{"kind":"eigenquestions-relation-details","schemaVersion":"1.0.0","relations":{"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l5":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l5","source":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6","target":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a","type":"method_for","title":"Use inference and identifiability checks to assess scalar histories","rationale":"Inverse inference and identifiability provide the method for assessing specified background histories, so the methodological arrow runs from s29 to s4.","qualification":"Keep each observational window, matter allocation, reconstruction prior and boundary prescription. Canonical restrictions apply only in the canonical setting; potential reconstruction retains field-origin freedom. Background data alone do not identify arbitrary coupling and equation-of-state functions together, and agreement with a background history does not establish microscopic consistency.","evidenceIds":["unit:120c2cb0b711c90fe2146fad6110c576a6d9f5bb61a2282eb9193a32adbc0781","unit:17ce6a8c558247f5d1babb1f7b675efcc62a404687ac8380c8458f643cfa24b9","unit:1d179d9ec0eeb226883411ac325737a1080d4d6be30e418be0a8b6f5aabd7ebc","unit:1d991528537c30eea8bb179079e2da8f6f0ebc83144e9a906e7dfa6179962f02","unit:1db3427f5e01897af82ffb70341402a5903a4ba2804954ea09a6398a0f6f8816","unit:1f3a44d5c43400920c65d02390ca364343e4c9b4dd746dd61439f8dd4cdf680b","unit:22c21ca871bd81d8f096b1b1792a59f08ccccb442a914dfade862288e1ccfbb4","unit:31271d7dfca4fe764442d0aa4e4801816261e32a4eae883b87aef7d1e0748704","unit:32c76a3dc827cd85202ac3b6c42f7b7d8f6d6c2ab3ad9142f2ee9eb607b4d4b4","unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","unit:3ce597e198d727b29270b1010d378cb7e69a79d091bbb00bb22bd87570bcf8fe","unit:4ea455d25f925a2ba8a956f05b4f002e50bf678ed2b309e51bd58ab2cfecd11e","unit:4fb0631119e19948090cfce6f4de34d798b58a6b8de8a44dd26a4b632fbc39bc","unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f","unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","unit:6118d7e96a4f864fc3e782183eb3e43d7a4be73f346ab0d364dfb0f008a67775","unit:68f4f4ffd4d4a71a068438e8dc7381a0d17df877d59b41d9ef0d979d4ed7d79b","unit:6a562fcb3f25b9ea7c981d6374a41848f4179fe3dba2f1a86ec0d452a09b0364","unit:6b2130ad6e7b0e47e7506c23e438d0b9f422fc271081de5f71663fca7df987e7","unit:7451f5bda7b338ca10496dce52f7d8d27a1f7af6a837a399dfd50ed064e8be9c","unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","unit:8622e1b046ad7758b7a2e489de32ec77b84b8f58531ea38343f9a699d14febd6","unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","unit:8b8691d111d78239dfebb4f1295fdb40c5a4c6bcd312819477396cedc278eb47","unit:8dbd5c3383317914b8e2f51b50b5f81b97c5590bba6322976ef4214b4e8c24fd","unit:8dfeb4f2701afdceb4409038dbee8c405856e17e281a0c1faf8cc627ac2b9542","unit:901c5fab7695b54466b6a37c27b993da70a4ca9134d5b9d07d6c9b70300cf760","unit:acc5e23bc2409d650a891c6737176fe601245c73bee1218e1c7fd918a01c4b20","unit:ad3d22473312b5e18cad347b59aa11b8287ee5ab98f8ed90ee566fb78441a4a5","unit:b0a10a242143873e59ba2d7f08fd905bc49dfacec461eeee485fdb7cf2d748e3","unit:b25a1afc039080d5e2a7b3fbb390ce16604e2cf7b726f019e5aac919ee19377b","unit:b53e13f9d30f2970b0a9171f1ab65a507b587ff40b3cc4aa2f7650369f08db1f","unit:b608be96ec00e275288357f876c88b0f1fd8ec3be6a67705025229b6bf767613","unit:b63d3da3b6ce278b8f181c21560d3525dd134e594326f9551ddde0ebec0b6385","unit:b9bac0cd5f769d330250fc015c3d2f7ba13fc06f6d1a53e3ab004d781ba58865","unit:bf99c7e3ba1c57e54212667656b9210bfefca360519cd5b1e9c2f1442d0f2f8f","unit:bff5f38896802d1c22a015771b36398fd9925228457e3cf6424900f472bc9bc9","unit:ccc46b79310e36a2cb8ad72afac190e35647e06a48443af8db1593a1f224931d","unit:cf5d992980e77e2c29936f1c1086725207f3d11567c24bcaec83400cc91664bc","unit:d270782bac26220422ff24d42ded24f1fcc35784c97d2da1569e5025061d8a90","unit:dee9557b2f592a80a5e4a0a70eab3066fd6d94dfd4cc9fa3f453e89da7a9f234","unit:f1cedb4fe828b30a905a1fddaf9f5ca95a51ff00999aadd22f202f5c99ab5542","unit:ffa164e65727d11206e8bc77e800dd904d519f93275ff3ce7eb3214a7e97f7df"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6","scopeContentSha256":"adb5d31dd329431521ed5321fd138dbfb86e5c2aaeebab9116b92f32e0b1e624","localRef":"s29"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a","scopeContentSha256":"cf4b878f8c8a9e621142d4757c68c105582cb223b4ed08afbca88ce0cbdf5a8a","localRef":"s4"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l5","originalCandidateId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge:link:26","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l5","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge:link:26","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l5","source":"s4","target":"s29","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Inference and identifiability supply an inverse route from scalar histories; the supplied field-origin limitation makes this distinction concrete."],"challengeStatement":"Inverse inference and identifiability complement specified histories; field-origin freedom limits the reconstructed potential.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"7b33b16c985585a06b369b1d0d8f2223ea66f4bf751e8180c02bac1d73685cad","reply.jsonSha256":"1f6db74d58e33725f67aec60f85cbb15f0bcf7f2b88678a3327e4ea342d661c7","reply.raw.txtSha256":"68f65e9cdbde08c1baabde287b0807d7de16a13f2f05da01eca5c7d7f804ab37","receipt.jsonSha256":"9351a4e44cb862bf94bd5d62d4ba23cc06434fe4035352177c15f4ecd41f1c33","normalization.jsonSha256":"5bb01ca69a3683f3cac170091b720de22bb04698b69c9b7d5a53283e96a10200","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"681b060972d2664e2c8461d9d9ba1c6a105480ab939d527c82406b3eba67fb77"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-ae3ac5701d07a07d14d4-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"894314622f9c38a49311c9aba776c5764c823d15384a6e582538f5b4d1b4a3fd","reply.jsonSha256":"b670b1f143a82ba9448c0b01000b16afb6d831937be636f0287ee70b1a133499","reply.raw.txtSha256":"8d3183c6cfd51f88c29ccc9c473017a0d31b94c74bb9512f0201658c79b8594e","receipt.jsonSha256":"14618f9fbef0ad8ab6c2b1b6f497a337f04bcc06f46b8263213fcf5440148635","normalization.jsonSha256":"894fb0b86097950af3369e4ef1eb9944571800d944830fa18ca9ef6594c63998"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a"},{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6"},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"2101.04666","sourceId":"ev:d86aca4bfac2b9c5b4bd74ab0fe3de90","sourceSha256":"604b32bdfe7f5f64c68bded6c39078fbfdf30d85710099e117e579a7339beecd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/176cb98d2fd47e508d27/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3d02f7d7b63b88b90c2ac31240bd4e26a28d70f59228d6d3f97f5079ae52976a","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"cdf8a4cfc2c1100e49bb5580d256cf39f529b02583a398896e664356f1a69d21","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"2101.04666","sourceId":"ev:87cdeba933243604d5897dd34f457bb9","sourceSha256":"604b32bdfe7f5f64c68bded6c39078fbfdf30d85710099e117e579a7339beecd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/176cb98d2fd47e508d27/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3d02f7d7b63b88b90c2ac31240bd4e26a28d70f59228d6d3f97f5079ae52976a","pdfPage":7,"start":2172,"end":4135,"textSha256":"de8e43273069c37af1a51efb87b8e5f0b3b15bd8e646781bb33269c1d785c9e0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a"},{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6"},{"ref":"e11","kind":"primary","paperId":"2101.04666","sourceId":"ev:d86aca4bfac2b9c5b4bd74ab0fe3de90","sourceSha256":"604b32bdfe7f5f64c68bded6c39078fbfdf30d85710099e117e579a7339beecd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/176cb98d2fd47e508d27/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3d02f7d7b63b88b90c2ac31240bd4e26a28d70f59228d6d3f97f5079ae52976a","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"cdf8a4cfc2c1100e49bb5580d256cf39f529b02583a398896e664356f1a69d21","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"2101.04666","sourceId":"ev:87cdeba933243604d5897dd34f457bb9","sourceSha256":"604b32bdfe7f5f64c68bded6c39078fbfdf30d85710099e117e579a7339beecd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/176cb98d2fd47e508d27/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3d02f7d7b63b88b90c2ac31240bd4e26a28d70f59228d6d3f97f5079ae52976a","pdfPage":7,"start":2172,"end":4135,"textSha256":"de8e43273069c37af1a51efb87b8e5f0b3b15bd8e646781bb33269c1d785c9e0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d5","originalRef":"l5","status":"route","source":"s29","target":"s4","type":"method_for","title":"Use inference and identifiability checks to assess scalar histories","rationale":"Inverse inference and identifiability provide the method for assessing specified background histories, so the methodological arrow runs from s29 to s4.","qualification":"Keep each observational window, matter allocation, reconstruction prior and boundary prescription. Canonical restrictions apply only in the canonical setting; potential reconstruction retains field-origin freedom. Background data alone do not identify arbitrary coupling and equation-of-state functions together, and agreement with a background history does not establish microscopic consistency.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l5","s29","s4"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The inverse-inference and identifiability contribution belongs to s29 and is applicable to assessing the histories in s4. Reversal is therefore justified. The record retains reconstruction priors, component allocation, boundary conditions and field-origin freedom without claiming arbitrary interactions are identifiable from background data.","refs":["l5","s4","s29"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l6":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l6","source":"q025-candidate-question:cb9d8ed82c9b8b3f697be05f","target":"q025-candidate-question:1faf45777574123ab250b2a3","type":"premise_check","title":"Check whether a candidate needs cosmological initial-condition preparation","rationale":"The statements make preparation a possible prerequisite for a candidate construction. The 1999 axion example retains initial-condition tuning after potential protection.","qualification":"This check applies to candidates whose proposed evolution requires preparation; it is not a universal requirement on every microscopic mechanism. Potential tuning, initial-condition tuning and moduli-dynamics conditions remain distinct. A sufficiently long tracking interval is conditional, with no supplied complete transition or interacting-dark-matter backreaction history. Hilltop evolution and preparation near a hilltop are separate questions.","evidenceIds":["unit:04bbd27e171530f1ca15b8becbfbeffffb614e8898f98cab5e356e060126335f","unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","unit:30e469dad86f2093687b4ce209e575cf9975924d40b859ab9ce3377e8915c306","unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","unit:47a7d4dbe6eb5b46006ed1d0f44ec4ee7286d7baf31ef7b4d97c0555675f0c47","unit:4ea455d25f925a2ba8a956f05b4f002e50bf678ed2b309e51bd58ab2cfecd11e","unit:57bf9b780d4129b24792df1928ec28d4dc96624d410aff81d96c4e9943eb2fd9","unit:597932033244fa69c82f19bfb04cd5e6042ef92b2cef58d932dcac367494dceb","unit:5f1f3a30968231eccb353d2672e0cb39fb4d94b0d58ade3628f5c0819ca1bc8f","unit:6be0ecc7820d5e13c5e215d806fb3daa52adb13f979b5d088ad899c85097eb82","unit:715cac064c580c2d253479415585f024e4a03e18ef9c4b2d8b465205b3e58191","unit:8b8691d111d78239dfebb4f1295fdb40c5a4c6bcd312819477396cedc278eb47","unit:9498c902d1fcafd6c6c840e010275277fdbf1a63b88584633518660a01fa1db1","unit:a86c20191a1dc1779510b965f7169dd574e12b81ebc6b47306051b1d11dbd0f9","unit:b1cf19af5cf136fbb49041ad43db6f95143cad70f3ae72000c29746dd813c79a","unit:bff5f38896802d1c22a015771b36398fd9925228457e3cf6424900f472bc9bc9","unit:ce3f118987da1eca9c5b5c26d112ed8f5c0f184cec476453d0e026bd7be505c8","unit:d6bf0b556994a0d99310a91945144814a89448a5e45f7c830627a63fd1d807c1","unit:df03aadc4b99d143164b10bdcc0851d80e5716b2ed1a9c7b093777528c222206","unit:e9e24ea161b304812cfb76ac5a1244bd7464237cd9727a3d57115f25d27d6cc1"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cb9d8ed82c9b8b3f697be05f","scopeContentSha256":"0b12990174fac44b92532be67665101d789a75310dcfa732ef46c9285eb95205","localRef":"s31"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1faf45777574123ab250b2a3","scopeContentSha256":"64923ea7478c33c4d1e04f65e83e432586e37948047006ccadd2a2dd1839c2aa","localRef":"s6"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l6","originalCandidateId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:link:26","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l6","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:link:26","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:cb9d8ed82c9b8b3f697be05f","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:1faf45777574123ab250b2a3","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l6","source":"s31","target":"s6","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["A candidate construction may require cosmological preparation. The 1999 axion proposal illustrates why protection alone does not remove initial-condition tuning."],"challengeStatement":"A proposed construction can require separate cosmological preparation; the 1999 axion discussion retains initial-condition tuning after potential protection.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"de84e99439170b2675fc38133e281739cd905d09bf2176f7b05d636550d2358d","reply.jsonSha256":"6c1522f20588d5a84327f472eab05170ff0d3eda36225ec0ace9f9ddc97f7ad9","reply.raw.txtSha256":"030615ba578cf0b722ed771c01b0a648d663906eee025156e9d465e092cb103b","receipt.jsonSha256":"18bb6a3ef1483f0c0a3014dd137df78ce1e7df0b36fe6ff0db6dfb679a70e583","normalization.jsonSha256":"8ffe97fa062071e4b2def45a386d092c0d7ad65feaad281c1103f4fdc12b828e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"611c9cba0dd489e3195b884167a256fcc6c17ee6b886d50b6270f88f1a588308"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"dfe84d8ec63eb76645d4e0514c9328876ac395a73a9e0d100cde2b0903929659","reply.jsonSha256":"ca3ac0c0490411401b241e2e0af4f191f5d53df1ec57be1a18e318870226bb8a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b2c8027291e6f5cb38f6a8c172905cb689d756f054e2253af3f7b62d0b11bb31","receipt.jsonSha256":"7a0f48e49d3ba21e2c5b9bf346eb99ef11cb59b2a179f59bb9ad4fa8ea669d7b","normalization.jsonSha256":"83b6672e51de5af1b40f530599e6072ff4f85dad2c87709a432c30e95ca6f172"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cb9d8ed82c9b8b3f697be05f"},{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1faf45777574123ab250b2a3"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-ph/9912218","sourceId":"ev:18be4ac310669d3986bf0d257346ab5d","sourceSha256":"a778f85eebbf927c9dd250a6e14b2f6308b9e4619ec47a8410ea0520a4e59547","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9c037672ed278b4e2b13/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1c0c4cf83619daecb691dd3f51844714a8b92c27a0a8c44efd7a53c7c04e3370","pdfPage":3,"start":90,"end":2602,"textSha256":"a06c89cbab9c1d8f633e30f3ec7b85954bb253a30a70e309232c804b4175e119","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:cb9d8ed82c9b8b3f697be05f"},{"ref":"x3_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1faf45777574123ab250b2a3"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-ph/9912218","sourceId":"ev:18be4ac310669d3986bf0d257346ab5d","sourceSha256":"a778f85eebbf927c9dd250a6e14b2f6308b9e4619ec47a8410ea0520a4e59547","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9c037672ed278b4e2b13/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1c0c4cf83619daecb691dd3f51844714a8b92c27a0a8c44efd7a53c7c04e3370","pdfPage":3,"start":90,"end":2602,"textSha256":"a06c89cbab9c1d8f633e30f3ec7b85954bb253a30a70e309232c804b4175e119","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d6","originalRef":"l6","status":"route","source":"s31","target":"s6","type":"premise_check","title":"Check whether a candidate needs cosmological initial-condition preparation","rationale":"The statements make preparation a possible prerequisite for a candidate construction. The 1999 axion example retains initial-condition tuning after potential protection.","qualification":"This check applies to candidates whose proposed evolution requires preparation; it is not a universal requirement on every microscopic mechanism. Potential tuning, initial-condition tuning and moduli-dynamics conditions remain distinct. A sufficiently long tracking interval is conditional, with no supplied complete transition or interacting-dark-matter backreaction history. Hilltop evolution and preparation near a hilltop are separate questions.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l6","s31","s6"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both statements identify cosmological preparation as a possible requirement of a candidate construction and retain initial-condition tuning in the axion example. The conditional premise-check direction is appropriate; the qualification does not presume a successful preparation history or require it for every microscopic candidate.","refs":["l6","s31","s6"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l7":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l7","source":"q025-candidate-question:acec4c36d68f9eaf75d3e2b7","target":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af","type":"application_of","title":"Locate the conditional consistency criteria used in particle-potential tests","rationale":"Particle-sector potentials furnish applications of selected consistency criteria. The applied tests point to the underlying conditional consistency question.","qualification":"This concerns selected conjectural tests, not every naturalness issue in s23. Gradient and Hessian formulations remain distinct. The matched-QCD argument assumes applicability to metastable states and fixes Standard Model parameters across sectors; its quantitative formulation is not supplied here. Coupled and decoupled constructions remain separate, with no unconditional flavor bound, universal Higgs coupling or Higgs-stabilization result.","evidenceIds":["unit:27a47bf78c1d2430dc5675b2aebef5e8846a5e502f2cdfcbdbca628b15970e5c","unit:30e469dad86f2093687b4ce209e575cf9975924d40b859ab9ce3377e8915c306","unit:4c0de05c6db76aa4a3fc01a44dbca59527f6c8724ba8f138060e7f9516ebb781","unit:5cf714ff1e97c7ee299c92d53371e311e46daaa2d38bc9588b6216f097196124","unit:61cc1a02b4b31ec8b0107932539c6f5abdb8f88f0a268e4589bba5535a61ffb8","unit:72dfb141d30e9395f3b96cafa4e1fb85e7ef591b0e4cf30e6b3c4da834cbc9da","unit:868672bc49418f6b8a0066e545ef3075db61ab8da9e908a6fd651ec3c358f95c","unit:87cb0eceab562aa9744189cb47b6a5156e05548f3518faff9998c73e469134ff","unit:994055d5b3fe54377d838aed0d9e48e88dfb7cfa8f4ff4a928523e89cfda9ef1","unit:9de0e271e58e3cb68d199bdbb85776fe2ae318c64e69850975bff3d69e94864e","unit:9f8d045ad5a768128cf8d298422ecba60cff1ef9a6d14d1c7b1825360539b9a2","unit:a07fb6304497e324aa94d59bce9684d0427ed288341ea6dcf768e335b7eedc7e","unit:a2ba2a4b5f1844186de66917fa160c354f5037118dfae1f0e66b23cd1da9a2ab","unit:ada8d151f5be8aea52454e10197f6455700bc9e49a025dd3fe4369fa6a1b9f71","unit:b2c02ee8dabea0739250e5585f116a7e0e351581d1c15ca9a3a2abd14c2e65af","unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","unit:dd50fc828c8dcc7c6812e0961d4651c51b6979f135220f28c26c0ba0c78dc6e8","unit:f2b59ee9884ca68f2a95480498595abcd6aed5042649de410ef959100b3383f0"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:acec4c36d68f9eaf75d3e2b7","scopeContentSha256":"32e1b128473222d507158a70cf32b21d86f366981865da2307c9c1ff5951cdb1","localRef":"s28"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af","scopeContentSha256":"8bba339c9e4207dca6b0f3f316a16a489c020412fb829f92cc20ae3c6ec3b8da","localRef":"s23"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l7","originalCandidateId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:link:30","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l7","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:link:30","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:acec4c36d68f9eaf75d3e2b7","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l7","source":"s23","target":"s28","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Particle-sector potentials furnish source-specific conditional tests; gradient, Hessian and metastable-sector assumptions remain separate."],"challengeStatement":"Particle-sector potentials supply conditional tests whose gradient, Hessian and metastable-sector premises remain source-specific.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"de84e99439170b2675fc38133e281739cd905d09bf2176f7b05d636550d2358d","reply.jsonSha256":"6c1522f20588d5a84327f472eab05170ff0d3eda36225ec0ace9f9ddc97f7ad9","reply.raw.txtSha256":"030615ba578cf0b722ed771c01b0a648d663906eee025156e9d465e092cb103b","receipt.jsonSha256":"18bb6a3ef1483f0c0a3014dd137df78ce1e7df0b36fe6ff0db6dfb679a70e583","normalization.jsonSha256":"8ffe97fa062071e4b2def45a386d092c0d7ad65feaad281c1103f4fdc12b828e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"611c9cba0dd489e3195b884167a256fcc6c17ee6b886d50b6270f88f1a588308"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"dfe84d8ec63eb76645d4e0514c9328876ac395a73a9e0d100cde2b0903929659","reply.jsonSha256":"ca3ac0c0490411401b241e2e0af4f191f5d53df1ec57be1a18e318870226bb8a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b2c8027291e6f5cb38f6a8c172905cb689d756f054e2253af3f7b62d0b11bb31","receipt.jsonSha256":"7a0f48e49d3ba21e2c5b9bf346eb99ef11cb59b2a179f59bb9ad4fa8ea669d7b","normalization.jsonSha256":"83b6672e51de5af1b40f530599e6072ff4f85dad2c87709a432c30e95ca6f172"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af"},{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:acec4c36d68f9eaf75d3e2b7"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af"},{"ref":"x0_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:acec4c36d68f9eaf75d3e2b7"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d7","originalRef":"l7","status":"route","source":"s28","target":"s23","type":"application_of","title":"Locate the conditional consistency criteria used in particle-potential tests","rationale":"Particle-sector potentials furnish applications of selected consistency criteria. The applied tests point to the underlying conditional consistency question.","qualification":"This concerns selected conjectural tests, not every naturalness issue in s23. Gradient and Hessian formulations remain distinct. The matched-QCD argument assumes applicability to metastable states and fixes Standard Model parameters across sectors; its quantitative formulation is not supplied here. Coupled and decoupled constructions remain separate, with no unconditional flavor bound, universal Higgs coupling or Higgs-stabilization result.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l7","s28","s23"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The particle-potential tests apply selected conjectural consistency criteria, supporting the applied-to-underlying direction. The record limits that application to the relevant consistency branch and preserves the separate gradient, Hessian and metastable-QCD premises without deriving universal particle-sector restrictions.","refs":["l7","s23","s28"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l8":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l8","source":"q025-candidate-question:2b791ffd570b9c34ef1b48e1","target":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af","type":"application_of","title":"Relate finite-excursion tests to adopted consistency criteria","rationale":"The excursion question applies an adopted consistency criterion to specified scalar representations, requiring the applied-to-underlying direction.","qualification":"Retain each scalar representation, background history, parameter region, Planck normalization and curvature convention. Interactions and multifield alternatives are separate cases. A finite-excursion test is neither a universal quantum-gravity theorem nor interchangeable with pointwise derivative bounds or every later quantum-gravity restriction. Observational compatibility remains source-dated.","evidenceIds":["unit:4c0de05c6db76aa4a3fc01a44dbca59527f6c8724ba8f138060e7f9516ebb781","unit:50f714128306b7870aa076b85832137d07a0cd649215e6ab603313146c76c621","unit:5cf714ff1e97c7ee299c92d53371e311e46daaa2d38bc9588b6216f097196124","unit:61cc1a02b4b31ec8b0107932539c6f5abdb8f88f0a268e4589bba5535a61ffb8","unit:66e03d6bf9660db34abc7045cda9272947eafeee3f0e663619de82d17f9ae5fc","unit:72dfb141d30e9395f3b96cafa4e1fb85e7ef591b0e4cf30e6b3c4da834cbc9da","unit:9022506f3ff85c3dcf170cb1cca65ffb20f4f81f975c0ccce157f46c3e9018e7","unit:96b969af669f8a857d2d7d5c073617aa570aa9e7ce14861169978dcf2f91c1a4","unit:9de0e271e58e3cb68d199bdbb85776fe2ae318c64e69850975bff3d69e94864e","unit:a2ba2a4b5f1844186de66917fa160c354f5037118dfae1f0e66b23cd1da9a2ab","unit:ada8d151f5be8aea52454e10197f6455700bc9e49a025dd3fe4369fa6a1b9f71","unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2b791ffd570b9c34ef1b48e1","scopeContentSha256":"eead0e3a06ec1099e922f6b8c490d0e361ff7d91bc71a52d54ccb361978249bd","localRef":"s8"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af","scopeContentSha256":"8bba339c9e4207dca6b0f3f316a16a489c020412fb829f92cc20ae3c6ec3b8da","localRef":"s23"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l8","originalCandidateId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:link:31","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l8","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:link:31","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:2b791ffd570b9c34ef1b48e1","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l8","source":"s23","target":"s8","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Finite-excursion tests apply adopted criteria to specified scalar representations. They are not identified with every later quantum-gravity restriction."],"challengeStatement":"Finite-excursion criteria are applied to specified scalar representations without identification with every quantum-gravity restriction.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"de84e99439170b2675fc38133e281739cd905d09bf2176f7b05d636550d2358d","reply.jsonSha256":"6c1522f20588d5a84327f472eab05170ff0d3eda36225ec0ace9f9ddc97f7ad9","reply.raw.txtSha256":"030615ba578cf0b722ed771c01b0a648d663906eee025156e9d465e092cb103b","receipt.jsonSha256":"18bb6a3ef1483f0c0a3014dd137df78ce1e7df0b36fe6ff0db6dfb679a70e583","normalization.jsonSha256":"8ffe97fa062071e4b2def45a386d092c0d7ad65feaad281c1103f4fdc12b828e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"611c9cba0dd489e3195b884167a256fcc6c17ee6b886d50b6270f88f1a588308"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"dfe84d8ec63eb76645d4e0514c9328876ac395a73a9e0d100cde2b0903929659","reply.jsonSha256":"ca3ac0c0490411401b241e2e0af4f191f5d53df1ec57be1a18e318870226bb8a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b2c8027291e6f5cb38f6a8c172905cb689d756f054e2253af3f7b62d0b11bb31","receipt.jsonSha256":"7a0f48e49d3ba21e2c5b9bf346eb99ef11cb59b2a179f59bb9ad4fa8ea669d7b","normalization.jsonSha256":"83b6672e51de5af1b40f530599e6072ff4f85dad2c87709a432c30e95ca6f172"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af"},{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2b791ffd570b9c34ef1b48e1"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af"},{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2b791ffd570b9c34ef1b48e1"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d8","originalRef":"l8","status":"route","source":"s8","target":"s23","type":"application_of","title":"Relate finite-excursion tests to adopted consistency criteria","rationale":"The excursion question applies an adopted consistency criterion to specified scalar representations, requiring the applied-to-underlying direction.","qualification":"Retain each scalar representation, background history, parameter region, Planck normalization and curvature convention. Interactions and multifield alternatives are separate cases. A finite-excursion test is neither a universal quantum-gravity theorem nor interchangeable with pointwise derivative bounds or every later quantum-gravity restriction. Observational compatibility remains source-dated.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l8","s8","s23"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The supplied statements explicitly describe applying an adopted excursion criterion to specified scalar representations. The reversal correctly places that applied question first. Representation, interaction, multifield and normalization qualifications prevent identification with every quantum-gravity restriction or pointwise derivative test.","refs":["l8","s23","s8"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l9":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l9","source":"q025-candidate-question:690548efb26af1f935d2d594","target":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af","type":"application_of","title":"Identify the selected consistency hypotheses used in observational tests","rationale":"The criterion-conditioned observational branch applies selected consistency hypotheses to specified quintessence models.","qualification":"This route covers tests that actually impose such criteria; ordinary observational questions in s17 acquire no conjectural premise. Preserve model restrictions, initial states, datasets and source dates. A Hessian alternative need not impose a gradient bound, and a proposed lower slope limit remains conditional. The 2018 sensitivity question neither tests nor excludes the entire Swampland program; forecasts are not observations.","evidenceIds":["unit:11a0059685ebc5d92317b74341c132c526c535e4418dac037a4ee7d9ab6f0822","unit:19a0e0c84ce900996d89cecea57b16c7bd8cba7f5d085c0441542214b508dab0","unit:202e6ec43555beedfcf41aed9d6ab187a5f0e2abf05a15181619cdad76ed6b65","unit:3f6f5dd44558b038277c91cc115224366734a2feb2ed3db55e6bcf3ddc877423","unit:4c0de05c6db76aa4a3fc01a44dbca59527f6c8724ba8f138060e7f9516ebb781","unit:594034216fc8444c4de8216b0176f020b908d747c84f2b93b8d297413ffca748","unit:59959f2d71d50d4d2cdb087da9115bf7d592513e8d01e4b1e7ac59155d1013df","unit:5cf714ff1e97c7ee299c92d53371e311e46daaa2d38bc9588b6216f097196124","unit:5da14434213a299b7350f4ee74172f800b0a0e31e0116aa447dc18750c959dc4","unit:61cc1a02b4b31ec8b0107932539c6f5abdb8f88f0a268e4589bba5535a61ffb8","unit:72dfb141d30e9395f3b96cafa4e1fb85e7ef591b0e4cf30e6b3c4da834cbc9da","unit:7de813181cb84cdd72ddd8653f83af43e6a5de480188b6e183ae827f0aff9606","unit:92293ef35fbcffb70b9704d193d85f20d7117de61b8ec10b926fa30aa829a593","unit:96b969af669f8a857d2d7d5c073617aa570aa9e7ce14861169978dcf2f91c1a4","unit:9a46687f77a7d1b805cec6d0a210216920b0a3df4fe3099b9de9d95a1ac5f882","unit:9de0e271e58e3cb68d199bdbb85776fe2ae318c64e69850975bff3d69e94864e","unit:a2ba2a4b5f1844186de66917fa160c354f5037118dfae1f0e66b23cd1da9a2ab","unit:ada8d151f5be8aea52454e10197f6455700bc9e49a025dd3fe4369fa6a1b9f71","unit:b294c41cc907984e71ef7b09f3befcf09fb6c8a0bd5792998440405a3abe56e2","unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","unit:ec7b75f28f2cecdefc1b075782c1b877b39e51a02b063d8be45c5ba384f38ca1"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:690548efb26af1f935d2d594","scopeContentSha256":"489b80fcc4b3ac5c7d49acd17445b3b681dc50e87397e7ee32290d805f529a21","localRef":"s17"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af","scopeContentSha256":"8bba339c9e4207dca6b0f3f316a16a489c020412fb829f92cc20ae3c6ec3b8da","localRef":"s23"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l9","originalCandidateId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:link:32","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l9","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:link:32","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:690548efb26af1f935d2d594","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l9","source":"s23","target":"s17","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Observations can test models under selected criteria; the 2018 sensitivity question does not test or exclude the entire Swampland program."],"challengeStatement":"Observations test models under selected criteria; the 2018 sensitivity question does not establish a test of the entire Swampland program.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"de84e99439170b2675fc38133e281739cd905d09bf2176f7b05d636550d2358d","reply.jsonSha256":"6c1522f20588d5a84327f472eab05170ff0d3eda36225ec0ace9f9ddc97f7ad9","reply.raw.txtSha256":"030615ba578cf0b722ed771c01b0a648d663906eee025156e9d465e092cb103b","receipt.jsonSha256":"18bb6a3ef1483f0c0a3014dd137df78ce1e7df0b36fe6ff0db6dfb679a70e583","normalization.jsonSha256":"8ffe97fa062071e4b2def45a386d092c0d7ad65feaad281c1103f4fdc12b828e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"611c9cba0dd489e3195b884167a256fcc6c17ee6b886d50b6270f88f1a588308"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"dfe84d8ec63eb76645d4e0514c9328876ac395a73a9e0d100cde2b0903929659","reply.jsonSha256":"ca3ac0c0490411401b241e2e0af4f191f5d53df1ec57be1a18e318870226bb8a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b2c8027291e6f5cb38f6a8c172905cb689d756f054e2253af3f7b62d0b11bb31","receipt.jsonSha256":"7a0f48e49d3ba21e2c5b9bf346eb99ef11cb59b2a179f59bb9ad4fa8ea669d7b","normalization.jsonSha256":"83b6672e51de5af1b40f530599e6072ff4f85dad2c87709a432c30e95ca6f172"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af"},{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:690548efb26af1f935d2d594"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1808.02877","sourceId":"ev:64e4ef3298da1deb8ceea5f61bd988bd","sourceSha256":"a260a82d4eb4cef8f0e55e6b238135bb233609c329f754900f2fe0f2ddb70b90","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fa1b99a4c65b3d24a832/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dd88fb7823b5830129aaf65645161846f329d7d75d4fb8d72fdd6ad5b3981ccb","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3032,"textSha256":"ef4e5b2119a597890b381c134420fc70619a322cbf579dedecb5e75fc827ee48","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:854dbfbe9eada204d7ed73af"},{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:690548efb26af1f935d2d594"},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"1808.02877","sourceId":"ev:64e4ef3298da1deb8ceea5f61bd988bd","sourceSha256":"a260a82d4eb4cef8f0e55e6b238135bb233609c329f754900f2fe0f2ddb70b90","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fa1b99a4c65b3d24a832/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dd88fb7823b5830129aaf65645161846f329d7d75d4fb8d72fdd6ad5b3981ccb","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3032,"textSha256":"ef4e5b2119a597890b381c134420fc70619a322cbf579dedecb5e75fc827ee48","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d9","originalRef":"l9","status":"route","source":"s17","target":"s23","type":"application_of","title":"Identify the selected consistency hypotheses used in observational tests","rationale":"The criterion-conditioned observational branch applies selected consistency hypotheses to specified quintessence models.","qualification":"This route covers tests that actually impose such criteria; ordinary observational questions in s17 acquire no conjectural premise. Preserve model restrictions, initial states, datasets and source dates. A Hessian alternative need not impose a gradient bound, and a proposed lower slope limit remains conditional. The 2018 sensitivity question neither tests nor excludes the entire Swampland program; forecasts are not observations.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l9","s17","s23"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d9","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The criterion-conditioned observational branch applies selected consistency hypotheses, supporting s17 → s23. The qualification explicitly leaves ordinary observational questions free of those premises and retains conjecture branches, historical datasets and the distinction between forecasts and completed observations.","refs":["l9","s23","s17"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l10":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l10","source":"q025-candidate-question:23e375cd77808f45751c1f4a","target":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","type":"application_of","title":"Identify the optional Higgs interactions underlying stability proposals","rationale":"The thermal and vacuum-stability questions apply optional quintessence–Higgs interactions, so they point to the coupling question.","qualification":"The earlier proposed remedy and the later conditional challenge remain distinct. Comparing bounds requires reconciliation of models, field histories, multiplier assumptions and the ξ–β mapping; those matters remain unresolved. The imported stability threshold and unresolved inflationary calculation are not independently established here, and the quoted uncertainty has no supplied confidence level. No universal cure or exclusion follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:0b53e5e6646ffb16fadf3ea1c0783332fb56433f06fc8ab4cd05b3aedfc53b22","unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","unit:1db3427f5e01897af82ffb70341402a5903a4ba2804954ea09a6398a0f6f8816","unit:30e469dad86f2093687b4ce209e575cf9975924d40b859ab9ce3377e8915c306","unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","unit:5451c93830dd037986fa048786df25d0738ea8e8f0e59085141c1733f9a1b37c","unit:603e025f78e9f821a61c97becfb35dc0f4d9a282942860b6bc69dc8dfd5d4acd","unit:6a562fcb3f25b9ea7c981d6374a41848f4179fe3dba2f1a86ec0d452a09b0364","unit:6be0ecc7820d5e13c5e215d806fb3daa52adb13f979b5d088ad899c85097eb82","unit:78e7e070d1312576cdde11b8505f5bba680eeda98599afdf99319f931f170778","unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","unit:868672bc49418f6b8a0066e545ef3075db61ab8da9e908a6fd651ec3c358f95c","unit:87cb0eceab562aa9744189cb47b6a5156e05548f3518faff9998c73e469134ff","unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","unit:994055d5b3fe54377d838aed0d9e48e88dfb7cfa8f4ff4a928523e89cfda9ef1","unit:9f8d045ad5a768128cf8d298422ecba60cff1ef9a6d14d1c7b1825360539b9a2","unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","unit:c50ed484b164685b6d82306e5dcdf328f656ab520b17344849d5625e053d5412","unit:c60d8c67531ab8d3094c9c6f55373da5eedcdb184cae99a87ca0cb86253deb59","unit:d3772e2e30e8f7ce2786ced303ae794af50b581f3d5e01d6cc8d5d61ea5357ec"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:23e375cd77808f45751c1f4a","scopeContentSha256":"caf67f83638e405b0d2fa923f6dc6b451b7d971d35d6b1843452e374ff85fb45","localRef":"s7"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","localRef":"s19"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l10","originalCandidateId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:link:33","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l10","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:link:33","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:23e375cd77808f45751c1f4a","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l10","source":"s19","target":"s7","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Optional Higgs couplings introduce thermal and vacuum-stability targets whose field histories and parameter mappings need separate reconciliation."],"challengeStatement":"Optional Higgs interactions introduce thermal and vacuum-stability targets with unresolved history and parameter-mapping qualifications.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"de84e99439170b2675fc38133e281739cd905d09bf2176f7b05d636550d2358d","reply.jsonSha256":"6c1522f20588d5a84327f472eab05170ff0d3eda36225ec0ace9f9ddc97f7ad9","reply.raw.txtSha256":"030615ba578cf0b722ed771c01b0a648d663906eee025156e9d465e092cb103b","receipt.jsonSha256":"18bb6a3ef1483f0c0a3014dd137df78ce1e7df0b36fe6ff0db6dfb679a70e583","normalization.jsonSha256":"8ffe97fa062071e4b2def45a386d092c0d7ad65feaad281c1103f4fdc12b828e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"611c9cba0dd489e3195b884167a256fcc6c17ee6b886d50b6270f88f1a588308"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"dfe84d8ec63eb76645d4e0514c9328876ac395a73a9e0d100cde2b0903929659","reply.jsonSha256":"ca3ac0c0490411401b241e2e0af4f191f5d53df1ec57be1a18e318870226bb8a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b2c8027291e6f5cb38f6a8c172905cb689d756f054e2253af3f7b62d0b11bb31","receipt.jsonSha256":"7a0f48e49d3ba21e2c5b9bf346eb99ef11cb59b2a179f59bb9ad4fa8ea669d7b","normalization.jsonSha256":"83b6672e51de5af1b40f530599e6072ff4f85dad2c87709a432c30e95ca6f172"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"},{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:23e375cd77808f45751c1f4a"},{"ref":"c0","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65"},{"ref":"x0_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:23e375cd77808f45751c1f4a"},{"ref":"c0","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d10","originalRef":"l10","status":"route","source":"s7","target":"s19","type":"application_of","title":"Identify the optional Higgs interactions underlying stability proposals","rationale":"The thermal and vacuum-stability questions apply optional quintessence–Higgs interactions, so they point to the coupling question.","qualification":"The earlier proposed remedy and the later conditional challenge remain distinct. Comparing bounds requires reconciliation of models, field histories, multiplier assumptions and the ξ–β mapping; those matters remain unresolved. The imported stability threshold and unresolved inflationary calculation are not independently established here, and the quoted uncertainty has no supplied confidence level. No universal cure or exclusion follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l10","s7","s19"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d10","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The thermal and vacuum-stability questions apply optional Higgs interactions, supporting s7 → s19. Unreconciled field histories, multiplier assumptions and parameter mappings limit comparisons of bounds; they do not erase the stated coupling application. The record keeps those unresolved matters explicit.","refs":["l10","s19","s7"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l10","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l11":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l11","source":"q025-candidate-question:890bb92e9010e75ad9773a62","target":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","type":"application_of","title":"Trace coupled-matter growth effects to the late dark-matter force","rationale":"The stated growth example applies a dark-sector force mechanism, making the structure question the applied endpoint.","qualification":"The connection is limited to the supplied late dark-matter-force example, with its force, background and growth targets; detailed constraints remain deferred. Visible-sector restrictions do not automatically transfer to hidden interactions. Other clustering-dark-energy and light-relic mechanisms in s24 remain distinct, and growth consequences alone establish neither observational viability nor an H0 remedy.","evidenceIds":["unit:02032097506faedddb62304121141d37daed97aa51550d412877361dc5817ab7","unit:0f13418e42f0666e4419ea74f45268921d28697ed1fda939a3f5b1d18791f79e","unit:128622e23dbd0a7aabb43506baba17e3b38181fb22558a0db701685bfbda855c","unit:17bf0f1a467406d255b5e19a7ac15f339aa732fb1c0a4f89874daa05ad34a4ac","unit:1db3427f5e01897af82ffb70341402a5903a4ba2804954ea09a6398a0f6f8816","unit:1f7c4843eb29fa0dce4578c3b09bf709c29ad71239de64bf60f47a277580ea84","unit:23331dba6f0afe60a3eba320984b63b48d25dc2ff083295d3f5b48c0dff6e04a","unit:30e469dad86f2093687b4ce209e575cf9975924d40b859ab9ce3377e8915c306","unit:397f26b2b8a42cb0076d5f2761bf0376685743790d9129b9e0e142c97c6646a1","unit:3b1a6221c38c552b6572952dca1d8c882c950608c4dac0afe750e24b0de76868","unit:5451c93830dd037986fa048786df25d0738ea8e8f0e59085141c1733f9a1b37c","unit:55e6ca617215ff9154355a526b2a4add2d429ec928eeaac8871c63fafa0446f3","unit:5fc4d96969fb3009992757a37a3b13de55ace9d448c8215f4b59ef29296a5f14","unit:603e025f78e9f821a61c97becfb35dc0f4d9a282942860b6bc69dc8dfd5d4acd","unit:6be0ecc7820d5e13c5e215d806fb3daa52adb13f979b5d088ad899c85097eb82","unit:78e7e070d1312576cdde11b8505f5bba680eeda98599afdf99319f931f170778","unit:859285a6f0599dfadae16769ced367f89fac5223023cd2cd8e997fb90f295095","unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","unit:868672bc49418f6b8a0066e545ef3075db61ab8da9e908a6fd651ec3c358f95c","unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","unit:900b8220509ff06388f91e3b26aaad0064606f8aea799242f499134a611a54c8","unit:994055d5b3fe54377d838aed0d9e48e88dfb7cfa8f4ff4a928523e89cfda9ef1","unit:9f8d045ad5a768128cf8d298422ecba60cff1ef9a6d14d1c7b1825360539b9a2","unit:a24ee933f9c08f58fccfeaac95856a8775c591a9772bcba9d04d7676b26b76fd","unit:a2a19d1f7a904b42706919a86bf8b2493b98d3b9ed5575fc89583c8eba64ae8f","unit:aabefc98b676930b9d77140acc87d719fcb1c10c30d4d27d94d3801638a3539f","unit:ae0ddac995b2e79363de6348f097a07e4b0bbb8c8ec86902c65014839e199c68","unit:b140096b3790078111aee96e85ebc49cbf35c6d9cced57bad8fdbb7dd89f2242","unit:bed9fcc85d036b84f7966c50fdb726003f11ab1cfb50687abfeb503800934769","unit:c50ed484b164685b6d82306e5dcdf328f656ab520b17344849d5625e053d5412","unit:c772b1ee93e23887b9d58d4e623e8a6efa052139f9caf6d5e43cb479ecf4ae8b","unit:c7e198732ad87c375df39681a9102ee5bc639a9e6fc27c68109e7c07cb1a8ab2","unit:d3772e2e30e8f7ce2786ced303ae794af50b581f3d5e01d6cc8d5d61ea5357ec","unit:d889111f077812ed6772d926aeaed05c188987c83643fa9e4dd59c905d3dbe6a","unit:eb64e18e8c54d76f0ce2774b8dae41c15f27cb4cff4bb7157c856d646d9c6302","unit:ed014b9e278ca66da579e43b683a94e513510ba64c99c77de4b03df3b3c234ee","unit:f39f5dcd2e7a7de4e08828e661f5d8ee0c50fcf7c57027cfb294cc10b32e80b5","unit:f4c1517a11d1b1fc877863de660af9b2f1ed6c8a2a279a52e2123ac41c59f577","unit:f5a3d56f92ce1dffa91804b9dc594353296ce9de7fea28ef075d6f1b2ea5519a"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:890bb92e9010e75ad9773a62","scopeContentSha256":"6dcd63781f5959ec30a1d95e024f4cb10e4b8ad95d0884c973b175b3369c7b30","localRef":"s24"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","scopeContentSha256":"839e390c363cfd19853f630ea47860ef1a937cc8201a4b48915ad081e04780c6","localRef":"s19"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l11","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge:link:25","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l11","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge:link:25","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:72c7ec910995c3167fd9cc65","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:890bb92e9010e75ad9773a62","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l11","source":"s19","target":"s24","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["The late dark-matter-force example produces growth consequences alongside its force and background targets; a full constraint analysis is deferred."],"challengeStatement":"The late dark-matter-force example produces growth consequences alongside force and expansion targets, with detailed constraints deferred.","originalEvidenceKinds":["primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"95b1c7ba751c3f0831666906655a0772176b892862235639ba1b9f54177c0fe0","reply.jsonSha256":"2e948e54b460d4b78bd71e446414fb0734f34ec4e97be5eb0e4df090e615020e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"05a9a6b1249fce2e08510b7210c348274ab6822ab09918c64eda2a48a3cc30ae","receipt.jsonSha256":"50b7a181fc889d648a958ce20d90f3bf63e9351bac28605053ee83284da96d71","normalization.jsonSha256":"4538227034e50489c356d26e199de14d19afbe9d7c067bd7af5966066d994d3c","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"8bb74bad7dd366b41cb748c2d9278ae4184272afe37dc42ea085bed7dcb576d9"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-b7f81485b7d06aed5b64-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"e259dbe129fef2f9d0be22648b8d6689b863f0acbb87ac00124a1011e9a73600","reply.jsonSha256":"08d00dca4e0be0dc1f1d71e1671f981ef07dd6078404652a39279d6ea35d1b25","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b0cb06db5235be5edcd5239e9867cbb3cf4eaa54bc95dcfd1b6d46130f595856","receipt.jsonSha256":"92c8bdf185ba9b933381dece64798713f76f0bfe64151241faee9b7b222a9e7a","normalization.jsonSha256":"0ef5d823adf0a25e589964d662378d8e7b623e16dece9d8146aed46a759851e4"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"1904.07082","sourceId":"ev:655c2a496708f6162b962dc2cbfca3d8","sourceSha256":"a2b2946d97aace557f8f4a6525b3dfee6e1bcab2e52175df638996dd4f7ea402","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8b5447e6964f083fc57/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46d120255ad59203f625dcf6ac85588403834451cb957e8386ca21d733248911","pdfPage":7,"start":489,"end":3489,"textSha256":"2b844d0b117298705dd1c0f563d4ad28165eb4e3609f6bff61dc2f4dff48a6cb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"1904.07082","sourceId":"ev:87b83e916bf3893088fbc8b09c4aa0ed","sourceSha256":"a2b2946d97aace557f8f4a6525b3dfee6e1bcab2e52175df638996dd4f7ea402","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8b5447e6964f083fc57/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46d120255ad59203f625dcf6ac85588403834451cb957e8386ca21d733248911","pdfPage":3,"start":420,"end":3420,"textSha256":"6e7847da9a1cd409fb1102fbca7906d83e14eeae1bb7583615fa9af3cbb98826","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"1904.07082","sourceId":"ev:03275cf96c50045f8842257beb0980bb","sourceSha256":"a2b2946d97aace557f8f4a6525b3dfee6e1bcab2e52175df638996dd4f7ea402","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8b5447e6964f083fc57/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46d120255ad59203f625dcf6ac85588403834451cb957e8386ca21d733248911","pdfPage":4,"start":414,"end":3414,"textSha256":"da33312bcff66a42955a852a9233971220f601eccc882e336032649f1c2f6aa1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"1904.07082","sourceId":"ev:655c2a496708f6162b962dc2cbfca3d8","sourceSha256":"a2b2946d97aace557f8f4a6525b3dfee6e1bcab2e52175df638996dd4f7ea402","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8b5447e6964f083fc57/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46d120255ad59203f625dcf6ac85588403834451cb957e8386ca21d733248911","pdfPage":7,"start":489,"end":3489,"textSha256":"2b844d0b117298705dd1c0f563d4ad28165eb4e3609f6bff61dc2f4dff48a6cb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e10","kind":"primary","paperId":"1904.07082","sourceId":"ev:87b83e916bf3893088fbc8b09c4aa0ed","sourceSha256":"a2b2946d97aace557f8f4a6525b3dfee6e1bcab2e52175df638996dd4f7ea402","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8b5447e6964f083fc57/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46d120255ad59203f625dcf6ac85588403834451cb957e8386ca21d733248911","pdfPage":3,"start":420,"end":3420,"textSha256":"6e7847da9a1cd409fb1102fbca7906d83e14eeae1bb7583615fa9af3cbb98826","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"1904.07082","sourceId":"ev:03275cf96c50045f8842257beb0980bb","sourceSha256":"a2b2946d97aace557f8f4a6525b3dfee6e1bcab2e52175df638996dd4f7ea402","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8b5447e6964f083fc57/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46d120255ad59203f625dcf6ac85588403834451cb957e8386ca21d733248911","pdfPage":4,"start":414,"end":3414,"textSha256":"da33312bcff66a42955a852a9233971220f601eccc882e336032649f1c2f6aa1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d11","originalRef":"l11","status":"route","source":"s24","target":"s19","type":"application_of","title":"Trace coupled-matter growth effects to the late dark-matter force","rationale":"The stated growth example applies a dark-sector force mechanism, making the structure question the applied endpoint.","qualification":"The connection is limited to the supplied late dark-matter-force example, with its force, background and growth targets; detailed constraints remain deferred. Visible-sector restrictions do not automatically transfer to hidden interactions. Other clustering-dark-energy and light-relic mechanisms in s24 remain distinct, and growth consequences alone establish neither observational viability nor an H0 remedy.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l11","s24","s19"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d11","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original statements identify a particular dark-matter-force mechanism with growth consequences, supporting an application from the structure question to the coupling question. The record restricts the connection to that example and preserves its deferred constraints and separate force, expansion and growth targets.","refs":["l11","s19","s24"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l11","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l12":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l12","source":"q025-candidate-question:98b4295e1de2ab1c334cce08","target":"q025-candidate-question:407a45488c47e1a4cafa2b59","type":"application_of","title":"Use monomial background evolution in axion polarization-rotation models","rationale":"The polarization-rotation contribution applies potential-dependent field-evolution relations, so the signal question points to the underlying background dynamics.","qualification":"Retain the specified axion coupling, abundance and recent-roll regime from the two statements. Potential shape and field boundary data jointly determine the relevant history. This application does not extend those assumptions to the other collapse, spectator, scalar-tensor or gravitational-wave questions in s25, and it establishes no current signal detection.","evidenceIds":["unit:2bb58a439c61456d7debe79b09e04296b2796e4aa99d3f0b64df9ad5b83328c5","unit:37b356ea1f1110a5333eb8afb3f225e33c1a72886e2e53af0d892e5fb35cb582","unit:3c3db74e5de8fcafabc944f0cc80d90c0f9f6b4606a9754fa522aeeed15d7196","unit:47a7d4dbe6eb5b46006ed1d0f44ec4ee7286d7baf31ef7b4d97c0555675f0c47","unit:57bf9b780d4129b24792df1928ec28d4dc96624d410aff81d96c4e9943eb2fd9","unit:597932033244fa69c82f19bfb04cd5e6042ef92b2cef58d932dcac367494dceb","unit:6af026250209a6a98e607432adfe7d2c03ff9e70082df1b181f8f60dc0df2f51","unit:715cac064c580c2d253479415585f024e4a03e18ef9c4b2d8b465205b3e58191","unit:860161140522f3b1f26142c3d8735b290a8a4cb2e1d684d88b369dd1064f3138","unit:887ed383780181a434c1c2d3ef1536c2e488cfa02cea83390310c90e1d085749","unit:9bc77c2e869938116e8e3787be6fba83cfb431bb5eab3d31a72dd032273cb031","unit:a2bb89a43f5778c5eef50d979cc636faf52dbf5c5e04e0c54376a9297a1c85d3","unit:a4c36be44698a2467f366516ccded698cb5cc5ba528472c55631be33d748047b","unit:b100c8e5394f4a6e0e5217449474a8b8abbf946075708d3fbe2c91deafcbc0cf","unit:b247bc3d47d971ed0cd3eac4a62423c44d729e11a7219dfff993e064b1cce9d7","unit:c50ed484b164685b6d82306e5dcdf328f656ab520b17344849d5625e053d5412","unit:ccc46b79310e36a2cb8ad72afac190e35647e06a48443af8db1593a1f224931d","unit:e91f912c2a932dba337331e17c3a6e9ec5732241e18bc6b02e96517a90318055"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98b4295e1de2ab1c334cce08","scopeContentSha256":"2ac8c41856fa7f59e4511ae33fec3f1cbea6e2dbd97b3b18c0bc5233926e03d8","localRef":"s25"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:407a45488c47e1a4cafa2b59","scopeContentSha256":"876efcf6c9c970476211523eafd06f239c121ea710f954d41c9095410963b96d","localRef":"s11"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l12","originalCandidateId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:link:36","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l12","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge:link:36","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:407a45488c47e1a4cafa2b59","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:98b4295e1de2ab1c334cce08","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l12","source":"s11","target":"s25","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["The monomial evolution relations connect a potential-dependent background to axion-induced polarization rotation, conditional on the coupling and recent-roll regime."],"challengeStatement":"Monomial background relations connect field motion to polarization rotation under the specified coupling, abundance and recent-roll assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"de84e99439170b2675fc38133e281739cd905d09bf2176f7b05d636550d2358d","reply.jsonSha256":"6c1522f20588d5a84327f472eab05170ff0d3eda36225ec0ace9f9ddc97f7ad9","reply.raw.txtSha256":"030615ba578cf0b722ed771c01b0a648d663906eee025156e9d465e092cb103b","receipt.jsonSha256":"18bb6a3ef1483f0c0a3014dd137df78ce1e7df0b36fe6ff0db6dfb679a70e583","normalization.jsonSha256":"8ffe97fa062071e4b2def45a386d092c0d7ad65feaad281c1103f4fdc12b828e","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"611c9cba0dd489e3195b884167a256fcc6c17ee6b886d50b6270f88f1a588308"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-00ca19aeee603cb16151-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"dfe84d8ec63eb76645d4e0514c9328876ac395a73a9e0d100cde2b0903929659","reply.jsonSha256":"ca3ac0c0490411401b241e2e0af4f191f5d53df1ec57be1a18e318870226bb8a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"b2c8027291e6f5cb38f6a8c172905cb689d756f054e2253af3f7b62d0b11bb31","receipt.jsonSha256":"7a0f48e49d3ba21e2c5b9bf346eb99ef11cb59b2a179f59bb9ad4fa8ea669d7b","normalization.jsonSha256":"83b6672e51de5af1b40f530599e6072ff4f85dad2c87709a432c30e95ca6f172"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2203.09409","sourceId":"ev:7bffdf81631d1152803f67b19da77508","sourceSha256":"53f03d3b8edf6a4e003a763e07c258975f6732cb3eb187ebca5cd98a6f7cbbc6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/934e579b74c95f97627c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81f52b71f0a4cc45b0f34b94b61218b979273dfb1a9ad5407a0e49bce916d886","pdfPage":10,"start":857,"end":2741,"textSha256":"cdf28a997860d203c6271ee62e411c8247101afa81aa021696824a9b1a0c9c50","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2203.09409","sourceId":"ev:3de9251fe6c010e0607f32809fc4d157","sourceSha256":"53f03d3b8edf6a4e003a763e07c258975f6732cb3eb187ebca5cd98a6f7cbbc6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/934e579b74c95f97627c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81f52b71f0a4cc45b0f34b94b61218b979273dfb1a9ad5407a0e49bce916d886","pdfPage":11,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0e364d32775792a466a7dfd5ad354bfd13cfe9404330878105b68211eb83ccc4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:407a45488c47e1a4cafa2b59"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98b4295e1de2ab1c334cce08"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:407a45488c47e1a4cafa2b59"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98b4295e1de2ab1c334cce08"},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2203.09409","sourceId":"ev:7bffdf81631d1152803f67b19da77508","sourceSha256":"53f03d3b8edf6a4e003a763e07c258975f6732cb3eb187ebca5cd98a6f7cbbc6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/934e579b74c95f97627c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81f52b71f0a4cc45b0f34b94b61218b979273dfb1a9ad5407a0e49bce916d886","pdfPage":10,"start":857,"end":2741,"textSha256":"cdf28a997860d203c6271ee62e411c8247101afa81aa021696824a9b1a0c9c50","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2203.09409","sourceId":"ev:3de9251fe6c010e0607f32809fc4d157","sourceSha256":"53f03d3b8edf6a4e003a763e07c258975f6732cb3eb187ebca5cd98a6f7cbbc6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/934e579b74c95f97627c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81f52b71f0a4cc45b0f34b94b61218b979273dfb1a9ad5407a0e49bce916d886","pdfPage":11,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0e364d32775792a466a7dfd5ad354bfd13cfe9404330878105b68211eb83ccc4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d12","originalRef":"l12","status":"route","source":"s25","target":"s11","type":"application_of","title":"Use monomial background evolution in axion polarization-rotation models","rationale":"The polarization-rotation contribution applies potential-dependent field-evolution relations, so the signal question points to the underlying background dynamics.","qualification":"Retain the specified axion coupling, abundance and recent-roll regime from the two statements. Potential shape and field boundary data jointly determine the relevant history. This application does not extend those assumptions to the other collapse, spectator, scalar-tensor or gravitational-wave questions in s25, and it establishes no current signal detection.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l12","s25","s11"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d12","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The polarization-rotation example uses monomial background-evolution relations, supporting the reversed application arrow. The qualification combines the coupling and recent-roll conditions with the abundance condition supplied by the independent statement, without transferring them to the other signal mechanisms in s25.","refs":["l12","s11","s25"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l12","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l13":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l13","source":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","target":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2","type":"method_for","title":"Organize attractor dynamics with admissible radial generators","rationale":"First-order radial generators supply the method for organizing attractor dynamics; the original arrow therefore requires reversal.","qualification":"An admissible generator and appropriate boundary conditions must be established in the stated extremal model. Global existence remains separate. Hamilton–Jacobi and standard fake-superpotential formulations are not universally identical, radial orientation accompanies monotonicity claims, and a formulation alone proves neither existence nor stability or uniqueness of an attractor.","evidenceIds":["unit:061875dcc30d1b8da4858ce9119fec3f0a0332c10d1297bfee281b823fb05617","unit:06190326ea6557dddf43224caad297e2d6d26f18696ed51af1f77bea3720db49","unit:06f00059ec0527c30284350afc99332ed924cf941fc5c17c9bce0ae018029f52","unit:1f6894b64b171d7633fbedb836da22d139929ff67c7464ac85a329ac7945a845","unit:54d81b36d210085443584b65f5f1c1487f796ca4f909c5b48972b5dab2873c71","unit:5b70fc9f833fe954843ad51f107baaa5ce66af010728563579854ca2562a919b","unit:8753b59c55475c3451c34ea7de444f624d9f1286a14bae7cc076dfea08ee3c6c","unit:8cc9692e8b26830ac513ee02996cbee01e6f0bc04d8928d934832c1326210c59","unit:9c32e248b69dfeda0dea51636dd14c04cc878d0b924c3dcc8b8a17a3c222600e","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:b63620729941a0bb6ef110f020cd03719262623830b3044a8dd8f53c81e68cdf","unit:bdb72f9bd07de83cf2e69fab9965b91e776fda276ccb25f06e2fd8430cc99234","unit:c82868f2de6c8d5e337785d9510ab83df6b6a8189a9ea394153d0928002068ed","unit:cff479ec2fcdfe199adc982ae8a2b9b490f064c9b77a9e4d1db166f302b35a74","unit:d51acc6431d81cacf2749e55a85e9164e55568157504350c84560c11c9cd7f21","unit:dab83aafc1ba7e84ce962d19c7fe7dbd6fb7b160a96a84d2896ead4067aeda35"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","scopeContentSha256":"adf1ee534d57caec5e7868f6f95c54a002a09499317c7dda1ce59f29ca8df25a","localRef":"s36"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2","scopeContentSha256":"4f90e7106600b4b59e94602de6ee76a6e95e4b586bb0d4e252e1e49b52f9da53","localRef":"s26"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l13","originalCandidateId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge:link:42","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l13","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge:link:42","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l13","source":"s26","target":"s36","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["First-order radial generators can organize attractor dynamics where admissible; their global existence is a separate question."],"challengeStatement":"Admissible first-order generators can organize radial attraction; global existence remains a separate question.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5cfa3fbc6230938417f752789e5b19629bea85493a107ce0a9edccfa8debf5ce","reply.jsonSha256":"ed0ddf2aa48827f39ee29f0738396b0de6c107c9a4e4f803262c2f3103860945","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f2184132d59aa6e5d2de7b3bd1b8e5e969f1538f58bfd809c690af54a0bff09e","receipt.jsonSha256":"da83a02e8e5d2e7920d535543a9de9c3a9a22870cd37251e6bcf32850800f7fc","normalization.jsonSha256":"2fd2f708d57b759c35b6f201499146945293785684776a91cceb503f43a72874","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6ce40753b78e58db08e049e9c1a6014b58905f4361e9dc27e04f147328f1a5bb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bc5c8121ee29c96d699bf39e479f9d07f30411182d1f9cc646afb0edfabadaff","reply.jsonSha256":"3467d7c089ba60097d869d8a855916e06138b64628659fd6f47b104ea9819116","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ac8f446c753c13e70c728faa83431989b9d0b5ff7dc04678079bde0c98a2de24","receipt.jsonSha256":"fb13edb637a6330cbcf3d41a89db0d1cb8d4e2d18bb9acb545e688ef7b37d2d8","normalization.jsonSha256":"cc105d678855ba283b2b06939fc7ce8cb8163aaad4ea7de3c0876311b34a3559"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c"},{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2"},{"ref":"e14","kind":"primary","paperId":"0706.0712","sourceId":"ev:f4e8091454ba8a25b411de15bc087815","sourceSha256":"5dfe51df0e6803754f65c3ccbd8bacb94b8b3b476966377e7b2e6d79afb909e2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/177a54c48c026a3107ba/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fc26779c0f2af4314289c232d849b751a918cee7ae733234367621b21ed5c7de","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":1756,"textSha256":"db3b1316481578a861539499aa7cce1e3e54980b941630b9ad0834e8da804847","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2"},{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c"},{"ref":"e14","kind":"primary","paperId":"0706.0712","sourceId":"ev:f4e8091454ba8a25b411de15bc087815","sourceSha256":"5dfe51df0e6803754f65c3ccbd8bacb94b8b3b476966377e7b2e6d79afb909e2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/177a54c48c026a3107ba/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fc26779c0f2af4314289c232d849b751a918cee7ae733234367621b21ed5c7de","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":1756,"textSha256":"db3b1316481578a861539499aa7cce1e3e54980b941630b9ad0834e8da804847","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d13","originalRef":"l13","status":"route","source":"s36","target":"s26","type":"method_for","title":"Organize attractor dynamics with admissible radial generators","rationale":"First-order radial generators supply the method for organizing attractor dynamics; the original arrow therefore requires reversal.","qualification":"An admissible generator and appropriate boundary conditions must be established in the stated extremal model. Global existence remains separate. Hamilton–Jacobi and standard fake-superpotential formulations are not universally identical, radial orientation accompanies monotonicity claims, and a formulation alone proves neither existence nor stability or uniqueness of an attractor.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l13","s36","s26"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d13","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Admissible first-order radial generators supply a method for organizing attractor dynamics, requiring reversal. The record preserves generator and boundary requirements, radial orientation and the unresolved global-existence question without asserting automatic attractor existence, stability or uniqueness.","refs":["l13","s26","s36"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l13","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l14":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l14","source":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","target":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2","type":"method_for","title":"Check the domain of first-order formulations for attractor solutions","rationale":"Radial generators and fake superpotentials provide the related dynamical formulations discussed in the statements, placing the method at s36.","qualification":"Existence, boundary conditions and any nonextremal extension require separate justification. The attractor endpoint concerns its specified extremal settings; nonextremal radial formulations do not automatically establish attractor results there. Global generators and a universal reduction of Hamilton–Jacobi dynamics to standard fake flow remain unverified. This record preserves l14 independently of l13.","evidenceIds":["unit:061875dcc30d1b8da4858ce9119fec3f0a0332c10d1297bfee281b823fb05617","unit:06190326ea6557dddf43224caad297e2d6d26f18696ed51af1f77bea3720db49","unit:06f00059ec0527c30284350afc99332ed924cf941fc5c17c9bce0ae018029f52","unit:1f6894b64b171d7633fbedb836da22d139929ff67c7464ac85a329ac7945a845","unit:54d81b36d210085443584b65f5f1c1487f796ca4f909c5b48972b5dab2873c71","unit:5b70fc9f833fe954843ad51f107baaa5ce66af010728563579854ca2562a919b","unit:8753b59c55475c3451c34ea7de444f624d9f1286a14bae7cc076dfea08ee3c6c","unit:8cc9692e8b26830ac513ee02996cbee01e6f0bc04d8928d934832c1326210c59","unit:9c32e248b69dfeda0dea51636dd14c04cc878d0b924c3dcc8b8a17a3c222600e","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:b63620729941a0bb6ef110f020cd03719262623830b3044a8dd8f53c81e68cdf","unit:bdb72f9bd07de83cf2e69fab9965b91e776fda276ccb25f06e2fd8430cc99234","unit:c82868f2de6c8d5e337785d9510ab83df6b6a8189a9ea394153d0928002068ed","unit:cff479ec2fcdfe199adc982ae8a2b9b490f064c9b77a9e4d1db166f302b35a74","unit:d51acc6431d81cacf2749e55a85e9164e55568157504350c84560c11c9cd7f21","unit:dab83aafc1ba7e84ce962d19c7fe7dbd6fb7b160a96a84d2896ead4067aeda35"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","scopeContentSha256":"adf1ee534d57caec5e7868f6f95c54a002a09499317c7dda1ce59f29ca8df25a","localRef":"s36"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2","scopeContentSha256":"4f90e7106600b4b59e94602de6ee76a6e95e4b586bb0d4e252e1e49b52f9da53","localRef":"s26"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l14","originalCandidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:19","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l14","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:19","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l14","source":"s26","target":"s36","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Radial generators and fake superpotentials offer related dynamical formulations, with separate existence and nonextremal restrictions."],"challengeStatement":"Radial generators provide related formulations with separate existence, boundary and nonextremal conditions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2"},{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2"},{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d14","originalRef":"l14","status":"route","source":"s36","target":"s26","type":"method_for","title":"Check the domain of first-order formulations for attractor solutions","rationale":"Radial generators and fake superpotentials provide the related dynamical formulations discussed in the statements, placing the method at s36.","qualification":"Existence, boundary conditions and any nonextremal extension require separate justification. The attractor endpoint concerns its specified extremal settings; nonextremal radial formulations do not automatically establish attractor results there. Global generators and a universal reduction of Hamilton–Jacobi dynamics to standard fake flow remain unverified. This record preserves l14 independently of l13.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l14","s36","s26"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d14","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The methodological contribution again resides at s36. This original relation specifically retains existence, boundary and nonextremal restrictions, which the proposal preserves. It remains accounted for under its own originalRef without inferring identity with, or adding another copy of, l13.","refs":["l14","s26","s36"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l14","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l15":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l15","source":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","target":"q025-candidate-region:e8d76d9907161eb0534206f7","type":"method_for","title":"Apply qualified first-order radial methods to black-hole dynamics","rationale":"First-order radial dynamics supplies a method for the radial and horizon questions within the broader black-hole region, requiring reversal.","qualification":"Restrict use to the stated supergravity radial reductions with admissible generators and appropriate boundary conditions. Keep radial orientation, BPS or non-BPS extremality, regular or small-hole limits and separately qualified nonextremal extensions explicit. Radial evolution is distinct from physical time and auxiliary geometric flow. The method does not cover every entropy, spectral or microscopic question in s39.","evidenceIds":["unit:06190326ea6557dddf43224caad297e2d6d26f18696ed51af1f77bea3720db49","unit:1f6894b64b171d7633fbedb836da22d139929ff67c7464ac85a329ac7945a845","unit:4ef40fc75357132f351e7b8958adb569e5803344fef42b39053c139088d8bbed","unit:54d81b36d210085443584b65f5f1c1487f796ca4f909c5b48972b5dab2873c71","unit:5b70fc9f833fe954843ad51f107baaa5ce66af010728563579854ca2562a919b","unit:8753b59c55475c3451c34ea7de444f624d9f1286a14bae7cc076dfea08ee3c6c","unit:8cc9692e8b26830ac513ee02996cbee01e6f0bc04d8928d934832c1326210c59","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:b63620729941a0bb6ef110f020cd03719262623830b3044a8dd8f53c81e68cdf","unit:bdb72f9bd07de83cf2e69fab9965b91e776fda276ccb25f06e2fd8430cc99234","unit:cceaa3bfcc201207993f4ea13cdf3e0b51d16dd54831a1207e883fec12ff0214","unit:cff479ec2fcdfe199adc982ae8a2b9b490f064c9b77a9e4d1db166f302b35a74","unit:d51acc6431d81cacf2749e55a85e9164e55568157504350c84560c11c9cd7f21","unit:df7475646db43f4f4853741aacbb5d06f91a3328bd2ec383e6daf98635f9cf76"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","scopeContentSha256":"adf1ee534d57caec5e7868f6f95c54a002a09499317c7dda1ce59f29ca8df25a","localRef":"s36"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:e8d76d9907161eb0534206f7","scopeContentSha256":"9867d8efaf9495607e6969b82ac4a73e26452ae5c9f440a19207c0fad4400d6e","localRef":"s39"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l15","originalCandidateId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge:link:8","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l15","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge:link:8","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:e8d76d9907161eb0534206f7","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l15","source":"s39","target":"s36","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["First-order radial dynamics supplies a method route with generator, orientation and regime qualifications."],"challengeStatement":"First-order radial dynamics provides a method route with generator-admissibility, orientation and regime qualifications.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5cfa3fbc6230938417f752789e5b19629bea85493a107ce0a9edccfa8debf5ce","reply.jsonSha256":"ed0ddf2aa48827f39ee29f0738396b0de6c107c9a4e4f803262c2f3103860945","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f2184132d59aa6e5d2de7b3bd1b8e5e969f1538f58bfd809c690af54a0bff09e","receipt.jsonSha256":"da83a02e8e5d2e7920d535543a9de9c3a9a22870cd37251e6bcf32850800f7fc","normalization.jsonSha256":"2fd2f708d57b759c35b6f201499146945293785684776a91cceb503f43a72874","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6ce40753b78e58db08e049e9c1a6014b58905f4361e9dc27e04f147328f1a5bb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bc5c8121ee29c96d699bf39e479f9d07f30411182d1f9cc646afb0edfabadaff","reply.jsonSha256":"3467d7c089ba60097d869d8a855916e06138b64628659fd6f47b104ea9819116","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ac8f446c753c13e70c728faa83431989b9d0b5ff7dc04678079bde0c98a2de24","receipt.jsonSha256":"fb13edb637a6330cbcf3d41a89db0d1cb8d4e2d18bb9acb545e688ef7b37d2d8","normalization.jsonSha256":"cc105d678855ba283b2b06939fc7ce8cb8163aaad4ea7de3c0876311b34a3559"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c"},{"ref":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"0706.0712","sourceId":"ev:f091921461cab98b38e9fee6cd2a0567","sourceSha256":"5dfe51df0e6803754f65c3ccbd8bacb94b8b3b476966377e7b2e6d79afb909e2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/177a54c48c026a3107ba/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fc26779c0f2af4314289c232d849b751a918cee7ae733234367621b21ed5c7de","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":1412,"textSha256":"9e6bd99a8da5c1d1093e396392f6ce7b27056eba0f8788fbcc1215cdf3c0b414","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e14","kind":"primary","paperId":"0706.0712","sourceId":"ev:f4e8091454ba8a25b411de15bc087815","sourceSha256":"5dfe51df0e6803754f65c3ccbd8bacb94b8b3b476966377e7b2e6d79afb909e2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/177a54c48c026a3107ba/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fc26779c0f2af4314289c232d849b751a918cee7ae733234367621b21ed5c7de","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":1756,"textSha256":"db3b1316481578a861539499aa7cce1e3e54980b941630b9ad0834e8da804847","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c"},{"ref":"e13","kind":"primary","paperId":"0706.0712","sourceId":"ev:f091921461cab98b38e9fee6cd2a0567","sourceSha256":"5dfe51df0e6803754f65c3ccbd8bacb94b8b3b476966377e7b2e6d79afb909e2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/177a54c48c026a3107ba/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fc26779c0f2af4314289c232d849b751a918cee7ae733234367621b21ed5c7de","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":1412,"textSha256":"9e6bd99a8da5c1d1093e396392f6ce7b27056eba0f8788fbcc1215cdf3c0b414","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e14","kind":"primary","paperId":"0706.0712","sourceId":"ev:f4e8091454ba8a25b411de15bc087815","sourceSha256":"5dfe51df0e6803754f65c3ccbd8bacb94b8b3b476966377e7b2e6d79afb909e2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/177a54c48c026a3107ba/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fc26779c0f2af4314289c232d849b751a918cee7ae733234367621b21ed5c7de","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":1756,"textSha256":"db3b1316481578a861539499aa7cce1e3e54980b941630b9ad0834e8da804847","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d15","originalRef":"l15","status":"route","source":"s36","target":"s39","type":"method_for","title":"Apply qualified first-order radial methods to black-hole dynamics","rationale":"First-order radial dynamics supplies a method for the radial and horizon questions within the broader black-hole region, requiring reversal.","qualification":"Restrict use to the stated supergravity radial reductions with admissible generators and appropriate boundary conditions. Keep radial orientation, BPS or non-BPS extremality, regular or small-hole limits and separately qualified nonextremal extensions explicit. Radial evolution is distinct from physical time and auxiliary geometric flow. The method does not cover every entropy, spectral or microscopic question in s39.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l15","s36","s39"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d15","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"First-order radial dynamics supplies methods for the radial and horizon questions within s39, supporting reversal. The qualification limits their reach to the stated reductions and admissible generators, preserving radial orientation and extremality restrictions without extending the method to the entire black-hole region.","refs":["l15","s39","s36"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l15","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l16":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l16","source":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2","target":"q025-candidate-question:16f5a1e00af6a60aab217f56","type":"method_for","title":"Determine qualified horizon scalar data and entropy through attractor extremization","rationale":"Attractor extremization supplies the method for selected horizon questions within black-object construction, so s26 is the source.","qualification":"Use only the stated extremal supergravity settings and their charge, scalar-geometry and boundary assumptions. Existence and stability of extrema remain model-specific, and ungauged central-charge and gauged boundary-action prescriptions are distinct. Horizon data do not construct every exterior, prove uniqueness or transfer classical finite-area conclusions to quantum-corrected small black holes.","evidenceIds":["unit:061875dcc30d1b8da4858ce9119fec3f0a0332c10d1297bfee281b823fb05617","unit:06f00059ec0527c30284350afc99332ed924cf941fc5c17c9bce0ae018029f52","unit:145a3df72cea777bbc4b03efb5b9d7501a4fe473fdd070f8d634c258553dd062","unit:9c32e248b69dfeda0dea51636dd14c04cc878d0b924c3dcc8b8a17a3c222600e","unit:a741c99ea00d61ae2c87cd25f3e8656453f01bca5c2469aa09a660b7d35d8da9","unit:bdb72f9bd07de83cf2e69fab9965b91e776fda276ccb25f06e2fd8430cc99234","unit:c82868f2de6c8d5e337785d9510ab83df6b6a8189a9ea394153d0928002068ed","unit:dab83aafc1ba7e84ce962d19c7fe7dbd6fb7b160a96a84d2896ead4067aeda35"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2","scopeContentSha256":"4f90e7106600b4b59e94602de6ee76a6e95e4b586bb0d4e252e1e49b52f9da53","localRef":"s26"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:16f5a1e00af6a60aab217f56","scopeContentSha256":"89651f41e168ab65f9e612d5759bb94aad586771e4745d3c1d84bfcd61f4c945","localRef":"s3"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l16","originalCandidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:18","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l16","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge:link:18","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:16f5a1e00af6a60aab217f56","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l16","source":"s3","target":"s26","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Attractor extremization supplies a qualified route to horizon scalar data and entropy; it is distinct from full exterior construction."],"challengeStatement":"Attractor extremization addresses horizon scalar data and entropy without constructing every exterior solution.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4bb1a956cb77dba1037ba6874413ba020370a9216fb83aaa77df17c486031997","reply.jsonSha256":"7ed90616c9778f81b207849be9eb5c8409d60aa01bcf4fa4ba0f82a137736fad","reply.raw.txtSha256":"1605d42dff89a5b7a6cbff7a5a315cb0cfb446cc18252608c960506fe134399f","receipt.jsonSha256":"e5add70abe2446f9953d851b615e12c3d529adad3e15776cce0aef28253a3d4e","normalization.jsonSha256":"20983be2b64fdaa40877e44a24a9bfc798be5097bd8a610cbce551867e6840b1","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a79cb182775aefb66d46362ff77438d46e292423ae0231bac805c0d51209c97b"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-278f3b8c9fe4a9756c61-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"89c6af5255cb0d9db7e64c1b5fee75c4e9730fd707b1b3bc5cd516c3eb533e80","reply.jsonSha256":"9e2fdce2126ab70b53c1110b62f3116ab4d2f2cc13a2035a82aff7a29dfca03a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"70d9e64f768234870af153ceedc7cc45c03f096b78ba825f8754a34aa866b7ff","receipt.jsonSha256":"77b1db77d3b7907330d3586fdc77d8b6a9624a16a4d8910d2656d0e3a541cd0a","normalization.jsonSha256":"3740e089a87eb0581833097a529ac1c370b8be552604bfa9b91dee4f7656deb4"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9602136","sourceId":"ev:37bf7d4149a1a8843cd54fdaad51e9bb","sourceSha256":"f3f40420b8e1a5a84fe28502d610c10a206be0902ed1f2ea17690fc4f1427953","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8043b58cc8da05c51d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f473373d5c6d483eedddd072c080a47d2acb9c908cbbc0ceb796f5c201c0595a","pdfPage":2,"start":102,"end":3202,"textSha256":"11cde44e28313a16005b12f9484d1a2fbe3e4ee77e02efbf268cdf5ddd305b42","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9602136","sourceId":"ev:7fc6c44aea43e8cf34cdac6756edd412","sourceSha256":"f3f40420b8e1a5a84fe28502d610c10a206be0902ed1f2ea17690fc4f1427953","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8043b58cc8da05c51d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f473373d5c6d483eedddd072c080a47d2acb9c908cbbc0ceb796f5c201c0595a","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1661,"textSha256":"3595582650116bc84408ee92867b0fb342eb11f391596b1502bf38173014da84","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:98c1d1d5dbd99d4a80ad03a2"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9602136","sourceId":"ev:37bf7d4149a1a8843cd54fdaad51e9bb","sourceSha256":"f3f40420b8e1a5a84fe28502d610c10a206be0902ed1f2ea17690fc4f1427953","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8043b58cc8da05c51d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f473373d5c6d483eedddd072c080a47d2acb9c908cbbc0ceb796f5c201c0595a","pdfPage":2,"start":102,"end":3202,"textSha256":"11cde44e28313a16005b12f9484d1a2fbe3e4ee77e02efbf268cdf5ddd305b42","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e9","kind":"primary","paperId":"hep-th/9602136","sourceId":"ev:7fc6c44aea43e8cf34cdac6756edd412","sourceSha256":"f3f40420b8e1a5a84fe28502d610c10a206be0902ed1f2ea17690fc4f1427953","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a8043b58cc8da05c51d5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f473373d5c6d483eedddd072c080a47d2acb9c908cbbc0ceb796f5c201c0595a","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1661,"textSha256":"3595582650116bc84408ee92867b0fb342eb11f391596b1502bf38173014da84","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d16","originalRef":"l16","status":"route","source":"s26","target":"s3","type":"method_for","title":"Determine qualified horizon scalar data and entropy through attractor extremization","rationale":"Attractor extremization supplies the method for selected horizon questions within black-object construction, so s26 is the source.","qualification":"Use only the stated extremal supergravity settings and their charge, scalar-geometry and boundary assumptions. Existence and stability of extrema remain model-specific, and ungauged central-charge and gauged boundary-action prescriptions are distinct. Horizon data do not construct every exterior, prove uniqueness or transfer classical finite-area conclusions to quantum-corrected small black holes.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l16","s26","s3"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d16","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Attractor extremization supplies the stated method for selected horizon scalar data and entropy, so s26 is the source. The record preserves extremal, model and boundary assumptions and distinguishes this local information from complete exterior construction or a uniqueness result.","refs":["l16","s3","s26"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l16","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l17":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l17","source":"q025-candidate-question:71452c3d2d77c2fcae6c1218","target":"q025-candidate-question:674aafcb45db8090fc96bf44","type":"application_of","title":"Locate the scaling geometries underlying the throat-distance question","rationale":"Distance analysis is applied to specified scaling geometries and adds a physical metric-normalization question beyond their construction.","qualification":"Restrict the connection to the fixed-charge multicentre scaling setting, including the supplied five-dimensional bubbling example. The explicit phase-space calculation is specialized to three centres. Spacetime throat length and moduli-space distance differ; canonical phase-space and mass-inferred distances remain competing candidates, possibly neither correctly normalized. No physical kinetic metric, settled finite or infinite distance, or generalized Distance Conjecture is established.","evidenceIds":["unit:143466b9c2dc1ac90c1dcc5eab875b9ee7bd867f2cd9fd85246726d1071431ce","unit:3f2f69fb8c668fddeaa76a883c972d513a7bc718c04789617a6519df5e91adb0","unit:4157b87f10a4c44adfecec19618b2b92affecec6ea52e24b488b9ff19293048d","unit:4ef40fc75357132f351e7b8958adb569e5803344fef42b39053c139088d8bbed","unit:73ef3bbcadd7cbee3f1ccb4bb1d2f8d52a75dce2daf340811464bce5ad7c0fe4","unit:76191baaf8d0024da5e54a238a72c9fa79965c3d9a7e1062389663c1f5939dfc","unit:9310e7bbf90b447ff4cf5211763289e4371676a39f5717b35643c13de853648d"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:71452c3d2d77c2fcae6c1218","scopeContentSha256":"995a36e8a42061f6b5fa9dca6f9aeffb598d5b22e011344a6e0d67baf05c8ab6","localRef":"s18"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:674aafcb45db8090fc96bf44","scopeContentSha256":"d84c729971afbe393b4646b6aa540eb0ffb2f402c599de09da8c7137f1c1e603","localRef":"s15"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l17","originalCandidateId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge:link:44","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l17","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge:link:44","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:674aafcb45db8090fc96bf44","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:71452c3d2d77c2fcae6c1218","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l17","source":"s15","target":"s18","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Distance analysis applies to specified scaling geometries, adding a metric-normalization question beyond throat construction."],"challengeStatement":"Distance analysis adds a physical metric and normalization question to specified scaling geometries.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5cfa3fbc6230938417f752789e5b19629bea85493a107ce0a9edccfa8debf5ce","reply.jsonSha256":"ed0ddf2aa48827f39ee29f0738396b0de6c107c9a4e4f803262c2f3103860945","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f2184132d59aa6e5d2de7b3bd1b8e5e969f1538f58bfd809c690af54a0bff09e","receipt.jsonSha256":"da83a02e8e5d2e7920d535543a9de9c3a9a22870cd37251e6bcf32850800f7fc","normalization.jsonSha256":"2fd2f708d57b759c35b6f201499146945293785684776a91cceb503f43a72874","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6ce40753b78e58db08e049e9c1a6014b58905f4361e9dc27e04f147328f1a5bb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bc5c8121ee29c96d699bf39e479f9d07f30411182d1f9cc646afb0edfabadaff","reply.jsonSha256":"3467d7c089ba60097d869d8a855916e06138b64628659fd6f47b104ea9819116","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ac8f446c753c13e70c728faa83431989b9d0b5ff7dc04678079bde0c98a2de24","receipt.jsonSha256":"fb13edb637a6330cbcf3d41a89db0d1cb8d4e2d18bb9acb545e688ef7b37d2d8","normalization.jsonSha256":"cc105d678855ba283b2b06939fc7ce8cb8163aaad4ea7de3c0876311b34a3559"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:674aafcb45db8090fc96bf44"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:71452c3d2d77c2fcae6c1218"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:674aafcb45db8090fc96bf44"},{"ref":"x3_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:71452c3d2d77c2fcae6c1218"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d17","originalRef":"l17","status":"route","source":"s18","target":"s15","type":"application_of","title":"Locate the scaling geometries underlying the throat-distance question","rationale":"Distance analysis is applied to specified scaling geometries and adds a physical metric-normalization question beyond their construction.","qualification":"Restrict the connection to the fixed-charge multicentre scaling setting, including the supplied five-dimensional bubbling example. The explicit phase-space calculation is specialized to three centres. Spacetime throat length and moduli-space distance differ; canonical phase-space and mass-inferred distances remain competing candidates, possibly neither correctly normalized. No physical kinetic metric, settled finite or infinite distance, or generalized Distance Conjecture is established.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l17","s18","s15"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d17","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The distance question applies its analysis to the specified scaling constructions, supporting s18 → s15. The construction is identified even though the physical distance prescription remains unsettled. The qualification preserves the three-center specialization, competing normalizations and distinction between throat length and moduli-space distance.","refs":["l17","s15","s18"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l17","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l18":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l18","source":"q025-candidate-question:772085c815dfeafbe9071d77","target":"q025-candidate-question:a31754bfdb42eed547f22213","type":"method_for","title":"Compute selected corrected observables with higher-derivative thermodynamic methods","rationale":"The thermodynamic endpoint supplies methods for selected corrected observables in the broader corrections and EFT question, requiring reversal.","qualification":"Keep the renormalized Gauss–Bonnet analysis and the Euclidean-action perturbation method distinct. The latter requires a known zeroth-order solution and thermodynamics, is first order in the added coupling with exact dependence on original background couplings, and aligns AdS boundary geometry. Worked examples are static and spherical; rotating use is conditional. These methods do not encompass every charged-loop or nonperturbative contribution.","evidenceIds":["unit:06f00059ec0527c30284350afc99332ed924cf941fc5c17c9bce0ae018029f52","unit:2be669014ca84fc8e35e163bd77c219f5fad9e0126442cf4ef7d60401e91c9b1","unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","unit:632375f47b6ebe7abe302950673fb2c489271d92fc2110cd14ac0990dcb709a5","unit:787534e2e35e019673c656715a983d3413316961ea455fd7e07a57627a3fe3dd","unit:8fb8681ed4c1713cb3f5958c5fe59b314fd128c7218c61f47882c58cfce2fade","unit:f009c07cff3302e24297f122f9b02532a01c1e3dbf2564b848ae94e80cbb4ddf"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:772085c815dfeafbe9071d77","scopeContentSha256":"ee08b354b21b4a2af50a86b8ce20d93505fab27d10a273be55ecd570517d24a2","localRef":"s21"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a31754bfdb42eed547f22213","scopeContentSha256":"f3ec456d680a10871e9d42736a7a463a599065be3fb0b0880a089c4e916ff4bc","localRef":"s27"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l18","originalCandidateId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge:link:49","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l18","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge:link:49","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:a31754bfdb42eed547f22213","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:772085c815dfeafbe9071d77","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l18","source":"s27","target":"s21","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Higher-derivative thermodynamic methods address selected corrected observables under boundary and perturbative-order conditions."],"challengeStatement":"Higher-derivative thermodynamic methods require appropriate boundary data and perturbative-order control.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5cfa3fbc6230938417f752789e5b19629bea85493a107ce0a9edccfa8debf5ce","reply.jsonSha256":"ed0ddf2aa48827f39ee29f0738396b0de6c107c9a4e4f803262c2f3103860945","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f2184132d59aa6e5d2de7b3bd1b8e5e969f1538f58bfd809c690af54a0bff09e","receipt.jsonSha256":"da83a02e8e5d2e7920d535543a9de9c3a9a22870cd37251e6bcf32850800f7fc","normalization.jsonSha256":"2fd2f708d57b759c35b6f201499146945293785684776a91cceb503f43a72874","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"6ce40753b78e58db08e049e9c1a6014b58905f4361e9dc27e04f147328f1a5bb"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-0177419a6060a2f477fb-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"bc5c8121ee29c96d699bf39e479f9d07f30411182d1f9cc646afb0edfabadaff","reply.jsonSha256":"3467d7c089ba60097d869d8a855916e06138b64628659fd6f47b104ea9819116","reply.raw.txtSha256":"ac8f446c753c13e70c728faa83431989b9d0b5ff7dc04678079bde0c98a2de24","receipt.jsonSha256":"fb13edb637a6330cbcf3d41a89db0d1cb8d4e2d18bb9acb545e688ef7b37d2d8","normalization.jsonSha256":"cc105d678855ba283b2b06939fc7ce8cb8163aaad4ea7de3c0876311b34a3559"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:772085c815dfeafbe9071d77"},{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a31754bfdb42eed547f22213"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a31754bfdb42eed547f22213"},{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:772085c815dfeafbe9071d77"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d18","originalRef":"l18","status":"route","source":"s21","target":"s27","type":"method_for","title":"Compute selected corrected observables with higher-derivative thermodynamic methods","rationale":"The thermodynamic endpoint supplies methods for selected corrected observables in the broader corrections and EFT question, requiring reversal.","qualification":"Keep the renormalized Gauss–Bonnet analysis and the Euclidean-action perturbation method distinct. The latter requires a known zeroth-order solution and thermodynamics, is first order in the added coupling with exact dependence on original background couplings, and aligns AdS boundary geometry. Worked examples are static and spherical; rotating use is conditional. These methods do not encompass every charged-loop or nonperturbative contribution.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l18","s21","s27"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d18","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Higher-derivative thermodynamic techniques at s21 supply methods for selected corrected observables at s27. Reversal is justified. The record keeps the two techniques distinct and preserves known-background requirements, perturbative order, AdS boundary matching and conditional rotating applicability.","refs":["l18","s27","s21"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l18","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l19":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l19","source":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","target":"q025-candidate-question:8211fbc50be30b9432116b18","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on deformations and holographic observables","rationale":"Deformation and holographic-data questions refine the compactification region's explicitly included background and holographic-application scope. The region is not itself a specific construction being applied.","qualification":"Retain each asymptotic, boundary, global-identification and duality assumption, along with the stated classical or large-N regime. Continuous supergravity families do not establish full quantum conformal manifolds or stability. Defect, finite-density and nonconformal applications remain distinct. Parent membership does not admit pending child revisions or certify their results.","evidenceIds":["unit:02fbdcb6b4fdb0428a6afa393914a399bfc8a652d4310d6a639537f21b92bb9d","unit:134d4e1478bede164105461ea180e7a41159e2f787b5e3275352dff2e6dc6bee","unit:25ebea21cbbe38fc1acaf95d5a4b9e504bfaec733a18c9091c0353bf60c14ab1","unit:27fdee1ff47052f3d4e3151c877b0dfd1cc57675dbe8fb6f29bae712840ad5a9","unit:2df68cc360d9803367e006001b21a7bff4856ea790d4dd173a8196c7644cfe59","unit:2f50fe2b718f6d7fafad6a50c2595b3043d5e5bf561262050e1824efcfed0bc5","unit:33feb2742465568f279d791d8fb9208b72621dab648520e4984ed680f175bd89","unit:3de8258a77c4c2f06ef8cdec44e03293bf48c78a07c29de61c34240e739342e3","unit:44142501d0c3647f3752342af4cf839b05f38019ebdb6219c60af813bfb17011","unit:45ef74aceef210d62a6384e200f077d1cdabaf7e7f313293da00366634d068e2","unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","unit:5de647cd03f2d3e695f7cb21ac37f2252812c88af5380f5de32847739bdc1f0e","unit:67cdcf4788ad5facf978b6e70065b422dbf1289e67fe8c4e37531c1afdec3166","unit:6886a41547e1252cf92633de38f1c524da2b02cabebac6166313e9a9f608bfdb","unit:70c1cc8c094ed6ae2becd7b304a9e65e9e1d731f7cb9ce8c373c0b9661919d87","unit:81c0354fafeb803ec6ce5fcc5acab5d754dbad435a812758812f6994e25e420b","unit:88bddf8537f4cb0ee1ca998e0b7a5769c66c8c172e5fdffd8bad2bb3e1d762aa","unit:8a8f0604f18053bcc37e203ee1f6e60f6c776ef3f7377c1113d4424b057d3465","unit:8bb6e79262b076c348991d0aac7736d83f5e198e5f78aba95620507d0020030b","unit:8c4b2c9b38c160cf0b570b0eea0d14d4e542beb9790c45907020573922a7ff9e","unit:9630fcb79ebb46dc9caf5465fdc8c294c310fc008776084917590902c462f9df","unit:9afac9e352b65a76e5eed0e6d9c0794b50a9c0c7d1da529c64b1321514451011","unit:a0ec5fb1c09d0256714f564b4b2ac1dae9d71d8d09be8b24ec25376c5f2eecf9","unit:a6d271becc7629cef7152fb4f39fa36f38c22279bfad23e5e36fba7b768152b6","unit:ade9bc25833aedd3c4d90eb12dbdefa7c05c1b8a61f211c4fd0fa1681f4a66a6","unit:bad22b78a74b1bef3b5dd8bcbf9b7d800b3050dfc4875dae017e4915d68caa23","unit:bd8d65ed50bb7108304c5d784df4501032febe6f78e643259d2fc1bceaf8d300","unit:daec1a59347fea16d441e2fc637b9da62976be0979319883b3d1b75e7d55b323","unit:ed17eb8ba083c5ca7f63c8f68e63c2c4e7dc2093440c5259b7f7c418f3b70c32"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","scopeContentSha256":"347fee2f1bd0ea394bafca055d49ebaf5e2ec572becb105f85372571b2bc46cd","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8211fbc50be30b9432116b18","scopeContentSha256":"70da9dc8bbcdb82b3ff8afbe8d3e7ae4064155244a471c90ad17a029c6d09c92","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l19","originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:12","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l19","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:12","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:8211fbc50be30b9432116b18","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l19","source":"s38","target":"s22","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Deformation and holographic-observable questions retain their own asymptotic, boundary and duality assumptions."],"challengeStatement":"Deformations and holographic observables retain their boundary, asymptotic and duality assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5e5d0c0d72fb950ebe1457b76fbc2e2ffd12c38ec05281a20aaea51785edacf2","reply.jsonSha256":"c164a1797f2579dd542d6a85d2d5ada3d3923f51dbf00c5ad7715dfcc3293196","reply.raw.txtSha256":"6fe1f9ffacf3fd23fcd414f8ea84dea076b70b1efa9cc4c1b266645516a3284c","receipt.jsonSha256":"949135a1913dfe4fc7bc496b3d40e6e41cb0fc8289d1ebe30e318c6fbc1fd497","normalization.jsonSha256":"60ac91844e3455fced77f0d35aa125b34a3618b7f066752c3b6583de30ead537","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"12aff7bccd1643b13672aabf092a32b906a1405e7d3f8a924039a2d009499098"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"113090d319770847b1bcf319abc555a657aec606eecef8697c3bfa6cb949a534","reply.jsonSha256":"3f358a065f5156682f2bef99d3ba50ed16c59ef4202316b790a99980a867e52a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"332bdc783baf2d0e00a74757f00a86efa14aa5098688b1b04ac620ab3ec084e9","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a728c710537f0d36937246c575232be90eac650ccbfc3a22c0180680ac5aa50","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e6136e890c81aac9092b885c2b64906f9fc4cccb35942ee78a80d99d814ac23"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8211fbc50be30b9432116b18"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:8211fbc50be30b9432116b18"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d19","originalRef":"l19","status":"route","source":"s38","target":"s22","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on deformations and holographic observables","rationale":"Deformation and holographic-data questions refine the compactification region's explicitly included background and holographic-application scope. The region is not itself a specific construction being applied.","qualification":"Retain each asymptotic, boundary, global-identification and duality assumption, along with the stated classical or large-N regime. Continuous supergravity families do not establish full quantum conformal manifolds or stability. Defect, finite-density and nonconformal applications remain distinct. Parent membership does not admit pending child revisions or certify their results.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l19","s38","s22"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d19","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The complete s38 scope expressly includes associated holographic and field-theory applications, supporting s22 as a refinement rather than an application of an unspecified parent mechanism. Its nonconformal, finite-density and defect components remain covered with their distinct boundary, asymptotic and duality assumptions.","refs":["l19","s38","s22"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l19","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l20":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l20","source":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","target":"q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on uplift and positive-energy vacuum control","rationale":"Positive-energy construction and uplift control refine the broader region's vacuum, stabilization and consistency questions.","qualification":"Keep AdS starting points, uplifted vacua and separate positive-energy branches distinct. Successful AdS construction or a positive potential contribution does not establish a controlled dS vacuum. Small-displacement arguments require control of potential curvature, coefficient scaling, other moduli and fractional mass changes; large volume alone is insufficient. Source-specific corrections, decay and phenomenological tests remain separate.","evidenceIds":["unit:10ff325d4a1e4dff8accc4e543d0343755ef0ea083e701b635ad37f3c3b3d05a","unit:140a27d068fc885807a238d869f87293725cf209d6902e0867cbfc45ea43be1e","unit:2df68cc360d9803367e006001b21a7bff4856ea790d4dd173a8196c7644cfe59","unit:365ea7585a09d912c85771e274590a8193ad7bcacd31dec878d96d89c6d84657","unit:38408412bb2fa795fdc51d56f7623f5e387474cd671d90cabbe96bfc9c6b38bd","unit:45ef74aceef210d62a6384e200f077d1cdabaf7e7f313293da00366634d068e2","unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","unit:59c2447d89549de5a435cc89808953d8264dbc04f227c669d280c23b9853609d","unit:602ea4010f973bdd2b6dc782eb95531e6bd512d1b1ba0bfadab3a1e80759790d","unit:609b4db6a2f88d640c05cbf8df3416972f3cd67a087b2240d1c697e843288bab","unit:6132a5f905836215a4462d4edb5aeea4f8f3179c43599632f87e5cc79c00700a","unit:65b14988261f78fec1cbb38359b2995a2ad3fd68881facccc19a33d14622582e","unit:717b9accb34f11d8453230a5531898b32f8d29e4adbb2f0d3a4261cf57306e3d","unit:724506f6a6094e499812e8d49f4023c4ffd39743a87edaa7fcf9deebd8f4c949","unit:773b44811b4a461b11ad02a5735f3ccf707831e1abfd2084d6908d48a4854b85","unit:7e27a7f1b03a9b3ddef19dbc12d9c743a715e85d8b04d39f6be8742b6ae00ae6","unit:926a8f17bbd42c4b9018a5d5f315a28475859cdfdd6e4f35e1e2ee4a4bbfd8a2","unit:a2fe340b7adccda1c72e87480de5647d55ffddb53540cf879634026a4fbe0cd1","unit:acecb6dca2ff654f444787a747727899241cd555089cfd2e80b48539197b0c18","unit:b6327667ae3d048cd2b81005de30206c8a6d2cd3c2165861868d2e348c86ecb3","unit:c2ec6fe7d0010dba5dad7ac3017e27fba7315410f1c28d14cbb2a39f4b6be0a3","unit:daec1a59347fea16d441e2fc637b9da62976be0979319883b3d1b75e7d55b323","unit:ecf167dfedd3b40e3b05194ad0c5b107e84f533b2e1889958c2c85e22c850f6d","unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","scopeContentSha256":"347fee2f1bd0ea394bafca055d49ebaf5e2ec572becb105f85372571b2bc46cd","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1","scopeContentSha256":"2398cac8767f326f9cb6ddc3c7f394f8c136847258c0eeb7c4a88571bd77d19a","localRef":"s10"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l20","originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:13","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l20","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:13","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l20","source":"s38","target":"s10","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Positive-energy and uplift questions test stabilization and consistency in a different phase; successful AdS construction alone does not settle them."],"challengeStatement":"Positive-energy constructions and uplift test a distinct phase; AdS construction alone does not establish their control.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5e5d0c0d72fb950ebe1457b76fbc2e2ffd12c38ec05281a20aaea51785edacf2","reply.jsonSha256":"c164a1797f2579dd542d6a85d2d5ada3d3923f51dbf00c5ad7715dfcc3293196","reply.raw.txtSha256":"6fe1f9ffacf3fd23fcd414f8ea84dea076b70b1efa9cc4c1b266645516a3284c","receipt.jsonSha256":"949135a1913dfe4fc7bc496b3d40e6e41cb0fc8289d1ebe30e318c6fbc1fd497","normalization.jsonSha256":"60ac91844e3455fced77f0d35aa125b34a3618b7f066752c3b6583de30ead537","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"12aff7bccd1643b13672aabf092a32b906a1405e7d3f8a924039a2d009499098"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"113090d319770847b1bcf319abc555a657aec606eecef8697c3bfa6cb949a534","reply.jsonSha256":"3f358a065f5156682f2bef99d3ba50ed16c59ef4202316b790a99980a867e52a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"332bdc783baf2d0e00a74757f00a86efa14aa5098688b1b04ac620ab3ec084e9","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a728c710537f0d36937246c575232be90eac650ccbfc3a22c0180680ac5aa50","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e6136e890c81aac9092b885c2b64906f9fc4cccb35942ee78a80d99d814ac23"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d20","originalRef":"l20","status":"route","source":"s38","target":"s10","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on uplift and positive-energy vacuum control","rationale":"Positive-energy construction and uplift control refine the broader region's vacuum, stabilization and consistency questions.","qualification":"Keep AdS starting points, uplifted vacua and separate positive-energy branches distinct. Successful AdS construction or a positive potential contribution does not establish a controlled dS vacuum. Small-displacement arguments require control of potential curvature, coefficient scaling, other moduli and fractional mass changes; large volume alone is insufficient. Source-specific corrections, decay and phenomenological tests remain separate.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l20","s38","s10"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d20","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Positive-energy vacuum construction and uplift control fall within s38's stated vacuum, stabilization, control and qualified application scope. The narrower direction is supported. The qualification preserves the distinct phases and branches and does not infer post-uplift control from successful AdS construction.","refs":["l20","s38","s10"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l20","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l21":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l21","source":"q025-candidate-question:e356a66ea835237726bb7474","target":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","type":"method_for","title":"Connect compactification descriptions through consistent reductions and uplifts","rationale":"Reduction ansätze and uplift constructions supply methods for connecting higher-dimensional systems with retained theories, requiring reversal.","qualification":"Preserve the stated classical regime, explicit corrections, internal geometry, sources and global identifications. Consistency does not establish retention of every light mode, the full spectrum or higher-dimensional stability. Classification hypotheses remain attached to their results; not every gauging is assigned an uplift, and effective descriptions need not all be gauged-supergravity truncations.","evidenceIds":["unit:1fa557a4b375ed27e8881c416bb03db1819ff7de55ba68a62dc9182552d3065a","unit:2df68cc360d9803367e006001b21a7bff4856ea790d4dd173a8196c7644cfe59","unit:37260cd5f7bf9f00f989830b49ca05b5db06295f8e9d9e29c0f9071c79ec11b9","unit:40f3f39b41446ea021c86860285d081ac2405028d5b66891812d79c95f4b5524","unit:45ef74aceef210d62a6384e200f077d1cdabaf7e7f313293da00366634d068e2","unit:48c0779729b24e1a1a59ecb3a9685b33f64a3f16868fa71c1d9574185fd8fa02","unit:561d44bf1dcd69232dc147a807feadab63eca75f135786044f0face2a09deb66","unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","unit:5a53b8232e5dd97f866c4b7913fc1621fe45917be7a189b952ea16bac2add82b","unit:5c57d59057069b1b90c14541005c44710d3ff3e04d6481d6499fde71bc400e1b","unit:5df19207ea02e4bf4f6a2309dad7a3e0d42a62ac086d84eecf6bb94f50e54336","unit:5e7692837069af2ee6959af240c0f4c4ad1487c588133716514f3c15bf0f2409","unit:67cdcf4788ad5facf978b6e70065b422dbf1289e67fe8c4e37531c1afdec3166","unit:695618fa76a1b3b8b0ab7d4c253e794affb4e530cad9f0c30db55e92bd643172","unit:811179a15875a83c446cdf3098bbd645ecebb99050bd8a2a8fb392fe288a674a","unit:8469be6d10d480c0190ae01b4d89d132d4796ea95f8d0fcedd85a3286734180b","unit:8bb6e79262b076c348991d0aac7736d83f5e198e5f78aba95620507d0020030b","unit:9564b1871831da4096b252bd9789aa784c7919a53ca2e15526920cbd45d82c76","unit:9b0d0a27ac20c29493251293fb61036dcf4640c56011e8d68d003b6c64abf106","unit:a58d2ff01acef0bb8b2e1f34b22654f2e3a4dc866bd57c78799c6c9c087c0501","unit:accabbb924dd2e4300c652b35a2da22c7e89ffecd8a1c9e5cd70bc2ea256cc41","unit:ae7dab35254eb57a1ce09e9c9cb556c76050c55f5f56829a43271459fadddb25","unit:b411c21c4f47d32594c358248607da302284bd4a5f8b15fff8a0abcce9cdc2df","unit:bd8d65ed50bb7108304c5d784df4501032febe6f78e643259d2fc1bceaf8d300","unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","unit:d228ff96068ab1f6e7a058db243f25c767643744dbfddaa586dc693a1bf4c9ea","unit:d3e4f4baa2fb42e27b549d2effcf9264a0466217d450f067e5fed1a4ecb1302d","unit:d4ba2ede3fe656f8b61d3635454f2e94d2f3ca194b22a02b8667687686180e97","unit:d85b32d3d6c811d39cd9a58290b5fefcb90b41c8a1b7180f8008ebfbbdfdc7b9","unit:da9dff92e6d10dbd077c963c948e51d67b338bb2a42de3c4e0cd97a2880dc326","unit:daec1a59347fea16d441e2fc637b9da62976be0979319883b3d1b75e7d55b323","unit:ed17eb8ba083c5ca7f63c8f68e63c2c4e7dc2093440c5259b7f7c418f3b70c32","unit:f01689b48c8df9f02a33b4e18d1a83b973c07aebdd7af5adf05ed8f0216ebcd3","unit:fab082686a36609e54f852b34b4214b49154d2eea82b49a1b551547fba414670"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e356a66ea835237726bb7474","scopeContentSha256":"c5b23ca2b5de4041591e0e32909f8aaaffc767201b4076264d56789e51b3e64e","localRef":"s33"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","scopeContentSha256":"347fee2f1bd0ea394bafca055d49ebaf5e2ec572becb105f85372571b2bc46cd","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l21","originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:6","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l21","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:6","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:e356a66ea835237726bb7474","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l21","source":"s38","target":"s33","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Consistent reductions and uplifts connect higher-dimensional systems to retained theories without establishing light-mode completeness."],"challengeStatement":"Consistent reductions and uplift constructions connect descriptions while leaving light-mode completeness as a separate test.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5e5d0c0d72fb950ebe1457b76fbc2e2ffd12c38ec05281a20aaea51785edacf2","reply.jsonSha256":"c164a1797f2579dd542d6a85d2d5ada3d3923f51dbf00c5ad7715dfcc3293196","reply.raw.txtSha256":"6fe1f9ffacf3fd23fcd414f8ea84dea076b70b1efa9cc4c1b266645516a3284c","receipt.jsonSha256":"949135a1913dfe4fc7bc496b3d40e6e41cb0fc8289d1ebe30e318c6fbc1fd497","normalization.jsonSha256":"60ac91844e3455fced77f0d35aa125b34a3618b7f066752c3b6583de30ead537","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"12aff7bccd1643b13672aabf092a32b906a1405e7d3f8a924039a2d009499098"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"113090d319770847b1bcf319abc555a657aec606eecef8697c3bfa6cb949a534","reply.jsonSha256":"3f358a065f5156682f2bef99d3ba50ed16c59ef4202316b790a99980a867e52a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"332bdc783baf2d0e00a74757f00a86efa14aa5098688b1b04ac620ab3ec084e9","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a728c710537f0d36937246c575232be90eac650ccbfc3a22c0180680ac5aa50","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e6136e890c81aac9092b885c2b64906f9fc4cccb35942ee78a80d99d814ac23"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e356a66ea835237726bb7474"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e356a66ea835237726bb7474"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d21","originalRef":"l21","status":"route","source":"s33","target":"s38","type":"method_for","title":"Connect compactification descriptions through consistent reductions and uplifts","rationale":"Reduction ansätze and uplift constructions supply methods for connecting higher-dimensional systems with retained theories, requiring reversal.","qualification":"Preserve the stated classical regime, explicit corrections, internal geometry, sources and global identifications. Consistency does not establish retention of every light mode, the full spectrum or higher-dimensional stability. Classification hypotheses remain attached to their results; not every gauging is assigned an uplift, and effective descriptions need not all be gauged-supergravity truncations.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l21","s33","s38"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d21","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Consistent reductions and uplift constructions supply methods for connecting higher- and lower-dimensional descriptions, supporting reversal to s33 → s38. The record preserves source and global assumptions while keeping consistency separate from light-mode completeness, full spectra and higher-dimensional stability.","refs":["l21","s38","s33"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l21","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l22":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l22","source":"q025-candidate-question:e356a66ea835237726bb7474","target":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056","type":"method_for","title":"Use reduction and uplift data in KK fluctuation calculations","rationale":"Here the statements explicitly identify reduction and uplift data as support for fluctuation calculations, so the existing direction is correct.","qualification":"Use only the data available for the stated higher-dimensional background and reduction, retaining geometry, source content, flux mixing, spin sector, normalization and boundary conditions. Consistency of a finite reduction does not determine the full KK spectrum or establish light-mode completeness. Finite retained-field mass matrices and a partial bosonic spectrum do not supply every tower or fermionic sector.","evidenceIds":["unit:0381e377d66fc5cb3c3dcd4eab33a6df90ce808ef1b989c355f3b43d4d72641e","unit:1146d0cbd9f758d0c550b0f71451a9e20d90b56ba1380cb1484ac294f8677b07","unit:1c62b905eb5369a879fa12d21537378b5e78361d1b277b024e3e79b23b0dc3dd","unit:1fa557a4b375ed27e8881c416bb03db1819ff7de55ba68a62dc9182552d3065a","unit:29b31c7a0bf765303fa0ca9a114469ec791a25952c0e2a7f85fbe806ac8f31cd","unit:2f50fe2b718f6d7fafad6a50c2595b3043d5e5bf561262050e1824efcfed0bc5","unit:37260cd5f7bf9f00f989830b49ca05b5db06295f8e9d9e29c0f9071c79ec11b9","unit:40f3f39b41446ea021c86860285d081ac2405028d5b66891812d79c95f4b5524","unit:47323622eedda5e6c843cfb73addf7e4586bba5d1dd148ac1bce1d8075d6b90e","unit:48c0779729b24e1a1a59ecb3a9685b33f64a3f16868fa71c1d9574185fd8fa02","unit:5241f30d4c21e69ba66904384c261ad57f154630cf9354e7c9da9ca6ae68895d","unit:561d44bf1dcd69232dc147a807feadab63eca75f135786044f0face2a09deb66","unit:5a53b8232e5dd97f866c4b7913fc1621fe45917be7a189b952ea16bac2add82b","unit:5c57d59057069b1b90c14541005c44710d3ff3e04d6481d6499fde71bc400e1b","unit:5de647cd03f2d3e695f7cb21ac37f2252812c88af5380f5de32847739bdc1f0e","unit:5decb2a85c4623aefbe9c469b89c27e8310688b40f9df57c9682d0d8d88b5b0a","unit:5df19207ea02e4bf4f6a2309dad7a3e0d42a62ac086d84eecf6bb94f50e54336","unit:5e7692837069af2ee6959af240c0f4c4ad1487c588133716514f3c15bf0f2409","unit:5f0f4c932a66ba4207808d1e60df0ee64b0e0e55ac7b7fd92d118886fe6eaddb","unit:67cdcf4788ad5facf978b6e70065b422dbf1289e67fe8c4e37531c1afdec3166","unit:695618fa76a1b3b8b0ab7d4c253e794affb4e530cad9f0c30db55e92bd643172","unit:6ec234cf777ad3342f46b4bd62d9cb2b26f1e320d9d630588adf3a0b7eaaa950","unit:7304d73b39aa68fcaa200662a52554438d3bd75da4e6574adc5699dd55b862a4","unit:785881ae758bc1873ea91a1aeaafadcde177771442de1d7c322f3f8ba0018845","unit:811179a15875a83c446cdf3098bbd645ecebb99050bd8a2a8fb392fe288a674a","unit:823ee153cf94a3e62d6099abbb025b289a8fd66dcf47830ec6427316a3e5a748","unit:8469be6d10d480c0190ae01b4d89d132d4796ea95f8d0fcedd85a3286734180b","unit:8bb6e79262b076c348991d0aac7736d83f5e198e5f78aba95620507d0020030b","unit:9564b1871831da4096b252bd9789aa784c7919a53ca2e15526920cbd45d82c76","unit:9afac9e352b65a76e5eed0e6d9c0794b50a9c0c7d1da529c64b1321514451011","unit:9b0d0a27ac20c29493251293fb61036dcf4640c56011e8d68d003b6c64abf106","unit:9b3c9f1fc7ff981e0a49b1e5d8d800722719cba89c154dbfa394b45b76089f44","unit:a58d2ff01acef0bb8b2e1f34b22654f2e3a4dc866bd57c78799c6c9c087c0501","unit:a6d271becc7629cef7152fb4f39fa36f38c22279bfad23e5e36fba7b768152b6","unit:a808fc8aa81e2fa1b2fa2dfc4184cbc721cbf27da5df2f6f87917d8422553748","unit:ac0abc2e9c12bbf29b598967170e1aa57a4524459809c1eb2c95d29693d28dcd","unit:accabbb924dd2e4300c652b35a2da22c7e89ffecd8a1c9e5cd70bc2ea256cc41","unit:ae7dab35254eb57a1ce09e9c9cb556c76050c55f5f56829a43271459fadddb25","unit:b411c21c4f47d32594c358248607da302284bd4a5f8b15fff8a0abcce9cdc2df","unit:bc8fda2450a08f2d0f91085a38cf4f9ce1c68b434e8626f52d7156f3c756975e","unit:bd8d65ed50bb7108304c5d784df4501032febe6f78e643259d2fc1bceaf8d300","unit:be9629d67ab81ab9f37bce1b68b6bed9d5dc0c5a5e3611339b486c99d7139461","unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","unit:d228ff96068ab1f6e7a058db243f25c767643744dbfddaa586dc693a1bf4c9ea","unit:d3758d272d90dacc14ffb50a9a40693795b77a3a9b0d5b8e26023515fb736ac7","unit:d3e4f4baa2fb42e27b549d2effcf9264a0466217d450f067e5fed1a4ecb1302d","unit:d4ba2ede3fe656f8b61d3635454f2e94d2f3ca194b22a02b8667687686180e97","unit:d636123cd103935865b2d66ae3e6980e977ae0ffce93c88e5b25004af39ed428","unit:d85b32d3d6c811d39cd9a58290b5fefcb90b41c8a1b7180f8008ebfbbdfdc7b9","unit:da9dff92e6d10dbd077c963c948e51d67b338bb2a42de3c4e0cd97a2880dc326","unit:ed17eb8ba083c5ca7f63c8f68e63c2c4e7dc2093440c5259b7f7c418f3b70c32","unit:f01689b48c8df9f02a33b4e18d1a83b973c07aebdd7af5adf05ed8f0216ebcd3","unit:f4f5961f783856c6eaf6432fe85aa05f8b92203c55a7a377614a95b9fd49f2c2","unit:f63d119eea422c7d1fe04976e5578f2656ba2fda16191f7bfa64fb7b8a0984e3","unit:fab082686a36609e54f852b34b4214b49154d2eea82b49a1b551547fba414670"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e356a66ea835237726bb7474","scopeContentSha256":"c5b23ca2b5de4041591e0e32909f8aaaffc767201b4076264d56789e51b3e64e","localRef":"s33"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056","scopeContentSha256":"1e6f60c5db93f69d2180cb0e6a09243204fd5d2a93c45aa163f7ee961ac4f681","localRef":"s35"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l22","originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:18","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l22","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:18","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:e356a66ea835237726bb7474","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l22","source":"s33","target":"s35","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Reduction and uplift data may support fluctuation calculations, while consistency of the reduction does not establish the full spectrum."],"challengeStatement":"Reduction and uplift data can support fluctuation calculations; consistency alone does not determine the full spectrum.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5e5d0c0d72fb950ebe1457b76fbc2e2ffd12c38ec05281a20aaea51785edacf2","reply.jsonSha256":"c164a1797f2579dd542d6a85d2d5ada3d3923f51dbf00c5ad7715dfcc3293196","reply.raw.txtSha256":"6fe1f9ffacf3fd23fcd414f8ea84dea076b70b1efa9cc4c1b266645516a3284c","receipt.jsonSha256":"949135a1913dfe4fc7bc496b3d40e6e41cb0fc8289d1ebe30e318c6fbc1fd497","normalization.jsonSha256":"60ac91844e3455fced77f0d35aa125b34a3618b7f066752c3b6583de30ead537","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"12aff7bccd1643b13672aabf092a32b906a1405e7d3f8a924039a2d009499098"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"113090d319770847b1bcf319abc555a657aec606eecef8697c3bfa6cb949a534","reply.jsonSha256":"3f358a065f5156682f2bef99d3ba50ed16c59ef4202316b790a99980a867e52a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"332bdc783baf2d0e00a74757f00a86efa14aa5098688b1b04ac620ab3ec084e9","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a728c710537f0d36937246c575232be90eac650ccbfc3a22c0180680ac5aa50","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e6136e890c81aac9092b885c2b64906f9fc4cccb35942ee78a80d99d814ac23"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e356a66ea835237726bb7474"},{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:e356a66ea835237726bb7474"},{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d22","originalRef":"l22","status":"route","source":"s33","target":"s35","type":"method_for","title":"Use reduction and uplift data in KK fluctuation calculations","rationale":"Here the statements explicitly identify reduction and uplift data as support for fluctuation calculations, so the existing direction is correct.","qualification":"Use only the data available for the stated higher-dimensional background and reduction, retaining geometry, source content, flux mixing, spin sector, normalization and boundary conditions. Consistency of a finite reduction does not determine the full KK spectrum or establish light-mode completeness. Finite retained-field mass matrices and a partial bosonic spectrum do not supply every tower or fermionic sector.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l22","s33","s35"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d22","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Here both statements explicitly identify reduction and uplift data as inputs supporting fluctuation calculations, so the original direction is appropriate. The qualification preserves background and spectral-sector dependencies and prevents finite-reduction consistency from being promoted to a full KK-spectrum result.","refs":["l22","s33","s35"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l22","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l23":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l23","source":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056","target":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","type":"method_for","title":"Assess compactification spectra through higher-dimensional KK operators","rationale":"Higher-dimensional fluctuation operators, eigenmodes and interaction calculations provide the spectral methods for the broader compactification question.","qualification":"Retain background geometry, spin sector, flux orientation and mixing, normalization, AdS boundary conditions and the stated linearized or tree-level regime. Full KK questions are distinct from finite supergravity mass matrices. A bosonic or otherwise partial spectrum does not establish all fermionic modes, complete light-mode retention or stability, and limited residual symmetry can restrict representation-theory methods.","evidenceIds":["unit:0381e377d66fc5cb3c3dcd4eab33a6df90ce808ef1b989c355f3b43d4d72641e","unit:1146d0cbd9f758d0c550b0f71451a9e20d90b56ba1380cb1484ac294f8677b07","unit:1c62b905eb5369a879fa12d21537378b5e78361d1b277b024e3e79b23b0dc3dd","unit:29b31c7a0bf765303fa0ca9a114469ec791a25952c0e2a7f85fbe806ac8f31cd","unit:2df68cc360d9803367e006001b21a7bff4856ea790d4dd173a8196c7644cfe59","unit:2f50fe2b718f6d7fafad6a50c2595b3043d5e5bf561262050e1824efcfed0bc5","unit:40f3f39b41446ea021c86860285d081ac2405028d5b66891812d79c95f4b5524","unit:45ef74aceef210d62a6384e200f077d1cdabaf7e7f313293da00366634d068e2","unit:47323622eedda5e6c843cfb73addf7e4586bba5d1dd148ac1bce1d8075d6b90e","unit:5241f30d4c21e69ba66904384c261ad57f154630cf9354e7c9da9ca6ae68895d","unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","unit:5de647cd03f2d3e695f7cb21ac37f2252812c88af5380f5de32847739bdc1f0e","unit:5decb2a85c4623aefbe9c469b89c27e8310688b40f9df57c9682d0d8d88b5b0a","unit:5f0f4c932a66ba4207808d1e60df0ee64b0e0e55ac7b7fd92d118886fe6eaddb","unit:6ec234cf777ad3342f46b4bd62d9cb2b26f1e320d9d630588adf3a0b7eaaa950","unit:7304d73b39aa68fcaa200662a52554438d3bd75da4e6574adc5699dd55b862a4","unit:785881ae758bc1873ea91a1aeaafadcde177771442de1d7c322f3f8ba0018845","unit:823ee153cf94a3e62d6099abbb025b289a8fd66dcf47830ec6427316a3e5a748","unit:9afac9e352b65a76e5eed0e6d9c0794b50a9c0c7d1da529c64b1321514451011","unit:9b0d0a27ac20c29493251293fb61036dcf4640c56011e8d68d003b6c64abf106","unit:9b3c9f1fc7ff981e0a49b1e5d8d800722719cba89c154dbfa394b45b76089f44","unit:a6d271becc7629cef7152fb4f39fa36f38c22279bfad23e5e36fba7b768152b6","unit:a808fc8aa81e2fa1b2fa2dfc4184cbc721cbf27da5df2f6f87917d8422553748","unit:ac0abc2e9c12bbf29b598967170e1aa57a4524459809c1eb2c95d29693d28dcd","unit:bc8fda2450a08f2d0f91085a38cf4f9ce1c68b434e8626f52d7156f3c756975e","unit:be9629d67ab81ab9f37bce1b68b6bed9d5dc0c5a5e3611339b486c99d7139461","unit:d3758d272d90dacc14ffb50a9a40693795b77a3a9b0d5b8e26023515fb736ac7","unit:d636123cd103935865b2d66ae3e6980e977ae0ffce93c88e5b25004af39ed428","unit:da9dff92e6d10dbd077c963c948e51d67b338bb2a42de3c4e0cd97a2880dc326","unit:daec1a59347fea16d441e2fc637b9da62976be0979319883b3d1b75e7d55b323","unit:f4f5961f783856c6eaf6432fe85aa05f8b92203c55a7a377614a95b9fd49f2c2","unit:f63d119eea422c7d1fe04976e5578f2656ba2fda16191f7bfa64fb7b8a0984e3","unit:fab082686a36609e54f852b34b4214b49154d2eea82b49a1b551547fba414670"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056","scopeContentSha256":"1e6f60c5db93f69d2180cb0e6a09243204fd5d2a93c45aa163f7ee961ac4f681","localRef":"s35"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","scopeContentSha256":"347fee2f1bd0ea394bafca055d49ebaf5e2ec572becb105f85372571b2bc46cd","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l23","originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:8","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l23","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:8","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:30e42c20fef58dd627023a94","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l23","source":"s38","target":"s35","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Full KK operators, eigenstates and interactions supply a spectral direction distinct from finite supergravity mass matrices."],"challengeStatement":"Higher-dimensional fluctuation operators and eigenmodes provide a spectral route distinct from finite supergravity mass matrices.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5e5d0c0d72fb950ebe1457b76fbc2e2ffd12c38ec05281a20aaea51785edacf2","reply.jsonSha256":"c164a1797f2579dd542d6a85d2d5ada3d3923f51dbf00c5ad7715dfcc3293196","reply.raw.txtSha256":"6fe1f9ffacf3fd23fcd414f8ea84dea076b70b1efa9cc4c1b266645516a3284c","receipt.jsonSha256":"949135a1913dfe4fc7bc496b3d40e6e41cb0fc8289d1ebe30e318c6fbc1fd497","normalization.jsonSha256":"60ac91844e3455fced77f0d35aa125b34a3618b7f066752c3b6583de30ead537","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"12aff7bccd1643b13672aabf092a32b906a1405e7d3f8a924039a2d009499098"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"113090d319770847b1bcf319abc555a657aec606eecef8697c3bfa6cb949a534","reply.jsonSha256":"3f358a065f5156682f2bef99d3ba50ed16c59ef4202316b790a99980a867e52a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"332bdc783baf2d0e00a74757f00a86efa14aa5098688b1b04ac620ab3ec084e9","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a728c710537f0d36937246c575232be90eac650ccbfc3a22c0180680ac5aa50","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e6136e890c81aac9092b885c2b64906f9fc4cccb35942ee78a80d99d814ac23"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056"},{"ref":"e0","kind":"primary","paperId":"1410.0711","sourceId":"ev:234ec36e5a5b3cc319766764db175700","sourceSha256":"28e1e0d0d7e63e6a8bfd26acb3dd4fd22595bc54a069d229c24594f84fab9439","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b6e7669a466686f1c57e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ac7f04052859746eb0198fcb404e9e43bef794f17de36785f05f2acfe8e8698","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2484,"textSha256":"7212d2abcab28c07914bebb57ba149ce61e9325c2d6849f97147d57c9e86b5a1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"1410.0711","sourceId":"ev:4658df3d0fc1127d57a8eef5a2a06aaa","sourceSha256":"28e1e0d0d7e63e6a8bfd26acb3dd4fd22595bc54a069d229c24594f84fab9439","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b6e7669a466686f1c57e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ac7f04052859746eb0198fcb404e9e43bef794f17de36785f05f2acfe8e8698","pdfPage":3,"start":93,"end":3487,"textSha256":"54eda794950160c3ab93cfb1b598afc1e0b75fa4acde599d774f269e108a7e5f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d23","originalRef":"l23","status":"route","source":"s35","target":"s38","type":"method_for","title":"Assess compactification spectra through higher-dimensional KK operators","rationale":"Higher-dimensional fluctuation operators, eigenmodes and interaction calculations provide the spectral methods for the broader compactification question.","qualification":"Retain background geometry, spin sector, flux orientation and mixing, normalization, AdS boundary conditions and the stated linearized or tree-level regime. Full KK questions are distinct from finite supergravity mass matrices. A bosonic or otherwise partial spectrum does not establish all fermionic modes, complete light-mode retention or stability, and limited residual symmetry can restrict representation-theory methods.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l23","s35","s38"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d23","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Higher-dimensional fluctuation operators and eigenmodes provide the spectral methods relevant to s38, supporting reversal. The qualification retains spin, flux, normalization, boundary and perturbative restrictions, including the difference between finite mass matrices, partial spectra and complete towers.","refs":["l23","s38","s35"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l23","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l24":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l24","source":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056","target":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","type":"method_for","title":"Test proposed KK/AdS hierarchies with the relevant spectra","rationale":"Spectral calculations supply a direct method for testing whether geometric hierarchy diagnostics correspond to the relevant physical KK masses.","qualification":"Keep the compared scales, flux parameters, admissible quantized scaling directions and spectral sectors explicit. Retained masses, curvature ratios and inverse-radius estimates cannot replace the relevant KK spectrum; an overall estimate need not bound every anisotropic direction. Partial spectral tests do not establish complete localization control, a Wilsonian cutoff or a hierarchy for every modulus.","evidenceIds":["unit:0381e377d66fc5cb3c3dcd4eab33a6df90ce808ef1b989c355f3b43d4d72641e","unit:0c1ff6f54ee35f9af9c3432a4972405b3c5f2d7223179fbc760c9281a1230231","unit:0d08d4f774b65ee2bf1501e8473ec7d3cc295913993a539ece15bec5a90b9309","unit:1146d0cbd9f758d0c550b0f71451a9e20d90b56ba1380cb1484ac294f8677b07","unit:16a93eb4b1db1b29cba350318f99e180e2a96ef34f3978fad40898793579fcdd","unit:1a6e84d68df39d4fbcdc4fc38b529cee40bc26791cf8504d47ba53d104ffaa7f","unit:1c62b905eb5369a879fa12d21537378b5e78361d1b277b024e3e79b23b0dc3dd","unit:28bf05cb66b26d4d11ec2a878e45cfd2f8944a006d2e16b86cfd4e53ba5609a1","unit:29b31c7a0bf765303fa0ca9a114469ec791a25952c0e2a7f85fbe806ac8f31cd","unit:2f50fe2b718f6d7fafad6a50c2595b3043d5e5bf561262050e1824efcfed0bc5","unit:2f7ada10910118137fade4d1c5f95677bfaacb8913d50547bf4dcd7f5af59a96","unit:39fcaef1130708f7cf1ad33246b09422ac21c4a057eb738df998881687d32abb","unit:40f3f39b41446ea021c86860285d081ac2405028d5b66891812d79c95f4b5524","unit:47323622eedda5e6c843cfb73addf7e4586bba5d1dd148ac1bce1d8075d6b90e","unit:5241f30d4c21e69ba66904384c261ad57f154630cf9354e7c9da9ca6ae68895d","unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","unit:566bab49279fecec97511945784f722b340083e352ab4abb2d198fdccce98d3a","unit:56d7019ebfae993107eed785420aa05f3d2172ea3277daaffa28765202502fe4","unit:5a86d64e6b3b5a61a5efcdd90f854d53f140659645d1c1131960095c7cd4bf21","unit:5de647cd03f2d3e695f7cb21ac37f2252812c88af5380f5de32847739bdc1f0e","unit:5decb2a85c4623aefbe9c469b89c27e8310688b40f9df57c9682d0d8d88b5b0a","unit:5f086c9f0811666ff2383b8e822f1ffb201ecdb585af8effc98898fe89d8f2a2","unit:5f0f4c932a66ba4207808d1e60df0ee64b0e0e55ac7b7fd92d118886fe6eaddb","unit:66cb0f576400ed50e9bc05f3838837c0fec10ff2637fc3bc264f9c16bf32b9b8","unit:6ec234cf777ad3342f46b4bd62d9cb2b26f1e320d9d630588adf3a0b7eaaa950","unit:71ab4bfb7bb6955069e31ba2d0081430dfcbff81121205477ca0323c62c87c43","unit:7304d73b39aa68fcaa200662a52554438d3bd75da4e6574adc5699dd55b862a4","unit:73396c7219e2be263081e76b7aa71e070c4fc0c124342f2c528d1f337866e921","unit:75f05cfa6455e4319da4d4c6aebea008f22e059ccd2aedec26ef2a83ad209c3d","unit:785881ae758bc1873ea91a1aeaafadcde177771442de1d7c322f3f8ba0018845","unit:7a72ce6ca9c05d80afe77db60ac6dcec490c4ee0aac7ac374403905580d11e13","unit:7b4bf01c885cb6e499c8735f67319cfdfe689afcdbe7cb145065bad2cac77852","unit:823ee153cf94a3e62d6099abbb025b289a8fd66dcf47830ec6427316a3e5a748","unit:911bc5151bcfa08a83281bac4660fc5646957f669f726ee00e978b93854f4511","unit:9afac9e352b65a76e5eed0e6d9c0794b50a9c0c7d1da529c64b1321514451011","unit:9b0d0a27ac20c29493251293fb61036dcf4640c56011e8d68d003b6c64abf106","unit:9b3c9f1fc7ff981e0a49b1e5d8d800722719cba89c154dbfa394b45b76089f44","unit:a1cf41feb9ff4216719296e75d7351bea56a20bdda22feb37859fab46cc4f063","unit:a61fb3e5abacfba5b230f6824c67b85f9123246d98a0246bf9a15726902af1cd","unit:a6d271becc7629cef7152fb4f39fa36f38c22279bfad23e5e36fba7b768152b6","unit:a7213e005778086953020c257c8c1837c29119e74e61917ab2ed5ebf1be86e63","unit:a808fc8aa81e2fa1b2fa2dfc4184cbc721cbf27da5df2f6f87917d8422553748","unit:ac0abc2e9c12bbf29b598967170e1aa57a4524459809c1eb2c95d29693d28dcd","unit:b6c628f310dd90e187ad5bb386b662748cc6bbb7655d8010505779bce816b43c","unit:bc8fda2450a08f2d0f91085a38cf4f9ce1c68b434e8626f52d7156f3c756975e","unit:be9629d67ab81ab9f37bce1b68b6bed9d5dc0c5a5e3611339b486c99d7139461","unit:c754e96679f15b716287ec818a8e8ee652b5eed1fe452e46b8d64a7bd5dba46c","unit:cc399617882af612bf3dedcbffe6afa6f37b732717d4ad66970f87d2b11918fc","unit:cc99847809b8d61e6d16aad8d4ff1d9eb3261beb45162260ebca12b011b3b89f","unit:ccf1b6b78dc294aeaaebd22febf16a8ec73d74e5b4b34a629c3c6b3ada3c7811","unit:d2b24674f2936e54c43ecd9368df3f22ac3e0ec94fd48b150a926e10dc7ddb57","unit:d3758d272d90dacc14ffb50a9a40693795b77a3a9b0d5b8e26023515fb736ac7","unit:d636123cd103935865b2d66ae3e6980e977ae0ffce93c88e5b25004af39ed428","unit:da9dff92e6d10dbd077c963c948e51d67b338bb2a42de3c4e0cd97a2880dc326","unit:ddea64b1288cc4b3b574818e4163a94a1e87994ae8836a63691d4fc46602f0da","unit:e419f5203399437634947f8bf71f51cb484df369673771bfd1b7c3d2ca3f5404","unit:e934cddef50d5f6f02086b4afe8ac459732213ee183e490f8ff42289915b405e","unit:ed79f6a525629d405933dbfaa1052927f7d512bb2a27f676e4a93117294c8a03","unit:f4f5961f783856c6eaf6432fe85aa05f8b92203c55a7a377614a95b9fd49f2c2","unit:f55b47948a70200c1f2960271a9b82deb3162a73e0eae0d9c33d3c6a022c6f19","unit:f56ce56c0452b14f4084798631cfe57089369d7a97f5689ab3473151f212c0ec","unit:f63d119eea422c7d1fe04976e5578f2656ba2fda16191f7bfa64fb7b8a0984e3","unit:f83165e390c51b48339b7b864228eb70d8177255a25415de24ed228e74fa17c0","unit:fab082686a36609e54f852b34b4214b49154d2eea82b49a1b551547fba414670"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056","scopeContentSha256":"1e6f60c5db93f69d2180cb0e6a09243204fd5d2a93c45aa163f7ee961ac4f681","localRef":"s35"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","scopeContentSha256":"ab31c979113b80aa3f10cabf458a728321f6f6edcfe214864404101a2ecea357","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l24","originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:19","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l24","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:19","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l24","source":"s35","target":"s5","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Spectral calculations can test geometric hierarchy diagnostics; retained masses or curvature estimates cannot replace the relevant KK spectrum."],"challengeStatement":"Spectral calculations test geometric hierarchy diagnostics; retained masses and curvature estimates do not replace the relevant KK spectrum.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5e5d0c0d72fb950ebe1457b76fbc2e2ffd12c38ec05281a20aaea51785edacf2","reply.jsonSha256":"c164a1797f2579dd542d6a85d2d5ada3d3923f51dbf00c5ad7715dfcc3293196","reply.raw.txtSha256":"6fe1f9ffacf3fd23fcd414f8ea84dea076b70b1efa9cc4c1b266645516a3284c","receipt.jsonSha256":"949135a1913dfe4fc7bc496b3d40e6e41cb0fc8289d1ebe30e318c6fbc1fd497","normalization.jsonSha256":"60ac91844e3455fced77f0d35aa125b34a3618b7f066752c3b6583de30ead537","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"12aff7bccd1643b13672aabf092a32b906a1405e7d3f8a924039a2d009499098"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"113090d319770847b1bcf319abc555a657aec606eecef8697c3bfa6cb949a534","reply.jsonSha256":"3f358a065f5156682f2bef99d3ba50ed16c59ef4202316b790a99980a867e52a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"332bdc783baf2d0e00a74757f00a86efa14aa5098688b1b04ac620ab3ec084e9","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a728c710537f0d36937246c575232be90eac650ccbfc3a22c0180680ac5aa50","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e6136e890c81aac9092b885c2b64906f9fc4cccb35942ee78a80d99d814ac23"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056"},{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f312dc34c0c5fd0c5ecde056"},{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d24","originalRef":"l24","status":"route","source":"s35","target":"s5","type":"method_for","title":"Test proposed KK/AdS hierarchies with the relevant spectra","rationale":"Spectral calculations supply a direct method for testing whether geometric hierarchy diagnostics correspond to the relevant physical KK masses.","qualification":"Keep the compared scales, flux parameters, admissible quantized scaling directions and spectral sectors explicit. Retained masses, curvature ratios and inverse-radius estimates cannot replace the relevant KK spectrum; an overall estimate need not bound every anisotropic direction. Partial spectral tests do not establish complete localization control, a Wilsonian cutoff or a hierarchy for every modulus.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l24","s35","s5"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d24","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"KK spectral calculations are an expressly supported method for testing geometric separation claims. The retained direction is correct. The record preserves the relevant scales, quantized limits and spectral sectors, while keeping curvature estimates and partial tests distinct from complete hierarchy and control conclusions.","refs":["l24","s35","s5"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l24","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l25":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l25","source":"q025-candidate-question:15fbcd034e97f6868a57e2ad","target":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","type":"narrower","title":"Specialize effective-description control to geometric KK/AdS separation","rationale":"The controlled lower-dimensional-description question includes global realization, light-mode content and scale hierarchies. Geometric KK/AdS separation is a refinement, so the broad-to-narrow arrow reverses.","qualification":"The refinement concerns parametric internal KK separation from AdS curvature under the stated dimension, flux and source assumptions. A geometric hierarchy alone does not establish global realizability or retention of all relevant light modes. Finite spectral improvements need not be parametric, and dated constructions or criticisms do not establish a universal result.","evidenceIds":["unit:0c1ff6f54ee35f9af9c3432a4972405b3c5f2d7223179fbc760c9281a1230231","unit:0d08d4f774b65ee2bf1501e8473ec7d3cc295913993a539ece15bec5a90b9309","unit:16a93eb4b1db1b29cba350318f99e180e2a96ef34f3978fad40898793579fcdd","unit:1a6e84d68df39d4fbcdc4fc38b529cee40bc26791cf8504d47ba53d104ffaa7f","unit:28bf05cb66b26d4d11ec2a878e45cfd2f8944a006d2e16b86cfd4e53ba5609a1","unit:29b31c7a0bf765303fa0ca9a114469ec791a25952c0e2a7f85fbe806ac8f31cd","unit:2f7ada10910118137fade4d1c5f95677bfaacb8913d50547bf4dcd7f5af59a96","unit:39fcaef1130708f7cf1ad33246b09422ac21c4a057eb738df998881687d32abb","unit:40f3f39b41446ea021c86860285d081ac2405028d5b66891812d79c95f4b5524","unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","unit:566bab49279fecec97511945784f722b340083e352ab4abb2d198fdccce98d3a","unit:56d7019ebfae993107eed785420aa05f3d2172ea3277daaffa28765202502fe4","unit:5a53b8232e5dd97f866c4b7913fc1621fe45917be7a189b952ea16bac2add82b","unit:5a86d64e6b3b5a61a5efcdd90f854d53f140659645d1c1131960095c7cd4bf21","unit:5c57d59057069b1b90c14541005c44710d3ff3e04d6481d6499fde71bc400e1b","unit:5f086c9f0811666ff2383b8e822f1ffb201ecdb585af8effc98898fe89d8f2a2","unit:66cb0f576400ed50e9bc05f3838837c0fec10ff2637fc3bc264f9c16bf32b9b8","unit:6886a41547e1252cf92633de38f1c524da2b02cabebac6166313e9a9f608bfdb","unit:692fee9e7b595f4a50081761f33cad85b5df93d8f93c8a20e2be4d1c43cebc7a","unit:71ab4bfb7bb6955069e31ba2d0081430dfcbff81121205477ca0323c62c87c43","unit:73396c7219e2be263081e76b7aa71e070c4fc0c124342f2c528d1f337866e921","unit:75f05cfa6455e4319da4d4c6aebea008f22e059ccd2aedec26ef2a83ad209c3d","unit:7a72ce6ca9c05d80afe77db60ac6dcec490c4ee0aac7ac374403905580d11e13","unit:7b4bf01c885cb6e499c8735f67319cfdfe689afcdbe7cb145065bad2cac77852","unit:811179a15875a83c446cdf3098bbd645ecebb99050bd8a2a8fb392fe288a674a","unit:8c4b2c9b38c160cf0b570b0eea0d14d4e542beb9790c45907020573922a7ff9e","unit:911bc5151bcfa08a83281bac4660fc5646957f669f726ee00e978b93854f4511","unit:a1cf41feb9ff4216719296e75d7351bea56a20bdda22feb37859fab46cc4f063","unit:a410d3f9d9c63b0a132cf31c2e760472618de209fe79cae34c5655ef1ef74369","unit:a61fb3e5abacfba5b230f6824c67b85f9123246d98a0246bf9a15726902af1cd","unit:a7213e005778086953020c257c8c1837c29119e74e61917ab2ed5ebf1be86e63","unit:b6c628f310dd90e187ad5bb386b662748cc6bbb7655d8010505779bce816b43c","unit:c754e96679f15b716287ec818a8e8ee652b5eed1fe452e46b8d64a7bd5dba46c","unit:cc399617882af612bf3dedcbffe6afa6f37b732717d4ad66970f87d2b11918fc","unit:cc99847809b8d61e6d16aad8d4ff1d9eb3261beb45162260ebca12b011b3b89f","unit:ccf1b6b78dc294aeaaebd22febf16a8ec73d74e5b4b34a629c3c6b3ada3c7811","unit:d228ff96068ab1f6e7a058db243f25c767643744dbfddaa586dc693a1bf4c9ea","unit:d2b24674f2936e54c43ecd9368df3f22ac3e0ec94fd48b150a926e10dc7ddb57","unit:d3758d272d90dacc14ffb50a9a40693795b77a3a9b0d5b8e26023515fb736ac7","unit:ddea64b1288cc4b3b574818e4163a94a1e87994ae8836a63691d4fc46602f0da","unit:e1fdb3af9f702f718ef082035e50dec5e1038cd585c38deaa5b5f5f349364b44","unit:e419f5203399437634947f8bf71f51cb484df369673771bfd1b7c3d2ca3f5404","unit:e934cddef50d5f6f02086b4afe8ac459732213ee183e490f8ff42289915b405e","unit:ed79f6a525629d405933dbfaa1052927f7d512bb2a27f676e4a93117294c8a03","unit:f55b47948a70200c1f2960271a9b82deb3162a73e0eae0d9c33d3c6a022c6f19","unit:f56ce56c0452b14f4084798631cfe57089369d7a97f5689ab3473151f212c0ec","unit:f83165e390c51b48339b7b864228eb70d8177255a25415de24ed228e74fa17c0"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:15fbcd034e97f6868a57e2ad","scopeContentSha256":"7ba49b737a116af7ed1f31453e54d5055fe04fb7e3f4f9b45e0e68f7d6960d2e","localRef":"s1"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","scopeContentSha256":"ab31c979113b80aa3f10cabf458a728321f6f6edcfe214864404101a2ecea357","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l25","originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:21","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l25","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:21","originalNativeType":"broadens","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:15fbcd034e97f6868a57e2ad","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l25","source":"s5","target":"s1","nativeType":"broadens","proposalStatements":["Controlled lower-dimensional descriptions also require global realization and relevant light-mode content, beyond a geometric hierarchy."],"challengeStatement":"A controlled lower-dimensional description also requires global realization and relevant light-mode content.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5e5d0c0d72fb950ebe1457b76fbc2e2ffd12c38ec05281a20aaea51785edacf2","reply.jsonSha256":"c164a1797f2579dd542d6a85d2d5ada3d3923f51dbf00c5ad7715dfcc3293196","reply.raw.txtSha256":"6fe1f9ffacf3fd23fcd414f8ea84dea076b70b1efa9cc4c1b266645516a3284c","receipt.jsonSha256":"949135a1913dfe4fc7bc496b3d40e6e41cb0fc8289d1ebe30e318c6fbc1fd497","normalization.jsonSha256":"60ac91844e3455fced77f0d35aa125b34a3618b7f066752c3b6583de30ead537","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"12aff7bccd1643b13672aabf092a32b906a1405e7d3f8a924039a2d009499098"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"113090d319770847b1bcf319abc555a657aec606eecef8697c3bfa6cb949a534","reply.jsonSha256":"3f358a065f5156682f2bef99d3ba50ed16c59ef4202316b790a99980a867e52a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"332bdc783baf2d0e00a74757f00a86efa14aa5098688b1b04ac620ab3ec084e9","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a728c710537f0d36937246c575232be90eac650ccbfc3a22c0180680ac5aa50","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e6136e890c81aac9092b885c2b64906f9fc4cccb35942ee78a80d99d814ac23"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3"},{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:15fbcd034e97f6868a57e2ad"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3"},{"ref":"x1_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:15fbcd034e97f6868a57e2ad"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d25","originalRef":"l25","status":"route","source":"s1","target":"s5","type":"narrower","title":"Specialize effective-description control to geometric KK/AdS separation","rationale":"The controlled lower-dimensional-description question includes global realization, light-mode content and scale hierarchies. Geometric KK/AdS separation is a refinement, so the broad-to-narrow arrow reverses.","qualification":"The refinement concerns parametric internal KK separation from AdS curvature under the stated dimension, flux and source assumptions. A geometric hierarchy alone does not establish global realizability or retention of all relevant light modes. Finite spectral improvements need not be parametric, and dated constructions or criticisms do not establish a universal result.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l25","s1","s5"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d25","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The complete s1 question covers controlled lower-dimensional descriptions, including relative scales, global realization and relevant light modes. Parametric geometric KK/AdS separation is a genuine refinement within that scope, supporting reversal. The qualification correctly leaves the additional control requirements independent.","refs":["l25","s5","s1"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l25","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l26":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l26","source":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","target":"q025-candidate-question:67909a5a99e2039f253f43c5","type":"premise_check","title":"Check localization, resolution and corrections behind hierarchy control","rationale":"For hierarchy proposals relying on the relevant starting approximations, localization, resolution and corrections test the control required by the construction claim.","qualification":"Apply the check to the specified sourced, smeared or singular candidates; source-free settings do not acquire every orientifold premise. Integrated-data matching and large-flux suppression away from sources do not settle near-source regions, higher orders or all exceptional modes. The child adjudication named in both original statements remains pending and is neither resolved nor admitted by this parent-level route.","evidenceIds":["unit:0c1ff6f54ee35f9af9c3432a4972405b3c5f2d7223179fbc760c9281a1230231","unit:0d08d4f774b65ee2bf1501e8473ec7d3cc295913993a539ece15bec5a90b9309","unit:16a93eb4b1db1b29cba350318f99e180e2a96ef34f3978fad40898793579fcdd","unit:1a6e84d68df39d4fbcdc4fc38b529cee40bc26791cf8504d47ba53d104ffaa7f","unit:28bf05cb66b26d4d11ec2a878e45cfd2f8944a006d2e16b86cfd4e53ba5609a1","unit:2f7ada10910118137fade4d1c5f95677bfaacb8913d50547bf4dcd7f5af59a96","unit:390c68f6c2db311a9aec2199ff93167888150ba112d3b3ea23df05e3cf17b5da","unit:39fcaef1130708f7cf1ad33246b09422ac21c4a057eb738df998881687d32abb","unit:4a1928fd26e2b4c2bf63fee83683bd60bf4b4524315c960073c74f8fea472a3d","unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","unit:566bab49279fecec97511945784f722b340083e352ab4abb2d198fdccce98d3a","unit:56d7019ebfae993107eed785420aa05f3d2172ea3277daaffa28765202502fe4","unit:5a86d64e6b3b5a61a5efcdd90f854d53f140659645d1c1131960095c7cd4bf21","unit:5f086c9f0811666ff2383b8e822f1ffb201ecdb585af8effc98898fe89d8f2a2","unit:6554201c3d0226f55ad9dfbc9539583543f7d3811effb2e29c36834df87ae4fa","unit:66cb0f576400ed50e9bc05f3838837c0fec10ff2637fc3bc264f9c16bf32b9b8","unit:67d377a65020f0693b52044670abacfe48c7eb5bae0d02d4f46edfeea1f7fbf4","unit:71ab4bfb7bb6955069e31ba2d0081430dfcbff81121205477ca0323c62c87c43","unit:73396c7219e2be263081e76b7aa71e070c4fc0c124342f2c528d1f337866e921","unit:75f05cfa6455e4319da4d4c6aebea008f22e059ccd2aedec26ef2a83ad209c3d","unit:7a72ce6ca9c05d80afe77db60ac6dcec490c4ee0aac7ac374403905580d11e13","unit:7b4bf01c885cb6e499c8735f67319cfdfe689afcdbe7cb145065bad2cac77852","unit:911bc5151bcfa08a83281bac4660fc5646957f669f726ee00e978b93854f4511","unit:9599d9eb99510e981ea181c8c5422c8fdf1474947fc45d7aba43c47ef9c75cc3","unit:a0e96edc0d42554d7a18bec7df92f19facfd61e7c6b0ca6076ac35afb5bef827","unit:a1cf41feb9ff4216719296e75d7351bea56a20bdda22feb37859fab46cc4f063","unit:a61fb3e5abacfba5b230f6824c67b85f9123246d98a0246bf9a15726902af1cd","unit:a7213e005778086953020c257c8c1837c29119e74e61917ab2ed5ebf1be86e63","unit:b6c628f310dd90e187ad5bb386b662748cc6bbb7655d8010505779bce816b43c","unit:c53687321db2c2352662c484d85e5b4a4e977d22a4fdf617aec2fb192c3bd891","unit:c754e96679f15b716287ec818a8e8ee652b5eed1fe452e46b8d64a7bd5dba46c","unit:c9097d30b51c77d81ef95b468fde19333ae785dc0ed19d4ec8eeeba100161de5","unit:cc399617882af612bf3dedcbffe6afa6f37b732717d4ad66970f87d2b11918fc","unit:cc99847809b8d61e6d16aad8d4ff1d9eb3261beb45162260ebca12b011b3b89f","unit:ccf1b6b78dc294aeaaebd22febf16a8ec73d74e5b4b34a629c3c6b3ada3c7811","unit:d2b24674f2936e54c43ecd9368df3f22ac3e0ec94fd48b150a926e10dc7ddb57","unit:dac66f21f9b37768247e585a5639e18b13725b83df6887af681d55d4bd8dd0a0","unit:ddea64b1288cc4b3b574818e4163a94a1e87994ae8836a63691d4fc46602f0da","unit:e419f5203399437634947f8bf71f51cb484df369673771bfd1b7c3d2ca3f5404","unit:e934cddef50d5f6f02086b4afe8ac459732213ee183e490f8ff42289915b405e","unit:ed79f6a525629d405933dbfaa1052927f7d512bb2a27f676e4a93117294c8a03","unit:f32e9c722ee32dd79087367305eece2c4ebc790f58b7ed0f3816e3283ba27c31","unit:f3bbbff0da430a63253d6d598bcd55999cefefbf4dee3cbf274957344d802e1c","unit:f55b47948a70200c1f2960271a9b82deb3162a73e0eae0d9c33d3c6a022c6f19","unit:f56ce56c0452b14f4084798631cfe57089369d7a97f5689ab3473151f212c0ec","unit:f83165e390c51b48339b7b864228eb70d8177255a25415de24ed228e74fa17c0","unit:f9a45781e7c39c54def27b7286d70f3f2b9fc284c674faf6c8d5dc876a720cb2","unit:fc93be0f45a10d53774f8b9ce90bebbfda512735ee01be90820224ec6df66722"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","scopeContentSha256":"ab31c979113b80aa3f10cabf458a728321f6f6edcfe214864404101a2ecea357","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:67909a5a99e2039f253f43c5","scopeContentSha256":"26377ab5b4577615ac1b32476f906ccf02d60a873aa038f002121cc8cca885a1","localRef":"s16"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l26","originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:23","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l26","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:23","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:67909a5a99e2039f253f43c5","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l26","source":"s5","target":"s16","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["Localization, resolution and corrections test construction control. This proposed route retains the pending child adjudication for x0_5."],"challengeStatement":"Localization, resolution and corrections test construction control; the pending x0_5 adjudication is preserved.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","attributed_child_review"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5e5d0c0d72fb950ebe1457b76fbc2e2ffd12c38ec05281a20aaea51785edacf2","reply.jsonSha256":"c164a1797f2579dd542d6a85d2d5ada3d3923f51dbf00c5ad7715dfcc3293196","reply.raw.txtSha256":"6fe1f9ffacf3fd23fcd414f8ea84dea076b70b1efa9cc4c1b266645516a3284c","receipt.jsonSha256":"949135a1913dfe4fc7bc496b3d40e6e41cb0fc8289d1ebe30e318c6fbc1fd497","normalization.jsonSha256":"60ac91844e3455fced77f0d35aa125b34a3618b7f066752c3b6583de30ead537","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"12aff7bccd1643b13672aabf092a32b906a1405e7d3f8a924039a2d009499098"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"113090d319770847b1bcf319abc555a657aec606eecef8697c3bfa6cb949a534","reply.jsonSha256":"3f358a065f5156682f2bef99d3ba50ed16c59ef4202316b790a99980a867e52a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"332bdc783baf2d0e00a74757f00a86efa14aa5098688b1b04ac620ab3ec084e9","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a728c710537f0d36937246c575232be90eac650ccbfc3a22c0180680ac5aa50","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e6136e890c81aac9092b885c2b64906f9fc4cccb35942ee78a80d99d814ac23"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3"},{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:67909a5a99e2039f253f43c5"},{"ref":"c0","kind":"attributed_child_review"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3"},{"ref":"x0_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:67909a5a99e2039f253f43c5"},{"ref":"c0","kind":"attributed_child_review"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d26","originalRef":"l26","status":"route","source":"s5","target":"s16","type":"premise_check","title":"Check localization, resolution and corrections behind hierarchy control","rationale":"For hierarchy proposals relying on the relevant starting approximations, localization, resolution and corrections test the control required by the construction claim.","qualification":"Apply the check to the specified sourced, smeared or singular candidates; source-free settings do not acquire every orientifold premise. Integrated-data matching and large-flux suppression away from sources do not settle near-source regions, higher orders or all exceptional modes. The child adjudication named in both original statements remains pending and is neither resolved nor admitted by this parent-level route.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l26","s5","s16"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d26","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"For the specified sourced or approximate hierarchy candidates, localization, resolution and corrections are relevant control checks, supporting the existing premise-check direction. The qualification avoids universal orientifold assumptions and explicitly preserves the pending child adjudication without resolving or admitting it.","refs":["l26","s5","s16"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l26","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l27":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l27","source":"q025-candidate-question:2e85345f5f983dd3a5658c5b","target":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","type":"method_for","title":"Evaluate geometric hierarchy claims with qualified flux and spectral diagnostics","rationale":"Flux, curvature and spectral diagnostics supply the methodological assessment of hierarchy claims, requiring reversal.","qualification":"Retain quantized flux or lattice data, source-orientation constraints, flux-dependent normalization and the lightest anisotropic KK directions. A flux/KK hierarchy does not establish an AdS/KK hierarchy, and small relative fibre size does not establish string-scale control. Curvature ratios are not universally KK eigenvalues; bounded test-scalar asymptotics provide neither a complete spectrum nor a universal obstruction.","evidenceIds":["unit:0c1ff6f54ee35f9af9c3432a4972405b3c5f2d7223179fbc760c9281a1230231","unit:0d08d4f774b65ee2bf1501e8473ec7d3cc295913993a539ece15bec5a90b9309","unit:16a93eb4b1db1b29cba350318f99e180e2a96ef34f3978fad40898793579fcdd","unit:1a6e84d68df39d4fbcdc4fc38b529cee40bc26791cf8504d47ba53d104ffaa7f","unit:28bf05cb66b26d4d11ec2a878e45cfd2f8944a006d2e16b86cfd4e53ba5609a1","unit:2f7ada10910118137fade4d1c5f95677bfaacb8913d50547bf4dcd7f5af59a96","unit:39fcaef1130708f7cf1ad33246b09422ac21c4a057eb738df998881687d32abb","unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","unit:566bab49279fecec97511945784f722b340083e352ab4abb2d198fdccce98d3a","unit:56d7019ebfae993107eed785420aa05f3d2172ea3277daaffa28765202502fe4","unit:5a86d64e6b3b5a61a5efcdd90f854d53f140659645d1c1131960095c7cd4bf21","unit:5f086c9f0811666ff2383b8e822f1ffb201ecdb585af8effc98898fe89d8f2a2","unit:66cb0f576400ed50e9bc05f3838837c0fec10ff2637fc3bc264f9c16bf32b9b8","unit:71ab4bfb7bb6955069e31ba2d0081430dfcbff81121205477ca0323c62c87c43","unit:73396c7219e2be263081e76b7aa71e070c4fc0c124342f2c528d1f337866e921","unit:75f05cfa6455e4319da4d4c6aebea008f22e059ccd2aedec26ef2a83ad209c3d","unit:7a72ce6ca9c05d80afe77db60ac6dcec490c4ee0aac7ac374403905580d11e13","unit:7b4bf01c885cb6e499c8735f67319cfdfe689afcdbe7cb145065bad2cac77852","unit:911bc5151bcfa08a83281bac4660fc5646957f669f726ee00e978b93854f4511","unit:a1cf41feb9ff4216719296e75d7351bea56a20bdda22feb37859fab46cc4f063","unit:a61fb3e5abacfba5b230f6824c67b85f9123246d98a0246bf9a15726902af1cd","unit:a7213e005778086953020c257c8c1837c29119e74e61917ab2ed5ebf1be86e63","unit:ae800cd577e7eba2024de48bbd317e08cebb33d4e52625107c5ef3501b626710","unit:b6c628f310dd90e187ad5bb386b662748cc6bbb7655d8010505779bce816b43c","unit:c754e96679f15b716287ec818a8e8ee652b5eed1fe452e46b8d64a7bd5dba46c","unit:cc399617882af612bf3dedcbffe6afa6f37b732717d4ad66970f87d2b11918fc","unit:cc99847809b8d61e6d16aad8d4ff1d9eb3261beb45162260ebca12b011b3b89f","unit:ccf1b6b78dc294aeaaebd22febf16a8ec73d74e5b4b34a629c3c6b3ada3c7811","unit:d2b24674f2936e54c43ecd9368df3f22ac3e0ec94fd48b150a926e10dc7ddb57","unit:ddea64b1288cc4b3b574818e4163a94a1e87994ae8836a63691d4fc46602f0da","unit:e419f5203399437634947f8bf71f51cb484df369673771bfd1b7c3d2ca3f5404","unit:e934cddef50d5f6f02086b4afe8ac459732213ee183e490f8ff42289915b405e","unit:ed79f6a525629d405933dbfaa1052927f7d512bb2a27f676e4a93117294c8a03","unit:f55b47948a70200c1f2960271a9b82deb3162a73e0eae0d9c33d3c6a022c6f19","unit:f56ce56c0452b14f4084798631cfe57089369d7a97f5689ab3473151f212c0ec","unit:f83165e390c51b48339b7b864228eb70d8177255a25415de24ed228e74fa17c0"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2e85345f5f983dd3a5658c5b","scopeContentSha256":"e34269d8ee0f6d96ef1645ab13186e8ab9d8d5b06ded0a1b58f156b2adaf28b6","localRef":"s9"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","scopeContentSha256":"ab31c979113b80aa3f10cabf458a728321f6f6edcfe214864404101a2ecea357","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l27","originalCandidateId":"parent-3ad8848c0af01da6b749-challenge:link:15","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l27","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-3ad8848c0af01da6b749-challenge:link:15","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:1f9b1d5cdab35624dd6346e3","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:2e85345f5f983dd3a5658c5b","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l27","source":"s5","target":"s9","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Flux, curvature and spectral diagnostics assess hierarchy claims with explicitly limited reach."],"challengeStatement":"Flux, curvature and spectral diagnostics assess proposed hierarchies with distinct evidential reach.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-3ad8848c0af01da6b749-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-3ad8848c0af01da6b749-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"dfeab231225841d110250e67e53a6b085f0149ddcd9d34131fc916904862f3a0","reply.jsonSha256":"5ee22779aec50a905890f710fe40a9c4de2aeba339abc41975f5cd86057a4c15","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d51d212e6fbaeab07bc4182ad6a03267ea18c502a7415ce7447c611c0f436e8b","receipt.jsonSha256":"06d81e46473ded6bd168aec8ee451dc3597bdc85a209319995194f7652a7684a","normalization.jsonSha256":"f156401fd0803f5e511fc60bf0ee8a9b7499cd991eb14cfabad574a7fb822142","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-3ad8848c0af01da6b749-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"3e41ef92573c41672c31b3fd3bb4be42fb4a15155d580d90264a2c9b89602645"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-3ad8848c0af01da6b749-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"a478bff107a2c46646b05f6b2a94aae6abed60a0c73d0e037a2769ec7c3b6dec","reply.jsonSha256":"1e5119404af0ec2932853dc356cade753fe7ace69a4b12b8c431cdf0cd4730f1","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c668f33c0eb432790e0141e02ca471b61e2df506e85bd843a46576f3bfba5d11","receipt.jsonSha256":"2a5c784da77c1eadd89ccc5b84de764f9f00416b2eac986e274bf0e786bc8e33","normalization.jsonSha256":"c3d8e3cf0940112cd18b491db619405bd9b2d4f6ea61890072c294728bb7de79"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2e85345f5f983dd3a5658c5b"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"1206.5900","sourceId":"ev:e10c2e52c72456875873d733faa2a2dd","sourceSha256":"a49d8ec51a84d1da72f54aaa5fa84d506ad4c4b24002fcbac038989a9a4cab76","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8dc194fae0fdf0bccb51/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"88efa708f5c368f353b7cfbbb7c38928c061862ec91b956f762649f258f6f49e","pdfPage":3,"start":101,"end":3113,"textSha256":"0c311c9b3383bd80238c38a5ec429e64502e0c1bff2accfb6a2179e3ed5321f6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"1206.5900","sourceId":"ev:2405eb53bdfd1360e855a9a0d51e06d7","sourceSha256":"a49d8ec51a84d1da72f54aaa5fa84d506ad4c4b24002fcbac038989a9a4cab76","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8dc194fae0fdf0bccb51/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"88efa708f5c368f353b7cfbbb7c38928c061862ec91b956f762649f258f6f49e","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2753,"textSha256":"87ef894378ce32908f280d2d8cd170ec7af2e8525a1a7a1e910e374edf4b1c22","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:2e85345f5f983dd3a5658c5b"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"1206.5900","sourceId":"ev:e10c2e52c72456875873d733faa2a2dd","sourceSha256":"a49d8ec51a84d1da72f54aaa5fa84d506ad4c4b24002fcbac038989a9a4cab76","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8dc194fae0fdf0bccb51/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"88efa708f5c368f353b7cfbbb7c38928c061862ec91b956f762649f258f6f49e","pdfPage":3,"start":101,"end":3113,"textSha256":"0c311c9b3383bd80238c38a5ec429e64502e0c1bff2accfb6a2179e3ed5321f6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e1","kind":"primary","paperId":"1206.5900","sourceId":"ev:2405eb53bdfd1360e855a9a0d51e06d7","sourceSha256":"a49d8ec51a84d1da72f54aaa5fa84d506ad4c4b24002fcbac038989a9a4cab76","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8dc194fae0fdf0bccb51/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"88efa708f5c368f353b7cfbbb7c38928c061862ec91b956f762649f258f6f49e","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2753,"textSha256":"87ef894378ce32908f280d2d8cd170ec7af2e8525a1a7a1e910e374edf4b1c22","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d27","originalRef":"l27","status":"route","source":"s9","target":"s5","type":"method_for","title":"Evaluate geometric hierarchy claims with qualified flux and spectral diagnostics","rationale":"Flux, curvature and spectral diagnostics supply the methodological assessment of hierarchy claims, requiring reversal.","qualification":"Retain quantized flux or lattice data, source-orientation constraints, flux-dependent normalization and the lightest anisotropic KK directions. A flux/KK hierarchy does not establish an AdS/KK hierarchy, and small relative fibre size does not establish string-scale control. Curvature ratios are not universally KK eigenvalues; bounded test-scalar asymptotics provide neither a complete spectrum nor a universal obstruction.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l27","s9","s5"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d27","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The diagnostics at s9 supply methods for assessing hierarchy claims at s5, requiring reversal. The record preserves their distinct evidential reach, including flux/KK versus AdS/KK separation, anisotropic directions, normalization and the limitations of curvature and test-scalar diagnostics.","refs":["l27","s5","s9"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l27","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l28":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l28","source":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050","target":"q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1","type":"premise_check","title":"Check control when a stabilization proposal adds positive energy","rationale":"When a stabilization construction includes a proposed positive-energy ingredient, the target asks whether stabilization and higher-dimensional consistency survive. This is a conditional reliability check.","qualification":"The route applies to that positive-energy branch of a stabilization proposal, not to every stabilization mechanism or vacuum. Keep pre-uplift, post-uplift and separate dS constructions distinct. A positive contribution establishes neither a complete stabilized vacuum nor higher-dimensional control. Any small-displacement argument retains its curvature, coefficient-scaling, other-modulus and fractional-mass-change conditions.","evidenceIds":["unit:10ff325d4a1e4dff8accc4e543d0343755ef0ea083e701b635ad37f3c3b3d05a","unit:140a27d068fc885807a238d869f87293725cf209d6902e0867cbfc45ea43be1e","unit:365ea7585a09d912c85771e274590a8193ad7bcacd31dec878d96d89c6d84657","unit:3784d299b77e8f600a05a4d4f7397fdc9173838bbe88033e16cb9b38f57d8873","unit:38408412bb2fa795fdc51d56f7623f5e387474cd671d90cabbe96bfc9c6b38bd","unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","unit:59c2447d89549de5a435cc89808953d8264dbc04f227c669d280c23b9853609d","unit:602ea4010f973bdd2b6dc782eb95531e6bd512d1b1ba0bfadab3a1e80759790d","unit:609b4db6a2f88d640c05cbf8df3416972f3cd67a087b2240d1c697e843288bab","unit:6132a5f905836215a4462d4edb5aeea4f8f3179c43599632f87e5cc79c00700a","unit:65b14988261f78fec1cbb38359b2995a2ad3fd68881facccc19a33d14622582e","unit:717b9accb34f11d8453230a5531898b32f8d29e4adbb2f0d3a4261cf57306e3d","unit:724506f6a6094e499812e8d49f4023c4ffd39743a87edaa7fcf9deebd8f4c949","unit:773b44811b4a461b11ad02a5735f3ccf707831e1abfd2084d6908d48a4854b85","unit:7e27a7f1b03a9b3ddef19dbc12d9c743a715e85d8b04d39f6be8742b6ae00ae6","unit:926a8f17bbd42c4b9018a5d5f315a28475859cdfdd6e4f35e1e2ee4a4bbfd8a2","unit:a2fe340b7adccda1c72e87480de5647d55ffddb53540cf879634026a4fbe0cd1","unit:acecb6dca2ff654f444787a747727899241cd555089cfd2e80b48539197b0c18","unit:b02dd5da03e89341008454d102255db0844b4a1d44b6bee2aa18a2d4881ac3ae","unit:b6327667ae3d048cd2b81005de30206c8a6d2cd3c2165861868d2e348c86ecb3","unit:c2ec6fe7d0010dba5dad7ac3017e27fba7315410f1c28d14cbb2a39f4b6be0a3","unit:ecf167dfedd3b40e3b05194ad0c5b107e84f533b2e1889958c2c85e22c850f6d","unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050","scopeContentSha256":"eeeddcb9d4ffb791b9ff8a9179a222d02258a75a20edd4dc9a4bc9b043b0407d","localRef":"s12"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1","scopeContentSha256":"2398cac8767f326f9cb6ddc3c7f394f8c136847258c0eeb7c4a88571bd77d19a","localRef":"s10"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l28","originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge:link:16","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l28","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge:link:16","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l28","source":"s12","target":"s10","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["A proposed positive-energy contribution raises a separate question about survival of stabilization and higher-dimensional consistency."],"challengeStatement":"Adding positive energy raises a separate question about survival of stabilization and higher-dimensional consistency.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","description"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"243e04cb28fb6b33bfa96e5eda4d54ca7f1af343e60a821fc67fc105dacfc45b","reply.jsonSha256":"30542dfa624ec89da090e90cf75243da344b32667b277b842ff6cfc654e3aae9","reply.raw.txtSha256":"90b5218bf434a1bfd0c3c1a4d90b8a95a14083ffa4069b7dfe20a16415ab1c11","receipt.jsonSha256":"0fccda43a0971b62d8848ab0ad4ebeae6037b46c45d16ff74a926a773d5f9130","normalization.jsonSha256":"0fc716054d79dd485b69df4e844a187e894e107e53f8694fade7d1b275ed2f6b","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"36b507a45e5ca7df9a0b02fd3fecda404fd0015d22c1a0481b6543582d9ce085"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/recovery-successors-v1/jobs/successor-parent-4fde62f72cf6b83a34be-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d02c7ad219c09349e8dcd8124489895af1160579f70282385fc4ab9d9d91ceb0","reply.jsonSha256":"58b5a1301ca2cc8c0e3afef0cbb3dbe2895f9ea425f190878005d66c38458866","reply.raw.txtSha256":"615df2ea57a4fa7bd3c370739d3932d381c2a4e45e87b6acc0096f19c8c21e93","receipt.jsonSha256":"d564d588a101901971c349d0e9e8529d8606a15b8a4a1cf0c61ef4d5b70e8351","normalization.jsonSha256":"af448248cdc4776f7d865f22db7dd34f9c5f22d82789725f0b6c4d6b2bb95deb"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050"},{"ref":"x4_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"},{"ref":"d0","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ca01af2138e69abe18d84225e620bdf481d60abbd18695693fc57e58de21b027","textSha256":"af696650641666b82b0062cf996ffcc4b680dc2671ff9303478c4fd0e30c3450"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050"},{"ref":"x4_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"},{"ref":"d0","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ca01af2138e69abe18d84225e620bdf481d60abbd18695693fc57e58de21b027","textSha256":"af696650641666b82b0062cf996ffcc4b680dc2671ff9303478c4fd0e30c3450"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d28","originalRef":"l28","status":"route","source":"s12","target":"s10","type":"premise_check","title":"Check control when a stabilization proposal adds positive energy","rationale":"When a stabilization construction includes a proposed positive-energy ingredient, the target asks whether stabilization and higher-dimensional consistency survive. This is a conditional reliability check.","qualification":"The route applies to that positive-energy branch of a stabilization proposal, not to every stabilization mechanism or vacuum. Keep pre-uplift, post-uplift and separate dS constructions distinct. A positive contribution establishes neither a complete stabilized vacuum nor higher-dimensional control. Any small-displacement argument retains its curvature, coefficient-scaling, other-modulus and fractional-mass-change conditions.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l28","s12","s10"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d28","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"A stabilization proposal containing a positive-energy ingredient raises the reliability question addressed by s10. The conditional premise-check direction is therefore supported. The qualification restricts the connection to that branch and retains the separate requirements for stabilization survival, higher-dimensional control and small-displacement arguments.","refs":["l28","s12","s10"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l28","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l29":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l29","source":"q025-candidate-question:fa052fa27dfa229acdbb3809","target":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050","type":"application_of","title":"Apply stabilization and ingredient-compatibility tests to global chiral quivers","rationale":"Global chiral-quiver embeddings apply stabilization constructions while adding charge, anomaly and visible-sector requirements, requiring the applied-to-underlying direction.","qualification":"Stabilization ingredients and brane data remain construction-specific. The dP5 Standard Model example requires its diagonal divisor and compatible orientifold involution; the inflationary example uses two geometric blow-up modes with different roles. General chiral and particular Standard Model quivers are not identified. Neither inflation, positive vacuum energy nor a completed global-control audit follows for every embedding.","evidenceIds":["unit:3784d299b77e8f600a05a4d4f7397fdc9173838bbe88033e16cb9b38f57d8873","unit:459a501400bd831a1c4638f5a60153a660c19228793faf1c2be51c2297f68784","unit:b02dd5da03e89341008454d102255db0844b4a1d44b6bee2aa18a2d4881ac3ae","unit:b99df706a49befef2153c6370fe5cd548772510ad50f1d6094f3c9560957fe43","unit:dd9865cda12c52f54e3411ea29635d4426b4d9080a1b7b6039d52f8225835a79"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fa052fa27dfa229acdbb3809","scopeContentSha256":"2e6d61814e9947b6b219c88bc9fdc1f722c6c0aa2ea023fd8bea11a76d1c5626","localRef":"s37"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050","scopeContentSha256":"eeeddcb9d4ffb791b9ff8a9179a222d02258a75a20edd4dc9a4bc9b043b0407d","localRef":"s12"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l29","originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:18","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l29","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:18","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:fa052fa27dfa229acdbb3809","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l29","source":"s12","target":"s37","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Global chiral-quiver embeddings add charge, anomaly and visible-sector requirements to stabilization."],"challengeStatement":"Global chiral-quiver construction adds charge, anomaly and visible-sector requirements to moduli stabilization.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"06eb6ab0b33d70ca488cba5574a9f088537d6f8995d7fe73a3723bac7b4629aa","reply.jsonSha256":"6c4d8c637b56232f0059109accce5f4bb0da0cbe4f45a0b1b81e46f9ac15f5cd","reply.raw.txtSha256":"cd67e7475590018355f77f32db96f4e6173f5fcca932905f15c9e4a775a45e06","receipt.jsonSha256":"96638c1db28963568fd216349473bcd081260d81b680cb511b9d595a1ccec349","normalization.jsonSha256":"eb13b5dcabb5eec20b63b3afb9b4c18c51aad00ca59c36865b0b01c0a85f67ab","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"453e9ec7e0df401d2fc7d51fa6e66e90d910976ea3a59d5dafaf142a73028e24"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3bdb9c1c5751351855447f699c81fe757b058f1a6ffc6b0a98df8ec571386dc4","reply.jsonSha256":"c0a78737eed75e2d99cca34f139ca0b2e8ddf4117c71b0f6a33ec1f1741d0197","reply.raw.txtSha256":"360ce47b505d70e79a42d86acaa4dc3fff0f2c26104cdbc5e598b0f45f7c54ed","receipt.jsonSha256":"27ea02f046fa52fc6800f6ca65031ee07f8788c77eec2133e59b7f4edd75aa40","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e407582e9fb73504a9bd6033318997b8efdb43c85931a162f6149af146cc15d"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050"},{"ref":"x1_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fa052fa27dfa229acdbb3809"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050"},{"ref":"x1_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fa052fa27dfa229acdbb3809"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d29","originalRef":"l29","status":"route","source":"s37","target":"s12","type":"application_of","title":"Apply stabilization and ingredient-compatibility tests to global chiral quivers","rationale":"Global chiral-quiver embeddings apply stabilization constructions while adding charge, anomaly and visible-sector requirements, requiring the applied-to-underlying direction.","qualification":"Stabilization ingredients and brane data remain construction-specific. The dP5 Standard Model example requires its diagonal divisor and compatible orientifold involution; the inflationary example uses two geometric blow-up modes with different roles. General chiral and particular Standard Model quivers are not identified. Neither inflation, positive vacuum energy nor a completed global-control audit follows for every embedding.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l29","s37","s12"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d29","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Global chiral-quiver construction applies stabilization and ingredient-compatibility mechanisms while adding charge, anomaly and visible-sector requirements, supporting reversal. The qualification retains the particular divisor, involution and blow-up-mode conditions without extending inflationary or positive-energy outcomes to every embedding.","refs":["l29","s12","s37"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l29","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l30":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l30","source":"q025-candidate-question:06c48e5209c53219e18c963c","target":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050","type":"application_of","title":"Examine which stabilization and gauge choices preserve light axions","rationale":"The QCD-axion and axiverse question applies particular stabilization constructions to determine which light axions survive, so it points to the stabilization question.","qualification":"Keep an uneaten QCD axion and suitable stabilization as substantive conditions, including possible removal by an anomalous Abelian gauge boson. Distinguish the thesis's nonsupersymmetric perturbative setting from LVS under the axiverse source's natural-flux assumptions. The supersymmetric-stabilization no-go has unsupplied precise hypotheses. Inflationary choices do not establish a particular mechanism, and source-dated phenomenology supplies no current validation.","evidenceIds":["unit:3784d299b77e8f600a05a4d4f7397fdc9173838bbe88033e16cb9b38f57d8873","unit:4e7fdce27fa1c114181feb3b0b3293cb8b41c1bf9acc4ad64315ebdcd7bd7b47","unit:b02dd5da03e89341008454d102255db0844b4a1d44b6bee2aa18a2d4881ac3ae","unit:cffec71c27634c92762dc36df8812cd045d13c5e90620bef2500e717ffbcb24b"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:06c48e5209c53219e18c963c","scopeContentSha256":"4375e6fb1b0b0355bbc1e87acb27f4ae094c5ef2248731dafb5df31f11e1a81c","localRef":"s0"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050","scopeContentSha256":"eeeddcb9d4ffb791b9ff8a9179a222d02258a75a20edd4dc9a4bc9b043b0407d","localRef":"s12"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l30","originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:19","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l30","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge:link:19","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:06c48e5209c53219e18c963c","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l30","source":"s12","target":"s0","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["QCD-axion and axiverse questions test which light axions survive particular stabilization and gauge sectors."],"challengeStatement":"QCD-axion and axiverse questions test which light axions survive specified stabilization and gauge sectors.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"06eb6ab0b33d70ca488cba5574a9f088537d6f8995d7fe73a3723bac7b4629aa","reply.jsonSha256":"6c4d8c637b56232f0059109accce5f4bb0da0cbe4f45a0b1b81e46f9ac15f5cd","reply.raw.txtSha256":"cd67e7475590018355f77f32db96f4e6173f5fcca932905f15c9e4a775a45e06","receipt.jsonSha256":"96638c1db28963568fd216349473bcd081260d81b680cb511b9d595a1ccec349","normalization.jsonSha256":"eb13b5dcabb5eec20b63b3afb9b4c18c51aad00ca59c36865b0b01c0a85f67ab","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"453e9ec7e0df401d2fc7d51fa6e66e90d910976ea3a59d5dafaf142a73028e24"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-2ad7ce9c04412b41bc1c-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"3bdb9c1c5751351855447f699c81fe757b058f1a6ffc6b0a98df8ec571386dc4","reply.jsonSha256":"c0a78737eed75e2d99cca34f139ca0b2e8ddf4117c71b0f6a33ec1f1741d0197","reply.raw.txtSha256":"360ce47b505d70e79a42d86acaa4dc3fff0f2c26104cdbc5e598b0f45f7c54ed","receipt.jsonSha256":"27ea02f046fa52fc6800f6ca65031ee07f8788c77eec2133e59b7f4edd75aa40","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e407582e9fb73504a9bd6033318997b8efdb43c85931a162f6149af146cc15d"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050"},{"ref":"x1_10","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:06c48e5209c53219e18c963c"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x3_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:4d926fd69f6bc59cf12f6050"},{"ref":"x1_10","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:06c48e5209c53219e18c963c"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d30","originalRef":"l30","status":"route","source":"s0","target":"s12","type":"application_of","title":"Examine which stabilization and gauge choices preserve light axions","rationale":"The QCD-axion and axiverse question applies particular stabilization constructions to determine which light axions survive, so it points to the stabilization question.","qualification":"Keep an uneaten QCD axion and suitable stabilization as substantive conditions, including possible removal by an anomalous Abelian gauge boson. Distinguish the thesis's nonsupersymmetric perturbative setting from LVS under the axiverse source's natural-flux assumptions. The supersymmetric-stabilization no-go has unsupplied precise hypotheses. Inflationary choices do not establish a particular mechanism, and source-dated phenomenology supplies no current validation.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l30","s0","s12"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d30","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The axion question applies specified stabilization constructions to light-mode survival, supporting s0 → s12. The qualification preserves gauge removal, stabilization regime and natural-flux conditions. It does not rely on unsupplied no-go hypotheses to derive a universal exclusion or claim current phenomenological validation.","refs":["l30","s12","s0"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-01-proposal","parent-orientation-01-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["Only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original route statements were assessed. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators and review hashes are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route refs are context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt limits, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. No original result, full spectrum, observational fit or control claim is independently verified.","The newly proposed broader scopes retain their independent-review or coordinator-adjudication requirements. These orientation proposals do not admit pending child replacements or certify unsupplied descendants.","Endpoint/content/receipt validation, independent challenge, admission and the global canonical/DAG gate remain separate steps."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed every supplied complete endpoint definition, both original statements for each relation and every proposed record. No tools, external operations or new primary reading were used.","Primary locators, review hashes and original review files are described as pinned in a machine sidecar; their contents were not supplied or inspected. Scope and route references identify context, not new empirical evidence.","Inherited description-only support, bounded-excerpt coverage, source dates and unresolved calculations remain binding. Agreement on navigation does not independently verify physical results, spectra, observational fits or construction control.","The broader proposed scopes and pending child revisions retain their separate review requirements. These agreements do not certify unsupplied descendants or admit pending replacements.","Endpoint, content and receipt checks, the global canonical/DAG gate and deterministic admission remain separate. The distinct supplied relations l13 and l14 remain individually accounted for without a new identity or deduplication judgment."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-01:l30","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l0":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l0","source":"q025-candidate-question:6097980287c9a202203bcc9c","target":"q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0","type":"method_for","title":"Use wall existence and boundary analysis to assess candidate decay channels","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the wall and flow question supplies the existence and boundary-value analysis needed when assessing a candidate tunnelling wall.","qualification":"This method connection concerns the relevant gravitational or brane walls under their source-specific asymptotic data, slicing and boundary conditions. A regular wall or interpolating flow does not by itself demonstrate vacuum decay. Localization mechanisms and neighboring gauge-theory walls are not automatically decay channels, and excluding one channel does not establish absolute stability.","evidenceIds":["unit:10ff325d4a1e4dff8accc4e543d0343755ef0ea083e701b635ad37f3c3b3d05a","unit:110a8404e758165142bdd6f0ed3b7d10513b4b9b86bb597a6c41ad83a23440d5","unit:140a27d068fc885807a238d869f87293725cf209d6902e0867cbfc45ea43be1e","unit:19971072e711635d8f078b183d6ebf73d0c892bd3ddea33c74a59825df47e6a5","unit:1c7cfcbdaba1794e5dce4f0ae231bae545e0f4a8f170abcdc45c8b19f6323d44","unit:2e9e36788dd970467c77f9f9502aa9165681e1f715b92fcd5daf773394880853","unit:2f5de3720e8cddcac4982b7d2fe15d6d825ff6329c6a05df19b8a2ff68910e13","unit:365ea7585a09d912c85771e274590a8193ad7bcacd31dec878d96d89c6d84657","unit:37260cd5f7bf9f00f989830b49ca05b5db06295f8e9d9e29c0f9071c79ec11b9","unit:3802b789515f76e3730221c6f094f0fb1f271882592445c55c73ff0fc6924b17","unit:39bd30258f63050e87205e5015680de143170c54a2290789e4a1e7d58e8e66cd","unit:3a17390b7d9517662281601236ff4276bc42f745d6c453887f4fe784f2a3e685","unit:3adda60a2e68509bf32cfb0b97a8e825d1b8b4a36a6bfc64b827e97474ff077d","unit:422ecf4e1219e7199b7bec5ef3ae6fe85407886af632f14fec526eb6f3a7de74","unit:4843a0a422b7c1012421ad0b9df2239dc4aa36dd07a8005acbac159dc7a01865","unit:48c0779729b24e1a1a59ecb3a9685b33f64a3f16868fa71c1d9574185fd8fa02","unit:56189257c4e585b47d5b7b90277e23697dea4b0031668fc46a007d4d3cbeca9d","unit:5a53b8232e5dd97f866c4b7913fc1621fe45917be7a189b952ea16bac2add82b","unit:65f8a3a2c021a593cebfac31ac25f9ece59b5ec91817df8bad70dd37759c68be","unit:70c1cc8c094ed6ae2becd7b304a9e65e9e1d731f7cb9ce8c373c0b9661919d87","unit:72862d95e299f5de7316b6debd34d82469972be24e090e2fba54fb1fc858afc0","unit:7c45c2b70f964acb8c726d816bd079c679873e5f5759645f9c3e226fccceeaf8","unit:7e27a7f1b03a9b3ddef19dbc12d9c743a715e85d8b04d39f6be8742b6ae00ae6","unit:7e7e59123cf54f929916f12eb059964fa7f512d7038a493f730b81f187a00e98","unit:80e64e43d9a2da3426827ae61f3044c7e93d83c833d7bb76d5fbbe2cb84ff8da","unit:8469be6d10d480c0190ae01b4d89d132d4796ea95f8d0fcedd85a3286734180b","unit:88836d6845689e13a221109f0b628665728f2d02c1e43cd6295214a96b81860f","unit:9564b1871831da4096b252bd9789aa784c7919a53ca2e15526920cbd45d82c76","unit:9630fcb79ebb46dc9caf5465fdc8c294c310fc008776084917590902c462f9df","unit:97d207ccb7abcaec58303686799da7db5888dec4ddfec5574a73226a0e0d27ef","unit:9b1251add165f9ec1cb5526162e89f93ce9ebb6bb320383542d9094818b7ff94","unit:a7450cd3203ce6b46f6e7c6a548cacadf3d949aad21d87dcac5ebf97fc87e814","unit:aa73864ad5573efed629eabcf95e82f084860f149be4e619429880b995d1bc9a","unit:af9905d7342f93cc5d7f62f60272b84f4519ccb3d75770dc886f4d4689bf5d0e","unit:b3a7ad47152e7c053984b270913ca745b043e27903d929885726b0958ddadb9e","unit:b4a247552710792df2389597db1667ad83ec5e0390abb308cf33ed73989d910d","unit:b59f24ed1dacf46837b7aaa4f6370d5ca38665501b3a433d6d3ea9af706a121e","unit:bf3c1087eb9ace4f405d11dfb66441ccfae0b16d83a605d4b4d6db10d3f1722e","unit:c1c9ecbc5f811cafb87a3caa578e54ed651a53903a6de49480ce588b8654285f","unit:ca76b277f1e716c752647c3661728b69dbaf3a99eff27a7280dd81a04f953328","unit:dac66f21f9b37768247e585a5639e18b13725b83df6887af681d55d4bd8dd0a0","unit:daec1a59347fea16d441e2fc637b9da62976be0979319883b3d1b75e7d55b323","unit:e3ab8ebca9e427e55af776101a4ee2c4564b62f3eec6343a8b25bcddffa71dfa","unit:e58cbc0c02f9ba7cb6c531f9459069e66483b7d44c460a288f92762d104c3f81","unit:ea57c2e5caa9a514bfac605a1a0aca449ac76a8e6bfc6cd24072274cceb4c1f2","unit:edee2f88f69dd159796c1bc6fa558ddd206842350fba674b186fee878c7f0f2a","unit:efd0f6c352bf72ba036201d77a960c7c4ccf17645d7f8665f190b8e8059e2f75","unit:f9f4869b8c2b9a8a938dc88ce83c99203a83a9e4554a77f41f9e1c53d5fd4938"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6097980287c9a202203bcc9c","scopeContentSha256":"ca71f7b5ff8d9e9585d50547995db9ca4df5fb1190ae5e8a11f09229f07a3815","localRef":"s11"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0","scopeContentSha256":"d3b8c53549ec45f774bb3f9e66a788da3fdf56d4f913afe3f315a51a5e581386","localRef":"s3"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l0","originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:28","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l0","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:28","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:6097980287c9a202203bcc9c","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l0","source":"s3","target":"s11","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Candidate tunnelling walls require an existence and boundary-value analysis. A regular wall or flow alone does not establish vacuum decay."],"challengeStatement":"Candidate tunnelling walls require an existence and boundary-value analysis; a wall or flow alone does not demonstrate decay.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5e5d0c0d72fb950ebe1457b76fbc2e2ffd12c38ec05281a20aaea51785edacf2","reply.jsonSha256":"c164a1797f2579dd542d6a85d2d5ada3d3923f51dbf00c5ad7715dfcc3293196","reply.raw.txtSha256":"6fe1f9ffacf3fd23fcd414f8ea84dea076b70b1efa9cc4c1b266645516a3284c","receipt.jsonSha256":"949135a1913dfe4fc7bc496b3d40e6e41cb0fc8289d1ebe30e318c6fbc1fd497","normalization.jsonSha256":"60ac91844e3455fced77f0d35aa125b34a3618b7f066752c3b6583de30ead537","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"12aff7bccd1643b13672aabf092a32b906a1405e7d3f8a924039a2d009499098"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"113090d319770847b1bcf319abc555a657aec606eecef8697c3bfa6cb949a534","reply.jsonSha256":"3f358a065f5156682f2bef99d3ba50ed16c59ef4202316b790a99980a867e52a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"332bdc783baf2d0e00a74757f00a86efa14aa5098688b1b04ac620ab3ec084e9","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a728c710537f0d36937246c575232be90eac650ccbfc3a22c0180680ac5aa50","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e6136e890c81aac9092b885c2b64906f9fc4cccb35942ee78a80d99d814ac23"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0"},{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6097980287c9a202203bcc9c"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2005.07072","sourceId":"ev:d24f5c0305dbea216c5007333a89ebb1","sourceSha256":"ca6cb0d913e820e61c916d2ce1c2cf74ed8644a40fe33e7bceeb46d0678a2a03","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6c30ee73bdc1009dc84c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"208b9378118dfbed76fe8943400a790c3b3eec2c4f9bf97c8d356daeb52c851b","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"59f69d791ac24d589e0572e5b88e408277b87e2998d2ccca3d76beb8cf0f6b97","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0"},{"ref":"x1_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6097980287c9a202203bcc9c"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2005.07072","sourceId":"ev:d24f5c0305dbea216c5007333a89ebb1","sourceSha256":"ca6cb0d913e820e61c916d2ce1c2cf74ed8644a40fe33e7bceeb46d0678a2a03","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6c30ee73bdc1009dc84c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"208b9378118dfbed76fe8943400a790c3b3eec2c4f9bf97c8d356daeb52c851b","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"59f69d791ac24d589e0572e5b88e408277b87e2998d2ccca3d76beb8cf0f6b97","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d0","originalRef":"l0","status":"route","source":"s11","target":"s3","type":"method_for","title":"Use wall existence and boundary analysis to assess candidate decay channels","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the wall and flow question supplies the existence and boundary-value analysis needed when assessing a candidate tunnelling wall.","qualification":"This method connection concerns the relevant gravitational or brane walls under their source-specific asymptotic data, slicing and boundary conditions. A regular wall or interpolating flow does not by itself demonstrate vacuum decay. Localization mechanisms and neighboring gauge-theory walls are not automatically decay channels, and excluding one channel does not establish absolute stability.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l0","s11","s3"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d0","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify wall existence and boundary-value analysis as a method needed for candidate tunnelling walls. Reversing to s11 → s3 is correct. The qualification preserves the distinction between a regular flow and demonstrated decay, together with boundary restrictions and the limits of channel-specific stability conclusions.","refs":["l0","s11","s3"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l0","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l1":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l1","source":"q025-candidate-question:d53f1514866a3000447bb7e7","target":"q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0","type":"premise_check","title":"Check conjecture applicability when interpreting stability tests","rationale":"When a stability inference invokes an instability or weak-gravity conjecture, s18 asks whether that conjecture applies. Both original statements distinguish this check from the outcome of an actual channel search.","qualification":"The connection applies only to conjecture-dependent interpretations within s28; ordinary perturbative and decay-channel tests do not acquire a conjectural premise. Retain the relevant charge/tension, boundary, near-horizon versus asymptotic, and quantum-correction assumptions. Neither a conjecture nor protection in a retained sector establishes an all-channel stability verdict.","evidenceIds":["unit:02fbdcb6b4fdb0428a6afa393914a399bfc8a652d4310d6a639537f21b92bb9d","unit:184595d5b60d76978dadc6a06c3fd9f7e5f84cd8ba056c25713c1a2cd088d526","unit:19971072e711635d8f078b183d6ebf73d0c892bd3ddea33c74a59825df47e6a5","unit:259caa186453f63f948d585fb1ccb16786768cd6eeebdbee1029ebbff7ca5b9b","unit:3a17390b7d9517662281601236ff4276bc42f745d6c453887f4fe784f2a3e685","unit:47323622eedda5e6c843cfb73addf7e4586bba5d1dd148ac1bce1d8075d6b90e","unit:4843a0a422b7c1012421ad0b9df2239dc4aa36dd07a8005acbac159dc7a01865","unit:4d08d3f785edf2a27db552925c33f2792ce8c54e1da79acfd19a9d58df4bdef8","unit:56189257c4e585b47d5b7b90277e23697dea4b0031668fc46a007d4d3cbeca9d","unit:564c546addbcc07be350f269ec6d26357d0c88dd4934dd009b1f575475bb7381","unit:59c2447d89549de5a435cc89808953d8264dbc04f227c669d280c23b9853609d","unit:5de647cd03f2d3e695f7cb21ac37f2252812c88af5380f5de32847739bdc1f0e","unit:5decb2a85c4623aefbe9c469b89c27e8310688b40f9df57c9682d0d8d88b5b0a","unit:5f0f4c932a66ba4207808d1e60df0ee64b0e0e55ac7b7fd92d118886fe6eaddb","unit:602ea4010f973bdd2b6dc782eb95531e6bd512d1b1ba0bfadab3a1e80759790d","unit:65b14988261f78fec1cbb38359b2995a2ad3fd68881facccc19a33d14622582e","unit:72862d95e299f5de7316b6debd34d82469972be24e090e2fba54fb1fc858afc0","unit:7304d73b39aa68fcaa200662a52554438d3bd75da4e6574adc5699dd55b862a4","unit:77b214332bd02ec66176450d89614ec213ed1ff3a350a2d5f3c1e8928561e590","unit:785881ae758bc1873ea91a1aeaafadcde177771442de1d7c322f3f8ba0018845","unit:7c45c2b70f964acb8c726d816bd079c679873e5f5759645f9c3e226fccceeaf8","unit:7e7e59123cf54f929916f12eb059964fa7f512d7038a493f730b81f187a00e98","unit:7f99d873353a8b06fcb628102ea05dfa3b49d96dd5005f64ef46ca6feafcd92a","unit:80e64e43d9a2da3426827ae61f3044c7e93d83c833d7bb76d5fbbe2cb84ff8da","unit:81c0354fafeb803ec6ce5fcc5acab5d754dbad435a812758812f6994e25e420b","unit:823ee153cf94a3e62d6099abbb025b289a8fd66dcf47830ec6427316a3e5a748","unit:8c4b2c9b38c160cf0b570b0eea0d14d4e542beb9790c45907020573922a7ff9e","unit:8e902d54f2f73f38c303ad3fd9cef07069292bea556223c0499eefc584a9d806","unit:9630fcb79ebb46dc9caf5465fdc8c294c310fc008776084917590902c462f9df","unit:9b0d0a27ac20c29493251293fb61036dcf4640c56011e8d68d003b6c64abf106","unit:9b3c9f1fc7ff981e0a49b1e5d8d800722719cba89c154dbfa394b45b76089f44","unit:a58d2ff01acef0bb8b2e1f34b22654f2e3a4dc866bd57c78799c6c9c087c0501","unit:a6d271becc7629cef7152fb4f39fa36f38c22279bfad23e5e36fba7b768152b6","unit:aa73864ad5573efed629eabcf95e82f084860f149be4e619429880b995d1bc9a","unit:ac0abc2e9c12bbf29b598967170e1aa57a4524459809c1eb2c95d29693d28dcd","unit:b4a247552710792df2389597db1667ad83ec5e0390abb308cf33ed73989d910d","unit:b59f24ed1dacf46837b7aaa4f6370d5ca38665501b3a433d6d3ea9af706a121e","unit:babbb2a02c04892aff7f659a1626ba51019751d87b6b1e30f8ace64464069bcb","unit:bf3c1087eb9ace4f405d11dfb66441ccfae0b16d83a605d4b4d6db10d3f1722e","unit:ce958f36745bf633996f49717b0e3ab8ca3c6922332c6ff5bddc978da648413a","unit:dac66f21f9b37768247e585a5639e18b13725b83df6887af681d55d4bd8dd0a0","unit:e3ab8ebca9e427e55af776101a4ee2c4564b62f3eec6343a8b25bcddffa71dfa","unit:f4f5961f783856c6eaf6432fe85aa05f8b92203c55a7a377614a95b9fd49f2c2","unit:f63d119eea422c7d1fe04976e5578f2656ba2fda16191f7bfa64fb7b8a0984e3","unit:f6f0c275e47bb87144173ded03648cf1949387a0c8fd81d187b9b8a6ed54622c","unit:fc19871bc842905d5d75f40345c354142598b5952f474a6eb053757b2fc994e8"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d53f1514866a3000447bb7e7","scopeContentSha256":"52879dd3e8de62a7c9b5297cf7b46279cff566ba7dbe0fc20541acad78a552bc","localRef":"s28"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0","scopeContentSha256":"a391c31dc44ef5080afb5df010c0f4b7049f9d9c3e58f66d1155990786029596","localRef":"s18"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l1","originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:29","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l1","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge:link:29","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:d53f1514866a3000447bb7e7","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l1","source":"s28","target":"s18","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["Instability and weak-gravity conjectures require their own applicability conditions; they motivate tests without deciding their outcomes."],"challengeStatement":"Instability and weak-gravity conjectures require applicability tests and do not decide the outcome of a channel search.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"5e5d0c0d72fb950ebe1457b76fbc2e2ffd12c38ec05281a20aaea51785edacf2","reply.jsonSha256":"c164a1797f2579dd542d6a85d2d5ada3d3923f51dbf00c5ad7715dfcc3293196","reply.raw.txtSha256":"6fe1f9ffacf3fd23fcd414f8ea84dea076b70b1efa9cc4c1b266645516a3284c","receipt.jsonSha256":"949135a1913dfe4fc7bc496b3d40e6e41cb0fc8289d1ebe30e318c6fbc1fd497","normalization.jsonSha256":"60ac91844e3455fced77f0d35aa125b34a3618b7f066752c3b6583de30ead537","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"12aff7bccd1643b13672aabf092a32b906a1405e7d3f8a924039a2d009499098"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-032f7db703bb514040cc-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"113090d319770847b1bcf319abc555a657aec606eecef8697c3bfa6cb949a534","reply.jsonSha256":"3f358a065f5156682f2bef99d3ba50ed16c59ef4202316b790a99980a867e52a","reply.raw.txtSha256":"332bdc783baf2d0e00a74757f00a86efa14aa5098688b1b04ac620ab3ec084e9","receipt.jsonSha256":"3a728c710537f0d36937246c575232be90eac650ccbfc3a22c0180680ac5aa50","normalization.jsonSha256":"3e6136e890c81aac9092b885c2b64906f9fc4cccb35942ee78a80d99d814ac23"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d53f1514866a3000447bb7e7"},{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2005.07072","sourceId":"ev:d24f5c0305dbea216c5007333a89ebb1","sourceSha256":"ca6cb0d913e820e61c916d2ce1c2cf74ed8644a40fe33e7bceeb46d0678a2a03","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6c30ee73bdc1009dc84c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"208b9378118dfbed76fe8943400a790c3b3eec2c4f9bf97c8d356daeb52c851b","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"59f69d791ac24d589e0572e5b88e408277b87e2998d2ccca3d76beb8cf0f6b97","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d53f1514866a3000447bb7e7"},{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0"},{"ref":"e8","kind":"primary","paperId":"2005.07072","sourceId":"ev:d24f5c0305dbea216c5007333a89ebb1","sourceSha256":"ca6cb0d913e820e61c916d2ce1c2cf74ed8644a40fe33e7bceeb46d0678a2a03","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6c30ee73bdc1009dc84c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"208b9378118dfbed76fe8943400a790c3b3eec2c4f9bf97c8d356daeb52c851b","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"59f69d791ac24d589e0572e5b88e408277b87e2998d2ccca3d76beb8cf0f6b97","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d1","originalRef":"l1","status":"route","source":"s28","target":"s18","type":"premise_check","title":"Check conjecture applicability when interpreting stability tests","rationale":"When a stability inference invokes an instability or weak-gravity conjecture, s18 asks whether that conjecture applies. Both original statements distinguish this check from the outcome of an actual channel search.","qualification":"The connection applies only to conjecture-dependent interpretations within s28; ordinary perturbative and decay-channel tests do not acquire a conjectural premise. Retain the relevant charge/tension, boundary, near-horizon versus asymptotic, and quantum-correction assumptions. Neither a conjecture nor protection in a retained sector establishes an all-channel stability verdict.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l1","s28","s18"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d1","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The source is the stability question whose conjecture-dependent interpretation requires an applicability check. The record correctly limits that check to such interpretations, consistent with both original statements that conjectures motivate tests without deciding their outcomes. Ordinary stability calculations acquire no universal conjectural premise.","refs":["l1","s28","s18"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l1","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l2":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l2","source":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","target":"q025-candidate-question:7501998dc50abadf89467f50","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on Higgs-sector measurements and model tests","rationale":"The complete Higgs-sector phenomenology question refines the Higgs-physics and observational-test directions explicitly included in s38. The broad parent is not itself a particular method being applied.","qualification":"Measurements and model tests constrain specified mechanisms without establishing their ultraviolet completion. The original challenge's crunching example remains a conditional scale-lowering proposal with prospective collider tests. Dataset dates, priors, flavour choices, hadronic uncertainties and production histories remain local; fit compatibility, model preference and discovery remain distinct.","evidenceIds":["unit:03e2016057e759a07fd15c21c84c0911e3d6d6c5f3e5f486e63901665eb3f93d","unit:06552982d252b03f1acc809710a1442978fb0b9bc28907047cae71d4416ab9b9","unit:1da1632b404bc4db79a6cf415567de4af9846de61148eadbd81d99d455ce5357","unit:30fff49bf370a30ca7eddcdf6cf037161cc9f2491f09a25bd424ccb1d126f0a9","unit:31408aa86f56a134d6ec73134418d888c990ebe7b57d4a6da8f5dc986b998918","unit:39a71b4db549f5caed523dacf7dfcea96d220941bfc863507c898c590ff3b113","unit:538bac7016407582224fa37fae6f2aee6c50e7bd24f5c96c3918a76726ded877","unit:54c21caf77796c05e48c93bffa72a3d12aaa36f3de2e8b82f272df80f84532d0","unit:5bf996b185a3a38471189f08ed73ee4e30d8ef515c10a9a56d4ea3f83a5ac8a8","unit:5c85851b79f0438ab83420ea87ab925ae233b4d9bd5a9890e6b4136e45397ded","unit:5e91d8d52e5cc3bbda39ce8b0e0d170a5f366072216964a4d3c2b720071bf67f","unit:6456bed05fa1e96898ea860f9fa9d369a4facfa66576ecc4e9cfd2fdffc30c0f","unit:666c9a459fcc3584853eed6c3c426fbe7ad6b326c05d9d736e0ee757e01d1c4b","unit:683f43a9c14ea8ac66f509737d9b1e6ad5b3e60cf5382308ec0cde5533c23231","unit:6e4c8b24cbb10788560a623257afa6cea1bbe0dc5741571debfd5107c0dab30a","unit:716810c7a0c3b08b7255426733a1bebe9e0c8dd55d904b3dae7c38082118e254","unit:8073617eadf0b0b4f7818b98bc59a645547dbbce57a77ccc5d934ff08fda68eb","unit:87cdd4696e9d733a20e8eb8482a1305d323d9f5f52df715697120c99bf4361d4","unit:9419708ac2f18c5783ea762b38a37b6fe2bfa891052b2504dbb88cf7dae820a9","unit:9f3548a8fee61852978d8678fba00119be8f28046d231ac09036b89ef8eec39f","unit:aa56a54eae6a2b6f9a26b7df7a539ba27c83e134c94660e0ca20f517fa81192c","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:b5dcdda9758c946146d53027cf6c556e0e2b7ea7e060606ffc74c130bac5e028","unit:c10774b049cb18ec9c9f0b2e958fc0ab6cd71b451bd85c494dbd49a4cddd4761","unit:c2623164c142e609ed750491fe3748eb123a17dec9c68f82e76a3914c057a3f4","unit:d1a88fa786d7359ef81cda261da55738b7fdfaa0bbd02d6d7b15a915dd25f175","unit:da809d9df9139a9579f84a9be5963ae19f082b348111239601e728f7a6017b04","unit:e16f67137d2df72baca21302278a1e8186aa7d5cfe7eb4248957ac4d1727291e","unit:e2e099886f88562437330f1114bea77be84ea05a15066b7fc4c55b9ef446f047","unit:e79d0f85a5eb3941177b2774f83a15683d15ecd4ffd8d96fa2c30ed06794e817","unit:ea95d6adb3356188d3ec9529e19f8f33b4bcaf4fc46dea3e562f97c7d422564f","unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351","unit:f9cd0d09416078182ebdebf95a3c5a2083105da408624694b3103a9ca4d202a2","unit:fa7567614cbdecb66294306cf3e752542afaf906f3a077f982331ee270931e11"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","scopeContentSha256":"ef71386060e2fc1d227f043cc98ffc9fb214a5308e8300f4925a535889b37388","localRef":"s38"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7501998dc50abadf89467f50","scopeContentSha256":"b68b8f0a0756c1833500d023d10ee0394867dc37c0bf8cd620e839855ab51ec4","localRef":"s15"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l2","originalCandidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:10","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l2","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:10","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:7501998dc50abadf89467f50","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l2","source":"s38","target":"s15","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Higgs-sector measurements and model tests constrain proposed mechanisms without establishing their ultraviolet completion."],"challengeStatement":"Measurements and model tests constrain proposed Higgs mechanisms. The crunching source supplies a conditional scale-lowering example and prospective collider tests.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d644ddab626378471e4e0e42e4647c7e7a25fecadbaa1e63a95a554f87191605","reply.jsonSha256":"6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baaa57c3371646728a9a6fdf0dbcf6993ec3823ad12","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d31aef6575a76f59717d4759f4579ffdd1d56fd28b78e02e8db7fc516e6047f7","receipt.jsonSha256":"9e433a0026eb4f85d23db2f00953ee9a3ae4a365086892133927c9d41ea370b0","normalization.jsonSha256":"183ad7569d3dae4c3d0b00de6b21c3f4f4bf7a84481aad349887a3baf49e221a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"cda5fe05a626a0f00541f652aa13f42b5d89bc4664a6f297b0a65b2db3d67f04"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec2db46cf22a587a919921edc537a478392d749e785a8148972bd1e70652a9ea","reply.jsonSha256":"56f480852079df01466714ab316a55727b30a2e0de94c29702889e66cda21363","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3f9873c2026cbfa22c8a3d0437949e4299c0be824d455277cf16d93676a1394e","receipt.jsonSha256":"e14c0967089e928b0b363cde04fa9a71ebc69e8422f7e25bc9ac929991d8120c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d7163380927a596c08f8f55bcb25bd02a8d363abdbb6eeeea8f0a08f9a8bcb4f"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7501998dc50abadf89467f50"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:a0251bebe68a60253ffa41cbc11bfb0f","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"eb684df53b76cc4bc8746e1233ab1bace2fd8fbbf645352cdacd40bfca85ba0a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_7","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:7501998dc50abadf89467f50"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:a0251bebe68a60253ffa41cbc11bfb0f","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"eb684df53b76cc4bc8746e1233ab1bace2fd8fbbf645352cdacd40bfca85ba0a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d2","originalRef":"l2","status":"route","source":"s38","target":"s15","type":"narrower","title":"Focus on Higgs-sector measurements and model tests","rationale":"The complete Higgs-sector phenomenology question refines the Higgs-physics and observational-test directions explicitly included in s38. The broad parent is not itself a particular method being applied.","qualification":"Measurements and model tests constrain specified mechanisms without establishing their ultraviolet completion. The original challenge's crunching example remains a conditional scale-lowering proposal with prospective collider tests. Dataset dates, priors, flavour choices, hadronic uncertainties and production histories remain local; fit compatibility, model preference and discovery remain distinct.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l2","s38","s15"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d2","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The complete Higgs-sector measurement and model-test scope refines the Higgs, spectra and phenomenological-test directions explicitly present in s38. The narrower type is supported without inventing an underlying method. Both original statements' limitations survive, including the conditional crunching example, prospective tests and absence of ultraviolet certification.","refs":["l2","s38","s15"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l2","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l3":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l3","source":"q025-candidate-question:626250d1cf4fae4cb2f38b96","target":"q025-candidate-question:a933bcee7169dcddca789765","type":"method_for","title":"Apply metastability and survival analysis to crunching selection","rationale":"Metastability and lifetime analysis supplies a method for the metastable-vacuum formation and survival conditions entering the supplied crunching-selection proposal.","qualification":"This connection is specific to selection mechanisms that use those conditions. It does not apply to every dynamical, environmental or statistical selection proposal. Particle content, matching, additional scalar directions and any curvature assumptions remain source-specific. A metastability condition alone is not a weak-scale selection mechanism, and the packet supplies no current numerical stability determination.","evidenceIds":["unit:0dd50f09801bbe36e67f310bbb7a822b9f135fac8fa91c0a0ed8e31047ab38bb","unit:11a76fcf82f7057a9cc816da8e28bce12c7ac8e7ab4edd67804b4b8a534240dc","unit:17d09347dd939560dcc1c42ad2a82bce66a5ba7b20f2e06b93bab1d9f22683d5","unit:199f6b0fce9bae286503fdf2418b2a96c35e0c2dca9e9f4293e8fc22f15fcd8c","unit:1b8f0e2f4775166f3d147b751b06640675f79830cbb41407c956f91748e3751c","unit:27d10739a4173802d43927c8caddb54b4369d4945c7c43f06c7b50aefabcb2ed","unit:32396e134ac59d6d3da5a22ba13b942018fb675c783e865af68db6648a33f2a2","unit:3319fc6c6a336917d4cb45fe2ac01390db6e0e18fe3047c2547e3ce6472c08be","unit:35ed96b584f91b47fa7d2eaca535aa6338a93f13b966e66d2451713f50c16466","unit:3952317ebb5d58768e76751aeadb22eab9a264485a4e01360397f2f24f576a35","unit:45061ceb132d557b4131f8bfab9c382a391a82f306f6c67619f32712c2b03e50","unit:4d7f7289c468297a8dd1c9c1fc8723d6294973362c5622119ce2ce5db4e7e9f5","unit:6870ae021972f92a80dd346121dc5445c3523a09f94cfbbaa013cc761481ec0d","unit:69be19facfa996156c61f80ee76f314dd41c639239eb6b59ef63e0476ab6dd7f","unit:8073617eadf0b0b4f7818b98bc59a645547dbbce57a77ccc5d934ff08fda68eb","unit:817779675cec36cd7d6f23c7573cc5a5004e159289cbdf34148d6d2d6f009c60","unit:872294c8bb9ba4a9e6c4233bcdd8a83f8372385487d5999f8e3e683db7b907a4","unit:87cdd4696e9d733a20e8eb8482a1305d323d9f5f52df715697120c99bf4361d4","unit:aa4774c7a943ccbad2a52983890c11a232dc2915e66e61c1180f68a23b8ab082","unit:aab8de110b756774005a643db1f1a2ff7f10b0b4dce92da670e9d5a153c7e322","unit:b0f6c76cc535164b7cbed504ce3b6e2ac0d8dcb369edf65a3c67a3d67952aa01","unit:b30c91627d9c717fa96ae2f611af3e4071e08aa019e2bae2daf0e1e771469d10","unit:b5dcdda9758c946146d53027cf6c556e0e2b7ea7e060606ffc74c130bac5e028","unit:b87019598e2188eccfb22391b8e2324945f69a5ae6a207b96715e79a1ac9abb9","unit:b9e3db8650ea29a6107205991324e6aa3ec320331e73f9be967b23a1c8c5e527","unit:c0c0ef6359c25b5d75513933cab7c3bba540ec2f3adbc6100661c86470b436c1","unit:c10774b049cb18ec9c9f0b2e958fc0ab6cd71b451bd85c494dbd49a4cddd4761","unit:c632a2e01571c45f72132a1a610dad6ce2f62e9c3bac4cdaf899b7712d57deb4","unit:d1a88fa786d7359ef81cda261da55738b7fdfaa0bbd02d6d7b15a915dd25f175","unit:e79d0f85a5eb3941177b2774f83a15683d15ecd4ffd8d96fa2c30ed06794e817","unit:ec921b45e6d82d62a365e5a8a5d846dcb325dffaaf641db2f5dd1ebcac20a13a","unit:ed2192dc41e60e41e23c386e995dfd77891c81c89b5de451b1354e6a607cbde4"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:626250d1cf4fae4cb2f38b96","scopeContentSha256":"bb30b7e5efe9ec58b8f1bbd96502d8acf75da53b279962b47f6bfaa73ac304fd","localRef":"s12"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:a933bcee7169dcddca789765","scopeContentSha256":"91870232de187174a04c73ac5c8ec8ac23886f5df8c5d34f6624aea3138c48e2","localRef":"s21"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l3","originalCandidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:17","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l3","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:17","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:626250d1cf4fae4cb2f38b96","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:a933bcee7169dcddca789765","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l3","source":"s12","target":"s21","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Metastability and lifetime conditions enter the supplied crunching-selection proposal. This connection is specific to relevant mechanisms, not every selection model."],"challengeStatement":"Metastable-vacuum formation and survival enter the supplied crunching-selection argument. This method relation does not apply to every selection proposal.","originalEvidenceKinds":["primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d644ddab626378471e4e0e42e4647c7e7a25fecadbaa1e63a95a554f87191605","reply.jsonSha256":"6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baaa57c3371646728a9a6fdf0dbcf6993ec3823ad12","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d31aef6575a76f59717d4759f4579ffdd1d56fd28b78e02e8db7fc516e6047f7","receipt.jsonSha256":"9e433a0026eb4f85d23db2f00953ee9a3ae4a365086892133927c9d41ea370b0","normalization.jsonSha256":"183ad7569d3dae4c3d0b00de6b21c3f4f4bf7a84481aad349887a3baf49e221a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"cda5fe05a626a0f00541f652aa13f42b5d89bc4664a6f297b0a65b2db3d67f04"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec2db46cf22a587a919921edc537a478392d749e785a8148972bd1e70652a9ea","reply.jsonSha256":"56f480852079df01466714ab316a55727b30a2e0de94c29702889e66cda21363","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3f9873c2026cbfa22c8a3d0437949e4299c0be824d455277cf16d93676a1394e","receipt.jsonSha256":"e14c0967089e928b0b363cde04fa9a71ebc69e8422f7e25bc9ac929991d8120c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d7163380927a596c08f8f55bcb25bd02a8d363abdbb6eeeea8f0a08f9a8bcb4f"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:5a2e732afa0228bb0d2ebc3a8af9f62a","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3493,"textSha256":"15a6c25c062e0337468495e8677e600e961960919a557c1279f5f4aa87e6ed7e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:7a7de13567ad7751d33811288481e377","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":3537,"textSha256":"d5e1c22f29a0b9878cc7a0aa8f915b45d95035246c848e5db876cdaf84dfa894","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:a0251bebe68a60253ffa41cbc11bfb0f","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"eb684df53b76cc4bc8746e1233ab1bace2fd8fbbf645352cdacd40bfca85ba0a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"e2","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:5a2e732afa0228bb0d2ebc3a8af9f62a","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3493,"textSha256":"15a6c25c062e0337468495e8677e600e961960919a557c1279f5f4aa87e6ed7e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e5","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:7a7de13567ad7751d33811288481e377","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":3537,"textSha256":"d5e1c22f29a0b9878cc7a0aa8f915b45d95035246c848e5db876cdaf84dfa894","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","paperId":"2502.07876","sourceId":"ev:a0251bebe68a60253ffa41cbc11bfb0f","sourceSha256":"8f7bccab00e021036048c43adc9de75e5408de4faa896ef55c5384f291f8f33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3cc9c678f29fe705d478/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"84ed92d947cd29f6a3fcff8b3dc09fce84d5e148d620aa09e195f4099272cd01","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"eb684df53b76cc4bc8746e1233ab1bace2fd8fbbf645352cdacd40bfca85ba0a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d3","originalRef":"l3","status":"route","source":"s12","target":"s21","type":"method_for","title":"Apply metastability and survival analysis to crunching selection","rationale":"Metastability and lifetime analysis supplies a method for the metastable-vacuum formation and survival conditions entering the supplied crunching-selection proposal.","qualification":"This connection is specific to selection mechanisms that use those conditions. It does not apply to every dynamical, environmental or statistical selection proposal. Particle content, matching, additional scalar directions and any curvature assumptions remain source-specific. A metastability condition alone is not a weak-scale selection mechanism, and the packet supplies no current numerical stability determination.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l3","s12","s21"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d3","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify metastability, formation and survival analysis as an input to the specified crunching-selection argument. The method direction s12 → s21 is correct. The record expressly avoids extending it to every selection mechanism or treating a lifetime condition as a sufficient scale-selection mechanism.","refs":["l3","s12","s21"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l3","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l4":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l4","source":"q025-candidate-question:da610f8c4b77dc97f21677f5","target":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","type":"application_of","title":"Trace spectrum diagnostics to their mediation constructions","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: mediation inference and model discrimination apply the source-specific spectrum predictions of breaking and mediation constructions.","qualification":"Shared mass patterns do not identify a unique mechanism. Fits retain their parameter-family, uncertainty and prior assumptions; hypothetical collider studies and historical search arguments remain dated. No universal mediation hierarchy or generic sequestering follows, and spatial separation alone does not establish sequestering.","evidenceIds":["unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","unit:06d0fff814a1ccfbc9c6fc6722b6a758f63b71fbbda46dffd5e1745f57d4723b","unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","unit:0de09fc89be45aa7aed25bbcdc28100471fa55c8fc0f8ca8e3601ac41f6a3d12","unit:11c64a9574c7812ca866ffe455dfa66bb99851524485b81fd996e966bf19d13f","unit:1b3f60d668b6e5e34f7d802825aca8a7da3d450a02c8871cc663009dcd0c4c9b","unit:356c33f119fd2002b7bfe3f5f27ec5ba96d0563691b3112342edaf46623fab53","unit:45d4b4ad8550bdbdc0c2b8b0b231e4802095910fec1c356277c544d8d63b79f0","unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","unit:4e46e8a6e98d00a4b93a3d78291fea1340276a1f49811129d1d7ba403c007d88","unit:66f2128fe3c730b2c6401827e2da1852e7022d1fbc910e8bdfa4ea219db44ee9","unit:6f4bd85cba9e7fa6775a09acf61cb878ef117b3cc5044b200147abb7a136e6b7","unit:86bdd8dbc9e3994b23ea8394c40a8c95b2c6cf1488c02715afa36663c68c2495","unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","unit:a89ad673796c91d6a0bd8f292dde9faae5fb686f291bb1208aa3d4b66da55f97","unit:ab871d7619e7955fe098f2140aba6103cfaf8991943cfa38ba18b6b2dca0f666","unit:acfa3c138fe7f7b17c784ccfc8c8cea3c9281ba86224d642963559b38f4a1c7c","unit:b7c0477228ebecae4aeec4d61ab1f908d3c903bf7bf94310f23d46c3290edbaf","unit:b9ada24dac412b144c1bfeec0199298988d608716c31cff05842d849994b456d","unit:ba2db2d76dd6ce5790bb60ec53801f7a3dcc9b3b31008a748cc4b2135a5fc45f","unit:c0939c5f7d452074b0f8f661a7a753e218ece5c8f215491d476a15ebe0124af2","unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","unit:c85f81c5a449a568894fda092cbbcd10adb8c797ffb1e7ef9afea547ca5f1d49","unit:ca6d1f2005c083a30e87c83b44eeb0a494da020a23c79f5c5ec57677c042cf8a","unit:e292d6f025aad66121d75508a8aa35844e2add144cb61d853c67b6b73c559f23","unit:e479b47323dd61aa7b752344d8e7943fce5039396e6e8dc59a7508f11be0c59e","unit:f12074876d2226dff1c73eb66784473fe6b8027a2e23b350b437f6572f3fb433","unit:f6b94df4b49821cf5e06d15c3f6aaba63616b2a1ed719390809dc5b594178351"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da610f8c4b77dc97f21677f5","scopeContentSha256":"ef8fe7b0005649e8240a7c32752969637370e3d8f6cf4257ae56d7c64b452988","localRef":"s30"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","localRef":"s24"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l4","originalCandidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:19","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l4","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge:link:19","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:da610f8c4b77dc97f21677f5","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l4","source":"s24","target":"s30","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Predicted spectra motivate inference and discrimination questions; shared mass patterns do not identify a unique mediation mechanism."],"challengeStatement":"Spectrum predictions motivate mediation inference and model discrimination; shared mass patterns do not uniquely identify a mechanism.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"d644ddab626378471e4e0e42e4647c7e7a25fecadbaa1e63a95a554f87191605","reply.jsonSha256":"6ff4d03e487b21ec1b511baaa57c3371646728a9a6fdf0dbcf6993ec3823ad12","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d31aef6575a76f59717d4759f4579ffdd1d56fd28b78e02e8db7fc516e6047f7","receipt.jsonSha256":"9e433a0026eb4f85d23db2f00953ee9a3ae4a365086892133927c9d41ea370b0","normalization.jsonSha256":"183ad7569d3dae4c3d0b00de6b21c3f4f4bf7a84481aad349887a3baf49e221a","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"cda5fe05a626a0f00541f652aa13f42b5d89bc4664a6f297b0a65b2db3d67f04"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-10605e3e73b1e2b3809f-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"ec2db46cf22a587a919921edc537a478392d749e785a8148972bd1e70652a9ea","reply.jsonSha256":"56f480852079df01466714ab316a55727b30a2e0de94c29702889e66cda21363","reply.raw.txtSha256":"3f9873c2026cbfa22c8a3d0437949e4299c0be824d455277cf16d93676a1394e","receipt.jsonSha256":"e14c0967089e928b0b363cde04fa9a71ebc69e8422f7e25bc9ac929991d8120c","normalization.jsonSha256":"d7163380927a596c08f8f55bcb25bd02a8d363abdbb6eeeea8f0a08f9a8bcb4f"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"},{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da610f8c4b77dc97f21677f5"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"},{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:da610f8c4b77dc97f21677f5"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d4","originalRef":"l4","status":"route","source":"s30","target":"s24","type":"application_of","title":"Trace spectrum diagnostics to their mediation constructions","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: mediation inference and model discrimination apply the source-specific spectrum predictions of breaking and mediation constructions.","qualification":"Shared mass patterns do not identify a unique mechanism. Fits retain their parameter-family, uncertainty and prior assumptions; hypothetical collider studies and historical search arguments remain dated. No universal mediation hierarchy or generic sequestering follows, and spatial separation alone does not establish sequestering.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l4","s30","s24"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d4","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Mediation inference applies the spectrum predictions of the underlying breaking and mediation constructions, supporting the reversed application direction. The record retains both statements' non-uniqueness warning and the endpoint restrictions on fits, hypothetical studies, mediation hierarchies and sequestering.","refs":["l4","s30","s24"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l4","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l5":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l5","source":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad","target":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","type":"method_for","title":"Use expansion, reheating and entropy histories in relic calculations","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the history calculations and questions in s31 supply source-specific inputs to candidate production and abundance calculations in s4.","qualification":"Altered expansion, matter domination, vacuum domination, late reheating, entropy release and stasis are distinct histories, not simultaneous assumptions. Reheating definitions and scalar-tensor boundary conditions remain local. Thermal and nonthermal production remain separate possibilities; nonstandard expansion does not require nonthermal dark matter, and a chosen history does not certify candidate viability.","evidenceIds":["unit:086443a70e473b97b9bf2b7cef696694c8b0c2e3ed9d6cce4c0e47b19fb12e22","unit:0ac5f33eee9e30f13d39d3e40376e84955b2b4250896a9c79dff2932fe52ddfe","unit:1a8568e9044c2488d4831b94b550dc431f436dd9c4df137b19b1e3c2d40e3f63","unit:1e96331a613901b21e0941d90c6652e41bcf7c74ba6030bed0a42d0a478e2968","unit:2d3d65b41648c0f939fba5152e588f2fb018d4e2274f758e39c6b9da23a72c57","unit:383d13703c71f3f25373a6ba0e1661f1e7e8cdeb7bd60a8065f24cc2200577f8","unit:3a27d6408cf96805cf6c280eb0c67b7715232bc784b79320000b8679b38de17a","unit:4388ba5c525b417e4a3e81463cabf723b16fda2447df04105d5d37c95b9f7fad","unit:56017bdcddd38ed7cba4066f0d2855ab32f64ec5330fc5104299358b29497dba","unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","unit:699d34cdd7756d1c072c7a517702ec67f86c041e11097f1ed8ca0fb4a3816e82","unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","unit:743a5ec4ec3327442a03957751dfa536fef453cc99c934ad167cc223432045a0","unit:85dbdc1c905fd4cc14c1060102df4e9ca557976fbdc069e9f588e83162c03b96","unit:886390bae4de13ca3fa9e42b4829aee4c1b2f9d3fa5107860df6115430055e16","unit:8e20c0326768a1f649bdfd14b44bd23e09092673cf36a5ad36fe7532ac92f1c6","unit:8e9e312f12fae1519b5dcbd7dec805b41fdf1f0d3442a9673093b49c0ad3df36","unit:96c6613c2dd137e812dbc4166a6e8ead41b9b0d2a2518722c8fa4f4de6056bbc","unit:9a58bbb2e0d7da3e10998875a6dfee59040d5ddf4d3845653b6354a2fbbe8f6a","unit:9ebc2cf7d7d878ac80b5084b5d5d450419cc253129cf1bc9dab73864be840032","unit:9f867e2655c9ee718616d07641d24237d81c9f1ee269a6f9ce1169bb7a5ebaee","unit:a757dfd6e7766fa39431351f4621d054ffbea3c8fc2ad8463b5fe265bc329bf7","unit:a774271268e9e40cd895b4062fae8e32f6418d55bebe369af87270ba8bc9c09f","unit:ba6b6174155db38b41214e5c3f99fa2493ce25ff20621535f6f9511c17f5c1d9","unit:c78813fed1118a3a9647db73b578c6931e7f80a6e2ea08f4a434be88cb997525","unit:ca873de0fdebf135f4071fd942269c1fb771f209effde80589c3f9b06af4677e","unit:cdb3c02f0a1f7c34f2b4010837319fb660002c53828f20c50788f60793573dd8","unit:cec053fff92732be4f03a2a8f423d75850c602a10c959a3319f2add0f4b67cc6","unit:cf0f5d73068de72fc720bc98c5772e2ad522fbd1b1df061575a88c53cc930bb5","unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","unit:d746397051946e3ea1aad18713ce16be7e7baa9f21b9fb53aeaa0c99b37027a5","unit:d8a0e02ebe7842c9f87c037afcb01c9d1450c39d15245a57af63b09db34d4d5a","unit:da249dfb31cb6293a2683e2c9a1ea3f6f7029ad13d668621824d0bac7eaa0a9c","unit:dbed9b6879afe9a03c27774aa14c0f3595a9a18d55979fecac48c074509831f2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad","scopeContentSha256":"5d126a280165780fdf8dfcdfd076bb2e8ffad8bba713458132c3104f44b8d846","localRef":"s31"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","scopeContentSha256":"392640e6a9b8a01652bc7d6dafda7769a164fa44c0efde3644a103be5f08f62a","localRef":"s4"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l5","originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:13","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l5","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:13","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l5","source":"s4","target":"s31","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Expansion, reheating and entropy histories supply source-specific inputs to relic calculations."],"challengeStatement":"Expansion, reheating and entropy histories supply distinct inputs to relic calculations.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"0d479554dd0b39ca9daf07157c4f39675210457752a02cafa57ef8e2f52bfa7e","reply.jsonSha256":"b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd4722ba8dda705c880ad49294161d9061295ac5c5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9f3caf81e788c84ac0164350156eee9d2eb362baacf7ad9f05eaf093273877e8","receipt.jsonSha256":"1165f285c2c643f1a2270fabeb515a22bfcd8476412d71364f6c4b7cc0b1b52b","normalization.jsonSha256":"65d79380e46d8c2f1a63efb46f5d49883594612e5b03d1e4c4c4cbcabbee2346","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4a44ea5475d2801e35e1e86aad6ff99d9db2dce8307fdc2c9041f7beb32dd37a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"876fcf82b3760877d5adf0ad3cea3352e0f0e96e9be01cbf7c7325a0609e4a55","reply.jsonSha256":"a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d2e1d06273788a3258264e645c16dcacdaa3f68ac","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d04dfd346aec28f9d51f6dd453759d3040c159c9b9041a0287eecdb7310d96d9","receipt.jsonSha256":"a1fa78d73a75fe703fb1cbeac5b35a16ddc235795219891d7e028e0e8f09c26b","normalization.jsonSha256":"2e493e2c7f4741d29428ad8769d68daf9d37a86a64b17eea548d298edea89613"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"},{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d5","originalRef":"l5","status":"route","source":"s31","target":"s4","type":"method_for","title":"Use expansion, reheating and entropy histories in relic calculations","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the history calculations and questions in s31 supply source-specific inputs to candidate production and abundance calculations in s4.","qualification":"Altered expansion, matter domination, vacuum domination, late reheating, entropy release and stasis are distinct histories, not simultaneous assumptions. Reheating definitions and scalar-tensor boundary conditions remain local. Thermal and nonthermal production remain separate possibilities; nonstandard expansion does not require nonthermal dark matter, and a chosen history does not certify candidate viability.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l5","s31","s4"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d5","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements place expansion, reheating and entropy histories on the input side of relic calculations. The reversed method direction is therefore supported. The qualification keeps distinct histories and thermal or nonthermal production alternatives separate without making a chosen history certify candidate viability.","refs":["l5","s31","s4"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l5","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l6":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l6","source":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","target":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","type":"related_question","title":"Connect axion candidates with non-inflaton initial conditions and abundance","rationale":"Both statements support a connection between axion candidate and abundance questions and the non-inflaton initial-condition questions in s22. They do not identify a particular transferable method or establish containment of the full non-inflaton scope within dark-matter production.","qualification":"The connection concerns the axion abundance component. Curvaton, spectator and dark-energy targets remain distinct, and an axion present during inflation is not automatically the inflaton. A radial PQ inflaton and its angular axion retain different roles. Heuristic angular sampling does not establish a success probability, and inherited observational bounds remain historical.","evidenceIds":["unit:04d0657e87fbe8361caa7c6ea285cd8d58a1af94f9c2f6eea29ae16ab42367d7","unit:086443a70e473b97b9bf2b7cef696694c8b0c2e3ed9d6cce4c0e47b19fb12e22","unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","unit:0ac5f33eee9e30f13d39d3e40376e84955b2b4250896a9c79dff2932fe52ddfe","unit:0f35aad79e513365b8edb7ec5f980ccfe09a912caa9a868b6dee97336580d917","unit:1e96331a613901b21e0941d90c6652e41bcf7c74ba6030bed0a42d0a478e2968","unit:2acf2e165d284872cc674da3477d42164092f746d47c1ccc727f20fba6ee4e7d","unit:2d3d65b41648c0f939fba5152e588f2fb018d4e2274f758e39c6b9da23a72c57","unit:383d13703c71f3f25373a6ba0e1661f1e7e8cdeb7bd60a8065f24cc2200577f8","unit:3a27d6408cf96805cf6c280eb0c67b7715232bc784b79320000b8679b38de17a","unit:42475120c24644ab18baac5efe62d3f73331d367763c6bfdb714a64e0daa1cec","unit:4388ba5c525b417e4a3e81463cabf723b16fda2447df04105d5d37c95b9f7fad","unit:4b9dcedf1682440a5020f2f9228dce80d564a7f45e509b27938495e6a33738b4","unit:56017bdcddd38ed7cba4066f0d2855ab32f64ec5330fc5104299358b29497dba","unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","unit:699d34cdd7756d1c072c7a517702ec67f86c041e11097f1ed8ca0fb4a3816e82","unit:69ac4e9fd736238f4f572feb553d0abdfdb9603b83439c486119d7177e098f68","unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","unit:743a5ec4ec3327442a03957751dfa536fef453cc99c934ad167cc223432045a0","unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","unit:886390bae4de13ca3fa9e42b4829aee4c1b2f9d3fa5107860df6115430055e16","unit:8e20c0326768a1f649bdfd14b44bd23e09092673cf36a5ad36fe7532ac92f1c6","unit:96c6613c2dd137e812dbc4166a6e8ead41b9b0d2a2518722c8fa4f4de6056bbc","unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","unit:9f867e2655c9ee718616d07641d24237d81c9f1ee269a6f9ce1169bb7a5ebaee","unit:a757dfd6e7766fa39431351f4621d054ffbea3c8fc2ad8463b5fe265bc329bf7","unit:b9161ceb2f21406c1bcaa52576595709c1c6f8cb0c53d03155a970b28c48da36","unit:c78813fed1118a3a9647db73b578c6931e7f80a6e2ea08f4a434be88cb997525","unit:cf0f5d73068de72fc720bc98c5772e2ad522fbd1b1df061575a88c53cc930bb5","unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","unit:dbed9b6879afe9a03c27774aa14c0f3595a9a18d55979fecac48c074509831f2","unit:dd96fa9eae2a7cbda855f49ee5ab0843e5f810bf7c448106a401b7142b797ccd","unit:eb1cae1758a8701851d75fdd607a1d25ac6cf994daad8e3dae4556a3a6ae541c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","scopeContentSha256":"392640e6a9b8a01652bc7d6dafda7769a164fa44c0efde3644a103be5f08f62a","localRef":"s4"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","scopeContentSha256":"8b152b0159ec18b695139265318c907f9566cf0589732d73e690bbbbf26732cb","localRef":"s22"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l6","originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:17","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l6","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:17","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l6","source":"s4","target":"s22","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Non-inflaton axion roles provide distinct initial-condition and abundance questions; no axion present during inflation is automatically the inflaton."],"challengeStatement":"Non-inflaton axion roles introduce initial-condition and abundance questions without identifying the axion as the inflaton.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"0d479554dd0b39ca9daf07157c4f39675210457752a02cafa57ef8e2f52bfa7e","reply.jsonSha256":"b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd4722ba8dda705c880ad49294161d9061295ac5c5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9f3caf81e788c84ac0164350156eee9d2eb362baacf7ad9f05eaf093273877e8","receipt.jsonSha256":"1165f285c2c643f1a2270fabeb515a22bfcd8476412d71364f6c4b7cc0b1b52b","normalization.jsonSha256":"65d79380e46d8c2f1a63efb46f5d49883594612e5b03d1e4c4c4cbcabbee2346","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4a44ea5475d2801e35e1e86aad6ff99d9db2dce8307fdc2c9041f7beb32dd37a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"876fcf82b3760877d5adf0ad3cea3352e0f0e96e9be01cbf7c7325a0609e4a55","reply.jsonSha256":"a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d2e1d06273788a3258264e645c16dcacdaa3f68ac","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d04dfd346aec28f9d51f6dd453759d3040c159c9b9041a0287eecdb7310d96d9","receipt.jsonSha256":"a1fa78d73a75fe703fb1cbeac5b35a16ddc235795219891d7e028e0e8f09c26b","normalization.jsonSha256":"2e493e2c7f4741d29428ad8769d68daf9d37a86a64b17eea548d298edea89613"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x1_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d6","originalRef":"l6","status":"route","source":"s4","target":"s22","type":"related_question","title":"Connect axion candidates with non-inflaton initial conditions and abundance","rationale":"Both statements support a connection between axion candidate and abundance questions and the non-inflaton initial-condition questions in s22. They do not identify a particular transferable method or establish containment of the full non-inflaton scope within dark-matter production.","qualification":"The connection concerns the axion abundance component. Curvaton, spectator and dark-energy targets remain distinct, and an axion present during inflation is not automatically the inflaton. A radial PQ inflaton and its angular axion retain different roles. Heuristic angular sampling does not establish a success probability, and inherited observational bounds remain historical.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l6","s4","s22"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d6","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The supplied connection concerns axion abundance and initial conditions, while s22 also contains curvaton, spectator and dark-energy targets. Neither original statement identifies a specific transferable method or full-scope containment. The related-question type preserves the useful connection and the distinction between an axion present during inflation and the inflaton.","refs":["l6","s4","s22"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l6","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l7":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l7","source":"q025-candidate-question:f39333b08ebf2cd4de3e3f4a","target":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","type":"method_for","title":"Use modulus and gravitino histories in candidate abundance studies","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: modulus and gravitino cosmology supplies production, dilution, decay and BBN conditions for the relevant candidate calculations.","qualification":"Dominance, spectra, branching fractions and mass ordering remain model-specific. Late decay, pre-freeze-out decay, stable gravitinos, thermal WIMPs and nonthermal neutralinos are distinct cases. Successful BBN timing alone does not establish gravitino, LSP or axion safety. A modulus may dilute rather than produce the surviving dark matter, and no complete parameter-space validation is supplied.","evidenceIds":["unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","unit:086443a70e473b97b9bf2b7cef696694c8b0c2e3ed9d6cce4c0e47b19fb12e22","unit:0987e132a53ff8e612486a3859842e861b76301b93ebb11d8a56e4f8e3022f43","unit:0ac5f33eee9e30f13d39d3e40376e84955b2b4250896a9c79dff2932fe52ddfe","unit:0e272eaeb369777716438692886a914336835f7b1943247e715a695370f36972","unit:0f564b72ccb9dd08acc40928a16c7107cbedce0b4d0f338d42736790503aea1a","unit:0ffa4883d2d1dbb4846bc0dddb5b72eafc6b959820a8da8a78a239830607e70c","unit:1d0d221f850057f7d3770dda05242e9041fdf6414d1d0d486ddc7269a519bbdb","unit:1e96331a613901b21e0941d90c6652e41bcf7c74ba6030bed0a42d0a478e2968","unit:1f8a143c34d15dddf88975dd80bcf893118c16c9b304ffe0e7c94185e5d9a5b6","unit:22567be11e9250ddabe2dba0a23b533b68abf8ea436c5d51f21cef613f5cc319","unit:245c1476e91cb35c093c370c48846f79a7f15c4f1cf5c57a488bb6aa08916b2f","unit:28bdd6f52cc30df281f1f4d836c85a0bf8578e9fd138fd286883b1f5c0a4f7c8","unit:2cfcc2ad59f436a184caf080c4d5f7db2f7b571ff75e8694880e0099242d0a98","unit:2d3d65b41648c0f939fba5152e588f2fb018d4e2274f758e39c6b9da23a72c57","unit:2d519cedab67a35e4e6b961e6c53a7b6712a382b0def484b733ad7e83ded608f","unit:328727ae562b449a9c1c36bf482eb6c2e8e0019f40018ad0b98fbba669217b28","unit:383d13703c71f3f25373a6ba0e1661f1e7e8cdeb7bd60a8065f24cc2200577f8","unit:3a27d6408cf96805cf6c280eb0c67b7715232bc784b79320000b8679b38de17a","unit:3a933b3a4fea0ed8ff28bb524e17b1e78260b146648f34c54a75342a3c3dadf0","unit:4388ba5c525b417e4a3e81463cabf723b16fda2447df04105d5d37c95b9f7fad","unit:4ed2ac936157aab2ac1031a731c7fd778188055e7092082eb69b67b68a11dc32","unit:56017bdcddd38ed7cba4066f0d2855ab32f64ec5330fc5104299358b29497dba","unit:605de0761b2358e37045e8df8819d2caf5b1d711f2cf269ba2307b74a697e465","unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","unit:62188642114ea75ef7b0d83ae1a11b515b9046a89f476a957ad3dafacdfd5826","unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","unit:67f94de05cb1ac512bcdd1cc70ba500a06f124b5b86dfc0e4bf48b4c139eb88e","unit:699d34cdd7756d1c072c7a517702ec67f86c041e11097f1ed8ca0fb4a3816e82","unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","unit:743a5ec4ec3327442a03957751dfa536fef453cc99c934ad167cc223432045a0","unit:7667a79b815f99de0d65c3e6792c3b433b65808c1385cdf7bf516fdcbf430f15","unit:7a836c7d5a9f02b5b0226b19a6d9a926a7507db1647810018d8563ccb41414ba","unit:7ebc51e5198ec3aeeefa5f45c261821b80198a81057463793194b8a1e6d3e133","unit:8283124d4672ec8e1ea6d1db07e36cf9cdfb9d3086b022af48550547e446bb0a","unit:886390bae4de13ca3fa9e42b4829aee4c1b2f9d3fa5107860df6115430055e16","unit:8e20c0326768a1f649bdfd14b44bd23e09092673cf36a5ad36fe7532ac92f1c6","unit:92a8fd8dbb27d5f8753b2e4259043bf1597de9feb26d3debd0c6c9806828f22e","unit:93e9fd67f1a42aeed6cf34020522ef2cda2998b28c161743ee91ef38aa89b137","unit:940f536d87ce2d1808f7b2604dffb29758784c347401d1ee5e8399cd9a2e551d","unit:96c6613c2dd137e812dbc4166a6e8ead41b9b0d2a2518722c8fa4f4de6056bbc","unit:9f867e2655c9ee718616d07641d24237d81c9f1ee269a6f9ce1169bb7a5ebaee","unit:a2984727dd94401649bcc01005538019d158f676a57d990613ae344d81618cbf","unit:a4c43d802142af3a9b10fcaaeb95f96273f81e146fb39d2fd6f9fadd7402f3f2","unit:a757dfd6e7766fa39431351f4621d054ffbea3c8fc2ad8463b5fe265bc329bf7","unit:ac36205563daf4202f4e9f37ea58874f0aeb0b9c3ee1f9e1a6d13a8779652faf","unit:bd18ebf05dedcfe1f8bdc3b2684907dfd28bad4c4f7460ece446bec2bccbe86d","unit:c406ba31ec49cbb23a6d7202a58582d1019db1e20a9e3531272a0bd7152d4e5c","unit:c6cd9586163c2c91d5f0751d8986e5f7f4d9a7b73e6aa797136ce0d141c2d3e0","unit:c78813fed1118a3a9647db73b578c6931e7f80a6e2ea08f4a434be88cb997525","unit:cf0f5d73068de72fc720bc98c5772e2ad522fbd1b1df061575a88c53cc930bb5","unit:d27ec210a934297e8291848f916d78ce168c3d6fa1baae330d0b45542e610256","unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","unit:dbd4ad422b115a1fe937440fef5d7995f208c895aa74b6cfebd6d79c22c0c2d6","unit:dbed9b6879afe9a03c27774aa14c0f3595a9a18d55979fecac48c074509831f2","unit:df4e43a49a8da815ba04100193a71993abd31ca89a823b3a15331e8e74205f14","unit:e16f67137d2df72baca21302278a1e8186aa7d5cfe7eb4248957ac4d1727291e","unit:f73648819770976e88055679fe32b0e5ec86b15c9aa45cd9fde1cbad23b16e87","unit:f8fd77bc87187ff0d5ff4caa8595f7c1b8df79ad86c5762d73083c83307369a9"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f39333b08ebf2cd4de3e3f4a","scopeContentSha256":"72903a14043a04810fb7f794bc8fdce92bef72e543ae0e7fc4ac3cff9acef5b4","localRef":"s35"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","scopeContentSha256":"392640e6a9b8a01652bc7d6dafda7769a164fa44c0efde3644a103be5f08f62a","localRef":"s4"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l7","originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:18","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l7","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:18","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:f39333b08ebf2cd4de3e3f4a","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l7","source":"s4","target":"s35","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Modulus and gravitino histories introduce production, dilution and BBN conditions with their own spectra and branching assumptions."],"challengeStatement":"Modulus and gravitino histories supply source-specific production, dilution and decay conditions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"0d479554dd0b39ca9daf07157c4f39675210457752a02cafa57ef8e2f52bfa7e","reply.jsonSha256":"b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd4722ba8dda705c880ad49294161d9061295ac5c5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9f3caf81e788c84ac0164350156eee9d2eb362baacf7ad9f05eaf093273877e8","receipt.jsonSha256":"1165f285c2c643f1a2270fabeb515a22bfcd8476412d71364f6c4b7cc0b1b52b","normalization.jsonSha256":"65d79380e46d8c2f1a63efb46f5d49883594612e5b03d1e4c4c4cbcabbee2346","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4a44ea5475d2801e35e1e86aad6ff99d9db2dce8307fdc2c9041f7beb32dd37a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"876fcf82b3760877d5adf0ad3cea3352e0f0e96e9be01cbf7c7325a0609e4a55","reply.jsonSha256":"a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d2e1d06273788a3258264e645c16dcacdaa3f68ac","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d04dfd346aec28f9d51f6dd453759d3040c159c9b9041a0287eecdb7310d96d9","receipt.jsonSha256":"a1fa78d73a75fe703fb1cbeac5b35a16ddc235795219891d7e028e0e8f09c26b","normalization.jsonSha256":"2e493e2c7f4741d29428ad8769d68daf9d37a86a64b17eea548d298edea89613"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f39333b08ebf2cd4de3e3f4a"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_8","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f39333b08ebf2cd4de3e3f4a"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d7","originalRef":"l7","status":"route","source":"s35","target":"s4","type":"method_for","title":"Use modulus and gravitino histories in candidate abundance studies","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: modulus and gravitino cosmology supplies production, dilution, decay and BBN conditions for the relevant candidate calculations.","qualification":"Dominance, spectra, branching fractions and mass ordering remain model-specific. Late decay, pre-freeze-out decay, stable gravitinos, thermal WIMPs and nonthermal neutralinos are distinct cases. Successful BBN timing alone does not establish gravitino, LSP or axion safety. A modulus may dilute rather than produce the surviving dark matter, and no complete parameter-space validation is supplied.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l7","s35","s4"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d7","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Modulus and gravitino histories supply the production, dilution and decay conditions used in the relevant candidate calculations, so reversing the method direction is justified. The record preserves the original BBN condition and source-specific spectra and branching assumptions, including alternatives in which the modulus dilutes rather than produces surviving dark matter.","refs":["l7","s35","s4"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l7","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l8":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l8","source":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","target":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","type":"premise_check","title":"Check construction-dependent restrictions on dark-matter proposals","rationale":"For candidate claims that invoke extra-dimensional constructions or quantum-gravity restrictions, s2 examines the relevant construction and conjecture assumptions.","qualification":"These checks are not premises of ordinary dark-matter proposals generally. Backgrounds, dimensional constructions, excursions and cutoff mechanisms remain distinct. Existential electric WGC and all-state Festina Lente conditions are not interchangeable. Undeveloped proposed connections remain undeveloped; this route supplies neither a demonstrated GSC implication, a gravitino abundance calculation nor a model-independent observational SDC test.","evidenceIds":["unit:04f12a626ec0a647658f6542fc7595e63d90376073441102f08ebefb6114ddc5","unit:086443a70e473b97b9bf2b7cef696694c8b0c2e3ed9d6cce4c0e47b19fb12e22","unit:0ac5f33eee9e30f13d39d3e40376e84955b2b4250896a9c79dff2932fe52ddfe","unit:1d816898cf90cb7d78b56b62f5a74c0b3743bec5859b6000ac8027c5b9234d36","unit:1e96331a613901b21e0941d90c6652e41bcf7c74ba6030bed0a42d0a478e2968","unit:2d3d65b41648c0f939fba5152e588f2fb018d4e2274f758e39c6b9da23a72c57","unit:383d13703c71f3f25373a6ba0e1661f1e7e8cdeb7bd60a8065f24cc2200577f8","unit:3a27d6408cf96805cf6c280eb0c67b7715232bc784b79320000b8679b38de17a","unit:4388ba5c525b417e4a3e81463cabf723b16fda2447df04105d5d37c95b9f7fad","unit:4b4367bc39fe44a4f016474d30a9868365ad74250d7f0813ab32703362baec63","unit:56017bdcddd38ed7cba4066f0d2855ab32f64ec5330fc5104299358b29497dba","unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","unit:699d34cdd7756d1c072c7a517702ec67f86c041e11097f1ed8ca0fb4a3816e82","unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","unit:743a5ec4ec3327442a03957751dfa536fef453cc99c934ad167cc223432045a0","unit:886390bae4de13ca3fa9e42b4829aee4c1b2f9d3fa5107860df6115430055e16","unit:8e20c0326768a1f649bdfd14b44bd23e09092673cf36a5ad36fe7532ac92f1c6","unit:96c6613c2dd137e812dbc4166a6e8ead41b9b0d2a2518722c8fa4f4de6056bbc","unit:9f867e2655c9ee718616d07641d24237d81c9f1ee269a6f9ce1169bb7a5ebaee","unit:a757dfd6e7766fa39431351f4621d054ffbea3c8fc2ad8463b5fe265bc329bf7","unit:b815dd160e57fb55e9ea389a7553227ab4c02b2e181a7da62dd08571b2dab756","unit:c78813fed1118a3a9647db73b578c6931e7f80a6e2ea08f4a434be88cb997525","unit:cf0f5d73068de72fc720bc98c5772e2ad522fbd1b1df061575a88c53cc930bb5","unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","unit:dbed9b6879afe9a03c27774aa14c0f3595a9a18d55979fecac48c074509831f2","unit:efe215eae3e6a5b18ac0855ffbc71ae0233844270b1106da9d28d75326277c54"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","scopeContentSha256":"392640e6a9b8a01652bc7d6dafda7769a164fa44c0efde3644a103be5f08f62a","localRef":"s4"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","scopeContentSha256":"6e30a08ea368b62247201ee1d26a6e7a88cbe3df8c016bdd1d778c372874f815","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l8","originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:21","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l8","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:link:21","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l8","source":"s4","target":"s2","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["Extra-dimensional and gravity-motivated restrictions apply only under their stated construction and conjecture assumptions."],"challengeStatement":"Extra-dimensional and gravitational restrictions apply only with their stated construction and conjecture assumptions.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"0d479554dd0b39ca9daf07157c4f39675210457752a02cafa57ef8e2f52bfa7e","reply.jsonSha256":"b7bcf14e1183763d76007edd4722ba8dda705c880ad49294161d9061295ac5c5","reply.raw.txtSha256":"9f3caf81e788c84ac0164350156eee9d2eb362baacf7ad9f05eaf093273877e8","receipt.jsonSha256":"1165f285c2c643f1a2270fabeb515a22bfcd8476412d71364f6c4b7cc0b1b52b","normalization.jsonSha256":"65d79380e46d8c2f1a63efb46f5d49883594612e5b03d1e4c4c4cbcabbee2346","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"4a44ea5475d2801e35e1e86aad6ff99d9db2dce8307fdc2c9041f7beb32dd37a"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"876fcf82b3760877d5adf0ad3cea3352e0f0e96e9be01cbf7c7325a0609e4a55","reply.jsonSha256":"a2b08185282aecafbfcf779d2e1d06273788a3258264e645c16dcacdaa3f68ac","reply.raw.txtSha256":"d04dfd346aec28f9d51f6dd453759d3040c159c9b9041a0287eecdb7310d96d9","receipt.jsonSha256":"a1fa78d73a75fe703fb1cbeac5b35a16ddc235795219891d7e028e0e8f09c26b","normalization.jsonSha256":"2e493e2c7f4741d29428ad8769d68daf9d37a86a64b17eea548d298edea89613"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d8","originalRef":"l8","status":"route","source":"s4","target":"s2","type":"premise_check","title":"Check construction-dependent restrictions on dark-matter proposals","rationale":"For candidate claims that invoke extra-dimensional constructions or quantum-gravity restrictions, s2 examines the relevant construction and conjecture assumptions.","qualification":"These checks are not premises of ordinary dark-matter proposals generally. Backgrounds, dimensional constructions, excursions and cutoff mechanisms remain distinct. Existential electric WGC and all-state Festina Lente conditions are not interchangeable. Undeveloped proposed connections remain undeveloped; this route supplies neither a demonstrated GSC implication, a gravitino abundance calculation nor a model-independent observational SDC test.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l8","s4","s2"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d8","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements support a construction-dependent applicability check for the relevant dark-matter proposals. The record correctly directs that check toward s2 and prevents its conjectures from becoming universal premises. Distinct dimensional settings, cutoff mechanisms and conjectural conditions remain separate, and undeveloped connections remain undeveloped.","refs":["l8","s4","s2"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l8","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l9":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l9","source":"q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f","target":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","type":"method_for","title":"Use U(1) construction and portal mechanisms as candidate ingredients","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: U(1) construction and portal mechanisms can supply model-building ingredients for specified dark-matter proposals.","qualification":"An allowed field or interaction establishes neither a dark-matter interpretation nor a relic abundance. Massless and massive, elementary and emergent, and weakly and strongly coupled constructions retain their own assumptions. Small observable charges need not imply small kinetic mixing; hypercharge normalization and hidden coupling remain separate parameters. No universal origin or mass–mixing relation follows.","evidenceIds":["unit:086443a70e473b97b9bf2b7cef696694c8b0c2e3ed9d6cce4c0e47b19fb12e22","unit:0ac5f33eee9e30f13d39d3e40376e84955b2b4250896a9c79dff2932fe52ddfe","unit:0b65bcfa464fe2d20aa71e786a049b7c79fdaec7f3d47f71843d7085eccad62f","unit:0f4e2c5077aea9b520248f2ee741566bd3de0877d077f707cd6b77fa1faa3131","unit:1e96331a613901b21e0941d90c6652e41bcf7c74ba6030bed0a42d0a478e2968","unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","unit:236a384191e529b7f8dee309efebc965170ae801e08f2c67dc0c66cab01cb987","unit:2d3d65b41648c0f939fba5152e588f2fb018d4e2274f758e39c6b9da23a72c57","unit:3011fc02b4ed9de6dcd1e6f47d0c38edbdf12375113e9b51b9c9759683c2b920","unit:383d13703c71f3f25373a6ba0e1661f1e7e8cdeb7bd60a8065f24cc2200577f8","unit:3a27d6408cf96805cf6c280eb0c67b7715232bc784b79320000b8679b38de17a","unit:3c22aedd53e3e67d4d4acdd11459b1e6d78d097381622ebb6aa5bedd9e32a3f3","unit:4388ba5c525b417e4a3e81463cabf723b16fda2447df04105d5d37c95b9f7fad","unit:56017bdcddd38ed7cba4066f0d2855ab32f64ec5330fc5104299358b29497dba","unit:59c6d382871013025851763b99a7220b712303f41583f17746c9f62e172b1a79","unit:60fe1db5a85517f06ac59e252e08b473ad1118bfd71d40961a52ae2bd09e2bd9","unit:642c1af4db58b4b4d6b31ed6d287159db06ff5d9f53a5d502b801d4d0334401e","unit:699d34cdd7756d1c072c7a517702ec67f86c041e11097f1ed8ca0fb4a3816e82","unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","unit:6ef22c9194ea552e97dc14eeac81ec0c5091b7e99aec4a19eda5b74e28a8a93f","unit:743a5ec4ec3327442a03957751dfa536fef453cc99c934ad167cc223432045a0","unit:7b5dde50f1386f1487fd26ba67e585433fd51a8e82d6bb9e15abda97670b5b2d","unit:886390bae4de13ca3fa9e42b4829aee4c1b2f9d3fa5107860df6115430055e16","unit:8e20c0326768a1f649bdfd14b44bd23e09092673cf36a5ad36fe7532ac92f1c6","unit:96c6613c2dd137e812dbc4166a6e8ead41b9b0d2a2518722c8fa4f4de6056bbc","unit:9f867e2655c9ee718616d07641d24237d81c9f1ee269a6f9ce1169bb7a5ebaee","unit:a757dfd6e7766fa39431351f4621d054ffbea3c8fc2ad8463b5fe265bc329bf7","unit:b6f59ba7e7bc46f5552b8741f188a8c1fb7803d445c34db63465d2208faacc04","unit:c78813fed1118a3a9647db73b578c6931e7f80a6e2ea08f4a434be88cb997525","unit:c84b534b6b9b6ebd186f5c574f962df41f2469f96b6504228baaa06a767be0ec","unit:c989facc3d172c3d0db0350f1e933d0f5a5c00337848e0e0e502badb85f468ff","unit:cf0f5d73068de72fc720bc98c5772e2ad522fbd1b1df061575a88c53cc930bb5","unit:d535cf5eaea11df101f10bea19b850ba21cc27001c6cf47ffc844210e5c2968f","unit:d569dc40d9d1c9f688c060eef1cb93ec981ed2cd77f3b3d185574c1808516ccf","unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","unit:dbed9b6879afe9a03c27774aa14c0f3595a9a18d55979fecac48c074509831f2","unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","unit:fd96745cb83a6a50d8656e0b21ea0d9bc11b8aff49f3a7297c7232e33f02c04f"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f","scopeContentSha256":"e030c5f828eed826766a5a0e2db4b052b6a43e19b5c358607b0f436632bff301","localRef":"s29"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","scopeContentSha256":"392640e6a9b8a01652bc7d6dafda7769a164fa44c0efde3644a103be5f08f62a","localRef":"s4"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l9","originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:14","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l9","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:14","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l9","source":"s4","target":"s29","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["U(1) construction and portal mechanisms can supply model ingredients; they do not automatically establish a dark-matter abundance or interpretation."],"challengeStatement":"U(1) construction and portal mechanisms supply possible model ingredients without establishing relic abundance.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4f88767e140ec911d98ed96cf88d5c80635315d2851f3cd9852ded3be8a0a32d","reply.jsonSha256":"5cae2d296c2312029b6035542eff38fa4f55426587c75161c4fc2c3daf3bbda0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c6c90479f85a502c579e840a4b793e77ec8cb627f84afcf18093558075f3ef53","receipt.jsonSha256":"6ebcdc203daebaca976bd1b819b42105b45f28dbd69c90e3c542386ec01b51ba","normalization.jsonSha256":"ad796afb2ffc10d1f869f0722aff8b560f1e6d4e9437973b922c4a52844fb6e4","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a50a2e796b56f03366769c25357d3bc10a23c6541736b8db4df955ac10e4c3b3"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"96dd7cead2cd66e8dd66af6c8b3e11240e64deb848d05deb23d3178ac1955128","reply.jsonSha256":"a577a7095f0e8b3b0adb6a918afc65ecfde89d0ca82623d9f65ee7caefac275e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f56614a666546960c8d32938e3d0d5e73f0227385870adf8071a35d79b0f57b6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4f7641c188a2eb2a2273ac4156762fc7ee454d1cfee615c39072949beddc3ef4","normalization.jsonSha256":"daa65bd672d3ee84971d3c6c9a70438709e8b57ad333470542b2f6494348fab2"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"},{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3807e422776615534282c7e2"},{"ref":"x1_0","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:d62066e89cef60e70b2fd30f"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d9","originalRef":"l9","status":"route","source":"s29","target":"s4","type":"method_for","title":"Use U(1) construction and portal mechanisms as candidate ingredients","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: U(1) construction and portal mechanisms can supply model-building ingredients for specified dark-matter proposals.","qualification":"An allowed field or interaction establishes neither a dark-matter interpretation nor a relic abundance. Massless and massive, elementary and emergent, and weakly and strongly coupled constructions retain their own assumptions. Small observable charges need not imply small kinetic mixing; hypercharge normalization and hidden coupling remain separate parameters. No universal origin or mass–mixing relation follows.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l9","s29","s4"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d9","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The original reasoning explicitly identifies U(1) construction and portal mechanisms as possible model-building ingredients. That supports the reversed method direction toward candidate construction. The qualification preserves the absence of an automatic dark-matter interpretation or abundance prediction and the source-specific distinctions among charges, mixing and couplings.","refs":["l9","s29","s4"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l9","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l10":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l10","source":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad","target":"q025-candidate-question:90b0af90acc9cce9d8b909ca","type":"premise_check","title":"Check BBN and neutrino-thermalization consistency of specified histories","rationale":"Both original statements describe BBN and unstable-relic analyses as constraints on specified reheating histories. This supports a conditional consistency check from the history question to s20.","qualification":"The check concerns histories containing the relevant late reheating or unstable populations. Upper reheating bounds from relic overproduction remain distinct from lower bounds on late restoration of radiation domination. Radiative, hadronic and direct-neutrino channels, stable and unstable gravitinos, and incomplete neutrino thermalization require their separate treatments. Numerical bounds retain their calculation, dataset and prior assumptions.","evidenceIds":["unit:02835cfa5db848997cf0e3c22f50f39ac94358b530639d593a0548fb382cb96d","unit:0618df9ef5270ad464fe1f01dd08ec7efd7d2d4340dd4f9ce65b160fb9b0ab17","unit:1a8568e9044c2488d4831b94b550dc431f436dd9c4df137b19b1e3c2d40e3f63","unit:1f52516c69551f2499ef77f96c54e4faae1f76d9269feb68551e7c449a5f60b0","unit:23eb0d42913853b4e0b073283acdbcd14d0332fedc6ae62e501806b6d6c13b4c","unit:34c75f8ea355d81507aba068500cd26feb89d0e4642971164d21d9b4551fdfd5","unit:445345e93a3ef6cbc1c9b1829cfd7ac8458ba81e309410ba379da6198af25151","unit:6490b9e42afca4b9d24fb7bb389c080e29d2b83a2a233371bf443f3e3bcfae7c","unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","unit:85dbdc1c905fd4cc14c1060102df4e9ca557976fbdc069e9f588e83162c03b96","unit:8e9e312f12fae1519b5dcbd7dec805b41fdf1f0d3442a9673093b49c0ad3df36","unit:9a58bbb2e0d7da3e10998875a6dfee59040d5ddf4d3845653b6354a2fbbe8f6a","unit:9ebc2cf7d7d878ac80b5084b5d5d450419cc253129cf1bc9dab73864be840032","unit:a774271268e9e40cd895b4062fae8e32f6418d55bebe369af87270ba8bc9c09f","unit:ba6b6174155db38b41214e5c3f99fa2493ce25ff20621535f6f9511c17f5c1d9","unit:ca873de0fdebf135f4071fd942269c1fb771f209effde80589c3f9b06af4677e","unit:cdb3c02f0a1f7c34f2b4010837319fb660002c53828f20c50788f60793573dd8","unit:cec053fff92732be4f03a2a8f423d75850c602a10c959a3319f2add0f4b67cc6","unit:d4dc631ea173581e0aa61a3cb4b1e2f3347eea5850a7e638011acb3a2f33d734","unit:d746397051946e3ea1aad18713ce16be7e7baa9f21b9fb53aeaa0c99b37027a5","unit:d8a0e02ebe7842c9f87c037afcb01c9d1450c39d15245a57af63b09db34d4d5a","unit:da249dfb31cb6293a2683e2c9a1ea3f6f7029ad13d668621824d0bac7eaa0a9c","unit:f7a47ff010c9f0364b1c05ab1c74916b4431e0c5b727f726f598bcd495eb84b5"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad","scopeContentSha256":"5d126a280165780fdf8dfcdfd076bb2e8ffad8bba713458132c3104f44b8d846","localRef":"s31"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:90b0af90acc9cce9d8b909ca","scopeContentSha256":"42e7acc535289c564edf43cde02c3b88944fd6d016ab7af7addc1312524e4e20","localRef":"s20"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l10","originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:17","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l10","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:17","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:90b0af90acc9cce9d8b909ca","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l10","source":"s31","target":"s20","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["BBN and unstable-relic analyses test specified reheating histories, keeping upper and lower bounds and their different channels separate."],"challengeStatement":"BBN and unstable relics constrain specified histories, with upper and lower reheating bounds and decay channels kept distinct.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4f88767e140ec911d98ed96cf88d5c80635315d2851f3cd9852ded3be8a0a32d","reply.jsonSha256":"5cae2d296c2312029b6035542eff38fa4f55426587c75161c4fc2c3daf3bbda0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c6c90479f85a502c579e840a4b793e77ec8cb627f84afcf18093558075f3ef53","receipt.jsonSha256":"6ebcdc203daebaca976bd1b819b42105b45f28dbd69c90e3c542386ec01b51ba","normalization.jsonSha256":"ad796afb2ffc10d1f869f0722aff8b560f1e6d4e9437973b922c4a52844fb6e4","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a50a2e796b56f03366769c25357d3bc10a23c6541736b8db4df955ac10e4c3b3"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"96dd7cead2cd66e8dd66af6c8b3e11240e64deb848d05deb23d3178ac1955128","reply.jsonSha256":"a577a7095f0e8b3b0adb6a918afc65ecfde89d0ca82623d9f65ee7caefac275e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f56614a666546960c8d32938e3d0d5e73f0227385870adf8071a35d79b0f57b6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4f7641c188a2eb2a2273ac4156762fc7ee454d1cfee615c39072949beddc3ef4","normalization.jsonSha256":"daa65bd672d3ee84971d3c6c9a70438709e8b57ad333470542b2f6494348fab2"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad"},{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:90b0af90acc9cce9d8b909ca"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad"},{"ref":"x2_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:90b0af90acc9cce9d8b909ca"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d10","originalRef":"l10","status":"route","source":"s31","target":"s20","type":"premise_check","title":"Check BBN and neutrino-thermalization consistency of specified histories","rationale":"Both original statements describe BBN and unstable-relic analyses as constraints on specified reheating histories. This supports a conditional consistency check from the history question to s20.","qualification":"The check concerns histories containing the relevant late reheating or unstable populations. Upper reheating bounds from relic overproduction remain distinct from lower bounds on late restoration of radiation domination. Radiative, hadronic and direct-neutrino channels, stable and unstable gravitinos, and incomplete neutrino thermalization require their separate treatments. Numerical bounds retain their calculation, dataset and prior assumptions.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l10","s31","s20"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d10","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements describe BBN and unstable-relic analyses as tests of specified histories. A premise check from those histories to their cosmological consistency conditions is supported. The record limits applicability to relevant populations and retains upper versus lower reheating bounds, channel distinctions and incomplete neutrino thermalization.","refs":["l10","s31","s20"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l10","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l11":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l11","source":"q025-candidate-question:11bfeda5ad2753a4e283af62","target":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad","type":"application_of","title":"Trace asymmetry generation to its reheating and decay history","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the relevant baryogenesis and cogenesis models apply specified thermal, reheating and decay histories to asymmetry generation.","qualification":"A baryon-asymmetry target need not be a dark-matter production target, and asymmetry generation is distinct from symmetric relic production. Sphaleron conversion and direct cogenesis are different mechanisms. Fundamental-vertex baryon conservation belongs to the supplied modulus model, while reheating requirements and dark-sector temperatures remain model-specific. The histories in s31 are alternatives, not common premises of every asymmetry model.","evidenceIds":["unit:1a8568e9044c2488d4831b94b550dc431f436dd9c4df137b19b1e3c2d40e3f63","unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","unit:7fd30c9ed5b13801c820c92342facea32b50a160987f2269c2fa40f4b2a8e8c3","unit:85dbdc1c905fd4cc14c1060102df4e9ca557976fbdc069e9f588e83162c03b96","unit:8e9e312f12fae1519b5dcbd7dec805b41fdf1f0d3442a9673093b49c0ad3df36","unit:98fd5cfe630bf51a0cefa6f3ed48999bba91f3e27e1884cc9f8398cb2e0db02f","unit:9a58bbb2e0d7da3e10998875a6dfee59040d5ddf4d3845653b6354a2fbbe8f6a","unit:9ebc2cf7d7d878ac80b5084b5d5d450419cc253129cf1bc9dab73864be840032","unit:a774271268e9e40cd895b4062fae8e32f6418d55bebe369af87270ba8bc9c09f","unit:ba6b6174155db38b41214e5c3f99fa2493ce25ff20621535f6f9511c17f5c1d9","unit:ca873de0fdebf135f4071fd942269c1fb771f209effde80589c3f9b06af4677e","unit:cad75bb6b04b67650e44ec4eb63215bcd874e4e6d9798d3b656a50d66c8b6127","unit:cdb3c02f0a1f7c34f2b4010837319fb660002c53828f20c50788f60793573dd8","unit:cec053fff92732be4f03a2a8f423d75850c602a10c959a3319f2add0f4b67cc6","unit:d746397051946e3ea1aad18713ce16be7e7baa9f21b9fb53aeaa0c99b37027a5","unit:d8a0e02ebe7842c9f87c037afcb01c9d1450c39d15245a57af63b09db34d4d5a","unit:da249dfb31cb6293a2683e2c9a1ea3f6f7029ad13d668621824d0bac7eaa0a9c"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:11bfeda5ad2753a4e283af62","scopeContentSha256":"25a958db163169598f00d01d2d887ba5ad847a8f88e806921aef8aca0bce9ac8","localRef":"s1"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad","scopeContentSha256":"5d126a280165780fdf8dfcdfd076bb2e8ffad8bba713458132c3104f44b8d846","localRef":"s31"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l11","originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:18","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l11","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:18","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:11bfeda5ad2753a4e283af62","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l11","source":"s31","target":"s1","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Thermal histories enter baryogenesis and cogenesis models, but a baryon-asymmetry target need not be a dark-matter production question."],"challengeStatement":"Reheating histories enter baryogenesis and cogenesis, whose asymmetry targets are separate from symmetric relic production.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4f88767e140ec911d98ed96cf88d5c80635315d2851f3cd9852ded3be8a0a32d","reply.jsonSha256":"5cae2d296c2312029b6035542eff38fa4f55426587c75161c4fc2c3daf3bbda0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c6c90479f85a502c579e840a4b793e77ec8cb627f84afcf18093558075f3ef53","receipt.jsonSha256":"6ebcdc203daebaca976bd1b819b42105b45f28dbd69c90e3c542386ec01b51ba","normalization.jsonSha256":"ad796afb2ffc10d1f869f0722aff8b560f1e6d4e9437973b922c4a52844fb6e4","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a50a2e796b56f03366769c25357d3bc10a23c6541736b8db4df955ac10e4c3b3"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"96dd7cead2cd66e8dd66af6c8b3e11240e64deb848d05deb23d3178ac1955128","reply.jsonSha256":"a577a7095f0e8b3b0adb6a918afc65ecfde89d0ca82623d9f65ee7caefac275e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f56614a666546960c8d32938e3d0d5e73f0227385870adf8071a35d79b0f57b6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4f7641c188a2eb2a2273ac4156762fc7ee454d1cfee615c39072949beddc3ef4","normalization.jsonSha256":"daa65bd672d3ee84971d3c6c9a70438709e8b57ad333470542b2f6494348fab2"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad"},{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:11bfeda5ad2753a4e283af62"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x2_1","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:df13652e4b166b843c904fad"},{"ref":"x2_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:11bfeda5ad2753a4e283af62"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d11","originalRef":"l11","status":"route","source":"s1","target":"s31","type":"application_of","title":"Trace asymmetry generation to its reheating and decay history","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the relevant baryogenesis and cogenesis models apply specified thermal, reheating and decay histories to asymmetry generation.","qualification":"A baryon-asymmetry target need not be a dark-matter production target, and asymmetry generation is distinct from symmetric relic production. Sphaleron conversion and direct cogenesis are different mechanisms. Fundamental-vertex baryon conservation belongs to the supplied modulus model, while reheating requirements and dark-sector temperatures remain model-specific. The histories in s31 are alternatives, not common premises of every asymmetry model.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l11","s1","s31"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d11","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The relevant asymmetry-generation models apply specified thermal, reheating and decay histories, supporting the reversed application direction. The qualification combines both original distinctions: a baryon-asymmetry target need not produce dark matter, and asymmetric generation is separate from symmetric relic production. Model-specific conservation and temperature assumptions are retained.","refs":["l11","s1","s31"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l11","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l12":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l12","source":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","target":"q025-candidate-question:bdfb6100643885f4cae8dc2f","type":"premise_check","title":"Check contested EFT matching behind the Dark Dimension scaling","rationale":"For the component of s2 relying on the proposed vacuum-energy relation, s23 examines its disputed EFT matching. Both original statements explicitly leave the opposing positions unresolved.","qualification":"The relation Λcc ∼ mKK⁴ is the proposition under test, not an established premise of every extra-dimensional model. Preserve four- versus five-dimensional matching, radius dependence, UV-sensitive terms and the distinction between KK-scale and species-scale cutoffs. The explicit Scherk–Schwarz example uses a compact circle with a qualified circle/orbifold choice. The supplied context does not settle the dispute.","evidenceIds":["unit:04f12a626ec0a647658f6542fc7595e63d90376073441102f08ebefb6114ddc5","unit:086443a70e473b97b9bf2b7cef696694c8b0c2e3ed9d6cce4c0e47b19fb12e22","unit:1d816898cf90cb7d78b56b62f5a74c0b3743bec5859b6000ac8027c5b9234d36","unit:22463270ddbc42a8a786821c81a569a3926481fb3b7ad73092b1bc863b2db5f0","unit:3a27d6408cf96805cf6c280eb0c67b7715232bc784b79320000b8679b38de17a","unit:4b4367bc39fe44a4f016474d30a9868365ad74250d7f0813ab32703362baec63","unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","unit:6ad52e8398308fc98ca01b366cd01e5025d0579ba5a58d45cc7788bd81aeac12","unit:743a5ec4ec3327442a03957751dfa536fef453cc99c934ad167cc223432045a0","unit:b815dd160e57fb55e9ea389a7553227ab4c02b2e181a7da62dd08571b2dab756","unit:c78813fed1118a3a9647db73b578c6931e7f80a6e2ea08f4a434be88cb997525","unit:dbed9b6879afe9a03c27774aa14c0f3595a9a18d55979fecac48c074509831f2","unit:efe215eae3e6a5b18ac0855ffbc71ae0233844270b1106da9d28d75326277c54"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","scopeContentSha256":"6e30a08ea368b62247201ee1d26a6e7a88cbe3df8c016bdd1d778c372874f815","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bdfb6100643885f4cae8dc2f","scopeContentSha256":"d773e3fd88696e62237b80e8d99110b9a2cdcb6d53823b26b1038f7720d7f79f","localRef":"s23"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l12","originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:41","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l12","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:41","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:bdfb6100643885f4cae8dc2f","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l12","source":"s2","target":"s23","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["Contested vacuum-energy matching tests a proposed Dark Dimension relation; the supplied opposing positions remain unresolved."],"challengeStatement":"Contested EFT matching examines a proposed vacuum-energy relation; the supplied opposing positions remain unresolved.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4f88767e140ec911d98ed96cf88d5c80635315d2851f3cd9852ded3be8a0a32d","reply.jsonSha256":"5cae2d296c2312029b6035542eff38fa4f55426587c75161c4fc2c3daf3bbda0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c6c90479f85a502c579e840a4b793e77ec8cb627f84afcf18093558075f3ef53","receipt.jsonSha256":"6ebcdc203daebaca976bd1b819b42105b45f28dbd69c90e3c542386ec01b51ba","normalization.jsonSha256":"ad796afb2ffc10d1f869f0722aff8b560f1e6d4e9437973b922c4a52844fb6e4","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a50a2e796b56f03366769c25357d3bc10a23c6541736b8db4df955ac10e4c3b3"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"96dd7cead2cd66e8dd66af6c8b3e11240e64deb848d05deb23d3178ac1955128","reply.jsonSha256":"a577a7095f0e8b3b0adb6a918afc65ecfde89d0ca82623d9f65ee7caefac275e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f56614a666546960c8d32938e3d0d5e73f0227385870adf8071a35d79b0f57b6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4f7641c188a2eb2a2273ac4156762fc7ee454d1cfee615c39072949beddc3ef4","normalization.jsonSha256":"daa65bd672d3ee84971d3c6c9a70438709e8b57ad333470542b2f6494348fab2"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"},{"ref":"x4_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bdfb6100643885f4cae8dc2f"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"},{"ref":"x4_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:bdfb6100643885f4cae8dc2f"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d12","originalRef":"l12","status":"route","source":"s2","target":"s23","type":"premise_check","title":"Check contested EFT matching behind the Dark Dimension scaling","rationale":"For the component of s2 relying on the proposed vacuum-energy relation, s23 examines its disputed EFT matching. Both original statements explicitly leave the opposing positions unresolved.","qualification":"The relation Λcc ∼ mKK⁴ is the proposition under test, not an established premise of every extra-dimensional model. Preserve four- versus five-dimensional matching, radius dependence, UV-sensitive terms and the distinction between KK-scale and species-scale cutoffs. The explicit Scherk–Schwarz example uses a compact circle with a qualified circle/orbifold choice. The supplied context does not settle the dispute.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l12","s2","s23"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d12","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The matching dispute checks a proposed relation used by the relevant Dark Dimension component of s2. The premise-check direction is correct and expressly conditional. Both original statements leave the opposing positions unresolved, and the record preserves cutoff, dimensional, radius and UV-sensitivity distinctions without resolving the dispute.","refs":["l12","s2","s23"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l12","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l13":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l13","source":"q025-candidate-question:fc582eff749d1936943465cf","target":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","type":"application_of","title":"Apply extra-dimensional KK constructions to stellar production and cooling","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: stellar KK production and cooling are applied tests of the specified extra-dimensional construction component of s2.","qualification":"Different numbers of dimensions and compactification settings remain distinct; this is not a test of every quantum-gravity hypothesis. Production and cooling constraints are separate from bounds on later Standard Model decay products. Weakening the latter requires dominant intra-tower decays, which are not assumed in every geometry. Pion properties and abundance remain uncertain, white-dwarf constraints are unfinished, and calculated rates or numerical limits are not verified here.","evidenceIds":["unit:04f12a626ec0a647658f6542fc7595e63d90376073441102f08ebefb6114ddc5","unit:086443a70e473b97b9bf2b7cef696694c8b0c2e3ed9d6cce4c0e47b19fb12e22","unit:1d816898cf90cb7d78b56b62f5a74c0b3743bec5859b6000ac8027c5b9234d36","unit:3a27d6408cf96805cf6c280eb0c67b7715232bc784b79320000b8679b38de17a","unit:4b4367bc39fe44a4f016474d30a9868365ad74250d7f0813ab32703362baec63","unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","unit:743a5ec4ec3327442a03957751dfa536fef453cc99c934ad167cc223432045a0","unit:b815dd160e57fb55e9ea389a7553227ab4c02b2e181a7da62dd08571b2dab756","unit:bd8c5b9a8b57126b3ca4cd9f8f106d4a591051d19ace30fd62d33141efb25f60","unit:c78813fed1118a3a9647db73b578c6931e7f80a6e2ea08f4a434be88cb997525","unit:dbed9b6879afe9a03c27774aa14c0f3595a9a18d55979fecac48c074509831f2","unit:efe215eae3e6a5b18ac0855ffbc71ae0233844270b1106da9d28d75326277c54"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fc582eff749d1936943465cf","scopeContentSha256":"e7d5b35706d4ac9bbb82ba7cadc149841164baaacfa955a62a989b5d27c8a125","localRef":"s36"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","scopeContentSha256":"6e30a08ea368b62247201ee1d26a6e7a88cbe3df8c016bdd1d778c372874f815","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l13","originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:42","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l13","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:42","originalNativeType":"application","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:fc582eff749d1936943465cf","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l13","source":"s2","target":"s36","nativeType":"application","proposalStatements":["Stellar KK production and cooling test specified extra-dimensional settings, with production and later visible decay treated separately."],"challengeStatement":"Stellar KK production and cooling test specified extra-dimensional settings, separately from subsequent visible decays.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4f88767e140ec911d98ed96cf88d5c80635315d2851f3cd9852ded3be8a0a32d","reply.jsonSha256":"5cae2d296c2312029b6035542eff38fa4f55426587c75161c4fc2c3daf3bbda0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c6c90479f85a502c579e840a4b793e77ec8cb627f84afcf18093558075f3ef53","receipt.jsonSha256":"6ebcdc203daebaca976bd1b819b42105b45f28dbd69c90e3c542386ec01b51ba","normalization.jsonSha256":"ad796afb2ffc10d1f869f0722aff8b560f1e6d4e9437973b922c4a52844fb6e4","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a50a2e796b56f03366769c25357d3bc10a23c6541736b8db4df955ac10e4c3b3"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"96dd7cead2cd66e8dd66af6c8b3e11240e64deb848d05deb23d3178ac1955128","reply.jsonSha256":"a577a7095f0e8b3b0adb6a918afc65ecfde89d0ca82623d9f65ee7caefac275e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f56614a666546960c8d32938e3d0d5e73f0227385870adf8071a35d79b0f57b6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4f7641c188a2eb2a2273ac4156762fc7ee454d1cfee615c39072949beddc3ef4","normalization.jsonSha256":"daa65bd672d3ee84971d3c6c9a70438709e8b57ad333470542b2f6494348fab2"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"},{"ref":"x4_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fc582eff749d1936943465cf"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"},{"ref":"x4_4","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:fc582eff749d1936943465cf"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d13","originalRef":"l13","status":"route","source":"s36","target":"s2","type":"application_of","title":"Apply extra-dimensional KK constructions to stellar production and cooling","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: stellar KK production and cooling are applied tests of the specified extra-dimensional construction component of s2.","qualification":"Different numbers of dimensions and compactification settings remain distinct; this is not a test of every quantum-gravity hypothesis. Production and cooling constraints are separate from bounds on later Standard Model decay products. Weakening the latter requires dominant intra-tower decays, which are not assumed in every geometry. Pion properties and abundance remain uncertain, white-dwarf constraints are unfinished, and calculated rates or numerical limits are not verified here.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l13","s36","s2"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d13","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Stellar KK production and cooling are applied tests of the specified extra-dimensional construction component, supporting s36 → s2 as application_of. The record retains both statements' separation of production and cooling from subsequent visible decays, together with dimensional restrictions, uncertain pion properties and the conditional intra-tower dominance requirement.","refs":["l13","s36","s2"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l13","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l14":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l14","source":"q025-candidate-question:850c14ec5e9355cc9d819037","target":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","type":"method_for","title":"Use microscopic interaction and production tools in specified constructions","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the microscopic interaction and production formalisms supply adjacent methodological tools for the relevant dark-sector calculations in s2.","qualification":"Applicability is limited to the particular interaction or production question and its stated framework. Portal boundary conditions, spin descriptions, tree-level or one-loop interactions, and thermal quantum processes retain separate assumptions. These tools supply neither a common ultraviolet completion nor an automatic relic abundance, and they do not establish the applicability of every gravitational conjecture. The framework calculations are description-supported only.","evidenceIds":["unit:039d64e67df4cdc89af69f2743b3070e7701bd7be146bf3cfc336d171dadb3ea","unit:04f12a626ec0a647658f6542fc7595e63d90376073441102f08ebefb6114ddc5","unit:05b3901f04726cf4f598a0b79c98d2ab8b8f74a22b5cbc55b981d790061afff9","unit:086443a70e473b97b9bf2b7cef696694c8b0c2e3ed9d6cce4c0e47b19fb12e22","unit:1c28587cc64367af38923ed63d36d42ff909d5f1b6bab6ffc7562989eb12e281","unit:1d816898cf90cb7d78b56b62f5a74c0b3743bec5859b6000ac8027c5b9234d36","unit:1f1c9499cb8fca49755e755c72b45106666107da9814d659eca83aca2d15bd95","unit:3a27d6408cf96805cf6c280eb0c67b7715232bc784b79320000b8679b38de17a","unit:4b4367bc39fe44a4f016474d30a9868365ad74250d7f0813ab32703362baec63","unit:6aced4b81a75479311bdf8c7e0e15ecb8f129a436338b4ebc19d6b73156ea115","unit:6bbfdb4cc6926928970627853c5ffe16e66ed2148d94cc73311847cf7ea59a0e","unit:743a5ec4ec3327442a03957751dfa536fef453cc99c934ad167cc223432045a0","unit:b815dd160e57fb55e9ea389a7553227ab4c02b2e181a7da62dd08571b2dab756","unit:be2382bc84048947ed521adbee1170bbcde820c3e93b5dda53c0c23e497c46ef","unit:c78813fed1118a3a9647db73b578c6931e7f80a6e2ea08f4a434be88cb997525","unit:dbed9b6879afe9a03c27774aa14c0f3595a9a18d55979fecac48c074509831f2","unit:de10ded146c06a240463a8fdccf047c3e85f01ca6c7821da8692a94661ccb1a7","unit:ede61c62dc25c7f33b7ac2c9eb5ad97a073b189cf84455db1b95c8b301e61dd3","unit:efe215eae3e6a5b18ac0855ffbc71ae0233844270b1106da9d28d75326277c54"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:850c14ec5e9355cc9d819037","scopeContentSha256":"0c13efc1c984b416b5a190141e46445132dd16e5a47edf6c2cd112a79c285452","localRef":"s17"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","scopeContentSha256":"6e30a08ea368b62247201ee1d26a6e7a88cbe3df8c016bdd1d778c372874f815","localRef":"s2"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l14","originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:43","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l14","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:43","originalNativeType":"method","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:850c14ec5e9355cc9d819037","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l14","source":"s2","target":"s17","nativeType":"method","proposalStatements":["Microscopic interaction and production formalisms provide adjacent tools without supplying a common ultraviolet completion or automatic relic prediction."],"challengeStatement":"Microscopic interaction and production formalisms supply adjacent tools without a common ultraviolet completion or automatic abundance prediction.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4f88767e140ec911d98ed96cf88d5c80635315d2851f3cd9852ded3be8a0a32d","reply.jsonSha256":"5cae2d296c2312029b6035542eff38fa4f55426587c75161c4fc2c3daf3bbda0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c6c90479f85a502c579e840a4b793e77ec8cb627f84afcf18093558075f3ef53","receipt.jsonSha256":"6ebcdc203daebaca976bd1b819b42105b45f28dbd69c90e3c542386ec01b51ba","normalization.jsonSha256":"ad796afb2ffc10d1f869f0722aff8b560f1e6d4e9437973b922c4a52844fb6e4","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a50a2e796b56f03366769c25357d3bc10a23c6541736b8db4df955ac10e4c3b3"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"96dd7cead2cd66e8dd66af6c8b3e11240e64deb848d05deb23d3178ac1955128","reply.jsonSha256":"a577a7095f0e8b3b0adb6a918afc65ecfde89d0ca82623d9f65ee7caefac275e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f56614a666546960c8d32938e3d0d5e73f0227385870adf8071a35d79b0f57b6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4f7641c188a2eb2a2273ac4156762fc7ee454d1cfee615c39072949beddc3ef4","normalization.jsonSha256":"daa65bd672d3ee84971d3c6c9a70438709e8b57ad333470542b2f6494348fab2"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"},{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:850c14ec5e9355cc9d819037"}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x0_6","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:190bdf4415c78268d594ff95"},{"ref":"x2_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:850c14ec5e9355cc9d819037"}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d14","originalRef":"l14","status":"route","source":"s17","target":"s2","type":"method_for","title":"Use microscopic interaction and production tools in specified constructions","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the microscopic interaction and production formalisms supply adjacent methodological tools for the relevant dark-sector calculations in s2.","qualification":"Applicability is limited to the particular interaction or production question and its stated framework. Portal boundary conditions, spin descriptions, tree-level or one-loop interactions, and thermal quantum processes retain separate assumptions. These tools supply neither a common ultraviolet completion nor an automatic relic abundance, and they do not establish the applicability of every gravitational conjecture. The framework calculations are description-supported only.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l14","s17","s2"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d14","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify microscopic interaction and production formalisms as adjacent tools. The reversed method direction is supported for the specified calculations, without claiming applicability to every component of s2. The record retains separate framework and perturbative assumptions and supplies neither a common ultraviolet completion nor an automatic abundance prediction.","refs":["l14","s17","s2"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l14","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l16":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l16","source":"q025-candidate-question:62dacb9af0517b2a3ba9ed97","target":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","type":"premise_check","title":"Check the fast-cascade premise against the reported KK threshold law","rationale":"The KK survival and cascade component of s13 depends on an assumed decay history that the threshold analysis tests. Both statements also retain the separate freeze-in constraint on populations that need not constitute dark matter.","qualification":"This check does not apply to the charged-field or near-extremal-PBH survival mechanisms. The reported threshold result retains its five-dimensional scalar–gravity, field/brane and comparable-daughter near-threshold assumptions. A partial decay law does not determine a summed cascade history. Freeze-in limits retain their production and reheating assumptions, and flat-dimension conclusions do not exclude every warped model.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","unit:6df39bcb6b52192e783e45e332d170619d74452ddfa32f036f52c1457ca2c8e1","unit:82d977a4365b8f5f3f0ee2447b7369235538e893bf9f106c1abd635ed12cecd5","unit:bd8c5b9a8b57126b3ca4cd9f8f106d4a591051d19ace30fd62d33141efb25f60","unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:62dacb9af0517b2a3ba9ed97","scopeContentSha256":"aa654edea1226c7f740c71b06ee93eae599255498f7926df52978dc04c639851","localRef":"s13"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","scopeContentSha256":"18e133141c5df5a60eb5a76bfe937797e87c309aa9aa9fe26a5d65922eec1f24","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l16","originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:35","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l16","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:35","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:62dacb9af0517b2a3ba9ed97","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l16","source":"s13","target":"s5","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["The threshold rate tests the assumed fast cascade and also supports a distinct non-dark-matter freeze-in constraint target."],"challengeStatement":"Threshold suppression tests the fast-cascade premise and also informs a distinct constraint on a population that need not be dark matter.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4f88767e140ec911d98ed96cf88d5c80635315d2851f3cd9852ded3be8a0a32d","reply.jsonSha256":"5cae2d296c2312029b6035542eff38fa4f55426587c75161c4fc2c3daf3bbda0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c6c90479f85a502c579e840a4b793e77ec8cb627f84afcf18093558075f3ef53","receipt.jsonSha256":"6ebcdc203daebaca976bd1b819b42105b45f28dbd69c90e3c542386ec01b51ba","normalization.jsonSha256":"ad796afb2ffc10d1f869f0722aff8b560f1e6d4e9437973b922c4a52844fb6e4","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a50a2e796b56f03366769c25357d3bc10a23c6541736b8db4df955ac10e4c3b3"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"96dd7cead2cd66e8dd66af6c8b3e11240e64deb848d05deb23d3178ac1955128","reply.jsonSha256":"a577a7095f0e8b3b0adb6a918afc65ecfde89d0ca82623d9f65ee7caefac275e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f56614a666546960c8d32938e3d0d5e73f0227385870adf8071a35d79b0f57b6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4f7641c188a2eb2a2273ac4156762fc7ee454d1cfee615c39072949beddc3ef4","normalization.jsonSha256":"daa65bd672d3ee84971d3c6c9a70438709e8b57ad333470542b2f6494348fab2"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"},{"ref":"e15","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:fac9569d8f192e54850486112c7fe0d8","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f047caa6711ddcf0dab834ac0976f6f55b1f49660dd4bcadb530252e9ef74864","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"},{"ref":"e15","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:fac9569d8f192e54850486112c7fe0d8","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f047caa6711ddcf0dab834ac0976f6f55b1f49660dd4bcadb530252e9ef74864","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d16","originalRef":"l16","status":"route","source":"s13","target":"s5","type":"premise_check","title":"Check the fast-cascade premise against the reported KK threshold law","rationale":"The KK survival and cascade component of s13 depends on an assumed decay history that the threshold analysis tests. Both statements also retain the separate freeze-in constraint on populations that need not constitute dark matter.","qualification":"This check does not apply to the charged-field or near-extremal-PBH survival mechanisms. The reported threshold result retains its five-dimensional scalar–gravity, field/brane and comparable-daughter near-threshold assumptions. A partial decay law does not determine a summed cascade history. Freeze-in limits retain their production and reheating assumptions, and flat-dimension conclusions do not exclude every warped model.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l16","s13","s5"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d16","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The reported threshold result checks the fast-cascade assumption within the KK component of the survival question. Both original statements also preserve a distinct freeze-in constraint for populations that need not be dark matter. The record retains these two targets, the threshold domain and the distinction between a partial rate and a complete cascade history.","refs":["l16","s13","s5"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l16","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l17":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l17","source":"q025-candidate-question:6b27590dbc2f3a0722174815","target":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","type":"premise_check","title":"Recheck the cascade input to visible KK-decay phenomenology","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: visible-decay phenomenology uses a historical tower-evolution input whose reliability is challenged by the later threshold analysis.","qualification":"The 2023 mass history and cascade prescription remain conditional inputs. The reported threshold suppression is bounded by its stated action, dimensional and kinematic domain and does not provide a complete replacement cascade history or observational reanalysis. The brane-overlap coupling λ remains phenomenological, and naturalness-based mass conclusions still require order-one dimensionless decay couplings.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","unit:bd8c5b9a8b57126b3ca4cd9f8f106d4a591051d19ace30fd62d33141efb25f60","unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","unit:e12ca8a5f0ff6c3418a1bad027868db22196d443140dbd0952d62c39ff0d811e"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6b27590dbc2f3a0722174815","scopeContentSha256":"124cfb266aa23191262792bb233373a8698d4a3578e0f3997e55ef64e9a02e35","localRef":"s14"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","scopeContentSha256":"18e133141c5df5a60eb5a76bfe937797e87c309aa9aa9fe26a5d65922eec1f24","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l17","originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:44","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l17","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:44","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:6b27590dbc2f3a0722174815","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l17","source":"s5","target":"s14","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["The later threshold analysis challenges a historical cascade input to visible-decay phenomenology; it does not supply an updated observational reanalysis."],"challengeStatement":"The later threshold result challenges a historical cascade input to visible-decay phenomenology; it supplies no updated observational reanalysis.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4f88767e140ec911d98ed96cf88d5c80635315d2851f3cd9852ded3be8a0a32d","reply.jsonSha256":"5cae2d296c2312029b6035542eff38fa4f55426587c75161c4fc2c3daf3bbda0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c6c90479f85a502c579e840a4b793e77ec8cb627f84afcf18093558075f3ef53","receipt.jsonSha256":"6ebcdc203daebaca976bd1b819b42105b45f28dbd69c90e3c542386ec01b51ba","normalization.jsonSha256":"ad796afb2ffc10d1f869f0722aff8b560f1e6d4e9437973b922c4a52844fb6e4","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a50a2e796b56f03366769c25357d3bc10a23c6541736b8db4df955ac10e4c3b3"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"96dd7cead2cd66e8dd66af6c8b3e11240e64deb848d05deb23d3178ac1955128","reply.jsonSha256":"a577a7095f0e8b3b0adb6a918afc65ecfde89d0ca82623d9f65ee7caefac275e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f56614a666546960c8d32938e3d0d5e73f0227385870adf8071a35d79b0f57b6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4f7641c188a2eb2a2273ac4156762fc7ee454d1cfee615c39072949beddc3ef4","normalization.jsonSha256":"daa65bd672d3ee84971d3c6c9a70438709e8b57ad333470542b2f6494348fab2"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"},{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6b27590dbc2f3a0722174815"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"},{"ref":"x4_2","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:6b27590dbc2f3a0722174815"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d17","originalRef":"l17","status":"route","source":"s14","target":"s5","type":"premise_check","title":"Recheck the cascade input to visible KK-decay phenomenology","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: visible-decay phenomenology uses a historical tower-evolution input whose reliability is challenged by the later threshold analysis.","qualification":"The 2023 mass history and cascade prescription remain conditional inputs. The reported threshold suppression is bounded by its stated action, dimensional and kinematic domain and does not provide a complete replacement cascade history or observational reanalysis. The brane-overlap coupling λ remains phenomenological, and naturalness-based mass conclusions still require order-one dimensionless decay couplings.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l17","s14","s5"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d17","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"The visible-decay inference depends on a historical cascade input challenged by the later threshold analysis. This supports reversing the premise check to s14 → s5. The record preserves the threshold-domain limits, historical mass-history assumption, phenomenological brane coupling and conditional natural-mass interpretation, while explicitly retaining the absence of an observational reanalysis.","refs":["l17","s14","s5"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l17","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l18":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l18","source":"q-kk-decay-linear-cosmology","target":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","type":"premise_check","title":"Recheck the cascade law underlying the modeled kick history","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the linear-cosmology interpretation depends on the decay and mass-evolution laws examined by the later threshold work. Changing that prescription requires reconsidering the kick history.","qualification":"The 2023 analysis assumes approximately equal, nonrelativistic daughters, small mass release and a last-decay approximation to the velocity history. Its principal constraint is on a velocity combination, not independent measurements of all tower parameters. The later partial-rate result supplies no revised likelihood fit, nonlinear evolution, Hubble-tension resolution or updated Dark Dimension parameter bounds.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","unit:bd8c5b9a8b57126b3ca4cd9f8f106d4a591051d19ace30fd62d33141efb25f60","unit:be7aae21bb2419d0869faff0e2d1c1e653b0e8e75d40ce2e657fb8fb7495284a","unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3f58b634e6f7439e502be440","scopeContentSha256":"03d80d48b23a8db2d46f630638eaf63f89d041d76202e5669181978e51acfbdc","localRef":"s6"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","scopeContentSha256":"18e133141c5df5a60eb5a76bfe937797e87c309aa9aa9fe26a5d65922eec1f24","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l18","originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:45","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l18","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:45","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:3f58b634e6f7439e502be440","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l18","source":"s5","target":"s6","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["Replacing the assumed cascade law could alter the modeled kick history, but the supplied text does not establish a revised linear-cosmology fit."],"challengeStatement":"A changed cascade prescription requires reconsidering the modeled kick history, but the supplied text establishes no revised cosmological fit.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4f88767e140ec911d98ed96cf88d5c80635315d2851f3cd9852ded3be8a0a32d","reply.jsonSha256":"5cae2d296c2312029b6035542eff38fa4f55426587c75161c4fc2c3daf3bbda0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c6c90479f85a502c579e840a4b793e77ec8cb627f84afcf18093558075f3ef53","receipt.jsonSha256":"6ebcdc203daebaca976bd1b819b42105b45f28dbd69c90e3c542386ec01b51ba","normalization.jsonSha256":"ad796afb2ffc10d1f869f0722aff8b560f1e6d4e9437973b922c4a52844fb6e4","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a50a2e796b56f03366769c25357d3bc10a23c6541736b8db4df955ac10e4c3b3"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"96dd7cead2cd66e8dd66af6c8b3e11240e64deb848d05deb23d3178ac1955128","reply.jsonSha256":"a577a7095f0e8b3b0adb6a918afc65ecfde89d0ca82623d9f65ee7caefac275e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f56614a666546960c8d32938e3d0d5e73f0227385870adf8071a35d79b0f57b6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4f7641c188a2eb2a2273ac4156762fc7ee454d1cfee615c39072949beddc3ef4","normalization.jsonSha256":"daa65bd672d3ee84971d3c6c9a70438709e8b57ad333470542b2f6494348fab2"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"},{"ref":"x4_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3f58b634e6f7439e502be440"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"},{"ref":"x4_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3f58b634e6f7439e502be440"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d18","originalRef":"l18","status":"route","source":"s6","target":"s5","type":"premise_check","title":"Recheck the cascade law underlying the modeled kick history","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the linear-cosmology interpretation depends on the decay and mass-evolution laws examined by the later threshold work. Changing that prescription requires reconsidering the kick history.","qualification":"The 2023 analysis assumes approximately equal, nonrelativistic daughters, small mass release and a last-decay approximation to the velocity history. Its principal constraint is on a velocity combination, not independent measurements of all tower parameters. The later partial-rate result supplies no revised likelihood fit, nonlinear evolution, Hubble-tension resolution or updated Dark Dimension parameter bounds.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l18","s6","s5"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d18","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify the modeled kick history as dependent on the cascade prescription. The reversed premise-check direction is correct. The record preserves the equal-daughter, nonrelativistic, small-release and last-decay approximations, distinguishes the measured velocity combination from inferred tower parameters, and supplies no revised fit.","refs":["l18","s6","s5"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l18","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true,"canonicalEndpointProjection":{"sourceOriginalId":"q025-candidate-question:3f58b634e6f7439e502be440","targetOriginalId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","originalRelation":{"id":"navigation:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l18","source":"q025-candidate-question:3f58b634e6f7439e502be440","target":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","type":"premise_check","title":"Recheck the cascade law underlying the modeled kick history","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the linear-cosmology interpretation depends on the decay and mass-evolution laws examined by the later threshold work. Changing that prescription requires reconsidering the kick history.","qualification":"The 2023 analysis assumes approximately equal, nonrelativistic daughters, small mass release and a last-decay approximation to the velocity history. Its principal constraint is on a velocity combination, not independent measurements of all tower parameters. The later partial-rate result supplies no revised likelihood fit, nonlinear evolution, Hubble-tension resolution or updated Dark Dimension parameter bounds.","evidenceIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","unit:bd8c5b9a8b57126b3ca4cd9f8f106d4a591051d19ace30fd62d33141efb25f60","unit:be7aae21bb2419d0869faff0e2d1c1e653b0e8e75d40ce2e657fb8fb7495284a","unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3f58b634e6f7439e502be440","scopeContentSha256":"03d80d48b23a8db2d46f630638eaf63f89d041d76202e5669181978e51acfbdc","localRef":"s6"},{"kind":"reviewed_scope","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","scopeContentSha256":"18e133141c5df5a60eb5a76bfe937797e87c309aa9aa9fe26a5d65922eec1f24","localRef":"s5"},{"kind":"paired_route_context","localRef":"l18","originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:45","sourceReadingBasis":"inherited_prior_rationales","notPrimary":true}],"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l18","provenance":{"originalCandidateId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge:link:45","originalNativeType":"premise_check","originalSource":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","originalTarget":"q025-candidate-question:3f58b634e6f7439e502be440","sourceReadingBasis":"complete_current_scope_definitions_and_both_inherited_route_rationales","originalStatements":{"ref":"l18","source":"s5","target":"s6","nativeType":"premise_check","proposalStatements":["Replacing the assumed cascade law could alter the modeled kick history, but the supplied text does not establish a revised linear-cosmology fit."],"challengeStatement":"A changed cascade prescription requires reconsidering the modeled kick history, but the supplied text establishes no revised cosmological fit.","originalEvidenceKinds":["attributed_child_question","primary"],"originalEvidenceProvidedAsText":false},"originalReviewPins":{"proposal":{"reviewId":"parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-proposal","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"4f88767e140ec911d98ed96cf88d5c80635315d2851f3cd9852ded3be8a0a32d","reply.jsonSha256":"5cae2d296c2312029b6035542eff38fa4f55426587c75161c4fc2c3daf3bbda0","reply.raw.txtSha256":"c6c90479f85a502c579e840a4b793e77ec8cb627f84afcf18093558075f3ef53","receipt.jsonSha256":"6ebcdc203daebaca976bd1b819b42105b45f28dbd69c90e3c542386ec01b51ba","normalization.jsonSha256":"ad796afb2ffc10d1f869f0722aff8b560f1e6d4e9437973b922c4a52844fb6e4","resolvedFromRequest":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge/dispatch-request.json","sha256":"a50a2e796b56f03366769c25357d3bc10a23c6541736b8db4df955ac10e4c3b3"}},"challenge":{"artifactDirectory":"full-pass/native-local/parents-wave-v1/jobs/parent-6df57d46d56df9c77805-challenge","packetFile":"packet.actual.json","packet.actual.jsonSha256":"96dd7cead2cd66e8dd66af6c8b3e11240e64deb848d05deb23d3178ac1955128","reply.jsonSha256":"a577a7095f0e8b3b0adb6a918afc65ecfde89d0ca82623d9f65ee7caefac275e","reply.raw.txtSha256":"f56614a666546960c8d32938e3d0d5e73f0227385870adf8071a35d79b0f57b6","receipt.jsonSha256":"4f7641c188a2eb2a2273ac4156762fc7ee454d1cfee615c39072949beddc3ef4","normalization.jsonSha256":"daa65bd672d3ee84971d3c6c9a70438709e8b57ad333470542b2f6494348fab2"}},"inheritedOriginalEvidence":[{"proposal":[{"ref":"x4_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"},{"ref":"x4_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3f58b634e6f7439e502be440"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"challenge":[{"ref":"x4_5","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"},{"ref":"x4_3","kind":"attributed_child_question","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3f58b634e6f7439e502be440"},{"ref":"e4","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"ref":"e6","kind":"primary","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}]}],"proposalDecision":{"id":"d18","originalRef":"l18","status":"route","source":"s6","target":"s5","type":"premise_check","title":"Recheck the cascade law underlying the modeled kick history","rationale":"Reverse the original direction: the linear-cosmology interpretation depends on the decay and mass-evolution laws examined by the later threshold work. Changing that prescription requires reconsidering the kick history.","qualification":"The 2023 analysis assumes approximately equal, nonrelativistic daughters, small mass release and a last-decay approximation to the velocity history. Its principal constraint is on a velocity combination, not independent measurements of all tower parameters. The later partial-rate result supplies no revised likelihood fit, nonlinear evolution, Hubble-tension resolution or updated Dark Dimension parameter bounds.","missingPremise":"","refs":["l18","s6","s5"]},"independentAssessment":{"ref":"d18","verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"Both original statements identify the modeled kick history as dependent on the cascade prescription. The reversed premise-check direction is correct. The record preserves the equal-daughter, nonrelativistic, small-release and last-decay approximations, distinguishes the measured velocity combination from inferred tower parameters, and supplies no revised fit.","refs":["l18","s6","s5"]},"currentReviewIds":["parent-orientation-02-proposal","parent-orientation-02-challenge"],"evidenceIdBasis":"inherited_admitted_endpoint_scope_support","freshPrimaryReading":false,"newPhysicalResults":false,"titleReadingDirection":"outgoing_only","fullPacketLimitations":["All endpoint definitions and both original independent route statements are supplied unchanged.","Primary citation locators and original review files are pinned in a machine sidecar, but their text is not newly supplied/read.","Choose a scientifically accurate navigation direction/type using this existing reasoning. Do not introduce a new physical condition or transfer a method beyond its stated scope.","A missing substantive premise must be withheld for a targeted evidence check, not guessed.","Rows can be disconnected; packing establishes no scientific relationship between them."],"nativeLimitations":{"proposal":["This review uses only the supplied complete endpoint definitions and both original statements for each relation. No tools, primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were accessed.","Reading counts, primary-evidence labels and historical source assessments are inherited context, not new verification. The s* and l* references identify that context rather than empirical evidence.","Qualified methods and applications concern the explicitly identified components; they do not redefine either endpoint or impose those assumptions on every question within a broad scope.","Source-specific dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and historical observational limits remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational claims.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their proposal status. Scope compatibility does not admit pending descendants, replacements or new canonical identities.","No receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. Changed and withheld outcomes remain subject to the separate coordination and independent-challenge process."],"challenge":["This challenge assessed the supplied complete endpoint definitions, both original statements for every relation and every proposed record. No tools or external operations were used.","No primary text, sidecar locators or original review files were newly accessed or read. Reading counts and historical source assessments remain inherited context; s* and l* references are not new empirical evidence.","Retained methods, applications and premise checks remain limited to their identified components and full endpoint conditions. They do not impose those conditions on every member of a broad scope.","Dimensional, background, spectral, perturbative, boundary and source-era observational restrictions remain operative. This review does not verify calculations, complete parameter spaces or updated observational conclusions.","Provisional overview and parent scopes retain their existing status. This challenge does not independently verify descendants or establish canonical identities.","No endpoint receipt, global canonical, DAG or admission checks were performed. The withheld relation remains an explicit coordinator exception."]},"decisionId":"decision:orientation:parent-orientation-02:l18","sourceScienceLayerSeparate":true},"status":"accepted_navigation"},"identityDecisionIds":["decision:whole-group:29396ef95e9ac02a2a49a2c3"],"sourceCanonicalScopeContentSha256":"69fa9f0f6b17e46e71e526415368140409596c60de30144cfed2ae7227905815","targetCanonicalScopeContentSha256":"18e133141c5df5a60eb5a76bfe937797e87c309aa9aa9fe26a5d65922eec1f24"}},"status":"accepted_navigation"}}}