{"schemaVersion":"1.0.0","kind":"eigenquestions-organizational-access-certificates","records":{"organizational-access:62d8bc7db62daa347be521b1":{"id":"organizational-access:62d8bc7db62daa347be521b1","source":"q025-candidate-question:157d528f72cc02f9ee13ebcc","target":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:157d528f72cc02f9ee13ebcc","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"64bb23d9ec940b84d2a4db9db438d8af95c8e37b2ccd9b1643e43c956ffe33ca","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:70e909c93a9a3d840bf2d226"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"bc4d55c0b31819b24d800407c881468951f19c5ed35195b203feba0c0a2d6f23","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:49f7fe9cbc98de691227886e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","home":{"unitId":"unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:157d528f72cc02f9ee13ebcc","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","paperId":"1809.03962","textSha256":"d9a66617be22f12d5d7e95bccf36e2e7cda114245831c357c0f8d03bb4647c70"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:487741ef9e191d34afee2fe23339a005","paperId":"1809.03962","sourceSha256":"9db8be93e1ec0f22c92df9f8f771ee2cb389a981eee588510b98557ada972be3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0663e34c29fb38b547b8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e1505ac8c2d1c67b7ad9da219b800be5bcf903b780494177beb7527b3364f5d3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f1e3cea826b511dc94376ebfaa8e0283b16a273ac6437d459471d7fb6a233fde","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:562586c14247f3aa96229fc5f1b96f0a","paperId":"1809.03962","sourceSha256":"9db8be93e1ec0f22c92df9f8f771ee2cb389a981eee588510b98557ada972be3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0663e34c29fb38b547b8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e1505ac8c2d1c67b7ad9da219b800be5bcf903b780494177beb7527b3364f5d3","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"ccc7d8da50f1ecdd1f27cf9100402b21e0380ada81e4caee78fa68c9ad53e082","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:93cc09067e464257d3e6f3b5fba42825","paperId":"1809.03962","sourceSha256":"9db8be93e1ec0f22c92df9f8f771ee2cb389a981eee588510b98557ada972be3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0663e34c29fb38b547b8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e1505ac8c2d1c67b7ad9da219b800be5bcf903b780494177beb7527b3364f5d3","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"934f63b8d424c1580844db259e7b7274785e12e893dea28cc99bba2f2d255ad2","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:131ba682cbe254134f137787"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:131ba682cbe254134f137787","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","q025-candidate-question:157d528f72cc02f9ee13ebcc"],"scopeContentSha256":"64bb23d9ec940b84d2a4db9db438d8af95c8e37b2ccd9b1643e43c956ffe33ca","placementContentSha256":"51011a9efe105141fcdc09c8f4004c04ead5c406b0e60c9846f65a0bdc98472c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-challenge","leaf-71f9bd087ee989805def-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","paperId":"1809.03962","textSha256":"d9a66617be22f12d5d7e95bccf36e2e7cda114245831c357c0f8d03bb4647c70"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:487741ef9e191d34afee2fe23339a005","paperId":"1809.03962","sourceSha256":"9db8be93e1ec0f22c92df9f8f771ee2cb389a981eee588510b98557ada972be3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0663e34c29fb38b547b8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e1505ac8c2d1c67b7ad9da219b800be5bcf903b780494177beb7527b3364f5d3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f1e3cea826b511dc94376ebfaa8e0283b16a273ac6437d459471d7fb6a233fde","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:562586c14247f3aa96229fc5f1b96f0a","paperId":"1809.03962","sourceSha256":"9db8be93e1ec0f22c92df9f8f771ee2cb389a981eee588510b98557ada972be3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0663e34c29fb38b547b8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e1505ac8c2d1c67b7ad9da219b800be5bcf903b780494177beb7527b3364f5d3","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"ccc7d8da50f1ecdd1f27cf9100402b21e0380ada81e4caee78fa68c9ad53e082","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:93cc09067e464257d3e6f3b5fba42825","paperId":"1809.03962","sourceSha256":"9db8be93e1ec0f22c92df9f8f771ee2cb389a981eee588510b98557ada972be3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0663e34c29fb38b547b8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e1505ac8c2d1c67b7ad9da219b800be5bcf903b780494177beb7527b3364f5d3","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"934f63b8d424c1580844db259e7b7274785e12e893dea28cc99bba2f2d255ad2","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:131ba682cbe254134f137787"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","textSha256":"d9a66617be22f12d5d7e95bccf36e2e7cda114245831c357c0f8d03bb4647c70"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:487741ef9e191d34afee2fe23339a005","paperId":"1809.03962","sourceSha256":"9db8be93e1ec0f22c92df9f8f771ee2cb389a981eee588510b98557ada972be3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0663e34c29fb38b547b8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e1505ac8c2d1c67b7ad9da219b800be5bcf903b780494177beb7527b3364f5d3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f1e3cea826b511dc94376ebfaa8e0283b16a273ac6437d459471d7fb6a233fde","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:562586c14247f3aa96229fc5f1b96f0a","paperId":"1809.03962","sourceSha256":"9db8be93e1ec0f22c92df9f8f771ee2cb389a981eee588510b98557ada972be3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0663e34c29fb38b547b8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e1505ac8c2d1c67b7ad9da219b800be5bcf903b780494177beb7527b3364f5d3","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"ccc7d8da50f1ecdd1f27cf9100402b21e0380ada81e4caee78fa68c9ad53e082","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:93cc09067e464257d3e6f3b5fba42825","paperId":"1809.03962","sourceSha256":"9db8be93e1ec0f22c92df9f8f771ee2cb389a981eee588510b98557ada972be3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0663e34c29fb38b547b8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e1505ac8c2d1c67b7ad9da219b800be5bcf903b780494177beb7527b3364f5d3","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"934f63b8d424c1580844db259e7b7274785e12e893dea28cc99bba2f2d255ad2","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e14af48de2544ff45d2782ae"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e14af48de2544ff45d2782ae","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7"],"scopeContentSha256":"bc4d55c0b31819b24d800407c881468951f19c5ed35195b203feba0c0a2d6f23","contributionContentSha256":"261f3897a2c00adf529edd9eb4cb149c3d7b3af12f37cd80e5c172a1bc834bd3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:664b594852707c9d02d8fccf01c7ce7b822bb04079f5669e190d2ab26de2c66c","textSha256":"d9a66617be22f12d5d7e95bccf36e2e7cda114245831c357c0f8d03bb4647c70"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:487741ef9e191d34afee2fe23339a005","paperId":"1809.03962","sourceSha256":"9db8be93e1ec0f22c92df9f8f771ee2cb389a981eee588510b98557ada972be3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0663e34c29fb38b547b8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e1505ac8c2d1c67b7ad9da219b800be5bcf903b780494177beb7527b3364f5d3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f1e3cea826b511dc94376ebfaa8e0283b16a273ac6437d459471d7fb6a233fde","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:562586c14247f3aa96229fc5f1b96f0a","paperId":"1809.03962","sourceSha256":"9db8be93e1ec0f22c92df9f8f771ee2cb389a981eee588510b98557ada972be3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0663e34c29fb38b547b8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e1505ac8c2d1c67b7ad9da219b800be5bcf903b780494177beb7527b3364f5d3","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"ccc7d8da50f1ecdd1f27cf9100402b21e0380ada81e4caee78fa68c9ad53e082","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:93cc09067e464257d3e6f3b5fba42825","paperId":"1809.03962","sourceSha256":"9db8be93e1ec0f22c92df9f8f771ee2cb389a981eee588510b98557ada972be3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0663e34c29fb38b547b8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e1505ac8c2d1c67b7ad9da219b800be5bcf903b780494177beb7527b3364f5d3","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"934f63b8d424c1580844db259e7b7274785e12e893dea28cc99bba2f2d255ad2","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e14af48de2544ff45d2782ae","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Cold single-field formulas are conditional. Warm, curvaton and initial-state alternatives do not share a supplied common action; order-one η invalidates the un‑","challengeNote":"April 2019 version. Cold formulas and warm, curvaton or state alternatives have distinct premises; order-one |ηV| is outside controlled potential slow roll.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"c51690e996ecfffecdcf785ee54576168dade2fc60310ad65269e9915c6d3b70"},"organizational-access:95c89e4c1a15ed8a661422ec":{"id":"organizational-access:95c89e4c1a15ed8a661422ec","source":"q025-candidate-question:20b741d8aefd7b97af399a0e","target":"q025-candidate-question:4ce323fa8e8f7bf619f6606b","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:20b741d8aefd7b97af399a0e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"2d4a598788c789f940f9603a925ec36f6c52f9fb9d92738196ae48d188d668d8","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3c9ba049d2e35e9d87fe9d04"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:4ce323fa8e8f7bf619f6606b","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"3359f16d47d6c601df1d3b9293eaec089b5845a50bc0c054dae80f43c9029527","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d104b65dc7fde2f8ae0ddf5d"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","home":{"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:20b741d8aefd7b97af399a0e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers regulated AdS/CFT information density and comparison of boundary entropy with boundary area through bulk-IR/boundary-UV regulation.","qualification":"q5 expressly covers finite information density, regulated entropy/area comparison and bulk-IR/boundary-UV regulation. q0 also supplies a complete foundational counting alternative, while q10 and q17 supply broader dictionary contexts. q5 is a focused choice because it names the compared quantities and regulator regime. Information capacity is not replaced with a particular subregion's entropy or operational reconstruction.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","textSha256":"f778529a916d97c311f42305661e888bca67f8f9e502e409f80cc3cd8f94d177"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0016:u19:q5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0016:u19:q5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","q025-candidate-question:20b741d8aefd7b97af399a0e"],"scopeContentSha256":"2d4a598788c789f940f9603a925ec36f6c52f9fb9d92738196ae48d188d668d8","placementContentSha256":"6bf7f662242c03163b66a0596de4ec5f9d7cf3fe18d9d46ffda363f3db6f16be","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0016:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0016:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","textSha256":"f778529a916d97c311f42305661e888bca67f8f9e502e409f80cc3cd8f94d177"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0016","unitRef":"u19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4ce323fa8e8f7bf619f6606b","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d63","kind":"description","unitIndex":63,"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","textSha256":"f778529a916d97c311f42305661e888bca67f8f9e502e409f80cc3cd8f94d177"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8a364bd089ae3f1fdd73dad149e30eaf","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","sourceSha256":"5185a9cd80d1f1d92b3b74832c0d3c3b7a8678dcef19d14912f41c4bc2051b3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6117198e7743034ee921/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e116a91f23e0758514e5c79078a3ff51beb54da84e09dcf8bd850bdeb3a0b7aa","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1083,"textSha256":"a68ee0222566040e6f1d3819e543b44a4ac00abe61bbb32fd8ce4ce4c7e7af5c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cb0d76e453019315ec1dcb33e694f229","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","sourceSha256":"5185a9cd80d1f1d92b3b74832c0d3c3b7a8678dcef19d14912f41c4bc2051b3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6117198e7743034ee921/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e116a91f23e0758514e5c79078a3ff51beb54da84e09dcf8bd850bdeb3a0b7aa","pdfPage":2,"start":96,"end":2566,"textSha256":"c0803c62f1b2eaa132532b62f62dabc6f141cbfcc815895e5248d1f50673137b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aa7a98e748b7b7903e1017fa","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: v1, 19 May 1998. The target is a regulated comparison of boundary area and entropy. Independent challenge qualification: v1, 19 May 1998. The target is the regulated area/entropy comparison through the bulk IR–boundary UV relation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:aa7a98e748b7b7903e1017fa","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","q025-candidate-question:4ce323fa8e8f7bf619f6606b"],"scopeContentSha256":"3359f16d47d6c601df1d3b9293eaec089b5845a50bc0c054dae80f43c9029527","contributionContentSha256":"0322f5924416c99588ad3bbce1d2747e343877ef79694ae7824b410240aceed0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d63","kind":"description","unitIndex":63,"unitId":"unit:fba21babdad0c31aa371d1cdfd8f51e7f9af31f4c84dd3c5643ff1905ca7d839","textSha256":"f778529a916d97c311f42305661e888bca67f8f9e502e409f80cc3cd8f94d177"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:8a364bd089ae3f1fdd73dad149e30eaf","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","sourceSha256":"5185a9cd80d1f1d92b3b74832c0d3c3b7a8678dcef19d14912f41c4bc2051b3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6117198e7743034ee921/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e116a91f23e0758514e5c79078a3ff51beb54da84e09dcf8bd850bdeb3a0b7aa","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1083,"textSha256":"a68ee0222566040e6f1d3819e543b44a4ac00abe61bbb32fd8ce4ce4c7e7af5c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cb0d76e453019315ec1dcb33e694f229","paperId":"hep-th/9805114","sourceSha256":"5185a9cd80d1f1d92b3b74832c0d3c3b7a8678dcef19d14912f41c4bc2051b3e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6117198e7743034ee921/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e116a91f23e0758514e5c79078a3ff51beb54da84e09dcf8bd850bdeb3a0b7aa","pdfPage":2,"start":96,"end":2566,"textSha256":"c0803c62f1b2eaa132532b62f62dabc6f141cbfcc815895e5248d1f50673137b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aa7a98e748b7b7903e1017fa","recordId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-c2b730a1e7f412f6b8e1-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"v1, 19 May 1998. The target is a regulated comparison of boundary area and entropy.","challengeNote":"v1, 19 May 1998. The target is the regulated area/entropy comparison through the bulk IR–boundary UV relation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"dfa47f0b9fdaffa640bf6a493c96a8964a60cade159020b8102ee0926e84f8a5"},"organizational-access:bb067479e78e6930deb5604f":{"id":"organizational-access:bb067479e78e6930deb5604f","source":"q025-candidate-question:273e19a8910ef9f78e1757aa","target":"q025-candidate-question:8d624d6e9f652948e4d58dab","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:273e19a8910ef9f78e1757aa","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"8c427608675b9fcd19f9c230d31c5b5ff5477da40d001548d0d00d722e294e16","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8594dfd3eddcea99c975cbbe"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8d624d6e9f652948e4d58dab","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a4a004addb5028ba62feacc74f86beb1077f92776112d676d49cc7953feb1454","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:13b3d6a0ca27eaab50af5373"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:505bbd3e6ab0c142ac667ee6ad93ba3198b0faee4276a87f95b4daca147a8e98","home":{"unitId":"unit:505bbd3e6ab0c142ac667ee6ad93ba3198b0faee4276a87f95b4daca147a8e98","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:273e19a8910ef9f78e1757aa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q4 spans contracting quantum fluctuations, quantum-bounce applications and affine Brans–Dicke quantization as distinct projects within one composite quantum-model question.","qualification":"q4 combines stochastic contraction, quantum-bounce applications and explicitly named affine Brans–Dicke consistency. Its application regime covers the magnetic-field subproject without identifying it with backreaction or quantization. q7 is narrower for magnetogenesis but incomplete for the whole source.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:505bbd3e6ab0c142ac667ee6ad93ba3198b0faee4276a87f95b4daca147a8e98","paperId":"2010.03462","textSha256":"62ef63a57d8dac76c16225b3e6c507ed829c7425ef99daafc5f010f719c3b2ed"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0022:u17:q4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0022:u17:q4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:505bbd3e6ab0c142ac667ee6ad93ba3198b0faee4276a87f95b4daca147a8e98","q025-candidate-question:273e19a8910ef9f78e1757aa"],"scopeContentSha256":"8c427608675b9fcd19f9c230d31c5b5ff5477da40d001548d0d00d722e294e16","placementContentSha256":"dae6afcbe2a2b99f2ef510418b77ca26d67a0a3a6726738a2a431cd47d404716","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0022:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0022:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:505bbd3e6ab0c142ac667ee6ad93ba3198b0faee4276a87f95b4daca147a8e98","paperId":"2010.03462","textSha256":"62ef63a57d8dac76c16225b3e6c507ed829c7425ef99daafc5f010f719c3b2ed"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0022","unitRef":"u17"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:505bbd3e6ab0c142ac667ee6ad93ba3198b0faee4276a87f95b4daca147a8e98","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8d624d6e9f652948e4d58dab","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d50","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:505bbd3e6ab0c142ac667ee6ad93ba3198b0faee4276a87f95b4daca147a8e98","textSha256":"62ef63a57d8dac76c16225b3e6c507ed829c7425ef99daafc5f010f719c3b2ed"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:33fc17ff6ac3a16a178f586399568fbf","paperId":"2010.03462","sourceSha256":"d9811c5158c05ef78df7b01e9356c944ac03a85b7e999209a5227e14ecbcea3f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ffd9c3e78e891d8dd2ce/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7734c7ddbfa772b0b7ead76b57ffdbf0ad8a1b431833a3493ac52ee45b7b861d","pdfPage":3,"start":1299,"end":2945,"textSha256":"46c25acc6d925975c03f7403da89e810bee55584791a451ed7cb830dc07b8e7a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7161a9570a5145b87f4c1233d3e21954","paperId":"2010.03462","sourceSha256":"d9811c5158c05ef78df7b01e9356c944ac03a85b7e999209a5227e14ecbcea3f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ffd9c3e78e891d8dd2ce/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7734c7ddbfa772b0b7ead76b57ffdbf0ad8a1b431833a3493ac52ee45b7b861d","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2945,"textSha256":"ecd090c13e576e0795088a4f6dcf13123062c054401fdaed2df73d889697880b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:92680151c7034948a7f7b96203e1e8f8","paperId":"2010.03462","sourceSha256":"d9811c5158c05ef78df7b01e9356c944ac03a85b7e999209a5227e14ecbcea3f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ffd9c3e78e891d8dd2ce/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7734c7ddbfa772b0b7ead76b57ffdbf0ad8a1b431833a3493ac52ee45b7b861d","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":2945,"textSha256":"2b3fd0b64f61b62e2497bbc5cacbd68a85e19fc468e75dd906e049eb968f2b9f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:94c3b2a701f99b4f85d13b22"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:94c3b2a701f99b4f85d13b22","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:505bbd3e6ab0c142ac667ee6ad93ba3198b0faee4276a87f95b4daca147a8e98","q025-candidate-question:8d624d6e9f652948e4d58dab"],"scopeContentSha256":"a4a004addb5028ba62feacc74f86beb1077f92776112d676d49cc7953feb1454","contributionContentSha256":"ee068f9f19672d25f7af43149469caa495d8b58ea8b59624f2211ef501b2a5e2","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d50","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:505bbd3e6ab0c142ac667ee6ad93ba3198b0faee4276a87f95b4daca147a8e98","textSha256":"62ef63a57d8dac76c16225b3e6c507ed829c7425ef99daafc5f010f719c3b2ed"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:33fc17ff6ac3a16a178f586399568fbf","paperId":"2010.03462","sourceSha256":"d9811c5158c05ef78df7b01e9356c944ac03a85b7e999209a5227e14ecbcea3f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ffd9c3e78e891d8dd2ce/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7734c7ddbfa772b0b7ead76b57ffdbf0ad8a1b431833a3493ac52ee45b7b861d","pdfPage":3,"start":1299,"end":2945,"textSha256":"46c25acc6d925975c03f7403da89e810bee55584791a451ed7cb830dc07b8e7a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7161a9570a5145b87f4c1233d3e21954","paperId":"2010.03462","sourceSha256":"d9811c5158c05ef78df7b01e9356c944ac03a85b7e999209a5227e14ecbcea3f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ffd9c3e78e891d8dd2ce/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7734c7ddbfa772b0b7ead76b57ffdbf0ad8a1b431833a3493ac52ee45b7b861d","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2945,"textSha256":"ecd090c13e576e0795088a4f6dcf13123062c054401fdaed2df73d889697880b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:92680151c7034948a7f7b96203e1e8f8","paperId":"2010.03462","sourceSha256":"d9811c5158c05ef78df7b01e9356c944ac03a85b7e999209a5227e14ecbcea3f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/ffd9c3e78e891d8dd2ce/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7734c7ddbfa772b0b7ead76b57ffdbf0ad8a1b431833a3493ac52ee45b7b861d","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":2945,"textSha256":"2b3fd0b64f61b62e2497bbc5cacbd68a85e19fc468e75dd906e049eb968f2b9f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:94c3b2a701f99b4f85d13b22","recordId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-da2a175c59a437944326-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Three materially distinct thesis targets—stochastic contraction, magnetogenesis and affine quantization—need finer reconciliation; the probe label does not make","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound identity: stochastic contraction, quantum-bounce magnetogenesis and affine Brans–Dicke quantization are distinct thesis projects.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"be5d8049e0bdd7c083577e26fe16493fffa240ae53d980e5c742168b6e2e8c9f"},"organizational-access:9c290de90f64d1ae2b8172ff":{"id":"organizational-access:9c290de90f64d1ae2b8172ff","source":"q025-candidate-question:2a4de9cc1e863c4f6a0f8fe4","target":"q025-candidate-question:30e964087f1f4e91c85a4a6d","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:2a4de9cc1e863c4f6a0f8fe4","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9c1ab3104e5be370ea218960e873f805844348dff1c729240e6ad78fb1cd7e9a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:02741bf4d1d267b599e32404"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:30e964087f1f4e91c85a4a6d","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"05b3561b11f4dce723f3ccd9dd77f072358467cb7479bd1e625d3ec48097d4b9","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c16e377089b0ffb97b7f97ec"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","home":{"unitId":"unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2a4de9cc1e863c4f6a0f8fe4","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","paperId":"0706.0514","textSha256":"2b58785de0b116829c31a6b8bf9ca3bd7ca6cacf616d5a18153cacdd0729dc7d"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:003ff26091251046d02d16d1e68f1d7c","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":5,"start":250,"end":1878,"textSha256":"3c36b57a71deca2170531e999197f99eb5c65be08c905fd2b40675e6f7f29477","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1a423fbd47160dececd67f964a7ae719","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2156,"textSha256":"32e7ed423072e38c7cbd3574600435786064a8497a18380b94636549ca25487d","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f697c98b5936dc259d0c8acb901fc560","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":2176,"textSha256":"a43301630cb41e73138b5658c4938af5a53106b6101cd3e33117fe8a39748e78","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dd2fbb0feeb55b0f78de1fd7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dd2fbb0feeb55b0f78de1fd7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","q025-candidate-question:2a4de9cc1e863c4f6a0f8fe4"],"scopeContentSha256":"9c1ab3104e5be370ea218960e873f805844348dff1c729240e6ad78fb1cd7e9a","placementContentSha256":"8aafbaf4ed48827f451a4c6849ef9c5a25d1effc203e30b51a764131dba29d3d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-challenge","leaf-2ad258bc94836dc637e4-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","paperId":"0706.0514","textSha256":"2b58785de0b116829c31a6b8bf9ca3bd7ca6cacf616d5a18153cacdd0729dc7d"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:003ff26091251046d02d16d1e68f1d7c","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":5,"start":250,"end":1878,"textSha256":"3c36b57a71deca2170531e999197f99eb5c65be08c905fd2b40675e6f7f29477","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1a423fbd47160dececd67f964a7ae719","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2156,"textSha256":"32e7ed423072e38c7cbd3574600435786064a8497a18380b94636549ca25487d","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f697c98b5936dc259d0c8acb901fc560","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":2176,"textSha256":"a43301630cb41e73138b5658c4938af5a53106b6101cd3e33117fe8a39748e78","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:dd2fbb0feeb55b0f78de1fd7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:30e964087f1f4e91c85a4a6d","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","textSha256":"2b58785de0b116829c31a6b8bf9ca3bd7ca6cacf616d5a18153cacdd0729dc7d"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:003ff26091251046d02d16d1e68f1d7c","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":5,"start":250,"end":1878,"textSha256":"3c36b57a71deca2170531e999197f99eb5c65be08c905fd2b40675e6f7f29477","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1a423fbd47160dececd67f964a7ae719","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2156,"textSha256":"32e7ed423072e38c7cbd3574600435786064a8497a18380b94636549ca25487d","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e28","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f697c98b5936dc259d0c8acb901fc560","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":2176,"textSha256":"a43301630cb41e73138b5658c4938af5a53106b6101cd3e33117fe8a39748e78","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:10e070c785ba685db713f459"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:10e070c785ba685db713f459","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","q025-candidate-question:30e964087f1f4e91c85a4a6d"],"scopeContentSha256":"05b3561b11f4dce723f3ccd9dd77f072358467cb7479bd1e625d3ec48097d4b9","contributionContentSha256":"da7537a1e41a89c96fdc3152f70df998b11ecd8132b8b58ca179b913743fcdd1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:1e4c9e29064eed0849814d1cc755cbe00f6ecff6c7ca8528cbab039a2e927f66","textSha256":"2b58785de0b116829c31a6b8bf9ca3bd7ca6cacf616d5a18153cacdd0729dc7d"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:003ff26091251046d02d16d1e68f1d7c","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":5,"start":250,"end":1878,"textSha256":"3c36b57a71deca2170531e999197f99eb5c65be08c905fd2b40675e6f7f29477","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1a423fbd47160dececd67f964a7ae719","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":2156,"textSha256":"32e7ed423072e38c7cbd3574600435786064a8497a18380b94636549ca25487d","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e28","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f697c98b5936dc259d0c8acb901fc560","paperId":"0706.0514","sourceSha256":"44f483f6d26a721b254c3f801cfd361750159a9d06f910c191f84288cf626030","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/47e6e754039c4f7392d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3aa527671d158478edca88d9db3cbfc465310efe85216a1dae981aa647d746a6","pdfPage":8,"start":0,"end":2176,"textSha256":"a43301630cb41e73138b5658c4938af5a53106b6101cd3e33117fe8a39748e78","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:10e070c785ba685db713f459","recordId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fd2851a3260c57d77fb1-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"No Kähler moduli exist here. Explicit bulk analysis assumes the other modes stabilized separately.","challengeNote":"No Kähler or size modulus exists. The explicit bulk analysis assumes other modes stabilized separately; the protection argument does not calculate a complete yo","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a352e8d40dbe132d84df9062776185cc2cbc68ac0b72808cb0baf744fb9a3af5"},"organizational-access:670a7ae6c0cc5eefd9d63519":{"id":"organizational-access:670a7ae6c0cc5eefd9d63519","source":"q025-candidate-question:32fb14ab6798cddd2cde3f5d","target":"q025-candidate-question:8e4149c7991f4ca5156a5299","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:32fb14ab6798cddd2cde3f5d","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"594dc89c7e49b39a3a50358f39b6283e92e2ecdc0389830e98f215129590b8cf","scopeDecisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:distance-and-emergence:scope:pq0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8e4149c7991f4ca5156a5299","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7805495be663950d1765ec8d9d598a5501e9bccf3e9b1f5fc9d8014c3eea041d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:28d4192d053891c173f86813"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","home":{"unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:32fb14ab6798cddd2cde3f5d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Its admitted question explicitly combines five-dimensional coupling/BPS diagnostics with tests of the associated Calabi–Yau geometric predictions.","qualification":"q4 explicitly combines the five-dimensional gauge/BPS diagnostic question with the associated geometric tests. Bottom-up cubic-EFT arguments and top-down charged BPS/GV tests remain separate evidence routes. Reported favorable-CICY agreement neither audits the sweep nor proves a universal classification, tower theorem or controlled worldsheet identification.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","paperId":"2309.10024","textSha256":"b839d43c589a477882b7e23cd04af016c466f1249c06d808d70a544baa012739"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0009:u20:q4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0009:u20:q4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","q025-candidate-question:32fb14ab6798cddd2cde3f5d"],"scopeContentSha256":"594dc89c7e49b39a3a50358f39b6283e92e2ecdc0389830e98f215129590b8cf","placementContentSha256":"33279f925a61f80f3f6a468d60c054081af0254023aee0a0276685e1ea329ee0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0009:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0009:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","paperId":"2309.10024","textSha256":"b839d43c589a477882b7e23cd04af016c466f1249c06d808d70a544baa012739"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0009","unitRef":"u20"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8e4149c7991f4ca5156a5299","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","textSha256":"b839d43c589a477882b7e23cd04af016c466f1249c06d808d70a544baa012739"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ad7cbb807bbf1fc735c7bf6b9c9f9581","paperId":"2309.10024","sourceSha256":"37763c541b77890e8b7024250ce16b27ce96dcb8c40bdc33c664c3fe8732fe3c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/222f6634fd6f8353feda/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2be8db64cb2c48830804ead23e890c538da6f8142c392e5a5f13860d6b34ea6f","pdfPage":3,"start":99,"end":2941,"textSha256":"297eadda29d7c3bf5118319e08e57e35b51ea4c21a2d6ec77f5a453eb52f6d2a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c58116c501c02fa35cbce7bd6bafd083","paperId":"2309.10024","sourceSha256":"37763c541b77890e8b7024250ce16b27ce96dcb8c40bdc33c664c3fe8732fe3c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/222f6634fd6f8353feda/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2be8db64cb2c48830804ead23e890c538da6f8142c392e5a5f13860d6b34ea6f","pdfPage":2,"start":114,"end":2064,"textSha256":"3652c31610a939058e90ab8a8ee146e08a4bef35d101acde469a1a54468e2bd5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f0fd5b2d4c23ab8d5367405d41129287","paperId":"2309.10024","sourceSha256":"37763c541b77890e8b7024250ce16b27ce96dcb8c40bdc33c664c3fe8732fe3c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/222f6634fd6f8353feda/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2be8db64cb2c48830804ead23e890c538da6f8142c392e5a5f13860d6b34ea6f","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2941,"textSha256":"148d9ded185b2e694f733a6fafb81f9e41c458f4b8b3c16efe3487cecff5d4dc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6195ee1b34c0e8399449febf"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6195ee1b34c0e8399449febf","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","q025-candidate-question:8e4149c7991f4ca5156a5299"],"scopeContentSha256":"7805495be663950d1765ec8d9d598a5501e9bccf3e9b1f5fc9d8014c3eea041d","contributionContentSha256":"3c5af282c81633b594fef3c85a79d0f6776bff7648f689c81859faafc56b1074","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:05d37b3589812aac5cfe2a2d399e1de59230c7be2005ed67f256bf51c1609de2","textSha256":"b839d43c589a477882b7e23cd04af016c466f1249c06d808d70a544baa012739"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ad7cbb807bbf1fc735c7bf6b9c9f9581","paperId":"2309.10024","sourceSha256":"37763c541b77890e8b7024250ce16b27ce96dcb8c40bdc33c664c3fe8732fe3c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/222f6634fd6f8353feda/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2be8db64cb2c48830804ead23e890c538da6f8142c392e5a5f13860d6b34ea6f","pdfPage":3,"start":99,"end":2941,"textSha256":"297eadda29d7c3bf5118319e08e57e35b51ea4c21a2d6ec77f5a453eb52f6d2a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c58116c501c02fa35cbce7bd6bafd083","paperId":"2309.10024","sourceSha256":"37763c541b77890e8b7024250ce16b27ce96dcb8c40bdc33c664c3fe8732fe3c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/222f6634fd6f8353feda/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2be8db64cb2c48830804ead23e890c538da6f8142c392e5a5f13860d6b34ea6f","pdfPage":2,"start":114,"end":2064,"textSha256":"3652c31610a939058e90ab8a8ee146e08a4bef35d101acde469a1a54468e2bd5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f0fd5b2d4c23ab8d5367405d41129287","paperId":"2309.10024","sourceSha256":"37763c541b77890e8b7024250ce16b27ce96dcb8c40bdc33c664c3fe8732fe3c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/222f6634fd6f8353feda/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2be8db64cb2c48830804ead23e890c538da6f8142c392e5a5f13860d6b34ea6f","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2941,"textSha256":"148d9ded185b2e694f733a6fafb81f9e41c458f4b8b3c16efe3487cecff5d4dc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6195ee1b34c0e8399449febf","recordId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8682907465d027e5a8b0-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound limit diagnosis and geometric testing. Reported agreement in 7820 favorable CICY examples is evidence within that sample; e17/e22 overlap.","challengeNote":"Compound limit diagnosis and geometric testing. Agreement in 7820 favorable CICY examples is sampled evidence; e17/e22 overlap.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"3f6928c4b77c068374f67a9876c1066f7e4e1b96a35f18760873afecb9416742"},"organizational-access:ccd607009f2e5689475090ba":{"id":"organizational-access:ccd607009f2e5689475090ba","source":"q025-candidate-question:3324bc237c27c5f00a7c22a1","target":"q025-candidate-question:3b3cef107f1cba22638adb2a","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3324bc237c27c5f00a7c22a1","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"85c98fd41677021abb86b790d367f7195b329222165af52ff1fd9fdfca47cdd9","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:82840e39da53f5e9ec3ee672"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3b3cef107f1cba22638adb2a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b850839d031340957793f872b5cd96d07854507cff212afb47a3dd80d0dffa49","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:9e55f13022d9d19079ea786a"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:329123e39e0e6f34f7e12e4311c6dc315e1246f01e6bc9ebd5fca6970e726c45","home":{"unitId":"unit:329123e39e0e6f34f7e12e4311c6dc315e1246f01e6bc9ebd5fca6970e726c45","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3324bc237c27c5f00a7c22a1","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q3 explicitly combines twisted-compactification anomalies and current levels with entropy applications of anomaly-derived levels.","qualification":"q3 explicitly includes both the isometry-related anomaly/current-level computation after twisted compactification and its entropy application. Electric charge, rotation, supersymmetry and the charged Cardy method remain part of the complete source.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:329123e39e0e6f34f7e12e4311c6dc315e1246f01e6bc9ebd5fca6970e726c45","paperId":"2006.08629","textSha256":"1f223cbf79b86305af3e7e3cb24cad5862aae12f197ce09ad541042acf7cdeee"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0011:u14:q3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0011:u14:q3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:329123e39e0e6f34f7e12e4311c6dc315e1246f01e6bc9ebd5fca6970e726c45","q025-candidate-question:3324bc237c27c5f00a7c22a1"],"scopeContentSha256":"85c98fd41677021abb86b790d367f7195b329222165af52ff1fd9fdfca47cdd9","placementContentSha256":"af21344e80a26ebdee085cbe435f80d825fbae19cfe884057a8fc9f84a921036","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0011:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0011:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:329123e39e0e6f34f7e12e4311c6dc315e1246f01e6bc9ebd5fca6970e726c45","paperId":"2006.08629","textSha256":"1f223cbf79b86305af3e7e3cb24cad5862aae12f197ce09ad541042acf7cdeee"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0011","unitRef":"u14"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:329123e39e0e6f34f7e12e4311c6dc315e1246f01e6bc9ebd5fca6970e726c45","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3b3cef107f1cba22638adb2a","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d43","kind":"description","unitIndex":43,"unitId":"unit:329123e39e0e6f34f7e12e4311c6dc315e1246f01e6bc9ebd5fca6970e726c45","textSha256":"1f223cbf79b86305af3e7e3cb24cad5862aae12f197ce09ad541042acf7cdeee"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b8e244f72e7cad0bf4544402"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b8e244f72e7cad0bf4544402","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:329123e39e0e6f34f7e12e4311c6dc315e1246f01e6bc9ebd5fca6970e726c45","q025-candidate-question:3b3cef107f1cba22638adb2a"],"scopeContentSha256":"b850839d031340957793f872b5cd96d07854507cff212afb47a3dd80d0dffa49","contributionContentSha256":"90e539f213ea3823b7214529a46abd30e23150337d8896516961d9e568f79495","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-proposal","leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d43","kind":"description","unitIndex":43,"unitId":"unit:329123e39e0e6f34f7e12e4311c6dc315e1246f01e6bc9ebd5fca6970e726c45","textSha256":"1f223cbf79b86305af3e7e3cb24cad5862aae12f197ce09ad541042acf7cdeee"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b8e244f72e7cad0bf4544402","recordId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-4c962dd12d07e9d303a0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Retains anomaly/current-level computation and the distinct charged-Cardy entropy application.","challengeNote":"Replace the unsupported inflow factor with the explicitly named charged Cardy method. Anomaly/current-level and entropy targets remain compound.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4603eab4aa6eb6704b6a87ccf2e120977b2ab92e0c2d8e2afb64e7eb7ba7eb66"},"organizational-access:a08e7fac609bcfe3b7652cb1":{"id":"organizational-access:a08e7fac609bcfe3b7652cb1","source":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","target":"q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ad449becadd3a4e1ef632d22d11437ab8b2060c64f934db103812d0ed558ea64","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e63d372fde3b4b8f1ee681f8"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a391c31dc44ef5080afb5df010c0f4b7049f9d9c3e58f66d1155990786029596","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d76d04c815f9832ef43a541d"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5decb2a85c4623aefbe9c469b89c27e8310688b40f9df57c9682d0d8d88b5b0a","home":{"unitId":"unit:5decb2a85c4623aefbe9c469b89c27e8310688b40f9df57c9682d0d8d88b5b0a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Directly covers instabilities from higher KK degrees of freedom omitted by a stable lower-dimensional truncation.","qualification":"q7 directly covers the perturbative test of sectors omitted by a stable truncation. The specified four-dimensional vacuum and eleven-dimensional higher-KK comparison remain together; a completed outcome is not required to place the question.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5decb2a85c4623aefbe9c469b89c27e8310688b40f9df57c9682d0d8d88b5b0a","paperId":"2005.07713","textSha256":"8181cefa89dce904eecf75eb25a4131f847dd4b4bc82eb278773865c6fbcce26"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0019:u15:q7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0019:u15:q7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5decb2a85c4623aefbe9c469b89c27e8310688b40f9df57c9682d0d8d88b5b0a","q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e"],"scopeContentSha256":"ad449becadd3a4e1ef632d22d11437ab8b2060c64f934db103812d0ed558ea64","placementContentSha256":"1df6f14d378f19ddba466a27f9544d7fe094f25bba97a270b0a36c0038ec0cad","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0019:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0019:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5decb2a85c4623aefbe9c469b89c27e8310688b40f9df57c9682d0d8d88b5b0a","paperId":"2005.07713","textSha256":"8181cefa89dce904eecf75eb25a4131f847dd4b4bc82eb278773865c6fbcce26"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0019","unitRef":"u15"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5decb2a85c4623aefbe9c469b89c27e8310688b40f9df57c9682d0d8d88b5b0a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d83","kind":"description","unitIndex":83,"unitId":"unit:5decb2a85c4623aefbe9c469b89c27e8310688b40f9df57c9682d0d8d88b5b0a","textSha256":"8181cefa89dce904eecf75eb25a4131f847dd4b4bc82eb278773865c6fbcce26"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2d9bfcace412c706e73bcb2f62a515f2","paperId":"2005.07713","sourceSha256":"2006a3b09bbaa55d78ac3116abb193a129592934ee4d8a715bcea8528a265f28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7d59966e834281235783/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"36bdb562b99506d2203b390e03c074bdc27a038d0583f49b564b10ccd827511a","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":3266,"textSha256":"c38635d119223dab7941f52d5fe4acb5b1797b4ccf3a664b97d05b6901cde2c2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a86fb591e085f54ca47dc2af1aa34725","paperId":"2005.07713","sourceSha256":"2006a3b09bbaa55d78ac3116abb193a129592934ee4d8a715bcea8528a265f28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7d59966e834281235783/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"36bdb562b99506d2203b390e03c074bdc27a038d0583f49b564b10ccd827511a","pdfPage":10,"start":112,"end":2283,"textSha256":"3f857b8ab5b8bbc0980dab623cf1bd2950f9a63e6921c79568d665183bcc525d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5b4b889759598ba81ed4eaa2bb7716c6","paperId":"2005.07713","sourceSha256":"2006a3b09bbaa55d78ac3116abb193a129592934ee4d8a715bcea8528a265f28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7d59966e834281235783/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"36bdb562b99506d2203b390e03c074bdc27a038d0583f49b564b10ccd827511a","pdfPage":2,"start":1295,"end":3266,"textSha256":"f4009037c23718141a92ca9770c46307c53cbf31cdf531717eae4eda8a6b045c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e89493e5a9cbf13604ce6177"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e89493e5a9cbf13604ce6177","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5decb2a85c4623aefbe9c469b89c27e8310688b40f9df57c9682d0d8d88b5b0a","q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0"],"scopeContentSha256":"a391c31dc44ef5080afb5df010c0f4b7049f9d9c3e58f66d1155990786029596","contributionContentSha256":"a719322bb32757962534a79829b063aea3b6251e3d219fdb1a15f84372dfdd7b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d83","kind":"description","unitIndex":83,"unitId":"unit:5decb2a85c4623aefbe9c469b89c27e8310688b40f9df57c9682d0d8d88b5b0a","textSha256":"8181cefa89dce904eecf75eb25a4131f847dd4b4bc82eb278773865c6fbcce26"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2d9bfcace412c706e73bcb2f62a515f2","paperId":"2005.07713","sourceSha256":"2006a3b09bbaa55d78ac3116abb193a129592934ee4d8a715bcea8528a265f28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7d59966e834281235783/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"36bdb562b99506d2203b390e03c074bdc27a038d0583f49b564b10ccd827511a","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":3266,"textSha256":"c38635d119223dab7941f52d5fe4acb5b1797b4ccf3a664b97d05b6901cde2c2","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a86fb591e085f54ca47dc2af1aa34725","paperId":"2005.07713","sourceSha256":"2006a3b09bbaa55d78ac3116abb193a129592934ee4d8a715bcea8528a265f28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7d59966e834281235783/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"36bdb562b99506d2203b390e03c074bdc27a038d0583f49b564b10ccd827511a","pdfPage":10,"start":112,"end":2283,"textSha256":"3f857b8ab5b8bbc0980dab623cf1bd2950f9a63e6921c79568d665183bcc525d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5b4b889759598ba81ed4eaa2bb7716c6","paperId":"2005.07713","sourceSha256":"2006a3b09bbaa55d78ac3116abb193a129592934ee4d8a715bcea8528a265f28","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7d59966e834281235783/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"36bdb562b99506d2203b390e03c074bdc27a038d0583f49b564b10ccd827511a","pdfPage":2,"start":1295,"end":3266,"textSha256":"f4009037c23718141a92ca9770c46307c53cbf31cdf531717eae4eda8a6b045c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e89493e5a9cbf13604ce6177","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Supplied pages establish the lower-dimensional comparison and set up higher-KK analysis; they do not provide its outcome.","challengeNote":"Supplied pages establish the stable four-dimensional comparison and set up higher-KK analysis; they do not supply the higher-KK outcome.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:7f99d873353a8b06fcb628102ea05dfa3b49d96dd5005f64ef46ca6feafcd92a","home":{"unitId":"unit:7f99d873353a8b06fcb628102ea05dfa3b49d96dd5005f64ef46ca6feafcd92a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Directly covers omitted D6 open-string degrees of freedom and the resulting perturbative stability test beyond closed-string truncations.","qualification":"q7 directly includes dynamical brane fields and perturbative instabilities absent from smaller truncations. It covers the complete closed/open-sector comparison without promoting specified examples to a universal claim.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7f99d873353a8b06fcb628102ea05dfa3b49d96dd5005f64ef46ca6feafcd92a","paperId":"1708.03293","textSha256":"05392281c7401d5144cb64d3a335edd604f8d0df354a3ce1ae34dd903234c4d6"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0019:u19:q7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0019:u19:q7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7f99d873353a8b06fcb628102ea05dfa3b49d96dd5005f64ef46ca6feafcd92a","q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e"],"scopeContentSha256":"ad449becadd3a4e1ef632d22d11437ab8b2060c64f934db103812d0ed558ea64","placementContentSha256":"d82a5059e6be260c6cdc43f91c2d32aecd1493a2757087098e10a029af145216","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0019:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0019:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7f99d873353a8b06fcb628102ea05dfa3b49d96dd5005f64ef46ca6feafcd92a","paperId":"1708.03293","textSha256":"05392281c7401d5144cb64d3a335edd604f8d0df354a3ce1ae34dd903234c4d6"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0019","unitRef":"u19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7f99d873353a8b06fcb628102ea05dfa3b49d96dd5005f64ef46ca6feafcd92a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:7f99d873353a8b06fcb628102ea05dfa3b49d96dd5005f64ef46ca6feafcd92a","textSha256":"05392281c7401d5144cb64d3a335edd604f8d0df354a3ce1ae34dd903234c4d6"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:abd7509f9b16fd39a8dfdc6327b43a0d","paperId":"1708.03293","sourceSha256":"2c57436df857b4a165185216c2fe82da9e4327721ba342d03335cfc1e3943bb4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/276623cb6b36efa3492d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46ee44d73d4f7c8ec7e9d5128274c0d2c7aba3d01c1f5755be4af8548592417c","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"8fefa0d0eab649e6c5c9fd2ee4677311d1df18fd93764861eea2a9fbaba0cfa4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cda39d6c1d2d767a6512b9649641cd3a","paperId":"1708.03293","sourceSha256":"2c57436df857b4a165185216c2fe82da9e4327721ba342d03335cfc1e3943bb4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/276623cb6b36efa3492d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46ee44d73d4f7c8ec7e9d5128274c0d2c7aba3d01c1f5755be4af8548592417c","pdfPage":3,"start":1288,"end":3009,"textSha256":"6c3d599bbb7e1bc40e6081df72f3fa6d9ca9ad5ca4986072eccc921c9181e390","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f5662ee86a8ab5f57ad8b5d6cbc79966","paperId":"1708.03293","sourceSha256":"2c57436df857b4a165185216c2fe82da9e4327721ba342d03335cfc1e3943bb4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/276623cb6b36efa3492d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46ee44d73d4f7c8ec7e9d5128274c0d2c7aba3d01c1f5755be4af8548592417c","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3009,"textSha256":"cffbfe8985b05bc8d6a0c1de2bbaa3969e4fe48a1fc836032c2e00f036dd132c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5b114637e290039810e7cc6f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5b114637e290039810e7cc6f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7f99d873353a8b06fcb628102ea05dfa3b49d96dd5005f64ef46ca6feafcd92a","q025-candidate-question:874c0daba0f5cb0fb3ee8bb0"],"scopeContentSha256":"a391c31dc44ef5080afb5df010c0f4b7049f9d9c3e58f66d1155990786029596","contributionContentSha256":"5f50426ab1c277bf2625fd0dde2d51eb8c746caab92b3d83f5fd15706c3434f6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d16","kind":"description","unitIndex":16,"unitId":"unit:7f99d873353a8b06fcb628102ea05dfa3b49d96dd5005f64ef46ca6feafcd92a","textSha256":"05392281c7401d5144cb64d3a335edd604f8d0df354a3ce1ae34dd903234c4d6"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:abd7509f9b16fd39a8dfdc6327b43a0d","paperId":"1708.03293","sourceSha256":"2c57436df857b4a165185216c2fe82da9e4327721ba342d03335cfc1e3943bb4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/276623cb6b36efa3492d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46ee44d73d4f7c8ec7e9d5128274c0d2c7aba3d01c1f5755be4af8548592417c","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"8fefa0d0eab649e6c5c9fd2ee4677311d1df18fd93764861eea2a9fbaba0cfa4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cda39d6c1d2d767a6512b9649641cd3a","paperId":"1708.03293","sourceSha256":"2c57436df857b4a165185216c2fe82da9e4327721ba342d03335cfc1e3943bb4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/276623cb6b36efa3492d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46ee44d73d4f7c8ec7e9d5128274c0d2c7aba3d01c1f5755be4af8548592417c","pdfPage":3,"start":1288,"end":3009,"textSha256":"6c3d599bbb7e1bc40e6081df72f3fa6d9ca9ad5ca4986072eccc921c9181e390","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f5662ee86a8ab5f57ad8b5d6cbc79966","paperId":"1708.03293","sourceSha256":"2c57436df857b4a165185216c2fe82da9e4327721ba342d03335cfc1e3943bb4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/276623cb6b36efa3492d/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"46ee44d73d4f7c8ec7e9d5128274c0d2c7aba3d01c1f5755be4af8548592417c","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3009,"textSha256":"cffbfe8985b05bc8d6a0c1de2bbaa3969e4fe48a1fc836032c2e00f036dd132c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5b114637e290039810e7cc6f","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"The source announces open-sector tachyons in specified AdS7 and AdS4 examples; this does not establish a universal theorem.","challengeNote":"The source announces D6 open-sector tachyons in specified AdS7/AdS4 examples. Earlier closed-sector assessments remain historical comparison, not full-stability","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"0bd41f24e8393ddf21b1ab14ffe0667a94485fbc7b575a5b4aecdf6f1b120386"},"organizational-access:cc2fad068895c630e0adf785":{"id":"organizational-access:cc2fad068895c630e0adf785","source":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","target":"q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ad449becadd3a4e1ef632d22d11437ab8b2060c64f934db103812d0ed558ea64","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e63d372fde3b4b8f1ee681f8"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6734fbe04f2387de13aad723a0e31051d7d28b96e70ae827863c809ca052b2f6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8beddc9f8b4587b287fbe3c6"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","home":{"unitId":"unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":0.3,"reason":"Covers the perturbative stability assessment of the AdS extrema in the specified retained field sector.","qualification":"Construction, AdS perturbative stability and positive-energy/inflation components remain distinct; isotropic stability or hierarchy is not a complete stable inflationary history. Exact full challenge coverage and source-local qualifications remain binding. Weights are organizational allocation, not confidence or physical importance.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","paperId":"1302.0529","textSha256":"eb331c59a80402ff9c6c974e7a1be44502921c6c498985f14f73d68406d8828d"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:u29:q8","coverageMode":"explicit_compound_union","targetCoverage":[{"sourceSpan":"Which constrained integer-flux configurations yield stable non-supersymmetric dS or AdS extrema in an isotropic type IIB non-geometric model,","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"],"explanation":"q35 covers constrained-flux AdS construction, q8 the stated AdS stability tests, and q7 the dS construction and stability branch. All retain the isotropic model restriction and nonsupersymmetric setting."},{"sourceSpan":"and do the reported dS examples admit small-field, multi-field slow-roll conditions?","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"],"explanation":"q7 explicitly allows supplied inflationary applications of the dS branch; this is a conditions test, not a claim of a complete inflationary history."}],"coverageReason":"The union covers constrained integer-flux AdS construction, retained-sector AdS stability, and the dS stability/slow-roll application. q35 alone omits the latter targets, q8's AdS definition cannot be silently extended to dS, and q7 does not cover the independent AdS construction question. No supplied whole composite covers all regimes. Isotropic stability and slow-roll conditions remain limited tests."},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:u29:q8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e"],"scopeContentSha256":"ad449becadd3a4e1ef632d22d11437ab8b2060c64f934db103812d0ed558ea64","placementContentSha256":"4466d5d429fa73f81989d4cf16b015adf4c745af60515eff122f4ce23eb4677f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:proposal","explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:challenge","root:explicit-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","paperId":"1302.0529","textSha256":"eb331c59a80402ff9c6c974e7a1be44502921c6c498985f14f73d68406d8828d"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"45cd7c1d060cb6f2fd1d8a4ace5cca7c3d64df235a869afc4ce7e31b2e6badfb"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0066","unitRef":"u29"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","textSha256":"eb331c59a80402ff9c6c974e7a1be44502921c6c498985f14f73d68406d8828d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a28d13b0e0204ce8b20b4ef5"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a28d13b0e0204ce8b20b4ef5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c"],"scopeContentSha256":"6734fbe04f2387de13aad723a0e31051d7d28b96e70ae827863c809ca052b2f6","contributionContentSha256":"abea4d784bb387ee35ba3459512403df9c0ffa38dc7074f27e531ecea7305960","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","textSha256":"eb331c59a80402ff9c6c974e7a1be44502921c6c498985f14f73d68406d8828d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a28d13b0e0204ce8b20b4ef5","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Isotropic flux extrema and dS slow-roll conditions are distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Isotropic flux extrema and dS slow-roll conditions are distinct targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","home":{"unitId":"unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":0.3,"reason":"Covers perturbative stability of the AdS candidates when scalar directions omitted by isotropic truncations are included.","qualification":"Construction, AdS perturbative stability and positive-energy/inflation components remain distinct; isotropic stability or hierarchy is not a complete stable inflationary history. Exact full challenge coverage and source-local qualifications remain binding. Weights are organizational allocation, not confidence or physical importance.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","paperId":"1304.0792","textSha256":"739ac8a50b523c68f1bdb0e11280bd60b17ddd9782f37c690e3e4af13c0886e6"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:u27:q8","coverageMode":"explicit_compound_union","targetCoverage":[{"sourceSpan":"Can S-dual nongeometric P-fluxes and torus anisotropy produce further stable dS/AdS candidates,","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"],"explanation":"q35 covers AdS construction with the stated flux and anisotropy ingredients, q8 its perturbative stability tests, and q7 the dS construction and stability branch. q8 is not enlarged to cover dS systems."},{"sourceSpan":"remove instabilities hidden by isotropic truncations,","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"],"explanation":"q8 covers previously omitted scalar directions for AdS candidates; q7 covers whether the dS branch remains stabilized and metastable when the relevant directions are tested."},{"sourceSpan":"and change the moduli hierarchies relevant to small-field inflation?","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"],"explanation":"q35 covers claimed hierarchies of the constructed AdS branch, and q7 covers their relevance in the supplied positive-energy and inflationary setting."}],"coverageReason":"The union covers flux/anisotropy construction and hierarchies, omitted-sector AdS stability, and dS stabilization/inflation applications. q35 separates construction from subsequent stability; q8 does not supply a general dS scope; q7 does not cover the independent AdS construction program. No supplied whole vacuum scope covers their conjunction. Stability remains sector-specific, and a hierarchy does not by itself establish successful inflation."},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:u27:q8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e"],"scopeContentSha256":"ad449becadd3a4e1ef632d22d11437ab8b2060c64f934db103812d0ed558ea64","placementContentSha256":"3d2fb3be394ada5494417d6921b6e25888534499ee00948af243f9bd2aa92468","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:proposal","explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:challenge","root:explicit-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","paperId":"1304.0792","textSha256":"739ac8a50b523c68f1bdb0e11280bd60b17ddd9782f37c690e3e4af13c0886e6"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"45cd7c1d060cb6f2fd1d8a4ace5cca7c3d64df235a869afc4ce7e31b2e6badfb"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0066","unitRef":"u27"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","textSha256":"739ac8a50b523c68f1bdb0e11280bd60b17ddd9782f37c690e3e4af13c0886e6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:94bece84f5ab6c22fb798097"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:94bece84f5ab6c22fb798097","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c"],"scopeContentSha256":"6734fbe04f2387de13aad723a0e31051d7d28b96e70ae827863c809ca052b2f6","contributionContentSha256":"09c7f871a58e2e67a6a2033fc24f6e8a0a7362edf60004fd43597bce9ec91485","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","textSha256":"739ac8a50b523c68f1bdb0e11280bd60b17ddd9782f37c690e3e4af13c0886e6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:94bece84f5ab6c22fb798097","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound P-flux/anisotropy, stability and inflation-hierarchy questions.","challengeNote":"Compound P-flux/anisotropy, stability and inflation-hierarchy questions.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"de1054cbaa3273159898e28e3323b7497aaa161f49efdb2739622db54be19124"},"organizational-access:db563ec26e56b444dc12c9d2":{"id":"organizational-access:db563ec26e56b444dc12c9d2","source":"q025-candidate-question:41a6d6f2a587d7f59ae35076","target":"q025-candidate-question:277a5abfb00c7273b388a5ef","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:41a6d6f2a587d7f59ae35076","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e0133fdacc109f5cb87aeb02227171bb3b84ef22bdddea404c6761413dd36993","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:51a61c4605c46bf3dc21970e"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:277a5abfb00c7273b388a5ef","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a208ba6d78c9f3d24ca3d5eeea9c104926b6920f28af1ddca13e89b5ada920ca","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8ba0ab6fa21ba20a93dc4583"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:65780eab637a911354e09c985ab6d1f21b455bf0a96392e9294377d8f27518b5","home":{"unitId":"unit:65780eab637a911354e09c985ab6d1f21b455bf0a96392e9294377d8f27518b5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:41a6d6f2a587d7f59ae35076","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q5 was defined to retain the thesis's response, entanglement-consistency and TbarT-observable questions across their separate settings.","qualification":"q5 is an admitted composite question with all listed response, entanglement and deformation targets. Its scope expressly allows separate thesis settings. Unresolved finer identities do not undermine this complete organizational home, whereas q3 covers only the de Sitter consistency component.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:65780eab637a911354e09c985ab6d1f21b455bf0a96392e9294377d8f27518b5","paperId":"2012.10109","textSha256":"42b347bc6e19dc16ba6500d5f85a9eeb83fbcd0c04075a775646604026810d97"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0050:u11:q5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0050:u11:q5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:65780eab637a911354e09c985ab6d1f21b455bf0a96392e9294377d8f27518b5","q025-candidate-question:41a6d6f2a587d7f59ae35076"],"scopeContentSha256":"e0133fdacc109f5cb87aeb02227171bb3b84ef22bdddea404c6761413dd36993","placementContentSha256":"9362793aff2658985f6d82bee935c6847c3434383645a32cca0ad9cb3d2c262f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0050:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0050:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:65780eab637a911354e09c985ab6d1f21b455bf0a96392e9294377d8f27518b5","paperId":"2012.10109","textSha256":"42b347bc6e19dc16ba6500d5f85a9eeb83fbcd0c04075a775646604026810d97"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0050","unitRef":"u11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:65780eab637a911354e09c985ab6d1f21b455bf0a96392e9294377d8f27518b5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:277a5abfb00c7273b388a5ef","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:65780eab637a911354e09c985ab6d1f21b455bf0a96392e9294377d8f27518b5","textSha256":"42b347bc6e19dc16ba6500d5f85a9eeb83fbcd0c04075a775646604026810d97"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:638898b44bee862cc0c266c9","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound thesis: only its de Sitter entanglement-consistency component maps to q5; finer identities remain unresolved. Independent challenge qualification: Compound thesis; only the de Sitter entanglement-consistency component specializes p5. Fine decomposition is unresolved."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:638898b44bee862cc0c266c9","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:65780eab637a911354e09c985ab6d1f21b455bf0a96392e9294377d8f27518b5","q025-candidate-question:277a5abfb00c7273b388a5ef"],"scopeContentSha256":"a208ba6d78c9f3d24ca3d5eeea9c104926b6920f28af1ddca13e89b5ada920ca","contributionContentSha256":"a35359d75f28fe1541800da13ecdd134dd9f24dcf282bae6df8ad6ccd7f38e93","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:65780eab637a911354e09c985ab6d1f21b455bf0a96392e9294377d8f27518b5","textSha256":"42b347bc6e19dc16ba6500d5f85a9eeb83fbcd0c04075a775646604026810d97"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:638898b44bee862cc0c266c9","recordId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound thesis: only its de Sitter entanglement-consistency component maps to q5; finer identities remain unresolved.","challengeNote":"Compound thesis; only the de Sitter entanglement-consistency component specializes p5. Fine decomposition is unresolved.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a891d7be5768021778cb0123d787754a818911e0d8aaec6185006d55bed947b1"},"organizational-access:40bfac9f3e2a8d96c6a66e01":{"id":"organizational-access:40bfac9f3e2a8d96c6a66e01","source":"q025-candidate-question:4cc2094969284fe528a7b176","target":"q025-candidate-question:9b19a7a3ee8d1dc0a54e2c1c","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:4cc2094969284fe528a7b176","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a231222dba95522f079d134b308cd82fc8e2dc6070fcae00dfaaa37a110a88a5","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:10b22c8559a19afbfe1262f4"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9b19a7a3ee8d1dc0a54e2c1c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"cad90b96d30bf010d885887eb246bc3c1c797501a268af1e7d329ab587d99d6b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3428a7672d1e0c340eabd68f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:f2f7b77b133d2dda8c66424463970c02120cc97a43e897f8fc4dc6a2a1b7889d","home":{"unitId":"unit:f2f7b77b133d2dda8c66424463970c02120cc97a43e897f8fc4dc6a2a1b7889d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4cc2094969284fe528a7b176","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers quantum descriptions of static patches and asymptotic data, their entropy compatibility and the distinction between boundary data and single-observer access.","qualification":"q20 covers patch and asymptotic quantum descriptions, their observable domains and compatibility with entropy. This matches the complete observer/metaobserver comparison without making all boundary data operationally accessible. q54 centers on observer-accessible algebras and capacity. q44 includes asymptotic observers, but its physical-measurement and finite-state branches do not as clearly cover the full comparison of quantum formulations. Neither finite entropy nor this placement establishes a finite global Hilbert space.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f2f7b77b133d2dda8c66424463970c02120cc97a43e897f8fc4dc6a2a1b7889d","textSha256":"88139a53cf9605a59169f4a748812ed301a9704c44360ebcf0a1e7f79f388b17"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:competing:u21:q20"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:competing:u21:q20","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f2f7b77b133d2dda8c66424463970c02120cc97a43e897f8fc4dc6a2a1b7889d","q025-candidate-question:4cc2094969284fe528a7b176"],"scopeContentSha256":"a231222dba95522f079d134b308cd82fc8e2dc6070fcae00dfaaa37a110a88a5","placementContentSha256":"e7938719b5e20fac38e638fe86ae59d5a4888da824f91344e6e1a44fb2375554","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:competing:proposal","placement-pilot:competing:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f2f7b77b133d2dda8c66424463970c02120cc97a43e897f8fc4dc6a2a1b7889d","textSha256":"88139a53cf9605a59169f4a748812ed301a9704c44360ebcf0a1e7f79f388b17"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:f2f7b77b133d2dda8c66424463970c02120cc97a43e897f8fc4dc6a2a1b7889d"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f2f7b77b133d2dda8c66424463970c02120cc97a43e897f8fc4dc6a2a1b7889d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9b19a7a3ee8d1dc0a54e2c1c","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:f2f7b77b133d2dda8c66424463970c02120cc97a43e897f8fc4dc6a2a1b7889d","textSha256":"88139a53cf9605a59169f4a748812ed301a9704c44360ebcf0a1e7f79f388b17"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:16dd4f3103ece4dfce5c3c1ab3305257","paperId":"1205.3855","sourceSha256":"4c96cb4c0173a9c8b2730589a63cd212ae610c224333eed30202d34664f408ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/654da096957524ee7dfe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5125f3c71f9c9f30615d07209800855fe359c3aa3d29670d048b2421784440a2","pdfPage":26,"start":101,"end":3147,"textSha256":"aee554cf0b293e14d6eb0cb84fd1eb22614f2538b58c60791bf8f6da9e3f07b7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9b0afa1eb6a6377925f9217a1acca32e","paperId":"1205.3855","sourceSha256":"4c96cb4c0173a9c8b2730589a63cd212ae610c224333eed30202d34664f408ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/654da096957524ee7dfe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5125f3c71f9c9f30615d07209800855fe359c3aa3d29670d048b2421784440a2","pdfPage":3,"start":1297,"end":3779,"textSha256":"398c1c71e6de56ff0148fd5e9f088a570af168fa0d2b2d3065dfbb9a7db5d272","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e0d99db4bac34a226aa953acbdc0d767","paperId":"1205.3855","sourceSha256":"4c96cb4c0173a9c8b2730589a63cd212ae610c224333eed30202d34664f408ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/654da096957524ee7dfe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5125f3c71f9c9f30615d07209800855fe359c3aa3d29670d048b2421784440a2","pdfPage":30,"start":102,"end":2978,"textSha256":"5f3dbc619acacca0e960bb080dc048597a7e916601bec9af2189184e07a36997","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7fc17673672877f757b2cdc4","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The 2012 survey combines observables, entropy interpretations and quantum definitions; one fine identity is unresolved. Independent challenge qualification: The 2012 survey combines observables, entropy interpretations and quantum definitions; one fine identity remains unresolved."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7fc17673672877f757b2cdc4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f2f7b77b133d2dda8c66424463970c02120cc97a43e897f8fc4dc6a2a1b7889d","q025-candidate-question:9b19a7a3ee8d1dc0a54e2c1c"],"scopeContentSha256":"cad90b96d30bf010d885887eb246bc3c1c797501a268af1e7d329ab587d99d6b","contributionContentSha256":"9bf2d105c64a63d25f76aa00c4e99a0ad0647be5a5da01e7c4c3d257280d7b35","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:f2f7b77b133d2dda8c66424463970c02120cc97a43e897f8fc4dc6a2a1b7889d","textSha256":"88139a53cf9605a59169f4a748812ed301a9704c44360ebcf0a1e7f79f388b17"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:16dd4f3103ece4dfce5c3c1ab3305257","paperId":"1205.3855","sourceSha256":"4c96cb4c0173a9c8b2730589a63cd212ae610c224333eed30202d34664f408ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/654da096957524ee7dfe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5125f3c71f9c9f30615d07209800855fe359c3aa3d29670d048b2421784440a2","pdfPage":26,"start":101,"end":3147,"textSha256":"aee554cf0b293e14d6eb0cb84fd1eb22614f2538b58c60791bf8f6da9e3f07b7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9b0afa1eb6a6377925f9217a1acca32e","paperId":"1205.3855","sourceSha256":"4c96cb4c0173a9c8b2730589a63cd212ae610c224333eed30202d34664f408ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/654da096957524ee7dfe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5125f3c71f9c9f30615d07209800855fe359c3aa3d29670d048b2421784440a2","pdfPage":3,"start":1297,"end":3779,"textSha256":"398c1c71e6de56ff0148fd5e9f088a570af168fa0d2b2d3065dfbb9a7db5d272","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e0d99db4bac34a226aa953acbdc0d767","paperId":"1205.3855","sourceSha256":"4c96cb4c0173a9c8b2730589a63cd212ae610c224333eed30202d34664f408ae","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/654da096957524ee7dfe/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"5125f3c71f9c9f30615d07209800855fe359c3aa3d29670d048b2421784440a2","pdfPage":30,"start":102,"end":2978,"textSha256":"5f3dbc619acacca0e960bb080dc048597a7e916601bec9af2189184e07a36997","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7fc17673672877f757b2cdc4","recordId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The 2012 survey combines observables, entropy interpretations and quantum definitions; one fine identity is unresolved.","challengeNote":"The 2012 survey combines observables, entropy interpretations and quantum definitions; one fine identity remains unresolved.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"daa6b8eca5430c4899ce681bf8d7e77430ab094e1d3927919eda625e13f7244a"},"organizational-access:eb1bf0cc6b63d3bdce39bc92":{"id":"organizational-access:eb1bf0cc6b63d3bdce39bc92","source":"q025-candidate-question:54c957af583e29b15de18961","target":"q025-candidate-question:9e41a3868dcdcfebf87974e3","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:54c957af583e29b15de18961","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"dbd7fbce12fb30b4bcc4d338b956c5b3e36779fdd3cf07b1a01537e7701dbd71","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:80333704c99b027a04d8d2fb"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9e41a3868dcdcfebf87974e3","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"076583202ef684ad98efa9949aca93770015dec3004e82ade5a5997ddfe6c6a9","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:fc1a6f8d7f5c0ae1b6605ee0"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5f5acebe2dc1df1ad97272a28776c9bcc2f118e8fffa0fc2ae81cccdc7831a69","home":{"unitId":"unit:5f5acebe2dc1df1ad97272a28776c9bcc2f118e8fffa0fc2ae81cccdc7831a69","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:54c957af583e29b15de18961","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5f5acebe2dc1df1ad97272a28776c9bcc2f118e8fffa0fc2ae81cccdc7831a69","paperId":"1412.3457","textSha256":"2fdbee5fe994aba9e36cb1757c176147d4ef18eeee85f7366da6cd077f4a96eb"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:be555b8eee8fb5033e309657"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:be555b8eee8fb5033e309657","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5f5acebe2dc1df1ad97272a28776c9bcc2f118e8fffa0fc2ae81cccdc7831a69","q025-candidate-question:54c957af583e29b15de18961"],"scopeContentSha256":"dbd7fbce12fb30b4bcc4d338b956c5b3e36779fdd3cf07b1a01537e7701dbd71","placementContentSha256":"a16af118907ee2e193406b4c516a0d03619e9395db34206327fa722179cf803a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-challenge","leaf-8e1e582d082b0be81d54-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5f5acebe2dc1df1ad97272a28776c9bcc2f118e8fffa0fc2ae81cccdc7831a69","paperId":"1412.3457","textSha256":"2fdbee5fe994aba9e36cb1757c176147d4ef18eeee85f7366da6cd077f4a96eb"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:be555b8eee8fb5033e309657"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5f5acebe2dc1df1ad97272a28776c9bcc2f118e8fffa0fc2ae81cccdc7831a69","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9e41a3868dcdcfebf87974e3","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d83","kind":"description","unitIndex":83,"unitId":"unit:5f5acebe2dc1df1ad97272a28776c9bcc2f118e8fffa0fc2ae81cccdc7831a69","textSha256":"2fdbee5fe994aba9e36cb1757c176147d4ef18eeee85f7366da6cd077f4a96eb"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3999bc7ea9b7893f912f7e8f1145aec4","paperId":"1412.3457","sourceSha256":"20676f4e3561afd9acbd35190e01e0f26752aaa867c5f8dcfb7040f552f4fb53","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7f6408ede5cf529e0acf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"89fb6afbe33a307306f0846ac56328c08f540851daa4a143ecd61197ccf6de78","pdfPage":2,"start":98,"end":3499,"textSha256":"9bb3c06d50f6541ad4f4cb03eab4863709dcae6b056b6986bd2fb7d13e6db8cc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7f68cae355a23cefbf5788168f4f179d","paperId":"1412.3457","sourceSha256":"20676f4e3561afd9acbd35190e01e0f26752aaa867c5f8dcfb7040f552f4fb53","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7f6408ede5cf529e0acf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"89fb6afbe33a307306f0846ac56328c08f540851daa4a143ecd61197ccf6de78","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0cde3bb93659bdb63acb9845555f1bca151b1096643e616e5deb59a4479f4f55","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e1505366365e332989e4f77a","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The outside probe fits the core. The excerpt describes a 4+1-dimensional gauge/Wilson-loop route under the paper's WGC criterion, not a completed top-down deriv Independent challenge qualification: The outside probe fits the core. The 4+1-dimensional Wilson-loop route is a conditional EFT construction, not a completed top-down derivation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e1505366365e332989e4f77a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5f5acebe2dc1df1ad97272a28776c9bcc2f118e8fffa0fc2ae81cccdc7831a69","q025-candidate-question:9e41a3868dcdcfebf87974e3"],"scopeContentSha256":"076583202ef684ad98efa9949aca93770015dec3004e82ade5a5997ddfe6c6a9","contributionContentSha256":"d6718f1ae8c220cae3fa4136c2ef4fa29f353d7bb612cb3f86111cde0c82e8d6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d83","kind":"description","unitIndex":83,"unitId":"unit:5f5acebe2dc1df1ad97272a28776c9bcc2f118e8fffa0fc2ae81cccdc7831a69","textSha256":"2fdbee5fe994aba9e36cb1757c176147d4ef18eeee85f7366da6cd077f4a96eb"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3999bc7ea9b7893f912f7e8f1145aec4","paperId":"1412.3457","sourceSha256":"20676f4e3561afd9acbd35190e01e0f26752aaa867c5f8dcfb7040f552f4fb53","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7f6408ede5cf529e0acf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"89fb6afbe33a307306f0846ac56328c08f540851daa4a143ecd61197ccf6de78","pdfPage":2,"start":98,"end":3499,"textSha256":"9bb3c06d50f6541ad4f4cb03eab4863709dcae6b056b6986bd2fb7d13e6db8cc","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7f68cae355a23cefbf5788168f4f179d","paperId":"1412.3457","sourceSha256":"20676f4e3561afd9acbd35190e01e0f26752aaa867c5f8dcfb7040f552f4fb53","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7f6408ede5cf529e0acf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"89fb6afbe33a307306f0846ac56328c08f540851daa4a143ecd61197ccf6de78","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0cde3bb93659bdb63acb9845555f1bca151b1096643e616e5deb59a4479f4f55","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e1505366365e332989e4f77a","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The outside probe fits the core. The excerpt describes a 4+1-dimensional gauge/Wilson-loop route under the paper's WGC criterion, not a completed top-down deriv","challengeNote":"The outside probe fits the core. The 4+1-dimensional Wilson-loop route is a conditional EFT construction, not a completed top-down derivation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"7df85b75aeff5288369c22380f24393097d6221f1a805b09e0838e6ee8f900fe"},"organizational-access:d2b3c430cbb57ac191da6a33":{"id":"organizational-access:d2b3c430cbb57ac191da6a33","source":"q025-candidate-question:627ab4c484b22b2e4821484e","target":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:627ab4c484b22b2e4821484e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"50c7c4807a918e127a4f863d0afb45e9f1f273fea0fc476f2b78d2aab05d01fc","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ddcabf5af21b03b939e5e88c"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"4c0909a26dff37b92eb93bf6a0a9404871cf159742d072f1b0a16e064f759e97","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:81de1c02761e160ccff700da"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:cb66dbc130fd54137b3abd2a44ba490ec912d20fa9fe6187b939f612c7504a43","home":{"unitId":"unit:cb66dbc130fd54137b3abd2a44ba490ec912d20fa9fe6187b939f612c7504a43","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:627ab4c484b22b2e4821484e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cb66dbc130fd54137b3abd2a44ba490ec912d20fa9fe6187b939f612c7504a43","paperId":"hep-th/0301073","textSha256":"4917f2a8c594a42833bfdfd686ca99da359cd15c9ad8444d85a6bdc736104fbf"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4f3b8a6d5cd762569d80c0a95efbd777","paperId":"hep-th/0301073","sourceSha256":"1621336ca80089b1ae5ba288adfc4fea2ff8352c1984052fcd017f9ca4bb791b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/87ec9770ad5ae3c452f3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3bdd6e31147ba12c85beb50461697f5a426f427ee997020719f8dfcde7efdd17","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2207,"textSha256":"9a5c767ec48c4958c65eff939405b01627c8516a1d1588db30a38f6232229b89","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cb009ff9d1d1c9ea1ae6235f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cb009ff9d1d1c9ea1ae6235f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cb66dbc130fd54137b3abd2a44ba490ec912d20fa9fe6187b939f612c7504a43","q025-candidate-question:627ab4c484b22b2e4821484e"],"scopeContentSha256":"50c7c4807a918e127a4f863d0afb45e9f1f273fea0fc476f2b78d2aab05d01fc","placementContentSha256":"98c858c888dc79397d2a62c1341d62f0ae8335f991ec6ac79b9f33b0dcd2ea77","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d629bf20b9ba60f8f113-challenge","leaf-d629bf20b9ba60f8f113-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cb66dbc130fd54137b3abd2a44ba490ec912d20fa9fe6187b939f612c7504a43","paperId":"hep-th/0301073","textSha256":"4917f2a8c594a42833bfdfd686ca99da359cd15c9ad8444d85a6bdc736104fbf"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4f3b8a6d5cd762569d80c0a95efbd777","paperId":"hep-th/0301073","sourceSha256":"1621336ca80089b1ae5ba288adfc4fea2ff8352c1984052fcd017f9ca4bb791b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/87ec9770ad5ae3c452f3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3bdd6e31147ba12c85beb50461697f5a426f427ee997020719f8dfcde7efdd17","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2207,"textSha256":"9a5c767ec48c4958c65eff939405b01627c8516a1d1588db30a38f6232229b89","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:cb009ff9d1d1c9ea1ae6235f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cb66dbc130fd54137b3abd2a44ba490ec912d20fa9fe6187b939f612c7504a43","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:cb66dbc130fd54137b3abd2a44ba490ec912d20fa9fe6187b939f612c7504a43","textSha256":"4917f2a8c594a42833bfdfd686ca99da359cd15c9ad8444d85a6bdc736104fbf"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0920aed9a337822fa8100eb8","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Retains the sequence de Sitter, radiation plus positive Λ, then radiation alone. Independent challenge qualification: Preserves the sequence de Sitter, radiation with positive Λ, then radiation alone."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0920aed9a337822fa8100eb8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cb66dbc130fd54137b3abd2a44ba490ec912d20fa9fe6187b939f612c7504a43","q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4c0909a26dff37b92eb93bf6a0a9404871cf159742d072f1b0a16e064f759e97","contributionContentSha256":"3e10687da4f7008822c08954f77f69065512bddbb0b27a3e8bb420e814b6023e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-03d3e9337dac249848d4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-03d3e9337dac249848d4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-03d3e9337dac249848d4-proposal","leaf-03d3e9337dac249848d4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:cb66dbc130fd54137b3abd2a44ba490ec912d20fa9fe6187b939f612c7504a43","textSha256":"4917f2a8c594a42833bfdfd686ca99da359cd15c9ad8444d85a6bdc736104fbf"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0920aed9a337822fa8100eb8","recordId":"leaf-03d3e9337dac249848d4-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-03d3e9337dac249848d4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-03d3e9337dac249848d4-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Retains the sequence de Sitter, radiation plus positive Λ, then radiation alone.","challengeNote":"Preserves the sequence de Sitter, radiation with positive Λ, then radiation alone.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"03ea99884c2d63968d92d66359be9b69b9ea29fc2d74e3c31d43f325fdd7f99d"},"organizational-access:2f90e3b5bd9a44e98e9742c1":{"id":"organizational-access:2f90e3b5bd9a44e98e9742c1","source":"q025-candidate-question:690efd65319fe5597ecdd907","target":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:690efd65319fe5597ecdd907","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"bdd6a7d473169a9e34f827f8b90f463bf0500e59fdfc5cbafdb21020c6bdc9e3","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:01591ad62e3bcceae03dea48"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"bc4d55c0b31819b24d800407c881468951f19c5ed35195b203feba0c0a2d6f23","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:49f7fe9cbc98de691227886e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","home":{"unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:690efd65319fe5597ecdd907","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Directly addresses how the specified scalar-curvature modification changes observables, potential steepness and field excursion under source-local assumptions.","qualification":"q5 directly covers the relation among the curvature modification, observable predictions, steepness and excursion. The inherited inverse-potential ansatz, correlated scans and inflation-only regulator treatment remain local qualifications. No full stability, cutoff, quantum-correction or general compatibility result follows.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","paperId":"1811.01625","textSha256":"80a73b3365e34cd8e871968d68b1ca985059f4145724351bf166a51b899c9ff9"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0024:u16:q5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0024:u16:q5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","q025-candidate-question:690efd65319fe5597ecdd907"],"scopeContentSha256":"bdd6a7d473169a9e34f827f8b90f463bf0500e59fdfc5cbafdb21020c6bdc9e3","placementContentSha256":"7bf8341783e2bbf5ccb0ac42b8e02f9f1dd28f731474856de3ea6bf349f78dc8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0024:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0024:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","paperId":"1811.01625","textSha256":"80a73b3365e34cd8e871968d68b1ca985059f4145724351bf166a51b899c9ff9"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0024","unitRef":"u16"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","textSha256":"80a73b3365e34cd8e871968d68b1ca985059f4145724351bf166a51b899c9ff9"},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d2fca3cc38104829c81d9aec8090ebd4","paperId":"1811.01625","sourceSha256":"6529fbef71ea75b45f40a3e54a8fbde82ab5ffc568ff064eec93185178bddd7d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2398bc28d40fd75502bb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d2f0bdc342b58dcb639a1c2c598f8f9bc6b25874bec5dbf61a22a26cf2c877c9","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":1767,"textSha256":"5d716f4133e917c1d06a31357aee1170a6976759ba458332110de5bc7fd76526","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:afd5ca8b9fcd1cf732fd98fa8e253bb1","paperId":"1811.01625","sourceSha256":"6529fbef71ea75b45f40a3e54a8fbde82ab5ffc568ff064eec93185178bddd7d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2398bc28d40fd75502bb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d2f0bdc342b58dcb639a1c2c598f8f9bc6b25874bec5dbf61a22a26cf2c877c9","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":951,"textSha256":"6792f975501f182e423c90f95c675a35fcf51f506dc45d8b30c61e0e5d5a380b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d49721a0175d75c7114d06f1c56472ec","paperId":"1811.01625","sourceSha256":"6529fbef71ea75b45f40a3e54a8fbde82ab5ffc568ff064eec93185178bddd7d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2398bc28d40fd75502bb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d2f0bdc342b58dcb639a1c2c598f8f9bc6b25874bec5dbf61a22a26cf2c877c9","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1336,"textSha256":"026a3e9c6a4463cf4f6a9cafd02b614f9bddf1aeb416d8ed79b839aa7d9d7fe7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:355b41188087062f826fd989"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:355b41188087062f826fd989","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","q025-candidate-question:644c8088120be9951d8040d7"],"scopeContentSha256":"bc4d55c0b31819b24d800407c881468951f19c5ed35195b203feba0c0a2d6f23","contributionContentSha256":"db4a39fa1ff5c75567f7f6b91b2ff4eaf90ec6ea231fbf435fa7701d3e3769c4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:fabe82b5e57d5aab5222dff868d228184be033c3da2d6310e2bec3e5ca845e0b","textSha256":"80a73b3365e34cd8e871968d68b1ca985059f4145724351bf166a51b899c9ff9"},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d2fca3cc38104829c81d9aec8090ebd4","paperId":"1811.01625","sourceSha256":"6529fbef71ea75b45f40a3e54a8fbde82ab5ffc568ff064eec93185178bddd7d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2398bc28d40fd75502bb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d2f0bdc342b58dcb639a1c2c598f8f9bc6b25874bec5dbf61a22a26cf2c877c9","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":1767,"textSha256":"5d716f4133e917c1d06a31357aee1170a6976759ba458332110de5bc7fd76526","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:afd5ca8b9fcd1cf732fd98fa8e253bb1","paperId":"1811.01625","sourceSha256":"6529fbef71ea75b45f40a3e54a8fbde82ab5ffc568ff064eec93185178bddd7d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2398bc28d40fd75502bb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d2f0bdc342b58dcb639a1c2c598f8f9bc6b25874bec5dbf61a22a26cf2c877c9","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":951,"textSha256":"6792f975501f182e423c90f95c675a35fcf51f506dc45d8b30c61e0e5d5a380b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d49721a0175d75c7114d06f1c56472ec","paperId":"1811.01625","sourceSha256":"6529fbef71ea75b45f40a3e54a8fbde82ab5ffc568ff064eec93185178bddd7d","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2398bc28d40fd75502bb/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d2f0bdc342b58dcb639a1c2c598f8f9bc6b25874bec5dbf61a22a26cf2c877c9","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1336,"textSha256":"026a3e9c6a4463cf4f6a9cafd02b614f9bddf1aeb416d8ed79b839aa7d9d7fe7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:355b41188087062f826fd989","recordId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b826c032aa9fcad09ba2-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Restricted coupling ansatz; the E-model scan co-varies α and λ. Cutoff and complete perturbative stability are not established.","challengeNote":"Restricted inverse-potential coupling; Λ0 is neglected during inflation. The E-model scan co-varies α and λ. Cutoff and full stability are unestablished.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"e0dab224860998aa8750e91b10a52ae22be0a50cca3a183d340619ebab21b4b8"},"organizational-access:095fa834d1713614fdd63151":{"id":"organizational-access:095fa834d1713614fdd63151","source":"q025-candidate-question:6aaa9013e706aa371167686a","target":"q025-candidate-question:8167beb97c0f26ca30868a12","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6aaa9013e706aa371167686a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b37bdd38e7429b64ac5ab1ee36bfe80c6cf00ecbc2315f9a31855f4333fd8138","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b75d8aa31deef0048bdedea5"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8167beb97c0f26ca30868a12","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9492cd17d3b5d1a31512c98091ae6994a5910f5fa73c74d703455de9fbf81e6e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:17bfea84de1f2930f221e1e6"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","home":{"unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6aaa9013e706aa371167686a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly preserves string-cosmology lectures spanning small vacuum energy, inflation, stabilization, potential obstacles, remedies and signatures.","qualification":"q31 explicitly preserves the complete lecture program: small vacuum energy, inflation, stabilization, potential obstacles, remedies and signatures. Its exclusion of a single fine identity for all lecture topics does not exclude the intact composite survey. q29, q18 and q41 omit the independent small-vacuum-energy inquiry. A cosmic-string signature is only one component. Historical force bounds remain dated, and announced coverage does not verify the reviewed remedies.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","textSha256":"6cc987d9a613796846db12afe3b42ec1d89e3de5e94d6605b6c74b14734a1f0b"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:competing:u7:q31"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:competing:u7:q31","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","q025-candidate-question:6aaa9013e706aa371167686a"],"scopeContentSha256":"b37bdd38e7429b64ac5ab1ee36bfe80c6cf00ecbc2315f9a31855f4333fd8138","placementContentSha256":"2b9defb4f0922fe04c64c6196a6cf6438e0d3c27cae95235c148ff5ed5059c18","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:competing:proposal","placement-pilot:competing:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","textSha256":"6cc987d9a613796846db12afe3b42ec1d89e3de5e94d6605b6c74b14734a1f0b"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8167beb97c0f26ca30868a12","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","textSha256":"6cc987d9a613796846db12afe3b42ec1d89e3de5e94d6605b6c74b14734a1f0b"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:479709da7b0565762ae80098e8872263","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":15,"start":0,"end":2393,"textSha256":"d418ffc8c05e0bbae1cf077f9e2d94112db012340a54a83a5779743616202eca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:62f49ee8e8a82ce94588f3b1f2ab2f95","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":796,"textSha256":"54e81229f435c7cea300f012cc56902556fc702f6f63cd4d1da53452403899f7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:97564ff6e8f39bb975ed1d2ce35c5879","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1721,"textSha256":"6851be5b22ec413c1d1bc9adc047e842297468a22d3ec9cd9dd7c30403d7638a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7b6fb4180100c6936df8a5d0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7b6fb4180100c6936df8a5d0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","q025-candidate-question:8167beb97c0f26ca30868a12"],"scopeContentSha256":"9492cd17d3b5d1a31512c98091ae6994a5910f5fa73c74d703455de9fbf81e6e","contributionContentSha256":"eddb9dca6f03a258d6eff5ce9837dc4b91e419e6d9b88e37d52231d135ad485b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:3cef1fb2590aee2936780b41e9adee31c76b5a6b77c279306a97e3f7778e46da","textSha256":"6cc987d9a613796846db12afe3b42ec1d89e3de5e94d6605b6c74b14734a1f0b"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:479709da7b0565762ae80098e8872263","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":15,"start":0,"end":2393,"textSha256":"d418ffc8c05e0bbae1cf077f9e2d94112db012340a54a83a5779743616202eca","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:62f49ee8e8a82ce94588f3b1f2ab2f95","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":796,"textSha256":"54e81229f435c7cea300f012cc56902556fc702f6f63cd4d1da53452403899f7","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:97564ff6e8f39bb975ed1d2ce35c5879","paperId":"hep-th/0612129","sourceSha256":"b928e1970e0663665bf5f1dc6560e8bec2ce19648b0166ee2e740ab17be387dc","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e3b65fa924d85cb29f7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"fdee7d5134b8d428d394a9770af1a7e992ffe2b2f15770d411aa4bc1005d5988","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":1721,"textSha256":"6851be5b22ec413c1d1bc9adc047e842297468a22d3ec9cd9dd7c30403d7638a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7b6fb4180100c6936df8a5d0","recordId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-0c43e24ef1344f8f7623-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound lectures on vacuum energy and inflation; the fifth-force discussion and experimental numbers remain source-era context.","challengeNote":"Compound vacuum-energy and inflation lectures; fifth-force numbers and observational prospects remain source-era context.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"b77a3afd2b17d4373eb59985de16a3187e3930d15673d12172821a89b505fcab"},"organizational-access:5d40d7831e33ae47801837e6":{"id":"organizational-access:5d40d7831e33ae47801837e6","source":"q025-candidate-question:7132aa4b2be087f7baa4cbe6","target":"q025-candidate-question:8b5f26f30de0d7cefebdb35c","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:7132aa4b2be087f7baa4cbe6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"3ea4723661232e9769b43fd1ad6f46816db92fe1e5f7a293832e9fb9ebd40b11","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:85a990fe6700c824bc1ff86b"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8b5f26f30de0d7cefebdb35c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"39cfc1128a73323caad8e7144f46d182027f7666b001dfe9dc615f561cfe77f0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b3e70ec151f204be3d6a3a32"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","home":{"unitId":"unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7132aa4b2be087f7baa4cbe6","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines continuous-parameter restrictions, imported moduli conjectures, distance/tower questions and conditional loop explanations.","qualification":"q10 explicitly combines parameter restrictions, imported moduli conjectures, distance constraints and conditional loop explanations. This covers the whole question without using conditional exponential scaling to establish tower existence or every imported geometric claim. Finite-path turnover, lower-cutoff EFTs and UV input for an axion potential retain their separate inherited qualifications.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","paperId":"1802.08698","textSha256":"6d186b16f6faf92d51c8633122b7da8036ab122b648780b9a3da2bac71087fe1"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0034:u13:q10"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0034:u13:q10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","q025-candidate-question:7132aa4b2be087f7baa4cbe6"],"scopeContentSha256":"3ea4723661232e9769b43fd1ad6f46816db92fe1e5f7a293832e9fb9ebd40b11","placementContentSha256":"f5284e85f2c72706be0ff40da3715d0f0ecb5466144b19a85e69c9128eefbd47","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0034:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0034:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","paperId":"1802.08698","textSha256":"6d186b16f6faf92d51c8633122b7da8036ab122b648780b9a3da2bac71087fe1"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0034","unitRef":"u13"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8b5f26f30de0d7cefebdb35c","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","textSha256":"6d186b16f6faf92d51c8633122b7da8036ab122b648780b9a3da2bac71087fe1"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:085bb3e25637c349cc918d95dccfe03c","paperId":"1802.08698","sourceSha256":"cfa54c1c9eb0267263c0f7e70c18de6c5295128b2c350e1d18c829a0333133e4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6816cb8f1f73044e671f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ca37441de198d36e4ee778ea39a98afcd0e6082f51c373aa6876ecec0a423f8","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"994baeb97b27bd7dd2a87f14ce43d95b57262d4ba6beb90520c5b7a7f7777f10","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:53c4bc6b0064e1b16015a1053c3a37b1","paperId":"1802.08698","sourceSha256":"cfa54c1c9eb0267263c0f7e70c18de6c5295128b2c350e1d18c829a0333133e4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6816cb8f1f73044e671f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ca37441de198d36e4ee778ea39a98afcd0e6082f51c373aa6876ecec0a423f8","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"3c28963bf0aad100960de09262888f7982141e6a54fb3c991d67f2bc51bc1dc7","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:59b9dc80224cc127aa26eefcf329eb74","paperId":"1802.08698","sourceSha256":"cfa54c1c9eb0267263c0f7e70c18de6c5295128b2c350e1d18c829a0333133e4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6816cb8f1f73044e671f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ca37441de198d36e4ee778ea39a98afcd0e6082f51c373aa6876ecec0a423f8","pdfPage":4,"start":2256,"end":4836,"textSha256":"081c1a6329678416b66fb50d1c89e77d356981bbb81d71ba827ca1a7b764eae1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:55f446186f09717179bbc480","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Imported moduli claims remain conjectural; the conditional loop calculation does not establish tower existence or every imported claim. Independent challenge qualification: Imported moduli conjectures and a conditional loop explanation coexist; the calculation does not establish tower existence or every imported claim."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:55f446186f09717179bbc480","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","q025-candidate-question:8b5f26f30de0d7cefebdb35c"],"scopeContentSha256":"39cfc1128a73323caad8e7144f46d182027f7666b001dfe9dc615f561cfe77f0","contributionContentSha256":"26893276034eb5b9ff1dcb4b8e790ff6969fae0872d1de55865cc458d77ab139","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b93dba7f3b569b6b854f-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b93dba7f3b569b6b854f-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b93dba7f3b569b6b854f-proposal","leaf-b93dba7f3b569b6b854f-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:ff332b866853298427a71d1dd90e39cb73c7ce094b1bcda3ae6d72d4bf863a2a","textSha256":"6d186b16f6faf92d51c8633122b7da8036ab122b648780b9a3da2bac71087fe1"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:085bb3e25637c349cc918d95dccfe03c","paperId":"1802.08698","sourceSha256":"cfa54c1c9eb0267263c0f7e70c18de6c5295128b2c350e1d18c829a0333133e4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6816cb8f1f73044e671f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ca37441de198d36e4ee778ea39a98afcd0e6082f51c373aa6876ecec0a423f8","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"994baeb97b27bd7dd2a87f14ce43d95b57262d4ba6beb90520c5b7a7f7777f10","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:53c4bc6b0064e1b16015a1053c3a37b1","paperId":"1802.08698","sourceSha256":"cfa54c1c9eb0267263c0f7e70c18de6c5295128b2c350e1d18c829a0333133e4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6816cb8f1f73044e671f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ca37441de198d36e4ee778ea39a98afcd0e6082f51c373aa6876ecec0a423f8","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"3c28963bf0aad100960de09262888f7982141e6a54fb3c991d67f2bc51bc1dc7","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:59b9dc80224cc127aa26eefcf329eb74","paperId":"1802.08698","sourceSha256":"cfa54c1c9eb0267263c0f7e70c18de6c5295128b2c350e1d18c829a0333133e4","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6816cb8f1f73044e671f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0ca37441de198d36e4ee778ea39a98afcd0e6082f51c373aa6876ecec0a423f8","pdfPage":4,"start":2256,"end":4836,"textSha256":"081c1a6329678416b66fb50d1c89e77d356981bbb81d71ba827ca1a7b764eae1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:55f446186f09717179bbc480","recordId":"leaf-b93dba7f3b569b6b854f-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b93dba7f3b569b6b854f-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b93dba7f3b569b6b854f-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Imported moduli claims remain conjectural; the conditional loop calculation does not establish tower existence or every imported claim.","challengeNote":"Imported moduli conjectures and a conditional loop explanation coexist; the calculation does not establish tower existence or every imported claim.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"5c41da867ba58b20fc79550f077e060ea76fe6276dc9fd244f5e95ebea1b91e1"},"organizational-access:db37a7307e74d552468c6cf8":{"id":"organizational-access:db37a7307e74d552468c6cf8","source":"q025-candidate-question:85dacc632f879fa2520b18e6","target":"q025-candidate-question:9b19a7a3ee8d1dc0a54e2c1c","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:85dacc632f879fa2520b18e6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"15a7d5b6ef5972221c85d504597d5e00ce54bc2d3cb8cfbe9b4c6f5f793340f5","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:996793eda11a7a284d5ab213"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9b19a7a3ee8d1dc0a54e2c1c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"cad90b96d30bf010d885887eb246bc3c1c797501a268af1e7d329ab587d99d6b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3428a7672d1e0c340eabd68f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:6f35e434f8c46dcea2e2daf0ef8ac6a2f789a334107d1b5328c594622777d3d6","home":{"unitId":"unit:6f35e434f8c46dcea2e2daf0ef8ac6a2f789a334107d1b5328c594622777d3d6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:85dacc632f879fa2520b18e6","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q12 explicitly combines candidate quantum definitions, observer-versus-global data, symmetry and S-matrix compatibility, including modified finite-state implementations.","qualification":"q12 explicitly covers holographic definitions, state spaces, symmetry and S-matrix compatibility while distinguishing observer-accessible data from global data. Those provisions include the whole compatibility problem and its obstruction. q16's operational emphasis is less specific to the amplitude and representation targets.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6f35e434f8c46dcea2e2daf0ef8ac6a2f789a334107d1b5328c594622777d3d6","paperId":"hep-th/0410227","textSha256":"7ab975eb51a12a7e08fe412ae6cce488bb77b612661dd008cd4625fe24eb45fe"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0050:u13:q12"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0050:u13:q12","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6f35e434f8c46dcea2e2daf0ef8ac6a2f789a334107d1b5328c594622777d3d6","q025-candidate-question:85dacc632f879fa2520b18e6"],"scopeContentSha256":"15a7d5b6ef5972221c85d504597d5e00ce54bc2d3cb8cfbe9b4c6f5f793340f5","placementContentSha256":"6b0a66da3fade14679ba2aa043291fc6f81ce5afae12e8c4b8a4790b81b0b0fe","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0050:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0050:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6f35e434f8c46dcea2e2daf0ef8ac6a2f789a334107d1b5328c594622777d3d6","paperId":"hep-th/0410227","textSha256":"7ab975eb51a12a7e08fe412ae6cce488bb77b612661dd008cd4625fe24eb45fe"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0050","unitRef":"u13"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:6f35e434f8c46dcea2e2daf0ef8ac6a2f789a334107d1b5328c594622777d3d6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9b19a7a3ee8d1dc0a54e2c1c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:6f35e434f8c46dcea2e2daf0ef8ac6a2f789a334107d1b5328c594622777d3d6","textSha256":"7ab975eb51a12a7e08fe412ae6cce488bb77b612661dd008cd4625fe24eb45fe"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0b473b0487d1cac896016430","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Observer-accessible finiteness is stated; the implementation in the neighboring S-matrix source is not imported. Independent challenge qualification: Observer-accessible finiteness does not inherit the neighboring source's Hamiltonian allowances."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0b473b0487d1cac896016430","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6f35e434f8c46dcea2e2daf0ef8ac6a2f789a334107d1b5328c594622777d3d6","q025-candidate-question:9b19a7a3ee8d1dc0a54e2c1c"],"scopeContentSha256":"cad90b96d30bf010d885887eb246bc3c1c797501a268af1e7d329ab587d99d6b","contributionContentSha256":"b7c7e2c210f2eb9200d4e1956807e98fc5401c74aa99834ad2f0d799698a6619","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:6f35e434f8c46dcea2e2daf0ef8ac6a2f789a334107d1b5328c594622777d3d6","textSha256":"7ab975eb51a12a7e08fe412ae6cce488bb77b612661dd008cd4625fe24eb45fe"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0b473b0487d1cac896016430","recordId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d2d937b717c789635775-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Observer-accessible finiteness is stated; the implementation in the neighboring S-matrix source is not imported.","challengeNote":"Observer-accessible finiteness does not inherit the neighboring source's Hamiltonian allowances.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"e55ba81b0338583fab9c4976a2f81d3b72843e0370df13c2a12ae7b41019e901"},"organizational-access:7c7b268b75b5a338b632a8a6":{"id":"organizational-access:7c7b268b75b5a338b632a8a6","source":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb","target":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6d0c9fd51c5f6983ed3baffb4047622300a4073f1af6fbadfe5f4d17524a003a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8bacc3263afe0c1d15fcec57"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"98599099741cf51a8964f861a3213d784da1a73c893632c783d5bcab7f34e301","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6f9a68dfa977df5abbcfe544"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","home":{"unitId":"unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q13 asks for both metric and supporting-field expectation values over an appropriate reference configuration and explicitly rejects metric matching as sufficient.","qualification":"The entire source asks for a state realization of a metric and its supporting fields with a particular reference configuration. These are explicit q13 targets and assumptions. Neither an inherited scalar surrogate nor metric prefactor matching is treated as completion of that construction.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","paperId":"2211.09181","textSha256":"04762b21ba58ec08c65509bfdf1d61880d28543631bda5ff2aa12cd3e159ca4e"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0050:u6:q13"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0050:u6:q13","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","q025-candidate-question:8ca6e2eb7d56068e728258cb"],"scopeContentSha256":"6d0c9fd51c5f6983ed3baffb4047622300a4073f1af6fbadfe5f4d17524a003a","placementContentSha256":"92b4f27ac7a8fb68c24f5a28eb312074fc9e36e3311a08560d08c240202ca5c6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0050:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0050:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","paperId":"2211.09181","textSha256":"04762b21ba58ec08c65509bfdf1d61880d28543631bda5ff2aa12cd3e159ca4e"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0050","unitRef":"u6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","qualification":"The specified warped target represented as an excitation specializes background interpretation. Metric-prefactor matching does not construct the state or supporting fields; the surrogate mentioned in inherited graph context is not a full tensor derivation. Independent confirmation: u22's specified excitation representation specializes c4's background interpretation. Its static soliton and evolving supporting fields remain distinct, and metric matching is not promoted to a constructed state or full tensor calculation.","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u22","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","textSha256":"04762b21ba58ec08c65509bfdf1d61880d28543631bda5ff2aa12cd3e159ca4e","paperId":"2211.09181"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:role:3"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:navigation-v2:de-sitter-organization:role:3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0"],"challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"de-sitter-organization-navigation-proposal","challengeReviewId":"de-sitter-organization-navigation-independent-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["de-sitter-organization-navigation-proposal","de-sitter-organization-navigation-independent-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u22","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","textSha256":"04762b21ba58ec08c65509bfdf1d61880d28543631bda5ff2aa12cd3e159ca4e","paperId":"2211.09181"}],"originalRole":{"unitRef":"u22","questionRef":"c4","role":"specializes","reason":"The specified warped target represented as an excitation specializes background interpretation. Metric-prefactor matching does not construct the state or supporting fields; the surrogate mentioned in inherited graph context is not a full tensor derivation.","refs":["u22","n30","c4"]},"independentAssessment":{"index":3,"verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"u22's specified excitation representation specializes c4's background interpretation. Its static soliton and evolving supporting fields remain distinct, and metric matching is not promoted to a constructed state or full tensor calculation.","refs":["u22","n30","c4"]},"contextRefs":[{"localRef":"n30","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:96c024fef7380172323385c7a838496e21ebbdb4b9c3db113f68e9bcd46e8fdd","reviewId":"leaf-9256206ee3dfc1044991-challenge","notPrimary":true},{"localRef":"c4","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-0dd2c748860e78df66b5-challenge:p0","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:f3e94d63ca3765fb7aaec3a0"}],"scopeContentSha256":"98599099741cf51a8964f861a3213d784da1a73c893632c783d5bcab7f34e301","contributionContentSha256":"6a3c1dd7e8b90210bf6df21ba909db3e2c05540835536f81e9012a96e746def8","coordinatorAdmissionReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/navigation-admissions-v2/de-sitter-organization-admission.json","sha256":"c12872cf2304168f663092654b4ae34f66023591718d507dc468ac34110a58ac"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"17e70f2b4e9c7e687934c004f44acb0b6656b66beeb178861d54f8c522553e82"},"organizational-access:b2e42d8fea93360299b0c76a":{"id":"organizational-access:b2e42d8fea93360299b0c76a","source":"q025-candidate-question:90c6a4ba70476b8396840aeb","target":"q025-candidate-question:95efbbed52217cca63129bce","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:90c6a4ba70476b8396840aeb","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"03155dc7eef0ae928d0f779f84976a2858c7eb63fd8d621780bd1730421cf8e9","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:9374dbe5d7eb1f87d1c004f0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:95efbbed52217cca63129bce","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"3983fac7fb545196ef7b26cd2de5350399fb0aeac1bdf170bc250d48fd794917","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:9fe72e100b281d099578ee0f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:24b35bb9969fc7fd1aff5005d2441eb27e74bb6edb0b61512b190d9f1b939400","home":{"unitId":"unit:24b35bb9969fc7fd1aff5005d2441eb27e74bb6edb0b61512b190d9f1b939400","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:90c6a4ba70476b8396840aeb","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q13 explicitly includes dS₂ Schwinger current beyond heavy-particle semiclassics and persistent dependence on initial conditions.","qualification":"q13 contains the dS₂ current, the beyond-heavy-particle regime and the requested symmetry, tunneling and memory interpretations of that response. Current is not identified with a universal pair-production rate, and no invariant state is presumed.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:24b35bb9969fc7fd1aff5005d2441eb27e74bb6edb0b61512b190d9f1b939400","paperId":"1401.4137","textSha256":"4025ca2cf392468803138ac1e4e0161c214d76609c67fd51eaf34206ea7efa25"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0067:u17:q13"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0067:u17:q13","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:24b35bb9969fc7fd1aff5005d2441eb27e74bb6edb0b61512b190d9f1b939400","q025-candidate-question:90c6a4ba70476b8396840aeb"],"scopeContentSha256":"03155dc7eef0ae928d0f779f84976a2858c7eb63fd8d621780bd1730421cf8e9","placementContentSha256":"304bf8e800a93e668c603a2999e0b14056a00cb48f4928b78f6ed76e9e17aaff","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0067:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0067:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:24b35bb9969fc7fd1aff5005d2441eb27e74bb6edb0b61512b190d9f1b939400","paperId":"1401.4137","textSha256":"4025ca2cf392468803138ac1e4e0161c214d76609c67fd51eaf34206ea7efa25"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0067","unitRef":"u17"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:24b35bb9969fc7fd1aff5005d2441eb27e74bb6edb0b61512b190d9f1b939400","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:95efbbed52217cca63129bce","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:24b35bb9969fc7fd1aff5005d2441eb27e74bb6edb0b61512b190d9f1b939400","textSha256":"4025ca2cf392468803138ac1e4e0161c214d76609c67fd51eaf34206ea7efa25"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f0a9673a54c4afe8323be214","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The current, de Sitter invariance and initial-condition memory are the targets; no heavy-particle restriction is imposed. Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f0a9673a54c4afe8323be214","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:24b35bb9969fc7fd1aff5005d2441eb27e74bb6edb0b61512b190d9f1b939400","q025-candidate-question:95efbbed52217cca63129bce"],"scopeContentSha256":"3983fac7fb545196ef7b26cd2de5350399fb0aeac1bdf170bc250d48fd794917","contributionContentSha256":"c713cecc7ce8eed438fa2b94983b34e419adad46dbb125278952510e271f57f6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-proposal","leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:24b35bb9969fc7fd1aff5005d2441eb27e74bb6edb0b61512b190d9f1b939400","textSha256":"4025ca2cf392468803138ac1e4e0161c214d76609c67fd51eaf34206ea7efa25"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f0a9673a54c4afe8323be214","recordId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9aec4ca94b068f477af8-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"The current, de Sitter invariance and initial-condition memory are the targets; no heavy-particle restriction is imposed.","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"1757549e1482e17e21cbf0b564b0df2e8be3e38fe34d612c19d23a0f5d27eda6"},"organizational-access:0fdd604c3ebcc9c15e065957":{"id":"organizational-access:0fdd604c3ebcc9c15e065957","source":"q025-candidate-question:9482bf4645e085c1fc149f73","target":"q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9482bf4645e085c1fc149f73","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9dae8f75f83462b5b036f0423c4beae8cd73ee43bee20f12570d05de1dbe78ef","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c21be9879b062db3689c1a47"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6734fbe04f2387de13aad723a0e31051d7d28b96e70ae827863c809ca052b2f6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8beddc9f8b4587b287fbe3c6"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4aee9fc2aea5ea6480d227ce3135d0be205e7c4dd954abcfd3a06b88ade1365c","home":{"unitId":"unit:4aee9fc2aea5ea6480d227ce3135d0be205e7c4dd954abcfd3a06b88ade1365c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9482bf4645e085c1fc149f73","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines brane reconstruction of scale-separated vacua with decoupling from unusual asymptotic geometries.","qualification":"q10 expressly combines reconstruction and decoupling while allowing scale-separated candidates and unusual asymptotic geometries. The ten-dimensional geometry and asymptotic blueshift remain conditions of the source. Successful near-horizon matching would not itself settle the separate decoupling question.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4aee9fc2aea5ea6480d227ce3135d0be205e7c4dd954abcfd3a06b88ade1365c","paperId":"2601.15093","textSha256":"eb939d25a6821d963facb849b0b71db196fd823c2d602df9cbdeff58ca36940b"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0046:u23:q10"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0046:u23:q10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4aee9fc2aea5ea6480d227ce3135d0be205e7c4dd954abcfd3a06b88ade1365c","q025-candidate-question:9482bf4645e085c1fc149f73"],"scopeContentSha256":"9dae8f75f83462b5b036f0423c4beae8cd73ee43bee20f12570d05de1dbe78ef","placementContentSha256":"2d17314c0af083ce45c3a022e7fd6ac3db22aa981d93d55eab55aeb170a0a99e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0046:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0046:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4aee9fc2aea5ea6480d227ce3135d0be205e7c4dd954abcfd3a06b88ade1365c","paperId":"2601.15093","textSha256":"eb939d25a6821d963facb849b0b71db196fd823c2d602df9cbdeff58ca36940b"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0046","unitRef":"u23"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4aee9fc2aea5ea6480d227ce3135d0be205e7c4dd954abcfd3a06b88ade1365c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d65","kind":"description","unitIndex":65,"unitId":"unit:4aee9fc2aea5ea6480d227ce3135d0be205e7c4dd954abcfd3a06b88ade1365c","textSha256":"eb939d25a6821d963facb849b0b71db196fd823c2d602df9cbdeff58ca36940b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:abb706f1c7ef6a166a8bd7b9"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:abb706f1c7ef6a166a8bd7b9","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4aee9fc2aea5ea6480d227ce3135d0be205e7c4dd954abcfd3a06b88ade1365c","q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c"],"scopeContentSha256":"6734fbe04f2387de13aad723a0e31051d7d28b96e70ae827863c809ca052b2f6","contributionContentSha256":"06c4b2e7459d26c2679a17ccd414c8b6c74845f1280d942ab6f59dadc037a24b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d65","kind":"description","unitIndex":65,"unitId":"unit:4aee9fc2aea5ea6480d227ce3135d0be205e7c4dd954abcfd3a06b88ade1365c","textSha256":"eb939d25a6821d963facb849b0b71db196fd823c2d602df9cbdeff58ca36940b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:abb706f1c7ef6a166a8bd7b9","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Near-horizon reconstruction and decoupling despite asymptotic blueshift are distinct claims.","challengeNote":"Compound near-horizon reconstruction and decoupling despite asymptotic blueshift.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"b07c95e658cde9c116eb174093bd65e2b53625684492ec3a39ab97234c293cb6"},"organizational-access:c36ad0f7f636c432d7ee61c4":{"id":"organizational-access:c36ad0f7f636c432d7ee61c4","source":"q025-candidate-question:a7f02a40bbc535293336ef21","target":"q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a7f02a40bbc535293336ef21","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1ca027ca282a7d9f8e5588df589ed2e847286e6ba1896de3139808f0e2f5c2b2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:7a821e24d85139f3056ca217"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"5b36fcc6054f22dabed9d8808ec44a1107c01f10a602951db0ef2cda23b889c4","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:878c94f8bafbac542388bfbc"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:35bfd5270623ff6b30cb39a3f313cf642ff2a6822d8deb7bf616dd88173136e2","home":{"unitId":"unit:35bfd5270623ff6b30cb39a3f313cf642ff2a6822d8deb7bf616dd88173136e2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a7f02a40bbc535293336ef21","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers gauge-modified scalar inflation, anisotropic attractors, slow-roll destabilization and transitions between the stated regimes.","qualification":"q11 includes gauge-modified scalar systems, anisotropic backgrounds and source-specific slow-roll and turning regimes. It covers attractors, destabilization and the transition between both phases without substituting a scalar-only geometry problem or asserting complete perturbative stability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:35bfd5270623ff6b30cb39a3f313cf642ff2a6822d8deb7bf616dd88173136e2","paperId":"2106.04813","textSha256":"0a236b56990a6f6f5bcde3345993c45fec8a9965038a7a0c2de5d3c4e49ce141"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0024:u18:q11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0024:u18:q11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:35bfd5270623ff6b30cb39a3f313cf642ff2a6822d8deb7bf616dd88173136e2","q025-candidate-question:a7f02a40bbc535293336ef21"],"scopeContentSha256":"1ca027ca282a7d9f8e5588df589ed2e847286e6ba1896de3139808f0e2f5c2b2","placementContentSha256":"356c146e2a63f61940c4cada263ea7e4c9e988a9d2576d84d322767b76caa420","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0024:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0024:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:35bfd5270623ff6b30cb39a3f313cf642ff2a6822d8deb7bf616dd88173136e2","paperId":"2106.04813","textSha256":"0a236b56990a6f6f5bcde3345993c45fec8a9965038a7a0c2de5d3c4e49ce141"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0024","unitRef":"u18"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:35bfd5270623ff6b30cb39a3f313cf642ff2a6822d8deb7bf616dd88173136e2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:35bfd5270623ff6b30cb39a3f313cf642ff2a6822d8deb7bf616dd88173136e2","textSha256":"0a236b56990a6f6f5bcde3345993c45fec8a9965038a7a0c2de5d3c4e49ce141"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:294b481939ac3751310c63b2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:294b481939ac3751310c63b2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:35bfd5270623ff6b30cb39a3f313cf642ff2a6822d8deb7bf616dd88173136e2","q025-candidate-question:cf0edc500f72f14549b02c65"],"scopeContentSha256":"5b36fcc6054f22dabed9d8808ec44a1107c01f10a602951db0ef2cda23b889c4","contributionContentSha256":"aa0167a97fb6d9d65fdf382d3bcd464636c61fee0dd575b32e9b5faf828d25a2","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:35bfd5270623ff6b30cb39a3f313cf642ff2a6822d8deb7bf616dd88173136e2","textSha256":"0a236b56990a6f6f5bcde3345993c45fec8a9965038a7a0c2de5d3c4e49ce141"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:294b481939ac3751310c63b2","recordId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f4bd79c6fc317999d078-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Transitions connect anisotropic slow-roll and anisotropic hyperbolic phases.","challengeNote":"The transitions connect anisotropic slow-roll and anisotropic hyperbolic phases.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"5538d1b802ad8e8d5251b97351936ac0ca495ca0bb9d4ffc700c01ac1fedd1d4"},"organizational-access:bb6679376052282a4eb18c70":{"id":"organizational-access:bb6679376052282a4eb18c70","source":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6","target":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"adb5d31dd329431521ed5321fd138dbfb86e5c2aaeebab9116b92f32e0b1e624","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c662c02e180fa7532a16ecc9"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5fe049038e0d09e39d73d407"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:31271d7dfca4fe764442d0aa4e4801816261e32a4eae883b87aef7d1e0748704","home":{"unitId":"unit:31271d7dfca4fe764442d0aa4e4801816261e32a4eae883b87aef7d1e0748704","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:31271d7dfca4fe764442d0aa4e4801816261e32a4eae883b87aef7d1e0748704","paperId":"1812.10448","textSha256":"46967abe82722ab57afa4eb107002cf3fcc6138b5c3169cce29d31ab176ee940"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d70c479665a7e06fa48c9925"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d70c479665a7e06fa48c9925","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:31271d7dfca4fe764442d0aa4e4801816261e32a4eae883b87aef7d1e0748704","q025-candidate-question:b3160206dff6f0006b81a9a6"],"scopeContentSha256":"adb5d31dd329431521ed5321fd138dbfb86e5c2aaeebab9116b92f32e0b1e624","placementContentSha256":"aadfbb6cd171c7d46b036f8288419eb8043ca5acaeffc70027d94ba3ba6cab4e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-challenge","leaf-e983c122c2a533d08364-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:31271d7dfca4fe764442d0aa4e4801816261e32a4eae883b87aef7d1e0748704","paperId":"1812.10448","textSha256":"46967abe82722ab57afa4eb107002cf3fcc6138b5c3169cce29d31ab176ee940"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d70c479665a7e06fa48c9925"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:31271d7dfca4fe764442d0aa4e4801816261e32a4eae883b87aef7d1e0748704","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:31271d7dfca4fe764442d0aa4e4801816261e32a4eae883b87aef7d1e0748704","textSha256":"46967abe82722ab57afa4eb107002cf3fcc6138b5c3169cce29d31ab176ee940"},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:acc29faeeec2c431d6076c6e35b9da06","paperId":"1812.10448","sourceSha256":"f0e6f0f58224e9b57769815010eb0be845b93daedd1f928dda60caf85afcee8c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1bfe7d04b0ec51271346/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4169355a7cb7d803ef87796c61534bc08a5e159400a33126cb32019b6604e6d6","pdfPage":4,"start":2746,"end":5746,"textSha256":"bf584b4be2ea46cdfa0f18db7885bf868afd5a975b563cf7a8d5ce357bc12ecb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:69011dae2d07b235b4f11ce120a326b3","paperId":"1812.10448","sourceSha256":"f0e6f0f58224e9b57769815010eb0be845b93daedd1f928dda60caf85afcee8c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1bfe7d04b0ec51271346/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4169355a7cb7d803ef87796c61534bc08a5e159400a33126cb32019b6604e6d6","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f5a58fed517aaefefa306034fde0ad558e3ba8af0a70240329a3e50ff6e9d73f","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d25c0bd459f625260793deec57c83a29","paperId":"1812.10448","sourceSha256":"f0e6f0f58224e9b57769815010eb0be845b93daedd1f928dda60caf85afcee8c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1bfe7d04b0ec51271346/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4169355a7cb7d803ef87796c61534bc08a5e159400a33126cb32019b6604e6d6","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"e5e453113e7a405a88ee2ba759368b8424c115d038736362816f6c5bea20fece","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8c74c8ec03b2f195c0b704c4"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8c74c8ec03b2f195c0b704c4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:31271d7dfca4fe764442d0aa4e4801816261e32a4eae883b87aef7d1e0748704","q025-candidate-question:44fd49b316e006e104752b0b"],"scopeContentSha256":"64879106d61ae829d8b351d918b33e8ab15c9ff0e5cf1ef238b0d5dad382f3df","contributionContentSha256":"cbbc0ea9c37f2628d52eece97fc803810df7a1c372206220dba5489b09ea3a72","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:31271d7dfca4fe764442d0aa4e4801816261e32a4eae883b87aef7d1e0748704","textSha256":"46967abe82722ab57afa4eb107002cf3fcc6138b5c3169cce29d31ab176ee940"},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:acc29faeeec2c431d6076c6e35b9da06","paperId":"1812.10448","sourceSha256":"f0e6f0f58224e9b57769815010eb0be845b93daedd1f928dda60caf85afcee8c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1bfe7d04b0ec51271346/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4169355a7cb7d803ef87796c61534bc08a5e159400a33126cb32019b6604e6d6","pdfPage":4,"start":2746,"end":5746,"textSha256":"bf584b4be2ea46cdfa0f18db7885bf868afd5a975b563cf7a8d5ce357bc12ecb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:69011dae2d07b235b4f11ce120a326b3","paperId":"1812.10448","sourceSha256":"f0e6f0f58224e9b57769815010eb0be845b93daedd1f928dda60caf85afcee8c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1bfe7d04b0ec51271346/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4169355a7cb7d803ef87796c61534bc08a5e159400a33126cb32019b6604e6d6","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"f5a58fed517aaefefa306034fde0ad558e3ba8af0a70240329a3e50ff6e9d73f","quoteExactInPage":false,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d25c0bd459f625260793deec57c83a29","paperId":"1812.10448","sourceSha256":"f0e6f0f58224e9b57769815010eb0be845b93daedd1f928dda60caf85afcee8c","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1bfe7d04b0ec51271346/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4169355a7cb7d803ef87796c61534bc08a5e159400a33126cb32019b6604e6d6","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"e5e453113e7a405a88ee2ba759368b8424c115d038736362816f6c5bea20fece","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8c74c8ec03b2f195c0b704c4","recordId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a425570e0e4ae58f03ce-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"The outside probe is a central observational benchmark. Exponential/cosine fits and nonparametric excursion reconstruction retain different priors and reporting","challengeNote":"A central observational benchmark. Parametric potential fits and nonparametric excursion reconstruction retain different priors and reporting intervals.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"fe1bd49a91d54e4aa0a04412929fc376360fc7972703ed25c15c03de19d58f44"},"organizational-access:f530972fd341467ea8208d16":{"id":"organizational-access:f530972fd341467ea8208d16","source":"q025-candidate-question:ba6c0c8b7e3685cf8d7246d8","target":"q025-candidate-question:cb74228797122ebbfc57da6e","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ba6c0c8b7e3685cf8d7246d8","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"35addf49bbfcbf26d81bc73796b34ccf66f44790a01b09829211a476c3b58556","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:24c739bde14efc9f29cd8c1c"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:cb74228797122ebbfc57da6e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"15e3e1304eaa15e78c4ed6abe2bf62be7751159ddafae790866a4151831e97b8","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:4fb5692afedb27270bb2164c"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","home":{"unitId":"unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ba6c0c8b7e3685cf8d7246d8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q15 covers gauge ranks and actual groups together with tests of proposed string realization and explicitly keeps the String Lamppost Principle conjectural.","qualification":"q15 covers rank gaps, allowed actual groups and the additional string-realization interpretation in one question. Cobordism triviality and anomaly reduction remain conditional ingredients in the sixteen-supercharge setting; support for the String Lamppost Principle is neither assumed nor upgraded to landscape completeness.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","paperId":"2008.11729","textSha256":"654ff54ad060a9b4b335bb0599e729935f07999e66fbdc9a1bb95ac9db034d97"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0011:u20:q15"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0011:u20:q15","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","q025-candidate-question:ba6c0c8b7e3685cf8d7246d8"],"scopeContentSha256":"35addf49bbfcbf26d81bc73796b34ccf66f44790a01b09829211a476c3b58556","placementContentSha256":"2bc3b6a550c80d3382ca1ceed2edef4d722e4f5faa74695a205fd5cd0b041d98","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0011:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0011:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","paperId":"2008.11729","textSha256":"654ff54ad060a9b4b335bb0599e729935f07999e66fbdc9a1bb95ac9db034d97"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0011","unitRef":"u20"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cb74228797122ebbfc57da6e","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","textSha256":"654ff54ad060a9b4b335bb0599e729935f07999e66fbdc9a1bb95ac9db034d97"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:19d4305b31d2f4bad7cf954725b6a699","paperId":"2008.11729","sourceSha256":"83ecafb35d0b33c0a811b38aa377ff4e63aff19e9f898e376000137ef8bffa62","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4122b504c4172c55c820/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e8991f065dadbbbc65b8b3f665e42426772325435779ca89f655aba8677c0e58","pdfPage":3,"start":1301,"end":3448,"textSha256":"19abfb302f3d132fe6ea6c1c7754c9dc4ea0162fc47d80077e4e5494b118cda5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:34cb6be42a15e5f8d6d880b219496990","paperId":"2008.11729","sourceSha256":"83ecafb35d0b33c0a811b38aa377ff4e63aff19e9f898e376000137ef8bffa62","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4122b504c4172c55c820/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e8991f065dadbbbc65b8b3f665e42426772325435779ca89f655aba8677c0e58","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2744,"textSha256":"461b6358a995e26154665cbdecbce5aa0b17abe193bab4a638232a885e2f7ced","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f8528193f4b962dd6ab88d45069daf18","paperId":"2008.11729","sourceSha256":"83ecafb35d0b33c0a811b38aa377ff4e63aff19e9f898e376000137ef8bffa62","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4122b504c4172c55c820/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e8991f065dadbbbc65b8b3f665e42426772325435779ca89f655aba8677c0e58","pdfPage":3,"start":102,"end":3448,"textSha256":"8d8f97159ed5e92baea28b300ffb83db436a7f2f4f4216fa09471acdb1f9749a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f123a47a974c66e83b97e787"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f123a47a974c66e83b97e787","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","q025-candidate-question:cb74228797122ebbfc57da6e"],"scopeContentSha256":"15e3e1304eaa15e78c4ed6abe2bf62be7751159ddafae790866a4151831e97b8","contributionContentSha256":"ca43541d222c1bc0c8686abd6f2c68f6436dbd183907739e6d47e238e46c670e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-b8dbfc8337c221a90ad1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b8dbfc8337c221a90ad1-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-b8dbfc8337c221a90ad1-proposal","leaf-b8dbfc8337c221a90ad1-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:7d641420fb63941dc9111674214a25d34c04f7ad0618cffe44c6bd8f843ea469","textSha256":"654ff54ad060a9b4b335bb0599e729935f07999e66fbdc9a1bb95ac9db034d97"},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:19d4305b31d2f4bad7cf954725b6a699","paperId":"2008.11729","sourceSha256":"83ecafb35d0b33c0a811b38aa377ff4e63aff19e9f898e376000137ef8bffa62","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4122b504c4172c55c820/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e8991f065dadbbbc65b8b3f665e42426772325435779ca89f655aba8677c0e58","pdfPage":3,"start":1301,"end":3448,"textSha256":"19abfb302f3d132fe6ea6c1c7754c9dc4ea0162fc47d80077e4e5494b118cda5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:34cb6be42a15e5f8d6d880b219496990","paperId":"2008.11729","sourceSha256":"83ecafb35d0b33c0a811b38aa377ff4e63aff19e9f898e376000137ef8bffa62","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4122b504c4172c55c820/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e8991f065dadbbbc65b8b3f665e42426772325435779ca89f655aba8677c0e58","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2744,"textSha256":"461b6358a995e26154665cbdecbce5aa0b17abe193bab4a638232a885e2f7ced","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f8528193f4b962dd6ab88d45069daf18","paperId":"2008.11729","sourceSha256":"83ecafb35d0b33c0a811b38aa377ff4e63aff19e9f898e376000137ef8bffa62","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4122b504c4172c55c820/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e8991f065dadbbbc65b8b3f665e42426772325435779ca89f655aba8677c0e58","pdfPage":3,"start":102,"end":3448,"textSha256":"8d8f97159ed5e92baea28b300ffb83db436a7f2f4f4216fa09471acdb1f9749a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f123a47a974c66e83b97e787","recordId":"leaf-b8dbfc8337c221a90ad1-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-b8dbfc8337c221a90ad1-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-b8dbfc8337c221a90ad1-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Rank, global-form and lamppost targets are compound. The conditional I-fold/anomaly argument does not prove landscape completeness.","challengeNote":"Rank, global-form and lamppost targets are compound. Conditional I-fold/anomaly arguments support restricted tests, not landscape completeness.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a7dcd3cf5883e9aa36b331e9396e6a694b6f150b4d140b4f4dcf713a27ec5330"},"organizational-access:95b937a94d09c99561a3460c":{"id":"organizational-access:95b937a94d09c99561a3460c","source":"q025-candidate-question:c62054cbd3f53ee7d55fb5dc","target":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c62054cbd3f53ee7d55fb5dc","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"1c302afcd544d554d26372752a2997aee2325b2b5370361a574186f76f898bd8","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:bf52914c7c3b3febc18c00fc"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"8b152b0159ec18b695139265318c907f9566cf0589732d73e690bbbbf26732cb","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f39059e5b17194135fe2f408"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","home":{"unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c62054cbd3f53ee7d55fb5dc","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers supersymmetric stronger-QCD histories reconciling inflation, suppressed isocurvature and axions constituting all dark matter, with distinct inflationary and present axion scales.","qualification":"q11 jointly covers the supersymmetric model, high-scale inflationary compatibility, all-dark-matter abundance and suppressed isocurvature through the specified stronger-QCD history. Inflationary axion normalization and subsequent suppression remain distinct ingredients.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","textSha256":"cfc48717a6a3c3f04dd4b500b0739b1dd611a94ff9e3bce707f319b5afa78b72"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u0:q11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u0:q11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","q025-candidate-question:c62054cbd3f53ee7d55fb5dc"],"scopeContentSha256":"1c302afcd544d554d26372752a2997aee2325b2b5370361a574186f76f898bd8","placementContentSha256":"59703f1018299f5e27ee309c5530f49b1ea3f6c80725dd3113ea3a842d8f6b01","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:coverage:proposal","placement-pilot:coverage:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","textSha256":"cfc48717a6a3c3f04dd4b500b0739b1dd611a94ff9e3bce707f319b5afa78b72"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d85","kind":"description","unitIndex":85,"unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","textSha256":"cfc48717a6a3c3f04dd4b500b0739b1dd611a94ff9e3bce707f319b5afa78b72"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:928a16324b03bde78d21b59f0b31f4d5","paperId":"1505.00306","sourceSha256":"e703b456fa7a4c820e6c26728498c0f75b17489b3ed4e51d6fb99c11663bb33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f86fa9c83484e648a275/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e7ddbe419c17a4419e18d1f58fbc83a450baa3d3cd5a5930b55baefd2e1bb7d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"d0491254ad0e5b0c839109660916ca48cca51d8a9c8e403dfa22e4353751d28a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ba09a28e19c5d96fb916a8af467e73ed","paperId":"1505.00306","sourceSha256":"e703b456fa7a4c820e6c26728498c0f75b17489b3ed4e51d6fb99c11663bb33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f86fa9c83484e648a275/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e7ddbe419c17a4419e18d1f58fbc83a450baa3d3cd5a5930b55baefd2e1bb7d","pdfPage":2,"start":1293,"end":4696,"textSha256":"d428bf503890d3a72bd4ed4521fd93387e5ac20578683b3e3080e5d48b665a34","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f5f0d5a3142d4ad0445ae1f0","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The May 2015 v2 proposal suppresses fluctuations after primordial inflation using stronger QCD and a larger inflationary axion scale; its observational bounds  Independent challenge qualification: May 2015 v2 combines a larger inflationary scale for the axion with later stronger-QCD fluctuation suppression; observational bounds remain source-dated."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f5f0d5a3142d4ad0445ae1f0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","q025-candidate-question:ada26176644ca826674f56a4"],"scopeContentSha256":"8b152b0159ec18b695139265318c907f9566cf0589732d73e690bbbbf26732cb","contributionContentSha256":"35fdad438af120e83e14eeb95e53e7bc3ccd1883557855c9be62adcbc9be6ce9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d85","kind":"description","unitIndex":85,"unitId":"unit:09eb55dfeaed962161991c90f507624ee4b29c4e9c4d36707e567de9ec8dc35b","textSha256":"cfc48717a6a3c3f04dd4b500b0739b1dd611a94ff9e3bce707f319b5afa78b72"},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:928a16324b03bde78d21b59f0b31f4d5","paperId":"1505.00306","sourceSha256":"e703b456fa7a4c820e6c26728498c0f75b17489b3ed4e51d6fb99c11663bb33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f86fa9c83484e648a275/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e7ddbe419c17a4419e18d1f58fbc83a450baa3d3cd5a5930b55baefd2e1bb7d","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"d0491254ad0e5b0c839109660916ca48cca51d8a9c8e403dfa22e4353751d28a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ba09a28e19c5d96fb916a8af467e73ed","paperId":"1505.00306","sourceSha256":"e703b456fa7a4c820e6c26728498c0f75b17489b3ed4e51d6fb99c11663bb33e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f86fa9c83484e648a275/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0e7ddbe419c17a4419e18d1f58fbc83a450baa3d3cd5a5930b55baefd2e1bb7d","pdfPage":2,"start":1293,"end":4696,"textSha256":"d428bf503890d3a72bd4ed4521fd93387e5ac20578683b3e3080e5d48b665a34","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f5f0d5a3142d4ad0445ae1f0","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The May 2015 v2 proposal suppresses fluctuations after primordial inflation using stronger QCD and a larger inflationary axion scale; its observational bounds ","challengeNote":"May 2015 v2 combines a larger inflationary scale for the axion with later stronger-QCD fluctuation suppression; observational bounds remain source-dated.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"f44c5a5d6f4b99361beb19c50424ef6ebc76054146d463f342c473686c8cb062"},"organizational-access:fdff4fb3257ddbfefb9d7f66":{"id":"organizational-access:fdff4fb3257ddbfefb9d7f66","source":"q025-candidate-question:ce879b7bedfc19489460b0f6","target":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ce879b7bedfc19489460b0f6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7cfbcb82b597338a887cd0f268575bbcef9fba749271efe0b55db5dcab394034","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:85a50485d29c016a02e63831"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"17b23896f033122b211a50ba05a1ebc085f18313a14253c55e252acf4c19192d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c3f798add8babb51f45edf05"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","home":{"unitId":"unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ce879b7bedfc19489460b0f6","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Specifically combines fixed-variable entropy response, conditional positivity, EFT coefficient bounds and WGC interpretations.","qualification":"q14 combines the fixed-mass-and-charge positivity question with coefficient restrictions, extremality response and conditional WGC interpretation. Stability, dominant massive-field tree contributions, the EFT window and the visible static-horizon restriction remain local conditions. A positive charge-to-mass extremality shift is not a positive fixed-charge mass shift.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","paperId":"1801.08546","textSha256":"53940ab369e1a6acaf063913e4a2922acb26adc0dc0d8d0647ce07d09b7284e5"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0021:u17:q14"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0021:u17:q14","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","q025-candidate-question:ce879b7bedfc19489460b0f6"],"scopeContentSha256":"7cfbcb82b597338a887cd0f268575bbcef9fba749271efe0b55db5dcab394034","placementContentSha256":"d3e292913a1b7aa538211326cc8e9cdff88ae64d6b98a3c47778f2066d651004","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0021:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0021:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","paperId":"1801.08546","textSha256":"53940ab369e1a6acaf063913e4a2922acb26adc0dc0d8d0647ce07d09b7284e5"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0021","unitRef":"u17"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d97","kind":"description","unitIndex":97,"unitId":"unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","textSha256":"53940ab369e1a6acaf063913e4a2922acb26adc0dc0d8d0647ce07d09b7284e5"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:66d59273157c2c3e9b72b0c79027a516","paperId":"1801.08546","sourceSha256":"7ca02cf7843ca44e97561a7f5b3aaa4dc4c7d6d767690d400dbc3a03bfc7488b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fa10646cae02d99a5074/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39bf11d378e7dcb060e1e5e8cc331ef71b14a8fa7b26680fd3d64c0ba7c172bc","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"043be5c6cfd0ce826b40066ae4cd5aa058b3459e850bfa45542a538886e3e9b8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cd9c051a6bd68be33f9e094fe91d212e","paperId":"1801.08546","sourceSha256":"7ca02cf7843ca44e97561a7f5b3aaa4dc4c7d6d767690d400dbc3a03bfc7488b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fa10646cae02d99a5074/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39bf11d378e7dcb060e1e5e8cc331ef71b14a8fa7b26680fd3d64c0ba7c172bc","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2535,"textSha256":"1349a31248efeafc128f4afeffa9a81f1e86a3172002e03149f1c60c1a7983f8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:edcc07c0f2bfc3c552bd0adb67aad786","paperId":"1801.08546","sourceSha256":"7ca02cf7843ca44e97561a7f5b3aaa4dc4c7d6d767690d400dbc3a03bfc7488b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fa10646cae02d99a5074/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39bf11d378e7dcb060e1e5e8cc331ef71b14a8fa7b26680fd3d64c0ba7c172bc","pdfPage":5,"start":104,"end":2014,"textSha256":"bbf3730d2092a2f1efa923cff87bb0de6b16b6f25bb8408c3f4f51c292099a34","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d4ed2c5d084f1cc9d31dfe90","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound positivity/coefficient and WGC targets. Fixed mass and charge, static Killing horizons, stability and tree-level dominance bound the stated proof. Independent challenge qualification: f0 replaces truncated pf54. Entropy positivity, coefficient restrictions and the extremality/WGC application are compound targets; positivity is not proved ​"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d4ed2c5d084f1cc9d31dfe90","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","q025-candidate-question:58658254978f6670fe11cdcb"],"scopeContentSha256":"17b23896f033122b211a50ba05a1ebc085f18313a14253c55e252acf4c19192d","contributionContentSha256":"1b84797c93b3c175141b40ab458a2e727a99dc8537ade2200cc88426054037c3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d97","kind":"description","unitIndex":97,"unitId":"unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","textSha256":"53940ab369e1a6acaf063913e4a2922acb26adc0dc0d8d0647ce07d09b7284e5"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:66d59273157c2c3e9b72b0c79027a516","paperId":"1801.08546","sourceSha256":"7ca02cf7843ca44e97561a7f5b3aaa4dc4c7d6d767690d400dbc3a03bfc7488b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fa10646cae02d99a5074/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39bf11d378e7dcb060e1e5e8cc331ef71b14a8fa7b26680fd3d64c0ba7c172bc","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"043be5c6cfd0ce826b40066ae4cd5aa058b3459e850bfa45542a538886e3e9b8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cd9c051a6bd68be33f9e094fe91d212e","paperId":"1801.08546","sourceSha256":"7ca02cf7843ca44e97561a7f5b3aaa4dc4c7d6d767690d400dbc3a03bfc7488b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fa10646cae02d99a5074/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39bf11d378e7dcb060e1e5e8cc331ef71b14a8fa7b26680fd3d64c0ba7c172bc","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2535,"textSha256":"1349a31248efeafc128f4afeffa9a81f1e86a3172002e03149f1c60c1a7983f8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:edcc07c0f2bfc3c552bd0adb67aad786","paperId":"1801.08546","sourceSha256":"7ca02cf7843ca44e97561a7f5b3aaa4dc4c7d6d767690d400dbc3a03bfc7488b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fa10646cae02d99a5074/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39bf11d378e7dcb060e1e5e8cc331ef71b14a8fa7b26680fd3d64c0ba7c172bc","pdfPage":5,"start":104,"end":2014,"textSha256":"bbf3730d2092a2f1efa923cff87bb0de6b16b6f25bb8408c3f4f51c292099a34","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d4ed2c5d084f1cc9d31dfe90","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound positivity/coefficient and WGC targets. Fixed mass and charge, static Killing horizons, stability and tree-level dominance bound the stated proof.","challengeNote":"f0 replaces truncated pf54. Entropy positivity, coefficient restrictions and the extremality/WGC application are compound targets; positivity is not proved ​","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"639ac8e396c1a07d0110563c05ab3e6dd6bfdde9bc813dc6282607c1da817026"},"organizational-access:36efb26bb1ec8764d6fe89d3":{"id":"organizational-access:36efb26bb1ec8764d6fe89d3","source":"q025-candidate-question:ce879b7bedfc19489460b0f6","target":"q025-candidate-question:c5b185b7cb8a2d31fb994b94","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ce879b7bedfc19489460b0f6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7cfbcb82b597338a887cd0f268575bbcef9fba749271efe0b55db5dcab394034","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:85a50485d29c016a02e63831"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c5b185b7cb8a2d31fb994b94","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b7522843eeb27ba83619faa620660f5b85f3017520b4ca341645a0027f1e646e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:aefb5e1c5bfce676276c585f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","home":{"unitId":"unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ce879b7bedfc19489460b0f6","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Specifically combines fixed-variable entropy response, conditional positivity, EFT coefficient bounds and WGC interpretations.","qualification":"q14 combines the fixed-mass-and-charge positivity question with coefficient restrictions, extremality response and conditional WGC interpretation. Stability, dominant massive-field tree contributions, the EFT window and the visible static-horizon restriction remain local conditions. A positive charge-to-mass extremality shift is not a positive fixed-charge mass shift.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","paperId":"1801.08546","textSha256":"53940ab369e1a6acaf063913e4a2922acb26adc0dc0d8d0647ce07d09b7284e5"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0021:u17:q14"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0021:u17:q14","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","q025-candidate-question:ce879b7bedfc19489460b0f6"],"scopeContentSha256":"7cfbcb82b597338a887cd0f268575bbcef9fba749271efe0b55db5dcab394034","placementContentSha256":"d3e292913a1b7aa538211326cc8e9cdff88ae64d6b98a3c47778f2066d651004","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0021:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0021:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","paperId":"1801.08546","textSha256":"53940ab369e1a6acaf063913e4a2922acb26adc0dc0d8d0647ce07d09b7284e5"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0021","unitRef":"u17"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c5b185b7cb8a2d31fb994b94","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d97","kind":"description","unitIndex":97,"unitId":"unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","textSha256":"53940ab369e1a6acaf063913e4a2922acb26adc0dc0d8d0647ce07d09b7284e5"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:66d59273157c2c3e9b72b0c79027a516","paperId":"1801.08546","sourceSha256":"7ca02cf7843ca44e97561a7f5b3aaa4dc4c7d6d767690d400dbc3a03bfc7488b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fa10646cae02d99a5074/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39bf11d378e7dcb060e1e5e8cc331ef71b14a8fa7b26680fd3d64c0ba7c172bc","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"043be5c6cfd0ce826b40066ae4cd5aa058b3459e850bfa45542a538886e3e9b8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cd9c051a6bd68be33f9e094fe91d212e","paperId":"1801.08546","sourceSha256":"7ca02cf7843ca44e97561a7f5b3aaa4dc4c7d6d767690d400dbc3a03bfc7488b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fa10646cae02d99a5074/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39bf11d378e7dcb060e1e5e8cc331ef71b14a8fa7b26680fd3d64c0ba7c172bc","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2535,"textSha256":"1349a31248efeafc128f4afeffa9a81f1e86a3172002e03149f1c60c1a7983f8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:edcc07c0f2bfc3c552bd0adb67aad786","paperId":"1801.08546","sourceSha256":"7ca02cf7843ca44e97561a7f5b3aaa4dc4c7d6d767690d400dbc3a03bfc7488b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fa10646cae02d99a5074/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39bf11d378e7dcb060e1e5e8cc331ef71b14a8fa7b26680fd3d64c0ba7c172bc","pdfPage":5,"start":104,"end":2014,"textSha256":"bbf3730d2092a2f1efa923cff87bb0de6b16b6f25bb8408c3f4f51c292099a34","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:523df9a03bc3cc2474323a86","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound positivity/coefficient and WGC targets. Fixed mass and charge, static Killing horizons, stability and tree-level dominance bound the stated proof. Independent challenge qualification: f0 replaces truncated pf54. Entropy positivity, coefficient restrictions and the extremality/WGC application are compound targets; positivity is not proved ​"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:523df9a03bc3cc2474323a86","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","q025-candidate-question:c5b185b7cb8a2d31fb994b94"],"scopeContentSha256":"b7522843eeb27ba83619faa620660f5b85f3017520b4ca341645a0027f1e646e","contributionContentSha256":"8c825bd627b790467ad69a4c0a807286b6d68cde60ab5bf27a3983633218ceda","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d97","kind":"description","unitIndex":97,"unitId":"unit:3947265a02602d4ead1f5677bb7f9cf93b83dd37f3af973db538c2343acfe91a","textSha256":"53940ab369e1a6acaf063913e4a2922acb26adc0dc0d8d0647ce07d09b7284e5"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:66d59273157c2c3e9b72b0c79027a516","paperId":"1801.08546","sourceSha256":"7ca02cf7843ca44e97561a7f5b3aaa4dc4c7d6d767690d400dbc3a03bfc7488b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fa10646cae02d99a5074/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39bf11d378e7dcb060e1e5e8cc331ef71b14a8fa7b26680fd3d64c0ba7c172bc","pdfPage":6,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"043be5c6cfd0ce826b40066ae4cd5aa058b3459e850bfa45542a538886e3e9b8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cd9c051a6bd68be33f9e094fe91d212e","paperId":"1801.08546","sourceSha256":"7ca02cf7843ca44e97561a7f5b3aaa4dc4c7d6d767690d400dbc3a03bfc7488b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fa10646cae02d99a5074/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39bf11d378e7dcb060e1e5e8cc331ef71b14a8fa7b26680fd3d64c0ba7c172bc","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2535,"textSha256":"1349a31248efeafc128f4afeffa9a81f1e86a3172002e03149f1c60c1a7983f8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:edcc07c0f2bfc3c552bd0adb67aad786","paperId":"1801.08546","sourceSha256":"7ca02cf7843ca44e97561a7f5b3aaa4dc4c7d6d767690d400dbc3a03bfc7488b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fa10646cae02d99a5074/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"39bf11d378e7dcb060e1e5e8cc331ef71b14a8fa7b26680fd3d64c0ba7c172bc","pdfPage":5,"start":104,"end":2014,"textSha256":"bbf3730d2092a2f1efa923cff87bb0de6b16b6f25bb8408c3f4f51c292099a34","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:523df9a03bc3cc2474323a86","recordId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-44e36a0a0b29e8b5ec8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound positivity/coefficient and WGC targets. Fixed mass and charge, static Killing horizons, stability and tree-level dominance bound the stated proof.","challengeNote":"f0 replaces truncated pf54. Entropy positivity, coefficient restrictions and the extremality/WGC application are compound targets; positivity is not proved ​","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"b592a07c4abd428d8062317bdb40a1d09f4676ee32cfe2436d8cea26337eadd9"},"organizational-access:8f4c4e351102afdfd3d713f3":{"id":"organizational-access:8f4c4e351102afdfd3d713f3","source":"q025-candidate-question:d35ff1bda85d822155c6a1e0","target":"q025-candidate-question:49eb2f6fe27254299393549f","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:d35ff1bda85d822155c6a1e0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c50d28790291128c59bb0467848a82c302105bb95873ab65cbfaa8456bb700ef","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3f3168627fbae04d82386ee4"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:49eb2f6fe27254299393549f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b5d27c4d7d26f57f9b954d4dc56f0b5c423a0d6e98af3097c1b826015f2d6a29","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0031ef20313721f209240460"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:f828b293f70a49ede426d42d91be9892f2b38efbe33f95daafeb50cede79138a","home":{"unitId":"unit:f828b293f70a49ede426d42d91be9892f2b38efbe33f95daafeb50cede79138a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d35ff1bda85d822155c6a1e0","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q20 expressly includes fourfold deformation families, divisors and quantum cohomology together with their compactification and effective-theory uses.","qualification":"q20 covers the explicit fourfold families and their topology, instanton divisors, elliptic degenerations, transitions and quantum cohomology as compactification data encoding effective physics. It retains M-theory in three and F-theory in four noncompact dimensions and does not equate geometric existence with completed consistency, instanton contributions or stabilized vacua. The source can remain compound.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f828b293f70a49ede426d42d91be9892f2b38efbe33f95daafeb50cede79138a","paperId":"hep-th/9701023","textSha256":"fd2f0ab7d5410dd46fd3d9030c3f7b39861355c3a5579e377d02d262be8825eb"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0006:u27:q20"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0006:u27:q20","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f828b293f70a49ede426d42d91be9892f2b38efbe33f95daafeb50cede79138a","q025-candidate-question:d35ff1bda85d822155c6a1e0"],"scopeContentSha256":"c50d28790291128c59bb0467848a82c302105bb95873ab65cbfaa8456bb700ef","placementContentSha256":"2ce3f8dbdfe6e331dd30cace5ab0ce160b8c699a2a04e826638bfa9b6ad66564","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0006:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0006:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f828b293f70a49ede426d42d91be9892f2b38efbe33f95daafeb50cede79138a","paperId":"hep-th/9701023","textSha256":"fd2f0ab7d5410dd46fd3d9030c3f7b39861355c3a5579e377d02d262be8825eb"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0006","unitRef":"u27"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f828b293f70a49ede426d42d91be9892f2b38efbe33f95daafeb50cede79138a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:49eb2f6fe27254299393549f","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d65","kind":"description","unitIndex":65,"unitId":"unit:f828b293f70a49ede426d42d91be9892f2b38efbe33f95daafeb50cede79138a","textSha256":"fd2f0ab7d5410dd46fd3d9030c3f7b39861355c3a5579e377d02d262be8825eb"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6d17e343fc74bfc0411ec31e004d39ba","paperId":"hep-th/9701023","sourceSha256":"de58d78439bc6ccfda1fd272d7af8ed0c59fd100ef175ab2b09ffb1d436372aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4abb4e75b0bbe63972c9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d728e8fbdda3f2243a4859e3e7622594d97260f356b366a7a1da35151e9ed0d1","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2788,"textSha256":"e3221e9fe174be448b4f7cbbfb53e5ad124cf811db561088d0be9fd6ba8f1080","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b1710d4c96096e7d4550b10a8274a29b","paperId":"hep-th/9701023","sourceSha256":"de58d78439bc6ccfda1fd272d7af8ed0c59fd100ef175ab2b09ffb1d436372aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4abb4e75b0bbe63972c9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d728e8fbdda3f2243a4859e3e7622594d97260f356b366a7a1da35151e9ed0d1","pdfPage":2,"start":94,"end":2704,"textSha256":"ccb8672111452bb9793a5675576ee9d3f2096587e46ee7e3b38678da0cc8fa45","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cf42f7767c19a63101278fa8956f346c","paperId":"hep-th/9701023","sourceSha256":"de58d78439bc6ccfda1fd272d7af8ed0c59fd100ef175ab2b09ffb1d436372aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4abb4e75b0bbe63972c9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d728e8fbdda3f2243a4859e3e7622594d97260f356b366a7a1da35151e9ed0d1","pdfPage":7,"start":0,"end":2460,"textSha256":"b2ff696f227b534915d72ce588beb507afb15e818de6385e835f9afcead8c53b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3b5723016b20c4dce0927ef9"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3b5723016b20c4dce0927ef9","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f828b293f70a49ede426d42d91be9892f2b38efbe33f95daafeb50cede79138a","q025-candidate-question:49eb2f6fe27254299393549f"],"scopeContentSha256":"b5d27c4d7d26f57f9b954d4dc56f0b5c423a0d6e98af3097c1b826015f2d6a29","contributionContentSha256":"26399891b55cb3d9448b5462c192b9260da5e15c3f37b7043dfdb20731d21ac7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-proposal","leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d65","kind":"description","unitIndex":65,"unitId":"unit:f828b293f70a49ede426d42d91be9892f2b38efbe33f95daafeb50cede79138a","textSha256":"fd2f0ab7d5410dd46fd3d9030c3f7b39861355c3a5579e377d02d262be8825eb"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6d17e343fc74bfc0411ec31e004d39ba","paperId":"hep-th/9701023","sourceSha256":"de58d78439bc6ccfda1fd272d7af8ed0c59fd100ef175ab2b09ffb1d436372aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4abb4e75b0bbe63972c9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d728e8fbdda3f2243a4859e3e7622594d97260f356b366a7a1da35151e9ed0d1","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2788,"textSha256":"e3221e9fe174be448b4f7cbbfb53e5ad124cf811db561088d0be9fd6ba8f1080","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b1710d4c96096e7d4550b10a8274a29b","paperId":"hep-th/9701023","sourceSha256":"de58d78439bc6ccfda1fd272d7af8ed0c59fd100ef175ab2b09ffb1d436372aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4abb4e75b0bbe63972c9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d728e8fbdda3f2243a4859e3e7622594d97260f356b366a7a1da35151e9ed0d1","pdfPage":2,"start":94,"end":2704,"textSha256":"ccb8672111452bb9793a5675576ee9d3f2096587e46ee7e3b38678da0cc8fa45","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e22","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cf42f7767c19a63101278fa8956f346c","paperId":"hep-th/9701023","sourceSha256":"de58d78439bc6ccfda1fd272d7af8ed0c59fd100ef175ab2b09ffb1d436372aa","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/4abb4e75b0bbe63972c9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"d728e8fbdda3f2243a4859e3e7622594d97260f356b366a7a1da35151e9ed0d1","pdfPage":7,"start":0,"end":2460,"textSha256":"b2ff696f227b534915d72ce588beb507afb15e818de6385e835f9afcead8c53b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3b5723016b20c4dce0927ef9","recordId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ae62356d300a62e86120-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Deformation families, instanton divisors, elliptic transitions and quantum cohomology form a compound program, not one established atomic question.","challengeNote":"Deformation families, instanton divisors, elliptic transitions and quantum cohomology constitute a compound program.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"0746f7decea51badfceef11ba8b301dea6281170375d09e903f0f7feb3532422"},"organizational-access:86cfb758fb8f249cd5d176bd":{"id":"organizational-access:86cfb758fb8f249cd5d176bd","source":"q025-candidate-question:db4c0b2446b4753f0ed748f0","target":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:db4c0b2446b4753f0ed748f0","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"d568460a22e0a8979feeb902a857187daf03dca7c74b516eb8d05ab8adab7f8c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:fb2b012d23fc1e4c02fa63e7"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"4c0909a26dff37b92eb93bf6a0a9404871cf159742d072f1b0a16e064f759e97","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:81de1c02761e160ccff700da"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:c494c5cfd2390c4babb6d2cc08ebe7a8141189182ad3b4a9e05c6d9255c50328","home":{"unitId":"unit:c494c5cfd2390c4babb6d2cc08ebe7a8141189182ad3b4a9e05c6d9255c50328","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:db4c0b2446b4753f0ed748f0","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c494c5cfd2390c4babb6d2cc08ebe7a8141189182ad3b4a9e05c6d9255c50328","paperId":"hep-th/9806039","textSha256":"1d027c1da4234d690e86593286794aa0818ef72e236a5d4ccc74f9aa6f1a6b72"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:59f7542c3ffcf428d20f6f397aee7abf","paperId":"hep-th/9806039","sourceSha256":"d7a346c973e50d7a96ca57ef058c480540f8b4a7d2fd81b4897dabd33dfd684e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2444bc9ac5559db68664/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b479bac6b68bf40791cfd479143c1c14f88be1a1a21a0f00977575899fa24e8b","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":478,"textSha256":"ec3514a5f0d3a2f8cd93f4626cb5fdbda9207dc0a56ee7be1095704727751dad","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5e5e71650eb03c5929d7618596713fd8","paperId":"hep-th/9806039","sourceSha256":"d7a346c973e50d7a96ca57ef058c480540f8b4a7d2fd81b4897dabd33dfd684e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2444bc9ac5559db68664/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b479bac6b68bf40791cfd479143c1c14f88be1a1a21a0f00977575899fa24e8b","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1977,"textSha256":"978e15e6c531dd48484d74bb8d34796eb8b74dd4c914c0568fe7ef08e1b673cd","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b68c50ea746da08a467c29a9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b68c50ea746da08a467c29a9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c494c5cfd2390c4babb6d2cc08ebe7a8141189182ad3b4a9e05c6d9255c50328","q025-candidate-question:db4c0b2446b4753f0ed748f0"],"scopeContentSha256":"d568460a22e0a8979feeb902a857187daf03dca7c74b516eb8d05ab8adab7f8c","placementContentSha256":"51a37bbc1ff14d0a09e25fcdd78b43d3c0b00eb1d1911f82162ea8206e2b1aa9","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge","leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c494c5cfd2390c4babb6d2cc08ebe7a8141189182ad3b4a9e05c6d9255c50328","paperId":"hep-th/9806039","textSha256":"1d027c1da4234d690e86593286794aa0818ef72e236a5d4ccc74f9aa6f1a6b72"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:59f7542c3ffcf428d20f6f397aee7abf","paperId":"hep-th/9806039","sourceSha256":"d7a346c973e50d7a96ca57ef058c480540f8b4a7d2fd81b4897dabd33dfd684e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2444bc9ac5559db68664/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b479bac6b68bf40791cfd479143c1c14f88be1a1a21a0f00977575899fa24e8b","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":478,"textSha256":"ec3514a5f0d3a2f8cd93f4626cb5fdbda9207dc0a56ee7be1095704727751dad","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5e5e71650eb03c5929d7618596713fd8","paperId":"hep-th/9806039","sourceSha256":"d7a346c973e50d7a96ca57ef058c480540f8b4a7d2fd81b4897dabd33dfd684e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2444bc9ac5559db68664/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b479bac6b68bf40791cfd479143c1c14f88be1a1a21a0f00977575899fa24e8b","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1977,"textSha256":"978e15e6c531dd48484d74bb8d34796eb8b74dd4c914c0568fe7ef08e1b673cd","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b68c50ea746da08a467c29a9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c494c5cfd2390c4babb6d2cc08ebe7a8141189182ad3b4a9e05c6d9255c50328","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:c494c5cfd2390c4babb6d2cc08ebe7a8141189182ad3b4a9e05c6d9255c50328","textSha256":"1d027c1da4234d690e86593286794aa0818ef72e236a5d4ccc74f9aa6f1a6b72"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:59f7542c3ffcf428d20f6f397aee7abf","paperId":"hep-th/9806039","sourceSha256":"d7a346c973e50d7a96ca57ef058c480540f8b4a7d2fd81b4897dabd33dfd684e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2444bc9ac5559db68664/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b479bac6b68bf40791cfd479143c1c14f88be1a1a21a0f00977575899fa24e8b","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":478,"textSha256":"ec3514a5f0d3a2f8cd93f4626cb5fdbda9207dc0a56ee7be1095704727751dad","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5e5e71650eb03c5929d7618596713fd8","paperId":"hep-th/9806039","sourceSha256":"d7a346c973e50d7a96ca57ef058c480540f8b4a7d2fd81b4897dabd33dfd684e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2444bc9ac5559db68664/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b479bac6b68bf40791cfd479143c1c14f88be1a1a21a0f00977575899fa24e8b","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1977,"textSha256":"978e15e6c531dd48484d74bb8d34796eb8b74dd4c914c0568fe7ef08e1b673cd","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:59501f5e78ed4b0942a80cb2","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: June 1998 proposal; the supplied introduction explicitly rejects the trial bound on arbitrary spatial regions. Announced cosmological restrictions are not full Independent challenge qualification: The June 1998 introduction rejects its arbitrary-spatial-region trial bound. The abstract's cosmological restrictions are announced targets, not verified d"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:59501f5e78ed4b0942a80cb2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c494c5cfd2390c4babb6d2cc08ebe7a8141189182ad3b4a9e05c6d9255c50328","q025-candidate-question:98e3f6cf76019904d7a37bcf"],"scopeContentSha256":"4c0909a26dff37b92eb93bf6a0a9404871cf159742d072f1b0a16e064f759e97","contributionContentSha256":"3c59ac67c498863a35356a3ee2680322d50439a96d7d228d2b499af7e62c8173","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-03d3e9337dac249848d4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-03d3e9337dac249848d4-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-03d3e9337dac249848d4-proposal","leaf-03d3e9337dac249848d4-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:c494c5cfd2390c4babb6d2cc08ebe7a8141189182ad3b4a9e05c6d9255c50328","textSha256":"1d027c1da4234d690e86593286794aa0818ef72e236a5d4ccc74f9aa6f1a6b72"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:59f7542c3ffcf428d20f6f397aee7abf","paperId":"hep-th/9806039","sourceSha256":"d7a346c973e50d7a96ca57ef058c480540f8b4a7d2fd81b4897dabd33dfd684e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2444bc9ac5559db68664/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b479bac6b68bf40791cfd479143c1c14f88be1a1a21a0f00977575899fa24e8b","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":478,"textSha256":"ec3514a5f0d3a2f8cd93f4626cb5fdbda9207dc0a56ee7be1095704727751dad","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5e5e71650eb03c5929d7618596713fd8","paperId":"hep-th/9806039","sourceSha256":"d7a346c973e50d7a96ca57ef058c480540f8b4a7d2fd81b4897dabd33dfd684e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2444bc9ac5559db68664/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b479bac6b68bf40791cfd479143c1c14f88be1a1a21a0f00977575899fa24e8b","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1977,"textSha256":"978e15e6c531dd48484d74bb8d34796eb8b74dd4c914c0568fe7ef08e1b673cd","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:59501f5e78ed4b0942a80cb2","recordId":"leaf-03d3e9337dac249848d4-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-03d3e9337dac249848d4-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-03d3e9337dac249848d4-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"June 1998 proposal; the supplied introduction explicitly rejects the trial bound on arbitrary spatial regions. Announced cosmological restrictions are not full","challengeNote":"The June 1998 introduction rejects its arbitrary-spatial-region trial bound. The abstract's cosmological restrictions are announced targets, not verified d","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"0c623a95a369fefb631ed4f4fd0b95c201a3e95d89c486d0919dbdd90b29e07d"},"organizational-access:66b2565bcab4c96566ddead4":{"id":"organizational-access:66b2565bcab4c96566ddead4","source":"q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008","target":"q025-candidate-question:4a92df89a8e61a8421708643","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f7a9d0a0641433afab67587a3c6e2049c011c48ed13d8324bdf7f0f5e85e135b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:91ba6a9f6f19ae29aa190fc2"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:4a92df89a8e61a8421708643","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"a99c0b3d027be9c6dcb64a05f088ca85fc97cd1a65c237dedcefeede27969afd","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2cf26b267c2b086d5944f9a2"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:3eb05be2af91dc318ddd27ddb13294cef00ef72c1668e8b0bc8995c69d439df1","home":{"unitId":"unit:3eb05be2af91dc318ddd27ddb13294cef00ef72c1668e8b0bc8995c69d439df1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q23 explicitly includes IFS cyclic histories and their reheating, transient-dark-energy and contraction stages, with control as a requirement.","qualification":"q23 explicitly encompasses the complete repeating IFS history, including nonsingularity, reheating, transient dark energy, contraction and control. ESP and the dilaton potential remain construction-specific ingredients. The reported weak-coupling and reheating conditions concern a worked example, with no independent verification inferred.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3eb05be2af91dc318ddd27ddb13294cef00ef72c1668e8b0bc8995c69d439df1","textSha256":"676a29cd8df8222be0cfd70d95b054f2060bdd8d55f69837b141ea1a97fb93b6"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:annotation:u7:q23"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:annotation:u7:q23","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3eb05be2af91dc318ddd27ddb13294cef00ef72c1668e8b0bc8995c69d439df1","q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008"],"scopeContentSha256":"f7a9d0a0641433afab67587a3c6e2049c011c48ed13d8324bdf7f0f5e85e135b","placementContentSha256":"75dc105e23de298dd1fb2ecdb2acf58c1726ec0b8e6864f7c12609fbb738e1a0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:annotation:proposal","placement-pilot:annotation:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3eb05be2af91dc318ddd27ddb13294cef00ef72c1668e8b0bc8995c69d439df1","textSha256":"676a29cd8df8222be0cfd70d95b054f2060bdd8d55f69837b141ea1a97fb93b6"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:3eb05be2af91dc318ddd27ddb13294cef00ef72c1668e8b0bc8995c69d439df1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3eb05be2af91dc318ddd27ddb13294cef00ef72c1668e8b0bc8995c69d439df1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4a92df89a8e61a8421708643","role":"instantiates","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:3eb05be2af91dc318ddd27ddb13294cef00ef72c1668e8b0bc8995c69d439df1","textSha256":"676a29cd8df8222be0cfd70d95b054f2060bdd8d55f69837b141ea1a97fb93b6"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:466f2b58d62034019d6257d484a1aae5","paperId":"2508.09745","sourceSha256":"53414ce77abc3e96699e1495e70aad1100bfd2fea254886e6ce752e880830dde","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/064309499099c1b827bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3febf2a525307515f8d696148dc5a0f51a989fb2ef114203f431b5eff50a55fc","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":2977,"textSha256":"d641f0e1093fc02e623c8082a863173394cdc43ff8f23b5feb9fca55b446ed50","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ef057b83c5aff210aa09cc8bfe813739","paperId":"2508.09745","sourceSha256":"53414ce77abc3e96699e1495e70aad1100bfd2fea254886e6ce752e880830dde","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/064309499099c1b827bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3febf2a525307515f8d696148dc5a0f51a989fb2ef114203f431b5eff50a55fc","pdfPage":4,"start":96,"end":2370,"textSha256":"ed44a9263f331c8d641115028ecf123a3ce90a4e3cfe8a7e96a227072edfc77c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4d20760dfcc818b24653a252"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4d20760dfcc818b24653a252","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3eb05be2af91dc318ddd27ddb13294cef00ef72c1668e8b0bc8995c69d439df1","q025-candidate-question:4a92df89a8e61a8421708643"],"scopeContentSha256":"a99c0b3d027be9c6dcb64a05f088ca85fc97cd1a65c237dedcefeede27969afd","contributionContentSha256":"d030db37ddbebe624c4c86c8ff43f423e90d13593b0b1103a997a403ced84b52","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:3eb05be2af91dc318ddd27ddb13294cef00ef72c1668e8b0bc8995c69d439df1","textSha256":"676a29cd8df8222be0cfd70d95b054f2060bdd8d55f69837b141ea1a97fb93b6"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:466f2b58d62034019d6257d484a1aae5","paperId":"2508.09745","sourceSha256":"53414ce77abc3e96699e1495e70aad1100bfd2fea254886e6ce752e880830dde","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/064309499099c1b827bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3febf2a525307515f8d696148dc5a0f51a989fb2ef114203f431b5eff50a55fc","pdfPage":3,"start":91,"end":2977,"textSha256":"d641f0e1093fc02e623c8082a863173394cdc43ff8f23b5feb9fca55b446ed50","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e25","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ef057b83c5aff210aa09cc8bfe813739","paperId":"2508.09745","sourceSha256":"53414ce77abc3e96699e1495e70aad1100bfd2fea254886e6ce752e880830dde","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/064309499099c1b827bf/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"3febf2a525307515f8d696148dc5a0f51a989fb2ef114203f431b5eff50a55fc","pdfPage":4,"start":96,"end":2370,"textSha256":"ed44a9263f331c8d641115028ecf123a3ce90a4e3cfe8a7e96a227072edfc77c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4d20760dfcc818b24653a252","recordId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"A 4D cycle combines ESP, IFSs and a dilaton potential. Weak coupling and sub-string-scale reheating are reported for a worked example, not independently checked","challengeNote":"A multistage 4D cycle uses ESP, IFSs and a dilaton potential. Weak coupling and sub-string-scale reheating are reported for a worked example, not independently","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4baaced46217eab4c6ba805115dcc8903f9bb7b7487d4148ddbbee041d6b6ca3"},"organizational-access:b870fafd6cf3e930932b0969":{"id":"organizational-access:b870fafd6cf3e930932b0969","source":"q025-candidate-question:fc2052739bc397b7cdf81d20","target":"q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:fc2052739bc397b7cdf81d20","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"910c575778d88198b1250aef4fe130efa5c527213f0936e20fbe9b211a88daa7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:47d420762c778407122a46a0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"8a73b16635ef766c7dd1d26a5437b8e7551b52c20d6577dca0c0c891452a91f8","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:70a6de87d57a571c17408b57"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:c5428988a7744ec264323aaf2501996b9b49ddd6184b4db6a61ca0898da0784f","home":{"unitId":"unit:c5428988a7744ec264323aaf2501996b9b49ddd6184b4db6a61ca0898da0784f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:fc2052739bc397b7cdf81d20","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly covers Eguchi–Hanson Standard Model flux consistency and violation questions, including the associated generalized-symmetry gauging.","qualification":"q7 explicitly includes the Eguchi–Hanson Standard Model setting and spans discrete-flux consistency, generalized-symmetry gauging and induced violations. The electric Z6 1-form specification and semiclassical character remain binding.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c5428988a7744ec264323aaf2501996b9b49ddd6184b4db6a61ca0898da0784f","paperId":"2509.22788","textSha256":"ed829a89914fe940eb14122f6a30d27c5420d65b1b290ec7f25a44befc2eb170"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0014:u6:q7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0014:u6:q7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c5428988a7744ec264323aaf2501996b9b49ddd6184b4db6a61ca0898da0784f","q025-candidate-question:fc2052739bc397b7cdf81d20"],"scopeContentSha256":"910c575778d88198b1250aef4fe130efa5c527213f0936e20fbe9b211a88daa7","placementContentSha256":"95cd25352c03616e3e0d14bd7fb104c03646974a87061ecade7f5d68b1fb03dd","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0014:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0014:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c5428988a7744ec264323aaf2501996b9b49ddd6184b4db6a61ca0898da0784f","paperId":"2509.22788","textSha256":"ed829a89914fe940eb14122f6a30d27c5420d65b1b290ec7f25a44befc2eb170"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0014","unitRef":"u6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c5428988a7744ec264323aaf2501996b9b49ddd6184b4db6a61ca0898da0784f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:c5428988a7744ec264323aaf2501996b9b49ddd6184b4db6a61ca0898da0784f","textSha256":"ed829a89914fe940eb14122f6a30d27c5420d65b1b290ec7f25a44befc2eb170"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4191c5a4f89dd6cd405dedd0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4191c5a4f89dd6cd405dedd0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c5428988a7744ec264323aaf2501996b9b49ddd6184b4db6a61ca0898da0784f","q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a"],"scopeContentSha256":"8a73b16635ef766c7dd1d26a5437b8e7551b52c20d6577dca0c0c891452a91f8","contributionContentSha256":"0e6f8879876e35f72572529ddced2b99ce7b259c1571cebd9975f3cbb09ce6cb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-proposal","leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:c5428988a7744ec264323aaf2501996b9b49ddd6184b4db6a61ca0898da0784f","textSha256":"ed829a89914fe940eb14122f6a30d27c5420d65b1b290ec7f25a44befc2eb170"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4191c5a4f89dd6cd405dedd0","recordId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound targets: consistent discrete flux, semiclassical gauging, and baryon/lepton violation.","challengeNote":"Compound targets are flux consistency, semiclassical gauging and baryon/lepton violation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:cdec8d8c7284c367905c93f88445349605ecfa7343805c293b7123e9e8175ddf","home":{"unitId":"unit:cdec8d8c7284c367905c93f88445349605ecfa7343805c293b7123e9e8175ddf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:fc2052739bc397b7cdf81d20","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers charged endpoint insertions and the mixed gauge-variation cancellation in the specified four-dimensional fermion/axion model.","qualification":"q7 directly covers charged insertions and anomaly cancellation in the specified four-dimensional gauge-instanton model. The chiral fermions, gauge groups and gauged-axion topological coupling stay attached to the endpoint-dressing question.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cdec8d8c7284c367905c93f88445349605ecfa7343805c293b7123e9e8175ddf","paperId":"2002.02456","textSha256":"a5d0da23d47de814a94f233ec9378f46aa935afd2b97a568e5abf8ead5b1e1f7"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0014:u11:q7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0014:u11:q7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cdec8d8c7284c367905c93f88445349605ecfa7343805c293b7123e9e8175ddf","q025-candidate-question:fc2052739bc397b7cdf81d20"],"scopeContentSha256":"910c575778d88198b1250aef4fe130efa5c527213f0936e20fbe9b211a88daa7","placementContentSha256":"b8e8aa6717a6a917e539084a82610dcb2c2fddf7a185f57d9ad5bfcaf42ec5f4","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0014:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0014:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-02"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cdec8d8c7284c367905c93f88445349605ecfa7343805c293b7123e9e8175ddf","paperId":"2002.02456","textSha256":"a5d0da23d47de814a94f233ec9378f46aa935afd2b97a568e5abf8ead5b1e1f7"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"b83d8082c4d165c364ce233d81d7568e524b7963d4a1549e7578d8448cd9a51a"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-02/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"0260fb77229d5655a0336788cc83d992b3bc6f06f00a50b96c3b6e27e8900337","bytes":3557508,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0014","unitRef":"u11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cdec8d8c7284c367905c93f88445349605ecfa7343805c293b7123e9e8175ddf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:cdec8d8c7284c367905c93f88445349605ecfa7343805c293b7123e9e8175ddf","textSha256":"a5d0da23d47de814a94f233ec9378f46aa935afd2b97a568e5abf8ead5b1e1f7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:546fec965fcf78af332102ea"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:546fec965fcf78af332102ea","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cdec8d8c7284c367905c93f88445349605ecfa7343805c293b7123e9e8175ddf","q025-candidate-question:4916978371350c65b64c5f8a"],"scopeContentSha256":"8a73b16635ef766c7dd1d26a5437b8e7551b52c20d6577dca0c0c891452a91f8","contributionContentSha256":"3752bb8719f88c3cd5017a89a34ac8d39ffbf1911ad027723e72ffdee74a8eeb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-proposal","leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:cdec8d8c7284c367905c93f88445349605ecfa7343805c293b7123e9e8175ddf","textSha256":"a5d0da23d47de814a94f233ec9378f46aa935afd2b97a568e5abf8ead5b1e1f7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:546fec965fcf78af332102ea","recordId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-ab56e9a82713036edb32-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Four-dimensional chiral U(1)-charged SU(N) fermions and a gauged axion; its topological coupling cancels the mixed variation.","challengeNote":"The gauged axion cancels the mixed variation of the specified chiral U(1)-charged SU(N) fermions.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"d8c2c5d74f8b36c9738ec435185a9628a6367ccd37719ea5ed89ba6e13b6e260"},"organizational-access:3b18aad25dde2cff93d4474e":{"id":"organizational-access:3b18aad25dde2cff93d4474e","source":"q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","target":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","sourceKind":"question","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"fine_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6734fbe04f2387de13aad723a0e31051d7d28b96e70ae827863c809ca052b2f6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8beddc9f8b4587b287fbe3c6"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ad449becadd3a4e1ef632d22d11437ab8b2060c64f934db103812d0ed558ea64","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e63d372fde3b4b8f1ee681f8"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","home":{"unitId":"unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":0.4,"reason":"Covers construction of nonsupersymmetric AdS extrema from constrained integer fluxes in the isotropic type IIB non-geometric model.","qualification":"Construction, AdS perturbative stability and positive-energy/inflation components remain distinct; isotropic stability or hierarchy is not a complete stable inflationary history. Exact full challenge coverage and source-local qualifications remain binding. Weights are organizational allocation, not confidence or physical importance.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","paperId":"1302.0529","textSha256":"eb331c59a80402ff9c6c974e7a1be44502921c6c498985f14f73d68406d8828d"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:u29:q35","coverageMode":"explicit_compound_union","targetCoverage":[{"sourceSpan":"Which constrained integer-flux configurations yield stable non-supersymmetric dS or AdS extrema in an isotropic type IIB non-geometric model,","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"],"explanation":"q35 covers constrained-flux AdS construction, q8 the stated AdS stability tests, and q7 the dS construction and stability branch. All retain the isotropic model restriction and nonsupersymmetric setting."},{"sourceSpan":"and do the reported dS examples admit small-field, multi-field slow-roll conditions?","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"],"explanation":"q7 explicitly allows supplied inflationary applications of the dS branch; this is a conditions test, not a claim of a complete inflationary history."}],"coverageReason":"The union covers constrained integer-flux AdS construction, retained-sector AdS stability, and the dS stability/slow-roll application. q35 alone omits the latter targets, q8's AdS definition cannot be silently extended to dS, and q7 does not cover the independent AdS construction question. No supplied whole composite covers all regimes. Isotropic stability and slow-roll conditions remain limited tests."},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:u29:q35","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c"],"scopeContentSha256":"6734fbe04f2387de13aad723a0e31051d7d28b96e70ae827863c809ca052b2f6","placementContentSha256":"97e6934a38385495e9f442de6c9e7524647b6a9e594c4077b7bdf974e0e58206","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:proposal","explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:challenge","root:explicit-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","paperId":"1302.0529","textSha256":"eb331c59a80402ff9c6c974e7a1be44502921c6c498985f14f73d68406d8828d"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"45cd7c1d060cb6f2fd1d8a4ace5cca7c3d64df235a869afc4ce7e31b2e6badfb"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0066","unitRef":"u29"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","textSha256":"eb331c59a80402ff9c6c974e7a1be44502921c6c498985f14f73d68406d8828d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:93684635f2f62db3d0279755"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:93684635f2f62db3d0279755","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e"],"scopeContentSha256":"ad449becadd3a4e1ef632d22d11437ab8b2060c64f934db103812d0ed558ea64","contributionContentSha256":"ac0efd76586d3fda3178859237ef96dcca33d7e226913a36e5a97939e4458734","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:52c31ef7fe23028cc2d30a66124d0eb6eb2e55cda247072f5d44a317e20c8c16","textSha256":"eb331c59a80402ff9c6c974e7a1be44502921c6c498985f14f73d68406d8828d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:93684635f2f62db3d0279755","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Isotropic flux extrema and dS slow-roll conditions are distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Isotropic flux extrema and dS slow-roll conditions are distinct targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","home":{"unitId":"unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":0.4,"reason":"Covers P-flux and anisotropy as AdS-construction ingredients and their effects on stabilization and claimed moduli hierarchies.","qualification":"Construction, AdS perturbative stability and positive-energy/inflation components remain distinct; isotropic stability or hierarchy is not a complete stable inflationary history. Exact full challenge coverage and source-local qualifications remain binding. Weights are organizational allocation, not confidence or physical importance.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","paperId":"1304.0792","textSha256":"739ac8a50b523c68f1bdb0e11280bd60b17ddd9782f37c690e3e4af13c0886e6"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:u27:q35","coverageMode":"explicit_compound_union","targetCoverage":[{"sourceSpan":"Can S-dual nongeometric P-fluxes and torus anisotropy produce further stable dS/AdS candidates,","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"],"explanation":"q35 covers AdS construction with the stated flux and anisotropy ingredients, q8 its perturbative stability tests, and q7 the dS construction and stability branch. q8 is not enlarged to cover dS systems."},{"sourceSpan":"remove instabilities hidden by isotropic truncations,","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"],"explanation":"q8 covers previously omitted scalar directions for AdS candidates; q7 covers whether the dS branch remains stabilized and metastable when the relevant directions are tested."},{"sourceSpan":"and change the moduli hierarchies relevant to small-field inflation?","destinationIds":["q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c","q025-candidate-question:3af34926639acad76878bbd1"],"explanation":"q35 covers claimed hierarchies of the constructed AdS branch, and q7 covers their relevance in the supplied positive-energy and inflationary setting."}],"coverageReason":"The union covers flux/anisotropy construction and hierarchies, omitted-sector AdS stability, and dS stabilization/inflation applications. q35 separates construction from subsequent stability; q8 does not supply a general dS scope; q7 does not cover the independent AdS construction program. No supplied whole vacuum scope covers their conjunction. Stability remains sector-specific, and a hierarchy does not by itself establish successful inflation."},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:u27:q35","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","q025-candidate-question:ff96208cc000292df076914c"],"scopeContentSha256":"6734fbe04f2387de13aad723a0e31051d7d28b96e70ae827863c809ca052b2f6","placementContentSha256":"7996e05f739faa4ae0aa0fd4fb8513411ffc65ff259798bfb4ca0436ab938052","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:proposal","explicit-cut-04:placement-continuation-0066:challenge","root:explicit-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","paperId":"1304.0792","textSha256":"739ac8a50b523c68f1bdb0e11280bd60b17ddd9782f37c690e3e4af13c0886e6"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-04/admission.json","sha256":"45cd7c1d060cb6f2fd1d8a4ace5cca7c3d64df235a869afc4ce7e31b2e6badfb"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/exception-intake.json","sha256":"f3e1caf9aa0c7959cc7db2466ece6b89d488e03d01ec498be11e040235d9c9be","bytes":9631717,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0066","unitRef":"u27"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","textSha256":"739ac8a50b523c68f1bdb0e11280bd60b17ddd9782f37c690e3e4af13c0886e6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9145d45078b435e4e9ae4a5e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9145d45078b435e4e9ae4a5e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","q025-candidate-question:3b8dd929725c71ca2311287e"],"scopeContentSha256":"ad449becadd3a4e1ef632d22d11437ab8b2060c64f934db103812d0ed558ea64","contributionContentSha256":"4b95e50395acafae36e8be0475fc08ec12429de9648dd877d4a32099f335f429","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:f3fb0d318371de74a788f62841c967f8c486e2499087545b4d775f60b4822493","textSha256":"739ac8a50b523c68f1bdb0e11280bd60b17ddd9782f37c690e3e4af13c0886e6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9145d45078b435e4e9ae4a5e","recordId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-7239d34ee0bb0924a274-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound P-flux/anisotropy, stability and inflation-hierarchy questions.","challengeNote":"Compound P-flux/anisotropy, stability and inflation-hierarchy questions.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"24a42e67f864374f2fe03fafc07a543551348b5914de8cc40387a11c218f861c"},"organizational-access:2ff01b68f6fdc0377602f38d":{"id":"organizational-access:2ff01b68f6fdc0377602f38d","source":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","target":"q025-candidate-question:8e566fe6ab9c8aa3af27d75f","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:924fe997fc8f49068b91d181"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8e566fe6ab9c8aa3af27d75f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e2d9b958338227b771c85346f5e2618a1561c98b413409e12406b23627cbec9c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:20db2db338cec3d491f9dbbc"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","home":{"unitId":"unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","paperId":"2007.02655","textSha256":"bf5ab907a3991c25c4a670ad12fd4b10bb2ebf59eba57c1e1c484077f519e06d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:251d0d394bf3462a329cf25e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:251d0d394bf3462a329cf25e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","q025-candidate-region:072557743b48c99c543e373c"],"scopeContentSha256":"a6cbd071cf5672c2aa0a661b9ea784d6bdf5c708c84c5d1a5fd03967011dd987","placementContentSha256":"69a8662ace1c02f7fad91d0d683d749a8be96315d0b93b67be78746bea114e13","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","paperId":"2007.02655","textSha256":"bf5ab907a3991c25c4a670ad12fd4b10bb2ebf59eba57c1e1c484077f519e06d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:251d0d394bf3462a329cf25e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8e566fe6ab9c8aa3af27d75f","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","textSha256":"bf5ab907a3991c25c4a670ad12fd4b10bb2ebf59eba57c1e1c484077f519e06d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1b097c9a34acd99659b29c48","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Retains both the conditional magnetic-WGC inference and a proposed compactification realization. Independent challenge qualification: Compound conditional magnetic-WGC inference and proposed compactification realization."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1b097c9a34acd99659b29c48","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","q025-candidate-question:8e566fe6ab9c8aa3af27d75f"],"scopeContentSha256":"e2d9b958338227b771c85346f5e2618a1561c98b413409e12406b23627cbec9c","contributionContentSha256":"e2bfe4a99a9b11908900cea882d1acdcaceb0104cd998a904ca5a1465c616aff","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:e0450abf3bc45bd5b2d4ccd9ea9c181e4b9bf8b157567463f1b234502a638d86","textSha256":"bf5ab907a3991c25c4a670ad12fd4b10bb2ebf59eba57c1e1c484077f519e06d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1b097c9a34acd99659b29c48","recordId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f939a01a5c102d02b5cf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Retains both the conditional magnetic-WGC inference and a proposed compactification realization.","challengeNote":"Compound conditional magnetic-WGC inference and proposed compactification realization.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"bdffe959e20c53f7a23dce69258f77e133d964409979906f292566f73e0cbe98"},"organizational-access:4f5837d65d6c7746895613ce":{"id":"organizational-access:4f5837d65d6c7746895613ce","source":"q025-candidate-region:08e506f6e18913013e767c3c","target":"q025-candidate-question:691003b8ebd007f1f8b9daa3","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:08e506f6e18913013e767c3c","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"c1f25d742b038101dace403be0dbe1389744c9bb91ea0403c4a080ad0c335707","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:4b81ecb496e2ce1c64be0fac"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:691003b8ebd007f1f8b9daa3","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c0dc42175188271a818cc5064b59a1018e586855efe265baf47503e0a84837f4","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:44b16524c0498dc6b37d20a6"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:4de67551c67b638657b557465ee5d01d95659ed0b14b2af60137fa583d8cd918","home":{"unitId":"unit:4de67551c67b638657b557465ee5d01d95659ed0b14b2af60137fa583d8cd918","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:08e506f6e18913013e767c3c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4de67551c67b638657b557465ee5d01d95659ed0b14b2af60137fa583d8cd918","paperId":"hep-th/9202046","textSha256":"d654bba263a4ff5416d8801849216cb0ac6ed1c5372e087819673a11f58055bc"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:41754444d6c50327aa2c69f7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:41754444d6c50327aa2c69f7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4de67551c67b638657b557465ee5d01d95659ed0b14b2af60137fa583d8cd918","q025-candidate-region:08e506f6e18913013e767c3c"],"scopeContentSha256":"c1f25d742b038101dace403be0dbe1389744c9bb91ea0403c4a080ad0c335707","placementContentSha256":"f5421e412a85c4ecbeea8b149089254cba50ed3312a85119fe892550a4c8accc","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge","leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4de67551c67b638657b557465ee5d01d95659ed0b14b2af60137fa583d8cd918","paperId":"hep-th/9202046","textSha256":"d654bba263a4ff5416d8801849216cb0ac6ed1c5372e087819673a11f58055bc"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:41754444d6c50327aa2c69f7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4de67551c67b638657b557465ee5d01d95659ed0b14b2af60137fa583d8cd918","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:691003b8ebd007f1f8b9daa3","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d80","kind":"description","unitIndex":80,"unitId":"unit:4de67551c67b638657b557465ee5d01d95659ed0b14b2af60137fa583d8cd918","textSha256":"d654bba263a4ff5416d8801849216cb0ac6ed1c5372e087819673a11f58055bc"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:86d233f1aa9e4b6fec7ad915"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:86d233f1aa9e4b6fec7ad915","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4de67551c67b638657b557465ee5d01d95659ed0b14b2af60137fa583d8cd918","q025-candidate-question:691003b8ebd007f1f8b9daa3"],"scopeContentSha256":"c0dc42175188271a818cc5064b59a1018e586855efe265baf47503e0a84837f4","contributionContentSha256":"d0d48b47ebb42e28d422377dddcb71f69326a182b4a38cd5fc6e8e7696ccb4fc","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d80","kind":"description","unitIndex":80,"unitId":"unit:4de67551c67b638657b557465ee5d01d95659ed0b14b2af60137fa583d8cd918","textSha256":"d654bba263a4ff5416d8801849216cb0ac6ed1c5372e087819673a11f58055bc"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:86d233f1aa9e4b6fec7ad915","recordId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound spectrum, unification and soft-mass restrictions from duality anomalies and modular weights.","challengeNote":"Spectrum, unification and soft-mass restrictions are compound outputs of anomaly and modular-weight constraints.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:7b8d9af78b1b22ed2a1850e14fbe76ec06254b9fd6edb2b22d2bc550b4ed624c","home":{"unitId":"unit:7b8d9af78b1b22ed2a1850e14fbe76ec06254b9fd6edb2b22d2bc550b4ed624c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:08e506f6e18913013e767c3c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7b8d9af78b1b22ed2a1850e14fbe76ec06254b9fd6edb2b22d2bc550b4ed624c","paperId":"0807.4384","textSha256":"d749c8315c904384c8080a543f4bb11b4af8ead205881c39be2c7da44eff0bfb"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ef37c08fdc38b96acc7954cf"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ef37c08fdc38b96acc7954cf","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7b8d9af78b1b22ed2a1850e14fbe76ec06254b9fd6edb2b22d2bc550b4ed624c","q025-candidate-region:08e506f6e18913013e767c3c"],"scopeContentSha256":"c1f25d742b038101dace403be0dbe1389744c9bb91ea0403c4a080ad0c335707","placementContentSha256":"4eee92e35b158c25b4e0a54935e36aa5f04b2cb98fee651d77b0788b52b5f33c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge","leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7b8d9af78b1b22ed2a1850e14fbe76ec06254b9fd6edb2b22d2bc550b4ed624c","paperId":"0807.4384","textSha256":"d749c8315c904384c8080a543f4bb11b4af8ead205881c39be2c7da44eff0bfb"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ef37c08fdc38b96acc7954cf"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7b8d9af78b1b22ed2a1850e14fbe76ec06254b9fd6edb2b22d2bc550b4ed624c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:691003b8ebd007f1f8b9daa3","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:7b8d9af78b1b22ed2a1850e14fbe76ec06254b9fd6edb2b22d2bc550b4ed624c","textSha256":"d749c8315c904384c8080a543f4bb11b4af8ead205881c39be2c7da44eff0bfb"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:67a670084e0feb9b7ed37236"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:67a670084e0feb9b7ed37236","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7b8d9af78b1b22ed2a1850e14fbe76ec06254b9fd6edb2b22d2bc550b4ed624c","q025-candidate-question:691003b8ebd007f1f8b9daa3"],"scopeContentSha256":"c0dc42175188271a818cc5064b59a1018e586855efe265baf47503e0a84837f4","contributionContentSha256":"cd2932fb7865d09f2a27e79132cc6a003d66896f7fd8cdd6ebaad74d5d9c29c1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:7b8d9af78b1b22ed2a1850e14fbe76ec06254b9fd6edb2b22d2bc550b4ed624c","textSha256":"d749c8315c904384c8080a543f4bb11b4af8ead205881c39be2c7da44eff0bfb"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:67a670084e0feb9b7ed37236","recordId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound candidate counting, local-GUT search assessment and hidden-sector scale question; maximal three Wilson lines and arbitrary shifts define the search.","challengeNote":"Compound counting, search-efficiency and condensation-scale targets; three Wilson lines and arbitrary shifts delimit the search.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:7bd46e4bb20f874a55c43c49155420ab0802bc4e873966e51dd5aec5fa1264cc","home":{"unitId":"unit:7bd46e4bb20f874a55c43c49155420ab0802bc4e873966e51dd5aec5fa1264cc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:08e506f6e18913013e767c3c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7bd46e4bb20f874a55c43c49155420ab0802bc4e873966e51dd5aec5fa1264cc","paperId":"0805.4186","textSha256":"e6c04f2a25dcf6eea6dda5a9c32d4a478f87fffa1fb7713012eaf0b0f8c90b33"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3909a26e5f8de0f3fdb0b739ae666a90","paperId":"0805.4186","sourceSha256":"c7001313a79dbc9419776d1c5e77a65cc8d971991dd24a15ae70af1e327e39f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc30ca155b02b3193ded/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e32ee58f0dd594e17efc42f65b4b3610356dc5a6cc8f2df44a637b1e4393515f","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3492,"textSha256":"7183d1d30683ff6789f3a5155e9265f1ff0b79f9e97ba1a089ab08117f4c5f38","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c95d4ca9a2b5026b99b87ab5164b6488","paperId":"0805.4186","sourceSha256":"c7001313a79dbc9419776d1c5e77a65cc8d971991dd24a15ae70af1e327e39f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc30ca155b02b3193ded/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e32ee58f0dd594e17efc42f65b4b3610356dc5a6cc8f2df44a637b1e4393515f","pdfPage":3,"start":1293,"end":3644,"textSha256":"18a3d0d817ccad8944243fcb4a1fe3b26c28aee375a99127a1e1cc5bfdce51db","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fea5b4bce366e2775972d7d820197e49","paperId":"0805.4186","sourceSha256":"c7001313a79dbc9419776d1c5e77a65cc8d971991dd24a15ae70af1e327e39f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc30ca155b02b3193ded/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e32ee58f0dd594e17efc42f65b4b3610356dc5a6cc8f2df44a637b1e4393515f","pdfPage":14,"start":102,"end":2930,"textSha256":"b5ef78c596e29c2c5ffb35cc5fdcbef41d85269aa844f746c182de6d81a4e5df","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a3c1c4cda674705128905123"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a3c1c4cda674705128905123","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7bd46e4bb20f874a55c43c49155420ab0802bc4e873966e51dd5aec5fa1264cc","q025-candidate-region:08e506f6e18913013e767c3c"],"scopeContentSha256":"c1f25d742b038101dace403be0dbe1389744c9bb91ea0403c4a080ad0c335707","placementContentSha256":"7fee4c3b0f4c713bde7c50351265dde0643d7a58db843c7f6df4ea408a699e5e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge","leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7bd46e4bb20f874a55c43c49155420ab0802bc4e873966e51dd5aec5fa1264cc","paperId":"0805.4186","textSha256":"e6c04f2a25dcf6eea6dda5a9c32d4a478f87fffa1fb7713012eaf0b0f8c90b33"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3909a26e5f8de0f3fdb0b739ae666a90","paperId":"0805.4186","sourceSha256":"c7001313a79dbc9419776d1c5e77a65cc8d971991dd24a15ae70af1e327e39f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc30ca155b02b3193ded/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e32ee58f0dd594e17efc42f65b4b3610356dc5a6cc8f2df44a637b1e4393515f","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3492,"textSha256":"7183d1d30683ff6789f3a5155e9265f1ff0b79f9e97ba1a089ab08117f4c5f38","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c95d4ca9a2b5026b99b87ab5164b6488","paperId":"0805.4186","sourceSha256":"c7001313a79dbc9419776d1c5e77a65cc8d971991dd24a15ae70af1e327e39f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc30ca155b02b3193ded/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e32ee58f0dd594e17efc42f65b4b3610356dc5a6cc8f2df44a637b1e4393515f","pdfPage":3,"start":1293,"end":3644,"textSha256":"18a3d0d817ccad8944243fcb4a1fe3b26c28aee375a99127a1e1cc5bfdce51db","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fea5b4bce366e2775972d7d820197e49","paperId":"0805.4186","sourceSha256":"c7001313a79dbc9419776d1c5e77a65cc8d971991dd24a15ae70af1e327e39f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc30ca155b02b3193ded/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e32ee58f0dd594e17efc42f65b4b3610356dc5a6cc8f2df44a637b1e4393515f","pdfPage":14,"start":102,"end":2930,"textSha256":"b5ef78c596e29c2c5ffb35cc5fdcbef41d85269aa844f746c182de6d81a4e5df","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:a3c1c4cda674705128905123"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7bd46e4bb20f874a55c43c49155420ab0802bc4e873966e51dd5aec5fa1264cc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:691003b8ebd007f1f8b9daa3","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:7bd46e4bb20f874a55c43c49155420ab0802bc4e873966e51dd5aec5fa1264cc","textSha256":"e6c04f2a25dcf6eea6dda5a9c32d4a478f87fffa1fb7713012eaf0b0f8c90b33"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3909a26e5f8de0f3fdb0b739ae666a90","paperId":"0805.4186","sourceSha256":"c7001313a79dbc9419776d1c5e77a65cc8d971991dd24a15ae70af1e327e39f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc30ca155b02b3193ded/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e32ee58f0dd594e17efc42f65b4b3610356dc5a6cc8f2df44a637b1e4393515f","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3492,"textSha256":"7183d1d30683ff6789f3a5155e9265f1ff0b79f9e97ba1a089ab08117f4c5f38","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c95d4ca9a2b5026b99b87ab5164b6488","paperId":"0805.4186","sourceSha256":"c7001313a79dbc9419776d1c5e77a65cc8d971991dd24a15ae70af1e327e39f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc30ca155b02b3193ded/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e32ee58f0dd594e17efc42f65b4b3610356dc5a6cc8f2df44a637b1e4393515f","pdfPage":3,"start":1293,"end":3644,"textSha256":"18a3d0d817ccad8944243fcb4a1fe3b26c28aee375a99127a1e1cc5bfdce51db","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fea5b4bce366e2775972d7d820197e49","paperId":"0805.4186","sourceSha256":"c7001313a79dbc9419776d1c5e77a65cc8d971991dd24a15ae70af1e327e39f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc30ca155b02b3193ded/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e32ee58f0dd594e17efc42f65b4b3610356dc5a6cc8f2df44a637b1e4393515f","pdfPage":14,"start":102,"end":2930,"textSha256":"b5ef78c596e29c2c5ffb35cc5fdcbef41d85269aa844f746c182de6d81a4e5df","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:98d90c99fd204acef3d431d0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:98d90c99fd204acef3d431d0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7bd46e4bb20f874a55c43c49155420ab0802bc4e873966e51dd5aec5fa1264cc","q025-candidate-question:691003b8ebd007f1f8b9daa3"],"scopeContentSha256":"c0dc42175188271a818cc5064b59a1018e586855efe265baf47503e0a84837f4","contributionContentSha256":"f1a6af5da3bb22d55f91f2f2bc701a47a31f0af3ce5d96bea9b590ace90a737d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:7bd46e4bb20f874a55c43c49155420ab0802bc4e873966e51dd5aec5fa1264cc","textSha256":"e6c04f2a25dcf6eea6dda5a9c32d4a478f87fffa1fb7713012eaf0b0f8c90b33"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3909a26e5f8de0f3fdb0b739ae666a90","paperId":"0805.4186","sourceSha256":"c7001313a79dbc9419776d1c5e77a65cc8d971991dd24a15ae70af1e327e39f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc30ca155b02b3193ded/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e32ee58f0dd594e17efc42f65b4b3610356dc5a6cc8f2df44a637b1e4393515f","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3492,"textSha256":"7183d1d30683ff6789f3a5155e9265f1ff0b79f9e97ba1a089ab08117f4c5f38","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e19","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:c95d4ca9a2b5026b99b87ab5164b6488","paperId":"0805.4186","sourceSha256":"c7001313a79dbc9419776d1c5e77a65cc8d971991dd24a15ae70af1e327e39f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc30ca155b02b3193ded/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e32ee58f0dd594e17efc42f65b4b3610356dc5a6cc8f2df44a637b1e4393515f","pdfPage":3,"start":1293,"end":3644,"textSha256":"18a3d0d817ccad8944243fcb4a1fe3b26c28aee375a99127a1e1cc5bfdce51db","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fea5b4bce366e2775972d7d820197e49","paperId":"0805.4186","sourceSha256":"c7001313a79dbc9419776d1c5e77a65cc8d971991dd24a15ae70af1e327e39f0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/dc30ca155b02b3193ded/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"e32ee58f0dd594e17efc42f65b4b3610356dc5a6cc8f2df44a637b1e4393515f","pdfPage":14,"start":102,"end":2930,"textSha256":"b5ef78c596e29c2c5ffb35cc5fdcbef41d85269aa844f746c182de6d81a4e5df","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:98d90c99fd204acef3d431d0","recordId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Linked unification, exotic-decoupling and proton-decay targets. Bounds are from 2008; the singlet hierarchy requires a renewed D=F=0 check.","challengeNote":"Linked unification, exotic-decoupling and proton-decay targets remain source-scoped. Bounds are from 2008; hierarchical singlet VEVs require a renewed D=F=0","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c7789ae0fa5ba7c74c2067db0890be3063985ee3c1729f874f4de161ebe7f166","home":{"unitId":"unit:c7789ae0fa5ba7c74c2067db0890be3063985ee3c1729f874f4de161ebe7f166","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:08e506f6e18913013e767c3c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c7789ae0fa5ba7c74c2067db0890be3063985ee3c1729f874f4de161ebe7f166","paperId":"0707.2305","textSha256":"cd54025cc52fdfd45d9101cae377f5ff0264ff51231ff6967aeedd932139a398"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5b26a64cf8d8ad3347f1e4a1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5b26a64cf8d8ad3347f1e4a1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c7789ae0fa5ba7c74c2067db0890be3063985ee3c1729f874f4de161ebe7f166","q025-candidate-region:08e506f6e18913013e767c3c"],"scopeContentSha256":"c1f25d742b038101dace403be0dbe1389744c9bb91ea0403c4a080ad0c335707","placementContentSha256":"629a483b4e5724d0f45b6f398a9c1b6179310d7c31b6fd23ab339480f991d599","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge","leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c7789ae0fa5ba7c74c2067db0890be3063985ee3c1729f874f4de161ebe7f166","paperId":"0707.2305","textSha256":"cd54025cc52fdfd45d9101cae377f5ff0264ff51231ff6967aeedd932139a398"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5b26a64cf8d8ad3347f1e4a1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c7789ae0fa5ba7c74c2067db0890be3063985ee3c1729f874f4de161ebe7f166","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:691003b8ebd007f1f8b9daa3","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:c7789ae0fa5ba7c74c2067db0890be3063985ee3c1729f874f4de161ebe7f166","textSha256":"cd54025cc52fdfd45d9101cae377f5ff0264ff51231ff6967aeedd932139a398"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:53a2ab2059045592cde33c87"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:53a2ab2059045592cde33c87","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c7789ae0fa5ba7c74c2067db0890be3063985ee3c1729f874f4de161ebe7f166","q025-candidate-question:691003b8ebd007f1f8b9daa3"],"scopeContentSha256":"c0dc42175188271a818cc5064b59a1018e586855efe265baf47503e0a84837f4","contributionContentSha256":"023f846cb9fbc9f408d11eb9b78a2944848abf940378d6893674693c0874014c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:c7789ae0fa5ba7c74c2067db0890be3063985ee3c1729f874f4de161ebe7f166","textSha256":"cd54025cc52fdfd45d9101cae377f5ff0264ff51231ff6967aeedd932139a398"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:53a2ab2059045592cde33c87","recordId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-322dd3c2c29bb79958bf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound construction, coupling and scale targets; the description does not specify one string realization.","challengeNote":"Compound construction, coupling and scale targets; no single string realization is specified.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":4,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"1cf68344082c5e8a9f3b4662973b7f00949687cab6427e77faa74ff30fe92bcf"},"organizational-access:2a689298e2cf3e9947e57267":{"id":"organizational-access:2a689298e2cf3e9947e57267","source":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","target":"q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:feb098a3c2dcad34f29a5e6f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f7a9d0a0641433afab67587a3c6e2049c011c48ed13d8324bdf7f0f5e85e135b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:91ba6a9f6f19ae29aa190fc2"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0c27e14149f724ec96bec1d403473b584158d9b52c11bdc1d83e6236bea3c33e","home":{"unitId":"unit:0c27e14149f724ec96bec1d403473b584158d9b52c11bdc1d83e6236bea3c33e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0c27e14149f724ec96bec1d403473b584158d9b52c11bdc1d83e6236bea3c33e","paperId":"2105.01083","textSha256":"8bd29caf4a0155c0883f9d9ed7283d80b7cd4090bf9c6179118592c505ed277b"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e400aa1044caab377141912f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e400aa1044caab377141912f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0c27e14149f724ec96bec1d403473b584158d9b52c11bdc1d83e6236bea3c33e","q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9"],"scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","placementContentSha256":"b16a4a53f5e290e2891ccf4c508b0059f9e4fc9486caf26280afdc8102827520","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0c27e14149f724ec96bec1d403473b584158d9b52c11bdc1d83e6236bea3c33e","paperId":"2105.01083","textSha256":"8bd29caf4a0155c0883f9d9ed7283d80b7cd4090bf9c6179118592c505ed277b"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e400aa1044caab377141912f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0c27e14149f724ec96bec1d403473b584158d9b52c11bdc1d83e6236bea3c33e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:0c27e14149f724ec96bec1d403473b584158d9b52c11bdc1d83e6236bea3c33e","textSha256":"8bd29caf4a0155c0883f9d9ed7283d80b7cd4090bf9c6179118592c505ed277b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5cec87412f8c192fe85fadb4"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5cec87412f8c192fe85fadb4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0c27e14149f724ec96bec1d403473b584158d9b52c11bdc1d83e6236bea3c33e","q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008"],"scopeContentSha256":"f7a9d0a0641433afab67587a3c6e2049c011c48ed13d8324bdf7f0f5e85e135b","contributionContentSha256":"bba0b838b1b399171ea5a0220489fdefe04e62b6810fa789bafce2d9557c255c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d26","kind":"description","unitIndex":26,"unitId":"unit:0c27e14149f724ec96bec1d403473b584158d9b52c11bdc1d83e6236bea3c33e","textSha256":"8bd29caf4a0155c0883f9d9ed7283d80b7cd4090bf9c6179118592c505ed277b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5cec87412f8c192fe85fadb4","recordId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Matter coupling, Einstein-frame acceleration and bounces remain compound targets.","challengeNote":"Matter coupling, Einstein-frame acceleration and bounces remain compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","home":{"unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers the full duality-motivated history: accelerated precursor, nonsingular transition, sufficient inflation and relic signatures.","qualification":"q71 covers the entire proposed history, including the origin and sufficiency of the accelerated precursor, singularity replacement and observable gravitons. q29 covers early expansion and fluctuations but does not establish whole coverage of singularity replacement. q61 covers transition control and surviving predictions, but does not clearly encompass the separate sufficiency-of-inflation inquiry. Frame distinctions remain source-specific, and a smooth interpolation is not a demonstrated self-consistent transition.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","textSha256":"bbe9e37b99550e85f47a8ef86f591a750da6de7b464fbd0086998c59e47d2151"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:competing:u8:q71"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:competing:u8:q71","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9"],"scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","placementContentSha256":"569a618813878485d900addfac3c75b16514dedfb6c6f314ee61d8ed99623b8e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:competing:proposal","placement-pilot:competing:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","textSha256":"bbe9e37b99550e85f47a8ef86f591a750da6de7b464fbd0086998c59e47d2151"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","textSha256":"bbe9e37b99550e85f47a8ef86f591a750da6de7b464fbd0086998c59e47d2151"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5f9a70d84eacf0dbbd91a9235fb6c9ea","paperId":"hep-th/9211021","sourceSha256":"2aae33e6e1a6522b12db43742ed0d6de72e33a714041f261a3b7efb382ed20e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62677d74f8c209112a67/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bd4b0bbaa9329feeea7e0c408f124fd4ccac61b63feffa6ec49b4a9ac52403c4","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2711,"textSha256":"36fe9310318e23f521f3761f2aacd35b582f44a7c1339c063e0d66f89e948f04","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:657f2966c6301b1db27bf4a032b41ea0","paperId":"hep-th/9211021","sourceSha256":"2aae33e6e1a6522b12db43742ed0d6de72e33a714041f261a3b7efb382ed20e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62677d74f8c209112a67/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bd4b0bbaa9329feeea7e0c408f124fd4ccac61b63feffa6ec49b4a9ac52403c4","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2130,"textSha256":"52b8172fd295b0abd28b27a4634b1a6e2830bb908cfe88ba603783bc3f9307f1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d622ca38f64eb4ad8302c4a09b096991","paperId":"hep-th/9211021","sourceSha256":"2aae33e6e1a6522b12db43742ed0d6de72e33a714041f261a3b7efb382ed20e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62677d74f8c209112a67/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bd4b0bbaa9329feeea7e0c408f124fd4ccac61b63feffa6ec49b4a9ac52403c4","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":949,"textSha256":"06b5d9134ca58da817d7be390436813118e3c2d798add9f26045f5bcd9aa7020","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:060299f65c752e09aea8125b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:060299f65c752e09aea8125b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008"],"scopeContentSha256":"f7a9d0a0641433afab67587a3c6e2049c011c48ed13d8324bdf7f0f5e85e135b","contributionContentSha256":"b2bb18a92d973fda45540bae9963de0388c67d988d0dccb18aef6a94c76bf2af","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:5db463a31b136afcdecd696212eaa0890d743e41ae182ccdcd03671e75d81f8f","textSha256":"bbe9e37b99550e85f47a8ef86f591a750da6de7b464fbd0086998c59e47d2151"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5f9a70d84eacf0dbbd91a9235fb6c9ea","paperId":"hep-th/9211021","sourceSha256":"2aae33e6e1a6522b12db43742ed0d6de72e33a714041f261a3b7efb382ed20e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62677d74f8c209112a67/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bd4b0bbaa9329feeea7e0c408f124fd4ccac61b63feffa6ec49b4a9ac52403c4","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2711,"textSha256":"36fe9310318e23f521f3761f2aacd35b582f44a7c1339c063e0d66f89e948f04","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:657f2966c6301b1db27bf4a032b41ea0","paperId":"hep-th/9211021","sourceSha256":"2aae33e6e1a6522b12db43742ed0d6de72e33a714041f261a3b7efb382ed20e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62677d74f8c209112a67/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bd4b0bbaa9329feeea7e0c408f124fd4ccac61b63feffa6ec49b4a9ac52403c4","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":2130,"textSha256":"52b8172fd295b0abd28b27a4634b1a6e2830bb908cfe88ba603783bc3f9307f1","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d622ca38f64eb4ad8302c4a09b096991","paperId":"hep-th/9211021","sourceSha256":"2aae33e6e1a6522b12db43742ed0d6de72e33a714041f261a3b7efb382ed20e3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/62677d74f8c209112a67/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bd4b0bbaa9329feeea7e0c408f124fd4ccac61b63feffa6ec49b4a9ac52403c4","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":949,"textSha256":"06b5d9134ca58da817d7be390436813118e3c2d798add9f26045f5bcd9aa7020","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:060299f65c752e09aea8125b","recordId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"The 1992 source proposes inflation and relic-graviton targets; smooth bounded interpolations lack a fully self-consistent string-source equation of state.","challengeNote":"The 1992 scenario combines inflation, singularity avoidance and relic-graviton targets. Its smooth interpolations lack a fully self-consistent source equation","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:760128930c9993167f1283f7b6ce8d20265bbb5b22f87f33fae24ff2d2f59b0e","home":{"unitId":"unit:760128930c9993167f1283f7b6ce8d20265bbb5b22f87f33fae24ff2d2f59b0e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:760128930c9993167f1283f7b6ce8d20265bbb5b22f87f33fae24ff2d2f59b0e","paperId":"hep-th/0207130","textSha256":"8266a7df9a83406dcd3768862aa028d6a096ff1f068fb9a87a9aafc027ce5b70"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05b4e4c2cba5e0e1881fc415"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05b4e4c2cba5e0e1881fc415","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:760128930c9993167f1283f7b6ce8d20265bbb5b22f87f33fae24ff2d2f59b0e","q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9"],"scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","placementContentSha256":"a585f7f56d68e32cf61af4c081b0f74324d1451e8eb3a869e06a1828d222f819","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:760128930c9993167f1283f7b6ce8d20265bbb5b22f87f33fae24ff2d2f59b0e","paperId":"hep-th/0207130","textSha256":"8266a7df9a83406dcd3768862aa028d6a096ff1f068fb9a87a9aafc027ce5b70"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05b4e4c2cba5e0e1881fc415"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:760128930c9993167f1283f7b6ce8d20265bbb5b22f87f33fae24ff2d2f59b0e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:760128930c9993167f1283f7b6ce8d20265bbb5b22f87f33fae24ff2d2f59b0e","textSha256":"8266a7df9a83406dcd3768862aa028d6a096ff1f068fb9a87a9aafc027ce5b70"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8c2a5488d67da7406a723aa6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8c2a5488d67da7406a723aa6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:760128930c9993167f1283f7b6ce8d20265bbb5b22f87f33fae24ff2d2f59b0e","q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008"],"scopeContentSha256":"f7a9d0a0641433afab67587a3c6e2049c011c48ed13d8324bdf7f0f5e85e135b","contributionContentSha256":"4c139ec4ab5c17536a640e6aa253bbfa4473d15c5d1208a439b204767f211369","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:760128930c9993167f1283f7b6ce8d20265bbb5b22f87f33fae24ff2d2f59b0e","textSha256":"8266a7df9a83406dcd3768862aa028d6a096ff1f068fb9a87a9aafc027ce5b70"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8c2a5488d67da7406a723aa6","recordId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Predictions are explicitly conditioned on uncertainty in the nonperturbative transition.","challengeNote":"Predictions remain conditional on the uncertain nonperturbative transition.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a782de620d0297fda5f2fde2d7797272d9dd6ccde4b952a1441c1bd9f25d52c2","home":{"unitId":"unit:a782de620d0297fda5f2fde2d7797272d9dd6ccde4b952a1441c1bd9f25d52c2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a782de620d0297fda5f2fde2d7797272d9dd6ccde4b952a1441c1bd9f25d52c2","paperId":"2301.06616","textSha256":"39303463dd66ee2d447ee1f04781740ea95ad322c386330884207e669d65fc34"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:968c6ff0ff7403786487a588"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:968c6ff0ff7403786487a588","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a782de620d0297fda5f2fde2d7797272d9dd6ccde4b952a1441c1bd9f25d52c2","q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9"],"scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","placementContentSha256":"316653be23ddf4f88a0e8b64d34e1ef1cb458f4fd2285363d58e32cd3e871515","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a782de620d0297fda5f2fde2d7797272d9dd6ccde4b952a1441c1bd9f25d52c2","paperId":"2301.06616","textSha256":"39303463dd66ee2d447ee1f04781740ea95ad322c386330884207e669d65fc34"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:968c6ff0ff7403786487a588"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a782de620d0297fda5f2fde2d7797272d9dd6ccde4b952a1441c1bd9f25d52c2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:a782de620d0297fda5f2fde2d7797272d9dd6ccde4b952a1441c1bd9f25d52c2","textSha256":"39303463dd66ee2d447ee1f04781740ea95ad322c386330884207e669d65fc34"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e3e0793e1873ab1de8e2f06e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e3e0793e1873ab1de8e2f06e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a782de620d0297fda5f2fde2d7797272d9dd6ccde4b952a1441c1bd9f25d52c2","q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008"],"scopeContentSha256":"f7a9d0a0641433afab67587a3c6e2049c011c48ed13d8324bdf7f0f5e85e135b","contributionContentSha256":"067272f506a293ed7671d4a98014aeb787e691677a2ff5b5f57a06ba15299fa4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:a782de620d0297fda5f2fde2d7797272d9dd6ccde4b952a1441c1bd9f25d52c2","textSha256":"39303463dd66ee2d447ee1f04781740ea95ad322c386330884207e669d65fc34"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e3e0793e1873ab1de8e2f06e","recordId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Anisotropic stability and shifted-dilaton branch changes are distinct targets; all-order α′ treatment is not inferred.","challengeNote":"Anisotropic stability and branch changes are compound targets; all-order α′ dependence is not specified.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","home":{"unitId":"unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","paperId":"2412.02630","textSha256":"61e8d336c9b31b0112a8ca83d698d6c58e8df5ebe450204911b8e598ad210cc1"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ae1cbf516f8ebf07c0559772"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ae1cbf516f8ebf07c0559772","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9"],"scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","placementContentSha256":"3148d1d630a55ba44f3b33dd72db2df27226c51546bc1550160c990fa7fd10c1","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","paperId":"2412.02630","textSha256":"61e8d336c9b31b0112a8ca83d698d6c58e8df5ebe450204911b8e598ad210cc1"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ae1cbf516f8ebf07c0559772"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","textSha256":"61e8d336c9b31b0112a8ca83d698d6c58e8df5ebe450204911b8e598ad210cc1"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:418b2a758297b4aa986df42f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:418b2a758297b4aa986df42f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008"],"scopeContentSha256":"f7a9d0a0641433afab67587a3c6e2049c011c48ed13d8324bdf7f0f5e85e135b","contributionContentSha256":"89b01ba522fc95709c1568d367d1d648939e3ce3bde61ae662c1678cdcf8bb57","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:cef07c15b4b38b85a2996c2464febf083197451f7df273b14a179680130de635","textSha256":"61e8d336c9b31b0112a8ca83d698d6c58e8df5ebe450204911b8e598ad210cc1"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:418b2a758297b4aa986df42f","recordId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Material compound targets: acceleration, effective stabilization, matter gravity and bounces. Source-scoped access does not establish atomicity.","challengeNote":"Compound acceleration, effective stabilization, modified matter gravity and bounce targets; singleton access does not assert atomicity.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f8fe0bbe8ea2539d7113f239f3978c9f288f399b457960cbc0aa8254a5152335","home":{"unitId":"unit:f8fe0bbe8ea2539d7113f239f3978c9f288f399b457960cbc0aa8254a5152335","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f8fe0bbe8ea2539d7113f239f3978c9f288f399b457960cbc0aa8254a5152335","paperId":"hep-th/0703055","textSha256":"3af6912d0ffd722222fcc8637f17b6c43c99308943dd6f16373e414dcf1674a3"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:567899bcfb92b2f9619245cf"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:567899bcfb92b2f9619245cf","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f8fe0bbe8ea2539d7113f239f3978c9f288f399b457960cbc0aa8254a5152335","q025-candidate-region:0935e91b314397cc105ab6d9"],"scopeContentSha256":"cca79f5ec3b2a73e3c58fa389e6815fa9eb541759a02d8ddd959ec7c1fe09f28","placementContentSha256":"14745b388b56de2af5a50cbc2ac7661208bc8c927f17329c0da5f2a02cec41de","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f8fe0bbe8ea2539d7113f239f3978c9f288f399b457960cbc0aa8254a5152335","paperId":"hep-th/0703055","textSha256":"3af6912d0ffd722222fcc8637f17b6c43c99308943dd6f16373e414dcf1674a3"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:567899bcfb92b2f9619245cf"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f8fe0bbe8ea2539d7113f239f3978c9f288f399b457960cbc0aa8254a5152335","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d48","kind":"description","unitIndex":48,"unitId":"unit:f8fe0bbe8ea2539d7113f239f3978c9f288f399b457960cbc0aa8254a5152335","textSha256":"3af6912d0ffd722222fcc8637f17b6c43c99308943dd6f16373e414dcf1674a3"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f2b3a1b240c1624e05a80d67"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f2b3a1b240c1624e05a80d67","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f8fe0bbe8ea2539d7113f239f3978c9f288f399b457960cbc0aa8254a5152335","q025-candidate-question:e5ef163bacf31a7749e56008"],"scopeContentSha256":"f7a9d0a0641433afab67587a3c6e2049c011c48ed13d8324bdf7f0f5e85e135b","contributionContentSha256":"7c2d931508ef97f60b21b8ff912b71b6d79141231a6912fd42ed9728f04d7fe2","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d48","kind":"description","unitIndex":48,"unitId":"unit:f8fe0bbe8ea2539d7113f239f3978c9f288f399b457960cbc0aa8254a5152335","textSha256":"3af6912d0ffd722222fcc8637f17b6c43c99308943dd6f16373e414dcf1674a3"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f2b3a1b240c1624e05a80d67","recordId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1a6ed099f0ad715a2e8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The weak-curvature precursor, nonsingular exit and observable spectra are compound targets.","challengeNote":"The weakly coupled, low-curvature past, nonsingular exit and primordial spectra are compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":6,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"12a189385760bca2e92815588f35639bbd4309c109cf6e51cdcbc0f5e1e5f652"},"organizational-access:7ac6d91da6505cbf9cf6483e":{"id":"organizational-access:7ac6d91da6505cbf9cf6483e","source":"q025-candidate-region:0ce3bf14ba7042ce2e1bd053","target":"q025-candidate-question:c99736bc225f5437e6ec9f2c","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:0ce3bf14ba7042ce2e1bd053","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"74ac9a4db2ccd141d9616006a94c65d59200ca947f3c71b21343771edb4210ad","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:796d8e81e059cf233f30610d"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c99736bc225f5437e6ec9f2c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"78b80e7a9a38fc284f1f0b4905be3c03d83800a4c4b2900ece87236c6a0c2f58","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:bf2e26325b8192571dc748cd"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:e1722646067e81c5a7fd5593808bb50f234b3b5687ff83629a4da3e8f29aff03","home":{"unitId":"unit:e1722646067e81c5a7fd5593808bb50f234b3b5687ff83629a4da3e8f29aff03","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:0ce3bf14ba7042ce2e1bd053","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e1722646067e81c5a7fd5593808bb50f234b3b5687ff83629a4da3e8f29aff03","paperId":"2407.15445","textSha256":"50da0e9ff118932b9ee8e4fe63179d8df32504ec4853fc5fa61c48d4fe754ddc"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c29009d09f0fac88e65d58f2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c29009d09f0fac88e65d58f2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e1722646067e81c5a7fd5593808bb50f234b3b5687ff83629a4da3e8f29aff03","q025-candidate-region:0ce3bf14ba7042ce2e1bd053"],"scopeContentSha256":"74ac9a4db2ccd141d9616006a94c65d59200ca947f3c71b21343771edb4210ad","placementContentSha256":"19b49b5312b9ab5139ec65d263596aa6df57592859f3c008267416d3ff3b3401","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge","leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e1722646067e81c5a7fd5593808bb50f234b3b5687ff83629a4da3e8f29aff03","paperId":"2407.15445","textSha256":"50da0e9ff118932b9ee8e4fe63179d8df32504ec4853fc5fa61c48d4fe754ddc"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c29009d09f0fac88e65d58f2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e1722646067e81c5a7fd5593808bb50f234b3b5687ff83629a4da3e8f29aff03","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c99736bc225f5437e6ec9f2c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:e1722646067e81c5a7fd5593808bb50f234b3b5687ff83629a4da3e8f29aff03","textSha256":"50da0e9ff118932b9ee8e4fe63179d8df32504ec4853fc5fa61c48d4fe754ddc"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:68f4e97c7ebf3f0ba29f4386"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:68f4e97c7ebf3f0ba29f4386","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e1722646067e81c5a7fd5593808bb50f234b3b5687ff83629a4da3e8f29aff03","q025-candidate-question:c99736bc225f5437e6ec9f2c"],"scopeContentSha256":"78b80e7a9a38fc284f1f0b4905be3c03d83800a4c4b2900ece87236c6a0c2f58","contributionContentSha256":"9308044386e11cd39e0a404ae7abcb373e1e90b5019104e60f057fa7647d450d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-proposal","leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:e1722646067e81c5a7fd5593808bb50f234b3b5687ff83629a4da3e8f29aff03","textSha256":"50da0e9ff118932b9ee8e4fe63179d8df32504ec4853fc5fa61c48d4fe754ddc"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:68f4e97c7ebf3f0ba29f4386","recordId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-297710f585b0edbffa67-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound CMB, PBH, induced-wave and conjecture-testing objectives retained within the low-scale SUSY potential question.","challengeNote":"Compound CMB, PBH, induced-wave and conjecture-testing objectives remain source-scoped.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"b0cedd9d4108eb476b2941e53038fe1471a5387a3e65ff6ed362b668fa178572"},"organizational-access:4fe80ea5aea94e4d1dc16d67":{"id":"organizational-access:4fe80ea5aea94e4d1dc16d67","source":"q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f","target":"q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"07f03ce1ff096f6decad953599d2576bf2a2c64f0201272a3a194992b5aa3bf5","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:704e11df59f0bb80f98be66e"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"93876315d69f2174aefd5e0fbc52f5a74fc389ca489ba711a61a8b7cb1452985","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ec8a3a2ac2e50f234095c047"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:02dd298620e4d0edea3b1967b2805c4362f55a80a94cd7e4f6e28d5ad27a8ce2","home":{"unitId":"unit:02dd298620e4d0edea3b1967b2805c4362f55a80a94cd7e4f6e28d5ad27a8ce2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:02dd298620e4d0edea3b1967b2805c4362f55a80a94cd7e4f6e28d5ad27a8ce2","paperId":"2412.07842","textSha256":"65cea7adf4f5d7f5448c52d12fd5bb315b923a23fadd98131649aab22bcad61c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:11e1095ff33251857f1b71c1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:11e1095ff33251857f1b71c1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:02dd298620e4d0edea3b1967b2805c4362f55a80a94cd7e4f6e28d5ad27a8ce2","q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f"],"scopeContentSha256":"07f03ce1ff096f6decad953599d2576bf2a2c64f0201272a3a194992b5aa3bf5","placementContentSha256":"fce6d1abc839e1c9a2759b20473a8524d7821b7b5a87912e3fbb913c25815d7a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge","leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:02dd298620e4d0edea3b1967b2805c4362f55a80a94cd7e4f6e28d5ad27a8ce2","paperId":"2412.07842","textSha256":"65cea7adf4f5d7f5448c52d12fd5bb315b923a23fadd98131649aab22bcad61c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:11e1095ff33251857f1b71c1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:02dd298620e4d0edea3b1967b2805c4362f55a80a94cd7e4f6e28d5ad27a8ce2","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:02dd298620e4d0edea3b1967b2805c4362f55a80a94cd7e4f6e28d5ad27a8ce2","textSha256":"65cea7adf4f5d7f5448c52d12fd5bb315b923a23fadd98131649aab22bcad61c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:53ae5fd9f8a6f02e2d81167f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:53ae5fd9f8a6f02e2d81167f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:02dd298620e4d0edea3b1967b2805c4362f55a80a94cd7e4f6e28d5ad27a8ce2","q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1"],"scopeContentSha256":"93876315d69f2174aefd5e0fbc52f5a74fc389ca489ba711a61a8b7cb1452985","contributionContentSha256":"7e2f522aa9a321f1377653bbba95542f64f3292c9386a64edd3ad304a66c058c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:02dd298620e4d0edea3b1967b2805c4362f55a80a94cd7e4f6e28d5ad27a8ce2","textSha256":"65cea7adf4f5d7f5448c52d12fd5bb315b923a23fadd98131649aab22bcad61c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:53ae5fd9f8a6f02e2d81167f","recordId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"D_N (2,0) SymTFT/global variants and the gravitational/R-symmetry anomaly polynomial are distinct targets.","challengeNote":"SymTFT/global variants and the gravitational/R-symmetry anomaly polynomial require compound-target reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:21adb8beb4946e2b9502b04652a5b53a18232d153501b17a3a45925114705ce3","home":{"unitId":"unit:21adb8beb4946e2b9502b04652a5b53a18232d153501b17a3a45925114705ce3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:21adb8beb4946e2b9502b04652a5b53a18232d153501b17a3a45925114705ce3","paperId":"2206.07073","textSha256":"f66c63ffa192e43992c4a1b5a379a779feeae5c55825f2ddc39045af792e8491"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3d5952e1acb65518bbb257fc"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3d5952e1acb65518bbb257fc","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:21adb8beb4946e2b9502b04652a5b53a18232d153501b17a3a45925114705ce3","q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f"],"scopeContentSha256":"07f03ce1ff096f6decad953599d2576bf2a2c64f0201272a3a194992b5aa3bf5","placementContentSha256":"8d6083055f45e09e7aade68698eace36ac8c01863ca006300a828fa9a0ebe938","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge","leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:21adb8beb4946e2b9502b04652a5b53a18232d153501b17a3a45925114705ce3","paperId":"2206.07073","textSha256":"f66c63ffa192e43992c4a1b5a379a779feeae5c55825f2ddc39045af792e8491"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3d5952e1acb65518bbb257fc"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:21adb8beb4946e2b9502b04652a5b53a18232d153501b17a3a45925114705ce3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:21adb8beb4946e2b9502b04652a5b53a18232d153501b17a3a45925114705ce3","textSha256":"f66c63ffa192e43992c4a1b5a379a779feeae5c55825f2ddc39045af792e8491"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b2f66b3ac4834b64034332f2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b2f66b3ac4834b64034332f2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:21adb8beb4946e2b9502b04652a5b53a18232d153501b17a3a45925114705ce3","q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1"],"scopeContentSha256":"93876315d69f2174aefd5e0fbc52f5a74fc389ca489ba711a61a8b7cb1452985","contributionContentSha256":"63a95fa2e668dc8121dfa965ae4c31f0385d64f574f739d5f40e1156a44c1075","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:21adb8beb4946e2b9502b04652a5b53a18232d153501b17a3a45925114705ce3","textSha256":"f66c63ffa192e43992c4a1b5a379a779feeae5c55825f2ddc39045af792e8491"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b2f66b3ac4834b64034332f2","recordId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Six-dimensional mixed anomalies and four-dimensional M-ality defect construction are distinct linked targets.","challengeNote":"Six-dimensional mixed anomalies and four-dimensional M-ality defects are distinct linked targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:464b08b6201ce086f0769d74260c6a8e315cf80261d793fbb7e9140fc48b1e8d","home":{"unitId":"unit:464b08b6201ce086f0769d74260c6a8e315cf80261d793fbb7e9140fc48b1e8d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:464b08b6201ce086f0769d74260c6a8e315cf80261d793fbb7e9140fc48b1e8d","paperId":"2106.14912","textSha256":"5eb2e1fdc45384af08222b8ce8bcbab8f30271fb683f5aa28ed7c45dcf6c0a8b"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:00e76bf2f47887178aa7a1ae"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:00e76bf2f47887178aa7a1ae","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:464b08b6201ce086f0769d74260c6a8e315cf80261d793fbb7e9140fc48b1e8d","q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f"],"scopeContentSha256":"07f03ce1ff096f6decad953599d2576bf2a2c64f0201272a3a194992b5aa3bf5","placementContentSha256":"d7ffed79293b758052b7ec1230d26401c8e6d717368f7939f917d6830d4e5ebb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge","leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:464b08b6201ce086f0769d74260c6a8e315cf80261d793fbb7e9140fc48b1e8d","paperId":"2106.14912","textSha256":"5eb2e1fdc45384af08222b8ce8bcbab8f30271fb683f5aa28ed7c45dcf6c0a8b"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:00e76bf2f47887178aa7a1ae"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:464b08b6201ce086f0769d74260c6a8e315cf80261d793fbb7e9140fc48b1e8d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d17","kind":"description","unitIndex":17,"unitId":"unit:464b08b6201ce086f0769d74260c6a8e315cf80261d793fbb7e9140fc48b1e8d","textSha256":"5eb2e1fdc45384af08222b8ce8bcbab8f30271fb683f5aa28ed7c45dcf6c0a8b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3dc619710fd62be3019ffdce"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3dc619710fd62be3019ffdce","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:464b08b6201ce086f0769d74260c6a8e315cf80261d793fbb7e9140fc48b1e8d","q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1"],"scopeContentSha256":"93876315d69f2174aefd5e0fbc52f5a74fc389ca489ba711a61a8b7cb1452985","contributionContentSha256":"703c9e8be882ce23ab9d36ddcfca9906649c18ff23f5c7b28b60f74598ca1135","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d17","kind":"description","unitIndex":17,"unitId":"unit:464b08b6201ce086f0769d74260c6a8e315cf80261d793fbb7e9140fc48b1e8d","textSha256":"5eb2e1fdc45384af08222b8ce8bcbab8f30271fb683f5aa28ed7c45dcf6c0a8b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3dc619710fd62be3019ffdce","recordId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Circle-lift obstructions and BPS-string constraints on six-dimensional geometry are distinct compound targets.","challengeNote":"Circle-lift obstructions and BPS-string constraints are distinct compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5b5884b2db3e7b991d33967b45e0ee452a4c7eb82b9e8e735d92b622d695d340","home":{"unitId":"unit:5b5884b2db3e7b991d33967b45e0ee452a4c7eb82b9e8e735d92b622d695d340","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5b5884b2db3e7b991d33967b45e0ee452a4c7eb82b9e8e735d92b622d695d340","paperId":"hep-th/9703167","textSha256":"672190fd2a3909ca5e76ccf53b29d47d3e0347c640d5f4caf085cccc93da2195"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6f26deb8378f768aef79ac6492e5caf3","paperId":"hep-th/9703167","sourceSha256":"9b5d4eb1c890f8a2e9c3f4ffac95ff0620e10b2f941e0ebd9f89b72588e941a2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7b28a5f81b06625f9cc4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7963a4eaa24b8223276afe4ac0b6fbb90d30b6f336583966b680e2fc1c03e4ce","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2677,"textSha256":"7a7f95cbbf25759f22b885ad22c044fd29ed7665989fcff1b520fb560d212479","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eb48f6fc322ada9f3ebdebe6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eb48f6fc322ada9f3ebdebe6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5b5884b2db3e7b991d33967b45e0ee452a4c7eb82b9e8e735d92b622d695d340","q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f"],"scopeContentSha256":"07f03ce1ff096f6decad953599d2576bf2a2c64f0201272a3a194992b5aa3bf5","placementContentSha256":"0d4d2a1a8c433b2ed5699ea9c34eb8577608b3777241ae63bcfe35482d8bf975","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge","leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5b5884b2db3e7b991d33967b45e0ee452a4c7eb82b9e8e735d92b622d695d340","paperId":"hep-th/9703167","textSha256":"672190fd2a3909ca5e76ccf53b29d47d3e0347c640d5f4caf085cccc93da2195"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6f26deb8378f768aef79ac6492e5caf3","paperId":"hep-th/9703167","sourceSha256":"9b5d4eb1c890f8a2e9c3f4ffac95ff0620e10b2f941e0ebd9f89b72588e941a2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7b28a5f81b06625f9cc4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7963a4eaa24b8223276afe4ac0b6fbb90d30b6f336583966b680e2fc1c03e4ce","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2677,"textSha256":"7a7f95cbbf25759f22b885ad22c044fd29ed7665989fcff1b520fb560d212479","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:eb48f6fc322ada9f3ebdebe6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5b5884b2db3e7b991d33967b45e0ee452a4c7eb82b9e8e735d92b622d695d340","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d35","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:5b5884b2db3e7b991d33967b45e0ee452a4c7eb82b9e8e735d92b622d695d340","textSha256":"672190fd2a3909ca5e76ccf53b29d47d3e0347c640d5f4caf085cccc93da2195"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6f26deb8378f768aef79ac6492e5caf3","paperId":"hep-th/9703167","sourceSha256":"9b5d4eb1c890f8a2e9c3f4ffac95ff0620e10b2f941e0ebd9f89b72588e941a2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7b28a5f81b06625f9cc4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7963a4eaa24b8223276afe4ac0b6fbb90d30b6f336583966b680e2fc1c03e4ce","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2677,"textSha256":"7a7f95cbbf25759f22b885ad22c044fd29ed7665989fcff1b520fb560d212479","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a373c238817ba23d28ae3b22"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a373c238817ba23d28ae3b22","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5b5884b2db3e7b991d33967b45e0ee452a4c7eb82b9e8e735d92b622d695d340","q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1"],"scopeContentSha256":"93876315d69f2174aefd5e0fbc52f5a74fc389ca489ba711a61a8b7cb1452985","contributionContentSha256":"9052cccb374327b4340ea5ce75d123b2333eb2e880c4541bf8bf273fea122f0a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d35","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:5b5884b2db3e7b991d33967b45e0ee452a4c7eb82b9e8e735d92b622d695d340","textSha256":"672190fd2a3909ca5e76ccf53b29d47d3e0347c640d5f4caf085cccc93da2195"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6f26deb8378f768aef79ac6492e5caf3","paperId":"hep-th/9703167","sourceSha256":"9b5d4eb1c890f8a2e9c3f4ffac95ff0620e10b2f941e0ebd9f89b72588e941a2","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/7b28a5f81b06625f9cc4/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"7963a4eaa24b8223276afe4ac0b6fbb90d30b6f336583966b680e2fc1c03e4ce","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2677,"textSha256":"7a7f95cbbf25759f22b885ad22c044fd29ed7665989fcff1b520fb560d212479","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a373c238817ba23d28ae3b22","recordId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":1,"proposalNote":"General global-anomaly tests and N=1 critical-theory realizations are linked but compound source targets.","challengeNote":"Global-anomaly tests start after local cancellation and need not assume supersymmetry; N=1 critical-theory realization is a further compound target.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d104d03f21c890c60e82e263d76a5c415f6840f79c40d09591a6cf5f4aec245d","home":{"unitId":"unit:d104d03f21c890c60e82e263d76a5c415f6840f79c40d09591a6cf5f4aec245d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d104d03f21c890c60e82e263d76a5c415f6840f79c40d09591a6cf5f4aec245d","paperId":"hep-th/9606008","textSha256":"ccdbb252528d3023c8a69e7792254ec1b216d3ed92cf0c6b87cd7b633217ad24"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d8a064aaf86d0770bbced698"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d8a064aaf86d0770bbced698","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d104d03f21c890c60e82e263d76a5c415f6840f79c40d09591a6cf5f4aec245d","q025-candidate-region:132653e4842cd11f883cf50f"],"scopeContentSha256":"07f03ce1ff096f6decad953599d2576bf2a2c64f0201272a3a194992b5aa3bf5","placementContentSha256":"32c402ab253310c71b35216fe02652f22778f2ebb85cceb864bfb8bb408ac635","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge","leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d104d03f21c890c60e82e263d76a5c415f6840f79c40d09591a6cf5f4aec245d","paperId":"hep-th/9606008","textSha256":"ccdbb252528d3023c8a69e7792254ec1b216d3ed92cf0c6b87cd7b633217ad24"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d8a064aaf86d0770bbced698"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d104d03f21c890c60e82e263d76a5c415f6840f79c40d09591a6cf5f4aec245d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:d104d03f21c890c60e82e263d76a5c415f6840f79c40d09591a6cf5f4aec245d","textSha256":"ccdbb252528d3023c8a69e7792254ec1b216d3ed92cf0c6b87cd7b633217ad24"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a2e13674cc619cac013bb952"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a2e13674cc619cac013bb952","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d104d03f21c890c60e82e263d76a5c415f6840f79c40d09591a6cf5f4aec245d","q025-candidate-question:8ac84633ffd36f03ff5415c1"],"scopeContentSha256":"93876315d69f2174aefd5e0fbc52f5a74fc389ca489ba711a61a8b7cb1452985","contributionContentSha256":"ae920ae52696b8fbc938a30046610f4508f7df74c34aef4da936e3da0ab17646","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:d104d03f21c890c60e82e263d76a5c415f6840f79c40d09591a6cf5f4aec245d","textSha256":"ccdbb252528d3023c8a69e7792254ec1b216d3ed92cf0c6b87cd7b633217ad24"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a2e13674cc619cac013bb952","recordId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bc459549ef9e43d5a378-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Smooth versus singular worldvolumes can distinguish spectra with the same homological data.","challengeNote":"Smooth and singular worldvolumes remain separate spectral possibilities despite matching homological data.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":5,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a5c76c0c80c318bbe03313aadebe126d868da2fd282b921d3d84c27c4a7b6405"},"organizational-access:3c198c09417140c385e40273":{"id":"organizational-access:3c198c09417140c385e40273","source":"q025-candidate-region:139051eb76d87f1a2cfa30ba","target":"q025-candidate-question:c8f35deffa4a53b237ad4c9a","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:139051eb76d87f1a2cfa30ba","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"7ffaa5aaec5ad300f8f6e39a613535c1f1d2de388a843867fdb4e604549ad533","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0f1729dfea93aec59f63f109"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c8f35deffa4a53b237ad4c9a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"81ffec11d23aa27f6e0496c288733969e4343fdae57722a431775bfb25b12f0e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2f56c35e281173fe9fc6961c"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:b9727b497eb2c8ee4f188290a4557928a0e78fff0bc70d827ec654cd153a047f","home":{"unitId":"unit:b9727b497eb2c8ee4f188290a4557928a0e78fff0bc70d827ec654cd153a047f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:139051eb76d87f1a2cfa30ba","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b9727b497eb2c8ee4f188290a4557928a0e78fff0bc70d827ec654cd153a047f","paperId":"2609.14650","textSha256":"36483f6942b501246bf66761563b18827006f266627dfda6386622f4b8dc3e40"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7a06a6c6406d95d62d79e437"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7a06a6c6406d95d62d79e437","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b9727b497eb2c8ee4f188290a4557928a0e78fff0bc70d827ec654cd153a047f","q025-candidate-region:139051eb76d87f1a2cfa30ba"],"scopeContentSha256":"7ffaa5aaec5ad300f8f6e39a613535c1f1d2de388a843867fdb4e604549ad533","placementContentSha256":"9823f6aad57f8c641af40f60300d95f16890a315bd3ba1302999e8d6a003ba60","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-proposal","successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b9727b497eb2c8ee4f188290a4557928a0e78fff0bc70d827ec654cd153a047f","paperId":"2609.14650","textSha256":"36483f6942b501246bf66761563b18827006f266627dfda6386622f4b8dc3e40"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7a06a6c6406d95d62d79e437"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b9727b497eb2c8ee4f188290a4557928a0e78fff0bc70d827ec654cd153a047f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c8f35deffa4a53b237ad4c9a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:b9727b497eb2c8ee4f188290a4557928a0e78fff0bc70d827ec654cd153a047f","textSha256":"36483f6942b501246bf66761563b18827006f266627dfda6386622f4b8dc3e40"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d1f06c5abc86a95d54c16765","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound proposed loop-suppression and vacuum-density targets; no quantitative validation or observational agreement is supplied. Independent challenge qualification: Compound loop-suppression and vacuum-density proposals. pf56 identifies a proposed method, not verified suppression or observational agreement."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d1f06c5abc86a95d54c16765","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b9727b497eb2c8ee4f188290a4557928a0e78fff0bc70d827ec654cd153a047f","q025-candidate-question:c8f35deffa4a53b237ad4c9a"],"scopeContentSha256":"81ffec11d23aa27f6e0496c288733969e4343fdae57722a431775bfb25b12f0e","contributionContentSha256":"37760e5d2a2698bb59f6affa321f6b8f93d46ddd8da3cf86fdd62b66ccd78ea2","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-proposal","successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:b9727b497eb2c8ee4f188290a4557928a0e78fff0bc70d827ec654cd153a047f","textSha256":"36483f6942b501246bf66761563b18827006f266627dfda6386622f4b8dc3e40"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d1f06c5abc86a95d54c16765","recordId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound proposed loop-suppression and vacuum-density targets; no quantitative validation or observational agreement is supplied.","challengeNote":"Compound loop-suppression and vacuum-density proposals. pf56 identifies a proposed method, not verified suppression or observational agreement.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f6ef5a553715cf402c36e9c967ad8769478206198c6ab52024b64173f8e8a212","home":{"unitId":"unit:f6ef5a553715cf402c36e9c967ad8769478206198c6ab52024b64173f8e8a212","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:139051eb76d87f1a2cfa30ba","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f6ef5a553715cf402c36e9c967ad8769478206198c6ab52024b64173f8e8a212","paperId":"1912.01878","textSha256":"5c6d9634485daccb6b6a4e469529e0a67f551728b5f063c9cf6746299b6c46a8"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7b23809547fad7c3f5b0ce50"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7b23809547fad7c3f5b0ce50","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f6ef5a553715cf402c36e9c967ad8769478206198c6ab52024b64173f8e8a212","q025-candidate-region:139051eb76d87f1a2cfa30ba"],"scopeContentSha256":"7ffaa5aaec5ad300f8f6e39a613535c1f1d2de388a843867fdb4e604549ad533","placementContentSha256":"34c8aef76777aac8c8a40f4382d6fe0137ee4636817b842935ba6e0c538dd235","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-proposal","successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f6ef5a553715cf402c36e9c967ad8769478206198c6ab52024b64173f8e8a212","paperId":"1912.01878","textSha256":"5c6d9634485daccb6b6a4e469529e0a67f551728b5f063c9cf6746299b6c46a8"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7b23809547fad7c3f5b0ce50"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f6ef5a553715cf402c36e9c967ad8769478206198c6ab52024b64173f8e8a212","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c8f35deffa4a53b237ad4c9a","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d29","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:f6ef5a553715cf402c36e9c967ad8769478206198c6ab52024b64173f8e8a212","textSha256":"5c6d9634485daccb6b6a4e469529e0a67f551728b5f063c9cf6746299b6c46a8"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3e002e820ea5afc4a672c9fe","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound accelerator-access, microscopic-causality and inflationary-correction targets. Independent challenge qualification: Compound accelerator-access, hidden microscopic-causality and inflationary-correction targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3e002e820ea5afc4a672c9fe","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f6ef5a553715cf402c36e9c967ad8769478206198c6ab52024b64173f8e8a212","q025-candidate-question:c8f35deffa4a53b237ad4c9a"],"scopeContentSha256":"81ffec11d23aa27f6e0496c288733969e4343fdae57722a431775bfb25b12f0e","contributionContentSha256":"a7e0a8a113b991214cfb62748f5398739911311a35fb8715955037e48f0478b8","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-proposal","successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d29","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:f6ef5a553715cf402c36e9c967ad8769478206198c6ab52024b64173f8e8a212","textSha256":"5c6d9634485daccb6b6a4e469529e0a67f551728b5f063c9cf6746299b6c46a8"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3e002e820ea5afc4a672c9fe","recordId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor2-leaf-ce36cae0274019373c8a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound accelerator-access, microscopic-causality and inflationary-correction targets.","challengeNote":"Compound accelerator-access, hidden microscopic-causality and inflationary-correction targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"dced60f644df04aef2b5d3d17e579125f8289803893a6031488d0d94e0d66ed4"},"organizational-access:4c5f561f7253fc6208e9ca88":{"id":"organizational-access:4c5f561f7253fc6208e9ca88","source":"q025-candidate-region:16e7a3854c88582d05e83321","target":"q025-candidate-question:f47afed6dc69bcafc6bc3e0c","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:16e7a3854c88582d05e83321","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"be902d854d1e25647dc75525e19150d267df2d93e2480b708945de7e7cf3bd3e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:86644f2772d9aa5a774b38b5"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:f47afed6dc69bcafc6bc3e0c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"43c89130a0d9351e93b66ee990f3825b3882bdc0b9ec6bdf029e8d8907a9cef8","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:a1bf1304408bf0c3ecb201e4"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:37ac3dbdbd50f86d908f774d21085510f480714b6e1753b18126d1c6240f6d50","home":{"unitId":"unit:37ac3dbdbd50f86d908f774d21085510f480714b6e1753b18126d1c6240f6d50","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:16e7a3854c88582d05e83321","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:37ac3dbdbd50f86d908f774d21085510f480714b6e1753b18126d1c6240f6d50","paperId":"2201.03660","textSha256":"2dc291eaed73f9b2ae14ecd99308746f8b240b5ff016ce3aa9e6da268310eaec"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4406ba07352bf1389b9a62cc"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4406ba07352bf1389b9a62cc","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:37ac3dbdbd50f86d908f774d21085510f480714b6e1753b18126d1c6240f6d50","q025-candidate-region:16e7a3854c88582d05e83321"],"scopeContentSha256":"be902d854d1e25647dc75525e19150d267df2d93e2480b708945de7e7cf3bd3e","placementContentSha256":"629a1811c7c6bb6e086c9e25ded3adfb05b492398fe6527dcf4392e91644b913","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge","leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:37ac3dbdbd50f86d908f774d21085510f480714b6e1753b18126d1c6240f6d50","paperId":"2201.03660","textSha256":"2dc291eaed73f9b2ae14ecd99308746f8b240b5ff016ce3aa9e6da268310eaec"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4406ba07352bf1389b9a62cc"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:37ac3dbdbd50f86d908f774d21085510f480714b6e1753b18126d1c6240f6d50","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:f47afed6dc69bcafc6bc3e0c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:37ac3dbdbd50f86d908f774d21085510f480714b6e1753b18126d1c6240f6d50","textSha256":"2dc291eaed73f9b2ae14ecd99308746f8b240b5ff016ce3aa9e6da268310eaec"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f258fef7a6b8b6d0b5963529","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Linked targets: first-operator and spin-2 gaps versus internal-Laplacian and KK bounds. Independent challenge qualification: Linked targets: first-operator and spin-2 gaps versus internal-Laplacian and KK bounds."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f258fef7a6b8b6d0b5963529","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:37ac3dbdbd50f86d908f774d21085510f480714b6e1753b18126d1c6240f6d50","q025-candidate-question:f47afed6dc69bcafc6bc3e0c"],"scopeContentSha256":"43c89130a0d9351e93b66ee990f3825b3882bdc0b9ec6bdf029e8d8907a9cef8","contributionContentSha256":"422181994a6eace491c761d7e7bbbc8189979089b26c10edcb54828a6f9bb5e1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal","leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:37ac3dbdbd50f86d908f774d21085510f480714b6e1753b18126d1c6240f6d50","textSha256":"2dc291eaed73f9b2ae14ecd99308746f8b240b5ff016ce3aa9e6da268310eaec"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f258fef7a6b8b6d0b5963529","recordId":"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Linked targets: first-operator and spin-2 gaps versus internal-Laplacian and KK bounds.","challengeNote":"Linked targets: first-operator and spin-2 gaps versus internal-Laplacian and KK bounds.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"e31c3669786342cba7578e6ab0222565844d3971b74040020a7873e3dec824e2"},"organizational-access:cb85c162a6cea79623594dc3":{"id":"organizational-access:cb85c162a6cea79623594dc3","source":"q025-candidate-region:1be95b360ae1e67db1740fe6","target":"q025-candidate-question:10e333580bdbf051baa6cb7f","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:1be95b360ae1e67db1740fe6","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"607680562d8b7d901e873cedd67b88d5ad42c04e34fcf609d5a42f9a9efaee2f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:103b6a6f75c3dbb11baef3a4"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:10e333580bdbf051baa6cb7f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f9d634703fa0fa78015ea0f7dd3676bdb9a5dfe0a5a39ded02758e715a6fbb79","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:bc904837588a3fd836c4e2b5"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","home":{"unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:1be95b360ae1e67db1740fe6","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines universal consistent reduction, massive-mode retention, resulting four-dimensional gaugings, AdS vacua and subtruncations within the compactification family.","qualification":"Whole composite supergravity target; retain every stated branch and no universal stability conclusion.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","paperId":"1110.5327","textSha256":"e8ec3115be3c89d2a146767159855bae9b1142fe39ddf3d3f3e513dc23a14b54"}],"decisionId":"decision:explicit-cut-03:placement-continuation-0019:u16:q19"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:explicit-cut-03:placement-continuation-0019:u16:q19","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","q025-candidate-region:1be95b360ae1e67db1740fe6"],"scopeContentSha256":"607680562d8b7d901e873cedd67b88d5ad42c04e34fcf609d5a42f9a9efaee2f","placementContentSha256":"5f47063a4adae5f6b493872c02298112c902cd7e29613a8238b73bbe92985917","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_exact_whole_or_compound_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-cut-03:placement-continuation-0019:proposal","explicit-cut-03:placement-continuation-0019:challenge","root:explicit-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","paperId":"1110.5327","textSha256":"e8ec3115be3c89d2a146767159855bae9b1142fe39ddf3d3f3e513dc23a14b54"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-03/admission.json","sha256":"5b6b7da34396186993a8ef61e55aeed43d5e0f46a341da8375feb2433acaa490"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/exception-intake.json","sha256":"e2c8feedca7ab901585b3a3f046fa6900d1fb60eec30b2dd8f668d09a2d15a7b","bytes":7068293,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0019","unitRef":"u16"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:10e333580bdbf051baa6cb7f","role":"instantiates","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","textSha256":"e8ec3115be3c89d2a146767159855bae9b1142fe39ddf3d3f3e513dc23a14b54"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6b882f14aa0fee0255fcd78389923d79","paperId":"1110.5327","sourceSha256":"9184e818255a65d7b1406131f22d6ad3403ac3a5c602bd2f92ef41ee3bd3ffbf","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/608fb7156331e4d391cc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cccd33f78cc8f00023c856030ea86f1c8c7e5f08d529e5334bb3e66098ba4bc1","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0a4b6318d33420e969e6d4e3dbaa8e9d240da4623bed9cbabe0d904b37a67ea4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:713fb9d19de3f8626604bd641933ade0","paperId":"1110.5327","sourceSha256":"9184e818255a65d7b1406131f22d6ad3403ac3a5c602bd2f92ef41ee3bd3ffbf","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/608fb7156331e4d391cc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cccd33f78cc8f00023c856030ea86f1c8c7e5f08d529e5334bb3e66098ba4bc1","pdfPage":4,"start":100,"end":3276,"textSha256":"5da4b22d451e773319b957580e5845978c81f858b957c2862c4ea4d03990a1e9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ede3c5d9cb8dc7cc3eec906f06e82441","paperId":"1110.5327","sourceSha256":"9184e818255a65d7b1406131f22d6ad3403ac3a5c602bd2f92ef41ee3bd3ffbf","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/608fb7156331e4d391cc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cccd33f78cc8f00023c856030ea86f1c8c7e5f08d529e5334bb3e66098ba4bc1","pdfPage":5,"start":1286,"end":3259,"textSha256":"a3193af96851740109191b938a2ec8bf1db545e60161be3a2ec050e034925d1a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c17902082cedabcfc2bfe228"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:c17902082cedabcfc2bfe228","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","q025-candidate-question:10e333580bdbf051baa6cb7f"],"scopeContentSha256":"f9d634703fa0fa78015ea0f7dd3676bdb9a5dfe0a5a39ded02758e715a6fbb79","contributionContentSha256":"12f5ff59e694d0b68c100eccb337208159db0a7b509004ab6047fc38ed516dfa","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d59","kind":"description","unitIndex":59,"unitId":"unit:c3466a9b26ae4c64485920567f36952239837ca7740c8d3a3b2290bc38a494d9","textSha256":"e8ec3115be3c89d2a146767159855bae9b1142fe39ddf3d3f3e513dc23a14b54"},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6b882f14aa0fee0255fcd78389923d79","paperId":"1110.5327","sourceSha256":"9184e818255a65d7b1406131f22d6ad3403ac3a5c602bd2f92ef41ee3bd3ffbf","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/608fb7156331e4d391cc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cccd33f78cc8f00023c856030ea86f1c8c7e5f08d529e5334bb3e66098ba4bc1","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0a4b6318d33420e969e6d4e3dbaa8e9d240da4623bed9cbabe0d904b37a67ea4","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:713fb9d19de3f8626604bd641933ade0","paperId":"1110.5327","sourceSha256":"9184e818255a65d7b1406131f22d6ad3403ac3a5c602bd2f92ef41ee3bd3ffbf","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/608fb7156331e4d391cc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cccd33f78cc8f00023c856030ea86f1c8c7e5f08d529e5334bb3e66098ba4bc1","pdfPage":4,"start":100,"end":3276,"textSha256":"5da4b22d451e773319b957580e5845978c81f858b957c2862c4ea4d03990a1e9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ede3c5d9cb8dc7cc3eec906f06e82441","paperId":"1110.5327","sourceSha256":"9184e818255a65d7b1406131f22d6ad3403ac3a5c602bd2f92ef41ee3bd3ffbf","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/608fb7156331e4d391cc/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"cccd33f78cc8f00023c856030ea86f1c8c7e5f08d529e5334bb3e66098ba4bc1","pdfPage":5,"start":1286,"end":3259,"textSha256":"a3193af96851740109191b938a2ec8bf1db545e60161be3a2ec050e034925d1a","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:c17902082cedabcfc2bfe228","recordId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ac6a9be121832bace66-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Universal truncation, vacua and subtruncations are distinct targets; distinguish the retained N=4 theory from its N=3 vacuum.","challengeNote":"Truncation, vacua and subtruncations are distinct targets. The retained N=4 theory differs from its N=3 vacuum; the source reports a specific Pope–Warner ins","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"2a0e7b88f4155e5a27194cc144aafdaa22d4b31daa89f3f10e2f6b6e1522d424"},"organizational-access:f7826968afa49d730f63402b":{"id":"organizational-access:f7826968afa49d730f63402b","source":"q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d","target":"q025-candidate-question:779f0a1b4e7a47d76b4ddee6","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"1f67a65e7bdf28b68b1d7e3f0b21946932f572ad796e372ca3f1651bf8e4f982","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c25921b2fa68bc8f9930854c"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:779f0a1b4e7a47d76b4ddee6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"12f4dda8ae184076594f76b2d692b5b7a848d7188604c497bb2ea9e20c719dc4","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f5e3da421dc053ea8b173029"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:28f529ffb59d8b7e8b902728433926e07cdf0966fbe2f6b8b1b8c5cfcccfddf4","home":{"unitId":"unit:28f529ffb59d8b7e8b902728433926e07cdf0966fbe2f6b8b1b8c5cfcccfddf4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:28f529ffb59d8b7e8b902728433926e07cdf0966fbe2f6b8b1b8c5cfcccfddf4","paperId":"2306.13951","textSha256":"e006f5e16b4494b3b4b2aecfa5d7b318d67ecf9e0a46d762cb768d0d9a6b1817"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a3bdb84aad9f4b8d353b48973025018b","paperId":"2306.13951","sourceSha256":"e5fd68154503aa6eabca406b4a82e23064787180da8f98caa1e4d7cc6d846e78","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0c885d1d60327ec8cf6f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a54f119def7d467adbc3c3e376e61e1e01c80d483f0430486a1841dd36fcb688","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1625,"textSha256":"e38a01b29875be54bc9d19fc37fc4f8d6c6739adf0f7450c2adb00fd42439db0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b1d8781fd95908e43b208800cdf3ef56","paperId":"2306.13951","sourceSha256":"e5fd68154503aa6eabca406b4a82e23064787180da8f98caa1e4d7cc6d846e78","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0c885d1d60327ec8cf6f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a54f119def7d467adbc3c3e376e61e1e01c80d483f0430486a1841dd36fcb688","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2928,"textSha256":"ac1ab0e2e27c14130bbfb3d1a2a904d5dfa42819fbbe6c56bd6f02aeec3c2a0e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:46b6ca356cce7f8e337311123e5d98e8","paperId":"2306.13951","sourceSha256":"e5fd68154503aa6eabca406b4a82e23064787180da8f98caa1e4d7cc6d846e78","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0c885d1d60327ec8cf6f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a54f119def7d467adbc3c3e376e61e1e01c80d483f0430486a1841dd36fcb688","pdfPage":3,"start":99,"end":2928,"textSha256":"13d8fafc9a9751c4d1f8e6828d63b2781faa25d430c0edb3cabde849580ac212","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c9df974c9da85029f916c281"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c9df974c9da85029f916c281","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:28f529ffb59d8b7e8b902728433926e07cdf0966fbe2f6b8b1b8c5cfcccfddf4","q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f67a65e7bdf28b68b1d7e3f0b21946932f572ad796e372ca3f1651bf8e4f982","placementContentSha256":"941b910ae59ed3f0763f9ea353563a80107d07b19671ba27679d19b86d3b0953","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge","leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:28f529ffb59d8b7e8b902728433926e07cdf0966fbe2f6b8b1b8c5cfcccfddf4","paperId":"2306.13951","textSha256":"e006f5e16b4494b3b4b2aecfa5d7b318d67ecf9e0a46d762cb768d0d9a6b1817"},{"localRef":"e17","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a3bdb84aad9f4b8d353b48973025018b","paperId":"2306.13951","sourceSha256":"e5fd68154503aa6eabca406b4a82e23064787180da8f98caa1e4d7cc6d846e78","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0c885d1d60327ec8cf6f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a54f119def7d467adbc3c3e376e61e1e01c80d483f0430486a1841dd36fcb688","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1625,"textSha256":"e38a01b29875be54bc9d19fc37fc4f8d6c6739adf0f7450c2adb00fd42439db0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b1d8781fd95908e43b208800cdf3ef56","paperId":"2306.13951","sourceSha256":"e5fd68154503aa6eabca406b4a82e23064787180da8f98caa1e4d7cc6d846e78","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0c885d1d60327ec8cf6f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a54f119def7d467adbc3c3e376e61e1e01c80d483f0430486a1841dd36fcb688","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2928,"textSha256":"ac1ab0e2e27c14130bbfb3d1a2a904d5dfa42819fbbe6c56bd6f02aeec3c2a0e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:46b6ca356cce7f8e337311123e5d98e8","paperId":"2306.13951","sourceSha256":"e5fd68154503aa6eabca406b4a82e23064787180da8f98caa1e4d7cc6d846e78","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0c885d1d60327ec8cf6f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a54f119def7d467adbc3c3e376e61e1e01c80d483f0430486a1841dd36fcb688","pdfPage":3,"start":99,"end":2928,"textSha256":"13d8fafc9a9751c4d1f8e6828d63b2781faa25d430c0edb3cabde849580ac212","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c9df974c9da85029f916c281"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:28f529ffb59d8b7e8b902728433926e07cdf0966fbe2f6b8b1b8c5cfcccfddf4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:779f0a1b4e7a47d76b4ddee6","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:28f529ffb59d8b7e8b902728433926e07cdf0966fbe2f6b8b1b8c5cfcccfddf4","textSha256":"e006f5e16b4494b3b4b2aecfa5d7b318d67ecf9e0a46d762cb768d0d9a6b1817"},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a3bdb84aad9f4b8d353b48973025018b","paperId":"2306.13951","sourceSha256":"e5fd68154503aa6eabca406b4a82e23064787180da8f98caa1e4d7cc6d846e78","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0c885d1d60327ec8cf6f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a54f119def7d467adbc3c3e376e61e1e01c80d483f0430486a1841dd36fcb688","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1625,"textSha256":"e38a01b29875be54bc9d19fc37fc4f8d6c6739adf0f7450c2adb00fd42439db0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b1d8781fd95908e43b208800cdf3ef56","paperId":"2306.13951","sourceSha256":"e5fd68154503aa6eabca406b4a82e23064787180da8f98caa1e4d7cc6d846e78","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0c885d1d60327ec8cf6f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a54f119def7d467adbc3c3e376e61e1e01c80d483f0430486a1841dd36fcb688","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2928,"textSha256":"ac1ab0e2e27c14130bbfb3d1a2a904d5dfa42819fbbe6c56bd6f02aeec3c2a0e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:46b6ca356cce7f8e337311123e5d98e8","paperId":"2306.13951","sourceSha256":"e5fd68154503aa6eabca406b4a82e23064787180da8f98caa1e4d7cc6d846e78","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0c885d1d60327ec8cf6f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a54f119def7d467adbc3c3e376e61e1e01c80d483f0430486a1841dd36fcb688","pdfPage":3,"start":99,"end":2928,"textSha256":"13d8fafc9a9751c4d1f8e6828d63b2781faa25d430c0edb3cabde849580ac212","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:56d21f158715a2a230df9176","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Reports fixed-flux stability and no action benefit from flux partition; proposes quantum bridges. UV completion is explicitly unassessed. Independent challenge qualification: D≥3 compound construction, stability, weight and continuation target. Fixed-flux stability and no action gain from flux partition are reported; bridges are an E"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:56d21f158715a2a230df9176","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:28f529ffb59d8b7e8b902728433926e07cdf0966fbe2f6b8b1b8c5cfcccfddf4","q025-candidate-question:779f0a1b4e7a47d76b4ddee6"],"scopeContentSha256":"12f4dda8ae184076594f76b2d692b5b7a848d7188604c497bb2ea9e20c719dc4","contributionContentSha256":"12524f5c1fabecb366c7a5f9e87532c8ec8404be98f0258396c1dfdcf35eb89a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-d1ef19e18a876e08eb78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d1ef19e18a876e08eb78-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-d1ef19e18a876e08eb78-proposal","leaf-d1ef19e18a876e08eb78-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:28f529ffb59d8b7e8b902728433926e07cdf0966fbe2f6b8b1b8c5cfcccfddf4","textSha256":"e006f5e16b4494b3b4b2aecfa5d7b318d67ecf9e0a46d762cb768d0d9a6b1817"},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a3bdb84aad9f4b8d353b48973025018b","paperId":"2306.13951","sourceSha256":"e5fd68154503aa6eabca406b4a82e23064787180da8f98caa1e4d7cc6d846e78","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0c885d1d60327ec8cf6f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a54f119def7d467adbc3c3e376e61e1e01c80d483f0430486a1841dd36fcb688","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":1625,"textSha256":"e38a01b29875be54bc9d19fc37fc4f8d6c6739adf0f7450c2adb00fd42439db0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:b1d8781fd95908e43b208800cdf3ef56","paperId":"2306.13951","sourceSha256":"e5fd68154503aa6eabca406b4a82e23064787180da8f98caa1e4d7cc6d846e78","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0c885d1d60327ec8cf6f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a54f119def7d467adbc3c3e376e61e1e01c80d483f0430486a1841dd36fcb688","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2928,"textSha256":"ac1ab0e2e27c14130bbfb3d1a2a904d5dfa42819fbbe6c56bd6f02aeec3c2a0e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:46b6ca356cce7f8e337311123e5d98e8","paperId":"2306.13951","sourceSha256":"e5fd68154503aa6eabca406b4a82e23064787180da8f98caa1e4d7cc6d846e78","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/0c885d1d60327ec8cf6f/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"a54f119def7d467adbc3c3e376e61e1e01c80d483f0430486a1841dd36fcb688","pdfPage":3,"start":99,"end":2928,"textSha256":"13d8fafc9a9751c4d1f8e6828d63b2781faa25d430c0edb3cabde849580ac212","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:56d21f158715a2a230df9176","recordId":"leaf-d1ef19e18a876e08eb78-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-d1ef19e18a876e08eb78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-d1ef19e18a876e08eb78-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Reports fixed-flux stability and no action benefit from flux partition; proposes quantum bridges. UV completion is explicitly unassessed.","challengeNote":"D≥3 compound construction, stability, weight and continuation target. Fixed-flux stability and no action gain from flux partition are reported; bridges are an E","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"e95ecb0507e28d3f8fb2e26fc661658ab0e5bd9b6d9badb44a1bd83a3530952f"},"organizational-access:e39ab9829026992c7ecba168":{"id":"organizational-access:e39ab9829026992c7ecba168","source":"q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d","target":"q025-candidate-question:e45306b39c2b8648379f2198","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"1f67a65e7bdf28b68b1d7e3f0b21946932f572ad796e372ca3f1651bf8e4f982","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c25921b2fa68bc8f9930854c"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e45306b39c2b8648379f2198","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c569efdb0b6f2133ebbc6f5be3f8a29fb7dcb0efe6de15fcbc2ee6949ad6ba47","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:04b9c4c9ec7511070e41b03e"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:3f4f9bd2802b50811d9c6f688ff9988388a6864e9186b76f635873e5f146c993","home":{"unitId":"unit:3f4f9bd2802b50811d9c6f688ff9988388a6864e9186b76f635873e5f146c993","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3f4f9bd2802b50811d9c6f688ff9988388a6864e9186b76f635873e5f146c993","paperId":"2012.07875","textSha256":"55b25b98faaf811a8fddef3412260778a347fa2274c848c5ffad32253d254b7c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fd71cfb02eb667d83e24efbf"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fd71cfb02eb667d83e24efbf","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3f4f9bd2802b50811d9c6f688ff9988388a6864e9186b76f635873e5f146c993","q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f67a65e7bdf28b68b1d7e3f0b21946932f572ad796e372ca3f1651bf8e4f982","placementContentSha256":"8046577e20dbdc6ac680babf4bd7016d9258f890b27f249de61e3be8f53eac4f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge","leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3f4f9bd2802b50811d9c6f688ff9988388a6864e9186b76f635873e5f146c993","paperId":"2012.07875","textSha256":"55b25b98faaf811a8fddef3412260778a347fa2274c848c5ffad32253d254b7c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fd71cfb02eb667d83e24efbf"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3f4f9bd2802b50811d9c6f688ff9988388a6864e9186b76f635873e5f146c993","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e45306b39c2b8648379f2198","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:3f4f9bd2802b50811d9c6f688ff9988388a6864e9186b76f635873e5f146c993","textSha256":"55b25b98faaf811a8fddef3412260778a347fa2274c848c5ffad32253d254b7c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:265eeeaa81f3b60ae1e793cb","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Charged ETH formulation and the symmetry diagnostic remain distinguishable within this source scope. Independent challenge qualification: Charged ETH formulation and the exact-versus-weakly-violated symmetry diagnostic remain distinct targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:265eeeaa81f3b60ae1e793cb","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3f4f9bd2802b50811d9c6f688ff9988388a6864e9186b76f635873e5f146c993","q025-candidate-question:e45306b39c2b8648379f2198"],"scopeContentSha256":"c569efdb0b6f2133ebbc6f5be3f8a29fb7dcb0efe6de15fcbc2ee6949ad6ba47","contributionContentSha256":"9b276fc1c5e591b17870ee13bd73ef95c58dfc4753695668d92e6bc25ffd6892","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:3f4f9bd2802b50811d9c6f688ff9988388a6864e9186b76f635873e5f146c993","textSha256":"55b25b98faaf811a8fddef3412260778a347fa2274c848c5ffad32253d254b7c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:265eeeaa81f3b60ae1e793cb","recordId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Charged ETH formulation and the symmetry diagnostic remain distinguishable within this source scope.","challengeNote":"Charged ETH formulation and the exact-versus-weakly-violated symmetry diagnostic remain distinct targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:8043929b434d969c6ddeabb5a89e2ec83ffb7d49cf84d592f46f756197e39092","home":{"unitId":"unit:8043929b434d969c6ddeabb5a89e2ec83ffb7d49cf84d592f46f756197e39092","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8043929b434d969c6ddeabb5a89e2ec83ffb7d49cf84d592f46f756197e39092","paperId":"2605.05336","textSha256":"9792cc86fd4a66479aae58b69bf9679291dc7107fcda52de64029c479c81053a"},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e1af0f6bb6bca001140fc1cb439401b5","paperId":"2605.05336","sourceSha256":"842e20d9706de14504f1bb5a1d731952b33f74e99c4383c12ef2b4486524afbe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c12acf8626cd72b62057/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce4e89572c4eed1ea60775ea5037cd1356b9f4f84c153949a3bafafdd698c254","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2979,"textSha256":"40e190c774da7c7b102366081b8460ac87a1688cef6ea6cb6c38690261281417","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:047a629c9982ee3b0f4077785fc6e09b","paperId":"2605.05336","sourceSha256":"842e20d9706de14504f1bb5a1d731952b33f74e99c4383c12ef2b4486524afbe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c12acf8626cd72b62057/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce4e89572c4eed1ea60775ea5037cd1356b9f4f84c153949a3bafafdd698c254","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":2979,"textSha256":"769cd9d2ef5103cfd05bd2a9437305534a2955bc5cb07ca0d5ba77ff20638186","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:975bb9546589a641ac2f401862f07ff5","paperId":"2605.05336","sourceSha256":"842e20d9706de14504f1bb5a1d731952b33f74e99c4383c12ef2b4486524afbe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c12acf8626cd72b62057/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce4e89572c4eed1ea60775ea5037cd1356b9f4f84c153949a3bafafdd698c254","pdfPage":13,"start":102,"end":2437,"textSha256":"0fcd99e717c2483bd18625e56caeadb69ba0867981b9ddee76b94aa33162f07b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e7ffa1045be62ad811427bf1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e7ffa1045be62ad811427bf1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8043929b434d969c6ddeabb5a89e2ec83ffb7d49cf84d592f46f756197e39092","q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f67a65e7bdf28b68b1d7e3f0b21946932f572ad796e372ca3f1651bf8e4f982","placementContentSha256":"57c142b1ec94b7ec681376a23f8d16f6f729b8fa6a65371c20fbd5867ca14853","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge","leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8043929b434d969c6ddeabb5a89e2ec83ffb7d49cf84d592f46f756197e39092","paperId":"2605.05336","textSha256":"9792cc86fd4a66479aae58b69bf9679291dc7107fcda52de64029c479c81053a"},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e1af0f6bb6bca001140fc1cb439401b5","paperId":"2605.05336","sourceSha256":"842e20d9706de14504f1bb5a1d731952b33f74e99c4383c12ef2b4486524afbe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c12acf8626cd72b62057/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce4e89572c4eed1ea60775ea5037cd1356b9f4f84c153949a3bafafdd698c254","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2979,"textSha256":"40e190c774da7c7b102366081b8460ac87a1688cef6ea6cb6c38690261281417","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:047a629c9982ee3b0f4077785fc6e09b","paperId":"2605.05336","sourceSha256":"842e20d9706de14504f1bb5a1d731952b33f74e99c4383c12ef2b4486524afbe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c12acf8626cd72b62057/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce4e89572c4eed1ea60775ea5037cd1356b9f4f84c153949a3bafafdd698c254","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":2979,"textSha256":"769cd9d2ef5103cfd05bd2a9437305534a2955bc5cb07ca0d5ba77ff20638186","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:975bb9546589a641ac2f401862f07ff5","paperId":"2605.05336","sourceSha256":"842e20d9706de14504f1bb5a1d731952b33f74e99c4383c12ef2b4486524afbe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c12acf8626cd72b62057/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce4e89572c4eed1ea60775ea5037cd1356b9f4f84c153949a3bafafdd698c254","pdfPage":13,"start":102,"end":2437,"textSha256":"0fcd99e717c2483bd18625e56caeadb69ba0867981b9ddee76b94aa33162f07b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e7ffa1045be62ad811427bf1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8043929b434d969c6ddeabb5a89e2ec83ffb7d49cf84d592f46f756197e39092","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e45306b39c2b8648379f2198","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:8043929b434d969c6ddeabb5a89e2ec83ffb7d49cf84d592f46f756197e39092","textSha256":"9792cc86fd4a66479aae58b69bf9679291dc7107fcda52de64029c479c81053a"},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e1af0f6bb6bca001140fc1cb439401b5","paperId":"2605.05336","sourceSha256":"842e20d9706de14504f1bb5a1d731952b33f74e99c4383c12ef2b4486524afbe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c12acf8626cd72b62057/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce4e89572c4eed1ea60775ea5037cd1356b9f4f84c153949a3bafafdd698c254","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2979,"textSha256":"40e190c774da7c7b102366081b8460ac87a1688cef6ea6cb6c38690261281417","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:047a629c9982ee3b0f4077785fc6e09b","paperId":"2605.05336","sourceSha256":"842e20d9706de14504f1bb5a1d731952b33f74e99c4383c12ef2b4486524afbe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c12acf8626cd72b62057/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce4e89572c4eed1ea60775ea5037cd1356b9f4f84c153949a3bafafdd698c254","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":2979,"textSha256":"769cd9d2ef5103cfd05bd2a9437305534a2955bc5cb07ca0d5ba77ff20638186","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:975bb9546589a641ac2f401862f07ff5","paperId":"2605.05336","sourceSha256":"842e20d9706de14504f1bb5a1d731952b33f74e99c4383c12ef2b4486524afbe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c12acf8626cd72b62057/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce4e89572c4eed1ea60775ea5037cd1356b9f4f84c153949a3bafafdd698c254","pdfPage":13,"start":102,"end":2437,"textSha256":"0fcd99e717c2483bd18625e56caeadb69ba0867981b9ddee76b94aa33162f07b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a25a039d2ca240ccc8dd30a0","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Single-theory effective-description bound and its intrinsic enforcement are linked conjectural targets, not a proved universal exclusion of wormholes. Independent challenge qualification: The single-theory bound concerns validity of an Einstein-plus-light-scalar approximation; universal intrinsic enforcement remains conjectural."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a25a039d2ca240ccc8dd30a0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8043929b434d969c6ddeabb5a89e2ec83ffb7d49cf84d592f46f756197e39092","q025-candidate-question:e45306b39c2b8648379f2198"],"scopeContentSha256":"c569efdb0b6f2133ebbc6f5be3f8a29fb7dcb0efe6de15fcbc2ee6949ad6ba47","contributionContentSha256":"e764431a9c3175d307ea5358bcef29739900287cea4a3c50dc6295b07d6f01b7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:8043929b434d969c6ddeabb5a89e2ec83ffb7d49cf84d592f46f756197e39092","textSha256":"9792cc86fd4a66479aae58b69bf9679291dc7107fcda52de64029c479c81053a"},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e1af0f6bb6bca001140fc1cb439401b5","paperId":"2605.05336","sourceSha256":"842e20d9706de14504f1bb5a1d731952b33f74e99c4383c12ef2b4486524afbe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c12acf8626cd72b62057/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce4e89572c4eed1ea60775ea5037cd1356b9f4f84c153949a3bafafdd698c254","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2979,"textSha256":"40e190c774da7c7b102366081b8460ac87a1688cef6ea6cb6c38690261281417","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e1","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:047a629c9982ee3b0f4077785fc6e09b","paperId":"2605.05336","sourceSha256":"842e20d9706de14504f1bb5a1d731952b33f74e99c4383c12ef2b4486524afbe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c12acf8626cd72b62057/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce4e89572c4eed1ea60775ea5037cd1356b9f4f84c153949a3bafafdd698c254","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":2979,"textSha256":"769cd9d2ef5103cfd05bd2a9437305534a2955bc5cb07ca0d5ba77ff20638186","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:975bb9546589a641ac2f401862f07ff5","paperId":"2605.05336","sourceSha256":"842e20d9706de14504f1bb5a1d731952b33f74e99c4383c12ef2b4486524afbe","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/c12acf8626cd72b62057/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce4e89572c4eed1ea60775ea5037cd1356b9f4f84c153949a3bafafdd698c254","pdfPage":13,"start":102,"end":2437,"textSha256":"0fcd99e717c2483bd18625e56caeadb69ba0867981b9ddee76b94aa33162f07b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a25a039d2ca240ccc8dd30a0","recordId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Single-theory effective-description bound and its intrinsic enforcement are linked conjectural targets, not a proved universal exclusion of wormholes.","challengeNote":"The single-theory bound concerns validity of an Einstein-plus-light-scalar approximation; universal intrinsic enforcement remains conjectural.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:8ee8ed074596dbf4c7ed0458844d762f27f0cb080ee87f1bbb9393ec4c7bb0ee","home":{"unitId":"unit:8ee8ed074596dbf4c7ed0458844d762f27f0cb080ee87f1bbb9393ec4c7bb0ee","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8ee8ed074596dbf4c7ed0458844d762f27f0cb080ee87f1bbb9393ec4c7bb0ee","paperId":"inspire-25446","textSha256":"294a74aea59fcd33a760bf783a6c5128d43aa66faeabb623af51faf88268039c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:72da1eb8cc154c9305a76125"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:72da1eb8cc154c9305a76125","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8ee8ed074596dbf4c7ed0458844d762f27f0cb080ee87f1bbb9393ec4c7bb0ee","q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f67a65e7bdf28b68b1d7e3f0b21946932f572ad796e372ca3f1651bf8e4f982","placementContentSha256":"53c6778284fb6768291fde36745eabf96a4a1045f188f369cb920101caf2a20d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge","leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8ee8ed074596dbf4c7ed0458844d762f27f0cb080ee87f1bbb9393ec4c7bb0ee","paperId":"inspire-25446","textSha256":"294a74aea59fcd33a760bf783a6c5128d43aa66faeabb623af51faf88268039c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:72da1eb8cc154c9305a76125"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8ee8ed074596dbf4c7ed0458844d762f27f0cb080ee87f1bbb9393ec4c7bb0ee","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e45306b39c2b8648379f2198","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:8ee8ed074596dbf4c7ed0458844d762f27f0cb080ee87f1bbb9393ec4c7bb0ee","textSha256":"294a74aea59fcd33a760bf783a6c5128d43aa66faeabb623af51faf88268039c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5ea49becaafaf34a277d9d65","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Symmetry violation across phases and local matching at infinite action remain distinct targets. Independent challenge qualification: Both symmetry phases and local matching at infinite action remain explicit compound targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5ea49becaafaf34a277d9d65","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8ee8ed074596dbf4c7ed0458844d762f27f0cb080ee87f1bbb9393ec4c7bb0ee","q025-candidate-question:e45306b39c2b8648379f2198"],"scopeContentSha256":"c569efdb0b6f2133ebbc6f5be3f8a29fb7dcb0efe6de15fcbc2ee6949ad6ba47","contributionContentSha256":"9f72e2a5025eb5c4421255d64641cf654036360eeb4dfbbdc5f5d7fb372c4ec8","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:8ee8ed074596dbf4c7ed0458844d762f27f0cb080ee87f1bbb9393ec4c7bb0ee","textSha256":"294a74aea59fcd33a760bf783a6c5128d43aa66faeabb623af51faf88268039c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5ea49becaafaf34a277d9d65","recordId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Symmetry violation across phases and local matching at infinite action remain distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Both symmetry phases and local matching at infinite action remain explicit compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9c44af5c50ae4117057da60515bc56abb9ad25d91996675ae50f823e0c32576c","home":{"unitId":"unit:9c44af5c50ae4117057da60515bc56abb9ad25d91996675ae50f823e0c32576c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9c44af5c50ae4117057da60515bc56abb9ad25d91996675ae50f823e0c32576c","paperId":"2609.11010","textSha256":"d9af5de6c73cd01f2b475947d23c8b4be0082494095e86573e0971d342d69961"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:73518bfce61d724b32d214b0"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:73518bfce61d724b32d214b0","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9c44af5c50ae4117057da60515bc56abb9ad25d91996675ae50f823e0c32576c","q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f67a65e7bdf28b68b1d7e3f0b21946932f572ad796e372ca3f1651bf8e4f982","placementContentSha256":"1ad44c07244cca55b6cceb42a2c7fcbad93ee0a95a913a2431b842e80790ae51","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge","leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9c44af5c50ae4117057da60515bc56abb9ad25d91996675ae50f823e0c32576c","paperId":"2609.11010","textSha256":"d9af5de6c73cd01f2b475947d23c8b4be0082494095e86573e0971d342d69961"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:73518bfce61d724b32d214b0"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9c44af5c50ae4117057da60515bc56abb9ad25d91996675ae50f823e0c32576c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e45306b39c2b8648379f2198","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:9c44af5c50ae4117057da60515bc56abb9ad25d91996675ae50f823e0c32576c","textSha256":"d9af5de6c73cd01f2b475947d23c8b4be0082494095e86573e0971d342d69961"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ddedd306eb0b40040fdd2595","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Action enhancement, PQ protection and representative inflation-compatible parameters remain distinct checks. Independent challenge qualification: Action enhancement, PQ protection and representative inflation-compatible parameters remain separate checks."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ddedd306eb0b40040fdd2595","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9c44af5c50ae4117057da60515bc56abb9ad25d91996675ae50f823e0c32576c","q025-candidate-question:e45306b39c2b8648379f2198"],"scopeContentSha256":"c569efdb0b6f2133ebbc6f5be3f8a29fb7dcb0efe6de15fcbc2ee6949ad6ba47","contributionContentSha256":"0d3b0a127d97c689f918486d9ec5377235106c380c5fc734b3ceff06caf40e53","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:9c44af5c50ae4117057da60515bc56abb9ad25d91996675ae50f823e0c32576c","textSha256":"d9af5de6c73cd01f2b475947d23c8b4be0082494095e86573e0971d342d69961"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ddedd306eb0b40040fdd2595","recordId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Action enhancement, PQ protection and representative inflation-compatible parameters remain distinct checks.","challengeNote":"Action enhancement, PQ protection and representative inflation-compatible parameters remain separate checks.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:e4b21512e2a1a6800a7687799409703cab239e928853f512aaebc20aefa76818","home":{"unitId":"unit:e4b21512e2a1a6800a7687799409703cab239e928853f512aaebc20aefa76818","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e4b21512e2a1a6800a7687799409703cab239e928853f512aaebc20aefa76818","paperId":"1110.2303","textSha256":"8c2a17cc92b79b5bba30e55916345a8d6f48e0dd072999a0eeef5b49178f9afa"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:462d1ce8422c7b57b23fab1c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:462d1ce8422c7b57b23fab1c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e4b21512e2a1a6800a7687799409703cab239e928853f512aaebc20aefa76818","q025-candidate-region:200c63d37ecc9cbcdf804e3d"],"scopeContentSha256":"1f67a65e7bdf28b68b1d7e3f0b21946932f572ad796e372ca3f1651bf8e4f982","placementContentSha256":"12900f625e26724e89d024108bd0ec7dd73e88ef4cc31397442c8504d5962c2c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge","leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e4b21512e2a1a6800a7687799409703cab239e928853f512aaebc20aefa76818","paperId":"1110.2303","textSha256":"8c2a17cc92b79b5bba30e55916345a8d6f48e0dd072999a0eeef5b49178f9afa"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:462d1ce8422c7b57b23fab1c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e4b21512e2a1a6800a7687799409703cab239e928853f512aaebc20aefa76818","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e45306b39c2b8648379f2198","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:e4b21512e2a1a6800a7687799409703cab239e928853f512aaebc20aefa76818","textSha256":"8c2a17cc92b79b5bba30e55916345a8d6f48e0dd072999a0eeef5b49178f9afa"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ebabc55503d9600214efe837","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound selection targets: cosmological constant, hierarchy and strong CP; atomic identity remains open. Independent challenge qualification: Compound cosmological-constant, hierarchy and strong-CP targets remain subject to finer reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ebabc55503d9600214efe837","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e4b21512e2a1a6800a7687799409703cab239e928853f512aaebc20aefa76818","q025-candidate-question:e45306b39c2b8648379f2198"],"scopeContentSha256":"c569efdb0b6f2133ebbc6f5be3f8a29fb7dcb0efe6de15fcbc2ee6949ad6ba47","contributionContentSha256":"53ab87a83fbf2caeb0f8732a8024b71f0097a627562d00ee7d2c0323093da41a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:e4b21512e2a1a6800a7687799409703cab239e928853f512aaebc20aefa76818","textSha256":"8c2a17cc92b79b5bba30e55916345a8d6f48e0dd072999a0eeef5b49178f9afa"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ebabc55503d9600214efe837","recordId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound selection targets: cosmological constant, hierarchy and strong CP; atomic identity remains open.","challengeNote":"Compound cosmological-constant, hierarchy and strong-CP targets remain subject to finer reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":5,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a2826c3f18d67ea8e1e4c9b668e19fa57f10f876ba470636f6872fb51250e1c2"},"organizational-access:fc1c59adb2cb05cc350f119c":{"id":"organizational-access:fc1c59adb2cb05cc350f119c","source":"q025-candidate-region:2344420c44d7bc2f2826b23a","target":"q025-candidate-question:90c2fd14ae1a9f62b6e93f60","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:2344420c44d7bc2f2826b23a","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"f15b0fdbed89f7305ee333f8fcd0de2296ca7c881f22157cd9bced7791acf86b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:58cc6ac8f6923ca4e5e64a01"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:90c2fd14ae1a9f62b6e93f60","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"bc26abb3cd2b95cdc4e8e8494551b6936c896f684860202b3dffb3f88cccd57c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c2b2b55ef263e0e65fbc0201"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:a49a8c0c450b0ce8a23326f25168db760c64027333dfa7f7229aa9350033d061","home":{"unitId":"unit:a49a8c0c450b0ce8a23326f25168db760c64027333dfa7f7229aa9350033d061","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2344420c44d7bc2f2826b23a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers ED5, ED1 and independent closed-string flux superpotentials, anomalous-U(1) constraints and their possible combined moduli stabilization in the specified Type I model.","qualification":"q12 covers every target: distinct ED5, ED1 and closed-string flux contributions, anomalous-U(1) invariance, and possible combined stabilization. q7 covers instanton selection and background-flux effects on branes, but its definition does not positively encompass independent closed-flux superpotentials and the resulting combined stabilization dynamics. Its exclusion of automatic complete stabilization is a caution, not positive coverage of that additional target. q12 supplies a suitable whole-question home, so no union is needed.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a49a8c0c450b0ce8a23326f25168db760c64027333dfa7f7229aa9350033d061","paperId":"hep-th/0702015","textSha256":"934529a83106e0e33ce259351e53a291045d77cd917160378345e06703cf8484"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-explicit-cut01:placement-continuation-0008:u23"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-explicit-cut01:placement-continuation-0008:u23","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a49a8c0c450b0ce8a23326f25168db760c64027333dfa7f7229aa9350033d061","q025-candidate-region:2344420c44d7bc2f2826b23a"],"scopeContentSha256":"f15b0fdbed89f7305ee333f8fcd0de2296ca7c881f22157cd9bced7791acf86b","placementContentSha256":"9e1a9e2844647267ea975065738e0e4e6c0e8ba88b4c08c6c5bb0d7e943b0639","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_changed_whole_home","sourceReviewIds":["explicit-home-cut01:placement-continuation-0008:proposal","explicit-home-cut01:placement-continuation-0008:challenge","root:explicit-home-cut01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a49a8c0c450b0ce8a23326f25168db760c64027333dfa7f7229aa9350033d061","paperId":"hep-th/0702015","textSha256":"934529a83106e0e33ce259351e53a291045d77cd917160378345e06703cf8484"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/explicit-cut-01/admission.json","sha256":"85701911093be3e75d3e2441256645f0244c34e54c621cf046da64e526da693d"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/exception-intake.json","sha256":"71263a9f0021efdb21ad157d46dc559b5271318bbabb074cf7b3d6ec8a9658a9","bytes":2044150,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0008","unitRef":"u23"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a49a8c0c450b0ce8a23326f25168db760c64027333dfa7f7229aa9350033d061","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:90c2fd14ae1a9f62b6e93f60","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d93","kind":"description","unitIndex":93,"unitId":"unit:a49a8c0c450b0ce8a23326f25168db760c64027333dfa7f7229aa9350033d061","textSha256":"934529a83106e0e33ce259351e53a291045d77cd917160378345e06703cf8484"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e955f45474c9931dd79a8bd8"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e955f45474c9931dd79a8bd8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a49a8c0c450b0ce8a23326f25168db760c64027333dfa7f7229aa9350033d061","q025-candidate-question:90c2fd14ae1a9f62b6e93f60"],"scopeContentSha256":"bc26abb3cd2b95cdc4e8e8494551b6936c896f684860202b3dffb3f88cccd57c","contributionContentSha256":"86a155e403fdaeb7f838f9565bccf3af88a2c090562cc002d87b442759b7bbd9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-8cbd232bf6adad063a61-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8cbd232bf6adad063a61-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-8cbd232bf6adad063a61-proposal","leaf-8cbd232bf6adad063a61-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d93","kind":"description","unitIndex":93,"unitId":"unit:a49a8c0c450b0ce8a23326f25168db760c64027333dfa7f7229aa9350033d061","textSha256":"934529a83106e0e33ce259351e53a291045d77cd917160378345e06703cf8484"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e955f45474c9931dd79a8bd8","recordId":"leaf-8cbd232bf6adad063a61-challenge:p6","proposalReviewId":"leaf-8cbd232bf6adad063a61-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-8cbd232bf6adad063a61-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"ED5, ED1 and closed-flux contributions, gauge invariance and possible combined stabilization form a compound source question.","challengeNote":"ED5, ED1, closed-flux contributions, gauge invariance and possible combined stabilization form a compound question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"25789364f82cd20925f829367acbc88d9c4d756203b6ffe35ac76cc66d02cfb0"},"organizational-access:f8e9ecedb6ff56b9782612d4":{"id":"organizational-access:f8e9ecedb6ff56b9782612d4","source":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","target":"q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1867e10e8c8bafd942db110d"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"5d417a0fbda515287e8c5249a8dae741394e71605d3ba2b32d39982005753813","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:56bc30ad04066bdc9033cabe"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5d7f7e18aa16e6086bf4413b8b97dbc3c83c8b04b571a792a122e746e42ead7c","home":{"unitId":"unit:5d7f7e18aa16e6086bf4413b8b97dbc3c83c8b04b571a792a122e746e42ead7c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Spans type IIB axion potentials, sufficient small-field inflation and the resulting inflationary and reheating scales across the relevant cosmological epochs.","qualification":"q14 covers the type IIB potential's inflationary viability and the separate inflationary and reheating scale outputs. Small excursion and small decay constant remain distinct, and no unspecified thermal scale is supplied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5d7f7e18aa16e6086bf4413b8b97dbc3c83c8b04b571a792a122e746e42ead7c","textSha256":"a299d4e02c63260d013b82ded40a268b0c0b13724e552d68c21207bffec7742f"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u10:q14"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u10:q14","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5d7f7e18aa16e6086bf4413b8b97dbc3c83c8b04b571a792a122e746e42ead7c","q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","placementContentSha256":"59395076089b5355e1523d94f287f6e0c8532458b140fbf4d17a9d13e6641de3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:coverage:proposal","placement-pilot:coverage:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5d7f7e18aa16e6086bf4413b8b97dbc3c83c8b04b571a792a122e746e42ead7c","textSha256":"a299d4e02c63260d013b82ded40a268b0c0b13724e552d68c21207bffec7742f"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:5d7f7e18aa16e6086bf4413b8b97dbc3c83c8b04b571a792a122e746e42ead7c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5d7f7e18aa16e6086bf4413b8b97dbc3c83c8b04b571a792a122e746e42ead7c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d40","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:5d7f7e18aa16e6086bf4413b8b97dbc3c83c8b04b571a792a122e746e42ead7c","textSha256":"a299d4e02c63260d013b82ded40a268b0c0b13724e552d68c21207bffec7742f"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4190ab253fb2e6e13007a30ad3f3f94a","paperId":"1606.03219","sourceSha256":"abf07688ae8fa8bf4f589b4438ced2d854a90eb9c5cfd65f98ff8b45efbaa4c1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d695c5309bb8596d6975/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"47f07f31c54e95a81d598052006f81b47c7a65c82587341d1d8f888ff7eb1804","pdfPage":2,"start":95,"end":2322,"textSha256":"d5459c139dbb0f64199ae119906d69b241c9bedf7ac517d1a25136ceb677c064","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6d744902c8c3a25f6d85ff65e5632e93","paperId":"1606.03219","sourceSha256":"abf07688ae8fa8bf4f589b4438ced2d854a90eb9c5cfd65f98ff8b45efbaa4c1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d695c5309bb8596d6975/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"47f07f31c54e95a81d598052006f81b47c7a65c82587341d1d8f888ff7eb1804","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":846,"textSha256":"45d57a5685fc73c1276c076cf7c30158791d0c901eb6f65318186e2ce797cbf3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bc24fbb88e96889d6e223cac6da6c3bd","paperId":"1606.03219","sourceSha256":"abf07688ae8fa8bf4f589b4438ced2d854a90eb9c5cfd65f98ff8b45efbaa4c1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d695c5309bb8596d6975/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"47f07f31c54e95a81d598052006f81b47c7a65c82587341d1d8f888ff7eb1804","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":1788,"textSha256":"ef5312f72a831a6cddafc0a67afb845ab03590af7ef58aba574643f508545fb3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:04b001077f25022310cfe49f","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The June 2016 v1 example mixes polynomial and sinusoidal terms; inflationary and reheating scales are separate outputs. Independent challenge qualification: The June 2016 v1 potential mixes polynomial and sinusoidal terms. Inflation and reheating outputs remain separately mapped."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:04b001077f25022310cfe49f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5d7f7e18aa16e6086bf4413b8b97dbc3c83c8b04b571a792a122e746e42ead7c","q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2"],"scopeContentSha256":"5d417a0fbda515287e8c5249a8dae741394e71605d3ba2b32d39982005753813","contributionContentSha256":"c6fe50f677885a399768bc14c53d96313e03ec364d86b9fa12aa20e29d8dbe75","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d40","kind":"description","unitIndex":40,"unitId":"unit:5d7f7e18aa16e6086bf4413b8b97dbc3c83c8b04b571a792a122e746e42ead7c","textSha256":"a299d4e02c63260d013b82ded40a268b0c0b13724e552d68c21207bffec7742f"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4190ab253fb2e6e13007a30ad3f3f94a","paperId":"1606.03219","sourceSha256":"abf07688ae8fa8bf4f589b4438ced2d854a90eb9c5cfd65f98ff8b45efbaa4c1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d695c5309bb8596d6975/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"47f07f31c54e95a81d598052006f81b47c7a65c82587341d1d8f888ff7eb1804","pdfPage":2,"start":95,"end":2322,"textSha256":"d5459c139dbb0f64199ae119906d69b241c9bedf7ac517d1a25136ceb677c064","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:6d744902c8c3a25f6d85ff65e5632e93","paperId":"1606.03219","sourceSha256":"abf07688ae8fa8bf4f589b4438ced2d854a90eb9c5cfd65f98ff8b45efbaa4c1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d695c5309bb8596d6975/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"47f07f31c54e95a81d598052006f81b47c7a65c82587341d1d8f888ff7eb1804","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":846,"textSha256":"45d57a5685fc73c1276c076cf7c30158791d0c901eb6f65318186e2ce797cbf3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:bc24fbb88e96889d6e223cac6da6c3bd","paperId":"1606.03219","sourceSha256":"abf07688ae8fa8bf4f589b4438ced2d854a90eb9c5cfd65f98ff8b45efbaa4c1","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/d695c5309bb8596d6975/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"47f07f31c54e95a81d598052006f81b47c7a65c82587341d1d8f888ff7eb1804","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":1788,"textSha256":"ef5312f72a831a6cddafc0a67afb845ab03590af7ef58aba574643f508545fb3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:04b001077f25022310cfe49f","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The June 2016 v1 example mixes polynomial and sinusoidal terms; inflationary and reheating scales are separate outputs.","challengeNote":"The June 2016 v1 potential mixes polynomial and sinusoidal terms. Inflation and reheating outputs remain separately mapped.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","home":{"unitId":"unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers inflationary potentials and observables, reheating and relic production, and restrictions across BBN and axion-isocurvature cosmology.","qualification":"q14 spans every requested output and constraint across inflation, reheating, relic production and BBN. The QCD-axion isocurvature condition is retained without identifying that axion with the inflaton or equating small excursion with small decay constant.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","textSha256":"744e8976216dc8e186c72e191582048f765a06303764370041d6e145638f202d"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u13:q14"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-pilot:home:coverage:u13:q14","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","q025-candidate-region:2580970ae5ac7203a464434d"],"scopeContentSha256":"d5be1898eafd678addd3ef17773f78947a3ba7263c5591d9f0f03217dcd4bfc3","placementContentSha256":"d6d282f9dca656c2a84478a1fa1043beb221e82fd809c6fdf89fa4f90aeb8de3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["placement-pilot:coverage:proposal","placement-pilot:coverage:challenge","root:placement-pilot-admission"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","textSha256":"744e8976216dc8e186c72e191582048f765a06303764370041d6e145638f202d"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/admission.json","sha256":"bc0f5545efd2d0dfc09239a354e9596043f8dd62f9566492f93539258112af66"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-pilot-review-v1/admitted-v1/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"74e1c3f9e28109607002d8c2daad27523df38df756e623e4e601fe1f4830bf81","bytes":1333575,"unitId":"unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","textSha256":"744e8976216dc8e186c72e191582048f765a06303764370041d6e145638f202d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fc775fabb3191d64857ad3e6","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Inflationary observables, reheating, dark-matter production and BBN/isocurvature restrictions remain compound targets. Independent challenge qualification: Observables, reheating, relic production and BBN/isocurvature restrictions remain compound targets for reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:fc775fabb3191d64857ad3e6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","q025-candidate-question:efb14fda2db508a780ceabc2"],"scopeContentSha256":"5d417a0fbda515287e8c5249a8dae741394e71605d3ba2b32d39982005753813","contributionContentSha256":"5234e5c92b31eb6b1ae8ecc844257018e9e0525f19a3f3040a20eaf8e97dee92","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:7f5fa4d1c33ea07be5f0c85410cf9582235c391042d93578147753f084eb4bd0","textSha256":"744e8976216dc8e186c72e191582048f765a06303764370041d6e145638f202d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:fc775fabb3191d64857ad3e6","recordId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-3d1118c04f114f9ecdc6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Inflationary observables, reheating, dark-matter production and BBN/isocurvature restrictions remain compound targets.","challengeNote":"Observables, reheating, relic production and BBN/isocurvature restrictions remain compound targets for reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"10a6de5e97bb6459399f70d49b6d90f67bb506d21e9c9060fedba4e7b1de5d88"},"organizational-access:768ae2111973cd20d0784f7c":{"id":"organizational-access:768ae2111973cd20d0784f7c","source":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","target":"q025-candidate-question:2f1a39d17de3d528d60633bf","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"23ff9118dfec8a655b571ba9ace4d2116a06675da50b80f04409cfbcecc4a308","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d2d02e5e315cbf7b186130d1"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:2f1a39d17de3d528d60633bf","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f83d831304cc6df5f4efb24a1739f427443a0b9cbf4e46a385360c7ed003cb92","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:76e026867f4c7367339a4584"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:2d9d7fbb41320ed17d2f06cd39c512de42fd653c7fc7f1b88579ed2a4950d333","home":{"unitId":"unit:2d9d7fbb41320ed17d2f06cd39c512de42fd653c7fc7f1b88579ed2a4950d333","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2d9d7fbb41320ed17d2f06cd39c512de42fd653c7fc7f1b88579ed2a4950d333","paperId":"2007.15009","textSha256":"2879d05de93e3bcdc4d83b183533884f0701bb338854875eff67a34bd05da5d3"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8aac850c0baefc1c3b4f73a9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8aac850c0baefc1c3b4f73a9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2d9d7fbb41320ed17d2f06cd39c512de42fd653c7fc7f1b88579ed2a4950d333","q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8"],"scopeContentSha256":"23ff9118dfec8a655b571ba9ace4d2116a06675da50b80f04409cfbcecc4a308","placementContentSha256":"cc3eb72c7ab02fe97875cd395e92a13aab26c3249748f72f9f252c5d8ef22363","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2d9d7fbb41320ed17d2f06cd39c512de42fd653c7fc7f1b88579ed2a4950d333","paperId":"2007.15009","textSha256":"2879d05de93e3bcdc4d83b183533884f0701bb338854875eff67a34bd05da5d3"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8aac850c0baefc1c3b4f73a9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2d9d7fbb41320ed17d2f06cd39c512de42fd653c7fc7f1b88579ed2a4950d333","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2f1a39d17de3d528d60633bf","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:2d9d7fbb41320ed17d2f06cd39c512de42fd653c7fc7f1b88579ed2a4950d333","textSha256":"2879d05de93e3bcdc4d83b183533884f0701bb338854875eff67a34bd05da5d3"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5cc8c3917dfe34b10816e589"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5cc8c3917dfe34b10816e589","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2d9d7fbb41320ed17d2f06cd39c512de42fd653c7fc7f1b88579ed2a4950d333","q025-candidate-question:2f1a39d17de3d528d60633bf"],"scopeContentSha256":"f83d831304cc6df5f4efb24a1739f427443a0b9cbf4e46a385360c7ed003cb92","contributionContentSha256":"61bef282cbaa8f741e47ecdf340c0ded174ac4e37803fc859268a86274f25db4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:2d9d7fbb41320ed17d2f06cd39c512de42fd653c7fc7f1b88579ed2a4950d333","textSha256":"2879d05de93e3bcdc4d83b183533884f0701bb338854875eff67a34bd05da5d3"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5cc8c3917dfe34b10816e589","recordId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","home":{"unitId":"unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","paperId":"2212.08001","textSha256":"251cec4b812fcdefb47c6f2c06fed5421b3e2ec4d81454914e964d33b13d57e7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f8bcb2ab68b1a74b5d69776c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f8bcb2ab68b1a74b5d69776c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8"],"scopeContentSha256":"23ff9118dfec8a655b571ba9ace4d2116a06675da50b80f04409cfbcecc4a308","placementContentSha256":"a5ae346defecfaeb71841a4e568ec59b807477acb0a8ee33ddcc5f95c59bbb90","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","paperId":"2212.08001","textSha256":"251cec4b812fcdefb47c6f2c06fed5421b3e2ec4d81454914e964d33b13d57e7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f8bcb2ab68b1a74b5d69776c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2f1a39d17de3d528d60633bf","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","textSha256":"251cec4b812fcdefb47c6f2c06fed5421b3e2ec4d81454914e964d33b13d57e7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e66a523feda6a7872fbe6337"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e66a523feda6a7872fbe6337","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","q025-candidate-question:2f1a39d17de3d528d60633bf"],"scopeContentSha256":"f83d831304cc6df5f4efb24a1739f427443a0b9cbf4e46a385360c7ed003cb92","contributionContentSha256":"7c90b88f4e289dacc1b07a9ba43eb3aa94a6f70bc205b01a0a2f77a06605e97a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:8411682605812d8c939b54b11f69fad2641c608498df036413c947a741ca039e","textSha256":"251cec4b812fcdefb47c6f2c06fed5421b3e2ec4d81454914e964d33b13d57e7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e66a523feda6a7872fbe6337","recordId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Avoiding a need for super-Planckian control is a target, not an established premise.","challengeNote":"Avoiding a need for super-Planckian control is an announced target, not an independently established result.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:afbc39ab67289457564951c4dfb5f02691ec225766bec15d79b4ef24b82d9b74","home":{"unitId":"unit:afbc39ab67289457564951c4dfb5f02691ec225766bec15d79b4ef24b82d9b74","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q28 explicitly combines gravitational infrared prescriptions, EFT interaction bounds and weak-gravity tests across photon, graviton and scalar sectors.","qualification":"q28 covers the four-dimensional forward singularity problem and all black-hole, mild-WGC and scalar-modified-gravity consequences. Pole control and the subsequent inferences remain conditional; a historical proof assertion is not accepted as a current theorem.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:afbc39ab67289457564951c4dfb5f02691ec225766bec15d79b4ef24b82d9b74","paperId":"1902.03250","textSha256":"df0adc61634dd4ffbbd74765563709d84c2a35c15cfa0d4ecc6a4f0aa412cc6b"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0026:u10:q28"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0026:u10:q28","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:afbc39ab67289457564951c4dfb5f02691ec225766bec15d79b4ef24b82d9b74","q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8"],"scopeContentSha256":"23ff9118dfec8a655b571ba9ace4d2116a06675da50b80f04409cfbcecc4a308","placementContentSha256":"40d885b7932372dd076578d3d3a0c1b65dddf70e35c724b660d3ea0ff46af50a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0026:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0026:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:afbc39ab67289457564951c4dfb5f02691ec225766bec15d79b4ef24b82d9b74","paperId":"1902.03250","textSha256":"df0adc61634dd4ffbbd74765563709d84c2a35c15cfa0d4ecc6a4f0aa412cc6b"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0026","unitRef":"u10"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:afbc39ab67289457564951c4dfb5f02691ec225766bec15d79b4ef24b82d9b74","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2f1a39d17de3d528d60633bf","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:afbc39ab67289457564951c4dfb5f02691ec225766bec15d79b4ef24b82d9b74","textSha256":"df0adc61634dd4ffbbd74765563709d84c2a35c15cfa0d4ecc6a4f0aa412cc6b"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3616e0a494008bcd78340591705a7a5a","paperId":"1902.03250","sourceSha256":"39a4ec29c9a9c3bc629f71116ed1b9e5e060cf921be06e0dd6bcd3008a5fd4ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6c83d49c626ba1dd370a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8c1d2c204002fee65737f17981ffa592858e7980580a7756121ae3923e848ff9","pdfPage":1,"start":106,"end":3503,"textSha256":"aa3cfeee4a7bafdffb9083e9e768f540d37621ad761990bd413bd37b1b443207","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3f7690cf88822a8c9881c6f2402500ab","paperId":"1902.03250","sourceSha256":"39a4ec29c9a9c3bc629f71116ed1b9e5e060cf921be06e0dd6bcd3008a5fd4ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6c83d49c626ba1dd370a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8c1d2c204002fee65737f17981ffa592858e7980580a7756121ae3923e848ff9","pdfPage":1,"start":1304,"end":4706,"textSha256":"93b0c8e29ad97ef335d65cf98054ea933c6e43e88dfc156babcbb105486887a6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:672c39014e524d9eaa30f446e4a4eb05","paperId":"1902.03250","sourceSha256":"39a4ec29c9a9c3bc629f71116ed1b9e5e060cf921be06e0dd6bcd3008a5fd4ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6c83d49c626ba1dd370a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8c1d2c204002fee65737f17981ffa592858e7980580a7756121ae3923e848ff9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"fe019b09a2eba36e510100a90d83fc378f4c07d311f3a884866d7adcd8cd101c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2bcd900afc9ef2558f426d52"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2bcd900afc9ef2558f426d52","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:afbc39ab67289457564951c4dfb5f02691ec225766bec15d79b4ef24b82d9b74","q025-candidate-question:2f1a39d17de3d528d60633bf"],"scopeContentSha256":"f83d831304cc6df5f4efb24a1739f427443a0b9cbf4e46a385360c7ed003cb92","contributionContentSha256":"bea322fd3b289f9a7b945d00091b3359f261ad87876e215d93d1dea4378b0058","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:afbc39ab67289457564951c4dfb5f02691ec225766bec15d79b4ef24b82d9b74","textSha256":"df0adc61634dd4ffbbd74765563709d84c2a35c15cfa0d4ecc6a4f0aa412cc6b"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3616e0a494008bcd78340591705a7a5a","paperId":"1902.03250","sourceSha256":"39a4ec29c9a9c3bc629f71116ed1b9e5e060cf921be06e0dd6bcd3008a5fd4ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6c83d49c626ba1dd370a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8c1d2c204002fee65737f17981ffa592858e7980580a7756121ae3923e848ff9","pdfPage":1,"start":106,"end":3503,"textSha256":"aa3cfeee4a7bafdffb9083e9e768f540d37621ad761990bd413bd37b1b443207","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3f7690cf88822a8c9881c6f2402500ab","paperId":"1902.03250","sourceSha256":"39a4ec29c9a9c3bc629f71116ed1b9e5e060cf921be06e0dd6bcd3008a5fd4ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6c83d49c626ba1dd370a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8c1d2c204002fee65737f17981ffa592858e7980580a7756121ae3923e848ff9","pdfPage":1,"start":1304,"end":4706,"textSha256":"93b0c8e29ad97ef335d65cf98054ea933c6e43e88dfc156babcbb105486887a6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:672c39014e524d9eaa30f446e4a4eb05","paperId":"1902.03250","sourceSha256":"39a4ec29c9a9c3bc629f71116ed1b9e5e060cf921be06e0dd6bcd3008a5fd4ff","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/6c83d49c626ba1dd370a/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8c1d2c204002fee65737f17981ffa592858e7980580a7756121ae3923e848ff9","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"fe019b09a2eba36e510100a90d83fc378f4c07d311f3a884866d7adcd8cd101c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2bcd900afc9ef2558f426d52","recordId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound pole-treatment, black-hole and modified-scalar targets; the claimed proof remains a dated source assertion.","challengeNote":"Compound pole-treatment, black-hole and modified-scalar targets. The September 2019 proof claim remains historical source context.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"24153d7ad9f4a39c615388cb2d16d6fceecddeb0aef2b18f3a2a06d1aee47a7c"},"organizational-access:08e1481ab923a76b06e7cb55":{"id":"organizational-access:08e1481ab923a76b06e7cb55","source":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","target":"q025-candidate-question:d7eff9c143cead9be06735d4","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"23ff9118dfec8a655b571ba9ace4d2116a06675da50b80f04409cfbcecc4a308","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d2d02e5e315cbf7b186130d1"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:d7eff9c143cead9be06735d4","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e1f0df6f67e1d89e0b02f2b96082921eece302e1a6bed03352d1d607f24cf55b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e485d52f0a6eb184a3eeda01"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:2ce00c7adf4b8b57ef5ca8cc514599b0b3c57528310c8432b5cf5a020f08e5af","home":{"unitId":"unit:2ce00c7adf4b8b57ef5ca8cc514599b0b3c57528310c8432b5cf5a020f08e5af","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2ce00c7adf4b8b57ef5ca8cc514599b0b3c57528310c8432b5cf5a020f08e5af","paperId":"2301.01999","textSha256":"3afef916456d1b2c0e7f0c23d6869eef78d0f859d10f55ca6c704e73dfc3127f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:927d5f24edb7d67249b05254"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:927d5f24edb7d67249b05254","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2ce00c7adf4b8b57ef5ca8cc514599b0b3c57528310c8432b5cf5a020f08e5af","q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8"],"scopeContentSha256":"23ff9118dfec8a655b571ba9ace4d2116a06675da50b80f04409cfbcecc4a308","placementContentSha256":"2761540f3db94523fa1b82e70b0748831138049c875291e4c0b4d6369c56bc6a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2ce00c7adf4b8b57ef5ca8cc514599b0b3c57528310c8432b5cf5a020f08e5af","paperId":"2301.01999","textSha256":"3afef916456d1b2c0e7f0c23d6869eef78d0f859d10f55ca6c704e73dfc3127f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:927d5f24edb7d67249b05254"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2ce00c7adf4b8b57ef5ca8cc514599b0b3c57528310c8432b5cf5a020f08e5af","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d7eff9c143cead9be06735d4","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:2ce00c7adf4b8b57ef5ca8cc514599b0b3c57528310c8432b5cf5a020f08e5af","textSha256":"3afef916456d1b2c0e7f0c23d6869eef78d0f859d10f55ca6c704e73dfc3127f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1da5f740502267663ac31b92"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1da5f740502267663ac31b92","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2ce00c7adf4b8b57ef5ca8cc514599b0b3c57528310c8432b5cf5a020f08e5af","q025-candidate-question:d7eff9c143cead9be06735d4"],"scopeContentSha256":"e1f0df6f67e1d89e0b02f2b96082921eece302e1a6bed03352d1d607f24cf55b","contributionContentSha256":"07f296aa984ddad9ec0c3e902761f594772f9f85e4a6a6c614837f9e10ef13b4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:2ce00c7adf4b8b57ef5ca8cc514599b0b3c57528310c8432b5cf5a020f08e5af","textSha256":"3afef916456d1b2c0e7f0c23d6869eef78d0f859d10f55ca6c704e73dfc3127f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1da5f740502267663ac31b92","recordId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Combines finite Regge contributions with a test of the unusually low scalar-QED cutoff.","challengeNote":"Finite Regge terms and the unusually low scalar-QED cutoff are linked but distinct targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","home":{"unitId":"unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","paperId":"2406.07606","textSha256":"527c56ec6c0d01c1a4ae70488489fa4c5d616b1b5febc53fa3bdfc56fb9e4655"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b67710f2e8e0776a8aba48e4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b67710f2e8e0776a8aba48e4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8"],"scopeContentSha256":"23ff9118dfec8a655b571ba9ace4d2116a06675da50b80f04409cfbcecc4a308","placementContentSha256":"31ec60a9db26d4a30092970a53918df51bed70575f05c8bada8e8b8eb273b269","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","paperId":"2406.07606","textSha256":"527c56ec6c0d01c1a4ae70488489fa4c5d616b1b5febc53fa3bdfc56fb9e4655"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b67710f2e8e0776a8aba48e4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d7eff9c143cead9be06735d4","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","textSha256":"527c56ec6c0d01c1a4ae70488489fa4c5d616b1b5febc53fa3bdfc56fb9e4655"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8bb698541d684277c325e5a6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8bb698541d684277c325e5a6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","q025-candidate-question:d7eff9c143cead9be06735d4"],"scopeContentSha256":"e1f0df6f67e1d89e0b02f2b96082921eece302e1a6bed03352d1d607f24cf55b","contributionContentSha256":"e9d2e16dda9bb37ac871f20039d849fb7a1f494ec1045473c84036424f9a0b55","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:80b33ffba0e30653cae81636483e2daa44b4063db79b4177a64fc5dc72357334","textSha256":"527c56ec6c0d01c1a4ae70488489fa4c5d616b1b5febc53fa3bdfc56fb9e4655"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8bb698541d684277c325e5a6","recordId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f84a3eed9de9e4d742118e493274a3e2cd794ea58739e4a21c1fa9661725b184","home":{"unitId":"unit:f84a3eed9de9e4d742118e493274a3e2cd794ea58739e4a21c1fa9661725b184","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f84a3eed9de9e4d742118e493274a3e2cd794ea58739e4a21c1fa9661725b184","paperId":"2112.12561","textSha256":"53e4102117958b3e0ad3c498fc1592305ea07dbb20dc4c9aa73d732f19f435d7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5bd9f31cdc3377217df3bdef"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5bd9f31cdc3377217df3bdef","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f84a3eed9de9e4d742118e493274a3e2cd794ea58739e4a21c1fa9661725b184","q025-candidate-region:38de34fa56dfdfd771b653d8"],"scopeContentSha256":"23ff9118dfec8a655b571ba9ace4d2116a06675da50b80f04409cfbcecc4a308","placementContentSha256":"304a6f3f4cc525fa608727e1ce133b0ded257903c4e5d0b0ac79b2e0f4b652dd","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f84a3eed9de9e4d742118e493274a3e2cd794ea58739e4a21c1fa9661725b184","paperId":"2112.12561","textSha256":"53e4102117958b3e0ad3c498fc1592305ea07dbb20dc4c9aa73d732f19f435d7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:5bd9f31cdc3377217df3bdef"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f84a3eed9de9e4d742118e493274a3e2cd794ea58739e4a21c1fa9661725b184","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:d7eff9c143cead9be06735d4","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:f84a3eed9de9e4d742118e493274a3e2cd794ea58739e4a21c1fa9661725b184","textSha256":"53e4102117958b3e0ad3c498fc1592305ea07dbb20dc4c9aa73d732f19f435d7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:98683c78608bf3a56732860d"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:98683c78608bf3a56732860d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f84a3eed9de9e4d742118e493274a3e2cd794ea58739e4a21c1fa9661725b184","q025-candidate-question:d7eff9c143cead9be06735d4"],"scopeContentSha256":"e1f0df6f67e1d89e0b02f2b96082921eece302e1a6bed03352d1d607f24cf55b","contributionContentSha256":"bfb250fa45a0ba765051748f1baf2f5b6cf2fda15e85a038f4b0b6162cb38548","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:f84a3eed9de9e4d742118e493274a3e2cd794ea58739e4a21c1fa9661725b184","textSha256":"53e4102117958b3e0ad3c498fc1592305ea07dbb20dc4c9aa73d732f19f435d7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:98683c78608bf3a56732860d","recordId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2bb36b2ccecd56449d47-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"5a3421c0063bb711386d7bfe6dd831e8ca8117c96e6866d28f0630a9582578c3"},"organizational-access:edf01233d3f1c3bd6d030fdf":{"id":"organizational-access:edf01233d3f1c3bd6d030fdf","source":"q025-candidate-region:41d2cbb62528201e0c7e2fdf","target":"q025-candidate-question:165edf41405890a5da70439b","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:41d2cbb62528201e0c7e2fdf","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"1d76f4a91f0833b9620ece04ed2ad4dbaa5b4c622b70bb6ac0d52e69e5b022e1","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d3c61e01490c4bdab8e9b9c7"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:165edf41405890a5da70439b","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"9b68ce7bb42ab4dfc63f93c0c756337caee1499752eb5b3372209912fc15073d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:35a9fef3b60ef95a9b2494bf"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:fe7cffac20a4ca48c81b29f613a0606291f15b989ae49afc0d59044d8be39fa5","home":{"unitId":"unit:fe7cffac20a4ca48c81b29f613a0606291f15b989ae49afc0d59044d8be39fa5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:41d2cbb62528201e0c7e2fdf","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Explicitly combines dynamical supersymmetry-breaking uplift, stabilized nonnegative-energy vacua, vacuum survival and mediation consequences.","qualification":"q24 explicitly combines construction, vacuum survival and mediation, covering the zero-energy endpoint, TeV gravitino, stabilized moduli, lifetime and visible soft terms. q1 supplies uplift and lifetime coverage but omits the complete soft-term target; q0 supplies phenomenology without construction and survival. q26 does not state decay-lifetime coverage as explicitly as q24.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fe7cffac20a4ca48c81b29f613a0606291f15b989ae49afc0d59044d8be39fa5","paperId":"hep-th/0610297","textSha256":"e6a5d44b341d82956286e6c171a65f00ad96832792bbded5f11efd5fc8b0bbc1"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0063:u10:q24"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0063:u10:q24","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fe7cffac20a4ca48c81b29f613a0606291f15b989ae49afc0d59044d8be39fa5","q025-candidate-region:41d2cbb62528201e0c7e2fdf"],"scopeContentSha256":"1d76f4a91f0833b9620ece04ed2ad4dbaa5b4c622b70bb6ac0d52e69e5b022e1","placementContentSha256":"f14bc246f14c9a19124c96a1722a3e42822d7ed1eb3bb6e2f259917dd1b4830d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0063:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0063:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fe7cffac20a4ca48c81b29f613a0606291f15b989ae49afc0d59044d8be39fa5","paperId":"hep-th/0610297","textSha256":"e6a5d44b341d82956286e6c171a65f00ad96832792bbded5f11efd5fc8b0bbc1"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0063","unitRef":"u10"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fe7cffac20a4ca48c81b29f613a0606291f15b989ae49afc0d59044d8be39fa5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:165edf41405890a5da70439b","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:fe7cffac20a4ca48c81b29f613a0606291f15b989ae49afc0d59044d8be39fa5","textSha256":"e6a5d44b341d82956286e6c171a65f00ad96832792bbded5f11efd5fc8b0bbc1"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:39b25ae5a584511ff2ac475b5e6311ca","paperId":"hep-th/0610297","sourceSha256":"f726494c784e86329fa424ff1f702ba3fbfd839b1ed5e4f036d99ddc1fe826e0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/14894bda54ae67a07cd7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"72c8be75347b230f587d52bb32ce86d6f2bf94ef9400067688fb5e5c6fc3bcd0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1172,"textSha256":"a666a5542f35fea5641bd8aab36fade177669b619aa7865dc983b6e9819cdf4c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9f36d1bc883b5329769c1d544dc7e52f","paperId":"hep-th/0610297","sourceSha256":"f726494c784e86329fa424ff1f702ba3fbfd839b1ed5e4f036d99ddc1fe826e0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/14894bda54ae67a07cd7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"72c8be75347b230f587d52bb32ce86d6f2bf94ef9400067688fb5e5c6fc3bcd0","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":3129,"textSha256":"41512a7df5aeb8588f702359f34abfda90fb5e9a7eb7f6a45de8ab06bab3c418","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f35836e76e8a275b7c06d91c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f35836e76e8a275b7c06d91c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fe7cffac20a4ca48c81b29f613a0606291f15b989ae49afc0d59044d8be39fa5","q025-candidate-question:165edf41405890a5da70439b"],"scopeContentSha256":"9b68ce7bb42ab4dfc63f93c0c756337caee1499752eb5b3372209912fc15073d","contributionContentSha256":"314adab68372c088db3f38b30cdffe01e8bfb2ad1b01d3fc6ebd84e8e2d9d4e9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-proposal","leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:fe7cffac20a4ca48c81b29f613a0606291f15b989ae49afc0d59044d8be39fa5","textSha256":"e6a5d44b341d82956286e6c171a65f00ad96832792bbded5f11efd5fc8b0bbc1"},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:39b25ae5a584511ff2ac475b5e6311ca","paperId":"hep-th/0610297","sourceSha256":"f726494c784e86329fa424ff1f702ba3fbfd839b1ed5e4f036d99ddc1fe826e0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/14894bda54ae67a07cd7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"72c8be75347b230f587d52bb32ce86d6f2bf94ef9400067688fb5e5c6fc3bcd0","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1172,"textSha256":"a666a5542f35fea5641bd8aab36fade177669b619aa7865dc983b6e9819cdf4c","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9f36d1bc883b5329769c1d544dc7e52f","paperId":"hep-th/0610297","sourceSha256":"f726494c784e86329fa424ff1f702ba3fbfd839b1ed5e4f036d99ddc1fe826e0","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/14894bda54ae67a07cd7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"72c8be75347b230f587d52bb32ce86d6f2bf94ef9400067688fb5e5c6fc3bcd0","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":3129,"textSha256":"41512a7df5aeb8588f702359f34abfda90fb5e9a7eb7f6a45de8ab06bab3c418","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f35836e76e8a275b7c06d91c","recordId":"leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-fc950e4a565d1ce2661a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Compound: uplift, lifetime and soft terms. Supersymmetric AdS minima may coexist with the metastable zero-energy target.","challengeNote":"Compound uplift, lifetime and soft-term targets. Supersymmetric AdS minima may coexist; suppressed decay is reported without a supplied rate calculation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"8d224091a0186bda6023777f52dd92b371a2732b14b23749f6ba03aa052d491c"},"organizational-access:e787d20f156cd91f7b63d994":{"id":"organizational-access:e787d20f156cd91f7b63d994","source":"q025-candidate-region:44919b69b7e1732d49289f30","target":"q025-candidate-question:11bfeda5ad2753a4e283af62","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:44919b69b7e1732d49289f30","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"fa85c9ae684ac73830028b4e8d56f579cffdee0d1cfc790d6eaa43929aa0dbd0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:81eb15a8e8998a6f3a4b9fd5"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:11bfeda5ad2753a4e283af62","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"25a958db163169598f00d01d2d887ba5ad847a8f88e806921aef8aca0bce9ac8","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3aadb8cf7cdb4922d00fc54f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:cad75bb6b04b67650e44ec4eb63215bcd874e4e6d9798d3b656a50d66c8b6127","home":{"unitId":"unit:cad75bb6b04b67650e44ec4eb63215bcd874e4e6d9798d3b656a50d66c8b6127","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:44919b69b7e1732d49289f30","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cad75bb6b04b67650e44ec4eb63215bcd874e4e6d9798d3b656a50d66c8b6127","paperId":"1511.06768","textSha256":"d3ff714d3421d1af0238fe60ee02258540352c40737a29ef6263c26521b3712f"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2418b098c47449aebcb65aa057fe97b5","paperId":"1511.06768","sourceSha256":"ca1b2aa5072ce95ec064c7bc6d7f2438a1af6ac69f7c1f1e2a88657418117674","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3e1b8bcf9ddebae3d739/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fce0a4d6ef317b9e98237e3b878e008a9e7e975ad384731ecff7fec5513f069","pdfPage":1,"start":1301,"end":2918,"textSha256":"aeb253f7f9fd21f56aafa31383a3324fd0c97f4989be51883d901dcc651af804","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:93e8ae972d6f5f08e29be378788b0b5d","paperId":"1511.06768","sourceSha256":"ca1b2aa5072ce95ec064c7bc6d7f2438a1af6ac69f7c1f1e2a88657418117674","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3e1b8bcf9ddebae3d739/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fce0a4d6ef317b9e98237e3b878e008a9e7e975ad384731ecff7fec5513f069","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c6089690d23df360aa460085a8abd08655c039e163a3634e382b15d8f65bb068","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d608ca9a5379dcd7cc792cb4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d608ca9a5379dcd7cc792cb4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cad75bb6b04b67650e44ec4eb63215bcd874e4e6d9798d3b656a50d66c8b6127","q025-candidate-region:44919b69b7e1732d49289f30"],"scopeContentSha256":"fa85c9ae684ac73830028b4e8d56f579cffdee0d1cfc790d6eaa43929aa0dbd0","placementContentSha256":"fb2788d997755252412d9cb9de27455ed139e1500b1c00872b9e9a8d88c65045","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge","leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cad75bb6b04b67650e44ec4eb63215bcd874e4e6d9798d3b656a50d66c8b6127","paperId":"1511.06768","textSha256":"d3ff714d3421d1af0238fe60ee02258540352c40737a29ef6263c26521b3712f"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2418b098c47449aebcb65aa057fe97b5","paperId":"1511.06768","sourceSha256":"ca1b2aa5072ce95ec064c7bc6d7f2438a1af6ac69f7c1f1e2a88657418117674","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3e1b8bcf9ddebae3d739/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fce0a4d6ef317b9e98237e3b878e008a9e7e975ad384731ecff7fec5513f069","pdfPage":1,"start":1301,"end":2918,"textSha256":"aeb253f7f9fd21f56aafa31383a3324fd0c97f4989be51883d901dcc651af804","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:93e8ae972d6f5f08e29be378788b0b5d","paperId":"1511.06768","sourceSha256":"ca1b2aa5072ce95ec064c7bc6d7f2438a1af6ac69f7c1f1e2a88657418117674","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3e1b8bcf9ddebae3d739/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fce0a4d6ef317b9e98237e3b878e008a9e7e975ad384731ecff7fec5513f069","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c6089690d23df360aa460085a8abd08655c039e163a3634e382b15d8f65bb068","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d608ca9a5379dcd7cc792cb4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cad75bb6b04b67650e44ec4eb63215bcd874e4e6d9798d3b656a50d66c8b6127","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:11bfeda5ad2753a4e283af62","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:cad75bb6b04b67650e44ec4eb63215bcd874e4e6d9798d3b656a50d66c8b6127","textSha256":"d3ff714d3421d1af0238fe60ee02258540352c40737a29ef6263c26521b3712f"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2418b098c47449aebcb65aa057fe97b5","paperId":"1511.06768","sourceSha256":"ca1b2aa5072ce95ec064c7bc6d7f2438a1af6ac69f7c1f1e2a88657418117674","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3e1b8bcf9ddebae3d739/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fce0a4d6ef317b9e98237e3b878e008a9e7e975ad384731ecff7fec5513f069","pdfPage":1,"start":1301,"end":2918,"textSha256":"aeb253f7f9fd21f56aafa31383a3324fd0c97f4989be51883d901dcc651af804","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:93e8ae972d6f5f08e29be378788b0b5d","paperId":"1511.06768","sourceSha256":"ca1b2aa5072ce95ec064c7bc6d7f2438a1af6ac69f7c1f1e2a88657418117674","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3e1b8bcf9ddebae3d739/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fce0a4d6ef317b9e98237e3b878e008a9e7e975ad384731ecff7fec5513f069","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c6089690d23df360aa460085a8abd08655c039e163a3634e382b15d8f65bb068","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:90ff24c67c61335955511fd8","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound detectability, cold-radiation and cogenesis targets. The selected interacting regime does not require dark-disk formation. Independent challenge qualification: Add p7 for the explicit visible-sector detectability target. Compound cold-radiation and cogenesis targets remain; dark-disk formation is not assumed."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:90ff24c67c61335955511fd8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cad75bb6b04b67650e44ec4eb63215bcd874e4e6d9798d3b656a50d66c8b6127","q025-candidate-question:11bfeda5ad2753a4e283af62"],"scopeContentSha256":"25a958db163169598f00d01d2d887ba5ad847a8f88e806921aef8aca0bce9ac8","contributionContentSha256":"e80921857eb25e4c17d3a5e28982d930c259181b93ffe77b65cfa8b6c6b8b5f1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-proposal","leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:cad75bb6b04b67650e44ec4eb63215bcd874e4e6d9798d3b656a50d66c8b6127","textSha256":"d3ff714d3421d1af0238fe60ee02258540352c40737a29ef6263c26521b3712f"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2418b098c47449aebcb65aa057fe97b5","paperId":"1511.06768","sourceSha256":"ca1b2aa5072ce95ec064c7bc6d7f2438a1af6ac69f7c1f1e2a88657418117674","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3e1b8bcf9ddebae3d739/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fce0a4d6ef317b9e98237e3b878e008a9e7e975ad384731ecff7fec5513f069","pdfPage":1,"start":1301,"end":2918,"textSha256":"aeb253f7f9fd21f56aafa31383a3324fd0c97f4989be51883d901dcc651af804","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:93e8ae972d6f5f08e29be378788b0b5d","paperId":"1511.06768","sourceSha256":"ca1b2aa5072ce95ec064c7bc6d7f2438a1af6ac69f7c1f1e2a88657418117674","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/3e1b8bcf9ddebae3d739/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0fce0a4d6ef317b9e98237e3b878e008a9e7e975ad384731ecff7fec5513f069","pdfPage":4,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"c6089690d23df360aa460085a8abd08655c039e163a3634e382b15d8f65bb068","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:90ff24c67c61335955511fd8","recordId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound detectability, cold-radiation and cogenesis targets. The selected interacting regime does not require dark-disk formation.","challengeNote":"Add p7 for the explicit visible-sector detectability target. Compound cold-radiation and cogenesis targets remain; dark-disk formation is not assumed.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"40b84671a28ef4c7ddce2c6e59a007315975792ea238d254ef5b8c6a7563fc88"},"organizational-access:ae305c391039d55f766312a5":{"id":"organizational-access:ae305c391039d55f766312a5","source":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","target":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:864135f72fedd7ba3f55409f"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0f607371ea101890393fea69"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","home":{"unitId":"unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","textSha256":"f5f33ec29b58901375340da5e7853147fe9dd28011a216435d2e4ceb12e02793"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2d8f9c1bce4badad8c955ff6f81e1647","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":20,"start":95,"end":2946,"textSha256":"ed91ce733a0623c035876b44aa9e9a8046f62e914d11ea4d24d40e14dcb22580","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7c4f407830d3c031da26b35370f0fb12","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3031,"textSha256":"38b1e47550773d3515acb275f0c0946a74ae48ecd2718cc169a329aaece2c61e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:7597544ffd9059fb56659ce5"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:7597544ffd9059fb56659ce5","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"c485e336c7ba17f41d59a8b60ea7598a01ead085571aeb5fac33daa2bd5fe71c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","textSha256":"f5f33ec29b58901375340da5e7853147fe9dd28011a216435d2e4ceb12e02793"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2d8f9c1bce4badad8c955ff6f81e1647","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":20,"start":95,"end":2946,"textSha256":"ed91ce733a0623c035876b44aa9e9a8046f62e914d11ea4d24d40e14dcb22580","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7c4f407830d3c031da26b35370f0fb12","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3031,"textSha256":"38b1e47550773d3515acb275f0c0946a74ae48ecd2718cc169a329aaece2c61e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:7597544ffd9059fb56659ce5"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d29","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","textSha256":"f5f33ec29b58901375340da5e7853147fe9dd28011a216435d2e4ceb12e02793"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2d8f9c1bce4badad8c955ff6f81e1647","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":20,"start":95,"end":2946,"textSha256":"ed91ce733a0623c035876b44aa9e9a8046f62e914d11ea4d24d40e14dcb22580","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7c4f407830d3c031da26b35370f0fb12","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3031,"textSha256":"38b1e47550773d3515acb275f0c0946a74ae48ecd2718cc169a329aaece2c61e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a4adc632a69966b8499e749e","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound D7-MSSM spectrum, EWSB and relic targets. Neutralino dominance changes allowed spectra; viability statements use 2005 constraints. Independent challenge qualification: Compound D7-MSSM spectrum, EWSB and relic targets. Neutralino dominance changes allowed regions; the reported viability uses 2005 constraints."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a4adc632a69966b8499e749e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"],"scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","contributionContentSha256":"756494dc28bb19b79fb38fe3476f2059ce25d6a0a660c37609e171ae58bb35e9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d29","kind":"description","unitIndex":29,"unitId":"unit:01bc0c8173b368aa08dc2f130a09e6ebb5f042128a0715452000f66f39cac321","textSha256":"f5f33ec29b58901375340da5e7853147fe9dd28011a216435d2e4ceb12e02793"},{"localRef":"e2","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:2d8f9c1bce4badad8c955ff6f81e1647","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":20,"start":95,"end":2946,"textSha256":"ed91ce733a0623c035876b44aa9e9a8046f62e914d11ea4d24d40e14dcb22580","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7c4f407830d3c031da26b35370f0fb12","paperId":"hep-ph/0507110","sourceSha256":"e16168fe4ac547ef75dc90a86b9856f5a69092fa6c836ab2b38ab368f32d417a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9e9902975c8f431fe916/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"bdb74ad870361c8d8a37929a9e4c03e90658df7365d77c4ca867dc8c1c9c1abd","pdfPage":3,"start":100,"end":3031,"textSha256":"38b1e47550773d3515acb275f0c0946a74ae48ecd2718cc169a329aaece2c61e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a4adc632a69966b8499e749e","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound D7-MSSM spectrum, EWSB and relic targets. Neutralino dominance changes allowed spectra; viability statements use 2005 constraints.","challengeNote":"Compound D7-MSSM spectrum, EWSB and relic targets. Neutralino dominance changes allowed regions; the reported viability uses 2005 constraints.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","home":{"unitId":"unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","paperId":"hep-ph/0509225","textSha256":"3d8c75187ff736f04567e61ae1af5b867452024fdf1f8c7809ad87f198fec72c"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:b902661f3a7923ffd80ea9b1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:b902661f3a7923ffd80ea9b1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"ee075e5bead5ddc8583d12c616059d6e186c9fcd38ff5883dffd5bea737e01fe","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","paperId":"hep-ph/0509225","textSha256":"3d8c75187ff736f04567e61ae1af5b867452024fdf1f8c7809ad87f198fec72c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:b902661f3a7923ffd80ea9b1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","textSha256":"3d8c75187ff736f04567e61ae1af5b867452024fdf1f8c7809ad87f198fec72c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:034d86a151a33480f88817c8","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound spectrum, EWSB and neutralino-composition targets; candidate composition alone does not establish relic-abundance viability. Independent challenge qualification: Compound spectrum, EWSB and neutralino-composition targets. Candidate composition does not establish acceptable relic abundance."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:034d86a151a33480f88817c8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"],"scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","contributionContentSha256":"871a0e8c06621e2360c8be0c0c90b6b7a44b76980c70ec2f62c93029f24d2bd7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:0ace88b90adb2b0ad9517509d8f54ccdf700eb16a9e5f6565febf4fccaafa5be","textSha256":"3d8c75187ff736f04567e61ae1af5b867452024fdf1f8c7809ad87f198fec72c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:034d86a151a33480f88817c8","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound spectrum, EWSB and neutralino-composition targets; candidate composition alone does not establish relic-abundance viability.","challengeNote":"Compound spectrum, EWSB and neutralino-composition targets. Candidate composition does not establish acceptable relic abundance.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:11c64a9574c7812ca866ffe455dfa66bb99851524485b81fd996e966bf19d13f","home":{"unitId":"unit:11c64a9574c7812ca866ffe455dfa66bb99851524485b81fd996e966bf19d13f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Combines soft-spectrum and electroweak targets with source-specific modulus/anomaly mediation and uplift assumptions.","qualification":"q24 covers both low-energy spectra and electroweak breaking under the specified stabilization, sequestered-uplift and comparable-mediation premise. Its effective-theory coverage does not require an unstated compactified string/M origin.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:11c64a9574c7812ca866ffe455dfa66bb99851524485b81fd996e966bf19d13f","paperId":"hep-ph/0504037","textSha256":"b873816290bbc2e071ca76aad4ace2602c550563658bb0b0d08b7234d92d6cfd"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0023:u18:q24"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0023:u18:q24","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:11c64a9574c7812ca866ffe455dfa66bb99851524485b81fd996e966bf19d13f","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"55e24cd3a98c8c674490fbc63f0c2619c3779157cca4186f92ebdf22ffee07e8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0023:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0023:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:11c64a9574c7812ca866ffe455dfa66bb99851524485b81fd996e966bf19d13f","paperId":"hep-ph/0504037","textSha256":"b873816290bbc2e071ca76aad4ace2602c550563658bb0b0d08b7234d92d6cfd"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0023","unitRef":"u18"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:11c64a9574c7812ca866ffe455dfa66bb99851524485b81fd996e966bf19d13f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:11c64a9574c7812ca866ffe455dfa66bb99851524485b81fd996e966bf19d13f","textSha256":"b873816290bbc2e071ca76aad4ace2602c550563658bb0b0d08b7234d92d6cfd"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9988566ab798aec03ad001e0","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: Remove pf2: stabilization and sequestered uplift do not identify a compactified string/M origin in this description. Spectrum and EWSB targets remain source-"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9988566ab798aec03ad001e0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:11c64a9574c7812ca866ffe455dfa66bb99851524485b81fd996e966bf19d13f","q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"],"scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","contributionContentSha256":"6d8cd7c7a9b25eb8063eb40a81cb1a53062437c9ccad1ba069987c5079b2592e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:11c64a9574c7812ca866ffe455dfa66bb99851524485b81fd996e966bf19d13f","textSha256":"b873816290bbc2e071ca76aad4ace2602c550563658bb0b0d08b7234d92d6cfd"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9988566ab798aec03ad001e0","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"Remove pf2: stabilization and sequestered uplift do not identify a compactified string/M origin in this description. Spectrum and EWSB targets remain source-","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:1b3f60d668b6e5e34f7d802825aca8a7da3d450a02c8871cc663009dcd0c4c9b","home":{"unitId":"unit:1b3f60d668b6e5e34f7d802825aca8a7da3d450a02c8871cc663009dcd0c4c9b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1b3f60d668b6e5e34f7d802825aca8a7da3d450a02c8871cc663009dcd0c4c9b","paperId":"0901.1713","textSha256":"3a29ec5418ceb686eb6f3f90241fb865bef805bf3d15cfbf19740f6552b87c68"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:c1adf6b431d3549f186c76e7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:c1adf6b431d3549f186c76e7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1b3f60d668b6e5e34f7d802825aca8a7da3d450a02c8871cc663009dcd0c4c9b","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"a51926c8880e8f9c83c0c8985b396d0761d2a2f40b3328fa4c9d0254e388a284","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1b3f60d668b6e5e34f7d802825aca8a7da3d450a02c8871cc663009dcd0c4c9b","paperId":"0901.1713","textSha256":"3a29ec5418ceb686eb6f3f90241fb865bef805bf3d15cfbf19740f6552b87c68"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:c1adf6b431d3549f186c76e7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1b3f60d668b6e5e34f7d802825aca8a7da3d450a02c8871cc663009dcd0c4c9b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:1b3f60d668b6e5e34f7d802825aca8a7da3d450a02c8871cc663009dcd0c4c9b","textSha256":"3a29ec5418ceb686eb6f3f90241fb865bef805bf3d15cfbf19740f6552b87c68"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9dd9d5988f386f255b68e47d","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound mediation and hierarchy program; metastability and collider implications are possibilities. Independent challenge qualification: Compound mediation and hierarchy program; metastability and collider implications remain possibilities."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9dd9d5988f386f255b68e47d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1b3f60d668b6e5e34f7d802825aca8a7da3d450a02c8871cc663009dcd0c4c9b","q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"],"scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","contributionContentSha256":"9d149c07d0a5d24b30c1bd599878403ec7d97eb44ba56d8c8bee8c023a516d49","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:1b3f60d668b6e5e34f7d802825aca8a7da3d450a02c8871cc663009dcd0c4c9b","textSha256":"3a29ec5418ceb686eb6f3f90241fb865bef805bf3d15cfbf19740f6552b87c68"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9dd9d5988f386f255b68e47d","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound mediation and hierarchy program; metastability and collider implications are possibilities.","challengeNote":"Compound mediation and hierarchy program; metastability and collider implications remain possibilities.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","home":{"unitId":"unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","paperId":"1204.2795","textSha256":"4df6b5b4eea3e625429a47b0a47142026656dc2c59a60048d450f717c4a4a804"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:dcd0ddb107429bd588522ee6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:dcd0ddb107429bd588522ee6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"975966ab19f212265fdb1b0508a29cf9336207b97a9276d7a0c0f639f9f93eff","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","paperId":"1204.2795","textSha256":"4df6b5b4eea3e625429a47b0a47142026656dc2c59a60048d450f717c4a4a804"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:dcd0ddb107429bd588522ee6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","textSha256":"4df6b5b4eea3e625429a47b0a47142026656dc2c59a60048d450f717c4a4a804"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:943ebbc6c88b06ed1114f997","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound particle/dark-matter predictions conditioned on low-energy SUSY, grand unification and cosmology. Independent challenge qualification: Compound particle and dark-matter predictions are conditional on low-energy SUSY, grand unification and cosmology."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:943ebbc6c88b06ed1114f997","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"],"scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","contributionContentSha256":"50db887ed86455f5e0803381f4b140c4f2414dadd020962679c967c6492c2c97","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:489527604010e8c1e725a9b31da69776b13eee8a095805148e026e832702ce11","textSha256":"4df6b5b4eea3e625429a47b0a47142026656dc2c59a60048d450f717c4a4a804"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:943ebbc6c88b06ed1114f997","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound particle/dark-matter predictions conditioned on low-energy SUSY, grand unification and cosmology.","challengeNote":"Compound particle and dark-matter predictions are conditional on low-energy SUSY, grand unification and cosmology.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","home":{"unitId":"unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","textSha256":"b6cb80648baeb089977af4bd22cf8dfb09059581f91ade64681168b9f77e874b"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7166b60b11f721c32ce307a47efa04b8","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2805,"textSha256":"3ba5317c7c58197b6da560920cfed21c82aadc587de51a4470e89f6084206f7f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af24f05e4071e4333662a3f0991336a9","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":2805,"textSha256":"093bf7780e9269290451ca16257e81ffd076dc3103c3b0900fdedcf0b63922aa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:3d59e75656c7b9a7266c6e62"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:3d59e75656c7b9a7266c6e62","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"77753654d32ab35ef0a9d9ad2e2e2174efaa031b00adff3f6372697d7c903058","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","textSha256":"b6cb80648baeb089977af4bd22cf8dfb09059581f91ade64681168b9f77e874b"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7166b60b11f721c32ce307a47efa04b8","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2805,"textSha256":"3ba5317c7c58197b6da560920cfed21c82aadc587de51a4470e89f6084206f7f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af24f05e4071e4333662a3f0991336a9","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":2805,"textSha256":"093bf7780e9269290451ca16257e81ffd076dc3103c3b0900fdedcf0b63922aa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:3d59e75656c7b9a7266c6e62"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","textSha256":"b6cb80648baeb089977af4bd22cf8dfb09059581f91ade64681168b9f77e874b"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7166b60b11f721c32ce307a47efa04b8","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2805,"textSha256":"3ba5317c7c58197b6da560920cfed21c82aadc587de51a4470e89f6084206f7f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af24f05e4071e4333662a3f0991336a9","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":2805,"textSha256":"093bf7780e9269290451ca16257e81ffd076dc3103c3b0900fdedcf0b63922aa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:081448cd6865ce920bf27f25","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound taxonomy with the Planck scale as sole explicit mass input; tuned vacuum energy is admitted and the R-symmetry pattern is not a theorem. Independent challenge qualification: Compound taxonomy with the Planck scale as sole explicit mass input. Vacuum-energy tuning is admitted; the stated R-symmetry pattern is not a theorem."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:081448cd6865ce920bf27f25","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"],"scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","contributionContentSha256":"7c25748da16f4303982c358ec3b0ab4cdbbb520f331afb2dfe3154877448e047","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:9e5952f58d1093b7e27464d4f68812d21a4f260a925be01f9666a58dfadb9e07","textSha256":"b6cb80648baeb089977af4bd22cf8dfb09059581f91ade64681168b9f77e874b"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7166b60b11f721c32ce307a47efa04b8","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2805,"textSha256":"3ba5317c7c58197b6da560920cfed21c82aadc587de51a4470e89f6084206f7f","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:af24f05e4071e4333662a3f0991336a9","paperId":"hep-ph/9308292","sourceSha256":"fdc01d938fece15b9fe9b2a0a241fed950931f3a1e623882fd8d0741c19f9de3","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/f1ed49bd512ae4f955d7/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"4017d3c2a5846236d3f0b450e5fac92e41e0d80da6975b36cab0d219a83f962a","pdfPage":2,"start":100,"end":2805,"textSha256":"093bf7780e9269290451ca16257e81ffd076dc3103c3b0900fdedcf0b63922aa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:081448cd6865ce920bf27f25","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound taxonomy with the Planck scale as sole explicit mass input; tuned vacuum energy is admitted and the R-symmetry pattern is not a theorem.","challengeNote":"Compound taxonomy with the Planck scale as sole explicit mass input. Vacuum-energy tuning is admitted; the stated R-symmetry pattern is not a theorem.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a89ad673796c91d6a0bd8f292dde9faae5fb686f291bb1208aa3d4b66da55f97","home":{"unitId":"unit:a89ad673796c91d6a0bd8f292dde9faae5fb686f291bb1208aa3d4b66da55f97","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a89ad673796c91d6a0bd8f292dde9faae5fb686f291bb1208aa3d4b66da55f97","paperId":"2011.11993","textSha256":"ee5525a86fa7e41bb639a173be5aab62a347cb4604de8b8f4e63cf76b298f4fa"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:966f50e2849b9a3c43a9c466b850f358","paperId":"2011.11993","sourceSha256":"6aafbeb729624496dfce1c9a3b4791fcde958c958c9d24a0f44d28185738ef32","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1e2368e8665bb2a803ed/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f4f15e166601ce8534db1eef6718272b82fb75c9edd90d36919396a1c0a8ce70","pdfPage":2,"start":110,"end":2352,"textSha256":"f3a3ac89feaad7938e56d29713fec3e477b455ed29fc6ad8cf21606aa749a530","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dc1d9d9710d819efd6bd8829f86a7925","paperId":"2011.11993","sourceSha256":"6aafbeb729624496dfce1c9a3b4791fcde958c958c9d24a0f44d28185738ef32","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1e2368e8665bb2a803ed/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f4f15e166601ce8534db1eef6718272b82fb75c9edd90d36919396a1c0a8ce70","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"65fb9a64a6870eceba9d3fd83ea4e7a89d103cb1d29be4acf1936c1c796c45fe","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:7be8138d8852d5ba9c10d176"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:7be8138d8852d5ba9c10d176","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a89ad673796c91d6a0bd8f292dde9faae5fb686f291bb1208aa3d4b66da55f97","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"c47d9dd3aa4eca9181b05376da22660df2fdb1f7f2fe8ab5e027a0fed25cb71c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a89ad673796c91d6a0bd8f292dde9faae5fb686f291bb1208aa3d4b66da55f97","paperId":"2011.11993","textSha256":"ee5525a86fa7e41bb639a173be5aab62a347cb4604de8b8f4e63cf76b298f4fa"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:966f50e2849b9a3c43a9c466b850f358","paperId":"2011.11993","sourceSha256":"6aafbeb729624496dfce1c9a3b4791fcde958c958c9d24a0f44d28185738ef32","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1e2368e8665bb2a803ed/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f4f15e166601ce8534db1eef6718272b82fb75c9edd90d36919396a1c0a8ce70","pdfPage":2,"start":110,"end":2352,"textSha256":"f3a3ac89feaad7938e56d29713fec3e477b455ed29fc6ad8cf21606aa749a530","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dc1d9d9710d819efd6bd8829f86a7925","paperId":"2011.11993","sourceSha256":"6aafbeb729624496dfce1c9a3b4791fcde958c958c9d24a0f44d28185738ef32","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1e2368e8665bb2a803ed/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f4f15e166601ce8534db1eef6718272b82fb75c9edd90d36919396a1c0a8ce70","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"65fb9a64a6870eceba9d3fd83ea4e7a89d103cb1d29be4acf1936c1c796c45fe","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:7be8138d8852d5ba9c10d176"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a89ad673796c91d6a0bd8f292dde9faae5fb686f291bb1208aa3d4b66da55f97","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:a89ad673796c91d6a0bd8f292dde9faae5fb686f291bb1208aa3d4b66da55f97","textSha256":"ee5525a86fa7e41bb639a173be5aab62a347cb4604de8b8f4e63cf76b298f4fa"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:966f50e2849b9a3c43a9c466b850f358","paperId":"2011.11993","sourceSha256":"6aafbeb729624496dfce1c9a3b4791fcde958c958c9d24a0f44d28185738ef32","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1e2368e8665bb2a803ed/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f4f15e166601ce8534db1eef6718272b82fb75c9edd90d36919396a1c0a8ce70","pdfPage":2,"start":110,"end":2352,"textSha256":"f3a3ac89feaad7938e56d29713fec3e477b455ed29fc6ad8cf21606aa749a530","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dc1d9d9710d819efd6bd8829f86a7925","paperId":"2011.11993","sourceSha256":"6aafbeb729624496dfce1c9a3b4791fcde958c958c9d24a0f44d28185738ef32","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1e2368e8665bb2a803ed/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f4f15e166601ce8534db1eef6718272b82fb75c9edd90d36919396a1c0a8ce70","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"65fb9a64a6870eceba9d3fd83ea4e7a89d103cb1d29be4acf1936c1c796c45fe","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d6a2b3e7e539cd4d3b75b833","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Reported percent-level tuning requires light Higgsinos, suitable discrete choices, unification and the source's loop-potential treatment. Independent challenge qualification: Percent-level tuning is conditional on light Higgsinos, suitable discrete choices, unification and the stated loop-potential treatment."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d6a2b3e7e539cd4d3b75b833","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a89ad673796c91d6a0bd8f292dde9faae5fb686f291bb1208aa3d4b66da55f97","q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"],"scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","contributionContentSha256":"617fa5824beff39352eaf471fa9bf8066e9ea15b50e592867144ee644e515136","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:a89ad673796c91d6a0bd8f292dde9faae5fb686f291bb1208aa3d4b66da55f97","textSha256":"ee5525a86fa7e41bb639a173be5aab62a347cb4604de8b8f4e63cf76b298f4fa"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:966f50e2849b9a3c43a9c466b850f358","paperId":"2011.11993","sourceSha256":"6aafbeb729624496dfce1c9a3b4791fcde958c958c9d24a0f44d28185738ef32","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1e2368e8665bb2a803ed/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f4f15e166601ce8534db1eef6718272b82fb75c9edd90d36919396a1c0a8ce70","pdfPage":2,"start":110,"end":2352,"textSha256":"f3a3ac89feaad7938e56d29713fec3e477b455ed29fc6ad8cf21606aa749a530","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dc1d9d9710d819efd6bd8829f86a7925","paperId":"2011.11993","sourceSha256":"6aafbeb729624496dfce1c9a3b4791fcde958c958c9d24a0f44d28185738ef32","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/1e2368e8665bb2a803ed/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f4f15e166601ce8534db1eef6718272b82fb75c9edd90d36919396a1c0a8ce70","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"65fb9a64a6870eceba9d3fd83ea4e7a89d103cb1d29be4acf1936c1c796c45fe","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d6a2b3e7e539cd4d3b75b833","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Reported percent-level tuning requires light Higgsinos, suitable discrete choices, unification and the source's loop-potential treatment.","challengeNote":"Percent-level tuning is conditional on light Higgsinos, suitable discrete choices, unification and the stated loop-potential treatment.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:acfa3c138fe7f7b17c784ccfc8c8cea3c9281ba86224d642963559b38f4a1c7c","home":{"unitId":"unit:acfa3c138fe7f7b17c784ccfc8c8cea3c9281ba86224d642963559b38f4a1c7c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:acfa3c138fe7f7b17c784ccfc8c8cea3c9281ba86224d642963559b38f4a1c7c","paperId":"0806.2672","textSha256":"a8cf4d2012a27468e8bfeb76ebc5f0c471a52beb4c433bab8c358b6cfaf1307e"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:8e84af9881e5961c74865736"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:8e84af9881e5961c74865736","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:acfa3c138fe7f7b17c784ccfc8c8cea3c9281ba86224d642963559b38f4a1c7c","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"709862443e3f7dadf725035905f439a4ded2280508439b97213162ba323e209f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:acfa3c138fe7f7b17c784ccfc8c8cea3c9281ba86224d642963559b38f4a1c7c","paperId":"0806.2672","textSha256":"a8cf4d2012a27468e8bfeb76ebc5f0c471a52beb4c433bab8c358b6cfaf1307e"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:8e84af9881e5961c74865736"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:acfa3c138fe7f7b17c784ccfc8c8cea3c9281ba86224d642963559b38f4a1c7c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:acfa3c138fe7f7b17c784ccfc8c8cea3c9281ba86224d642963559b38f4a1c7c","textSha256":"a8cf4d2012a27468e8bfeb76ebc5f0c471a52beb4c433bab8c358b6cfaf1307e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b18e84c1224dd91c08177e37","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound soft-term/Higgs targets; cosmological-constant tuning is admitted, not explained. Independent challenge qualification: Compound soft-term and Higgs targets; cosmological-constant tuning is admitted rather than explained."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b18e84c1224dd91c08177e37","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:acfa3c138fe7f7b17c784ccfc8c8cea3c9281ba86224d642963559b38f4a1c7c","q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"],"scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","contributionContentSha256":"f8f79bfbd383fcafd50e4279642476f0f3008274a32d5bf4e0712c4f74b419d4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:acfa3c138fe7f7b17c784ccfc8c8cea3c9281ba86224d642963559b38f4a1c7c","textSha256":"a8cf4d2012a27468e8bfeb76ebc5f0c471a52beb4c433bab8c358b6cfaf1307e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b18e84c1224dd91c08177e37","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound soft-term/Higgs targets; cosmological-constant tuning is admitted, not explained.","challengeNote":"Compound soft-term and Higgs targets; cosmological-constant tuning is admitted rather than explained.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","home":{"unitId":"unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers soft-term predictions, electroweak breaking, dark-matter and experimental constraints, and source-era collider prospects.","qualification":"q24 contains the soft-pattern prediction, electroweak test, experimental/dark-matter constraints and prospective collider tests. Kähler-modulus dominance is retained without inferring a compactification, and all constraints remain source-era.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","paperId":"0805.2943","textSha256":"04715bfe5458d8e013b9e5b471c2980a6fdea9d8e26f11ef15c04dbcf4110c85"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0023:u20:q24"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0023:u20:q24","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"071eab4506757bed30cea957a50e597bfa5ac2c1feb9aaa5e08004e7a6a367af","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0023:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0023:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","paperId":"0805.2943","textSha256":"04715bfe5458d8e013b9e5b471c2980a6fdea9d8e26f11ef15c04dbcf4110c85"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0023","unitRef":"u20"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","textSha256":"04715bfe5458d8e013b9e5b471c2980a6fdea9d8e26f11ef15c04dbcf4110c85"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:825f0c85e7bda19ca598cc6d","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound spectrum, electroweak, dark-matter and prospective-test targets remain source-scoped. Independent challenge qualification: Remove pf2: Kähler-modulus dominance does not identify a compactified string/M setting in this description. Compound spectrum, EWSB, dark-matter and test scopes"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:825f0c85e7bda19ca598cc6d","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"],"scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","contributionContentSha256":"978dea83f1651f612cfa188dc642fe6cb0610674272f913a9b04bf9be3930351","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:c5bbd61b6ffbf7b3b79c246c42a374c29e65fddd4a97dcf1bf088ac9a6b9b921","textSha256":"04715bfe5458d8e013b9e5b471c2980a6fdea9d8e26f11ef15c04dbcf4110c85"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:825f0c85e7bda19ca598cc6d","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound spectrum, electroweak, dark-matter and prospective-test targets remain source-scoped.","challengeNote":"Remove pf2: Kähler-modulus dominance does not identify a compactified string/M setting in this description. Compound spectrum, EWSB, dark-matter and test scopes","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c85f81c5a449a568894fda092cbbcd10adb8c797ffb1e7ef9afea547ca5f1d49","home":{"unitId":"unit:c85f81c5a449a568894fda092cbbcd10adb8c797ffb1e7ef9afea547ca5f1d49","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c85f81c5a449a568894fda092cbbcd10adb8c797ffb1e7ef9afea547ca5f1d49","paperId":"hep-th/0505202","textSha256":"1c13dd85fe9abc222fd7cf3f54d3492a072bacb67c1229f93174de36e6df4030"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:dadec977c5a295521df777cd"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:dadec977c5a295521df777cd","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c85f81c5a449a568894fda092cbbcd10adb8c797ffb1e7ef9afea547ca5f1d49","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"6b0f3502cde1cd4b91ef91d8e3a4c26aae0fc52255e18685e9b192af1a5b19a6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c85f81c5a449a568894fda092cbbcd10adb8c797ffb1e7ef9afea547ca5f1d49","paperId":"hep-th/0505202","textSha256":"1c13dd85fe9abc222fd7cf3f54d3492a072bacb67c1229f93174de36e6df4030"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:dadec977c5a295521df777cd"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c85f81c5a449a568894fda092cbbcd10adb8c797ffb1e7ef9afea547ca5f1d49","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:c85f81c5a449a568894fda092cbbcd10adb8c797ffb1e7ef9afea547ca5f1d49","textSha256":"1c13dd85fe9abc222fd7cf3f54d3492a072bacb67c1229f93174de36e6df4030"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aad5a98801d801934962ed6b","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound spectral and tuning questions conditioned on an intermediate-scale branch and dark-matter selection. Independent challenge qualification: Compound spectral and tuning questions conditioned on an intermediate-scale landscape branch and dark-matter selection."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:aad5a98801d801934962ed6b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c85f81c5a449a568894fda092cbbcd10adb8c797ffb1e7ef9afea547ca5f1d49","q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"],"scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","contributionContentSha256":"5eb9ef1b2e81801c7967f9d96a34a0b8ed133ab4c531e7f4a14e18b80964ee9a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:c85f81c5a449a568894fda092cbbcd10adb8c797ffb1e7ef9afea547ca5f1d49","textSha256":"1c13dd85fe9abc222fd7cf3f54d3492a072bacb67c1229f93174de36e6df4030"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:aad5a98801d801934962ed6b","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound spectral and tuning questions conditioned on an intermediate-scale branch and dark-matter selection.","challengeNote":"Compound spectral and tuning questions conditioned on an intermediate-scale landscape branch and dark-matter selection.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:e292d6f025aad66121d75508a8aa35844e2add144cb61d853c67b6b73c559f23","home":{"unitId":"unit:e292d6f025aad66121d75508a8aa35844e2add144cb61d853c67b6b73c559f23","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e292d6f025aad66121d75508a8aa35844e2add144cb61d853c67b6b73c559f23","paperId":"hep-ph/0508029","textSha256":"ad186b2166fbde5edd558daa27ab9ba43517ff740c57feab54c37e5b58ab5308"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:55e1c0245cf329ca8129961c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:55e1c0245cf329ca8129961c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e292d6f025aad66121d75508a8aa35844e2add144cb61d853c67b6b73c559f23","q025-candidate-region:4d6bdfd39abbaae85087b4a7"],"scopeContentSha256":"d35c67377e3cfd8ff2a3538833e23595173ff9ed2f0d32d6817b4843b0b03e8f","placementContentSha256":"11b3381643549098c58ecdfb1c15e01f5e0bb94ce9a972deb6434dd60e9be73c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e292d6f025aad66121d75508a8aa35844e2add144cb61d853c67b6b73c559f23","paperId":"hep-ph/0508029","textSha256":"ad186b2166fbde5edd558daa27ab9ba43517ff740c57feab54c37e5b58ab5308"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:55e1c0245cf329ca8129961c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e292d6f025aad66121d75508a8aa35844e2add144cb61d853c67b6b73c559f23","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:e292d6f025aad66121d75508a8aa35844e2add144cb61d853c67b6b73c559f23","textSha256":"ad186b2166fbde5edd558daa27ab9ba43517ff740c57feab54c37e5b58ab5308"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2a332a3a109c18b94c6c9f81","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Higgs soft-mass suppression and viable μ/B are coupled targets under the paper's contemporary MSSM Higgs bound. Independent challenge qualification: Higgs soft-mass suppression and viable μ/B are coupled targets under the source-era MSSM Higgs bound."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2a332a3a109c18b94c6c9f81","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e292d6f025aad66121d75508a8aa35844e2add144cb61d853c67b6b73c559f23","q025-candidate-question:c1acbd9e4487628b850d08b2"],"scopeContentSha256":"6c5d094dd5cb0fb6dbdbf17b5c59a2a3d197bd31c175d0afac889d9a3294d651","contributionContentSha256":"52fb579216ad7fa608dbdfaf03a38b3d97bb1314bb62d22b3b87d42bb54a3e1d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:e292d6f025aad66121d75508a8aa35844e2add144cb61d853c67b6b73c559f23","textSha256":"ad186b2166fbde5edd558daa27ab9ba43517ff740c57feab54c37e5b58ab5308"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2a332a3a109c18b94c6c9f81","recordId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-2386dc0b02ae434e5bc5-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Higgs soft-mass suppression and viable μ/B are coupled targets under the paper's contemporary MSSM Higgs bound.","challengeNote":"Higgs soft-mass suppression and viable μ/B are coupled targets under the source-era MSSM Higgs bound.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":11,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"d6664b36302a9b3305ddad2de559a0cf2372e67000879ca9942fea441fd93725"},"organizational-access:a441a265b4f7bfe7248368d5":{"id":"organizational-access:a441a265b4f7bfe7248368d5","source":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","target":"q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b917a551e8b5c2d24f59328c"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"e0275f7f5a0ae928e0e7b47668f1faa119319b3cb4436178d1f9fd79b21ea73e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:a3500432160ffaed187c69c8"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:442875576a3ec8d6d155e0eb005344e593b4a26ca063c2306fbf1a46e1c47618","home":{"unitId":"unit:442875576a3ec8d6d155e0eb005344e593b4a26ca063c2306fbf1a46e1c47618","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:442875576a3ec8d6d155e0eb005344e593b4a26ca063c2306fbf1a46e1c47618","paperId":"2509.02632","textSha256":"b8a7a9ee2b6e93c5e68c6ae11a213b8cd2c15704d8171b96a9d71444aae3cb41"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0f00ac9832eb6351bb8c4b5e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0f00ac9832eb6351bb8c4b5e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:442875576a3ec8d6d155e0eb005344e593b4a26ca063c2306fbf1a46e1c47618","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"517cd1c3e16bd9355c0c63c0ea5b8dff844c64fdab96ab76affe7e2801d72036","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:442875576a3ec8d6d155e0eb005344e593b4a26ca063c2306fbf1a46e1c47618","paperId":"2509.02632","textSha256":"b8a7a9ee2b6e93c5e68c6ae11a213b8cd2c15704d8171b96a9d71444aae3cb41"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:0f00ac9832eb6351bb8c4b5e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:442875576a3ec8d6d155e0eb005344e593b4a26ca063c2306fbf1a46e1c47618","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:442875576a3ec8d6d155e0eb005344e593b4a26ca063c2306fbf1a46e1c47618","textSha256":"b8a7a9ee2b6e93c5e68c6ae11a213b8cd2c15704d8171b96a9d71444aae3cb41"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1b1dcc94400e165f0c37fd80","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: A multi-target survey of constraints and evidence; the description does not resolve its individual question identities. Independent challenge qualification: A survey spanning several cosmological targets; the description does not resolve individual question identities or certify the constraints."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1b1dcc94400e165f0c37fd80","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:442875576a3ec8d6d155e0eb005344e593b4a26ca063c2306fbf1a46e1c47618","q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e0275f7f5a0ae928e0e7b47668f1faa119319b3cb4436178d1f9fd79b21ea73e","contributionContentSha256":"59d609c54d1a7f004ffca6bae131f954c0aff36a1f68a82ebf669338950c0c5e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d37","kind":"description","unitIndex":37,"unitId":"unit:442875576a3ec8d6d155e0eb005344e593b4a26ca063c2306fbf1a46e1c47618","textSha256":"b8a7a9ee2b6e93c5e68c6ae11a213b8cd2c15704d8171b96a9d71444aae3cb41"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1b1dcc94400e165f0c37fd80","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"A multi-target survey of constraints and evidence; the description does not resolve its individual question identities.","challengeNote":"A survey spanning several cosmological targets; the description does not resolve individual question identities or certify the constraints.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5b693becf8aa816c82d8c20c05e1656302f3137a0d614b49866fd7ff00a67cc3","home":{"unitId":"unit:5b693becf8aa816c82d8c20c05e1656302f3137a0d614b49866fd7ff00a67cc3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5b693becf8aa816c82d8c20c05e1656302f3137a0d614b49866fd7ff00a67cc3","paperId":"1706.05392","textSha256":"0feb0f8e8e8ae9ca20e8864a446de72348c12a6de25af0050cb389e439a55c6b"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:33dbd0be24d576b5a93eaebe"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:33dbd0be24d576b5a93eaebe","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5b693becf8aa816c82d8c20c05e1656302f3137a0d614b49866fd7ff00a67cc3","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"09692ba6fcf48bc811159ad9e8bf63997287a6e36593f872640ec76e04cd28df","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5b693becf8aa816c82d8c20c05e1656302f3137a0d614b49866fd7ff00a67cc3","paperId":"1706.05392","textSha256":"0feb0f8e8e8ae9ca20e8864a446de72348c12a6de25af0050cb389e439a55c6b"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:33dbd0be24d576b5a93eaebe"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5b693becf8aa816c82d8c20c05e1656302f3137a0d614b49866fd7ff00a67cc3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:5b693becf8aa816c82d8c20c05e1656302f3137a0d614b49866fd7ff00a67cc3","textSha256":"0feb0f8e8e8ae9ca20e8864a446de72348c12a6de25af0050cb389e439a55c6b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:482c11c380c5eac4b287d697","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Infrared restrictions are conditional on the stated absence of stable compactified AdS solutions. Independent challenge qualification: Spectrum and vacuum-energy restrictions depend on the proposed absence of stable compactified AdS solutions."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:482c11c380c5eac4b287d697","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5b693becf8aa816c82d8c20c05e1656302f3137a0d614b49866fd7ff00a67cc3","q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e0275f7f5a0ae928e0e7b47668f1faa119319b3cb4436178d1f9fd79b21ea73e","contributionContentSha256":"4eca6d6f59d5c421df7914a32ed47c1ac09828e0707c9930cdc545d51eb4ab43","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:5b693becf8aa816c82d8c20c05e1656302f3137a0d614b49866fd7ff00a67cc3","textSha256":"0feb0f8e8e8ae9ca20e8864a446de72348c12a6de25af0050cb389e439a55c6b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:482c11c380c5eac4b287d697","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Infrared restrictions are conditional on the stated absence of stable compactified AdS solutions.","challengeNote":"Spectrum and vacuum-energy restrictions depend on the proposed absence of stable compactified AdS solutions.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:623973bd8780b1dfefa82d807414b364ef101c08d975d842e620de189f16fac7","home":{"unitId":"unit:623973bd8780b1dfefa82d807414b364ef101c08d975d842e620de189f16fac7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:623973bd8780b1dfefa82d807414b364ef101c08d975d842e620de189f16fac7","paperId":"1808.03483","textSha256":"3425ba384c8bd1f430ed71c370ee8f07f573cbb2c5abdcc76e8b606adfb801c1"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b44109b192b0544618ddccf2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b44109b192b0544618ddccf2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:623973bd8780b1dfefa82d807414b364ef101c08d975d842e620de189f16fac7","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"0cf74887d45bfe36dfcfdfa2b7f4cfb3b89f955e808a4e099982d91fd6263212","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:623973bd8780b1dfefa82d807414b364ef101c08d975d842e620de189f16fac7","paperId":"1808.03483","textSha256":"3425ba384c8bd1f430ed71c370ee8f07f573cbb2c5abdcc76e8b606adfb801c1"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b44109b192b0544618ddccf2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:623973bd8780b1dfefa82d807414b364ef101c08d975d842e620de189f16fac7","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:623973bd8780b1dfefa82d807414b364ef101c08d975d842e620de189f16fac7","textSha256":"3425ba384c8bd1f430ed71c370ee8f07f573cbb2c5abdcc76e8b606adfb801c1"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cce111fd8ffe4e46e851aff7","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Theta-angle selection and an arithmetic electromagnetic condition are distinct targets requiring reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Theta-angle selection and electromagnetic arithmetic are distinct targets whose fine identity remains unresolved."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:cce111fd8ffe4e46e851aff7","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:623973bd8780b1dfefa82d807414b364ef101c08d975d842e620de189f16fac7","q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e0275f7f5a0ae928e0e7b47668f1faa119319b3cb4436178d1f9fd79b21ea73e","contributionContentSha256":"b90fd313d4a70cd8576e29795418e2775f3de6b5c9e16f045d2ff3e5c3b243ab","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:623973bd8780b1dfefa82d807414b364ef101c08d975d842e620de189f16fac7","textSha256":"3425ba384c8bd1f430ed71c370ee8f07f573cbb2c5abdcc76e8b606adfb801c1"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:cce111fd8ffe4e46e851aff7","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Theta-angle selection and an arithmetic electromagnetic condition are distinct targets requiring reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Theta-angle selection and electromagnetic arithmetic are distinct targets whose fine identity remains unresolved.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","home":{"unitId":"unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","paperId":"2107.00087","textSha256":"b01635e1b0a56b493eae67738dbcc3947293f80ddbadc9c1bc1e475a7bf3c567"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c038e8ad25249552dd2ad2c3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c038e8ad25249552dd2ad2c3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"68a3085bab3c8f1615fc25e15d2e53c110dd94280f37bd3fe5a282e6a0c0db84","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","paperId":"2107.00087","textSha256":"b01635e1b0a56b493eae67738dbcc3947293f80ddbadc9c1bc1e475a7bf3c567"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c038e8ad25249552dd2ad2c3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","textSha256":"b01635e1b0a56b493eae67738dbcc3947293f80ddbadc9c1bc1e475a7bf3c567"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:01e3b418023f040b845d624e","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:01e3b418023f040b845d624e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e0275f7f5a0ae928e0e7b47668f1faa119319b3cb4436178d1f9fd79b21ea73e","contributionContentSha256":"859efdd16c92c2b87272131473032726b0431815458c503f51bf420e291f5d61","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d30","kind":"description","unitIndex":30,"unitId":"unit:730f85c8a41b03346b6815473e02d1c4b56ebda58a51763f6ccbf889d5baa72f","textSha256":"b01635e1b0a56b493eae67738dbcc3947293f80ddbadc9c1bc1e475a7bf3c567"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:01e3b418023f040b845d624e","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:750efb2bcf9201ec15f5c4a409e6857a9ea488cfb4eee8b17b51b9c04e8be5ec","home":{"unitId":"unit:750efb2bcf9201ec15f5c4a409e6857a9ea488cfb4eee8b17b51b9c04e8be5ec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:750efb2bcf9201ec15f5c4a409e6857a9ea488cfb4eee8b17b51b9c04e8be5ec","paperId":"2002.02456","textSha256":"17b8970aa319c484aa82d3eb765fc9b674e3173406555c2818b9d2b83726c9d8"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fa9ef57115485fde558a4624"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fa9ef57115485fde558a4624","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:750efb2bcf9201ec15f5c4a409e6857a9ea488cfb4eee8b17b51b9c04e8be5ec","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"a290952e16f9921c5006eb3cb66fd3bb711a7382a14de222f3f74551c65673b0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:750efb2bcf9201ec15f5c4a409e6857a9ea488cfb4eee8b17b51b9c04e8be5ec","paperId":"2002.02456","textSha256":"17b8970aa319c484aa82d3eb765fc9b674e3173406555c2818b9d2b83726c9d8"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:fa9ef57115485fde558a4624"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:750efb2bcf9201ec15f5c4a409e6857a9ea488cfb4eee8b17b51b9c04e8be5ec","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:750efb2bcf9201ec15f5c4a409e6857a9ea488cfb4eee8b17b51b9c04e8be5ec","textSha256":"17b8970aa319c484aa82d3eb765fc9b674e3173406555c2818b9d2b83726c9d8"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9cefe9176cbd564a21fd0226","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9cefe9176cbd564a21fd0226","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:750efb2bcf9201ec15f5c4a409e6857a9ea488cfb4eee8b17b51b9c04e8be5ec","q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e0275f7f5a0ae928e0e7b47668f1faa119319b3cb4436178d1f9fd79b21ea73e","contributionContentSha256":"9ce9cb2b5dd9ace7a6b30dbe5fdca5d69907ef67c8b0b0bed4da44dd97e19f8b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d21","kind":"description","unitIndex":21,"unitId":"unit:750efb2bcf9201ec15f5c4a409e6857a9ea488cfb4eee8b17b51b9c04e8be5ec","textSha256":"17b8970aa319c484aa82d3eb765fc9b674e3173406555c2818b9d2b83726c9d8"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9cefe9176cbd564a21fd0226","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","home":{"unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","paperId":"1801.03503","textSha256":"70666671b810a7cbb77a17ef0ab9ad3ee1e8f88209200d70d37a4cdaf70aa1d6"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:77052e39d59537333930fa21"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:77052e39d59537333930fa21","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"0ac0a363672d8fb5a9ebd23ca5f4379c2c63361994887bce3c83344ca94e4bcb","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","paperId":"1801.03503","textSha256":"70666671b810a7cbb77a17ef0ab9ad3ee1e8f88209200d70d37a4cdaf70aa1d6"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:77052e39d59537333930fa21"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","textSha256":"70666671b810a7cbb77a17ef0ab9ad3ee1e8f88209200d70d37a4cdaf70aa1d6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:70b9f27fa90843843fcecfbf","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The description's reference to established restrictions does not identify or independently verify particular restrictions. Independent challenge qualification: The description does not identify or independently verify the restrictions it calls established."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:70b9f27fa90843843fcecfbf","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e0275f7f5a0ae928e0e7b47668f1faa119319b3cb4436178d1f9fd79b21ea73e","contributionContentSha256":"68d847a79bd12be8ee2163aa2d3b4b9af44801e217c5329bbcd958712b8048d2","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d9","kind":"description","unitIndex":9,"unitId":"unit:94deb740c0ab12f91314f44a5cd5763a36454b67745d413fd88063b60c466853","textSha256":"70666671b810a7cbb77a17ef0ab9ad3ee1e8f88209200d70d37a4cdaf70aa1d6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:70b9f27fa90843843fcecfbf","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"The description's reference to established restrictions does not identify or independently verify particular restrictions.","challengeNote":"The description does not identify or independently verify the restrictions it calls established.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:99e48c07ddded18c98c4f81917ca198bc98e2ba14bf86f95081bed66ead0acf1","home":{"unitId":"unit:99e48c07ddded18c98c4f81917ca198bc98e2ba14bf86f95081bed66ead0acf1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:99e48c07ddded18c98c4f81917ca198bc98e2ba14bf86f95081bed66ead0acf1","paperId":"0804.0769","textSha256":"d506ac6b8fc294f81a1d163ffd6016713249501af9770d5b4387ba8d4af8e9a7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e5e8d33cda2a44b2eff1f62f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e5e8d33cda2a44b2eff1f62f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:99e48c07ddded18c98c4f81917ca198bc98e2ba14bf86f95081bed66ead0acf1","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"393cc14bc784fa37de5baa1de0f4cdb19491b7bbb5344d8cf9a61c300bcc9519","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:99e48c07ddded18c98c4f81917ca198bc98e2ba14bf86f95081bed66ead0acf1","paperId":"0804.0769","textSha256":"d506ac6b8fc294f81a1d163ffd6016713249501af9770d5b4387ba8d4af8e9a7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e5e8d33cda2a44b2eff1f62f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:99e48c07ddded18c98c4f81917ca198bc98e2ba14bf86f95081bed66ead0acf1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:99e48c07ddded18c98c4f81917ca198bc98e2ba14bf86f95081bed66ead0acf1","textSha256":"d506ac6b8fc294f81a1d163ffd6016713249501af9770d5b4387ba8d4af8e9a7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6b7c601710e96644e900a8de","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Large periodicity is explicitly considered without N species. Independent challenge qualification: Large periodicity is considered without requiring N species."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6b7c601710e96644e900a8de","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:99e48c07ddded18c98c4f81917ca198bc98e2ba14bf86f95081bed66ead0acf1","q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e0275f7f5a0ae928e0e7b47668f1faa119319b3cb4436178d1f9fd79b21ea73e","contributionContentSha256":"e81583a621e8e144cde82d052f9971b49297ce1f3dfff36f7047136b8b6811cb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:99e48c07ddded18c98c4f81917ca198bc98e2ba14bf86f95081bed66ead0acf1","textSha256":"d506ac6b8fc294f81a1d163ffd6016713249501af9770d5b4387ba8d4af8e9a7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6b7c601710e96644e900a8de","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Large periodicity is explicitly considered without N species.","challengeNote":"Large periodicity is considered without requiring N species.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b7659a058834f35a888b3758e2b54df7d030170a7aa129cd8270665da09bc51f","home":{"unitId":"unit:b7659a058834f35a888b3758e2b54df7d030170a7aa129cd8270665da09bc51f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b7659a058834f35a888b3758e2b54df7d030170a7aa129cd8270665da09bc51f","paperId":"hep-th/0106058","textSha256":"5b0f42b50c5da73736c0c63d95ec38619d880fea2c7742a6a986676466005ee0"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:87656436b667a4655764d26d"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:87656436b667a4655764d26d","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b7659a058834f35a888b3758e2b54df7d030170a7aa129cd8270665da09bc51f","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"d5bfa3e90f03d90471c268cf33d12f40e62571781cb22977f875e591c5a78366","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b7659a058834f35a888b3758e2b54df7d030170a7aa129cd8270665da09bc51f","paperId":"hep-th/0106058","textSha256":"5b0f42b50c5da73736c0c63d95ec38619d880fea2c7742a6a986676466005ee0"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:87656436b667a4655764d26d"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b7659a058834f35a888b3758e2b54df7d030170a7aa129cd8270665da09bc51f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:b7659a058834f35a888b3758e2b54df7d030170a7aa129cd8270665da09bc51f","textSha256":"5b0f42b50c5da73736c0c63d95ec38619d880fea2c7742a6a986676466005ee0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1a55a4d9cb67edd3ac87b7d4","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The proposed M* near 10^−3 eV and compatibility with the observations considered remain source-dated scenario claims. Independent challenge qualification: The possible M* near 10^−3 eV and compatibility with the observations considered remain source-dated scenario claims."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1a55a4d9cb67edd3ac87b7d4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b7659a058834f35a888b3758e2b54df7d030170a7aa129cd8270665da09bc51f","q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e0275f7f5a0ae928e0e7b47668f1faa119319b3cb4436178d1f9fd79b21ea73e","contributionContentSha256":"9d78e1e9cf41f2f9baafdd1d3ed488268ed5f92fbcfa6f62ffd294f4e454a2f7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:b7659a058834f35a888b3758e2b54df7d030170a7aa129cd8270665da09bc51f","textSha256":"5b0f42b50c5da73736c0c63d95ec38619d880fea2c7742a6a986676466005ee0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1a55a4d9cb67edd3ac87b7d4","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"The proposed M* near 10^−3 eV and compatibility with the observations considered remain source-dated scenario claims.","challengeNote":"The possible M* near 10^−3 eV and compatibility with the observations considered remain source-dated scenario claims.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:cf00116d1515925b66c1fc802bcb5728fc103d04a8c4ecc6decce9ab60146485","home":{"unitId":"unit:cf00116d1515925b66c1fc802bcb5728fc103d04a8c4ecc6decce9ab60146485","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cf00116d1515925b66c1fc802bcb5728fc103d04a8c4ecc6decce9ab60146485","paperId":"hep-ph/9809582","textSha256":"be18c36e6d58242752bd01a9678388aff81b267f823d6316d401842a90331879"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6141b711188bd5a2c8cab5d3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6141b711188bd5a2c8cab5d3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cf00116d1515925b66c1fc802bcb5728fc103d04a8c4ecc6decce9ab60146485","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"a89f46dc5177d1bea23efd80d4a2f4cfc1b7a6f0065bcdb3db903a98c0138910","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:cf00116d1515925b66c1fc802bcb5728fc103d04a8c4ecc6decce9ab60146485","paperId":"hep-ph/9809582","textSha256":"be18c36e6d58242752bd01a9678388aff81b267f823d6316d401842a90331879"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6141b711188bd5a2c8cab5d3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:cf00116d1515925b66c1fc802bcb5728fc103d04a8c4ecc6decce9ab60146485","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:cf00116d1515925b66c1fc802bcb5728fc103d04a8c4ecc6decce9ab60146485","textSha256":"be18c36e6d58242752bd01a9678388aff81b267f823d6316d401842a90331879"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9bbf47ac9ffa88b7e7739ccc","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Early scenario-building remains eligible. Unification, supersymmetry breaking and phenomenology are linked but distinct construction goals. Independent challenge qualification: Historical construction remains eligible. Unification, supersymmetry breaking and phenomenology are distinct goals within its compound scope."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9bbf47ac9ffa88b7e7739ccc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:cf00116d1515925b66c1fc802bcb5728fc103d04a8c4ecc6decce9ab60146485","q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e0275f7f5a0ae928e0e7b47668f1faa119319b3cb4436178d1f9fd79b21ea73e","contributionContentSha256":"b8c1cd1a6e7d87ebaffdda7ab7b2b5efe87a7e262cbb066794be5982c7fce96c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:cf00116d1515925b66c1fc802bcb5728fc103d04a8c4ecc6decce9ab60146485","textSha256":"be18c36e6d58242752bd01a9678388aff81b267f823d6316d401842a90331879"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9bbf47ac9ffa88b7e7739ccc","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Early scenario-building remains eligible. Unification, supersymmetry breaking and phenomenology are linked but distinct construction goals.","challengeNote":"Historical construction remains eligible. Unification, supersymmetry breaking and phenomenology are distinct goals within its compound scope.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d1814b27ded5dbaa7fb946d5b7bdab779414b79ebf44bb4e384c8f1bc6249cab","home":{"unitId":"unit:d1814b27ded5dbaa7fb946d5b7bdab779414b79ebf44bb4e384c8f1bc6249cab","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d1814b27ded5dbaa7fb946d5b7bdab779414b79ebf44bb4e384c8f1bc6249cab","paperId":"0706.2050","textSha256":"dc235435ca1bb608c3b6bca735d9a6073adec004fb252b220a5f13a8c53db9d0"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bcc994fc41e8b72ca1a90be2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bcc994fc41e8b72ca1a90be2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d1814b27ded5dbaa7fb946d5b7bdab779414b79ebf44bb4e384c8f1bc6249cab","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"42faeb4c739dc1aae6bb9846a2771a2bc89a48baabdfc2f2281c8a0068a66577","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d1814b27ded5dbaa7fb946d5b7bdab779414b79ebf44bb4e384c8f1bc6249cab","paperId":"0706.2050","textSha256":"dc235435ca1bb608c3b6bca735d9a6073adec004fb252b220a5f13a8c53db9d0"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bcc994fc41e8b72ca1a90be2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d1814b27ded5dbaa7fb946d5b7bdab779414b79ebf44bb4e384c8f1bc6249cab","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:d1814b27ded5dbaa7fb946d5b7bdab779414b79ebf44bb4e384c8f1bc6249cab","textSha256":"dc235435ca1bb608c3b6bca735d9a6073adec004fb252b220a5f13a8c53db9d0"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7d8e4b977c406d37d197d51c","qualification":"Original proposal qualification:  Independent challenge qualification: "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7d8e4b977c406d37d197d51c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d1814b27ded5dbaa7fb946d5b7bdab779414b79ebf44bb4e384c8f1bc6249cab","q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e0275f7f5a0ae928e0e7b47668f1faa119319b3cb4436178d1f9fd79b21ea73e","contributionContentSha256":"21805b4b6b37005de6ed1a8b9153c1d5529549680764c4dbcf20a3444930ad24","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d0","kind":"description","unitIndex":0,"unitId":"unit:d1814b27ded5dbaa7fb946d5b7bdab779414b79ebf44bb4e384c8f1bc6249cab","textSha256":"dc235435ca1bb608c3b6bca735d9a6073adec004fb252b220a5f13a8c53db9d0"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7d8e4b977c406d37d197d51c","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f5dec9b2d4dc6384ca412c8833621f00443379b3fc52ef04d918abd3d1972b9f","home":{"unitId":"unit:f5dec9b2d4dc6384ca412c8833621f00443379b3fc52ef04d918abd3d1972b9f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f5dec9b2d4dc6384ca412c8833621f00443379b3fc52ef04d918abd3d1972b9f","paperId":"1605.05311","textSha256":"18f90a433e897802a0d48354f3d6332bef6c260d7e36905a973edffdcc49f3fe"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:53a3ea9acde708bad4bf34da"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:53a3ea9acde708bad4bf34da","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f5dec9b2d4dc6384ca412c8833621f00443379b3fc52ef04d918abd3d1972b9f","q025-candidate-region:53207929d52445f818c87366"],"scopeContentSha256":"6bd6825555ec1aa7a08167272c578da00b725a059cd69f65d39517439a015c1c","placementContentSha256":"2986d35955028496ddf6e07964338db87a4f3679884fc1bb10b27d50ecee0b50","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f5dec9b2d4dc6384ca412c8833621f00443379b3fc52ef04d918abd3d1972b9f","paperId":"1605.05311","textSha256":"18f90a433e897802a0d48354f3d6332bef6c260d7e36905a973edffdcc49f3fe"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:53a3ea9acde708bad4bf34da"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f5dec9b2d4dc6384ca412c8833621f00443379b3fc52ef04d918abd3d1972b9f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:f5dec9b2d4dc6384ca412c8833621f00443379b3fc52ef04d918abd3d1972b9f","textSha256":"18f90a433e897802a0d48354f3d6332bef6c260d7e36905a973edffdcc49f3fe"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:556cf68865164bf4d2327a74","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound scope: the lattice requirement and its axion, CFT and geometry applications remain distinguishable. Independent challenge qualification: Compound source scope: the lattice requirement and its axion, CFT and geometry applications require separate reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:556cf68865164bf4d2327a74","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f5dec9b2d4dc6384ca412c8833621f00443379b3fc52ef04d918abd3d1972b9f","q025-candidate-question:0672145a7188eb44ec7bb38b"],"scopeContentSha256":"e0275f7f5a0ae928e0e7b47668f1faa119319b3cb4436178d1f9fd79b21ea73e","contributionContentSha256":"5a77aa5281c381bacaa01bfa68f3270eed8a4cecf9ae572dc306f33224ab2934","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d3","kind":"description","unitIndex":3,"unitId":"unit:f5dec9b2d4dc6384ca412c8833621f00443379b3fc52ef04d918abd3d1972b9f","textSha256":"18f90a433e897802a0d48354f3d6332bef6c260d7e36905a973edffdcc49f3fe"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:556cf68865164bf4d2327a74","recordId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1bda1fe5f1a713de5462-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound scope: the lattice requirement and its axion, CFT and geometry applications remain distinguishable.","challengeNote":"Compound source scope: the lattice requirement and its axion, CFT and geometry applications require separate reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":11,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"0291de480af66155892158e5f4e3adb73adef0bc5c3236a4dcd729aff36c1620"},"organizational-access:e1475155fa6f1202d99ee54c":{"id":"organizational-access:e1475155fa6f1202d99ee54c","source":"q025-candidate-region:56e696eef2d144a62b8c5625","target":"q025-candidate-question:9f77e45292937042cbb2ad5f","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:56e696eef2d144a62b8c5625","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"541ae939a43204c44eddeb62575bac87a667d0f2bf16c3c797250ae391e0ab98","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:303f0721e0215672450e8069"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:9f77e45292937042cbb2ad5f","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"54ee71816baf708cff7612e93a7e775d90ffc43dfef8da50f4e19635ec287427","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:453a41fa8fee8a2657bd80a6"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:325cfe68b3b27a348a3ff1337b43ac4982217ebf33b3ce97f95b6b063f3c5b11","home":{"unitId":"unit:325cfe68b3b27a348a3ff1337b43ac4982217ebf33b3ce97f95b6b063f3c5b11","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:56e696eef2d144a62b8c5625","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:325cfe68b3b27a348a3ff1337b43ac4982217ebf33b3ce97f95b6b063f3c5b11","paperId":"1112.1899","textSha256":"cd768dd8d9e643f0fb3bcfe20a7be9ffe520281c11272dd92ace1e6c7887ac6d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4b2d438d2403d1cf8aca1166"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4b2d438d2403d1cf8aca1166","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:325cfe68b3b27a348a3ff1337b43ac4982217ebf33b3ce97f95b6b063f3c5b11","q025-candidate-region:56e696eef2d144a62b8c5625"],"scopeContentSha256":"541ae939a43204c44eddeb62575bac87a667d0f2bf16c3c797250ae391e0ab98","placementContentSha256":"133dcaf7bd3b4c02bba5d526d8921c68f8638b043f63861f8363039cf4730931","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge","successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:325cfe68b3b27a348a3ff1337b43ac4982217ebf33b3ce97f95b6b063f3c5b11","paperId":"1112.1899","textSha256":"cd768dd8d9e643f0fb3bcfe20a7be9ffe520281c11272dd92ace1e6c7887ac6d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4b2d438d2403d1cf8aca1166"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:325cfe68b3b27a348a3ff1337b43ac4982217ebf33b3ce97f95b6b063f3c5b11","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9f77e45292937042cbb2ad5f","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:325cfe68b3b27a348a3ff1337b43ac4982217ebf33b3ce97f95b6b063f3c5b11","textSha256":"cd768dd8d9e643f0fb3bcfe20a7be9ffe520281c11272dd92ace1e6c7887ac6d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:07265c89268fcb9cb2d26205","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Inverse-triad and holonomy effects are compared, not equated. Independent challenge qualification: Inverse-triad and holonomy effects are compared, not equated."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:07265c89268fcb9cb2d26205","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:325cfe68b3b27a348a3ff1337b43ac4982217ebf33b3ce97f95b6b063f3c5b11","q025-candidate-question:9f77e45292937042cbb2ad5f"],"scopeContentSha256":"54ee71816baf708cff7612e93a7e775d90ffc43dfef8da50f4e19635ec287427","contributionContentSha256":"b172e35a911d924b5143955b9a12f26f703da77ff7ac4381b377f827487fc4a6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d1","kind":"description","unitIndex":1,"unitId":"unit:325cfe68b3b27a348a3ff1337b43ac4982217ebf33b3ce97f95b6b063f3c5b11","textSha256":"cd768dd8d9e643f0fb3bcfe20a7be9ffe520281c11272dd92ace1e6c7887ac6d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:07265c89268fcb9cb2d26205","recordId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Inverse-triad and holonomy effects are compared, not equated.","challengeNote":"Inverse-triad and holonomy effects are compared, not equated.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5e20a4133eef0e6d24127eb0f157e325ab4412d9992a9a9fddf76c497410853a","home":{"unitId":"unit:5e20a4133eef0e6d24127eb0f157e325ab4412d9992a9a9fddf76c497410853a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:56e696eef2d144a62b8c5625","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5e20a4133eef0e6d24127eb0f157e325ab4412d9992a9a9fddf76c497410853a","paperId":"hep-th/0209079","textSha256":"71def2ad04b09c29fb107387e50764685ca8baf681a0a02fa96bdf8157d56ae3"},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cbd93192aedcfb759601cb1c03ede737","paperId":"hep-th/0209079","sourceSha256":"b4d4463922961b4990832bc5134f90255fb5222c7d112fb61c522c44cb458190","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a161e063e5b8c8ff6ea1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"91bbce936b3410296ffd7309a09727f3ab8669a6e2f9408ad9b5db195f44d288","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":1862,"textSha256":"1280fcf794fcd901b4eb819dea9d7889180f44dd6f602c406acd8d4d45ce6c0e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fb85b5483167b1df0c4fbb5bc36c3289","paperId":"hep-th/0209079","sourceSha256":"b4d4463922961b4990832bc5134f90255fb5222c7d112fb61c522c44cb458190","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a161e063e5b8c8ff6ea1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"91bbce936b3410296ffd7309a09727f3ab8669a6e2f9408ad9b5db195f44d288","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1862,"textSha256":"50d34ba24bbca0de3a5762c17360889e3455dbc2384b09da69efbdf374cb5046","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d7e7599466cda1b384dee0a7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d7e7599466cda1b384dee0a7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5e20a4133eef0e6d24127eb0f157e325ab4412d9992a9a9fddf76c497410853a","q025-candidate-region:56e696eef2d144a62b8c5625"],"scopeContentSha256":"541ae939a43204c44eddeb62575bac87a667d0f2bf16c3c797250ae391e0ab98","placementContentSha256":"57e31c5eaec479110c4e708dfed0fb2e2a0a8f657f49286f37228bd618797bb2","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge","successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5e20a4133eef0e6d24127eb0f157e325ab4412d9992a9a9fddf76c497410853a","paperId":"hep-th/0209079","textSha256":"71def2ad04b09c29fb107387e50764685ca8baf681a0a02fa96bdf8157d56ae3"},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cbd93192aedcfb759601cb1c03ede737","paperId":"hep-th/0209079","sourceSha256":"b4d4463922961b4990832bc5134f90255fb5222c7d112fb61c522c44cb458190","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a161e063e5b8c8ff6ea1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"91bbce936b3410296ffd7309a09727f3ab8669a6e2f9408ad9b5db195f44d288","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":1862,"textSha256":"1280fcf794fcd901b4eb819dea9d7889180f44dd6f602c406acd8d4d45ce6c0e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fb85b5483167b1df0c4fbb5bc36c3289","paperId":"hep-th/0209079","sourceSha256":"b4d4463922961b4990832bc5134f90255fb5222c7d112fb61c522c44cb458190","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a161e063e5b8c8ff6ea1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"91bbce936b3410296ffd7309a09727f3ab8669a6e2f9408ad9b5db195f44d288","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1862,"textSha256":"50d34ba24bbca0de3a5762c17360889e3455dbc2384b09da69efbdf374cb5046","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d7e7599466cda1b384dee0a7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5e20a4133eef0e6d24127eb0f157e325ab4412d9992a9a9fddf76c497410853a","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9f77e45292937042cbb2ad5f","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:5e20a4133eef0e6d24127eb0f157e325ab4412d9992a9a9fddf76c497410853a","textSha256":"71def2ad04b09c29fb107387e50764685ca8baf681a0a02fa96bdf8157d56ae3"},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cbd93192aedcfb759601cb1c03ede737","paperId":"hep-th/0209079","sourceSha256":"b4d4463922961b4990832bc5134f90255fb5222c7d112fb61c522c44cb458190","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a161e063e5b8c8ff6ea1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"91bbce936b3410296ffd7309a09727f3ab8669a6e2f9408ad9b5db195f44d288","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":1862,"textSha256":"1280fcf794fcd901b4eb819dea9d7889180f44dd6f602c406acd8d4d45ce6c0e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fb85b5483167b1df0c4fbb5bc36c3289","paperId":"hep-th/0209079","sourceSha256":"b4d4463922961b4990832bc5134f90255fb5222c7d112fb61c522c44cb458190","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a161e063e5b8c8ff6ea1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"91bbce936b3410296ffd7309a09727f3ab8669a6e2f9408ad9b5db195f44d288","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1862,"textSha256":"50d34ba24bbca0de3a5762c17360889e3455dbc2384b09da69efbdf374cb5046","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:39cc546aff6fc9235c20ed65","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: v1 9 September 2002, manuscript dated 28 August: compound vacuum, low-energy recovery and horizon-bound claims retain their historical scope. Independent challenge qualification: v1 9 September 2002, manuscript dated 28 August: vacuum, low-energy recovery, dispersion and horizon-bound claims form a compound historical proposal; they are neither recertified nor declared refuted."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:39cc546aff6fc9235c20ed65","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5e20a4133eef0e6d24127eb0f157e325ab4412d9992a9a9fddf76c497410853a","q025-candidate-question:9f77e45292937042cbb2ad5f"],"scopeContentSha256":"54ee71816baf708cff7612e93a7e775d90ffc43dfef8da50f4e19635ec287427","contributionContentSha256":"0b0b866791d8dbc3f4527910b17e5a2210f7650f3f169e2c363e05cc9859d19f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d31","kind":"description","unitIndex":31,"unitId":"unit:5e20a4133eef0e6d24127eb0f157e325ab4412d9992a9a9fddf76c497410853a","textSha256":"71def2ad04b09c29fb107387e50764685ca8baf681a0a02fa96bdf8157d56ae3"},{"localRef":"e15","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:cbd93192aedcfb759601cb1c03ede737","paperId":"hep-th/0209079","sourceSha256":"b4d4463922961b4990832bc5134f90255fb5222c7d112fb61c522c44cb458190","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a161e063e5b8c8ff6ea1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"91bbce936b3410296ffd7309a09727f3ab8669a6e2f9408ad9b5db195f44d288","pdfPage":1,"start":103,"end":1862,"textSha256":"1280fcf794fcd901b4eb819dea9d7889180f44dd6f602c406acd8d4d45ce6c0e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fb85b5483167b1df0c4fbb5bc36c3289","paperId":"hep-th/0209079","sourceSha256":"b4d4463922961b4990832bc5134f90255fb5222c7d112fb61c522c44cb458190","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/a161e063e5b8c8ff6ea1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"91bbce936b3410296ffd7309a09727f3ab8669a6e2f9408ad9b5db195f44d288","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1862,"textSha256":"50d34ba24bbca0de3a5762c17360889e3455dbc2384b09da69efbdf374cb5046","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:39cc546aff6fc9235c20ed65","recordId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"v1 9 September 2002, manuscript dated 28 August: compound vacuum, low-energy recovery and horizon-bound claims retain their historical scope.","challengeNote":"v1 9 September 2002, manuscript dated 28 August: vacuum, low-energy recovery, dispersion and horizon-bound claims form a compound historical proposal; they are neither recertified nor declared refuted.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:83021a037849acf0ea4581494f9fd123e4f5fe8b9c06fac9d8536df5ad9e2db4","home":{"unitId":"unit:83021a037849acf0ea4581494f9fd123e4f5fe8b9c06fac9d8536df5ad9e2db4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:56e696eef2d144a62b8c5625","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:83021a037849acf0ea4581494f9fd123e4f5fe8b9c06fac9d8536df5ad9e2db4","paperId":"hep-th/0408048","textSha256":"f423fae8afe514817275ea99e62c11ea9803ee3a50a93be7cb87c6dd96876062"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9a5513054b5240ef86910e60e80f3224","paperId":"hep-th/0408048","sourceSha256":"9969b039308452edfbb0c91976b4fc396e8be4122efef3f8a294aedd9d67571a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/905d0577d69821bdee87/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"007d4e711ea209317b094d0b95a082439a55158f049af9a59d84fede08310774","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a6703b28f21f282153e4ee9647613abe0d3b06fabd8a63c75d11b4b961bce012","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d9f6cd4b6d2d02acfd95fd23542b78d7","paperId":"hep-th/0408048","sourceSha256":"9969b039308452edfbb0c91976b4fc396e8be4122efef3f8a294aedd9d67571a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/905d0577d69821bdee87/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"007d4e711ea209317b094d0b95a082439a55158f049af9a59d84fede08310774","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":3369,"textSha256":"36bfd029b901df6aa9c4e96bc8ab0dca17cbb707e96570cf120796c6904a4d27","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:13f28c9ef71827edeb2df33e"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:13f28c9ef71827edeb2df33e","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:83021a037849acf0ea4581494f9fd123e4f5fe8b9c06fac9d8536df5ad9e2db4","q025-candidate-region:56e696eef2d144a62b8c5625"],"scopeContentSha256":"541ae939a43204c44eddeb62575bac87a667d0f2bf16c3c797250ae391e0ab98","placementContentSha256":"bfe2831a26c633f620cf0079ac279b41bb5462a012d8e71b893f10c8ef385a9c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge","successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:83021a037849acf0ea4581494f9fd123e4f5fe8b9c06fac9d8536df5ad9e2db4","paperId":"hep-th/0408048","textSha256":"f423fae8afe514817275ea99e62c11ea9803ee3a50a93be7cb87c6dd96876062"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9a5513054b5240ef86910e60e80f3224","paperId":"hep-th/0408048","sourceSha256":"9969b039308452edfbb0c91976b4fc396e8be4122efef3f8a294aedd9d67571a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/905d0577d69821bdee87/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"007d4e711ea209317b094d0b95a082439a55158f049af9a59d84fede08310774","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a6703b28f21f282153e4ee9647613abe0d3b06fabd8a63c75d11b4b961bce012","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d9f6cd4b6d2d02acfd95fd23542b78d7","paperId":"hep-th/0408048","sourceSha256":"9969b039308452edfbb0c91976b4fc396e8be4122efef3f8a294aedd9d67571a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/905d0577d69821bdee87/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"007d4e711ea209317b094d0b95a082439a55158f049af9a59d84fede08310774","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":3369,"textSha256":"36bfd029b901df6aa9c4e96bc8ab0dca17cbb707e96570cf120796c6904a4d27","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:13f28c9ef71827edeb2df33e"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:83021a037849acf0ea4581494f9fd123e4f5fe8b9c06fac9d8536df5ad9e2db4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9f77e45292937042cbb2ad5f","role":"instantiates","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:83021a037849acf0ea4581494f9fd123e4f5fe8b9c06fac9d8536df5ad9e2db4","textSha256":"f423fae8afe514817275ea99e62c11ea9803ee3a50a93be7cb87c6dd96876062"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9a5513054b5240ef86910e60e80f3224","paperId":"hep-th/0408048","sourceSha256":"9969b039308452edfbb0c91976b4fc396e8be4122efef3f8a294aedd9d67571a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/905d0577d69821bdee87/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"007d4e711ea209317b094d0b95a082439a55158f049af9a59d84fede08310774","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a6703b28f21f282153e4ee9647613abe0d3b06fabd8a63c75d11b4b961bce012","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d9f6cd4b6d2d02acfd95fd23542b78d7","paperId":"hep-th/0408048","sourceSha256":"9969b039308452edfbb0c91976b4fc396e8be4122efef3f8a294aedd9d67571a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/905d0577d69821bdee87/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"007d4e711ea209317b094d0b95a082439a55158f049af9a59d84fede08310774","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":3369,"textSha256":"36bfd029b901df6aa9c4e96bc8ab0dca17cbb707e96570cf120796c6904a4d27","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f4fa46279d25db5abd3a1507","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: The 2004 review's construction claims, applications and experimental forecasts are historical source assertions. Independent challenge qualification: The 2004 review links a foundational construction question with several applications. Its consistency, singularity and experimental assertions retain historical scope."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f4fa46279d25db5abd3a1507","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:83021a037849acf0ea4581494f9fd123e4f5fe8b9c06fac9d8536df5ad9e2db4","q025-candidate-question:9f77e45292937042cbb2ad5f"],"scopeContentSha256":"54ee71816baf708cff7612e93a7e775d90ffc43dfef8da50f4e19635ec287427","contributionContentSha256":"e52c7c6da8bb8e1c8474a2efd5fd62303b9b99d23fbb3835cfa3a942aa31ea29","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d33","kind":"description","unitIndex":33,"unitId":"unit:83021a037849acf0ea4581494f9fd123e4f5fe8b9c06fac9d8536df5ad9e2db4","textSha256":"f423fae8afe514817275ea99e62c11ea9803ee3a50a93be7cb87c6dd96876062"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9a5513054b5240ef86910e60e80f3224","paperId":"hep-th/0408048","sourceSha256":"9969b039308452edfbb0c91976b4fc396e8be4122efef3f8a294aedd9d67571a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/905d0577d69821bdee87/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"007d4e711ea209317b094d0b95a082439a55158f049af9a59d84fede08310774","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a6703b28f21f282153e4ee9647613abe0d3b06fabd8a63c75d11b4b961bce012","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e20","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d9f6cd4b6d2d02acfd95fd23542b78d7","paperId":"hep-th/0408048","sourceSha256":"9969b039308452edfbb0c91976b4fc396e8be4122efef3f8a294aedd9d67571a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/905d0577d69821bdee87/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"007d4e711ea209317b094d0b95a082439a55158f049af9a59d84fede08310774","pdfPage":3,"start":1294,"end":3369,"textSha256":"36bfd029b901df6aa9c4e96bc8ab0dca17cbb707e96570cf120796c6904a4d27","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f4fa46279d25db5abd3a1507","recordId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"The 2004 review's construction claims, applications and experimental forecasts are historical source assertions.","challengeNote":"The 2004 review links a foundational construction question with several applications. Its consistency, singularity and experimental assertions retain historical scope.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9c3b4c2db1b348d888434d8b6085340edc3177cc7c00711d5697e84bfd5a5139","home":{"unitId":"unit:9c3b4c2db1b348d888434d8b6085340edc3177cc7c00711d5697e84bfd5a5139","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:56e696eef2d144a62b8c5625","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9c3b4c2db1b348d888434d8b6085340edc3177cc7c00711d5697e84bfd5a5139","paperId":"1605.04173","textSha256":"77cc0b634652f754c3c609be7d951d6891a0a0c34c11593b5977cb343d596938"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:364349fc043c758920d4c1b1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:364349fc043c758920d4c1b1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9c3b4c2db1b348d888434d8b6085340edc3177cc7c00711d5697e84bfd5a5139","q025-candidate-region:56e696eef2d144a62b8c5625"],"scopeContentSha256":"541ae939a43204c44eddeb62575bac87a667d0f2bf16c3c797250ae391e0ab98","placementContentSha256":"b2087707a8108eabf0be8113515b8283e89d2c703b4895921124f45e348116a4","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge","successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9c3b4c2db1b348d888434d8b6085340edc3177cc7c00711d5697e84bfd5a5139","paperId":"1605.04173","textSha256":"77cc0b634652f754c3c609be7d951d6891a0a0c34c11593b5977cb343d596938"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:364349fc043c758920d4c1b1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9c3b4c2db1b348d888434d8b6085340edc3177cc7c00711d5697e84bfd5a5139","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9f77e45292937042cbb2ad5f","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:9c3b4c2db1b348d888434d8b6085340edc3177cc7c00711d5697e84bfd5a5139","textSha256":"77cc0b634652f754c3c609be7d951d6891a0a0c34c11593b5977cb343d596938"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6a6ad862259b0e0b08edc02b","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound: anomaly-free Weyl reformulation and classical singularity removal require separate assessment. Independent challenge qualification: Compound Weyl-anomaly and classical-singularity targets require separate assessment; s retains the complete source question."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6a6ad862259b0e0b08edc02b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9c3b4c2db1b348d888434d8b6085340edc3177cc7c00711d5697e84bfd5a5139","q025-candidate-question:9f77e45292937042cbb2ad5f"],"scopeContentSha256":"54ee71816baf708cff7612e93a7e775d90ffc43dfef8da50f4e19635ec287427","contributionContentSha256":"fbf5751758c3928321841874e2edaeed94bf28871129c648ba3c8a1750d85fd0","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:9c3b4c2db1b348d888434d8b6085340edc3177cc7c00711d5697e84bfd5a5139","textSha256":"77cc0b634652f754c3c609be7d951d6891a0a0c34c11593b5977cb343d596938"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6a6ad862259b0e0b08edc02b","recordId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound: anomaly-free Weyl reformulation and classical singularity removal require separate assessment.","challengeNote":"Compound Weyl-anomaly and classical-singularity targets require separate assessment; s retains the complete source question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f4ceab51464cb597de138840c92382493030f5163efb1c568edeedb30c2c48f3","home":{"unitId":"unit:f4ceab51464cb597de138840c92382493030f5163efb1c568edeedb30c2c48f3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:56e696eef2d144a62b8c5625","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f4ceab51464cb597de138840c92382493030f5163efb1c568edeedb30c2c48f3","paperId":"2409.06441","textSha256":"9b703af04f6e279350b9d0aa9f5b511c6e10d60e0b3dc946431554942e714e39"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:28a01053e97e4b6b9636def6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:28a01053e97e4b6b9636def6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f4ceab51464cb597de138840c92382493030f5163efb1c568edeedb30c2c48f3","q025-candidate-region:56e696eef2d144a62b8c5625"],"scopeContentSha256":"541ae939a43204c44eddeb62575bac87a667d0f2bf16c3c797250ae391e0ab98","placementContentSha256":"c225cf6ec9a292fba0ccfc6f866ffe2eee764de9444c6189eb4ef8730325ba51","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge","successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f4ceab51464cb597de138840c92382493030f5163efb1c568edeedb30c2c48f3","paperId":"2409.06441","textSha256":"9b703af04f6e279350b9d0aa9f5b511c6e10d60e0b3dc946431554942e714e39"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:28a01053e97e4b6b9636def6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f4ceab51464cb597de138840c92382493030f5163efb1c568edeedb30c2c48f3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9f77e45292937042cbb2ad5f","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:f4ceab51464cb597de138840c92382493030f5163efb1c568edeedb30c2c48f3","textSha256":"9b703af04f6e279350b9d0aa9f5b511c6e10d60e0b3dc946431554942e714e39"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:66e0c61837d0884c1ea18bc7","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Effective cosmological perturbations; the extra background-curvature correction is tested for additional physical effects. Independent challenge qualification: Closure, required counterterms and additional physical effects of background-curvature corrections remain separate tests within effective cosmological perturbations."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:66e0c61837d0884c1ea18bc7","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f4ceab51464cb597de138840c92382493030f5163efb1c568edeedb30c2c48f3","q025-candidate-question:9f77e45292937042cbb2ad5f"],"scopeContentSha256":"54ee71816baf708cff7612e93a7e775d90ffc43dfef8da50f4e19635ec287427","contributionContentSha256":"647371818c2496928170f97f4e79609a77c721119af7950cdcdc4f4ee1c10ffa","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:f4ceab51464cb597de138840c92382493030f5163efb1c568edeedb30c2c48f3","textSha256":"9b703af04f6e279350b9d0aa9f5b511c6e10d60e0b3dc946431554942e714e39"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:66e0c61837d0884c1ea18bc7","recordId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Effective cosmological perturbations; the extra background-curvature correction is tested for additional physical effects.","challengeNote":"Closure, required counterterms and additional physical effects of background-curvature corrections remain separate tests within effective cosmological perturbations.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:f9aaf152c698dd171680c23c5c84e6a02b720ab6781db3ced0a8c97c7febf2a9","home":{"unitId":"unit:f9aaf152c698dd171680c23c5c84e6a02b720ab6781db3ced0a8c97c7febf2a9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:56e696eef2d144a62b8c5625","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Its combined scope explicitly covers physical-state construction, quantum spacetime, covariance, singularity criteria and physical observables in loop approaches.","qualification":"q28 explicitly combines physical-state construction with spacetime, covariance, singularity and observable targets. q11 is strongest on quantization, while q18 is strongest on effective geometry and singularity questions; neither defines the entire combination as explicitly. The stronger inherited warning that vacuum constraint simplification appears not to survive matter inclusion remains local and operative.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f9aaf152c698dd171680c23c5c84e6a02b720ab6781db3ced0a8c97c7febf2a9","paperId":"2211.05621","textSha256":"cfb3b21a582c033bb6886a7319131bc0ced249365a42307f683dd530ff684c44"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0034:u21:q28"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0034:u21:q28","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f9aaf152c698dd171680c23c5c84e6a02b720ab6781db3ced0a8c97c7febf2a9","q025-candidate-region:56e696eef2d144a62b8c5625"],"scopeContentSha256":"541ae939a43204c44eddeb62575bac87a667d0f2bf16c3c797250ae391e0ab98","placementContentSha256":"23c70a73971195d9a9c1ff7d9277a2bbe5a6d2a0e89327fe5db5a0bb9fd30bec","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0034:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0034:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:f9aaf152c698dd171680c23c5c84e6a02b720ab6781db3ced0a8c97c7febf2a9","paperId":"2211.05621","textSha256":"cfb3b21a582c033bb6886a7319131bc0ced249365a42307f683dd530ff684c44"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0034","unitRef":"u21"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:f9aaf152c698dd171680c23c5c84e6a02b720ab6781db3ced0a8c97c7febf2a9","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:9f77e45292937042cbb2ad5f","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:f9aaf152c698dd171680c23c5c84e6a02b720ab6781db3ced0a8c97c7febf2a9","textSha256":"cfb3b21a582c033bb6886a7319131bc0ced249365a42307f683dd530ff684c44"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:54f604a5016809e53b6bbbffc07e6665","paperId":"2211.05621","sourceSha256":"d2fd09e477c39e687766fa12d8b0ac55c1a0a649f98d3a673f88dd10b43b6a7b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fc680fc83e15b5457bd1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"29fa449998f3fec573e762813b88363b41a6e9160c434682f289e5417fde8134","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1517,"textSha256":"99e29a0497b7cdcf83eea66a9bd29bd4187c52c6fcf4f3e10d800ba983d9b004","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ee40b0673fc1300754c22bd0e2694e7f","paperId":"2211.05621","sourceSha256":"d2fd09e477c39e687766fa12d8b0ac55c1a0a649f98d3a673f88dd10b43b6a7b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fc680fc83e15b5457bd1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"29fa449998f3fec573e762813b88363b41a6e9160c434682f289e5417fde8134","pdfPage":2,"start":95,"end":2552,"textSha256":"6590d5117ae1fa6eb54f9e2a2cf0b49db7f93f3bf680da75307f5063e4420121","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6c296d553dd1ac83f75dc3c4","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Review, v2 26 July 2023. Compound states, metrics, singularities, covariance and ringdown targets; vacuum Abelianization does not establish general matter scope Independent challenge qualification: Review, v2 26 July 2023; compound states, metrics, singularity, covariance and ringdown targets. e21 says constraint simplification does not seem to survive matter inclusion, stronger than merely an unverified extension."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6c296d553dd1ac83f75dc3c4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:f9aaf152c698dd171680c23c5c84e6a02b720ab6781db3ced0a8c97c7febf2a9","q025-candidate-question:9f77e45292937042cbb2ad5f"],"scopeContentSha256":"54ee71816baf708cff7612e93a7e775d90ffc43dfef8da50f4e19635ec287427","contributionContentSha256":"aaf862b80cc0f9d92a115086fe53706163fe8aad236a82f98ba32a9aad5792be","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:f9aaf152c698dd171680c23c5c84e6a02b720ab6781db3ced0a8c97c7febf2a9","textSha256":"cfb3b21a582c033bb6886a7319131bc0ced249365a42307f683dd530ff684c44"},{"localRef":"e7","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:54f604a5016809e53b6bbbffc07e6665","paperId":"2211.05621","sourceSha256":"d2fd09e477c39e687766fa12d8b0ac55c1a0a649f98d3a673f88dd10b43b6a7b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fc680fc83e15b5457bd1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"29fa449998f3fec573e762813b88363b41a6e9160c434682f289e5417fde8134","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1517,"textSha256":"99e29a0497b7cdcf83eea66a9bd29bd4187c52c6fcf4f3e10d800ba983d9b004","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:ee40b0673fc1300754c22bd0e2694e7f","paperId":"2211.05621","sourceSha256":"d2fd09e477c39e687766fa12d8b0ac55c1a0a649f98d3a673f88dd10b43b6a7b","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/fc680fc83e15b5457bd1/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"29fa449998f3fec573e762813b88363b41a6e9160c434682f289e5417fde8134","pdfPage":2,"start":95,"end":2552,"textSha256":"6590d5117ae1fa6eb54f9e2a2cf0b49db7f93f3bf680da75307f5063e4420121","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6c296d553dd1ac83f75dc3c4","recordId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-proposal","challengeReviewId":"successor-leaf-ce2e0c80657f40e352ee-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Review, v2 26 July 2023. Compound states, metrics, singularities, covariance and ringdown targets; vacuum Abelianization does not establish general matter scope","challengeNote":"Review, v2 26 July 2023; compound states, metrics, singularity, covariance and ringdown targets. e21 says constraint simplification does not seem to survive matter inclusion, stronger than merely an unverified extension.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":6,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"2d3c19ce193cd3a0460481b5693827636cc202ae32c2a1886e04189f4fd3e1e7"},"organizational-access:fa4f00e47ed7f9762b8ce294":{"id":"organizational-access:fa4f00e47ed7f9762b8ce294","source":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","target":"q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b214b22eb3b0a1a3b419fc93"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"10c91e842592747fabd695adde41b1746857f0f5fd32bb1b327ca5c72bdd857c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:b95736960161f794ae0ece76"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0566af7cb1b7722dc9d8fee74268360b906f8d24299531c62f9692558fb173bd","home":{"unitId":"unit:0566af7cb1b7722dc9d8fee74268360b906f8d24299531c62f9692558fb173bd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0566af7cb1b7722dc9d8fee74268360b906f8d24299531c62f9692558fb173bd","paperId":"1909.11106","textSha256":"927ec7877300ec4a823ff5d0e900c864e32a3ffdb6ac26a9ff75fbf3657f3006"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:34386e4f33d4662e14f01349e4714f38","paperId":"1909.11106","sourceSha256":"97418d05020761906ecfdb2a29b7e8878a286fbf17f0fec4e044096f06996f00","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2e55c6a67fee3ebeeb28/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b7024962df81c50038b5046b157f32cd3441b57bfafb0161299de1d028ba5a3","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"1a7752d3606801bc254875d20fb4ef210d7a967b4fa12532568882bd73d8a15b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:40bd9da130eeba4c8aa8eb858e4d5b3f","paperId":"1909.11106","sourceSha256":"97418d05020761906ecfdb2a29b7e8878a286fbf17f0fec4e044096f06996f00","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2e55c6a67fee3ebeeb28/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b7024962df81c50038b5046b157f32cd3441b57bfafb0161299de1d028ba5a3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0990088cd2cdd716a4c0b1d0d82c8a0e74d256fc27b15b3a8b8db0bdad4faffb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e08a7b8cdf10e97adb19f137"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e08a7b8cdf10e97adb19f137","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0566af7cb1b7722dc9d8fee74268360b906f8d24299531c62f9692558fb173bd","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"3601f1e76e773e8e8a3e75e3e55f7e0b7107c69dadd42d70757d43bf50c0e3d7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0566af7cb1b7722dc9d8fee74268360b906f8d24299531c62f9692558fb173bd","paperId":"1909.11106","textSha256":"927ec7877300ec4a823ff5d0e900c864e32a3ffdb6ac26a9ff75fbf3657f3006"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:34386e4f33d4662e14f01349e4714f38","paperId":"1909.11106","sourceSha256":"97418d05020761906ecfdb2a29b7e8878a286fbf17f0fec4e044096f06996f00","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2e55c6a67fee3ebeeb28/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b7024962df81c50038b5046b157f32cd3441b57bfafb0161299de1d028ba5a3","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"1a7752d3606801bc254875d20fb4ef210d7a967b4fa12532568882bd73d8a15b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:40bd9da130eeba4c8aa8eb858e4d5b3f","paperId":"1909.11106","sourceSha256":"97418d05020761906ecfdb2a29b7e8878a286fbf17f0fec4e044096f06996f00","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2e55c6a67fee3ebeeb28/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b7024962df81c50038b5046b157f32cd3441b57bfafb0161299de1d028ba5a3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0990088cd2cdd716a4c0b1d0d82c8a0e74d256fc27b15b3a8b8db0bdad4faffb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e08a7b8cdf10e97adb19f137"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0566af7cb1b7722dc9d8fee74268360b906f8d24299531c62f9692558fb173bd","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d17","kind":"description","unitIndex":17,"unitId":"unit:0566af7cb1b7722dc9d8fee74268360b906f8d24299531c62f9692558fb173bd","textSha256":"927ec7877300ec4a823ff5d0e900c864e32a3ffdb6ac26a9ff75fbf3657f3006"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:34386e4f33d4662e14f01349e4714f38","paperId":"1909.11106","sourceSha256":"97418d05020761906ecfdb2a29b7e8878a286fbf17f0fec4e044096f06996f00","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2e55c6a67fee3ebeeb28/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b7024962df81c50038b5046b157f32cd3441b57bfafb0161299de1d028ba5a3","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"1a7752d3606801bc254875d20fb4ef210d7a967b4fa12532568882bd73d8a15b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:40bd9da130eeba4c8aa8eb858e4d5b3f","paperId":"1909.11106","sourceSha256":"97418d05020761906ecfdb2a29b7e8878a286fbf17f0fec4e044096f06996f00","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2e55c6a67fee3ebeeb28/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b7024962df81c50038b5046b157f32cd3441b57bfafb0161299de1d028ba5a3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0990088cd2cdd716a4c0b1d0d82c8a0e74d256fc27b15b3a8b8db0bdad4faffb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:834d6e09913e5b3b97db37b6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:834d6e09913e5b3b97db37b6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0566af7cb1b7722dc9d8fee74268360b906f8d24299531c62f9692558fb173bd","q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77"],"scopeContentSha256":"10c91e842592747fabd695adde41b1746857f0f5fd32bb1b327ca5c72bdd857c","contributionContentSha256":"868b1b936a5d9dcbda05112bd950d543598dd3d59f2bb946be6860cf6b836a89","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d17","kind":"description","unitIndex":17,"unitId":"unit:0566af7cb1b7722dc9d8fee74268360b906f8d24299531c62f9692558fb173bd","textSha256":"927ec7877300ec4a823ff5d0e900c864e32a3ffdb6ac26a9ff75fbf3657f3006"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:34386e4f33d4662e14f01349e4714f38","paperId":"1909.11106","sourceSha256":"97418d05020761906ecfdb2a29b7e8878a286fbf17f0fec4e044096f06996f00","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2e55c6a67fee3ebeeb28/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b7024962df81c50038b5046b157f32cd3441b57bfafb0161299de1d028ba5a3","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"1a7752d3606801bc254875d20fb4ef210d7a967b4fa12532568882bd73d8a15b","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:40bd9da130eeba4c8aa8eb858e4d5b3f","paperId":"1909.11106","sourceSha256":"97418d05020761906ecfdb2a29b7e8878a286fbf17f0fec4e044096f06996f00","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/2e55c6a67fee3ebeeb28/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0b7024962df81c50038b5046b157f32cd3441b57bfafb0161299de1d028ba5a3","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"0990088cd2cdd716a4c0b1d0d82c8a0e74d256fc27b15b3a8b8db0bdad4faffb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:834d6e09913e5b3b97db37b6","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"The supplied analysis uses a flat homogeneous four-dimensional setting and constant-H approximation; slow-roll initial-condition claims are a specialization.","challengeNote":"Flat homogeneous four-dimensional setting and constant-H approximation; the slow-roll initial-condition analysis is a specialization.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:1e65deb776183a0c114918fa6f778ef678af958ab59b8d5328f2e9052b3e4c26","home":{"unitId":"unit:1e65deb776183a0c114918fa6f778ef678af958ab59b8d5328f2e9052b3e4c26","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Jointly covers entropy-motivated cutoff reasoning, field and duration budgets, and primordial tensors in dimensional settings.","qualification":"q10 jointly covers ultraviolet assumptions, field budgets, duration and tensor consequences, and dimensional settings. q5 covers the excursion component but does not establish complete coverage of the distinct tensor–extra-dimension relation. Entropy-motivated cutoff relations remain separate from TCC, and spacetime dimension is not identified with field-space dimension.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e65deb776183a0c114918fa6f778ef678af958ab59b8d5328f2e9052b3e4c26","paperId":"2507.02738","textSha256":"105954650e518ff04245f212e71223017e7f272fe357e7b3f9dd7ed6e79c8b5e"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0001:u25:q10"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0001:u25:q10","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e65deb776183a0c114918fa6f778ef678af958ab59b8d5328f2e9052b3e4c26","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"355dc0ec85d85b2413fc111e9319fcd5032c8be3822edaa952a0c163507c930a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0001:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0001:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1e65deb776183a0c114918fa6f778ef678af958ab59b8d5328f2e9052b3e4c26","paperId":"2507.02738","textSha256":"105954650e518ff04245f212e71223017e7f272fe357e7b3f9dd7ed6e79c8b5e"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0001","unitRef":"u25"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1e65deb776183a0c114918fa6f778ef678af958ab59b8d5328f2e9052b3e4c26","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d88","kind":"description","unitIndex":88,"unitId":"unit:1e65deb776183a0c114918fa6f778ef678af958ab59b8d5328f2e9052b3e4c26","textSha256":"105954650e518ff04245f212e71223017e7f272fe357e7b3f9dd7ed6e79c8b5e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0584fd9709488b35fecc65fd"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:0584fd9709488b35fecc65fd","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1e65deb776183a0c114918fa6f778ef678af958ab59b8d5328f2e9052b3e4c26","q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77"],"scopeContentSha256":"10c91e842592747fabd695adde41b1746857f0f5fd32bb1b327ca5c72bdd857c","contributionContentSha256":"93a3866c09088e35ece709ad552f733fc6468ed117f27583f5ff4e9702273d25","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d88","kind":"description","unitIndex":88,"unitId":"unit:1e65deb776183a0c114918fa6f778ef678af958ab59b8d5328f2e9052b3e4c26","textSha256":"105954650e518ff04245f212e71223017e7f272fe357e7b3f9dd7ed6e79c8b5e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:0584fd9709488b35fecc65fd","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound excursion/duration and tensor/dimensionality targets; entropy-motivated cutoff relations are not identified with TCC.","challengeNote":"Compound excursion/duration and tensor/dimensionality targets; entropy cutoff relations are not identified with TCC.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:34aec69e636ccc1a84326a9428e2ba80708d085eb3544f25cb35183bf8d9375d","home":{"unitId":"unit:34aec69e636ccc1a84326a9428e2ba80708d085eb3544f25cb35183bf8d9375d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:34aec69e636ccc1a84326a9428e2ba80708d085eb3544f25cb35183bf8d9375d","paperId":"2006.01902","textSha256":"5bb38a9055bddb22ccb43cd1a3eb54ec9d784ec4a02031074145df770e44233c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2ff408ea0ea63016e80e4aa2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2ff408ea0ea63016e80e4aa2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:34aec69e636ccc1a84326a9428e2ba80708d085eb3544f25cb35183bf8d9375d","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"0691e3a072ee219fbe1e9036e4246c29ede8555f47a02ebdcbbdad878c98e8dc","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:34aec69e636ccc1a84326a9428e2ba80708d085eb3544f25cb35183bf8d9375d","paperId":"2006.01902","textSha256":"5bb38a9055bddb22ccb43cd1a3eb54ec9d784ec4a02031074145df770e44233c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2ff408ea0ea63016e80e4aa2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:34aec69e636ccc1a84326a9428e2ba80708d085eb3544f25cb35183bf8d9375d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d50","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:34aec69e636ccc1a84326a9428e2ba80708d085eb3544f25cb35183bf8d9375d","textSha256":"5bb38a9055bddb22ccb43cd1a3eb54ec9d784ec4a02031074145df770e44233c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e70cd8ab82fad82abaf30902"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e70cd8ab82fad82abaf30902","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:34aec69e636ccc1a84326a9428e2ba80708d085eb3544f25cb35183bf8d9375d","q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77"],"scopeContentSha256":"10c91e842592747fabd695adde41b1746857f0f5fd32bb1b327ca5c72bdd857c","contributionContentSha256":"9a56a8339508d5068d370aa3659c9a7efed9c171557073afd0da26e7d97efabc","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d50","kind":"description","unitIndex":50,"unitId":"unit:34aec69e636ccc1a84326a9428e2ba80708d085eb3544f25cb35183bf8d9375d","textSha256":"5bb38a9055bddb22ccb43cd1a3eb54ec9d784ec4a02031074145df770e44233c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e70cd8ab82fad82abaf30902","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Thermal trapping and added damping are alternative mechanisms; neither is assumed to evade censorship.","challengeNote":"Potential-derivative criteria are unnamed. Thermal trapping and added damping are alternatives; censorship evasion is a question.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:39effa966c186172fc4e1e3953a654a28f482e05fcfe0075c1b767bfcd554005","home":{"unitId":"unit:39effa966c186172fc4e1e3953a654a28f482e05fcfe0075c1b767bfcd554005","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:39effa966c186172fc4e1e3953a654a28f482e05fcfe0075c1b767bfcd554005","paperId":"2610.04858","textSha256":"da838dad0892c52d6a7215a7927357541173ee0576cf01b3cd93b0ee079f6e36"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ff38022daebdfb0104f63c1b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ff38022daebdfb0104f63c1b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:39effa966c186172fc4e1e3953a654a28f482e05fcfe0075c1b767bfcd554005","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"458b07f877b342f431afd9ece52f4d2e7edb98abf14c6d275ecd1e844ff1fe9b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:39effa966c186172fc4e1e3953a654a28f482e05fcfe0075c1b767bfcd554005","paperId":"2610.04858","textSha256":"da838dad0892c52d6a7215a7927357541173ee0576cf01b3cd93b0ee079f6e36"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ff38022daebdfb0104f63c1b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:39effa966c186172fc4e1e3953a654a28f482e05fcfe0075c1b767bfcd554005","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d94","kind":"description","unitIndex":94,"unitId":"unit:39effa966c186172fc4e1e3953a654a28f482e05fcfe0075c1b767bfcd554005","textSha256":"da838dad0892c52d6a7215a7927357541173ee0576cf01b3cd93b0ee079f6e36"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2bf201d78719296b488c0df6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2bf201d78719296b488c0df6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:39effa966c186172fc4e1e3953a654a28f482e05fcfe0075c1b767bfcd554005","q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77"],"scopeContentSha256":"10c91e842592747fabd695adde41b1746857f0f5fd32bb1b327ca5c72bdd857c","contributionContentSha256":"67737f6d1cabbe95117e4c134195ee2ec62479ea75cf523735b2e4e1da84489a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d94","kind":"description","unitIndex":94,"unitId":"unit:39effa966c186172fc4e1e3953a654a28f482e05fcfe0075c1b767bfcd554005","textSha256":"da838dad0892c52d6a7215a7927357541173ee0576cf01b3cd93b0ee079f6e36"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2bf201d78719296b488c0df6","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Partial extrema and multifield evolution are separate targets within one-parameter type IIB flux-potential tests.","challengeNote":"Potential restrictions, partial extrema and multifield evolution are distinct targets of the compound study.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","home":{"unitId":"unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","paperId":"2002.07061","textSha256":"2153f6443ca7b468f0ba022755e50d120b593da816f343434f975438c864c00f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05df496c35f7f5a29cbaa795"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05df496c35f7f5a29cbaa795","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"513340bd30d691729cb9199b1366dd7f29de08e5330700aa827e8d0a6a0ff43e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","paperId":"2002.07061","textSha256":"2153f6443ca7b468f0ba022755e50d120b593da816f343434f975438c864c00f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:05df496c35f7f5a29cbaa795"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","textSha256":"2153f6443ca7b468f0ba022755e50d120b593da816f343434f975438c864c00f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b38613f04a0a95fa07e50ae5"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b38613f04a0a95fa07e50ae5","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77"],"scopeContentSha256":"10c91e842592747fabd695adde41b1746857f0f5fd32bb1b327ca5c72bdd857c","contributionContentSha256":"991085487158f99a3289f92a333940fc00719362c998260d4ad3b53926fc1677","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:3fa4e151e796d4b2209411c6356fdde72be16ab91eef4fa068cdb70f523b4a21","textSha256":"2153f6443ca7b468f0ba022755e50d120b593da816f343434f975438c864c00f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b38613f04a0a95fa07e50ae5","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The 55–75 e-fold target and selected reheating histories are part of the modified-expansion test.","challengeNote":"The potential-gradient conjecture is unnamed. Retain 55–75 e-folds and the dependence of TCC compatibility on selected reheating histories.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","home":{"unitId":"unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","paperId":"2504.04561","textSha256":"f9552de72682bc018bd9b80e0af0539a576923a2bf12b1be58fdfbf53cf950db"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9f363e4248020cd471e7452c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9f363e4248020cd471e7452c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"2e9c035c7373ddca52cacbbe26af36fab3778bebedde96355e043f56d51619d5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","paperId":"2504.04561","textSha256":"f9552de72682bc018bd9b80e0af0539a576923a2bf12b1be58fdfbf53cf950db"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:9f363e4248020cd471e7452c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d87","kind":"description","unitIndex":87,"unitId":"unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","textSha256":"f9552de72682bc018bd9b80e0af0539a576923a2bf12b1be58fdfbf53cf950db"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:71a293d2ee3e2aa53fa5ce8b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:71a293d2ee3e2aa53fa5ce8b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77"],"scopeContentSha256":"10c91e842592747fabd695adde41b1746857f0f5fd32bb1b327ca5c72bdd857c","contributionContentSha256":"731342768d15165f7b420d786114d444b2756d20870f8f0b2e46fb76cc1cab95","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d87","kind":"description","unitIndex":87,"unitId":"unit:d4aa2c99ff86319dd746d60e077d71036f50ac4bf7771519720a19a5bfaca03c","textSha256":"f9552de72682bc018bd9b80e0af0539a576923a2bf12b1be58fdfbf53cf950db"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:71a293d2ee3e2aa53fa5ce8b","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The constant-EoS scalar tail is a proposed remedy; observational and slope compatibility require separate tests.","challengeNote":"The scalar tail is a proposed remedy whose observational and slope compatibility require testing.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:eb561729f390efb27400eab9232f2ada5f10d5d84568b4ee990e64bbf507f6b6","home":{"unitId":"unit:eb561729f390efb27400eab9232f2ada5f10d5d84568b4ee990e64bbf507f6b6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:eb561729f390efb27400eab9232f2ada5f10d5d84568b4ee990e64bbf507f6b6","paperId":"1910.02147","textSha256":"4bfab6bcfcb2dd4b8a802824e434ce85239bd2b22ba435e79342120d49a828b3"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:50e609f910e078870ff68ae6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:50e609f910e078870ff68ae6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:eb561729f390efb27400eab9232f2ada5f10d5d84568b4ee990e64bbf507f6b6","q025-candidate-region:5a27f6c000b10d72c4dd6f8c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c337f6d69575cf24d9931a8b432f22285c538d5e61949009e894c5accb19573","placementContentSha256":"637af271d4cead91616f72667ed6c58bd91e798033843378a6df4967c9c9bd67","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:eb561729f390efb27400eab9232f2ada5f10d5d84568b4ee990e64bbf507f6b6","paperId":"1910.02147","textSha256":"4bfab6bcfcb2dd4b8a802824e434ce85239bd2b22ba435e79342120d49a828b3"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:50e609f910e078870ff68ae6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:eb561729f390efb27400eab9232f2ada5f10d5d84568b4ee990e64bbf507f6b6","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:eb561729f390efb27400eab9232f2ada5f10d5d84568b4ee990e64bbf507f6b6","textSha256":"4bfab6bcfcb2dd4b8a802824e434ce85239bd2b22ba435e79342120d49a828b3"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a57f183feb86fee2d8565fac"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a57f183feb86fee2d8565fac","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:eb561729f390efb27400eab9232f2ada5f10d5d84568b4ee990e64bbf507f6b6","q025-candidate-question:6a5935fcb056494772a40d77"],"scopeContentSha256":"10c91e842592747fabd695adde41b1746857f0f5fd32bb1b327ca5c72bdd857c","contributionContentSha256":"247b21461fb69713261b16655151580ccf85b90c3617b876f254c9807f1b526b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d20","kind":"description","unitIndex":20,"unitId":"unit:eb561729f390efb27400eab9232f2ada5f10d5d84568b4ee990e64bbf507f6b6","textSha256":"4bfab6bcfcb2dd4b8a802824e434ce85239bd2b22ba435e79342120d49a828b3"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a57f183feb86fee2d8565fac","recordId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-568a730d23db86e13f19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":7,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"a91b7532e9b8e9eaf4b6d0733c3e17078fc1f2be9455c4c6cbe13488a4116543"},"organizational-access:a37b0c80bf04a92313db7c63":{"id":"organizational-access:a37b0c80bf04a92313db7c63","source":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","target":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:5025d915791a4d704d8c95c2"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ec2c47e7ee84c6d123adca5b3d961b204b3261307a6c2bc5a4aaf3baae54201d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:cef6ef19d5338c5bfb7fa705"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","home":{"unitId":"unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","paperId":"2512.07922","textSha256":"6d8e287667544c9e1cf688ddeeddacaf4665af3fece547d8c6e5a3947ad1b399"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1799571771d21b92c6cf0ca6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1799571771d21b92c6cf0ca6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"8471bbaf554b0c4458055bdf26f9dc2d93f88b19d1cb612bdcb8492d53797d1f","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","paperId":"2512.07922","textSha256":"6d8e287667544c9e1cf688ddeeddacaf4665af3fece547d8c6e5a3947ad1b399"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1799571771d21b92c6cf0ca6"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d53","kind":"description","unitIndex":53,"unitId":"unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","textSha256":"6d8e287667544c9e1cf688ddeeddacaf4665af3fece547d8c6e5a3947ad1b399"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3bc42aff1a2f0ebe0a7b68f9","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Extremality/particle bounds and weak lensing remain distinct targets. Independent challenge qualification: Extremality, particle bounds, censorship and weak lensing remain distinguishable targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3bc42aff1a2f0ebe0a7b68f9","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec2c47e7ee84c6d123adca5b3d961b204b3261307a6c2bc5a4aaf3baae54201d","contributionContentSha256":"23b73f7f806219082b0a77edd2ac573d0d95d121ccf80be8a86450243402ec23","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d53","kind":"description","unitIndex":53,"unitId":"unit:1213e00a2683350694097421a39bff85087934d8a6c8c8b5432c50a5334506e8","textSha256":"6d8e287667544c9e1cf688ddeeddacaf4665af3fece547d8c6e5a3947ad1b399"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3bc42aff1a2f0ebe0a7b68f9","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Extremality/particle bounds and weak lensing remain distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Extremality, particle bounds, censorship and weak lensing remain distinguishable targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:250f00a77454639daab4d868b8fbf4201fb055c349e01ce92146b2043a656345","home":{"unitId":"unit:250f00a77454639daab4d868b8fbf4201fb055c349e01ce92146b2043a656345","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:250f00a77454639daab4d868b8fbf4201fb055c349e01ce92146b2043a656345","paperId":"2205.03648","textSha256":"c8336af96663f5f589aaa61108f5ec185b78e87cda7f635e22e428a9604e5f24"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:17f90a03b3a8e24f44bbf226"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:17f90a03b3a8e24f44bbf226","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:250f00a77454639daab4d868b8fbf4201fb055c349e01ce92146b2043a656345","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"02b4147d55fb426c8901c6803b9495db717142c907f9dfb1af0fabf7b8d05d4d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:250f00a77454639daab4d868b8fbf4201fb055c349e01ce92146b2043a656345","paperId":"2205.03648","textSha256":"c8336af96663f5f589aaa61108f5ec185b78e87cda7f635e22e428a9604e5f24"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:17f90a03b3a8e24f44bbf226"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:250f00a77454639daab4d868b8fbf4201fb055c349e01ce92146b2043a656345","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:250f00a77454639daab4d868b8fbf4201fb055c349e01ce92146b2043a656345","textSha256":"c8336af96663f5f589aaa61108f5ec185b78e87cda7f635e22e428a9604e5f24"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f9c5afa32b67af79262acf4c","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Criticality and the two-charge criterion remain a compound source question. Independent challenge qualification: Criticality and the two-charge criterion remain compound targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:f9c5afa32b67af79262acf4c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:250f00a77454639daab4d868b8fbf4201fb055c349e01ce92146b2043a656345","q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec2c47e7ee84c6d123adca5b3d961b204b3261307a6c2bc5a4aaf3baae54201d","contributionContentSha256":"34af6dfddee804776a5833684151812ccb88f3d6fb2cc44b32c2c9f2006b3a4c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d24","kind":"description","unitIndex":24,"unitId":"unit:250f00a77454639daab4d868b8fbf4201fb055c349e01ce92146b2043a656345","textSha256":"c8336af96663f5f589aaa61108f5ec185b78e87cda7f635e22e428a9604e5f24"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:f9c5afa32b67af79262acf4c","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Criticality and the two-charge criterion remain a compound source question.","challengeNote":"Criticality and the two-charge criterion remain compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","home":{"unitId":"unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","paperId":"2602.22930","textSha256":"01877014db3f362e43394e04cd7bb38b399cbc60d3f8d66124740d870d9aed79"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:700f2c72796ca56a37e4aaaf"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:700f2c72796ca56a37e4aaaf","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"732864db1d67a24bf18cf086a3de5e7a5c1a3f3ab4351a9f9f98ee24883a16ac","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","paperId":"2602.22930","textSha256":"01877014db3f362e43394e04cd7bb38b399cbc60d3f8d66124740d870d9aed79"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:700f2c72796ca56a37e4aaaf"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","textSha256":"01877014db3f362e43394e04cd7bb38b399cbc60d3f8d66124740d870d9aed79"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a07811532a08bee8982cc1df","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Conjecture compatibility, optical predictions and Barrow thermodynamics need separate facet reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Conjecture compatibility, optics and Barrow thermodynamics require separate facet reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a07811532a08bee8982cc1df","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec2c47e7ee84c6d123adca5b3d961b204b3261307a6c2bc5a4aaf3baae54201d","contributionContentSha256":"137a104aea146c3b53745671c545d5fba144b25d07239386071de962bcb143c7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:266c8804aef50dd02be675a0980896f44a5e8e4da543bb193d6c1ea373e907d8","textSha256":"01877014db3f362e43394e04cd7bb38b399cbc60d3f8d66124740d870d9aed79"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a07811532a08bee8982cc1df","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Conjecture compatibility, optical predictions and Barrow thermodynamics need separate facet reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Conjecture compatibility, optics and Barrow thermodynamics require separate facet reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","home":{"unitId":"unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","paperId":"2412.00079","textSha256":"d03d1b50b781ff5409984998207acc0198e513509b34c5c757e9e25f3790875f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4accca414640b6a328667b11"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4accca414640b6a328667b11","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"bdfe47a208e63ac1faf4a723351055cac4e9020af4ce6c54b21f0d5edbd0a845","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","paperId":"2412.00079","textSha256":"d03d1b50b781ff5409984998207acc0198e513509b34c5c757e9e25f3790875f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:4accca414640b6a328667b11"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","textSha256":"d03d1b50b781ff5409984998207acc0198e513509b34c5c757e9e25f3790875f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:00ddf6207c501b53c2ac52d0","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Horizon, photon and timelike-orbit targets remain a compound source scope. Independent challenge qualification: Horizon, photon and timelike-orbit targets remain a compound source scope."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:00ddf6207c501b53c2ac52d0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec2c47e7ee84c6d123adca5b3d961b204b3261307a6c2bc5a4aaf3baae54201d","contributionContentSha256":"d21e178b5f0bd10d5049395218f717a979e80244c7759be4124591270b37e662","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:2a2c060a46d220877bd5228dfda3f59b0a5a9e3b16caa1f41e43aa1a093298ad","textSha256":"d03d1b50b781ff5409984998207acc0198e513509b34c5c757e9e25f3790875f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:00ddf6207c501b53c2ac52d0","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Horizon, photon and timelike-orbit targets remain a compound source scope.","challengeNote":"Horizon, photon and timelike-orbit targets remain a compound source scope.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b29e943f46599a933462f1a4d376e1ef14b2f6708aac265ad11131c6b8790d62","home":{"unitId":"unit:b29e943f46599a933462f1a4d376e1ef14b2f6708aac265ad11131c6b8790d62","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b29e943f46599a933462f1a4d376e1ef14b2f6708aac265ad11131c6b8790d62","paperId":"2410.14492","textSha256":"f6c667cef909db9d64ceee13dc7e17e42506cf290a3826e8fa56638e2739e972"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:928e2837737b7f8d1f485031"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:928e2837737b7f8d1f485031","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b29e943f46599a933462f1a4d376e1ef14b2f6708aac265ad11131c6b8790d62","q025-candidate-region:5f91a1accabb39a167183aaa"],"scopeContentSha256":"545e7e7627a7e9d8266d887e83425d4902da19d72bef776cd3488b61936df845","placementContentSha256":"f5c6c11df64a789669e5dbdeaa9feb36bff7521ebbc87ff3592c99aa302f65c1","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b29e943f46599a933462f1a4d376e1ef14b2f6708aac265ad11131c6b8790d62","paperId":"2410.14492","textSha256":"f6c667cef909db9d64ceee13dc7e17e42506cf290a3826e8fa56638e2739e972"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:928e2837737b7f8d1f485031"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b29e943f46599a933462f1a4d376e1ef14b2f6708aac265ad11131c6b8790d62","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:b29e943f46599a933462f1a4d376e1ef14b2f6708aac265ad11131c6b8790d62","textSha256":"f6c667cef909db9d64ceee13dc7e17e42506cf290a3826e8fa56638e2739e972"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:87c924f633e2bfc37550890c","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Horizon/photon compatibility and thermodynamic winding are separate targets requiring reconciliation. Independent challenge qualification: Horizon/photon compatibility and thermodynamic winding require separate facet reconciliation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:87c924f633e2bfc37550890c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b29e943f46599a933462f1a4d376e1ef14b2f6708aac265ad11131c6b8790d62","q025-candidate-question:80969e8fb17e225f7f82cbf7"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec2c47e7ee84c6d123adca5b3d961b204b3261307a6c2bc5a4aaf3baae54201d","contributionContentSha256":"b54cb0a7100799278fa9bc1d7d7e057f69eecb451126c6fe23d2b14010c0735a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:b29e943f46599a933462f1a4d376e1ef14b2f6708aac265ad11131c6b8790d62","textSha256":"f6c667cef909db9d64ceee13dc7e17e42506cf290a3826e8fa56638e2739e972"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:87c924f633e2bfc37550890c","recordId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bb490e0488679819dafc-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Horizon/photon compatibility and thermodynamic winding are separate targets requiring reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Horizon/photon compatibility and thermodynamic winding require separate facet reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":5,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"0f643e5635769132a3286ac376f8ebcd5192f99892b6fb2a9087fda99fdfae49"},"organizational-access:cb802a2595c7a9e3deaf02b3":{"id":"organizational-access:cb802a2595c7a9e3deaf02b3","source":"q025-candidate-region:6e18906f7041bc3fb341eec5","target":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:6e18906f7041bc3fb341eec5","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"75aa703e869c9556ca46c6acd5d4b2d135805ff595b8250dcfeac7c61ca848e0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:d45fc8ba3af65c842fea6691"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ccd5e77a867e82ef7825199cd2d2c893840dc9ae3a8e87e1462a81ac1aa99d41","scopeDecisionId":"decision:canonical-pilot-scope:statistics:pq0"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:fff6a7782b613baac41e699dabffd995958cf249265239c921f2d9ad3646f9dc","home":{"unitId":"unit:fff6a7782b613baac41e699dabffd995958cf249265239c921f2d9ad3646f9dc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:6e18906f7041bc3fb341eec5","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers IIB stabilization, vacuum structure, control conditions and inflationary applications together.","qualification":"q29 covers IIB stabilization, vacuum structure, consistency and inflation under construction-specific conditions. q21 lacks an explicit full slow-roll target, and q1 does not cover the complete potential-generation and control question. The broader q29 is therefore a justified whole home even though not nominated.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fff6a7782b613baac41e699dabffd995958cf249265239c921f2d9ad3646f9dc","paperId":"0912.3287","textSha256":"5137f6e4f96b0d1575cb3dde93d794bdfdae0c8ee86a87abd091b7b4d39d28fa"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0049:u19:q29"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0049:u19:q29","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fff6a7782b613baac41e699dabffd995958cf249265239c921f2d9ad3646f9dc","q025-candidate-region:6e18906f7041bc3fb341eec5"],"scopeContentSha256":"75aa703e869c9556ca46c6acd5d4b2d135805ff595b8250dcfeac7c61ca848e0","placementContentSha256":"26e5abd39c9fc0522a489415c02c6e5ababa454cbfe364c73d9a5fb40dd43748","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0049:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0049:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fff6a7782b613baac41e699dabffd995958cf249265239c921f2d9ad3646f9dc","paperId":"0912.3287","textSha256":"5137f6e4f96b0d1575cb3dde93d794bdfdae0c8ee86a87abd091b7b4d39d28fa"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0049","unitRef":"u19"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:fff6a7782b613baac41e699dabffd995958cf249265239c921f2d9ad3646f9dc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u52","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fff6a7782b613baac41e699dabffd995958cf249265239c921f2d9ad3646f9dc","paperId":"0912.3287","textSha256":"5137f6e4f96b0d1575cb3dde93d794bdfdae0c8ee86a87abd091b7b4d39d28fa"}],"qualification":"Original source-specific qualification: Description-level evidence asks whether the O5/O7 compactifications stabilize moduli in controlled vacua. It does not provide a finite control calculation in this packet. Current explicit adjudication: The description directly narrows pq0 to O5/O7 compactifications; it supplies no particular obstruction or contrast supporting boundary. Additional qualifications: Support concerns the controlled-stabilization component in the specified O5/O7 setting. Metastability and slow-roll inflation remain separate components, and no finite control calculation is supplied. The previous boundary classification is superseded by the source-component specializes role; it is not a countercondition, whole-source home or identity.","decisionId":"decision:canonical-adjudicated-role:statistics:z20"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:canonical-adjudicated-role:statistics:z20","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:fff6a7782b613baac41e699dabffd995958cf249265239c921f2d9ad3646f9dc","q025-candidate-question:97f54791c4e9f3485e17eb02"],"scopeContentSha256":"ccd5e77a867e82ef7825199cd2d2c893840dc9ae3a8e87e1462a81ac1aa99d41","contributionContentSha256":"fe74de95b39a604ef446fe57f855b9a1c68a448fbddf982ba8af9acde559e694","challengerAgreement":"coordinator_adjudicated_source_contribution","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_source_contribution","receipt":{"path":"../../../evaluation/full-pass/canonical-role-adjudications-v2/admission.json","sha256":"ebb259802ad5fb3293e5a30ab9b6f2efd72ed948191d12ceb30445e26b4dfe97"}},"sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","statistics-source-role-confirmation"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u52","kind":"description","unitId":"unit:fff6a7782b613baac41e699dabffd995958cf249265239c921f2d9ad3646f9dc","paperId":"0912.3287","textSha256":"5137f6e4f96b0d1575cb3dde93d794bdfdae0c8ee86a87abd091b7b4d39d28fa"}],"explicitAdjudicationBasis":{"decisionId":"decision:canonical-adjudicated-role:statistics:z20","sourceReviewIds":["canonical-adopted-control-statistics-proposal","statistics-source-role-confirmation"],"originalContribution":{"id":"z20","unitRef":"u52","questionRef":"pq0","role":"boundary","reason":"Description-level evidence asks whether the O5/O7 compactifications stabilize moduli in controlled vacua. It does not provide a finite control calculation in this packet.","refs":["u52"]},"confirmationJudgment":{"id":"z20","verdict":"revise_role","basis":"description_checked","revisedRole":"specializes","additionalQualifications":["Support concerns the controlled-stabilization component in the specified O5/O7 setting. Metastability and slow-roll inflation remain separate components, and no finite control calculation is supplied."],"reason":"The description directly narrows pq0 to O5/O7 compactifications; it supplies no particular obstruction or contrast supporting boundary.","refs":["u52","pq0","n24"]},"exactPrivatePacket":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/native-local/canonical-role-adjudication-v1/statistics-z20.json","sha256":"dfdd7cbaca80944fe55da71d97a108bb31c36c6a191a466cb3ad3ebe332385d6"},"scopeContentSha256":"ccd5e77a867e82ef7825199cd2d2c893840dc9ae3a8e87e1462a81ac1aa99d41"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"7e38fed6431dda4a8f13cc40ae88e2dd7f61d4bd90ba5c9b5827866b11168343"},"organizational-access:b6eacbb6da4f506757dd9e88":{"id":"organizational-access:b6eacbb6da4f506757dd9e88","source":"q025-candidate-region:6fe3fe07f985ff9858ad3c06","target":"q025-candidate-question:4723858a27075d6ac6ef24e2","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:6fe3fe07f985ff9858ad3c06","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"c5d83fce0f112ee76c63471cc6b77e91727b2c50991735d7d9eef02c83a58d19","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f43fe713206641a2663fcac8"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:4723858a27075d6ac6ef24e2","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ec0627bb3f8ba5bb12bb5357002d42915d2118ab1b983a214350ae2ba581c00c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c0dd96763010ed05110f3402"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:abf41d18dd23b1f74069e723564729e7b301e4bbbc95cbd3407d92ee9e10a9fc","home":{"unitId":"unit:abf41d18dd23b1f74069e723564729e7b301e4bbbc95cbd3407d92ee9e10a9fc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:6fe3fe07f985ff9858ad3c06","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q15 jointly covers inflationary effective-theory construction, background origins, primordial predictions, exit and matter production.","qualification":"q15 covers microscopic justification, initial conditions, preserved fluctuation predictions and energy transfer together. q4 addresses control, q5 preparation and exit, and q9 perturbation histories, but none alone explicitly carries this entire conjunction.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:abf41d18dd23b1f74069e723564729e7b301e4bbbc95cbd3407d92ee9e10a9fc","paperId":"0708.2865","textSha256":"73df5aa06aecb117c78b4979000a1a948845309dd166d811123d8d74bbad4894"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0047:u24:q15"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0047:u24:q15","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:abf41d18dd23b1f74069e723564729e7b301e4bbbc95cbd3407d92ee9e10a9fc","q025-candidate-region:6fe3fe07f985ff9858ad3c06"],"scopeContentSha256":"c5d83fce0f112ee76c63471cc6b77e91727b2c50991735d7d9eef02c83a58d19","placementContentSha256":"37acbdd7f428c2cc96c6e3449dd9dea721685ab7e21b1b51ed3e4c0690bc3946","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0047:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0047:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:abf41d18dd23b1f74069e723564729e7b301e4bbbc95cbd3407d92ee9e10a9fc","paperId":"0708.2865","textSha256":"73df5aa06aecb117c78b4979000a1a948845309dd166d811123d8d74bbad4894"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0047","unitRef":"u24"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:abf41d18dd23b1f74069e723564729e7b301e4bbbc95cbd3407d92ee9e10a9fc","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4723858a27075d6ac6ef24e2","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:abf41d18dd23b1f74069e723564729e7b301e4bbbc95cbd3407d92ee9e10a9fc","textSha256":"73df5aa06aecb117c78b4979000a1a948845309dd166d811123d8d74bbad4894"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:88af226b2067d7e51c0e4520"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:88af226b2067d7e51c0e4520","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:abf41d18dd23b1f74069e723564729e7b301e4bbbc95cbd3407d92ee9e10a9fc","q025-candidate-question:4723858a27075d6ac6ef24e2"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec0627bb3f8ba5bb12bb5357002d42915d2118ab1b983a214350ae2ba581c00c","contributionContentSha256":"290cd273e01b248f1c54b9c888a709fb4eb42013a17502eb3e847c8db37259f6","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-proposal","leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:abf41d18dd23b1f74069e723564729e7b301e4bbbc95cbd3407d92ee9e10a9fc","textSha256":"73df5aa06aecb117c78b4979000a1a948845309dd166d811123d8d74bbad4894"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:88af226b2067d7e51c0e4520","recordId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound justification of approximations, initial conditions, predictions and energy transfer.","challengeNote":"Compound microscopic justification, initial conditions, fluctuation predictions and energy-transfer targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c4fa1b7c68eabb7edca73c17a973433c5b69481951e76eeb8b84e70f8e7e4570","home":{"unitId":"unit:c4fa1b7c68eabb7edca73c17a973433c5b69481951e76eeb8b84e70f8e7e4570","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:6fe3fe07f985ff9858ad3c06","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q15 covers initial inflationary histories, model stability and flatness, reheating, and conditional predictions under differing cosmological histories.","qualification":"q15 covers initial preparation, potential protection, reheating and conditional predictions across different cosmological histories. The regional-prediction target remains explicit rather than being reduced to ordinary mode evolution. No common regional dynamics, measure or probability prescription is assumed.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c4fa1b7c68eabb7edca73c17a973433c5b69481951e76eeb8b84e70f8e7e4570","paperId":"0708.2865","textSha256":"0091b4f899d069b218a76f8a4bc13a5bfd937d0bc54dbd8e9779a1b48328c79f"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0047:u25:q15"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0047:u25:q15","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c4fa1b7c68eabb7edca73c17a973433c5b69481951e76eeb8b84e70f8e7e4570","q025-candidate-region:6fe3fe07f985ff9858ad3c06"],"scopeContentSha256":"c5d83fce0f112ee76c63471cc6b77e91727b2c50991735d7d9eef02c83a58d19","placementContentSha256":"f809340e0f84556828ed7fa7565f6f0e8bed902d605948728ca9ff1b7d00abe3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0047:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0047:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c4fa1b7c68eabb7edca73c17a973433c5b69481951e76eeb8b84e70f8e7e4570","paperId":"0708.2865","textSha256":"0091b4f899d069b218a76f8a4bc13a5bfd937d0bc54dbd8e9779a1b48328c79f"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0047","unitRef":"u25"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c4fa1b7c68eabb7edca73c17a973433c5b69481951e76eeb8b84e70f8e7e4570","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:4723858a27075d6ac6ef24e2","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:c4fa1b7c68eabb7edca73c17a973433c5b69481951e76eeb8b84e70f8e7e4570","textSha256":"0091b4f899d069b218a76f8a4bc13a5bfd937d0bc54dbd8e9779a1b48328c79f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:493313000ff43ab01d86c2e1"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:493313000ff43ab01d86c2e1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c4fa1b7c68eabb7edca73c17a973433c5b69481951e76eeb8b84e70f8e7e4570","q025-candidate-question:4723858a27075d6ac6ef24e2"],"scopeContentSha256":"ec0627bb3f8ba5bb12bb5357002d42915d2118ab1b983a214350ae2ba581c00c","contributionContentSha256":"9b74997aec43ce92c6d0ea12a93d85ee7c2fdf3d54dac6d6077457a5df12d6e3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-proposal","leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d2","kind":"description","unitIndex":2,"unitId":"unit:c4fa1b7c68eabb7edca73c17a973433c5b69481951e76eeb8b84e70f8e7e4570","textSha256":"0091b4f899d069b218a76f8a4bc13a5bfd937d0bc54dbd8e9779a1b48328c79f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:493313000ff43ab01d86c2e1","recordId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1ddd8c662faffd2b9587-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound initial-condition, flatness, reheating and causally separated-region prediction targets require reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Compound initial-condition, flatness, reheating and regional-prediction targets require finer reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"5a1f5f56e9454f0cb8214b943ef9c5f3658bd4b237b840bb20757744db952a8a"},"organizational-access:a4bbe251db48c177a44dd8f5":{"id":"organizational-access:a4bbe251db48c177a44dd8f5","source":"q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a","target":"q025-candidate-question:11bfeda5ad2753a4e283af62","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"2cedf2781e2953afce1e2340444d42ab59eae346b7d35bce9676fa98db3f3973","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:739782e7c50cd229ce148b16"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:11bfeda5ad2753a4e283af62","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"25a958db163169598f00d01d2d887ba5ad847a8f88e806921aef8aca0bce9ac8","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:3aadb8cf7cdb4922d00fc54f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","home":{"unitId":"unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","paperId":"1508.04144","textSha256":"551dfb3f309e125642963c9666177436f278790ac0993480c07faaf86a5d4e7c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:02c8183e7a1db3187e49d932"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:02c8183e7a1db3187e49d932","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a"],"scopeContentSha256":"2cedf2781e2953afce1e2340444d42ab59eae346b7d35bce9676fa98db3f3973","placementContentSha256":"f74de0abe2aad2406f720e4e65c9be0e8b06727a764315e5ad926a976918035c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge","leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","paperId":"1508.04144","textSha256":"551dfb3f309e125642963c9666177436f278790ac0993480c07faaf86a5d4e7c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:02c8183e7a1db3187e49d932"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:11bfeda5ad2753a4e283af62","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d56","kind":"description","unitIndex":56,"unitId":"unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","textSha256":"551dfb3f309e125642963c9666177436f278790ac0993480c07faaf86a5d4e7c"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1b77eca9fd772b472ed3d39027b043e0","paperId":"1508.04144","sourceSha256":"801ddd0bd62396a9748598808cb5f9b3ac0fb2c0496e372937de6cbabc75afab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/88deb16563ce190cdcb9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b798f55423f3e0f41a41ee301a0f26d228c37fd10a195cb3bb34a1ec1f25f6c2","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"8f9f2f739e142446143a489359c344e5cee6c2010bc380f23fea860866c337fa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3c2530218f8e559151cca03dd88295f8","paperId":"1508.04144","sourceSha256":"801ddd0bd62396a9748598808cb5f9b3ac0fb2c0496e372937de6cbabc75afab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/88deb16563ce190cdcb9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b798f55423f3e0f41a41ee301a0f26d228c37fd10a195cb3bb34a1ec1f25f6c2","pdfPage":2,"start":1286,"end":4672,"textSha256":"3d15b6cc5935469ffa792f0336c9c7cf884efecbda701220f1fd0345e74fb4df","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fbfff173a7f96cbc6bd6b00489179179","paperId":"1508.04144","sourceSha256":"801ddd0bd62396a9748598808cb5f9b3ac0fb2c0496e372937de6cbabc75afab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/88deb16563ce190cdcb9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b798f55423f3e0f41a41ee301a0f26d228c37fd10a195cb3bb34a1ec1f25f6c2","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a30c4628c6102b8c0bbb49a478304d9f2b4b77a0495ab859824e74d425f75cde","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8fca9480f42b76b09e903cb6","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Despite its outside-probe label, this directly connects late-modulus reheating with joint abundances. Vertex baryon conservation and R-parity are model-specific Independent challenge qualification: Directly connects late-modulus reheating and joint abundances despite the outside-probe label. Vertex baryon conservation, R-parity and symmetric-component "},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8fca9480f42b76b09e903cb6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","q025-candidate-question:11bfeda5ad2753a4e283af62"],"scopeContentSha256":"25a958db163169598f00d01d2d887ba5ad847a8f88e806921aef8aca0bce9ac8","contributionContentSha256":"dec8c58f381c79f2031e0877ade6ac0c9c3887d98de4069bb1e77d478d821e22","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-proposal","leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d56","kind":"description","unitIndex":56,"unitId":"unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","textSha256":"551dfb3f309e125642963c9666177436f278790ac0993480c07faaf86a5d4e7c"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1b77eca9fd772b472ed3d39027b043e0","paperId":"1508.04144","sourceSha256":"801ddd0bd62396a9748598808cb5f9b3ac0fb2c0496e372937de6cbabc75afab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/88deb16563ce190cdcb9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b798f55423f3e0f41a41ee301a0f26d228c37fd10a195cb3bb34a1ec1f25f6c2","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"8f9f2f739e142446143a489359c344e5cee6c2010bc380f23fea860866c337fa","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e6","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3c2530218f8e559151cca03dd88295f8","paperId":"1508.04144","sourceSha256":"801ddd0bd62396a9748598808cb5f9b3ac0fb2c0496e372937de6cbabc75afab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/88deb16563ce190cdcb9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b798f55423f3e0f41a41ee301a0f26d228c37fd10a195cb3bb34a1ec1f25f6c2","pdfPage":2,"start":1286,"end":4672,"textSha256":"3d15b6cc5935469ffa792f0336c9c7cf884efecbda701220f1fd0345e74fb4df","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e24","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fbfff173a7f96cbc6bd6b00489179179","paperId":"1508.04144","sourceSha256":"801ddd0bd62396a9748598808cb5f9b3ac0fb2c0496e372937de6cbabc75afab","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/88deb16563ce190cdcb9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"b798f55423f3e0f41a41ee301a0f26d228c37fd10a195cb3bb34a1ec1f25f6c2","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"a30c4628c6102b8c0bbb49a478304d9f2b4b77a0495ab859824e74d425f75cde","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8fca9480f42b76b09e903cb6","recordId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-32512ec22b7a8f790253-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Despite its outside-probe label, this directly connects late-modulus reheating with joint abundances. Vertex baryon conservation and R-parity are model-specific","challengeNote":"Directly connects late-modulus reheating and joint abundances despite the outside-probe label. Vertex baryon conservation, R-parity and symmetric-component ","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"3d310afeb71caa8ed82263ea389975b1549cf97594a6ee67df0c6f7e8a8e24c6"},"organizational-access:6f75b7c04ced2c56edcdea4a":{"id":"organizational-access:6f75b7c04ced2c56edcdea4a","source":"q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a","target":"q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"2cedf2781e2953afce1e2340444d42ab59eae346b7d35bce9676fa98db3f3973","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:739782e7c50cd229ce148b16"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c6b2e1dc8872ff9d9e38fe4d82925ec53f7c9dc611beff73b482d13b7b3279c5","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:a2e4fca4ce2f4d96b9a42ef7"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","home":{"unitId":"unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","paperId":"1508.04144","textSha256":"551dfb3f309e125642963c9666177436f278790ac0993480c07faaf86a5d4e7c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:02c8183e7a1db3187e49d932"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:02c8183e7a1db3187e49d932","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a"],"scopeContentSha256":"2cedf2781e2953afce1e2340444d42ab59eae346b7d35bce9676fa98db3f3973","placementContentSha256":"f74de0abe2aad2406f720e4e65c9be0e8b06727a764315e5ad926a976918035c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge","leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","paperId":"1508.04144","textSha256":"551dfb3f309e125642963c9666177436f278790ac0993480c07faaf86a5d4e7c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:02c8183e7a1db3187e49d932"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","textSha256":"551dfb3f309e125642963c9666177436f278790ac0993480c07faaf86a5d4e7c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5b6558002c1f3f67ae199c0c","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound visible and dark asymmetry generation at GeV reheating, with baryon-conserving vertices. Independent challenge qualification: Joint visible/dark asymmetry generation at GeV reheating with baryon-conserving vertices."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:5b6558002c1f3f67ae199c0c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c"],"scopeContentSha256":"c6b2e1dc8872ff9d9e38fe4d82925ec53f7c9dc611beff73b482d13b7b3279c5","contributionContentSha256":"4cdb4fe9585fcc5bb931faf45d09c36eb945ac58f73a6f238e63599b0ad58397","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:6c95cc45baa85b1673bbe078df7f2a95f948641d7475ed3c0a93a8de7618bb10","textSha256":"551dfb3f309e125642963c9666177436f278790ac0993480c07faaf86a5d4e7c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:5b6558002c1f3f67ae199c0c","recordId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound visible and dark asymmetry generation at GeV reheating, with baryon-conserving vertices.","challengeNote":"Joint visible/dark asymmetry generation at GeV reheating with baryon-conserving vertices.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:93e9fd67f1a42aeed6cf34020522ef2cda2998b28c161743ee91ef38aa89b137","home":{"unitId":"unit:93e9fd67f1a42aeed6cf34020522ef2cda2998b28c161743ee91ef38aa89b137","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:93e9fd67f1a42aeed6cf34020522ef2cda2998b28c161743ee91ef38aa89b137","paperId":"1207.2771","textSha256":"18e4714bd1c698f4c35b4c647d526516c685cdf8f228eee4c2e05fdb067c37db"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8e930e4da7308adc3ed2fb27"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8e930e4da7308adc3ed2fb27","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:93e9fd67f1a42aeed6cf34020522ef2cda2998b28c161743ee91ef38aa89b137","q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a"],"scopeContentSha256":"2cedf2781e2953afce1e2340444d42ab59eae346b7d35bce9676fa98db3f3973","placementContentSha256":"96da8dd6b6634c6f5f6fea322ac4c47c4687bd7fe9e04701311b56f7a70a76ba","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge","leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:93e9fd67f1a42aeed6cf34020522ef2cda2998b28c161743ee91ef38aa89b137","paperId":"1207.2771","textSha256":"18e4714bd1c698f4c35b4c647d526516c685cdf8f228eee4c2e05fdb067c37db"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8e930e4da7308adc3ed2fb27"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:93e9fd67f1a42aeed6cf34020522ef2cda2998b28c161743ee91ef38aa89b137","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:93e9fd67f1a42aeed6cf34020522ef2cda2998b28c161743ee91ef38aa89b137","textSha256":"18e4714bd1c698f4c35b4c647d526516c685cdf8f228eee4c2e05fdb067c37db"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d828cdb440515409377b2c89","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound scope also includes Q-ball formation and enhanced inflaton–AD couplings. Independent challenge qualification: Compound scope also retains Q-balls and enhanced inflaton–AD couplings."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d828cdb440515409377b2c89","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:93e9fd67f1a42aeed6cf34020522ef2cda2998b28c161743ee91ef38aa89b137","q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c"],"scopeContentSha256":"c6b2e1dc8872ff9d9e38fe4d82925ec53f7c9dc611beff73b482d13b7b3279c5","contributionContentSha256":"27ed0ccc384efad77206826b2e18210466f0390d19551443c8dd2e618221776a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d10","kind":"description","unitIndex":10,"unitId":"unit:93e9fd67f1a42aeed6cf34020522ef2cda2998b28c161743ee91ef38aa89b137","textSha256":"18e4714bd1c698f4c35b4c647d526516c685cdf8f228eee4c2e05fdb067c37db"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d828cdb440515409377b2c89","recordId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound scope also includes Q-ball formation and enhanced inflaton–AD couplings.","challengeNote":"Compound scope also retains Q-balls and enhanced inflaton–AD couplings.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a2984727dd94401649bcc01005538019d158f676a57d990613ae344d81618cbf","home":{"unitId":"unit:a2984727dd94401649bcc01005538019d158f676a57d990613ae344d81618cbf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a2984727dd94401649bcc01005538019d158f676a57d990613ae344d81618cbf","paperId":"1604.03120","textSha256":"fb3e535aa10c6ad6c098ae490bdb9121fe4f0884a3b7bd7caededb5b300f7d78"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f11d3469e4b15960a453d9ae"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f11d3469e4b15960a453d9ae","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a2984727dd94401649bcc01005538019d158f676a57d990613ae344d81618cbf","q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a"],"scopeContentSha256":"2cedf2781e2953afce1e2340444d42ab59eae346b7d35bce9676fa98db3f3973","placementContentSha256":"6b50c224b3912ae0f78aba3a96e50874c4e3ef541c5a7caef06fbd713123abea","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge","leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a2984727dd94401649bcc01005538019d158f676a57d990613ae344d81618cbf","paperId":"1604.03120","textSha256":"fb3e535aa10c6ad6c098ae490bdb9121fe4f0884a3b7bd7caededb5b300f7d78"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f11d3469e4b15960a453d9ae"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a2984727dd94401649bcc01005538019d158f676a57d990613ae344d81618cbf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:a2984727dd94401649bcc01005538019d158f676a57d990613ae344d81618cbf","textSha256":"fb3e535aa10c6ad6c098ae490bdb9121fe4f0884a3b7bd7caededb5b300f7d78"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b762edcea7568a38a8bce45c","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Joint embedding target: inflationary tachyonic mass, positive late masses and asymmetry surviving dilution. Independent challenge qualification: Compound embedding target: inflationary tachyonic mass, positive late masses and asymmetry surviving dilution."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b762edcea7568a38a8bce45c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a2984727dd94401649bcc01005538019d158f676a57d990613ae344d81618cbf","q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c"],"scopeContentSha256":"c6b2e1dc8872ff9d9e38fe4d82925ec53f7c9dc611beff73b482d13b7b3279c5","contributionContentSha256":"485b7b9efc3741e273a522f24c05cdf07c6d4e56a7573066e839f41f230cacaf","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d28","kind":"description","unitIndex":28,"unitId":"unit:a2984727dd94401649bcc01005538019d158f676a57d990613ae344d81618cbf","textSha256":"fb3e535aa10c6ad6c098ae490bdb9121fe4f0884a3b7bd7caededb5b300f7d78"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b762edcea7568a38a8bce45c","recordId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Joint embedding target: inflationary tachyonic mass, positive late masses and asymmetry surviving dilution.","challengeNote":"Compound embedding target: inflationary tachyonic mass, positive late masses and asymmetry surviving dilution.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ac36205563daf4202f4e9f37ea58874f0aeb0b9c3ee1f9e1a6d13a8779652faf","home":{"unitId":"unit:ac36205563daf4202f4e9f37ea58874f0aeb0b9c3ee1f9e1a6d13a8779652faf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ac36205563daf4202f4e9f37ea58874f0aeb0b9c3ee1f9e1a6d13a8779652faf","paperId":"1108.5178","textSha256":"a3a8901ba9908619710e138e884124e229c59fd73d6d9cec1b95af6f8a4a3a96"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6f366530fb7cde65e1221f77"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6f366530fb7cde65e1221f77","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ac36205563daf4202f4e9f37ea58874f0aeb0b9c3ee1f9e1a6d13a8779652faf","q025-candidate-region:70d75ef9abfe7226ec3f9a4a"],"scopeContentSha256":"2cedf2781e2953afce1e2340444d42ab59eae346b7d35bce9676fa98db3f3973","placementContentSha256":"4fcf076a8417ffcc53e496ca0e86ca57b52653928fcbb8a12c0b7d6ff3c388b5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge","leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ac36205563daf4202f4e9f37ea58874f0aeb0b9c3ee1f9e1a6d13a8779652faf","paperId":"1108.5178","textSha256":"a3a8901ba9908619710e138e884124e229c59fd73d6d9cec1b95af6f8a4a3a96"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:6f366530fb7cde65e1221f77"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ac36205563daf4202f4e9f37ea58874f0aeb0b9c3ee1f9e1a6d13a8779652faf","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:ac36205563daf4202f4e9f37ea58874f0aeb0b9c3ee1f9e1a6d13a8779652faf","textSha256":"a3a8901ba9908619710e138e884124e229c59fd73d6d9cec1b95af6f8a4a3a96"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7c1dd1c97358eaec1bd697d1","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound target: dilute an excessive earlier AD asymmetry while producing nonthermal LSPs. Independent challenge qualification: Joint dilution of excessive earlier AD asymmetry and production of nonthermal LSPs."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7c1dd1c97358eaec1bd697d1","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ac36205563daf4202f4e9f37ea58874f0aeb0b9c3ee1f9e1a6d13a8779652faf","q025-candidate-question:1230807946a715bc01e2c34c"],"scopeContentSha256":"c6b2e1dc8872ff9d9e38fe4d82925ec53f7c9dc611beff73b482d13b7b3279c5","contributionContentSha256":"0f70cb9e2606b0d030bd1a269e468b4caca4560ba4532c6fa48ac30a9efce4a1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:ac36205563daf4202f4e9f37ea58874f0aeb0b9c3ee1f9e1a6d13a8779652faf","textSha256":"a3a8901ba9908619710e138e884124e229c59fd73d6d9cec1b95af6f8a4a3a96"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7c1dd1c97358eaec1bd697d1","recordId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-a07f87c80964ac1def6a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Compound target: dilute an excessive earlier AD asymmetry while producing nonthermal LSPs.","challengeNote":"Joint dilution of excessive earlier AD asymmetry and production of nonthermal LSPs.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":4,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4c1e3d0668943702ed9717b70b7d9bdd347d015f9c0959c449c3fec98e599c4c"},"organizational-access:5f262af1e7790fef49551783":{"id":"organizational-access:5f262af1e7790fef49551783","source":"q025-candidate-region:81066fcb454d8f1a3a7754dd","target":"q025-candidate-question:24b94aefd795da3b08c511f4","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:81066fcb454d8f1a3a7754dd","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"925dd4dc8120dfbc46f6bfbac0710713a1238b06073d14a618528ae1f968f1f6","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0b66cecf09332982408b26e7"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:24b94aefd795da3b08c511f4","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"05e9dc31365639b2ce1003f5709f95da4fc94d43b4d5f3b189d4cd0131c4abb8","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2fbca62fb2c481a65279b5d3"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:dac25c35a47fdf989c735cba4561387c01d49c880c7334bcf1040897ace31885","home":{"unitId":"unit:dac25c35a47fdf989c735cba4561387c01d49c880c7334bcf1040897ace31885","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:81066fcb454d8f1a3a7754dd","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"The admitted region explicitly retains this compound ALP/cloud question and permits separately identified nongravitational signatures.","qualification":"q36 expressly retains the compound ALP/cloud source with separate branches. It covers nongravitational matter-power signatures comparatively and direct cloud-transition gravitational radiation substantively, without asserting a common mechanism or a string-GW signal.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:dac25c35a47fdf989c735cba4561387c01d49c880c7334bcf1040897ace31885","paperId":"2608.23789","textSha256":"b1b9a906f2db49d4047f5ead38a580cc11ca7ccb8bc5cd39dce146c970ece2cc"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0072:u8:q36"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0072:u8:q36","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:dac25c35a47fdf989c735cba4561387c01d49c880c7334bcf1040897ace31885","q025-candidate-region:81066fcb454d8f1a3a7754dd"],"scopeContentSha256":"925dd4dc8120dfbc46f6bfbac0710713a1238b06073d14a618528ae1f968f1f6","placementContentSha256":"645d5057c28a1e278ab0d15ad5a1567930814f1894b13dadd4050272ad6cd3b1","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0072:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0072:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:dac25c35a47fdf989c735cba4561387c01d49c880c7334bcf1040897ace31885","paperId":"2608.23789","textSha256":"b1b9a906f2db49d4047f5ead38a580cc11ca7ccb8bc5cd39dce146c970ece2cc"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0072","unitRef":"u8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:dac25c35a47fdf989c735cba4561387c01d49c880c7334bcf1040897ace31885","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:24b94aefd795da3b08c511f4","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:dac25c35a47fdf989c735cba4561387c01d49c880c7334bcf1040897ace31885","textSha256":"b1b9a906f2db49d4047f5ead38a580cc11ca7ccb8bc5cd39dce146c970ece2cc"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:574f10f23a0a2448014c9269"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:574f10f23a0a2448014c9269","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:dac25c35a47fdf989c735cba4561387c01d49c880c7334bcf1040897ace31885","q025-candidate-question:24b94aefd795da3b08c511f4"],"scopeContentSha256":"05e9dc31365639b2ce1003f5709f95da4fc94d43b4d5f3b189d4cd0131c4abb8","contributionContentSha256":"7d1089eaddc961426df6f3d77329648b68ba98f4f694d5ec9c2bf86e27dff198","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-proposal","leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:dac25c35a47fdf989c735cba4561387c01d49c880c7334bcf1040897ace31885","textSha256":"b1b9a906f2db49d4047f5ead38a580cc11ca7ccb8bc5cd39dce146c970ece2cc"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:574f10f23a0a2448014c9269","recordId":"leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48be7b1d737cd42fe141-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Unresolved compound identity: string-emitted ALP matter power and direct cloud-transition GWs are separate targets; no string-GW signal is asserted.","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound identity: string-emitted ALP matter power and binary-cloud transition GWs are separate targets; no string-GW branch is supplied.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"bd8132af40d79bd6e3e0e7651419c4fa32cca13ae6601815f1d7627264b7edb7"},"organizational-access:6b25f93a3b1a4a3cf38b4507":{"id":"organizational-access:6b25f93a3b1a4a3cf38b4507","source":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","target":"q025-candidate-question:2064d452abd633e46ee9dab6","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0725de22166d9fb2ff8caea8"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:2064d452abd633e46ee9dab6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"c6a7f4aafa31b6a90b7596464ad77464aff3a0575caac0b1e59f623577984235","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:98c7350216c9e3f0205882b0"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:11d8ecc9fb6def1d7a502d5d55709b8a49e21fd0dfe691d9b4e726f26057d4e4","home":{"unitId":"unit:11d8ecc9fb6def1d7a502d5d55709b8a49e21fd0dfe691d9b4e726f26057d4e4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:11d8ecc9fb6def1d7a502d5d55709b8a49e21fd0dfe691d9b4e726f26057d4e4","paperId":"2012.00013","textSha256":"1dd39fc3e50f1e286ca920abda24866e8d042d171d775ab3b394738d6869e0c1"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c55a9797d86017920ea87921"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c55a9797d86017920ea87921","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:11d8ecc9fb6def1d7a502d5d55709b8a49e21fd0dfe691d9b4e726f26057d4e4","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"959c7fe463eea56da7fc66306a772f190c78c89dab39489b394a243eac535627","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:11d8ecc9fb6def1d7a502d5d55709b8a49e21fd0dfe691d9b4e726f26057d4e4","paperId":"2012.00013","textSha256":"1dd39fc3e50f1e286ca920abda24866e8d042d171d775ab3b394738d6869e0c1"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:c55a9797d86017920ea87921"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:11d8ecc9fb6def1d7a502d5d55709b8a49e21fd0dfe691d9b4e726f26057d4e4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2064d452abd633e46ee9dab6","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d79","kind":"description","unitIndex":79,"unitId":"unit:11d8ecc9fb6def1d7a502d5d55709b8a49e21fd0dfe691d9b4e726f26057d4e4","textSha256":"1dd39fc3e50f1e286ca920abda24866e8d042d171d775ab3b394738d6869e0c1"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e415912cd94272455b9ec175"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e415912cd94272455b9ec175","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:11d8ecc9fb6def1d7a502d5d55709b8a49e21fd0dfe691d9b4e726f26057d4e4","q025-candidate-question:2064d452abd633e46ee9dab6"],"scopeContentSha256":"c6a7f4aafa31b6a90b7596464ad77464aff3a0575caac0b1e59f623577984235","contributionContentSha256":"2a6ea7dbec3e4f40addbf918893c3681f9cccc751539c1dfa003d3fb0ad6c005","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d79","kind":"description","unitIndex":79,"unitId":"unit:11d8ecc9fb6def1d7a502d5d55709b8a49e21fd0dfe691d9b4e726f26057d4e4","textSha256":"1dd39fc3e50f1e286ca920abda24866e8d042d171d775ab3b394738d6869e0c1"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e415912cd94272455b9ec175","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:aaa39aa867c2a2c06f371744a24780020d9152ae24d7d508cd335be2dec98a18","home":{"unitId":"unit:aaa39aa867c2a2c06f371744a24780020d9152ae24d7d508cd335be2dec98a18","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:aaa39aa867c2a2c06f371744a24780020d9152ae24d7d508cd335be2dec98a18","paperId":"1909.10355","textSha256":"0720bde080317a9ebc6421acc600becd36e7908a4aa2bbc8511e7e970ef4cef3"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ea6dbb3779dd82689f6071c3"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ea6dbb3779dd82689f6071c3","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:aaa39aa867c2a2c06f371744a24780020d9152ae24d7d508cd335be2dec98a18","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"10ec5e0a979e9f5facee1877eaecf0f2462f2d2328165e1549a4ed1fc25aae9b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:aaa39aa867c2a2c06f371744a24780020d9152ae24d7d508cd335be2dec98a18","paperId":"1909.10355","textSha256":"0720bde080317a9ebc6421acc600becd36e7908a4aa2bbc8511e7e970ef4cef3"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ea6dbb3779dd82689f6071c3"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:aaa39aa867c2a2c06f371744a24780020d9152ae24d7d508cd335be2dec98a18","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:2064d452abd633e46ee9dab6","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:aaa39aa867c2a2c06f371744a24780020d9152ae24d7d508cd335be2dec98a18","textSha256":"0720bde080317a9ebc6421acc600becd36e7908a4aa2bbc8511e7e970ef4cef3"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6a28afb2d3ad454cfcf9d4c8"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:6a28afb2d3ad454cfcf9d4c8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:aaa39aa867c2a2c06f371744a24780020d9152ae24d7d508cd335be2dec98a18","q025-candidate-question:2064d452abd633e46ee9dab6"],"scopeContentSha256":"c6a7f4aafa31b6a90b7596464ad77464aff3a0575caac0b1e59f623577984235","contributionContentSha256":"31cf2025135503c9c0ce0e0f1e17b5861d5eb506692058af4f2bec8db6dc30ec","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:aaa39aa867c2a2c06f371744a24780020d9152ae24d7d508cd335be2dec98a18","textSha256":"0720bde080317a9ebc6421acc600becd36e7908a4aa2bbc8511e7e970ef4cef3"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:6a28afb2d3ad454cfcf9d4c8","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Additional elliptic data alter the tangential structure; the ordinary spin hemisphere remains the comparison obstruction.","challengeNote":"Additional elliptic data change the tangential structure; the ordinary spin hemisphere is the obstructed comparison.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"59ab9eecbf83ceac0ec5991beeec7d8c71de4a3b39ad3fa44bb1d5be1a2bce74"},"organizational-access:6181f5aa4a2554e056808373":{"id":"organizational-access:6181f5aa4a2554e056808373","source":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","target":"q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:0725de22166d9fb2ff8caea8"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b0182bc61aaa90c9e39d667fafc29feaf99f7e8f8f6fb948a5797ab7c6c8d41a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:072a852bfd2db0ce0fd05226"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:06ca809811821b4610d0520d2b52c2eb82f47e3c15fbe4885f742df6e194dc68","home":{"unitId":"unit:06ca809811821b4610d0520d2b52c2eb82f47e3c15fbe4885f742df6e194dc68","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"The region covers geometric construction records and dimension-specific anomaly tests in one compactification question.","qualification":"q23 covers both record-oriented compact fivefold constructions and gravitational anomaly tests in 2d (0,2) F-theory. Smooth and singular fourfold bases remain distinct regimes. The record claim stays source-era and construction-dependent; neither a universal maximum nor sufficiency of anomaly cancellation follows.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:06ca809811821b4610d0520d2b52c2eb82f47e3c15fbe4885f742df6e194dc68","paperId":"2009.10668","textSha256":"0b148a650eb4885df397d0a450d3e3381865da8208d7be5c5bc17c615d7b77f4"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0006:u23:q23"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0006:u23:q23","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:06ca809811821b4610d0520d2b52c2eb82f47e3c15fbe4885f742df6e194dc68","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"d0bfc984be8c63b39e29eadf8dc40d599a69895092cc0c229a143b9a0bcf2b70","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0006:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0006:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-01"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:06ca809811821b4610d0520d2b52c2eb82f47e3c15fbe4885f742df6e194dc68","paperId":"2009.10668","textSha256":"0b148a650eb4885df397d0a450d3e3381865da8208d7be5c5bc17c615d7b77f4"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"5aa801513aeabdfa5423f7d016f63e93acf2f4ca5ef692c73b0be6ac405d2b54"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-01/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"dc1cf62cd026cfcb2701ef5bd7aa9c2ddfad0950711732a66f26c796b071502b","bytes":4051638,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0006","unitRef":"u23"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:06ca809811821b4610d0520d2b52c2eb82f47e3c15fbe4885f742df6e194dc68","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d78","kind":"description","unitIndex":78,"unitId":"unit:06ca809811821b4610d0520d2b52c2eb82f47e3c15fbe4885f742df6e194dc68","textSha256":"0b148a650eb4885df397d0a450d3e3381865da8208d7be5c5bc17c615d7b77f4"},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a3a6a48a84a6ee7c1e767fc2289279a8","paperId":"2009.10668","sourceSha256":"866b2c71c73e7d89b289ba3d740688082fa901bd1694cca84c825e02ff76b128","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e73017008d3790f83c14/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f262c51efec7142491050d78c47f82a725be2c27895c663dba6d31cda5aaf920","pdfPage":4,"start":92,"end":3027,"textSha256":"4e472eb558a51385f81eafc79b42f52f5ea3bf84d68cff2d1d04efac9a1cb037","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f4988deb7f88496ebfce5221942b7378","paperId":"2009.10668","sourceSha256":"866b2c71c73e7d89b289ba3d740688082fa901bd1694cca84c825e02ff76b128","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e73017008d3790f83c14/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f262c51efec7142491050d78c47f82a725be2c27895c663dba6d31cda5aaf920","pdfPage":3,"start":103,"end":2611,"textSha256":"862cc8793abbf7544dd9b39c644554d7b9f123f939d712685835249bba59d57e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:37f15f5cf2462e5256ac950b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:37f15f5cf2462e5256ac950b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:06ca809811821b4610d0520d2b52c2eb82f47e3c15fbe4885f742df6e194dc68","q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902"],"scopeContentSha256":"b0182bc61aaa90c9e39d667fafc29feaf99f7e8f8f6fb948a5797ab7c6c8d41a","contributionContentSha256":"e4e696ca55a30b46a1fdc61fb90cfec473c5c2b4a8a34e01ca68689d674f3976","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d78","kind":"description","unitIndex":78,"unitId":"unit:06ca809811821b4610d0520d2b52c2eb82f47e3c15fbe4885f742df6e194dc68","textSha256":"0b148a650eb4885df397d0a450d3e3381865da8208d7be5c5bc17c615d7b77f4"},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:a3a6a48a84a6ee7c1e767fc2289279a8","paperId":"2009.10668","sourceSha256":"866b2c71c73e7d89b289ba3d740688082fa901bd1694cca84c825e02ff76b128","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e73017008d3790f83c14/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f262c51efec7142491050d78c47f82a725be2c27895c663dba6d31cda5aaf920","pdfPage":4,"start":92,"end":3027,"textSha256":"4e472eb558a51385f81eafc79b42f52f5ea3bf84d68cff2d1d04efac9a1cb037","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f4988deb7f88496ebfce5221942b7378","paperId":"2009.10668","sourceSha256":"866b2c71c73e7d89b289ba3d740688082fa901bd1694cca84c825e02ff76b128","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e73017008d3790f83c14/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"f262c51efec7142491050d78c47f82a725be2c27895c663dba6d31cda5aaf920","pdfPage":3,"start":103,"end":2611,"textSha256":"862cc8793abbf7544dd9b39c644554d7b9f123f939d712685835249bba59d57e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:37f15f5cf2462e5256ac950b","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Record geometric field content and anomaly tests are distinct targets. The restricted hypersurface search and singular-base contributions do not establish a 2D ","challengeNote":"The 2020 records and anomaly checks are distinct targets. The degree-limited hypersurface study and singular-base contributions do not establish a universal 2D ","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:50ebe5f7384b22730362ffd66d8b7a84862d258f1cd9482a6e096bfc5d52c03f","home":{"unitId":"unit:50ebe5f7384b22730362ffd66d8b7a84862d258f1cd9482a6e096bfc5d52c03f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:50ebe5f7384b22730362ffd66d8b7a84862d258f1cd9482a6e096bfc5d52c03f","paperId":"1802.04802","textSha256":"58b62359b2f402836cf2671ee56f805683f2885e1a9d29a7fa716ef8450107a8"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:af0a3f645da461b8a9c2b981"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:af0a3f645da461b8a9c2b981","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:50ebe5f7384b22730362ffd66d8b7a84862d258f1cd9482a6e096bfc5d52c03f","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"c8e1477fc0abb2d13ee5cec5780f148d00aa8cee20990be27d18b47cdcfc54a4","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:50ebe5f7384b22730362ffd66d8b7a84862d258f1cd9482a6e096bfc5d52c03f","paperId":"1802.04802","textSha256":"58b62359b2f402836cf2671ee56f805683f2885e1a9d29a7fa716ef8450107a8"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:af0a3f645da461b8a9c2b981"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:50ebe5f7384b22730362ffd66d8b7a84862d258f1cd9482a6e096bfc5d52c03f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:50ebe5f7384b22730362ffd66d8b7a84862d258f1cd9482a6e096bfc5d52c03f","textSha256":"58b62359b2f402836cf2671ee56f805683f2885e1a9d29a7fa716ef8450107a8"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b1fac2b373622ff02d2efb67"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b1fac2b373622ff02d2efb67","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:50ebe5f7384b22730362ffd66d8b7a84862d258f1cd9482a6e096bfc5d52c03f","q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902"],"scopeContentSha256":"b0182bc61aaa90c9e39d667fafc29feaf99f7e8f8f6fb948a5797ab7c6c8d41a","contributionContentSha256":"1c3779de87bfd686d71f796ee6e8a2ecbc341e5dc0ed87f502948a3633e84915","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:50ebe5f7384b22730362ffd66d8b7a84862d258f1cd9482a6e096bfc5d52c03f","textSha256":"58b62359b2f402836cf2671ee56f805683f2885e1a9d29a7fa716ef8450107a8"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b1fac2b373622ff02d2efb67","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:527707884d7697b3442c44b216be8c8c73585ad48398e7383c7395587a7c3ce8","home":{"unitId":"unit:527707884d7697b3442c44b216be8c8c73585ad48398e7383c7395587a7c3ce8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:527707884d7697b3442c44b216be8c8c73585ad48398e7383c7395587a7c3ce8","paperId":"2210.09473","textSha256":"9ad259c458b4c6e7cd377d9e21f51eb23833174566af90f14b9b66b181be264d"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc62eef969f650561e090a65"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc62eef969f650561e090a65","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:527707884d7697b3442c44b216be8c8c73585ad48398e7383c7395587a7c3ce8","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"105a472e76d573718d9e79a52ee3f30f19a834c4a61b1f883f2a8fbc8b7c3b66","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:527707884d7697b3442c44b216be8c8c73585ad48398e7383c7395587a7c3ce8","paperId":"2210.09473","textSha256":"9ad259c458b4c6e7cd377d9e21f51eb23833174566af90f14b9b66b181be264d"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:bc62eef969f650561e090a65"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:527707884d7697b3442c44b216be8c8c73585ad48398e7383c7395587a7c3ce8","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d105","kind":"description","unitIndex":105,"unitId":"unit:527707884d7697b3442c44b216be8c8c73585ad48398e7383c7395587a7c3ce8","textSha256":"9ad259c458b4c6e7cd377d9e21f51eb23833174566af90f14b9b66b181be264d"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d0f6d6f63c1d96334114268f"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d0f6d6f63c1d96334114268f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:527707884d7697b3442c44b216be8c8c73585ad48398e7383c7395587a7c3ce8","q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902"],"scopeContentSha256":"b0182bc61aaa90c9e39d667fafc29feaf99f7e8f8f6fb948a5797ab7c6c8d41a","contributionContentSha256":"cb3dd6d1d671c4568675c76138ab939499b4ff2d3865e72e095fc490e1486425","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d105","kind":"description","unitIndex":105,"unitId":"unit:527707884d7697b3442c44b216be8c8c73585ad48398e7383c7395587a7c3ce8","textSha256":"9ad259c458b4c6e7cd377d9e21f51eb23833174566af90f14b9b66b181be264d"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d0f6d6f63c1d96334114268f","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Admitting all anomaly-free linear families and restricting their multiplicities are different tests.","challengeNote":"Access to all anomaly-free linear families and constraints on their multiplicities are separate tests.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a35b025de42f378947aec6cb46cdef8b3d5d33f8dda06e23f8a363d6681e1e72","home":{"unitId":"unit:a35b025de42f378947aec6cb46cdef8b3d5d33f8dda06e23f8a363d6681e1e72","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a35b025de42f378947aec6cb46cdef8b3d5d33f8dda06e23f8a363d6681e1e72","paperId":"1805.03214","textSha256":"6c2f383f885f0f5743306f29cd469a0f01d49ebb2d2996863ac63a1b3c28a204"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:767854d2198509012b26fe43"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:767854d2198509012b26fe43","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a35b025de42f378947aec6cb46cdef8b3d5d33f8dda06e23f8a363d6681e1e72","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"08f06e11e5f300910c38e6be06eb786d3ab40a4c9c43da3fe0fab4c0847e3821","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a35b025de42f378947aec6cb46cdef8b3d5d33f8dda06e23f8a363d6681e1e72","paperId":"1805.03214","textSha256":"6c2f383f885f0f5743306f29cd469a0f01d49ebb2d2996863ac63a1b3c28a204"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:767854d2198509012b26fe43"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a35b025de42f378947aec6cb46cdef8b3d5d33f8dda06e23f8a363d6681e1e72","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:a35b025de42f378947aec6cb46cdef8b3d5d33f8dda06e23f8a363d6681e1e72","textSha256":"6c2f383f885f0f5743306f29cd469a0f01d49ebb2d2996863ac63a1b3c28a204"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8c67d94a4b403f84a1ed055c"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8c67d94a4b403f84a1ed055c","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a35b025de42f378947aec6cb46cdef8b3d5d33f8dda06e23f8a363d6681e1e72","q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902"],"scopeContentSha256":"b0182bc61aaa90c9e39d667fafc29feaf99f7e8f8f6fb948a5797ab7c6c8d41a","contributionContentSha256":"5607101435bd15a343c749c07adf81ac10d917bca4ca0cb447c08aeab3c77215","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d42","kind":"description","unitIndex":42,"unitId":"unit:a35b025de42f378947aec6cb46cdef8b3d5d33f8dda06e23f8a363d6681e1e72","textSha256":"6c2f383f885f0f5743306f29cd469a0f01d49ebb2d2996863ac63a1b3c28a204"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8c67d94a4b403f84a1ed055c","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:a6876fc5c9a0252b5d420345d4e2dbe9c3d014438946eb52f7866ded0ada5e71","home":{"unitId":"unit:a6876fc5c9a0252b5d420345d4e2dbe9c3d014438946eb52f7866ded0ada5e71","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a6876fc5c9a0252b5d420345d4e2dbe9c3d014438946eb52f7866ded0ada5e71","paperId":"1709.06609","textSha256":"87a0d7ba6b4bd5f4e674b955df2d3f556f27b9083b137187126cd146c299acd7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2945254a6de7b6ec5ddfba55"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2945254a6de7b6ec5ddfba55","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a6876fc5c9a0252b5d420345d4e2dbe9c3d014438946eb52f7866ded0ada5e71","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"031a62fa8f11bd584d60b1483b8acc7d9a595982c39392f269fe01cd3a853739","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:a6876fc5c9a0252b5d420345d4e2dbe9c3d014438946eb52f7866ded0ada5e71","paperId":"1709.06609","textSha256":"87a0d7ba6b4bd5f4e674b955df2d3f556f27b9083b137187126cd146c299acd7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2945254a6de7b6ec5ddfba55"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:a6876fc5c9a0252b5d420345d4e2dbe9c3d014438946eb52f7866ded0ada5e71","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d35","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:a6876fc5c9a0252b5d420345d4e2dbe9c3d014438946eb52f7866ded0ada5e71","textSha256":"87a0d7ba6b4bd5f4e674b955df2d3f556f27b9083b137187126cd146c299acd7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e8b06d808470f252b7d168cc"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e8b06d808470f252b7d168cc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:a6876fc5c9a0252b5d420345d4e2dbe9c3d014438946eb52f7866ded0ada5e71","q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902"],"scopeContentSha256":"b0182bc61aaa90c9e39d667fafc29feaf99f7e8f8f6fb948a5797ab7c6c8d41a","contributionContentSha256":"614b0565f8051067edf173a9c58b176e3d7ec9ba849b8beb874c06a6b44654df","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d35","kind":"description","unitIndex":35,"unitId":"unit:a6876fc5c9a0252b5d420345d4e2dbe9c3d014438946eb52f7866ded0ada5e71","textSha256":"87a0d7ba6b4bd5f4e674b955df2d3f556f27b9083b137187126cd146c299acd7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e8b06d808470f252b7d168cc","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"A proposed flux-GUT embedding is an additional target beyond the six-dimensional spectrum.","challengeNote":"Flux-GUT embedding is an additional target beyond the six-dimensional spectrum and anomalies.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:bb149664d0ef7c6d2ea1020c0d2e69dedec5bc692a77f52cbaec5aeda633406d","home":{"unitId":"unit:bb149664d0ef7c6d2ea1020c0d2e69dedec5bc692a77f52cbaec5aeda633406d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bb149664d0ef7c6d2ea1020c0d2e69dedec5bc692a77f52cbaec5aeda633406d","paperId":"1901.02012","textSha256":"327811bd21d1d6a26de96d7b85b00b47e261464a02157323b718a0bd7f5755ff"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ce3ea1cbfdfbcc1014a00f23"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ce3ea1cbfdfbcc1014a00f23","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bb149664d0ef7c6d2ea1020c0d2e69dedec5bc692a77f52cbaec5aeda633406d","q025-candidate-region:839da90831bec9d6ef0a811b"],"scopeContentSha256":"6511a5e9f7efbb35770bffbc5f2c2070b04b5152e8d0973843321d7dfa169a06","placementContentSha256":"5c1dd8412be02c9e4d98972259f8b8d1d1c040a78a471619ef90032eb9d2fef3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bb149664d0ef7c6d2ea1020c0d2e69dedec5bc692a77f52cbaec5aeda633406d","paperId":"1901.02012","textSha256":"327811bd21d1d6a26de96d7b85b00b47e261464a02157323b718a0bd7f5755ff"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ce3ea1cbfdfbcc1014a00f23"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bb149664d0ef7c6d2ea1020c0d2e69dedec5bc692a77f52cbaec5aeda633406d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d53","kind":"description","unitIndex":53,"unitId":"unit:bb149664d0ef7c6d2ea1020c0d2e69dedec5bc692a77f52cbaec5aeda633406d","textSha256":"327811bd21d1d6a26de96d7b85b00b47e261464a02157323b718a0bd7f5755ff"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4d64bbff9eb4ecb555844da9"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4d64bbff9eb4ecb555844da9","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bb149664d0ef7c6d2ea1020c0d2e69dedec5bc692a77f52cbaec5aeda633406d","q025-candidate-question:a928f60cf7531abc8e9f8902"],"scopeContentSha256":"b0182bc61aaa90c9e39d667fafc29feaf99f7e8f8f6fb948a5797ab7c6c8d41a","contributionContentSha256":"dc154116960204f867548073ce57c3accff0679424d66e8137a980e7bc73b547","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d53","kind":"description","unitIndex":53,"unitId":"unit:bb149664d0ef7c6d2ea1020c0d2e69dedec5bc692a77f52cbaec5aeda633406d","textSha256":"327811bd21d1d6a26de96d7b85b00b47e261464a02157323b718a0bd7f5755ff"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4d64bbff9eb4ecb555844da9","recordId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f3d0ef8dd184e0ce2e9a-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Existence of an admissible spectrum is not silently replaced by existence of the fundamental–adjoint spectrum.","challengeNote":"Existence of an admissible spectrum and existence of a fundamental–adjoint spectrum are distinct statements.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":6,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"c946dbc1ee3708b0c764b46a6d657530eb5ec5de3574af7b5cfbacb536d0ff42"},"organizational-access:63d7d0039c63102a9890cc81":{"id":"organizational-access:63d7d0039c63102a9890cc81","source":"q025-candidate-region:88fa8687d2ded4f0a4462ab0","target":"q025-candidate-question:0a56e8ec715aba106b43abf5","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:88fa8687d2ded4f0a4462ab0","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"32801060108ad7e3abd0a9f853eef8166d108c2000fbc9eb31b178761a4b958b","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:9e510c8a5c395d59ce2ef3d0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:0a56e8ec715aba106b43abf5","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f09d4c06ead13b86190780b0c361933785684ff53d042d39b3458798dd67e582","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:fbef59546fd1db229afd6705"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:5e345ae19ffde267e9877634c9c24f0651d42b9ba5d0f28070824123449ec388","home":{"unitId":"unit:5e345ae19ffde267e9877634c9c24f0651d42b9ba5d0f28070824123449ec388","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:88fa8687d2ded4f0a4462ab0","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5e345ae19ffde267e9877634c9c24f0651d42b9ba5d0f28070824123449ec388","paperId":"2202.12840","textSha256":"66d5f2fbd283cddb070048c5c5d09dacbb092d4f5f106fa155ddc592f460e768"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1959639df0ee4f55eb9f4e3b0dd86ce8","paperId":"2202.12840","sourceSha256":"ffe0b9cd71e15919a20b45756930b023a199b2e72760f513d6ad5c4cb07c2918","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/03cbaf5a249df7cc4e55/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2030b2f8dcd6f0444dbf8b7c18f1e110ad7cd9da3b0270c632577ba42671a516","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3495,"textSha256":"80fc013ae3939944654a8fee24aa12cb01bf87a82f5fd1dc009da9d3e7f3b5d9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d824034ab54f4921d837334c7cdbef4b","paperId":"2202.12840","sourceSha256":"ffe0b9cd71e15919a20b45756930b023a199b2e72760f513d6ad5c4cb07c2918","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/03cbaf5a249df7cc4e55/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2030b2f8dcd6f0444dbf8b7c18f1e110ad7cd9da3b0270c632577ba42671a516","pdfPage":17,"start":1301,"end":3940,"textSha256":"9ace9f12c74dea14627ed17a10c5de712b7062d6ded3849edf34723b4625f6c6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e84c1ac0101f9c6c3754436eda1fd789","paperId":"2202.12840","sourceSha256":"ffe0b9cd71e15919a20b45756930b023a199b2e72760f513d6ad5c4cb07c2918","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/03cbaf5a249df7cc4e55/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2030b2f8dcd6f0444dbf8b7c18f1e110ad7cd9da3b0270c632577ba42671a516","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"75a5e3c8409027883909585fe35be7b39f51ef90476bd3d9502f7f02572871b5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:88d02fdf97745aec1537a073"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:88d02fdf97745aec1537a073","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5e345ae19ffde267e9877634c9c24f0651d42b9ba5d0f28070824123449ec388","q025-candidate-region:88fa8687d2ded4f0a4462ab0"],"scopeContentSha256":"32801060108ad7e3abd0a9f853eef8166d108c2000fbc9eb31b178761a4b958b","placementContentSha256":"0b1f9f469877b6fbc59f004f355d539a1cd1a2ef8cac99699c87ac272b9772a1","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-challenge","leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5e345ae19ffde267e9877634c9c24f0651d42b9ba5d0f28070824123449ec388","paperId":"2202.12840","textSha256":"66d5f2fbd283cddb070048c5c5d09dacbb092d4f5f106fa155ddc592f460e768"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1959639df0ee4f55eb9f4e3b0dd86ce8","paperId":"2202.12840","sourceSha256":"ffe0b9cd71e15919a20b45756930b023a199b2e72760f513d6ad5c4cb07c2918","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/03cbaf5a249df7cc4e55/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2030b2f8dcd6f0444dbf8b7c18f1e110ad7cd9da3b0270c632577ba42671a516","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3495,"textSha256":"80fc013ae3939944654a8fee24aa12cb01bf87a82f5fd1dc009da9d3e7f3b5d9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d824034ab54f4921d837334c7cdbef4b","paperId":"2202.12840","sourceSha256":"ffe0b9cd71e15919a20b45756930b023a199b2e72760f513d6ad5c4cb07c2918","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/03cbaf5a249df7cc4e55/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2030b2f8dcd6f0444dbf8b7c18f1e110ad7cd9da3b0270c632577ba42671a516","pdfPage":17,"start":1301,"end":3940,"textSha256":"9ace9f12c74dea14627ed17a10c5de712b7062d6ded3849edf34723b4625f6c6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e84c1ac0101f9c6c3754436eda1fd789","paperId":"2202.12840","sourceSha256":"ffe0b9cd71e15919a20b45756930b023a199b2e72760f513d6ad5c4cb07c2918","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/03cbaf5a249df7cc4e55/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2030b2f8dcd6f0444dbf8b7c18f1e110ad7cd9da3b0270c632577ba42671a516","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"75a5e3c8409027883909585fe35be7b39f51ef90476bd3d9502f7f02572871b5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:88d02fdf97745aec1537a073"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5e345ae19ffde267e9877634c9c24f0651d42b9ba5d0f28070824123449ec388","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0a56e8ec715aba106b43abf5","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:5e345ae19ffde267e9877634c9c24f0651d42b9ba5d0f28070824123449ec388","textSha256":"66d5f2fbd283cddb070048c5c5d09dacbb092d4f5f106fa155ddc592f460e768"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1959639df0ee4f55eb9f4e3b0dd86ce8","paperId":"2202.12840","sourceSha256":"ffe0b9cd71e15919a20b45756930b023a199b2e72760f513d6ad5c4cb07c2918","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/03cbaf5a249df7cc4e55/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2030b2f8dcd6f0444dbf8b7c18f1e110ad7cd9da3b0270c632577ba42671a516","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3495,"textSha256":"80fc013ae3939944654a8fee24aa12cb01bf87a82f5fd1dc009da9d3e7f3b5d9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d824034ab54f4921d837334c7cdbef4b","paperId":"2202.12840","sourceSha256":"ffe0b9cd71e15919a20b45756930b023a199b2e72760f513d6ad5c4cb07c2918","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/03cbaf5a249df7cc4e55/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2030b2f8dcd6f0444dbf8b7c18f1e110ad7cd9da3b0270c632577ba42671a516","pdfPage":17,"start":1301,"end":3940,"textSha256":"9ace9f12c74dea14627ed17a10c5de712b7062d6ded3849edf34723b4625f6c6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e84c1ac0101f9c6c3754436eda1fd789","paperId":"2202.12840","sourceSha256":"ffe0b9cd71e15919a20b45756930b023a199b2e72760f513d6ad5c4cb07c2918","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/03cbaf5a249df7cc4e55/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2030b2f8dcd6f0444dbf8b7c18f1e110ad7cd9da3b0270c632577ba42671a516","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"75a5e3c8409027883909585fe35be7b39f51ef90476bd3d9502f7f02572871b5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b550ce6da0bfe0dc6066ea03"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b550ce6da0bfe0dc6066ea03","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5e345ae19ffde267e9877634c9c24f0651d42b9ba5d0f28070824123449ec388","q025-candidate-question:0a56e8ec715aba106b43abf5"],"scopeContentSha256":"f09d4c06ead13b86190780b0c361933785684ff53d042d39b3458798dd67e582","contributionContentSha256":"965daa4d03cdf3d0207e53eb883884ffecc2be8079bb3d00345f02d940668bb7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-proposal","leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:5e345ae19ffde267e9877634c9c24f0651d42b9ba5d0f28070824123449ec388","textSha256":"66d5f2fbd283cddb070048c5c5d09dacbb092d4f5f106fa155ddc592f460e768"},{"localRef":"e3","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:1959639df0ee4f55eb9f4e3b0dd86ce8","paperId":"2202.12840","sourceSha256":"ffe0b9cd71e15919a20b45756930b023a199b2e72760f513d6ad5c4cb07c2918","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/03cbaf5a249df7cc4e55/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2030b2f8dcd6f0444dbf8b7c18f1e110ad7cd9da3b0270c632577ba42671a516","pdfPage":3,"start":97,"end":3495,"textSha256":"80fc013ae3939944654a8fee24aa12cb01bf87a82f5fd1dc009da9d3e7f3b5d9","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:d824034ab54f4921d837334c7cdbef4b","paperId":"2202.12840","sourceSha256":"ffe0b9cd71e15919a20b45756930b023a199b2e72760f513d6ad5c4cb07c2918","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/03cbaf5a249df7cc4e55/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2030b2f8dcd6f0444dbf8b7c18f1e110ad7cd9da3b0270c632577ba42671a516","pdfPage":17,"start":1301,"end":3940,"textSha256":"9ace9f12c74dea14627ed17a10c5de712b7062d6ded3849edf34723b4625f6c6","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:e84c1ac0101f9c6c3754436eda1fd789","paperId":"2202.12840","sourceSha256":"ffe0b9cd71e15919a20b45756930b023a199b2e72760f513d6ad5c4cb07c2918","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/03cbaf5a249df7cc4e55/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"2030b2f8dcd6f0444dbf8b7c18f1e110ad7cd9da3b0270c632577ba42671a516","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"75a5e3c8409027883909585fe35be7b39f51ef90476bd3d9502f7f02572871b5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b550ce6da0bfe0dc6066ea03","recordId":"leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound search/control target. One axionic combination remains flat; f23 is the no-go baseline being evaded.","challengeNote":"Compound search/control singleton. One axionic combination remains flat; pf23 is the no-go baseline being evaded, and missing identities remain unresolved.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9160a7381e25d42bd42199be3dbae1171d9ff1720f9e534eacf955399a0e9ec1","home":{"unitId":"unit:9160a7381e25d42bd42199be3dbae1171d9ff1720f9e534eacf955399a0e9ec1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:88fa8687d2ded4f0a4462ab0","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Combines positive-vacuum existence, scalar stability, candidate consistency and conditional challenges to de Sitter conjectures.","qualification":"q30 covers candidate construction, non-tachyonicity, refined-conjecture implications and unresolved microscopic consistency together. q2 concentrates on consistency/control and q9 on conjecture diagnostics; their positive connections do not each establish complete coverage of the joint outlook.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9160a7381e25d42bd42199be3dbae1171d9ff1720f9e534eacf955399a0e9ec1","paperId":"1811.08889","textSha256":"b5cbc8b663cadff6bbba0b895ca3a1c47c45be431ed2301981067f81f7b993ec"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0062:u26:q30"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0062:u26:q30","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9160a7381e25d42bd42199be3dbae1171d9ff1720f9e534eacf955399a0e9ec1","q025-candidate-region:88fa8687d2ded4f0a4462ab0"],"scopeContentSha256":"32801060108ad7e3abd0a9f853eef8166d108c2000fbc9eb31b178761a4b958b","placementContentSha256":"352cc0b41b958e919d31715abe6c765f8ba66fc20bc49229de1134676047c9e5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0062:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0062:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9160a7381e25d42bd42199be3dbae1171d9ff1720f9e534eacf955399a0e9ec1","paperId":"1811.08889","textSha256":"b5cbc8b663cadff6bbba0b895ca3a1c47c45be431ed2301981067f81f7b993ec"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0062","unitRef":"u26"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9160a7381e25d42bd42199be3dbae1171d9ff1720f9e534eacf955399a0e9ec1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:0a56e8ec715aba106b43abf5","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:9160a7381e25d42bd42199be3dbae1171d9ff1720f9e534eacf955399a0e9ec1","textSha256":"b5cbc8b663cadff6bbba0b895ca3a1c47c45be431ed2301981067f81f7b993ec"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3e1cced974c70060c5c264d61708991e","paperId":"1811.08889","sourceSha256":"3c6375214edd0fec8fc45847655e3139db7466bbb426fdcb5261b9629a1ed65a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/60ffa6209cea6dec83d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"663f3fc286c91720fd3d3730c55829ca449881af15ae35d0b1306946b665cf87","pdfPage":15,"start":325,"end":3086,"textSha256":"387cbe10cadf51ebb328f8b761ae49b5274f8b581a3c1c908bf072b1bebd70cb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5373dd91b26e7fcdb9ab5fde684a0f95","paperId":"1811.08889","sourceSha256":"3c6375214edd0fec8fc45847655e3139db7466bbb426fdcb5261b9629a1ed65a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/60ffa6209cea6dec83d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"663f3fc286c91720fd3d3730c55829ca449881af15ae35d0b1306946b665cf87","pdfPage":4,"start":867,"end":3774,"textSha256":"cd0c45e7e038317123d86599d9fe064b0f50a39e2fd8c0f242ffbe46af231a92","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f6ddf95be87b8eb91f84122f319e4e8c","paperId":"1811.08889","sourceSha256":"3c6375214edd0fec8fc45847655e3139db7466bbb426fdcb5261b9629a1ed65a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/60ffa6209cea6dec83d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"663f3fc286c91720fd3d3730c55829ca449881af15ae35d0b1306946b665cf87","pdfPage":4,"start":1098,"end":3774,"textSha256":"6bd45078e60c0a1b93e8f926061bec7fd975ef73ca4e6dce92101075dd96c238","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9c4bb0d4d6a118ec32f2a1c4"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9c4bb0d4d6a118ec32f2a1c4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9160a7381e25d42bd42199be3dbae1171d9ff1720f9e534eacf955399a0e9ec1","q025-candidate-question:0a56e8ec715aba106b43abf5"],"scopeContentSha256":"f09d4c06ead13b86190780b0c361933785684ff53d042d39b3458798dd67e582","contributionContentSha256":"aec685f23c9e720edcfda232a7f3fef7e04fc8f3bb95e9e056542970881c564f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-proposal","leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d5","kind":"description","unitIndex":5,"unitId":"unit:9160a7381e25d42bd42199be3dbae1171d9ff1720f9e534eacf955399a0e9ec1","textSha256":"b5cbc8b663cadff6bbba0b895ca3a1c47c45be431ed2301981067f81f7b993ec"},{"localRef":"e10","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3e1cced974c70060c5c264d61708991e","paperId":"1811.08889","sourceSha256":"3c6375214edd0fec8fc45847655e3139db7466bbb426fdcb5261b9629a1ed65a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/60ffa6209cea6dec83d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"663f3fc286c91720fd3d3730c55829ca449881af15ae35d0b1306946b665cf87","pdfPage":15,"start":325,"end":3086,"textSha256":"387cbe10cadf51ebb328f8b761ae49b5274f8b581a3c1c908bf072b1bebd70cb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5373dd91b26e7fcdb9ab5fde684a0f95","paperId":"1811.08889","sourceSha256":"3c6375214edd0fec8fc45847655e3139db7466bbb426fdcb5261b9629a1ed65a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/60ffa6209cea6dec83d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"663f3fc286c91720fd3d3730c55829ca449881af15ae35d0b1306946b665cf87","pdfPage":4,"start":867,"end":3774,"textSha256":"cd0c45e7e038317123d86599d9fe064b0f50a39e2fd8c0f242ffbe46af231a92","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e26","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:f6ddf95be87b8eb91f84122f319e4e8c","paperId":"1811.08889","sourceSha256":"3c6375214edd0fec8fc45847655e3139db7466bbb426fdcb5261b9629a1ed65a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/60ffa6209cea6dec83d8/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"663f3fc286c91720fd3d3730c55829ca449881af15ae35d0b1306946b665cf87","pdfPage":4,"start":1098,"end":3774,"textSha256":"6bd45078e60c0a1b93e8f926061bec7fd975ef73ca4e6dce92101075dd96c238","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9c4bb0d4d6a118ec32f2a1c4","recordId":"leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-9362f80cb5012707a1cc-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":3,"proposalNote":"Compound outlook on KK-source and anti-brane routes; no common fine identity or controlled realization established.","challengeNote":"Unresolved compound outlook: KK-source and anti-brane routes have different consistency and control gaps. The combined inequality is contextual conjecture.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"bc5ef0bba15aa405e4e6dde31fb1b2db80c5f2c0c9b4cec694fad83e64aac02a"},"organizational-access:9aaf8b85fcc1c11eb389d805":{"id":"organizational-access:9aaf8b85fcc1c11eb389d805","source":"q025-candidate-region:8ea1f3c1ebed5c44b2aaf8cb","target":"q025-candidate-question:7b86afd64af222b209e3b53d","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:8ea1f3c1ebed5c44b2aaf8cb","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"7b2d53c35dd299461a9a7dfa92ace817480c6e2a891f11bc1ae1e8f77c461510","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:fc5b9290fc335caa343566a0"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:7b86afd64af222b209e3b53d","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"7bdf63e3a2a1850a23a87155d69151fa7ce8fe870c8764345e84cd8f14c65c61","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:677cfcfa9074e7faece46c00"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:2cadf15aa06c9a02cbcf7db7ac3b36e87568a43f790b8e5bd80fc908d3fa6719","home":{"unitId":"unit:2cadf15aa06c9a02cbcf7db7ac3b36e87568a43f790b8e5bd80fc908d3fa6719","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8ea1f3c1ebed5c44b2aaf8cb","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2cadf15aa06c9a02cbcf7db7ac3b36e87568a43f790b8e5bd80fc908d3fa6719","paperId":"2306.16440","textSha256":"7d80330e13360c6dcf30e6b4036fa85688bcc1325b01a001008d83daa93d4f2b"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ebc56c21e67257b9d8f0dbee"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ebc56c21e67257b9d8f0dbee","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2cadf15aa06c9a02cbcf7db7ac3b36e87568a43f790b8e5bd80fc908d3fa6719","q025-candidate-region:8ea1f3c1ebed5c44b2aaf8cb"],"scopeContentSha256":"7b2d53c35dd299461a9a7dfa92ace817480c6e2a891f11bc1ae1e8f77c461510","placementContentSha256":"5582564019d70cea6e3b620da53d4e635c3a7e1839083da5f7ccfa2594ad0e91","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge","leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2cadf15aa06c9a02cbcf7db7ac3b36e87568a43f790b8e5bd80fc908d3fa6719","paperId":"2306.16440","textSha256":"7d80330e13360c6dcf30e6b4036fa85688bcc1325b01a001008d83daa93d4f2b"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:ebc56c21e67257b9d8f0dbee"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2cadf15aa06c9a02cbcf7db7ac3b36e87568a43f790b8e5bd80fc908d3fa6719","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7b86afd64af222b209e3b53d","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:2cadf15aa06c9a02cbcf7db7ac3b36e87568a43f790b8e5bd80fc908d3fa6719","textSha256":"7d80330e13360c6dcf30e6b4036fa85688bcc1325b01a001008d83daa93d4f2b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:38b6817c1a4eafce0f3afea7"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:38b6817c1a4eafce0f3afea7","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2cadf15aa06c9a02cbcf7db7ac3b36e87568a43f790b8e5bd80fc908d3fa6719","q025-candidate-question:7b86afd64af222b209e3b53d"],"scopeContentSha256":"7bdf63e3a2a1850a23a87155d69151fa7ce8fe870c8764345e84cd8f14c65c61","contributionContentSha256":"694161121786863fdafff4d9d16055003f151e543aa3e82e2a06d0acb54b2765","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-proposal","leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d36","kind":"description","unitIndex":36,"unitId":"unit:2cadf15aa06c9a02cbcf7db7ac3b36e87568a43f790b8e5bd80fc908d3fa6719","textSha256":"7d80330e13360c6dcf30e6b4036fa85688bcc1325b01a001008d83daa93d4f2b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:38b6817c1a4eafce0f3afea7","recordId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Separate conjecture tests share a running-dilaton setting with non-BPS tower masses.","challengeNote":"Distinct conjecture tests share a running-dilaton setting with non-BPS tower masses; singleton status does not make them atomic.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:2df383d423ec490e456e2d19a41af5c6844a50b5246e44aa5273728c8097c997","home":{"unitId":"unit:2df383d423ec490e456e2d19a41af5c6844a50b5246e44aa5273728c8097c997","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:8ea1f3c1ebed5c44b2aaf8cb","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2df383d423ec490e456e2d19a41af5c6844a50b5246e44aa5273728c8097c997","paperId":"2303.13585","textSha256":"c6070cc29de26477cfc5243af47563d6ee865048e1f109cdd934bf29f7ee51e7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2a783d4b84993088aef4cb9c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2a783d4b84993088aef4cb9c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2df383d423ec490e456e2d19a41af5c6844a50b5246e44aa5273728c8097c997","q025-candidate-region:8ea1f3c1ebed5c44b2aaf8cb"],"scopeContentSha256":"7b2d53c35dd299461a9a7dfa92ace817480c6e2a891f11bc1ae1e8f77c461510","placementContentSha256":"3c137fd4117c654c0a89c3cde78d096c5f45cdfa6aee488f2e766635f40d4e3d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge","leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2df383d423ec490e456e2d19a41af5c6844a50b5246e44aa5273728c8097c997","paperId":"2303.13585","textSha256":"c6070cc29de26477cfc5243af47563d6ee865048e1f109cdd934bf29f7ee51e7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:2a783d4b84993088aef4cb9c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2df383d423ec490e456e2d19a41af5c6844a50b5246e44aa5273728c8097c997","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:7b86afd64af222b209e3b53d","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:2df383d423ec490e456e2d19a41af5c6844a50b5246e44aa5273728c8097c997","textSha256":"c6070cc29de26477cfc5243af47563d6ee865048e1f109cdd934bf29f7ee51e7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8d7c671ec457957f7df527a6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:8d7c671ec457957f7df527a6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2df383d423ec490e456e2d19a41af5c6844a50b5246e44aa5273728c8097c997","q025-candidate-question:7b86afd64af222b209e3b53d"],"scopeContentSha256":"7bdf63e3a2a1850a23a87155d69151fa7ce8fe870c8764345e84cd8f14c65c61","contributionContentSha256":"51516160d0c231b0ed5ce8d403d5658827980eccef8244042f2054dc264bbf92","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-proposal","leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d32","kind":"description","unitIndex":32,"unitId":"unit:2df383d423ec490e456e2d19a41af5c6844a50b5246e44aa5273728c8097c997","textSha256":"c6070cc29de26477cfc5243af47563d6ee865048e1f109cdd934bf29f7ee51e7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:8d7c671ec457957f7df527a6","recordId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5eb6694dc3244f2b8e19-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound reconstruction includes enhancement loci and nonperturbative branes; string UV origin is not assumed.","challengeNote":"Compound reconstruction includes enhancement loci and nonperturbative branes; string UV origin is a target, not an assumption.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"86686a85e910c4999b69d5273fc925e9f31c77da3a8c578025f3f94f7e2d4b3c"},"organizational-access:dfddd248ad22c6baad611f64":{"id":"organizational-access:dfddd248ad22c6baad611f64","source":"q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e","target":"q025-candidate-question:75700f88267ddfb782519604","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"7f0d26455f3d8805a4200b0c150bb440a09b6e854e08978c54f94b1829a3370a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:170d19771c86199111bcd0f9"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:75700f88267ddfb782519604","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"3da338caaf853fd6e5a4129afd2370266a26dc4b6df29487463024bb81aa5da9","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:ede63bea9cf21b901163462b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","home":{"unitId":"unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","paperId":"1902.01412","textSha256":"a847680e4ef4efa6d138a688de0d4bc2939f854719e78974b27d632527e52ba1"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:517a95b25c813a0e6bf89950"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:517a95b25c813a0e6bf89950","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e"],"scopeContentSha256":"7f0d26455f3d8805a4200b0c150bb440a09b6e854e08978c54f94b1829a3370a","placementContentSha256":"37b04d579fe00c5cdf84f189d6509e06d787e4a3f3806ecbe249f18107affab8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","paperId":"1902.01412","textSha256":"a847680e4ef4efa6d138a688de0d4bc2939f854719e78974b27d632527e52ba1"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:517a95b25c813a0e6bf89950"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:75700f88267ddfb782519604","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","textSha256":"a847680e4ef4efa6d138a688de0d4bc2939f854719e78974b27d632527e52ba1"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1d2e24e4f6bfbec823d945cc"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1d2e24e4f6bfbec823d945cc","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","q025-candidate-question:75700f88267ddfb782519604"],"scopeContentSha256":"3da338caaf853fd6e5a4129afd2370266a26dc4b6df29487463024bb81aa5da9","contributionContentSha256":"0aa2a682e15636e34e03515869bd9013a2dce445f57305e777fcdead7a7541cb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","textSha256":"a847680e4ef4efa6d138a688de0d4bc2939f854719e78974b27d632527e52ba1"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1d2e24e4f6bfbec823d945cc","recordId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge:p0","proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: integrated consistency and geometric throat fit remain distinct tests.","challengeNote":"Compound: integrated consistency and geometric throat fit remain distinct tests.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4e791ea561eaeca328623079b53f4a6f1cccbbfe3e1815f0bd0c8b9ca5d20f21"},"organizational-access:f3a41b2fc3d1eb53e287fa15":{"id":"organizational-access:f3a41b2fc3d1eb53e287fa15","source":"q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e","target":"q025-candidate-question:ca98a7fe13dd48c0124cfcd6","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"7f0d26455f3d8805a4200b0c150bb440a09b6e854e08978c54f94b1829a3370a","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:170d19771c86199111bcd0f9"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ca98a7fe13dd48c0124cfcd6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"fdb28ecbc180941e9809d24f99d053e393fe9016f0898b39432cb33521c2e93d","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:69b9cc97dc073af10a0b812f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","home":{"unitId":"unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","paperId":"1902.01412","textSha256":"a847680e4ef4efa6d138a688de0d4bc2939f854719e78974b27d632527e52ba1"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:517a95b25c813a0e6bf89950"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:517a95b25c813a0e6bf89950","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e"],"scopeContentSha256":"7f0d26455f3d8805a4200b0c150bb440a09b6e854e08978c54f94b1829a3370a","placementContentSha256":"37b04d579fe00c5cdf84f189d6509e06d787e4a3f3806ecbe249f18107affab8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","paperId":"1902.01412","textSha256":"a847680e4ef4efa6d138a688de0d4bc2939f854719e78974b27d632527e52ba1"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:517a95b25c813a0e6bf89950"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ca98a7fe13dd48c0124cfcd6","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","textSha256":"a847680e4ef4efa6d138a688de0d4bc2939f854719e78974b27d632527e52ba1"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:165a31d9bf5bca9180640976"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:165a31d9bf5bca9180640976","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","q025-candidate-question:ca98a7fe13dd48c0124cfcd6"],"scopeContentSha256":"fdb28ecbc180941e9809d24f99d053e393fe9016f0898b39432cb33521c2e93d","contributionContentSha256":"5722e1e6db4cdb5ea9ed211094b94b3f0b0aa22a765a8dc467f924858385ed3a","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:057f5aaf622d0c4d5bbdb46b663a7970381ed1c977680c87b2e4b15ba0dc4d67","textSha256":"a847680e4ef4efa6d138a688de0d4bc2939f854719e78974b27d632527e52ba1"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:165a31d9bf5bca9180640976","recordId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: integrated consistency and geometric throat fit remain distinct tests.","challengeNote":"Compound: integrated consistency and geometric throat fit remain distinct tests.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:4996df8b45164f798ec522bbe858c9ef806b2728092a97fa513c7413df26c262","home":{"unitId":"unit:4996df8b45164f798ec522bbe858c9ef806b2728092a97fa513c7413df26c262","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4996df8b45164f798ec522bbe858c9ef806b2728092a97fa513c7413df26c262","paperId":"2206.08400","textSha256":"c3cb1e6a2cb6d74bdb6ffb43b689ab79d3c4a4ff6626a4068a76716dc7bc9096"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:de312ee0d2e3fb1e668391ef"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:de312ee0d2e3fb1e668391ef","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4996df8b45164f798ec522bbe858c9ef806b2728092a97fa513c7413df26c262","q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e"],"scopeContentSha256":"7f0d26455f3d8805a4200b0c150bb440a09b6e854e08978c54f94b1829a3370a","placementContentSha256":"82f8d880baea1fcbad28d7db442c662894bf579f11436b31622c058b3ffe22ff","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:4996df8b45164f798ec522bbe858c9ef806b2728092a97fa513c7413df26c262","paperId":"2206.08400","textSha256":"c3cb1e6a2cb6d74bdb6ffb43b689ab79d3c4a4ff6626a4068a76716dc7bc9096"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:de312ee0d2e3fb1e668391ef"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:4996df8b45164f798ec522bbe858c9ef806b2728092a97fa513c7413df26c262","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ca98a7fe13dd48c0124cfcd6","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:4996df8b45164f798ec522bbe858c9ef806b2728092a97fa513c7413df26c262","textSha256":"c3cb1e6a2cb6d74bdb6ffb43b689ab79d3c4a4ff6626a4068a76716dc7bc9096"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2a04ae9d9fc1d396c76638db"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:2a04ae9d9fc1d396c76638db","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:4996df8b45164f798ec522bbe858c9ef806b2728092a97fa513c7413df26c262","q025-candidate-question:ca98a7fe13dd48c0124cfcd6"],"scopeContentSha256":"fdb28ecbc180941e9809d24f99d053e393fe9016f0898b39432cb33521c2e93d","contributionContentSha256":"7c34c101fe76680f966b555e7d7c04b7f72b7f0e03d78d34d9a26c2a5d9cb2d3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d15","kind":"description","unitIndex":15,"unitId":"unit:4996df8b45164f798ec522bbe858c9ef806b2728092a97fa513c7413df26c262","textSha256":"c3cb1e6a2cb6d74bdb6ffb43b689ab79d3c4a4ff6626a4068a76716dc7bc9096"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:2a04ae9d9fc1d396c76638db","recordId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound: small-W0 generation, global compatibility and scale control require separate reconciliation.","challengeNote":"Compound: small-W0 generation, global compatibility and scale control require separate reconciliation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","home":{"unitId":"unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","paperId":"2010.15903","textSha256":"d4dd85c73e441f19a809b9e3c6345592d20ba52264841afb4ad5c4399eadd688"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f29ba2f3a825a219be912888"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f29ba2f3a825a219be912888","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e"],"scopeContentSha256":"7f0d26455f3d8805a4200b0c150bb440a09b6e854e08978c54f94b1829a3370a","placementContentSha256":"679457bce5f4d1e5db6a86deac33bb064c1b8c5aa76b14448631aa98b6d728a7","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","paperId":"2010.15903","textSha256":"d4dd85c73e441f19a809b9e3c6345592d20ba52264841afb4ad5c4399eadd688"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f29ba2f3a825a219be912888"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ca98a7fe13dd48c0124cfcd6","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","textSha256":"d4dd85c73e441f19a809b9e3c6345592d20ba52264841afb4ad5c4399eadd688"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e810f149a76450b3ee41fd33"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e810f149a76450b3ee41fd33","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","q025-candidate-question:ca98a7fe13dd48c0124cfcd6"],"scopeContentSha256":"fdb28ecbc180941e9809d24f99d053e393fe9016f0898b39432cb33521c2e93d","contributionContentSha256":"6b404cf7b145e8342029f8e208a6ecf4439616e4ad03a644048ee182204e1e63","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d11","kind":"description","unitIndex":11,"unitId":"unit:9b24ff5c79c615f2e15114b54fd6f755d50ad6e19d873000d87630d60bb8dad4","textSha256":"d4dd85c73e441f19a809b9e3c6345592d20ba52264841afb4ad5c4399eadd688"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e810f149a76450b3ee41fd33","recordId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","home":{"unitId":"unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","paperId":"2201.03572","textSha256":"3743f66644ef863f841b437f55e159dd1ef0772d8062583ac9ecaff7fd9c6d1e"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:836a660e84ec56d272949370"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:836a660e84ec56d272949370","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","q025-candidate-region:96135ae9eda9f2d91aa85b1e"],"scopeContentSha256":"7f0d26455f3d8805a4200b0c150bb440a09b6e854e08978c54f94b1829a3370a","placementContentSha256":"134e2128823d55fe25b263b1d3981c6a6e02b384ddccb20d0a4c61740fd96a95","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","paperId":"2201.03572","textSha256":"3743f66644ef863f841b437f55e159dd1ef0772d8062583ac9ecaff7fd9c6d1e"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:836a660e84ec56d272949370"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ca98a7fe13dd48c0124cfcd6","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","textSha256":"3743f66644ef863f841b437f55e159dd1ef0772d8062583ac9ecaff7fd9c6d1e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a5bfa0e05c0161a2fa6d3ad6"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a5bfa0e05c0161a2fa6d3ad6","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","q025-candidate-question:ca98a7fe13dd48c0124cfcd6"],"scopeContentSha256":"fdb28ecbc180941e9809d24f99d053e393fe9016f0898b39432cb33521c2e93d","contributionContentSha256":"4df2db0aa5de8d89fa7b285d2ec6201ff3a499a7d33fe360ac553a0217f84199","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d12","kind":"description","unitIndex":12,"unitId":"unit:bce4035397262742d26057790846afa65311fd54f9e0de492c678b879e11a9e5","textSha256":"3743f66644ef863f841b437f55e159dd1ef0772d8062583ac9ecaff7fd9c6d1e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a5bfa0e05c0161a2fa6d3ad6","recordId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge:p2","proposalReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-eb2b14b890c0c74ca5f6-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Setting-derived facet: a single canonical question is unresolved; retaining the conifold field does not establish a vacuum or an LVS identification.","challengeNote":"Setting-derived facet; canonical question identity is unresolved. Its instantiated EFT setting establishes neither an LVS identification nor a vacuum.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":4,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"bca602467417fd0b739ebd7b216a6df51500f19617d0e330cb4e66be2922d295"},"organizational-access:095b1bf022c188ed27f10e92":{"id":"organizational-access:095b1bf022c188ed27f10e92","source":"q025-candidate-region:b21723836524518d4ef91f4c","target":"q025-candidate-question:e2c46e51e88d64a89bd8cdd6","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:b21723836524518d4ef91f4c","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"2c05b569209711ef792ef3d3bf63ce17f619ca3068980d5e54d03e87524b0257","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:79eabfcbe89a6e88145048a6"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:e2c46e51e88d64a89bd8cdd6","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"4e38280bbb321dbb8d37bc5f3eca8dffeb0a15645f6b3190b5825e7a68ca031e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:aea940983ce0b88a4f75feb4"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:01d5373859c12156075de69b4d42a9cdfcb4de10293d297d65713d5a82c1b724","home":{"unitId":"unit:01d5373859c12156075de69b4d42a9cdfcb4de10293d297d65713d5a82c1b724","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b21723836524518d4ef91f4c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:01d5373859c12156075de69b4d42a9cdfcb4de10293d297d65713d5a82c1b724","paperId":"1811.11034","textSha256":"30dcb2e7649be265b4eb9944c66d092f57becb7de532196eee27825ee791a96a"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:572e885b2ddd5fdfb9f29ef9b828ec15","paperId":"1811.11034","sourceSha256":"be71ade63a80d86410551500cd6fbc8ee0fa3cf630f2822e10cdfc0c97de105f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cb9d6513e0b40aeb0db9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8b8ee026c86b2daf8b0fa1192c595db422aa73cbcb541c46021030f129ede31c","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1228,"textSha256":"2bbbd379ff29d2d70256e5e72fb2c451b8fe432839a5b2d993efdc7377db35b3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e27","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fef6e45deab6657b429d358d4b1ae639","paperId":"1811.11034","sourceSha256":"be71ade63a80d86410551500cd6fbc8ee0fa3cf630f2822e10cdfc0c97de105f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cb9d6513e0b40aeb0db9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8b8ee026c86b2daf8b0fa1192c595db422aa73cbcb541c46021030f129ede31c","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2683,"textSha256":"e25a499b73e5d679568d1e3c5638c5e8e02a4da73d5509b7b8429cfb9fb2da70","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dfef3a8d10ce637620020625d9bad2b2","paperId":"1811.11034","sourceSha256":"be71ade63a80d86410551500cd6fbc8ee0fa3cf630f2822e10cdfc0c97de105f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cb9d6513e0b40aeb0db9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8b8ee026c86b2daf8b0fa1192c595db422aa73cbcb541c46021030f129ede31c","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2776,"textSha256":"b33d01e54e878b699067ae503dc726d7397fc4cdce0754ca72241dba872afcb0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:09c86a4a83748e336037347d"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:09c86a4a83748e336037347d","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:01d5373859c12156075de69b4d42a9cdfcb4de10293d297d65713d5a82c1b724","q025-candidate-region:b21723836524518d4ef91f4c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c05b569209711ef792ef3d3bf63ce17f619ca3068980d5e54d03e87524b0257","placementContentSha256":"71528e1c10053f9aa16f7aa4b48af08eab529e1d923e0a1db60d1d270b3449bc","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge","leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:01d5373859c12156075de69b4d42a9cdfcb4de10293d297d65713d5a82c1b724","paperId":"1811.11034","textSha256":"30dcb2e7649be265b4eb9944c66d092f57becb7de532196eee27825ee791a96a"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:572e885b2ddd5fdfb9f29ef9b828ec15","paperId":"1811.11034","sourceSha256":"be71ade63a80d86410551500cd6fbc8ee0fa3cf630f2822e10cdfc0c97de105f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cb9d6513e0b40aeb0db9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8b8ee026c86b2daf8b0fa1192c595db422aa73cbcb541c46021030f129ede31c","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1228,"textSha256":"2bbbd379ff29d2d70256e5e72fb2c451b8fe432839a5b2d993efdc7377db35b3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e27","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fef6e45deab6657b429d358d4b1ae639","paperId":"1811.11034","sourceSha256":"be71ade63a80d86410551500cd6fbc8ee0fa3cf630f2822e10cdfc0c97de105f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cb9d6513e0b40aeb0db9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8b8ee026c86b2daf8b0fa1192c595db422aa73cbcb541c46021030f129ede31c","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2683,"textSha256":"e25a499b73e5d679568d1e3c5638c5e8e02a4da73d5509b7b8429cfb9fb2da70","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dfef3a8d10ce637620020625d9bad2b2","paperId":"1811.11034","sourceSha256":"be71ade63a80d86410551500cd6fbc8ee0fa3cf630f2822e10cdfc0c97de105f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cb9d6513e0b40aeb0db9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8b8ee026c86b2daf8b0fa1192c595db422aa73cbcb541c46021030f129ede31c","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2776,"textSha256":"b33d01e54e878b699067ae503dc726d7397fc4cdce0754ca72241dba872afcb0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:09c86a4a83748e336037347d"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:01d5373859c12156075de69b4d42a9cdfcb4de10293d297d65713d5a82c1b724","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e2c46e51e88d64a89bd8cdd6","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:01d5373859c12156075de69b4d42a9cdfcb4de10293d297d65713d5a82c1b724","textSha256":"30dcb2e7649be265b4eb9944c66d092f57becb7de532196eee27825ee791a96a"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:572e885b2ddd5fdfb9f29ef9b828ec15","paperId":"1811.11034","sourceSha256":"be71ade63a80d86410551500cd6fbc8ee0fa3cf630f2822e10cdfc0c97de105f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cb9d6513e0b40aeb0db9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8b8ee026c86b2daf8b0fa1192c595db422aa73cbcb541c46021030f129ede31c","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1228,"textSha256":"2bbbd379ff29d2d70256e5e72fb2c451b8fe432839a5b2d993efdc7377db35b3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e27","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fef6e45deab6657b429d358d4b1ae639","paperId":"1811.11034","sourceSha256":"be71ade63a80d86410551500cd6fbc8ee0fa3cf630f2822e10cdfc0c97de105f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cb9d6513e0b40aeb0db9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8b8ee026c86b2daf8b0fa1192c595db422aa73cbcb541c46021030f129ede31c","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2683,"textSha256":"e25a499b73e5d679568d1e3c5638c5e8e02a4da73d5509b7b8429cfb9fb2da70","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dfef3a8d10ce637620020625d9bad2b2","paperId":"1811.11034","sourceSha256":"be71ade63a80d86410551500cd6fbc8ee0fa3cf630f2822e10cdfc0c97de105f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cb9d6513e0b40aeb0db9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8b8ee026c86b2daf8b0fa1192c595db422aa73cbcb541c46021030f129ede31c","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2776,"textSha256":"b33d01e54e878b699067ae503dc726d7397fc4cdce0754ca72241dba872afcb0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9da256594a4755e014152b24","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound naturalness/time-arrow essay; explicitly neither a constructive hierarchy solution nor a quantitative early-entropy explanation. Independent challenge qualification: Compound naturalness/time-arrow essay; explicitly no constructive hierarchy solution or quantitative early-entropy explanation."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:9da256594a4755e014152b24","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:01d5373859c12156075de69b4d42a9cdfcb4de10293d297d65713d5a82c1b724","q025-candidate-question:e2c46e51e88d64a89bd8cdd6"],"scopeContentSha256":"4e38280bbb321dbb8d37bc5f3eca8dffeb0a15645f6b3190b5825e7a68ca031e","contributionContentSha256":"17f46d88a34ed2f6a1f87a6637e5d7b0d59e8fd84ff4bbcf3bb8208c56c182f7","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal","leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d4","kind":"description","unitIndex":4,"unitId":"unit:01d5373859c12156075de69b4d42a9cdfcb4de10293d297d65713d5a82c1b724","textSha256":"30dcb2e7649be265b4eb9944c66d092f57becb7de532196eee27825ee791a96a"},{"localRef":"e9","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:572e885b2ddd5fdfb9f29ef9b828ec15","paperId":"1811.11034","sourceSha256":"be71ade63a80d86410551500cd6fbc8ee0fa3cf630f2822e10cdfc0c97de105f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cb9d6513e0b40aeb0db9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8b8ee026c86b2daf8b0fa1192c595db422aa73cbcb541c46021030f129ede31c","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1228,"textSha256":"2bbbd379ff29d2d70256e5e72fb2c451b8fe432839a5b2d993efdc7377db35b3","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e27","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:fef6e45deab6657b429d358d4b1ae639","paperId":"1811.11034","sourceSha256":"be71ade63a80d86410551500cd6fbc8ee0fa3cf630f2822e10cdfc0c97de105f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cb9d6513e0b40aeb0db9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8b8ee026c86b2daf8b0fa1192c595db422aa73cbcb541c46021030f129ede31c","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":2683,"textSha256":"e25a499b73e5d679568d1e3c5638c5e8e02a4da73d5509b7b8429cfb9fb2da70","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e23","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:dfef3a8d10ce637620020625d9bad2b2","paperId":"1811.11034","sourceSha256":"be71ade63a80d86410551500cd6fbc8ee0fa3cf630f2822e10cdfc0c97de105f","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/cb9d6513e0b40aeb0db9/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"8b8ee026c86b2daf8b0fa1192c595db422aa73cbcb541c46021030f129ede31c","pdfPage":3,"start":0,"end":2776,"textSha256":"b33d01e54e878b699067ae503dc726d7397fc4cdce0754ca72241dba872afcb0","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:9da256594a4755e014152b24","recordId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound naturalness/time-arrow essay; explicitly neither a constructive hierarchy solution nor a quantitative early-entropy explanation.","challengeNote":"Compound naturalness/time-arrow essay; explicitly no constructive hierarchy solution or quantitative early-entropy explanation.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:52db2358090481050b01d0ca82e5534b031115de4b3f58c143c73d8371d6fb48","home":{"unitId":"unit:52db2358090481050b01d0ca82e5534b031115de4b3f58c143c73d8371d6fb48","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:b21723836524518d4ef91f4c","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:52db2358090481050b01d0ca82e5534b031115de4b3f58c143c73d8371d6fb48","paperId":"2307.16712","textSha256":"271db1d79b3546b546d48e0700227a4ef5639b3300c0b7f3e7713de004b96e69"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e389c6becf798c7db2bb09d2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e389c6becf798c7db2bb09d2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:52db2358090481050b01d0ca82e5534b031115de4b3f58c143c73d8371d6fb48","q025-candidate-region:b21723836524518d4ef91f4c"],"scopeContentSha256":"2c05b569209711ef792ef3d3bf63ce17f619ca3068980d5e54d03e87524b0257","placementContentSha256":"59961f12ed5535671bc995b5fa2f88ad46e69fe15475ae2a426334d984f6ef4e","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge","leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:52db2358090481050b01d0ca82e5534b031115de4b3f58c143c73d8371d6fb48","paperId":"2307.16712","textSha256":"271db1d79b3546b546d48e0700227a4ef5639b3300c0b7f3e7713de004b96e69"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:e389c6becf798c7db2bb09d2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:52db2358090481050b01d0ca82e5534b031115de4b3f58c143c73d8371d6fb48","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:e2c46e51e88d64a89bd8cdd6","role":"instantiates","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:52db2358090481050b01d0ca82e5534b031115de4b3f58c143c73d8371d6fb48","textSha256":"271db1d79b3546b546d48e0700227a4ef5639b3300c0b7f3e7713de004b96e69"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:14a6f4f71101415ca4f464cb","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Vacuum/Higgs bounds and proposed fermion mass/mixing extensions are related but distinct targets. Independent challenge qualification: Vacuum/Higgs bounds and proposed fermion mass/mixing extensions remain distinct targets."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:14a6f4f71101415ca4f464cb","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:52db2358090481050b01d0ca82e5534b031115de4b3f58c143c73d8371d6fb48","q025-candidate-question:e2c46e51e88d64a89bd8cdd6"],"scopeContentSha256":"4e38280bbb321dbb8d37bc5f3eca8dffeb0a15645f6b3190b5825e7a68ca031e","contributionContentSha256":"8d86129539bfd899c3b209b00576ec03349985ffe94731c20a1e8c0a2d51d323","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal","leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:52db2358090481050b01d0ca82e5534b031115de4b3f58c143c73d8371d6fb48","textSha256":"271db1d79b3546b546d48e0700227a4ef5639b3300c0b7f3e7713de004b96e69"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:14a6f4f71101415ca4f464cb","recordId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge:p5","proposalReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-1c9c910b3bb301762466-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Vacuum/Higgs bounds and proposed fermion mass/mixing extensions are related but distinct targets.","challengeNote":"Vacuum/Higgs bounds and proposed fermion mass/mixing extensions remain distinct targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ada6cafeff1ffe01139d7fca9d97bf63412bb2e2147db5e0a57baa75b1703830"},"organizational-access:677598e3cddf3a0c1e278a0c":{"id":"organizational-access:677598e3cddf3a0c1e278a0c","source":"q025-candidate-region:d0f766169db11c70aacb8911","target":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:d0f766169db11c70aacb8911","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"91b92bbcb0d102489afaf251c5a4ebc8e06ad4ec9d42a0f18f6ef52bcfb28f54","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:f4cba2c585a9e434832a016d"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"0c62cb248ae157b466d10e16f6fe43104cbd02070f364a7cafb72faef0cffa3c","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:2ec69a7706ae99bc2d9e2934"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839","home":{"unitId":"unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:d0f766169db11c70aacb8911","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839","paperId":"2111.01139","textSha256":"a485540ff078f0966491859055000b20c5781c5f15f44c14ff1c51eb6dfc8a64"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:26dda64681d90bec7d6dfcf4"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:26dda64681d90bec7d6dfcf4","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839","q025-candidate-region:d0f766169db11c70aacb8911"],"scopeContentSha256":"91b92bbcb0d102489afaf251c5a4ebc8e06ad4ec9d42a0f18f6ef52bcfb28f54","placementContentSha256":"51e97f64c8b6f348234bb614ce1f45f1ae7a64374bc98cfb4d9faaa48f0753c3","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-c0f344101cf345acf854-challenge","leaf-c0f344101cf345acf854-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839","paperId":"2111.01139","textSha256":"a485540ff078f0966491859055000b20c5781c5f15f44c14ff1c51eb6dfc8a64"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:26dda64681d90bec7d6dfcf4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","qualification":"The conditional obstruction to a trivially gapped infrared phase directly specializes c6's phase constraints. Half-space gauging remains a distinguishable construction target, and no universal obstruction is asserted. Independent confirmation: u36 itself states a conditional infrared obstruction, supporting a specialization of c6 independently of its prior c2 attribution.","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u36","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839","textSha256":"a485540ff078f0966491859055000b20c5781c5f15f44c14ff1c51eb6dfc8a64","paperId":"2111.01139"}],"decisionId":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:role:3"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:navigation-v3:strong-scope-bundle-06:role:3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839","q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c"],"challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-proposal","challengeReviewId":"strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-independent-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-proposal","strong-scope-bundle-06-navigation-independent-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"u36","kind":"description","unitIndex":13,"unitId":"unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839","textSha256":"a485540ff078f0966491859055000b20c5781c5f15f44c14ff1c51eb6dfc8a64","paperId":"2111.01139"}],"originalRole":{"unitRef":"u36","questionRef":"c6","role":"specializes","reason":"The conditional obstruction to a trivially gapped infrared phase directly specializes c6's phase constraints. Half-space gauging remains a distinguishable construction target, and no universal obstruction is asserted.","refs":["u36","c6","n30"]},"independentAssessment":{"index":3,"verdict":"supported_as_written","reason":"u36 itself states a conditional infrared obstruction, supporting a specialization of c6 independently of its prior c2 attribution.","refs":["u36","n30","c6"]},"contextRefs":[{"localRef":"c6","kind":"reviewed_scope","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p4","candidateId":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c"},{"localRef":"n30","kind":"paired_attribution_context","unitId":"unit:bb623db4cf579b9217c42d06d9bddd3740f71589ed5d34507a2c1332163a7839","reviewId":"leaf-c0f344101cf345acf854-challenge","notPrimary":true}],"scopeContentSha256":"0c62cb248ae157b466d10e16f6fe43104cbd02070f364a7cafb72faef0cffa3c","contributionContentSha256":"353547a4fe237160e9268d5e1083a7d74c1008bcbdc0f5ae8688f775a94b9af1","coordinatorAdmissionReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/navigation-admissions-v4/strong-scope-bundle-06-admission.json","sha256":"ed302a756dface517b9e39fd7bb362078094731e22b19e165a290e0cc4027507"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","home":{"unitId":"unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:d0f766169db11c70aacb8911","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers invertible generalized-symmetry definitions and computation together with anomalies, gauging, spontaneous breaking and introductory higher-group organization.","qualification":"q20 covers the entire structural and dynamical program: invertible higher-form and higher-group symmetry, gauging, anomalies and spontaneous breaking. q2 and q9 independently cover only narrower structural portions. Organizational completeness does not imply developed treatment of higher-group anomalies, gauging or breaking, which the annotations explicitly limit.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","paperId":"2307.07547","textSha256":"91596907933a9297d0c1f42cbcc68c2b3ac6e394197b76ed7201f9b7305d32ae"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0030:u12:q20"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0030:u12:q20","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","q025-candidate-region:d0f766169db11c70aacb8911"],"scopeContentSha256":"91b92bbcb0d102489afaf251c5a4ebc8e06ad4ec9d42a0f18f6ef52bcfb28f54","placementContentSha256":"2578e75a1bf6fc279334bb44814b23c68cc025e60f4e73387fed17047472c4b4","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0030:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0030:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","paperId":"2307.07547","textSha256":"91596907933a9297d0c1f42cbcc68c2b3ac6e394197b76ed7201f9b7305d32ae"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0030","unitRef":"u12"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d49","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","textSha256":"91596907933a9297d0c1f42cbcc68c2b3ac6e394197b76ed7201f9b7305d32ae"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3f22cac1cce9db34134b96a4a6ae09c7","paperId":"2307.07547","sourceSha256":"3e97a62f7f9dcfcaa1e6374dee2d0152526ea368f4b3c836a799eddbe306ec31","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e206f2afa29c4e11f785/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0f5e665f33ddf04598d2b684031d436510aa19aa0ed96a99c7a6822accf8bb20","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2351,"textSha256":"e9b9b8dc46fc3702c21e3e48b2fa174aba9035143129ca9c60790ce32bbba607","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9e3da4433c5efd8dad1bd916d562d875","paperId":"2307.07547","sourceSha256":"3e97a62f7f9dcfcaa1e6374dee2d0152526ea368f4b3c836a799eddbe306ec31","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e206f2afa29c4e11f785/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0f5e665f33ddf04598d2b684031d436510aa19aa0ed96a99c7a6822accf8bb20","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1379,"textSha256":"d21cb57b1b04448edd42ff3eee839dd00c220513d70ae088918d8d5ffda79750","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3303176692739055fb3142e8"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:3303176692739055fb3142e8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","q025-candidate-question:3c16774a3e2b5fe8d043246c"],"scopeContentSha256":"0c62cb248ae157b466d10e16f6fe43104cbd02070f364a7cafb72faef0cffa3c","contributionContentSha256":"43c8c5102abce40cf98c085933662991b8565e13170d93041c5c86dcd86ad11b","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d49","kind":"description","unitIndex":49,"unitId":"unit:c53406ac24fc76d9b129a0677f4cc5ed7c99984177cbbcaf696c5ca221a1cd0f","textSha256":"91596907933a9297d0c1f42cbcc68c2b3ac6e394197b76ed7201f9b7305d32ae"},{"localRef":"e8","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:3f22cac1cce9db34134b96a4a6ae09c7","paperId":"2307.07547","sourceSha256":"3e97a62f7f9dcfcaa1e6374dee2d0152526ea368f4b3c836a799eddbe306ec31","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e206f2afa29c4e11f785/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0f5e665f33ddf04598d2b684031d436510aa19aa0ed96a99c7a6822accf8bb20","pdfPage":5,"start":0,"end":2351,"textSha256":"e9b9b8dc46fc3702c21e3e48b2fa174aba9035143129ca9c60790ce32bbba607","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e18","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:9e3da4433c5efd8dad1bd916d562d875","paperId":"2307.07547","sourceSha256":"3e97a62f7f9dcfcaa1e6374dee2d0152526ea368f4b3c836a799eddbe306ec31","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/e206f2afa29c4e11f785/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"0f5e665f33ddf04598d2b684031d436510aa19aa0ed96a99c7a6822accf8bb20","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1379,"textSha256":"d21cb57b1b04448edd42ff3eee839dd00c220513d70ae088918d8d5ffda79750","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:3303176692739055fb3142e8","recordId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-48776508c4bd6798ab21-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"Focus is invertible symmetry. Higher-group properties beyond the introduction are not developed in the stated section.","challengeNote":"Broad lecture program focused on invertible symmetry; the announced higher-group section does not develop its anomaly, gauging or breaking properties.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":2,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"126925fe43229c2f8b9dbcecff63772b4e58ded091bcbb7f65ca1ad4104196f1"},"organizational-access:2abe884965db90a15b29146c":{"id":"organizational-access:2abe884965db90a15b29146c","source":"q025-candidate-region:e2071b6d680aee82e0841323","target":"q025-candidate-question:ad4be2fe9505114449878a2c","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:e2071b6d680aee82e0841323","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"28769b44922504a99e8c01ecc2ade25d25051ab602f73fe071479c2593c5bef7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6baab3338668d6c7bd3bac3d"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:ad4be2fe9505114449878a2c","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"f06559b41f68bb241a3d41451679dbe6f9e24c8c312006ee1dc5593d8eaa62bc","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:15aa345826ae08f6ebb9808f"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:0c5652033ee81cd2de646634f8c98f7593e5f2fcf2572ac4eb50825c18431cd1","home":{"unitId":"unit:0c5652033ee81cd2de646634f8c98f7593e5f2fcf2572ac4eb50825c18431cd1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e2071b6d680aee82e0841323","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0c5652033ee81cd2de646634f8c98f7593e5f2fcf2572ac4eb50825c18431cd1","paperId":"2208.00009","textSha256":"bafdba8e1da83d44ed5cca74254e3666671de6ac145c77e8ba4299a9e3eea9a7"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:93d2c0108134cf08ce1f155b"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:93d2c0108134cf08ce1f155b","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0c5652033ee81cd2de646634f8c98f7593e5f2fcf2572ac4eb50825c18431cd1","q025-candidate-region:e2071b6d680aee82e0841323"],"scopeContentSha256":"28769b44922504a99e8c01ecc2ade25d25051ab602f73fe071479c2593c5bef7","placementContentSha256":"6a8bb998f40572538de98113a71a9597bd925f73d732a975c1147f0696e4b284","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:0c5652033ee81cd2de646634f8c98f7593e5f2fcf2572ac4eb50825c18431cd1","paperId":"2208.00009","textSha256":"bafdba8e1da83d44ed5cca74254e3666671de6ac145c77e8ba4299a9e3eea9a7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:93d2c0108134cf08ce1f155b"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:0c5652033ee81cd2de646634f8c98f7593e5f2fcf2572ac4eb50825c18431cd1","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ad4be2fe9505114449878a2c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:0c5652033ee81cd2de646634f8c98f7593e5f2fcf2572ac4eb50825c18431cd1","textSha256":"bafdba8e1da83d44ed5cca74254e3666671de6ac145c77e8ba4299a9e3eea9a7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7a85d5d65dc851204232539b"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7a85d5d65dc851204232539b","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:0c5652033ee81cd2de646634f8c98f7593e5f2fcf2572ac4eb50825c18431cd1","q025-candidate-question:ad4be2fe9505114449878a2c"],"scopeContentSha256":"f06559b41f68bb241a3d41451679dbe6f9e24c8c312006ee1dc5593d8eaa62bc","contributionContentSha256":"3122b6bab1f63e00a5d19850a78b2c54d3d63bce2e59ee90c7ac36d257d8955c","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:0c5652033ee81cd2de646634f8c98f7593e5f2fcf2572ac4eb50825c18431cd1","textSha256":"bafdba8e1da83d44ed5cca74254e3666671de6ac145c77e8ba4299a9e3eea9a7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7a85d5d65dc851204232539b","recordId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"No critical heterotic string is assumed to emerge; four-dimensional scale control is a separate target.","challengeNote":"No critical heterotic string emerges in the stated test; four-dimensional scale control is a separate target.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:20c3bd57a5896062bd5782a21efbe0ffd3dc04323aa3ce20441d085734d0c418","home":{"unitId":"unit:20c3bd57a5896062bd5782a21efbe0ffd3dc04323aa3ce20441d085734d0c418","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e2071b6d680aee82e0841323","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:20c3bd57a5896062bd5782a21efbe0ffd3dc04323aa3ce20441d085734d0c418","paperId":"2102.01111","textSha256":"61d67dd9ee0b1b41b4d09935189a851667cc34642d4cfd739a7310f54d6a529c"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b1cdc2aa0dc7b38fba372960"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b1cdc2aa0dc7b38fba372960","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:20c3bd57a5896062bd5782a21efbe0ffd3dc04323aa3ce20441d085734d0c418","q025-candidate-region:e2071b6d680aee82e0841323"],"scopeContentSha256":"28769b44922504a99e8c01ecc2ade25d25051ab602f73fe071479c2593c5bef7","placementContentSha256":"a73ac790d6f0e2fc5c7cba388677158c78eef148760691e6454d9ab265fc6d63","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:20c3bd57a5896062bd5782a21efbe0ffd3dc04323aa3ce20441d085734d0c418","paperId":"2102.01111","textSha256":"61d67dd9ee0b1b41b4d09935189a851667cc34642d4cfd739a7310f54d6a529c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b1cdc2aa0dc7b38fba372960"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:20c3bd57a5896062bd5782a21efbe0ffd3dc04323aa3ce20441d085734d0c418","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ad4be2fe9505114449878a2c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:20c3bd57a5896062bd5782a21efbe0ffd3dc04323aa3ce20441d085734d0c418","textSha256":"61d67dd9ee0b1b41b4d09935189a851667cc34642d4cfd739a7310f54d6a529c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ede664196de1b8d733980eb4"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:ede664196de1b8d733980eb4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:20c3bd57a5896062bd5782a21efbe0ffd3dc04323aa3ce20441d085734d0c418","q025-candidate-question:ad4be2fe9505114449878a2c"],"scopeContentSha256":"f06559b41f68bb241a3d41451679dbe6f9e24c8c312006ee1dc5593d8eaa62bc","contributionContentSha256":"53681c3f6e3b3f11e48d6f30f0222d73d0c43aa2e6d670128f431670dc11e59d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d44","kind":"description","unitIndex":44,"unitId":"unit:20c3bd57a5896062bd5782a21efbe0ffd3dc04323aa3ce20441d085734d0c418","textSha256":"61d67dd9ee0b1b41b4d09935189a851667cc34642d4cfd739a7310f54d6a529c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:ede664196de1b8d733980eb4","recordId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Tower identification, potentials, profiles and cosmology remain compound targets.","challengeNote":"Tower identification, potentials, spacetime profiles and cosmology remain compound targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:34db5129dae681c551e263797210df528e67bde3a6144c876ee9807a06548957","home":{"unitId":"unit:34db5129dae681c551e263797210df528e67bde3a6144c876ee9807a06548957","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e2071b6d680aee82e0841323","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:34db5129dae681c551e263797210df528e67bde3a6144c876ee9807a06548957","paperId":"2202.10466","textSha256":"905ae74ebd2a0e403b5210490b83177edf1cdcade2f1de9dd1aa96c0695b43a8"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b6d9c39d18f86c376c192748"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b6d9c39d18f86c376c192748","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:34db5129dae681c551e263797210df528e67bde3a6144c876ee9807a06548957","q025-candidate-region:e2071b6d680aee82e0841323"],"scopeContentSha256":"28769b44922504a99e8c01ecc2ade25d25051ab602f73fe071479c2593c5bef7","placementContentSha256":"ebe8c189559c5eda11054cb332b26edf3157c587f49651b8cc1b4e554e14f568","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:34db5129dae681c551e263797210df528e67bde3a6144c876ee9807a06548957","paperId":"2202.10466","textSha256":"905ae74ebd2a0e403b5210490b83177edf1cdcade2f1de9dd1aa96c0695b43a8"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:b6d9c39d18f86c376c192748"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:34db5129dae681c551e263797210df528e67bde3a6144c876ee9807a06548957","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ad4be2fe9505114449878a2c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:34db5129dae681c551e263797210df528e67bde3a6144c876ee9807a06548957","textSha256":"905ae74ebd2a0e403b5210490b83177edf1cdcade2f1de9dd1aa96c0695b43a8"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4b5a358bb2ac6cd2681588b3"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:4b5a358bb2ac6cd2681588b3","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:34db5129dae681c551e263797210df528e67bde3a6144c876ee9807a06548957","q025-candidate-question:ad4be2fe9505114449878a2c"],"scopeContentSha256":"f06559b41f68bb241a3d41451679dbe6f9e24c8c312006ee1dc5593d8eaa62bc","contributionContentSha256":"fa1eb965841b2431ff14c427afb4620a41d4af813d54a27e8857fb6e19925a0d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d54","kind":"description","unitIndex":54,"unitId":"unit:34db5129dae681c551e263797210df528e67bde3a6144c876ee9807a06548957","textSha256":"905ae74ebd2a0e403b5210490b83177edf1cdcade2f1de9dd1aa96c0695b43a8"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:4b5a358bb2ac6cd2681588b3","recordId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"Global BPS extension and tension bounds away from weak coupling remain linked targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:3f3332596c7d22d2d6ef783c37e45ede3d39cefa32f74632fe2b46ea0f13709b","home":{"unitId":"unit:3f3332596c7d22d2d6ef783c37e45ede3d39cefa32f74632fe2b46ea0f13709b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e2071b6d680aee82e0841323","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3f3332596c7d22d2d6ef783c37e45ede3d39cefa32f74632fe2b46ea0f13709b","paperId":"2607.21700","textSha256":"8dc06eab9e78144b18921e15ba82072485bdc3d76a49a2465c65d24cad649ef6"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f98fd066f6b759e6c1dd6093"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f98fd066f6b759e6c1dd6093","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3f3332596c7d22d2d6ef783c37e45ede3d39cefa32f74632fe2b46ea0f13709b","q025-candidate-region:e2071b6d680aee82e0841323"],"scopeContentSha256":"28769b44922504a99e8c01ecc2ade25d25051ab602f73fe071479c2593c5bef7","placementContentSha256":"08868d19323dd55f51128dc916cac993b294e7a4a10767ccd6978169c7a0df67","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:3f3332596c7d22d2d6ef783c37e45ede3d39cefa32f74632fe2b46ea0f13709b","paperId":"2607.21700","textSha256":"8dc06eab9e78144b18921e15ba82072485bdc3d76a49a2465c65d24cad649ef6"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:f98fd066f6b759e6c1dd6093"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:3f3332596c7d22d2d6ef783c37e45ede3d39cefa32f74632fe2b46ea0f13709b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ad4be2fe9505114449878a2c","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d85","kind":"description","unitIndex":85,"unitId":"unit:3f3332596c7d22d2d6ef783c37e45ede3d39cefa32f74632fe2b46ea0f13709b","textSha256":"8dc06eab9e78144b18921e15ba82072485bdc3d76a49a2465c65d24cad649ef6"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dff29cf7aa0e30d9956740a8"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:dff29cf7aa0e30d9956740a8","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:3f3332596c7d22d2d6ef783c37e45ede3d39cefa32f74632fe2b46ea0f13709b","q025-candidate-question:ad4be2fe9505114449878a2c"],"scopeContentSha256":"f06559b41f68bb241a3d41451679dbe6f9e24c8c312006ee1dc5593d8eaa62bc","contributionContentSha256":"12b5b82368bef63a7401fc8bb37d16dae5a870e4ab61f9d1bf578a222abbbc4f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d85","kind":"description","unitIndex":85,"unitId":"unit:3f3332596c7d22d2d6ef783c37e45ede3d39cefa32f74632fe2b46ea0f13709b","textSha256":"8dc06eab9e78144b18921e15ba82072485bdc3d76a49a2465c65d24cad649ef6"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:dff29cf7aa0e30d9956740a8","recordId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Spectral inference, duality arrangements and potential exclusion are conditional linked targets.","challengeNote":"Spectral inference, duality arrangements and exclusion of Kähler potentials remain conditional linked targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:43e366899f7da3ff10b67ca5fe08b66383a741cb28085d0cc4d19048977a4f2c","home":{"unitId":"unit:43e366899f7da3ff10b67ca5fe08b66383a741cb28085d0cc4d19048977a4f2c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e2071b6d680aee82e0841323","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:43e366899f7da3ff10b67ca5fe08b66383a741cb28085d0cc4d19048977a4f2c","paperId":"2006.15154","textSha256":"d9a0cbeacd16fa677da81353bf41b75dc96de18992392f85e031aac6cc22c088"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d0a8690e788bdffc7f9bd5a7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d0a8690e788bdffc7f9bd5a7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:43e366899f7da3ff10b67ca5fe08b66383a741cb28085d0cc4d19048977a4f2c","q025-candidate-region:e2071b6d680aee82e0841323"],"scopeContentSha256":"28769b44922504a99e8c01ecc2ade25d25051ab602f73fe071479c2593c5bef7","placementContentSha256":"76bf9bc7f95c2839ea2a7249c50fc12f06fb3c3490ff142c43330a3b2dffa38c","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:43e366899f7da3ff10b67ca5fe08b66383a741cb28085d0cc4d19048977a4f2c","paperId":"2006.15154","textSha256":"d9a0cbeacd16fa677da81353bf41b75dc96de18992392f85e031aac6cc22c088"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:d0a8690e788bdffc7f9bd5a7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:43e366899f7da3ff10b67ca5fe08b66383a741cb28085d0cc4d19048977a4f2c","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:ad4be2fe9505114449878a2c","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:43e366899f7da3ff10b67ca5fe08b66383a741cb28085d0cc4d19048977a4f2c","textSha256":"d9a0cbeacd16fa677da81353bf41b75dc96de18992392f85e031aac6cc22c088"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1139c40c7a2d46855413c6e4"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1139c40c7a2d46855413c6e4","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:43e366899f7da3ff10b67ca5fe08b66383a741cb28085d0cc4d19048977a4f2c","q025-candidate-question:ad4be2fe9505114449878a2c"],"scopeContentSha256":"f06559b41f68bb241a3d41451679dbe6f9e24c8c312006ee1dc5593d8eaa62bc","contributionContentSha256":"b812f06dddde181d590638100a1c91eb878af59df46547bc72128226fe4cb7bc","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d39","kind":"description","unitIndex":39,"unitId":"unit:43e366899f7da3ff10b67ca5fe08b66383a741cb28085d0cc4d19048977a4f2c","textSha256":"d9a0cbeacd16fa677da81353bf41b75dc96de18992392f85e031aac6cc22c088"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1139c40c7a2d46855413c6e4","recordId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-adcc4556537d69777acf-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"String and membrane charges are linked but distinct defect targets.","challengeNote":"String and membrane charge definitions are linked but distinct defect targets.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":5,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"8a96602010c43dcde9175dc73becd024c6ec7f0f19151ac9744795a8835f90b0"},"organizational-access:ebab377c9874f653b57c30df":{"id":"organizational-access:ebab377c9874f653b57c30df","source":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","target":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"ab1de9788cdff248e6a9144541581f459b67514ed459a517eb55c37566181be0","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:9a6c88495887f4d8bbe8a62d"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"ae0c45ee17c61b31badd044cde74a88b4b30caddc79c1072e568a149440827d5","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:206da7f1a660e2d5c44f83f4"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1ff2095dc4f5fc4d48b6b37172fafc4faace0af2151a7bc893f5ee33c5dea787","home":{"unitId":"unit:1ff2095dc4f5fc4d48b6b37172fafc4faace0af2151a7bc893f5ee33c5dea787","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1ff2095dc4f5fc4d48b6b37172fafc4faace0af2151a7bc893f5ee33c5dea787","paperId":"1711.04807","textSha256":"b0be1f0194abc2a96e24f89270e078661cb9050e6086976ebcd86380468881a7"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:c73f031c74bb12749aa911d1"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:c73f031c74bb12749aa911d1","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1ff2095dc4f5fc4d48b6b37172fafc4faace0af2151a7bc893f5ee33c5dea787","q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32"],"scopeContentSha256":"ab1de9788cdff248e6a9144541581f459b67514ed459a517eb55c37566181be0","placementContentSha256":"dfa9faacb31195f43662a596f644c210d199ceb8fc38c9062b9df9e14fc9db4b","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1ff2095dc4f5fc4d48b6b37172fafc4faace0af2151a7bc893f5ee33c5dea787","paperId":"1711.04807","textSha256":"b0be1f0194abc2a96e24f89270e078661cb9050e6086976ebcd86380468881a7"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:c73f031c74bb12749aa911d1"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1ff2095dc4f5fc4d48b6b37172fafc4faace0af2151a7bc893f5ee33c5dea787","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:1ff2095dc4f5fc4d48b6b37172fafc4faace0af2151a7bc893f5ee33c5dea787","textSha256":"b0be1f0194abc2a96e24f89270e078661cb9050e6086976ebcd86380468881a7"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:51e0b96dfc9cb7aca5c2d8d0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:51e0b96dfc9cb7aca5c2d8d0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1ff2095dc4f5fc4d48b6b37172fafc4faace0af2151a7bc893f5ee33c5dea787","q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180"],"scopeContentSha256":"ae0c45ee17c61b31badd044cde74a88b4b30caddc79c1072e568a149440827d5","contributionContentSha256":"7a6ec68e6e1eeda4cc1f5d175016ade2fe8057e20fa88f1c07477d2239edb8c9","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d27","kind":"description","unitIndex":27,"unitId":"unit:1ff2095dc4f5fc4d48b6b37172fafc4faace0af2151a7bc893f5ee33c5dea787","textSha256":"b0be1f0194abc2a96e24f89270e078661cb9050e6086976ebcd86380468881a7"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:51e0b96dfc9cb7aca5c2d8d0","recordId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Shared e-fold targets do not establish identity with the other Kähler-inflation history analyses.","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:258c1f3214a06ee412f4f4ebc09357b92de2ad0474c7bff1f90ad6503a8427c3","home":{"unitId":"unit:258c1f3214a06ee412f4f4ebc09357b92de2ad0474c7bff1f90ad6503a8427c3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:258c1f3214a06ee412f4f4ebc09357b92de2ad0474c7bff1f90ad6503a8427c3","paperId":"2303.02947","textSha256":"0749c08fa4998c4afb8427d0c0c28baa5f00c345c7bd2a03eac8d6a276b51100"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:b8b6c093216996ce3ee145fd"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:b8b6c093216996ce3ee145fd","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:258c1f3214a06ee412f4f4ebc09357b92de2ad0474c7bff1f90ad6503a8427c3","q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32"],"scopeContentSha256":"ab1de9788cdff248e6a9144541581f459b67514ed459a517eb55c37566181be0","placementContentSha256":"7b9d4a3c48c1904855cf6f8c2cd9cca9244ce619c899fb6a55762cac528d3ee0","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:258c1f3214a06ee412f4f4ebc09357b92de2ad0474c7bff1f90ad6503a8427c3","paperId":"2303.02947","textSha256":"0749c08fa4998c4afb8427d0c0c28baa5f00c345c7bd2a03eac8d6a276b51100"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:b8b6c093216996ce3ee145fd"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:258c1f3214a06ee412f4f4ebc09357b92de2ad0474c7bff1f90ad6503a8427c3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:258c1f3214a06ee412f4f4ebc09357b92de2ad0474c7bff1f90ad6503a8427c3","textSha256":"0749c08fa4998c4afb8427d0c0c28baa5f00c345c7bd2a03eac8d6a276b51100"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:13c8a5c981b1a4bae4cfaeaa"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:13c8a5c981b1a4bae4cfaeaa","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:258c1f3214a06ee412f4f4ebc09357b92de2ad0474c7bff1f90ad6503a8427c3","q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180"],"scopeContentSha256":"ae0c45ee17c61b31badd044cde74a88b4b30caddc79c1072e568a149440827d5","contributionContentSha256":"cbfc5809f284d5713b17cc1bef7f71cacbe7cb6d2c7a20bb92b9e6a77c0149f4","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d46","kind":"description","unitIndex":46,"unitId":"unit:258c1f3214a06ee412f4f4ebc09357b92de2ad0474c7bff1f90ad6503a8427c3","textSha256":"0749c08fa4998c4afb8427d0c0c28baa5f00c345c7bd2a03eac8d6a276b51100"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:13c8a5c981b1a4bae4cfaeaa","recordId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:2fe3bf45b108a47c655b93d259e8d4d5be232fcd097afa214f66cb53e71a84f3","home":{"unitId":"unit:2fe3bf45b108a47c655b93d259e8d4d5be232fcd097afa214f66cb53e71a84f3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2fe3bf45b108a47c655b93d259e8d4d5be232fcd097afa214f66cb53e71a84f3","paperId":"hep-th/0403119","textSha256":"9374bb68caa8b13479586139ff27e8021ba9624fd3ed2745581bcd26c843fe5f"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5cd901ad6f219f925a275f7a08520088","paperId":"hep-th/0403119","sourceSha256":"525ed5dd6c1a05a4407b459827a8bcab495d6bc3a0da7f2b20d70195c1f902e7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/784399d96d0e5ddaf132/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce71b16dad1cb2a8c75f613c95ff86730e2dbae506c398c3844e99d47757acfb","pdfPage":4,"start":97,"end":2348,"textSha256":"fd690aabcab9223b91afff964a52010e167238c4fd697e4ce9ad04f0c91f7213","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:db8eb371ce9bf44992ba8a4adcb9a822","paperId":"hep-th/0403119","sourceSha256":"525ed5dd6c1a05a4407b459827a8bcab495d6bc3a0da7f2b20d70195c1f902e7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/784399d96d0e5ddaf132/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce71b16dad1cb2a8c75f613c95ff86730e2dbae506c398c3844e99d47757acfb","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1691,"textSha256":"8b36a034c79bef6494ceb0cf4e365480bb6f75b485bcfc3cd2531f13b9dd992e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:5b531b0681dea12ea57b270f"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:5b531b0681dea12ea57b270f","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2fe3bf45b108a47c655b93d259e8d4d5be232fcd097afa214f66cb53e71a84f3","q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32"],"scopeContentSha256":"ab1de9788cdff248e6a9144541581f459b67514ed459a517eb55c37566181be0","placementContentSha256":"3a55183553a1414cb9d2ba16641569c5504c0855f2545f99fc2c5ba53d72afc5","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:2fe3bf45b108a47c655b93d259e8d4d5be232fcd097afa214f66cb53e71a84f3","paperId":"hep-th/0403119","textSha256":"9374bb68caa8b13479586139ff27e8021ba9624fd3ed2745581bcd26c843fe5f"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5cd901ad6f219f925a275f7a08520088","paperId":"hep-th/0403119","sourceSha256":"525ed5dd6c1a05a4407b459827a8bcab495d6bc3a0da7f2b20d70195c1f902e7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/784399d96d0e5ddaf132/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce71b16dad1cb2a8c75f613c95ff86730e2dbae506c398c3844e99d47757acfb","pdfPage":4,"start":97,"end":2348,"textSha256":"fd690aabcab9223b91afff964a52010e167238c4fd697e4ce9ad04f0c91f7213","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:db8eb371ce9bf44992ba8a4adcb9a822","paperId":"hep-th/0403119","sourceSha256":"525ed5dd6c1a05a4407b459827a8bcab495d6bc3a0da7f2b20d70195c1f902e7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/784399d96d0e5ddaf132/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce71b16dad1cb2a8c75f613c95ff86730e2dbae506c398c3844e99d47757acfb","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1691,"textSha256":"8b36a034c79bef6494ceb0cf4e365480bb6f75b485bcfc3cd2531f13b9dd992e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:5b531b0681dea12ea57b270f"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:2fe3bf45b108a47c655b93d259e8d4d5be232fcd097afa214f66cb53e71a84f3","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d61","kind":"description","unitIndex":61,"unitId":"unit:2fe3bf45b108a47c655b93d259e8d4d5be232fcd097afa214f66cb53e71a84f3","textSha256":"9374bb68caa8b13479586139ff27e8021ba9624fd3ed2745581bcd26c843fe5f"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5cd901ad6f219f925a275f7a08520088","paperId":"hep-th/0403119","sourceSha256":"525ed5dd6c1a05a4407b459827a8bcab495d6bc3a0da7f2b20d70195c1f902e7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/784399d96d0e5ddaf132/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce71b16dad1cb2a8c75f613c95ff86730e2dbae506c398c3844e99d47757acfb","pdfPage":4,"start":97,"end":2348,"textSha256":"fd690aabcab9223b91afff964a52010e167238c4fd697e4ce9ad04f0c91f7213","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:db8eb371ce9bf44992ba8a4adcb9a822","paperId":"hep-th/0403119","sourceSha256":"525ed5dd6c1a05a4407b459827a8bcab495d6bc3a0da7f2b20d70195c1f902e7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/784399d96d0e5ddaf132/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce71b16dad1cb2a8c75f613c95ff86730e2dbae506c398c3844e99d47757acfb","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1691,"textSha256":"8b36a034c79bef6494ceb0cf4e365480bb6f75b485bcfc3cd2531f13b9dd992e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bad0f26bf41478a4058ce593"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:bad0f26bf41478a4058ce593","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:2fe3bf45b108a47c655b93d259e8d4d5be232fcd097afa214f66cb53e71a84f3","q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180"],"scopeContentSha256":"ae0c45ee17c61b31badd044cde74a88b4b30caddc79c1072e568a149440827d5","contributionContentSha256":"59083d58ed57dcf90a5d24dfd21e3ffd43d31ed0812a7ae3afd7f0a2376339df","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d61","kind":"description","unitIndex":61,"unitId":"unit:2fe3bf45b108a47c655b93d259e8d4d5be232fcd097afa214f66cb53e71a84f3","textSha256":"9374bb68caa8b13479586139ff27e8021ba9624fd3ed2745581bcd26c843fe5f"},{"localRef":"e12","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5cd901ad6f219f925a275f7a08520088","paperId":"hep-th/0403119","sourceSha256":"525ed5dd6c1a05a4407b459827a8bcab495d6bc3a0da7f2b20d70195c1f902e7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/784399d96d0e5ddaf132/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce71b16dad1cb2a8c75f613c95ff86730e2dbae506c398c3844e99d47757acfb","pdfPage":4,"start":97,"end":2348,"textSha256":"fd690aabcab9223b91afff964a52010e167238c4fd697e4ce9ad04f0c91f7213","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e21","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:db8eb371ce9bf44992ba8a4adcb9a822","paperId":"hep-th/0403119","sourceSha256":"525ed5dd6c1a05a4407b459827a8bcab495d6bc3a0da7f2b20d70195c1f902e7","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/784399d96d0e5ddaf132/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"ce71b16dad1cb2a8c75f613c95ff86730e2dbae506c398c3844e99d47757acfb","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1691,"textSha256":"8b36a034c79bef6494ceb0cf4e365480bb6f75b485bcfc3cd2531f13b9dd992e","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bad0f26bf41478a4058ce593","recordId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"The search allows moduli to roll and needs special vacuum parameters. Reheating is opened as a future question, not completed in these excerpts.","challengeNote":"The source allows moduli to roll and requires special vacuum parameters. A Standard Model-like sector enables a reheating question without completing it.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5da6f6514370355c3db838c43bafb202ee5834221a322e3925a19241e3fb6c57","home":{"unitId":"unit:5da6f6514370355c3db838c43bafb202ee5834221a322e3925a19241e3fb6c57","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5da6f6514370355c3db838c43bafb202ee5834221a322e3925a19241e3fb6c57","paperId":"1708.08922","textSha256":"63ca513c7979b5fae2064bfceb709465b1fa252666f7799523a7a8bb82fba604"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:a57431c2e457e5098eecf424"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:a57431c2e457e5098eecf424","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5da6f6514370355c3db838c43bafb202ee5834221a322e3925a19241e3fb6c57","q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32"],"scopeContentSha256":"ab1de9788cdff248e6a9144541581f459b67514ed459a517eb55c37566181be0","placementContentSha256":"8d435098eb67631895aad4a1a944dfa68861dce0fbc22f6095cd35365bf9ec29","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5da6f6514370355c3db838c43bafb202ee5834221a322e3925a19241e3fb6c57","paperId":"1708.08922","textSha256":"63ca513c7979b5fae2064bfceb709465b1fa252666f7799523a7a8bb82fba604"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:a57431c2e457e5098eecf424"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5da6f6514370355c3db838c43bafb202ee5834221a322e3925a19241e3fb6c57","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:5da6f6514370355c3db838c43bafb202ee5834221a322e3925a19241e3fb6c57","textSha256":"63ca513c7979b5fae2064bfceb709465b1fa252666f7799523a7a8bb82fba604"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:71e94875543c1284cb49047a"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:71e94875543c1284cb49047a","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5da6f6514370355c3db838c43bafb202ee5834221a322e3925a19241e3fb6c57","q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180"],"scopeContentSha256":"ae0c45ee17c61b31badd044cde74a88b4b30caddc79c1072e568a149440827d5","contributionContentSha256":"e2fc18dd2780c46c4d98140445cb835a4a14a8a7a0b81d0d97395319d659507d","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d25","kind":"description","unitIndex":25,"unitId":"unit:5da6f6514370355c3db838c43bafb202ee5834221a322e3925a19241e3fb6c57","textSha256":"63ca513c7979b5fae2064bfceb709465b1fa252666f7799523a7a8bb82fba604"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:71e94875543c1284cb49047a","recordId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:5db5ff7cb03a2b79fd2a3066c6c9d4636cea22deebbff83542aca527a7180b2b","home":{"unitId":"unit:5db5ff7cb03a2b79fd2a3066c6c9d4636cea22deebbff83542aca527a7180b2b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5db5ff7cb03a2b79fd2a3066c6c9d4636cea22deebbff83542aca527a7180b2b","paperId":"1108.2659","textSha256":"ef7fe9d29c2e885e6ec4ec659f72af99ed7b04626d21b2f7777c341bb62b7d35"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:51e63992e5fb5588cf104c67"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:51e63992e5fb5588cf104c67","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5db5ff7cb03a2b79fd2a3066c6c9d4636cea22deebbff83542aca527a7180b2b","q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32"],"scopeContentSha256":"ab1de9788cdff248e6a9144541581f459b67514ed459a517eb55c37566181be0","placementContentSha256":"439d32b78e859bcd3b9085a5c1be8361a789b44e8f8e16c2d56023a0ac410408","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:5db5ff7cb03a2b79fd2a3066c6c9d4636cea22deebbff83542aca527a7180b2b","paperId":"1108.2659","textSha256":"ef7fe9d29c2e885e6ec4ec659f72af99ed7b04626d21b2f7777c341bb62b7d35"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:51e63992e5fb5588cf104c67"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:5db5ff7cb03a2b79fd2a3066c6c9d4636cea22deebbff83542aca527a7180b2b","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:5db5ff7cb03a2b79fd2a3066c6c9d4636cea22deebbff83542aca527a7180b2b","textSha256":"ef7fe9d29c2e885e6ec4ec659f72af99ed7b04626d21b2f7777c341bb62b7d35"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d695830d57dda6b81234d457"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:d695830d57dda6b81234d457","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:5db5ff7cb03a2b79fd2a3066c6c9d4636cea22deebbff83542aca527a7180b2b","q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180"],"scopeContentSha256":"ae0c45ee17c61b31badd044cde74a88b4b30caddc79c1072e568a149440827d5","contributionContentSha256":"facbb354508466903cc20e8f53dab9689ff4206c1db4f38ca2c02b7a94b50175","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d8","kind":"description","unitIndex":8,"unitId":"unit:5db5ff7cb03a2b79fd2a3066c6c9d4636cea22deebbff83542aca527a7180b2b","textSha256":"ef7fe9d29c2e885e6ec4ec659f72af99ed7b04626d21b2f7777c341bb62b7d35"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:d695830d57dda6b81234d457","recordId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:626de3ac29d27c8133acbdaa015f99befbcedf0719400a9e9299ef1f09d8ecde","home":{"unitId":"unit:626de3ac29d27c8133acbdaa015f99befbcedf0719400a9e9299ef1f09d8ecde","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:626de3ac29d27c8133acbdaa015f99befbcedf0719400a9e9299ef1f09d8ecde","paperId":"1603.06789","textSha256":"e7b8708307d0a8aeac30baf66da1bf7541cf056005be075fd8a41372bc495c46"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:f77edbecdfd1972bf404cf6c"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:f77edbecdfd1972bf404cf6c","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:626de3ac29d27c8133acbdaa015f99befbcedf0719400a9e9299ef1f09d8ecde","q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32"],"scopeContentSha256":"ab1de9788cdff248e6a9144541581f459b67514ed459a517eb55c37566181be0","placementContentSha256":"c20a8785902d4771a0d08726315f0de15ef8d883abe9fb65d6f4b5df63316ea9","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:626de3ac29d27c8133acbdaa015f99befbcedf0719400a9e9299ef1f09d8ecde","paperId":"1603.06789","textSha256":"e7b8708307d0a8aeac30baf66da1bf7541cf056005be075fd8a41372bc495c46"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:f77edbecdfd1972bf404cf6c"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:626de3ac29d27c8133acbdaa015f99befbcedf0719400a9e9299ef1f09d8ecde","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:626de3ac29d27c8133acbdaa015f99befbcedf0719400a9e9299ef1f09d8ecde","textSha256":"e7b8708307d0a8aeac30baf66da1bf7541cf056005be075fd8a41372bc495c46"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1e5d8c541edd6676e6196961"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1e5d8c541edd6676e6196961","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:626de3ac29d27c8133acbdaa015f99befbcedf0719400a9e9299ef1f09d8ecde","q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180"],"scopeContentSha256":"ae0c45ee17c61b31badd044cde74a88b4b30caddc79c1072e568a149440827d5","contributionContentSha256":"352b416a4ef7fcc6e7d7ded724aea2e0672166b59f73458406b7da569c1efb01","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d18","kind":"description","unitIndex":18,"unitId":"unit:626de3ac29d27c8133acbdaa015f99befbcedf0719400a9e9299ef1f09d8ecde","textSha256":"e7b8708307d0a8aeac30baf66da1bf7541cf056005be075fd8a41372bc495c46"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1e5d8c541edd6676e6196961","recordId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:6657a8bd16bceefae6c2a0b83996c767eebc45833b124f683975374b4f3f2b0e","home":{"unitId":"unit:6657a8bd16bceefae6c2a0b83996c767eebc45833b124f683975374b4f3f2b0e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6657a8bd16bceefae6c2a0b83996c767eebc45833b124f683975374b4f3f2b0e","paperId":"1604.08512","textSha256":"089563d44fc82c91941b89d621695060159ae1f858e188f39117976b99d5024e"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:410450e7cd71a3c0dc970dc9"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:410450e7cd71a3c0dc970dc9","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6657a8bd16bceefae6c2a0b83996c767eebc45833b124f683975374b4f3f2b0e","q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32"],"scopeContentSha256":"ab1de9788cdff248e6a9144541581f459b67514ed459a517eb55c37566181be0","placementContentSha256":"6ed474bbf3be2ac2acd277a0cb42c070aa1f05026ed393a7db84cf769bab1825","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:6657a8bd16bceefae6c2a0b83996c767eebc45833b124f683975374b4f3f2b0e","paperId":"1604.08512","textSha256":"089563d44fc82c91941b89d621695060159ae1f858e188f39117976b99d5024e"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:410450e7cd71a3c0dc970dc9"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:6657a8bd16bceefae6c2a0b83996c767eebc45833b124f683975374b4f3f2b0e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:6657a8bd16bceefae6c2a0b83996c767eebc45833b124f683975374b4f3f2b0e","textSha256":"089563d44fc82c91941b89d621695060159ae1f858e188f39117976b99d5024e"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e808034b0f1b42a685ee8934"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:e808034b0f1b42a685ee8934","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:6657a8bd16bceefae6c2a0b83996c767eebc45833b124f683975374b4f3f2b0e","q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180"],"scopeContentSha256":"ae0c45ee17c61b31badd044cde74a88b4b30caddc79c1072e568a149440827d5","contributionContentSha256":"a154c8213fb2560c3ccd22df80a080ca5e8c8330f415996c9ae72e0d353c1399","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d19","kind":"description","unitIndex":19,"unitId":"unit:6657a8bd16bceefae6c2a0b83996c767eebc45833b124f683975374b4f3f2b0e","textSha256":"089563d44fc82c91941b89d621695060159ae1f858e188f39117976b99d5024e"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:e808034b0f1b42a685ee8934","recordId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"","challengeNote":"","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9f10508baa78ad61160044e95e18478249543f5bfcab269315bbcbae965a0117","home":{"unitId":"unit:9f10508baa78ad61160044e95e18478249543f5bfcab269315bbcbae965a0117","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9f10508baa78ad61160044e95e18478249543f5bfcab269315bbcbae965a0117","paperId":"2411.08467","textSha256":"880a2e9323afb4dcf01d46245f86083dbc2eeb1cb3930274fbc0381379efe81f"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:de5e7af1c6d7f0b68e43d619"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:de5e7af1c6d7f0b68e43d619","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9f10508baa78ad61160044e95e18478249543f5bfcab269315bbcbae965a0117","q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32"],"scopeContentSha256":"ab1de9788cdff248e6a9144541581f459b67514ed459a517eb55c37566181be0","placementContentSha256":"680f3ca4e37d6f830c5cabc6c3d0a69dab03d3944b6b9474e6eaac415cbe7bf6","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9f10508baa78ad61160044e95e18478249543f5bfcab269315bbcbae965a0117","paperId":"2411.08467","textSha256":"880a2e9323afb4dcf01d46245f86083dbc2eeb1cb3930274fbc0381379efe81f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:de5e7af1c6d7f0b68e43d619"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9f10508baa78ad61160044e95e18478249543f5bfcab269315bbcbae965a0117","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:9f10508baa78ad61160044e95e18478249543f5bfcab269315bbcbae965a0117","textSha256":"880a2e9323afb4dcf01d46245f86083dbc2eeb1cb3930274fbc0381379efe81f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:56b9ddf6b46da4d2a654c5ba"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:56b9ddf6b46da4d2a654c5ba","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9f10508baa78ad61160044e95e18478249543f5bfcab269315bbcbae965a0117","q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180"],"scopeContentSha256":"ae0c45ee17c61b31badd044cde74a88b4b30caddc79c1072e568a149440827d5","contributionContentSha256":"b2b109ed788091ef4f1f2cb488837be90cbc9d8f294e9409d92533de556013eb","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d55","kind":"description","unitIndex":55,"unitId":"unit:9f10508baa78ad61160044e95e18478249543f5bfcab269315bbcbae965a0117","textSha256":"880a2e9323afb4dcf01d46245f86083dbc2eeb1cb3930274fbc0381379efe81f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:56b9ddf6b46da4d2a654c5ba","recordId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Generic Calabi–Yau extensions are part of the question, not certified generality.","challengeNote":"Generic Calabi–Yau extensions are an announced target.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ac6f483c46dd85cc2577f73a624723b5d9d792eeaf69d8e3c769338889f21394","home":{"unitId":"unit:ac6f483c46dd85cc2577f73a624723b5d9d792eeaf69d8e3c769338889f21394","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ac6f483c46dd85cc2577f73a624723b5d9d792eeaf69d8e3c769338889f21394","paperId":"1707.07924","textSha256":"54b7b99e10fd9ef4eae926e1921e3744d7a61a826ca60f3c6ddb3b50dc613f8b"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:3d594aa9c03a462603bbd8b8"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:3d594aa9c03a462603bbd8b8","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ac6f483c46dd85cc2577f73a624723b5d9d792eeaf69d8e3c769338889f21394","q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32"],"scopeContentSha256":"ab1de9788cdff248e6a9144541581f459b67514ed459a517eb55c37566181be0","placementContentSha256":"0a0976e7def5059fbd102e35dd107e2b534228dc010b5c963cecf95c551734c1","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ac6f483c46dd85cc2577f73a624723b5d9d792eeaf69d8e3c769338889f21394","paperId":"1707.07924","textSha256":"54b7b99e10fd9ef4eae926e1921e3744d7a61a826ca60f3c6ddb3b50dc613f8b"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:3d594aa9c03a462603bbd8b8"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ac6f483c46dd85cc2577f73a624723b5d9d792eeaf69d8e3c769338889f21394","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:ac6f483c46dd85cc2577f73a624723b5d9d792eeaf69d8e3c769338889f21394","textSha256":"54b7b99e10fd9ef4eae926e1921e3744d7a61a826ca60f3c6ddb3b50dc613f8b"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:21399840aacc82ac82c96762"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:21399840aacc82ac82c96762","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ac6f483c46dd85cc2577f73a624723b5d9d792eeaf69d8e3c769338889f21394","q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180"],"scopeContentSha256":"ae0c45ee17c61b31badd044cde74a88b4b30caddc79c1072e568a149440827d5","contributionContentSha256":"f3b697dd42bb93ce77e30883ceca4c1841b6add092aef225d942209675518e62","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d23","kind":"description","unitIndex":23,"unitId":"unit:ac6f483c46dd85cc2577f73a624723b5d9d792eeaf69d8e3c769338889f21394","textSha256":"54b7b99e10fd9ef4eae926e1921e3744d7a61a826ca60f3c6ddb3b50dc613f8b"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:21399840aacc82ac82c96762","recordId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Planck compatibility refers to the datasets available to the 2017 authors.","challengeNote":"Retain the Planck datasets available to the authors.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:b0f6c1ec1e6a714be7bfe1379104db3a80c1259eef4a195fda6dbe0710c8bf39","home":{"unitId":"unit:b0f6c1ec1e6a714be7bfe1379104db3a80c1259eef4a195fda6dbe0710c8bf39","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"q6 encompasses loop-generated inflation, stabilization and control, moduli reheating, dark radiation and dated observational comparisons.","qualification":"q6 covers the construction and its reheating-dependent predictions together. Coverage retains the comparison with the spoiled non-perturbative regime, the v2 proceedings status, updated observations and Scenario III parameters.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b0f6c1ec1e6a714be7bfe1379104db3a80c1259eef4a195fda6dbe0710c8bf39","paperId":"2604.07288","textSha256":"f31156b8fb049aa09dfb222a99675f597f7ed2f4aed0d05aa3677dffdc9cf201"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0039:u4:q6"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0039:u4:q6","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b0f6c1ec1e6a714be7bfe1379104db3a80c1259eef4a195fda6dbe0710c8bf39","q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32"],"scopeContentSha256":"ab1de9788cdff248e6a9144541581f459b67514ed459a517eb55c37566181be0","placementContentSha256":"882e77eaf349468bf171d26404218435bc2abb2e1715faabf4f6a9b84d49cfed","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0039:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0039:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b0f6c1ec1e6a714be7bfe1379104db3a80c1259eef4a195fda6dbe0710c8bf39","paperId":"2604.07288","textSha256":"f31156b8fb049aa09dfb222a99675f597f7ed2f4aed0d05aa3677dffdc9cf201"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0039","unitRef":"u4"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b0f6c1ec1e6a714be7bfe1379104db3a80c1259eef4a195fda6dbe0710c8bf39","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:b0f6c1ec1e6a714be7bfe1379104db3a80c1259eef4a195fda6dbe0710c8bf39","textSha256":"f31156b8fb049aa09dfb222a99675f597f7ed2f4aed0d05aa3677dffdc9cf201"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7ea9dfde37887ecd5037241e"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:7ea9dfde37887ecd5037241e","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b0f6c1ec1e6a714be7bfe1379104db3a80c1259eef4a195fda6dbe0710c8bf39","q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180"],"scopeContentSha256":"ae0c45ee17c61b31badd044cde74a88b4b30caddc79c1072e568a149440827d5","contributionContentSha256":"b20c047b3114c439dacbed36f9b40c7236fa1e735e9bf230ed776254c80edd97","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d57","kind":"description","unitIndex":57,"unitId":"unit:b0f6c1ec1e6a714be7bfe1379104db3a80c1259eef4a195fda6dbe0710c8bf39","textSha256":"f31156b8fb049aa09dfb222a99675f597f7ed2f4aed0d05aa3677dffdc9cf201"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:7ea9dfde37887ecd5037241e","recordId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"A v2 proceedings synthesis with updated comparisons and Scenario III parameters; not an independent new derivation of every summarized result.","challengeNote":"Preserve the v2 proceedings status, updated comparisons and Scenario III parameters. The spoiled non-perturbative regime is comparison context.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:e6edab0c7647e91a25f8aafc1ebe1b8c7326eff30412805e515b689870db6e93","home":{"unitId":"unit:e6edab0c7647e91a25f8aafc1ebe1b8c7326eff30412805e515b689870db6e93","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e6edab0c7647e91a25f8aafc1ebe1b8c7326eff30412805e515b689870db6e93","paperId":"1309.3412","textSha256":"bf56ca3b837f88eecf6deba4ebf9d47f5e7ea3fca01b24183828c491076fdeb5"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:e3643dfbd933f8bfb9b37a45"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:e3643dfbd933f8bfb9b37a45","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e6edab0c7647e91a25f8aafc1ebe1b8c7326eff30412805e515b689870db6e93","q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32"],"scopeContentSha256":"ab1de9788cdff248e6a9144541581f459b67514ed459a517eb55c37566181be0","placementContentSha256":"10d0f5a0e89c96d3e3a0bd1fe1b96b0973cedad6e492f767b54efe8f74d8c7a8","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:e6edab0c7647e91a25f8aafc1ebe1b8c7326eff30412805e515b689870db6e93","paperId":"1309.3412","textSha256":"bf56ca3b837f88eecf6deba4ebf9d47f5e7ea3fca01b24183828c491076fdeb5"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:e3643dfbd933f8bfb9b37a45"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:e6edab0c7647e91a25f8aafc1ebe1b8c7326eff30412805e515b689870db6e93","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:e6edab0c7647e91a25f8aafc1ebe1b8c7326eff30412805e515b689870db6e93","textSha256":"bf56ca3b837f88eecf6deba4ebf9d47f5e7ea3fca01b24183828c491076fdeb5"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bc1f7d63d29aff7c871841a0"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:bc1f7d63d29aff7c871841a0","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:e6edab0c7647e91a25f8aafc1ebe1b8c7326eff30412805e515b689870db6e93","q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180"],"scopeContentSha256":"ae0c45ee17c61b31badd044cde74a88b4b30caddc79c1072e568a149440827d5","contributionContentSha256":"9e6eb81f8d49951850420a19602c7befba3ab5b968e2466330ed2870f69d7ffc","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d14","kind":"description","unitIndex":14,"unitId":"unit:e6edab0c7647e91a25f8aafc1ebe1b8c7326eff30412805e515b689870db6e93","textSha256":"bf56ca3b837f88eecf6deba4ebf9d47f5e7ea3fca01b24183828c491076fdeb5"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:bc1f7d63d29aff7c871841a0","recordId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"The low-multipole suppression is a historical reported feature, not a certified anomaly.","challengeNote":"The low-multipole suppression remains a historically reported feature.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ea8791c203378708df6b560033d11a581270899474bc99c36b1c81a2df8b8a83","home":{"unitId":"unit:ea8791c203378708df6b560033d11a581270899474bc99c36b1c81a2df8b8a83","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is placed within the exact unchanged admitted scope using the approved A/B policy. Source-specific conditions and reading limits remain attached; no equivalence or applicability is implied.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ea8791c203378708df6b560033d11a581270899474bc99c36b1c81a2df8b8a83","paperId":"hep-th/0702059","textSha256":"ae3b9f6b2c6e7aa711374ec5dac15a6bdd78f80c71f28aa251cd0013e56f18cd"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:244e798d044dd49b7c819e953b89c2ce","paperId":"hep-th/0702059","sourceSha256":"7069fc60dc2857d372b55d21f40e3db66020075944e84bf3289af23772b84d6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9b48a7715e32ef1d17a3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"890fe3043660fca3e3c76511e37723bfe3a649ef4d12234f450ce8ed1720b672","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1949,"textSha256":"899a6aaf7a528233311e97aafe1021f3a047bf59c8940de4a18f29726bcb9efb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5b90e44c174e2662e0fb0236ab7d9621","paperId":"hep-th/0702059","sourceSha256":"7069fc60dc2857d372b55d21f40e3db66020075944e84bf3289af23772b84d6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9b48a7715e32ef1d17a3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"890fe3043660fca3e3c76511e37723bfe3a649ef4d12234f450ce8ed1720b672","pdfPage":33,"start":1296,"end":3357,"textSha256":"6b2865fe9a009e47c36cec24b804b52e90e0fd23ca9f0668cc7c13bf8d7522e5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:bf87aa70d428afa000afa8e2"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:bf87aa70d428afa000afa8e2","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ea8791c203378708df6b560033d11a581270899474bc99c36b1c81a2df8b8a83","q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32"],"scopeContentSha256":"ab1de9788cdff248e6a9144541581f459b67514ed459a517eb55c37566181be0","placementContentSha256":"87c50c6d0c3483fc52ca73cb0dfae45b88469faba83fb6c5015fe894f83eab62","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ea8791c203378708df6b560033d11a581270899474bc99c36b1c81a2df8b8a83","paperId":"hep-th/0702059","textSha256":"ae3b9f6b2c6e7aa711374ec5dac15a6bdd78f80c71f28aa251cd0013e56f18cd"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:244e798d044dd49b7c819e953b89c2ce","paperId":"hep-th/0702059","sourceSha256":"7069fc60dc2857d372b55d21f40e3db66020075944e84bf3289af23772b84d6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9b48a7715e32ef1d17a3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"890fe3043660fca3e3c76511e37723bfe3a649ef4d12234f450ce8ed1720b672","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1949,"textSha256":"899a6aaf7a528233311e97aafe1021f3a047bf59c8940de4a18f29726bcb9efb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5b90e44c174e2662e0fb0236ab7d9621","paperId":"hep-th/0702059","sourceSha256":"7069fc60dc2857d372b55d21f40e3db66020075944e84bf3289af23772b84d6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9b48a7715e32ef1d17a3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"890fe3043660fca3e3c76511e37723bfe3a649ef4d12234f450ce8ed1720b672","pdfPage":33,"start":1296,"end":3357,"textSha256":"6b2865fe9a009e47c36cec24b804b52e90e0fd23ca9f0668cc7c13bf8d7522e5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:bf87aa70d428afa000afa8e2"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ea8791c203378708df6b560033d11a581270899474bc99c36b1c81a2df8b8a83","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:ea8791c203378708df6b560033d11a581270899474bc99c36b1c81a2df8b8a83","textSha256":"ae3b9f6b2c6e7aa711374ec5dac15a6bdd78f80c71f28aa251cd0013e56f18cd"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:244e798d044dd49b7c819e953b89c2ce","paperId":"hep-th/0702059","sourceSha256":"7069fc60dc2857d372b55d21f40e3db66020075944e84bf3289af23772b84d6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9b48a7715e32ef1d17a3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"890fe3043660fca3e3c76511e37723bfe3a649ef4d12234f450ce8ed1720b672","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1949,"textSha256":"899a6aaf7a528233311e97aafe1021f3a047bf59c8940de4a18f29726bcb9efb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5b90e44c174e2662e0fb0236ab7d9621","paperId":"hep-th/0702059","sourceSha256":"7069fc60dc2857d372b55d21f40e3db66020075944e84bf3289af23772b84d6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9b48a7715e32ef1d17a3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"890fe3043660fca3e3c76511e37723bfe3a649ef4d12234f450ce8ed1720b672","pdfPage":33,"start":1296,"end":3357,"textSha256":"6b2865fe9a009e47c36cec24b804b52e90e0fd23ca9f0668cc7c13bf8d7522e5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b6d0e55c1ce6e4a544eb2c32"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:b6d0e55c1ce6e4a544eb2c32","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ea8791c203378708df6b560033d11a581270899474bc99c36b1c81a2df8b8a83","q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180"],"scopeContentSha256":"ae0c45ee17c61b31badd044cde74a88b4b30caddc79c1072e568a149440827d5","contributionContentSha256":"7b8accb07ac1dbde8dc5ff4f4e757045619fd483ceb3b11871d949853652d032","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d66","kind":"description","unitIndex":66,"unitId":"unit:ea8791c203378708df6b560033d11a581270899474bc99c36b1c81a2df8b8a83","textSha256":"ae3b9f6b2c6e7aa711374ec5dac15a6bdd78f80c71f28aa251cd0013e56f18cd"},{"localRef":"e0","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:244e798d044dd49b7c819e953b89c2ce","paperId":"hep-th/0702059","sourceSha256":"7069fc60dc2857d372b55d21f40e3db66020075944e84bf3289af23772b84d6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9b48a7715e32ef1d17a3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"890fe3043660fca3e3c76511e37723bfe3a649ef4d12234f450ce8ed1720b672","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":1949,"textSha256":"899a6aaf7a528233311e97aafe1021f3a047bf59c8940de4a18f29726bcb9efb","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e11","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:5b90e44c174e2662e0fb0236ab7d9621","paperId":"hep-th/0702059","sourceSha256":"7069fc60dc2857d372b55d21f40e3db66020075944e84bf3289af23772b84d6e","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/9b48a7715e32ef1d17a3/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"890fe3043660fca3e3c76511e37723bfe3a649ef4d12234f450ce8ed1720b672","pdfPage":33,"start":1296,"end":3357,"textSha256":"6b2865fe9a009e47c36cec24b804b52e90e0fd23ca9f0668cc7c13bf8d7522e5","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:b6d0e55c1ce6e4a544eb2c32","recordId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":2,"proposalNote":"The 2007 review explicitly describes an incomplete model sample and makes observational testing conditional on reliable derivation and distinct predictions.","challengeNote":"The 2007 review states that its model sample is incomplete. Observational testing requires reliable derivations and distinctive predictions.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:ecb0c87c0111d589cf97835863b4c283f66e6159e6324c95146cb0edc3fe980d","home":{"unitId":"unit:ecb0c87c0111d589cf97835863b4c283f66e6159e6324c95146cb0edc3fe980d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question retains one reviewed whole-family home. All stated targets, source-era conditions and typed contributions remain distinct; no atomic split, question equivalence or automatic mass division is asserted.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ecb0c87c0111d589cf97835863b4c283f66e6159e6324c95146cb0edc3fe980d","paperId":"2511.19610","textSha256":"8fac3dc883b88f40c7d417a35cc89a565a85114d081416c4fddb99af88fbe27c"}],"decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:07b34b3d62b0e1d6919807ab"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:same-policy-extension:07b34b3d62b0e1d6919807ab","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ecb0c87c0111d589cf97835863b4c283f66e6159e6324c95146cb0edc3fe980d","q025-candidate-region:e5c49abf6212b445c5c4ec32"],"scopeContentSha256":"ab1de9788cdff248e6a9144541581f459b67514ed459a517eb55c37566181be0","placementContentSha256":"fce96bd97818df403dce88597f33afadcc7c55ca44dd732d0c19f3b0383eef00","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"2767f08f2d2ebfa9894a44a5e204c9ac39b99e40c3328ef79a8cad350214a9f0","bytes":18660}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ecb0c87c0111d589cf97835863b4c283f66e6159e6324c95146cb0edc3fe980d","paperId":"2511.19610","textSha256":"8fac3dc883b88f40c7d417a35cc89a565a85114d081416c4fddb99af88fbe27c"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-residual-v1/admitted-extension-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"055f67ed6da6dab09b41a4a0542492a5bc73bf40ea40ad035d2117ce68856949","decisionId":"decision:same-policy-extension:07b34b3d62b0e1d6919807ab"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ecb0c87c0111d589cf97835863b4c283f66e6159e6324c95146cb0edc3fe980d","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d56","kind":"description","unitIndex":56,"unitId":"unit:ecb0c87c0111d589cf97835863b4c283f66e6159e6324c95146cb0edc3fe980d","textSha256":"8fac3dc883b88f40c7d417a35cc89a565a85114d081416c4fddb99af88fbe27c"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a084658c5f73b20aeec529f2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a084658c5f73b20aeec529f2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ecb0c87c0111d589cf97835863b4c283f66e6159e6324c95146cb0edc3fe980d","q025-candidate-question:29b9dc1d47760671b4a15180"],"scopeContentSha256":"ae0c45ee17c61b31badd044cde74a88b4b30caddc79c1072e568a149440827d5","contributionContentSha256":"9f66c6f1a9b45194449224365e68df3d09bc1f2b1355b006e64d30a263228a60","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d56","kind":"description","unitIndex":56,"unitId":"unit:ecb0c87c0111d589cf97835863b4c283f66e6159e6324c95146cb0edc3fe980d","textSha256":"8fac3dc883b88f40c7d417a35cc89a565a85114d081416c4fddb99af88fbe27c"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a084658c5f73b20aeec529f2","recordId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge:p7","proposalReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-bd82eaf89f08295fe285-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound tilt, quintessence and partial-dark-matter targets require reconciliation; ACT preference is the paper's 2025 claim.","challengeNote":"Tilt, axion quintessence and partial dark matter are separate material targets. The ACT preference is the source's 2025 claim.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":13,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"bb84d54015c516ee1569728cb8fcc53bd68afac50577a69183eaf356c07b471e"},"organizational-access:22feec0f3a2d9e651897e2ca":{"id":"organizational-access:22feec0f3a2d9e651897e2ca","source":"q025-candidate-region:f174f5f3658af4e764385fd2","target":"q025-candidate-question:a933bcee7169dcddca789765","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:f174f5f3658af4e764385fd2","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"64ebeb09c5511e1668133802570b7588a2820e526230b2a71b754ed0b5488ead","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:dcde1a628d9d4c9dbf720d0e"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:a933bcee7169dcddca789765","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"91870232de187174a04c73ac5c8ec8ac23886f5df8c5d34f6624aea3138c48e2","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:8b6ff517758f89ed82de3ac8"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:b5dcdda9758c946146d53027cf6c556e0e2b7ea7e060606ffc74c130bac5e028","home":{"unitId":"unit:b5dcdda9758c946146d53027cf6c556e0e2b7ea7e060606ffc74c130bac5e028","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f174f5f3658af4e764385fd2","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Combines Higgs-scale selection, axion dynamics, inflationary requirements, strong CP and the complete cold-dark-matter target.","qualification":"q14 explicitly encompasses Higgs and axion potentials, excursions, inflation, strong-CP models and relic production and persistence. It covers the selection mechanism and every stated viability condition, including the all-cold-dark-matter requirement.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b5dcdda9758c946146d53027cf6c556e0e2b7ea7e060606ffc74c130bac5e028","paperId":"1811.06520","textSha256":"0c782aac4da2fd184fb8f6d5a8b6266a3b2167c1719a3a39c225409536c0b61a"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0036:u10:q14"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0036:u10:q14","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b5dcdda9758c946146d53027cf6c556e0e2b7ea7e060606ffc74c130bac5e028","q025-candidate-region:f174f5f3658af4e764385fd2"],"scopeContentSha256":"64ebeb09c5511e1668133802570b7588a2820e526230b2a71b754ed0b5488ead","placementContentSha256":"fef543c0ba187dcc80709dc10316a0742fc901d17846693d3955192d38e18426","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0036:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0036:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-03"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:b5dcdda9758c946146d53027cf6c556e0e2b7ea7e060606ffc74c130bac5e028","paperId":"1811.06520","textSha256":"0c782aac4da2fd184fb8f6d5a8b6266a3b2167c1719a3a39c225409536c0b61a"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"649059ad2799c18589d6c060e312361bf2b063743cc64b69ac605422712473da"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-03/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"23339baf89182d89370f5289d0217061bf0b1fbe1c7162f1c530935db6c7170a","bytes":14953079,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0036","unitRef":"u10"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:b5dcdda9758c946146d53027cf6c556e0e2b7ea7e060606ffc74c130bac5e028","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:a933bcee7169dcddca789765","role":"specializes","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:b5dcdda9758c946146d53027cf6c556e0e2b7ea7e060606ffc74c130bac5e028","textSha256":"0c782aac4da2fd184fb8f6d5a8b6266a3b2167c1719a3a39c225409536c0b61a"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4c0fff3c0da6a9a92cc79ec2f85c0198","paperId":"1811.06520","sourceSha256":"4ac27b36557b10d3b6bfebe1267282dcece6cecd99dc34e755527a6dfebbdd52","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/15e14f94cdaf9763147e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"16aa1a58b961f209d3639d9dfc2ee9a43fb877152198a68c18c8106bdee90691","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"29327f7960987e4df9e4b20c3110eff4bae6a5e221ded262aa6bc47c064ed4ac","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:aeed90c825a6168a7346d8af28d9f9cc","paperId":"1811.06520","sourceSha256":"4ac27b36557b10d3b6bfebe1267282dcece6cecd99dc34e755527a6dfebbdd52","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/15e14f94cdaf9763147e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"16aa1a58b961f209d3639d9dfc2ee9a43fb877152198a68c18c8106bdee90691","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"07ebfd7cc3c06c7cc90db3069f1fff015a401c738d9561ff16d3b785494196b8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:292dd782a62f7640f580ea8f","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: May 2019 version proposes instability-driven stochastic selection. Sub-Planckian scanning, strong CP and all-CDM compatibility are linked targets, not fully re- Independent challenge qualification: May 2019 version proposes instability-driven stochastic selection. Sub-Planckian scanning, inflationary duration, strong CP and all-CDM compatibility are comp"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:292dd782a62f7640f580ea8f","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:b5dcdda9758c946146d53027cf6c556e0e2b7ea7e060606ffc74c130bac5e028","q025-candidate-question:a933bcee7169dcddca789765"],"scopeContentSha256":"91870232de187174a04c73ac5c8ec8ac23886f5df8c5d34f6624aea3138c48e2","contributionContentSha256":"c2544f02873ea131c9bbd706fadc22e442b5070545b87dbf4d2f958bdf57649e","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-71728a1cff56ec63dfed-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-71728a1cff56ec63dfed-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-71728a1cff56ec63dfed-proposal","leaf-71728a1cff56ec63dfed-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:b5dcdda9758c946146d53027cf6c556e0e2b7ea7e060606ffc74c130bac5e028","textSha256":"0c782aac4da2fd184fb8f6d5a8b6266a3b2167c1719a3a39c225409536c0b61a"},{"localRef":"e4","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4c0fff3c0da6a9a92cc79ec2f85c0198","paperId":"1811.06520","sourceSha256":"4ac27b36557b10d3b6bfebe1267282dcece6cecd99dc34e755527a6dfebbdd52","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/15e14f94cdaf9763147e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"16aa1a58b961f209d3639d9dfc2ee9a43fb877152198a68c18c8106bdee90691","pdfPage":1,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"29327f7960987e4df9e4b20c3110eff4bae6a5e221ded262aa6bc47c064ed4ac","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e16","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:aeed90c825a6168a7346d8af28d9f9cc","paperId":"1811.06520","sourceSha256":"4ac27b36557b10d3b6bfebe1267282dcece6cecd99dc34e755527a6dfebbdd52","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/15e14f94cdaf9763147e/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"16aa1a58b961f209d3639d9dfc2ee9a43fb877152198a68c18c8106bdee90691","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"07ebfd7cc3c06c7cc90db3069f1fff015a401c738d9561ff16d3b785494196b8","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:292dd782a62f7640f580ea8f","recordId":"leaf-71728a1cff56ec63dfed-challenge:p1","proposalReviewId":"leaf-71728a1cff56ec63dfed-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-71728a1cff56ec63dfed-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"May 2019 version proposes instability-driven stochastic selection. Sub-Planckian scanning, strong CP and all-CDM compatibility are linked targets, not fully re-","challengeNote":"May 2019 version proposes instability-driven stochastic selection. Sub-Planckian scanning, inflationary duration, strong CP and all-CDM compatibility are comp","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"b7b37f178d04be9989fff10918c7cc4eaf592c3bd734e579c673e769c3bd714d"},"organizational-access:31a7f758aaccab5b364a2fc7":{"id":"organizational-access:31a7f758aaccab5b364a2fc7","source":"q025-candidate-region:f2fc15151767e8d57cba3e6a","target":"q025-candidate-question:cfa5cb52681b4df887e3555a","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:f2fc15151767e8d57cba3e6a","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"46c9ac144d6d8a4826942bf7411c4d9dc63f508c9b15d3bd0de891f729bb4be7","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:1f4a64412945907171f4ebd8"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:cfa5cb52681b4df887e3555a","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"baa1cec19ba0a06a7d156de2d130d70cd2634436973bd5f90b0d6ed1b69e9b53","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:6099bc9cb4d3928d5800a385"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","home":{"unitId":"unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f2fc15151767e8d57cba3e6a","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The complete source question is organizationally placed within this admitted scope, retaining source-specific systems, regimes and reading limits. This does not assert question equivalence or method applicability.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","paperId":"2005.12304","textSha256":"e7f81dec05e5e893713eb0bcefa1a91b22885723b3d7175a3843c0d68d926d2a"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3fb87ad6138f2325483f4723"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3fb87ad6138f2325483f4723","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","q025-candidate-region:f2fc15151767e8d57cba3e6a"],"scopeContentSha256":"46c9ac144d6d8a4826942bf7411c4d9dc63f508c9b15d3bd0de891f729bb4be7","placementContentSha256":"1bb43959f72839f9c6ef9b0a67f580fa08deed821ceb015337caacb675cea456","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge","leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","paperId":"2005.12304","textSha256":"e7f81dec05e5e893713eb0bcefa1a91b22885723b3d7175a3843c0d68d926d2a"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:3fb87ad6138f2325483f4723"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:cfa5cb52681b4df887e3555a","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","textSha256":"e7f81dec05e5e893713eb0bcefa1a91b22885723b3d7175a3843c0d68d926d2a"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a52fd5c3c33d6adf5fe342ac","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Gauge consistency, scattering, conjectural and magnetar constraints remain distinct tests of charge. Independent challenge qualification: Gauge consistency, scattering, conjectural and magnetar bounds are distinct tests of charge."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:a52fd5c3c33d6adf5fe342ac","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","q025-candidate-question:cfa5cb52681b4df887e3555a"],"scopeContentSha256":"baa1cec19ba0a06a7d156de2d130d70cd2634436973bd5f90b0d6ed1b69e9b53","contributionContentSha256":"ed9531e313a108e96bef742479fa2b1f638db7f20f3fc6aabcd47459bd7813e3","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-proposal","leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d7","kind":"description","unitIndex":7,"unitId":"unit:ee34de38b13a03b73f0c5d1d90e79490e5a26b320aad11591e1b6501acd13904","textSha256":"e7f81dec05e5e893713eb0bcefa1a91b22885723b3d7175a3843c0d68d926d2a"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:a52fd5c3c33d6adf5fe342ac","recordId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge:p4","proposalReviewId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-5063c04bb11eb0924b1d-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","proposalNote":"Gauge consistency, scattering, conjectural and magnetar constraints remain distinct tests of charge.","challengeNote":"Gauge consistency, scattering, conjectural and magnetar bounds are distinct tests of charge.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"ea1f16ed8fff06d07493e7b26a77db9acd5f93dd639daadd04d3febdc0cea843"},"organizational-access:337f3bbe0e471d979856decf":{"id":"organizational-access:337f3bbe0e471d979856decf","source":"q025-candidate-region:f4b2c8b298db32a095b85918","target":"q025-candidate-question:8447e00133a49c08c82040ee","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:f4b2c8b298db32a095b85918","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"9c56fd5b553c24e13cc678811979898240514dfda4c2e1cef58e04b1c26c551e","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:c437ac6237d8663aa876e79b"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:8447e00133a49c08c82040ee","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"b207f70104717bd785c0fce17d3150edc814dbbd7de38f4e44d2106f7a1241c3","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:e3f55d2f36a902b52bcb8c5a"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:1a23ff128e7ecc8f4e9bf8fa0ed6a32520caea361d597ce7b8148915ba2e8e1e","home":{"unitId":"unit:1a23ff128e7ecc8f4e9bf8fa0ed6a32520caea361d597ce7b8148915ba2e8e1e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f4b2c8b298db32a095b85918","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1a23ff128e7ecc8f4e9bf8fa0ed6a32520caea361d597ce7b8148915ba2e8e1e","paperId":"2506.05173","textSha256":"56a85b9fd37dc60da9686e6bb39d97da3029e4428b193f3abe4e186628148cac"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1ea60a72b0d654fef95e9e89"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1ea60a72b0d654fef95e9e89","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1a23ff128e7ecc8f4e9bf8fa0ed6a32520caea361d597ce7b8148915ba2e8e1e","q025-candidate-region:f4b2c8b298db32a095b85918"],"scopeContentSha256":"9c56fd5b553c24e13cc678811979898240514dfda4c2e1cef58e04b1c26c551e","placementContentSha256":"7e7b7fed2657ff1b5b9e398f9680e8865df3aa7717cc331162279931e29aba1d","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge","leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:1a23ff128e7ecc8f4e9bf8fa0ed6a32520caea361d597ce7b8148915ba2e8e1e","paperId":"2506.05173","textSha256":"56a85b9fd37dc60da9686e6bb39d97da3029e4428b193f3abe4e186628148cac"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:1ea60a72b0d654fef95e9e89"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:1a23ff128e7ecc8f4e9bf8fa0ed6a32520caea361d597ce7b8148915ba2e8e1e","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8447e00133a49c08c82040ee","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:1a23ff128e7ecc8f4e9bf8fa0ed6a32520caea361d597ce7b8148915ba2e8e1e","textSha256":"56a85b9fd37dc60da9686e6bb39d97da3029e4428b193f3abe4e186628148cac"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:22923f17ae6db21e7e3c50e7"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:22923f17ae6db21e7e3c50e7","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:1a23ff128e7ecc8f4e9bf8fa0ed6a32520caea361d597ce7b8148915ba2e8e1e","q025-candidate-question:8447e00133a49c08c82040ee"],"scopeContentSha256":"b207f70104717bd785c0fce17d3150edc814dbbd7de38f4e44d2106f7a1241c3","contributionContentSha256":"b5c5b67aa780e0a1a7ae00eefadd1f4ccb961ca9a8d3a73eb3ea039e360f37aa","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-proposal","leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d34","kind":"description","unitIndex":34,"unitId":"unit:1a23ff128e7ecc8f4e9bf8fa0ed6a32520caea361d597ce7b8148915ba2e8e1e","textSha256":"56a85b9fd37dc60da9686e6bb39d97da3029e4428b193f3abe4e186628148cac"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:22923f17ae6db21e7e3c50e7","recordId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Consistency and connectivity remain separate targets in the non-geometric sector.","challengeNote":"Consistency and connectivity remain distinct targets in the non-geometric sector.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:9b5ab8372705655d82ee3bfe3cf8c1cb2fda4b4100b573a2d02f7aa2a0b814ba","home":{"unitId":"unit:9b5ab8372705655d82ee3bfe3cf8c1cb2fda4b4100b573a2d02f7aa2a0b814ba","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f4b2c8b298db32a095b85918","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9b5ab8372705655d82ee3bfe3cf8c1cb2fda4b4100b573a2d02f7aa2a0b814ba","paperId":"2610.10711","textSha256":"a760702c3df73773b5e74e246e520c563d36a415eed2a07a94fcbcc874533047"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8af96c947b83405e45ef4290"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8af96c947b83405e45ef4290","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9b5ab8372705655d82ee3bfe3cf8c1cb2fda4b4100b573a2d02f7aa2a0b814ba","q025-candidate-region:f4b2c8b298db32a095b85918"],"scopeContentSha256":"9c56fd5b553c24e13cc678811979898240514dfda4c2e1cef58e04b1c26c551e","placementContentSha256":"870d8cad608dacd1fb20abf9063e6483742e8f690ec77fbb64fecf3ddcf6ce5a","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge","leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:9b5ab8372705655d82ee3bfe3cf8c1cb2fda4b4100b573a2d02f7aa2a0b814ba","paperId":"2610.10711","textSha256":"a760702c3df73773b5e74e246e520c563d36a415eed2a07a94fcbcc874533047"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:8af96c947b83405e45ef4290"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:9b5ab8372705655d82ee3bfe3cf8c1cb2fda4b4100b573a2d02f7aa2a0b814ba","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8447e00133a49c08c82040ee","role":"addresses","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:9b5ab8372705655d82ee3bfe3cf8c1cb2fda4b4100b573a2d02f7aa2a0b814ba","textSha256":"a760702c3df73773b5e74e246e520c563d36a415eed2a07a94fcbcc874533047"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1e4c92fab36b5fb45ccf8ea7"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:1e4c92fab36b5fb45ccf8ea7","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:9b5ab8372705655d82ee3bfe3cf8c1cb2fda4b4100b573a2d02f7aa2a0b814ba","q025-candidate-question:8447e00133a49c08c82040ee"],"scopeContentSha256":"b207f70104717bd785c0fce17d3150edc814dbbd7de38f4e44d2106f7a1241c3","contributionContentSha256":"2faa96a99d180a7ef025adda9f8acca676ef4672d25f8891ae17eb128948549f","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-proposal","leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d41","kind":"description","unitIndex":41,"unitId":"unit:9b5ab8372705655d82ee3bfe3cf8c1cb2fda4b4100b573a2d02f7aa2a0b814ba","textSha256":"a760702c3df73773b5e74e246e520c563d36a415eed2a07a94fcbcc874533047"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:1e4c92fab36b5fb45ccf8ea7","recordId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Reconstruction of the complete closed BPS cone and tensor moduli space is the target; completeness and resulting obstructions are not verified here.","challengeNote":"Compound targets: complete cone/moduli reconstruction and additional obstructions. Completeness is sought, not established by the description.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]},{"unitId":"unit:d7425436138b2c46698af19b33f1a9f174d1e22727b784be92c95778e956a481","home":{"unitId":"unit:d7425436138b2c46698af19b33f1a9f174d1e22727b784be92c95778e956a481","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:f4b2c8b298db32a095b85918","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"workRelation":"on","qualification":"The entire compound source question has one reviewed whole-family home. Distinct subtargets and their typed contributions remain visible; this does not certify atomic identity or equivalence, and does not split allocation automatically.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d7425436138b2c46698af19b33f1a9f174d1e22727b784be92c95778e956a481","paperId":"2603.17713","textSha256":"699a6aafd7ae263fbc8b15cb09fb8cd7611d512f712b2c265867da51ac3a315f"}],"decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7a47068c778c577a1d9da0c7"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7a47068c778c577a1d9da0c7","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d7425436138b2c46698af19b33f1a9f174d1e22727b784be92c95778e956a481","q025-candidate-region:f4b2c8b298db32a095b85918"],"scopeContentSha256":"9c56fd5b553c24e13cc678811979898240514dfda4c2e1cef58e04b1c26c551e","placementContentSha256":"b8194ba32864a4758a643e5823fa9fdcf1f178216ddfb02452b65c4f79447408","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_placement","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_agreed","adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../organization-v4/admitted-v1/policy-admission.json","sha256":"b5520cd866efcbd7deb243b88c39e613c0b762009a2df7f5b19e1cb4fa5eddaa","bytes":308046}},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge","leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-proposal"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:d7425436138b2c46698af19b33f1a9f174d1e22727b784be92c95778e956a481","paperId":"2603.17713","textSha256":"699a6aafd7ae263fbc8b15cb09fb8cd7611d512f712b2c265867da51ac3a315f"}],"sourceAgreementBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/organization-v4/admitted-v1/placement-bindings.local.json","sha256":"6667c6510cf0348cd57fc2602b5a866c988a18c7643e94813da3165d1ad1b2b9","decisionId":"decision:approved-home-policy-v5:7a47068c778c577a1d9da0c7"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:d7425436138b2c46698af19b33f1a9f174d1e22727b784be92c95778e956a481","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:8447e00133a49c08c82040ee","role":"specializes","basis":"description_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:d7425436138b2c46698af19b33f1a9f174d1e22727b784be92c95778e956a481","textSha256":"699a6aafd7ae263fbc8b15cb09fb8cd7611d512f712b2c265867da51ac3a315f"}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:021ffcad5dfe4dc398a800c2"},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:021ffcad5dfe4dc398a800c2","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:d7425436138b2c46698af19b33f1a9f174d1e22727b784be92c95778e956a481","q025-candidate-question:8447e00133a49c08c82040ee"],"scopeContentSha256":"b207f70104717bd785c0fce17d3150edc814dbbd7de38f4e44d2106f7a1241c3","contributionContentSha256":"3f0c8cc17095302e6dba8ae21b985cc7ccda981c41ccd892ee507c570a632ab1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-proposal","leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d38","kind":"description","unitIndex":38,"unitId":"unit:d7425436138b2c46698af19b33f1a9f174d1e22727b784be92c95778e956a481","textSha256":"699a6aafd7ae263fbc8b15cb09fb8cd7611d512f712b2c265867da51ac3a315f"}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:021ffcad5dfe4dc398a800c2","recordId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-f78166e21bc03445425d-challenge","proposalBasis":"description","challengeBasis":"description","commonBasis":"description_checked","commonPrimaryWindowCount":0,"proposalNote":"Compound targets: tests of five candidates, refined elliptic genera and global gauge groups.","challengeNote":"Compound targets: tests of five candidates, refined elliptic genera and global gauge groups.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"publicationStatus":"scope/contribution admission only; canonical reconciliation, exact homes, routes and editorial status remain separate"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":3,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"4cbc43e5c69a0e9018f68e6fdf2d139ed9de64c4d5662fc299c744f3c631dc91"},"organizational-access:ca37c5c77bcffc51226a671a":{"id":"organizational-access:ca37c5c77bcffc51226a671a","source":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","target":"q025-candidate-question:72bd8d88840080a7e94a11c7","sourceKind":"region","targetKind":"question","policyClass":"broad_home_to_question","endpointBindings":{"source":{"id":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","kind":"region","scopeContentSha256":"24d924b5a5bc7ad2a4781a4ea77c66d1d13b0049360b252c512645dbbd8609aa","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:bc050ef03b26e140d58a392e"},"target":{"id":"q025-candidate-question:72bd8d88840080a7e94a11c7","kind":"question","scopeContentSha256":"579fdb39e8a706682349be3b34ed74accad93addd983e991dce1b1de36c938af","scopeDecisionId":"decision:scope:957bab5c7ca52f9a28a61a3b"}},"witnesses":[{"unitId":"unit:bf40421712b0d217a22c6d4bf39582855ec9be408acbdc6f3ce29e123b2b3792","home":{"unitId":"unit:bf40421712b0d217a22c6d4bf39582855ec9be408acbdc6f3ce29e123b2b3792","destinationId":"q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f","role":"member","status":"accepted","basis":"description_checked","allocationWeight":1,"reason":"Covers alternative axion inflation mechanisms, stabilization hierarchies and cosmological completion across inflationary and post-inflationary epochs.","qualification":"q22 covers both inflationary alternatives, stabilization hierarchies and post-inflationary cosmological completion. Natural inflation remains distinct from monodromy, and preferential Standard Model reheating remains an additional required phase rather than a consequence inferred from inflation.","evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bf40421712b0d217a22c6d4bf39582855ec9be408acbdc6f3ce29e123b2b3792","paperId":"1404.3542","textSha256":"f382d69520b842457cd21dbee1b7057c2383438eb5f7239a560faa44a0ec9533"}],"decisionId":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0041:u29:q22"},"homeDecision":{"id":"decision:placement-continuation:placement-continuation-0041:u29:q22","type":"placement","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bf40421712b0d217a22c6d4bf39582855ec9be408acbdc6f3ce29e123b2b3792","q025-candidate-region:fd1e4849fda34877708a1d5f"],"scopeContentSha256":"24d924b5a5bc7ad2a4781a4ea77c66d1d13b0049360b252c512645dbbd8609aa","placementContentSha256":"7a342b8e2c038987389cd11d5516ad994182597d3825f3809d11d696f2c7e657","challengerAgreement":"not_reviewed_as_allocation","sourceEvidenceAgreement":"independently_retained_whole_home_judgment","sourceReviewIds":["incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0041:proposal","incremental-placement:placement-continuation-0041:challenge","root:incremental-placement-cut-04"],"evidenceRefs":[{"kind":"description","unitId":"unit:bf40421712b0d217a22c6d4bf39582855ec9be408acbdc6f3ce29e123b2b3792","paperId":"1404.3542","textSha256":"f382d69520b842457cd21dbee1b7057c2383438eb5f7239a560faa44a0ec9533"}],"adjudication":{"status":"accepted_explicit_placement","receipt":{"path":"../../placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/admitted/admission.json","sha256":"1d4ebe750d9c867d59156d8b48e00362cb43cdc4618f38ef17b1c7f495b91cb2"}},"sourceBinding":{"path":"research/q025/assembly/placement-incremental-v1/cut-04/source-bindings.local.json","sha256":"db173f2f83dee5596f26d8f3830599f581b129b7ea3a0fcc1e9c4e3a2367d2d0","bytes":17667769,"familyId":"placement-continuation-0041","unitRef":"u29"}},"observations":[{"contribution":{"unitId":"unit:bf40421712b0d217a22c6d4bf39582855ec9be408acbdc6f3ce29e123b2b3792","destinationId":"q025-candidate-question:72bd8d88840080a7e94a11c7","role":"addresses","basis":"source_excerpt_checked","evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:bf40421712b0d217a22c6d4bf39582855ec9be408acbdc6f3ce29e123b2b3792","textSha256":"f382d69520b842457cd21dbee1b7057c2383438eb5f7239a560faa44a0ec9533"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4be863b9c090131be0d24acb0a3ad18f","paperId":"1404.3542","sourceSha256":"5d8a092137d38fe96b645d69d9046d5dd5d723e9b8c09a7745a1e2127fbf218a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/51b3841e9f578e2c72f5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"be993310c91afe6302032765270fbc1fe8b5591880129c9d7a3c5a5f7713edf1","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"023d043f299901003aab50ac0d92a238a42680aa55b31ac10868a8bd7800f269","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7c44e384ddec4e7583ff6a0202ecc507","paperId":"1404.3542","sourceSha256":"5d8a092137d38fe96b645d69d9046d5dd5d723e9b8c09a7745a1e2127fbf218a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/51b3841e9f578e2c72f5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"be993310c91afe6302032765270fbc1fe8b5591880129c9d7a3c5a5f7713edf1","pdfPage":1,"start":2502,"end":4969,"textSha256":"5621065bdc5e95e700c2571511992dbc56421b5f2c8b68249ae1a78efef5cc7d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:75f0c167936fac7dc8304874df8a1e86","paperId":"1404.3542","sourceSha256":"5d8a092137d38fe96b645d69d9046d5dd5d723e9b8c09a7745a1e2127fbf218a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/51b3841e9f578e2c72f5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"be993310c91afe6302032765270fbc1fe8b5591880129c9d7a3c5a5f7713edf1","pdfPage":2,"start":1315,"end":4362,"textSha256":"01f5f749459b35e4129c392d302ef39a8ac027447a7a396cc655db865318fe13","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:feb86eaf4b6430c25637f947","qualification":"Original proposal qualification: Compound natural/flux-monodromy alternatives plus reheating; no single fine canonical question is established. Independent challenge qualification: Natural and flux-monodromy alternatives plus reheating form a compound source; atomic identity remains unresolved."},"contributionDecision":{"id":"decision:source-contribution:feb86eaf4b6430c25637f947","type":"source_contribution","status":"accepted","subjectIds":["unit:bf40421712b0d217a22c6d4bf39582855ec9be408acbdc6f3ce29e123b2b3792","q025-candidate-question:72bd8d88840080a7e94a11c7"],"scopeContentSha256":"579fdb39e8a706682349be3b34ed74accad93addd983e991dce1b1de36c938af","contributionContentSha256":"95d129865215c8e85398e18c9e1da39dffca11e289847262371bf3bdafbad1c1","challengerAgreement":"independently_agreed","reviewAgreement":{"proposalReviewId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-challenge"},"sourceReviewIds":["leaf-03743073a7938a015819-proposal","leaf-03743073a7938a015819-challenge"],"evidenceRefs":[{"localRef":"d6","kind":"description","unitIndex":6,"unitId":"unit:bf40421712b0d217a22c6d4bf39582855ec9be408acbdc6f3ce29e123b2b3792","textSha256":"f382d69520b842457cd21dbee1b7057c2383438eb5f7239a560faa44a0ec9533"},{"localRef":"e5","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:4be863b9c090131be0d24acb0a3ad18f","paperId":"1404.3542","sourceSha256":"5d8a092137d38fe96b645d69d9046d5dd5d723e9b8c09a7745a1e2127fbf218a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/51b3841e9f578e2c72f5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"be993310c91afe6302032765270fbc1fe8b5591880129c9d7a3c5a5f7713edf1","pdfPage":2,"start":0,"end":3000,"textSha256":"023d043f299901003aab50ac0d92a238a42680aa55b31ac10868a8bd7800f269","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e14","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:7c44e384ddec4e7583ff6a0202ecc507","paperId":"1404.3542","sourceSha256":"5d8a092137d38fe96b645d69d9046d5dd5d723e9b8c09a7745a1e2127fbf218a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/51b3841e9f578e2c72f5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"be993310c91afe6302032765270fbc1fe8b5591880129c9d7a3c5a5f7713edf1","pdfPage":1,"start":2502,"end":4969,"textSha256":"5621065bdc5e95e700c2571511992dbc56421b5f2c8b68249ae1a78efef5cc7d","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}},{"localRef":"e13","kind":"primary","sourceId":"ev:75f0c167936fac7dc8304874df8a1e86","paperId":"1404.3542","sourceSha256":"5d8a092137d38fe96b645d69d9046d5dd5d723e9b8c09a7745a1e2127fbf218a","sourceContext":{"path":"papers/51b3841e9f578e2c72f5/reading-order.json","fileSha256":"be993310c91afe6302032765270fbc1fe8b5591880129c9d7a3c5a5f7713edf1","pdfPage":2,"start":1315,"end":4362,"textSha256":"01f5f749459b35e4129c392d302ef39a8ac027447a7a396cc655db865318fe13","quoteExactInPage":true,"scope":"Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."}}],"readingAgreement":{"decisionId":"decision:source-contribution:feb86eaf4b6430c25637f947","recordId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-challenge:p3","proposalReviewId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-proposal","challengeReviewId":"leaf-03743073a7938a015819-challenge","proposalBasis":"excerpt","challengeBasis":"excerpt","commonBasis":"source_excerpt_checked","proposalNote":"Compound natural/flux-monodromy alternatives plus reheating; no single fine canonical question is established.","challengeNote":"Natural and flux-monodromy alternatives plus reheating form a compound source; atomic identity remains unresolved.","dispositionAgreement":true,"factorIdentityAndPlacementAgreementNotInferred":true,"unresolvedFactorQualificationsNotPromoted":true},"policyContinuationReceipt":{"path":"research/q025/evaluation/full-pass/admissions-v3/scope-role-admission-v3.json","sha256":"814536aec90aabf250309c4cd63bd6cc0e926e931bcaffcd285cf710aca7cf03"}}}]}],"uniqueWitnessCount":1,"semantics":"Exact same-source organizational access; no implication, containment, premise transfer, equivalence, source allocation or method applicability.","reviewBasis":"Explicit coordinator composition policy, not independently reviewed physical relation","certificateSha256":"5f6d5c4c9232088fdc34ca79d99f24b55dc78bac7636a0666648da7fc29ff7c9"}}}
