Under what charge spacing, symmetry structure and state-family assumptions do lowest charged dimensions obey superadditivity or convexity, and where do proposed universal versions fail?
Separates discrete superadditivity, restricted Goldstone-family convexity, multidirectional extensions and asymptotic moduli-space questions.
Semiclassical fixed-charge calculations; Goldstone consistency; Large-charge EFT; Model-specific perturbative tests
8 extracted descriptions checked; 3 source excerpts checked.
Bounded primary pages include the 3 Mar 2023 v1 Goldstone result and the later EFT discussion. Multisymmetry onset, meson tests and moduli-tower bounds are description-only. Reported counterexamples do not certify every formulation's status.
Separately admitted review observations are retained for each source-and-role relationship. These reviewed roles are separate from source membership. A shared source does not establish question equivalence; a method contribution does not certify applicability.
- addresses — description_checked
Convexity of charged operators in CFTs and the weak gravity conjecture
Original proposal qualification: Links a self-binding proposal to a proposed universal CFT constraint. Independent challenge qualification: Links a self-binding proposal to a proposed universal CFT constraint.
Can a weak-gravity principle formulated through nonnegative self-binding energy motivate a universal constraint on the lowest dimensions of charged CFT operators, including theories without weakly curved gravitational duals?
Exact source: unit:9d8495c4771721ac72aab3749e6613a8117a23f15d4454a8f299482d1e17069e. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:7801a328005c39d7d976018b.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2108.04594","sourceSha256":"7d2ec7a5ece707ad213fe407903b65ceb1c4c4233addba3be0f382a9094912bc","pages":[1,3],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:41e7c402aab0220589e9f199c9f40c13","source-graph:ev:4647c6b94b94d8a53bb766aa14ec0165","source-graph:ev:6a46ec4fe598646f551b2d1df77cb393"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d15",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 15,
"unitId": "unit:9d8495c4771721ac72aab3749e6613a8117a23f15d4454a8f299482d1e17069e",
"textSha256": "8d909a0f91ee121c921be3b56f0c542eb30f74f22fc72ae6f9b5e1833b24caa2"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "1e49318cc454657fda713f24d90218ea071baee0e463ea99d1a9ee04d300718b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:7801a328005c39d7d976018b",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - addresses — source_excerpt_checked
More on the weak gravity conjecture via convexity of charged operators
Original proposal qualification: Compound tests include complex spectra and an explicitly falsified multidirectional extension. Independent challenge qualification: Compound 2021 tests: e25 explicitly falsifies the fixed-sign extension. The broader claim's historical status uses later supplied context; complex-dimension and
Which precise charged-operator inequalities express the convex charge conjecture, and do semiclassical fixed-charge spectra support them beyond small-charge perturbation theory? The paper also investigates complex dimensions and a proposed extension to different charge directions.
Exact source: unit:8979341f210af0439fc577d5cc1f50fd2a759f3542a5ee14b712b64ac44080c1. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:54b455c3e7bb924d016ff9d8.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2109.04946","sourceSha256":"82f5de8c368446c76cc1d49f062954a41fd2b9b783dbb93868d5829fb9668c38","pages":[2,3,7],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:140997bfe73c3490773983f90740dff1","source-graph:ev:166b2dee31865dc2f4527a2ea40b311b","source-graph:ev:f6bffab230d4c36533d0f4a109670389"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d16",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 16,
"unitId": "unit:8979341f210af0439fc577d5cc1f50fd2a759f3542a5ee14b712b64ac44080c1",
"textSha256": "74e94654575f48efe479d10899f86167351611d975b3daf162943f0f54d7624e"
},
{
"localRef": "e2",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:140997bfe73c3490773983f90740dff1",
"paperId": "2109.04946",
"sourceSha256": "82f5de8c368446c76cc1d49f062954a41fd2b9b783dbb93868d5829fb9668c38",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/3ea7ed17979f777edc7e/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "eb38baa8ee99409fdfb378ef4645afeeb7f394c4e227141de26b2325154dd3fd",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 113,
"end": 3504,
"textSha256": "5a4a0844dc73c8400d888515a123293dfbcc278c463aa5342493e48cf3ec7f3a",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e3",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:166b2dee31865dc2f4527a2ea40b311b",
"paperId": "2109.04946",
"sourceSha256": "82f5de8c368446c76cc1d49f062954a41fd2b9b783dbb93868d5829fb9668c38",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/3ea7ed17979f777edc7e/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "eb38baa8ee99409fdfb378ef4645afeeb7f394c4e227141de26b2325154dd3fd",
"pdfPage": 3,
"start": 99,
"end": 3496,
"textSha256": "e17ed45f482cbf7eed63f5ab1fc59a87e4cf7deda941d74ee330dcf1bcdcb536",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e25",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:f6bffab230d4c36533d0f4a109670389",
"paperId": "2109.04946",
"sourceSha256": "82f5de8c368446c76cc1d49f062954a41fd2b9b783dbb93868d5829fb9668c38",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/3ea7ed17979f777edc7e/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "eb38baa8ee99409fdfb378ef4645afeeb7f394c4e227141de26b2325154dd3fd",
"pdfPage": 7,
"start": 0,
"end": 3000,
"textSha256": "1e31604a4d9c758d44613f1fef7ee63c01bb5d2ade9da476e0b26163331d9a18",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "1e49318cc454657fda713f24d90218ea071baee0e463ea99d1a9ee04d300718b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:54b455c3e7bb924d016ff9d8",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - specializes — description_checked
Convexity of charged operators in CFTs with multiple Abelian symmetries
Original proposal qualification: Independent challenge qualification:
How should the charge scale for convexity of lowest-dimension charged operators be defined independently of basis when a CFT has multiple Abelian symmetries, and can that scale become parametrically large?
Exact source: unit:c0698189e63c6d8c9083006f743adee6761c1dcec270153a2f4cdb9d33773604. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:33c1dee96af12580998ebb66.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2206.06703","sourceSha256":"3458d062be436d9969e8ee026fafd2712bc7b026d4832036a75812cfe4b6bb99","pages":[3,4],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:10b27de924e48e9fbb24174e3971cd5b","source-graph:ev:16a642c9eaee75dce86fee2bd3f58b84","source-graph:ev:56370f1703036d0847a5a5d7c3928af2"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d22",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 22,
"unitId": "unit:c0698189e63c6d8c9083006f743adee6761c1dcec270153a2f4cdb9d33773604",
"textSha256": "58f2b91353f86c12915cfd776759019c0fc88a2a932c9cc02dde625e0b9c495c"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "1e49318cc454657fda713f24d90218ea071baee0e463ea99d1a9ee04d300718b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:33c1dee96af12580998ebb66",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - addresses — description_checked
A counterexample to the CFT convexity conjecture
Original proposal qualification: Retain the unitary d>2, single-U(1), all-positive-integer-multiples formulation. Independent challenge qualification: Retain unitary d>2, a single U(1) and all positive integer multiples. The description alone does not certify a counterexample.
Must every unitary CFT in d>2 with a single U(1) admit an order-one charge q0 such that its minimum operator dimensions are superadditive on all positive integer multiples of q0, or can the onset charge be parametrically delayed?
Exact source: unit:a98de9aadca0869cfa499c51565d76eedc0e6ca7b25f52807cba0825cfcea2d6. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:032fbc936443c4a1abccd375.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2301.08262","sourceSha256":"517bfc76518f6f475f7def572f1398dd55ab2ec278e9498a1f6b44624dd57f05","pages":[1,2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:294022d968cff201c1c656e93bbb9846","source-graph:ev:c1a3249dcab679ec950f0cf4f9ab0a8b","source-graph:ev:cebf0f59c8a226c3d9b38c6ff9531735"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d24",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 24,
"unitId": "unit:a98de9aadca0869cfa499c51565d76eedc0e6ca7b25f52807cba0825cfcea2d6",
"textSha256": "4b7dce08c40353ced729f920a262ecdd9ff3ed2930910e954092747a673c9e1f"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "1e49318cc454657fda713f24d90218ea071baee0e463ea99d1a9ee04d300718b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:032fbc936443c4a1abccd375",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - specializes — source_excerpt_checked
Goldstone bosons and convexity
Original proposal qualification: Independent challenge qualification:
Does consistency of Goldstone excitations constrain the charge dependence of lowest scalar operator dimensions in a CFT with global U(1), including regimes broader than the usual large-charge expansion?
Exact source: unit:11376646c010b3e51581d0fa24c48f560ec12c0a09de33c2322ac3b9c7333596. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:23c5dc4f1eaf7f1ca1676080.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2303.02178","sourceSha256":"bce101399ee1a2b167d2955c3b9ba641a231bbbe3d5673bb6c73ec748808258b","pages":[1,3],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:2c0ce4f13d08c504a97e1b19d2a6c268","source-graph:ev:4df38b2ebc2727166a2989774fb328d7","source-graph:ev:b0d6fa54fa524196303a98975365c6a6"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d25",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 25,
"unitId": "unit:11376646c010b3e51581d0fa24c48f560ec12c0a09de33c2322ac3b9c7333596",
"textSha256": "c2aec62f80f3ab7e35c2fed367bc456b953c8ee37c60f72bc50b1b9b72173f9a"
},
{
"localRef": "e5",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:2c0ce4f13d08c504a97e1b19d2a6c268",
"paperId": "2303.02178",
"sourceSha256": "bce101399ee1a2b167d2955c3b9ba641a231bbbe3d5673bb6c73ec748808258b",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/a457b70079646396415e/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "e2cb27af1fa6a8851e92c601b98ca379f827bf4a789ed00c5a638a44ffd01904",
"pdfPage": 1,
"start": 105,
"end": 1376,
"textSha256": "78d5d58936a1ac3a7d1377d1edd60014303c9a05435bc13c7a20508b464a8cd4",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e6",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:4df38b2ebc2727166a2989774fb328d7",
"paperId": "2303.02178",
"sourceSha256": "bce101399ee1a2b167d2955c3b9ba641a231bbbe3d5673bb6c73ec748808258b",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/a457b70079646396415e/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "e2cb27af1fa6a8851e92c601b98ca379f827bf4a789ed00c5a638a44ffd01904",
"pdfPage": 3,
"start": 0,
"end": 2962,
"textSha256": "63a1eb130bee1f90a05722997d051fe8e4cf95dd31eac59c49b10bf757f6e658",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e20",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:b0d6fa54fa524196303a98975365c6a6",
"paperId": "2303.02178",
"sourceSha256": "bce101399ee1a2b167d2955c3b9ba641a231bbbe3d5673bb6c73ec748808258b",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/a457b70079646396415e/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "e2cb27af1fa6a8851e92c601b98ca379f827bf4a789ed00c5a638a44ffd01904",
"pdfPage": 1,
"start": 0,
"end": 1376,
"textSha256": "f540adfbf4fa2c2eec8e719541c5a22f47ed5770df712fe3c69084664cffd16a",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "1e49318cc454657fda713f24d90218ea071baee0e463ea99d1a9ee04d300718b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:23c5dc4f1eaf7f1ca1676080",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - specializes — description_checked
Tests of the Charge Convexity Conjecture in Caswell-Banks-Zaks theory
Original proposal qualification: The product-symmetry extension is a test target; its outcome is not supplied. Independent challenge qualification: The product-symmetry extension is a test target; its outcome and equivalence to the falsified fixed-sign extension are not supplied.
Does the Charge Convexity Conjecture (CCC), including its proposed extension to products of global-symmetry factors, hold for the lowest charged mesons at weakly coupled four-dimensional Caswell–Banks–Zaks fixed points?
Exact source: unit:f671cc6868a90ad35ed9a9358ea43b28378b3769161dd4b761364aecea862811. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:cd8bf111e5c51c6bc09d1a1d.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2305.08947","sourceSha256":"0e0f0cb1d0541af78a9f051c92dd2aebb39edfafe36bafb6d0c852d6f4e3ad43","pages":[2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:7c27607912b6cc0de77dae5886c76914","source-graph:ev:881c3876059b0e868b03983051b13fae","source-graph:ev:933e37553042993e5d102e616a7fa688"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d26",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 26,
"unitId": "unit:f671cc6868a90ad35ed9a9358ea43b28378b3769161dd4b761364aecea862811",
"textSha256": "8176778bbaa5ec16cfe3b8871e46f1110502877d24c9a0414ac943a45831fdd7"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "1e49318cc454657fda713f24d90218ea071baee0e463ea99d1a9ee04d300718b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:cd8bf111e5c51c6bc09d1a1d",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - addresses — source_excerpt_checked
Superadditivity at large charge
Original proposal qualification: Compound spacing and EFT-sufficiency tests; the violating EFT has no known UV completion. Independent challenge qualification: Compound spacing and EFT-sufficiency tests; the potentially violating EFT has no known UV completion.
Does the minimal charged-operator dimension satisfy Δ((n1+n2)q0) ≥ Δ(n1q0)+Δ(n2q0) for positive integers n1,n2, particularly at large charge? The paper examines the required charge spacing q0 and whether bottom-up EFT consistency can establish this conjecture.
Exact source: unit:2a5ba695c08eac2c09afe8bfa63a36a8acba0a73a5fbbeb0f6db08757003e84b. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:7a2708ecf3449e63660d1ef1.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2503.16603","sourceSha256":"441a5cf00faa742901b3ff10debbebfbbc388946d0627e32a419c1790e82404c","pages":[3,4],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:70b58001ef92812695c2be30c69c05ea","source-graph:ev:c15f7021e6b6ab72126984bba6c6dec7"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d33",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 33,
"unitId": "unit:2a5ba695c08eac2c09afe8bfa63a36a8acba0a73a5fbbeb0f6db08757003e84b",
"textSha256": "e7e63b7c8939a1a42d042936bf46bdf6ed6adc10afcf1bd24032e915b684b61c"
},
{
"localRef": "e12",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:70b58001ef92812695c2be30c69c05ea",
"paperId": "2503.16603",
"sourceSha256": "441a5cf00faa742901b3ff10debbebfbbc388946d0627e32a419c1790e82404c",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/457ec22afbd170aa8439/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "cc6a22aa90c39462ab063434424b32bd6c8f13c33964b467d70cc1f6dfb39fa3",
"pdfPage": 3,
"start": 1297,
"end": 3210,
"textSha256": "faf8f18ec98d00d02774070ec50c4cd825b6f4b9b7c154ff0fa14f94a28fd8f3",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e21",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:c15f7021e6b6ab72126984bba6c6dec7",
"paperId": "2503.16603",
"sourceSha256": "441a5cf00faa742901b3ff10debbebfbbc388946d0627e32a419c1790e82404c",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/457ec22afbd170aa8439/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "cc6a22aa90c39462ab063434424b32bd6c8f13c33964b467d70cc1f6dfb39fa3",
"pdfPage": 4,
"start": 0,
"end": 2948,
"textSha256": "6ba980477d0269163f03e9e872198d194bde8c0b8f0067673e5fcaad6d82daec",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "1e49318cc454657fda713f24d90218ea071baee0e463ea99d1a9ee04d300718b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:7a2708ecf3449e63660d1ef1",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
} - specializes — description_checked
Towers of Operators in CFTs and Convexity Bounds at Large Charge
Original proposal qualification: Independent challenge qualification: Linked coefficient bounds and asymptotic convexity; neither establishes a universal order-one onset.
For CFTs with moduli spaces and asymptotically linear charged towers, what bounds constrain the slope α1 and subleading coefficient α0? Can moduli-space EFT establish WGC-motivated asymptotic charge convexity?
Exact source: unit:a780eea62f153077b1801932c7ad1178c036c4ca8a4ec38ecf9b62a8244941e7. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:ebad75b6f80baea5ff5ca484.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2607.28726","sourceSha256":"c81d1f6f7cb673fed69c0bd548dfdbc8bc78960911230350115b350f2f850bfa","pages":[1,4,6],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:29d11df59e0ab2a71e0de2a770fc6853","source-graph:ev:6248e27607ae7e1e83c9d9ccc4b84c06","source-graph:ev:ff1960dcf49bd8ea3d929957fb573b43"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d34",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 34,
"unitId": "unit:a780eea62f153077b1801932c7ad1178c036c4ca8a4ec38ecf9b62a8244941e7",
"textSha256": "ab7e0eab2c03d9162c1cd8a7c0b8889f2f8ec6f3a2432db79edb6f253f701f8a"
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "1e49318cc454657fda713f24d90218ea071baee0e463ea99d1a9ee04d300718b",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:ebad75b6f80baea5ff5ca484",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-6b2c2832ade434e899f0-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
}
- AdS weak gravity and binding criteria — comparison (outgoing recorded relation)
Charge inequalities and AdS binding or weak-gravity criteria concern related charged-state data but have different premises and are not equivalent formulations.
Charge inequalities and AdS binding or weak-gravity criteria share charged-state questions but have different assumptions and are not equivalent formulations.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:2b38604788684c564adc1196; 17 source references; SHA-256 d0dc84cf9abdc27ddd1ea5b6b3fa1d006a018f8ad03541266f52a353ebe1e357)
- Conditional holographic consistency tests — comparison (incoming recorded relation)
Charged-dimension inequalities can be compared with gravitational motivations while retaining intrinsic-CFT assumptions and failed universal formulations.
Charged-dimension inequalities can be compared with gravitational consistency motivations while retaining their intrinsic-CFT premises and failed universal formulations.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:3c18313d155607bec501b7f7; 33 source references; SHA-256 7ba18a907a9ba4b6658b2a6b4c350ae751d9de15b8188b1448f2e890ace67a7a)
- Fixed-charge spectra, phases and symmetry breaking — method for (incoming recorded relation)
Controlled charge expansions and applicable Goldstone descriptions provide methods for studying charged dimensions and testing scoped inequality questions. They do not themselves establish a universal inequality.
Apply only to the overlapping systems and controlled regimes, preserving source-specific large-charge, leading-N and dimensional assumptions. Large f can occur outside the large-charge regime. Goldstone-family convexity requires lowest scalar states sharing the stated Goldstone realization and does not extend across competing families. Fixed-spin minima need not equal unrestricted charge-sector minima. Effective-potential convexity does not itself establish charge superadditivity; continuous convexity and the stated discrete superadditivity condition are distinct properties. Minimum charge, chosen spacing and onset remain distinct. Defect and nonrelativistic applications do not automatically transfer, and an EFT without a known UV completion does not establish a CFT counterexample.
Complete source and review record (navigation:orientation-adjudicated:parent-orientation-15:l17; 14 source references; SHA-256 61b0fb882f18bfbb04d2505c249c114bc83513f2a0a8cb00445d3be69e4f0339)
- Local consistency, global structure and state preparation — related question (incoming recorded relation)
Charge spacing, onset and restricted state-family inequalities remain distinct questions about CFT data.
Charge spacing, state-family restrictions and convexity questions remain accessible as distinct questions about CFT data.
Complete source and review record (navigation:parent-reasserted:5f627af341df149813f78b1d; 12 source references; SHA-256 95f91afc808b4ff8458ab0192cccf935e7d86d6b73d52c4d713d2dc85b0d3c9d)
- CFT spectra, consistency constraints and holographic limits — shared source access (incoming recorded relation)
The same source question has a direct reviewed home in this scope and an admitted positive contribution to this scientific scope. The complete qualifications remain in the support certificate.
Complete source and review record (organizational-access:9eb04b75c82c16cb0aebda27; 3 source references; SHA-256 9fc07548210caeda5311c0ff693df9805a133f946815d4164bff17e9da5eecdf)
3 shared source questions across the whole scope, independent of source filters. Shared-source organizational access; witnesses are counted across the whole scope. This is not containment, equivalence, physical implication or established method applicability. Incoming browsing does not reverse a scientific claim.
Witnesses, qualifications and review decisions · Access policy
- Does consistency of Goldstone excitations constrain the charge dependence of lowest scalar operator dimensions in a CFT with global U(1), including regimes broader than the usual large-charge expansion? — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:95601558f93306fc76b1f03a; 1 source references; SHA-256 d137d21c2ab51cf1ef1464bb6ac7ae0691499c9c656952f5e1bb06e8321a5e30)
- Does the Charge Convexity Conjecture (CCC), including its proposed extension to products of global-symmetry factors, hold for the lowest charged mesons at weakly coupled four-dimensional Caswell–Banks–Zaks fixed points? — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:7ffa8ca4e788beac81c63999; 1 source references; SHA-256 ee9f3c38c8f6607221433c7500f877ddb852cc373f3930f407e36ae9cd984cdf)
- How should the charge scale for convexity of lowest-dimension charged operators be defined independently of basis when a CFT has multiple Abelian symmetries, and can that scale become parametrically large? — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:fd98561d9700546f31d16672; 1 source references; SHA-256 05f724369f2f111e444e7be62572c3c33e33ec0cfb9735d2f64e2a279b6ccdf2)
- Must every unitary CFT in d>2 with a single U(1) admit an order-one charge q0 such that its minimum operator dimensions are superadditive on all positive integer multiples of q0, or can the onset charge be parametrically delayed? — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:50ba2c0748e27e79392b08ca; 1 source references; SHA-256 88b52f0d5a221fa62c118d6fd08d2e378ad6633f6af8d4ec713a11edb0287c4e)
- Which precise charged-operator inequalities express the convex charge conjecture, and do semiclassical fixed-charge spectra support them beyond small-charge perturbation theory? The paper also investigates complex dimensions and a proposed extension to different charge directions. — source question (outgoing recorded relation)
Inspect the exact source question contributing to this authored family/card. This access link does not assert equivalence to the overview question.
Complete source and review record (source-access:e6459c535e16249556133eaa; 1 source references; SHA-256 c3d8c3aef0eb6e7eedd5794a0622478720905ce7f467e0542237889ca036be65)
- Goldstone bosons and convexity
Does consistency of Goldstone excitations constrain the charge dependence of lowest scalar operator dimensions in a CFT with global U(1), including regimes broader than the usual large-charge expansion?
Source ID: unit:11376646c010b3e51581d0fa24c48f560ec12c0a09de33c2322ac3b9c7333596
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2303.02178","sourceSha256":"bce101399ee1a2b167d2955c3b9ba641a231bbbe3d5673bb6c73ec748808258b","pages":[1,3],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:2c0ce4f13d08c504a97e1b19d2a6c268","source-graph:ev:4df38b2ebc2727166a2989774fb328d7","source-graph:ev:b0d6fa54fa524196303a98975365c6a6"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- Superadditivity at large charge
Does the minimal charged-operator dimension satisfy Δ((n1+n2)q0) ≥ Δ(n1q0)+Δ(n2q0) for positive integers n1,n2, particularly at large charge? The paper examines the required charge spacing q0 and whether bottom-up EFT consistency can establish this conjecture.
Source ID: unit:2a5ba695c08eac2c09afe8bfa63a36a8acba0a73a5fbbeb0f6db08757003e84b
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2503.16603","sourceSha256":"441a5cf00faa742901b3ff10debbebfbbc388946d0627e32a419c1790e82404c","pages":[3,4],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:70b58001ef92812695c2be30c69c05ea","source-graph:ev:c15f7021e6b6ab72126984bba6c6dec7"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- More on the weak gravity conjecture via convexity of charged operators
Which precise charged-operator inequalities express the convex charge conjecture, and do semiclassical fixed-charge spectra support them beyond small-charge perturbation theory? The paper also investigates complex dimensions and a proposed extension to different charge directions.
Source ID: unit:8979341f210af0439fc577d5cc1f50fd2a759f3542a5ee14b712b64ac44080c1
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2109.04946","sourceSha256":"82f5de8c368446c76cc1d49f062954a41fd2b9b783dbb93868d5829fb9668c38","pages":[2,3,7],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:140997bfe73c3490773983f90740dff1","source-graph:ev:166b2dee31865dc2f4527a2ea40b311b","source-graph:ev:f6bffab230d4c36533d0f4a109670389"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- Convexity of charged operators in CFTs and the weak gravity conjecture
Can a weak-gravity principle formulated through nonnegative self-binding energy motivate a universal constraint on the lowest dimensions of charged CFT operators, including theories without weakly curved gravitational duals?
Source ID: unit:9d8495c4771721ac72aab3749e6613a8117a23f15d4454a8f299482d1e17069e
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2108.04594","sourceSha256":"7d2ec7a5ece707ad213fe407903b65ceb1c4c4233addba3be0f382a9094912bc","pages":[1,3],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:41e7c402aab0220589e9f199c9f40c13","source-graph:ev:4647c6b94b94d8a53bb766aa14ec0165","source-graph:ev:6a46ec4fe598646f551b2d1df77cb393"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- Towers of Operators in CFTs and Convexity Bounds at Large Charge
For CFTs with moduli spaces and asymptotically linear charged towers, what bounds constrain the slope α1 and subleading coefficient α0? Can moduli-space EFT establish WGC-motivated asymptotic charge convexity?
Source ID: unit:a780eea62f153077b1801932c7ad1178c036c4ca8a4ec38ecf9b62a8244941e7
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2607.28726","sourceSha256":"c81d1f6f7cb673fed69c0bd548dfdbc8bc78960911230350115b350f2f850bfa","pages":[1,4,6],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:29d11df59e0ab2a71e0de2a770fc6853","source-graph:ev:6248e27607ae7e1e83c9d9ccc4b84c06","source-graph:ev:ff1960dcf49bd8ea3d929957fb573b43"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- A counterexample to the CFT convexity conjecture
Must every unitary CFT in d>2 with a single U(1) admit an order-one charge q0 such that its minimum operator dimensions are superadditive on all positive integer multiples of q0, or can the onset charge be parametrically delayed?
Source ID: unit:a98de9aadca0869cfa499c51565d76eedc0e6ca7b25f52807cba0825cfcea2d6
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2301.08262","sourceSha256":"517bfc76518f6f475f7def572f1398dd55ab2ec278e9498a1f6b44624dd57f05","pages":[1,2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:294022d968cff201c1c656e93bbb9846","source-graph:ev:c1a3249dcab679ec950f0cf4f9ab0a8b","source-graph:ev:cebf0f59c8a226c3d9b38c6ff9531735"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- Convexity of charged operators in CFTs with multiple Abelian symmetries
How should the charge scale for convexity of lowest-dimension charged operators be defined independently of basis when a CFT has multiple Abelian symmetries, and can that scale become parametrically large?
Source ID: unit:c0698189e63c6d8c9083006f743adee6761c1dcec270153a2f4cdb9d33773604
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2206.06703","sourceSha256":"3458d062be436d9969e8ee026fafd2712bc7b026d4832036a75812cfe4b6bb99","pages":[3,4],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:10b27de924e48e9fbb24174e3971cd5b","source-graph:ev:16a642c9eaee75dce86fee2bd3f58b84","source-graph:ev:56370f1703036d0847a5a5d7c3928af2"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
- Tests of the Charge Convexity Conjecture in Caswell-Banks-Zaks theory
Does the Charge Convexity Conjecture (CCC), including its proposed extension to products of global-symmetry factors, hold for the lowest charged mesons at weakly coupled four-dimensional Caswell–Banks–Zaks fixed points?
Source ID: unit:f671cc6868a90ad35ed9a9358ea43b28378b3769161dd4b761364aecea862811
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"2305.08947","sourceSha256":"0e0f0cb1d0541af78a9f051c92dd2aebb39edfafe36bafb6d0c852d6f4e3ad43","pages":[2],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:7c27607912b6cc0de77dae5886c76914","source-graph:ev:881c3876059b0e868b03983051b13fae","source-graph:ev:933e37553042993e5d102e616a7fa688"]}
Optional complete source context (gzip JSON). Exact source-object relations retain their own scope; they do not imply relations between entire topics.
Scientific status: source_reviewed_scope_with_explicit_limits. Placement: reviewed_scope_and_placements.
Listed sources support this record; they do not claim exhaustive literature coverage. Versioned data manifest