Original proposal qualification: The physical tower remains open. Finite-charge extremality, infinite entropy and the contradictory entropy wording must remain distinct. Independent challenge qualification: The generic extremal tower is explicitly unidentified. Gap expectations and conflicting entropy wording retain their extracted-context status.
Which tower realizes infinite entropy distance for extremal black holes when internal KK modes can remain heavy and the proposed horizon gaps already vanish at zero temperature? The paper identifies this as unresolved.
Exact source: unit:741c400f8c7d9e05a9bdf8f21ee215002a661a39063f6e5e923715f42a5a323c. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:a4481be23797aa9b72592ece.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1912.07453","sourceSha256":"11991746d8ebb36a9838376559e09f0818801df85b049f8793ad939aa17e5a2b","pages":[12,13],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:3b4d2c7510287f900f95d09fa6ee0980","source-graph:ev:cc591861850d264b92a17d01c9da4ff7"]}
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d5",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 5,
"unitId": "unit:741c400f8c7d9e05a9bdf8f21ee215002a661a39063f6e5e923715f42a5a323c",
"textSha256": "eedb55414818da985bc914daa6e72c502a3a52179f0b00f51e8cc01db0e89821"
},
{
"localRef": "e5",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:3b4d2c7510287f900f95d09fa6ee0980",
"paperId": "1912.07453",
"sourceSha256": "11991746d8ebb36a9838376559e09f0818801df85b049f8793ad939aa17e5a2b",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/8eb875637d2e1e1c1762/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "27c6c5dc16a8915cb7de2b3768958ace48f5582d51a9cfaf6a035995a84f2e55",
"pdfPage": 13,
"start": 0,
"end": 3000,
"textSha256": "cdcdaa65bfe60ae9ab5a6468e4dbd99e8fa0fdea0023578889f3827efe3e33fe",
"quoteExactInPage": false,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e14",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:97db9273ffdaa343dd25bee9492ddda1",
"paperId": "1912.07453",
"sourceSha256": "11991746d8ebb36a9838376559e09f0818801df85b049f8793ad939aa17e5a2b",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/8eb875637d2e1e1c1762/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "27c6c5dc16a8915cb7de2b3768958ace48f5582d51a9cfaf6a035995a84f2e55",
"pdfPage": 5,
"start": 0,
"end": 3000,
"textSha256": "c8ee52054174c8d5d174d3835bf90717f8bea47d60e666c6a0c9bdf63b9c4a18",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e18",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:d3c34023ddf7b9a880b3c3a1e6f0b6c5",
"paperId": "1912.07453",
"sourceSha256": "11991746d8ebb36a9838376559e09f0818801df85b049f8793ad939aa17e5a2b",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/8eb875637d2e1e1c1762/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "27c6c5dc16a8915cb7de2b3768958ace48f5582d51a9cfaf6a035995a84f2e55",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 3583,
"end": 4929,
"textSha256": "1bd5294c93e7b1c08ec7549d13adea7655859447765ca58959f4b90321c78e92",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "9df64c2f64b2d5746a806079f6d530f423d9f04de331b6a574c1cd43d1c79010",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:a4481be23797aa9b72592ece",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal",
"leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-5e48162a149e4716f5c6-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
}