76d1fe99d09da65381b21dca08e0664bd69","unit:4c01cd20f371b5ac977e1f0f79097b052191e85aa7ed5e1a67c99c260fdc18ab","unit:4d388d36e6956a18d864fc2e32f9f5a6e7c65d17a6ae252bcbb192bd245bce65","unit:50ea9ab21a49c4d87f5460972c01d37c74d643ae76cfa5035d38813d90edd321","unit:5e20891cb12629fffa33df70b37ff011e67f1c659bdfc2adaa611e5d2c076152","unit:608619b017b6c673fc4244017dc3661e08376bdfd0ab586c609b615d56cfea8d","unit:62e19aec34fed015c5633b574829e4bc5fbbfcae46e00331f97ae72e5a2df146","unit:64c055b1c7573b0abfdf755e804dcd8d5d01be224faa17c617218782eb37cb51","unit:72bda98a5b2812d02fe3f9ff5e8633993bb212e67bb497f06b47d58063cec347","unit:7ae02a50582e25531383c1233c046cd102fe7f4693e3214107f7f58e05bdbd91","unit:bb182875354f3d6250b755dc736e6e201ff685a9e64682bc842dd535c061cb3f","unit:c87b313d905c95625b0805931388bfb34a175e15a34bc92ee0a9e471cbeffe07","unit:e689f3da70d9186f83102555882b389c6f9abfed1af39282a23e0131570d5ca1","unit:f2d16e1773e3c5b168c1d70e06c2819a1ddcd0ba1b980a8a42919a192ed1db5c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:294fd0bae69760e5ca1f11a0","scopeContentSha256":"d3a4aa86956e85827352aa46b8afcdd142ade7ff45cc24a4df258451a05c2c8d","localRef":"s3"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b1d00d468b9e623001906be3","scopeContentSha256":"75cee2a0efe0954b7e8a873f41b09fb7cce39abff7ba5580bdfc4234aa61bd71","localRef":"s20"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l9","originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:39","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l9","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:39","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:b1d00d468b9e623001906be3","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:294fd0bae69760e5ca1f11a0","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l9","source":"s20","target":"s3","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Geometric flows provide one method for examining selected phase boundaries; the complete tensor equation remains a separate consistency check."],"challengeStatement":"Geometric flows examine selected phase boundaries, subject to checking the complete tensor equation along a consistent coordinate identification.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary","source_relation"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"925b3a06e0d58b1ad55d18ab053b1eb9d69cad6c9cf79f5e8c7018f776a6b930","reply.jsonSha256":"da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a6946727adefee7f3b2b748ff0c0ce5f0a58757e5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"135d367256f1c72fe01022ea832c9dc4f9f738e1d96ce8bf53734f13fe5f68e6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4b6e52d88ba3a909c203c07b3da236d98c0b1b281c2e2c6b7f3607b778bfda8b","normalization.jsonSha256":"6fd88b04991ddf39e7ff5092add083be8e384bafd3f19e71277cd6e2f088e477","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"05576f0db3fb5c595fb6d3897bf21da45667e0eb85b5e9a62f807106dd4fde78"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5765d539bf0f3099f1950f796691829e7f864cd76798b1bb052698baddfe718a","reply.jsonSha256":"0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c480e26d6cfc8a931b11cfe5472f4d19633a4fd55","reply.raw.txtSha256":"de1a8fb3eb5515d58d9c7ca2a9b788a8c9e65e1036945a6bf0722f302d37714a","receipt.jsonSha256":"758edf392c44cf3888db4d027ada99bb3d726b6d5f985600aba5ee4acc328beb","normalization.jsonSha256":"a617cbb678db447bcc5636be99fe70967c460f3c466178602875d90df3617927"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b1d00d468b9e623001906be3"},{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:294fd0bae69760e5ca1f11a0"},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"2006.03076","sourceId":"ev:c65c1b97b8f4f826a57655fb3ced929f","sourceSha256":"6d503e5f4a7214e7d4a3fc3bf8055d9994dca8491371cb3b9207b454a9129f85","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6b98e963940a318598b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"829ee0738c1bae8ea2b4010cf8b958b2f010556be97c6acbda7a1951f96f18a8","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1623,"textSha256":"a838b39784c43e769d0d1b68de34cd4bbb84606154a0360683d343b33f66623e","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"g5","kind":"source_relation","sourceId":"edge:a4fd8cab4da197e5dffc2f7c0d4a0c49"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b1d00d468b9e623001906be3"},{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:294fd0bae69760e5ca1f11a0"},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"2006.03076","sourceId":"ev:c65c1b97b8f4f826a57655fb3ced929f","sourceSha256":"6d503e5f4a7214e7d4a3fc3bf8055d9994dca8491371cb3b9207b454a9129f85","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6b98e963940a318598b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"829ee0738c1bae8ea2b4010cf8b958b2f010556be97c6acbda7a1951f96f18a8","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1623,"textSha256":"a838b39784c43e769d0d1b68de34cd4bbb84606154a0360683d343b33f66623e","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"g5","kind":"source_relation","sourceId":"edge:a4fd8cab4da197e5dffc2f7c0d4a0c49"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d9","originalRef":"l9","status":"route","source":"s3","target":"s20","type":"method_for","title":"Construct and check flows for selected phase-boundary studies","rationale":"The construction and consistency questions in s3 provide a method for examining the selected phase-boundary problems in s20. This reverses the original arrow without certifying any particular trajectory.","qualification":"The connection is limited to the selected flow applications, including the stated four-dimensional Schwarzschild–AdS examples. A proposed trajectory requires checking the complete tensor equation along a consistent coordinate identification; this packet does not establish that check as completed. Numerical crossings remain limited to examined cases and do not establish a thermal process, a general entropy theorem or a global weak-flow extension.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l9","s3","s20"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d9","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The reversed method route is supported for selected phase-boundary studies. It retains the challenge statement's complete-tensor-equation and coordinate-identification condition and does not claim that condition has been satisfied. A construction-and-checking route does not certify the particular phase-crossing trajectory.","refs":["l9","s3","s20"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l10":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l10","source":"q025-candidate-question:697e3045c7aa1c03f400e828","target":"q025-candidate-question:0ce75b71f62a993a0919398b","type":"method_for","title":"Apply conditional geometric and matter tests to spacetime constructions","rationale":"Energy conditions, barriers and singularity criteria supply tests for relevant accessibility and regularity questions in s0. The tests belong at the source of the method arrow.","qualification":"Use only the criterion appropriate to the specified matter, geometry and boundary problem. Barrier hypotheses are geometric rather than energy-condition premises, and singularity implications retain their additional slice assumptions. Stress-tensor classification retains its dimensional scope; incompleteness and soft divergences remain distinct. These tests do not by themselves decide contour admissibility, topology weighting or physical quantum contribution, and conservation does not establish positive-action realizability.","evidenceIds":["unit:082aab8b608d032fa71e74e65c8cdd229111bcb6408e67cee5fd945737e751d2","unit:24a802e1495877b2de5d9379a55e6c653ebaafad79066895b807ea3023a6b822","unit:489ce850d54b041496e37e2f212cb76d1fe99d09da65381b21dca08e0664bd69","unit:48bcc84c477742ecc2d440b713f5839289895a8cec0dac11e63763e199a4c924","unit:50ea9ab21a49c4d87f5460972c01d37c74d643ae76cfa5035d38813d90edd321","unit:62e19aec34fed015c5633b574829e4bc5fbbfcae46e00331f97ae72e5a2df146","unit:67d86fa100ab30e8251e7004be6deb424b8e614af4ff61dfeb54078dc78224d4","unit:72bda98a5b2812d02fe3f9ff5e8633993bb212e67bb497f06b47d58063cec347","unit:773bd725c3b7f1f81319b667afc4dfa89979ee9ec5da2730f455eb11e1f56732","unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:697e3045c7aa1c03f400e828","scopeContentSha256":"175f186c340c0fdcf295acdcd41a42dd3aaeffe2916ef202e0c87e153eb279a6","localRef":"s11"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:0ce75b71f62a993a0919398b","scopeContentSha256":"90606e895059cfb6cf702a94847d6be7af9c98988b5a6ebd3753d88a8abe8d0e","localRef":"s0"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l10","originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-c8776465ed44d9e65c4c-challenge:link:56","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l10","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor2-parent-c8776465ed44d9e65c4c-challenge:link:56","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:0ce75b71f62a993a0919398b","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:697e3045c7aa1c03f400e828","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l10","source":"s0","target":"s11","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Energy conditions, geometric barriers and singularity criteria provide conditional tests; their hypotheses are not shared automatically."],"challengeStatement":"Energy conditions, barriers and singularity criteria supply conditional tests with different hypotheses.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor2-parent-c8776465ed44d9e65c4c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-c8776465ed44d9e65c4c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4250259949d988810aa2c98dd501068b9403401a34970c2c59745895b7f6f640","reply.jsonSha256":"547960bd314f007e772aac5947496369a847c9dfae965ffa81e1ced1bac48dd9","reply.raw.txtSha256":"230cc14fb22a61d877d826956665627db3fa96d1c57547a93e6200c0810214c5","receipt.jsonSha256":"a6d9a65aba5648db0bba5ce53f3058cdd41bc3e02e73e5900ccbba8713bb58d1","normalization.jsonSha256":"9e5aa7389b499e2cccd79b753eae6a8fe0ad5812c59fe738a2eef595573a9207","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-c8776465ed44d9e65c4c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"f3c79872f56409f9dd8f71a1277a00929cf4cbc7b818cd69ecec6795da5f77ae"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v2/jobs/successor2-parent-c8776465ed44d9e65c4c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"9cdd37349fb1ca46a5fba163dab6943e4b42eb7da6047c592dbd886aae6d951a","reply.jsonSha256":"763ca8cc56edbfd3b5e3e32bfe6f7178c34deac4d6e2adb74d0367c2f76b57c2","reply.raw.txtSha256":"a854f24433f7ce7f82effeffb18349bf607172a24709039e17925c048c2c8a9a","receipt.jsonSha256":"69a6f7a935debdff52d9659f6ff573be379d97fbccf50467efd818dfcce9b37e","normalization.jsonSha256":"ca1999c21a17763aa8d1bfb04329242e4817946d94c850e2cc850f2710116676"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:697e3045c7aa1c03f400e828"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:697e3045c7aa1c03f400e828"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d10","originalRef":"l10","status":"route","source":"s11","target":"s0","type":"method_for","title":"Apply conditional geometric and matter tests to spacetime constructions","rationale":"Energy conditions, barriers and singularity criteria supply tests for relevant accessibility and regularity questions in s0. The tests belong at the source of the method arrow.","qualification":"Use only the criterion appropriate to the specified matter, geometry and boundary problem. Barrier hypotheses are geometric rather than energy-condition premises, and singularity implications retain their additional slice assumptions. Stress-tensor classification retains its dimensional scope; incompleteness and soft divergences remain distinct. These tests do not by themselves decide contour admissibility, topology weighting or physical quantum contribution, and conservation does not establish positive-action realizability.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l10","s11","s0"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d10","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements describe conditional tests supplied by s11, so the method arrow correctly points toward the spacetime-construction question. The qualification preserves their different hypotheses and prevents accessibility or regularity tests from deciding quantum contributions, contour admissibility or topology weighting.","refs":["l10","s11","s0"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l10","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l11":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l11","source":"q025-candidate-question:c0dbb1b0781dd0d0bc259565","target":"q025-candidate-question:7bc0300e291a9aa1af67e782","type":"method_for","title":"Use temporal reduction and lifting for specified instanton constructions","rationale":"Temporal reduction and lifting supply the stated tools for shared scalar-geometry, instanton and lift questions within s15, so the methodological arrow reverses.","qualification":"Applicability is restricted to constructions admitting the specified reduction or lift and its scalar or tensor formulation. Instanton action–mass relations and no-force conditions retain their own assumptions. Vanishing horizon area and vanishing surface gravity are alternative stated regimes. Heuristic wormhole lessons do not establish existence, regularity, embedding control or quantum admissibility, and no-force conditions are not interchangeable with those tests.","evidenceIds":["unit:0b45baefe06facca719b975db6cd73f0db9327c7931f9ca1421f50069cb0bc8f","unit:0cfddafcd6417097c3c3c3756823bf4d80fd8ceaee54edc785f413aabdefd6fe","unit:129c3a5d43df14c7b9d1420495756470f0c59d2cc217ac0dfaaa5ec826ab5fed","unit:13ccd7b2a232a0d89c64147db7b1d68ec896844b2c5c94b278996ce09ba8030c","unit:1418230f2e85ee2956182e61095ff37e313248ce8a05294486c82dca38c720fc","unit:28f529ffb59d8b7e8b902728433926e07cdf0966fbe2f6b8b1b8c5cfcccfddf4","unit:424dbc9cee47ab69945a2ba5b656bc8478eb4aa22d07f841a4328929e69bf8a7","unit:4ef10749b8b3fd847237a1a4d8167b98b8de3450ef23037094f80325d03bf4b4","unit:528a022b18fe951a7de92d103e7fea429ab7053f93a36094b1d58c7d38d27927","unit:53bbbfdd1f9ce52569bcd74d62cac4cd9481cc83f74efb2cf1f42440fadc1779","unit:550423fdf3047d45f9e9b4f364bc7f34123518f1cff83ade52c28a31c460711e","unit:59060764a8958648787081c3143d15cecff75e5486faf30689b1f66ff064fd5d","unit:621efa310c3c1d6fd7b8adc8b97d48e5e66ec8bf55ce554bd7caafdeb635a6e3","unit:65035708d4cc84822a4fe3ae9198f79c5918903cc1d3ea2221cc9a0e8905d64d","unit:7e9e95b146062e6d0a496a51dc7767b2bf7054e472d8e99b95096cb1693741de","unit:8043929b434d969c6ddeabb5a89e2ec83ffb7d49cf84d592f46f756197e39092","unit:a7425bf08bc51b478f636dfda6ad9c5aeaf1705325509bbd76df72abe6da736e","unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","unit:c305ac5c72c00b8cd19bf586b38cbfd5c34474f63b04df6c14a91b2ed13a0614","unit:c9a60f36ae7b41562d33623b86202e9b09e83fe60663bd5beab438f67a735fb6","unit:e1ba659d26938a22a598518fc10a0a5bbc0755462f145418159c8f72d29d28ff","unit:e637915452c5efb2a97deaaed070f8aaaf3e2b690584ed05b07b202e1a6e8b20","unit:fa0c54cbd62581d38c96a5dbfb3d1c040e3709dffce839f2ac48d8d985611d90"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c0dbb1b0781dd0d0bc259565","scopeContentSha256":"105b2a3397df2f488b761cfc7804239c444136141b73609c4b41e93bf013e15a","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7bc0300e291a9aa1af67e782","scopeContentSha256":"a31b9e4fa6b9c6a737582de55b2df513d9b941d5c0edccf7681aa0a12a56441b","localRef":"s15"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l11","originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:16","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l11","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:16","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:7bc0300e291a9aa1af67e782","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:c0dbb1b0781dd0d0bc259565","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l11","source":"s15","target":"s22","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Temporal reduction and lifting provide a separate methodological home for scalar geometry, action–mass and no-force questions."],"challengeStatement":"Temporal reduction and lifting provide access to scalar geometry, action–mass relations and no-force questions under their own assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"925b3a06e0d58b1ad55d18ab053b1eb9d69cad6c9cf79f5e8c7018f776a6b930","reply.jsonSha256":"da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a6946727adefee7f3b2b748ff0c0ce5f0a58757e5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"135d367256f1c72fe01022ea832c9dc4f9f738e1d96ce8bf53734f13fe5f68e6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4b6e52d88ba3a909c203c07b3da236d98c0b1b281c2e2c6b7f3607b778bfda8b","normalization.jsonSha256":"6fd88b04991ddf39e7ff5092add083be8e384bafd3f19e71277cd6e2f088e477","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"05576f0db3fb5c595fb6d3897bf21da45667e0eb85b5e9a62f807106dd4fde78"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5765d539bf0f3099f1950f796691829e7f864cd76798b1bb052698baddfe718a","reply.jsonSha256":"0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c480e26d6cfc8a931b11cfe5472f4d19633a4fd55","reply.raw.txtSha256":"de1a8fb3eb5515d58d9c7ca2a9b788a8c9e65e1036945a6bf0722f302d37714a","receipt.jsonSha256":"758edf392c44cf3888db4d027ada99bb3d726b6d5f985600aba5ee4acc328beb","normalization.jsonSha256":"a617cbb678db447bcc5636be99fe70967c460f3c466178602875d90df3617927"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7bc0300e291a9aa1af67e782"},{"ref":"x3_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c0dbb1b0781dd0d0bc259565"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7bc0300e291a9aa1af67e782"},{"ref":"x3_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c0dbb1b0781dd0d0bc259565"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d11","originalRef":"l11","status":"route","source":"s22","target":"s15","type":"method_for","title":"Use temporal reduction and lifting for specified instanton constructions","rationale":"Temporal reduction and lifting supply the stated tools for shared scalar-geometry, instanton and lift questions within s15, so the methodological arrow reverses.","qualification":"Applicability is restricted to constructions admitting the specified reduction or lift and its scalar or tensor formulation. Instanton action–mass relations and no-force conditions retain their own assumptions. Vanishing horizon area and vanishing surface gravity are alternative stated regimes. Heuristic wormhole lessons do not establish existence, regularity, embedding control or quantum admissibility, and no-force conditions are not interchangeable with those tests.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l11","s22","s15"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d11","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Temporal reduction and lifting constitute the supplied methodological connection to the relevant instanton and embedding questions. The reversal remains bounded to specified reductions and lifts, preserves the heuristic wormhole status, and does not identify action–mass or no-force relations with regularity, control or quantum admissibility.","refs":["l11","s22","s15"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l11","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l12":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l12","source":"q025-candidate-question:5d349bd0fe32c666c4325643","target":"q025-candidate-question:b90c1d2a753bae902cd48f60","type":"method_for","title":"Analyze admissible fluctuations of a specified gravitational amplitude","rationale":"Physical fluctuation analysis supplies a method for testing a specified amplitude after its constraints and admissible perturbations are defined. The original method arrow reverses.","qualification":"Specify the amplitude, contour, gauge constraints, boundary terms and boundary conditions before interpreting modes. Retain fixed-charge or fixed-flux ensembles and distinguish asymptotically flat from positive-cosmological-constant backgrounds. Scalar and dual-form descriptions require their stated matching. Disagreement among calculations remains visible; neither a family-wide stability verdict nor an automatic contribution or exclusion follows, and perturbative modes are not identified with fragmentation into charged defects.","evidenceIds":["unit:0b45baefe06facca719b975db6cd73f0db9327c7931f9ca1421f50069cb0bc8f","unit:129c3a5d43df14c7b9d1420495756470f0c59d2cc217ac0dfaaa5ec826ab5fed","unit:1418230f2e85ee2956182e61095ff37e313248ce8a05294486c82dca38c720fc","unit:1a3643e025ae7e683ec6ccfc5d356fa6b58456d9489ef9775f5627c7654a805e","unit:23dedca299ce8c9197f5c587351099dee23bf7040b0d9aeb033d9214753759a2","unit:28f529ffb59d8b7e8b902728433926e07cdf0966fbe2f6b8b1b8c5cfcccfddf4","unit:424dbc9cee47ab69945a2ba5b656bc8478eb4aa22d07f841a4328929e69bf8a7","unit:528a022b18fe951a7de92d103e7fea429ab7053f93a36094b1d58c7d38d27927","unit:621efa310c3c1d6fd7b8adc8b97d48e5e66ec8bf55ce554bd7caafdeb635a6e3","unit:65035708d4cc84822a4fe3ae9198f79c5918903cc1d3ea2221cc9a0e8905d64d","unit:75e5cbfa138e302b2f839d61a898e9334b563deb3f606789cad50b7204dc8c07","unit:801178f25f4f0b10817c8c2efc4c411bff4728cd3b64ed401062085f7ef01d30","unit:8043929b434d969c6ddeabb5a89e2ec83ffb7d49cf84d592f46f756197e39092","unit:a7425bf08bc51b478f636dfda6ad9c5aeaf1705325509bbd76df72abe6da736e","unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","unit:ade71918e9da2c23020370c7a668029e2db0df2e0752da15f7bcf5eee43cad64","unit:ae7c62eceddadf1cd5dddf97d7ab88fb72cf7582553b726a2464e400369ccd96","unit:cc0e32d259fee5c4c3c26fc28d68f854a013fca4f74121ba20814f1734b05707","unit:e637915452c5efb2a97deaaed070f8aaaf3e2b690584ed05b07b202e1a6e8b20","unit:f34c63f75edb5ed676e5cb09d868b8344fbea9a9b8ddc8d5ec625889adc4a818"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5d349bd0fe32c666c4325643","scopeContentSha256":"f57f5b96bac2392fbc5fcb7f702fcbec03884d31538d2bf64797918e3ae37770","localRef":"s10"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b90c1d2a753bae902cd48f60","scopeContentSha256":"4a7f50a8790b7c1ba4ac291eb2659bc3b44405c66a89965bdc03cfcedf52713b","localRef":"s21"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l12","originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:17","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l12","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:17","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:b90c1d2a753bae902cd48f60","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:5d349bd0fe32c666c4325643","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l12","source":"s21","target":"s10","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Physical fluctuation analysis tests a specified amplitude after its constraints, boundary data and admissible modes have been identified."],"challengeStatement":"Fluctuation analysis tests a specified amplitude after constraints, boundary data and admissible modes are identified.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"925b3a06e0d58b1ad55d18ab053b1eb9d69cad6c9cf79f5e8c7018f776a6b930","reply.jsonSha256":"da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a6946727adefee7f3b2b748ff0c0ce5f0a58757e5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"135d367256f1c72fe01022ea832c9dc4f9f738e1d96ce8bf53734f13fe5f68e6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4b6e52d88ba3a909c203c07b3da236d98c0b1b281c2e2c6b7f3607b778bfda8b","normalization.jsonSha256":"6fd88b04991ddf39e7ff5092add083be8e384bafd3f19e71277cd6e2f088e477","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"05576f0db3fb5c595fb6d3897bf21da45667e0eb85b5e9a62f807106dd4fde78"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5765d539bf0f3099f1950f796691829e7f864cd76798b1bb052698baddfe718a","reply.jsonSha256":"0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c480e26d6cfc8a931b11cfe5472f4d19633a4fd55","reply.raw.txtSha256":"de1a8fb3eb5515d58d9c7ca2a9b788a8c9e65e1036945a6bf0722f302d37714a","receipt.jsonSha256":"758edf392c44cf3888db4d027ada99bb3d726b6d5f985600aba5ee4acc328beb","normalization.jsonSha256":"a617cbb678db447bcc5636be99fe70967c460f3c466178602875d90df3617927"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b90c1d2a753bae902cd48f60"},{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5d349bd0fe32c666c4325643"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b90c1d2a753bae902cd48f60"},{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:5d349bd0fe32c666c4325643"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d12","originalRef":"l12","status":"route","source":"s10","target":"s21","type":"method_for","title":"Analyze admissible fluctuations of a specified gravitational amplitude","rationale":"Physical fluctuation analysis supplies a method for testing a specified amplitude after its constraints and admissible perturbations are defined. The original method arrow reverses.","qualification":"Specify the amplitude, contour, gauge constraints, boundary terms and boundary conditions before interpreting modes. Retain fixed-charge or fixed-flux ensembles and distinguish asymptotically flat from positive-cosmological-constant backgrounds. Scalar and dual-form descriptions require their stated matching. Disagreement among calculations remains visible; neither a family-wide stability verdict nor an automatic contribution or exclusion follows, and perturbative modes are not identified with fragmentation into charged defects.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l12","s10","s21"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d12","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Physical fluctuation analysis supplies the method for examining an already specified amplitude, making s10 the correct source. The record preserves the required constraints, contours, ensembles and boundary data, along with disagreement among calculations and the distinction between perturbative stability and saddle contribution.","refs":["l12","s10","s21"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l12","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l13":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l13","source":"q025-candidate-question:779f0a1b4e7a47d76b4ddee6","target":"q025-candidate-question:b90c1d2a753bae902cd48f60","type":"application_of","title":"Examine continuation prescriptions underlying cosmological interpretations","rationale":"The continuation-based cosmological constructions in s14 apply the continuation and quantum-interpretation prescriptions examined by s21. The applied question therefore points to that underlying prescription question.","qualification":"Keep source-specific cuts, analytic continuations, boundary data, charge or dual-form prescriptions and contours explicit. Distinct continuations need not produce the same state or cosmology, and dS-like and singular branches remain distinct. A proposed interpretation does not establish a physical transition or UV completion. Endpoint classification alone remains an adjacent question and does not establish a wormhole construction.","evidenceIds":["unit:0b45baefe06facca719b975db6cd73f0db9327c7931f9ca1421f50069cb0bc8f","unit:0f61bc21dc3b5694ae5000973ea2a6044eabae8f544a4c92320a87498067ddb3","unit:129c3a5d43df14c7b9d1420495756470f0c59d2cc217ac0dfaaa5ec826ab5fed","unit:13ccd7b2a232a0d89c64147db7b1d68ec896844b2c5c94b278996ce09ba8030c","unit:1418230f2e85ee2956182e61095ff37e313248ce8a05294486c82dca38c720fc","unit:1a3643e025ae7e683ec6ccfc5d356fa6b58456d9489ef9775f5627c7654a805e","unit:23dedca299ce8c9197f5c587351099dee23bf7040b0d9aeb033d9214753759a2","unit:28f529ffb59d8b7e8b902728433926e07cdf0966fbe2f6b8b1b8c5cfcccfddf4","unit:424dbc9cee47ab69945a2ba5b656bc8478eb4aa22d07f841a4328929e69bf8a7","unit:528a022b18fe951a7de92d103e7fea429ab7053f93a36094b1d58c7d38d27927","unit:621efa310c3c1d6fd7b8adc8b97d48e5e66ec8bf55ce554bd7caafdeb635a6e3","unit:65035708d4cc84822a4fe3ae9198f79c5918903cc1d3ea2221cc9a0e8905d64d","unit:75e5cbfa138e302b2f839d61a898e9334b563deb3f606789cad50b7204dc8c07","unit:801178f25f4f0b10817c8c2efc4c411bff4728cd3b64ed401062085f7ef01d30","unit:8043929b434d969c6ddeabb5a89e2ec83ffb7d49cf84d592f46f756197e39092","unit:a7425bf08bc51b478f636dfda6ad9c5aeaf1705325509bbd76df72abe6da736e","unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","unit:ade71918e9da2c23020370c7a668029e2db0df2e0752da15f7bcf5eee43cad64","unit:e637915452c5efb2a97deaaed070f8aaaf3e2b690584ed05b07b202e1a6e8b20","unit:f34c63f75edb5ed676e5cb09d868b8344fbea9a9b8ddc8d5ec625889adc4a818","unit:f89e21c28d3de5bdb450bc237271b8822425b837f33c81a83b9c8b74675eaa5b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:779f0a1b4e7a47d76b4ddee6","scopeContentSha256":"12f4dda8ae184076594f76b2d692b5b7a848d7188604c497bb2ea9e20c719dc4","localRef":"s14"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b90c1d2a753bae902cd48f60","scopeContentSha256":"4a7f50a8790b7c1ba4ac291eb2659bc3b44405c66a89965bdc03cfcedf52713b","localRef":"s21"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l13","originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:19","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l13","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:19","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:b90c1d2a753bae902cd48f60","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:779f0a1b4e7a47d76b4ddee6","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l13","source":"s21","target":"s14","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Specified continuations motivate cosmological interpretations without establishing that every construction defines a physical transition."],"challengeStatement":"Specified continuations motivate cosmological interpretations without establishing a physical transition.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"925b3a06e0d58b1ad55d18ab053b1eb9d69cad6c9cf79f5e8c7018f776a6b930","reply.jsonSha256":"da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a6946727adefee7f3b2b748ff0c0ce5f0a58757e5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"135d367256f1c72fe01022ea832c9dc4f9f738e1d96ce8bf53734f13fe5f68e6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4b6e52d88ba3a909c203c07b3da236d98c0b1b281c2e2c6b7f3607b778bfda8b","normalization.jsonSha256":"6fd88b04991ddf39e7ff5092add083be8e384bafd3f19e71277cd6e2f088e477","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"05576f0db3fb5c595fb6d3897bf21da45667e0eb85b5e9a62f807106dd4fde78"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5765d539bf0f3099f1950f796691829e7f864cd76798b1bb052698baddfe718a","reply.jsonSha256":"0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c480e26d6cfc8a931b11cfe5472f4d19633a4fd55","reply.raw.txtSha256":"de1a8fb3eb5515d58d9c7ca2a9b788a8c9e65e1036945a6bf0722f302d37714a","receipt.jsonSha256":"758edf392c44cf3888db4d027ada99bb3d726b6d5f985600aba5ee4acc328beb","normalization.jsonSha256":"a617cbb678db447bcc5636be99fe70967c460f3c466178602875d90df3617927"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b90c1d2a753bae902cd48f60"},{"ref":"x3_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:779f0a1b4e7a47d76b4ddee6"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b90c1d2a753bae902cd48f60"},{"ref":"x3_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:779f0a1b4e7a47d76b4ddee6"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d13","originalRef":"l13","status":"route","source":"s14","target":"s21","type":"application_of","title":"Examine continuation prescriptions underlying cosmological interpretations","rationale":"The continuation-based cosmological constructions in s14 apply the continuation and quantum-interpretation prescriptions examined by s21. The applied question therefore points to that underlying prescription question.","qualification":"Keep source-specific cuts, analytic continuations, boundary data, charge or dual-form prescriptions and contours explicit. Distinct continuations need not produce the same state or cosmology, and dS-like and singular branches remain distinct. A proposed interpretation does not establish a physical transition or UV completion. Endpoint classification alone remains an adjacent question and does not establish a wormhole construction.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l13","s14","s21"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d13","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The continuation-based cosmological interpretations are the applications, while s21 examines their underlying continuation and amplitude prescriptions. The qualification preserves source-specific cuts and state choices, excludes an established physical transition, and keeps endpoint classification adjacent rather than treating it as a wormhole construction.","refs":["l13","s14","s21"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l13","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l14":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l14","source":"q025-candidate-question:c5001239beec0eba7d0e3af5","target":"q025-candidate-question:2c78e415731e9932afb29e16","type":"method_for","title":"Use field-theory and replica models to diagnose wormhole correlations","rationale":"The explicit field theories and replica constructions provide the diagnostic settings identified by both statements for relevant wormhole and factorization questions. The method arrow reverses.","qualification":"Apply diagnostics only within the specified interacting models, messenger constructions, gauge integrations or nongravitational analogues. Analogue behavior does not establish a gravitational dual. Direct boundary interactions and messenger couplings remain distinct, and interacting source functionals do not violate a decoupled-boundary factorization requirement. These settings do not prove the higher-dimensional Baby Universe Hypothesis or provide a general microscopic factorization solution; Lorentzian continuations require separate assessment.","evidenceIds":["unit:02487ffbfaa1639114abe79b01d1f27711505763f1886bef0a175768f9cc6e51","unit:090cbdc6d29e8048b346e64b14ebcfb8a7d71bfe243f3ee15abcf03fc5fda785","unit:185ac8d73d64d28130a2008434e05b4be603a2c03aeea7a61f298708e915bba1","unit:225bb5564b3448903eabe2bade8a2950f3377db1c685e2fafc024453837ae79d","unit:937a839e6c9217f54a37897970aa11b2aba3c4a4cd2ab87e063e02c31ba89bf4","unit:ab4d5964f21e057598e3727b0135bb430008abce29b2fa2e26011ea3e20a071a","unit:be2afdcb59bdd216567312c261cb60318d99e7907fa4d784b86b303641c53cb0","unit:c7d304613e27bf90398366fc2a9fbf41fa164ffdb0213bfbe4132df5b2956deb","unit:c942b222e9151c78f137a29bf4560d99c9b0faf6e6b846f0c4d5fab6ad2b421a","unit:f8a66320e20078b9610988f61e9eafe307228febab163d634edccd8b01122509"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c5001239beec0eba7d0e3af5","scopeContentSha256":"8708611cfb5c59ca3dd56eba5d9357980bb13d58b51c8a37c585d053641d8144","localRef":"s24"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2c78e415731e9932afb29e16","scopeContentSha256":"ee74a12225f6de5b9168f30dccaa16e70ce86fe6bf4008764e2f344828adf1cb","localRef":"s4"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l14","originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:22","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l14","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge:link:22","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:2c78e415731e9932afb29e16","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:c5001239beec0eba7d0e3af5","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l14","source":"s4","target":"s24","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Explicit field theories and replica constructions supply diagnostic settings; analogues and interacting models retain their distinct status."],"challengeStatement":"Field theories and replica constructions provide diagnostic settings; interacting models and nongravitational analogues retain their distinct status.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"925b3a06e0d58b1ad55d18ab053b1eb9d69cad6c9cf79f5e8c7018f776a6b930","reply.jsonSha256":"da01f44d883f0f13964a9d1a6946727adefee7f3b2b748ff0c0ce5f0a58757e5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"135d367256f1c72fe01022ea832c9dc4f9f738e1d96ce8bf53734f13fe5f68e6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4b6e52d88ba3a909c203c07b3da236d98c0b1b281c2e2c6b7f3607b778bfda8b","normalization.jsonSha256":"6fd88b04991ddf39e7ff5092add083be8e384bafd3f19e71277cd6e2f088e477","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"05576f0db3fb5c595fb6d3897bf21da45667e0eb85b5e9a62f807106dd4fde78"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-22acaf11562af7482c1e-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5765d539bf0f3099f1950f796691829e7f864cd76798b1bb052698baddfe718a","reply.jsonSha256":"0b9a0ee7aea364fc9142a34c480e26d6cfc8a931b11cfe5472f4d19633a4fd55","reply.raw.txtSha256":"de1a8fb3eb5515d58d9c7ca2a9b788a8c9e65e1036945a6bf0722f302d37714a","receipt.jsonSha256":"758edf392c44cf3888db4d027ada99bb3d726b6d5f985600aba5ee4acc328beb","normalization.jsonSha256":"a617cbb678db447bcc5636be99fe70967c460f3c466178602875d90df3617927"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2c78e415731e9932afb29e16"},{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c5001239beec0eba7d0e3af5"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2c78e415731e9932afb29e16"},{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c5001239beec0eba7d0e3af5"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d14","originalRef":"l14","status":"route","source":"s24","target":"s4","type":"method_for","title":"Use field-theory and replica models to diagnose wormhole correlations","rationale":"The explicit field theories and replica constructions provide the diagnostic settings identified by both statements for relevant wormhole and factorization questions. The method arrow reverses.","qualification":"Apply diagnostics only within the specified interacting models, messenger constructions, gauge integrations or nongravitational analogues. Analogue behavior does not establish a gravitational dual. Direct boundary interactions and messenger couplings remain distinct, and interacting source functionals do not violate a decoupled-boundary factorization requirement. These settings do not prove the higher-dimensional Baby Universe Hypothesis or provide a general microscopic factorization solution; Lorentzian continuations require separate assessment.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l14","s24","s4"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d14","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify field theories and replicas as diagnostic settings, supporting s24 as the method source. The record preserves interacting-model and nongravitational-analogue status, distinguishes interacting correlations from decoupled-boundary factorization, and makes no general duality or factorization claim.","refs":["l14","s24","s4"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l14","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l15":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l15","source":"q025-candidate-question:100a9795ee0bcbce12bf1a62","target":"q025-candidate-question:503518828b60243ad6ef86db","type":"related_question","title":"Explore compact-object viability and observational tests","rationale":"Both statements connect proposed alternative geometries to viability and observational questions. They do not identify a shared construction sufficient to turn this motivation into a definite application relationship.","qualification":"Regular interiors, horizon replacement, horizonless objects and the broader compact-object or emission proposals retain their distinct scopes. A regular background does not establish formation, stability or a viable compact object. Proposed signatures and observational resemblance establish neither consistency nor detection. Light rings supply an ultracompactness criterion only where explicitly adopted.","evidenceIds":["unit:09e32bf03ec2c0ed02e8fad1a4032eb8b7ebd5c00482219bfc0cb4f1c3865e5a","unit:0fe5d862a2668ec807356286906e98d03ecb22315a1eb1253f2030f88d823f9e","unit:1d87c5e540ebb5be4750cfe437ea4ca055b2e70201854a17730b505c44c4dd37","unit:2c89ae25da30ab42add8e5f316dfd31db4358d8b2d936dc0591ee5960c1d59a2","unit:34ecdac73b4b2f2c2e3b282c2a8072b9f56bb7d5985bb9e0cf41a0ffa248537e","unit:44d06de4401805f7182a7bf86bb6932f58600d8625e45a21b67a358f696a94fb","unit:56873c30e0c3716ad16523bd178609285463c8cbba1edf05d462b2952e95906f","unit:576dc306e4137d4062854a319e419173c19bf889e64525f6b74866c36efcf4fa","unit:577da843774ab5910089e3d17a70b15ff00027c68599cea456a3d2476ea2d36b","unit:61b2332423529ebbfa888cade82bf134cae75d802bc45f2e3c8c1014b43737d8","unit:73eaf12b0b4b20ca9b32b5fa4b92324a79de7c01cf4c48e27cb92542eb8e154d","unit:7891a0fe9fc99af780ae9e4d762c33ed6f50962de523f5b2f89bb1155ea39b0c","unit:8cf5855318e785df20a65454566cae8ef46a5dca02601b319cb5944d246ba7ec","unit:9f985e632e53103d0ddf982e7721870dd2db7dcbf568fa4a8c1cfa4f336fd815","unit:a06ef0566b7bf0ef6cfdf565567c987eb597196d00fe6252fe5c338ca2c55709","unit:abb828b8ae67a447f50d0685a65da88323b873f555ed9acdfd98593ddc03fc28","unit:bc6be6e472bd166a34808efa4bcdd710888223f8366691104eb54788493adacd","unit:d99a727c0f8ae592c1fc2f6831ca28dab559d4412684ac7084302ae19df08d67","unit:de8041ddd7acec54d3f515d90e848e4e9dcad7b68bfe86be9a04e5ed380d4c0d","unit:eba41a449c52cda273339321940e923267180c27613d3af5a9895ec0c1195f0b","unit:f6f1bf740d256309ab685e93d52ff3e50c8d71cc12682b8868bd33de78bd26ae","unit:f8e2400a54d1536b58f4c7f5b9888ac9ce80b124a83d37becb3e417ed868a575","unit:fbf40b6d4807285c6bd7514cd39c5c1eada19fc21f9b5473f80f03e7584b8b04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:100a9795ee0bcbce12bf1a62","scopeContentSha256":"b8760c25e0400a709e29322e25aa3da19523a5e62a9fef3e342af51e741651bc","localRef":"s1"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:503518828b60243ad6ef86db","scopeContentSha256":"229c7fa1d5087fb81ab7a1cc1224287a3ffac1743b2ff46e28425f7c719aaa96","localRef":"s8"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l15","originalCandidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:22","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l15","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:22","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:100a9795ee0bcbce12bf1a62","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:503518828b60243ad6ef86db","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l15","source":"s1","target":"s8","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Proposed alternative geometries motivate compact-object viability and observational discriminants without establishing either."],"challengeStatement":"Alternative geometries motivate compact-object viability and observational questions without establishing a viable model or detection.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:100a9795ee0bcbce12bf1a62"},{"ref":"x3_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:503518828b60243ad6ef86db"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:100a9795ee0bcbce12bf1a62"},{"ref":"x3_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:503518828b60243ad6ef86db"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d15","originalRef":"l15","status":"route","source":"s1","target":"s8","type":"related_question","title":"Explore compact-object viability and observational tests","rationale":"Both statements connect proposed alternative geometries to viability and observational questions. They do not identify a shared construction sufficient to turn this motivation into a definite application relationship.","qualification":"Regular interiors, horizon replacement, horizonless objects and the broader compact-object or emission proposals retain their distinct scopes. A regular background does not establish formation, stability or a viable compact object. Proposed signatures and observational resemblance establish neither consistency nor detection. Light rings supply an ultracompactness criterion only where explicitly adopted.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l15","s1","s8"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d15","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The supplied reasoning establishes that alternative geometries motivate compact-object viability and observational questions, but identifies no particular construction being applied. Related_question preserves that useful connection without conflating regular interiors, horizonless objects and emission proposals or implying viability or detection.","refs":["l15","s1","s8"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l15","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l16":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l16","source":"q025-candidate-question:85a6b5a4f3bad4223cccb940","target":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34","type":"method_for","title":"Calculate thermodynamic corrections using variational and ensemble methods","rationale":"Variational principles, ensemble transformations and field redefinitions supply calculation routes for the corrected-thermodynamics question. The original arrow reverses.","qualification":"Require a usable background and the appropriate action, boundary conditions, renormalization scheme and ensemble. Added perturbations are predominantly first order; exact dependence on existing couplings applies only where established. Retain fixed temperature and angular velocity in the Kerr Euclidean calculation and matched AdS asymptotics where required. Rotating higher-derivative extensions need suitable known solutions. No universal unmodified entropy or temperature prescription, arbitrary corrected geometry or identification of action stationarity with physical extremality follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:151822cebd530bc89ef31bc2293f2213b585ebef17202aaa220318cf5d97b739","unit:1877ac824b12f923a22b9a1410a474675bcab4fcc7fee2a93c55f9d96742d23a","unit:1efd9f9c192ab47eb9d6b64ea349f9a6c0b2cf5d7672b12b7dafd61e379548a7","unit:25e50cf0d0c93ce5a51d4da0f884796d5145450e7798d5c79585492c25c5a652","unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","unit:3a270e0aeff8114e04b2252be47b23163f3375a232f890db0ae0c73850f08fe9","unit:3c106070bf074f6507e76f297d665fec11c195d39b6edf65e83ca0a5905723f8","unit:4eed395343818bfba203c6fb50a1692618ec3ad5b5c9c362928a4cb25d471ef7","unit:5311dc99f3430f7032763d85160d29683df4356ea8bdf483093010dd804882fd","unit:55793d616bd78fdb5fd72de6dd8be224c096f26641468c99c8869dad9ea3126e","unit:5c65d0cc3602f62da727f036ccdefaed1719e834b500725b75902f372f9d3e66","unit:5e772a318ef7be8c945f9d319d01674f0415ff74d9c34fc08b5bab13c69de57a","unit:5e8532e5d51877e6508933ce812aee19d40f5c30fc314fa643ab478e9470eb0a","unit:5ead4ae79a9f4c448d9f47daddc72047adc7d0385aa0c7a0aef9e117ce97a12c","unit:618c7476e9bd17d716b6730a0c83a5b14174deb00690e4bdd359630f74f131ed","unit:632375f47b6ebe7abe302950673fb2c489271d92fc2110cd14ac0990dcb709a5","unit:6686c0f595e92020810dcd791a1fc5ab5ee933267f487569b762fc37a24dbf96","unit:745f35375ebfb12aece3f15c491f2ecd90af4e669e1107e37754ca972cc5f180","unit:787534e2e35e019673c656715a983d3413316961ea455fd7e07a57627a3fe3dd","unit:7a51a318f853da645a4e7c073f452e8b31664afe3cf0f9fa153d19c330037177","unit:7f74ed53aa9e88488adf9350f6c34e4c409b716f24a0b2def99253e7842a7b56","unit:accfe2a19c4fb08ce0eb7fdd83f5012cde08774653f070f81705669e75537fb6","unit:b35ae44c6ba74a9966e60b6bc994be69e207b51b2d01e515329ee1674f058fcd","unit:b5505445a85f89950ba6f38d799d36a1a46dac4f03dffa2e386a69b4c2895fb8","unit:b58a3ad71c793111d5d8d7025b3a3347bcf56652af65c3684c18af99e2480f56","unit:b83d41617038331d16fae81216e62872b17f5b98219d20a94a085a90f61e26cb","unit:bb0076de91c75000347da475dde66347547beff9291ae679c16b5b82ddc329fe","unit:bb6e38375672c2460f470d98ff71dc7fab8eb1ac1065293d909e84faf63c58d7","unit:d4362492b6339b25a09c8fe17e66561967023cb288122938666ca4ff4d8fb342","unit:deb140f8a9d9eebacd7cd647cd5eda20c50b3319aac96e371ee35bee877f32e1","unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","unit:eb1997d2fb75c5bf865bea781a0327dc3e8bca4a01cd4d523428103d4c7c6c83","unit:f9459fa6a0698d7fb5eb5597ac1d3f3adcd0dacbbe7f34945a11fbe510d58ebc","unit:ff6e5c9f362ef2405a4c290978ce050944e9987a99ee38ce1ae9521bb42b2327"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:85a6b5a4f3bad4223cccb940","scopeContentSha256":"975e070e4ac1033db4eae7c0cac17b76ca7c607c9ab8d66563d24817319ca246","localRef":"s16"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34","scopeContentSha256":"71871b4049eae42d5a1f8261a512e9159784414b96da3dc46efe68e19792349a","localRef":"s12"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l16","originalCandidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:23","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l16","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:23","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:85a6b5a4f3bad4223cccb940","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l16","source":"s12","target":"s16","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Variational principles, ensembles and field redefinitions are calculation routes with their own boundary and perturbative assumptions."],"challengeStatement":"Variational principles, ensembles and field redefinitions offer calculation routes with specific boundary and perturbative assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34"},{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:85a6b5a4f3bad4223cccb940"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34"},{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:85a6b5a4f3bad4223cccb940"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d16","originalRef":"l16","status":"route","source":"s16","target":"s12","type":"method_for","title":"Calculate thermodynamic corrections using variational and ensemble methods","rationale":"Variational principles, ensemble transformations and field redefinitions supply calculation routes for the corrected-thermodynamics question. The original arrow reverses.","qualification":"Require a usable background and the appropriate action, boundary conditions, renormalization scheme and ensemble. Added perturbations are predominantly first order; exact dependence on existing couplings applies only where established. Retain fixed temperature and angular velocity in the Kerr Euclidean calculation and matched AdS asymptotics where required. Rotating higher-derivative extensions need suitable known solutions. No universal unmodified entropy or temperature prescription, arbitrary corrected geometry or identification of action stationarity with physical extremality follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l16","s16","s12"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d16","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The calculation methods reside in s16 and serve the thermodynamic targets of s12, so reversal is required. The record retains usable-background, boundary, ensemble and perturbative conditions, including the specified Kerr and AdS prescriptions and the conditional status of rotating extensions.","refs":["l16","s16","s12"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l16","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l17":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l17","source":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34","target":"q025-candidate-question:548e8e272fbc1348cec89487","type":"related_question","title":"Explore model-specific action-deformation response tests","rationale":"The paired statements establish a shared equilibrium-response calculation target. They do not identify s12 as an underlying method, and s9's explicit brane, string and additional-conjugate scope should not be silently assumed to be fully contained in s12's stated black-hole scope.","qualification":"Retain each model's thermodynamic definitions, dimension, matter sector, horizon limit and admissible parameters. Small constant corrections and cosmological-term deformations remain distinct; the latter need not be higher-derivative UV corrections. Keep deformation signs, fixed variables and matching conditions, including conical-deficit matching where relevant. These examples establish neither universal response identities nor a WGC conclusion from a chosen perturbation sign.","evidenceIds":["unit:05cd4f24969a052c34c8179054503d486871b3aed4b1e1a358d1eb5d420df862","unit:0702b8a1df85cd2f038bbf2cb02964037dd5c07a76a319b8f3fc3068e4beb9dc","unit:151822cebd530bc89ef31bc2293f2213b585ebef17202aaa220318cf5d97b739","unit:1877ac824b12f923a22b9a1410a474675bcab4fcc7fee2a93c55f9d96742d23a","unit:1efd9f9c192ab47eb9d6b64ea349f9a6c0b2cf5d7672b12b7dafd61e379548a7","unit:25e50cf0d0c93ce5a51d4da0f884796d5145450e7798d5c79585492c25c5a652","unit:2b3919215dc1fca229981ae3e7b23c3934cb596808b4edc4a419fc5185b8abaf","unit:316b6aba761439e7ba6e17cf62f24d43ea17ff33e0023bf9773e840882d386ba","unit:33c0d814c0b006cb08912b3f8bebb7b3656b611be8ea7d2b001ea9098c40936d","unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","unit:3a270e0aeff8114e04b2252be47b23163f3375a232f890db0ae0c73850f08fe9","unit:3c106070bf074f6507e76f297d665fec11c195d39b6edf65e83ca0a5905723f8","unit:3c6fe1a3fbb93d537c10542256e163cc61ec0d243746307a6a6053def1ad0966","unit:4f0d1fc376ea4ae4f6e4db123c48391a5a9dd5cb1e02ee44f763cb5d8973334c","unit:5311dc99f3430f7032763d85160d29683df4356ea8bdf483093010dd804882fd","unit:55793d616bd78fdb5fd72de6dd8be224c096f26641468c99c8869dad9ea3126e","unit:57a7a2acf4ccbf7274c833c50127cdbf73951f3ee6f2fcc4e268829fb231e490","unit:5c65d0cc3602f62da727f036ccdefaed1719e834b500725b75902f372f9d3e66","unit:5e772a318ef7be8c945f9d319d01674f0415ff74d9c34fc08b5bab13c69de57a","unit:5e8532e5d51877e6508933ce812aee19d40f5c30fc314fa643ab478e9470eb0a","unit:5ead4ae79a9f4c448d9f47daddc72047adc7d0385aa0c7a0aef9e117ce97a12c","unit:618c7476e9bd17d716b6730a0c83a5b14174deb00690e4bdd359630f74f131ed","unit:632375f47b6ebe7abe302950673fb2c489271d92fc2110cd14ac0990dcb709a5","unit:745f35375ebfb12aece3f15c491f2ecd90af4e669e1107e37754ca972cc5f180","unit:753eb80972aeb4eef8bed36c3cb2d5095c7adbe4b7dcf803204ab2b1475b8eba","unit:787534e2e35e019673c656715a983d3413316961ea455fd7e07a57627a3fe3dd","unit:7a51a318f853da645a4e7c073f452e8b31664afe3cf0f9fa153d19c330037177","unit:7f74ed53aa9e88488adf9350f6c34e4c409b716f24a0b2def99253e7842a7b56","unit:8645df96e1d5a104c77d9fd0bdb5a08073bfedec34d3951354a6e84eedbcadb4","unit:9a8af3668541b2fe297df0e6b321c5a00f6bf829c6daac0c9c5116444be5642b","unit:accfe2a19c4fb08ce0eb7fdd83f5012cde08774653f070f81705669e75537fb6","unit:b35ae44c6ba74a9966e60b6bc994be69e207b51b2d01e515329ee1674f058fcd","unit:b5505445a85f89950ba6f38d799d36a1a46dac4f03dffa2e386a69b4c2895fb8","unit:b58a3ad71c793111d5d8d7025b3a3347bcf56652af65c3684c18af99e2480f56","unit:b83d41617038331d16fae81216e62872b17f5b98219d20a94a085a90f61e26cb","unit:bafc4b56732941e2a932db04d2397cd6650889120d1309550cb23ff4059e06f8","unit:bb0076de91c75000347da475dde66347547beff9291ae679c16b5b82ddc329fe","unit:bb6e38375672c2460f470d98ff71dc7fab8eb1ac1065293d909e84faf63c58d7","unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","unit:d4362492b6339b25a09c8fe17e66561967023cb288122938666ca4ff4d8fb342","unit:deb140f8a9d9eebacd7cd647cd5eda20c50b3319aac96e371ee35bee877f32e1","unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","unit:e8031fc404e3674cecf9260727208dd068349f5eaed7ca729a465c859af2255b","unit:eb1997d2fb75c5bf865bea781a0327dc3e8bca4a01cd4d523428103d4c7c6c83","unit:f9459fa6a0698d7fb5eb5597ac1d3f3adcd0dacbbe7f34945a11fbe510d58ebc","unit:ff6e5c9f362ef2405a4c290978ce050944e9987a99ee38ce1ae9521bb42b2327"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34","scopeContentSha256":"71871b4049eae42d5a1f8261a512e9159784414b96da3dc46efe68e19792349a","localRef":"s12"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:548e8e272fbc1348cec89487","scopeContentSha256":"7504376bc1b611ccb63d488cb2ac5b0d435901d138954db91fcde117c7789e55","localRef":"s9"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l17","originalCandidateId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge:link:23","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l17","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge:link:23","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:548e8e272fbc1348cec89487","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l17","source":"s12","target":"s9","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Specified action-deformation tests instantiate equilibrium response calculations without requiring every deformation to be a higher-derivative operator."],"challengeStatement":"Action-deformation tests instantiate equilibrium calculations; a cosmological-term deformation need not be a higher-derivative UV correction.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"84c78c62088892b814b68e32c00b71cb44c811e155e03704c869635c02ad60df","reply.jsonSha256":"556603e974a55e8c5927e97fb726622a468d8f112662207e6a08bc0646e43789","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7b38215c12856c8ed885f6428d00f8188a7f89226128f05da080faf2d6792223","receipt.jsonSha256":"e560951e4131a6965c2ba42042f6313b94d08d1f6694451859d5e1f5c63c2050","normalization.jsonSha256":"f3d0459f84b1374a8cadff1057734609b239a1a8c72d3aed44940ebdd51e1ce5","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"d3c8e8b718e7a870eb88a75140444059ccd9d19dca9ec0cb0dfff5c1cfebf466"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"97edd783afd94e77249a9c8387f811508d82091ef1bcf206c36283c8face47a0","reply.jsonSha256":"cdb6a30f0ff898fa6ea97136abb7ea0089e9389e35852e43f10fe2f3db761849","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7495a97ce30109a98279c8ccf8f3d1dab60248a70f6e0c64d9e999d9e3b6f072","receipt.jsonSha256":"2c33f5695d3da5b90ebbb19c4d6d8cc1049f0f09c72f9fd45d205ed8ff0552fe","normalization.jsonSha256":"fcc3c1dfd4aaca584c2d99d78344a028a34a99c7080baf41b099b8f773b50f91"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34"},{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:548e8e272fbc1348cec89487"},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"2507.19800","sourceId":"ev:e5191284c0d57beba945aba537906dea","sourceSha256":"c1ef35e7f67d1fea7509dd1ec22f767d96fb4a96100c5fdfdc8b9a02d2913f9b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/63ddb5c181e765b6ecef/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32366865050156cd44288469f6fbc8042252848935c3a0aef8b491e202536c66","pdfPage":2,"start":1288,"end":4684,"textSha256":"c70e15f36b9ef9e1b4c75790222242640f5953388e1834e4172608e4c3cfbef2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:75146882cc70098975962e34"},{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:548e8e272fbc1348cec89487"},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"2507.19800","sourceId":"ev:e5191284c0d57beba945aba537906dea","sourceSha256":"c1ef35e7f67d1fea7509dd1ec22f767d96fb4a96100c5fdfdc8b9a02d2913f9b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/63ddb5c181e765b6ecef/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32366865050156cd44288469f6fbc8042252848935c3a0aef8b491e202536c66","pdfPage":2,"start":1288,"end":4684,"textSha256":"c70e15f36b9ef9e1b4c75790222242640f5953388e1834e4172608e4c3cfbef2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d17","originalRef":"l17","status":"route","source":"s12","target":"s9","type":"related_question","title":"Explore model-specific action-deformation response tests","rationale":"The paired statements establish a shared equilibrium-response calculation target. They do not identify s12 as an underlying method, and s9's explicit brane, string and additional-conjugate scope should not be silently assumed to be fully contained in s12's stated black-hole scope.","qualification":"Retain each model's thermodynamic definitions, dimension, matter sector, horizon limit and admissible parameters. Small constant corrections and cosmological-term deformations remain distinct; the latter need not be higher-derivative UV corrections. Keep deformation signs, fixed variables and matching conditions, including conical-deficit matching where relevant. These examples establish neither universal response identities nor a WGC conclusion from a chosen perturbation sign.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l17","s12","s9"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d17","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The originals establish a shared equilibrium-response target without making s12 an underlying method. The explicit brane, string and additional-conjugate content of s9 also prevents assuming complete containment. Related_question retains the connection and preserves the distinction between cosmological-term deformations and higher-derivative UV corrections.","refs":["l17","s12","s9"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l17","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l18":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l18","source":"q025-candidate-question:548e8e272fbc1348cec89487","target":"q025-candidate-question:ce879b7bedfc19489460b0f6","type":"application_of","title":"Inspect the entropy-response framework used by model tests","rationale":"The model-specific tests in s9 apply the entropy–extremality response ideas examined by s25, so the application arrow reverses.","qualification":"Each test retains its first law, constraints, fixed variables, deformation direction and admissible parameter domain. Preserve near-extremal limiting subtleties and distinguish fixed-quantity entropy response from entropy at exactly corrected zero temperature. Positivity is an additional conditional claim: the stated tree-level argument requires thermodynamic stability, dominant massive-field tree contributions and an applicable EFT window. AdS positivity and relevant renormalization conventions remain conditional and source-specific; flat-space decay reasoning does not automatically transfer to AdS. Collected examples prove neither universality nor the WGC.","evidenceIds":["unit:05cd4f24969a052c34c8179054503d486871b3aed4b1e1a358d1eb5d420df862","unit:0702b8a1df85cd2f038bbf2cb02964037dd5c07a76a319b8f3fc3068e4beb9dc","unit:2b3919215dc1fca229981ae3e7b23c3934cb596808b4edc4a419fc5185b8abaf","unit:316b6aba761439e7ba6e17cf62f24d43ea17ff33e0023bf9773e840882d386ba","unit:33c0d814c0b006cb08912b3f8bebb7b3656b611be8ea7d2b001ea9098c40936d","unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","unit:3c6fe1a3fbb93d537c10542256e163cc61ec0d243746307a6a6053def1ad0966","unit:43527b6acc9949962f85a2cb17ce8564be00d0dc88fcfe207376f9f97b0abc53","unit:4f0d1fc376ea4ae4f6e4db123c48391a5a9dd5cb1e02ee44f763cb5d8973334c","unit:57a7a2acf4ccbf7274c833c50127cdbf73951f3ee6f2fcc4e268829fb231e490","unit:753eb80972aeb4eef8bed36c3cb2d5095c7adbe4b7dcf803204ab2b1475b8eba","unit:8645df96e1d5a104c77d9fd0bdb5a08073bfedec34d3951354a6e84eedbcadb4","unit:88df84f42743eece8af1fa6e459123a00c600f2576ea257b282fa55b0c00f028","unit:9a8af3668541b2fe297df0e6b321c5a00f6bf829c6daac0c9c5116444be5642b","unit:b5505445a85f89950ba6f38d799d36a1a46dac4f03dffa2e386a69b4c2895fb8","unit:bafc4b56732941e2a932db04d2397cd6650889120d1309550cb23ff4059e06f8","unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581","unit:e8031fc404e3674cecf9260727208dd068349f5eaed7ca729a465c859af2255b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:548e8e272fbc1348cec89487","scopeContentSha256":"7504376bc1b611ccb63d488cb2ac5b0d435901d138954db91fcde117c7789e55","localRef":"s9"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ce879b7bedfc19489460b0f6","scopeContentSha256":"7cfbcb82b597338a887cd0f268575bbcef9fba749271efe0b55db5dcab394034","localRef":"s25"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l18","originalCandidateId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge:link:24","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l18","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge:link:24","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:ce879b7bedfc19489460b0f6","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:548e8e272fbc1348cec89487","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l18","source":"s25","target":"s9","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Model tests apply response ideas under their own first laws, fixed variables and admissible parameter ranges; examples do not prove universality."],"challengeStatement":"Model tests apply response ideas with their own first laws, constraints and parameter domains; collected examples do not prove universality.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"84c78c62088892b814b68e32c00b71cb44c811e155e03704c869635c02ad60df","reply.jsonSha256":"556603e974a55e8c5927e97fb726622a468d8f112662207e6a08bc0646e43789","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7b38215c12856c8ed885f6428d00f8188a7f89226128f05da080faf2d6792223","receipt.jsonSha256":"e560951e4131a6965c2ba42042f6313b94d08d1f6694451859d5e1f5c63c2050","normalization.jsonSha256":"f3d0459f84b1374a8cadff1057734609b239a1a8c72d3aed44940ebdd51e1ce5","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"d3c8e8b718e7a870eb88a75140444059ccd9d19dca9ec0cb0dfff5c1cfebf466"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"97edd783afd94e77249a9c8387f811508d82091ef1bcf206c36283c8face47a0","reply.jsonSha256":"cdb6a30f0ff898fa6ea97136abb7ea0089e9389e35852e43f10fe2f3db761849","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7495a97ce30109a98279c8ccf8f3d1dab60248a70f6e0c64d9e999d9e3b6f072","receipt.jsonSha256":"2c33f5695d3da5b90ebbb19c4d6d8cc1049f0f09c72f9fd45d205ed8ff0552fe","normalization.jsonSha256":"fcc3c1dfd4aaca584c2d99d78344a028a34a99c7080baf41b099b8f773b50f91"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ce879b7bedfc19489460b0f6"},{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:548e8e272fbc1348cec89487"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2507.19800","sourceId":"ev:6edba53eaca953c44f40b6a49c9b7fc0","sourceSha256":"c1ef35e7f67d1fea7509dd1ec22f767d96fb4a96100c5fdfdc8b9a02d2913f9b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/63ddb5c181e765b6ecef/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32366865050156cd44288469f6fbc8042252848935c3a0aef8b491e202536c66","pdfPage":2,"start":97,"end":3487,"textSha256":"ebd9ad5ebc71e9c5f26e80b204803f06b1ee57b533e6717c8ae06502014e7474","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ce879b7bedfc19489460b0f6"},{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:548e8e272fbc1348cec89487"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2507.19800","sourceId":"ev:6edba53eaca953c44f40b6a49c9b7fc0","sourceSha256":"c1ef35e7f67d1fea7509dd1ec22f767d96fb4a96100c5fdfdc8b9a02d2913f9b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/63ddb5c181e765b6ecef/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32366865050156cd44288469f6fbc8042252848935c3a0aef8b491e202536c66","pdfPage":2,"start":97,"end":3487,"textSha256":"ebd9ad5ebc71e9c5f26e80b204803f06b1ee57b533e6717c8ae06502014e7474","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"2507.19800","sourceId":"ev:e5191284c0d57beba945aba537906dea","sourceSha256":"c1ef35e7f67d1fea7509dd1ec22f767d96fb4a96100c5fdfdc8b9a02d2913f9b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/63ddb5c181e765b6ecef/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"32366865050156cd44288469f6fbc8042252848935c3a0aef8b491e202536c66","pdfPage":2,"start":1288,"end":4684,"textSha256":"c70e15f36b9ef9e1b4c75790222242640f5953388e1834e4172608e4c3cfbef2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d18","originalRef":"l18","status":"route","source":"s9","target":"s25","type":"application_of","title":"Inspect the entropy-response framework used by model tests","rationale":"The model-specific tests in s9 apply the entropy–extremality response ideas examined by s25, so the application arrow reverses.","qualification":"Each test retains its first law, constraints, fixed variables, deformation direction and admissible parameter domain. Preserve near-extremal limiting subtleties and distinguish fixed-quantity entropy response from entropy at exactly corrected zero temperature. Positivity is an additional conditional claim: the stated tree-level argument requires thermodynamic stability, dominant massive-field tree contributions and an applicable EFT window. AdS positivity and relevant renormalization conventions remain conditional and source-specific; flat-space decay reasoning does not automatically transfer to AdS. Collected examples prove neither universality nor the WGC.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l18","s9","s25"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d18","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The model tests apply entropy–extremality response ideas, so s9 correctly points to s25. The qualification preserves both statements' first-law, constraint, fixed-variable and parameter-domain limits while separating response identities from positivity assumptions, corrected-zero-temperature entropy and universal WGC claims.","refs":["l18","s9","s25"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l18","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l19":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l19","source":"q025-candidate-question:85a6b5a4f3bad4223cccb940","target":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","type":"method_for","title":"Use background-based methods for thermodynamic and ensemble questions","rationale":"The known-background, variational and ensemble methods in s16 serve the relevant equilibrium-calculation branches of s35. The method source is therefore s16.","qualification":"Applicability requires the specified background solution, action, boundaries and ensemble; it does not extend automatically to every transport, dynamical or spectral question in the region. Keep perturbative order, field basis, renormalization and Legendre transforms local to each method. Retain the Kerr fixed-variable prescription and matched AdS asymptotics where applicable. Static examples do not establish rotating extensions without suitable known solutions, and thermodynamics alone does not reconstruct arbitrary corrected geometry.","evidenceIds":["unit:151822cebd530bc89ef31bc2293f2213b585ebef17202aaa220318cf5d97b739","unit:4eed395343818bfba203c6fb50a1692618ec3ad5b5c9c362928a4cb25d471ef7","unit:5311dc99f3430f7032763d85160d29683df4356ea8bdf483093010dd804882fd","unit:55793d616bd78fdb5fd72de6dd8be224c096f26641468c99c8869dad9ea3126e","unit:5c65d0cc3602f62da727f036ccdefaed1719e834b500725b75902f372f9d3e66","unit:5ead4ae79a9f4c448d9f47daddc72047adc7d0385aa0c7a0aef9e117ce97a12c","unit:618c7476e9bd17d716b6730a0c83a5b14174deb00690e4bdd359630f74f131ed","unit:632375f47b6ebe7abe302950673fb2c489271d92fc2110cd14ac0990dcb709a5","unit:6686c0f595e92020810dcd791a1fc5ab5ee933267f487569b762fc37a24dbf96","unit:745f35375ebfb12aece3f15c491f2ecd90af4e669e1107e37754ca972cc5f180","unit:787534e2e35e019673c656715a983d3413316961ea455fd7e07a57627a3fe3dd","unit:b35ae44c6ba74a9966e60b6bc994be69e207b51b2d01e515329ee1674f058fcd","unit:b5505445a85f89950ba6f38d799d36a1a46dac4f03dffa2e386a69b4c2895fb8","unit:b83d41617038331d16fae81216e62872b17f5b98219d20a94a085a90f61e26cb","unit:bafc4b56732941e2a932db04d2397cd6650889120d1309550cb23ff4059e06f8","unit:bb0076de91c75000347da475dde66347547beff9291ae679c16b5b82ddc329fe","unit:deb140f8a9d9eebacd7cd647cd5eda20c50b3319aac96e371ee35bee877f32e1","unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","unit:eb1997d2fb75c5bf865bea781a0327dc3e8bca4a01cd4d523428103d4c7c6c83","unit:f9459fa6a0698d7fb5eb5597ac1d3f3adcd0dacbbe7f34945a11fbe510d58ebc"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:85a6b5a4f3bad4223cccb940","scopeContentSha256":"975e070e4ac1033db4eae7c0cac17b76ca7c607c9ab8d66563d24817319ca246","localRef":"s16"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","scopeContentSha256":"1123f220fa66dcfaf6d7e353a5cf057117c27fd54c0bd35da01fa61759e8d824","localRef":"s35"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l19","originalCandidateId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge:link:4","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l19","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge:link:4","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:85a6b5a4f3bad4223cccb940","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l19","source":"s35","target":"s16","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Methods for calculating thermodynamic changes and defining ensembles, retaining each method's background and boundary requirements."],"challengeStatement":"Background-based calculations and consistent ensembles provide a method route with source-specific action, boundary and solution requirements.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"84c78c62088892b814b68e32c00b71cb44c811e155e03704c869635c02ad60df","reply.jsonSha256":"556603e974a55e8c5927e97fb726622a468d8f112662207e6a08bc0646e43789","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7b38215c12856c8ed885f6428d00f8188a7f89226128f05da080faf2d6792223","receipt.jsonSha256":"e560951e4131a6965c2ba42042f6313b94d08d1f6694451859d5e1f5c63c2050","normalization.jsonSha256":"f3d0459f84b1374a8cadff1057734609b239a1a8c72d3aed44940ebdd51e1ce5","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"d3c8e8b718e7a870eb88a75140444059ccd9d19dca9ec0cb0dfff5c1cfebf466"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"97edd783afd94e77249a9c8387f811508d82091ef1bcf206c36283c8face47a0","reply.jsonSha256":"cdb6a30f0ff898fa6ea97136abb7ea0089e9389e35852e43f10fe2f3db761849","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7495a97ce30109a98279c8ccf8f3d1dab60248a70f6e0c64d9e999d9e3b6f072","receipt.jsonSha256":"2c33f5695d3da5b90ebbb19c4d6d8cc1049f0f09c72f9fd45d205ed8ff0552fe","normalization.jsonSha256":"fcc3c1dfd4aaca584c2d99d78344a028a34a99c7080baf41b099b8f773b50f91"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:85a6b5a4f3bad4223cccb940"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2211.09823","sourceId":"ev:9f71eae44a14e7af9dfda24155b17b1c","sourceSha256":"c25e0043042ce9f37305814091a2b82bda4c1403d75e0499c1f199e0d9c2b734","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b09109db9c5a2c1d73a6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"04f3cb7abec8c7ca0b120a26e7e4a00f90599682c9edabaa54b8d8f3a6ccec85","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1093,"textSha256":"d37629b84ddd6ab8cc8cc8d4aec4584cf6d3ec443263b8a49e610eff9a4e3e7e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:85a6b5a4f3bad4223cccb940"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2211.09823","sourceId":"ev:9f71eae44a14e7af9dfda24155b17b1c","sourceSha256":"c25e0043042ce9f37305814091a2b82bda4c1403d75e0499c1f199e0d9c2b734","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b09109db9c5a2c1d73a6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"04f3cb7abec8c7ca0b120a26e7e4a00f90599682c9edabaa54b8d8f3a6ccec85","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1093,"textSha256":"d37629b84ddd6ab8cc8cc8d4aec4584cf6d3ec443263b8a49e610eff9a4e3e7e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d19","originalRef":"l19","status":"route","source":"s16","target":"s35","type":"method_for","title":"Use background-based methods for thermodynamic and ensemble questions","rationale":"The known-background, variational and ensemble methods in s16 serve the relevant equilibrium-calculation branches of s35. The method source is therefore s16.","qualification":"Applicability requires the specified background solution, action, boundaries and ensemble; it does not extend automatically to every transport, dynamical or spectral question in the region. Keep perturbative order, field basis, renormalization and Legendre transforms local to each method. Retain the Kerr fixed-variable prescription and matched AdS asymptotics where applicable. Static examples do not establish rotating extensions without suitable known solutions, and thermodynamics alone does not reconstruct arbitrary corrected geometry.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l19","s16","s35"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d19","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Known-background and ensemble methods are supplied by s16, fixing the reversed method direction. Their use is confined to relevant equilibrium branches of s35, with action, solution, boundary and perturbative requirements retained rather than transferred to every response question in the region.","refs":["l19","s16","s35"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l19","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l20":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l20","source":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","target":"q025-candidate-question:e1dba049f825fb05cfbcef1e","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on transport and bound comparisons in charged branes","rationale":"Charged-brane transport and its conditional coefficient comparisons refine the region's explicit transport and consistency-test targets. The region is not a single transport mechanism being applied.","qualification":"Viscosity-to-entropy and DC conductivity bounds remain separate observables and branches. Charged AdS5, translation-breaking and hyperscaling-violating models retain different couplings, correction orders and extremal limits. AdS weak-gravity conditions are assumed only in the relevant comparison and supply no universal KSS implication. Transport branches without a WGC premise remain available, and compatible inequalities do not establish UV completion.","evidenceIds":["unit:1422bd111a28e986ed7b7959cab6d8d0ec9ad6b252e165b45c898011f0f96f1e","unit:629d04fe85ca39274546509257e00e686c1956ccc53b423eeafb5822c8d6269f","unit:6c420479f2d318c23f902042d25d93d051cc9b979241a1eb2f6a470f7d74778f","unit:92a363541e78a6e5da00bd6e656914347a516b8f7085cbe73305b5ddf2907689","unit:b83d41617038331d16fae81216e62872b17f5b98219d20a94a085a90f61e26cb","unit:bafc4b56732941e2a932db04d2397cd6650889120d1309550cb23ff4059e06f8","unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","scopeContentSha256":"1123f220fa66dcfaf6d7e353a5cf057117c27fd54c0bd35da01fa61759e8d824","localRef":"s35"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e1dba049f825fb05cfbcef1e","scopeContentSha256":"8902924334ed4547cc52217a80813a7d8b7f88ea4b1d9e614ce808e879b35a61","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l20","originalCandidateId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge:link:11","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l20","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge:link:11","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:e1dba049f825fb05cfbcef1e","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l20","source":"s35","target":"s30","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Charged-brane transport is a distinct application; viscosity and conductivity bounds retain separate premises."],"challengeStatement":"Charged-brane transport is a separate application; viscosity and conductivity comparisons retain different models and assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"84c78c62088892b814b68e32c00b71cb44c811e155e03704c869635c02ad60df","reply.jsonSha256":"556603e974a55e8c5927e97fb726622a468d8f112662207e6a08bc0646e43789","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7b38215c12856c8ed885f6428d00f8188a7f89226128f05da080faf2d6792223","receipt.jsonSha256":"e560951e4131a6965c2ba42042f6313b94d08d1f6694451859d5e1f5c63c2050","normalization.jsonSha256":"f3d0459f84b1374a8cadff1057734609b239a1a8c72d3aed44940ebdd51e1ce5","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"d3c8e8b718e7a870eb88a75140444059ccd9d19dca9ec0cb0dfff5c1cfebf466"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"97edd783afd94e77249a9c8387f811508d82091ef1bcf206c36283c8face47a0","reply.jsonSha256":"cdb6a30f0ff898fa6ea97136abb7ea0089e9389e35852e43f10fe2f3db761849","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7495a97ce30109a98279c8ccf8f3d1dab60248a70f6e0c64d9e999d9e3b6f072","receipt.jsonSha256":"2c33f5695d3da5b90ebbb19c4d6d8cc1049f0f09c72f9fd45d205ed8ff0552fe","normalization.jsonSha256":"fcc3c1dfd4aaca584c2d99d78344a028a34a99c7080baf41b099b8f773b50f91"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e1dba049f825fb05cfbcef1e"},{"ref":"c1","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e1dba049f825fb05cfbcef1e"},{"ref":"c1","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d20","originalRef":"l20","status":"route","source":"s35","target":"s30","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on transport and bound comparisons in charged branes","rationale":"Charged-brane transport and its conditional coefficient comparisons refine the region's explicit transport and consistency-test targets. The region is not a single transport mechanism being applied.","qualification":"Viscosity-to-entropy and DC conductivity bounds remain separate observables and branches. Charged AdS5, translation-breaking and hyperscaling-violating models retain different couplings, correction orders and extremal limits. AdS weak-gravity conditions are assumed only in the relevant comparison and supply no universal KSS implication. Transport branches without a WGC premise remain available, and compatible inequalities do not establish UV completion.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l20","s35","s30"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d20","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The complete charged-brane transport question falls within s35's stated systems, response targets and conditional consistency tests. Narrower therefore accurately replaces the application label. The qualification keeps viscosity, conductivity, model-dependent couplings and the conditional AdS WGC comparison distinct.","refs":["l20","s35","s30"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l20","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l21":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l21","source":"q025-candidate-question:e1dba049f825fb05cfbcef1e","target":"q025-candidate-question:fcf2a0e484eb9ce08d9a524a","type":"application_of","title":"Examine extremality and coupling constraints used in transport comparisons","rationale":"Where the transport question uses specified extremality or effective-coupling constraints, it applies the constraint analysis organized by s34. The application arrow reverses.","qualification":"This applies to the stated constraint-dependent comparisons, not automatically to every conductivity or viscosity branch. Preserve the model, derivative order, charge sector and any extremal limit. The relevant AdS WGC assumption is conditional and does not yield a universal KSS implication. Viscosity, conductivity and extremality bounds remain different observables, and compatibility among their inequalities does not demonstrate UV completion or a light superextremal particle.","evidenceIds":["unit:1422bd111a28e986ed7b7959cab6d8d0ec9ad6b252e165b45c898011f0f96f1e","unit:17bdc8a426ac6b6b065b7e1cb157370aeed8a77c52758b49a6330e9def3cfb56","unit:25b08e923faccd30417be78d70b65751bff47f9afa89ec8cc12f21cdd11b6aba","unit:276adf2e98150b2c186a8579dcc80deb499b90809192a919238990efea0089d6","unit:33795b828c5d509854c6ec3adce7eeee65ea986fb28dc301a1390891b2de3c71","unit:629d04fe85ca39274546509257e00e686c1956ccc53b423eeafb5822c8d6269f","unit:62b40ad157d793c9cc78f21fa8d1d19ae7adab53275014bd7e8a60c51b0b2171","unit:6c420479f2d318c23f902042d25d93d051cc9b979241a1eb2f6a470f7d74778f","unit:753eb80972aeb4eef8bed36c3cb2d5095c7adbe4b7dcf803204ab2b1475b8eba","unit:78f8c006ee532a8f2f71ede7991935e6ff0cb89fa0bd684233b37250ad31efaf","unit:92a363541e78a6e5da00bd6e656914347a516b8f7085cbe73305b5ddf2907689","unit:9f82c7e6ecaccd2d0c5e41eb0688af2055cabd987e8e27800b862e41a8704433","unit:b302e962d78c38c66e4c7b6b748fceb724c9457299310651bfa90dc64ce4190a","unit:c21c27956bcaf785e9e22220849c3b2ef508a04eee76456f52b4199d0422b106","unit:ce218425438c65ebef30f49a95be4b87b000be3b6c6c61929636bf176c29b581"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e1dba049f825fb05cfbcef1e","scopeContentSha256":"8902924334ed4547cc52217a80813a7d8b7f88ea4b1d9e614ce808e879b35a61","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fcf2a0e484eb9ce08d9a524a","scopeContentSha256":"c3ed9c10b816aad0ebeb5d60ff8326205681c8580cbd6f14e32493eeeee35781","localRef":"s34"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l21","originalCandidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:50","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l21","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:50","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:fcf2a0e484eb9ce08d9a524a","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:e1dba049f825fb05cfbcef1e","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l21","source":"s34","target":"s30","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Transport comparisons use specified coupling constraints without equating viscosity, conductivity and extremality bounds."],"challengeStatement":"Transport comparisons use specified coupling constraints; viscosity, conductivity and extremality bounds remain different observables.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fcf2a0e484eb9ce08d9a524a"},{"ref":"x1_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e1dba049f825fb05cfbcef1e"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fcf2a0e484eb9ce08d9a524a"},{"ref":"x1_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e1dba049f825fb05cfbcef1e"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d21","originalRef":"l21","status":"route","source":"s30","target":"s34","type":"application_of","title":"Examine extremality and coupling constraints used in transport comparisons","rationale":"Where the transport question uses specified extremality or effective-coupling constraints, it applies the constraint analysis organized by s34. The application arrow reverses.","qualification":"This applies to the stated constraint-dependent comparisons, not automatically to every conductivity or viscosity branch. Preserve the model, derivative order, charge sector and any extremal limit. The relevant AdS WGC assumption is conditional and does not yield a universal KSS implication. Viscosity, conductivity and extremality bounds remain different observables, and compatibility among their inequalities does not demonstrate UV completion or a light superextremal particle.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l21","s30","s34"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d21","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The originals explicitly connect transport comparisons to specified coupling constraints, supporting application from s30 to s34. The record limits that dependence to the relevant branches and preserves separate observables, models and AdS assumptions without deriving universal transport bounds or ultraviolet completion.","refs":["l21","s30","s34"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l21","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l22":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l22","source":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","target":"q025-candidate-question:e3d413fdb21c9ba9b200dbee","type":"related_question","title":"Explore distinct holographic and microscopic information","rationale":"The statements support a connection through black-hole entropy and holographic observables. They do not specify a single underlying method in s35, while s31 also contains independent AdS/CFT-information targets that preclude assuming full-scope containment from the shared topic.","qualification":"Kerr/CFT entropy, higher-curvature holographic observables and supersymmetric index comparisons retain their separate constructions and assumptions. A microscopic comparison need not be a derivative-correction calculation. BPS, extremal and zero-temperature limits are not identified across theories, and no universal holographic dual or equivalence among the CFT constructions is asserted.","evidenceIds":["unit:1877ac824b12f923a22b9a1410a474675bcab4fcc7fee2a93c55f9d96742d23a","unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","unit:61361651de21b4ad525bbed123aef27f493286d11b1c7237e1c1c296b136fb0d","unit:b5505445a85f89950ba6f38d799d36a1a46dac4f03dffa2e386a69b4c2895fb8","unit:b83d41617038331d16fae81216e62872b17f5b98219d20a94a085a90f61e26cb","unit:bafc4b56732941e2a932db04d2397cd6650889120d1309550cb23ff4059e06f8","unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","unit:f9459fa6a0698d7fb5eb5597ac1d3f3adcd0dacbbe7f34945a11fbe510d58ebc"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","scopeContentSha256":"1123f220fa66dcfaf6d7e353a5cf057117c27fd54c0bd35da01fa61759e8d824","localRef":"s35"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e3d413fdb21c9ba9b200dbee","scopeContentSha256":"e92f2b3a97f08ffba1b9b9641b58966e325013d153a203214047ef10a178e837","localRef":"s31"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l22","originalCandidateId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge:link:7","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l22","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge:link:7","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:e3d413fdb21c9ba9b200dbee","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l22","source":"s35","target":"s31","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Holographic and microscopic information is an application with its own targets and source-specific constructions."],"challengeStatement":"Holographic and microscopic information has its own observables and construction-specific assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"84c78c62088892b814b68e32c00b71cb44c811e155e03704c869635c02ad60df","reply.jsonSha256":"556603e974a55e8c5927e97fb726622a468d8f112662207e6a08bc0646e43789","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7b38215c12856c8ed885f6428d00f8188a7f89226128f05da080faf2d6792223","receipt.jsonSha256":"e560951e4131a6965c2ba42042f6313b94d08d1f6694451859d5e1f5c63c2050","normalization.jsonSha256":"f3d0459f84b1374a8cadff1057734609b239a1a8c72d3aed44940ebdd51e1ce5","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"d3c8e8b718e7a870eb88a75140444059ccd9d19dca9ec0cb0dfff5c1cfebf466"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"97edd783afd94e77249a9c8387f811508d82091ef1bcf206c36283c8face47a0","reply.jsonSha256":"cdb6a30f0ff898fa6ea97136abb7ea0089e9389e35852e43f10fe2f3db761849","reply.raw.txtSha256":"7495a97ce30109a98279c8ccf8f3d1dab60248a70f6e0c64d9e999d9e3b6f072","receipt.jsonSha256":"2c33f5695d3da5b90ebbb19c4d6d8cc1049f0f09c72f9fd45d205ed8ff0552fe","normalization.jsonSha256":"fcc3c1dfd4aaca584c2d99d78344a028a34a99c7080baf41b099b8f773b50f91"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e3d413fdb21c9ba9b200dbee"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceId":"ev:713fb43ca7fd96fd919ec46895f6027a","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":0,"end":2881,"textSha256":"fad42dabc3103931820ed5b6950fd27cc8cd4b2de969bf275e28435904a81c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e3d413fdb21c9ba9b200dbee"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceId":"ev:713fb43ca7fd96fd919ec46895f6027a","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":0,"end":2881,"textSha256":"fad42dabc3103931820ed5b6950fd27cc8cd4b2de969bf275e28435904a81c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d22","originalRef":"l22","status":"route","source":"s35","target":"s31","type":"related_question","title":"Explore distinct holographic and microscopic information","rationale":"The statements support a connection through black-hole entropy and holographic observables. They do not specify a single underlying method in s35, while s31 also contains independent AdS/CFT-information targets that preclude assuming full-scope containment from the shared topic.","qualification":"Kerr/CFT entropy, higher-curvature holographic observables and supersymmetric index comparisons retain their separate constructions and assumptions. A microscopic comparison need not be a derivative-correction calculation. BPS, extremal and zero-temperature limits are not identified across theories, and no universal holographic dual or equivalence among the CFT constructions is asserted.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l22","s35","s31"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d22","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The supplied connection concerns entropy and holographic information, but identifies no single underlying construction being applied. Independent AdS/CFT-information targets and s35's qualified treatment of neighboring holographic systems make full containment unwarranted. The related route preserves the distinct Kerr/CFT, higher-curvature and index-comparison questions.","refs":["l22","s35","s31"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l22","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l23":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l23","source":"q025-candidate-question:d7cfd84ab75ca68b9aaf0862","target":"q025-candidate-question:a0b81ad3358ecff3e0f1c4ad","type":"application_of","title":"Inspect spectral calculations underlying proposed lifetime tests","rationale":"The proposed EFT lifetime analysis uses frequency and damping calculations from the spectral question, with an additional adopted criterion. The applied lifetime question therefore points to the underlying spectral analysis.","qualification":"Coefficient restrictions require the stated no-resolvable-lifetime-increase criterion and resolvability prescription; spectral calculations alone do not supply them. Retain the background, field, perturbation sector, EFT order, boundary conditions and any near-extremal or zero-damping limit. Test-field and coupled perturbations, and quasinormal and quasibound spectra, are not interchangeable. Neither selected-mode behavior nor matching coefficient combinations establishes universal stability, equivalence with the WGC or equivalence with Minkowski-amplitude constraints.","evidenceIds":["unit:2cffb9faa09377ebdb32ba5c63683b146eb96e11aeb144b60b3ac3fc4bd423ae","unit:5783724fc808522c2af61b13b75cf4729a590d52ffb40088d43573abb197d4c6","unit:57a520d44c6bd952114b2e391f5cd050b4b691aa8d77bd85e885a9ef8c3ac69c","unit:6c9b99404221e9a3f9f6a31fd5345f7e6f40f9cdfe0fc8bc88457e067defde70","unit:7bf4bd3a8935302c15057334958e89cdfed7cf4a5930f6a2ba758513eec88130","unit:96345e5537d3fa14fa15466b4ef26f326e9d1c7940b690d795c546484ca5e3e2","unit:d39ec96e47b495cb46c0adbd42b4804910fdc2511938c586a37113fbf9da13ef","unit:d3f5b55db4a44f1242a1e7d55aa8537cef7c92ac8fdf3ab106110092aee93643","unit:d7329c96948bb1c45bad844bb1e9569b94ff66c1afd943be70e980acc24a4f2d","unit:d8efc3c113d9682ae66c3f4f2a4291e4ae73e03ca649880fde809a5da49d2d12","unit:df55ebc8a474485011f53ee5b3441b949228d4863fe885a7baea3ea4b38b809a","unit:e6ce3f18a14b5e0eb1725a359560ab382c0a255321929818db9d3c384a9e2f5e","unit:f2107ba4391515831703f47d5d2f16773f60be9737f4c55764ce5ceeb6fd5603","unit:fbc21f1bbe6b9d93460c81b998bfdeec6d15061b26c6abe7a25b081bb1691970"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d7cfd84ab75ca68b9aaf0862","scopeContentSha256":"ade70551942fdf5bcb6dc5497719cca22e88b781eeba73f303883f3c4395b4d3","localRef":"s28"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a0b81ad3358ecff3e0f1c4ad","scopeContentSha256":"6df3923f3faa1e43076915b4d67d3cc2e2721e960efe39e562490a50580c1829","localRef":"s18"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l23","originalCandidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:39","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l23","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:39","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:a0b81ad3358ecff3e0f1c4ad","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:d7cfd84ab75ca68b9aaf0862","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l23","source":"s18","target":"s28","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["EFT frequency shifts enter proposed lifetime constraints only with an additional adopted criterion."],"challengeStatement":"EFT frequency shifts enter lifetime constraints only with an additional adopted criterion and resolvability prescription.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a0b81ad3358ecff3e0f1c4ad"},{"ref":"x1_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d7cfd84ab75ca68b9aaf0862"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a0b81ad3358ecff3e0f1c4ad"},{"ref":"x1_9","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d7cfd84ab75ca68b9aaf0862"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d23","originalRef":"l23","status":"route","source":"s28","target":"s18","type":"application_of","title":"Inspect spectral calculations underlying proposed lifetime tests","rationale":"The proposed EFT lifetime analysis uses frequency and damping calculations from the spectral question, with an additional adopted criterion. The applied lifetime question therefore points to the underlying spectral analysis.","qualification":"Coefficient restrictions require the stated no-resolvable-lifetime-increase criterion and resolvability prescription; spectral calculations alone do not supply them. Retain the background, field, perturbation sector, EFT order, boundary conditions and any near-extremal or zero-damping limit. Test-field and coupled perturbations, and quasinormal and quasibound spectra, are not interchangeable. Neither selected-mode behavior nor matching coefficient combinations establishes universal stability, equivalence with the WGC or equivalence with Minkowski-amplitude constraints.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l23","s28","s18"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d23","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The lifetime tests use spectral frequency and damping calculations, supporting the application direction from s28 to s18. The record preserves the additional adopted criterion and resolvability prescription, along with background, mode, boundary and EFT restrictions, without identifying spectral results with universal causality or WGC principles.","refs":["l23","s28","s18"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l23","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l24":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l24","source":"q025-candidate-region:8574187d747387068f02fe63","target":"q025-candidate-question:377c1312908bf36a9fc734a9","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on mediation, visible soft spectra and hidden-sector transmission","rationale":"The mediation and soft-spectrum question refines s38's explicit supersymmetry-breaking transmission, mass and cosmological targets. It is a scoped branch rather than an application of one common parent mechanism.","qualification":"Observable visible-sector soft masses remain distinct from masses in a condensing stabilization sector. Keep warped, local LARGE-volume and fluxless G2 assumptions separate, together with leading versus subleading terms and joint versus sequential stabilization and breaking. Locality or separation alone does not establish sequestering, and comparable mediation contributions do not establish gauge dominance. No common normalization, universal viable spectrum or current validation of historical forecasts is supplied.","evidenceIds":["unit:7470d0e34f69e9dc5633603fabbbcb83768c8ac5eab46053e9f55dfd06a2c1c3","unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","unit:a3b7823d6c82542b388bee53058edfc5cd3c2259fd27cfcd25cf06901fe8a04d","unit:b02dd5da03e89341008454d102255db0844b4a1d44b6bee2aa18a2d4881ac3ae","unit:ba2db2d76dd6ce5790bb60ec53801f7a3dcc9b3b31008a748cc4b2135a5fc45f","unit:ecec83bd62de4b786661045f9ea61d3f60c54f643435bed0f7866528ed39d06f","unit:f4aca86d28221e1908f1020562113b6e5b302b2bf0c96f02d6278286d5965162","unit:f99f7bf5f8c60b89408bc8c1b0adfdb96c577a2d8e02f6a67d19b1dfab159b71"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:8574187d747387068f02fe63","scopeContentSha256":"f09de89ad17b314d53c57c60d1ffb7ff3e77cdd6ea7ef20e64644f897046a079","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:377c1312908bf36a9fc734a9","scopeContentSha256":"7fccfebc21cbee0e57ae9aa921f4b3834354eb8e37bdddd3db1d4c38c07c128a","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l24","originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:10","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l24","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:10","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:8574187d747387068f02fe63","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:377c1312908bf36a9fc734a9","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l24","source":"s38","target":"s5","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Routes supersymmetry-breaking transmission and observable soft spectra separately from stabilization-sector gaugino masses."],"challengeStatement":"Supersymmetry-breaking transmission and observable spectra have distinct targets from masses in a condensing stabilization sector.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"06eb6ab0b33d70ca488cba5574a9f088537d6f8995d7fe73a3723bac7b4629aa","reply.jsonSha256":"6c4d8c637b56232f0059109accce5f4bb0da0cbe4f45a0b1b81e46f9ac15f5cd","reply.raw.txtSha256":"cd67e7475590018355f77f32db96f4e6173f5fcca932905f15c9e4a775a45e06","receipt.jsonSha256":"96638c1db28963568fd216349473bcd081260d81b680cb511b9d595a1ccec349","normalization.jsonSha256":"eb13b5dcabb5eec20b63b3afb9b4c18c51aad00ca59c36865b0b01c0a85f67ab","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"453e9ec7e0df401d2fc7d51fa6e66e90d910976ea3a59d5dafaf142a73028e24"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3bdb9c1c5751351855447f699c81fe757b058f1a6ffc6b0a98df8ec571386dc4","reply.jsonSha256":"c0a78737eed75e2d99cca34f139ca0b2e8ddf4117c71b0f6a33ec1f1741d0197","reply.raw.txtSha256":"360ce47b505d70e79a42d86acaa4dc3fff0f2c26104cdbc5e598b0f45f7c54ed","receipt.jsonSha256":"27ea02f046fa52fc6800f6ca65031ee07f8788c77eec2133e59b7f4edd75aa40","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e407582e9fb73504a9bd6033318997b8efdb43c85931a162f6149af146cc15d"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:377c1312908bf36a9fc734a9"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"2211.14381","sourceId":"ev:0d51acaf33f6d9d0b64f30268b3089f7","sourceSha256":"1eb3f555289798d8d6970ad87bfe88c815aee2ec665703293937a928e91e2d43","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0ec6bdc58f819a0241f0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a6fc3c7b101b72b64662d35ce1d5ad86e34bd34737bb14f7dba54c58916eae73","pdfPage":3,"start":89,"end":3189,"textSha256":"f3554987f126f4786e6b494b57ee3b6a8d1c2705d10dfae0a9c81d3e43071869","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:377c1312908bf36a9fc734a9"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"2211.14381","sourceId":"ev:0d51acaf33f6d9d0b64f30268b3089f7","sourceSha256":"1eb3f555289798d8d6970ad87bfe88c815aee2ec665703293937a928e91e2d43","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0ec6bdc58f819a0241f0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a6fc3c7b101b72b64662d35ce1d5ad86e34bd34737bb14f7dba54c58916eae73","pdfPage":3,"start":89,"end":3189,"textSha256":"f3554987f126f4786e6b494b57ee3b6a8d1c2705d10dfae0a9c81d3e43071869","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d24","originalRef":"l24","status":"route","source":"s38","target":"s5","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on mediation, visible soft spectra and hidden-sector transmission","rationale":"The mediation and soft-spectrum question refines s38's explicit supersymmetry-breaking transmission, mass and cosmological targets. It is a scoped branch rather than an application of one common parent mechanism.","qualification":"Observable visible-sector soft masses remain distinct from masses in a condensing stabilization sector. Keep warped, local LARGE-volume and fluxless G2 assumptions separate, together with leading versus subleading terms and joint versus sequential stabilization and breaking. Locality or separation alone does not establish sequestering, and comparable mediation contributions do not establish gauge dominance. No common normalization, universal viable spectrum or current validation of historical forecasts is supplied.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l24","s38","s5"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d24","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Mediation, visible spectra and their cosmological consequences refine s38's explicit transmission, mass and evolution targets. The narrower route preserves the originals' distinction from condensing-sector masses and keeps warped, LARGE-volume and G2 assumptions, sequestering tests and mediation requirements separate.","refs":["l24","s38","s5"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l24","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l25":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l25","source":"q025-candidate-region:8574187d747387068f02fe63","target":"q025-candidate-question:af0fda4fb4fdec799df95524","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on evolving moduli, inflation and quintessence","rationale":"The moduli-cosmology question refines the region's explicit rolling, thermal and cosmological-evolution targets. Its dynamical requirements extend beyond checking a static vacuum.","qualification":"Inflation, backreaction, quintessence, overshoot, background-fluid capture and thermal or time-dependent stabilization remain different source-specific problems. Static light-field models and evolving internal moduli are not identified with static de Sitter minima. Canonical normalization, retained-sector stability and assumed hierarchies require model-specific checks. Observational comparisons retain their dates and do not establish an extended model's fit or a complete cosmological history.","evidenceIds":["unit:168d83055a347476f8e232bd4812ff9b75a8f20f149fcf1e5d641e10531deee3","unit:3267740f211252bd12f44b0c848cf418e59f929650f231d45f4371bc63b44ec4","unit:556f2d74f08a4c051743903dd4413c0a6bc453d30c0a8ec50d2fcdb3458d928f","unit:7470d0e34f69e9dc5633603fabbbcb83768c8ac5eab46053e9f55dfd06a2c1c3","unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","unit:82c2356213daa2cc05ebfeec1340610d0f56380865440191070602637534dcb8","unit:a3b7823d6c82542b388bee53058edfc5cd3c2259fd27cfcd25cf06901fe8a04d","unit:ac833f8a2f16c94da090aea819f0f62d4bb59337f7e6789791dbf86698634146","unit:b57c9bc5d6be70d25d3db9ba5138f812c031eb70dce48eb097b514770d934b7d","unit:c496b0f57a26cf707360727607563458edc3af780062af2b4660dc963c7257ec","unit:d8339891c0adf5f5a935f3364bd8694b02ee5fffc61060ea729ba383426f0989","unit:e82ee7314c0e5c1fcc3ba4c3f7ad207563242313370efe3a73d243ae2cf0ce67","unit:ecec83bd62de4b786661045f9ea61d3f60c54f643435bed0f7866528ed39d06f","unit:ee857c660a5b30359c367b74ceb16dea3faaaeab51c61e2c4961458169a6569e","unit:f4aca86d28221e1908f1020562113b6e5b302b2bf0c96f02d6278286d5965162","unit:f99f7bf5f8c60b89408bc8c1b0adfdb96c577a2d8e02f6a67d19b1dfab159b71","unit:fe7692d6999bd72a2d7a120642d14a6e7991ffc9d7a970dc9e23d662bd49ed66","unit:ff063daf73b247c772af73e6822e6dcd4396e7e5ba3da722089e5bad92d04cf8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:8574187d747387068f02fe63","scopeContentSha256":"f09de89ad17b314d53c57c60d1ffb7ff3e77cdd6ea7ef20e64644f897046a079","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:af0fda4fb4fdec799df95524","scopeContentSha256":"52ee5874b797f882c60aec085816ebf334fa97ba75ab80622e3ad0fe650bd375","localRef":"s19"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l25","originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:11","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l25","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:11","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:8574187d747387068f02fe63","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:af0fda4fb4fdec799df95524","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l25","source":"s38","target":"s19","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Routes evolving moduli, inflation and quintessence without treating them as static de Sitter minima."],"challengeStatement":"Moduli evolution, inflation and quintessence require dynamical questions beyond static vacuum existence.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"06eb6ab0b33d70ca488cba5574a9f088537d6f8995d7fe73a3723bac7b4629aa","reply.jsonSha256":"6c4d8c637b56232f0059109accce5f4bb0da0cbe4f45a0b1b81e46f9ac15f5cd","reply.raw.txtSha256":"cd67e7475590018355f77f32db96f4e6173f5fcca932905f15c9e4a775a45e06","receipt.jsonSha256":"96638c1db28963568fd216349473bcd081260d81b680cb511b9d595a1ccec349","normalization.jsonSha256":"eb13b5dcabb5eec20b63b3afb9b4c18c51aad00ca59c36865b0b01c0a85f67ab","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"453e9ec7e0df401d2fc7d51fa6e66e90d910976ea3a59d5dafaf142a73028e24"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3bdb9c1c5751351855447f699c81fe757b058f1a6ffc6b0a98df8ec571386dc4","reply.jsonSha256":"c0a78737eed75e2d99cca34f139ca0b2e8ddf4117c71b0f6a33ec1f1741d0197","reply.raw.txtSha256":"360ce47b505d70e79a42d86acaa4dc3fff0f2c26104cdbc5e598b0f45f7c54ed","receipt.jsonSha256":"27ea02f046fa52fc6800f6ca65031ee07f8788c77eec2133e59b7f4edd75aa40","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e407582e9fb73504a9bd6033318997b8efdb43c85931a162f6149af146cc15d"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:af0fda4fb4fdec799df95524"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"1901.05075","sourceId":"ev:344eb4e9ba0bdbdec2ef825a98cfd652","sourceSha256":"325e8ea0293fa7a3c8bb784057dea134d097085a985d171345db36d982394d20","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/edf9ad1578345f9a3fd4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cafa7588fca492bd29400194721d34496766e5faae1208ac53e39e102b6bbd3c","pdfPage":4,"start":95,"end":3459,"textSha256":"5f8caef3df77ec1aec37bdb3ed0b511784f898cb6e9637e41ee0170f14421573","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:af0fda4fb4fdec799df95524"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"1901.05075","sourceId":"ev:344eb4e9ba0bdbdec2ef825a98cfd652","sourceSha256":"325e8ea0293fa7a3c8bb784057dea134d097085a985d171345db36d982394d20","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/edf9ad1578345f9a3fd4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cafa7588fca492bd29400194721d34496766e5faae1208ac53e39e102b6bbd3c","pdfPage":4,"start":95,"end":3459,"textSha256":"5f8caef3df77ec1aec37bdb3ed0b511784f898cb6e9637e41ee0170f14421573","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d25","originalRef":"l25","status":"route","source":"s38","target":"s19","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on evolving moduli, inflation and quintessence","rationale":"The moduli-cosmology question refines the region's explicit rolling, thermal and cosmological-evolution targets. Its dynamical requirements extend beyond checking a static vacuum.","qualification":"Inflation, backreaction, quintessence, overshoot, background-fluid capture and thermal or time-dependent stabilization remain different source-specific problems. Static light-field models and evolving internal moduli are not identified with static de Sitter minima. Canonical normalization, retained-sector stability and assumed hierarchies require model-specific checks. Observational comparisons retain their dates and do not establish an extended model's fit or a complete cosmological history.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l25","s38","s19"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d25","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The full moduli-evolution scope is contained in s38's dynamical and cosmological targets. Narrower avoids treating the region as a single mechanism while preserving the originals' distinction between evolving-moduli questions and static vacuum existence, together with model-specific stability and hierarchy checks.","refs":["l25","s38","s19"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l25","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l26":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l26","source":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5","target":"q025-candidate-region:8574187d747387068f02fe63","type":"method_for","title":"Construct effective actions and assess retained-field control","rationale":"Action construction and retained-field analysis supply methods for relevant compactification and vacuum questions in s38 while remaining independent calculation targets. The original arrow reverses.","qualification":"Retain each source's dimensions, fields, localized terms, derivative and coupling expansions, and classical, quantum or fermionic truncation. Retained and omitted fields require separate justification. Matching an effective coupling does not establish a controlled vacuum, and an obstruction in an examined ansatz is not universal. Conditional improvements involving internal evolution remain conditional; no complete non-Abelian action or general de Sitter no-go follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:7470d0e34f69e9dc5633603fabbbcb83768c8ac5eab46053e9f55dfd06a2c1c3","unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","unit:a3b7823d6c82542b388bee53058edfc5cd3c2259fd27cfcd25cf06901fe8a04d","unit:ecec83bd62de4b786661045f9ea61d3f60c54f643435bed0f7866528ed39d06f","unit:f470eb824c4b1d16b3f6da475b1b6ce95854de58171ce5393ccb7281c05a2a35","unit:f4aca86d28221e1908f1020562113b6e5b302b2bf0c96f02d6278286d5965162","unit:f99f7bf5f8c60b89408bc8c1b0adfdb96c577a2d8e02f6a67d19b1dfab159b71"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5","scopeContentSha256":"b3ab149cbff528b8f436220d62ecc8ccf893cd824b0bc53b1653cd6a1f5a1a71","localRef":"s7"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:8574187d747387068f02fe63","scopeContentSha256":"f09de89ad17b314d53c57c60d1ffb7ff3e77cdd6ea7ef20e64644f897046a079","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l26","originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:8","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l26","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:8","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:8574187d747387068f02fe63","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l26","source":"s38","target":"s7","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Provides a shared route for constructing effective actions and checking retained-field descriptions without imposing one dimension or expansion."],"challengeStatement":"Action construction and retained-field descriptions supply methods and independent targets with source-specific dimensions and expansions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"06eb6ab0b33d70ca488cba5574a9f088537d6f8995d7fe73a3723bac7b4629aa","reply.jsonSha256":"6c4d8c637b56232f0059109accce5f4bb0da0cbe4f45a0b1b81e46f9ac15f5cd","reply.raw.txtSha256":"cd67e7475590018355f77f32db96f4e6173f5fcca932905f15c9e4a775a45e06","receipt.jsonSha256":"96638c1db28963568fd216349473bcd081260d81b680cb511b9d595a1ccec349","normalization.jsonSha256":"eb13b5dcabb5eec20b63b3afb9b4c18c51aad00ca59c36865b0b01c0a85f67ab","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"453e9ec7e0df401d2fc7d51fa6e66e90d910976ea3a59d5dafaf142a73028e24"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3bdb9c1c5751351855447f699c81fe757b058f1a6ffc6b0a98df8ec571386dc4","reply.jsonSha256":"c0a78737eed75e2d99cca34f139ca0b2e8ddf4117c71b0f6a33ec1f1741d0197","reply.raw.txtSha256":"360ce47b505d70e79a42d86acaa4dc3fff0f2c26104cdbc5e598b0f45f7c54ed","receipt.jsonSha256":"27ea02f046fa52fc6800f6ca65031ee07f8788c77eec2133e59b7f4edd75aa40","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e407582e9fb73504a9bd6033318997b8efdb43c85931a162f6149af146cc15d"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d26","originalRef":"l26","status":"route","source":"s7","target":"s38","type":"method_for","title":"Construct effective actions and assess retained-field control","rationale":"Action construction and retained-field analysis supply methods for relevant compactification and vacuum questions in s38 while remaining independent calculation targets. The original arrow reverses.","qualification":"Retain each source's dimensions, fields, localized terms, derivative and coupling expansions, and classical, quantum or fermionic truncation. Retained and omitted fields require separate justification. Matching an effective coupling does not establish a controlled vacuum, and an obstruction in an examined ansatz is not universal. Conditional improvements involving internal evolution remain conditional; no complete non-Abelian action or general de Sitter no-go follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l26","s7","s38"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d26","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Action construction and retained-field analysis supply methods for the relevant compactification questions, making s7 the correct source. Their independent scientific targets remain visible, and the qualification preserves dimensions, expansions, truncations and source-local control failures without inferring a controlled vacuum or universal obstruction.","refs":["l26","s7","s38"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l26","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l27":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l27","source":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5","target":"q025-candidate-question:d80a9184d398ba359358baca","type":"related_question","title":"Connect effective-action descriptions with correction calculations","rationale":"Both statements identify corrected geometry, coordinates and couplings as independent calculation targets relevant to effective actions. They do not specify a directional methodological dependency sufficient to select a method_for arrow.","qualification":"Preserve the useful action-level connection without assuming complete scope containment or that one endpoint supplies every calculation at the other. Dimensions, field content, warping, frame, field variables and loop or derivative order remain local to each calculation. Corrected coordinates and cancellations matter: a corrected Kähler potential alone does not establish no-scale breaking. The limited unwarped result cannot be generalized, and a correction calculation does not establish vacuum existence.","evidenceIds":["unit:1482ea9eb536f8d6d3fda5a05a843413436eb09170a05b2678c953374b37f745","unit:1928a8fd4c4cd67d8c272d27207c31db578aef9d73fe5c70beca7751221ffd91","unit:1bf8d448385ec0395bf51790b285147f22edddcd759f2037e5cd9a6259bfae3c","unit:2c8175c925d67b5e36fbfa8a147386f6f5bbd1bb69a28d9cd98e679fee7f80f3","unit:3e8aa697ac9d3896934105129c7ca28d9876c2abb6e3abb0acf17b10376c4fbe","unit:554e94d245c3f0a043125d575adfd9fbf669b91f5739612587a20fb594981940","unit:5d7c2a067e17ef7fe266482f87065fb4baeb3d602913fce0b4a733e8da194019","unit:9203709f8eae6328a00f35a479418477154ca8c1da84cbd4ffea287e9e6481ef","unit:9a1ae49ae9ce84af8c8e001a0030c621916c18f3fed512a5c3a045b4238bab19","unit:9f9f096f1e34a20b3c061ee327cba575c7ecc417b32526ee26b7beaf5b52e0ed","unit:a0008710581a6b7347b51ec060d6fd52673e7c00ad11f7ee8cada930c413b854","unit:a98acbe8fc7f76ddc4628b6803ab0dfffe961ded8b292ab59eea5f0718dd60fd","unit:abc4f7db2a9cd48ac8f4b92af9533d436dce9b11070f88e099c34c66b5466239","unit:ade1f05341da1573563bf55238b02db535886a493fe2ab63f9088c8dccfeafcb","unit:b64c509b4716f315da93d02d56c4586664c14980ebdc1f058a2c41ff46e19297","unit:c2ec79a715013ff373bd4de3eefea493a097a9a5b4b123962e225a7443022e4b","unit:cad8603be5dc26b86428a24c17a30b0a35a404e30be6e35d7be29c58f009e164","unit:daa28791b6c6c157d2d2bf9abfdadc55c0b7e8c8698ea642c53aa4f354dcc564","unit:defaa5c4ce92ca99501947b2ca3e30fed424ca586d6bf4386548b382b0c3054c","unit:e77465805661b7c91f2b40713df744f0440dfb99e3308c8b487d302fdf2206bd","unit:e7c37d1a5febe0a0d47a65fd51e7e479cc727dd88290ae1e292ba69488e1b135","unit:ed7be8a365fc7ffc3c5acd89208b0618e1be91b7e7741cad478cf6a5b154759d","unit:f470eb824c4b1d16b3f6da475b1b6ce95854de58171ce5393ccb7281c05a2a35"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5","scopeContentSha256":"b3ab149cbff528b8f436220d62ecc8ccf893cd824b0bc53b1653cd6a1f5a1a71","localRef":"s7"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d80a9184d398ba359358baca","scopeContentSha256":"8436df2f9b87856d335271765e5fd37ecf9756e1a697d197b3da386016504534","localRef":"s29"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l27","originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:20","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l27","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:20","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:d80a9184d398ba359358baca","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l27","source":"s7","target":"s29","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Correction calculations for geometry, coordinates and couplings supply independent action-level targets."],"challengeStatement":"Corrected geometry, coordinates and couplings provide independent calculation targets relevant to effective actions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"06eb6ab0b33d70ca488cba5574a9f088537d6f8995d7fe73a3723bac7b4629aa","reply.jsonSha256":"6c4d8c637b56232f0059109accce5f4bb0da0cbe4f45a0b1b81e46f9ac15f5cd","reply.raw.txtSha256":"cd67e7475590018355f77f32db96f4e6173f5fcca932905f15c9e4a775a45e06","receipt.jsonSha256":"96638c1db28963568fd216349473bcd081260d81b680cb511b9d595a1ccec349","normalization.jsonSha256":"eb13b5dcabb5eec20b63b3afb9b4c18c51aad00ca59c36865b0b01c0a85f67ab","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"453e9ec7e0df401d2fc7d51fa6e66e90d910976ea3a59d5dafaf142a73028e24"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3bdb9c1c5751351855447f699c81fe757b058f1a6ffc6b0a98df8ec571386dc4","reply.jsonSha256":"c0a78737eed75e2d99cca34f139ca0b2e8ddf4117c71b0f6a33ec1f1741d0197","reply.raw.txtSha256":"360ce47b505d70e79a42d86acaa4dc3fff0f2c26104cdbc5e598b0f45f7c54ed","receipt.jsonSha256":"27ea02f046fa52fc6800f6ca65031ee07f8788c77eec2133e59b7f4edd75aa40","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e407582e9fb73504a9bd6033318997b8efdb43c85931a162f6149af146cc15d"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5"},{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d80a9184d398ba359358baca"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5"},{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d80a9184d398ba359358baca"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d27","originalRef":"l27","status":"route","source":"s7","target":"s29","type":"related_question","title":"Connect effective-action descriptions with correction calculations","rationale":"Both statements identify corrected geometry, coordinates and couplings as independent calculation targets relevant to effective actions. They do not specify a directional methodological dependency sufficient to select a method_for arrow.","qualification":"Preserve the useful action-level connection without assuming complete scope containment or that one endpoint supplies every calculation at the other. Dimensions, field content, warping, frame, field variables and loop or derivative order remain local to each calculation. Corrected coordinates and cancellations matter: a corrected Kähler potential alone does not establish no-scale breaking. The limited unwarped result cannot be generalized, and a correction calculation does not establish vacuum existence.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l27","s7","s29"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d27","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both originals identify independent correction targets relevant to effective actions but do not fix a directional methodological dependency. Related_question preserves the stated connection without guessing that dependency. The qualification also retains coordinate, frame and cancellation issues and avoids inferring no-scale breaking or vacuum existence.","refs":["l27","s7","s29"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l27","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l28":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l28","source":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","target":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5","type":"method_for","title":"Use symmetry and uplift constructions in effective-potential sectors","rationale":"The symmetry, no-scale and effective-uplift constructions in s23 inform the potential-construction part of s7. This supplies a bounded method direction from s23 to s7.","qualification":"The connection concerns the appropriate potential sectors and dictionaries, particularly the stated four-dimensional effective-supergravity settings; it does not extend automatically to every action or retained-field problem. Keep string-loop, α′ and explicitly invoked nonperturbative contributions, supersymmetry-breaking scales and nilpotent-multiplet assumptions distinct. Breaking scaling symmetry need not remove every no-scale property. Encoding uplift or removing one universal tachyon does not establish a fully stable controlled vacuum or a universally valid truncation.","evidenceIds":["unit:0331d936c08069563803cebe5d3527498080bf62848a27ba3f499deb4eb96d33","unit:03394bf20ceebe5d8fa665d97dfd6b5e900d27627f13bc5286f807cfb8cacd4f","unit:8c36ce59b59e2e547af818a3e8183807d26108092e3ba75bf4dfb532f37c8eee","unit:9214beb73af7c6709ac195bbefa77d6146aee7d6cf25d8b6b243d417d0024383","unit:abed7f7a15f00df2901178a63e7b88b901f9e85bcff3092d8375fce922152c08","unit:bf9cbeeef58cb882cda011b856aa3521221620fd0c14a53f8bc382edac0e4a4b","unit:cfb072d78bcd8a8e97ee32a59eae1f9721e43fc04ff40df2f423adb804cb1e44","unit:f470eb824c4b1d16b3f6da475b1b6ce95854de58171ce5393ccb7281c05a2a35","unit:f7dacde5e3ec1cd1a0ec3c942186b9014318356ac97fa62126074ac816fa49c7"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","scopeContentSha256":"dc667e1c6331e506dae8bfb90994b6e1469c8c2828b9eb96c93630d236fa3791","localRef":"s23"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5","scopeContentSha256":"b3ab149cbff528b8f436220d62ecc8ccf893cd824b0bc53b1653cd6a1f5a1a71","localRef":"s7"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l28","originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:22","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l28","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:22","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l28","source":"s7","target":"s23","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Connects action construction to symmetry, no-scale structure and effective uplift terms while retaining their distinct mechanisms."],"challengeStatement":"Symmetries, no-scale structure and effective uplift terms inform potential construction without sharing one mechanism.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"06eb6ab0b33d70ca488cba5574a9f088537d6f8995d7fe73a3723bac7b4629aa","reply.jsonSha256":"6c4d8c637b56232f0059109accce5f4bb0da0cbe4f45a0b1b81e46f9ac15f5cd","reply.raw.txtSha256":"cd67e7475590018355f77f32db96f4e6173f5fcca932905f15c9e4a775a45e06","receipt.jsonSha256":"96638c1db28963568fd216349473bcd081260d81b680cb511b9d595a1ccec349","normalization.jsonSha256":"eb13b5dcabb5eec20b63b3afb9b4c18c51aad00ca59c36865b0b01c0a85f67ab","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"453e9ec7e0df401d2fc7d51fa6e66e90d910976ea3a59d5dafaf142a73028e24"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3bdb9c1c5751351855447f699c81fe757b058f1a6ffc6b0a98df8ec571386dc4","reply.jsonSha256":"c0a78737eed75e2d99cca34f139ca0b2e8ddf4117c71b0f6a33ec1f1741d0197","reply.raw.txtSha256":"360ce47b505d70e79a42d86acaa4dc3fff0f2c26104cdbc5e598b0f45f7c54ed","receipt.jsonSha256":"27ea02f046fa52fc6800f6ca65031ee07f8788c77eec2133e59b7f4edd75aa40","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e407582e9fb73504a9bd6033318997b8efdb43c85931a162f6149af146cc15d"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5"},{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d35ecaac6f6200acc8ed5c5"},{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c14f3d71c00d52c2b6e578"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d28","originalRef":"l28","status":"route","source":"s23","target":"s7","type":"method_for","title":"Use symmetry and uplift constructions in effective-potential sectors","rationale":"The symmetry, no-scale and effective-uplift constructions in s23 inform the potential-construction part of s7. This supplies a bounded method direction from s23 to s7.","qualification":"The connection concerns the appropriate potential sectors and dictionaries, particularly the stated four-dimensional effective-supergravity settings; it does not extend automatically to every action or retained-field problem. Keep string-loop, α′ and explicitly invoked nonperturbative contributions, supersymmetry-breaking scales and nilpotent-multiplet assumptions distinct. Breaking scaling symmetry need not remove every no-scale property. Encoding uplift or removing one universal tachyon does not establish a fully stable controlled vacuum or a universally valid truncation.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l28","s23","s7"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d28","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The challenge statement explicitly identifies symmetry, no-scale and uplift ingredients as informing potential construction, supporting the bounded method direction from s23 to s7. The record confines applicability to appropriate potential sectors and preserves distinct mechanisms, expansions and truncation limits.","refs":["l28","s23","s7"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l28","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l29":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l29","source":"q025-candidate-region:79dd11c4632243fb25aa5bad","target":"q025-candidate-question:af0fda4fb4fdec799df95524","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on cosmological moduli evolution and dynamical stabilization","rationale":"Inflation, backreaction and dynamical stabilization are explicit refinements of s37's moduli-dynamics and cosmological targets, including partially stabilized and evolving systems.","qualification":"Keep plateau construction, backreaction, thermal dynamics, overshoot capture and quintessence constraints separate under their source-specific approximations. Static backgrounds with light fields and evolving internal moduli retain different assumptions. Canonical normalization, retained-sector stability and hierarchy checks remain necessary; stabilization need not mean a stationary vacuum. Dated observational comparisons do not establish a new fit or complete cosmological history.","evidenceIds":["unit:12e88a8cc2e681c53234ab6a048049585088143cab8f7f5b2a631956778ed071","unit:168d83055a347476f8e232bd4812ff9b75a8f20f149fcf1e5d641e10531deee3","unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","unit:2133ea4516372df8ed406bebf84f4bf43eaf9cb46abdfefd377e108610fc79db","unit:3267740f211252bd12f44b0c848cf418e59f929650f231d45f4371bc63b44ec4","unit:556f2d74f08a4c051743903dd4413c0a6bc453d30c0a8ec50d2fcdb3458d928f","unit:82c2356213daa2cc05ebfeec1340610d0f56380865440191070602637534dcb8","unit:8d97447c2b609f272cd9def253a662b73ffe66c32eb0fce9f9e0193cee6aa5be","unit:ac833f8a2f16c94da090aea819f0f62d4bb59337f7e6789791dbf86698634146","unit:b57c9bc5d6be70d25d3db9ba5138f812c031eb70dce48eb097b514770d934b7d","unit:c496b0f57a26cf707360727607563458edc3af780062af2b4660dc963c7257ec","unit:d8339891c0adf5f5a935f3364bd8694b02ee5fffc61060ea729ba383426f0989","unit:e82ee7314c0e5c1fcc3ba4c3f7ad207563242313370efe3a73d243ae2cf0ce67","unit:ee857c660a5b30359c367b74ceb16dea3faaaeab51c61e2c4961458169a6569e","unit:f99f7bf5f8c60b89408bc8c1b0adfdb96c577a2d8e02f6a67d19b1dfab159b71","unit:fe7692d6999bd72a2d7a120642d14a6e7991ffc9d7a970dc9e23d662bd49ed66","unit:ff063daf73b247c772af73e6822e6dcd4396e7e5ba3da722089e5bad92d04cf8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:79dd11c4632243fb25aa5bad","scopeContentSha256":"d3c011dcc64dfd2ee852002e99e8b72bf036b8ef6d7c34b5cf6c9d76a4ba590d","localRef":"s37"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:af0fda4fb4fdec799df95524","scopeContentSha256":"52ee5874b797f882c60aec085816ebf334fa97ba75ab80622e3ad0fe650bd375","localRef":"s19"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l29","originalCandidateId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge:link:10","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l29","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge:link:10","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:79dd11c4632243fb25aa5bad","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:af0fda4fb4fdec799df95524","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l29","source":"s37","target":"s19","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Access evolving-moduli cosmology, inflation, backreaction and dynamical stabilization across batches."],"challengeStatement":"Cosmological evolution includes inflation, backreaction and dynamical stabilization under source-specific assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"131630606abe5e685d4f482c31dbf108eb3c089557aa1767a14f5558e26c7d1a","reply.jsonSha256":"f289006fa1d21bc2e56706aaee31fca5b72c9200d2f69bb1ce803c6586811163","reply.raw.txtSha256":"06bc13b86ad5f081206300276fe54e7905838cbcd5e07e258f250d0653d58d46","receipt.jsonSha256":"efc647c4343d9ff237ba8345051a6dad746e904fed3f31c1a0f07e44a6bf7dd5","normalization.jsonSha256":"15bc44bd9635d55c267b4830aad253c598c0dc2dbc5d3c7f18f49c1fbe9a0f8f","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"843fb31a8154645c7f7487b754b3458f0033f1690cfbca733df381da6d512f3a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec52cc7db9d07efb8eff2523f41369d40988dfc1834866b49ee8da16c206193a","reply.jsonSha256":"3bc5fed164bc8d5b9fb2945acdb0e0b08b80d76dc1977dbd1adb2b65b405f353","reply.raw.txtSha256":"05d6084ab5a49d6844ce34298ad04fdceae55085699880fe94cf18ad2ba3a45d","receipt.jsonSha256":"e26f19694cf9ab164c4afc92ec86916e52e92a5211d21ab59348e16d401a6050","normalization.jsonSha256":"b742016defc4750e562f3bca62011dae9d3813ea2499d18f573140e04a337699"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:af0fda4fb4fdec799df95524"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceId":"ev:0286f42ac8bbe1af9f974924107f76df","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":2,"start":2495,"end":5173,"textSha256":"e7c0a5ba884b22057878f87c15d17f9d3c459216f93f6f7bd0834cde3b325aca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceId":"ev:ad87fad48150a4ec1d9f8aaebefcffc8","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":1,"start":2495,"end":4175,"textSha256":"968bc4c2c1a3ac84e841a628a50fbbd53e8826323064c7c3e6b2e6e50d3104d6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:af0fda4fb4fdec799df95524"},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceId":"ev:0286f42ac8bbe1af9f974924107f76df","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":2,"start":2495,"end":5173,"textSha256":"e7c0a5ba884b22057878f87c15d17f9d3c459216f93f6f7bd0834cde3b325aca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"2308.00302","sourceId":"ev:ad87fad48150a4ec1d9f8aaebefcffc8","sourceSha256":"830be9442d2ae352745a64eb6a39c4e47e5a3a625f11e0194e07ef5d1ee31418","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5d9f27f6f2a9654726b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8e2ca8fb76583c91c82d1f1a570931458378aa2406b069b88a82c9c694e54f4f","pdfPage":1,"start":2495,"end":4175,"textSha256":"968bc4c2c1a3ac84e841a628a50fbbd53e8826323064c7c3e6b2e6e50d3104d6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d29","originalRef":"l29","status":"route","source":"s37","target":"s19","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on cosmological moduli evolution and dynamical stabilization","rationale":"Inflation, backreaction and dynamical stabilization are explicit refinements of s37's moduli-dynamics and cosmological targets, including partially stabilized and evolving systems.","qualification":"Keep plateau construction, backreaction, thermal dynamics, overshoot capture and quintessence constraints separate under their source-specific approximations. Static backgrounds with light fields and evolving internal moduli retain different assumptions. Canonical normalization, retained-sector stability and hierarchy checks remain necessary; stabilization need not mean a stationary vacuum. Dated observational comparisons do not establish a new fit or complete cosmological history.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l29","s37","s19"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d29","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Cosmological moduli evolution, inflation and dynamical stabilization genuinely refine s37's explicit scope, including partially stabilized and evolving systems. The qualification preserves source-specific approximations and distinguishes dynamical stabilization from stationary vacua without claiming a new observational fit.","refs":["l29","s37","s19"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l29","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l30":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l30","source":"q025-candidate-question:d80a9184d398ba359358baca","target":"q025-candidate-region:79dd11c4632243fb25aa5bad","type":"method_for","title":"Calculate corrected geometry and couplings for moduli dynamics","rationale":"Both statements explicitly identify the correction calculations as inputs to subsequent moduli dynamics while preserving them as independent scientific targets. This fixes the method direction from s29 to s37.","qualification":"Use only the corrections computed for the specified compactification, retained couplings, fields and approximation order. Preserve frame and coordinate choices, warping assumptions, and the distinction between three-dimensional N=2 and four-dimensional N=1 sectors. Corrected Kähler data alone do not determine no-scale breaking; the limited unwarped result does not establish a general cancellation. Correction calculations establish neither a vacuum nor full stability, global realization or control.","evidenceIds":["unit:12e88a8cc2e681c53234ab6a048049585088143cab8f7f5b2a631956778ed071","unit:1482ea9eb536f8d6d3fda5a05a843413436eb09170a05b2678c953374b37f745","unit:1928a8fd4c4cd67d8c272d27207c31db578aef9d73fe5c70beca7751221ffd91","unit:1bf8d448385ec0395bf51790b285147f22edddcd759f2037e5cd9a6259bfae3c","unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","unit:2133ea4516372df8ed406bebf84f4bf43eaf9cb46abdfefd377e108610fc79db","unit:2c8175c925d67b5e36fbfa8a147386f6f5bbd1bb69a28d9cd98e679fee7f80f3","unit:3267740f211252bd12f44b0c848cf418e59f929650f231d45f4371bc63b44ec4","unit:3e8aa697ac9d3896934105129c7ca28d9876c2abb6e3abb0acf17b10376c4fbe","unit:554e94d245c3f0a043125d575adfd9fbf669b91f5739612587a20fb594981940","unit:5d7c2a067e17ef7fe266482f87065fb4baeb3d602913fce0b4a733e8da194019","unit:8d97447c2b609f272cd9def253a662b73ffe66c32eb0fce9f9e0193cee6aa5be","unit:9203709f8eae6328a00f35a479418477154ca8c1da84cbd4ffea287e9e6481ef","unit:9a1ae49ae9ce84af8c8e001a0030c621916c18f3fed512a5c3a045b4238bab19","unit:9f9f096f1e34a20b3c061ee327cba575c7ecc417b32526ee26b7beaf5b52e0ed","unit:a0008710581a6b7347b51ec060d6fd52673e7c00ad11f7ee8cada930c413b854","unit:a98acbe8fc7f76ddc4628b6803ab0dfffe961ded8b292ab59eea5f0718dd60fd","unit:abc4f7db2a9cd48ac8f4b92af9533d436dce9b11070f88e099c34c66b5466239","unit:ade1f05341da1573563bf55238b02db535886a493fe2ab63f9088c8dccfeafcb","unit:b64c509b4716f315da93d02d56c4586664c14980ebdc1f058a2c41ff46e19297","unit:c2ec79a715013ff373bd4de3eefea493a097a9a5b4b123962e225a7443022e4b","unit:cad8603be5dc26b86428a24c17a30b0a35a404e30be6e35d7be29c58f009e164","unit:daa28791b6c6c157d2d2bf9abfdadc55c0b7e8c8698ea642c53aa4f354dcc564","unit:defaa5c4ce92ca99501947b2ca3e30fed424ca586d6bf4386548b382b0c3054c","unit:e77465805661b7c91f2b40713df744f0440dfb99e3308c8b487d302fdf2206bd","unit:e7c37d1a5febe0a0d47a65fd51e7e479cc727dd88290ae1e292ba69488e1b135","unit:ed7be8a365fc7ffc3c5acd89208b0618e1be91b7e7741cad478cf6a5b154759d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d80a9184d398ba359358baca","scopeContentSha256":"8436df2f9b87856d335271765e5fd37ecf9756e1a697d197b3da386016504534","localRef":"s29"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:79dd11c4632243fb25aa5bad","scopeContentSha256":"d3c011dcc64dfd2ee852002e99e8b72bf036b8ef6d7c34b5cf6c9d76a4ba590d","localRef":"s37"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l30","originalCandidateId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge:link:5","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l30","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge:link:5","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:79dd11c4632243fb25aa5bad","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:d80a9184d398ba359358baca","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l30","source":"s37","target":"s29","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Corrected actions, coordinates and couplings are independent calculation targets and inputs to subsequent dynamics."],"challengeStatement":"Corrected actions, coordinates and couplings are independent calculation targets as well as inputs to moduli dynamics.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"131630606abe5e685d4f482c31dbf108eb3c089557aa1767a14f5558e26c7d1a","reply.jsonSha256":"f289006fa1d21bc2e56706aaee31fca5b72c9200d2f69bb1ce803c6586811163","reply.raw.txtSha256":"06bc13b86ad5f081206300276fe54e7905838cbcd5e07e258f250d0653d58d46","receipt.jsonSha256":"efc647c4343d9ff237ba8345051a6dad746e904fed3f31c1a0f07e44a6bf7dd5","normalization.jsonSha256":"15bc44bd9635d55c267b4830aad253c598c0dc2dbc5d3c7f18f49c1fbe9a0f8f","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"843fb31a8154645c7f7487b754b3458f0033f1690cfbca733df381da6d512f3a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec52cc7db9d07efb8eff2523f41369d40988dfc1834866b49ee8da16c206193a","reply.jsonSha256":"3bc5fed164bc8d5b9fb2945acdb0e0b08b80d76dc1977dbd1adb2b65b405f353","reply.raw.txtSha256":"05d6084ab5a49d6844ce34298ad04fdceae55085699880fe94cf18ad2ba3a45d","receipt.jsonSha256":"e26f19694cf9ab164c4afc92ec86916e52e92a5211d21ab59348e16d401a6050","normalization.jsonSha256":"b742016defc4750e562f3bca62011dae9d3813ea2499d18f573140e04a337699"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d80a9184d398ba359358baca"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d80a9184d398ba359358baca"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d30","originalRef":"l30","status":"route","source":"s29","target":"s37","type":"method_for","title":"Calculate corrected geometry and couplings for moduli dynamics","rationale":"Both statements explicitly identify the correction calculations as inputs to subsequent moduli dynamics while preserving them as independent scientific targets. This fixes the method direction from s29 to s37.","qualification":"Use only the corrections computed for the specified compactification, retained couplings, fields and approximation order. Preserve frame and coordinate choices, warping assumptions, and the distinction between three-dimensional N=2 and four-dimensional N=1 sectors. Corrected Kähler data alone do not determine no-scale breaking; the limited unwarped result does not establish a general cancellation. Correction calculations establish neither a vacuum nor full stability, global realization or control.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l30","s29","s37"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d30","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Unlike l27, both statements here explicitly identify correction calculations as inputs to subsequent moduli dynamics, fixing the method direction from s29 to s37. Independent calculation targets remain intact, with dimensional, field, coordinate and approximation limits and no inference of vacuum existence or full control.","refs":["l30","s29","s37"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l30","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l31":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l31","source":"q025-candidate-region:79dd11c4632243fb25aa5bad","target":"q025-candidate-question:fa052fa27dfa229acdbb3809","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on global chiral embeddings with stabilized moduli","rationale":"The global chiral-embedding question refines s37's compactification, global-realization, stabilization and particle-physics targets by adding explicit charge, brane and visible-sector requirements.","qualification":"A local modulus potential does not establish global charge or anomaly consistency, suitable brane data or the intended visible sector. General chiral quivers and the particular Standard Model quiver remain distinct. Retain the diagonal-divisor and compatible-involution requirements of the dP5 construction and the separate dynamical roles of the two blow-up modes in the inflationary example. Not every embedding supports inflation, and announced constructions do not supply a complete global-consistency or control audit.","evidenceIds":["unit:12e88a8cc2e681c53234ab6a048049585088143cab8f7f5b2a631956778ed071","unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","unit:2133ea4516372df8ed406bebf84f4bf43eaf9cb46abdfefd377e108610fc79db","unit:3267740f211252bd12f44b0c848cf418e59f929650f231d45f4371bc63b44ec4","unit:459a501400bd831a1c4638f5a60153a660c19228793faf1c2be51c2297f68784","unit:8d97447c2b609f272cd9def253a662b73ffe66c32eb0fce9f9e0193cee6aa5be","unit:b99df706a49befef2153c6370fe5cd548772510ad50f1d6094f3c9560957fe43","unit:dd9865cda12c52f54e3411ea29635d4426b4d9080a1b7b6039d52f8225835a79"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:79dd11c4632243fb25aa5bad","scopeContentSha256":"d3c011dcc64dfd2ee852002e99e8b72bf036b8ef6d7c34b5cf6c9d76a4ba590d","localRef":"s37"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fa052fa27dfa229acdbb3809","scopeContentSha256":"2e6d61814e9947b6b219c88bc9fdc1f722c6c0aa2ea023fd8bea11a76d1c5626","localRef":"s33"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l31","originalCandidateId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge:link:11","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l31","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge:link:11","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:79dd11c4632243fb25aa5bad","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:fa052fa27dfa229acdbb3809","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l31","source":"s37","target":"s33","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Global chiral embeddings add charge, brane and visible-sector requirements beyond a local modulus potential."],"challengeStatement":"Global chiral embeddings introduce charge, brane and visible-sector conditions beyond a local modulus potential.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"131630606abe5e685d4f482c31dbf108eb3c089557aa1767a14f5558e26c7d1a","reply.jsonSha256":"f289006fa1d21bc2e56706aaee31fca5b72c9200d2f69bb1ce803c6586811163","reply.raw.txtSha256":"06bc13b86ad5f081206300276fe54e7905838cbcd5e07e258f250d0653d58d46","receipt.jsonSha256":"efc647c4343d9ff237ba8345051a6dad746e904fed3f31c1a0f07e44a6bf7dd5","normalization.jsonSha256":"15bc44bd9635d55c267b4830aad253c598c0dc2dbc5d3c7f18f49c1fbe9a0f8f","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"843fb31a8154645c7f7487b754b3458f0033f1690cfbca733df381da6d512f3a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-7ae074a19448e4fca43f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec52cc7db9d07efb8eff2523f41369d40988dfc1834866b49ee8da16c206193a","reply.jsonSha256":"3bc5fed164bc8d5b9fb2945acdb0e0b08b80d76dc1977dbd1adb2b65b405f353","reply.raw.txtSha256":"05d6084ab5a49d6844ce34298ad04fdceae55085699880fe94cf18ad2ba3a45d","receipt.jsonSha256":"e26f19694cf9ab164c4afc92ec86916e52e92a5211d21ab59348e16d401a6050","normalization.jsonSha256":"b742016defc4750e562f3bca62011dae9d3813ea2499d18f573140e04a337699"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fa052fa27dfa229acdbb3809"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fa052fa27dfa229acdbb3809"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d31","originalRef":"l31","status":"route","source":"s37","target":"s33","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on global chiral embeddings with stabilized moduli","rationale":"The global chiral-embedding question refines s37's compactification, global-realization, stabilization and particle-physics targets by adding explicit charge, brane and visible-sector requirements.","qualification":"A local modulus potential does not establish global charge or anomaly consistency, suitable brane data or the intended visible sector. General chiral quivers and the particular Standard Model quiver remain distinct. Retain the diagonal-divisor and compatible-involution requirements of the dP5 construction and the separate dynamical roles of the two blow-up modes in the inflationary example. Not every embedding supports inflation, and announced constructions do not supply a complete global-consistency or control audit.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l31","s37","s33"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d31","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Global chiral embeddings with stabilized moduli refine s37's explicit global-realization and particle-physics targets. The narrower route preserves the additional charge, brane and visible-sector requirements, the distinct quiver constructions and their specific divisor, involution and inflation conditions.","refs":["l31","s37","s33"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-03-proposal","parent-orientation-03-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. Primary locators, hashes and review files remain in the unsupplied sidecar; no primary text was newly read or verified.","Scope and relation refs are navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Inherited reading counts, descendant coverage, source dates and reported results retain their original limits; no full-paper, proof, numerical or current-status verification is inferred.","Conditional routes establish a supported navigation relationship, not successful construction, universal applicability or satisfaction of every stated prerequisite. Pending child scopes and incomplete constructions are not independently admitted.","No deterministic admission, canonical identity, DAG, endpoint-receipt or complete-atlas checks were performed."],"challenge":["This challenge considered all supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No primary text was supplied or newly read; sidecar locators, hashes and original review files were not inspected.","Scope and route references provide navigation context, not new empirical evidence. Historical reading limits, source dates, description-only support and attributed descendant coverage remain unchanged.","Supported routes establish bounded navigation relationships, not verified physical results, satisfaction of every prerequisite, universal applicability or admission of pending child scopes.","No tools or external operations were used. Endpoint receipts, canonical identity, global DAG checks and deterministic admission remain outside this review."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-03:l31","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-04:l0":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-04:l0","source":"q025-candidate-question:9bb204301590984ed22e8b1d","target":"q025-candidate-question:00429d3881e0e8d0e46afb1d","type":"premise_check","title":"Check the charged-state constraint on a long warped hierarchy","rationale":"For the specified warped hierarchy question, the charged-state volume argument supplies a conditional compatibility test. It does not constrain every spectral problem in s27.","qualification":"Restricted to the Planck-brane AdS5 × X construction with five-dimensional X, the D3 U(1), the selected stretched-string W states and the stated mass, coupling and Planck-scale scalings. The parametric comparison takes large L_AdS M_s at fixed relevant string coupling. Applying the proposed electric bound to these W states is an imposed premise: the general existence conjecture does not bound every charged state. The resulting volume inequality is neither an unconditional consistency theorem nor a classification of geometries.","evidenceIds":["unit:04d9f7e136a3978388b851c1522bc2c648be2b1a577756f1bcf35a5b3618f621","unit:07f0dcbf45d83b092654b32b9901df033f40245ebd2bffd6b09a8152a0bea124","unit:0cdd4a2174237b7ffcef1e011e5b3ca2ad1112069b3d667c087ebbe3f932704f","unit:1a633547a451eb951cde542acdb430c7f2b4409801b6b4123908479c7c40e5ee","unit:299eb28ac0db3b0183bdec5b46363a479b4bfadb461ec021c5bac8ffb4d4e482","unit:2ebe4d7b5c5169a46775c408d9039e0a1c76081281f7fc0ef56cacebac2a0845","unit:485e7bc8f362f1352fb0b56c28c1e482e3a4f122b0a645ac72d83210ab12aa43","unit:683262ad8d9f0246025249ca6fb72bfdb1319cb7f31e6291e6259b52c201cfa9","unit:6bf4557a847702782ebdec3e78d30e683c40147a833b572e51129186e93fccda","unit:850c2f4deac5fd7591a85034789480771331321f5d6484888dd14b26cd41876c","unit:9cce5d0968e5cacd1be7a37cf32da1e06a6395ba999e54ab67439e9821dc225b","unit:af816bc020ce7fd85c434eb2f2701c8c6bf4315cd29c2de3feb14497d5b8859d","unit:d23da649af1f47b55f73c2e0b1d65a7ec0df7d8da7f14d5e391ac00202e3765e","unit:d826a0155b87894800a312b6b6de00a292fd78932bef0c9300e883a00b147e46","unit:e69f26a1805e3c44532c28d002929a807e28fdc9171e59fa53f018b1ad68c5f0"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9bb204301590984ed22e8b1d","scopeContentSha256":"b2655d53fff4cff62621f8e7eab3287bc875ab959537b6253786fe486ef924e0","localRef":"s27"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:00429d3881e0e8d0e46afb1d","scopeContentSha256":"1fd4272f642fc077bcfa6697a7ab0831325a2e5c35adca4f0fbfcf33e01a6f36","localRef":"s0"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l0","originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:30","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-04:l0","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:30","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:9bb204301590984ed22e8b1d","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:00429d3881e0e8d0e46afb1d","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l0","source":"s27","target":"s0","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["The charged-state volume argument supplies a conditional boundary test with its imposed W-state premise retained."],"challengeStatement":"The charged-state volume argument offers a conditional test with its imposed W-state premise retained.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"06eb6ab0b33d70ca488cba5574a9f088537d6f8995d7fe73a3723bac7b4629aa","reply.jsonSha256":"6c4d8c637b56232f0059109accce5f4bb0da0cbe4f45a0b1b81e46f9ac15f5cd","reply.raw.txtSha256":"cd67e7475590018355f77f32db96f4e6173f5fcca932905f15c9e4a775a45e06","receipt.jsonSha256":"96638c1db28963568fd216349473bcd081260d81b680cb511b9d595a1ccec349","normalization.jsonSha256":"eb13b5dcabb5eec20b63b3afb9b4c18c51aad00ca59c36865b0b01c0a85f67ab","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"453e9ec7e0df401d2fc7d51fa6e66e90d910976ea3a59d5dafaf142a73028e24"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3bdb9c1c5751351855447f699c81fe757b058f1a6ffc6b0a98df8ec571386dc4","reply.jsonSha256":"c0a78737eed75e2d99cca34f139ca0b2e8ddf4117c71b0f6a33ec1f1741d0197","reply.raw.txtSha256":"360ce47b505d70e79a42d86acaa4dc3fff0f2c26104cdbc5e598b0f45f7c54ed","receipt.jsonSha256":"27ea02f046fa52fc6800f6ca65031ee07f8788c77eec2133e59b7f4edd75aa40","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e407582e9fb73504a9bd6033318997b8efdb43c85931a162f6149af146cc15d"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9bb204301590984ed22e8b1d"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:00429d3881e0e8d0e46afb1d"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:9bb204301590984ed22e8b1d"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:00429d3881e0e8d0e46afb1d"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d0","originalRef":"l0","status":"route","source":"s27","target":"s0","type":"premise_check","title":"Check the charged-state constraint on a long warped hierarchy","rationale":"For the specified warped hierarchy question, the charged-state volume argument supplies a conditional compatibility test. It does not constrain every spectral problem in s27.","qualification":"Restricted to the Planck-brane AdS5 × X construction with five-dimensional X, the D3 U(1), the selected stretched-string W states and the stated mass, coupling and Planck-scale scalings. The parametric comparison takes large L_AdS M_s at fixed relevant string coupling. Applying the proposed electric bound to these W states is an imposed premise: the general existence conjecture does not bound every charged state. The resulting volume inequality is neither an unconditional consistency theorem nor a classification of geometries.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l0","s27","s0"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The warped-hierarchy question appropriately points to the conditional charged-state compatibility check. The qualification preserves the specific compactification, fixed-coupling limit and imposed W-state bound, without extending an existence conjecture to every charged state or every spectral question in s27.","refs":["l0","s27","s0"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-04-proposal","parent-orientation-04-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the 40 supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each of the 35 relations. References identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence.","No primary text, sidecar locator files or full per-unit attribution notes were supplied or newly read. Historical readingCoverage statements are inherited limitations, not work performed in this review.","Method and application routes can concern explicitly bounded components of their endpoints; they do not establish full-scope containment. The narrower routes rely on the complete supplied parent and destination scopes.","The proposed parent definitions remain subject to their stated independent-review or coordinator requirements. No descendant-wide coverage, new question identity, source contribution, home or alias is established here.","No calculations, equations, numerical searches, current phenomenology, global embeddings or general validity claims were independently verified. Existing failures, incomplete constructions and description-only support remain applicable.","Admission, receipt checks, canonical identity and the global DAG gate are separate. The workload grouping establishes no additional relation between disconnected cases."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed all 40 supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for each of the 35 relations, and every proposed decision. References identify supplied context, not new primary evidence.","No tools or external operations were used. Primary texts, sidecar locators, review hashes and full per-unit attribution notes were not supplied or newly read; historical readingCoverage statements remain inherited limitations.","Method and application routes concern their explicitly bounded components. The seven narrower routes were assessed against complete endpoint scopes, not merely shared methods or selected components.","Conditional navigation does not verify the underlying conjecture, calculation or successful construction. The retained records do not claim the unresolved outcomes listed below.","The proposed parent definitions retain their independent-review or coordinator requirements. This challenge establishes no new questions, homes, aliases, source contributions or descendant-wide verification.","Admission, endpoint and receipt checks, canonical identity and the global DAG gate remain separate. The workload grouping supplies no relationship between disconnected cases."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-04:l0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-04:l1":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-04:l1","source":"q025-candidate-question:20f3a88ab190a3ad1d8c7cec","target":"q025-candidate-question:11fb124b974497a204c1b45d","type":"method_for","title":"Apply geometric and sector-coupling criteria to local stability","rationale":"The structural tools are supplied by s10, so the method arrow must be reversed. They address the applicable supergravity stability questions within s5.","qualification":"Retain the specified scalar geometry, field content and supersymmetry-breaking directions. The sector-coupling discussion uses independently defined sectors with nonzero superpotentials and a toy one-modulus setting; approximate no-scale tuning remains geometry-dependent, with exceptions. Necessary conditions and local superpotential engineering do not establish global compactifications or reliable elimination of arbitrary fields. The route does not absorb rigid N=2 mass bounds, extend them to gravity, or remove their exclusion of constant FI terms.","evidenceIds":["unit:01b9e17b212ac830249aa35bb92a25b5b03543642cf905ec8886f48fde71ca79","unit:12db93fcd7db364da2e8233a53f7284428d51bf5123cea9ed11088568c2244bc","unit:1a7536c38a39c2daa37ae5bfb53516c5e5d2a38a94f4ff8435dc431163828b07","unit:3d07823a97e8be735784e81ca0aa22daeb03442d56e9b3294e817397b33ce38c","unit:41a3eb3b375ce9513ff65f1268a22de0acc55096043e38855cb7c1f4835af30a","unit:46189926a6b85d2ad9dce396f84c7ffbb70699a828fa690c760bc7e3d90c2df8","unit:4d4f590c322198538803d365d432edd7b7a9bb2e0b342d9fa7dc4b4b7a71f67d","unit:53fe72a086698ab6f15428ea4e164f6528ddfcb1e07f3ff3010ac411bd00198a","unit:5d1e9815bc5265fe445e8bb665945ac7af9a1b14a95c8c3e4ea456be14af8b0b","unit:5fea2e78e138ffff90571570213b6b33fabcbf9a1b0392746537c516d4f75d6b","unit:7470d0e34f69e9dc5633603fabbbcb83768c8ac5eab46053e9f55dfd06a2c1c3","unit:8d931f3d77f8b3a308dcb654bf1b6bfdf149c8214476ae02030d70393dd597d2","unit:be9645d9dbe61509900cc80f1c2056dd13a589f543d9332d317f481e9e04f2e8","unit:c9bd6e3528bb33c411974acfb291ddad156e7b28094146216dfb20fb08fa7841","unit:ce1f8dd63a55d2456df51d883efb20f293c26d32c588565ec9a619e72ce391e4","unit:d7fe0160987dc2fd2accff13f8e4e4865332e25eb21fbe057f2d034e6ffababb"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:20f3a88ab190a3ad1d8c7cec","scopeContentSha256":"f41222fbe2d66d41add3c24921e9ef9e0afa8ee27a2d7906f53f05cde0fe81a4","localRef":"s10"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:11fb124b974497a204c1b45d","scopeContentSha256":"f7f407c6763805e7805d3f36cb5b1a74711ae76aa7952b89e0b8a668da113f0a","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l1","originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:33","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-04:l1","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:33","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:11fb124b974497a204c1b45d","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:20f3a88ab190a3ad1d8c7cec","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l1","source":"s5","target":"s10","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Supergravity geometry and sector-coupling criteria offer structural tools without absorbing the rigid N=2 question."],"challengeStatement":"Supergravity geometry and sector-coupling criteria provide structural tools without absorbing rigid-theory mass bounds.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"06eb6ab0b33d70ca488cba5574a9f088537d6f8995d7fe73a3723bac7b4629aa","reply.jsonSha256":"6c4d8c637b56232f0059109accce5f4bb0da0cbe4f45a0b1b81e46f9ac15f5cd","reply.raw.txtSha256":"cd67e7475590018355f77f32db96f4e6173f5fcca932905f15c9e4a775a45e06","receipt.jsonSha256":"96638c1db28963568fd216349473bcd081260d81b680cb511b9d595a1ccec349","normalization.jsonSha256":"eb13b5dcabb5eec20b63b3afb9b4c18c51aad00ca59c36865b0b01c0a85f67ab","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"453e9ec7e0df401d2fc7d51fa6e66e90d910976ea3a59d5dafaf142a73028e24"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3bdb9c1c5751351855447f699c81fe757b058f1a6ffc6b0a98df8ec571386dc4","reply.jsonSha256":"c0a78737eed75e2d99cca34f139ca0b2e8ddf4117c71b0f6a33ec1f1741d0197","reply.raw.txtSha256":"360ce47b505d70e79a42d86acaa4dc3fff0f2c26104cdbc5e598b0f45f7c54ed","receipt.jsonSha256":"27ea02f046fa52fc6800f6ca65031ee07f8788c77eec2133e59b7f4edd75aa40","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e407582e9fb73504a9bd6033318997b8efdb43c85931a162f6149af146cc15d"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:11fb124b974497a204c1b45d"},{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:20f3a88ab190a3ad1d8c7cec"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1211.7364","sourceId":"ev:3345323d3117cd3f0a3909697fe1e6a8","sourceSha256":"9929321d7eae16277bfe92a5ecf65ee2ca23ac2fb8b14784555517dbf423f711","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e46f8119cb76c1c6bb3c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6a9c6290300676a1699846af93f51e28ea088b1ce14d30d3fffb947081ac9837","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2688,"textSha256":"5a53ac9821b319f83eaac0097463306a184e491006f5b5955eac8984fe5ff666","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:11fb124b974497a204c1b45d"},{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:20f3a88ab190a3ad1d8c7cec"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"1211.7364","sourceId":"ev:3345323d3117cd3f0a3909697fe1e6a8","sourceSha256":"9929321d7eae16277bfe92a5ecf65ee2ca23ac2fb8b14784555517dbf423f711","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e46f8119cb76c1c6bb3c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6a9c6290300676a1699846af93f51e28ea088b1ce14d30d3fffb947081ac9837","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2688,"textSha256":"5a53ac9821b319f83eaac0097463306a184e491006f5b5955eac8984fe5ff666","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d1","originalRef":"l1","status":"route","source":"s10","target":"s5","type":"method_for","title":"Apply geometric and sector-coupling criteria to local stability","rationale":"The structural tools are supplied by s10, so the method arrow must be reversed. They address the applicable supergravity stability questions within s5.","qualification":"Retain the specified scalar geometry, field content and supersymmetry-breaking directions. The sector-coupling discussion uses independently defined sectors with nonzero superpotentials and a toy one-modulus setting; approximate no-scale tuning remains geometry-dependent, with exceptions. Necessary conditions and local superpotential engineering do not establish global compactifications or reliable elimination of arbitrary fields. The route does not absorb rigid N=2 mass bounds, extend them to gravity, or remove their exclusion of constant FI terms.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l1","s5","s10"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify s10 as the provider of structural stability tools, so the reversal is justified. The record retains the sector-coupling and geometry restrictions and explicitly prevents transfer to rigid N=2 mass bounds or arbitrary field elimination.","refs":["l1","s5","s10"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-04-proposal","parent-orientation-04-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the 40 supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each of the 35 relations. References identify supplied context, not new empirical evidence.","No primary text, sidecar locator files or full per-unit attribution notes were supplied or newly read. Historical readingCoverage statements are inherited limitations, not work performed in this review.","Method and application routes can concern explicitly bounded components of their endpoints; they do not establish full-scope containment. The narrower routes rely on the complete supplied parent and destination scopes.","The proposed parent definitions remain subject to their stated independent-review or coordinator requirements. No descendant-wide coverage, new question identity, source contribution, home or alias is established here.","No calculations, equations, numerical searches, current phenomenology, global embeddings or general validity claims were independently verified. Existing failures, incomplete constructions and description-only support remain applicable.","Admission, receipt checks, canonical identity and the global DAG gate are separate. The workload grouping establishes no additional relation between disconnected cases."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed all 40 supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for each of the 35 relations, and every proposed decision. References identify supplied context, not new primary evidence.","No tools or external operations were used. Primary texts, sidecar locators, review hashes and full per-unit attribution notes were not supplied or newly read; historical readingCoverage statements remain inherited limitations.","Method and application routes concern their explicitly bounded components. The seven narrower routes were assessed against complete endpoint scopes, not merely shared methods or selected components.","Conditional navigation does not verify the underlying conjecture, calculation or successful construction. The retained records do not claim the unresolved outcomes listed below.","The proposed parent definitions retain their independent-review or coordinator requirements. This challenge establishes no new questions, homes, aliases, source contributions or descendant-wide verification.","Admission, endpoint and receipt checks, canonical identity and the global DAG gate remain separate. The workload grouping supplies no relationship between disconnected cases."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-04:l1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"}}}