{"schemaVersion":"1.0.0","kind":"eigenquestions-organizational-access-certificates","records":{"organizational-access:0398a6c0b43051c161b3d4e6":{"id":"organizational-access:0398a6c0b43051c161b3d4e6","source":"q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0","target":"q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"d3b8c53549ec45f774bb3f9e66a788da3fdf56d4f913afe3f315a51a5e581386","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:15f500c3aa50203c8e876dbd"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a391c31dc44ef5080afb5df010c0f4b7049f9d9c3e58f66d1155990786029596","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d76d04c815f9832ef43a541d"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:7e7e59123cf54f929916f12eb059964fa7f512d7038a493f730b81f187a00e98","home":{"unitId":"unit:7e7e59123cf54f929916f12eb059964fa7f512d7038a493f730b81f187a00e98","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers existence of a nonperturbative decay for the specified AdS minima, with conjectural compatibility retained as motivation.","qualification":"q3 directly asks whether specified AdS decay channels exist or can be excluded. The source's conjectural compatibility clause qualifies that search without supplying a decay or an absolute-stability conclusion.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7e7e59123cf54f929916f12eb059964fa7f512d7038a493f730b81f187a00e98","paperId":"1812.06520","textSha256":"210ae4305849bea8d56de09e831dd5076eaecd797db6c4b3d3b1a02f34cfe049"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0019:u28:q3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0019:u28:q3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7e7e59123cf54f929916f12eb059964fa7f512d7038a493f730b81f187a00e98","q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0"],"scopeContentSha256":"d3b8c53549ec45f774bb3f9e66a788da3fdf56d4f913afe3f315a51a5e581386","placementContentSha256":"6149967107b77c1306e9cb8a973155b97986cb4edb97d6ba1648c489c513eb13","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0019:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0019:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7e7e59123cf54f929916f12eb059964fa7f512d7038a493f730b81f187a00e98","paperId":"1812.06520","textSha256":"210ae4305849bea8d56de09e831dd5076eaecd797db6c4b3d3b1a02f34cfe049"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0019","unitRef":"u28"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7e7e59123cf54f929916f12eb059964fa7f512d7038a493f730b81f187a00e98","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:7e7e59123cf54f929916f12eb059964fa7f512d7038a493f730b81f187a00e98","textSha256":"210ae4305849bea8d56de09e831dd5076eaecd797db6c4b3d3b1a02f34cfe049"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2631eb3462a14b0466b6ece1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2631eb3462a14b0466b6ece1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7e7e59123cf54f929916f12eb059964fa7f512d7038a493f730b81f187a00e98","q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0"],"scopeContentSha256":"a391c31dc44ef5080afb5df010c0f4b7049f9d9c3e58f66d1155990786029596","contributionContentSha256":"0d3c1770fdbf10aefcee067251623a9570242e9d25beef2a63c67e618276d405","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:7e7e59123cf54f929916f12eb059964fa7f512d7038a493f730b81f187a00e98","textSha256":"210ae4305849bea8d56de09e831dd5076eaecd797db6c4b3d3b1a02f34cfe049"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2631eb3462a14b0466b6ece1","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"14c805cdc82af560d16dfb8ecd384a61271af68120415de63827c62873e4f2f0"},"organizational-access:36686443d44f2bcff394f000":{"id":"organizational-access:36686443d44f2bcff394f000","source":"q025-candidate-question:30f89734bb0878d0e4b37a83","target":"q025-candidate-question:564f88e156d202fbaa8b1edf","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:30f89734bb0878d0e4b37a83","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a8c68802166cbec62b13faf5f04b7a72cb9453b481886a086f6c80ec0bfc064b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:090383fd314a92033383892f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:564f88e156d202fbaa8b1edf","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"0ad8781ec685f9729c5bf02d3d7e00ece501d988ecfa7618c30bb0484828dc33","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:mediation:pq11"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:3e8aa697ac9d3896934105129c7ca28d9876c2abb6e3abb0acf17b10376c4fbe","home":{"unitId":"unit:3e8aa697ac9d3896934105129c7ca28d9876c2abb6e3abb0acf17b10376c4fbe","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:30f89734bb0878d0e4b37a83","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers one-loop threshold/Kähler-corrected hidden condensation, scalar potentials, moduli determination and dilaton stabilization with either hidden-matter alternative.","qualification":"q6 explicitly encompasses the correction, condensation, scalar-potential, moduli and dilaton targets with both matter alternatives. The resolved source association supports use of its source-specific hidden-sector setting without inferring a new compactification class from the description. Twisted-Yukawa exceptions remain local qualifications, and dilaton stabilization remains a target rather than a verified result.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3e8aa697ac9d3896934105129c7ca28d9876c2abb6e3abb0acf17b10376c4fbe","paperId":"hep-th/9201047","textSha256":"d06251560f85b3a98bfef273fb828ff8197298c2aed4d4ab250457c9c93392f1"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0025:u15:q6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0025:u15:q6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3e8aa697ac9d3896934105129c7ca28d9876c2abb6e3abb0acf17b10376c4fbe","q025-candidate-question:30f89734bb0878d0e4b37a83"],"scopeContentSha256":"a8c68802166cbec62b13faf5f04b7a72cb9453b481886a086f6c80ec0bfc064b","placementContentSha256":"723b19bed28c3d65695b3e7da1175e5667c93a550e15570cfacc79b0eaceb2bc","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0025:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0025:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3e8aa697ac9d3896934105129c7ca28d9876c2abb6e3abb0acf17b10376c4fbe","paperId":"hep-th/9201047","textSha256":"d06251560f85b3a98bfef273fb828ff8197298c2aed4d4ab250457c9c93392f1"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0025","unitRef":"u15"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3e8aa697ac9d3896934105129c7ca28d9876c2abb6e3abb0acf17b10376c4fbe","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:564f88e156d202fbaa8b1edf","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u43","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3e8aa697ac9d3896934105129c7ca28d9876c2abb6e3abb0acf17b10376c4fbe","paperId":"hep-th/9201047","textSha256":"d06251560f85b3a98bfef273fb828ff8197298c2aed4d4ab250457c9c93392f1"},{"localRef":"e42","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:02048e175bd1181b4d39e178017fbae4","paperId":"hep-th/9201047","sourceSha256":"7606f8031be05df9b7894e2d0674761508598183cf614bacac6d0c60fee2341d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/756d6e6d22dd0b6bb0fe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"183886d3ca1803f6613417a2cee4fb9e751f6928c6ca27c7cd9fef7ce19098e1","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2613,"textSha256":"1478b4191c5a171d45be449fab6488e455dc54fee60d8d0a123a759ce860f82e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e45","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:59f9afa2effeae0f75b3f10810ca9eea","paperId":"hep-th/9201047","sourceSha256":"7606f8031be05df9b7894e2d0674761508598183cf614bacac6d0c60fee2341d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/756d6e6d22dd0b6bb0fe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"183886d3ca1803f6613417a2cee4fb9e751f6928c6ca27c7cd9fef7ce19098e1","pdfPage":2,"start":98,"end":2613,"textSha256":"b30123dccc929b2627d9edd220c6eed92e25872fd7ae9b3745a14992db5961ca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e46","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7a7566ed3ff303aebcbf3d5f78272ac7","paperId":"hep-th/9201047","sourceSha256":"7606f8031be05df9b7894e2d0674761508598183cf614bacac6d0c60fee2341d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/756d6e6d22dd0b6bb0fe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"183886d3ca1803f6613417a2cee4fb9e751f6928c6ca27c7cd9fef7ce19098e1","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":612,"textSha256":"1c088b4a5d8b0f8f60631e34fc0ffedf2f4f2e9765adc5c5c02eb630bf051a9b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"qualification":"The abstract and introduction directly support the threshold and one-loop Kähler analysis of hidden condensation and moduli determination, including the exceptions involving twisted Yukawa couplings.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z19"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z19","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3e8aa697ac9d3896934105129c7ca28d9876c2abb6e3abb0acf17b10376c4fbe","q025-candidate-question:564f88e156d202fbaa8b1edf"],"scopeContentSha256":"0ad8781ec685f9729c5bf02d3d7e00ece501d988ecfa7618c30bb0484828dc33","contributionContentSha256":"e15dcc7133e953f3cd95b188741bbc77df256ada0cfdd8effbf7fe65d3aa2175","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","challengeReviewId":"mediation-source-role-confirmation"},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","mediation-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u43","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3e8aa697ac9d3896934105129c7ca28d9876c2abb6e3abb0acf17b10376c4fbe","paperId":"hep-th/9201047","textSha256":"d06251560f85b3a98bfef273fb828ff8197298c2aed4d4ab250457c9c93392f1"},{"localRef":"e42","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:02048e175bd1181b4d39e178017fbae4","paperId":"hep-th/9201047","sourceSha256":"7606f8031be05df9b7894e2d0674761508598183cf614bacac6d0c60fee2341d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/756d6e6d22dd0b6bb0fe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"183886d3ca1803f6613417a2cee4fb9e751f6928c6ca27c7cd9fef7ce19098e1","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2613,"textSha256":"1478b4191c5a171d45be449fab6488e455dc54fee60d8d0a123a759ce860f82e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e45","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:59f9afa2effeae0f75b3f10810ca9eea","paperId":"hep-th/9201047","sourceSha256":"7606f8031be05df9b7894e2d0674761508598183cf614bacac6d0c60fee2341d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/756d6e6d22dd0b6bb0fe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"183886d3ca1803f6613417a2cee4fb9e751f6928c6ca27c7cd9fef7ce19098e1","pdfPage":2,"start":98,"end":2613,"textSha256":"b30123dccc929b2627d9edd220c6eed92e25872fd7ae9b3745a14992db5961ca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e46","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7a7566ed3ff303aebcbf3d5f78272ac7","paperId":"hep-th/9201047","sourceSha256":"7606f8031be05df9b7894e2d0674761508598183cf614bacac6d0c60fee2341d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/756d6e6d22dd0b6bb0fe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"183886d3ca1803f6613417a2cee4fb9e751f6928c6ca27c7cd9fef7ce19098e1","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":612,"textSha256":"1c088b4a5d8b0f8f60631e34fc0ffedf2f4f2e9765adc5c5c02eb630bf051a9b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"explicitConfirmation":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z19","family":"mediation","originalRowId":"z19","oldRole":{"id":"z19","unitRef":"u43","questionRef":"pq11","role":"addresses","reason":"The abstract and introduction directly support the threshold and one-loop Kähler analysis of hidden condensation and moduli determination, including the exceptions involving twisted Yukawa couplings.","refs":["u43","e42","e45","e46"]},"confirmation":{"id":"z19","verdict":"supported_as_written","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":[],"reason":"The abstract and introduction directly investigate thresholds, one-loop Kähler corrections, hidden condensation and moduli determination, including pure-gauge/massive-matter cases and the stated twisted-Yukawa exceptions.","refs":["u43","pq11","e42","e45","e46","n32"]},"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","challengeReviewId":"mediation-source-role-confirmation","qualificationUnchanged":true}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"593105a0d845717ddad4e7c3cf7779bfa07274faaa89bf68ffa250068b932341"},"organizational-access:731cde6d7c38fe7d0f6cf7a3":{"id":"organizational-access:731cde6d7c38fe7d0f6cf7a3","source":"q025-candidate-question:3d5c2b4ed57cefc85bb9a422","target":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3d5c2b4ed57cefc85bb9a422","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1f348cab8fcb7081a6fb142faa239ec4d8ce85e6031349fff85e8ffaa14e81e2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:scope:pq0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ccd5e77a867e82ef7825199cd2d2c893840dc9ae3a8e87e1462a81ac1aa99d41","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:statistics:pq0"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","home":{"unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3d5c2b4ed57cefc85bb9a422","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q9 explicitly covers finite IIB flux, source and lattice consistency, classical correction control, and the separate implications of a proposed asymptotic scaling.","qualification":"q9 explicitly combines finite quantized IIB consistency/control with the separate question of parametric improvement and obstruction evasion. The reported tachyons, tower limitation and inconclusive correction estimates restrict conclusions, without removing either target.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","paperId":"2403.07065","textSha256":"d8e5d6cccfe27b0d233e28d23db633473b21413bbc7ea9b5862c3a89d3da04e0"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u13:q9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u13:q9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","q025-candidate-question:3d5c2b4ed57cefc85bb9a422"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f348cab8fcb7081a6fb142faa239ec4d8ce85e6031349fff85e8ffaa14e81e2","placementContentSha256":"ab8f66c6ea5d584f82c635c09e2f990ec8003e341efd8768da627b77130151ab","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","paperId":"2403.07065","textSha256":"d8e5d6cccfe27b0d233e28d23db633473b21413bbc7ea9b5862c3a89d3da04e0"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0031","unitRef":"u13"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u37","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","paperId":"2403.07065","textSha256":"d8e5d6cccfe27b0d233e28d23db633473b21413bbc7ea9b5862c3a89d3da04e0"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:464f8ecb8622f01c189cd53ecfa72248","paperId":"2403.07065","sourceSha256":"5be1329ee3cf770594e4c2172176556c1e4203ebb7f2e5a0a0d06d4449cceb28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eb309a810c842697eae1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1f25699c74daa7c51ef93aa11e828ef60cfc2b418b306c63fa4481b2d3fbea7c","pdfPage":6,"start":98,"end":3490,"textSha256":"e86f3ddd22652eba0fb8582bea1a910823361cb0766cf190f714e8468fbd41fa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7ea95c17749aae25b4bf473e42bb3f8f","paperId":"2403.07065","sourceSha256":"5be1329ee3cf770594e4c2172176556c1e4203ebb7f2e5a0a0d06d4449cceb28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eb309a810c842697eae1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1f25699c74daa7c51ef93aa11e828ef60cfc2b418b306c63fa4481b2d3fbea7c","pdfPage":3,"start":94,"end":3490,"textSha256":"f37088127e8b3ae87152cfcfe7f89964330f526fd38beb179472e788e8eb1239","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ec59abccbc58da0389ed9b48f5517f74","paperId":"2403.07065","sourceSha256":"5be1329ee3cf770594e4c2172176556c1e4203ebb7f2e5a0a0d06d4449cceb28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eb309a810c842697eae1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1f25699c74daa7c51ef93aa11e828ef60cfc2b418b306c63fa4481b2d3fbea7c","pdfPage":3,"start":1291,"end":4149,"textSha256":"ec4b7960198b31671e6f96b569b624bc813e82281d52b48a57af715c9e5e43f8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"qualification":"The primary discussion identifies unresolved finite radii and correction estimates required for classical control of the particular IIB candidates.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z14"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z14","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02"],"scopeContentSha256":"ccd5e77a867e82ef7825199cd2d2c893840dc9ae3a8e87e1462a81ac1aa99d41","contributionContentSha256":"116d0bd3281d5710aa38836c3f781e1799d348f3bd01e71d4c8bf92a9af618a1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation"},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","statistics-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u37","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:781d9a4a0f2322b2f8d03809553253b32604528df15a476cc965c86f5be426b6","paperId":"2403.07065","textSha256":"d8e5d6cccfe27b0d233e28d23db633473b21413bbc7ea9b5862c3a89d3da04e0"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:464f8ecb8622f01c189cd53ecfa72248","paperId":"2403.07065","sourceSha256":"5be1329ee3cf770594e4c2172176556c1e4203ebb7f2e5a0a0d06d4449cceb28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eb309a810c842697eae1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1f25699c74daa7c51ef93aa11e828ef60cfc2b418b306c63fa4481b2d3fbea7c","pdfPage":6,"start":98,"end":3490,"textSha256":"e86f3ddd22652eba0fb8582bea1a910823361cb0766cf190f714e8468fbd41fa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7ea95c17749aae25b4bf473e42bb3f8f","paperId":"2403.07065","sourceSha256":"5be1329ee3cf770594e4c2172176556c1e4203ebb7f2e5a0a0d06d4449cceb28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eb309a810c842697eae1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1f25699c74daa7c51ef93aa11e828ef60cfc2b418b306c63fa4481b2d3fbea7c","pdfPage":3,"start":94,"end":3490,"textSha256":"f37088127e8b3ae87152cfcfe7f89964330f526fd38beb179472e788e8eb1239","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ec59abccbc58da0389ed9b48f5517f74","paperId":"2403.07065","sourceSha256":"5be1329ee3cf770594e4c2172176556c1e4203ebb7f2e5a0a0d06d4449cceb28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eb309a810c842697eae1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1f25699c74daa7c51ef93aa11e828ef60cfc2b418b306c63fa4481b2d3fbea7c","pdfPage":3,"start":1291,"end":4149,"textSha256":"ec4b7960198b31671e6f96b569b624bc813e82281d52b48a57af715c9e5e43f8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"explicitConfirmation":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z14","family":"statistics","originalRowId":"z14","oldRole":{"id":"z14","unitRef":"u37","questionRef":"pq0","role":"specializes","reason":"The primary discussion identifies unresolved finite radii and correction estimates required for classical control of the particular IIB candidates.","refs":["u37","e10","e12","e13"]},"confirmation":{"id":"z14","verdict":"supported_as_written","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":[],"reason":"The particular IIB candidates specialize finite validity through unresolved radii and correction estimates explicitly identified in e10.","refs":["u37","pq0","e10","e12","e13"]},"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation","qualificationUnchanged":true}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"b124543ce23db2b4c0680bfc4984f3187cf24e9195828ece0f51058dede21d2b"},"organizational-access:29d9bcde8a9052e5b09c5541":{"id":"organizational-access:29d9bcde8a9052e5b09c5541","source":"q025-candidate-question:3d9676d2fc4a8b9638c37bff","target":"q025-candidate-question:891a8b29f5b4c34d1fea8065","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3d9676d2fc4a8b9638c37bff","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"784e029177b133e68f2c2141b82fa338af3969f9a8a85821eed351309df04779","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:27e36335d3119a5fdb8ded92"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:891a8b29f5b4c34d1fea8065","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1338a4e95740a79b34858bbda68c9c1adabe8ef60833f2f95e343ebbe57aa1f6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d8d64ed137b9ea81530d91fd"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:cd56a5e47e7656cd0e977e029cd1725f01fe8da2c1ca4f02666fe6c89ae28955","home":{"unitId":"unit:cd56a5e47e7656cd0e977e029cd1725f01fe8da2c1ca4f02666fe6c89ae28955","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3d9676d2fc4a8b9638c37bff","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":0.5,"reason":"Covers conditional compatibility of the inflationary potential with the source's Swampland restrictions.","qualification":"Warm-background and conjectural tests do not automatically establish exit or censorship evasion. Exact full challenge coverage and source-local qualifications remain binding. Weights are organizational allocation, not confidence or physical importance.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cd56a5e47e7656cd0e977e029cd1725f01fe8da2c1ca4f02666fe6c89ae28955","paperId":"1809.03962","textSha256":"8a05d51ca4fbd7374bbb7946381f12a8c5a69672e3a1f602977c475a834d3af8"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0068:u18:q5","coverageMode":"explicit_compound_union","targetCoverage":[{"sourceSpan":"Can radiation production during inflation remove the need for an oscillatory reheating minimum","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:891a8b29f5b4c34d1fea8065"],"explanation":"This is the warm-background and transition-mechanism target; radiation production alone is not assumed to establish successful exit."},{"sourceSpan":"while permitting inflation on a potential restricted by the Swampland conjectures?","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:3d9676d2fc4a8b9638c37bff"],"explanation":"This is the linked conditional-potential viability target, with conjectures retained as assumptions."}],"coverageReason":"The two selected scopes collectively cover the complete linked feasibility question: q10 covers during-inflation radiation production and the proposed replacement of oscillatory reheating, while q5 covers compatibility of that same inflationary history with conjectural potential restrictions. q10 does not include the conjecture test; q5 does not independently encompass the radiation-supported replacement mechanism. q17 centers on postinflationary transfer and retains warm histories as comparisons. q19 connects dynamics and consistency to primordial-observable questions, which are absent here. No supplied whole composite home establishes both targets at this scope. The union preserves their simultaneous requirement and remains subject to separate coordinator scrutiny."},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0068:u18:q5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cd56a5e47e7656cd0e977e029cd1725f01fe8da2c1ca4f02666fe6c89ae28955","q025-candidate-question:3d9676d2fc4a8b9638c37bff"],"scopeContentSha256":"784e029177b133e68f2c2141b82fa338af3969f9a8a85821eed351309df04779","placementContentSha256":"2d9b68fe5efd2a94d0b19720e26f766014ddbde371bbad51de887c37a57b9e30","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0068:proposal","explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0068:challenge","root:explicit-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cd56a5e47e7656cd0e977e029cd1725f01fe8da2c1ca4f02666fe6c89ae28955","paperId":"1809.03962","textSha256":"8a05d51ca4fbd7374bbb7946381f12a8c5a69672e3a1f602977c475a834d3af8"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"45cd7c1d060cb6f2fd1d8a4ace5cca7c3d64df235a869afc4ce7e31b2e6badfb"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0068","unitRef":"u18"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cd56a5e47e7656cd0e977e029cd1725f01fe8da2c1ca4f02666fe6c89ae28955","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:891a8b29f5b4c34d1fea8065","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:cd56a5e47e7656cd0e977e029cd1725f01fe8da2c1ca4f02666fe6c89ae28955","textSha256":"8a05d51ca4fbd7374bbb7946381f12a8c5a69672e3a1f602977c475a834d3af8"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3534fcf40a9911d961b1b74a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3534fcf40a9911d961b1b74a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cd56a5e47e7656cd0e977e029cd1725f01fe8da2c1ca4f02666fe6c89ae28955","q025-candidate-question:891a8b29f5b4c34d1fea8065"],"scopeContentSha256":"1338a4e95740a79b34858bbda68c9c1adabe8ef60833f2f95e343ebbe57aa1f6","contributionContentSha256":"869027ba1fbe28d28b0fc32a6545e5032aeaa00320390dfbffd4e49ff0d15420","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-proposal","leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:cd56a5e47e7656cd0e977e029cd1725f01fe8da2c1ca4f02666fe6c89ae28955","textSha256":"8a05d51ca4fbd7374bbb7946381f12a8c5a69672e3a1f602977c475a834d3af8"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3534fcf40a9911d961b1b74a","recordId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Conjectural potential restrictions and avoiding an oscillatory reheating minimum are linked targets, not established outcomes.","challengeNote":"Avoiding an oscillatory minimum and satisfying conjectural potential restrictions are linked questions, not established outcomes.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"0f01e07276ebd7b9775e1cb2a5c05c9b18f0a301e137080a19425e1271dfe0bb"},"organizational-access:b44a4a6495b6636345e2ca8c":{"id":"organizational-access:b44a4a6495b6636345e2ca8c","source":"q025-candidate-question:3dadd0a3f57bbc0a09ad9c38","target":"q025-candidate-question:f12b7cf4bcf363a5fecd5c98","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3dadd0a3f57bbc0a09ad9c38","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b5d910cd7ce59298d1f52308649e929f2da0fe5e5585fe20657f3a0be1c11e44","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e228b0628ed4592ee7ad8448"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f12b7cf4bcf363a5fecd5c98","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"411905f1f8a6ac23ccc9795329678da671a486a7da918ace06abab9514755704","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:922c4f7a5dbc9847f43ec225"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","home":{"unitId":"unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3dadd0a3f57bbc0a09ad9c38","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":0.25,"reason":"Covers entanglement as a diagnostic of deformed holographic theories, including the stated TT̄ target.","qualification":"Keep transport, de Sitter matter tests and TTbar entanglement distinct; infer no holographic construction or TTbar prescription. Exact full challenge coverage and source-local qualifications remain binding. Weights are organizational allocation, not confidence or physical importance.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","paperId":"2012.10109","textSha256":"818a4ad1a0fd66d40c3efb2ca23366e6bfdcc7845321f6465aee87b856e4a826"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0059:u22:q4","coverageMode":"explicit_compound_union","targetCoverage":[{"sourceSpan":"broken translations and chiral anomalies affect strongly coupled transport","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:59a1073896d8181c0e961e88"],"explanation":"q8 includes anomalous strongly coupled QFT transport and translation-breaking comparisons; both stated mechanisms remain in this transport assignment."},{"sourceSpan":"holographic entanglement constrain de Sitter matter","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:b9d8df4f750ac8295aba03ed"],"explanation":"This is q13's entropy-based matter-test direction in a de Sitter setting."},{"sourceSpan":"clarify TT̄-deformed theories","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:3dadd0a3f57bbc0a09ad9c38"],"explanation":"The shared holographic-entanglement method applies here to deformed-theory state structure, within q4's information-measure scope; no particular TT̄ prescription is inferred."}],"coverageReason":"The union covers both transport mechanisms and the two separate entanglement applications. q8 supplies anomalous transport and translation-breaking comparisons, q13 the de Sitter matter test, and q4 entanglement in deformed theories. No supplied whole scope includes all three branches: q17 lacks the entanglement applications and q4 lacks the transport question. The source remains whole; the union requires separate coordinator scrutiny."},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0059:u22:q4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","q025-candidate-question:3dadd0a3f57bbc0a09ad9c38"],"scopeContentSha256":"b5d910cd7ce59298d1f52308649e929f2da0fe5e5585fe20657f3a0be1c11e44","placementContentSha256":"99dae3f152b2b6762adc08361823861bbbf0f418c459ba7d90a798ae4a9d6c44","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0059:proposal","explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0059:challenge","root:explicit-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","paperId":"2012.10109","textSha256":"818a4ad1a0fd66d40c3efb2ca23366e6bfdcc7845321f6465aee87b856e4a826"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"45cd7c1d060cb6f2fd1d8a4ace5cca7c3d64df235a869afc4ce7e31b2e6badfb"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0059","unitRef":"u22"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f12b7cf4bcf363a5fecd5c98","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","textSha256":"818a4ad1a0fd66d40c3efb2ca23366e6bfdcc7845321f6465aee87b856e4a826"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a807bdf7cf43e008273684a3","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound transport, de Sitter-matter and TT̄-entanglement targets require finer reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Transport, de Sitter matter and TT̄-entanglement targets require finer reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a807bdf7cf43e008273684a3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","q025-candidate-question:f12b7cf4bcf363a5fecd5c98"],"scopeContentSha256":"411905f1f8a6ac23ccc9795329678da671a486a7da918ace06abab9514755704","contributionContentSha256":"8f35ff375e244da20885bb528f1183de5655a182a96bdc4b7b9cb92235cce192","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b25d09c378f754eff252-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b25d09c378f754eff252-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b25d09c378f754eff252-proposal","leaf-b25d09c378f754eff252-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:0d9e7eaa39201d1f0c00e31203404c299be4a60e81b8ceb315f65349286630df","textSha256":"818a4ad1a0fd66d40c3efb2ca23366e6bfdcc7845321f6465aee87b856e4a826"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a807bdf7cf43e008273684a3","recordId":"leaf-b25d09c378f754eff252-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b25d09c378f754eff252-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b25d09c378f754eff252-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound transport, de Sitter-matter and TT̄-entanglement targets require finer reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Transport, de Sitter matter and TT̄-entanglement targets require finer reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"20677dbab01b27cff22321e56b151ff5617e0d4a6645bcf05f08af0aa87000b3"},"organizational-access:1ec6cf1a434b65dd5a4d1c5a":{"id":"organizational-access:1ec6cf1a434b65dd5a4d1c5a","source":"q025-candidate-question:3f906fa96d6677e697637ad4","target":"q025-candidate-question:6d7d8562d98adfdd5985ab06","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3f906fa96d6677e697637ad4","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"47b3f8ee886a14a1fa8c910aeb0075d32385c41de6f5560d6f6bf4614482b817","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5dce518a42525b1493e7b30f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6d7d8562d98adfdd5985ab06","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6775dd3f166429935ea75833b8677f05f2b8b2cad717859a7c06e4e161664fb2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ccfabc22337921bb6a03f171"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:ec2060e7a862abc09f505ce5b8851a036be839814f6c4baa8ff92734b350e99a","home":{"unitId":"unit:ec2060e7a862abc09f505ce5b8851a036be839814f6c4baa8ff92734b350e99a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3f906fa96d6677e697637ad4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q3 explicitly combines large-volume stabilization comparisons with loop robustness of soft-term predictions.","qualification":"q3 directly includes both robustness targets: the large-volume stabilized setting and its soft-term predictions under string-loop corrections. Its perturbative qualifications prevent an inference of all-orders control.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ec2060e7a862abc09f505ce5b8851a036be839814f6c4baa8ff92734b350e99a","paperId":"0704.0737","textSha256":"f392fb38cddc718a2961735cd50ddc068e26c150bf98e081712d9dbacb0a6623"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0027:u8:q3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0027:u8:q3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ec2060e7a862abc09f505ce5b8851a036be839814f6c4baa8ff92734b350e99a","q025-candidate-question:3f906fa96d6677e697637ad4"],"scopeContentSha256":"47b3f8ee886a14a1fa8c910aeb0075d32385c41de6f5560d6f6bf4614482b817","placementContentSha256":"369b6a5a7c88ec1fdf84778f159a753bff9c582145dface3125ecd78dc5759b8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0027:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0027:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ec2060e7a862abc09f505ce5b8851a036be839814f6c4baa8ff92734b350e99a","paperId":"0704.0737","textSha256":"f392fb38cddc718a2961735cd50ddc068e26c150bf98e081712d9dbacb0a6623"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0027","unitRef":"u8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ec2060e7a862abc09f505ce5b8851a036be839814f6c4baa8ff92734b350e99a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6d7d8562d98adfdd5985ab06","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:ec2060e7a862abc09f505ce5b8851a036be839814f6c4baa8ff92734b350e99a","textSha256":"f392fb38cddc718a2961735cd50ddc068e26c150bf98e081712d9dbacb0a6623"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7c239140b7c6f27c4708a4db"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7c239140b7c6f27c4708a4db","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ec2060e7a862abc09f505ce5b8851a036be839814f6c4baa8ff92734b350e99a","q025-candidate-question:6d7d8562d98adfdd5985ab06"],"scopeContentSha256":"6775dd3f166429935ea75833b8677f05f2b8b2cad717859a7c06e4e161664fb2","contributionContentSha256":"91548b6c3851ba68891d5f0a5e7e302fa53a7017dd6ca0bfabd1029b25c1ca4d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-137910ef0e05f3c93520-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-137910ef0e05f3c93520-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-137910ef0e05f3c93520-proposal","leaf-137910ef0e05f3c93520-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:ec2060e7a862abc09f505ce5b8851a036be839814f6c4baa8ff92734b350e99a","textSha256":"f392fb38cddc718a2961735cd50ddc068e26c150bf98e081712d9dbacb0a6623"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7c239140b7c6f27c4708a4db","recordId":"leaf-137910ef0e05f3c93520-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-137910ef0e05f3c93520-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-137910ef0e05f3c93520-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"3e9bb58b13a3c6849c9234917128ec8366a08933bed8e90e77ae2b09c3925493"},"organizational-access:f47ca4bbb020817f82edfcfd":{"id":"organizational-access:f47ca4bbb020817f82edfcfd","source":"q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a","target":"q025-candidate-question:a5d73977b672c9cdb6533662","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"8a73b16635ef766c7dd1d26a5437b8e7551b52c20d6577dca0c0c891452a91f8","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:70a6de87d57a571c17408b57"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a5d73977b672c9cdb6533662","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"37a772c18c208f1c81894cf0506a7dd9e35f26382b04d717ff443e00d21b1aa0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:fc231964a4cd176a4a832861"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:867d6306bb4ef249127e34e49e42de51ce9499dca33bcece718da62847d8f05d","home":{"unitId":"unit:867d6306bb4ef249127e34e49e42de51ce9499dca33bcece718da62847d8f05d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers duality-based superpotential computation, flux-dependent determinants and multiwrappings, together with the proposed generalized superpotential motivated by that calculation.","qualification":"q1 covers both the explicit duality computation and the generalized-superpotential proposal it motivates. Flux dependence, determinants and multiwrappings remain explicit; neither a controlled KKLT vacuum nor equality with distinct-instanton effects follows from the placement.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:867d6306bb4ef249127e34e49e42de51ce9499dca33bcece718da62847d8f05d","paperId":"hep-th/0504058","textSha256":"45bdb539789f0716089ff4192a064f636b485fff28bc0518abe7c8b1cdbf1b4e"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0014:u13:q1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0014:u13:q1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:867d6306bb4ef249127e34e49e42de51ce9499dca33bcece718da62847d8f05d","q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a"],"scopeContentSha256":"8a73b16635ef766c7dd1d26a5437b8e7551b52c20d6577dca0c0c891452a91f8","placementContentSha256":"9d495bba7d255e989d76f7df03d1cd3493c2d881fc840bb1778cc4b0c3633857","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0014:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0014:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:867d6306bb4ef249127e34e49e42de51ce9499dca33bcece718da62847d8f05d","paperId":"hep-th/0504058","textSha256":"45bdb539789f0716089ff4192a064f636b485fff28bc0518abe7c8b1cdbf1b4e"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0014","unitRef":"u13"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:867d6306bb4ef249127e34e49e42de51ce9499dca33bcece718da62847d8f05d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a5d73977b672c9cdb6533662","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:867d6306bb4ef249127e34e49e42de51ce9499dca33bcece718da62847d8f05d","textSha256":"45bdb539789f0716089ff4192a064f636b485fff28bc0518abe7c8b1cdbf1b4e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:967b1051e81a48f8b1293adc"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:967b1051e81a48f8b1293adc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:867d6306bb4ef249127e34e49e42de51ce9499dca33bcece718da62847d8f05d","q025-candidate-question:a5d73977b672c9cdb6533662"],"scopeContentSha256":"37a772c18c208f1c81894cf0506a7dd9e35f26382b04d717ff443e00d21b1aa0","contributionContentSha256":"8bbd452cd1e361fad684fcfd36015af3ed415c06325cc726a38ddd34de76c40e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-proposal","leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:867d6306bb4ef249127e34e49e42de51ce9499dca33bcece718da62847d8f05d","textSha256":"45bdb539789f0716089ff4192a064f636b485fff28bc0518abe7c8b1cdbf1b4e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:967b1051e81a48f8b1293adc","recordId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Flux-dependent determinants and multiwrappings in a KKLT-type setting; generalized GVW remains an additional proposal.","challengeNote":"Fluxed determinants and multiwrappings are computation targets; generalized GVW is an additional proposal. KKLT context alone does not certify stabilization.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"45fc2e6ae9a582013347dcd4ab245b0900ccc207149f3263c66e0fdd6c5679ae"},"organizational-access:d843f535fca190fb7183ce39":{"id":"organizational-access:d843f535fca190fb7183ce39","source":"q025-candidate-question:578a592e996db0ed70b6e2b8","target":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:578a592e996db0ed70b6e2b8","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"fb49faf8be9264a928d5f5a5b06552ee6be67510339a37bce599a3ef8f0a9f8c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:4885fe8f4459348f7f968392"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"5e6c90cc5733aced848abc6aeafcd6daa829b97d761364bc71ea7803d1df1dd6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7afc98ee8265af1b50632f20"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:13fff5545063255f2448c6dfee410e9df4c329abe8319bf87872deb125a9fcec","home":{"unitId":"unit:13fff5545063255f2448c6dfee410e9df4c329abe8319bf87872deb125a9fcec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:578a592e996db0ed70b6e2b8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers a string-derived inflationary potential, threshold-generated field-range enhancement, stabilization of other moduli and the significance of subleading corrections.","qualification":"Both threshold enhancement with stabilized moduli and consequential subleading modulations fit q0's controlled-potential construction question. The two targets remain distinct within that complete composite home.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:13fff5545063255f2448c6dfee410e9df4c329abe8319bf87872deb125a9fcec","textSha256":"c84b856f5654444b26cccafdea05c56f4f078d2b5178f0790ed3fdd10c8e51f6"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u3:q0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u3:q0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:13fff5545063255f2448c6dfee410e9df4c329abe8319bf87872deb125a9fcec","q025-candidate-question:578a592e996db0ed70b6e2b8"],"scopeContentSha256":"fb49faf8be9264a928d5f5a5b06552ee6be67510339a37bce599a3ef8f0a9f8c","placementContentSha256":"077ff1fb2dcd9ff250e99cb050f2193065aaae41b600d4923a6b0405fbc8c1f6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:coverage:proposal","placement-pilot:coverage:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:13fff5545063255f2448c6dfee410e9df4c329abe8319bf87872deb125a9fcec","textSha256":"c84b856f5654444b26cccafdea05c56f4f078d2b5178f0790ed3fdd10c8e51f6"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:13fff5545063255f2448c6dfee410e9df4c329abe8319bf87872deb125a9fcec"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:13fff5545063255f2448c6dfee410e9df4c329abe8319bf87872deb125a9fcec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:13fff5545063255f2448c6dfee410e9df4c329abe8319bf87872deb125a9fcec","textSha256":"c84b856f5654444b26cccafdea05c56f4f078d2b5178f0790ed3fdd10c8e51f6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:83ebad01285605125265340a","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Threshold-generated enhancement and consequential subleading modulations remain separate targets. Independent challenge qualification: Threshold-generated enhancement and consequential subleading modulations remain distinct targets for reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:83ebad01285605125265340a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:13fff5545063255f2448c6dfee410e9df4c329abe8319bf87872deb125a9fcec","q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c"],"scopeContentSha256":"5e6c90cc5733aced848abc6aeafcd6daa829b97d761364bc71ea7803d1df1dd6","contributionContentSha256":"5c2197c949fd370165787b7afdbb9d79319bc1d8a7378062df28a5fae01a9cf5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:13fff5545063255f2448c6dfee410e9df4c329abe8319bf87872deb125a9fcec","textSha256":"c84b856f5654444b26cccafdea05c56f4f078d2b5178f0790ed3fdd10c8e51f6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:83ebad01285605125265340a","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Threshold-generated enhancement and consequential subleading modulations remain separate targets.","challengeNote":"Threshold-generated enhancement and consequential subleading modulations remain distinct targets for reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:e163f9233750831cb88e35aa05ec7de30973d42424819d9c121f1ac3b85e9e71","home":{"unitId":"unit:e163f9233750831cb88e35aa05ec7de30973d42424819d9c121f1ac3b85e9e71","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:578a592e996db0ed70b6e2b8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers higher-dimensional potential construction for inflation, including the illustrative string-inspired supersymmetry-breaking setting and its small-field, small-decay-constant target.","qualification":"q0 covers the higher-dimensional origin of the multi-sinusoidal potential and its intended small-field inflationary use in the illustrative supersymmetry-breaking construction. Small excursion, small decay constant and completed string realization remain distinct notions.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e163f9233750831cb88e35aa05ec7de30973d42424819d9c121f1ac3b85e9e71","textSha256":"ce2fef31dc443e1e0e738a56eb4dc0afa73d98d9e50e646e7f972ba31ffdcb3e"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u23:q0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u23:q0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e163f9233750831cb88e35aa05ec7de30973d42424819d9c121f1ac3b85e9e71","q025-candidate-question:578a592e996db0ed70b6e2b8"],"scopeContentSha256":"fb49faf8be9264a928d5f5a5b06552ee6be67510339a37bce599a3ef8f0a9f8c","placementContentSha256":"994211ee1b820d3e82dd76315cd3584ed9f8268693abe814f8c82f1415327301","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:coverage:proposal","placement-pilot:coverage:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e163f9233750831cb88e35aa05ec7de30973d42424819d9c121f1ac3b85e9e71","textSha256":"ce2fef31dc443e1e0e738a56eb4dc0afa73d98d9e50e646e7f972ba31ffdcb3e"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:e163f9233750831cb88e35aa05ec7de30973d42424819d9c121f1ac3b85e9e71"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e163f9233750831cb88e35aa05ec7de30973d42424819d9c121f1ac3b85e9e71","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:e163f9233750831cb88e35aa05ec7de30973d42424819d9c121f1ac3b85e9e71","textSha256":"ce2fef31dc443e1e0e738a56eb4dc0afa73d98d9e50e646e7f972ba31ffdcb3e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:67aa81905713ebe570803762","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The construction is explicitly illustrative and string-inspired. Independent challenge qualification: The construction remains illustrative and string-inspired."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:67aa81905713ebe570803762","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e163f9233750831cb88e35aa05ec7de30973d42424819d9c121f1ac3b85e9e71","q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c"],"scopeContentSha256":"5e6c90cc5733aced848abc6aeafcd6daa829b97d761364bc71ea7803d1df1dd6","contributionContentSha256":"7d271f6783ab3433889838ea7d9136172086ad5d8873cf2eb8fce572a1f1c0c5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:e163f9233750831cb88e35aa05ec7de30973d42424819d9c121f1ac3b85e9e71","textSha256":"ce2fef31dc443e1e0e738a56eb4dc0afa73d98d9e50e646e7f972ba31ffdcb3e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:67aa81905713ebe570803762","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"The construction is explicitly illustrative and string-inspired.","challengeNote":"The construction remains illustrative and string-inspired.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"de75ee407273405ac84d29482e31c51cdc13163bb7c775b2039233fb2515749f"},"organizational-access:714daaa49cc79c34cbc31ddb":{"id":"organizational-access:714daaa49cc79c34cbc31ddb","source":"q025-candidate-question:5c35ce6f7bbfa8429002f452","target":"q025-candidate-question:419cd67842fd578d43ef0ac4","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:5c35ce6f7bbfa8429002f452","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"40dbbd5c128b6924b162e9a0e52a036f5e8e9c330a15d4572533043bdfa81f96","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:566c0cf68ccb9c770577f5ad"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:419cd67842fd578d43ef0ac4","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f4dd0c19755b9d1cb7e094b731f173cd25ca64b988662f1b8c064257ef66e779","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0844dd0853b7d4cc70093c10"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:80d28e2aada100f500478b89c2f47312642b416d8f5b43dec2bc7aec07955e3b","home":{"unitId":"unit:80d28e2aada100f500478b89c2f47312642b416d8f5b43dec2bc7aec07955e3b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:5c35ce6f7bbfa8429002f452","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:80d28e2aada100f500478b89c2f47312642b416d8f5b43dec2bc7aec07955e3b","paperId":"1702.02423","textSha256":"9c0302ccc1a45d5267c57bb217d657070458c8b72cbed23298fd7932bec5a399"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:06e4b219ca1cf3a1bc10c1dfaff04589","paperId":"1702.02423","sourceSha256":"233892f99735226564aa615b1585611fe1c2a42de23908a65107a08ecc3736bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/effd351b46c9e47ca428/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39f2f980a8e9e0ee772926b2a5c3ce92e5085176cc51521ddcdd6218cddfef5e","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f98ba2f9ce53c6fd0137a2f5825246ccf1750328fe2fcc7128d3ea5085613547","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:be864f4d395c5be274e418231d2a7cb3","paperId":"1702.02423","sourceSha256":"233892f99735226564aa615b1585611fe1c2a42de23908a65107a08ecc3736bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/effd351b46c9e47ca428/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39f2f980a8e9e0ee772926b2a5c3ce92e5085176cc51521ddcdd6218cddfef5e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1029,"textSha256":"da4c8f6c422fd2f07e741c04560493034260117594beb244ec76029cc4e793e3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dc21282fcc5f6dc8fc6ade3c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dc21282fcc5f6dc8fc6ade3c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:80d28e2aada100f500478b89c2f47312642b416d8f5b43dec2bc7aec07955e3b","q025-candidate-question:5c35ce6f7bbfa8429002f452"],"scopeContentSha256":"40dbbd5c128b6924b162e9a0e52a036f5e8e9c330a15d4572533043bdfa81f96","placementContentSha256":"e7b46a42051288aed3ced73add7d825479ed34936430c8a751d5cb77c4e9825c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b2e631ff674dfe9f6385-challenge","leaf-b2e631ff674dfe9f6385-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:80d28e2aada100f500478b89c2f47312642b416d8f5b43dec2bc7aec07955e3b","paperId":"1702.02423","textSha256":"9c0302ccc1a45d5267c57bb217d657070458c8b72cbed23298fd7932bec5a399"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:06e4b219ca1cf3a1bc10c1dfaff04589","paperId":"1702.02423","sourceSha256":"233892f99735226564aa615b1585611fe1c2a42de23908a65107a08ecc3736bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/effd351b46c9e47ca428/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39f2f980a8e9e0ee772926b2a5c3ce92e5085176cc51521ddcdd6218cddfef5e","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f98ba2f9ce53c6fd0137a2f5825246ccf1750328fe2fcc7128d3ea5085613547","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:be864f4d395c5be274e418231d2a7cb3","paperId":"1702.02423","sourceSha256":"233892f99735226564aa615b1585611fe1c2a42de23908a65107a08ecc3736bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/effd351b46c9e47ca428/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39f2f980a8e9e0ee772926b2a5c3ce92e5085176cc51521ddcdd6218cddfef5e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1029,"textSha256":"da4c8f6c422fd2f07e741c04560493034260117594beb244ec76029cc4e793e3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dc21282fcc5f6dc8fc6ade3c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:80d28e2aada100f500478b89c2f47312642b416d8f5b43dec2bc7aec07955e3b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:419cd67842fd578d43ef0ac4","role":"instantiates","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:80d28e2aada100f500478b89c2f47312642b416d8f5b43dec2bc7aec07955e3b","textSha256":"9c0302ccc1a45d5267c57bb217d657070458c8b72cbed23298fd7932bec5a399"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:06e4b219ca1cf3a1bc10c1dfaff04589","paperId":"1702.02423","sourceSha256":"233892f99735226564aa615b1585611fe1c2a42de23908a65107a08ecc3736bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/effd351b46c9e47ca428/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39f2f980a8e9e0ee772926b2a5c3ce92e5085176cc51521ddcdd6218cddfef5e","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f98ba2f9ce53c6fd0137a2f5825246ccf1750328fe2fcc7128d3ea5085613547","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:be864f4d395c5be274e418231d2a7cb3","paperId":"1702.02423","sourceSha256":"233892f99735226564aa615b1585611fe1c2a42de23908a65107a08ecc3736bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/effd351b46c9e47ca428/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39f2f980a8e9e0ee772926b2a5c3ce92e5085176cc51521ddcdd6218cddfef5e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1029,"textSha256":"da4c8f6c422fd2f07e741c04560493034260117594beb244ec76029cc4e793e3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:75f6e51a166279a5b2d96fe2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:75f6e51a166279a5b2d96fe2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:80d28e2aada100f500478b89c2f47312642b416d8f5b43dec2bc7aec07955e3b","q025-candidate-question:419cd67842fd578d43ef0ac4"],"scopeContentSha256":"f4dd0c19755b9d1cb7e094b731f173cd25ca64b988662f1b8c064257ef66e779","contributionContentSha256":"5f86cb00402bfed275865b1b3de88fd87aaf648c6a9723d9fc6a332463efbf16","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"parent-beb61f1820482cf3ff0f-proposal","challengeReviewId":"parent-beb61f1820482cf3ff0f-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["parent-beb61f1820482cf3ff0f-proposal","parent-beb61f1820482cf3ff0f-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:80d28e2aada100f500478b89c2f47312642b416d8f5b43dec2bc7aec07955e3b","textSha256":"9c0302ccc1a45d5267c57bb217d657070458c8b72cbed23298fd7932bec5a399"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:06e4b219ca1cf3a1bc10c1dfaff04589","paperId":"1702.02423","sourceSha256":"233892f99735226564aa615b1585611fe1c2a42de23908a65107a08ecc3736bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/effd351b46c9e47ca428/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39f2f980a8e9e0ee772926b2a5c3ce92e5085176cc51521ddcdd6218cddfef5e","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f98ba2f9ce53c6fd0137a2f5825246ccf1750328fe2fcc7128d3ea5085613547","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:be864f4d395c5be274e418231d2a7cb3","paperId":"1702.02423","sourceSha256":"233892f99735226564aa615b1585611fe1c2a42de23908a65107a08ecc3736bd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/effd351b46c9e47ca428/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39f2f980a8e9e0ee772926b2a5c3ce92e5085176cc51521ddcdd6218cddfef5e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1029,"textSha256":"da4c8f6c422fd2f07e741c04560493034260117594beb244ec76029cc4e793e3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:75f6e51a166279a5b2d96fe2","recordId":"parent-beb61f1820482cf3ff0f-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"parent-beb61f1820482cf3ff0f-proposal","challengeReviewId":"parent-beb61f1820482cf3ff0f-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"The primary target is an off-shell coupling construction; its de Sitter application is parameter-dependent and does not supply a general stability result.","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ae407f725742b0ab131ee4ed3ae6e424abaf4d34de0967fbccad7e475f6158fa"},"organizational-access:e848c1e0f408f7b2945357de":{"id":"organizational-access:e848c1e0f408f7b2945357de","source":"q025-candidate-question:64d242f010006f3d1a0a3120","target":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:64d242f010006f3d1a0a3120","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6db4338af96093be5bb3a761b43810837e71fd34bbfca731558568f4853ee5ef","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:dafca507ba1939d2aba44091"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:a4b58bf49c3221cb97852968"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:169ab0e21f47349a999eb55a11755da0927b327a7ada710d934bbdf7b442472c","home":{"unitId":"unit:169ab0e21f47349a999eb55a11755da0927b327a7ada710d934bbdf7b442472c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:64d242f010006f3d1a0a3120","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q0 explicitly combines stabilization, hierarchies, supersymmetry breaking and vacuum energy with source-scoped cosmological-viability tests and the 2004 light-modulus distinction.","qualification":"q0 explicitly covers every construction target and includes the separate cosmological-viability test. It retains the one-versus-at-least-two-light-moduli distinction. The intact supplied context reports no complete string model meeting all constraints and an outer-region overshoot problem; neither limitation obstructs placing the open compound question.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:169ab0e21f47349a999eb55a11755da0927b327a7ada710d934bbdf7b442472c","paperId":"hep-th/0402088","textSha256":"5a204e0689d8c7a382137ba748b81d99970bf62e33bb16c2d6e7c0339388dcda"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0004:u28:q0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0004:u28:q0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:169ab0e21f47349a999eb55a11755da0927b327a7ada710d934bbdf7b442472c","q025-candidate-question:64d242f010006f3d1a0a3120"],"scopeContentSha256":"6db4338af96093be5bb3a761b43810837e71fd34bbfca731558568f4853ee5ef","placementContentSha256":"3846ef75bda3760785b95c5f7d69630d8375a2669c54789d6eb7e0f5a2026f14","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0004:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0004:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:169ab0e21f47349a999eb55a11755da0927b327a7ada710d934bbdf7b442472c","paperId":"hep-th/0402088","textSha256":"5a204e0689d8c7a382137ba748b81d99970bf62e33bb16c2d6e7c0339388dcda"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0004","unitRef":"u28"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:169ab0e21f47349a999eb55a11755da0927b327a7ada710d934bbdf7b442472c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d77","kind":"description","unitIndex":77,"unitId":"unit:169ab0e21f47349a999eb55a11755da0927b327a7ada710d934bbdf7b442472c","textSha256":"5a204e0689d8c7a382137ba748b81d99970bf62e33bb16c2d6e7c0339388dcda"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:afaa5c176c01e28446dcc91328e54575","paperId":"hep-th/0402088","sourceSha256":"18e5f429876340d2375691e171ec08d3aa47e6b14d89742ebf3e8e8fe30f88cb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fdb0e61e0d1c1c7ad182/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1aeadd0f0bf5a9dc8e5852ff3a2253c2fe203c0acbd6bda302cb0e2993ff9476","pdfPage":5,"start":100,"end":2496,"textSha256":"9d56291c9983a8c4d7032e311f84469981c683c57d4f0ee5015cc70bc85db203","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cd7ee65e57a6d2e5569a83577d325f62","paperId":"hep-th/0402088","sourceSha256":"18e5f429876340d2375691e171ec08d3aa47e6b14d89742ebf3e8e8fe30f88cb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fdb0e61e0d1c1c7ad182/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1aeadd0f0bf5a9dc8e5852ff3a2253c2fe203c0acbd6bda302cb0e2993ff9476","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2496,"textSha256":"eac7c993460cd32d850db8a8be5e64365306ce1615e45ad0c70351e7f62be4e5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3c32ca9e814ab859fdb085ed"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3c32ca9e814ab859fdb085ed","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:169ab0e21f47349a999eb55a11755da0927b327a7ada710d934bbdf7b442472c","q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0"],"scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","contributionContentSha256":"af2951690566eef8ad9f41d28f0cb50f1e0fe6ea5bbe97d8bc2539f42a4bd949","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d77","kind":"description","unitIndex":77,"unitId":"unit:169ab0e21f47349a999eb55a11755da0927b327a7ada710d934bbdf7b442472c","textSha256":"5a204e0689d8c7a382137ba748b81d99970bf62e33bb16c2d6e7c0339388dcda"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:afaa5c176c01e28446dcc91328e54575","paperId":"hep-th/0402088","sourceSha256":"18e5f429876340d2375691e171ec08d3aa47e6b14d89742ebf3e8e8fe30f88cb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fdb0e61e0d1c1c7ad182/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1aeadd0f0bf5a9dc8e5852ff3a2253c2fe203c0acbd6bda302cb0e2993ff9476","pdfPage":5,"start":100,"end":2496,"textSha256":"9d56291c9983a8c4d7032e311f84469981c683c57d4f0ee5015cc70bc85db203","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cd7ee65e57a6d2e5569a83577d325f62","paperId":"hep-th/0402088","sourceSha256":"18e5f429876340d2375691e171ec08d3aa47e6b14d89742ebf3e8e8fe30f88cb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fdb0e61e0d1c1c7ad182/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1aeadd0f0bf5a9dc8e5852ff3a2253c2fe203c0acbd6bda302cb0e2993ff9476","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2496,"textSha256":"eac7c993460cd32d850db8a8be5e64365306ce1615e45ad0c70351e7f62be4e5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3c32ca9e814ab859fdb085ed","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound construction/viability. Racetrack claims require at least two light moduli for nonnegative broken-SUSY minima; no complete string model is produced; ","challengeNote":"Compound construction/viability. Nonnegative broken-SUSY minima require at least two light moduli in the stated analysis; no complete string model is supplied","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4630ab5451511706d01e8bf19f09146fb775aca6b43c575319693ef807051050"},"organizational-access:1a3f3c3d3168fb3a3ca15dc8":{"id":"organizational-access:1a3f3c3d3168fb3a3ca15dc8","source":"q025-candidate-question:6aaa9013e706aa371167686a","target":"q025-candidate-question:46228dfa113d796ed0b87b17","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6aaa9013e706aa371167686a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b37bdd38e7429b64ac5ab1ee36bfe80c6cf00ecbc2315f9a31855f4333fd8138","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b75d8aa31deef0048bdedea5"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:46228dfa113d796ed0b87b17","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"5a2d158ead6d9de97f148a0f17bd624480c290193a0539966990e2f557bbf500","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:301946cdc3ed0ca5955df889"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","home":{"unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6aaa9013e706aa371167686a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly preserves string-cosmology lectures spanning small vacuum energy, inflation, stabilization, potential obstacles, remedies and signatures.","qualification":"q31 explicitly preserves the complete lecture program: small vacuum energy, inflation, stabilization, potential obstacles, remedies and signatures. Its exclusion of a single fine identity for all lecture topics does not exclude the intact composite survey. q29, q18 and q41 omit the independent small-vacuum-energy inquiry. A cosmic-string signature is only one component. Historical force bounds remain dated, and announced coverage does not verify the reviewed remedies.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","textSha256":"6cc987d9a613796846db12afe3b42ec1d89e3de5e94d6605b6c74b14734a1f0b"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:competing:u7:q31"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:competing:u7:q31","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","q025-candidate-question:6aaa9013e706aa371167686a"],"scopeContentSha256":"b37bdd38e7429b64ac5ab1ee36bfe80c6cf00ecbc2315f9a31855f4333fd8138","placementContentSha256":"2b9defb4f0922fe04c64c6196a6cf6438e0d3c27cae95235c148ff5ed5059c18","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:competing:proposal","placement-pilot:competing:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","textSha256":"6cc987d9a613796846db12afe3b42ec1d89e3de5e94d6605b6c74b14734a1f0b"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:46228dfa113d796ed0b87b17","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","textSha256":"6cc987d9a613796846db12afe3b42ec1d89e3de5e94d6605b6c74b14734a1f0b"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:479709da7b0565762ae80098e8872263","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":15,"start":0,"end":2393,"textSha256":"d418ffc8c05e0bbae1cf077f9e2d94112db012340a54a83a5779743616202eca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:62f49ee8e8a82ce94588f3b1f2ab2f95","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":796,"textSha256":"54e81229f435c7cea300f012cc56902556fc702f6f63cd4d1da53452403899f7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:97564ff6e8f39bb975ed1d2ce35c5879","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1721,"textSha256":"6851be5b22ec413c1d1bc9adc047e842297468a22d3ec9cd9dd7c30403d7638a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:688a9f6125bae1a9d379cc35"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:688a9f6125bae1a9d379cc35","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","q025-candidate-question:46228dfa113d796ed0b87b17"],"scopeContentSha256":"5a2d158ead6d9de97f148a0f17bd624480c290193a0539966990e2f557bbf500","contributionContentSha256":"3293644f8e5b572f89ff66cd5844b046ed8cc64898d2ada2770161180eaf4567","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","textSha256":"6cc987d9a613796846db12afe3b42ec1d89e3de5e94d6605b6c74b14734a1f0b"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:479709da7b0565762ae80098e8872263","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":15,"start":0,"end":2393,"textSha256":"d418ffc8c05e0bbae1cf077f9e2d94112db012340a54a83a5779743616202eca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:62f49ee8e8a82ce94588f3b1f2ab2f95","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":796,"textSha256":"54e81229f435c7cea300f012cc56902556fc702f6f63cd4d1da53452403899f7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:97564ff6e8f39bb975ed1d2ce35c5879","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1721,"textSha256":"6851be5b22ec413c1d1bc9adc047e842297468a22d3ec9cd9dd7c30403d7638a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:688a9f6125bae1a9d379cc35","recordId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"The lecture survey spans vacuum energy, stabilization and multiple inflation mechanisms; its compound scope requires finer reconciliation.","challengeNote":"The survey spans vacuum energy, stabilization and multiple inflation mechanisms; finer identity remains unresolved. Lecture-era force bounds are dated context.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"17e19c197d772d134ab5aa4814742d99b4bbb1613a5e30781581c24378e2735c"},"organizational-access:a593c0ae25ba738550f643ee":{"id":"organizational-access:a593c0ae25ba738550f643ee","source":"q025-candidate-question:6b099a72fa61aa622880dfa2","target":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6b099a72fa61aa622880dfa2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"24db97dc82d9b7e926b5b22c624c1591c5d8fd94caf62cc41348d2bbb50e6ab2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ab088afeec803d9cd272cf27"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ccd5e77a867e82ef7825199cd2d2c893840dc9ae3a8e87e1462a81ac1aa99d41","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:statistics:pq0"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","home":{"unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6b099a72fa61aa622880dfa2","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","paperId":"1812.04147","textSha256":"79093b923c07e9d3c57bd1d4f83b5ccdaa90f10630a9f3abd967575c6f30a64c"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9acaec5c0e653c89b0a3ef7432d4b783","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"15ed8868bb10683405878235928c821c92c1d85fd1708e9a2ee6e705ff6bf161","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f54ba78c46dede1a602bc9ae77ffce85","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":1293,"end":4693,"textSha256":"404f190296444d7c2a164706fd626c80a36fcaaf36d767eaea468f46a1eda1d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e27","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ffe5b5d3589c87c44231377111d83fa6","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":2494,"end":5251,"textSha256":"7db530de1ec75dd0da2ed39ae1e90d410ec5bc0be738f16d124db9484263a30d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6028a363351de2049d83ef75"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6028a363351de2049d83ef75","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","q025-candidate-question:6b099a72fa61aa622880dfa2"],"scopeContentSha256":"24db97dc82d9b7e926b5b22c624c1591c5d8fd94caf62cc41348d2bbb50e6ab2","placementContentSha256":"f9e65aa912ce395c04082cf9bbfc9debf8653fc356f034b3d23d46f607548bd5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","paperId":"1812.04147","textSha256":"79093b923c07e9d3c57bd1d4f83b5ccdaa90f10630a9f3abd967575c6f30a64c"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9acaec5c0e653c89b0a3ef7432d4b783","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"15ed8868bb10683405878235928c821c92c1d85fd1708e9a2ee6e705ff6bf161","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f54ba78c46dede1a602bc9ae77ffce85","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":1293,"end":4693,"textSha256":"404f190296444d7c2a164706fd626c80a36fcaaf36d767eaea468f46a1eda1d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e27","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ffe5b5d3589c87c44231377111d83fa6","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":2494,"end":5251,"textSha256":"7db530de1ec75dd0da2ed39ae1e90d410ec5bc0be738f16d124db9484263a30d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6028a363351de2049d83ef75"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","paperId":"1812.04147","textSha256":"79093b923c07e9d3c57bd1d4f83b5ccdaa90f10630a9f3abd967575c6f30a64c"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9acaec5c0e653c89b0a3ef7432d4b783","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"15ed8868bb10683405878235928c821c92c1d85fd1708e9a2ee6e705ff6bf161","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f54ba78c46dede1a602bc9ae77ffce85","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":1293,"end":4693,"textSha256":"404f190296444d7c2a164706fd626c80a36fcaaf36d767eaea468f46a1eda1d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ffe5b5d3589c87c44231377111d83fa6","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":2494,"end":5251,"textSha256":"7db530de1ec75dd0da2ed39ae1e90d410ec5bc0be738f16d124db9484263a30d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"qualification":"The primary abstract and introduction discuss localized backreaction and weak-coupling and curvature criteria. They report a construction and leave its string fate dependent on corrections; this role does not adjudicate the separate O8 boundary-condition objection.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z3"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02"],"scopeContentSha256":"ccd5e77a867e82ef7825199cd2d2c893840dc9ae3a8e87e1462a81ac1aa99d41","contributionContentSha256":"dd8b75814216a9b073e488814bc1a8845ae8e0bc0849b327ad3d4744ee7a29a5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation"},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","statistics-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u15","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","paperId":"1812.04147","textSha256":"79093b923c07e9d3c57bd1d4f83b5ccdaa90f10630a9f3abd967575c6f30a64c"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9acaec5c0e653c89b0a3ef7432d4b783","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"15ed8868bb10683405878235928c821c92c1d85fd1708e9a2ee6e705ff6bf161","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f54ba78c46dede1a602bc9ae77ffce85","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":1293,"end":4693,"textSha256":"404f190296444d7c2a164706fd626c80a36fcaaf36d767eaea468f46a1eda1d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ffe5b5d3589c87c44231377111d83fa6","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":2494,"end":5251,"textSha256":"7db530de1ec75dd0da2ed39ae1e90d410ec5bc0be738f16d124db9484263a30d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"explicitConfirmation":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z3","family":"statistics","originalRowId":"z3","oldRole":{"id":"z3","unitRef":"u15","questionRef":"pq0","role":"addresses","reason":"The primary abstract and introduction discuss localized backreaction and weak-coupling and curvature criteria. They report a construction and leave its string fate dependent on corrections; this role does not adjudicate the separate O8 boundary-condition objection.","refs":["u15","e4","e7","e8"]},"confirmation":{"id":"z3","verdict":"supported_as_written","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":[],"reason":"The supplied construction abstract and introduction directly discuss localized backreaction and classical validity, while retaining quantum-dependent string fate and the separate source-matching dispute.","refs":["u15","pq0","e4","e7","e8"]},"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation","qualificationUnchanged":true}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ea5894d555686f55c093f89de194777abe1e6d0b20fa56a6e48913bf93168a3d"},"organizational-access:37b5b69c9d670b494d295e86":{"id":"organizational-access:37b5b69c9d670b494d295e86","source":"q025-candidate-question:7132aa4b2be087f7baa4cbe6","target":"q025-candidate-question:00dfce58b4c82e0607ac72a0","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:7132aa4b2be087f7baa4cbe6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"3ea4723661232e9769b43fd1ad6f46816db92fe1e5f7a293832e9fb9ebd40b11","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:85a990fe6700c824bc1ff86b"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:00dfce58b4c82e0607ac72a0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"81b6dd15db2bfc812d0a0d159a1b78b69c4dcd99224afd115a1425155d8db612","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:22d32cca378bc8ccd7ef0c65"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","home":{"unitId":"unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7132aa4b2be087f7baa4cbe6","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines continuous-parameter restrictions, imported moduli conjectures, distance/tower questions and conditional loop explanations.","qualification":"q10 explicitly combines parameter restrictions, imported moduli conjectures, distance constraints and conditional loop explanations. This covers the whole question without using conditional exponential scaling to establish tower existence or every imported geometric claim. Finite-path turnover, lower-cutoff EFTs and UV input for an axion potential retain their separate inherited qualifications.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","paperId":"1802.08698","textSha256":"6d186b16f6faf92d51c8633122b7da8036ab122b648780b9a3da2bac71087fe1"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0034:u13:q10"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0034:u13:q10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","q025-candidate-question:7132aa4b2be087f7baa4cbe6"],"scopeContentSha256":"3ea4723661232e9769b43fd1ad6f46816db92fe1e5f7a293832e9fb9ebd40b11","placementContentSha256":"f5284e85f2c72706be0ff40da3715d0f0ecb5466144b19a85e69c9128eefbd47","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0034:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0034:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","paperId":"1802.08698","textSha256":"6d186b16f6faf92d51c8633122b7da8036ab122b648780b9a3da2bac71087fe1"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0034","unitRef":"u13"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:00dfce58b4c82e0607ac72a0","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","textSha256":"6d186b16f6faf92d51c8633122b7da8036ab122b648780b9a3da2bac71087fe1"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:085bb3e25637c349cc918d95dccfe03c","paperId":"1802.08698","sourceSha256":"cfa54c1c9eb0267263c0f7e70c18de6c5295128b2c350e1d18c829a0333133e4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6816cb8f1f73044e671f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ca37441de198d36e4ee778ea39a98afcd0e6082f51c373aa6876ecec0a423f8","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"994baeb97b27bd7dd2a87f14ce43d95b57262d4ba6beb90520c5b7a7f7777f10","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:53c4bc6b0064e1b16015a1053c3a37b1","paperId":"1802.08698","sourceSha256":"cfa54c1c9eb0267263c0f7e70c18de6c5295128b2c350e1d18c829a0333133e4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6816cb8f1f73044e671f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ca37441de198d36e4ee778ea39a98afcd0e6082f51c373aa6876ecec0a423f8","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"3c28963bf0aad100960de09262888f7982141e6a54fb3c991d67f2bc51bc1dc7","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:59b9dc80224cc127aa26eefcf329eb74","paperId":"1802.08698","sourceSha256":"cfa54c1c9eb0267263c0f7e70c18de6c5295128b2c350e1d18c829a0333133e4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6816cb8f1f73044e671f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ca37441de198d36e4ee778ea39a98afcd0e6082f51c373aa6876ecec0a423f8","pdfPage":4,"start":2256,"end":4836,"textSha256":"081c1a6329678416b66fb50d1c89e77d356981bbb81d71ba827ca1a7b764eae1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e1fa8c2306b5e5e4a3c77b38","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound imported conjectures are retained as source-scoped access; the conditional exponential-scaling calculation does not prove every imported assertion. Independent challenge qualification: Source-scoped singleton retains compound imported conjectures. Conditional exponential scaling does not establish tower existence or every moduli-space claim."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e1fa8c2306b5e5e4a3c77b38","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","q025-candidate-question:00dfce58b4c82e0607ac72a0"],"scopeContentSha256":"81b6dd15db2bfc812d0a0d159a1b78b69c4dcd99224afd115a1425155d8db612","contributionContentSha256":"83402d65aeb0b2915814ebd1adb67118273556952f0d25f23661de1c10cffb33","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","textSha256":"6d186b16f6faf92d51c8633122b7da8036ab122b648780b9a3da2bac71087fe1"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:085bb3e25637c349cc918d95dccfe03c","paperId":"1802.08698","sourceSha256":"cfa54c1c9eb0267263c0f7e70c18de6c5295128b2c350e1d18c829a0333133e4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6816cb8f1f73044e671f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ca37441de198d36e4ee778ea39a98afcd0e6082f51c373aa6876ecec0a423f8","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"994baeb97b27bd7dd2a87f14ce43d95b57262d4ba6beb90520c5b7a7f7777f10","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:53c4bc6b0064e1b16015a1053c3a37b1","paperId":"1802.08698","sourceSha256":"cfa54c1c9eb0267263c0f7e70c18de6c5295128b2c350e1d18c829a0333133e4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6816cb8f1f73044e671f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ca37441de198d36e4ee778ea39a98afcd0e6082f51c373aa6876ecec0a423f8","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"3c28963bf0aad100960de09262888f7982141e6a54fb3c991d67f2bc51bc1dc7","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:59b9dc80224cc127aa26eefcf329eb74","paperId":"1802.08698","sourceSha256":"cfa54c1c9eb0267263c0f7e70c18de6c5295128b2c350e1d18c829a0333133e4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6816cb8f1f73044e671f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ca37441de198d36e4ee778ea39a98afcd0e6082f51c373aa6876ecec0a423f8","pdfPage":4,"start":2256,"end":4836,"textSha256":"081c1a6329678416b66fb50d1c89e77d356981bbb81d71ba827ca1a7b764eae1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e1fa8c2306b5e5e4a3c77b38","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound imported conjectures are retained as source-scoped access; the conditional exponential-scaling calculation does not prove every imported assertion.","challengeNote":"Source-scoped singleton retains compound imported conjectures. Conditional exponential scaling does not establish tower existence or every moduli-space claim.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"7411e13dffacf2bd46b718ee987aa0b064934b6329273f07287475cb638593d8"},"organizational-access:8da3c67086f056436bbaac25":{"id":"organizational-access:8da3c67086f056436bbaac25","source":"q025-candidate-question:79af33e2c6c3ace19ae14365","target":"q025-candidate-question:72d41d3456dd196085af10c9","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:79af33e2c6c3ace19ae14365","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"8c53ab286822ec7f0f1795cee8cb7fc8f4a32ebd0c4c0c6f660243a9b21835cb","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:mediation:pq2"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:72d41d3456dd196085af10c9","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"711d90fcf40465662a97cdea612498e6397859ad64ec3e7815f14cbe73918345","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0bfbf694c40101e89329c65b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:b02dd5da03e89341008454d102255db0844b4a1d44b6bee2aa18a2d4881ac3ae","home":{"unitId":"unit:b02dd5da03e89341008454d102255db0844b4a1d44b6bee2aa18a2d4881ac3ae","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:79af33e2c6c3ace19ae14365","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Specifically covers fluxless G2 strong-gauge-dynamics models and explicitly includes the linked stabilization, hierarchy-generation and resulting soft-spectrum question.","qualification":"q17 is specific to G2 dynamics and expressly includes the linked stabilization, hierarchy-generation and spectrum question. Its inclusion makes it a whole-source home, not merely a destination for the final spectrum clause. Strong gauge dynamics remains selected over the acknowledged membrane-instanton alternative; source-specific hidden-sector and Kähler restrictions are preserved.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b02dd5da03e89341008454d102255db0844b4a1d44b6bee2aa18a2d4881ac3ae","paperId":"hep-th/0606262","textSha256":"16c2614b90ac16576c02689bf87f7719dea093463eb52d56b61af57a295d75d8"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0042:u17:q17"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0042:u17:q17","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b02dd5da03e89341008454d102255db0844b4a1d44b6bee2aa18a2d4881ac3ae","q025-candidate-question:79af33e2c6c3ace19ae14365"],"scopeContentSha256":"8c53ab286822ec7f0f1795cee8cb7fc8f4a32ebd0c4c0c6f660243a9b21835cb","placementContentSha256":"ffce9575b2220b0d233f14800a523a74c553d591f281f5c2e58922c27277c089","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0042:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0042:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b02dd5da03e89341008454d102255db0844b4a1d44b6bee2aa18a2d4881ac3ae","paperId":"hep-th/0606262","textSha256":"16c2614b90ac16576c02689bf87f7719dea093463eb52d56b61af57a295d75d8"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0042","unitRef":"u17"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b02dd5da03e89341008454d102255db0844b4a1d44b6bee2aa18a2d4881ac3ae","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72d41d3456dd196085af10c9","role":"instantiates","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:b02dd5da03e89341008454d102255db0844b4a1d44b6bee2aa18a2d4881ac3ae","textSha256":"16c2614b90ac16576c02689bf87f7719dea093463eb52d56b61af57a295d75d8"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6436d33d19b4edf80dfea7679692953d","paperId":"hep-th/0606262","sourceSha256":"c58b9f4969562a01d6975299dd9fe4f105ad9cbf62b8bba0d977de1cc13e6a34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/96aafcbfd3e31dc01609/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9d2f26cab7c6f6393cab1131da4f0b61d0751355e726ce35c2287420931b7bdb","pdfPage":1,"start":2489,"end":5293,"textSha256":"23db2db9c60c90df0af38dda138eaf37ea38494231f9ed027cf34da173b59a91","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:db724bc5e97103dfa321316ae76176b4","paperId":"hep-th/0606262","sourceSha256":"c58b9f4969562a01d6975299dd9fe4f105ad9cbf62b8bba0d977de1cc13e6a34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/96aafcbfd3e31dc01609/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9d2f26cab7c6f6393cab1131da4f0b61d0751355e726ce35c2287420931b7bdb","pdfPage":1,"start":3689,"end":5293,"textSha256":"810d08594eda6f76fc9674a6482cf421191d689128b068625815d38a9eacb8da","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:36762e4c834a5dce4598438f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:36762e4c834a5dce4598438f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b02dd5da03e89341008454d102255db0844b4a1d44b6bee2aa18a2d4881ac3ae","q025-candidate-question:72d41d3456dd196085af10c9"],"scopeContentSha256":"711d90fcf40465662a97cdea612498e6397859ad64ec3e7815f14cbe73918345","contributionContentSha256":"90cb938ee9343bfe5081960f1a97b19f3d6ff8576d79574099af7254d8918619","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0594a24f01f9b493cef4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0594a24f01f9b493cef4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0594a24f01f9b493cef4-proposal","leaf-0594a24f01f9b493cef4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:b02dd5da03e89341008454d102255db0844b4a1d44b6bee2aa18a2d4881ac3ae","textSha256":"16c2614b90ac16576c02689bf87f7719dea093463eb52d56b61af57a295d75d8"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6436d33d19b4edf80dfea7679692953d","paperId":"hep-th/0606262","sourceSha256":"c58b9f4969562a01d6975299dd9fe4f105ad9cbf62b8bba0d977de1cc13e6a34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/96aafcbfd3e31dc01609/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9d2f26cab7c6f6393cab1131da4f0b61d0751355e726ce35c2287420931b7bdb","pdfPage":1,"start":2489,"end":5293,"textSha256":"23db2db9c60c90df0af38dda138eaf37ea38494231f9ed027cf34da173b59a91","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:db724bc5e97103dfa321316ae76176b4","paperId":"hep-th/0606262","sourceSha256":"c58b9f4969562a01d6975299dd9fe4f105ad9cbf62b8bba0d977de1cc13e6a34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/96aafcbfd3e31dc01609/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9d2f26cab7c6f6393cab1131da4f0b61d0751355e726ce35c2287420931b7bdb","pdfPage":1,"start":3689,"end":5293,"textSha256":"810d08594eda6f76fc9674a6482cf421191d689128b068625815d38a9eacb8da","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:36762e4c834a5dce4598438f","recordId":"leaf-0594a24f01f9b493cef4-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0594a24f01f9b493cef4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0594a24f01f9b493cef4-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Stabilization/hierarchy and resulting soft terms remain linked targets. The supplied analysis explicitly restricts attention to gauge dynamics rather than memb","challengeNote":"Gauge-dynamics-only analysis; stabilization/hierarchy and resulting soft spectra remain linked targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"9b87b8a499ef1b02038fcc775b1d8d783be63f53a37d944a504dcf761a5b9a2c"},"organizational-access:6b3592ae3ef77b7e69e24db1":{"id":"organizational-access:6b3592ae3ef77b7e69e24db1","source":"q025-candidate-question:81f470a0ac410fac14afee7a","target":"q025-candidate-question:01dd0b3ca11d7552d2ad4622","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:81f470a0ac410fac14afee7a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a157a81bf26d977aa43cebe007260603f8c5a03060afcaed9fcc124c5cc3e141","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:671962b853a1f749b89b2493"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:01dd0b3ca11d7552d2ad4622","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"701e23f7ccc02c9ed404941dd6e09fa5aa639e8c1c59fa2ee1c242e4977c0d8a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:82d9d01190c0fed3dd358543"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:6e67a057c1775468c835b3768de59813f248cb325e29578e87a6bd18a670ed51","home":{"unitId":"unit:6e67a057c1775468c835b3768de59813f248cb325e29578e87a6bd18a670ed51","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:81f470a0ac410fac14afee7a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Combines gamma-ray background inference, propagation modifications and modelling uncertainties, including photon–ALP alternatives.","qualification":"q10 covers all three propagation-inference targets and the observational/modelling limitations. The ALP scope alone would omit background-light and Lorentz-invariance inference.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6e67a057c1775468c835b3768de59813f248cb325e29578e87a6bd18a670ed51","paperId":"1602.06825","textSha256":"cbc9addc083917081c67c6215f672c05031702717bd5b9b81bd7d202ddfecebf"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0020:u10:q10"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0020:u10:q10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6e67a057c1775468c835b3768de59813f248cb325e29578e87a6bd18a670ed51","q025-candidate-question:81f470a0ac410fac14afee7a"],"scopeContentSha256":"a157a81bf26d977aa43cebe007260603f8c5a03060afcaed9fcc124c5cc3e141","placementContentSha256":"e6e971c8529cfc4d3cf052c4b87ac9f6efc059a1f6d891927e090952e8a96405","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0020:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0020:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6e67a057c1775468c835b3768de59813f248cb325e29578e87a6bd18a670ed51","paperId":"1602.06825","textSha256":"cbc9addc083917081c67c6215f672c05031702717bd5b9b81bd7d202ddfecebf"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0020","unitRef":"u10"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:6e67a057c1775468c835b3768de59813f248cb325e29578e87a6bd18a670ed51","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:01dd0b3ca11d7552d2ad4622","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:6e67a057c1775468c835b3768de59813f248cb325e29578e87a6bd18a670ed51","textSha256":"cbc9addc083917081c67c6215f672c05031702717bd5b9b81bd7d202ddfecebf"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:88a5177ddf2e8c6f7ab6e7c0","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound background-light, Lorentz-invariance and photon–ALP targets. Independent challenge qualification: Compound background-light, Lorentz-invariance and photon–ALP targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:88a5177ddf2e8c6f7ab6e7c0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6e67a057c1775468c835b3768de59813f248cb325e29578e87a6bd18a670ed51","q025-candidate-question:01dd0b3ca11d7552d2ad4622"],"scopeContentSha256":"701e23f7ccc02c9ed404941dd6e09fa5aa639e8c1c59fa2ee1c242e4977c0d8a","contributionContentSha256":"1d63d4226bb4627b58caf87cc28c5f691545914a03efc76ae4d48b7048c37779","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:6e67a057c1775468c835b3768de59813f248cb325e29578e87a6bd18a670ed51","textSha256":"cbc9addc083917081c67c6215f672c05031702717bd5b9b81bd7d202ddfecebf"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:88a5177ddf2e8c6f7ab6e7c0","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound background-light, Lorentz-invariance and photon–ALP targets.","challengeNote":"Compound background-light, Lorentz-invariance and photon–ALP targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b1791e363f5bc022f78eac5dc5fa84301f00499da68bdd36cf9ef5da9f0a9497","home":{"unitId":"unit:b1791e363f5bc022f78eac5dc5fa84301f00499da68bdd36cf9ef5da9f0a9497","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:81f470a0ac410fac14afee7a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers gamma-ray propagation, background light and related cosmological inference, intergalactic environments and new propagation interactions.","qualification":"q10's background-related cosmological inference covers light, star formation and distance; its propagation and intergalactic coverage includes magnetism, ALP coupling and Lorentz-invariance tests. These remain distinct inferences within one home.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b1791e363f5bc022f78eac5dc5fa84301f00499da68bdd36cf9ef5da9f0a9497","paperId":"2202.00523","textSha256":"c136c1cf885c373e530fa42c214dba344bd671df8ff169c48f402843d6b21ac0"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0020:u11:q10"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0020:u11:q10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b1791e363f5bc022f78eac5dc5fa84301f00499da68bdd36cf9ef5da9f0a9497","q025-candidate-question:81f470a0ac410fac14afee7a"],"scopeContentSha256":"a157a81bf26d977aa43cebe007260603f8c5a03060afcaed9fcc124c5cc3e141","placementContentSha256":"ad02340e6d9e7a7c2d5967d40886252aa1bbe07b704e5d213b08eaa37f23ebdd","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0020:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0020:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b1791e363f5bc022f78eac5dc5fa84301f00499da68bdd36cf9ef5da9f0a9497","paperId":"2202.00523","textSha256":"c136c1cf885c373e530fa42c214dba344bd671df8ff169c48f402843d6b21ac0"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0020","unitRef":"u11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b1791e363f5bc022f78eac5dc5fa84301f00499da68bdd36cf9ef5da9f0a9497","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:01dd0b3ca11d7552d2ad4622","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:b1791e363f5bc022f78eac5dc5fa84301f00499da68bdd36cf9ef5da9f0a9497","textSha256":"c136c1cf885c373e530fa42c214dba344bd671df8ff169c48f402843d6b21ac0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:32a9af45c9cee6dc485eaed5","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound cosmic-background, distance-scale, magnetism, ALP and Lorentz-invariance targets. Independent challenge qualification: Compound background, star-formation, distance, magnetism, ALP and Lorentz-invariance targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:32a9af45c9cee6dc485eaed5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b1791e363f5bc022f78eac5dc5fa84301f00499da68bdd36cf9ef5da9f0a9497","q025-candidate-question:01dd0b3ca11d7552d2ad4622"],"scopeContentSha256":"701e23f7ccc02c9ed404941dd6e09fa5aa639e8c1c59fa2ee1c242e4977c0d8a","contributionContentSha256":"230f5c53ba24c02a4f0f9fcadd433a74951de1554c43c180af1f4a774d1ddd36","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:b1791e363f5bc022f78eac5dc5fa84301f00499da68bdd36cf9ef5da9f0a9497","textSha256":"c136c1cf885c373e530fa42c214dba344bd671df8ff169c48f402843d6b21ac0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:32a9af45c9cee6dc485eaed5","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound cosmic-background, distance-scale, magnetism, ALP and Lorentz-invariance targets.","challengeNote":"Compound background, star-formation, distance, magnetism, ALP and Lorentz-invariance targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"30adc47ef805a561df3b78c6147932e1054e906406826697fa6f01b35e20aac4"},"organizational-access:d0441d57f1453caa340f3fac":{"id":"organizational-access:d0441d57f1453caa340f3fac","source":"q025-candidate-question:82487b8cbf0848b5967846bd","target":"q025-candidate-question:c26ada1ecace15deb97fbeca","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:82487b8cbf0848b5967846bd","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7fa8cd8d9bbf2124faa0e7040d2c681f3ae38bf88f5bff724a999b7c7dbea9f3","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:041d7d0c359b7155b0ac78cb"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c26ada1ecace15deb97fbeca","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"2afe795f1566a1964e8e3e915bf1b68bd41988fb913f84b31209afb1549ad995","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:af7defc56f80165f640f28ed"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:62a31b86ebf537505fcc37d86e63113dd46c26f4034c35d993914335af66c33b","home":{"unitId":"unit:62a31b86ebf537505fcc37d86e63113dd46c26f4034c35d993914335af66c33b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:82487b8cbf0848b5967846bd","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Includes anomaly-required chiral fermions, dark-sector lifetimes and explicit connections to compactified-vacuum questions.","qualification":"q13 expressly includes anomaly-required fermions and connections between dark-sector properties and compactified-vacuum questions. This covers the ultralight fermion's AdS-removal role as part of the linked construction, while preserving its distinction from the long-lived dark-matter particle.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:62a31b86ebf537505fcc37d86e63113dd46c26f4034c35d993914335af66c33b","paperId":"1811.01755","textSha256":"51dc8ba50d29c2deb51dfaaa274a026b979fd488d4c17ec045710abfbeb30a10"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0049:u8:q13"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0049:u8:q13","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:62a31b86ebf537505fcc37d86e63113dd46c26f4034c35d993914335af66c33b","q025-candidate-question:82487b8cbf0848b5967846bd"],"scopeContentSha256":"7fa8cd8d9bbf2124faa0e7040d2c681f3ae38bf88f5bff724a999b7c7dbea9f3","placementContentSha256":"36930c8d7c4f75e96263c9c796536b14381ba7027f03368ee17106a637007541","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0049:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0049:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:62a31b86ebf537505fcc37d86e63113dd46c26f4034c35d993914335af66c33b","paperId":"1811.01755","textSha256":"51dc8ba50d29c2deb51dfaaa274a026b979fd488d4c17ec045710abfbeb30a10"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0049","unitRef":"u8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:62a31b86ebf537505fcc37d86e63113dd46c26f4034c35d993914335af66c33b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c26ada1ecace15deb97fbeca","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:62a31b86ebf537505fcc37d86e63113dd46c26f4034c35d993914335af66c33b","textSha256":"51dc8ba50d29c2deb51dfaaa274a026b979fd488d4c17ec045710abfbeb30a10"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4b9304fac45dbf23d9bb7a55","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound dark-matter and compactified-vacuum targets; no named conjecture is inferred from AdS-minimum removal. Independent challenge qualification: Dark-particle longevity and compactified-vacuum removal are compound targets; no named conjecture follows from the latter alone."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4b9304fac45dbf23d9bb7a55","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:62a31b86ebf537505fcc37d86e63113dd46c26f4034c35d993914335af66c33b","q025-candidate-question:c26ada1ecace15deb97fbeca"],"scopeContentSha256":"2afe795f1566a1964e8e3e915bf1b68bd41988fb913f84b31209afb1549ad995","contributionContentSha256":"eab7be553e43aaacdd0ad42585f86abf1085edeb7c103eef256f240143adbb9e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:62a31b86ebf537505fcc37d86e63113dd46c26f4034c35d993914335af66c33b","textSha256":"51dc8ba50d29c2deb51dfaaa274a026b979fd488d4c17ec045710abfbeb30a10"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4b9304fac45dbf23d9bb7a55","recordId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound dark-matter and compactified-vacuum targets; no named conjecture is inferred from AdS-minimum removal.","challengeNote":"Dark-particle longevity and compactified-vacuum removal are compound targets; no named conjecture follows from the latter alone.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"2af369d1c817fc76d8c0e4c90fabffbcc2e0e13e08a87eba95fc45a613a87b5e"},"organizational-access:8caa2b081b0020c90a80404e":{"id":"organizational-access:8caa2b081b0020c90a80404e","source":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","target":"q025-candidate-question:9995aa7eccdc7b058b671a36","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1e56d8ed3c0ddff03060b195"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9995aa7eccdc7b058b671a36","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f662ac1ec11148ea5d2725b7c54597f35b6efaab8366209403afbba5b2790640","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:58c1b3c5990298da3e97b0bd"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:be84db276052807740116351027e22e1b16f571478735b04e58ab589edd9c8e6","home":{"unitId":"unit:be84db276052807740116351027e22e1b16f571478735b04e58ab589edd9c8e6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers proposed species thermodynamics, particle-tower entropy and black hole–tower correspondence.","qualification":"The current q4 definition jointly admits species thermodynamics, restrictions on towers and the black hole–tower correspondence. It therefore covers every target, including the parametric level of the Schwarzschild entropy comparison. Neither exact normalization nor a common microscopic state space is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:be84db276052807740116351027e22e1b16f571478735b04e58ab589edd9c8e6","paperId":"2406.17851","textSha256":"cb01558d6ad8332af1562e5708a8e88fe9732a020661f7cafd0d5e9ea2464704"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0021:u4:q4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0021:u4:q4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:be84db276052807740116351027e22e1b16f571478735b04e58ab589edd9c8e6","q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","placementContentSha256":"a6a5f1037124a07647e871c5661348596bc797b12cc83fb5e2c8433ed34e0447","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0021:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0021:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:be84db276052807740116351027e22e1b16f571478735b04e58ab589edd9c8e6","paperId":"2406.17851","textSha256":"cb01558d6ad8332af1562e5708a8e88fe9732a020661f7cafd0d5e9ea2464704"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0021","unitRef":"u4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:be84db276052807740116351027e22e1b16f571478735b04e58ab589edd9c8e6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9995aa7eccdc7b058b671a36","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d56","kind":"description","unitIndex":56,"unitId":"unit:be84db276052807740116351027e22e1b16f571478735b04e58ab589edd9c8e6","textSha256":"cb01558d6ad8332af1562e5708a8e88fe9732a020661f7cafd0d5e9ea2464704"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:067c830cfd34b4050cb1b5c47306de42","paperId":"2406.17851","sourceSha256":"6862a936aa0cb43094aa1365c6b8b76070e2c067dc74b83fe2bbd69ae35be438","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b0d061e98b62cbec5eee/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"036c2ae22c820c836ddf2b5d3fb18497ff08642e3eb5fce96182c7794bfa1bc7","pdfPage":51,"start":1293,"end":3293,"textSha256":"59a5554642a807d50bbbff317c889ea102f1b677ade5ebcc048a4499a000e4a6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6665e2cfe236a9e99d1667d41ef8dcef","paperId":"2406.17851","sourceSha256":"6862a936aa0cb43094aa1365c6b8b76070e2c067dc74b83fe2bbd69ae35be438","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b0d061e98b62cbec5eee/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"036c2ae22c820c836ddf2b5d3fb18497ff08642e3eb5fce96182c7794bfa1bc7","pdfPage":49,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"01d8b838b6338408bc86dfb427deb5203f47c1c9f6981e6385fd00003055a415","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b7d90f56f960ff1e6f61a1db17d8110f","paperId":"2406.17851","sourceSha256":"6862a936aa0cb43094aa1365c6b8b76070e2c067dc74b83fe2bbd69ae35be438","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b0d061e98b62cbec5eee/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"036c2ae22c820c836ddf2b5d3fb18497ff08642e3eb5fce96182c7794bfa1bc7","pdfPage":51,"start":98,"end":3293,"textSha256":"73e942bac9f4875941a1c45114e6a7ca654967657f8804e158be03695dfc6241","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ed9f1188ac0b4652b1028fab","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound constitutive relations, admissible towers and parametric correspondence. Fixed/sub-polynomial towers generally fail the stated scaling test, with an mt Independent challenge qualification: Compound constitutive, tower-selection and correspondence targets. Fixed-mass/sub-polynomial towers fail simultaneous scaling except at mt≈Λsp. Corresponden​"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ed9f1188ac0b4652b1028fab","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:be84db276052807740116351027e22e1b16f571478735b04e58ab589edd9c8e6","q025-candidate-question:9995aa7eccdc7b058b671a36"],"scopeContentSha256":"f662ac1ec11148ea5d2725b7c54597f35b6efaab8366209403afbba5b2790640","contributionContentSha256":"c3beac1cd982d981c51837e5dcb675ac80f72ff22cbe809889bd7eee330a97f3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d56","kind":"description","unitIndex":56,"unitId":"unit:be84db276052807740116351027e22e1b16f571478735b04e58ab589edd9c8e6","textSha256":"cb01558d6ad8332af1562e5708a8e88fe9732a020661f7cafd0d5e9ea2464704"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:067c830cfd34b4050cb1b5c47306de42","paperId":"2406.17851","sourceSha256":"6862a936aa0cb43094aa1365c6b8b76070e2c067dc74b83fe2bbd69ae35be438","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b0d061e98b62cbec5eee/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"036c2ae22c820c836ddf2b5d3fb18497ff08642e3eb5fce96182c7794bfa1bc7","pdfPage":51,"start":1293,"end":3293,"textSha256":"59a5554642a807d50bbbff317c889ea102f1b677ade5ebcc048a4499a000e4a6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6665e2cfe236a9e99d1667d41ef8dcef","paperId":"2406.17851","sourceSha256":"6862a936aa0cb43094aa1365c6b8b76070e2c067dc74b83fe2bbd69ae35be438","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b0d061e98b62cbec5eee/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"036c2ae22c820c836ddf2b5d3fb18497ff08642e3eb5fce96182c7794bfa1bc7","pdfPage":49,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"01d8b838b6338408bc86dfb427deb5203f47c1c9f6981e6385fd00003055a415","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b7d90f56f960ff1e6f61a1db17d8110f","paperId":"2406.17851","sourceSha256":"6862a936aa0cb43094aa1365c6b8b76070e2c067dc74b83fe2bbd69ae35be438","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b0d061e98b62cbec5eee/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"036c2ae22c820c836ddf2b5d3fb18497ff08642e3eb5fce96182c7794bfa1bc7","pdfPage":51,"start":98,"end":3293,"textSha256":"73e942bac9f4875941a1c45114e6a7ca654967657f8804e158be03695dfc6241","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ed9f1188ac0b4652b1028fab","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound constitutive relations, admissible towers and parametric correspondence. Fixed/sub-polynomial towers generally fail the stated scaling test, with an mt","challengeNote":"Compound constitutive, tower-selection and correspondence targets. Fixed-mass/sub-polynomial towers fail simultaneous scaling except at mt≈Λsp. Corresponden​","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ad60db9fb465add0f8711646f48b55e81566c6bf9c0d01156fa7bbcf0e87419f"},"organizational-access:f2f488feaf2fcfe4b11f1020":{"id":"organizational-access:f2f488feaf2fcfe4b11f1020","source":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f","target":"q025-candidate-question:b1c4c37becd0a3ce0ded3d15","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"0c8927e5fc77028278e864261d5b309e1bf96114a7ea8c96e0c7a28e10675dba","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b755286c7ce716fa638781d0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:b1c4c37becd0a3ce0ded3d15","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1c202d368227801eb77bc6e51b81c3bf9bf49fd14459e58bf33c2c1fca27e765","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:75cbf8626d9e792ad19b03c8"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","home":{"unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q11 explicitly combines physical Coulomb-branch positivity and boundary consistency with global gauge forms and required BPS excitations of six-dimensional parents.","qualification":"q11 explicitly covers the dimensional relation, positivity and boundary method, global gauge forms and required BPS excitations. The physical Kähler cone, restricted T=0 examples, limited announced exclusions and full-theory gauging exception remain qualifications. Neither a universal exclusion nor a supplied full proof is inferred.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","paperId":"2406.06704","textSha256":"15b1e590735c3a6ff49a6fa300d6d3ee2db98046685164dddc1c35ae68071cb0"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0011:u22:q11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0011:u22:q11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f"],"scopeContentSha256":"0c8927e5fc77028278e864261d5b309e1bf96114a7ea8c96e0c7a28e10675dba","placementContentSha256":"95592f7ee494230f77e55a3a2f7df6f5472f64596c072c43e861e9cd30d79700","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0011:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0011:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","paperId":"2406.06704","textSha256":"15b1e590735c3a6ff49a6fa300d6d3ee2db98046685164dddc1c35ae68071cb0"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0011","unitRef":"u22"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b1c4c37becd0a3ce0ded3d15","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d90","kind":"description","unitIndex":90,"unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","textSha256":"15b1e590735c3a6ff49a6fa300d6d3ee2db98046685164dddc1c35ae68071cb0"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2e2911efe2aa99dcf542ce53e4bfd71f","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":3331,"textSha256":"fe044a98fc79e764f1bfa2167d527ed55a9a71e5e488bd702c4f344772525a9d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e43e2b5a5b2a5d6d8d417cac80b63f76","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b82113e5d0345d1188abd0a95be0e94f6ed91617ba29db732d6d60269f435d49","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:144ece21dbc03af4e550e38e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:144ece21dbc03af4e550e38e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","q025-candidate-question:b1c4c37becd0a3ce0ded3d15"],"scopeContentSha256":"1c202d368227801eb77bc6e51b81c3bf9bf49fd14459e58bf33c2c1fca27e765","contributionContentSha256":"03d7606d53015a5b90f9edcdbabf660d6c5f6a984625b5014e97fc286542b368","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-proposal","leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d90","kind":"description","unitIndex":90,"unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","textSha256":"15b1e590735c3a6ff49a6fa300d6d3ee2db98046685164dddc1c35ae68071cb0"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2e2911efe2aa99dcf542ce53e4bfd71f","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":3331,"textSha256":"fe044a98fc79e764f1bfa2167d527ed55a9a71e5e488bd702c4f344772525a9d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e43e2b5a5b2a5d6d8d417cac80b63f76","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b82113e5d0345d1188abd0a95be0e94f6ed91617ba29db732d6d60269f435d49","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:144ece21dbc03af4e550e38e","recordId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Scientifically fits despite outside-probe provenance. The excerpt announces T=0 applications and limited exclusions, not a complete landscape criterion.","challengeNote":"Scientific fit is independent of outside-probe provenance. Positivity requires the physical cone; the introduction announces T=0 applications and limited exclus","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"b0589ed33522600d030f0d8183fea7cb9b7cf0e6c30c0d399ab3b2175196ab08"},"organizational-access:6430bb64ba527776f3d610df":{"id":"organizational-access:6430bb64ba527776f3d610df","source":"q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae","target":"q025-candidate-question:528990f28c3ccba6d5d8b47d","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6222773dbbd2d1d21ae40e96680b69b7a1a683aa0e99245dc7ce3a37bf1dc278","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f664c84546bd5a79082b408f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:528990f28c3ccba6d5d8b47d","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"bae79f7df0fdb4a7de842c161ffdcee66a0f9322f4a87a0745d2c078fcb27cf7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5fb1a25377f06ba5149f24fe"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:a373f914c70791b9711cbeaeb950a55f37271b4df6a6d4ee136f93b4835c8e0b","home":{"unitId":"unit:a373f914c70791b9711cbeaeb950a55f37271b4df6a6d4ee136f93b4835c8e0b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q11 covers rapid-turn dynamics, observational viability and source-specific conjecture compatibility while distinguishing hyperinflation from all rapid-turn models.","qualification":"q11 covers changes to rapid-turn dynamics together with observational viability and particular conjectural tests. Its explicit distinction between hyperinflation and all rapid-turn models preserves the inherited domain restriction. q7 captures the geometric generalization but does not clearly encompass every unspecified conjectural viability test. Historical reheating language does not enlarge the immutable description.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a373f914c70791b9711cbeaeb950a55f37271b4df6a6d4ee136f93b4835c8e0b","paperId":"1901.08603","textSha256":"7c342ba751e8d593f5da5c663b785b2e7c735997d9b4b61ffed701302f868ec4"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0010:u22:q11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0010:u22:q11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a373f914c70791b9711cbeaeb950a55f37271b4df6a6d4ee136f93b4835c8e0b","q025-candidate-question:c253246412d0dc8d86ed91ae"],"scopeContentSha256":"6222773dbbd2d1d21ae40e96680b69b7a1a683aa0e99245dc7ce3a37bf1dc278","placementContentSha256":"4261fb4954adc03230bcb2b664978383dbaf09305739b080e84ceb303ef586ed","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0010:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0010:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a373f914c70791b9711cbeaeb950a55f37271b4df6a6d4ee136f93b4835c8e0b","paperId":"1901.08603","textSha256":"7c342ba751e8d593f5da5c663b785b2e7c735997d9b4b61ffed701302f868ec4"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0010","unitRef":"u22"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a373f914c70791b9711cbeaeb950a55f37271b4df6a6d4ee136f93b4835c8e0b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:528990f28c3ccba6d5d8b47d","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:a373f914c70791b9711cbeaeb950a55f37271b4df6a6d4ee136f93b4835c8e0b","textSha256":"7c342ba751e8d593f5da5c663b785b2e7c735997d9b4b61ffed701302f868ec4"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ac902b89c9f67cfd87e88d7f57dce744","paperId":"1901.08603","sourceSha256":"5d821af47591517684e8c149583ba05879fe94ea4e4fa19fe693af988d95c9aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/56e65bcc950c8b3f74c7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"80111c476772f007c350ac3556c1c6018700c8cc6c4b9c32555497d388bdcb3c","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"947efd29d38f397e1cfcd7865b5aa95c5c7a4810046cfc055308f7c8683aa406","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f50959a7738afa522348cf1f2b5a259e","paperId":"1901.08603","sourceSha256":"5d821af47591517684e8c149583ba05879fe94ea4e4fa19fe693af988d95c9aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/56e65bcc950c8b3f74c7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"80111c476772f007c350ac3556c1c6018700c8cc6c4b9c32555497d388bdcb3c","pdfPage":9,"start":515,"end":1948,"textSha256":"e1311f3bc208077869945851ff5e8ee58acd0a73de87a2e52a63d587a1f62636","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:aefdabc1334f71a5e004e3e7242deed4","paperId":"1901.08603","sourceSha256":"5d821af47591517684e8c149583ba05879fe94ea4e4fa19fe693af988d95c9aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/56e65bcc950c8b3f74c7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"80111c476772f007c350ac3556c1c6018700c8cc6c4b9c32555497d388bdcb3c","pdfPage":10,"start":0,"end":2729,"textSha256":"018c461d6727f6f7f6105edefc0cbc0f47758bc4da0ebf00bffad89991f032a4","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4ff4a3c046d46c9cf92cc61c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4ff4a3c046d46c9cf92cc61c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a373f914c70791b9711cbeaeb950a55f37271b4df6a6d4ee136f93b4835c8e0b","q025-candidate-question:528990f28c3ccba6d5d8b47d"],"scopeContentSha256":"bae79f7df0fdb4a7de842c161ffdcee66a0f9322f4a87a0745d2c078fcb27cf7","contributionContentSha256":"74250cd9458a266c88201b883fa630f1a8a531d6a0c3eeed5433afb6924c6312","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:a373f914c70791b9711cbeaeb950a55f37271b4df6a6d4ee136f93b4835c8e0b","textSha256":"7c342ba751e8d593f5da5c663b785b2e7c735997d9b4b61ffed701302f868ec4"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ac902b89c9f67cfd87e88d7f57dce744","paperId":"1901.08603","sourceSha256":"5d821af47591517684e8c149583ba05879fe94ea4e4fa19fe693af988d95c9aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/56e65bcc950c8b3f74c7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"80111c476772f007c350ac3556c1c6018700c8cc6c4b9c32555497d388bdcb3c","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"947efd29d38f397e1cfcd7865b5aa95c5c7a4810046cfc055308f7c8683aa406","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f50959a7738afa522348cf1f2b5a259e","paperId":"1901.08603","sourceSha256":"5d821af47591517684e8c149583ba05879fe94ea4e4fa19fe693af988d95c9aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/56e65bcc950c8b3f74c7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"80111c476772f007c350ac3556c1c6018700c8cc6c4b9c32555497d388bdcb3c","pdfPage":9,"start":515,"end":1948,"textSha256":"e1311f3bc208077869945851ff5e8ee58acd0a73de87a2e52a63d587a1f62636","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:aefdabc1334f71a5e004e3e7242deed4","paperId":"1901.08603","sourceSha256":"5d821af47591517684e8c149583ba05879fe94ea4e4fa19fe693af988d95c9aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/56e65bcc950c8b3f74c7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"80111c476772f007c350ac3556c1c6018700c8cc6c4b9c32555497d388bdcb3c","pdfPage":10,"start":0,"end":2729,"textSha256":"018c461d6727f6f7f6105edefc0cbc0f47758bc4da0ebf00bffad89991f032a4","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4ff4a3c046d46c9cf92cc61c","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound generalization, observational/conjectural tests and reheating target. Restricted hyperinflation solutions do not classify all rapid-turn dynamics.","challengeNote":"Compound hyperinflation generalization, compatibility and reheating targets. Local controlled solutions do not classify all rapid-turn dynamics or establish the","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"5821756433fd2e7b73649ec3e232ff6782edbe21b21376fb893b4f83cea1da3d"},"organizational-access:45a8302bbf7eabd34e889bc4":{"id":"organizational-access:45a8302bbf7eabd34e889bc4","source":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","target":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9e6c184caeeca1fe514b806a44ec65f74bf314448503e5b9dead2e99a6f758bf","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:498d2ccc89fa873c91e4b585"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"5e6c90cc5733aced848abc6aeafcd6daa829b97d761364bc71ea7803d1df1dd6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7afc98ee8265af1b50632f20"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1250ebeed54952b26e25c8f332139d3b5fe4bc9bfc721c64241683ee0dc8e9d7","home":{"unitId":"unit:1250ebeed54952b26e25c8f332139d3b5fe4bc9bfc721c64241683ee0dc8e9d7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Modified kinetic dynamics, gauge-mediated thermal dissipation and stability encompass the determination of warm, effectively single-field and genuinely two-field evolution.","qualification":"q10 covers the interacting kinetic and thermal dynamics and determination of all three stated regimes. Heterotic motivation does not add a separate compactification proof or establish a small decay constant.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1250ebeed54952b26e25c8f332139d3b5fe4bc9bfc721c64241683ee0dc8e9d7","textSha256":"f72a54fece194af494a35771aaeafda96ccb9be4564fd11153c6c74a933b62e6"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u2:q10"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u2:q10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1250ebeed54952b26e25c8f332139d3b5fe4bc9bfc721c64241683ee0dc8e9d7","q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a"],"scopeContentSha256":"9e6c184caeeca1fe514b806a44ec65f74bf314448503e5b9dead2e99a6f758bf","placementContentSha256":"cc652fb3e45f76f04e398d0a3032cf12255ea21c50285915fcced09fa1aa1eb4","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:coverage:proposal","placement-pilot:coverage:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1250ebeed54952b26e25c8f332139d3b5fe4bc9bfc721c64241683ee0dc8e9d7","textSha256":"f72a54fece194af494a35771aaeafda96ccb9be4564fd11153c6c74a933b62e6"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:1250ebeed54952b26e25c8f332139d3b5fe4bc9bfc721c64241683ee0dc8e9d7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1250ebeed54952b26e25c8f332139d3b5fe4bc9bfc721c64241683ee0dc8e9d7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d73","kind":"description","unitIndex":73,"unitId":"unit:1250ebeed54952b26e25c8f332139d3b5fe4bc9bfc721c64241683ee0dc8e9d7","textSha256":"f72a54fece194af494a35771aaeafda96ccb9be4564fd11153c6c74a933b62e6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5b69aa554e9959f1486f664e","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Warm, effectively single-field and genuinely two-field evolution are regimes to determine. Independent challenge qualification: Warm, effectively single-field and genuinely two-field evolution are regimes to determine."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5b69aa554e9959f1486f664e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1250ebeed54952b26e25c8f332139d3b5fe4bc9bfc721c64241683ee0dc8e9d7","q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c"],"scopeContentSha256":"5e6c90cc5733aced848abc6aeafcd6daa829b97d761364bc71ea7803d1df1dd6","contributionContentSha256":"67f0f2fb09d29b7f8fc317c79bfcbce5b7fd6270ced8c410729072d8be8bbbe2","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d73","kind":"description","unitIndex":73,"unitId":"unit:1250ebeed54952b26e25c8f332139d3b5fe4bc9bfc721c64241683ee0dc8e9d7","textSha256":"f72a54fece194af494a35771aaeafda96ccb9be4564fd11153c6c74a933b62e6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5b69aa554e9959f1486f664e","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Warm, effectively single-field and genuinely two-field evolution are regimes to determine.","challengeNote":"Warm, effectively single-field and genuinely two-field evolution are regimes to determine.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:44c4cb36779d40cd065031fe74d3171faf148f868aeaae6ce7b56c2e9ccf157c","home":{"unitId":"unit:44c4cb36779d40cd065031fe74d3171faf148f868aeaae6ce7b56c2e9ccf157c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly includes spinodal non-equilibrium dynamics, sustained inflation at small fundamental scales and acceptable perturbations.","qualification":"q10 explicitly covers spinodal dynamics, sufficient inflation and acceptable perturbations. The source's restrictions on the decay constant and on actual field excursions remain separate conditions.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:44c4cb36779d40cd065031fe74d3171faf148f868aeaae6ce7b56c2e9ccf157c","textSha256":"141fbbfbb8442b028c00c473f29db651d44bf66836898595a27145b52d5a311f"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u7:q10"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u7:q10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:44c4cb36779d40cd065031fe74d3171faf148f868aeaae6ce7b56c2e9ccf157c","q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a"],"scopeContentSha256":"9e6c184caeeca1fe514b806a44ec65f74bf314448503e5b9dead2e99a6f758bf","placementContentSha256":"f6765dbcdb6a351bbff020f5329dd47f46a14703d2157bbd260f9ee93789ee2a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:coverage:proposal","placement-pilot:coverage:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:44c4cb36779d40cd065031fe74d3171faf148f868aeaae6ce7b56c2e9ccf157c","textSha256":"141fbbfbb8442b028c00c473f29db651d44bf66836898595a27145b52d5a311f"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:44c4cb36779d40cd065031fe74d3171faf148f868aeaae6ce7b56c2e9ccf157c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:44c4cb36779d40cd065031fe74d3171faf148f868aeaae6ce7b56c2e9ccf157c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:44c4cb36779d40cd065031fe74d3171faf148f868aeaae6ce7b56c2e9ccf157c","textSha256":"141fbbfbb8442b028c00c473f29db651d44bf66836898595a27145b52d5a311f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dd333e19c7b1002aa2bd1c44","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:dd333e19c7b1002aa2bd1c44","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:44c4cb36779d40cd065031fe74d3171faf148f868aeaae6ce7b56c2e9ccf157c","q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c"],"scopeContentSha256":"5e6c90cc5733aced848abc6aeafcd6daa829b97d761364bc71ea7803d1df1dd6","contributionContentSha256":"30513746aa131b86c46b07b97512ac0a75659facd21f7ec477b252891da3a978","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:44c4cb36779d40cd065031fe74d3171faf148f868aeaae6ce7b56c2e9ccf157c","textSha256":"141fbbfbb8442b028c00c473f29db651d44bf66836898595a27145b52d5a311f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dd333e19c7b1002aa2bd1c44","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:7a16c6358397efbdeb773b01d136b33c4ade2a593369be237424ac16ba04916a","home":{"unitId":"unit:7a16c6358397efbdeb773b01d136b33c4ade2a593369be237424ac16ba04916a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers classical non-Abelian assistance on steep axion potentials, small fundamental scales and the separate requirement of acceptable perturbations.","qualification":"q10 covers classical non-Abelian slow-roll support, the steep potential and small decay constant, and the further fluctuation target. Its conventions distinguish this mechanism from Abelian fluctuation production.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7a16c6358397efbdeb773b01d136b33c4ade2a593369be237424ac16ba04916a","textSha256":"92e608daa3fce3599469d3e779bbeaaeccc092eb73003c738b36ee52dc904342"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u11:q10"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u11:q10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7a16c6358397efbdeb773b01d136b33c4ade2a593369be237424ac16ba04916a","q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a"],"scopeContentSha256":"9e6c184caeeca1fe514b806a44ec65f74bf314448503e5b9dead2e99a6f758bf","placementContentSha256":"5d7acadfa837c6f9540dc871d1b8d1a79e05f6d79af6daf1cd1fedc066c086fd","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:coverage:proposal","placement-pilot:coverage:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7a16c6358397efbdeb773b01d136b33c4ade2a593369be237424ac16ba04916a","textSha256":"92e608daa3fce3599469d3e779bbeaaeccc092eb73003c738b36ee52dc904342"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:7a16c6358397efbdeb773b01d136b33c4ade2a593369be237424ac16ba04916a"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7a16c6358397efbdeb773b01d136b33c4ade2a593369be237424ac16ba04916a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:7a16c6358397efbdeb773b01d136b33c4ade2a593369be237424ac16ba04916a","textSha256":"92e608daa3fce3599469d3e779bbeaaeccc092eb73003c738b36ee52dc904342"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3e0e6c9f206c1f58d8e52f6b","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Acceptable fluctuations are a target, not established by the supplied background description. Independent challenge qualification: Acceptable fluctuations remain a target beyond background existence."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3e0e6c9f206c1f58d8e52f6b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7a16c6358397efbdeb773b01d136b33c4ade2a593369be237424ac16ba04916a","q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c"],"scopeContentSha256":"5e6c90cc5733aced848abc6aeafcd6daa829b97d761364bc71ea7803d1df1dd6","contributionContentSha256":"bfa10eea094a2180fee7be6373b5278b0886ea891c218bb224e0a83905a121ff","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:7a16c6358397efbdeb773b01d136b33c4ade2a593369be237424ac16ba04916a","textSha256":"92e608daa3fce3599469d3e779bbeaaeccc092eb73003c738b36ee52dc904342"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3e0e6c9f206c1f58d8e52f6b","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Acceptable fluctuations are a target, not established by the supplied background description.","challengeNote":"Acceptable fluctuations remain a target beyond background existence.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:e50105d51ef65387e4e82eaf2f653c33b204dc8fd44466599fd4b1a11661f07c","home":{"unitId":"unit:e50105d51ef65387e4e82eaf2f653c33b204dc8fd44466599fd4b1a11661f07c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers derivative-modified axion damping, sufficient inflation at a small fundamental scale and perturbation-based parameter determination.","qualification":"q12 covers derivative dynamics, sustained inflation, perturbations and required interaction strengths. Parameter determination from linear perturbations belongs to that same assessment, so the entire question fits one home. The specified decay constant is preserved without interpreting it as an excursion bound.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e50105d51ef65387e4e82eaf2f653c33b204dc8fd44466599fd4b1a11661f07c","paperId":"1209.6554","textSha256":"d0b1f1ed129d8e602c5229a09facb894d3840a43539aecf520e0631ab9bb8248"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0056:u10:q12"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0056:u10:q12","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e50105d51ef65387e4e82eaf2f653c33b204dc8fd44466599fd4b1a11661f07c","q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a"],"scopeContentSha256":"9e6c184caeeca1fe514b806a44ec65f74bf314448503e5b9dead2e99a6f758bf","placementContentSha256":"a96f4aa7a21456689f3dc9eb86b6837bd5c0c85feb9ab47d5ec8be250d45c773","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0056:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0056:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e50105d51ef65387e4e82eaf2f653c33b204dc8fd44466599fd4b1a11661f07c","paperId":"1209.6554","textSha256":"d0b1f1ed129d8e602c5229a09facb894d3840a43539aecf520e0631ab9bb8248"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0056","unitRef":"u10"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e50105d51ef65387e4e82eaf2f653c33b204dc8fd44466599fd4b1a11661f07c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:e50105d51ef65387e4e82eaf2f653c33b204dc8fd44466599fd4b1a11661f07c","textSha256":"d0b1f1ed129d8e602c5229a09facb894d3840a43539aecf520e0631ab9bb8248"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:afdfb34d88650263fe80358f","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:afdfb34d88650263fe80358f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e50105d51ef65387e4e82eaf2f653c33b204dc8fd44466599fd4b1a11661f07c","q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c"],"scopeContentSha256":"5e6c90cc5733aced848abc6aeafcd6daa829b97d761364bc71ea7803d1df1dd6","contributionContentSha256":"37da85e8b0b07a9c1bf66ac4a51f2e62d0b7443128d6b8382c7f0ecab0a1f3e3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:e50105d51ef65387e4e82eaf2f653c33b204dc8fd44466599fd4b1a11661f07c","textSha256":"d0b1f1ed129d8e602c5229a09facb894d3840a43539aecf520e0631ab9bb8248"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:afdfb34d88650263fe80358f","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f6a4df371b8b0c027eda1620205eb32aecdd1f83e2c1625a76801ccef8ec8753","home":{"unitId":"unit:f6a4df371b8b0c027eda1620205eb32aecdd1f83e2c1625a76801ccef8ec8753","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers gauge-particle production as axion damping and the separate scalar-amplitude viability test at f≲MP.","qualification":"q12 explicitly covers particle-production damping and perturbative viability on steep potentials at small fundamental scales. Its distinction between background damping and acceptable perturbations accommodates the inherited excessive-amplitude report. That March 2010 v2 report remains limited to the simplest construction.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f6a4df371b8b0c027eda1620205eb32aecdd1f83e2c1625a76801ccef8ec8753","paperId":"0908.4089","textSha256":"624e3469b5bb8ce16d3de8a1ff1c92c7e3e758fdf5bc1da663925e7545b9e394"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0056:u11:q12"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0056:u11:q12","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f6a4df371b8b0c027eda1620205eb32aecdd1f83e2c1625a76801ccef8ec8753","q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a"],"scopeContentSha256":"9e6c184caeeca1fe514b806a44ec65f74bf314448503e5b9dead2e99a6f758bf","placementContentSha256":"8595fc0fe5bd70f306f17cc7b867d41d047470a2f298b23e8277ea919115a423","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0056:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0056:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f6a4df371b8b0c027eda1620205eb32aecdd1f83e2c1625a76801ccef8ec8753","paperId":"0908.4089","textSha256":"624e3469b5bb8ce16d3de8a1ff1c92c7e3e758fdf5bc1da663925e7545b9e394"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0056","unitRef":"u11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f6a4df371b8b0c027eda1620205eb32aecdd1f83e2c1625a76801ccef8ec8753","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:f6a4df371b8b0c027eda1620205eb32aecdd1f83e2c1625a76801ccef8ec8753","textSha256":"624e3469b5bb8ce16d3de8a1ff1c92c7e3e758fdf5bc1da663925e7545b9e394"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0b3f9491bc305bb605cb5d706d12e3e6","paperId":"0908.4089","sourceSha256":"086da0b10e05f211ff2d19e7ca5a0be5ac1f33dc1502501d79000cacd696af17","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d6f06056122b0b2a758a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"488e3f4823ac292c449bc4da8b84569c0df743f1d4cbebdead804e37b5f84669","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":3500,"textSha256":"0b2c0efe51da008fe34677295b1f2eddd323a02e871c71746ae7293b28a953f7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7dcb82c5b7b6f0dddeb27782025d553b","paperId":"0908.4089","sourceSha256":"086da0b10e05f211ff2d19e7ca5a0be5ac1f33dc1502501d79000cacd696af17","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d6f06056122b0b2a758a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"488e3f4823ac292c449bc4da8b84569c0df743f1d4cbebdead804e37b5f84669","pdfPage":1,"start":1301,"end":4537,"textSha256":"6ec4db3c8f4df0488f062c5b4cee74b00e9a0b4c57f77fe324c34ef67d513d52","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5030e7060ae785fe770366f3","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The March 2010 v2 source reports excessive scalar amplitude in the simplest construction. Independent challenge qualification: The March 2010 v2 source reports excessive scalar amplitude in its simplest construction."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5030e7060ae785fe770366f3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f6a4df371b8b0c027eda1620205eb32aecdd1f83e2c1625a76801ccef8ec8753","q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c"],"scopeContentSha256":"5e6c90cc5733aced848abc6aeafcd6daa829b97d761364bc71ea7803d1df1dd6","contributionContentSha256":"7965355a91554221852d108110a74d6c415256a85e544e969087f2bd7b44dd1e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:f6a4df371b8b0c027eda1620205eb32aecdd1f83e2c1625a76801ccef8ec8753","textSha256":"624e3469b5bb8ce16d3de8a1ff1c92c7e3e758fdf5bc1da663925e7545b9e394"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0b3f9491bc305bb605cb5d706d12e3e6","paperId":"0908.4089","sourceSha256":"086da0b10e05f211ff2d19e7ca5a0be5ac1f33dc1502501d79000cacd696af17","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d6f06056122b0b2a758a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"488e3f4823ac292c449bc4da8b84569c0df743f1d4cbebdead804e37b5f84669","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":3500,"textSha256":"0b2c0efe51da008fe34677295b1f2eddd323a02e871c71746ae7293b28a953f7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7dcb82c5b7b6f0dddeb27782025d553b","paperId":"0908.4089","sourceSha256":"086da0b10e05f211ff2d19e7ca5a0be5ac1f33dc1502501d79000cacd696af17","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d6f06056122b0b2a758a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"488e3f4823ac292c449bc4da8b84569c0df743f1d4cbebdead804e37b5f84669","pdfPage":1,"start":1301,"end":4537,"textSha256":"6ec4db3c8f4df0488f062c5b4cee74b00e9a0b4c57f77fe324c34ef67d513d52","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5030e7060ae785fe770366f3","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The March 2010 v2 source reports excessive scalar amplitude in the simplest construction.","challengeNote":"The March 2010 v2 source reports excessive scalar amplitude in its simplest construction.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","home":{"unitId":"unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":0.5,"reason":"Covers axion-induced thermal damping, sustained inflation on steep potentials and the scalar-spectrum requirement.","qualification":"Thermal dynamics and three conditional criteria remain distinct. Exact full challenge coverage and source-local qualifications remain binding. Weights are organizational allocation, not confidence or physical importance.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","paperId":"1911.00323","textSha256":"950c928b0245d6f31d6daadd318e2a783f897a124df9753c860442b330cd9440"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0056:u16:q12","coverageMode":"explicit_compound_union","targetCoverage":[{"sourceSpan":"Can a concrete axion-induced thermal bath sustain inflation on steep potentials while reproducing the observed scalar spectrum","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a"],"explanation":"Assigns the thermal mechanism, steep-potential background and scalar-spectrum viability to the modified-dynamics scope."},{"sourceSpan":"and respecting the paper's de Sitter, distance, and trans-Planckian criteria?","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd"],"explanation":"Assigns the three source-specific conditional consistency tests to their explicit admitted scope, without treating them as universal premises."}],"coverageReason":"The union covers the thermal mechanism, steep-potential inflation and observed-spectrum requirement through q12, and the explicitly named conjectural criteria through q10. q12's stability/EFT targets do not themselves specify those three quantum-gravity tests; its exclusion of automatic Swampland compatibility is a warning, not positive coverage of every test. q10 does not independently cover the full thermal construction and spectrum calculation. No supplied single scope covers all these targets without enlargement. The source remains one question, with coordinator scrutiny required."},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0056:u16:q12","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a"],"scopeContentSha256":"9e6c184caeeca1fe514b806a44ec65f74bf314448503e5b9dead2e99a6f758bf","placementContentSha256":"bb89426d80f0938e7fa662e9070ec114d5d71e571f89becdf433fbd99b3622c3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0056:proposal","explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0056:challenge","root:explicit-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","paperId":"1911.00323","textSha256":"950c928b0245d6f31d6daadd318e2a783f897a124df9753c860442b330cd9440"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"45cd7c1d060cb6f2fd1d8a4ace5cca7c3d64df235a869afc4ce7e31b2e6badfb"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0056","unitRef":"u16"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","textSha256":"950c928b0245d6f31d6daadd318e2a783f897a124df9753c860442b330cd9440"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8145fa5124a79a84629d83c4","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Shares a paper with the completion question but has a different target and scope. Independent challenge qualification: Shares a paper with the completion facet, but asks a different scoped question."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8145fa5124a79a84629d83c4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","q025-candidate-question:a1d7ce1c5d3ed3474b0ea14c"],"scopeContentSha256":"5e6c90cc5733aced848abc6aeafcd6daa829b97d761364bc71ea7803d1df1dd6","contributionContentSha256":"59a92a5e9a4230cd9fe953f5db0fa6d40cb09f6da6443fb465f528c1e7e94bd9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:ff6c8294bb034401e54fbee369e052828705dd419d20459de8bf92d9186d58d7","textSha256":"950c928b0245d6f31d6daadd318e2a783f897a124df9753c860442b330cd9440"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8145fa5124a79a84629d83c4","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Shares a paper with the completion question but has a different target and scope.","challengeNote":"Shares a paper with the completion facet, but asks a different scoped question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":6,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"80ea752c9899d957473002ac9631db9f255f20a35fa7b640cef4d2aa953f5639"},"organizational-access:3c8fa7034a5c0430bf6c524b":{"id":"organizational-access:3c8fa7034a5c0430bf6c524b","source":"q025-candidate-question:cbec67884d8051e3e85220e5","target":"q025-candidate-question:efd0ae79fc058ceedfe0e8a7","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:cbec67884d8051e3e85220e5","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"cd223b7bb9ce8471d2482cf212a5f59407f512128f603dbe008d0a75795e27b1","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:19821a47db543794e6b8f35d"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:efd0ae79fc058ceedfe0e8a7","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"46a8ab5a9fd3c8469ce78ab1c7e998f9a75544f3fd80e4da7a056016191c4dfb","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:statistics:pq7"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:9e159759d6a0d6214e46d3c03d38df508e889f09dbfb114aa31d504a14ad835a","home":{"unitId":"unit:9e159759d6a0d6214e46d3c03d38df508e889f09dbfb114aa31d504a14ad835a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cbec67884d8051e3e85220e5","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9e159759d6a0d6214e46d3c03d38df508e889f09dbfb114aa31d504a14ad835a","paperId":"2006.07290","textSha256":"ca9d11a43c30bdefa5056ecd20971f8eb48a2e4604e675f4547da410cf2d18c8"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:043d6a6568c6f9119c957ab5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:043d6a6568c6f9119c957ab5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9e159759d6a0d6214e46d3c03d38df508e889f09dbfb114aa31d504a14ad835a","q025-candidate-question:cbec67884d8051e3e85220e5"],"scopeContentSha256":"cd223b7bb9ce8471d2482cf212a5f59407f512128f603dbe008d0a75795e27b1","placementContentSha256":"85e456ccd37549e371e2f38dfaba28f9af0e462b370116ebdbfacf360bb89559","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge","leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9e159759d6a0d6214e46d3c03d38df508e889f09dbfb114aa31d504a14ad835a","paperId":"2006.07290","textSha256":"ca9d11a43c30bdefa5056ecd20971f8eb48a2e4604e675f4547da410cf2d18c8"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:043d6a6568c6f9119c957ab5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9e159759d6a0d6214e46d3c03d38df508e889f09dbfb114aa31d504a14ad835a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:efd0ae79fc058ceedfe0e8a7","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u76","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9e159759d6a0d6214e46d3c03d38df508e889f09dbfb114aa31d504a14ad835a","paperId":"2006.07290","textSha256":"ca9d11a43c30bdefa5056ecd20971f8eb48a2e4604e675f4547da410cf2d18c8"}],"qualification":"The description explicitly asks whether the proposed typicality argument explains exclusions in that selected model. No primary statistical derivation is supplied.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z60"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z60","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9e159759d6a0d6214e46d3c03d38df508e889f09dbfb114aa31d504a14ad835a","q025-candidate-question:efd0ae79fc058ceedfe0e8a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"46a8ab5a9fd3c8469ce78ab1c7e998f9a75544f3fd80e4da7a056016191c4dfb","contributionContentSha256":"240946f2ba2064b6a91015f903edc4d3a362264e93436dd6ff02244c2d85e84c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation"},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","statistics-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u76","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9e159759d6a0d6214e46d3c03d38df508e889f09dbfb114aa31d504a14ad835a","paperId":"2006.07290","textSha256":"ca9d11a43c30bdefa5056ecd20971f8eb48a2e4604e675f4547da410cf2d18c8"}],"explicitConfirmation":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:statistics:z60","family":"statistics","originalRowId":"z60","oldRole":{"id":"z60","unitRef":"u76","questionRef":"pq7","role":"addresses","reason":"The description explicitly asks whether the proposed typicality argument explains exclusions in that selected model. No primary statistical derivation is supplied.","refs":["u76"]},"confirmation":{"id":"z60","verdict":"supported_as_written","basis":"description_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":[],"reason":"Explaining the selected model's observed exclusions through proposed typicality is the explicit question; no statistical derivation is supplied.","refs":["u76","pq7"]},"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","challengeReviewId":"statistics-source-role-confirmation","qualificationUnchanged":true}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"35f3b23b2c4404a6fac0ae27aa716dd60156c2e8f2ba297b761fc0589dc4439e"},"organizational-access:4d2d9c61fa4d083109ee9226":{"id":"organizational-access:4d2d9c61fa4d083109ee9226","source":"q025-candidate-question:cbf6c5e2de995ab25972d12a","target":"q025-candidate-question:eedb7c2ce7d3c7d1a8df49c2","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:cbf6c5e2de995ab25972d12a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"93f9b8019769e94f4ded3363a81fe84ccbacf1033d8a5702c2b65d2f534930d3","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:mediation:pq1"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:eedb7c2ce7d3c7d1a8df49c2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"4d9dbc8af0a23840d1085899ccf13d62431e0818be1b467a398c1b2a00de624b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:mediation:pq12"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:39e1c2de327684ec2d946f37c8cc3bba7eed720d86821a3b9b84a341efeef59c","home":{"unitId":"unit:39e1c2de327684ec2d946f37c8cc3bba7eed720d86821a3b9b84a341efeef59c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cbf6c5e2de995ab25972d12a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Its admitted question directly states gauge dominance, stabilized moduli, tuned vacuum energy and the matter–Kähler independence test.","qualification":"q17 directly states the entire linked question, including vacuum-energy tuning and matter–modulus separation. Gauge dominance remains stronger than a comparable gauge contribution, and the reported joint-stabilization conclusion stays bounded to the analyzed type IIB setting.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:39e1c2de327684ec2d946f37c8cc3bba7eed720d86821a3b9b84a341efeef59c","paperId":"hep-th/0703247","textSha256":"02a05f7be94d052e2ca94fa2822a7812a5b9192e9883518f67bd0c8caade6666"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0025:u16:q17"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0025:u16:q17","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:39e1c2de327684ec2d946f37c8cc3bba7eed720d86821a3b9b84a341efeef59c","q025-candidate-question:cbf6c5e2de995ab25972d12a"],"scopeContentSha256":"93f9b8019769e94f4ded3363a81fe84ccbacf1033d8a5702c2b65d2f534930d3","placementContentSha256":"e0e605a2d87823dbdd9c365b5df7b2e9b946594419c8082cb847588a074fe275","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0025:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0025:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:39e1c2de327684ec2d946f37c8cc3bba7eed720d86821a3b9b84a341efeef59c","paperId":"hep-th/0703247","textSha256":"02a05f7be94d052e2ca94fa2822a7812a5b9192e9883518f67bd0c8caade6666"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0025","unitRef":"u16"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:39e1c2de327684ec2d946f37c8cc3bba7eed720d86821a3b9b84a341efeef59c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:eedb7c2ce7d3c7d1a8df49c2","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u6","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:39e1c2de327684ec2d946f37c8cc3bba7eed720d86821a3b9b84a341efeef59c","paperId":"hep-th/0703247","textSha256":"02a05f7be94d052e2ca94fa2822a7812a5b9192e9883518f67bd0c8caade6666"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5c59800970d4a6d4fc0cd349726668b8","paperId":"hep-th/0703247","sourceSha256":"07c203b1ce08cfc47597443f99db8102f31b5cf0121f6e787a3aa7b0ea80016f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a5aed0c04ed71a465e53/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"96d3a61c8f460b7888975972cb4ef13fcce49b0ba9888a862aa799a5ecb8f2c0","pdfPage":10,"start":0,"end":2230,"textSha256":"72d56509eacfba4e03cc1230bca90e855107fcef27ed5e3bcf6747c49ca513a3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bd1be0f4b27beb9d304bfdfb0fa25d40","paperId":"hep-th/0703247","sourceSha256":"07c203b1ce08cfc47597443f99db8102f31b5cf0121f6e787a3aa7b0ea80016f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a5aed0c04ed71a465e53/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"96d3a61c8f460b7888975972cb4ef13fcce49b0ba9888a862aa799a5ecb8f2c0","pdfPage":17,"start":0,"end":1767,"textSha256":"5a2c2d1f7c7a49113a693fd1f293c755607d85e4cce24e17e8fb78c1abf119c2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"qualification":"The supplied toy-model discussion and conclusion test supersymmetric elimination of moduli before analyzing the breaking sector and call for joint stabilization in the examined type IIB setting.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z20"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z20","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:39e1c2de327684ec2d946f37c8cc3bba7eed720d86821a3b9b84a341efeef59c","q025-candidate-question:eedb7c2ce7d3c7d1a8df49c2"],"scopeContentSha256":"4d9dbc8af0a23840d1085899ccf13d62431e0818be1b467a398c1b2a00de624b","contributionContentSha256":"d74751a87e6ee9a728ab5dee91a7a066f13f5c716da05a620e8e790d667317d8","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","challengeReviewId":"mediation-source-role-confirmation"},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","mediation-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u6","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:39e1c2de327684ec2d946f37c8cc3bba7eed720d86821a3b9b84a341efeef59c","paperId":"hep-th/0703247","textSha256":"02a05f7be94d052e2ca94fa2822a7812a5b9192e9883518f67bd0c8caade6666"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5c59800970d4a6d4fc0cd349726668b8","paperId":"hep-th/0703247","sourceSha256":"07c203b1ce08cfc47597443f99db8102f31b5cf0121f6e787a3aa7b0ea80016f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a5aed0c04ed71a465e53/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"96d3a61c8f460b7888975972cb4ef13fcce49b0ba9888a862aa799a5ecb8f2c0","pdfPage":10,"start":0,"end":2230,"textSha256":"72d56509eacfba4e03cc1230bca90e855107fcef27ed5e3bcf6747c49ca513a3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bd1be0f4b27beb9d304bfdfb0fa25d40","paperId":"hep-th/0703247","sourceSha256":"07c203b1ce08cfc47597443f99db8102f31b5cf0121f6e787a3aa7b0ea80016f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a5aed0c04ed71a465e53/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"96d3a61c8f460b7888975972cb4ef13fcce49b0ba9888a862aa799a5ecb8f2c0","pdfPage":17,"start":0,"end":1767,"textSha256":"5a2c2d1f7c7a49113a693fd1f293c755607d85e4cce24e17e8fb78c1abf119c2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"explicitConfirmation":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z20","family":"mediation","originalRowId":"z20","oldRole":{"id":"z20","unitRef":"u6","questionRef":"pq12","role":"specializes","reason":"The supplied toy-model discussion and conclusion test supersymmetric elimination of moduli before analyzing the breaking sector and call for joint stabilization in the examined type IIB setting.","refs":["u6","e1","e6"]},"confirmation":{"id":"z20","verdict":"supported_as_written","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":[],"reason":"The toy model explicitly tests supersymmetric elimination of moduli before the breaking-sector analysis, and the conclusion calls for coupled stabilization in the examined IIB setting. This is a narrower application of pq12.","refs":["u6","pq12","e1","e6","n7","n31"]},"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","challengeReviewId":"mediation-source-role-confirmation","qualificationUnchanged":true}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"81e22d00cb8b672b063529c72b65ce79b9b1d52c453f5bdb356bc834ce1434fd"},"organizational-access:5646902d954b73bede8280e2":{"id":"organizational-access:5646902d954b73bede8280e2","source":"q025-candidate-question:d252b2e89ab996553c954c1e","target":"q025-candidate-question:15eede7db820c188145c48b5","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:d252b2e89ab996553c954c1e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"3dc9b2850f1eabf1ba9fc62ee9a6249b1ff314e0f7b245f9dda9a2cf2dcb66ac","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c350cfe6bc8d90085788047f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:15eede7db820c188145c48b5","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1d71a039ec5746b0975c4665d4f6700ceb9542fbfd6f42370dd580fcd4dc6e24","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:acff7ced6dd3e539ff5c782c"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:f8f05f6f77273996698edae5531e1fecfd426c09a2039483c21834c501f2d479","home":{"unitId":"unit:f8f05f6f77273996698edae5531e1fecfd426c09a2039483c21834c501f2d479","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d252b2e89ab996553c954c1e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f8f05f6f77273996698edae5531e1fecfd426c09a2039483c21834c501f2d479","paperId":"1202.4758","textSha256":"f5ba33728c6c62f5abe9a9379430e97b5673fda87bfc46c2710dedc043ad77db"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:017b5cc271a4085993eb93d2b58fe8de","paperId":"1202.4758","sourceSha256":"382f97723a1611e0e6d6fc8a1171a0c640f8a4c141fb0d5dc83c7178fc5b3cdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eac348b16725705a084c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4999a2f720e27bf7c25b63d9589f69d7d4bfd3319fc060ed8a0111ba0caa2fce","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"cb0505cc615b58558f4e8baf04e41d57e5caa558f2f9aa373ac833877722d07a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d304cd462b7ce83b12b70497d4217bcc","paperId":"1202.4758","sourceSha256":"382f97723a1611e0e6d6fc8a1171a0c640f8a4c141fb0d5dc83c7178fc5b3cdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eac348b16725705a084c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4999a2f720e27bf7c25b63d9589f69d7d4bfd3319fc060ed8a0111ba0caa2fce","pdfPage":1,"start":1304,"end":4131,"textSha256":"5da67b79ec0740232099052a4c8c75281f9025d2a712f8e23fdea1bb15392c2a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:104e83c882aaed8d184db328"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:104e83c882aaed8d184db328","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f8f05f6f77273996698edae5531e1fecfd426c09a2039483c21834c501f2d479","q025-candidate-question:d252b2e89ab996553c954c1e"],"scopeContentSha256":"3dc9b2850f1eabf1ba9fc62ee9a6249b1ff314e0f7b245f9dda9a2cf2dcb66ac","placementContentSha256":"9e63aa3412eb67402c745e505cfb1ce821a8710081e51e01ee87a918867645ae","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0ea3168b74f8672272d8-challenge","leaf-0ea3168b74f8672272d8-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f8f05f6f77273996698edae5531e1fecfd426c09a2039483c21834c501f2d479","paperId":"1202.4758","textSha256":"f5ba33728c6c62f5abe9a9379430e97b5673fda87bfc46c2710dedc043ad77db"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:017b5cc271a4085993eb93d2b58fe8de","paperId":"1202.4758","sourceSha256":"382f97723a1611e0e6d6fc8a1171a0c640f8a4c141fb0d5dc83c7178fc5b3cdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eac348b16725705a084c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4999a2f720e27bf7c25b63d9589f69d7d4bfd3319fc060ed8a0111ba0caa2fce","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"cb0505cc615b58558f4e8baf04e41d57e5caa558f2f9aa373ac833877722d07a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d304cd462b7ce83b12b70497d4217bcc","paperId":"1202.4758","sourceSha256":"382f97723a1611e0e6d6fc8a1171a0c640f8a4c141fb0d5dc83c7178fc5b3cdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eac348b16725705a084c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4999a2f720e27bf7c25b63d9589f69d7d4bfd3319fc060ed8a0111ba0caa2fce","pdfPage":1,"start":1304,"end":4131,"textSha256":"5da67b79ec0740232099052a4c8c75281f9025d2a712f8e23fdea1bb15392c2a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:104e83c882aaed8d184db328"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f8f05f6f77273996698edae5531e1fecfd426c09a2039483c21834c501f2d479","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:15eede7db820c188145c48b5","role":"instantiates","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:f8f05f6f77273996698edae5531e1fecfd426c09a2039483c21834c501f2d479","textSha256":"f5ba33728c6c62f5abe9a9379430e97b5673fda87bfc46c2710dedc043ad77db"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:017b5cc271a4085993eb93d2b58fe8de","paperId":"1202.4758","sourceSha256":"382f97723a1611e0e6d6fc8a1171a0c640f8a4c141fb0d5dc83c7178fc5b3cdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eac348b16725705a084c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4999a2f720e27bf7c25b63d9589f69d7d4bfd3319fc060ed8a0111ba0caa2fce","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"cb0505cc615b58558f4e8baf04e41d57e5caa558f2f9aa373ac833877722d07a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d304cd462b7ce83b12b70497d4217bcc","paperId":"1202.4758","sourceSha256":"382f97723a1611e0e6d6fc8a1171a0c640f8a4c141fb0d5dc83c7178fc5b3cdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eac348b16725705a084c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4999a2f720e27bf7c25b63d9589f69d7d4bfd3319fc060ed8a0111ba0caa2fce","pdfPage":1,"start":1304,"end":4131,"textSha256":"5da67b79ec0740232099052a4c8c75281f9025d2a712f8e23fdea1bb15392c2a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7f5e8fdd377daaa3610e7d4b","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The archived dipole preference remains a dated measurement claim with explicit model comparisons and unresolved systematic alternatives. Independent challenge qualification: The 2012 dipole preferences retain their different statistical comparators. Failure to identify one mimicking systematic does not exclude all systematic explanations."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7f5e8fdd377daaa3610e7d4b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f8f05f6f77273996698edae5531e1fecfd426c09a2039483c21834c501f2d479","q025-candidate-question:15eede7db820c188145c48b5"],"scopeContentSha256":"1d71a039ec5746b0975c4665d4f6700ceb9542fbfd6f42370dd580fcd4dc6e24","contributionContentSha256":"0cf0346324e07a62275fb56412f8a6a402fd478073cbbadde42fc6840b80247a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","challengeReviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:f8f05f6f77273996698edae5531e1fecfd426c09a2039483c21834c501f2d479","textSha256":"f5ba33728c6c62f5abe9a9379430e97b5673fda87bfc46c2710dedc043ad77db"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:017b5cc271a4085993eb93d2b58fe8de","paperId":"1202.4758","sourceSha256":"382f97723a1611e0e6d6fc8a1171a0c640f8a4c141fb0d5dc83c7178fc5b3cdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eac348b16725705a084c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4999a2f720e27bf7c25b63d9589f69d7d4bfd3319fc060ed8a0111ba0caa2fce","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"cb0505cc615b58558f4e8baf04e41d57e5caa558f2f9aa373ac833877722d07a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d304cd462b7ce83b12b70497d4217bcc","paperId":"1202.4758","sourceSha256":"382f97723a1611e0e6d6fc8a1171a0c640f8a4c141fb0d5dc83c7178fc5b3cdd","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/eac348b16725705a084c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4999a2f720e27bf7c25b63d9589f69d7d4bfd3319fc060ed8a0111ba0caa2fce","pdfPage":1,"start":1304,"end":4131,"textSha256":"5da67b79ec0740232099052a4c8c75281f9025d2a712f8e23fdea1bb15392c2a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7f5e8fdd377daaa3610e7d4b","recordId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-proposal","challengeReviewId":"parent-12df24ef76989bce6d58-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The archived dipole preference remains a dated measurement claim with explicit model comparisons and unresolved systematic alternatives.","challengeNote":"The 2012 dipole preferences retain their different statistical comparators. Failure to identify one mimicking systematic does not exclude all systematic explanations.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"d2f7c21dcbb2033b0627705de4ce880bff927ecaf7367315074a054d4d873f34"},"organizational-access:07fc5da2126540f02f0da94c":{"id":"organizational-access:07fc5da2126540f02f0da94c","source":"q025-candidate-question:e08e1ff12138364f07ce32f8","target":"q025-candidate-question:eb40b8307a12406a757cc9fa","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e08e1ff12138364f07ce32f8","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ebb77a566177d9ac32a461bcd1b972ed240d5e9b32be836c99a47f7d72bde744","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3e1e614320d576e96c65326a"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:eb40b8307a12406a757cc9fa","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"39ff735137f8048d85d666d2e1f1ba6769fa3aeb3e8208c11e35567ad32a9198","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f7f531ca6e6ca0a6e92c0e11"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","home":{"unitId":"unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e08e1ff12138364f07ce32f8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers D-brane-generated closed-string axion potentials, large-field inflation, moduli hierarchies and potential flattening.","qualification":"q13 explicitly covers brane-generated closed-string axion potentials, large-field inflation, moduli hierarchies and flattening. Controlled stabilizer dynamics belongs to the stated preservation-of-stabilization requirement. The whole conjunction remains a construction question, without claiming a verified hierarchy, stable trajectory or full compactification.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","paperId":"1505.07871","textSha256":"a2bb29c7231ee9d84fa83c6df6ddfd181db5dece731f024935f4fbf80bdc7533"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0041:u23:q13"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0041:u23:q13","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","q025-candidate-question:e08e1ff12138364f07ce32f8"],"scopeContentSha256":"ebb77a566177d9ac32a461bcd1b972ed240d5e9b32be836c99a47f7d72bde744","placementContentSha256":"2b9094949f00850747a0729ba0e294388ea8b0127908031718bfefd62abbdb8f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0041:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0041:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","paperId":"1505.07871","textSha256":"a2bb29c7231ee9d84fa83c6df6ddfd181db5dece731f024935f4fbf80bdc7533"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0041","unitRef":"u23"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:eb40b8307a12406a757cc9fa","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","textSha256":"a2bb29c7231ee9d84fa83c6df6ddfd181db5dece731f024935f4fbf80bdc7533"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6475a36d27af5f426e6dcafc138e18ee","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":3702,"end":5258,"textSha256":"3b386ffdd7e00343d9b8b9c78a87c535d4ebd1153ce40d5598760376100d573b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6fbfc7c06218d1d003c92a9d3fd374a3","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"d6edb05265bfd680fcf58e49ee05b7dbfe68c6b77f17ac6c6b0970f6aa23b9ce","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e9f6cdddd5e5c88c22931151b9dd2d01","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":1307,"end":4704,"textSha256":"75cdbcbda398bc937658606360153f2b5dd29fcf1bb0b21a7eac1355800f1c43","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:06628c40200becc64fc049c6","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The proposal separates inflaton-potential and stabilization sources; its quadratic regime is small-field and its fit language is source-dated. Independent challenge qualification: Distinct potential and stabilization sources are proposed; the quadratic description is a small-field regime."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:06628c40200becc64fc049c6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","q025-candidate-question:eb40b8307a12406a757cc9fa"],"scopeContentSha256":"39ff735137f8048d85d666d2e1f1ba6769fa3aeb3e8208c11e35567ad32a9198","contributionContentSha256":"6990e8fef609aab1c3a0298710482c9c5fc635fd4242b2f4e86a1b7cf47b1d9e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-03743073a7938a015819-proposal","leaf-03743073a7938a015819-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:235a00c21c46874ee4a971a1d4fea1904a3d3f088c1297f4fc4c7fc6259dbf76","textSha256":"a2bb29c7231ee9d84fa83c6df6ddfd181db5dece731f024935f4fbf80bdc7533"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6475a36d27af5f426e6dcafc138e18ee","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":3702,"end":5258,"textSha256":"3b386ffdd7e00343d9b8b9c78a87c535d4ebd1153ce40d5598760376100d573b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6fbfc7c06218d1d003c92a9d3fd374a3","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"d6edb05265bfd680fcf58e49ee05b7dbfe68c6b77f17ac6c6b0970f6aa23b9ce","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e9f6cdddd5e5c88c22931151b9dd2d01","paperId":"1505.07871","sourceSha256":"6ee67645af736ce6eecbb4419cffa7dcd659a078ea6f23d6eb1d76228eb4c7fe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2fdae868c00ad5483326/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"68bb48f336f7d6606ff1962134a0dadc2c069e4f390ddd96a5fef10f46e4aece","pdfPage":1,"start":1307,"end":4704,"textSha256":"75cdbcbda398bc937658606360153f2b5dd29fcf1bb0b21a7eac1355800f1c43","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:06628c40200becc64fc049c6","recordId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The proposal separates inflaton-potential and stabilization sources; its quadratic regime is small-field and its fit language is source-dated.","challengeNote":"Distinct potential and stabilization sources are proposed; the quadratic description is a small-field regime.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:53bf2a5e8129d30faba8f8a17ff0fd94fa21b3c96247e3a026580aa96083e23a","home":{"unitId":"unit:53bf2a5e8129d30faba8f8a17ff0fd94fa21b3c96247e3a026580aa96083e23a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e08e1ff12138364f07ce32f8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"This source addresses a question within this scoped destination. Its specific system, regime and source-reading limits remain attached; membership does not equate the source statement with the broader question.","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:53bf2a5e8129d30faba8f8a17ff0fd94fa21b3c96247e3a026580aa96083e23a","textSha256":"4a998adcd17d17d085ab825e25ae11920f01e4cbba68651f814e35663b596a68"}],"decisionId":"decision:organizational-home:cb8abac899001b596ee0da61"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:organizational-home:cb8abac899001b596ee0da61","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:53bf2a5e8129d30faba8f8a17ff0fd94fa21b3c96247e3a026580aa96083e23a","q025-candidate-question:e08e1ff12138364f07ce32f8"],"scopeContentSha256":"ebb77a566177d9ac32a461bcd1b972ed240d5e9b32be836c99a47f7d72bde744","placementContentSha256":"baa091678befbb9adcfddb9d9583fc16e89af5341c737da6d87b4abfd06945c4","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../../evaluation/full-pass/home-admissions-v1/home-policy-admission.json","sha256":"275fd7dc27c397141cee2737c967e070cf75df3c6446f8d5c2e2a3e7cc79d740"}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal","leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:53bf2a5e8129d30faba8f8a17ff0fd94fa21b3c96247e3a026580aa96083e23a","textSha256":"4a998adcd17d17d085ab825e25ae11920f01e4cbba68651f814e35663b596a68"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"decisionId":"decision:organizational-home:cb8abac899001b596ee0da61","sourceContributionDecisionId":"decision:source-contribution:93cf8510e08b35b78198cff1","sourceReviewIds":["leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal","leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge"],"reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-464468c3b62ead8ef802-challenge"},"sourceDescriptionSha256":"4a998adcd17d17d085ab825e25ae11920f01e4cbba68651f814e35663b596a68","sourceScopeContentSha256":"ebb77a566177d9ac32a461bcd1b972ed240d5e9b32be836c99a47f7d72bde744","originalNotesSha256":{"proposal":"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855","challenge":"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855"},"evidenceAgreementIsNotOriginalPlacementAgreement":true}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:53bf2a5e8129d30faba8f8a17ff0fd94fa21b3c96247e3a026580aa96083e23a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:eb40b8307a12406a757cc9fa","role":"instantiates","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:53bf2a5e8129d30faba8f8a17ff0fd94fa21b3c96247e3a026580aa96083e23a","textSha256":"4a998adcd17d17d085ab825e25ae11920f01e4cbba68651f814e35663b596a68"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:65286dd627a42b63ad603bea96bbb0c8","paperId":"0803.3085","sourceSha256":"6e2696a2e8978b93063bce2da8feb810ea337c704211c96b72ff1724395c1e5f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c2ee95d72fd38af9e3cb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7b830c3f85a14d488beba6c1b9e4adbc98a0250f4992282bfbb8a82465099641","pdfPage":4,"start":99,"end":3497,"textSha256":"0cb57f0848ce9e91818f253fd1bdfac2d894e064b3ff03ed0b85238afe4da0a6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8bb19ce54cda3cd7b3374022e02bb707","paperId":"0803.3085","sourceSha256":"6e2696a2e8978b93063bce2da8feb810ea337c704211c96b72ff1724395c1e5f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c2ee95d72fd38af9e3cb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7b830c3f85a14d488beba6c1b9e4adbc98a0250f4992282bfbb8a82465099641","pdfPage":3,"start":101,"end":3364,"textSha256":"ecf297176f9261af02dfd2b7c47d39752d3ef2b3a946edb5ab5c17820057f3de","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b9836ddc3504e3da138b4bb27b706720","paperId":"0803.3085","sourceSha256":"6e2696a2e8978b93063bce2da8feb810ea337c704211c96b72ff1724395c1e5f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c2ee95d72fd38af9e3cb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7b830c3f85a14d488beba6c1b9e4adbc98a0250f4992282bfbb8a82465099641","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":3364,"textSha256":"6fddce70c1b48f2443bc858aa23f9c3b42ef3f96506f4f050068110f299f9d3c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:afca391d64601b8d37f3d159","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Wrapped-D4 motion is distinct from a closed-string axion. The proposed fractional-power regime and excluded quadratic regime must remain separate. Independent challenge qualification: The inflaton is a transported wrapped-D4 coordinate. Its proposed fractional-power regime remains distinct from its excluded quadratic regime."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:afca391d64601b8d37f3d159","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:53bf2a5e8129d30faba8f8a17ff0fd94fa21b3c96247e3a026580aa96083e23a","q025-candidate-question:eb40b8307a12406a757cc9fa"],"scopeContentSha256":"39ff735137f8048d85d666d2e1f1ba6769fa3aeb3e8208c11e35567ad32a9198","contributionContentSha256":"5496b1c8186fc229f43f7228f1878311a75fa4887052e987f6a5a96ab2c9658f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-03743073a7938a015819-proposal","leaf-03743073a7938a015819-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:53bf2a5e8129d30faba8f8a17ff0fd94fa21b3c96247e3a026580aa96083e23a","textSha256":"4a998adcd17d17d085ab825e25ae11920f01e4cbba68651f814e35663b596a68"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:65286dd627a42b63ad603bea96bbb0c8","paperId":"0803.3085","sourceSha256":"6e2696a2e8978b93063bce2da8feb810ea337c704211c96b72ff1724395c1e5f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c2ee95d72fd38af9e3cb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7b830c3f85a14d488beba6c1b9e4adbc98a0250f4992282bfbb8a82465099641","pdfPage":4,"start":99,"end":3497,"textSha256":"0cb57f0848ce9e91818f253fd1bdfac2d894e064b3ff03ed0b85238afe4da0a6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8bb19ce54cda3cd7b3374022e02bb707","paperId":"0803.3085","sourceSha256":"6e2696a2e8978b93063bce2da8feb810ea337c704211c96b72ff1724395c1e5f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c2ee95d72fd38af9e3cb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7b830c3f85a14d488beba6c1b9e4adbc98a0250f4992282bfbb8a82465099641","pdfPage":3,"start":101,"end":3364,"textSha256":"ecf297176f9261af02dfd2b7c47d39752d3ef2b3a946edb5ab5c17820057f3de","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b9836ddc3504e3da138b4bb27b706720","paperId":"0803.3085","sourceSha256":"6e2696a2e8978b93063bce2da8feb810ea337c704211c96b72ff1724395c1e5f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c2ee95d72fd38af9e3cb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7b830c3f85a14d488beba6c1b9e4adbc98a0250f4992282bfbb8a82465099641","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":3364,"textSha256":"6fddce70c1b48f2443bc858aa23f9c3b42ef3f96506f4f050068110f299f9d3c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:afca391d64601b8d37f3d159","recordId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Wrapped-D4 motion is distinct from a closed-string axion. The proposed fractional-power regime and excluded quadratic regime must remain separate.","challengeNote":"The inflaton is a transported wrapped-D4 coordinate. Its proposed fractional-power regime remains distinct from its excluded quadratic regime.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4941cf7c7f6c7000acf0ff52bf5574fddcc59235f517e70e658e3e9435fecd25"},"organizational-access:3e57343368205244e9a674ca":{"id":"organizational-access:3e57343368205244e9a674ca","source":"q025-candidate-question:e2c4083adb09d23e9f378897","target":"q025-candidate-question:20a1895bc31783591d7b5d0a","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e2c4083adb09d23e9f378897","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c859c270c7ba173162d6065b48e1b35d23eb3af94c9c9e50d14abdf2a453b49d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0000daf9353309109a32b14a"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:20a1895bc31783591d7b5d0a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c5d3c2fc9c9d478e9fe815b8b7bd970341a9ec352e2b000a314c76d10c1487fb","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7a6d5c5bb53e50332ff176fa"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:e2247b252c671bb3909d28838a2ace5f528ab4b49ec969a4aa485264887bc85c","home":{"unitId":"unit:e2247b252c671bb3909d28838a2ace5f528ab4b49ec969a4aa485264887bc85c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e2c4083adb09d23e9f378897","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q11 explicitly covers local Wheeler–DeWitt measures, finite anthropic probabilities and terminal Minkowski settings; inflation-scale predictions are outputs of that measure.","qualification":"q11 includes the named measure, finite anthropic probabilities and terminal Minkowski sectors. The inflationary-scale prediction is a selection output of this measure, and creation mechanisms, ETW branes and transitions are expressly dependencies of that output. No independent brane-construction or observational-fit task is added or omitted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e2247b252c671bb3909d28838a2ace5f528ab4b49ec969a4aa485264887bc85c","paperId":"2411.11944","textSha256":"73a0a49dbfd28cd72182ccf0b113eaa03f39da044b475ebfebc7327439497cc1"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0058:u12:q11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0058:u12:q11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e2247b252c671bb3909d28838a2ace5f528ab4b49ec969a4aa485264887bc85c","q025-candidate-question:e2c4083adb09d23e9f378897"],"scopeContentSha256":"c859c270c7ba173162d6065b48e1b35d23eb3af94c9c9e50d14abdf2a453b49d","placementContentSha256":"59e2b13b99af4269df87a9d085ea8af7d5c9db17a37e9bb7665c0a37ad6cab35","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0058:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0058:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e2247b252c671bb3909d28838a2ace5f528ab4b49ec969a4aa485264887bc85c","paperId":"2411.11944","textSha256":"73a0a49dbfd28cd72182ccf0b113eaa03f39da044b475ebfebc7327439497cc1"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0058","unitRef":"u12"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e2247b252c671bb3909d28838a2ace5f528ab4b49ec969a4aa485264887bc85c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:20a1895bc31783591d7b5d0a","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d63","kind":"description","unitIndex":63,"unitId":"unit:e2247b252c671bb3909d28838a2ace5f528ab4b49ec969a4aa485264887bc85c","textSha256":"73a0a49dbfd28cd72182ccf0b113eaa03f39da044b475ebfebc7327439497cc1"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:62f1759ab8b5fe4e7bdb116f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:62f1759ab8b5fe4e7bdb116f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e2247b252c671bb3909d28838a2ace5f528ab4b49ec969a4aa485264887bc85c","q025-candidate-question:20a1895bc31783591d7b5d0a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c5d3c2fc9c9d478e9fe815b8b7bd970341a9ec352e2b000a314c76d10c1487fb","contributionContentSha256":"1fd42392487f15235eb8ebdd6544c3f17ccfe0d0d2e0132c0b9006bebdf64444","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d63","kind":"description","unitIndex":63,"unitId":"unit:e2247b252c671bb3909d28838a2ace5f528ab4b49ec969a4aa485264887bc85c","textSha256":"73a0a49dbfd28cd72182ccf0b113eaa03f39da044b475ebfebc7327439497cc1"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:62f1759ab8b5fe4e7bdb116f","recordId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Creation mechanisms, ETW branes and transitions remain distinct dependencies of the proposed measure.","challengeNote":"Source-scoped measure question; inflation-scale predictions and creation, ETW-brane and transition dependencies need separate reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"311274002e4c1708708e5e8edd583948a7222f5d1872f6c1b18ec91f6576834d"},"organizational-access:12f655b639eb2c669d1fbb2a":{"id":"organizational-access:12f655b639eb2c669d1fbb2a","source":"q025-candidate-question:e375e3a777fbccf230745197","target":"q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e375e3a777fbccf230745197","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b8690d50ae925a10733b1c0ed0093ad211a7ab9a281f6602efd807466a69051e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6b9395b19a6c8832d154028f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"aa5be41770333084b6014c6ea4ebee7f07d662ac4b16a425057f660d33e7713e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d4c1f7c6dcceb1c95c37b70e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:82fba453d189628b9112e7c6a9b795a9fdbba4d2b8f7f48a1613ffcb2d04b707","home":{"unitId":"unit:82fba453d189628b9112e7c6a9b795a9fdbba4d2b8f7f48a1613ffcb2d04b707","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e375e3a777fbccf230745197","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q16 covers potential- and initial-data-dependent scalar evolution, tracking behavior and acceleration without imposing slow roll generally.","qualification":"q16 covers dependence of homogeneous evolution on potential couplings and initial data, including scaling attraction and acceleration. Its source-specific treatment of slow roll accommodates the stated absence of that assumption. Complete convergence hypotheses are needed to verify a theorem, not to locate the question asking when convergence occurs.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:82fba453d189628b9112e7c6a9b795a9fdbba4d2b8f7f48a1613ffcb2d04b707","paperId":"2306.07327","textSha256":"9e443f4f8a2c80a0826ead2b309206846354c6313c24e712548502c4246ce54f"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0057:u21:q16"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0057:u21:q16","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:82fba453d189628b9112e7c6a9b795a9fdbba4d2b8f7f48a1613ffcb2d04b707","q025-candidate-question:e375e3a777fbccf230745197"],"scopeContentSha256":"b8690d50ae925a10733b1c0ed0093ad211a7ab9a281f6602efd807466a69051e","placementContentSha256":"2b048b9f6bb90919d4d88468eb9b8ed895207f0c98a093705ca5e34b25d35909","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0057:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0057:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:82fba453d189628b9112e7c6a9b795a9fdbba4d2b8f7f48a1613ffcb2d04b707","paperId":"2306.07327","textSha256":"9e443f4f8a2c80a0826ead2b309206846354c6313c24e712548502c4246ce54f"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0057","unitRef":"u21"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:82fba453d189628b9112e7c6a9b795a9fdbba4d2b8f7f48a1613ffcb2d04b707","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d67","kind":"description","unitIndex":67,"unitId":"unit:82fba453d189628b9112e7c6a9b795a9fdbba4d2b8f7f48a1613ffcb2d04b707","textSha256":"9e443f4f8a2c80a0826ead2b309206846354c6313c24e712548502c4246ce54f"},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6b0362426ec70713d1655190ebfd2fbf","paperId":"2306.07327","sourceSha256":"b31222433f33f8705b3ecffc3674b9716a6f4bb39befea9e8dd3217bad110817","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d6ff73c7c09777e027b/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12b7f74f9d74ce4deaca48ee39e364f630b3c8a3b561654bcc74a76c4734db84","pdfPage":2,"start":96,"end":3495,"textSha256":"07b80b69e6f98c7c21bcdc8b3950c5417a18c214424356c2b3cf84ee65d27b2a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:96afbe7de94a6368600e3a1e81e7d3ba","paperId":"2306.07327","sourceSha256":"b31222433f33f8705b3ecffc3674b9716a6f4bb39befea9e8dd3217bad110817","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d6ff73c7c09777e027b/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12b7f74f9d74ce4deaca48ee39e364f630b3c8a3b561654bcc74a76c4734db84","pdfPage":1,"start":3688,"end":5300,"textSha256":"125e69d154f39e42ac796a12e6d61ceccd8b3c3c3d995281ac85ad592e69e9b4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e40893754a9cbcac69cb14d2c6bbc4ba","paperId":"2306.07327","sourceSha256":"b31222433f33f8705b3ecffc3674b9716a6f4bb39befea9e8dd3217bad110817","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d6ff73c7c09777e027b/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12b7f74f9d74ce4deaca48ee39e364f630b3c8a3b561654bcc74a76c4734db84","pdfPage":1,"start":2498,"end":5300,"textSha256":"3aab35f8a1a5f801d2a9516f566034b5a02cec92e8d047da2c259497fd17b67a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d0a622c60b1359eab64d1c53"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d0a622c60b1359eab64d1c53","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:82fba453d189628b9112e7c6a9b795a9fdbba4d2b8f7f48a1613ffcb2d04b707","q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef"],"scopeContentSha256":"aa5be41770333084b6014c6ea4ebee7f07d662ac4b16a425057f660d33e7713e","contributionContentSha256":"3758f5c8aea93f5ae035bd5bab8e9e5724d692701971cab7644aefca053f5e11","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d67","kind":"description","unitIndex":67,"unitId":"unit:82fba453d189628b9112e7c6a9b795a9fdbba4d2b8f7f48a1613ffcb2d04b707","textSha256":"9e443f4f8a2c80a0826ead2b309206846354c6313c24e712548502c4246ce54f"},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6b0362426ec70713d1655190ebfd2fbf","paperId":"2306.07327","sourceSha256":"b31222433f33f8705b3ecffc3674b9716a6f4bb39befea9e8dd3217bad110817","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d6ff73c7c09777e027b/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12b7f74f9d74ce4deaca48ee39e364f630b3c8a3b561654bcc74a76c4734db84","pdfPage":2,"start":96,"end":3495,"textSha256":"07b80b69e6f98c7c21bcdc8b3950c5417a18c214424356c2b3cf84ee65d27b2a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:96afbe7de94a6368600e3a1e81e7d3ba","paperId":"2306.07327","sourceSha256":"b31222433f33f8705b3ecffc3674b9716a6f4bb39befea9e8dd3217bad110817","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d6ff73c7c09777e027b/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12b7f74f9d74ce4deaca48ee39e364f630b3c8a3b561654bcc74a76c4734db84","pdfPage":1,"start":3688,"end":5300,"textSha256":"125e69d154f39e42ac796a12e6d61ceccd8b3c3c3d995281ac85ad592e69e9b4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e40893754a9cbcac69cb14d2c6bbc4ba","paperId":"2306.07327","sourceSha256":"b31222433f33f8705b3ecffc3674b9716a6f4bb39befea9e8dd3217bad110817","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8d6ff73c7c09777e027b/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12b7f74f9d74ce4deaca48ee39e364f630b3c8a3b561654bcc74a76c4734db84","pdfPage":1,"start":2498,"end":5300,"textSha256":"3aab35f8a1a5f801d2a9516f566034b5a02cec92e8d047da2c259497fd17b67a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d0a622c60b1359eab64d1c53","recordId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"No slow roll or string assumption is required for the announced general results. Complete convergence hypotheses and proofs are not supplied.","challengeNote":"The announced general results assume neither slow roll nor a string origin. Full convergence hypotheses and proofs are outside these excerpts.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ce1781c0c89d54fdf0e43014616d3c4f14bf57ae46e0d4f7c15bd20e7b1fbe73"},"organizational-access:0651a2e826fad482f5408cd2":{"id":"organizational-access:0651a2e826fad482f5408cd2","source":"q025-candidate-question:e7dd9e64e880a68126257008","target":"q025-candidate-question:69a65a29a24da5c816ab43e1","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e7dd9e64e880a68126257008","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"4d9c19d0b285c63220bfd0bc6acd5feddb5aaa5403f32db7fa0d7907f952a477","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1f62d77a16c5aa4f562d4665"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:69a65a29a24da5c816ab43e1","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"eaa0067db04e9b74861005ad97f4698871ee86a161a2d759d484ca8143eb1520","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f1c6b1738a58be09d5a2d0ff"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4ea3981c7bacabc42813050df040b7a5dcd8c3f239caba4343b39cd2452bde9e","home":{"unitId":"unit:4ea3981c7bacabc42813050df040b7a5dcd8c3f239caba4343b39cd2452bde9e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e7dd9e64e880a68126257008","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q12 expressly includes both perturbative loop control and conditional potential reconstruction in PBH and induced-GW settings.","qualification":"q12 explicitly covers perturbative reliability and conditional reconstruction together. The cubic-interaction, generalized E-type and PBH qualifications remain intact. Tree-level enhancement, loop corrections and induced tensors are distinct calculations; small loops and successful or unique inversion are not assumed.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4ea3981c7bacabc42813050df040b7a5dcd8c3f239caba4343b39cd2452bde9e","paperId":"2502.00628","textSha256":"d00bf997fab6348fa6e489464bb000fb85d88b86a4c70691dffa96c34dc4a211"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0047:u7:q12"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0047:u7:q12","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4ea3981c7bacabc42813050df040b7a5dcd8c3f239caba4343b39cd2452bde9e","q025-candidate-question:e7dd9e64e880a68126257008"],"scopeContentSha256":"4d9c19d0b285c63220bfd0bc6acd5feddb5aaa5403f32db7fa0d7907f952a477","placementContentSha256":"eb75e33a45f8ab33d58e73e4ad1e5aee03de0d17ecb964021e870f3a2ebde956","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0047:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0047:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4ea3981c7bacabc42813050df040b7a5dcd8c3f239caba4343b39cd2452bde9e","paperId":"2502.00628","textSha256":"d00bf997fab6348fa6e489464bb000fb85d88b86a4c70691dffa96c34dc4a211"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0047","unitRef":"u7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4ea3981c7bacabc42813050df040b7a5dcd8c3f239caba4343b39cd2452bde9e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:69a65a29a24da5c816ab43e1","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:4ea3981c7bacabc42813050df040b7a5dcd8c3f239caba4343b39cd2452bde9e","textSha256":"d00bf997fab6348fa6e489464bb000fb85d88b86a4c70691dffa96c34dc4a211"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5fb6b298baf3d2788e8ccd5b33df0a22","paperId":"2502.00628","sourceSha256":"6394c803b60888082f18f5a26495dc5c80591db1e88c5890677d5cf2e56be176","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d9015b6c633521412a95/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"979092fd240505e7dfd1d02ffa29a6b7c7e3491aed38f73f3c7c23f2d891d874","pdfPage":3,"start":96,"end":3493,"textSha256":"1a9fb24b80dd08ece1eec7693818adc5cf12f18b7091339ee473f12d240e4a35","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9697a2f409a286a98a6e6ac3c8489339","paperId":"2502.00628","sourceSha256":"6394c803b60888082f18f5a26495dc5c80591db1e88c5890677d5cf2e56be176","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d9015b6c633521412a95/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"979092fd240505e7dfd1d02ffa29a6b7c7e3491aed38f73f3c7c23f2d891d874","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":3590,"textSha256":"7cf278e640f974a4697262782cb128cae5fb01372a42a67220a898fc6dfa651a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fd2ef220be4a24534de55e08"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:fd2ef220be4a24534de55e08","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4ea3981c7bacabc42813050df040b7a5dcd8c3f239caba4343b39cd2452bde9e","q025-candidate-question:69a65a29a24da5c816ab43e1"],"scopeContentSha256":"eaa0067db04e9b74861005ad97f4698871ee86a161a2d759d484ca8143eb1520","contributionContentSha256":"99c1a65946fc488c00c44c98f3e45c87062ad39f5d9a240841f86614a3318157","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1af99ca66bfed8e0bf6f-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1af99ca66bfed8e0bf6f-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1af99ca66bfed8e0bf6f-proposal","leaf-1af99ca66bfed8e0bf6f-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:4ea3981c7bacabc42813050df040b7a5dcd8c3f239caba4343b39cd2452bde9e","textSha256":"d00bf997fab6348fa6e489464bb000fb85d88b86a4c70691dffa96c34dc4a211"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5fb6b298baf3d2788e8ccd5b33df0a22","paperId":"2502.00628","sourceSha256":"6394c803b60888082f18f5a26495dc5c80591db1e88c5890677d5cf2e56be176","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d9015b6c633521412a95/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"979092fd240505e7dfd1d02ffa29a6b7c7e3491aed38f73f3c7c23f2d891d874","pdfPage":3,"start":96,"end":3493,"textSha256":"1a9fb24b80dd08ece1eec7693818adc5cf12f18b7091339ee473f12d240e4a35","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9697a2f409a286a98a6e6ac3c8489339","paperId":"2502.00628","sourceSha256":"6394c803b60888082f18f5a26495dc5c80591db1e88c5890677d5cf2e56be176","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d9015b6c633521412a95/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"979092fd240505e7dfd1d02ffa29a6b7c7e3491aed38f73f3c7c23f2d891d874","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":3590,"textSha256":"7cf278e640f974a4697262782cb128cae5fb01372a42a67220a898fc6dfa651a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fd2ef220be4a24534de55e08","recordId":"leaf-1af99ca66bfed8e0bf6f-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1af99ca66bfed8e0bf6f-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1af99ca66bfed8e0bf6f-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Loop reliability and GW inverse reconstruction require separate fine reconciliation. The outside-probe label does not negate explicit α-attractor content.","challengeNote":"Loop reliability and GW inversion require fine reconciliation. Explicit α-attractor content supports membership despite the outside-probe selection label.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a39a947aab8b932b18d713557a69c1815584a3ea89b525e3c5e816bfa224ba71"},"organizational-access:9841db577941cddb43841031":{"id":"organizational-access:9841db577941cddb43841031","source":"q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054","target":"q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"4767c28a27ce8e5b6989c54df86e541d42a48775c23459fc0b6d2b1c3a9a1673","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e37bc9192bb6818b506804f0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f16d7c6925c58fc6cc4780df20a2710cc059337859d448a292b284a99da67751","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2badfce555218a7b4016382f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1f60dca66eed8c1c21492f7246b43ee45b28fcc5822a568510ab051ce19d3a80","home":{"unitId":"unit:1f60dca66eed8c1c21492f7246b43ee45b28fcc5822a568510ab051ce19d3a80","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1f60dca66eed8c1c21492f7246b43ee45b28fcc5822a568510ab051ce19d3a80","paperId":"1808.05958","textSha256":"a908d4363c7a7df9554e14b169a7783f46844a6451331013546de5641512d12e"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ed37ab37ee383458ec0fa22f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ed37ab37ee383458ec0fa22f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1f60dca66eed8c1c21492f7246b43ee45b28fcc5822a568510ab051ce19d3a80","q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054"],"scopeContentSha256":"4767c28a27ce8e5b6989c54df86e541d42a48775c23459fc0b6d2b1c3a9a1673","placementContentSha256":"8003fea3182914f30c26a79c613c1badf627a48e5fd4db89a356783fc3af6d74","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1f60dca66eed8c1c21492f7246b43ee45b28fcc5822a568510ab051ce19d3a80","paperId":"1808.05958","textSha256":"a908d4363c7a7df9554e14b169a7783f46844a6451331013546de5641512d12e"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ed37ab37ee383458ec0fa22f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1f60dca66eed8c1c21492f7246b43ee45b28fcc5822a568510ab051ce19d3a80","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:1f60dca66eed8c1c21492f7246b43ee45b28fcc5822a568510ab051ce19d3a80","textSha256":"a908d4363c7a7df9554e14b169a7783f46844a6451331013546de5641512d12e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ecf2432a7563a6ca3e5f2a49"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ecf2432a7563a6ca3e5f2a49","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1f60dca66eed8c1c21492f7246b43ee45b28fcc5822a568510ab051ce19d3a80","q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392"],"scopeContentSha256":"f16d7c6925c58fc6cc4780df20a2710cc059337859d448a292b284a99da67751","contributionContentSha256":"4ebe842fc8ca86ef91de4e6ce84f7b04cd02266b76b661393916985232a85136","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:1f60dca66eed8c1c21492f7246b43ee45b28fcc5822a568510ab051ce19d3a80","textSha256":"a908d4363c7a7df9554e14b169a7783f46844a6451331013546de5641512d12e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ecf2432a7563a6ca3e5f2a49","recordId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"State persistence and persistence of superextremality are separate tests.","challengeNote":"Persistence of states and persistence of superextremality are separate tests.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:347b6240c2a4f3313867dec7b09625f7a2ed91f981838ed20aa7a45ac3141dff","home":{"unitId":"unit:347b6240c2a4f3313867dec7b09625f7a2ed91f981838ed20aa7a45ac3141dff","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:347b6240c2a4f3313867dec7b09625f7a2ed91f981838ed20aa7a45ac3141dff","paperId":"2011.08854","textSha256":"1c3262c92ea4b459ea02e433ade97272844a68cd0bfb5fd793a1e8f567fbf79c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7953447e3a475d79a1b677c8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7953447e3a475d79a1b677c8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:347b6240c2a4f3313867dec7b09625f7a2ed91f981838ed20aa7a45ac3141dff","q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054"],"scopeContentSha256":"4767c28a27ce8e5b6989c54df86e541d42a48775c23459fc0b6d2b1c3a9a1673","placementContentSha256":"3c96956b77a6bd1ff5643dd17a96d96077b0f7f813ff5f83d8d7950094353b45","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:347b6240c2a4f3313867dec7b09625f7a2ed91f981838ed20aa7a45ac3141dff","paperId":"2011.08854","textSha256":"1c3262c92ea4b459ea02e433ade97272844a68cd0bfb5fd793a1e8f567fbf79c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7953447e3a475d79a1b677c8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:347b6240c2a4f3313867dec7b09625f7a2ed91f981838ed20aa7a45ac3141dff","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:347b6240c2a4f3313867dec7b09625f7a2ed91f981838ed20aa7a45ac3141dff","textSha256":"1c3262c92ea4b459ea02e433ade97272844a68cd0bfb5fd793a1e8f567fbf79c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:36444e1645bcce2c5835d31d"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:36444e1645bcce2c5835d31d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:347b6240c2a4f3313867dec7b09625f7a2ed91f981838ed20aa7a45ac3141dff","q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392"],"scopeContentSha256":"f16d7c6925c58fc6cc4780df20a2710cc059337859d448a292b284a99da67751","contributionContentSha256":"21ff21ac171df56fa6c92f14ff334beb440a555620755aea20a4b8affc0c0b12","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:347b6240c2a4f3313867dec7b09625f7a2ed91f981838ed20aa7a45ac3141dff","textSha256":"1c3262c92ea4b459ea02e433ade97272844a68cd0bfb5fd793a1e8f567fbf79c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:36444e1645bcce2c5835d31d","recordId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:35df5678118094ddbad23f740bba1a730b7070bf8b70cbf0df356276c8be4b5e","home":{"unitId":"unit:35df5678118094ddbad23f740bba1a730b7070bf8b70cbf0df356276c8be4b5e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:35df5678118094ddbad23f740bba1a730b7070bf8b70cbf0df356276c8be4b5e","paperId":"2004.10768","textSha256":"00a26eca98648ffe0c15bbfa0496ac016e561217e7e6e8b1aaacc0180dae3478"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:00d1ac71fafd9442840eeb32"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:00d1ac71fafd9442840eeb32","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:35df5678118094ddbad23f740bba1a730b7070bf8b70cbf0df356276c8be4b5e","q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054"],"scopeContentSha256":"4767c28a27ce8e5b6989c54df86e541d42a48775c23459fc0b6d2b1c3a9a1673","placementContentSha256":"f8c92accf5a13b6494f63e72350bf0924457a5a3e78587a4b83651555fff63fb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:35df5678118094ddbad23f740bba1a730b7070bf8b70cbf0df356276c8be4b5e","paperId":"2004.10768","textSha256":"00a26eca98648ffe0c15bbfa0496ac016e561217e7e6e8b1aaacc0180dae3478"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:00d1ac71fafd9442840eeb32"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:35df5678118094ddbad23f740bba1a730b7070bf8b70cbf0df356276c8be4b5e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:35df5678118094ddbad23f740bba1a730b7070bf8b70cbf0df356276c8be4b5e","textSha256":"00a26eca98648ffe0c15bbfa0496ac016e561217e7e6e8b1aaacc0180dae3478"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b5cd0df98781db174a7cc4c3"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b5cd0df98781db174a7cc4c3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:35df5678118094ddbad23f740bba1a730b7070bf8b70cbf0df356276c8be4b5e","q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392"],"scopeContentSha256":"f16d7c6925c58fc6cc4780df20a2710cc059337859d448a292b284a99da67751","contributionContentSha256":"906bc94ccd559363f5cc1c2a42977f3589da2d3e54623f95586f4d25c238f7dd","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:35df5678118094ddbad23f740bba1a730b7070bf8b70cbf0df356276c8be4b5e","textSha256":"00a26eca98648ffe0c15bbfa0496ac016e561217e7e6e8b1aaacc0180dae3478"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b5cd0df98781db174a7cc4c3","recordId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The full charged-tower route is broader than the gauge-sector existence question.","challengeNote":"The complete charged-tower SDC route asks more than whether a suitable gauge sector exists.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:585dfe643fda6f61f2bf179c5a1c27f7b8fbed527984e17ad15db4a28269025e","home":{"unitId":"unit:585dfe643fda6f61f2bf179c5a1c27f7b8fbed527984e17ad15db4a28269025e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:585dfe643fda6f61f2bf179c5a1c27f7b8fbed527984e17ad15db4a28269025e","paperId":"2505.22713","textSha256":"0a5b6d6c899201f2b1cb1c39dce9ac01ee7988ce25fb7a1c8c0e2af1dfa25086"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ac4c650d442b1a8f9c413ce4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ac4c650d442b1a8f9c413ce4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:585dfe643fda6f61f2bf179c5a1c27f7b8fbed527984e17ad15db4a28269025e","q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054"],"scopeContentSha256":"4767c28a27ce8e5b6989c54df86e541d42a48775c23459fc0b6d2b1c3a9a1673","placementContentSha256":"d6003d7e80391c799f8ad53381f323b6828ade3c298800bf7455b6c6524ed1d0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:585dfe643fda6f61f2bf179c5a1c27f7b8fbed527984e17ad15db4a28269025e","paperId":"2505.22713","textSha256":"0a5b6d6c899201f2b1cb1c39dce9ac01ee7988ce25fb7a1c8c0e2af1dfa25086"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ac4c650d442b1a8f9c413ce4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:585dfe643fda6f61f2bf179c5a1c27f7b8fbed527984e17ad15db4a28269025e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:585dfe643fda6f61f2bf179c5a1c27f7b8fbed527984e17ad15db4a28269025e","textSha256":"0a5b6d6c899201f2b1cb1c39dce9ac01ee7988ce25fb7a1c8c0e2af1dfa25086"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7a738693b9ec409be60966bb"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7a738693b9ec409be60966bb","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:585dfe643fda6f61f2bf179c5a1c27f7b8fbed527984e17ad15db4a28269025e","q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392"],"scopeContentSha256":"f16d7c6925c58fc6cc4780df20a2710cc059337859d448a292b284a99da67751","contributionContentSha256":"bfb3355ef90cfe3d9b06fb0e6399bed81ba4164bd47f835a1c57d3c17d923a3c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:585dfe643fda6f61f2bf179c5a1c27f7b8fbed527984e17ad15db4a28269025e","textSha256":"0a5b6d6c899201f2b1cb1c39dce9ac01ee7988ce25fb7a1c8c0e2af1dfa25086"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7a738693b9ec409be60966bb","recordId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Comparability, alignment and geometric consequences are connected but distinct proposed targets.","challengeNote":"Ratio comparability, charge alignment and geometric constraints are connected but distinct proposed targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:7e76495a7292e07fa3cdd3f5ee24317c445f091ffb3fa97c5b055387ca463dfb","home":{"unitId":"unit:7e76495a7292e07fa3cdd3f5ee24317c445f091ffb3fa97c5b055387ca463dfb","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7e76495a7292e07fa3cdd3f5ee24317c445f091ffb3fa97c5b055387ca463dfb","paperId":"2004.10768","textSha256":"7e86536574492a687bdd0163cd26f3a27a2412abf53751803728e3f048047ae4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cc2776c6f33c0d2a45762579"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cc2776c6f33c0d2a45762579","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7e76495a7292e07fa3cdd3f5ee24317c445f091ffb3fa97c5b055387ca463dfb","q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054"],"scopeContentSha256":"4767c28a27ce8e5b6989c54df86e541d42a48775c23459fc0b6d2b1c3a9a1673","placementContentSha256":"bc45c26bbb0b9e1ea872ef26fbd61a97a25135f8241ce2a5c0efaf950b95e1c3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7e76495a7292e07fa3cdd3f5ee24317c445f091ffb3fa97c5b055387ca463dfb","paperId":"2004.10768","textSha256":"7e86536574492a687bdd0163cd26f3a27a2412abf53751803728e3f048047ae4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cc2776c6f33c0d2a45762579"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7e76495a7292e07fa3cdd3f5ee24317c445f091ffb3fa97c5b055387ca463dfb","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:7e76495a7292e07fa3cdd3f5ee24317c445f091ffb3fa97c5b055387ca463dfb","textSha256":"7e86536574492a687bdd0163cd26f3a27a2412abf53751803728e3f048047ae4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cce7c0513fe3fff26d1d07ff"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:cce7c0513fe3fff26d1d07ff","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7e76495a7292e07fa3cdd3f5ee24317c445f091ffb3fa97c5b055387ca463dfb","q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392"],"scopeContentSha256":"f16d7c6925c58fc6cc4780df20a2710cc059337859d448a292b284a99da67751","contributionContentSha256":"c6d2ef115005f01bef1c978f0dc3d1fdf25a38a8aacf47b55030eb1b62f3aba0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:7e76495a7292e07fa3cdd3f5ee24317c445f091ffb3fa97c5b055387ca463dfb","textSha256":"7e86536574492a687bdd0163cd26f3a27a2412abf53751803728e3f048047ae4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cce7c0513fe3fff26d1d07ff","recordId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a5cc40c3dad5424b3e675c57cdb98fc65b96b68998461984671e875a27675518","home":{"unitId":"unit:a5cc40c3dad5424b3e675c57cdb98fc65b96b68998461984671e875a27675518","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a5cc40c3dad5424b3e675c57cdb98fc65b96b68998461984671e875a27675518","paperId":"1901.08065","textSha256":"e187ecbc7a21dfa85d7dc724ef55cb5d6d2b2daad1a48070390317fee9942a9e"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c5f436f991b45f0de6f46fb5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c5f436f991b45f0de6f46fb5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a5cc40c3dad5424b3e675c57cdb98fc65b96b68998461984671e875a27675518","q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054"],"scopeContentSha256":"4767c28a27ce8e5b6989c54df86e541d42a48775c23459fc0b6d2b1c3a9a1673","placementContentSha256":"136f1931075eae9c95a9c3889cdabe6cdff7987cc9833384c52f3632fe98750c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a5cc40c3dad5424b3e675c57cdb98fc65b96b68998461984671e875a27675518","paperId":"1901.08065","textSha256":"e187ecbc7a21dfa85d7dc724ef55cb5d6d2b2daad1a48070390317fee9942a9e"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c5f436f991b45f0de6f46fb5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a5cc40c3dad5424b3e675c57cdb98fc65b96b68998461984671e875a27675518","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:a5cc40c3dad5424b3e675c57cdb98fc65b96b68998461984671e875a27675518","textSha256":"e187ecbc7a21dfa85d7dc724ef55cb5d6d2b2daad1a48070390317fee9942a9e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aba21ff01422c1dfd4eaf3d8"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:aba21ff01422c1dfd4eaf3d8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a5cc40c3dad5424b3e675c57cdb98fc65b96b68998461984671e875a27675518","q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392"],"scopeContentSha256":"f16d7c6925c58fc6cc4780df20a2710cc059337859d448a292b284a99da67751","contributionContentSha256":"5140eb9cf5fb7b496877a60c909b1ac9c2e6d169fde68c48efeac848c1a9afc5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:a5cc40c3dad5424b3e675c57cdb98fc65b96b68998461984671e875a27675518","textSha256":"e187ecbc7a21dfa85d7dc724ef55cb5d6d2b2daad1a48070390317fee9942a9e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aba21ff01422c1dfd4eaf3d8","recordId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Gauge-flux sensitivity remains part of the tower question.","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b6ba9366d5236b8db613a047e515ef2bfa7fa8a6719f021dad87e4b088456375","home":{"unitId":"unit:b6ba9366d5236b8db613a047e515ef2bfa7fa8a6719f021dad87e4b088456375","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b6ba9366d5236b8db613a047e515ef2bfa7fa8a6719f021dad87e4b088456375","paperId":"2510.23192","textSha256":"16375b48004c61b06007c40c43ff2e145a0e1c5914b69572423c5060877bed0b"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:033051e314674fa11f97b612"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:033051e314674fa11f97b612","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b6ba9366d5236b8db613a047e515ef2bfa7fa8a6719f021dad87e4b088456375","q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054"],"scopeContentSha256":"4767c28a27ce8e5b6989c54df86e541d42a48775c23459fc0b6d2b1c3a9a1673","placementContentSha256":"94c2c79d662f195df1664dba87bdba335ad4f3a96fae57b3fe6eb1306aa99c96","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b6ba9366d5236b8db613a047e515ef2bfa7fa8a6719f021dad87e4b088456375","paperId":"2510.23192","textSha256":"16375b48004c61b06007c40c43ff2e145a0e1c5914b69572423c5060877bed0b"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:033051e314674fa11f97b612"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b6ba9366d5236b8db613a047e515ef2bfa7fa8a6719f021dad87e4b088456375","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:b6ba9366d5236b8db613a047e515ef2bfa7fa8a6719f021dad87e4b088456375","textSha256":"16375b48004c61b06007c40c43ff2e145a0e1c5914b69572423c5060877bed0b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ce5ded36dba34b1687d1ccfc"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ce5ded36dba34b1687d1ccfc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b6ba9366d5236b8db613a047e515ef2bfa7fa8a6719f021dad87e4b088456375","q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392"],"scopeContentSha256":"f16d7c6925c58fc6cc4780df20a2710cc059337859d448a292b284a99da67751","contributionContentSha256":"b9f1cf8d7be1800de369894f29c41cabecde8883f26f8afbb07ef69d03d24800","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:b6ba9366d5236b8db613a047e515ef2bfa7fa8a6719f021dad87e4b088456375","textSha256":"16375b48004c61b06007c40c43ff2e145a0e1c5914b69572423c5060877bed0b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ce5ded36dba34b1687d1ccfc","recordId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound minimal-WGC tower test and weak/strong spectral correspondence.","challengeNote":"Compound minimal-WGC tower test and weak/strong spectral correspondence.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d12ea05930a33153578a3ffbf5e5f43e742d07860ecf070f53371d9ad074dd8c","home":{"unitId":"unit:d12ea05930a33153578a3ffbf5e5f43e742d07860ecf070f53371d9ad074dd8c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d12ea05930a33153578a3ffbf5e5f43e742d07860ecf070f53371d9ad074dd8c","paperId":"2212.09758","textSha256":"5c40a9a8dd066ff8dceea42ba926780024243722de662526d37f36b7a5eb77de"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0b7b1d8ebc57130fc3c6286ec2efa6a3","paperId":"2212.09758","sourceSha256":"7aa624448a2f1e6d538d52d4714c936901ae174dc66e7dac97c3bb886fbcf05b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ad905cd2e07e4e024a5a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"603bca1102f84846bd266b59b2a99f319bcc8b8e423d6042e70774a7315ceafc","pdfPage":12,"start":0,"end":2392,"textSha256":"c09a68e7f7678d56030f94684e19dcffd84dfe49e5fc870c43021978a080b1f6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eca45b81f24fef65e88ba354fce95912","paperId":"2212.09758","sourceSha256":"7aa624448a2f1e6d538d52d4714c936901ae174dc66e7dac97c3bb886fbcf05b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ad905cd2e07e4e024a5a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"603bca1102f84846bd266b59b2a99f319bcc8b8e423d6042e70774a7315ceafc","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f0d7c3b27ea437e3c0c8ae34ad242e50efb4f5c11327f5680ccfdad44bb7ec56","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:62a656d9f7ea304c117e28eb"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:62a656d9f7ea304c117e28eb","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d12ea05930a33153578a3ffbf5e5f43e742d07860ecf070f53371d9ad074dd8c","q025-candidate-region:0125afaa2cbd203936f8d054"],"scopeContentSha256":"4767c28a27ce8e5b6989c54df86e541d42a48775c23459fc0b6d2b1c3a9a1673","placementContentSha256":"ad815f35adedac4f7125e086fee5216ddb02d71499d4c2a623e421dfb239742f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d12ea05930a33153578a3ffbf5e5f43e742d07860ecf070f53371d9ad074dd8c","paperId":"2212.09758","textSha256":"5c40a9a8dd066ff8dceea42ba926780024243722de662526d37f36b7a5eb77de"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0b7b1d8ebc57130fc3c6286ec2efa6a3","paperId":"2212.09758","sourceSha256":"7aa624448a2f1e6d538d52d4714c936901ae174dc66e7dac97c3bb886fbcf05b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ad905cd2e07e4e024a5a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"603bca1102f84846bd266b59b2a99f319bcc8b8e423d6042e70774a7315ceafc","pdfPage":12,"start":0,"end":2392,"textSha256":"c09a68e7f7678d56030f94684e19dcffd84dfe49e5fc870c43021978a080b1f6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eca45b81f24fef65e88ba354fce95912","paperId":"2212.09758","sourceSha256":"7aa624448a2f1e6d538d52d4714c936901ae174dc66e7dac97c3bb886fbcf05b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ad905cd2e07e4e024a5a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"603bca1102f84846bd266b59b2a99f319bcc8b8e423d6042e70774a7315ceafc","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f0d7c3b27ea437e3c0c8ae34ad242e50efb4f5c11327f5680ccfdad44bb7ec56","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:62a656d9f7ea304c117e28eb"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d12ea05930a33153578a3ffbf5e5f43e742d07860ecf070f53371d9ad074dd8c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d29","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:d12ea05930a33153578a3ffbf5e5f43e742d07860ecf070f53371d9ad074dd8c","textSha256":"5c40a9a8dd066ff8dceea42ba926780024243722de662526d37f36b7a5eb77de"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0b7b1d8ebc57130fc3c6286ec2efa6a3","paperId":"2212.09758","sourceSha256":"7aa624448a2f1e6d538d52d4714c936901ae174dc66e7dac97c3bb886fbcf05b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ad905cd2e07e4e024a5a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"603bca1102f84846bd266b59b2a99f319bcc8b8e423d6042e70774a7315ceafc","pdfPage":12,"start":0,"end":2392,"textSha256":"c09a68e7f7678d56030f94684e19dcffd84dfe49e5fc870c43021978a080b1f6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eca45b81f24fef65e88ba354fce95912","paperId":"2212.09758","sourceSha256":"7aa624448a2f1e6d538d52d4714c936901ae174dc66e7dac97c3bb886fbcf05b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ad905cd2e07e4e024a5a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"603bca1102f84846bd266b59b2a99f319bcc8b8e423d6042e70774a7315ceafc","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f0d7c3b27ea437e3c0c8ae34ad242e50efb4f5c11327f5680ccfdad44bb7ec56","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:13d78df18fd068b0efb37d39"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:13d78df18fd068b0efb37d39","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d12ea05930a33153578a3ffbf5e5f43e742d07860ecf070f53371d9ad074dd8c","q025-candidate-question:3fd6fe0ea9cb68d46c4b9392"],"scopeContentSha256":"f16d7c6925c58fc6cc4780df20a2710cc059337859d448a292b284a99da67751","contributionContentSha256":"67ed5c42dc1442e36a94bf5b6e15c5051c0db95360ecefe6b7b195008fa153fd","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d29","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:d12ea05930a33153578a3ffbf5e5f43e742d07860ecf070f53371d9ad074dd8c","textSha256":"5c40a9a8dd066ff8dceea42ba926780024243722de662526d37f36b7a5eb77de"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0b7b1d8ebc57130fc3c6286ec2efa6a3","paperId":"2212.09758","sourceSha256":"7aa624448a2f1e6d538d52d4714c936901ae174dc66e7dac97c3bb886fbcf05b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ad905cd2e07e4e024a5a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"603bca1102f84846bd266b59b2a99f319bcc8b8e423d6042e70774a7315ceafc","pdfPage":12,"start":0,"end":2392,"textSha256":"c09a68e7f7678d56030f94684e19dcffd84dfe49e5fc870c43021978a080b1f6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eca45b81f24fef65e88ba354fce95912","paperId":"2212.09758","sourceSha256":"7aa624448a2f1e6d538d52d4714c936901ae174dc66e7dac97c3bb886fbcf05b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ad905cd2e07e4e024a5a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"603bca1102f84846bd266b59b2a99f319bcc8b8e423d6042e70774a7315ceafc","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f0d7c3b27ea437e3c0c8ae34ad242e50efb4f5c11327f5680ccfdad44bb7ec56","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:13d78df18fd068b0efb37d39","recordId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"For rays without BPS towers: no qualifying weak limit, or a critical-string non-BPS tower. The displayed claim specifies asymptotic self-repulsion.","challengeNote":"For a ray without a BPS tower: no qualifying weak limit, or a critical-string non-BPS tower. The displayed claim establishes its target as asymptotic self-rep‐","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":8,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ca371c740037937c9111d09885759d479a3f588f0947ea1c71f028ece5284481"},"organizational-access:9354d8d9a45f220849ab9b6d":{"id":"organizational-access:9354d8d9a45f220849ab9b6d","source":"q025-candidate-region:018f1421493336d3dc8b8760","target":"q025-candidate-question:be168f701d200915d291ec25","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:018f1421493336d3dc8b8760","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"ac935147948e461a16f81749f002757eb9e75e8b8b7d9cf34a45c4f96efcfa37","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c6096ee2040b2c4a2056e9ad"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:be168f701d200915d291ec25","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"4ebf3825eb9dca5f823f50266ab84fbb42cb97a74373f7c40fdd05dfda3d94bb","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:aab45a02be36be54c76b0422"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:12d2c6750899c380d46d5b5ffa78367ee5e1d86eeb63c81957caad956fb2b938","home":{"unitId":"unit:12d2c6750899c380d46d5b5ffa78367ee5e1d86eeb63c81957caad956fb2b938","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:018f1421493336d3dc8b8760","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:12d2c6750899c380d46d5b5ffa78367ee5e1d86eeb63c81957caad956fb2b938","paperId":"1906.04142","textSha256":"5debe32901f6716db0c49affa4a82fab43e9fc3e1b0c09dfb45671f8d0a08801"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:35415699cec1a3cf1acc27d5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:35415699cec1a3cf1acc27d5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:12d2c6750899c380d46d5b5ffa78367ee5e1d86eeb63c81957caad956fb2b938","q025-candidate-region:018f1421493336d3dc8b8760"],"scopeContentSha256":"ac935147948e461a16f81749f002757eb9e75e8b8b7d9cf34a45c4f96efcfa37","placementContentSha256":"ac4c9c49bd7487767b512981f39e59af5f299bc28e1c51e9a15227a995d4452a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-challenge","leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:12d2c6750899c380d46d5b5ffa78367ee5e1d86eeb63c81957caad956fb2b938","paperId":"1906.04142","textSha256":"5debe32901f6716db0c49affa4a82fab43e9fc3e1b0c09dfb45671f8d0a08801"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:35415699cec1a3cf1acc27d5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:12d2c6750899c380d46d5b5ffa78367ee5e1d86eeb63c81957caad956fb2b938","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:be168f701d200915d291ec25","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:12d2c6750899c380d46d5b5ffa78367ee5e1d86eeb63c81957caad956fb2b938","textSha256":"5debe32901f6716db0c49affa4a82fab43e9fc3e1b0c09dfb45671f8d0a08801"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d4aa61fdfd5ef2b44483a11b","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Dictionary, linearized dynamics and gravitational-energy constraints remain distinguishable targets within the original compound question. Independent challenge qualification: Stress-tensor dictionary, linearized dynamics and energy constraints remain distinct targets within the compound source question."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d4aa61fdfd5ef2b44483a11b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:12d2c6750899c380d46d5b5ffa78367ee5e1d86eeb63c81957caad956fb2b938","q025-candidate-question:be168f701d200915d291ec25"],"scopeContentSha256":"4ebf3825eb9dca5f823f50266ab84fbb42cb97a74373f7c40fdd05dfda3d94bb","contributionContentSha256":"08438de219b5691ae8d58bc8a8a7bd6bc5216dce6e1f17df2af95714cea17c70","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-proposal","leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:12d2c6750899c380d46d5b5ffa78367ee5e1d86eeb63c81957caad956fb2b938","textSha256":"5debe32901f6716db0c49affa4a82fab43e9fc3e1b0c09dfb45671f8d0a08801"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d4aa61fdfd5ef2b44483a11b","recordId":"leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Dictionary, linearized dynamics and gravitational-energy constraints remain distinguishable targets within the original compound question.","challengeNote":"Stress-tensor dictionary, linearized dynamics and energy constraints remain distinct targets within the compound source question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5a7a25fcfc038f48dddded2591f6105b9aa6796a574ef65e021caca8b9227d1a","home":{"unitId":"unit:5a7a25fcfc038f48dddded2591f6105b9aa6796a574ef65e021caca8b9227d1a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:018f1421493336d3dc8b8760","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"The region covers adjacent continuum-QFT subsystem constructions together with their proposed connections to holographic entropy and geometry.","qualification":"q18 covers both the continuum-algebra question and the prospective holographic explanation. q14 directly covers the first part, but its particular holographic targets do not establish coverage of the second. The broader region is therefore the most specific supplied complete home.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5a7a25fcfc038f48dddded2591f6105b9aa6796a574ef65e021caca8b9227d1a","paperId":"1905.10487","textSha256":"2708ca2c4f134d7289626bb0c81c08cad93f840125e3e836922beac3b597c9c4"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0057:u0:q18"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0057:u0:q18","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5a7a25fcfc038f48dddded2591f6105b9aa6796a574ef65e021caca8b9227d1a","q025-candidate-region:018f1421493336d3dc8b8760"],"scopeContentSha256":"ac935147948e461a16f81749f002757eb9e75e8b8b7d9cf34a45c4f96efcfa37","placementContentSha256":"09164f0ce92fc3aeb6391f35ec98a8b40b192b6d55b4a8979a0769997483f51b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0057:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0057:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5a7a25fcfc038f48dddded2591f6105b9aa6796a574ef65e021caca8b9227d1a","paperId":"1905.10487","textSha256":"2708ca2c4f134d7289626bb0c81c08cad93f840125e3e836922beac3b597c9c4"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0057","unitRef":"u0"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5a7a25fcfc038f48dddded2591f6105b9aa6796a574ef65e021caca8b9227d1a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:be168f701d200915d291ec25","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:5a7a25fcfc038f48dddded2591f6105b9aa6796a574ef65e021caca8b9227d1a","textSha256":"2708ca2c4f134d7289626bb0c81c08cad93f840125e3e836922beac3b597c9c4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:08ed355e6a0bf0ac1d46100b","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The possible holographic explanation is a further target beyond the continuum region–algebra question. Independent challenge qualification: The possible holographic explanation is an additional target beyond continuum region–algebra assignments."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:08ed355e6a0bf0ac1d46100b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5a7a25fcfc038f48dddded2591f6105b9aa6796a574ef65e021caca8b9227d1a","q025-candidate-question:be168f701d200915d291ec25"],"scopeContentSha256":"4ebf3825eb9dca5f823f50266ab84fbb42cb97a74373f7c40fdd05dfda3d94bb","contributionContentSha256":"7d06ce3aa5a1f40ae4cf0012784271233835f18aa156423b850cad8d74fd3fad","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-proposal","leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:5a7a25fcfc038f48dddded2591f6105b9aa6796a574ef65e021caca8b9227d1a","textSha256":"2708ca2c4f134d7289626bb0c81c08cad93f840125e3e836922beac3b597c9c4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:08ed355e6a0bf0ac1d46100b","recordId":"leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-de6c996ab0f533ff9545-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"The possible holographic explanation is a further target beyond the continuum region–algebra question.","challengeNote":"The possible holographic explanation is an additional target beyond continuum region–algebra assignments.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"f24de95e8d7ddb5154ffb5826206e1ff07e8e0fb63dd4364aba312cec0c07f97"},"organizational-access:0c5d176e6d8857b3b676d52c":{"id":"organizational-access:0c5d176e6d8857b3b676d52c","source":"q025-candidate-region:0373a22d5bfba4144b34728b","target":"q025-candidate-question:8f9a7ad7ba1d9bfaf451a595","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:0373a22d5bfba4144b34728b","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"a3a2579d115a1464f96eb7bb79e1cb85ffbd506856b1563c8355b3c516c8a5a0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:54a819990a6473625004e24a"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8f9a7ad7ba1d9bfaf451a595","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"891760d85966934fe9c4122d6624497add80af2ada6063f1406188dd552b6737","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c1fd17afbba9f0626961415e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5e772a318ef7be8c945f9d319d01674f0415ff74d9c34fc08b5bab13c69de57a","home":{"unitId":"unit:5e772a318ef7be8c945f9d319d01674f0415ff74d9c34fc08b5bab13c69de57a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0373a22d5bfba4144b34728b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5e772a318ef7be8c945f9d319d01674f0415ff74d9c34fc08b5bab13c69de57a","paperId":"2009.00015","textSha256":"a3f4ea92f81f9760eab2563bfc56dd49b153e1f645ad2f654436a4828f098775"},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:de3f5396ff2d6f83bb6d290119dce3a6","paperId":"2009.00015","sourceSha256":"1c72a046374fbeb288b9306605defb97dae314a48120f3bcc8fc614faf375473","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9aebadaa4f5bf083d0d4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07f5ba8e61fe086d53bbdfaed0d294beb3da4e379b63a7df2bdcfec45dcd6fce","pdfPage":4,"start":97,"end":2826,"textSha256":"be97597738b0004b0b3ec7ca4d106c294097eb1323dbb1714addd23040000d44","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e7f52ef3a6eddb31a08af3ca7a6e8dca","paperId":"2009.00015","sourceSha256":"1c72a046374fbeb288b9306605defb97dae314a48120f3bcc8fc614faf375473","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9aebadaa4f5bf083d0d4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07f5ba8e61fe086d53bbdfaed0d294beb3da4e379b63a7df2bdcfec45dcd6fce","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2826,"textSha256":"37188793e3e6c0b6387316365e700d96f2d2d01d22c40d0863b15271d239e0a6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0e4cd28771017f72fd50b4cf"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0e4cd28771017f72fd50b4cf","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5e772a318ef7be8c945f9d319d01674f0415ff74d9c34fc08b5bab13c69de57a","q025-candidate-region:0373a22d5bfba4144b34728b"],"scopeContentSha256":"a3a2579d115a1464f96eb7bb79e1cb85ffbd506856b1563c8355b3c516c8a5a0","placementContentSha256":"831a58d5369e0b46d04e887f3fcd4da6eefdf13cfadf655f87342e75c5763d30","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-challenge","leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5e772a318ef7be8c945f9d319d01674f0415ff74d9c34fc08b5bab13c69de57a","paperId":"2009.00015","textSha256":"a3f4ea92f81f9760eab2563bfc56dd49b153e1f645ad2f654436a4828f098775"},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:de3f5396ff2d6f83bb6d290119dce3a6","paperId":"2009.00015","sourceSha256":"1c72a046374fbeb288b9306605defb97dae314a48120f3bcc8fc614faf375473","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9aebadaa4f5bf083d0d4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07f5ba8e61fe086d53bbdfaed0d294beb3da4e379b63a7df2bdcfec45dcd6fce","pdfPage":4,"start":97,"end":2826,"textSha256":"be97597738b0004b0b3ec7ca4d106c294097eb1323dbb1714addd23040000d44","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e7f52ef3a6eddb31a08af3ca7a6e8dca","paperId":"2009.00015","sourceSha256":"1c72a046374fbeb288b9306605defb97dae314a48120f3bcc8fc614faf375473","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9aebadaa4f5bf083d0d4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07f5ba8e61fe086d53bbdfaed0d294beb3da4e379b63a7df2bdcfec45dcd6fce","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2826,"textSha256":"37188793e3e6c0b6387316365e700d96f2d2d01d22c40d0863b15271d239e0a6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0e4cd28771017f72fd50b4cf"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5e772a318ef7be8c945f9d319d01674f0415ff74d9c34fc08b5bab13c69de57a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8f9a7ad7ba1d9bfaf451a595","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:5e772a318ef7be8c945f9d319d01674f0415ff74d9c34fc08b5bab13c69de57a","textSha256":"a3f4ea92f81f9760eab2563bfc56dd49b153e1f645ad2f654436a4828f098775"},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e7f52ef3a6eddb31a08af3ca7a6e8dca","paperId":"2009.00015","sourceSha256":"1c72a046374fbeb288b9306605defb97dae314a48120f3bcc8fc614faf375473","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9aebadaa4f5bf083d0d4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07f5ba8e61fe086d53bbdfaed0d294beb3da4e379b63a7df2bdcfec45dcd6fce","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2826,"textSha256":"37188793e3e6c0b6387316365e700d96f2d2d01d22c40d0863b15271d239e0a6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d29e13e26a8218f3f21b7ff3","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound extremal mass–spin, entropy and limiting-prescription targets; RN is a methodological comparison, not the main rotating system. Independent challenge qualification: Mass–spin relation, entropy and limit ordering are compound targets. The main construction has two equal angular momenta and linear Gauss–Bonnet order; RN i"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d29e13e26a8218f3f21b7ff3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5e772a318ef7be8c945f9d319d01674f0415ff74d9c34fc08b5bab13c69de57a","q025-candidate-question:8f9a7ad7ba1d9bfaf451a595"],"scopeContentSha256":"891760d85966934fe9c4122d6624497add80af2ada6063f1406188dd552b6737","contributionContentSha256":"182cf09b03c16eaecacace61c0ae9b136aeae2b5ce9ce517b71f00d9959871d0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-proposal","leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:5e772a318ef7be8c945f9d319d01674f0415ff74d9c34fc08b5bab13c69de57a","textSha256":"a3f4ea92f81f9760eab2563bfc56dd49b153e1f645ad2f654436a4828f098775"},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e7f52ef3a6eddb31a08af3ca7a6e8dca","paperId":"2009.00015","sourceSha256":"1c72a046374fbeb288b9306605defb97dae314a48120f3bcc8fc614faf375473","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9aebadaa4f5bf083d0d4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"07f5ba8e61fe086d53bbdfaed0d294beb3da4e379b63a7df2bdcfec45dcd6fce","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2826,"textSha256":"37188793e3e6c0b6387316365e700d96f2d2d01d22c40d0863b15271d239e0a6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d29e13e26a8218f3f21b7ff3","recordId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound extremal mass–spin, entropy and limiting-prescription targets; RN is a methodological comparison, not the main rotating system.","challengeNote":"Mass–spin relation, entropy and limit ordering are compound targets. The main construction has two equal angular momenta and linear Gauss–Bonnet order; RN i","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"aa223838eb62960f35ea4d74756f7e98973088b8356261b8af84a7c7762c301a"},"organizational-access:f430f49ba53ba9471e592adb":{"id":"organizational-access:f430f49ba53ba9471e592adb","source":"q025-candidate-region:0373a22d5bfba4144b34728b","target":"q025-candidate-question:a31754bfdb42eed547f22213","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:0373a22d5bfba4144b34728b","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"a3a2579d115a1464f96eb7bb79e1cb85ffbd506856b1563c8355b3c516c8a5a0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:54a819990a6473625004e24a"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a31754bfdb42eed547f22213","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f3ec456d680a10871e9d42736a7a463a599065be3fb0b0880a089c4e916ff4bc","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c4777a8327aa97acef04839b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","home":{"unitId":"unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0373a22d5bfba4144b34728b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers corrected charged rotating black-hole thermodynamics and source-specific microscopic comparisons, including the AdS5 action and BPS entropy/index question.","qualification":"q36 covers the thermodynamic calculation and independent action/entropy comparison with the index. q15, q23 and q30 each emphasize only part of that conjunction; q10 centers on BPS limits and ensembles. Retain the linear four-derivative regime and second-sheet index convention without treating an abstract-level matching claim as independently verified.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","paperId":"2208.01007","textSha256":"3eca11b0748f40929f8cce004550feb57ec86a6fccfe702d8e84739426e2399d"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0066:u5:q36"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0066:u5:q36","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","q025-candidate-region:0373a22d5bfba4144b34728b"],"scopeContentSha256":"a3a2579d115a1464f96eb7bb79e1cb85ffbd506856b1563c8355b3c516c8a5a0","placementContentSha256":"054ec558021125c9575384448016bdfd20379f58706e5ecc484b443978fee512","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0066:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0066:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","paperId":"2208.01007","textSha256":"3eca11b0748f40929f8cce004550feb57ec86a6fccfe702d8e84739426e2399d"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0066","unitRef":"u5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a31754bfdb42eed547f22213","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","textSha256":"3eca11b0748f40929f8cce004550feb57ec86a6fccfe702d8e84739426e2399d"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5a0ff5bd30c5d39910aeaf82997b8b47","paperId":"2208.01007","sourceSha256":"932b2c18bde669c741916deca59ab6562581e933485f46b861ea54d304fc5225","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5ca4e5cf9ad3959992eb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c1d7e62cc64da8d702cca22f64e9a30c7377c7390a3a80503da993af347b4fb4","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":1622,"textSha256":"83c9991906e65c53fed668eec0ef61ac55a05fa3a63fb69e4d93abc2a890502d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9e25aac21f3af4255169cdf649b1828b","paperId":"2208.01007","sourceSha256":"932b2c18bde669c741916deca59ab6562581e933485f46b861ea54d304fc5225","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5ca4e5cf9ad3959992eb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c1d7e62cc64da8d702cca22f64e9a30c7377c7390a3a80503da993af347b4fb4","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1622,"textSha256":"e95eab9f2d82adca5d8b6c05d521113aaf6d294bf45dbc5d457b3bbd763137fd","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d1640c268c56f60a6d45b5e5","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Relevant despite its probe selection label. Thermodynamic corrections and index matching are linked compound targets; only the abstract is supplied. Independent challenge qualification: Thermodynamic corrections and index matching remain compound targets. The abstract supports inclusion despite the outside-probe label."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d1640c268c56f60a6d45b5e5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","q025-candidate-question:a31754bfdb42eed547f22213"],"scopeContentSha256":"f3ec456d680a10871e9d42736a7a463a599065be3fb0b0880a089c4e916ff4bc","contributionContentSha256":"488e18e087383deab9ee6ea78bbc9b66bf48b5beb0c091a5b0a757136b107b51","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-203fd6a716a0a1f60d6f-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-203fd6a716a0a1f60d6f-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-203fd6a716a0a1f60d6f-proposal","leaf-203fd6a716a0a1f60d6f-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:3517381b23ba2e7e6ed1783006dfe7e66e3769b21ebc122f0ff3369e7c59ea22","textSha256":"3eca11b0748f40929f8cce004550feb57ec86a6fccfe702d8e84739426e2399d"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5a0ff5bd30c5d39910aeaf82997b8b47","paperId":"2208.01007","sourceSha256":"932b2c18bde669c741916deca59ab6562581e933485f46b861ea54d304fc5225","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5ca4e5cf9ad3959992eb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c1d7e62cc64da8d702cca22f64e9a30c7377c7390a3a80503da993af347b4fb4","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":1622,"textSha256":"83c9991906e65c53fed668eec0ef61ac55a05fa3a63fb69e4d93abc2a890502d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9e25aac21f3af4255169cdf649b1828b","paperId":"2208.01007","sourceSha256":"932b2c18bde669c741916deca59ab6562581e933485f46b861ea54d304fc5225","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5ca4e5cf9ad3959992eb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c1d7e62cc64da8d702cca22f64e9a30c7377c7390a3a80503da993af347b4fb4","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1622,"textSha256":"e95eab9f2d82adca5d8b6c05d521113aaf6d294bf45dbc5d457b3bbd763137fd","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d1640c268c56f60a6d45b5e5","recordId":"leaf-203fd6a716a0a1f60d6f-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-203fd6a716a0a1f60d6f-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-203fd6a716a0a1f60d6f-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Relevant despite its probe selection label. Thermodynamic corrections and index matching are linked compound targets; only the abstract is supplied.","challengeNote":"Thermodynamic corrections and index matching remain compound targets. The abstract supports inclusion despite the outside-probe label.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"199717da32adc4cb7797e6556d0eff548363ab3d842dbc192eea83adeb78c297"},"organizational-access:a581285ff743f8c537bc187f":{"id":"organizational-access:a581285ff743f8c537bc187f","source":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","target":"q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:924fe997fc8f49068b91d181"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"4e5fb78ca4afe83c42bb70d0f630fa99255f71831b6900404fb7c5ede86b117e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1fe24c5a78fb40519193e264"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1d87878d7b2172c4799a83ef70790a6415a7029e72abaf10a478e3dbf96b2362","home":{"unitId":"unit:1d87878d7b2172c4799a83ef70790a6415a7029e72abaf10a478e3dbf96b2362","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1d87878d7b2172c4799a83ef70790a6415a7029e72abaf10a478e3dbf96b2362","paperId":"2307.07855","textSha256":"9309e9db7cf9e4294598e98a9c1cc24db27dd6ee6de9da8445a5c60826b72a1a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:332f8ed7bc66a4fa405fd58b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:332f8ed7bc66a4fa405fd58b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1d87878d7b2172c4799a83ef70790a6415a7029e72abaf10a478e3dbf96b2362","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"f1b7296a397e098d1450be47dda5ffdce3af538edd2c50f49e69c4c5f1281494","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1d87878d7b2172c4799a83ef70790a6415a7029e72abaf10a478e3dbf96b2362","paperId":"2307.07855","textSha256":"9309e9db7cf9e4294598e98a9c1cc24db27dd6ee6de9da8445a5c60826b72a1a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:332f8ed7bc66a4fa405fd58b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1d87878d7b2172c4799a83ef70790a6415a7029e72abaf10a478e3dbf96b2362","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:1d87878d7b2172c4799a83ef70790a6415a7029e72abaf10a478e3dbf96b2362","textSha256":"9309e9db7cf9e4294598e98a9c1cc24db27dd6ee6de9da8445a5c60826b72a1a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6fb1b02d75317a36348df7d3","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound framework and search review; completed, ongoing and proposed statuses are source-dated. Independent challenge qualification: Compound framework and search review; completed, ongoing and proposed statuses retain their source date."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6fb1b02d75317a36348df7d3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1d87878d7b2172c4799a83ef70790a6415a7029e72abaf10a478e3dbf96b2362","q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6"],"scopeContentSha256":"4e5fb78ca4afe83c42bb70d0f630fa99255f71831b6900404fb7c5ede86b117e","contributionContentSha256":"69b8694291a6e6aa8351ce5d5b5cfe376b7958cc17f433ceac8d1ae40440ad39","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:1d87878d7b2172c4799a83ef70790a6415a7029e72abaf10a478e3dbf96b2362","textSha256":"9309e9db7cf9e4294598e98a9c1cc24db27dd6ee6de9da8445a5c60826b72a1a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6fb1b02d75317a36348df7d3","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound framework and search review; completed, ongoing and proposed statuses are source-dated.","challengeNote":"Compound framework and search review; completed, ongoing and proposed statuses retain their source date.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","home":{"unitId":"unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","paperId":"2005.01515","textSha256":"098a40597fce8b1f0ffc67b95294f02ef90a5023d56722c3193b4241aa859fe6"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d3ad84c1c53a552bf0e3f61f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d3ad84c1c53a552bf0e3f61f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"2c950317f830b5b7e410e61a64d02a678fb89cd779dcfc946b07cc8a11733889","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","paperId":"2005.01515","textSha256":"098a40597fce8b1f0ffc67b95294f02ef90a5023d56722c3193b4241aa859fe6"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d3ad84c1c53a552bf0e3f61f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","textSha256":"098a40597fce8b1f0ffc67b95294f02ef90a5023d56722c3193b4241aa859fe6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e7806d421fc739d7927a9f07","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound theoretical and experimental review of massless and massive cases, not one interaction mechanism. Independent challenge qualification: Compound theoretical and experimental review; massless and massive cases remain alternatives."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e7806d421fc739d7927a9f07","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6"],"scopeContentSha256":"4e5fb78ca4afe83c42bb70d0f630fa99255f71831b6900404fb7c5ede86b117e","contributionContentSha256":"3bfbd13cf7db4cd32da9b98d40f4bfbe8866a2cfd3b140ffc48c8fc885bad980","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:1ff6c1282a25ce82b92338b5ba3e290d23f791a11d410cf6f836ae37c34b071b","textSha256":"098a40597fce8b1f0ffc67b95294f02ef90a5023d56722c3193b4241aa859fe6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e7806d421fc739d7927a9f07","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound theoretical and experimental review of massless and massive cases, not one interaction mechanism.","challengeNote":"Compound theoretical and experimental review; massless and massive cases remain alternatives.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","home":{"unitId":"unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","paperId":"1103.4556","textSha256":"0f73eecb3f80234af71138127d86c1257886fe7ef0b2596dfd93a2bd4bf0e873"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6208b5c7d974740bd7ec0c27"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6208b5c7d974740bd7ec0c27","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"50c51d17f201ef4bbb92840793f451f183f6adc018dc321d748e05ea4bbfdec0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","paperId":"1103.4556","textSha256":"0f73eecb3f80234af71138127d86c1257886fe7ef0b2596dfd93a2bd4bf0e873"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6208b5c7d974740bd7ec0c27"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","textSha256":"0f73eecb3f80234af71138127d86c1257886fe7ef0b2596dfd93a2bd4bf0e873"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e3a6511c16cf627f1bfcd657","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Combines MeV-to-TeV phenomenological constraints with ultraviolet motivation. Independent challenge qualification: Compound MeV-to-TeV constraints and ultraviolet model-building targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e3a6511c16cf627f1bfcd657","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6"],"scopeContentSha256":"4e5fb78ca4afe83c42bb70d0f630fa99255f71831b6900404fb7c5ede86b117e","contributionContentSha256":"0c32e598e641960c6b4edac762d4fad940ad8ee71c1313063fbbe827ec6360c5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:20968c53276ff4c5a280c80f91f32c8251ada65f555c0ef2c814b7784d6258db","textSha256":"0f73eecb3f80234af71138127d86c1257886fe7ef0b2596dfd93a2bd4bf0e873"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e3a6511c16cf627f1bfcd657","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Combines MeV-to-TeV phenomenological constraints with ultraviolet motivation.","challengeNote":"Compound MeV-to-TeV constraints and ultraviolet model-building targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:47b34843571d74f6af57ee052b02004b92ffffd0637b658ca5fe13e2ac5823e7","home":{"unitId":"unit:47b34843571d74f6af57ee052b02004b92ffffd0637b658ca5fe13e2ac5823e7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:47b34843571d74f6af57ee052b02004b92ffffd0637b658ca5fe13e2ac5823e7","paperId":"2003.10465","textSha256":"3abc3a9ae2bb6ee638f0aee084ffdad08bbc70439e76529698309c9590aff6e0"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:134ba8425a7d71b9e8287a58"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:134ba8425a7d71b9e8287a58","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:47b34843571d74f6af57ee052b02004b92ffffd0637b658ca5fe13e2ac5823e7","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"5e4171350468376d8ecbd85756a1eb949f6e2f69599bf44faea46faa2029d6a7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:47b34843571d74f6af57ee052b02004b92ffffd0637b658ca5fe13e2ac5823e7","paperId":"2003.10465","textSha256":"3abc3a9ae2bb6ee638f0aee084ffdad08bbc70439e76529698309c9590aff6e0"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:134ba8425a7d71b9e8287a58"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:47b34843571d74f6af57ee052b02004b92ffffd0637b658ca5fe13e2ac5823e7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:47b34843571d74f6af57ee052b02004b92ffffd0637b658ca5fe13e2ac5823e7","textSha256":"3abc3a9ae2bb6ee638f0aee084ffdad08bbc70439e76529698309c9590aff6e0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bc5dad850672ff2fcd59d18e","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: CMB depletion, anisotropy and photons from dark radiation are distinct retained targets. Independent challenge qualification: Compound CMB depletion, anisotropy and dark-radiation conversion targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:bc5dad850672ff2fcd59d18e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:47b34843571d74f6af57ee052b02004b92ffffd0637b658ca5fe13e2ac5823e7","q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6"],"scopeContentSha256":"4e5fb78ca4afe83c42bb70d0f630fa99255f71831b6900404fb7c5ede86b117e","contributionContentSha256":"a214c5fc1867279f64e7d173ed76c5fa415eb32d248a7030294e0c4894c33483","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:47b34843571d74f6af57ee052b02004b92ffffd0637b658ca5fe13e2ac5823e7","textSha256":"3abc3a9ae2bb6ee638f0aee084ffdad08bbc70439e76529698309c9590aff6e0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bc5dad850672ff2fcd59d18e","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"CMB depletion, anisotropy and photons from dark radiation are distinct retained targets.","challengeNote":"Compound CMB depletion, anisotropy and dark-radiation conversion targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:69e1b8e7257e20aec70609f47040f950ba3e6c5ae86b0e43f75e238e3eb5537f","home":{"unitId":"unit:69e1b8e7257e20aec70609f47040f950ba3e6c5ae86b0e43f75e238e3eb5537f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:69e1b8e7257e20aec70609f47040f950ba3e6c5ae86b0e43f75e238e3eb5537f","paperId":"hep-ph/0703144","textSha256":"c5159a3a5303b780443ef19d5253f35da9ab436c18a2f5b4bbed6d8b2277af68"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:24c23b0ce428c87263eac191"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:24c23b0ce428c87263eac191","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:69e1b8e7257e20aec70609f47040f950ba3e6c5ae86b0e43f75e238e3eb5537f","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"9e287bc4a5e71c9c5e19bd39d8e34746c3db517b53a1616e5fdc711c1412c858","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:69e1b8e7257e20aec70609f47040f950ba3e6c5ae86b0e43f75e238e3eb5537f","paperId":"hep-ph/0703144","textSha256":"c5159a3a5303b780443ef19d5253f35da9ab436c18a2f5b4bbed6d8b2277af68"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:24c23b0ce428c87263eac191"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:69e1b8e7257e20aec70609f47040f950ba3e6c5ae86b0e43f75e238e3eb5537f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d49","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:69e1b8e7257e20aec70609f47040f950ba3e6c5ae86b0e43f75e238e3eb5537f","textSha256":"c5159a3a5303b780443ef19d5253f35da9ab436c18a2f5b4bbed6d8b2277af68"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0d85d29fdbe0fb7a54d0ab04","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Uses post-recombination production and charge appearing at small momentum transfer; the PVLAS motivation is historical. Independent challenge qualification: Post-recombination production and charge appearing at small momentum transfer are essential; PVLAS motivation is historical."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0d85d29fdbe0fb7a54d0ab04","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:69e1b8e7257e20aec70609f47040f950ba3e6c5ae86b0e43f75e238e3eb5537f","q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6"],"scopeContentSha256":"4e5fb78ca4afe83c42bb70d0f630fa99255f71831b6900404fb7c5ede86b117e","contributionContentSha256":"fd136560b3ce1f7120e35c6985e5604b2603d2d360d2db5df9eae63d41b15653","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d49","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:69e1b8e7257e20aec70609f47040f950ba3e6c5ae86b0e43f75e238e3eb5537f","textSha256":"c5159a3a5303b780443ef19d5253f35da9ab436c18a2f5b4bbed6d8b2277af68"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0d85d29fdbe0fb7a54d0ab04","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Uses post-recombination production and charge appearing at small momentum transfer; the PVLAS motivation is historical.","challengeNote":"Post-recombination production and charge appearing at small momentum transfer are essential; PVLAS motivation is historical.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:8a05451c0740d126e00c8817560ba3c953cd5030b0422767d411aa362f911b9a","home":{"unitId":"unit:8a05451c0740d126e00c8817560ba3c953cd5030b0422767d411aa362f911b9a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8a05451c0740d126e00c8817560ba3c953cd5030b0422767d411aa362f911b9a","paperId":"hep-ph/9310288","textSha256":"c0fe90deeb2d7dee60bab7a864685a731c6d6096375e21ef81254c7785fdb702"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:df770da6658586a15b00c9e9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:df770da6658586a15b00c9e9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8a05451c0740d126e00c8817560ba3c953cd5030b0422767d411aa362f911b9a","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"5ff430b491dc9faea0d695b3b1e6c980e65a6d0da51bc42f754d42c21e6985b8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8a05451c0740d126e00c8817560ba3c953cd5030b0422767d411aa362f911b9a","paperId":"hep-ph/9310288","textSha256":"c0fe90deeb2d7dee60bab7a864685a731c6d6096375e21ef81254c7785fdb702"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:df770da6658586a15b00c9e9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8a05451c0740d126e00c8817560ba3c953cd5030b0422767d411aa362f911b9a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d50","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:8a05451c0740d126e00c8817560ba3c953cd5030b0422767d411aa362f911b9a","textSha256":"c0fe90deeb2d7dee60bab7a864685a731c6d6096375e21ef81254c7785fdb702"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f3826cc87d25ddc8b3cd8cb0","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound astrophysical and nucleosynthesis reassessment; the earlier exclusion is not adopted as a premise. Independent challenge qualification: Compound astrophysical and nucleosynthesis reassessment; the earlier claimed exclusion is not adopted."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f3826cc87d25ddc8b3cd8cb0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8a05451c0740d126e00c8817560ba3c953cd5030b0422767d411aa362f911b9a","q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6"],"scopeContentSha256":"4e5fb78ca4afe83c42bb70d0f630fa99255f71831b6900404fb7c5ede86b117e","contributionContentSha256":"7cf2798f0bbc91dba39eab2746044e35719a8b70796cdaacd801a1e7f28489c2","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d50","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:8a05451c0740d126e00c8817560ba3c953cd5030b0422767d411aa362f911b9a","textSha256":"c0fe90deeb2d7dee60bab7a864685a731c6d6096375e21ef81254c7785fdb702"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f3826cc87d25ddc8b3cd8cb0","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound astrophysical and nucleosynthesis reassessment; the earlier exclusion is not adopted as a premise.","challengeNote":"Compound astrophysical and nucleosynthesis reassessment; the earlier claimed exclusion is not adopted.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c08cb49e7dae639bc345c215bf0c2d09278382566485a0f8a9492542619ca3cb","home":{"unitId":"unit:c08cb49e7dae639bc345c215bf0c2d09278382566485a0f8a9492542619ca3cb","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c08cb49e7dae639bc345c215bf0c2d09278382566485a0f8a9492542619ca3cb","paperId":"2002.05165","textSha256":"840a0e2d7380d2bca19941e9232e1ab30a12cd12b8a0582256c43d2ef7bbd4e2"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6370b821579167ec76f494af"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6370b821579167ec76f494af","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c08cb49e7dae639bc345c215bf0c2d09278382566485a0f8a9492542619ca3cb","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"d91b9216898f85ad795e0ea471034b2320f9c4dae158d48977db98418ed0a51f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c08cb49e7dae639bc345c215bf0c2d09278382566485a0f8a9492542619ca3cb","paperId":"2002.05165","textSha256":"840a0e2d7380d2bca19941e9232e1ab30a12cd12b8a0582256c43d2ef7bbd4e2"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6370b821579167ec76f494af"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c08cb49e7dae639bc345c215bf0c2d09278382566485a0f8a9492542619ca3cb","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:c08cb49e7dae639bc345c215bf0c2d09278382566485a0f8a9492542619ca3cb","textSha256":"840a0e2d7380d2bca19941e9232e1ab30a12cd12b8a0582256c43d2ef7bbd4e2"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e1aae42158bf9dc80a830c11","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Retains both CMB spectral-distortion and dark-matter-heating targets. Independent challenge qualification: Compound CMB spectral-distortion and dark-matter-heating targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e1aae42158bf9dc80a830c11","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c08cb49e7dae639bc345c215bf0c2d09278382566485a0f8a9492542619ca3cb","q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6"],"scopeContentSha256":"4e5fb78ca4afe83c42bb70d0f630fa99255f71831b6900404fb7c5ede86b117e","contributionContentSha256":"6d13c6936d23d600bd0687314c500dd14bbcb8cd0f1158cec611e3997133904a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:c08cb49e7dae639bc345c215bf0c2d09278382566485a0f8a9492542619ca3cb","textSha256":"840a0e2d7380d2bca19941e9232e1ab30a12cd12b8a0582256c43d2ef7bbd4e2"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e1aae42158bf9dc80a830c11","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Retains both CMB spectral-distortion and dark-matter-heating targets.","challengeNote":"Compound CMB spectral-distortion and dark-matter-heating targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ce22d2e1867e298c6c140899c86f09055d0b2caf275a0666b9417d4cde814a48","home":{"unitId":"unit:ce22d2e1867e298c6c140899c86f09055d0b2caf275a0666b9417d4cde814a48","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ce22d2e1867e298c6c140899c86f09055d0b2caf275a0666b9417d4cde814a48","paperId":"1406.6518","textSha256":"14191ea29958dfb36fa5c3d60ed5f0fe5ffb3d9907bcfdfae95696cb29fd9411"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:03424d77c0216c344cd1d93adeb1ec32","paperId":"1406.6518","sourceSha256":"415cc2f8e4de175043eb129fb0d51578eda5ede0db45cd880ac73ea8043455f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/49e6023c1afcf56d0710/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dc96bbd0bde4dcc0271a49ced725ef1d30485eb89feb902fff38e68966ad00d0","pdfPage":2,"start":1340,"end":4001,"textSha256":"43845103fa33683954f0a050c850416ba81f839af92dbbdb462c07fabffcc5a7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3182f37e1796089a999eda44a43bebcf","paperId":"1406.6518","sourceSha256":"415cc2f8e4de175043eb129fb0d51578eda5ede0db45cd880ac73ea8043455f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/49e6023c1afcf56d0710/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dc96bbd0bde4dcc0271a49ced725ef1d30485eb89feb902fff38e68966ad00d0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"721c745cbff0b19beedeaa725a4451bdcc5d82587874c897be1ed7094a8ef6ba","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:56b5c02cd7a2feb21a25404841f721dc","paperId":"1406.6518","sourceSha256":"415cc2f8e4de175043eb129fb0d51578eda5ede0db45cd880ac73ea8043455f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/49e6023c1afcf56d0710/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dc96bbd0bde4dcc0271a49ced725ef1d30485eb89feb902fff38e68966ad00d0","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":3500,"textSha256":"ed745931fa45cbbe29a5e48ec9c3055c93c6b08b78682f0ecd4adb5235afce50","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc5beb2e1622f3946ecde919"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc5beb2e1622f3946ecde919","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ce22d2e1867e298c6c140899c86f09055d0b2caf275a0666b9417d4cde814a48","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"48f0a672afda113047e462654c1385e098cb3ae95b1c4cf246490c1bf412d156","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ce22d2e1867e298c6c140899c86f09055d0b2caf275a0666b9417d4cde814a48","paperId":"1406.6518","textSha256":"14191ea29958dfb36fa5c3d60ed5f0fe5ffb3d9907bcfdfae95696cb29fd9411"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:03424d77c0216c344cd1d93adeb1ec32","paperId":"1406.6518","sourceSha256":"415cc2f8e4de175043eb129fb0d51578eda5ede0db45cd880ac73ea8043455f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/49e6023c1afcf56d0710/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dc96bbd0bde4dcc0271a49ced725ef1d30485eb89feb902fff38e68966ad00d0","pdfPage":2,"start":1340,"end":4001,"textSha256":"43845103fa33683954f0a050c850416ba81f839af92dbbdb462c07fabffcc5a7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3182f37e1796089a999eda44a43bebcf","paperId":"1406.6518","sourceSha256":"415cc2f8e4de175043eb129fb0d51578eda5ede0db45cd880ac73ea8043455f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/49e6023c1afcf56d0710/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dc96bbd0bde4dcc0271a49ced725ef1d30485eb89feb902fff38e68966ad00d0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"721c745cbff0b19beedeaa725a4451bdcc5d82587874c897be1ed7094a8ef6ba","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:56b5c02cd7a2feb21a25404841f721dc","paperId":"1406.6518","sourceSha256":"415cc2f8e4de175043eb129fb0d51578eda5ede0db45cd880ac73ea8043455f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/49e6023c1afcf56d0710/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dc96bbd0bde4dcc0271a49ced725ef1d30485eb89feb902fff38e68966ad00d0","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":3500,"textSha256":"ed745931fa45cbbe29a5e48ec9c3055c93c6b08b78682f0ecd4adb5235afce50","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc5beb2e1622f3946ecde919"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ce22d2e1867e298c6c140899c86f09055d0b2caf275a0666b9417d4cde814a48","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:ce22d2e1867e298c6c140899c86f09055d0b2caf275a0666b9417d4cde814a48","textSha256":"14191ea29958dfb36fa5c3d60ed5f0fe5ffb3d9907bcfdfae95696cb29fd9411"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:03424d77c0216c344cd1d93adeb1ec32","paperId":"1406.6518","sourceSha256":"415cc2f8e4de175043eb129fb0d51578eda5ede0db45cd880ac73ea8043455f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/49e6023c1afcf56d0710/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dc96bbd0bde4dcc0271a49ced725ef1d30485eb89feb902fff38e68966ad00d0","pdfPage":2,"start":1340,"end":4001,"textSha256":"43845103fa33683954f0a050c850416ba81f839af92dbbdb462c07fabffcc5a7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3182f37e1796089a999eda44a43bebcf","paperId":"1406.6518","sourceSha256":"415cc2f8e4de175043eb129fb0d51578eda5ede0db45cd880ac73ea8043455f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/49e6023c1afcf56d0710/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dc96bbd0bde4dcc0271a49ced725ef1d30485eb89feb902fff38e68966ad00d0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"721c745cbff0b19beedeaa725a4451bdcc5d82587874c897be1ed7094a8ef6ba","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:56b5c02cd7a2feb21a25404841f721dc","paperId":"1406.6518","sourceSha256":"415cc2f8e4de175043eb129fb0d51578eda5ede0db45cd880ac73ea8043455f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/49e6023c1afcf56d0710/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dc96bbd0bde4dcc0271a49ced725ef1d30485eb89feb902fff38e68966ad00d0","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":3500,"textSha256":"ed745931fa45cbbe29a5e48ec9c3055c93c6b08b78682f0ecd4adb5235afce50","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:054a639aced9576fd8816956","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound QED benchmark and ALP/millicharge limits; the 2014 measurement is null-compatible. Independent challenge qualification: Compound QED benchmark and ALP/millicharge limits; the September 2014 measurement is compatible with zero."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:054a639aced9576fd8816956","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ce22d2e1867e298c6c140899c86f09055d0b2caf275a0666b9417d4cde814a48","q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6"],"scopeContentSha256":"4e5fb78ca4afe83c42bb70d0f630fa99255f71831b6900404fb7c5ede86b117e","contributionContentSha256":"435fc0fca7d65031e54535bd858bbb20a3567d09c80e98452639bbfd7c144ece","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:ce22d2e1867e298c6c140899c86f09055d0b2caf275a0666b9417d4cde814a48","textSha256":"14191ea29958dfb36fa5c3d60ed5f0fe5ffb3d9907bcfdfae95696cb29fd9411"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:03424d77c0216c344cd1d93adeb1ec32","paperId":"1406.6518","sourceSha256":"415cc2f8e4de175043eb129fb0d51578eda5ede0db45cd880ac73ea8043455f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/49e6023c1afcf56d0710/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dc96bbd0bde4dcc0271a49ced725ef1d30485eb89feb902fff38e68966ad00d0","pdfPage":2,"start":1340,"end":4001,"textSha256":"43845103fa33683954f0a050c850416ba81f839af92dbbdb462c07fabffcc5a7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3182f37e1796089a999eda44a43bebcf","paperId":"1406.6518","sourceSha256":"415cc2f8e4de175043eb129fb0d51578eda5ede0db45cd880ac73ea8043455f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/49e6023c1afcf56d0710/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dc96bbd0bde4dcc0271a49ced725ef1d30485eb89feb902fff38e68966ad00d0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"721c745cbff0b19beedeaa725a4451bdcc5d82587874c897be1ed7094a8ef6ba","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:56b5c02cd7a2feb21a25404841f721dc","paperId":"1406.6518","sourceSha256":"415cc2f8e4de175043eb129fb0d51578eda5ede0db45cd880ac73ea8043455f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/49e6023c1afcf56d0710/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"dc96bbd0bde4dcc0271a49ced725ef1d30485eb89feb902fff38e68966ad00d0","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":3500,"textSha256":"ed745931fa45cbbe29a5e48ec9c3055c93c6b08b78682f0ecd4adb5235afce50","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:054a639aced9576fd8816956","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound QED benchmark and ALP/millicharge limits; the 2014 measurement is null-compatible.","challengeNote":"Compound QED benchmark and ALP/millicharge limits; the September 2014 measurement is compatible with zero.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","home":{"unitId":"unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","paperId":"2405.08534","textSha256":"f4ec3bc74ecb02982e21c24f0524414ccc9a3011faa29781aeb11a7e2b2d92e5"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:84b5500fef2e1adc1e6bb3e8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:84b5500fef2e1adc1e6bb3e8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"3b3f13b5f70a73553c3d1d72409f10f82b0a9d82c5e5afe5086e8b6910b9d665","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","paperId":"2405.08534","textSha256":"f4ec3bc74ecb02982e21c24f0524414ccc9a3011faa29781aeb11a7e2b2d92e5"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:84b5500fef2e1adc1e6bb3e8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","textSha256":"f4ec3bc74ecb02982e21c24f0524414ccc9a3011faa29781aeb11a7e2b2d92e5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6902ce6918b014ae9341a345","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound overview; the description does not identify a particular quantum-gravity conjecture or mass mechanism. Independent challenge qualification: Compound overview; no particular quantum-gravity conjecture or mass mechanism is specified."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6902ce6918b014ae9341a345","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","q025-candidate-question:cb83f9bfcc5ee84151cef9b6"],"scopeContentSha256":"4e5fb78ca4afe83c42bb70d0f630fa99255f71831b6900404fb7c5ede86b117e","contributionContentSha256":"78a908b4cdbab667d58071038de965c7a0ea25ac9d6c027e75311f2db2384bd7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:d80318a7bec7d6c00173c89354a7cff447d2c2a9c93ad674374e51f22d5091ac","textSha256":"f4ec3bc74ecb02982e21c24f0524414ccc9a3011faa29781aeb11a7e2b2d92e5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6902ce6918b014ae9341a345","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound overview; the description does not identify a particular quantum-gravity conjecture or mass mechanism.","challengeNote":"Compound overview; no particular quantum-gravity conjecture or mass mechanism is specified.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":9,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"feef6fe41a442d8fe83b36ba431b9b01ab7969dd5bb8ad01742cd54584f8b075"},"organizational-access:d5ba1641d7bd6c1fd9b59eaf":{"id":"organizational-access:d5ba1641d7bd6c1fd9b59eaf","source":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","target":"q025-candidate-question:f412f1abf63acf2a1fa8b2e4","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:feb098a3c2dcad34f29a5e6f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f412f1abf63acf2a1fa8b2e4","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b7b8c61bd9dfa6108b3fc5d10394bee9267be6ce90bb938ee27205ce12d0b761","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:39eed0341dcb24520736303e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","home":{"unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers the full duality-motivated history: accelerated precursor, nonsingular transition, sufficient inflation and relic signatures.","qualification":"q71 covers the entire proposed history, including the origin and sufficiency of the accelerated precursor, singularity replacement and observable gravitons. q29 covers early expansion and fluctuations but does not establish whole coverage of singularity replacement. q61 covers transition control and surviving predictions, but does not clearly encompass the separate sufficiency-of-inflation inquiry. Frame distinctions remain source-specific, and a smooth interpolation is not a demonstrated self-consistent transition.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","textSha256":"bbe9e37b99550e85f47a8ef86f591a750da6de7b464fbd0086998c59e47d2151"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:competing:u8:q71"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:competing:u8:q71","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9"],"scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","placementContentSha256":"569a618813878485d900addfac3c75b16514dedfb6c6f314ee61d8ed99623b8e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:competing:proposal","placement-pilot:competing:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","textSha256":"bbe9e37b99550e85f47a8ef86f591a750da6de7b464fbd0086998c59e47d2151"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f412f1abf63acf2a1fa8b2e4","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","textSha256":"bbe9e37b99550e85f47a8ef86f591a750da6de7b464fbd0086998c59e47d2151"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d8ca7149f5b973ea1e2ba094"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d8ca7149f5b973ea1e2ba094","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","q025-candidate-question:f412f1abf63acf2a1fa8b2e4"],"scopeContentSha256":"b7b8c61bd9dfa6108b3fc5d10394bee9267be6ce90bb938ee27205ce12d0b761","contributionContentSha256":"09cfa075af4e7619571675ec3da5d9f9942ae80d5e11f011f67a3ff35dc1e1d7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","textSha256":"bbe9e37b99550e85f47a8ef86f591a750da6de7b464fbd0086998c59e47d2151"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d8ca7149f5b973ea1e2ba094","recordId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: growing-curvature acceleration, singularity replacement and relic gravitons.","challengeNote":"Compound growing-curvature acceleration, singularity-replacement and relic-graviton targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4b4efe9c99975e108d942e24050dd19ceadba5b571c14e9b4a77ef548f529456"},"organizational-access:ddd5336b56937b711ca23055":{"id":"organizational-access:ddd5336b56937b711ca23055","source":"q025-candidate-region:0ce3bf14ba7042ce2e1bd053","target":"q025-candidate-question:34990732591a1b91983b1849","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:0ce3bf14ba7042ce2e1bd053","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"74ac9a4db2ccd141d9616006a94c65d59200ca947f3c71b21343771edb4210ad","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:796d8e81e059cf233f30610d"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:34990732591a1b91983b1849","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"99e40ce7f503e03ed6f3ef3d9d518d9645fe2334932e89e6f96cabb8684fc106","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:65c619a2d34791f1a2b9ce22"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","home":{"unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0ce3bf14ba7042ce2e1bd053","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","paperId":"2610.41636","textSha256":"78cb7d616db1242c87b4506921af36e198b09b50c8ca953c7f04499bc7585e82"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:189be3e4f24f99d68de0e3cf07d4563e","paperId":"2610.41636","sourceSha256":"e88352dcd22ad489eb3530aa6ad5d1981c4280964e8b3701c5875e30af356f63","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/024fb03a344a4d4ca693/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5d41fa3db86127029cd521e18604d58d91f1dfb802a507e827765652c13a76ec","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1354,"textSha256":"3c0b1487738d80b781aaa959c2d3269a01ae6ffc10aaa7952c01641b89fa558e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:23ef52f1656da80bcbf325dc33eb441f","paperId":"2610.41636","sourceSha256":"e88352dcd22ad489eb3530aa6ad5d1981c4280964e8b3701c5875e30af356f63","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/024fb03a344a4d4ca693/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5d41fa3db86127029cd521e18604d58d91f1dfb802a507e827765652c13a76ec","pdfPage":4,"start":91,"end":3031,"textSha256":"3e301bcd8c175f3685da589e04e9b80892451803d0f31cb588a933559dc3cdeb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6428716e3f9d892a20e3505e56eafc2f","paperId":"2610.41636","sourceSha256":"e88352dcd22ad489eb3530aa6ad5d1981c4280964e8b3701c5875e30af356f63","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/024fb03a344a4d4ca693/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5d41fa3db86127029cd521e18604d58d91f1dfb802a507e827765652c13a76ec","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f0834b2df6492ebd6b49d67b113e2bcc78ce16cca82f59d1fdeff05e7f613c0c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:10954cb450fa6786842acbcf"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:10954cb450fa6786842acbcf","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","q025-candidate-region:0ce3bf14ba7042ce2e1bd053"],"scopeContentSha256":"74ac9a4db2ccd141d9616006a94c65d59200ca947f3c71b21343771edb4210ad","placementContentSha256":"176257300015d98a5056bb79056496b2cc965603b4ae23ccf3a03fd789a4f80b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge","leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","paperId":"2610.41636","textSha256":"78cb7d616db1242c87b4506921af36e198b09b50c8ca953c7f04499bc7585e82"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:189be3e4f24f99d68de0e3cf07d4563e","paperId":"2610.41636","sourceSha256":"e88352dcd22ad489eb3530aa6ad5d1981c4280964e8b3701c5875e30af356f63","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/024fb03a344a4d4ca693/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5d41fa3db86127029cd521e18604d58d91f1dfb802a507e827765652c13a76ec","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1354,"textSha256":"3c0b1487738d80b781aaa959c2d3269a01ae6ffc10aaa7952c01641b89fa558e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:23ef52f1656da80bcbf325dc33eb441f","paperId":"2610.41636","sourceSha256":"e88352dcd22ad489eb3530aa6ad5d1981c4280964e8b3701c5875e30af356f63","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/024fb03a344a4d4ca693/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5d41fa3db86127029cd521e18604d58d91f1dfb802a507e827765652c13a76ec","pdfPage":4,"start":91,"end":3031,"textSha256":"3e301bcd8c175f3685da589e04e9b80892451803d0f31cb588a933559dc3cdeb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6428716e3f9d892a20e3505e56eafc2f","paperId":"2610.41636","sourceSha256":"e88352dcd22ad489eb3530aa6ad5d1981c4280964e8b3701c5875e30af356f63","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/024fb03a344a4d4ca693/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5d41fa3db86127029cd521e18604d58d91f1dfb802a507e827765652c13a76ec","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f0834b2df6492ebd6b49d67b113e2bcc78ce16cca82f59d1fdeff05e7f613c0c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:10954cb450fa6786842acbcf"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:34990732591a1b91983b1849","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","textSha256":"78cb7d616db1242c87b4506921af36e198b09b50c8ca953c7f04499bc7585e82"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:189be3e4f24f99d68de0e3cf07d4563e","paperId":"2610.41636","sourceSha256":"e88352dcd22ad489eb3530aa6ad5d1981c4280964e8b3701c5875e30af356f63","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/024fb03a344a4d4ca693/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5d41fa3db86127029cd521e18604d58d91f1dfb802a507e827765652c13a76ec","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1354,"textSha256":"3c0b1487738d80b781aaa959c2d3269a01ae6ffc10aaa7952c01641b89fa558e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:23ef52f1656da80bcbf325dc33eb441f","paperId":"2610.41636","sourceSha256":"e88352dcd22ad489eb3530aa6ad5d1981c4280964e8b3701c5875e30af356f63","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/024fb03a344a4d4ca693/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5d41fa3db86127029cd521e18604d58d91f1dfb802a507e827765652c13a76ec","pdfPage":4,"start":91,"end":3031,"textSha256":"3e301bcd8c175f3685da589e04e9b80892451803d0f31cb588a933559dc3cdeb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6428716e3f9d892a20e3505e56eafc2f","paperId":"2610.41636","sourceSha256":"e88352dcd22ad489eb3530aa6ad5d1981c4280964e8b3701c5875e30af356f63","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/024fb03a344a4d4ca693/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5d41fa3db86127029cd521e18604d58d91f1dfb802a507e827765652c13a76ec","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f0834b2df6492ebd6b49d67b113e2bcc78ce16cca82f59d1fdeff05e7f613c0c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fd0fc6a20fe8c05d327d0e5e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:fd0fc6a20fe8c05d327d0e5e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","q025-candidate-question:34990732591a1b91983b1849"],"scopeContentSha256":"99e40ce7f503e03ed6f3ef3d9d518d9645fe2334932e89e6f96cabb8684fc106","contributionContentSha256":"788df757dad8bad4df61aef85817257331483fef0952352954aa1aa2b12e2d80","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-431e39adaf172dcc211a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-431e39adaf172dcc211a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-431e39adaf172dcc211a-proposal","leaf-431e39adaf172dcc211a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:f022123c5f0e7c0f8d9742966fef7d49f05bb9c1abbcd3f26f9046a1fb86423e","textSha256":"78cb7d616db1242c87b4506921af36e198b09b50c8ca953c7f04499bc7585e82"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:189be3e4f24f99d68de0e3cf07d4563e","paperId":"2610.41636","sourceSha256":"e88352dcd22ad489eb3530aa6ad5d1981c4280964e8b3701c5875e30af356f63","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/024fb03a344a4d4ca693/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5d41fa3db86127029cd521e18604d58d91f1dfb802a507e827765652c13a76ec","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1354,"textSha256":"3c0b1487738d80b781aaa959c2d3269a01ae6ffc10aaa7952c01641b89fa558e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:23ef52f1656da80bcbf325dc33eb441f","paperId":"2610.41636","sourceSha256":"e88352dcd22ad489eb3530aa6ad5d1981c4280964e8b3701c5875e30af356f63","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/024fb03a344a4d4ca693/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5d41fa3db86127029cd521e18604d58d91f1dfb802a507e827765652c13a76ec","pdfPage":4,"start":91,"end":3031,"textSha256":"3e301bcd8c175f3685da589e04e9b80892451803d0f31cb588a933559dc3cdeb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6428716e3f9d892a20e3505e56eafc2f","paperId":"2610.41636","sourceSha256":"e88352dcd22ad489eb3530aa6ad5d1981c4280964e8b3701c5875e30af356f63","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/024fb03a344a4d4ca693/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5d41fa3db86127029cd521e18604d58d91f1dfb802a507e827765652c13a76ec","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f0834b2df6492ebd6b49d67b113e2bcc78ce16cca82f59d1fdeff05e7f613c0c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fd0fc6a20fe8c05d327d0e5e","recordId":"leaf-431e39adaf172dcc211a-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-431e39adaf172dcc211a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-431e39adaf172dcc211a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound identity crosses epochs: rapid-turn inflationary consistency and phantom-like dark energy need separate reconciliation while retaining the exact so","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound identity spans inflationary consistency and late-time phantom-like behavior. Retain both contributions and the original source unit.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"09f40dd95d429aae12372d92b34a92b4ccf9f40e0a7a5b66b9e775cecc7cfccf"},"organizational-access:3b614939fdeae4519f8dd32a":{"id":"organizational-access:3b614939fdeae4519f8dd32a","source":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","target":"q025-candidate-question:e3d413fdb21c9ba9b200dbee","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"1123f220fa66dcfaf6d7e353a5cf057117c27fd54c0bd35da01fa61759e8d824","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:4ed4ace2d0148acd0fa0f6ef"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e3d413fdb21c9ba9b200dbee","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e92f2b3a97f08ffba1b9b9641b58966e325013d153a203214047ef10a178e837","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ef228973ffdab797a31e2f32"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","home":{"unitId":"unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","paperId":"1912.07035","textSha256":"e1aea81d9bd585ee762e5b69301278e87c9066181525bb4f5b04a418a26dafc5"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2ec82b2f70aabaa6cfa328ab7c804558","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":97,"end":2881,"textSha256":"0e06c003edd1d789601faebce4ee1de5444df67912a0f317078f9fe7887229d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6ac192739d9b90633d519a4c5d974d8a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":52,"start":103,"end":2928,"textSha256":"88ac6d250126085be76bf1731dd9ed1643a4b2d35eadefb0336d3d722e55e639","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:713fb43ca7fd96fd919ec46895f6027a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":0,"end":2881,"textSha256":"fad42dabc3103931820ed5b6950fd27cc8cd4b2de969bf275e28435904a81c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0149353f35a4b32af877a66b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0149353f35a4b32af877a66b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","q025-candidate-region:253a0228d3b0d0c00a935278"],"scopeContentSha256":"1123f220fa66dcfaf6d7e353a5cf057117c27fd54c0bd35da01fa61759e8d824","placementContentSha256":"d5ecec94cf92589ba1f861ab9bb0d025ae977603d5686fcc1fef473ad0221782","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-challenge","parent-6ab3e7dd3d9d3194f51a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","paperId":"1912.07035","textSha256":"e1aea81d9bd585ee762e5b69301278e87c9066181525bb4f5b04a418a26dafc5"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2ec82b2f70aabaa6cfa328ab7c804558","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":97,"end":2881,"textSha256":"0e06c003edd1d789601faebce4ee1de5444df67912a0f317078f9fe7887229d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6ac192739d9b90633d519a4c5d974d8a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":52,"start":103,"end":2928,"textSha256":"88ac6d250126085be76bf1731dd9ed1643a4b2d35eadefb0336d3d722e55e639","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:713fb43ca7fd96fd919ec46895f6027a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":0,"end":2881,"textSha256":"fad42dabc3103931820ed5b6950fd27cc8cd4b2de969bf275e28435904a81c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0149353f35a4b32af877a66b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e3d413fdb21c9ba9b200dbee","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","textSha256":"e1aea81d9bd585ee762e5b69301278e87c9066181525bb4f5b04a418a26dafc5"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6ac192739d9b90633d519a4c5d974d8a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":52,"start":103,"end":2928,"textSha256":"88ac6d250126085be76bf1731dd9ed1643a4b2d35eadefb0336d3d722e55e639","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:713fb43ca7fd96fd919ec46895f6027a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":0,"end":2881,"textSha256":"fad42dabc3103931820ed5b6950fd27cc8cd4b2de969bf275e28435904a81c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2ec82b2f70aabaa6cfa328ab7c804558","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":97,"end":2881,"textSha256":"0e06c003edd1d789601faebce4ee1de5444df67912a0f317078f9fe7887229d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bb7b3fcaff54b513438f462f","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound thesis: spectrum classification, black-hole thermodynamics and CFT observables need separate fine-facet reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Unresolved compound thesis: spectrum classification, black-hole thermodynamics and CFT observables require separate fine facets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:bb7b3fcaff54b513438f462f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","q025-candidate-question:e3d413fdb21c9ba9b200dbee"],"scopeContentSha256":"e92f2b3a97f08ffba1b9b9641b58966e325013d153a203214047ef10a178e837","contributionContentSha256":"920da42b12b9be5cc83f4afd501a7b78ecaec7fb347d4fb012d27b47a2d379e6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-proposal","leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:e59966e2a780d074cdfedf192144ac3d89a945343f15ab2340ac6dcf73d719c8","textSha256":"e1aea81d9bd585ee762e5b69301278e87c9066181525bb4f5b04a418a26dafc5"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6ac192739d9b90633d519a4c5d974d8a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":52,"start":103,"end":2928,"textSha256":"88ac6d250126085be76bf1731dd9ed1643a4b2d35eadefb0336d3d722e55e639","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:713fb43ca7fd96fd919ec46895f6027a","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":0,"end":2881,"textSha256":"fad42dabc3103931820ed5b6950fd27cc8cd4b2de969bf275e28435904a81c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2ec82b2f70aabaa6cfa328ab7c804558","paperId":"1912.07035","sourceSha256":"b8d2f5c3a7e36072ba9648c51d4e2e54914a16c713eb008b61f6a385e1b89579","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48bf8e411b88488036b9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"de556ccc053904d8aa605eb41510a17944484b4b9e57c7b9de1492a661398613","pdfPage":293,"start":97,"end":2881,"textSha256":"0e06c003edd1d789601faebce4ee1de5444df67912a0f317078f9fe7887229d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bb7b3fcaff54b513438f462f","recordId":"leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8e775767127ad728f8c6-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound thesis: spectrum classification, black-hole thermodynamics and CFT observables need separate fine-facet reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound thesis: spectrum classification, black-hole thermodynamics and CFT observables require separate fine facets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"903d7a4ac98bb09235a290af7143b2ca9d46b5409d3aa0b7aa9aaf06c10a6b3f"},"organizational-access:8b349e1cca978e99750755b3":{"id":"organizational-access:8b349e1cca978e99750755b3","source":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","target":"q025-candidate-question:38ec1fe08d842dd1c5bb0d42","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1867e10e8c8bafd942db110d"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:38ec1fe08d842dd1c5bb0d42","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a846177560d3061b71819f8f7fc887ed426412c1dbc90bf5657ec817ad38d776","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d319154fc8eec1701d425182"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","home":{"unitId":"unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","paperId":"2302.00685","textSha256":"3b7fcd6b2f1dec8f64295fb209c4e301eed8f1ec6f54d26e9bf78ae1e89d02b4"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:487da602a0f61fa172069ea3d71a46d7","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":2499,"end":5288,"textSha256":"58f2cfdd09f2191f7fb75183e0b70dae7eb77444f91d4a4f5d7e0ca914e10219","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:634922c473a35f85b66140f4c0471c8d","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"74c6ac082bc688a7c195472344d278e557885ed6861025e0ff0f1ff9a769a115","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6c1b05d8662c34aba249330e53db8df3","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":99,"end":3500,"textSha256":"1110501119530ca5d1ee811fa19465428ac25416d71c95a386ef31112ea04421","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:deed292c39ba07b7f287a279"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:deed292c39ba07b7f287a279","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","placementContentSha256":"bba6090ce3cb6d33f91500193e8797dd745cf0912450e02010706eda5ce3d096","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","paperId":"2302.00685","textSha256":"3b7fcd6b2f1dec8f64295fb209c4e301eed8f1ec6f54d26e9bf78ae1e89d02b4"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:487da602a0f61fa172069ea3d71a46d7","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":2499,"end":5288,"textSha256":"58f2cfdd09f2191f7fb75183e0b70dae7eb77444f91d4a4f5d7e0ca914e10219","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:634922c473a35f85b66140f4c0471c8d","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"74c6ac082bc688a7c195472344d278e557885ed6861025e0ff0f1ff9a769a115","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6c1b05d8662c34aba249330e53db8df3","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":99,"end":3500,"textSha256":"1110501119530ca5d1ee811fa19465428ac25416d71c95a386ef31112ea04421","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:deed292c39ba07b7f287a279"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:38ec1fe08d842dd1c5bb0d42","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","textSha256":"3b7fcd6b2f1dec8f64295fb209c4e301eed8f1ec6f54d26e9bf78ae1e89d02b4"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:487da602a0f61fa172069ea3d71a46d7","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":2499,"end":5288,"textSha256":"58f2cfdd09f2191f7fb75183e0b70dae7eb77444f91d4a4f5d7e0ca914e10219","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:634922c473a35f85b66140f4c0471c8d","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"74c6ac082bc688a7c195472344d278e557885ed6861025e0ff0f1ff9a769a115","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6c1b05d8662c34aba249330e53db8df3","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":99,"end":3500,"textSha256":"1110501119530ca5d1ee811fa19465428ac25416d71c95a386ef31112ea04421","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1e109bab205a8f5a71434d83","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Cold-to-relativistic conversion bounds depend on the DM fraction, perturbations and growth past critical mass; no SM coupling is required. Independent challenge qualification: Bounds require a sufficient relic fraction, approximately power-law isocurvature and stars reaching critical mass. Independence from SM couplings does not erase"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1e109bab205a8f5a71434d83","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","q025-candidate-question:38ec1fe08d842dd1c5bb0d42"],"scopeContentSha256":"a846177560d3061b71819f8f7fc887ed426412c1dbc90bf5657ec817ad38d776","contributionContentSha256":"7d0d6cd93aebfc9d5204ed7ab4a0af20a1f5c900e86c3a02391d3036a5025e8f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-proposal","leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","textSha256":"3b7fcd6b2f1dec8f64295fb209c4e301eed8f1ec6f54d26e9bf78ae1e89d02b4"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:487da602a0f61fa172069ea3d71a46d7","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":2499,"end":5288,"textSha256":"58f2cfdd09f2191f7fb75183e0b70dae7eb77444f91d4a4f5d7e0ca914e10219","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:634922c473a35f85b66140f4c0471c8d","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"74c6ac082bc688a7c195472344d278e557885ed6861025e0ff0f1ff9a769a115","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6c1b05d8662c34aba249330e53db8df3","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":99,"end":3500,"textSha256":"1110501119530ca5d1ee811fa19465428ac25416d71c95a386ef31112ea04421","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1e109bab205a8f5a71434d83","recordId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-73087c9e584d0be9e7c5-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Cold-to-relativistic conversion bounds depend on the DM fraction, perturbations and growth past critical mass; no SM coupling is required.","challengeNote":"Bounds require a sufficient relic fraction, approximately power-law isocurvature and stars reaching critical mass. Independence from SM couplings does not erase","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"17306d970f7864eb16f99e0e891a489fd5bcb88d9ea7cdadc76874c3aa8b6eb1"},"organizational-access:6972201fddbac6e1ea732259":{"id":"organizational-access:6972201fddbac6e1ea732259","source":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","target":"q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1867e10e8c8bafd942db110d"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7ff3fca5366d230a83fac4fa717a38ec33392311ec71189349ae7aa6f682b5e9","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8355fb968e21a26d5f50ce2b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","home":{"unitId":"unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","paperId":"2302.00685","textSha256":"3b7fcd6b2f1dec8f64295fb209c4e301eed8f1ec6f54d26e9bf78ae1e89d02b4"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:487da602a0f61fa172069ea3d71a46d7","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":2499,"end":5288,"textSha256":"58f2cfdd09f2191f7fb75183e0b70dae7eb77444f91d4a4f5d7e0ca914e10219","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:634922c473a35f85b66140f4c0471c8d","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"74c6ac082bc688a7c195472344d278e557885ed6861025e0ff0f1ff9a769a115","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6c1b05d8662c34aba249330e53db8df3","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":99,"end":3500,"textSha256":"1110501119530ca5d1ee811fa19465428ac25416d71c95a386ef31112ea04421","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:deed292c39ba07b7f287a279"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:deed292c39ba07b7f287a279","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","placementContentSha256":"bba6090ce3cb6d33f91500193e8797dd745cf0912450e02010706eda5ce3d096","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","paperId":"2302.00685","textSha256":"3b7fcd6b2f1dec8f64295fb209c4e301eed8f1ec6f54d26e9bf78ae1e89d02b4"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:487da602a0f61fa172069ea3d71a46d7","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":2499,"end":5288,"textSha256":"58f2cfdd09f2191f7fb75183e0b70dae7eb77444f91d4a4f5d7e0ca914e10219","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:634922c473a35f85b66140f4c0471c8d","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"74c6ac082bc688a7c195472344d278e557885ed6861025e0ff0f1ff9a769a115","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6c1b05d8662c34aba249330e53db8df3","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":99,"end":3500,"textSha256":"1110501119530ca5d1ee811fa19465428ac25416d71c95a386ef31112ea04421","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:deed292c39ba07b7f287a279"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","textSha256":"3b7fcd6b2f1dec8f64295fb209c4e301eed8f1ec6f54d26e9bf78ae1e89d02b4"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:487da602a0f61fa172069ea3d71a46d7","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":2499,"end":5288,"textSha256":"58f2cfdd09f2191f7fb75183e0b70dae7eb77444f91d4a4f5d7e0ca914e10219","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:634922c473a35f85b66140f4c0471c8d","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"74c6ac082bc688a7c195472344d278e557885ed6861025e0ff0f1ff9a769a115","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6c1b05d8662c34aba249330e53db8df3","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":99,"end":3500,"textSha256":"1110501119530ca5d1ee811fa19465428ac25416d71c95a386ef31112ea04421","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cc08e2fe425ef1f55656bcae","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: February 2023 constraints require suitable structure formation and axion abundance; independence from Standard Model couplings is not independence from these Independent challenge qualification: February 2023 bounds depend on attractive self-interactions, structure formation and abundance; fractional axion matter weakens them. Standard Model coupli"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:cc08e2fe425ef1f55656bcae","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35"],"scopeContentSha256":"7ff3fca5366d230a83fac4fa717a38ec33392311ec71189349ae7aa6f682b5e9","contributionContentSha256":"f2bbc2fcc8dbd3c227dfb64bf7488628b66c323013a1fcde741b80fcb6ce1823","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:5af4163b9d5d993e6deeceed659c0db3f07fc3cb5a3df8e52f23092bab6d3178","textSha256":"3b7fcd6b2f1dec8f64295fb209c4e301eed8f1ec6f54d26e9bf78ae1e89d02b4"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:487da602a0f61fa172069ea3d71a46d7","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":2499,"end":5288,"textSha256":"58f2cfdd09f2191f7fb75183e0b70dae7eb77444f91d4a4f5d7e0ca914e10219","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:634922c473a35f85b66140f4c0471c8d","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"74c6ac082bc688a7c195472344d278e557885ed6861025e0ff0f1ff9a769a115","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6c1b05d8662c34aba249330e53db8df3","paperId":"2302.00685","sourceSha256":"1367fecdb28718df0a6b2d742607ea1043ca3bf9a17cfbdf23ecec48b00468b9","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/38ad4cbadea61fc559a5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d5205b7d1656f74eeaef1b39fcc64d9c1bc05db56dda85ef053b78b54b483f99","pdfPage":1,"start":99,"end":3500,"textSha256":"1110501119530ca5d1ee811fa19465428ac25416d71c95a386ef31112ea04421","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cc08e2fe425ef1f55656bcae","recordId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"February 2023 constraints require suitable structure formation and axion abundance; independence from Standard Model couplings is not independence from these","challengeNote":"February 2023 bounds depend on attractive self-interactions, structure formation and abundance; fractional axion matter weakens them. Standard Model coupli","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:84f7837aaa838b43f86ca0b1f9d246a71640b984dfd2992b32e26429618e4fcc","home":{"unitId":"unit:84f7837aaa838b43f86ca0b1f9d246a71640b984dfd2992b32e26429618e4fcc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:84f7837aaa838b43f86ca0b1f9d246a71640b984dfd2992b32e26429618e4fcc","paperId":"2410.11099","textSha256":"cbbcb830b53735a5706fe23524319da7506cd7840e1844b26d2839929acc6937"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc31c5db27ef642ed8b457a4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc31c5db27ef642ed8b457a4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:84f7837aaa838b43f86ca0b1f9d246a71640b984dfd2992b32e26429618e4fcc","q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","placementContentSha256":"9ba429b36ac85f9e034754eabe8ed33024de224142e57f265a14a66933005bbc","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:84f7837aaa838b43f86ca0b1f9d246a71640b984dfd2992b32e26429618e4fcc","paperId":"2410.11099","textSha256":"cbbcb830b53735a5706fe23524319da7506cd7840e1844b26d2839929acc6937"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc31c5db27ef642ed8b457a4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:84f7837aaa838b43f86ca0b1f9d246a71640b984dfd2992b32e26429618e4fcc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d29","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:84f7837aaa838b43f86ca0b1f9d246a71640b984dfd2992b32e26429618e4fcc","textSha256":"cbbcb830b53735a5706fe23524319da7506cd7840e1844b26d2839929acc6937"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dc9810a3694ff5b19cc0d4d9","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Joint model assigns matter to axion oscillations and dark energy to the dilaton; local constraints are a viability requirement. Independent challenge qualification: Joint construction assigns dark matter to axion oscillations and dark energy to the dilaton; local tests constrain viability."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:dc9810a3694ff5b19cc0d4d9","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:84f7837aaa838b43f86ca0b1f9d246a71640b984dfd2992b32e26429618e4fcc","q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35"],"scopeContentSha256":"7ff3fca5366d230a83fac4fa717a38ec33392311ec71189349ae7aa6f682b5e9","contributionContentSha256":"958ad82b0597c509da8daafd8cad17ede0a57377984b86a43385065063fe1dee","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d29","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:84f7837aaa838b43f86ca0b1f9d246a71640b984dfd2992b32e26429618e4fcc","textSha256":"cbbcb830b53735a5706fe23524319da7506cd7840e1844b26d2839929acc6937"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dc9810a3694ff5b19cc0d4d9","recordId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Joint model assigns matter to axion oscillations and dark energy to the dilaton; local constraints are a viability requirement.","challengeNote":"Joint construction assigns dark matter to axion oscillations and dark energy to the dilaton; local tests constrain viability.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:88de209a3126b3cf78907ad52ec560fa8a0b3b8884e6c037c1492316c225106c","home":{"unitId":"unit:88de209a3126b3cf78907ad52ec560fa8a0b3b8884e6c037c1492316c225106c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:88de209a3126b3cf78907ad52ec560fa8a0b3b8884e6c037c1492316c225106c","paperId":"2602.23424","textSha256":"fa7519f75e80d6d4e217c606711c76389a1d8a95da02e25ca3071206134b78f2"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:44fcdc8fa0d19759b0a8b598"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:44fcdc8fa0d19759b0a8b598","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:88de209a3126b3cf78907ad52ec560fa8a0b3b8884e6c037c1492316c225106c","q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","placementContentSha256":"e87e803f0b648ef38a58bd07e07d62d4a77dde7238c89d2b23765f45b2124f3e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:88de209a3126b3cf78907ad52ec560fa8a0b3b8884e6c037c1492316c225106c","paperId":"2602.23424","textSha256":"fa7519f75e80d6d4e217c606711c76389a1d8a95da02e25ca3071206134b78f2"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:44fcdc8fa0d19759b0a8b598"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:88de209a3126b3cf78907ad52ec560fa8a0b3b8884e6c037c1492316c225106c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:88de209a3126b3cf78907ad52ec560fa8a0b3b8884e6c037c1492316c225106c","textSha256":"fa7519f75e80d6d4e217c606711c76389a1d8a95da02e25ca3071206134b78f2"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:540263ac2d065f91a776949e","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound conditioned-ensemble program; inflationary relic production does not establish axion-driven inflation. Independent challenge qualification: Compound conditioned-ensemble program. The potential-building method connection does not establish that relic-producing fields drove inflation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:540263ac2d065f91a776949e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:88de209a3126b3cf78907ad52ec560fa8a0b3b8884e6c037c1492316c225106c","q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35"],"scopeContentSha256":"7ff3fca5366d230a83fac4fa717a38ec33392311ec71189349ae7aa6f682b5e9","contributionContentSha256":"a8edd9110ea8e424aa679aea98fcd052c89ae45868253749ae0ad756396dbd2e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:88de209a3126b3cf78907ad52ec560fa8a0b3b8884e6c037c1492316c225106c","textSha256":"fa7519f75e80d6d4e217c606711c76389a1d8a95da02e25ca3071206134b78f2"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:540263ac2d065f91a776949e","recordId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound conditioned-ensemble program; inflationary relic production does not establish axion-driven inflation.","challengeNote":"Compound conditioned-ensemble program. The potential-building method connection does not establish that relic-producing fields drove inflation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","home":{"unitId":"unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","paperId":"1510.07633","textSha256":"a43716256e5420305ab4cb364f4c990e81bcab046ecc6f7a0d6c16f116602642"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:efd0cba87b3141f21003c1f8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:efd0cba87b3141f21003c1f8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","placementContentSha256":"550191cfb7a8ed79eeded04bf7372507b62d439abffdff9d6ca5257853b136fd","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","paperId":"1510.07633","textSha256":"a43716256e5420305ab4cb364f4c990e81bcab046ecc6f7a0d6c16f116602642"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:efd0cba87b3141f21003c1f8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","textSha256":"a43716256e5420305ab4cb364f4c990e81bcab046ecc6f7a0d6c16f116602642"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f8937ab930bdc8ad3fd004df","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Broad survey question; source-scoped access does not imply one atomic target. Independent challenge qualification: Broad survey question; source-scoped identity does not establish atomicity."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f8937ab930bdc8ad3fd004df","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35"],"scopeContentSha256":"7ff3fca5366d230a83fac4fa717a38ec33392311ec71189349ae7aa6f682b5e9","contributionContentSha256":"a966b9b31f7e5927e596c4654d813474fcd10dee048a30c7611b1ba645e68c7f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:ac64bd673fdb98c52a06263ef1686f589e0a1f4bcadb8550f171d98b93f9a203","textSha256":"a43716256e5420305ab4cb364f4c990e81bcab046ecc6f7a0d6c16f116602642"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f8937ab930bdc8ad3fd004df","recordId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Broad survey question; source-scoped access does not imply one atomic target.","challengeNote":"Broad survey question; source-scoped identity does not establish atomicity.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ebd0a34924be07207d236aae6a251efa2d7438b4ddfc5cb5a00abbceeaab08e4","home":{"unitId":"unit:ebd0a34924be07207d236aae6a251efa2d7438b4ddfc5cb5a00abbceeaab08e4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ebd0a34924be07207d236aae6a251efa2d7438b4ddfc5cb5a00abbceeaab08e4","paperId":"2011.11894","textSha256":"f60dd3da17a815757449a69c93c33c51441bfd53374e1dd0032c09a692bd74e9"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:af2cf6a98ca207dc8f811047"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:af2cf6a98ca207dc8f811047","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ebd0a34924be07207d236aae6a251efa2d7438b4ddfc5cb5a00abbceeaab08e4","q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","placementContentSha256":"ed40b69ee0e3f8fda9fc11ae9a6fffcf02de3d8c1dce52af2a7643f4bccddb8a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ebd0a34924be07207d236aae6a251efa2d7438b4ddfc5cb5a00abbceeaab08e4","paperId":"2011.11894","textSha256":"f60dd3da17a815757449a69c93c33c51441bfd53374e1dd0032c09a692bd74e9"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:af2cf6a98ca207dc8f811047"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ebd0a34924be07207d236aae6a251efa2d7438b4ddfc5cb5a00abbceeaab08e4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:ebd0a34924be07207d236aae6a251efa2d7438b4ddfc5cb5a00abbceeaab08e4","textSha256":"f60dd3da17a815757449a69c93c33c51441bfd53374e1dd0032c09a692bd74e9"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fc2e5696ce818b81f38faca4","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Dark matter, thawing dark energy and early dark energy are alternative roles in a compound conditional question. Independent challenge qualification: Dark matter, thawing dark energy and early dark energy are alternative roles; historical birefringence motivates conditional bounds."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:fc2e5696ce818b81f38faca4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ebd0a34924be07207d236aae6a251efa2d7438b4ddfc5cb5a00abbceeaab08e4","q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35"],"scopeContentSha256":"7ff3fca5366d230a83fac4fa717a38ec33392311ec71189349ae7aa6f682b5e9","contributionContentSha256":"31a333d951e3a386444f4a25ad88bac460d1b7fdb1bd37c953e81f24fe5b2bcf","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:ebd0a34924be07207d236aae6a251efa2d7438b4ddfc5cb5a00abbceeaab08e4","textSha256":"f60dd3da17a815757449a69c93c33c51441bfd53374e1dd0032c09a692bd74e9"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fc2e5696ce818b81f38faca4","recordId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Dark matter, thawing dark energy and early dark energy are alternative roles in a compound conditional question.","challengeNote":"Dark matter, thawing dark energy and early dark energy are alternative roles; historical birefringence motivates conditional bounds.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ef6709dac226f0321fdf7b7f7107dcd507841b2307e650baf36aaf9dcd6d57fb","home":{"unitId":"unit:ef6709dac226f0321fdf7b7f7107dcd507841b2307e650baf36aaf9dcd6d57fb","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ef6709dac226f0321fdf7b7f7107dcd507841b2307e650baf36aaf9dcd6d57fb","paperId":"2311.00234","textSha256":"8a0d327f3249b2d1d8c764d15e4cd1ef8fb8c9e6cee5e05db80e46777206562f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:932fcdb5768efa239a7bf2a1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:932fcdb5768efa239a7bf2a1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ef6709dac226f0321fdf7b7f7107dcd507841b2307e650baf36aaf9dcd6d57fb","q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","placementContentSha256":"0faaf42f4e7e24fad5f173f214555fe2fb421451b7a16b088fffdd98f58be4df","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ef6709dac226f0321fdf7b7f7107dcd507841b2307e650baf36aaf9dcd6d57fb","paperId":"2311.00234","textSha256":"8a0d327f3249b2d1d8c764d15e4cd1ef8fb8c9e6cee5e05db80e46777206562f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:932fcdb5768efa239a7bf2a1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ef6709dac226f0321fdf7b7f7107dcd507841b2307e650baf36aaf9dcd6d57fb","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:ef6709dac226f0321fdf7b7f7107dcd507841b2307e650baf36aaf9dcd6d57fb","textSha256":"8a0d327f3249b2d1d8c764d15e4cd1ef8fb8c9e6cee5e05db80e46777206562f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:28d07491ac8458cc5997fa79","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:28d07491ac8458cc5997fa79","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ef6709dac226f0321fdf7b7f7107dcd507841b2307e650baf36aaf9dcd6d57fb","q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35"],"scopeContentSha256":"7ff3fca5366d230a83fac4fa717a38ec33392311ec71189349ae7aa6f682b5e9","contributionContentSha256":"b7c3aefc20a3c7e6e2463762b25f5ad52aee87e8d1f16ee3a2808f038da61d6d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:ef6709dac226f0321fdf7b7f7107dcd507841b2307e650baf36aaf9dcd6d57fb","textSha256":"8a0d327f3249b2d1d8c764d15e4cd1ef8fb8c9e6cee5e05db80e46777206562f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:28d07491ac8458cc5997fa79","recordId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:fa7372bf16bc3ae6b7c5e396f5c6ff0ada6292982fbf075aa43aba334571f6b8","home":{"unitId":"unit:fa7372bf16bc3ae6b7c5e396f5c6ff0ada6292982fbf075aa43aba334571f6b8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers axion potentials, coupling measurements, relic production and thermal interaction methods across distinct cosmic epochs.","qualification":"q38 covers measurement, reliable potential construction, post-inflationary abundance and thermal-friction dynamics collectively within one existing scope. q7, q13 and q23 each cover only parts. Unspecified friction epochs do not prevent this family-level placement, and none are reconstructed from the truncated annotations.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fa7372bf16bc3ae6b7c5e396f5c6ff0ada6292982fbf075aa43aba334571f6b8","paperId":"2203.08026","textSha256":"a2b39cd800d923d8566012e7cab380c9113cf37f857f534aa5febf8548c99412"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0060:u2:q38"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0060:u2:q38","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fa7372bf16bc3ae6b7c5e396f5c6ff0ada6292982fbf075aa43aba334571f6b8","q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","placementContentSha256":"caacfe3ffee9e149608dd8fdb7f041561dd22a89393f9b75d44c546b18256e72","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0060:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0060:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fa7372bf16bc3ae6b7c5e396f5c6ff0ada6292982fbf075aa43aba334571f6b8","paperId":"2203.08026","textSha256":"a2b39cd800d923d8566012e7cab380c9113cf37f857f534aa5febf8548c99412"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0060","unitRef":"u2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fa7372bf16bc3ae6b7c5e396f5c6ff0ada6292982fbf075aa43aba334571f6b8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:fa7372bf16bc3ae6b7c5e396f5c6ff0ada6292982fbf075aa43aba334571f6b8","textSha256":"a2b39cd800d923d8566012e7cab380c9113cf37f857f534aa5febf8548c99412"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5117ae1ac5f9c6d06f769cd0","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Coupling measurement, monopole potentials, relic prediction and thermal friction are distinct tasks; atomic question identity is unresolved. Friction epochs are Independent challenge qualification: Coupling measurement, monopole potentials, relic prediction and thermal friction are distinct tasks; atomic identity and specific friction epochs remain ope"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5117ae1ac5f9c6d06f769cd0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fa7372bf16bc3ae6b7c5e396f5c6ff0ada6292982fbf075aa43aba334571f6b8","q025-candidate-question:685805e1a84614c2d0e03f35"],"scopeContentSha256":"7ff3fca5366d230a83fac4fa717a38ec33392311ec71189349ae7aa6f682b5e9","contributionContentSha256":"161fa53a76ddb1afdfb9e650d20f92cb812a0200caa9a104530bb3cbc2aedc4e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:fa7372bf16bc3ae6b7c5e396f5c6ff0ada6292982fbf075aa43aba334571f6b8","textSha256":"a2b39cd800d923d8566012e7cab380c9113cf37f857f534aa5febf8548c99412"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5117ae1ac5f9c6d06f769cd0","recordId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-971fa8dc901b31a1c07e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Coupling measurement, monopole potentials, relic prediction and thermal friction are distinct tasks; atomic question identity is unresolved. Friction epochs are","challengeNote":"Coupling measurement, monopole potentials, relic prediction and thermal friction are distinct tasks; atomic identity and specific friction epochs remain ope","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":7,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"6ed02204d442ff3949b821fe81c00b75b3b7050506669191571af4719f29cb4a"},"organizational-access:3d1c23e575ebb87a291f75af":{"id":"organizational-access:3d1c23e575ebb87a291f75af","source":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","target":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1867e10e8c8bafd942db110d"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9e6c184caeeca1fe514b806a44ec65f74bf314448503e5b9dead2e99a6f758bf","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:498d2ccc89fa873c91e4b585"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:806fb9dbceedc7746e4bf49d2bf83bfa907d6c07ec02ffdd57a3a69df5f48904","home":{"unitId":"unit:806fb9dbceedc7746e4bf49d2bf83bfa907d6c07ec02ffdd57a3a69df5f48904","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Combines axion–gauge interaction construction, inflationary signals, effective-theory control and conditional gravitational restrictions, covering every spectator clockwork target.","qualification":"q14 covers spectator clockwork coupling generation, observational agreement, calculational control and both additional restriction targets. Quantized coupling, field range, perturbative unitarity and conjectural consistency are kept distinct.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:806fb9dbceedc7746e4bf49d2bf83bfa907d6c07ec02ffdd57a3a69df5f48904","textSha256":"f1dc05c56317ed22bfd5b2a9280abacb96e1d1b7c9893813002fadb363ee8fa6"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u14:q14"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u14:q14","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:806fb9dbceedc7746e4bf49d2bf83bfa907d6c07ec02ffdd57a3a69df5f48904","q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","placementContentSha256":"7d0de6de4d0af770c7c7e60afbd21268718160ac9b0e97ec50d9feb8a404effb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:coverage:proposal","placement-pilot:coverage:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:806fb9dbceedc7746e4bf49d2bf83bfa907d6c07ec02ffdd57a3a69df5f48904","textSha256":"f1dc05c56317ed22bfd5b2a9280abacb96e1d1b7c9893813002fadb363ee8fa6"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:806fb9dbceedc7746e4bf49d2bf83bfa907d6c07ec02ffdd57a3a69df5f48904"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:806fb9dbceedc7746e4bf49d2bf83bfa907d6c07ec02ffdd57a3a69df5f48904","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:806fb9dbceedc7746e4bf49d2bf83bfa907d6c07ec02ffdd57a3a69df5f48904","textSha256":"f1dc05c56317ed22bfd5b2a9280abacb96e1d1b7c9893813002fadb363ee8fa6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a4bac74f0046fb7b47e056b6","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Spectator chromo-natural coupling generation, observational control, perturbative unitarity and conjectural restrictions remain compound targets. Independent challenge qualification: Spectator coupling generation, observational control, unitarity and conjectural restrictions remain compound targets for reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a4bac74f0046fb7b47e056b6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:806fb9dbceedc7746e4bf49d2bf83bfa907d6c07ec02ffdd57a3a69df5f48904","q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a"],"scopeContentSha256":"9e6c184caeeca1fe514b806a44ec65f74bf314448503e5b9dead2e99a6f758bf","contributionContentSha256":"5c05c26546761fe5dee3451f669267776dee82966d0811adc3ed62abee612f44","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:806fb9dbceedc7746e4bf49d2bf83bfa907d6c07ec02ffdd57a3a69df5f48904","textSha256":"f1dc05c56317ed22bfd5b2a9280abacb96e1d1b7c9893813002fadb363ee8fa6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a4bac74f0046fb7b47e056b6","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Spectator chromo-natural coupling generation, observational control, perturbative unitarity and conjectural restrictions remain compound targets.","challengeNote":"Spectator coupling generation, observational control, unitarity and conjectural restrictions remain compound targets for reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"107d3738e3762f58e5e3af7885176acbd1941590ec87d20f24ba81a15a2b9222"},"organizational-access:f7c5e6a89eb833c6b30a40e8":{"id":"organizational-access:f7c5e6a89eb833c6b30a40e8","source":"q025-candidate-region:333d785571e1a50f88438b24","target":"q025-candidate-question:95efbbed52217cca63129bce","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:333d785571e1a50f88438b24","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"b0e054f2a029bb87bf7be8aef9d3766ba839f63d8c88498e3635a32c623f9366","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e1178c51f9332e69f248bc19"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:95efbbed52217cca63129bce","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"3983fac7fb545196ef7b26cd2de5350399fb0aeac1bdf170bc250d48fd794917","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:9fe72e100b281d099578ee0f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:7405c8339af3ffe46f68a3eefa148d2c8a09d2f17f60ca4c7c002bdb46ba2a76","home":{"unitId":"unit:7405c8339af3ffe46f68a3eefa148d2c8a09d2f17f60ca4c7c002bdb46ba2a76","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:333d785571e1a50f88438b24","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q24 combines field-theoretic dynamics and observables in prescribed backgrounds with subsystem structure and physical information, covering production and correlation targets together.","qualification":"q24 covers both fermionic creation and the independent entanglement/Bell observables. q15 covers the curved-spacetime production contribution only. Selected states and fermionic α-vacua remain explicit; alternative strong-field and heavy-mass limits are not imposed simultaneously or universally.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7405c8339af3ffe46f68a3eefa148d2c8a09d2f17f60ca4c7c002bdb46ba2a76","paperId":"2102.11745","textSha256":"eb11ec036920842cff27f866f6990f74d54cb284d02657375256b8ab18863523"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0067:u19:q24"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0067:u19:q24","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7405c8339af3ffe46f68a3eefa148d2c8a09d2f17f60ca4c7c002bdb46ba2a76","q025-candidate-region:333d785571e1a50f88438b24"],"scopeContentSha256":"b0e054f2a029bb87bf7be8aef9d3766ba839f63d8c88498e3635a32c623f9366","placementContentSha256":"34c179087dca8780ead8b0043db0513d1eeb253a38db1cd92e522bbfdf96646f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0067:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0067:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7405c8339af3ffe46f68a3eefa148d2c8a09d2f17f60ca4c7c002bdb46ba2a76","paperId":"2102.11745","textSha256":"eb11ec036920842cff27f866f6990f74d54cb284d02657375256b8ab18863523"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0067","unitRef":"u19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7405c8339af3ffe46f68a3eefa148d2c8a09d2f17f60ca4c7c002bdb46ba2a76","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:95efbbed52217cca63129bce","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:7405c8339af3ffe46f68a3eefa148d2c8a09d2f17f60ca4c7c002bdb46ba2a76","textSha256":"eb11ec036920842cff27f866f6990f74d54cb284d02657375256b8ab18863523"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:050db3b8cd3fdb258ac2e5c7e4c1a415","paperId":"2102.11745","sourceSha256":"d264531870bdc50ba17e0885d732d0eb50ec7928e6c7ea9b09e06ef651e78a09","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0161443e1d245a324875/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"56b1eb7701d7c57a3dd809b5605415b53deb9e2fec59f378c0d5c379942b1505","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1547,"textSha256":"742f80b66650df77e675584687913841a671e091a808238e77730ec9bc185b66","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dea5f54f9f0b1568d81a0cfa3d5d5fb8","paperId":"2102.11745","sourceSha256":"d264531870bdc50ba17e0885d732d0eb50ec7928e6c7ea9b09e06ef651e78a09","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0161443e1d245a324875/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"56b1eb7701d7c57a3dd809b5605415b53deb9e2fec59f378c0d5c379942b1505","pdfPage":1,"start":99,"end":1547,"textSha256":"244c56f5a8c9100055dadd22f63b2063ace4f7711708261d8d775eabca2c4bbc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b3cd538bf0a19d26aacb600a","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Production and Bell/correlation targets remain distinct within this source-scoped singleton; the abstract restricts its regimes. Independent challenge qualification: Production and correlation targets remain distinguishable within this source-scoped singleton; strong-field and heavy-mass limits are alternatives."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b3cd538bf0a19d26aacb600a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7405c8339af3ffe46f68a3eefa148d2c8a09d2f17f60ca4c7c002bdb46ba2a76","q025-candidate-question:95efbbed52217cca63129bce"],"scopeContentSha256":"3983fac7fb545196ef7b26cd2de5350399fb0aeac1bdf170bc250d48fd794917","contributionContentSha256":"a864684dc4855afe004c9492daa74c94fc2c493aac5cbc564308fe0887c4d9bd","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-proposal","leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:7405c8339af3ffe46f68a3eefa148d2c8a09d2f17f60ca4c7c002bdb46ba2a76","textSha256":"eb11ec036920842cff27f866f6990f74d54cb284d02657375256b8ab18863523"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:050db3b8cd3fdb258ac2e5c7e4c1a415","paperId":"2102.11745","sourceSha256":"d264531870bdc50ba17e0885d732d0eb50ec7928e6c7ea9b09e06ef651e78a09","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0161443e1d245a324875/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"56b1eb7701d7c57a3dd809b5605415b53deb9e2fec59f378c0d5c379942b1505","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1547,"textSha256":"742f80b66650df77e675584687913841a671e091a808238e77730ec9bc185b66","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dea5f54f9f0b1568d81a0cfa3d5d5fb8","paperId":"2102.11745","sourceSha256":"d264531870bdc50ba17e0885d732d0eb50ec7928e6c7ea9b09e06ef651e78a09","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0161443e1d245a324875/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"56b1eb7701d7c57a3dd809b5605415b53deb9e2fec59f378c0d5c379942b1505","pdfPage":1,"start":99,"end":1547,"textSha256":"244c56f5a8c9100055dadd22f63b2063ace4f7711708261d8d775eabca2c4bbc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b3cd538bf0a19d26aacb600a","recordId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Production and Bell/correlation targets remain distinct within this source-scoped singleton; the abstract restricts its regimes.","challengeNote":"Production and correlation targets remain distinguishable within this source-scoped singleton; strong-field and heavy-mass limits are alternatives.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:efc358dd0d48722c602ffa93bce39ace14eb559ed9afa300e42e83ed795a23ec","home":{"unitId":"unit:efc358dd0d48722c602ffa93bce39ace14eb559ed9afa300e42e83ed795a23ec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:333d785571e1a50f88438b24","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q24 covers relativistic field observables, prescribed-background dynamics, quantum-observer distinctions and subsystem information across source-specific settings.","qualification":"q24 covers creation and correlation observables across the supplied scalar/Dirac and Minkowski/de Sitter/Rindler breadth. Initial charge and retained sectors remain part of each state/subsystem definition. q15 covers only the de Sitter emission contribution; no common particle interpretation is assumed across settings.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:efc358dd0d48722c602ffa93bce39ace14eb559ed9afa300e42e83ed795a23ec","paperId":"2311.01014","textSha256":"3fc99732b1bad8c7aad9709edfacc52d6cae8ff5d2e804122c7cf2e02b566607"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0067:u20:q24"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0067:u20:q24","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:efc358dd0d48722c602ffa93bce39ace14eb559ed9afa300e42e83ed795a23ec","q025-candidate-region:333d785571e1a50f88438b24"],"scopeContentSha256":"b0e054f2a029bb87bf7be8aef9d3766ba839f63d8c88498e3635a32c623f9366","placementContentSha256":"f941be1d3faf7b85a2bb46fafecf73d46b1762d3f90f529113f82b0b5af202fb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0067:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0067:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:efc358dd0d48722c602ffa93bce39ace14eb559ed9afa300e42e83ed795a23ec","paperId":"2311.01014","textSha256":"3fc99732b1bad8c7aad9709edfacc52d6cae8ff5d2e804122c7cf2e02b566607"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0067","unitRef":"u20"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:efc358dd0d48722c602ffa93bce39ace14eb559ed9afa300e42e83ed795a23ec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:95efbbed52217cca63129bce","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:efc358dd0d48722c602ffa93bce39ace14eb559ed9afa300e42e83ed795a23ec","textSha256":"3fc99732b1bad8c7aad9709edfacc52d6cae8ff5d2e804122c7cf2e02b566607"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0f5956eb00d629aafd452483e4e8c675","paperId":"2311.01014","sourceSha256":"0ef6786ea5a1141cde4b890faae76038a0174d970952d7485ed9adf22a886cee","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62dbe291533e30e4d565/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3009449c4c7d04e75b2acbd0dd51f6e6035d8628f06dba73f9e5be8029ae2202","pdfPage":55,"start":100,"end":2183,"textSha256":"74cdf4141f909b88cc481d0a226baa41bf0681a2b5e508069996800c4a13b971","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:27a0d8087fd2a06cf223b06d8604ed95","paperId":"2311.01014","sourceSha256":"0ef6786ea5a1141cde4b890faae76038a0174d970952d7485ed9adf22a886cee","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62dbe291533e30e4d565/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3009449c4c7d04e75b2acbd0dd51f6e6035d8628f06dba73f9e5be8029ae2202","pdfPage":56,"start":99,"end":2381,"textSha256":"f329c67b881830ae3f18242ac03b862980de407670621e206d4eadf7274ab00d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6bedde50eedfce4bb8dea1220e097e4c","paperId":"2311.01014","sourceSha256":"0ef6786ea5a1141cde4b890faae76038a0174d970952d7485ed9adf22a886cee","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62dbe291533e30e4d565/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3009449c4c7d04e75b2acbd0dd51f6e6035d8628f06dba73f9e5be8029ae2202","pdfPage":55,"start":0,"end":2183,"textSha256":"a61109332d3509a052dae1e916b712b8beb556821424a2a82bf3f40df63a5291","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:caac9167ce3b23e75fcc7748","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound thesis scope spans scalar/Dirac fields, Minkowski/de Sitter/Rindler settings and different correlation sectors. Only its de Sitter contribution maps to Independent challenge qualification: Compound scalar/Dirac and Minkowski/de Sitter/Rindler scope. Only the de Sitter contribution specializes p2; Rindler spectra include observer-dependent Unruh c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:caac9167ce3b23e75fcc7748","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:efc358dd0d48722c602ffa93bce39ace14eb559ed9afa300e42e83ed795a23ec","q025-candidate-question:95efbbed52217cca63129bce"],"scopeContentSha256":"3983fac7fb545196ef7b26cd2de5350399fb0aeac1bdf170bc250d48fd794917","contributionContentSha256":"66788138517bb40cb547c1bebdfa1a4de55f3316001f49f3af29298f03530d70","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-proposal","leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:efc358dd0d48722c602ffa93bce39ace14eb559ed9afa300e42e83ed795a23ec","textSha256":"3fc99732b1bad8c7aad9709edfacc52d6cae8ff5d2e804122c7cf2e02b566607"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0f5956eb00d629aafd452483e4e8c675","paperId":"2311.01014","sourceSha256":"0ef6786ea5a1141cde4b890faae76038a0174d970952d7485ed9adf22a886cee","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62dbe291533e30e4d565/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3009449c4c7d04e75b2acbd0dd51f6e6035d8628f06dba73f9e5be8029ae2202","pdfPage":55,"start":100,"end":2183,"textSha256":"74cdf4141f909b88cc481d0a226baa41bf0681a2b5e508069996800c4a13b971","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:27a0d8087fd2a06cf223b06d8604ed95","paperId":"2311.01014","sourceSha256":"0ef6786ea5a1141cde4b890faae76038a0174d970952d7485ed9adf22a886cee","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62dbe291533e30e4d565/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3009449c4c7d04e75b2acbd0dd51f6e6035d8628f06dba73f9e5be8029ae2202","pdfPage":56,"start":99,"end":2381,"textSha256":"f329c67b881830ae3f18242ac03b862980de407670621e206d4eadf7274ab00d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6bedde50eedfce4bb8dea1220e097e4c","paperId":"2311.01014","sourceSha256":"0ef6786ea5a1141cde4b890faae76038a0174d970952d7485ed9adf22a886cee","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62dbe291533e30e4d565/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3009449c4c7d04e75b2acbd0dd51f6e6035d8628f06dba73f9e5be8029ae2202","pdfPage":55,"start":0,"end":2183,"textSha256":"a61109332d3509a052dae1e916b712b8beb556821424a2a82bf3f40df63a5291","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:caac9167ce3b23e75fcc7748","recordId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound thesis scope spans scalar/Dirac fields, Minkowski/de Sitter/Rindler settings and different correlation sectors. Only its de Sitter contribution maps to","challengeNote":"Compound scalar/Dirac and Minkowski/de Sitter/Rindler scope. Only the de Sitter contribution specializes p2; Rindler spectra include observer-dependent Unruh c","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"036f13da6cbf96e8e436e01651cf445ce9f6ec3d8c03d6be7217b376c247443d"},"organizational-access:51eddf4f258e9849f89bf10c":{"id":"organizational-access:51eddf4f258e9849f89bf10c","source":"q025-candidate-region:4358a34a0cf4ae04154d032c","target":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:4358a34a0cf4ae04154d032c","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"966dc2323005fe819a2fb647e38b7b75d4818c6d5f00aac840f5e25ed69a3938","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:47cffa4787a3ddb055d90268"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"109144fa8a095198b384a24792b3bc35aae4f403a9291361948e15c8eb93da90","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5062dff44ee2b4d00911a342"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","home":{"unitId":"unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4358a34a0cf4ae04154d032c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","paperId":"1808.07498","textSha256":"577541ee725dd3912cb102c363b9c596722c2226efa21fceee9907ca9e979d2c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:24d691e0505dfe0581c9175e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:24d691e0505dfe0581c9175e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","q025-candidate-region:4358a34a0cf4ae04154d032c"],"scopeContentSha256":"966dc2323005fe819a2fb647e38b7b75d4818c6d5f00aac840f5e25ed69a3938","placementContentSha256":"398d9117af1bbeeb287fcc2ab48dbcc620610c3a2e1d0ecca88a1ec15213fae0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","paperId":"1808.07498","textSha256":"577541ee725dd3912cb102c363b9c596722c2226efa21fceee9907ca9e979d2c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:24d691e0505dfe0581c9175e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","textSha256":"577541ee725dd3912cb102c363b9c596722c2226efa21fceee9907ca9e979d2c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fce98ed4ca962ae31f3fbd83"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:fce98ed4ca962ae31f3fbd83","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c"],"scopeContentSha256":"109144fa8a095198b384a24792b3bc35aae4f403a9291361948e15c8eb93da90","contributionContentSha256":"f997dd0d4de73d730c366b5ac2d63dde24733a38800b8838f24099dccf8c8da0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:0898ba4f17e5ef9018844d969abf67b860794bd140d270fb6d39707cf9b90f33","textSha256":"577541ee725dd3912cb102c363b9c596722c2226efa21fceee9907ca9e979d2c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fce98ed4ca962ae31f3fbd83","recordId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Conjecture compatibility and controlled four-dimensional EFT are distinct tests requiring reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Conjecture applicability directly addresses p4. Compatibility and controlled four-dimensional EFT remain distinct targets requiring reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:49aa5609978dbf0d3e81cfdd55e33e8e4b4866793a24db7ebbdcd8f68c24ddfc","home":{"unitId":"unit:49aa5609978dbf0d3e81cfdd55e33e8e4b4866793a24db7ebbdcd8f68c24ddfc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4358a34a0cf4ae04154d032c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:49aa5609978dbf0d3e81cfdd55e33e8e4b4866793a24db7ebbdcd8f68c24ddfc","paperId":"2108.08365","textSha256":"b50164c111c9e5e193c6de526f188e60662069fed3b04320a98f7d3b9c10af8a"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:239011d7c7c11e55847e159c0e5c5c30","paperId":"2108.08365","sourceSha256":"4ad8d865dbcfed85713e6b8e68ff82fa683cd399dab08e74f2a648fd327db8ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/97df720603dd94b357a9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b0ea8ec6a80493a3eb3c9904f050ec716b98bc5477916a097a41d5d42db5b3e","pdfPage":6,"start":99,"end":3498,"textSha256":"70c775079e9d416c90d5bab27da8571716151171429053b112f3977814dfcd7a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:756c069ffaf0b798208deabbfc21016e","paperId":"2108.08365","sourceSha256":"4ad8d865dbcfed85713e6b8e68ff82fa683cd399dab08e74f2a648fd327db8ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/97df720603dd94b357a9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b0ea8ec6a80493a3eb3c9904f050ec716b98bc5477916a097a41d5d42db5b3e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2321,"textSha256":"e615f8f503298b0ee47208e6ac0973f5551ea7d419f486c09f826982458fc072","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eb98f635d81dc301daa66563dc858f1b","paperId":"2108.08365","sourceSha256":"4ad8d865dbcfed85713e6b8e68ff82fa683cd399dab08e74f2a648fd327db8ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/97df720603dd94b357a9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b0ea8ec6a80493a3eb3c9904f050ec716b98bc5477916a097a41d5d42db5b3e","pdfPage":1,"start":97,"end":2321,"textSha256":"b94bbfb87fbab5022d037556df76a44c5dadd1fb19fbb675d8a19cd791a8009e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f3c7c62a70d6b7c5c2554c1f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f3c7c62a70d6b7c5c2554c1f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:49aa5609978dbf0d3e81cfdd55e33e8e4b4866793a24db7ebbdcd8f68c24ddfc","q025-candidate-region:4358a34a0cf4ae04154d032c"],"scopeContentSha256":"966dc2323005fe819a2fb647e38b7b75d4818c6d5f00aac840f5e25ed69a3938","placementContentSha256":"ac6d92b8b57b7ce3c4912f966ab4e7136270c0168a315b40b3914f8279beade5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:49aa5609978dbf0d3e81cfdd55e33e8e4b4866793a24db7ebbdcd8f68c24ddfc","paperId":"2108.08365","textSha256":"b50164c111c9e5e193c6de526f188e60662069fed3b04320a98f7d3b9c10af8a"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:239011d7c7c11e55847e159c0e5c5c30","paperId":"2108.08365","sourceSha256":"4ad8d865dbcfed85713e6b8e68ff82fa683cd399dab08e74f2a648fd327db8ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/97df720603dd94b357a9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b0ea8ec6a80493a3eb3c9904f050ec716b98bc5477916a097a41d5d42db5b3e","pdfPage":6,"start":99,"end":3498,"textSha256":"70c775079e9d416c90d5bab27da8571716151171429053b112f3977814dfcd7a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:756c069ffaf0b798208deabbfc21016e","paperId":"2108.08365","sourceSha256":"4ad8d865dbcfed85713e6b8e68ff82fa683cd399dab08e74f2a648fd327db8ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/97df720603dd94b357a9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b0ea8ec6a80493a3eb3c9904f050ec716b98bc5477916a097a41d5d42db5b3e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2321,"textSha256":"e615f8f503298b0ee47208e6ac0973f5551ea7d419f486c09f826982458fc072","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eb98f635d81dc301daa66563dc858f1b","paperId":"2108.08365","sourceSha256":"4ad8d865dbcfed85713e6b8e68ff82fa683cd399dab08e74f2a648fd327db8ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/97df720603dd94b357a9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b0ea8ec6a80493a3eb3c9904f050ec716b98bc5477916a097a41d5d42db5b3e","pdfPage":1,"start":97,"end":2321,"textSha256":"b94bbfb87fbab5022d037556df76a44c5dadd1fb19fbb675d8a19cd791a8009e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f3c7c62a70d6b7c5c2554c1f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:49aa5609978dbf0d3e81cfdd55e33e8e4b4866793a24db7ebbdcd8f68c24ddfc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:49aa5609978dbf0d3e81cfdd55e33e8e4b4866793a24db7ebbdcd8f68c24ddfc","textSha256":"b50164c111c9e5e193c6de526f188e60662069fed3b04320a98f7d3b9c10af8a"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:239011d7c7c11e55847e159c0e5c5c30","paperId":"2108.08365","sourceSha256":"4ad8d865dbcfed85713e6b8e68ff82fa683cd399dab08e74f2a648fd327db8ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/97df720603dd94b357a9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b0ea8ec6a80493a3eb3c9904f050ec716b98bc5477916a097a41d5d42db5b3e","pdfPage":6,"start":99,"end":3498,"textSha256":"70c775079e9d416c90d5bab27da8571716151171429053b112f3977814dfcd7a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:756c069ffaf0b798208deabbfc21016e","paperId":"2108.08365","sourceSha256":"4ad8d865dbcfed85713e6b8e68ff82fa683cd399dab08e74f2a648fd327db8ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/97df720603dd94b357a9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b0ea8ec6a80493a3eb3c9904f050ec716b98bc5477916a097a41d5d42db5b3e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2321,"textSha256":"e615f8f503298b0ee47208e6ac0973f5551ea7d419f486c09f826982458fc072","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eb98f635d81dc301daa66563dc858f1b","paperId":"2108.08365","sourceSha256":"4ad8d865dbcfed85713e6b8e68ff82fa683cd399dab08e74f2a648fd327db8ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/97df720603dd94b357a9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b0ea8ec6a80493a3eb3c9904f050ec716b98bc5477916a097a41d5d42db5b3e","pdfPage":1,"start":97,"end":2321,"textSha256":"b94bbfb87fbab5022d037556df76a44c5dadd1fb19fbb675d8a19cd791a8009e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aa6954416b443f7c553ef8b0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:aa6954416b443f7c553ef8b0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:49aa5609978dbf0d3e81cfdd55e33e8e4b4866793a24db7ebbdcd8f68c24ddfc","q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c"],"scopeContentSha256":"109144fa8a095198b384a24792b3bc35aae4f403a9291361948e15c8eb93da90","contributionContentSha256":"bce5b5fa8c7ed983f1ed5dfe724112efbe4fbfbc2c15ef04f6c304fb427fbb65","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:49aa5609978dbf0d3e81cfdd55e33e8e4b4866793a24db7ebbdcd8f68c24ddfc","textSha256":"b50164c111c9e5e193c6de526f188e60662069fed3b04320a98f7d3b9c10af8a"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:239011d7c7c11e55847e159c0e5c5c30","paperId":"2108.08365","sourceSha256":"4ad8d865dbcfed85713e6b8e68ff82fa683cd399dab08e74f2a648fd327db8ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/97df720603dd94b357a9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b0ea8ec6a80493a3eb3c9904f050ec716b98bc5477916a097a41d5d42db5b3e","pdfPage":6,"start":99,"end":3498,"textSha256":"70c775079e9d416c90d5bab27da8571716151171429053b112f3977814dfcd7a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:756c069ffaf0b798208deabbfc21016e","paperId":"2108.08365","sourceSha256":"4ad8d865dbcfed85713e6b8e68ff82fa683cd399dab08e74f2a648fd327db8ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/97df720603dd94b357a9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b0ea8ec6a80493a3eb3c9904f050ec716b98bc5477916a097a41d5d42db5b3e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2321,"textSha256":"e615f8f503298b0ee47208e6ac0973f5551ea7d419f486c09f826982458fc072","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eb98f635d81dc301daa66563dc858f1b","paperId":"2108.08365","sourceSha256":"4ad8d865dbcfed85713e6b8e68ff82fa683cd399dab08e74f2a648fd327db8ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/97df720603dd94b357a9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b0ea8ec6a80493a3eb3c9904f050ec716b98bc5477916a097a41d5d42db5b3e","pdfPage":1,"start":97,"end":2321,"textSha256":"b94bbfb87fbab5022d037556df76a44c5dadd1fb19fbb675d8a19cd791a8009e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aa6954416b443f7c553ef8b0","recordId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"The static patch lacks the stated weakly coupled IIA regime; FLRW/NEC is an additional extension.","challengeNote":"Slicing claims have temporal and static-patch qualifications. FLRW/NEC is an additional target; the authors' universal necessity claim is not established here.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a891711fce939807aeca71cbc920440485c69abb757068f6624b8f2e49049524","home":{"unitId":"unit:a891711fce939807aeca71cbc920440485c69abb757068f6624b8f2e49049524","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4358a34a0cf4ae04154d032c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a891711fce939807aeca71cbc920440485c69abb757068f6624b8f2e49049524","paperId":"1911.12382","textSha256":"07aab160fffa4c6cc673270744966b11d48e6854b5e1bb6e742c6c55545dffc7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:556e1fa51468bd75c233b9a2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:556e1fa51468bd75c233b9a2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a891711fce939807aeca71cbc920440485c69abb757068f6624b8f2e49049524","q025-candidate-region:4358a34a0cf4ae04154d032c"],"scopeContentSha256":"966dc2323005fe819a2fb647e38b7b75d4818c6d5f00aac840f5e25ed69a3938","placementContentSha256":"db637078b5f23709505eeacd1d87739b37d74091a3a81a6ac25384ae0c36b10f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a891711fce939807aeca71cbc920440485c69abb757068f6624b8f2e49049524","paperId":"1911.12382","textSha256":"07aab160fffa4c6cc673270744966b11d48e6854b5e1bb6e742c6c55545dffc7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:556e1fa51468bd75c233b9a2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a891711fce939807aeca71cbc920440485c69abb757068f6624b8f2e49049524","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:a891711fce939807aeca71cbc920440485c69abb757068f6624b8f2e49049524","textSha256":"07aab160fffa4c6cc673270744966b11d48e6854b5e1bb6e742c6c55545dffc7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:719ad3e81d9863c519acd0bb"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:719ad3e81d9863c519acd0bb","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a891711fce939807aeca71cbc920440485c69abb757068f6624b8f2e49049524","q025-candidate-question:4db14b8fbb552f4f281fed9c"],"scopeContentSha256":"109144fa8a095198b384a24792b3bc35aae4f403a9291361948e15c8eb93da90","contributionContentSha256":"48e088fde9163eeaa5600c72edd6a79d0a4a67fe071656d40963678d641595a0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:a891711fce939807aeca71cbc920440485c69abb757068f6624b8f2e49049524","textSha256":"07aab160fffa4c6cc673270744966b11d48e6854b5e1bb6e742c6c55545dffc7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:719ad3e81d9863c519acd0bb","recordId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Equation solving and a Wilsonian action remain distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Equation solving, expansion control and a Wilsonian action remain separate tests within this source-scoped singleton.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"3d82d807c4d02705d594eb5f8c95a4c5c35a4fa734bad99a6e6f81ddb8913b5d"},"organizational-access:51f688cf485bb95b8d933e56":{"id":"organizational-access:51f688cf485bb95b8d933e56","source":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","target":"q025-candidate-question:0cd6cb3f68868453b5558f45","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b767efda27a7bd28e206e3c3"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:0cd6cb3f68868453b5558f45","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1f580221212c34dd0d6f981b5f69d95445840aab919c077ca7eb5ab1fa2d4c47","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:775420b2e416d31c5940dd04"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","home":{"unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q28 jointly includes bulk spectra, strong-coupling dual descriptions, retained-modulus stabilization and conditional uplift mechanisms.","qualification":"q28 covers the independent mass-scaling, strong-coupling dual and correction-dependent stabilization/uplift tasks. Its admitted regimes explicitly include strong-coupling alternatives and related uplift branches. The comparison formula and coefficients are not supplied, but their values are unnecessary to identify these targets; neither a mass-scaling law nor successful uplift is inferred. q0, q3 and q19 are individually incomplete.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","textSha256":"8c2614b19f09ade7c79d9af44a0247aaed3e66876173fad52613bf06464cd890"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:annotation:u13:q28"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:annotation:u13:q28","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207"],"scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","placementContentSha256":"36b7f00a26d77fc8c57cc1c0150748ac2900b0e15f5386e37960c4ace658a6bb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:annotation:proposal","placement-pilot:annotation:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","textSha256":"8c2614b19f09ade7c79d9af44a0247aaed3e66876173fad52613bf06464cd890"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0cd6cb3f68868453b5558f45","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","textSha256":"8c2614b19f09ade7c79d9af44a0247aaed3e66876173fad52613bf06464cd890"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3e5107df411dc77a34cd618887d4f077","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":23,"start":0,"end":2757,"textSha256":"07670aae1d9238cfb0d73cc57ad12f3e9609ec2015a99862a944b7fce7dc435c","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0accde7f47c9ea3c6065ce8a60f5ee3b","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2825,"textSha256":"c6a8d96152c120a20410c9676ec3abb35b67435d12b5d337b033d4fa134cec90","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b129517d38dadae2762f50ab00c2f986","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":24,"start":0,"end":2148,"textSha256":"1eecd6c8ebf625c74a9836798030901f206e6623ada4d3b617b8006540214287","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e9bd148e45c7191f532ba4ac"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e9bd148e45c7191f532ba4ac","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","q025-candidate-question:0cd6cb3f68868453b5558f45"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f580221212c34dd0d6f981b5f69d95445840aab919c077ca7eb5ab1fa2d4c47","contributionContentSha256":"9323a2c9529bc4c55e84e43ad2fe9d83524f255ff81e314201accd7b9f647b82","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:4e321e90114dc6bb8af038135cfcb27a11aa41c8c409d80eaa0dbd9812f3bfaf","textSha256":"8c2614b19f09ade7c79d9af44a0247aaed3e66876173fad52613bf06464cd890"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3e5107df411dc77a34cd618887d4f077","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":23,"start":0,"end":2757,"textSha256":"07670aae1d9238cfb0d73cc57ad12f3e9609ec2015a99862a944b7fce7dc435c","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0accde7f47c9ea3c6065ce8a60f5ee3b","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2825,"textSha256":"c6a8d96152c120a20410c9676ec3abb35b67435d12b5d337b033d4fa134cec90","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b129517d38dadae2762f50ab00c2f986","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":24,"start":0,"end":2148,"textSha256":"1eecd6c8ebf625c74a9836798030901f206e6623ada4d3b617b8006540214287","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e9bd148e45c7191f532ba4ac","recordId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound identity: anisotropic mass scaling, a strong-coupling dual and correction coefficients are separate unresolved tasks.","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound identity: anisotropic mass scaling, a strong-coupling dual and theory-determined correction coefficients are separate tasks. Supersymmetry-b","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:62084b0d512e60bfb6d61b4aef3e8f3ea6cf19f63b1d1d1548f20234b015259e","home":{"unitId":"unit:62084b0d512e60bfb6d61b4aef3e8f3ea6cf19f63b1d1d1548f20234b015259e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:62084b0d512e60bfb6d61b4aef3e8f3ea6cf19f63b1d1d1548f20234b015259e","paperId":"0908.0756","textSha256":"36408f0410d747de72e35fa9b4098abd470a4559b56b56308061996cb3be5751"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8fc638dee2d694f7475ca102"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8fc638dee2d694f7475ca102","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:62084b0d512e60bfb6d61b4aef3e8f3ea6cf19f63b1d1d1548f20234b015259e","q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207"],"scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","placementContentSha256":"3a3f27c7696b8f6ca5a7b89836b9a5e9e87eab8b4f9c03a26f3eb2849a140a19","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:62084b0d512e60bfb6d61b4aef3e8f3ea6cf19f63b1d1d1548f20234b015259e","paperId":"0908.0756","textSha256":"36408f0410d747de72e35fa9b4098abd470a4559b56b56308061996cb3be5751"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8fc638dee2d694f7475ca102"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:62084b0d512e60bfb6d61b4aef3e8f3ea6cf19f63b1d1d1548f20234b015259e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0cd6cb3f68868453b5558f45","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:62084b0d512e60bfb6d61b4aef3e8f3ea6cf19f63b1d1d1548f20234b015259e","textSha256":"36408f0410d747de72e35fa9b4098abd470a4559b56b56308061996cb3be5751"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:146377805b739f91963ca8bc"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:146377805b739f91963ca8bc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:62084b0d512e60bfb6d61b4aef3e8f3ea6cf19f63b1d1d1548f20234b015259e","q025-candidate-question:0cd6cb3f68868453b5558f45"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f580221212c34dd0d6f981b5f69d95445840aab919c077ca7eb5ab1fa2d4c47","contributionContentSha256":"1c149a0a26f0606b91ce352f228a85aa0001376d5d8d65d2ec768f5656c4dbd2","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:62084b0d512e60bfb6d61b4aef3e8f3ea6cf19f63b1d1d1548f20234b015259e","textSha256":"36408f0410d747de72e35fa9b4098abd470a4559b56b56308061996cb3be5751"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:146377805b739f91963ca8bc","recordId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Hierarchy construction and retention of a concrete brane-defined dual are joint requirements.","challengeNote":"Hierarchy construction and retention of a concrete brane-defined dual are joint requirements.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c53687321db2c2352662c484d85e5b4a4e977d22a4fdf617aec2fb192c3bd891","home":{"unitId":"unit:c53687321db2c2352662c484d85e5b4a4e977d22a4fdf617aec2fb192c3bd891","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c53687321db2c2352662c484d85e5b4a4e977d22a4fdf617aec2fb192c3bd891","paperId":"2610.13586","textSha256":"1633716d520fe4fe8ad49585f9271d99d5d17cc3ea3021f40570d5dcbb830863"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7325eff6beb5ce674714b9b9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7325eff6beb5ce674714b9b9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c53687321db2c2352662c484d85e5b4a4e977d22a4fdf617aec2fb192c3bd891","q025-candidate-region:45f6412f0b685bf8bf595207"],"scopeContentSha256":"64893146ad80ab74e46a4a6f3685c74bb6d1ffe8a759f3ef4e375334c9729e9a","placementContentSha256":"e4314a616518d2810c4599909ecfa1613f993f8c8856852fe0d860b20365857e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c53687321db2c2352662c484d85e5b4a4e977d22a4fdf617aec2fb192c3bd891","paperId":"2610.13586","textSha256":"1633716d520fe4fe8ad49585f9271d99d5d17cc3ea3021f40570d5dcbb830863"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7325eff6beb5ce674714b9b9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c53687321db2c2352662c484d85e5b4a4e977d22a4fdf617aec2fb192c3bd891","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0cd6cb3f68868453b5558f45","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:c53687321db2c2352662c484d85e5b4a4e977d22a4fdf617aec2fb192c3bd891","textSha256":"1633716d520fe4fe8ad49585f9271d99d5d17cc3ea3021f40570d5dcbb830863"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6fdaf119c4d2e196b0851b31"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6fdaf119c4d2e196b0851b31","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c53687321db2c2352662c484d85e5b4a4e977d22a4fdf617aec2fb192c3bd891","q025-candidate-question:0cd6cb3f68868453b5558f45"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f580221212c34dd0d6f981b5f69d95445840aab919c077ca7eb5ab1fa2d4c47","contributionContentSha256":"8d6b9a208c956bc8063f52960e36d8c254608e1de23f58f23a49260946b93989","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:c53687321db2c2352662c484d85e5b4a4e977d22a4fdf617aec2fb192c3bd891","textSha256":"1633716d520fe4fe8ad49585f9271d99d5d17cc3ea3021f40570d5dcbb830863"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6fdaf119c4d2e196b0851b31","recordId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6fd2ff4266c7a7ef4bf4-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Resolution, exceptional-mode stabilization, tadpole consistency and a decoupling brane interpretation form material compound targets.","challengeNote":"Resolution, exceptional-mode stabilization, tadpoles and a decoupling brane interpretation are material compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"60127db2e8d604e63d79597e0a62f9ab9df8ce1024b28d45c9593840584d9974"},"organizational-access:ca1ddd0ae947e358544cd656":{"id":"organizational-access:ca1ddd0ae947e358544cd656","source":"q025-candidate-region:512167db42c1e71ba8679283","target":"q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:512167db42c1e71ba8679283","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"6508c3f39680a8df8390c5d2ade5d6f37bf9fbd4dfc5adc8e978c0f07dcbc89a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e31b24d7a952aae264faca46"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"0ae2a2c292601d0231a4e2722175c6ff721b5fb3410f42fe1af6c480f2e9ff60","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e8425e3597b12e35a1eb0a4b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:e4bfc91058de09e4b7a14e1ecbe451affb7f2715fdd0ed2649f520fefb45ba7c","home":{"unitId":"unit:e4bfc91058de09e4b7a14e1ecbe451affb7f2715fdd0ed2649f520fefb45ba7c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:512167db42c1e71ba8679283","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e4bfc91058de09e4b7a14e1ecbe451affb7f2715fdd0ed2649f520fefb45ba7c","paperId":"1703.00025","textSha256":"90a2e471fbdbee9b254b4031fbd33a0952bee21cbd7dd9f551f11e19ffe0c41c"},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8ef71830228a30018f409484737a44a9","paperId":"1703.00025","sourceSha256":"82afbdab961ce6052aad21772186a2007415c5c754f4047c4c41c85736fd133c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/71819e9ead4d35e9c107/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"49e912959793205b2c238a96b26a9f96d38de9c862a78b452951d3f2e4f6e198","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"4d5c05421aa2f1ad1375e8d8d6d2720a5f05342dc68ee9f10b44a1aaa48caa66","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a3750b79ebbd3d5c18fe3b7da9e7494c","paperId":"1703.00025","sourceSha256":"82afbdab961ce6052aad21772186a2007415c5c754f4047c4c41c85736fd133c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/71819e9ead4d35e9c107/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"49e912959793205b2c238a96b26a9f96d38de9c862a78b452951d3f2e4f6e198","pdfPage":1,"start":101,"end":1449,"textSha256":"b47f7a1461fb241d44074dcc2e2844837317a3f798bd02f2e96895814d96034e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ba8ea99835f2348093ad2748573f8bee","paperId":"1703.00025","sourceSha256":"82afbdab961ce6052aad21772186a2007415c5c754f4047c4c41c85736fd133c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/71819e9ead4d35e9c107/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"49e912959793205b2c238a96b26a9f96d38de9c862a78b452951d3f2e4f6e198","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1449,"textSha256":"cb80a0096e924036cce5b6f7e0a92afac6e206f0c0923a98ee7d67e9047ef7b7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f3afea7b16009a02f19157db"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f3afea7b16009a02f19157db","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e4bfc91058de09e4b7a14e1ecbe451affb7f2715fdd0ed2649f520fefb45ba7c","q025-candidate-region:512167db42c1e71ba8679283"],"scopeContentSha256":"6508c3f39680a8df8390c5d2ade5d6f37bf9fbd4dfc5adc8e978c0f07dcbc89a","placementContentSha256":"af3e7dcaedbe5df846c17cb7b077f4f901e7040dcfae174b559e5ece17a6476e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-challenge","successor-parent-3e5edc9beef1248c32eb-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e4bfc91058de09e4b7a14e1ecbe451affb7f2715fdd0ed2649f520fefb45ba7c","paperId":"1703.00025","textSha256":"90a2e471fbdbee9b254b4031fbd33a0952bee21cbd7dd9f551f11e19ffe0c41c"},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8ef71830228a30018f409484737a44a9","paperId":"1703.00025","sourceSha256":"82afbdab961ce6052aad21772186a2007415c5c754f4047c4c41c85736fd133c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/71819e9ead4d35e9c107/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"49e912959793205b2c238a96b26a9f96d38de9c862a78b452951d3f2e4f6e198","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"4d5c05421aa2f1ad1375e8d8d6d2720a5f05342dc68ee9f10b44a1aaa48caa66","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a3750b79ebbd3d5c18fe3b7da9e7494c","paperId":"1703.00025","sourceSha256":"82afbdab961ce6052aad21772186a2007415c5c754f4047c4c41c85736fd133c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/71819e9ead4d35e9c107/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"49e912959793205b2c238a96b26a9f96d38de9c862a78b452951d3f2e4f6e198","pdfPage":1,"start":101,"end":1449,"textSha256":"b47f7a1461fb241d44074dcc2e2844837317a3f798bd02f2e96895814d96034e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ba8ea99835f2348093ad2748573f8bee","paperId":"1703.00025","sourceSha256":"82afbdab961ce6052aad21772186a2007415c5c754f4047c4c41c85736fd133c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/71819e9ead4d35e9c107/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"49e912959793205b2c238a96b26a9f96d38de9c862a78b452951d3f2e4f6e198","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1449,"textSha256":"cb80a0096e924036cce5b6f7e0a92afac6e206f0c0923a98ee7d67e9047ef7b7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f3afea7b16009a02f19157db"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e4bfc91058de09e4b7a14e1ecbe451affb7f2715fdd0ed2649f520fefb45ba7c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:e4bfc91058de09e4b7a14e1ecbe451affb7f2715fdd0ed2649f520fefb45ba7c","textSha256":"90a2e471fbdbee9b254b4031fbd33a0952bee21cbd7dd9f551f11e19ffe0c41c"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8ef71830228a30018f409484737a44a9","paperId":"1703.00025","sourceSha256":"82afbdab961ce6052aad21772186a2007415c5c754f4047c4c41c85736fd133c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/71819e9ead4d35e9c107/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"49e912959793205b2c238a96b26a9f96d38de9c862a78b452951d3f2e4f6e198","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"4d5c05421aa2f1ad1375e8d8d6d2720a5f05342dc68ee9f10b44a1aaa48caa66","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a3750b79ebbd3d5c18fe3b7da9e7494c","paperId":"1703.00025","sourceSha256":"82afbdab961ce6052aad21772186a2007415c5c754f4047c4c41c85736fd133c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/71819e9ead4d35e9c107/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"49e912959793205b2c238a96b26a9f96d38de9c862a78b452951d3f2e4f6e198","pdfPage":1,"start":101,"end":1449,"textSha256":"b47f7a1461fb241d44074dcc2e2844837317a3f798bd02f2e96895814d96034e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ba8ea99835f2348093ad2748573f8bee","paperId":"1703.00025","sourceSha256":"82afbdab961ce6052aad21772186a2007415c5c754f4047c4c41c85736fd133c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/71819e9ead4d35e9c107/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"49e912959793205b2c238a96b26a9f96d38de9c862a78b452951d3f2e4f6e198","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1449,"textSha256":"cb80a0096e924036cce5b6f7e0a92afac6e206f0c0923a98ee7d67e9047ef7b7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f486c7205457b0373570f423"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f486c7205457b0373570f423","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e4bfc91058de09e4b7a14e1ecbe451affb7f2715fdd0ed2649f520fefb45ba7c","q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685"],"scopeContentSha256":"0ae2a2c292601d0231a4e2722175c6ff721b5fb3410f42fe1af6c480f2e9ff60","contributionContentSha256":"2ee9e8c34fe47866b30532d1ed8e15e0741e3dc9530dc87439b77877c68e69b6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:e4bfc91058de09e4b7a14e1ecbe451affb7f2715fdd0ed2649f520fefb45ba7c","textSha256":"90a2e471fbdbee9b254b4031fbd33a0952bee21cbd7dd9f551f11e19ffe0c41c"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8ef71830228a30018f409484737a44a9","paperId":"1703.00025","sourceSha256":"82afbdab961ce6052aad21772186a2007415c5c754f4047c4c41c85736fd133c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/71819e9ead4d35e9c107/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"49e912959793205b2c238a96b26a9f96d38de9c862a78b452951d3f2e4f6e198","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"4d5c05421aa2f1ad1375e8d8d6d2720a5f05342dc68ee9f10b44a1aaa48caa66","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a3750b79ebbd3d5c18fe3b7da9e7494c","paperId":"1703.00025","sourceSha256":"82afbdab961ce6052aad21772186a2007415c5c754f4047c4c41c85736fd133c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/71819e9ead4d35e9c107/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"49e912959793205b2c238a96b26a9f96d38de9c862a78b452951d3f2e4f6e198","pdfPage":1,"start":101,"end":1449,"textSha256":"b47f7a1461fb241d44074dcc2e2844837317a3f798bd02f2e96895814d96034e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ba8ea99835f2348093ad2748573f8bee","paperId":"1703.00025","sourceSha256":"82afbdab961ce6052aad21772186a2007415c5c754f4047c4c41c85736fd133c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/71819e9ead4d35e9c107/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"49e912959793205b2c238a96b26a9f96d38de9c862a78b452951d3f2e4f6e198","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1449,"textSha256":"cb80a0096e924036cce5b6f7e0a92afac6e206f0c0923a98ee7d67e9047ef7b7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f486c7205457b0373570f423","recordId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Explicitly local EFT control, not a full history. The broad NEC-necessity sentence is not generalized to curved FRW; e15 is comparison evidence.","challengeNote":"Explicitly local EFT control, not a full history. The abstract's NEC-necessity sentence is not generalized to all Einstein-frame geometries; e15 supplies curved","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"d0a288c0df0f9acf2e0910082360cb6065a444fa2cd859aba168e9747cdadf10"},"organizational-access:4491c02b42ccd267d42e3d76":{"id":"organizational-access:4491c02b42ccd267d42e3d76","source":"q025-candidate-region:512167db42c1e71ba8679283","target":"q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:512167db42c1e71ba8679283","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"6508c3f39680a8df8390c5d2ade5d6f37bf9fbd4dfc5adc8e978c0f07dcbc89a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e31b24d7a952aae264faca46"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"aa5be41770333084b6014c6ea4ebee7f07d662ac4b16a425057f660d33e7713e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d4c1f7c6dcceb1c95c37b70e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:f477ffc0227aaaf3b0d5ed0856a7f3b29a105431b1185945e4aebafaa0016619","home":{"unitId":"unit:f477ffc0227aaaf3b0d5ed0856a7f3b29a105431b1185945e4aebafaa0016619","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:512167db42c1e71ba8679283","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers negative-vacuum-energy gravitational EFT histories, their existence and control, continuation and observational discrimination.","qualification":"q39 covers negative-energy gravitational EFT histories, their empirical discrimination and continuation, and the construction conditions for their scalar potentials. The superpotential question is retained as a construction requirement alongside acceleration, time symmetry and Euclidean asymptotics; none is inferred from another.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f477ffc0227aaaf3b0d5ed0856a7f3b29a105431b1185945e4aebafaa0016619","paperId":"2212.00050","textSha256":"89513af577da0dbfe07941517072fb1298b768a2bd678a931403e501886b55aa"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0071:u13:q39"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0071:u13:q39","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f477ffc0227aaaf3b0d5ed0856a7f3b29a105431b1185945e4aebafaa0016619","q025-candidate-region:512167db42c1e71ba8679283"],"scopeContentSha256":"6508c3f39680a8df8390c5d2ade5d6f37bf9fbd4dfc5adc8e978c0f07dcbc89a","placementContentSha256":"68677e3d376948b48286baf08674b150f635a853861d52143a95200cd0aba972","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0071:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0071:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f477ffc0227aaaf3b0d5ed0856a7f3b29a105431b1185945e4aebafaa0016619","paperId":"2212.00050","textSha256":"89513af577da0dbfe07941517072fb1298b768a2bd678a931403e501886b55aa"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0071","unitRef":"u13"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f477ffc0227aaaf3b0d5ed0856a7f3b29a105431b1185945e4aebafaa0016619","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d65","kind":"description","unitIndex":65,"unitId":"unit:f477ffc0227aaaf3b0d5ed0856a7f3b29a105431b1185945e4aebafaa0016619","textSha256":"89513af577da0dbfe07941517072fb1298b768a2bd678a931403e501886b55aa"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:882ed84f3711474c3ad486c3"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:882ed84f3711474c3ad486c3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f477ffc0227aaaf3b0d5ed0856a7f3b29a105431b1185945e4aebafaa0016619","q025-candidate-question:8bba77116eb4cd514a15d7ef"],"scopeContentSha256":"aa5be41770333084b6014c6ea4ebee7f07d662ac4b16a425057f660d33e7713e","contributionContentSha256":"0d9044eaa55bdcf27b023ac129e16fbefeaba2b006012f70260ce97eee558daa","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d65","kind":"description","unitIndex":65,"unitId":"unit:f477ffc0227aaaf3b0d5ed0856a7f3b29a105431b1185945e4aebafaa0016619","textSha256":"89513af577da0dbfe07941517072fb1298b768a2bd678a931403e501886b55aa"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:882ed84f3711474c3ad486c3","recordId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e1ff019ab19d4359202a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound empirical-history, bang/crunch, Euclidean-continuation and superpotential-construction targets require later reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Empirical histories, bang/crunch symmetry, Euclidean continuation and superpotential construction are compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"343e01cf7410c13c647233a687d095ecda97e9e38cb69cedc3686ca80ed6f61c"},"organizational-access:c532f3434acaf1a8592fcc5a":{"id":"organizational-access:c532f3434acaf1a8592fcc5a","source":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","target":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b214b22eb3b0a1a3b419fc93"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:49ec66a8c6b5e4747536c1d3"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:08d8901b7c533a10bfa9665788f6e4a89256182ce89514bff331f0423a1867c5","home":{"unitId":"unit:08d8901b7c533a10bfa9665788f6e4a89256182ce89514bff331f0423a1867c5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:08d8901b7c533a10bfa9665788f6e4a89256182ce89514bff331f0423a1867c5","paperId":"2111.10540","textSha256":"3f075106a28b4de111054a04d146d72f3a9374447c2d0106b1c67b5163971232"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7b092a4d26718ae62cfe5722"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7b092a4d26718ae62cfe5722","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:08d8901b7c533a10bfa9665788f6e4a89256182ce89514bff331f0423a1867c5","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"dbd5eae5ea38e354e3d371a46b3afb812b3604f40d8e9bea8252ff6e25882d30","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:08d8901b7c533a10bfa9665788f6e4a89256182ce89514bff331f0423a1867c5","paperId":"2111.10540","textSha256":"3f075106a28b4de111054a04d146d72f3a9374447c2d0106b1c67b5163971232"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7b092a4d26718ae62cfe5722"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:08d8901b7c533a10bfa9665788f6e4a89256182ce89514bff331f0423a1867c5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d70","kind":"description","unitIndex":70,"unitId":"unit:08d8901b7c533a10bfa9665788f6e4a89256182ce89514bff331f0423a1867c5","textSha256":"3f075106a28b4de111054a04d146d72f3a9374447c2d0106b1c67b5163971232"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:be9875f93f7ac4b5a28b7176"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:be9875f93f7ac4b5a28b7176","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:08d8901b7c533a10bfa9665788f6e4a89256182ce89514bff331f0423a1867c5","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"ec74813a4da29fd1375014dd74ec84e53acb74edfa321ca54c70d5a8fff01511","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d70","kind":"description","unitIndex":70,"unitId":"unit:08d8901b7c533a10bfa9665788f6e4a89256182ce89514bff331f0423a1867c5","textSha256":"3f075106a28b4de111054a04d146d72f3a9374447c2d0106b1c67b5163971232"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:be9875f93f7ac4b5a28b7176","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Intermediate expansion with approximately constant large dissipation; unspecified swampland criteria are not assigned named versions.","challengeNote":"Intermediate expansion and approximately constant large dissipation are specified; other swampland criteria remain unnamed.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:124ed1126f661a0223c5c61828b628c35307a39dc84f5563bc0491826e09beec","home":{"unitId":"unit:124ed1126f661a0223c5c61828b628c35307a39dc84f5563bc0491826e09beec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:124ed1126f661a0223c5c61828b628c35307a39dc84f5563bc0491826e09beec","paperId":"2002.02420","textSha256":"3c5d12c52a3e32fe5f307c0e985c5d432695c580b268b6376bd166e1e09c1db2"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0b72b673f7b6f4277045f1e7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0b72b673f7b6f4277045f1e7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:124ed1126f661a0223c5c61828b628c35307a39dc84f5563bc0491826e09beec","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"ac1f3ef5eaa524a9901a3e2cb23e64e0ad876820f170ef98b6120dfbd2c7462b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:124ed1126f661a0223c5c61828b628c35307a39dc84f5563bc0491826e09beec","paperId":"2002.02420","textSha256":"3c5d12c52a3e32fe5f307c0e985c5d432695c580b268b6376bd166e1e09c1db2"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0b72b673f7b6f4277045f1e7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:124ed1126f661a0223c5c61828b628c35307a39dc84f5563bc0491826e09beec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d43","kind":"description","unitIndex":43,"unitId":"unit:124ed1126f661a0223c5c61828b628c35307a39dc84f5563bc0491826e09beec","textSha256":"3c5d12c52a3e32fe5f307c0e985c5d432695c580b268b6376bd166e1e09c1db2"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ac0c4ab6c51c0a4bcbc9add2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ac0c4ab6c51c0a4bcbc9add2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:124ed1126f661a0223c5c61828b628c35307a39dc84f5563bc0491826e09beec","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"308135dd98802196da1c333ca0c95ee6da1adf5a1cf8d1d70be7175d5ce84e86","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d43","kind":"description","unitIndex":43,"unitId":"unit:124ed1126f661a0223c5c61828b628c35307a39dc84f5563bc0491826e09beec","textSha256":"3c5d12c52a3e32fe5f307c0e985c5d432695c580b268b6376bd166e1e09c1db2"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ac0c4ab6c51c0a4bcbc9add2","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Combines homogeneous initial-condition selection with CMB and proposed TCC comparisons.","challengeNote":"Initial-condition selection, CMB comparison and conjectural censorship tests remain distinguishable.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:176bc4f314e3d92a9165735dd704b55023531584fc89f620988e321ce28a59a5","home":{"unitId":"unit:176bc4f314e3d92a9165735dd704b55023531584fc89f620988e321ce28a59a5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:176bc4f314e3d92a9165735dd704b55023531584fc89f620988e321ce28a59a5","paperId":"2007.09674","textSha256":"8afd941b4b3472ed72a12c221122a7c38a477a023bc9b684eca07f38206dfdee"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3e8cd2eec1b3bea971e28f0e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3e8cd2eec1b3bea971e28f0e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:176bc4f314e3d92a9165735dd704b55023531584fc89f620988e321ce28a59a5","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"851f9896822a4c31f9c6f12e57f4dcfca7de077aeba51b40894a9bbd21a2d920","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:176bc4f314e3d92a9165735dd704b55023531584fc89f620988e321ce28a59a5","paperId":"2007.09674","textSha256":"8afd941b4b3472ed72a12c221122a7c38a477a023bc9b684eca07f38206dfdee"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3e8cd2eec1b3bea971e28f0e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:176bc4f314e3d92a9165735dd704b55023531584fc89f620988e321ce28a59a5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:176bc4f314e3d92a9165735dd704b55023531584fc89f620988e321ce28a59a5","textSha256":"8afd941b4b3472ed72a12c221122a7c38a477a023bc9b684eca07f38206dfdee"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:18d20f5609301b503ecbfed2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:18d20f5609301b503ecbfed2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:176bc4f314e3d92a9165735dd704b55023531584fc89f620988e321ce28a59a5","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"1feecf334bd80afc78499f81890810bcd59635ea037a77e42dd43564a8a6108c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:176bc4f314e3d92a9165735dd704b55023531584fc89f620988e321ce28a59a5","textSha256":"8afd941b4b3472ed72a12c221122a7c38a477a023bc9b684eca07f38206dfdee"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:18d20f5609301b503ecbfed2","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The order-10^-3 tensor target depends on effective-Planck-mass and reheating conditions.","challengeNote":"The order-10^−3 tensor target is conditional on effective-Planck-mass and reheating choices.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:27d263abd5f680ed64cfee2e4eb77251e3ce2b64cd8b73ad126f3915c8935ef0","home":{"unitId":"unit:27d263abd5f680ed64cfee2e4eb77251e3ce2b64cd8b73ad126f3915c8935ef0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:27d263abd5f680ed64cfee2e4eb77251e3ce2b64cd8b73ad126f3915c8935ef0","paperId":"2012.01512","textSha256":"acc201b80c97388cc4be0d67e9f67d0f4ef906c667966b0eebf374efc4391ff4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:21ce080876148aa933e81ed5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:21ce080876148aa933e81ed5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:27d263abd5f680ed64cfee2e4eb77251e3ce2b64cd8b73ad126f3915c8935ef0","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"6c021c5886e6ddb4964aba3c3099f8ea6e655809d1a41a07c387c59ecd2a9646","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:27d263abd5f680ed64cfee2e4eb77251e3ce2b64cd8b73ad126f3915c8935ef0","paperId":"2012.01512","textSha256":"acc201b80c97388cc4be0d67e9f67d0f4ef906c667966b0eebf374efc4391ff4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:21ce080876148aa933e81ed5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:27d263abd5f680ed64cfee2e4eb77251e3ce2b64cd8b73ad126f3915c8935ef0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d61","kind":"description","unitIndex":61,"unitId":"unit:27d263abd5f680ed64cfee2e4eb77251e3ce2b64cd8b73ad126f3915c8935ef0","textSha256":"acc201b80c97388cc4be0d67e9f67d0f4ef906c667966b0eebf374efc4391ff4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2ef9c7e8d70a671dd7c1571b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2ef9c7e8d70a671dd7c1571b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:27d263abd5f680ed64cfee2e4eb77251e3ce2b64cd8b73ad126f3915c8935ef0","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"aff6396f002c7ec13f972b9bdacda7189d174b09421bf1ea514e4dc3931a6db1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d61","kind":"description","unitIndex":61,"unitId":"unit:27d263abd5f680ed64cfee2e4eb77251e3ce2b64cd8b73ad126f3915c8935ef0","textSha256":"acc201b80c97388cc4be0d67e9f67d0f4ef906c667966b0eebf374efc4391ff4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2ef9c7e8d70a671dd7c1571b","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Constant-H bounds are compared with a slowly varying-H alternative in RS brane cosmology.","challengeNote":"Compares constant-H and slowly varying-H cases within RS brane cosmology.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:2f2938d98209cb969338ce98103c58ab91c049da31819e4948dd4a8822ef8e83","home":{"unitId":"unit:2f2938d98209cb969338ce98103c58ab91c049da31819e4948dd4a8822ef8e83","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2f2938d98209cb969338ce98103c58ab91c049da31819e4948dd4a8822ef8e83","paperId":"2111.11436","textSha256":"2c7eed95789e64ac17b0bae653331697ee7434484253035104fbdfb8de3a79b3"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c626b12d223abb9cd91cf83e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c626b12d223abb9cd91cf83e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2f2938d98209cb969338ce98103c58ab91c049da31819e4948dd4a8822ef8e83","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"2ba3c0c23191be2bd4f530b06473d7b177e7ac3850277de498401d7358c278ff","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2f2938d98209cb969338ce98103c58ab91c049da31819e4948dd4a8822ef8e83","paperId":"2111.11436","textSha256":"2c7eed95789e64ac17b0bae653331697ee7434484253035104fbdfb8de3a79b3"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c626b12d223abb9cd91cf83e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2f2938d98209cb969338ce98103c58ab91c049da31819e4948dd4a8822ef8e83","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d71","kind":"description","unitIndex":71,"unitId":"unit:2f2938d98209cb969338ce98103c58ab91c049da31819e4948dd4a8822ef8e83","textSha256":"2c7eed95789e64ac17b0bae653331697ee7434484253035104fbdfb8de3a79b3"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1bb52231823fcfe297ef549c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1bb52231823fcfe297ef549c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2f2938d98209cb969338ce98103c58ab91c049da31819e4948dd4a8822ef8e83","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"7a337426f7456055e6dfc3709f08b2f5bf85038bdd0621c64ced60bb0edfe7c8","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d71","kind":"description","unitIndex":71,"unitId":"unit:2f2938d98209cb969338ce98103c58ab91c049da31819e4948dd4a8822ef8e83","textSha256":"2c7eed95789e64ac17b0bae653331697ee7434484253035104fbdfb8de3a79b3"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1bb52231823fcfe297ef549c","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The hybrid-form minimal warm model is fitted using its own primordial spectrum.","challengeNote":"The model-specific primordial spectrum is fitted directly according to the description.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","home":{"unitId":"unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","paperId":"2002.07061","textSha256":"2153f6443ca7b468f0ba022755e50d120b593da816f343434f975438c864c00f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05df496c35f7f5a29cbaa795"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05df496c35f7f5a29cbaa795","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"513340bd30d691729cb9199b1366dd7f29de08e5330700aa827e8d0a6a0ff43e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","paperId":"2002.07061","textSha256":"2153f6443ca7b468f0ba022755e50d120b593da816f343434f975438c864c00f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05df496c35f7f5a29cbaa795"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","textSha256":"2153f6443ca7b468f0ba022755e50d120b593da816f343434f975438c864c00f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ce4e10259e0df2104a8d90d7"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ce4e10259e0df2104a8d90d7","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"3c9966fb64e6badad01d62fbd3471196f08535bd50f490f83cce92d7d8f948d8","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","textSha256":"2153f6443ca7b468f0ba022755e50d120b593da816f343434f975438c864c00f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ce4e10259e0df2104a8d90d7","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The 55–75 e-fold target and selected reheating histories are part of the modified-expansion test.","challengeNote":"The potential-gradient conjecture is unnamed. Retain 55–75 e-folds and the dependence of TCC compatibility on selected reheating histories.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5445fafd9d26017758dbaa7433f3cbe949a3af250e6497e3805b2ca4fb0e8519","home":{"unitId":"unit:5445fafd9d26017758dbaa7433f3cbe949a3af250e6497e3805b2ca4fb0e8519","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5445fafd9d26017758dbaa7433f3cbe949a3af250e6497e3805b2ca4fb0e8519","paperId":"2101.06378","textSha256":"7ec32aab4e44e2e651ce427239ef70227f914cd299fc5c23bb39f47157da8812"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1ed05b0db83240f1ce5e1103"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1ed05b0db83240f1ce5e1103","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5445fafd9d26017758dbaa7433f3cbe949a3af250e6497e3805b2ca4fb0e8519","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"6addd877e83f3089ddc19d9ae6a04fb4455348cb2d43036ff91c52ada3131573","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5445fafd9d26017758dbaa7433f3cbe949a3af250e6497e3805b2ca4fb0e8519","paperId":"2101.06378","textSha256":"7ec32aab4e44e2e651ce427239ef70227f914cd299fc5c23bb39f47157da8812"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1ed05b0db83240f1ce5e1103"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5445fafd9d26017758dbaa7433f3cbe949a3af250e6497e3805b2ca4fb0e8519","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d63","kind":"description","unitIndex":63,"unitId":"unit:5445fafd9d26017758dbaa7433f3cbe949a3af250e6497e3805b2ca4fb0e8519","textSha256":"7ec32aab4e44e2e651ce427239ef70227f914cd299fc5c23bb39f47157da8812"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:621731338bb9d0c629170abe"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:621731338bb9d0c629170abe","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5445fafd9d26017758dbaa7433f3cbe949a3af250e6497e3805b2ca4fb0e8519","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"19e7b4561f4feac990b01e4dc375406b177b11084a78c6dd046c4841f988d098","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d63","kind":"description","unitIndex":63,"unitId":"unit:5445fafd9d26017758dbaa7433f3cbe949a3af250e6497e3805b2ca4fb0e8519","textSha256":"7ec32aab4e44e2e651ce427239ef70227f914cd299fc5c23bb39f47157da8812"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:621731338bb9d0c629170abe","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound targets include scalar-field background correspondences; these do not establish perturbative equivalence.","challengeNote":"Compound phenomenology, background-correspondence and censorship targets; background correspondence does not establish perturbative equivalence.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5eaebb7eb4a017d508dc306caa74107586604a60c58cb7975b986bf28c6a0edd","home":{"unitId":"unit:5eaebb7eb4a017d508dc306caa74107586604a60c58cb7975b986bf28c6a0edd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5eaebb7eb4a017d508dc306caa74107586604a60c58cb7975b986bf28c6a0edd","paperId":"1910.08837","textSha256":"39f6473c5bf76a6e1a4081b0348643ba4844392e73c9e791b7b6362774464f84"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7657f920c10fd0dc33a88134"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7657f920c10fd0dc33a88134","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5eaebb7eb4a017d508dc306caa74107586604a60c58cb7975b986bf28c6a0edd","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"dd61dfcb7f06357ad97f6cddfab04d3a68bc75f0152b21d9bb966b0c10d24974","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5eaebb7eb4a017d508dc306caa74107586604a60c58cb7975b986bf28c6a0edd","paperId":"1910.08837","textSha256":"39f6473c5bf76a6e1a4081b0348643ba4844392e73c9e791b7b6362774464f84"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7657f920c10fd0dc33a88134"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5eaebb7eb4a017d508dc306caa74107586604a60c58cb7975b986bf28c6a0edd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:5eaebb7eb4a017d508dc306caa74107586604a60c58cb7975b986bf28c6a0edd","textSha256":"39f6473c5bf76a6e1a4081b0348643ba4844392e73c9e791b7b6362774464f84"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7f32d84759a578650adb1c17"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7f32d84759a578650adb1c17","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5eaebb7eb4a017d508dc306caa74107586604a60c58cb7975b986bf28c6a0edd","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"c32b8a0c342677f838d8b6bc66801f0b37c2dcbbe9e65ea69e9d6fe0c23fc076","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:5eaebb7eb4a017d508dc306caa74107586604a60c58cb7975b986bf28c6a0edd","textSha256":"39f6473c5bf76a6e1a4081b0348643ba4844392e73c9e791b7b6362774464f84"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7f32d84759a578650adb1c17","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"A GUT-scale symmetry-breaking parameter is distinct from inflationary energy.","challengeNote":"The symmetry-breaking parameter is distinct from inflationary energy.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:776d2714eaa2908e98f60f1d7c25d49e5c3e6f1aae2174f39c5fb01013336f7f","home":{"unitId":"unit:776d2714eaa2908e98f60f1d7c25d49e5c3e6f1aae2174f39c5fb01013336f7f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:776d2714eaa2908e98f60f1d7c25d49e5c3e6f1aae2174f39c5fb01013336f7f","paperId":"1910.09460","textSha256":"c330f21d7745dcfb3a1c498a8316c5597e6762e444f6389bd1095875b2cfedd5"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6aa139cef5dc051ca895d05e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6aa139cef5dc051ca895d05e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:776d2714eaa2908e98f60f1d7c25d49e5c3e6f1aae2174f39c5fb01013336f7f","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"550e39262116e21e5a43e0d8ae42087ad1cdcbdf07ab373cac939e705cf15a3e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:776d2714eaa2908e98f60f1d7c25d49e5c3e6f1aae2174f39c5fb01013336f7f","paperId":"1910.09460","textSha256":"c330f21d7745dcfb3a1c498a8316c5597e6762e444f6389bd1095875b2cfedd5"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6aa139cef5dc051ca895d05e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:776d2714eaa2908e98f60f1d7c25d49e5c3e6f1aae2174f39c5fb01013336f7f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:776d2714eaa2908e98f60f1d7c25d49e5c3e6f1aae2174f39c5fb01013336f7f","textSha256":"c330f21d7745dcfb3a1c498a8316c5597e6762e444f6389bd1095875b2cfedd5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2ecf8500e406a24809b17f5d"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2ecf8500e406a24809b17f5d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:776d2714eaa2908e98f60f1d7c25d49e5c3e6f1aae2174f39c5fb01013336f7f","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"110aae78165326f3f512318d1ed4bfe17da2869181d358276a0e54941e78b1a8","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:776d2714eaa2908e98f60f1d7c25d49e5c3e6f1aae2174f39c5fb01013336f7f","textSha256":"c330f21d7745dcfb3a1c498a8316c5597e6762e444f6389bd1095875b2cfedd5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2ecf8500e406a24809b17f5d","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The all-physically-possible-initial-conditions quantifier is material to this question.","challengeNote":"The quantifier over every physically possible initial condition must be retained.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a000dcfeca9d2f236c7cdce6a4ca97192d10927cce49ee813f025249a246dc89","home":{"unitId":"unit:a000dcfeca9d2f236c7cdce6a4ca97192d10927cce49ee813f025249a246dc89","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a000dcfeca9d2f236c7cdce6a4ca97192d10927cce49ee813f025249a246dc89","paperId":"2601.20056","textSha256":"8076f045e18a479e78a8b3cb452fd0bbd82314322a9cfc30414efa7d46f68a19"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:876856a88396008ce1a1b867"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:876856a88396008ce1a1b867","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a000dcfeca9d2f236c7cdce6a4ca97192d10927cce49ee813f025249a246dc89","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"ab385945a9c96391a5318d1d7f4c0ea4c2b3113475c7f34aea5ad11d7462bef6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a000dcfeca9d2f236c7cdce6a4ca97192d10927cce49ee813f025249a246dc89","paperId":"2601.20056","textSha256":"8076f045e18a479e78a8b3cb452fd0bbd82314322a9cfc30414efa7d46f68a19"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:876856a88396008ce1a1b867"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a000dcfeca9d2f236c7cdce6a4ca97192d10927cce49ee813f025249a246dc89","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d92","kind":"description","unitIndex":92,"unitId":"unit:a000dcfeca9d2f236c7cdce6a4ca97192d10927cce49ee813f025249a246dc89","textSha256":"8076f045e18a479e78a8b3cb452fd0bbd82314322a9cfc30414efa7d46f68a19"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c18792a382982dc3330abfab"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c18792a382982dc3330abfab","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a000dcfeca9d2f236c7cdce6a4ca97192d10927cce49ee813f025249a246dc89","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"37cbfaef962844419bf9c8ddfa884dcaafe6c435a66c231ba10a5419b40da2f6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d92","kind":"description","unitIndex":92,"unitId":"unit:a000dcfeca9d2f236c7cdce6a4ca97192d10927cce49ee813f025249a246dc89","textSha256":"8076f045e18a479e78a8b3cb452fd0bbd82314322a9cfc30414efa7d46f68a19"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c18792a382982dc3330abfab","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Requires a smooth single-scalar transition; the proposed tail remedy is a target, not an established success.","challengeNote":"Requires a smooth single-scalar transition; successful implementation of the remedy is not established here.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b9edf5b2713f37a383fe3f32b780a20766f2e4f52f80444436a0343378f977d8","home":{"unitId":"unit:b9edf5b2713f37a383fe3f32b780a20766f2e4f52f80444436a0343378f977d8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b9edf5b2713f37a383fe3f32b780a20766f2e4f52f80444436a0343378f977d8","paperId":"2105.10571","textSha256":"cdd043b84b78f92ad4ba28b022e3c60080a6376d53189f1dcc26256724d0b0a1"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4e7528640d4bf209a04ee5a7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4e7528640d4bf209a04ee5a7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b9edf5b2713f37a383fe3f32b780a20766f2e4f52f80444436a0343378f977d8","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"3c94765a219e321a8c66be248f13c0166b75d91dfeb4d361779aad05fcfaf8d8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b9edf5b2713f37a383fe3f32b780a20766f2e4f52f80444436a0343378f977d8","paperId":"2105.10571","textSha256":"cdd043b84b78f92ad4ba28b022e3c60080a6376d53189f1dcc26256724d0b0a1"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4e7528640d4bf209a04ee5a7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b9edf5b2713f37a383fe3f32b780a20766f2e4f52f80444436a0343378f977d8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d67","kind":"description","unitIndex":67,"unitId":"unit:b9edf5b2713f37a383fe3f32b780a20766f2e4f52f80444436a0343378f977d8","textSha256":"cdd043b84b78f92ad4ba28b022e3c60080a6376d53189f1dcc26256724d0b0a1"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e12313d0e8f23fa7aeea0e00"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e12313d0e8f23fa7aeea0e00","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b9edf5b2713f37a383fe3f32b780a20766f2e4f52f80444436a0343378f977d8","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"47b76b0947e7ca06be26d0696c2f95c504a0005893bf8bb159fea971d9e66ad7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d67","kind":"description","unitIndex":67,"unitId":"unit:b9edf5b2713f37a383fe3f32b780a20766f2e4f52f80444436a0343378f977d8","textSha256":"cdd043b84b78f92ad4ba28b022e3c60080a6376d53189f1dcc26256724d0b0a1"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e12313d0e8f23fa7aeea0e00","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Retains Jordan/Einstein frame comparison and the proposed initial-effective-Planck-mass prescription.","challengeNote":"Retains the frame comparison and proposed initial-effective-Planck-mass prescription.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c2a49b73c2bedc55a18a13e1ca8c35a4218580bacb0da68b6c27f48fc72adb20","home":{"unitId":"unit:c2a49b73c2bedc55a18a13e1ca8c35a4218580bacb0da68b6c27f48fc72adb20","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c2a49b73c2bedc55a18a13e1ca8c35a4218580bacb0da68b6c27f48fc72adb20","paperId":"1910.00521","textSha256":"16535ac1e746d8130eb0dea052dc464a61892a726c69b3fa1f7d90ee2b3e7fdb"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:80e30f3887399fcd93c53d90"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:80e30f3887399fcd93c53d90","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c2a49b73c2bedc55a18a13e1ca8c35a4218580bacb0da68b6c27f48fc72adb20","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"e91aabf9e93c1561fce8041840202a4433cb18b41cc83fa3456c820e667f6c58","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c2a49b73c2bedc55a18a13e1ca8c35a4218580bacb0da68b6c27f48fc72adb20","paperId":"1910.00521","textSha256":"16535ac1e746d8130eb0dea052dc464a61892a726c69b3fa1f7d90ee2b3e7fdb"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:80e30f3887399fcd93c53d90"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c2a49b73c2bedc55a18a13e1ca8c35a4218580bacb0da68b6c27f48fc72adb20","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:c2a49b73c2bedc55a18a13e1ca8c35a4218580bacb0da68b6c27f48fc72adb20","textSha256":"16535ac1e746d8130eb0dea052dc464a61892a726c69b3fa1f7d90ee2b3e7fdb"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:813b895ac3c1777388e1810e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:813b895ac3c1777388e1810e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c2a49b73c2bedc55a18a13e1ca8c35a4218580bacb0da68b6c27f48fc72adb20","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"280e97886967d50050f47689f8aeeb0de83dbcfa58410cce534d6252534003fd","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:c2a49b73c2bedc55a18a13e1ca8c35a4218580bacb0da68b6c27f48fc72adb20","textSha256":"16535ac1e746d8130eb0dea052dc464a61892a726c69b3fa1f7d90ee2b3e7fdb"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:813b895ac3c1777388e1810e","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound targets: viable low-scale inflation and spectator-produced dark matter. TCC validity is not assessed.","challengeNote":"Compound inflation-viability and spectator-dark-matter targets; the author does not assess TCC validity.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","home":{"unitId":"unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","paperId":"2504.04561","textSha256":"f9552de72682bc018bd9b80e0af0539a576923a2bf12b1be58fdfbf53cf950db"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9f363e4248020cd471e7452c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9f363e4248020cd471e7452c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"2e9c035c7373ddca52cacbbe26af36fab3778bebedde96355e043f56d51619d5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","paperId":"2504.04561","textSha256":"f9552de72682bc018bd9b80e0af0539a576923a2bf12b1be58fdfbf53cf950db"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9f363e4248020cd471e7452c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d87","kind":"description","unitIndex":87,"unitId":"unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","textSha256":"f9552de72682bc018bd9b80e0af0539a576923a2bf12b1be58fdfbf53cf950db"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6a997a0c5d749726c1dee800"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6a997a0c5d749726c1dee800","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"7b4e1ff1094ae18ecd166248e1e34aa90a4701a065a2bc6440aa198c6760368b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d87","kind":"description","unitIndex":87,"unitId":"unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","textSha256":"f9552de72682bc018bd9b80e0af0539a576923a2bf12b1be58fdfbf53cf950db"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6a997a0c5d749726c1dee800","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The constant-EoS scalar tail is a proposed remedy; observational and slope compatibility require separate tests.","challengeNote":"The scalar tail is a proposed remedy whose observational and slope compatibility require testing.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ed0b94aa900b52dad4a70eb6d88da5c142d5210011dcb08c8d37a94c85b3c5eb","home":{"unitId":"unit:ed0b94aa900b52dad4a70eb6d88da5c142d5210011dcb08c8d37a94c85b3c5eb","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ed0b94aa900b52dad4a70eb6d88da5c142d5210011dcb08c8d37a94c85b3c5eb","paperId":"2404.03141","textSha256":"dbf2ba52720f727a555e933596de4241ddf6f776cfa71f7760653792f453e961"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a7bdd795b857d55af19fcbe1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a7bdd795b857d55af19fcbe1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ed0b94aa900b52dad4a70eb6d88da5c142d5210011dcb08c8d37a94c85b3c5eb","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"9830fcfcce29582afd358736ef295fb864b757007d6df069076beb94b4d92e26","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ed0b94aa900b52dad4a70eb6d88da5c142d5210011dcb08c8d37a94c85b3c5eb","paperId":"2404.03141","textSha256":"dbf2ba52720f727a555e933596de4241ddf6f776cfa71f7760653792f453e961"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a7bdd795b857d55af19fcbe1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ed0b94aa900b52dad4a70eb6d88da5c142d5210011dcb08c8d37a94c85b3c5eb","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d84","kind":"description","unitIndex":84,"unitId":"unit:ed0b94aa900b52dad4a70eb6d88da5c142d5210011dcb08c8d37a94c85b3c5eb","textSha256":"dbf2ba52720f727a555e933596de4241ddf6f776cfa71f7760653792f453e961"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e9ba0eaf331ac0a2affc65d1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e9ba0eaf331ac0a2affc65d1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ed0b94aa900b52dad4a70eb6d88da5c142d5210011dcb08c8d37a94c85b3c5eb","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"148ccda9a14006f71f32cd1714edace299bb6cabb339375271b977a58a893da0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d84","kind":"description","unitIndex":84,"unitId":"unit:ed0b94aa900b52dad4a70eb6d88da5c142d5210011dcb08c8d37a94c85b3c5eb","textSha256":"dbf2ba52720f727a555e933596de4241ddf6f776cfa71f7760653792f453e961"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e9ba0eaf331ac0a2affc65d1","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Spin-sourced torsion is treated by the source as a trans-Planckian effect with a finite-time vacuum prescription.","challengeNote":"The source treats torsion as a trans-Planckian effect and uses a finite-time vacuum prescription.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:fe8b057e0beaffaf96c3fcfa7f9c50cdb1c3f604eb9a187e10389094656a24bd","home":{"unitId":"unit:fe8b057e0beaffaf96c3fcfa7f9c50cdb1c3f604eb9a187e10389094656a24bd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fe8b057e0beaffaf96c3fcfa7f9c50cdb1c3f604eb9a187e10389094656a24bd","paperId":"2509.11387","textSha256":"171f0a274fe2a0872f4d4459456126dd3df18e593b95e5e435d427246e5353d0"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0e769dc57844b6e9e7b895ed"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0e769dc57844b6e9e7b895ed","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fe8b057e0beaffaf96c3fcfa7f9c50cdb1c3f604eb9a187e10389094656a24bd","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"ea5cd0be3938cd04173c5ab73f595224223650a890989f361cf24d911c2f523e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fe8b057e0beaffaf96c3fcfa7f9c50cdb1c3f604eb9a187e10389094656a24bd","paperId":"2509.11387","textSha256":"171f0a274fe2a0872f4d4459456126dd3df18e593b95e5e435d427246e5353d0"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0e769dc57844b6e9e7b895ed"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fe8b057e0beaffaf96c3fcfa7f9c50cdb1c3f604eb9a187e10389094656a24bd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d89","kind":"description","unitIndex":89,"unitId":"unit:fe8b057e0beaffaf96c3fcfa7f9c50cdb1c3f604eb9a187e10389094656a24bd","textSha256":"171f0a274fe2a0872f4d4459456126dd3df18e593b95e5e435d427246e5353d0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a91ee600cc3bca5c6130beb1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a91ee600cc3bca5c6130beb1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fe8b057e0beaffaf96c3fcfa7f9c50cdb1c3f604eb9a187e10389094656a24bd","q025-candidate-question:57da09d9019ebb36598ae313"],"scopeContentSha256":"421e3adac55f1c9a1df51545096ee689c60fe202dce3ae358cb4638b9da80a38","contributionContentSha256":"1462141f3e1470157a1f0cbd1013c8ec22ecdaaedd264f523c5ad1445709794a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d89","kind":"description","unitIndex":89,"unitId":"unit:fe8b057e0beaffaf96c3fcfa7f9c50cdb1c3f604eb9a187e10389094656a24bd","textSha256":"171f0a274fe2a0872f4d4459456126dd3df18e593b95e5e435d427246e5353d0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a91ee600cc3bca5c6130beb1","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Tests whether the combined theory realizes the proposed tail; modifications and exit mechanisms remain conditional alternatives.","challengeNote":"Tests tail realization in the combined theory; modifications and exit mechanisms are conditional alternatives.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":15,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a87d8bcfe0aca69691fa5a1b744a20927f1bad86ae31a0eaa2a528b6d5e3769a"},"organizational-access:861de234ecd7b51c73e693c1":{"id":"organizational-access:861de234ecd7b51c73e693c1","source":"q025-candidate-region:5f44fe88006e0eff9841d550","target":"q025-candidate-question:1bba20c6dc8e02125a91f305","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:5f44fe88006e0eff9841d550","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"f2124993d3e8582959ca15ee90f6ccf1c99681ca143e320af53b9e9e35ef3f95","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d37f1c1a720cf914c8cab48e"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1bba20c6dc8e02125a91f305","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"18bed97c69d539d9168692e9db3adf1178cbda5c41b83190cfaae71a6585584c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:82763c05a59c183b454f7b53"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1ed478f3aa965123bc0e203873a20b0b76f5eb5ff8052c3774b6c62c5dfdc2d5","home":{"unitId":"unit:1ed478f3aa965123bc0e203873a20b0b76f5eb5ff8052c3774b6c62c5dfdc2d5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f44fe88006e0eff9841d550","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1ed478f3aa965123bc0e203873a20b0b76f5eb5ff8052c3774b6c62c5dfdc2d5","paperId":"2408.04011","textSha256":"9b8b408aefde3a0b6befdc227fd7bf55e87593dbccf6a59c083155658e540ff7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fcca0b3e21a7135a94baacc1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fcca0b3e21a7135a94baacc1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1ed478f3aa965123bc0e203873a20b0b76f5eb5ff8052c3774b6c62c5dfdc2d5","q025-candidate-region:5f44fe88006e0eff9841d550"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2124993d3e8582959ca15ee90f6ccf1c99681ca143e320af53b9e9e35ef3f95","placementContentSha256":"c9ab82f9ba054606254f0c9d5c6eeb7fb5c77144c04d09ff876c76fe33b917a6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e5169763c8e4f665bca3-challenge","leaf-e5169763c8e4f665bca3-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1ed478f3aa965123bc0e203873a20b0b76f5eb5ff8052c3774b6c62c5dfdc2d5","paperId":"2408.04011","textSha256":"9b8b408aefde3a0b6befdc227fd7bf55e87593dbccf6a59c083155658e540ff7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fcca0b3e21a7135a94baacc1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1ed478f3aa965123bc0e203873a20b0b76f5eb5ff8052c3774b6c62c5dfdc2d5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1bba20c6dc8e02125a91f305","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:1ed478f3aa965123bc0e203873a20b0b76f5eb5ff8052c3774b6c62c5dfdc2d5","textSha256":"9b8b408aefde3a0b6befdc227fd7bf55e87593dbccf6a59c083155658e540ff7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:71f4b4a319435faa799d8f63","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound target: local symmetry/Haag-duality diagnostics, two-dimensional completeness and quantitative deficits require finer reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Local diagnostics, completeness and quantitative failure are separable; fine identity remains unresolved."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:71f4b4a319435faa799d8f63","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1ed478f3aa965123bc0e203873a20b0b76f5eb5ff8052c3774b6c62c5dfdc2d5","q025-candidate-question:1bba20c6dc8e02125a91f305"],"scopeContentSha256":"18bed97c69d539d9168692e9db3adf1178cbda5c41b83190cfaae71a6585584c","contributionContentSha256":"7d702bdf24651769922ddbde8868b5e22c08b6ccab19261177a0aa9fa66848b7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-e5169763c8e4f665bca3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e5169763c8e4f665bca3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e5169763c8e4f665bca3-proposal","leaf-e5169763c8e4f665bca3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:1ed478f3aa965123bc0e203873a20b0b76f5eb5ff8052c3774b6c62c5dfdc2d5","textSha256":"9b8b408aefde3a0b6befdc227fd7bf55e87593dbccf6a59c083155658e540ff7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:71f4b4a319435faa799d8f63","recordId":"leaf-e5169763c8e4f665bca3-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-e5169763c8e4f665bca3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e5169763c8e4f665bca3-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound target: local symmetry/Haag-duality diagnostics, two-dimensional completeness and quantitative deficits require finer reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Local diagnostics, completeness and quantitative failure are separable; fine identity remains unresolved.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a7d8721b9477f432a8ab68ade5e039823a051fe73e6046f7248df0a82fe1da3b"},"organizational-access:675b0b1c6e06627972432dc7":{"id":"organizational-access:675b0b1c6e06627972432dc7","source":"q025-candidate-region:80d1124cd831dc31225394f7","target":"q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:80d1124cd831dc31225394f7","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"2785285c4a53e5790d36d03b339f0f8b55420002eed0c615b46dd57a047a4d60","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:54eb1356af3770263ae92ed7"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"0ae2a2c292601d0231a4e2722175c6ff721b5fb3410f42fe1af6c480f2e9ff60","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e8425e3597b12e35a1eb0a4b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:34e6894b54e96ada2be5cda2ede7844d33f78e5f9d09a3044b026b58016d4278","home":{"unitId":"unit:34e6894b54e96ada2be5cda2ede7844d33f78e5f9d09a3044b026b58016d4278","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:80d1124cd831dc31225394f7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:34e6894b54e96ada2be5cda2ede7844d33f78e5f9d09a3044b026b58016d4278","paperId":"hep-th/0612098","textSha256":"74ff837fc438005b2b5df5e34b09581c067a5c1d45b20e94fbe6483d809ec677"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d4d4326daf568eb0f817c7d5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d4d4326daf568eb0f817c7d5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:34e6894b54e96ada2be5cda2ede7844d33f78e5f9d09a3044b026b58016d4278","q025-candidate-region:80d1124cd831dc31225394f7"],"scopeContentSha256":"2785285c4a53e5790d36d03b339f0f8b55420002eed0c615b46dd57a047a4d60","placementContentSha256":"28106f58c143776cab5143b6516ed09168aa8a2294b30bf93b42c14221751128","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge","leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:34e6894b54e96ada2be5cda2ede7844d33f78e5f9d09a3044b026b58016d4278","paperId":"hep-th/0612098","textSha256":"74ff837fc438005b2b5df5e34b09581c067a5c1d45b20e94fbe6483d809ec677"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d4d4326daf568eb0f817c7d5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:34e6894b54e96ada2be5cda2ede7844d33f78e5f9d09a3044b026b58016d4278","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:34e6894b54e96ada2be5cda2ede7844d33f78e5f9d09a3044b026b58016d4278","textSha256":"74ff837fc438005b2b5df5e34b09581c067a5c1d45b20e94fbe6483d809ec677"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3164cc70897e04af1ce7bc45"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3164cc70897e04af1ce7bc45","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:34e6894b54e96ada2be5cda2ede7844d33f78e5f9d09a3044b026b58016d4278","q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685"],"scopeContentSha256":"0ae2a2c292601d0231a4e2722175c6ff721b5fb3410f42fe1af6c480f2e9ff60","contributionContentSha256":"0a471ff9bae614ba0a00639024725aa901b3174502bb67a98658689392bba836","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:34e6894b54e96ada2be5cda2ede7844d33f78e5f9d09a3044b026b58016d4278","textSha256":"74ff837fc438005b2b5df5e34b09581c067a5c1d45b20e94fbe6483d809ec677"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3164cc70897e04af1ce7bc45","recordId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Ghost-condensate and nonlocal tachyon models, and phantom versus bounce applications, are alternatives.","challengeNote":"Compound alternatives: ghost condensate versus nonlocal tachyon, and phantom dark energy versus bounce applications.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:426a4cf493a5a3b922ea40cf03c78da255363985bc76c0f91e2c23adaa08bf76","home":{"unitId":"unit:426a4cf493a5a3b922ea40cf03c78da255363985bc76c0f91e2c23adaa08bf76","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:80d1124cd831dc31225394f7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:426a4cf493a5a3b922ea40cf03c78da255363985bc76c0f91e2c23adaa08bf76","paperId":"1912.10532","textSha256":"e6510f17bad3f3536de29873a09fc2107a74fbf8fbf8920e147114477689c525"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:11043ef36768e39c78c0ad89"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:11043ef36768e39c78c0ad89","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:426a4cf493a5a3b922ea40cf03c78da255363985bc76c0f91e2c23adaa08bf76","q025-candidate-region:80d1124cd831dc31225394f7"],"scopeContentSha256":"2785285c4a53e5790d36d03b339f0f8b55420002eed0c615b46dd57a047a4d60","placementContentSha256":"8becd87c79f4b5c2f445e0ccc18cb5a8ed35f38d6b6a2413aaf11f2be9a5ab01","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge","leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:426a4cf493a5a3b922ea40cf03c78da255363985bc76c0f91e2c23adaa08bf76","paperId":"1912.10532","textSha256":"e6510f17bad3f3536de29873a09fc2107a74fbf8fbf8920e147114477689c525"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:11043ef36768e39c78c0ad89"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:426a4cf493a5a3b922ea40cf03c78da255363985bc76c0f91e2c23adaa08bf76","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:426a4cf493a5a3b922ea40cf03c78da255363985bc76c0f91e2c23adaa08bf76","textSha256":"e6510f17bad3f3536de29873a09fc2107a74fbf8fbf8920e147114477689c525"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a7ca284e52c7f173c9f77f5c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a7ca284e52c7f173c9f77f5c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:426a4cf493a5a3b922ea40cf03c78da255363985bc76c0f91e2c23adaa08bf76","q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685"],"scopeContentSha256":"0ae2a2c292601d0231a4e2722175c6ff721b5fb3410f42fe1af6c480f2e9ff60","contributionContentSha256":"ab70aa35813fecd75c92bda45341ef943b49b42990d7eda644035247bcde5d7d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:426a4cf493a5a3b922ea40cf03c78da255363985bc76c0f91e2c23adaa08bf76","textSha256":"e6510f17bad3f3536de29873a09fc2107a74fbf8fbf8920e147114477689c525"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a7ca284e52c7f173c9f77f5c","recordId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Bounce, cyclic and exponentially expanding backgrounds are alternative applications.","challengeNote":"Bounce, cyclic and exponentially expanding backgrounds are alternative applications of the thermal mechanism.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:58b5a07fd563f65adb06cabe07024a3110519bf59aa584f6f503adff2ce34fbe","home":{"unitId":"unit:58b5a07fd563f65adb06cabe07024a3110519bf59aa584f6f503adff2ce34fbe","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:80d1124cd831dc31225394f7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:58b5a07fd563f65adb06cabe07024a3110519bf59aa584f6f503adff2ce34fbe","paperId":"2207.11772","textSha256":"0f7da7f351bc3e74500efdde64ef1a7a6770d192ef0dee2f361cf95092e363f5"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0bcf52710749ce58f36c4e6449c2f4c6","paperId":"2207.11772","sourceSha256":"24052b67482c8d3f65063c1a85298eacb08262f0181aaa7cae30064176916368","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e06701eca7cdf86c2a13/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0779280b9ec6b1da7c00acaccc6babfdede99f04c26849b034f00c62dc6808e3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1672,"textSha256":"cd4e798c669436e1bff1792e83c4b5554cef850805eb681ac8fcea8641bc31a1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b6e253665f9271007489ff9dc26315ec","paperId":"2207.11772","sourceSha256":"24052b67482c8d3f65063c1a85298eacb08262f0181aaa7cae30064176916368","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e06701eca7cdf86c2a13/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0779280b9ec6b1da7c00acaccc6babfdede99f04c26849b034f00c62dc6808e3","pdfPage":1,"start":109,"end":1672,"textSha256":"2c7c342ea54ddc7fc6c06bb2880fdbac85b24586e5e96372fe05e7d19a342283","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:da770942cff3768db7760f9ba202983e","paperId":"2207.11772","sourceSha256":"24052b67482c8d3f65063c1a85298eacb08262f0181aaa7cae30064176916368","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e06701eca7cdf86c2a13/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0779280b9ec6b1da7c00acaccc6babfdede99f04c26849b034f00c62dc6808e3","pdfPage":14,"start":0,"end":2041,"textSha256":"9c600cac5fb49e8fe5e11f28e7221a533205cd6876164b57f70b9f99b40a8c21","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7e4a48cb2dce5331405d759b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7e4a48cb2dce5331405d759b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:58b5a07fd563f65adb06cabe07024a3110519bf59aa584f6f503adff2ce34fbe","q025-candidate-region:80d1124cd831dc31225394f7"],"scopeContentSha256":"2785285c4a53e5790d36d03b339f0f8b55420002eed0c615b46dd57a047a4d60","placementContentSha256":"5f55158c4f0d80b0304ae86995ecdbc73ed9b2ea0aaabda11c173982d74bed73","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge","leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:58b5a07fd563f65adb06cabe07024a3110519bf59aa584f6f503adff2ce34fbe","paperId":"2207.11772","textSha256":"0f7da7f351bc3e74500efdde64ef1a7a6770d192ef0dee2f361cf95092e363f5"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0bcf52710749ce58f36c4e6449c2f4c6","paperId":"2207.11772","sourceSha256":"24052b67482c8d3f65063c1a85298eacb08262f0181aaa7cae30064176916368","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e06701eca7cdf86c2a13/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0779280b9ec6b1da7c00acaccc6babfdede99f04c26849b034f00c62dc6808e3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1672,"textSha256":"cd4e798c669436e1bff1792e83c4b5554cef850805eb681ac8fcea8641bc31a1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b6e253665f9271007489ff9dc26315ec","paperId":"2207.11772","sourceSha256":"24052b67482c8d3f65063c1a85298eacb08262f0181aaa7cae30064176916368","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e06701eca7cdf86c2a13/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0779280b9ec6b1da7c00acaccc6babfdede99f04c26849b034f00c62dc6808e3","pdfPage":1,"start":109,"end":1672,"textSha256":"2c7c342ea54ddc7fc6c06bb2880fdbac85b24586e5e96372fe05e7d19a342283","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:da770942cff3768db7760f9ba202983e","paperId":"2207.11772","sourceSha256":"24052b67482c8d3f65063c1a85298eacb08262f0181aaa7cae30064176916368","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e06701eca7cdf86c2a13/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0779280b9ec6b1da7c00acaccc6babfdede99f04c26849b034f00c62dc6808e3","pdfPage":14,"start":0,"end":2041,"textSha256":"9c600cac5fb49e8fe5e11f28e7221a533205cd6876164b57f70b9f99b40a8c21","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7e4a48cb2dce5331405d759b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:58b5a07fd563f65adb06cabe07024a3110519bf59aa584f6f503adff2ce34fbe","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:58b5a07fd563f65adb06cabe07024a3110519bf59aa584f6f503adff2ce34fbe","textSha256":"0f7da7f351bc3e74500efdde64ef1a7a6770d192ef0dee2f361cf95092e363f5"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0bcf52710749ce58f36c4e6449c2f4c6","paperId":"2207.11772","sourceSha256":"24052b67482c8d3f65063c1a85298eacb08262f0181aaa7cae30064176916368","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e06701eca7cdf86c2a13/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0779280b9ec6b1da7c00acaccc6babfdede99f04c26849b034f00c62dc6808e3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1672,"textSha256":"cd4e798c669436e1bff1792e83c4b5554cef850805eb681ac8fcea8641bc31a1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b6e253665f9271007489ff9dc26315ec","paperId":"2207.11772","sourceSha256":"24052b67482c8d3f65063c1a85298eacb08262f0181aaa7cae30064176916368","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e06701eca7cdf86c2a13/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0779280b9ec6b1da7c00acaccc6babfdede99f04c26849b034f00c62dc6808e3","pdfPage":1,"start":109,"end":1672,"textSha256":"2c7c342ea54ddc7fc6c06bb2880fdbac85b24586e5e96372fe05e7d19a342283","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:da770942cff3768db7760f9ba202983e","paperId":"2207.11772","sourceSha256":"24052b67482c8d3f65063c1a85298eacb08262f0181aaa7cae30064176916368","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e06701eca7cdf86c2a13/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0779280b9ec6b1da7c00acaccc6babfdede99f04c26849b034f00c62dc6808e3","pdfPage":14,"start":0,"end":2041,"textSha256":"9c600cac5fb49e8fe5e11f28e7221a533205cd6876164b57f70b9f99b40a8c21","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8c8a503e4b75af519f6ad80a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8c8a503e4b75af519f6ad80a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:58b5a07fd563f65adb06cabe07024a3110519bf59aa584f6f503adff2ce34fbe","q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685"],"scopeContentSha256":"0ae2a2c292601d0231a4e2722175c6ff721b5fb3410f42fe1af6c480f2e9ff60","contributionContentSha256":"51324733bd9ceb860ce73525eeca975eafe6c27b28c5a55055fb29645cb4bc05","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:58b5a07fd563f65adb06cabe07024a3110519bf59aa584f6f503adff2ce34fbe","textSha256":"0f7da7f351bc3e74500efdde64ef1a7a6770d192ef0dee2f361cf95092e363f5"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0bcf52710749ce58f36c4e6449c2f4c6","paperId":"2207.11772","sourceSha256":"24052b67482c8d3f65063c1a85298eacb08262f0181aaa7cae30064176916368","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e06701eca7cdf86c2a13/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0779280b9ec6b1da7c00acaccc6babfdede99f04c26849b034f00c62dc6808e3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1672,"textSha256":"cd4e798c669436e1bff1792e83c4b5554cef850805eb681ac8fcea8641bc31a1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b6e253665f9271007489ff9dc26315ec","paperId":"2207.11772","sourceSha256":"24052b67482c8d3f65063c1a85298eacb08262f0181aaa7cae30064176916368","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e06701eca7cdf86c2a13/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0779280b9ec6b1da7c00acaccc6babfdede99f04c26849b034f00c62dc6808e3","pdfPage":1,"start":109,"end":1672,"textSha256":"2c7c342ea54ddc7fc6c06bb2880fdbac85b24586e5e96372fe05e7d19a342283","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:da770942cff3768db7760f9ba202983e","paperId":"2207.11772","sourceSha256":"24052b67482c8d3f65063c1a85298eacb08262f0181aaa7cae30064176916368","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e06701eca7cdf86c2a13/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0779280b9ec6b1da7c00acaccc6babfdede99f04c26849b034f00c62dc6808e3","pdfPage":14,"start":0,"end":2041,"textSha256":"9c600cac5fb49e8fe5e11f28e7221a533205cd6876164b57f70b9f99b40a8c21","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8c8a503e4b75af519f6ad80a","recordId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"A possible need for additional sub-cutoff physics is reported; classical stability is not a unitarity certificate.","challengeNote":"The abstract reports a possible need for additional sub-cutoff physics; classical stability does not certify unitarity.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f8632f31908aa4f21d25083db27d9ae4f94d692f8ec459e725f68d45716e4454","home":{"unitId":"unit:f8632f31908aa4f21d25083db27d9ae4f94d692f8ec459e725f68d45716e4454","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:80d1124cd831dc31225394f7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f8632f31908aa4f21d25083db27d9ae4f94d692f8ec459e725f68d45716e4454","paperId":"1401.4024","textSha256":"e2b7e5e912e46eba769c320791baaf544eea8de19808358a1926499c4517fccc"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:16989628d4fe820d1d4c586b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:16989628d4fe820d1d4c586b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f8632f31908aa4f21d25083db27d9ae4f94d692f8ec459e725f68d45716e4454","q025-candidate-region:80d1124cd831dc31225394f7"],"scopeContentSha256":"2785285c4a53e5790d36d03b339f0f8b55420002eed0c615b46dd57a047a4d60","placementContentSha256":"34c18687b1c0b8ce89176e1503810f44030fc649f4aaffb6eaf6c67d36bf6ec9","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge","leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f8632f31908aa4f21d25083db27d9ae4f94d692f8ec459e725f68d45716e4454","paperId":"1401.4024","textSha256":"e2b7e5e912e46eba769c320791baaf544eea8de19808358a1926499c4517fccc"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:16989628d4fe820d1d4c586b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f8632f31908aa4f21d25083db27d9ae4f94d692f8ec459e725f68d45716e4454","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:f8632f31908aa4f21d25083db27d9ae4f94d692f8ec459e725f68d45716e4454","textSha256":"e2b7e5e912e46eba769c320791baaf544eea8de19808358a1926499c4517fccc"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3b08ea73ecd676e91b47d611"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3b08ea73ecd676e91b47d611","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f8632f31908aa4f21d25083db27d9ae4f94d692f8ec459e725f68d45716e4454","q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685"],"scopeContentSha256":"0ae2a2c292601d0231a4e2722175c6ff721b5fb3410f42fe1af6c480f2e9ff60","contributionContentSha256":"ac8af047b92bd9524df0c81e0073d5ac49e6b8a7f0e7b51c66389df22b36fa75","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:f8632f31908aa4f21d25083db27d9ae4f94d692f8ec459e725f68d45716e4454","textSha256":"e2b7e5e912e46eba769c320791baaf544eea8de19808358a1926499c4517fccc"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3b08ea73ecd676e91b47d611","recordId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Mini-review of alternative examples; laboratory universe creation is an additional target, not an established cosmological history.","challengeNote":"Compound mini-review of alternative examples, including laboratory universe creation; no single successful construction is inferred.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:feb1d1f25d5350ff287062491bda58fed13a19172a53d0a421d4f4a6625b569f","home":{"unitId":"unit:feb1d1f25d5350ff287062491bda58fed13a19172a53d0a421d4f4a6625b569f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:80d1124cd831dc31225394f7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:feb1d1f25d5350ff287062491bda58fed13a19172a53d0a421d4f4a6625b569f","paperId":"1109.1047","textSha256":"495bc8f1ef68b2092a5d37462d27f7f98c73a56a02ea6202291bc97070492c87"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9051205e11024dfe98b43d08"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9051205e11024dfe98b43d08","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:feb1d1f25d5350ff287062491bda58fed13a19172a53d0a421d4f4a6625b569f","q025-candidate-region:80d1124cd831dc31225394f7"],"scopeContentSha256":"2785285c4a53e5790d36d03b339f0f8b55420002eed0c615b46dd57a047a4d60","placementContentSha256":"dc31e16e801980892a7fdc10d06336151ad93c53a913967eccde2d9c3fd52df5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge","leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:feb1d1f25d5350ff287062491bda58fed13a19172a53d0a421d4f4a6625b569f","paperId":"1109.1047","textSha256":"495bc8f1ef68b2092a5d37462d27f7f98c73a56a02ea6202291bc97070492c87"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9051205e11024dfe98b43d08"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:feb1d1f25d5350ff287062491bda58fed13a19172a53d0a421d4f4a6625b569f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:feb1d1f25d5350ff287062491bda58fed13a19172a53d0a421d4f4a6625b569f","textSha256":"495bc8f1ef68b2092a5d37462d27f7f98c73a56a02ea6202291bc97070492c87"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fe5c268d3d2d5a9ae657c29c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:fe5c268d3d2d5a9ae657c29c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:feb1d1f25d5350ff287062491bda58fed13a19172a53d0a421d4f4a6625b569f","q025-candidate-question:6b09bc582f83e660ae989685"],"scopeContentSha256":"0ae2a2c292601d0231a4e2722175c6ff721b5fb3410f42fe1af6c480f2e9ff60","contributionContentSha256":"4a322f8695b8abd7b1d3c7d2e060b5584b4f7f49aa88ef84d1afb2f70095384a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:feb1d1f25d5350ff287062491bda58fed13a19172a53d0a421d4f4a6625b569f","textSha256":"495bc8f1ef68b2092a5d37462d27f7f98c73a56a02ea6202291bc97070492c87"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fe5c268d3d2d5a9ae657c29c","recordId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":5,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a84de5bc54773e4599f992d07e716a50c1f4c6e820c16d250de2b3c29025ec1c"},"organizational-access:4eaefebc3ebbfb4c6e1e0f1c":{"id":"organizational-access:4eaefebc3ebbfb4c6e1e0f1c","source":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","target":"q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b6323dd1e35e5cbd54d31c70"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"2291a91ac97dbb71707d2c5077e0537d13b1a88b50dc88d7e15e74c5f07ff7a0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6e87ba1d7db71057094fed13"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:3fe4cf3e6e2eac85e76401b6dfa6b0238dacc240c69857f0b8dcde3847b47ad1","home":{"unitId":"unit:3fe4cf3e6e2eac85e76401b6dfa6b0238dacc240c69857f0b8dcde3847b47ad1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3fe4cf3e6e2eac85e76401b6dfa6b0238dacc240c69857f0b8dcde3847b47ad1","paperId":"2111.06404","textSha256":"fd6d9756e36a0aa9d9661dd21c0d4cef44c4fad05dadbb8d02beabaad46c6122"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dd95dd73a976a90d04a916d4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dd95dd73a976a90d04a916d4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3fe4cf3e6e2eac85e76401b6dfa6b0238dacc240c69857f0b8dcde3847b47ad1","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"32a49107295a93d9e8ea2ae26650aa64e6a951963d80cfc5e0523bbac5181cd5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3fe4cf3e6e2eac85e76401b6dfa6b0238dacc240c69857f0b8dcde3847b47ad1","paperId":"2111.06404","textSha256":"fd6d9756e36a0aa9d9661dd21c0d4cef44c4fad05dadbb8d02beabaad46c6122"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dd95dd73a976a90d04a916d4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3fe4cf3e6e2eac85e76401b6dfa6b0238dacc240c69857f0b8dcde3847b47ad1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:3fe4cf3e6e2eac85e76401b6dfa6b0238dacc240c69857f0b8dcde3847b47ad1","textSha256":"fd6d9756e36a0aa9d9661dd21c0d4cef44c4fad05dadbb8d02beabaad46c6122"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0c5d3deae52668b23c16effe","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: A setting-level question; no specified coupling or unique effective geometry is established. Independent challenge qualification: A setting-level question; no particular coupling or unique effective geometry is established."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0c5d3deae52668b23c16effe","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3fe4cf3e6e2eac85e76401b6dfa6b0238dacc240c69857f0b8dcde3847b47ad1","q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39"],"scopeContentSha256":"2291a91ac97dbb71707d2c5077e0537d13b1a88b50dc88d7e15e74c5f07ff7a0","contributionContentSha256":"3bf461fcfef02b22a8abb87c30cf3f638782439aeb3e1c1664d64a49b3afa0c0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:3fe4cf3e6e2eac85e76401b6dfa6b0238dacc240c69857f0b8dcde3847b47ad1","textSha256":"fd6d9756e36a0aa9d9661dd21c0d4cef44c4fad05dadbb8d02beabaad46c6122"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0c5d3deae52668b23c16effe","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"A setting-level question; no specified coupling or unique effective geometry is established.","challengeNote":"A setting-level question; no particular coupling or unique effective geometry is established.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:488091044759d2ad3a7250510b2f972f910648532c6f987cefa4155b4680a555","home":{"unitId":"unit:488091044759d2ad3a7250510b2f972f910648532c6f987cefa4155b4680a555","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:488091044759d2ad3a7250510b2f972f910648532c6f987cefa4155b4680a555","paperId":"hep-th/0112080","textSha256":"2ff30d598c1d5abbc1536e953cc9f27d3512e4491aecb50ad24ec727caaa9aa3"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:82a4d0c384f64d7f6fa304a3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:82a4d0c384f64d7f6fa304a3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:488091044759d2ad3a7250510b2f972f910648532c6f987cefa4155b4680a555","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"f3047f9032536da279962d5e7ca1b43ebc742148b958b3d188c4333a25bae876","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:488091044759d2ad3a7250510b2f972f910648532c6f987cefa4155b4680a555","paperId":"hep-th/0112080","textSha256":"2ff30d598c1d5abbc1536e953cc9f27d3512e4491aecb50ad24ec727caaa9aa3"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:82a4d0c384f64d7f6fa304a3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:488091044759d2ad3a7250510b2f972f910648532c6f987cefa4155b4680a555","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d58","kind":"description","unitIndex":58,"unitId":"unit:488091044759d2ad3a7250510b2f972f910648532c6f987cefa4155b4680a555","textSha256":"2ff30d598c1d5abbc1536e953cc9f27d3512e4491aecb50ad24ec727caaa9aa3"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:876e53103515e628d992dc99","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:876e53103515e628d992dc99","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:488091044759d2ad3a7250510b2f972f910648532c6f987cefa4155b4680a555","q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39"],"scopeContentSha256":"2291a91ac97dbb71707d2c5077e0537d13b1a88b50dc88d7e15e74c5f07ff7a0","contributionContentSha256":"0dadb90cf9bfd8ff19128bd282480701c6e5e6bb099c6ce04d4a1d935ca6f2d4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d58","kind":"description","unitIndex":58,"unitId":"unit:488091044759d2ad3a7250510b2f972f910648532c6f987cefa4155b4680a555","textSha256":"2ff30d598c1d5abbc1536e953cc9f27d3512e4491aecb50ad24ec727caaa9aa3"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:876e53103515e628d992dc99","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5bb88679c7d130d944d02d2cb6f16e0b96a18a46298e2f4a5a0f214cc39929e4","home":{"unitId":"unit:5bb88679c7d130d944d02d2cb6f16e0b96a18a46298e2f4a5a0f214cc39929e4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5bb88679c7d130d944d02d2cb6f16e0b96a18a46298e2f4a5a0f214cc39929e4","paperId":"1807.09794","textSha256":"d44638170f7c0ec56592fb5b6382371f66fdd9b343a0df3471d9bdefd537620e"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5b1ed8bc8fce455cc880ea74"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5b1ed8bc8fce455cc880ea74","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5bb88679c7d130d944d02d2cb6f16e0b96a18a46298e2f4a5a0f214cc39929e4","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"14bf852b03ad8abccb872d606e9ef5ccfcb7f088661e2b30eb095e0faed49e10","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5bb88679c7d130d944d02d2cb6f16e0b96a18a46298e2f4a5a0f214cc39929e4","paperId":"1807.09794","textSha256":"d44638170f7c0ec56592fb5b6382371f66fdd9b343a0df3471d9bdefd537620e"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5b1ed8bc8fce455cc880ea74"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5bb88679c7d130d944d02d2cb6f16e0b96a18a46298e2f4a5a0f214cc39929e4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:5bb88679c7d130d944d02d2cb6f16e0b96a18a46298e2f4a5a0f214cc39929e4","textSha256":"d44638170f7c0ec56592fb5b6382371f66fdd9b343a0df3471d9bdefd537620e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:42adb78c210495917c19e76a","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The de Sitter factor denotes one branch; anti-de Sitter branes remain an explicit alternative. Independent challenge qualification: de Sitter and anti-de Sitter branes are alternative branches."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:42adb78c210495917c19e76a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5bb88679c7d130d944d02d2cb6f16e0b96a18a46298e2f4a5a0f214cc39929e4","q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39"],"scopeContentSha256":"2291a91ac97dbb71707d2c5077e0537d13b1a88b50dc88d7e15e74c5f07ff7a0","contributionContentSha256":"a1ec9a2a28938167742977ad21406659cc1b302ba621b8c8b8e18ac0562ee987","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:5bb88679c7d130d944d02d2cb6f16e0b96a18a46298e2f4a5a0f214cc39929e4","textSha256":"d44638170f7c0ec56592fb5b6382371f66fdd9b343a0df3471d9bdefd537620e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:42adb78c210495917c19e76a","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"The de Sitter factor denotes one branch; anti-de Sitter branes remain an explicit alternative.","challengeNote":"de Sitter and anti-de Sitter branes are alternative branches.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:63fa8cfc40f53e31ba5e2a6aa44dba336e6fb668f8a9cef2cc83bb3f2d661c67","home":{"unitId":"unit:63fa8cfc40f53e31ba5e2a6aa44dba336e6fb668f8a9cef2cc83bb3f2d661c67","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:63fa8cfc40f53e31ba5e2a6aa44dba336e6fb668f8a9cef2cc83bb3f2d661c67","paperId":"2212.03881","textSha256":"1046bbb9592a9137918e0b23ffb72b6bf9cb043761b84c48cd5aa6fffa74801a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a15c1bd973e23e2d6d73ea9f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a15c1bd973e23e2d6d73ea9f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:63fa8cfc40f53e31ba5e2a6aa44dba336e6fb668f8a9cef2cc83bb3f2d661c67","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"2dca4d87bf210e046c8b96854e8e96e61506d0edbb3ecfa26aad2fc9e01a6c97","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:63fa8cfc40f53e31ba5e2a6aa44dba336e6fb668f8a9cef2cc83bb3f2d661c67","paperId":"2212.03881","textSha256":"1046bbb9592a9137918e0b23ffb72b6bf9cb043761b84c48cd5aa6fffa74801a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a15c1bd973e23e2d6d73ea9f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:63fa8cfc40f53e31ba5e2a6aa44dba336e6fb668f8a9cef2cc83bb3f2d661c67","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:63fa8cfc40f53e31ba5e2a6aa44dba336e6fb668f8a9cef2cc83bb3f2d661c67","textSha256":"1046bbb9592a9137918e0b23ffb72b6bf9cb043761b84c48cd5aa6fffa74801a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9dc0fb57b21748d4b9860d19","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Focusing is imposed only at vanishing quantum expansion; no proof of the full QFC is inferred. Independent challenge qualification: The focusing condition is restricted to vanishing quantum expansion; a proof of full QFC is not inferred."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9dc0fb57b21748d4b9860d19","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:63fa8cfc40f53e31ba5e2a6aa44dba336e6fb668f8a9cef2cc83bb3f2d661c67","q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39"],"scopeContentSha256":"2291a91ac97dbb71707d2c5077e0537d13b1a88b50dc88d7e15e74c5f07ff7a0","contributionContentSha256":"0226e3f1a1cb4862b27701792c9dcb294234f735c0b649e4a1333d2ffb3d3487","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:63fa8cfc40f53e31ba5e2a6aa44dba336e6fb668f8a9cef2cc83bb3f2d661c67","textSha256":"1046bbb9592a9137918e0b23ffb72b6bf9cb043761b84c48cd5aa6fffa74801a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9dc0fb57b21748d4b9860d19","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Focusing is imposed only at vanishing quantum expansion; no proof of the full QFC is inferred.","challengeNote":"The focusing condition is restricted to vanishing quantum expansion; a proof of full QFC is not inferred.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:834193d15fe67a1991e9303a0dc9755fdb6b4a51f237bb34c1c82f879d39112b","home":{"unitId":"unit:834193d15fe67a1991e9303a0dc9755fdb6b4a51f237bb34c1c82f879d39112b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:834193d15fe67a1991e9303a0dc9755fdb6b4a51f237bb34c1c82f879d39112b","paperId":"2103.17121","textSha256":"350f2a6729824aeb9bdde5cc87e6415dda120a11243c2013b174b0f3869e98ff"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:de617aa87114bf8ac904f005"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:de617aa87114bf8ac904f005","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:834193d15fe67a1991e9303a0dc9755fdb6b4a51f237bb34c1c82f879d39112b","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"e4d93467db02662fa0f4fdd9223a33e40e0e42419411bfd92452799c6e004eb8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:834193d15fe67a1991e9303a0dc9755fdb6b4a51f237bb34c1c82f879d39112b","paperId":"2103.17121","textSha256":"350f2a6729824aeb9bdde5cc87e6415dda120a11243c2013b174b0f3869e98ff"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:de617aa87114bf8ac904f005"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:834193d15fe67a1991e9303a0dc9755fdb6b4a51f237bb34c1c82f879d39112b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:834193d15fe67a1991e9303a0dc9755fdb6b4a51f237bb34c1c82f879d39112b","textSha256":"350f2a6729824aeb9bdde5cc87e6415dda120a11243c2013b174b0f3869e98ff"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6071ecc1985de6fe081c24af","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Proposed reflection-symmetric regulator with two interior AdS regions; no established dual is supplied. Independent challenge qualification: The reflection-symmetric regulator has two interior AdS regions; no established dual is supplied."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6071ecc1985de6fe081c24af","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:834193d15fe67a1991e9303a0dc9755fdb6b4a51f237bb34c1c82f879d39112b","q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39"],"scopeContentSha256":"2291a91ac97dbb71707d2c5077e0537d13b1a88b50dc88d7e15e74c5f07ff7a0","contributionContentSha256":"a7ccfe94f5f471f7d4556c13db63ae25771b911f3ab984a5beae4baa3c74d7bd","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:834193d15fe67a1991e9303a0dc9755fdb6b4a51f237bb34c1c82f879d39112b","textSha256":"350f2a6729824aeb9bdde5cc87e6415dda120a11243c2013b174b0f3869e98ff"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6071ecc1985de6fe081c24af","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Proposed reflection-symmetric regulator with two interior AdS regions; no established dual is supplied.","challengeNote":"The reflection-symmetric regulator has two interior AdS regions; no established dual is supplied.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:8dc0cb13c30b5081a7f91c23bd3dd2cc917eb431125161a0d80d93890f5297c0","home":{"unitId":"unit:8dc0cb13c30b5081a7f91c23bd3dd2cc917eb431125161a0d80d93890f5297c0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8dc0cb13c30b5081a7f91c23bd3dd2cc917eb431125161a0d80d93890f5297c0","paperId":"0907.3237","textSha256":"4c00386f27b08c4d93d7f23fcba3dad83c83400c22b4af75ac884bd8197c3cbb"},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:982c5e83cc63b8dba9c6abfd25bd4ec6","paperId":"0907.3237","sourceSha256":"bb5e41f710866e1bac72a3eab90020f081c6ef2403118b2fc3236d8f2726aac6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c4eef6bb5786d83d2773/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ba02fc162e384eb9c39423092b107238e082b763b6dab09ef01fa2515280103","pdfPage":5,"start":109,"end":2404,"textSha256":"17803ca5ec7da15afe105f6e166120d6fbcfb77dd7c1540d7b28d17a280cfbd4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ad797f80fa96e0007b352c1698159594","paperId":"0907.3237","sourceSha256":"bb5e41f710866e1bac72a3eab90020f081c6ef2403118b2fc3236d8f2726aac6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c4eef6bb5786d83d2773/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ba02fc162e384eb9c39423092b107238e082b763b6dab09ef01fa2515280103","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2321,"textSha256":"9b577fd3d7c4dc18123602edcde72b30c4ba07f7f94da0034a60ed02587ef75a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dd1581783ce049b2dec1d3bd2dd58f7d","paperId":"0907.3237","sourceSha256":"bb5e41f710866e1bac72a3eab90020f081c6ef2403118b2fc3236d8f2726aac6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c4eef6bb5786d83d2773/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ba02fc162e384eb9c39423092b107238e082b763b6dab09ef01fa2515280103","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2534,"textSha256":"71449e40144c98fc68e82bcb749fd3f0e003ed93f279793e2688441b385bdfb2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8d5cb1a25234e81f6d6977cb"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8d5cb1a25234e81f6d6977cb","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8dc0cb13c30b5081a7f91c23bd3dd2cc917eb431125161a0d80d93890f5297c0","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"a7095020574b7bd750d47a052147105da27a82228ce118c920cb30526b1800cd","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8dc0cb13c30b5081a7f91c23bd3dd2cc917eb431125161a0d80d93890f5297c0","paperId":"0907.3237","textSha256":"4c00386f27b08c4d93d7f23fcba3dad83c83400c22b4af75ac884bd8197c3cbb"},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:982c5e83cc63b8dba9c6abfd25bd4ec6","paperId":"0907.3237","sourceSha256":"bb5e41f710866e1bac72a3eab90020f081c6ef2403118b2fc3236d8f2726aac6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c4eef6bb5786d83d2773/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ba02fc162e384eb9c39423092b107238e082b763b6dab09ef01fa2515280103","pdfPage":5,"start":109,"end":2404,"textSha256":"17803ca5ec7da15afe105f6e166120d6fbcfb77dd7c1540d7b28d17a280cfbd4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ad797f80fa96e0007b352c1698159594","paperId":"0907.3237","sourceSha256":"bb5e41f710866e1bac72a3eab90020f081c6ef2403118b2fc3236d8f2726aac6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c4eef6bb5786d83d2773/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ba02fc162e384eb9c39423092b107238e082b763b6dab09ef01fa2515280103","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2321,"textSha256":"9b577fd3d7c4dc18123602edcde72b30c4ba07f7f94da0034a60ed02587ef75a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dd1581783ce049b2dec1d3bd2dd58f7d","paperId":"0907.3237","sourceSha256":"bb5e41f710866e1bac72a3eab90020f081c6ef2403118b2fc3236d8f2726aac6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c4eef6bb5786d83d2773/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ba02fc162e384eb9c39423092b107238e082b763b6dab09ef01fa2515280103","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2534,"textSha256":"71449e40144c98fc68e82bcb749fd3f0e003ed93f279793e2688441b385bdfb2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8d5cb1a25234e81f6d6977cb"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8dc0cb13c30b5081a7f91c23bd3dd2cc917eb431125161a0d80d93890f5297c0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:8dc0cb13c30b5081a7f91c23bd3dd2cc917eb431125161a0d80d93890f5297c0","textSha256":"4c00386f27b08c4d93d7f23fcba3dad83c83400c22b4af75ac884bd8197c3cbb"},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:982c5e83cc63b8dba9c6abfd25bd4ec6","paperId":"0907.3237","sourceSha256":"bb5e41f710866e1bac72a3eab90020f081c6ef2403118b2fc3236d8f2726aac6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c4eef6bb5786d83d2773/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ba02fc162e384eb9c39423092b107238e082b763b6dab09ef01fa2515280103","pdfPage":5,"start":109,"end":2404,"textSha256":"17803ca5ec7da15afe105f6e166120d6fbcfb77dd7c1540d7b28d17a280cfbd4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ad797f80fa96e0007b352c1698159594","paperId":"0907.3237","sourceSha256":"bb5e41f710866e1bac72a3eab90020f081c6ef2403118b2fc3236d8f2726aac6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c4eef6bb5786d83d2773/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ba02fc162e384eb9c39423092b107238e082b763b6dab09ef01fa2515280103","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2321,"textSha256":"9b577fd3d7c4dc18123602edcde72b30c4ba07f7f94da0034a60ed02587ef75a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dd1581783ce049b2dec1d3bd2dd58f7d","paperId":"0907.3237","sourceSha256":"bb5e41f710866e1bac72a3eab90020f081c6ef2403118b2fc3236d8f2726aac6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c4eef6bb5786d83d2773/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ba02fc162e384eb9c39423092b107238e082b763b6dab09ef01fa2515280103","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2534,"textSha256":"71449e40144c98fc68e82bcb749fd3f0e003ed93f279793e2688441b385bdfb2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:eba7963bb4d3bf9aaad4ad32","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Asymptotically flat (4+d)-dimensional bulk with 4D species; AdS is a saturation example, not required. Independent challenge qualification: The source asserts a strong-coupling bound for localized 4D species in an asymptotically flat bulk; an AdS near-horizon geometry is not required."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:eba7963bb4d3bf9aaad4ad32","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8dc0cb13c30b5081a7f91c23bd3dd2cc917eb431125161a0d80d93890f5297c0","q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39"],"scopeContentSha256":"2291a91ac97dbb71707d2c5077e0537d13b1a88b50dc88d7e15e74c5f07ff7a0","contributionContentSha256":"448a854e4cb9b2cfa9d336a9befa7e71d3564d18e6f70785697cd75933772afe","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:8dc0cb13c30b5081a7f91c23bd3dd2cc917eb431125161a0d80d93890f5297c0","textSha256":"4c00386f27b08c4d93d7f23fcba3dad83c83400c22b4af75ac884bd8197c3cbb"},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:982c5e83cc63b8dba9c6abfd25bd4ec6","paperId":"0907.3237","sourceSha256":"bb5e41f710866e1bac72a3eab90020f081c6ef2403118b2fc3236d8f2726aac6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c4eef6bb5786d83d2773/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ba02fc162e384eb9c39423092b107238e082b763b6dab09ef01fa2515280103","pdfPage":5,"start":109,"end":2404,"textSha256":"17803ca5ec7da15afe105f6e166120d6fbcfb77dd7c1540d7b28d17a280cfbd4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ad797f80fa96e0007b352c1698159594","paperId":"0907.3237","sourceSha256":"bb5e41f710866e1bac72a3eab90020f081c6ef2403118b2fc3236d8f2726aac6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c4eef6bb5786d83d2773/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ba02fc162e384eb9c39423092b107238e082b763b6dab09ef01fa2515280103","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2321,"textSha256":"9b577fd3d7c4dc18123602edcde72b30c4ba07f7f94da0034a60ed02587ef75a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dd1581783ce049b2dec1d3bd2dd58f7d","paperId":"0907.3237","sourceSha256":"bb5e41f710866e1bac72a3eab90020f081c6ef2403118b2fc3236d8f2726aac6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c4eef6bb5786d83d2773/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ba02fc162e384eb9c39423092b107238e082b763b6dab09ef01fa2515280103","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2534,"textSha256":"71449e40144c98fc68e82bcb749fd3f0e003ed93f279793e2688441b385bdfb2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:eba7963bb4d3bf9aaad4ad32","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Asymptotically flat (4+d)-dimensional bulk with 4D species; AdS is a saturation example, not required.","challengeNote":"The source asserts a strong-coupling bound for localized 4D species in an asymptotically flat bulk; an AdS near-horizon geometry is not required.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","home":{"unitId":"unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","paperId":"2312.12349","textSha256":"ab1e94bccc0a640f77156ec85ecbe49c8c4fe6bb26ffe45c7e6e9b44ed2bcc59"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e31b93a334d9134e894e56ea"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e31b93a334d9134e894e56ea","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"9a08e1cd11af4985b3939105ddbecaf0660e702b3dc2c470cfe1522dadf1ded9","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","paperId":"2312.12349","textSha256":"ab1e94bccc0a640f77156ec85ecbe49c8c4fe6bb26ffe45c7e6e9b44ed2bcc59"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e31b93a334d9134e894e56ea"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","textSha256":"ab1e94bccc0a640f77156ec85ecbe49c8c4fe6bb26ffe45c7e6e9b44ed2bcc59"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:788c74e41d537c9eeba705ee","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:788c74e41d537c9eeba705ee","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39"],"scopeContentSha256":"2291a91ac97dbb71707d2c5077e0537d13b1a88b50dc88d7e15e74c5f07ff7a0","contributionContentSha256":"060c88fca630713ab57a34701079b0e90fddc5e5917d920e75a121680d7e9343","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:ab6ca3bdfe5b14828e6a7d29a3eb7e7b9d37d585237a8f54e89482277614b5b2","textSha256":"ab1e94bccc0a640f77156ec85ecbe49c8c4fe6bb26ffe45c7e6e9b44ed2bcc59"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:788c74e41d537c9eeba705ee","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:bac76b4016c0bbd0a5985456193dbe18700298ff076cd75962a03bb8f037b3ac","home":{"unitId":"unit:bac76b4016c0bbd0a5985456193dbe18700298ff076cd75962a03bb8f037b3ac","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bac76b4016c0bbd0a5985456193dbe18700298ff076cd75962a03bb8f037b3ac","paperId":"2404.00763","textSha256":"7706982ef013fdcb6233ee39c243d35c34ad140925511560417403446579bda9"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5b24b800a7a83cee6b0df36d"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5b24b800a7a83cee6b0df36d","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bac76b4016c0bbd0a5985456193dbe18700298ff076cd75962a03bb8f037b3ac","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"2a8a5dc82ad87b42ad28278cc4f75a38bf8efdddc78d82208e3b886ec340090a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bac76b4016c0bbd0a5985456193dbe18700298ff076cd75962a03bb8f037b3ac","paperId":"2404.00763","textSha256":"7706982ef013fdcb6233ee39c243d35c34ad140925511560417403446579bda9"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5b24b800a7a83cee6b0df36d"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bac76b4016c0bbd0a5985456193dbe18700298ff076cd75962a03bb8f037b3ac","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:bac76b4016c0bbd0a5985456193dbe18700298ff076cd75962a03bb8f037b3ac","textSha256":"7706982ef013fdcb6233ee39c243d35c34ad140925511560417403446579bda9"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b8b6ac66ecfd6d5a9939c925","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Information-exchanging brane arrangements are construction proposals. Independent challenge qualification: Information-exchanging brane arrangements remain construction proposals."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b8b6ac66ecfd6d5a9939c925","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bac76b4016c0bbd0a5985456193dbe18700298ff076cd75962a03bb8f037b3ac","q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39"],"scopeContentSha256":"2291a91ac97dbb71707d2c5077e0537d13b1a88b50dc88d7e15e74c5f07ff7a0","contributionContentSha256":"e5abe37d904d8728d7a706b9c5dde37250dbc7a1f1778ebaef0d0006ba28ca9b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:bac76b4016c0bbd0a5985456193dbe18700298ff076cd75962a03bb8f037b3ac","textSha256":"7706982ef013fdcb6233ee39c243d35c34ad140925511560417403446579bda9"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b8b6ac66ecfd6d5a9939c925","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Information-exchanging brane arrangements are construction proposals.","challengeNote":"Information-exchanging brane arrangements remain construction proposals.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:bdf51ca695d22b33b50e6af0fec0217123da1a933a3a484d9e6f53af50d2edc7","home":{"unitId":"unit:bdf51ca695d22b33b50e6af0fec0217123da1a933a3a484d9e6f53af50d2edc7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bdf51ca695d22b33b50e6af0fec0217123da1a933a3a484d9e6f53af50d2edc7","paperId":"2309.13624","textSha256":"be44d6257593d749b3f95ba61be1fa222030cdb84ea54bc850c52c760b2d85b6"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:89b9a7fe6b1f1d5dd0db9999"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:89b9a7fe6b1f1d5dd0db9999","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bdf51ca695d22b33b50e6af0fec0217123da1a933a3a484d9e6f53af50d2edc7","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"a556d698ba0e3d4a2a074f632a204f8303771c2f30a2496c075bf36385b6290c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bdf51ca695d22b33b50e6af0fec0217123da1a933a3a484d9e6f53af50d2edc7","paperId":"2309.13624","textSha256":"be44d6257593d749b3f95ba61be1fa222030cdb84ea54bc850c52c760b2d85b6"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:89b9a7fe6b1f1d5dd0db9999"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bdf51ca695d22b33b50e6af0fec0217123da1a933a3a484d9e6f53af50d2edc7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:bdf51ca695d22b33b50e6af0fec0217123da1a933a3a484d9e6f53af50d2edc7","textSha256":"be44d6257593d749b3f95ba61be1fa222030cdb84ea54bc850c52c760b2d85b6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bad06486dc3e06daba130c91","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:bad06486dc3e06daba130c91","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bdf51ca695d22b33b50e6af0fec0217123da1a933a3a484d9e6f53af50d2edc7","q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39"],"scopeContentSha256":"2291a91ac97dbb71707d2c5077e0537d13b1a88b50dc88d7e15e74c5f07ff7a0","contributionContentSha256":"b536c65f252cfba1cb3ecd4a724a435d7c7d863c10c572aaca469ab634a31424","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:bdf51ca695d22b33b50e6af0fec0217123da1a933a3a484d9e6f53af50d2edc7","textSha256":"be44d6257593d749b3f95ba61be1fa222030cdb84ea54bc850c52c760b2d85b6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bad06486dc3e06daba130c91","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","home":{"unitId":"unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","paperId":"2307.01263","textSha256":"3388139a03fbdf7eddf84002c6ad9e84323f6b2ba15ffc20f3d324102622f245"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0d7b4813e8c364801c275b363204ac97","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":91,"end":2890,"textSha256":"c244a13a221e023193dafab11b3da512c23d99f0a989929158ec553fe7ac3589","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1df13e1dbd1cadc7e3b87c38cbad3a1b","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2008,"textSha256":"31775e93fcc92f0d2318448abe9b0adaa30b63ab8a6abdf9bdba44c7ae0f7397","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c9caecdb2024463707cede6379b65943","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":1287,"end":2890,"textSha256":"4a4f9474ae695e78143f3aee31c65e39bfac437b3918bb210e1319302c3da466","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c5572b48e4bc17b504395891"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c5572b48e4bc17b504395891","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"6beee1bf0bee9150813f2ae61a438bc8716bfbe3f657fd851e15266217c75d1d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","paperId":"2307.01263","textSha256":"3388139a03fbdf7eddf84002c6ad9e84323f6b2ba15ffc20f3d324102622f245"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0d7b4813e8c364801c275b363204ac97","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":91,"end":2890,"textSha256":"c244a13a221e023193dafab11b3da512c23d99f0a989929158ec553fe7ac3589","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1df13e1dbd1cadc7e3b87c38cbad3a1b","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2008,"textSha256":"31775e93fcc92f0d2318448abe9b0adaa30b63ab8a6abdf9bdba44c7ae0f7397","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c9caecdb2024463707cede6379b65943","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":1287,"end":2890,"textSha256":"4a4f9474ae695e78143f3aee31c65e39bfac437b3918bb210e1319302c3da466","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c5572b48e4bc17b504395891"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","textSha256":"3388139a03fbdf7eddf84002c6ad9e84323f6b2ba15ffc20f3d324102622f245"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0d7b4813e8c364801c275b363204ac97","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":91,"end":2890,"textSha256":"c244a13a221e023193dafab11b3da512c23d99f0a989929158ec553fe7ac3589","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1df13e1dbd1cadc7e3b87c38cbad3a1b","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2008,"textSha256":"31775e93fcc92f0d2318448abe9b0adaa30b63ab8a6abdf9bdba44c7ae0f7397","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c9caecdb2024463707cede6379b65943","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":1287,"end":2890,"textSha256":"4a4f9474ae695e78143f3aee31c65e39bfac437b3918bb210e1319302c3da466","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c63e69193a2727b1779e5597","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: v3, 18 Mar 2024. Tension, island/Page and complexity targets require reconciliation; abstract claims do not settle separate consistency tests. Independent challenge qualification: v3, 18 Mar 2024. Compound identity unresolved. DGP-dependent nonzero tension and Page curves without DGP are separate announced claims; complexity is another"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c63e69193a2727b1779e5597","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39"],"scopeContentSha256":"2291a91ac97dbb71707d2c5077e0537d13b1a88b50dc88d7e15e74c5f07ff7a0","contributionContentSha256":"ea03af5ef7bf1399063570e3ef191dab5605edefd09747928620b2d402347238","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:d8598a4ddff49f790c1d3a2064987184f0d47882cb2bfc32e32f8122b2953d92","textSha256":"3388139a03fbdf7eddf84002c6ad9e84323f6b2ba15ffc20f3d324102622f245"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0d7b4813e8c364801c275b363204ac97","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":91,"end":2890,"textSha256":"c244a13a221e023193dafab11b3da512c23d99f0a989929158ec553fe7ac3589","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1df13e1dbd1cadc7e3b87c38cbad3a1b","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2008,"textSha256":"31775e93fcc92f0d2318448abe9b0adaa30b63ab8a6abdf9bdba44c7ae0f7397","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c9caecdb2024463707cede6379b65943","paperId":"2307.01263","sourceSha256":"f62b3043921d046f45d1ab8646daa94136fc41adfe2ed2a1ca1ab2ad6ac143cc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/309cfbabb1b05aa3ae46/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d8b12ca5784a3fc8c122c403424bfce600a7630f1413b17e20d0104711552053","pdfPage":2,"start":1287,"end":2890,"textSha256":"4a4f9474ae695e78143f3aee31c65e39bfac437b3918bb210e1319302c3da466","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c63e69193a2727b1779e5597","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"v3, 18 Mar 2024. Tension, island/Page and complexity targets require reconciliation; abstract claims do not settle separate consistency tests.","challengeNote":"v3, 18 Mar 2024. Compound identity unresolved. DGP-dependent nonzero tension and Page curves without DGP are separate announced claims; complexity is another","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:e3a88a9420b346a55a9e9b0d0a60f6153b440a18212ffa5b088ebd4474fa0a3a","home":{"unitId":"unit:e3a88a9420b346a55a9e9b0d0a60f6153b440a18212ffa5b088ebd4474fa0a3a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e3a88a9420b346a55a9e9b0d0a60f6153b440a18212ffa5b088ebd4474fa0a3a","paperId":"1212.0561","textSha256":"1cf393b9cd48a0dcfb0ddf27047ce37e409d5c98cf65ee940ad7e160c7b830e0"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a09fb846973185eb021815a9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a09fb846973185eb021815a9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e3a88a9420b346a55a9e9b0d0a60f6153b440a18212ffa5b088ebd4474fa0a3a","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"67cee5cbdb374b63b25ead5ece39ccd1a91cfb6a019634403f040e146d675c82","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e3a88a9420b346a55a9e9b0d0a60f6153b440a18212ffa5b088ebd4474fa0a3a","paperId":"1212.0561","textSha256":"1cf393b9cd48a0dcfb0ddf27047ce37e409d5c98cf65ee940ad7e160c7b830e0"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a09fb846973185eb021815a9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e3a88a9420b346a55a9e9b0d0a60f6153b440a18212ffa5b088ebd4474fa0a3a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:e3a88a9420b346a55a9e9b0d0a60f6153b440a18212ffa5b088ebd4474fa0a3a","textSha256":"1cf393b9cd48a0dcfb0ddf27047ce37e409d5c98cf65ee940ad7e160c7b830e0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9652d7cead0f5f6da46f5050","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9652d7cead0f5f6da46f5050","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e3a88a9420b346a55a9e9b0d0a60f6153b440a18212ffa5b088ebd4474fa0a3a","q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39"],"scopeContentSha256":"2291a91ac97dbb71707d2c5077e0537d13b1a88b50dc88d7e15e74c5f07ff7a0","contributionContentSha256":"21816de627d5248274f3824ec2ab809a39115e5f1732a9c146f0046093f47bc9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:e3a88a9420b346a55a9e9b0d0a60f6153b440a18212ffa5b088ebd4474fa0a3a","textSha256":"1cf393b9cd48a0dcfb0ddf27047ce37e409d5c98cf65ee940ad7e160c7b830e0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9652d7cead0f5f6da46f5050","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f0ffd6885bc8a757f7697ce3d3d8b08f8e2ce33a5650f9c95088988ad3209c84","home":{"unitId":"unit:f0ffd6885bc8a757f7697ce3d3d8b08f8e2ce33a5650f9c95088988ad3209c84","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f0ffd6885bc8a757f7697ce3d3d8b08f8e2ce33a5650f9c95088988ad3209c84","paperId":"2201.02014","textSha256":"f9f8b99d7f0ae185d462716eeaaf485d7832184f7f64baf4887ff5cab4c8862a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:704a6a94298baceb480b3678"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:704a6a94298baceb480b3678","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f0ffd6885bc8a757f7697ce3d3d8b08f8e2ce33a5650f9c95088988ad3209c84","q025-candidate-region:8bfa13b0263b7c0e669058c4"],"scopeContentSha256":"c405bd5a0c891bc2534cac0eafb03ce9070cb1690b307d05d57c507fe5cc47b7","placementContentSha256":"9d39f913d8bbb4e37c8de9392fe2f72c6fa1f9403be308fe1e71a29ee20a72cb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f0ffd6885bc8a757f7697ce3d3d8b08f8e2ce33a5650f9c95088988ad3209c84","paperId":"2201.02014","textSha256":"f9f8b99d7f0ae185d462716eeaaf485d7832184f7f64baf4887ff5cab4c8862a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:704a6a94298baceb480b3678"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f0ffd6885bc8a757f7697ce3d3d8b08f8e2ce33a5650f9c95088988ad3209c84","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:f0ffd6885bc8a757f7697ce3d3d8b08f8e2ce33a5650f9c95088988ad3209c84","textSha256":"f9f8b99d7f0ae185d462716eeaaf485d7832184f7f64baf4887ff5cab4c8862a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ec33cebbc5a2128e84abd424","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Effective action/spectra, Weyl anomaly and entanglement first law form a compound target. Independent challenge qualification: Unresolved compound identity: effective action/spectra, Weyl anomaly and entanglement first law."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ec33cebbc5a2128e84abd424","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f0ffd6885bc8a757f7697ce3d3d8b08f8e2ce33a5650f9c95088988ad3209c84","q025-candidate-question:1bb71dc013491f452f67ad39"],"scopeContentSha256":"2291a91ac97dbb71707d2c5077e0537d13b1a88b50dc88d7e15e74c5f07ff7a0","contributionContentSha256":"159ef8c937df826f50f6e4e6d50977c8db77654b8938922b43af599f7646f9b1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:f0ffd6885bc8a757f7697ce3d3d8b08f8e2ce33a5650f9c95088988ad3209c84","textSha256":"f9f8b99d7f0ae185d462716eeaaf485d7832184f7f64baf4887ff5cab4c8862a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ec33cebbc5a2128e84abd424","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Effective action/spectra, Weyl anomaly and entanglement first law form a compound target.","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound identity: effective action/spectra, Weyl anomaly and entanglement first law.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":12,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4ec824893cfda9a5bbd9b834440f04e12c62827bca65aa4fa10498e846150506"},"organizational-access:3e80e3a8debe6c4494cd0f2c":{"id":"organizational-access:3e80e3a8debe6c4494cd0f2c","source":"q025-candidate-region:96ffdaa1cf92c95b23b2ce17","target":"q025-candidate-question:9b19a7a3ee8d1dc0a54e2c1c","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:96ffdaa1cf92c95b23b2ce17","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"b92bfafa3859ef3a0fdc7ad176c63b424f04dad11f82d8a7302ed1da81a9067c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e2f20243880bf360e57b5668"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9b19a7a3ee8d1dc0a54e2c1c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"cad90b96d30bf010d885887eb246bc3c1c797501a268af1e7d329ab587d99d6b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3428a7672d1e0c340eabd68f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:93c84a2c8c30be4d9d8fecd617e18ebb9a72c82123ed9b2db0540f291f6f93b6","home":{"unitId":"unit:93c84a2c8c30be4d9d8fecd617e18ebb9a72c82123ed9b2db0540f291f6f93b6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:96ffdaa1cf92c95b23b2ce17","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:93c84a2c8c30be4d9d8fecd617e18ebb9a72c82123ed9b2db0540f291f6f93b6","paperId":"hep-th/0403140","textSha256":"f46f93e476e24c7d190e06ca4546abbc757e22763cc1ea1681278bd01336d2e2"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:60d5d496973d8ac3b305dbf1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:60d5d496973d8ac3b305dbf1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:93c84a2c8c30be4d9d8fecd617e18ebb9a72c82123ed9b2db0540f291f6f93b6","q025-candidate-region:96ffdaa1cf92c95b23b2ce17"],"scopeContentSha256":"b92bfafa3859ef3a0fdc7ad176c63b424f04dad11f82d8a7302ed1da81a9067c","placementContentSha256":"f31641bfc388ad606cb934b44b260b7df58b9b4ada9a1b11c4b28275c863c50e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge","leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:93c84a2c8c30be4d9d8fecd617e18ebb9a72c82123ed9b2db0540f291f6f93b6","paperId":"hep-th/0403140","textSha256":"f46f93e476e24c7d190e06ca4546abbc757e22763cc1ea1681278bd01336d2e2"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:60d5d496973d8ac3b305dbf1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:93c84a2c8c30be4d9d8fecd617e18ebb9a72c82123ed9b2db0540f291f6f93b6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9b19a7a3ee8d1dc0a54e2c1c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:93c84a2c8c30be4d9d8fecd617e18ebb9a72c82123ed9b2db0540f291f6f93b6","textSha256":"f46f93e476e24c7d190e06ca4546abbc757e22763cc1ea1681278bd01336d2e2"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a82212213c5ba77ab19e3814","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Explicitly allows non-Hermitian Hamiltonians and symmetry generators mixing incoming and outgoing states. Independent challenge qualification: Explicit allowances concern non-Hermitian Hamiltonians and generators mixing incoming and outgoing states."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a82212213c5ba77ab19e3814","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:93c84a2c8c30be4d9d8fecd617e18ebb9a72c82123ed9b2db0540f291f6f93b6","q025-candidate-question:9b19a7a3ee8d1dc0a54e2c1c"],"scopeContentSha256":"cad90b96d30bf010d885887eb246bc3c1c797501a268af1e7d329ab587d99d6b","contributionContentSha256":"d4795aedbcaf91577f278092b8a096ef0dc4fb3c4a2e547133c6c4acb3cc22cd","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d45","kind":"description","unitIndex":45,"unitId":"unit:93c84a2c8c30be4d9d8fecd617e18ebb9a72c82123ed9b2db0540f291f6f93b6","textSha256":"f46f93e476e24c7d190e06ca4546abbc757e22763cc1ea1681278bd01336d2e2"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a82212213c5ba77ab19e3814","recordId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Explicitly allows non-Hermitian Hamiltonians and symmetry generators mixing incoming and outgoing states.","challengeNote":"Explicit allowances concern non-Hermitian Hamiltonians and generators mixing incoming and outgoing states.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ff80f9555e06399fbc03793eef4ff4a7e2040487f5cff0b64a8ed8a410bf2521","home":{"unitId":"unit:ff80f9555e06399fbc03793eef4ff4a7e2040487f5cff0b64a8ed8a410bf2521","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:96ffdaa1cf92c95b23b2ce17","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ff80f9555e06399fbc03793eef4ff4a7e2040487f5cff0b64a8ed8a410bf2521","paperId":"2201.08824","textSha256":"105953a41e5057d424fa4fe2a9ae522abfeb4abb042d5565688ace24e244afc7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:df77efd58c05c3e6777faffc"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:df77efd58c05c3e6777faffc","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ff80f9555e06399fbc03793eef4ff4a7e2040487f5cff0b64a8ed8a410bf2521","q025-candidate-region:96ffdaa1cf92c95b23b2ce17"],"scopeContentSha256":"b92bfafa3859ef3a0fdc7ad176c63b424f04dad11f82d8a7302ed1da81a9067c","placementContentSha256":"506d330270abb72c8fff5862b17eacdcbfcaf3468a2179d1591e2cc42faad2d2","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge","leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ff80f9555e06399fbc03793eef4ff4a7e2040487f5cff0b64a8ed8a410bf2521","paperId":"2201.08824","textSha256":"105953a41e5057d424fa4fe2a9ae522abfeb4abb042d5565688ace24e244afc7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:df77efd58c05c3e6777faffc"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ff80f9555e06399fbc03793eef4ff4a7e2040487f5cff0b64a8ed8a410bf2521","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9b19a7a3ee8d1dc0a54e2c1c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:ff80f9555e06399fbc03793eef4ff4a7e2040487f5cff0b64a8ed8a410bf2521","textSha256":"105953a41e5057d424fa4fe2a9ae522abfeb4abb042d5565688ace24e244afc7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3012416b1b1bb66b46f90fc1","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3012416b1b1bb66b46f90fc1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ff80f9555e06399fbc03793eef4ff4a7e2040487f5cff0b64a8ed8a410bf2521","q025-candidate-question:9b19a7a3ee8d1dc0a54e2c1c"],"scopeContentSha256":"cad90b96d30bf010d885887eb246bc3c1c797501a268af1e7d329ab587d99d6b","contributionContentSha256":"106e7131e9c799bb591e13ae269cd56c593e3a9324d490ed96a13e0f67c59f33","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:ff80f9555e06399fbc03793eef4ff4a7e2040487f5cff0b64a8ed8a410bf2521","textSha256":"105953a41e5057d424fa4fe2a9ae522abfeb4abb042d5565688ace24e244afc7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3012416b1b1bb66b46f90fc1","recordId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"72302d4f2ea34f880d524fa745577ef96592385f9ca9e9dea224570036b31777"},"organizational-access:c191c8396254ca3d73bef448":{"id":"organizational-access:c191c8396254ca3d73bef448","source":"q025-candidate-region:97d4fc17e8f5a2bdf5f65db6","target":"q025-candidate-question:22a0f8ab2885bb6b4d072cba","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:97d4fc17e8f5a2bdf5f65db6","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"82b4c3b416e0c551036f76765715df85fd745ebcfc6941c89f53181a9ab0533e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e77cad5ed878f0a11e1495fa"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:22a0f8ab2885bb6b4d072cba","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"06b56611e60ca2856432c62da65026e30f93cedd900e4aaf1dc19541134e0263","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e917dfa7638cf6c5402bb072"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1bc9fbdd6744794fc9eb35ffa878b250c3e7497de96f66d765c523bc004826d2","home":{"unitId":"unit:1bc9fbdd6744794fc9eb35ffa878b250c3e7497de96f66d765c523bc004826d2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:97d4fc17e8f5a2bdf5f65db6","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Combines the geometric-universality and model-relationship direction with source-dated observational constraints and limits on attractor models.","qualification":"q32 combines the physical relationships underlying attractor predictions with their source-dated observational constraints and possible extensions. q4 does not cover the full historical mechanism comparison, while q12 does not cover the full observational programme.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1bc9fbdd6744794fc9eb35ffa878b250c3e7497de96f66d765c523bc004826d2","paperId":"2509.01675","textSha256":"dd9f73d6f3bd5b843ddd5217f3094af74f58394cd8c9f2b23cfc3e20b2515901"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0073:u9:q32"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0073:u9:q32","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1bc9fbdd6744794fc9eb35ffa878b250c3e7497de96f66d765c523bc004826d2","q025-candidate-region:97d4fc17e8f5a2bdf5f65db6"],"scopeContentSha256":"82b4c3b416e0c551036f76765715df85fd745ebcfc6941c89f53181a9ab0533e","placementContentSha256":"f02050e63476b4e648e639f7153077fcb7b65cb01ea75a359f0fe0ede3c2023c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0073:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0073:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-05"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1bc9fbdd6744794fc9eb35ffa878b250c3e7497de96f66d765c523bc004826d2","paperId":"2509.01675","textSha256":"dd9f73d6f3bd5b843ddd5217f3094af74f58394cd8c9f2b23cfc3e20b2515901"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-05/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"6079f3dff4de3bce86aff04cfa91b1a0da7ebf86722c5c33e44b4f563ac45e8e"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-05/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"b73dfbc8974cebd1c5c02da428f1652a9b6f36d6a1073a93ae692399858c7d3e","bytes":1594204,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0073","unitRef":"u9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1bc9fbdd6744794fc9eb35ffa878b250c3e7497de96f66d765c523bc004826d2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:22a0f8ab2885bb6b4d072cba","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:1bc9fbdd6744794fc9eb35ffa878b250c3e7497de96f66d765c523bc004826d2","textSha256":"dd9f73d6f3bd5b843ddd5217f3094af74f58394cd8c9f2b23cfc3e20b2515901"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:71ef2cf7060c19281d1ded0043b40c78","paperId":"2509.01675","sourceSha256":"d80e523288f9bd79a24ce9fe88822d1ce2d4aa91f5a6d7f20473317444eff53f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7003495dc9ab25f0d036/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1634cabedaeef7f8d3cecef7a540956814e48a819d26582fcb4a4ac11019a0c2","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":602,"textSha256":"d6af8add5ccbb27ff1795a60701397e5ad76f6e8fdcb83579758e2a5e259915a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:905d96e18ff21516341c0a5da96f4cb4","paperId":"2509.01675","sourceSha256":"d80e523288f9bd79a24ce9fe88822d1ce2d4aa91f5a6d7f20473317444eff53f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7003495dc9ab25f0d036/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1634cabedaeef7f8d3cecef7a540956814e48a819d26582fcb4a4ac11019a0c2","pdfPage":14,"start":1294,"end":3082,"textSha256":"63432e98d089c72fe91b4bc3a3d722c78d9ba3b077277e7a55b7ecf5db9749f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dda874154174eb090efd1e5df40aafd0","paperId":"2509.01675","sourceSha256":"d80e523288f9bd79a24ce9fe88822d1ce2d4aa91f5a6d7f20473317444eff53f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7003495dc9ab25f0d036/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1634cabedaeef7f8d3cecef7a540956814e48a819d26582fcb4a4ac11019a0c2","pdfPage":4,"start":97,"end":2522,"textSha256":"5dcd032c73855bb04d5f8162f942afb1746664bb0be3dd3287bf3ae8f8f8406e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:529fa3886eb1c97ad73c73c3"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:529fa3886eb1c97ad73c73c3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1bc9fbdd6744794fc9eb35ffa878b250c3e7497de96f66d765c523bc004826d2","q025-candidate-question:22a0f8ab2885bb6b4d072cba"],"scopeContentSha256":"06b56611e60ca2856432c62da65026e30f93cedd900e4aaf1dc19541134e0263","contributionContentSha256":"9d3ecb955dd046d5dc4063548708e8c424dbe96c0201bcd89fe07a64dbbbae7f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1af99ca66bfed8e0bf6f-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1af99ca66bfed8e0bf6f-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1af99ca66bfed8e0bf6f-proposal","leaf-1af99ca66bfed8e0bf6f-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:1bc9fbdd6744794fc9eb35ffa878b250c3e7497de96f66d765c523bc004826d2","textSha256":"dd9f73d6f3bd5b843ddd5217f3094af74f58394cd8c9f2b23cfc3e20b2515901"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:71ef2cf7060c19281d1ded0043b40c78","paperId":"2509.01675","sourceSha256":"d80e523288f9bd79a24ce9fe88822d1ce2d4aa91f5a6d7f20473317444eff53f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7003495dc9ab25f0d036/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1634cabedaeef7f8d3cecef7a540956814e48a819d26582fcb4a4ac11019a0c2","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":602,"textSha256":"d6af8add5ccbb27ff1795a60701397e5ad76f6e8fdcb83579758e2a5e259915a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:905d96e18ff21516341c0a5da96f4cb4","paperId":"2509.01675","sourceSha256":"d80e523288f9bd79a24ce9fe88822d1ce2d4aa91f5a6d7f20473317444eff53f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7003495dc9ab25f0d036/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1634cabedaeef7f8d3cecef7a540956814e48a819d26582fcb4a4ac11019a0c2","pdfPage":14,"start":1294,"end":3082,"textSha256":"63432e98d089c72fe91b4bc3a3d722c78d9ba3b077277e7a55b7ecf5db9749f4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dda874154174eb090efd1e5df40aafd0","paperId":"2509.01675","sourceSha256":"d80e523288f9bd79a24ce9fe88822d1ce2d4aa91f5a6d7f20473317444eff53f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7003495dc9ab25f0d036/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1634cabedaeef7f8d3cecef7a540956814e48a819d26582fcb4a4ac11019a0c2","pdfPage":4,"start":97,"end":2522,"textSha256":"5dcd032c73855bb04d5f8162f942afb1746664bb0be3dd3287bf3ae8f8f8406e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:529fa3886eb1c97ad73c73c3","recordId":"leaf-1af99ca66bfed8e0bf6f-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1af99ca66bfed8e0bf6f-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1af99ca66bfed8e0bf6f-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Historical relationships and 2025 viability are compound targets; the excerpts do not resolve one atomic fine identity.","challengeNote":"Historical relationships and conditional 2025 viability are compound targets without a resolved atomic identity.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"59417df7c23875a86011778aadd3e1a813783c0b22ab10787184884cd43d1178"},"organizational-access:6da0be5df50b4611c503fae2":{"id":"organizational-access:6da0be5df50b4611c503fae2","source":"q025-candidate-region:a7dd484446128212c3fcdbf3","target":"q025-candidate-question:dadad20a395bace49ff00729","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:a7dd484446128212c3fcdbf3","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"e3ad4bc849b8d8010eb13481ab9e5221362ba04c3b7b21353e08bdbc7602ddec","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:355e85bcd0656da8d3befb38"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:dadad20a395bace49ff00729","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"d98d92448071fc0274087e277c0080a725eca81ab6e7d3340a9173afde27b09b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1c1d03d3fb1eb3049d6c8bea"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:31c277acd5d409ad9838661789d63efb4c38e6056b82be5e3ed050f39d4d391d","home":{"unitId":"unit:31c277acd5d409ad9838661789d63efb4c38e6056b82be5e3ed050f39d4d391d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a7dd484446128212c3fcdbf3","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:31c277acd5d409ad9838661789d63efb4c38e6056b82be5e3ed050f39d4d391d","paperId":"gr-qc/0612068","textSha256":"4281109b8c131b7901226661489b6e961645ee9b1f090494861929342a4d957a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ca2c0e925e70127565f12560"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ca2c0e925e70127565f12560","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:31c277acd5d409ad9838661789d63efb4c38e6056b82be5e3ed050f39d4d391d","q025-candidate-region:a7dd484446128212c3fcdbf3"],"scopeContentSha256":"e3ad4bc849b8d8010eb13481ab9e5221362ba04c3b7b21353e08bdbc7602ddec","placementContentSha256":"03d2b1d8a4b0a0afd1d353bab89d2716e0c990177eae67b1947d8ac4e6372f96","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-challenge","leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:31c277acd5d409ad9838661789d63efb4c38e6056b82be5e3ed050f39d4d391d","paperId":"gr-qc/0612068","textSha256":"4281109b8c131b7901226661489b6e961645ee9b1f090494861929342a4d957a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ca2c0e925e70127565f12560"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:31c277acd5d409ad9838661789d63efb4c38e6056b82be5e3ed050f39d4d391d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:dadad20a395bace49ff00729","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:31c277acd5d409ad9838661789d63efb4c38e6056b82be5e3ed050f39d4d391d","textSha256":"4281109b8c131b7901226661489b6e961645ee9b1f090494861929342a4d957a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b89bf15892427e8eb335668f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b89bf15892427e8eb335668f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:31c277acd5d409ad9838661789d63efb4c38e6056b82be5e3ed050f39d4d391d","q025-candidate-question:dadad20a395bace49ff00729"],"scopeContentSha256":"d98d92448071fc0274087e277c0080a725eca81ab6e7d3340a9173afde27b09b","contributionContentSha256":"aa16da8cc39e93b6d542303469065d90bd1d92f8741019f8bd92c50e8e0fe0fb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-proposal","leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:31c277acd5d409ad9838661789d63efb4c38e6056b82be5e3ed050f39d4d391d","textSha256":"4281109b8c131b7901226661489b6e961645ee9b1f090494861929342a4d957a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b89bf15892427e8eb335668f","recordId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Vacuum-energy screening and conformal CMB signatures are distinct compound targets.","challengeNote":"Vacuum screening and conformal CMB signatures require separate fine reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:40e45999b6ba4f2ca81cb93d78ba2fede79246b2478d23158487384b9e01bf6e","home":{"unitId":"unit:40e45999b6ba4f2ca81cb93d78ba2fede79246b2478d23158487384b9e01bf6e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a7dd484446128212c3fcdbf3","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:40e45999b6ba4f2ca81cb93d78ba2fede79246b2478d23158487384b9e01bf6e","paperId":"1908.02534","textSha256":"024a274255672313bb5ecf50c4166f9201d3adc6b061a4ce803a2f0c00906b58"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cf0d7140d6070ef2d5f683c2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cf0d7140d6070ef2d5f683c2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:40e45999b6ba4f2ca81cb93d78ba2fede79246b2478d23158487384b9e01bf6e","q025-candidate-region:a7dd484446128212c3fcdbf3"],"scopeContentSha256":"e3ad4bc849b8d8010eb13481ab9e5221362ba04c3b7b21353e08bdbc7602ddec","placementContentSha256":"e4408e83f252da9db0006f6779cba41d146f3ba7cf6b3aad885b19ba90b249d5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-challenge","leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:40e45999b6ba4f2ca81cb93d78ba2fede79246b2478d23158487384b9e01bf6e","paperId":"1908.02534","textSha256":"024a274255672313bb5ecf50c4166f9201d3adc6b061a4ce803a2f0c00906b58"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cf0d7140d6070ef2d5f683c2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:40e45999b6ba4f2ca81cb93d78ba2fede79246b2478d23158487384b9e01bf6e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:dadad20a395bace49ff00729","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:40e45999b6ba4f2ca81cb93d78ba2fede79246b2478d23158487384b9e01bf6e","textSha256":"024a274255672313bb5ecf50c4166f9201d3adc6b061a4ce803a2f0c00906b58"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3bc4e0d56e9498979af0d239"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3bc4e0d56e9498979af0d239","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:40e45999b6ba4f2ca81cb93d78ba2fede79246b2478d23158487384b9e01bf6e","q025-candidate-question:dadad20a395bace49ff00729"],"scopeContentSha256":"d98d92448071fc0274087e277c0080a725eca81ab6e7d3340a9173afde27b09b","contributionContentSha256":"a35c0b84ab46259a15d2f730f1526fb0a56a9e7d7c433337fb231e148119360f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-proposal","leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:40e45999b6ba4f2ca81cb93d78ba2fede79246b2478d23158487384b9e01bf6e","textSha256":"024a274255672313bb5ecf50c4166f9201d3adc6b061a4ce803a2f0c00906b58"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3bc4e0d56e9498979af0d239","recordId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1edac96cec3f11fd7806-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Four-dimensional Einstein gravity; screening, entropy growth and an effective inflation/quintessence description remain distinct compound targets.","challengeNote":"Four-dimensional Einstein gravity; screening, entropy growth and effective inflation/quintessence descriptions are compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"aaaf3746b8e436346dcf973f6d365ace55bb7a17977f4a90dca15889d9ec1549"},"organizational-access:26fd9c7ca2b21da66fba6507":{"id":"organizational-access:26fd9c7ca2b21da66fba6507","source":"q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f","target":"q025-candidate-question:7a2ad3b50133f27f3045da25","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"e2945db24f65f674ea8605b609c51dd9fe5073bd21e154a24a61eea305a587d0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:69a6cdf6a19cdd69ea9874a3"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:7a2ad3b50133f27f3045da25","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"3a9fa961b42f69c736ea366f4d242e5e7689f108bdef630acb9d16268ce9f4e7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:9d5d71a550291dc7ef3df947"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1928a8fd4c4cd67d8c272d27207c31db578aef9d73fe5c70beca7751221ffd91","home":{"unitId":"unit:1928a8fd4c4cd67d8c272d27207c31db578aef9d73fe5c70beca7751221ffd91","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers higher-derivative corrections in heterotic M-theory and their combined geometric, soft-term and vacuum consequences.","qualification":"q30 covers heterotic M-theory higher-derivative corrections and their combined effects on geometry, effective potentials, soft terms and vacua. q26 and q12 respectively cover geometric and downstream aspects without individually covering the complete four-target question.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1928a8fd4c4cd67d8c272d27207c31db578aef9d73fe5c70beca7751221ffd91","paperId":"hep-th/0506191","textSha256":"1c12f52c1e1f9e2535e760526f5b99fc82377bdf3622e266b025c98a03cd54ab"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0049:u30:q30"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0049:u30:q30","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1928a8fd4c4cd67d8c272d27207c31db578aef9d73fe5c70beca7751221ffd91","q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e2945db24f65f674ea8605b609c51dd9fe5073bd21e154a24a61eea305a587d0","placementContentSha256":"8ee30dff59530cbf0fcfe537840858adc74d35d0d28aa738b806961f0f212082","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0049:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0049:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1928a8fd4c4cd67d8c272d27207c31db578aef9d73fe5c70beca7751221ffd91","paperId":"hep-th/0506191","textSha256":"1c12f52c1e1f9e2535e760526f5b99fc82377bdf3622e266b025c98a03cd54ab"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0049","unitRef":"u30"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1928a8fd4c4cd67d8c272d27207c31db578aef9d73fe5c70beca7751221ffd91","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7a2ad3b50133f27f3045da25","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:1928a8fd4c4cd67d8c272d27207c31db578aef9d73fe5c70beca7751221ffd91","textSha256":"1c12f52c1e1f9e2535e760526f5b99fc82377bdf3622e266b025c98a03cd54ab"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5356a117569635bf87fd3a10"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5356a117569635bf87fd3a10","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1928a8fd4c4cd67d8c272d27207c31db578aef9d73fe5c70beca7751221ffd91","q025-candidate-question:7a2ad3b50133f27f3045da25"],"scopeContentSha256":"3a9fa961b42f69c736ea366f4d242e5e7689f108bdef630acb9d16268ce9f4e7","contributionContentSha256":"efa5402e4e5c885b1839a11d5c77aac9f2dd1683e785b3b8611f777cd195e92a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:1928a8fd4c4cd67d8c272d27207c31db578aef9d73fe5c70beca7751221ffd91","textSha256":"1c12f52c1e1f9e2535e760526f5b99fc82377bdf3622e266b025c98a03cd54ab"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5356a117569635bf87fd3a10","recordId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound identity: Kähler geometry, warped background, soft terms and effects on previously proposed de Sitter vacua.","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound identity: corrected Kähler geometry, warped background, soft terms and effects on previously proposed de Sitter vacua.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:2c2f9bbf1d6521a0e9eaa4058ce65013ebec33f04c693ba881240f2800595e22","home":{"unitId":"unit:2c2f9bbf1d6521a0e9eaa4058ce65013ebec33f04c693ba881240f2800595e22","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2c2f9bbf1d6521a0e9eaa4058ce65013ebec33f04c693ba881240f2800595e22","paperId":"hep-th/0408054","textSha256":"92719bb2bba689f8105a9b44bc8ec315e7245aa41d1ceac45c43dab65bb24ebe"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c4e28008a102969e2be4122599fbbef3","paperId":"hep-th/0408054","sourceSha256":"5e69e99bee88cf30addd9c930cba862619c7e31cf9d27f7946304c51709cf8c6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55c17f4c95a6ae7aee2c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87960d0c7b6bbdf4c7c6d7b8dd83170326ef56055e4b37e6cebb1a108f0a9153","pdfPage":2,"start":1294,"end":3169,"textSha256":"13026d27a038509ce403fc688ee3ae9cdf95b7f712db42863c86a4503450cd2f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eca0f7222234d59922900481436d4ef3","paperId":"hep-th/0408054","sourceSha256":"5e69e99bee88cf30addd9c930cba862619c7e31cf9d27f7946304c51709cf8c6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55c17f4c95a6ae7aee2c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87960d0c7b6bbdf4c7c6d7b8dd83170326ef56055e4b37e6cebb1a108f0a9153","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1170,"textSha256":"bc6c1bb54fde408e622ae0fcdfd589381fd7763a2f8a0b2b0f4937973b4904e0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4decec5a8f01285ea47b3608"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4decec5a8f01285ea47b3608","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2c2f9bbf1d6521a0e9eaa4058ce65013ebec33f04c693ba881240f2800595e22","q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e2945db24f65f674ea8605b609c51dd9fe5073bd21e154a24a61eea305a587d0","placementContentSha256":"1b0ff891bd3fc05830787520b66f8924498c79dff1f2fe677fed73bc7eb69316","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge","leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2c2f9bbf1d6521a0e9eaa4058ce65013ebec33f04c693ba881240f2800595e22","paperId":"hep-th/0408054","textSha256":"92719bb2bba689f8105a9b44bc8ec315e7245aa41d1ceac45c43dab65bb24ebe"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c4e28008a102969e2be4122599fbbef3","paperId":"hep-th/0408054","sourceSha256":"5e69e99bee88cf30addd9c930cba862619c7e31cf9d27f7946304c51709cf8c6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55c17f4c95a6ae7aee2c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87960d0c7b6bbdf4c7c6d7b8dd83170326ef56055e4b37e6cebb1a108f0a9153","pdfPage":2,"start":1294,"end":3169,"textSha256":"13026d27a038509ce403fc688ee3ae9cdf95b7f712db42863c86a4503450cd2f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eca0f7222234d59922900481436d4ef3","paperId":"hep-th/0408054","sourceSha256":"5e69e99bee88cf30addd9c930cba862619c7e31cf9d27f7946304c51709cf8c6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55c17f4c95a6ae7aee2c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87960d0c7b6bbdf4c7c6d7b8dd83170326ef56055e4b37e6cebb1a108f0a9153","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1170,"textSha256":"bc6c1bb54fde408e622ae0fcdfd589381fd7763a2f8a0b2b0f4937973b4904e0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4decec5a8f01285ea47b3608"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2c2f9bbf1d6521a0e9eaa4058ce65013ebec33f04c693ba881240f2800595e22","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7a2ad3b50133f27f3045da25","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:2c2f9bbf1d6521a0e9eaa4058ce65013ebec33f04c693ba881240f2800595e22","textSha256":"92719bb2bba689f8105a9b44bc8ec315e7245aa41d1ceac45c43dab65bb24ebe"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c4e28008a102969e2be4122599fbbef3","paperId":"hep-th/0408054","sourceSha256":"5e69e99bee88cf30addd9c930cba862619c7e31cf9d27f7946304c51709cf8c6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55c17f4c95a6ae7aee2c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87960d0c7b6bbdf4c7c6d7b8dd83170326ef56055e4b37e6cebb1a108f0a9153","pdfPage":2,"start":1294,"end":3169,"textSha256":"13026d27a038509ce403fc688ee3ae9cdf95b7f712db42863c86a4503450cd2f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eca0f7222234d59922900481436d4ef3","paperId":"hep-th/0408054","sourceSha256":"5e69e99bee88cf30addd9c930cba862619c7e31cf9d27f7946304c51709cf8c6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55c17f4c95a6ae7aee2c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87960d0c7b6bbdf4c7c6d7b8dd83170326ef56055e4b37e6cebb1a108f0a9153","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1170,"textSha256":"bc6c1bb54fde408e622ae0fcdfd589381fd7763a2f8a0b2b0f4937973b4904e0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e36d08fc1119a0efdd647967"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e36d08fc1119a0efdd647967","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2c2f9bbf1d6521a0e9eaa4058ce65013ebec33f04c693ba881240f2800595e22","q025-candidate-question:7a2ad3b50133f27f3045da25"],"scopeContentSha256":"3a9fa961b42f69c736ea366f4d242e5e7689f108bdef630acb9d16268ce9f4e7","contributionContentSha256":"dfb5adf5d4676607f528a30cecd7f997d2a61184acfb0249445eb60b1fce5439","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:2c2f9bbf1d6521a0e9eaa4058ce65013ebec33f04c693ba881240f2800595e22","textSha256":"92719bb2bba689f8105a9b44bc8ec315e7245aa41d1ceac45c43dab65bb24ebe"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c4e28008a102969e2be4122599fbbef3","paperId":"hep-th/0408054","sourceSha256":"5e69e99bee88cf30addd9c930cba862619c7e31cf9d27f7946304c51709cf8c6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55c17f4c95a6ae7aee2c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87960d0c7b6bbdf4c7c6d7b8dd83170326ef56055e4b37e6cebb1a108f0a9153","pdfPage":2,"start":1294,"end":3169,"textSha256":"13026d27a038509ce403fc688ee3ae9cdf95b7f712db42863c86a4503450cd2f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eca0f7222234d59922900481436d4ef3","paperId":"hep-th/0408054","sourceSha256":"5e69e99bee88cf30addd9c930cba862619c7e31cf9d27f7946304c51709cf8c6","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55c17f4c95a6ae7aee2c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"87960d0c7b6bbdf4c7c6d7b8dd83170326ef56055e4b37e6cebb1a108f0a9153","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1170,"textSha256":"bc6c1bb54fde408e622ae0fcdfd589381fd7763a2f8a0b2b0f4937973b4904e0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e36d08fc1119a0efdd647967","recordId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound identity: corrected vacuum structure and a radiative cosmological-constant hierarchy. The latter is conditional in the archived 2005v3 text.","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound identity: corrected vacuum structure and radiative vacuum-energy hierarchy. The latter is conditional on the vacuum and supersymmetry-break","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:cad8603be5dc26b86428a24c17a30b0a35a404e30be6e35d7be29c58f009e164","home":{"unitId":"unit:cad8603be5dc26b86428a24c17a30b0a35a404e30be6e35d7be29c58f009e164","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cad8603be5dc26b86428a24c17a30b0a35a404e30be6e35d7be29c58f009e164","paperId":"1003.0388","textSha256":"4dd13ad0c748febee0ca1472bdefdbf975f2e4a3c485f9e89c471709e50bfcf7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9d52b6bbccf73934a1c46a03"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9d52b6bbccf73934a1c46a03","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cad8603be5dc26b86428a24c17a30b0a35a404e30be6e35d7be29c58f009e164","q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e2945db24f65f674ea8605b609c51dd9fe5073bd21e154a24a61eea305a587d0","placementContentSha256":"25f9fc47bf64ef03f474106eb82b525f08c1856d68effb64a45161dd97140d42","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge","leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cad8603be5dc26b86428a24c17a30b0a35a404e30be6e35d7be29c58f009e164","paperId":"1003.0388","textSha256":"4dd13ad0c748febee0ca1472bdefdbf975f2e4a3c485f9e89c471709e50bfcf7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9d52b6bbccf73934a1c46a03"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cad8603be5dc26b86428a24c17a30b0a35a404e30be6e35d7be29c58f009e164","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7a2ad3b50133f27f3045da25","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:cad8603be5dc26b86428a24c17a30b0a35a404e30be6e35d7be29c58f009e164","textSha256":"4dd13ad0c748febee0ca1472bdefdbf975f2e4a3c485f9e89c471709e50bfcf7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:260b1f09c2b9a60e2bbc3ddf"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:260b1f09c2b9a60e2bbc3ddf","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cad8603be5dc26b86428a24c17a30b0a35a404e30be6e35d7be29c58f009e164","q025-candidate-question:7a2ad3b50133f27f3045da25"],"scopeContentSha256":"3a9fa961b42f69c736ea366f4d242e5e7689f108bdef630acb9d16268ce9f4e7","contributionContentSha256":"66aafdd348ab471665be3fabba976ce7dfccc168f6ef97ab6ea94dbf7fdea460","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:cad8603be5dc26b86428a24c17a30b0a35a404e30be6e35d7be29c58f009e164","textSha256":"4dd13ad0c748febee0ca1472bdefdbf975f2e4a3c485f9e89c471709e50bfcf7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:260b1f09c2b9a60e2bbc3ddf","recordId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Possible redefinition is conditional. Compound applications include stabilization, supersymmetry breaking and soft terms.","challengeNote":"The redefinition is possible, not established universally. Stabilization, supersymmetry breaking and soft terms remain compound applications.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","home":{"unitId":"unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","paperId":"0704.0737","textSha256":"e16a39b8987bb3989d40985b56d0180f777dfab354985e26efef19722db78dbc"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8a0961060492a635994b3b61"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8a0961060492a635994b3b61","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","q025-candidate-region:a8ceefd32f840db53e3a843f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e2945db24f65f674ea8605b609c51dd9fe5073bd21e154a24a61eea305a587d0","placementContentSha256":"6237cd427037cf1d9c8deb65a7c86fef8300cd049f63f040477a6036db708109","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge","leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","paperId":"0704.0737","textSha256":"e16a39b8987bb3989d40985b56d0180f777dfab354985e26efef19722db78dbc"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8a0961060492a635994b3b61"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7a2ad3b50133f27f3045da25","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","textSha256":"e16a39b8987bb3989d40985b56d0180f777dfab354985e26efef19722db78dbc"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b16ca3a4db77eba19bb6b1fa"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b16ca3a4db77eba19bb6b1fa","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","q025-candidate-question:7a2ad3b50133f27f3045da25"],"scopeContentSha256":"3a9fa961b42f69c736ea366f4d242e5e7689f108bdef630acb9d16268ce9f4e7","contributionContentSha256":"a7207e8c9cba203960a619482e4c90731762a7f9b53d123801806b98630d2eee","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:ed3ffa75661d34686007069b39cb898b31bf640adad48eede97e17c0f48c000b","textSha256":"e16a39b8987bb3989d40985b56d0180f777dfab354985e26efef19722db78dbc"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b16ca3a4db77eba19bb6b1fa","recordId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-628d4cf06b5d1f3ad38b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The large-volume vacuum is assumed; stabilization compatibility and soft breaking are linked subtargets.","challengeNote":"The vacuum is assumed. Stabilization compatibility and soft supersymmetry breaking are compound subtargets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":4,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ebf02426fff3b780ac1e923cfc0d7ac363807a73b95f91a3701fc1fc0733b4db"},"organizational-access:709da8dc28ad04161048cd0d":{"id":"organizational-access:709da8dc28ad04161048cd0d","source":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","target":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8ac1c5bf56b05064635db5ff"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"17b23896f033122b211a50ba05a1ebc085f18313a14253c55e252acf4c19192d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c3f798add8babb51f45edf05"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","home":{"unitId":"unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","paperId":"1003.2850","textSha256":"4ff0fecf9893cc6507f54a1df78681543c70297c0ae2e4976e0cc797a0603a7d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ce5e10316100fc52869d1fab"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ce5e10316100fc52869d1fab","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"f5516dddcbcb8ec9fee165018c02d54c88ca00e76f96b024ddfc2780c90437b0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","paperId":"1003.2850","textSha256":"4ff0fecf9893cc6507f54a1df78681543c70297c0ae2e4976e0cc797a0603a7d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ce5e10316100fc52869d1fab"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","textSha256":"4ff0fecf9893cc6507f54a1df78681543c70297c0ae2e4976e0cc797a0603a7d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e7d0e4011860ef65f75aec55","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound: entropy versus species, Einstein minimality at fixed mass and an analogous AdS black-brane density question; weak coupling and unitarity are assumed. Independent challenge qualification: Species bounds, fixed-mass Einstein minimality and AdS black-brane entropy density remain distinct targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e7d0e4011860ef65f75aec55","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb"],"scopeContentSha256":"17b23896f033122b211a50ba05a1ebc085f18313a14253c55e252acf4c19192d","contributionContentSha256":"1745cef37fc99a5db19bb12869e38b998a22ec14f8d615293c7323618f588900","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","textSha256":"4ff0fecf9893cc6507f54a1df78681543c70297c0ae2e4976e0cc797a0603a7d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e7d0e4011860ef65f75aec55","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound: entropy versus species, Einstein minimality at fixed mass and an analogous AdS black-brane density question; weak coupling and unitarity are assumed.","challengeNote":"Species bounds, fixed-mass Einstein minimality and AdS black-brane entropy density remain distinct targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","home":{"unitId":"unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","paperId":"2506.04905","textSha256":"d2032c576bc9949ceacd04ff5b2afb6189d756f7fd80c9cb0f3b085c44dce4f4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ec5628cb4c4baa76d2403f97"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ec5628cb4c4baa76d2403f97","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"98db3376466cdc21fb9ff18e3b8271ac2ebc622a8152eee9e5d16ff7b676f581","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","paperId":"2506.04905","textSha256":"d2032c576bc9949ceacd04ff5b2afb6189d756f7fd80c9cb0f3b085c44dce4f4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ec5628cb4c4baa76d2403f97"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d61","kind":"description","unitIndex":61,"unitId":"unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","textSha256":"d2032c576bc9949ceacd04ff5b2afb6189d756f7fd80c9cb0f3b085c44dce4f4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:341fedc4f53181600adace66","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Historical gravitational-wave inputs plus an extra sign criterion; logarithmic-correction restrictions include axion candidates conditionally. Independent challenge qualification: Historical area-theorem inputs and an additional sign criterion condition the species restrictions."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:341fedc4f53181600adace66","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb"],"scopeContentSha256":"17b23896f033122b211a50ba05a1ebc085f18313a14253c55e252acf4c19192d","contributionContentSha256":"9a074af20485582136b8d7274fb70966b5e3eac78df2a1795393d14a48990cd4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d61","kind":"description","unitIndex":61,"unitId":"unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","textSha256":"d2032c576bc9949ceacd04ff5b2afb6189d756f7fd80c9cb0f3b085c44dce4f4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:341fedc4f53181600adace66","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Historical gravitational-wave inputs plus an extra sign criterion; logarithmic-correction restrictions include axion candidates conditionally.","challengeNote":"Historical area-theorem inputs and an additional sign criterion condition the species restrictions.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:1d3b64bc4ff22f0ed98915bdc55ca1021dbc9596c4d52746dd2719ea94b3ed1f","home":{"unitId":"unit:1d3b64bc4ff22f0ed98915bdc55ca1021dbc9596c4d52746dd2719ea94b3ed1f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1d3b64bc4ff22f0ed98915bdc55ca1021dbc9596c4d52746dd2719ea94b3ed1f","paperId":"2604.18669","textSha256":"5f06c131a9749e1037a1374122decb14124b2b28031af44b9aad7bc726d190aa"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2dff61d24ba75a78bd36dcca"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2dff61d24ba75a78bd36dcca","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1d3b64bc4ff22f0ed98915bdc55ca1021dbc9596c4d52746dd2719ea94b3ed1f","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"83e0d9c08a10dfdce5dea36bebd0600996ce13e6149fc9355cbdc5a6088c8a30","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1d3b64bc4ff22f0ed98915bdc55ca1021dbc9596c4d52746dd2719ea94b3ed1f","paperId":"2604.18669","textSha256":"5f06c131a9749e1037a1374122decb14124b2b28031af44b9aad7bc726d190aa"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2dff61d24ba75a78bd36dcca"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1d3b64bc4ff22f0ed98915bdc55ca1021dbc9596c4d52746dd2719ea94b3ed1f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d67","kind":"description","unitIndex":67,"unitId":"unit:1d3b64bc4ff22f0ed98915bdc55ca1021dbc9596c4d52746dd2719ea94b3ed1f","textSha256":"5f06c131a9749e1037a1374122decb14124b2b28031af44b9aad7bc726d190aa"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5660acbbf35c9dfa4786cfb6","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound higher-curvature restrictions, Wald entropy and multifractal geometry, conditional on exact area increase. Independent challenge qualification: Higher-curvature restrictions, Wald entropy and multifractal geometry are conditional on postulated exact area increase."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5660acbbf35c9dfa4786cfb6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1d3b64bc4ff22f0ed98915bdc55ca1021dbc9596c4d52746dd2719ea94b3ed1f","q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb"],"scopeContentSha256":"17b23896f033122b211a50ba05a1ebc085f18313a14253c55e252acf4c19192d","contributionContentSha256":"7486cffea9b04c1e17fe6d7d54b8a083f1f1daa88b6201d968047be24e09029f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d67","kind":"description","unitIndex":67,"unitId":"unit:1d3b64bc4ff22f0ed98915bdc55ca1021dbc9596c4d52746dd2719ea94b3ed1f","textSha256":"5f06c131a9749e1037a1374122decb14124b2b28031af44b9aad7bc726d190aa"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5660acbbf35c9dfa4786cfb6","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound higher-curvature restrictions, Wald entropy and multifractal geometry, conditional on exact area increase.","challengeNote":"Higher-curvature restrictions, Wald entropy and multifractal geometry are conditional on postulated exact area increase.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","home":{"unitId":"unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","paperId":"2607.25513","textSha256":"59d5a2b7de7e7c651c31f971a7ead97b8a680214d1580740828f9696b78c5e8f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e73413056ee366b6a1bf6fad"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e73413056ee366b6a1bf6fad","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"6ab4614656ca205bccae6b66eeb6bdd2d9ce33f21d625872e5d985bbd9436142","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","paperId":"2607.25513","textSha256":"59d5a2b7de7e7c651c31f971a7ead97b8a680214d1580740828f9696b78c5e8f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e73413056ee366b6a1bf6fad"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d68","kind":"description","unitIndex":68,"unitId":"unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","textSha256":"59d5a2b7de7e7c651c31f971a7ead97b8a680214d1580740828f9696b78c5e8f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ad318a23ede3e68a8e18ad73","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Small additive corrections; F(R) and species restrictions require GSL and the additional sign criterion, beyond area-theorem support. Independent challenge qualification: F(R) and species restrictions are distinct applications requiring small corrections, the GSL and an additional sign criterion."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ad318a23ede3e68a8e18ad73","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb"],"scopeContentSha256":"17b23896f033122b211a50ba05a1ebc085f18313a14253c55e252acf4c19192d","contributionContentSha256":"e9bde655cab589ad83a86ede6ab6613d36748f7bb9f55025cf36fc827361f944","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d68","kind":"description","unitIndex":68,"unitId":"unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","textSha256":"59d5a2b7de7e7c651c31f971a7ead97b8a680214d1580740828f9696b78c5e8f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ad318a23ede3e68a8e18ad73","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Small additive corrections; F(R) and species restrictions require GSL and the additional sign criterion, beyond area-theorem support.","challengeNote":"F(R) and species restrictions are distinct applications requiring small corrections, the GSL and an additional sign criterion.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a1ab952615e70d93bf703bacbc352d93ef4ef70ebffa4f022783403d1a1284b7","home":{"unitId":"unit:a1ab952615e70d93bf703bacbc352d93ef4ef70ebffa4f022783403d1a1284b7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a1ab952615e70d93bf703bacbc352d93ef4ef70ebffa4f022783403d1a1284b7","paperId":"2407.20321","textSha256":"47f6967584ae148ee1e92560520522a3f07adeb057227a5b210205b1ceba8a47"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0d86978fb5ded6ebd7d524f7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0d86978fb5ded6ebd7d524f7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a1ab952615e70d93bf703bacbc352d93ef4ef70ebffa4f022783403d1a1284b7","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"c6523be8dafe3d524e93533985f7ac094da5bf573787b053c4fa684707386b42","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a1ab952615e70d93bf703bacbc352d93ef4ef70ebffa4f022783403d1a1284b7","paperId":"2407.20321","textSha256":"47f6967584ae148ee1e92560520522a3f07adeb057227a5b210205b1ceba8a47"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0d86978fb5ded6ebd7d524f7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a1ab952615e70d93bf703bacbc352d93ef4ef70ebffa4f022783403d1a1284b7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:a1ab952615e70d93bf703bacbc352d93ef4ef70ebffa4f022783403d1a1284b7","textSha256":"47f6967584ae148ee1e92560520522a3f07adeb057227a5b210205b1ceba8a47"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:eb61defb86d9bde18faf6fcc","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Near-extremal negative entropy motivates quenched entropy when the topological expansion fails. Independent challenge qualification: Explaining negativity and computing a meaningful quenched entropy are related but distinct targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:eb61defb86d9bde18faf6fcc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a1ab952615e70d93bf703bacbc352d93ef4ef70ebffa4f022783403d1a1284b7","q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb"],"scopeContentSha256":"17b23896f033122b211a50ba05a1ebc085f18313a14253c55e252acf4c19192d","contributionContentSha256":"ba1e4cd01a8c49277b39c29340978360b0f4bc92c2f65b790e8448f45c349f0b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:a1ab952615e70d93bf703bacbc352d93ef4ef70ebffa4f022783403d1a1284b7","textSha256":"47f6967584ae148ee1e92560520522a3f07adeb057227a5b210205b1ceba8a47"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:eb61defb86d9bde18faf6fcc","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Near-extremal negative entropy motivates quenched entropy when the topological expansion fails.","challengeNote":"Explaining negativity and computing a meaningful quenched entropy are related but distinct targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":5,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"7d5df2b5fc350d307475e98892b77c6eafab1eed3b45a2ad83b257257aca4f0c"},"organizational-access:b7a0893d48aa7d8ba395fd71":{"id":"organizational-access:b7a0893d48aa7d8ba395fd71","source":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","target":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8ac1c5bf56b05064635db5ff"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1e56d8ed3c0ddff03060b195"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","home":{"unitId":"unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","paperId":"1003.2850","textSha256":"4ff0fecf9893cc6507f54a1df78681543c70297c0ae2e4976e0cc797a0603a7d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ce5e10316100fc52869d1fab"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ce5e10316100fc52869d1fab","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"f5516dddcbcb8ec9fee165018c02d54c88ca00e76f96b024ddfc2780c90437b0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","paperId":"1003.2850","textSha256":"4ff0fecf9893cc6507f54a1df78681543c70297c0ae2e4976e0cc797a0603a7d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ce5e10316100fc52869d1fab"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","textSha256":"4ff0fecf9893cc6507f54a1df78681543c70297c0ae2e4976e0cc797a0603a7d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:eed5823684e0acfe9749542a","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound: entropy versus species, Einstein minimality at fixed mass and an analogous AdS black-brane density question; weak coupling and unitarity are assumed. Independent challenge qualification: Species bounds, fixed-mass Einstein minimality and AdS black-brane entropy density remain distinct targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:eed5823684e0acfe9749542a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","contributionContentSha256":"d9114eecf300b5cf7701d5df3d1bccfa7f67a6329b0e847167c2ed59ba2c6862","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:0ed95e528a288703f7751e234c589c0655402a51dd74007bdc2b1ffa8f9b7dff","textSha256":"4ff0fecf9893cc6507f54a1df78681543c70297c0ae2e4976e0cc797a0603a7d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:eed5823684e0acfe9749542a","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound: entropy versus species, Einstein minimality at fixed mass and an analogous AdS black-brane density question; weak coupling and unitarity are assumed.","challengeNote":"Species bounds, fixed-mass Einstein minimality and AdS black-brane entropy density remain distinct targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","home":{"unitId":"unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","paperId":"2506.04905","textSha256":"d2032c576bc9949ceacd04ff5b2afb6189d756f7fd80c9cb0f3b085c44dce4f4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ec5628cb4c4baa76d2403f97"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ec5628cb4c4baa76d2403f97","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"98db3376466cdc21fb9ff18e3b8271ac2ebc622a8152eee9e5d16ff7b676f581","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","paperId":"2506.04905","textSha256":"d2032c576bc9949ceacd04ff5b2afb6189d756f7fd80c9cb0f3b085c44dce4f4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ec5628cb4c4baa76d2403f97"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d61","kind":"description","unitIndex":61,"unitId":"unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","textSha256":"d2032c576bc9949ceacd04ff5b2afb6189d756f7fd80c9cb0f3b085c44dce4f4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:552b7e586ddaccf22d5c34a8","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Historical gravitational-wave inputs plus an extra sign criterion; logarithmic-correction restrictions include axion candidates conditionally. Independent challenge qualification: Historical area-theorem inputs and an additional sign criterion condition the species restrictions."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:552b7e586ddaccf22d5c34a8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","contributionContentSha256":"d448554c33e538106346f4112cb1103ab67f718b5124b8df50762458ed527c4d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d61","kind":"description","unitIndex":61,"unitId":"unit:102e260b3948eab0cc830482101f398bb4fae43bb2d6eb1a212438143a8d44a2","textSha256":"d2032c576bc9949ceacd04ff5b2afb6189d756f7fd80c9cb0f3b085c44dce4f4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:552b7e586ddaccf22d5c34a8","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Historical gravitational-wave inputs plus an extra sign criterion; logarithmic-correction restrictions include axion candidates conditionally.","challengeNote":"Historical area-theorem inputs and an additional sign criterion condition the species restrictions.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:27de729e86985af5949fe7e927216effe80691a1e30892a3157395fff62390a4","home":{"unitId":"unit:27de729e86985af5949fe7e927216effe80691a1e30892a3157395fff62390a4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:27de729e86985af5949fe7e927216effe80691a1e30892a3157395fff62390a4","paperId":"0812.2768","textSha256":"9fdba43fcec8b2d169764c96b623b9feda8a5517c8ba0605ad5f9a369371215f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d3236d55d24e5f355f8a370d"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d3236d55d24e5f355f8a370d","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:27de729e86985af5949fe7e927216effe80691a1e30892a3157395fff62390a4","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"603305bf70f44d156a12970f23f5a4988cb336279ecc68e87b0f7c97aa7cb57a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:27de729e86985af5949fe7e927216effe80691a1e30892a3157395fff62390a4","paperId":"0812.2768","textSha256":"9fdba43fcec8b2d169764c96b623b9feda8a5517c8ba0605ad5f9a369371215f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d3236d55d24e5f355f8a370d"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:27de729e86985af5949fe7e927216effe80691a1e30892a3157395fff62390a4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:27de729e86985af5949fe7e927216effe80691a1e30892a3157395fff62390a4","textSha256":"9fdba43fcec8b2d169764c96b623b9feda8a5517c8ba0605ad5f9a369371215f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:148a92a16d9f1888dc3d0f7d","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound near-collapse entropy, species count and matching targets under holographic UV/IR mixing. Independent challenge qualification: Compound entropy, species-count and matching targets under holographic UV/IR mixing."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:148a92a16d9f1888dc3d0f7d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:27de729e86985af5949fe7e927216effe80691a1e30892a3157395fff62390a4","q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","contributionContentSha256":"7c091737709a94e30bd3e3af18e5339941cf1f642f490a799aec99e314ea9047","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:27de729e86985af5949fe7e927216effe80691a1e30892a3157395fff62390a4","textSha256":"9fdba43fcec8b2d169764c96b623b9feda8a5517c8ba0605ad5f9a369371215f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:148a92a16d9f1888dc3d0f7d","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound near-collapse entropy, species count and matching targets under holographic UV/IR mixing.","challengeNote":"Compound entropy, species-count and matching targets under holographic UV/IR mixing.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","home":{"unitId":"unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","paperId":"2607.25513","textSha256":"59d5a2b7de7e7c651c31f971a7ead97b8a680214d1580740828f9696b78c5e8f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e73413056ee366b6a1bf6fad"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e73413056ee366b6a1bf6fad","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"6ab4614656ca205bccae6b66eeb6bdd2d9ce33f21d625872e5d985bbd9436142","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","paperId":"2607.25513","textSha256":"59d5a2b7de7e7c651c31f971a7ead97b8a680214d1580740828f9696b78c5e8f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e73413056ee366b6a1bf6fad"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d68","kind":"description","unitIndex":68,"unitId":"unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","textSha256":"59d5a2b7de7e7c651c31f971a7ead97b8a680214d1580740828f9696b78c5e8f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7a43e14f530cb0df850f2060","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Small additive corrections; F(R) and species restrictions require GSL and the additional sign criterion, beyond area-theorem support. Independent challenge qualification: F(R) and species restrictions are distinct applications requiring small corrections, the GSL and an additional sign criterion."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7a43e14f530cb0df850f2060","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","contributionContentSha256":"403a43854c052288485053aca58d96d259dab192a7d2d9d3ef6c9cbd359fbc36","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d68","kind":"description","unitIndex":68,"unitId":"unit:2c9043a6e12a31aac9c0e7e7a3bc921047d6c964e0e5cf86567bb1bd8cb2e60a","textSha256":"59d5a2b7de7e7c651c31f971a7ead97b8a680214d1580740828f9696b78c5e8f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7a43e14f530cb0df850f2060","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Small additive corrections; F(R) and species restrictions require GSL and the additional sign criterion, beyond area-theorem support.","challengeNote":"F(R) and species restrictions are distinct applications requiring small corrections, the GSL and an additional sign criterion.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:4e52ef2bd952088fc2e7ca6aa3be103a10eda6eb73493ddabccf8496fc8af981","home":{"unitId":"unit:4e52ef2bd952088fc2e7ca6aa3be103a10eda6eb73493ddabccf8496fc8af981","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4e52ef2bd952088fc2e7ca6aa3be103a10eda6eb73493ddabccf8496fc8af981","paperId":"0710.4344","textSha256":"e9a3008c42b63afa502d5bd82b641971ecbf05c0ee070046a2208f67ee441c4c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ac1894e7898b3d266c440b70"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ac1894e7898b3d266c440b70","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4e52ef2bd952088fc2e7ca6aa3be103a10eda6eb73493ddabccf8496fc8af981","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"376e8fb2dd00662f73fd63709a310ba13558964b79bb5ce50958a9c19eded64c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4e52ef2bd952088fc2e7ca6aa3be103a10eda6eb73493ddabccf8496fc8af981","paperId":"0710.4344","textSha256":"e9a3008c42b63afa502d5bd82b641971ecbf05c0ee070046a2208f67ee441c4c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ac1894e7898b3d266c440b70"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4e52ef2bd952088fc2e7ca6aa3be103a10eda6eb73493ddabccf8496fc8af981","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:4e52ef2bd952088fc2e7ca6aa3be103a10eda6eb73493ddabccf8496fc8af981","textSha256":"e9a3008c42b63afa502d5bd82b641971ecbf05c0ee070046a2208f67ee441c4c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:33e16d15ae39b55b5d48d357","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound: species bounds, hierarchy application and microscopic decay patterns. Independent challenge qualification: Compound cutoff, hierarchy and microscopic-decay targets remain source-scoped."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:33e16d15ae39b55b5d48d357","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4e52ef2bd952088fc2e7ca6aa3be103a10eda6eb73493ddabccf8496fc8af981","q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","contributionContentSha256":"344191bc695a37d34638ab66f75349a5302f0f1598ff5e0da08d9bb7123632c6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:4e52ef2bd952088fc2e7ca6aa3be103a10eda6eb73493ddabccf8496fc8af981","textSha256":"e9a3008c42b63afa502d5bd82b641971ecbf05c0ee070046a2208f67ee441c4c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:33e16d15ae39b55b5d48d357","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound: species bounds, hierarchy application and microscopic decay patterns.","challengeNote":"Compound cutoff, hierarchy and microscopic-decay targets remain source-scoped.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:54793e8aee4dc8187d08cea62e7f7aa796f778a299239927972af7bff92f78ec","home":{"unitId":"unit:54793e8aee4dc8187d08cea62e7f7aa796f778a299239927972af7bff92f78ec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:54793e8aee4dc8187d08cea62e7f7aa796f778a299239927972af7bff92f78ec","paperId":"2306.16450","textSha256":"8cd6d25966849ef9d2eba130692334e3cb28aa9cefbfdc63801639f9bc1d2985"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc753fcd3a6a5c2aed56f9e0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc753fcd3a6a5c2aed56f9e0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:54793e8aee4dc8187d08cea62e7f7aa796f778a299239927972af7bff92f78ec","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"3d00b0e4faa76f922d644f66f02a7cd614c21c313161e86efb5dd288afa0aadd","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:54793e8aee4dc8187d08cea62e7f7aa796f778a299239927972af7bff92f78ec","paperId":"2306.16450","textSha256":"8cd6d25966849ef9d2eba130692334e3cb28aa9cefbfdc63801639f9bc1d2985"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc753fcd3a6a5c2aed56f9e0"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:54793e8aee4dc8187d08cea62e7f7aa796f778a299239927972af7bff92f78ec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d52","kind":"description","unitIndex":52,"unitId":"unit:54793e8aee4dc8187d08cea62e7f7aa796f778a299239927972af7bff92f78ec","textSha256":"8cd6d25966849ef9d2eba130692334e3cb28aa9cefbfdc63801639f9bc1d2985"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fa7f45bb459ab1da8ad8b1bb","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound geodesic/exponential distance behavior, species decay and dimensional-reduction preservation targets. Independent challenge qualification: Compound distance behavior, species-scale decay and dimensional-reduction targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:fa7f45bb459ab1da8ad8b1bb","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:54793e8aee4dc8187d08cea62e7f7aa796f778a299239927972af7bff92f78ec","q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","contributionContentSha256":"18b44d5096e4a25a2e456ec73c04109b5ab8ddab7390b3f16ca21c9827a9f5f9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d52","kind":"description","unitIndex":52,"unitId":"unit:54793e8aee4dc8187d08cea62e7f7aa796f778a299239927972af7bff92f78ec","textSha256":"8cd6d25966849ef9d2eba130692334e3cb28aa9cefbfdc63801639f9bc1d2985"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fa7f45bb459ab1da8ad8b1bb","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound geodesic/exponential distance behavior, species decay and dimensional-reduction preservation targets.","challengeNote":"Compound distance behavior, species-scale decay and dimensional-reduction targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5f29f9a247b12ad4d624aa8b3430f5c1aa19309493f0de96d089a40c11d49745","home":{"unitId":"unit:5f29f9a247b12ad4d624aa8b3430f5c1aa19309493f0de96d089a40c11d49745","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5f29f9a247b12ad4d624aa8b3430f5c1aa19309493f0de96d089a40c11d49745","paperId":"0806.3976","textSha256":"54d2ba44149782a70afbacfaca71c3fbe762e6ad5043a38c9d4272ea7f0b9b28"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:08c8086ed12ced79de34b96f2fc649e3","paperId":"0806.3976","sourceSha256":"86d8878c74736158efa6b5bc9b4f48bdd60e4a6c683eae5f78ad8735765dc912","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b8cabdf6967e6ed4f937/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"218611fb2a1cbaad0dfe74600bb28ce8c0a80ae997adf0fde047d8f95ad03524","pdfPage":2,"start":104,"end":2705,"textSha256":"4dd86561b5c87ec7ffaec6fbab68bd92a5eab34f7310ec309f54f0534d523726","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:40d67a50ccab05a5d09de898f958f136","paperId":"0806.3976","sourceSha256":"86d8878c74736158efa6b5bc9b4f48bdd60e4a6c683eae5f78ad8735765dc912","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b8cabdf6967e6ed4f937/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"218611fb2a1cbaad0dfe74600bb28ce8c0a80ae997adf0fde047d8f95ad03524","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":936,"textSha256":"d95a5fdc0865496b9fd51c99d9e168272b6589fbd3c051d6d58eed4908380598","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d3669d3577c18a01b04385b0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d3669d3577c18a01b04385b0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5f29f9a247b12ad4d624aa8b3430f5c1aa19309493f0de96d089a40c11d49745","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"f38a6eb4ebdda202397ce4f2cfa4e625f126abf9b1f033e4d0c18a0156780321","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5f29f9a247b12ad4d624aa8b3430f5c1aa19309493f0de96d089a40c11d49745","paperId":"0806.3976","textSha256":"54d2ba44149782a70afbacfaca71c3fbe762e6ad5043a38c9d4272ea7f0b9b28"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:08c8086ed12ced79de34b96f2fc649e3","paperId":"0806.3976","sourceSha256":"86d8878c74736158efa6b5bc9b4f48bdd60e4a6c683eae5f78ad8735765dc912","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b8cabdf6967e6ed4f937/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"218611fb2a1cbaad0dfe74600bb28ce8c0a80ae997adf0fde047d8f95ad03524","pdfPage":2,"start":104,"end":2705,"textSha256":"4dd86561b5c87ec7ffaec6fbab68bd92a5eab34f7310ec309f54f0534d523726","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:40d67a50ccab05a5d09de898f958f136","paperId":"0806.3976","sourceSha256":"86d8878c74736158efa6b5bc9b4f48bdd60e4a6c683eae5f78ad8735765dc912","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b8cabdf6967e6ed4f937/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"218611fb2a1cbaad0dfe74600bb28ce8c0a80ae997adf0fde047d8f95ad03524","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":936,"textSha256":"d95a5fdc0865496b9fd51c99d9e168272b6589fbd3c051d6d58eed4908380598","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d3669d3577c18a01b04385b0"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5f29f9a247b12ad4d624aa8b3430f5c1aa19309493f0de96d089a40c11d49745","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:5f29f9a247b12ad4d624aa8b3430f5c1aa19309493f0de96d089a40c11d49745","textSha256":"54d2ba44149782a70afbacfaca71c3fbe762e6ad5043a38c9d4272ea7f0b9b28"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:08c8086ed12ced79de34b96f2fc649e3","paperId":"0806.3976","sourceSha256":"86d8878c74736158efa6b5bc9b4f48bdd60e4a6c683eae5f78ad8735765dc912","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b8cabdf6967e6ed4f937/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"218611fb2a1cbaad0dfe74600bb28ce8c0a80ae997adf0fde047d8f95ad03524","pdfPage":2,"start":104,"end":2705,"textSha256":"4dd86561b5c87ec7ffaec6fbab68bd92a5eab34f7310ec309f54f0534d523726","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:40d67a50ccab05a5d09de898f958f136","paperId":"0806.3976","sourceSha256":"86d8878c74736158efa6b5bc9b4f48bdd60e4a6c683eae5f78ad8735765dc912","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b8cabdf6967e6ed4f937/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"218611fb2a1cbaad0dfe74600bb28ce8c0a80ae997adf0fde047d8f95ad03524","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":936,"textSha256":"d95a5fdc0865496b9fd51c99d9e168272b6589fbd3c051d6d58eed4908380598","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:da8a054198d1391ee77e5ef5","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Source proposes species-cutoff cancellation and reports leading-order matching and explicit examples. Independent challenge qualification: Reported leading-order matching and explicit examples support the proposed cutoff resolution within the stated normalization."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:da8a054198d1391ee77e5ef5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5f29f9a247b12ad4d624aa8b3430f5c1aa19309493f0de96d089a40c11d49745","q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","contributionContentSha256":"fafdb8a2320952f197dbb564c4aba4fca10ecd39e6cb7686e676f1fb1233223a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:5f29f9a247b12ad4d624aa8b3430f5c1aa19309493f0de96d089a40c11d49745","textSha256":"54d2ba44149782a70afbacfaca71c3fbe762e6ad5043a38c9d4272ea7f0b9b28"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:08c8086ed12ced79de34b96f2fc649e3","paperId":"0806.3976","sourceSha256":"86d8878c74736158efa6b5bc9b4f48bdd60e4a6c683eae5f78ad8735765dc912","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b8cabdf6967e6ed4f937/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"218611fb2a1cbaad0dfe74600bb28ce8c0a80ae997adf0fde047d8f95ad03524","pdfPage":2,"start":104,"end":2705,"textSha256":"4dd86561b5c87ec7ffaec6fbab68bd92a5eab34f7310ec309f54f0534d523726","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:40d67a50ccab05a5d09de898f958f136","paperId":"0806.3976","sourceSha256":"86d8878c74736158efa6b5bc9b4f48bdd60e4a6c683eae5f78ad8735765dc912","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b8cabdf6967e6ed4f937/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"218611fb2a1cbaad0dfe74600bb28ce8c0a80ae997adf0fde047d8f95ad03524","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":936,"textSha256":"d95a5fdc0865496b9fd51c99d9e168272b6589fbd3c051d6d58eed4908380598","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:da8a054198d1391ee77e5ef5","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Source proposes species-cutoff cancellation and reports leading-order matching and explicit examples.","challengeNote":"Reported leading-order matching and explicit examples support the proposed cutoff resolution within the stated normalization.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:87672a715f9223b7dc84f73ae35504ca0b79843c4d7fef355bd66e3c8774dbeb","home":{"unitId":"unit:87672a715f9223b7dc84f73ae35504ca0b79843c4d7fef355bd66e3c8774dbeb","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:87672a715f9223b7dc84f73ae35504ca0b79843c4d7fef355bd66e3c8774dbeb","paperId":"0812.1940","textSha256":"8c6c49dfb3953823e029657135f4799027392bd9771c20346526c0484a7cad7d"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:49fd06da118eec55d5ee9dbfbb994f39","paperId":"0812.1940","sourceSha256":"d0f093ead75c5249c39888fee0ad4f7917c3cf32a24117584b88bbbc900cdc3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc6eb20e8e5813ffeac4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"92133a439d4b3197c6a67dcc675fc95955672e0e6ff8580ba280eb458a4e1b2f","pdfPage":2,"start":99,"end":2169,"textSha256":"99f8da6ed2a616a865e75f8a464abeee21b1e9610e4674e3a16c58d278433a0d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6bbf2ca61bec8033f658956864eb9f00","paperId":"0812.1940","sourceSha256":"d0f093ead75c5249c39888fee0ad4f7917c3cf32a24117584b88bbbc900cdc3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc6eb20e8e5813ffeac4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"92133a439d4b3197c6a67dcc675fc95955672e0e6ff8580ba280eb458a4e1b2f","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2404,"textSha256":"f533742a02e72a3e73bc024a4a1cc477534c8e4bddc98e27788fd42bcda778e0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d01da69336bb5ce5ceaec3abc4357ab4","paperId":"0812.1940","sourceSha256":"d0f093ead75c5249c39888fee0ad4f7917c3cf32a24117584b88bbbc900cdc3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc6eb20e8e5813ffeac4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"92133a439d4b3197c6a67dcc675fc95955672e0e6ff8580ba280eb458a4e1b2f","pdfPage":3,"start":96,"end":2404,"textSha256":"994b8b7c7c4c8b47e7dddcd5661ccdc118e7cd57ec228f2cf9eb7d3bdac1a4e4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:daa4a2fe15dd586a10693237"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:daa4a2fe15dd586a10693237","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:87672a715f9223b7dc84f73ae35504ca0b79843c4d7fef355bd66e3c8774dbeb","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"e06fe50b47f2518d46e5901b62e98a4016ed5295df7b0d70a7aa046844acd89a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:87672a715f9223b7dc84f73ae35504ca0b79843c4d7fef355bd66e3c8774dbeb","paperId":"0812.1940","textSha256":"8c6c49dfb3953823e029657135f4799027392bd9771c20346526c0484a7cad7d"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:49fd06da118eec55d5ee9dbfbb994f39","paperId":"0812.1940","sourceSha256":"d0f093ead75c5249c39888fee0ad4f7917c3cf32a24117584b88bbbc900cdc3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc6eb20e8e5813ffeac4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"92133a439d4b3197c6a67dcc675fc95955672e0e6ff8580ba280eb458a4e1b2f","pdfPage":2,"start":99,"end":2169,"textSha256":"99f8da6ed2a616a865e75f8a464abeee21b1e9610e4674e3a16c58d278433a0d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6bbf2ca61bec8033f658956864eb9f00","paperId":"0812.1940","sourceSha256":"d0f093ead75c5249c39888fee0ad4f7917c3cf32a24117584b88bbbc900cdc3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc6eb20e8e5813ffeac4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"92133a439d4b3197c6a67dcc675fc95955672e0e6ff8580ba280eb458a4e1b2f","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2404,"textSha256":"f533742a02e72a3e73bc024a4a1cc477534c8e4bddc98e27788fd42bcda778e0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d01da69336bb5ce5ceaec3abc4357ab4","paperId":"0812.1940","sourceSha256":"d0f093ead75c5249c39888fee0ad4f7917c3cf32a24117584b88bbbc900cdc3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc6eb20e8e5813ffeac4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"92133a439d4b3197c6a67dcc675fc95955672e0e6ff8580ba280eb458a4e1b2f","pdfPage":3,"start":96,"end":2404,"textSha256":"994b8b7c7c4c8b47e7dddcd5661ccdc118e7cd57ec228f2cf9eb7d3bdac1a4e4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:daa4a2fe15dd586a10693237"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:87672a715f9223b7dc84f73ae35504ca0b79843c4d7fef355bd66e3c8774dbeb","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:87672a715f9223b7dc84f73ae35504ca0b79843c4d7fef355bd66e3c8774dbeb","textSha256":"8c6c49dfb3953823e029657135f4799027392bd9771c20346526c0484a7cad7d"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:49fd06da118eec55d5ee9dbfbb994f39","paperId":"0812.1940","sourceSha256":"d0f093ead75c5249c39888fee0ad4f7917c3cf32a24117584b88bbbc900cdc3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc6eb20e8e5813ffeac4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"92133a439d4b3197c6a67dcc675fc95955672e0e6ff8580ba280eb458a4e1b2f","pdfPage":2,"start":99,"end":2169,"textSha256":"99f8da6ed2a616a865e75f8a464abeee21b1e9610e4674e3a16c58d278433a0d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6bbf2ca61bec8033f658956864eb9f00","paperId":"0812.1940","sourceSha256":"d0f093ead75c5249c39888fee0ad4f7917c3cf32a24117584b88bbbc900cdc3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc6eb20e8e5813ffeac4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"92133a439d4b3197c6a67dcc675fc95955672e0e6ff8580ba280eb458a4e1b2f","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2404,"textSha256":"f533742a02e72a3e73bc024a4a1cc477534c8e4bddc98e27788fd42bcda778e0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d01da69336bb5ce5ceaec3abc4357ab4","paperId":"0812.1940","sourceSha256":"d0f093ead75c5249c39888fee0ad4f7917c3cf32a24117584b88bbbc900cdc3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc6eb20e8e5813ffeac4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"92133a439d4b3197c6a67dcc675fc95955672e0e6ff8580ba280eb458a4e1b2f","pdfPage":3,"start":96,"end":2404,"textSha256":"994b8b7c7c4c8b47e7dddcd5661ccdc118e7cd57ec228f2cf9eb7d3bdac1a4e4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aa2b84000805d1df11c1b00b","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound: detection/storage/cloning arguments and field-theory/gravity threshold matching. Perturbation theory alone is explicitly insufficient for a rigorous Independent challenge qualification: Compound information-limit and correspondence targets. The source explicitly rejects perturbation theory alone as a rigorous cutoff-bound argument."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:aa2b84000805d1df11c1b00b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:87672a715f9223b7dc84f73ae35504ca0b79843c4d7fef355bd66e3c8774dbeb","q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","contributionContentSha256":"4ee7efcdec7f1f53c8f3f92f7a82c3793b9dcf91a64586e9a12c2ad193c05b6d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:87672a715f9223b7dc84f73ae35504ca0b79843c4d7fef355bd66e3c8774dbeb","textSha256":"8c6c49dfb3953823e029657135f4799027392bd9771c20346526c0484a7cad7d"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:49fd06da118eec55d5ee9dbfbb994f39","paperId":"0812.1940","sourceSha256":"d0f093ead75c5249c39888fee0ad4f7917c3cf32a24117584b88bbbc900cdc3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc6eb20e8e5813ffeac4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"92133a439d4b3197c6a67dcc675fc95955672e0e6ff8580ba280eb458a4e1b2f","pdfPage":2,"start":99,"end":2169,"textSha256":"99f8da6ed2a616a865e75f8a464abeee21b1e9610e4674e3a16c58d278433a0d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6bbf2ca61bec8033f658956864eb9f00","paperId":"0812.1940","sourceSha256":"d0f093ead75c5249c39888fee0ad4f7917c3cf32a24117584b88bbbc900cdc3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc6eb20e8e5813ffeac4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"92133a439d4b3197c6a67dcc675fc95955672e0e6ff8580ba280eb458a4e1b2f","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2404,"textSha256":"f533742a02e72a3e73bc024a4a1cc477534c8e4bddc98e27788fd42bcda778e0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d01da69336bb5ce5ceaec3abc4357ab4","paperId":"0812.1940","sourceSha256":"d0f093ead75c5249c39888fee0ad4f7917c3cf32a24117584b88bbbc900cdc3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc6eb20e8e5813ffeac4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"92133a439d4b3197c6a67dcc675fc95955672e0e6ff8580ba280eb458a4e1b2f","pdfPage":3,"start":96,"end":2404,"textSha256":"994b8b7c7c4c8b47e7dddcd5661ccdc118e7cd57ec228f2cf9eb7d3bdac1a4e4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aa2b84000805d1df11c1b00b","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound: detection/storage/cloning arguments and field-theory/gravity threshold matching. Perturbation theory alone is explicitly insufficient for a rigorous","challengeNote":"Compound information-limit and correspondence targets. The source explicitly rejects perturbation theory alone as a rigorous cutoff-bound argument.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a66f304ac79f6847e486545293cda65b15454d96a6d62917e6227a5c8f2697f0","home":{"unitId":"unit:a66f304ac79f6847e486545293cda65b15454d96a6d62917e6227a5c8f2697f0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a66f304ac79f6847e486545293cda65b15454d96a6d62917e6227a5c8f2697f0","paperId":"2305.10489","textSha256":"18398981aad7fc998cc6ad176ef3cf8fd1ef0a4884f2eac866dc74f2bf58591c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9ded9439dd82045b5e7537bc"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9ded9439dd82045b5e7537bc","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a66f304ac79f6847e486545293cda65b15454d96a6d62917e6227a5c8f2697f0","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"d869874eda3f3d4de97385209c9a358c27bc55a105aee811a7c9a1bec843bae0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a66f304ac79f6847e486545293cda65b15454d96a6d62917e6227a5c8f2697f0","paperId":"2305.10489","textSha256":"18398981aad7fc998cc6ad176ef3cf8fd1ef0a4884f2eac866dc74f2bf58591c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9ded9439dd82045b5e7537bc"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a66f304ac79f6847e486545293cda65b15454d96a6d62917e6227a5c8f2697f0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d51","kind":"description","unitIndex":51,"unitId":"unit:a66f304ac79f6847e486545293cda65b15454d96a6d62917e6227a5c8f2697f0","textSha256":"18398981aad7fc998cc6ad176ef3cf8fd1ef0a4884f2eac866dc74f2bf58591c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fd91a5d9056d077d59668809","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Species thermodynamics is proposed by analogy with minimal black holes. Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:fd91a5d9056d077d59668809","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a66f304ac79f6847e486545293cda65b15454d96a6d62917e6227a5c8f2697f0","q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","contributionContentSha256":"f6dca9984db27aacab67e7f6d21f3b985bfd988cb754b1906e422c027ce76e71","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d51","kind":"description","unitIndex":51,"unitId":"unit:a66f304ac79f6847e486545293cda65b15454d96a6d62917e6227a5c8f2697f0","textSha256":"18398981aad7fc998cc6ad176ef3cf8fd1ef0a4884f2eac866dc74f2bf58591c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fd91a5d9056d077d59668809","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Species thermodynamics is proposed by analogy with minimal black holes.","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a7858f30e4f198420da499efd0a6f464ec24624dce00dcf545f92c42c790319f","home":{"unitId":"unit:a7858f30e4f198420da499efd0a6f464ec24624dce00dcf545f92c42c790319f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a7858f30e4f198420da499efd0a6f464ec24624dce00dcf545f92c42c790319f","paperId":"2310.04488","textSha256":"238ec16c04eae6bf7336681ac5ad298b20ba6200ac7a586e09e1ae03faf6d66e"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5c5c19dfc189af90b4bad640"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5c5c19dfc189af90b4bad640","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a7858f30e4f198420da499efd0a6f464ec24624dce00dcf545f92c42c790319f","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"9d3a942ab679ea4eb28bf99df7a2318a1f921ff5945f093199225d996380f0f6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a7858f30e4f198420da499efd0a6f464ec24624dce00dcf545f92c42c790319f","paperId":"2310.04488","textSha256":"238ec16c04eae6bf7336681ac5ad298b20ba6200ac7a586e09e1ae03faf6d66e"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5c5c19dfc189af90b4bad640"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a7858f30e4f198420da499efd0a6f464ec24624dce00dcf545f92c42c790319f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:a7858f30e4f198420da499efd0a6f464ec24624dce00dcf545f92c42c790319f","textSha256":"238ec16c04eae6bf7336681ac5ad298b20ba6200ac7a586e09e1ae03faf6d66e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9e97e1a765645f2f7b5f6b0d","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Tests identification of three scales through integrating out a core tower; their equality is the target. Independent challenge qualification: Agreement among the three cutoff definitions is investigated, not assumed."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9e97e1a765645f2f7b5f6b0d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a7858f30e4f198420da499efd0a6f464ec24624dce00dcf545f92c42c790319f","q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","contributionContentSha256":"43ebc6dbfe99bda5838e23caf7f8a6deabde87fe7c403f7120bacf23eb75de87","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:a7858f30e4f198420da499efd0a6f464ec24624dce00dcf545f92c42c790319f","textSha256":"238ec16c04eae6bf7336681ac5ad298b20ba6200ac7a586e09e1ae03faf6d66e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9e97e1a765645f2f7b5f6b0d","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Tests identification of three scales through integrating out a core tower; their equality is the target.","challengeNote":"Agreement among the three cutoff definitions is investigated, not assumed.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c01b4bf8b06fe73fb45cd7949e93f3cd370b2c56df4b213e3e136b47f4b4f9cd","home":{"unitId":"unit:c01b4bf8b06fe73fb45cd7949e93f3cd370b2c56df4b213e3e136b47f4b4f9cd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c01b4bf8b06fe73fb45cd7949e93f3cd370b2c56df4b213e3e136b47f4b4f9cd","paperId":"2103.15668","textSha256":"3991266175a11a2998bb04620d88986d267c6531770f3cd74de86994745d6998"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:13b69eb56b36ac1ed2f3d2ea"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:13b69eb56b36ac1ed2f3d2ea","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c01b4bf8b06fe73fb45cd7949e93f3cd370b2c56df4b213e3e136b47f4b4f9cd","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"a1282c98b33e1db34d2fe515a44c7819fe48259c998b63a38e4afcc8c6d4364a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c01b4bf8b06fe73fb45cd7949e93f3cd370b2c56df4b213e3e136b47f4b4f9cd","paperId":"2103.15668","textSha256":"3991266175a11a2998bb04620d88986d267c6531770f3cd74de86994745d6998"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:13b69eb56b36ac1ed2f3d2ea"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c01b4bf8b06fe73fb45cd7949e93f3cd370b2c56df4b213e3e136b47f4b4f9cd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:c01b4bf8b06fe73fb45cd7949e93f3cd370b2c56df4b213e3e136b47f4b4f9cd","textSha256":"3991266175a11a2998bb04620d88986d267c6531770f3cd74de86994745d6998"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2cb6606650e2521871c6a8f4","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Large species number is proposed to isolate collective effects; black-hole/de Sitter depletion and quantum breaking remain distinct targets. Independent challenge qualification: Isolation of collective effects, depletion, entanglement and quantum breaking remain compound targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2cb6606650e2521871c6a8f4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c01b4bf8b06fe73fb45cd7949e93f3cd370b2c56df4b213e3e136b47f4b4f9cd","q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","contributionContentSha256":"429ddd7f81ff8b97922e742dbe982d9a9c90c975b8279a88073dc50c49303511","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:c01b4bf8b06fe73fb45cd7949e93f3cd370b2c56df4b213e3e136b47f4b4f9cd","textSha256":"3991266175a11a2998bb04620d88986d267c6531770f3cd74de86994745d6998"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2cb6606650e2521871c6a8f4","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Large species number is proposed to isolate collective effects; black-hole/de Sitter depletion and quantum breaking remain distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Isolation of collective effects, depletion, entanglement and quantum breaking remain compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:edd785a95635133e669e7ecdde92a79f034d503f6e634cca9da9bb130c191ce9","home":{"unitId":"unit:edd785a95635133e669e7ecdde92a79f034d503f6e634cca9da9bb130c191ce9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:edd785a95635133e669e7ecdde92a79f034d503f6e634cca9da9bb130c191ce9","paperId":"2506.02335","textSha256":"14052101e8fab4beee76f30f8030af42b9759e9ef3581a664902ea95d277ae61"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7df7930c73021244ec544691"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7df7930c73021244ec544691","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:edd785a95635133e669e7ecdde92a79f034d503f6e634cca9da9bb130c191ce9","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"a8cdb5254b6d71f7637d500d71088810933528da52dfa97f4bab5dbe373c7c13","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:edd785a95635133e669e7ecdde92a79f034d503f6e634cca9da9bb130c191ce9","paperId":"2506.02335","textSha256":"14052101e8fab4beee76f30f8030af42b9759e9ef3581a664902ea95d277ae61"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7df7930c73021244ec544691"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:edd785a95635133e669e7ecdde92a79f034d503f6e634cca9da9bb130c191ce9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d60","kind":"description","unitIndex":60,"unitId":"unit:edd785a95635133e669e7ecdde92a79f034d503f6e634cca9da9bb130c191ce9","textSha256":"14052101e8fab4beee76f30f8030af42b9759e9ef3581a664902ea95d277ae61"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:01000166b5ff3436175a53f5","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Proceedings review of correspondence and tower consistency; not independently verified as the same scoped question as the earlier construction. Independent challenge qualification: The proceedings review retains correspondence and tower-consistency targets; equivalence with the earlier construction is unestablished."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:01000166b5ff3436175a53f5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:edd785a95635133e669e7ecdde92a79f034d503f6e634cca9da9bb130c191ce9","q025-candidate-question:912a7d47901274f18ac63d5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"f2f85f9093993043bbaac6c3243867cfa859f8eca517552fd310047bb6d40587","contributionContentSha256":"7ad8944ce9145e7167c9a2acb32d080faf263e19bcf5e383cbdea089c914eb71","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d60","kind":"description","unitIndex":60,"unitId":"unit:edd785a95635133e669e7ecdde92a79f034d503f6e634cca9da9bb130c191ce9","textSha256":"14052101e8fab4beee76f30f8030af42b9759e9ef3581a664902ea95d277ae61"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:01000166b5ff3436175a53f5","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Proceedings review of correspondence and tower consistency; not independently verified as the same scoped question as the earlier construction.","challengeNote":"The proceedings review retains correspondence and tower-consistency targets; equivalence with the earlier construction is unestablished.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":12,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ef24bcf19660bb512bf5bf44ec279b562af9887c15ab651997d6fcb7661b0a32"},"organizational-access:c9e00bd05be295a736c9fb4f":{"id":"organizational-access:c9e00bd05be295a736c9fb4f","source":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","target":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7b5a236a470736f0c0bd8d64"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5fe049038e0d09e39d73d407"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0babff28d59c2045872a0e14914d5de607f2a417099adaf19c013fa75f5a1245","home":{"unitId":"unit:0babff28d59c2045872a0e14914d5de607f2a417099adaf19c013fa75f5a1245","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0babff28d59c2045872a0e14914d5de607f2a417099adaf19c013fa75f5a1245","paperId":"2008.05465","textSha256":"ef13fd35f6068183834ce6e976f81df4fdcb97ff24ddcd962b9a3caa87705eb4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7f0df1cacbf9d69c9b82392d"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7f0df1cacbf9d69c9b82392d","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0babff28d59c2045872a0e14914d5de607f2a417099adaf19c013fa75f5a1245","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"c5a79c4b42deb62c4fccc9b15d9227d790cae08d7df3b468dd01397a91016661","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0babff28d59c2045872a0e14914d5de607f2a417099adaf19c013fa75f5a1245","paperId":"2008.05465","textSha256":"ef13fd35f6068183834ce6e976f81df4fdcb97ff24ddcd962b9a3caa87705eb4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7f0df1cacbf9d69c9b82392d"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0babff28d59c2045872a0e14914d5de607f2a417099adaf19c013fa75f5a1245","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d49","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:0babff28d59c2045872a0e14914d5de607f2a417099adaf19c013fa75f5a1245","textSha256":"ef13fd35f6068183834ce6e976f81df4fdcb97ff24ddcd962b9a3caa87705eb4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d22322e1ec8893a3c6e01183"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d22322e1ec8893a3c6e01183","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0babff28d59c2045872a0e14914d5de607f2a417099adaf19c013fa75f5a1245","q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b"],"scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","contributionContentSha256":"49f46a5b003821573aab552fe7f3e79faae769db77bd39c80d613491e6df0abf","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d49","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:0babff28d59c2045872a0e14914d5de607f2a417099adaf19c013fa75f5a1245","textSha256":"ef13fd35f6068183834ce6e976f81df4fdcb97ff24ddcd962b9a3caa87705eb4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d22322e1ec8893a3c6e01183","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:2a6539ca3a94c2a6d09d77704e13eb441d56e988608c60b3caa93cb7d9652c10","home":{"unitId":"unit:2a6539ca3a94c2a6d09d77704e13eb441d56e988608c60b3caa93cb7d9652c10","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2a6539ca3a94c2a6d09d77704e13eb441d56e988608c60b3caa93cb7d9652c10","paperId":"1812.10448","textSha256":"bbe198073065851c3fd90a3ceabafe4629eb855fff66d29b1cd1260b6a8957e4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4f077e13253eb13f0466cdf9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4f077e13253eb13f0466cdf9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2a6539ca3a94c2a6d09d77704e13eb441d56e988608c60b3caa93cb7d9652c10","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"9de9915314a9cfa5626cadbac899b46e2802715c3b799df5472cf7e43cfbea55","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2a6539ca3a94c2a6d09d77704e13eb441d56e988608c60b3caa93cb7d9652c10","paperId":"1812.10448","textSha256":"bbe198073065851c3fd90a3ceabafe4629eb855fff66d29b1cd1260b6a8957e4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4f077e13253eb13f0466cdf9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2a6539ca3a94c2a6d09d77704e13eb441d56e988608c60b3caa93cb7d9652c10","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:2a6539ca3a94c2a6d09d77704e13eb441d56e988608c60b3caa93cb7d9652c10","textSha256":"bbe198073065851c3fd90a3ceabafe4629eb855fff66d29b1cd1260b6a8957e4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:02c9b7b1305cb7dd898278fc"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:02c9b7b1305cb7dd898278fc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2a6539ca3a94c2a6d09d77704e13eb441d56e988608c60b3caa93cb7d9652c10","q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b"],"scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","contributionContentSha256":"9ec1d142391bb8492d027d8218c4ac5704beffbe66ac4c9342f5a75839b9b458","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:2a6539ca3a94c2a6d09d77704e13eb441d56e988608c60b3caa93cb7d9652c10","textSha256":"bbe198073065851c3fd90a3ceabafe4629eb855fff66d29b1cd1260b6a8957e4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:02c9b7b1305cb7dd898278fc","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound slope, negative-curvature and excursion diagnostics; slope and curvature are alternative refined branches.","challengeNote":"Compound potential and excursion diagnostics; the slope and negative-curvature branches are alternatives.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:3e153bc723c3804a7eeaf56a0a003c852c26f092e81892a6a70c4651a7786b03","home":{"unitId":"unit:3e153bc723c3804a7eeaf56a0a003c852c26f092e81892a6a70c4651a7786b03","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3e153bc723c3804a7eeaf56a0a003c852c26f092e81892a6a70c4651a7786b03","paperId":"1810.03575","textSha256":"2b1f40ac8ab9daf19e64ca987e9dc607d038a058fe8589c04ab30e24308c2651"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5edf758025cbc0d58837232d"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5edf758025cbc0d58837232d","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3e153bc723c3804a7eeaf56a0a003c852c26f092e81892a6a70c4651a7786b03","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"2c9e27fc810435f09eb783df7961a306d5a5de4790b3192f6f0cbbfb677bbd78","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3e153bc723c3804a7eeaf56a0a003c852c26f092e81892a6a70c4651a7786b03","paperId":"1810.03575","textSha256":"2b1f40ac8ab9daf19e64ca987e9dc607d038a058fe8589c04ab30e24308c2651"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5edf758025cbc0d58837232d"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3e153bc723c3804a7eeaf56a0a003c852c26f092e81892a6a70c4651a7786b03","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:3e153bc723c3804a7eeaf56a0a003c852c26f092e81892a6a70c4651a7786b03","textSha256":"2b1f40ac8ab9daf19e64ca987e9dc607d038a058fe8589c04ab30e24308c2651"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ddf3d627c30c8ba17997544a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ddf3d627c30c8ba17997544a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3e153bc723c3804a7eeaf56a0a003c852c26f092e81892a6a70c4651a7786b03","q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b"],"scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","contributionContentSha256":"7e0eb6983b0337f69538f5a745efc1834610559c48aaa2d1e4cfb075e6c28cb5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:3e153bc723c3804a7eeaf56a0a003c852c26f092e81892a6a70c4651a7786b03","textSha256":"2b1f40ac8ab9daf19e64ca987e9dc607d038a058fe8589c04ab30e24308c2651"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ddf3d627c30c8ba17997544a","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The reported constant-slope attractor association does not enforce an explicit quantum-gravity inequality.","challengeNote":"The reported attractor association does not enforce an explicit quantum-gravity inequality.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:4a8e7bc93e02fd0d7b9d9cbe9def7f4722fac7ea1e6242f44ed948e1a966303f","home":{"unitId":"unit:4a8e7bc93e02fd0d7b9d9cbe9def7f4722fac7ea1e6242f44ed948e1a966303f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4a8e7bc93e02fd0d7b9d9cbe9def7f4722fac7ea1e6242f44ed948e1a966303f","paperId":"1809.00478","textSha256":"800161d6baca4db654d025af7cb3ac64806528a28bf2be6e30b001fb809315e4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0a7dbf4d965407b04016ade4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0a7dbf4d965407b04016ade4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4a8e7bc93e02fd0d7b9d9cbe9def7f4722fac7ea1e6242f44ed948e1a966303f","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"2486fbe86fd957bd693d8182998582e33b4bb95a35ab54e701a9df0df6b20fab","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4a8e7bc93e02fd0d7b9d9cbe9def7f4722fac7ea1e6242f44ed948e1a966303f","paperId":"1809.00478","textSha256":"800161d6baca4db654d025af7cb3ac64806528a28bf2be6e30b001fb809315e4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0a7dbf4d965407b04016ade4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4a8e7bc93e02fd0d7b9d9cbe9def7f4722fac7ea1e6242f44ed948e1a966303f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:4a8e7bc93e02fd0d7b9d9cbe9def7f4722fac7ea1e6242f44ed948e1a966303f","textSha256":"800161d6baca4db654d025af7cb3ac64806528a28bf2be6e30b001fb809315e4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7d9baf05639f9e65c5572533"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7d9baf05639f9e65c5572533","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4a8e7bc93e02fd0d7b9d9cbe9def7f4722fac7ea1e6242f44ed948e1a966303f","q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b"],"scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","contributionContentSha256":"e50a56331c0918eb676851e5ed45ac91082d57a01c1ebcad051000363fe55633","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:4a8e7bc93e02fd0d7b9d9cbe9def7f4722fac7ea1e6242f44ed948e1a966303f","textSha256":"800161d6baca4db654d025af7cb3ac64806528a28bf2be6e30b001fb809315e4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7d9baf05639f9e65c5572533","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"An exponential and tiny energy scale are explicit; the conjecture's derivative branch and a slope-inference target are not.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:561027502ea348144ef6e64c1dfeea0db72f8d873de0d2a01e901ecebfc61e4a","home":{"unitId":"unit:561027502ea348144ef6e64c1dfeea0db72f8d873de0d2a01e901ecebfc61e4a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:561027502ea348144ef6e64c1dfeea0db72f8d873de0d2a01e901ecebfc61e4a","paperId":"2504.07679","textSha256":"8ba94a6db714b10446aecfd77c65007c9f2af0f0d50a87322d549cb3db24119c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:02fdb5771a6efa9e1c396f45"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:02fdb5771a6efa9e1c396f45","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:561027502ea348144ef6e64c1dfeea0db72f8d873de0d2a01e901ecebfc61e4a","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"6826576157967ec517d6851cb5909226632a3c10da09dfe815603a34b66361d3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:561027502ea348144ef6e64c1dfeea0db72f8d873de0d2a01e901ecebfc61e4a","paperId":"2504.07679","textSha256":"8ba94a6db714b10446aecfd77c65007c9f2af0f0d50a87322d549cb3db24119c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:02fdb5771a6efa9e1c396f45"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:561027502ea348144ef6e64c1dfeea0db72f8d873de0d2a01e901ecebfc61e4a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d62","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:561027502ea348144ef6e64c1dfeea0db72f8d873de0d2a01e901ecebfc61e4a","textSha256":"8ba94a6db714b10446aecfd77c65007c9f2af0f0d50a87322d549cb3db24119c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:24ff9f18cbc6cb6c219c8ef0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:24ff9f18cbc6cb6c219c8ef0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:561027502ea348144ef6e64c1dfeea0db72f8d873de0d2a01e901ecebfc61e4a","q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b"],"scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","contributionContentSha256":"3ccf28bb3c391ff3c3f2abe92cf4bfc6ec043936d712c49a592c4d0cc108c034","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d62","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:561027502ea348144ef6e64c1dfeea0db72f8d873de0d2a01e901ecebfc61e4a","textSha256":"8ba94a6db714b10446aecfd77c65007c9f2af0f0d50a87322d549cb3db24119c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:24ff9f18cbc6cb6c219c8ef0","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Dataset-conditioned curvature/coupling inference and small-scale compatibility remain separate tests; no current preference is independently established.","challengeNote":"Dataset-conditioned curvature/coupling inference and small-scale gravity compatibility are separate tests.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:617119be7fe370fd838b7c471967f8619be8d649e41a22d8827d1fef0caa92cb","home":{"unitId":"unit:617119be7fe370fd838b7c471967f8619be8d649e41a22d8827d1fef0caa92cb","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:617119be7fe370fd838b7c471967f8619be8d649e41a22d8827d1fef0caa92cb","paperId":"1811.00554","textSha256":"91d4d433931ee36456103def1cbee580c674b8e74ed8bd8316d3c7fcaf59b4ea"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:45c0f12b58779533b9bd91de"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:45c0f12b58779533b9bd91de","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:617119be7fe370fd838b7c471967f8619be8d649e41a22d8827d1fef0caa92cb","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"9c055444213ccaf62bcd76dc91ad67f95d7126dcce81d7ae0726df4f2ad2e5ae","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:617119be7fe370fd838b7c471967f8619be8d649e41a22d8827d1fef0caa92cb","paperId":"1811.00554","textSha256":"91d4d433931ee36456103def1cbee580c674b8e74ed8bd8316d3c7fcaf59b4ea"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:45c0f12b58779533b9bd91de"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:617119be7fe370fd838b7c471967f8619be8d649e41a22d8827d1fef0caa92cb","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:617119be7fe370fd838b7c471967f8619be8d649e41a22d8827d1fef0caa92cb","textSha256":"91d4d433931ee36456103def1cbee580c674b8e74ed8bd8316d3c7fcaf59b4ea"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:32e4e4ce20f0112e4baf23d3"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:32e4e4ce20f0112e4baf23d3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:617119be7fe370fd838b7c471967f8619be8d649e41a22d8827d1fef0caa92cb","q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b"],"scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","contributionContentSha256":"26395d87707580542d7abf5a2666a6a840951fb9f83d2d18a466142c84876ee8","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:617119be7fe370fd838b7c471967f8619be8d649e41a22d8827d1fef0caa92cb","textSha256":"91d4d433931ee36456103def1cbee580c674b8e74ed8bd8316d3c7fcaf59b4ea"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:32e4e4ce20f0112e4baf23d3","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Initial displacement controls rolling independently of hilltop height and tachyonic curvature.","challengeNote":"Initial displacement controls rolling alongside hilltop height and tachyonic curvature.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:8efe02c2be06f2d94959d3a375a15381a1f8213eaaea188699be5d962d4ae5f7","home":{"unitId":"unit:8efe02c2be06f2d94959d3a375a15381a1f8213eaaea188699be5d962d4ae5f7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8efe02c2be06f2d94959d3a375a15381a1f8213eaaea188699be5d962d4ae5f7","paperId":"1809.00154","textSha256":"57e1d00b10e65f17e5d5168918595f82d9f7596b4ad6819dc6a20414facd4fec"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:249e2ffb7e7d2af1d2922a3a"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:249e2ffb7e7d2af1d2922a3a","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8efe02c2be06f2d94959d3a375a15381a1f8213eaaea188699be5d962d4ae5f7","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"dc662f8df2163f0ffcd241a93394d81289594dfe070f567f7c3253257f70d866","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8efe02c2be06f2d94959d3a375a15381a1f8213eaaea188699be5d962d4ae5f7","paperId":"1809.00154","textSha256":"57e1d00b10e65f17e5d5168918595f82d9f7596b4ad6819dc6a20414facd4fec"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:249e2ffb7e7d2af1d2922a3a"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8efe02c2be06f2d94959d3a375a15381a1f8213eaaea188699be5d962d4ae5f7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d17","kind":"description","unitIndex":17,"unitId":"unit:8efe02c2be06f2d94959d3a375a15381a1f8213eaaea188699be5d962d4ae5f7","textSha256":"57e1d00b10e65f17e5d5168918595f82d9f7596b4ad6819dc6a20414facd4fec"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:81f8ccc10080c5d05ec286c9"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:81f8ccc10080c5d05ec286c9","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8efe02c2be06f2d94959d3a375a15381a1f8213eaaea188699be5d962d4ae5f7","q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b"],"scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","contributionContentSha256":"46e06944c4116f1fcca2de8a853a7daf0bef604335d1f90bec20fdf33e0e740f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d17","kind":"description","unitIndex":17,"unitId":"unit:8efe02c2be06f2d94959d3a375a15381a1f8213eaaea188699be5d962d4ae5f7","textSha256":"57e1d00b10e65f17e5d5168918595f82d9f7596b4ad6819dc6a20414facd4fec"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:81f8ccc10080c5d05ec286c9","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:90a7d69c80c6ec390aa2401801e7c1e86b8bf69e2e7070c68be5478de1b1dfdd","home":{"unitId":"unit:90a7d69c80c6ec390aa2401801e7c1e86b8bf69e2e7070c68be5478de1b1dfdd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:90a7d69c80c6ec390aa2401801e7c1e86b8bf69e2e7070c68be5478de1b1dfdd","paperId":"1811.03164","textSha256":"9c264557cd5744264786278f775b35612d061997c888109392ea7d51b48806ab"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b7e8e93c34d9f61d44550386"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b7e8e93c34d9f61d44550386","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:90a7d69c80c6ec390aa2401801e7c1e86b8bf69e2e7070c68be5478de1b1dfdd","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"873689dac78d3d997c0c06d576afa0add97feb33b6b67c7dbfeef1736682902d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:90a7d69c80c6ec390aa2401801e7c1e86b8bf69e2e7070c68be5478de1b1dfdd","paperId":"1811.03164","textSha256":"9c264557cd5744264786278f775b35612d061997c888109392ea7d51b48806ab"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b7e8e93c34d9f61d44550386"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:90a7d69c80c6ec390aa2401801e7c1e86b8bf69e2e7070c68be5478de1b1dfdd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:90a7d69c80c6ec390aa2401801e7c1e86b8bf69e2e7070c68be5478de1b1dfdd","textSha256":"9c264557cd5744264786278f775b35612d061997c888109392ea7d51b48806ab"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f871263181356255b83f2955"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f871263181356255b83f2955","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:90a7d69c80c6ec390aa2401801e7c1e86b8bf69e2e7070c68be5478de1b1dfdd","q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b"],"scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","contributionContentSha256":"fd0907901521244ffd3192f4db50d3cbdc76bebd68393ed4812171ba9f32d63e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:90a7d69c80c6ec390aa2401801e7c1e86b8bf69e2e7070c68be5478de1b1dfdd","textSha256":"9c264557cd5744264786278f775b35612d061997c888109392ea7d51b48806ab"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f871263181356255b83f2955","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Detecting time dependence and identifying potential shape are distinct inference targets.","challengeNote":"Detecting time dependence and identifying potential shape remain distinct targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a1ca894be0a4b50b3a6f0d6c0072574b5404b31d47da4ee774ef877e9fa3654e","home":{"unitId":"unit:a1ca894be0a4b50b3a6f0d6c0072574b5404b31d47da4ee774ef877e9fa3654e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a1ca894be0a4b50b3a6f0d6c0072574b5404b31d47da4ee774ef877e9fa3654e","paperId":"2008.05465","textSha256":"c7c3ef14728f6c1f1dbea8f9f3c641c31c58b90b14d7003d39a1314119f35753"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eff4dd937dd3ffc7dfea219e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eff4dd937dd3ffc7dfea219e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a1ca894be0a4b50b3a6f0d6c0072574b5404b31d47da4ee774ef877e9fa3654e","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"19c9c419effa80a96e9695244c5c3d8d5d0e8594b3ebd907b735116a7ec2cb97","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a1ca894be0a4b50b3a6f0d6c0072574b5404b31d47da4ee774ef877e9fa3654e","paperId":"2008.05465","textSha256":"c7c3ef14728f6c1f1dbea8f9f3c641c31c58b90b14d7003d39a1314119f35753"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eff4dd937dd3ffc7dfea219e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a1ca894be0a4b50b3a6f0d6c0072574b5404b31d47da4ee774ef877e9fa3654e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d48","kind":"description","unitIndex":48,"unitId":"unit:a1ca894be0a4b50b3a6f0d6c0072574b5404b31d47da4ee774ef877e9fa3654e","textSha256":"c7c3ef14728f6c1f1dbea8f9f3c641c31c58b90b14d7003d39a1314119f35753"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7ca0d48caf184e1275cbda99"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7ca0d48caf184e1275cbda99","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a1ca894be0a4b50b3a6f0d6c0072574b5404b31d47da4ee774ef877e9fa3654e","q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b"],"scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","contributionContentSha256":"ce23bd31644f1b76ccdde3509e27865d1bc9cf58cdae549cc68224d3e3e56629","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d48","kind":"description","unitIndex":48,"unitId":"unit:a1ca894be0a4b50b3a6f0d6c0072574b5404b31d47da4ee774ef877e9fa3654e","textSha256":"c7c3ef14728f6c1f1dbea8f9f3c641c31c58b90b14d7003d39a1314119f35753"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7ca0d48caf184e1275cbda99","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d8697a4074d155f86a26950951270c2978f2092fd5449ce97e9eaac87e9f1c15","home":{"unitId":"unit:d8697a4074d155f86a26950951270c2978f2092fd5449ce97e9eaac87e9f1c15","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d8697a4074d155f86a26950951270c2978f2092fd5449ce97e9eaac87e9f1c15","paperId":"2101.04666","textSha256":"6a20a8dcec9ed1f8ccb654f890ed664d450ffa49b2e03d2ad413f7f8bafab936"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:397ff8247b61c1d3f07fb481"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:397ff8247b61c1d3f07fb481","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d8697a4074d155f86a26950951270c2978f2092fd5449ce97e9eaac87e9f1c15","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"4952cb4884453bd30706d77162ea2af79cf520f9f926948a05a14cc00fae12a3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d8697a4074d155f86a26950951270c2978f2092fd5449ce97e9eaac87e9f1c15","paperId":"2101.04666","textSha256":"6a20a8dcec9ed1f8ccb654f890ed664d450ffa49b2e03d2ad413f7f8bafab936"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:397ff8247b61c1d3f07fb481"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d8697a4074d155f86a26950951270c2978f2092fd5449ce97e9eaac87e9f1c15","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d53","kind":"description","unitIndex":53,"unitId":"unit:d8697a4074d155f86a26950951270c2978f2092fd5449ce97e9eaac87e9f1c15","textSha256":"6a20a8dcec9ed1f8ccb654f890ed664d450ffa49b2e03d2ad413f7f8bafab936"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8d3ac191eff94033692030e4"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8d3ac191eff94033692030e4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d8697a4074d155f86a26950951270c2978f2092fd5449ce97e9eaac87e9f1c15","q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b"],"scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","contributionContentSha256":"290d800864ec7a92a26499fac6aae1ae7fe517defc29f31d2e79961253a373f0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d53","kind":"description","unitIndex":53,"unitId":"unit:d8697a4074d155f86a26950951270c2978f2092fd5449ce97e9eaac87e9f1c15","textSha256":"6a20a8dcec9ed1f8ccb654f890ed664d450ffa49b2e03d2ad413f7f8bafab936"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8d3ac191eff94033692030e4","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound slope, curvature and excursion diagnostics on the reconstructed positive potential.","challengeNote":"Compound slope, curvature and excursion diagnostics of a reconstructed positive potential.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d8eccad8cb9e9e073b037d513f12fe82f39c08054945c3e6519a8d2022384b82","home":{"unitId":"unit:d8eccad8cb9e9e073b037d513f12fe82f39c08054945c3e6519a8d2022384b82","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d8eccad8cb9e9e073b037d513f12fe82f39c08054945c3e6519a8d2022384b82","paperId":"1809.04854","textSha256":"c323a352d71f11632c8d80bcfab3400ae495a4b07ba060d9e717a5bea81a34b5"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5c28fd03e6327a3e8e1fe9d6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5c28fd03e6327a3e8e1fe9d6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d8eccad8cb9e9e073b037d513f12fe82f39c08054945c3e6519a8d2022384b82","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"244583f4c9d8fb6e244d0542cab0943a16d8a40d37a8477d51f9e6301c2be13a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d8eccad8cb9e9e073b037d513f12fe82f39c08054945c3e6519a8d2022384b82","paperId":"1809.04854","textSha256":"c323a352d71f11632c8d80bcfab3400ae495a4b07ba060d9e717a5bea81a34b5"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5c28fd03e6327a3e8e1fe9d6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d8eccad8cb9e9e073b037d513f12fe82f39c08054945c3e6519a8d2022384b82","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:d8eccad8cb9e9e073b037d513f12fe82f39c08054945c3e6519a8d2022384b82","textSha256":"c323a352d71f11632c8d80bcfab3400ae495a4b07ba060d9e717a5bea81a34b5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a2750427a4510bf90dc47ad4"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a2750427a4510bf90dc47ad4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d8eccad8cb9e9e073b037d513f12fe82f39c08054945c3e6519a8d2022384b82","q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b"],"scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","contributionContentSha256":"ed754ad8d5cf50654862c7de82b964b000d62c92e31e6690d18e45439e2306ee","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:d8eccad8cb9e9e073b037d513f12fe82f39c08054945c3e6519a8d2022384b82","textSha256":"c323a352d71f11632c8d80bcfab3400ae495a4b07ba060d9e717a5bea81a34b5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a2750427a4510bf90dc47ad4","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":11,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"8c24ee7a2177716fa00f7502904aa64dc8d98470c10e66fa46ebcd43504e09d8"},"organizational-access:0ef209ed95bdd62c5dfe8ee9":{"id":"organizational-access:0ef209ed95bdd62c5dfe8ee9","source":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","target":"q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:43ad89e4e2ad7abd05dd9665"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"180f1b26eea91a8928c13ef8e091163bdb7576381d7b769b3a164f09e93feeb6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ff005957536bac1812fa8219"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1cae5b228a3e171707f63547f3b65e3f6e765e2b299d64b356c4a09fddcb1e34","home":{"unitId":"unit:1cae5b228a3e171707f63547f3b65e3f6e765e2b299d64b356c4a09fddcb1e34","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Dynamics and selection in source-specific string compactifications, including their low-energy consequences, are explicit targets of q11.","qualification":"q11 covers proposed selection and its possible consequences for flux quanta, generation number and compactification scale. The restriction to a nonsupersymmetric heterotic family is essential; neither broad model-building coverage nor a proposed potential establishes successful physical selection.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1cae5b228a3e171707f63547f3b65e3f6e765e2b299d64b356c4a09fddcb1e34","paperId":"2511.04145","textSha256":"fceb5c60f9dbe35d6cc4476919a93d7eb1ba379cffa52a1e214cc5edeef27ad4"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0004:u16:q11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0004:u16:q11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1cae5b228a3e171707f63547f3b65e3f6e765e2b299d64b356c4a09fddcb1e34","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"1459fd95952dff6f37f61dc4cb99a1bfbb36a38c8246a5885256fe1b312ce41d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0004:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0004:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1cae5b228a3e171707f63547f3b65e3f6e765e2b299d64b356c4a09fddcb1e34","paperId":"2511.04145","textSha256":"fceb5c60f9dbe35d6cc4476919a93d7eb1ba379cffa52a1e214cc5edeef27ad4"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0004","unitRef":"u16"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1cae5b228a3e171707f63547f3b65e3f6e765e2b299d64b356c4a09fddcb1e34","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:1cae5b228a3e171707f63547f3b65e3f6e765e2b299d64b356c4a09fddcb1e34","textSha256":"fceb5c60f9dbe35d6cc4476919a93d7eb1ba379cffa52a1e214cc5edeef27ad4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cdd8e36cd8053e6a68b09ba1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:cdd8e36cd8053e6a68b09ba1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1cae5b228a3e171707f63547f3b65e3f6e765e2b299d64b356c4a09fddcb1e34","q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5"],"scopeContentSha256":"180f1b26eea91a8928c13ef8e091163bdb7576381d7b769b3a164f09e93feeb6","contributionContentSha256":"f6f71120bbfd58152758c014a754f3c3fbd98c791c97069fe95da61e4546acb8","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:1cae5b228a3e171707f63547f3b65e3f6e765e2b299d64b356c4a09fddcb1e34","textSha256":"fceb5c60f9dbe35d6cc4476919a93d7eb1ba379cffa52a1e214cc5edeef27ad4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cdd8e36cd8053e6a68b09ba1","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Proposed potential within a restricted nonsupersymmetric family; successful physical selection is not established here.","challengeNote":"Selection by the proposed potential remains restricted to the stated nonsupersymmetric heterotic family.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","home":{"unitId":"unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","paperId":"1811.09282","textSha256":"6511505ddb2cf8a11445de636d4abeca8f52338414f97009e3b12e8f0e87e0fd"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:43299369fd3b0fd76b56a4d8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:43299369fd3b0fd76b56a4d8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"b775f14fd8f1dd8ed10a38e5a913e34d8a5f311071ca7354e43c140900c261a5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","paperId":"1811.09282","textSha256":"6511505ddb2cf8a11445de636d4abeca8f52338414f97009e3b12e8f0e87e0fd"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:43299369fd3b0fd76b56a4d8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","textSha256":"6511505ddb2cf8a11445de636d4abeca8f52338414f97009e3b12e8f0e87e0fd"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c6039c8c466330b19f05d9f1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c6039c8c466330b19f05d9f1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5"],"scopeContentSha256":"180f1b26eea91a8928c13ef8e091163bdb7576381d7b769b3a164f09e93feeb6","contributionContentSha256":"04e03034cff08761893e880e1c22e9a25a42107909f4c2c9dcc5e482715c48e0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","textSha256":"6511505ddb2cf8a11445de636d4abeca8f52338414f97009e3b12e8f0e87e0fd"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c6039c8c466330b19f05d9f1","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","home":{"unitId":"unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","paperId":"0904.4601","textSha256":"3d404d207a91cd29c46bcea11bed37344008b9d20feedba3be6fb14715fac554"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:35b4febe482d468861a43025"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:35b4febe482d468861a43025","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"3d93d9dcbeacd972bbb4ae10e4481fd656ca0ce0fa457f730ff187e180846298","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","paperId":"0904.4601","textSha256":"3d404d207a91cd29c46bcea11bed37344008b9d20feedba3be6fb14715fac554"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:35b4febe482d468861a43025"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","textSha256":"3d404d207a91cd29c46bcea11bed37344008b9d20feedba3be6fb14715fac554"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0dd0768a041a3a105ff075a1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0dd0768a041a3a105ff075a1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5"],"scopeContentSha256":"180f1b26eea91a8928c13ef8e091163bdb7576381d7b769b3a164f09e93feeb6","contributionContentSha256":"79c05f3be76424b624fbc21d72bd5e4b8a8539c4598f3a605fdc853bfb9197af","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","textSha256":"3d404d207a91cd29c46bcea11bed37344008b9d20feedba3be6fb14715fac554"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0dd0768a041a3a105ff075a1","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound review spanning model construction, statistics and cosmological signatures.","challengeNote":"Compound review of construction, statistics and particle/cosmological signatures.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","home":{"unitId":"unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","paperId":"2310.20559","textSha256":"62736f351d73808f031c5ad9a0b3680d2bb146f2d6a25c8b50ee11fc63b6ff10"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dda39a55c34d4b5aafe052aa"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dda39a55c34d4b5aafe052aa","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"91d1215083a39245cabeebea425f9ed1e5b451ef0f61dfb4a021ce4ee1fd14d0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","paperId":"2310.20559","textSha256":"62736f351d73808f031c5ad9a0b3680d2bb146f2d6a25c8b50ee11fc63b6ff10"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dda39a55c34d4b5aafe052aa"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","textSha256":"62736f351d73808f031c5ad9a0b3680d2bb146f2d6a25c8b50ee11fc63b6ff10"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f58bfe2dd2f13a8dfe98d58b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f58bfe2dd2f13a8dfe98d58b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5"],"scopeContentSha256":"180f1b26eea91a8928c13ef8e091163bdb7576381d7b769b3a164f09e93feeb6","contributionContentSha256":"d5888629ca7390447d03308a2fccd0cd809d329bf575c56e53c9339203eb64dc","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","textSha256":"62736f351d73808f031c5ad9a0b3680d2bb146f2d6a25c8b50ee11fc63b6ff10"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f58bfe2dd2f13a8dfe98d58b","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound construction, control and phenomenological/cosmological requirements.","challengeNote":"Compound construction, control and phenomenological/cosmological requirements.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:dc5d5bb1ea6e6bdf18708808d361917dc635ccb7f88c5c9a8cf6f35a39b1a603","home":{"unitId":"unit:dc5d5bb1ea6e6bdf18708808d361917dc635ccb7f88c5c9a8cf6f35a39b1a603","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:dc5d5bb1ea6e6bdf18708808d361917dc635ccb7f88c5c9a8cf6f35a39b1a603","paperId":"1404.7359","textSha256":"16e5ae884724e7f6151548abd840ef4a5349cac6389c1eedd817412defa103f7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4100db1e1dcadf94e0ec063d"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4100db1e1dcadf94e0ec063d","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:dc5d5bb1ea6e6bdf18708808d361917dc635ccb7f88c5c9a8cf6f35a39b1a603","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"db05f3ce188631af8d1ee8021ba909f9e43a8b8018c6e558eea87d991958f202","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:dc5d5bb1ea6e6bdf18708808d361917dc635ccb7f88c5c9a8cf6f35a39b1a603","paperId":"1404.7359","textSha256":"16e5ae884724e7f6151548abd840ef4a5349cac6389c1eedd817412defa103f7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4100db1e1dcadf94e0ec063d"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:dc5d5bb1ea6e6bdf18708808d361917dc635ccb7f88c5c9a8cf6f35a39b1a603","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:dc5d5bb1ea6e6bdf18708808d361917dc635ccb7f88c5c9a8cf6f35a39b1a603","textSha256":"16e5ae884724e7f6151548abd840ef4a5349cac6389c1eedd817412defa103f7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f7e2d2e353bd0adebdd99bf2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f7e2d2e353bd0adebdd99bf2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:dc5d5bb1ea6e6bdf18708808d361917dc635ccb7f88c5c9a8cf6f35a39b1a603","q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5"],"scopeContentSha256":"180f1b26eea91a8928c13ef8e091163bdb7576381d7b769b3a164f09e93feeb6","contributionContentSha256":"dfa9ea8914b605ca55774429ba5781d056465bc97ac965587b9a87625659c664","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:dc5d5bb1ea6e6bdf18708808d361917dc635ccb7f88c5c9a8cf6f35a39b1a603","textSha256":"16e5ae884724e7f6151548abd840ef4a5349cac6389c1eedd817412defa103f7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f7e2d2e353bd0adebdd99bf2","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Convergence offers indirect evidence about the encoded landscape, not a completeness proof.","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","home":{"unitId":"unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","paperId":"1212.0555","textSha256":"c180947d17f1f742fd6ff41a1902dbb09cd1d08d5a24706710e7dd7faf547697"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:64e06c07845fe92a09dbb94e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:64e06c07845fe92a09dbb94e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"6cf317ee564afadd4752bebb7f1887e1a2fec7c3642a241eed993e41385facbe","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","paperId":"1212.0555","textSha256":"c180947d17f1f742fd6ff41a1902dbb09cd1d08d5a24706710e7dd7faf547697"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:64e06c07845fe92a09dbb94e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","textSha256":"c180947d17f1f742fd6ff41a1902dbb09cd1d08d5a24706710e7dd7faf547697"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b575caf87303f7cb738d17ea"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b575caf87303f7cb738d17ea","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","q025-candidate-question:df23596dbeaa76de4c2a16c5"],"scopeContentSha256":"180f1b26eea91a8928c13ef8e091163bdb7576381d7b769b3a164f09e93feeb6","contributionContentSha256":"d2f45d5b40f5e52a062ceb22a7b0337a2ba48eb09299a105b83a3152da33b390","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","textSha256":"c180947d17f1f742fd6ff41a1902dbb09cd1d08d5a24706710e7dd7faf547697"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b575caf87303f7cb738d17ea","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"Combined stabilization, SUSY-breaking and particle-sector construction targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":6,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ab81f9d4354271db4e078cda1ef74958e147bb1d39879343a472e537218565cc"},"organizational-access:6fac2c555e0f56b8df4f0302":{"id":"organizational-access:6fac2c555e0f56b8df4f0302","source":"q025-candidate-region:beaaa0449eb11baa0bec0654","target":"q025-candidate-question:88a53ffd232533388c7b4dbf","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:beaaa0449eb11baa0bec0654","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"f29a49b587f59df30e5f46d5c0a90f6195e623abaa176e59e413d219bd1cf60c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:219ac776184d3707e3c03743"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:88a53ffd232533388c7b4dbf","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ce6eed737c503018d6b6988f81506885571aa506a44e873096505c7cb2d81e78","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6d33e0f91d3cfd5860485857"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:29aa205487a31e9be8589777ecdbbd77f9b309f9bb831311a71154a08825340c","home":{"unitId":"unit:29aa205487a31e9be8589777ecdbbd77f9b309f9bb831311a71154a08825340c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:beaaa0449eb11baa0bec0654","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:29aa205487a31e9be8589777ecdbbd77f9b309f9bb831311a71154a08825340c","paperId":"0910.0673","textSha256":"1eee954b4d2a8809774854982c08e5d6d14dc8226908566518d6aa9460093f13"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bb01fce82d881c84079fbcc9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bb01fce82d881c84079fbcc9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:29aa205487a31e9be8589777ecdbbd77f9b309f9bb831311a71154a08825340c","q025-candidate-region:beaaa0449eb11baa0bec0654"],"scopeContentSha256":"f29a49b587f59df30e5f46d5c0a90f6195e623abaa176e59e413d219bd1cf60c","placementContentSha256":"af70e51bad72078ad999bf3660146bc79aadf32c8c2049ab101a00deaebc723d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-challenge","leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:29aa205487a31e9be8589777ecdbbd77f9b309f9bb831311a71154a08825340c","paperId":"0910.0673","textSha256":"1eee954b4d2a8809774854982c08e5d6d14dc8226908566518d6aa9460093f13"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bb01fce82d881c84079fbcc9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:29aa205487a31e9be8589777ecdbbd77f9b309f9bb831311a71154a08825340c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:88a53ffd232533388c7b4dbf","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:29aa205487a31e9be8589777ecdbbd77f9b309f9bb831311a71154a08825340c","textSha256":"1eee954b4d2a8809774854982c08e5d6d14dc8226908566518d6aa9460093f13"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:77f80a6b70270017b11d982a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:77f80a6b70270017b11d982a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:29aa205487a31e9be8589777ecdbbd77f9b309f9bb831311a71154a08825340c","q025-candidate-question:88a53ffd232533388c7b4dbf"],"scopeContentSha256":"ce6eed737c503018d6b6988f81506885571aa506a44e873096505c7cb2d81e78","contributionContentSha256":"7746316178a4eea1955865ea22200596f9a82a1b1f8b0cd48ac472e4520770a1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-proposal","leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:29aa205487a31e9be8589777ecdbbd77f9b309f9bb831311a71154a08825340c","textSha256":"1eee954b4d2a8809774854982c08e5d6d14dc8226908566518d6aa9460093f13"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:77f80a6b70270017b11d982a","recordId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: observable discreteness, dated program assessment and moving-source transmission are distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Discreteness signatures, dated program assessment and moving-source transmission remain distinct targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c9b3aa824aa4206a120296405f027d9fc3e87f250f79fa936de06714a8de333d","home":{"unitId":"unit:c9b3aa824aa4206a120296405f027d9fc3e87f250f79fa936de06714a8de333d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:beaaa0449eb11baa0bec0654","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c9b3aa824aa4206a120296405f027d9fc3e87f250f79fa936de06714a8de333d","paperId":"0709.2365","textSha256":"76b048fd8ea119488e8fc0cc8ce3bd9dbb647056e37437db3075dcc230701c2b"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:41b59e42156510e6dcca1894"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:41b59e42156510e6dcca1894","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c9b3aa824aa4206a120296405f027d9fc3e87f250f79fa936de06714a8de333d","q025-candidate-region:beaaa0449eb11baa0bec0654"],"scopeContentSha256":"f29a49b587f59df30e5f46d5c0a90f6195e623abaa176e59e413d219bd1cf60c","placementContentSha256":"882aefe9167357fcc785d85eee118c30b41e3ee07f6ac6c664dcc6097e29ea9a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-challenge","leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c9b3aa824aa4206a120296405f027d9fc3e87f250f79fa936de06714a8de333d","paperId":"0709.2365","textSha256":"76b048fd8ea119488e8fc0cc8ce3bd9dbb647056e37437db3075dcc230701c2b"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:41b59e42156510e6dcca1894"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c9b3aa824aa4206a120296405f027d9fc3e87f250f79fa936de06714a8de333d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:88a53ffd232533388c7b4dbf","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:c9b3aa824aa4206a120296405f027d9fc3e87f250f79fa936de06714a8de333d","textSha256":"76b048fd8ea119488e8fc0cc8ce3bd9dbb647056e37437db3075dcc230701c2b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:317ab0a84c38ea6b6c8534ea"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:317ab0a84c38ea6b6c8534ea","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c9b3aa824aa4206a120296405f027d9fc3e87f250f79fa936de06714a8de333d","q025-candidate-question:88a53ffd232533388c7b4dbf"],"scopeContentSha256":"ce6eed737c503018d6b6988f81506885571aa506a44e873096505c7cb2d81e78","contributionContentSha256":"e98b61c5135a4fe60d9002c4393c302d49f7175eebf5c558dcb0f8666d5dc741","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-proposal","leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:c9b3aa824aa4206a120296405f027d9fc3e87f250f79fa936de06714a8de333d","textSha256":"76b048fd8ea119488e8fc0cc8ce3bd9dbb647056e37437db3075dcc230701c2b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:317ab0a84c38ea6b6c8534ea","recordId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: shared gravitational/electromagnetic cones and stability/closure constraints on discrete-state evolution require separate fine reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Shared wave cones and stability/constraint-closure restrictions on discrete-state evolution require separate fine reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"858200be18eddf66791b9e406cc99bef956c0871d04ec1e05cfb419c78e70ee5"},"organizational-access:523512c3024eb12c9839ee5b":{"id":"organizational-access:523512c3024eb12c9839ee5b","source":"q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51","target":"q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"d3f7138201941f5392c7965425260297e0654776f08734a7cde28d7a1fd2932f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c40213cb2b4fefffa2b110aa"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"d5494f718c89bb27ce3bb84b3f1fbe78067966f98d2e61b722b6d91452712772","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d5144c13adebd1b7d85856bd"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:162e9236c1f275190e7104c7d7e1b457ca8442a1d12efef80e4a9458fa84ad1a","home":{"unitId":"unit:162e9236c1f275190e7104c7d7e1b457ca8442a1d12efef80e4a9458fa84ad1a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:162e9236c1f275190e7104c7d7e1b457ca8442a1d12efef80e4a9458fa84ad1a","paperId":"0810.4251","textSha256":"a4cf172621954b6fe921cd44ce5e18bfce1d996349f4b9b482d4ead957f89778"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6fb0d255b45403e1e425d36c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6fb0d255b45403e1e425d36c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:162e9236c1f275190e7104c7d7e1b457ca8442a1d12efef80e4a9458fa84ad1a","q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51"],"scopeContentSha256":"d3f7138201941f5392c7965425260297e0654776f08734a7cde28d7a1fd2932f","placementContentSha256":"e46b0ba2a55825d68dd7af2621a0eedc0d2a374ba379272a009f18e48854959b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:162e9236c1f275190e7104c7d7e1b457ca8442a1d12efef80e4a9458fa84ad1a","paperId":"0810.4251","textSha256":"a4cf172621954b6fe921cd44ce5e18bfce1d996349f4b9b482d4ead957f89778"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6fb0d255b45403e1e425d36c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:162e9236c1f275190e7104c7d7e1b457ca8442a1d12efef80e4a9458fa84ad1a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:162e9236c1f275190e7104c7d7e1b457ca8442a1d12efef80e4a9458fa84ad1a","textSha256":"a4cf172621954b6fe921cd44ce5e18bfce1d996349f4b9b482d4ead957f89778"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:17c2c52df6673d9ef370e545"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:17c2c52df6673d9ef370e545","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:162e9236c1f275190e7104c7d7e1b457ca8442a1d12efef80e4a9458fa84ad1a","q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5494f718c89bb27ce3bb84b3f1fbe78067966f98d2e61b722b6d91452712772","contributionContentSha256":"2592c3b4ffaded29a127f4012f3473017b605ae1da5e3176cbc891ce4a194bfa","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:162e9236c1f275190e7104c7d7e1b457ca8442a1d12efef80e4a9458fa84ad1a","textSha256":"a4cf172621954b6fe921cd44ce5e18bfce1d996349f4b9b482d4ead957f89778"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:17c2c52df6673d9ef370e545","recordId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:19394978dce2b45d32760bad79de42ee2f41e7f14fc640cbaf22bf81c5a05cc1","home":{"unitId":"unit:19394978dce2b45d32760bad79de42ee2f41e7f14fc640cbaf22bf81c5a05cc1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:19394978dce2b45d32760bad79de42ee2f41e7f14fc640cbaf22bf81c5a05cc1","paperId":"1902.02365","textSha256":"a0d1f0ee9de23fcee90871ceedf973a0226916c9d77c55d074c656b1c6739292"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7db89ebb90adfe0362fa110b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7db89ebb90adfe0362fa110b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:19394978dce2b45d32760bad79de42ee2f41e7f14fc640cbaf22bf81c5a05cc1","q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51"],"scopeContentSha256":"d3f7138201941f5392c7965425260297e0654776f08734a7cde28d7a1fd2932f","placementContentSha256":"1819d6aef7196703e66af51f0a211d0cc96dfd989af8a76e25902171097d3024","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:19394978dce2b45d32760bad79de42ee2f41e7f14fc640cbaf22bf81c5a05cc1","paperId":"1902.02365","textSha256":"a0d1f0ee9de23fcee90871ceedf973a0226916c9d77c55d074c656b1c6739292"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7db89ebb90adfe0362fa110b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:19394978dce2b45d32760bad79de42ee2f41e7f14fc640cbaf22bf81c5a05cc1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:19394978dce2b45d32760bad79de42ee2f41e7f14fc640cbaf22bf81c5a05cc1","textSha256":"a0d1f0ee9de23fcee90871ceedf973a0226916c9d77c55d074c656b1c6739292"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a8df5cc354da3c280a9084d6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a8df5cc354da3c280a9084d6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:19394978dce2b45d32760bad79de42ee2f41e7f14fc640cbaf22bf81c5a05cc1","q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5494f718c89bb27ce3bb84b3f1fbe78067966f98d2e61b722b6d91452712772","contributionContentSha256":"098e5cc8c37ed00e3ed6ad77f6ab734fccfd711ffbfa14608791abd9e15a9659","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:19394978dce2b45d32760bad79de42ee2f41e7f14fc640cbaf22bf81c5a05cc1","textSha256":"a0d1f0ee9de23fcee90871ceedf973a0226916c9d77c55d074c656b1c6739292"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a8df5cc354da3c280a9084d6","recordId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:346d00c27f5022cc9f6fa5898d7b16626e2c398ef34470bf852fef114bca45e8","home":{"unitId":"unit:346d00c27f5022cc9f6fa5898d7b16626e2c398ef34470bf852fef114bca45e8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:346d00c27f5022cc9f6fa5898d7b16626e2c398ef34470bf852fef114bca45e8","paperId":"1106.6025","textSha256":"edf824be87ba62695705555d315cb0e9123515233d35216c488b4da810219d6e"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b56b5180b875d01db76262e4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b56b5180b875d01db76262e4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:346d00c27f5022cc9f6fa5898d7b16626e2c398ef34470bf852fef114bca45e8","q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51"],"scopeContentSha256":"d3f7138201941f5392c7965425260297e0654776f08734a7cde28d7a1fd2932f","placementContentSha256":"b77b1013b02b70364a1131d06d163b68055d92a236b76846f50d58fb91dbd6e3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:346d00c27f5022cc9f6fa5898d7b16626e2c398ef34470bf852fef114bca45e8","paperId":"1106.6025","textSha256":"edf824be87ba62695705555d315cb0e9123515233d35216c488b4da810219d6e"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b56b5180b875d01db76262e4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:346d00c27f5022cc9f6fa5898d7b16626e2c398ef34470bf852fef114bca45e8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:346d00c27f5022cc9f6fa5898d7b16626e2c398ef34470bf852fef114bca45e8","textSha256":"edf824be87ba62695705555d315cb0e9123515233d35216c488b4da810219d6e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3c79677e33f5cb390fe23b7d"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3c79677e33f5cb390fe23b7d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:346d00c27f5022cc9f6fa5898d7b16626e2c398ef34470bf852fef114bca45e8","q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5494f718c89bb27ce3bb84b3f1fbe78067966f98d2e61b722b6d91452712772","contributionContentSha256":"064a3abc1e35844944e6987eaddb1b263a6be3aa4abb02388e1936217b74ef53","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:346d00c27f5022cc9f6fa5898d7b16626e2c398ef34470bf852fef114bca45e8","textSha256":"edf824be87ba62695705555d315cb0e9123515233d35216c488b4da810219d6e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3c79677e33f5cb390fe23b7d","recordId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound construction target includes potential freedom, visible matter and postinflationary moduli/gravitino cosmology.","challengeNote":"Compound construction: potential freedom, visible matter, low-scale breaking and postinflationary moduli/gravitino cosmology require finer reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:366cb2dbe7404daa834aeed7fec73bec2c5a1acd8b359f1233a866963b6fdebd","home":{"unitId":"unit:366cb2dbe7404daa834aeed7fec73bec2c5a1acd8b359f1233a866963b6fdebd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:366cb2dbe7404daa834aeed7fec73bec2c5a1acd8b359f1233a866963b6fdebd","paperId":"1607.01680","textSha256":"e748a047af414262d75e8f96b5e196e5239d3b7877931ad47f43f1d63582192c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6ddc41bea7a1c953c1006b31"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6ddc41bea7a1c953c1006b31","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:366cb2dbe7404daa834aeed7fec73bec2c5a1acd8b359f1233a866963b6fdebd","q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51"],"scopeContentSha256":"d3f7138201941f5392c7965425260297e0654776f08734a7cde28d7a1fd2932f","placementContentSha256":"76a146776d119864dce4054cef6f3467bd2b694e991607b1a2fb3e611bad6415","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:366cb2dbe7404daa834aeed7fec73bec2c5a1acd8b359f1233a866963b6fdebd","paperId":"1607.01680","textSha256":"e748a047af414262d75e8f96b5e196e5239d3b7877931ad47f43f1d63582192c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6ddc41bea7a1c953c1006b31"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:366cb2dbe7404daa834aeed7fec73bec2c5a1acd8b359f1233a866963b6fdebd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:366cb2dbe7404daa834aeed7fec73bec2c5a1acd8b359f1233a866963b6fdebd","textSha256":"e748a047af414262d75e8f96b5e196e5239d3b7877931ad47f43f1d63582192c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:33e60f24410bf979f5b06b1c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:33e60f24410bf979f5b06b1c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:366cb2dbe7404daa834aeed7fec73bec2c5a1acd8b359f1233a866963b6fdebd","q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5494f718c89bb27ce3bb84b3f1fbe78067966f98d2e61b722b6d91452712772","contributionContentSha256":"13d13ff3c8758397ff02f908a9434bb185759e98cf0a0b8e3e423f40fdcebe45","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:366cb2dbe7404daa834aeed7fec73bec2c5a1acd8b359f1233a866963b6fdebd","textSha256":"e748a047af414262d75e8f96b5e196e5239d3b7877931ad47f43f1d63582192c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:33e60f24410bf979f5b06b1c","recordId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:4a5c630365458e16da6974d46770333ceee117927068b7a23fc3df62be422969","home":{"unitId":"unit:4a5c630365458e16da6974d46770333ceee117927068b7a23fc3df62be422969","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4a5c630365458e16da6974d46770333ceee117927068b7a23fc3df62be422969","paperId":"hep-th/0504168","textSha256":"a029a450ab24407792aef68b3ab8f25813601923d2d3dbc0963e07b4d8733254"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:65cba84d1223ce8ec16082bd"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:65cba84d1223ce8ec16082bd","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4a5c630365458e16da6974d46770333ceee117927068b7a23fc3df62be422969","q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51"],"scopeContentSha256":"d3f7138201941f5392c7965425260297e0654776f08734a7cde28d7a1fd2932f","placementContentSha256":"94fcfea005f18e9a9545ab49b4d61a7ffc7ed50f8dd0d023775ccda475d02d29","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4a5c630365458e16da6974d46770333ceee117927068b7a23fc3df62be422969","paperId":"hep-th/0504168","textSha256":"a029a450ab24407792aef68b3ab8f25813601923d2d3dbc0963e07b4d8733254"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:65cba84d1223ce8ec16082bd"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4a5c630365458e16da6974d46770333ceee117927068b7a23fc3df62be422969","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d68","kind":"description","unitIndex":68,"unitId":"unit:4a5c630365458e16da6974d46770333ceee117927068b7a23fc3df62be422969","textSha256":"a029a450ab24407792aef68b3ab8f25813601923d2d3dbc0963e07b4d8733254"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:539ede9c49187f0d5f0612b6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:539ede9c49187f0d5f0612b6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4a5c630365458e16da6974d46770333ceee117927068b7a23fc3df62be422969","q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5494f718c89bb27ce3bb84b3f1fbe78067966f98d2e61b722b6d91452712772","contributionContentSha256":"3eddefe1a5ff6d6cb0b0b0629a602eb39794540b26afeeaa9eca5afd6f5ecda0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d68","kind":"description","unitIndex":68,"unitId":"unit:4a5c630365458e16da6974d46770333ceee117927068b7a23fc3df62be422969","textSha256":"a029a450ab24407792aef68b3ab8f25813601923d2d3dbc0963e07b4d8733254"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:539ede9c49187f0d5f0612b6","recordId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Hybrid inflation is a comparison for the resulting two-field evolution, not an asserted identity.","challengeNote":"Hybrid inflation is a comparison for the resulting two-field evolution, not an asserted identification.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:74028ba763b74865d15a8aa0b180e1e4cfaaf6628f8896f578cb99511def50e6","home":{"unitId":"unit:74028ba763b74865d15a8aa0b180e1e4cfaaf6628f8896f578cb99511def50e6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:74028ba763b74865d15a8aa0b180e1e4cfaaf6628f8896f578cb99511def50e6","paperId":"1509.07748","textSha256":"d4e5dfd17ee23fcf795f64fb8942b8f6bcda13dcf1b9789f6f4bf32b0fab3173"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ff91be221bc09a2911a2fca5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ff91be221bc09a2911a2fca5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:74028ba763b74865d15a8aa0b180e1e4cfaaf6628f8896f578cb99511def50e6","q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51"],"scopeContentSha256":"d3f7138201941f5392c7965425260297e0654776f08734a7cde28d7a1fd2932f","placementContentSha256":"257c9880b3606c44b1ac3745506d31885f03961f2a99e992430333d60524ebb7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:74028ba763b74865d15a8aa0b180e1e4cfaaf6628f8896f578cb99511def50e6","paperId":"1509.07748","textSha256":"d4e5dfd17ee23fcf795f64fb8942b8f6bcda13dcf1b9789f6f4bf32b0fab3173"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ff91be221bc09a2911a2fca5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:74028ba763b74865d15a8aa0b180e1e4cfaaf6628f8896f578cb99511def50e6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:74028ba763b74865d15a8aa0b180e1e4cfaaf6628f8896f578cb99511def50e6","textSha256":"d4e5dfd17ee23fcf795f64fb8942b8f6bcda13dcf1b9789f6f4bf32b0fab3173"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1801ed08377b3a7eb11fdc56"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1801ed08377b3a7eb11fdc56","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:74028ba763b74865d15a8aa0b180e1e4cfaaf6628f8896f578cb99511def50e6","q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5494f718c89bb27ce3bb84b3f1fbe78067966f98d2e61b722b6d91452712772","contributionContentSha256":"759b14a72558ab282ccc3e82b74acdc35a0e4102f33be293633099983c31adce","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:74028ba763b74865d15a8aa0b180e1e4cfaaf6628f8896f578cb99511def50e6","textSha256":"d4e5dfd17ee23fcf795f64fb8942b8f6bcda13dcf1b9789f6f4bf32b0fab3173"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1801ed08377b3a7eb11fdc56","recordId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","home":{"unitId":"unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","paperId":"1503.01777","textSha256":"9e021bdd648713fb2fa0a4b55e77046339db8b3628bfb28329197c56497790cc"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:87c3cf66a375bb88d76f4343fdce5465","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":3496,"textSha256":"727915ee0c75964e3c2018d3269cfc570990d960b7d5ab5085632adb7ca60fb4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8f0ab88755d530002a4d3f89345faae4","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":808,"textSha256":"37baa3889a0a78889b15128b8dc6188062647e465ac779619a8e5ff4b3c8a28d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f8f9460420d4f6c78cde718d3889f09d","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":2,"start":1297,"end":3552,"textSha256":"62e96d09930abfebde28085df00b9afac6a6518fa271b81f16832cb20cbdfec0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1ca5c37f0066d612426ef43b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1ca5c37f0066d612426ef43b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51"],"scopeContentSha256":"d3f7138201941f5392c7965425260297e0654776f08734a7cde28d7a1fd2932f","placementContentSha256":"3cd4b51837c371ec0efa7719d916f1fe26aad9baa0a44722711b904365772456","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","paperId":"1503.01777","textSha256":"9e021bdd648713fb2fa0a4b55e77046339db8b3628bfb28329197c56497790cc"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:87c3cf66a375bb88d76f4343fdce5465","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":3496,"textSha256":"727915ee0c75964e3c2018d3269cfc570990d960b7d5ab5085632adb7ca60fb4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8f0ab88755d530002a4d3f89345faae4","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":808,"textSha256":"37baa3889a0a78889b15128b8dc6188062647e465ac779619a8e5ff4b3c8a28d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f8f9460420d4f6c78cde718d3889f09d","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":2,"start":1297,"end":3552,"textSha256":"62e96d09930abfebde28085df00b9afac6a6518fa271b81f16832cb20cbdfec0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1ca5c37f0066d612426ef43b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d72","kind":"description","unitIndex":72,"unitId":"unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","textSha256":"9e021bdd648713fb2fa0a4b55e77046339db8b3628bfb28329197c56497790cc"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:87c3cf66a375bb88d76f4343fdce5465","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":3496,"textSha256":"727915ee0c75964e3c2018d3269cfc570990d960b7d5ab5085632adb7ca60fb4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8f0ab88755d530002a4d3f89345faae4","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":808,"textSha256":"37baa3889a0a78889b15128b8dc6188062647e465ac779619a8e5ff4b3c8a28d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f8f9460420d4f6c78cde718d3889f09d","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":2,"start":1297,"end":3552,"textSha256":"62e96d09930abfebde28085df00b9afac6a6518fa271b81f16832cb20cbdfec0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f851ab64b271dbc146794dbb"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f851ab64b271dbc146794dbb","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5494f718c89bb27ce3bb84b3f1fbe78067966f98d2e61b722b6d91452712772","contributionContentSha256":"0c02c3bdbfa4daa62441bf5516f0537c24efd52747c18603e75a5ee0af084adb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d72","kind":"description","unitIndex":72,"unitId":"unit:9cd2c98fbe526e1f09ab9b1885e94c9c81dff1a3a42b864a20e36ecb51a177c1","textSha256":"9e021bdd648713fb2fa0a4b55e77046339db8b3628bfb28329197c56497790cc"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:87c3cf66a375bb88d76f4343fdce5465","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":3496,"textSha256":"727915ee0c75964e3c2018d3269cfc570990d960b7d5ab5085632adb7ca60fb4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8f0ab88755d530002a4d3f89345faae4","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":808,"textSha256":"37baa3889a0a78889b15128b8dc6188062647e465ac779619a8e5ff4b3c8a28d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f8f9460420d4f6c78cde718d3889f09d","paperId":"1503.01777","sourceSha256":"9a45cb8617daf70a550a6aa95e7a296f2af586fa03344f38253a6ec83f4a1952","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/bebcd888a41f681f5e08/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"12e7b0faa40e754eb53aec8fadc0678d2bbf7bbd4e70a9b0614bb8b2e635335f","pdfPage":2,"start":1297,"end":3552,"textSha256":"62e96d09930abfebde28085df00b9afac6a6518fa271b81f16832cb20cbdfec0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f851ab64b271dbc146794dbb","recordId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"The 5 Mar 2015 v1 abstract and introduction announce two-axion compatibility; no complete string stabilization or present observational fit is certified.","challengeNote":"The 5 Mar 2015 v1 abstract and introduction announce two-axion compatibility; the full construction and present observational viability are unverified.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:aa3203502f27f32e6815aa8701e8eb8525bc367e395ad4e29c832a8a26356214","home":{"unitId":"unit:aa3203502f27f32e6815aa8701e8eb8525bc367e395ad4e29c832a8a26356214","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:aa3203502f27f32e6815aa8701e8eb8525bc367e395ad4e29c832a8a26356214","paperId":"1702.02173","textSha256":"11c36381ee26cea308f6b1cc3be00bd1b823afc44dbf0eba1e47d389eeb90f0f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:80b6367713db9983c4b7980f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:80b6367713db9983c4b7980f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:aa3203502f27f32e6815aa8701e8eb8525bc367e395ad4e29c832a8a26356214","q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51"],"scopeContentSha256":"d3f7138201941f5392c7965425260297e0654776f08734a7cde28d7a1fd2932f","placementContentSha256":"af20069e4ed2ebb3c52a335afaf92ff70d0d9a64809d7620f327a264513922ef","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:aa3203502f27f32e6815aa8701e8eb8525bc367e395ad4e29c832a8a26356214","paperId":"1702.02173","textSha256":"11c36381ee26cea308f6b1cc3be00bd1b823afc44dbf0eba1e47d389eeb90f0f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:80b6367713db9983c4b7980f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:aa3203502f27f32e6815aa8701e8eb8525bc367e395ad4e29c832a8a26356214","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:aa3203502f27f32e6815aa8701e8eb8525bc367e395ad4e29c832a8a26356214","textSha256":"11c36381ee26cea308f6b1cc3be00bd1b823afc44dbf0eba1e47d389eeb90f0f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:60a96400d79b058077509a2a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:60a96400d79b058077509a2a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:aa3203502f27f32e6815aa8701e8eb8525bc367e395ad4e29c832a8a26356214","q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5494f718c89bb27ce3bb84b3f1fbe78067966f98d2e61b722b6d91452712772","contributionContentSha256":"cbd04084f6ef478a456e82e100de248d0cf1dd15aa0a82dcbb25d8fe051cc947","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:aa3203502f27f32e6815aa8701e8eb8525bc367e395ad4e29c832a8a26356214","textSha256":"11c36381ee26cea308f6b1cc3be00bd1b823afc44dbf0eba1e47d389eeb90f0f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:60a96400d79b058077509a2a","recordId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"FI origin, charged-scalar/modulus stability, tilt and strings are joint construction requirements.","challengeNote":"FI origin, scalar stability, tilt and cosmic strings remain joint requirements, not a single atomic target.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f0ffe3597ce2766b9afc3c6cf8cc12cfdc2bdde6ecf17818cb05e5be11f60c6c","home":{"unitId":"unit:f0ffe3597ce2766b9afc3c6cf8cc12cfdc2bdde6ecf17818cb05e5be11f60c6c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f0ffe3597ce2766b9afc3c6cf8cc12cfdc2bdde6ecf17818cb05e5be11f60c6c","paperId":"2001.09574","textSha256":"2823fd7adfa26ec6744f1873fab58bb011cd81e9a98dfb797b0601a4e7c88983"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e176c23d8e584474e91effd7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e176c23d8e584474e91effd7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f0ffe3597ce2766b9afc3c6cf8cc12cfdc2bdde6ecf17818cb05e5be11f60c6c","q025-candidate-region:ed65857ef24822d8b3c9af51"],"scopeContentSha256":"d3f7138201941f5392c7965425260297e0654776f08734a7cde28d7a1fd2932f","placementContentSha256":"65db1bd9ac24c510c1e7dea62cc735acd3fdb9f46f3641353bc7a507dd7e4b0d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f0ffe3597ce2766b9afc3c6cf8cc12cfdc2bdde6ecf17818cb05e5be11f60c6c","paperId":"2001.09574","textSha256":"2823fd7adfa26ec6744f1873fab58bb011cd81e9a98dfb797b0601a4e7c88983"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e176c23d8e584474e91effd7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f0ffe3597ce2766b9afc3c6cf8cc12cfdc2bdde6ecf17818cb05e5be11f60c6c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:f0ffe3597ce2766b9afc3c6cf8cc12cfdc2bdde6ecf17818cb05e5be11f60c6c","textSha256":"2823fd7adfa26ec6744f1873fab58bb011cd81e9a98dfb797b0601a4e7c88983"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3fecd52184c943b497c04bf9"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3fecd52184c943b497c04bf9","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f0ffe3597ce2766b9afc3c6cf8cc12cfdc2bdde6ecf17818cb05e5be11f60c6c","q025-candidate-question:293acf472724b9f8475b8d33"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5494f718c89bb27ce3bb84b3f1fbe78067966f98d2e61b722b6d91452712772","contributionContentSha256":"d4f2bcea4475c07e4f55ed6489e7460c57d89bf150642f70c2d0892e31e43ee3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:f0ffe3597ce2766b9afc3c6cf8cc12cfdc2bdde6ecf17818cb05e5be11f60c6c","textSha256":"2823fd7adfa26ec6744f1873fab58bb011cd81e9a98dfb797b0601a4e7c88983"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3fecd52184c943b497c04bf9","recordId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ceed47fe303f83034594-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":9,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"954ffde21c7fa41a0b133fbb1fc90a152638fe1ae0d711111143e189db5a1447"},"organizational-access:d631c7a49ecc534bf559726d":{"id":"organizational-access:d631c7a49ecc534bf559726d","source":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","target":"q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"ef71386060e2fc1d227f043cc98ffc9fb214a5308e8300f4925a535889b37388","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b49337f8db3daf684ab18e8c"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c6b2e1dc8872ff9d9e38fe4d82925ec53f7c9dc611beff73b482d13b7b3279c5","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:a2e4fca4ce2f4d96b9a42ef7"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:12ed93f503af165a2e6b07144dd6fa00b6213e32a584405d47e465b596e64532","home":{"unitId":"unit:12ed93f503af165a2e6b07144dd6fa00b6213e32a584405d47e465b596e64532","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q19 covers supersymmetric particle models, scalar backgrounds, cosmological histories and conditional consistency restrictions together.","qualification":"q19 covers the MSSM condensate construction, inflationary FL compatibility and AD baryogenesis with reheating and isocurvature requirements. Gauge breaking remains proposed and FL conditional. q3's baryogenesis focus and q2's constraint comparisons do not individually provide equally clear coverage of the complete construction.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:12ed93f503af165a2e6b07144dd6fa00b6213e32a584405d47e465b596e64532","paperId":"2609.37674","textSha256":"f22f0ae969a87fd40524e2833dd381b6a9ef25d8a7b66cb87c535731e88c6ad0"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0013:u15:q19"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0013:u15:q19","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:12ed93f503af165a2e6b07144dd6fa00b6213e32a584405d47e465b596e64532","q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef71386060e2fc1d227f043cc98ffc9fb214a5308e8300f4925a535889b37388","placementContentSha256":"fb70f52acb23add0e358a56788ae9dd422dec93ba14cc9a37ea7505dd6d6d3a5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0013:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0013:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:12ed93f503af165a2e6b07144dd6fa00b6213e32a584405d47e465b596e64532","paperId":"2609.37674","textSha256":"f22f0ae969a87fd40524e2833dd381b6a9ef25d8a7b66cb87c535731e88c6ad0"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0013","unitRef":"u15"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:12ed93f503af165a2e6b07144dd6fa00b6213e32a584405d47e465b596e64532","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:12ed93f503af165a2e6b07144dd6fa00b6213e32a584405d47e465b596e64532","textSha256":"f22f0ae969a87fd40524e2833dd381b6a9ef25d8a7b66cb87c535731e88c6ad0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:85821c72556d7def865704c1","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound conditional-FL and AD target; complete gauge breaking is proposed, not established by this description. Independent challenge qualification: Compound conditional-FL and AD target; complete gauge breaking is proposed, not demonstrated by the description."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:85821c72556d7def865704c1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:12ed93f503af165a2e6b07144dd6fa00b6213e32a584405d47e465b596e64532","q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c"],"scopeContentSha256":"c6b2e1dc8872ff9d9e38fe4d82925ec53f7c9dc611beff73b482d13b7b3279c5","contributionContentSha256":"f1d7eb901e8415d60112ea8e8d31271ab9f02e28e91ef398ae8638c4a7ce7177","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:12ed93f503af165a2e6b07144dd6fa00b6213e32a584405d47e465b596e64532","textSha256":"f22f0ae969a87fd40524e2833dd381b6a9ef25d8a7b66cb87c535731e88c6ad0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:85821c72556d7def865704c1","recordId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound conditional-FL and AD target; complete gauge breaking is proposed, not established by this description.","challengeNote":"Compound conditional-FL and AD target; complete gauge breaking is proposed, not demonstrated by the description.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:874bc871a06798a9f45916d13bfd0fbf8fb52c2a0ebf11068950d47c47960e70","home":{"unitId":"unit:874bc871a06798a9f45916d13bfd0fbf8fb52c2a0ebf11068950d47c47960e70","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q19 covers electroweak-scale generation together with cosmological selection histories, energy transfer and cosmological viability.","qualification":"q19 covers weak-hierarchy generation, visible reheating and leptogenesis together. The post-inflationary regime and prohibition on additional particles below the SM EFT cutoff remain explicit; a supersymmetric model is not inferred from the regional title.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:874bc871a06798a9f45916d13bfd0fbf8fb52c2a0ebf11068950d47c47960e70","paperId":"1804.06599","textSha256":"c363cdf88b33b46b0fb3135aa7c05f053fe4bd0c1da758e6ae3272822decd506"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0013:u17:q19"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0013:u17:q19","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:874bc871a06798a9f45916d13bfd0fbf8fb52c2a0ebf11068950d47c47960e70","q025-candidate-region:f87c99e7c23e7d82e9d1db78"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef71386060e2fc1d227f043cc98ffc9fb214a5308e8300f4925a535889b37388","placementContentSha256":"ad950252f3aa602b744370fec971bf9c7698d814b27bde1ac96481724d69e0a3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0013:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0013:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:874bc871a06798a9f45916d13bfd0fbf8fb52c2a0ebf11068950d47c47960e70","paperId":"1804.06599","textSha256":"c363cdf88b33b46b0fb3135aa7c05f053fe4bd0c1da758e6ae3272822decd506"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0013","unitRef":"u17"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:874bc871a06798a9f45916d13bfd0fbf8fb52c2a0ebf11068950d47c47960e70","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:874bc871a06798a9f45916d13bfd0fbf8fb52c2a0ebf11068950d47c47960e70","textSha256":"c363cdf88b33b46b0fb3135aa7c05f053fe4bd0c1da758e6ae3272822decd506"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d61590c9d3cc6695340149d4","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound hierarchy, reheating and leptogenesis targets; no additional particles below the SM EFT cutoff are allowed. Independent challenge qualification: Compound hierarchy, reheating and leptogenesis targets, without extra particles below the SM EFT cutoff."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d61590c9d3cc6695340149d4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:874bc871a06798a9f45916d13bfd0fbf8fb52c2a0ebf11068950d47c47960e70","q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c"],"scopeContentSha256":"c6b2e1dc8872ff9d9e38fe4d82925ec53f7c9dc611beff73b482d13b7b3279c5","contributionContentSha256":"faf32b10351bcf66edb6b7f08a6677c30aa46ef2faaf8adfbbed05a936300b07","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:874bc871a06798a9f45916d13bfd0fbf8fb52c2a0ebf11068950d47c47960e70","textSha256":"c363cdf88b33b46b0fb3135aa7c05f053fe4bd0c1da758e6ae3272822decd506"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d61590c9d3cc6695340149d4","recordId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound hierarchy, reheating and leptogenesis targets; no additional particles below the SM EFT cutoff are allowed.","challengeNote":"Compound hierarchy, reheating and leptogenesis targets, without extra particles below the SM EFT cutoff.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"c24f4df573222973fc7b6c5392c6fa5ddd851e1aa5a90c91a405c2284e15c503"},"organizational-access:89bde7f99fbe20768860116b":{"id":"organizational-access:89bde7f99fbe20768860116b","source":"q025-placement-question:d638c2b66920ad1f9a74c4b0","target":"q025-candidate-question:9be0cd89f1a22827c73327de","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-placement-question:d638c2b66920ad1f9a74c4b0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b0c5234811f55a68ea64f4295ea535ff49c3047606d0fe22ad597749527808ef","scopeDecisionId":"decision:placement-new-scope:placement-continuation-0048:n3"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9be0cd89f1a22827c73327de","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ade19dcd010cb62857fa010534e85d2cb381a424aac2e9b9e82e1d059d031824","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:066ecdc331a9ac6b6ca8bb92"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:ceaf95b231cc3176e28ff6a123bb795d9499f7c00d316a8acfdab9bc3e14ea89","home":{"unitId":"unit:ceaf95b231cc3176e28ff6a123bb795d9499f7c00d316a8acfdab9bc3e14ea89","destinationId":"q025-placement-question:d638c2b66920ad1f9a74c4b0","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"The revised composite scope preserves both superpotential alternatives, construction of multiple KKLT de Sitter vacua and the separate semiclassical-stability inference.","qualification":"q7 covers construction but does not establish the separate semiclassical-survival target; q9 covers survival but not superpotential-based vacuum multiplicity. n3 preserves the complete linked question. It revises n1 by moving evidence-availability statements into readingCoverage and explicitly naming its revision target.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ceaf95b231cc3176e28ff6a123bb795d9499f7c00d316a8acfdab9bc3e14ea89","paperId":"hep-th/0307160","textSha256":"a61c83530d6aa0c8e687fb667be04084ef93de985a8dd577ba437c61901a987c"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0048:u18:n3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0048:u18:n3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ceaf95b231cc3176e28ff6a123bb795d9499f7c00d316a8acfdab9bc3e14ea89","q025-placement-question:d638c2b66920ad1f9a74c4b0"],"scopeContentSha256":"b0c5234811f55a68ea64f4295ea535ff49c3047606d0fe22ad597749527808ef","placementContentSha256":"b864688efe3dc494d24ecbd011694fa9478bca543f7b71158c25157e7cca612f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_selected_challenger_whole_home","sourceReviewIds":["new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0048:proposal","new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0048:challenge","root:placement-new-scope-homes:new-scope-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ceaf95b231cc3176e28ff6a123bb795d9499f7c00d316a8acfdab9bc3e14ea89","paperId":"hep-th/0307160","textSha256":"a61c83530d6aa0c8e687fb667be04084ef93de985a8dd577ba437c61901a987c"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/new-scope-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"1fbb32b25cf9d13b6b84cc511720eb22a4b031c1cd03ff6881e01a7f4aee8c31"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0048","unitRef":"u18"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ceaf95b231cc3176e28ff6a123bb795d9499f7c00d316a8acfdab9bc3e14ea89","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9be0cd89f1a22827c73327de","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d40","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:ceaf95b231cc3176e28ff6a123bb795d9499f7c00d316a8acfdab9bc3e14ea89","textSha256":"a61c83530d6aa0c8e687fb667be04084ef93de985a8dd577ba437c61901a987c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5c9df4d276f924cbcbe41f01"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5c9df4d276f924cbcbe41f01","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ceaf95b231cc3176e28ff6a123bb795d9499f7c00d316a8acfdab9bc3e14ea89","q025-candidate-question:9be0cd89f1a22827c73327de"],"scopeContentSha256":"ade19dcd010cb62857fa010534e85d2cb381a424aac2e9b9e82e1d059d031824","contributionContentSha256":"94def41e4227ef3dc0014b9c0adc6d29673b5f0157ddc00e3800960b0dbe8f65","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-56e3a84a9ddbd4b99ab7-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-56e3a84a9ddbd4b99ab7-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-56e3a84a9ddbd4b99ab7-proposal","leaf-56e3a84a9ddbd4b99ab7-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d40","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:ceaf95b231cc3176e28ff6a123bb795d9499f7c00d316a8acfdab9bc3e14ea89","textSha256":"a61c83530d6aa0c8e687fb667be04084ef93de985a8dd577ba437c61901a987c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5c9df4d276f924cbcbe41f01","recordId":"leaf-56e3a84a9ddbd4b99ab7-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-56e3a84a9ddbd4b99ab7-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-56e3a84a9ddbd4b99ab7-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound target: multiple de Sitter vacua and their semiclassical stability; racetrack and full-instanton alternatives remain visible.","challengeNote":"Compound multiplicity and semiclassical-stability targets; racetrack and full-instanton alternatives remain separate.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"8a8a456da018548026efa1947d7c0e84fe93a8714c5a5ee5282e540d30f06c41"}}}
