Original proposal qualification: The alternatives are argued not manifestly inconsistent; no UV-complete NEC-violating gravity theory is demonstrated. Independent challenge qualification: The criticized minimal coupling remains a rejected premise; proposed alternatives are not established UV completions.
Can classically NEC-violating matter effective theories couple consistently to gravity, and which changes to minimal Einstein coupling evade the obstructions suggested by black-hole thermodynamics and perturbative string theory?
Exact source: unit:bd294a2cec86696e3e229c40c497e7f41ebe8dcacaabf0e6031eec3113398d8d. Review decision: decision:source-contribution:de5c38fb98243ce2c64c0ee6.
Archived source locator: {"paperId":"1503.07950","sourceSha256":"751bba6c4f0e0efec85046836dff7644fd36941dfb4b82639311a473448da624","pages":[1,2,9],"evidenceRefs":["source-graph:ev:362a2084d6d2c17e7433c6c34cc1f965","source-graph:ev:5a1033a645422f5b7be473af72c73e18","source-graph:ev:c9bb056a037cc2b50f2254fb7d978550"]}
Evidence and scope binding
{
"evidenceRefs": [
{
"localRef": "d5",
"kind": "description",
"unitIndex": 5,
"unitId": "unit:bd294a2cec86696e3e229c40c497e7f41ebe8dcacaabf0e6031eec3113398d8d",
"textSha256": "c3b3c55bae2c6b4eb48a86ad370f20fa17e3f77f52bf13ab0429c908bef45d1e"
},
{
"localRef": "e20",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:c9bb056a037cc2b50f2254fb7d978550",
"paperId": "1503.07950",
"sourceSha256": "751bba6c4f0e0efec85046836dff7644fd36941dfb4b82639311a473448da624",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/0ba77051b64c434a23da/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "88733f048cf380b88889814678838711a173152fbccf56abd6c24f1e97f9cc9a",
"pdfPage": 1,
"start": 0,
"end": 1830,
"textSha256": "4b92140e89d739f4b1f3e14c79ebb8c8e1d06dce991792072520069812b456af",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e11",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:5a1033a645422f5b7be473af72c73e18",
"paperId": "1503.07950",
"sourceSha256": "751bba6c4f0e0efec85046836dff7644fd36941dfb4b82639311a473448da624",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/0ba77051b64c434a23da/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "88733f048cf380b88889814678838711a173152fbccf56abd6c24f1e97f9cc9a",
"pdfPage": 2,
"start": 1284,
"end": 2756,
"textSha256": "7c3ce49a52f9c6936e89d2182a449e915c6ba80840ca505e8cfd05623ffc18a6",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
},
{
"localRef": "e7",
"kind": "primary",
"sourceId": "ev:362a2084d6d2c17e7433c6c34cc1f965",
"paperId": "1503.07950",
"sourceSha256": "751bba6c4f0e0efec85046836dff7644fd36941dfb4b82639311a473448da624",
"sourceContext": {
"path": "papers/0ba77051b64c434a23da/reading-order.json",
"fileSha256": "88733f048cf380b88889814678838711a173152fbccf56abd6c24f1e97f9cc9a",
"pdfPage": 9,
"start": 0,
"end": 1986,
"textSha256": "589223de9c13f3472ef540ffd033738d3d4e75d777a3775adaaa8760635433b0",
"quoteExactInPage": true,
"scope": "Bounded archived primary text; no equation-image or full-paper certification."
}
}
],
"scopeContentSha256": "ebec61d23b29a682817acdb27cf540d89643d09750b31a06ad5fc245698858de",
"provenance": {
"decisionId": "decision:source-contribution:de5c38fb98243ce2c64c0ee6",
"sourceReviewIds": [
"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal",
"leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge"
],
"reviewAgreement": {
"proposalReviewId": "leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-proposal",
"challengeReviewId": "leaf-e21c77227cd6671dcd78-challenge"
},
"doesNotAssertDirectHome": true,
"doesNotAssertEquivalence": true,
"doesNotAssertMethodApplicability": true
}
}