{"schemaVersion":"1.0.0","kind":"eigenquestions-organizational-access-certificates","records":{"organizational-access:490cf19bcb8179f54a0a32df":{"id":"organizational-access:490cf19bcb8179f54a0a32df","source":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay","target":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"206baf6ffa291d6327e37311f13fe1f436e0f87e304acc8b238ed4a8eb39fef7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:kk-scope:p1"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"18e133141c5df5a60eb5a76bfe937797e87c309aa9aa9fe26a5d65922eec1f24","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8e113866c072fedc904a4f2a"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","home":{"unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","destinationId":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay","role":"overlap","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":0.5,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The immutable source explicitly asks for near-threshold partial-wave suppression and its cascade rate.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","textSha256":"b15227ab24b6d9e9aa2221056c9eaf81216f3e71f3bd75f708ef906dd9496512"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fac9569d8f192e54850486112c7fe0d8","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f047caa6711ddcf0dab834ac0976f6f55b1f49660dd4bcadb530252e9ef74864","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:kk-placement:0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:kk-placement:0","type":"overlap","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay"],"scopeContentSha256":"206baf6ffa291d6327e37311f13fe1f436e0f87e304acc8b238ed4a8eb39fef7","placementContentSha256":"d7ef758344acda330bd1d1026876dc5f7480ac3cc7070fb9ab142da89cd2ef22","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../../evaluation/full-pass/organization-placement-v1/kk-organization-adjudication.json","sha256":"5edf011616c98fbf1da360c145cbcba504414f91b97b1fb2bc09302d5a423512"}},"sourceReviewIds":["kk-normalized-original","kk-compact-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","textSha256":"b15227ab24b6d9e9aa2221056c9eaf81216f3e71f3bd75f708ef906dd9496512"},{"ref":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}},{"ref":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fac9569d8f192e54850486112c7fe0d8","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f047caa6711ddcf0dab834ac0976f6f55b1f49660dd4bcadb530252e9ef74864","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary reading-order context; no images or full-paper verification."}}]},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","textSha256":"b15227ab24b6d9e9aa2221056c9eaf81216f3e71f3bd75f708ef906dd9496512"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fac9569d8f192e54850486112c7fe0d8","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f047caa6711ddcf0dab834ac0976f6f55b1f49660dd4bcadb530252e9ef74864","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b428f6dad2427cb434b91a08","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound target: partial waves, flat-dimension dark-matter viability and freeze-in bounds without KK dark matter. Independent challenge qualification: Compound: partial waves, flat-dimension dark-matter viability and freeze-in bounds even when another component supplies dark matter."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b428f6dad2427cb434b91a08","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"],"scopeContentSha256":"18e133141c5df5a60eb5a76bfe937797e87c309aa9aa9fe26a5d65922eec1f24","contributionContentSha256":"3bbb4916fa784b2580ff26256c14a941c0ec211c81a692d725714727c01cd46c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-proposal","leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:263db4b147b8e930ef44a07d47a9c50ff4d9d9c8278f1780cf79f7a9280f0346","textSha256":"b15227ab24b6d9e9aa2221056c9eaf81216f3e71f3bd75f708ef906dd9496512"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:43d9cfd4b680cd2a138a8de5c3a9ecfb","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":1305,"end":4703,"textSha256":"3aa90f5a74b09d2df2fe6b0bc7a52adc2b6b49a1cef673ae8af87b1f14c4001c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:721039277fa8e9c964b594ebb5f55380","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":2504,"end":4949,"textSha256":"29ce938132d71992b518d50f08598cbd98eedc2c07ebd29ba46218038ef6e6d8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fac9569d8f192e54850486112c7fe0d8","paperId":"2610.01825","sourceSha256":"69997129c1776bb28cbbfe61d9b0c2ff158b360650faaf74e6b729e1e6eb533e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3768bbe41c392cde3687/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d527adb4895b727deb2b6788b1ac8275e29c3f42a83fa31e4d7d1c1ffbe45095","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f047caa6711ddcf0dab834ac0976f6f55b1f49660dd4bcadb530252e9ef74864","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b428f6dad2427cb434b91a08","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound target: partial waves, flat-dimension dark-matter viability and freeze-in bounds without KK dark matter.","challengeNote":"Compound: partial waves, flat-dimension dark-matter viability and freeze-in bounds even when another component supplies dark matter.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","home":{"unitId":"unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","destinationId":"q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The description directly asks for the threshold amplitude and generality of suppression. Description coverage does not certify a derivation.","evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"d65","kind":"description","unitIndex":65,"unitId":"unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","textSha256":"9106a842c07c887daa181d76dfb11f0af970dcc414acc0eae0997cf771d0bf97"}],"decisionId":"decision:kk-placement:3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:kk-placement:3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","q-kk-graviton-threshold-decay"],"scopeContentSha256":"206baf6ffa291d6327e37311f13fe1f436e0f87e304acc8b238ed4a8eb39fef7","placementContentSha256":"a87566012c58f45bfed69d326949712c5ed859efe8508f5255ea26bfd4afa7fd","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../../evaluation/full-pass/organization-placement-v1/kk-organization-adjudication.json","sha256":"5edf011616c98fbf1da360c145cbcba504414f91b97b1fb2bc09302d5a423512"}},"sourceReviewIds":["kk-normalized-original","kk-compact-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"ref":"d65","kind":"description","unitIndex":65,"unitId":"unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","textSha256":"9106a842c07c887daa181d76dfb11f0af970dcc414acc0eae0997cf771d0bf97"}]},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","textSha256":"9106a842c07c887daa181d76dfb11f0af970dcc414acc0eae0997cf771d0bf97"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b5844480c05d0d147da2b730a1e57e96","paperId":"2609.36234","sourceSha256":"c00cd25b0bd7453e4396e5019fbd50ef9668863dcbdaf265fd05ec9ba35c9df8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/859136b54d28aa532422/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6717dc406ef79136d2ceb3c1da6f4bb7a0f4790d46edc1eef7d2699d369418e9","pdfPage":2,"start":92,"end":3489,"textSha256":"a1c4bd00a0014d7fbee2b1492d36232d4c08d93e7b2ddcb6db103686ca4031e3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c76367b06976076a63311e0895e04418","paperId":"2609.36234","sourceSha256":"c00cd25b0bd7453e4396e5019fbd50ef9668863dcbdaf265fd05ec9ba35c9df8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/859136b54d28aa532422/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6717dc406ef79136d2ceb3c1da6f4bb7a0f4790d46edc1eef7d2699d369418e9","pdfPage":1,"start":2497,"end":5454,"textSha256":"94fe5c0ae7c6d1ae663a2775ef6ec6184146c88d0baa04689a0cb645162a4c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c8544b384a261048a1203da39609d23f","paperId":"2609.36234","sourceSha256":"c00cd25b0bd7453e4396e5019fbd50ef9668863dcbdaf265fd05ec9ba35c9df8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/859136b54d28aa532422/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6717dc406ef79136d2ceb3c1da6f4bb7a0f4790d46edc1eef7d2699d369418e9","pdfPage":1,"start":1294,"end":4696,"textSha256":"0c9461b7861efa5ebfb648899dd483a90d792edf40ae01026eaba2c630a745e5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f3b574bd761f24d4267150dc","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound target: amplitude scaling, its stated generality and cascade viability. Boundary contributions challenge premises, not observational likelihoods. Independent challenge qualification: Compound: threshold amplitude, stated generality and cascade viability. Boundary contributions concern historical premises, not replacement observational fits."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f3b574bd761f24d4267150dc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","q025-candidate-question:3837596ccc94dbb619230dc6"],"scopeContentSha256":"18e133141c5df5a60eb5a76bfe937797e87c309aa9aa9fe26a5d65922eec1f24","contributionContentSha256":"7b0d5fc6d907a5ff237e9312251d8c1d7b226d6635adb55a7117d55f16eea7de","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-proposal","leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:c667eaad26bf24f79ac000d31da08a2e1f6be8c980569251185cfd41bfdc3ae2","textSha256":"9106a842c07c887daa181d76dfb11f0af970dcc414acc0eae0997cf771d0bf97"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b5844480c05d0d147da2b730a1e57e96","paperId":"2609.36234","sourceSha256":"c00cd25b0bd7453e4396e5019fbd50ef9668863dcbdaf265fd05ec9ba35c9df8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/859136b54d28aa532422/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6717dc406ef79136d2ceb3c1da6f4bb7a0f4790d46edc1eef7d2699d369418e9","pdfPage":2,"start":92,"end":3489,"textSha256":"a1c4bd00a0014d7fbee2b1492d36232d4c08d93e7b2ddcb6db103686ca4031e3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c76367b06976076a63311e0895e04418","paperId":"2609.36234","sourceSha256":"c00cd25b0bd7453e4396e5019fbd50ef9668863dcbdaf265fd05ec9ba35c9df8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/859136b54d28aa532422/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6717dc406ef79136d2ceb3c1da6f4bb7a0f4790d46edc1eef7d2699d369418e9","pdfPage":1,"start":2497,"end":5454,"textSha256":"94fe5c0ae7c6d1ae663a2775ef6ec6184146c88d0baa04689a0cb645162a4c77","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c8544b384a261048a1203da39609d23f","paperId":"2609.36234","sourceSha256":"c00cd25b0bd7453e4396e5019fbd50ef9668863dcbdaf265fd05ec9ba35c9df8","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/859136b54d28aa532422/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"6717dc406ef79136d2ceb3c1da6f4bb7a0f4790d46edc1eef7d2699d369418e9","pdfPage":1,"start":1294,"end":4696,"textSha256":"0c9461b7861efa5ebfb648899dd483a90d792edf40ae01026eaba2c630a745e5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f3b574bd761f24d4267150dc","recordId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0403944f92af04eaed4a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound target: amplitude scaling, its stated generality and cascade viability. Boundary contributions challenge premises, not observational likelihoods.","challengeNote":"Compound: threshold amplitude, stated generality and cascade viability. Boundary contributions concern historical premises, not replacement observational fits.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"c24d44d8fe7a47a2a70c5a7f4c959154897ccc40f7c3e0729abf0f67e146b876"},"organizational-access:c9ba83d3f12a31e83e0b8bc8":{"id":"organizational-access:c9ba83d3f12a31e83e0b8bc8","source":"q025-candidate-question:0e48cffa284b6cecf1592281","target":"q025-candidate-question:7b57448ff6a9e86a553d18a8","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:0e48cffa284b6cecf1592281","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"871d68471912f3a6a7765720fa8f1002dd4a07feaebd36b6aee9d1a530ba79e2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:53d308f21d5e975a51406b8c"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:7b57448ff6a9e86a553d18a8","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"439ede1ee9f4917c7a132e473b9d361e94b10cec2f145aa44276ea410680616b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:4de9eb5caac71b9e73ecb881"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8","home":{"unitId":"unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0e48cffa284b6cecf1592281","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q3 directly combines quantum-gravity restrictions on low-energy EFT with implications for strong CP, the weak scale, gauge interactions and dark energy, without guaranteeing solutions.","qualification":"q3 explicitly combines the EFT-consistency review and all four phenomenological applications, including the absence of guaranteed solutions. The review remains one compound source without a common successful mechanism or mandatory fine decomposition.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8","paperId":"2203.07624","textSha256":"495bf3f89c139f93197d0408c023a17d4b50a95a608afd0792d5e23719757667"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0026:u16:q3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0026:u16:q3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8","q025-candidate-question:0e48cffa284b6cecf1592281"],"scopeContentSha256":"871d68471912f3a6a7765720fa8f1002dd4a07feaebd36b6aee9d1a530ba79e2","placementContentSha256":"dd7ec63af6f19d5c007f0b0542deab8176a1d2caed53a4d661b306be178f466a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0026:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0026:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8","paperId":"2203.07624","textSha256":"495bf3f89c139f93197d0408c023a17d4b50a95a608afd0792d5e23719757667"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0026","unitRef":"u16"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7b57448ff6a9e86a553d18a8","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d40","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8","textSha256":"495bf3f89c139f93197d0408c023a17d4b50a95a608afd0792d5e23719757667"},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ad556fc63a18fb1e9885e041b4dd94c6","paperId":"2203.07624","sourceSha256":"c895f9a40099e729ee94446083f8c4f98949a3c894118a104f5cb8ff37823bc7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/91b86eb8982d9549f2b2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"acb82ded71c09dd2953075ceed50c39e4596735012ed84fe70752130abae5077","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"5d13a492f0b48823ae05fd433bd8759d20fad827ff545eab98ff692709f823e7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af78084cf347eef98bbe97217bc94e5d","paperId":"2203.07624","sourceSha256":"c895f9a40099e729ee94446083f8c4f98949a3c894118a104f5cb8ff37823bc7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/91b86eb8982d9549f2b2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"acb82ded71c09dd2953075ceed50c39e4596735012ed84fe70752130abae5077","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1161,"textSha256":"90600347cf36744684fa2251d16253e0168cc364c2bdee76cc7a05c7ecf92c1e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c4df7332b38d593fedeb191d"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c4df7332b38d593fedeb191d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8","q025-candidate-question:7b57448ff6a9e86a553d18a8"],"scopeContentSha256":"439ede1ee9f4917c7a132e473b9d361e94b10cec2f145aa44276ea410680616b","contributionContentSha256":"6fb33a9744447068efcd35cc00b13cae393a3da014eeeaa9f299756fc952676a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-proposal","leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d40","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:d0740dc774eecb12c8962ddf1e7326a2e6ca3ca58b3ec53c09ff6820fea4a6c8","textSha256":"495bf3f89c139f93197d0408c023a17d4b50a95a608afd0792d5e23719757667"},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ad556fc63a18fb1e9885e041b4dd94c6","paperId":"2203.07624","sourceSha256":"c895f9a40099e729ee94446083f8c4f98949a3c894118a104f5cb8ff37823bc7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/91b86eb8982d9549f2b2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"acb82ded71c09dd2953075ceed50c39e4596735012ed84fe70752130abae5077","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"5d13a492f0b48823ae05fd433bd8759d20fad827ff545eab98ff692709f823e7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af78084cf347eef98bbe97217bc94e5d","paperId":"2203.07624","sourceSha256":"c895f9a40099e729ee94446083f8c4f98949a3c894118a104f5cb8ff37823bc7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/91b86eb8982d9549f2b2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"acb82ded71c09dd2953075ceed50c39e4596735012ed84fe70752130abae5077","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1161,"textSha256":"90600347cf36744684fa2251d16253e0168cc364c2bdee76cc7a05c7ecf92c1e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c4df7332b38d593fedeb191d","recordId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7ceb9013e65d26f1b931-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound review of consistency conditions and several phenomenological problems; no guaranteed solution is claimed.","challengeNote":"Multiple consistency conditions and phenomenological applications form a compound review; solutions to the listed problems are expressly not guaranteed.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"b49975ec9dfaa2a035130c5688eda2d76b5b27ae541becd3248c3a13184e3ba4"},"organizational-access:4d6ce7a0bad09e7299405d9f":{"id":"organizational-access:4d6ce7a0bad09e7299405d9f","source":"q025-candidate-question:1166e0699c62279659b12b0e","target":"q025-candidate-question:20a1895bc31783591d7b5d0a","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1166e0699c62279659b12b0e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"22e031b9c06883a9288ef8b6cddca2461f704518d010864aaf7c34014ef999ac","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c308a719afeb6cdf4e237330"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:20a1895bc31783591d7b5d0a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c5d3c2fc9c9d478e9fe815b8b7bd970341a9ec352e2b000a314c76d10c1487fb","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7a6d5c5bb53e50332ff176fa"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:69907110ef197727980a175215aea5a97e737499f9cff32df709ee760b849958","home":{"unitId":"unit:69907110ef197727980a175215aea5a97e737499f9cff32df709ee760b849958","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1166e0699c62279659b12b0e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q0 directly covers historical residual α-vacuum UHECR production, the vacuum-parameter bound and the conditional saturated-bound super-GZK explanation.","qualification":"q0 explicitly covers production, the vacuum-parameter bound and the additional saturation hypothesis. Its matter/detector premise, α convention and historical epoch remain local to this proposal. q2 and q14 are broader homes; neither a Dark Dimension origin nor current observational validation follows.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:69907110ef197727980a175215aea5a97e737499f9cff32df709ee760b849958","paperId":"astro-ph/0307413","textSha256":"806d09cf39dc6de66d1f6b30c8aa80069347b4eac2a6c63c95c32e2d26dc108b"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0058:u30:q0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0058:u30:q0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:69907110ef197727980a175215aea5a97e737499f9cff32df709ee760b849958","q025-candidate-question:1166e0699c62279659b12b0e"],"scopeContentSha256":"22e031b9c06883a9288ef8b6cddca2461f704518d010864aaf7c34014ef999ac","placementContentSha256":"451379888cd2583d15dbf763f81f53b82c6f8d0ebabc0d512c3a08faab7a923c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0058:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0058:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:69907110ef197727980a175215aea5a97e737499f9cff32df709ee760b849958","paperId":"astro-ph/0307413","textSha256":"806d09cf39dc6de66d1f6b30c8aa80069347b4eac2a6c63c95c32e2d26dc108b"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0058","unitRef":"u30"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:69907110ef197727980a175215aea5a97e737499f9cff32df709ee760b849958","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:20a1895bc31783591d7b5d0a","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d64","kind":"description","unitIndex":64,"unitId":"unit:69907110ef197727980a175215aea5a97e737499f9cff32df709ee760b849958","textSha256":"806d09cf39dc6de66d1f6b30c8aa80069347b4eac2a6c63c95c32e2d26dc108b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c5e93f596c2d961f8842cd2e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c5e93f596c2d961f8842cd2e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:69907110ef197727980a175215aea5a97e737499f9cff32df709ee760b849958","q025-candidate-question:20a1895bc31783591d7b5d0a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c5d3c2fc9c9d478e9fe815b8b7bd970341a9ec352e2b000a314c76d10c1487fb","contributionContentSha256":"cdd40280b510409a521839d2c9a7790914ef35d95348e1abfa76fbacaa13ae1a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d64","kind":"description","unitIndex":64,"unitId":"unit:69907110ef197727980a175215aea5a97e737499f9cff32df709ee760b849958","textSha256":"806d09cf39dc6de66d1f6b30c8aa80069347b4eac2a6c63c95c32e2d26dc108b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c5e93f596c2d961f8842cd2e","recordId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ed8a448224c00c10020e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Quantum-state cosmic-ray phenomenology is distinct from scalar-potential metastability; the observational proposal remains source-dated.","challengeNote":"The bound and super-GZK interpretation remain source-dated.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"e44b9d9ac2c1f1abd2db8af12d7ab4ede3dd79db91bdebf04f53fd483766c5bf"},"organizational-access:60438fd03725098b1e90ba23":{"id":"organizational-access:60438fd03725098b1e90ba23","source":"q025-candidate-question:12a2e56e9a3e4a85989a684c","target":"q025-candidate-question:80cd83e98ea12d1084d47c4d","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:12a2e56e9a3e4a85989a684c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"da7d218c2f8e077a8e32d2aee988ab77679ea16fa2e7eb999dfecb655306f99a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f172d745f261c9ec6e9cde96"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:80cd83e98ea12d1084d47c4d","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e8c0108e69538167341577313174ae0fbcef382844129438ec04e360e08848fa","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:64d3bed29b6ff39cf67d4075"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","home":{"unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:12a2e56e9a3e4a85989a684c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers additive exponential scalar fields, cooperative inflation, exact scaling backgrounds and their perturbation spectra.","qualification":"q0 explicitly joins additive exponential fields, ordinary assistance, scaling attractors and perturbation spectra. Unequal slopes and expansion-only cooperation remain local premises. Exact background scaling does not establish an exact spectral formula, a current observational fit or any quantum-gravity criterion.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","textSha256":"7aa306b37d444bb72c20d45042ed6c79f78d4ba7f75932003723cbbf8f4517f2"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0024:u14:q0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0024:u14:q0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","q025-candidate-question:12a2e56e9a3e4a85989a684c"],"scopeContentSha256":"da7d218c2f8e077a8e32d2aee988ab77679ea16fa2e7eb999dfecb655306f99a","placementContentSha256":"40fab782d5e0c1e1843fb646cb64f3ba77e1f3938d800ec0d2b00dff962d1b94","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0024:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0024:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","textSha256":"7aa306b37d444bb72c20d45042ed6c79f78d4ba7f75932003723cbbf8f4517f2"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0024","unitRef":"u14"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80cd83e98ea12d1084d47c4d","role":"instantiates","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d83","kind":"description","unitIndex":83,"unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","textSha256":"7aa306b37d444bb72c20d45042ed6c79f78d4ba7f75932003723cbbf8f4517f2"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:45fe1827b0f2a4faf3e6a9dcab050945","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","sourceSha256":"4bb665e487cd75fe15fd8ea0f2272ab9e37a9200669c3c812bbd20beb393b2ab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1018abf2bf26376a9ff3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"376a42a5a2823341f2ec6361814659bb206ac52b64a4aed93c5961399642e8bb","pdfPage":1,"start":1304,"end":4170,"textSha256":"22f59185f431d90fd30a7c9e307aab51ff0b20069dfc343731e06e392e2fa351","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e27","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fcc37c0fa77317481e78cd5e0f8c2a6e","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","sourceSha256":"4bb665e487cd75fe15fd8ea0f2272ab9e37a9200669c3c812bbd20beb393b2ab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1018abf2bf26376a9ff3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"376a42a5a2823341f2ec6361814659bb206ac52b64a4aed93c5961399642e8bb","pdfPage":3,"start":114,"end":3510,"textSha256":"d9ab2330a1965d788609160167983b17fba678af63e3da71bd03391c218973ae","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:79356626aafd3b2c74ba43de03ab8827","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","sourceSha256":"4bb665e487cd75fe15fd8ea0f2272ab9e37a9200669c3c812bbd20beb393b2ab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1018abf2bf26376a9ff3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"376a42a5a2823341f2ec6361814659bb206ac52b64a4aed93c5961399642e8bb","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"6153dfd2eb7e0a944f70498cfaa8b781d45c8ee43b409dca43f036cc1e6fb034","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:69b03e04dfe2b6f8f9e072ef"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:69b03e04dfe2b6f8f9e072ef","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","q025-candidate-question:80cd83e98ea12d1084d47c4d"],"scopeContentSha256":"e8c0108e69538167341577313174ae0fbcef382844129438ec04e360e08848fa","contributionContentSha256":"3d45f3049aa16e4d650df46db26be8b0191a48b0f2b2060b49229c9722b0fcf6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d83","kind":"description","unitIndex":83,"unitId":"unit:580b2ff44089ad93797ed8623b3d352d27d68389b215c5fe8be127d01c2f8d42","textSha256":"7aa306b37d444bb72c20d45042ed6c79f78d4ba7f75932003723cbbf8f4517f2"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:45fe1827b0f2a4faf3e6a9dcab050945","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","sourceSha256":"4bb665e487cd75fe15fd8ea0f2272ab9e37a9200669c3c812bbd20beb393b2ab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1018abf2bf26376a9ff3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"376a42a5a2823341f2ec6361814659bb206ac52b64a4aed93c5961399642e8bb","pdfPage":1,"start":1304,"end":4170,"textSha256":"22f59185f431d90fd30a7c9e307aab51ff0b20069dfc343731e06e392e2fa351","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e27","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fcc37c0fa77317481e78cd5e0f8c2a6e","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","sourceSha256":"4bb665e487cd75fe15fd8ea0f2272ab9e37a9200669c3c812bbd20beb393b2ab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1018abf2bf26376a9ff3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"376a42a5a2823341f2ec6361814659bb206ac52b64a4aed93c5961399642e8bb","pdfPage":3,"start":114,"end":3510,"textSha256":"d9ab2330a1965d788609160167983b17fba678af63e3da71bd03391c218973ae","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:79356626aafd3b2c74ba43de03ab8827","paperId":"astro-ph/9804177","sourceSha256":"4bb665e487cd75fe15fd8ea0f2272ab9e37a9200669c3c812bbd20beb393b2ab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1018abf2bf26376a9ff3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"376a42a5a2823341f2ec6361814659bb206ac52b64a4aed93c5961399642e8bb","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"6153dfd2eb7e0a944f70498cfaa8b781d45c8ee43b409dca43f036cc1e6fb034","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:69b03e04dfe2b6f8f9e072ef","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Fields interact only through expansion. Background scaling is exact; no quantum-gravity criterion is imposed.","challengeNote":"Fields couple through expansion only. Exact background scaling and the spectral calculation are separate results; no quantum-gravity criterion is imposed.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"8716779acffd7b6590c61ae2814129337db241739878f579819e62357e39677a"},"organizational-access:c4fb028b4190f9360969a0f3":{"id":"organizational-access:c4fb028b4190f9360969a0f3","source":"q025-candidate-question:149a528fb33d0e6df177bf33","target":"q025-candidate-question:9a53af2e8590efe26dca52f4","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:149a528fb33d0e6df177bf33","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a3535fbbe53a115a3fa88fd4824122c54ed0178ff297e09dc05a688c080acbaf","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6537cb3a781e54a33c097b1b"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9a53af2e8590efe26dca52f4","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"104f8c71dc8929b5ec76563f16f6707306d11015a0f728f0e4efb3e59c871435","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:72eb7cfd4954bd641c8f3a00"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:93b976f2d1f726378e1d7db6724e6e146750fe9ad81e0a10c43c3ef0da9eb0e7","home":{"unitId":"unit:93b976f2d1f726378e1d7db6724e6e146750fe9ad81e0a10c43c3ef0da9eb0e7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:149a528fb33d0e6df177bf33","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Directly includes the antibrane-generated small-superpotential proposal and its coupled stabilization-and-uplift requirements.","qualification":"q3 explicitly covers both antibrane functions and their compatibility with Kähler stabilization and proposed de Sitter minima. Initially supersymmetric fluxes remain, the later antibrane response is a distinct stage, and the construction is not identified with standard KKLT or certified as globally controlled.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:93b976f2d1f726378e1d7db6724e6e146750fe9ad81e0a10c43c3ef0da9eb0e7","paperId":"2202.02327","textSha256":"ed54822101d9eebcb649a8a50a4b87c5d60f145b2fdd5039b6d9c7620fb3e297"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0029:u27:q3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0029:u27:q3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:93b976f2d1f726378e1d7db6724e6e146750fe9ad81e0a10c43c3ef0da9eb0e7","q025-candidate-question:149a528fb33d0e6df177bf33"],"scopeContentSha256":"a3535fbbe53a115a3fa88fd4824122c54ed0178ff297e09dc05a688c080acbaf","placementContentSha256":"82da1b0bce7ccc59d5d2cb2ab8ed521bf444a4908c517006027cd890129b89e2","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0029:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0029:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:93b976f2d1f726378e1d7db6724e6e146750fe9ad81e0a10c43c3ef0da9eb0e7","paperId":"2202.02327","textSha256":"ed54822101d9eebcb649a8a50a4b87c5d60f145b2fdd5039b6d9c7620fb3e297"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0029","unitRef":"u27"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:93b976f2d1f726378e1d7db6724e6e146750fe9ad81e0a10c43c3ef0da9eb0e7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9a53af2e8590efe26dca52f4","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:93b976f2d1f726378e1d7db6724e6e146750fe9ad81e0a10c43c3ef0da9eb0e7","textSha256":"ed54822101d9eebcb649a8a50a4b87c5d60f145b2fdd5039b6d9c7620fb3e297"},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:81d5ec35f521a95322502973890a3f77","paperId":"2202.02327","sourceSha256":"b23836d51cf079097d228d67903a892640d692c8415898e646c5cf43e88e2bcb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5c61f9511e7a73c91141/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a20152588a1cd073a93d48c159529cc76011b55873a84f69d260341772ac6c9b","pdfPage":1,"start":2496,"end":4836,"textSha256":"0d2adb9c321efb4cc481a7884b915ba38044d268018c04928600c99a1e4aa440","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cb6d5e8bc86bf71abb8549c2c07eb6be","paperId":"2202.02327","sourceSha256":"b23836d51cf079097d228d67903a892640d692c8415898e646c5cf43e88e2bcb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5c61f9511e7a73c91141/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a20152588a1cd073a93d48c159529cc76011b55873a84f69d260341772ac6c9b","pdfPage":1,"start":1298,"end":4695,"textSha256":"c1389ee9482dbe855103d2d4a11752aad61a2266212cfec6108868ff8efa2c8d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5babf26c82862a7494a9b5d4"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5babf26c82862a7494a9b5d4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:93b976f2d1f726378e1d7db6724e6e146750fe9ad81e0a10c43c3ef0da9eb0e7","q025-candidate-question:9a53af2e8590efe26dca52f4"],"scopeContentSha256":"104f8c71dc8929b5ec76563f16f6707306d11015a0f728f0e4efb3e59c871435","contributionContentSha256":"fccec218e3a6b685443bb774d0b48fd2e703ec29dcfc63a546119581dfe85785","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-4c7fc4cccbcfee39ef45-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4c7fc4cccbcfee39ef45-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4c7fc4cccbcfee39ef45-proposal","leaf-4c7fc4cccbcfee39ef45-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:93b976f2d1f726378e1d7db6724e6e146750fe9ad81e0a10c43c3ef0da9eb0e7","textSha256":"ed54822101d9eebcb649a8a50a4b87c5d60f145b2fdd5039b6d9c7620fb3e297"},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:81d5ec35f521a95322502973890a3f77","paperId":"2202.02327","sourceSha256":"b23836d51cf079097d228d67903a892640d692c8415898e646c5cf43e88e2bcb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5c61f9511e7a73c91141/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a20152588a1cd073a93d48c159529cc76011b55873a84f69d260341772ac6c9b","pdfPage":1,"start":2496,"end":4836,"textSha256":"0d2adb9c321efb4cc481a7884b915ba38044d268018c04928600c99a1e4aa440","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cb6d5e8bc86bf71abb8549c2c07eb6be","paperId":"2202.02327","sourceSha256":"b23836d51cf079097d228d67903a892640d692c8415898e646c5cf43e88e2bcb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5c61f9511e7a73c91141/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a20152588a1cd073a93d48c159529cc76011b55873a84f69d260341772ac6c9b","pdfPage":1,"start":1298,"end":4695,"textSha256":"c1389ee9482dbe855103d2d4a11752aad61a2266212cfec6108868ff8efa2c8d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5babf26c82862a7494a9b5d4","recordId":"leaf-4c7fc4cccbcfee39ef45-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-4c7fc4cccbcfee39ef45-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4c7fc4cccbcfee39ef45-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Proposal with initially supersymmetric fluxes; anti-D3 sources supply the small superpotential as well as uplift.","challengeNote":"Initially supersymmetric fluxes remain; anti-D3 sources are proposed to supply both the small superpotential and uplift.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"551e8e3c7b031f7ed714ca0608da2e564172014e73a4f64770f10246c5d7c434"},"organizational-access:604ad88b8d77b781eeede979":{"id":"organizational-access:604ad88b8d77b781eeede979","source":"q025-candidate-question:24124b028c946c6bc1e48479","target":"q025-candidate-question:1741aec31a82052c172c976b","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:24124b028c946c6bc1e48479","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c8ce0551a7176250b322641749325d23c55b2a8c1e52afcb5a6f8984b7b02bef","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:79b395161b15f04d86771ddc"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1741aec31a82052c172c976b","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"83f288a69ec8a6cea81b310a997e639d249a7bb15adafc2c00f635ffec8e8e45","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8e48e7ff10e21fb0c1709356"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","home":{"unitId":"unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:24124b028c946c6bc1e48479","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines symmetry-protected Dirac seesaw/radiative masses, mixing patterns, dark-matter stability and charged-lepton-flavour tests.","qualification":"q2 explicitly combines symmetry-protected Dirac mass mechanisms, seesaw/radiative regimes, mixing patterns, dark-matter stability and charged-lepton-flavour tests. The composite home accommodates distinct constructions without imposing quarticity universally or requiring an atomic decomposition. No particular B−L-breaking implementation is needed.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","paperId":"2110.15755","textSha256":"1b1486827b6017d8e3d11794f6eeb0c5bb94904826be395667cba3eea2a1903f"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0015:u30:q2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0015:u30:q2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","q025-candidate-question:24124b028c946c6bc1e48479"],"scopeContentSha256":"c8ce0551a7176250b322641749325d23c55b2a8c1e52afcb5a6f8984b7b02bef","placementContentSha256":"3eee7d90f173146e6b87dbc9ed4677eb96c19e6d0d6368c6a9dd7d559eab4d5c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0015:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0015:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","paperId":"2110.15755","textSha256":"1b1486827b6017d8e3d11794f6eeb0c5bb94904826be395667cba3eea2a1903f"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0015","unitRef":"u30"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1741aec31a82052c172c976b","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","textSha256":"1b1486827b6017d8e3d11794f6eeb0c5bb94904826be395667cba3eea2a1903f"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:162a16fada92e6b548db0421d8207ee3","paperId":"2110.15755","sourceSha256":"49b942675ae95ad094f4b7e4e7f9746986a05b4b0eb91c65f01492b7956a7e6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/70a8ab94eab8ffb96dea/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9326dfe963d219e34f551884bc27c4c4471526f6d03a5b8ec7bb19757029eb51","pdfPage":17,"start":0,"end":1398,"textSha256":"e9c5a52df8901c66b9f1060d53c9e8f7e1760db5701e27f04a8bf91c277bc757","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2dc8c597ba40cb8346d662e539bbfd2a","paperId":"2110.15755","sourceSha256":"49b942675ae95ad094f4b7e4e7f9746986a05b4b0eb91c65f01492b7956a7e6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/70a8ab94eab8ffb96dea/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9326dfe963d219e34f551884bc27c4c4471526f6d03a5b8ec7bb19757029eb51","pdfPage":101,"start":0,"end":1926,"textSha256":"02c54b5be4bb3ec7a83d3e65ade3b01ed8a4b0b57d78be1a1c5c8c6a2cf5cbe5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6f0b46b8040641d430778d6aa5a6e855","paperId":"2110.15755","sourceSha256":"49b942675ae95ad094f4b7e4e7f9746986a05b4b0eb91c65f01492b7956a7e6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/70a8ab94eab8ffb96dea/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9326dfe963d219e34f551884bc27c4c4471526f6d03a5b8ec7bb19757029eb51","pdfPage":119,"start":102,"end":1968,"textSha256":"af11943a5bf736e0d25a2f03d86d0fbe23e4a63f980bcce67b19382efb8fea4b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4f5f517e6729f43c1daf1c5a","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The dissertation spans distinct Dirac seesaw and radiative constructions; quarticity is one construction. Atomic canonical identities remain unresolved. Independent challenge qualification: The dissertation covers distinct Dirac seesaw and radiative constructions. Quarticity is one construction; a single atomic identity is not established."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4f5f517e6729f43c1daf1c5a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","q025-candidate-question:1741aec31a82052c172c976b"],"scopeContentSha256":"83f288a69ec8a6cea81b310a997e639d249a7bb15adafc2c00f635ffec8e8e45","contributionContentSha256":"bd43e47a9c4def7b9ce20ccd7d723e069b06985266582aff6744836d864a1dee","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:06e02802a61822debb84bbbd593b9aa31ecb9e95a9ead7fee85cd61e9816f808","textSha256":"1b1486827b6017d8e3d11794f6eeb0c5bb94904826be395667cba3eea2a1903f"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:162a16fada92e6b548db0421d8207ee3","paperId":"2110.15755","sourceSha256":"49b942675ae95ad094f4b7e4e7f9746986a05b4b0eb91c65f01492b7956a7e6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/70a8ab94eab8ffb96dea/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9326dfe963d219e34f551884bc27c4c4471526f6d03a5b8ec7bb19757029eb51","pdfPage":17,"start":0,"end":1398,"textSha256":"e9c5a52df8901c66b9f1060d53c9e8f7e1760db5701e27f04a8bf91c277bc757","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2dc8c597ba40cb8346d662e539bbfd2a","paperId":"2110.15755","sourceSha256":"49b942675ae95ad094f4b7e4e7f9746986a05b4b0eb91c65f01492b7956a7e6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/70a8ab94eab8ffb96dea/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9326dfe963d219e34f551884bc27c4c4471526f6d03a5b8ec7bb19757029eb51","pdfPage":101,"start":0,"end":1926,"textSha256":"02c54b5be4bb3ec7a83d3e65ade3b01ed8a4b0b57d78be1a1c5c8c6a2cf5cbe5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6f0b46b8040641d430778d6aa5a6e855","paperId":"2110.15755","sourceSha256":"49b942675ae95ad094f4b7e4e7f9746986a05b4b0eb91c65f01492b7956a7e6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/70a8ab94eab8ffb96dea/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9326dfe963d219e34f551884bc27c4c4471526f6d03a5b8ec7bb19757029eb51","pdfPage":119,"start":102,"end":1968,"textSha256":"af11943a5bf736e0d25a2f03d86d0fbe23e4a63f980bcce67b19382efb8fea4b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4f5f517e6729f43c1daf1c5a","recordId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The dissertation spans distinct Dirac seesaw and radiative constructions; quarticity is one construction. Atomic canonical identities remain unresolved.","challengeNote":"The dissertation covers distinct Dirac seesaw and radiative constructions. Quarticity is one construction; a single atomic identity is not established.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"f1b33174e1954df283f4ec120d29716bcee3465deb68276be639331eaeee2e9d"},"organizational-access:9764ef28e16c67c9485fb787":{"id":"organizational-access:9764ef28e16c67c9485fb787","source":"q025-candidate-question:2a4de9cc1e863c4f6a0f8fe4","target":"q025-candidate-question:069d6300377d97c2979ddbeb","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:2a4de9cc1e863c4f6a0f8fe4","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9c1ab3104e5be370ea218960e873f805844348dff1c729240e6ad78fb1cd7e9a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:02741bf4d1d267b599e32404"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:069d6300377d97c2979ddbeb","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b1529cd7c734dba0ac9528ea84a965d32a7aa885deb64b6ca8981767e3ed17ca","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7465e2e25fa87b768449fe40"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","home":{"unitId":"unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2a4de9cc1e863c4f6a0f8fe4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","paperId":"0706.0514","textSha256":"2b58785de0b116829c31a6b8bf9ca3bd7ca6cacf616d5a18153cacdd0729dc7d"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:003ff26091251046d02d16d1e68f1d7c","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":5,"start":250,"end":1878,"textSha256":"3c36b57a71deca2170531e999197f99eb5c65be08c905fd2b40675e6f7f29477","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1a423fbd47160dececd67f964a7ae719","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2156,"textSha256":"32e7ed423072e38c7cbd3574600435786064a8497a18380b94636549ca25487d","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f697c98b5936dc259d0c8acb901fc560","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":2176,"textSha256":"a43301630cb41e73138b5658c4938af5a53106b6101cd3e33117fe8a39748e78","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dd2fbb0feeb55b0f78de1fd7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dd2fbb0feeb55b0f78de1fd7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","q025-candidate-question:2a4de9cc1e863c4f6a0f8fe4"],"scopeContentSha256":"9c1ab3104e5be370ea218960e873f805844348dff1c729240e6ad78fb1cd7e9a","placementContentSha256":"8aafbaf4ed48827f451a4c6849ef9c5a25d1effc203e30b51a764131dba29d3d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","paperId":"0706.0514","textSha256":"2b58785de0b116829c31a6b8bf9ca3bd7ca6cacf616d5a18153cacdd0729dc7d"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:003ff26091251046d02d16d1e68f1d7c","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":5,"start":250,"end":1878,"textSha256":"3c36b57a71deca2170531e999197f99eb5c65be08c905fd2b40675e6f7f29477","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1a423fbd47160dececd67f964a7ae719","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2156,"textSha256":"32e7ed423072e38c7cbd3574600435786064a8497a18380b94636549ca25487d","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f697c98b5936dc259d0c8acb901fc560","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":2176,"textSha256":"a43301630cb41e73138b5658c4938af5a53106b6101cd3e33117fe8a39748e78","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dd2fbb0feeb55b0f78de1fd7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:069d6300377d97c2979ddbeb","role":"instantiates","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","textSha256":"2b58785de0b116829c31a6b8bf9ca3bd7ca6cacf616d5a18153cacdd0729dc7d"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:003ff26091251046d02d16d1e68f1d7c","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":5,"start":250,"end":1878,"textSha256":"3c36b57a71deca2170531e999197f99eb5c65be08c905fd2b40675e6f7f29477","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1a423fbd47160dececd67f964a7ae719","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2156,"textSha256":"32e7ed423072e38c7cbd3574600435786064a8497a18380b94636549ca25487d","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e28","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f697c98b5936dc259d0c8acb901fc560","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":2176,"textSha256":"a43301630cb41e73138b5658c4938af5a53106b6101cd3e33117fe8a39748e78","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ec66222f5012b494e3652603"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ec66222f5012b494e3652603","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","q025-candidate-question:069d6300377d97c2979ddbeb"],"scopeContentSha256":"b1529cd7c734dba0ac9528ea84a965d32a7aa885deb64b6ca8981767e3ed17ca","contributionContentSha256":"d9ad86bf9582f8ab676ccb48bf53797c30ea1f9756acf97351fdd1556fa5f1de","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","textSha256":"2b58785de0b116829c31a6b8bf9ca3bd7ca6cacf616d5a18153cacdd0729dc7d"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:003ff26091251046d02d16d1e68f1d7c","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":5,"start":250,"end":1878,"textSha256":"3c36b57a71deca2170531e999197f99eb5c65be08c905fd2b40675e6f7f29477","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1a423fbd47160dececd67f964a7ae719","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2156,"textSha256":"32e7ed423072e38c7cbd3574600435786064a8497a18380b94636549ca25487d","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e28","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f697c98b5936dc259d0c8acb901fc560","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":2176,"textSha256":"a43301630cb41e73138b5658c4938af5a53106b6101cd3e33117fe8a39748e78","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ec66222f5012b494e3652603","recordId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"No Kähler moduli exist here. Explicit bulk analysis assumes the other modes stabilized separately.","challengeNote":"No Kähler or size modulus exists. The explicit bulk analysis assumes other modes stabilized separately; the protection argument does not calculate a complete yo","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a355bf6479ac1236f8bdf0290a0c53a7a1d9f0ce9e392f41b73cdefc04fbcb23"},"organizational-access:72c844ccbddfc90f1bbebcad":{"id":"organizational-access:72c844ccbddfc90f1bbebcad","source":"q025-candidate-question:35316f740154f23f8962093c","target":"q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:35316f740154f23f8962093c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"77d6ad69cdf17206def09a9eb793f3b85ee8fc5f212c880705dc69c0ae7b5a73","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:962e96a2ed40019765389ad6"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b0182bc61aaa90c9e39d667fafc29feaf99f7e8f8f6fb948a5797ab7c6c8d41a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:072a852bfd2db0ce0fd05226"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","home":{"unitId":"unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:35316f740154f23f8962093c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q3 explicitly combines global discrete anomaly conditions, Green–Schwarz couplings and string/geometric extraction methods.","qualification":"q3 explicitly covers global discrete anomalies, Green–Schwarz couplings and extraction through string inflow and geometry. Cancellation and coupling extraction remain distinguishable but linked targets. The Z3, T=0 example and refinement choices constrain the inherited example's reach without restricting the whole question to it or establishing a universal refinement.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","paperId":"2212.04503","textSha256":"bf56c61652cdabdd77d671ce93ce3541e1bc12acd295d7006619111b19b44365"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0006:u26:q3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0006:u26:q3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","q025-candidate-question:35316f740154f23f8962093c"],"scopeContentSha256":"77d6ad69cdf17206def09a9eb793f3b85ee8fc5f212c880705dc69c0ae7b5a73","placementContentSha256":"8fa682bca181e499d07043c06854d4735a0313e968695e287216226ae29a7e7c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0006:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0006:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","paperId":"2212.04503","textSha256":"bf56c61652cdabdd77d671ce93ce3541e1bc12acd295d7006619111b19b44365"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0006","unitRef":"u26"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d128","kind":"description","unitIndex":128,"unitId":"unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","textSha256":"bf56c61652cdabdd77d671ce93ce3541e1bc12acd295d7006619111b19b44365"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:569340c5297d4704418ce943c29be4e2","paperId":"2212.04503","sourceSha256":"f978fd35a32ff866798f0e3e5d4c8de2f437804dd4d8d72eb620cf2b596be565","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c10c96102e205afa0dc7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0dd97facdb9986cf810cdf587288a865487027fe0eadcbd0dda9e4acbb260389","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":1993,"textSha256":"14151b0a6df01d358f3900f15c27d602ea28e4efd572360d98f399e018baab1b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bd03e53bb8c91c86f88c4667e78220f3","paperId":"2212.04503","sourceSha256":"f978fd35a32ff866798f0e3e5d4c8de2f437804dd4d8d72eb620cf2b596be565","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c10c96102e205afa0dc7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0dd97facdb9986cf810cdf587288a865487027fe0eadcbd0dda9e4acbb260389","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1993,"textSha256":"8cc2204308fa6bdd167a6a2405c993e455420f711e8be845fd7a6d170a1cde7f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:962410ece00302bd5e6a003c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:962410ece00302bd5e6a003c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902"],"scopeContentSha256":"b0182bc61aaa90c9e39d667fafc29feaf99f7e8f8f6fb948a5797ab7c6c8d41a","contributionContentSha256":"4b0aaf5e76e019ceccde015ca907d8c23a6221823653bbaf4f3dd5bb1ce559b0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d128","kind":"description","unitIndex":128,"unitId":"unit:107804fe9e012e05bf397bcf2746efd8f2b2c74973526f5fe642433fc40844a3","textSha256":"bf56c61652cdabdd77d671ce93ce3541e1bc12acd295d7006619111b19b44365"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:569340c5297d4704418ce943c29be4e2","paperId":"2212.04503","sourceSha256":"f978fd35a32ff866798f0e3e5d4c8de2f437804dd4d8d72eb620cf2b596be565","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c10c96102e205afa0dc7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0dd97facdb9986cf810cdf587288a865487027fe0eadcbd0dda9e4acbb260389","pdfPage":1,"start":100,"end":1993,"textSha256":"14151b0a6df01d358f3900f15c27d602ea28e4efd572360d98f399e018baab1b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bd03e53bb8c91c86f88c4667e78220f3","paperId":"2212.04503","sourceSha256":"f978fd35a32ff866798f0e3e5d4c8de2f437804dd4d8d72eb620cf2b596be565","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c10c96102e205afa0dc7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0dd97facdb9986cf810cdf587288a865487027fe0eadcbd0dda9e4acbb260389","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1993,"textSha256":"8cc2204308fa6bdd167a6a2405c993e455420f711e8be845fd7a6d170a1cde7f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:962410ece00302bd5e6a003c","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Abstract-level support for the announced mechanism; Z3 with no tensor multiplets supplies the highlighted refinement test.","challengeNote":"The 8 December 2022 abstract announces the mechanism; Z3 with no tensor multiplets is the highlighted quadratic-refinement test.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"64c9a27253a34afd46a3a6df105dd1526ce4491889e83ecba3bb3790a6014ad0"},"organizational-access:4de3e7fee868874687acb6b3":{"id":"organizational-access:4de3e7fee868874687acb6b3","source":"q025-candidate-question:38ea8d7b16f6a8726c81a6f3","target":"q025-candidate-question:4e64ba9b3cb4c45100335cf8","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:38ea8d7b16f6a8726c81a6f3","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"aa8de3a58f23b483548c1329344e7ee3e5bb38a689eb369b357aa769c536243e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f6bef67a0a3b95e1c3f4a62d"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:4e64ba9b3cb4c45100335cf8","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"af5c5b5b5e59e59144bac6ddf535fe13dc58d53bcbb385b676735e51808c3883","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c8d263bfd257c82692af2e22"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:6bff20f447a4ef623c02e7de8251634e18fa63f1e98311c38770308d80343fc4","home":{"unitId":"unit:6bff20f447a4ef623c02e7de8251634e18fa63f1e98311c38770308d80343fc4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:38ea8d7b16f6a8726c81a6f3","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Connects quality protection, existence of extra-dimensional axion defects and post-inflationary relic viability.","qualification":"q7 explicitly connects quality, extra-dimensional axion defects, their existence and post-inflationary relic predictions. The sub-gravity tension is a required property of the strings whose compatibility is being tested, and remains part of the full question.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6bff20f447a4ef623c02e7de8251634e18fa63f1e98311c38770308d80343fc4","paperId":"2606.16445","textSha256":"50587a2f2bc5576f492fbf41db6d1a31bb567d50d97208041bb67a45212932d2"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0038:u17:q7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0038:u17:q7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6bff20f447a4ef623c02e7de8251634e18fa63f1e98311c38770308d80343fc4","q025-candidate-question:38ea8d7b16f6a8726c81a6f3"],"scopeContentSha256":"aa8de3a58f23b483548c1329344e7ee3e5bb38a689eb369b357aa769c536243e","placementContentSha256":"7f629cbaba8fa7b0a9abf8b2dd07445edd3c5bdd7c48c4b9bcd49469e05df06c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0038:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0038:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6bff20f447a4ef623c02e7de8251634e18fa63f1e98311c38770308d80343fc4","paperId":"2606.16445","textSha256":"50587a2f2bc5576f492fbf41db6d1a31bb567d50d97208041bb67a45212932d2"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0038","unitRef":"u17"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:6bff20f447a4ef623c02e7de8251634e18fa63f1e98311c38770308d80343fc4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4e64ba9b3cb4c45100335cf8","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:6bff20f447a4ef623c02e7de8251634e18fa63f1e98311c38770308d80343fc4","textSha256":"50587a2f2bc5576f492fbf41db6d1a31bb567d50d97208041bb67a45212932d2"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:62880f4b03b49ed5eae97037ab480ef9","paperId":"2606.16445","sourceSha256":"c101ff3ba0e57273cf1c16d4c18d53d2a37c453270f89175e4221427aa8f53c1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b80ccdc9e5f820e6dfe1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3ca5284c99c8d280d33409766714a247e6eb6460235a63f4a46a5b639dec1ef0","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b1ef08bb4fff8b7e3f2263f07e6e4fdf15de462356c5a49d4e30d3362df1b980","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cd68fe62dba77dbc97143dc7ead2f30b","paperId":"2606.16445","sourceSha256":"c101ff3ba0e57273cf1c16d4c18d53d2a37c453270f89175e4221427aa8f53c1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b80ccdc9e5f820e6dfe1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3ca5284c99c8d280d33409766714a247e6eb6460235a63f4a46a5b639dec1ef0","pdfPage":4,"start":1285,"end":3573,"textSha256":"0b2849e44f8009c82da0bc9c9244522ff0532a3c15b26bfaabceb02343594e36","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:10782a2bff1b74b4c0617ea8","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: String construction, quality protection and post-inflationary viability are linked but distinct targets for later reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: String construction, quality protection and post-inflationary viability are linked but distinct targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:10782a2bff1b74b4c0617ea8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6bff20f447a4ef623c02e7de8251634e18fa63f1e98311c38770308d80343fc4","q025-candidate-question:4e64ba9b3cb4c45100335cf8"],"scopeContentSha256":"af5c5b5b5e59e59144bac6ddf535fe13dc58d53bcbb385b676735e51808c3883","contributionContentSha256":"1b8abba043a2eb7885ddc95d2b24cb130414e380ae187ca8fb59fc58f03193f9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-proposal","leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:6bff20f447a4ef623c02e7de8251634e18fa63f1e98311c38770308d80343fc4","textSha256":"50587a2f2bc5576f492fbf41db6d1a31bb567d50d97208041bb67a45212932d2"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:62880f4b03b49ed5eae97037ab480ef9","paperId":"2606.16445","sourceSha256":"c101ff3ba0e57273cf1c16d4c18d53d2a37c453270f89175e4221427aa8f53c1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b80ccdc9e5f820e6dfe1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3ca5284c99c8d280d33409766714a247e6eb6460235a63f4a46a5b639dec1ef0","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b1ef08bb4fff8b7e3f2263f07e6e4fdf15de462356c5a49d4e30d3362df1b980","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cd68fe62dba77dbc97143dc7ead2f30b","paperId":"2606.16445","sourceSha256":"c101ff3ba0e57273cf1c16d4c18d53d2a37c453270f89175e4221427aa8f53c1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b80ccdc9e5f820e6dfe1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3ca5284c99c8d280d33409766714a247e6eb6460235a63f4a46a5b639dec1ef0","pdfPage":4,"start":1285,"end":3573,"textSha256":"0b2849e44f8009c82da0bc9c9244522ff0532a3c15b26bfaabceb02343594e36","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:10782a2bff1b74b4c0617ea8","recordId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b84c4bf91f06faf7761e-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"String construction, quality protection and post-inflationary viability are linked but distinct targets for later reconciliation.","challengeNote":"String construction, quality protection and post-inflationary viability are linked but distinct targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"28349c15f636041024e1e518556f4ad79a213c7c395a96a1c9df2384cef7bcdb"},"organizational-access:ce49b53c8020e782c20c70bf":{"id":"organizational-access:ce49b53c8020e782c20c70bf","source":"q025-candidate-question:50a72199b010ce93bbc70376","target":"q025-candidate-question:ba6c0c8b7e3685cf8d7246d8","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:50a72199b010ce93bbc70376","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f16cda300158f6d3ed0eb9e60b0f3a0d6f4284b530777e947d83b7d2c2603385","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e03920cfd80b341abda79831"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ba6c0c8b7e3685cf8d7246d8","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"35addf49bbfcbf26d81bc73796b34ccf66f44790a01b09829211a476c3b58556","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:24c739bde14efc9f29cd8c1c"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0ec7a43507d417d909cb7e32bb2f82bc02fa953a89c31a2f642cd4fa3c5b75aa","home":{"unitId":"unit:0ec7a43507d417d909cb7e32bb2f82bc02fa953a89c31a2f642cd4fa3c5b75aa","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:50a72199b010ce93bbc70376","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q7 explicitly covers local supersymmetric R-symmetry models, anomaly consistency, viable breaking and controlled effective interactions.","qualification":"q7 covers local supersymmetric R models, anomaly consistency, symmetry breaking and controlled effective interactions. The baryon/lepton restrictions are retained as interaction-selection outputs. The inherited near-Planck breaking setting remains particular to this construction.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0ec7a43507d417d909cb7e32bb2f82bc02fa953a89c31a2f642cd4fa3c5b75aa","paperId":"hep-ph/9504337","textSha256":"9aa29a09a301d06546c3f6bd3b4462d0fbd518b3f25483ac746b1fd45600303c"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0011:u21:q7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0011:u21:q7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0ec7a43507d417d909cb7e32bb2f82bc02fa953a89c31a2f642cd4fa3c5b75aa","q025-candidate-question:50a72199b010ce93bbc70376"],"scopeContentSha256":"f16cda300158f6d3ed0eb9e60b0f3a0d6f4284b530777e947d83b7d2c2603385","placementContentSha256":"2c98fcfd9d100a4b1494cc20597588f8a10264106f8f08feef72636c3651f327","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0011:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0011:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0ec7a43507d417d909cb7e32bb2f82bc02fa953a89c31a2f642cd4fa3c5b75aa","paperId":"hep-ph/9504337","textSha256":"9aa29a09a301d06546c3f6bd3b4462d0fbd518b3f25483ac746b1fd45600303c"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0011","unitRef":"u21"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0ec7a43507d417d909cb7e32bb2f82bc02fa953a89c31a2f642cd4fa3c5b75aa","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ba6c0c8b7e3685cf8d7246d8","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d81","kind":"description","unitIndex":81,"unitId":"unit:0ec7a43507d417d909cb7e32bb2f82bc02fa953a89c31a2f642cd4fa3c5b75aa","textSha256":"9aa29a09a301d06546c3f6bd3b4462d0fbd518b3f25483ac746b1fd45600303c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:be8ae9ab1ac1657553edd78e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:be8ae9ab1ac1657553edd78e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0ec7a43507d417d909cb7e32bb2f82bc02fa953a89c31a2f642cd4fa3c5b75aa","q025-candidate-question:ba6c0c8b7e3685cf8d7246d8"],"scopeContentSha256":"35addf49bbfcbf26d81bc73796b34ccf66f44790a01b09829211a476c3b58556","contributionContentSha256":"e04f23c451126f251cbc34f3d6c2813faac7d590466af753da6575160bdc1427","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-proposal","leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d81","kind":"description","unitIndex":81,"unitId":"unit:0ec7a43507d417d909cb7e32bb2f82bc02fa953a89c31a2f642cd4fa3c5b75aa","textSha256":"9aa29a09a301d06546c3f6bd3b4462d0fbd518b3f25483ac746b1fd45600303c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:be8ae9ab1ac1657553edd78e","recordId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Viable breaking and baryon/lepton-number restrictions supplement the anomaly-cancellation target.","challengeNote":"Viable symmetry breaking and baryon/lepton-number restrictions supplement anomaly cancellation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"8bc0e459455306a2290aed1747e1fb2a035a92ee10fc1e2f25ae72306d85d1ae"},"organizational-access:f6517d5dfe2ed88ecef2f367":{"id":"organizational-access:f6517d5dfe2ed88ecef2f367","source":"q025-candidate-question:5b92b8a6f9019e398cfb5784","target":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:5b92b8a6f9019e398cfb5784","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"0ad3b3f71674ff362425b140142e59f55e207f26a8d04d218b1638d883d4a234","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6b1795c796db5472ba304552"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e7bfdb347122b88b4493cb61c8710d7d4a59d83dfaafed946ad077d25fd8bedb","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:859d8ffda9e026d9a6f0a1fb"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","home":{"unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:5b92b8a6f9019e398cfb5784","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Directly covers canonical and interacting quintessence, low-redshift expansion fitting, inferred H0 and observational acceptability.","qualification":"q1 covers canonical quintessence with an optional exponential dark-matter interaction, low-redshift fitted histories, H0 displacement relative to ΛCDM and statistical acceptability. The CMB comparison motivates the question without requiring a constructed high-redshift completion. A finite scan cannot establish a universal no-go.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","paperId":"2006.00244","textSha256":"fabb290146b115b17311b3b2c38b0343ebb029cf637ecf49554b7bea58f59a65"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0032:u9:q1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0032:u9:q1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","q025-candidate-question:5b92b8a6f9019e398cfb5784"],"scopeContentSha256":"0ad3b3f71674ff362425b140142e59f55e207f26a8d04d218b1638d883d4a234","placementContentSha256":"c27a231c9a62f1fa19b72eb63a43eabb239962d7020dad214463d010aacd26df","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0032:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0032:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","paperId":"2006.00244","textSha256":"fabb290146b115b17311b3b2c38b0343ebb029cf637ecf49554b7bea58f59a65"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0032","unitRef":"u9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","textSha256":"fabb290146b115b17311b3b2c38b0343ebb029cf637ecf49554b7bea58f59a65"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c22d747d330f23006457b16b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c22d747d330f23006457b16b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80"],"scopeContentSha256":"e7bfdb347122b88b4493cb61c8710d7d4a59d83dfaafed946ad077d25fd8bedb","contributionContentSha256":"1487a5dce08e0c80306dfdc013a997ff86a6753e307f46005361cf484fa41109","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:2354b78d6e59edddc763d0c2c00417cb1b787f65a7fb9bcd16095eb4af5ba9b8","textSha256":"fabb290146b115b17311b3b2c38b0343ebb029cf637ecf49554b7bea58f59a65"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c22d747d330f23006457b16b","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Includes an exponential interaction as an option; the target is low-redshift inference and fit quality.","challengeNote":"The exponential interaction is an included option; an increased fitted H0 does not establish an acceptable joint fit.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a2a19d1f7a904b42706919a86bf8b2493b98d3b9ed5575fc89583c8eba64ae8f","home":{"unitId":"unit:a2a19d1f7a904b42706919a86bf8b2493b98d3b9ed5575fc89583c8eba64ae8f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:5b92b8a6f9019e398cfb5784","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers phenomenological coupled quintessence, equation-of-state departures, expansion fits and joint linear-growth constraints.","qualification":"The target is an allowed departure from cosmological-constant behavior under joint expansion and linear-growth constraints. q1 directly encompasses that question for phenomenological interacting quintessence. q0 explicitly names PST axions but emphasizes scaling, forces and dynamical behavior; the system match does not make it the more direct home for this full data-compatibility target.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a2a19d1f7a904b42706919a86bf8b2493b98d3b9ed5575fc89583c8eba64ae8f","paperId":"1302.1331","textSha256":"86ec599f30560d898560af4aa0edaf36533e8a685a99a4117d51d584fb7e27d0"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0032:u8:q1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0032:u8:q1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a2a19d1f7a904b42706919a86bf8b2493b98d3b9ed5575fc89583c8eba64ae8f","q025-candidate-question:5b92b8a6f9019e398cfb5784"],"scopeContentSha256":"0ad3b3f71674ff362425b140142e59f55e207f26a8d04d218b1638d883d4a234","placementContentSha256":"ba25a7bb5a801f6da9cb2000f6cb9f5fb228573692bbb7eb1ebddbc692807126","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0032:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0032:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a2a19d1f7a904b42706919a86bf8b2493b98d3b9ed5575fc89583c8eba64ae8f","paperId":"1302.1331","textSha256":"86ec599f30560d898560af4aa0edaf36533e8a685a99a4117d51d584fb7e27d0"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0032","unitRef":"u8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a2a19d1f7a904b42706919a86bf8b2493b98d3b9ed5575fc89583c8eba64ae8f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:a2a19d1f7a904b42706919a86bf8b2493b98d3b9ed5575fc89583c8eba64ae8f","textSha256":"86ec599f30560d898560af4aa0edaf36533e8a685a99a4117d51d584fb7e27d0"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:07acef40e5427faddac9df5acef1a2c9","paperId":"1302.1331","sourceSha256":"11f2bd3423d461061a27b8f84ace2be5419498b1971cc5a0f2b37f44e3a11401","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9ff4740272ae86d424cc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3a74d34328a34fca3c57708f446c562f6fbb1338d8456a4728582860613f2f41","pdfPage":2,"start":1307,"end":4361,"textSha256":"0eab1e2f5ca50f5c61eb97d11be2bbeb71771f846732945dc3c5ff9f448fb479","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4d8a794ccd732d3db66c45f6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4d8a794ccd732d3db66c45f6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a2a19d1f7a904b42706919a86bf8b2493b98d3b9ed5575fc89583c8eba64ae8f","q025-candidate-question:a04d5ca049ff9c0177a5dd80"],"scopeContentSha256":"e7bfdb347122b88b4493cb61c8710d7d4a59d83dfaafed946ad077d25fd8bedb","contributionContentSha256":"3187a3ee97d74bd0a7e454f60ed1e55f1167c65ec059c44962047f07438a9628","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:a2a19d1f7a904b42706919a86bf8b2493b98d3b9ed5575fc89583c8eba64ae8f","textSha256":"86ec599f30560d898560af4aa0edaf36533e8a685a99a4117d51d584fb7e27d0"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:07acef40e5427faddac9df5acef1a2c9","paperId":"1302.1331","sourceSha256":"11f2bd3423d461061a27b8f84ace2be5419498b1971cc5a0f2b37f44e3a11401","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9ff4740272ae86d424cc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3a74d34328a34fca3c57708f446c562f6fbb1338d8456a4728582860613f2f41","pdfPage":2,"start":1307,"end":4361,"textSha256":"0eab1e2f5ca50f5c61eb97d11be2bbeb71771f846732945dc3c5ff9f448fb479","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4d8a794ccd732d3db66c45f6","recordId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-45dcaa67fd021056a4f5-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":1,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"dc42e5d72561799509f35121b4e9b495a45b0a8098deb0aac290ee7013a9ec33"},"organizational-access:efae8a6252a8f2a45355cde9":{"id":"organizational-access:efae8a6252a8f2a45355cde9","source":"q025-candidate-question:640ecf6fc92cc27f6876f2e5","target":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:640ecf6fc92cc27f6876f2e5","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a704ba50ce38a2c5ea4058a0579ac1e594976a04ec161b6ae97512d7de414fcd","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3a30728c8a03c1333d4dadf9"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"cf4b878f8c8a9e621142d4757c68c105582cb223b4ed08afbca88ce0cbdf5a8a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:9aa50da17d13735ad47e333f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","home":{"unitId":"unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:640ecf6fc92cc27f6876f2e5","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q5 explicitly combines potential inference, expansion-history tests, H0 tests and statistical comparison with ΛCDM.","qualification":"q5 covers all four observational targets as one composite question. Unconstrained shapes, unsuccessful H0 cases and preference for ΛCDM remain source-dated outcomes. The truncated historical annotation is unnecessary for coverage because the complete description and q5 independently specify model comparison.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","paperId":"1810.08586","textSha256":"6e0c5bfacfbc6b3ca37fecc88061ce7970d88d295b9e590dbca371904722c3a1"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0055:u7:q5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0055:u7:q5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","q025-candidate-question:640ecf6fc92cc27f6876f2e5"],"scopeContentSha256":"a704ba50ce38a2c5ea4058a0579ac1e594976a04ec161b6ae97512d7de414fcd","placementContentSha256":"0dc202e564be2becb60bde95cbf9895eca55f6a81a15849bf16709a93bb844f2","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0055:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0055:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","paperId":"1810.08586","textSha256":"6e0c5bfacfbc6b3ca37fecc88061ce7970d88d295b9e590dbca371904722c3a1"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0055","unitRef":"u7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","textSha256":"6e0c5bfacfbc6b3ca37fecc88061ce7970d88d295b9e590dbca371904722c3a1"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3ac9e645de7d189e78cd74e4793457cd","paperId":"1810.08586","sourceSha256":"4806c743dda7c7aa39bf57e01d607b3b9f2304a9d0b76c32804706c91f7d1f06","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b2f0301c351118bc9bfe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"580c1f64ffd7225adb5213442a008cab4ae87565cbcc9db00be0bf5f3c3d0a65","pdfPage":23,"start":93,"end":3491,"textSha256":"bb9dabcc0b9b321dd156e3eb971cf363480952c0b8521e6b1d9ad57357870d44","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e172800a675f9e09bddba5eeafc05aa2","paperId":"1810.08586","sourceSha256":"4806c743dda7c7aa39bf57e01d607b3b9f2304a9d0b76c32804706c91f7d1f06","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b2f0301c351118bc9bfe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"580c1f64ffd7225adb5213442a008cab4ae87565cbcc9db00be0bf5f3c3d0a65","pdfPage":13,"start":2489,"end":5245,"textSha256":"897475bb5c8f9238ad4c7004db5a70159dfaa8586eb52af87b650097e93ee7eb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d8eb7cbb91f144923b791c02421625b0","paperId":"1810.08586","sourceSha256":"4806c743dda7c7aa39bf57e01d607b3b9f2304a9d0b76c32804706c91f7d1f06","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b2f0301c351118bc9bfe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"580c1f64ffd7225adb5213442a008cab4ae87565cbcc9db00be0bf5f3c3d0a65","pdfPage":23,"start":3686,"end":5544,"textSha256":"a9a591caaf70c70da5451c9e60be831db4fadd58af5bae1b2865a8a58b9f50af","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:79f2d3e16f224a7f612b3bf0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:79f2d3e16f224a7f612b3bf0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","q025-candidate-question:1cb68c84f4e26bf3ade9917a"],"scopeContentSha256":"cf4b878f8c8a9e621142d4757c68c105582cb223b4ed08afbca88ce0cbdf5a8a","contributionContentSha256":"b3006d8dc27e7c216720cc5815181f36b8db54e3cf79f8630f3d1fc0bb4ad568","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:6081a1b036118c5b586f8cac8b8ff923f48f5408baa0fa576c17535d73d16ba7","textSha256":"6e0c5bfacfbc6b3ca37fecc88061ce7970d88d295b9e590dbca371904722c3a1"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3ac9e645de7d189e78cd74e4793457cd","paperId":"1810.08586","sourceSha256":"4806c743dda7c7aa39bf57e01d607b3b9f2304a9d0b76c32804706c91f7d1f06","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b2f0301c351118bc9bfe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"580c1f64ffd7225adb5213442a008cab4ae87565cbcc9db00be0bf5f3c3d0a65","pdfPage":23,"start":93,"end":3491,"textSha256":"bb9dabcc0b9b321dd156e3eb971cf363480952c0b8521e6b1d9ad57357870d44","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e172800a675f9e09bddba5eeafc05aa2","paperId":"1810.08586","sourceSha256":"4806c743dda7c7aa39bf57e01d607b3b9f2304a9d0b76c32804706c91f7d1f06","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b2f0301c351118bc9bfe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"580c1f64ffd7225adb5213442a008cab4ae87565cbcc9db00be0bf5f3c3d0a65","pdfPage":13,"start":2489,"end":5245,"textSha256":"897475bb5c8f9238ad4c7004db5a70159dfaa8586eb52af87b650097e93ee7eb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d8eb7cbb91f144923b791c02421625b0","paperId":"1810.08586","sourceSha256":"4806c743dda7c7aa39bf57e01d607b3b9f2304a9d0b76c32804706c91f7d1f06","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b2f0301c351118bc9bfe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"580c1f64ffd7225adb5213442a008cab4ae87565cbcc9db00be0bf5f3c3d0a65","pdfPage":23,"start":3686,"end":5544,"textSha256":"a9a591caaf70c70da5451c9e60be831db4fadd58af5bae1b2865a8a58b9f50af","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:79f2d3e16f224a7f612b3bf0","recordId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1084a296ab33ed67069b-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound observational tests retained. Shape parameters remain unconstrained in the reported analysis; cited H0 cases fail, and Bayesian evidence favors ΛCDM.","challengeNote":"Compound observational tests retained for reconciliation. Reported shape parameters are unconstrained, the cited H0 cases fail, and Bayesian evidence favors ΛCD","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"8db33f49570d10d747640b6abc74903318d8d0049210af590add76d057c1bae8"},"organizational-access:0289628b0e4fd6f3938d1dcc":{"id":"organizational-access:0289628b0e4fd6f3938d1dcc","source":"q025-candidate-question:653860ca81adb137672b4e79","target":"q025-candidate-question:0c6354dde52b6f30d076f1af","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:653860ca81adb137672b4e79","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"96afb058b85e944df291b8e24fbf0bdf1df1478ec2b88acab0aedf46734c5c44","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:213bb0c111230c75e80651cc"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:0c6354dde52b6f30d076f1af","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"d9c4aa77f376618d18d38ca7df66807164f6104116e16469dc4db037905fd4c6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7ac1f3360ed0fcfec3c41eff"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:fe6dc046ee7770118eba5c76219c8cb0727f768a7f3614fde8015deb02cd0301","home":{"unitId":"unit:fe6dc046ee7770118eba5c76219c8cb0727f768a7f3614fde8015deb02cd0301","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:653860ca81adb137672b4e79","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Its question explicitly covers scalar-dependent masses, permitted potentials, stasis duration, exits and future capture.","qualification":"q5 directly covers the mechanism, allowed potentials, existence, duration, exits and future capture, including cosmological consistency. Its general-model and constrained-specialization branches remain separate; PBH evaporation supplies background context only.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fe6dc046ee7770118eba5c76219c8cb0727f768a7f3614fde8015deb02cd0301","paperId":"2609.25230","textSha256":"5f98965e8a50d8ef0345c36f38ea044a113d222cd370dbbe20adb9de3c91c0f8"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0064:u6:q5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0064:u6:q5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fe6dc046ee7770118eba5c76219c8cb0727f768a7f3614fde8015deb02cd0301","q025-candidate-question:653860ca81adb137672b4e79"],"scopeContentSha256":"96afb058b85e944df291b8e24fbf0bdf1df1478ec2b88acab0aedf46734c5c44","placementContentSha256":"9c5a624cfe3ab604f0d551927689fca15e49784fbef987b50fa71a542e0e7ced","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0064:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0064:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fe6dc046ee7770118eba5c76219c8cb0727f768a7f3614fde8015deb02cd0301","paperId":"2609.25230","textSha256":"5f98965e8a50d8ef0345c36f38ea044a113d222cd370dbbe20adb9de3c91c0f8"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0064","unitRef":"u6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fe6dc046ee7770118eba5c76219c8cb0727f768a7f3614fde8015deb02cd0301","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0c6354dde52b6f30d076f1af","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d67","kind":"description","unitIndex":67,"unitId":"unit:fe6dc046ee7770118eba5c76219c8cb0727f768a7f3614fde8015deb02cd0301","textSha256":"5f98965e8a50d8ef0345c36f38ea044a113d222cd370dbbe20adb9de3c91c0f8"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2213203cc71830375632d1a5","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Existence, duration, exit and future capture retain their different temporal roles. Independent challenge qualification: Existence, duration, exits and future capture retain their distinct temporal roles."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2213203cc71830375632d1a5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fe6dc046ee7770118eba5c76219c8cb0727f768a7f3614fde8015deb02cd0301","q025-candidate-question:0c6354dde52b6f30d076f1af"],"scopeContentSha256":"d9c4aa77f376618d18d38ca7df66807164f6104116e16469dc4db037905fd4c6","contributionContentSha256":"2a98b490443137bc4c7af4c600f590095f73bfac336433711fe12c4ff20c1a5c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-proposal","leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d67","kind":"description","unitIndex":67,"unitId":"unit:fe6dc046ee7770118eba5c76219c8cb0727f768a7f3614fde8015deb02cd0301","textSha256":"5f98965e8a50d8ef0345c36f38ea044a113d222cd370dbbe20adb9de3c91c0f8"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2213203cc71830375632d1a5","recordId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a3a82516dca24e6d25cc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Existence, duration, exit and future capture retain their different temporal roles.","challengeNote":"Existence, duration, exits and future capture retain their distinct temporal roles.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"c6d017c6f3dd9d7738716d5786e31b9f7172df4a49af7534dfd35ccbf5821591"},"organizational-access:973b2251a137084384254586":{"id":"organizational-access:973b2251a137084384254586","source":"q025-candidate-question:6ab6e19333e148a30affb029","target":"q025-candidate-question:9e44e8dff4c26ab1b806c4f8","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6ab6e19333e148a30affb029","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ec93c95809bd34031670c5e29fedf6611ea2b7632909ec0aef504be4a738e5b1","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e2a9e18025f201398f2476ce"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9e44e8dff4c26ab1b806c4f8","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c60141132495379295a225dfd91f69ac1c55e5ab3c5a4234f41830d3b9b2858b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:60ec8964b23e8e3cca11a46f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5fdf6b6c0a0cc7419f01f2ce6d10c49fcaee31d1081ed57fca3dd8c1a7fc7df9","home":{"unitId":"unit:5fdf6b6c0a0cc7419f01f2ce6d10c49fcaee31d1081ed57fca3dd8c1a7fc7df9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6ab6e19333e148a30affb029","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q13 connects conditional no-go inequalities from compactification scaling to gradient coefficients and explicitly preserves dependence on external dimension and scalar normalization.","qualification":"q13 covers the background hypotheses of conditional scaling inequalities and their slope coefficients. The ten-dimensional parent theory remains distinct from the external dimension; numerical slopes require the source's field metric and normalization.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5fdf6b6c0a0cc7419f01f2ce6d10c49fcaee31d1081ed57fca3dd8c1a7fc7df9","paperId":"2208.14462","textSha256":"239817f5bcd207cbcdaec4d84af6b83ef440c333b757b822ef257287a819eb65"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u27:q13"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u27:q13","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5fdf6b6c0a0cc7419f01f2ce6d10c49fcaee31d1081ed57fca3dd8c1a7fc7df9","q025-candidate-question:6ab6e19333e148a30affb029"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec93c95809bd34031670c5e29fedf6611ea2b7632909ec0aef504be4a738e5b1","placementContentSha256":"9da5f03d3511cd93ce7cc402d0b9d7ab626cd02ea35644ac1b0fb5178a0fe902","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5fdf6b6c0a0cc7419f01f2ce6d10c49fcaee31d1081ed57fca3dd8c1a7fc7df9","paperId":"2208.14462","textSha256":"239817f5bcd207cbcdaec4d84af6b83ef440c333b757b822ef257287a819eb65"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0031","unitRef":"u27"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5fdf6b6c0a0cc7419f01f2ce6d10c49fcaee31d1081ed57fca3dd8c1a7fc7df9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9e44e8dff4c26ab1b806c4f8","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:5fdf6b6c0a0cc7419f01f2ce6d10c49fcaee31d1081ed57fca3dd8c1a7fc7df9","textSha256":"239817f5bcd207cbcdaec4d84af6b83ef440c333b757b822ef257287a819eb65"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a15a8120b2ace4beae32af18"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a15a8120b2ace4beae32af18","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5fdf6b6c0a0cc7419f01f2ce6d10c49fcaee31d1081ed57fca3dd8c1a7fc7df9","q025-candidate-question:9e44e8dff4c26ab1b806c4f8"],"scopeContentSha256":"c60141132495379295a225dfd91f69ac1c55e5ab3c5a4234f41830d3b9b2858b","contributionContentSha256":"e67e6512a52be4c25309cdab37c4d4ab86511ea786f9522cdbf6ad09c3965a61","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:5fdf6b6c0a0cc7419f01f2ce6d10c49fcaee31d1081ed57fca3dd8c1a7fc7df9","textSha256":"239817f5bcd207cbcdaec4d84af6b83ef440c333b757b822ef257287a819eb65"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a15a8120b2ace4beae32af18","recordId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"f74704683afb14128ffda1612fedbbf79bf1aad866a11f0dbe2e824463f5661f"},"organizational-access:4b1519ad8fe1b66c0e8fbebc":{"id":"organizational-access:4b1519ad8fe1b66c0e8fbebc","source":"q025-candidate-question:6b099a72fa61aa622880dfa2","target":"q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6b099a72fa61aa622880dfa2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"24db97dc82d9b7e926b5b22c624c1591c5d8fd94caf62cc41348d2bbb50e6ab2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ab088afeec803d9cd272cf27"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e5f0b23e05b128ff01faf30c56b499ddf93e45dcfd83b25fe7c3d1a35cf9eb55","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:98807f68849d9c5d578063b5"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","home":{"unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6b099a72fa61aa622880dfa2","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","paperId":"1812.04147","textSha256":"79093b923c07e9d3c57bd1d4f83b5ccdaa90f10630a9f3abd967575c6f30a64c"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9acaec5c0e653c89b0a3ef7432d4b783","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"15ed8868bb10683405878235928c821c92c1d85fd1708e9a2ee6e705ff6bf161","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f54ba78c46dede1a602bc9ae77ffce85","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":1293,"end":4693,"textSha256":"404f190296444d7c2a164706fd626c80a36fcaaf36d767eaea468f46a1eda1d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e27","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ffe5b5d3589c87c44231377111d83fa6","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":2494,"end":5251,"textSha256":"7db530de1ec75dd0da2ed39ae1e90d410ec5bc0be738f16d124db9484263a30d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6028a363351de2049d83ef75"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6028a363351de2049d83ef75","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","q025-candidate-question:6b099a72fa61aa622880dfa2"],"scopeContentSha256":"24db97dc82d9b7e926b5b22c624c1591c5d8fd94caf62cc41348d2bbb50e6ab2","placementContentSha256":"f9e65aa912ce395c04082cf9bbfc9debf8653fc356f034b3d23d46f607548bd5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","paperId":"1812.04147","textSha256":"79093b923c07e9d3c57bd1d4f83b5ccdaa90f10630a9f3abd967575c6f30a64c"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9acaec5c0e653c89b0a3ef7432d4b783","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"15ed8868bb10683405878235928c821c92c1d85fd1708e9a2ee6e705ff6bf161","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f54ba78c46dede1a602bc9ae77ffce85","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":1293,"end":4693,"textSha256":"404f190296444d7c2a164706fd626c80a36fcaaf36d767eaea468f46a1eda1d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e27","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ffe5b5d3589c87c44231377111d83fa6","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":2494,"end":5251,"textSha256":"7db530de1ec75dd0da2ed39ae1e90d410ec5bc0be738f16d124db9484263a30d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6028a363351de2049d83ef75"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","textSha256":"79093b923c07e9d3c57bd1d4f83b5ccdaa90f10630a9f3abd967575c6f30a64c"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9acaec5c0e653c89b0a3ef7432d4b783","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"15ed8868bb10683405878235928c821c92c1d85fd1708e9a2ee6e705ff6bf161","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f54ba78c46dede1a602bc9ae77ffce85","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":1293,"end":4693,"textSha256":"404f190296444d7c2a164706fd626c80a36fcaaf36d767eaea468f46a1eda1d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ffe5b5d3589c87c44231377111d83fa6","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":2494,"end":5251,"textSha256":"7db530de1ec75dd0da2ed39ae1e90d410ec5bc0be738f16d124db9484263a30d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fe8b7d61e6b51c5d8c59e0fc"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:fe8b7d61e6b51c5d8c59e0fc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e5f0b23e05b128ff01faf30c56b499ddf93e45dcfd83b25fe7c3d1a35cf9eb55","contributionContentSha256":"c2c3cd89a78c2aa17f596bc83f7e7e976861800402c7c9396bf51d0a0f69e828","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-proposal","leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:adb83ac3bccd28c2b053256ba8f51d7d22709d24e3d8cb8be9fa0907a755a68e","textSha256":"79093b923c07e9d3c57bd1d4f83b5ccdaa90f10630a9f3abd967575c6f30a64c"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9acaec5c0e653c89b0a3ef7432d4b783","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"15ed8868bb10683405878235928c821c92c1d85fd1708e9a2ee6e705ff6bf161","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f54ba78c46dede1a602bc9ae77ffce85","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":1293,"end":4693,"textSha256":"404f190296444d7c2a164706fd626c80a36fcaaf36d767eaea468f46a1eda1d3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ffe5b5d3589c87c44231377111d83fa6","paperId":"1812.04147","sourceSha256":"f4c4da471bbc8af0604c1045350c7565037c966f909b90cba8e1fe6a5d9fce87","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f775cdb55efcf6316697/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"154e85854d8c3c5a87012ab9b837b3b42fac1728f0e8a1adbb89308d300c4700","pdfPage":1,"start":2494,"end":5251,"textSha256":"7db530de1ec75dd0da2ed39ae1e90d410ec5bc0be738f16d124db9484263a30d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fe8b7d61e6b51c5d8c59e0fc","recordId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"14 Feb 2019 v2 announces numerical solutions with tree-level moduli; its O8 boundary identification is challenged by unit 19.","challengeNote":"The 14 Feb 2019 v2 announces numerical solutions with tree-level moduli and quantum-dependent fate. d19 is other-unit criticism context, not this unit's primary","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"14d88b5f6711d88ecbed67ce99872473e7850f6a7684c6c1ad53cf1451f4668c"},"organizational-access:9674904cd8cb3770b23c9e68":{"id":"organizational-access:9674904cd8cb3770b23c9e68","source":"q025-candidate-question:79701c4c3a5da9d76794b9b8","target":"q025-candidate-question:6a4acdd5504a55612dbfce6e","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:79701c4c3a5da9d76794b9b8","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"964cae9874b92a4a196af36d182aa6f2b1892a5dfce71c8bed7f1d950d629d94","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c7fc7d9a71bacdfa47cdaf12"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6a4acdd5504a55612dbfce6e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"93b5bac1d8fbedcaab700cd59d61d0371df18fd5a553e48e4c9252a44161d00b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:aec62c2073d9e64921c08b57"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:d919c5dd993905449cecd1112381c4c78ab564d7f8b6a25c0ed3ed082e2e537e","home":{"unitId":"unit:d919c5dd993905449cecd1112381c4c78ab564d7f8b6a25c0ed3ed082e2e537e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:79701c4c3a5da9d76794b9b8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Jointly covers accidental/gauge-protected axion constructions, explicit-breaking control, strong CP and dark matter.","qualification":"q11 explicitly combines accidental-symmetry construction, control of explicit breaking, strong-CP relaxation and dark-matter viability. The anomaly-free axial gauge setting remains distinct from anomalous-U(1) constructions.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d919c5dd993905449cecd1112381c4c78ab564d7f8b6a25c0ed3ed082e2e537e","paperId":"2412.21157","textSha256":"d88e8dc18981b03d0be7c90b0c023d6ab0c569bb647d7cbecc6445bb2518c04c"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0038:u5:q11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0038:u5:q11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d919c5dd993905449cecd1112381c4c78ab564d7f8b6a25c0ed3ed082e2e537e","q025-candidate-question:79701c4c3a5da9d76794b9b8"],"scopeContentSha256":"964cae9874b92a4a196af36d182aa6f2b1892a5dfce71c8bed7f1d950d629d94","placementContentSha256":"a7739c472bf708f68af0e484fc285f23dbf7589ae08797a58858a550b7b11b6e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0038:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0038:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d919c5dd993905449cecd1112381c4c78ab564d7f8b6a25c0ed3ed082e2e537e","paperId":"2412.21157","textSha256":"d88e8dc18981b03d0be7c90b0c023d6ab0c569bb647d7cbecc6445bb2518c04c"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0038","unitRef":"u5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d919c5dd993905449cecd1112381c4c78ab564d7f8b6a25c0ed3ed082e2e537e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6a4acdd5504a55612dbfce6e","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:d919c5dd993905449cecd1112381c4c78ab564d7f8b6a25c0ed3ed082e2e537e","textSha256":"d88e8dc18981b03d0be7c90b0c023d6ab0c569bb647d7cbecc6445bb2518c04c"},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:da3acac3a748e58f7bc1ab1d83c6b64d","paperId":"2412.21157","sourceSha256":"985fb8c27c108fe104002f4df3084389e36c2a20604d2953ac734932e41fe9cb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5f6a9208e77b4b11dd7d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5135e37dc80e2307f9449cf8546d80231084af7a6496e0fb0ef6fea6ec94b13e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2005,"textSha256":"d42d54a8c723bd769fa0cc6e22448578540bfecbde5629aa2c7c658645234ecb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eb4fc4527cab93e1bf77cd71608c1b5e","paperId":"2412.21157","sourceSha256":"985fb8c27c108fe104002f4df3084389e36c2a20604d2953ac734932e41fe9cb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5f6a9208e77b4b11dd7d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5135e37dc80e2307f9449cf8546d80231084af7a6496e0fb0ef6fea6ec94b13e","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":2005,"textSha256":"1462b8046fb3f45b34569359d438e8a5c4bcd0dc174d2cf96beb4cdda456f268","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e0904b9b658f273edb735397","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The 18 February 2025 v2 abstract announces KSVZ and SO(10) hybrid classes, distinct couplings and wall number one; full calculations are unverified. Independent challenge qualification: 18 February 2025 v2 abstract: KSVZ and SO(10) hybrid classes, distinct couplings and wall number one are announced results, not independently checked."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e0904b9b658f273edb735397","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d919c5dd993905449cecd1112381c4c78ab564d7f8b6a25c0ed3ed082e2e537e","q025-candidate-question:6a4acdd5504a55612dbfce6e"],"scopeContentSha256":"93b5bac1d8fbedcaab700cd59d61d0371df18fd5a553e48e4c9252a44161d00b","contributionContentSha256":"2f19ceb42218567793b8f363bb3aea5e7a9c57d3bf19891a7329707a3616eaca","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:d919c5dd993905449cecd1112381c4c78ab564d7f8b6a25c0ed3ed082e2e537e","textSha256":"d88e8dc18981b03d0be7c90b0c023d6ab0c569bb647d7cbecc6445bb2518c04c"},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:da3acac3a748e58f7bc1ab1d83c6b64d","paperId":"2412.21157","sourceSha256":"985fb8c27c108fe104002f4df3084389e36c2a20604d2953ac734932e41fe9cb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5f6a9208e77b4b11dd7d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5135e37dc80e2307f9449cf8546d80231084af7a6496e0fb0ef6fea6ec94b13e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2005,"textSha256":"d42d54a8c723bd769fa0cc6e22448578540bfecbde5629aa2c7c658645234ecb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:eb4fc4527cab93e1bf77cd71608c1b5e","paperId":"2412.21157","sourceSha256":"985fb8c27c108fe104002f4df3084389e36c2a20604d2953ac734932e41fe9cb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5f6a9208e77b4b11dd7d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5135e37dc80e2307f9449cf8546d80231084af7a6496e0fb0ef6fea6ec94b13e","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":2005,"textSha256":"1462b8046fb3f45b34569359d438e8a5c4bcd0dc174d2cf96beb4cdda456f268","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e0904b9b658f273edb735397","recordId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The 18 February 2025 v2 abstract announces KSVZ and SO(10) hybrid classes, distinct couplings and wall number one; full calculations are unverified.","challengeNote":"18 February 2025 v2 abstract: KSVZ and SO(10) hybrid classes, distinct couplings and wall number one are announced results, not independently checked.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a9277ad15f515f4d0c9a5c6fc2cc269a0dcb70689f8f06821d477c16d5487649"},"organizational-access:c921eceee816755a60ecf585":{"id":"organizational-access:c921eceee816755a60ecf585","source":"q025-candidate-question:79701c4c3a5da9d76794b9b8","target":"q025-candidate-question:b41fa11966510deaa70f3073","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:79701c4c3a5da9d76794b9b8","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"964cae9874b92a4a196af36d182aa6f2b1892a5dfce71c8bed7f1d950d629d94","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c7fc7d9a71bacdfa47cdaf12"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:b41fa11966510deaa70f3073","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"cf08b9ee14deaae1ca481b1dba7c1ceb4969310f10d107ad7bbb87d61b7c9da5","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0af67303048e7105cd0f9871"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:d6d2e3fd884cff4e3e7eb2ed4ff4184cd4eda8eca0f818108f3b8eaefdc4f4ee","home":{"unitId":"unit:d6d2e3fd884cff4e3e7eb2ed4ff4184cd4eda8eca0f818108f3b8eaefdc4f4ee","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:79701c4c3a5da9d76794b9b8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d6d2e3fd884cff4e3e7eb2ed4ff4184cd4eda8eca0f818108f3b8eaefdc4f4ee","paperId":"hep-ph/9203206","textSha256":"466e98bbb237d55c6581b04ed2bb0d8a7a635dc5e3a8fb155a56581892646ca8"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fe89f1741606a71d86b9824d"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fe89f1741606a71d86b9824d","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d6d2e3fd884cff4e3e7eb2ed4ff4184cd4eda8eca0f818108f3b8eaefdc4f4ee","q025-candidate-question:79701c4c3a5da9d76794b9b8"],"scopeContentSha256":"964cae9874b92a4a196af36d182aa6f2b1892a5dfce71c8bed7f1d950d629d94","placementContentSha256":"f5cd430884e677875235b6598183f81f7284d3278303fb4879d5961325609b4a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a9ef220080e0a764e6d7-challenge","leaf-a9ef220080e0a764e6d7-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d6d2e3fd884cff4e3e7eb2ed4ff4184cd4eda8eca0f818108f3b8eaefdc4f4ee","paperId":"hep-ph/9203206","textSha256":"466e98bbb237d55c6581b04ed2bb0d8a7a635dc5e3a8fb155a56581892646ca8"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fe89f1741606a71d86b9824d"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d6d2e3fd884cff4e3e7eb2ed4ff4184cd4eda8eca0f818108f3b8eaefdc4f4ee","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b41fa11966510deaa70f3073","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d52","kind":"description","unitIndex":52,"unitId":"unit:d6d2e3fd884cff4e3e7eb2ed4ff4184cd4eda8eca0f818108f3b8eaefdc4f4ee","textSha256":"466e98bbb237d55c6581b04ed2bb0d8a7a635dc5e3a8fb155a56581892646ca8"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:846399f4b958b08077ef257b79b75546","paperId":"hep-ph/9203206","sourceSha256":"ccad71b59563fd0eb5535fbda733efe530193461d62cd12170262d17f41e7a14","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ccffc0e8064008804ff/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f6f227bab6f6fb268b596e6fd83292b2661705b898c42a9132060ddccf7e53fd","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1516,"textSha256":"60a0637454be1da2d6cc5ab1a546b6f14b79f410eb1710e4009841c8ad8677e3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e0ac777db33970948c5f3ebdf7edb06a","paperId":"hep-ph/9203206","sourceSha256":"ccad71b59563fd0eb5535fbda733efe530193461d62cd12170262d17f41e7a14","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ccffc0e8064008804ff/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f6f227bab6f6fb268b596e6fd83292b2661705b898c42a9132060ddccf7e53fd","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2138,"textSha256":"aa03e4acc0e0930149a0f69815ecf2ae9db20b8534b639d267cbb382599d1c9a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8742f9646b15b15710f3e6dd7f068282","paperId":"hep-ph/9203206","sourceSha256":"ccad71b59563fd0eb5535fbda733efe530193461d62cd12170262d17f41e7a14","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ccffc0e8064008804ff/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f6f227bab6f6fb268b596e6fd83292b2661705b898c42a9132060ddccf7e53fd","pdfPage":1,"start":109,"end":1516,"textSha256":"192584072ac9c4955989baf74849f937ddaa550e214162c420fdf4c61d8ab12a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:84da377adcc27ff1f90d6373","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The 1992 comparison treats Planck breaking conditionally and includes other strong-CP solutions; its operator threshold and theta bound are dated, not universal Independent challenge qualification: The 1992 comparison includes other strong-CP solutions and conditional wormhole effects; its operator threshold and theta bound are dated and assumption-"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:84da377adcc27ff1f90d6373","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d6d2e3fd884cff4e3e7eb2ed4ff4184cd4eda8eca0f818108f3b8eaefdc4f4ee","q025-candidate-question:b41fa11966510deaa70f3073"],"scopeContentSha256":"cf08b9ee14deaae1ca481b1dba7c1ceb4969310f10d107ad7bbb87d61b7c9da5","contributionContentSha256":"3f082dece5d7374a52342ca293320663207cd48c9c4cd4ccd91c781207f7b3f0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d52","kind":"description","unitIndex":52,"unitId":"unit:d6d2e3fd884cff4e3e7eb2ed4ff4184cd4eda8eca0f818108f3b8eaefdc4f4ee","textSha256":"466e98bbb237d55c6581b04ed2bb0d8a7a635dc5e3a8fb155a56581892646ca8"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:846399f4b958b08077ef257b79b75546","paperId":"hep-ph/9203206","sourceSha256":"ccad71b59563fd0eb5535fbda733efe530193461d62cd12170262d17f41e7a14","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ccffc0e8064008804ff/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f6f227bab6f6fb268b596e6fd83292b2661705b898c42a9132060ddccf7e53fd","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1516,"textSha256":"60a0637454be1da2d6cc5ab1a546b6f14b79f410eb1710e4009841c8ad8677e3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e0ac777db33970948c5f3ebdf7edb06a","paperId":"hep-ph/9203206","sourceSha256":"ccad71b59563fd0eb5535fbda733efe530193461d62cd12170262d17f41e7a14","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ccffc0e8064008804ff/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f6f227bab6f6fb268b596e6fd83292b2661705b898c42a9132060ddccf7e53fd","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2138,"textSha256":"aa03e4acc0e0930149a0f69815ecf2ae9db20b8534b639d267cbb382599d1c9a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8742f9646b15b15710f3e6dd7f068282","paperId":"hep-ph/9203206","sourceSha256":"ccad71b59563fd0eb5535fbda733efe530193461d62cd12170262d17f41e7a14","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3ccffc0e8064008804ff/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f6f227bab6f6fb268b596e6fd83292b2661705b898c42a9132060ddccf7e53fd","pdfPage":1,"start":109,"end":1516,"textSha256":"192584072ac9c4955989baf74849f937ddaa550e214162c420fdf4c61d8ab12a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:84da377adcc27ff1f90d6373","recordId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The 1992 comparison treats Planck breaking conditionally and includes other strong-CP solutions; its operator threshold and theta bound are dated, not universal","challengeNote":"The 1992 comparison includes other strong-CP solutions and conditional wormhole effects; its operator threshold and theta bound are dated and assumption-","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"479d4409c9dda520b6ca99002bcf994696d69f041c1c153e5ef4a78041fabab4"},"organizational-access:e4389a9f5b31c72258883cd8":{"id":"organizational-access:e4389a9f5b31c72258883cd8","source":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","target":"q025-candidate-question:8f9a7ad7ba1d9bfaf451a595","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ec2c47e7ee84c6d123adca5b3d961b204b3261307a6c2bc5a4aaf3baae54201d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:cef6ef19d5338c5bfb7fa705"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8f9a7ad7ba1d9bfaf451a595","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"891760d85966934fe9c4122d6624497add80af2ada6063f1406188dd552b6737","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c1fd17afbba9f0626961415e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","home":{"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Specifically covers environmentally dressed charged-hole horizons at source-defined charge-to-mass thresholds and the authors' conditional WGC–WCCC interpretations.","qualification":"q4 directly covers environmental deformations, horizon existence at source-defined charge-to-mass thresholds and the attributed WGC–WCCC interpretation. The RN reference ratio, deformed extremality relation and particle criterion remain distinct. Neither a charged spectrum nor a dynamical censorship test is supplied or required to place this qualified question.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","paperId":"2508.01487","textSha256":"0fe7561fb15c4ef32d44fe1d9ab5bab835c29bf3c5247d8c6aa8ad93d3daba86"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0003:u29:q4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0003:u29:q4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec2c47e7ee84c6d123adca5b3d961b204b3261307a6c2bc5a4aaf3baae54201d","placementContentSha256":"643ef9ef38602396f188cc7cae2a52e7c457ff91b5bc404b46b2ba6ae4055aed","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0003:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0003:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","paperId":"2508.01487","textSha256":"0fe7561fb15c4ef32d44fe1d9ab5bab835c29bf3c5247d8c6aa8ad93d3daba86"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0003","unitRef":"u29"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8f9a7ad7ba1d9bfaf451a595","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","textSha256":"0fe7561fb15c4ef32d44fe1d9ab5bab835c29bf3c5247d8c6aa8ad93d3daba86"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af029defe36ef00c6fac0019ee4c7429","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2437,"textSha256":"73bf4a56b7dcbc3bd67f37591e166bc1da313f12fc5fa144a84a5d390e746dde","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1d88198c6582501de8c447c84e4cdc56","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":2,"start":2496,"end":5891,"textSha256":"9569f3b4337df96d2ff86a7f3015a39a170777acb8435607459ab1bf57d4cfda","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6a3654c29dc852744440eb28","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Static horizon regions and conjecture compatibility are separate claims; no particle spectrum or dynamical censorship test is supplied. Independent challenge qualification: Static horizon existence and the authors' WGC/WCCC interpretation are separate claims. No particle-spectrum or dynamical-censorship test is established by these"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6a3654c29dc852744440eb28","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","q025-candidate-question:8f9a7ad7ba1d9bfaf451a595"],"scopeContentSha256":"891760d85966934fe9c4122d6624497add80af2ada6063f1406188dd552b6737","contributionContentSha256":"ef436b57f831624e6e168a53809a18f7fade24881b627779c296531dee1298aa","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-proposal","leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","textSha256":"0fe7561fb15c4ef32d44fe1d9ab5bab835c29bf3c5247d8c6aa8ad93d3daba86"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af029defe36ef00c6fac0019ee4c7429","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2437,"textSha256":"73bf4a56b7dcbc3bd67f37591e166bc1da313f12fc5fa144a84a5d390e746dde","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1d88198c6582501de8c447c84e4cdc56","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":2,"start":2496,"end":5891,"textSha256":"9569f3b4337df96d2ff86a7f3015a39a170777acb8435607459ab1bf57d4cfda","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6a3654c29dc852744440eb28","recordId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-592a646d39d467ff61ab-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Static horizon regions and conjecture compatibility are separate claims; no particle spectrum or dynamical censorship test is supplied.","challengeNote":"Static horizon existence and the authors' WGC/WCCC interpretation are separate claims. No particle-spectrum or dynamical-censorship test is established by these","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"c9db90306c8bc40fc32390a64f1b9a407f8199841f8ecd434aaf18f651ce0aa9"},"organizational-access:428690a0c6e8545f4838d5c1":{"id":"organizational-access:428690a0c6e8545f4838d5c1","source":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","target":"q025-candidate-question:bc0e38e8d6299c3104eddde6","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ec2c47e7ee84c6d123adca5b3d961b204b3261307a6c2bc5a4aaf3baae54201d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:cef6ef19d5338c5bfb7fa705"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:bc0e38e8d6299c3104eddde6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"2074360f67455b8be335df69457934394bea188d96f8b4e1b163fd96b8567ba5","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:03cdff5e03436885792ea554"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","home":{"unitId":"unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","paperId":"2303.02487","textSha256":"08962bc8c1f3b3b197184e03a5342b7328439372057c3d7eabc5ef395004d69b"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0c63c6518043ef6850b030c5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0c63c6518043ef6850b030c5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec2c47e7ee84c6d123adca5b3d961b204b3261307a6c2bc5a4aaf3baae54201d","placementContentSha256":"451cb947db34d8e0b0e31d167384d80ae13b6b396253bdbe54ff70c17b855451","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","paperId":"2303.02487","textSha256":"08962bc8c1f3b3b197184e03a5342b7328439372057c3d7eabc5ef395004d69b"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0c63c6518043ef6850b030c5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:bc0e38e8d6299c3104eddde6","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d90","kind":"description","unitIndex":90,"unitId":"unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","textSha256":"08962bc8c1f3b3b197184e03a5342b7328439372057c3d7eabc5ef395004d69b"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8d9947dcbc84f9cb8e22633d39ed7a35","paperId":"2303.02487","sourceSha256":"e8231034df6804d4deb0f709d8f57dc54394dbcaa4e6e52daf708da564f25b8e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62a7825d84c2e8252388/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"da7b3a24b82b43c9126390609109958223d4bc96f7fd89cb7851833e8d79e83d","pdfPage":3,"start":1298,"end":3088,"textSha256":"c5cf49fa874212f9c7fc31f2491fe69294cbde24a5e122bc2f184119f632c971","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a5d0c3e81400dfe4fc1c6d279be6a01f","paperId":"2303.02487","sourceSha256":"e8231034df6804d4deb0f709d8f57dc54394dbcaa4e6e52daf708da564f25b8e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62a7825d84c2e8252388/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"da7b3a24b82b43c9126390609109958223d4bc96f7fd89cb7851833e8d79e83d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1908,"textSha256":"a076074c2d7cc43453c1c36d6043610adf15a28bac0737b3d72f2d4535617fac","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e537a6c971766d3a4c9c60252bc13e8f","paperId":"2303.02487","sourceSha256":"e8231034df6804d4deb0f709d8f57dc54394dbcaa4e6e52daf708da564f25b8e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62a7825d84c2e8252388/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"da7b3a24b82b43c9126390609109958223d4bc96f7fd89cb7851833e8d79e83d","pdfPage":1,"start":104,"end":1908,"textSha256":"841bf7221c9faa808b9fb5ecb89cb58888f1dd38b230feaec35a744d8bda0eb4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0172fabbae3770b02dabada1","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: March 2023 v1 critical-point RPS test with variable G and central charge; distinct from rotating extremal KNKL and from a dynamical censorship theorem. Independent challenge qualification: March 2023 v1 RPS critical-point test with variable G and central charge; neither extremality nor dynamical censorship follows from this setup."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0172fabbae3770b02dabada1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","q025-candidate-question:bc0e38e8d6299c3104eddde6"],"scopeContentSha256":"2074360f67455b8be335df69457934394bea188d96f8b4e1b163fd96b8567ba5","contributionContentSha256":"dca5f98c9e6dd554c987d1144810c2cd76d1bab48de197c0df210956ecaf6af0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d90","kind":"description","unitIndex":90,"unitId":"unit:533b87e308dfdcfc3a347bf4efed71607bebe1c1b14e945d4c4bf5b27190c9fc","textSha256":"08962bc8c1f3b3b197184e03a5342b7328439372057c3d7eabc5ef395004d69b"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8d9947dcbc84f9cb8e22633d39ed7a35","paperId":"2303.02487","sourceSha256":"e8231034df6804d4deb0f709d8f57dc54394dbcaa4e6e52daf708da564f25b8e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62a7825d84c2e8252388/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"da7b3a24b82b43c9126390609109958223d4bc96f7fd89cb7851833e8d79e83d","pdfPage":3,"start":1298,"end":3088,"textSha256":"c5cf49fa874212f9c7fc31f2491fe69294cbde24a5e122bc2f184119f632c971","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a5d0c3e81400dfe4fc1c6d279be6a01f","paperId":"2303.02487","sourceSha256":"e8231034df6804d4deb0f709d8f57dc54394dbcaa4e6e52daf708da564f25b8e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62a7825d84c2e8252388/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"da7b3a24b82b43c9126390609109958223d4bc96f7fd89cb7851833e8d79e83d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1908,"textSha256":"a076074c2d7cc43453c1c36d6043610adf15a28bac0737b3d72f2d4535617fac","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e537a6c971766d3a4c9c60252bc13e8f","paperId":"2303.02487","sourceSha256":"e8231034df6804d4deb0f709d8f57dc54394dbcaa4e6e52daf708da564f25b8e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62a7825d84c2e8252388/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"da7b3a24b82b43c9126390609109958223d4bc96f7fd89cb7851833e8d79e83d","pdfPage":1,"start":104,"end":1908,"textSha256":"841bf7221c9faa808b9fb5ecb89cb58888f1dd38b230feaec35a744d8bda0eb4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0172fabbae3770b02dabada1","recordId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"March 2023 v1 critical-point RPS test with variable G and central charge; distinct from rotating extremal KNKL and from a dynamical censorship theorem.","challengeNote":"March 2023 v1 RPS critical-point test with variable G and central charge; neither extremality nor dynamical censorship follows from this setup.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","home":{"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Specifically covers environmentally dressed charged-hole horizons at source-defined charge-to-mass thresholds and the authors' conditional WGC–WCCC interpretations.","qualification":"q4 directly covers environmental deformations, horizon existence at source-defined charge-to-mass thresholds and the attributed WGC–WCCC interpretation. The RN reference ratio, deformed extremality relation and particle criterion remain distinct. Neither a charged spectrum nor a dynamical censorship test is supplied or required to place this qualified question.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","paperId":"2508.01487","textSha256":"0fe7561fb15c4ef32d44fe1d9ab5bab835c29bf3c5247d8c6aa8ad93d3daba86"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0003:u29:q4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0003:u29:q4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec2c47e7ee84c6d123adca5b3d961b204b3261307a6c2bc5a4aaf3baae54201d","placementContentSha256":"643ef9ef38602396f188cc7cae2a52e7c457ff91b5bc404b46b2ba6ae4055aed","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0003:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0003:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","paperId":"2508.01487","textSha256":"0fe7561fb15c4ef32d44fe1d9ab5bab835c29bf3c5247d8c6aa8ad93d3daba86"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0003","unitRef":"u29"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:bc0e38e8d6299c3104eddde6","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d72","kind":"description","unitIndex":72,"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","textSha256":"0fe7561fb15c4ef32d44fe1d9ab5bab835c29bf3c5247d8c6aa8ad93d3daba86"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:056f03f61a118320a256cbd4666feeb2","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2437,"textSha256":"f104d9b8804048972bcc6fbc39c5f4533de6425c49dfc7a2d30e494aa0ddf228","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1d88198c6582501de8c447c84e4cdc56","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":2,"start":2496,"end":5891,"textSha256":"9569f3b4337df96d2ff86a7f3015a39a170777acb8435607459ab1bf57d4cfda","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af029defe36ef00c6fac0019ee4c7429","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2437,"textSha256":"73bf4a56b7dcbc3bd67f37591e166bc1da313f12fc5fa144a84a5d390e746dde","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a37abf032eba471641155553","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Supplied August 2025 v2 gives a stationary parameter/horizon test and an author interpretation; it does not establish collapse censorship or a WGC spectrum. Independent challenge qualification: August 2025 v2 announces stationary parameter/horizon compatibility. This does not establish collapse censorship or the required charged-matter spectrum."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a37abf032eba471641155553","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","q025-candidate-question:bc0e38e8d6299c3104eddde6"],"scopeContentSha256":"2074360f67455b8be335df69457934394bea188d96f8b4e1b163fd96b8567ba5","contributionContentSha256":"083329afc4f3dbcfcd9356afb1294ee9fcd6a043c89e241c351d92dc4e07d549","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d72","kind":"description","unitIndex":72,"unitId":"unit:acdcf6d1c12cba96c6400a399405a6cb306c0afb0c23eabbab260936103d62c4","textSha256":"0fe7561fb15c4ef32d44fe1d9ab5bab835c29bf3c5247d8c6aa8ad93d3daba86"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:056f03f61a118320a256cbd4666feeb2","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2437,"textSha256":"f104d9b8804048972bcc6fbc39c5f4533de6425c49dfc7a2d30e494aa0ddf228","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1d88198c6582501de8c447c84e4cdc56","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":2,"start":2496,"end":5891,"textSha256":"9569f3b4337df96d2ff86a7f3015a39a170777acb8435607459ab1bf57d4cfda","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af029defe36ef00c6fac0019ee4c7429","paperId":"2508.01487","sourceSha256":"cdcbd2bda01efe91678816a274e072a87a66544ab37b682c7d25ffad6a82b94f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0a251ef0008da66b68a0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1e546777bb877621cd99aae3bf1b7a5246ffb5790eb9349a1cbec827ccdfc91e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2437,"textSha256":"73bf4a56b7dcbc3bd67f37591e166bc1da313f12fc5fa144a84a5d390e746dde","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a37abf032eba471641155553","recordId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Supplied August 2025 v2 gives a stationary parameter/horizon test and an author interpretation; it does not establish collapse censorship or a WGC spectrum.","challengeNote":"August 2025 v2 announces stationary parameter/horizon compatibility. This does not establish collapse censorship or the required charged-matter spectrum.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"b6dab417aff821ceeb392b8634329a757edf4c0400bc9705180d1563e795b3b0"},"organizational-access:74539ed6dfddf2bc6af416f0":{"id":"organizational-access:74539ed6dfddf2bc6af416f0","source":"q025-candidate-question:837292f1691498b40d709a2f","target":"q025-candidate-question:7fc5f55b18f12ec4bbab14ee","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:837292f1691498b40d709a2f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"896ceeb583fa5615576fb255cb7ece16ca479594cee2243502e9769417b58e66","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e13c972e34cf505cb8643b9e"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:7fc5f55b18f12ec4bbab14ee","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c3b9d609498caed1a2348a6ba544ccac3bad7e8155684df977f9a1abeff800f5","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:936ac6329ded7e6729d67ed7"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:6958d5f5106c01cc8c17e92fd5c72bc3e7452a5a538794cab6afb132e592f3bf","home":{"unitId":"unit:6958d5f5106c01cc8c17e92fd5c72bc3e7452a5a538794cab6afb132e592f3bf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:837292f1691498b40d709a2f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly includes combined higher-derivative and Reuter-flow studies, asymptotically free and interacting regimes, and infrared viability.","qualification":"q18 explicitly includes the combined-flow system, both ultraviolet alternatives and infrared viability. Seeking one flow description does not identify the regimes or establish that a connecting trajectory exists.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6958d5f5106c01cc8c17e92fd5c72bc3e7452a5a538794cab6afb132e592f3bf","paperId":"2111.04696","textSha256":"e6564bf2a0b73d6695e6a6804894936aeacfe691408da1d3d698ed6b781124b1"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0071:u6:q18"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0071:u6:q18","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6958d5f5106c01cc8c17e92fd5c72bc3e7452a5a538794cab6afb132e592f3bf","q025-candidate-question:837292f1691498b40d709a2f"],"scopeContentSha256":"896ceeb583fa5615576fb255cb7ece16ca479594cee2243502e9769417b58e66","placementContentSha256":"bb2dce70a4e5469b52204547ec444c3f35783b4be5be3bead664fc9e98a59978","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0071:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0071:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6958d5f5106c01cc8c17e92fd5c72bc3e7452a5a538794cab6afb132e592f3bf","paperId":"2111.04696","textSha256":"e6564bf2a0b73d6695e6a6804894936aeacfe691408da1d3d698ed6b781124b1"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0071","unitRef":"u6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:6958d5f5106c01cc8c17e92fd5c72bc3e7452a5a538794cab6afb132e592f3bf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7fc5f55b18f12ec4bbab14ee","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:6958d5f5106c01cc8c17e92fd5c72bc3e7452a5a538794cab6afb132e592f3bf","textSha256":"e6564bf2a0b73d6695e6a6804894936aeacfe691408da1d3d698ed6b781124b1"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:23e255bf09a380491fa74144"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:23e255bf09a380491fa74144","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6958d5f5106c01cc8c17e92fd5c72bc3e7452a5a538794cab6afb132e592f3bf","q025-candidate-question:7fc5f55b18f12ec4bbab14ee"],"scopeContentSha256":"c3b9d609498caed1a2348a6ba544ccac3bad7e8155684df977f9a1abeff800f5","contributionContentSha256":"8210486a331ad5201d14ab57ad06e045bec2908f7923904f28f31393cd206636","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b2ca79d3d5eb80e10584-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b2ca79d3d5eb80e10584-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b2ca79d3d5eb80e10584-proposal","leaf-b2ca79d3d5eb80e10584-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:6958d5f5106c01cc8c17e92fd5c72bc3e7452a5a538794cab6afb132e592f3bf","textSha256":"e6564bf2a0b73d6695e6a6804894936aeacfe691408da1d3d698ed6b781124b1"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:23e255bf09a380491fa74144","recordId":"leaf-b2ca79d3d5eb80e10584-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b2ca79d3d5eb80e10584-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b2ca79d3d5eb80e10584-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Asymptotically free and Reuter regimes are alternatives to connect, not an identified fixed point.","challengeNote":"The question seeks a flow connecting distinct asymptotically free and Reuter regimes.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"5d75fb6bcd6e22f3895dc42100b3378487d0f72267313d14983c4284a8c845a2"},"organizational-access:103a982f3f7cb62754c0972e":{"id":"organizational-access:103a982f3f7cb62754c0972e","source":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f","target":"q025-candidate-question:fd5211b683511ff4d6b93478","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"0c8927e5fc77028278e864261d5b309e1bf96114a7ea8c96e0c7a28e10675dba","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b755286c7ce716fa638781d0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:fd5211b683511ff4d6b93478","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"5635486953f466035403ccdb2aa1f7b97d953454b1ed40fe0d0cd4f1778e69ed","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8711bcbfc5952f26395fc4da"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","home":{"unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q11 explicitly combines physical Coulomb-branch positivity and boundary consistency with global gauge forms and required BPS excitations of six-dimensional parents.","qualification":"q11 explicitly covers the dimensional relation, positivity and boundary method, global gauge forms and required BPS excitations. The physical Kähler cone, restricted T=0 examples, limited announced exclusions and full-theory gauging exception remain qualifications. Neither a universal exclusion nor a supplied full proof is inferred.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","paperId":"2406.06704","textSha256":"15b1e590735c3a6ff49a6fa300d6d3ee2db98046685164dddc1c35ae68071cb0"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0011:u22:q11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0011:u22:q11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","q025-candidate-question:938a191b0bc66f746e68557f"],"scopeContentSha256":"0c8927e5fc77028278e864261d5b309e1bf96114a7ea8c96e0c7a28e10675dba","placementContentSha256":"95592f7ee494230f77e55a3a2f7df6f5472f64596c072c43e861e9cd30d79700","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0011:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0011:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","paperId":"2406.06704","textSha256":"15b1e590735c3a6ff49a6fa300d6d3ee2db98046685164dddc1c35ae68071cb0"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0011","unitRef":"u22"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:fd5211b683511ff4d6b93478","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d90","kind":"description","unitIndex":90,"unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","textSha256":"15b1e590735c3a6ff49a6fa300d6d3ee2db98046685164dddc1c35ae68071cb0"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2e2911efe2aa99dcf542ce53e4bfd71f","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":3331,"textSha256":"fe044a98fc79e764f1bfa2167d527ed55a9a71e5e488bd702c4f344772525a9d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e43e2b5a5b2a5d6d8d417cac80b63f76","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b82113e5d0345d1188abd0a95be0e94f6ed91617ba29db732d6d60269f435d49","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:26a859fad66f8b2411f30afe"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:26a859fad66f8b2411f30afe","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","q025-candidate-question:fd5211b683511ff4d6b93478"],"scopeContentSha256":"5635486953f466035403ccdb2aa1f7b97d953454b1ed40fe0d0cd4f1778e69ed","contributionContentSha256":"f51a8461c2c8140ff7f40a27d41f6cdfb13986619eee2a3b33d91fa12aad04ff","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-proposal","leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d90","kind":"description","unitIndex":90,"unitId":"unit:1e6af88c18e85a54c7132d73ddf4fcb742124276be92ee18293844c6b1f727e6","textSha256":"15b1e590735c3a6ff49a6fa300d6d3ee2db98046685164dddc1c35ae68071cb0"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2e2911efe2aa99dcf542ce53e4bfd71f","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":3331,"textSha256":"fe044a98fc79e764f1bfa2167d527ed55a9a71e5e488bd702c4f344772525a9d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e43e2b5a5b2a5d6d8d417cac80b63f76","paperId":"2406.06704","sourceSha256":"cb88cafffe11d83aa2f47a1289beae3ca719d1553f7eef811126ab94b5b67a19","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0f65ccc8cbddf4aa3f47/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8d7754390c08c53038638ba895e8c0e2b426b0f316a36d34d33cbf9564a77696","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b82113e5d0345d1188abd0a95be0e94f6ed91617ba29db732d6d60269f435d49","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:26a859fad66f8b2411f30afe","recordId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Scientifically fits despite outside-probe provenance. The excerpt announces T=0 applications and limited exclusions, not a complete landscape criterion.","challengeNote":"Scientific fit is independent of outside-probe provenance. Positivity requires the physical cone; the introduction announces T=0 applications and limited exclus","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"172a1245cff9b047f120a2499d132842348bf5bfff75108653295d8364cd98e3"},"organizational-access:309a18003360cdb052b5c8d2":{"id":"organizational-access:309a18003360cdb052b5c8d2","source":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","target":"q025-candidate-question:88437dc28af65e7d1a03e4c5","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ccd5e77a867e82ef7825199cd2d2c893840dc9ae3a8e87e1462a81ac1aa99d41","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:statistics:pq0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:88437dc28af65e7d1a03e4c5","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"bbda7c487afaea151eacff86cff6b09ce4a7991c8489842ec911bade9b8099fa","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c165bcf5437752a0f5b071f2"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1eab3b69f4159ab3840871737d90601288732b8d446fbf413187a86b2c82144a","home":{"unitId":"unit:1eab3b69f4159ab3840871737d90601288732b8d446fbf413187a86b2c82144a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q19 covers the validity of proposed finite candidates at fixed quantized data, including source identification, boundary-condition control and whether an apparent deformation is physically admissible.","qualification":"The flat-direction target concerns whether proposed deformations remain admissible at fixed discrete and source data. q19 covers this finite-candidate validity test together with singular-boundary and source-identification limitations; no unbounded scaling or accepted modulus is assumed.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1eab3b69f4159ab3840871737d90601288732b8d446fbf413187a86b2c82144a","paperId":"1902.04084","textSha256":"caf4899e9a48d415687ae95fb3831766373acd58204046fad16404df7c437d5b"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u8:q19"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u8:q19","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1eab3b69f4159ab3840871737d90601288732b8d446fbf413187a86b2c82144a","q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02"],"scopeContentSha256":"ccd5e77a867e82ef7825199cd2d2c893840dc9ae3a8e87e1462a81ac1aa99d41","placementContentSha256":"9d10b5a861e9ae52e9728e2aeafbe64697e0e78a2606df662f52a7aea749e1de","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1eab3b69f4159ab3840871737d90601288732b8d446fbf413187a86b2c82144a","paperId":"1902.04084","textSha256":"caf4899e9a48d415687ae95fb3831766373acd58204046fad16404df7c437d5b"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0031","unitRef":"u8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1eab3b69f4159ab3840871737d90601288732b8d446fbf413187a86b2c82144a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:88437dc28af65e7d1a03e4c5","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:1eab3b69f4159ab3840871737d90601288732b8d446fbf413187a86b2c82144a","textSha256":"caf4899e9a48d415687ae95fb3831766373acd58204046fad16404df7c437d5b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4894e949bb319ea60e48d64f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4894e949bb319ea60e48d64f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1eab3b69f4159ab3840871737d90601288732b8d446fbf413187a86b2c82144a","q025-candidate-question:88437dc28af65e7d1a03e4c5"],"scopeContentSha256":"bbda7c487afaea151eacff86cff6b09ce4a7991c8489842ec911bade9b8099fa","contributionContentSha256":"855e00e66e5578ffea955e4e574c64003dcb1099ca754efd9ac16349c2f6a4b7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-proposal","leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:1eab3b69f4159ab3840871737d90601288732b8d446fbf413187a86b2c82144a","textSha256":"caf4899e9a48d415687ae95fb3831766373acd58204046fad16404df7c437d5b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4894e949bb319ea60e48d64f","recordId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The earlier scan's apparent flat direction is historical evidence to check, not an accepted modulus or scaling freedom.","challengeNote":"The earlier numerical flat direction remains historical context under test; neither survival nor rejection is established here.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"8c0121364d6e8997b410067c2e82c9481017076a563330d9675c1097a142926d"},"organizational-access:b1348a45d833aa2a6ca0824d":{"id":"organizational-access:b1348a45d833aa2a6ca0824d","source":"q025-candidate-question:9e41a3868dcdcfebf87974e3","target":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9e41a3868dcdcfebf87974e3","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"076583202ef684ad98efa9949aca93770015dec3004e82ade5a5997ddfe6c6a9","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:fc1a6f8d7f5c0ae1b6605ee0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9e6c184caeeca1fe514b806a44ec65f74bf314448503e5b9dead2e99a6f758bf","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:498d2ccc89fa873c91e4b585"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:e8c0a0bffd5b08931037fafc4f60b51a9c3f1973750a35405bcdcded2eaab51b","home":{"unitId":"unit:e8c0a0bffd5b08931037fafc4f60b51a9c3f1973750a35405bcdcded2eaab51b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9e41a3868dcdcfebf87974e3","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers alternative mechanisms for a large effective inflationary scale from a small microscopic decay constant, including their different scale interpretations.","qualification":"The shared target is an effective inflationary scale above M_Pl despite an assumed microscopic bound. q7 covers mechanisms that reorganize that scale and their inflationary application, including alternatives with different physical interpretations. Neither DBI dynamics nor harmonic cancellation is silently identified with enlarged periodicity, and the microscopic bound is not established by placement.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e8c0a0bffd5b08931037fafc4f60b51a9c3f1973750a35405bcdcded2eaab51b","paperId":"1906.02764","textSha256":"051295f4ca4bda071f9f0e961fc60be36a00038146e5695acebdac16d09cbb2b"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0056:u14:q7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0056:u14:q7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e8c0a0bffd5b08931037fafc4f60b51a9c3f1973750a35405bcdcded2eaab51b","q025-candidate-question:9e41a3868dcdcfebf87974e3"],"scopeContentSha256":"076583202ef684ad98efa9949aca93770015dec3004e82ade5a5997ddfe6c6a9","placementContentSha256":"651a80c2325763282acf06c79967b19e1ff6b20a2329b2fa6e251a2d3e987bcc","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0056:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0056:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e8c0a0bffd5b08931037fafc4f60b51a9c3f1973750a35405bcdcded2eaab51b","paperId":"1906.02764","textSha256":"051295f4ca4bda071f9f0e961fc60be36a00038146e5695acebdac16d09cbb2b"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0056","unitRef":"u14"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e8c0a0bffd5b08931037fafc4f60b51a9c3f1973750a35405bcdcded2eaab51b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d50","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:e8c0a0bffd5b08931037fafc4f60b51a9c3f1973750a35405bcdcded2eaab51b","textSha256":"051295f4ca4bda071f9f0e961fc60be36a00038146e5695acebdac16d09cbb2b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:94863e89116bc6cd43da691c","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Harmonic cancellation and DBI dynamics are alternative mechanisms requiring fine reconciliation; f<M_Pl is assumed, not established. Independent challenge qualification: Harmonic cancellation and DBI are alternative mechanisms awaiting fine reconciliation; the microscopic bound is assumed."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:94863e89116bc6cd43da691c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e8c0a0bffd5b08931037fafc4f60b51a9c3f1973750a35405bcdcded2eaab51b","q025-candidate-question:c36f4ff11a803526b660a70a"],"scopeContentSha256":"9e6c184caeeca1fe514b806a44ec65f74bf314448503e5b9dead2e99a6f758bf","contributionContentSha256":"66f65e33cd5037b83063def65c492bf4d2a53ac88c37a5842e96dfb8571aa9cb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d50","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:e8c0a0bffd5b08931037fafc4f60b51a9c3f1973750a35405bcdcded2eaab51b","textSha256":"051295f4ca4bda071f9f0e961fc60be36a00038146e5695acebdac16d09cbb2b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:94863e89116bc6cd43da691c","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Harmonic cancellation and DBI dynamics are alternative mechanisms requiring fine reconciliation; f<M_Pl is assumed, not established.","challengeNote":"Harmonic cancellation and DBI are alternative mechanisms awaiting fine reconciliation; the microscopic bound is assumed.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"2eb434aa6b3442ccaed39369752a3b554a919b62efa4d45ed5f523cfe02215e9"},"organizational-access:90462f3e553ca60bc441cbfe":{"id":"organizational-access:90462f3e553ca60bc441cbfe","source":"q025-candidate-question:c21e45ba9f13fdb3763ec1d2","target":"q025-candidate-question:eb102181167fb9491c1f2cce","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c21e45ba9f13fdb3763ec1d2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"333bc8f781ae7c2b61118543307914a58af1f2b55cab939d7e7e334793e1ec7f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:408bb7f949a5d05def21183a"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:eb102181167fb9491c1f2cce","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"433ef893452af39da21ca93efd27e3fd57251a486213a2a5a07d0728a7f8876f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:9fd3ce4af5df1a5442548f03"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:8ae0040e64ff1d810ee4ded700b1d8529b67b174be34f237a10cda125bb221cd","home":{"unitId":"unit:8ae0040e64ff1d810ee4ded700b1d8529b67b174be34f237a10cda125bb221cd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c21e45ba9f13fdb3763ec1d2","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines pedagogical de Sitter geometry, free scalar QFT, horizon descriptions and asymptotic symmetry/boundary analysis.","qualification":"q56 covers both the pedagogical geometry, free-scalar and horizon material and the conformal asymptotic-symmetry/falloff analysis. q40 and q20 cover quantum-description prerequisites without equally complete coverage of the independently stated field-theory review; q64 covers that review without the whole asymptotic construction. q56 permits one intact composite source without identifying fixed-background QFT with a completed quantum-gravity theory or updating the historical embedding claims.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8ae0040e64ff1d810ee4ded700b1d8529b67b174be34f237a10cda125bb221cd","textSha256":"b30ab9d27408621306c467cd7379f4c1343bd385379fc2a7daa38ddd62a03666"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:competing:u20:q56"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:competing:u20:q56","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8ae0040e64ff1d810ee4ded700b1d8529b67b174be34f237a10cda125bb221cd","q025-candidate-question:c21e45ba9f13fdb3763ec1d2"],"scopeContentSha256":"333bc8f781ae7c2b61118543307914a58af1f2b55cab939d7e7e334793e1ec7f","placementContentSha256":"58eb6db4c399d0d33b4db577433ffa21e46beac5216fc453875332c26408dd4c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:competing:proposal","placement-pilot:competing:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8ae0040e64ff1d810ee4ded700b1d8529b67b174be34f237a10cda125bb221cd","textSha256":"b30ab9d27408621306c467cd7379f4c1343bd385379fc2a7daa38ddd62a03666"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:8ae0040e64ff1d810ee4ded700b1d8529b67b174be34f237a10cda125bb221cd"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8ae0040e64ff1d810ee4ded700b1d8529b67b174be34f237a10cda125bb221cd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:eb102181167fb9491c1f2cce","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:8ae0040e64ff1d810ee4ded700b1d8529b67b174be34f237a10cda125bb221cd","textSha256":"b30ab9d27408621306c467cd7379f4c1343bd385379fc2a7daa38ddd62a03666"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8d678a766d1385a338b4ef1e805067c7","paperId":"hep-th/0110007","sourceSha256":"06c45017ba6e2af85958b6b596a657bed933ae43948230faf8d18852864082aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/db855901401810e91228/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81b8b8ffaaaad7df35cef5877e7ea442503cc1ea847dd693602948a47cb74231","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":1478,"textSha256":"d49da500758b46cb9b72b2fcdd33c678a91fa0f00f1a2b280c7cc2b5502ae8c0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cf3399dbb49e9837498a25e7824ff9cf","paperId":"hep-th/0110007","sourceSha256":"06c45017ba6e2af85958b6b596a657bed933ae43948230faf8d18852864082aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/db855901401810e91228/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81b8b8ffaaaad7df35cef5877e7ea442503cc1ea847dd693602948a47cb74231","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1118,"textSha256":"7845462256d8ad20cfbde2c41b142c12c4b891a3ee669b3664f32f6b690a8acf","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f3524dc37bd5ea2411d7cab0cf8b5cca","paperId":"hep-th/0110007","sourceSha256":"06c45017ba6e2af85958b6b596a657bed933ae43948230faf8d18852864082aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/db855901401810e91228/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81b8b8ffaaaad7df35cef5877e7ea442503cc1ea847dd693602948a47cb74231","pdfPage":3,"start":1288,"end":3378,"textSha256":"21923440cfce40fe0200fc4d61f1434f48c39c5cb0a046262e4639cc9ef7de92","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9722e840e3b9be0c3ab5afed","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: v2 27 November 2001, from August lectures. Compound pedagogical geometry/QFT/horizon scope and asymptotic dS/CFT analysis are preserved. Independent challenge qualification: v2 27 November 2001, from August lectures: compound geometry, scalar QFT, horizon thermodynamics and asymptotic dS/CFT analysis. Dated embedding remarks do not establish present-day exclusion criteria."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9722e840e3b9be0c3ab5afed","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8ae0040e64ff1d810ee4ded700b1d8529b67b174be34f237a10cda125bb221cd","q025-candidate-question:eb102181167fb9491c1f2cce"],"scopeContentSha256":"433ef893452af39da21ca93efd27e3fd57251a486213a2a5a07d0728a7f8876f","contributionContentSha256":"cfcd02c9e6faad1139df2451f708c3d1a5c068cad563a9fa32d585f7fb0f9cd3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:8ae0040e64ff1d810ee4ded700b1d8529b67b174be34f237a10cda125bb221cd","textSha256":"b30ab9d27408621306c467cd7379f4c1343bd385379fc2a7daa38ddd62a03666"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8d678a766d1385a338b4ef1e805067c7","paperId":"hep-th/0110007","sourceSha256":"06c45017ba6e2af85958b6b596a657bed933ae43948230faf8d18852864082aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/db855901401810e91228/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81b8b8ffaaaad7df35cef5877e7ea442503cc1ea847dd693602948a47cb74231","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":1478,"textSha256":"d49da500758b46cb9b72b2fcdd33c678a91fa0f00f1a2b280c7cc2b5502ae8c0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cf3399dbb49e9837498a25e7824ff9cf","paperId":"hep-th/0110007","sourceSha256":"06c45017ba6e2af85958b6b596a657bed933ae43948230faf8d18852864082aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/db855901401810e91228/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81b8b8ffaaaad7df35cef5877e7ea442503cc1ea847dd693602948a47cb74231","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1118,"textSha256":"7845462256d8ad20cfbde2c41b142c12c4b891a3ee669b3664f32f6b690a8acf","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f3524dc37bd5ea2411d7cab0cf8b5cca","paperId":"hep-th/0110007","sourceSha256":"06c45017ba6e2af85958b6b596a657bed933ae43948230faf8d18852864082aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/db855901401810e91228/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"81b8b8ffaaaad7df35cef5877e7ea442503cc1ea847dd693602948a47cb74231","pdfPage":3,"start":1288,"end":3378,"textSha256":"21923440cfce40fe0200fc4d61f1434f48c39c5cb0a046262e4639cc9ef7de92","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9722e840e3b9be0c3ab5afed","recordId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"v2 27 November 2001, from August lectures. Compound pedagogical geometry/QFT/horizon scope and asymptotic dS/CFT analysis are preserved.","challengeNote":"v2 27 November 2001, from August lectures: compound geometry, scalar QFT, horizon thermodynamics and asymptotic dS/CFT analysis. Dated embedding remarks do not establish present-day exclusion criteria.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"b2be0a32cd13c00973261790f460278e1abda2cb0164b4cf443c1095bc7cfec5"},"organizational-access:a9534629a6a35579f455ee35":{"id":"organizational-access:a9534629a6a35579f455ee35","source":"q025-candidate-question:c5283438d7645c848e6300a4","target":"q025-candidate-question:8ed595b668e0ce28a313a22f","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c5283438d7645c848e6300a4","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a144d6b04e3dacdebbcb9b4e3ad22a5776aa23eac1c0be83cab8eb6bbe872afb","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3d1c5b816ab7b010c42a40fd"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8ed595b668e0ce28a313a22f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"4734e5b051ad02beb6c1a6bad1af755269139ada64f1c9cdda272a273f99f208","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:55c2fbcca5be5fa48290756e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:bf67eede250ac54e8a5b23051140b74d5a21127755334dc194740647ff605333","home":{"unitId":"unit:bf67eede250ac54e8a5b23051140b74d5a21127755334dc194740647ff605333","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c5283438d7645c848e6300a4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers sustained multifield turning, perturbative viability and conditional distance/de Sitter tests in alternative flat and negatively curved field spaces.","qualification":"q18 covers the sustained-turning mechanism, inflationary viability, adopted distance/refined-de-Sitter criteria and alternative field-space geometries. Local helix-region conditions and reported global orbital conditions remain different, with perturbative and source-era observational qualifications preserved.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bf67eede250ac54e8a5b23051140b74d5a21127755334dc194740647ff605333","paperId":"1905.07495","textSha256":"ac3f2b4a9da0ed32b300d993036df4906771b55eadca2ac3eee4d129ddb73a32"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0062:u21:q18"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0062:u21:q18","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bf67eede250ac54e8a5b23051140b74d5a21127755334dc194740647ff605333","q025-candidate-question:c5283438d7645c848e6300a4"],"scopeContentSha256":"a144d6b04e3dacdebbcb9b4e3ad22a5776aa23eac1c0be83cab8eb6bbe872afb","placementContentSha256":"fea0bb2514d1e1ffd403c76ded3fb4f9dc7ce29b10281716d9e4c06ef81460de","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0062:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0062:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bf67eede250ac54e8a5b23051140b74d5a21127755334dc194740647ff605333","paperId":"1905.07495","textSha256":"ac3f2b4a9da0ed32b300d993036df4906771b55eadca2ac3eee4d129ddb73a32"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0062","unitRef":"u21"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bf67eede250ac54e8a5b23051140b74d5a21127755334dc194740647ff605333","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8ed595b668e0ce28a313a22f","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:bf67eede250ac54e8a5b23051140b74d5a21127755334dc194740647ff605333","textSha256":"ac3f2b4a9da0ed32b300d993036df4906771b55eadca2ac3eee4d129ddb73a32"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1d1ed5feb5c952528fa2a8e52e13a2df","paperId":"1905.07495","sourceSha256":"558e887bdc12b6169ce9c67412a8e568ea898e9713d748e73a63af6910d368dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8a5c031f789cf4c57c2c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"115a9b923a6f77310828e48bbae930b88d6c7f326e1aae2bdafd414df4cb846f","pdfPage":3,"start":111,"end":3460,"textSha256":"413c971f6e7847eca2c65192a8d37d75e91a4f5fc7c530b57852fff252c98fa7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:baacc8a9aa1c45bffc4831a964560d2d","paperId":"1905.07495","sourceSha256":"558e887bdc12b6169ce9c67412a8e568ea898e9713d748e73a63af6910d368dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8a5c031f789cf4c57c2c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"115a9b923a6f77310828e48bbae930b88d6c7f326e1aae2bdafd414df4cb846f","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"6aab4fa6736133fdb4c84df5f7af62ccd2990c0c35bb59a2e2d76cf173a90c10","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fde70ebe34d231e5a8ba99359bce669b","paperId":"1905.07495","sourceSha256":"558e887bdc12b6169ce9c67412a8e568ea898e9713d748e73a63af6910d368dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8a5c031f789cf4c57c2c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"115a9b923a6f77310828e48bbae930b88d6c7f326e1aae2bdafd414df4cb846f","pdfPage":20,"start":1301,"end":3386,"textSha256":"8bf4ae401d88b5a24a408b92d3f5a1b49fa97bec22ae221c462f01b4830d3357","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:14539bb256b0106024d7aba1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:14539bb256b0106024d7aba1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bf67eede250ac54e8a5b23051140b74d5a21127755334dc194740647ff605333","q025-candidate-question:8ed595b668e0ce28a313a22f"],"scopeContentSha256":"4734e5b051ad02beb6c1a6bad1af755269139ada64f1c9cdda272a273f99f208","contributionContentSha256":"6b682d5cd8ff936db085045d5f086f9eca41be33e39e16368d6b135247833f37","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-15e4ee95696901bc525a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-15e4ee95696901bc525a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-15e4ee95696901bc525a-proposal","leaf-15e4ee95696901bc525a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:bf67eede250ac54e8a5b23051140b74d5a21127755334dc194740647ff605333","textSha256":"ac3f2b4a9da0ed32b300d993036df4906771b55eadca2ac3eee4d129ddb73a32"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1d1ed5feb5c952528fa2a8e52e13a2df","paperId":"1905.07495","sourceSha256":"558e887bdc12b6169ce9c67412a8e568ea898e9713d748e73a63af6910d368dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8a5c031f789cf4c57c2c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"115a9b923a6f77310828e48bbae930b88d6c7f326e1aae2bdafd414df4cb846f","pdfPage":3,"start":111,"end":3460,"textSha256":"413c971f6e7847eca2c65192a8d37d75e91a4f5fc7c530b57852fff252c98fa7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:baacc8a9aa1c45bffc4831a964560d2d","paperId":"1905.07495","sourceSha256":"558e887bdc12b6169ce9c67412a8e568ea898e9713d748e73a63af6910d368dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8a5c031f789cf4c57c2c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"115a9b923a6f77310828e48bbae930b88d6c7f326e1aae2bdafd414df4cb846f","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"6aab4fa6736133fdb4c84df5f7af62ccd2990c0c35bb59a2e2d76cf173a90c10","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fde70ebe34d231e5a8ba99359bce669b","paperId":"1905.07495","sourceSha256":"558e887bdc12b6169ce9c67412a8e568ea898e9713d748e73a63af6910d368dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8a5c031f789cf4c57c2c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"115a9b923a6f77310828e48bbae930b88d6c7f326e1aae2bdafd414df4cb846f","pdfPage":20,"start":1301,"end":3386,"textSha256":"8bf4ae401d88b5a24a408b92d3f5a1b49fa97bec22ae221c462f01b4830d3357","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:14539bb256b0106024d7aba1","recordId":"leaf-15e4ee95696901bc525a-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-15e4ee95696901bc525a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-15e4ee95696901bc525a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Two distinct bottom-up model families; local versus global criterion satisfaction and perturbative limits must remain separate.","challengeNote":"Two bottom-up families: helix criterion satisfaction is local; orbital satisfaction is reported globally. Perturbative restrictions and absent top-down origin","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"dbf39a17088326ed05bbffed0f209fb814de152cc2ef1b8b76c12deb453f9ece"},"organizational-access:a6ee824280d35057337f10f4":{"id":"organizational-access:a6ee824280d35057337f10f4","source":"q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202","target":"q025-candidate-question:94d01979496f4cc48fd01f07","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e37a245e6ae1d1aa265e99802e84ffa43da2d21fd7607d56ed797bf572150e15","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:271456e69b01eabb323fca56"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:94d01979496f4cc48fd01f07","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6ae0fdecac69ef3eea93000607006efe0d48316a195521ecbc4ef5c66a196e7c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ad9878442ed7836b1f6ea23b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:47f20c13555b6a24e036eb69dac9e33374893a5dd73e32257e2e2d23a39ca6c6","home":{"unitId":"unit:47f20c13555b6a24e036eb69dac9e33374893a5dd73e32257e2e2d23a39ca6c6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:47f20c13555b6a24e036eb69dac9e33374893a5dd73e32257e2e2d23a39ca6c6","paperId":"1610.01533","textSha256":"5eccd82bbb6ea2e7d6aa21f666038bbec56e93748392e5d8ad2324b7d0203003"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2d1256db35cf4b2320ecc85c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2d1256db35cf4b2320ecc85c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:47f20c13555b6a24e036eb69dac9e33374893a5dd73e32257e2e2d23a39ca6c6","q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202"],"scopeContentSha256":"e37a245e6ae1d1aa265e99802e84ffa43da2d21fd7607d56ed797bf572150e15","placementContentSha256":"582c63240c206dfb330f9a06940fae0a79978b31b879b86efd4619faa3f61f86","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:47f20c13555b6a24e036eb69dac9e33374893a5dd73e32257e2e2d23a39ca6c6","paperId":"1610.01533","textSha256":"5eccd82bbb6ea2e7d6aa21f666038bbec56e93748392e5d8ad2324b7d0203003"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2d1256db35cf4b2320ecc85c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:47f20c13555b6a24e036eb69dac9e33374893a5dd73e32257e2e2d23a39ca6c6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:94d01979496f4cc48fd01f07","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:47f20c13555b6a24e036eb69dac9e33374893a5dd73e32257e2e2d23a39ca6c6","textSha256":"5eccd82bbb6ea2e7d6aa21f666038bbec56e93748392e5d8ad2324b7d0203003"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a6fc4e3b0b0091067efd4a256eaf5bd0","paperId":"1610.01533","sourceSha256":"d657ea017b1fbd70ec35f800afe7d4a8fd828149b44e7289c09c403f9e6d0b48","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2d4156bc28c704bea044/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f0737b6458a5d1be5b4421bbbb5d749607e9de976aecb67c23c1663cad4ba4fa","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2715,"textSha256":"2cf56e7d9fd268b084e90a2c51573fce1417f9ce5aa2849373ac1c0434683284","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c38998db58c0dfc88712abe516506e86","paperId":"1610.01533","sourceSha256":"d657ea017b1fbd70ec35f800afe7d4a8fd828149b44e7289c09c403f9e6d0b48","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2d4156bc28c704bea044/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f0737b6458a5d1be5b4421bbbb5d749607e9de976aecb67c23c1663cad4ba4fa","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2662,"textSha256":"c795f6db711e9b51a16fa91d63e32fef0ee8e136a63e1deb533d4ea6970be6eb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cfd94c2f9767777780b62082ad325f3f","paperId":"1610.01533","sourceSha256":"d657ea017b1fbd70ec35f800afe7d4a8fd828149b44e7289c09c403f9e6d0b48","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2d4156bc28c704bea044/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f0737b6458a5d1be5b4421bbbb5d749607e9de976aecb67c23c1663cad4ba4fa","pdfPage":2,"start":147,"end":3147,"textSha256":"aad2b69d6cfb16e8984063a9365b25072a909554ff0f119eb9facf0f446865eb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b1571f41c8865c7b4089e495","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Suitable sub-Planckian particles/basic-charge multiples and a brane extension; BPS saturation is allowed. The sharpened non-BPS claim is separate context. Independent challenge qualification: Particle and brane extensions retain distinct thresholds. BPS saturation is allowed; the sharpened non-BPS conjecture remains separate context."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b1571f41c8865c7b4089e495","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:47f20c13555b6a24e036eb69dac9e33374893a5dd73e32257e2e2d23a39ca6c6","q025-candidate-question:94d01979496f4cc48fd01f07"],"scopeContentSha256":"6ae0fdecac69ef3eea93000607006efe0d48316a195521ecbc4ef5c66a196e7c","contributionContentSha256":"2165a21021e4dc28caa4c5adac0721f74d8a17d883f91b92b79bd1f0f947b25f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1b3b48ae03dbe168d677-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1b3b48ae03dbe168d677-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1b3b48ae03dbe168d677-proposal","leaf-1b3b48ae03dbe168d677-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:47f20c13555b6a24e036eb69dac9e33374893a5dd73e32257e2e2d23a39ca6c6","textSha256":"5eccd82bbb6ea2e7d6aa21f666038bbec56e93748392e5d8ad2324b7d0203003"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a6fc4e3b0b0091067efd4a256eaf5bd0","paperId":"1610.01533","sourceSha256":"d657ea017b1fbd70ec35f800afe7d4a8fd828149b44e7289c09c403f9e6d0b48","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2d4156bc28c704bea044/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f0737b6458a5d1be5b4421bbbb5d749607e9de976aecb67c23c1663cad4ba4fa","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2715,"textSha256":"2cf56e7d9fd268b084e90a2c51573fce1417f9ce5aa2849373ac1c0434683284","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c38998db58c0dfc88712abe516506e86","paperId":"1610.01533","sourceSha256":"d657ea017b1fbd70ec35f800afe7d4a8fd828149b44e7289c09c403f9e6d0b48","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2d4156bc28c704bea044/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f0737b6458a5d1be5b4421bbbb5d749607e9de976aecb67c23c1663cad4ba4fa","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2662,"textSha256":"c795f6db711e9b51a16fa91d63e32fef0ee8e136a63e1deb533d4ea6970be6eb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cfd94c2f9767777780b62082ad325f3f","paperId":"1610.01533","sourceSha256":"d657ea017b1fbd70ec35f800afe7d4a8fd828149b44e7289c09c403f9e6d0b48","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2d4156bc28c704bea044/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f0737b6458a5d1be5b4421bbbb5d749607e9de976aecb67c23c1663cad4ba4fa","pdfPage":2,"start":147,"end":3147,"textSha256":"aad2b69d6cfb16e8984063a9365b25072a909554ff0f119eb9facf0f446865eb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b1571f41c8865c7b4089e495","recordId":"leaf-1b3b48ae03dbe168d677-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1b3b48ae03dbe168d677-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1b3b48ae03dbe168d677-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Suitable sub-Planckian particles/basic-charge multiples and a brane extension; BPS saturation is allowed. The sharpened non-BPS claim is separate context.","challengeNote":"Particle and brane extensions retain distinct thresholds. BPS saturation is allowed; the sharpened non-BPS conjecture remains separate context.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"88cd596351098728bafb057f44e75c0964f84804b1cbd3255fc29f3974f89914"},"organizational-access:1f87f3b8a93d82538e50decf":{"id":"organizational-access:1f87f3b8a93d82538e50decf","source":"q025-candidate-question:d89b19e693da92fde80705be","target":"q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:d89b19e693da92fde80705be","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7b8f96518231bb1c245bc515b4e25069f29d25f99b85dfdf05ddbe7012bc046f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d916688370f2863181d9f1b8"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"d3b8c53549ec45f774bb3f9e66a788da3fdf56d4f913afe3f315a51a5e581386","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:15f500c3aa50203c8e876dbd"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:97d207ccb7abcaec58303686799da7db5888dec4ddfec5574a73226a0e0d27ef","home":{"unitId":"unit:97d207ccb7abcaec58303686799da7db5888dec4ddfec5574a73226a0e0d27ef","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d89b19e693da92fde80705be","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines selected compactification perturbative tests with gravitational restrictions on bubble transitions.","qualification":"q19 explicitly joins selected perturbative compactification tests with bubble formation and gravitational restrictions. Blow-up-mode stability and admissibility of lower-energy transitions remain separate, and excluded channels establish no absolute stability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:97d207ccb7abcaec58303686799da7db5888dec4ddfec5574a73226a0e0d27ef","paperId":"1002.4498","textSha256":"5b19ec1c8a176c87eda27a3c62d43df30ed7e468c96bd01b9fce2050f1a73849"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0051:u25:q19"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0051:u25:q19","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:97d207ccb7abcaec58303686799da7db5888dec4ddfec5574a73226a0e0d27ef","q025-candidate-question:d89b19e693da92fde80705be"],"scopeContentSha256":"7b8f96518231bb1c245bc515b4e25069f29d25f99b85dfdf05ddbe7012bc046f","placementContentSha256":"87f92a119a5d1ac0e8fa05d132dba65d69e6b1a1d0f80ef79ee104a729aef71e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0051:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0051:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:97d207ccb7abcaec58303686799da7db5888dec4ddfec5574a73226a0e0d27ef","paperId":"1002.4498","textSha256":"5b19ec1c8a176c87eda27a3c62d43df30ed7e468c96bd01b9fce2050f1a73849"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0051","unitRef":"u25"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:97d207ccb7abcaec58303686799da7db5888dec4ddfec5574a73226a0e0d27ef","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:97d207ccb7abcaec58303686799da7db5888dec4ddfec5574a73226a0e0d27ef","textSha256":"5b19ec1c8a176c87eda27a3c62d43df30ed7e468c96bd01b9fce2050f1a73849"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2585d31de376f6faae9dedbb"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2585d31de376f6faae9dedbb","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:97d207ccb7abcaec58303686799da7db5888dec4ddfec5574a73226a0e0d27ef","q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0"],"scopeContentSha256":"d3b8c53549ec45f774bb3f9e66a788da3fdf56d4f913afe3f315a51a5e581386","contributionContentSha256":"8ea68a3681d019df7194273e9c8b1bbe939a3cc4c7131b244c134a99b1083b4f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:97d207ccb7abcaec58303686799da7db5888dec4ddfec5574a73226a0e0d27ef","textSha256":"5b19ec1c8a176c87eda27a3c62d43df30ed7e468c96bd01b9fce2050f1a73849"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2585d31de376f6faae9dedbb","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound blow-up-mode and gravitational bubble-nucleation tests.","challengeNote":"Compound blow-up-mode and gravitational bubble-nucleation tests.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9b1251add165f9ec1cb5526162e89f93ce9ebb6bb320383542d9094818b7ff94","home":{"unitId":"unit:9b1251add165f9ec1cb5526162e89f93ce9ebb6bb320383542d9094818b7ff94","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d89b19e693da92fde80705be","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Its selected compactification stability scope includes perturbative tests and brane-nucleation mechanisms under source-specific parameters.","qualification":"q19's admitted targets expressly include selected perturbative and nonperturbative compactification tests and nucleation mechanisms. Its system definition is not restricted to the separate massive-IIA example. Both magnetic fluxes remain independent parameters of this heterotic question.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9b1251add165f9ec1cb5526162e89f93ce9ebb6bb320383542d9094818b7ff94","paperId":"2604.18692","textSha256":"4200e1fda05d7e18c95e107ce6e2ccd6afe2d75b0fa9d8608b660e75b36aa016"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0051:u28:q19"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0051:u28:q19","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9b1251add165f9ec1cb5526162e89f93ce9ebb6bb320383542d9094818b7ff94","q025-candidate-question:d89b19e693da92fde80705be"],"scopeContentSha256":"7b8f96518231bb1c245bc515b4e25069f29d25f99b85dfdf05ddbe7012bc046f","placementContentSha256":"9fca52453bf6ad68fc0167336b4a3bb391ad410c1a191ebbbed1bd39be2917f0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0051:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0051:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9b1251add165f9ec1cb5526162e89f93ce9ebb6bb320383542d9094818b7ff94","paperId":"2604.18692","textSha256":"4200e1fda05d7e18c95e107ce6e2ccd6afe2d75b0fa9d8608b660e75b36aa016"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0051","unitRef":"u28"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9b1251add165f9ec1cb5526162e89f93ce9ebb6bb320383542d9094818b7ff94","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d67","kind":"description","unitIndex":67,"unitId":"unit:9b1251add165f9ec1cb5526162e89f93ce9ebb6bb320383542d9094818b7ff94","textSha256":"4200e1fda05d7e18c95e107ce6e2ccd6afe2d75b0fa9d8608b660e75b36aa016"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d248d252c86439360b6a7b76"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d248d252c86439360b6a7b76","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9b1251add165f9ec1cb5526162e89f93ce9ebb6bb320383542d9094818b7ff94","q025-candidate-question:19ab030eb55337ead0d27de0"],"scopeContentSha256":"d3b8c53549ec45f774bb3f9e66a788da3fdf56d4f913afe3f315a51a5e581386","contributionContentSha256":"ad3b4506babbea636bbc53f6f8f3a2b38cedd358fe515e41cde4d0bb0428e45e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d67","kind":"description","unitIndex":67,"unitId":"unit:9b1251add165f9ec1cb5526162e89f93ce9ebb6bb320383542d9094818b7ff94","textSha256":"4200e1fda05d7e18c95e107ce6e2ccd6afe2d75b0fa9d8608b660e75b36aa016"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d248d252c86439360b6a7b76","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Perturbative and NS5-nucleation tests depend on two independent magnetic fluxes.","challengeNote":"Compound perturbative and NS5-nucleation tests, with dependence on two independent magnetic fluxes.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"d6112ce47f01ae705af1d3135241b80ba1d26dbe80140169b39853ed08432795"},"organizational-access:3bd02f9cfada49b32323b099":{"id":"organizational-access:3bd02f9cfada49b32323b099","source":"q025-candidate-question:da1a8eaa21ee72ef1dbadcdb","target":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:da1a8eaa21ee72ef1dbadcdb","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b08045d7412fb34bafa4d2dddfd3e5ecb3e370702d85c58a8523641ffa855e79","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f1a477d366a5280c01feb2e3"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6d0c9fd51c5f6983ed3baffb4047622300a4073f1af6fbadfe5f4d17524a003a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8bacc3263afe0c1d15fcec57"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5b2aae28d28e84fb4856d2743e199cb798f7ae995fef3dbc5c6c538b23732215","home":{"unitId":"unit:5b2aae28d28e84fb4856d2743e199cb798f7ae995fef3dbc5c6c538b23732215","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:da1a8eaa21ee72ef1dbadcdb","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q21 joins transient string/M-theory cosmology, state-construction applications, effective evolution and axionic-coupling tests in one question.","qualification":"q21 explicitly connects state constructions to transient cosmology, effective evolution and axionic requirements. All three tests remain material within this composite question; q13 alone does not expressly cover the separate axionic application.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5b2aae28d28e84fb4856d2743e199cb798f7ae995fef3dbc5c6c538b23732215","paperId":"2601.15489","textSha256":"45e1e85d7ca457e1055c1bcc1918cad57f36e593dc703cb086ab7a8e999e81c5"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0050:u1:q21"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0050:u1:q21","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5b2aae28d28e84fb4856d2743e199cb798f7ae995fef3dbc5c6c538b23732215","q025-candidate-question:da1a8eaa21ee72ef1dbadcdb"],"scopeContentSha256":"b08045d7412fb34bafa4d2dddfd3e5ecb3e370702d85c58a8523641ffa855e79","placementContentSha256":"a797a889e9a77e3fe9a8384c4c297044a52a02ca1a0583946639730088ca500b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0050:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0050:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5b2aae28d28e84fb4856d2743e199cb798f7ae995fef3dbc5c6c538b23732215","paperId":"2601.15489","textSha256":"45e1e85d7ca457e1055c1bcc1918cad57f36e593dc703cb086ab7a8e999e81c5"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0050","unitRef":"u1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5b2aae28d28e84fb4856d2743e199cb798f7ae995fef3dbc5c6c538b23732215","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:5b2aae28d28e84fb4856d2743e199cb798f7ae995fef3dbc5c6c538b23732215","textSha256":"45e1e85d7ca457e1055c1bcc1918cad57f36e593dc703cb086ab7a8e999e81c5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:340e10313e5c939a4d323ab8"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:340e10313e5c939a4d323ab8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5b2aae28d28e84fb4856d2743e199cb798f7ae995fef3dbc5c6c538b23732215","q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb"],"scopeContentSha256":"6d0c9fd51c5f6983ed3baffb4047622300a4073f1af6fbadfe5f4d17524a003a","contributionContentSha256":"23a565573b013755a602e1e06195d9e238cf0bac2257c7db49b0842a98e8e469","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:5b2aae28d28e84fb4856d2743e199cb798f7ae995fef3dbc5c6c538b23732215","textSha256":"45e1e85d7ca457e1055c1bcc1918cad57f36e593dc703cb086ab7a8e999e81c5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:340e10313e5c939a4d323ab8","recordId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"State existence, EFT evolution and axionic compatibility require separate reconciliation.","challengeNote":"State existence, controlled evolution and axionic compatibility require separate reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:6608803896cc22be3bb13ddb07582dce3034062c6c3672d137a4feedb7bbc85f","home":{"unitId":"unit:6608803896cc22be3bb13ddb07582dce3034062c6c3672d137a4feedb7bbc85f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:da1a8eaa21ee72ef1dbadcdb","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q21 explicitly includes dynamical Horava–Witten walls, weakly coupled heterotic transient phases, four-dimensional NEC tests and time-dependent axion decay constants.","qualification":"q21 explicitly includes every system, regime and target stated here. Its exclusion of numerical bounds absent from the packet prevents invented values or verified phenomenology; it does not exclude asking whether the source's stated range can be met.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6608803896cc22be3bb13ddb07582dce3034062c6c3672d137a4feedb7bbc85f","paperId":"2412.09449","textSha256":"803e0f430049955540ff84d452989fd20d1c1285637aff45cca7020bddf18b22"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0050:u4:q21"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0050:u4:q21","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6608803896cc22be3bb13ddb07582dce3034062c6c3672d137a4feedb7bbc85f","q025-candidate-question:da1a8eaa21ee72ef1dbadcdb"],"scopeContentSha256":"b08045d7412fb34bafa4d2dddfd3e5ecb3e370702d85c58a8523641ffa855e79","placementContentSha256":"8fa62d313bb5c4aadf113db3412688a0b9b3858862d4462716deff7532e1980f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0050:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0050:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6608803896cc22be3bb13ddb07582dce3034062c6c3672d137a4feedb7bbc85f","paperId":"2412.09449","textSha256":"803e0f430049955540ff84d452989fd20d1c1285637aff45cca7020bddf18b22"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0050","unitRef":"u4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:6608803896cc22be3bb13ddb07582dce3034062c6c3672d137a4feedb7bbc85f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:6608803896cc22be3bb13ddb07582dce3034062c6c3672d137a4feedb7bbc85f","textSha256":"803e0f430049955540ff84d452989fd20d1c1285637aff45cca7020bddf18b22"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a43e27f9f5ed7eded9dbba99acab1343","paperId":"2412.09449","sourceSha256":"dd15c90fa3b195e6b9b98f18fc3763e328f34de3b8c4db887a679a9e7a1ffbf4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c37606d424825fee0d92/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"499b30c7fbebffa732357260c1f2f66c10b747c811449287737cb6198a9ffdc6","pdfPage":1,"start":1297,"end":4683,"textSha256":"12985a0369490e1fc7ec0a11325fa4b56724ea9376823d8d92a76c9b84f10a8a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d265ecfc222f7479e0e2e26954a16bd2","paperId":"2412.09449","sourceSha256":"dd15c90fa3b195e6b9b98f18fc3763e328f34de3b8c4db887a679a9e7a1ffbf4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c37606d424825fee0d92/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"499b30c7fbebffa732357260c1f2f66c10b747c811449287737cb6198a9ffdc6","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"53dadd5b27349c834eeb6dd7844a366af0f1393be654cd25fca82dd9a8672e91","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aecb0a22ea5cd6f9890a41ad"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:aecb0a22ea5cd6f9890a41ad","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6608803896cc22be3bb13ddb07582dce3034062c6c3672d137a4feedb7bbc85f","q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb"],"scopeContentSha256":"6d0c9fd51c5f6983ed3baffb4047622300a4073f1af6fbadfe5f4d17524a003a","contributionContentSha256":"ac4ea98e8f993a57d2a838a563057dad569b2401ff0c21e5afec8109f340ecd6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:6608803896cc22be3bb13ddb07582dce3034062c6c3672d137a4feedb7bbc85f","textSha256":"803e0f430049955540ff84d452989fd20d1c1285637aff45cca7020bddf18b22"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a43e27f9f5ed7eded9dbba99acab1343","paperId":"2412.09449","sourceSha256":"dd15c90fa3b195e6b9b98f18fc3763e328f34de3b8c4db887a679a9e7a1ffbf4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c37606d424825fee0d92/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"499b30c7fbebffa732357260c1f2f66c10b747c811449287737cb6198a9ffdc6","pdfPage":1,"start":1297,"end":4683,"textSha256":"12985a0369490e1fc7ec0a11325fa4b56724ea9376823d8d92a76c9b84f10a8a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d265ecfc222f7479e0e2e26954a16bd2","paperId":"2412.09449","sourceSha256":"dd15c90fa3b195e6b9b98f18fc3763e328f34de3b8c4db887a679a9e7a1ffbf4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c37606d424825fee0d92/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"499b30c7fbebffa732357260c1f2f66c10b747c811449287737cb6198a9ffdc6","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"53dadd5b27349c834eeb6dd7844a366af0f1393be654cd25fca82dd9a8672e91","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aecb0a22ea5cd6f9890a41ad","recordId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Transient-state construction and axion phenomenology require separate reconciliation; supplied evidence is abstract/introduction.","challengeNote":"Transient-state construction and axion phenomenology require separate reconciliation. The abstract/introduction announces NEC compatibility without a supplied b","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a14904db2864ee771649fb98008d936c396bd369bc29f668e867bda19490a0dc"},"organizational-access:dfa4664576ac7169ba1595a2":{"id":"organizational-access:dfa4664576ac7169ba1595a2","source":"q025-candidate-question:f1404b998870392e20db73ac","target":"q025-candidate-question:05078b74799f7ef706cf5c85","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f1404b998870392e20db73ac","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"480418a38ba50233b55d061db68a0111cb74f3a1ba841072553a94b0f06064cd","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:85e7d620277131c3a567b767"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:05078b74799f7ef706cf5c85","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e0897eda8535cee1fa90d2d8cef8fd85447164528f6cd7d5cb34f68e54110787","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6accd74a67605847ec75226b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:09f59bf6cf7b67fa34e2cafbcb8d95fb1f88a5ba130cd0a32e4a7e7496372183","home":{"unitId":"unit:09f59bf6cf7b67fa34e2cafbcb8d95fb1f88a5ba130cd0a32e4a7e7496372183","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f1404b998870392e20db73ac","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Combines selected propagation probes and source-specific timing comparisons with discrimination between selected cosmological models.","qualification":"q8 explicitly joins selected propagation probes and timing comparisons with cosmological-model discrimination. It covers localized FRB redshifts, frequency-dependent timing, differential propagation constraints and the proposed dark-energy/Hubble-model application. Discriminating power remains a question rather than an established result.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:09f59bf6cf7b67fa34e2cafbcb8d95fb1f88a5ba130cd0a32e4a7e7496372183","paperId":"1907.02838","textSha256":"bfad35df2ad82f9934473299339b7e4e1260409fd33ae1fabdd96bee74bb2d5b"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0005:u15:q8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0005:u15:q8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:09f59bf6cf7b67fa34e2cafbcb8d95fb1f88a5ba130cd0a32e4a7e7496372183","q025-candidate-question:f1404b998870392e20db73ac"],"scopeContentSha256":"480418a38ba50233b55d061db68a0111cb74f3a1ba841072553a94b0f06064cd","placementContentSha256":"e4bd54bab66947f92e6a4b728da3bdc627d06393fe128b64fe611be8a95d7d20","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0005:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0005:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:09f59bf6cf7b67fa34e2cafbcb8d95fb1f88a5ba130cd0a32e4a7e7496372183","paperId":"1907.02838","textSha256":"bfad35df2ad82f9934473299339b7e4e1260409fd33ae1fabdd96bee74bb2d5b"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0005","unitRef":"u15"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:09f59bf6cf7b67fa34e2cafbcb8d95fb1f88a5ba130cd0a32e4a7e7496372183","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:05078b74799f7ef706cf5c85","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:09f59bf6cf7b67fa34e2cafbcb8d95fb1f88a5ba130cd0a32e4a7e7496372183","textSha256":"bfad35df2ad82f9934473299339b7e4e1260409fd33ae1fabdd96bee74bb2d5b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:48ec1239588063b326309125"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:48ec1239588063b326309125","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:09f59bf6cf7b67fa34e2cafbcb8d95fb1f88a5ba130cd0a32e4a7e7496372183","q025-candidate-question:05078b74799f7ef706cf5c85"],"scopeContentSha256":"e0897eda8535cee1fa90d2d8cef8fd85447164528f6cd7d5cb34f68e54110787","contributionContentSha256":"ad514831e72cbfcb23673cbb80ece19f424d409d88b9e0f75a89ebc4133ce247","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-777289df84203d433c78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-777289df84203d433c78-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-777289df84203d433c78-proposal","leaf-777289df84203d433c78-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:09f59bf6cf7b67fa34e2cafbcb8d95fb1f88a5ba130cd0a32e4a7e7496372183","textSha256":"bfad35df2ad82f9934473299339b7e4e1260409fd33ae1fabdd96bee74bb2d5b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:48ec1239588063b326309125","recordId":"leaf-777289df84203d433c78-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-777289df84203d433c78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-777289df84203d433c78-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Differential propagation limits and discrimination among selected cosmological models are distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Differential propagation constraints and selected cosmological-model discrimination are separate targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"00ac2848383e1a7ab5a9367c5bc74e02fa2f84026eaa93f5114238e75a0137c0"},"organizational-access:a65b45301bf6f8f1ae057b5e":{"id":"organizational-access:a65b45301bf6f8f1ae057b5e","source":"q025-candidate-question:f88819fe8ce4e6bee34f3db6","target":"q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f88819fe8ce4e6bee34f3db6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"cb9e232c9c6ec6939720a3ceb4597a03c513965a1eaa64886cc22d0241b3989c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:148e72baf2bbe9fb98b22d32"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e5f0b23e05b128ff01faf30c56b499ddf93e45dcfd83b25fe7c3d1a35cf9eb55","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:98807f68849d9c5d578063b5"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:824e4a71e18ebd9d2e0162be9fd83fa782938db4baddc6087e257d68b41030b2","home":{"unitId":"unit:824e4a71e18ebd9d2e0162be9fd83fa782938db4baddc6087e257d68b41030b2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f88819fe8ce4e6bee34f3db6","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q30 includes classical type-II existence analyses through scalar potentials together with the flux and source consistency checks needed to interpret candidate extrema as compactifications.","qualification":"q30 includes scalar-potential existence analyses and discrete/source consistency tests. The description states both activities despite its declarative form; a continuous-flux extremum is not thereby quantized, physically sourced or controlled.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:824e4a71e18ebd9d2e0162be9fd83fa782938db4baddc6087e257d68b41030b2","paperId":"1807.09538","textSha256":"157b1631c424a357c2920e4b0305cf883b6c14dd6b649684a0335760b5824849"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u22:q30"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u22:q30","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:824e4a71e18ebd9d2e0162be9fd83fa782938db4baddc6087e257d68b41030b2","q025-candidate-question:f88819fe8ce4e6bee34f3db6"],"scopeContentSha256":"cb9e232c9c6ec6939720a3ceb4597a03c513965a1eaa64886cc22d0241b3989c","placementContentSha256":"434a7ba1d44b95c53cfded4ee2423ac6bf9f06f39383ffcd189cfe8a0f9f69fa","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:824e4a71e18ebd9d2e0162be9fd83fa782938db4baddc6087e257d68b41030b2","paperId":"1807.09538","textSha256":"157b1631c424a357c2920e4b0305cf883b6c14dd6b649684a0335760b5824849"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0031","unitRef":"u22"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:824e4a71e18ebd9d2e0162be9fd83fa782938db4baddc6087e257d68b41030b2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:647f4b3de8eb982fbd1db9af","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:824e4a71e18ebd9d2e0162be9fd83fa782938db4baddc6087e257d68b41030b2","textSha256":"157b1631c424a357c2920e4b0305cf883b6c14dd6b649684a0335760b5824849"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:47cd352bc10a91f2b0b8c1ffa3ae4514","paperId":"1807.09538","sourceSha256":"3cddad8d06e86a06ed2f8e43f631188f24dea9c090898ab86b30d3e6f3f5e586","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e0f04a3e0e8c68e1fe0d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"637f0d1af3602ce54aed3cbf06151431b104b51d753df18437afc76330395c24","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2914,"textSha256":"267eac9b2a5317d664cdd79eb392d5874261a8306fea7fa70bd502499d647ab9","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6be30db6e3551fee512de2fc4d5794e8","paperId":"1807.09538","sourceSha256":"3cddad8d06e86a06ed2f8e43f631188f24dea9c090898ab86b30d3e6f3f5e586","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e0f04a3e0e8c68e1fe0d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"637f0d1af3602ce54aed3cbf06151431b104b51d753df18437afc76330395c24","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2798,"textSha256":"696324baa8814830f2a07400d2a825e15edf2cd8234b60d785bdbaf55abcc31d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b4dc36cf16ae39bdf98d3413f4d12dda","paperId":"1807.09538","sourceSha256":"3cddad8d06e86a06ed2f8e43f631188f24dea9c090898ab86b30d3e6f3f5e586","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e0f04a3e0e8c68e1fe0d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"637f0d1af3602ce54aed3cbf06151431b104b51d753df18437afc76330395c24","pdfPage":9,"start":0,"end":2997,"textSha256":"3dc7f6ad73b9203a88ec50753962d670c0795d69012d70f8f574fba7a81d55ae","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d6061889327482e6fda0ca3f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d6061889327482e6fda0ca3f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:824e4a71e18ebd9d2e0162be9fd83fa782938db4baddc6087e257d68b41030b2","q025-candidate-question:647f4b3de8eb982fbd1db9af"],"scopeContentSha256":"65903bd4f4ce6fb0475fb2453e1fd0df99c15fa02668db65c0f9ce30ccf7e3ba","contributionContentSha256":"50ccad6f9b19fca364847d7a78f4ad228998f8756f74759b44ad28174eae22fc","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:824e4a71e18ebd9d2e0162be9fd83fa782938db4baddc6087e257d68b41030b2","textSha256":"157b1631c424a357c2920e4b0305cf883b6c14dd6b649684a0335760b5824849"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:47cd352bc10a91f2b0b8c1ffa3ae4514","paperId":"1807.09538","sourceSha256":"3cddad8d06e86a06ed2f8e43f631188f24dea9c090898ab86b30d3e6f3f5e586","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e0f04a3e0e8c68e1fe0d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"637f0d1af3602ce54aed3cbf06151431b104b51d753df18437afc76330395c24","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2914,"textSha256":"267eac9b2a5317d664cdd79eb392d5874261a8306fea7fa70bd502499d647ab9","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6be30db6e3551fee512de2fc4d5794e8","paperId":"1807.09538","sourceSha256":"3cddad8d06e86a06ed2f8e43f631188f24dea9c090898ab86b30d3e6f3f5e586","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e0f04a3e0e8c68e1fe0d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"637f0d1af3602ce54aed3cbf06151431b104b51d753df18437afc76330395c24","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2798,"textSha256":"696324baa8814830f2a07400d2a825e15edf2cd8234b60d785bdbaf55abcc31d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b4dc36cf16ae39bdf98d3413f4d12dda","paperId":"1807.09538","sourceSha256":"3cddad8d06e86a06ed2f8e43f631188f24dea9c090898ab86b30d3e6f3f5e586","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e0f04a3e0e8c68e1fe0d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"637f0d1af3602ce54aed3cbf06151431b104b51d753df18437afc76330395c24","pdfPage":9,"start":0,"end":2997,"textSha256":"3dc7f6ad73b9203a88ec50753962d670c0795d69012d70f8f574fba7a81d55ae","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d6061889327482e6fda0ca3f","recordId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"The numerical sample and its string-consistency checks are distinct stages.","challengeNote":"Compound search and consistency targets remain source-scoped. Continuous-flux stationary points initially fail full quantization and physical tadpole conditions","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}},"canonicalTarget":{"originalDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:647f4b3de8eb982fbd1db9af","currentDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b","originalScopeContentSha256":"65903bd4f4ce6fb0475fb2453e1fd0df99c15fa02668db65c0f9ce30ccf7e3ba","currentScopeContentSha256":"e5f0b23e05b128ff01faf30c56b499ddf93e45dcfd83b25fe7c3d1a35cf9eb55","identityGroupId":"identity-group:687ebb399d919925dc9039e5"}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9705ad3d292e33395fde36eb3ebdf125da55c529e7231576925cea450628a092","home":{"unitId":"unit:9705ad3d292e33395fde36eb3ebdf125da55c529e7231576925cea450628a092","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f88819fe8ce4e6bee34f3db6","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q30 combines classical type-II existence restrictions with weak-coupling and large-length control tests, using source-specific scalar-potential analyses without requiring every modulus equation to have been solved.","qualification":"q30 covers positive-stationarity restrictions together with weak-coupling and large-volume control tests. Universal-field restrictions remain necessary tests, and average volume does not certify every relevant length. The unresolved curvature wording is not needed for this sign-agnostic placement.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9705ad3d292e33395fde36eb3ebdf125da55c529e7231576925cea450628a092","paperId":"2203.10125","textSha256":"910dc48a7a94721e9aee009a4aae3675b79409b720d916061abc2f027b2c22e0"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u26:q30"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u26:q30","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9705ad3d292e33395fde36eb3ebdf125da55c529e7231576925cea450628a092","q025-candidate-question:f88819fe8ce4e6bee34f3db6"],"scopeContentSha256":"cb9e232c9c6ec6939720a3ceb4597a03c513965a1eaa64886cc22d0241b3989c","placementContentSha256":"9f054d589d415c305d5eae501a36ca424da6446c3081d2b8b8ba6beb99e2b62b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9705ad3d292e33395fde36eb3ebdf125da55c529e7231576925cea450628a092","paperId":"2203.10125","textSha256":"910dc48a7a94721e9aee009a4aae3675b79409b720d916061abc2f027b2c22e0"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0031","unitRef":"u26"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9705ad3d292e33395fde36eb3ebdf125da55c529e7231576925cea450628a092","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:647f4b3de8eb982fbd1db9af","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:9705ad3d292e33395fde36eb3ebdf125da55c529e7231576925cea450628a092","textSha256":"910dc48a7a94721e9aee009a4aae3675b79409b720d916061abc2f027b2c22e0"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:09f91dc0a340d12bd7d72b6c55737ce8","paperId":"2203.10125","sourceSha256":"a1786e907d23dfb94c42f571141159b9b2abaf3def11df61860765bd884a3f3b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8bcd2cf1ed983fca2080/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2f53d9143485e0e2238137a3f5b353f88c4737b1d27370b51cb4b92eaf78a79e","pdfPage":118,"start":0,"end":2080,"textSha256":"0c67102220441c0928b98fccb9c02f97b0f8996c3facf9983aaa8069b80ca74c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d28eb99a62f342f7cda227c6a90bd07b","paperId":"2203.10125","sourceSha256":"a1786e907d23dfb94c42f571141159b9b2abaf3def11df61860765bd884a3f3b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8bcd2cf1ed983fca2080/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2f53d9143485e0e2238137a3f5b353f88c4737b1d27370b51cb4b92eaf78a79e","pdfPage":121,"start":0,"end":1782,"textSha256":"a91cb06713a91d5e46129af8b1996afb17d1f0d219242e1147cc0b4852fe1de6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d27b29a8ecc1de78d7d9696c4ef629c9","paperId":"2203.10125","sourceSha256":"a1786e907d23dfb94c42f571141159b9b2abaf3def11df61860765bd884a3f3b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8bcd2cf1ed983fca2080/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2f53d9143485e0e2238137a3f5b353f88c4737b1d27370b51cb4b92eaf78a79e","pdfPage":122,"start":0,"end":1900,"textSha256":"7a3c461f082028758fb89c4df99ce92bc7804ed92d6194adc4439fed78a231a0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6cca6bac39c5b0b61f9feac4"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6cca6bac39c5b0b61f9feac4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9705ad3d292e33395fde36eb3ebdf125da55c529e7231576925cea450628a092","q025-candidate-question:647f4b3de8eb982fbd1db9af"],"scopeContentSha256":"65903bd4f4ce6fb0475fb2453e1fd0df99c15fa02668db65c0f9ce30ccf7e3ba","contributionContentSha256":"93daeb597c349d9b389aef34d03d7c5cfbb85afaad3df6b12e70b0013b7b83b0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:9705ad3d292e33395fde36eb3ebdf125da55c529e7231576925cea450628a092","textSha256":"910dc48a7a94721e9aee009a4aae3675b79409b720d916061abc2f027b2c22e0"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:09f91dc0a340d12bd7d72b6c55737ce8","paperId":"2203.10125","sourceSha256":"a1786e907d23dfb94c42f571141159b9b2abaf3def11df61860765bd884a3f3b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8bcd2cf1ed983fca2080/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2f53d9143485e0e2238137a3f5b353f88c4737b1d27370b51cb4b92eaf78a79e","pdfPage":118,"start":0,"end":2080,"textSha256":"0c67102220441c0928b98fccb9c02f97b0f8996c3facf9983aaa8069b80ca74c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d28eb99a62f342f7cda227c6a90bd07b","paperId":"2203.10125","sourceSha256":"a1786e907d23dfb94c42f571141159b9b2abaf3def11df61860765bd884a3f3b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8bcd2cf1ed983fca2080/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2f53d9143485e0e2238137a3f5b353f88c4737b1d27370b51cb4b92eaf78a79e","pdfPage":121,"start":0,"end":1782,"textSha256":"a91cb06713a91d5e46129af8b1996afb17d1f0d219242e1147cc0b4852fe1de6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d27b29a8ecc1de78d7d9696c4ef629c9","paperId":"2203.10125","sourceSha256":"a1786e907d23dfb94c42f571141159b9b2abaf3def11df61860765bd884a3f3b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8bcd2cf1ed983fca2080/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2f53d9143485e0e2238137a3f5b353f88c4737b1d27370b51cb4b92eaf78a79e","pdfPage":122,"start":0,"end":1900,"textSha256":"7a3c461f082028758fb89c4df99ce92bc7804ed92d6194adc4439fed78a231a0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6cca6bac39c5b0b61f9feac4","recordId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"The negative-curvature sentence in e22 conflicts with e23 and the stated positive curvature-coefficient requirement; no silent repair.","challengeNote":"Replaces truncated pf42 with f0. Compound existence/control targets remain source-scoped; e22's curvature wording conflicts with the other supplied conditions.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}},"canonicalTarget":{"originalDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:647f4b3de8eb982fbd1db9af","currentDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b","originalScopeContentSha256":"65903bd4f4ce6fb0475fb2453e1fd0df99c15fa02668db65c0f9ce30ccf7e3ba","currentScopeContentSha256":"e5f0b23e05b128ff01faf30c56b499ddf93e45dcfd83b25fe7c3d1a35cf9eb55","identityGroupId":"identity-group:687ebb399d919925dc9039e5"}}]},{"unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","home":{"unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f88819fe8ce4e6bee34f3db6","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q30 explicitly joins restricted-ansatz classical type-II existence and instability with weak-coupling, large-length and internal-hierarchy control questions.","qualification":"q30 explicitly includes existence, instability and classical control within source-specific ansätze. The omitted exact ansatz prevents applying detailed source-class theorems but does not prevent this placement, which imposes no common ansatz or successful tachyon proof.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","paperId":"1902.10093","textSha256":"13d2a2a68a7c8d73145c555257b20f27296ae1046d89c4e0071c488fbd4f77c3"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u20:q30"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u20:q30","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","q025-candidate-question:f88819fe8ce4e6bee34f3db6"],"scopeContentSha256":"cb9e232c9c6ec6939720a3ceb4597a03c513965a1eaa64886cc22d0241b3989c","placementContentSha256":"0ce1d23aacd5c69d26353d3299a7dd39aff92b5429ee4ae786619bd3f48e6e64","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","paperId":"1902.10093","textSha256":"13d2a2a68a7c8d73145c555257b20f27296ae1046d89c4e0071c488fbd4f77c3"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0031","unitRef":"u20"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","textSha256":"13d2a2a68a7c8d73145c555257b20f27296ae1046d89c4e0071c488fbd4f77c3"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6912dd5714522a0894382f644908274a","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":32,"start":0,"end":2249,"textSha256":"fd349ef92c4e02795f4b0289c55e68106c957f933c0420c5ef8486ff6cb74a4a","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:02ab63bee4b07e0b303a5a503a068b2a","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":30,"start":1917,"end":3517,"textSha256":"5e20c9555081e7a7078068b3749dd7e9542703fde5380a4e6a3c6b2694ad1aa3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:550eb8fc26b3055601fead3df0331240","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":30,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"99b1beb1f45d1ea918b16dee11187c74a028336c5f719b32bb7b2d4feb53df91","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6ecbe2afea409116d1ceb03a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6ecbe2afea409116d1ceb03a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e5f0b23e05b128ff01faf30c56b499ddf93e45dcfd83b25fe7c3d1a35cf9eb55","contributionContentSha256":"3ad15eab03661c5e3594e5b83058f130b26947f8bff8b4d56a56f462740e5b86","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-proposal","leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","textSha256":"13d2a2a68a7c8d73145c555257b20f27296ae1046d89c4e0071c488fbd4f77c3"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6912dd5714522a0894382f644908274a","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":32,"start":0,"end":2249,"textSha256":"fd349ef92c4e02795f4b0289c55e68106c957f933c0420c5ef8486ff6cb74a4a","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:02ab63bee4b07e0b303a5a503a068b2a","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":30,"start":1917,"end":3517,"textSha256":"5e20c9555081e7a7078068b3749dd7e9542703fde5380a4e6a3c6b2694ad1aa3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:550eb8fc26b3055601fead3df0331240","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":30,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"99b1beb1f45d1ea918b16dee11187c74a028336c5f719b32bb7b2d4feb53df91","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6ecbe2afea409116d1ceb03a","recordId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3e586699180f4bb42528-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound control, existence and stability targets; neither a systematic tachyon nor exclusion of the internal hierarchy is proved.","challengeNote":"Compound existence, stability and control target. The exact ansatz is omitted; neither a systematic tachyon nor exclusion of the internal hierarchy is proved.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}},{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:647f4b3de8eb982fbd1db9af","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","textSha256":"13d2a2a68a7c8d73145c555257b20f27296ae1046d89c4e0071c488fbd4f77c3"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6912dd5714522a0894382f644908274a","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":32,"start":0,"end":2249,"textSha256":"fd349ef92c4e02795f4b0289c55e68106c957f933c0420c5ef8486ff6cb74a4a","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:02ab63bee4b07e0b303a5a503a068b2a","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":30,"start":1917,"end":3517,"textSha256":"5e20c9555081e7a7078068b3749dd7e9542703fde5380a4e6a3c6b2694ad1aa3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:550eb8fc26b3055601fead3df0331240","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":30,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"99b1beb1f45d1ea918b16dee11187c74a028336c5f719b32bb7b2d4feb53df91","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b84cfa8de2283a723f2a0b18"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b84cfa8de2283a723f2a0b18","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","q025-candidate-question:647f4b3de8eb982fbd1db9af"],"scopeContentSha256":"65903bd4f4ce6fb0475fb2453e1fd0df99c15fa02668db65c0f9ce30ccf7e3ba","contributionContentSha256":"1b365dd9b9a903083a43b82c142bbc005994d42883803acf67eaf44673aa5322","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:db1da7fc8f9868ed77110bfe577656b9105f361209e522d50ff0ff56dde81c89","textSha256":"13d2a2a68a7c8d73145c555257b20f27296ae1046d89c4e0071c488fbd4f77c3"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6912dd5714522a0894382f644908274a","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":32,"start":0,"end":2249,"textSha256":"fd349ef92c4e02795f4b0289c55e68106c957f933c0420c5ef8486ff6cb74a4a","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:02ab63bee4b07e0b303a5a503a068b2a","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":30,"start":1917,"end":3517,"textSha256":"5e20c9555081e7a7078068b3749dd7e9542703fde5380a4e6a3c6b2694ad1aa3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:550eb8fc26b3055601fead3df0331240","paperId":"1902.10093","sourceSha256":"b8e800b08d85f5c341209eb2dd290b49f172ccf807a60650580af130ef05b2d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4fb0a89f6fdae30196df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8ac381906afc2217f9480e052d5ab890b4bb6c4fa41ef41793f81d9365a20781","pdfPage":30,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"99b1beb1f45d1ea918b16dee11187c74a028336c5f719b32bb7b2d4feb53df91","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b84cfa8de2283a723f2a0b18","recordId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-54aab275ab4a0ea75137-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound existence, instability and control targets. A systematic tachyon and exclusion of the internal hierarchy remain unproved.","challengeNote":"Replaces truncated pf44 with f1/f2. Compound targets remain unresolved; neither a systematic tachyon nor exclusion of the internal hierarchy is proved.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}},"canonicalTarget":{"originalDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:647f4b3de8eb982fbd1db9af","currentDestinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0fe511cad863493858f2321b","originalScopeContentSha256":"65903bd4f4ce6fb0475fb2453e1fd0df99c15fa02668db65c0f9ce30ccf7e3ba","currentScopeContentSha256":"e5f0b23e05b128ff01faf30c56b499ddf93e45dcfd83b25fe7c3d1a35cf9eb55","identityGroupId":"identity-group:687ebb399d919925dc9039e5"}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"e4a7a4864428c99e245cbc16f30dfa10986c46c2ab798ece5f33935a14a85b67"},"organizational-access:3ddadd7290a48928a0526482":{"id":"organizational-access:3ddadd7290a48928a0526482","source":"q025-candidate-region:0c603fa5159ab39094554a1f","target":"q025-candidate-question:2caa317cebef9683f1893fc7","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:0c603fa5159ab39094554a1f","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"2abb367532aabbbca54d73d3e43bb30332b0c210d1c612fcc1464e8aa1ebff32","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2abedcab33c631b9bac17a3b"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:2caa317cebef9683f1893fc7","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c0866e51a274ab3b55739861afe5a40be5dcad9eb09bdc29d410458943d29ed6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:dbbd8e844bd773bc535b06e6"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","home":{"unitId":"unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0c603fa5159ab39094554a1f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","paperId":"2102.05550","textSha256":"b06da6c33f848b4586d90c72d2e2259e5b7ffb5b02e946555a251a57805df938"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5a8b5c065527f98d61b9fbc6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5a8b5c065527f98d61b9fbc6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","q025-candidate-region:0c603fa5159ab39094554a1f"],"scopeContentSha256":"2abb367532aabbbca54d73d3e43bb30332b0c210d1c612fcc1464e8aa1ebff32","placementContentSha256":"eea8829e0fb9e3956c0e5560b4da3a65524754d2ecd42679032d2d2870f65397","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-challenge","leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","paperId":"2102.05550","textSha256":"b06da6c33f848b4586d90c72d2e2259e5b7ffb5b02e946555a251a57805df938"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5a8b5c065527f98d61b9fbc6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2caa317cebef9683f1893fc7","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","textSha256":"b06da6c33f848b4586d90c72d2e2259e5b7ffb5b02e946555a251a57805df938"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f8df005f059aa479f11201fc"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f8df005f059aa479f11201fc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","q025-candidate-question:2caa317cebef9683f1893fc7"],"scopeContentSha256":"c0866e51a274ab3b55739861afe5a40be5dcad9eb09bdc29d410458943d29ed6","contributionContentSha256":"26d0704e39ad5ed5fa0aa0edfa03b5c801ef5365746208923ca2783f0a1a43c7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-proposal","leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:0e88413a97d896af578dfc9740722de20661a9a4d42f4b61ae26aaed4d5751cd","textSha256":"b06da6c33f848b4586d90c72d2e2259e5b7ffb5b02e946555a251a57805df938"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f8df005f059aa479f11201fc","recordId":"leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a66bea011582274d11b-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound background and dimensional-release question extracted from a setting.","challengeNote":"Compound background-persistence and dimensional-release question extracted from a setting.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"d1bc999fb71d463c77331d7f0950ec64f5b5075f46e7818f71b156734a32a856"},"organizational-access:fd4ca15da9ac8b05411991cc":{"id":"organizational-access:fd4ca15da9ac8b05411991cc","source":"q025-candidate-region:16e7a3854c88582d05e83321","target":"q025-candidate-question:72b723c34c9eefcdaffedee3","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:16e7a3854c88582d05e83321","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"be902d854d1e25647dc75525e19150d267df2d93e2480b708945de7e7cf3bd3e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:86644f2772d9aa5a774b38b5"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:72b723c34c9eefcdaffedee3","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"8a5f8cb13a9237c19a3adecbd7fac4817e9064cd334c5dc6868aad81b60cac44","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3cca2916bc00d9ebf2770609"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:a780eea62f153077b1801932c7ad1178c036c4ca8a4ec38ecf9b62a8244941e7","home":{"unitId":"unit:a780eea62f153077b1801932c7ad1178c036c4ca8a4ec38ecf9b62a8244941e7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:16e7a3854c88582d05e83321","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a780eea62f153077b1801932c7ad1178c036c4ca8a4ec38ecf9b62a8244941e7","paperId":"2607.28726","textSha256":"ab7e0eab2c03d9162c1cd8a7c0b8889f2f8ec6f3a2432db79edb6f253f701f8a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dfe2ffb3018c6a58194305e0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dfe2ffb3018c6a58194305e0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a780eea62f153077b1801932c7ad1178c036c4ca8a4ec38ecf9b62a8244941e7","q025-candidate-region:16e7a3854c88582d05e83321"],"scopeContentSha256":"be902d854d1e25647dc75525e19150d267df2d93e2480b708945de7e7cf3bd3e","placementContentSha256":"2fda2c7f2ada1811f0c69c0533b827d7ee729e4b5e6d40730837f9160e5a3659","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge","leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a780eea62f153077b1801932c7ad1178c036c4ca8a4ec38ecf9b62a8244941e7","paperId":"2607.28726","textSha256":"ab7e0eab2c03d9162c1cd8a7c0b8889f2f8ec6f3a2432db79edb6f253f701f8a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dfe2ffb3018c6a58194305e0"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a780eea62f153077b1801932c7ad1178c036c4ca8a4ec38ecf9b62a8244941e7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72b723c34c9eefcdaffedee3","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:a780eea62f153077b1801932c7ad1178c036c4ca8a4ec38ecf9b62a8244941e7","textSha256":"ab7e0eab2c03d9162c1cd8a7c0b8889f2f8ec6f3a2432db79edb6f253f701f8a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7384fecb80f17f6c9ba2a258","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: Linked coefficient bounds and asymptotic convexity; neither establishes a universal order-one onset."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7384fecb80f17f6c9ba2a258","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a780eea62f153077b1801932c7ad1178c036c4ca8a4ec38ecf9b62a8244941e7","q025-candidate-question:72b723c34c9eefcdaffedee3"],"scopeContentSha256":"8a5f8cb13a9237c19a3adecbd7fac4817e9064cd334c5dc6868aad81b60cac44","contributionContentSha256":"5cb3f8ccc28ecb6c9ceb12dbc6c52e7f79e14985e9430ccf68bbc9194d7709c0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal","leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:a780eea62f153077b1801932c7ad1178c036c4ca8a4ec38ecf9b62a8244941e7","textSha256":"ab7e0eab2c03d9162c1cd8a7c0b8889f2f8ec6f3a2432db79edb6f253f701f8a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7384fecb80f17f6c9ba2a258","recordId":"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"Linked coefficient bounds and asymptotic convexity; neither establishes a universal order-one onset.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4015565246a7a3b79e5fe01d2e769fb676b9d5139f781ba8644addad56e49ed5"},"organizational-access:47866b5ad1d4de903c5d6c1d":{"id":"organizational-access:47866b5ad1d4de903c5d6c1d","source":"q025-candidate-region:1a284aee5a8a7637c41d3c4d","target":"q025-candidate-question:341f402459726e643e8b16ef","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:1a284aee5a8a7637c41d3c4d","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"13cf7b03940536349931e54e0d67ccda135feb9b0e3262b422d0c7ca332cff1e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f860b4fb5da15f376119a806"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:341f402459726e643e8b16ef","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"832eee09b10287fb709108d27f6457d8cac23cc6ea70284eea343140851494a7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:statistics:cq0"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:225686e3711b95bfbd209681b2e29b34f4e29cd5ec94708d24883f8435cca1e4","home":{"unitId":"unit:225686e3711b95bfbd209681b2e29b34f4e29cd5ec94708d24883f8435cca1e4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:1a284aee5a8a7637c41d3c4d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:225686e3711b95bfbd209681b2e29b34f4e29cd5ec94708d24883f8435cca1e4","paperId":"0707.0105","textSha256":"bb09c15b25b638bb2d110c15b1531ed19b6542392a67e92f93b3c5c85998bef2"},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a094704b17fafde38e58d3ecc02f0bad","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b7f08785cc72bd974e25c18ec2017ba8258d585244979b4f2b2fd79ec771e194","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e25419af8e5ed1bb0c70c98b09d046fb","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":2,"start":1299,"end":4330,"textSha256":"71152ee8be67712065c70f429601a3d51bdf5401498b698f45595576732c9862","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:da71a00a7f6ae32fc896d219"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:da71a00a7f6ae32fc896d219","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:225686e3711b95bfbd209681b2e29b34f4e29cd5ec94708d24883f8435cca1e4","q025-candidate-region:1a284aee5a8a7637c41d3c4d"],"scopeContentSha256":"13cf7b03940536349931e54e0d67ccda135feb9b0e3262b422d0c7ca332cff1e","placementContentSha256":"f79ff7901f958e16476bb5ed24c4560b98d6a0d91cf24ec9910ce8bfcb2aa963","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge","leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:225686e3711b95bfbd209681b2e29b34f4e29cd5ec94708d24883f8435cca1e4","paperId":"0707.0105","textSha256":"bb09c15b25b638bb2d110c15b1531ed19b6542392a67e92f93b3c5c85998bef2"},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a094704b17fafde38e58d3ecc02f0bad","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b7f08785cc72bd974e25c18ec2017ba8258d585244979b4f2b2fd79ec771e194","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e25419af8e5ed1bb0c70c98b09d046fb","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":2,"start":1299,"end":4330,"textSha256":"71152ee8be67712065c70f429601a3d51bdf5401498b698f45595576732c9862","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:da71a00a7f6ae32fc896d219"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:225686e3711b95bfbd209681b2e29b34f4e29cd5ec94708d24883f8435cca1e4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:341f402459726e643e8b16ef","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","qualification":"The description and primary introduction explicitly ask about finitely separated complex-structure and axio-dilaton configurations at identical fluxes. This new component role does not independently verify the claimed multiplicity.","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u73","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:225686e3711b95bfbd209681b2e29b34f4e29cd5ec94708d24883f8435cca1e4","paperId":"0707.0105","textSha256":"bb09c15b25b638bb2d110c15b1531ed19b6542392a67e92f93b3c5c85998bef2"},{"localRef":"e46","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a094704b17fafde38e58d3ecc02f0bad","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b7f08785cc72bd974e25c18ec2017ba8258d585244979b4f2b2fd79ec771e194","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e47","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e25419af8e5ed1bb0c70c98b09d046fb","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":2,"start":1299,"end":4330,"textSha256":"71152ee8be67712065c70f429601a3d51bdf5401498b698f45595576732c9862","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-source-role:statistics:u73:cq0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-pilot-source-role:statistics:u73:cq0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:225686e3711b95bfbd209681b2e29b34f4e29cd5ec94708d24883f8435cca1e4","q025-candidate-question:341f402459726e643e8b16ef"],"challengerAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_source_contribution","sourceReviewIds":["canonical-fields-control-statistics-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u73","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:225686e3711b95bfbd209681b2e29b34f4e29cd5ec94708d24883f8435cca1e4","paperId":"0707.0105","textSha256":"bb09c15b25b638bb2d110c15b1531ed19b6542392a67e92f93b3c5c85998bef2"},{"localRef":"e46","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a094704b17fafde38e58d3ecc02f0bad","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b7f08785cc72bd974e25c18ec2017ba8258d585244979b4f2b2fd79ec771e194","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e47","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e25419af8e5ed1bb0c70c98b09d046fb","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":2,"start":1299,"end":4330,"textSha256":"71152ee8be67712065c70f429601a3d51bdf5401498b698f45595576732c9862","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"scopeContentSha256":"832eee09b10287fb709108d27f6457d8cac23cc6ea70284eea343140851494a7","contributionContentSha256":"c3960f65a2a14f2d4278a4bfcaa8363f7ce9a587986c8353c86fff82492acd5d","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_source_contribution","receipt":{"path":"../../../evaluation/full-pass/canonical-pilot-admissions-v1/scope-role-operation-admission.json","sha256":"97216f13b56534815e329d1b2725c40fb3b1fdc0b5f596ba7ea1c1ef6ac39812"}}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"5fdd41118803ae5d799991b0ae590e531aa73066ee02671ec7ee19d755a70047"},"organizational-access:64cde88e536105e4a0781a19":{"id":"organizational-access:64cde88e536105e4a0781a19","source":"q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b","target":"q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"968b0788aa6f521e5fb1c3447aa97044480ddb3d54746c54c33ec77cabb94349","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0b295d6ca18c4a2a7a0c6da2"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"fce7ab18ffc5b72fb3d62e68da96ba63d129b5966753ee5c648eb8c4918dfa62","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:92604a00128ac4837c2b4036"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1afe22209df797df7117501faf477b8d658a1d23c80b78be9bca3d0781f633b0","home":{"unitId":"unit:1afe22209df797df7117501faf477b8d658a1d23c80b78be9bca3d0781f633b0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1afe22209df797df7117501faf477b8d658a1d23c80b78be9bca3d0781f633b0","paperId":"1503.09026","textSha256":"6292dccf3f35970658f5f9ed52c8fe9b6c0ebee5a0eb1f9225a93aaf686964e9"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:596a5f23b3e21fa9873f65a4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:596a5f23b3e21fa9873f65a4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1afe22209df797df7117501faf477b8d658a1d23c80b78be9bca3d0781f633b0","q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b"],"scopeContentSha256":"968b0788aa6f521e5fb1c3447aa97044480ddb3d54746c54c33ec77cabb94349","placementContentSha256":"049180ecdf8331c36ed927b43629cb4fd8acb9d9cddce13cc0927c4176a09f4f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1afe22209df797df7117501faf477b8d658a1d23c80b78be9bca3d0781f633b0","paperId":"1503.09026","textSha256":"6292dccf3f35970658f5f9ed52c8fe9b6c0ebee5a0eb1f9225a93aaf686964e9"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:596a5f23b3e21fa9873f65a4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1afe22209df797df7117501faf477b8d658a1d23c80b78be9bca3d0781f633b0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:1afe22209df797df7117501faf477b8d658a1d23c80b78be9bca3d0781f633b0","textSha256":"6292dccf3f35970658f5f9ed52c8fe9b6c0ebee5a0eb1f9225a93aaf686964e9"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0fc140f9370f149ad6559098","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Survey-style compound question spanning CP, dark-sector cosmology and KNP inflation; no atomic identity assigned. Independent challenge qualification: Removed p4 comparison: CP coverage alone does not specify a measurement. Compound survey scope remains unresolved."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0fc140f9370f149ad6559098","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1afe22209df797df7117501faf477b8d658a1d23c80b78be9bca3d0781f633b0","q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507"],"scopeContentSha256":"fce7ab18ffc5b72fb3d62e68da96ba63d129b5966753ee5c648eb8c4918dfa62","contributionContentSha256":"847c7ecd161ebc035e0f5c619a3f3de949e19be790a5842551fef44e3d7728a6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:1afe22209df797df7117501faf477b8d658a1d23c80b78be9bca3d0781f633b0","textSha256":"6292dccf3f35970658f5f9ed52c8fe9b6c0ebee5a0eb1f9225a93aaf686964e9"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0fc140f9370f149ad6559098","recordId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Survey-style compound question spanning CP, dark-sector cosmology and KNP inflation; no atomic identity assigned.","challengeNote":"Removed p4 comparison: CP coverage alone does not specify a measurement. Compound survey scope remains unresolved.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:4ca2ec1798c9460523d7233ec1f1fa8c7b160eaded860d494d76e43686f3e1be","home":{"unitId":"unit:4ca2ec1798c9460523d7233ec1f1fa8c7b160eaded860d494d76e43686f3e1be","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4ca2ec1798c9460523d7233ec1f1fa8c7b160eaded860d494d76e43686f3e1be","paperId":"hep-th/0409059","textSha256":"89b9d4987810a710c16f0f77cd713867fe6c2117f3d2adc095592413b6ebfcef"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b6e0a12f1f80789b6d766a01"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b6e0a12f1f80789b6d766a01","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4ca2ec1798c9460523d7233ec1f1fa8c7b160eaded860d494d76e43686f3e1be","q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b"],"scopeContentSha256":"968b0788aa6f521e5fb1c3447aa97044480ddb3d54746c54c33ec77cabb94349","placementContentSha256":"7ddb6a97c485e7822a14346da2e13281757490ff8cc3d6e1995942ec181d762e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4ca2ec1798c9460523d7233ec1f1fa8c7b160eaded860d494d76e43686f3e1be","paperId":"hep-th/0409059","textSha256":"89b9d4987810a710c16f0f77cd713867fe6c2117f3d2adc095592413b6ebfcef"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b6e0a12f1f80789b6d766a01"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4ca2ec1798c9460523d7233ec1f1fa8c7b160eaded860d494d76e43686f3e1be","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:4ca2ec1798c9460523d7233ec1f1fa8c7b160eaded860d494d76e43686f3e1be","textSha256":"89b9d4987810a710c16f0f77cd713867fe6c2117f3d2adc095592413b6ebfcef"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1dc5cb830019d996e83032c1","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Initial misalignment, axion DM fraction and allowed late entropy dilution remain variable rather than fixed. Independent challenge qualification: Initial misalignment, axion DM fraction and allowed late entropy dilution remain variable."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1dc5cb830019d996e83032c1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4ca2ec1798c9460523d7233ec1f1fa8c7b160eaded860d494d76e43686f3e1be","q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507"],"scopeContentSha256":"fce7ab18ffc5b72fb3d62e68da96ba63d129b5966753ee5c648eb8c4918dfa62","contributionContentSha256":"fd10d17030c2d9337fb1907f2b3b98d44690d29deb1afd4e84556688c3c3f4ca","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:4ca2ec1798c9460523d7233ec1f1fa8c7b160eaded860d494d76e43686f3e1be","textSha256":"89b9d4987810a710c16f0f77cd713867fe6c2117f3d2adc095592413b6ebfcef"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1dc5cb830019d996e83032c1","recordId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Initial misalignment, axion DM fraction and allowed late entropy dilution remain variable rather than fixed.","challengeNote":"Initial misalignment, axion DM fraction and allowed late entropy dilution remain variable.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:56cece0d31db80712d6a47aa1327fb46031374d7bd22cdea16722f418cf74d2c","home":{"unitId":"unit:56cece0d31db80712d6a47aa1327fb46031374d7bd22cdea16722f418cf74d2c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:56cece0d31db80712d6a47aa1327fb46031374d7bd22cdea16722f418cf74d2c","paperId":"1806.06056","textSha256":"1198e88c565f5325a85968e6ec6940a0349f9658b13e7ce7f211ae835f38d68a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c86824676873338bc38f7941"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c86824676873338bc38f7941","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:56cece0d31db80712d6a47aa1327fb46031374d7bd22cdea16722f418cf74d2c","q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b"],"scopeContentSha256":"968b0788aa6f521e5fb1c3447aa97044480ddb3d54746c54c33ec77cabb94349","placementContentSha256":"9ee855ebffd355e8a259d6e9927f23f8a6ad4c34c10ccd6cffeca676ec5b4bad","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:56cece0d31db80712d6a47aa1327fb46031374d7bd22cdea16722f418cf74d2c","paperId":"1806.06056","textSha256":"1198e88c565f5325a85968e6ec6940a0349f9658b13e7ce7f211ae835f38d68a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c86824676873338bc38f7941"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:56cece0d31db80712d6a47aa1327fb46031374d7bd22cdea16722f418cf74d2c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:56cece0d31db80712d6a47aa1327fb46031374d7bd22cdea16722f418cf74d2c","textSha256":"1198e88c565f5325a85968e6ec6940a0349f9658b13e7ce7f211ae835f38d68a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b5e7996a3a723d86f5046f16","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: F-term and D-term models are alternatives; cosmic-string constraints are not automatically axion-string constraints. Independent challenge qualification: F-term and D-term models are alternatives; their cosmic-string constraints do not establish axion-string constraints."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b5e7996a3a723d86f5046f16","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:56cece0d31db80712d6a47aa1327fb46031374d7bd22cdea16722f418cf74d2c","q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507"],"scopeContentSha256":"fce7ab18ffc5b72fb3d62e68da96ba63d129b5966753ee5c648eb8c4918dfa62","contributionContentSha256":"cf385fdbf9735aa3ba55adc056640b956e1cf0fbc8be17fa449884ff74e00f85","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:56cece0d31db80712d6a47aa1327fb46031374d7bd22cdea16722f418cf74d2c","textSha256":"1198e88c565f5325a85968e6ec6940a0349f9658b13e7ce7f211ae835f38d68a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b5e7996a3a723d86f5046f16","recordId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"F-term and D-term models are alternatives; cosmic-string constraints are not automatically axion-string constraints.","challengeNote":"F-term and D-term models are alternatives; their cosmic-string constraints do not establish axion-string constraints.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:7a81eb485ea7aa5de921ecedf860452666796a511ea14e4c836a05418b44485a","home":{"unitId":"unit:7a81eb485ea7aa5de921ecedf860452666796a511ea14e4c836a05418b44485a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines microscopic origin and PQ quality with inflationary constraints, dark radiation and source-specific cosmic histories.","qualification":"q30 explicitly combines microscopic origin and quality with inflation, dark radiation and cosmic histories. This covers the complete LVS coexistence requirement, including reheating, without assuming its success.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7a81eb485ea7aa5de921ecedf860452666796a511ea14e4c836a05418b44485a","paperId":"2203.08833","textSha256":"6543b52478c3172725f032b0065391607f3efa4ffe45437d3543c3a86fc75c02"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0038:u18:q30"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0038:u18:q30","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7a81eb485ea7aa5de921ecedf860452666796a511ea14e4c836a05418b44485a","q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b"],"scopeContentSha256":"968b0788aa6f521e5fb1c3447aa97044480ddb3d54746c54c33ec77cabb94349","placementContentSha256":"996d69e1699aea94e5e40b43ed6698c67d7c765b6d4d9eba90d7da2ab87a68ee","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0038:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0038:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7a81eb485ea7aa5de921ecedf860452666796a511ea14e4c836a05418b44485a","paperId":"2203.08833","textSha256":"6543b52478c3172725f032b0065391607f3efa4ffe45437d3543c3a86fc75c02"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0038","unitRef":"u18"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7a81eb485ea7aa5de921ecedf860452666796a511ea14e4c836a05418b44485a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:7a81eb485ea7aa5de921ecedf860452666796a511ea14e4c836a05418b44485a","textSha256":"6543b52478c3172725f032b0065391607f3efa4ffe45437d3543c3a86fc75c02"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b1390cb60e37cfe0825215bd1e03f769","paperId":"2203.08833","sourceSha256":"55cbe1f194e37153dbfc27346b7cfdbd099ea44d7b417b609d261728023abd97","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c0b795a0ff0f73a2cd87/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7319b7f465d6f81c09375b62e7657f52236dc822b8f4e11de271ec9649a0dcfa","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"04b9a1ee9787252fc787438e52a91cda064f612a981282b901da6c4fee4cab22","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a3c705630a98f8cc4c5a97a1","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Joint LVS construction and cosmology target. Low inflation and Higgs/moduli/inflaton decay channels are model-specific; Higgs-mass fine-tuning enters the portal Independent challenge qualification: Joint LVS construction and cosmology. Low inflation, absence of axionic strings and decay channels are model-specific; Higgs-mass fine-tuning matters to th,"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a3c705630a98f8cc4c5a97a1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7a81eb485ea7aa5de921ecedf860452666796a511ea14e4c836a05418b44485a","q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507"],"scopeContentSha256":"fce7ab18ffc5b72fb3d62e68da96ba63d129b5966753ee5c648eb8c4918dfa62","contributionContentSha256":"92ecef507017aa6fa89247255c04ebafea72e09138ed98f9d106d95243a0d54e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:7a81eb485ea7aa5de921ecedf860452666796a511ea14e4c836a05418b44485a","textSha256":"6543b52478c3172725f032b0065391607f3efa4ffe45437d3543c3a86fc75c02"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b1390cb60e37cfe0825215bd1e03f769","paperId":"2203.08833","sourceSha256":"55cbe1f194e37153dbfc27346b7cfdbd099ea44d7b417b609d261728023abd97","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c0b795a0ff0f73a2cd87/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7319b7f465d6f81c09375b62e7657f52236dc822b8f4e11de271ec9649a0dcfa","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"04b9a1ee9787252fc787438e52a91cda064f612a981282b901da6c4fee4cab22","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a3c705630a98f8cc4c5a97a1","recordId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Joint LVS construction and cosmology target. Low inflation and Higgs/moduli/inflaton decay channels are model-specific; Higgs-mass fine-tuning enters the portal","challengeNote":"Joint LVS construction and cosmology. Low inflation, absence of axionic strings and decay channels are model-specific; Higgs-mass fine-tuning matters to th,","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:8c62bdd7cefa5e5b69efbb26ab01a0ad8e0eafdb48f786761fc272f814d4c237","home":{"unitId":"unit:8c62bdd7cefa5e5b69efbb26ab01a0ad8e0eafdb48f786761fc272f814d4c237","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8c62bdd7cefa5e5b69efbb26ab01a0ad8e0eafdb48f786761fc272f814d4c237","paperId":"2507.12519","textSha256":"f45c54da384488548306819029ff3280032a669e06d6e9f7a3ffafd265d1a74f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8eaa40c3a8e052098ddc9ff1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8eaa40c3a8e052098ddc9ff1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8c62bdd7cefa5e5b69efbb26ab01a0ad8e0eafdb48f786761fc272f814d4c237","q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b"],"scopeContentSha256":"968b0788aa6f521e5fb1c3447aa97044480ddb3d54746c54c33ec77cabb94349","placementContentSha256":"b471c6ca100e19b9425f478009c15fb17cb5d5d7b24fdfdb25c6c3f3bb5189c3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8c62bdd7cefa5e5b69efbb26ab01a0ad8e0eafdb48f786761fc272f814d4c237","paperId":"2507.12519","textSha256":"f45c54da384488548306819029ff3280032a669e06d6e9f7a3ffafd265d1a74f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8eaa40c3a8e052098ddc9ff1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8c62bdd7cefa5e5b69efbb26ab01a0ad8e0eafdb48f786761fc272f814d4c237","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:8c62bdd7cefa5e5b69efbb26ab01a0ad8e0eafdb48f786761fc272f814d4c237","textSha256":"f45c54da384488548306819029ff3280032a669e06d6e9f7a3ffafd265d1a74f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bbc3c4cee10f24334da6052d","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The switched contribution vanishes after inflation; the question still retains late QCD relaxation and misalignment. Independent challenge qualification: The switched contribution vanishes after inflation; the eventual QCD-generated mass and late relaxation remain part of the question."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:bbc3c4cee10f24334da6052d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8c62bdd7cefa5e5b69efbb26ab01a0ad8e0eafdb48f786761fc272f814d4c237","q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507"],"scopeContentSha256":"fce7ab18ffc5b72fb3d62e68da96ba63d129b5966753ee5c648eb8c4918dfa62","contributionContentSha256":"cf69352147206a66f8ca3fc3f23ca93ffd385101432c3ded3a441e575e4f0c9e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:8c62bdd7cefa5e5b69efbb26ab01a0ad8e0eafdb48f786761fc272f814d4c237","textSha256":"f45c54da384488548306819029ff3280032a669e06d6e9f7a3ffafd265d1a74f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bbc3c4cee10f24334da6052d","recordId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"The switched contribution vanishes after inflation; the question still retains late QCD relaxation and misalignment.","challengeNote":"The switched contribution vanishes after inflation; the eventual QCD-generated mass and late relaxation remain part of the question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:97c5b76d12951bc2b8730eb805d5ef856bfa89a341cf7d9680a1505194061807","home":{"unitId":"unit:97c5b76d12951bc2b8730eb805d5ef856bfa89a341cf7d9680a1505194061807","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:97c5b76d12951bc2b8730eb805d5ef856bfa89a341cf7d9680a1505194061807","paperId":"2606.17019","textSha256":"2c764408e8f464fa3cb0be276d74701e8a08cdb17e0d3d543094eb356808a917"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8540f89b11b5f8a0c48d89ae"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8540f89b11b5f8a0c48d89ae","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:97c5b76d12951bc2b8730eb805d5ef856bfa89a341cf7d9680a1505194061807","q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b"],"scopeContentSha256":"968b0788aa6f521e5fb1c3447aa97044480ddb3d54746c54c33ec77cabb94349","placementContentSha256":"e6162da7dda9d6c9124946f6db184be241b1fa080a77569999efa82bab5a70ed","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:97c5b76d12951bc2b8730eb805d5ef856bfa89a341cf7d9680a1505194061807","paperId":"2606.17019","textSha256":"2c764408e8f464fa3cb0be276d74701e8a08cdb17e0d3d543094eb356808a917"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8540f89b11b5f8a0c48d89ae"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:97c5b76d12951bc2b8730eb805d5ef856bfa89a341cf7d9680a1505194061807","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d53","kind":"description","unitIndex":53,"unitId":"unit:97c5b76d12951bc2b8730eb805d5ef856bfa89a341cf7d9680a1505194061807","textSha256":"2c764408e8f464fa3cb0be276d74701e8a08cdb17e0d3d543094eb356808a917"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b3ebbc1814af27e3e76f8ce1","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Pre-QCD runaway evolution with acceptable residual CP is distinct from an exactly switched-off mass. Independent challenge qualification: Pre-QCD runaway evolution permits a residual-CP test; it is distinct from a contribution stipulated to switch off exactly."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b3ebbc1814af27e3e76f8ce1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:97c5b76d12951bc2b8730eb805d5ef856bfa89a341cf7d9680a1505194061807","q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507"],"scopeContentSha256":"fce7ab18ffc5b72fb3d62e68da96ba63d129b5966753ee5c648eb8c4918dfa62","contributionContentSha256":"7e1e3fa28ace488d6517493d8ca23eb2245345383c99860b62618d0065bbb2bc","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d53","kind":"description","unitIndex":53,"unitId":"unit:97c5b76d12951bc2b8730eb805d5ef856bfa89a341cf7d9680a1505194061807","textSha256":"2c764408e8f464fa3cb0be276d74701e8a08cdb17e0d3d543094eb356808a917"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b3ebbc1814af27e3e76f8ce1","recordId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Pre-QCD runaway evolution with acceptable residual CP is distinct from an exactly switched-off mass.","challengeNote":"Pre-QCD runaway evolution permits a residual-CP test; it is distinct from a contribution stipulated to switch off exactly.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","home":{"unitId":"unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","paperId":"2603.28620","textSha256":"ef14b9eda88aaeb03ce6e75510cab072a0c2189d259328f8a1505f5ee883cc06"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:873df9cccf310ac57173454f36301da7","paperId":"2603.28620","sourceSha256":"0f886221062379ad596b96847b82311dad6b35435f682c48d0be0041dca27cac","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b766cfa1c38da8b2cb83/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"77e0b03326adbdd99b1a62bb7f4fcac40a2cb281eaa56dc9bfa46724a6b920a4","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"52c8106406a7d9b85a85bd9eb6943d3ce52b6b541988fc7eade4fc4a8167792e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d5a3d91143d87ff53ac9b56e75003960","paperId":"2603.28620","sourceSha256":"0f886221062379ad596b96847b82311dad6b35435f682c48d0be0041dca27cac","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b766cfa1c38da8b2cb83/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"77e0b03326adbdd99b1a62bb7f4fcac40a2cb281eaa56dc9bfa46724a6b920a4","pdfPage":1,"start":104,"end":3502,"textSha256":"a74b8121bbe1783c243d2c870302b27540cd73172981b54eeed9c816a11db49f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ed2125e9e103bde32b3afd71"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ed2125e9e103bde32b3afd71","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b"],"scopeContentSha256":"968b0788aa6f521e5fb1c3447aa97044480ddb3d54746c54c33ec77cabb94349","placementContentSha256":"5f18a680718a1e69ea14e8d90bb4bcb5e4d48d34fd08bc26876f734f8a799794","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","paperId":"2603.28620","textSha256":"ef14b9eda88aaeb03ce6e75510cab072a0c2189d259328f8a1505f5ee883cc06"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:873df9cccf310ac57173454f36301da7","paperId":"2603.28620","sourceSha256":"0f886221062379ad596b96847b82311dad6b35435f682c48d0be0041dca27cac","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b766cfa1c38da8b2cb83/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"77e0b03326adbdd99b1a62bb7f4fcac40a2cb281eaa56dc9bfa46724a6b920a4","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"52c8106406a7d9b85a85bd9eb6943d3ce52b6b541988fc7eade4fc4a8167792e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d5a3d91143d87ff53ac9b56e75003960","paperId":"2603.28620","sourceSha256":"0f886221062379ad596b96847b82311dad6b35435f682c48d0be0041dca27cac","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b766cfa1c38da8b2cb83/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"77e0b03326adbdd99b1a62bb7f4fcac40a2cb281eaa56dc9bfa46724a6b920a4","pdfPage":1,"start":104,"end":3502,"textSha256":"a74b8121bbe1783c243d2c870302b27540cd73172981b54eeed9c816a11db49f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ed2125e9e103bde32b3afd71"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d62","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","textSha256":"ef14b9eda88aaeb03ce6e75510cab072a0c2189d259328f8a1505f5ee883cc06"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:873df9cccf310ac57173454f36301da7","paperId":"2603.28620","sourceSha256":"0f886221062379ad596b96847b82311dad6b35435f682c48d0be0041dca27cac","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b766cfa1c38da8b2cb83/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"77e0b03326adbdd99b1a62bb7f4fcac40a2cb281eaa56dc9bfa46724a6b920a4","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"52c8106406a7d9b85a85bd9eb6943d3ce52b6b541988fc7eade4fc4a8167792e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d5a3d91143d87ff53ac9b56e75003960","paperId":"2603.28620","sourceSha256":"0f886221062379ad596b96847b82311dad6b35435f682c48d0be0041dca27cac","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b766cfa1c38da8b2cb83/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"77e0b03326adbdd99b1a62bb7f4fcac40a2cb281eaa56dc9bfa46724a6b920a4","pdfPage":1,"start":104,"end":3502,"textSha256":"a74b8121bbe1783c243d2c870302b27540cd73172981b54eeed9c816a11db49f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:adc33e5e3428c7311a8b115a","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Total or partial SU(5) confinement acts during inflation. KSVZ, DFSZ and gauge axions are alternatives; arbitrary-f_a viability is an announced conditional res Independent challenge qualification: Total or partial SU(5) confinement acts during inflation. KSVZ, DFSZ and gauge axions are alternatives; arbitrary-f_a viability is a conditional announced re,"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:adc33e5e3428c7311a8b115a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507"],"scopeContentSha256":"fce7ab18ffc5b72fb3d62e68da96ba63d129b5966753ee5c648eb8c4918dfa62","contributionContentSha256":"a2035bde70fdfc04f4550dfd4cbb618f287d417580c2ded684216ca933b6d321","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d62","kind":"description","unitIndex":62,"unitId":"unit:980e53f48312fbfa5056bdb6b67d3bc974a03d773e46a273f11645d4824ae688","textSha256":"ef14b9eda88aaeb03ce6e75510cab072a0c2189d259328f8a1505f5ee883cc06"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:873df9cccf310ac57173454f36301da7","paperId":"2603.28620","sourceSha256":"0f886221062379ad596b96847b82311dad6b35435f682c48d0be0041dca27cac","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b766cfa1c38da8b2cb83/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"77e0b03326adbdd99b1a62bb7f4fcac40a2cb281eaa56dc9bfa46724a6b920a4","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"52c8106406a7d9b85a85bd9eb6943d3ce52b6b541988fc7eade4fc4a8167792e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d5a3d91143d87ff53ac9b56e75003960","paperId":"2603.28620","sourceSha256":"0f886221062379ad596b96847b82311dad6b35435f682c48d0be0041dca27cac","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b766cfa1c38da8b2cb83/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"77e0b03326adbdd99b1a62bb7f4fcac40a2cb281eaa56dc9bfa46724a6b920a4","pdfPage":1,"start":104,"end":3502,"textSha256":"a74b8121bbe1783c243d2c870302b27540cd73172981b54eeed9c816a11db49f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:adc33e5e3428c7311a8b115a","recordId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Total or partial SU(5) confinement acts during inflation. KSVZ, DFSZ and gauge axions are alternatives; arbitrary-f_a viability is an announced conditional res","challengeNote":"Total or partial SU(5) confinement acts during inflation. KSVZ, DFSZ and gauge axions are alternatives; arbitrary-f_a viability is a conditional announced re,","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b122315e905fbf135ede87403ab70d33ec844357a55e58baf78416e30f77e05d","home":{"unitId":"unit:b122315e905fbf135ede87403ab70d33ec844357a55e58baf78416e30f77e05d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b122315e905fbf135ede87403ab70d33ec844357a55e58baf78416e30f77e05d","paperId":"1601.03049","textSha256":"4d410d8c14411afc4710458aaf726a5b58fa35077462f96b1733ffeabf88af26"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9ae48cebe428c437079b6fb5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9ae48cebe428c437079b6fb5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b122315e905fbf135ede87403ab70d33ec844357a55e58baf78416e30f77e05d","q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b"],"scopeContentSha256":"968b0788aa6f521e5fb1c3447aa97044480ddb3d54746c54c33ec77cabb94349","placementContentSha256":"5b747b123b6548dcaf218e3b3c7d68ab26d2c68412591bb55b882d6f296cc673","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b122315e905fbf135ede87403ab70d33ec844357a55e58baf78416e30f77e05d","paperId":"1601.03049","textSha256":"4d410d8c14411afc4710458aaf726a5b58fa35077462f96b1733ffeabf88af26"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9ae48cebe428c437079b6fb5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b122315e905fbf135ede87403ab70d33ec844357a55e58baf78416e30f77e05d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:b122315e905fbf135ede87403ab70d33ec844357a55e58baf78416e30f77e05d","textSha256":"4d410d8c14411afc4710458aaf726a5b58fa35077462f96b1733ffeabf88af26"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d11d3ec917fec563c984a0d0","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Inflationary PQ modifications are constrained jointly by later cosmology and preserved strong-CP cancellation. Independent challenge qualification: Inflationary PQ changes are constrained jointly by strong-CP cancellation and subsequent cosmology."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d11d3ec917fec563c984a0d0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b122315e905fbf135ede87403ab70d33ec844357a55e58baf78416e30f77e05d","q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507"],"scopeContentSha256":"fce7ab18ffc5b72fb3d62e68da96ba63d129b5966753ee5c648eb8c4918dfa62","contributionContentSha256":"fc78a84ae1406f18639738a99e467f9f916c9234dee67fbd6067d5d2cbf0f0d2","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:b122315e905fbf135ede87403ab70d33ec844357a55e58baf78416e30f77e05d","textSha256":"4d410d8c14411afc4710458aaf726a5b58fa35077462f96b1733ffeabf88af26"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d11d3ec917fec563c984a0d0","recordId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Inflationary PQ modifications are constrained jointly by later cosmology and preserved strong-CP cancellation.","challengeNote":"Inflationary PQ changes are constrained jointly by strong-CP cancellation and subsequent cosmology.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b771884dd2ab0bc8b96738c89402756d88a1be1f711e7fa60a0b37f41be2c0cc","home":{"unitId":"unit:b771884dd2ab0bc8b96738c89402756d88a1be1f711e7fa60a0b37f41be2c0cc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b771884dd2ab0bc8b96738c89402756d88a1be1f711e7fa60a0b37f41be2c0cc","paperId":"2411.00768","textSha256":"5516b1f78812ec5cda155b9aede6af1b9249f0c0f55b7b387010ed03d9ab439b"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d5e0b950185539a998de2e5d"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d5e0b950185539a998de2e5d","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b771884dd2ab0bc8b96738c89402756d88a1be1f711e7fa60a0b37f41be2c0cc","q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b"],"scopeContentSha256":"968b0788aa6f521e5fb1c3447aa97044480ddb3d54746c54c33ec77cabb94349","placementContentSha256":"a1cc179e0147b2f02d83845d030d5e5aa2b718ba43168f9cd599f2799b47c5e9","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b771884dd2ab0bc8b96738c89402756d88a1be1f711e7fa60a0b37f41be2c0cc","paperId":"2411.00768","textSha256":"5516b1f78812ec5cda155b9aede6af1b9249f0c0f55b7b387010ed03d9ab439b"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d5e0b950185539a998de2e5d"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b771884dd2ab0bc8b96738c89402756d88a1be1f711e7fa60a0b37f41be2c0cc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:b771884dd2ab0bc8b96738c89402756d88a1be1f711e7fa60a0b37f41be2c0cc","textSha256":"5516b1f78812ec5cda155b9aede6af1b9249f0c0f55b7b387010ed03d9ab439b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3f84bfab2d390abf022c82de","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound threshold, quality, mass and inflationary consequences of the stated large nonminimal scalar coupling. Independent challenge qualification: Removed pf12: changed masses from thresholds do not establish temporal potential evolution. Threshold, quality, mass and inflation targets remain compound."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3f84bfab2d390abf022c82de","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b771884dd2ab0bc8b96738c89402756d88a1be1f711e7fa60a0b37f41be2c0cc","q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507"],"scopeContentSha256":"fce7ab18ffc5b72fb3d62e68da96ba63d129b5966753ee5c648eb8c4918dfa62","contributionContentSha256":"c69063dd7abc2228527f932c0bb9c761be3c6316b3a601130d6e4ea4f4197109","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:b771884dd2ab0bc8b96738c89402756d88a1be1f711e7fa60a0b37f41be2c0cc","textSha256":"5516b1f78812ec5cda155b9aede6af1b9249f0c0f55b7b387010ed03d9ab439b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3f84bfab2d390abf022c82de","recordId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound threshold, quality, mass and inflationary consequences of the stated large nonminimal scalar coupling.","challengeNote":"Removed pf12: changed masses from thresholds do not establish temporal potential evolution. Threshold, quality, mass and inflation targets remain compound.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:cec1176f88da7ceabc0b9a0be73131e4c42e86f8443bc3d6dc655bc4728945b1","home":{"unitId":"unit:cec1176f88da7ceabc0b9a0be73131e4c42e86f8443bc3d6dc655bc4728945b1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cec1176f88da7ceabc0b9a0be73131e4c42e86f8443bc3d6dc655bc4728945b1","paperId":"1410.5045","textSha256":"f5eebeb59c37bf5efddb9e628a315ee5be227591c49b98cfbe0f155fafc7afb4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2e2d2567d55686e0b44d3550"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2e2d2567d55686e0b44d3550","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cec1176f88da7ceabc0b9a0be73131e4c42e86f8443bc3d6dc655bc4728945b1","q025-candidate-region:34301033e68b91e068723a3b"],"scopeContentSha256":"968b0788aa6f521e5fb1c3447aa97044480ddb3d54746c54c33ec77cabb94349","placementContentSha256":"190ee7c0762aed2a89721011336a9432d0d5f732b120200871763e798a63e702","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cec1176f88da7ceabc0b9a0be73131e4c42e86f8443bc3d6dc655bc4728945b1","paperId":"1410.5045","textSha256":"f5eebeb59c37bf5efddb9e628a315ee5be227591c49b98cfbe0f155fafc7afb4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2e2d2567d55686e0b44d3550"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cec1176f88da7ceabc0b9a0be73131e4c42e86f8443bc3d6dc655bc4728945b1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:cec1176f88da7ceabc0b9a0be73131e4c42e86f8443bc3d6dc655bc4728945b1","textSha256":"f5eebeb59c37bf5efddb9e628a315ee5be227591c49b98cfbe0f155fafc7afb4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:999461cc7260395d6863e14a","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound dark-energy, dark-matter and inflation targets; atomic fine identity is unresolved. Independent challenge qualification: Compound dark-energy, dark-matter and inflation targets; atomic identity remains unresolved."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:999461cc7260395d6863e14a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cec1176f88da7ceabc0b9a0be73131e4c42e86f8443bc3d6dc655bc4728945b1","q025-candidate-question:fde270461c42913454b20507"],"scopeContentSha256":"fce7ab18ffc5b72fb3d62e68da96ba63d129b5966753ee5c648eb8c4918dfa62","contributionContentSha256":"86f21d4b5cb8e2634aeefcfa1d84b65502010aeb7f34338d7f841a717a717be4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:cec1176f88da7ceabc0b9a0be73131e4c42e86f8443bc3d6dc655bc4728945b1","textSha256":"f5eebeb59c37bf5efddb9e628a315ee5be227591c49b98cfbe0f155fafc7afb4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:999461cc7260395d6863e14a","recordId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6ff2d3ccb5814b03bac3-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound dark-energy, dark-matter and inflation targets; atomic fine identity is unresolved.","challengeNote":"Compound dark-energy, dark-matter and inflation targets; atomic identity remains unresolved.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":10,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"86dc655a652ac332bf6c13965c283e33270bc5c207fbb50dbaeb1c344b0dfa9d"},"organizational-access:1cd70c2880eab81b21db0b53":{"id":"organizational-access:1cd70c2880eab81b21db0b53","source":"q025-candidate-region:402b72881561aec06577ac84","target":"q025-candidate-question:b1eba9143531ae9fa14f21e1","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:402b72881561aec06577ac84","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"4151f53e47a670b4af586bce9b29750b32a9c742114bf0760c865f143857f97f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e4db761e23064fe7665d6cce"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:b1eba9143531ae9fa14f21e1","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"584ecddda07c98f9d9042183fe32f21ad3109bd71dac58d9906e3959e18dfe02","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:52c5539ffcf7e68a2f674479"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:7d71ca50bec29ede4a61a967aa3e210fba184e5d48c34bb5d3293922c00f992e","home":{"unitId":"unit:7d71ca50bec29ede4a61a967aa3e210fba184e5d48c34bb5d3293922c00f992e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:402b72881561aec06577ac84","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7d71ca50bec29ede4a61a967aa3e210fba184e5d48c34bb5d3293922c00f992e","paperId":"2409.06488","textSha256":"90b9d8f2751aa72b3b64cff5ebcf279191a419e314bd80fd9ee9b2284616a4a6"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:01814801f3475fd3794f22ef"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:01814801f3475fd3794f22ef","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7d71ca50bec29ede4a61a967aa3e210fba184e5d48c34bb5d3293922c00f992e","q025-candidate-region:402b72881561aec06577ac84"],"scopeContentSha256":"4151f53e47a670b4af586bce9b29750b32a9c742114bf0760c865f143857f97f","placementContentSha256":"3309b5b6def5903a210e8727dd196bf3a979a8f8a4a107d0b2300c44a6ac4531","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge","leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7d71ca50bec29ede4a61a967aa3e210fba184e5d48c34bb5d3293922c00f992e","paperId":"2409.06488","textSha256":"90b9d8f2751aa72b3b64cff5ebcf279191a419e314bd80fd9ee9b2284616a4a6"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:01814801f3475fd3794f22ef"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7d71ca50bec29ede4a61a967aa3e210fba184e5d48c34bb5d3293922c00f992e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b1eba9143531ae9fa14f21e1","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:7d71ca50bec29ede4a61a967aa3e210fba184e5d48c34bb5d3293922c00f992e","textSha256":"90b9d8f2751aa72b3b64cff5ebcf279191a419e314bd80fd9ee9b2284616a4a6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1644fdc5d062003c4cce1b4e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1644fdc5d062003c4cce1b4e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7d71ca50bec29ede4a61a967aa3e210fba184e5d48c34bb5d3293922c00f992e","q025-candidate-question:b1eba9143531ae9fa14f21e1"],"scopeContentSha256":"584ecddda07c98f9d9042183fe32f21ad3109bd71dac58d9906e3959e18dfe02","contributionContentSha256":"171978e247eff874b415b307dabe4fd28e4db83f618251083d44ea17a6daea87","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-proposal","leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:7d71ca50bec29ede4a61a967aa3e210fba184e5d48c34bb5d3293922c00f992e","textSha256":"90b9d8f2751aa72b3b64cff5ebcf279191a419e314bd80fd9ee9b2284616a4a6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1644fdc5d062003c4cce1b4e","recordId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The named conjectures are distinct tests, not one interchangeable restriction.","challengeNote":"The named conjectures remain distinct tests within a comparative source scope.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a63ac6afd1ba332c9df94c36b756b64c9974a872518bd2173bb659bd3bad8077","home":{"unitId":"unit:a63ac6afd1ba332c9df94c36b756b64c9974a872518bd2173bb659bd3bad8077","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:402b72881561aec06577ac84","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a63ac6afd1ba332c9df94c36b756b64c9974a872518bd2173bb659bd3bad8077","paperId":"2101.00497","textSha256":"a86ed6c6ef172751427905790be463fae26aaae3a6708f65cc003fa902cd3835"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:82b1f16a6235f6ce458dccb7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:82b1f16a6235f6ce458dccb7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a63ac6afd1ba332c9df94c36b756b64c9974a872518bd2173bb659bd3bad8077","q025-candidate-region:402b72881561aec06577ac84"],"scopeContentSha256":"4151f53e47a670b4af586bce9b29750b32a9c742114bf0760c865f143857f97f","placementContentSha256":"4ef3e6f763da663cf059da1b2ef0515392ab173c11908414a0b285a4d21bb75d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge","leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a63ac6afd1ba332c9df94c36b756b64c9974a872518bd2173bb659bd3bad8077","paperId":"2101.00497","textSha256":"a86ed6c6ef172751427905790be463fae26aaae3a6708f65cc003fa902cd3835"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:82b1f16a6235f6ce458dccb7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a63ac6afd1ba332c9df94c36b756b64c9974a872518bd2173bb659bd3bad8077","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b1eba9143531ae9fa14f21e1","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:a63ac6afd1ba332c9df94c36b756b64c9974a872518bd2173bb659bd3bad8077","textSha256":"a86ed6c6ef172751427905790be463fae26aaae3a6708f65cc003fa902cd3835"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cb9f08b68b79acf9e73b4883"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:cb9f08b68b79acf9e73b4883","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a63ac6afd1ba332c9df94c36b756b64c9974a872518bd2173bb659bd3bad8077","q025-candidate-question:b1eba9143531ae9fa14f21e1"],"scopeContentSha256":"584ecddda07c98f9d9042183fe32f21ad3109bd71dac58d9906e3959e18dfe02","contributionContentSha256":"00bc5a13a8c00ba5254e85a577397b866fca66e33c31f3208499afde8019c216","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-proposal","leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:a63ac6afd1ba332c9df94c36b756b64c9974a872518bd2173bb659bd3bad8077","textSha256":"a86ed6c6ef172751427905790be463fae26aaae3a6708f65cc003fa902cd3835"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cb9f08b68b79acf9e73b4883","recordId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f5115054547406cde63efc051c4fe033f61145476fc748b9edebce6f098a4467","home":{"unitId":"unit:f5115054547406cde63efc051c4fe033f61145476fc748b9edebce6f098a4467","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:402b72881561aec06577ac84","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f5115054547406cde63efc051c4fe033f61145476fc748b9edebce6f098a4467","paperId":"1008.0603","textSha256":"8a22fb53888b552f50c50a6b7c092cac9768309d2793ceeb88341cac49c3eca0"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8cb5974b5f7233e1bcdbf2ed"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8cb5974b5f7233e1bcdbf2ed","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f5115054547406cde63efc051c4fe033f61145476fc748b9edebce6f098a4467","q025-candidate-region:402b72881561aec06577ac84"],"scopeContentSha256":"4151f53e47a670b4af586bce9b29750b32a9c742114bf0760c865f143857f97f","placementContentSha256":"6aaffe34d51ce029d2d0f5d0e48436d035c06d75194a611524c2433be1984bda","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge","leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f5115054547406cde63efc051c4fe033f61145476fc748b9edebce6f098a4467","paperId":"1008.0603","textSha256":"8a22fb53888b552f50c50a6b7c092cac9768309d2793ceeb88341cac49c3eca0"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8cb5974b5f7233e1bcdbf2ed"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f5115054547406cde63efc051c4fe033f61145476fc748b9edebce6f098a4467","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b1eba9143531ae9fa14f21e1","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:f5115054547406cde63efc051c4fe033f61145476fc748b9edebce6f098a4467","textSha256":"8a22fb53888b552f50c50a6b7c092cac9768309d2793ceeb88341cac49c3eca0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1234baf4a46956109552ff21"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1234baf4a46956109552ff21","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f5115054547406cde63efc051c4fe033f61145476fc748b9edebce6f098a4467","q025-candidate-question:b1eba9143531ae9fa14f21e1"],"scopeContentSha256":"584ecddda07c98f9d9042183fe32f21ad3109bd71dac58d9906e3959e18dfe02","contributionContentSha256":"dd63e370c09aa9f9baca40bcabea1be2113cb2733393588bc352e824900846e9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-proposal","leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:f5115054547406cde63efc051c4fe033f61145476fc748b9edebce6f098a4467","textSha256":"8a22fb53888b552f50c50a6b7c092cac9768309d2793ceeb88341cac49c3eca0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1234baf4a46956109552ff21","recordId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f8947c2aa8f1d177da2a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Ordinary inflationary work is eligible. Dynamics, fluctuations and NEC stability remain linked but distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Ordinary inflationary work remains eligible. Dynamics, fluctuations and NEC stability form a compound source scope whose atomicity remains for reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"f05ab8831078fb97638e514a34f303d1bf582eb59ac2d6098dcad9b25ca3d005"},"organizational-access:c6df792c3173220b1c086e24":{"id":"organizational-access:c6df792c3173220b1c086e24","source":"q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820","target":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"d33dc1c9c7954e7517020455639b32f2f4707e5e1057c3ac46f189c22223a874","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:10004b08d2d954c767db634b"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"76c5d082026fd9a0d47bd5d09cd42348561556f627fab562e3c50e192dff0d48","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:eaf78bb6aa276acc50291c73"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:2f40897ce40985f0aed53d57525957da134aa1fab861226daa0e1fd329150f77","home":{"unitId":"unit:2f40897ce40985f0aed53d57525957da134aa1fab861226daa0e1fd329150f77","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2f40897ce40985f0aed53d57525957da134aa1fab861226daa0e1fd329150f77","paperId":"2209.04705","textSha256":"218bf7ca898ac2c8a3d4eb6b36282e5f1365c406ab233cf16fb9a0c91da88143"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ecda9a4fdd1658c19bf5ff7a"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ecda9a4fdd1658c19bf5ff7a","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2f40897ce40985f0aed53d57525957da134aa1fab861226daa0e1fd329150f77","q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820"],"scopeContentSha256":"d33dc1c9c7954e7517020455639b32f2f4707e5e1057c3ac46f189c22223a874","placementContentSha256":"d367e6e587f45cc3415deef9ecdfadd6e695e6a93b875803221b98491ea425d6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2f40897ce40985f0aed53d57525957da134aa1fab861226daa0e1fd329150f77","paperId":"2209.04705","textSha256":"218bf7ca898ac2c8a3d4eb6b36282e5f1365c406ab233cf16fb9a0c91da88143"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ecda9a4fdd1658c19bf5ff7a"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2f40897ce40985f0aed53d57525957da134aa1fab861226daa0e1fd329150f77","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:2f40897ce40985f0aed53d57525957da134aa1fab861226daa0e1fd329150f77","textSha256":"218bf7ca898ac2c8a3d4eb6b36282e5f1365c406ab233cf16fb9a0c91da88143"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:18d3a4f7098e1e6400786b42","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound source-era R_D(*) and muon targets with unification, perturbativity and proton constraints. Independent challenge qualification: The source-era R_D(*) and muon targets are tested jointly with unification, perturbativity and proton stability."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:18d3a4f7098e1e6400786b42","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2f40897ce40985f0aed53d57525957da134aa1fab861226daa0e1fd329150f77","q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9"],"scopeContentSha256":"76c5d082026fd9a0d47bd5d09cd42348561556f627fab562e3c50e192dff0d48","contributionContentSha256":"648807b26ac33c617d36316bc6fc17cac3e1cd0f8e187cc7b93a018ddee910eb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:2f40897ce40985f0aed53d57525957da134aa1fab861226daa0e1fd329150f77","textSha256":"218bf7ca898ac2c8a3d4eb6b36282e5f1365c406ab233cf16fb9a0c91da88143"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:18d3a4f7098e1e6400786b42","recordId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound source-era R_D(*) and muon targets with unification, perturbativity and proton constraints.","challengeNote":"The source-era R_D(*) and muon targets are tested jointly with unification, perturbativity and proton stability.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:4985c89fa8231b69b28c956e89653144a04b68f69420d5fe8edbd8c9af260cac","home":{"unitId":"unit:4985c89fa8231b69b28c956e89653144a04b68f69420d5fe8edbd8c9af260cac","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Jointly covers flavour suppression, anomaly consistency, proton protection and neutrino mechanisms in higher-dimensional particle models.","qualification":"q27 jointly covers the flavour, anomaly and protection requirements in a low-string-scale higher-dimensional construction. q6 identifies the FCNC target but does not explicitly cover both preserved protections as part of the full compatibility question.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4985c89fa8231b69b28c956e89653144a04b68f69420d5fe8edbd8c9af260cac","paperId":"hep-th/9902080","textSha256":"fd16b80b519fdc580f6a01027220253f483b50c616a787bc2b2329aff635bbaa"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0049:u5:q27"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0049:u5:q27","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4985c89fa8231b69b28c956e89653144a04b68f69420d5fe8edbd8c9af260cac","q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820"],"scopeContentSha256":"d33dc1c9c7954e7517020455639b32f2f4707e5e1057c3ac46f189c22223a874","placementContentSha256":"e13f8ab6a5fa0b9a0fed6ff6825443f43fadd85b400f108d0f0dfc2a5c833f04","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0049:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0049:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4985c89fa8231b69b28c956e89653144a04b68f69420d5fe8edbd8c9af260cac","paperId":"hep-th/9902080","textSha256":"fd16b80b519fdc580f6a01027220253f483b50c616a787bc2b2329aff635bbaa"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0049","unitRef":"u5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4985c89fa8231b69b28c956e89653144a04b68f69420d5fe8edbd8c9af260cac","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:4985c89fa8231b69b28c956e89653144a04b68f69420d5fe8edbd8c9af260cac","textSha256":"fd16b80b519fdc580f6a01027220253f483b50c616a787bc2b2329aff635bbaa"},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:835dd730ef007bfd61a4171e4c6008c0","paperId":"hep-th/9902080","sourceSha256":"c6275b42fa1a2303742dc6c2b3575adc3f671e8ce5c35af624fb450c511b9fa3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48b96349d3ac8ae016d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"72f72806fcf63e66c790bc02c7899a4b9d13e891f351e9a17fe914ebb249bf08","pdfPage":6,"start":96,"end":3493,"textSha256":"4865753a3469c572a842b5cb0933e7bb37b8a029d81a6d9e76afd526e3e542d7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a032a00127bbc755c3308718f37fa8c0","paperId":"hep-th/9902080","sourceSha256":"c6275b42fa1a2303742dc6c2b3575adc3f671e8ce5c35af624fb450c511b9fa3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48b96349d3ac8ae016d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"72f72806fcf63e66c790bc02c7899a4b9d13e891f351e9a17fe914ebb249bf08","pdfPage":4,"start":98,"end":3496,"textSha256":"40b04843d81a95b2c58c95a82f113ea8c318086240610c407a378bd853bbefaa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c2e9208b0c6428ca6e469cb5353e4a01","paperId":"hep-th/9902080","sourceSha256":"c6275b42fa1a2303742dc6c2b3575adc3f671e8ce5c35af624fb450c511b9fa3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48b96349d3ac8ae016d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"72f72806fcf63e66c790bc02c7899a4b9d13e891f351e9a17fe914ebb249bf08","pdfPage":6,"start":1294,"end":3714,"textSha256":"825e2ce67c58dbab9bd89f3bdb9466a83118527442f1ef8548e89a34fe7db683","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:50b010b8674a0688716c57de","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The new target is FCNC suppression while preserving existing proton and neutrino protections. Independent challenge qualification: FCNC suppression is the new target. Existing proton/neutrino protection is preserved; the stated solution requires bulk flavons and at least two large transvers"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:50b010b8674a0688716c57de","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4985c89fa8231b69b28c956e89653144a04b68f69420d5fe8edbd8c9af260cac","q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9"],"scopeContentSha256":"76c5d082026fd9a0d47bd5d09cd42348561556f627fab562e3c50e192dff0d48","contributionContentSha256":"d30836f9927259ff37431e78a648f28b1f49acd3c32b4a1e264ca54f32a60e24","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:4985c89fa8231b69b28c956e89653144a04b68f69420d5fe8edbd8c9af260cac","textSha256":"fd16b80b519fdc580f6a01027220253f483b50c616a787bc2b2329aff635bbaa"},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:835dd730ef007bfd61a4171e4c6008c0","paperId":"hep-th/9902080","sourceSha256":"c6275b42fa1a2303742dc6c2b3575adc3f671e8ce5c35af624fb450c511b9fa3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48b96349d3ac8ae016d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"72f72806fcf63e66c790bc02c7899a4b9d13e891f351e9a17fe914ebb249bf08","pdfPage":6,"start":96,"end":3493,"textSha256":"4865753a3469c572a842b5cb0933e7bb37b8a029d81a6d9e76afd526e3e542d7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a032a00127bbc755c3308718f37fa8c0","paperId":"hep-th/9902080","sourceSha256":"c6275b42fa1a2303742dc6c2b3575adc3f671e8ce5c35af624fb450c511b9fa3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48b96349d3ac8ae016d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"72f72806fcf63e66c790bc02c7899a4b9d13e891f351e9a17fe914ebb249bf08","pdfPage":4,"start":98,"end":3496,"textSha256":"40b04843d81a95b2c58c95a82f113ea8c318086240610c407a378bd853bbefaa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c2e9208b0c6428ca6e469cb5353e4a01","paperId":"hep-th/9902080","sourceSha256":"c6275b42fa1a2303742dc6c2b3575adc3f671e8ce5c35af624fb450c511b9fa3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48b96349d3ac8ae016d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"72f72806fcf63e66c790bc02c7899a4b9d13e891f351e9a17fe914ebb249bf08","pdfPage":6,"start":1294,"end":3714,"textSha256":"825e2ce67c58dbab9bd89f3bdb9466a83118527442f1ef8548e89a34fe7db683","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:50b010b8674a0688716c57de","recordId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The new target is FCNC suppression while preserving existing proton and neutrino protections.","challengeNote":"FCNC suppression is the new target. Existing proton/neutrino protection is preserved; the stated solution requires bulk flavons and at least two large transvers","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:58f0248166912206ea1fd983aa0a1b4c564260a6586236766dc708392d9011d6","home":{"unitId":"unit:58f0248166912206ea1fd983aa0a1b4c564260a6586236766dc708392d9011d6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Includes dynamical alternatives and combines fermion-property generation with flavour suppression and testability.","qualification":"q27 includes dynamical alternatives and the combined fermion-property, suppression and phenomenological requirements. q20 principally covers flavour structure, while q6 principally covers unwanted transitions and signals; neither narrower definition explicitly covers the entire combination.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:58f0248166912206ea1fd983aa0a1b4c564260a6586236766dc708392d9011d6","paperId":"2607.18382","textSha256":"541eeeae0f16de1715f5d935c99ebed7c48a4d833454466b596a28f65c07975c"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0049:u3:q27"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0049:u3:q27","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:58f0248166912206ea1fd983aa0a1b4c564260a6586236766dc708392d9011d6","q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820"],"scopeContentSha256":"d33dc1c9c7954e7517020455639b32f2f4707e5e1057c3ac46f189c22223a874","placementContentSha256":"f6d13ff8ce78b2b3aa1b7b36f71729e516a40e9be01ea23d2df5725e666a714f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0049:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0049:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:58f0248166912206ea1fd983aa0a1b4c564260a6586236766dc708392d9011d6","paperId":"2607.18382","textSha256":"541eeeae0f16de1715f5d935c99ebed7c48a4d833454466b596a28f65c07975c"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0049","unitRef":"u3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:58f0248166912206ea1fd983aa0a1b4c564260a6586236766dc708392d9011d6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:58f0248166912206ea1fd983aa0a1b4c564260a6586236766dc708392d9011d6","textSha256":"541eeeae0f16de1715f5d935c99ebed7c48a4d833454466b596a28f65c07975c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1aa02459433f6e39871cc740","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Explicit symmetry protection is absent; retain the dynamical alternative without adding a symmetry premise. Independent challenge qualification: Absence of explicit symmetry protection is retained as part of the proposed dynamical alternative."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1aa02459433f6e39871cc740","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:58f0248166912206ea1fd983aa0a1b4c564260a6586236766dc708392d9011d6","q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9"],"scopeContentSha256":"76c5d082026fd9a0d47bd5d09cd42348561556f627fab562e3c50e192dff0d48","contributionContentSha256":"4eb3accc533147ca7ae60f4271cf47d8c38663467360df2fdd69aa35fb08d61e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:58f0248166912206ea1fd983aa0a1b4c564260a6586236766dc708392d9011d6","textSha256":"541eeeae0f16de1715f5d935c99ebed7c48a4d833454466b596a28f65c07975c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1aa02459433f6e39871cc740","recordId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Explicit symmetry protection is absent; retain the dynamical alternative without adding a symmetry premise.","challengeNote":"Absence of explicit symmetry protection is retained as part of the proposed dynamical alternative.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:92ddde398de33b59a195fa2a0fd7d3822950e3499a971b7ae2bee7735b39d70c","home":{"unitId":"unit:92ddde398de33b59a195fa2a0fd7d3822950e3499a971b7ae2bee7735b39d70c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:92ddde398de33b59a195fa2a0fd7d3822950e3499a971b7ae2bee7735b39d70c","paperId":"1211.5560","textSha256":"69ad15deeda01d7b5cd12afe9cf3c87bd221793c892d56bd891351ecf7c1431f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bdf855b15204bde8bc31e4a0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bdf855b15204bde8bc31e4a0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:92ddde398de33b59a195fa2a0fd7d3822950e3499a971b7ae2bee7735b39d70c","q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820"],"scopeContentSha256":"d33dc1c9c7954e7517020455639b32f2f4707e5e1057c3ac46f189c22223a874","placementContentSha256":"8e32c0172a63b60776c276695dc679de808bb3ed3de5c57e4a2c8c2ba8fef7ca","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:92ddde398de33b59a195fa2a0fd7d3822950e3499a971b7ae2bee7735b39d70c","paperId":"1211.5560","textSha256":"69ad15deeda01d7b5cd12afe9cf3c87bd221793c892d56bd891351ecf7c1431f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bdf855b15204bde8bc31e4a0"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:92ddde398de33b59a195fa2a0fd7d3822950e3499a971b7ae2bee7735b39d70c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:92ddde398de33b59a195fa2a0fd7d3822950e3499a971b7ae2bee7735b39d70c","textSha256":"69ad15deeda01d7b5cd12afe9cf3c87bd221793c892d56bd891351ecf7c1431f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:07a42e0c13f86bd99a5c5f10","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:07a42e0c13f86bd99a5c5f10","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:92ddde398de33b59a195fa2a0fd7d3822950e3499a971b7ae2bee7735b39d70c","q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9"],"scopeContentSha256":"76c5d082026fd9a0d47bd5d09cd42348561556f627fab562e3c50e192dff0d48","contributionContentSha256":"073edeb760b12fd8ef725045b9b34ccf69e74ebfb8b728a6e4d2760d827d90ad","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:92ddde398de33b59a195fa2a0fd7d3822950e3499a971b7ae2bee7735b39d70c","textSha256":"69ad15deeda01d7b5cd12afe9cf3c87bd221793c892d56bd891351ecf7c1431f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:07a42e0c13f86bd99a5c5f10","recordId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a73f05de86b9bbd556c6838740af716b6069e20ee9380818ef33127c30345760","home":{"unitId":"unit:a73f05de86b9bbd556c6838740af716b6069e20ee9380818ef33127c30345760","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a73f05de86b9bbd556c6838740af716b6069e20ee9380818ef33127c30345760","paperId":"2007.15016","textSha256":"4486cd4eac1a6d9087f79e4e03c092b4364aa818e0d7b18d71b147b3ac3f6983"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d793a395eddf286f88480a68"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d793a395eddf286f88480a68","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a73f05de86b9bbd556c6838740af716b6069e20ee9380818ef33127c30345760","q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820"],"scopeContentSha256":"d33dc1c9c7954e7517020455639b32f2f4707e5e1057c3ac46f189c22223a874","placementContentSha256":"4641d8487a0875c77aab5b0cb818e223be16a37a76358cc79bae61e58139f76e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a73f05de86b9bbd556c6838740af716b6069e20ee9380818ef33127c30345760","paperId":"2007.15016","textSha256":"4486cd4eac1a6d9087f79e4e03c092b4364aa818e0d7b18d71b147b3ac3f6983"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d793a395eddf286f88480a68"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a73f05de86b9bbd556c6838740af716b6069e20ee9380818ef33127c30345760","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:a73f05de86b9bbd556c6838740af716b6069e20ee9380818ef33127c30345760","textSha256":"4486cd4eac1a6d9087f79e4e03c092b4364aa818e0d7b18d71b147b3ac3f6983"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1ebb3a72c477ce0026d03153","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound source-era B fit, proton/flavour protection and scalar-mass decoupling tests. Independent challenge qualification: Source-era B anomalies, proton/flavour protection and scalar-mass decoupling remain distinct tests within the source question."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1ebb3a72c477ce0026d03153","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a73f05de86b9bbd556c6838740af716b6069e20ee9380818ef33127c30345760","q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9"],"scopeContentSha256":"76c5d082026fd9a0d47bd5d09cd42348561556f627fab562e3c50e192dff0d48","contributionContentSha256":"e9b11994bc24bdc361764bcf636abb0e329d8898d0051d50c732d42d89c73a70","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:a73f05de86b9bbd556c6838740af716b6069e20ee9380818ef33127c30345760","textSha256":"4486cd4eac1a6d9087f79e4e03c092b4364aa818e0d7b18d71b147b3ac3f6983"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1ebb3a72c477ce0026d03153","recordId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound source-era B fit, proton/flavour protection and scalar-mass decoupling tests.","challengeNote":"Source-era B anomalies, proton/flavour protection and scalar-mass decoupling remain distinct tests within the source question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b3fe97ce3b8f2cefa969015225420b6e1cd4ef763dafd872c525a99d20ef2d55","home":{"unitId":"unit:b3fe97ce3b8f2cefa969015225420b6e1cd4ef763dafd872c525a99d20ef2d55","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b3fe97ce3b8f2cefa969015225420b6e1cd4ef763dafd872c525a99d20ef2d55","paperId":"2412.00196","textSha256":"6be732dafe7d62f9be0ef6c0f857b9ae2c7274276905cf89f2a45ab98c53fb2d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:83d8d352f12ed17cfff80685"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:83d8d352f12ed17cfff80685","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b3fe97ce3b8f2cefa969015225420b6e1cd4ef763dafd872c525a99d20ef2d55","q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820"],"scopeContentSha256":"d33dc1c9c7954e7517020455639b32f2f4707e5e1057c3ac46f189c22223a874","placementContentSha256":"21b50bd380d3259e4a5ecf0e38f171873ec74cd06cf6065ae2e8defe6ad084a1","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b3fe97ce3b8f2cefa969015225420b6e1cd4ef763dafd872c525a99d20ef2d55","paperId":"2412.00196","textSha256":"6be732dafe7d62f9be0ef6c0f857b9ae2c7274276905cf89f2a45ab98c53fb2d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:83d8d352f12ed17cfff80685"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b3fe97ce3b8f2cefa969015225420b6e1cd4ef763dafd872c525a99d20ef2d55","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:b3fe97ce3b8f2cefa969015225420b6e1cd4ef763dafd872c525a99d20ef2d55","textSha256":"6be732dafe7d62f9be0ef6c0f857b9ae2c7274276905cf89f2a45ab98c53fb2d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:03975fc3c3343d3054c01440","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Electroweak scalars, flavour effects and proton branching ratios are linked but distinct tests. Independent challenge qualification: Branching-ratio correlations give a boundary contribution to p0. Replace pf9 with f0; the description does not specify proton protection."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:03975fc3c3343d3054c01440","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b3fe97ce3b8f2cefa969015225420b6e1cd4ef763dafd872c525a99d20ef2d55","q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9"],"scopeContentSha256":"76c5d082026fd9a0d47bd5d09cd42348561556f627fab562e3c50e192dff0d48","contributionContentSha256":"5418759d1978e0e6f36a91f048fb67321947dbb78be32e193d23360bf9c869f3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d22","kind":"description","unitIndex":22,"unitId":"unit:b3fe97ce3b8f2cefa969015225420b6e1cd4ef763dafd872c525a99d20ef2d55","textSha256":"6be732dafe7d62f9be0ef6c0f857b9ae2c7274276905cf89f2a45ab98c53fb2d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:03975fc3c3343d3054c01440","recordId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Electroweak scalars, flavour effects and proton branching ratios are linked but distinct tests.","challengeNote":"Branching-ratio correlations give a boundary contribution to p0. Replace pf9 with f0; the description does not specify proton protection.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b604821725804734b597284dab5fdbcfd4f268cd6eff23e3403e25c8f6624094","home":{"unitId":"unit:b604821725804734b597284dab5fdbcfd4f268cd6eff23e3403e25c8f6624094","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b604821725804734b597284dab5fdbcfd4f268cd6eff23e3403e25c8f6624094","paperId":"hep-ph/0010144","textSha256":"16f09770adc51e86f20046c74ba8a34d529eeccca736453695516568611510c8"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5f2c3a83d110af7a3f98025fdbbfc8c1","paperId":"hep-ph/0010144","sourceSha256":"ee38bf7bb1c54f79a3984b59245baee1934184df8e1889ae55578f75274db652","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a627cdd9e69a96606469/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4e56e07e5171ff1c85ec26ab715efed31ffd1ec430d4657f1b29b7083f4380f0","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a1a326436025f4e2302942b0267f2144e9800e35346b302ebc511ee33b7bb486","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7d0fce83f3b8ab2900747169f80b70e5","paperId":"hep-ph/0010144","sourceSha256":"ee38bf7bb1c54f79a3984b59245baee1934184df8e1889ae55578f75274db652","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a627cdd9e69a96606469/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4e56e07e5171ff1c85ec26ab715efed31ffd1ec430d4657f1b29b7083f4380f0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2275,"textSha256":"d750dc74d10f5e3095de61a374b7cafdbc63641386fe47768e81fe53c420a8db","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05a41717d027c224998e2942"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05a41717d027c224998e2942","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b604821725804734b597284dab5fdbcfd4f268cd6eff23e3403e25c8f6624094","q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820"],"scopeContentSha256":"d33dc1c9c7954e7517020455639b32f2f4707e5e1057c3ac46f189c22223a874","placementContentSha256":"8bdfbf43cae8719531cf1a323a7c19766f120c371392134dfb2079e34ca96ad7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b604821725804734b597284dab5fdbcfd4f268cd6eff23e3403e25c8f6624094","paperId":"hep-ph/0010144","textSha256":"16f09770adc51e86f20046c74ba8a34d529eeccca736453695516568611510c8"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5f2c3a83d110af7a3f98025fdbbfc8c1","paperId":"hep-ph/0010144","sourceSha256":"ee38bf7bb1c54f79a3984b59245baee1934184df8e1889ae55578f75274db652","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a627cdd9e69a96606469/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4e56e07e5171ff1c85ec26ab715efed31ffd1ec430d4657f1b29b7083f4380f0","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a1a326436025f4e2302942b0267f2144e9800e35346b302ebc511ee33b7bb486","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7d0fce83f3b8ab2900747169f80b70e5","paperId":"hep-ph/0010144","sourceSha256":"ee38bf7bb1c54f79a3984b59245baee1934184df8e1889ae55578f75274db652","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a627cdd9e69a96606469/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4e56e07e5171ff1c85ec26ab715efed31ffd1ec430d4657f1b29b7083f4380f0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2275,"textSha256":"d750dc74d10f5e3095de61a374b7cafdbc63641386fe47768e81fe53c420a8db","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05a41717d027c224998e2942"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b604821725804734b597284dab5fdbcfd4f268cd6eff23e3403e25c8f6624094","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:b604821725804734b597284dab5fdbcfd4f268cd6eff23e3403e25c8f6624094","textSha256":"16f09770adc51e86f20046c74ba8a34d529eeccca736453695516568611510c8"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5f2c3a83d110af7a3f98025fdbbfc8c1","paperId":"hep-ph/0010144","sourceSha256":"ee38bf7bb1c54f79a3984b59245baee1934184df8e1889ae55578f75274db652","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a627cdd9e69a96606469/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4e56e07e5171ff1c85ec26ab715efed31ffd1ec430d4657f1b29b7083f4380f0","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a1a326436025f4e2302942b0267f2144e9800e35346b302ebc511ee33b7bb486","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7d0fce83f3b8ab2900747169f80b70e5","paperId":"hep-ph/0010144","sourceSha256":"ee38bf7bb1c54f79a3984b59245baee1934184df8e1889ae55578f75274db652","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a627cdd9e69a96606469/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4e56e07e5171ff1c85ec26ab715efed31ffd1ec430d4657f1b29b7083f4380f0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2275,"textSha256":"d750dc74d10f5e3095de61a374b7cafdbc63641386fe47768e81fe53c420a8db","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f71f10f6fad7b388b1d72512","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: The October 2000 solar alternatives are historical inputs; the stated mixed-anomaly condition is not a full independent anomaly certification."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f71f10f6fad7b388b1d72512","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b604821725804734b597284dab5fdbcfd4f268cd6eff23e3403e25c8f6624094","q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9"],"scopeContentSha256":"76c5d082026fd9a0d47bd5d09cd42348561556f627fab562e3c50e192dff0d48","contributionContentSha256":"f738bf0ea97a5c4675c9eeb42db49f76e3c51c4868cb1c646e4973c9966634fe","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:b604821725804734b597284dab5fdbcfd4f268cd6eff23e3403e25c8f6624094","textSha256":"16f09770adc51e86f20046c74ba8a34d529eeccca736453695516568611510c8"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5f2c3a83d110af7a3f98025fdbbfc8c1","paperId":"hep-ph/0010144","sourceSha256":"ee38bf7bb1c54f79a3984b59245baee1934184df8e1889ae55578f75274db652","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a627cdd9e69a96606469/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4e56e07e5171ff1c85ec26ab715efed31ffd1ec430d4657f1b29b7083f4380f0","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a1a326436025f4e2302942b0267f2144e9800e35346b302ebc511ee33b7bb486","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7d0fce83f3b8ab2900747169f80b70e5","paperId":"hep-ph/0010144","sourceSha256":"ee38bf7bb1c54f79a3984b59245baee1934184df8e1889ae55578f75274db652","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a627cdd9e69a96606469/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4e56e07e5171ff1c85ec26ab715efed31ffd1ec430d4657f1b29b7083f4380f0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2275,"textSha256":"d750dc74d10f5e3095de61a374b7cafdbc63641386fe47768e81fe53c420a8db","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f71f10f6fad7b388b1d72512","recordId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"The October 2000 solar alternatives are historical inputs; the stated mixed-anomaly condition is not a full independent anomaly certification.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c4e930ea2979f60b435134b88a1a398778d7172bcc08d7c06939fc02e20b7b6b","home":{"unitId":"unit:c4e930ea2979f60b435134b88a1a398778d7172bcc08d7c06939fc02e20b7b6b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c4e930ea2979f60b435134b88a1a398778d7172bcc08d7c06939fc02e20b7b6b","paperId":"2511.10468","textSha256":"6c59d91e4f2426226533b42ede7963ddc674bf5f6a9fecbbf2b119749e08c379"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:48481059aa59c88112dadc28e92bab7e","paperId":"2511.10468","sourceSha256":"580ad0f92413ce0285dc21b37e380f4db125a94ce266ccc1719023ad9556319f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55733f0d92aeecb82c90/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c557e7262cd093b6ce54755e420aec559b1add92e8e88b42a9aeadae69c3c027","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":4126,"textSha256":"5101d4b26d82a910b1e362da3cd4686f44358112515da4780170910d397de63c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:662e1a8692a42d2b37755a64a73ae8c7","paperId":"2511.10468","sourceSha256":"580ad0f92413ce0285dc21b37e380f4db125a94ce266ccc1719023ad9556319f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55733f0d92aeecb82c90/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c557e7262cd093b6ce54755e420aec559b1add92e8e88b42a9aeadae69c3c027","pdfPage":3,"start":2490,"end":4126,"textSha256":"8858b1269fabf4052051578ad62fec4e1371c6568a702d3e39b7d25781c7c6a0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8c27b2574ab6296c43529a1c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8c27b2574ab6296c43529a1c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c4e930ea2979f60b435134b88a1a398778d7172bcc08d7c06939fc02e20b7b6b","q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820"],"scopeContentSha256":"d33dc1c9c7954e7517020455639b32f2f4707e5e1057c3ac46f189c22223a874","placementContentSha256":"c9f87e964a2cbd6ad311ea6fc1d4d0e07256b18bbed75070904a2ae96743a3df","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c4e930ea2979f60b435134b88a1a398778d7172bcc08d7c06939fc02e20b7b6b","paperId":"2511.10468","textSha256":"6c59d91e4f2426226533b42ede7963ddc674bf5f6a9fecbbf2b119749e08c379"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:48481059aa59c88112dadc28e92bab7e","paperId":"2511.10468","sourceSha256":"580ad0f92413ce0285dc21b37e380f4db125a94ce266ccc1719023ad9556319f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55733f0d92aeecb82c90/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c557e7262cd093b6ce54755e420aec559b1add92e8e88b42a9aeadae69c3c027","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":4126,"textSha256":"5101d4b26d82a910b1e362da3cd4686f44358112515da4780170910d397de63c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:662e1a8692a42d2b37755a64a73ae8c7","paperId":"2511.10468","sourceSha256":"580ad0f92413ce0285dc21b37e380f4db125a94ce266ccc1719023ad9556319f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55733f0d92aeecb82c90/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c557e7262cd093b6ce54755e420aec559b1add92e8e88b42a9aeadae69c3c027","pdfPage":3,"start":2490,"end":4126,"textSha256":"8858b1269fabf4052051578ad62fec4e1371c6568a702d3e39b7d25781c7c6a0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8c27b2574ab6296c43529a1c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c4e930ea2979f60b435134b88a1a398778d7172bcc08d7c06939fc02e20b7b6b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:c4e930ea2979f60b435134b88a1a398778d7172bcc08d7c06939fc02e20b7b6b","textSha256":"6c59d91e4f2426226533b42ede7963ddc674bf5f6a9fecbbf2b119749e08c379"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:48481059aa59c88112dadc28e92bab7e","paperId":"2511.10468","sourceSha256":"580ad0f92413ce0285dc21b37e380f4db125a94ce266ccc1719023ad9556319f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55733f0d92aeecb82c90/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c557e7262cd093b6ce54755e420aec559b1add92e8e88b42a9aeadae69c3c027","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":4126,"textSha256":"5101d4b26d82a910b1e362da3cd4686f44358112515da4780170910d397de63c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:662e1a8692a42d2b37755a64a73ae8c7","paperId":"2511.10468","sourceSha256":"580ad0f92413ce0285dc21b37e380f4db125a94ce266ccc1719023ad9556319f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55733f0d92aeecb82c90/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c557e7262cd093b6ce54755e420aec559b1add92e8e88b42a9aeadae69c3c027","pdfPage":3,"start":2490,"end":4126,"textSha256":"8858b1269fabf4052051578ad62fec4e1371c6568a702d3e39b7d25781c7c6a0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e131904b74b6bef4a85bb37c","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Global and gauged SU(2)F are alternatives; U(1)F remains global in both. Independent challenge qualification: Global PNGBs and weakly coupled gauge bosons are alternative cases; U(1)F stays global in both."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e131904b74b6bef4a85bb37c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c4e930ea2979f60b435134b88a1a398778d7172bcc08d7c06939fc02e20b7b6b","q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9"],"scopeContentSha256":"76c5d082026fd9a0d47bd5d09cd42348561556f627fab562e3c50e192dff0d48","contributionContentSha256":"f60838fdba1ec99929f21d34655aeb36530d587485cb345a986566deeb2023a3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:c4e930ea2979f60b435134b88a1a398778d7172bcc08d7c06939fc02e20b7b6b","textSha256":"6c59d91e4f2426226533b42ede7963ddc674bf5f6a9fecbbf2b119749e08c379"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:48481059aa59c88112dadc28e92bab7e","paperId":"2511.10468","sourceSha256":"580ad0f92413ce0285dc21b37e380f4db125a94ce266ccc1719023ad9556319f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55733f0d92aeecb82c90/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c557e7262cd093b6ce54755e420aec559b1add92e8e88b42a9aeadae69c3c027","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":4126,"textSha256":"5101d4b26d82a910b1e362da3cd4686f44358112515da4780170910d397de63c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:662e1a8692a42d2b37755a64a73ae8c7","paperId":"2511.10468","sourceSha256":"580ad0f92413ce0285dc21b37e380f4db125a94ce266ccc1719023ad9556319f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/55733f0d92aeecb82c90/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"c557e7262cd093b6ce54755e420aec559b1add92e8e88b42a9aeadae69c3c027","pdfPage":3,"start":2490,"end":4126,"textSha256":"8858b1269fabf4052051578ad62fec4e1371c6568a702d3e39b7d25781c7c6a0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e131904b74b6bef4a85bb37c","recordId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Global and gauged SU(2)F are alternatives; U(1)F remains global in both.","challengeNote":"Global PNGBs and weakly coupled gauge bosons are alternative cases; U(1)F stays global in both.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:cb9253be78362fb64ea474e1945b662db8219f8d10b44e6811a8c3a045a85b10","home":{"unitId":"unit:cb9253be78362fb64ea474e1945b662db8219f8d10b44e6811a8c3a045a85b10","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers the combined flavour, neutrino-mixing and collider targets of a gauged particle-physics extension.","qualification":"The independent neutrino-mixing requirement extends beyond q6's dipole and collider targets, while q2 does not encompass the whole anomalous-moment question. q27 covers their joint realization in the electroweak gauged model.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cb9253be78362fb64ea474e1945b662db8219f8d10b44e6811a8c3a045a85b10","paperId":"hep-ph/0110146","textSha256":"32c84ff59165e4dd95667d9cf115dea6a0434fcf416e8a771cdca847ad610847"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0049:u1:q27"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0049:u1:q27","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cb9253be78362fb64ea474e1945b662db8219f8d10b44e6811a8c3a045a85b10","q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820"],"scopeContentSha256":"d33dc1c9c7954e7517020455639b32f2f4707e5e1057c3ac46f189c22223a874","placementContentSha256":"3be062d9189d8521fa1c4bfb216bf8b423ad3599e6986d2d73592ad50762abde","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0049:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0049:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cb9253be78362fb64ea474e1945b662db8219f8d10b44e6811a8c3a045a85b10","paperId":"hep-ph/0110146","textSha256":"32c84ff59165e4dd95667d9cf115dea6a0434fcf416e8a771cdca847ad610847"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0049","unitRef":"u1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cb9253be78362fb64ea474e1945b662db8219f8d10b44e6811a8c3a045a85b10","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:cb9253be78362fb64ea474e1945b662db8219f8d10b44e6811a8c3a045a85b10","textSha256":"32c84ff59165e4dd95667d9cf115dea6a0434fcf416e8a771cdca847ad610847"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8672ac269f41ad701e1ad78c","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8672ac269f41ad701e1ad78c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cb9253be78362fb64ea474e1945b662db8219f8d10b44e6811a8c3a045a85b10","q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9"],"scopeContentSha256":"76c5d082026fd9a0d47bd5d09cd42348561556f627fab562e3c50e192dff0d48","contributionContentSha256":"02aafcec4b2fd56baf2359f225312f77a0278e4770b8678a42d31624afbbb7a3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:cb9253be78362fb64ea474e1945b662db8219f8d10b44e6811a8c3a045a85b10","textSha256":"32c84ff59165e4dd95667d9cf115dea6a0434fcf416e8a771cdca847ad610847"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8672ac269f41ad701e1ad78c","recordId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:fa83000a9e94b7442161dc086bebfff5c9132cda8e7b66599faef3f7b0775550","home":{"unitId":"unit:fa83000a9e94b7442161dc086bebfff5c9132cda8e7b66599faef3f7b0775550","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fa83000a9e94b7442161dc086bebfff5c9132cda8e7b66599faef3f7b0775550","paperId":"hep-ph/9210211","textSha256":"2181db2e1b0020e2d806f358cf074d0c13419300b3fd637a13b191cb4ee8d7b7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8420551d7955e5dd4eb97cd5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8420551d7955e5dd4eb97cd5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fa83000a9e94b7442161dc086bebfff5c9132cda8e7b66599faef3f7b0775550","q025-candidate-region:41e1cade22167485c3fd8820"],"scopeContentSha256":"d33dc1c9c7954e7517020455639b32f2f4707e5e1057c3ac46f189c22223a874","placementContentSha256":"5947487ac6d1df29fc856e8e9a3419e0bf191eb2a9ef94806ef62a18316dfd51","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fa83000a9e94b7442161dc086bebfff5c9132cda8e7b66599faef3f7b0775550","paperId":"hep-ph/9210211","textSha256":"2181db2e1b0020e2d806f358cf074d0c13419300b3fd637a13b191cb4ee8d7b7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8420551d7955e5dd4eb97cd5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fa83000a9e94b7442161dc086bebfff5c9132cda8e7b66599faef3f7b0775550","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:fa83000a9e94b7442161dc086bebfff5c9132cda8e7b66599faef3f7b0775550","textSha256":"2181db2e1b0020e2d806f358cf074d0c13419300b3fd637a13b191cb4ee8d7b7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:99d42864c849560dc7670e15","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:99d42864c849560dc7670e15","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fa83000a9e94b7442161dc086bebfff5c9132cda8e7b66599faef3f7b0775550","q025-candidate-question:2d5f73adc5721a19ab5510b9"],"scopeContentSha256":"76c5d082026fd9a0d47bd5d09cd42348561556f627fab562e3c50e192dff0d48","contributionContentSha256":"24736d3d2ff54f477b7568d05dc35ab992d1c197287f3920ae4c704f30773b2a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:fa83000a9e94b7442161dc086bebfff5c9132cda8e7b66599faef3f7b0775550","textSha256":"2181db2e1b0020e2d806f358cf074d0c13419300b3fd637a13b191cb4ee8d7b7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:99d42864c849560dc7670e15","recordId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1eb263570ba6c0ad8441-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":10,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"162a284339670499910a9089d46ad3223f620bf6d74089c8743d4933c3ccd2de"},"organizational-access:ac92ef3d7f11a8b3d2bab1b5":{"id":"organizational-access:ac92ef3d7f11a8b3d2bab1b5","source":"q025-candidate-region:4b1b43798f4cff47d094ef0a","target":"q025-candidate-question:b5305578f582f8c846d69fcb","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:4b1b43798f4cff47d094ef0a","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"c27e7c690d53caa33e3da863b071c125439ece276a7a296d2a3538f6632d34c1","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0e1cb3d8a4b46c9b289ba6af"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:b5305578f582f8c846d69fcb","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f904e41a72cbaeb7bbc9c7d93293e339b3388ebffbdb90e3aa57badd8f1dc3a7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:914abc105e2f8baab12de023"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:63eaf4c1dd6b6aa06f6e83ceed9c4254299f6278e0ca399a33dc39fa2898ea1d","home":{"unitId":"unit:63eaf4c1dd6b6aa06f6e83ceed9c4254299f6278e0ca399a33dc39fa2898ea1d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4b1b43798f4cff47d094ef0a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:63eaf4c1dd6b6aa06f6e83ceed9c4254299f6278e0ca399a33dc39fa2898ea1d","paperId":"1706.05097","textSha256":"ee3da85b474c29c9534777239decaaa7b48badf8bf827fa6e9e64124a5966022"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:22fbad5d5d031d2f9698ab19"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:22fbad5d5d031d2f9698ab19","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:63eaf4c1dd6b6aa06f6e83ceed9c4254299f6278e0ca399a33dc39fa2898ea1d","q025-candidate-region:4b1b43798f4cff47d094ef0a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c27e7c690d53caa33e3da863b071c125439ece276a7a296d2a3538f6632d34c1","placementContentSha256":"16d871468e82c02327fc62d7c51ae645f8e27711eea9d4f9305830e3effa6bc8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-challenge","leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:63eaf4c1dd6b6aa06f6e83ceed9c4254299f6278e0ca399a33dc39fa2898ea1d","paperId":"1706.05097","textSha256":"ee3da85b474c29c9534777239decaaa7b48badf8bf827fa6e9e64124a5966022"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:22fbad5d5d031d2f9698ab19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:63eaf4c1dd6b6aa06f6e83ceed9c4254299f6278e0ca399a33dc39fa2898ea1d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b5305578f582f8c846d69fcb","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:63eaf4c1dd6b6aa06f6e83ceed9c4254299f6278e0ca399a33dc39fa2898ea1d","textSha256":"ee3da85b474c29c9534777239decaaa7b48badf8bf827fa6e9e64124a5966022"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f2d5d09e02213f0bba1b6a08","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Resolved GWs, backgrounds and spin inference are linked but distinct targets. Equivalence with the neighboring population study is unverified. Independent challenge qualification: Resolved GWs, backgrounds and spin inference are distinct targets. Similarity to the neighboring population study does not establish scoped equivalence."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f2d5d09e02213f0bba1b6a08","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:63eaf4c1dd6b6aa06f6e83ceed9c4254299f6278e0ca399a33dc39fa2898ea1d","q025-candidate-question:b5305578f582f8c846d69fcb"],"scopeContentSha256":"f904e41a72cbaeb7bbc9c7d93293e339b3388ebffbdb90e3aa57badd8f1dc3a7","contributionContentSha256":"dfac3e8c69c00c7da1a1012cb8a21edf874bd91ae1b531e33a799abe28a1baa2","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-proposal","leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:63eaf4c1dd6b6aa06f6e83ceed9c4254299f6278e0ca399a33dc39fa2898ea1d","textSha256":"ee3da85b474c29c9534777239decaaa7b48badf8bf827fa6e9e64124a5966022"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f2d5d09e02213f0bba1b6a08","recordId":"leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Resolved GWs, backgrounds and spin inference are linked but distinct targets. Equivalence with the neighboring population study is unverified.","challengeNote":"Resolved GWs, backgrounds and spin inference are distinct targets. Similarity to the neighboring population study does not establish scoped equivalence.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:be3c6edb12ec861b9845aca564c31c0ac1bfce92770620a25ca7b058cc7906bc","home":{"unitId":"unit:be3c6edb12ec861b9845aca564c31c0ac1bfce92770620a25ca7b058cc7906bc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4b1b43798f4cff47d094ef0a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:be3c6edb12ec861b9845aca564c31c0ac1bfce92770620a25ca7b058cc7906bc","paperId":"1706.06311","textSha256":"b09d3fcb573ab2f522991117e519950e3062c120aa6e06be1693f9c556ea6fb7"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:66a1ab188367dbce329f2c1b9fe2d5ac","paperId":"1706.06311","sourceSha256":"4e063197657917301f7605f1c9769ace6fe63ab3fafb3e3d542b0f901195b06d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b2c74e74ab4a0f181bc6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"38748b35eb47a32ad9aea543aca52680afff2df92d248559aa9e631ea4b7e825","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":3501,"textSha256":"819583069fab74ba2d5e7c1c361319dc2a82e2866a2a1051c642c525c9f975ed","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cf1c7df671bb9c57bca5106e927d7bda","paperId":"1706.06311","sourceSha256":"4e063197657917301f7605f1c9769ace6fe63ab3fafb3e3d542b0f901195b06d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b2c74e74ab4a0f181bc6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"38748b35eb47a32ad9aea543aca52680afff2df92d248559aa9e631ea4b7e825","pdfPage":3,"start":2490,"end":5890,"textSha256":"185b7f7fc606aed78008c1a2718aef4834b77d1955af2abea949c7afd7506a36","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8d9eb0d25e116971a72b291e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8d9eb0d25e116971a72b291e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:be3c6edb12ec861b9845aca564c31c0ac1bfce92770620a25ca7b058cc7906bc","q025-candidate-region:4b1b43798f4cff47d094ef0a"],"scopeContentSha256":"c27e7c690d53caa33e3da863b071c125439ece276a7a296d2a3538f6632d34c1","placementContentSha256":"022ef792b2f592cf3f30eb5cb3a72593d8d8d7c743f399968ef55ac273946c2c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-challenge","leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:be3c6edb12ec861b9845aca564c31c0ac1bfce92770620a25ca7b058cc7906bc","paperId":"1706.06311","textSha256":"b09d3fcb573ab2f522991117e519950e3062c120aa6e06be1693f9c556ea6fb7"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:66a1ab188367dbce329f2c1b9fe2d5ac","paperId":"1706.06311","sourceSha256":"4e063197657917301f7605f1c9769ace6fe63ab3fafb3e3d542b0f901195b06d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b2c74e74ab4a0f181bc6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"38748b35eb47a32ad9aea543aca52680afff2df92d248559aa9e631ea4b7e825","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":3501,"textSha256":"819583069fab74ba2d5e7c1c361319dc2a82e2866a2a1051c642c525c9f975ed","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cf1c7df671bb9c57bca5106e927d7bda","paperId":"1706.06311","sourceSha256":"4e063197657917301f7605f1c9769ace6fe63ab3fafb3e3d542b0f901195b06d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b2c74e74ab4a0f181bc6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"38748b35eb47a32ad9aea543aca52680afff2df92d248559aa9e631ea4b7e825","pdfPage":3,"start":2490,"end":5890,"textSha256":"185b7f7fc606aed78008c1a2718aef4834b77d1955af2abea949c7afd7506a36","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8d9eb0d25e116971a72b291e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:be3c6edb12ec861b9845aca564c31c0ac1bfce92770620a25ca7b058cc7906bc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b5305578f582f8c846d69fcb","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:be3c6edb12ec861b9845aca564c31c0ac1bfce92770620a25ca7b058cc7906bc","textSha256":"b09d3fcb573ab2f522991117e519950e3062c120aa6e06be1693f9c556ea6fb7"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:66a1ab188367dbce329f2c1b9fe2d5ac","paperId":"1706.06311","sourceSha256":"4e063197657917301f7605f1c9769ace6fe63ab3fafb3e3d542b0f901195b06d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b2c74e74ab4a0f181bc6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"38748b35eb47a32ad9aea543aca52680afff2df92d248559aa9e631ea4b7e825","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":3501,"textSha256":"819583069fab74ba2d5e7c1c361319dc2a82e2866a2a1051c642c525c9f975ed","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cf1c7df671bb9c57bca5106e927d7bda","paperId":"1706.06311","sourceSha256":"4e063197657917301f7605f1c9769ace6fe63ab3fafb3e3d542b0f901195b06d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b2c74e74ab4a0f181bc6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"38748b35eb47a32ad9aea543aca52680afff2df92d248559aa9e631ea4b7e825","pdfPage":3,"start":2490,"end":5890,"textSha256":"185b7f7fc606aed78008c1a2718aef4834b77d1955af2abea949c7afd7506a36","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c1e559429c41a6af70ffb6a2","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound GW and spin-distribution targets. The source explicitly excludes a LIGO mass–spin depletion study; that analysis is for LISA. Independent challenge qualification: Compound GW and spin-distribution targets. The source's mass–spin depletion analysis is for LISA; it explicitly excludes that analysis for LIGO."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c1e559429c41a6af70ffb6a2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:be3c6edb12ec861b9845aca564c31c0ac1bfce92770620a25ca7b058cc7906bc","q025-candidate-question:b5305578f582f8c846d69fcb"],"scopeContentSha256":"f904e41a72cbaeb7bbc9c7d93293e339b3388ebffbdb90e3aa57badd8f1dc3a7","contributionContentSha256":"566cf5a79bd7a8681e3b25c292996b883e2189eb5c93434762a2c9f7dab32683","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-proposal","leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:be3c6edb12ec861b9845aca564c31c0ac1bfce92770620a25ca7b058cc7906bc","textSha256":"b09d3fcb573ab2f522991117e519950e3062c120aa6e06be1693f9c556ea6fb7"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:66a1ab188367dbce329f2c1b9fe2d5ac","paperId":"1706.06311","sourceSha256":"4e063197657917301f7605f1c9769ace6fe63ab3fafb3e3d542b0f901195b06d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b2c74e74ab4a0f181bc6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"38748b35eb47a32ad9aea543aca52680afff2df92d248559aa9e631ea4b7e825","pdfPage":1,"start":102,"end":3501,"textSha256":"819583069fab74ba2d5e7c1c361319dc2a82e2866a2a1051c642c525c9f975ed","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cf1c7df671bb9c57bca5106e927d7bda","paperId":"1706.06311","sourceSha256":"4e063197657917301f7605f1c9769ace6fe63ab3fafb3e3d542b0f901195b06d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/b2c74e74ab4a0f181bc6/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"38748b35eb47a32ad9aea543aca52680afff2df92d248559aa9e631ea4b7e825","pdfPage":3,"start":2490,"end":5890,"textSha256":"185b7f7fc606aed78008c1a2718aef4834b77d1955af2abea949c7afd7506a36","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c1e559429c41a6af70ffb6a2","recordId":"leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0ec228b53f325a877cb0-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound GW and spin-distribution targets. The source explicitly excludes a LIGO mass–spin depletion study; that analysis is for LISA.","challengeNote":"Compound GW and spin-distribution targets. The source's mass–spin depletion analysis is for LISA; it explicitly excludes that analysis for LIGO.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"cde7f5b2d3693981f27dea6e878a56ace32d1bc52d259f9bfbb8e9dc759e7fec"},"organizational-access:b0e5020f563cfa5d05fe368e":{"id":"organizational-access:b0e5020f563cfa5d05fe368e","source":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","target":"q025-candidate-question:472ece611b86e09198879194","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:864135f72fedd7ba3f55409f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:472ece611b86e09198879194","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"154ca9072ab112d1dfa10127c50c6d63c66ba24e7f1931aeffaa900847fadac7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8012f62f70fd439fe0cf9999"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:adf249b07b18434ba58b71fbc9873ff45a6694164faf5f0759e34b3b5fba5174","home":{"unitId":"unit:adf249b07b18434ba58b71fbc9873ff45a6694164faf5f0759e34b3b5fba5174","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:adf249b07b18434ba58b71fbc9873ff45a6694164faf5f0759e34b3b5fba5174","paperId":"2301.07719","textSha256":"0e225f7f8da7f67d76d0937c8249efa6e3f6b2ec19e7fe921629f4d35633624c"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:02d8b13fc42761d7187dbc25"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:02d8b13fc42761d7187dbc25","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:adf249b07b18434ba58b71fbc9873ff45a6694164faf5f0759e34b3b5fba5174","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"9c5035068fed32266f1868f00dc7bf94a0a7bc01b499087635e7344a3afd25fc","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:adf249b07b18434ba58b71fbc9873ff45a6694164faf5f0759e34b3b5fba5174","paperId":"2301.07719","textSha256":"0e225f7f8da7f67d76d0937c8249efa6e3f6b2ec19e7fe921629f4d35633624c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:02d8b13fc42761d7187dbc25"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:adf249b07b18434ba58b71fbc9873ff45a6694164faf5f0759e34b3b5fba5174","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:472ece611b86e09198879194","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:adf249b07b18434ba58b71fbc9873ff45a6694164faf5f0759e34b3b5fba5174","textSha256":"0e225f7f8da7f67d76d0937c8249efa6e3f6b2ec19e7fe921629f4d35633624c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c2f572c514eb72bb1637eb12","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Tower configurations and effective realizations qualify the proposed dark-energy/SUSY connection. Independent challenge qualification: Tower choices and effective realizations qualify the proposed dark-energy/SUSY relation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c2f572c514eb72bb1637eb12","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:adf249b07b18434ba58b71fbc9873ff45a6694164faf5f0759e34b3b5fba5174","q025-candidate-question:472ece611b86e09198879194"],"scopeContentSha256":"154ca9072ab112d1dfa10127c50c6d63c66ba24e7f1931aeffaa900847fadac7","contributionContentSha256":"ffb439177ad58b3416d530c2f8df9064c842b5a7358482acc8503734eaaa7e0d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:adf249b07b18434ba58b71fbc9873ff45a6694164faf5f0759e34b3b5fba5174","textSha256":"0e225f7f8da7f67d76d0937c8249efa6e3f6b2ec19e7fe921629f4d35633624c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c2f572c514eb72bb1637eb12","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Tower configurations and effective realizations qualify the proposed dark-energy/SUSY connection.","challengeNote":"Tower choices and effective realizations qualify the proposed dark-energy/SUSY relation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4ae3ff6fdd300cd2db5c70c20e2fa88746f8269f40fd4dd4a0d840ce261b1275"},"organizational-access:7ee86aa853664ec142049004":{"id":"organizational-access:7ee86aa853664ec142049004","source":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","target":"q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:864135f72fedd7ba3f55409f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"fffd2d016b2325365b30925228e3d39c45ea92e8e8ee2ab96e614850b33c54bb","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:95a165182a18cae2582c0d4f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","home":{"unitId":"unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","textSha256":"f5f33ec29b58901375340da5e7853147fe9dd28011a216435d2e4ceb12e02793"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2d8f9c1bce4badad8c955ff6f81e1647","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":20,"start":95,"end":2946,"textSha256":"ed91ce733a0623c035876b44aa9e9a8046f62e914d11ea4d24d40e14dcb22580","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7c4f407830d3c031da26b35370f0fb12","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3031,"textSha256":"38b1e47550773d3515acb275f0c0946a74ae48ecd2718cc169a329aaece2c61e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:7597544ffd9059fb56659ce5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:7597544ffd9059fb56659ce5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"c485e336c7ba17f41d59a8b60ea7598a01ead085571aeb5fac33daa2bd5fe71c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","textSha256":"f5f33ec29b58901375340da5e7853147fe9dd28011a216435d2e4ceb12e02793"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2d8f9c1bce4badad8c955ff6f81e1647","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":20,"start":95,"end":2946,"textSha256":"ed91ce733a0623c035876b44aa9e9a8046f62e914d11ea4d24d40e14dcb22580","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7c4f407830d3c031da26b35370f0fb12","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3031,"textSha256":"38b1e47550773d3515acb275f0c0946a74ae48ecd2718cc169a329aaece2c61e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:7597544ffd9059fb56659ce5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d29","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","textSha256":"f5f33ec29b58901375340da5e7853147fe9dd28011a216435d2e4ceb12e02793"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2d8f9c1bce4badad8c955ff6f81e1647","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":20,"start":95,"end":2946,"textSha256":"ed91ce733a0623c035876b44aa9e9a8046f62e914d11ea4d24d40e14dcb22580","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7c4f407830d3c031da26b35370f0fb12","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3031,"textSha256":"38b1e47550773d3515acb275f0c0946a74ae48ecd2718cc169a329aaece2c61e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:be671dba998c6207c0c7a7c7","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound D7-MSSM spectrum, EWSB and relic targets. Neutralino dominance changes allowed spectra; viability statements use 2005 constraints. Independent challenge qualification: Compound D7-MSSM spectrum, EWSB and relic targets. Neutralino dominance changes allowed regions; the reported viability uses 2005 constraints."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:be671dba998c6207c0c7a7c7","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a"],"scopeContentSha256":"fffd2d016b2325365b30925228e3d39c45ea92e8e8ee2ab96e614850b33c54bb","contributionContentSha256":"414994dc95f0d34a7bf13f2f5ea0c63f9a10b6be77ab700f8bbb9b29128ebc66","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d29","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","textSha256":"f5f33ec29b58901375340da5e7853147fe9dd28011a216435d2e4ceb12e02793"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2d8f9c1bce4badad8c955ff6f81e1647","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":20,"start":95,"end":2946,"textSha256":"ed91ce733a0623c035876b44aa9e9a8046f62e914d11ea4d24d40e14dcb22580","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7c4f407830d3c031da26b35370f0fb12","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3031,"textSha256":"38b1e47550773d3515acb275f0c0946a74ae48ecd2718cc169a329aaece2c61e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:be671dba998c6207c0c7a7c7","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound D7-MSSM spectrum, EWSB and relic targets. Neutralino dominance changes allowed spectra; viability statements use 2005 constraints.","challengeNote":"Compound D7-MSSM spectrum, EWSB and relic targets. Neutralino dominance changes allowed regions; the reported viability uses 2005 constraints.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","home":{"unitId":"unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","paperId":"hep-ph/0509225","textSha256":"3d8c75187ff736f04567e61ae1af5b867452024fdf1f8c7809ad87f198fec72c"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:b902661f3a7923ffd80ea9b1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:b902661f3a7923ffd80ea9b1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"ee075e5bead5ddc8583d12c616059d6e186c9fcd38ff5883dffd5bea737e01fe","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","paperId":"hep-ph/0509225","textSha256":"3d8c75187ff736f04567e61ae1af5b867452024fdf1f8c7809ad87f198fec72c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:b902661f3a7923ffd80ea9b1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","textSha256":"3d8c75187ff736f04567e61ae1af5b867452024fdf1f8c7809ad87f198fec72c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bcb389b52f335f254314840f","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound spectrum, EWSB and neutralino-composition targets; candidate composition alone does not establish relic-abundance viability. Independent challenge qualification: Compound spectrum, EWSB and neutralino-composition targets. Candidate composition does not establish acceptable relic abundance."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:bcb389b52f335f254314840f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a"],"scopeContentSha256":"fffd2d016b2325365b30925228e3d39c45ea92e8e8ee2ab96e614850b33c54bb","contributionContentSha256":"58e6e3acead8a25543fe63e3ca6029079bad149304af73a605634ff1640295da","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","textSha256":"3d8c75187ff736f04567e61ae1af5b867452024fdf1f8c7809ad87f198fec72c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bcb389b52f335f254314840f","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound spectrum, EWSB and neutralino-composition targets; candidate composition alone does not establish relic-abundance viability.","challengeNote":"Compound spectrum, EWSB and neutralino-composition targets. Candidate composition does not establish acceptable relic abundance.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","home":{"unitId":"unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","paperId":"1204.2795","textSha256":"4df6b5b4eea3e625429a47b0a47142026656dc2c59a60048d450f717c4a4a804"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:dcd0ddb107429bd588522ee6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:dcd0ddb107429bd588522ee6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"975966ab19f212265fdb1b0508a29cf9336207b97a9276d7a0c0f639f9f93eff","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","paperId":"1204.2795","textSha256":"4df6b5b4eea3e625429a47b0a47142026656dc2c59a60048d450f717c4a4a804"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:dcd0ddb107429bd588522ee6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","textSha256":"4df6b5b4eea3e625429a47b0a47142026656dc2c59a60048d450f717c4a4a804"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1dc290f5ff17223ac867dd20","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound particle/dark-matter predictions conditioned on low-energy SUSY, grand unification and cosmology. Independent challenge qualification: Compound particle and dark-matter predictions are conditional on low-energy SUSY, grand unification and cosmology."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1dc290f5ff17223ac867dd20","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a"],"scopeContentSha256":"fffd2d016b2325365b30925228e3d39c45ea92e8e8ee2ab96e614850b33c54bb","contributionContentSha256":"e2caaac8ac06653b9172a5fdd8edddc9c661ae0540e96bfdc07497c9e8149f63","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","textSha256":"4df6b5b4eea3e625429a47b0a47142026656dc2c59a60048d450f717c4a4a804"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1dc290f5ff17223ac867dd20","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound particle/dark-matter predictions conditioned on low-energy SUSY, grand unification and cosmology.","challengeNote":"Compound particle and dark-matter predictions are conditional on low-energy SUSY, grand unification and cosmology.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","home":{"unitId":"unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","textSha256":"b6cb80648baeb089977af4bd22cf8dfb09059581f91ade64681168b9f77e874b"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7166b60b11f721c32ce307a47efa04b8","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2805,"textSha256":"3ba5317c7c58197b6da560920cfed21c82aadc587de51a4470e89f6084206f7f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af24f05e4071e4333662a3f0991336a9","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":2805,"textSha256":"093bf7780e9269290451ca16257e81ffd076dc3103c3b0900fdedcf0b63922aa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:3d59e75656c7b9a7266c6e62"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:3d59e75656c7b9a7266c6e62","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"77753654d32ab35ef0a9d9ad2e2e2174efaa031b00adff3f6372697d7c903058","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","textSha256":"b6cb80648baeb089977af4bd22cf8dfb09059581f91ade64681168b9f77e874b"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7166b60b11f721c32ce307a47efa04b8","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2805,"textSha256":"3ba5317c7c58197b6da560920cfed21c82aadc587de51a4470e89f6084206f7f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af24f05e4071e4333662a3f0991336a9","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":2805,"textSha256":"093bf7780e9269290451ca16257e81ffd076dc3103c3b0900fdedcf0b63922aa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:3d59e75656c7b9a7266c6e62"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","textSha256":"b6cb80648baeb089977af4bd22cf8dfb09059581f91ade64681168b9f77e874b"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7166b60b11f721c32ce307a47efa04b8","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2805,"textSha256":"3ba5317c7c58197b6da560920cfed21c82aadc587de51a4470e89f6084206f7f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af24f05e4071e4333662a3f0991336a9","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":2805,"textSha256":"093bf7780e9269290451ca16257e81ffd076dc3103c3b0900fdedcf0b63922aa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0bb2c50c1be45087d0c506ef","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound taxonomy with the Planck scale as sole explicit mass input; tuned vacuum energy is admitted and the R-symmetry pattern is not a theorem. Independent challenge qualification: Compound taxonomy with the Planck scale as sole explicit mass input. Vacuum-energy tuning is admitted; the stated R-symmetry pattern is not a theorem."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0bb2c50c1be45087d0c506ef","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a"],"scopeContentSha256":"fffd2d016b2325365b30925228e3d39c45ea92e8e8ee2ab96e614850b33c54bb","contributionContentSha256":"34d3f102358bd3a94f95a192e40e5497473667df7bfa4926c9dfffd8a78febb3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","textSha256":"b6cb80648baeb089977af4bd22cf8dfb09059581f91ade64681168b9f77e874b"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7166b60b11f721c32ce307a47efa04b8","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2805,"textSha256":"3ba5317c7c58197b6da560920cfed21c82aadc587de51a4470e89f6084206f7f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af24f05e4071e4333662a3f0991336a9","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":2805,"textSha256":"093bf7780e9269290451ca16257e81ffd076dc3103c3b0900fdedcf0b63922aa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0bb2c50c1be45087d0c506ef","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound taxonomy with the Planck scale as sole explicit mass input; tuned vacuum energy is admitted and the R-symmetry pattern is not a theorem.","challengeNote":"Compound taxonomy with the Planck scale as sole explicit mass input. Vacuum-energy tuning is admitted; the stated R-symmetry pattern is not a theorem.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","home":{"unitId":"unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers soft-term predictions, electroweak breaking, dark-matter and experimental constraints, and source-era collider prospects.","qualification":"q24 contains the soft-pattern prediction, electroweak test, experimental/dark-matter constraints and prospective collider tests. Kähler-modulus dominance is retained without inferring a compactification, and all constraints remain source-era.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","paperId":"0805.2943","textSha256":"04715bfe5458d8e013b9e5b471c2980a6fdea9d8e26f11ef15c04dbcf4110c85"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0023:u20:q24"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0023:u20:q24","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"071eab4506757bed30cea957a50e597bfa5ac2c1feb9aaa5e08004e7a6a367af","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0023:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0023:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","paperId":"0805.2943","textSha256":"04715bfe5458d8e013b9e5b471c2980a6fdea9d8e26f11ef15c04dbcf4110c85"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0023","unitRef":"u20"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","textSha256":"04715bfe5458d8e013b9e5b471c2980a6fdea9d8e26f11ef15c04dbcf4110c85"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c166a91e6c79e086827e7f21","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound spectrum, electroweak, dark-matter and prospective-test targets remain source-scoped. Independent challenge qualification: Remove pf2: Kähler-modulus dominance does not identify a compactified string/M setting in this description. Compound spectrum, EWSB, dark-matter and test scopes"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c166a91e6c79e086827e7f21","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","q025-candidate-question:949e06b78f51aaba4079294a"],"scopeContentSha256":"fffd2d016b2325365b30925228e3d39c45ea92e8e8ee2ab96e614850b33c54bb","contributionContentSha256":"03ce446d09c9ca56abbb3f35a86e26889f157d3d5bbecde3ca9024317b36ce0e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","textSha256":"04715bfe5458d8e013b9e5b471c2980a6fdea9d8e26f11ef15c04dbcf4110c85"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c166a91e6c79e086827e7f21","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound spectrum, electroweak, dark-matter and prospective-test targets remain source-scoped.","challengeNote":"Remove pf2: Kähler-modulus dominance does not identify a compactified string/M setting in this description. Compound spectrum, EWSB, dark-matter and test scopes","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":5,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4ee3777553cb827f86a35bd0145a871d2edde1283ba8eb1419eac5cbf49e5c00"},"organizational-access:bfaf36634ca9460db0f0b66d":{"id":"organizational-access:bfaf36634ca9460db0f0b66d","source":"q025-candidate-region:56e448507bae8015b488c2d1","target":"q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:56e448507bae8015b488c2d1","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"be985d3e6cc3015a287fb37de5be16a62dae41501b9bb80bca5a3c12f5d05d91","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e4fddc9d62c3cd704e637773"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1f0300ebb75ae20a042a7a13d20c0a0f3543b50bf6a7f0985811c6bc71256bdd","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:034e173e6c01f70a1cc70b4c"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:175bba135d91ae044124d00bca478428a124e354d3b61b189acf75b7aef67d9d","home":{"unitId":"unit:175bba135d91ae044124d00bca478428a124e354d3b61b189acf75b7aef67d9d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:56e448507bae8015b488c2d1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:175bba135d91ae044124d00bca478428a124e354d3b61b189acf75b7aef67d9d","paperId":"hep-th/9502069","textSha256":"988aed9e6795e1768fe36e0f0e0c15caa3e3eac15de4957241aaeaa7798c1f38"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f00a0180f2f7cc422cf047e5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f00a0180f2f7cc422cf047e5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:175bba135d91ae044124d00bca478428a124e354d3b61b189acf75b7aef67d9d","q025-candidate-region:56e448507bae8015b488c2d1"],"scopeContentSha256":"be985d3e6cc3015a287fb37de5be16a62dae41501b9bb80bca5a3c12f5d05d91","placementContentSha256":"63bc4f28a303a9887e8f4a236984abdf5d47fba0730610ea6b003d9d41e8329e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge","leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:175bba135d91ae044124d00bca478428a124e354d3b61b189acf75b7aef67d9d","paperId":"hep-th/9502069","textSha256":"988aed9e6795e1768fe36e0f0e0c15caa3e3eac15de4957241aaeaa7798c1f38"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f00a0180f2f7cc422cf047e5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:175bba135d91ae044124d00bca478428a124e354d3b61b189acf75b7aef67d9d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d49","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:175bba135d91ae044124d00bca478428a124e354d3b61b189acf75b7aef67d9d","textSha256":"988aed9e6795e1768fe36e0f0e0c15caa3e3eac15de4957241aaeaa7798c1f38"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:be01fe17190b0cf90e4d5039","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Wormhole threats, dual two-form protection and modified short-distance gravity are distinct parts of the question. Independent challenge qualification: Wormhole threats, dual two-form protection and short-distance modifications form a compound question."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:be01fe17190b0cf90e4d5039","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:175bba135d91ae044124d00bca478428a124e354d3b61b189acf75b7aef67d9d","q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f0300ebb75ae20a042a7a13d20c0a0f3543b50bf6a7f0985811c6bc71256bdd","contributionContentSha256":"4bf4f8bee8e89ec3072086d578579db79a8d3d39376d60c5bae9e9c7ebc0b03e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d49","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:175bba135d91ae044124d00bca478428a124e354d3b61b189acf75b7aef67d9d","textSha256":"988aed9e6795e1768fe36e0f0e0c15caa3e3eac15de4957241aaeaa7798c1f38"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:be01fe17190b0cf90e4d5039","recordId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Wormhole threats, dual two-form protection and modified short-distance gravity are distinct parts of the question.","challengeNote":"Wormhole threats, dual two-form protection and short-distance modifications form a compound question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:bb06bf32b17553f51af8a6c601b0b5d198509d67714c0ec97f2cf3a606d94d3d","home":{"unitId":"unit:bb06bf32b17553f51af8a6c601b0b5d198509d67714c0ec97f2cf3a606d94d3d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:56e448507bae8015b488c2d1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bb06bf32b17553f51af8a6c601b0b5d198509d67714c0ec97f2cf3a606d94d3d","paperId":"2603.18566","textSha256":"a8b54de64842b36cd5d80c4ade855ffbbf11ac9dcade8eca1b209391fa4a4257"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7b1775b6a7b89277f00dca24"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7b1775b6a7b89277f00dca24","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bb06bf32b17553f51af8a6c601b0b5d198509d67714c0ec97f2cf3a606d94d3d","q025-candidate-region:56e448507bae8015b488c2d1"],"scopeContentSha256":"be985d3e6cc3015a287fb37de5be16a62dae41501b9bb80bca5a3c12f5d05d91","placementContentSha256":"2d05ed215fa33b7641ae7ae5eda22d5d872c87761f890877d3d9bca3d28832cd","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge","leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bb06bf32b17553f51af8a6c601b0b5d198509d67714c0ec97f2cf3a606d94d3d","paperId":"2603.18566","textSha256":"a8b54de64842b36cd5d80c4ade855ffbbf11ac9dcade8eca1b209391fa4a4257"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7b1775b6a7b89277f00dca24"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bb06bf32b17553f51af8a6c601b0b5d198509d67714c0ec97f2cf3a606d94d3d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:bb06bf32b17553f51af8a6c601b0b5d198509d67714c0ec97f2cf3a606d94d3d","textSha256":"a8b54de64842b36cd5d80c4ade855ffbbf11ac9dcade8eca1b209391fa4a4257"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:47216831032301c11ccae050","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound dark-matter, four-form, moduli-stabilization and SUSY-breaking targets; no equivalence with a two-form proposal is inferred. Independent challenge qualification: Compound dark-matter, four-form, stabilization and SUSY-breaking targets; no equivalence with two-form mechanisms is established."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:47216831032301c11ccae050","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bb06bf32b17553f51af8a6c601b0b5d198509d67714c0ec97f2cf3a606d94d3d","q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f0300ebb75ae20a042a7a13d20c0a0f3543b50bf6a7f0985811c6bc71256bdd","contributionContentSha256":"92930549ab1453cd5ab55c957598f47076bde504d9fa2fc0b3f6c1e8822a73a0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:bb06bf32b17553f51af8a6c601b0b5d198509d67714c0ec97f2cf3a606d94d3d","textSha256":"a8b54de64842b36cd5d80c4ade855ffbbf11ac9dcade8eca1b209391fa4a4257"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:47216831032301c11ccae050","recordId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound dark-matter, four-form, moduli-stabilization and SUSY-breaking targets; no equivalence with a two-form proposal is inferred.","challengeNote":"Compound dark-matter, four-form, stabilization and SUSY-breaking targets; no equivalence with two-form mechanisms is established.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ff5e35da5142d1259b2427910e159252fe25dff3029fd88e4f5a0b0f25d7a0c7","home":{"unitId":"unit:ff5e35da5142d1259b2427910e159252fe25dff3029fd88e4f5a0b0f25d7a0c7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:56e448507bae8015b488c2d1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ff5e35da5142d1259b2427910e159252fe25dff3029fd88e4f5a0b0f25d7a0c7","paperId":"2007.13320","textSha256":"81bb7bb3aa7effa751aed1c9101bf7bc53b7a787a28f57cd84a4ef6b8b7c6052"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7ac8350a468e0ba4c80e1933"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7ac8350a468e0ba4c80e1933","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ff5e35da5142d1259b2427910e159252fe25dff3029fd88e4f5a0b0f25d7a0c7","q025-candidate-region:56e448507bae8015b488c2d1"],"scopeContentSha256":"be985d3e6cc3015a287fb37de5be16a62dae41501b9bb80bca5a3c12f5d05d91","placementContentSha256":"aa4bf8666a012d7dfe4b46c2c9350f87d2fbd26eef4d77b4be9e4bcc3f6d19f7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge","leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ff5e35da5142d1259b2427910e159252fe25dff3029fd88e4f5a0b0f25d7a0c7","paperId":"2007.13320","textSha256":"81bb7bb3aa7effa751aed1c9101bf7bc53b7a787a28f57cd84a4ef6b8b7c6052"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7ac8350a468e0ba4c80e1933"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ff5e35da5142d1259b2427910e159252fe25dff3029fd88e4f5a0b0f25d7a0c7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:ff5e35da5142d1259b2427910e159252fe25dff3029fd88e4f5a0b0f25d7a0c7","textSha256":"81bb7bb3aa7effa751aed1c9101bf7bc53b7a787a28f57cd84a4ef6b8b7c6052"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:df9c7d7434a9da4d7f4ca798","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The scale explanation is WGC-conditional; low-cutoff axion cosmology is an additional target. Independent challenge qualification: Compound protection, WGC-conditional scale explanation and low-cutoff cosmology."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:df9c7d7434a9da4d7f4ca798","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ff5e35da5142d1259b2427910e159252fe25dff3029fd88e4f5a0b0f25d7a0c7","q025-candidate-question:7594ef95875650ce83e2017a"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f0300ebb75ae20a042a7a13d20c0a0f3543b50bf6a7f0985811c6bc71256bdd","contributionContentSha256":"d85a2263fbe3a57e35627cf9345d5d625581ac61b4eaf887ceb2f3e6294c6ac5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:ff5e35da5142d1259b2427910e159252fe25dff3029fd88e4f5a0b0f25d7a0c7","textSha256":"81bb7bb3aa7effa751aed1c9101bf7bc53b7a787a28f57cd84a4ef6b8b7c6052"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:df9c7d7434a9da4d7f4ca798","recordId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-11aa8be8882cb7f17f80-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"The scale explanation is WGC-conditional; low-cutoff axion cosmology is an additional target.","challengeNote":"Compound protection, WGC-conditional scale explanation and low-cutoff cosmology.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"bddd955ae35fbd7e19ebcf07478e5da637d4912c5713446f943ecf23663be9de"},"organizational-access:b92542127c7d69a7aa26eb00":{"id":"organizational-access:b92542127c7d69a7aa26eb00","source":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","target":"q025-candidate-question:205a007cc4dcbb840728fd39","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5025d915791a4d704d8c95c2"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:205a007cc4dcbb840728fd39","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"58cc4c5eabf7ab3021a567ea6e41f3f163b905c3108cac55539bf9cd263d3f95","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:518a5d3d30149add6aaee2dc"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:57efaacada3863df7e123e58e578da23f20a5e64026a365781eb3ad5232b873d","home":{"unitId":"unit:57efaacada3863df7e123e58e578da23f20a5e64026a365781eb3ad5232b873d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:57efaacada3863df7e123e58e578da23f20a5e64026a365781eb3ad5232b873d","paperId":"2206.00198","textSha256":"89277e343b6cafd5a0bd58e44ff16c986dff4607e4e3454e681cb08b41c7a9a1"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:db02aef2754a22a3e5e9e652"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:db02aef2754a22a3e5e9e652","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:57efaacada3863df7e123e58e578da23f20a5e64026a365781eb3ad5232b873d","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"940657512fcc1fcaf063fd80d1626830f418259d0274ca202e43d0440393e6ac","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:57efaacada3863df7e123e58e578da23f20a5e64026a365781eb3ad5232b873d","paperId":"2206.00198","textSha256":"89277e343b6cafd5a0bd58e44ff16c986dff4607e4e3454e681cb08b41c7a9a1"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:db02aef2754a22a3e5e9e652"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:57efaacada3863df7e123e58e578da23f20a5e64026a365781eb3ad5232b873d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:205a007cc4dcbb840728fd39","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:57efaacada3863df7e123e58e578da23f20a5e64026a365781eb3ad5232b873d","textSha256":"89277e343b6cafd5a0bd58e44ff16c986dff4607e4e3454e681cb08b41c7a9a1"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:15750333ae8afe9da4073d64","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Size, fall-time and thermal one-point consequences retain the emission scenario's conditional premises. Independent challenge qualification: Size, fall-time and thermal one-point consequences retain the conditional emission premises."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:15750333ae8afe9da4073d64","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:57efaacada3863df7e123e58e578da23f20a5e64026a365781eb3ad5232b873d","q025-candidate-question:205a007cc4dcbb840728fd39"],"scopeContentSha256":"58cc4c5eabf7ab3021a567ea6e41f3f163b905c3108cac55539bf9cd263d3f95","contributionContentSha256":"602590b1edcef77df4a5436fadfc0775c8d8fcc824184e47a984663616a2edd4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:57efaacada3863df7e123e58e578da23f20a5e64026a365781eb3ad5232b873d","textSha256":"89277e343b6cafd5a0bd58e44ff16c986dff4607e4e3454e681cb08b41c7a9a1"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:15750333ae8afe9da4073d64","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Size, fall-time and thermal one-point consequences retain the emission scenario's conditional premises.","challengeNote":"Size, fall-time and thermal one-point consequences retain the conditional emission premises.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:753eb80972aeb4eef8bed36c3cb2d5095c7adbe4b7dcf803204ab2b1475b8eba","home":{"unitId":"unit:753eb80972aeb4eef8bed36c3cb2d5095c7adbe4b7dcf803204ab2b1475b8eba","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:753eb80972aeb4eef8bed36c3cb2d5095c7adbe4b7dcf803204ab2b1475b8eba","paperId":"2411.02427","textSha256":"b39bd65720283dd1ec72ad43ca4ffd4882b649f38cfc2bc488da9f485069a993"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:69792e3b033d54d72bbf6c44a608a4f8","paperId":"2411.02427","sourceSha256":"2d53ea2c11ac072852e56cdf3992756c8447fdddbedd5d3b10df47108a04854b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6e4b6966b4bea6600756/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"79cfd7317e1cf0440e7afafd575ad1743bd6cb39b0144b72399c5c15a0b68e1d","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2780,"textSha256":"f6a7ef1d1adcd9d2fd2a0b5dacb6c60df3dc77cbd636559612235b5dc30ca6a8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f1f4eec4fb8d393d018b5e4a8f084906","paperId":"2411.02427","sourceSha256":"2d53ea2c11ac072852e56cdf3992756c8447fdddbedd5d3b10df47108a04854b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6e4b6966b4bea6600756/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"79cfd7317e1cf0440e7afafd575ad1743bd6cb39b0144b72399c5c15a0b68e1d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1329,"textSha256":"0e2b3099cadeaaa4766ecc12e9284085305dfe7ed4178784170702f9c9d34355","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e4c2034694e41510b7a9f0de"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e4c2034694e41510b7a9f0de","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:753eb80972aeb4eef8bed36c3cb2d5095c7adbe4b7dcf803204ab2b1475b8eba","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"79a6fd0c6180cb82a97e3a797c35fac0b199db9801f4b1a762a1e785bd0ef9fd","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:753eb80972aeb4eef8bed36c3cb2d5095c7adbe4b7dcf803204ab2b1475b8eba","paperId":"2411.02427","textSha256":"b39bd65720283dd1ec72ad43ca4ffd4882b649f38cfc2bc488da9f485069a993"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:69792e3b033d54d72bbf6c44a608a4f8","paperId":"2411.02427","sourceSha256":"2d53ea2c11ac072852e56cdf3992756c8447fdddbedd5d3b10df47108a04854b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6e4b6966b4bea6600756/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"79cfd7317e1cf0440e7afafd575ad1743bd6cb39b0144b72399c5c15a0b68e1d","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2780,"textSha256":"f6a7ef1d1adcd9d2fd2a0b5dacb6c60df3dc77cbd636559612235b5dc30ca6a8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f1f4eec4fb8d393d018b5e4a8f084906","paperId":"2411.02427","sourceSha256":"2d53ea2c11ac072852e56cdf3992756c8447fdddbedd5d3b10df47108a04854b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6e4b6966b4bea6600756/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"79cfd7317e1cf0440e7afafd575ad1743bd6cb39b0144b72399c5c15a0b68e1d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1329,"textSha256":"0e2b3099cadeaaa4766ecc12e9284085305dfe7ed4178784170702f9c9d34355","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e4c2034694e41510b7a9f0de"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:753eb80972aeb4eef8bed36c3cb2d5095c7adbe4b7dcf803204ab2b1475b8eba","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:205a007cc4dcbb840728fd39","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d64","kind":"description","unitIndex":64,"unitId":"unit:753eb80972aeb4eef8bed36c3cb2d5095c7adbe4b7dcf803204ab2b1475b8eba","textSha256":"b39bd65720283dd1ec72ad43ca4ffd4882b649f38cfc2bc488da9f485069a993"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:69792e3b033d54d72bbf6c44a608a4f8","paperId":"2411.02427","sourceSha256":"2d53ea2c11ac072852e56cdf3992756c8447fdddbedd5d3b10df47108a04854b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6e4b6966b4bea6600756/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"79cfd7317e1cf0440e7afafd575ad1743bd6cb39b0144b72399c5c15a0b68e1d","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2780,"textSha256":"f6a7ef1d1adcd9d2fd2a0b5dacb6c60df3dc77cbd636559612235b5dc30ca6a8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f1f4eec4fb8d393d018b5e4a8f084906","paperId":"2411.02427","sourceSha256":"2d53ea2c11ac072852e56cdf3992756c8447fdddbedd5d3b10df47108a04854b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6e4b6966b4bea6600756/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"79cfd7317e1cf0440e7afafd575ad1743bd6cb39b0144b72399c5c15a0b68e1d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1329,"textSha256":"0e2b3099cadeaaa4766ecc12e9284085305dfe7ed4178784170702f9c9d34355","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4d79cdcd3337c37023679e9b","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Thermodynamic perturbations and scalar-scattering censorship tests are distinct facets. The metric requires r>a; the small-correction regime uses r≫a. Independent challenge qualification: Thermodynamic perturbations and scattering tests are distinct facets. The metric requires r>a; the small-correction regime uses r≫a. Entropy increase is t."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4d79cdcd3337c37023679e9b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:753eb80972aeb4eef8bed36c3cb2d5095c7adbe4b7dcf803204ab2b1475b8eba","q025-candidate-question:205a007cc4dcbb840728fd39"],"scopeContentSha256":"58cc4c5eabf7ab3021a567ea6e41f3f163b905c3108cac55539bf9cd263d3f95","contributionContentSha256":"29e9386b00f15ccc49d8ecc847389b04358266ae4fa156182b0eded296727d39","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d64","kind":"description","unitIndex":64,"unitId":"unit:753eb80972aeb4eef8bed36c3cb2d5095c7adbe4b7dcf803204ab2b1475b8eba","textSha256":"b39bd65720283dd1ec72ad43ca4ffd4882b649f38cfc2bc488da9f485069a993"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:69792e3b033d54d72bbf6c44a608a4f8","paperId":"2411.02427","sourceSha256":"2d53ea2c11ac072852e56cdf3992756c8447fdddbedd5d3b10df47108a04854b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6e4b6966b4bea6600756/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"79cfd7317e1cf0440e7afafd575ad1743bd6cb39b0144b72399c5c15a0b68e1d","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2780,"textSha256":"f6a7ef1d1adcd9d2fd2a0b5dacb6c60df3dc77cbd636559612235b5dc30ca6a8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f1f4eec4fb8d393d018b5e4a8f084906","paperId":"2411.02427","sourceSha256":"2d53ea2c11ac072852e56cdf3992756c8447fdddbedd5d3b10df47108a04854b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6e4b6966b4bea6600756/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"79cfd7317e1cf0440e7afafd575ad1743bd6cb39b0144b72399c5c15a0b68e1d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1329,"textSha256":"0e2b3099cadeaaa4766ecc12e9284085305dfe7ed4178784170702f9c9d34355","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4d79cdcd3337c37023679e9b","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Thermodynamic perturbations and scalar-scattering censorship tests are distinct facets. The metric requires r>a; the small-correction regime uses r≫a.","challengeNote":"Thermodynamic perturbations and scattering tests are distinct facets. The metric requires r>a; the small-correction regime uses r≫a. Entropy increase is t.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"267e3c1812306f8e2fbcb0d45470b936439cf84135106b6f0ae97bff4c28a317"},"organizational-access:3c9a37824c9d93b3ddb9edbf":{"id":"organizational-access:3c9a37824c9d93b3ddb9edbf","source":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","target":"q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5025d915791a4d704d8c95c2"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e37a245e6ae1d1aa265e99802e84ffa43da2d21fd7607d56ed797bf572150e15","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:271456e69b01eabb323fca56"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1e0b62fef6d88368f14aa9f84041a33d5f8b936c7b9e126d935c8f502e4d1e44","home":{"unitId":"unit:1e0b62fef6d88368f14aa9f84041a33d5f8b936c7b9e126d935c8f502e4d1e44","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e0b62fef6d88368f14aa9f84041a33d5f8b936c7b9e126d935c8f502e4d1e44","paperId":"1812.08181","textSha256":"8e7b32a5ea36425e702752a9cc7de7e725978469abe23bbf22fd5d647c01be12"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0ee065a44c40ef5d5ef3935c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0ee065a44c40ef5d5ef3935c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e0b62fef6d88368f14aa9f84041a33d5f8b936c7b9e126d935c8f502e4d1e44","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"8614c0e813cb9e82b7950ec48609f89e9c2c4abe426f37d313c4d293fbabdcf2","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e0b62fef6d88368f14aa9f84041a33d5f8b936c7b9e126d935c8f502e4d1e44","paperId":"1812.08181","textSha256":"8e7b32a5ea36425e702752a9cc7de7e725978469abe23bbf22fd5d647c01be12"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0ee065a44c40ef5d5ef3935c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1e0b62fef6d88368f14aa9f84041a33d5f8b936c7b9e126d935c8f502e4d1e44","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:1e0b62fef6d88368f14aa9f84041a33d5f8b936c7b9e126d935c8f502e4d1e44","textSha256":"8e7b32a5ea36425e702752a9cc7de7e725978469abe23bbf22fd5d647c01be12"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1fde9b24111fa438dcd547f4","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Discrete discharge and weak-scale fine-tuning remain compound targets. Independent challenge qualification: Discrete discharge bounds and weak-scale fine-tuning remain compound targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1fde9b24111fa438dcd547f4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e0b62fef6d88368f14aa9f84041a33d5f8b936c7b9e126d935c8f502e4d1e44","q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202"],"scopeContentSha256":"e37a245e6ae1d1aa265e99802e84ffa43da2d21fd7607d56ed797bf572150e15","contributionContentSha256":"f47fcc8c87d0ecbeaafefced96e7afb809da8baaf4d0991ba16e00eeceed7c28","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:1e0b62fef6d88368f14aa9f84041a33d5f8b936c7b9e126d935c8f502e4d1e44","textSha256":"8e7b32a5ea36425e702752a9cc7de7e725978469abe23bbf22fd5d647c01be12"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1fde9b24111fa438dcd547f4","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Discrete discharge and weak-scale fine-tuning remain compound targets.","challengeNote":"Discrete discharge bounds and weak-scale fine-tuning remain compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:33795b828c5d509854c6ec3adce7eeee65ea986fb28dc301a1390891b2de3c71","home":{"unitId":"unit:33795b828c5d509854c6ec3adce7eeee65ea986fb28dc301a1390891b2de3c71","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:33795b828c5d509854c6ec3adce7eeee65ea986fb28dc301a1390891b2de3c71","paperId":"1810.03637","textSha256":"99264019da4d46136e223eca98feb7bf49e0d4f942dfa3cf59f2ce6e6374b247"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c9f924088f749ca770aff488"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c9f924088f749ca770aff488","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:33795b828c5d509854c6ec3adce7eeee65ea986fb28dc301a1390891b2de3c71","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"8c54976b3097be47313e2e0d22b5e4a53fe575cd67b31a2e0d905af0a95b51e2","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:33795b828c5d509854c6ec3adce7eeee65ea986fb28dc301a1390891b2de3c71","paperId":"1810.03637","textSha256":"99264019da4d46136e223eca98feb7bf49e0d4f942dfa3cf59f2ce6e6374b247"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c9f924088f749ca770aff488"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:33795b828c5d509854c6ec3adce7eeee65ea986fb28dc301a1390891b2de3c71","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:33795b828c5d509854c6ec3adce7eeee65ea986fb28dc301a1390891b2de3c71","textSha256":"99264019da4d46136e223eca98feb7bf49e0d4f942dfa3cf59f2ce6e6374b247"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5bd14c0f71b9cea21fa163a7","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Explicitly includes absence of a charged particle satisfying the bound. Independent challenge qualification: The question explicitly includes cases without a charged particle meeting the bound."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5bd14c0f71b9cea21fa163a7","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:33795b828c5d509854c6ec3adce7eeee65ea986fb28dc301a1390891b2de3c71","q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202"],"scopeContentSha256":"e37a245e6ae1d1aa265e99802e84ffa43da2d21fd7607d56ed797bf572150e15","contributionContentSha256":"2f649eb7e5abb244110db5576a3447ed8e54d8da32020293f569ca38064e959f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:33795b828c5d509854c6ec3adce7eeee65ea986fb28dc301a1390891b2de3c71","textSha256":"99264019da4d46136e223eca98feb7bf49e0d4f942dfa3cf59f2ce6e6374b247"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5bd14c0f71b9cea21fa163a7","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Explicitly includes absence of a charged particle satisfying the bound.","challengeNote":"The question explicitly includes cases without a charged particle meeting the bound.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:4a8b876bcba99634b4c95779f37fa0547a65d27c6bbf4010a534aafe14bed149","home":{"unitId":"unit:4a8b876bcba99634b4c95779f37fa0547a65d27c6bbf4010a534aafe14bed149","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4a8b876bcba99634b4c95779f37fa0547a65d27c6bbf4010a534aafe14bed149","paperId":"2605.23047","textSha256":"74ad8b7b7ef15566886e289fdcf7348d18356e5d5277e9951ac41ee2babe131d"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:30294995952eacdf91796ad81cfd78fd","paperId":"2605.23047","sourceSha256":"e66ed682b7b667032409e8c9b629cb0c17cbeb1c7bf6cb1deacef596e82edc59","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/079f7514891eda1b257a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7bf57bae1fb015628a3e7d25cc96224b86d5af3474f80f1a4bb549fb40747eb3","pdfPage":2,"start":1298,"end":3521,"textSha256":"a21129aa3ed92043661ac2b7c0c9e2e645481b64086d123b6c473a13475f9018","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f5266987fcbb6f5732fc18b2d2dd25fb","paperId":"2605.23047","sourceSha256":"e66ed682b7b667032409e8c9b629cb0c17cbeb1c7bf6cb1deacef596e82edc59","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/079f7514891eda1b257a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7bf57bae1fb015628a3e7d25cc96224b86d5af3474f80f1a4bb549fb40747eb3","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"7338c5c7ba621cb6b67166189a9e62e9560a75c2581e41468cb8a50d628180c7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:582fe0e68040833c44ab5e73"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:582fe0e68040833c44ab5e73","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4a8b876bcba99634b4c95779f37fa0547a65d27c6bbf4010a534aafe14bed149","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"17ede815ddbe901592023f3a7b1483c0dc428da2bcaf99005147d06fe65fe06a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4a8b876bcba99634b4c95779f37fa0547a65d27c6bbf4010a534aafe14bed149","paperId":"2605.23047","textSha256":"74ad8b7b7ef15566886e289fdcf7348d18356e5d5277e9951ac41ee2babe131d"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:30294995952eacdf91796ad81cfd78fd","paperId":"2605.23047","sourceSha256":"e66ed682b7b667032409e8c9b629cb0c17cbeb1c7bf6cb1deacef596e82edc59","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/079f7514891eda1b257a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7bf57bae1fb015628a3e7d25cc96224b86d5af3474f80f1a4bb549fb40747eb3","pdfPage":2,"start":1298,"end":3521,"textSha256":"a21129aa3ed92043661ac2b7c0c9e2e645481b64086d123b6c473a13475f9018","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f5266987fcbb6f5732fc18b2d2dd25fb","paperId":"2605.23047","sourceSha256":"e66ed682b7b667032409e8c9b629cb0c17cbeb1c7bf6cb1deacef596e82edc59","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/079f7514891eda1b257a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7bf57bae1fb015628a3e7d25cc96224b86d5af3474f80f1a4bb549fb40747eb3","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"7338c5c7ba621cb6b67166189a9e62e9560a75c2581e41468cb8a50d628180c7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:582fe0e68040833c44ab5e73"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4a8b876bcba99634b4c95779f37fa0547a65d27c6bbf4010a534aafe14bed149","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202","role":"instantiates","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:4a8b876bcba99634b4c95779f37fa0547a65d27c6bbf4010a534aafe14bed149","textSha256":"74ad8b7b7ef15566886e289fdcf7348d18356e5d5277e9951ac41ee2babe131d"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:30294995952eacdf91796ad81cfd78fd","paperId":"2605.23047","sourceSha256":"e66ed682b7b667032409e8c9b629cb0c17cbeb1c7bf6cb1deacef596e82edc59","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/079f7514891eda1b257a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7bf57bae1fb015628a3e7d25cc96224b86d5af3474f80f1a4bb549fb40747eb3","pdfPage":2,"start":1298,"end":3521,"textSha256":"a21129aa3ed92043661ac2b7c0c9e2e645481b64086d123b6c473a13475f9018","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f5266987fcbb6f5732fc18b2d2dd25fb","paperId":"2605.23047","sourceSha256":"e66ed682b7b667032409e8c9b629cb0c17cbeb1c7bf6cb1deacef596e82edc59","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/079f7514891eda1b257a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7bf57bae1fb015628a3e7d25cc96224b86d5af3474f80f1a4bb549fb40747eb3","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"7338c5c7ba621cb6b67166189a9e62e9560a75c2581e41468cb8a50d628180c7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d65f12bb38857fa34cb3c04c","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Phase transitions, the proposed conjecture bridge and dark-dimension application are separable targets; scalar time derivatives are neglected. Independent challenge qualification: Phase transitions, a conjecture bridge and the dark-dimension application are separable targets; scalar time derivatives are neglected."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d65f12bb38857fa34cb3c04c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4a8b876bcba99634b4c95779f37fa0547a65d27c6bbf4010a534aafe14bed149","q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202"],"scopeContentSha256":"e37a245e6ae1d1aa265e99802e84ffa43da2d21fd7607d56ed797bf572150e15","contributionContentSha256":"9db7d7526ebaeee1459ba5a805312b4881143c7c60ee558f011f3b620ae06f77","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:4a8b876bcba99634b4c95779f37fa0547a65d27c6bbf4010a534aafe14bed149","textSha256":"74ad8b7b7ef15566886e289fdcf7348d18356e5d5277e9951ac41ee2babe131d"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:30294995952eacdf91796ad81cfd78fd","paperId":"2605.23047","sourceSha256":"e66ed682b7b667032409e8c9b629cb0c17cbeb1c7bf6cb1deacef596e82edc59","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/079f7514891eda1b257a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7bf57bae1fb015628a3e7d25cc96224b86d5af3474f80f1a4bb549fb40747eb3","pdfPage":2,"start":1298,"end":3521,"textSha256":"a21129aa3ed92043661ac2b7c0c9e2e645481b64086d123b6c473a13475f9018","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f5266987fcbb6f5732fc18b2d2dd25fb","paperId":"2605.23047","sourceSha256":"e66ed682b7b667032409e8c9b629cb0c17cbeb1c7bf6cb1deacef596e82edc59","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/079f7514891eda1b257a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7bf57bae1fb015628a3e7d25cc96224b86d5af3474f80f1a4bb549fb40747eb3","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"7338c5c7ba621cb6b67166189a9e62e9560a75c2581e41468cb8a50d628180c7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d65f12bb38857fa34cb3c04c","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Phase transitions, the proposed conjecture bridge and dark-dimension application are separable targets; scalar time derivatives are neglected.","challengeNote":"Phase transitions, a conjecture bridge and the dark-dimension application are separable targets; scalar time derivatives are neglected.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:94794b970e2c6ee6f19e94eefdc28cc8ff8f029cb53bf01ebd46e00bb64e8ff4","home":{"unitId":"unit:94794b970e2c6ee6f19e94eefdc28cc8ff8f029cb53bf01ebd46e00bb64e8ff4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:94794b970e2c6ee6f19e94eefdc28cc8ff8f029cb53bf01ebd46e00bb64e8ff4","paperId":"2108.08309","textSha256":"4fea9331508e3b72bddf8839907e0a36b221233627e77b74809867298cdd7a1d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c27f0f8daede81b81acf5502"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c27f0f8daede81b81acf5502","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:94794b970e2c6ee6f19e94eefdc28cc8ff8f029cb53bf01ebd46e00bb64e8ff4","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"5c7087c8610b00698fc0fcb835f2e8d98af1b0c80e73e9161a5a3145f39b468b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:94794b970e2c6ee6f19e94eefdc28cc8ff8f029cb53bf01ebd46e00bb64e8ff4","paperId":"2108.08309","textSha256":"4fea9331508e3b72bddf8839907e0a36b221233627e77b74809867298cdd7a1d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c27f0f8daede81b81acf5502"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:94794b970e2c6ee6f19e94eefdc28cc8ff8f029cb53bf01ebd46e00bb64e8ff4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:94794b970e2c6ee6f19e94eefdc28cc8ff8f029cb53bf01ebd46e00bb64e8ff4","textSha256":"4fea9331508e3b72bddf8839907e0a36b221233627e77b74809867298cdd7a1d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f9513ba52524ace96026c084","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f9513ba52524ace96026c084","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:94794b970e2c6ee6f19e94eefdc28cc8ff8f029cb53bf01ebd46e00bb64e8ff4","q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202"],"scopeContentSha256":"e37a245e6ae1d1aa265e99802e84ffa43da2d21fd7607d56ed797bf572150e15","contributionContentSha256":"552e67cc1fd714bf038aecf21c64230ff750b86a6130d946144a38090f5ff855","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:94794b970e2c6ee6f19e94eefdc28cc8ff8f029cb53bf01ebd46e00bb64e8ff4","textSha256":"4fea9331508e3b72bddf8839907e0a36b221233627e77b74809867298cdd7a1d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f9513ba52524ace96026c084","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9f82c7e6ecaccd2d0c5e41eb0688af2055cabd987e8e27800b862e41a8704433","home":{"unitId":"unit:9f82c7e6ecaccd2d0c5e41eb0688af2055cabd987e8e27800b862e41a8704433","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9f82c7e6ecaccd2d0c5e41eb0688af2055cabd987e8e27800b862e41a8704433","paperId":"2011.06083","textSha256":"0271b9df46bcffbd71024859bc93d05812f802528fa9977db87ec361a7c93ddb"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f6741aae875535ae5881fca2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f6741aae875535ae5881fca2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9f82c7e6ecaccd2d0c5e41eb0688af2055cabd987e8e27800b862e41a8704433","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"95531a7d0c2c952a4f04b8ac3f73aa06a24449c87f314f61c8bdbbbc19606f15","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9f82c7e6ecaccd2d0c5e41eb0688af2055cabd987e8e27800b862e41a8704433","paperId":"2011.06083","textSha256":"0271b9df46bcffbd71024859bc93d05812f802528fa9977db87ec361a7c93ddb"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f6741aae875535ae5881fca2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9f82c7e6ecaccd2d0c5e41eb0688af2055cabd987e8e27800b862e41a8704433","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d17","kind":"description","unitIndex":17,"unitId":"unit:9f82c7e6ecaccd2d0c5e41eb0688af2055cabd987e8e27800b862e41a8704433","textSha256":"0271b9df46bcffbd71024859bc93d05812f802528fa9977db87ec361a7c93ddb"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:128fa76199d4ff99737b0a8e","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:128fa76199d4ff99737b0a8e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9f82c7e6ecaccd2d0c5e41eb0688af2055cabd987e8e27800b862e41a8704433","q025-candidate-question:d6f2cb2fa6f5238e69b07202"],"scopeContentSha256":"e37a245e6ae1d1aa265e99802e84ffa43da2d21fd7607d56ed797bf572150e15","contributionContentSha256":"1484bf2ce4f5b2aa2aa02d4abc6e5b5b1008483048b955cbaaf8deef7895a690","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d17","kind":"description","unitIndex":17,"unitId":"unit:9f82c7e6ecaccd2d0c5e41eb0688af2055cabd987e8e27800b862e41a8704433","textSha256":"0271b9df46bcffbd71024859bc93d05812f802528fa9977db87ec361a7c93ddb"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:128fa76199d4ff99737b0a8e","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":5,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"9bc6f34ba3203e9cffd43af921ffda6c0ac778af8f5ebc43423907e57563f4e2"},"organizational-access:1e287a6afcf9950caae22f17":{"id":"organizational-access:1e287a6afcf9950caae22f17","source":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","target":"q025-candidate-question:e1407b9cdf71e84033922dd1","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5025d915791a4d704d8c95c2"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e1407b9cdf71e84033922dd1","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"2cf40a960ac3d34b5bb7eaf093efe3cebe69deccaf022865527e7a79d8f06e95","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c8436933d54cd028d9c3d9ad"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4bea2236adce2a83cf3c451f430db2b31ccbb60826ec94caf64e9a0ca2613854","home":{"unitId":"unit:4bea2236adce2a83cf3c451f430db2b31ccbb60826ec94caf64e9a0ca2613854","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4bea2236adce2a83cf3c451f430db2b31ccbb60826ec94caf64e9a0ca2613854","paperId":"2203.03378","textSha256":"afcdf532e7df321ed329083eabca8505a0994bab3487fd9345424de0e88074a5"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:27f8d7c7b2b3e535ffaf6b010eb077a6","paperId":"2203.03378","sourceSha256":"dd897f1a33e85f66725a98935d6fb1e44d440c58e436ef6eb32e5ed45681d80b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4471860445feb7b1a83e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c56626bb7a454027b4cad2772d0d3ac944fbd66ac25cd68ab7c2b89e84cd002","pdfPage":2,"start":2504,"end":5111,"textSha256":"ee22f22781c688f975859adce41502f20908a213c92f26cd0eada4227fbd3872","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c2d319d5d46b203f6d7d7d8c08c5f00f","paperId":"2203.03378","sourceSha256":"dd897f1a33e85f66725a98935d6fb1e44d440c58e436ef6eb32e5ed45681d80b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4471860445feb7b1a83e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c56626bb7a454027b4cad2772d0d3ac944fbd66ac25cd68ab7c2b89e84cd002","pdfPage":1,"start":1302,"end":4565,"textSha256":"22aede4bd849add2609750f5c556f02e44545825191995afd80e13efefe4954f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f737b4b0f373279a3dc15ae7db28d293","paperId":"2203.03378","sourceSha256":"dd897f1a33e85f66725a98935d6fb1e44d440c58e436ef6eb32e5ed45681d80b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4471860445feb7b1a83e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c56626bb7a454027b4cad2772d0d3ac944fbd66ac25cd68ab7c2b89e84cd002","pdfPage":2,"start":3705,"end":5111,"textSha256":"768f7f4fd3eccc185d234e8a113d8940e898defd2c819c36e4b334882d62c879","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fe33e311bc34203882a58338"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fe33e311bc34203882a58338","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4bea2236adce2a83cf3c451f430db2b31ccbb60826ec94caf64e9a0ca2613854","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"0a66d8bc10f724ed8d149f60851435890c7bce788a69c1d315e2a75a10fc48b0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4bea2236adce2a83cf3c451f430db2b31ccbb60826ec94caf64e9a0ca2613854","paperId":"2203.03378","textSha256":"afcdf532e7df321ed329083eabca8505a0994bab3487fd9345424de0e88074a5"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:27f8d7c7b2b3e535ffaf6b010eb077a6","paperId":"2203.03378","sourceSha256":"dd897f1a33e85f66725a98935d6fb1e44d440c58e436ef6eb32e5ed45681d80b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4471860445feb7b1a83e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c56626bb7a454027b4cad2772d0d3ac944fbd66ac25cd68ab7c2b89e84cd002","pdfPage":2,"start":2504,"end":5111,"textSha256":"ee22f22781c688f975859adce41502f20908a213c92f26cd0eada4227fbd3872","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c2d319d5d46b203f6d7d7d8c08c5f00f","paperId":"2203.03378","sourceSha256":"dd897f1a33e85f66725a98935d6fb1e44d440c58e436ef6eb32e5ed45681d80b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4471860445feb7b1a83e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c56626bb7a454027b4cad2772d0d3ac944fbd66ac25cd68ab7c2b89e84cd002","pdfPage":1,"start":1302,"end":4565,"textSha256":"22aede4bd849add2609750f5c556f02e44545825191995afd80e13efefe4954f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f737b4b0f373279a3dc15ae7db28d293","paperId":"2203.03378","sourceSha256":"dd897f1a33e85f66725a98935d6fb1e44d440c58e436ef6eb32e5ed45681d80b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4471860445feb7b1a83e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c56626bb7a454027b4cad2772d0d3ac944fbd66ac25cd68ab7c2b89e84cd002","pdfPage":2,"start":3705,"end":5111,"textSha256":"768f7f4fd3eccc185d234e8a113d8940e898defd2c819c36e4b334882d62c879","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fe33e311bc34203882a58338"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4bea2236adce2a83cf3c451f430db2b31ccbb60826ec94caf64e9a0ca2613854","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e1407b9cdf71e84033922dd1","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:4bea2236adce2a83cf3c451f430db2b31ccbb60826ec94caf64e9a0ca2613854","textSha256":"afcdf532e7df321ed329083eabca8505a0994bab3487fd9345424de0e88074a5"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:27f8d7c7b2b3e535ffaf6b010eb077a6","paperId":"2203.03378","sourceSha256":"dd897f1a33e85f66725a98935d6fb1e44d440c58e436ef6eb32e5ed45681d80b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4471860445feb7b1a83e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c56626bb7a454027b4cad2772d0d3ac944fbd66ac25cd68ab7c2b89e84cd002","pdfPage":2,"start":2504,"end":5111,"textSha256":"ee22f22781c688f975859adce41502f20908a213c92f26cd0eada4227fbd3872","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c2d319d5d46b203f6d7d7d8c08c5f00f","paperId":"2203.03378","sourceSha256":"dd897f1a33e85f66725a98935d6fb1e44d440c58e436ef6eb32e5ed45681d80b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4471860445feb7b1a83e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c56626bb7a454027b4cad2772d0d3ac944fbd66ac25cd68ab7c2b89e84cd002","pdfPage":1,"start":1302,"end":4565,"textSha256":"22aede4bd849add2609750f5c556f02e44545825191995afd80e13efefe4954f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f737b4b0f373279a3dc15ae7db28d293","paperId":"2203.03378","sourceSha256":"dd897f1a33e85f66725a98935d6fb1e44d440c58e436ef6eb32e5ed45681d80b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4471860445feb7b1a83e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c56626bb7a454027b4cad2772d0d3ac944fbd66ac25cd68ab7c2b89e84cd002","pdfPage":2,"start":3705,"end":5111,"textSha256":"768f7f4fd3eccc185d234e8a113d8940e898defd2c819c36e4b334882d62c879","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:804775ff4842ac7584cc6d46","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: HSV and KNA are parallel model cases; the selected charged mode and damping normalization need explicit checking. Independent challenge qualification: HSV and KNA remain separate model cases. Mode selection and the damping-time normalization require checking."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:804775ff4842ac7584cc6d46","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4bea2236adce2a83cf3c451f430db2b31ccbb60826ec94caf64e9a0ca2613854","q025-candidate-question:e1407b9cdf71e84033922dd1"],"scopeContentSha256":"2cf40a960ac3d34b5bb7eaf093efe3cebe69deccaf022865527e7a79d8f06e95","contributionContentSha256":"1d2d4314febf4c88123322ed1aae4445103065cf2d5d0434ce3aabe3f01a1f7e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:4bea2236adce2a83cf3c451f430db2b31ccbb60826ec94caf64e9a0ca2613854","textSha256":"afcdf532e7df321ed329083eabca8505a0994bab3487fd9345424de0e88074a5"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:27f8d7c7b2b3e535ffaf6b010eb077a6","paperId":"2203.03378","sourceSha256":"dd897f1a33e85f66725a98935d6fb1e44d440c58e436ef6eb32e5ed45681d80b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4471860445feb7b1a83e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c56626bb7a454027b4cad2772d0d3ac944fbd66ac25cd68ab7c2b89e84cd002","pdfPage":2,"start":2504,"end":5111,"textSha256":"ee22f22781c688f975859adce41502f20908a213c92f26cd0eada4227fbd3872","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c2d319d5d46b203f6d7d7d8c08c5f00f","paperId":"2203.03378","sourceSha256":"dd897f1a33e85f66725a98935d6fb1e44d440c58e436ef6eb32e5ed45681d80b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4471860445feb7b1a83e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c56626bb7a454027b4cad2772d0d3ac944fbd66ac25cd68ab7c2b89e84cd002","pdfPage":1,"start":1302,"end":4565,"textSha256":"22aede4bd849add2609750f5c556f02e44545825191995afd80e13efefe4954f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f737b4b0f373279a3dc15ae7db28d293","paperId":"2203.03378","sourceSha256":"dd897f1a33e85f66725a98935d6fb1e44d440c58e436ef6eb32e5ed45681d80b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4471860445feb7b1a83e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c56626bb7a454027b4cad2772d0d3ac944fbd66ac25cd68ab7c2b89e84cd002","pdfPage":2,"start":3705,"end":5111,"textSha256":"768f7f4fd3eccc185d234e8a113d8940e898defd2c819c36e4b334882d62c879","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:804775ff4842ac7584cc6d46","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"HSV and KNA are parallel model cases; the selected charged mode and damping normalization need explicit checking.","challengeNote":"HSV and KNA remain separate model cases. Mode selection and the damping-time normalization require checking.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","home":{"unitId":"unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers environmental black-hole relaxation, geometric or optical diagnostics and conditional conjectural compatibility tests within one regional scope.","qualification":"q21 includes ordinary relaxation and geometric diagnostics together with conditional conjecture tests. It covers both environmental modifications and the simultaneous inequality/cutoff question. q16 omits optics and q12 omits relaxation compatibility; scalar charge and a specific optical construction need not be inferred.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","paperId":"2603.09816","textSha256":"335b550de1ce8282fae259a249eb28594cf0558e12d4689bd40a6fe769cc2d17"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0059:u10:q21"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0059:u10:q21","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"8863a87cbace3351bf2aa92aea793c42479273046857937e951d3efe73639534","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0059:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0059:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","paperId":"2603.09816","textSha256":"335b550de1ce8282fae259a249eb28594cf0558e12d4689bd40a6fe769cc2d17"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0059","unitRef":"u10"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e1407b9cdf71e84033922dd1","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","textSha256":"335b550de1ce8282fae259a249eb28594cf0558e12d4689bd40a6fe769cc2d17"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:89a04b619c439f174ef6b013","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Relaxation, optics and an adopted distance-conjecture cutoff require separate facet checks; WGC is not stated. Independent challenge qualification: Replace pf34/pf29: scalar charge and photon-sphere diagnostics are unspecified. Relaxation, optics and an adopted distance cutoff require facet reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:89a04b619c439f174ef6b013","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","q025-candidate-question:e1407b9cdf71e84033922dd1"],"scopeContentSha256":"2cf40a960ac3d34b5bb7eaf093efe3cebe69deccaf022865527e7a79d8f06e95","contributionContentSha256":"841ad2331c2c252c1d5bed7efe0a9c3c9bb5ebe359ad6c7782d7c871d3e96dd0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:59ac709063854ee50babdf7c25b724f03fbcf7aa288fc732235c6ecbedcd97dd","textSha256":"335b550de1ce8282fae259a249eb28594cf0558e12d4689bd40a6fe769cc2d17"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:89a04b619c439f174ef6b013","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Relaxation, optics and an adopted distance-conjecture cutoff require separate facet checks; WGC is not stated.","challengeNote":"Replace pf34/pf29: scalar charge and photon-sphere diagnostics are unspecified. Relaxation, optics and an adopted distance cutoff require facet reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"2f3d83bc7c595fb2e55c7a3691b54397c912a15db56ba6aef00a2b796ef97c03"},"organizational-access:41408aa1faac0e1bfc77c067":{"id":"organizational-access:41408aa1faac0e1bfc77c067","source":"q025-candidate-region:6d24a523c4c21070c56e84a3","target":"q025-candidate-question:10ff9531bed3ce83b82bd269","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:6d24a523c4c21070c56e84a3","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"558bf8930fb3071950d960ab60a8a0ed5f4fedf3e0db2b4632869359c8d74be2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c41037fbc11aab5314d8f88c"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:10ff9531bed3ce83b82bd269","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"007d8e471c0e3c88122aa21be112e65ac036fcc90db25f80798d64db80b3d52c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:09e9cce5c45b981cf840333e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:f6ffdaf511ed5c765e6752c83ea51cd536f512ef62d58d04838a9ddde016f71a","home":{"unitId":"unit:f6ffdaf511ed5c765e6752c83ea51cd536f512ef62d58d04838a9ddde016f71a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:6d24a523c4c21070c56e84a3","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f6ffdaf511ed5c765e6752c83ea51cd536f512ef62d58d04838a9ddde016f71a","paperId":"2007.10353","textSha256":"c28e76f0d446faa0177e82573ee8d0c609b9d325890c0ffc136ad82c726a72fa"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f14e681244b37bd0259a3e8a"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f14e681244b37bd0259a3e8a","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f6ffdaf511ed5c765e6752c83ea51cd536f512ef62d58d04838a9ddde016f71a","q025-candidate-region:6d24a523c4c21070c56e84a3"],"scopeContentSha256":"558bf8930fb3071950d960ab60a8a0ed5f4fedf3e0db2b4632869359c8d74be2","placementContentSha256":"d199a3cd5cd30f7fbaf7cd93281aa3f644e5aff2cbcb6bea0f0048e03bc1871e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-challenge","leaf-9e99731da66ff8cbcbc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f6ffdaf511ed5c765e6752c83ea51cd536f512ef62d58d04838a9ddde016f71a","paperId":"2007.10353","textSha256":"c28e76f0d446faa0177e82573ee8d0c609b9d325890c0ffc136ad82c726a72fa"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f14e681244b37bd0259a3e8a"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f6ffdaf511ed5c765e6752c83ea51cd536f512ef62d58d04838a9ddde016f71a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:10ff9531bed3ce83b82bd269","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:f6ffdaf511ed5c765e6752c83ea51cd536f512ef62d58d04838a9ddde016f71a","textSha256":"c28e76f0d446faa0177e82573ee8d0c609b9d325890c0ffc136ad82c726a72fa"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0328f2325fff732aebd46cd7722ac3ae","paperId":"2007.10353","sourceSha256":"d1aef42e902f59ec32d34e699e1f145d7cdc097a48b80209e4c070c39f18a0bb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/caf92ef774e0bc0d1a35/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3253cb405f88c7d8acaa5e270863ef0851679f15092316dfc4a9c302e6c3f7b3","pdfPage":1,"start":3697,"end":5649,"textSha256":"543bf56c3d58397a67e43c23d4709f0bc630fbc8e220f380c92fb465b388bf45","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:133f36ed921a47c6f6c56854a2d94a1e","paperId":"2007.10353","sourceSha256":"d1aef42e902f59ec32d34e699e1f145d7cdc097a48b80209e4c070c39f18a0bb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/caf92ef774e0bc0d1a35/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3253cb405f88c7d8acaa5e270863ef0851679f15092316dfc4a9c302e6c3f7b3","pdfPage":1,"start":101,"end":3502,"textSha256":"b925c0e4f6b0281f8f0e214074514e964578c11b2189fe8cdbe016e4514e0694","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3d9def972ed38b087763058461f3c68f","paperId":"2007.10353","sourceSha256":"d1aef42e902f59ec32d34e699e1f145d7cdc097a48b80209e4c070c39f18a0bb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/caf92ef774e0bc0d1a35/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3253cb405f88c7d8acaa5e270863ef0851679f15092316dfc4a9c302e6c3f7b3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"cdd74ec72349c4de557fc2c984b2db9d894e6008d7de609182b21908646eb306","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c07d03f01363b18c75a85190"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c07d03f01363b18c75a85190","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f6ffdaf511ed5c765e6752c83ea51cd536f512ef62d58d04838a9ddde016f71a","q025-candidate-question:10ff9531bed3ce83b82bd269"],"scopeContentSha256":"007d8e471c0e3c88122aa21be112e65ac036fcc90db25f80798d64db80b3d52c","contributionContentSha256":"ac43c1e61dbb9c9127f0afad414209f92c112680f751596878c72bbd04214aac","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-50c9b094473c1f94566a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-50c9b094473c1f94566a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-50c9b094473c1f94566a-proposal","leaf-50c9b094473c1f94566a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:f6ffdaf511ed5c765e6752c83ea51cd536f512ef62d58d04838a9ddde016f71a","textSha256":"c28e76f0d446faa0177e82573ee8d0c609b9d325890c0ffc136ad82c726a72fa"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:0328f2325fff732aebd46cd7722ac3ae","paperId":"2007.10353","sourceSha256":"d1aef42e902f59ec32d34e699e1f145d7cdc097a48b80209e4c070c39f18a0bb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/caf92ef774e0bc0d1a35/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3253cb405f88c7d8acaa5e270863ef0851679f15092316dfc4a9c302e6c3f7b3","pdfPage":1,"start":3697,"end":5649,"textSha256":"543bf56c3d58397a67e43c23d4709f0bc630fbc8e220f380c92fb465b388bf45","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:133f36ed921a47c6f6c56854a2d94a1e","paperId":"2007.10353","sourceSha256":"d1aef42e902f59ec32d34e699e1f145d7cdc097a48b80209e4c070c39f18a0bb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/caf92ef774e0bc0d1a35/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3253cb405f88c7d8acaa5e270863ef0851679f15092316dfc4a9c302e6c3f7b3","pdfPage":1,"start":101,"end":3502,"textSha256":"b925c0e4f6b0281f8f0e214074514e964578c11b2189fe8cdbe016e4514e0694","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3d9def972ed38b087763058461f3c68f","paperId":"2007.10353","sourceSha256":"d1aef42e902f59ec32d34e699e1f145d7cdc097a48b80209e4c070c39f18a0bb","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/caf92ef774e0bc0d1a35/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3253cb405f88c7d8acaa5e270863ef0851679f15092316dfc4a9c302e6c3f7b3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"cdd74ec72349c4de557fc2c984b2db9d894e6008d7de609182b21908646eb306","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c07d03f01363b18c75a85190","recordId":"leaf-50c9b094473c1f94566a-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-50c9b094473c1f94566a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-50c9b094473c1f94566a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Review spans fixed-point evidence, matter stability, locality and unitarity; no single fine question is selected.","challengeNote":"The review spans fixed-point evidence, matter stability, locality and unitarity; no single fine question is selected.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"88776cbf31194387e2797110372a1885aaaef170bed3beae0adacd90bbbec195"},"organizational-access:e01dbf39a68b9ed77f0fb223":{"id":"organizational-access:e01dbf39a68b9ed77f0fb223","source":"q025-candidate-region:73d009b239ae2691f97baeba","target":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:73d009b239ae2691f97baeba","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"14df7ab3a8dde0d7f559b16fbb33717470615fe920ef114a0a2cee2eaad7ce18","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:22ef24b2d9d5d9b81530d689"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"adf1ee534d57caec5e7868f6f95c54a002a09499317c7dda1ce59f29ca8df25a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5bbec5a65f9296d400aa6b08"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:06190326ea6557dddf43224caad297e2d6d26f18696ed51af1f77bea3720db49","home":{"unitId":"unit:06190326ea6557dddf43224caad297e2d6d26f18696ed51af1f77bea3720db49","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:73d009b239ae2691f97baeba","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:06190326ea6557dddf43224caad297e2d6d26f18696ed51af1f77bea3720db49","paperId":"1002.4340","textSha256":"19161da953ceb095a8195dc7f4b0a65d5941f6428f91388f54d3520e0dd365d7"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4cdf16635843a42f191b4e218005394d","paperId":"1002.4340","sourceSha256":"98f7fba129f9c565f12b52d04cc09968d66de21cd450640190219d500c1a5e3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/91ea9f76c8fc8539441d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c35ad51fc548a0d792b8700ca9a213152530d0427d47c7274fe3807a300a71e","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b65c494111169ae281b8e3554ecef9a71142114732e550b794d52da19cb37682","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4f372bc095156957144132bfb4ac4eac","paperId":"1002.4340","sourceSha256":"98f7fba129f9c565f12b52d04cc09968d66de21cd450640190219d500c1a5e3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/91ea9f76c8fc8539441d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c35ad51fc548a0d792b8700ca9a213152530d0427d47c7274fe3807a300a71e","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"019198d221741c270ef753107c78523a601bb3137e465aefd261b6647e017af7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a3fedc12f0fd14a1324750ad"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a3fedc12f0fd14a1324750ad","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:06190326ea6557dddf43224caad297e2d6d26f18696ed51af1f77bea3720db49","q025-candidate-region:73d009b239ae2691f97baeba"],"scopeContentSha256":"14df7ab3a8dde0d7f559b16fbb33717470615fe920ef114a0a2cee2eaad7ce18","placementContentSha256":"a176c1261eb613c72c6a46deaf6e8860160d4b6fb0d627f32be4226742338e61","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge","leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:06190326ea6557dddf43224caad297e2d6d26f18696ed51af1f77bea3720db49","paperId":"1002.4340","textSha256":"19161da953ceb095a8195dc7f4b0a65d5941f6428f91388f54d3520e0dd365d7"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4cdf16635843a42f191b4e218005394d","paperId":"1002.4340","sourceSha256":"98f7fba129f9c565f12b52d04cc09968d66de21cd450640190219d500c1a5e3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/91ea9f76c8fc8539441d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c35ad51fc548a0d792b8700ca9a213152530d0427d47c7274fe3807a300a71e","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b65c494111169ae281b8e3554ecef9a71142114732e550b794d52da19cb37682","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4f372bc095156957144132bfb4ac4eac","paperId":"1002.4340","sourceSha256":"98f7fba129f9c565f12b52d04cc09968d66de21cd450640190219d500c1a5e3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/91ea9f76c8fc8539441d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c35ad51fc548a0d792b8700ca9a213152530d0427d47c7274fe3807a300a71e","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"019198d221741c270ef753107c78523a601bb3137e465aefd261b6647e017af7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a3fedc12f0fd14a1324750ad"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:06190326ea6557dddf43224caad297e2d6d26f18696ed51af1f77bea3720db49","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:06190326ea6557dddf43224caad297e2d6d26f18696ed51af1f77bea3720db49","textSha256":"19161da953ceb095a8195dc7f4b0a65d5941f6428f91388f54d3520e0dd365d7"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4cdf16635843a42f191b4e218005394d","paperId":"1002.4340","sourceSha256":"98f7fba129f9c565f12b52d04cc09968d66de21cd450640190219d500c1a5e3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/91ea9f76c8fc8539441d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c35ad51fc548a0d792b8700ca9a213152530d0427d47c7274fe3807a300a71e","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b65c494111169ae281b8e3554ecef9a71142114732e550b794d52da19cb37682","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4f372bc095156957144132bfb4ac4eac","paperId":"1002.4340","sourceSha256":"98f7fba129f9c565f12b52d04cc09968d66de21cd450640190219d500c1a5e3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/91ea9f76c8fc8539441d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c35ad51fc548a0d792b8700ca9a213152530d0427d47c7274fe3807a300a71e","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"019198d221741c270ef753107c78523a601bb3137e465aefd261b6647e017af7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8895304003558d7e84c6aeb4","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Flow-wide properties and small-hole mass construction are compound targets; small holes lack the stated interior critical points. Independent challenge qualification: Compound flow-wide properties and small-hole mass construction. The stated small-hole sector lacks an interior critical point and has a boundary runaway."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8895304003558d7e84c6aeb4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:06190326ea6557dddf43224caad297e2d6d26f18696ed51af1f77bea3720db49","q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c"],"scopeContentSha256":"adf1ee534d57caec5e7868f6f95c54a002a09499317c7dda1ce59f29ca8df25a","contributionContentSha256":"76abb1249154c3ac976625efdcac0906e9e993d71e289e37c34991270ef9d233","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal","leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:06190326ea6557dddf43224caad297e2d6d26f18696ed51af1f77bea3720db49","textSha256":"19161da953ceb095a8195dc7f4b0a65d5941f6428f91388f54d3520e0dd365d7"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4cdf16635843a42f191b4e218005394d","paperId":"1002.4340","sourceSha256":"98f7fba129f9c565f12b52d04cc09968d66de21cd450640190219d500c1a5e3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/91ea9f76c8fc8539441d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c35ad51fc548a0d792b8700ca9a213152530d0427d47c7274fe3807a300a71e","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"b65c494111169ae281b8e3554ecef9a71142114732e550b794d52da19cb37682","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4f372bc095156957144132bfb4ac4eac","paperId":"1002.4340","sourceSha256":"98f7fba129f9c565f12b52d04cc09968d66de21cd450640190219d500c1a5e3a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/91ea9f76c8fc8539441d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c35ad51fc548a0d792b8700ca9a213152530d0427d47c7274fe3807a300a71e","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"019198d221741c270ef753107c78523a601bb3137e465aefd261b6647e017af7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8895304003558d7e84c6aeb4","recordId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Flow-wide properties and small-hole mass construction are compound targets; small holes lack the stated interior critical points.","challengeNote":"Compound flow-wide properties and small-hole mass construction. The stated small-hole sector lacks an interior critical point and has a boundary runaway.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:1f6894b64b171d7633fbedb836da22d139929ff67c7464ac85a329ac7945a845","home":{"unitId":"unit:1f6894b64b171d7633fbedb836da22d139929ff67c7464ac85a329ac7945a845","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:73d009b239ae2691f97baeba","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1f6894b64b171d7633fbedb836da22d139929ff67c7464ac85a329ac7945a845","paperId":"1106.2611","textSha256":"8aee1091b32270057fd16139e2579a698a094acba448b565d6ef628e5fa5c4e6"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc55015079d7673ad87ee03e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc55015079d7673ad87ee03e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1f6894b64b171d7633fbedb836da22d139929ff67c7464ac85a329ac7945a845","q025-candidate-region:73d009b239ae2691f97baeba"],"scopeContentSha256":"14df7ab3a8dde0d7f559b16fbb33717470615fe920ef114a0a2cee2eaad7ce18","placementContentSha256":"be29e39b4b07687e126be8b53f089dcd8b12c0e3cea05f276323c4f8a01eed67","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge","leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1f6894b64b171d7633fbedb836da22d139929ff67c7464ac85a329ac7945a845","paperId":"1106.2611","textSha256":"8aee1091b32270057fd16139e2579a698a094acba448b565d6ef628e5fa5c4e6"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc55015079d7673ad87ee03e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1f6894b64b171d7633fbedb836da22d139929ff67c7464ac85a329ac7945a845","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:1f6894b64b171d7633fbedb836da22d139929ff67c7464ac85a329ac7945a845","textSha256":"8aee1091b32270057fd16139e2579a698a094acba448b565d6ef628e5fa5c4e6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:76cbbce4936be9bc39b0168e","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Survey-scale compound scope spans flows, attractors, duality and multiple centres; an atomic identity is unresolved. Independent challenge qualification: Survey-scale compound scope; atomic identities across flow, attraction, duality and multicentre organization remain unresolved."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:76cbbce4936be9bc39b0168e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1f6894b64b171d7633fbedb836da22d139929ff67c7464ac85a329ac7945a845","q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c"],"scopeContentSha256":"adf1ee534d57caec5e7868f6f95c54a002a09499317c7dda1ce59f29ca8df25a","contributionContentSha256":"a7bf3e1e7539186d8649428ff2216ac873585fef1d9d22cab574bd8aa19730d3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal","leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:1f6894b64b171d7633fbedb836da22d139929ff67c7464ac85a329ac7945a845","textSha256":"8aee1091b32270057fd16139e2579a698a094acba448b565d6ef628e5fa5c4e6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:76cbbce4936be9bc39b0168e","recordId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Survey-scale compound scope spans flows, attractors, duality and multiple centres; an atomic identity is unresolved.","challengeNote":"Survey-scale compound scope; atomic identities across flow, attraction, duality and multicentre organization remain unresolved.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:54d81b36d210085443584b65f5f1c1487f796ca4f909c5b48972b5dab2873c71","home":{"unitId":"unit:54d81b36d210085443584b65f5f1c1487f796ca4f909c5b48972b5dab2873c71","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:73d009b239ae2691f97baeba","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:54d81b36d210085443584b65f5f1c1487f796ca4f909c5b48972b5dab2873c71","paperId":"0707.0105","textSha256":"c7d5b427138c541fd8ac8c8cbbc6d34d0280b6c9af69f7a3aea0f76ec56a598f"},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f7db4534c7c26b9a00b80c8b5fbcc161","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":16,"start":0,"end":2640,"textSha256":"178579fc47c9058518380927985a7d7c19beb9a31fbafa2dfc6c922ac80008ea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6fdbec3558e9e245d24e4ca696de4daf","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":22,"start":1301,"end":3155,"textSha256":"b04fe3e26449e7caccc3a99176b7826c1c52bb25adc7ff6c3194a5172268d321","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3f75678cd4b9ae5612264ae6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3f75678cd4b9ae5612264ae6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:54d81b36d210085443584b65f5f1c1487f796ca4f909c5b48972b5dab2873c71","q025-candidate-region:73d009b239ae2691f97baeba"],"scopeContentSha256":"14df7ab3a8dde0d7f559b16fbb33717470615fe920ef114a0a2cee2eaad7ce18","placementContentSha256":"5241bd7d2f261d63d1231637897d69bc2650000bde27b038d02281db03dfa220","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge","leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:54d81b36d210085443584b65f5f1c1487f796ca4f909c5b48972b5dab2873c71","paperId":"0707.0105","textSha256":"c7d5b427138c541fd8ac8c8cbbc6d34d0280b6c9af69f7a3aea0f76ec56a598f"},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f7db4534c7c26b9a00b80c8b5fbcc161","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":16,"start":0,"end":2640,"textSha256":"178579fc47c9058518380927985a7d7c19beb9a31fbafa2dfc6c922ac80008ea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6fdbec3558e9e245d24e4ca696de4daf","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":22,"start":1301,"end":3155,"textSha256":"b04fe3e26449e7caccc3a99176b7826c1c52bb25adc7ff6c3194a5172268d321","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3f75678cd4b9ae5612264ae6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:54d81b36d210085443584b65f5f1c1487f796ca4f909c5b48972b5dab2873c71","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:54d81b36d210085443584b65f5f1c1487f796ca4f909c5b48972b5dab2873c71","textSha256":"c7d5b427138c541fd8ac8c8cbbc6d34d0280b6c9af69f7a3aea0f76ec56a598f"},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f7db4534c7c26b9a00b80c8b5fbcc161","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":16,"start":0,"end":2640,"textSha256":"178579fc47c9058518380927985a7d7c19beb9a31fbafa2dfc6c922ac80008ea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6fdbec3558e9e245d24e4ca696de4daf","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":22,"start":1301,"end":3155,"textSha256":"b04fe3e26449e7caccc3a99176b7826c1c52bb25adc7ff6c3194a5172268d321","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b2bb45b2f42c28df44870ba9","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound identity: inverse charges and distinct generators for the same potential require separate reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Compound identity: inverse charges and nonunique superpotentials are separate targets. Charge integrality is relaxed in the stated inverse problem."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b2bb45b2f42c28df44870ba9","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:54d81b36d210085443584b65f5f1c1487f796ca4f909c5b48972b5dab2873c71","q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c"],"scopeContentSha256":"adf1ee534d57caec5e7868f6f95c54a002a09499317c7dda1ce59f29ca8df25a","contributionContentSha256":"a74c615924e65fad84fcc71342633d797e76928fca3bd07bec107c31c1838c3f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal","leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:54d81b36d210085443584b65f5f1c1487f796ca4f909c5b48972b5dab2873c71","textSha256":"c7d5b427138c541fd8ac8c8cbbc6d34d0280b6c9af69f7a3aea0f76ec56a598f"},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f7db4534c7c26b9a00b80c8b5fbcc161","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":16,"start":0,"end":2640,"textSha256":"178579fc47c9058518380927985a7d7c19beb9a31fbafa2dfc6c922ac80008ea","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6fdbec3558e9e245d24e4ca696de4daf","paperId":"0707.0105","sourceSha256":"fc8e4bc2e9274df876622ee2822a617f995baa9e6b902d451bcd3b59c6ffad34","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e500bc0da83fe3d1a6a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bfd34357fde02f16e94df32f340fcbcfa8548e8adcae2c793ae34bde9c84ea27","pdfPage":22,"start":1301,"end":3155,"textSha256":"b04fe3e26449e7caccc3a99176b7826c1c52bb25adc7ff6c3194a5172268d321","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b2bb45b2f42c28df44870ba9","recordId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound identity: inverse charges and distinct generators for the same potential require separate reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Compound identity: inverse charges and nonunique superpotentials are separate targets. Charge integrality is relaxed in the stated inverse problem.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d51acc6431d81cacf2749e55a85e9164e55568157504350c84560c11c9cd7f21","home":{"unitId":"unit:d51acc6431d81cacf2749e55a85e9164e55568157504350c84560c11c9cd7f21","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:73d009b239ae2691f97baeba","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d51acc6431d81cacf2749e55a85e9164e55568157504350c84560c11c9cd7f21","paperId":"0905.3938","textSha256":"4678a18c8aed8ab89c37ffdb9efebc25fdc6c0b49d6512adfdd29408c253c520"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:775a062e9bac7564afa8ce70"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:775a062e9bac7564afa8ce70","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d51acc6431d81cacf2749e55a85e9164e55568157504350c84560c11c9cd7f21","q025-candidate-region:73d009b239ae2691f97baeba"],"scopeContentSha256":"14df7ab3a8dde0d7f559b16fbb33717470615fe920ef114a0a2cee2eaad7ce18","placementContentSha256":"d2701dd8f55d4092960eab651c8256fa2dd28f12eaf51e378b66a40308a51847","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge","leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d51acc6431d81cacf2749e55a85e9164e55568157504350c84560c11c9cd7f21","paperId":"0905.3938","textSha256":"4678a18c8aed8ab89c37ffdb9efebc25fdc6c0b49d6512adfdd29408c253c520"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:775a062e9bac7564afa8ce70"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d51acc6431d81cacf2749e55a85e9164e55568157504350c84560c11c9cd7f21","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:d51acc6431d81cacf2749e55a85e9164e55568157504350c84560c11c9cd7f21","textSha256":"4678a18c8aed8ab89c37ffdb9efebc25fdc6c0b49d6512adfdd29408c253c520"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c40134a3d826032de04f4e21","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Existence, duality, monotonicity and multiple-attractor Hessian tests remain distinguishable targets. Independent challenge qualification: Existence, duality, monotonicity and multiple-attractor Hessian tests form a compound source question."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c40134a3d826032de04f4e21","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d51acc6431d81cacf2749e55a85e9164e55568157504350c84560c11c9cd7f21","q025-candidate-question:f439c38f8c08c59fba69bf2c"],"scopeContentSha256":"adf1ee534d57caec5e7868f6f95c54a002a09499317c7dda1ce59f29ca8df25a","contributionContentSha256":"90dcb2561a17643284b85bdeadfe0be5b402e03ca2cef691f31325c1a33af32f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal","leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:d51acc6431d81cacf2749e55a85e9164e55568157504350c84560c11c9cd7f21","textSha256":"4678a18c8aed8ab89c37ffdb9efebc25fdc6c0b49d6512adfdd29408c253c520"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c40134a3d826032de04f4e21","recordId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-809d9c2ad4a9038e31c9-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Existence, duality, monotonicity and multiple-attractor Hessian tests remain distinguishable targets.","challengeNote":"Existence, duality, monotonicity and multiple-attractor Hessian tests form a compound source question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":4,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"82a9f40c384798ab9c8fa16234cb741a95027663d579f33019d0f4e66b21cfdd"},"organizational-access:af53b49845f43fe36b1e511f":{"id":"organizational-access:af53b49845f43fe36b1e511f","source":"q025-candidate-region:7b614634ab6daa5c973dec85","target":"q025-candidate-question:02adc31e40e06be6c5ae591a","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:7b614634ab6daa5c973dec85","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"df2a02064de8c227854dce39edc472544c28acae17135c0e58fc539e75ff190b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:df7c1d438496d3b7585bce8f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:02adc31e40e06be6c5ae591a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a1d63d1a9cc4260d72f18c715654d66fd4324d92342a71ef52c6bf8b6beeec18","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ad9cffb8095ee63277092ce6"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5b0886a6f1551fb995867959a6c244b54a8b6e817e6336d5158edf9232e86f56","home":{"unitId":"unit:5b0886a6f1551fb995867959a6c244b54a8b6e817e6336d5158edf9232e86f56","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:7b614634ab6daa5c973dec85","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5b0886a6f1551fb995867959a6c244b54a8b6e817e6336d5158edf9232e86f56","paperId":"1210.2590","textSha256":"3ef79aed764fab4d5d1e882ad715b0d99f52e1bdcc3ca5229d40f76ea1f02bbd"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b5e4beba571a17e7a0ecc712d3748a25","paperId":"1210.2590","sourceSha256":"060d5b0d180088fa2b3dd5c02e5245d433702bc809abf501d995c389587e5ee2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c1c17e3db61972d5216d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"67e1282a73d21892157edb837ee1d36ee53a421510652b0dcb19097293fffb5e","pdfPage":1,"start":108,"end":1784,"textSha256":"8478638725a3f19abe92b2b2884fec5a2699362efe8b7263a89efff22036c40b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f1fdb58183c7d26eb3aa92930f3d48dc","paperId":"1210.2590","sourceSha256":"060d5b0d180088fa2b3dd5c02e5245d433702bc809abf501d995c389587e5ee2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c1c17e3db61972d5216d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"67e1282a73d21892157edb837ee1d36ee53a421510652b0dcb19097293fffb5e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1784,"textSha256":"eaa1e00b7106fa9e0de3c166f17c96fa04de87938a551dd05789a84fe74e47de","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0308ebd6dd6887b52cfe8e60"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0308ebd6dd6887b52cfe8e60","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5b0886a6f1551fb995867959a6c244b54a8b6e817e6336d5158edf9232e86f56","q025-candidate-region:7b614634ab6daa5c973dec85"],"scopeContentSha256":"df2a02064de8c227854dce39edc472544c28acae17135c0e58fc539e75ff190b","placementContentSha256":"59595788348bf48b73f89065239a20423ac98a13f556761edf594afaeb2c740e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge","leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5b0886a6f1551fb995867959a6c244b54a8b6e817e6336d5158edf9232e86f56","paperId":"1210.2590","textSha256":"3ef79aed764fab4d5d1e882ad715b0d99f52e1bdcc3ca5229d40f76ea1f02bbd"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b5e4beba571a17e7a0ecc712d3748a25","paperId":"1210.2590","sourceSha256":"060d5b0d180088fa2b3dd5c02e5245d433702bc809abf501d995c389587e5ee2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c1c17e3db61972d5216d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"67e1282a73d21892157edb837ee1d36ee53a421510652b0dcb19097293fffb5e","pdfPage":1,"start":108,"end":1784,"textSha256":"8478638725a3f19abe92b2b2884fec5a2699362efe8b7263a89efff22036c40b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f1fdb58183c7d26eb3aa92930f3d48dc","paperId":"1210.2590","sourceSha256":"060d5b0d180088fa2b3dd5c02e5245d433702bc809abf501d995c389587e5ee2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c1c17e3db61972d5216d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"67e1282a73d21892157edb837ee1d36ee53a421510652b0dcb19097293fffb5e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1784,"textSha256":"eaa1e00b7106fa9e0de3c166f17c96fa04de87938a551dd05789a84fe74e47de","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0308ebd6dd6887b52cfe8e60"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5b0886a6f1551fb995867959a6c244b54a8b6e817e6336d5158edf9232e86f56","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:02adc31e40e06be6c5ae591a","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:5b0886a6f1551fb995867959a6c244b54a8b6e817e6336d5158edf9232e86f56","textSha256":"3ef79aed764fab4d5d1e882ad715b0d99f52e1bdcc3ca5229d40f76ea1f02bbd"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b5e4beba571a17e7a0ecc712d3748a25","paperId":"1210.2590","sourceSha256":"060d5b0d180088fa2b3dd5c02e5245d433702bc809abf501d995c389587e5ee2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c1c17e3db61972d5216d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"67e1282a73d21892157edb837ee1d36ee53a421510652b0dcb19097293fffb5e","pdfPage":1,"start":108,"end":1784,"textSha256":"8478638725a3f19abe92b2b2884fec5a2699362efe8b7263a89efff22036c40b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f1fdb58183c7d26eb3aa92930f3d48dc","paperId":"1210.2590","sourceSha256":"060d5b0d180088fa2b3dd5c02e5245d433702bc809abf501d995c389587e5ee2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c1c17e3db61972d5216d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"67e1282a73d21892157edb837ee1d36ee53a421510652b0dcb19097293fffb5e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1784,"textSha256":"eaa1e00b7106fa9e0de3c166f17c96fa04de87938a551dd05789a84fe74e47de","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ffe3fe5abf5de5bdd5c79137"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ffe3fe5abf5de5bdd5c79137","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5b0886a6f1551fb995867959a6c244b54a8b6e817e6336d5158edf9232e86f56","q025-candidate-question:02adc31e40e06be6c5ae591a"],"scopeContentSha256":"a1d63d1a9cc4260d72f18c715654d66fd4324d92342a71ef52c6bf8b6beeec18","contributionContentSha256":"54229324f94c1712e8994de513a807da9e292f434f6f80cb9456c364949ccaff","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-proposal","leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:5b0886a6f1551fb995867959a6c244b54a8b6e817e6336d5158edf9232e86f56","textSha256":"3ef79aed764fab4d5d1e882ad715b0d99f52e1bdcc3ca5229d40f76ea1f02bbd"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b5e4beba571a17e7a0ecc712d3748a25","paperId":"1210.2590","sourceSha256":"060d5b0d180088fa2b3dd5c02e5245d433702bc809abf501d995c389587e5ee2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c1c17e3db61972d5216d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"67e1282a73d21892157edb837ee1d36ee53a421510652b0dcb19097293fffb5e","pdfPage":1,"start":108,"end":1784,"textSha256":"8478638725a3f19abe92b2b2884fec5a2699362efe8b7263a89efff22036c40b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f1fdb58183c7d26eb3aa92930f3d48dc","paperId":"1210.2590","sourceSha256":"060d5b0d180088fa2b3dd5c02e5245d433702bc809abf501d995c389587e5ee2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c1c17e3db61972d5216d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"67e1282a73d21892157edb837ee1d36ee53a421510652b0dcb19097293fffb5e","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1784,"textSha256":"eaa1e00b7106fa9e0de3c166f17c96fa04de87938a551dd05789a84fe74e47de","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ffe3fe5abf5de5bdd5c79137","recordId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Construction, large-L limit and proposed orbifold equivalence are compound targets; the singleton preserves the source question.","challengeNote":"Construction, the large-L limit and proposed orbifold equivalence are compound targets; s preserves the exact source question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","home":{"unitId":"unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:7b614634ab6daa5c973dec85","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","paperId":"0803.4474","textSha256":"cf119116160ef8bf549a6fcd4ee1bd060a8033e04fefdcfe6ac0c23cc36d87c7"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:369523f7345594e0462c783811b5cf81","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1059,"textSha256":"30934071613d9a710c34ba34f2d5ba709e51ea2110116567bb127eb4ea1dcf3e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3620b2574e4c216a020bd7f5925690e","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":12,"start":99,"end":2764,"textSha256":"57f8d29781439657b7ad09fb9f9854739127909c924c5f2004149c0ed668ac95","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:22ba736db5983f0ec3581ba7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:22ba736db5983f0ec3581ba7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","q025-candidate-region:7b614634ab6daa5c973dec85"],"scopeContentSha256":"df2a02064de8c227854dce39edc472544c28acae17135c0e58fc539e75ff190b","placementContentSha256":"652d702aedfba6e352356c28ebd8b5d130913bda956fc3314047e1812f03c853","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge","leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","paperId":"0803.4474","textSha256":"cf119116160ef8bf549a6fcd4ee1bd060a8033e04fefdcfe6ac0c23cc36d87c7"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:369523f7345594e0462c783811b5cf81","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1059,"textSha256":"30934071613d9a710c34ba34f2d5ba709e51ea2110116567bb127eb4ea1dcf3e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3620b2574e4c216a020bd7f5925690e","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":12,"start":99,"end":2764,"textSha256":"57f8d29781439657b7ad09fb9f9854739127909c924c5f2004149c0ed668ac95","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:22ba736db5983f0ec3581ba7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:02adc31e40e06be6c5ae591a","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","textSha256":"cf119116160ef8bf549a6fcd4ee1bd060a8033e04fefdcfe6ac0c23cc36d87c7"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:369523f7345594e0462c783811b5cf81","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1059,"textSha256":"30934071613d9a710c34ba34f2d5ba709e51ea2110116567bb127eb4ea1dcf3e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3620b2574e4c216a020bd7f5925690e","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":12,"start":99,"end":2764,"textSha256":"57f8d29781439657b7ad09fb9f9854739127909c924c5f2004149c0ed668ac95","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7d1b134876c98ae496621358"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7d1b134876c98ae496621358","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","q025-candidate-question:02adc31e40e06be6c5ae591a"],"scopeContentSha256":"a1d63d1a9cc4260d72f18c715654d66fd4324d92342a71ef52c6bf8b6beeec18","contributionContentSha256":"91be0eb679c41f0a769918427f190346a030276d3ae5e0864a6b85092b3a7c2e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-proposal","leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:a3cd529270028d86dd8b5cd5c4a821af6aed1a631605ddc7eb31c980e3a93b6f","textSha256":"cf119116160ef8bf549a6fcd4ee1bd060a8033e04fefdcfe6ac0c23cc36d87c7"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:369523f7345594e0462c783811b5cf81","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1059,"textSha256":"30934071613d9a710c34ba34f2d5ba709e51ea2110116567bb127eb4ea1dcf3e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3620b2574e4c216a020bd7f5925690e","paperId":"0803.4474","sourceSha256":"bf69a63831fd9bccc255d84c8ebc1e20311a328aea07026509c7494ac269c7ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4cf73b0fc860cf989026/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b4e155fa2ff54364ad65da9a9ebe39ff101889066dbe0d8942338ebbce3ec016","pdfPage":12,"start":99,"end":2764,"textSha256":"57f8d29781439657b7ad09fb9f9854739127909c924c5f2004149c0ed668ac95","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7d1b134876c98ae496621358","recordId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5cfdc2682c70266ad55a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound encoding, central-charge/volume matching and homological-mirror-symmetry targets require finer reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Encoding, central-charge/volume matching and homological mirror symmetry are compound targets requiring finer reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"587fc7699f5f9343321b89ccecabfc28a6f0240d502cdbb154c4466b2a0add74"},"organizational-access:9ab2ded88d4f487d698645b3":{"id":"organizational-access:9ab2ded88d4f487d698645b3","source":"q025-candidate-region:81066fcb454d8f1a3a7754dd","target":"q025-candidate-question:c3c6165e67d9ef91bb120d5b","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:81066fcb454d8f1a3a7754dd","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"925dd4dc8120dfbc46f6bfbac0710713a1238b06073d14a618528ae1f968f1f6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0b66cecf09332982408b26e7"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c3c6165e67d9ef91bb120d5b","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"93c081b206e7e00b37922d7fc54663c2caa8ab49891f5f1159f39e7f1e4689e5","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c0747dd0aed4f8c3ee100d81"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0cd34dbc398d14f0adccf778cdf3c7382394205c8579313f87f8e8d71fbac62b","home":{"unitId":"unit:0cd34dbc398d14f0adccf778cdf3c7382394205c8579313f87f8e8d71fbac62b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:81066fcb454d8f1a3a7754dd","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0cd34dbc398d14f0adccf778cdf3c7382394205c8579313f87f8e8d71fbac62b","paperId":"1912.03245","textSha256":"c653f98fd0b8bdb53c24e94e22765d74a3bf7b320c5e07aafef334016d25aa91"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:47fa35c0b07026e02273f7b47f004f29","paperId":"1912.03245","sourceSha256":"7f0e3548009f35991fe9c18dbf0bf6f3978b36171c04ac16989789b64122d914","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bd3c729af4cdac0cf80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"725dc1c45b20cc0838a2970136407158324acadeaad1c32425b87658bad7b2a9","pdfPage":3,"start":1292,"end":3766,"textSha256":"780500126c79b976606429f08df6c73a28e902ec92bc304978a89047cf2f3bb0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:54c5a7f6e89b82f0332d493f615f51f4","paperId":"1912.03245","sourceSha256":"7f0e3548009f35991fe9c18dbf0bf6f3978b36171c04ac16989789b64122d914","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bd3c729af4cdac0cf80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"725dc1c45b20cc0838a2970136407158324acadeaad1c32425b87658bad7b2a9","pdfPage":2,"start":1304,"end":3092,"textSha256":"f962a7f39cb8ea8d500bd7890c2710bc45a7c6aeb68de091ce03311142be88ee","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9b37ec89b58ae2d8a52e6dd0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9b37ec89b58ae2d8a52e6dd0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0cd34dbc398d14f0adccf778cdf3c7382394205c8579313f87f8e8d71fbac62b","q025-candidate-region:81066fcb454d8f1a3a7754dd"],"scopeContentSha256":"925dd4dc8120dfbc46f6bfbac0710713a1238b06073d14a618528ae1f968f1f6","placementContentSha256":"a5df838d28a7001968a0ef0d578ed552a546abc93ff17e832e8ff8464c830599","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-challenge","leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0cd34dbc398d14f0adccf778cdf3c7382394205c8579313f87f8e8d71fbac62b","paperId":"1912.03245","textSha256":"c653f98fd0b8bdb53c24e94e22765d74a3bf7b320c5e07aafef334016d25aa91"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:47fa35c0b07026e02273f7b47f004f29","paperId":"1912.03245","sourceSha256":"7f0e3548009f35991fe9c18dbf0bf6f3978b36171c04ac16989789b64122d914","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bd3c729af4cdac0cf80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"725dc1c45b20cc0838a2970136407158324acadeaad1c32425b87658bad7b2a9","pdfPage":3,"start":1292,"end":3766,"textSha256":"780500126c79b976606429f08df6c73a28e902ec92bc304978a89047cf2f3bb0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:54c5a7f6e89b82f0332d493f615f51f4","paperId":"1912.03245","sourceSha256":"7f0e3548009f35991fe9c18dbf0bf6f3978b36171c04ac16989789b64122d914","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bd3c729af4cdac0cf80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"725dc1c45b20cc0838a2970136407158324acadeaad1c32425b87658bad7b2a9","pdfPage":2,"start":1304,"end":3092,"textSha256":"f962a7f39cb8ea8d500bd7890c2710bc45a7c6aeb68de091ce03311142be88ee","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9b37ec89b58ae2d8a52e6dd0"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0cd34dbc398d14f0adccf778cdf3c7382394205c8579313f87f8e8d71fbac62b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c3c6165e67d9ef91bb120d5b","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:0cd34dbc398d14f0adccf778cdf3c7382394205c8579313f87f8e8d71fbac62b","textSha256":"c653f98fd0b8bdb53c24e94e22765d74a3bf7b320c5e07aafef334016d25aa91"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:47fa35c0b07026e02273f7b47f004f29","paperId":"1912.03245","sourceSha256":"7f0e3548009f35991fe9c18dbf0bf6f3978b36171c04ac16989789b64122d914","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bd3c729af4cdac0cf80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"725dc1c45b20cc0838a2970136407158324acadeaad1c32425b87658bad7b2a9","pdfPage":3,"start":1292,"end":3766,"textSha256":"780500126c79b976606429f08df6c73a28e902ec92bc304978a89047cf2f3bb0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:54c5a7f6e89b82f0332d493f615f51f4","paperId":"1912.03245","sourceSha256":"7f0e3548009f35991fe9c18dbf0bf6f3978b36171c04ac16989789b64122d914","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bd3c729af4cdac0cf80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"725dc1c45b20cc0838a2970136407158324acadeaad1c32425b87658bad7b2a9","pdfPage":2,"start":1304,"end":3092,"textSha256":"f962a7f39cb8ea8d500bd7890c2710bc45a7c6aeb68de091ce03311142be88ee","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b1fb162f8c55d7d2c4274a67"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b1fb162f8c55d7d2c4274a67","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0cd34dbc398d14f0adccf778cdf3c7382394205c8579313f87f8e8d71fbac62b","q025-candidate-question:c3c6165e67d9ef91bb120d5b"],"scopeContentSha256":"93c081b206e7e00b37922d7fc54663c2caa8ab49891f5f1159f39e7f1e4689e5","contributionContentSha256":"dc1db7d293e64139380f29836698c05b3411668267060929fb866456c29df3d9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-proposal","leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:0cd34dbc398d14f0adccf778cdf3c7382394205c8579313f87f8e8d71fbac62b","textSha256":"c653f98fd0b8bdb53c24e94e22765d74a3bf7b320c5e07aafef334016d25aa91"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:47fa35c0b07026e02273f7b47f004f29","paperId":"1912.03245","sourceSha256":"7f0e3548009f35991fe9c18dbf0bf6f3978b36171c04ac16989789b64122d914","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bd3c729af4cdac0cf80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"725dc1c45b20cc0838a2970136407158324acadeaad1c32425b87658bad7b2a9","pdfPage":3,"start":1292,"end":3766,"textSha256":"780500126c79b976606429f08df6c73a28e902ec92bc304978a89047cf2f3bb0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:54c5a7f6e89b82f0332d493f615f51f4","paperId":"1912.03245","sourceSha256":"7f0e3548009f35991fe9c18dbf0bf6f3978b36171c04ac16989789b64122d914","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7bd3c729af4cdac0cf80/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"725dc1c45b20cc0838a2970136407158324acadeaad1c32425b87658bad7b2a9","pdfPage":2,"start":1304,"end":3092,"textSha256":"f962a7f39cb8ea8d500bd7890c2710bc45a7c6aeb68de091ce03311142be88ee","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b1fb162f8c55d7d2c4274a67","recordId":"leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Conditional inference from an active string background during temporary relic-driven matter domination.","challengeNote":"Inference assumes an active string source during temporary post-reheating relic domination, followed by decay before BBN.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4b902101796433693b787664aa23ed079c9cd5809ab4f7ada2049dc505b55999"},"organizational-access:c619f0702425d89a52578d4c":{"id":"organizational-access:c619f0702425d89a52578d4c","source":"q025-candidate-region:8574187d747387068f02fe63","target":"q025-candidate-question:267bafe177e2c0bcf415d2bc","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:8574187d747387068f02fe63","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"f09de89ad17b314d53c57c60d1ffb7ff3e77cdd6ea7ef20e64644f897046a079","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6f6097a91c0a6585d71fb2e6"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:267bafe177e2c0bcf415d2bc","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"0f22a08d96b74e07b207d5ed29ae28f0c6f2b3e85bbd2e42b48ef1a5bd5aabe6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f328dfb31dc83d127d801f3b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:aaeea2e7b3e0dbb44a4b72426688bf32370ee848f1048de7b76a9ff3a64931a6","home":{"unitId":"unit:aaeea2e7b3e0dbb44a4b72426688bf32370ee848f1048de7b76a9ff3a64931a6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8574187d747387068f02fe63","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q33 covers effective-potential organization, different vacuum signs, asymptotic limits, backreaction and quantitative control, with conjectural restrictions remaining questions.","qualification":"q33 covers potential classification, asymptotic effective descriptions, vacuum signs and backreaction/control questions. It permits asking whether the constraints extend beyond familiar limits without assuming that extension or importing a universal asymptotic theorem.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:aaeea2e7b3e0dbb44a4b72426688bf32370ee848f1048de7b76a9ff3a64931a6","paperId":"1910.09549","textSha256":"cc2be88c3ff0e1ab06f0d566df20f49831c625dc76bbf699d91f83bb43a3a1cf"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u5:q33"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0031:u5:q33","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:aaeea2e7b3e0dbb44a4b72426688bf32370ee848f1048de7b76a9ff3a64931a6","q025-candidate-region:8574187d747387068f02fe63"],"scopeContentSha256":"f09de89ad17b314d53c57c60d1ffb7ff3e77cdd6ea7ef20e64644f897046a079","placementContentSha256":"338660ef2ac29b82493fb8315c3b8721329f5ae7b1c54ab33ecd1fe352adca56","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0031:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:aaeea2e7b3e0dbb44a4b72426688bf32370ee848f1048de7b76a9ff3a64931a6","paperId":"1910.09549","textSha256":"cc2be88c3ff0e1ab06f0d566df20f49831c625dc76bbf699d91f83bb43a3a1cf"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0031","unitRef":"u5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:aaeea2e7b3e0dbb44a4b72426688bf32370ee848f1048de7b76a9ff3a64931a6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:267bafe177e2c0bcf415d2bc","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:aaeea2e7b3e0dbb44a4b72426688bf32370ee848f1048de7b76a9ff3a64931a6","textSha256":"cc2be88c3ff0e1ab06f0d566df20f49831c625dc76bbf699d91f83bb43a3a1cf"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:62c44aa4ac6d0d3b9903ba79"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:62c44aa4ac6d0d3b9903ba79","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:aaeea2e7b3e0dbb44a4b72426688bf32370ee848f1048de7b76a9ff3a64931a6","q025-candidate-question:267bafe177e2c0bcf415d2bc"],"scopeContentSha256":"0f22a08d96b74e07b207d5ed29ae28f0c6f2b3e85bbd2e42b48ef1a5bd5aabe6","contributionContentSha256":"8f562363c6cd821eda2517aea0336f29ba6243307475a6d02253a884c1cd965f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-proposal","leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:aaeea2e7b3e0dbb44a4b72426688bf32370ee848f1048de7b76a9ff3a64931a6","textSha256":"cc2be88c3ff0e1ab06f0d566df20f49831c625dc76bbf699d91f83bb43a3a1cf"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:62c44aa4ac6d0d3b9903ba79","recordId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-917023476c8ed7e389e0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: de Sitter constraints, controlled AdS sequences and axion backreaction. The proposed extension beyond familiar limits is itself under examination.","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound identity: de Sitter constraints, controlled AdS sequences and axion backreaction beyond familiar limits.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"448a5572cc710a7c037c93c78c967b3369cd48a4c2e6c5282e5dc33befebf612"},"organizational-access:a03fc5688281e2df5d6c1e21":{"id":"organizational-access:a03fc5688281e2df5d6c1e21","source":"q025-candidate-region:8ee745ee7d8712a471e1f8e9","target":"q025-candidate-question:53b99cbfc60fb7e3141505d2","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:8ee745ee7d8712a471e1f8e9","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"875223c9bb1f3d1dd1ccf5237c054ef5ba8bee9af42b4901e358753f2c00eb84","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3268b7c129e23846a7e98a41"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:53b99cbfc60fb7e3141505d2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"08fd5b8bd0b55cb07effe07e6ff5d725d1ffb2b58d5d1914c9f15a88a090f307","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e5286d56c30466a65b4e23b6"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:29f9084ff18400c98f4e84a337f085a65d8d99667d6e9a31e12a7d3eaeae6cf1","home":{"unitId":"unit:29f9084ff18400c98f4e84a337f085a65d8d99667d6e9a31e12a7d3eaeae6cf1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8ee745ee7d8712a471e1f8e9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:29f9084ff18400c98f4e84a337f085a65d8d99667d6e9a31e12a7d3eaeae6cf1","paperId":"2106.14580","textSha256":"1f252f4b0de0645c02040244954e1cb91f1b56edb003dd5c5e9ff5a8cd0cc8d6"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:003b214db072fb7a7d033d92"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:003b214db072fb7a7d033d92","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:29f9084ff18400c98f4e84a337f085a65d8d99667d6e9a31e12a7d3eaeae6cf1","q025-candidate-region:8ee745ee7d8712a471e1f8e9"],"scopeContentSha256":"875223c9bb1f3d1dd1ccf5237c054ef5ba8bee9af42b4901e358753f2c00eb84","placementContentSha256":"d772d7a1f9c32e689691a30d8918b9476a3967051e2c799114ba81f0e38c37b4","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-931e9f9ec613bf43c548-challenge","leaf-931e9f9ec613bf43c548-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:29f9084ff18400c98f4e84a337f085a65d8d99667d6e9a31e12a7d3eaeae6cf1","paperId":"2106.14580","textSha256":"1f252f4b0de0645c02040244954e1cb91f1b56edb003dd5c5e9ff5a8cd0cc8d6"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:003b214db072fb7a7d033d92"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:29f9084ff18400c98f4e84a337f085a65d8d99667d6e9a31e12a7d3eaeae6cf1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:53b99cbfc60fb7e3141505d2","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:29f9084ff18400c98f4e84a337f085a65d8d99667d6e9a31e12a7d3eaeae6cf1","textSha256":"1f252f4b0de0645c02040244954e1cb91f1b56edb003dd5c5e9ff5a8cd0cc8d6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b028c3cd571b04ff9db9aae1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b028c3cd571b04ff9db9aae1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:29f9084ff18400c98f4e84a337f085a65d8d99667d6e9a31e12a7d3eaeae6cf1","q025-candidate-question:53b99cbfc60fb7e3141505d2"],"scopeContentSha256":"08fd5b8bd0b55cb07effe07e6ff5d725d1ffb2b58d5d1914c9f15a88a090f307","contributionContentSha256":"ed3d8f17a180c264236a8ce3282174dd99c470f7e275f5399d3feecce5b2c2d6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-931e9f9ec613bf43c548-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-931e9f9ec613bf43c548-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-931e9f9ec613bf43c548-proposal","leaf-931e9f9ec613bf43c548-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:29f9084ff18400c98f4e84a337f085a65d8d99667d6e9a31e12a7d3eaeae6cf1","textSha256":"1f252f4b0de0645c02040244954e1cb91f1b56edb003dd5c5e9ff5a8cd0cc8d6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b028c3cd571b04ff9db9aae1","recordId":"leaf-931e9f9ec613bf43c548-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-931e9f9ec613bf43c548-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-931e9f9ec613bf43c548-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"KPV classical stability and KP thermal transitions are distinct targets. The description does not identify the KP background.","challengeNote":"Compound equilibrium, KPV classical-stability and KP thermal-transition targets. The KP background is not identified in the description.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"526ca68b28da5b2f08bf45761a06a1f78c7e7e23ae3c2562de7d3f0b1e6ecc20"},"organizational-access:07a1833f39c608a57866f148":{"id":"organizational-access:07a1833f39c608a57866f148","source":"q025-candidate-region:907943c754bc979c33d0169e","target":"q025-candidate-question:b379f653d054fc370bcae24f","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:907943c754bc979c33d0169e","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"94c8928039af8b6bc7ee0c684c6cb4772275910e320f6af8c45b726672301ac0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0e39c195c3296fa20e119c56"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:b379f653d054fc370bcae24f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"fd1efc476deef3f2b3351a63b839c7e02e99ff32be68d4e7f9c0ea2ee2b69022","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7d5a92e86b6c7f9b85739e45"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:b2c99fcff8d796aed6e78400682160240f0f72a24019661aa796c6151ad3a0b2","home":{"unitId":"unit:b2c99fcff8d796aed6e78400682160240f0f72a24019661aa796c6151ad3a0b2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:907943c754bc979c33d0169e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b2c99fcff8d796aed6e78400682160240f0f72a24019661aa796c6151ad3a0b2","paperId":"2010.04999","textSha256":"c6b9a43b2b53345682463f3e983eebcbd1d048ff2d648f7c5bfc9c941eb812c8"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9084daf701ddfa5e991f5876"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9084daf701ddfa5e991f5876","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b2c99fcff8d796aed6e78400682160240f0f72a24019661aa796c6151ad3a0b2","q025-candidate-region:907943c754bc979c33d0169e"],"scopeContentSha256":"94c8928039af8b6bc7ee0c684c6cb4772275910e320f6af8c45b726672301ac0","placementContentSha256":"eb9249d37daabfc33a613095d81de7ba1c76008e881ef9f9e989ffd32095def3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-challenge","leaf-fd81fbc9a7aeac07a2cd-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b2c99fcff8d796aed6e78400682160240f0f72a24019661aa796c6151ad3a0b2","paperId":"2010.04999","textSha256":"c6b9a43b2b53345682463f3e983eebcbd1d048ff2d648f7c5bfc9c941eb812c8"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9084daf701ddfa5e991f5876"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b2c99fcff8d796aed6e78400682160240f0f72a24019661aa796c6151ad3a0b2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b379f653d054fc370bcae24f","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:b2c99fcff8d796aed6e78400682160240f0f72a24019661aa796c6151ad3a0b2","textSha256":"c6b9a43b2b53345682463f3e983eebcbd1d048ff2d648f7c5bfc9c941eb812c8"},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f459f777238f028d0e92d01db0a56794","paperId":"2010.04999","sourceSha256":"94b421effbf27b0cabebb419403681a2edcbcae2ee01cb5f55300434b9ccaa5e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/07fa549951639b3b05b0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5adedf8b0dd19ca6f4b9ae947a4c040bc875838af0232abd7f9e14a3e1015994","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"cabe3c8336308bafc1900adb18e36b57a8e2aed61abf8a6fcbceb4f5d1870c98","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cbb6df5ac02d8f37486a08ef01e62ef3","paperId":"2010.04999","sourceSha256":"94b421effbf27b0cabebb419403681a2edcbcae2ee01cb5f55300434b9ccaa5e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/07fa549951639b3b05b0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5adedf8b0dd19ca6f4b9ae947a4c040bc875838af0232abd7f9e14a3e1015994","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2335,"textSha256":"a3c2872059cf2c28ff3527ba244d870190dd37e412ed21a960b3dcbcff373dc3","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:92a92c7f5119665a4a0045e93bb52ffb","paperId":"2010.04999","sourceSha256":"94b421effbf27b0cabebb419403681a2edcbcae2ee01cb5f55300434b9ccaa5e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/07fa549951639b3b05b0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5adedf8b0dd19ca6f4b9ae947a4c040bc875838af0232abd7f9e14a3e1015994","pdfPage":8,"start":2257,"end":4473,"textSha256":"7ea9823663689326d2862b892bbe2362560e587f8783b422bc5b83c8ced24443","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b6c2eb9a97a5c9fc6e9686ff"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b6c2eb9a97a5c9fc6e9686ff","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b2c99fcff8d796aed6e78400682160240f0f72a24019661aa796c6151ad3a0b2","q025-candidate-question:b379f653d054fc370bcae24f"],"scopeContentSha256":"fd1efc476deef3f2b3351a63b839c7e02e99ff32be68d4e7f9c0ea2ee2b69022","contributionContentSha256":"7323474391bc7d0cd57a0cb72e0917a699f83837889df8372a47608eba912ba9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-proposal","leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:b2c99fcff8d796aed6e78400682160240f0f72a24019661aa796c6151ad3a0b2","textSha256":"c6b9a43b2b53345682463f3e983eebcbd1d048ff2d648f7c5bfc9c941eb812c8"},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f459f777238f028d0e92d01db0a56794","paperId":"2010.04999","sourceSha256":"94b421effbf27b0cabebb419403681a2edcbcae2ee01cb5f55300434b9ccaa5e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/07fa549951639b3b05b0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5adedf8b0dd19ca6f4b9ae947a4c040bc875838af0232abd7f9e14a3e1015994","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"cabe3c8336308bafc1900adb18e36b57a8e2aed61abf8a6fcbceb4f5d1870c98","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cbb6df5ac02d8f37486a08ef01e62ef3","paperId":"2010.04999","sourceSha256":"94b421effbf27b0cabebb419403681a2edcbcae2ee01cb5f55300434b9ccaa5e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/07fa549951639b3b05b0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5adedf8b0dd19ca6f4b9ae947a4c040bc875838af0232abd7f9e14a3e1015994","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2335,"textSha256":"a3c2872059cf2c28ff3527ba244d870190dd37e412ed21a960b3dcbcff373dc3","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:92a92c7f5119665a4a0045e93bb52ffb","paperId":"2010.04999","sourceSha256":"94b421effbf27b0cabebb419403681a2edcbcae2ee01cb5f55300434b9ccaa5e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/07fa549951639b3b05b0/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5adedf8b0dd19ca6f4b9ae947a4c040bc875838af0232abd7f9e14a3e1015994","pdfPage":8,"start":2257,"end":4473,"textSha256":"7ea9823663689326d2862b892bbe2362560e587f8783b422bc5b83c8ced24443","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b6c2eb9a97a5c9fc6e9686ff","recordId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-43bff44b5aee7719a3da-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Comparative compound question. Self-production rescue is rejected in the studied branch. Reported g² > 10³ follows when the modulation-derived spacing res","challengeNote":"Comparative compound singleton pending branch reconciliation. Self-production rescue is rejected; the reported large coupling depends on importing the sp","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"868f244092872e0daff68dec273365dad605f55e84618e04f31f7da6a8733143"},"organizational-access:e33dcbb025b7808a709cf59d":{"id":"organizational-access:e33dcbb025b7808a709cf59d","source":"q025-candidate-region:9415e2410543c786c103f973","target":"q025-candidate-question:d9c88565ce42186238d1bbbc","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:9415e2410543c786c103f973","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"352091960e271f2656b7f81e5ea88064a4960756d4eb6df74be4496e892a1c86","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:96538f19b9e243da5d5fd0d4"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:d9c88565ce42186238d1bbbc","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7fbffce885307565b0074f5c2f6b3eaa460cc456b684b5f07f94054c74300612","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:38812ed42f5cd171aa894ac5"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5d6fe11efb299aa6d475973d02a91a8d972816166e4fec8c09c5d5f49c32026e","home":{"unitId":"unit:5d6fe11efb299aa6d475973d02a91a8d972816166e4fec8c09c5d5f49c32026e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:9415e2410543c786c103f973","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5d6fe11efb299aa6d475973d02a91a8d972816166e4fec8c09c5d5f49c32026e","paperId":"1810.10626","textSha256":"a83ca32223c0dfca6f7390986e2fc1fae18333800783e714484c9bd6d4b14416"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ecef43e9ba918054cf79bfc3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ecef43e9ba918054cf79bfc3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5d6fe11efb299aa6d475973d02a91a8d972816166e4fec8c09c5d5f49c32026e","q025-candidate-region:9415e2410543c786c103f973"],"scopeContentSha256":"352091960e271f2656b7f81e5ea88064a4960756d4eb6df74be4496e892a1c86","placementContentSha256":"69e152e42ff1d7432cb177a68dff850120a3d19b42fed2b9e8e0ca8df581a8f8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ff14f5d419a6b2794573-challenge","leaf-ff14f5d419a6b2794573-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5d6fe11efb299aa6d475973d02a91a8d972816166e4fec8c09c5d5f49c32026e","paperId":"1810.10626","textSha256":"a83ca32223c0dfca6f7390986e2fc1fae18333800783e714484c9bd6d4b14416"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ecef43e9ba918054cf79bfc3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5d6fe11efb299aa6d475973d02a91a8d972816166e4fec8c09c5d5f49c32026e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d9c88565ce42186238d1bbbc","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:5d6fe11efb299aa6d475973d02a91a8d972816166e4fec8c09c5d5f49c32026e","textSha256":"a83ca32223c0dfca6f7390986e2fc1fae18333800783e714484c9bd6d4b14416"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:24defd0475ed9cdd348788fe"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:24defd0475ed9cdd348788fe","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5d6fe11efb299aa6d475973d02a91a8d972816166e4fec8c09c5d5f49c32026e","q025-candidate-question:d9c88565ce42186238d1bbbc"],"scopeContentSha256":"7fbffce885307565b0074f5c2f6b3eaa460cc456b684b5f07f94054c74300612","contributionContentSha256":"5c4b1dc3e98c3b91d044a1f746075a8f8daf666c222e5decbe04b7fcdc515a1a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ff14f5d419a6b2794573-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ff14f5d419a6b2794573-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ff14f5d419a6b2794573-proposal","leaf-ff14f5d419a6b2794573-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:5d6fe11efb299aa6d475973d02a91a8d972816166e4fec8c09c5d5f49c32026e","textSha256":"a83ca32223c0dfca6f7390986e2fc1fae18333800783e714484c9bd6d4b14416"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:24defd0475ed9cdd348788fe","recordId":"leaf-ff14f5d419a6b2794573-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ff14f5d419a6b2794573-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ff14f5d419a6b2794573-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: continuum spectrum recovery and spontaneous U(1) breaking are separate targets; fine decomposition remains unresolved.","challengeNote":"Compound spectrum-recovery and spontaneous U(1)-breaking targets; fine decomposition remains unresolved.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a227e8ec1b32ffbf1a4d7bb0a48a709b5a353edc3bdf67a740025a6121db2236"},"organizational-access:858e3bad64a63577ca9a931b":{"id":"organizational-access:858e3bad64a63577ca9a931b","source":"q025-candidate-region:9da96f81b811eed09ae6d4db","target":"q025-candidate-question:c0acabd5a23eb0c33269a155","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:9da96f81b811eed09ae6d4db","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"45a7893d7eeb0b88076e447b014a3d5e9c1a9b23d6f275679ec8da4eaa57c3ff","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:34da03c6b8a90e37f047df67"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c0acabd5a23eb0c33269a155","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"bae42dba5e04296f209c53e2dd30bfa706afbfc2020f7119a1411388245ef82d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:096a7a8a96adfeb18b0b1475"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0ea5bb44cc2e1ce92257b354e4b88b326d2d6c82f1292b5b502b2c38485d6de2","home":{"unitId":"unit:0ea5bb44cc2e1ce92257b354e4b88b326d2d6c82f1292b5b502b2c38485d6de2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:9da96f81b811eed09ae6d4db","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0ea5bb44cc2e1ce92257b354e4b88b326d2d6c82f1292b5b502b2c38485d6de2","paperId":"1304.1809","textSha256":"c341831af2d0bd0ae165933e0bde6acc150fccdfa080c171bdfed4843cc3be02"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4105300abb2cd9664b2414764290a7b6","paperId":"1304.1809","sourceSha256":"24aeb09138111aa8bcf3f0f7523d38de7eab8587119846224085f263fd63876b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fe4745080c4243fd9771/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"65d350c593a2bdbe1741fad378b3eeb90b5f61564152dacc2af4b07eedeedfb3","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2945,"textSha256":"46db1e78b9dad580cc892a7b567c9401fc14d4368eaac3c6daaf3ea1999cac00","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4d5e41ab477230c5940a0e283b728faf","paperId":"1304.1809","sourceSha256":"24aeb09138111aa8bcf3f0f7523d38de7eab8587119846224085f263fd63876b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fe4745080c4243fd9771/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"65d350c593a2bdbe1741fad378b3eeb90b5f61564152dacc2af4b07eedeedfb3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2945,"textSha256":"64a328e067e3c6940378df9f2dbc7117e9da22641ce4d4e86b57326a041986f1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f638254f8fa28206ad6d98e5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f638254f8fa28206ad6d98e5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0ea5bb44cc2e1ce92257b354e4b88b326d2d6c82f1292b5b502b2c38485d6de2","q025-candidate-region:9da96f81b811eed09ae6d4db"],"scopeContentSha256":"45a7893d7eeb0b88076e447b014a3d5e9c1a9b23d6f275679ec8da4eaa57c3ff","placementContentSha256":"5216ef7c433f2ed45cf3fca2a418769ad9e97847b6305c0b5a869c5a5a215901","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0594a24f01f9b493cef4-challenge","leaf-0594a24f01f9b493cef4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0ea5bb44cc2e1ce92257b354e4b88b326d2d6c82f1292b5b502b2c38485d6de2","paperId":"1304.1809","textSha256":"c341831af2d0bd0ae165933e0bde6acc150fccdfa080c171bdfed4843cc3be02"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4105300abb2cd9664b2414764290a7b6","paperId":"1304.1809","sourceSha256":"24aeb09138111aa8bcf3f0f7523d38de7eab8587119846224085f263fd63876b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fe4745080c4243fd9771/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"65d350c593a2bdbe1741fad378b3eeb90b5f61564152dacc2af4b07eedeedfb3","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2945,"textSha256":"46db1e78b9dad580cc892a7b567c9401fc14d4368eaac3c6daaf3ea1999cac00","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4d5e41ab477230c5940a0e283b728faf","paperId":"1304.1809","sourceSha256":"24aeb09138111aa8bcf3f0f7523d38de7eab8587119846224085f263fd63876b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fe4745080c4243fd9771/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"65d350c593a2bdbe1741fad378b3eeb90b5f61564152dacc2af4b07eedeedfb3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2945,"textSha256":"64a328e067e3c6940378df9f2dbc7117e9da22641ce4d4e86b57326a041986f1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f638254f8fa28206ad6d98e5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0ea5bb44cc2e1ce92257b354e4b88b326d2d6c82f1292b5b502b2c38485d6de2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c0acabd5a23eb0c33269a155","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:0ea5bb44cc2e1ce92257b354e4b88b326d2d6c82f1292b5b502b2c38485d6de2","textSha256":"c341831af2d0bd0ae165933e0bde6acc150fccdfa080c171bdfed4843cc3be02"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4105300abb2cd9664b2414764290a7b6","paperId":"1304.1809","sourceSha256":"24aeb09138111aa8bcf3f0f7523d38de7eab8587119846224085f263fd63876b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fe4745080c4243fd9771/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"65d350c593a2bdbe1741fad378b3eeb90b5f61564152dacc2af4b07eedeedfb3","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2945,"textSha256":"46db1e78b9dad580cc892a7b567c9401fc14d4368eaac3c6daaf3ea1999cac00","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4d5e41ab477230c5940a0e283b728faf","paperId":"1304.1809","sourceSha256":"24aeb09138111aa8bcf3f0f7523d38de7eab8587119846224085f263fd63876b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fe4745080c4243fd9771/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"65d350c593a2bdbe1741fad378b3eeb90b5f61564152dacc2af4b07eedeedfb3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2945,"textSha256":"64a328e067e3c6940378df9f2dbc7117e9da22641ce4d4e86b57326a041986f1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9c41970dea649bba4f4548ca"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9c41970dea649bba4f4548ca","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0ea5bb44cc2e1ce92257b354e4b88b326d2d6c82f1292b5b502b2c38485d6de2","q025-candidate-question:c0acabd5a23eb0c33269a155"],"scopeContentSha256":"bae42dba5e04296f209c53e2dd30bfa706afbfc2020f7119a1411388245ef82d","contributionContentSha256":"030b34fa57b2cf8a9e4abb28554831ff29cef7497f9c3401d0215e103445701d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:0ea5bb44cc2e1ce92257b354e4b88b326d2d6c82f1292b5b502b2c38485d6de2","textSha256":"c341831af2d0bd0ae165933e0bde6acc150fccdfa080c171bdfed4843cc3be02"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4105300abb2cd9664b2414764290a7b6","paperId":"1304.1809","sourceSha256":"24aeb09138111aa8bcf3f0f7523d38de7eab8587119846224085f263fd63876b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fe4745080c4243fd9771/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"65d350c593a2bdbe1741fad378b3eeb90b5f61564152dacc2af4b07eedeedfb3","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":2945,"textSha256":"46db1e78b9dad580cc892a7b567c9401fc14d4368eaac3c6daaf3ea1999cac00","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4d5e41ab477230c5940a0e283b728faf","paperId":"1304.1809","sourceSha256":"24aeb09138111aa8bcf3f0f7523d38de7eab8587119846224085f263fd63876b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fe4745080c4243fd9771/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"65d350c593a2bdbe1741fad378b3eeb90b5f61564152dacc2af4b07eedeedfb3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":2945,"textSha256":"64a328e067e3c6940378df9f2dbc7117e9da22641ce4d4e86b57326a041986f1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9c41970dea649bba4f4548ca","recordId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound stabilization, breaking and unification targets. Abstract-level support; small vacuum energy and low-scale supersymmetry require additional conditions.","challengeNote":"Compound stabilization, supersymmetry-breaking and unification targets. The abstract announces results and retains substantial vacuum-energy tuning difficulties","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"928f3aab38afd5b1aa648f2e47dd340ed3d4a86c0ba3f7bda439ed73d4fba68d"},"organizational-access:4de1667c4ec810a3c452bb1a":{"id":"organizational-access:4de1667c4ec810a3c452bb1a","source":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","target":"q025-candidate-question:a4bd16233abe73c43d27d12e","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8ac1c5bf56b05064635db5ff"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a4bd16233abe73c43d27d12e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"24e69e30f9102b298128eb6d48bcaa4688da1bda3f96b44db2adc644bf53e314","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:4aa530cc5a4cd8808544820c"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:c8f1ac050b8b2f9c6eb7ecbaa81442647ed73868ba66aa8459e2f28cd1fd9947","home":{"unitId":"unit:c8f1ac050b8b2f9c6eb7ecbaa81442647ed73868ba66aa8459e2f28cd1fd9947","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c8f1ac050b8b2f9c6eb7ecbaa81442647ed73868ba66aa8459e2f28cd1fd9947","paperId":"2504.03452","textSha256":"264a328d04e647d78dabab32977a63202830b2424937426a994850a34bc780c6"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:19b31ae52296e62bd7149991"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:19b31ae52296e62bd7149991","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c8f1ac050b8b2f9c6eb7ecbaa81442647ed73868ba66aa8459e2f28cd1fd9947","q025-candidate-region:ace45537f56681cc78d7a950"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ef6f9136da75323ce1a4c818ed1bc49b4f947d55e8e9a5235f8246fab7a5c21","placementContentSha256":"c0ba0e70e62187704c6d05b8eb17aeeebd801369fb9710b1c04dbd5073196bb5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c8f1ac050b8b2f9c6eb7ecbaa81442647ed73868ba66aa8459e2f28cd1fd9947","paperId":"2504.03452","textSha256":"264a328d04e647d78dabab32977a63202830b2424937426a994850a34bc780c6"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:19b31ae52296e62bd7149991"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c8f1ac050b8b2f9c6eb7ecbaa81442647ed73868ba66aa8459e2f28cd1fd9947","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a4bd16233abe73c43d27d12e","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:c8f1ac050b8b2f9c6eb7ecbaa81442647ed73868ba66aa8459e2f28cd1fd9947","textSha256":"264a328d04e647d78dabab32977a63202830b2424937426a994850a34bc780c6"},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6361eaf957f530cae1ba8be4aac0481f","paperId":"2504.03452","sourceSha256":"8108a13fac3dad7357190147b4821d5a40421c4b30f9e9ad7d689c3f77dd7d67","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ad4228d650d3fe241919/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1958b72743690cb78b54d12eb4a330a45bb32b2019e08cee07f852d2c02f6d8c","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2755,"textSha256":"92823fb929a4f5b9a489f1f3142e348751eae825ddab270c29a138c4abc51691","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7777120b540df22b9da3162a","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Targets extremal-surface entanglement area. The illustrative A-model proposal does not establish generic black-hole microstate counting. Independent challenge qualification: The proposed mechanism targets extremal-surface entanglement area and is illustrated in the A model; a general factorization theorem is not established."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7777120b540df22b9da3162a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c8f1ac050b8b2f9c6eb7ecbaa81442647ed73868ba66aa8459e2f28cd1fd9947","q025-candidate-question:a4bd16233abe73c43d27d12e"],"scopeContentSha256":"24e69e30f9102b298128eb6d48bcaa4688da1bda3f96b44db2adc644bf53e314","contributionContentSha256":"893bcd182fd685f0e7ffe6dac795837f324a91d387308aa2ab5705c5cc30bb88","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal","leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:c8f1ac050b8b2f9c6eb7ecbaa81442647ed73868ba66aa8459e2f28cd1fd9947","textSha256":"264a328d04e647d78dabab32977a63202830b2424937426a994850a34bc780c6"},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6361eaf957f530cae1ba8be4aac0481f","paperId":"2504.03452","sourceSha256":"8108a13fac3dad7357190147b4821d5a40421c4b30f9e9ad7d689c3f77dd7d67","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ad4228d650d3fe241919/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"1958b72743690cb78b54d12eb4a330a45bb32b2019e08cee07f852d2c02f6d8c","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2755,"textSha256":"92823fb929a4f5b9a489f1f3142e348751eae825ddab270c29a138c4abc51691","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7777120b540df22b9da3162a","recordId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Targets extremal-surface entanglement area. The illustrative A-model proposal does not establish generic black-hole microstate counting.","challengeNote":"The proposed mechanism targets extremal-surface entanglement area and is illustrated in the A model; a general factorization theorem is not established.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4f561599595ebecaed605db5aa57be5b0aab5d5e155a6598c0a70651850b957f"},"organizational-access:d4b82a21e7d7fa75340cd342":{"id":"organizational-access:d4b82a21e7d7fa75340cd342","source":"q025-candidate-region:ad70723be7e74e06a698de89","target":"q025-candidate-question:b675e7dd132c628539732073","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:ad70723be7e74e06a698de89","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"693bc8769dce612c66e423423019c047faf9b5c81a61a491d1b6c93d6e9bd7ea","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2db71d6e797d9ccbb3fcad70"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:b675e7dd132c628539732073","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ca6ba162cdf1da264826dd3eafc87190f871d6f97c0ee7b4e06100401914c8e9","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:dfc38a5023db8ed56eb4947b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:dfe5f99cc7ba73781a76cfb8c5c950164afeb11def1e53ad9a08f1cbdc8461df","home":{"unitId":"unit:dfe5f99cc7ba73781a76cfb8c5c950164afeb11def1e53ad9a08f1cbdc8461df","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:ad70723be7e74e06a698de89","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:dfe5f99cc7ba73781a76cfb8c5c950164afeb11def1e53ad9a08f1cbdc8461df","paperId":"1910.11676","textSha256":"9f8792a04b05d0bf3d18f3e41b2159c72079b908f7d6ede1913f2c7c52c30798"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:55daba70d7170f60b5340a386993c748","paperId":"1910.11676","sourceSha256":"f9a306c90fcb37777bb2c4e5e09343836fde653dbc326309627dddd6f357b252","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/344a057fb65e8ad63cd2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4cfefbc6deedc219f051acbed5851b32a44a71d6219ddbdf5ff9a7ebe06047a9","pdfPage":3,"start":1255,"end":2807,"textSha256":"fcf94da2f0d272ae1df993c549d3c71c187f31c7ba8d98d4071f5fb97792eb12","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8dfd8fd2f1acf5eacacce1831cf1dca7","paperId":"1910.11676","sourceSha256":"f9a306c90fcb37777bb2c4e5e09343836fde653dbc326309627dddd6f357b252","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/344a057fb65e8ad63cd2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4cfefbc6deedc219f051acbed5851b32a44a71d6219ddbdf5ff9a7ebe06047a9","pdfPage":3,"start":1160,"end":2807,"textSha256":"35fbe17f33c69572e950dd74469350837331f17adcfc266b47986e9fa03ac74f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4a67de670664b3c5c6ad136a337d388d","paperId":"1910.11676","sourceSha256":"f9a306c90fcb37777bb2c4e5e09343836fde653dbc326309627dddd6f357b252","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/344a057fb65e8ad63cd2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4cfefbc6deedc219f051acbed5851b32a44a71d6219ddbdf5ff9a7ebe06047a9","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1376,"textSha256":"8eafa25e596051c1d3fa570046a0ccec43f89dcd6d986a58caee158d65b5ed3f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4be5197228dcb2721a075c44"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4be5197228dcb2721a075c44","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:dfe5f99cc7ba73781a76cfb8c5c950164afeb11def1e53ad9a08f1cbdc8461df","q025-candidate-region:ad70723be7e74e06a698de89"],"scopeContentSha256":"693bc8769dce612c66e423423019c047faf9b5c81a61a491d1b6c93d6e9bd7ea","placementContentSha256":"60fff6d3122882b8db9987b4140f6aff80dcdf245317626d12ffecd9d4a10acf","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-challenge","leaf-recovery-54e3e83d0ccbf2700b0f-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:dfe5f99cc7ba73781a76cfb8c5c950164afeb11def1e53ad9a08f1cbdc8461df","paperId":"1910.11676","textSha256":"9f8792a04b05d0bf3d18f3e41b2159c72079b908f7d6ede1913f2c7c52c30798"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:55daba70d7170f60b5340a386993c748","paperId":"1910.11676","sourceSha256":"f9a306c90fcb37777bb2c4e5e09343836fde653dbc326309627dddd6f357b252","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/344a057fb65e8ad63cd2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4cfefbc6deedc219f051acbed5851b32a44a71d6219ddbdf5ff9a7ebe06047a9","pdfPage":3,"start":1255,"end":2807,"textSha256":"fcf94da2f0d272ae1df993c549d3c71c187f31c7ba8d98d4071f5fb97792eb12","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8dfd8fd2f1acf5eacacce1831cf1dca7","paperId":"1910.11676","sourceSha256":"f9a306c90fcb37777bb2c4e5e09343836fde653dbc326309627dddd6f357b252","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/344a057fb65e8ad63cd2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4cfefbc6deedc219f051acbed5851b32a44a71d6219ddbdf5ff9a7ebe06047a9","pdfPage":3,"start":1160,"end":2807,"textSha256":"35fbe17f33c69572e950dd74469350837331f17adcfc266b47986e9fa03ac74f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4a67de670664b3c5c6ad136a337d388d","paperId":"1910.11676","sourceSha256":"f9a306c90fcb37777bb2c4e5e09343836fde653dbc326309627dddd6f357b252","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/344a057fb65e8ad63cd2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4cfefbc6deedc219f051acbed5851b32a44a71d6219ddbdf5ff9a7ebe06047a9","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1376,"textSha256":"8eafa25e596051c1d3fa570046a0ccec43f89dcd6d986a58caee158d65b5ed3f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4be5197228dcb2721a075c44"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:dfe5f99cc7ba73781a76cfb8c5c950164afeb11def1e53ad9a08f1cbdc8461df","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b675e7dd132c628539732073","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d94","kind":"description","unitIndex":94,"unitId":"unit:dfe5f99cc7ba73781a76cfb8c5c950164afeb11def1e53ad9a08f1cbdc8461df","textSha256":"9f8792a04b05d0bf3d18f3e41b2159c72079b908f7d6ede1913f2c7c52c30798"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:55daba70d7170f60b5340a386993c748","paperId":"1910.11676","sourceSha256":"f9a306c90fcb37777bb2c4e5e09343836fde653dbc326309627dddd6f357b252","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/344a057fb65e8ad63cd2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4cfefbc6deedc219f051acbed5851b32a44a71d6219ddbdf5ff9a7ebe06047a9","pdfPage":3,"start":1255,"end":2807,"textSha256":"fcf94da2f0d272ae1df993c549d3c71c187f31c7ba8d98d4071f5fb97792eb12","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4a67de670664b3c5c6ad136a337d388d","paperId":"1910.11676","sourceSha256":"f9a306c90fcb37777bb2c4e5e09343836fde653dbc326309627dddd6f357b252","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/344a057fb65e8ad63cd2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4cfefbc6deedc219f051acbed5851b32a44a71d6219ddbdf5ff9a7ebe06047a9","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1376,"textSha256":"8eafa25e596051c1d3fa570046a0ccec43f89dcd6d986a58caee158d65b5ed3f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8dfd8fd2f1acf5eacacce1831cf1dca7","paperId":"1910.11676","sourceSha256":"f9a306c90fcb37777bb2c4e5e09343836fde653dbc326309627dddd6f357b252","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/344a057fb65e8ad63cd2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4cfefbc6deedc219f051acbed5851b32a44a71d6219ddbdf5ff9a7ebe06047a9","pdfPage":3,"start":1160,"end":2807,"textSha256":"35fbe17f33c69572e950dd74469350837331f17adcfc266b47986e9fa03ac74f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2ec6a53a1ec5546a5559e740"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2ec6a53a1ec5546a5559e740","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:dfe5f99cc7ba73781a76cfb8c5c950164afeb11def1e53ad9a08f1cbdc8461df","q025-candidate-question:b675e7dd132c628539732073"],"scopeContentSha256":"ca6ba162cdf1da264826dd3eafc87190f871d6f97c0ee7b4e06100401914c8e9","contributionContentSha256":"d794a8496ef7e70a7c02b3dd3289b5b660532532beb7b77e196534f7f82c6ac5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-777289df84203d433c78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-777289df84203d433c78-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-777289df84203d433c78-proposal","leaf-777289df84203d433c78-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d94","kind":"description","unitIndex":94,"unitId":"unit:dfe5f99cc7ba73781a76cfb8c5c950164afeb11def1e53ad9a08f1cbdc8461df","textSha256":"9f8792a04b05d0bf3d18f3e41b2159c72079b908f7d6ede1913f2c7c52c30798"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:55daba70d7170f60b5340a386993c748","paperId":"1910.11676","sourceSha256":"f9a306c90fcb37777bb2c4e5e09343836fde653dbc326309627dddd6f357b252","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/344a057fb65e8ad63cd2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4cfefbc6deedc219f051acbed5851b32a44a71d6219ddbdf5ff9a7ebe06047a9","pdfPage":3,"start":1255,"end":2807,"textSha256":"fcf94da2f0d272ae1df993c549d3c71c187f31c7ba8d98d4071f5fb97792eb12","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4a67de670664b3c5c6ad136a337d388d","paperId":"1910.11676","sourceSha256":"f9a306c90fcb37777bb2c4e5e09343836fde653dbc326309627dddd6f357b252","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/344a057fb65e8ad63cd2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4cfefbc6deedc219f051acbed5851b32a44a71d6219ddbdf5ff9a7ebe06047a9","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1376,"textSha256":"8eafa25e596051c1d3fa570046a0ccec43f89dcd6d986a58caee158d65b5ed3f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8dfd8fd2f1acf5eacacce1831cf1dca7","paperId":"1910.11676","sourceSha256":"f9a306c90fcb37777bb2c4e5e09343836fde653dbc326309627dddd6f357b252","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/344a057fb65e8ad63cd2/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4cfefbc6deedc219f051acbed5851b32a44a71d6219ddbdf5ff9a7ebe06047a9","pdfPage":3,"start":1160,"end":2807,"textSha256":"35fbe17f33c69572e950dd74469350837331f17adcfc266b47986e9fa03ac74f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2ec6a53a1ec5546a5559e740","recordId":"leaf-777289df84203d433c78-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-777289df84203d433c78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-777289df84203d433c78-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"The reported approximate potential and nominated full reconstruction are not certified equivalent. No image, error estimate, physical field domain or missing  ","challengeNote":"Replace truncated pf78 with candidate f4. Approximate potential and nominated full reconstruction remain unverified as equivalents; no image or error control is","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"03834ebeada5750e901aca6c1cf758fd4f1738cf6bbf303bfec32cd790ee9227"},"organizational-access:4767914844c9fe4401930ffb":{"id":"organizational-access:4767914844c9fe4401930ffb","source":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","target":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7b5a236a470736f0c0bd8d64"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"268939a83d4929df66b954dacdd9bfeebd08b3331a1d4d7a3dd2f54778f8da73","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6d28e66d9dabc88b794c03d7"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:060283e8dcc4b3ee212795f14b95f8cc4ae68729e635c70b08cf4a947a8668d7","home":{"unitId":"unit:060283e8dcc4b3ee212795f14b95f8cc4ae68729e635c70b08cf4a947a8668d7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:060283e8dcc4b3ee212795f14b95f8cc4ae68729e635c70b08cf4a947a8668d7","paperId":"2008.13660","textSha256":"6fde3580f3f6b00e82844c2e4b6548b332919ccb84e28b903fb5dfca7ff7c637"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e7c679700367fcaa36ed5d32"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e7c679700367fcaa36ed5d32","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:060283e8dcc4b3ee212795f14b95f8cc4ae68729e635c70b08cf4a947a8668d7","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"bb476354112e9a0aaa3257b3181a41e99847451ac0859fdc9bdb7ed530eecf09","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:060283e8dcc4b3ee212795f14b95f8cc4ae68729e635c70b08cf4a947a8668d7","paperId":"2008.13660","textSha256":"6fde3580f3f6b00e82844c2e4b6548b332919ccb84e28b903fb5dfca7ff7c637"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e7c679700367fcaa36ed5d32"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:060283e8dcc4b3ee212795f14b95f8cc4ae68729e635c70b08cf4a947a8668d7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d51","kind":"description","unitIndex":51,"unitId":"unit:060283e8dcc4b3ee212795f14b95f8cc4ae68729e635c70b08cf4a947a8668d7","textSha256":"6fde3580f3f6b00e82844c2e4b6548b332919ccb84e28b903fb5dfca7ff7c637"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f5c2df9320b96d4768ee590a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f5c2df9320b96d4768ee590a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:060283e8dcc4b3ee212795f14b95f8cc4ae68729e635c70b08cf4a947a8668d7","q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83"],"scopeContentSha256":"268939a83d4929df66b954dacdd9bfeebd08b3331a1d4d7a3dd2f54778f8da73","contributionContentSha256":"be6be625d9fe9a220e9cdec7392692751cd538bf2b6475c715676368f1f7d699","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d51","kind":"description","unitIndex":51,"unitId":"unit:060283e8dcc4b3ee212795f14b95f8cc4ae68729e635c70b08cf4a947a8668d7","textSha256":"6fde3580f3f6b00e82844c2e4b6548b332919ccb84e28b903fb5dfca7ff7c637"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f5c2df9320b96d4768ee590a","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Slow scalar-sector evolution with matter and radiation present does not itself establish total cosmic acceleration.","challengeNote":"Slow scalar-sector evolution with matter and radiation present does not itself imply total acceleration.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:144d15bd07bff4702159f25afc0b0cb0fac4ae62303f365db4fd6584a6e1b6eb","home":{"unitId":"unit:144d15bd07bff4702159f25afc0b0cb0fac4ae62303f365db4fd6584a6e1b6eb","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:144d15bd07bff4702159f25afc0b0cb0fac4ae62303f365db4fd6584a6e1b6eb","paperId":"2007.11011","textSha256":"0a99f38b3d7433c1eb8ab03311450dc525d7ea3a67cbfeecc4929964e2c7d129"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0a246eeb855d01e03f2fca71"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0a246eeb855d01e03f2fca71","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:144d15bd07bff4702159f25afc0b0cb0fac4ae62303f365db4fd6584a6e1b6eb","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"498fa9f1501bd59cf7ab083635550440fcf56e0aaaad1d12623e33ad3827e3c5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:144d15bd07bff4702159f25afc0b0cb0fac4ae62303f365db4fd6584a6e1b6eb","paperId":"2007.11011","textSha256":"0a99f38b3d7433c1eb8ab03311450dc525d7ea3a67cbfeecc4929964e2c7d129"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0a246eeb855d01e03f2fca71"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:144d15bd07bff4702159f25afc0b0cb0fac4ae62303f365db4fd6584a6e1b6eb","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:144d15bd07bff4702159f25afc0b0cb0fac4ae62303f365db4fd6584a6e1b6eb","textSha256":"0a99f38b3d7433c1eb8ab03311450dc525d7ea3a67cbfeecc4929964e2c7d129"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e7871709d0305f095fc8d9d8"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e7871709d0305f095fc8d9d8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:144d15bd07bff4702159f25afc0b0cb0fac4ae62303f365db4fd6584a6e1b6eb","q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83"],"scopeContentSha256":"268939a83d4929df66b954dacdd9bfeebd08b3331a1d4d7a3dd2f54778f8da73","contributionContentSha256":"ed16cabc754cd0bb44ce177ca54b9b43530e451c347625f6dec1d609be50281f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:144d15bd07bff4702159f25afc0b0cb0fac4ae62303f365db4fd6584a6e1b6eb","textSha256":"0a99f38b3d7433c1eb8ab03311450dc525d7ea3a67cbfeecc4929964e2c7d129"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e7871709d0305f095fc8d9d8","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"A complete ultraviolet realization remains an independent unresolved requirement.","challengeNote":"A complete ultraviolet realization remains a separate unresolved requirement.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:21d78b40b06445230e213424d597f980ec223ff2e3479d1821642990fe935981","home":{"unitId":"unit:21d78b40b06445230e213424d597f980ec223ff2e3479d1821642990fe935981","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:21d78b40b06445230e213424d597f980ec223ff2e3479d1821642990fe935981","paperId":"2007.11011","textSha256":"3c5bb4605c15bb018befc0536bd428f4ca2cffe7876283a630c2fc6cb498f9c4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8b5d076099b2dee39e44fe3f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8b5d076099b2dee39e44fe3f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:21d78b40b06445230e213424d597f980ec223ff2e3479d1821642990fe935981","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"ac75913de1afb3189329d3b0f06c864bab7d6953de87e3cfc905b287403f73aa","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:21d78b40b06445230e213424d597f980ec223ff2e3479d1821642990fe935981","paperId":"2007.11011","textSha256":"3c5bb4605c15bb018befc0536bd428f4ca2cffe7876283a630c2fc6cb498f9c4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8b5d076099b2dee39e44fe3f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:21d78b40b06445230e213424d597f980ec223ff2e3479d1821642990fe935981","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:21d78b40b06445230e213424d597f980ec223ff2e3479d1821642990fe935981","textSha256":"3c5bb4605c15bb018befc0536bd428f4ca2cffe7876283a630c2fc6cb498f9c4"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aff04c772b5b8fed899a54b9"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:aff04c772b5b8fed899a54b9","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:21d78b40b06445230e213424d597f980ec223ff2e3479d1821642990fe935981","q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83"],"scopeContentSha256":"268939a83d4929df66b954dacdd9bfeebd08b3331a1d4d7a3dd2f54778f8da73","contributionContentSha256":"3ecbfe6b7e13e68e5b3c486d1a2467374629167addd376abee9d5848437a2b34","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:21d78b40b06445230e213424d597f980ec223ff2e3479d1821642990fe935981","textSha256":"3c5bb4605c15bb018befc0536bd428f4ca2cffe7876283a630c2fc6cb498f9c4"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aff04c772b5b8fed899a54b9","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Only φ1 has a potential; motion along the exactly flat φ2 direction acts through kinetic coupling.","challengeNote":"Only φ1 experiences a potential; the exactly flat φ2 direction acts through kinetic coupling.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:55b36ec5eb0c213c3084fe0149d07c71e61a10521d20df683a3e7853fb209502","home":{"unitId":"unit:55b36ec5eb0c213c3084fe0149d07c71e61a10521d20df683a3e7853fb209502","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:55b36ec5eb0c213c3084fe0149d07c71e61a10521d20df683a3e7853fb209502","paperId":"2201.01015","textSha256":"d381a475665c1d8b3cc20910aa1395aadb04ff56e5724ae6233b77bcee6992cf"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:defbb740682b3683f389604c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:defbb740682b3683f389604c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:55b36ec5eb0c213c3084fe0149d07c71e61a10521d20df683a3e7853fb209502","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"5606d7b452a08591461e95b9b62c76db0c8ea5fea50f3e18ae2633ab0ed18ae0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:55b36ec5eb0c213c3084fe0149d07c71e61a10521d20df683a3e7853fb209502","paperId":"2201.01015","textSha256":"d381a475665c1d8b3cc20910aa1395aadb04ff56e5724ae6233b77bcee6992cf"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:defbb740682b3683f389604c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:55b36ec5eb0c213c3084fe0149d07c71e61a10521d20df683a3e7853fb209502","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:55b36ec5eb0c213c3084fe0149d07c71e61a10521d20df683a3e7853fb209502","textSha256":"d381a475665c1d8b3cc20910aa1395aadb04ff56e5724ae6233b77bcee6992cf"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:30cdf00a080f540e43333e4c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:30cdf00a080f540e43333e4c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:55b36ec5eb0c213c3084fe0149d07c71e61a10521d20df683a3e7853fb209502","q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83"],"scopeContentSha256":"268939a83d4929df66b954dacdd9bfeebd08b3331a1d4d7a3dd2f54778f8da73","contributionContentSha256":"b86a7af0c4e554c560bb020d24c3e461bdc18787bda16ce4cfd28762a338e83f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:55b36ec5eb0c213c3084fe0149d07c71e61a10521d20df683a3e7853fb209502","textSha256":"d381a475665c1d8b3cc20910aa1395aadb04ff56e5724ae6233b77bcee6992cf"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:30cdf00a080f540e43333e4c","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The setting includes field-dependent kinetic coupling and pressureless matter; it is not restricted to a canonical scalar.","challengeNote":"The setting retains pressureless matter and field-dependent kinetic coupling beyond a canonical-only restriction.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:56343e23efd8e6b61083a258d070db586367ec3cc2060ca610189f3d0c267fd7","home":{"unitId":"unit:56343e23efd8e6b61083a258d070db586367ec3cc2060ca610189f3d0c267fd7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:56343e23efd8e6b61083a258d070db586367ec3cc2060ca610189f3d0c267fd7","paperId":"1911.01606","textSha256":"a2b9646770262962e49333a5ca77e5926c97fcf720d63613260cd48f2183184c"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:23adeb764a58974f484460361a49148b","paperId":"1911.01606","sourceSha256":"88cd20ebb66b017d86dd37d3ef137519420224064b3e418c7e7e05895bb50fd3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8c107653ddedc13e558c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"185ec3167f8037be0b7692a97fef3818e91f8b461f9bfca1d435b1ebc63796d0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"3402fb8e876c5f7d07c258b37aa22fb89dc8d01f32e7704a03a84243a33f7d1a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3982ed89cd6e66e9c40b171c4496d1dc","paperId":"1911.01606","sourceSha256":"88cd20ebb66b017d86dd37d3ef137519420224064b3e418c7e7e05895bb50fd3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8c107653ddedc13e558c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"185ec3167f8037be0b7692a97fef3818e91f8b461f9bfca1d435b1ebc63796d0","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0c1b2361fc2ddcd851acca53b2fb5ffb0ada086d29ef9669545e51cd3ba66acc","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2cf77cb9bc372eb57055cc24"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2cf77cb9bc372eb57055cc24","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:56343e23efd8e6b61083a258d070db586367ec3cc2060ca610189f3d0c267fd7","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"2f2b93a0dde987f53bb1534edd0c1ce51fa66db551364151241f5851822b8a7b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:56343e23efd8e6b61083a258d070db586367ec3cc2060ca610189f3d0c267fd7","paperId":"1911.01606","textSha256":"a2b9646770262962e49333a5ca77e5926c97fcf720d63613260cd48f2183184c"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:23adeb764a58974f484460361a49148b","paperId":"1911.01606","sourceSha256":"88cd20ebb66b017d86dd37d3ef137519420224064b3e418c7e7e05895bb50fd3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8c107653ddedc13e558c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"185ec3167f8037be0b7692a97fef3818e91f8b461f9bfca1d435b1ebc63796d0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"3402fb8e876c5f7d07c258b37aa22fb89dc8d01f32e7704a03a84243a33f7d1a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3982ed89cd6e66e9c40b171c4496d1dc","paperId":"1911.01606","sourceSha256":"88cd20ebb66b017d86dd37d3ef137519420224064b3e418c7e7e05895bb50fd3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8c107653ddedc13e558c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"185ec3167f8037be0b7692a97fef3818e91f8b461f9bfca1d435b1ebc63796d0","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0c1b2361fc2ddcd851acca53b2fb5ffb0ada086d29ef9669545e51cd3ba66acc","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2cf77cb9bc372eb57055cc24"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:56343e23efd8e6b61083a258d070db586367ec3cc2060ca610189f3d0c267fd7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:56343e23efd8e6b61083a258d070db586367ec3cc2060ca610189f3d0c267fd7","textSha256":"a2b9646770262962e49333a5ca77e5926c97fcf720d63613260cd48f2183184c"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:23adeb764a58974f484460361a49148b","paperId":"1911.01606","sourceSha256":"88cd20ebb66b017d86dd37d3ef137519420224064b3e418c7e7e05895bb50fd3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8c107653ddedc13e558c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"185ec3167f8037be0b7692a97fef3818e91f8b461f9bfca1d435b1ebc63796d0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"3402fb8e876c5f7d07c258b37aa22fb89dc8d01f32e7704a03a84243a33f7d1a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3982ed89cd6e66e9c40b171c4496d1dc","paperId":"1911.01606","sourceSha256":"88cd20ebb66b017d86dd37d3ef137519420224064b3e418c7e7e05895bb50fd3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8c107653ddedc13e558c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"185ec3167f8037be0b7692a97fef3818e91f8b461f9bfca1d435b1ebc63796d0","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0c1b2361fc2ddcd851acca53b2fb5ffb0ada086d29ef9669545e51cd3ba66acc","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c92b5d1dcfba92115d1151e2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c92b5d1dcfba92115d1151e2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:56343e23efd8e6b61083a258d070db586367ec3cc2060ca610189f3d0c267fd7","q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83"],"scopeContentSha256":"268939a83d4929df66b954dacdd9bfeebd08b3331a1d4d7a3dd2f54778f8da73","contributionContentSha256":"7416a9e90e6a78bd8250835ef0a51c94a9a5604fdebbabf9fdfb6ca13f1e6a9f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:56343e23efd8e6b61083a258d070db586367ec3cc2060ca610189f3d0c267fd7","textSha256":"a2b9646770262962e49333a5ca77e5926c97fcf720d63613260cd48f2183184c"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:23adeb764a58974f484460361a49148b","paperId":"1911.01606","sourceSha256":"88cd20ebb66b017d86dd37d3ef137519420224064b3e418c7e7e05895bb50fd3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8c107653ddedc13e558c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"185ec3167f8037be0b7692a97fef3818e91f8b461f9bfca1d435b1ebc63796d0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"3402fb8e876c5f7d07c258b37aa22fb89dc8d01f32e7704a03a84243a33f7d1a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3982ed89cd6e66e9c40b171c4496d1dc","paperId":"1911.01606","sourceSha256":"88cd20ebb66b017d86dd37d3ef137519420224064b3e418c7e7e05895bb50fd3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/8c107653ddedc13e558c/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"185ec3167f8037be0b7692a97fef3818e91f8b461f9bfca1d435b1ebc63796d0","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0c1b2361fc2ddcd851acca53b2fb5ffb0ada086d29ef9669545e51cd3ba66acc","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c92b5d1dcfba92115d1151e2","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound canonical-potential mapping, late-time dynamics and conjecture tests. The w(z)<−0.9 examples are not likelihood fits or ultraviolet constructions.","challengeNote":"Compound potential mapping, dynamics and conjecture tests. The w(z)<−0.9 examples establish neither a likelihood fit nor ultraviolet control.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:88ce44f0caa7b30b634908a43627ec92122791e73c618e3a83a89e95b539a112","home":{"unitId":"unit:88ce44f0caa7b30b634908a43627ec92122791e73c618e3a83a89e95b539a112","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:88ce44f0caa7b30b634908a43627ec92122791e73c618e3a83a89e95b539a112","paperId":"2405.00762","textSha256":"0eecee0006f7c537ca5145c41e3008b825d346477f6d902b343efc426a3953a2"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a604ef9a2afb4e61907b29ef"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a604ef9a2afb4e61907b29ef","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:88ce44f0caa7b30b634908a43627ec92122791e73c618e3a83a89e95b539a112","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"4cb0ef138d9fb6488793d3137cdb259ded16270b0576be5788619b3713bd5356","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:88ce44f0caa7b30b634908a43627ec92122791e73c618e3a83a89e95b539a112","paperId":"2405.00762","textSha256":"0eecee0006f7c537ca5145c41e3008b825d346477f6d902b343efc426a3953a2"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a604ef9a2afb4e61907b29ef"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:88ce44f0caa7b30b634908a43627ec92122791e73c618e3a83a89e95b539a112","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d60","kind":"description","unitIndex":60,"unitId":"unit:88ce44f0caa7b30b634908a43627ec92122791e73c618e3a83a89e95b539a112","textSha256":"0eecee0006f7c537ca5145c41e3008b825d346477f6d902b343efc426a3953a2"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ef5061459a200c759aebc561"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ef5061459a200c759aebc561","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:88ce44f0caa7b30b634908a43627ec92122791e73c618e3a83a89e95b539a112","q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83"],"scopeContentSha256":"268939a83d4929df66b954dacdd9bfeebd08b3331a1d4d7a3dd2f54778f8da73","contributionContentSha256":"defd5ade59a224e81f9f1268db6cb2f20b04f6d608e393070817bd95c21d21c8","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d60","kind":"description","unitIndex":60,"unitId":"unit:88ce44f0caa7b30b634908a43627ec92122791e73c618e3a83a89e95b539a112","textSha256":"0eecee0006f7c537ca5145c41e3008b825d346477f6d902b343efc426a3953a2"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ef5061459a200c759aebc561","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound wave-variable and background-solution targets; power-law and exponential potentials are alternatives and η remains source-defined.","challengeNote":"Compound wave-variable and background targets; power-law and exponential potentials are alternatives. η is not identified with a wave-speed bound.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:8ca2967543747a18cf10fbd1dbd3d6fb2efe74f9d143b4c3877e04b19c399698","home":{"unitId":"unit:8ca2967543747a18cf10fbd1dbd3d6fb2efe74f9d143b4c3877e04b19c399698","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8ca2967543747a18cf10fbd1dbd3d6fb2efe74f9d143b4c3877e04b19c399698","paperId":"1911.01606","textSha256":"4367946ef98497d135c00557c1e18c74c225cb8b02e19abbb2a86ce379af3252"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8cd1cdcf04569c6dc60b0b3c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8cd1cdcf04569c6dc60b0b3c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8ca2967543747a18cf10fbd1dbd3d6fb2efe74f9d143b4c3877e04b19c399698","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"086ecbaa8e644e89fd729bf5d73e691c590987950a4b2d87a74a3d06af302d2f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8ca2967543747a18cf10fbd1dbd3d6fb2efe74f9d143b4c3877e04b19c399698","paperId":"1911.01606","textSha256":"4367946ef98497d135c00557c1e18c74c225cb8b02e19abbb2a86ce379af3252"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8cd1cdcf04569c6dc60b0b3c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8ca2967543747a18cf10fbd1dbd3d6fb2efe74f9d143b4c3877e04b19c399698","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d35","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:8ca2967543747a18cf10fbd1dbd3d6fb2efe74f9d143b4c3877e04b19c399698","textSha256":"4367946ef98497d135c00557c1e18c74c225cb8b02e19abbb2a86ce379af3252"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:39ff2f0f303407bcf5d57bfe"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:39ff2f0f303407bcf5d57bfe","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8ca2967543747a18cf10fbd1dbd3d6fb2efe74f9d143b4c3877e04b19c399698","q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83"],"scopeContentSha256":"268939a83d4929df66b954dacdd9bfeebd08b3331a1d4d7a3dd2f54778f8da73","contributionContentSha256":"23e29d0cdbd4b8b5af8012b2635c9b7d8d1f30936da1df1e299cd4e5ffb0b374","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d35","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:8ca2967543747a18cf10fbd1dbd3d6fb2efe74f9d143b4c3877e04b19c399698","textSha256":"4367946ef98497d135c00557c1e18c74c225cb8b02e19abbb2a86ce379af3252"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:39ff2f0f303407bcf5d57bfe","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:92288b1829363084fe19c59d554f46ab107393c44265ab76ff9964447783d975","home":{"unitId":"unit:92288b1829363084fe19c59d554f46ab107393c44265ab76ff9964447783d975","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:92288b1829363084fe19c59d554f46ab107393c44265ab76ff9964447783d975","paperId":"0801.3375","textSha256":"5bdd523ab29e9b56923157519eecbf3cd05cfdf0a502b8377017011b5f3ce751"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3d92894b9e57ec57ce7ea0fa"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3d92894b9e57ec57ce7ea0fa","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:92288b1829363084fe19c59d554f46ab107393c44265ab76ff9964447783d975","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"a6185c1b009efc33bb989138707bf15570a0c66f170e31f368f415c1dc79bc3b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:92288b1829363084fe19c59d554f46ab107393c44265ab76ff9964447783d975","paperId":"0801.3375","textSha256":"5bdd523ab29e9b56923157519eecbf3cd05cfdf0a502b8377017011b5f3ce751"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3d92894b9e57ec57ce7ea0fa"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:92288b1829363084fe19c59d554f46ab107393c44265ab76ff9964447783d975","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:92288b1829363084fe19c59d554f46ab107393c44265ab76ff9964447783d975","textSha256":"5bdd523ab29e9b56923157519eecbf3cd05cfdf0a502b8377017011b5f3ce751"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5ca4641cd8bf41ceab1a0791"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5ca4641cd8bf41ceab1a0791","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:92288b1829363084fe19c59d554f46ab107393c44265ab76ff9964447783d975","q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83"],"scopeContentSha256":"268939a83d4929df66b954dacdd9bfeebd08b3331a1d4d7a3dd2f54778f8da73","contributionContentSha256":"e4b2edd1e1483ddb9efd33a3960856bac14ffa9017c36b0205b6a6c005a27aa9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:92288b1829363084fe19c59d554f46ab107393c44265ab76ff9964447783d975","textSha256":"5bdd523ab29e9b56923157519eecbf3cd05cfdf0a502b8377017011b5f3ce751"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5ca4641cd8bf41ceab1a0791","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound attractor and viability targets. Sub-Planckian field values are not automatically excursions.","challengeNote":"Compound attractor, model-shape and viability targets. Field values are not automatically canonical excursions.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:e6e8090f9f9af9401a5477aad4bfc04bc712d75d59b7c4ccfad1b3c1f3606b66","home":{"unitId":"unit:e6e8090f9f9af9401a5477aad4bfc04bc712d75d59b7c4ccfad1b3c1f3606b66","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e6e8090f9f9af9401a5477aad4bfc04bc712d75d59b7c4ccfad1b3c1f3606b66","paperId":"1808.09440","textSha256":"80f2ea5197bb6db29657d6c18787c6ae3a9509cc303e0688cde73b50cb8450fe"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a9b8891cc5085c9d970e0b08"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a9b8891cc5085c9d970e0b08","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e6e8090f9f9af9401a5477aad4bfc04bc712d75d59b7c4ccfad1b3c1f3606b66","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"1b2d332bf8a88482c8b3f5cc1c1db86ff691dad8b0afa6afcfa85912ffc21da3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e6e8090f9f9af9401a5477aad4bfc04bc712d75d59b7c4ccfad1b3c1f3606b66","paperId":"1808.09440","textSha256":"80f2ea5197bb6db29657d6c18787c6ae3a9509cc303e0688cde73b50cb8450fe"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a9b8891cc5085c9d970e0b08"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e6e8090f9f9af9401a5477aad4bfc04bc712d75d59b7c4ccfad1b3c1f3606b66","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:e6e8090f9f9af9401a5477aad4bfc04bc712d75d59b7c4ccfad1b3c1f3606b66","textSha256":"80f2ea5197bb6db29657d6c18787c6ae3a9509cc303e0688cde73b50cb8450fe"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bdcc05e663f949f4ac1cd02a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:bdcc05e663f949f4ac1cd02a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e6e8090f9f9af9401a5477aad4bfc04bc712d75d59b7c4ccfad1b3c1f3606b66","q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83"],"scopeContentSha256":"268939a83d4929df66b954dacdd9bfeebd08b3331a1d4d7a3dd2f54778f8da73","contributionContentSha256":"835e11e015b94d8574c8e7976fe0dcc528c9dd7c2a4b089d1c37357e58e89976","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d13","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:e6e8090f9f9af9401a5477aad4bfc04bc712d75d59b7c4ccfad1b3c1f3606b66","textSha256":"80f2ea5197bb6db29657d6c18787c6ae3a9509cc303e0688cde73b50cb8450fe"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bdcc05e663f949f4ac1cd02a","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:fbeb63b8648db40f61c7a6d0ec0b38c689f100fac60129cc3d457cfb1f579ea1","home":{"unitId":"unit:fbeb63b8648db40f61c7a6d0ec0b38c689f100fac60129cc3d457cfb1f579ea1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fbeb63b8648db40f61c7a6d0ec0b38c689f100fac60129cc3d457cfb1f579ea1","paperId":"2503.01961","textSha256":"659bbd5573db0d6493b304cdb84d1dacaed1c83d370e68bf222f3eaf3151c6b6"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:909d45763b53b674eb0ba3f1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:909d45763b53b674eb0ba3f1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fbeb63b8648db40f61c7a6d0ec0b38c689f100fac60129cc3d457cfb1f579ea1","q025-candidate-region:afcbf18172178c18659ee7f1"],"scopeContentSha256":"e440e9cb762e51faf6cf780f55027f078bbf18890eab77753bd95c99b9765a35","placementContentSha256":"7b1111250234b888d78d7a72438c83ef901ecf52fda070d456a9afd733b865ac","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fbeb63b8648db40f61c7a6d0ec0b38c689f100fac60129cc3d457cfb1f579ea1","paperId":"2503.01961","textSha256":"659bbd5573db0d6493b304cdb84d1dacaed1c83d370e68bf222f3eaf3151c6b6"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:909d45763b53b674eb0ba3f1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fbeb63b8648db40f61c7a6d0ec0b38c689f100fac60129cc3d457cfb1f579ea1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d61","kind":"description","unitIndex":61,"unitId":"unit:fbeb63b8648db40f61c7a6d0ec0b38c689f100fac60129cc3d457cfb1f579ea1","textSha256":"659bbd5573db0d6493b304cdb84d1dacaed1c83d370e68bf222f3eaf3151c6b6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d698b4a62be329c4b43d048e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d698b4a62be329c4b43d048e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fbeb63b8648db40f61c7a6d0ec0b38c689f100fac60129cc3d457cfb1f579ea1","q025-candidate-question:715cd4329d49d0da86047b83"],"scopeContentSha256":"268939a83d4929df66b954dacdd9bfeebd08b3331a1d4d7a3dd2f54778f8da73","contributionContentSha256":"c233dee1c3121237577988595ce4d50d847cc3f8cd19ea91c593327968b679d6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d61","kind":"description","unitIndex":61,"unitId":"unit:fbeb63b8648db40f61c7a6d0ec0b38c689f100fac60129cc3d457cfb1f579ea1","textSha256":"659bbd5573db0d6493b304cdb84d1dacaed1c83d370e68bf222f3eaf3151c6b6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d698b4a62be329c4b43d048e","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Interaction distinguishability and cancellation are related targets, not proof of a uniquely identifiable coupling.","challengeNote":"Distinguishability and possible cancellation remain separate targets within the source question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":10,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"311256a1bd9326af84db51b6b0d2d6fe6240fbb9a7ac727b3342544790fe8079"},"organizational-access:4fd5613c7d06a7d76db052bd":{"id":"organizational-access:4fd5613c7d06a7d76db052bd","source":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","target":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:43ad89e4e2ad7abd05dd9665"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:a4b58bf49c3221cb97852968"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0cae266d78712fa075f02fab181af200d8268d0031f3a1ee6f0326eb0b0f9555","home":{"unitId":"unit:0cae266d78712fa075f02fab181af200d8268d0031f3a1ee6f0326eb0b0f9555","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0cae266d78712fa075f02fab181af200d8268d0031f3a1ee6f0326eb0b0f9555","paperId":"2405.04584","textSha256":"2c85176014c1f418573d35a67d94ae08e221f584f2a5dc2da18239a0646c5a8a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:76919e633b06e898bdf40859"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:76919e633b06e898bdf40859","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0cae266d78712fa075f02fab181af200d8268d0031f3a1ee6f0326eb0b0f9555","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"7b0f2b979cb9c65c8cbbb7aba4131e09e3ddbe84a0a720c98009c5aab8c3b92c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0cae266d78712fa075f02fab181af200d8268d0031f3a1ee6f0326eb0b0f9555","paperId":"2405.04584","textSha256":"2c85176014c1f418573d35a67d94ae08e221f584f2a5dc2da18239a0646c5a8a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:76919e633b06e898bdf40859"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0cae266d78712fa075f02fab181af200d8268d0031f3a1ee6f0326eb0b0f9555","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:0cae266d78712fa075f02fab181af200d8268d0031f3a1ee6f0326eb0b0f9555","textSha256":"2c85176014c1f418573d35a67d94ae08e221f584f2a5dc2da18239a0646c5a8a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3ec1278deb362a43b0e6baf2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3ec1278deb362a43b0e6baf2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0cae266d78712fa075f02fab181af200d8268d0031f3a1ee6f0326eb0b0f9555","q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0"],"scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","contributionContentSha256":"64d30d7903b2b24da2bad85fb8337757d8449ef05e7eef15403b54155054c4e0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:0cae266d78712fa075f02fab181af200d8268d0031f3a1ee6f0326eb0b0f9555","textSha256":"2c85176014c1f418573d35a67d94ae08e221f584f2a5dc2da18239a0646c5a8a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3ec1278deb362a43b0e6baf2","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Interior critical-point existence and supersymmetric DW-index tests remain distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Compound interior critical-point existence and supersymmetric DW-index targets remain distinct.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:0f083105ddf43ac6e86182ab8759dfba6f85dcdb69b41af103c3e19f5b041f17","home":{"unitId":"unit:0f083105ddf43ac6e86182ab8759dfba6f85dcdb69b41af103c3e19f5b041f17","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0f083105ddf43ac6e86182ab8759dfba6f85dcdb69b41af103c3e19f5b041f17","paperId":"hep-th/0610102","textSha256":"3e6ae63671d22501dc3a1475e8fb6d3073a35aae22feb6bde538d074f75d34c5"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fa1541a0ad61aaaa9c65f918a10eeec3","paperId":"hep-th/0610102","sourceSha256":"21a5452e8c8746b9d211f1b8c945fbaa614b55a953ef7f167500407e7597865e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/627858364259b19294d9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1c08511e6f322a52a613800ef5cdaf731c92cfa35f8f45b1223a519f9ef87c9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"66818320522b8defb6b50b9ba167001889a5a211cbf4b67b6be87c919a48dd1f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f4ca7a0d2efd90d20f6e2d53"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f4ca7a0d2efd90d20f6e2d53","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0f083105ddf43ac6e86182ab8759dfba6f85dcdb69b41af103c3e19f5b041f17","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"d93ba58cc4f5c0cae9d473dbbe542084e7ad5df95c40f4b04aa46ddf70799e21","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0f083105ddf43ac6e86182ab8759dfba6f85dcdb69b41af103c3e19f5b041f17","paperId":"hep-th/0610102","textSha256":"3e6ae63671d22501dc3a1475e8fb6d3073a35aae22feb6bde538d074f75d34c5"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fa1541a0ad61aaaa9c65f918a10eeec3","paperId":"hep-th/0610102","sourceSha256":"21a5452e8c8746b9d211f1b8c945fbaa614b55a953ef7f167500407e7597865e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/627858364259b19294d9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1c08511e6f322a52a613800ef5cdaf731c92cfa35f8f45b1223a519f9ef87c9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"66818320522b8defb6b50b9ba167001889a5a211cbf4b67b6be87c919a48dd1f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f4ca7a0d2efd90d20f6e2d53"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0f083105ddf43ac6e86182ab8759dfba6f85dcdb69b41af103c3e19f5b041f17","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d68","kind":"description","unitIndex":68,"unitId":"unit:0f083105ddf43ac6e86182ab8759dfba6f85dcdb69b41af103c3e19f5b041f17","textSha256":"3e6ae63671d22501dc3a1475e8fb6d3073a35aae22feb6bde538d074f75d34c5"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fa1541a0ad61aaaa9c65f918a10eeec3","paperId":"hep-th/0610102","sourceSha256":"21a5452e8c8746b9d211f1b8c945fbaa614b55a953ef7f167500407e7597865e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/627858364259b19294d9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1c08511e6f322a52a613800ef5cdaf731c92cfa35f8f45b1223a519f9ef87c9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"66818320522b8defb6b50b9ba167001889a5a211cbf4b67b6be87c919a48dd1f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c3170a8135cb51f5fd472683"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c3170a8135cb51f5fd472683","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0f083105ddf43ac6e86182ab8759dfba6f85dcdb69b41af103c3e19f5b041f17","q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0"],"scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","contributionContentSha256":"678475b09ffe44a5311ee5e34388d62d3389ba197cee4679ee3a8e0654ad68f6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d68","kind":"description","unitIndex":68,"unitId":"unit:0f083105ddf43ac6e86182ab8759dfba6f85dcdb69b41af103c3e19f5b041f17","textSha256":"3e6ae63671d22501dc3a1475e8fb6d3073a35aae22feb6bde538d074f75d34c5"},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fa1541a0ad61aaaa9c65f918a10eeec3","paperId":"hep-th/0610102","sourceSha256":"21a5452e8c8746b9d211f1b8c945fbaa614b55a953ef7f167500407e7597865e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/627858364259b19294d9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b1c08511e6f322a52a613800ef5cdaf731c92cfa35f8f45b1223a519f9ef87c9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"66818320522b8defb6b50b9ba167001889a5a211cbf4b67b6be87c919a48dd1f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c3170a8135cb51f5fd472683","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":1,"proposalNote":"Compound review; January 2007 construction and landscape claims retain their dated scope.","challengeNote":"Compound construction, statistical and cosmological review; claims retain the January 2007 source scope.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:2143abd5e22c51bbfffcd445f22b2f700af171924f3dc9c0194b573914fba4e0","home":{"unitId":"unit:2143abd5e22c51bbfffcd445f22b2f700af171924f3dc9c0194b573914fba4e0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2143abd5e22c51bbfffcd445f22b2f700af171924f3dc9c0194b573914fba4e0","paperId":"hep-th/0701050","textSha256":"e9c7f2ec25d0ef6a8780e41eac5969a06bc76651e860ffc9eb905b4cf797a338"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c7aa31fa0febf1c5746b04f9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c7aa31fa0febf1c5746b04f9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2143abd5e22c51bbfffcd445f22b2f700af171924f3dc9c0194b573914fba4e0","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"8226f2659e9ebe411d51f277ad4ad40c909e2fc1c6f515f05f2c0299bfe7c5e2","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2143abd5e22c51bbfffcd445f22b2f700af171924f3dc9c0194b573914fba4e0","paperId":"hep-th/0701050","textSha256":"e9c7f2ec25d0ef6a8780e41eac5969a06bc76651e860ffc9eb905b4cf797a338"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c7aa31fa0febf1c5746b04f9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2143abd5e22c51bbfffcd445f22b2f700af171924f3dc9c0194b573914fba4e0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d72","kind":"description","unitIndex":72,"unitId":"unit:2143abd5e22c51bbfffcd445f22b2f700af171924f3dc9c0194b573914fba4e0","textSha256":"e9c7f2ec25d0ef6a8780e41eac5969a06bc76651e860ffc9eb905b4cf797a338"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5bb38d71a900a98178b01802"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5bb38d71a900a98178b01802","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2143abd5e22c51bbfffcd445f22b2f700af171924f3dc9c0194b573914fba4e0","q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0"],"scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","contributionContentSha256":"5d79ba4bb275e25274e64570252f4b725268a5ed4a9adc60f64c621b2d3a2b3c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d72","kind":"description","unitIndex":72,"unitId":"unit:2143abd5e22c51bbfffcd445f22b2f700af171924f3dc9c0194b573914fba4e0","textSha256":"e9c7f2ec25d0ef6a8780e41eac5969a06bc76651e860ffc9eb905b4cf797a338"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5bb38d71a900a98178b01802","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound stabilization and statistical-testability overview.","challengeNote":"Compound stabilization, ensemble and statistical-testability overview.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:45eb2ac7b3b7ff30d89ca2b99a4310acd54a8d0a037da4733b5f786a4d798346","home":{"unitId":"unit:45eb2ac7b3b7ff30d89ca2b99a4310acd54a8d0a037da4733b5f786a4d798346","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q11 includes effective-theory vacuum existence, control and counting/finiteness, covering the entire solution-and-accumulation question.","qualification":"q11 covers supersymmetric effective-theory solutions, coupling and cosmological-constant tuning, and the explicit landscape-finiteness question. q1 covers construction/control but not the entire accumulation target. The intact notes deny established α′ control and a ten-dimensional lift; neither damaged ending is needed or reconstructed.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:45eb2ac7b3b7ff30d89ca2b99a4310acd54a8d0a037da4733b5f786a4d798346","paperId":"hep-th/0607015","textSha256":"a60179d67c1cf55eae05138a249eb10a5bbef9f463b2bd12c3cb6ab3ae2282e0"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0004:u24:q11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0004:u24:q11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:45eb2ac7b3b7ff30d89ca2b99a4310acd54a8d0a037da4733b5f786a4d798346","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"6a3185e88a5b0d566d192599711fb7a74d12e7d5d54103e3a15f3754930f27de","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0004:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0004:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:45eb2ac7b3b7ff30d89ca2b99a4310acd54a8d0a037da4733b5f786a4d798346","paperId":"hep-th/0607015","textSha256":"a60179d67c1cf55eae05138a249eb10a5bbef9f463b2bd12c3cb6ab3ae2282e0"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0004","unitRef":"u24"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:45eb2ac7b3b7ff30d89ca2b99a4310acd54a8d0a037da4733b5f786a4d798346","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:45eb2ac7b3b7ff30d89ca2b99a4310acd54a8d0a037da4733b5f786a4d798346","textSha256":"a60179d67c1cf55eae05138a249eb10a5bbef9f463b2bd12c3cb6ab3ae2282e0"},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cb3939a6caa2ea49cc61711ca5c88d8a","paperId":"hep-th/0607015","sourceSha256":"f41373c6bec9beaddd0bb98a855305e4d6ecb8bf8047afc3856acd50678b5e82","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2979aca4b52a62f25bcd/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3ee2187075836a6ead26b4ef2bfa4180d996a58f10d58234cbb96ba1db00fc15","pdfPage":4,"start":1296,"end":3138,"textSha256":"ca74fc98685d3d2abd64d503e2f3f4b8abb0c24ba04ba6f3ce9eb06c560f96f0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fb89aa0c07a29c05cd24cdb3e93c3048","paperId":"hep-th/0607015","sourceSha256":"f41373c6bec9beaddd0bb98a855305e4d6ecb8bf8047afc3856acd50678b5e82","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2979aca4b52a62f25bcd/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3ee2187075836a6ead26b4ef2bfa4180d996a58f10d58234cbb96ba1db00fc15","pdfPage":4,"start":96,"end":3138,"textSha256":"bd2be10aa2f70cbe0be7b123286362a2ec2c2a867d1713e3b4b5775743372b90","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3471467fa0a1d16242c0b329"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3471467fa0a1d16242c0b329","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:45eb2ac7b3b7ff30d89ca2b99a4310acd54a8d0a037da4733b5f786a4d798346","q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0"],"scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","contributionContentSha256":"5502b65446683edb04dc5213a602b0141a62b2c73c88c1f6c4ec2d15e75547fb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:45eb2ac7b3b7ff30d89ca2b99a4310acd54a8d0a037da4733b5f786a4d798346","textSha256":"a60179d67c1cf55eae05138a249eb10a5bbef9f463b2bd12c3cb6ab3ae2282e0"},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cb3939a6caa2ea49cc61711ca5c88d8a","paperId":"hep-th/0607015","sourceSha256":"f41373c6bec9beaddd0bb98a855305e4d6ecb8bf8047afc3856acd50678b5e82","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2979aca4b52a62f25bcd/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3ee2187075836a6ead26b4ef2bfa4180d996a58f10d58234cbb96ba1db00fc15","pdfPage":4,"start":1296,"end":3138,"textSha256":"ca74fc98685d3d2abd64d503e2f3f4b8abb0c24ba04ba6f3ce9eb06c560f96f0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fb89aa0c07a29c05cd24cdb3e93c3048","paperId":"hep-th/0607015","sourceSha256":"f41373c6bec9beaddd0bb98a855305e4d6ecb8bf8047afc3856acd50678b5e82","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2979aca4b52a62f25bcd/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3ee2187075836a6ead26b4ef2bfa4180d996a58f10d58234cbb96ba1db00fc15","pdfPage":4,"start":96,"end":3138,"textSha256":"bd2be10aa2f70cbe0be7b123286362a2ec2c2a867d1713e3b4b5775743372b90","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3471467fa0a1d16242c0b329","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound solution/accumulation target. Four-dimensional tree-level families lack an established 10D lift and α′ control; apparent infinity is not completed-vac ","challengeNote":"Compound solution/accumulation target. Tree-level coupling and Λ tuning establishes neither α′ control nor a 10D lift; apparent infinity is not an infinity of ","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","home":{"unitId":"unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","paperId":"1811.09282","textSha256":"6511505ddb2cf8a11445de636d4abeca8f52338414f97009e3b12e8f0e87e0fd"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:43299369fd3b0fd76b56a4d8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:43299369fd3b0fd76b56a4d8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"b775f14fd8f1dd8ed10a38e5a913e34d8a5f311071ca7354e43c140900c261a5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","paperId":"1811.09282","textSha256":"6511505ddb2cf8a11445de636d4abeca8f52338414f97009e3b12e8f0e87e0fd"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:43299369fd3b0fd76b56a4d8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","textSha256":"6511505ddb2cf8a11445de636d4abeca8f52338414f97009e3b12e8f0e87e0fd"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:66759d1346fabb5b4242b484"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:66759d1346fabb5b4242b484","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0"],"scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","contributionContentSha256":"cce8e3260b5ba2119803ce40f5b1272b1e3175d3f66aaa3e79db21cab00b7f5b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:8283ede5a5c02209bb80e0884c1d6e28e10cf178ab041d8fc59fc50df664b66a","textSha256":"6511505ddb2cf8a11445de636d4abeca8f52338414f97009e3b12e8f0e87e0fd"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:66759d1346fabb5b4242b484","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","home":{"unitId":"unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","paperId":"0904.4601","textSha256":"3d404d207a91cd29c46bcea11bed37344008b9d20feedba3be6fb14715fac554"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:35b4febe482d468861a43025"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:35b4febe482d468861a43025","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"3d93d9dcbeacd972bbb4ae10e4481fd656ca0ce0fa457f730ff187e180846298","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","paperId":"0904.4601","textSha256":"3d404d207a91cd29c46bcea11bed37344008b9d20feedba3be6fb14715fac554"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:35b4febe482d468861a43025"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","textSha256":"3d404d207a91cd29c46bcea11bed37344008b9d20feedba3be6fb14715fac554"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4a59d55f5eac1172848575db"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4a59d55f5eac1172848575db","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0"],"scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","contributionContentSha256":"b7232f1971c8241dfa43684e370199a63d5d0fc4508bcaf6b19f9e03183e18d9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:891215e68c9dffe4839ac3526dadb6bc1eb6579ee5c6c0c771f2db67ca2b4392","textSha256":"3d404d207a91cd29c46bcea11bed37344008b9d20feedba3be6fb14715fac554"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4a59d55f5eac1172848575db","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound review spanning model construction, statistics and cosmological signatures.","challengeNote":"Compound review of construction, statistics and particle/cosmological signatures.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:8ae1449c44f44e88df92d5f7c8b09b2e26723c4f2363b3c5c2c75538408cec50","home":{"unitId":"unit:8ae1449c44f44e88df92d5f7c8b09b2e26723c4f2363b3c5c2c75538408cec50","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8ae1449c44f44e88df92d5f7c8b09b2e26723c4f2363b3c5c2c75538408cec50","paperId":"2006.07290","textSha256":"e6bee2e6cbef076c2214e13c3c2a60c54a26ead270a99b7a2f0cc3b8d197b698"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0c1302b1fb12991d34407c5b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0c1302b1fb12991d34407c5b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8ae1449c44f44e88df92d5f7c8b09b2e26723c4f2363b3c5c2c75538408cec50","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"c59f7e2f310ba05d00e8a198b14dbb5345a554cb1296df769d81be1993d56fc3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8ae1449c44f44e88df92d5f7c8b09b2e26723c4f2363b3c5c2c75538408cec50","paperId":"2006.07290","textSha256":"e6bee2e6cbef076c2214e13c3c2a60c54a26ead270a99b7a2f0cc3b8d197b698"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0c1302b1fb12991d34407c5b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8ae1449c44f44e88df92d5f7c8b09b2e26723c4f2363b3c5c2c75538408cec50","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:8ae1449c44f44e88df92d5f7c8b09b2e26723c4f2363b3c5c2c75538408cec50","textSha256":"e6bee2e6cbef076c2214e13c3c2a60c54a26ead270a99b7a2f0cc3b8d197b698"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:501e29d54782907ad959d693"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:501e29d54782907ad959d693","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8ae1449c44f44e88df92d5f7c8b09b2e26723c4f2363b3c5c2c75538408cec50","q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0"],"scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","contributionContentSha256":"13c2b0b7948b194e98b027cab92a0799bffeff02e43b32eec6d4706bb2f8b963","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:8ae1449c44f44e88df92d5f7c8b09b2e26723c4f2363b3c5c2c75538408cec50","textSha256":"e6bee2e6cbef076c2214e13c3c2a60c54a26ead270a99b7a2f0cc3b8d197b698"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:501e29d54782907ad959d693","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Perturbative compactification and proposed quantum-gravity restrictions remain source-specific.","challengeNote":"Small-energy construction and proposed spectral restrictions are stated; an ensemble-distribution target is not.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:99cb1f90c104096350b01eaf57e5bbcba948c90c77a96e89e14994d8bef961de","home":{"unitId":"unit:99cb1f90c104096350b01eaf57e5bbcba948c90c77a96e89e14994d8bef961de","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:99cb1f90c104096350b01eaf57e5bbcba948c90c77a96e89e14994d8bef961de","paperId":"0803.1194","textSha256":"1244fb127851a204223fa6ddd91c495b74511267977fe0b57d5c286529d11a24"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:00b39a6ec2eacd9ce600b2486912038c","paperId":"0803.1194","sourceSha256":"3235494a4bd7d0b9728284666b52269c08055716395d80a7b195228887b716be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2c715bbade5b10245b11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"424f56e3c9b8da51c1f1b94b51d6f33519ddf7dbd27ca0bcfdd6cfade0f0dd2d","pdfPage":7,"start":100,"end":2856,"textSha256":"8c04983d8df9ec7c62b47df7aad542bf6c9cf06c2d6e4fbfa9832c209f6c388d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:99d41839212d7075cd9926f1ba4c504c","paperId":"0803.1194","sourceSha256":"3235494a4bd7d0b9728284666b52269c08055716395d80a7b195228887b716be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2c715bbade5b10245b11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"424f56e3c9b8da51c1f1b94b51d6f33519ddf7dbd27ca0bcfdd6cfade0f0dd2d","pdfPage":6,"start":101,"end":3010,"textSha256":"59700f10c018ad3816cc93dda44bac0f22ff8ac6a76db15f1dd11c1216fd8bd4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3e7e4493bda5976b805434ac801e5f7","paperId":"0803.1194","sourceSha256":"3235494a4bd7d0b9728284666b52269c08055716395d80a7b195228887b716be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2c715bbade5b10245b11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"424f56e3c9b8da51c1f1b94b51d6f33519ddf7dbd27ca0bcfdd6cfade0f0dd2d","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2382,"textSha256":"5fef96e94e4f38b1524f7dca4caa108e086f2e8f20d774c2b2ffbec9cb68c85e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6b1aec99d2828dc50e97538f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6b1aec99d2828dc50e97538f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:99cb1f90c104096350b01eaf57e5bbcba948c90c77a96e89e14994d8bef961de","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"aa4e74f40ab1c29cce80020210e984b98aad30f462e98ccd102bace4a643b6c9","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:99cb1f90c104096350b01eaf57e5bbcba948c90c77a96e89e14994d8bef961de","paperId":"0803.1194","textSha256":"1244fb127851a204223fa6ddd91c495b74511267977fe0b57d5c286529d11a24"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:00b39a6ec2eacd9ce600b2486912038c","paperId":"0803.1194","sourceSha256":"3235494a4bd7d0b9728284666b52269c08055716395d80a7b195228887b716be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2c715bbade5b10245b11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"424f56e3c9b8da51c1f1b94b51d6f33519ddf7dbd27ca0bcfdd6cfade0f0dd2d","pdfPage":7,"start":100,"end":2856,"textSha256":"8c04983d8df9ec7c62b47df7aad542bf6c9cf06c2d6e4fbfa9832c209f6c388d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:99d41839212d7075cd9926f1ba4c504c","paperId":"0803.1194","sourceSha256":"3235494a4bd7d0b9728284666b52269c08055716395d80a7b195228887b716be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2c715bbade5b10245b11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"424f56e3c9b8da51c1f1b94b51d6f33519ddf7dbd27ca0bcfdd6cfade0f0dd2d","pdfPage":6,"start":101,"end":3010,"textSha256":"59700f10c018ad3816cc93dda44bac0f22ff8ac6a76db15f1dd11c1216fd8bd4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3e7e4493bda5976b805434ac801e5f7","paperId":"0803.1194","sourceSha256":"3235494a4bd7d0b9728284666b52269c08055716395d80a7b195228887b716be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2c715bbade5b10245b11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"424f56e3c9b8da51c1f1b94b51d6f33519ddf7dbd27ca0bcfdd6cfade0f0dd2d","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2382,"textSha256":"5fef96e94e4f38b1524f7dca4caa108e086f2e8f20d774c2b2ffbec9cb68c85e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6b1aec99d2828dc50e97538f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:99cb1f90c104096350b01eaf57e5bbcba948c90c77a96e89e14994d8bef961de","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:99cb1f90c104096350b01eaf57e5bbcba948c90c77a96e89e14994d8bef961de","textSha256":"1244fb127851a204223fa6ddd91c495b74511267977fe0b57d5c286529d11a24"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:00b39a6ec2eacd9ce600b2486912038c","paperId":"0803.1194","sourceSha256":"3235494a4bd7d0b9728284666b52269c08055716395d80a7b195228887b716be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2c715bbade5b10245b11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"424f56e3c9b8da51c1f1b94b51d6f33519ddf7dbd27ca0bcfdd6cfade0f0dd2d","pdfPage":7,"start":100,"end":2856,"textSha256":"8c04983d8df9ec7c62b47df7aad542bf6c9cf06c2d6e4fbfa9832c209f6c388d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:99d41839212d7075cd9926f1ba4c504c","paperId":"0803.1194","sourceSha256":"3235494a4bd7d0b9728284666b52269c08055716395d80a7b195228887b716be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2c715bbade5b10245b11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"424f56e3c9b8da51c1f1b94b51d6f33519ddf7dbd27ca0bcfdd6cfade0f0dd2d","pdfPage":6,"start":101,"end":3010,"textSha256":"59700f10c018ad3816cc93dda44bac0f22ff8ac6a76db15f1dd11c1216fd8bd4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3e7e4493bda5976b805434ac801e5f7","paperId":"0803.1194","sourceSha256":"3235494a4bd7d0b9728284666b52269c08055716395d80a7b195228887b716be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2c715bbade5b10245b11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"424f56e3c9b8da51c1f1b94b51d6f33519ddf7dbd27ca0bcfdd6cfade0f0dd2d","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2382,"textSha256":"5fef96e94e4f38b1524f7dca4caa108e086f2e8f20d774c2b2ffbec9cb68c85e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:25a22974895ef46d44ca40a0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:25a22974895ef46d44ca40a0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:99cb1f90c104096350b01eaf57e5bbcba948c90c77a96e89e14994d8bef961de","q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0"],"scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","contributionContentSha256":"55e5e94b786a025b4654afc632a0c11d3ce118dc6ba33aadb606320de7fd4b4d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:99cb1f90c104096350b01eaf57e5bbcba948c90c77a96e89e14994d8bef961de","textSha256":"1244fb127851a204223fa6ddd91c495b74511267977fe0b57d5c286529d11a24"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:00b39a6ec2eacd9ce600b2486912038c","paperId":"0803.1194","sourceSha256":"3235494a4bd7d0b9728284666b52269c08055716395d80a7b195228887b716be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2c715bbade5b10245b11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"424f56e3c9b8da51c1f1b94b51d6f33519ddf7dbd27ca0bcfdd6cfade0f0dd2d","pdfPage":7,"start":100,"end":2856,"textSha256":"8c04983d8df9ec7c62b47df7aad542bf6c9cf06c2d6e4fbfa9832c209f6c388d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:99d41839212d7075cd9926f1ba4c504c","paperId":"0803.1194","sourceSha256":"3235494a4bd7d0b9728284666b52269c08055716395d80a7b195228887b716be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2c715bbade5b10245b11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"424f56e3c9b8da51c1f1b94b51d6f33519ddf7dbd27ca0bcfdd6cfade0f0dd2d","pdfPage":6,"start":101,"end":3010,"textSha256":"59700f10c018ad3816cc93dda44bac0f22ff8ac6a76db15f1dd11c1216fd8bd4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e3e7e4493bda5976b805434ac801e5f7","paperId":"0803.1194","sourceSha256":"3235494a4bd7d0b9728284666b52269c08055716395d80a7b195228887b716be","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2c715bbade5b10245b11/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"424f56e3c9b8da51c1f1b94b51d6f33519ddf7dbd27ca0bcfdd6cfade0f0dd2d","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2382,"textSha256":"5fef96e94e4f38b1524f7dca4caa108e086f2e8f20d774c2b2ffbec9cb68c85e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:25a22974895ef46d44ca40a0","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound construction/statistics review; specific phenomenological applications are explicitly left out.","challengeNote":"Compound review. Add explicit distribution methods from e0; particular phenomenological applications are left out.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a859c242ffc1718b17394d3e37c93c5c959db8a581bab92407f713ca808d62a1","home":{"unitId":"unit:a859c242ffc1718b17394d3e37c93c5c959db8a581bab92407f713ca808d62a1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a859c242ffc1718b17394d3e37c93c5c959db8a581bab92407f713ca808d62a1","paperId":"2107.09065","textSha256":"d9cb84670e6216c69bbc6fe509935fde5f55d33eee0fda7d7102b2f18fa87740"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ecc031d2d0806c63e1520a58"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ecc031d2d0806c63e1520a58","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a859c242ffc1718b17394d3e37c93c5c959db8a581bab92407f713ca808d62a1","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"e08f57524d79ae23fb47d7255b1d5d1f4ed5584888045c914029781849026f24","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a859c242ffc1718b17394d3e37c93c5c959db8a581bab92407f713ca808d62a1","paperId":"2107.09065","textSha256":"d9cb84670e6216c69bbc6fe509935fde5f55d33eee0fda7d7102b2f18fa87740"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ecc031d2d0806c63e1520a58"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a859c242ffc1718b17394d3e37c93c5c959db8a581bab92407f713ca808d62a1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:a859c242ffc1718b17394d3e37c93c5c959db8a581bab92407f713ca808d62a1","textSha256":"d9cb84670e6216c69bbc6fe509935fde5f55d33eee0fda7d7102b2f18fa87740"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e9f4c3e7d83d4b7eca389a9f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e9f4c3e7d83d4b7eca389a9f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a859c242ffc1718b17394d3e37c93c5c959db8a581bab92407f713ca808d62a1","q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0"],"scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","contributionContentSha256":"edf03f927754cf43bfb8c47f244515f4f41f8131b4566f41934eea804a2d3bbd","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:a859c242ffc1718b17394d3e37c93c5c959db8a581bab92407f713ca808d62a1","textSha256":"d9cb84670e6216c69bbc6fe509935fde5f55d33eee0fda7d7102b2f18fa87740"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e9f4c3e7d83d4b7eca389a9f","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The target includes energy below 10^−123 M_pl^4 and extreme radius separation without exhaustive flux search.","challengeNote":"Replace statistical specialization with the explicit search comparison. Targets include energy below 10^−123 M_pl^4 and extreme radius separation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","home":{"unitId":"unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","paperId":"2310.20559","textSha256":"62736f351d73808f031c5ad9a0b3680d2bb146f2d6a25c8b50ee11fc63b6ff10"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dda39a55c34d4b5aafe052aa"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dda39a55c34d4b5aafe052aa","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"91d1215083a39245cabeebea425f9ed1e5b451ef0f61dfb4a021ce4ee1fd14d0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","paperId":"2310.20559","textSha256":"62736f351d73808f031c5ad9a0b3680d2bb146f2d6a25c8b50ee11fc63b6ff10"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dda39a55c34d4b5aafe052aa"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","textSha256":"62736f351d73808f031c5ad9a0b3680d2bb146f2d6a25c8b50ee11fc63b6ff10"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ad9a81d24f3e92ebe5c72723"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ad9a81d24f3e92ebe5c72723","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0"],"scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","contributionContentSha256":"81e1adb6dccf4502a60b47a233d0c139906502435f6efd1e78823553d2b1e0e5","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:ca7f4cf83d65c06e80abd2ce590890a652fc3847670ebb371c4da13c92d9502f","textSha256":"62736f351d73808f031c5ad9a0b3680d2bb146f2d6a25c8b50ee11fc63b6ff10"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ad9a81d24f3e92ebe5c72723","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound construction, control and phenomenological/cosmological requirements.","challengeNote":"Compound construction, control and phenomenological/cosmological requirements.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:e164b13eaa3dfcdb99849c22b0c27206a681da15f10727d72bc11717f327bab0","home":{"unitId":"unit:e164b13eaa3dfcdb99849c22b0c27206a681da15f10727d72bc11717f327bab0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e164b13eaa3dfcdb99849c22b0c27206a681da15f10727d72bc11717f327bab0","paperId":"2104.10181","textSha256":"5cd3ec9d105bf8c3669db1c8881a70863486a24ae31bb02d7eaad395b960b265"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5a058a4809b844ad1fd894e8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5a058a4809b844ad1fd894e8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e164b13eaa3dfcdb99849c22b0c27206a681da15f10727d72bc11717f327bab0","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"89259e733e3aeea966972125d2cd512a4d71d77016e6193afe956f46a601cae4","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e164b13eaa3dfcdb99849c22b0c27206a681da15f10727d72bc11717f327bab0","paperId":"2104.10181","textSha256":"5cd3ec9d105bf8c3669db1c8881a70863486a24ae31bb02d7eaad395b960b265"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5a058a4809b844ad1fd894e8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e164b13eaa3dfcdb99849c22b0c27206a681da15f10727d72bc11717f327bab0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d29","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:e164b13eaa3dfcdb99849c22b0c27206a681da15f10727d72bc11717f327bab0","textSha256":"5cd3ec9d105bf8c3669db1c8881a70863486a24ae31bb02d7eaad395b960b265"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aaf174657bdecfde468d5027"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:aaf174657bdecfde468d5027","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e164b13eaa3dfcdb99849c22b0c27206a681da15f10727d72bc11717f327bab0","q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0"],"scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","contributionContentSha256":"f8e67751647f7843ad90360b34aa3ef5afb75fe33ecb7c47cd0bc8e826d645f1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d29","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:e164b13eaa3dfcdb99849c22b0c27206a681da15f10727d72bc11717f327bab0","textSha256":"5cd3ec9d105bf8c3669db1c8881a70863486a24ae31bb02d7eaad395b960b265"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aaf174657bdecfde468d5027","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Fixed two-modulus growth sector; large volume and weak coupling are retained requirements.","challengeNote":"Setting-derived facet with a fixed two-modulus growth sector, large volume and weak coupling.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","home":{"unitId":"unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","paperId":"1212.0555","textSha256":"c180947d17f1f742fd6ff41a1902dbb09cd1d08d5a24706710e7dd7faf547697"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:64e06c07845fe92a09dbb94e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:64e06c07845fe92a09dbb94e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","q025-candidate-region:b4d08fb421593b2978269858"],"scopeContentSha256":"ef5676541487a7a5dd01cbe61b6ac47a9096439aa2156355140bf9ba11bdabba","placementContentSha256":"6cf317ee564afadd4752bebb7f1887e1a2fec7c3642a241eed993e41385facbe","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","paperId":"1212.0555","textSha256":"c180947d17f1f742fd6ff41a1902dbb09cd1d08d5a24706710e7dd7faf547697"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:64e06c07845fe92a09dbb94e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","textSha256":"c180947d17f1f742fd6ff41a1902dbb09cd1d08d5a24706710e7dd7faf547697"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:70877e6291a41f54350121c6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:70877e6291a41f54350121c6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","q025-candidate-question:80913a03f5344f1bf9d703e0"],"scopeContentSha256":"91952d28c2f3796467f82acf104ff931a8abb3656e1dc20862a12885a102c429","contributionContentSha256":"b9e335426d9dff296a7666d4ca9fecc918c4236d87434d701e9e8ebd38311393","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:ec19e49b31889bc616cc488c1295a534404b8e7ccd99c92d997e5057f45dbab6","textSha256":"c180947d17f1f742fd6ff41a1902dbb09cd1d08d5a24706710e7dd7faf547697"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:70877e6291a41f54350121c6","recordId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d13b20f32a6b348a6afc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"Combined stabilization, SUSY-breaking and particle-sector construction targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":12,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"5d72171510a952d4e2de71f1ba0c6ba5d831f29edbd083e0728fc1dd62c2663b"},"organizational-access:8ac5bbb37198aeeb3f4506e2":{"id":"organizational-access:8ac5bbb37198aeeb3f4506e2","source":"q025-candidate-region:b94ce03fce78e6a7aff5b473","target":"q025-candidate-question:93e176170dec2b76cee2349e","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:b94ce03fce78e6a7aff5b473","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"ed67270cc117e3d7ebededa4f2cbde2cb13aca6cc6474d05fcba403fd3944a8a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:56a00d8f0d60727d7e1d6d46"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:93e176170dec2b76cee2349e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"69a615906cb4eb89bf45c03630f0e539c2cb9eb9449c17d72d28860e1bd1120b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:78bec7c07252316d857087ea"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5321f630c0764d12d4458a4b246943b35dfa29ce45ff09634c0397507c6984a6","home":{"unitId":"unit:5321f630c0764d12d4458a4b246943b35dfa29ce45ff09634c0397507c6984a6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b94ce03fce78e6a7aff5b473","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5321f630c0764d12d4458a4b246943b35dfa29ce45ff09634c0397507c6984a6","paperId":"0808.1709","textSha256":"70fede50acefbf8ff49dcea51fbab86caa1260933987d99e301317c91ff560b4"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6a6b8c051b3789bd4f5eab9ea1407302","paperId":"0808.1709","sourceSha256":"299b48485ee48349dbe1eab0e683400e0036cc2e34fb1ec71aa5d0d6c6138b7d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/20f4514de02a68bf34fe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"85a4df0567462a36aeca618f0e7f905df86618cd8d9cf727976c38066c38c1ac","pdfPage":2,"start":1299,"end":3391,"textSha256":"2da31daf0edd8846d9ed6afdee257967f2f1878dfb93e26a8c4319443ff2c3cc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c54e93a26931412fd6bf5a3f03f9ef70","paperId":"0808.1709","sourceSha256":"299b48485ee48349dbe1eab0e683400e0036cc2e34fb1ec71aa5d0d6c6138b7d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/20f4514de02a68bf34fe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"85a4df0567462a36aeca618f0e7f905df86618cd8d9cf727976c38066c38c1ac","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2520,"textSha256":"50e8082ff66c7b282264e5626c06247a76915b7c7c0bfad02ad61ed6a73e7c83","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:497d06895d39cc416804223c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:497d06895d39cc416804223c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5321f630c0764d12d4458a4b246943b35dfa29ce45ff09634c0397507c6984a6","q025-candidate-region:b94ce03fce78e6a7aff5b473"],"scopeContentSha256":"ed67270cc117e3d7ebededa4f2cbde2cb13aca6cc6474d05fcba403fd3944a8a","placementContentSha256":"07fa6889b9ab438abf274cb224201355408be81a723f083641a43a2bb166e70e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge","leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5321f630c0764d12d4458a4b246943b35dfa29ce45ff09634c0397507c6984a6","paperId":"0808.1709","textSha256":"70fede50acefbf8ff49dcea51fbab86caa1260933987d99e301317c91ff560b4"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6a6b8c051b3789bd4f5eab9ea1407302","paperId":"0808.1709","sourceSha256":"299b48485ee48349dbe1eab0e683400e0036cc2e34fb1ec71aa5d0d6c6138b7d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/20f4514de02a68bf34fe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"85a4df0567462a36aeca618f0e7f905df86618cd8d9cf727976c38066c38c1ac","pdfPage":2,"start":1299,"end":3391,"textSha256":"2da31daf0edd8846d9ed6afdee257967f2f1878dfb93e26a8c4319443ff2c3cc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c54e93a26931412fd6bf5a3f03f9ef70","paperId":"0808.1709","sourceSha256":"299b48485ee48349dbe1eab0e683400e0036cc2e34fb1ec71aa5d0d6c6138b7d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/20f4514de02a68bf34fe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"85a4df0567462a36aeca618f0e7f905df86618cd8d9cf727976c38066c38c1ac","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2520,"textSha256":"50e8082ff66c7b282264e5626c06247a76915b7c7c0bfad02ad61ed6a73e7c83","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:497d06895d39cc416804223c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5321f630c0764d12d4458a4b246943b35dfa29ce45ff09634c0397507c6984a6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:93e176170dec2b76cee2349e","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:5321f630c0764d12d4458a4b246943b35dfa29ce45ff09634c0397507c6984a6","textSha256":"70fede50acefbf8ff49dcea51fbab86caa1260933987d99e301317c91ff560b4"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6a6b8c051b3789bd4f5eab9ea1407302","paperId":"0808.1709","sourceSha256":"299b48485ee48349dbe1eab0e683400e0036cc2e34fb1ec71aa5d0d6c6138b7d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/20f4514de02a68bf34fe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"85a4df0567462a36aeca618f0e7f905df86618cd8d9cf727976c38066c38c1ac","pdfPage":2,"start":1299,"end":3391,"textSha256":"2da31daf0edd8846d9ed6afdee257967f2f1878dfb93e26a8c4319443ff2c3cc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c54e93a26931412fd6bf5a3f03f9ef70","paperId":"0808.1709","sourceSha256":"299b48485ee48349dbe1eab0e683400e0036cc2e34fb1ec71aa5d0d6c6138b7d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/20f4514de02a68bf34fe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"85a4df0567462a36aeca618f0e7f905df86618cd8d9cf727976c38066c38c1ac","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2520,"textSha256":"50e8082ff66c7b282264e5626c06247a76915b7c7c0bfad02ad61ed6a73e7c83","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:34c904c1e292d188420bbab4","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound causal-structure, inner-horizon and complementarity targets remain source-scoped. Independent challenge qualification: Compound causal-structure, inner-horizon and complementarity targets remain source-scoped and require fine reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:34c904c1e292d188420bbab4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5321f630c0764d12d4458a4b246943b35dfa29ce45ff09634c0397507c6984a6","q025-candidate-question:93e176170dec2b76cee2349e"],"scopeContentSha256":"69a615906cb4eb89bf45c03630f0e539c2cb9eb9449c17d72d28860e1bd1120b","contributionContentSha256":"222a5c6764c329df56aa350accb251f7730c369ba8a1219cb6a0ceb9727fd7a2","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:5321f630c0764d12d4458a4b246943b35dfa29ce45ff09634c0397507c6984a6","textSha256":"70fede50acefbf8ff49dcea51fbab86caa1260933987d99e301317c91ff560b4"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6a6b8c051b3789bd4f5eab9ea1407302","paperId":"0808.1709","sourceSha256":"299b48485ee48349dbe1eab0e683400e0036cc2e34fb1ec71aa5d0d6c6138b7d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/20f4514de02a68bf34fe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"85a4df0567462a36aeca618f0e7f905df86618cd8d9cf727976c38066c38c1ac","pdfPage":2,"start":1299,"end":3391,"textSha256":"2da31daf0edd8846d9ed6afdee257967f2f1878dfb93e26a8c4319443ff2c3cc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c54e93a26931412fd6bf5a3f03f9ef70","paperId":"0808.1709","sourceSha256":"299b48485ee48349dbe1eab0e683400e0036cc2e34fb1ec71aa5d0d6c6138b7d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/20f4514de02a68bf34fe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"85a4df0567462a36aeca618f0e7f905df86618cd8d9cf727976c38066c38c1ac","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2520,"textSha256":"50e8082ff66c7b282264e5626c06247a76915b7c7c0bfad02ad61ed6a73e7c83","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:34c904c1e292d188420bbab4","recordId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound causal-structure, inner-horizon and complementarity targets remain source-scoped.","challengeNote":"Compound causal-structure, inner-horizon and complementarity targets remain source-scoped and require fine reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5c57793bfe2b69a7f10cae45744159a7be7ab72d459445d1bd3d622a3abc0c5a","home":{"unitId":"unit:5c57793bfe2b69a7f10cae45744159a7be7ab72d459445d1bd3d622a3abc0c5a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b94ce03fce78e6a7aff5b473","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5c57793bfe2b69a7f10cae45744159a7be7ab72d459445d1bd3d622a3abc0c5a","paperId":"2005.07032","textSha256":"e78cd91dcca66ab08d41b4b5eda2d36552776ac2a0adc4538150de11b1db0c9f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:92056a0dc342e69262722a47"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:92056a0dc342e69262722a47","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5c57793bfe2b69a7f10cae45744159a7be7ab72d459445d1bd3d622a3abc0c5a","q025-candidate-region:b94ce03fce78e6a7aff5b473"],"scopeContentSha256":"ed67270cc117e3d7ebededa4f2cbde2cb13aca6cc6474d05fcba403fd3944a8a","placementContentSha256":"6d4ccbae516da0afc1ea530101ed2ff1a5c23acaf93f1b5057874d2f8f72ef03","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge","leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5c57793bfe2b69a7f10cae45744159a7be7ab72d459445d1bd3d622a3abc0c5a","paperId":"2005.07032","textSha256":"e78cd91dcca66ab08d41b4b5eda2d36552776ac2a0adc4538150de11b1db0c9f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:92056a0dc342e69262722a47"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5c57793bfe2b69a7f10cae45744159a7be7ab72d459445d1bd3d622a3abc0c5a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:93e176170dec2b76cee2349e","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d35","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:5c57793bfe2b69a7f10cae45744159a7be7ab72d459445d1bd3d622a3abc0c5a","textSha256":"e78cd91dcca66ab08d41b4b5eda2d36552776ac2a0adc4538150de11b1db0c9f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:373c1b298b5516744ef70a37","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Broad review combines weak and strong censorship, genericity and quantum predictivity; fine identity needs separation. Independent challenge qualification: Review combines weak and strong censorship, genericity and quantum predictivity; no atomic fine question is established."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:373c1b298b5516744ef70a37","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5c57793bfe2b69a7f10cae45744159a7be7ab72d459445d1bd3d622a3abc0c5a","q025-candidate-question:93e176170dec2b76cee2349e"],"scopeContentSha256":"69a615906cb4eb89bf45c03630f0e539c2cb9eb9449c17d72d28860e1bd1120b","contributionContentSha256":"0cbf1266e6d9d29a65b15262c2a64277d96fb9dd8f0167b0a62fd5ff0162108a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d35","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:5c57793bfe2b69a7f10cae45744159a7be7ab72d459445d1bd3d622a3abc0c5a","textSha256":"e78cd91dcca66ab08d41b4b5eda2d36552776ac2a0adc4538150de11b1db0c9f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:373c1b298b5516744ef70a37","recordId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-778d942f6c1caa8a4096-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Broad review combines weak and strong censorship, genericity and quantum predictivity; fine identity needs separation.","challengeNote":"Review combines weak and strong censorship, genericity and quantum predictivity; no atomic fine question is established.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"77cefe5ff70efbb11c2ce4b05394a78e7ead24773ed56888e7605e98021a9369"},"organizational-access:e22e678dadc00b0b9128199c":{"id":"organizational-access:e22e678dadc00b0b9128199c","source":"q025-candidate-region:cdffe542ffa4d073352bef49","target":"q025-candidate-question:ce218cc821c841d040efcc77","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:cdffe542ffa4d073352bef49","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"eff3a57caf822b2927c7977fca7e168e59929c1aaa503a36e624b1a4ab15aafc","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2a86d4345e3de85794493b1a"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ce218cc821c841d040efcc77","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"13e5f91c349312f47f68c4ac7b3b043a82a169fe849e04f15afd385da7cf2b32","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d28fe3c9315e64506cdb5dac"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:23a8368e6d4aafb39ea7755a94192ce8deea0056241cb5ddb4620f2bf6c20909","home":{"unitId":"unit:23a8368e6d4aafb39ea7755a94192ce8deea0056241cb5ddb4620f2bf6c20909","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:cdffe542ffa4d073352bef49","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:23a8368e6d4aafb39ea7755a94192ce8deea0056241cb5ddb4620f2bf6c20909","paperId":"hep-th/0507158","textSha256":"9da0243f10d6aef71eb167a4ac3e060b7283c0344f253692cbc83e1416d1ee72"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:96c4bbf57e7d1857b01d2623"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:96c4bbf57e7d1857b01d2623","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:23a8368e6d4aafb39ea7755a94192ce8deea0056241cb5ddb4620f2bf6c20909","q025-candidate-region:cdffe542ffa4d073352bef49"],"scopeContentSha256":"eff3a57caf822b2927c7977fca7e168e59929c1aaa503a36e624b1a4ab15aafc","placementContentSha256":"a25badc88255e6fe534aecca439268e9fb225935a26c09545d4ea053a76374f6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-challenge","leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:23a8368e6d4aafb39ea7755a94192ce8deea0056241cb5ddb4620f2bf6c20909","paperId":"hep-th/0507158","textSha256":"9da0243f10d6aef71eb167a4ac3e060b7283c0344f253692cbc83e1416d1ee72"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:96c4bbf57e7d1857b01d2623"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:23a8368e6d4aafb39ea7755a94192ce8deea0056241cb5ddb4620f2bf6c20909","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ce218cc821c841d040efcc77","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:23a8368e6d4aafb39ea7755a94192ce8deea0056241cb5ddb4620f2bf6c20909","textSha256":"9da0243f10d6aef71eb167a4ac3e060b7283c0344f253692cbc83e1416d1ee72"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:857ecc780ebbd8efb80867f0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:857ecc780ebbd8efb80867f0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:23a8368e6d4aafb39ea7755a94192ce8deea0056241cb5ddb4620f2bf6c20909","q025-candidate-question:ce218cc821c841d040efcc77"],"scopeContentSha256":"13e5f91c349312f47f68c4ac7b3b043a82a169fe849e04f15afd385da7cf2b32","contributionContentSha256":"ac2433306e402d2e1b37d83b743bdc8b5441804fade71313c66a94bf6d1d3339","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-proposal","leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:23a8368e6d4aafb39ea7755a94192ce8deea0056241cb5ddb4620f2bf6c20909","textSha256":"9da0243f10d6aef71eb167a4ac3e060b7283c0344f253692cbc83e1416d1ee72"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:857ecc780ebbd8efb80867f0","recordId":"leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Potential construction and distinct stabilization, de Sitter and slow-roll tests form a material compound; canonical fine identity remains unresolved.","challengeNote":"Potential construction, stabilization, de Sitter extrema and slow roll form a material compound; canonical fine identity remains unresolved.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:683262ad8d9f0246025249ca6fb72bfdb1319cb7f31e6291e6259b52c201cfa9","home":{"unitId":"unit:683262ad8d9f0246025249ca6fb72bfdb1319cb7f31e6291e6259b52c201cfa9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:cdffe542ffa4d073352bef49","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:683262ad8d9f0246025249ca6fb72bfdb1319cb7f31e6291e6259b52c201cfa9","paperId":"2610.30248","textSha256":"f5b4a6665b62aa8cf7ad5ac5c5929940491546ef884e38baefd90cadb3e00a6a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ac5e21c112a29ae52b7f1b07"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ac5e21c112a29ae52b7f1b07","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:683262ad8d9f0246025249ca6fb72bfdb1319cb7f31e6291e6259b52c201cfa9","q025-candidate-region:cdffe542ffa4d073352bef49"],"scopeContentSha256":"eff3a57caf822b2927c7977fca7e168e59929c1aaa503a36e624b1a4ab15aafc","placementContentSha256":"aab4f0951a655c2fc934b8f0209c0fbb299963304188e8036e938306ae93f813","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-challenge","leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:683262ad8d9f0246025249ca6fb72bfdb1319cb7f31e6291e6259b52c201cfa9","paperId":"2610.30248","textSha256":"f5b4a6665b62aa8cf7ad5ac5c5929940491546ef884e38baefd90cadb3e00a6a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ac5e21c112a29ae52b7f1b07"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:683262ad8d9f0246025249ca6fb72bfdb1319cb7f31e6291e6259b52c201cfa9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ce218cc821c841d040efcc77","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:683262ad8d9f0246025249ca6fb72bfdb1319cb7f31e6291e6259b52c201cfa9","textSha256":"f5b4a6665b62aa8cf7ad5ac5c5929940491546ef884e38baefd90cadb3e00a6a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d2c8906253d31adaf450cbf4"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d2c8906253d31adaf450cbf4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:683262ad8d9f0246025249ca6fb72bfdb1319cb7f31e6291e6259b52c201cfa9","q025-candidate-question:ce218cc821c841d040efcc77"],"scopeContentSha256":"13e5f91c349312f47f68c4ac7b3b043a82a169fe849e04f15afd385da7cf2b32","contributionContentSha256":"0a53481eaff96d6fcc890bc20c6fe07a42294f89c7c00967d238c3029478677d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-proposal","leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:683262ad8d9f0246025249ca6fb72bfdb1319cb7f31e6291e6259b52c201cfa9","textSha256":"f5b4a6665b62aa8cf7ad5ac5c5929940491546ef884e38baefd90cadb3e00a6a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d2c8906253d31adaf450cbf4","recordId":"leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5ead4e26cf383a1fc84c-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound existence, KK-control and supersymmetry targets. Nonconstant internal warping is queried, not assumed realized.","challengeNote":"Existence, KK hierarchy and supersymmetry remain compound targets. Nonconstant warping is queried, not assumed realized.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"d819e16884ec22e70c8cbfd0792de8fcf391d0e65744d1fdf68f57e31a91c7f3"},"organizational-access:56e62016e9658da6a462427f":{"id":"organizational-access:56e62016e9658da6a462427f","source":"q025-candidate-region:cf54c3ee2ccc692267164342","target":"q025-candidate-question:eedb7c2ce7d3c7d1a8df49c2","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:cf54c3ee2ccc692267164342","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"a9f2d668c67c40d9c6be947714cd46480f488cd987fab378453c1e98a2934f25","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b05cbaf93e05bdd908dd7cd2"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:eedb7c2ce7d3c7d1a8df49c2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"4d9dbc8af0a23840d1085899ccf13d62431e0818be1b467a398c1b2a00de624b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:mediation:pq12"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:23e19e25602589efaad70a244b32268c40bfd13aed5ba20ebe40a5abb7978337","home":{"unitId":"unit:23e19e25602589efaad70a244b32268c40bfd13aed5ba20ebe40a5abb7978337","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:cf54c3ee2ccc692267164342","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:23e19e25602589efaad70a244b32268c40bfd13aed5ba20ebe40a5abb7978337","paperId":"1912.09948","textSha256":"e653435ed9f0adb2aa8aa147391e1882d0e28633e090ea09014471b53df782d4"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:860918608b134eefd2fdac35"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:860918608b134eefd2fdac35","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:23e19e25602589efaad70a244b32268c40bfd13aed5ba20ebe40a5abb7978337","q025-candidate-region:cf54c3ee2ccc692267164342"],"scopeContentSha256":"a9f2d668c67c40d9c6be947714cd46480f488cd987fab378453c1e98a2934f25","placementContentSha256":"c0e312d471a92907d7bff4e7c20013ee770af83677dcf07690c35573cf59066e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-challenge","leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:23e19e25602589efaad70a244b32268c40bfd13aed5ba20ebe40a5abb7978337","paperId":"1912.09948","textSha256":"e653435ed9f0adb2aa8aa147391e1882d0e28633e090ea09014471b53df782d4"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:860918608b134eefd2fdac35"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:23e19e25602589efaad70a244b32268c40bfd13aed5ba20ebe40a5abb7978337","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:eedb7c2ce7d3c7d1a8df49c2","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u30","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:23e19e25602589efaad70a244b32268c40bfd13aed5ba20ebe40a5abb7978337","paperId":"1912.09948","textSha256":"e653435ed9f0adb2aa8aa147391e1882d0e28633e090ea09014471b53df782d4"}],"qualification":"The description explicitly asks what changes when a light conifold field is retained, including vacuum structure and supersymmetry breaking. No primary retained-field calculation is supplied.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z23"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z23","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:23e19e25602589efaad70a244b32268c40bfd13aed5ba20ebe40a5abb7978337","q025-candidate-question:eedb7c2ce7d3c7d1a8df49c2"],"scopeContentSha256":"4d9dbc8af0a23840d1085899ccf13d62431e0818be1b467a398c1b2a00de624b","contributionContentSha256":"5de75c7cd038ee3a684075025d95dcafb1254c944c2be8178156166f22ac8d23","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","challengeReviewId":"mediation-source-role-confirmation"},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","mediation-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u30","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:23e19e25602589efaad70a244b32268c40bfd13aed5ba20ebe40a5abb7978337","paperId":"1912.09948","textSha256":"e653435ed9f0adb2aa8aa147391e1882d0e28633e090ea09014471b53df782d4"}],"explicitConfirmation":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z23","family":"mediation","originalRowId":"z23","oldRole":{"id":"z23","unitRef":"u30","questionRef":"pq12","role":"instantiates","reason":"The description explicitly asks what changes when a light conifold field is retained, including vacuum structure and supersymmetry breaking. No primary retained-field calculation is supplied.","refs":["u30"]},"confirmation":{"id":"z23","verdict":"supported_as_written","basis":"description_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":[],"reason":"Retaining a light conifold field and asking how vacuum structure, supersymmetry breaking and soft terms change supplies a concrete retained-field application. The original absence of primary calculations is correctly retained.","refs":["u30","pq12","n17"]},"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","challengeReviewId":"mediation-source-role-confirmation","qualificationUnchanged":true}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:63c8d92af5aabdc8733514f1557cafc49e8ccf5e4e9196709079d8a51c4708fc","home":{"unitId":"unit:63c8d92af5aabdc8733514f1557cafc49e8ccf5e4e9196709079d8a51c4708fc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:cf54c3ee2ccc692267164342","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:63c8d92af5aabdc8733514f1557cafc49e8ccf5e4e9196709079d8a51c4708fc","paperId":"hep-th/0411066","textSha256":"76bebc6a2a66abdf691ea79a6bc2d8a19217dd0e80ee5cb9f449d191da677621"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4f13b76b45e9f2556431dfc8769e686d","paperId":"hep-th/0411066","sourceSha256":"9f9e795811715d35ee9bcd4b62526a79276668f9cb3061055091aabedd31dd36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e31c8436b8e71cf065a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9a34379df3263ffe3a4e6b3254593b757e5fa3b0109ee139bd29b3f62fcb25ac","pdfPage":2,"start":101,"end":2610,"textSha256":"bd87b5ac008129f5a8c97706df4727a70d95b608d1daa5e41a4df1204790319b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5c2567140292b51fd79c805002b8dbce","paperId":"hep-th/0411066","sourceSha256":"9f9e795811715d35ee9bcd4b62526a79276668f9cb3061055091aabedd31dd36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e31c8436b8e71cf065a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9a34379df3263ffe3a4e6b3254593b757e5fa3b0109ee139bd29b3f62fcb25ac","pdfPage":5,"start":99,"end":2258,"textSha256":"3355413c3ff8c6efa8e56613253974e3fb9340fa3340f9b7c8c532c096e5040d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:280f2f49d04caec004193745"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:280f2f49d04caec004193745","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:63c8d92af5aabdc8733514f1557cafc49e8ccf5e4e9196709079d8a51c4708fc","q025-candidate-region:cf54c3ee2ccc692267164342"],"scopeContentSha256":"a9f2d668c67c40d9c6be947714cd46480f488cd987fab378453c1e98a2934f25","placementContentSha256":"eb34917760ac780162b7f225d579d31d3b2340b6d26591560972455db09a5453","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-challenge","leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:63c8d92af5aabdc8733514f1557cafc49e8ccf5e4e9196709079d8a51c4708fc","paperId":"hep-th/0411066","textSha256":"76bebc6a2a66abdf691ea79a6bc2d8a19217dd0e80ee5cb9f449d191da677621"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4f13b76b45e9f2556431dfc8769e686d","paperId":"hep-th/0411066","sourceSha256":"9f9e795811715d35ee9bcd4b62526a79276668f9cb3061055091aabedd31dd36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e31c8436b8e71cf065a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9a34379df3263ffe3a4e6b3254593b757e5fa3b0109ee139bd29b3f62fcb25ac","pdfPage":2,"start":101,"end":2610,"textSha256":"bd87b5ac008129f5a8c97706df4727a70d95b608d1daa5e41a4df1204790319b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5c2567140292b51fd79c805002b8dbce","paperId":"hep-th/0411066","sourceSha256":"9f9e795811715d35ee9bcd4b62526a79276668f9cb3061055091aabedd31dd36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e31c8436b8e71cf065a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9a34379df3263ffe3a4e6b3254593b757e5fa3b0109ee139bd29b3f62fcb25ac","pdfPage":5,"start":99,"end":2258,"textSha256":"3355413c3ff8c6efa8e56613253974e3fb9340fa3340f9b7c8c532c096e5040d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:280f2f49d04caec004193745"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:63c8d92af5aabdc8733514f1557cafc49e8ccf5e4e9196709079d8a51c4708fc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:eedb7c2ce7d3c7d1a8df49c2","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u31","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:63c8d92af5aabdc8733514f1557cafc49e8ccf5e4e9196709079d8a51c4708fc","paperId":"hep-th/0411066","textSha256":"76bebc6a2a66abdf691ea79a6bc2d8a19217dd0e80ee5cb9f449d191da677621"},{"localRef":"e34","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4f13b76b45e9f2556431dfc8769e686d","paperId":"hep-th/0411066","sourceSha256":"9f9e795811715d35ee9bcd4b62526a79276668f9cb3061055091aabedd31dd36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e31c8436b8e71cf065a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9a34379df3263ffe3a4e6b3254593b757e5fa3b0109ee139bd29b3f62fcb25ac","pdfPage":2,"start":101,"end":2610,"textSha256":"bd87b5ac008129f5a8c97706df4727a70d95b608d1daa5e41a4df1204790319b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e35","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5c2567140292b51fd79c805002b8dbce","paperId":"hep-th/0411066","sourceSha256":"9f9e795811715d35ee9bcd4b62526a79276668f9cb3061055091aabedd31dd36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e31c8436b8e71cf065a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9a34379df3263ffe3a4e6b3254593b757e5fa3b0109ee139bd29b3f62fcb25ac","pdfPage":5,"start":99,"end":2258,"textSha256":"3355413c3ff8c6efa8e56613253974e3fb9340fa3340f9b7c8c532c096e5040d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"qualification":"The primary windows explicitly test the hierarchy used to integrate out the dilaton and complex structure and explain why retained auxiliary expectations matter to mediation.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z24"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z24","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:63c8d92af5aabdc8733514f1557cafc49e8ccf5e4e9196709079d8a51c4708fc","q025-candidate-question:eedb7c2ce7d3c7d1a8df49c2"],"scopeContentSha256":"4d9dbc8af0a23840d1085899ccf13d62431e0818be1b467a398c1b2a00de624b","contributionContentSha256":"27bf39583c2facd69271213779ee642191be4ac781f20929d6d553015e3e2242","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","challengeReviewId":"mediation-source-role-confirmation"},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","mediation-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u31","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:63c8d92af5aabdc8733514f1557cafc49e8ccf5e4e9196709079d8a51c4708fc","paperId":"hep-th/0411066","textSha256":"76bebc6a2a66abdf691ea79a6bc2d8a19217dd0e80ee5cb9f449d191da677621"},{"localRef":"e34","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4f13b76b45e9f2556431dfc8769e686d","paperId":"hep-th/0411066","sourceSha256":"9f9e795811715d35ee9bcd4b62526a79276668f9cb3061055091aabedd31dd36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e31c8436b8e71cf065a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9a34379df3263ffe3a4e6b3254593b757e5fa3b0109ee139bd29b3f62fcb25ac","pdfPage":2,"start":101,"end":2610,"textSha256":"bd87b5ac008129f5a8c97706df4727a70d95b608d1daa5e41a4df1204790319b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e35","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5c2567140292b51fd79c805002b8dbce","paperId":"hep-th/0411066","sourceSha256":"9f9e795811715d35ee9bcd4b62526a79276668f9cb3061055091aabedd31dd36","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5e31c8436b8e71cf065a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9a34379df3263ffe3a4e6b3254593b757e5fa3b0109ee139bd29b3f62fcb25ac","pdfPage":5,"start":99,"end":2258,"textSha256":"3355413c3ff8c6efa8e56613253974e3fb9340fa3340f9b7c8c532c096e5040d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"explicitConfirmation":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z24","family":"mediation","originalRowId":"z24","oldRole":{"id":"z24","unitRef":"u31","questionRef":"pq12","role":"addresses","reason":"The primary windows explicitly test the hierarchy used to integrate out the dilaton and complex structure and explain why retained auxiliary expectations matter to mediation.","refs":["u31","e34","e35"]},"confirmation":{"id":"z24","verdict":"supported_as_written","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":[],"reason":"e34/e35 explicitly test the dilaton/complex-structure decoupling hierarchy and explain why their auxiliary expectations must be recoverable for a mediation analysis. This directly addresses pq12.","refs":["u31","pq12","e34","e35","n18"]},"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","challengeReviewId":"mediation-source-role-confirmation","qualificationUnchanged":true}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c319d7046901768d6ecd16c7ac64cbc3f7e70a2459ee9eb8c508820c3b77929b","home":{"unitId":"unit:c319d7046901768d6ecd16c7ac64cbc3f7e70a2459ee9eb8c508820c3b77929b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:cf54c3ee2ccc692267164342","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c319d7046901768d6ecd16c7ac64cbc3f7e70a2459ee9eb8c508820c3b77929b","paperId":"0707.2671","textSha256":"da9519895e186fa3532236dec00809cae6905bc713dc04340791893d67dba42d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:38b12ed34ac6d76700b6b457"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:38b12ed34ac6d76700b6b457","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c319d7046901768d6ecd16c7ac64cbc3f7e70a2459ee9eb8c508820c3b77929b","q025-candidate-region:cf54c3ee2ccc692267164342"],"scopeContentSha256":"a9f2d668c67c40d9c6be947714cd46480f488cd987fab378453c1e98a2934f25","placementContentSha256":"e0d5179f10e52adaf0a435b4ca68ebed2b6564063e34ba6573e40957d910870d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-challenge","leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c319d7046901768d6ecd16c7ac64cbc3f7e70a2459ee9eb8c508820c3b77929b","paperId":"0707.2671","textSha256":"da9519895e186fa3532236dec00809cae6905bc713dc04340791893d67dba42d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:38b12ed34ac6d76700b6b457"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c319d7046901768d6ecd16c7ac64cbc3f7e70a2459ee9eb8c508820c3b77929b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:eedb7c2ce7d3c7d1a8df49c2","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u28","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c319d7046901768d6ecd16c7ac64cbc3f7e70a2459ee9eb8c508820c3b77929b","paperId":"0707.2671","textSha256":"da9519895e186fa3532236dec00809cae6905bc713dc04340791893d67dba42d"}],"qualification":"The description tests direct nonperturbative breaking-field/modulus coupling and the fate of F-term uplift and the suppressed modulus auxiliary expectation. Detailed consistency calculations are absent.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z22"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z22","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c319d7046901768d6ecd16c7ac64cbc3f7e70a2459ee9eb8c508820c3b77929b","q025-candidate-question:eedb7c2ce7d3c7d1a8df49c2"],"scopeContentSha256":"4d9dbc8af0a23840d1085899ccf13d62431e0818be1b467a398c1b2a00de624b","contributionContentSha256":"2c7c51890e4314495398a3ce8415a6565cf8af2e73d672996f4d55fc0255970e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","challengeReviewId":"mediation-source-role-confirmation"},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","mediation-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u28","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c319d7046901768d6ecd16c7ac64cbc3f7e70a2459ee9eb8c508820c3b77929b","paperId":"0707.2671","textSha256":"da9519895e186fa3532236dec00809cae6905bc713dc04340791893d67dba42d"}],"explicitConfirmation":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-explicit-role:mediation:z22","family":"mediation","originalRowId":"z22","oldRole":{"id":"z22","unitRef":"u28","questionRef":"pq12","role":"specializes","reason":"The description tests direct nonperturbative breaking-field/modulus coupling and the fate of F-term uplift and the suppressed modulus auxiliary expectation. Detailed consistency calculations are absent.","refs":["u28"]},"confirmation":{"id":"z22","verdict":"supported_as_written","basis":"description_checked","revisedRole":"unchanged","additionalQualifications":[],"reason":"Direct nonperturbative breaking-field/modulus coupling and its effects on F-term uplift and modulus-F suppression form a narrower coupled-treatment question. Detailed consistency calculations are absent.","refs":["u28","pq12","n15"]},"proposalReviewId":"canonical-adopted-mediation-scope-proposal","challengeReviewId":"mediation-source-role-confirmation","qualificationUnchanged":true}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"bcf971a24b9b0e4ccc947b3aca4654537ab1d0de74321c5db54af393ac755e40"},"organizational-access:cd4f3e9a949a8bfccc279c87":{"id":"organizational-access:cd4f3e9a949a8bfccc279c87","source":"q025-candidate-region:d5580f01c8ada8c471a82935","target":"q025-candidate-question:db786e98ec14ff55fc8b4fa4","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:d5580f01c8ada8c471a82935","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"ebf00394aba52d8c1e456bcb18b34f72812b778dab46fe5ab19c2711d9c1e3b8","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0c80b662736dbd2fe3815e69"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:db786e98ec14ff55fc8b4fa4","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b037bd2a2c3d8581c38c150d33ea51b207775c1acd3ec0b74341d838154e4ef3","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8c85f54a2bb78d22fac7e9c2"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:23f022a5b96a6c82346be1db63379affd1085d3adc544b53c70dd77b7c69ef9d","home":{"unitId":"unit:23f022a5b96a6c82346be1db63379affd1085d3adc544b53c70dd77b7c69ef9d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:d5580f01c8ada8c471a82935","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:23f022a5b96a6c82346be1db63379affd1085d3adc544b53c70dd77b7c69ef9d","paperId":"1912.06626","textSha256":"ddfff9834d398daec8fb0222e7d8a426d0b0d24e28bb1acf46f8622c89d53f71"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c0f85d2c7654e7a164e4d1f4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c0f85d2c7654e7a164e4d1f4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:23f022a5b96a6c82346be1db63379affd1085d3adc544b53c70dd77b7c69ef9d","q025-candidate-region:d5580f01c8ada8c471a82935"],"scopeContentSha256":"ebf00394aba52d8c1e456bcb18b34f72812b778dab46fe5ab19c2711d9c1e3b8","placementContentSha256":"22948216b5238cef7d78761cb2a8c55581d0767df6e8472a06a2d96abda054d7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge","leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:23f022a5b96a6c82346be1db63379affd1085d3adc544b53c70dd77b7c69ef9d","paperId":"1912.06626","textSha256":"ddfff9834d398daec8fb0222e7d8a426d0b0d24e28bb1acf46f8622c89d53f71"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c0f85d2c7654e7a164e4d1f4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:23f022a5b96a6c82346be1db63379affd1085d3adc544b53c70dd77b7c69ef9d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:db786e98ec14ff55fc8b4fa4","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d72","kind":"description","unitIndex":72,"unitId":"unit:23f022a5b96a6c82346be1db63379affd1085d3adc544b53c70dd77b7c69ef9d","textSha256":"ddfff9834d398daec8fb0222e7d8a426d0b0d24e28bb1acf46f8622c89d53f71"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b727cd53b05716f628afeda1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b727cd53b05716f628afeda1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:23f022a5b96a6c82346be1db63379affd1085d3adc544b53c70dd77b7c69ef9d","q025-candidate-question:db786e98ec14ff55fc8b4fa4"],"scopeContentSha256":"b037bd2a2c3d8581c38c150d33ea51b207775c1acd3ec0b74341d838154e4ef3","contributionContentSha256":"b6964debaee1dfc345ff72c9052431eb1d565d23586223b414d6b007c40040a3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-proposal","leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d72","kind":"description","unitIndex":72,"unitId":"unit:23f022a5b96a6c82346be1db63379affd1085d3adc544b53c70dd77b7c69ef9d","textSha256":"ddfff9834d398daec8fb0222e7d8a426d0b0d24e28bb1acf46f8622c89d53f71"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b727cd53b05716f628afeda1","recordId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9c41fa8255a69e60078713bd394407041f97ecd4d4c57c81dc1288db5d319eaf","home":{"unitId":"unit:9c41fa8255a69e60078713bd394407041f97ecd4d4c57c81dc1288db5d319eaf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:d5580f01c8ada8c471a82935","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9c41fa8255a69e60078713bd394407041f97ecd4d4c57c81dc1288db5d319eaf","paperId":"2209.11821","textSha256":"791ddc166a7c0d3aae760b4199eb23f0a4da5e6d05e754cd251a2897fda27eec"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a5c7021236ce0d5c0d3e47fc"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a5c7021236ce0d5c0d3e47fc","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9c41fa8255a69e60078713bd394407041f97ecd4d4c57c81dc1288db5d319eaf","q025-candidate-region:d5580f01c8ada8c471a82935"],"scopeContentSha256":"ebf00394aba52d8c1e456bcb18b34f72812b778dab46fe5ab19c2711d9c1e3b8","placementContentSha256":"1433719461959871c9eaac911c4f41baf27a820982265e2f18f57cc2d992e15b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge","leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9c41fa8255a69e60078713bd394407041f97ecd4d4c57c81dc1288db5d319eaf","paperId":"2209.11821","textSha256":"791ddc166a7c0d3aae760b4199eb23f0a4da5e6d05e754cd251a2897fda27eec"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a5c7021236ce0d5c0d3e47fc"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9c41fa8255a69e60078713bd394407041f97ecd4d4c57c81dc1288db5d319eaf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:db786e98ec14ff55fc8b4fa4","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d97","kind":"description","unitIndex":97,"unitId":"unit:9c41fa8255a69e60078713bd394407041f97ecd4d4c57c81dc1288db5d319eaf","textSha256":"791ddc166a7c0d3aae760b4199eb23f0a4da5e6d05e754cd251a2897fda27eec"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6af0620cbc7babcf550a7b03"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6af0620cbc7babcf550a7b03","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9c41fa8255a69e60078713bd394407041f97ecd4d4c57c81dc1288db5d319eaf","q025-candidate-question:db786e98ec14ff55fc8b4fa4"],"scopeContentSha256":"b037bd2a2c3d8581c38c150d33ea51b207775c1acd3ec0b74341d838154e4ef3","contributionContentSha256":"afa9df1820016f900e4f4a1c731b006405b310b3053f38d9737b110289d89990","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-proposal","leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d97","kind":"description","unitIndex":97,"unitId":"unit:9c41fa8255a69e60078713bd394407041f97ecd4d4c57c81dc1288db5d319eaf","textSha256":"791ddc166a7c0d3aae760b4199eb23f0a4da5e6d05e754cd251a2897fda27eec"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6af0620cbc7babcf550a7b03","recordId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Competing terms are retained instead of assuming one-term dominance.","challengeNote":"Competing terms are retained; single-term dominance is not assumed.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:bf7eba2d96cbe46b67a5148b845d875714faee8fadcd97538e51e5aa25d9c129","home":{"unitId":"unit:bf7eba2d96cbe46b67a5148b845d875714faee8fadcd97538e51e5aa25d9c129","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:d5580f01c8ada8c471a82935","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bf7eba2d96cbe46b67a5148b845d875714faee8fadcd97538e51e5aa25d9c129","paperId":"2004.09285","textSha256":"2cbbb48720b49c16e3d8c8f54d95e685e049ccb5c8372a3981221919f9f05f42"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05280472875729a2e7cd39d5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05280472875729a2e7cd39d5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bf7eba2d96cbe46b67a5148b845d875714faee8fadcd97538e51e5aa25d9c129","q025-candidate-region:d5580f01c8ada8c471a82935"],"scopeContentSha256":"ebf00394aba52d8c1e456bcb18b34f72812b778dab46fe5ab19c2711d9c1e3b8","placementContentSha256":"0f15beb4e372f5742524ba6de1d6cbec1882c69f7992c7bfb8502a353083038c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge","leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bf7eba2d96cbe46b67a5148b845d875714faee8fadcd97538e51e5aa25d9c129","paperId":"2004.09285","textSha256":"2cbbb48720b49c16e3d8c8f54d95e685e049ccb5c8372a3981221919f9f05f42"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05280472875729a2e7cd39d5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bf7eba2d96cbe46b67a5148b845d875714faee8fadcd97538e51e5aa25d9c129","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:db786e98ec14ff55fc8b4fa4","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d79","kind":"description","unitIndex":79,"unitId":"unit:bf7eba2d96cbe46b67a5148b845d875714faee8fadcd97538e51e5aa25d9c129","textSha256":"2cbbb48720b49c16e3d8c8f54d95e685e049ccb5c8372a3981221919f9f05f42"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6f57d3d57b33bee4d3070a8c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6f57d3d57b33bee4d3070a8c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bf7eba2d96cbe46b67a5148b845d875714faee8fadcd97538e51e5aa25d9c129","q025-candidate-question:db786e98ec14ff55fc8b4fa4"],"scopeContentSha256":"b037bd2a2c3d8581c38c150d33ea51b207775c1acd3ec0b74341d838154e4ef3","contributionContentSha256":"2165284f7c21d19dcf751bd34be06064e065f5fe0ee2e26ea5b7ada90d50b1db","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-proposal","leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d79","kind":"description","unitIndex":79,"unitId":"unit:bf7eba2d96cbe46b67a5148b845d875714faee8fadcd97538e51e5aa25d9c129","textSha256":"2cbbb48720b49c16e3d8c8f54d95e685e049ccb5c8372a3981221919f9f05f42"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6f57d3d57b33bee4d3070a8c","recordId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a27350d21fc9bb138bf8-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"09713a8af0b668705b0346687bb370942946494d6ae8b44f1eba8de8d727ebb3"},"organizational-access:295ed1214ebe5aea49e32ee0":{"id":"organizational-access:295ed1214ebe5aea49e32ee0","source":"q025-candidate-region:d6f875b76d84910cb6887d5f","target":"q025-candidate-question:f46690ac720bffc643debed2","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:d6f875b76d84910cb6887d5f","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"fa24d84732dc03bafb44b9947cfbb9be672f828e17335b2a1fac2527fdb60dd0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:435250e60e6c9cbd0f1fc5fc"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f46690ac720bffc643debed2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f75817e88f49e4dea7df9d2824eea9ece40c605a33d656134a437e93e307a3f4","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3827980d1806c365b326d522"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:3d5072a54d78051ec3206a183b439e7afddaab17a407487e50edaf29c0809e27","home":{"unitId":"unit:3d5072a54d78051ec3206a183b439e7afddaab17a407487e50edaf29c0809e27","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:d6f875b76d84910cb6887d5f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3d5072a54d78051ec3206a183b439e7afddaab17a407487e50edaf29c0809e27","paperId":"hep-th/0312104","textSha256":"e7c8189d70b5b7a20c50e42ec1dd43be192edd21933c590fad80c31bb70d1af0"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:a43bb52dc016931fcb766bd3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:a43bb52dc016931fcb766bd3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3d5072a54d78051ec3206a183b439e7afddaab17a407487e50edaf29c0809e27","q025-candidate-region:d6f875b76d84910cb6887d5f"],"scopeContentSha256":"fa24d84732dc03bafb44b9947cfbb9be672f828e17335b2a1fac2527fdb60dd0","placementContentSha256":"d06cb30a63f378c13106e55bc2bed0a2f66bb12f4d6aa858246621166835d817","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3d5072a54d78051ec3206a183b439e7afddaab17a407487e50edaf29c0809e27","paperId":"hep-th/0312104","textSha256":"e7c8189d70b5b7a20c50e42ec1dd43be192edd21933c590fad80c31bb70d1af0"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:a43bb52dc016931fcb766bd3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3d5072a54d78051ec3206a183b439e7afddaab17a407487e50edaf29c0809e27","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f46690ac720bffc643debed2","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d52","kind":"description","unitIndex":52,"unitId":"unit:3d5072a54d78051ec3206a183b439e7afddaab17a407487e50edaf29c0809e27","textSha256":"e7c8189d70b5b7a20c50e42ec1dd43be192edd21933c590fad80c31bb70d1af0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1fc21bfe124582fb9ae04af0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1fc21bfe124582fb9ae04af0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3d5072a54d78051ec3206a183b439e7afddaab17a407487e50edaf29c0809e27","q025-candidate-question:f46690ac720bffc643debed2"],"scopeContentSha256":"f75817e88f49e4dea7df9d2824eea9ece40c605a33d656134a437e93e307a3f4","contributionContentSha256":"7567ea10af063b6d6bf6fdc5d6c061024aa231cd0cc88ac2099dc527816928c9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d52","kind":"description","unitIndex":52,"unitId":"unit:3d5072a54d78051ec3206a183b439e7afddaab17a407487e50edaf29c0809e27","textSha256":"e7c8189d70b5b7a20c50e42ec1dd43be192edd21933c590fad80c31bb70d1af0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1fc21bfe124582fb9ae04af0","recordId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Full SU(3) holonomy; supersymmetric and nonsupersymmetric no-scale branches remain separate.","challengeNote":"Retain full SU(3) holonomy and the alternative supersymmetric and nonsupersymmetric no-scale branches.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:91d0ad1797239ed607e106a149888d5ef43fce563dad7afbaf7e6b1141e4bf96","home":{"unitId":"unit:91d0ad1797239ed607e106a149888d5ef43fce563dad7afbaf7e6b1141e4bf96","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:d6f875b76d84910cb6887d5f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:91d0ad1797239ed607e106a149888d5ef43fce563dad7afbaf7e6b1141e4bf96","paperId":"1212.4530","textSha256":"f3949851187099e6154a9d4ca9d4c143eff52105da12862c47cbf285a65fab83"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:3708420092c61571ffa394af"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:3708420092c61571ffa394af","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:91d0ad1797239ed607e106a149888d5ef43fce563dad7afbaf7e6b1141e4bf96","q025-candidate-region:d6f875b76d84910cb6887d5f"],"scopeContentSha256":"fa24d84732dc03bafb44b9947cfbb9be672f828e17335b2a1fac2527fdb60dd0","placementContentSha256":"6662dd3db90d51b8cbbd7f8b63f3ed964ca48ff6534cefcb6eea35bcb67ac34f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:91d0ad1797239ed607e106a149888d5ef43fce563dad7afbaf7e6b1141e4bf96","paperId":"1212.4530","textSha256":"f3949851187099e6154a9d4ca9d4c143eff52105da12862c47cbf285a65fab83"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:3708420092c61571ffa394af"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:91d0ad1797239ed607e106a149888d5ef43fce563dad7afbaf7e6b1141e4bf96","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f46690ac720bffc643debed2","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:91d0ad1797239ed607e106a149888d5ef43fce563dad7afbaf7e6b1141e4bf96","textSha256":"f3949851187099e6154a9d4ca9d4c143eff52105da12862c47cbf285a65fab83"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:344c8960f0cdd0239221d47b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:344c8960f0cdd0239221d47b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:91d0ad1797239ed607e106a149888d5ef43fce563dad7afbaf7e6b1141e4bf96","q025-candidate-question:f46690ac720bffc643debed2"],"scopeContentSha256":"f75817e88f49e4dea7df9d2824eea9ece40c605a33d656134a437e93e307a3f4","contributionContentSha256":"9dc5039ab10e9d23452799e30761f78c2d3c079fa3df3dbd64e56e0dfbb1c20e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:91d0ad1797239ed607e106a149888d5ef43fce563dad7afbaf7e6b1141e4bf96","textSha256":"f3949851187099e6154a9d4ca9d4c143eff52105da12862c47cbf285a65fab83"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:344c8960f0cdd0239221d47b","recordId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: bounded enumeration and conditional Kähler-uplift applications; no completed de Sitter construction is established.","challengeNote":"Compound enumeration and conditional Kähler-uplift targets; a completed de Sitter construction is not established.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:99149a08ebbb286600f891a49a86b2ce5e20a92f7854ec66e74782ad4f9f571c","home":{"unitId":"unit:99149a08ebbb286600f891a49a86b2ce5e20a92f7854ec66e74782ad4f9f571c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:d6f875b76d84910cb6887d5f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:99149a08ebbb286600f891a49a86b2ce5e20a92f7854ec66e74782ad4f9f571c","paperId":"2210.03706","textSha256":"42883ea77eec657a4aa832d373a436c7f0187e09876b735ac29aca38238851c5"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:aa3a7fedaa17fb500b8aa6c1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:aa3a7fedaa17fb500b8aa6c1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:99149a08ebbb286600f891a49a86b2ce5e20a92f7854ec66e74782ad4f9f571c","q025-candidate-region:d6f875b76d84910cb6887d5f"],"scopeContentSha256":"fa24d84732dc03bafb44b9947cfbb9be672f828e17335b2a1fac2527fdb60dd0","placementContentSha256":"4a3c1ccd5d0eba4675e7535f84b998eb9b2ed0928b4939739dadb20b6ceda655","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:99149a08ebbb286600f891a49a86b2ce5e20a92f7854ec66e74782ad4f9f571c","paperId":"2210.03706","textSha256":"42883ea77eec657a4aa832d373a436c7f0187e09876b735ac29aca38238851c5"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:aa3a7fedaa17fb500b8aa6c1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:99149a08ebbb286600f891a49a86b2ce5e20a92f7854ec66e74782ad4f9f571c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f46690ac720bffc643debed2","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d35","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:99149a08ebbb286600f891a49a86b2ce5e20a92f7854ec66e74782ad4f9f571c","textSha256":"42883ea77eec657a4aa832d373a436c7f0187e09876b735ac29aca38238851c5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:621d8e0bed7b8c07a717b9d6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:621d8e0bed7b8c07a717b9d6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:99149a08ebbb286600f891a49a86b2ce5e20a92f7854ec66e74782ad4f9f571c","q025-candidate-question:f46690ac720bffc643debed2"],"scopeContentSha256":"f75817e88f49e4dea7df9d2824eea9ece40c605a33d656134a437e93e307a3f4","contributionContentSha256":"07c3260df9dca785bc1fea691d59beda2d05e1bc46abceff72ecbc7e6f059b7b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d35","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:99149a08ebbb286600f891a49a86b2ce5e20a92f7854ec66e74782ad4f9f571c","textSha256":"42883ea77eec657a4aa832d373a436c7f0187e09876b735ac29aca38238851c5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:621d8e0bed7b8c07a717b9d6","recordId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: charge/mass/higher-order constraints and infinite supersymmetric Minkowski/AdS families.","challengeNote":"Compound charge, mass and higher-order constraints plus existence of infinite Minkowski/AdS families.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:cb197b0b9a01505681f1cc108073b97eb3fdbfdfbe7d63839a6e1f5caf790186","home":{"unitId":"unit:cb197b0b9a01505681f1cc108073b97eb3fdbfdfbe7d63839a6e1f5caf790186","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:d6f875b76d84910cb6887d5f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cb197b0b9a01505681f1cc108073b97eb3fdbfdfbe7d63839a6e1f5caf790186","paperId":"2401.13339","textSha256":"507e1037d5293b442fcaea949d1449b9f9ceb2a0bc94e5d3d4c4472cca1d685a"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:38c0abc65d8c9cd74de3bbd2d02d26d4","paperId":"2401.13339","sourceSha256":"76ca71060fdac042af5077e55df925e369569d2f0a13d41c0cd5c405a333cd23","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/42677651528ecf47ff44/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8a900890a8dbea97ef172e93f43b69bee71915cab7ef4c0eac234eb8afbc2cc9","pdfPage":19,"start":0,"end":2379,"textSha256":"9f51174f97345b6974bf1bd52d0b868f2b34df5e6eb9fc9af3dca58e9c3f8cce","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f3fecc46b9d869480ca73df5ebc960cd","paperId":"2401.13339","sourceSha256":"76ca71060fdac042af5077e55df925e369569d2f0a13d41c0cd5c405a333cd23","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/42677651528ecf47ff44/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8a900890a8dbea97ef172e93f43b69bee71915cab7ef4c0eac234eb8afbc2cc9","pdfPage":19,"start":92,"end":2379,"textSha256":"459901b3924960efb49dead003dd8fcbb235ab2d6d5cf283eb2f036b9443e02a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:254d8a53bd44d9003dd5b638"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:254d8a53bd44d9003dd5b638","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cb197b0b9a01505681f1cc108073b97eb3fdbfdfbe7d63839a6e1f5caf790186","q025-candidate-region:d6f875b76d84910cb6887d5f"],"scopeContentSha256":"fa24d84732dc03bafb44b9947cfbb9be672f828e17335b2a1fac2527fdb60dd0","placementContentSha256":"fad1e5c63760bf68e66d5323be112e3b6c823365a2c752f0be284f28ff062c3a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cb197b0b9a01505681f1cc108073b97eb3fdbfdfbe7d63839a6e1f5caf790186","paperId":"2401.13339","textSha256":"507e1037d5293b442fcaea949d1449b9f9ceb2a0bc94e5d3d4c4472cca1d685a"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:38c0abc65d8c9cd74de3bbd2d02d26d4","paperId":"2401.13339","sourceSha256":"76ca71060fdac042af5077e55df925e369569d2f0a13d41c0cd5c405a333cd23","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/42677651528ecf47ff44/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8a900890a8dbea97ef172e93f43b69bee71915cab7ef4c0eac234eb8afbc2cc9","pdfPage":19,"start":0,"end":2379,"textSha256":"9f51174f97345b6974bf1bd52d0b868f2b34df5e6eb9fc9af3dca58e9c3f8cce","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f3fecc46b9d869480ca73df5ebc960cd","paperId":"2401.13339","sourceSha256":"76ca71060fdac042af5077e55df925e369569d2f0a13d41c0cd5c405a333cd23","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/42677651528ecf47ff44/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8a900890a8dbea97ef172e93f43b69bee71915cab7ef4c0eac234eb8afbc2cc9","pdfPage":19,"start":92,"end":2379,"textSha256":"459901b3924960efb49dead003dd8fcbb235ab2d6d5cf283eb2f036b9443e02a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:254d8a53bd44d9003dd5b638"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cb197b0b9a01505681f1cc108073b97eb3fdbfdfbe7d63839a6e1f5caf790186","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f46690ac720bffc643debed2","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:cb197b0b9a01505681f1cc108073b97eb3fdbfdfbe7d63839a6e1f5caf790186","textSha256":"507e1037d5293b442fcaea949d1449b9f9ceb2a0bc94e5d3d4c4472cca1d685a"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:38c0abc65d8c9cd74de3bbd2d02d26d4","paperId":"2401.13339","sourceSha256":"76ca71060fdac042af5077e55df925e369569d2f0a13d41c0cd5c405a333cd23","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/42677651528ecf47ff44/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8a900890a8dbea97ef172e93f43b69bee71915cab7ef4c0eac234eb8afbc2cc9","pdfPage":19,"start":0,"end":2379,"textSha256":"9f51174f97345b6974bf1bd52d0b868f2b34df5e6eb9fc9af3dca58e9c3f8cce","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f3fecc46b9d869480ca73df5ebc960cd","paperId":"2401.13339","sourceSha256":"76ca71060fdac042af5077e55df925e369569d2f0a13d41c0cd5c405a333cd23","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/42677651528ecf47ff44/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8a900890a8dbea97ef172e93f43b69bee71915cab7ef4c0eac234eb8afbc2cc9","pdfPage":19,"start":92,"end":2379,"textSha256":"459901b3924960efb49dead003dd8fcbb235ab2d6d5cf283eb2f036b9443e02a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5ff6f8a320b6d86477d5eb8b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5ff6f8a320b6d86477d5eb8b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cb197b0b9a01505681f1cc108073b97eb3fdbfdfbe7d63839a6e1f5caf790186","q025-candidate-question:f46690ac720bffc643debed2"],"scopeContentSha256":"f75817e88f49e4dea7df9d2824eea9ece40c605a33d656134a437e93e307a3f4","contributionContentSha256":"d25a1624071036d60512aebbc408a36087627ba58612d34729db1569b0a4c641","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:cb197b0b9a01505681f1cc108073b97eb3fdbfdfbe7d63839a6e1f5caf790186","textSha256":"507e1037d5293b442fcaea949d1449b9f9ceb2a0bc94e5d3d4c4472cca1d685a"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:38c0abc65d8c9cd74de3bbd2d02d26d4","paperId":"2401.13339","sourceSha256":"76ca71060fdac042af5077e55df925e369569d2f0a13d41c0cd5c405a333cd23","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/42677651528ecf47ff44/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8a900890a8dbea97ef172e93f43b69bee71915cab7ef4c0eac234eb8afbc2cc9","pdfPage":19,"start":0,"end":2379,"textSha256":"9f51174f97345b6974bf1bd52d0b868f2b34df5e6eb9fc9af3dca58e9c3f8cce","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f3fecc46b9d869480ca73df5ebc960cd","paperId":"2401.13339","sourceSha256":"76ca71060fdac042af5077e55df925e369569d2f0a13d41c0cd5c405a333cd23","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/42677651528ecf47ff44/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8a900890a8dbea97ef172e93f43b69bee71915cab7ef4c0eac234eb8afbc2cc9","pdfPage":19,"start":92,"end":2379,"textSha256":"459901b3924960efb49dead003dd8fcbb235ab2d6d5cf283eb2f036b9443e02a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5ff6f8a320b6d86477d5eb8b","recordId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound thesis scope spans vacuum structure, uplifts, stability, scale separation and several stabilization families; supplied text is a roadmap.","challengeNote":"A compound thesis roadmap spans stabilization, vacuum stability, scale separation and higher-dimensional tests; detailed calculations are absent.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ef705210e19e2989458b7407b52276fc329e5ed5e51d3870370c64298384f546","home":{"unitId":"unit:ef705210e19e2989458b7407b52276fc329e5ed5e51d3870370c64298384f546","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:d6f875b76d84910cb6887d5f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ef705210e19e2989458b7407b52276fc329e5ed5e51d3870370c64298384f546","paperId":"2104.15030","textSha256":"fa5ba32e9c7fdcb54e851db4f5f17e9867c1ee6cb93a9a55ffaa2bd5e83a1150"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:05e70af5e9f276fa2ef81944"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:05e70af5e9f276fa2ef81944","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ef705210e19e2989458b7407b52276fc329e5ed5e51d3870370c64298384f546","q025-candidate-region:d6f875b76d84910cb6887d5f"],"scopeContentSha256":"fa24d84732dc03bafb44b9947cfbb9be672f828e17335b2a1fac2527fdb60dd0","placementContentSha256":"149d6725c53746687e516ac8c12b7d92de5f64e67f4a584c04513298b7051e28","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ef705210e19e2989458b7407b52276fc329e5ed5e51d3870370c64298384f546","paperId":"2104.15030","textSha256":"fa5ba32e9c7fdcb54e851db4f5f17e9867c1ee6cb93a9a55ffaa2bd5e83a1150"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:05e70af5e9f276fa2ef81944"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ef705210e19e2989458b7407b52276fc329e5ed5e51d3870370c64298384f546","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f46690ac720bffc643debed2","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:ef705210e19e2989458b7407b52276fc329e5ed5e51d3870370c64298384f546","textSha256":"fa5ba32e9c7fdcb54e851db4f5f17e9867c1ee6cb93a9a55ffaa2bd5e83a1150"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2b9ba3ebb2eda0ef5fa3ebb9"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2b9ba3ebb2eda0ef5fa3ebb9","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ef705210e19e2989458b7407b52276fc329e5ed5e51d3870370c64298384f546","q025-candidate-question:f46690ac720bffc643debed2"],"scopeContentSha256":"f75817e88f49e4dea7df9d2824eea9ece40c605a33d656134a437e93e307a3f4","contributionContentSha256":"3d222dc654a733d7af0f77c4b4330e4a823ad3445f7e43aeb9da0ee1438f9014","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:ef705210e19e2989458b7407b52276fc329e5ed5e51d3870370c64298384f546","textSha256":"fa5ba32e9c7fdcb54e851db4f5f17e9867c1ee6cb93a9a55ffaa2bd5e83a1150"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2b9ba3ebb2eda0ef5fa3ebb9","recordId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Vacuum energy, stability and several conjecture implications remain separate outputs.","challengeNote":"Vacuum energy, perturbative stability and the different conjecture tests form a compound source facet.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f7532eea8449f928dad85f10cbaa691beedd2bea751df198f8815931ad9744f3","home":{"unitId":"unit:f7532eea8449f928dad85f10cbaa691beedd2bea751df198f8815931ad9744f3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:d6f875b76d84910cb6887d5f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f7532eea8449f928dad85f10cbaa691beedd2bea751df198f8815931ad9744f3","paperId":"2308.15525","textSha256":"7422db08dd75b045417d335ebd3fe3e40a94acc01533b25e21173d80a27b12ee"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:d3ba5b95ad0833bb87dab0e4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:d3ba5b95ad0833bb87dab0e4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f7532eea8449f928dad85f10cbaa691beedd2bea751df198f8815931ad9744f3","q025-candidate-region:d6f875b76d84910cb6887d5f"],"scopeContentSha256":"fa24d84732dc03bafb44b9947cfbb9be672f828e17335b2a1fac2527fdb60dd0","placementContentSha256":"c4138f612d25b707141de0170a54ee042e1d4630d88e70355007f4a36fbb5ff7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f7532eea8449f928dad85f10cbaa691beedd2bea751df198f8815931ad9744f3","paperId":"2308.15525","textSha256":"7422db08dd75b045417d335ebd3fe3e40a94acc01533b25e21173d80a27b12ee"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:d3ba5b95ad0833bb87dab0e4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f7532eea8449f928dad85f10cbaa691beedd2bea751df198f8815931ad9744f3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f46690ac720bffc643debed2","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d40","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:f7532eea8449f928dad85f10cbaa691beedd2bea751df198f8815931ad9744f3","textSha256":"7422db08dd75b045417d335ebd3fe3e40a94acc01533b25e21173d80a27b12ee"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:29a92a34413a8ab57bcadb1a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:29a92a34413a8ab57bcadb1a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f7532eea8449f928dad85f10cbaa691beedd2bea751df198f8815931ad9744f3","q025-candidate-question:f46690ac720bffc643debed2"],"scopeContentSha256":"f75817e88f49e4dea7df9d2824eea9ece40c605a33d656134a437e93e307a3f4","contributionContentSha256":"99166a07c50ddab97d0244e0e0051364d442a0063f33c8ecd8988bd051972425","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d40","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:f7532eea8449f928dad85f10cbaa691beedd2bea751df198f8815931ad9744f3","textSha256":"7422db08dd75b045417d335ebd3fe3e40a94acc01533b25e21173d80a27b12ee"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:29a92a34413a8ab57bcadb1a","recordId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Small positive sector energies are proposed future uplift ingredients, not complete de Sitter vacua.","challengeNote":"Compound sampling, distribution and sector-energy targets; positive energies are ingredients for future uplifting.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":6,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"e3a6224b9edbf32f598d598710937156ef6aa499c76454582e1035f787e75751"},"organizational-access:fa2c9feb9665eac60eb601c9":{"id":"organizational-access:fa2c9feb9665eac60eb601c9","source":"q025-candidate-region:db2b0d8182ae1c0e65ae7688","target":"q025-candidate-question:ec49be4276e71be9401e1ebf","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:db2b0d8182ae1c0e65ae7688","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"4175b492dfce95585d6f7b4bfbcf824de0fdeefb5d1858ed2db1871d9f5e6921","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:305eb365c3ed76c1bf367e97"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ec49be4276e71be9401e1ebf","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f94eb81dc5bbdc92b45e85dba14326a4776fe8a10f9beec23d9d2fca13bd0062","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:72c623b578b912e7731d770b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:691118b41404042e62a36deafa0f76adda5855d13b36f59a1f27b4512316b321","home":{"unitId":"unit:691118b41404042e62a36deafa0f76adda5855d13b36f59a1f27b4512316b321","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:db2b0d8182ae1c0e65ae7688","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:691118b41404042e62a36deafa0f76adda5855d13b36f59a1f27b4512316b321","paperId":"hep-th/0204058","textSha256":"c3d18b2ae78c8e2385630d6544f9079778a3c755c08b501e6e59cb4e8899239d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e01f5bffd2d9e7ad22209597"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e01f5bffd2d9e7ad22209597","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:691118b41404042e62a36deafa0f76adda5855d13b36f59a1f27b4512316b321","q025-candidate-region:db2b0d8182ae1c0e65ae7688"],"scopeContentSha256":"4175b492dfce95585d6f7b4bfbcf824de0fdeefb5d1858ed2db1871d9f5e6921","placementContentSha256":"4910f656b022a94998c51926680f41eba9765bc8b832b3ee4990d7297720add5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge","leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:691118b41404042e62a36deafa0f76adda5855d13b36f59a1f27b4512316b321","paperId":"hep-th/0204058","textSha256":"c3d18b2ae78c8e2385630d6544f9079778a3c755c08b501e6e59cb4e8899239d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e01f5bffd2d9e7ad22209597"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:691118b41404042e62a36deafa0f76adda5855d13b36f59a1f27b4512316b321","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ec49be4276e71be9401e1ebf","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:691118b41404042e62a36deafa0f76adda5855d13b36f59a1f27b4512316b321","textSha256":"c3d18b2ae78c8e2385630d6544f9079778a3c755c08b501e6e59cb4e8899239d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c7a11c8b0a6ff173e89d2660","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound horizon, proposed RG and covariant-entropy-bound questions for positive-Λ perfect fluids. Independent challenge qualification: Compound causal structure, proposed RG interpretation and covariant-entropy-bound targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c7a11c8b0a6ff173e89d2660","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:691118b41404042e62a36deafa0f76adda5855d13b36f59a1f27b4512316b321","q025-candidate-question:ec49be4276e71be9401e1ebf"],"scopeContentSha256":"f94eb81dc5bbdc92b45e85dba14326a4776fe8a10f9beec23d9d2fca13bd0062","contributionContentSha256":"0d0027128db872a9768c52f41720dc9cd933bcd54915287407fb6e092b4985d0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-proposal","leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:691118b41404042e62a36deafa0f76adda5855d13b36f59a1f27b4512316b321","textSha256":"c3d18b2ae78c8e2385630d6544f9079778a3c755c08b501e6e59cb4e8899239d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c7a11c8b0a6ff173e89d2660","recordId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound horizon, proposed RG and covariant-entropy-bound questions for positive-Λ perfect fluids.","challengeNote":"Compound causal structure, proposed RG interpretation and covariant-entropy-bound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b5508feab1659e8484857bdeef78a7f92395f240e4e500cd8c1e5470b97bf437","home":{"unitId":"unit:b5508feab1659e8484857bdeef78a7f92395f240e4e500cd8c1e5470b97bf437","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:db2b0d8182ae1c0e65ae7688","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b5508feab1659e8484857bdeef78a7f92395f240e4e500cd8c1e5470b97bf437","paperId":"hep-th/0303157","textSha256":"287c5539c1f27f1fc7dde04f159d354ba9e836f03ec2fe28333fac9b1fe4956a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:721fc305c1951c5695280757"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:721fc305c1951c5695280757","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b5508feab1659e8484857bdeef78a7f92395f240e4e500cd8c1e5470b97bf437","q025-candidate-region:db2b0d8182ae1c0e65ae7688"],"scopeContentSha256":"4175b492dfce95585d6f7b4bfbcf824de0fdeefb5d1858ed2db1871d9f5e6921","placementContentSha256":"bf39679a5ea48308d52174dc68ef806fff9498c44f9b29ee729ce0c558821d87","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge","leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b5508feab1659e8484857bdeef78a7f92395f240e4e500cd8c1e5470b97bf437","paperId":"hep-th/0303157","textSha256":"287c5539c1f27f1fc7dde04f159d354ba9e836f03ec2fe28333fac9b1fe4956a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:721fc305c1951c5695280757"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b5508feab1659e8484857bdeef78a7f92395f240e4e500cd8c1e5470b97bf437","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ec49be4276e71be9401e1ebf","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:b5508feab1659e8484857bdeef78a7f92395f240e4e500cd8c1e5470b97bf437","textSha256":"287c5539c1f27f1fc7dde04f159d354ba9e836f03ec2fe28333fac9b1fe4956a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c0e166ce5176bd79c5af4c00","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c0e166ce5176bd79c5af4c00","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b5508feab1659e8484857bdeef78a7f92395f240e4e500cd8c1e5470b97bf437","q025-candidate-question:ec49be4276e71be9401e1ebf"],"scopeContentSha256":"f94eb81dc5bbdc92b45e85dba14326a4776fe8a10f9beec23d9d2fca13bd0062","contributionContentSha256":"1baaa0082f2dd4307b3214a87d54306cd7d343b8ea5c2bcfce8dbe1ffe9aef0e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-proposal","leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:b5508feab1659e8484857bdeef78a7f92395f240e4e500cd8c1e5470b97bf437","textSha256":"287c5539c1f27f1fc7dde04f159d354ba9e836f03ec2fe28333fac9b1fe4956a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c0e166ce5176bd79c5af4c00","recordId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f46b1ed2fe897b8169bc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"3b076e129d9d5aa472388e2cded3bd1b50fd93b38bad1cd43d21e4ff5e866c0f"},"organizational-access:f6e24fa4af3ab8d72c009600":{"id":"organizational-access:f6e24fa4af3ab8d72c009600","source":"q025-candidate-region:dc231740ddaf7d57bc7b2c70","target":"q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:dc231740ddaf7d57bc7b2c70","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"770c368bc806a40b89f24cd884fd24f424e2ee3e1adbe4d32c130a7680c55e20","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f85ecfddc53798007ca5298c"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ec72d997efbf3777e636b33eeb54df9badb1160e950b011f7117c74be70e4037","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7955febd87c1c31249f95ec9"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1e8ac24f6b97a40351d25374daed8a5f8650e0fef06abbb205d93de240efa3d2","home":{"unitId":"unit:1e8ac24f6b97a40351d25374daed8a5f8650e0fef06abbb205d93de240efa3d2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:dc231740ddaf7d57bc7b2c70","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e8ac24f6b97a40351d25374daed8a5f8650e0fef06abbb205d93de240efa3d2","paperId":"gr-qc/9607022","textSha256":"c5986fd81f815e79594b343876611ebad05a8a802fa7de2d655eb710eac95a5c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:67bf1ac318ae7781264ec1ab"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:67bf1ac318ae7781264ec1ab","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e8ac24f6b97a40351d25374daed8a5f8650e0fef06abbb205d93de240efa3d2","q025-candidate-region:dc231740ddaf7d57bc7b2c70"],"scopeContentSha256":"770c368bc806a40b89f24cd884fd24f424e2ee3e1adbe4d32c130a7680c55e20","placementContentSha256":"9947280338986653e53d8e8d850a842c11ee92be36bb2755f0c7336fb2733758","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge","leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e8ac24f6b97a40351d25374daed8a5f8650e0fef06abbb205d93de240efa3d2","paperId":"gr-qc/9607022","textSha256":"c5986fd81f815e79594b343876611ebad05a8a802fa7de2d655eb710eac95a5c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:67bf1ac318ae7781264ec1ab"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1e8ac24f6b97a40351d25374daed8a5f8650e0fef06abbb205d93de240efa3d2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d49","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:1e8ac24f6b97a40351d25374daed8a5f8650e0fef06abbb205d93de240efa3d2","textSha256":"c5986fd81f815e79594b343876611ebad05a8a802fa7de2d655eb710eac95a5c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3db4ed8be9039e4f30baf928","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Scattering consistency, finite entropy/discrete spectrum and horizon degrees of freedom remain linked targets. Independent challenge qualification: Scattering consistency, finite entropy/discrete spectrum and horizon degrees of freedom remain linked targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3db4ed8be9039e4f30baf928","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e8ac24f6b97a40351d25374daed8a5f8650e0fef06abbb205d93de240efa3d2","q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec72d997efbf3777e636b33eeb54df9badb1160e950b011f7117c74be70e4037","contributionContentSha256":"f0481dfa7f11a7f9bba320649a79aeddb7b953040843047717869c574a2d0c5b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d49","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:1e8ac24f6b97a40351d25374daed8a5f8650e0fef06abbb205d93de240efa3d2","textSha256":"c5986fd81f815e79594b343876611ebad05a8a802fa7de2d655eb710eac95a5c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3db4ed8be9039e4f30baf928","recordId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Scattering consistency, finite entropy/discrete spectrum and horizon degrees of freedom remain linked targets.","challengeNote":"Scattering consistency, finite entropy/discrete spectrum and horizon degrees of freedom remain linked targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:bfe365f00f5bf8c6e5a68ce4c2d68810b20898088460d0ebd34bd64a19f18d82","home":{"unitId":"unit:bfe365f00f5bf8c6e5a68ce4c2d68810b20898088460d0ebd34bd64a19f18d82","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:dc231740ddaf7d57bc7b2c70","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers specified quantum-gravity models, possible information loss, scattering-related descriptions and evaporation endpoints, including competing historical proposals.","qualification":"q23 covers the quantum-gravity foam interpretation and its proposed scattering, coherence-loss and endpoint consequences. These remain alternative questions rather than jointly established outcomes. q9 supports the information-loss aspect but does not establish full coverage of the foam and endpoint program.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bfe365f00f5bf8c6e5a68ce4c2d68810b20898088460d0ebd34bd64a19f18d82","paperId":"hep-th/9510029","textSha256":"a9247706552924d46182442013f7eb2b38acacd888eb243dffb1ccf07c8b1360"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0021:u27:q23"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0021:u27:q23","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bfe365f00f5bf8c6e5a68ce4c2d68810b20898088460d0ebd34bd64a19f18d82","q025-candidate-region:dc231740ddaf7d57bc7b2c70"],"scopeContentSha256":"770c368bc806a40b89f24cd884fd24f424e2ee3e1adbe4d32c130a7680c55e20","placementContentSha256":"e7e3a2dc2f82ee42bb53243dddb4ce990d250045f16dbcbfa376dca34b14987d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0021:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0021:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bfe365f00f5bf8c6e5a68ce4c2d68810b20898088460d0ebd34bd64a19f18d82","paperId":"hep-th/9510029","textSha256":"a9247706552924d46182442013f7eb2b38acacd888eb243dffb1ccf07c8b1360"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0021","unitRef":"u27"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bfe365f00f5bf8c6e5a68ce4c2d68810b20898088460d0ebd34bd64a19f18d82","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d56","kind":"description","unitIndex":56,"unitId":"unit:bfe365f00f5bf8c6e5a68ce4c2d68810b20898088460d0ebd34bd64a19f18d82","textSha256":"a9247706552924d46182442013f7eb2b38acacd888eb243dffb1ccf07c8b1360"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9d041ce59796b71d6963a7a7","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Foam interpretation, coherence loss and evaporation endpoint are compound alternatives; no current acceptance or rejection is supplied. Independent challenge qualification: Foam interpretation, coherence loss and evaporation endpoint are compound alternatives; current acceptance or rejection is not supplied."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9d041ce59796b71d6963a7a7","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bfe365f00f5bf8c6e5a68ce4c2d68810b20898088460d0ebd34bd64a19f18d82","q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec72d997efbf3777e636b33eeb54df9badb1160e950b011f7117c74be70e4037","contributionContentSha256":"3411874f962ef21b068780df80d42d332ed9a9facd4165c906ef818b621b80f1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d56","kind":"description","unitIndex":56,"unitId":"unit:bfe365f00f5bf8c6e5a68ce4c2d68810b20898088460d0ebd34bd64a19f18d82","textSha256":"a9247706552924d46182442013f7eb2b38acacd888eb243dffb1ccf07c8b1360"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9d041ce59796b71d6963a7a7","recordId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Foam interpretation, coherence loss and evaporation endpoint are compound alternatives; no current acceptance or rejection is supplied.","challengeNote":"Foam interpretation, coherence loss and evaporation endpoint are compound alternatives; current acceptance or rejection is not supplied.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c52197fa10beaa6c1d1080c3e34d75ce6b78c8a60e0b12a140c9d7c588f98ffc","home":{"unitId":"unit:c52197fa10beaa6c1d1080c3e34d75ce6b78c8a60e0b12a140c9d7c588f98ffc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:dc231740ddaf7d57bc7b2c70","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers proposed microscopic information mechanisms, interior entropy, horizon structure and related cosmological geometries under source-specific causality assumptions.","qualification":"q23 covers the proposed vacuum mechanism, information loss, interior entropy and the black-hole/cosmological horizon comparison under the stated causality condition. q9 alone does not establish cosmological-horizon coverage; q7 alone does not cover the full information mechanism. The existing region keeps the question whole without endorsing its proposed resolution.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c52197fa10beaa6c1d1080c3e34d75ce6b78c8a60e0b12a140c9d7c588f98ffc","paperId":"2001.11057","textSha256":"927f10dc0f2001243d4f9e172b74b20ebef9a9cd86e702b3a265ec5f8ff327c5"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0021:u26:q23"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0021:u26:q23","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c52197fa10beaa6c1d1080c3e34d75ce6b78c8a60e0b12a140c9d7c588f98ffc","q025-candidate-region:dc231740ddaf7d57bc7b2c70"],"scopeContentSha256":"770c368bc806a40b89f24cd884fd24f424e2ee3e1adbe4d32c130a7680c55e20","placementContentSha256":"a8157ad93c7c3adaf6bf83195a846b81c2775f517a68ec937399a7b4e29cc8e4","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0021:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0021:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c52197fa10beaa6c1d1080c3e34d75ce6b78c8a60e0b12a140c9d7c588f98ffc","paperId":"2001.11057","textSha256":"927f10dc0f2001243d4f9e172b74b20ebef9a9cd86e702b3a265ec5f8ff327c5"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0021","unitRef":"u26"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c52197fa10beaa6c1d1080c3e34d75ce6b78c8a60e0b12a140c9d7c588f98ffc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:c52197fa10beaa6c1d1080c3e34d75ce6b78c8a60e0b12a140c9d7c588f98ffc","textSha256":"927f10dc0f2001243d4f9e172b74b20ebef9a9cd86e702b3a265ec5f8ff327c5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7084213e5bd5d669596b8d5e","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Information loss, unbounded interior entropy and horizon comparison remain compound targets. Independent challenge qualification: Information loss, unbounded interior entropy and horizon comparison remain compound targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7084213e5bd5d669596b8d5e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c52197fa10beaa6c1d1080c3e34d75ce6b78c8a60e0b12a140c9d7c588f98ffc","q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec72d997efbf3777e636b33eeb54df9badb1160e950b011f7117c74be70e4037","contributionContentSha256":"2cddb0b5f240cfdd71b72cb265db543b52fd38bafd37298ec693138858d38204","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:c52197fa10beaa6c1d1080c3e34d75ce6b78c8a60e0b12a140c9d7c588f98ffc","textSha256":"927f10dc0f2001243d4f9e172b74b20ebef9a9cd86e702b3a265ec5f8ff327c5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7084213e5bd5d669596b8d5e","recordId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Information loss, unbounded interior entropy and horizon comparison remain compound targets.","challengeNote":"Information loss, unbounded interior entropy and horizon comparison remain compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ffc295e02ea2bc590df9ee37dbbe4706bec8ab5d89587f1d6e2f90a8748b3c87","home":{"unitId":"unit:ffc295e02ea2bc590df9ee37dbbe4706bec8ab5d89587f1d6e2f90a8748b3c87","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:dc231740ddaf7d57bc7b2c70","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ffc295e02ea2bc590df9ee37dbbe4706bec8ab5d89587f1d6e2f90a8748b3c87","paperId":"1905.08255","textSha256":"f92db3e5621ac6b2b30394c78722e2007a2bfdc3f0614cccd8b4348cceda8f80"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:281942b3abd325cc6176aa62"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:281942b3abd325cc6176aa62","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ffc295e02ea2bc590df9ee37dbbe4706bec8ab5d89587f1d6e2f90a8748b3c87","q025-candidate-region:dc231740ddaf7d57bc7b2c70"],"scopeContentSha256":"770c368bc806a40b89f24cd884fd24f424e2ee3e1adbe4d32c130a7680c55e20","placementContentSha256":"5e672370ce348f9cff6de8122bf72bd446212ab63fc4cf2f0b678ecc627fc9e5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge","leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ffc295e02ea2bc590df9ee37dbbe4706bec8ab5d89587f1d6e2f90a8748b3c87","paperId":"1905.08255","textSha256":"f92db3e5621ac6b2b30394c78722e2007a2bfdc3f0614cccd8b4348cceda8f80"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:281942b3abd325cc6176aa62"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ffc295e02ea2bc590df9ee37dbbe4706bec8ab5d89587f1d6e2f90a8748b3c87","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:ffc295e02ea2bc590df9ee37dbbe4706bec8ab5d89587f1d6e2f90a8748b3c87","textSha256":"f92db3e5621ac6b2b30394c78722e2007a2bfdc3f0614cccd8b4348cceda8f80"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:093ea7b4cf52149f765c886f","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound entropy, recovery and smooth-horizon targets; initial-state knowledge remains explicit. Independent challenge qualification: Compound entropy, recovery and smooth-horizon targets; initial-state knowledge remains explicit."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:093ea7b4cf52149f765c886f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ffc295e02ea2bc590df9ee37dbbe4706bec8ab5d89587f1d6e2f90a8748b3c87","q025-candidate-question:bb2d5440d8c7e79d762ad6e1"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec72d997efbf3777e636b33eeb54df9badb1160e950b011f7117c74be70e4037","contributionContentSha256":"908ec4709b79444017dd11cbb68d5b681a91c594d8d982e494cb87298c74a2da","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:ffc295e02ea2bc590df9ee37dbbe4706bec8ab5d89587f1d6e2f90a8748b3c87","textSha256":"f92db3e5621ac6b2b30394c78722e2007a2bfdc3f0614cccd8b4348cceda8f80"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:093ea7b4cf52149f765c886f","recordId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0df0ef6811061185a33d-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound entropy, recovery and smooth-horizon targets; initial-state knowledge remains explicit.","challengeNote":"Compound entropy, recovery and smooth-horizon targets; initial-state knowledge remains explicit.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":4,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"837f7292b844e7f6f83a937b14fe9118575346fc1c97aec76d3fc802abc900ba"},"organizational-access:f30aaed97269d18b312b52c3":{"id":"organizational-access:f30aaed97269d18b312b52c3","source":"q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93","target":"q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"202fe5654826379a65ea20665347721a8c129c0bbd322083db60a9b699796330","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1b2e85141cc0796a33548265"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"64fa356684397cf004c5af3db72c52c17ddd67e08c1d75642d73ed599a5e5b12","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:210a12495c3684b73af016cb"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1205fd86ce3193f1937d91e3d557e575a09a3a7ab659bc07c079b0adaabbaaaa","home":{"unitId":"unit:1205fd86ce3193f1937d91e3d557e575a09a3a7ab659bc07c079b0adaabbaaaa","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1205fd86ce3193f1937d91e3d557e575a09a3a7ab659bc07c079b0adaabbaaaa","paperId":"2110.10157","textSha256":"5086d9027bb95245ac9d16920149996811fc3e99eb246537850639f4dbfee8cd"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:65d534675fb7465f39ba16b2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:65d534675fb7465f39ba16b2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1205fd86ce3193f1937d91e3d557e575a09a3a7ab659bc07c079b0adaabbaaaa","q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93"],"scopeContentSha256":"202fe5654826379a65ea20665347721a8c129c0bbd322083db60a9b699796330","placementContentSha256":"40708a78f214d62b15ed6f88fb3d990e4575df1c010b63d8ba1775d1313c4a9a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1205fd86ce3193f1937d91e3d557e575a09a3a7ab659bc07c079b0adaabbaaaa","paperId":"2110.10157","textSha256":"5086d9027bb95245ac9d16920149996811fc3e99eb246537850639f4dbfee8cd"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:65d534675fb7465f39ba16b2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1205fd86ce3193f1937d91e3d557e575a09a3a7ab659bc07c079b0adaabbaaaa","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:1205fd86ce3193f1937d91e3d557e575a09a3a7ab659bc07c079b0adaabbaaaa","textSha256":"5086d9027bb95245ac9d16920149996811fc3e99eb246537850639f4dbfee8cd"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:230bc65b5b2b4cd3e944fdd6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:230bc65b5b2b4cd3e944fdd6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1205fd86ce3193f1937d91e3d557e575a09a3a7ab659bc07c079b0adaabbaaaa","q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6"],"scopeContentSha256":"64fa356684397cf004c5af3db72c52c17ddd67e08c1d75642d73ed599a5e5b12","contributionContentSha256":"06c38ae91755823701cb502eb92a66d194d6f980833dcd6189f2015c3e844cd2","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:1205fd86ce3193f1937d91e3d557e575a09a3a7ab659bc07c079b0adaabbaaaa","textSha256":"5086d9027bb95245ac9d16920149996811fc3e99eb246537850639f4dbfee8cd"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:230bc65b5b2b4cd3e944fdd6","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Dimensions seven through nine are the main scope; extension toward six dimensions remains distinct.","challengeNote":"Main scope: dimensions seven through nine. Extension toward six dimensions is separately qualified.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:418b64c1cc4be08fef56503fb0ee998e5baa31e365db75aaa431901eec7263e3","home":{"unitId":"unit:418b64c1cc4be08fef56503fb0ee998e5baa31e365db75aaa431901eec7263e3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:418b64c1cc4be08fef56503fb0ee998e5baa31e365db75aaa431901eec7263e3","paperId":"2210.10797","textSha256":"dfaa092bc5a26e1feb58f548c7ea3487a14c9907ba77b0dd3b72c842cb2b11a2"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:48a5a81800b1165334582916"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:48a5a81800b1165334582916","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:418b64c1cc4be08fef56503fb0ee998e5baa31e365db75aaa431901eec7263e3","q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93"],"scopeContentSha256":"202fe5654826379a65ea20665347721a8c129c0bbd322083db60a9b699796330","placementContentSha256":"b3eabb4a0da00a6e50089a2c81c2dca3b748e051ecfded564f20080d782cbdf2","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:418b64c1cc4be08fef56503fb0ee998e5baa31e365db75aaa431901eec7263e3","paperId":"2210.10797","textSha256":"dfaa092bc5a26e1feb58f548c7ea3487a14c9907ba77b0dd3b72c842cb2b11a2"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:48a5a81800b1165334582916"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:418b64c1cc4be08fef56503fb0ee998e5baa31e365db75aaa431901eec7263e3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:418b64c1cc4be08fef56503fb0ee998e5baa31e365db75aaa431901eec7263e3","textSha256":"dfaa092bc5a26e1feb58f548c7ea3487a14c9907ba77b0dd3b72c842cb2b11a2"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6a0e1610028f60b090e80b49"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6a0e1610028f60b090e80b49","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:418b64c1cc4be08fef56503fb0ee998e5baa31e365db75aaa431901eec7263e3","q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6"],"scopeContentSha256":"64fa356684397cf004c5af3db72c52c17ddd67e08c1d75642d73ed599a5e5b12","contributionContentSha256":"43bec788cb8c057010b08a02a08d1d02842a77752c7644d17e7b13336157ac10","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:418b64c1cc4be08fef56503fb0ee998e5baa31e365db75aaa431901eec7263e3","textSha256":"dfaa092bc5a26e1feb58f548c7ea3487a14c9907ba77b0dd3b72c842cb2b11a2"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6a0e1610028f60b090e80b49","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The parent's method type does not identify an additional method or premise for this facet.","challengeNote":"The parent object's method type supplies no additional physical premise.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:47ad085d52785da87279f006ada4645906960d46c308c590478b557800895c4c","home":{"unitId":"unit:47ad085d52785da87279f006ada4645906960d46c308c590478b557800895c4c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:47ad085d52785da87279f006ada4645906960d46c308c590478b557800895c4c","paperId":"2209.03361","textSha256":"eec0751e04259109e4f5bdf389a72e8447c589484c2444b23417225ffa565816"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7d6c484e4f6ddd0703c10dc2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7d6c484e4f6ddd0703c10dc2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:47ad085d52785da87279f006ada4645906960d46c308c590478b557800895c4c","q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93"],"scopeContentSha256":"202fe5654826379a65ea20665347721a8c129c0bbd322083db60a9b699796330","placementContentSha256":"74e56733aed56cedc3ad459580d714b57996346cb97c0ecd98bd3ab1fb6f46cb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:47ad085d52785da87279f006ada4645906960d46c308c590478b557800895c4c","paperId":"2209.03361","textSha256":"eec0751e04259109e4f5bdf389a72e8447c589484c2444b23417225ffa565816"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7d6c484e4f6ddd0703c10dc2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:47ad085d52785da87279f006ada4645906960d46c308c590478b557800895c4c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d40","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:47ad085d52785da87279f006ada4645906960d46c308c590478b557800895c4c","textSha256":"eec0751e04259109e4f5bdf389a72e8447c589484c2444b23417225ffa565816"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ac899857b14a3235cd7ff9af"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ac899857b14a3235cd7ff9af","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:47ad085d52785da87279f006ada4645906960d46c308c590478b557800895c4c","q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6"],"scopeContentSha256":"64fa356684397cf004c5af3db72c52c17ddd67e08c1d75642d73ed599a5e5b12","contributionContentSha256":"a33375c24e25d5b91e2bc1825745696ad6797af685dc1e4c4eb4be6603ecd175","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d40","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:47ad085d52785da87279f006ada4645906960d46c308c590478b557800895c4c","textSha256":"eec0751e04259109e4f5bdf389a72e8447c589484c2444b23417225ffa565816"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ac899857b14a3235cd7ff9af","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:77e29b2062e63dd179bae08d4f52070cdd8a95bd68a1075474ad9d13dba26166","home":{"unitId":"unit:77e29b2062e63dd179bae08d4f52070cdd8a95bd68a1075474ad9d13dba26166","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:77e29b2062e63dd179bae08d4f52070cdd8a95bd68a1075474ad9d13dba26166","paperId":"hep-th/0509212","textSha256":"0dc3e736e5ce0c672ea013fc2555a196c0bff9d02fd60854efa671dbcd46bef5"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2731a13641fefc158ddd8a2c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2731a13641fefc158ddd8a2c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:77e29b2062e63dd179bae08d4f52070cdd8a95bd68a1075474ad9d13dba26166","q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93"],"scopeContentSha256":"202fe5654826379a65ea20665347721a8c129c0bbd322083db60a9b699796330","placementContentSha256":"be577f94afbf2dba72709f15fd7ddf500aabc93990bff5466a973b2338920eec","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:77e29b2062e63dd179bae08d4f52070cdd8a95bd68a1075474ad9d13dba26166","paperId":"hep-th/0509212","textSha256":"0dc3e736e5ce0c672ea013fc2555a196c0bff9d02fd60854efa671dbcd46bef5"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2731a13641fefc158ddd8a2c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:77e29b2062e63dd179bae08d4f52070cdd8a95bd68a1075474ad9d13dba26166","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:77e29b2062e63dd179bae08d4f52070cdd8a95bd68a1075474ad9d13dba26166","textSha256":"0dc3e736e5ce0c672ea013fc2555a196c0bff9d02fd60854efa671dbcd46bef5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e745a07693d1d6aa109c7b9c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e745a07693d1d6aa109c7b9c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:77e29b2062e63dd179bae08d4f52070cdd8a95bd68a1075474ad9d13dba26166","q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6"],"scopeContentSha256":"64fa356684397cf004c5af3db72c52c17ddd67e08c1d75642d73ed599a5e5b12","contributionContentSha256":"eda798a3d8e715ff0ca0adc835df965528de97a210e0a1bb2d2f8eef4a885a46","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:77e29b2062e63dd179bae08d4f52070cdd8a95bd68a1075474ad9d13dba26166","textSha256":"0dc3e736e5ce0c672ea013fc2555a196c0bff9d02fd60854efa671dbcd46bef5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e745a07693d1d6aa109c7b9c","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b41fa3a9a27292a24a7b0e542c779b0f5fcf0d6dc86ef3b23485cdb494bcca1e","home":{"unitId":"unit:b41fa3a9a27292a24a7b0e542c779b0f5fcf0d6dc86ef3b23485cdb494bcca1e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b41fa3a9a27292a24a7b0e542c779b0f5fcf0d6dc86ef3b23485cdb494bcca1e","paperId":"2511.09613","textSha256":"58b1676c128f8b801fb3537a73fb5ef5acaeb5a27eec9f880f29c0686d462840"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:04a51250c1f80a9ed165521c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:04a51250c1f80a9ed165521c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b41fa3a9a27292a24a7b0e542c779b0f5fcf0d6dc86ef3b23485cdb494bcca1e","q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93"],"scopeContentSha256":"202fe5654826379a65ea20665347721a8c129c0bbd322083db60a9b699796330","placementContentSha256":"3c181fdfb455d8dd17b1e89f2e187811ce8c0f81c659cbab7c80aaceb7e1569f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b41fa3a9a27292a24a7b0e542c779b0f5fcf0d6dc86ef3b23485cdb494bcca1e","paperId":"2511.09613","textSha256":"58b1676c128f8b801fb3537a73fb5ef5acaeb5a27eec9f880f29c0686d462840"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:04a51250c1f80a9ed165521c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b41fa3a9a27292a24a7b0e542c779b0f5fcf0d6dc86ef3b23485cdb494bcca1e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d51","kind":"description","unitIndex":51,"unitId":"unit:b41fa3a9a27292a24a7b0e542c779b0f5fcf0d6dc86ef3b23485cdb494bcca1e","textSha256":"58b1676c128f8b801fb3537a73fb5ef5acaeb5a27eec9f880f29c0686d462840"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2bfdf94b663ad105d011f664"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2bfdf94b663ad105d011f664","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b41fa3a9a27292a24a7b0e542c779b0f5fcf0d6dc86ef3b23485cdb494bcca1e","q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6"],"scopeContentSha256":"64fa356684397cf004c5af3db72c52c17ddd67e08c1d75642d73ed599a5e5b12","contributionContentSha256":"96ea5c5cfe86c336eddc1abec5921c242f096a1ac54c05990735cfabddbf4784","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d51","kind":"description","unitIndex":51,"unitId":"unit:b41fa3a9a27292a24a7b0e542c779b0f5fcf0d6dc86ef3b23485cdb494bcca1e","textSha256":"58b1676c128f8b801fb3537a73fb5ef5acaeb5a27eec9f880f29c0686d462840"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2bfdf94b663ad105d011f664","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","home":{"unitId":"unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","paperId":"2003.10452","textSha256":"cbec3a8955cfcaa3b78b56bd6f0f75ed56656d62d0efe0afebd590d1e04472b3"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:caa7bec258d86f7e62e02a71"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:caa7bec258d86f7e62e02a71","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93"],"scopeContentSha256":"202fe5654826379a65ea20665347721a8c129c0bbd322083db60a9b699796330","placementContentSha256":"75a9f35b2a1abfa99a2e057823aba89381e074b6ba20b5b6a18a6418ad80f309","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","paperId":"2003.10452","textSha256":"cbec3a8955cfcaa3b78b56bd6f0f75ed56656d62d0efe0afebd590d1e04472b3"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:caa7bec258d86f7e62e02a71"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","textSha256":"cbec3a8955cfcaa3b78b56bd6f0f75ed56656d62d0efe0afebd590d1e04472b3"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b0b4a25ccbded87b8dc97db2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b0b4a25ccbded87b8dc97db2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6"],"scopeContentSha256":"64fa356684397cf004c5af3db72c52c17ddd67e08c1d75642d73ed599a5e5b12","contributionContentSha256":"e97d3df1ae7ae9330837166ef46498ee49ded534cb2d7159d7233a281242f659","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","textSha256":"cbec3a8955cfcaa3b78b56bd6f0f75ed56656d62d0efe0afebd590d1e04472b3"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b0b4a25ccbded87b8dc97db2","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound alternatives: vanishing N=1 superpotential versus absent N=2 prepotential instanton corrections.","challengeNote":"Compound alternatives: vanishing N=1 superpotential and absent N=2 prepotential instanton corrections.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b79eaa8baa500246ae6cde07b7c458aa7af8cbf9445e822b51567311eb28709f","home":{"unitId":"unit:b79eaa8baa500246ae6cde07b7c458aa7af8cbf9445e822b51567311eb28709f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b79eaa8baa500246ae6cde07b7c458aa7af8cbf9445e822b51567311eb28709f","paperId":"2501.01900","textSha256":"46568394da3bf1b5cfeb8aca8fb71c737fb14da18f29710f9931378dc3ebe611"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ae8d20761889a0efcb2ddbd1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ae8d20761889a0efcb2ddbd1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b79eaa8baa500246ae6cde07b7c458aa7af8cbf9445e822b51567311eb28709f","q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93"],"scopeContentSha256":"202fe5654826379a65ea20665347721a8c129c0bbd322083db60a9b699796330","placementContentSha256":"a1df4fabd51d6260427b818dbec88cb0230ae55b41d5fb4c4bb559393f98d9ab","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b79eaa8baa500246ae6cde07b7c458aa7af8cbf9445e822b51567311eb28709f","paperId":"2501.01900","textSha256":"46568394da3bf1b5cfeb8aca8fb71c737fb14da18f29710f9931378dc3ebe611"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ae8d20761889a0efcb2ddbd1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b79eaa8baa500246ae6cde07b7c458aa7af8cbf9445e822b51567311eb28709f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:b79eaa8baa500246ae6cde07b7c458aa7af8cbf9445e822b51567311eb28709f","textSha256":"46568394da3bf1b5cfeb8aca8fb71c737fb14da18f29710f9931378dc3ebe611"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d9f0e08a784844a7c1194752"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d9f0e08a784844a7c1194752","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b79eaa8baa500246ae6cde07b7c458aa7af8cbf9445e822b51567311eb28709f","q025-candidate-question:0a6795d7d471717cd8a4fdf6"],"scopeContentSha256":"64fa356684397cf004c5af3db72c52c17ddd67e08c1d75642d73ed599a5e5b12","contributionContentSha256":"73403f977f5828005d0ef33b34b26066e76b01cf3a40b96d49370df872179cbd","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d47","kind":"description","unitIndex":47,"unitId":"unit:b79eaa8baa500246ae6cde07b7c458aa7af8cbf9445e822b51567311eb28709f","textSha256":"46568394da3bf1b5cfeb8aca8fb71c737fb14da18f29710f9931378dc3ebe611"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d9f0e08a784844a7c1194752","recordId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Negative quaternion-Kähler curvature is tested for sufficiency, not assumed sufficient for a string realization.","challengeNote":"Negative-curvature quaternion-Kähler geometry is tested for sufficiency, not presumed sufficient.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":7,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"0311077a301e6e71d05ac8a397b87cea71ed36a73b8d428a9633482e9f154ddd"},"organizational-access:e18b068808a0eb569ad21c74":{"id":"organizational-access:e18b068808a0eb569ad21c74","source":"q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93","target":"q025-candidate-question:f157d5380d76ec4750dc6350","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"202fe5654826379a65ea20665347721a8c129c0bbd322083db60a9b699796330","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1b2e85141cc0796a33548265"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f157d5380d76ec4750dc6350","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7357998ad5c44f97d9a8727785dc3f15571d0ac6be8d4d971320fcda552770a7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f83958bcf4c1fad3d7b4bfcb"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","home":{"unitId":"unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","paperId":"2003.10452","textSha256":"cbec3a8955cfcaa3b78b56bd6f0f75ed56656d62d0efe0afebd590d1e04472b3"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:caa7bec258d86f7e62e02a71"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:caa7bec258d86f7e62e02a71","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","q025-candidate-region:e17abc449246f4e7128f3d93"],"scopeContentSha256":"202fe5654826379a65ea20665347721a8c129c0bbd322083db60a9b699796330","placementContentSha256":"75a9f35b2a1abfa99a2e057823aba89381e074b6ba20b5b6a18a6418ad80f309","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-challenge","leaf-248bde69de2c0409078e-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","paperId":"2003.10452","textSha256":"cbec3a8955cfcaa3b78b56bd6f0f75ed56656d62d0efe0afebd590d1e04472b3"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:caa7bec258d86f7e62e02a71"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f157d5380d76ec4750dc6350","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","textSha256":"cbec3a8955cfcaa3b78b56bd6f0f75ed56656d62d0efe0afebd590d1e04472b3"},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bb82a590a426415974b155524e7c1cbd","paperId":"2003.10452","sourceSha256":"1498bb5f2f48acf39375c2307c2a361e51b36c7bccad9a5b4076d2ff3cba8563","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4341c642b572133433df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7cd93130d270faf98754ce7487613598cf20cfdb5eb9ddc4290b465a9f95f608","pdfPage":3,"start":1536,"end":3420,"textSha256":"e84e1db3540b39f270cdc009a0b19b64b52f065d501597a82e4537d8abc2eda9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:77c0d3676c64bf2ad1105d60dd179f84","paperId":"2003.10452","sourceSha256":"1498bb5f2f48acf39375c2307c2a361e51b36c7bccad9a5b4076d2ff3cba8563","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4341c642b572133433df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7cd93130d270faf98754ce7487613598cf20cfdb5eb9ddc4290b465a9f95f608","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2741,"textSha256":"77661a9f1c6ffd65ae4984d726697c869770f32f20380a9bf3e95086acdf5cc2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dd37d2cf129339c6ffbcd98244df83c0","paperId":"2003.10452","sourceSha256":"1498bb5f2f48acf39375c2307c2a361e51b36c7bccad9a5b4076d2ff3cba8563","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4341c642b572133433df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7cd93130d270faf98754ce7487613598cf20cfdb5eb9ddc4290b465a9f95f608","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0eed0c99ea496a5e7effa55f701a8bd97e2bd6ee26caf87b06efcef3eb21d144","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:40dac575b87874db1b194153"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:40dac575b87874db1b194153","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","q025-candidate-question:f157d5380d76ec4750dc6350"],"scopeContentSha256":"7357998ad5c44f97d9a8727785dc3f15571d0ac6be8d4d971320fcda552770a7","contributionContentSha256":"a59c9da0b43af2aaae143755b6f00af0051ca771e9f4c25b3e19454a7455b208","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-48ae6db969bee38e8050-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48ae6db969bee38e8050-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48ae6db969bee38e8050-proposal","leaf-48ae6db969bee38e8050-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:b56f122b9211825e6fb18e535e9b67984f1fcdbe5aa2f9590924ec2acfdbb396","textSha256":"cbec3a8955cfcaa3b78b56bd6f0f75ed56656d62d0efe0afebd590d1e04472b3"},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bb82a590a426415974b155524e7c1cbd","paperId":"2003.10452","sourceSha256":"1498bb5f2f48acf39375c2307c2a361e51b36c7bccad9a5b4076d2ff3cba8563","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4341c642b572133433df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7cd93130d270faf98754ce7487613598cf20cfdb5eb9ddc4290b465a9f95f608","pdfPage":3,"start":1536,"end":3420,"textSha256":"e84e1db3540b39f270cdc009a0b19b64b52f065d501597a82e4537d8abc2eda9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:77c0d3676c64bf2ad1105d60dd179f84","paperId":"2003.10452","sourceSha256":"1498bb5f2f48acf39375c2307c2a361e51b36c7bccad9a5b4076d2ff3cba8563","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4341c642b572133433df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7cd93130d270faf98754ce7487613598cf20cfdb5eb9ddc4290b465a9f95f608","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2741,"textSha256":"77661a9f1c6ffd65ae4984d726697c869770f32f20380a9bf3e95086acdf5cc2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dd37d2cf129339c6ffbcd98244df83c0","paperId":"2003.10452","sourceSha256":"1498bb5f2f48acf39375c2307c2a361e51b36c7bccad9a5b4076d2ff3cba8563","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4341c642b572133433df/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7cd93130d270faf98754ce7487613598cf20cfdb5eb9ddc4290b465a9f95f608","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0eed0c99ea496a5e7effa55f701a8bd97e2bd6ee26caf87b06efcef3eb21d144","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:40dac575b87874db1b194153","recordId":"leaf-48ae6db969bee38e8050-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-48ae6db969bee38e8050-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48ae6db969bee38e8050-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"N=1 W and N=2 instanton-prepotential vanishings are compound alternatives. The conjecture and historical examples are context, not accepted constraints.","challengeNote":"N=1 superpotential and N=2 prepotential vanishings are compound alternatives; conjectural protection and revisited examples remain qualified context.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"10f649f826bc58b45779264d8fda93b5f92ea0d73f5be9b144c8050ede433f0c"},"organizational-access:15929bda78b3de1eeeea1421":{"id":"organizational-access:15929bda78b3de1eeeea1421","source":"q025-candidate-region:f2fc15151767e8d57cba3e6a","target":"q025-candidate-question:18dc4f4eb6b419ff578229eb","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:f2fc15151767e8d57cba3e6a","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"46c9ac144d6d8a4826942bf7411c4d9dc63f508c9b15d3bd0de891f729bb4be7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1f4a64412945907171f4ebd8"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:18dc4f4eb6b419ff578229eb","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9ca20718cf1f1d3af91343e9b539d67581cf470622898403a6eacf2fcea84d64","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c7bdd887cbf24f16c95cb6c7"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:b8aa51ab780cbeb99abc5f746d9535da6fa5e61f4f3c50998e356f99c3d77221","home":{"unitId":"unit:b8aa51ab780cbeb99abc5f746d9535da6fa5e61f4f3c50998e356f99c3d77221","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f2fc15151767e8d57cba3e6a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b8aa51ab780cbeb99abc5f746d9535da6fa5e61f4f3c50998e356f99c3d77221","paperId":"2505.01422","textSha256":"2f18f8a1390ec3f7b8f68326e6ce6554cd7a5dc77b34f0de8d4218016265b277"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:093ae8644c40e8bc463fd00a9db21e51","paperId":"2505.01422","sourceSha256":"1eedbd71eda8c905fbcd9172c9b6120c769752c62fedd29b6e22309b6d108580","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5749e9bc7fd645210f27/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"29da6dd9a0d881c32ca5e7e3df9a1e9c1a63faf051516378b774327b899a1031","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"486d86757f7bae3d3a422b517bda09a3618113d818610965f445570f155fc0da","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:53462e912f17169f335fa8c2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:53462e912f17169f335fa8c2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b8aa51ab780cbeb99abc5f746d9535da6fa5e61f4f3c50998e356f99c3d77221","q025-candidate-region:f2fc15151767e8d57cba3e6a"],"scopeContentSha256":"46c9ac144d6d8a4826942bf7411c4d9dc63f508c9b15d3bd0de891f729bb4be7","placementContentSha256":"ae7e330eda3ffcd8adbe20148dcf47347c35d35d8573bd35399635b6c870c467","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge","leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b8aa51ab780cbeb99abc5f746d9535da6fa5e61f4f3c50998e356f99c3d77221","paperId":"2505.01422","textSha256":"2f18f8a1390ec3f7b8f68326e6ce6554cd7a5dc77b34f0de8d4218016265b277"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:093ae8644c40e8bc463fd00a9db21e51","paperId":"2505.01422","sourceSha256":"1eedbd71eda8c905fbcd9172c9b6120c769752c62fedd29b6e22309b6d108580","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5749e9bc7fd645210f27/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"29da6dd9a0d881c32ca5e7e3df9a1e9c1a63faf051516378b774327b899a1031","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"486d86757f7bae3d3a422b517bda09a3618113d818610965f445570f155fc0da","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:53462e912f17169f335fa8c2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b8aa51ab780cbeb99abc5f746d9535da6fa5e61f4f3c50998e356f99c3d77221","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:18dc4f4eb6b419ff578229eb","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d43","kind":"description","unitIndex":43,"unitId":"unit:b8aa51ab780cbeb99abc5f746d9535da6fa5e61f4f3c50998e356f99c3d77221","textSha256":"2f18f8a1390ec3f7b8f68326e6ce6554cd7a5dc77b34f0de8d4218016265b277"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:093ae8644c40e8bc463fd00a9db21e51","paperId":"2505.01422","sourceSha256":"1eedbd71eda8c905fbcd9172c9b6120c769752c62fedd29b6e22309b6d108580","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5749e9bc7fd645210f27/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"29da6dd9a0d881c32ca5e7e3df9a1e9c1a63faf051516378b774327b899a1031","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"486d86757f7bae3d3a422b517bda09a3618113d818610965f445570f155fc0da","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:10088aed25360c97fa962994","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Three targets: additional matter, type-I seesaw bounds and pseudo-Dirac compatibility. The excerpt announces questions and method, not their answers. Independent challenge qualification: Additional matter, type-I seesaw bounds and pseudo-Dirac compatibility are distinct targets. The excerpt supplies questions and methodology, not their answers."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:10088aed25360c97fa962994","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b8aa51ab780cbeb99abc5f746d9535da6fa5e61f4f3c50998e356f99c3d77221","q025-candidate-question:18dc4f4eb6b419ff578229eb"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ca20718cf1f1d3af91343e9b539d67581cf470622898403a6eacf2fcea84d64","contributionContentSha256":"665750024b56341d28e588312b8cabf5f973750b26a0af0fd1d3197557ba97a2","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-proposal","leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d43","kind":"description","unitIndex":43,"unitId":"unit:b8aa51ab780cbeb99abc5f746d9535da6fa5e61f4f3c50998e356f99c3d77221","textSha256":"2f18f8a1390ec3f7b8f68326e6ce6554cd7a5dc77b34f0de8d4218016265b277"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:093ae8644c40e8bc463fd00a9db21e51","paperId":"2505.01422","sourceSha256":"1eedbd71eda8c905fbcd9172c9b6120c769752c62fedd29b6e22309b6d108580","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/5749e9bc7fd645210f27/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"29da6dd9a0d881c32ca5e7e3df9a1e9c1a63faf051516378b774327b899a1031","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"486d86757f7bae3d3a422b517bda09a3618113d818610965f445570f155fc0da","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:10088aed25360c97fa962994","recordId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Three targets: additional matter, type-I seesaw bounds and pseudo-Dirac compatibility. The excerpt announces questions and method, not their answers.","challengeNote":"Additional matter, type-I seesaw bounds and pseudo-Dirac compatibility are distinct targets. The excerpt supplies questions and methodology, not their answers.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","home":{"unitId":"unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f2fc15151767e8d57cba3e6a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","paperId":"2005.12304","textSha256":"e7f81dec05e5e893713eb0bcefa1a91b22885723b3d7175a3843c0d68d926d2a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3fb87ad6138f2325483f4723"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3fb87ad6138f2325483f4723","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","q025-candidate-region:f2fc15151767e8d57cba3e6a"],"scopeContentSha256":"46c9ac144d6d8a4826942bf7411c4d9dc63f508c9b15d3bd0de891f729bb4be7","placementContentSha256":"1bb43959f72839f9c6ef9b0a67f580fa08deed821ceb015337caacb675cea456","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge","leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","paperId":"2005.12304","textSha256":"e7f81dec05e5e893713eb0bcefa1a91b22885723b3d7175a3843c0d68d926d2a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3fb87ad6138f2325483f4723"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:18dc4f4eb6b419ff578229eb","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","textSha256":"e7f81dec05e5e893713eb0bcefa1a91b22885723b3d7175a3843c0d68d926d2a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f5321acdeca5f117ac229fbd","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Gauge consistency, scattering, conjectural and magnetar constraints remain distinct tests of charge. Independent challenge qualification: Gauge consistency, scattering, conjectural and magnetar bounds are distinct tests of charge."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f5321acdeca5f117ac229fbd","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","q025-candidate-question:18dc4f4eb6b419ff578229eb"],"scopeContentSha256":"9ca20718cf1f1d3af91343e9b539d67581cf470622898403a6eacf2fcea84d64","contributionContentSha256":"422b8f5c64301744411956c1fec0dcf199680a400a6545a87827ab7d29efbf1d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-proposal","leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","textSha256":"e7f81dec05e5e893713eb0bcefa1a91b22885723b3d7175a3843c0d68d926d2a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f5321acdeca5f117ac229fbd","recordId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Gauge consistency, scattering, conjectural and magnetar constraints remain distinct tests of charge.","challengeNote":"Gauge consistency, scattering, conjectural and magnetar bounds are distinct tests of charge.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"013e45a4a88ec6724f8988fee5f75efa574082d4a7bb6bdd9b693fc06773464f"},"organizational-access:30d20b962fa3b9208fe8add6":{"id":"organizational-access:30d20b962fa3b9208fe8add6","source":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","target":"q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"24d924b5a5bc7ad2a4781a4ea77c66d1d13b0049360b252c512645dbbd8609aa","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:bc050ef03b26e140d58a392e"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7d9d96e78da885b873119f7761b68d7d9d83239838c2086498214ba3aa8734a2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7bf564e28fb040852d80558f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:9722f05525b43a2e281cf0d8c0dfd28b0afc58f8d63d39dfd0c8d0978471e812","home":{"unitId":"unit:9722f05525b43a2e281cf0d8c0dfd28b0afc58f8d63d39dfd0c8d0978471e812","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines periodic ranges, potential requirements, inflation and distinct dark-energy or scanning applications.","qualification":"q16 explicitly combines fundamental periodic ranges, potential control, inflationary applications and distinct vacuum-energy or scanning uses. It preserves both alternative requirements without identifying a large period with adequate potential flatness or adding an initial-condition, evolution or successful cosmological-constant-selection claim.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9722f05525b43a2e281cf0d8c0dfd28b0afc58f8d63d39dfd0c8d0978471e812","paperId":"hep-th/0303252","textSha256":"67793c97ed1eaad15a66e9aa20e52efa4805bd6ef1471a9f656e2f8c8e830969"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0036:u29:q16"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0036:u29:q16","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9722f05525b43a2e281cf0d8c0dfd28b0afc58f8d63d39dfd0c8d0978471e812","q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f"],"scopeContentSha256":"24d924b5a5bc7ad2a4781a4ea77c66d1d13b0049360b252c512645dbbd8609aa","placementContentSha256":"b1d79ab4b6574953f8c0df44e52c08608c04147f44b09b7bc8316699e317dbfb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0036:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0036:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9722f05525b43a2e281cf0d8c0dfd28b0afc58f8d63d39dfd0c8d0978471e812","paperId":"hep-th/0303252","textSha256":"67793c97ed1eaad15a66e9aa20e52efa4805bd6ef1471a9f656e2f8c8e830969"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0036","unitRef":"u29"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9722f05525b43a2e281cf0d8c0dfd28b0afc58f8d63d39dfd0c8d0978471e812","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d79","kind":"description","unitIndex":79,"unitId":"unit:9722f05525b43a2e281cf0d8c0dfd28b0afc58f8d63d39dfd0c8d0978471e812","textSha256":"67793c97ed1eaad15a66e9aa20e52efa4805bd6ef1471a9f656e2f8c8e830969"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:32d1e0b2bcdd16ad485ac618","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Natural-inflation flatness and the larger ranges invoked for anthropic cosmological-constant scenarios require separate fine reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Remove p6: anthropic field-range requirements do not establish an initial-condition or evolution target. Inflation and cosmological-constant scopes remain split"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:32d1e0b2bcdd16ad485ac618","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9722f05525b43a2e281cf0d8c0dfd28b0afc58f8d63d39dfd0c8d0978471e812","q025-candidate-question:b33f462599f224b494ca0ffd"],"scopeContentSha256":"7d9d96e78da885b873119f7761b68d7d9d83239838c2086498214ba3aa8734a2","contributionContentSha256":"044043bd805ebc5c8dceff0a9fcac3c5e86bd885b9406ee99e20f77d33ba52d1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d79","kind":"description","unitIndex":79,"unitId":"unit:9722f05525b43a2e281cf0d8c0dfd28b0afc58f8d63d39dfd0c8d0978471e812","textSha256":"67793c97ed1eaad15a66e9aa20e52efa4805bd6ef1471a9f656e2f8c8e830969"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:32d1e0b2bcdd16ad485ac618","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Natural-inflation flatness and the larger ranges invoked for anthropic cosmological-constant scenarios require separate fine reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Remove p6: anthropic field-range requirements do not establish an initial-condition or evolution target. Inflation and cosmological-constant scopes remain split","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"61a5333f4b1fc97dbeb3976f9d9b9876b6d783ec45fb31099861a67a9d331dad"},"organizational-access:0af62ff4af73b772abe990a5":{"id":"organizational-access:0af62ff4af73b772abe990a5","source":"q025-placement-question:07f75c122772af108382b804","target":"q025-candidate-question:9ad1c47aa822eb6de8a45801","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-placement-question:07f75c122772af108382b804","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"da83f33ece5b000acf3b62873684fda9412684c1a55317fcc58863da6aacda12","scopeDecisionId":"decision:placement-new-scope:placement-continuation-0074:n0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9ad1c47aa822eb6de8a45801","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"705cbd24ed6d75cbd58094b6f765608a59ad55d68a456a0157ccdd185be4b09b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2219c82b42ad5c5aa0ab7c63"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:c7324d49ff27c430ae1716c482542699b7bf5151ebe23e5f106e23ddb2966791","home":{"unitId":"unit:c7324d49ff27c430ae1716c482542699b7bf5151ebe23e5f106e23ddb2966791","destinationId":"q025-placement-question:07f75c122772af108382b804","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"The proposed composite question covers both long-range SYK spectra and scrambling and protected boundary Yukawa-SYK operator data, with their dimensions and mechanisms kept distinct.","qualification":"n0 preserves the full compound question. q29 covers long-range spectra, chaos and spatial scrambling but limits its boundary construction to a chaos observable; q3 covers conformal data and free-bulk protection without the spatial-scrambling program. Neither is independently complete. The supplied regions do not establish a suitable whole home solely from SYK or bulk–boundary terminology. Retaining the supported composite n0 avoids a union while preserving separate dimensions and protection mechanisms.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c7324d49ff27c430ae1716c482542699b7bf5151ebe23e5f106e23ddb2966791","paperId":"2308.12598","textSha256":"8964c60caf96cd1e3cdc2182c2da64c1f3c492e1b1363ff9d042be8a00423ee8"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0074:u26:n0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0074:u26:n0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c7324d49ff27c430ae1716c482542699b7bf5151ebe23e5f106e23ddb2966791","q025-placement-question:07f75c122772af108382b804"],"scopeContentSha256":"da83f33ece5b000acf3b62873684fda9412684c1a55317fcc58863da6aacda12","placementContentSha256":"2d8eff8e48ccacdc89d8cda7101f3eb70e90648116142176d42b3482790afb56","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0074:proposal","new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0074:challenge","root:placement-new-scope-homes:new-scope-cut-05"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c7324d49ff27c430ae1716c482542699b7bf5151ebe23e5f106e23ddb2966791","paperId":"2308.12598","textSha256":"8964c60caf96cd1e3cdc2182c2da64c1f3c492e1b1363ff9d042be8a00423ee8"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/new-scope-cut-05/admission.json","sha256":"48525e8a3ed84d2723d6ecd1d87ab7cd68f1b011d661c42ddf3ed1e14c58d1cf"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-05/exception-intake.json","sha256":"1f583b4cc39626d5268756896ea3e8e8ac0885c2a2aa6719c3ec7ea360952f5a","bytes":659602,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0074","unitRef":"u26"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c7324d49ff27c430ae1716c482542699b7bf5151ebe23e5f106e23ddb2966791","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9ad1c47aa822eb6de8a45801","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:c7324d49ff27c430ae1716c482542699b7bf5151ebe23e5f106e23ddb2966791","textSha256":"8964c60caf96cd1e3cdc2182c2da64c1f3c492e1b1363ff9d042be8a00423ee8"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:243d4fda262c580d4e071b7275709df2","paperId":"2308.12598","sourceSha256":"5328de48ca94041a75ca91dbf015f2bd6b4ecc5455f1d74eabaa25872faa416d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48cd5bfc7662074c7b61/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c6a47e8d18c075cd781d5dc0a2f667146f6b1613efde18f51a157a2d462dcb1","pdfPage":1,"start":3689,"end":5416,"textSha256":"fcbc3d78aba4d30f84bfbb7b358106c76642af309b2a1a3166f6e7ec178564a6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:655afb92c7f5fe0d582fd06bbe3aa418","paperId":"2308.12598","sourceSha256":"5328de48ca94041a75ca91dbf015f2bd6b4ecc5455f1d74eabaa25872faa416d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48cd5bfc7662074c7b61/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c6a47e8d18c075cd781d5dc0a2f667146f6b1613efde18f51a157a2d462dcb1","pdfPage":1,"start":2492,"end":5416,"textSha256":"0726443eb40427acac0f77137e9e58cf74ce26de34654d7eb33f666ad502937e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0b71fd2c78d473476ec657fe","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound source: long-range two-dimensional dynamics and a three-dimensional boundary/four-dimensional bulk construction require separate canonical facets. Independent challenge qualification: Compound source: two-dimensional long-range dynamics and three-dimensional boundary/four-dimensional bulk operator protection need separate canonical facets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0b71fd2c78d473476ec657fe","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c7324d49ff27c430ae1716c482542699b7bf5151ebe23e5f106e23ddb2966791","q025-candidate-question:9ad1c47aa822eb6de8a45801"],"scopeContentSha256":"705cbd24ed6d75cbd58094b6f765608a59ad55d68a456a0157ccdd185be4b09b","contributionContentSha256":"12e67f76c34bb0a9dad1d74115e3ab7ac2f1c0d396372ad195144f1c2214fe09","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-861145bf6ce05d0f3540-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-861145bf6ce05d0f3540-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-861145bf6ce05d0f3540-proposal","leaf-861145bf6ce05d0f3540-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:c7324d49ff27c430ae1716c482542699b7bf5151ebe23e5f106e23ddb2966791","textSha256":"8964c60caf96cd1e3cdc2182c2da64c1f3c492e1b1363ff9d042be8a00423ee8"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:243d4fda262c580d4e071b7275709df2","paperId":"2308.12598","sourceSha256":"5328de48ca94041a75ca91dbf015f2bd6b4ecc5455f1d74eabaa25872faa416d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48cd5bfc7662074c7b61/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c6a47e8d18c075cd781d5dc0a2f667146f6b1613efde18f51a157a2d462dcb1","pdfPage":1,"start":3689,"end":5416,"textSha256":"fcbc3d78aba4d30f84bfbb7b358106c76642af309b2a1a3166f6e7ec178564a6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:655afb92c7f5fe0d582fd06bbe3aa418","paperId":"2308.12598","sourceSha256":"5328de48ca94041a75ca91dbf015f2bd6b4ecc5455f1d74eabaa25872faa416d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/48cd5bfc7662074c7b61/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"9c6a47e8d18c075cd781d5dc0a2f667146f6b1613efde18f51a157a2d462dcb1","pdfPage":1,"start":2492,"end":5416,"textSha256":"0726443eb40427acac0f77137e9e58cf74ce26de34654d7eb33f666ad502937e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0b71fd2c78d473476ec657fe","recordId":"leaf-861145bf6ce05d0f3540-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-861145bf6ce05d0f3540-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-861145bf6ce05d0f3540-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound source: long-range two-dimensional dynamics and a three-dimensional boundary/four-dimensional bulk construction require separate canonical facets.","challengeNote":"Compound source: two-dimensional long-range dynamics and three-dimensional boundary/four-dimensional bulk operator protection need separate canonical facets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"9d278c7738408b95246f048e452adf3143a28fd069dac6d1c2d8fd86f2b51020"},"organizational-access:89a7019433cbd355719b1da7":{"id":"organizational-access:89a7019433cbd355719b1da7","source":"q025-placement-question:ed2290243ac0eb5428ebbe4f","target":"q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-placement-question:ed2290243ac0eb5428ebbe4f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1a6be6235008e67e259d34527ab04c81fdd968d0bfab51f2c417445fe103a421","scopeDecisionId":"decision:placement-new-scope:placement-continuation-0061:n4"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f182d2957140a3f44bdc7c0c469ec4c0b69768b439470a47b36d261656eee304","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2d91b98abf949cd418ef9d0e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:7b170403a5737e6af2f3a916800b62fce5693b16a808044e1344110b2dd9c52e","home":{"unitId":"unit:7b170403a5737e6af2f3a916800b62fce5693b16a808044e1344110b2dd9c52e","destinationId":"q025-placement-question:ed2290243ac0eb5428ebbe4f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers supporting field theories, cosmological formation and evolution, and gravitational and other observational signatures within one dated review scope.","qualification":"n4 covers the complete classification, formation, evolution and observational review. It preserves the field-theory system and 1994 context without inferring a fundamental-string origin or current empirical status. Unresolved fine identity does not prevent this composite placement.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7b170403a5737e6af2f3a916800b62fce5693b16a808044e1344110b2dd9c52e","paperId":"hep-ph/9411342","textSha256":"f65fda7107c2d981346b95cad3663f31d836453873a7a862677fff3173e09cad"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0061:u7:n4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0061:u7:n4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7b170403a5737e6af2f3a916800b62fce5693b16a808044e1344110b2dd9c52e","q025-placement-question:ed2290243ac0eb5428ebbe4f"],"scopeContentSha256":"1a6be6235008e67e259d34527ab04c81fdd968d0bfab51f2c417445fe103a421","placementContentSha256":"284ce2eec93d3f32612614319c4e4903b8008d80b661734b696bd03ada86dcf8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0061:proposal","new-scope-home:placement-continuation-0061:challenge","root:placement-new-scope-homes:new-scope-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7b170403a5737e6af2f3a916800b62fce5693b16a808044e1344110b2dd9c52e","paperId":"hep-ph/9411342","textSha256":"f65fda7107c2d981346b95cad3663f31d836453873a7a862677fff3173e09cad"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/new-scope-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"1fbb32b25cf9d13b6b84cc511720eb22a4b031c1cd03ff6881e01a7f4aee8c31"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0061","unitRef":"u7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7b170403a5737e6af2f3a916800b62fce5693b16a808044e1344110b2dd9c52e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:7b170403a5737e6af2f3a916800b62fce5693b16a808044e1344110b2dd9c52e","textSha256":"f65fda7107c2d981346b95cad3663f31d836453873a7a862677fff3173e09cad"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:246bd556353d42ef82be23bd4e0a5c0f","paperId":"hep-ph/9411342","sourceSha256":"07e100aa1e2fa80b060cebb08f69246a7091406e48a4869247e6daed3878b1d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/614218723a8a3b0ff096/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e77e86de6d8df04ee942bfa5a02e75d318b70e6d72e015bf4b47410d0a8074f","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1439,"textSha256":"52dbaf3dd52e979401d4e3f49a9c87597161d6e7eb9986ef1891fd1398cac9e7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f70fe040657721551026d4a3897832e6","paperId":"hep-ph/9411342","sourceSha256":"07e100aa1e2fa80b060cebb08f69246a7091406e48a4869247e6daed3878b1d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/614218723a8a3b0ff096/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e77e86de6d8df04ee942bfa5a02e75d318b70e6d72e015bf4b47410d0a8074f","pdfPage":2,"start":95,"end":1439,"textSha256":"8337d10507dcc337002224efa3c430113f1215beff403286caf9f5f60cc4507c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:38c5754941b7580014852c7b","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound 1994 review scope; the abstract establishes coverage, not present empirical status. Independent challenge qualification: Compound 1994 review of field-theory strings, formation, dynamics and observations. The abstract supports coverage, without certifying current empirical status."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:38c5754941b7580014852c7b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7b170403a5737e6af2f3a916800b62fce5693b16a808044e1344110b2dd9c52e","q025-candidate-question:64635b37730a2b92e48478ef"],"scopeContentSha256":"f182d2957140a3f44bdc7c0c469ec4c0b69768b439470a47b36d261656eee304","contributionContentSha256":"1e6bab2bc30acda9a801023b6ea963f6bfa05e0dd72021ff787cbf96fe3609aa","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:7b170403a5737e6af2f3a916800b62fce5693b16a808044e1344110b2dd9c52e","textSha256":"f65fda7107c2d981346b95cad3663f31d836453873a7a862677fff3173e09cad"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:246bd556353d42ef82be23bd4e0a5c0f","paperId":"hep-ph/9411342","sourceSha256":"07e100aa1e2fa80b060cebb08f69246a7091406e48a4869247e6daed3878b1d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/614218723a8a3b0ff096/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e77e86de6d8df04ee942bfa5a02e75d318b70e6d72e015bf4b47410d0a8074f","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1439,"textSha256":"52dbaf3dd52e979401d4e3f49a9c87597161d6e7eb9986ef1891fd1398cac9e7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f70fe040657721551026d4a3897832e6","paperId":"hep-ph/9411342","sourceSha256":"07e100aa1e2fa80b060cebb08f69246a7091406e48a4869247e6daed3878b1d7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/614218723a8a3b0ff096/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e77e86de6d8df04ee942bfa5a02e75d318b70e6d72e015bf4b47410d0a8074f","pdfPage":2,"start":95,"end":1439,"textSha256":"8337d10507dcc337002224efa3c430113f1215beff403286caf9f5f60cc4507c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:38c5754941b7580014852c7b","recordId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-55a2311c12b246ddbd15-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound 1994 review scope; the abstract establishes coverage, not present empirical status.","challengeNote":"Compound 1994 review of field-theory strings, formation, dynamics and observations. The abstract supports coverage, without certifying current empirical status.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a63ae6fffd5f37c2857d4c1fe6ede7329d9487964447ffb4291bc155dbc2cc59"}}}
